CorpusRecord 39012

2/19/2025 - English - Chula Vista Elementary School District Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Chula Vista Elementary School District
Date
2025-02-20
Location
San Diego County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
22,620 words · about 126 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e this regular meeting of the Chul Vista Elementary School District Board of Education is now in order welcome everyone all board members are present except for uh vice president the Mayo we will now approve the agenda is there a motion motion to approve second moved by clerk Dominguez cantes seconded by trustee Ramirez Dominguez I gotta get used to it um all those in favor I motion carries absent oral communication for Clos session items the oral communic ation section provides the public with an opportunity to address the board on Clos session items only persons wishing to be heard May attend in person and should complete a request to be heard card and submit it to the recording secretary before the start of the meeting speakers are requested to limit their remarks to three minutes

002and speak in a respectful and professional manner the board shall limit the total time for public input on each topic to 20 minutes with board consent the president may increase or decrease the time allowed for public comments depending on the number of persons wishing to be heard no board action can be taken we have no speakers we will now adjourn to close session in accordance with the following government code sections 35491 D and 54957.6 collective bargaining employee negotiations LLP and Adam Silva and MCN LLP employee organizations Chula Vista classified employees organization Chula Vista Educators non-represented employees and administrators Association Chula Vista government code section 54957 B1 Public Employee discipline dismissal release government code section 54956.9 D1 conference with legal councel existing litigation in the office of administrative hearings case number 0399 student expulsion case 225-1464

00318918 government code section 54956.9 conference with real property negotiator property location 845 Broadway Chul Vista California 9 91911 APN number 760- 235-70 negotiating parties chivista ele school district and metropolitan area advisory committee on anti-poverty of San Diego County Incorporated and government code section 54957 Public Employee appointment employment title principal e e e with all board members present please note that truste Tamayo arrived at 420 for the minutes I will entertain a motion to accept the recommendation of the hearing panel and plan of Rehabilitation for case close session announcements will be made by clerk Dominguez cantes on government code section 54957 B1 Public Employee discipline dismissal release on motion by member Tamayo second by member Ramirez Dominguez the board approved the non- reelection pursuant to Education Code section 449 2921 of employee number 2011 1 625

004286 and by the following vote the a is five no zero on government code section 54956.9 D1 conference with legal councel existing litigation in office of administrative hearings case number 0399 on motion by member Dominguez cantes second by member Ramirez Dominguez the board approved the settlement agreement by the following vote the a are for zero NOS toaya was absent thank you the Open session of the regular meeting of the Chula Vista Elementary School District Board of Education is now in order welcome everyone truste ramz Dominguez if you could lead us in the pledge please I pledge Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the for it stands one nation God indivisible with liy and justice for all thank you I will now accept a motion to to approve the agenda

005with flexibility so moved second move by vice president Theo seconded by truste Dominguez santes all those in favor I motion carries unanimously we will be um moving items item the items of uh section 13 which is the public hearing to just before the consent agenda followed by item [Music] 10n communication to the Board of Education Chula Vista classified employees organization Miss Angela Reed good evening board um I come for before you tonight on behalf of our school secretaries who serve as the backbone of every School site they are the first faces when visitors enter the office the right hand of the principle and the ones who ensure the day-to-day operations of the school run smoothly tonight I want to address the significant challenges they face from the recent changes in the district's purchasing and Supply

006ordering process what was once a straightforward task has now become far more complex and burdensome for secretaries and they are concerned about the negative impact it's having on their ability to effectively support the school's front office a major issue is that the new process places much of the responsibility for purchasing and procurement on secretary's shoulders what was once handled by the purchasing department at the district office the requisitioning and ordering of supplies for the warehouse has now been shifted to them while they have always been committed to supporting our schools and students they are now being asked to take on the roles of buyer purchaser and budget manager the intent behind these changes may have been for efficiency but what has resulted is a much more fragmented and error prone system let me explain a

007few of the difficulties secretaries now face secretaries are now required to create open purchase orders for multiple vendors which ties up the school's very limited budget this adds another layer of complexity to their already full plates and the process of placing orders with multiple vendors instead of having a central warehouse system has led to higher costs for schools as they now purchase smaller quantities at higher prices secretaries are now expected to handle returns track warranties obtain quotes and enter new budget codes all while assuring that the budgets are accurate this is a lot to juggle especially considering that they are already working full-time managing the school office the new system has led to frequent issues with orders being cancelled by the district without notice forcing secretaries to reenter the same orders repeatedly additionally they are

008unable to see the final order amount with taxes until after the order is processed making it difficult to track how much money is left in the budget this lack of transparency transp Arcy and constant back and forth with canceled orders is taking up valuable time on top of placing orders and managing budgets secretaries are now required to check items as they arrive scan packing slips and email them to the district unfortunately months later they are still receiving emails stating that the packing slips were not received and that the district is delaying payments for invoices despite the fact that invoices were sent on time they are now doing what feels like a full-time job in purchasing accounting and inventory management tasks that were pre previously handled by the district office the burden of this added workload

009is taking away from the time and energy they have to support the students and the staff at our schools CB CEO sees the strain this is putting on our school secretaries and we ask that the board to return the primary contact for vendors to purchasing where they can be managed more effectively and not the school secretaries they are already stretched inin with their primary duties and adding the responsibilities of buyers and accountants only tether away from supporting our schools in the way we need them to thank you thank you Chul Vista Educators Miss Rosie Martinez good evening I want to start off by recognizing all the site teachers of the year were selected by their peers I applaud the sites that took the opportunity to highlight the amazing work that our teachers do on a

010daily basis for our students I extend my sincere gratitude and admiration to all who show up every day to ensure that our students have a safe productive and stimulating experience at school I believe that we all share in this responsibility all of our students Des serve their school to be a safe space we all owe that to our colleagues to our students and to to our community members that is why I wear a heart pin that shows my commitment to um to them as representative of the chil Vista Educators this my commitment is to students to staff and to community to community members to ensure that they are that they know that they are safe with me I will continue to work to ensure that our district is a place where we are all treated

011with respect where we value equity for all regardless of their race gender identity ability or resident status and where they will be included in celebrated for their diverse backgrounds I brought you all one so that you can join me in this commitment to making Chula Vista Elementary School District a safe place for all I hope that you wear it as proudly as I do because while we celebrate the accomplishments across the district we recognize that there is still much work to be done our students cannot thrive if they're hungry months ago I brought up the concern of Second Chance breakfast being taken away and yet we continue to allow our students to sit in our classrooms hungry and expect them to learn and behave we continue to have playgrounds without slides and communities where they

012don't have access to Parks we focus on consistency in learning practices but fail to include social emotional learning in the conversation we do need to take an honest look at areas that need Improvement and we look to you for your direction and support our students and staff cannot wait any longer tonight on the agenda you will vote on reduction in Staffing for the next school year cve believes that this is an un necessary stress for our members since we are confident that they will be brought back the system used by this district for projections does not work it never has it only creates Staffing nightmares for human resources A disruption to our school sites and a lot of anxiety for staff we urge you to look into how other districts around us make their projections

013so that we can improve our practices and avoid causing this disruption moving forward CV recognizes that the district is tasked with making difficult decisions about the budget as advocates of Community Schools we ask that you consider the pillars of shared leadership and parenting engagement by uplifting the voices of the community the students and the staff to help guide these decisions in a time when we are faced with serious budget cuts we need an additional layer of input after the elcap survey and the district's input tours to help prioritize the areas that rise to the surface we want a more active role in these decisions that impact our working conditions and our students learning conditions we prioritize ensuring that our students have adequate access to supports around academics and mental health class size has a tremendous

014impact on this there has been a lot of conversation about how to appropriately include our students with disabilities into general education settings cve stands firm behind our contract language around class size that is because we believe that our students deserve to be in a space that provides them the best opportunity to learn and grow this cannot happen if students are mainstreamed into classrooms that do not have sufficient desks chairs or materials for them it does not happen when the teacher cannot provide the students with the individual attention that they need and deserve the district's position on this is not only disappointing but very concerning it goes against all the work that we are doing around rigorous learning for all we urge you to problem solve with us and commit to creating the best opport unities

015for our students I want to thank Sharon Casey for working with us to find Solutions around the issue of RSP case loads we had our first meeting today with a team tasked to find better practices to support our students with IEPs cve will continue to be open to collaborate with the district and finding solutions to some of these challenges that we Face together thank you thank you administrator administrators Association to Vista Miss Teresa Corona thank you good evening president ugar superintendent Dr Reas and esteemed members of the board on behalf of the administrators Association chil Vista I'm pleased to share some good news that our cons consultation process with the district continued to move forward strongly and successfully this past month we truly value having a voice at the table to be able to contribute

016the unique perspectives of school administrators on the district's plans programs and structures Beyond consultation aacv members also serve on multiple subcommittees ensuring that our input is embedded at every level of decisionmaking so that is very much appreciated we are looking forward to the upcoming joint consultation with Chul Vista Educators as we work alongside the district to give input on the details and the components of the rigorous learning for all plan aacv remains committed to ensuring that school leaders have a role in these discussions because we know that clear well-structured policies and programs will only strengthen our district and move us towards lasting Excellence aacv is actually part of the American Federation of school administrators it's the only National Labor Union exclusively representing School administrators professionals and supervisors the mission of both aacv and Absa are

017to advocate for excellence and equity in our schools our workplaces and communities I wanted to take this opportunity that both aacv and ASA firmly believe in the power of public education as the Cornerstone Cornerstone of our democracy We Stand firmly against any and all efforts to dismantle public education whether through defunding privatization or policies that threaten the very Foundation of equal opportunity for all students for Generations public education has opened doors for children of all backgrounds regardless of income or immigration status and we are unwavering in our commitment to protect and strengthen it we also recognize the real challenges that many of our students and families face due to immigration policies that create fear and uncertainty as Educators we of course do not ask about our child our children's documentation status when they walk through

018our doors we ask how we can support them how we can help them learn and make sure they feel safe every student in cvesd deserves to know that our school schools are a place of belonging not a place of fear aacv was pleased to see the superintendent's recent communication reaffirming the safeguards we have in place to protect our students and families uh these communities matter and we will continue working with the district to ensure that every child in our school knows they are valued and supported we hope for continued communication and uh enforcing of the policies to ensure that that our school communities are safe places to learn and grow our schools are the heart of this community and our greatest strength lies in our shared commitment to the students and families we serve we

019will continue to stand for strong well-funded Public Schools the protection of our most vulnerable students and a future where every child no matter their background has the opportunity to reach their full potential thank you thank you [Applause] before we get to oral Communications Dr Reyes would you like to speak on the new composition of the dis yes so I would like to welcome uh two new members on the Das which is going to be executive directors uh Leilani perz and Buddy Montgomery welcome [Applause] welcome in for some fun oral Communications the oral communication section provides the public with an opportunity to address the board on non-agenda items persons wishing to be heard May attend in person and should complete a request to be her card and submit it to the recording secretary before the start

020of the meeting speakers are requested to limit their remarks to 3 minutes and speak in a respectful and professional manner the board shall limit the total time for public input on each topic to 20 minutes with board consent the president may increase or decrease the time allowed for public comments depending on the number of persons wishing to be heard no board action can be taken we have three speakers the first is Noel Cravens hello good evening um just wanted to inquire on a timeline on when the new board members are going to have their official um email addresses and I also want to know if um if all if the emails that have been sent to the board have been forwarded to them that's all thank you thank you Kim Matias good evening my name

021is Kim I'm an ESN teach I'm sorry ESN teacher at McMillan we've not had a principal since September we thought we she was supposed to come back in January but we've heard nothing from the district and we've heard nothing from anyone else emails were sent out earlier in January and nobody responded to any of the teachers that sent out those emails now I believe communication is the foundation of trust and right now that Foundation is cracked we're not here to demand every detail what happened or why decisions were made but I'm here to say that keeping the community the teachers the parents the students in the dark is not it's not just frustrating it's also disrespectful for us we deserve to know what's happening especially when it directly affects the education of the children at

022McMillan trust is not given it is built and that's something that we teach our kids daily and right now you're asking us to trust you but not but you've not given us the basic courtesy of transparency and that's not how trust works if you want to repair the relationship between this board and the community at McMillan the people it serves then communication needs to be a priority moving forward but this isn't just about what's already happened it's about what comes next what is this District going to do to build back that trust what concrete steps will you take to ensure that teachers parents and students are not just informed but actively involved in the education and the future of our schools and it's not enough to acknowledge the past missteps the lack of communication we

023also want action whether that means regular updates Community forums open dialogue something must change because right now the Silence from the dis district is breeding uncertainty at McMillan uncertainty breeds frustration and frustration leads to division and right now we need a leader at McMillan we have someone that we are that we love but we need someone we need communication from you guys and right now you guys have an opportunity to change that to show that you value McMillan like any other school in the district and please let us know what we can do to help or at least let us be part of that decision so right now how will you guys help us thank [Applause] you Ken is zigon good evening trustees cabinet and Dr Rees my name is Karen isacson and I'm both

024a teacher and a parent at a Roy to Charter School I'm here tonight to speak on behalf of my staff and myself to address the complete lack of communication we received on January 24th 2025 or as one of our staff calls it fire Friday on the morning of January 24th parents received three forms of communication around 6:00 a.m. a text a phone call and an email the staff at my site however were not given the same courtesy it was not until 7:30 a.m. that our administrator notified Us by email that we had to report to the the district office to be clear this was not my administrator's fault this failure falls on the district because a royya Vista is not part of the district school cohorts our administrator did not receive the same notification that

025the others did in fact while I sat at the bargaining table the following week Mr Romero admitted that only one school had been left out of the communication chain surprise it was a Roy Vista his reasoning because we're a charter school and our staff are Charter employees let me be very clear that's false the staff at a royya Vista are District employees and as a district employee we should have received the same notification as every other closed school then during the safety meeting on February 4th Mr Romero once again confirmed a royya Vista was left out of the communication chain this was not a simple oversight this was a failure that had Direct consequences to for my staff because my staff was informed so late that we had to report to the district many of

026us were left scrambling for child care as our children's school was closed due to air quality concerns the priority should have been the safety of our community since we were the ones directly impacted by the fire yes some of my staff were able to report and they were assigned to other sites but many were not because of child care conflicts because their homes were in warning zones or simply because by the time they checked their email it was already past our reporting time despite these circumstances the district took away a panl day from us that's completely unacceptable the lack of Comm communication failed us and instead of accountability we were penalized for it I sent multiple emails that Friday I reached out to Jason Romero Angela Rosendale Jorge MOA truste tomayo Ugarte and Dominguez cantes

