CorpusRecord 39015

01/17/2025 - Spanish - Chula Vista Elementary School District Special Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Chula Vista Elementary School District
Date
2025-01-18
Location
San Diego County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,963 words · about 56 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001al al testing testing testing one two al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al Mrs. Cervantes requests it and Mr. Tamayo seconds it. All in favor. I, the motion passes unanimously. Oral communications. Persons who wish to address the board on any item on the agenda of the extraordinary meeting must attend in person and complete a request card to be heard and submit it to the secretary of meetings before the start of the meeting. No action will be taken or discussion taken on any item not listed on the posted agenda. Exactly, the Education Board or district staff may respond briefly. The board will limit the total time for participation on each item to 20

002minutes. With the consent of the board, the chairperson may decrease the time allowed for public presentations. No action can be taken. There is no one who wants to communicate. We will now go into closed session. Government section 354 9.1d 549 57.6 of the Government Code. Collective bargaining. Negotiations with employees. Agency negotiators. Yes to Government Code section 54 nu5 7 B1 discipline dismissal of a public employee government code 54957 government code appointment public employee title director of student services government code 54957 of the Government Code appointment employee employment of public employee executive director of curriculum or instructional support services and services we return to the open session with all members Presenting the announcements will be Ms. Dominguez Cervantes, Government Code 54957, appointment of the Executive Director of Instructional Support Services. Second, Mr. Tamayo, the Board of

003Directors, appointed Maria Montgomery as Executive Director of Support Services and Curriculum and Instruction, Government Code 54957, appointment of a public employee, Senior Director of Student Services. The Board of Directors approved Paula Madrigal Patel as Senior Director of Student Services. Three votes. No. None. Abstentions. None. Thank you very much, Mr. Romero. If you could please introduce our new superintendent to the community, we present to you our new administrators taking the new position of Executive Director. I call on Maria Montgomery. Good evening, Dr. Reyes, Superintendent, members of the Board. I just want to take a moment to thank you for this opportunity to serve our District in this new role. I am looking forward to this leadership and collaboration, and working with our schools, leaders, and educators to serve our community. Thank you for this honor. And

004our new Senior Director, Dr. Paula Madrigal Patel. Good evening, Superintendent, members of the Board. Thank you for your confidence. I am very Excited to continue my journey of leadership and learning in this District within my community, and then CBSD is the best place to be. Thank you very much. And that concludes the open session of the Board of Education. Order is called. Welcome, everyone. Are all members present, Mr. Romero? If not, please lead us in the salute to the flag. Your right hand on your heart to the flag of the United States and the Republic, which represents one nation under God with liberty and justice for all. We approve the agenda. There is a motion. I request a motion to approve. Ms. Dominguez Cervantes requests it, and Mr. Tamayo seconds it. All in favor. Say

005I. The emotion passes unanimously. Oral communications. The oral communications of the special board give the public the opportunity to address the Board on items only on this agenda. People who wish to be heard may attend in person and must complete a request card to be heard and give it to the recording secretary before the start of the meeting. Speakers should limit their remarks to 3 minutes and speak in a Respectful and professional, the board will limit the total time for public participation to 20 minutes per topic. With the board's consent, the chair may increase or decrease the time allowed for comments. We have nine people who want to speak, and with approval, we will have 3 minutes for each. The first person to address us is Ana Cabral. Good evening. My name is Ana Cabral,

006and I support the nomination of Noah Cravens for the board. Noah has an established base. She is the president of Jeffers School PTA and also represents our Special Education children. She is part of our school board and part of our safety plan, and also a representative for DILAC. She has also been appointed as a member of the Community Advisory Council. She has dedicated her life to serving others with compassion and loyalty. She is ethical, reasonable, considers the well-being of all, and likes the best results. She is a moral thinker. Combining those two qualities, she considers actions that are right and wrong with her husband and her two daughters, Estel and Nova, both of whom attend the school. Jeffers is like every parent in this room who wants change, action, and answers. She has listened to

007the concerns and shared her experiences. That's why I'm here to advocate for her and for the parents. She's frustrated and tired of the information she's been given. She feels things have progressed. My advice to her is to follow the money, and that's why she wants to be a member. She has researched the agendas and minutes, and she has also looked into the members' votes. She's not political, but she's a parent like me asking for change and action. She's going to investigate, she's going to question, and she's going to demand action. She's going to focus on transparency and collaboration. Thank you. Good evening, board members and community members. My name is Felipe Dominguez, and I'm here today as a proud brother to talk about someone who has been an inspiration, an example. And that is my

008sister, Karen Dominguez. She wants a position on the board, and I believe she is exactly the leader this community needs. Karen is a mother of three, and like any parent, she understands the The hopes and concerns that come with raising children in this environment are about giving each child the opportunity, support, and education they deserve. That's a big part of what motivates her, and that's why she wants to serve. But what truly makes Karen special is her heart for people. She's worked for many years in non- profit organizations, she's also worked with her local church, and she's held leadership and support roles, whether working in front of or behind the scenes. She has humility, dedication, and a great spirit of humility. Karen doesn't just talk about making a difference; she's someone who listens first. One

009of the things I admire about her is that she values ​​faith and integrity, putting herself before everyone else, like her brother. I've seen these qualities in action for as long as I can remember, helping me with my homework. And yes, she's also competitive. That's why she's such a strong leader, and people want to be in this position because they believe in the potential of this community, in the schools, and what they offer. She is someone who wants to sit at the table to ensure that the voices of teachers, parents, and students are heard and valued. So today, I ask that you please consider her. Thank you. [Music] Roberto: Hello, good evening. I can't believe this is the first meeting of the year. So, Happy New Year! I appreciate that everyone is here. It's very important

010that everyone is here for their roles. Whether it's to appoint someone, or if you can't appoint someone, then it will be through election. It's important that you demonstrate good character and also good judgment, perhaps for our students. In that sense, I truly hope that this board considers that they are not choosing a favorite and that this person, whoever it may be, is the right person for the job and is someone who will serve the community well. Making an appointment is not an easy job because you are removing the voice of the people to choose their representative. So, I want to point out that if you make an appointment, remember the consequences of doing so. We are not going to choose who it is, and just like in the positions, they couldn't choose because the time

011from the 8th to the 17th was very short. Review The requests then to wait for many people who see this and give their opinion, because there wasn't much time to plan it. So I just want to say these things and wish you a good year and let's make 2025 the Year of the Children and we have to care about them because sometimes they closed the school and forced them to wear masks and also get vaccines. I appreciate you and thank you to the public who are here today. Thank you, Enrique Ramirez. Good night everyone. I am Enrique Ramirez and I am here not as a father, I am here as a Chulavista resident and as a proud husband. And I am here to fully support Keren Ramirez Dominguez. I believe she is the best, the

