001al al testing al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al Chulavista Elementary School District calls to order Welcome to all members present except for Vice President Tamayo. Now we will approve the agenda. There is a motion. I request a motion to approve, and Ms. Dominguez Cervantes requested it. Ms. Toen, everyone in favor, say I. The motion passes. 41. One absent. Oral communications. Those who wish to be heard have an opportunity to address agenda items only. Only items on the closed session agenda must be filled out to be heard and submitted to the recording secretary before the start of the meeting. No discussion will be held on any item not listed on the posted agenda. The presiding
002officers will limit the time for comments to 20 minutes with the consent of the presiding officers. The chairperson may increase or decrease the time for the posted agenda, and no action may be taken. There is no one who wishes to address the presiding officers. Now we will close session in accordance with section 35 49.1 d and 549 57.6 of the Government Code collective bargaining employee negotiations negotiator agency Adam Silva and McNally employee organizations Chula Vista classified employees organization Chula Vista educators unrepresented employees and Chula Vista administrators association section 54957 B1 of the Government Code discipline dismissal and release of public employee section 5495 6.9 D1 of the Government Code conference with legal counsel existing litigation in the Office of Administrative Hearings case 202 41094 section 549 56.9 D1 of the Government Code conference with legal
003counsel existing litigation in the Office of Administrative Hearings house number 0799 al ... 20241 1094 Mr. Tamayo made the motion, Ms. Dominguez Cervantes seconded it, and it was approved by five votes in favor, no one abstained, no one voted against. Section 549 56.9 D1 Government Code Conference with Legal Counsel. Existing digits in the Office of Administrative Hearings, Case 202 99. The motion was made by Ms. Cervantes, Ms. Ramirez Dominguez seconded it, and it was approved by five votes in favor, no one voted against, zero abstentions. That's all. The open session of the regular board of the Chula Vista Elementary Schools District. Order is called. Welcome, everyone. All members are present. And Ms. Tosten, if you could please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance, I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of
004America and to the republic which it represents, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. Now let's proceed to the agenda. There is a motion. Uh, I request a motion to approve. I second it. Mr. Tamayo requested the motion. Ms. Dominguez Cervantes seconded, all in favor, say I, the Freemason, unanimously pass communications to the board of directors. Ms. Angela, from the Chulavista Classified Employees, good evening, board of directors. First, I would like to congratulate Keren Ramirez and Jessica Toston on their respective appointments to the Chulavista Elementary School District board of directors. I look forward to a future of collaboration and know that we can work together to improve the classified employees throughout the district, advance professional development, increase compensation, and improve working conditions for classified employees, strengthening the core infrastructure
005of our schools. I would like to take this opportunity to highlight the classified service and support we collectively provide to the district and student achievement. Before I finish, I want to share an experience at a parent forum I attended during the construction of our newest school, Sotomayor Elementary. At the forum, the district gave a presentation about the new school and mentioned the classified employees. Toward the end, a parent asked for clarification regarding the presentation and specifically asked if the parents would be told the names of the employees. What does this imply? The most commonly used definition is incorrectly used, and the word " classified" is used as a secrecy term instead of the adjectival form used to refer to the categories. This definitional error, although funny in hindsight, illustrates an existing disability among classified and
006certified employees. It is most common for schools to be described through the lens of the teacher, the students, and the administration. The essential but invisible tasks are carried out by classified employees day after day to keep those schools running and allow them to thrive. Too often, classified employees are not celebrated with the same emphasis as other employee groups and are the first to be sidelined when resources are scarce. For example, we are the first to be laid off to balance the budget. Furthermore, the district does everything possible to ensure that there are adequate substitute employees to fill gaps in teacher and administrator availability, while efforts to do the same for classified employees are woefully inadequate. Unfortunately, whether intentional or not, this also sends a very clear message to classified employees about their perceived value. To
007describe just a few of the many ways in which classified employees support students, they are the First to greet students at the main doors, the office, and outside the classroom, waiting for the school day to begin. We are the home-to- school connection, with bus and van drivers transporting students there and to school every day. Classified employees feed students, providing one of the fundamental principles of the Mars hierarchy. Food, shelter, and clothing needs are met. CNC provides breakfast and lunch to every student at every school and even delivers an afternoon snack to all students participating in the lead program. We provide safe supervision for students to play and express themselves. We provide educational support with professional educators capable of providing small-group instruction to the most needy students. Our main office staff are the face of the
008school, connecting with parents to keep students in school and in their seats, thus increasing the ADA—the same ADA the district relies on so desperately to function. My hope tonight is that you will recognize the vital work the classified employees provide to the district and prioritize our needs accordingly. Sometimes this is related to funding; other times it requires prioritization and recognition of our challenges. Specifically, I request that the maintenance and coverage of all required classified positions take priority over other discretionary items, rather than using reductions in classified staff as a means to balance the budget. Thank you, Chula Vista educators. Rosi Martinez, good evening, and welcome to 2025. I want to begin by welcoming Ms. Tosten and Ms. Ramirez Dominguez. CBE collaborates and has relationships with the board members, since the board members have the responsibility
009to approve policies that impact families, students, staff, and the Chula Vista community. Understanding the board's concerns is crucial. They find a space that welcomes everyone. As I said at a special meeting, the board must serve the people of education and the community; they should not pursue their own agendas on behalf of Chula Vista educators. I ask that while you take on this role, you maintain the district's vision, the commitment to provide a challenging educational experience, and the importance of education for all students, knowing that each student is an individual of great value. And that everyone has the right to a quality education, we encourage every contribution from individuals. We value a multicultural perspective so that Chula Vista educators and all staff create a welcoming environment. The equity policy says that the district will eliminate racism
010from anything or things that are not intended to be racist, and we will eliminate disparities in outcomes for students who are not represented. Decisions do not have to assume stereotypical things. In this time of insecurity, we have to say clearly as a district that we support all of our students regardless of their citizenship status, their identity, their ability, their race, or their gender. And again, these values are not limited to the students we serve, but also to those who work with us. I want to remind you that the United States Constitution explicitly says that the government, including public schools, cannot promote a specific religion. Public schools cannot require religious education, and school officials must be neutral and cannot encourage or promote religious activities. CBE continues to be proactive. We will continue to prioritize safety, social-emotional
