CorpusRecord 3569

AADUSD EDUCATION SUBCOMMITTEE- KICK-OFF 12-03-2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District
Date
2025-02-05
Location
Los Angeles County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,883 words · about 39 min
Collected
2026-05-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good afternoon everyone uh Welcome to our first education subcommittee for aadusd um we'll go ahead and call this meeting to order at 3:48 pm on December 3rd um we are recording the zoom meeting uh the virtual aspect of it so that we could go ahead and upload um the subcommittee Zoom meetings to our library under Board of Education on our website uh reviewing the agenda for this afternoon uh we have of course call to order because this is a public meeting we have public comments for anybody via Zoom or in person that would like to make a public comment we'll go through introduction and roles of the subcommittee and then positions and purpose for the subcommittee as a whole and then we'll have our topic our first topic Education Code and school discipline and then

002future meeting agenda items next steps and a a date in January since we meet once a month uh so with that um public comment we don't have anybody on online correct Mr ores okay anybody oh might you have anybody there Dr Chamberlain public comments raised hand I don't see anybody let me just no two participants which is Basis yes okay no public comment at this time we'll move on to item C introduction and roles we have uh two of our Board of board members are liaison to the subcommittee um Miss um board clerk as well as Dr Deus board member um in their role U for the district as well as subcomittee um we could maybe go around the room maybe we could start with Dr Chamberlain just to introduce and to you hi I'm

003Paula Chamberlain and I am I don't am I chair on the subcommittee for Education no we'll get into the chair okay yeah okay but director so I'm director of um student support services and education services you Eric sahak superintendent Nanda mcau assistant to the superintendent and Mr Ortiz you're a big part of this I'm Caesar Ortiz this is network administrator thank you thank you for your support there U for this meeting all right so we'll move on to subcommittee positions and purpose um it is during this FIS school year that there was a kickoff of subcommittees something that was initiated by our our trustees so we have two that have already commenced facilities and finance subcommittee and today's the kickoff for Education subcommittee we anticipate in the month of January our policy and management subcommittee

004to kick off as well we have Liaisons for each subcommittee assigned uh the purpose of the subcommittee is to really kind of go in depth and have a deeper dive into topics concerns issues that are pertinent to the district to our community to our students and our parents and so that we could go ahead collectively uh through our chair who who is Miss txon and I'll get into that uh to actually bring it forward to the board um at the regular board meetings as part of a subcommittee uh report if there's anything that is going to be recommended from the subcommittee to be brought forward to the regular board meetings of for the community so um in positions I do believe that board president FSG graph designated uh Miss ton as the chair of the

005subcommittee for Education all right um okay with that said going to go ahead and turn it over to um our chair if she if she' like to say a few words and then we could go into the um agenda item for today I am just um thankful that everybody's here so thank you guys very much for taking time out of your day George online um thank you for putting together the the um the agenda that's what that's called um and the everything to go with it that we asked for so thank you very much for putting that together to the staff thank you Dr Chamberlain thank you Miss ton all right Dr Chamberlain Education Code and school discipline our topic for today get right to it so I shared two documents with you the first

006one that that is nine pages long it's entitled student discipline guidelines it starts with kind of an overall where we start with student discipline and goes um with kind of progressive to more um punitive forms of discipline if you go I'm just going to kind of summarize over it because there's kind of a lot but our principes use this at the school site it's shared in our um in our school um handbooks as well if you go to the second page it lists of a number of things that could be considered alternatives to suspension and kind of the pro the progressive discipline um pathway if you will was starting with the conference with school Personnel usually the principal a parents the P's parents a guardian and the people themselves um next might be referrals to

007counselors school psychologist so social workers child welfare and attendance Personnel is actually the student support office which is my office and then other school support personal Personnel ca for case managers also our PBIS which is our proactive behavior intervention supports um and you you guys have heard a little bit about that at board meetings as well we also sometimes do Student Success teams or study teams they're teams where a panel of teachers and other SK site um support will get together and look at a students records and kind of look at everything and discuss kind of what the pluses are that where the student's doing well where the student has areas of growth and then put together um some ideas of interventions that might support the students whether they be social emotional or academically sometimes

