001in Colombia, do it, do it, testing, testing, the board of directors is called to order, and not everyone is present except Vice President Tamayo. We are going to approve the agenda. There is a motion to approve the agenda. Mrs. Domínguez Cervantes requests it, and Mrs. Remírez Domínguez seconds it. Everyone in favor, say I. The motion passes. 41 absent. Oral communications for this session allow the public the opportunity to address the board of directors, and people who want to address may attend in person and give it to the secretary before the meeting begins. They are asked to speak for 3 minutes and to speak respectfully and professionally. The board of directors may limit the time for receiving public comments on each topic to 20 minutes with the consent of the board of directors. The president may
002increase or decrease the time allowed for the presentation, and no action can be taken. There is no person who wants to address the board and the agenda is section 354 9.1d 5495 7.6 government code collective bargaining employee negotiations agency to Adams Nilva organization of classified employees educators of Chula Vista and unrepresented employees the Chula Vista administrators association section 54957 B1 of the Government Code discipline dismissal release of public employee eh section 5495 6.9 of one of the Government Code conference with legal advisor of an existing litigation in the office of administrative hearings house number 0399 expulsion of student case 22501 education code section 48 916 4891 8 government code section 5495 6.8 conference with the real estate negotiator property location 845 Broadway Chula Vista 91911 apn 572 270 6200 760 235 7300 and the negotiating
003parties is the district of Chula Vista view and the San Diego County and NC metropolitan area advisory committee against poverty m aac section 5 4957 of the Government Code appointment title of public employee director one to the ... al ... The following votes were five yeses and no noes. Government section 549 56.1 D1 conference with legal advisor on existing litigation in the administrative hearings office, case number 0399. Ms. Tamayo requested it, and Ms. Ramirez Dominguez seconded it. The board approved the agreement. 4 yeses and no noes. Tamayo was absent. Thank you. The open session of the Chulavista District Board of Education is called to order. Welcome everyone. Ma'am, please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic which it represents,
004one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you very much. Now I will accept a motion to approve the agenda with flexibility. I request a motion. Mr. Tamayo requested it, and Ms. Dominguez Cervantes seconded it. Everyone in favor, say yes. The motion passes unanimously. Now we will move on to the articles of section 13, which are the public hearings before the consent agenda, followed by article 10, communication to the board. Chula Vista School Board, Classified Employees, Ms. Angela Reed, good evening, members of the Board. I am standing before you on behalf of our school secretaries, who serve as the backbone of each school. They are the first faces visitors see when they enter the office, the principal's right hand, and those who ensure that the school's daily operations run smoothly. Tonight,
005I want to address the significant challenges you face due to recent changes in the district's purchasing and supply ordering process. What was once a simple task has now become much more problematic and is impacting your ability to effectively support the main school office. A major issue is that the new process places much of the responsibility for purchasing and procurement on the shoulders of the secretaries. What was previously handled by the district office's purchasing department— requisitioning and ordering supplies for the warehouse—has now been shifted to them. While they have always been committed to supporting our schools and students, they are now being asked to assume the roles of buyers and budget managers. The intention behind these changes may have been efficiency, but what has resulted is a system Much more fragmented and error-prone, let me explain
006some of the difficulties secretaries now face. One of the Dean's secretaries is creating open purchase orders for multiple vendors, which ties up the school's budget. This adds another layer of complexity to their already full plates, and the process of ordering from multiple vendors instead of having a central warehouse system has led to higher costs for schools, as they now buy smaller quantities at higher prices. Secretaries are now expected to handle returns, track warranties, obtain quotes, and enter new budget codes—all while ensuring budgets are accurate. The new system has caused frequent problems with orders being canceled by the district without prior notice, forcing secretaries to re-enter the same orders repeatedly. Furthermore, they can't see the final amount of the order with taxes until after the order is processed, making it difficult to track how much money
007is left in the budget. This lack of transparency and the constant back and forth with canceled orders consumes valuable time. From placing orders and managing budgets, secretaries are now required to verify items as they arrive at the stores and email them to the District. Unfortunately, months later they are still receiving emails indicating that the delivery slips were not received and that the district is delaying invoice payments even though the invoices were submitted on time. Now they are doing what seems like a full-time job in purchasing, accounting, and inventory management—tasks that were previously handled by the district office. The burden of this additional work is taking away the time and energy they have to support the students and staff of our schools. CBCO sees the strain this is putting on school secretaries and we ask the
008board to return the primary contact for vendors to purchasing where it can be managed more effectively. School secretaries are already stretched thin with their primary duties, and adding the responsibility of buyers and accountants only takes them further away from supporting our schools in the way we need them to. Thank you, Chula Vista educators. Mrs. Rosy Martinez, good evening. I want to begin by acknowledging the teachers who were Chosen by the staff, I applaud those who took the opportunity to recognize the work they do every day for our students. I give thanks to all those who come and ensure stimulating and effective experiences every day. All students deserve for schools to be a safe place. That is why I demonstrate my commitment to them. By representing them, my commitment is to the staff, the students, and
009the community members to ensure they know they are safe. I will continue working to ensure that our District is a place where everyone is treated with respect, where we value equity for all, and that it doesn't matter the race, the entity, or the state of residence. I brought you here, and I invite you all to make the Chula Vista District a safe place for everyone. Because while we celebrate the district's achievements, we recognize that there is still much work to be done. Our students cannot progress if they are hungry. Months ago, I told you my concern that they were going to eliminate the second breakfast opportunity. They cannot be in the classroom hungry and expect to learn. We focus on consistency. We need to take awareness of the areas that Our students and staff need
010improvements. They ca n't wait any longer. On the agenda today, you're going to vote on staff reductions for next year. We think this is unnecessary stress for our members. The system used for this district's projections is ineffective. This causes a lot of anxiety for the staff. Please look at how other districts make their projections so we can approve these practices. CBR recognizes that the district has to make very tough budget decisions at a time when we have budget cuts. We need more input after the ELC survey to prioritize things. We want a more active role in these decisions. We prioritize ensuring students have adequate access. The number of students in the classroom has a big impact. We want our students to deserve to be in a space that gives them the best opportunity to learn
011and grow. This doesn't happen if we put students where there are n't enough desks, chairs, or materials. It doesn't happen when the teacher can't give students the individual attention they need. The district's position here is not just depressing. We really are. Please fix the problems. with us and let's do our best for our students' opportunities. I want to thank Sharon Cassy for finding solutions around this. We had our first meeting so we could also support students with IPIS. IP will be CBE collaborating with the district. Thank you, Chula Vista Administrators Association. Mrs. Teresa Corona, thank you. Good evening, President Ugarte, Superintendent Dr. Reyes, and members of the board. On behalf of the Chula Vista Administrators Association, I want to share good news that the consultation process with the district continued to move forward successfully this
012past month. We value having a voice at the table, being able to contribute the unique perspectives of principals to district plans, programs, and writings. Beyond consultations, AACB members serve on many subcommittees, ensuring their input is at every level of decision-making. That is greatly appreciated. We are excited to be consulting with Chula Vista educators as we work with the district to have input on the details and components of the Rigorous Learning for All plan. AACB wants to ensure that leaders are involved in these discussions because we know that clear and established policies are important. And these programs will strengthen our district. The ACB is part of the American Federation of School Administrators, and the mission of the AACB and APSA is to advocate for excellence and equity in our schools, our workplaces, and our communities. We
013want to take this opportunity to show that we believe in the power of public education. We are firmly against any effort to dismantle public education, whether it's by defunding or implementing policies that threaten the very foundation of education for all, regardless of immigration status or income. We are here to strengthen this commitment. We also recognize the real challenges that many of our families and students have faced, which create fear and uncertainty. As educators, we don't ask about the status of our children's documents; we ask how we can support them, how we can help them learn, and how we can ensure their safety. Every student in CBSD deserves to know that our schools are places of belonging, not places of fear. The AACB was pleased with the communication sent by the superintendent regarding the plans we
014have to help and support our families, and we want to work with the district so that every student in our district can benefit. Schools know they are valued and supported with communication, and we will ensure our school communities are places where they will be safe and learn. We will continue to support public schools, protecting our most vulnerable students, and ensuring their future, regardless of their background, so they can reach their full potential. Before we move to oral communications, Dr. Reyes, would you like to speak about...? I would like to welcome the Executive Directors, Ms. Lan Perez and Ms. Maria Montgomery. Welcome. Oral communications: Oral communications gives the public the opportunity to address the board on topics not on the agenda. Speakers are asked to limit their remarks to 3 minutes and are asked to submit
015a request to the recording secretary upon being heard. Speakers are asked to limit their remarks to 3 minutes. The board will limit the total speaking time to 20 minutes per topic. With the board's consent, the chair may increase or decrease the time allowed for public presentation depending on the topic and the number of people who wish to be heard. No action can be taken by the board. And we have three speakers. The first is... Noel Cravens: Hello, good evening. I just wanted to ask about the timeline for when the new members will have their official email addresses, and I also want to know if the emails that have been sent to the board have been forwarded to these new members. Thank you. K matas: Oh, you're here. Good evening. Uh, my name is Kem, and
016I'm a teacher at McMillan. We haven't had a principal since September. Supposedly, he was coming back in January, but we haven't heard from anyone. Emails have been sent since January, and no one has responded to the teachers. I believe that communication is the foundation of trust, but right now, this trust is broken. We're not here to know every detail or why the decisions were made, but the teachers, the parents, the students... It's not only frustrating, it's also disrespectful. We deserve to know what's happening, especially when it affects the children who are studying at McMillan. Trust isn't given; it's built. And that's what we teach our students every day. You haven't given us the courtesy of transparency, and that's not how trust works. If you want to repair the relationship with this board and the McMillan
017community... Communication needs to be a priority. But this is n't just what's happening; it's what's coming next. What is this district going to do to continue building that trust? Not just to keep us informed, but to be actively involved in our school. We want action, whether it's regular updates or something. Something has to change because right now the district's silence is creating uncertainty in McMillan, and frustration is leading to division. And now we need a leader. We have someone we want, but we also want communication. We want the opportunity for you to change this. Please let us know what we can do to help, or at least let us not be part of that decision. Please, how are you going to help us? Thank you. Corin is Sexon. She's from Arroyo. Good evening, Cabinet members,
018Dr. Reyes. My name is Corin Sexon, and I 'm a teacher at Arroyo Vista. I'm here tonight to speak on behalf of my staff to address the lack of communication on January 24, or as some know it, the Friday of the fires. Parents received several forms of communication: text, call, and email. My staff at Arroyo Vista didn't receive this. It wasn't until 7:30 in the morning that our The administrator told us we had to report to the office. To be clear, this wasn't my administrator's fault; this is a district issue because Arroyo Vista isn't part of the group of schools. We didn't receive the communication, and then Mr. Romero admitted that Arroyo Vista was the only school that wasn't included in the communication. The reason is that Arroyo Vista is autonomous, which isn't right. The
019staff at Arroyo Vista are members of the district and should have received all the communication. Then Mr. Romero again admitted that Arroyo Vista wasn't part of the communication chain. This was a failure that had direct consequences for my staff because my staff was informed so late. Many of us were looking for childcare because our school was closed. The priority was the safety of our community because we were directly impacted by the fires. Many didn't show up due to childcare conflicts or simply because when they checked their email, it was too late. The district took a day off from us. That's unacceptable. The lack of communication fell on us, and I sent many emails. That Friday, I spoke to Mr. Jason and Mr. Jorge Mora. Angela Rosendal And the only one who responded was Ms. Dominguez.
