001all right uh welcome everybody uh like to call the order the facilities and finance subcommittee meeting of November 12th uh can I get a roll call May here here Kai here Tom Brown a visitor thank you let's masch on here uh are there any public comments no no okay uh with that I'll uh turn it over to K esto for presentation [Music] from high performance learning Department corre well thank you Mr mascon and Mr May so we we're gonna switch a little bit here where we're gonna have the presentation Mr Tom from high performance learning environment is going to give us some an overview Mr Brown's going to give us ANW of what this organization does for school districts in general and then some options that um we would like to hear from him whether
002we want to move modular from the district office here to another facilities or were to build put in a new modular at the elementary school as an example so with that said Mr Brown um is you're on the floor thank you very much uh so we did prepare this presentation very quickly and I'll let you know beyond can you uh start with just kind of your history working with the school district okay I I will of course um I am a a local community member um and we have done a few little supporting uh projects uh I do want to emphasize uh as a community member I am dedicated to this community and this district and I do want to help out in what are ways I know Ernesto and I have become pretty pretty
003good friends and often times you know if there's a question he's he feels comfortable calling and asking and we generally figure out a solution um so that said high performance learning environments is uh a what's called a boutique firm so we're a small firm and let's look at the principles here uh contents the approach on the presentation just very short give you a quick introduction I'm going to show you some related examples of temporary versus uh or portable versus modular uh facilities and various pros and cons of those uh and then Q&A now I say then Q&A but I will say I'm also an agile professor for the College of uh engineering at se Sun I encourage open Forum so something comes up throw me a question it's fine I think that's more effective for
004all of us so do feel free um the Again Boutique firm the leadership uh Mr haime Ortiz Prime the president of the firm has a architect by training but he's basically all his career in construction management and particularly k12 and public institutions okay and he's done a lot of research to look at what are the optimal environments for children to learn uh Michael Terry is a licensed architect he's in runs the Northern California office uh we do collaborate and Michael has an extended uh history of full design L stamped licensed DSA design um and myself I'm technically a licensed mechanical engineer but I have 30 years of facilities operations and Service uh not to mention my military service before that uh I did retire from Cal State University Northridge in uh in 2009 and went
005immediately out into the public uh service side uh doing uh special services Consulting design Etc uh for my uh other colleges community colleges and K12 uh school districts and I've been doing that ever since uh been with the firm here which I very much appreciate for uh seven plus years now I appreciate this firm because it is a boutique firm and when you're looking for uh optimal efficiency the big firms unfortunately are cookie cutter cut and paste and that's what you get and there's no bargain we and what I love to do and have done all my life is problem solve um and if you ever want a example of you guys love project S I can share with you some of the $200 plus million dollars of full design build installs we did at
006Seas Sun that's inhouse that's him and I doing it all ourselves right equivalent uh or the two billion plus I've been responsible for Public Works uh so it's a great team let's move on to the next slide here please uh and the emphasis on that the firm has with with particular uh research and understanding of pedagogical needs vision is to increase student performance that's our Primary Vision agree with that and embrace that our mission is to serve as professional stewards uh the a steward is a professional that serves the needs of others that to the table so I act now as an owner operator representative I was a owner operator for a lot of years uh but I especially would like to be that service Steward for you all um and I think we can
007demonstrate the value of that too and then the goal is to deliver those values to you and our all of our clients technically this on next slide oh I'm sorry a little bit of a repeat so so again student Centric research based and data driven which I love and the the goal is to contribute to your strategic plan and needs um at whatever extent and often times we know and I know you guys know being in the construction in sometimes it's just an immediate need and you just got to react and act and effectively get it done and that's key and important too go ahead please and a little reiteration of what the research shows in regards to the effective environment and and that's something we have uh specialized in I should note Beyond just
008the classroom that most of my design build work at the University was for specialized Labs research Labs special technology uh uh Grant applications and and such so when it couldn't get done by conventional means they usually came to me uh go ahead please so we are looking at the priority in facilitating the performance but also optimal safety all right and now I think we get into the examples so let's go through these and again ask questions anytime you feel the need so we're going to discuss modular versus portable classrooms pros and cons different options uh risk factors Etc go ahead the modulars is portable what we have at metal Arc now are those considered Portables or modulars there is a nuanced line the vendor may have sold those to you as modular and until I