012ideal candidate for the board. She has always been dedicated to the community and the well-being of the children of Chulavista. She has been a resident for almost 20 years and she understands the needs of this unit and now she is a mother of three beautiful children who attend Chulavista schools. She understands what is happening in the school system. She has always been committed to learning. She has spent years preparing. She earned her She has a diploma in child development and has also volunteered extensively with local organizations. One of her most outstanding qualities is her passion for sacrificing her own time to make a positive impact on the community. I believe she is the ideal candidate for this role. She is someone who truly cares and understands, and she has been there, as someone said, behind

013the scenes. I truly cannot express in enough words how much she cares about this position. It's not about politics, it's not about her name being out there or what people will say or think. It's about making a change, doing things right, and bringing these values ​​back. It is my privilege and pleasure to support my wife, Keren Ramirez Dominguez. Thank you, Mike Jager. Good evening. Thank you so much for everything you do for us. My recommendation is also for Keren Ramirez Dominguez. I am the pastor of a local church where she attends with her beautiful family. I want you to know something that I know you may not: she spends her Sundays and Saturday afternoons at our church. She has a lot of faith and volunteers her time in every area she can, serving on many

014teams. Wherever she wanted to be or could be, she chose the children's church. She is one of our most faithful volunteers, and she chooses her free time to be with school-aged children. Her attitude and stance toward service—she doesn't receive any reward, but that desire to serve, being with the children, talking to them, playing with them, teaching them—is remarkable. Thank you so much for your time and consideration. Thank you, Crystal. Hello, good evening, board. Thank you for what you do for the children in Chul Vista. I am also here to support my friend Keren Ramirez Dominguez. I am supporting her not just because she is my friend, but because I have known her for approximately the last three years. Her dedication to her children, her family, her community, and helping others is so evident. Since I

015met her and she taught me about Education, where she puts her heart, and being part of the board, she is committed to the children. When goals are set, they are met; that is something I know about her. When she sets her mind to something... She works on something until the very end, and that's very beautiful for me to see. Another thing is how she treats children. I don't have school-aged children now, but maybe in a few months. It's very encouraging to know that she will be there for the next leaders of Chul Vista and that the children's voices will be heard. I know she would be a magnificent member of the board, just like you are. Jorge Méndez, good evening. First of all, thank you for your service to the community. My name is Jorge

016Méndez, and I am the director of a program at a church with Karen and her husband, and I am here to speak in favor of Karen Ramirez Dominguez. I had the privilege of working with her for almost two years when she was in our children's department here at our church. She is not just a volunteer; she is a leader. She takes care of approximately 20 to 25 children every Wednesday and Sunday. There are children with special needs, and her natural ability to solve problems—if she sees something that needs to be done, she will do it. She will communicate through the appropriate channels. She handles different things and ensures that every child is in She creates a pleasant and supportive environment, which she cares about deeply. She invests her time in the well-being of children and

017understands the importance of education, their safety, and their development. She has trained some people because we have leaders who take the classes. She has faith, she is hardworking, she is dedicated, and what she does for our community... I believe she would be a magnificent addition to our board. She has the heart and the leadership skills necessary to make an impact on the community. Thank you, Rosi Martinez. Good evening, President Tamayo and Mrs. Dominguez Cervantes. Before you hear from potential members, we evaluate strong relationships, not only with the director of this district but also with this board. I appreciate having you as partners and having you support our advocacy for students. It is this collaborative relationship that we have had, support for students, staff, and families. There is also academic and socio-emotional support, and we also

018have community schools. When you consider candidates, consider who shares our values, who understands that these strong relationships are what help us keep moving forward, who understands that our working conditions are the conditions of our students. that will unite us instead of dividing us. CBS values ​​parents as partners. We cannot have a platform for those who will discredit or undervalue the work of educators. We also hope that when you hear from the candidates, you will prioritize advocacy for the District and not for their own aspirations. We hope you will consider board members who will add to the work we have already begun and not detract from it. Thank you for taking the time to make this important decision, Mr. Pérez Chica. Good evening, Dr. Reyes. Board members, CBS Cabinet sent an email, and we want to

019share it with you. We want to share our concerns, but we will not mention the name, Ms. Algarte. I hope this message finds you well. I am from the Fahari Jeffers community. I am concerned about Noel Cravens. In recent years, Ms. Cravens's actions have been problematic. She has publicly incited parents to speak out against teachers, created hostility, and established media platforms between parents and teachers. These actions are not only damaging but are also jeopardizing the atmosphere of cordiality. A board member must embody unity, and this person lacks these values. Please consider the unpleasant consequences of your leadership. Thank you for your time, and we hope that CBSD will be a place of collaboration, respect, and mutual commitment. Thank you. There is no one else who wishes to speak. We will now move on to the

020interviews of candidates for interim appointments to the board vacancies. At the last meeting in December, it was detailed how this would be conducted. We will call the candidates who drew numbers in a random order, and we will proceed through the same process with each candidate. We will not ask follow-up questions. And you will hear how this will be done. Thank you very much for being here, Mr. Farías. I will describe the process, and then we will begin. You will have your 3-minute introduction, followed by a question from each member. You will have 3 minutes for each answer, and then you will have the opportunity to present a one- minute statement outlining what you want us to know about you for this position you are applying for. Good evening, President Hugarte, cabinet members, staff, and community.

021It is my honor to be here. Here in front of you, seeking the same opportunity as I did a few years ago, please repeat the question: What is it that you want us to know about you regarding this position? I want to be committed to the students, the well-being of the staff, and our community. I have been in education for 25 years and have worked in a variety of roles, from custodian to teacher, principal, human resources director, and now business assistant. I have held all these positions, which have given me a unique and comprehensive understanding of the challenges we face as a district, but also the opportunities we have to make a significant impact not only on the students, staff, and community. I have had the privilege of working with partners from many businesses and

022organizations to directly benefit each student and family, whether it's providing meals, working with law firms to ask for advice for families, providing security, or making annual contributions to truly support academic programs. These experiences have truly taught me how to manage and maintain lasting relationships. But beyond that, I am someone who values collaboration and teamwork. I want to address the needs of each and every student with all of you. I am the only candidate from the postal code. l 91911 and I want to make sure that every community has a voice at the table. You know, I used to sell ice cream in Mexico, and when I came here, I was a custodian for 17 years, and now I'm here before you advocating for these opportunities. Thank you, Ms. Dominguez Cervantes. My question is... Excuse me,