011support, academic interventions, and work in schools. Community: I want to congratulate Ms. Paula Patel and Ms. Maria Montgomery on their promotions. Dr. Patel has been outstanding in her work with young students, and Ms. Montgomery is an important addition to the instruction department. I appreciate that the district continues to create opportunities for staff to have a voice in this rigorous learning plan. We are pleased to announce that we will be negotiating with the district next week and will be... We are happy that we are almost ready to finalize our contract. We always find ways to create language that fosters clear understanding for everyone. Thank you, Chula Vista Administrators Association. Ms. Teresa Corona: Good evening, President Hugarte, members of the board, Superintendent Dr. Reyes. On behalf of the Chula Vista Administrators Association, I want to welcome our
012new members, Ms. Tosten and Ms. Ramirez. Congratulations on your appointments, and thank you for your willingness to serve the community in this role. AACB is eager to hear about your contributions to our district. I also want to let our members know that AACB represents dedicated principals and assistant principals who work tirelessly to lead our schools and support... Our teachers, and most importantly, we care about the success and well-being of our students and our school communities. We are one of three unions in the district, but the newest, working with our first contract this year. Our mission is to advocate for our members, to have a voice at the table, and to contribute to collaborative relationships that improve the educational experience for every student in the district. We are successful in having a relationship with our board
013because everyone begins their service on this board together. I want to emphasize that AACB's commitment is to participation, and the decisions made in this room impact students, families, and educators. We truly hope that you, as members, will focus your work on what is best for the students, aligning your efforts with our district's mission and also solving problems collaboratively. This sets a great example for the students we educate and inspire every day. There are many decisions ahead, and AACB hopes that we can make informed and equitable decisions that prioritize the needs of our students, our staff, and our school communities. Thank you so much for your service and dedication. Welcome to our new members, and this dedication is for the children. And AACB families and school communities are eager to collaborate with you as we continue
014to navigate our work in education with the courage, passion, and commitment to excellence that we all share. Thank you. Oral communications provide the public with an opportunity to address the board on matters not on the agenda. Speakers are asked to limit their remarks to 3 minutes and to submit a request to be heard to the recording secretary. The board will limit the total time for public input on each topic to 20 minutes with the consent of the board. The chair may increase or decrease the time allowed for public input depending on the topic and the number of people who wish to be heard. No action can be taken by the board. We have eight speakers tonight. First, we have Christy M. Good evening. As Roger's parent, I want to express my appreciation for appointing Principal
015Rodrigo as principal. We are very pleased with this decision to bring in someone with so much experience. His leadership has made a huge difference, and the staff and parents have already felt the change. As we move forward, I want to give you Please consider someone with elementary school leadership experience who also demonstrates a commitment to parent involvement. Research shows that when parents are involved, children succeed. I also want to take a moment to advocate for our assistant principal. From day one, she has encouraged the children and staff and worked tirelessly. Her leadership has been invaluable. I believe she should have the opportunity for this new position. She is an ideal candidate. Rogers is a special place and needs a principal who knows how to solve challenges and has the ability to connect with the staff,
016students, and families. Thank you, Brandy Len Herrera. My name is Randy Herrera, and my son is a first-grader at Rogers. It was very difficult for me to see my son struggling to attend school. They had combined kindergarten classes, and it affected not only the students but also the parents. I hope this will be considered for the next school year. I want to thank the teachers and parents for advocating for children who cannot do so, and the school board for coming to our school and seeing that this was something that... It needed to happen, to split the classes. I can only see and feel the huge difference at school since we came back from vacation. I'm eager to see this new chapter at Rogers and I hope we can continue with good leadership that understands the
017children. And thank you. If we don't reach out to you, no one will. Thank you, Rosemary Laury. Uh, respectfully, I'd like to request 30 more seconds. Good evening. First of all, I congratulate the members who were appointed. Do things not just because they're popular, do things because they're right. You have the education of more than 30,000 students in your hands, many students with disabilities and English learners. To the people I'm interpreting for, this person who is addressing the board is reading at a speed that I can't interpret word for word. Noah Cravens is the PTA president at Fahari School. There were many problems with her. I know it's true because Mrs. Noah Cravens advocated for my son. No, he wasn't afraid for that reason. I'm concerned about the comments that were made about her. She
018advocates for students, staff, and families. She brought a very good PTA program to Fahari Jeffers School. It's a very special community. Advocacy shouldn't be discouraged. What are these actions saying to our students? If you speak out, they're going to discourage you. Make sure your actions are aligned with your words. And lastly, I want to say that advocating for students doesn't mean you don't support teachers. It means you speak up for those who can't. And remember, we're here for a common purpose: the safety and education of the children here in the district. I have statements from 20 parents across the district. So, I'm going to give you this statement. Thank you, Carlos. I'm also here on behalf of Noel Cravens. I wasn't here last week, but I heard what was said about her, and it really
019broke my heart. I just want to say that from my experience, she has definitely been there for the students, the teachers, and the principal. And as PTA president, she's always communicating with us. I just want to make sure that what you heard last week isn't her. And she knows that many of us support her and love her for all she has done for us. Thank you, Noel Cravens. Good evening. Before I go, I want to congratulate Ken Ramirez and Jessica Tosten. I am excited that you are parents of students in our district. It has been a pleasure working with you. The educators of Chul Vista are dedicated to improving learning and advocating for equity and justice. But if you allow the Fajari teachers to retaliate against me, students have been harassed. Students in special education
020have come home with bruises from school and exhibiting behavioral problems. Students have been left alone in a classroom while the rest of the class is in the yard or having lunch. I want to emphasize that these problems have occurred and that the parents have tried to cooperate. I have not mentioned any men or anyone from the None of the 17 students who were in Fahari returned this year. It's a disgrace because you all knew what I said was true. It's a disgrace that Chula Vista educators are supporting teachers who are going against the grain. Before deciding to tear apart a parent who is publicly defending students, think about it. Intimidating someone who advocates for students should not be supported or encouraged. We will not remain silent. Thank you, René Henry. Good evening, members of the
021board. Thank you for allowing me to address you. I am not here to speak for myself; I am here to speak about a parent who was attacked during the special meeting. As a community, we want to have a good school environment, and when we are attacked unfairly, we are all attacked. The accusations made against Noel Cravens do not represent her intentions and actions. I have had the privilege of working alongside her, and she is dedicated and responsible. Her focus has always been on what is best for the students and the school community. Unfortunately, these accusations can last a long time and only cause harm, and you also lose the trust of the school community. It's so important to have a member of the teachers' union here speaking for all the teachers. No, not all teachers
