CorpusRecord 39016

01/17/2025 - English - Chula Vista Elementary School District Special Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Chula Vista Elementary School District
Date
2025-01-18
Location
San Diego County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
15,189 words · about 85 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e I'm now calling to order the special meeting of the chil Vista ele School District Board of Education is now in order welcome everyone all board members are present we will now approve the agenda is there a motion motion to approve second moved by clerk Dominguez serantes seconded by vice president de Mayo all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously oral Communications on Clos session items the oral communication section provides the public with an opportunity to address the board on Clos session items only persons wishing to be heard May attend in person and should complete a request to be heard card and submit it to the recording secretary before the start of the meeting speakers are requested to limit their remarks to three minutes and speak in a respectful and professional manner

002the board shall limit the total time for public input on each topic to 20 minutes with board consent the president may increase or decrease the time allowed for public comments depending on the number of persons wishing to be heard no board action can be taken no speakers there are no speakers we will now adjourn to close session in accordance with the following government code section 35491 D and 54957.6 collective bargaining employee negotiations agency negotiators Adam Silva and MCN LLP employee organizations chista classified employees organization Chula Vista Educators non-represented employees administrators Association Chula Vista government code section B1 uh Public Employee discipline dismissal and release government code section 54957 Public Employee appointment employment title senior director of student services and government code section 54957 Public Employee appointment employment title EX executive director of curriculum and instruction

003services and support e e e we now reconvene to open session with all board members present close session announcements will be made by clerk Dominguez cantes in the matter of government code section 54957 Public Employee appointment title executive director excuse me executive director of curriculum and instruction services and support on motion by member Dominguez santes second by member ber to Mayo the board approved the employment of Maria Montgomery as executive director of curriculum and instruction services and support by the following vote A's three NOS no abstain [Applause] zero on the matter of government code section 54957 Public Employee appointment title senior director of student services on motion by member Tamayo second by member Dominguez santes the board approved the promotion of Paula Madrigal Patel as senior director of student services by the following vote a

004three NOS zero extensions zero thank you um Mr Romero if you will um introduce our newest promotions awesome thank you uh governing board members and our superintendent and our community it's great pleasure for us to introduce our two newest uh administrators in new roles um so uh taking on the executive director position I'd like to call up Maria [Applause] Montgomery good evening Dr Reyes superintendent Dr Reyes and president Ugarte and members of the board I just wanted to take a moment to say thank you uh for this opportunity to serve our district in this new role I'm looking forward to uh the cooperative and collaborative leadership across our district office and as well as working in partnership with our School site leaders and Educators to serve our community thank you so much for this honor

005thank you and our newest senior director uh Dr Paula Madrigal [Applause] Patel good evening superintendent and members of the board thank you again so much for your trust um very excited to continue my journey uh leading and learning uh within this district and within my community and again CBD is the best place to be so thank you so much thank you and that concludes our newest promoted employees thank you thank you the Open session of the special meeting of the Chula Vista Elementary School District Board of Education is now in order welcome everyone all board members are present Mr Romero if you will lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance please to of the United States of America and to the stand we will now approve the agenda is there a motion motion to approve

006second moved by clerk Dominguez santes seconded by vice president de Mayo all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously oral Communications on posted items the oral Communications portion of the special meeting provides the public with an opportunity to address the board on items included in the special meeting agenda only persons wishing to be heard May attend in person and should complete a request to be heard card and submit it to the recording secretary before the start of the meeting speakers are requested to limit their remarks to 3 minutes and speak in a respectful and professional manner the board shall limit the total time for public input on each topic to 20 minutes with board consent the president may increase or decrease the time allowed for public comments depending on the number of persons wishing

007to be heard no board action can be taken in we have nine speakers and with the board approval we'll uh remain with the 3 minutes okay thank you the first Speaker Anna cabal let me know when I'm ready all right good evening my name is Anna bra and I am support and encourage the nomination of Noel Cravens for our chil Vista Elementary School Board Noel is an established background she is a president of the PTA of Jeffers Elementary as well as a secretary she's also the representative at s paa which represents our special needs children she is a part of our School site Council she's also a part of our safety School plan she's also a laac representative she is also appointed as a community advisory committee member I've known Noel for 20 years as