027and I do want to acknowledge that trustee Dominguez cantes responded and forwarded my email to Dr Reyes in my email I shared pictures of the fire from my four-year-old Twin's bedroom window I shared photos of the belongings that I packed in case we had to evacuate and I also shared Sweetwater's message to their staff which explicitly stated that they would not be penalized for not reporting to work that day when I brought this up to Mr Romero his response was I should be lucky that cve bargained those three p&l days for us because Sweetwater employees don't get those extra days let me be very clear I'm absolutely grateful for those who have bargained before me I know exactly how much work it takes to write contract language and to fight for our working conditions and

028because this situation impacted me and so many of my staff contract language has now been written into the safety article to address natural disasters like fires this isn't our first fire and we know it won't be our last so I'm calling on you trustees to Rel to restore the p&l day that my staff lost due to the district's failure in communication let's not repeat this failure do better thank you thank you m madame president point point of privilege um Dr Rees I thought we fixed this issue Mr R uh thank you president Ugarte uh governing board and and Dr Rey um the district uh met with uh cve um the district being myself uh and Dr Reyes uh one of the the methods we need to uh support our staff was we uh rectified this

029situation by employees that were living uh in the yellow or red zones um would be uh re re uh re the pnl day would be reinstated um and so uh communication was sent out today notifying everyone that that would be the case um through giovana we've received a few emails in response to that um and some of the questions on how that would uh be done uh so we did say that would be um about 30 days to restore that p&l day because we're going to be looking at that data to make sure that it supports what the decision that was made Mr M is this for aoo only or for all the schools all the school sites thank you thank you was aoo also notified in that email Miss thank you oral present ation

030and written reports District sa safety health update Mr Romeo presar governing board uh members and our superintendent Dr Ra and Community it's my pleasure to report today uh on our safety update for the month of February so uh one of the things that we are looking at is making sure that we're just keeping up to date with some of our best practices so we have heating pads um at our School sites um that are used for various reasons and so some of the concerns that were brought up at our safety meeting was um how hot do these pads get um as they're outdated and and old and the cleanliness of these pads uh these signs did go up and we shared these signs at our uh our last uh presentation meeting U one of the

031things that we're still ensuring uh as the safest practice is our what we call Bell to Bell which is access uh to our campus um uh from the when the first Bell Rings to the last bell rings from the start of the school day to the end of the school day uh we got some uh quotes on some buzzer systems and we're excited to be rolling those out um for the 25 26 school year um but more on that to come uh so on February 5th uh there was a strong School smell at multiple School sites uh some of uh the school sites and our uh Westside uh the calls came in to our safety team and facility team team uh we were working with our uh School principles to make sure that we're implementing

032the safest practices um and the protocols on how to respond to that one of the things that we're we're making sure that we prioritize is their use of eegi uh for that um but they did conclude that the smells were coming from the area we know as the Tiana River uh so board policy uh 14513 uh the district response to immigration uh enforcement um there was a staff meeting uh that was presented and we did inform uh our staff on what that board policy is uh so Board of Two Fire response um this was you know one thing uh we heard today that it wasn't the first and definitely won't be the last and we did learn a lot from that so uh this is just a timeline of uh how things occurred um one

033of the things that we do want to make sure that uh at one of our School sites a Royal Vista we did have a break in uh communication with that School site uh because our school sites are zoned uh by areas and our Charter Schools uh weren't part of that communication we've now fixed that issue um with that but uh that was something that we learned um you know from this incident uh we still have multiple communication methods that we use uh such as email text and uh phone um but we're wanting to make sure that our our charter schools are part of that um because as charter schools have their own uh U body of uh oversight uh we do want to make sure that they're aligned with Chula Vista so uh that was

034one of the takeaways that we had from that um but this is a continuation of the timelines that took place uh for the Border 2 Fire response um we are um currently working with one of our labor groups cve to memorialize uh some langu on what to do as these incidents uh occur we haven't finalized that language and will be part of uh our continued negotiations that take place next week questions any questions or comments from the board I have a question with um president Ugarte with um the smell that they mentioned I've known that um other cities like Imperial Beach or cornado um are deeming that might be like a health risk um are we doing anything or providing any guidance in that Dr Reyes Mr Mayor yeah so currently we are not um

035uh actively um advocating such as they are so one of the things I know that they've uh talked about was uh providing uh the residents of that area air purifiers um uh if that's something that the board would like uh Dr Reyes to uh explore um you know he can reach out to the city and see if that's something that that would be of interest to them thank you any other questions or comments yeah I just have a question or comment um so just to reiterate the charters will be added to safety announcements and anything that the district has to pass as an emergency correct okay yes in regards to the uh filters it's some kind of a lottery I know my sister lives in that area even though she she fell into the senior

036citizen being sick and all that she still didn't get one so that might be something we might consider for those areas that we have as we've monitored before uh or that I asked that we monitor the air quality there because of the sewage coming over so I don't know where we are with that I know you were checking on that that's one point and another point that on that same also the smells the quality the safety the health sweet waterer Reservoir um I'd like to request president Ugarte if uh this request I'm going to this concern I'm going to bring up if you would consider it to be addressed in an urgent manner I don't know what the protocol is as a norm but just keeping that mind in mind let me share I don't

037think it can wait another month uh for it to stick get on the agenda as background it's been reported that the suit Water Authority which supplies roughly 200,000 customers in chil Vista where one of the customers okay especially on the west side and surrounding communities they learned last month that its main reservoir contains levels of toxic industrial chemical that could require extensive treatment or necessitate decommissioning the reservoir entirely Justin Brazil he's the director of water quality for Sweetwater Authority said quote we don't have treatment in place for pfas chemicals and said our options right now are we could take the reservoir out of service or blend Reservoir water with uncontaminated water brought from the out bought from outside agencies pfas are chemicals that are a class of industrial chemicals used in everyday products ranging from

038electronic devices to fire retardants they're known as forever chemicals one of the chemical of pfoa was found in the suit water reservoir and it's been linked to health hazards including pregnancy complications liver damage and cancer it is a it is a carcinogenic to humans I've been raising this alert about this the quality of water there and our presence with having conversations and I believe Dr Rey shared that he met with someone at suat before but I don't think they're taking us seriously our staff and our children I mean even if we're not bringing up the fact that there's residents there Chila Vista the city of should be looking at that as all but we have a responsibility to our staff and our students that are drinking that water that's very much of a concern to

039me and I've been it's been a for almost a year if not longer that I've been raising this concern since it's came up to our attention and I just don't know what else president newart that we can do to press this matter to an urgency level we're drinking carcinogens Dr Reyes yeah that's a so it's a complicated issue because we uh we're two different entities uh however what comes to mind possibly is if this the board's direction is to um write uh some kind of resolution um I don't know if that's the route that the board once is there like a season desist type of uh approach we have legal this is serious this is they're drinking water the children run to their or they refill their thermoses our our staff is bringing their water

040jugs to fill up the water and I it's just rather serious so so when you say assistant assist some that they have to do I don't know somebody figure I'm not the expert I just know that this is very very serious we can't keep drinking this water can we look into the fact that and I and I trust your information trusty Ling said R this just um the the quality I I've got to imagine that they're not going to push forward the the levels what they're using I know with the air quality they have certain levels the that the county puts out with regard to um health risks when we have those pollutants in the air do we have something with regard to water that we can look into yeah I'm just I know we're

041not experts in that are there why I'm posing is is just for the fact that we're completely separate entities we have no but we're the customer we pay we pay water bills right so not sure if we if we go directly with them or maybe have conversations with the city or do a resolution so what would the resolution really do just stop it so a resolution uh is declares a stance on how the district feels about a certain topic do we need to go present it at one of their do you need to go present it at one of their meetings how does that work so that they're informed that they need to take action so one of the things that we could do is if we if the board again this is for discussion

042for the board to give me direction if we do a resolution uh and I would like to know what type of uh what would be on the resolution and based on that I bring It Forward uh the board um edits it or or or provides additional comments uh approves it and then a copy of the resolution can be sent to that agency do we have how many schools are do we do does a Sweetwater Authority that's quite a few right don't they have Bonita it's yeah all the most webites most of the Westside schools and then I imagine that Sweetwater schools is also impacted by this um so maybe uh it's a conversation that we need to have not just with the Sweetwater Authority it's also a conversation we need to have with the city

043about what are they going to do to mitigate this because yes they can try to mix water and to lower the the levels but at the end of the day uh there has to be a stronger filtration system in place and I don't know if filtration system at a school side is coste effective uh but there might be a way to in conversations with Sweetwater uh School District uh to do a class acing lawsuit because if we don't Sue they're going to sue us the the community I would if I was sitting on that other side and drinking that water I'd be really angry I agree with you truste tomayo we have to look at this in a more serious manner because it is a serious health risk so I think the direction at this

044point would be let's have a conversation with Sweetwater school district and the city to see what uh Pathways we can have to mitigate the toxicity levels of the water that has been found and with with the mindset that uh if there's no resolution we would consider a class auction lawsuit yeah obviously if they're willing to be part of that right yeah if they're willing correct right thank you trust uh m p um are we doing any testing or where where are we with that so we have our environmental consultant TNT that we just met with earlier this or last week um we just had to identify on the maps the areas that we're testing so we'll be moving forward with testing the water at the school sites um but because there's so many tests that

045we have to do we'll be testing them about six or seven at a time so we'll be having some results I do know that um if you're only looking for lead and you don't find lead you think it's okay okay I think you need to speak with um the analysts that came across these uh these this carcinogenics to see what they're looking for and it probably needs to be a little broader than uh than so they'll be searching for lead and any other pathogens carcinogens too thank you thank you Mark I don't mind foring that report also I'll I'll or I'll search for it too right because they were also TNT was all supposed be checking the air quality as far in regards to the the the Tijuana sewage coming over right yeah how soon

046do you think Dr Reyes this would some we get some results well so a lot of it depends on the other agencies so I can set up meetings with uh I can connect with uh both the city and Sweetwater this week now based those conversations then it would be the next step uh not sure what where they're going to be with this or where the city is with this or or other neighboring uh district is with this and then based on that I can so in two weeks we have another board meeting so I can give you an update on where are we with the conversations that we had with the city and with food water and in the meantime since we're aware of this should we not be notifying our schools to have I

047don't know what but we can't let them keep drinking the water when we know that there's some there's an issue with them what can we do to I mean obviously it has to be a managed message but communi need to know so so we need to be careful with messaging the community don't drink the water because we're not the authority of the water so so uh that's yeah that that's why I was asking with regard about the what standards qual standards of quality are is a Sweetwater Authority using to get the water have us drinking the water there're still and you know what I'll do is I'm also going to uh schedule a meeting with folks from Sweetwater Authority because we got to be able to connect with them as well right you should speak

048to the he's the one that's been quoted he's an izes the water he's the one that was quoted and I do agree that the messaging probably should come from the S Water Authority uh about if they found this or if these numbers hold then they should be messaging people on what steps to take to protect themselves um so I think it would be great to have that conversation with whoever in Sweetwater Authority or or the Justin Brazil director of water quality for sweet waterer Authority um and then have maybe work with them to if notifications need to go out to have them send those notifications that way we can take appropriate steps at the school site level on whatever that messaging is is it we provide bottle water we provide additional filters or whatever it

049is uh but based on their communication okay I had a question on the report the environmental report um how when do we get results and when can we find how bad it is the environmental report the one that is being done by Mr pong while he said six to seven schools at a time and that's going to take I guess over the course of time it's going to be lengthy right I mean I believe it takes about two weeks to get results on on a specimen thank you and what we can do is so correct yes yes and as we get the results uh Mr B do me a favor as we get the results for each cohort of six schools go ahead and put them on the on as you get the results put

050them on the board update that way you're you're getting every week so yeah different schools that's good any other questions or comments regarding the safety report from Mr Romeo all right report on the results of the California school dashboard Miss Morales thank you president Ugarte I'd like to introduce Mrs Estrada our coordinator of assessment accountability and teacher induction who will be providing us the report on the dashboard tonight thank you Miss Morales good evening president muak Board of Trustees Dr and cabinet this evening I am presenting an overview of the 2024 uh California school dashboard which will be highlighting key indicators and what they mean for our district the data that you will see in this presentation is representative of the 2023 2024 school year the school dashboard is California's accountability system and tracks how

051well districts and schools meet the needs of diverse students using various performance measures the dashboard also helps to identify strength and areas for improvement and determin eligibility for areas of support such as differentiated assistance through local control funding formula and additional targeted support and Improvement or atsi through every student uh every student succeeds act there are two new additions to the California dashboard this year the first one being science is now a state indicator on the dashboard and we have a new student group of long-term English Learners that you will see um on the dashboard it's important to understand how the colors are determined and so when we're looking at the performance there are two factors status which is ranging from very low to very high and change ranging ranging from declined significantly to increased

052significantly the performance level or color is determined by the point in which these two factors inter intersect when looking at a dashboard 5x5 grid we do want to be cautious and not to look at the color alone because growth does matter for example a school with medium performance that is improving is more promising than one with high performance that is significantly declining in short the 5x5 grid provides valuable context but growth and change over time are just as important when we are assessing progress so there are two sets of indic ators on the California dashboard and the first one um is our state indicator and these key uh assess key areas like academic performance English language proficiency chronic absenteeism and suspension uh these help identify the strengths and areas of Need for us to focus

053on not just as a district or just as or a school but also at the student group level the second set of indicators are our local indicators the local indicators include basic conditions implementation of State Standards parent engagement School climate and access to a broad course of study local indicators are self-reported through the use of a reflection tool and focus on aspects that are locally important for Student Success the local indicators also um serves to inform our planning with our local control and accountability plan California Edco does require specific student groups to be reported to the dashboard and by looking at these groups separately it helps us to identify achievement gaps and track progress for underserved or historically marginalized students and populations there are some indicators that you will see will not have a color