020In my email, I sent them photos of the belongings and also shared the message from the Sweetwater district that they would not be penalized for not going to work that day. Let me be very clear, I am absolutely grateful to those who negotiate for us, but I also want to fight for our working conditions and how these conditions affected my staff. This has not been the first nor the last time. So please reinstate the day off that my staff lost. Let's not repeat this mistake; let's do better. Thank you, Dr. Reyes. I believe this problem had already been resolved, Mr. Romero, Ms. Ugarte, Dr. Reyes. The district met with CBE, and one of the methods we used to support our staff was to rectify the situation for employees who live in the red or yellow
021zones. They were going to have their day off reinstated, and the notification was sent out today. We received some emails in response to how it was going to be done, and I believe we asked for 30 days to give this day off. Oh, Mr. Romero, this is just because Arroyo, or for all schools, Arroyo was also notified in this email. The email was sent to all district staff. Oral presentations, security update, Mr. Romero. Ay, President Ugarte, Board Members, Superintendent, and communities, it is my pleasure to report today on the update for February. One of the things we are looking at is ensuring and having our best practices. We now have heated cushions. These heated cushions are no longer updated. And these signs are now also in place. This is from bell to bell. And this
022is access to the building. When the first bell rings, to the last bell. And we also have some budgets in systems. So, on February 5th, there was a very strong odor in some schools in the west, and there were calls to our security and facilities team. And we worked with the principals to make sure they had the safest practices and protocols in place. And how to respond to this? One of the things we want to prioritize is that they used the EJEX. But they included that the odor was coming from the Tijuana River. So, policy 514, 5.13, the District's response to immigration. There was a meeting where they were informed about this policy. The response to the Border 2 fires... we learned a lot from this. This is a timeline of how things happened at
023one of our schools in Arroyo Vista. Yes, there was a lack of communication because our schools are zoned by area, and our charter schools were not part of this communication group. And it has been fixed, and it was something we learned from this incident. We still have many methods of communication: email, text, phone, but we want to ensure that our charter schools are part of this because charter schools have their own administrative body. We want them to be aligned with our district as well. But this is a continuation of the timeline it took for the Border 2 response to the Border 2 fires. We are working with some of our working groups to fix some of this language. We haven't finalized this, and we are continuing negotiations next week. Any questions or comments from the
024board regarding the smell they had? This could be a health hazard. We are not currently actively advocating for it. Any other comments to reiterate? Charter schools will be added to the safety announcements. Yes. Regarding the filters, it's like a lottery. My sister lives in that area. It's something we could consider for those areas. I don't know where we're going with that. I was there, you were checking the odors, the quality, the Sweetwater Reservoir. I want to ask Mr. President to address this concern and put it on the agenda as an urgent matter. I don't know what the protocol is, but please keep this in mind. I don't think we can wait another month to put it on the agenda. We are customers of the Sweetwater Authority. They discovered that their reservoir has toxic materials. One
025of the chemicals found in the Sweetwater Reservoir is dangerous and can cause liver damage, cancer, and pregnancy problems. I've raised this issue many times, and we've had conversations. I believe Dr. Reyes said he met with someone from Sweetwater, but I don't think they're taking it seriously. Our staff, our children, the fact that there are Chula Vista residents—we have a responsibility to our staff and students who are drinking that water—is a huge concern for me. It's been almost a year since I've spoken about this concern, and I don't know what else we can do, Mr. President. Ugarte, we're drinking carcinogens. It's a complicated problem because we're two different entities. I think we need to write a resolution. Is there any way to approach this? This is serious. This is the water we're drinking. The children fill
026their thermoses. Also, our [Music] staff... I don't know, I'm not the expert, but this is very serious. We can't keep drinking this water. I believe your information. I trust this information. I know that with the... air quality, Miguel, we're not experts in this area. We're the customers, right? I know the basis. So what's the solution? The solution is... how does the disorder feel about certain issues? You need to go and present it to one of your boards so they're informed, so you can tell me what the resolution will be and what we're going to base it on, or how we're going to edit it so it can be approved and sent out. Because how many schools don't have... well, all the schools... and I imagine the Sweet Water schools are also impacted by this. It's
027a conversation that isn't just with the Sweet Water Authority, it's with the city. What are they going to do to mitigate this? Yes, because they can... Trying to blend the water to lower the levels. But at the end of the day, there has to be a stronger filtration system, and I don't know if an infiltration system at the school would be cost- effective. In conversation with the Sweetwater School District, I don't know if filing a class-action lawsuit is appropriate. I agree with you because it's a health risk. I think we should have a conversation with the Sweetwater district and see what path we can take to mitigate the water's toxicity levels, keeping in mind that if there isn't a solution, there will be a class-action lawsuit. Thank you, Mr. Pong. We are doing some testing.