023my question is: If you were appointed, what is your agenda for the first 30 days? Thank you, Ms. Cervantes. The first item on my agenda... well, there are several items in my mind because I don't have the agenda. I'm here to meet with the superintendent first and foremost to make sure that I understand what the district's successes are and, at the same time, what the needs are. Although the Chul Vista School District has been an example for all other districts, there is much work to be done, especially with students with special needs. There are still many needs. The second item on my mind is that I want a $15 million deficit for the 2024-2025 school year. It's very important to ensure the physical stability of our district so that we can maintain the programs we

024have, and also to make sure that... the third... This is not in order to ensure that our students are safe, that each of our teachers and classified staff members has the training on how they can support our children every day. Many times we talk and say, "Oh, it's just 20, 24 children, possibly 27 in the upper elementary grades," but it's the teacher who knows what's happening in those classrooms. Unfortunately, there is an increase in the social-emotional needs of our students. I was able to read the meeting minutes; there is a memorandum of understanding, but the professional development meetings for our teachers haven't been held. I'm going to push for that, and if it's already in action, well, I want to see how to support it, and I'm going to meet with the superintendent so we

025can collaborate and be aligned on what the needs of the School District are. I don't have any authority or power, and I'm okay with that because I believe in collaboration. I believe in working together to ensure that every member is well. Thank you, Mr. Tamayo. What are your ideas for providing social-emotional support to students, and how should it be provided? I just... I should mention that, although when I was a principal I knew the needs of my school in terms of social-emotional support, making sure that those communication channels were being used and that they existed, but that we were taking action, I understand again that there has been a delay in understanding between CBE and CBSD in ensuring that they are being used and that we are taking action. Social-emotional needs have grown tremendously. I

026have children, I have felt it. What I want to do is be here to collaborate and ensure that we take action on these needs. If our children have social-emotional needs, there are numbers and letters, and we must ensure that we are not only serving our students but also our families. The teachers use an adopted curriculum for their lessons; some also bring their own materials to supplement the instruction. How much flexibility do you think teachers can have in adopting these, in changing these lessons? I was a teacher for 11 years, and we had flexibility in the grade I taught. Now, I think that as members of the board, we have policies, we have administrative regulations, and I think we need to meet with the teacher leaders to ensure that we are on the This is the

027same page where we're enabling a multi-diverse curriculum that truly represents the community of students we serve. Thank you. Do you have a minute for a statement? I just stated a couple of things about who I am and why I'm here. I'm here because of the promise to public education and because the teachers believed in me when many people didn't. I'm doing my doctorate at the University of San Diego, and this is a reflection on who the teachers were and the promise to public education. I want to work with you to ensure that we work together and have good conditions for each of our students: general education, special education, diverse. Every student deserves the opportunity to have the right to be the best they can be. That's why I'm here. Thank you. Next up is Noel

028Cravens. Good evening, thank you for being here, Ms. Cravens. I'm going to describe the process, and then we'll begin. You'll have your three minutes for an introduction, then one question from each member, and you'll have three minutes for each answer. So don't think I'm going to be rude by letting you know. And then you'll present one. One minute to conclude: what is it you want us to know about you related to the position you are applying for? First of all, thank you very much for considering my application to serve on this board. I am Noel Cravens. I have two daughters here in the district. I have also been a registered nurse for almost 20 years. I am seeking an appointment to advocate for the needs of students and educators and to rebuild relationships with the

029district and parents. I served on the school board and the PTA. I was also appointed as the CBSD representative to the CAC. The CC is a group of parents, teachers, and school districts that supports children with special needs. I have attended CS meetings to stay up-to-date on district policies, budget, curriculum, staff, and much more. These experiences have allowed me to build relationships with teachers and community members, not only in my school community but also in other communities within the district, giving me a deep understanding of the current challenges of our district. Speaking of strengths, well, yes, our English student scores have increased, and so has the rigorous learning initiative. Challenges... The challenges the district has faced are transparency, accountability, and collaboration with teachers and parents. As employees, there are no political aspirations. I believe that

030my fresh perspective, combined with my leadership, passion for advocacy, and the relationships I build within the school community, allows me to make positive changes and improve transparency. Thank you, Ms. Dominguez Cervantes. Good evening. My question is, if you were appointed, what would your agenda be for the first 30 days? As I mentioned before, I would like to rebuild the community's trust in the district, have open communication, welcome and increase parent involvement, and promote equity. What are your ideas for providing socio-emotional support to students, and how would you provide it? It's very important for students to start at school. If children are in a positive learning environment, they will succeed. Ensuring student success requires making sure they feel comfortable at school and that they are in a safe environment. That's all. Thank you. Teachers use the

031adopted curriculum for their lessons; sometimes they also bring their own materials to supplement instruction. As a parent, I feel that the teachers... I trust the teachers. They are educators and they go to training, and I believe they should have the flexibility to bring any material to the school that they believe will help educate our students. But as long as it stays within the mission of our district... Now you have the opportunity for a one- minute concluding statement. I'm just a mom, a dad, a member of the community. I want all students to succeed, whether they're from Chula Vista, or Chula Vista, or... Thank you. Our next candidate is Jessica Thorston. It has n't started yet. It's about to start. What? What? What? What? Right now, slow down because I'm... but it hasn't started yet because

032she's the third candidate. And how many are there? Here are the names. This one already went... just in case, this one already went, and this one already went, and now comes Jessica Thorston. H. It's difficult. And also, thank you for being here, Mrs. Thorston. I'm going to describe the process, and then we'll begin. You'll have a three-minute introduction followed by a question from each board member, and you'll have three minutes for each answer. So, after that, you'll have the opportunity to present a one-minute concluding statement. Ready? What would you like us to know about you? And how does the position you're applying for relate to this? Good evening, members of the board. [Music] And how could I contribute to ensuring that families have equal opportunities? My experience as a mother is that planning for the

033future can lead us to different situations. When my son entered transitional kindergarten, my husband was a veteran. It was a very difficult time for my family when he passed away. The school staff provided us with support and care. Their actions showed what it truly means to support families and students. Since we started school, I appreciate all the opportunities the district provides to families and students. These initiatives demonstrate a commitment to providing an inclusive environment. Professionally, I am a public servant with Homeland Security. I am bilingual, bicultural, and also a veteran. I have held several leadership positions. [Music] Through my experience, I possess the qualifications as a veteran of the armed forces. I understand The difficulties I have are that I am passionate about advocating for families and ensuring that all students have access to the

034resources they need. Student success depends on the system they are in. If I have the honor of serving as a board member, I will make sure to work collaboratively so that teachers have all the resources they need. I will also promote transparency and accountability, and ensure that parents have information about their children's progress. I am ready and willing to continue contributing to the success of the School District. Thank you, Member Cervantes. Good evening. My question, if you are assigned, is what is your agenda for the first 30 days? In the first 30 days, my agenda would be to start introducing myself. I believe in communication. I want to have open communication with all the schools. I want them to have access to me, to us, so they feel comfortable. I want to advocate for the

