001e e e the regular meeting of the Chula Vista Elementary School District Board of Education is now in order welcome everyone all board members are present except for vice president Tayo we will now approve the agenda is there a motion motion to approve is there a second second uh moved by truste Dominguez santes seconded by trusty tolston all of those in favor I I motion carries four one absent oral Communications the oral communication section provides the public with an opportunity to address the board on close session items only persons wishing to be heard May attend in person and should complete a request to be heard card and submited to the recording secretary before the start of the meeting speakers are requested to limit their remarks to 3 minutes and speak in a respectful and professional
002manner the board shall limit the total time for public input on each topic to 20 minutes with board consent the president may increase or decrease the time allowed for public comments depending on the number of persons wishing to be heard no board action can be taken there are no speakers we will now adjourn to close session in accordance with the following government code section 35491 D and 54957.6 collective bargaining employee negotiations LLP and Adam Silva and MCN LLP employee organizations Chula Vista classified employees organization Chula Vista Educators non-represented employees administrators Association Chula Vista government code section 54957 B1 Public Employee discipline dismissal release government code section 54956.9 D1 conference with legal councel existing litigation and the office of administrative hearings case number 01094 government code section 54956.9 D1 conference with legal councel existing litigation and
003the office of administrative hearings case number e e e we now reconvene to open session with all board members present please let the minutes reflect that truste Tamayo arrived at 4:18 close session announcements will be made by the clerk in to regarding government code section 54956.9 D1 conference with legal counsel existing litigation and office of administrative hearing case number 01094 on motion by member tomayo second by member Dominguez cantes the board approved the settlement agreement by the following vote the A's were five no zero abstentions zero in regards to government code section 54956.9 D1 conference with legal councel existing litigation in office of Administrative Hearings case number 0799 on motion by Dominguez serantes second by member Ramirez Dominguez the board approved the settlement agreement by the following vote the A's were five no zero exstension
004zero that's all thank you the Open session of the regular meeting of the Chula Vista Elementary School District Board of Education is now in order welcome everyone all members are present and trusty Tolson if you'll lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands na under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you we will now approve the agenda is there a motion so moved second move by vice president de Mayo seconded by clerk do Dominguez cantes all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously communication to the Board of Education Chula Vista classified employees organization Miss Angela Reed good evening Schoolboard first I would like to congratulate both Karen Ramirez Dominguez and Jessica tolston for the respective appointments to
005the Chula Vista Elementary School Board I look forward to a future of collaboration ation and know we can work together to uplift classified employees across the district advancing professional development increasing compensation and improving working conditions for classified employees bolstering the core infrastructure of our schools I would like to take this opportunity to highlight the classified service and what support we collectively provide to the district and to student achievement before I do I want to share an experience at a parent Forum I attended during the construction of our new school scho Sonia soor Elementary School at The Forum the district gave a presentation about the new school and what to expect and mentioned classified employees towards the end a parent asked for clarification in regards to the presentation and specifically asked if the parents would be
006told the names of the employees erroneously implying the most commonly used definition of the word classified as secret rather than the adjective form used to mean categories this mistake of definition while funny after the fact illustrates an existing disparity between classified and other employees most commonly schools are described through the lens of teacher student and administrator Administration the essential but invisible tasks are carried out by classified employees day in and day out to keep those schools running allowing those schools to thrive too often classified employees are not celebrated with the same emphasis as other other groups of employees and are first to be pushed to the background when resources are scarce for instance we are the first to be laid off to balance the budget Additionally the district goes to Great Lengths to ensures adequate
007substitute employees are available to fill gaps in teacher and administrator availability while efforts to do the same for classified employees are woefully inadequate unfortunately intended or not it also sends a very clear message to classified employees about their perceived value to describe just a few of the many ways classified employees support students classified employees are the first to greet students at the front Gates the office and outside the classroom waiting for the school day to begin we are the home to school connection with bus and van drivers transporting students to and from school every day classified employees feed students providing one of the fundamental tenants of maso's hierarchy of needs of food shelter and clothing CNS provides both breakfast and lunch to all students at each School site and even delivers an afternoon stack snack
008to all students that participate in the lead program we provide safe supervision for students to play and express themselves we provide instructional support with par professional Educators able to provide small group instruction to the most needy students our front office office employees are the face of the school connecting with parents to keep students at school and in seats thereby increasing the Ada the same Ada the district so desperately relies on to function My Hope tonight is that you recognize the vital work that we classified employees provide to the district and that you prioritize our needs accordingly sometimes this is related to funding other times this requires prioritization and recognition of our challenges and needs specific spefically I ask that maintaining and filling all required classified positions receive priority over other discretionary items rather than utilizing
009classified Manning reductions as a means to balance the budget thank you thank you CH L Vista Educators Miss Rosie Martinez good evening and welcome to I want to start off by welcoming trusty tolston and trusty Ramirez Dominguez to our school board cbe's goal is to have mutually respectful and collaborative relationships with school board members we find this to be very important since board members have a responsibility to pass policies and make decisions that directly impact our students and their families our staff and our chista community the board's understanding of cbe's concerns is crucial to ensure that all who attend chil Vista schools who work in chil Vista schools or who interact with the chil Vista school district will find a safe place here that they find a welcoming space for all as I said in
010the special board meeting last Friday the Schoolboard trustees should serve the interest of education and the interest of the community trustees should not pursue their personal agendas on behalf of chista Educators I ask that as you take on this role you keep in the Forefront that the vision of this District includes a commitment to providing a successful safe challenging and nurturing educational experience while promoting the joy and importance of learning for all students our shared values include that each child is an individual of great worth that all children deserve equal access to Quality education we must seek encourage and respect each individual's contributions we must value a multicultural perspective in order for chivista educators and all staff to create safe and welcoming environments for our students the staff need to feel that the place of
011employment offers them a safe and welcoming environment as well in the Chul Vista board policy equity and access section it states that the district shall eradicate institutional bias and racism of any kind including implicit or unintentional biases and prejudices that negatively impact students academic achievement social emotional well-being and access to Opportunities and will eliminate disparities in educational outcomes for students from historically underserved and underrepresented populations board decisions shall not rely on biased or stereotypical assumptions about any particular group of students parents guardians or staff in this time of uncertainty we need to say clearly as a district that we support all our students regardless of their citizenship status of their identity of their ability of their race or of their gender and once again these values are not limited to the students that we serve
012but to those who work in our district I would like to remind you that the Constitution of the United States explicitly provides that the government and including Public Schools cannot promote or endorse a specific religion Public Schools cannot require religious education or prayer and that school officials must remain neutral and not encourage or discourage religious activities I look forward to working with you in our advocacy for our students and staff CV continues to be committed to the proactive to be proactive and problem solving in the challenges that arise we will continue to prioritize safety social emotional support academic interventions and our work around Community Schools I wanted to congratulate Dr Paula Patel and Maria Montgomery on their promotions Dr Patel has been instrumental in the work with our youngest students and Miss Montgomery an important
013addition to the instruction Department their background and knowledge have already begun to play an important role in our work work I appreciate that the district continues to create opportunities to uplift the voice of Staff in this plan around rigorous learning for all I encourage everyone to participate in the upcoming teacher roundtables we are happy to announce that we will be bargaining with the district next week and believe that we are very close to settling our contract we hope to have a TA to bring to you next month as well as the Articles to Sunshine for our next round of bargaining we are never done we're always finding ways to better memorialize language that create clear and mutual understandings of our work together wishing everyone a productive second half to this school year thank you thank
014you admin administrators Association Chula Vista Miss Teresa Corona good evening president ugar members of the board superintendent Dr Rees on behalf of the administrators Association ch Vista I'd like to welcome our two newest trustees trustee tolston and truste Ramirez cantes uh congratulations on your appointments and thank you for your willingness to serve our community in this vital role aacv looks forward to the fresh perspectives and contributions you will bring to our district I would also like to take this time to let our new board members as well as our previous board members uh that AAC represents the dedicated principles and Associate principles who work Tire tirelessly to lead our schools support our teachers and most importantly ensure the success and well-being of our students and school communities we are one of three unions in this
015school district and we are also the newest Union in the school district working under our F first contract this year our mission is to advocate for our members to have a voice at the table and to build collaborative relationships that enhance the educational experience for every student in the district we strive to be a partner with the board and the district working together in what I have stated several times in professional partnership to uphold our standards of education and Equity as you all begin your service on this board together I want to emphasize aac's commitment to that collaboration and partnership the decisions made in this room impact the lives of thousands of students families and Educators it is AAC CV's greatest hope that you all as board members approach your work with a focus on
016what is best for our students aligning your efforts with our District's mission and vision your ability to model respectful dialogue thoughtful deliberation and collaborative problem solving will serve as an important example for the students we educate and Inspire every day we continue to seek to have a voice at the table and to make that voice uh present at the table as we seek to address the challenges and opportunities that lie ahead including in the rigorous learning for all plan there are big decisions ahead and aacv hopes that we can make informed and Equitable decisions that prioritize the needs of our students our staff and our school communities I in closing thank you all for your service and dedication not only our new members but our existing members uh and that dedication is to the children