022felt that way. I want the board to reflect on the facts so that this person can recover her name because she was defamed. And I want to reiterate that this isn't about defending an individual; it's about protecting the integrity of the entire school community. Thank you for your attention and commitment to Iris Marcela. My name is Iris Marcela, and I had the pleasure of meeting Ms. Noel at the beginning of this school year. Her knowledge was evident. She gave us resources and training to help me understand the role and also how to comply with the guidelines and policies at PTA meetings. I saw Noel's commitment to advocating for the students of Fajari Jeffers. She maintains open communication with the teachers and parents. I have nothing but good things to say about her. I am grateful
023for her donating her time and energy to make a positive impact on our community. Thank you, Tris and Talamantes. Good night, everyone. Thank you for allowing us to speak and congratulate the new members. Welcome. I am Tris Talamantes, and I am a second-grade teacher. As a CBE member and proud teacher, I want to talk to you about the funding for teacher support. Our principal shared with us the CASP assessments and how our grades improved, and how proud we all are. Then we talked about how we were able to do this with the students and what supported them. What was the best support? It was very clear that the two things were the impact teachers and the teachers, and the classified staff who had small groups to support the students most in need. And then our
024principal also shared with us that the funding for that no longer exists. Please, I ask you to look at the budget, to analyze it. The students need it, the teachers need it. I am one person trying to meet the needs of 25 people who have different needs. I cannot meet all their needs as an individual alone. I need that support for the students, and my students desperately need the support. Please try to have these impact teacher positions ready again to have academic support for the lower elementary children. Please, I am begging you, our children need it. Thank you. There are no more speakers. District Security Update Mr. Romero Mr. Ugarte President Board Member Superintendent Dr. Reyes I'm presenting my update for January, a quick update on the projects we're having. We talked about our crossings
025at the school, and where we were meeting with the city, and they've shared that all the projects have been approved and will take between 6 and 24 months to complete. V Lindo is updating the forward signs, they're also installing signage for crossing, also installing a pedestrian crossing that meets the city of Chula Vista standards, also boxes, uh, a parking restriction, and Rogers to close a crossing on East Naples Street and at the school, a parking restriction on J Street in front of the school, and in Soto Mayor, uh, uh, the city is also going to install a four- sided pedestrian crossing and also the COVET protocol. Uh, the notification letter is no longer needed. The CEC notification letter, the trainings, our staff is regularly involved in training. Ah, for example, in W Canyon we did
026uh [Music] The threat assessment at Heritage, the AX training at Marshall, incident management, and the camera project are all still pending. The camera installations have been assessed, and the contractors have submitted a project outlining where these cameras can be placed. We have a timeline for this to be completed by June 30th, with the goal of having it ready by the 25th or 26th. You will notice if you go to the schools in the next week or two that each school is receiving these signs. We already talked about the schools being closed—sorry, they are open at entry and exit times, but from bell to bell, the only access is for authorized staff and volunteers. So this signage will be on our doors and access points on our 11x17 campuses. This will require attention. So, an update:
027Here I present our district security team. It is managed by Amed Wiggins, and he is the Security and Operations Program Manager. He has extensive experience in the security world, including with some of the most secure schools, such as UCSD, and then he said he had to serve where his granddaughter was going to school. And so that's why he decided to join CBSD. But he's trained in counterterrorism, how to stop bleeding, a lot of security stuff. And also, Daren Newborn is the school safety coordinator, and he's served 13 years in the armed forces. Really, the first time there's any indication of need, Teren is going to be in the schools providing these security services. And also, Mrs. Jenny and I, well, we watch this program. Also, any questions? Is there anyone who wants to talk about
028this article? Any questions or comments from the table? And that's fine. You don't have to say anything; we already know this happens every month. Thank you very much, Mr. Romero. We appreciate the updates; they help identify what's happening out there. But the crosswalks you were talking about, the Hillcrest school signs, are going to be a no- parking zone? There are two types of signage: we have signs that limit parking during these hours, and also the Red Zone, where you can never park. And after school, you'll be able to pick up your children. Yes, okay. So that's still a... The problem, I saw it in the board update. Maybe you can tell us what happened. I had a conversation with the city manager and addressed our concerns, and she's going to meet with the transit division.
029One of the problems was already identified when they did the traffic study; they did it on a weekend after school hours. So that's not when the problems are happening. And I sent Dr. Reyes a picture. Parents are turning around in the middle of the street. The dangers are during school hours, before and after school. I have another meeting, and I'm going to address this. And for Jeta Yoos, we had that incident where someone gained access to the school. I know you were going to have forums to address the parents. I don't have Med here, but we had approximately four. I do n't know if he's still here, but we had four community forums. The last one was after the board suggested this, and we had very positive feedback. Darren was there after the incident. Health
030feedback from the community regarding access to other schools. I can go to any school. Anyone. You can enter the school and have access, and that's it, right? So I know you wanted a variety of access control options. The doors are open. We worked with Mr. Mar Pong, and we also conducted visits. The operations team visited each school to see if it was something that could be implemented, whether it was a doorbell or cameras. But our goal is for all schools to have this type of access and the ability for our staff. All our staff are trained. Not all schools are. Right now, we are working with our schools to have as many trained people as possible. So I'm going to send it in my weekly update, and I can suggest that you also give it
031to the principals to see if they have 10 people who need it and can include our union partners. Unions, sorry, because we also have to see what those training sessions will be like. Will it be during school hours? Will it be on a Friday? Is it on Zoom? I don't know how that can work so that you can demonstrate it to them. So I'm wondering if you have enough information to be able to provide that training. I'm going to follow up and make sure they are included in our communication. What is the current model for the training? Great question. Mr. Tamayo, we did a training for all the staff, but this is another one where we go to our schools and give them active training where we press the button and everyone will have a
032notification. We are prioritizing working with our schools and having the principal decide when they want to have this training. We are leaving it up to the school to decide; a school can decide. We don't want to train until June; everyone has been trained. This is level two, so we want to have it ready by the end of the school year. We have a meeting with the safety committee once a month, and then we can talk about when the deadline should be. Thank you. We are training the substitutes, not yet, but it's part of our next step. Things with our substitutes need to be on your cell phone, and it's one that is recognized by each school. So, for example, let's say you were in Arroyo and then went to Liberia; you have to register each