009would get down and look at the actual footing of the Portables I wouldn't exactly know the difference but you're talking Jacks and straps on Portables that are sitting underneath it versus sitting on a slab on grade or Foundation versus permanent foundation that's the one critical different differentiating except raining ground yeah uh however true modulars have a lot more potential functionality and Mo and and uh capability of fitting multiple needs being size in different modes different extensions Etc so so the ones that the vendors might sell you as a modular versus a portable or temporary is just because they put a design element in their PC drawings their DSA preapproved drawings that would allow a permanent foundation right when you look at those compared to all the others you can't tell difference for the most part
010they're wood frame stick frame structures uh single door on one side very simple very basic um so so you do want to to kind of know and recognize that subtle difference they'll sell you anything trust me these are gen 7 modular true modular those are uh five classrooms that were installed plus a restroom building uh at the tumble weed School the average cost per classroom was $570,000 um so that's times five then 570 Time 5 yes okay yeah that was total cost yeah uh all the soft cost overhead design Etc so the uh what's the square footage on that price per square foot on the classroom I'd have to I'd have to scale that out but they're substantial classrooms what size classrooms there that estimate there are they're effectively similar size to the Temporaries you
011have with two modular sections tied to main 20 by 40 600 foot 570,000 600 squ foot stick bu one then I'll do remember that's all site work that's everything right that's the grading and everything everything Foundation everything and those are actuals in that case and the actuals do vary I'm not going to sit here and say I can tell you exactly what number it's going to be U the ones on the bottom are actually more expensive but they are larger and there was much more site work so you see these gen 7 modular science labs um and the inside picture is of that science lab so there are two large science labs there side by side uh and per lab those were 1 Point 1 milon 440,000 uh per lab okay so slightly more it
012doesn't look like slightly but it is substantially more on the numbers but it does include as the top one did as well site work question 570,000 that that is just for the mod Exel that includes um the building but it doesn't include the infrastructure piece everything is included so that's permitting DSA arit all soft cost inspections so report geology so turn [Music] key that's a all soft cost it wasn't turn key for me because I had to hire all the but it's turn us turn that's all that's everything and that's per per classroom so I tried to break it down per classroom I know you're looking at a minimal no we only needed two classrooms does that price change because it's a smaller footprint there's economy and numers would you need a bathroom or the
013bathroom not really you adding a bathroom would probably we would have to add a septic here's the risk be a lot cheaper and we'll jump to that doing it I got a little sticker shock over th000 to be DSA we just got sticker shock no avoiding DSA right and and then predicting the access needs the requirements they usually Target 30% of the gross Capital cost and what you're doing but if they see and and deem it necessary to extend access routing from their current proof plan set Beyond you it's it's a that's your your risk factor in regards to managing cost DSA if you can avoid it and I'm I'm not going to put down DSA um but but they do look seriously at some rote elements access is being one um and uh you
014know that that's your big risk I don't know what building you were planning on moving or what where this was considered as located as being located uh the analysis should first look at it to try and uh ensure we don't put those those potential cost factors in front of the DS say where they're going to say you got to do this m so you kind of plan ahead when you normally do that so talk about path of travel path of travel and uh and and they'll look at you know drinking fountains restroom distance from classroom restroom distance they'll require Ada upgrades in your you know in your school no matter what no matter where they'll find something so let's jump to the next example uh I'm not a big fan of portable or temporary from
015my experience and my experience goes back a long ways [Music] here this example we actually landed for 335 portable classrooms and eight uh spring structures after the earthquake we did that in seven weeks um which was crazy well the spring structures are nice but there the last couple years not long now he mentioned we were not under DSA CSU has an exemption for DSA except access ada8 now that Cas um uh so yeah but that was indeed a temporary need those were all temporary needs and they were uh removed as quickly as I could get them removed quite frankly once we refurbished and or rebuilt the campus we would demo those things out as quick as passing uh so they do definitely serve a purpose especially if it's a temporary use I did want to
016emphasize that with this slide this uh these are uh future learning environments and these portable interior retrofits uh we've done many many schools in Palmdale and other locations uh to upgrade those Portables and and we have fixed them where they are DSA exempt Scopes much like the next example we'll get which was the metal L Comm SP but the advantage is primarily for the pedagogical program and the the learning opportunities so improved Acoustics Lighting daylighting in many cases we put the daylighting does yes sir so that cost that's all cough please [Music] connection but we can look at it here how's that no worries there's another one there say show say brush Hall and it's just an example of how modular can be configured in virtually anyway that was 26 modular section back in 1987