035staff, the teachers, and the parents. So I want them to feel comfortable introducing myself and starting to work, starting to learn what it means to be a board member. Thank you, Mr. Tamayo. What are your... Your thoughts on social-emotional learning and how it should be delivered are something my son and I have relied on a lot. We have taken advantage of what the district has offered us in the area of ​​emotional education. I believe that all students deserve access to any social-emotional support they may need. The school has been fantastic in offering different supports for social-emotional development, and everything that has been offered to us is available, encouraging us to take advantage of it for our social-emotional well-being. I recently learned that the district had a workshop this week called "It Starts at Home." I

036saw it on Instagram, and I thought it was very good because it really does start at home. I believe all of these programs should be accessible to all students. But I think parents should always be informed of these opportunities and also of the materials that will be provided and taught because I believe that teachers and parents should always work together. Thank you very much. Teachers use this curriculum, approved or adopted books, and sometimes they use their own materials to supplement the teaching. What is your opinion of teachers... My son is in first grade. I believe that students and teachers should use their own materials or supplement instruction with their own materials from what the district offers. There are always some books that I've been interested in, and The Magic Book is one of them. Let's

037Play Reading offers good phonemic development exercises. My Mom Loves Me, Mom, My Mamu—I would donate all of those to the teachers so they can use them in the classroom. So I believe they should be allowed the flexibility to supplement instruction with their own materials. I think those exercises and materials give you the opportunity to have a one-minute statement and a one-minute conclusion. Again, thank you for the opportunity. Based on my experience, I believe I can offer a new perspective to the district. My son is in first grade. We've been here for two years. My experience working in government and leadership means I think I can contribute. I want the children to feel safe physically and emotionally. In conclusion, thank you again for the opportunity. And if I am assigned this, I am ready to begin.

038Thank you very much. Now we have Fernando Parra. Thank you very much for being here, sir. Parra, I'm going to describe the process, and then we'll begin. You'll have a 3-minute introduction, followed by one question from each board member, and you'll have 3 minutes for each answer. If I have to cut you off—it's not that I 'm being rude—you'll have the opportunity to give a one-minute concluding statement. Okay, what do you want us to know about you? How do you relate to the position you're running for? A little bit about me: I was born in Mexico, and at the age of 15, I was brought to the United States. It was very difficult adjusting to a new life. I didn't know the language, and I didn't know anyone. However, with the wonderful help of my

039teachers, I persevered. I'm not a public speaker, but I persevered and succeeded. I had a successful experience and was able to become the man I am now. I've been living in Chula Vista for the last 40 years. I love this community. There's no better community than Chula Vista. I'm also a proud father of two wonderful daughters who came through this district and are now... In high school, I have spent the last 18 years professionally in facilities management and project management for both non- profit and private organizations. I have extensive experience in budget management, among other areas. I believe my experience aligns with the requirements of a board member position, especially in construction management and budget management. I know the board plans to build more schools and housing. This is one of my passions, and I

040believe I can bring this experience to support these initiatives. As a member of the community, giving back is very important to me. Whether it's working with families, doing community service, helping the homeless, or those in need of any kind of support, I truly enjoy what I do. It's very important to make a difference. Thank you very much, Ms. Cervantes. Member Cervantes, if you are assigned, what is on your agenda for the first 30 days? As I mentioned, I want to make sure I bring my experience and knowledge in construction and budgeting. I want the district to use these resources for the benefit of the students. I also want to make sure I get to know each of them and support them in any way I can. Now that you know my knowledge and experience, I

041believe... that we can share information and I'm here to help. Thank you very much, Member Tamayo. Thank you very much. What are your thoughts on providing social-emotional support to students? And how should this support be provided? This question really touches my heart. As I mentioned before, I have two daughters who, at a young age, went through a very traumatic experience. When I won custody of them, I realized that a home wasn't enough. They needed that social-emotional support to heal. Being a single parent without family to depend on, I was a little lost, not knowing where to start or how to help my daughters. [Music] Fortunately, the school supported me, and it was a blessing. The schools became our lifeline. Now, it sounds very personal to you, but there are many families in the community who

042are struggling with trauma from difficult situations, just like me. Perhaps you feel lost, not knowing where to start or where to go for counseling. This is a very important issue for me, and I would like to make sure that if I am a member of the board, I can address this issue. To empower and involve parents in this topic with their children, that's all. Thank you very much. Teachers use approved curricula and texts; sometimes they bring their own materials to complement or supplement the teaching. How much flexibility do you think they should have to adapt the curriculum using their own materials? This happens all the time with teachers, and I think it's good to give them flexibility to bring their own materials, their handouts, or perhaps use resources on the internet. But at the same

043time, I think we must be careful. For example, in a subject like mathematics, we know it has its own language, and no matter how they manipulate numbers and equations, the answer will always be the same. There's no single topic for teaching mathematics. But for a subject like history, for example, it's a subject where the teacher has to be more careful. History is written by different people at different times. Teachers, without knowing it, may be very sensitive, and I think we shouldn't touch on topics like politics or religion. And in conclusion, a one-minute concluding statement, like... You can see I get very nervous when I have people in front of me, when I have an audience, but I want to thank you for the opportunity to be here. I want to make sure that if I

044have the honor of sitting next to you as a member, I will ensure that our children have the best academic support and also the emotional support that is so necessary in all schools, not just in Chula Vista, but everywhere. But support for you and with you will always be available. Thank you very much. Our next candidate is Victor Zavala. Thank you for being here, Mr. Zavala. I'm going to describe the process, and then we'll begin. You'll have a 3-minute introduction followed by a question from each member of the board. You will have 3 minutes for each answer. If I'm cutting it short, it's not because I'm being rude, but I'm just being consistent. Afterward, you will have the opportunity to present a one-minute closing statement. Are you ready? Yes, what would you like us to

045know about you and how you relate to the position you are applying for? Good evening, first of all, members, superintendent. I want to begin by thanking you for giving me this opportunity. It is a very exciting opportunity for me, and because of the enormous responsibility that comes with being a member of the board. I grew up in the city of Chula Vista. In this community, I met my wife, my children, and my wife. Excuse me, I'm getting a little choked up. This account has had a very positive, very profound effect on my family and me. Throughout my children's education, I was very actively involved in school events and activities, and I have experienced firsthand the impact that schools and teachers can have on the lives of students. Professionally, I have experience in management and administration,

046and I have experience in making balanced decisions. And well thought out, my experience is with budgets and budget management. I can contribute to discussions about sustainable finance. This will help me be part of this board team. As a board member, I want to prioritize initiatives that directly benefit student learning so that all students in the district can reach their full potential. I am very passionate about serving, and I would be honored to be part of your team. I promise to work tirelessly and to uphold Chula Vista's values ​​and make decisions that not only make the district proud but also bring innovative ideas. Thank you, Member Cervantes. Good evening. If assigned, what is on your agenda in the first 30 days? Good question. Thank you. First of all, I want to participate in everything I can,