033time. So what we are looking at is having about 10 iPads or tablets in each school so that the program is installed on those tablets, and when a The alternate arrives and can register this tablet in their name. This is something we're talking about doing right now, but the goal is to have every alternate have access to the tablet and receive training on how to use it. It would be recurring training. No, we don't stop any of our training. The training we did last year, we had the San Diego Police Department with us, on things like using a phone. We have a couple of training sessions in the district, but they also notify us annually that we'll have more training. Okay, thank you very much, Mr. Romero. Thank you for a good report on the
034Governor's 2526 State Budget Proposal, Mr. P. Thank you and good night, Mr. Ugarte, members of the board, Dr. Reyes, members of the community. Today, I have, just for your information, a report on the Governor's 2526 State Budget Proposal. So, he already gave the proposal on January 10th. We went to the workshop in Anahim. So, in general, as you can see, the Governor presented a balanced budget that assumes stable national growth and projects $17 billion with healthy reserves. So, in terms of reserves, there are two that focus on the budget. State of a rainy day and that maintains 1.5 billion in the public school system in the psss account and when we look at the LCF and that's how we receive almost all of our funds, the cost of living, or also known as cola, as
035for the 2025-2026 school year, ah, ah, now it went down because before it was 2.93 and now it's projected to be 2.43, and then in the 2026-2027 school year, 3.08, now it's projected to be 3.52, and we also have other programs like special education, they're also going to receive the 2.43 cost of living, and there's also legislation about the District reserve in 2025-2026, and that has to be, ah, there's not going to be an effective reserve when we look at other programs and proposals, student support and professional development, it's to support professional learning in English language and literature, math, and also in recruiting and retaining teachers, and we're also looking at emergency money for learning recovery, and this initiative is until 2027-2028, and also universal meals are projecting one billion meals which will be served
036in 25 26 and this is measured in how many hamburgers have been sold and in terms of Transition Kindergarten forward they have to be 4 years old by September first and it is also from 121 to 10 to one and also additional funds for recruitment and they are also going to be terminating to finish uh that the pack is not good for Transition Kindergarten so they want to look for another way and in terms of retirement systems CPERS is projecting an increase in 2526 from 2705 to 27.40 and also the ELOP program is proposing to make it lower before it was 75 per now 55 per. And our District is approximately 60 percent, and some risks to this State budget are market volatility, extreme weather events, delayed tax deadlines due to natural disasters, and migration.
037So, what are the steps for the budget now? The Senate and the Assembly have their subcommittees, and they're going to combine, and on June 15, they're going to send a proposal to the Governor, and then on June 30, they're going to reach an agreement. Questions, comments: I appreciate, Mark, that you talked about the risks. It's very important. So, I read the legislative analysis, and there was another report that I read, and one of its articles that I want to make a statement about is that you said this is a budget brought down to current policy. There are many assumptions we're making, and also what's happening with the budget. A few years ago, the BSA account had a requirement to deposit money there, and that has been suspended, and we've been using that money, and it's
038like using your savings. I know the County office specifically recommended that we encourage the District to remain conservative and also have contingency plans. Alternating for the last three or four years, we've been told, "Everything's fine. This is happening, but it's not okay." Every year it's been more in our face that we need to make sure we don't rely on others to give us money because when the money runs out, what happens to the taxes? And then it's a vicious cycle. So I really want to say that one of these comments that were made—well, this year our estimate is higher and more accurate— I just wanted to say that we should remain cautious and conservative, and I appreciate you naming the risks. Thank you. Oh, thank you very much. Can you give us a summary? When
039the taxes were delayed, what happened so that the new members know what this means? The tax delay can be a challenge for the state to know the money it's going to have, the profits it's going to have. Thank you. And now we have the fires. Are they going to delay the taxes? When they do that, well, there are things that are going to be delayed because we don't have the actual number. Thank you, Mr. Pong. Okay, now we're going to try the approval of the consent schedule. The following items under the consent schedule are considered for the board to take non-action. There will be discussion on these articles before they are devoted. Unless it is required that they be removed or discussed, that they be removed. Sorry members, this is when I ask you if
040any articles need to be removed for separate discussion. Yes, 10b, 10c with subsection CD, which is page 5 of 14, C, which is page 8 of 14, and 10d, F, H. Oh my god, I lost the letters, sorry. 10b, 10c with subsection CD, 5 of 14, CK, 8 of 14, and then 10d, 10f, 10h, 10i, 10j, 10k, 10m, 10m, and 10p. I take out the K. I have a motion to pass the consent agenda with these articles removed. Everyone in favor, say: I. The emotion passes unanimously. First, Dominguez Cervantes. 10b is a statement. Yesterday I gave Mrs. Araceli my note on the minutes, and I already know how to repost them as reviewed. But do you think the public should know there was a spelling mistake on page 93? It had finished an unfinished sentence
041that was on pages 93, 98, and 100. Then it changed the pages; it became 101 and 102, but the revision is on page 93. Thank you, Mrs. Araceli. With that, I request a motion to approve 10b. I second it. Mr. Tamayo requested it, Mrs. Cermes seconded it. The motion passes unanimously. Article 10c with CD. On page 5 of 14, it says "family resource assistant" and also " librarian." This is a new description. These are new positions, Dr. Reyes, Mr. Romero. Thank you. We try to update the job descriptions. We have two. This is a new position: the family resource assistant, and the librarian/purchaser specialist is one of our positions, but they are aligned with the processes and functions that require it. May I ask a question regarding the family resource assistant? Will the funds be
042from the community schools? Anything else, Mrs. Dominguez? No, thank you. And 10, and so that our Members understand, we don't approve 10 until it's page 8 of 14. I'm imagining you mean Cabana. This is retroactive payment to last year, Mr. Pong. Yes, we're having problems in business. That was with Rogers' pool. This is for general pool maintenance, but we're going back to July first to pay you. We didn't pay you, you didn't send us the services, you didn't do them, you did n't send us an invoice. It's because this was another company. So instead of paying Log, we're going to pay Cabana. I have a question. There's a consultant called Shield Security Systems. Can you explain a little more because this is a very small amount. What are you doing? We're going to plan for
043other doors, Mr. Pong. It's a locksmith company. It's annual services, not that we're replacing keys, right? More questions on 10. I request the approval of 10. Mr. Tamayo requested it, and Mrs. Dominguez Cervant seconded it. Everyone in favor, say: I, the motion passes unanimously. Article 10d: Approve the revised salary program for the Substitutes classified as of January 1, 2025. And we have someone who wants to talk about this, Ms. Angela. Thank you. I just want to point out that when we are looking at this revised salary for substitutes, some of these salary increases have n't even been requested. We don't even have an interpreter, a sign language interpreter. We don't have anyone hired, but we do have a substitute. But if you look at general maintenance, it's janitorial staff. When you look at the manager,
