001[Music] he [Music] w [Music] a [Music] [Applause] [Music] you [Music] he [Music] oh [Music] a [Music] n [Music] oh [Music] a [Music] he [Music] a [Music] roll call Mr Nishi I'm here Mr noyola Mrs Yama Bui present Mrs Mendoza present Dr Rios Mrs SE Mrs U okay motion passes UH 60 Pledge of Allegiance um can I have um Miss Mendoza please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance please stand face the flag put your right hand over your heart ready begin I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all all right we're here for a special budget session I'll call on Dr zlo for the budget review thank you um this evening board
002you have in front of you a few documents um there's a PowerPoint that we will walk through as well as some information um in regard to uh ab218 which we will talk about and the information that has come from from fmat which is a um agency that reviews fiscal solvency for school districts um at as our process goes along tonight our plan will be that we'll go through a section and then we'll pause and the board can ask questions and seek clarification so at the table near you are some boxes with Post-its highlighters if you want to mark your uh slide uh presentation or you want to write questions down please feel free to do so you also have a notepad um but Mr W will pause at each section and we'll just go through
003questions we don't have the buzzer system this evening so Mr Nashi will just look for hands and take those who want to talk we'll make note and call on you in the order um but our hope is to have a good discussion tonight um once we go through all the sections we will hear public comments and then we'll open for the board to have discussion at the end so with that if you're good I'd like to turn this over to Mr Twan Wen our Deputy superintendent CFO thank you so much uh Dr zlo good evening president Nishi member of the boor member of the public we here to have a bunch of study sessions on the current budget right where are we at a district with our budget for this year for next year for
004the future years um with enrollment with ab218 and um with the structureal deficit that we are facing so thank you for that so again this is the four sections that we would like to go over and at the end of each sections we'll pause for questions from the board so in the current year the 20 24 25 year Cola which is the cost of living ajustments um was increased for school districts by 1.0 7% so this is an an automatic increase in funding for the districts from one year to the next uh you will get 1% more if your enrollment or attendance stay flat right if you if your enrollment attendance go up then you get more funding if your attendant go down then you get less funding the majority of the district's funding is
005based on our Ada or average daily attendance so but we have decline in what they call funded Ada of 840 students so as a result when you add those two together the net decrease in the lcff funding for this year is about $9 million so the Top Line we get a reductions of about $9 million so I want to spend a little bit of time to talk about the Ada versus the actual P2 Ada versus the funded Ada for the school district again Ada is average da attendant right P2 is our actual Ada at P2 which is April 15 or about April of every given year so this is your actual attendance cumulatively through from the beginning of the school year through that through that day so this is for every year right and obviously
006the current year 2425 is projected the funded Ada because of a formula given by the state during the co area to to to to help with school district um to get through the co they did not penalize school districts for the actual drop in Ada there was we were given a higher dollar amount per Ada but because of the three-year average is catching up to us you can use your threeyear average but since we declining so as you can see this year the funded Ada has dropped from 18,45 to to 17612 so so this is what we actually get funded and it's about 840 students less so for this year when we put the budget to together and presented to the board so what did we have to consider right what these are what we
007call assumptions so we have a declining um Ada of 840 students or Ada we have step and column cost that's normal every year we have health benefits increase that goes up automatically every year and we have pension cost that's also goes up and per the pur is for classify employees that stand for Public Employees Retirement Systems so um there we have two system stirs and purs stirs are for certificate employees and purs are for uh classifi employees the stirs pension system has not experienced an increase for several years and it's not expected to go up so I'll have a chart for that later so I want to start talking about a restricted program first because within a general fund you can always always look at it is we have two po of monies within the
008general fund right one is restricted and one is unrestricted the unrestricted general fund the board of education has full control on how to spend the money the restricted programs are comes with strings attach right the federal or state government they give you the funding they tell you how to spend it what to spend it on who to spend it on and what you can uh do with that money so when you look at Federal programs or restricted programs you know these are the programs that that come to mind right Title One title two three and four and Thea four Title One to support low-income students and you can see here right the biggest another bigger piece of the federal program is also idea which is to support for special education students right of course the
009concern right now with everything's going on at the federal level is that how safe are these funds right are they protected from from potential uh reductions at the federal level you know from the information we got from the state and and the county we believe that these funding are still safe at this point but we really don't know right we we have to go year by year so when we talk about restricted Federal programs these are the major programs at the state level what are the restricted programs again special educations Extended Learning opportunities program or elop the the learning recovery block grant instructional materials prop 28 with the state fundings some of the these are one time and some of these are ongoing so or a lot of them are are one time right so
010that's how the state controled their budget they provide funding just one time and then the next year if they have funding they can give it to you again another one time but um it's distinguish between one time and ongoing so so we always you know ask did we not have $100 million in fund balance or we had a lot of money we do have a lot of money but about $79 million of it is restricted the board of education does not have control over this money this money is given to us for these purposes and I list it out in here in the order from large too small right learning recovery block rant that's one time instructional materials that's ongoing art music and instructional block rant that's one time elop ongoing specification ongoing so you
011as you can see here up the almost more than $100 million in our fund balance in a reserve $79 million restricted we must spend it based according with the directions and with the with the criteria Within These programs you can't just you know win out of that for example instruction materials that's clear they have to be spent on instructional materials so that's just an example of that so how much do we get in restricted programs every year it's about $68 million as you can see here right $12 million from the federal government about $51 million from the state and there's local restrictions that's usually money from the county uh so about $ 68.1 million in revenues per year restricted so on the expenditure size how much do we spend about $115 million so as you
012can see why do we spend much more than we we we get in because there are certain programs there's what we call local contribution like special education right we receive less but the expenditures is more than the revenues so when you see the other financing sources that's local contribution for those programs but yet we still have a 14 million dollar deficit spending even after that and that's intentional we talked about spending down the learning recovery block rent when the Esser federal funds expire all the co money expire we are using the learning recovery block rent here about $21 million to extend all the programs we have in place right uh e counselor is a good example and all the other programs that we have going so the goal is eventually it'll never happen but we
013want to spend down the $79 million this money is restricted you have to spend it a lot of time it has um a timeline right for example right now the art and music block rant you have to send it by 2526 the learning recovery we have to 2627 so if you don't spend all the money by the time the grant expires you have to return the money and we don't want that so you will see um a deficit spending every year on the restricted programs and it's intentional it's to support our students we want to spend down this fund balance so the unrestricted programs is this is the money again the Bo has full control of right and the biggest piece you can see here is what we call lcff funding or local control funding
014formula and that's just a way of the state fund school districts and that's basically based on your students right there's two as you can see here 231 million that's that's a lot of money last year in lcff we got $240 million that's the $9 million reduction that I talked about earlier right if you look at the audit report that theor just received last month it was 240 this year's 231 and all these amount comes from the county and fake matat so they they would tell us how much money we have how we expect to receive but I want to spend a little time to break down how do we get the 231 right what is it base on so so so this chart will tell you the way the state look at school districts and
015how to fund school district is everyone get a base Grant right based on the number of your students up and down the state every District get a base Grand if you have a th students you get an X doll amount picking up $133,000 right more or less so that's the base gr on top of that districts receive what we call supplemental and concentration Grant and as you can see here is almost about $29 million and this is when we refer to this we refer to something called the lcap the local control accountability plan this money the top two part the supplemental bnc's and concentration this fund is generated by what we call unduplicated count students and these are lowincome English Learners and Foster youth so School two School District may have the same number of
016students but depends on your UDP percentage the percentage of your student who are low-income English lers and Foster youth um you may get more in supplemental concentration that Mak sense so two School District may have the same number of students but can get different funding most likely it will because no two school district have the exact number of UDP right uh we are at about 58 59% that's percent percentage in ABC uh our surrounding districts have more but it's based every district is different based on the demographic right the funding here although it's not restricted it's targeted it must be spent on the students Target it who generate the funding meaning it needs to substantially Target it and benefit those students again low income English Learners and Foster Youth and that's what the the all
017the 29 million is under the LC cap where we have about 37 line items on how to spend that money and the board received that every year and we review that every year and there's a lengthy process that Dr Castro we have to go through every year involving of course beginning with the county involving all stakeholder groups on putting the c cap together and the c cap is usually about it's a three-year lcap plan and and within every within uh the year within that plan we can tweak it but usually it's good for 3 years so that's how District receive funding right based on the number of students we have um attendance and based on the type of students we have so this is where we spent our money and and the focus is on
018here right we having a deficit if you can see here the net change in fund balance of $8.3 million that is our deficit that we are spending down the reserve and again why do we have an $8.3 million deficit shouldn't we just spend what we receive right uh part of the reason is as I mentioned earlier is Right a 1% Cola with a declining funded 80 of 840 million Top Line you already get A9 $9 million reductions right and then but on the expenditure size we have things that goes up automatically health benefits step and column right at the same time though there are savings when you have less students right most of our costs are fixed costs the only variable cost would be the teachers right if you see any reduction in FTE would
019be the teachers it followed the students right based on the contract do we staff schools based on the number of students we have and we reduce about 20 FTE from last year to this year due to to declining enrollment and we have been reducing FTE because of declining enrollment right so unless we make other changes right now the only saving would be teachers so we'll get to the 8 million and what the county assets and and the structure deficit because if you keep spending down $8 million um you know you only have 14 million left right so um where do we go from here and we'll get get to that because not all 8 3.3 million is what we call structural deficit there's onetime expenditures that cost the deficit spending and that's ab218 we'll talk