028Where are we? We have our environmental consultant, and we met with him last week. They are identifying on the map the areas where they are doing testing. I know that if you are only looking for lead, you have to talk to the analyst to find out what they are looking for and do some broader research. Thank you. And why do they have to be checking the air quality with respect to Tijuana's drainage? Ah, a lot depends on the other agencies. I can connect with the city and with Sweetwater this week in two. In a few weeks, we have another board meeting so I can give you updates on where we stand in this conversation. While we're being aware of this, I don't know, but we can't allow them to continue drinking that water. What can
029we do? Obviously, it has to be a message. We have to be careful with the community. We 're not the water authority. That's what I was asking about, and I agree that the message has to come from the Sweet [Music] Water Authority. I think it would be great to have the conversation. I do n't know if we give them water or additional filters when we receive the results of the environmental report that Mr. Pong is doing. It's from six to seven schools at the same time, approximately two weeks. And when you have the results, please put them in the Act. Asis in the update. More comments on Mr. Romero's safety report. Thank you, Mrs. Morales. I want to introduce Mrs. Estrada, our coordinator, and she's going to give us the California dashboard report. Good evening,
030Dr. Reyes. Tonight I'm presenting to you the California dashboard. The data you're going to see in this presentation is from the 2023-2024 school year. The California dashboard is the The California system, which is how our schools meet the needs of students, also helps identify strengths and areas for improvement and determines eligibility for support areas such as differentiated assistance. Also, in accordance with the law that every student must succeed, we have a new group of English language learners. It's important to understand how these groups are determined. There are two factors: status, which ranges from very low to very high, and the change from significantly toward low AB and upward. It's determined by the point where these two factors intersect. It's not just about color, because growth also matters. For example, a school with average performance is
031more promising than one that is high but significantly declining in its ratings. The first set of indicators is our state indicators, such as academic performance, English language proficiency, suspensions, and chronic absenteeism. The second set of indicators are Local indicators include basic conditions, implementation of state standards, family involvement, school climate, and access to a broad course of study. These focus on aspects that are important. Local indicators also serve to... Reporting and viewing these groups separately helps us identify achievement gaps. There are some indicators, and it's usually because the number of students is less than 30. It's important to see the differences between the ELPAC and CASP results and when compared to the California dashboard because it reports the number and the grade at each level, while the California dashboard is for all the results of all
032students. On the dashboard, the distance from the standard measures how far the student's performance is from meeting the standard, and this is like level three or the standard achieved. Here 's an example: fifth grade math, one out of 2528 is level 3, which is indicated by the green arrow on the screen. And here are these 28 when they are at 200-500; they are the ones who need to reach that level. But, for example, 25-28, sorry, 2568 are 40 points above level 3. So, you see how it's reported on the California dashboard: each of the indicator cards will report the average student's distance from the standard. Now that I've given you a little background In the "How the Dashboard Presents" section, I'm going to present the results for CBSD on the 2024 California dashboard. And these
033are from the 2024 school year. So this page gives us an overview for the district and the schools. Here you see CBSD local indicators, state indicators, and also demographic indicators. And the state indicators here are the English language learners. The English language learners had an 8.8 above standard, and math progress is indicated in yellow. English language learner progress is at 49, represented in orange. Science is not included, and chronic absenteeism has decreased by 7.2%. These results offer a lot of information for local indicators. The dashboard indicates that CBSD has met the standard in all areas, including basic standards implementation, family involvement, the local climate, and the survey. As I mentioned before, the 5x5 chart demonstrates school performance. This combines performance with changes over the years: blue, green, yellow, orange, and red. This 5x5 chart is
034showing English language and literature, and it shows that we have zero schools in red, and also none of our schools are in the very low status. We have 10 schools in orange, 19 in yellow, 17 in green, and six in blue. Overall, the Chula Vista Elementary School District is shown here, and here is the one for mathematics. The 5x5 chart reports that zero schools are in red, none in the very low status, 14 are in orange, 11 in yellow, 15 in green, and 12 in blue. Overall, as a district, CBSD maintained average status in mathematics with the yellow indicator. So this time, I want to compare between 2023 and 2024. The numbers you see are these squares; they represent the number of schools that fell within that area in 2023. CBSD had 26 schools for
035English Language Arts that were at high or very high levels, meaning they increased in English Language Arts. And in 2024, we had 32 schools that achieved high or very high levels and significantly increased in English Language Arts. As a district, English Language Arts was our focus, and this chart demonstrates the effort. And this is for mathematics: in 2023, CBSD had 27 schools that were at high or very high levels, meaning they increased or significantly increased. And in 2024, we had 24 schools that achieved either high or very high status and significantly improved. They worked strategically to meet these challenges, and there were leadership plans in each school. The focus on mathematics is within our ELC (Educational Leadership Council). And we are finishing it this week. Right now, I want to highlight two schools and give
036two examples of what is happening in our district. We are, for example, Harbor Side and Valy Vesta, which had significant growth. The first school I want to highlight is Harborside in 2023. Harborside School had seven indicators in red impacting five student groups in 2024. This decreased to only one student group, and the comparisons in the graph show a significant decrease in orange. The Harborside Tigers have increased by 7.4 points in math and 13 points in English language arts, and chronic absenteeism has also improved. Harborside is no longer identified as an ATS school. The next school I want to highlight is Valey Vesta Elementary. In 2023, it had five student group indicators in red, and in 2024, it has none. This shows a decrease in orange; now they have four in blue and three in green.
037The Valey Vesta Vikings have made great progress, increasing by 7.4 points in math and 28 in English language arts, also reducing their absences by 11.3. We are very proud of all their achievements, and I believe they also deserve applause. Now I want to compare with you a local comparison with the districts in our area. Of the seven CDSD districts, it is... The only district with a green indicator in language and literature, and the only district that is higher for language and literature. Our district had an increase of 4.3 points in language and literature. In mathematics, we remained with the yellow indicator, and the district closest to meeting the standard is 16 points away. When we look at science, CBSD is again the closest to meeting the standard. Six of the districts that had the least
038in language and literature, and CBSD has the highest percentage of students making progress. In conclusion, the data presented here gives us very valuable information and directly relates to our planning. But at this moment, thank you for your time. And I welcome any questions about the California dashboard. Could we have a copy of this PowerPoint? Yes, absolutely, it's in the Friday update. I just want to say congratulations, very good work, congratulations, and the congratulations go to the teachers and staff for supporting this. It's magnificent. For these schools that are having problems, we know they have that average because there are schools that are improving and there are schools that need more support. If you could share with us what we are doing to support those schools, such as... I mentioned all the data I presented here
039is strategically included in the ELC. And you're going to hear this information later tonight. Looking specifically at the data, perhaps you'll select this as your focus. They're working with their teachers in professional development and learning cycles. Is there a mechanism that some schools can contact you directly? We need to redone this. Please come; they can contact me whenever they want. I can speak for instructional services. We work very closely in our schools, and I know there's a lot going on. That's a great question. I also want to say that we have the principal of Valy Vesta here. But one of the things we 've worked very hard on is the structure for our leaders. What we do at the beginning of the year is we look at the data from all the schools and all
040the leaders, and then our principals, who are with me, develop intervention plans. These are data-based and involve actions to increase where increase is needed. And also, as a leadership team, we have levels of support that we give to our schools. We really want to highlight Harl Side School because we know this is indicative of when we can Sending our resources is made up of... And that's the point I'd like to make. How can we multiply them by one? Each school has a special dynamic, and that dynamic is... contributing not as much as the staff would like, but... the different dynamics that happen... that this action plan is more out there. Congratulations to the staff, the classified and certified staff, and the principals. Congratulations! It's truly magnificent to see this change in a school that needed
041it and needed additional resources. Congratulations to the staff and the principal as well. Maybe she wants to share... Yes, the translation... I do n't know the translation. But what time is it? Here it is. Let's see, you look it up. Absolutely, it's the team we have, the school team, with the collaboration of the leaders. We work closely with the resource teachers. We are a double- investment school. But it's all about working collaboratively. Oh, thank you very much for that hard work, and let them know that we see and value the work they are doing, and we hope that we can use what you used in our schools as well. Thank you very much. Yes, I saw it just now. At this moment, I can't tell you how happy I am because it's seeing the fruits
042of collaboration when we talk about schools. community and when we talk about the spirit of this and maintaining it, we are sustaining it without collaboration, and I know that our leaders have spoken about this, whether it's professional development or collaboration, and I know that every time I've been here, Ms. Martinez has spoken and worked to receive that leadership. And these are the results. I really am so nice to see this because it was during the pandemic when I arrived and things weren't good, and now we're not in the red and we're moving forward. I saw that some schools did very well in language and literature. We focused on those efforts, and I hear from the teachers and principals about the support the district is giving them with the visits from community educators, and having that
043support available has made a difference. Thank you all so much for your work; you made this very easy. Okay, let's move on to Article 13 a and b, and [Music] This is the first reading and possible second reading of the renewal petition for Arroyovista Charter School. Mr. Romero, it is our pleasure to present to the leadership of Charter Schools. We have agreements that in the past we have seen in a single day, but it is a It is a pleasure to present the administration. Good evening, Dr. Reyes, board members, and the district executive cabinet. I am honored to be the principal of Arroyo Vista Autonomous School. I am pleased to present the renovation plan for July 2025/June 2030. The school opened in 1999 as a district school from kindergarten through sixth grade and became an
044autonomous school in 2002 due to a high level of interest from the community and staff. In 2005, the dual-investment program for kindergarten and first grade was added, and it continued adding grades until reaching seventh grade in 2011. Seventh grade was opened, and our English-only Transition Kindergarten program was added in 2014 and to support our youngest kindergarten students. Currently, there are 9,914 students enrolled from kindergarten through eighth grade. 18% come from military families. We are proud of our students from military families and thank their parents for their service. Our target group is the following: 16% English language students 12% of our students have disabilities, 2% are homeless, and 28% are from socioeconomically disadvantaged backgrounds. They are supported by our wonderful staff: school counselor, psychologist, special education team, and teacher's aides who provide academic support. These are