008students act out in classrooms because they are they are not following the academic piece they're so far behind so they're just not engaged so we really look at their behavior we look at their academics we look at their attendance we include parents um and and really a whole team to put together a a support plan for the student um those are generally followed up with a meeting in every four to six weeks where you say we're going to do certain interventions and you look at those interventions to see if the students making progress whether it be academically or social emotional or perhaps both um often times if you we would have three of these meetings if we do see a students not making academic progress um or there continues to be concerns there are times

009where a student at that point might be referred um for a um special education assessment um it's really on an individual basis um and that's kind of what the next if you I kind of spoke about the next pieces going that the number four is referral for comprehensive cych social or psycho educational assessment um or enrollment in programs for teaching behavior management we address a lot of that through our social emotional um program which is through PBIS and navigate 360 and that is a platform that has a whole lot of resources on teaching lessons with students and at each School site depending on what's going on with the student if it's bullying just we may sit with a student a team and um work with the student on bullying activities one of the things that

010I know Vasquez did and they had the social workers it is they did they put together a six- week program where the social worker went into all the ninth grade classes and did lessons on bullying um and that ended up with some ended with kind of some restorative practices and it was a really um it was actually a really good experience for kids other kids asked why they didn't get a do it older kids and I said well we did it one year for nth graders and the plan was to extend it the next year and for 10th graders so I know that those are some things that we're doing to help students make better choices that and I said but vaping is another area of concern where that schools are working on as well

011as the anger management sometimes leading to fights and things um and then it goes into individual suspensions into and into multi-day suspensions and kind of what the law is as it relates to how many days a student can be suspended it talks about makeup work and it talks about active violence on the next page which would be fighting if you go to the following page and I'm sorry these aren't numbered moving forward I may add numbers to them um these are interventions that we consider remediations and consequences they're lettered a through F and they align with if you go to the next page um it's actually a g the G is at the top of the next page you have a table right here and the table is um this is the table of the

012Ed codes that we generally suspend for so you can't suspend a student if you don't have an ed code it's not allinclusive but these are the main ones that we find that come up at school so you see them listed on the far left the Ed code and and the name like assault with the de weapon fighting assault and they go down this is violations against persons on the next page um we have a continuation of violence violations against persons we have violations against public health and safety and we have violations against School administrators and administra administrative procedures the next two columns are elementary and middle and high school as it relates to Ed code and the discipline as far as the discipline rules they're different at elementary school even as it relates to Ed

013code so a student that like kindergarten through third grade cannot be there's no such thing as an education code for a student for sexual assault for a student that's not in the fourth grade um for students that are younger you're seeing some inappropriate behaviors which you do sometimes sometimes depending again on the situation that might be just guidance from the principal and the family and working with the student but if you see some things that are pretty disturbing that's a call to child protective services and also sometimes law enforcement but generally it's Child Protective Services again it depends kind of on what the situation is as far as the level of support outside the school that you might reach out to but we ask our principles to follow these for example if a student's fighting

014which is the second um column down or second box down if they're in elementary school for your first offense you would look at b c g or F those are the letters on the previous pages and you would work through those as Progressive disciplines so it usually involves calling a parent um it make this one a is parent contact B is counseling C is personal responsibility we find a lot of um kind of positive students make some positive gains with personal responsibility when you start to help them reflect on their behavior and the impact of their behavior on others for example if there's a fight at school or you're arguing with another student student you know that's not just between myself and the student that affects everybody else in the room or around that scena

015it affects the families of both both uh students involved and sometimes can affect affect the families of others we're really trying to help kids understand through positive behavior reinforcements that their behaviors have a wide range of effects they start to understand and to help them make better decisions can I ask clarifying questions on that part um where it says first offense second offense third offense what is the timeline of that are we talking first offense in a school year or first offense for their life time like usually a school year it's usually a school year so so if a student gets in a fight on May 25th and then they get in another fight on August 15th we're talking August 15th is a First Defense yeah but I will say and I'll give you an

016example um when I was a school principal I had some kids that decided to get in a fight in the last day of school what could I do theyve got in a fight they ran through the park and they were gone school's over yeah we called the parents we documented it we actually talked to those kids when they came back to school right like we didn't forget about them and we provided some supervision and some interventions we obviously didn't suspend them because that's after the fact but if those students would have gotten a fight oh no that they would have been suspended like that or or what would have been the appropriate be you know what I mean like it yes so but what should should happen in in that case and I know that