054assigned to it and this is usually because the student group size is um smaller than 30 so for privacy reasons they do not report um the color on those okay now it's important to note the differences between looking at test results for elpac and Casp on the public reporting site and then the comparison of that to the California dashboard the test results for California's assessment website reports the number and percent of student students within each achievement level assigned a one two three or four the California dashboard reports the average of all students distance from standard scores and that is based on students who are continuously enrolled on the dashboard distance from standard measures how far a student's performance is from meeting the state's threshold it shows the distance between that score known as level three

055or standard met here's an example fifth grade math a score of 2528 is needed to meet standard or a level three as indicated by the green arrow on the screen if a student scores 2500 then they are 28 points below that threshold and their distance from standard is a negative 28 if a student scores 2568 they are 40 Point 40 points above the threshold with a distance from standard of positive 40 and so the way that you will see this reported on the California dashboard is each of the indicator cards here's an example up on the screen for you will report the average of all students distance from standard so in this case this example is 4.5 points above standard so now that I've giving you a little background on how the dashboard works I'm

056happy to present to you our results for cvd on the 24 uh 2024 School dashboard and again this the data that you will see in these slides is coming from last year 23 24 school year so the dashboard landing page gives us a clear view of a performance for district and schools here you will see CV esd's overview which includes State indicators local indicators and population and demographic information the 2024 dashboard State indicators for cvd reveal notable progress and areas for Focus English language arts saw an improved M marked by a green indicator with increased score of 8.8 points above the distance from standard math maintained its performance indicated in yellow and English learner progress is at 49% reflected with an orange indicator the science indicator does not yet include color for the 2024 dashboard

057chronic absenteeism has decreased by 7.2% with both chronic absenteeism and suspension rates showing yellow indicators these results offer valuable insights as we continue to support Student Success across the district for our local indicators the dashboard indicates cvesd has met standard for all areas of the local indicators including Basics implementation of Standards parent and family engagement local climate survey and access to a broad course of study as I mentioned earlier the 5x5 placement grid is used to assess or display the performance of schools and uh districts across various indicators this grid combines current performance or status with year-over-year changes and categorize that information into five levels blue green yellow orange and red the 5x5 grid that you see here uh is showing English language arts and the placement of our schools cvd English language arts 5x5

058report shows that we have zero schools in red also none of cvd schools are in the very low status we have 10 schools in Orange nine in yellow 17 in green and six in blue overall cvesd as a district has increase at the medium level with the green indicator assigned here you see the 5x5 placement grid for mathematics CV's grid reports that zero schools are in red again none of our schools are in the very low status 14 of our schools are in orange 11 in yellow 15 in green and two in blue overall as a district CV cvd maintained the medium status in mathematics with a yellow indicator assigned so at this time I'd like to present a comparison between the 2023 and 2024 uh dashboard the numbers that you see in each one

059of these little quadrant squares represents the number of our schools that fell Within in that area in 2023 cvesd had 26 schools for English language arts achieve either high or very high status and increased or significantly increased in English language arts in 2024 we had 32 schools achieve either high or very high status and increased or significantly increased in English language arts as a district Ela was our focus last year and the positive change indicated here on the 5x5 grid highlights the impact of that effort let's take a look at the same for mathematics in 2023 cvesd had 27 schools achieve either high or very high and increase or significantly increased in mathematics in 2024 we had 24 schools achieve either high or very high status and increase or significantly increased as a district we

060acknowledge areas for growth in mathematics and are hard at work strategically and intentionally addressing these challenges through School site plans for student achievement turnaround leadership plans at every School site the focus of mathematics you will hear later on is embedded within our lcap and we have ongoing professional development for teachers in the area of mathematics happening actually finishing up this week at this time I'd like to highlight two of our schools um and put a spotlight on just two examples of the amazing work that's happening throughout our district um we're proud to share these examples where significant growth has been achieved uh through the focused efforts of not only our students our teachers but also our administrators the first school I'd like to highlight is Harborside Elementary in 2023 Harborside Elementary had seven indicators in

061red impacting five student groups in 2020 before that has decreased to just one student group the comparison Graphics show a significant decrease in Orange an increase in yellow reflecting Positive Growth Harbor Side tigers have made impressive strides increasing 7.4 points in math and 13.7 points in language arts while also reducing their chronic absenteeism rate by 11.3% as a result of their hard work in progress harbor side is no longer identified as an atsi [Applause] school the next school that I would like to highlight is Valley Vista Elementary in 2023 Valley Vista Elementary had five indicators for student groups in red and 2024 they have none that's great the 5x5 comparison Gra graphic show a significant decrease in Orange and increase in yellow along with four groups now in blue and three in green the Valley

062Vista Vikings have made an outstanding progress increasing 7.4 points in math and 28.1 points in English language arts by also reducing their chronic absenteeism by 11.3% we're incredibly proud of all of their accomplishments and I think they deserve an Applause as well now I'd like to share with you a local comparison of school districts in our area out of the seven local districts listed cvesd stands out as the only district with a green indicator in English language arts and the only District that is above standard for English language arts by 8.8 points our district also had the highest increase in English language arts among our local districts Rising 4.3 points in mathematics we maintained with the yellow indicator are and are the closest District to meeting the standard just 16 points away versus local districts

063ranging from 39 to 84 points when looking at science cvesd again is the closest to meeting standard nine points away compared to local districts ranging from 12 to 25 points while six out of the seven districts list declined in the English language progress indicator or LP cvesd has the highest percentage of students making progress at 48.6% in conclusion the data uh presented on the California dashboard provides us with valuable information to impact our goals and priorities as a district and directly is related to our planning around our LC cap which you will hear more about uh this evening but at this time I thank you for your time and welcome any questions about the California dashboard questions on the board or comments go ahead oh could we have a copy of the PowerPoint please absolutely

064yes we'll make sure that gets sent thank you yeah board update Friday update sounds good I just want to say congratulations thank you amazing job yeah yes congratulations the congratulations goes to the teachers the staff the classified the supporting the principles principl trying to catch everything I really appreciate you and I really I that's wonderful you that's what we've been asking for but I always also want to see in the future I don't know at what point you can is what are we doing for those School schools that are struggling that um that we know we get that average up there is because there's some schools that are really excelling and then there's these other schools that need some more support if you could share with us what are we doing to support those schools

065so like I mentioned all of the data that was presented here is looked over and is strategically and intentionally included into our lcap so you will hear some of that information later on this evening but um one of the things that is happening is um site leaders have all created a turnaround leadership plan looking specifically at the data reflective of their School site and having that um focus for example if there's a school that may have been uh declining slightly in language arts they may have selected that as their focus so they're working with their teachers professional learning Cycles um uh going through classrooms or en cuss walks might be focused on that too um we are digging into Data to identify Trends as you can see there's a lot there so um we're happy

066to provide you with more in an update as well right and is there a a mechanism that specific schools can reach out to you directly and say you know what we need a total makeover come in here well schools can reach out to me anytime they like I have an open door policy but I think that is reflective of all of our teams as well but and I can speak for instructional Services um we work very closely with our sites and um I know that there's a lot happening um with Miss Morales as well so that's a great question it's a a core Focus right now of our leadership and learning team um I just want to also say that we have one of the principles Valley vista's principles Miss Roman is here so I'm

067going to recognize you I know Mr abio couldn't come tonight um but one of the things that we've worked really hard to create is a support structure for our leaders that then hopefully trickles down to the staff members of the school sites the teachers and the classified staff so what we do at the beginning of the year through a common data analysis protocol we look at the data of all of the school site with our school leaders and then our senior directors who coach um with me and then our enus coaches they develop intervention plans that we call them tlap plans but they're turnaround leadership action plans they're based on data and actions to be able to support the increase um in whatever area is needed at the school site we also as a leadership

068and learning team we have different levels of support that we give our schools so we really wanted to highlight Herber side tonight because we do think that it is indicative of when we are able to channel our support and our resources we see movement in those schools and so it inspires us to be able to do more and that's the point I was trying to make that that was the direction to do that Focus that makeover and it worked so how can we multiply you guys by a thousand to go out and help those other schools every school has a different Dynamic and that Dynamic may be contributing to them not as excelling as much as they would like to as much as the staff would like them to because the Dynamics the absenteeism the

069the um parents not being engaged and just the different dynamics that happen and hoping to see that that that this action plan get out there more Tom more of the other schools thank you congratulations to the staff the classified and the certificated and our principles thank you very much yeah congratulations to um harborsite it's it's amazing to see that positive change uh for a school that um needed additional help need uh needed additional resources and to focus and and think outside the box a little bit on how we're delivering instruction and how we're supporting uh the students there so congratulations to the staff and to the to the principal same with uh the principal is here maybe she wants to share uh a little bit of what OT yes I'm going to put her on

070her spot I mean let's have her her five minutes of of Fame right we know it's not the water so what what is it that you're doing that is magical over there it's got jokes I got jokes it's absolutely um the teams that we have it's our school team and it's also with the collaboration with our district leaders and their team um at our school in particular for previous from previous years we've worked closely with even our district resource teachers um we are a dual Lang schools wide and so there's been a lot of good work but it all comes down to working collaboratively and working as a team well thank you for for that hard work and please extend our our gratitude to to your team and and let them know that we see

071you and we value that work that you're doing every day to change the lives of those students that are in your schools and and hopefully we can use what you we learn from your tool School to impact other other schools that need additional help absolutely thank you so much thank you right now I can't tell you how happy I am because it's it's coming to the end of not the end but seeing the fruition of the hard work that collaboration when we talk about Community Schools and we talk about the spirit of it and we talk about sustaining it we are sustaining it without that the funding necessary through collaboration and both I know Miss all all of our labor leaders have talked about that collaborative uh effort whether it's PD for classified that Miss

072Reed talks about whether it's the collaboration that our principal lead talks about and I know that for all the time that I've been here Miss Martinez has talked about that and really work to get that leadership and and when you see that at a site these are the results and so I it's nice to be here in this second term to see where that started because I came here during the pandemic when things were no buo and uh to see that these schools and to see that we don't have the red that we are moving even if it's in one particular area um you know I saw some sites did really well in English language arts which shows that focus makes a difference but then they maybe weren't so they didn't do so well in

073mathematics and so I hope we we refocus those those efforts and I hear from other um from teachers and from principles that the support that the district is giving with the encest walks and having that support available to them being able to call has really made a difference so thank you for all of your work um you made this very easy to understand I mean I can speak for myself um and we we very much appreciate the the work thank you [Applause] all right we are going to move to item 13 um both A and B and it is uh the first reading and possible second reading for the renewal of the aroyo Vista Charter School petition Mr Romero thank you uh it's our pleasure um to bring forward our AO Visa Charter School leadership

074today uh as a charter school who that is a dependent charter school we have uh agreements that are made and brought forward to the board um in two processes in the past we've looked at these and made it all in one day but it's up to the board on how we proceed so uh it's with pleasure today that I bring forward um Mary Margaret thank you good evening Dr Reyes cvesd board president Ugarte trustee Dominguez Cervantes trustee Ramirez Dominguez trustee too trustee tolston and the cvsd executive cabinet my name is Mary Margaret Landers and I'm honored to be the principal at a Roy of Vista Charter School and the the presenter this evening on behalf of the aroya Vista students families and staff as we share our Charter renewal petition for a 5-year term from

075July 2025 through June 2030 aoy of Vista Charter School opened in 1999 as a district school serving students in grades kindergarten through sixth grade and converted to a charter school in 2002 due to a high level of interest from the community and staff aoya Vista added our dual immersion program in 205 with kindergarten and first grade and continued to add a grade each year until we had a complete strand aoya Vista Charter Middle School opened in 2011 with seventh grade and we added 8th grade in 2012 our English only transitional kindergarten program opened in 2014 we we added a 5050 dual immersion TK program in 2022 to support our youngest Learners interested in our k6 dual immersion program aoya Vista currently serves 914 students in grades TK through 8 18% of our student population come

076from military families we are proud of our military students and thank their families for their service our Target group populations are as follows 16% English Learners 12% students with disabilities 2% Foster homeless and 28% socioeconomically disadvantaged our diverse student population is supported by an amazing teaching staff and in addition a military family life counselor school counselor school psychologist a Special Education team and instructional assistance for academic support the highlights of the aoya Vista program include our Visual and Performing Arts program dual immersion program our middle school and our teams program for grades 1 through six all students participate in our Visual and Performing Arts program where they learn from specialists in the area of music drama and visual arts student performances occur throughout the school year for families to enjoy our 9010 dual immersion program

077is a two-way language model designed to develop bilingualism and biliteracy in Spanish and English our middle school provides core subject instruction including Spanish for all students based on language level and a variety of electives including speech and debate kitchen science yearbook space science photography and Outdoor Sports the teams program creates a vibrant Learning Community by bringing together cross-age student groups these teams Foster meaningful relationships promote character development and engage students in community projects our Charter renewal process has has been a 2-year Endeavor School staff worked in small groups to review each element of the charter and made suggestions on changes community members provided input on priorities through surveys and during parent leadership group meetings our Charter rewrite team compiled all the input from stakeholders and made revisions and additions many of the additions are legislative

078requirements from the state of California those additions will be highlighted as each element is presented the highest priorities for our community based on survey results were our Visual and Performing Arts program student academic support and our dual immersion and middle school programs our mission as members of the ABCs staff are to foster a vibrant Learning Community where collaboration communication and relationships are our da daily Focus we are Guided by our team of philosophy together everyone achieves more as Educators we are partners with our families to ensure their children reach their full potential as Scholars and citizens we recognize that each student comes to us with a unique set of experiences abilities and needs and we actively work to ensure that all students receive the resources support and opportunities they need to thrive we aspire to

079nurture Learners who engage in critical thinking Embrace creativity and approach challenges with flexibility and resilience by fostering a growth mindset we Empower students to become adaptable and Innovative thinkers who are prepared to navigate an Ever Changing World our comprehensive TK through e8th grade program nurtures The Social emotional and physical development of every student fostering a balanced approach to achieving academic Excellence by prioritizing Reading Writing and problem solving across all academic disciplines we equip students with the necessary skills to clarify their thinking process ideas and communicate their understanding this Focus prepares students to become lifelong independent Learners and empowers them with the skills skills needed for future success in higher education and the workforce a royya Vista Charter School encompasses many programs we were honored to receive a Department of Defense grant for a steam Studio