047get involved with the team, familiarize myself with it, follow your guidelines, collaborate with you, see what the issues are, and try to reach conclusions that benefit the students, but also the parents and the teachers. Thank you, Member Tamayo. Thank you. What are your thoughts on providing socio-emotional support education to Students and how should it be provided as a parent and be involved in my children's education? Social-emotional support gives you the opportunity to engage with educators and help them in any way you can because their influence and effect on our children shape their lives. Our children have tremendous capacities to listen to other people besides their parents. Teachers can transmit values ​​that can help students succeed. So, if social-emotional support is provided, how does it affect the lives of students in our community? Thank you. Teachers

048use approved curricula and textbooks; sometimes they also bring their own materials to supplement the teaching. How much exclusivity do you think they should have in adapting curricula using their own materials? Good question. Educators now have a very difficult task: to give attention, to interact with students, as long as the curriculum is relevant and age-appropriate. I think it can be practical. I think children's minds receive a lot of information outside of the curriculum that can affect the way they learn. I think all of them... [Music] Children, each educator must have a different perspective. There are no identical minds, but adapting the curriculum can bring problems with parents and can affect the minds of the students. Thank you. Now you have the opportunity to give a one-minute conclusion. Thank you very much. I really hope. I know

049you have a very difficult task and many applicants, but it would be a privilege to be part of your team again. I promise to work tirelessly among you and with you to provide the best solutions, the best ideas, and find something common ground for innovative ideas for the entire district, but above all, that it be for the benefit of our students so they can feel proud of our district. I will collaborate with you and make this community very proud of us. Thank you very much. Our last applicant is Karen Ramirez Dominguez. Thank you very much for being here, Ms. Ramirez Dominguez. I'm going to review the process, and we'll begin. You will have a three-minute introduction, followed by a question from each board member, and you will have three minutes for each answer. And if

050I cut you off, it's not because I'm rude; it's because your time is up. I have a one-minute closing statement. I want you to know what you want us to know about me and how you relate to the position. Good evening, members of the board and everyone present. My name is Keren Ramirez Dominguez. What I want you to know about me is that I am the daughter of Felipe Maria Dominguez. I have been taught that life and true triumph are about serving others. My parents taught me that success is when we serve God and others. I am the fruit of Felipe, and I have been empowered by his love. I am the fruit of Point Loma Nazar, where I studied, a place where I learned that to serve children, we must first serve the parents.

051I am the fruit of the local churches where I have been able to serve for the past 15 years. I have been able to lead, to guide, and to be a part of this community, helping them to prosper. I am the fruit of community organizations that educate families and various community members, as well as providing spiritual well-being and information to the community about the importance of mental health and how important it is to... It's about giving resources to the community. I am the fruit of being a mother. That is the stage of my life that gives me the strength to be in front of you and to fight for my children, but also for the children of Chul Vista, so that they can prosper. And now I know that all the experiences I have had

052and that have given me experiences have brought me to this point. My role is to be the stepping stone for the next generation and leave a legacy. Thank you, ma'am. Good evening. If it is assigned to you, what is on your agenda in the first 30 days? One of the things I want to establish first is open communication with the parents. I want the parents to know that they can talk to me, that they can share any concerns they may have. Once I establish this relationship with the parents, our community will have more closeness. That would be one of the first things I would do. Thank you very much, Member Tamayo. Thank you. What are your thoughts on providing socio-emotional support to students? And how should it be implemented? Thank you. I believe that socio-emotional

053support is one of the pillars not only for the students but also for the parents because, again, when we educate the parents, we empower and help them. so that their children thrive. Thank you. Teachers use adopted curricula and textbooks, and sometimes they also bring their own materials to supplement the teaching. How much flexibility do you think they should have to adapt lessons using their own materials? I think it is important that teachers have the flexibility to bring their own materials as long as it supports the same goal. But again, our goal is for our children to thrive and progress. So there should be flexibility as long as it supports the same goal: that they learn better, that they read better. Thank you very much. Now you will have the opportunity to present a one- minute

054conclusion. I want to thank you for being here. I want to thank my community behind me for speaking on my behalf. I know that my community is supporting me. I know, and I know that everything is in my favor, thank God. Now I know that He is the one who brought me here, and all my experiences give me the qualifications to be the best member I can be. And I want to thank you for the opportunity, and I also want to talk a little bit more about the legacy, the legacy that I want to leave. I want to make sure that the children of the next generation that They will have the foundation to reach their full potential, and that is the legacy I want to leave. That's why I 'm here, and I want

055to serve for several years. Thank you. That concludes the interview portion of the process. The board will now work in conjunction with the papers, writings, and information that were presented tonight, and then we will present motions recommending particular candidates. Member Cervantes, if you would like to make any comments or have any questions, I think I'll take a moment to process this information. So, you can... I might also take a moment, but first of all, I want to thank all the candidates who made it to the final round. It's difficult to be on the podium. It's difficult. So thank you for your commitment to this process, for wanting to share your strengths with all the students. I'm grateful that we have such a great group of candidates. I think it's very important for the District, or

056the board, to see the mission and vision that the board has adopted, and that is what we use to make our decisions. I think there is an opportunity to make a decision. I think we have a lot of information through the applications that were... provided. And with those comments, tonight I do consider having parents and the voice of the parents very important. I think that's one of the factors that guide us. I also want to thank everyone. I know it's very difficult to speak in public, and so I also think it's very important to note that our decisions tonight are based not only on what we heard last night but also on the information you provided, also based on the vision and mission of our District. So it's going to be very difficult to decide.