017that this fight happened if you and I got in a fight at the end of the school year may even we should be having the school should be having a conversation with both of you to make sure like oh have how are you friends now since the summer okay so when a when kid get in a fight in January and then that same student gets in a fight again in September Now That September fight is a first offense because it's been 6 months or n months or whatever if it was March like say it was spring break most likely you're going to yeah and and and sometimes usually what happens is like maybe there's a fight say there's a fight in March and we come back to school and the student gets in a fight

018but they they don't maybe they don't even get in a fight till the next January so no we wouldn't we now did we look at everything because when we pull Aries up we can see everything as student we can see everything all the way from metal art yeah and so we do take that into consideration that doesn't mean that we because suspension is not so suspension is not going to correct the behavior um and and if you read the research and I've read really a lot of it and just done it suspension severs relationships it causes distrust with families does it work sometimes yeah it does it does work sometimes but most of the time you know if you've done other things first and then I suspend a student now I have a relationship with

019that student you know that we've try but there have to be consequences at some point we might have to suspend you if the rule is generally if you if if I have to worry as an administrator that you're a danger on my campus and I can't trust you to not fight another student then I'm going to suspend you I don't know and there's and there's there's an element Sorry Miss Tex that's okay there's an element of um you know with the suspension as well even for let's say an alleged aggressor right there's a cooling down period with the suspension um yes notification um that's that's and that is sometimes why like sometimes we do like give you a day to go home for for that very reason again because I don't at this point feel

020like you can stay on campus I mean the day of we're probably going to send you home I mean if it's a fight if you're fighting we're GNA suspend you like I mean yeah or stealing or bullying like let's not just talk about fights so tell me where so it says theft it says first offense and this this is my next follow-up question m where it says first offense AB c g without looking at the rubric of what ABC and G are what who decides which one of those or two or all four of them who decides what that it should be the principal and it should be based on Progressive discipline now this is elementary school we could talk about any of them but right but I mean on for a middle high school

021student and that's seventh grade maybe sixth grade um again a first offense may be a suspense it it depends it may be a suspension or it may be BC or F I'm going to go look back at BC ORF because even as many times if I've use this document I don't have it memorized and a lot of times if it's an older student I'm even actually going to talk to them about their behavior and say these are our choices and I mean it depends on the level of theft you know I mean if they stole somebody's phone and they smashed it and broke it and they're pretty vindicative we probably sus spend them if the kid's never been in trouble before and you know in all the years that we've had them you know that's

022where you get to be like well am I going to suspend you so just because it says here suspend one day that's not an automatic suspend one day no it's a suspension or bcnf okay so it could be counseling it could be personal responsibility definitely parent conference you'd call the parents anyway I mean e is not on there but campus beautific is one of our Progressive discipline like it's something that we and we do lunch detention like there are some things that aren't on here that we do we have also after school detention and principales want to add Saturday school too so at some point I think that we'll have that as well so let's go back to fighting okay um fighting assault threat Mutual assault and battery third offense suspend 3 to 5 days

023bcnf and then for continued infractions that mean the fourth infraction is when they get so it depends on the it depends on the um it depends on the intensity and the level of the fight right so I think that's where that's where there was confusion in a different conversation is if this person is fighting in September of last year and then they're fighting in September of this year one time they're being suspended and the next time they're being put up for expulsion where or talk of put being put up for expulsion where is so the only time that You' be put up for expulsion and that's one of the big it's not a big five is because is if there was some egregious like um behavior on your part you ganged up on a student

024the student didn't bu back there was physical injuries so again it it depends on the level of like the level of fights if you will like I mean Dr Chamberlain is correct so yeah the level of egregiousness yeah so if the fight um leads to let's say the alleged victim receiving medical treatment that could be considered as an assault and then so that is it's almost an automatic exposion recommendation referral right and recommendation so what normally happens in a bigger school district is a recommendation like that wouldn't re result in an expulsion it would normally result in you being moved to another school due to safety and because we now luckily we do have Virtual Academy now so it does give us the option of doing an expulsion um with suspended enforcement which we kind