008a ER nurse she was a steward of our community and she has dedicated her life to the service of others with compassion and loyalty she's clear ethical reasoning considering wellbeing of others and makes for the best outcomes she is a moral thinker cognitive and emotional process with combining of those two she is considering the actions that are right and wrong she carries with her a vibrancy of family life and student life with her husband and her two amazing daughters Stella and Nova who both attend Jeffrey's Elementary she's just like every parent in this room wanting answers wanting change wanting action I know no well of attending Grassroots meetings in front of Jeff's Elementary with parents with special need children and she has listened with their concerns and their experiences that is why I'm here today

009to advocate for her and advocate for our parents she is frustrated and fed up with the information that she has given she feels that things are just smoothed over so that they will stop the District phone call stop the district meetings and stop the district emails my one piece of advice to her was to follow the many and with that One Singular sentence this is why she is reaching out to be one of your board members she has research past agendas she has research board minutes and she has researched the votes of our current board members now she's not a seasoned politician but she is apparent just like I am demanding change and demanding action and she will not be ill-prepared for our meetings she will research and she will question and she will demand

010action she will focus on transparency collaboration thank you very much thank you you're welcome phip [Applause] Dominguez good evening members of the board and um community members as well my name is Felipe Dominguez uh and I am here today as a uh proud brother to speak about someone who has been an aid to me uh an inspiration an example and uh that is my sister Ken Dominguez she's running for a position on the Chula Vista school board and I believe she's exactly the kind of leader this community needs Karen is a mother of three and like any parent she understands the hopes and concerns that come with raising children in today's environment her journey as a mom isn't just about gu her own kids it's about wanting every child to have the opportunities support and

011education they deserve that's a big part of what drives her and that's why she wants to serve but what truly makes Karen special is her heart for people she's she spent years working in nonprofits helping real families solving real problems she's also deeply rooted in her faith and her local church where she has stepped up in leadership roles and rolled up her sleeves in support roles as well whether she's leading from the front or working quietly behind the scenes she does it all with a spirit of humility dedication as well as with a great spirit of humbleness Karen doesn't just talk about making a difference she lives it she's someone who listens first finds common ground and works hard to bring people together one thing I admire most about her is How Deeply family driven

012she is her values are rooted in what matters most Faith integrity and putting others before herself as her brother I've seen these qualities in action for as long as I can remember uh whether she was guiding me sharing me on or showing up when it matter the most helping me even in my homeworks uh and yes she's also uh competitive as well that drive is what makes her such a strong leader and Karen is running this position because she believes in the potential of this community its schools and what it provides she's someone who won't just sit at the table she'll make sure the voices of parents teachers and students are heard and valued so tonight I ask you to consider consider her qualifications and consider who she is holistically and I know she'll bring

013the same care dedication and problem solving mindset to the school board that she brings to everything else she does thank you thank [Applause] you Robert hello good evening um I believe this is the first meeting of the year so happy New Year uh really appreciate everybody showing up tonight it's very important that everybody show up for their roles whoever is uh either appointed or if you can't uh agree upon someone uh then through the election is elected right we expect these things from the people in charge to show good uh um attendance good more judgment um we also want to look out for the best of our children in that sense so I would really hope the board considered tonight that you're not picking a favorite purse something like party or things like that and

014that this this person whoever it may be is the right person for the job and is someone who's going to serve the community well um you know making an appointment is not an easy job because you're taking away the voice of the people to choose their representative and I just like to bring notice to that that if you do make an appointment just remember the consequences of that we're not also getting to choose who it is and just as in the board supervisor position they couldn't choose and they had to ask the people for who it is and sometimes that's the more respectable position considering how short it was from the 8th to the 17th to get applic ations reviewed and things like that and then the public didn't even know until two days ago

015on who it was so to expect a lot of people to come in here and and voice different concerns they didn't have a lot of time to plan for this so I I just want to address those things and and hope you know wish you guys a good year uh let's make 2025 the year for the children and let's care about them CU there were times when you shut down the schools and made them wear masks and then tried to force it back at them you know we want to we want to give people the right platform so I appreciate you guys and thank you for the public for showing up today so thank You Enrique Ramirez good evening everyone my name is Enrique Ramirez and I'm here today as a father I'm here today