044it 's a 26. All of these are step one ranks. I have been requesting for four years that the salary for substitutes reflect the work they are doing, that it be the employee rank. Step one. That would solve our program. We wouldn't have to have it back on the table, and it would allow paramedics, secretaries, and office staff to take their right to be absent due to illness, personal reasons, or vacation without having to worry about leaving their jobs without someone to cover for them. Thank you. I agree with the increase in some of the classifications. It's good that you are doing it, but some of the others are not acceptable. I have a copy of the program. Regarding salaries, and the one they gave me this time, I would like to request that in
045the future, when you're changing it, you also give us a copy of the previous one so we can compare. Why are we changing it? Most of these are minimum wage salaries, and everyone knows my line, which I always say: when are we going to be at the same price as McDonald's? We have an ongoing problem: we don't have substitutes. It's something we hear about from certified classified personnel in student services, from instructional assistants, but we don't treat them that way. We have playground attendants. I know of a school that doesn't have enough substitute playground attendants because the children had to stay under the roof where the lunch tables are. But how are we going to encourage substitutes, people who want to come, when you're comparing? General maintenance went from 19 to 21, and the interpreter,
046who doesn't exist, went from 17.25 to 19.2. Computer support went from 23 to 26, almost a difference of 3. Everyone needs it, everyone needs it, but if the teacher has an assistant absent... In the classroom, the teacher is going to spend all their time trying to manage the needs of that student. There's also a loss of instruction. I recommend, I recommend, and that with the same increase, the others be increased as well. And I appreciate the recommendation. What's going through my mind right now is costing all of this. What is this? And Dr. Reyes, the camera F, oh, oh, it's a camera. When we're looking at the budget and things we're going to have to possibly cut in the future, I would like a cost increase for Miguel. Increase all of those because increasing the
047interpreter work, which doesn't exist, well, it's not going to have a physical impact, but we do have fiscal impact. But we do have, I don't know, 120 clerks, and these substitutes are used. She made a valid point. So we have to... I understand the cost. Because we just shared with Mark about being conservative, but there are things that are not negotiable, that shouldn't be negotiable, or that shouldn't be on the table. I'm going to tell you to tread carefully and say that it's not negotiable. And that's another thing. I'm here. I don't want to be negotiating, and they're not part of the negotiations unit. But before we do a... Negotiation is that cost. I would like to make a motion to test this as it is, but also ask the District how the rates for
048these positions in El Paso One should be changed and what it would cost. So that the Board can make an informed decision if we elevate these to El Paso One. What would it look like? It's a motion. You could recall, I have the explanation, and I want to second it. I just want the motion to include, yes, and be clear to the District. But I can summarize it. So I'm going to summarize it to approve the article so that the District sends us a cost analysis for the appropriate classification. I second it. Any discussion? We can invent that to give a timeline for the next Board meeting. Is there enough time? I approve it. So any further discussion on this? We have a motion. Mr. Tamayo requested it. President Ugarte seconded it. Everyone in favor.
049I pass the motion. Thank you. They just approved this. Very good. Article F 10f. Ratify the reports of the student responsibility grades for the 2023-2024 school year. As Dr. Reyes commented, Boxes of reports arrive, and believe it or not, reviewing them takes a long time. This last time, he had the reports ready, and thank you for coming to read them to me. They gave them to me on Thursday, but I also took the opportunity to compare numbers that overlapped in other reports in December. I also received the 2023, 2024, and 2024 Student Achievement Plan, and I had the opportunity to look at the California Dashboard. What I found is that we 're looking at a report for 2023, 2024, 2025, and what's currently on the dashboard, and there were almost no inconsistencies, even in specific
050year-to-year demographic data in these reports. This struck me as odd. Why should there be changes? I have copies here, examples. But it seems like something is wrong, something isn't right, there should be changes. So what I did, and I'll talk about this in more detail in article 12, is that when there were differences, they didn't reflect the changes or the change in another category when they should have, and everything was the same. Even when there were numbers of 2023, the difference in the numbers didn't affect the rest. If they remove 30 children, it wouldn't affect the other demographics. I just do n't feel comfortable approving this article because it seems to have been copied and pasted, with the exception of a few things. And although we assumed there were no differences, some of the numbers
051were stagnant. There were four that showed changes. I noticed few changes, even when there were numbers, changes in the numbers were considerable. I just wanted to tell you the reasoning behind why I won't be approving this article. I have a question for Mr. Reyes: Where does the information come from? Many sections of our school accountability report are generated by the information we provide to the California Department of Education. Principals also review it, as does the communications director. All this information is generated based on the reports given by the state. I think there will always be human error. But we have all schools with some three or four [unclear - possibly "unclear" or "unclear"] schools. There must be something that would raise suspicion or alert the ALCAP. They use numbers from these reports to identify some
052other issues that I will bring up in Article 12 that I believe we shouldn't examine. I've done a comparison of the IPSA figures with the SARC figures, and we expect them to be similar since we're using our data system and the California dashboard. So they're consistent across documents, meaning they're year after year, even the same student enrollment numbers. I have n't done an analysis of the SARC specifically, but we can verify that the SARC information is accurate: 20, 23, 20, 24, 20, and it has the exact enrollment numbers. It just doesn't add up. I can't do it. If there are no more comments or questions, I request a motion to approve Article 10f, Mr. Dominguez's motion, provided that an analysis is done of what Mrs. Dominguez expressed, seconded by President Ugarte. In favor, say "
053I," everyone in favor. Everyone, say "I," and put one abstention. I mean, it was a motion to pass 10h, the approval of the change order for the security camera project request. My question is 8 7,855 is a substantial increase. What was the offer from the other vendors, Dr. Reyes? Mr. Pong, the initial offer after they did the tour, that's a review based on the needs of the schools, that's why the order changed, the type of cameras being requested, and the other, the other lower offer is lower than the second offer. I appreciate your preparation. Motion to approve it, Mrs. Dominguez, seconded by Mr. Tamayo in favor. I say, the motion passes unanimously. Article 10i, one question: Is the Maswell Center fully functional? Is everything working, Dr. Reyes? Mr. Pong, can you share where we are
054in terms of space and operation? The workshop is finished. One of the recommendations/suggestions that we analyzed is to add a PAXI seal where the buses park. We are in the process of preparing the documents for it. So we anticipate when this project will be completed, finished, a few months, a couple of months. Thank you very much. Motion, but it will be finished by another contractor. We will see another contractor. Motion to approve. Motion seconded by the Sir, I am in favor. Say, I, the motion passes unanimously. This Article 10 J approves the awarding of the bidding package. I appreciate the contextual information, but I want to know. I would like to know when the projected completion date is. To be honest, I don't know anyone. I went online to see the data from October 18.