080due to our military connected population last year our studio is opening this month in an integrated space in our library and our mobile carts can also be used in classrooms students use the design thinking process which incorporates five key elements empathize Define ideate prototype and test to develop solutions to problems staff members have received professional development from The cvesd Innovation team and our students are excited to create solutions to a variety of problems our Visual and Performing Arts program continues to expand as we started a beginning band program for our middle school students this semester students were excited to make their first sounds on flutes trumpets trombones and the tuba just last week our dual immersion program has expanded due to community interest and we now have two di classes in kindergarten 1 second and

081third grade a Roy of Vista Charter School measures student outcomes through clearly defined goals that align with our curriculum and adhere to national state and local standards our short short-term objectives and annual goals are aligned with our lcap and guide our efforts to enhance student achievement for all students with a particular Focus On underperforming Target groups student monitoring meetings with teachers and administration provide time to discuss student progress and develop action plans to ensure student growth in academics and social emotional learning aoya Vista is committed to a team approach when making School decisions all certificated staff members serve on one of our three governing commun committees our committees include CIA curriculum instruction and assessment mtss multi-tiered systems of support and Partnerships classified team members are welcome to join any school committee our governing board is

082team Council and we have parody and with staff and community members to ensure that all decisions are jointly decided our community members meet the legislative requirement and we will welcome a cvesd member to our board if appointed School administration works collaboratively with the cvesd HR department on behalf of all staff members with regards to employee qualifications retirement benefits and return rights since all staff members are cvesd employees this is a unique partnership with cvsd based on an agreement determined in 2002 when ABCs converted from a district school to a charter school ABCs Administration follows the cve and CV CEO contracts on behalf of all staff members there are many new health and safety requirements required by the state of California for the upcoming school years ABCs will comply with all new legislative requirements starting in

083July 2025 aoy Vista will include a sui Suicide Prevention policy for our middle school students in our comprehensive school safety plan prior to July 2026 ABCs will provide an all-gender rest room for voluntary student use mental health education sexual health education and HIV prevention education will be taught explicitly during physical education Health classes for all seventh and eth graders beginning with the 2025 2026 school year at the beginning of each school year ABCs will distribute a notice to families addressing California's child gun access prevention mention laws and laws related to firearm safety as required by the state of California a Roy Vista Charter School seeks to maintain a racial ethnic special education and English learner balance within its student population admission preference is given to students within the ABCs boundary area in compliance with the

084cvesd schools of choice policy parents and Guardians May request a Zone transfer to ABCs for grades TK through six from other schools in cvd a royya Vista Charter Middle School admission is based on a lottery system with priority given to students residing in the ABCs boundary area legal requirements are currently implemented at ABCs with a random drawing for interested students for our middle school and dual immersion programs ABCs Administration works collaboratively with the cvesd budget and accounting departments to ensure that all allocated Charter funds are spent according to State guidelines within the respective timelines ABCs is grateful for the partnership with Lisa Waller cvesd Charter accountant the collaboration and partnership assists School administration with meeting funding guidelines and completing state required reporting a Roy aista Charter School meets the requirement of fiscal responsibility for our

085five-year renewal our fiscal plan for the years 2024 through 2027 shows that we have the funds necessary to meet Staffing requirements and program interests of our school Community as ABCs navigates changes in Grants and funding sources in the upcoming years our school team will ensure that programs continue based on community and staff input ABCs performed above standard in both English language arts and math in 2023 as shown by our dashboard data aoya Vista is extremely proud of our continued academic achievement with our 2020 for CP scores 79.8% of our students met or exceeded standards in English language arts continuing with the highest score on the dashboard and 58.9% of our students met or exceeded in math continuing with a score of Green we were 51.6% above standard in English language arts and 16.2 points above

086standard in math for 2024 our school team is focused on improving our math scores with targeted instruction in all grades we recognize the needs of our English Learners to continue to grow in all academic areas we did receive a score of Green on the dashboard for 2024 but acknowledge that only 50% of our Els are showing progress AOA Vista will continue to fund a full-time English language instructional assistant to support students identified as newcomers emerging and expanding English Learners our team knows that with a combination of designated and integrated ELD in addition to small group support our students will continue to grow in their acquisition of the English language chronic absenteeism is an area of continued growth for aoy Vista our school team works with families to ensure all students are at school on time

087every day to ensure their success aoy of the charter school celebrates our areas of strength and is committed to Improvement in the previously mentioned areas before I answer questions from the Board of Education I'd like to recognize the AO Vista staff and community members in attendance here tonight in support of this petition I'm guessing we have no speakers on this item thank you um any comments or questions from the board I have a comment um I just want to say congratulations um I guess we're telling on myself that I'm proud to be part of that community and I acknowledge and just like we did with the previous dashboard presentation you all do an amazing job a Royal Vista and the rest of these schools are something that we are so grateful for personally as we've

088told our story we've received all of the support and everything we've ever needed for my family and my son to thrive so thank you and again congratulations thank you um I have a comment also congratulations on your I wrote down um 79.8 on Ela and 58.5 um on math so those are really good numb numbers and whatever you guys are doing we need to multiply that to the rest of our schools um and for the English Learners what is one of the um barriers you see um and I see that you you you mentioned that you guys actually actually bringing in special specialty help um but do you want to just elaborate elaborate yeah um yes of course thank you for the question um I think one of the things that we do see with

089our English Learners our dual immersion program is absolutely exceptional um but we are relooking at how English instruction is taught within that program um to really ensure that the reading foundational skills that students need in the area of literacy start in kindergarten um it is a 9010 model um and we believe wholeheartedly in that model for our students um but there's some things that we need to re refine and relook at as far as ensuring that students are receiving foundational skills um starting in those primary grades um when we look at our school data for upper grades um more through third grade through sixth grade um It's a combination we um are located in East Lake but we welcome newcomers to our school just like every other school in the district um and so we

090have brought in additional instructional assistance um to support the academic achievement of those students um and for our students that are still expanding their language skills um in Upper Grade English only classes um we have an amazing full-time English um language instructional assistant um a royal funds additional time for her so that she's not just supporting um lpac testing um but she is able to support small group instruction um when it's not the testing window um right now obviously it is elpac testing season so we're doing testing in the morning um and she is still working with small groups of students in the afternoon sounds great I'd like to hear a bit a little bit more about the instructional assist that you're using to support your teachers absolutely so a royya Vista um as a

091charter schol is very fortunate to receive our own lcap funding um and so one of the goal areas of our lcap is academic support um so aoya fista funds four full-time instructional assistance to support students in kindergarten through sixth grade in the areas of English language arts and Mathematics um we've written very targeted goals for our elap um in order to use that funding to support those additional adults um those adults are supervised um by the classroom teachers they push in support in all classrooms um teachers prepare additional materials for students that are striving to meet grade level standards um and so the classroom teacher is still the supervisor of the instructional assistant but the instructional assistant is in the classroom working with small groups of students um that still need additional support in ela

092and Mathematics thank you and thank you for sharing such details about your programs appreciate it you're welcome any other board comments or questions no U but I I do want to say thank you um my my son was um part of ay shter uh for the middle school so he benefited from from that program and now thanks to all of you um he's very successful at um Olympian High School um I think that you have shown that you deserve this renewal normally I would make the motion but being that Tristy Tolson is uh resident there do I get to say anything no I just wanted to thank you for such a detailed a very thorough job of presenting the information um and if someone would like to make the motion to approve the chart renewal

093I make the motion to approve the charter with a comment my grandson started there in 1999 and he went on to be a nuclear engineer thank you uh the other two grandkids are one the second his brother got a full scholarship at USD full academic scholarship the other ones two more they went on to college one's already finished and uh works for a law firm the other one is finishing up College thank you aroyo of course and so I make my motion to approve this Charter I second moved by truste Dominguez santes seconded by trusty tolston all those in favor I motion carries unanimously [Applause] [Music] congratulations item 13B the first reading and possible adoption of board policy 4331 which is new Personnel staff development administrative and supervisory Personnel Mr pong thank you president Ugarte

094as you just mentioned that this is a new board policy being proposed to the board for um reading and possible action to approve this um it uh shows the value that um professional development brings to our um administrative and supervisory personnel as well as the option of individual memberships at the board's approval are there any questions from the board or comments regarding the staff development administrative and supervisory Personnel policy I I have a comment I just thought we were doing this already are we right I mean codifying it all right well thank you I motion to approve that requires a motion move by truste linga svantes seconded by vice president the Mayo all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously all right um item 10n needs to be pulled before we do the consent

095is my understanding um the staff has said there needs to be a so are they pulling or with drawing we're draw what are we doing with this are we 10n we need to discuss it okay so from the consent okay so we are at the um consent calendar we're going back to item and yeah yeah yeah I've got so the St office let me get through the okay so we are going to um pull items but before I um take the board's pulled items staff has pulled item 10 C item 10 L 10 C all of 10 C it's been and there's one section 10 n so 10 C 10 L 10 n and 10 y have all been pulled by the staff and then any other pulls from the board truste um do Ramirez

096Dominguez anything you're pulling I was gonna I was pulling C so okay we'll get is there a special subsection or k k okay CK trusty tolston yes I wanted to pull 10 E 10 e TR Dominguez cantes 10 C subsection CD uhuh which is Page 6 of 20 and CK okay page 10 11 of 20 okay of and then 10 D and that's it oh excuse me uh CK did I say CK you said CK and C right then 10d please okay thank you anything else I mean 10 C is being pulled as as a whole so um but particularly job descriptions okay all right so do I have a motion to approve the consent calendar with um the polls of 10 C in all the subsections d e l n and y so moved

097second moved by vice president Deo seconded by trusty Dominguez santes all those in favor I I any opposed all right motion carries unanimously um before we get started Let's uh on 10 C staff pulled the item so Dr Reyes can we go over the reason for the staff pull yes uh I need to uh or Mr on on the on the job description for lead buyer there's a correction it states there there will be no additional funding that is incorrect there's a fiscal impact of 8600 8600 8600 annually fiscal impact for the lead buyer what page is that's page 16 and 17 that that would be um oh 16 you see you'll see the description there and you said 8600 annually 8600 annually impacts but you don't list that on the job description do you

098that's why he's pulling it to but no job description list that right but it's I think the impact on the actual front page is what you yes so it's not on the job description it's actually on the on the job description uh where it says on the explanation on explanation or got it okay okay then we have item c d is that uh just no C item is that what you pulled CD okay CD I think what page was that that uh CD starts on page six of 20 the job descriptions and I believe trustee Tayo also pulled that and uh in regards to lead buyer I wasn't clear on who the lead buyer reports to Dr Rees Mr Romero uh with uh allowance Dr reard you like Mark pong to the lead buyer reports

099to the director of purchasing warehouse and Publications I think the job description is lacking that information most other ones you you state who they report to if you could amend that I got it Dr AES I'm Sorry Miss s repeat who the lead buyer reports to normally the um job description States who they report to or under the supervision of and this one didn't state it Mr Romero yes I we can update that for okay okay okay and social worker counselor uh the job description itself starts on page 18 and 19 of 20 that's just the job description itself but it's over on page six um I can't follow the second dot Point help me understand that it says lead for school- attending District I'm not sure I understand what that dot Point means it's

100the second dot point maybe I'm just not getting it the Spanish is coming into my I'm sorry what page page 18 under essential job functions second bullet are the lead for the school it says lead for school- attending District committees I don't know what that means oh lead so it's a the is going to be the lead for school attending District committees it's this part right so so yeah I mean it it doesn't start at lead lead is what was added it starts as acts as the school-based mtss lead for school attending District committees so the ax isn't highlighted because it's not new language I see okay well the Spanglish and me came in and it just couldn't connect thank you and then um and my next question on that is this an on-site position

101is that an administrator because that scares me I would like to see the psychologist or uh social workers be on the actual schools will they be are going they're going to be assigned like okay on Mondays are at this school or Tuesdays on Wednesdays at that school what what's the idea Mr yes these are on School site positions yes okay my biggest concern was not taking them away from the students because I hear tell they are so needed out there so and the next one is the program specialist special education the job description is on page 14 and 15 of 20 I just wanted to be clear is this another administrator or is this going to being onsite we need more counselors and psychologists so I wanted to make sure that I was clear before

102before I vote Cas yes this is a new position it is an administrator that's going to be supporting School sites and teachers on campus so instead of aossa they'll be out in classroom supporting teachers so they won't be assigned here they'll be out at the school they'll be assigned to the district office but they will be supporting School sites on a regular basis so so so their office let's say it's here but they'll be dispatched to school sites every day to support teachers okay can we get feedback on how that works out because um they just need the help at the school site so much so if I we can get feedback on how that's coming you know and actually survey the the schools and ask them is this working out not working out what's

103going on here help us be a better help absolutely the intend is to support School sit so yes thank you Sharon that's all on CD CD did you yes uh so earlier we heard that the um school secretaries are going to take over uh buying why do we need a lead buyer if the secretaries are taking out buying Dr Reyes so Mr Romo can you share with the board and clarify that uh what the current job description is and what it entails and how [Music] um the this new position the lead buyer position is different from what the current job job job description is for the cies yes so uh there's multiple layers involved in in buying and so our lead buyer position and I appreciate the opportunity to clarify this uh we still have

104um buying that takes place at a grand level uh so with our our size of our district one of our greatest assets is our ability to buy in large scales so the school secretaries will still be responsible for the ordering if you will where the lead buyer is still responsible for the overall buying of of the product so for example one of our biggest uh issues that we have are supplies like regularly they toilet paper or or whatever every School site buying toilet paper individually cost is expensive right but think of it as like Costco right we're we're Costco for each individual School sites we're able to purchase a large amount of items and then these schools can then buy individually from our great purchases so we still have those needs also at our need

105we also have like our warehouse that our lead buyer provides opportunities for products that we purchase in bulk here so at the district office lead buyer also hopefully the goal is that we get the best value when we're buying products such as like computers and things like that they'll also have the oversight of making sure that those items are not just ordered and secured but then transported and and make it their way back to our school sites so there's many levels of uh layers that are included in this but the the the need of a district R size to have someone who's overseeing that is huge one of the things that we're also going to be making sure since our schools are going to be taking more responsibility is having that person go to our

106school sites and train so if someone has an issue with an order or something that needs to be uh procured the lead buyer can actually go out there and that's why we added that to the second page you'll see that the training and oversight and and understanding of that is being added to the job description so the I understand the the position of the lead buyer now the school secretary the way to you explain it and the way I understood it was that there's they're still going to buy but they buy in to us not to directly to Staples or two ways so yes one absolutely through us we'll be able to secure large orders of of big big items so some of the things like I talked about like the cleaning supplies and things