045the points that stand out. We have a dual- investment program and a high school with our Teams program. All students participate in our VAPA program where they learn from specialists in the areas of music, theater, and visual arts. Throughout the year, there are student presentations. Our 9010 dual-investment program is a dual-investment model to develop literacy in English and Spanish. Our high school offers basic education that includes Spanish for all students based on their Spanish level. There are also clubs, elective classes, photography, and outdoor sports. The Teams program provides a vibrant community by bringing together students of different ages, cultivating meaningful relationships, and involving students in community programs. This process has been a two-year effort. Staff worked in small groups to provide feedback and suggestions to students. All this information was gathered by our staff. This
046will be highlighted with every item presented as the highest priority for our community. Based on the survey results, our academic support and our dual investment program and our high school program were key. Our mission as members is to cultivate a vibrant learning community. Collaboration, communication, and relationships are our daily focus. We are guided by our philosophy: as a team, together we all achieve more. As educators, we are allies with our families to ensure that their children reach their full potential as students and citizens. We recognize that all students come to us with experiences, knowledge, skills, and needs, and we actively work to ensure they receive all the resources, support, and opportunities they need to thrive. We aspire for students to be analytical thinkers who approach problems with flexibility and perseverance. By cultivating a flexible mind,
047they are prepared to navigate an ever- changing world. Our comprehensive program for TK Kindergarten cultivates the academic, social-emotional, and development of all students. A balanced approach prioritizes reading, writing, and problem-solving across all school subjects. We equip students with the skills they need to process and communicate their understanding. This approach prepares them to be independent lifelong learners and provides them with the skills they need in higher education. And in the world of work, we have several programs. We received a grant from the Department of Defense. Our studio, which opened this year, is an integrated space in our library. Students use the design process to empathize, define, ideate, prototype, and test to arrive at solutions. The staff receives professional training. The students are excited to arrive at solutions to a variety of problems. We started a music
048program with flutes, trumpets, trambo, and tuba last year. Last week, our dual-investment program expanded due to community interest. Kindergarten, first, second, and third grade. Arroyo measures the outcome for students with clearly defined goals and adheres to national and local standards. Our short-term objective and goals align with our ECA and guide our efforts so that all students achieve success with a focus on those students who are underperforming. Arroyo is committed to teamwork when making decisions. All certified members serve on one of our steering committees. Our committees include CIA, curriculum, instruction and assessment, and systems. Multi-level support means that classified staff have the opportunity to be involved in any of its committees. There is also parity between community members and staff to ensure that all decisions are made jointly. Our community members comply with legislative requirements [Music]
049and the school administration works in collaboration with the CBSD department regarding staff qualifications, benefits, and compensation, since all staff members are part of the Chol Vista school district. There are many new updates required by the State of California for the next school year. We will follow all requirements starting in July 2026. We will include a suicide prevention policy for our high school students. Before July 2026, there will be school sex education and prevention. It will be explicitly taught during physical education classes starting in the 2026-2027 school year. At the beginning of each school year, we will distribute a notice to families that will address the laws regarding firearms. Roll Vista Autonomous strives to have a To balance its student population, priority is given to students who live within the ABCS boundaries. Parents may request a
050transfer from kindergarten through sixth grade from other Chula Vista district schools to Arroyo Vista. Admission is based on a lottery with priority given to students who live within the ABCS boundaries. The Arroyo Vista administration works collaboratively with the district's finance, budget, and human resources departments and meets the corresponding deadlines. We appreciate the collaboration with Lisa Wallace; this collaboration helps the school administration meet funding guidelines and comply with state guidelines. Arroyo Vista meets the requirements for fiscal responsibility for our 5-year renewal. Our plan for 2025-2027 shows that we have the necessary funding for staffing while navigating changes in funding sources. Our team will ensure that programs continue based on feedback from staff and the school community. ABCS performed above standards, as you can see from the dashboard information. We are very proud. Of our academic achievement
051in the CASP exam results in 2024, 50.8% of our students met the standards in mathematics, and 51% met and exceeded the standards in language arts. Our school team is striving to improve math performance for all grade levels. We recognize the needs of our English language students to show progress in all subjects. We received a green rating in 2024, but only 50% of our English language students are showing progress. Arroyo Vista will continue to fund a teacher's aide for English language students. Our team knows that a combination of teacher support and dedicated support, further integrated with small group support, will help our students continue to show progress in English language acquisition. Chronic absenteeism continues to rise. We are working with families to ensure that they arrive at school on time every day for their success. We
052celebrate our strengths and are committed to improving our weaknesses. Before asking questions from the board, I would like to acknowledge the Arroyo Vista staff and the community members present here in support of this request. There are no speakers. Board comments Or questions. I have a comment. I want to congratulate you because I am a proud member of that community. You do an excellent job. Arroyo Vista and the rest of the schools are very grateful. Personally, we have received all the support and everything we have needed for my family and my children. Again, thank you and congratulations. I have a comment. Congratulations. 79.8 in language and literature and 50 points in mathematics are very good numbers. Whatever you are doing, we need to multiply it in the rest of our schools for our English students. What
053are some of the barriers you observe? You mentioned that you can develop. Yes, of course, thank you for the questions. One of the things we see with our English students is that the dual-investment program is exceptional, and we are seeing how the teaching of the English language is being taught in that context. It is the 9010 model, and we totally believe in that model for our students. But there are some things that we have to refine and examine to ensure that the students are learning the additional skills. When we look at the results in the upper grades, from third to sixth, it is a combination. We place ourselves in But we open the doors to other new students. So we have brought in additional support through teacher assistants to ensure that students continue to develop
054their English language skills. We have a full-time English language teaching assistant who will not only support the administration of the ELPAC test but also work with the students. So they work with students in the afternoons and focus on administering the ELPAC test in the mornings. I would like to hear more about the teacher assistants who support students as we see it in school. Autonomous School is very fortunate to have its own funding from Arroyo Vista. It funds four full-time teacher assistants to support students from kindergarten through sixth grade in the areas of language arts, literature, and mathematics. We have established very specific goals and want to use that funding to support these goals. These adult assistants are supervised by the classroom teacher and provide support within the classroom. The classroom teacher supervises the teacher assistants,
055but the teacher assistants in the classroom work in small groups with students. They provide support in language arts, literature, and mathematics. Thank you for sharing all the details of your program. We appreciate it. Any other questions or comments from board members? No, but I would like to say thank you. My son was part of Arroyo Vista during middle school, so he benefited from that program. So thank you all. He is very successful at Olympia High School. I think you have shown that you deserve this renewal. I just want to thank you for a very detailed presentation of the information. If anyone would like to do a vote to approve the renewal of Autonomous School, I would do it. Motion to approve with a comment: My grandson started in 1999 and he became a nuclear engineer.
056My other grandsons, the second one, his brother, got a full scholarship to the US, an academic scholarship. The other two went to university. One already finished and works for a law firm, and the other is... So I make the motion to approve the renewal. Seconded by Member 12. Say I. The motion passes unanimously. Congratulations. Item 13B: The first reading and possible approval of the directive policy, which is new. Professional development training. Mr. P. Thank you, President Ugarte. As you mentioned, this is a new policy proposed by the Board. The reading and possible approval shows the value that professional capacity brings to our administrative and management staff. Questions from the Board or comments on professional capacity for administrators and managers: I have a comment. It seems we were already doing it right; we are codifying it.
057Motion to approve it. Seconded by Vice President Tamayo. All in favor, say I. The motion passes unanimously. Item 10: To be... to be removed before giving consent the staff commented said that we are going to do 10n we should discuss it consent consensus we are on the schedule of let's go to matter 10 schedule of consent approval staff we are going to remove matters or items 10c 10 there is a section n 10c 10L 10n and 10 and all have been removed by the staff and any other member Dominguez anything that she would like to remove there is a member H wanted to remove 10e m and 10 as well and that would be all Oh excuse me that k and C something else d c is going to be removed but particularly job descriptions
058or work very well a motion to approve the consent schedule with having removing c l n and e motion by Tamayo and seconded by member Dominguez Cervantes all in favor I the motion passes unanimously before starting on 10c in the job description there is a correction there will not be additional funding that is incorrect there is a fiscal impact of 86000 annually 8600 annually what page is annually it is not on The description is very good. We have topic articles C and D. What are the articles we removed? What page is the description? Reyes, Mr. Romero, the main buyer. I think the job description is missing that information. The others include who they report to. My dear Mr. Reyes, Dr. Reyes, who is the main buyer? Who does the main buyer report to? Who is
059he/she reporting to, or under whom is he/she, or who is the supervisor, Mr. Romero? If we can update that information, and the social worker/counselor, the description itself starts on page 18-19. That's the description. I can't follow the next point. Can you help me understand? I don't understand what that point means. The second point. Or maybe I don't understand it. Maybe the Spanish is messing with my head. Page 18, basic responsibilities, second point. I don't understand what that means. Leading is going to be the person in charge of the school who attends the committees. Very good, the Spanglish... I can't connect because of my Spanglish. My second question: Is that a position on- site? I would like to see the counselors/squad at the school. Are they going to be... Those assigned on Monday will be at
060their school Tuesday and Wednesday at another school. What's the idea, Mr. Romero? Yes, they are placements in the schools. My main concern is not to take them away from the students. The next one is a specialist in the Special Education program. The job description is on pages 14 and 15. I just want to make sure this was clarified before voting. Mr./Ms. That is an administrator who will support the schools and the administrators. They are special education teachers. So they will be assigned to the District, to the School District office, but they will be going to schools. Their office is here in the district office, but they will be going to the schools to support the teachers. If we can, we can get more information on how all this works, if it's working, if it's not
061working. The intention is for them to support the schools. That's all. In 10c, the schools, the school secretaries will be in charge. From the sales department, then we need a lead seller, a lead buyer, Dr. Reyes. Mr. Romero, could you share with us at the table and clarify the job description for this new lead buyer position and how it compares to what a secretary would do? Yes, there are several levels for making purchases. Our lead buyer... and I appreciate the opportunity to clarify. We have purchases that happen at a higher level. One of our advantages is buying in bulk. Our secretaries will handle placing orders. For example, one of our biggest issues is our toilet paper supplies. All the schools that buy toilet paper cost more. It's like Costco. We are Costco for each school.