025of didn't have last year so that's kind of new this year um since we're small we don't have that movement of let's say from one Middle School to another Middle School one high school to another but with the addition of the Virtual Academy of celis it opens up the we do have a little bit more wiggle room I know this is where George is pretty passionate about it so do you I don't want to speak over you if you have anything jump in you finish yeah I'm very passionate about this subject I think safety is important as far as physical safety to our students um one of my questions that I have is I kind of asked most of my questions that I was think about so the suspension dates one to two to five

026section who's coming up with that no but it's LEL provides guidance and I'll tell five days is always pending an expulsion I will say principles do break that rule sometimes but they're not supposed to suspend for five days unless they're going to recommend for expulsion now has it been done yes but it's not supposed to be done but that I have is not not the typical you know one one fight a year or not even one fight a year just just Case by case circumstances right like the typical I pushed you or whatever I'm not worried about those cases I'm worried about the cases where the repated individual keeps fighting and fighting you know multiple people through throughout the school the school year that's what I'm worried about at what point are we saying okay

027now it's time for exposion or a recommendation for exposion and I want to see some criteria that the district needs to follow to recommend for exposion like we just talked about the egregiousness of the fight the injuries the multiple attackers I don't see that in this Matrix I want to see okay so at what point is the board going to hear this story of what happened because that's what's missing that's the piece that I think is missing I agree with that because we just talked and it completely makes sense when you say it out loud and we just talked about it but it's not written anywhere so like when a when a parent is coming in saying why isn't this student being expelled we get a lot of that right that you know different parents

028parents of victims or parents of onlookers why isn't this student being expelled it would be great to have a document that says this is the document see is it does it say it in there like the is there was no medical attention so we're not expelling or there was the student went to the hospital so we need to like so on when a student gets hurt it raises from the fir the second one which is fighting assault threat um that's a that's the Lesser violation assault and battery when it raises to the level where a student goes to the hospital they come back they've been hurt then it changes to assault assault assumes assault assumes um physical injury so we wouldn't use this fighting assault threat mutual combat one um I mean okay so I

029have a bloody nose I don't go to the hospital it's still considered assault but when someone goes to the hospital and then they're hurt and the doctors confirm that they're hurt then that raises the level of the suspension 2 4892 I mean it's hard to yeah that that's are these title fighting and are these coming from the educational code because battery is fighting I don't understand why that's that's separated like that unless like you said there are some conditions that outline the sever of the fight which I really would like to see but the you're using a different terminologies that really mean the same thing in the criminal aspect of it so I'm not sure I'm not sure how we this the educ that you fight somebody that's battery if you touch somebody that's un

030wanted touching that's battery so I'm not sure that's confused on these two whe they list yeah good comment um Dr De Jesus um you know we follow the language that's provided by the state U per the Education Code so the other the other document that you that you have um and we have it on Zoom right now thank you Caesar so Midway Midway down um page one of the second second document um it says some discretion student offenses with limited principal discretion principal M principal must recommend expulsion when the following occur at a school or at a school activity off campus unless a principal determines that the expulsion is inappropriate that first that that first um row uh says causing serious physical injury to another person except in self-defense so that's language that we have

031to go by by CDE by the state and so what Dr Chamberlain was describing as a former principal when I had to deal and investigate fights and if there wasn't that physical injury which uh amounted to let's say um needing medical attention then I would code it as Education Code ec4 48900 A1 and that's and that's that's a drop- down menu that we have in our student information system and it will be coded as such 48900 A1 and it says causing serious physical injury to another person accept in self-defense I can't change that terminology if there was an incident and it's happened to me as a former principal suda needs physical attention the victim then the the same it's the same terminology but I'm going to go ahead and now switch it from 48900 A1

032to 48 48900 A2 and then when I code it as have a list of a criteria that that that that kind of spells out what serious body injury is so we do in law enforcement you know it's something injury requiring stitches unconsciousness broken bones but is there something that we can put into this policy where we can show people okay well we did not meet this criteria because there was none of these right now it's pretty vague it's like physical serious or physical injury that's pretty vague if my my daughter comes home with a bloody nose to me that could be serious so I don't is there a way we can input what that means to the district what does serious or physical injury mean to us as relates to a recommendation for exposion so