017and families and our school communities in our district I ACB looks forward to collaborating with you as we continue uh to navigate our work in education with that courage compassion and shared commitment to Excellence that we all have thank you thank [Applause] you oral Communications the oral Communications section provides the public with an opportunity to address the board on non-agenda items persons wishing to be heard May attend in person and should complete a request to be heard card and submit it to the recording secretary before the start of the meeting speakers are requested to limit their remarks to 3 minutes and speak in a respectful and professional manner the board shall limit the total time for public input on each topic to 20 minutes with board consent the president may increase or decrease the time
018allowed for public comments depending on the number of persons wishing to be heard no board action can be taken we have eight speakers this evening first we have Christy M okay good evening as a parent at Rogers I want to start by expressing my gratitude for appointing principal Rodrigo as our interim principal we're incredibly thankful for the thoughtful decision to bring in someone with such extensive experience his leadership has already made such a profound difference and both staff and parents have already felt the positive impact within just this this week as we look ahead to selecting a permanent principal I respectfully ask that you consider someone who not only brings experience in elementary leadership but also a demonstrated commitment to increasing parental engagement we all know how crucial that partnership is research consistently shows that
019when parents are involved students succeed not just academically but socially and emotionally as well strong parental engagement is a Cornerstone of the thriving School Community we all want for our children I also want to take a moment to advocate for our acting associate principal since day one she has shown unwavering commitment to our children and staff working tirelessly to ensure that everyone's needs are met her leadership has been invaluable and I truly believe she is welld deserving of the opportunity to step into this role permanently her deep understanding for our school community and her dedication to the success of our students and staff make her an ideal candidate for this important position this decision regarding leadership is so important and I sincerely hope that it is not rushed Rogers is a special place and we
020need a principal who understands our unique challenges and strengths I believe it is essential to take the time to carefully select a principal who can guide us forward with empathy vision and the ability to connect with our staff students and families thank you for your time and for considering the future of our school with such care and dedication thank you thank you Randy Lin erera Randy ly erera sorry I'm not my name is Randy Etta and my son is a first grader at Rogers I it was really hard for me to see my son struggle in dis like going to school having both kindergarten classes combined not only affected our children but also affected us as parents and I hope that this will also be considered for the following school year I'd like to thank
021the teachers parents and for advocating for the children that are unable to do so for themselves and the board for coming to our school and honestly coming and seeing that we it was something that needed to happen um and splitting the classes um I can already see and feel a big difference in our school just since returning from break I am truly looking forward to this new chapter at Rogers and I hope we can continue good track under leadership from someone who understands children and like I said thank you I mean if we don't speak up nobody will so um thank you that's it thank you Rosemary Lowry I would like to respectfully ask for 30 more seconds if I could Bo okay thank you good evening first I would like to congratulate the trustees
022that were recently appointed I encourage you to be bold and not to do things just to be popular but to do it because it is right you have the education of nearly 30,000 students in your hands many of which are students with disabilities students with limited resources and new English Learners when faced with difficult decisions remember that you you are here to serve our students and please do not let politics or other interests Cloud your judgment I'm here today as an involved parent who is concerned with the defamation of character of a parent leader during the special meeting by our certificated Union Representatives I want to speak to Noel Craven's character and how shortsighted disrespectful and destructive slandering a parent is to the mission and values of cbsd Noel Cravens is a PTA uh president
023for farari Jeffers Elementary she was brave enough to confront serious issues concerning our school at a board meeting last year issues that the District board and previous principal were well aware of but were not being addressed in a timely manner considering the severity of the issues what Noel CRA Craven said regarding those incidents for students with disabilities and students who were being bullied was true I know this is true because my child was one of the children whom she advocated for I know these families and I know these children at my lowest points last year when I was going against a figure who had more power than I who was by all accounts very popular within this District Noel was not afraid she was Brave when I couldn't be for this reason I'm troubled by
024the public comment and the precedent it sets for for parents who speak up what was said about her could not have been further from the truth she is a steadfast advocate for staff students and their families she brought students and parents to the fold that were normally excluded she Champions teachers inclusion efforts and brought forth a PTA program that has given back over $122,000 and supplies and supplemental programs to our teachers and their students fahari Jeffers is a very special Community with many amazing teachers a wonderful staff and wonderful principal it is disheartening that the progress that we have all worked towards could be derailed by a small group of individuals who won't let us heal from last year's events advoc advocacy should not be discouraged it should be celebrated what these what are these
025actions saying to our students if they speak up they will be excluded their parents will be ostracized please look to your mission don't just speak your values live them make sure that your actions align with your words and for any future parents speaking out please ensure that this will continue to be a safe space to speak to our Representatives that when we speak up we'll be allowed to continue volunteering and feel a part of our community that our children will not bear the burden for doing what's right and telling the truth last I would like to state that advocacy for students does not mean that you do not support teachers it means that you speak for those who can't urge those who've created a culture of silence and division to look inwards as to why
026it angers you when we do and remember we're here for a common purpose the safety and education of the students of this District I have here a statement of two parents who unfortunately could not be here today and then 20 parents throughout the district not just for har Jeffers um but that co-signed my statement so I will turn that into to you thank you very much thank [Applause] you Carlo hi um I'm here on also on behalf of uh Noel Cravens I wasn't here uh last week to uh speak to her character um but I did listen to what was said about her and I just want to say that it was it was disheartening to hear but also I just wanted to say that uh from my experience she's definitely somebody who has been
027there for the students for the teachers and for the principal and just making sure that all of us are collaborating and and really trying to understand where each other are coming from and her thankless job as a president of PTA for our group she's always communicating with us always trying to find better ways to get any message across um so I just want to make sure that what you heard last week wasn't just what you felt about her um and I just want to make sure that she knows that a lot of us support her and uh love her for all that she's done for our children and that's all I really wanted to say so thank you thank you Noel Cravens good evening first I'd like to congratulate miss Karen Ramirez Dominguez and Miss
028Jessica tolston um I'm excited that you both you are both parents of children that are currently enrolled in the school district I'm looking forward to working with both of you to advocate for our students and Educators the submission statement on the Trula Vista Educators website says Trula Vista Educators is dedicated Empower members improve working and learning conditions for students and Educators and advocate for equity and Justice yet they allowed and continue to allow a teacher or possibly a group of teachers from har Jeffers Elementary School to intimidate and retaliate towards me because I spoke up last year at a board meeting regarding students being bullied and not being addressed in accordance with the school district's policy students in special education class getting physically hurt coming home with bruises and having behavior issues that are only
029seen at school and students being left alone in classrooms sleeping alone you heard me right while the rest of the class are in the playground or having lunch I want to emphasize that when I spoke these issues have been happening and the parents have tried to collaborate with the school I did not mention any names nor did I accuse any staff of negligence I also would like to mention that none of the 17 students that were in the special day class that were at fahari Jeffers last school year returned to returned this year it is a shame that the board allowed this it is a shame because you all knew what I said was true it is a shame trul this educators are supporting a teacher or teachers that obviously goes against your mission statement
030please next time before you decide to slander a parent advocating for students in public please address the dis please do your own please do your due diligence make sure you are not supporting a teacher or teachers who create a hostile environment for students and school staff intimidating and retaliating against anyone that advocates for students should never be supported and encouraged trying to silence a parent who advocates for students should never be supported or encouraged we will not stay quiet thank you thank you lenee Henry good evening esteemed members of the board and thank you for the opportunity to address you today I'm here not to speak on behalf of myself but to stand in support of a fellow parent whose character has been unjustly maligned at the special board meeting it has come to my
031attention that false and damaging statements have been made about this parent and I feel compelled to speak out in their defense as a community we all strive for a school environment built on mutual respect trust and collaboration and one and when one of us is unjustly attacked it affects us all the accusations made against Noel Cravens are not only baseless but they also misrepresent her intentions actions and commitment to our children's education I've had the privilege of working alongside Miss Cravens and I can say without hesitation that she is dedicated responsible and have always engaged with the school in a constructive and respectful manner her Focus has always been on what is best for the children and the entire School Community unfortunately false accusations when left un addressed can cause lasting harm these unfounded claims
032not only damaged an individual's reputation but also erode the trust that is so essential in any school environment I am confident that this board understands the importance of fostering a community where parents feel safe to be involved speak up for their children in the community and be able to collaborate with Educators allowing false accusations to go unchecked can have a chilling effect on Parental environment involvement and that ultimately harms our children having the UN repb speak gives the false notion that all the teachers feel this way and that is not true those statements were false Petty and cowardly and frankly wreak of intimidation and retaliation I guess no good deed goes unpunished I guess I ask that the board take a moment to reflect on the facts and the impact of these unfounded allegations this
033parent has been a committed and caring advocate for children and deserves to have their good name restored I strongly urge the board to support them in this effort by addressing these defamatory claims and ensuring that such situations are handled with the seriousness they deserve in closing I would like to reiterate that this is not just about defending one individual it's about protecting the Integrity of our entire School Community we must stand together against falsehoods ensuring that our interactions are based on respect transparency and truth thank you for your attention and your commitment to maintaining a healthy supportive environment for both both our children and their families thank you Iris Marcela Alan I can't read the end I'm sorry I can't see the end good evening my name is Iris Marcel alcane I had the pleasure