057It's a very difficult process. You've already done the hardest part. Now it's up to us to make a decision. As president of the board, as facilitator, sometimes I 'm reluctant to make motions because it's not my role. So I'll be listening tonight. I'll be listening to your comments, and I'll give my opinion or comment when necessary. But I await the motions. Very well, okay? Tom. A pause. So I think how I'm going to express my thoughts on processing the requests we received, what was I'm going to share what first comes to mind about each candidate. As member Tamayo said, the mission, vision, and values ​​are what I'm taking into account. Putting someone in a box and having them speak for five minutes and convey their experiences is all we have. So, with your understanding, I

058think I always share what I think, so you shouldn't have much difficulty. So, don't take anything personally. It is about you, but I also ask for your understanding. Now, looking at our mission, it is to cultivate the potential of all students through the collaboration of teachers, parents, and the community. There is our website. The last person who spoke, Ms. Keren Ramirez Dominguez, there is no conceptual relationship whatsoever. She conceptualized that very well. Clearly, I think that when she was looking at the mission, she conveyed it, she conceptualized it. It's something that is because she thanked everyone. I can appreciate that. I can articulate it. It's not always easy for everyone to articulate with respect to the mission. Zavala's collaboration, I felt that the passion she conveyed, the passion that she expressed Regarding education and socio-emotional

059support, I couldn't see the connection of how it relates to our schools. It doesn't mean he didn't try; I'm just expressing what comes to mind out loud. Mr. Parra was very clear about the social support his son received, and he also expressed the importance of collaboration between teachers, staff, and parents. It's very important that our purpose is not only to support students but also academically. I did n't hear [Music] that, but Mr. Tosten and Mrs. Tosten, we appreciate your journey, a very difficult journey, your ability, and for knowing that your son and your family needed those additional supports from the school and the community that could be offered. He also mentioned family involvement. And I wonder, I 'm sharing... I don't know, we haven't sat down together, how available you are given your very important

060work. Sometimes we have to stay very late, but we're here sometimes until 1 a.m. It does n't happen very often, but sometimes we're here until 3 or 4 in the afternoon, and sometimes, very rarely, we... We go before 10, and being with the community outside, the community isn't so easy because we only have one employee, Dr. Reyes, and it can be a very fine line, but I understand, Mr. Cravens, Mrs. Cravens, your dedication to the school, your volunteer work, the PTA, and the different organizations. I don't think you were able to articulate what you wanted to share and connect the mission. I think you did n't take full advantage of the time you were given, but bringing a new perspective is good, and there's always a balance. We hear from our parents, from the staff,

061and what we hear from the support of our cabinet, and in the middle are the facts. Because we are people, not robots, our feelings and emotions can lead us in certain directions, and in the middle, we have to find the facts. Dr. Reyes is responsible for knowing the facts to make decisions. My Farías, I want to write more, more briefly, more. You have a very elaborate application. Your experience from the beginning, you talked about the students, the community, and the staff. That was the first thing you said. You understand the role of a As a member of the board, I can also perhaps learn from you and the rest of my colleagues. I've been a board member and understand the importance of collaboration with teachers, staff, parents, and the community. That resonated with everything you

062said. So, I 'm now on the mission statement. I don't know if the rest of my colleagues would like to talk about something else. I'm going to talk about values. I think that's one of the key components on which this board is based. Every decision we make affects thousands of students and thousands of staff members. Having similar values—we may not agree on everything because we have similar value systems—we can reach agreements. I may not like them, but I can support them. That's very important when we consider who sits at this table. To continue is to keep improving, to learn from past mistakes and identify opportunities to move forward. I think each of you shows potential to sit on the board. Some of you have a little more understanding because you've been in this role before

063or are currently involved in the PTA or some district-level committee. But I do think we need... Include more of the parents' voice in one of the vacancies. Instead of talking about each of them individually, I will talk about representation as a board member. Each one I present is capable of being a board member. With seven applicants, we have to reduce that number. [Music] Part of that is listening to the constituents. There are several ways, several things I've experienced in recent years, that I learned two years ago during the elections. It was often said that having political aspirations and being a politician means listening to the constituents and representing their interests. What is recurring is that there are no political ties. There are two candidates as a board member, and listening to the constituents, and what

064I was asked, what I was asked, is that there be no political connections. The candidates tonight who participated in the previous elections, that's a political connection. When we asked to listen to the constituents' voices, and they were unsuccessful in those elections, and yes, we have to take it very seriously with regard to listening to the constituents because there is the opportunity to run, to be a candidate in a political career, and some have I took that opportunity. And then they have that experience. There's also the aspect of representing our labor groups, who are our constituents. Many of them, so [Music] if the three of us have to reach a consensus and agree, those with political ties who have participated in past elections will not be considered. Here we go. And yes, that was one of

065our concerns. Some of the applicants aren't here. Some of them called me, and I had to tell them, "I have it memorized." And there are people who were talking to say good things about some of the applicants, but that was my appointment. I don't encourage anyone to contact me. If it's about the appointment, once the process is over, I'd be happy to talk to them. We can talk. I bet everyone here has an "r" or a "d" because they're politicians. That's how they vote. Some have an "r" after their name, some have a "d." Mr. Tamayo, as he said, values ​​are what we're interested in: the well-being of our children, of our students. And that usually happens if we have that collaboration among the staff. Classified certificate and our parents, our community, is the only

066way we can collaborate and help our students succeed. The fact that some of them may have participated in a political election, and I don't know, but I think we have to focus here. After we had some people talk to me, many people contacted me to try to... Because that's why these applicants are here. Because they passed those filters, but my preference would be a special election because people deserve to choose their people. They have the right. I have the right, we all have the right, we deserve that. But consider all the components. Dr. Reyes, it seems there are 3 million [dollars] to... to have a special election. I don't know if I would consider it, but on that, based on the... the... of the... That is the mission, that is the mission to cultivate the

067potential of all students through collaboration between staff, parents, and the community. I would like to assign Karen Ramirez Domingos to seat C. The emotion of the seconded by Member Tamayo in favor, I am in favor. The emotion does not pass. Now, it means we will go to a special election. We don't have five candidates, we have six because they have to be the ones you want. I don't know any of them. We have five candidates because you do n't want Karen Dominguez. I already expressed my concern. One of the filters is that they not be political by definition. If you already participate in a political election, by definition you are already political. For me, the people who have contacted me, I haven't answered the phone. But I'm talking about the last four years that I

068have been on this board, and having political candidates that the people didn't choose, and how problematic that can be as a representative, and listening to previous interactions, I am not going to support any candidate who has participated in a political race or election. That would be my rationale. Often, sometimes we don't reach an agreement, but it means we're going to close the door. I think there's value in all the applicants. Talk about parents. I, uh, for the... the cow, seat number five. It's that I have a lot of chocolate. So there was no one to second it. You have to... you want to make another motion? Okay, I'm going to make another motion. So I propose to nominate... we 're still at five, or are we going to change to one? Okay, so I'm going

069to make a motion to nominate Armando Farías. I second it. I second it. Mr. Domingo Cervantes, Mr. Tamaño, they second it. All in favor. I... the motion doesn't pass. Okay, so I'm going to request the motion for Noel Cravens, seat number five. I'm going to wait for the chair to share the opinion. So I abstain. So the motion dies. It doesn't pass. Do you want to make another motion? I request the motion for Chair number C, for Keren Ramírez Domínguez. It has to be a motion to reconsider, and the three of us have to reconsider. I'm going to share here with the table that those are my two selections, and I'm not going to... So, if we're going to double down, then we're going to have to request a special election. And I appreciate the