062We can buy in bulk, and the schools can then buy individually from us. So we meet those needs. We also have our warehouse at the district level where we buy wholesale. Our goal is to get the best value on products like computers and that kind of thing. We also oversee that those items are not only ordered but also transported to the schools. So there are many levels involved. This includes the need for a supplier, a buyer to oversee all of this. It's very important. Our schools will have that person go to the schools to train staff. If there's an issue with an order, then the main buyer will go to those schools to train the staff. I understand the main buyer's role. So, the secretaries, the way you described it, will still place orders, but
063they won't buy from us directly. In two ways: yes, one way is through us. We can secure bulk orders, like cleaning supplies, but sometimes purchases of $100. So, we're going to allow the schools to buy from Off-Dip on Amazon so they have those products at their schools. But we also need to train and monitor that there must be balances. And we want to be clear: our secretaries will be responsible; it's in their job description. The custodians are still responsible for unpacking and organizing those items, but there will be several people who will carry out those responsibilities. We want to prioritize. that expedites the arrival of the items to our schools and there are opportunities for other questions. Maybe not for this article, this matter, article 10c, member Ramirez Dominguez, for the consultants that Family is
064going to offer Education for community schools because only those schools, Dr. Reyes. Other schools can contact them, it's free. So I can see if other schools would like to participate. Thank you for clarifying, Jewish Family Center or Family Services, because here it says Center or centro, it's a rat. I have another question that I see at the bottom because we are promoting, uh, technical support, Dr. Reyes. No, we are not prohibiting it, it's the money that passes through us to them. There is a partial release that follows the students. Which students can? Is it something that the shelves can go to the school? I need this? Are these services, specific services for tuition? We are not talking about tuition, we are talking about services for students. Those who take care of those funds, we release
065them to pay. We are like the caretakers of those funds. Can you give me an example, sir? Put this contract, it is for professional development for teachers in the schools. So it is federal funding. With these funds we have to give, uh, services. Equitable. Because that private school is within our boundaries, and based on its enrollment, we have to share that funding, and they're using it for professional training. I have another question: Is that something ongoing? Is it every year that we renew the funds for these schools? And are there other private schools that can use these funds, Dr. Reyes? Yes, there's a certain amount of money, depending on the number of students they have, and they can use it throughout the year for different purposes until the fund runs out. So, Rosalin, different private
066schools. My question is, are there other private schools besides these schools that receive funds for professional training? I think [Music] Yes, almost all the boards of the Mio Cervantes Dominguez. A question regarding Esteon Enterprises Incorporated. I was curious what General Bond we're talking about, sir. That project comes from the measure. I think it was a rat of the others. It was a rat. I think they're all the... I have a motion to accept Article 10c. Motion to approve it. Seconded by Vice President May. All in favor, say I. The motion passes unanimously. Article 10 d member Dominguez Cervantes is recommending to strike out the word [Music] progressive. Because if it is history of the month of women's history, she is making a motion to approve with those amendments. Does anyone second the motion to approve
067the resolution with modifications made by Ms. Dominguez Cervantes, seconded by Ramirez Dominguez? Everyone in favor, say I. Any abstentions? I abstain. The emotion does not pass. Two to two, one abstention. I would like to propose an amendment to the resolution to recognize the change. What was the first? Remove " progressive" right here. Here is the motion to eliminate " progressive" where women of different backgrounds have political connotations. It is only a change. A motion to make that change. No one seconds the motion. Vice President Mayo, seconded by Domingos. Everyone in favor, say I. Discussion. We have already called for all those who oppose it. Any abstentions? I abstain. Two to two, one abstention. The emotion does not pass. To approve as written by The vote is all in favor of the motion as written. Say
068" I," "Everyone who opposes," " Everyone who abstains." I abstain. The motion does not pass. Next, Article 10e: Approve the resolution to recognize February as Black History Month. I wanted to address you because February is Black History Month. My son is of mixed race; he is Hispanic and African American. I feel it is very important to continue recognizing every month when we celebrate people of different ethnicities and the contributions they have made to the country and the world. With that, I would like to read the resolution. If you want to alternate, or if you want to call it National Black History Month, it should highlight the contributions Black workers have made to social and economic development, where students learn about the achievements of African Americans. It should also be a month where African Americans have
069helped develop, in various ways, and maintain the essence and substance of American democracy, and where the study of African American contributions helps students learn analytically and reach conclusions based on solid evidence. It is an opportunity for all students to enrich their education and deepen their understanding of history. African American and where the development of skills learned during Black History Month will contribute to all students advocating for individual rights, the rights of African Americans, the rights and responsibilities of citizens in a democracy. The Senate recognizes and celebrates Black History Month during the month of February 2025. We have not approved it. So I am going to entertain a motion to approve the resolution. Motion to accept. Seconded by all in favor. Say I. Any abstentions or objections? The motion passes unanimously. Item 10 removed. Sir, this
070item is for individual memberships to the association. The California Latino Superintendents and Administrators Association. We believe that the affiliation of these members would benefit our District. It is a national organization that provides professional training to support our administrators in areas such as leadership. It is worthwhile for us to invest at a very low cost to send administrators to have this membership. A motion to try. Does anyone want to sever it? Seconded by all unanimously. Item 10 removed. By the staff, Mr. Dr. Reyes, 10, it is a correction of the dates, it says November 4, 2024 to November 3, 2025, it should read February 20, 2024 to February 2025. Motion to approve it with the change, seconded motion by Tamayo, all in favor. The motion passes unanimously. No, he doesn't know that from 8 o'clock, so
071I'm not chilling Article 10 and that Dr. Reyes took it out. We're going to remove Chatman Santos and Cook. I'm going to ask for a motion to approve the article with the revision. I ask for a motion. Everyone in favor, say I. The motion passes unanimously. At this moment, I want to give the microphone to Mr. Romero so he can talk about our newly hired employees. Thank you very much to the members of the board. It is my pleasure to present to you tonight our newly hired employees, and we also have Hilda Ambris as manager of Congratulations to Diana Guerrero, Yard Supervisor, from Special Education Instruction Assistant; J Insuna, Purchaser, and Library Specialist Technician; Joh Le Naeli Oeda, Yard Supervisor and Student Assistant, and Silvia Pedrosa, Payroll Specialist One, and Payroll Specialist Two. Congratulations to
072Silvia, Instruction Assistant, and Student Assistant; Congratulations to Dora Victoria Reyes, Payroll Specialist Two, and Specialist Three; Congratulations to Victoria Arlin Rubalcava, Yard Supervisor and Instruction Assistant; Congratulations to Arlin; and finally, Emma Williams, School Secretary, Secretary, and Principal. It has been a pleasure working with her this past month. Congratulations, Emma. And that concludes our newly promoted employees. The public hearing gives the public the opportunity to communicate with the board on any point regarding specific topics. The board will limit the total time for public input to 20 minutes per point at the public hearing, and attendees will be asked to be respectful of the board's decision. The chairperson may increase or decrease the time allowed for public comments depending on the number and length of the petitions to be submitted. We've heard our first point. It's about
073the continuation of certain services, or rather, the discontinuation of certain classified services. This item is for the Board to consider. We make our annual projections based on the District's needs and physical responsibilities, and we're going to be eliminating some positions. It's recommended that the District move forward with these positions that are no longer required. I'm opening the public hearing. Is there anyone who wants to speak on this? I do n't see anyone. Now, I'm closing the public hearing. This is an action item, Madam President. What are the savings from this item, Mr. Pong? Approximately $ 521,000. I have a question. I'd like to know what opportunities people have if these positions disappear, Mr. Romero. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to respond to this. The District prioritizes ensuring that employees have opportunities. We are
074the second largest employer in Chula Vista. Our District employs approximately 4,000 employees. As you know, we have positions that become available each month, and there are opportunities to fill those positions. But now, some of these positions belong to someone. One of them is vacant. Yes, these employees will be with us until June 30 in their current positions. From now until June 30, with board approval, we will work with these employees and ensure they have opportunities to stay. Ms. Angela, you will be working with her very closely to find positions, right? Yes, thank you. I have a question to clarify these positions. These positions will be reduced because, for example, I see a yard supervisor here. My question is, does the school no longer need it? Dr. Reyes, Mr. Romero, great question. One of the things
075that happens in the organizational part is that the district bases the number of yard supervisors at each school on a given scale, and schools have the opportunity to provide more support if needed, but that is an annual decision. So, depending on the needs or the number of students in their enrollment, perhaps they no longer need that support. So these positions will be eliminated, but people have job opportunities at nearby schools. Thank you. This is an action item, an action item. Excuse me, we have an emotion. Technically, you can deny it. This happens every year. This creates a problem because these positions in those Um, they have seniority. So it's a domino effect, maybe the people—and this is something Ms. Angela talked about—is there anything we can do to change this? A couple of things for
076today. I would tell you to approve it because we would have over half a million dollars' worth of staff that we don't need. In the formula, you have to see two things, Mr. Absolute, right? When you hire someone, which is called a soft hire, which is a Title I position for schools, they may or may not have the same amount of funding for the following year. So that position may continue, or instead of being full-time, it may be part-time. It may change in how it originates. Now, on one hand, yes, restricting schools from hiring additional staff limits the action. Maybe there will be a reduction, for example. However, on one hand, yes, it can happen, but on the other hand, it takes the flexibility of the schools and the school board to address individual needs,
077and it may be with respect to safety or instruction, many things. Allowing flexibility for the schools, yes, this decision costs money, but it gives principals and schools that flexibility. For tonight, I do want to... I ask that you consider approving it because otherwise it will be half a million dollars in personnel costs that we are not projecting to use. So I have a question: the way I understand it, listening to Mr. Tamayo and Mr. Punk, these are positions that the schools are covering, aside from the savings. What happens if the school has already decided that these are not priorities for next year? It's not the school, it's the district that has to take over the positions, the work that these people are doing. Where does that workload go? For example, instructional assistants might be helping