020about that but outside of that without ab218 we still have what we call a structural deficit meaning that structurally your expenditure is higher than your revenues so we have to align those two right so the three-year projections one of the requirement is that we have to check out the 3 years and see not only this year but the next two years right what will the budget look like if we don't make any adjustments to the budget meaning if we don't um reduce the budget or the expenditures this will be the deficit spending going forward and we be down to $3.9 million right so after reviewing the district's first interm report the county sent this letter to us and basically it says that you know you have about 6. million in fund 17 that you can
021use to help with your deficit but even with that you may not be able to meet all your financial obligations so therefore we require you to have put together a fiscal stabilization plan it's a budget reduction plan and submit it to us because without that you will not be able to make an meets by the end of the third year right unless things change drastically this is based on today right State funding may go up drastically in the next year or the year after we don't know right right now um we know what the governor proposed for next year and I'll talk about that but it will one thing we know for sure for next year is it will change until the state adopt the budget we'll know exactly how much we get so with
022that that is at the end of the first um item is the current year budget I'll pause for questions Mr President questions there's no U buzzer so just raise your hand trying to turn my mic off go ahead Olga Dr Rios okay Twan um thank you for that thank you Mr President um can you talk a little bit about back to the restricted programs our fund balance as of 630 2024 was 79 million what is our expected fund balance for 2425 under restricted programs so this is at the beginning of this year right June 30th 2024 we had 79 million we expect to spend down about 14 million so we will end this year with 65 million next year hopefully we'll spend another 15 so we be down to 50 and the year after that
023we'll spend to 15 so we had a three-year plan if you recall to spend the learning recovery block rant and the instructional art material block rant to extend the SR funds so that's our plan so about $14 million every year spending down to 79 million but it's like it'll it's expected to be 675 right 65 at the end of this year when June 30th 2025 the other question that came up for me is on one of the beginning slides um have the number and again we're trying to understand the budget right the um Bud um slide number three so lcsf funding is made up of those three categories that you talked about right the correct um base Grant supplemental and concentration um this decline of 840 students net decrease I mean what is are you
024talking about lcap is going to decrease by 9,000 9 million total but that money is we get it for every student so it doesn't really like I don't see how this applies like if we get 10 students we get more money for 10 students correct so if you get 840 less then it's the base that took the bulk of the hit so the $9 million reduction mostly come from the base your 29 million for the um lcap funding is still there so this affects the base gr not necessarily supplemental in concentration correct it will eventually because when the you know when you lose students right if 60% of our students or 58% is is is unduplicated so in theory it it should go down also when the base go down the top two also go
025down but as of right now still $29 million next year will'll be less okay yeah as you know my focus is LC cap right and I I'm glad to see that we'll still be getting money for the students we have correct that won't be affected we may get less money but we have less students still corre money that's it for now thank you thank you so go ahead your mic is not on though of course I want to welcome everyone um when page four page page four four we did talk about the total 8 calculation when outside the district people they also bring the money here right they bring the the budget to our district so I just have one quick question regarding uh the outside District student in the past you know how many
026student approximately we getting it CU on page 25 you say outside District student we we current about 2,383 student what about this before did we get a lot of outside District transfer in so that if you're referring to page 25 and if you're talking about interdistrict permits students students come from outside of ABC I'll address that when we get there okay but um it it's more than a little bit more than 2383 I just updated that but I'll get i'll get to that point yeah yeah on new page five um your fund the ada8 decline 840 student ada8 sta coling this is any other optional here we I know this kind of restricted ground usually we cannot touch it any other option on this one the page five I want to make sure I understand
027the question are the expenditures automatic do we have a choice in these expenditures chice right um no I mean yes and no no if if we want to free St and column we would have to go to the table negotiate that under the current um you know agreement step and column move down and automatically right so no it it's something that we agree to already it's something that in the CV the collective bargaining agreement the CBA heal benefit same thing right heal benefit goes up we have an agreement in there on how much the district should pay and how much the employee should pay so these these two and pension cost apparently obviously it's it's automatic and it's not choice so we do have uh we don't have a choice we do and we don't
028right we do we have to go to the table and negotiate but but for to answer your question no these cost are automatic and the pent cost P pension I think it's over all district the same right same way how we apply the pension cost number yes the the rate the pension rate for school district is is the same throughout the state whether you in P or stur uh every District have the same rate right now now I'm just talking about school districts right other public agency might be different but School District STS rate is exactly the same for us or our neighboring District per same thing yeah I just want to Audi to understand that so um School follow exactly how District apply in here and other questions all right I just have uh
029two actually want to thank the Community Partners that are out here the city manager for uh our teachers here Mr Abel Abalos and city councilwoman Z like here I think is here she's here she's over there she's over there okay well thank you for coming cuz you are part of our community and we need to hear what we're doing here uh because this is a cumulative decision of all of us two quick questions so uh on page four we talked about p28a is 16,8 13 that's our actual that's projected that's this year so we don't know until April right but we are projecting is about 16,800 so the 17,1 1947 is the actual correct last year happened already yes all the years there is actual except for the last one okay so then basically as
030it is declining uh over a three-year average since it is a three-year average it will decline uh in terms of the actual funded Ada yes eventually until you stop declining doesn't matter what what formula you use right until you stop declining you always going to have less money yes right because it's it's a three-year average so it's correct it's a gentle decline but it is an inevitable decline correct all right the last question is regarding U page 14 and kind of also page uh um 13 it's 8 million this is a budgeted uh amount of 8,328 637 does that include the recent judgments that uh we just paid it does not you will see that at the next second inim report which is at the next board meeting so the board has approved two settlement
031agreement one back in November of 4 million it's in here the last one that Bo has approved it is not part of the $8.3 million so it's that's $2.5 million $2.5 million more than million as our deficit that is correct okay that that's all I have one more question go ahead I have one more one more question on page 13 first I want to thank you so much spending like half hour with me today go over this things um on page 13 because I'm really concerned about this because our budget fund usually when we talk 2024 to 2025 means from the June 2024 to July 2025 right that's how fisal but that is correct my my concern is how we um right now we have another 7 month to go and we only have 14
032million here yes so we do not expect to overspend beyond what we show here so we we will stay within the 8.3 million if not better right because we we start implementing certain cost controls immediately already right it will be will be shared with with everyone but there are certain things we can do from a district perspective um so so so the 8.3 other than the 2.5 million um that the bo approv as in settlement agreements uh we do not anticipate that we'll go up unless we have another settlement agreement so yeah I'm worried that too thank you that that could happen we'll talk more about that Miss Mendoza thank you Mr President thank you for the presentation um just a clarifying question um I know it says certificated salaries and classified salaries I'm very
033familiar with both of those terms where does a superintendent and like cabinet does that do they fall under certificate ated or classified correct which one of them uh both depends right so thank you for the question I I'll I'll I'll explain it thank you so any employee of a school district who needs a credential in their positions would be under certificated salaries right whether you are principals assistant principals a teacher special you know uh you need a credential to do your job that's certificated right classify employees are all the other support staff this would be any anything from custodian secretary um all those uh accounting staff up here uh classify employees are those non certificated non- credential employees so superintendent she needs a credential to do her job so she will be under certificated right
034um CBO would be classified you know for my job I don't need a credential so of course okay any other questions we do have more of a presentation by the way okay um it say stat a 3% of reserves and right now we have how many percentage 10% so we started a year with 10% right but of of course with the deficit spending of 8 million or it's going to be 10.5 that's about a little bit more than 3% if our budget is 300 million so um so we we'll end a year with probably 7 six % okay thank you and we need to have a minimum of 3% yeah thank you okay continue thank you thank you so much so thank you I will go on into next year's budget so this process just
035began right it began with the governor budget proposal in January um so between now and May 10th which is the made revision update um the the legislature up in Sago are holding committee meetings right to to look at the governor budget proposal and and to determine you know uh where to go from there right but they don't take any major actions until they they they get an update from the governor and by law that's by May 10 and that's what we usually refer to the May revisions and the reason is May 10 is because that's all in theory right after all the April 15 tax collection come in now the governors pretty much have a better idea of how much money that the state has right he would update his proposal right from a money
036part and also from a program perspective right hearing feedback from the legislature the different constituents and he will update his budget between May 10 and June 15 is that's when the legislature they do their work and they will have to approve a budget by June 15 send it to the governor and the governor having to July 1st to sign the budget that's when we actually know right after July 1st exactly how much money re we we expect to receive from Cola and all the different programs but this is s of right now and I want to talk about the volatility of the state budget right $97 billion in Surplus to 73 billion doll in deficit and next year we have a balanced budget everything is good so uh that's that's that that that's the positive
037news right so but that's our tax system right it's it's hard hard to to manage but it is what it is we big swings right very volatile so uh with with with us as as residents right inflation still a concern an environment of high interest rate still a concern unemployment is is is under check it's not an issue right now but uh inflation and high interest rate right and of course now you um it's given all the federal government uncertainty added to that but next year Cola will be at least projected to be 2.43 higher than the 1.07 this year so we'll get more money right so and of course the governor is also funding a lot of one-time programs and office what we call Legacy programs and I'll talk more about that so there's
038money for higher Cola there's money for additional one-time funding different block grant and there's money for all the different programs so um Cola we talked about that the three programs under Governor Newsome would be the l or the expanded learning opportunities program the universal meals program and the transitional um the TK program uh kindergarten programs I'll talk more about that so the ELA program is this right School District are required to offer to all at least ABC UDP students right the low-income English Learners and Foster use and homeless 3 hours beyond the school day right you can do it before you we can do it after until 6:00 right any of these students free of charge have the right to stay in school so that's Extended Learning opportunity right school doesn't end at 2:30 3:00