017and and uh that's an actual current picture that you see there um and uh three floors it was two floors of modular in permanent foundation which had a full basement level um for for storage 12 classrooms full Department office restrooms on both Flo and an elevator and stairwells so just an example of how modulars can be uh configured in just about any for any need so let's move on now to metal Lu and this was uh a pretty effective $200,000 interior and minimal exterior upgrade uh for that spot and was DSA exi so there are ways of of doing certain improvements and still fitting within the exemption allowable exemptions for DSA um you really want to know your the nuanced interpretation of those exemptions um one thing I will share with you directly we kind
018of got lucky on this job had it been a DSA process what we did find is that the West half of that portable and this may be modular it may be portable I don't know you see it's at grade level and uh I did not go down and check if it's had a permanent foundation or if it was still just excavated compact did and and a stick frame Foundation I don't know you know no I had never been down underneath it's a stick frame foundation with t111 sighting yeah so it's it's in all other equivalencies it's a portable it's sitting on a permanent foundation I believe it does have Jacks for the subflow I don't think it's sitting directly a soft sub not saying directly it is it has to be yeah because there's framing
019under there but I suspected that because we found the West half had had sunk and it actually had sunk greater than a 2% fall from the center of the classroom it was slightly greater than 2% which is not legal right for cross slope we were able to float it there's still some slope there we floated the floor we got it above less than the 2% cross slope and it avoided all of the other major costs and issues had you if it were a DSA DSA would have said lift the whole thing redo the entire footing Foundation I mean you would have been stuck what we did is we took reasonable approach we floated it to the extent we could we still didn't get it absolutely flat you can if you go over there you take
020a little marble you can actually see that that one half say it's a little slight slow but it is now Ada legal and accessible and that was an important issue I did want to share with this group so now we look at pros and cons and I'll run through these very quickly and then I will share uh what I thought your main uh goals and and uh priorities would be so modular cons uh is considered permanent portable considered temporary uh industry life 50y year for modular construction affordable 20-year industry life permanent foundations versus framed temp Foundation that's a primary difference quite frankly uh most modular have far better fire resistant construction uh uh most modular have improved access Eris and I do want to call to your attention and you've seen them most of your
021Temporaries SL Portables slash whatever they are single door erress um and that's a for me that's a fairly important consideration especially with the uh the fire resistant type they are legal I just want to note they are legal so steel frame structures typically for modular and then wood frame for Temporaries modular can be customized far more far substantially uh even on a single unit portable is one size spits all capital cost it's about double what you would see for for temporary size portable for modular for portable I'm sorry U and availability is reasonable I will say but the temporary portable they're off the shift the the delays are permitting right uh so let's jump to the last page so I did kind of recap what I thought you might be considering and one uh is
022the relocation of an existing portable classroom from from one school to another pros and cons or secondary considerations now it is the minimal cost and that is a absolute minimal cost that's not improving the Interiors that's not with any unforeseen conditions we we lift that thing and we find find dry rot in the in the full flooring frame mean elsewhere you know you it's you going to pay for it um so higher potential for un unforeseen repair costs to existing structure higher risk of DSA delays and unforeseen cost impacts they too are going to look at that reload let's say it's an older reload and there was a dsaa number uh uh problem and it never got filed they're going to have you get rid of that they're going to say get rid of that
023one put a put a new one in that has proper DSA in them and it's happened already fact we're just removing two over at bille just surprise surprise didn't get closed out properly years ago about a a numbers yeah and that's cl2 issu new yeah so there's a lot of risk with doing that loss of programable and you lose programmable space at the Old School site Tom why are we not looking at stick build uh I kind of understood that it was modular or uh or portable $1,000 a square foot to put a modular in is Extreme but you know where a lot of that cost go and I know guys your your perspective uh is with commercial buildings and you're right you're absolutely right even residential commercial residential yes that that you you you
024are now you cannot avoid with a new facility the DSA requirements 30% increase for DSA oh yeah it's still well that's their adders but now you talk about all you know you you have to make sure all your your te's are crossed your eyes are dotted right so it's a lot of other soft cost third party designer your your architect your construction manager whoever your I cost because you have to have that um so it it does add up pretty quickly and again stick frame you're probably not going to be as you think it's as cost effective as even the modular approach yeah yeah I'm I've done it I've done it all I'm open to anything I think with $300 a square foot would be extreme with architecturals and everything it's oh those first modular
025by the way they had they also have restrooms inside of those each restroom even though they required a restroom trailer just it's it's crazy so let let's just quickly go through these uh final ones uh the other option is lead the existing portable in place purchase install a new portable classroom so again that minimal cost is projected at $300,000 uh you don't lose programmable space at the other at the other school likely the fastest delivery method if time schedule is urgent and then the last option I listed here is leave the portable in place purchase stall new modular classroom uh again the cost almost doubles for the modular no loss of program in Space the old school and the big consideration is permanent versus temporary classroom space fromr and for me that's an impact on