078students one-on-one. A sixth-grade student is going into seventh grade, and now there won't be a need for that position. It could be a situation in a particular school, or enrollment might have decreased, or a playground supervisor might be working overtime. So now they can use fewer playground supervisors over a shorter period of time. There are many different scenarios. It's not necessarily that someone will have that workload; it's that at that moment it's not needed. I spoke about this a year ago, for example. Having instructional assistants to help students between kindergarten and third grade to teach them to read the presentation we just had a moment ago to help them when you have this focus group. Harbor already saw the results. It's something we could look at. I'm not saying all of them, but some things
079we can use to help teachers put children where they need to be. Teachers have to do the tests once a year and spend an hour with each student. Having someone trained to go around the school and do the assessment because it takes up instructional time. Because the teacher has 31 students and they're spending an hour with each student to do the assessment. And the idea was to have consistency in how these assessments are being given, and it will allow teachers to teach classes. Training instructional assistants to do it. All the schools need the help. It's something we can do. Mr. Romero, one point to clarify: These are positions, not people. That's what I was asking. Are there currently people sitting in these positions? But on average, and correct me if I'm wrong, but approximately we
080have We have 800 instructional assistants in our district, but not a single instructional assistant will be without a job next year. We're hiring some every month. These instructional assistant positions aren't going to be lost. We have a real need for playground supervisors. I don't think there's a single person on this list who won't have a job. Our instructional assistants will have jobs; they'll return as instructional assistants. Some of these positions are subsidized by the schools, and others we don't have. Our parent coordinator— that position will be eliminated. And if there is someone interested in positions within the district, well, that position will be eliminated. But that position will be eliminated. I just want to clarify that these people will have jobs. I'm a little confused because Dr. Reyes said we don't need these positions. I
081have the list of all the people who were hired. So why are we hiring, and tomorrow we have another job fair? One thing is the positions, and another is the people. So let's say we have 10 positions, and let's say we have three vacancies. Of those three positions, we only need nine. So we reduce one position, and we still have to hire. Two people because we still have two vacancies, but we don't need the tenth. What I just explained makes sense. You just mentioned it, and I want to be very specific. What happens is that we have instructional assistants, or what we call one-on-one assistants. We have a number of sixth-grade students who are leaving and who have an assistant assigned to them. Those positions are going to be eliminated because they no longer need
082that one-on- one support. This is eliminating the position, not the person. That person will still be an instructional assistant, but the one they were assigned will no longer exist, and there are a number of these that happen annually. I think we can work with the district on this. Obviously, we have to look at how the schools distribute the money for positions. There are people involved, and it creates chaos in human resources when priorities change. There needs to be more training at the school board level, and what decisions are impacted. I want to see the district involved in the board, in the school board decisions. I'm calling for a motion. Mr. Tamayo and Ms. [Name] requested it. Everyone seconded it. Everyone in favor. Is there anyone who opposes it? And I... I abstain. The motion passes,
083and one abstention. Article 11b. Public hearing on the discontinuation of certified services for the 2025 school year. Mr. Romero, thank you very much, President Ugarte, Dr. Reyes, Board of Directors. Today's item is for similar reasons that the classified personnel in the enrollment projections and projections for our schools have positions that have to be eliminated due to money, to the budgets, and they are being reduced because enrollment has decreased. And that means that we have to address these decreases in enrollment, and we have to be prepared for the current projections and our need to address other areas as priorities. The district recommends that we reduce certified full-time positions, and so I am opening the public hearing. Does anyone want to speak? No one wants to speak. I am going to close the public hearing. Discussions before
084it is an action item for this item. It is $1.1 million. If we are using the same logic, President Ugarte, we are using the same logic. We are saying that all these people are going to return, Dr. Reyes. Mr. Romero, great question. It varies among the positions we are talking about. The district is eliminating the Director of Assistance and Welfare. This employee is a former educator, and A position in the district may return, and because of the changes we 're seeing, it's no longer necessary for special education teachers, having a resource teacher and a music teacher. Those positions, if we're looking at Proposition 28 and the needs of our district, may return at the end of this year. And the general education teachers— we hear that the district uses enrollment projections for the school year,
085and it's to be fiscally aware that it could be reduced to nine teachers. I think this could be an area where there's a possibility they won't return, but we have to wait and see how those enrollments look. I have a question, Dr. Reyes: What's the difference between this year and next year, Mr. Pong? We're making projections with one sixth-grade teacher who won't be there anymore and another transition teacher. The question is, what's the projection for this year? Will it decrease or increase, or will it stay the same? We're projecting that enrollments will be the same. If we're projecting that it will be the same, why eliminate or discontinue these positions, Mr. Pong? We're looking at where there's a possibility of doing so. Combo classes in some areas to achieve some savings. We're talking about combos,
086basically. We're looking at schools that have two classes, two classrooms, 10 children and eight children. Financially, it's not good to have two teachers with so few children. Any district wouldn't be operating with a classroom that's losing money, and that's why combo classes are done. They're not very popular with teachers. Yes, they are grades they are teaching, the instructional time doesn't change because if you have this, you have students sitting there, maybe learning a little bit here, a little bit there. I'm going to take the lead here. Let me know if you want to move forward with these financial projections. So, tell me how you want us to avoid a deficit. We understand you're between a rock and a stone, but the sacrifice can't be in the classroom. Where else can we find it? Maybe it's
087an exercise, a workshop, or something. I spoke with President Rosy Martinez and said, "Where is all our staff and what are they doing?" I'm sure they're doing something, but what are we going to... Sacrificing classroom space or something else to put things in perspective regarding fiscal efficiency, any school district, for example, 92 percent of our budget is for personnel. So when you have an organization where 90 percent was 15 million to 20 million—I don't even know what 12 million is anymore— where can we maximize our resources? Just to clarify, these resource teachers, the schools say we need fewer teachers. Our enrollment projections—we have a department that takes enrollment data and does it by eliminating the sixth-grade level and doubling the kindergarten numbers. Doing that, they have projections they use to talk about each school. If
088there's a decrease in enrollment, how many teachers will they lose? And in a school that's increasing enrollment, how many classes will they add? Taking all that data, and based on one school losing two teachers and another losing three, plus one, we have a formula. And we have a number. In general, schools are losing more than one teacher. Yes, again, and it's based on enrollment. We have some schools that have more enrollments, and there are others that have decreased theirs. Registration, I have a question for clarification. I'm going to guess. We have equivalent full-time teachers, right? 1600 full-time equivalents, all certified staff. I'm guessing. I know the association numbers, right? Those 1600 are full-time. We're just talking about it. I wanted to clarify. I'm making a motion. I'm not clarifying. I think some members are thinking
089there are hundreds of teachers. These are nine positions out of 1600. No, yes, I understand what you're saying. The problem I'm having is with the General Education teachers, but this is a domino effect. But here they're going to tell us that the students aren't at their instructional level because they're in a blended class. I had a fourth-grade student and I said, "Oh yes, they're going to be more exposed to much more." But if it were the other way around, if I have a fifth-grade student and I know that teacher has to take time to teach the fourth-grade curriculum, you can't ignore those students. I would love it if there were another way, Dr. Reyes. I'm looking, I'm waiting for someone to come up with a great idea, right? I would love it if you had
090an answer for this. I would say, "Okay, I'm going to..." The motion without the General Education teachers is what I would like to hear. Yes, I understand what you are trying to say. This is a process that unfortunately—and I say unfortunately because it is not for fun or enjoyment—is something that happens every year. And yes, I recognize that other schools or districts have 400 teachers. This is magnificent. I cannot guarantee that these four or six teachers will return, but I can assure you that most of them will return. We don't want to be in a position where we are spending more, where we have people. So what we have to do is accept this, and I will work with Human Resources to see which ones we can bring back. It won't be until May or
091June. The excitement passes. You promised it on the condition that you are seeing the General Education teachers. I second that. Ms. Dominguez Cervantes seconded it. Mr. [Name Missing] requested it. Ms. Tosten seconded it. Everyone in favor, say yes. Everyone who opposes it, and Mr. Tamzo abstains, and Ms. Ugarte abstains. Three votes, two abstentions. And before we move forward... It's very difficult to separate myself from this because this is a topic I'm passionate about. But having to make this decision now instead of in July, there could be something else like this in August, and teachers won't find their jobs. That's why it's being done now. And I appreciate you making comments because if enrollments come in and are lower, we would have been reviewing this at that time. Thank you for allowing me this privilege. Now
092we are in the process of the Board of Directors adopting a resolution regarding independent citizen oversight of Measure A, the scope of duties of the Chula Vista District Independent Citizen Oversight Committee for General Obligation Bond Revenue, and amending the committee's bylaws to reflect the same. Thank you very much, President Hugorte. Based on the law regarding General Obligation Bonds, we need to have the election results certified. So this will have Measure A to also have an independent citizen oversight committee. Nobody wants to talk about this item. Any questions or comments? Quick comment. The report for these audits. This is the one we receive once a year. Yes, yes, these are independent members of The community, would it be possible? I know we receive some emails from community members, but we can update it; it doesn't have
093to be a formal presentation. It's twice a year. That's all. This is an action item. I second Mrs. Tamayo's request, and Mr. Domínguez Cervantes requested it. We all unanimously agree to adopt a resolution authorizing the Chulo Vista district to submit Form J1A, an application for emergency assistance, and to adopt a resolution authorizing construction for the Extended Learning Opportunities Program due to emergency conditions, and to adopt a resolution to establish the bond construction fund (double measure 2134) and a debt service fund. We had some emergency situations in January; then it was at Juárez Lincoln and also at Tiffany School. So with that, we're going to be requesting assistance. We have to request it for these days for which we weren't in session. Mrs. Domínguez Cervantes requested it, and Mr. Tamayo seconded it. Everyone is in favor.