055You should see. It seems like quite a few algorithms. I had to stop. You can't find the information. I think those who responded were the ones who were contacted directly by email. Is there another method we can use? To call on circulation to make a bid, and also the completion date? Sir, the date, the timeline. Yes, you can investigate. When we announce a position for the projects, make sure that other potential contractors... So we are starting with the bidding. The second stage will be completed by the beginning of the next school year, July 18. Other contractors also... We communicate with contractors who have the license to carry out this type of project. This is one of the requirements. But we can look for other methods. Motion to approve the motion by Secretary Cervantes, seconded by
056Mr. Tamallo, all in favor, say I. The motion passes unanimously. We said we can vote for Article K. Motion to approve Article K. Second motion by Vice President Mayo and seconded by Secretary Cervantes, all in favor, say I. The motion passes. We have Article M. It has been approved. Article has been approved. We can. We will return. 10m. Know that I had a problem with it. 10m. Approve the agreement with Runan Clark for architectural services for the V Lindo Elementary School modernization project. They are doing the construction, but BFOR is monitoring the work. The project, Dr. Reyes, could you explain that? R Clark, are the architects? They are talking about monitoring the work. We need it in Article 10m. Perhaps the question for the superintendent: can you explain a little more what BFOR does in
057terms of monitoring the contractors? Sir, could you explain to the table the roles of the architects? I can have an entity for Article M, but in the article, but is in charge of monitoring the projects in Val Lindo. Could you explain the roles? How are each contractor different and how do they work together? The architects are the ones who design the project, the construction managers are the ones who supervise on behalf of the district. So in the future, we're going to submit another proposal for a contractor to build the school. So they're not doing the construction, but they're doing the monitoring. And I think we've talked about that. We've addressed that conversation with other companies. When we hire a qualified company, we hire another qualified company to monitor what's happening. But now we have to
058hire another company to monitor. I don't want to presuppose, but that company you mentioned a few months ago regarding the construction is completely separate. The construction company is the one that manages and monitors. My questions stem from being fiscally responsible. Motion to approve, seconded by the Vice President of Tamaya. All in favor, say I. The motion passes unanimously. 10. To approve the agreement with Frontline Technologies for the amount of $67,890.40. That's the application connected to the subal where the employees pay a fee. Let me share. I had two teachers. They told me two months ago that they weren't finding substitute jobs because I think they weren't paying the Frontline membership dues. If the dues are true, where does that money go, Dr. Reyes? Mr. Pong, perhaps we'll have to refer those two members to our
059knowledge. There isn't a dues fee that requires being registered with Frontline to receive calls. We 've never heard of this. They sent me a screenshot of it. We'll follow up. Can you send me the screenshot, please? We have a motion to approve Article 10, seconded by Secretary Cervantes and Mr. Tamaya. All in favor, say I. The motion passes unanimously. Article 10p: to approve and/or ratify the service requests. One quick question: In Council 2024, they say that several members of Reyes and Mrs. Morales are making money. Could it be a A rat says practically the same price, some indicate one day, others indicate three days. Maybe it's a rat, maybe it's the 13,000. Currently, it's a conference of the sea. The funding is the subsidy. Where does that subsidy come from? Where are those funds obtained?
060Who has access to this subsidy? Do they apply? Do they have to apply? Mrs. Morales, could you ask for your answer? I want to make sure I understand. Due to the economic difficulties, is it specifically for this conference, or what is it for? No, the subsidy can include other items. It's professional training for our instruction team and also for our directors who are launching and leading these initiatives at their schools. There can be other items that are funded with this subsidy. It's not the same as every day, which goes to all our expenses. Every day there are many expenses. Thank you very much. I was just very sure if you found this subsidy or if it's available for other opportunities. The employees, the classified employees, yes, they can go. We don't have classified employees who
061are going to this training; however, it would be appropriate in the future for the classified personnel who support learning to be able to attend. Thank you very much. Regarding the same topic, there are only three schools that are going to put In practice, we currently have three principals who are going to implement cultures of thinking. We also use a reading club, and we are expanding this group. We have 17 members this year. What we do is provide this professional training to our leaders so that they can take that training to their schools, and the same is true for the members of our instruction team. This allows us to save money because it's training within our district, and thus we save money. A follow-up question: Is there certification for this training? That's a good question. Thank
062you very much. If there are no further questions, this motion to approve Article P, motion by Secretary Cervantes, seconded by Member [Name], the motion passes unanimously. Before moving to our Elements of Administrative Action, where we will take a 5- minute recess and return at 7:45, by [Name]. All members are present. We will adopt a resolution of the Board of Trustees of the Chuel Vista Elementary School District appointing officers and taking related actions. Pong, thank you, President Ugarte, tonight for your recommendation of officers for the board of directors of the Facilities Financing Corporation. This is what we use for the application of our bonds. This is the only time we call a board meeting for a separate meeting to try the president. The president of the board is the vice president, and with Oscar's retirement, I
063will become president. Mr. Reyes, typically the secretary, and the director of Fiscal Services are the heads of... We don't have speakers in this article. The PSF PSP will be conducted in this manner, as Mr. described. We are going to elect a president and vice president, and with Mr. Esquivel's retirement, the resignation of... This is a measure of action. We need a motion to adopt the officers that were mentioned by Mr. Pong. The motion to approve was seconded by Member Servantes and seconded by Ms. Dominguez in favor of the approval of the officers. There was no opposition, and the motion passed unanimously. With the conclusion of this article, we adjourn this meeting. [Music] Now We resumed the board meeting. In fact, we are at the agenda item of accepting the 2023-24 annual audit report of the
064Chula Vista Elementary School District. Mr. Pong, thank you, Chairwoman Ugarte. We have Brian Henley here, and he will give a summary of the audit, a modified audit. Good evening. I appreciate the opportunity to present the audit report to the board tonight. I mentioned that when I see a report, I always do these three things, and I would like to tell you what they are so that it can help you when you see audit reports in the future. The first thing I look at is the first page of the audit; it's the accountant's opinion. It's the most important part of the entire report. Your report is over 120 pages long. And if you look at all the numbers [Music] How can you see that the most important page is the page that communicates the accountant's opinion.