034of meeting Noel at the start of the school year when I expressed interest in joining the PTA as a Treasurer from the very beginning Noel's knowledge was evident she encouraged me to review the bylaws and provide and she provided resources and training information to help me better understand understand the role and ensure compliance with guidelines it quickly became clear how professional she is in our PTA meetings I witnessed firsthand Noel's commitment to advocating for the students at fahari L Jeffers Elementary School she maintains open communication between parents and teachers I I truly have nothing but great things to say about Noel her leadership and dedications are inspiring I am grateful to her for donating her time and energy to make a positive impact in our community thank you thank you Tracy talamantes good evening everyone
035thank you so much for allowing us to speak and congratulations to the new board members welcome um I'm Tracy talamantes I'm a second grade teacher at Chul Vista Hills Elementary School I'm a proud cve member and a very proud teacher and I'm here tonight because I want to speak to you about funding for um student supports when our teachers came back last week at our staff meeting our principal shared with us our scores from Casp testing and how our scores improved in every area and how proud we all were and then we broke out and we talking about how we managed to do that with our students and what it was that um that supported them the most and it was very clear that the two biggest things were our impact teacher and our classified
036teacher classified staff members who were running small groups to support our needest Learners and prior to that our principal shared with us that the funding for those are gone and I wanted to urge all of you to please look at the budget and please find ways to bring those supports back our students need them as teachers we need them I am one person trying to meet the needs of 25 students who have very varied needs and I cannot meet all of their need needs as one individual I need that support for my students and my students desperately need that support please find a way to make those impact positions ready again for our students and provide those supports the academic supports for our neediest lower grade Learners as well please I beg our kids need
037it thank you thank you there are no more speakers District safety health update Mr Romero president Ugarte uh governing board members and superintendent Dr Reyes it's my pleasure this evening to uh present our monthly safety update for the month of January uh so just a quick update on some of the projects and things that we have going on uh we did talk uh at some of our previous uh board meetings about our School site crosswalks and wanted to give a timeline that the city shared with us on where we were with some of these uh the city doesn't have a final timeline that they can guarantee us uh but they have shared that all projects have been approved and will take uh from 6 to 24 months to complete so uh we have the project
038at violo which is updated ing uh the advanced warning School signage uh to current California mucd requirements installing pedestrian Crossing signage installing ladder uh thermoplastic laddered crosswalk per uh city of chilisa Standards at Casas we have uh provided time restriction parking sign along the J Street and School Frontage the consider the loading zone um at Rogers we're going to schedule a traffic collection data uh from pedestrian vehicles to uh evaluate for a mid block Crossing along East Naples Street at hilcrest provide uh time restriction parking signs along the uh the street uh School Frontage the loading zone um currently there's no uh parking blocking signs there and at Soto mayor the city will install a four-way crosswalk adjacent to the school uh Co protocol a long time since we've talked about covid protocols uh but
039beginning February 3rd the California Department of Public Health no longer requires us to notify uh our our staff with uh covid-19 letters so um longone are the notification days of covid uh training uh so our staff is regularly involved in training and I'll go over our safety staff in just a moment um but we've completed trainings at Wolf Canyon we did a thread assessment there uh Heritage we did uh eix training at Marshall an incident Management training at Roar Incident Management and an egis training um and then we had uh three radio communication drills uh at our district uh camera projects all of our schools that are still pending camera installation have been evaluated and our vendor has made recommendations for where those cameras will be located uh every School site will get a minimum
040of four to six cameras depending on school sites and configuration of the schools um and Equipment has already been ordered so uh we do have a as mention men before a generous timeline of June 30th to be completed with the project we're hoping to over perform um and get those installed before then but we just want so we're we're making sure that we all know the goal will have them be ready for 25 26 but we are installing and um starting that ASAP uh you will notice uh if you go to our school sites uh within the next week or two uh every School site is uh getting uh uh these signs that will be placed at point of entry for our School site remember we've talked about schools being open Bell tobell uh closed
041Bel tobell excuse me open before the start of school open after start school end day ends but from Bell to Bell the only access should be for staff students and authorized volunteers um that are permitted on campus during those times so these SK signs will be located on our doors and access points to our school sites um so they're 11 by 17 so they're good siiz signs that uh should bring attention to our safety uh commodity our students so just a real quick update uh a revisitation of who our safety team is uh so our safety team at the school district is managed by uh Amed Wiggins who is our Security Programs and safety operations manager ahed has served 24 years in the United States Navy retiring as a senior chief petty officer has extensive
042experience in uh the world of safety including leading the uh the safest School College in our County at UCSD he was the safety officer there then realized he wanted to serve uh where his granddaughter would be going to school uh and decided to join Chula Vista Elementary School District so we're excited to have a med but he is uh trained um with all the safety anti-terrorism uh arms masked Intruder stop the bleed uh lots of experience with safety uh Darren newborn who is our School site uh security coordinator uh he is 13 years in the United States Army uh in security as a security uh forces officer uh he joined our team and he is really boots on the ground when it comes to uh all of our school sites um the first time that
043there's any indication of need uh Darren will be at the school sites uh providing those um Safety Services um myself and Jenny oversee the program but we also have four of our uh site um uh custodial managers that represent a different quadrant and then four and a half of funded District funded uh community service resource officers um that also make up our safety team any questions okay there are no speakers on this item um starting any questions or comments from the board I do and it's and it's okay we know it's our first time it's it this happens every month but don't feel like you need to say anything cuz some of us may have things to say thank you uh Mr Romeo we really appreciate these updates they help identify what's happening out there
044and otherwise we're in days but uh the school crosswalks you're speaking about hail Crest parking sign being out in front of the school right would be the sidewalk in front of the school the sidewalks they're going to they're going to make that in no parking zone no parking sign so where we have that access point there's two types of uh uh signage that happens we have signage that limits like during this time there's no parking and then there's like the Red Zone which will be never parking so these will be a No Parking time at all a time frame time frame okay so after school they'll be able to pick up their kids there without fear of getting ticketed yes right okay all right and um so that still is a a problem I know
045I saw in the board update Dr re is that you met with the the city manager to address some of the things maybe you can tell us what what came of that when it came to that school yes so I had a conversation with the uh city manager I did address our concerns and some of the parent and Community member concerns that they've brought to the the the board and uh she did say that she was going to be meeting with the safety the traffic um inspector I believe that it's a division division yeah uh so that's how this came about uh once it goes to that uh division then it's up to that inspector and the um audits that they do to determine what can be done one was done before because I attend
046the City Council meetings as well and one of the issues was well a city it was already done well when they did the traffic study they did it on a weekend after school hours stuff like that well that's not when the problems are happening necessarily I know that I drove you know over there one of these meetings and I sent Dr Rees a picture parents are making u-turns in the middle of the street with cars on both sides and it it was and kids running across the street so I don't I I feel that that somehow we need to have a say so as to when they're doing those studies because it makes no sense to do it when there's the dangers for the our students are during those school hours before and after school
047uh I have a meetings with the city manager from time to time so I will uh bring this along again thank you my other question for Heritage I know we had that incident when someone accessed our our school there and um thank God the the first day substitute handled it so well was all the questions I know you were going to have some like after school forums to address the parents issues yes so I believe um and I don't have a med here but I think we had at least four Town Halls actually I saw the principal in here I don't know if he's still here um but we had four Town Halls meetings the last one came after uh the board had suggested that and we spent a good hour and a half answering
048the questions and we have super positive feedback um Darren um was there uh after that incident for like the next couple weeks um and uh parent is no longer and child no is no longer at school um but yeah all the questions were resolved and we had a ton of positive feedback from from the community just want to make sure we had some closure and still kept the pulse on yes there okay so in regards to access I know some of our other schools and more spef specifically what comes to mind is Sunnyside where um access to the school with the whole Buzzard business about I can go into any school not me personally but you know any a person could go into the school and just go walk right by the secretary and have
049access they just walk in and through and they're they're done they're in so I know you were looking into some variable of that to control access of those people that are still coming through although the gates are up the doors are open to the office and then right out again yes uh so uh we worked with Mark pong um and our uh listening tours and did uh site visitations um and our our um operations team on this uh so every School site was visited um to determine whether or not the buzzer system would be just something that we can implement or did we need buzzer and cameras and things like that so we got a range of cost uh for that and we we are in the process of going out to bid uh and
050looking at that but but our goal is to have every school have that type of access and then um the ability for our staff that's in those offices to prioritize how they see them so some of them like I said will require cameras and some of them will require different type of events um to to take place during that time but our goal is to work with that during the summer to have the start of the 25 26 scho year have it and just for the board's um reference about $3500 to $10,000 per site depending on uh which which product we we use and what campers and things are needed and and aex is all our are all our sites trained the staff so a great question no not all of our sites are trained
051so uh right now we are we are working with our school sites to get as many trained as possible possible um but there's been we're available and our HR team does send out regular Communications uh so I I'll send in my weekly update the staff's uh the the school sites that need still need training I'll provide that on my Friday update and may I suggest you provideed to the principal so they know if they have 10 persons that need it and maybe also include our uh Union Partners so that they when they interact with their um their teacher they're classified they know to remind them hey you've got this training you know something that supports it because it also makes the difference as to when that training is going to be is it going to
052be during school hours not you know they're working so is it going to be on a Friday is it a zoom I don't know how that can work because we have to they have to do handson so you can show them and I'm just wondering if um you have uh enough input to be able to provide that that training because it does us no good if they don't know how to use it and or don't use it at all yeah we got endorsement from all of our unions but I will follow up and make sure that uh they're included in our Communications to make sure that we get that training taken care of thank you can I jump bit so what is the current model right now for the training uh do we leave it