070opinion that we should have two candidates. But again, we've said, and this is part of our values and part of the district's mission, that we need to move forward with the understanding that a special election is probably the best way. However, we've stated, and we've all said that a special election is between 2.5 and 3 million dollars. We're ready to consider what the options are, or which programs we're going to take away from the students to exchange that 3 million for. So, you consider it, and I understand. But there are other candidates here, and you're saying that this is how it is, or we're going to have a special election. This isn't the value we're saying we need. We said that sometimes we don't agree, and this is one of those times that's going to

071be difficult to pass, but the value of making sure that we put our students first has to be our principle, the one we're being guided by. You already have my motions. And you already did them, you and I already did them. I did n't want to say this before because I felt this wasn't nice, but one of the candidates, one that you I mentioned earlier, our teachers' union spoke out against this. I didn't make the motion; the motion died. I'm asking you to reconsider your choice. And I was going to say, yes, I'm hearing you clearly. Can you share that? Besides that, there's something else, and really, don't take it personally. Mr. Armando Farías has an extensive background. He's equivalent to Mr. Mark here, also with experience in human resources. It's not your job to

072sell it to me. I want to say something. This is what I 'm hearing: we have six candidates before us, and you're saying that if I don't vote for those candidates, then you're not going to move forward, you're not going to put any of the other four in, and we're going to have a special session. I don't have any issues with these candidates, only with Mr. Farías. I'm very clear about this. I mean, you competed against him. That's not the problem. And the problem is, I was very clear, and I've heard many times about this being politicized. And if we 're reviewing all the politicians who have connections with other people, well, I don't know who the other candidates are. I don't know how many there are. I only know the seven who came to

073us today. I'm telling you that I've been maintaining this for the last four years in the last special appointment, and over time, because I've seen and been here, I want to make it clear that if you're saying—and that's what you're saying—that I'm not going to agree, and I don't understand why the committee sent seven, and we had a person who, for technical reasons, had to remove them, that there's a problem with the other candidates, I've had the least amount of time with any of this. And if I don't vote the way you want me to, for these two candidates, then we're not going to move on to anyone else or make another motion, and then we're going to have a special election. You summarized it well. So, part of the subcommittee, as you all know,

074was Ms. Cervantes and me. We spent six hours going over and over, reviewing each of the applications. My understanding was that these seven candidates were viable candidates, so why are we closing the door on the rest? Because the other half of the decision was based on the presentation, and that's where I based my decision. In other words, it didn't matter. We would have called them based on the application, that's why we needed them to come and talk. That's the other part of the application process. I don't think the other candidates said anything that raised an alarm in my head that we shouldn't nominate them or that they shouldn't serve, and I just stated that all of these candidates are capable of serving. I believe it would be a waste of money if we go to

075a special election when we have viable candidates. And those two I mentioned are viable because someone decided—if you look at your affiliations and your groups, you know if these two people are doing political things, are they politically active? And in your words and in some of your discussions and other meetings, this is anyone who has been in any political activity. Now, you're saying that if I don't vote for those two candidates, you're going to keep me here and we're going to have an election without considering the other candidates. And the other candidates aren't being judged by me alone in this interview tonight. They've been evaluated on their values and missions according to their application. Ms. Ugarte, you have the same opportunity to review all the applications. You too... You could have sat there, but I'm

076not basing it on the interview. Today there are four other candidates, four candidates that we can move to have as our potential members. You're telling me that you're not going to accept any of them. I 'm telling you that there are candidates here that I want to accept who aren't in the political arena, and that's what you stated. There are other candidates, and you put these candidates forward based on the review of their paperwork, and the other part was going to be the presentation. So, which part don't we understand? The other part is the presentation. They are different perspectives. Again, as part of the subcommittee, I believe that we brought these seven candidates. Six participated in this presentation. So, of the seven candidates, we knew, at the point that Ms. Cantes says, that the presentation

077part was still missing. However, regarding the presentation, I don't feel that any of these seven or six did badly. I believe that because of the effort they made, the commitment they showed the students, an emotion they deserve, and that's why I ask that Josica Toston be nominated for seat number five. Is there anyone who seconds this? I second it for discussion. Mr. Tamayo requested it. He asked for it, and I have to explain why I'm refraining, as I shared before, because of my concern about his availability. But that's my concern. I would have the same concern about Farías because he's an assistant superintendent in Fallbrook. He's busy. I have a niece who works in the military, and they could call her at any moment. I'm asking for Mr. Farías because we're entering an area with

078a $15 million deficit, and given his experience, I never thought you all had so much reservation about him. And I'm still not getting over the fact that he's run for this position before. He has experience in finance, he's been part of the board, understanding the processes, understanding the curriculum. That's turning into something where I'm not going to back down. I see it as not speculating any further, but I can say the same thing. I can say you're keeping me here. I'm not refusing, and here's the thing: we're making assumptions. I appreciate his experience, but we can ask follow-up questions. We don't know the situation with his job, so you're making an assumption, and that's valid. You can do that. That wasn't the only reason. I shared earlier that what was presented to us, and Mr.

079Tamayo knows, when we were in the subcommittee, we were looking for someone who could best articulate and connect with our district, its mission, vision, and values. And I was, uh, seeing that we could do the same here, not to be negative. But I agree with you. I can't compromise on who I think is the best- qualified candidate. That's lying to me, and that's lying to the community. That's not right. Instead of giving it to the person who received a B, you have to give it to the person who received a B. That's not right. It's not about right or wrong. And here's the part: I have the capacity, I had the capacity for this, and because of Brown's Act, I reviewed those and read them and the advantages. I did n't select the seven who

080passed; you did. And then you didn't just pick that aspect. Now, I was given only the six who are here, and I'm choosing from those six, and I'm choosing from my official position and being a representative of the community and making sure that [Music] I, I have had conversations too, and I was also elected, and it's not one above the other, it's that, and we're not going to talk about which ones I would like everyone to be in favor of, say, "I, I oppose," the emotion doesn't come through for the same reason, the ability to share the mission, the vision, and the values, and as I said before, this was the other part of the process, and it was the presentation. There's no value. We shouldn't have wasted your time. You're talking about presentations, but

081you're also talking about your application. So if that were the case, you want to do it again, we're not going to have a special election. We already fulfilled the motion for each of the candidates who were present here. Let me share with you what's going to happen. That's why now I'm not going to be on the next committee, right? No, we're not going to start the process again. We're going to the special election, and we're going to see what we're going to cut in order to have the money for the sessions for the special election, and you're going to take responsibility for this because I've sent two names. You nominated me for this committee, and the names are here. This isn't about who, when, how. We can't agree; not just one person is going to