016as a Testa resident for the last 17 years and as a proud proud husband uh as a proud husband it is my pleasure to fully support Karen Ramirez Dominguez I strongly believe that she is the ideal candidate for the for the for school board she has always been dedicated to her community and the well-being of the children of chil Vista uh being by being a resident of chil Vista for almost 20 years he understands firsthand the the the the needs that this community has he years as a student were not that were not that long ago and now as a mother of three beautiful kids attending to her school district she understands uh she understands uh what's really going on in the school system on and the school board she has always been committed to

017learning both uh academically and through real world experiences she spent years preparing her preparing herself uh she obtained her degree in child development attended to relevant educational programs seek advice from educ from Community leaders and she volunteer a lot of time with local organizations I think she volunteer more than work through his life through her life I'm sorry one of the qualities that stands more that stands out most on her pass it's her passion and willingness to sacrifice her own time and even her own finances to make a positive impact in the in the community her her passion for serving the community and for serving those around her it's it I believe makes makes her an ideal candidate for this role it's someone that really cares it's someone that really understands it's someone that be

018that she has been there firsthand with the students like someone said like behind scenes and I can not express with enough word that with enough words that she really cares about this position about the children it's not a political move it's not about her name being out there it's not about what people's going to say what people's going to think it's about making a change making things right bringing those values and the parents first to this to the school system so once again it is my privilege it is my pleasure to fully support my wife Kenan Ramirez Dominguez thank you thank you Mike Jagger well good evening um thank you guys so much for all you do for our great City want to offer my recommendation as well for kin Ramirez Dominguez that was my

019best Spanish accent I hope I did her justice and I'm the the pastor of a local church where uh she attends along with her beautiful family and um as as you all are responsible for this appointment I want to make sure that you're aware of something that I know that you may not which is how kidon chooses to spend her Sunday mornings and her Wednesday evenings at our church um she's not just a faithful attender of our church and member of our church but she serves very faithfully and volunteers with her time every single week and out of all the areas that she could serve and there are many many teams that she could have chosen to be on it's our kids church that she serves so Faithfully every single uh every single week she's

020one of our most diligent most faithful volunteers and you can tell a lot about a person by how they spend their free time and kenin chooses her uh free time to be spent pouring into the next generation of school AG uh children and it's this attitude and posture of service and again it's it's service that she doesn't get any any gratification for it's it can be at times a very thankless job but it's that that posture that heart posture of servitude that she gives every single Sunday morning every single Wednesday to be back there with the kids with them loving them teaching them and it's that posture of service that makes her I think the perfect appointment so thank you so much for your time and your consideration and all you guys do for our

021great city thank you thank [Applause] you Crystal minardi hi good evening board um thank you first thank you for what you do for the children of trul Vista and I am also here in Advocate and support for my good friend Kenan Ramirez Dominguez and I am supporting her not because she's my friend um because we have many friends and some people aren't uh you know made for certain positions but I'm advocating for Karen because since the moment I've known her I've known her for about three years now um her dedication to her children her family her community and helping others was so evident from the moment I met her and that just showed me her dedication to what she puts her heart and what she believes um in and I believe that um being part

022of the school board is something that she would she is she is going to take and put her full commitment have you as you've heard everyone else say that she is committed to the children and to the betterment of their future and I she is a team player she has this way of bringing people together for one goal and making sure everyone is on top of it so that way um when goals are set they are met and they're not just um being talked about one thing I know about her is when she puts her word to something she sees it to the end and that is very um uh very nice for me to see as well as her friend in the last few years and another thing is I've seen the way she

023parents her three little children and it is a huge um it's something that I I take away from too and I don't have any schoolage children as of right now but I am expecting in a few months and just to know that someone like her would be on the board is very encouraging knowing that our children our future generation who are going to become the leaders of our city of CH Vista right she will be there and making sure that they are being advocated for their families are being heard and the CH the voices of the children are being heard so again I um I'm in support for Karen and I know she's going to make an amazing um board member along uh the rest of you and thank you again for what you do