053up to the staff to look at watch the training yeah so we did great question uh Mr to uh so we did did an all staff training uh so our staff is trained on it um but we're this is kind of like to training 2.0 where we actually go to our school sites and provide an active training so we do an incident uh uh training where we actually would push the buzzer and everyone would get notification so we do that we're that's the the 2.0 training that we're talking about and doing those um so we actually got approval for eeg's kind of mid year so we haven't had like the beginning of the school which would probably have been the best time to do it so right now we're prioritizing working with our school sites
054and having the the principal uh let us know when they' like to provide that training but we're available to whenever so I don't want to give you guys a false number of how many we've trained I know it's been a majority of our school sites that have been trained um but I'll be able on my Friday update to provide you the ones that still need to be training so if we're leaving it up to the the School site to the side when is there a deadline that we're giving them to have that training completed for example can a school district I mean can a school decide that we don't want the train until uh June yeah so as as I said everybody's been trained this is kind of the the the level two training we
055haven't given a deadline but I'll talk to Amed and I think that's a good idea maybe we can prioritize having me by the end of the school year everybody trained um but I'll I'll reach out we have a safety committee meeting that meets monthly and I'll talk to my Safety Committee members about you know giving you know what they think about a deadline and what that deadline should be um and then we'll make that recommendation toed and his team all right thank you I want to um I have a question um are we training the subs so great um and that that is actually uh not yet but that is part of our our next step um one of the things with our subs because it needs to be on your cell phone and it's
056actually a sight by sight uh recognition anytime a sub would need to go go to like you say you were at a Royal Vista then you went to Liberty you would need to re-register every time you do that and it'd be kind of complicated so what we're looking at doing is getting 10 uh like iPads or notebook uh tablets um at every School site putting the program on those tablets and then when a substitute comes in they'll check out a tablet um and then go over it so uh we haven't completed our first year of this program yet um we're still we're still in the like I don't want to say pilot stage but still first year stage um so that is something that we're talking about doing right now um and working with with
057how do we roll that out but the goal would definitely be to have every sub have an access to a tablet so they can and training to to use it thank you welcome I also have a question will it be recurring when what will it be recurring training once you implement it yeah we don't stop any of our trainings um so uh we we have a team and we're actually excited about that because uh our training that we did last time we actually had uh cvpd uh San Diego sheriff and San Diego PD out with us uh doing these trainings and so uh we want to have as they have revolving people coming in and out we want to make sure that they're uh actively involved in these trainings and so one of the things
058that that I do want to share we do have some highlights of the program um and some instances where it actually has responded is it bypasses like a phone and it goes right to what we call Rapid SOS so anytime we hit that alert butt like the dispatch gets notification instantly so the goal would be to to Contin having these trainings and we do have them on the books as regular trainings that we do we just had a couple districtwide trainings uh a couple weeks ago um where we get notification also so those are ongoing trainings and they'll be very similar to like earthquake drills or fire drills of that so yeah it's going to be an annually we'll have updates oh thank you of course just da are you okay anything else okay thank
059you Mr Romeo thank you and thank you to the safety team to Darren and ahed good job uh report on the governor's 2526 state budget proposal Mr pong thank you and good evening president Ugarte members of the board and superintendent Dr Rees members of the community tonight I have Just for information um a report on the governor's proposed budget for the 2526 School year so the governor released his Budget on January 10th and actually earlier today myself um some of the Union leadership and some of the District staff went to the governor's budget Workshop in Anaheim so this is a very um brief summary of the of the proposal so overall the economic Outlook the governor presented a balanced budget um he's proposing or assuming a steady and stable national government or national growth and
060projecting an overall budget surplus of about 17 billion with healthy reserves um in terms of the reserves there's two different reserves that he focused on the state budget um rainy day fund having about 10.9 billion in that at the end of the year and then 1.5 billion in the public school system stabilization account which is particularly for K12 education so 1.5 billion at the end of the year when we look at the local control funding formula which is how we receive a majority of our state funds um abbreviated as lcff uh the cost of living adjustment or otherwise known as a cola for the 2526 school year did decrease uh previously it was 2.93 um and now it's projected to be 2.43 sorry actually that's backwards um and then uh was previously projected at 3.8
06108 and going up to 5 3.52 our other uh categorical programs such as special education will also receive the cola of 2.43 and then um there's a legislation about the district Reserve cap so that's all based on the the pssa um amount and that has to be at least at least 3% of proposition 98 but that requirement will not be met so there will not be an effective Reserve cap in the 25 26 school year when we look at some of his other proposals and programs there he's proposing uh some onetime funds so uh student support and professional development discretionary block grant um it's to support professional learning and teachers um in ela and Mathematics and and there can also be um some spent on teacher Recruitment and Retention efforts and other discretionary expenditures when
062looking at our learning recovery emergency block grant these are funds that were awarded back in the um 2223 school year and then we're pulled back um some of it they're looking at Resto a partial restoration um next year and then Universal meals continuing they're projecting 1 billion meals to be served and 2526 and when we think about that you know McDonald's always uses that as their measure of how many hamburgers have been sold so that was interesting um in terms of transitional kindergarten um moving forward the date four years old by September 1st inclusive of September 1st the class size ratio going down from 12:1 to 10:1 additional funds for the ratio requirement and the state will also be working on a um English learner screener so the Alpac right now um is not appropriate
063for transitional kindergarten level so they'll be looking at a new um screener in terms of Retirement Systems kpur is the one that's having an increase slight increase 27.05.2012 uh he's proposing to lower the unduplicated population requirement for a higher funding level previously it was at 75% to get a higher funding and now he's proposing to have it at 55% so our district um is about 60% right now so we would fall into that category just some overall risks to the state budget that was talked about um stock market volatility some extreme weather events that have been occurring U with the fires they're delaying the tax deadlines again um and then at the federal level just some uncertainty with policies on tariffs and immigration and then the continued um elevated interest rates so what are the
064next steps for the budget so right now the um Senate and assembly they'll have their subcommittees on the budget and then they will um combine and um submit a proposal to the governor on June 15th and then the governor will um hopefully come to an agreement with the legislature um by June 30th with that I will open up for any questions board questions comments I do I appreciate Mark that um that you called out the risks it's it's important I because I'm I'm not a Mark I had to do a lot of other reading so I pulled out what the County Office of Education in a board update Dr Rees that you sent us and I read the legislative analyst office review and there was another report that I read and um the California Budget
065and policy Center their review of the budget and some of those items that I would like to um make a statement on is that like you called out that this is a budget based on current law and policy so we know we have to work with something so there's a lot of assumptions that we're working with but um also what's H been happening with the budget earlier a few years ago the budget stabilization account the BSA there was a requirement that the state deposit certain dollars in there a certain percentage what's been suspended and has been and we've been using that money it's like using your savings So eventually your savings is gone and so I know the um the County Office of Education specifically set recommended to us that we encourage the district to
066remain conservative in budget assumptions and to develop Al alternative budget scenarios and cash flow projections to prepare for the potential reduction in future funding for the last three four years we've been told everything's okay yes this is happening but it's not okay each year it's been more in our face that we need to ensure that uh we can't depend on others to just keep giving us money because when the money runs out what happens the taxes and then it just becomes a vicious cycle so I did want to call that out that one of the other comments that the Lao said was that while these year out estimates are highly uncertain this is an indication that the legislator might need to address deficits in the F deficits in the future for example by reducing spending
067or increasing taxes in our view this year's budget does not have capacity for new Commandments particular particularly ones that are ongoing and um I just wanted us to continue to remain cautious and be conservative and I appreciate you calling out the risk because that tells me that you are going to keep us in the black thank you vice president Theo any comments I did just for um I I appreciate thank you for for the report Mr pong um I especially the the end there with the risk to the budget as my colleague was saying could you just not get was a brief synopsis The last time we delayed taxes and how that had impacts on school budgets right did it come in higher than expected did it come in lower just so that we can
068prepare and so that our newest board members have an idea of what that means right so with the delay in taxes it became a challenge for the the state to project its revenues um because um with the last storm that happened um throughout California and the flooding that happened they delayed the taxes um and so we had some triggers that were initially proposed in the budget um and then a majority didn't come to fruition but there were some um pullbacks that they had to do um after the budget was approved thank you you're so right trustee and then now we have the fires they're probably going to delay their taxes now so just yeah just so that it's fresh in our mind that there when they do that we can have things that are being
069pulled back because we don't have a real number by delaying the taxes after um the April deadline right thank you Mr pong all right we are at the approval of the consent calendar the following items listed under the consent calendar are considered by the board in one action there will be no discussion on these items prior to the time the board votes on the motion unless members of the board staff or public request specific items to be discussed and or removed from the consent calendar um and board members this is a time where I ask if any items are needing to be pulled for separate discussion any yes yes uh agenda item 10B it's just a short statement and then agenda item 10 C with subsections CD which is which is page five of 14
070CK which is Page 8 of 14 and 10 d f h i j k m n and p okay I'm going to read these back so agenda item 10B 10 C with subsection C CD page 5 of 14 CK 8 of 14 and then 10 D 10f 10 H 10 I 10 J 10 K 10 m 10 n and 10 P I believe I may have misquoted K not K not k no okay I'll pull K you oh you're pulling K yes okay um do I have a motion to approve the consent agenda with these items pulled so move second move by vice president de Mayo seconded by clerk Dominguez cantes all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously okay first up trusty Dominguez santes is 10 b b it's just a a brief
071statement um yesterday I provided um miss seli my notes on the meeting minutes and uh they've been reposted as revised but I do think the public should know what was revised it was a typo on page 93 There Was An Unfinished sentence clarification on a couple of paragraphs which were which were on pages 93 98 100 and then it caused some pagination to change so it became 101 and 102 but the revisions are on the website thank you mreli okay with that I'll entertain a motion to accept 10B so moved second moved by vice president de Mayo seconded by clerk Dominguez santes all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously okay item 10 C with a subsection of CD page 5 of 14 yes it says Family Resource assistant and buyer so that's page