094I, the Mason, agree to adopt the resolution to establish the bond construction fund. Bond measure AA 2134 and a corresponding debt service fund for each series of bonds issued under measure AA. Thank you very much. This is to establish a new fund with the treasury to track each fund separately. Mrs. Dominguez Cervantes requested it, Mr. Tamayo seconded it, everyone in favor. I say the motion passes. 50 general information articles and reports. So at the last meeting, Mrs. Dominguez Cervantes requested a review of the human resources department and also the crisis team to do a study on our human resources department. I contacted the department and there are a couple of things. They are very busy right now because they were assigned to do tax audits to support some districts in Los Angeles. However, they sent
095me the proposal and what I told them is, "Give me the proposal for this and the amount." So this includes hiring, doing interviews, and cross-training. Management and it also goes to evaluate the work flow and they are also going to review all the staff and make recommendations for the staff and so that The organization will be restructured, and then the report will be presented at a board meeting. The cost for all of this would be $ 26,000. This is an information point. There are questions about the information that Dr. Reyes just gave. I wanted to get the board's opinion. If you tell me, I'll contact them and then bring it to you for approval. I think it covers what we talked about. No, yes, how are you? Excuse me, we have a timeline. Thank you.
096When I spoke with them, they were able to... They didn't give me a timeline, a chronology, but they could talk to me about this in about a month. If they send me the contract, I can bring it to the March meeting. If I receive the information, Mrs. Morales... Oh, thank you, thank you, President Huguert and board members. Tonight, we are going to update our community and board's mid- year report of the 2024-2025 Local Accountability Plan. The development and implementation of this report has been a collaborative effort in our district, and it will be reflected in how... We have a team of staff who have been eagerly awaiting this presentation. They have been collaborators, and I thank them for staying and joining us. I would like to invite Dr. Patel, who will be presenting tonight. We
097will be updating you on where we stand in all the measures, services, and expenditures for all of our NC goals. We will begin with Ms. Perez, who will start with a summary. Good evening. The districts have the responsibility to develop an ELC, which is a 3-year plan that outlines strategies that address state and local priorities. It is an opportunity for the district to share its foundation of services that meet the needs of our schools. We are in the first year of this 3-year plan. As you can see, the key components on this slide include metrics to evaluate our progress over time. Over time, the ELC is Bosa, as the district plans to improve student achievement. It is important to note that concentration funds must be directed to low- income students, English language learners, and students
098in foster care. As Ms. Morales stated, the development of the ALAP is a collaborative effort. It includes consultation with teachers, principals, administrators, staff, union members, members of the school community, and students. It includes various boards, an open survey, and focus groups to obtain comprehensive feedback. In November 2024, we began engaging our educational partners. In February 2025, there is a mid-year report to the board on the progress of the plan, which is what we are presenting today. The feedback we obtain will be updated, and there will be a public hearing in 2026. This is an opportunity for the public to comment, and the board can provide feedback. On June 25, the five main goals were approved. They are as follows: Academic achievement, safety, and inclusive environments (Goal 3); English language learners (Goal 4); Innovation ( Goal
0995); and Educational stakeholder engagement (Goal 6). Our district's first priority is ensuring academic achievement for all our students. When we look at the overall achievement for our students in English Literature, we see an increase of 4.5, and we've moved from yellow to green on the board. This is good news. Looking at our local measures, using Achieve 3000, 37.2% of our students are meeting the standards. We remain committed to the development and literacy of all students, and we also provide literacy and language training in all grade levels. When we look at the math data, we see that we still need to work. We are currently below the standard by 6.4, and we remain in a yellow status on the board for this year. Our focus will be on creating math-focused plans at the district level. We
100are providing math training for all our teachers in grades 2, 4, and 6. The purpose of this training is to ensure that our teachers deepen their understanding of the framework and become familiar with the routines within our curriculum. As we see in the next slides, we are also continuing our work with all our... Principals participate in learning walks. We are visiting classrooms and observing the encasting practices and how they are impacting our students' learning. We have a specific focus on the groups of students who receive Special Education services. When we look at the data in this group of students, we maintain the same level of achievement in language arts and literature, and we are declining a little in math. We are ensuring that we invite all of our school staff members who provide supports to
101students with disabilities to participate in our language arts, literature, math, and civics training for their role in our district. This helps provide access to standards-based instruction, supports, and collaboration with our regular education teachers and special education teachers. Lastly, we are pleased to share that we remain committed to supporting the implementation of TK. 100% of our TK classrooms have a teacher's aide. We also provide professional development training for all teacher's aides and all TK teachers, and we are pleased to announce that we plan to open 13 TK classrooms. In the next school year, we will be able to provide that support and those opportunities. Goal number two is safe environments. We have several measures in place, including student belonging and safety. We have been very intentional about working on chronic absenteeism, as well as providing training
102and talks on the measures. The data shows improvements, including a decrease in chronic absenteeism. As part of promoting social-emotional well-being, we are pleased to report on the various counseling sessions we have been offering throughout the district, including individual and group counseling, as well as social-emotional lessons. 100% of safety assessments were also conducted. A collaboration with Rocket Rules was approved, which includes lessons and videos. We are also pleased to report that 100% of our staff have been trained in the use of EEX, and all campuses are in contact with our office. Our ongoing commitment to supporting English language learners is also evident. Current information shows a reduction in long-term English language learners, which is good news. It means more students are on track for redesign, and the data also shows an increase from last year. We
103expect further improvements by the end of the school year. School performance, the results of the 2024 QEPER show an improvement over the previous year. We have provided professional development training for all teachers in language and literature, which includes a comprehensive component. This year, we provided curriculum training in 19 schools. We are pleased to report a 16.04% decrease in chronic absenteeism among English language students. The principals and teachers remain dedicated to continuing to make improvements in the academic achievement of our English language students, and we are confident that we will continue to see positive improvements. Goal number four focuses on innovation. We continue to develop our LIP program, with over 960 students participating in the Hubby Club. Equity has improved, and we have also introduced exciting clubs and classes. Students have access to our VAPA classes,
104and we are pleased. Finally, the Life Sciences Station has been very successful, and 13 out of 15 schools have installed Studio STEM. Something I would like to highlight is that, as you can see, regarding expenses, we are pleased to report that many of your positions have been filled. The total cost is indicated there as $9.9 million and we have about $ 5.5 million that's still there in our plan. Our ultimate goal is to strengthen educational partner engagement, to strengthen collaboration with the school community, to ensure that parents are connected and informed. In different ways, one of our priorities continues to be the engagement of families and the school community. 86 parents attended or participated in seven CB ESD University workshops. And this is evidence that we want to strengthen our bond with parents to cultivate
105student success. When we look at the expenses, our expenses were $135 million. Of those expenses, $58 million is allocated to the goals, so we have about $377 million. A lot of that is the core program, and it consists of certified and classified staff, transportation, facilities and operations, and also support for special education. Now, I can ask questions about the report update. We don't have any speakers or board comments on it. I have a question: Are you going to open more? We're focusing on the west side. Is there equity on both sides of the district, Ms. Morales? I want to know if I understand the question. We project that all of our schools will... Having access to Ajax, all our schools have access to Ajax. There are other questions. Yes, one question: how many Physical Education
106teachers do we have? And I have another question about Ajax, Mr. Reyes. Mr. Romero, do you have that number, that data? You want to ask the question about Ajax? Yes, to access that software soon. If the teachers aren't giving feedback when they're logging in, if it's fast, if the servers are working because why aren't they? It doesn't work if they don't have access. Perhaps if the substitutes can get laptops, if they're being trained. Mr. Romero, could you tell us if we can address Ajax? 15 physical education teachers? Yes. We've talked about it several times, that it takes a year to implement. We've been talking in our safety meetings about the priority of how to use it. We get more value when we use it, so familiarizing our staff with it is critical. One of the
107situations that arose was that one of our schools was placed under this Plant Security program but didn't implement Ajax. So the principal, but still our district, is... It's more than anything to make sure our staff becomes familiar with it. It's one of our priorities how to use this program. The district is looking to acquire tablets that can be used by the... Substitutes only work if a substitute comes to Liberty, for example. We want to ensure they have a tablet they can use if there's an emergency, so they can respond or receive a response. That's what we're looking at for the 2025-2026 school year, and training our staff on how to use the program. We've received feedback on usage; access is one of our priorities, a necessity, and we want to make sure. Another thing we
108're looking at is that we have staff; it's not a requirement for them to install programs on their cell phones. We want to prioritize that it's not required, but if a staff member is supervising, or if they're in recess supervising, and they don't have it on their cell phone and there's an emergency, they won't receive notifications. So the idea of the tablet is that the substitute can borrow a tablet and take it with them. I'm not talking about 8- inch tablets; it's not a very large tablet. Amazon makes those tablets; it only works if they use it. That's a challenge. I don't hear much; I'm not hearing from anyone. They're committed to training the staff, and the only benefit we've seen is with usage, and not... It's worthwhile if we're not using it. What I'm