107like that right those are huge but when we need oneoff items you know something that's like $100 to speed up the process we're absolutely going to allow schools to order from from you know Office Depot Amazon things like that to get the products to the school sites fast um but we're also going to need training on how to oversee that and make sure that there's basically some checks and balances on that system to make sure that they're working out one of the things I do want to be clear so there's you mentioned um our secretaries they're going to be responsible and it's in their job description for the ordering our custodians are responsible for the unpacking and and storing so it's actually and that's still that's not a new thing to our job description it's

108been in the job descriptions in the past but it's really multiple people that are going to be performing some of those those duties and we'll be working with CV uh CEO to make sure that the workload is addressed it's it's something that we're we're we want to prioritize the quickness of products getting to our school sites and if there's opportunities for us to you know like um understand the The increased workload you know I'll I'll sure uh sure uh agela will address it with us okay I have other questions but probably not for this item so thank you item CK truste Ramirez Dominguez yes uh for the Consultants um I see first Jewish Family Services will provide parent education curriculum to Community Schools and they're listed um why just this schools Dr Rees Miss uh

109Casey so other schools can reach out to them but they they're they Contracting us to support Community Schools for positive parenting classes they're there it's free of charge so I'm happy to look at if other schools would like to participate we can do that clarification on that is it Jewish Family Center or Jewish Family Services Services because it says Center on your yeah it's it's an it's a typo okay than you we can oh I have another question um I see on the bottom Rubicon West uh why are we providing technical support for matter Day St Pas and St Roso Lima Dr Rees uh so we're we're not providing so money goes through us uh to them so what happens is uh students that should be going to our district actually attend those schools private

110schools so there's a partial amount of funding that follows the students so we're sort of like the caretakers of that of that funding so as they use it we release it so it's their money so what students are able to is this something that parents just come up and say I want my child then matter day you pay for it no no no no no it's for services then matter day specific services that there's guidelines of services that they can use the money for not for not for tuition we're not talking about tuition for services for the student and so we're the caretakers of that fund of those funds and then we just release it to pay for that so we're sort of like the caretakers of that money can you give could you give

111an example so we better Mr Ro can you give an example so this contract is actually for professional learn professional development services for the teachers at the school so this is a federal fund title two and with federal funds we always have to provide Equitable Services they call it so um because this private schools within our boundary we have to provide a Equitable share um based on enrollment of the funding to those private schools so they're utilizing it for this professional learning opportunity I have another question um is this an on ongoing like every year we're renewing this money for this certain schools and are there any other private schools that could use these funds Dr re yes yes so uh there's x amount of money that each school has depending on the students that

112they have and uh they can use it throughout the year for different uh reasons and until the money is gone their amount is gone so it could be sen Pas it could be S Rosal Lima it could be yeah different private schools so my question was are there any other schools other than these three getting money for the professional development so I believe there's other so almost every board meeting there's uh or every other board meeting there's schools that actually use it yeah yes thank you trust Dominguez serantes did you pull this one also yes yes uh just one question in regards to Stapleton Enterprises Incorporated I was just curious as to which general obligation Bond we're speaking about it's on page 13 Dr Rees so is that for the HVAC yes M Mr P

113Tiffany this project at Tiffany Elementary is coming from measure VV thank think it was just a typle because most of the other items you're calling out which Bond thank you I believe that's all of the pulls from item uh C I'll um entertain a motion to accept item 10c motion to approve item 10 C second moved by truste Dominguez herant seconded by vice president the Mayo all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously item 10 D truste Dominguez santes yes adopt resolution designating March as women's History Month in cvd cvsd I'd like to recommend an amended version um recommend go ahead recommend on on I uh the fourth whereas the second line item I'm recommending that it read whereas women of diverse backgrounds have served as leaders in the front line Forefront of social

114change so you're recommending no to cross out the word Progressive correct okay and then any other the seventh whereas the last line to replace identify with R to read nearly 70 74% of teachers are women because it is a women's History Month so are you motioning are you going to motion to approve with those amendments those amendments do you have a second second okay motion um to approve the resolution with noted revisions um made by truste dominga serantes and seconded by truste Ramirez Dominguez all those in favor say I I all those opposed nay nay any extensions I abstain the motion fails 2 two and one exstension I would like to propose an amendment to the resolution acknowledging the change in what was it the what was your first one the first one was just

115just to remove Progressive where where it would read here it's right here remove the word Progressive on the fourth uh whereas to uh what what do you call it whereas women of a diverse backgrounds have served as leaders in the Forefront of social change just removing Progressive I looked up the word Progressive and it has political implications that's the only reason so I'll make that change and that's it so just the one change the one are you motioning are you making a motion I'm making a motion do you have a second I second motion by vice president Tayo seconded by truste ramz Dominguez all those in favor I I discussion right I still we we already called the vote so um all those opposed nay nay any abstentions I abstain so two to two and

116one abstention motion fails move to approve assis I'll second call for the vote all those in favor of the motion as is a i i i all those opposed nay a all those abstaining I abstain motion fails all right I think we've tried every iteration so all right next item item 10e adopt the resolution acknowledging February as Black History Month um trustee tolston um I just kind of wanted to bring to the attention that February is Black History Month and the reason why I would like to talk about it is because it hits home um my son is of mixed race he is African-American and Hispanic by me um I feel like it's it's very important for us to keep acknowledging every month when we celebrate people from other ethnicities and backgrounds for the contributions

117that they've given to the country and to the world um and with that I was wondering if I could read the resolution may I share the share in the reading share of the reading my grandkids and my sons are black too you want to do it if you want to alternate if you want to go go ahead whereas Black History Month is celebrated every February as tribute to the achievements of African-Americans who have shaped American history from 1619 to the election of the first black President and Vice President of the United States of America in 2008 and 2020 respectively and Beyond and whereas Black History Month is promoted by a yearly theme which for 2025 is African-Americans and labor focusing on the significant contributions black workers have made to the social economic and cultural development

118of the United States throughout history whereas students learn about the history and achievements of black people throughout the school year Black History Month is established in response to the inadequate and oftentimes biased depiction of black history and black communities in history books and schools curricula of the era whereas black people helped develop our nation in countless ways those recognized unrecognized and unrecorded whereas the contributions of black citizens scientists and mentors Educators Farmers Homemakers and explorers of Earth and Sky have been recognized annually during the Black History Month and whereas black citizens have participated in every American effort to secure protect and maintain the essence right and substance of American democracy and and and whereas the study of the contributions of black people will help students think critically judge information related to problems and issues and

119reach conclusions based on on solid evidence and be an opportunity for all students in the district to enrich their educational experience and to deepen their understanding of black history now and whereas the development of the skills learned during Black History Month will contribute to every student becoming an advocate of the rights of the individual the rights of black people and the rights and responsibilities of citizens in democracy now therefore be it resolved that the chil Vista Elementary School District does hereby recognize and celebrate Black History Month during the month of February 2025 and we haven't passed it yet so we're so I will entertain a motion to accept the resolution motion to accept I'll second um all those in favor I I any abstentions or objections motion carries unanimously item 10 L pulled by staff

120Dr Reyes L Mr P Mr B this item this item is for individual memberships for the um California Association of Latino superintendents and administrators with about 71% of our student population being from the this Latina or Latina um demographic we believe that membership for administrators um in this Association would benefit both the district the school sites and the students yeah and I just want to add that uh kalsa is uh it's an organization it's a Statewide organization that provides uh great uh professional development support uh for administrators uh on in in areas such as leadership and uh it is I think well worth our investment for very very very low cost to be able to send 34 student 34 uh administrators to be able to have the yearlong membership is it appropriate to motion to

121approve it's very appropriate anyone on a second second second mooved by truste Dominguez svantes um seconded by trusty Ramirez Dominguez all those in favor I motion carries unanimously item 10n pulled also pulled by staff Dr Reyes so 10n is just a correction on the date it reads November 4 2024 through November 3rd 2025 and it should read February 20th 2025 through November 3rd 2025 okay move to approve with the change is there a second a second mov by vice president DeMayo seconded by truste Dominguez santes all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously all right you need recess please okay we'll take a 10-minute break at 8 810 812 we'll return we we might get out of here in time e e e of item 10 y that was pulled by staff Dr Reyes

122yes uh we're going to be um taking off uh Chapman Santos and cook from the travel from the travel I will entertain a motion to app approve the item with the revision motion to approve second move by trusty Dominguez cantes seconded by truste Ramirez Dominguez all those in favor I motion carries unanimously at this time I would like to welcome Mr Jason reto to announce our newly hired and promoted employees thank you president Ugarte governing board and uh superintendent it's my pleasure today to introduce this evening our newly promoted employees so uh with pleasure I'd like to announce H amim as uh moving from Van Driver to bus driver congratulations Hilda Diana gerero who's moving from noon Duty supervisor to instructional assistant special education congratul Diana Jona Lee en zunza from buyer to buyer Library

123specialist technician congratulations jonali neli O'Hara who's moving from noon Duty supervisor to student and attendant congratulations neli Sylvia pedosa who's moving from payroll specialist one to payroll specialist 2 congratulations Sylvia Dora k jenez who's moving from instructional assistant special education to student attendant congratulations Dora Victoria Ray Reyes who's moving from payroll specialist 2 to payroll specialist 3 congratulations Victoria Arlene Raba who's moving from noon Duty supervisor to instructional assistant congratulations Arlene and finally El Emma Williams who's moving from school secretary to secretary to Executive uh director dor been pleasure working with her the past month she's amazing congratulations Emma and that concludes our uh recently promoted employees thank you public hearings the public hearing section provides the public with an opportunity to address the board on specific items persons wishing to address the board on

124any public hearing items must complete a request to be heard card and submit it to the recording secretary before the start of the meeting speakers are requested to limit their remarks to 3 minutes and speak in a respectful and professional manner the board shall limit the total time for input on each public hearing item to 20 minutes with board consent the president may increase or decrease the time allowed for public comments on each public hearing item depending on the topic and the number of persons wishing to be heard and our first public hearing item is conduct a public hearing on the discontinuance of certain classified services and adopt the resolution on discontinuance of certain classified services for the 2025 excuse me 2025 26 school year Mr Romero so this item is being brought forward uh

125for uh consideration by the board um we conduct our annual uh budget projections based on the needs of the district and our physical responsibilities and for the 25 uh 26 s year we are are going to be eliminating uh some positions and it's the recommendation of the district uh the the leadership at the district that we move forward with these um uh no longer required positions I am now opening the public hearing is there anyone speaking on this matter seeing no one I'm now closing the public hearing this is an action item Madam president what is the projected Savings of this item Dr Rees Mr bong it's approximately 521 th000 thank you I have a question as well I'd like to know in these um positions are there people sitting in those positions and if

126so what um opportunities do they have when this position disappears Mr Romero thank you for uh being given the opportunity to respond to that so the district does prioritize uh making sure that our employees have opportunities to fulfill positions that are open that they were qualified for so as the second largest employer in the city of Chula Vista our District employees over 4,000 employees so we have as you know uh um monthly positions that come available and so we prioritize working to make sure that these people are given opportunities to to move into positions that they're qualified to take as of now are are there employees sitting in those positions or are some of these positions vac it one of them is currently vacant the delivery driver storekeeper one of those positions and and so

127the others they've been contacted and given other opportunities of other vacancies that we're looking to fill how's so yes we have the these employees will be with us until June 30th in their current role so from now and until June 30th upon approval from the board we'll work with those employees and um labor groups if required to make sure that they have opportunities to to stay employed within the district yes based on who these positions are I'm imagining it's with Miss Angela Reed correct Angela you'll be working with and um working very closely to find them positions if they still want to stay on 100% yes thank you thank you I have a question um so just to clarify this positions are being um removed or reduced because they no longer um there's no more

128so I see like noon Duty and I used to be a noon Duty so my question is is the school no longer in need of new duties or Dr Reyes Mr rero great question and so uh one of the things that happens organically is the district based on a ratio that's provided by uh Business Services provides a standard level of how many noon Duties are at every school sites based on a formula and school sites have the opportunity uh to provide more support if needed um but that's an annual decision that's made by that School site and so depending on their needs or maybe their enrollment if their enrollment decreases they may not continue to provide that that new Duty support so these new Duties are being eliminated the positions but the people will have

129opportunities for for jobs in in um neighboring schools thank you this is an action item do we have a motion well we have to move forward with it no well give me the op talk to me I mean technically you can reject it and tell the district to find the money uh or change the formula and stop having the the the school fund positions like this because this happens every year because of that right that the the school decides to fund the position this year and then the next year they decide that that's no longer priority and they or the money had was reduced so they take that position away but that creates a problem because now those people in those positions have seniority and that causes a chain of events a domino effect and

130you start bumping other people based on senority so while that position at a particular school they might not lose the the job somebody else is going to be impacted in a different school because that school brought in instructional Aid and this is something that Miss Angela reading have spoken about is there something we can do about that change that formula Dr re so couple things one is like for tonight I would uh ask that you highly consider approving it because otherwise we're going to be uh over half a million dollars that of of Staffing that we don't need now um one of the things that to look at the formula you have to look at two things so Mr tayu is Absol absolutely correct that uh when when you hire someone with what is called

131soft money which is for example um uh Title One funds for for uh for school sites well they may or may not have the same amount of funds for the for for the following year so that position that the position May either may continue or may not continue or may continue at a different uh instead of being full-time might be part-time so it might change from how it was originated uh originated now on one hand yes by restricting the sites to not be able to hire additional staff it limits this this action to be taken every year there there still might be a reduction just because of attrition uh a natural attrition of students there still might be a need to reduce uh maybe not as much but there there'll be a need to reduce

132however so on one hand yes that will happen but on the other hand it takes away the flexibility of school sites not and and say School site because it's not the principle it's through uh School site Council uh to address the individual needs of that particular site uh and it could be regarding safety or it could be regarding instruction or it could be in regarding many different things that is really hard to almost impossible to for from a district perspective to foresee all those things with 50 schools so by allowing the flexibility of the sites all the sites yes it does cause this this issue but it does uh provide principles and schools School sites that flexibility for for tonight uh I do ask that you consider approving because of the fact that uh otherwise