07211 of 14 of inside of there but and the library specialist technician on page 12 of 14 within that but both speak of creating the job description or refers to a new job description are these new positions as well Dr Rey M R thank you so um as we look at at uh updating our job descriptions on a regular basis and aligning them to their current duties so we have two job descriptions that are being forward the Family Resource assistant is a new position new job description um and it would be the first time that we bring this forward uh and the buyer Library specialist technician is a revision of one of our positions uh with added duties uh that align with the current uh process and and function that is required for that position
073the can I ask the question about um with regard to the Family Resource assistant I see that um it um references director of Community Schools will this be funded through the Community Schools FR yeah M Casey thank you yes so this position is for us to create District level positions that are currently being filled by South Bay Community Services to support our community collaborative with our community schools initiative and our F frc's perfect thank you anything else that one just thank you okay and then 10 CK and just so that our new board members under um can understand we don't approve 10 C until we go through the subset the entire subset so page eight of 14 trusty me yes caban I imagine it's meaning Cabana Pool Services is this retro paid to July of
074last year Dr re Mr B yes it is we were having some issues um because they were having a change in business or someone bought them out so there was a change in the business so um we finally got that cleared they used to be pool logic um so now we will be going back to pay them under Cabana did that have to do with um a concern we had with something with the pool there at Rogers well this is for pool maintenance in gen General pool maintenance okay yeah all right thank but we're going back to July 1st to pay them yes why but we didn't pay them they didn't bill us they didn't do the services they did perform the services but they've been having that change in ownership so just trying to
075figure out who we're going to pay correct so so it used to be another the name under another company name and then Cabana bottom so instead of paying logic you were paying Cabana all right so this is the first time we'll be paying them all right thank you I do have a question on it's actually this K instead of the other K there's a consultant called Shield security systems um to install um locks keys and software Services I imagine that's digital locks uh can you explain a little bit more since this is a fairly low amount what locks are we doing and are we going to plan for other doors to be converted to these type of logs Dr a Mr Punk so they're actually a locksmith a locksmith company that helps us with wreaking
076some of the locks um so they're projecting about uh it's for annual services for them okay so it's not that we're replacing um actual keys with fobs right no not yet okay it's in case we use them and we need them as we need them for R Services okay any other questions and 10c no move to approve TC second move by vice president the Mayo seconded by clerk Dominguez santes all those in favor of 10 c i i i motion carries unanimously item 10 D yes approve Revis salary schedule for classified substitutes effec of January 1st 2025 and we have one speaker on this Miss Angela Reed thank you thank you um I just want to point out that when we're looking at this revised substitute salary schedule we have some historically male dominated roles
077that are being raised above minimum wage uh consistently the last couple schedules they have been higher and some of these have not even been not even been requested by the management uh or the managers that oversee them and we don't even have an interpreter deaf heart of hearing that works for the district so to have a salary as a substitute for them and then to raise their salary would be a subbing for no one just saying um when you look at general maintenance that new salary is a custodian 22 step one um when you look at the computer support Tech that is the technology equipment Tech that's a 31 step one when you look at the bus driver that's a 26 step one these are all current ranges step one of the classes that they
078sub for I have requested for four three years that salary for substitutes reflect the job that they are subbing for to be the range of the absent employee at a step one that would solve our problem forever we would never have to come back to the table to review salary schedules and it would actually allow par professionals and secretary office staff to take their earned right of absence absences for sick leave for p&l and vacation without having to worry about leaving their jobs unfilled thank you thank [Applause] you my turn y so I agree the increases to some of the classifications appear valid they're good good for doing that but some of the others appear to me unacceptable I have a copy of the previous schedule and of course the one that was provided this
079time and I'd like to request that in the future when we're changing that we're also provided with the previous one so we can make a comparison what are we changing it from and I think that just would help us to uh uh raise our questions most of these are at minimum wage and everyone knows my line that I always say when are we going to price match McDonald's we've have an ongoing problem with being able to get subs frequently that's something we hear from classified we hear from the certificated we hear from our student service the student AIDS the instructional AIDS the Specialties but but we don't treat them like that uh we have the we have the new duties you know I know of one school that because they don't have enough noon duties
080the kids a few months ago were just kept under where the lunch area is and the kids are not allowed to run around that's something I shared with you Dr re is we just can't have that but how do we encourage the substitutes or to even have a a pool of people that want to come when we pay pennies and when you're comparing like the general maintenance it went from 1904 to 2138 that's over $2 The Interpreter that doesn't exist went from 1937 excuse me went from 1725 to 1937 $212 the computer support Tech it went from the 20 361 to 26 almost $3 difference bus driver they're all needed I'm not saying they're not they all need it but when also a a teacher has an absence of a student aid in their classroom
081the the teacher spending most of their try TR time trying to manage the the needs of that student instead of addressing 90% 80% of their class so there's also instruction loss I would recommend and I would ask the chair to consider a motion that by the same dollar amount that we raise the others that we raise these others too and I appreciate the the recommendation um what's going through my mind right now is costing all of this out right um when we have pay increases and my guess is and and Dr Rey is you can direct this to the appropriate person is that this is as a result of making sure we're matching right now the minimum wage um as we're looking at the budget and we're looking at things that we are going to
082have to possibly cut in the future um I would want a cost out of raising all of those um because we may as as Miss um Reed pointed out raising the rate on The Interpreter for a job that doesn't exist really isn't going to have a fiscal impact but if we have uh let's say I don't know a number of I'd say a hundred clerks I'm just putting a number out there and we raised them all $2 and then they use those substitutes which I she made a valid point um with that we need to cost that out before we make that that motion so um I I understand the costing out because I was we know we just shared with Mark about being um conservative about some of our um directions but the student
083there's some things that are not negotiable they shouldn't be negotiable are on the table when it comes to providing that student the support I'm going to caution you truste Dominguez because when you're saying it's not negotiable and and that's another thing that I'm sitting here going through my mind I don't want us bargaining in and and and they're not part of the bargaining unit but before we make a motion in order to be fiscally responsible and I'll ask for this at the appropriate time um is that cost out Madam president so I could recommend that we make a motion to approve this item as is but to also ask the district to cast out what would it look like to change the rates for each of these positions at the appropriate range step one what
084would that cost and what would that look like based on our previous uh usage of substitutes that way the board can make an informed decision on if we raise these uh rates to the recommended uh step one of the appropriate classification what would that do to our budget that was a really long motion so could you cut the motion I got the explanation on the motion and I'm willing to second that I just want the the I wanted the motion to include the description of why want that way it's clear for for the district but I I can summarize the the motion so I will summarize to move to approve the item with the dis asking the dis directing the district to bring back uh cost analysis for um the rates on step one of
085the appropriate classification I will second that discussion MH could we amend that to give a time frame that it be provided by next board m is that enough time for the district it out Dr yes that's sign I approve okay so um all any other um discussion on that okay um we have a motion by vice president Deo seconded by President ugar all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously thank you truste Dominguez thank you all right let me go back to my list 10 f so ratify student accountability report cards for the 2023 2024 well as Dr Rees knows um I get these boxes of reports and um believe it or not I do go through them takes me a long time and um this last time he had the reports ready I
086didn't have to come back and get them he had them ready for me thank you but they were given to me on Thursday but also took the opportunity to compare overlapping numbers in the other reports we have in December I also received the 2023 2024 School plan for student achievement this and I took the opportunity to look at the California Dash my findings were that here we were looking at a 202 2425 report a 2324 report and what's currently on the dashboard there were almost no inconsistencies even on specific demographics from year to year between these reports and I found that kind of odd because there should be changes and um I made I've got copies here some you know examples but um that just seems like there's something off okay there there should be
087some changes so then what I did and I'll speak to it more in agenda item number 12 that when there were some differences it didn't reflect a change on another category when it should have everything else still froze so even when there were numbers from 20 to 50 to 60 numbers difference it didn't affect anything else so if you remove 30 kids well wouldn't that have affected some some of the other demographics I just feel uncomfortable approving this item because I don't it looked like it was cut and paste with the exception of just a couple they look cut and past to me so even if we assume there should not be a difference in some of the stagnant numbers with some of the other there was four that I noticed m minor changes that
088didn't change anything else even when there was significant numbers changed so I just wanted to let you know my reasoning behind it that I will not be approving this item and I I just have a question for Dr Reyes the generation of the SARS um where does that originate M Morales so many sections of our school accountability report card are generated from data that we submit to the state through CDE and then that is prepopulated into our sarks through our document tracking system for our principles to review for our director of communications to review as well as Mrs uh pre to review so a lot of those data pieces are generated for US based on reports that are given to the state and it's only as good as the human entry um well I think
089that there's always going to be a level of human entry that is going to be present but when you have all these schools with the exception of three or four that's got to be something that red flags us um I even looked at the uh lcap okay and the lcap uses numbers from here and um especially to identify some of the other issues that I'll bring up at item number 12 but I I just don't think we should take it without further research okay so I haven't done a comparison of how the numbers within the spases or the sipsas would compare to these sarks um we would expect them though to be pretty similar since we are working with our data Quest system as well as our dashboard system so for us when we see
090consistency within our scores within the two different documents it's a sign that it is validating that those systems are from year even the same number of students enrollments I haven't done an analysis of the sipsa to the sarc but for the sarc we can we can verify that the data within the SARS are accurate and that is from our we two year twoyear ranges 2023 24 the 24 25 and they have the exact number of enrollments I just can't do it thank you if there's no more um comment or question questions I'll entertain a motion to approve item 10f I'll move to approve item 10f with the request that the district um makes an analysis of the statements that um trusty Dominguez made I'll second it's been moved by trusty too seconded by President ugar