033I think if we take out the gray area we put something that's concrete we can avoid parents coming in saying well why is my kid not this why is my kid you know only get or the suspect only getting two days or the student getting two days well this is why because under these parameters it says he he didn't have stitches he didn't he wasn't unconscious he didn't receive medical attention but at the parent if I read this I don't I don't see that to me it's just like okay well you guys are making you know subjective decision on whether or not to expel this kid or not well first of all a lot of what you're talking about is confidential and we can't share that information anyway so and and even in law enforcement

034things are subjective I don't know that you're ever going to get away from some subjectiveness I I don't I don't know how you're going to get away with that has injuries that's not the objective that's objective he has if he has stitches you're getting arrested for this code if you have a broken well you're getting arrested for well I wish I I so I I I had a huge fight at Vasquez a few years ago for students that I put up for expulsion and that was one of it was a huge fight I'd call law enforcement I've never had to do that in 10 years and I couldn't believe they didn't arrest the student they ganged up on this the there was blood everywhere and I asked the officer afterwards like why why wasn't the

035student arrested and because we they called it assault they said this is assault we called it assault and they said because nobody went to the hospital like okay so well I tell you right now that's because they're lazy okay but I agree with you I'm not disagreeing I'm just saying like we're gonna like there's I don't know how we get around that like you have humans involved in all of these situations right exactly I just would like to be a little bit more clear on what what a parent can expect or what a student can expect I'm not I'm not saying you have to share confeti stuff but you know if a student I mean it's clear if a student gets hurt to the point where we list the parameters of the injuries it's clear

036their recomend recommendation is expulsion and also that would give our our administrators black and white backup where they're saying this you know this is why your student is getting suspended this is why you're student this is what and it's not well that's what I decided because it was up to my discretion and that's what Dr sahakian decided because it's up to discretion I use this with parents and I get those calls too that you guys get and you can refer them to me and I share this with parents and I will in vague terms without speaking specifically about their case say that has for us to even suspend a student one it has to be in the Ed code so if I don't have an ed code then I'm not suspending are we perfect using

037this this is new like we have one new principle and this was I think presented to our staff last year for the first year this this maj um and I am still working with our principles to be consistent in using it um I think if we're consistent in using it we'll do better I do and we review it almost every time we meet I I will also say like as humans we make mistakes so you know and and we bring biases and so that unfortunately does affect and we're aware of that I'm aware of it I'm sensitive to it so when I am working with our principles I try to provide guidance um but you know I I think sometimes you know we we're not perfect and you know I completely agree I think I

038mean I just think that I think the intention is is is aligned with your thoughts is there a way to combine these two documents because this is confusing for me to go back and forth so if I was a parent trying to find it on the and even if you just like no discretion some discretion broad discretion under each one of these so then we can know like okay what does that mean and then put these yeah I can make it as one document that's a good idea definitely not a directive but I think it would be a lot easier to follow I think it's a good suggestion I consider it direct here thank you I actually like working together like this so yeah it's easier to follow but I do I I do agree

039like um and this we this this year is the first year that this was in our student handout so um I think may even making some updates to to language so this matches this is this also available on our website or just in the student handbook yes which is on the websites so each of the so you have to find it by going to the student handbook and then search scr way to make it a standalone document yeah we can make a website for student support services and put the stuff up there that's what a lot of District yeah we could I mean we could have a link and then yeah so be great I mean because we do that with our curriculum too like you have ed services page and I'll look to see

040what we have on our page if if we could go back um to Dr deus's comments I I just want to share my thoughts on that um no I appreciate you know having a more definitive response for our parent Community having it very clarified and making it more objective um you know it kind of it's a nice segue into perhaps an agenda item for the policy subcommittee so that we could take a look at the administrative regulations for student discipline if we want to take a look at that language so you know a recommendation from again it's our board liaison that would make the recommendation not staff to the board but it's it's it's um taking taking the input here in terms of maybe elaborating on what constitutes an expulsion in terms of bodily injury

041to an administrative regulation so we could take that from this subcommittee to the policy subcommittee to work on as well based on this group recommendation and can you share some of the definitions like if like stitches I think is a yes right like do you have if you could even email me like if that might be something we could add I will if we're updating policies I definitely will do that and I'm not I I totally agree with you when you say if we're all human with make mistakes I agree I totally agree with you but what I'm talking about is the one that keeps making the mistakes over and over again U you know third fight within the you know his time in the district that's what I'm worried about because as the fights