039whatever anymore it will end at 6:00 for these students right so on top of that we on top of the traditional 180 school days per year we are required to offer 30 more additional days at 9 hours a day for these students so the school year now for these students would be 210 days if they choose to attend obviously um the 180 days mandatory not the the additional 30 that that the extended summer school right so um this year and next year what the governor proposal is that for school district uh that are above the 55% UDP now we will be under tier one current year you have to be above 75% to be in tier one right now we in tier two next year should the governor proposal get approved we'll be in tier
040one because tier one now anyone above 55% and like I share we about 58 59% with tier one as you can see the funding increased drastically from about $1,579 per student 22750 that's about $1,200 more per student almost double how budget right right now we get about $8 million eventually it could go up to million so that's that's that's $6 million more but this is a restricted program and the catch is that now we have to offer the program to all students not just UDP all students right if you tier one program had to be available at every school TK to 6 but the best part about the proposal is that this money can be used for tenant recovery so if a student miss a school we don't get fund for that right if they
041you miss 5 days we lose five days of funding the traditional attendance recovery normally would be Saturday school but the new program is saying that we can make up for loss attendance by the hour after school program during inter sessions so and you can use this money to do that so basically you can turn restricted funds into unrestricted if you do it right right because Ada recovery would be attendance so if your attendant percentage now is 95% if you do this right next year we up to 98% that's a 3% real increase in in in in in funding because we get again pay uh funded on a tenant so so so we excited about this if we get funded more funding and we can use the money to have offset um you know with attendance
042recovery so that is his first Legacy program is the Extended Learning opportunities program basically more chance for students to learn more school time that's just as simple as that right uh more school school time during the regular school day and 30 more days univers meals this is very simple all students does in regardless of income level from the family have the right or entitled to have free breakfast and free lunch we serve about 16,000 meals a day and the budget for the nutrition services department is about $16 million so any if you recall the under the um the meals program right students who are eligible for free and reduced PR meals the federal government reimburse us for that right and for the pay students family had to pay in the past now all students eat
043for free right there's still an application process because we want to go after the federal funding and maximize that and then the state will come back and back fill those so every meals we serve will get reimbursed by either the federal government or state government and because of this program we have seen a a drastic increase in in in in in terms of um students eating lunch and U you know we're doing our best some some of our faciliity is not you know uh prepare for for us to do this but uh we do what we can right so this is another exciting program for students that not only that they get more schooling they get they have a free breakfast and lunch the third program is basically the utk or the state is adding
044a grade level be Beyond on the kindergarten to the school system right traditionally gets turn five by December 1st you start kindergarten next year with the utk any students who turn four by September 1st will be eligible to attend the univers the TK program so if we start school in August technically we can have students that 3 years old in TK right for for a couple of weeks uh but then they have to turn four by September 1st to be eligible again no question ask but there's changes made to to the program for next year also is that uh there's two requirements the average class size per at the school site not District but at the school is students and the ratio between adult to students 10 to one so if you have 10 students
045it's one teacher if you have 11 students it's a teacher and a par educator up to 20 students right if you have 21 students be a teacher and two par Educators so the adult to student racial cannot exceed 10 to one the average class size can be 24 so you can have a TK with 24 students that's the average you know uh and you would have three adults in there one teacher and two um instructional Aid or per Educators so because of this program it helps because in the current year we have about 480 students in the TK program and next year with full implementation hopefully we are hopeful to get more and that would upset with declining enrollment so there's a few new grants that Governor proposal propos um uh a block grant called
046student support and professional devel vment block rant about $1.8 billion uh for school districts he add more money to the learning recovery uh block rant about $400 million again this a proposal but we excited we hopeful uh that that theer will will fund this plus add money to it so uh next year what do we worry about right we still have declining enrollment uh we still have uh the same issue step and column we don't know how much health benefits cost going to be we still have the pension cost we have an increase in special cost I'll talk more about that and then we have the ongoing structural deficit from the current year so when I put together the budget for next year these are the things that we have to consider right to make
047sure it's balanced this is our enrollment uh since 1819 as you can see here through uh this year's actual right now as of today students and U projected way down to 15,5 41 by 2930 so I know I updated the numbers here because I want to make this point to the public and to the board up to 17,5 110,000 um to 17,500 students that we currently have 277 students come from outside the district this is different than what you have in your slide and I apologize for that I just updated that um 7 so these students come from the outside districts unless we can continue to attract them we will decline further right so so that's where we are so the net number here is less than the 15,000 I have now right it's about
04814,000 and change of ABC students right if you take the 15 uh 10 and you subtract the 2707 you get about 14,835 um at at Peak it was at 3,300 students about preco 3,300 students from outside the district now we 2707 we expect that number to to be smaller every year as students graduate from us right we expect new students come in to come in but everyone is declining so everyone's hurting so school districts that normally would send or release their students will hold on to their students I won't release it right there there there's there's there's law regarding you know what a family can do to to appeal that but but that's where we are so we we are um still you know more than 15% of our population is from outside the district
049this is as of today and you can see here um by school by grade level and as you can see here right our TK is at 473 and our K is almost almost a thousand students right in theory right the goal is that the TK should be similar or closer to K but you know that families some of them won't send they're four years old to to to us but we will um you know promote our programs and hopefully our goal is about 70% uh of TK um is of K is in TK so hopefully after a few years after full implementation we'll get 700 TK but um for sure next year we'll get more this is just um you know what the state projected for the County of Los Angeles in the next 5
050years for this County wi enrollment will decline by 177% so we are not unique in term of declining enrollment it happens to most districts in the County of Los Angeles I talk about this right part the funding is enrollment helps but Ada is what we actually get funded by the state and as you can see preco we were at 96 A5 now we at 95% so we are still making progress after Co every year it's been going up every year with the attendance recovery program we hopeful that we will exceed the 28 uh 2018 2019 uh Ada rate of 96.5 3% so we preparing for that um Although our general populations of students Decline and this is the Statewide data the the population within that the special education students have been going up every year
051so the students that we have a higher percentage of those students are um qualifi for special education programs um when I began you know we always hear about especially at about 10% of your populations right now it's going to be almost 15% and it's Statewide this is Statewide data this is not uh ABC ABC's follow this similar to to to to this and and uh special education students you know um cost a little bit more to educate because of their needs uh this is that local contribution uh the orange bar is is is is that percentage of what we put in so as you can see here between the federal and the state programs they only fund about 44% of the special education cost the district funds the other 50% right in theory they should
052fund 100% the federal government should fund up to 40% and the state would fund 60% Ida pass in 1973 uh and the state the federal government as you can see there still at about 8% so so that's that's where we are pension cost we talk about that the thir system which is for certificate employees has been stabilized at 19.10% don't expect to go up purs which is the pension system for classifi employees expect to go up but it's going to level off as you can see it top out at 28% so this is every dollar that we pay to employee 20 cents 28 cents go toward the pension cost this is just one factor under the benefits right there's there's other benef uh statutory health benefits not heal statutory benefits such as Medicare workers comp
053Social Security um unemployment so are those are the also the other benefits that on top of this that is um at the end of the section two for next year's budget Mr President have any questions M coming closer to the mic also thank you Mr President and uh thank you um Mr noan uh for uh page um and and I know that perhaps this may not be relevant to the budget discussion but for uh T teachers uh to meet additional qualifications do do we know if um most of our TK teachers have already have they already met that qualification or will we be needing to um um have new teachers come in like what are what's the Thought on that thank you for the question Dr faser you want to take that or you want
054me to answer that so we uh we fortunate in ABC that all of our teachers um have met all the additional um requirements uh for uh the TK program so 100% of our employees have um even before the deadline have have all the requirements to be a TK teachers and you know with the expected increase in TK classes next year we prepare for that we we also expect 100% of our teachers are fully qualified with the additional um you know uh class needed for for the early uh Child Development uh you know for TK students so yes the answer is yes 100% of us good news thank you mhm Francisco Mr that's okay uh thank you president uh on page 18 I had a question about uh the elop program um with the new changes
055that the governor is proposing is there any potential savings for the rest I mean unrestricted fund that we or is there any fund that we use unrestricted to pay for the elop that will be saved right great question so yes so elop we get about 8 million this year should the governor proposal get approved and we'll be in tier one we're looking at about 14 million so that's a $6 million increase um so yes we can use that under the attendance recovery program and spend a lot of that money on to to to recover attendance that will increase the base revenues so that that's that's our plan and and that's that's the beauty of this uh program is that it can be used uh next year to uh support attendance recovery and more beyond the
056traditional Saturday school because now there's a new attendance recovery program that we just had a workshop today and learn about it on how to maximize uh this potential additional funding to support our students right clearly right to give them intervention and whatnot but also to give them the additional schooling that they need but at the same time we'll get we'll get to recover the attendance thank you and just to clarify I know uh another rule was to another part of it was to expand the ELA programs to all the schools and that's something we currently do correct we do have it um at all of our schools with a different um elementary schools uh we still unknown whether we still can charge those who are not UDP because under the tier one in theory we
057have to offer to all one you have to make it available at all of our schools we already there but right now those who don't qualify to under UDP parents have to pay for a fee so it's still unknown at this point point whether we still can charge that or if there's a sliding scales we're still confirming with the state and we really don't know until you know this this become the law yeah moving closer oh thank you uh just one more question on page 22 uh Universal TK uh how does that affect our current TK Staffing in the classroom do we have do we meet these requirements already with the class size per adult yes so right now if you look at here um we at 2421 right and if you can look here