082decide. It's a special election, but when the cuts are made to pay for that, we all have to bear that responsibility. It's not Mrs. Hugarte, it's not Mrs. Cervantes, or Mr. Tamayo; it's the board of directors. They couldn't choose, and now we're going to have to allocate 3 million dollars for the special election. And if that's the case, as I've said, and we're not going to agree, we're all going to have the responsibility. And if that's what the board of directors says, then we're going to have to agree. Dr. Reyes has a recommendation. I know this is something very delicate for the board of directors. We still have time to appoint someone. Something we must consider is whether we reach an agreement today, or if we don't reach an agreement today, perhaps they won't want

083to make the decision today for the special election. Next week we have the board meeting to try to reach an agreement. I don't know how our advisors work; let them tell us what we're going to do. Mrs. Domínguez Cervantes, if you don't want to change or consider the other candidates, I don't know. I've already voted on three motions. I think that if we send this to another meeting, well, nothing will be done either. Choose one of the two candidates. One, I already did it twice. Do it again, please. You know what I don't know. I don't want to go to a special election. I 'm not offering you an opportunity either. Let's try again. To be clear, that's not where I want to go. And what I said loud and clear is why I feel

084that a special election would have had to be because the person, the people, are going to have a vote. But the fact of the 15 million dollars is what made me back down, and I said, okay, programs, personnel, all the different things that can happen, but I have two very qualified candidates that we brought here who gave a great presentation. As a teacher, they know, they know, he's going to be fine. Or, give it a go, that's what they did here. Combined with this, I'm going to make another motion. My first motion, I'll repeat it, was a motion to test. I second it. I ask for it, Mrs. Dominguez Cervantes. I second it, Mr. Tamayo. Everyone in favor, say: I, thank you. I request a motion to take a 5-minute break. I second it to

085take a 5- minute recess. Al, al ... Thank you very much, thank you President Ugarte for the break. Sometimes it's good. I know the values ​​of this board. We've worked for a long time, and I believe that all of you want to put students first. And that is our goal. Sometimes we may see it differently because we have different perspectives. You've seen today that we share different perspectives. But at the end of the day, I still believe we can come to an agreement, an agreement that values ​​the work our staff is doing, the programs we offer our students, and also our opportunity to work on the mission and vision of our district. I'm going to put forward the following motion. I request a motion to nominate Karen Ramirez Dominguez to AS5 and to nominate Ms.

086Jessica Toston to number 5. Wait, we can't do that. Yes, we can. They're on the same topic, so you can combine them as we have in the past. And the other thing, I believe that in order for us to come to an agreement and make sure that we are not cutting programs for students, classified staff, certified staff, is a viable option to meet in the middle. From this path, I believe this is something that will unite us and help us make the best decision so we can move forward. I think the first emotion is—and I 'm just thinking—we're under the same agenda item. You can make a motion to combine items B and C, and then we can have one list of candidates. I 'm concerned about the repercussions of this. There's a reason why

087we did it separately at the beginning. So now, putting them back together, you can elaborate on the reason. From my perspective, it was so we wouldn't get stuck here. Now, I think if we're doing what's best for the children, then it's better that we move forward. And I'm proposing that we have one list, and that way we honor what you're saying about the candidates you're proposing. We can also include someone Lucy can support, and we move forward. I think it's a way to do it. I'm still thinking, Ms. Dominguez Cervantes, we had the option of doing it under one item. Now, it's a way to do this the other way around. That's why I said we didn't have to do two separate ones. But as I said, somehow it doesn't seem right, but in this

088case, we're doing it to move forward so we don't get stuck. Are we stuck here, or do you want to talk to legal counsel? No, legal counsel wouldn't allow you to do that. So that's not my problem. My problem is that the person who can help us with these 15 million dollars is off this list. I have the same capacity. And we have someone here... no, no. This is something more personal between you and Mr. Farías. There's no other way to explain it. Because if you really want to allow Karen Domínguez to be approved now, then what's the reason for not allowing Mr. Farías? He also ran, so it sounds like it's a personal problem. And as you said, Mr. Tamayo and Ugarte, we haven't agreed on things, but we've been respectful. It has nothing

089to do with that. I would n't vote for you because you chew gum in front of me, and I hate chewing gum. I would be looking at your qualifications. There's nothing personal here. I want to commit and make this list a reality and combine the items. It has nothing to do with anything personal. Mr. Tamayo is listening to you and your concerns, and he's trying so that we can move forward. Go ahead, it's not personal, and if I'm sticking to what I said before, politically, Ms. Ramirez Dominguez has less political experience than Mr. Farias. When I make important decisions, I can't make these decisions in a minute; I need to process them. I'm not going to snore; I would take some time. It's millions of dollars. I still feel it's personal, that it's not good.

090You know, I have to... Oh my God... Excuse me, but I have to leave. To pray, we have to... no, I'm not leaving. Who has to pray? Oh, oh, oh, I 'm ready. So I'm going to combine Articles A, B, and C into a single motion. Is there anyone seconding it? I second it. Combining Articles B, B, and C was requested by Mr. Tamayo. I second it. No, I'm going to stay as I want it to stay as it is, and I'm going to vote. I request Ms. Jessica Toston for Chair C. Is there anyone seconding it? No, I have an alternate motion. I want to nominate for Chair 5. I second it. Mr. Tamayo requested it. Ms. Domingo Servantes, I second it. Mr. Tamayo, everyone in favor, say thank you. I'm moving to nominate

091Jess. I want to apologize to Mr. Farías from the bottom of my heart because I thought this was personal, and I apologize for going through this because I believe you are the most qualified, not only based on the application but also on your presentation. Please accept my apology. I'm going to carry this with me for a long time. I ask for the second, the emotion of Mrs. Toston, because you have the strategies, because you are very strategic in all your projects, so I'm going to put you on the back burner, but please help us at this moment of a 15 million deficit. And I apologize to the rest of the applicants because they weren't given a better opportunity. I think they all would have been magnificent, but I can't compromise based on what was presented

092in the application and what was presented to us. I would only be lying to you, and to myself as well. Please accept my apologies, and I encourage you not to be discouraged, to be involved in our schools where you have taught love. And to the parents and the community, I ask that you please support us in these motions so that we can be stronger in the end. If I may ask this, it is only for the children and the staff who need you and us. Everyone in favor. And the excitement passes, Dr. Reyes. Now you will administer the oath of office to the elected members. After this, we will be congratulating the members, Dr. Reyes. It's going to end early, at least, well, it's already 9 o'clock, son. And since they don't have microphones for

093the people I'm interpreting for, I can't tell you what's happening in the room, but they're taking the oath, speaking about the United States Constitution and the California state constitution. I'd like to thank everyone for being here with us tonight. Now we have a full table. We have a motion to adjourn the meeting. Anyone second? I second. Everyone in favor? I'm in. The motion passes unanimously.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.