042intensify the the level of they intensify yeah I don't want to be sitting there on the news saying that he could have stopped this a long time ago you know when this kid showed evidence of violence physical violence toward to other students and now the kid maybe I don't know could be dead right you don't know yeah I want to prevent that how do we do that by having a clearing of our polic is too what's that the well Dr De Jesus you know you know I hate to go back to the Matrix the rubric that we have but if you know if you have this Con this Continuum of this this this misbehavior right the example you brought up so even for let's say Middle School High School third offense you're looking at a

0435-day suspension and a 5-day suspension typically warrants a recommendation for expulsion yep so there's really no wiggle room when you do a 5 day that's 99.9% of the time it's a recommendation for expulsion that comes to the district office so I mean you know we're not condoning this Perpetual misbehavior and it just you know let's suspend and bring the kid back um especially if the level of you know bodily injury is is heightened right um well a third offense is an automatic three to five days so if it was a higher level like what you're saying egregious someone got hurt or stitches would definitely be on a third of I mean I don't even recall any I don't even recall any students that have had were on a third offense but if there was a

044third offense this you would go to this document and you would follow these directions and if I could interject to just pling Devil's Advocate Dr Deus you know if if we do make if we do make any amendments to the existing policies moving forward and we try to Define you know what would constitute an expulsion recommendation let's say stitches uh broken arm what have you and we leave some other elements out that could really backfire in the sense of well you know these you know these injuries are not listed but these injuries are listed so how do we now decide for because that could for lack of better term pigeon hole a district to say okay these are the five injuries but then my child has something that's out outside of the five just playing

045Devil's Advocate to not to kind of well Corner us anything requiring medical attention it could be medical attention yeah go around by that if I I take my K to the hospital I mean it's pretty serious correct now I was just talking about certain examples that's for some parents some parents also take their kid to the doctor for like a hangnail you know what I mean like just going to the doctor doesn't make it a serious offense going to the doctor and having the doctor say yes this student is injured makes it a serious offense the doctor says there's nothing wrong with you yeah well look at domestic violence in this case right if you have no injuries no visible injuries it's a misdemeanor but if there's visible marks it's a felony that's another thing

046if there's visible injuries to a person it becomes a different level a higher level of Pride yeah and that's and many times we yeah without bringing up any examples you know not to break any confidentiality but you know working with our parents are our Guardians in terms of the community communication piece you know your child went to the doctor I believe you said you're you know they're going to get medical attention the parent brings back documentation you know that's all part of the investigation quote unquote quote unquote um so if there's anything that indicates their medical attention was um provided based on injuries and that's you know coming from a you know a physician well that that plays a huge factor in in the investigation and the outcome so my my my only point was

047you know professionally speaking not to list specifics let's say stitches as an example because then gosh if my my child has something else and it's not on the list and then then what are we looking at if it's something a little bit broader and I know then it comes that gray area again about subjectivity and we're trying to avoid that just playing Devil's Advocate looking at both sides that's all but definitely to take a look at policy moving forward if a student punched another kid in the face and they received some stitches they say they got cut first offense are we talking about the BC G and F uh type of U uh recommendations or what are we talking in that same scenario based on the chart that we have now he gets punched in

048the face got five pches what what are we doing at the district so every single one every case is so different so like if you just looked at the form you would say first offense spend one to three days but if it was a really bad fight and they got stitches we'd probably be recommending them for expulsion that's and that's all I'm asking for yeah I mean is is just to look at the severity of injuries and the totality of how many times this person's been in a fight and then say here you go we're gonna recommend exposure that's all I'm asking based off of what you just said that goes against what is right here so again again look you could put stuff in writing but you you can't put every this it it's

049the same with special education you cannot put everything single scenario you have to deal with every single scenario differently right so so here so and there's so many things that affect it we had a student First Defense involved in a fight no stitches but it was two girls they it was a bunch of girls they were fighting it was pretty egregious and one girl not un similar to probably what you recently was but it was over a year ago those kids are in foster care and the and they're great kids they're but they have an attorney so as soon as we you know let the parents know that we're moving forward with an expulsion for both kids um we get a call from the attorney she was great she said so share with me the