058miraculously it's very close to the 24 to1 right uh if you have uh schools like at Kennedy there's two classes obviously at at 40 get and see uh is it 48 or uh very close at 42 so so right now under the current law is 24 to1 um and then 12 to1 adult to to uh student ratio so when you have a class of 24 right now it'll be one teachers and one per Educators full-time right next year if you happen to have 24 students it'll be one teacher and two per Educators because the ratio will have to be 10 to one or less it can't be more thank you mhm um Miss say sure move a little closer to the mic though I will back on the page a little closer 19 can you
059hear me page 19 then we talk about attendance recovery that's they're going to start from Summer actually July 1st right I know you guys had a conference meeting today already so prepared the staff ready for summer program right yeah okay so we still have the traditional summer school right and then we still going to have the 30 days under the current elop to the extent what can we count to our tenance recovery we still we still waiting for further clarification but we know for sure is that um you know after school it it can be by the hour now so after school intervention or even before school or even during intercessions like fall break winter break spring break not that students will want to come but we want to offer it anyway so anything we
060can do to maximize that and recover the attendance right from an educational perspective as well as from a funding perspective so when you talk about Saturday program or even after after school program um what was the inter what is the curriculum that we focus on I just for activity or some more I think care prob need to answer that do we have some program for that to yeah encourag learn learning uhhuh yes our current Saturday school program is focused on English math and science skills so we take a steam approach where students are engaged with literacy skills uh math skills and they work on science projects so we do an extension of what they're learning but we're also making sure it's fun play based but focused on something Hands-On because since this this program expended
061to all student you know how it used to be Saturday program or afternoon program especially for kids who really needs to recover the grade but this one for everyone so your level education also going to divide it out differently right well now now that we can use um this attendance recovery program we will have to redesign the program based on what is needed but essentially we don't have to do it on Saturdays we can do it in the after school program that exists we can do it through summer school and intercession so that's the shift that's happening is you can do Saturday school but you can also do it in the after school summer school and intercessions which is something we're not able to do right now right now we can only do Saturday school
062okay uh second question Universal meal not all the students see this restricted program there a there's a budgeted for the meal what about you know I don't think all the student will use the meal there some you know cuz I'm working at school we get free meal for the staff too okay if you eat the same meal almost you you know repeat the same thing kids may not like it so they bring their own food here so what's going to happen I mean you're using the number total number of student using the universal meals should be dropped so what would you do for that uh budget I want to make sure so we we only get reimbursed by the number of meals we serve right so not all students eat obviously the school lunch program
063or breakfast right and that that's where the the the effort come in right if you want to attract more students to eat then you need to improve the quality of your food right but there's a lot of restrictions on what we can serve right there's federal guidelines on the school meals program uh you know um the the percentage of sodium uh sugar all of that it it so so we have to stay within all those legal requirements not that we can't improve and and we were looking at you know additional facilities and and we always look at the different menu options um you know we visit other District to see what's popular uh we just got an audit from the federal government and they very impressive what we have right we can always do better
064right and will there be a time that 100% of students will eat no but we can go from 60% to 65 any increment is good so we striving every day now that we know this program is here to stay we can expand and and we can staff accordingly and we can offer CTI what what what is healthy and but popular so what would you do because if we don't spend all what would you do some those not spending all the money what do you plan to do can you justify to other area or no you have to just give it back to the government this program is extremely restricted it's so restricted that it has its own fund it's even more restricted in the programs that we talked earlier meaning that no it can only
065be spent for the meals program you can you know upgrade your um infrastructure have be related to the kitchen you can you know enhance the quality of your food uh by by by uh buying more organic stuff so so those are the things that we want to do or fresh food you know uh food or local grown so so they encourage all of that but the bottom line is any revenues generated from this program must be spent on this program I'm going to go to um board member you and then Dr Rios and then after that M Mendoza okay thank you president say I president Nish um yeah and thank you very much for our uh CFO preparing all this and explaining it very uh uh you know making it very easy for us to
066understand and breaking it down we hear this every year but it's always new information thank you very much and appreciate all the community members attending our meeting during your You know despite your busy schedule um for the the deficit spending seems to be inevitable because of mainly because of the declining enrollment correct yes sir and then the state budget too for the current year yes right like like I explained it we we have we decline it in funded ada8 of 840 students with a 1% Cola yes that's inevitable as you've been hearing you know most districts deficit spending this year right they have to spend down the fund balance if they don't have that they have to do something drastic and you hear some of that on the news so so how do we stay
067competitive like retain good employees and uh student keep up with the student achievement and uh how about the overhead the structural spending is kind of said whether you have 500 students in the school or 1,000 students there are certain overhead expenses that are pretty consistent yes yeah yeah those are the fixed costs so yeah that that would be the question that we ask ourselves every day right how do we stay competitive uh given the facts that we have with declining enrollment and and the budget situation how do we um still offering all the programs and even enhance it to our students right um at the end of the day um we we do with what we have uh at some point it's not possible to do everything we can do a lot of things but
068you can't do everything right so it is with the superintendent and and her cabinet to present to the board a plan eventually right if the county is saying now that we have to align our budget basically reduce our spending to make sure that that that we we we still comply we will do that right but um you know as the old saying goes right we will cut if we need to as far away from the classroom as possible it's true 20 years ago it's true now and it's always going to be true right but I want to make the point clear if you have to cut anything from the budget something will have to go I won't I will never sit here and say that everything will be the same all service will be the
069same right no there will be adjustments and there will be positions that will not be you know around and and you see that but we have a guiding principles when it come to budget and we'll it's worked for us we work closely with our employee groups uh to to have a path forward for ABC that will benefit our students and our employees M so all the stakeholders stakeholders do have to work together to come up with some resolution yes ma'am because uh on page 15 I noticed that there's a letter from the County to the president of the board yeah that's that sounds pretty serious it's like we have to require the district to address the deficit spending through submission of a board approved resolution to develop a physical uh stabiliz stabilization plan yes is
070do we have a deadline for this yes by June when the board approve next year's budget it has to be part of that okay yeah so thank you very much yes ma'am Dr Rios well as a followup um you know as a board member we get to interact with people from all over the state um at nsba all over the country and it's I guess reassuring that I've met superintendents from districts that have as little as 12200 students and you know districts that are two times or three times as big as ours and that are fully functional so I have no doubt that we'll manage to put a proposal together and have a program in place that will still keep us as a full functioning District on to my comments and question I'm really excited
071about the programs that are coming up I'm really excited about the expanded learning opportunity program um I hope that this translates again into better outcomes question about um the current law versus the governor's proposed budget do we have a timeline for that yes so the governor proposed his budget last month right in may he will update his budget assuming that he will keep it the same by June 15 the legislature will either reject or accept his proposal and we we we will know pretty much around that time there there's always feedback about you know what's survive what's not all the ne negotiations going on in Sacramento and and this seems like a a a very popular program uh and there's there's not a lot of resistance to this so but but we should know by
072June 15 to answer your question fantastic um very happy about this Universal meals program and the fact that there may be more M money coming into the district um I know as board members often times we get to hear this request from our families about you know the meals and about more freshly prepared meals so it's really exciting that they're putting money with that for that um TK again exciting because we talk about declining enrollment and hopefully that'll address that um a question that I have is related to slide number 26 do we have data that follows like for example right now we have 21 students at Aloha and TK about how many of those students actually continue on to kindergarten and full and go on to um or stay at their home schools because
073I know that a concern that has come up for me um every year that I've been on the board is this idea of making our schools better right um and by that I mean student achievement improving student achievement um we know that as parents we look at test scores we look at how schools are rated and I'll get I working student services during my day right so a lot of times when parents are looking to either leave a district or enter a district it's because the school is considered you know a an excellent school or a good school um my question I guess is do we know do we have data I guess that would be the first part yes we do and we can provide that um when when the subject come up if
074it there'll be about you know the report that the the at the next meeting when the board retain an outside auditor um consultant to look at our you know enrollment data and make recommendations it will be all in there right the cohort Survival how many stays and move on to the great level how many Resident students stay within that school all of that will be will be looked at and that will be something that very that that is very important to me because you know students we're talking about declining enrollment it's really important for us to talk about like why our students and I know that maybe doing an exit survey is not very feasible but it would be really important to know is it because we know the high cost of California and families
075are leaving the state or are they moving across the city to another school district you know we're in a place that we're surrounded by a number of districts right um some with good outcomes um some with comparable outcomes I know that ABC has always been at a very high standard but everybody's competing for students right now and we have schools that are doing very well with the same de demographics that some of our schools could probably do a little bit better um I think the last question that I had was I know we use a lot um the term restricted programs and to me that seems like everything under restricted is what we're about in schools right about students learning teaching teachers becoming um having professional development can you give me an example of an
076um unrestricted program that or a program that is funded through unrestricted funds so the biggest one is actually what happened in the classrooms right so you have teachers there that fund it out of the unrestricted programs that the daily instructions right we would have a lot of programs um supplemental programs that we we offer that would be uh you know from I don't want to say the spelling B to the math B to all of that a lot of it is restricted but we leverage that and and but the bulk of it is just legally required is the instruction in the classrooms right that's what restricted for and like you said right anything above that would be restricted and you want to leverage that right because you want to have that flexibility you want the