026life cycle and safety you're saying minimal cost so that's a budget budget number that could shoot up it it could there's there's site conditions we may not know there's again it's still DSA but um in in the case of the modular with the foundations and usually those are set on the rat slab M right so it's a little more overx um if you get uh un unusual soil conditions I wouldn't expect it out here I know I live up on the hill here and I'm sitting on a rock um you're going to have more rivered type of condition down I wouldn't be too concerned about it yeah so questions answers Ernesto you ready for answers I think we asked most the questions in the proc yeah I have no further questions um yeah it's a
027good uh a little sticker shock to be honest I you know I don't want to undersell it can you get it I I I just couldn't I mean you could say minimal cost is 500,000 then come in at 570 years 600 so I don't want to there's no reason to take on this project to build one classroom right and we don't we can't afford to build 10 five so um it's on on starter at that price yeah so we got to find a different way to do it now at least that's my opinion would agree Bud one chat I'm sorry there was one chat we had several weeks maybe months ago about looking at the existing space to see if there was programmable space that could be converted to a classroom and then reassigning some
028of the non academic space into portable or something you remember that you had mentioned it wasn't at that site though that s completely no that one no not at metal AR that one was completely yeah so we would have to look at I mean we that's where we have to go took a look if we were going to move portable from here and move it over there and see if the condition and esate to see what if it's even movable to over there obviously putting it back in getting a a truck to move the Portables and then putting it back together obviously architectural um drawing send it to DSA and ir's got to come out here to inspect making sure everything gets put together make sure the agbs are work working Etc um so you're
029looking at $24 per modular for portable or that's minimum that's just pain thing we would we would bid options right right so you're you're saying you don't know there could be an a number that's dequal disqualifies that but you would find that out before you even try to move the thing right you yeah I mean I wouldn't move until you don't want to do it no because I don't want to do it but I'm just saying it needs to be saying if cuz the if there was a problem with the a number right and DSA because you got to ask but these modular you're talking about aren't being used they're just they've been sitting for years unused so it's not like and where they originally placed as classrooms yes okay yeah they haven't been for
030probably over 20 years they weren't prior to 81 were they constructed they're from the80s I'm pretty sure they're from the 81 was the they were already I was here in 1992 and they were there already so they're from the 80s yeah do sound like a good option they're all bungals yeah 81 so we'd probably probably be safe to do testing so if you had any regulatory regulated materials you test pain but like you said it's probably not that's probably not the option get something the outside we already pay the outside um there is other inspections we have to do well there's a third option and um and Dr St had really good idea and we're going to go through this this PowerPoint here and um see what the committee wants to decide what to do
031if that is a feasible solution and more economical practical solution right so um and then looking at the cost overall for all this um I don't know if I'm making enough cop [Music] we need more copies um one more you know I I can or you me out so the last time we spoke um Mr mcon and Mr ma give us directives of telling us which ones are needs and which ones are wants so we sorted out and we went by by by year year one year two year three year four and then also based on what the what are the most important so based on the information that we got from the committee and from Mr meon Mr ma we know that we need to expand metal art that's that's very important so again
032guesstimate of um $550,000 to move two modulars two portables from here to right to the school to metal AR then you also look at Landscaping um painting the the portable the existing Portables right that's the first year if we were to move the modulars portable excuse me it's going to cause about 680,000 plus including Landscaping 680,000 those are needs Year too obviously we have to look at the roof Replacements because that is very important because there are leak issues right now and rain is coming in raining seasons is here upon us and uh it's just to do the maintain the wear and tear of our facilities basically and that your te is going to cost $445,000 and then year three um based on our discussions um asphalt replacement at metal art as well as high
033desert concrete um resal the classroom flooring and [Music] um new roofs of the Portables at um High Desert again $250,000 um in year four um these are um wands is not important I mean it's important but it's not detrimental to the district um playground structure shade structure I I understand that there's really no shade structure at best best High School since Inception um students are trying to find shades during the winter during the summertime just to stay cool so that's that's a little something that we would like to address um and then classroom Furnitures again the we're looking at $623,000 just an estimate but let's go to the next next slide here if does anyone anyone has any questions so far uh we can we'll finish this and we'll go back okay yeah we can