050other forms of other means of discipline correction thank you and for one student we had some because she'd been in trouble before not fights but she'd been in trouble before we had worked with her and so we moved ahead with an expulsion for her but the other student um I think we end up putting her on on Virtual but she was in the 11th grade never been in trouble before at all and was in this fight and so we put her up for expulsion but it didn't go to that level it didn't go through as far as the expulsion because it wasn't going to hold up legally not just because she was fostered just because she had an attorney who then calls and says well you don't have other means of Correction you don't have

051proof of that so in that case we and we we she went on Virtual and I believe that student has been back in school for a long time again not not in trouble but now if there if there hadn't been an attorney involved would we have gone forward with the expulsion uh yeah we would have we but see the the attorney it doesn't matter if they have an attorney everyone gets an attorney it's just let the courts figure it out if if we did something wrong against educational Cod they would figure that out in court just because they have an attorney doesn't mean that we're going to say you know what all right we're not going to just no no but in this case Leo would have turned it over and this case the the

052goal was to have this campus be safe and for the student to have a consequence for her behavior and she was out of school for the remainder of the year and maybe possibly the part of the next year I'd have to go back and look so she still got a consequence she didn't go back to school we we put her on Virtual but there's just so many things that affect what that even what we can do is all I'm saying in every single case is different right and it's clear what we can and can't do it says I mean the educational code says you can suspend our recommendation for exposure for these categories every every call I go to on on in a police department are different just like abely all the scenarios are different

053but the law is there in black and white it says if you the elements of the crime if you do a b c and d you are going to get this you know same but here if you do this this and this the education allows you to do within these parameters that's that's exactly what I'm trying to convey here is that it is for the most part there is some objectivity within this within this educational code yeah there is definitely but Dr Deus I know T has to leave so um anything that the chair on the agenda was supposed to do I'm gonna go ahead and let Dr Deus handle that um thank you very much and please fill me in on anything that I'm going to miss after this point because this is riveting

054so thank you very much thank you thank you for coming bye George bye Bri we'll see you and Dr Deus you know you know completely understand the objectivity piece um with all due respect you know you know we're we're we're working with with children K through 12 and there is some subjectivity you know working with youth um I know you could understand that in a sense where you know LA County Office of Education CDE you know tells you you know you know pretty much directs and guides administrators to say you know unless it's egregious where it's the five mandatories right sexual assault possession of a firearm and so forth so on all these other elements they're going to look for especially if there's repeat behaviors you know are there other means of Correction because you

055are working with children you know between ages of six through let's say 18 um so so there there is some subjectivity but they the state provides you a guideline um and that's a guideline that we kind of you know work with and we take each each individual student U for you know what it's worth and on their Merit um you know so so for example you may have a first fight and the student you know I'm going to give an example I was a foster youth liaison for my former district and a principal so you you you have a foster youth who comes in in enrolls in your school he been there for two weeks uh gets into a fight if I put them up for expulsion it's not um something that need medical attention

056per se but they're in the fight you know I cannot put them up because I've only had them for two weeks I I haven't put any supports in place for the student if I do put them up and it goes to expulsion parent Ed rights holder puts an appeal goes to Leo they're going to overturn it the student is back on my campus so there's all these there's all these parameters and there's all this there is there's a there's plenty of sub objectivity I would say my recommendation you know again you know you're the trustee uh to you know utilize this this platform to you know uh work with the policy subcommittee to take a look at both both the BP and the AR for student discipline and to maybe clarify some of the definitions

057to make it more clear for our parents our community members um but there's but while there's some wiggle room there on the other side of that same coin there isn't a whole lot of wiggle room um because of the parameters that are set forth by the state I hope I hope that makes sense no it makes sense I just want to get to a point where we can have some some objectivity when it comes to the the repeat offenders are the ones that are doing the most physical harm to other students that's it I know that you know every case is different I understand that you know every child is different um but how we protect the other kids from being physically hurt at school that's that's where I'm trying to get at of course

058you know I'm not even focused on the first offense unless it's very egregious I'm just just to repeat offenders that's what I that's what I'm focused on so if we could somehow later on come up with some kind of collaborative way to um like you said lay out some criteria would be beneficial I think um but no I'm not trying to take away all subjectivity I know you have to have some subjectivity in each case I'm just trying to protect the students from the ones that uh are are very viol our repeated sure yeah but on third defense that gets automatic like it's written it is written down on third offense the example I shared with you earlier with the girl that was fost youth it was first offense and she still was put up