133it's going to be over half a million dollar of uh Staffing that we're not projecting to need it for next year have a question with regard to so and and the way that I'm understanding this is from listening to trusty too and and Mr pong these are sight funded positions so if we don't if the resolution is not passed to to cut these and aside from the savings the money savings what happens to these positions if the site has already determined that these are not priorities for next year so then the district so it's not the site the district picks up the the bill pays for the positions and then we have extra staff okay so the the work that's being done by these people or these positions we'll say positions where does that work

134go to so there are many different circumstan uh and let me focus on instructional assistance so for example it could be a case where instructional assistant might be uh possibly helping with a one-onone of uh uh with the students sixth grader sixth grader goes to seventh grade and now there might there might not be that need for that for for that position it could be a situation where at a particular site the enrollment decreases where they might not need two extra hours of a noon Duty uh or they do a shift in the lunch schedule where now they're able to concentrate this uh less new duties within a short per period of time so you don't need the extra time because of the of the of the new schedule uh it could be so so

135there's many different scenarios so not necessarily that somebody else is going to be picking up the the job or the duties it might be that it's not needed at that time may I sure well we spoke earlier and we've spoke and I brought it up what is it about a year ago about having instructional assistance trained instructional assistance to assist with second and third graders uh to help them get to the knowing how to read so that they can then read to learn uh would this be an opportunity especially for the schools that are really struggling in in you know the presentation we just had earlier to help them in that manner when you had this focus group going into Harbor Side you saw the results they were great is that something we could entertain

136to I'm not saying all of them I understand can't save all of these positions but certainly some that we can use the kids are worth it to help the teachers to get the children where they need to be when it comes to reading and then we have that other as a matter of fact I was going to address it later in my um comments about um you know when they they that that testing the teachers have to do once a year and it takes it spend they spend one hour with each child and we spoke even back then about um having someone that was trained that could go around in a school and do the testing because it takes away from instruction if that teacher's got 31 kids they're spending an hour with each child

137to test them and the whole idea was that they'd be consistency in how the test is being delivered and if you have a trained IIA or IAS they would be consistently delivering the the test and it would allow the teachers to teach because we're taking instructional time I'm wondering if we can save some of these instructional assistance to that capacity to help some of the um School sites that really need the help and there's even well all the schools need the help when it comes to this testing is there something we can do there uh Mr R yeah yeah I just a point of clarification the these are positions not people so the instructional assist that's why I was asking earlier were there people sitting in these positions yeah so there currently are people sitting

138in these positions but on average because we have correct me if I'm wrong but I think it's about 800 instructional AIDS u in our district so this is a a relative ly High turnover position so there are people in our positions but there won't be an instructional Aid that won't have a job next year they will definitely just because of attrition uh retirements and all of that we're hiring about 20 AIDS a month we have a job fair tomorrow for instructional assistants so these instructional assistants won't be uh positions uh positions that we lose uh noon duties we're we have an ongoing need for noon duties those willon be people who will be without jobs um I I don't believe and I'm not I can't speak for certain but I don't believe there's a single

139person on this list that won't have jobs our lead instructional assistants will be they'll have jobs they they were previously instructional assistants so they're going back as instructional assistance um and some of these positions there's both there are site funded and there are also District funded positions um you know the one position that's going to be eliminated and not a need to have U so like we have a couple like our our coordinator or parent engagement leason that position is being eliminated and so that that one you know what we have opportunities if she's interested in positions in the district but that position itself will be eliminated we're not eliminating instructional assistance we're not eliminating instructional assistant English language Learners um lead instructional assistants we are but they have opportunities to return back because they

140were previously instructional assistants in the district so um just wanted to to clarify that that these people will have jobs I think I'm a little mixed up because I thought I heard Dr Reya said that we didn't need these positions yeah I was under the same impression I had that question so I have the list of all the hired people and we hired last month 13 instructional assistants so we're reducing the positions how come we're still hiring every month and tomorrow we have another um fair so so so there are different things so one thing is the position and the other one is the people and so let's say we have 10 positions and out of the 10 let's say let's say let's say we have three vacancies right so we have 10 positions three

141vacancies out of the 10 positions we only need nine so then we would reduce one position we still need to hire two two people because we still have two vacancies but that this the 10th one we didn't need so that's what we reducing we're reducing the position we might still need additional folks for the other positions where there vacancies but uh we reduce a position not a person does that make sense Mr Romero and just on that you mentioned it and I want to I want to be very specific Dr Rees did mentioned when it comes to instructional assistance what happens is we have instructional assistance that may be um what we call skas or like what it's commonly know as like one to one AIDS we have a number of sixth grade students that

142annually leave that have these instructional AIDS assigned to them so those positions that they're assigned to will be eliminated because there's no longer a need for that one to one that person will still have a job this is eliminating the position not eliminating the person so that person will still be able to be an instructional assistant with us but that position that's assigned to like if it was me like I'm I'm moving into seventh grade I no longer need that one to one anymore and there's a number of those that happen annually where we need to reduce the number of AIDS but not to reduce the number of people that will have jobs I think we can work um with the district on this one um obviously there's we need to look at the how

143the schools allocate money for positions and understand that these positions are there's people involved and it creates chaos in HR when priorities change so um there there probably has to be more training at the school site Council level um to let them know what what their decisions uh impact um I'm willing to allow this for this time with the condition that the district looks at the school site Council processes so I'll make a motion to approve is there a second I'll second move by vice president de Mayo seconded by truste tolston all those in favor I I I all those opposed and I abstain motion carries for one exstension item 11b conduct a public hearing on the discontinuance of particular kinds of certificated services and adopt resolution on discontinuance of particular kinds of certificated services

144for the 2025 26 school year Mr Romero thank you president Ugarte governing board Dr Rez um it's uh today's item um is being brought forward for very similar uh reasons as the classified uh The District in its enrollment projections and uh projections for our um needs at our school sites uh have uh are bringing forward uh positions that need to be eliminated uh due to funding and due to um needs at our school sites so some of these uh positions um are largely um being uh reduced because of declining enrollment um and the needs that we have to address those declines um also to be physically um uh financially and physically uh prepared uh for our Uh current projections uh things like our uh music teachers um at one of our sites that's being reduced

145because of uh site funding um and uh our need to address other areas such as uh priorities of the district with um our fiscal uh solvency so uh the district is recommending that we reduce uh the FTE equivalent of 12.19 uh certificated positions I'm now opening the public hearing does anyone push to speak seeing no speakers I am closing the public hearing discussion before it is an action item what is the fin fiscal um savings Dr Reyes Mr morning so for for this item it's about 1.1 million may I speak yes so if we're using the same logic trustee um president Ugarte if we're using the same logic are we saying that all these people are going to come right back Dr Reyes Mr so great question um so it it varies between the position

146that we're talking about so the district is eliminating uh the director of attendance and wellness position so that would be an elimination of that position uh that that uh employee is a previous uh educator um and would be returning to a position within the district um the uh preschool teacher because of our our changes in uh what we're looking at with uh TK there's no longer a need for uh a SDC preschool teacher now that is a unicorn so um having a an SDC preschool teacher is absolutely a priority so we won't have a a withdrawal of anything but uh an opportunity for them to take a different position the um resource teacher and music teacher uh those positions as we look at proposition 28 um and the needs of our district there's a high

147likelihood that those positions would return by the end of this year and our general education teachers now one of the things um you heard uh from um our cve president uh Rosie uh Martinez that the district uh uses uh one method to determine the uh enrollment projections uh for uh our school year um and really our our objective is to be physically aware that this could be a possibility that we reduce by nine teachers um the likelihood that that is something that continues uh remains to be seen um but I think that that would be the one area where I'd say there's a possibility that they might not come back um um but that but we would need to wait to see what their enrollment looks like I have a question regarding projected enrollment Dr

148Reyes um how the projected enrollment this year how what's the difference between this year is projected enrollment and last year and next year Mr P for right now we're budgeting at plat um based on uh our sixth grade cohort rolling out with the addition of another quarter of TK coming in um with the full implementation of transitional kindergarten and other developments in the area so so I think the question was comparing this year's enrollment how are we doing yeah what what is the projection for next year in regards to either attrition or increase or staying the same we're projecting their rment to be the same around the same so if we're projecting it to be the same why why the elimination or discontinuance of these General Ed positions Dr re Mr P so in looking

149at the enrollment um we're looking districtwide at all the schools and um we we are realizing some um Staffing efficiency where there's a possibility of um you know combining like a combination class or something like that um as some areas that could see some savings are we talking about combos so so basically we're doing we're looking at this uh we're looking at uh School sites where we have let's say we have two classes we have um 10 kids and eight kids so it is not uh financially feasible to have two different teachers one with 10 kids one with eight kids um I mean the break even point for for class is I think 18 or so in the breaking point in regards to the the financial uh financially and so um any District doesn't want

150to operate uh classroom at a loss so then you do that's why we need to sometimes um uh do combos now they're not very popular with the teachers they have to absolutely age really I mean that's two grades they're teaching and uh depending on I mean your the instruction time doesn't change so the instruction if it's geared to I'm making up grades fifth graders and then you have the fourth graders that are not there it's just like going over their head they're sitting there maybe they're picking up something here or there but that doesn't seem that it might look fiscally responsible but logically speaking the teach the children are missing out on instruction time and the teachers are at a Breaking Point and and so that uh I will take the lead from the board

151to let me know how um you want to move forward in regards to the financial projections that way um you know we are at a deficit sure and so you let me know how and how you want us to to uh be not in the red um and so I just sure we understand that you're caught between a rock and a hard place as my father used to say but uh the sacrifice can't be in the classroom it just can't be there so how else can where else can we curb maybe that's something that an exercise in a workshop or some sort of telling us I know that we spoke with um uh president um Rosie Martinez okay where are all our staff where are they and what are they doing I'm sure they're doing

152something but is it something that what's what are we going to sacrifice the classroom or somewhere else yeah to to put things in perspective in regards to to uh fiscal uh right efficiency so any school district um so for example us uh and and Mr fr can correct me but it's it's about 92% of our budget 92% 92 92% of our budget is in Personnel so when you have an organization where 92% of the budget is in Personnel then the ability to to reduce amounts like 20 million in other areas is really minute did it go from 15 million to 20 million now 15 I don't even know how much it is right now but it's 15 18 let's say 15 million uhuh 12 million the ability to to reduce those amounts right in in

153by saving gas or lights it's really really uh minute and so the the savings or the fiscal efficiency always look comes at looking where can we um maximize our Resources with our Personnel I have a question so just to clarify these positions um teachers music teachers resource teacher and preschool are these um brought forth as like the the schools said we need less teachers Mr Romero Mr B so um our enrollment projections and where we look at it we have a department uh that uh uh takes the enrollment data that we have which is currently done by eliminating the sixth grade uh grade level and then basically duplicating what the kindergarten um numbers look like and in doing that they have have projections that they use to talk about every School site uh if there's

154a decline in enrollment how many teachers will they be losing in a class in a school that's increasing in enrollment how many classrooms will they will be adding and so we take all of that data and it's based on um okay if a school a is losing two students but School B is gaining three students then it's a plus one and we just basically do the math like this school needs four less teachers this school needs three more teachers and then we come up with a general number um and then uh our student placement Department shares that with us and we get uh enrollment projections starting now through July uh on Real Time data on when people enroll a follow-up question so are any of the schools um losing more than one teacher uh yes

155so so again correct and it's based on the enrollment of that particular site so we have some sites that actually are going up in enrollment other sites are decreasing I I have a clarifying question I just want to point out so there are I'm going to guess in our in cvsd full-time equivalent teachers and certificate or certificated 1,600 1,600 full time equivalent of certificated that all all certificate that's I'm guessing because I I know numbers from associations right out of those 1,600 FTE we're talking 12 ftes basically yes just wanted to clarify so we making a motion no not making a motion I'm just I'm clarifying because I think I think I think maybe some of our newer board members don't get the they're thinking it's hundreds of teachers this is 12.19 positions out of

1561600 positions I I I I do understand what you're saying and the the the problem I'm having is with the The General teachers the other ones I understand but this is an impact that will cause there's a domino effect right so now we're going to have our different School sites parents and teachers coming to us about how their students are not in their grade level of instruction because they're in a combo class and um if I had a fourth grader and and I was a fifth grade class I say yay you know because he's going to get more uh he going to have be exposed to a lot more but if if it was the other way around if I had a fifth grader and I have fourth graders I know that teacher has to

157take time to teach fourth grade curriculum they have to they can't ignore those children I just wish there was another way or somewhere else Dr a I understand the fiscal implications that we're in I do I'm just searching I'm hoping somebody come up with a Bright Idea here somewhere of how we Salvage that how we how we do that I imagine you guys have spent hours trying to figure it out but I'm just I wish there was a an answer to this one I would I would say okay I motion with the exception of the jet teachers I wouldn't approve that that would be what I'm that's what I'm thinking I'd like to hear someone pull a hat rub it out of the Hat you you know Mr m i doar he you yeah I

158do understand where you're coming from um this is a process that unfortunately and I say unfortunately because this not enjoyable you know um every single School District every single year goes through um and I do recognize that other schools are districts have 400 something so I do this is like great yeah so so so uh I I can you know I can't guarantee you that all those nine uh the nine teachers are going to be coming back but I can assure you that most of them if not all most likely will come back um we don't want to be in a position where we are spending more that is coming in when we have folks that you know we we not needed so the the The Prudent thing to do is uh is to to

159accept this and then uh I will personally work with HR to look closely at this nine positions to see uh how many if not all we can bring back okay won't be won't be until May or June that's all right but I take that as a promise motion to approve thank you all of them with the condition that you're looking at the General Ed teachers yes yes thank you I second moved by trusty Dominguez santes seconded by trusty Tolson all those in favor I I all those opposed I abstain I abstain was it three three so 32 motion carries three three yes two abstentions um and before we move on point of personal privilege please I do I it's very hard for me to separate myself from this because I this is a very passionate

160topic but I do want to say that making this decision now versus making it in July um there can be another riff in August and teachers can't find jobs then and so the fact that we do this and that Dr has made the commitment to look at this um gives me a little peace of mind um and I I like that you I I thank you for for making the comments because if enrollment comes back in in August and July then and it's lower then we would be going through this at that time so thank you and thank you for divulging me that um privilege all right um we are now on administrative action item s adopt a resolution adding independent citizens oversight of measure AA to the scope of Duties to the existing Chul