065It's the financial statement as of June 30, 2024. There are four types of opinions you can receive. The best is an unmodified opinion, which you also received. You can also receive a qualified opinion, an adverse opinion, or a qualified opinion. These three are the ones that will cause you... There were problems regarding funding, but they received an unmodified opinion, which is the best opinion they can receive. That's the first thing I always look at. The second thing I look at is at the end of the report. There's a section of findings or conclusions. As Mr. Mark said, there are two compliance findings. There's a rule that you have to have a permanent teacher credential for more than 30 days in the same classroom for more than 30 days. The second, and quite unusual, had to
066do with a student who didn't have the required vaccinations to attend school. This student was receiving cancer treatment and didn't have the vaccinations. There was a medical certificate stating that they would receive the vaccinations after finishing treatment. To obtain this exemption from having the vaccinations, there's a state agency, California Immunization Registration Medical Exception. Fortunately, the district didn't apply for that extension. Those were the two things I found. In fact, I have n't seen these types of cases in a long time, but that's the second thing I analyze to see if there are any findings, anything that needs to be brought to the attention of the board. So, there were two compliance findings. The last thing I look at is the very last page of the audit, which is a requirement. It says if there were
067findings in previous years, the report in previous years, if those findings were resolved. I am pleased to say that there were no findings in the 2023-2024 audit report. But if you look at those three things: the opinion, the findings, and if the findings in previous years were resolved, it is a good indicator of what the district is doing throughout the year. As I told you, this audit report is more than 12-20 pages long. I don't want to bore you with the technical details, but I will gladly answer any questions you may have. We don't have speakers at this point. Comments, questions from the table. This is an action item. There is a motion to accept the audit report. The motion to accept the report, by Member Dominguez, seconded by Vice President Tamayo, in favor. I
068say, the motion passes unanimously. Next, to adopt a resolution of the Chuel Vista Elementary School District Board of Education certifying all procedures in the election of general obligation bonds on November 5, 2024, for Measure AA. We have A resolution for your approval of the November 5th election for measure AA. This approval will verify this. We have no speakers at this item. Questions or comments from the Board. This is an item of action. A motion to adopt this resolution. Motion to approve it. Motion by Member Cervantes, seconded by Vice-President Mayo. In favor. I. The motion passes unanimously. To adopt a resolution for emergency services and equipment pursuant to sections 22035 and 2050 of the Public Contracts Code. Mr. Pong, we have for your approval an emergency resolution that would extend our contract to supply a generator.
069Originally, we were anticipating that the parts would be delivered earlier this month so we could install it, but there is a delay. It looks like it will be delivered on January 31st, and we have to make an appointment with SDNG for the installation. So we need a little more time for delivery. Thank you, Mr. Pong. There are no speakers at this item. Questions or comments from the Board. This is an item of action. A motion to approve it. Motion seconded by Mr. Tamayo and seconded by Member Cervantes in favor, I say the motion passes unanimously. Very good. We have elements of general information. This section is for new members. This is to request from Dr. Reyes regarding our School District. Reyes, we don't have any speakers. Is there anyone who wants to request a report?
070If you are new, if you want to see what we requested, you can do so next time. It seems I have five reports that I would like to request. The first one I would like to know is, I know that last month when I brought it up, he told me he would start working on it in February. But I didn't want to lose sight of the formula for determining which schools have the support of an assistant principal, either fully or partially. We look at it in its entirety. As we are proposing changes related to hiring and staffing, it is something we will analyze next month. We will vote on some changes for the board, and that will be taken into consideration. Could you then bring us in February the formula that you are using to
071date so that I can have a comparison, ask questions such as the schedule chart and how it was being handled before, and so that my questions are better informed? That would be the second I requested the Title One funds. Thank you, Mark. Yes, you sent them to me a month and a half ago. What I want to know is a report that captures the parameters and criteria being used for these funds. I wanted to share a concern: we don't have playground equipment, or there are holes in the slides, and the money is just sitting there, sitting in storage. I know that members Tamay Garte went to other schools and shared their concerns a few months ago. A parent approached me about how they had spoken with their principal about when they were going to get
072equipment— balls. I bought balls, jump ropes, and I did n't ask for a refund. Another parent, as you know, approached me from another classroom at another school, and that worries me. So when I see Title One money that I know is transferred year after year, and we talk about the disparities between the West and the East, and we worry, and I speak with President Rosy Martinez frequently, she always addresses it, as does Mrs. Angela, with whom we talk about equity, and we see all that money sitting there, money that is meant for those children who need it. There needs to be a better way. What are the parameters? What are the criteria? What are the exceptions for using this money? Because I saw something like $200,000 that was carried over to the next year when
073the students feel like second- class citizens and their schools aren't as nice, they aren't as new as other schools. It doesn't make it worse. I know my colleagues feel the same way. They've addressed this before, and in previous years and months, we really need to know what the parameters are. What can be done? Because if you tell me I can spend a million dollars and I can spend it, I would spend it. So, love, they don't know the parameters, they don't know the criteria. I do n't know. Please, can you pass that information on to me? And I'm going to talk to you. Just to summarize, there's a table update, a report on the parameters, requirements, and exceptions for using Title I funds. Our students are there with no equipment, with nothing to play with,
074and the teachers... and they're expected to... and the teachers think the students are out there burning all their energy, but no. The third thing is, the teachers are listening, and I know that President Rosy shares with me frequently. I always address it, it doesn't mean she hasn't already. Who else is she sharing it with? But I will address this. We agree that we don't want students in front of a computer screen because interaction with people is what they need. If they need help with homework, with special assignments, that can be monitored. In fact, it was the parents who brought it to my attention. They hear that it's going away and they're surprised. Why? Because they all feel that this individualized program that comes to them—I've been with my granddaughters and their daughters too—is really helpful.