034change things around again and um so um I mean the focus out of this presentation here is just to figure out the have to do stuff correct like this stuff that has to happen correct so that we don't impact our ability to educate our kids so we're going to extract from those the things we have to do yes correct um so um so yes we'll we'll go back you know after we go through this PowerPoint slides so we have um three kindergarten classrooms at metal Arc right and um an idea is to transition those three classrooms move the three kindergarten classrooms to here instead of spending the money instead of relocating instead of purchasing new modulars as an example and I think Dr s a really good idea was move three sections that will free
035up three classrooms at metal Arc the TK is already here right no the TK is here that's correct metal yes I just did that just for our enrollment purposes right so if we move it here that will free up three classrooms over there that would gives us the flexibility of growing at at at a metal AR as an example and obviously classrooms yeah yeah that they'll free up and then in the future if if we continue to grow then we obviously we have to add new mod time correct do we have to at that point then put that kitchen back in order and get all that stuff and what would be the cost to be able to use this facility for that the the kitchen here yeah you know correct what we're going to do
036is that they're going to do scratch cooking or prepackage Goods at at um High Desert and move meal they do that now yeah they'll be doing the same thing they're doing right now cook it somewhere else and then just bring it here and they'll we have the class ready yeah we have classrooms we just have to clean them up and basically beautify just beautify the classrooms but we have the classrooms I just have to get them all all sufficient all the rest are completely done already uh no um well just a couple toilets I have to bring him down to make him a little bit smaller but right now why you cross the V do you have that number uh not at this moment I would have to put something together yeah what's your best
037what's your best guess 50 two probably around there about yeah because we haven't done anything to those refurbished beting restroom that we have right now making them changing the toilets from standard size to little mini toilets but but if we bring in if we if if we have our own staff to do that that would lower the cost down oh yeah no we can definitely yeah yeah so I love that idea no we do we do a lot of inhouse uh we only bring out outside contractors and it's something out of our work scope for those classrooms are already DSA certified or they have to be recertified or what's no we those are already the one the bungalows in the back they're DSA certified already okay we did some uh repairs on the ramps they
038requested okay and they signed off on those okay but that's just the pathway right we had to change the pathway for ada8 yeah so and and again these are our existing enrollment right now at High Desert metal AR we have 353 students at metal Arch and high desert 311 FC 398 so we're at 1,60 students approximately throughout the entire District so the pros and cons of um relocating or portable obviously um the pr is a it's a one-time cost and give metal art to additional classrooms um the cons is that it's going to cost at least $550,000 if not probably more and obviously have that doesn't include um Furnitures no if we can get three classrooms out of out of maybe we spend 250 at best we get three classrooms out of this place we
039Kinder over I don't see any the only we have to do is beautify them and get the furniture for them that's it so if we relocate the kindergarten students the next page then again we'll free up three classrooms and what we can do I know that there's no shade structures out here we can use elop funds and general funds to split the cost to put shade structure we have the solar panels the solar panel there but if the kids are playing in the plate in the in the um he want over the uh area where the playground is right yeah and it'll be idea we can put shade structure underneath above the um playground structure as well that's correct thank you so back to rough gases total project price that add the three classrooms here
040including the shade structure everything you need to do well I know that the shade structure will probably cost about 10 $20,000 D like not to exceed a 500 to do the whole thing that should be plenty for yeah what's your uh your your your codes your your I know you have to go through DSA on certain things but what's it's LA County right are you under Palmdale City at all County sou County I I just mentioned that Palmdale adopted a 20 lb snow load requirement BSA mandates the regional they they will support whatever the local Regulatory Agencies effect we have our own acting Community standards here that kind of govern most of our building codes here yeah we we got impacted big time with that and while you can there's only one shade structure we
041found that actually had we're only California LA county and then acting Community standards so if it's not in California's codebook or it's not in La County's codebook it doesn't apply to us other than what's in the acting Community standards guide which wouldn't affect the school yeah um yeah so just for exiting this meeting here [Music] um obviously looking at the year one stuff we can get rid of the portable modu stuff MH look does that mean that and obviously we have the paining of the buildings stuff is that what it's included here the 130 that was just a rough estimate to paint the bungal over at metal Arc yeah it has to happen those are going to so because they're in really bad condition right now I agree I think this one has to yeah
042yeah um year two items needs need to be Year One um I would definitely throw the uh building one and building two from High Desert the roofs because those are really we've been patching them up if they're weaking they need to be yeah we just right now we just do whatever we can inh housee but it's time for them it's the original roof from 1992 because if you don't then you're going to get dry and it's going to be a lot let's move those two items to Year One for the two building one building two roof um these are my opinions we'll need to all discuss this at some point but here's what I suggest we do uh year three anything in year three that needs to get done in year one or year two