059for expulsion because of the egregiousness said Behavior that's all I'm asking yeah yeah yeah we could even we could bump that up to from third to be able to you know for us as you know when parents come into the board meeting you know they say well you know my my my student was this this and this I want to have an answer this is why because you know why we did or did not do something you know yeah we we we we understand I know you're the expert you guys been doing this for years you guys I don't take that away you guys are the experts in this field um and you you know what what benefits the students the most I'm just uh you know again I think as L on to the

060community my job is to um kind of relay their their wants of needs of of safety so if I'm not doing that I wouldn't be doing my job and we do too I mean we want the campuses to be safe kids can't learn if they don't feel safe right and that's important to us and if parents don't feel safe they're not going to send their kids to school so we do want with the drug the drug off I can I see the drug possession of Narcotics campus is that OB find parhelia yeah we drugs we put drugs under tobacco possession and use and under alcohol possession and use we'll because it says um substance abuse if you look in the third column over let me see if there's one on the next page um so

061we use those two Ed codes right there tobacco possession use or alcohol either one of those for drugs um and and paraphernalia obviously like The Vaping and stuff but if someone has a vape they they're going to get two they're going to get drug paraphernalia as well as well if we can prove they used it they're going to get used but we can still do 48900 because they had possession does that make sense you know it the the second document that we have um there's a section there that says sold forish or offered uh you know a substitute substance represented as the controlled substance so so we do have the discretion under Ed code 48 915b as a boy to put up a student under that that terminology that definition for expulsion so that's so

062that's there it it kind of goes in more detail in the second document with the I think it's a different Ed code because that's a selling yeah right so selling is those might be on this one a student comes up to stool with a little bit of fanol that can kill students instantly how do we treat that is that that's of course that's more egregious than a day suspension you follow me yeah and if we knew it was fentol I think what we run into is we come across things that school as administrators and we don't often know what they are unless it's obvious like marijuana right even in a vape we don't know what's in The Vape right it could be tobacco it could be marijuana I don't know what else you can put

063in those well there there is there is the Ed code again 4915 Dr Deus kind of encapsulates that as well well possession or under influence of marijuana or control substance or alcohol or any intoxicant that's so 495b as in boy again you know that defines that and you can actually expel um so if it's fenol and you know you know the the ramifications and it's it's deadly to be frank um right that's something that you know student students can be put up for expulsion yes that my question and so brand to mentioned combining these this document that I'm holding up this the second one that this is the one that came from Leo so I think it would be a really great idea to update even this second page of this document are not necessarily

064expellable on a first offense like bullying is on here but updating one it like making we're going to combine these okay so because some of the same Ed codes are on both of them and just updating the language so it more align um with the Ed code which that second two pager that you have that's directly from the Ed code okay right and um so is it is it fair to say because I I want to be respectful of everybody's time per the agenda um is it is it safe to say that you know for the policy subcommittee that's coming up in January uh no date has been set but it's it's set for January sometime that uh recommendation could be made from this subcommittee to the policy subcommittee in terms of taking a look

065and reviewing the student discipline policy absolutely okay just want to make sure thank you for that um with with that um topic it was an informational item Education Code and school discipline again taking a look at the time we we're at the two-minute Mark future meeting agenda items and next meeting date it's December it's Jan jary 17th it looks like the seven on there but it like wrinkled my printer it is the 17th yeah January 17th okay and then future meeting agenda items this could be continued or what was next on our topic I know we had a kind of a goal set out I'd have to go back and look but I think the January one I know we also talked about doing some um like test scores and education things like that as

066it relates to our curriculums and things and and I know the dashboard was just recent re recently released and we'll be doing a presentation for the board I think January 23d so it might be nice to kind of do a little bit of that with this committee prior to that board meeting um if that's okay yeah that sounds like a planner okay thank you so so State dashboard test scores test results in their next meeting January 17th all right um I'll go over all the the I'll go over all the um dashboard components like the College and Career indicator to I'll kind of review everything with with we'll have enough time okay with the committee next time wonderful all right we're we're approaching that 440 mark because we got off to a late start um

067with that and this is the chairs our chair you know um she had to leave um but I guess you're the designate you could call the meeting to an end um Dr D you're the alternate yeah let's do this it 440 perfect thank you all right thank you thank you thank you everybody

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.