161Vista Elementary School District independent citizens oversight committee for General obligation Bond proceeds and amending the committee bylaws to reflect the same Mr palong thank you president garte um based on the law under govern um General obligation bonds we have to appoint US citizens oversight committee within 60 days of the certification of the election results which we did at the last board meeting so this would um have measure AA come under the current ioc um independent citizens oversight committee for oversight in addition to um Bond measure M and VB and we have no speakers on this item any board comments or questions quick comment now uh the report out schedule for these audits this is the once a year one that we get yes yes this is uh independent uh community members would it be possible

162I know that we've gotten some emails from uh from a Community member about updates Maybe maybe quarterly or twice a year just where our funds are at I mean doesn't have to be a formal presentation like we have just like the status like like your like when you do your book tce twice a year thank you that's it this is an action item approve second mooved by vice president de Mayo seconded by truste Dominguez santes all those in favor I motion carries unanimously adopt resolution authorizing the children Vista Elementary School District to uh submit form j13 a the request for the allowance of attendance because of emergency conditions and adopt the resolution authorizing the chil Vista Elementary School District to seek waivers or alternative measures for the Extended Learning opportunity program due to emergency conditions

163Mr pong we've had a couple of emergency situations um in January the first one being the Border two fires that close eight of our schools um the second one being a flood at Waters Lincoln and then the third one being um a power outage at Tiffany Elementary so with that um we will be applying for a waiver um for those days and then with the elop program the Extended Learning opport opportunities program there's a minimum day requirement so because we didn't have school on that this waves that requir for those days that we were in in session motion to approve second move by truste Dominguez cantes seconded by vice president the Mayo all those in favor I motion carries 5 Z adopt resolution to establish the bond building fund measure AA 21-34 and corresponding Debt

164Service fund for each series of bonds issued under measure AA Mr pong thank you this is to establish a new fund with the treasury we keep um track of each of our bonds separately motion to approve second moved by truste Dominguez Sant seconded by vice president the Mayo all those in favor I motion carries 5 Z general information items and reports report on fiscal crisis management assistant team in the human resour resources services and support department Dr Reyes so last board meeting uh trust requested a review of our HR department uh with the and contacting um the fiscal crisis management assistant team also known as fmats to do a study of again to of our HR department I went ahead and contacted the department and they are a couple things one right now they they

165did tell me that they are incredibly busy because they um were assigned to do fiscal audits to support uh some of the school some districts in La where they had entire schools burned down uh however they went ahead and sent me a proposal uh and what I told him was well give me the proposal of the scope of work and the amount so the scope would include the hiring onboarding exit interviews evaluations training and cross trining personal file management leave management they would also evaluate the current workflow and distribution of functions within the department and make recommendations for improved efficiencies in addition uh they will conduct an organizational and Staffing review of the above department and make recommendations for Staffing improvements and organizational restructuring and finally the team will present the final report uh at

166a board meeting at a public board meeting following the completion of the review and the cost for all this would be 26,000 this is an informational item only are there any questions with regard to the information provided by Dr Reyes yeah and and yes so so the reason why I put it as informational because I before I got it to approve I want to make sure that I have input from the board to make sure that this the scope that the board is looking for the scope of work and so the process would be if this is the scope that the board wants or if they want to make modifications you tell me now and then I would contact them to revise it and then I would bring it back for approval I think it

167covers what we spoke about okay so assis assis okay so uh I'm going question sorry do we have a timeline I know they said they're very busy so does that mean this would take so so I was going to cover that next so so thank you so yes so when I spoke with them they told me that um uh we can go ahead and get it approved right now I know that currently they're 100% working on the those school districts because they need the the support right now but uh so they would be able to they they couldn't really give me a timeline because they got to finish that first but uh they said approximately they could begin the work in about a month so which work kind of works out because by the time

168we bring it back I can work on if if they send me the the I just got to I just got to make sure that they send me the the contract within um a week and a half I can bring it to the March 5th meeting I if I have the contract right okay information received thank you um midyear update to the local control and accountability plan and the local control funding formula budget overview for parents Miss Morales okay we're getting ready here thank you president Ugarte Board of Trustees tonight we are going to update our board and Community um on a midyear report for the goals and actions outlined in our 2425 local control and accountability plan elcap the development and implementation of this plan as well as the preparation of this midyear report

169has been a collaborative effort across our district and will be reflected in how we present tonight you can see we have a team of Staff here who have so diligently waited to see the elcap presentation because they have been co-creators in it so um I thank them for staying with us and and joining us tonight I'd like to um invite up uh Dr Madrick Al Patel who is also going to be presenting tonight you can go ahead and come up to the podium so tonight what we're going to do is we're going to provide an update on where we're at in all the actions services and expenditures for all of the goals of our lcap um and we're going to go ahead and get started with Miss Perez is going to start us with an

170overview good evening the elcap process is rooted in the local control funding formula or lcff the lcff consists of three key components a base Grant a supplemental Grant and a concentration Grant as part of the lcff school districts are required to develop an lcap the lcap is a three-year plan that outlines our strategies to support positive student outcomes addressing both state and local priorities it serves as an opportunity for cvesd to share the rationale behind the selection of programs and services designed to meet our community's unique needs we are currently in the first year of this three-year plan and you can see the key components of the lcap on this slide including established metrics to track and assess our progress over time the lcap outlines how the district plans to improve academic achievement for all

171students however it is important important to note that supplemental and concentration Grant funds must primarily be directed toward the following student groups low income students English Learners and Foster youth as Mrs Morales mentioned the development of the elcap is a collaborative effort and this effort involves consultation with teachers principals administrators staff labor Partners parents community members and students and this process typically includes multiple meetings an open survey and focus groups to Gather Comprehensive feedback so you see the timeline on the screen in November of 2024 we began actively engaging our educational Partners to provide input for the 2526 iteration of the lcap and then you see in February there is a midyear report to the Board of Education regarding the current lcap and that is what we are presenting to you right now and then

172the input we gather will inform any changes to the current lcap and in May there will be a public hearing for the proposed 2526 lcap and this is the opportunity for the public to comment and for the board to provide feedback and in June the 2526 lcap goes for board approval the five key goal areas of our lcap are as follows goal one academics goal two safe and inclusive environments goal three three English Learners goal four Innovation and goal five educational partner engagement and today our team will provide a midyear update on the progress of key actions tied to each goal so our our District's first goal is to ensure academic success for all of our students when we look at the overall achievement for our Ela in CP as we heard earlier in the

173dashboard presentation we're seeing an increase in by 4 three in distance from standard and we have moved from yellow to Green on our dashboard this is exciting news for us and as we look at our midyear local measures using Achieve 3000 we see that 37.2% of our students are meeting or exceeding the standards we continue to be committed to the development of literacy for all of our students and this year in quarter 1 and Quarter Two we provided literacy and language profession learning for all teachers in the district for each of their grade levels when we look at our data for math we see that we still have some work to do and we see that we are still maintaining that distance from standard at about -6.4 points as well as maintaining a yellow status

174on the dashboard for us to maintain a focus on math this year we know that our principles are creating tlap plans with a focus in math and at the district level we are providing Math training for all of our teachers in grades 2 4 and six as a matter of fact those trainings are happening this week and we're finishing up sixth grade the purpose of those trainings is to ensure that our teachers deepen their understanding of the framework and also get more familiar with the instructional routines that are provided in our core District curriculum for I ready if we look at the next slide you'll see that we also continue our work with en cust all of our principles are participating and learning walks across our districts we're visiting classrooms and looking at the eight

175ncust instructional practices and and noticing and naming the way in which those instructional practices are having an impact on our students learning we also have 28 PR 28 principles who are receiving coaching from enus an encest coach in the middle there you'll see that we have a specific focus on a student group our students who are receiving special education services when we look at the data for our these this group of students you'll see that we're maintaining the same level of performance in ela and we're declining slightly in math one of the shifts that we've made this year regarding this student group is to ensure that we are inviting and including all of our staff members who are providing supports to students with disabilities in our literacy and language training in our Math training as

176well as receiving specific training for their special education roles in our district this is helping to provide access for our students to standards based instruction and support in collaboration with our general education teachers and our special education teachers the last bottom column you'll see um we're pleased to share that um we continue to remain committed to supporting our implementation of TK we have 100% of our TK classrooms um staffed with an instructional assistant we also are providing a variety of professional learning opportunities for all IAS and our TK teachers and we're very pleased to announce that we are projected to open up 13 additional TK classrooms in the coming school year and we'll be able to provide that support and also that opportunity to our earliest Learners in communities across our district so for goal

177two in safe and inclusive environments we show two broad themes with various metrics which include student belonging and safety as a district we have been very intentional and focused on our chronic absenteeism and we provide continuous support to our sites which include review of data discussions with sites about next steps and training we are happy to report that the year data shows an improvement where we decreased overall in our chronic absenteeism as you can see from last year 23 24 it was 15.3 and our midar internal data shows that we're currently at 12.2 additionally as part of promoting students social emotional and physical wellness we are happy to report the multitude of counseling sessions that we have been providing uh districtwide which include Individual Counseling group counseling and social emotional learning lessons and as part

178of our continuous Improvement of school safety 100% we've had of safety assessments completed uh moreover we have the rocket rules collaboration that was approved which is a series of developmentally age appropriate resources that include lesson plans and videos to engage our youngest Learners this includes preschool through 2 grade uh in emergency preparedness and safety and we're also happy to report that 100% of our staff have been trained in the use of eix and all schools have partnership with our school resource officers as well goal three English learner our ongoing commitment to supporting multilingual English Learners remains a key focus in cvsd recent data highlights a reduction in the number of students identified as at risk for long-term English Learners and long-term English Learners and this is good news because that means more students are on

179track for reclassification mid-year reclassification rates show a slight increase compared to last year and with lpac testing currently underway we expect further gains by the end of the year the latest Casp data reflects a positive trend in multilingual English learner achievement in English language arts with midyear progress also showing a slight improvement from the previous year ensuring that our students make consistent progress on the elpac remains critical and to address this we have provided as Miss Montgomery said literacy and language professional learning for all teachers that does include a component of comprehensive ELD this year we also introduced supplemental English language development curriculum at 19 School sites offering enhanced resources for teachers to support designated ELD instruction additionally we are pleased to report a decrease in chronic absenteeism among our multilingual English Learners this is

180encouraging news as regular attendance directly contributes to student learning and success instructional services our principes our teachers and staff remain dedicated to continuing our work to elevate the academic achievement of our multilingual English Learners and we are confident that through our Collective efforts we will continue to see positive growth and outcomes for our students so goal number four is focused on driving Innovation efforts in our um efforts for our students in our district we continue to build our lead after school program with 15,000 students participating inad lead Hub and Club our lead team has focused on increasing program Equity throughout the district and introducing new and exciting classes to students our students continue to have access to our amazing vapa classes in one or more Arts disciplines and orp and we are excited about bringing

181on our new vapa lead teachers who will support vapa professional learning lastly the launch of our life science station has been a success and our Innovation team has been busy installing steam Studios at 13 schools and engaging our teachers in meaningful professional learning around learning environments design thinking cultures of thinking and more one note I'd like to point out for this slide in particular as you may have noticed the budgeted expenditures and actuals match on many of the slides because as Dr re said we're a very um employee heavy organization right and so we're glad to report that we have a lot of those positions filled I did want to put a note though by vappa that the total cost of the program is also indicated there equaling about about $9.2 million and we have

182about 5.8 of that currently sitting within our lcap budget and then our last goal is educational partner engagement and cvesd has continued to strengthen family engagement through community outreach family leadership education opportunities and enhanced digital communication to ensure families are informed and connected they routinely receive social media posts Flyers translations and interpret portation services to ensure accessibility for all community outreach continues to be a top priority for the district with over a thousand families attending this the community Expo furthermore parents and Guardians attend seven cvesd University workshops and two lcap information sessions thus far this year these educational partner engagement initiatives underscore cvsd commitment to strengthening The Homeschool connection and providing our families with the resources and support necessary to Foster Student Success and when we look at our overall Al cap and general fund

183expenditures our first interim our total expenditures were about 436 million of that our lcap expenditures that we have specific goals and actions for we have budgeted about 58.7 million um so that means that we have about 377 million that's not captured in the lcap and a lot of that is the base program program so our base program consists of all of our certificated and instructional staff at the school sites um both side and district office administration side funded supports uh Transportation facilities and operations special education supports and all of our other um supported programs that weren't mentioned in the cap all right and with that we'd like to take any questions that you you have about our mid year up update we have no we have no speakers um any board comments or questions regarding

184the lcap I have a question um are the baa um they mentioned um they're opening more are they are we concentrating on the west side or like is it equal or both siid Miss Morales so let make sure I understand the question that you're asking so are are we are we foreseeing all of our schools to have this program all of our schools currently do have our vapa program as well as our lead program yeah any other I do had a question how many PE teachers do we have and I had a question about aex after that Dr re Mr R you have that that number do you want to ask your ax question yes ax question yes um to access that software I'm wondering if we're getting some feedback from our teachers uh as

185far as uh when they're logging in it doesn't come up as quickly uh servers are they working cuz a lot it doesn't do us any good if they can't access it and then the I know there was a question about maybe getting laptops for those substitute teachers coming in are are they going to be trained I'm I'm not sure that we yes yeah Mr could you uh tell us where we are with the there were several things that we needed to address regarding ax are you sure where we are with that yeah question 1.0 um 15 p teachers um the second question 2.0 uh yes so we talked about uh multiple times that this is like a roll out year for eix one of the things um that we've been working with is uh we've

186been uh in our safety meetings talking about um the priority in US using it so uh the we get more value from it when we use it so getting uh our staff used to using it um is something that that's critical one of the the situations that arose uh we shared about in our safety update uh one of our school sites uh went on to um uh a uh controlled um not a lock down what's the oneus sry secure campus thank you um but didn't put it on egx so our principal went through the process of like calling but even our principal admitted that like now I think about I should have put it on eix right so it's getting our staff used to using it is one of the the biggest priorities that we