043or is this all stuff you're comfortable waiting two years three years to do um I would definitely jump the Bungalows the the roofs from the Bungalows to year number two that need to be year one yeah I mean number one um those those roofs are leaking too or no basically we've been patching them up all the anything that's a roof issues should be done should be done that's year one year four let's right there um this is all the want for the classroom furniture for metal AR is that for what what grade level for metal Arc it would be if we're going to move uh kindergarten be one two just three grades saying is this classroom furniture for kindergarten or is it because if it is then that's going to be part of this other
044project basically the the kindergarten Furniture would be moved over here okay and then we would have to purchase new furniture for older students for metal Arch can we prioritize this list here one two three and four what's what's number one what's number two what's number three what's number four mhm for the this WS list for the number four okay Ian what's yeah basically the uh the classroom furniture for metal AR does need to be if we're going to move the students needs to be number one that's going to happen this put High Desert classing Furniture is number two that would do number two been like forever the shade structure number three and playground or playground four the shade structure issue that doesn't come into any compliance issues because ocean now is requiring shade stru for
045everything now so that's going to be a general thing that's going to come into place so we might want to look at that yeah temperatures and there's a lot of different as the the last time we had a a shade structure was here was probably nine years ago eight when we built the high school we wouldn't be subject to new codes but it we wouldn't be but there could be something that comes up that says I'll look into it so if was to formalize what I believe we're making as a recommendation um we'll take our not seed budget which should be more than adequate of 500k for the relocation of the uh kindergarten over to metalark from metal to here from metalark to here um Landscaping of the portal buildings is a year one project
046plus looking the roofs out of the year three as well as the high desert stuff here so that puts us roughly at a million in expenditures for year one to be able to accomplish all those things and we can pick the year two year three s um I want to ask committee here and this is a tough question is um where's it going to come from where exactly where where's it going to come from that's your um how much of that would have we did that the things that we're talking about there how much would have to come from the general fund how much could come from grant money that we available Grant um unrestricted how much restricted funds can you use for that the only thing I can use if we were to move
047the kindergarten classroom here then I could split the cost for a shade structure underneath the above the playground if um that's because after school Services I I cannot use elop funds for the other school sites because there's no after school services so everything else what you're so basically it's all pretty much general fund so un but you're saying you had 500 so year one you have 600 ,000 is that what you have you've already got that you can allocate that money no so that's just how much so this is just how much it is it's not yeah you add all this up we're looking at no I understand that I'm looking at year one yeah because so I mean um I just I I just can't see how we can use general fund to do
048we can do I can um I don't think we're going to try to leave this meeting with um a recommendation for the board meeting this week it doesn't seem possible to me based on what we just looked at but I think what we just discussed you guys need to take it away for four weeks and figure out what to do with it and we meet again in December hopefully in prep in preparation for the December board meeting but I think what we can take away from this meeting is that if we can all be in agreement is to move the three sections of kindergarten yeah I would say though as priority standpoint we have to address these roots before we go spending money on another project like that so as much as I think that's
049a high priority item um we'll have greater impact to our ability educate if we don't address the the roofing issues that we have that's going on right now so I would um but what we just discussed though if we could recast this with that light and then let's package up the Year One two year three recommendations M like that um try to spend some time be great if we could spend some time potentially trying to come up with an actual construction price instead of kind of a swag number we just talked about but trying to come up with some real numbers that we we really think that we could do what we can well okay look I'm not saying have to go get bids and everything for this site yeah for this site and if
050you're going to use guys how many man hours you think it's going to take and how much I only have three guys right so I don't think it's going be feasible to do with that no that's that's a bigger project than what we expect yeah even if they work Saturdays and Sundays they still need a day off no no I'll look into it I I could get definitely get proposals it doesn't cost a lot I mean it's free I get estimates put together for painting and beautifying the classrooms um what's our threshold putting out RFP for this um the 100,000 if it's again ratified limit is going up to 70k very soon I want to hear C oh I'm sorry oh no no go ahead go ahead um what I'm saying is that anything um