077best teachers in that classrooms right right therefore you need to pay a competitive wage let's let's let's let's let's be real right our total compensation package have to be competitive employees teachers have choice right so so we know that so that's what the unrestricted money is for to make sure that you know the working condition the class size what we pay our employees is is is is is is is competitive um everything else we have the restricted programs for that's it thank you Mr President Mendoza thank you Mr President I have a couple questions and some of them are just follow-ups to my my colleagues so uh Twan expanded learning opportunity program um I'm learning um so the programs to extend the school day before and after school are those are our child care or
078is that like teachers actually credentials teachers teaching instruction to those students great question there's a combination Dr CRA you want to take that sure uh this State requires that we meet minimum requirements uh towards units for Child Development and so there are some Child Development units that are required although a credential teacher is not required currently at our school sites we do serve all 19 elementary schools and we work with some Community Partners such as the YMCA and Aya who provide cohorts of students various experiences but in combination with that we have certificated teachers who provide math tutoring and other supports during that time as well so it's a combination of being supervised by individuals who meet the minimum credentialing requirements that are part of elot okay as well as credential teachers who push in
079to do math tutoring and other supports during that time okay so let me see if I understand this so we have a group of Staff that's meets minimum requirements they're working with students and then there's a credential teacher who pushes in and kind of supervises them and provides instruction at the same time correct correct okay okay okay so then that that that answers my next question is that um this program pays for the staff does it also pay for materials does it pay for everything yes okay okay thank you so much thank you um my next question was kind of like a followup to um Olas um sorry Dr Wheels TK and I'm just going to put this out there I'm I'm I'm a kindergarten teacher and when I heard 24 TKS Ah that's a
080lot it's 10 to one it'll be 10 to1 the class going to be 24 I understand the Staffing I I totally understand the Staffing but if you haven't been in a in a TK classroom please visit one because 24 Little Children okay so I I understand that the the that's that's a state but I'm just for my teachers who teaching TK I know that that's a lot and I I I hope next year that we keep to that and make sure that if we meet those those numbers that we do have a teacher and those two pairs because it is NE necessary we need to have those adults in those classrooms um it's mandatory it's mandatory but I know sometimes we don't may not have the staff to be in there so we I think
081that's and this I think this is where we start right here in TK because Olga was say sorry Dr R I'm sorry I'm sorry um if we if we get these kids in TK in our district and we keep them and I the projection right we can keep them but we got to keep them we got to keep them and as a parent if I go in there and I'm enrolling my child and I'm walking in there and I see 24 little students and I see one teacher and you know it's like okay maybe this is not the right place maybe I have to go to another school district so I hope that before this this takes place that we have our staffing for our teachers there um and I know that and I'm just
082going to tell you this and I'm a kindergarten teacher and I know this takes this takes a staff member at a school site um before our students actually enroll in my kindergarten class we have a little tour of our school my classroom is not completely done but they can come in they can they can visit me the parents come in this is before the first day of school this is like maybe a week before and I do a presentation and so that the parents feel comfortable with me and I don't know if we do that at every School site but I think that's something that that you know we can hopefully pay some staff members to do because it makes a complete difference for a family to come on a School site and to visit
083and not come in that very first day of school and be like I don't know where anything is um and also like Dr Olga Rio said is that if they don't stay with us why why are they not staying with us I mean why can't we do an exit ticket is it can we ask the parents why they don't come back is that not allowed it is we can ask but whether they're going to give us an honest opinion or not is that but we can always ask I think it would it would help us you know to have data to find out why I mean it could be simple like you know they're moving fine we can take that too but it it would it would be in our best interest to find out
084where we can do better and make sure we keep those students because like we're we're all state law requires to follow up with them we need we need to report where they go otherwise it's going to be a drop out right so if we need to transfer a file to another District then we know where they going that would be great to know you know why where they're going why they're leaving because I would like to keep all of them I would like to keep all of them and then Twan on on uh sorry I keep calling by your first name I'm so sorry um slide 25 if you could go to slide 25 so in projections you projected fully full TK kindergarten TK going into kindergarten yes okay did we also project um I
085have I have my city of ARA here we have new housing going up are we projecting hopefully that we have new students coming into our school district yes we factors all that in thank you for the questions right um so I'll elaborate a little bit with enrollment right what happens why are we declining right so birth rate is the biggest Factor we all all know that and that's happened Statewide or countywide housing affordability right and of course new developments the cities that we serve where there's artia Hawaiian citos part of Lakewood are what we call mature cities they don't have a lot of undeveloped lands right so everything we have to do is is basic on exist existing land and we work closely and the the demographer they do look at the planning uh from
086the cities to see what's potentially uh you know uh will become housing uh affordable housing hopefully uh within the districts and how many students will yield this is another set of data that you don't like to hear but in the past each residence or each new unit would generate more than one students right two 1.6 whatever the formula is now it's less than one students per unit unfortunately um either the families that move in don't have kids or they just have on average less than than one or two um case in point would be you know in citos they have the two apartments that fairly new right sage and Arya MH we did not see a material increase in the students although collectively I believe they have close to 400 500 units in those two
087right we excited to hear about potentially the o seers department store going to turn into some kind of mixed use and two 300 units but um you know we keep our finger crossed right Aria has been very active with a different development but um it's it yes we do look at all of that for our projections unfortunately I I I'm interested in seeing that and my very last question is I know we do we're going to work on attendance recovery but what about attendance incentive what does the district do to in incentivize our students to come to school so they don't have to do the the tenants recovery yeah do do we do School site visits do District staff go and visit school you know students yeah we very active with that as you can
088see right we preco our tenance rate was above the state level uh about 1% and we've been going up since we consistently above 1% of the state average we have an active CWA um Department we have a position called community liais on or parents leaz on at the schools we have El counselors that yes we do go and knock on doors to make sure to get the students to come to school so we do a lot of those things before we have to do attendance recovery um there's factors that beyond our controls right this flu season whether it's RSV or whether's is whatever you know it is it's worse than normal uh the fire there an impact the the reason protest but that's that's different right uh we still can if they show up to
089school even for 1 hour we can count for that so there's there's not of that but yes we do of that unfort chronic absenteeism is is a dashboard um item we watch that closely and we work with families to ensure that students come to school so yes we do everything we can uh um and our tense rate have been going up and and higher than the state average and we'll continue to do that thank you um I don't actually have any questions just one real quick comment regarding the uh projected enrollments that based upon also the housing element to a certain extent and some of that is let's say optimistic um because they factor in changing the zone as to building the housing that they need and sometimes that doesn't always result in created homes
090so that's just one of the examples but I'll let you keep on going let's uh keep on going for this last one let's let's finish up U this 218 okay we're going to also have a board discussion time after this too okay all right yes ma'am oh as we discussed this before the moving to the the microphone we will be able to discuss this further by the way yeah but because you have a bunch of schools that they are under like 300 students attending the school there I can see that's a bleeding area right yes ma'am I know the Consultants coming the next week am I right we are hopeful we we trying to get them here at the next board meeting uh uh we will work with the superintendent on that okay then on
091your page 24 ongoing structure deficit you know the measure BB does that some allocate to this on going infrastructure area it's completely outside of this it has nothing to do with this okay we were talking about um M Mendoza Miss Mendoza you teaching kindergarten how many student you have her 17 17 my my grandson actually and TK program right now because I go visit them very well um the issues on TK program we started in the Chinese vendoring immersion program there so the numbers increased from original Stars only have one TK program now you have three TK program so staff may want to think about another second language there to support that will retain more student here yes so we will always look at program enhancements right we have a dual um dual language immersion
092program at uh we had them at nemis we have them at Ferguson's we began theion program at Star we always going to look at you know expanding those if if it makes sense right we want to make sure that uh we have the Staffing but but important most importantly if you take students from other schools then that's it's a it's a net zero gain you have to attract students from outside the district right that's how you gain students otherwise if you have a program at stars but it take students from Gonzales then you know it it it it doesn't help have to it have to attract stud from outside the district definitely I can share my colleague person rate is not going to go up getting less and less cuz I in the OB Department
093before so I know that's going to hurting us more yeah thank you MH okay go on thank you Mr President this is um the third part of our presentation is we haven't talked about this um in a public board meeting uh but um I believe it's time uh because there has a negative impact on the district finances so AB assembly Bill 218 it's just a law passed by the state a few years back basically um you can read it here allow um victims that could go back as far as they can in the 60 and the 70s whenever to file uh litigations against the districts for sexual misconduct that's happened in the past so it's open a Revival period for 3 years that period has closed but many School District up and down the state
094you know get uh litigations because of this uh this law and it make other changes that you can see here about going forward uh you know Li the SAT limitation to the age of 40 going forward but going back you know it's it's it was um open-ended uh so um the districts ABC receive you know claims against the districts as the result of 218 right so normally in the normal operations you have insurance for these things liability insurance hopefully right but when you go back to the mid 80s or the mid 70s either even if you have insurance the limit was like a million dollars it was low because you didn't need more than that back in the mid 80s or mid-70s or there's time that you you don't have any records whether you have
095insurance or not or a lot of times the carrier at the time went under right insurance company they they they go upside down so because of those factors um I want to say a lot of time but there are times that the liability would go back to the districts and now we would have to be liable for that so if you can't find anyone else to cover for you you will have to pay so that's the law so uh we have uh total I want to say five claims against the districts the board has um settle or approve uh with uh three plane tips uh two different claims for $6.5 million you know the report it out in in public uh at a board meeting um and and this is something that uh outside of