091all those in favor of accepting 10f with an analysis please say I I hold on I'm I you know I do it s because I need to hear so that we can hear um all those in favor please say I I I all those opposed please say nay nay any abstentions okay so I want to say that was a 41 motion carries all right 10h okay a approv change order for request proposal 2425 security camera the qu my question is 87,8 15532 is quite an increase for an oversight so what was the other vendor's bid does this change order now amount to the possibility that the other vendor if there was one may have had a chance to win this bid Dr Rees Mr P yes um it wasn't an oversight the initial bid um
092we didn't um go out and do the exact location of the cameras and typer cameras so after they did the full walk through this is a revision based on the needs of the schools so um that's what the change order is for changing the C the types of cameras um that are being requested and then um the other one we did look at that and the next lowest bid after it's still below the second bid which was 83,000 I appreciate your preparedness thank you motion to approve second motion by um clerk Dominguez cantes seconded by vice president Tam Mayo all those in favor of 10 H please say I I I any opposed motion carries unanimously 10 I quick question is Maxwell Transportation Center fully functional up and running everything's going everything's green light Dr
093ases Mr pun can you uh share where we are in regards to the office space and also the actual shop the office space itself is complete we're uh going out to we met with the local MTS and they also had a new Transportation Center and we kind of got some insight from them on how some recommendations on how they keep the longevity of their facilities and so one of the things that um they had suggested that we looked into and agree with is the adding an epoxy seal onto the um where the buses will be um worked on so that's the last step so we're currently in the process of preparing the bid documents to go out to bid for that so we foresee when this project will be completed um few months yeah a
094couple more months okay okay all right thank you motion to approve but that will be completed by a different contractor not Conan so we'll see another contractor motion okay motion to approve second motion by clerk Dominguez Sant seconded by vice president de Mayo all those in favor I motion carries unanimously item 10 J yes approve Award of bid package number one for Tiffany HVAC and Roofing renovation project I appreciate the additional background information but I like to know when the projected finish time is and also there's notice there that bids were posted in the Star News to be honest I don't know anybody who gets that anymore so I don't know how that's General circulation and I and then I went online to look at the October 18 and October 25th dates that are stated
095that it was you know posted you should take a look at that you it looks like a bunch of algorithms a bunch of letters I had to stop you can't even find it so I don't I I believe I would venture to believe that the ones that responded to it were those that were directly emailed versus the posting so I'm wondering if there's um another method that we can really call General circulation to reach out to to bid and then the finish time okay Dr Reyes Miss BR uh so two questions the expected uh finish uh timeline for the project and two if you can research uh when we announce a position we publish the position the the the the projects if we could look into uh having other possible uh venues so we're anticipating
096the start of the construction to be during spring break where we'll do one of the phases and then the second phase will happen as soon as school lets out in June oh good um and then it'll be completed by the start of school July 18th okay and then in terms of the posting um a lot of the vendors are used to looking at those trade journals but we can also look at other trade journals and then under cupka we also reach out to um contractors that have the license that are able to perform the work and we send them the bid package so that's one of the requirements too right but could we look for yes another method thank you motion to approve second motion by clerk Dominguez santes seconded by vice president Deo all
097those in favor I I motion carries unanimously did we say k was we can just vote on it do we have it was okay I wanted to pull something so okay move to approve uh 10K second move by vice president the Mayo seconded by clerk Dominguez cantes all those in favor I I motion carries and we have 10 m l did I did I didn't I had when I went from K I went to M so l is not L's been approved and consent yeah it wasn't pulled sorry okay have it here can we we rewind next I know it's not replay instant replay right 10 okay well well know that I had an issue with it okay 10m approve agreement with renal Clark Architects for architectural services viol Lindo Elementary so they're doing the
098construction work but bfor bidy is monitoring the work Dr Reyes can we explain that for me no uh runal Clark are The Architects okay the buer Bey is the construction and preconstruction management to different entities right so then we have right so I would have been able to connect it to the previous one but now I can't so um all right because they're talking about monitoring B for is saying they're going to monitor the construction let's go to 10m please okay so do we need to vote on 10m so so so I maybe the question to the superintendent can be can you explain a little bit more what Bal for be actually does in in terms of monitoring what do they monitor do they monitor the subcontractors or something like that so yeah so Mr
099can you uh explain for the board the role of the Architects and I I can I can I can still speak to just the M but in a previous agenda item it's Bel for uh that's being called out to um do Management Services for vindo so can you explain the role of an architect and then explain the role of a construction management and how they're different and how they work together so the the architect is the one that designs the project right which is what Runa Clark will do and then Baler batty are the construction managers so they provide um oversight on behalf of the district on the project and all the subcontractors so um we will be in the future bringing out another proposal for a contractor to actually build the school and they're
100the intermediary between the district and that contractor um whenever there's issues and they're on the site monitoring right so BTY is not doing the construction on it but they're doing the the monitoring right and I think we've been through this conversation before on other companies so we we hire a qualified company to do a work and then we hire another qualified company to monitor that they're doing qualified work and now we got to get a Monitor to Monitor the monitor so so so this is very different from uh the other company that uh I don't want to assume but uh the other company that you mentioned before a few uh uh months ago regarding um a company regarding the the pla uh monitoring this is completely separate this is just for construction um the the
101construction company or the the management they manage the different subcontractors and my questions stem from the fact that about the fiscally being phisically responsible thank you move to approve second move by clerk Dominguez santes seconded by vice president de Mayo all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously 10 n approve agreement with Frontline Technologies DBA Frontline education in the amount of 67,8 190 for the time and attendance module add-on is this the application connected to subalert where staff pay a monthly fee to get preferential notification Dr Rees M and let me share with you uh why I had two substitute teachers tell me a few months ago that they were wondering why they were not getting sub jobs and then they found out that they were not getting notification because they weren't pay I
102think they said $5 for to be members so after that question is answered if the $5 is true I'd like to know where that money is going Dr Rees Mr P um we'll probably have to refer those staff over to the sub desk but to our knowledge there's not a fee requirement um I haven't heard of subalert but we use Frontline for the substitute call out system so whoever's registered with front line receive calls whenever um a staff member puts in an absence and we'll go ahead and research that I've never heard of that yes never heard of that they sent me a screenshot of it so yes if we could follow up on that we'll follow up on that right because um he got a scam going and and if you have a screenshot
103if you can forward the screenshot I would appreciate it thank you do I have a motion to approve 10n motion to approve second moved by clerk Dominguez santes seconded by trustee or vice president Deo all those in favor I motion carries unanimously and then I have item 10 P approve or ratify inservice travel requests so a quick question on the cavid 2025 annual conference it says various staff is that just a a placeholder Dr Reyes Miss Morales yes it is a placeholder so what it allows us to do is that staff members who are interested in attending we already have it ready to go very much like our umbrella agreements with our icas all right and my next question is related to the leading a culture of thinking Summit in delmare uh it's let's see
104it looks like there might be a typo on one of the day trips while the others claim a three-day event it says this pretty much the same price somebody's claiming one day the others are claiming a three-day event I think it's just a typo probably minor and a minor dollar amount at one of them but uh the $13,250 currently claimed it's a local Summit in delmare so my question the funding coming from educator effective Effectiveness Grant is that a grant that drawn down by other Educators classified who gets access to this grant or is just this someone that someone applied for it and it's like all theirs Dr Rees M Morales can you repeat your question I just want to make sure I understand it correctly yes um in light of the current econ economic
105challenges I'd like to know if this grant is specifically for this Summit or or what no the grant could incl include other items that we have used that grant money towards uh this is a professional learning opportunity for our instructional Services team as well as our group of principles who are launching and leading these initiatives at their school sites and so there could be other items that are funded from this grant money it's not the same as like DOA where DOA grant money is going towards all of our DOA expenditures there are a lot of different expenditures within um the Sr grant funding that we can update you on some some of those examples thank you I just wasn't sure if they found this grant to pay for that or if it's available for other
106opportunities yes it is did classified get to go to this we do not have any classified going to this um training at this time however it would be appropriate in the future for a classified like instructional assistant who is supporting the learning around visible thinking and the use of thinking routines to attend thank you move to a question oh sorry um regarding the travel it's about the same subject and the same um place that they're going is there only three schools that are going to implement currently right now we have three principles who are implementing to a larger degree cultures of thinking and it's been part of for example Harbor sides uh redesign of their school we also do a cultures of thinking book club with our principal uh leadership team and uh we are
107vetting uh expanding that group we have about 17 in it this year and so what we do is try to provide that professional learning to our leaders so that they can then take that learning back to their school sites and the same is true of our members of our instructional Services team and that that does allow us to have a cost savings because it becomes in-house trainers that we can then scale that learning quicker um a follow-up question do they get like certified to be able to train there's no certification for this one but that's a good question okay thank you y okay if there's no if there are no more questions I'll entertain a motion to accept 10p motion to approve second moved by clerk Dominguez serantes seconded by trustee Ramirez Dominguez all those
108in favor I motion carries unanimously before we move into our administrative action item uh where we are going to recess to the public facilities Finance Corp I'll take a five minute bio break and come back at 7:45 e e e now recess to Chula Vista Elementary School District for the public facilities Finance Corporation I'm calling to order this meeting of the board of directors of the Chula Vista Elementary School District public facilities financing Corporation all members are present we are going to uh adopt a resolution of the board of directors and the Chula Vista Elementary School District public facilities financing Corporation appointing officer and taking related action in connection therewith Mr pong thank you president Ugarte tonight um we have for your recommendation um of a slate of officers for the um Public Finance facilities