051under 60,000 65 or 70,000 I know the threshold has changed um then you not to go for former bidding you can just go get three codes from three three different vendor but if it's over 60,000 65,000 your 70,000 then it's informal bidding then you can get three quotes from your list of subcontractors list your current list of contractors anything over $200,000 or a little bit over $200,000 it's going to require form of bidding so you got to post it on a trade Journal um go out for competitive bidding and do a job walk and um do a design build right interesting we you package this up together potentially yeah if we put it on the package it is going to exceed that amount but if you have painters Furniture it'll definitely it's different it'll cut
052it back so we don't have to go into out beting you we can put it in a package if you want in a package fry Dr oh if you have a Cass PEB contract is well you don't have to see Mas multiprime is you break the scope up individual trades right takes a little more oversight and managing and coordinating uh but you can often keep the higher value bids below the ratified limit and it just FAS that's what say I'm actually a fan of letting people compete the business you know what price we can get we could put something together for those three classrooms to see how much it would be including furniture and everything that's what you want to see I mean look I I I don't know what the cuz that way that'll
053be an actual number versus what we're putting together here it'd be nice if we um would we do we have a consultant that we use for scope scope writing and RFP writing um we would have to work with what he did maker space and he also did the field over at High Desert okay yeah so he he does that okay he could put everything together and let us know he this is how much it would cost to do the three classrooms and upgrade those restrooms that you have but yeah that might be something that well let's um take the next four weeks to kind of formalize what we just talked about okay and try to get that into a we'll look at it again and then um maybe we could see uh I think um
054if we were to entertain a price it would really just be for the uh scope writing and the RFP process would be where we would probably be curious and seeing a okay I'm fine I I help my friend here put something appreciate you yeah thank you my community thank you nice to meet you guys are you done with me yes thank you thank you thank you Mr Brown okay so so the next step is that um if I get clarification here then so that way we can let the community know that our parents know that we want to transition the kindergarten well I think we're not there yet right so we're not there at all so this has to go before the board board has to approve such a change along with the cost estings
055as well for us to move to the next step okay um I think if we're um we're not even ready to make a recommendation to the board yet so okay I think we'll take the next four weeks to formalize that recommendation we'll meet again they're going to ask with numbers yeah exactly it's better to get actual numbers um and I'd like to to see the whole thing see the thing as a whole I don't think you're doing a roof project right now anyway you're G have to wait till raining season we could always uh we could do with the same thing we're doing right now I you wouldn't start it right now yeah can't start cuz you're tearing Lo and that's not going that's a when kids AR that's a summer project when everybody's out
056of school you potential for MH flying pain yep oh yeah they'll hear too noisy people walking up of there hammering and yeah would be good but great work gentlemen I feel like it's progress at least towards coming up with a good solid plan to move forward brilliant idea to look at moving uh kindergarten over TK is already here you know TK kindergarten Here I think it's a brilliant idea let's try of put some some meat on the bones of that idea and try to see if we can come up with a good also estim what my plan is the uh old office that we had down below next to Transportation y I want to get those offices up and running so we could utilize our classrooms for right students versus staff that could fit one
057two three four five like six staff members inside that building okay so I'm going to work on that as well I just want to let you guys know that's a great that's fantastic yeah cuz I just got the approval to repair the roof and then the next thing is going to be beautifying the inside of the offices yeah you're pretty close yeah yeah it's uh it's amazing you got one minute to your hard stop I know well I don't have a hard stop but we have it's yeah we've said the meeting would GOI we can run over if we need to but good so future agenda item will look like um just coming up with that that plan for that so are you talking about or at least coming up with that is a rough
058estimate a solid estimate for here if we were to move the three classroom here move the three classrooms and that I think we just want to formalize what we just discussed though like as well okay so the roofing stuff is year one um let's get those items formalized so I'd like to the goal would be to leave the next meeting with that recommendation so we can say hey here's what you know here's what we're recommending here's where the money can come from um if it has to come from general fund then then it's so be it that's where it has to come from to be able to accomplish it um we to figure out if we're making the recommendation to spend that money or not Board gets to say no I don't like it but
059obviously we're in a bit of a crunch so so those Roofing items we just can't delay them any longer like those are absolutely must we got I do have bids from them um they need to be revised though they're probably couple years old now 100% so for the roofing stuff like let's put it all together as one bid and let's let let's let contractors compete on that business okay those roofs they're asphalt or TPO they're you got gravel so those are even worse because the more they step on them they do puncture the actual you got scrape all that out you got to scrape everything off and hot hot pop up yep so the T even even if you informally bit it like really make it a competitive process okay just to ensure that we're