096the insurance limit and we have to pay that um we we working closely with uh the County of Los Angeles Lal and fmat if I use that term is the fiscal crisis management assistant team that's a state agency that would come in and help district um and you know under financial distress if you will to see if you know yeah we have the the fund balance but but we need that right we have to pay we get that that's the law there's it is what it is but how do we um alleviate the impact if if possible uh so we're looking at if there's any restricted programs that allow for this to be charged to right there are sums uh that allow for operational costs for example so we're looking at that uh but outside
097of that it will be the district general fund under restricted fund balance withth the pay so that's where we are so we settle for a couple and we still have a few more to go so fmat just issue a report a few weeks ago on this ab218 and you can go here uh to look at the full report I believe it's about 40 pages report I think there's a copy for the board uh in front of you uh read it uh when you can but it basically outlined the impact of the law on school districts up and down the state St and and potentially what happened so that's where we are with 218 so uh it's something that was handed to us and something we have to deal with right we all for the victims
098but it it's have an impact on us and is taking money for us to support our current students but it is the law that is the section three Mr President on ab218 do you have any questions all right maybe you can do the structural deficit yes thank you so much so this is the last sections so outside of 218 right we have about a $4.1 million structural deficit that's mean we spent more than we take in and unless you align the expenditures to the revenues is you always going to be $4 million spending more so um the county have asked that by June we have to have a plan to address this so right now we are putting together a plan uh the superintendent and her cabinet is putting together a plan we we have
099gone through this before in 2008 during the great recessions when we have to make multiple cuts um so there's a process that we do there's a guiding principles on budget that we follow uh we we would always uh talk with our Union groups um there's the finance and audit committee um um created by the board that we we we we we discuss this with them and to get the input and feedback and and we will share to the board at the May meeting and of course you will have options for the board right if you have to cut 4.1 million these are the options and these there's some additional options for the board uh to consider and and and that's at the May meeting um so but after not after we we thoroughly think everything
100through and and talk to our Union uh employee groups and our audit and finance committee and that's our process right so yes this is something we have to do unfortunately all right let's uh open up for public comments and then we'll have B uh board discussion after that you can't see so what you to fill out a card yeah persons wishing to address the board should fill out a card located on the table by the door and submit the completed card to the secretary speakers will be called in sequence during the public comment section persons wishing to address the board on a specific agenda item at the time the item is under discussion are limited to 5 minutes each the board shall provide 30 minutes for speakers to address agendized items should there be 6
101to 10 speakers for agendized items individual speakers shall be allowed 3 minutes to address the board on the item with board consent the president may increase or decrease the time allowed for public comments depending on the topic and the number of persons wishing to be heard in order to ensure that non-english speakers receive the same opportunity to directly address the board any member of the public who utilizes a translator shall be provided at least twice the allotted time to address the board unless simultaneous translation equipment is used to allow the board to hear the translated public testimony simultaneously government code 549-5433 a in addition neither the board nor District staff verify the accuracy of the statements made during public comments adverse remarks about a person's race ancestry ethnic group identification religion color national origin sex
102sexual orientation gender mental or physical disability or age may not be made do you have any submitted cards and you can submit it directly to the clerk our first uh our first speaker if you could please step up um to the mic near the door over here um kit uh cha Chan cha Chan yes five minutes oh the mic's not on can you turn the mic on um next speaker will be Zeal ahir good evening board members Community I actually had some questions and they were partially addressed but I am going to make a statement ab218 is about the reprehensible behavior of a adults who were employed within this District sometimes we shy around these things and say was what you are paying for is the trauma that was caused to those individuals it is
103not your fault hell it's not even my fault I was a teacher because of one or two individuals we all share the blame but instead of just saying we are losing money I need you to do something I need you to work with the legislator find some resolution change some rules allow some flexibility in the monies that we have or monies that we will get to pay the debt one of the solution why can't the state give us zero interest loans to pay off these things so that when you do and you will have to close schools when you get those money you pay off those loans make some structural changes that are needed I love the presentation of the programs I'm bring in do you know that they're going to cost money as well
104you're going to require staff staff equals salaries and benefits so each program as a plus but also comes with some added responsibilities special ed when I was a teacher 8% of the general population was special ed and went to 10 and then went to 13 whatever the number is for this district there is a very great report from Lao in 2019 which spells out exactly what the problem is and not to Sugar Cod it what happens is that the regular students it's not your money regular students have to pay for the Special Ed I wish we could speak in plain language to explain to the parents where this money come from it is not a magical free fee we need to quantify it so people understand that money in school is finite the other issue
105which have deferred since 2016 I've been coming to this board asking for to put restrooms in our schools because you are non-compliant you do not have enough restroom for the female students in your high schools every time it comes up some other bloody crisis comes along last time it was a pandemic there will always be crisis when are you going to fix it because next year in COD 35 295 35 29 2.5 on or before July 1 2026 each School District or county office shall maintain a combination so basically you have to report the number of restrooms you have it is going to be required on your Sark and I've been monitoring this so please I'm asking you on behalf of all the students before that too turns into a trauma and another lawsuit that
106you will then have to pay for thank you next speaker is uh zil ahir Aria council member zal a here and following um council member ah here we'll have um Zen I'm sorry cannot read the first name thank you respected board members and community members for attending today thank you for the presentation um I as a community member would like to make a comment and a suggestion um I suggest that um making use of the facilities that ABC school has should perhaps be looked into in terms of generating Revenue to get a more sustainable budget throughout I do know that because of um is it ab218 um the insurance policy is also added to rental use uh which makes it expensive for the the Community member or the organization to rent our facilities um then
107to counter that perhaps maybe we lower the rental value um I know it's $84 an hour to use a sports facility um and minimum 4 hours are required but perhaps looking into maybe 2 hours minimum for someone who just wants to play volleyball or basketball for a couple hours um I think that could prove beneficial in the long run um furthermore streamlining the process maybe having a platform that could be more user friendly online rather than having to go in person and um figuring out who to speak to and whatnot um lastly um maybe major events as just weddings or festivals can be looked at on our school grounds and seeing whether we can generate some Revenue through that so thank you and that was my suggestion um Aria does look forward to having um
108some solutions for closing down for the schools but if not we're happy to facilitate any kind of um decision that you make to mitigate that with our community members thank you thank you Community member Zang or z h g thank you uh give me the opportunity I just have a question but let me introduce myself uh we we move to uh seros uh in uh 2018 I have two daughters in the conser elementary and um yeah I'm also a uh investor in ABC uh USD bonds so I'm glad to be here and learn a little bit about how to run this thing and any uh from my education any successful organization uh basically doing three things right you're your generate Revenue um you'll improve asset utilization and you reduce cost so I'm an engineer so
109I'd like to read between the numbers so forgive me for that so on the slide 14 um there is a projection of total expenditures in 2425 is 218 million and then 25 26 down to 214 uh which is reduction of 3.6 millions and then 26 to 27 uh goes up about 1.2 Millions so I'd like to know uh yeah just one curious curious what's uh what's the reason of the reduction if I heard it correctly that's the reduce of the number of teachers hired and then uh what was the is there any other contributing factor uh reduction of the operation operating cost like those solar panels they put on to reduce the utility something like that and then what's the reason for increase is that ab218 or anything like that so I'm just I just
110like to know a little bit more about that thank you okay I see no further public comment great um so we're going to open up the board comments and and just so that you know uh for the public uh normally we don't have this special session normally we don't do this in March we usually do something in May or June and it just goes as a a regular budget item and uh kind of goes quickly but the reason I thought this was important for us to have a special session and take another day out of our week and I apologize for that is that uh although these are not huge reductions they are reduction and so I feel like we need to get our Community Partners to hear what we prioritize and provide that direction
111to staff well before the deadline that we have and so that's that's the main point of having this meeting so that way each one of you as board members uh we don't go in in May going oh it's too late to make any changes and it's some change that we don't want staff needs our Direction and we can provide that leadership to the extent possible so that's why we have this meeting um so I'll just go um if you have no comment that's fine too but um I'll go this way around and see if you have anything that you'd like to say is your particular priority or questions or anything this is our time uh thank you president Nishi and thank you I appreciate uh this opportunity to you know review the budget early and
112give that direction and give that input and also you know get input from the community and inform them of you know where we're at currently um I know what the budget stabilization plan I know we have a lot of you know decisions that we're going to have to make for the future and for today um but on top of that I would also you know implore us to be proactive if there's things that we do need to cut uh that we try our best to replace them or enhance them with Community Partners or you know like Ernie mentioned look to our community to see how we can work together to to even enhance them in these times and I think that could also help in the future where if we are looking to attract outside
113students while other districts having to make Cuts we are actually growing in you know in an efficient way so thank you thank you couple thing I'd like to make a recommendation that we are we arew the superintendent and cabinet will de develop a budget reduction plan right I do like to make some kind of a recommendation number one closer to the mic okay I do want to make some recommendation we have about four school elementary school the student number has been dropped below 300 right um those school that we have to in the future and I know I have consultant comes out but I recommend we need this Consolidated School number one number two for elementary school and I also suggest you know you have a middle school some other school district they having merging
114them together they have a 789 uh no 678 together as a uh middle school that I suggest in the future we can look that one of U Middle School who I don't want to point the school's name it's also have a lower attendant rate so that need to take a consideration what we want to do consolidate them and we also can use in change six to 78 Middle School change a little bit practice as compare with regular what are we doing right now I know a lot of school choose that direction now um Staffing hiring you know I do want to conern in the past our history in ABC USD we don't lay off people we usually um we start freezing uh if the people retire we don't hire no more or have you and