109financing Corporation and the pfcc pffc is what we use um when we issue some of our CFT bonds um and so um this is one that's the only time when it comes about um that we call it separate meeting to approve those um related items and so typically um the board president is the the board of director the chair of the board of directors the vice president is the vice president chair and then with Oscar's retirement I would become the president um Dr Reyes is the the typically the secretary and then the director of fiscal services with Kristen leing and prapor coming on is typically the Chief Financial Officer thank you Mr pong um we have no speakers on this item and um the PFC c meeting will be conducted in this manner as to
110what um Mr pong um described we are electing a new chairperson vice vice chairperson um and are um as we acknowledge the retirement of Mr eskel as he said and um the resignation of Kristen aradus um so it is an action item and we would need a motion to adopt the officers that were um mentioned by by Mr pong in the typical fashion of the public facilities financing Corp I motion to appoint to approve as stated okay and I second okay um motion by clerk Dominguez cantes seconded by truste Ramirez Dominguez all those in favor of adopting that um motion for the officers please say I I I and there were no no opposition correct so um motion carries unanimously and having concluded conducting the district public facilities financing Corporation business we now adjourn its
111meeting we now reconvene to the Chula Vista Elementary School District Board of Education meeting and we are um at the point of the agenda accepting the Chula Vista Elementary School District District's 2324 annual audit report Mr pong thank you president your garte um tonight we have for your review and acceptance the 2324 annual audit report uh we have tonight um Brian Hadley from Wilkinson Hadley and King and he will do a short summary of the audit we did have a um unmodified audit however there were a couple of findings which um Mr Hadley will refer to in his discussion okay thank you Mr Hadley good evening I appreciate the opportunity uh to present the audit report to the to the board this evening um you know you mentioned that there was a well when I
112look at an audit report whether it's one that our firm does or whether it's one that another CPA firm does I always do these three things and I'd like to tell you what they were um so that you know it might help you when you look at audit reports in the future um uh the first thing that I do is I look at the first page of the audit report which is the accountant's opinion um this is the most important page in the entire audit report you know your audit report is over it's about 120 some pages long and you and you look at all those numbers and you say how can that one letter be the most important page in the audit report but it's the it's the it's the page that communicates the
113accountant's opinion and as U Mark said that you received an unmodified opinion and that means that the financial statements fairily present the financial position of the district at June 30 2024 in a governmental audit there are four types of opinions you can receive the best one is an unmodified opinion which what you which is what you received you can also have a qualified opinion an adverse opinion or a disclaimer of opinion those last three are the types of opinions that you want to stay away from they'll cause you problems in getting financing and and other things but you you received an unmodified opinion which is the best opinion that you can receive so that's the first thing I always look at um the second thing that I do is I look at uh towards the
114back of the audit report there's a section that talks about about um findings and and question costs and as Mark said there were two compliance findings this year one dealt with a substitute with a substitute teacher who taught more than 30 days uh there's a rule that says uh you have to have a permanent credential to teach more than 30 days the same class more than 30 days um the second one is a very unusual one it dealt with a student that that didn't have uh an immunization uh the student you know the students are required to have an imun immunization to attend school this student was undergoing cancer treatment and didn't have a didn't have an immunization there was a doctor's note that said he would get the immunization after the cancer treatment was
115completed um and there is a uh you know to to get that exception uh to not having a um an immunization there's a state agency that's called the California immunization registry for medical exception and unfortunately this the the district didn't apply for that exemption and so those were the two findings very unusual I've been doing this for a long time and I haven't seen either uh either either of those findings come across you know my desk um but that's the second thing that I do is I look to see if there are findings and a finding is something that needs to be brought to the attention of the board or the California Department of Education or the state controller and there so there are those two compliance findings during the year and then the last
116thing I do is I look at the very last page of the audit report which is a requirement that says if there were findings on the prior year audit report on the June 30 2023 audit report were those findings res olved and I'm happy to tell you that there were no findings on the 20 June 3rd June 30 2023 audit report so there's nothing to report on that um but if you look at those three things you know the opinion letter the the findings and whether the prior your findings were resolved um it gives you a good indication of what the district is doing during the year um like I said you know this audit report is more than 120 pages I don't want to B you with the you know the technical part of
117going through that but I'd be happy to try to answer any questions that you have at this time if if you have any we have no speakers on this item um board comments questions um this is an action item and is there a motion to accept the audit annual audit report motion to accept the report second motion by trustee Ramirez Dominguez seconded by vice president Tayo all those in favor I motion carries unanimously next we have adopt the resolution of the Board of Education of the Chula Vista Elementary School District certifying all proceedings in the November 5th 2024 General obligation bond election for measure AA Mr pong tonight we have for your adoption um a resolution certifying the November 5th election for measure AA uh the community voted with a 61. 72% yes vote and
118this approval of this will certify that vote we have no speakers on this item any board questions or comments okay this is an action item is there a motion to adopt the general obligation bond election for measure AA motion to accept second moved by clerk Dominguez cantes seconded by trust uh vice president the Mayo all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously adopt the resolution for emergency services and equipment pursuant to public contract code sections 22035 and 22050 Mr pong tonight we have for your adoption an emergency resolution that will extend our agreement with VBS um to provide a generator at the cssc location originally we were anticipating that the the parts to be delivered um earlier in the month so that we we can have it installed but when we um followed up
119with the vendor it's looking like it'll be delivered on January 31st and then after that we have to schedule an appointment with sg& um to get their approval for install so um we just need a little bit more time um in the delivery process thank you Mr pong there are no speakers on this item do we have any board questions or comments this is an action item um is there a motion to adopt so moved second moved by vice president de Mayo seconded by clerk Dominguez santes all those in favor of adopting this motion please say I I I motion carries unanimously all right um we are at the general information item reports and for our new board members this is any item that you would like to request um for um um from Dr
120Reyes um with regard to um our school district and so report calendar to um the Board of Education Dr Reyes we have no speakers and whoever wants to jump in and ask for a report they have if they're new to this they want to see what we ask for and they can do that next time all right I believe I have five reports that I'd like to regurgitate uh number the first one I'd like to know and I know last month when I brought it up Dr Ray you said you were going to start working in it on it in February so I didn't want us to lose sight of it the assistant principal formula I want to know what formula is being used to determine which schools get a fully or partially District supported
121assistant principal so can I make comment so so part of what we're doing right now is uh we're look since uh we just got the governor's uh proposed budget we're looking at how we're going to be projecting our fiscal um solvency for next year in regards to Staffing so it's it's we don't see it as as a um one item in isolation we said we see it as a whole so as we're proposing different changes uh in regards to Staffing that's one of the ones that we're we're looking into so next month when we bring to the board um some some changes uh then that will be taken into consideration okay could you then also in um February bring us the formula that's being being used up to this point so that I can have
122a comparison so we can ask questions much like the salary schedule I said if we knew what was how it was being addressed before what was on there we could have I would have better informed questions sure can we expect to have that yes yes thank you and that's the first one the title one money thank you Mark he did uh send it to us uh like month and a half ago and what I want to know is uh I want a report that captures the parameters the criteria that's being used for this money I've got to share a concern that when we know there's no playground equipment in some of the classes or there's there's holes and slides and the money is sitting there I know that trusty Ugarte and trusty tomayo went to
123a school and shared the very the very concerns I'm raising again right now and I'll share one instance I a few months ago a parent approached me about how they had approached their leadership there for when are they going to get equipment when are they getting equipment little balls you know whatever I bought them and you know that I bought them for that class about the balls the jump ropes you know whatever I thought this is ridiculous I said I gave them the the I bought it I purchased I got the receipt I bought it I didn't ask for reimbursement and again another parent of course you know things spread I was approached again uh of another classroom another school and I that's con conc erning so when I see the title one money going
124and just being rolled over and rolled over and we talk about the disparity between the west side and the east side and then we get so concerned I speak frequently um president um uh Rosie Martinez always brings it up so does um uh Miss Angela that we we keep talking about equity and then we see all this money sitting there the very money that that's for the very deprived children there's got to be a better way what are the parameters what is the criteria what are the exceptions from using that money because I saw something for 200 something thousand being rolled over from the previous year that to me is appalling When the Children already feel like second class citizens I know my kids did and their schools not as pretty as new as the
125other ones it just makes it for that much worse and I I know my colleagues feel the same because they brought it up before and even the previous months have brought it up before I I we really need to reel that in and tell us what are the parameters what are they allowed to do because if hey if you tell me I can spend a million dollars I'll go spend it you know what are the parameters so that maybe they don't even know what you know I don't know I don't know could please get that please and I'll share with you what school I'm going to be donating more equipment for for another classroom okay so so just to recap uh we're going to give you a board update on a report on the parameters
126and criteria and exceptions for the use of tilean money specifically for sites correct M wherever our students are sitting there with no nothing to play with and the teacher the classified they're expected they're thinking the kids out there burning their energy so they can come in and listen and they they're not thank you the next one the achieve teachers are hearing and I know that President um Rosie shares with me frequently so sometimes I bring it up again it's not that she hasn't brought it up but I don't know who else she's sharing it with so if it doesn't get aired but I'm bringing this one up so we agree that we don't want kids in front of the uh computer all day long we all agree that because that interaction with the people is
127what they need if they use it for homework or special assignments that's a little more monitored but they're hearing that and parents with that the first ones that brought it to my attention that they rely they're hearing that achieve is going away and they are in um shock because they all feel that this individualized um material that comes to them actually takes them or it give makes them those inquiries have you guys I've sat with my granddaughters on the achieve you probably with your kids but it really is helpful it helps the teacher short of having another tutor there watching them it has that personalized support so I'm wondering is it going away I think they need to know whether that program is going away or not so so we goinging achieve 3,000 we're looking