060getting the best price that's possible for us yeah we do I think that would be the preferred way to try to approach that but for next meeting formalize the we can formalize the the items that we discussed as kind of like that we have to do um obviously we're bursting over at metalarc so U does create some priority there if you can try to shave some cost off of that move that would be better yeah look into it and see what the best uh once we get the actual estimate from Tom Brown see what we got to do to cut it down okay yeah then uh Kai's going to find us some free money done and um I think I we can look at using developer fees the point um to to pay for some
061of these projects but it's not going to be all of it not even come close I think I think I mentioned to you or developer fees we have about think about if if you give me a minute I can just go and and and find out for you how much we have in different we have a rough number I think it's like 10 and something thousand so so that that that'll be enough to you're doing great you just found like 18% of the cost right yeah I mean we can look at ways to generate revenues but again um I can illustrate the options we we can look at um there may be options that um the board the committee may not like but it's I'll leave it out I'll bring it out and well let's
062discuss those all options in our next meeting okay and then we can hopefully leave this group with recommendation or a few different options for the board to consider here's option one two and three how we address this um I think it's worth showing the cost of what three new Portables would cost at like 1.8 million like that's that's worth seeing that um versus the cost of moving three Portables just I think you I think you know listening to what he had to say we should really take into account the fact that it's probably going to be about 20% more that just for rehabilitation of those buildings and then there 40y old buildings that we're moving right so if that's option one is is the cheapest which option one the cheapest option really is moving kindergarten
063over here by a lot because 34es moved we're talking 800 to 900,000 building three buildings you're talking about 1.8 million versus relocating kindergarten Here which would be not to exceed 500,000 and that's a high estimate hopefully nesto comes back and says he can do it for three with the shade structure and then then we can and I think that really puts it into perspective of what we're actually considering as an option yeah we can do that right I mean and then obviously the things that the have to do maintenance items are there and honestly that doesn't really leave us a lot of room to consider the wants but I think there's some I think if we could try fit one of these in um we could try to fit one of the wants in and
064we obviously prioritized classroom Furniture over at metal one of them yeah classroom furniture at metal AR desert are probably um the wants that we can try to fit into that as well the total project price and recommendations for for all that I think that um looks like a good plan to work on okay yeah let us work on this and um we'll come up with some ideas in terms of generating revenues and um also how we generate revenues in order to pay for all these yeah I mean look obviously um we have potential we're drawing so that's a positive thing for us um options you don't have to solve it right now right I know your Brand's spinning on how but don't try to solve it right now it's not uh it won't be productive
065I don't think like go away and sit with it yeah and put some thought to it discuss it and try to figure out um how we get it done for free right right okay um again future agenda items so that's really going to be our priority at the next meeting correct um once we have that we're past that uh uh I think we honestly I think we're getting to a point where we'd like to discuss um what the community actually wants to see as improvements to the schools very good point um I these are things we have to do yeah but we should probably try to put uh maybe we can do some surveys and try to figure out what the community wants maybe um maybe we can come up with a top 10 list
066of our own for things that we know that are sitting out there and then we could try to get some surveys out of the community to go hey this is what we want this is what we need yeah I like that and then we all give us some direction there as well yeah good point so we can accomplish those two things at the next meeting I think will be in good shape um we real quick you have any comments or anything no comments no good thank you yes I'm good all right well with that um we talked about a lot of stuff does anybody have any comments from the public that's sitting on Zoom I no questions yeah that were sent one person there's a question there was maybe you guys can answer it so
067um she was asking about the map that you guys were discussing for placement of classrooms um for here but I think that was discussed at for metal art when um Mr Brown was speaking like where those costumes would be placed there and then there was another one was um in regards to moving uh kindergarten Here her question was the ground Valley site question the her question is when they say moving kindergarten Here is here the ground Valley site yes it is yeah okay so and again these are discussions we're having to try to form a recommendation for the board there's a lot of processes that would need to happen before um before it got to a formal uh question or decision and as far as map of where the facilities would go for the buildings
068I think um I don't think we had a solid plan of where exactly at but that was still to be discussed so yeah but it sounds like we' shelled that idea so we're focusing on flushing out the idea of relocating kindergarten to the or to the to the school office cool anything else anybody had questions on no all right um anything else from the group that's itk you with that we will adjourn at 5:09 p.m. all right thank you very much