075It helps teachers, like having another tutor, seeing the students, having that personalized support. Yes, it's going to go. I would like to know if that program is going to go or not with respect to Chip 3000. We're going to have the financial and educational implications, like how effective it is academically and how it aligns with student achievement. So we're going to have that discussion and we're going to present something to the board because it's good. It gives them immediate feedback regarding reading comprehension. How are they going to evaluate its effectiveness? We can do now or in the update of the table how do they know if it's effective? I don't know. The fourth report, this, the parents report that the evaluations, when parents get the report cards from the teachers, the parents depend on the
076teachers. They don't get them mailed like before. So the teachers depend on the teachers to provide them with this information, but the results don't mean anything to them. What it does say is there's no key that tells them what the results mean. They get the reports, they have a random number. They do n't know if their child is progressing or is below grade level. And you have young children, I think you want to know if they're just barely meeting expectations. [Music] I 've seen this on our website. The teachers send it to the parents. Um, make sure your children go to bed early and eat a good breakfast. So parents want feedback on their children's performance. For example, on the report card, a four doesn't specify if they're above grade level or a two approaching
077expectation. How does that differ from a three? This is it. It does n't help the parents. It doesn't tell them how their children are performing. I think all parents want to know exactly where their children stand so they can... If we want parental participation and collaboration, we need to provide that. But if it's something we teachers create, we just give it to the parents. What is your request regarding the report card? Explaining to the parents what those numbers mean. There isn't a standardized one. It's not uniform. Ms. Dominguez, I want to make sure of what you're requesting. What are you asking for? Do you want us to send you a code? Do you want us to address it during the parent-teacher conference week? What is your request? To meet with the union and see what
078they need because it's a burden for teachers to have to explain, or not, to have to work with parents for 30 minutes, what the report card means, why this teacher gives this grade. That's more than a report card, and we're standardized, and we have to send the parents the code. Obviously, it costs more money to mail it, but if the report that the teachers give to the parents had the... Key, at least they could understand what the grades mean. If we could add this, and I addressed it months ago, and the other thing is more of a task, the report cards aren't uniform with respect to the numbers. What's the difference between one and the other, and approaching compliance? What we can do is this instead of saying we have a report card committee made
079up of district administrators. I'm going to meet with Chairwoman Ros Martinez and we're going to talk about what Member Cervantes addressed. Thank you for analyzing it. I think we're at the point where we should conduct a management study. There's a lot of noise on social media and our human resources. I think it's time to ask them how they can add value. I researched what they do: investigate potential problems and solve small problems. It's a better strategy than waiting for the problem to affect the finances and making recommendations for improvement. They review our processes, identify gaps in practices, and make practical recommendations. Management assistance uses an approach for specific conditions. I always welcome the invitation. How can we improve? I'd like to ask you To the president, if we can make a motion, if you accept
080a motion so that this request for this report for these services, we can at this point, we can potentially put it on the agenda, an agenda item, to make a motion, and it can be seconded, just for everyone in favor. He wants a resource study of the processes, a scope. Also, I read what they do. They meet with all of us to identify the scope with the local entity, the organization, the process from publication to contracting, the processes that [Music] we have from the point of contact, both of the integration, what we can do better. That would be at the next meeting. Another point we should analyze is that it may be a small department for our district. Maybe we need more staff. I think that's one of the things that another part... uh, analyze
081if we need more staff. Dr. Romero could be looking at the operation. To support a district as large as ours, when we add schools, we don't think about adding to the staff structure. I will meet with him next month with the scope, based on the information he just provided us, and after that, when we have the item on the agenda, if he wants to add... Another scope, another article as part of the scope, you tell me and we add it, it works for you, thank you very much, Dr. Reyes. If we can schedule an extraordinary meeting that focuses on two aspects of the roles and responsibilities of the board members, we can do that at the end of February, does that sound good to you, at the end of February, send and then, after, we
082schedule it based on your responses, common board announcements, board members communicate to the public, events, events related to the district since they were at the last board meeting, member, welcome to this empowerment process about what you see, member Cervantes, it was a short month but I feel that the union presidents have breaks because when I spoke with them they had met with several people. We had a touch meeting yesterday that I attended, it was very informative It motivates the different programs we have with the lead program. That was good. I also asked the gentleman, the gentleman, when they publish the application to let the parents know because some of the calls we receive are from people who didn't know it was published. Now the opportunity to enroll my son has closed, so I met with
083both presidents of the union and I am waiting to meet with the associate directors. That will be my visit. I met with some parents about some concerns that I already shared. I appreciate and thank our speakers for coming and sharing their concerns as well. Thank you very much, Vice President. I didn't go anywhere, but I do want to welcome our new board members, Dominguez and Member To. Obviously, there are times when these meetings run long. This is not our goal; it is to be as efficient as possible while asking the right questions and having the right information to make decisions that not only affect our students but also our staff. So welcome. I want to welcome all the staff back from winter break. I hope you had a good vacation during the winter break. The
084holiday season to reunite with their families. As member Cervantes said, it seems that the union presidents didn't take a break because they were... I want to thank you for the feedback you gave us because it helps me understand the issues. Thank you, and now thank you very much. This is the beginning in our three associations in the district. I appreciate your comments. I especially appreciate the professional collaboration aspect of working with the union presidents. One of the things I was able to do before the holidays, and it was the most fun, was to go to the career day at Los Altos. And I was the most popular because I brought stickers, and I didn't give them just one sticker; I gave them many stickers. That was very fun, very exciting for me. The students were
085a little nervous because they were second-grade and fifth-grade students in the same classroom, and there is a big difference in attention span. It was very exciting to be there, and now everyone knows that Dr. Reyes... It's great that Dr. Reyes' bosses were at Los Altos. Welcome back, and I look forward to the second part of the school year. Dr. Reyes, it's your turn. First of all... I want to thank and welcome our new members. Your first meeting is over. Welcome! I'm sure many things were new to you, but you'll become familiar with them. In a month, you'll understand. We are very fortunate to have you. I also want to thank the union leaders, the teachers, and everyone else, including my incredible cabinet, and everyone who supports the work we do. I know you spend many,
086many hours working to make sure everything is ready. We are looking forward to a new semester and an excellent second semester. I look forward to the success of our students. Thank you. The next regular meeting of the board will be held on February 19, 2025, at 4:00 p.m. for the closed session and at 6:00 p.m. for the open session. Motion to adjourn, seconded by member Ramírez Domínguez. All in favor, say: I adjourn the session.