115we also have a some sub teer there too right so we used our teacher as much we can and not hire no more the minute they have they retire I don't think in the past where we don't um L the people off I think that's one of the thing at least as a board member we need to think something for our staff here and the last part is um the couple thing that we need to look into our asset staff when you build up the reduction plan think about the travel expensive that we've been using it um I need you to look into it I know in the past we all have four or five people go travel out of the state I think in F in the future I suggest just one person to
116go out and then come back and and educate the people I think that will save some cost from there too so that's my recommendation here thank you you thank you president n uh um and thank you for the community members who spoke for sure for the ab218 that's the assembly Bill 218 and that will hit most of the district up and down the California state so this is something that we definitely have to address and my heart goes out to the the victims however uh we are going through some crisis with the budget and the deficit so I mean as a district I think we can maybe um write up a a letter to our legislator to Sacramento to to appeal to find some Solution that's something we can do maybe with the help of
117Our Community member K and uh secondly for sure I talked about the structure and uh just we just need to have some business uh you know hat on and as a district we need to come together to analyze and listen to the the expert with um the professionals who give us the data the company what's the name that's doing the the numbers the data School works yeah School works right so we're going to see the results soon um we definitely have to do something about the numbers and like it doesn't make sense to pay the overhead same overhead for a school with 300 students and 500 students so that's something that we can really look into and it's not necessarily for student achievement too instead of uh combined classes we do most parents want uh
118students to have the best uh academic education so we can come together to come up with a solution and um also programs talking about the programs to attract students from outside the district and uh yeah if I if I was a Mom right I'm a mom of four girls I'm going to look for schools and programs that will prepare my children best with math and English math and English prepare them for the future whether it be college or for career so if we can and and ABC has always been very attractive and competitive in the past even before the pandemic right so maybe we can um kind of fine-tune and work on uh programs where we can attract students from outside the district from TK all the way up to high school and parents do
119look at very seriously the middle school and high school especially because that's where you know your students are prepared for high school and there's you get tested you know that we do have comp competition all around Oxford um Troy you know all these different schools so Whitney has actually been number one you know in the state so if we can something not just only Whitney but we have uh other middle schools to have a really competitive program where we can actually attract more students from outside the district that's one another thing and then also uh generating income I know that that's a not an easy issue I mean I would love to see our facilities uh used by our community members such as you know we talked about pickle ball if we can after hours
120on the weekend that'll be great but I think that's something that uh you would know better that we have to coordinate with the the cities because of the liabilities right we do have a case you know which is not a good experience when someone gets hurt so I think that if the cities are willing to step up and take care of the you know take ownership of those uh liabilities I mean I would love our you know schools you know uh to to make ourselves open to to utilizing our facilities to the community especially for sports that's just you know great right it's great for the community so that's something that I'm very very Pro okay so that is it thank you very much dros so sorry this think I was so hard perfect segue
121um thank you I I think that I'm going to take this opportunity to talk about something that you know kind of has been a thief of mine since I've been on the board and that's this sense of urgency um for some of our students some of our trusty areas right I like to say that all of our students are achieving success to the level that we'd all want to see but that's not the case and so I think that challenges present opportunities like I love the idea we've all talked about rebranding as um board member you just mentioned um a lot of our schools are magnets but they're obviously not attracting the kind of students or at the number that we'd like um so let's think outside the box you know when um my daughter
122was growing up she ended up at Leo not yes it was a good school but what attracted me to consider Leo was that I was a performing art school and that's something that my daughter truly enjoyed she loved to sing she loved to draw and I thought okay she's going to get a good education and she's going to do what she loves um I know that some of our schools have things that you know I I I really encourage us to revisit and see is it getting the attention or the interest that we want I think Sports I think um language is you know the three TKS I'm not surprised that you know that school has 3 TKS because the families want their kids to learn a second language we know what a need that
123is um we know what soft skills are out there that our students need to be successful how about we look at those and seriously consider rebranding again our schools because if you know Aloha was at the level that um Leo was like parents would be lining up and and you know my my earlier question about exit surveys like I really do want to know that you know students are not leaving our district not because they can't get into the Leo or the serritos and and are leaving for you know maybe necessity um because if they are leaving because they can't get into these schools and they think that their home schools are not going to give them what they are looking for then we have a problem that we need to fix and we've been
124saying that for as long as I've been on the board at least and and not a lot has changed um so we need to improve what we do we need to improve our outcomes um that was one so opportunities challenges present opportunities the second thing that I wanted to talk about is in the news lately again now that we have these budget issues again the sense of urgency let's do better with what we do have um in the news is an article about how low performing students fall further behind the pack and I cannot tell you how much this upset me because we've had more money than we've ever had in our schools and there's absolutely no excuse no excuse for this to be true and I get that that's a national statistic but I'm
125pretty um you know I I challenge your staff to prove that that's not the case at ABC not only that we continue to get outc cap money you know $29 million is like I consider it a bonus it's money that we wouldn't have if we didn't have students with these added challenges this money is for getet you know we all probably have seen that image of you know stepping stool some kids need no stepping stool while other kids need a stepping stool that's super high we have the money to provide that and I think if we did and if we did appropriately we would have better outcomes because in the news as well is how Compton Unified boosted a standardized test course I mean if Compton can do it I like to think we can
126do it um back to funding I think we need to be more accountable for the money that we have I think we need to spend it more wisely um we really need to do an about if we're not getting the outcomes that we want why instead of continuing to do the same thing or maybe trying something that may or may not work i' like to think that just like we hired a demographer that we can hire someone that will probably cost us some money but may give us better returns for those $29 million that we spend year after year and could potentially decrease by a few million but there're still good there is going to be a lot of money um so I like to ask my board colleagues to support that idea and our
127superintendent to maybe explore that um the last thing is that I attended a presentation on the importance of belonging I know that when we had the last board report something that we probably didn't talk as much about is you know our schools all do healthy kid surveys um we have a lot of our kids that don't feel like school is a place where they belong or that they feel welcomed whether it be by their classroom or by the outside environment we know that that goes the long way so how much of the time and effort and resources are we investing in making sure that our schools are that place because we know that you know we as adults if we like where we work our productivity is at an all-time high when we don't like
128where we work our productivity is probably not as high and so the same thing is for little all kinds of bodies right little ones middle size all of them um we need to be where we spend our time needs to be a place that is welcoming um that's what my notes end so that's it thank you thank you miss m thank you Mr President um thank you cuz a lot of stuff that I had I'm going to I'm going to Echo you a little bit so um first I want to thank um our community for coming out and making suggestions especially my Council woman SE um it it you know you you you're here and we get a lot of information and sometimes it's hard for us to think outside the box so thank you
129for coming up with those ideas along that way I was thinking about we have have um solar panels um and if I was on the board when we put them back I would have asked for charging stations because I know um I've got an electrical vehicle I'm always looking for a place to charge even if I have to pay you know not as much as gas so thinking outside the box like how much would that cost us and what would our Revenue be um and I know at some stations they started at a certain time so it would be for our employees during the day date and then afterwards you open it up and you start charging the community and I know that it's going to be like who's going to come here that's that's
130something we have to look into but that would be something thinking out of the box to make to get some Revenue into um you know our funds um and then I have a question do we have a hiring freeze is there a hiring freeze in the district we call it strategic hiring so yes we are actively reviewing all positions and and and and and prioritize it uh you know of course certain critical roles certain roles you have to back fill right uh clearly the teaching staff right usually when we talk about hiring free or strategic hiring is more support staff and and how do we go about that and how can we still provide the support uh uh you know at the same time uh save some money so uh as part of that we
131we start looking into strategic hiring yes so so can I make a recommendation for strategic hiring is that we make sure that it's across the board and it's not you know just one bargaining unit because I I've I I don't want to be the the the district that says we're just not we're going to put a hiring freeze for these you know subgroup and but not this subgroup if we're going to do strategic it needs to be strategic in across the board right and I know the classroom is going to be probably the last one because we need credential teachers we need experience teacher but we also need experience classified so can we just make sure that it's not just one bargaining unit that we're focusing on and that we're kind of looking at the
132entire District yes ma'am so to make it you know Equitable to everybody and also along that I also want to make sure that um if our if our staff is working overtime that we make sure we pay them right if they're working if they're working hours that we need to pay them they they're owed that money for working those hours so I don't want to say that we're having a hiring freeze and we're having a pay freeze too if they're working those extra hours they're entitled to that pay um the next one I want to go to to um is uh we're making recommendations so some of my recommendations Mr President is along with um Dr Rios is that we have an amazing district and I think everyone knows that but sometimes as she said
133some schools we don't really know what's offered at that school and I'm going to look to Scott um he's our Communications and um we've looked at other districts and we know that Downey does an amazing job and they're bringing in you know students and their their um enrollment has not gone down as much as ours so what can we do I mean let's not reinvent the wheel we have districts who are doing things um and I see some on social media I'm sorry I'm on social media I have to admit it um but there's some amazing things and one of the things I like to look at is videos I like to see reals I like to see things that are happening at schools because they're quick right they're quick um so I would love