109going to do is prioritize going to the schools and getting information so we can share information and also revisit and analyze how often it's being used lately. The goal is that we don't use it all the time because we're already familiar with the program's functions. An update is needed, and it's not that they asked for this information, but we're going to collaborate with them. We're the largest district using their program. The cost of EEX is 3,000 and something per school year. It's not much, but we're negotiating a price with them to reduce it to 100 per school per year. If we're going to wrap up, any other questions or comments about the program? I just mentioned that for teachers who are supervising the playground area, they have to have it on their personal device. They
110will also have access. They have to have their cell phone; if they don't have it, it's not a requirement to have a cell phone. It's optional. All the unions are encouraged to use this program. The union doesn't have access to their data, that's why they have to borrow a device every time they visit a school. Thank you so much for the report, it was very informative and we appreciate it. I love that it's concise information with few slides and easy-to- read text. Thank you so much. That's the time when board members can request reports from Dr. Reyes. I think we've already covered most of it. I just want an update on it, and I sat down with Jacob, and I know that Lineb, the Lineb software, I would like an update on Lineb. They can
111give us a report to see where we are, what the status is. An update on Friday. I would like a report, not a whole presentation, something, a report to see what the status is. Any other report, another result report? Yes, Neo, an update. What happened with that school that wanted a water bottle station? I know I requested it. I wanted to see something. What was it? I have n't seen it on the agenda. There's only one update. We had meetings with 32 studios, and another was that we met with the principal to determine the location. We are waiting for our contractors to confirm that they will be able to install it. And the third school That's already been installed, so they're happy and satisfied. Very good. I'm going to have to go see. There you
112can fill your water. The next report: it's been several months since I applied for the contract to repair the playgrounds. I've been told we have to wait for the bond, I've been told we have to wait for the contractor, I've been told we have to wait for the moon and the sun to align. Where are we with that? Secondly, Mr. Pon, some of the play structures can't be repaired. We're thinking [Music] about going to meet with vendors to see if some will be replaced. It's going to be in two stages. They're going to help us design the playground structures, and then we're going to seek approval. One of the things we discovered when we looked at the different play structures, almost all schools have different types of play structures. So one of the things we
113believe is important is that we involve this instructional service so that they have a learning component, not just play, for this exercise. And currently, they're working on that. Mrs. Morales, do you have an update? We had We had a meeting this week and asked the vendor to provide us with some options. We would like our playgrounds to have different types of equipment for making music, echoing, climbing, and exploring, as well as swings. So we gave them different parameters so they could give us options to choose from to see if they fit in the spaces. This meeting is for the modernization of Bolind. So we are trying to create standards for the District. I appreciate that we are trying to maximize the opportunity. Now, what are the timelines? Because that is very important. We can talk
114about what we want to do and the things we can do with this project, but several of these schools don't have playgrounds for these children. The playground is the schoolyard. We have to maximize those opportunities for those students as well. So, what are the timelines, at least for those three schools? I understand we have 50 students. We are a large District, but there is an urgency that we have to address for those students who deserve to have a playground. I assure you that if there is a piece of someone who has to remove that dangerous structure, if we have to knock on whose door... We have to do that, it's not your fault. But what they keep telling us is this sense of urgency, Mr. Pong. Make this a priority. I would like that when
115we consider all the academic aspects, especially with students with physical disabilities, all the new play structures will comply with ADA guidelines. There are safety regulations regarding these play structures. Are we ensuring that safety is our priority, Mr. Morales? What happens when we have a damaged play structure? If we agree that it's an emergency, because otherwise it requires us to close some components, then we give it priority. You can check Castle Park because it's not happening there. That's all I have. Communication from the board. That's the agenda item when the board members... Excuse me, I have another one. You didn't lie to us about the board's solution. A list of the number of complaints that have been filed this year. This is an agenda item when the board members can report on any activities they have
116participated in since the last board meeting. Events Activities that have been attended, starting with member Dominguez Ramirez, I was able to visit two campuses. AB is very educational and informative. I was able to visit Fister, one of their programs. They mentioned that our innovation station is based on their innovation program. It's wonderful to see what they are currently doing. They have a neuroscience club where they work with brains, which is wonderful. The ability to visit this place in Downtown and take the trolley is a wonderful experience. I was also very intrigued. I was also able to visit another charter school and I loved it. They have a 30-minute program called... What's it called? It's at the end of the day. I forget the name, but basically the children have to do homework. Students from all
117grade levels: one is the owner, another is the cashier, another is the painter, another is the photographer. It's very good to see the students working in groups at different levels and having that community and having their paydays. All those components were very nice to see in our charter schools with the innovation station. What the charter schools implement we can apply in other schools. It was very informative and I look forward to visiting other schools and being able to... Supporting and helping those schools, I was able to visit the health and science station. It was very informative and eye-opening. It was very interesting to see that it's not just about what they are learning that day, that they are being guided towards a career, but also that they are being based on their strengths. I told
118Dr. Reyes that I feel that communication should be more with parents, not just on social media. We get excited when they go on a field trip, but there is much more to it than that. It was wonderful, fascinating. I can't wait to see more of those stations. I also had the opportunity to attend the Discover Charter School. I am very proud of the staff and the students. Their costumes were wonderful, the acting, the organization of everything, the entire production, from the seating to the play in general. I would like to see more of that. Members of Cervantes, I also attended the Lion King performance at the Discover Charter School, and it is wonderful that the students are so brave and perform for an audience that is intimidating to them, but they love it. They are
119very good. Again, The costumes, the music, Simba—I love it. My colleague here liked it, and so did the other person. I attended and participated in the speakers' presentations. There was a boy who, I mean, had all our attention. It was wonderful to see how you work in your brain, having a conversation with the audience, and you don't realize you're in a conversation with them, but you are, because they're anticipating, asking questions about what you're thinking, and before you can even think, they've already... It was a very interesting journey to see this boy's presentation. His name is Diego. Also, at Heritage, another presentation... Giving these [Music] children a theme and seeing how they develop it and how they incorporate their ideas is wonderful. This little girl took us on a journey of How to See the
120Stars, and it was almost like a movie. It was wonderful. I know all schools have that; all schools have stars. This little girl should write a book because the illustrations and the way she did it were wonderful. All our children are wonderful, and I look forward to seeing those who move on to the next stage, the next phase. It's not that the others haven't done a good job. I also met with some parents. I also attended the monthly touch meeting last week, and it's always nice to see the parents and hear their experiences and share some things that are working, things that aren't working at their schools, but are working among them. Thank you for the opportunity. They tried to make me sing, but it was a terrible idea. I only moved my lips; it
121wasn't very good. Thank you. I also had the opportunity to attend The Lion King at Discovery School. It was wonderful. My favorite part was the production, how the students... not only the acting, but all the students... well, setting up the stage. My favorite was Scar. I loved the character so much. Timon and Pumba were also very funny, but overall, each of them was very, very talented, reminding us of lines. Little Simba, I tell you, when he was very little, and to be able to remember all the lines was very impressive. I knew all the lines, the script of that movie, and I remembered when I heard it. It's very impressive that they can do that. The talent we have in our schools. New members will be able to see the talent in our students. They
122will be able to see it as long as they invite us and have the opportunity to attend these events because there is so much talent in our schools with our children. It's wonderful. That would be all. I, you say, everything I had to say. I went to a Family Friday night. It was the first time my daughter, who is very, very... accompanied me. She goes to plays of Tron. She came with me and all the time she was telling me about little Simba. Scar was amazed by everything the students did in this play. In the end, I found out that we know who Scar's parents are. We also knew the students from the choirs and also... Seeing other alumni made me feel very veteran, not old, but veteran. It was a very nice night, excellent
123production, and please continue inviting us to these events because they are very fun. Dr. Reyes, the Superintendent of Communications, just wanted to thank everyone for the great work, for your leadership, for making sure our students are always safe and receive the best possible education. Thank you. There's a question before we adjourn. I thought I wanted to address that the teachers have been asking about CHIF. We're going to send a notification. We're going to send communication through the IS bulletin, and also that we're going to use CHIF for another year and we're going to review the evaluations to see if there should be any changes. Thank you very much. The next regular meeting of the Board of Trustees will be on March 5th, closed session, and at 6 p.m. Motion to adjourn, open session. Second motion:
124all in favor. It was frozen. It was frozen. It was frozen.