187have uh to address the second issue the uh district is looking at a a acquiring tablets uh that can be checked out uh when substitutes come in um and staff that come in that aren't assigned to that school site eix only works at the app only works because it doesn't track staff um we don't have any uh and they don't want to have any access to it but like if a a substitute teacher comes into Liberty uh for example we want to be able to assign them a tablet that they can use and if there's an emergency they can respond or if there's an emergency they can get the response um so all of that is is what we're looking at for the 25 26 school year um um and then training our subs on

188on using it so um we are getting we have gotten some feedback um on on the use of it um access is the number one area of of of need um and making sure that our staff uses it one of the things that we're also looking at with the whole tablet um item that I shared with you uh we have some staff that just are nervous about putting anything on their phone we're not we're not it's not a requirement you know you know we definitely want to prioritize that that you know this is not something that's required but if a staff is doing supervision at lunchtime right or our staff is doing recess supervision and they don't have it on their phone and there's an emergency that happens they're not getting notified right so the

189whole tablet idea would be like if it's your day to do new Duty work or recess Duty you would be able to check out one of the tablets from the office and have it with you tablet so yeah I'm not talking about like a I'm not talking about that but we're talking about like 8 in tablets which are a little bit bigger than a cell phone it's not huge because the need for the information sharing isn't like a a like a computer right but um you know Amazon makes these tablets that are 8 concern because it can only work if they use it right and um that I think is a challenge because I'm not hearing too much um I'm not hearing the the engagement from the school some just wondering where we might be

190able to support them more so they you know yeah Amed and Darren are committed to providing that training um and getting out there um and the only benefit we get is from use right it's not worth it if we're not using it um so what I'll have them do is I'll have them um prioritize reaching out to our sites and getting usage data that we can share it in upcoming Friday uh weekly where we can you know revisit how how many times it's being used and and you know whether we want I mean ultimately the goal is that we don't use it too often right you know because we have safe campuses but when we do use it it's it's being used to the function in which we we uh purchased it for thank you

191just want to keep it on the uh on the horizon can I I can also just one little update and it's not that that you asked for for this information um but Jenny vgnc um is uh partnering with eix to talk about we're the largest uh School District to use their product right now so we've been um the cost of eix is about $3,700 per School site not a lot but she's negotiating a a price with with them right now to reduce it to $1,500 so $1,500 per School site per year um so we're really close to to finalizing that um so they want to be a partner with us and she's really good at negotiating things like that thank you thank you any any other questions or comments on the elap I I just

192wanted to jump back in um for you mentioned uh for teachers that are in like lunch duty how about the noon duties that are in Lun Duty do they have to have it on their phone on their personal phone no it would definitely would be for those people as well yes so they would be able to have it um they have to have it on their phone that's my question no they don't have to have an another phone that is it's optional it's definitely encouraged and we're working with our labor groups all of our labor groups um you know were part of the the uh decisionmaking in using eix and uh I don't want to speak for them but I believe that most of them have endorsed uh this being you know part of something

193that's shared one of the concerns that I want to make that we address in in open is the app doesn't track employees they don't have any access to your data that's why we have to check out a device anytime you go on to school sites thank you thank you thank you for the report that was an informational item for us and we very much appreciate it I love minimal slides and concise information so thank you yes we do and letters you can read yes thank you report calendar to the Board of Education this is a point in the agenda where board members can ask for reports of Dr Reyes do we have any report requests for Dr Reyes I think we've kind of gone most of it yes I just like an IT update of

194from um we hadn't remember last school year we had an in incident where children were accessing very inappro rate um uh subject matter on our school devices and uh I sat with is it Jacob there and uh I know line wise software was I I'd like an update on that I don't know maybe next go around yes bring us a report on that where we're at so you want a like a Friday update or uh no I'd like the report presentation yes please not not a whole presentation just something let us know we probably do it uh we could probably attach that presentation on the safety you the safety yeah that's that's fine thank you any other report requests yes so I need an update on what happened to that school that wanted um a

195water bottle station uh I know that I asked that we I wanted to see a um a quote or something to be purchased and the agenda I haven't seen it uh so I requested that do you have a an update so we had um meetings with there are three schools actually I think um one was rice where they had one donated that one was installed um East Lake was another one that we um met with the the principal um to determine the location so we were waiting on one of our contractors to um confirm that they're able to install it there and then the third School HS yeah that one was installed already that's installed mhm so they're happy and good with it that was okay CH Hills all right I'll have to go and

196anything else Check Yes Go refill your water there yeah I know put a put a line CR cross that out the the next one is um it's been several months since I have asked asked for a RFP uh contract or whatever it is that we need to do to fix the the playgrounds uh specifically the three ones that have a piece of plywood um to prevent students from from sliding uh that is disturbing to me to have that um I've been told that we needed to wait for the bond I've been told that we needed to wait for contractor I've been told that um the moon and the sun doesn't align uh where are we with that I second that and I and I fled it so Mr BR so those um play structures some

197of them are not able to be repaired so we're looking at replacing them and actually um we were speaking with instructional services and Facilities this week um we're going to be meeting with vendors to create what our district standard is going to be so as we um replace they come in two different stages so ages 2 to 5 and then 5 to 12 um we're going to have have them help us design what our new standard will be and then we'll be bringing that forward for um approval and installation for those so so one of the things that we discovered is that we were looking at the different structures and we discovered that almost every school has a different type of play structure so one of the things that we believe is important is that

198we involv instructional services that it's not just for play but that it also has uh some kind of a learning uh component so the for exercise or for other stuff um so right now they're currently working on that Miss Morales do you have a input on that yeah so we had a meeting this week and what we asked the vendor to do is to provide us some options based upon different parameters so we would like to see some of our play Stacks have um items at the ground level such as music making items some things that they can talk through and make Echoes we're looking at different climbing options for them we're even exploring swings um and so we've given them different parameters to be able to provide us with options to choose from to

199see whether or not they fit also the spaces that we have and we're also create like we just had the meeting today for the violo modernization and so we are trying to create a district standard with some more engaging play structures for our students and that's fine and well uh and I appreciate that we're trying to maximize the opportunity now what is the timeline because that's that's important piece right because we can talk about what we want to do and the great things that we can do with this project but there's several of these schools that they're Park they don't have Parks uh their for these kids their playground is the school playground and we need to maximize that opportunity for those um students also so timeline at least for those three I I get

200that we have 50 schools I get that we're a big system but there's there's a urgency that we need to act for these uh students uh they they deserve to have a playground uh uh as much as the playground that I my kids have in moroa or that other kids have in in those schools um I assure you that if there was a plywood a piece of plywood in moroa h that would have been fixed that a long time ago so we've discussed this every single month practic and I think the time of talking is over someone needs to go in and remove that dangerous structure if we have to go knock at the mayor's house or business you know their business because you mentioned something about permitting we need to do that and just

201the vendor's going to let us know the vendor's going to let it's not your fault but that's what they keep telling you but um just that sense of urgency like Tristy Tom saying Mr pong make this no make it's a priority I I'm going to throw a little bit of a wrench in here just a second and not may not be a wrench I I would also hope that in our looking at all of the academic aspect of play that we're looking at for our students with challenges physical challenges because I know when I visit School sites and I asked them what is your pie in the sky desire that is one of the things that they say they would like to see and that's one of the pieces that uh all the new place

202structures that we put in are going to be ADA Compliant good sounds good I have a question so to these three schools with these playgrounds is there any safety regulation are we still allowing students to play um or are we are we making sure you know we keep safety our priority as well uh so M mores what happens when we have a damaged playground is that the facilities Department goes out and works with the school team and we do agree there is an urgency around this because it does require us to close different components of the playground so we do prioritize the safety uh could you please double check Castle Park because that is not happening I will thank you that's all I have I just added what I needed to add um board Communications

203um this is the point in the agenda where board members can wa I have one more sorry you lied sorry I lied um sorry I misspoke spoke um can we get a on the board updates um a number a list of the number of grievances that have been filed by any of the association read you were reading my mind yes I I tend to do that um the list of Grievances and where where are we and what is the description of the the grievance are you talking about acting active or for this year act active active okay yes Mr are we done yes okay uh put my this is the point in the agenda where board members can um report out any of their activities in the last month since the last board meeting um

204events that they've attended beginning with truste Ramirez Dominguez thank you I was able to visit to our school sites which is very um eye openening and really educating for me um I was actually able to visit Feer and one of their uh programs there they actually mentioned that our Innovation stations were based on their Innovation um program which was very it's amazing to see what they're doing um they're actually having this neuroscientist um or this Neuroscience like Club where they actually work with brains which was amazing um and the students have the ability to you know um visit this place in downtown and take the trolley over there so it's it's such um an amazing experience to see I was also very intrigued um and I was also able to visit cvcc which is another

205of our um charter schools and I love to see their um they have a 30 minute program called uh what is it called it's at the end of the day um I forgot the name oh my god um but basically they have little jobs like all the stud they have Shops and and the students of all grades get together and one is the owner one is the clerk one is the painter one is the photographer so it's so cute to see the students actually work together in different levels and have this little community and have their paydays and and paychecks and all these things so it it was um one of the features that I love seeing in our in our charter schools because taking like with Ovation stations what the charter schools implement we

206can use for the rest of our schools so um it was very eye openening and I look forward to visiting more of our um our schools and be able to help and support and have all the experience so thank you very much trusty tolston I too got to visit a science the Science Station and the health station um it was very eye openening to see um it was very interesting to see that it's not just being geared to what they're learning that day but they're actually taking it and I this was a complete surprise to me that they're gearing themselves to a career they're being pinpointed to where their strengths are um I told Mr Bruder and I told Dr Reyes that um I I feel like I I would hope that the communication for

207that goes out more to parents and not just like social media or Flyers because yes you we get excited when our kids go to a field trip come to find out there's a lot more to that and again it goes back to what we've been seeing today um the amazing work that's being done by all of the District staff it was amazing I was very fascinated I'm looking forward to seeing more of those and I also had the opportunity to attend The Lion King at the at uh Discovery Charter same I was so proud of the staff the students the costumes were amazing the acting was fantastic and I mean the organization of the whole uh production from the seating arrangements to the play itself it was very very very nice and I'd like to

208see more of that thank you trusty Ling santes I too attended the Lion King uh presentation at Discovery and it's always amazing that these kids are so gutsy to get up there and perform in front of these people that are just staring at them oh my gosh how intimidating but they're not they're loving it they're really good and again the costumes the music the acting Simba I love that and my colleague here he lik the other person he'll tell you a little bit but I also attended um uh I participated at the Liberty speech presentations and by golly there's this one kid there that just he owned the floor he just owned he owned us we're just watching and listening to everything he said and um it was just amazing to watch that brain work

209and it's he's having a conversation with you you don't even know that you're having a conversation with him but you are because he's asking he's anticipating what you're thinking almost and before you can think it he's already interjected another thought it was a wonderful journey to watch him watch this child's presentation by the way his name is Diego and I also so um watches other again at Heritage of speech presentations these kids the ideas and how they you give them they're given the the the subject matter but how they turn around and weave their thoughts and this one little girl she took us through a journey of watching The Stars you could almost see it in a movie and it was just amazing I know every school has these because every school has stars and

210um we even thought gosh this little girl should write a book because the illustrations and the way she wrote them it's just really amazing I think all our kids are just great I'm looking forward to watching those that were moved forward not that the other ones didn't Merit going there they should but when you go to judging it just you know you have to you have some of them stay behind I met with some parents and I also attended the DC deac monthly meeting uh last week and it's always nice to meet other parents and hear some of their experiences and they're sharing um uh some of what works something some other stuff that doesn't work as well but they're learning from each other and um thank you thank you for the opportunities yeah that

211I they try to make me sing that's horrible idea but they I just kind of lip sync it was not good thank you next um I too had uh the opportunity to uh attend The Lion King uh junior presentation at Discovery it was amazing I uh my colleague said um the production the the how students are able to not just uh the acting right it was Alo the all those students in the in the background moving the stage setting up the the scenarios um my favorite uh was uh scar um sassy scar sassy scar was was there um I love that character Timone and pumbo were were hilarious um but overall every single one of them uh they they were very very um talented people uh remembering the lines and I mean the the young

212Simba I'll tell you that be being so young and being able to remember the amount of lines yeah was impressive I I I mean I I used to know every single line of that movie and kids I I couldn't remember some of the things that they were saying and it's like oh yeah it caught up to me but uh it's impressive it's impressive that they're able to do that it's um the amount of of talent that we have in our schools with trusty Domingo svant saying about the the speech uh that that happened at that school uh for the new trustees you'll you'll have the opportunity to hear very talented um students that we have and there'll be showcase here but as as we get invited to attend take that opportunity to attend those because

213there's so much talent in our schools with with the kids that it's it's amazing um um uh most often I say I I can't hold a candle to those kids in in public speaking so it's like they they rock it so that's all I have I don't even need to talk you said everything I did um I did um I I went on a Friday night because that's how exciting my Friday nights are I get to spend them with students out of play and I took I realized it was the first time that my daughter who's very private um went she she said I'll go with you and she's a Critic she's she this is a an adult who goes on vacation to Broadway to see plays and so um she came with me and

214the whole time she kept saying oh my gosh young Simba oh my gosh sassy scar oh my go she was just she was blown away by just everything that they did um and um at the end um I came to find out that we know scar we know Scar's parents and we um also knew some of the chorus um students and always running into former students who who and then I feel super super veteran not old um because they're either teachers at the school or parents of the students that are in the play um and so it was very very um a nice evening um excellent excellent um production and uh continue to invite us to to these events because they're really fun Dr Reyes your superintendent communication I just want to thank everyone for

215all the hard work for your leadership for making sure that our kids are always safe and are getting the best education possible thank you Dr Rees before you there was one question that I was hoping you were going to address about the achieve so I know parents have been teachers have been asking about the achieve you sent out a notice yes and we're actually going to be sending out a notice uh Miss Morales um just yeah um yeah so we are going to be sending out communication through the ISS newsletter as well as our principal's weekly update and I have also spoke to Miss Martinez about it and some shared messaging that we will um be holding on to achieve for one more year and then we are looking at the assessments that we need

216for our students and the programs um within that year to see whether or not any future changes need to be made all right thank you thank you Dr Reyes for hanging in there of course the next regular meeting of the Board of Education of the Chulavista Elementary School District will be held on March 5th at 400 PM for closed session and 6: PM for Open Session do we have a motion to adjourn this meeting motion to adjourn motion by can I say the doingi um and seconded and all in favor I

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.