134to see our district highlight some schools um like Dr Rio said you know maybe as a parent I don't know what's happening at that magnet school maybe my child is interested in that but I don't know that because I haven't I haven't been told that um and I know we do like a district um open house and that would be great to invite not just you know like our community like blast it out there and have everybody come um and and I know this this this is something that um Dr R mentioned is belonging and then the some some of the struggles that we we we deal with with our students that we need to address is we had our diversity Equity meeting the other night and we were talking about students and how um
135um we need to make sure that they have access to certain classes and after the whole meeting was done um there was a young lady that was sitting with me and I kind of asked her I said mi how do you you know um would you take these classes and she she told me and she her history is that she was at gar and she struggled at gar and she's at she's at Tracy and she said Tracy was the best place for her like she is getting a compared to the other grade she was doing and I think Tracy has sometimes been looked at as punitive um my son if I ask my son I say hey about Tracy he says well that's where you go when you don't do well but I think Tracy
136is an amazing opportunity for students to grow because it's a different envir environment for them and I would like to see our district promote Tracy as an option this is an option for you to go to um if you are struggling at one of our um high schools then maybe this is an option for you and we can go and visit it we can go because she said said I'm getting A's I might even graduate early and that was an amazing story to hear from her um but then she told me she says Miss Mela honestly um I wouldn't take the AP classes I said why why not CU I go to work after school and so that's one of the struggles that our students of color are faced with and not just color a
137lot of our students have jobs and not just because um they want to it's out of necessity because they're helping their families and so I think that's something that we need to address and and and say you know you belong here at our school um please come and whatever way we can support you in that maybe you have some struggles outside of the school that we can still support you in that way um she left happy she was happy she's like okay I said hey she works at a pizza place I go I'm going to go visit you and have some pizza so I think that's something that we need to address because um if our students are struggling and they don't feel they belong then they're not going to come to school and then
138we have to give them attendance recovery so that's something I I hope that we could um we could address um and I think let me see and yes we need to make Cuts away from the classroom um I we know that and I know that that there's been mentioned school closures and I was on the committee and I was the one that made the recommendation not to recommend school closures and I would only consider even thinking about it if we have done everything possible before we do that so we need to get to the point where we said we we crossed out everything we did this we did this we did this okay now we can consider this because I don't want to go from here to here and we know our community they didn't
139want that so I don't want to have to bring them back over here to the school board and have the same um presentation that they did I want to be able to say to them Community we went through every single step we tried everything that we can do and this is our last resort and so that those are my recommendations thank you Mr President thank you Tatiana Buie thank you Mr President um and again thank you uh Mr wi and for um staff for for this budget study um to my fellow board members thank you i' I'm um echoing a lot of your thoughts and comments and um in response to what Dr Rios has presented in terms of um somewhat of an audit of of what's being done with the elcap Buns um you
140know I some something I I think I I have been thinking about since Dr Castro's last presentation a couple weeks ago is the challenge of being a parent um uh during these times of of all the challenges we face just just with raising our kids and doing what we have to do on a daily basis to ensure our kids have the best education they can um I know that schools and our district can provide a lot during the school day um and even after school I'm finding out now but I want to know what other limitations are we facing in the after school time um and how that negatively impacts our numbers because I know even as a working mom um my day doesn't end at 5:00 I'm doing stuff with my kids I'm ensuring
141they get their work done and even my son who who is very bright and very um academically focused he he somewhat enjoys school I still have to push him and I can't even imagine a child who is having a hard difficult time wanting to do schoolwork when he's just done school work all day and the last thing he wants to do is have his parent further push it at home so so you know where where is that challenge happening and is is that uh what's happening with our our our um students who are facing you know those those kind of struggles and and whether that a potential audit wouldn't cover that is something I'm interested to know additionally um we've brought up figuring out data behind where our kids are going why our kids are
142going why our kids are attracted to certain schools are we attracting kids from outside of the district to um schools in our area um in our district and if so why I'm very interested to know those those details because as we said there's certain districts around us um that are growing why are they growing um you know obviously there's may be more housing develop developments elsewhere but um if they have programs that we could potentially bring here let's do it um in terms of generating Revenue I know there was mention of actually uh utilizing the the buildings I'm I it's been suggested to me by Educators that our fields are not in great condition and they could be in a better condition and could potentially be rented to um sports teams uh you know soccer
143soccer teams and I do see that that is being done at the ABC Adult School on cabillo um and I believe um at other elementary schools but for example hasool middle school has a very large field that is not in a great shape due to gophers and and whether that anything can be done to rehabilitate that um so so those are those are additional thoughts my for me for me I'm very concerned about losing potentially um you know long-term loyal dedicated staff and teachers um I I I really you know obviously don't want to go that route ever um and lastly in in regards to the ab218 uh that was probably one of the most difficult things for me to to really understand and learn about um as I first became a board member uh
144something I I don't want to say obviously it's a very emotional thing we have to um and I think the community me member who brought it up said it very well is that we can't look at it like you know we are obviously paying for for for the faults and and the bad things other people have done now but it's something that as as a community you know it just has to be done whether we can potentially get any of that money back is something we definitely have to explore but where I find kind of a light at the end of the tunnel tunnel is that um those those extremely old old claims old cases will never come back that that window has closed right and now potentially if there are any other claims of
145of someone of of an age who wants to come bring it back we will have the insurance policy um to help us cover that because that was the time period then that we had an additional um insurance so that's something that that find a little bit of of I don't want to say peace but I don't feel like we're going to have that potential struggle in the future years to come in terms of ab218 so I did want to bring that up because that was something I was a little bit confused about but but my understanding is that window has closed as of January 2023 correct and and now um also on that slide deck it said there are several claims left I my understanding there was like two claims left is that incorrect I
146I can only speak General while depends on how you see it a claim could have multiple plan tips so whether you want to see it's one claim or multiple claims okay so thank you yes we have discussed this in close sessions okay thank you thank you um thank you Twan that was a great presentation detailed and I think what the community needed thank you Dr Castro for providing some additional academic background cuz we are a school we're not a necessarily a profit making indust and also Dr zlo for madly taking everybody's notes down to see what our priorities are on all this I'm really honored to be working on this board uh with this great community that comes here and with these great ideas optimism is just great doc uh Sue has good optimistic ideas
147electric vehicles I think is a great idea cutting the travel budget is um you know one that uh is interesting and and um and so getting this ahead of this now a lot of what we're talking about is costing more and investing more um but I'm sure that we can have a good discussion as far as what I'm doing in terms of some of this is that I'm I have appointments with all the city managers because this is an important issue that the entire community so we're going to meet with Hawaiian Gardens we're going to meet with Lakewood we're going to meet with Aria um so I'm glad Aria City uh city council persons here seros as to find finding a good solution for all of us um real estate solusion is not the end
148of the world it's $4 million and we have a $3 million budget so if we actually just addressed 1% you know that's uh that we would actually meet these particular issues but I think it's the long-term gain that we're hoping for here right you're talking about helping us with math and you're talking about helping us with some of the schools in really showcasing them making a radical uh change ab218 and I can talk to the legislature cuz I'm a delegate on csba and so um and I've been talking about that till I'm blw in the face uh that we need to have a real fund not a fake little itty bitty fund but a real fund and have the reforms that are necessary so that way these things don't happen again we have the insurance
149now but I mean separate apart from that we have procedures and costs but also we can't cost out our community because all those great little activities that we have if we charge a ton of money we we'll never get them on our football fields because of the uh cost for the sexual abuse insurance right we're charging them more than a lot of areas so we need to balance all that and I'm so glad for these great ideas and um and yes Twan knows that our priorities is to cut away from our kids as much as possible so we've reduced down from 25,000 to actually 16,000 students um almost 9,000 students since the time uh before actually the time that uh I think uh Sophie say started on the board um that's 9,000 students we've figured
150out how to really uh do the the math and and make it all work um and I'm sure we'll try to do that to the future but um we're really going to have to uh do all the steps that we're talking about to make sure that the community knows that um we are trying to ensure the best education for for all of our kids all of our kids not just a few of the the top ends but all of them and so um I think we have our homework let me quickly just say something um so we have we have homework cut out for us we have another March April May to figure out the priorities and uh uh I'm sure I'm confident that we can come up with something positive uh board member say
151yeah I just want to make a one clarification here um most people say hey why don't you share a facility with us let let use the facility make some Revenue actually not really because usually it's on the after school hour time so the labor will cause overtime so we almost make even from there don't even bring that much revenue in I just want to let people know that using the facility we also have a contract with the city so a lot of time people want certain time we can't let the public to use it because contract with the Sero City they will have first right to use it so a lot of things behind that people doesn't know the history about and so School District we don't mind to uh rent the place for the
152people to use but we just provideed service we don't really make a lot of Revenue here thank you board members say I think uh the idea is that so many ideas that we have here are are not going to be realistic right they're just not going to get this result but I'm glad that we're bringing up the issues so that way we can analyze and get the right answers so if we didn't if somebody heard all the negatives first well of course we can't do anything um but there is an example of a District in Downey that's not declined as much and they had a a major change in the way they did business and uh um so that's why I'm I'm not saying oh we can't do any of this stuff let's hear it
153I've heard from we've heard from you I think the staff has heard and they're going to fully explore all of these alternatives to the best they can and I think they'll give us a good explanation as to what we can and and uh what what is the best CU we can't gamble with our kids right we're not going to bet on a hope that something's going to happen when we know datawise it's not going to happen right we're we're not going to do that um and our staff is going to make sure we make the best decisions possible so with that can I have a motion to close our meeting all in favor say I I thank you [Music] [Applause] [Music]