128at the academic and and financial uh implications so we're not just looking at the cost but we're looking at uh how effective academically and and how uh is it aligned to to um providing achievement uh for students and so we are having that discussion in curriculum instruction at this point and we'll be bringing a um something projected for to the board shortly they theye app because it gives them immediate feedback on their comprehension and share with me how are you going to test its Effectiveness uh we well we can tell you now or we can uh do a report a board update okay because how do you know that it's effective I don't know so the the fourth report parent reporting uh they're they're reporting that the test when the parents get the reports from
129the teachers the parents are depending on the teachers giving it instead of it's it's not being mailed out to them like it used to so parents are depending on the teacher to provide them this information but the scores mean nothing to them if it says whatever it says there's no key to let them know what that score means so they give the report it has a random number on there it means nothing to the parent so if the child is they don't know if the child is way ahead barely ahead are they way below grade level or barely missing the mark and you guys have little ones I think You' want to know if are they barely making the Mark or did they go did they hit it and all of this this whole time
130you know how and I've seen it on our website and the teacher send it out you know to tell the parents you know put them to sleep uh early make sure they eat good you know make their breakfast and they work on it so the parents want some feedback on how they did on these testings so like the report cards four the number four it meets exceeds and meats it doesn't differentiate between students performing above their grade or a student who barely made it how does two approaching differ from a three nearly met this is a disservice to parents who are relying on Educators as the experts to tell them how their child is doing there's no uniform standard across a district one teacher can rate a 60% as a one not met while another
131teacher gives it a two approaching so I think all parents want to know exactly where they're at so they know how if we're looking for parent engagement and partners parip we need to provide them that but it's something that's given to the teacher it's not it's something we've created teachers are just here supposed to get handed out I'd like so what is our what is our request is on the test on the report card tell them what that means what does that number mean and look at the issues I brought up you know how are we going so there's no unifor uniformity so so um trusty I just want to make sure that I that I have it correctly what the ask is so what what is the ask that we you want us to
132mail him a key you want us to have to look into parent conferences which would have to be negotiated with the the union would you like us to do exactly what is the request meet with the union and find out what they want because it's the teacher that's burdened with having to explain or not explain because then the teacher has to spend 30 minutes working with the parent to tell them what that means and why this teacher gives that score there's just no uniformity this is more than a report this is like we've got to get something standardized here and and we have to send the parents the key are we it's obviously costs more money to mail it out to them and with a key so if the report that the teachers are giving
133to the parents had the key on there at least they'd understand that that ask would would be addressed there if it could be added there and I brought this up months ago believe during the summer and then the other is more of a task about the report cards and the not there not being a uniform standard across those numbers I just quoted about what's the difference between approaching from nearly met and uh one teacher rating a uh 60% as a not met one where another would give it to approaching so Mr from what we can do is we can have a if you can set up meeting with uh cve and start having those conversations yeah we do have uh a report card committee that is comprised of cve members uh and administrators and so
134uh I'll have a meeting with uh cve president Rosie Martinez and we can talk about um some of the things that um clerk Domingo Sant has mentioned thank you thank you thank you thank you for dissecting it for me that was the five the fifth that was four the fourth is the fiscal crisis management assistance team f fat is that how you pronounce that ficat Management Services I think we're at a a Crossroads where we need to conduct a management assistance study uh there are some concerns with some practices and I think that uh fecm can provide Human Resources with some management assistance uh it there's just too much chatter out in the social media and um our HR must be without reproach and when one or more board members have multiple unanswered inquiries and
135the community is also raising concerns or doubts about the process I think it's pasted time that we request FM is that how you pronounce it Management Services they can add value I looked up what what they do their focus is investigating a potential problem and or helping solve a small problem when we first recognizes recognize is that's much better strategy than waiting until the problem contributes to fiscal troubles or instability the idea is that they make recommendations for improvement if any review our processes ident ify specific gaps or deficiencies between best practice conditions and offer practical recommendations like fmac studies management assistance studies use a consistent approach suitable to identify the appropriate best practice determine the conditions particular to the Lea identify specific gaps or deficiency between best practices and the Lea's conditions and off
136they offer practical recommendations I always welcome in invitation to how can we do better and um I'd like to ask the chair if we could motion if we would accept the motion to have this request um for this report for these Services we can we we would um need a second we okay so at this point we can potentially put it on an agenda so that we could uh motion for that and if you have a second I can ask Dr Rees to put that on there okay so agenda for next so just for so make sure I understand oh well let we we motioned and we seconded all those in favor I okay so we got it just to make sure I understand that so uh you want a ficm study of uh human
137resources department uh could you processes could you please provide me with a scope so I can have that conversation with them well I also read read what they do they'll they'll meet with all of us to identify the scope well that would be so I with the Lea is what it says that would be for me so so so the board would give me what the scope what what scope you want so like organization wise okay organization processes like from posting to hiring the processes we have processes what falls under is that what yes you know just trying to read your mind sure mhm okay you got it from point of contact to onboarding just the the process and what can we do better okay so it'll be on the next agenda thank you okay
138so so I think that also another point that we should look is the number of people right because I think HR might be a small department for our district so we might need more people there U so I think that that it's one of the things that we like to look look from a third party get that perspective do we need an additional support to help um uh Mr Romero there uh to be able to um continue the operations of the HR department to support the district as large as ours I mean we have 50 schools that we when we add schools we don't think about sometimes adding that structure structure so what I can do is this I can bring I'll have a conversation with them I'll meet with them I'll bring it as
139a board item for next month uh with the scope that based on the the information that you just provided and after that when when you have the item here in front of you if you want to add a different scope the part of the scope another item as part of the scope you let me know and we'll add it okay does that work yeah thank you that was number five thank you that was it okay do you have any more no I'm going to add um Dr Reyes if we can schedule a special board meeting um that uh focuses on two aspects um the roles and responsibilities of a school board member with um the brown act uh information as well uh can we do that towards the end of February would that be okay
140just clear our calendars yeah so so what I can do is I can to have a rsle send you some uh possible dates and times and then we'll base it on based on your responses thank you all right board communication this is the members of the board communicating to the public um the um events things related to The District that you've attended since the last board meeting um trustee um trustees welcoming you to this process and um being able to report out the things that you've heard um within the community as you go out to site so truste Dominguez serantes it was a short month it was a short month with everyone having a nice break but I don't think our Union presidents get breaks because when I talked to them they've already met with
141quite a few people but um we had a DC deac meeting yesterday that I attended and um it was rather informational um the different programs we have with uh our lead programs and that that was good and what I did ask was did Mr gabayo leave but about when you post the Avail the application to let the parents know because some of the calls we get is I didn't know it was up you know now I didn't you know now it's closed the opportunity to enroll their children so I went there appreciate our Union Partners I met with um both Union Partners I'm looking forward to the day that our associate principles give me a day to meet and um that's probably my visit I've met met with some parents with some of the concerns
142that I've already shared here that's it and I appreciate our speakers for coming out and sharing their concerns here as well thank you thank you vice president the Mayo did you go anywhere didn't go anywhere um but I do want to welcome uh our two newest trustees uh trusty Ram Dominguez and trusty Tolson uh uh to the show so obviously um there's there's times that these meetings uh go a little bit longer this is not normal that's not our goal uh but that's that is not our goal our goal is to be as as efficient as we can uh while still um making sure that we're asking the appropriate questions and making sure that um we have the appropriate information to make decisions that not only affect all our students but also our staff um
143so welcome and I want to welcome back uh all our staff from from the break I hope that um you had a a nice break during the holiday season and um enjoy time with your families um as trusty Dominguez rant said um the it seems like the union presidents didn't uh take a break because they were calling uh with different ideas perspectives and issues so I want to thank for that um feedback that you providing provide uh because that helps me understand a little bit more the the issues and the questions that I need to ask here in the DI so thank you and um I'll pass it on thank you um I'll start by echoing that our three our three associations um in the district I appreciate your comments and I I listen um
144and I especially like the uh professional and collaboration aspect of um working with the association president um one thing I got to do right before break and it was the most fun I've had in a while was I got to go to career day at Los Altos and I was the most popular career day person because I brought stickers wow and I didn't let them have just one sticker I let them have many stickers um and so that was um very fun very exciting for me um the students were um I was a little bit nervous because the grouping was second graders with fifth graders in the same room and that's a very different attention span so um I was really happy with that um and um I was excited to be there and they
145all now know that Dr reyes's bosses have been at Los Salto so they're going to ask you who your bosses are yes oh um but um welcome back everyone and um I look forward to a great uh ending of the second part of the Year Dr Rees it's your turn all right first I want I I want to welcome our new trustees thank you first meeting done done check yeah so so yeah so so welcome um I know it was probably some of the things were new to you however you'll get this uh you know by within a month or so you'll get it and uh uh we're very fortunate to have you here with us so welcome uh also want to thank our uh Union uh leadership thank you for staying for for being
146uh Partners in the work that we do as well as our teachers and everybody else and my incredible uh uh cabinet and uh everyone that that supports uh all the work that we do I know that you spend a lot of hours lot of hours working and making sure that everything is done uh the way it's supposed to be we're looking forward to a new uh semester for a great second semester and we're looking forward to uh lot of uh Student Success and achievements thank you thank you the next regular meeting of the Board of Education of the Chula Vista Elementary School District will be held on February 19th 2025 at 4m. for close session and 6:00 pm for the Open Session do we have a meeting a motion to adjourn this meeting motion to
147adjourn second moved by clerk Dominguez cantes seconded by truste Ramirez Dominguez all those in favor I meeting adjourned e