024and putting our children first in this in this community thank you thank [Applause] you Jorge Mendes good evening um first of all thank you for your service to our community my name is jendes I am the director of the kids program at at our local church and I I serve directly with uh with gon and her husband and um I'm I'm here to to speak in favor of kin damz Dominguez a candidate for the school board I've had the privilege of working with alongside Kon for nearly two years as she served in in our kids department at here at our church um Kon is not just a volunteer um she's a leader as a team lead she Faithfully oversees and cares for usually 20 to 25 kids um every almost every Wednesday and Sunday um

025there's kids with special needs there's all different type of kids including my own kids are are in under her care um what sets Karen apart is her natural ability to S problems and lead with initiative if she if she sees something if she sees something that needs to get done she'll get it done if if she sees an issue that is something that is unsafe she'll take care of it she'll communicate with the proper channels she'll do what it takes to get things done in an orderly fashion and quickly depending on the the gravity of the issue um she handles issues whether it's addressing challenges mentoring her team because she's in charge she oversees a few people as well every time that she serves um ensures every child that is in a nurturing environment and

026my kid can speak for that I have a three and a six-year-old and and they they have both gone through her care uh and more importantly Kon really really really cares she invests her time um the well-being in she invests in the well-being of children and understands the importance of their education safety and development she's not just a team player she's a spearhead leader who inspires others to step up and make a difference she's trained a few people to take her role as a team lead we've had team leads um take on classrooms on on the leadership of the classroom because they've gone under her care in leadership along with her husband and I believe kin is is faithful she she's a hard worker she's dedicated to what she does to our community um I

027believe she will be an incredible asset to our school board and she has proven time and time again in in our department that she has the heart and Leadership skills needed to make positive impact on the lives of students in our community um so thank you again for your time and consideration I urge you to support Karen's candidacy for the school board thank you thank you Rosie Martinez good good evening president Duarte vice president Tamayo and clerk Dominguez cantes before you hear from potential new trustees to this board I want to share with you chil Vista Educator's thoughts on the qualities of individuals who we believe would make an impactful addition to the school board cve values the strong relationships that we have built not only with this District leadership but with this board I

028personally appreciate having each of you as partners in helping to address our concerns and supporting our advocacy for our students cve believes in building meaningful Partnerships and working collaboratively in order to address and meet the needs of our students it is out of this collaborative relationship that we have begun to put in place supports for staff students and families by working with the district to uplift the voices of all educational Partners around instruction curriculum academic and social emotional supports as well as our work around Community Schools as you consider the candidates tonight we ask that you can consider who shares our values and advocating for students who understands that those strong relationships are what help move the work forward ra rather than erroneously seeing teachers as a special interest group who understands that our working

029conditions are our students learning conditions who will unite us rather than divide us as a strong supporter of Community Schools cve sees parents as valuable partners and want to create more opportunities to strengthen that partnership in benefits of our students we cannot give a platform to those who dis discredit or undermine the work of our Educators since that has a detrimental impact on our kids we also hope that as you hear from candidates who have previously run unsuccessfully for a seat on this board you prioritize advocacy for the district and not political aspirations the voters have spoken we hope that you consider our perspective and select board members that will add to the work that we've already started not take away from it thank you for listening and for your thoughtfulness in this most important

030decision thank you thank you Tom peris chica good evening Dr Reyes board and cabinet cve was copied in an email that was sent to cabinet members and the board we went we want to share share it openly to Echo the concerns of a teacher in our district we will share their concerns but in order to respect privacy not share their name Dear Miss ugar I hope this message finds you well I am writing to you as a parent a teacher and a deeply invested member of farari Al Jeffers Elementary School community and I'm compelled to share my concerns about Nal Craven's candidacy for the seat on the chist elementary school board over the past years I observed actions by Miss Cravens that have deeply that have been deeply troubling particularly in how they have impacted

031teachers and the essential collaboration required between families and Educators she has publicly rallied parents to speak and act negatively toward teachers other staff members and parents creating unnecessary Division and hostility additionally she has established social media platforms that actively SE mistrust and drive a wedge between parents and teachers fostered an environment of drama and Discord these actions not only undermine the critical partnership between teachers and parents but also hinder the positive collaborative atmosphere that our students deserve a cvesd board member should only embody a commitment to supporting teachers and promoting Unity within the school Community unfortunately Miss Craven's track record suggest she does not share these values making her an unsuitable candidate for the position I urge you to carefully consider the long-term consequences of her leadership that her leadership could have on our district

032electing individuals who do not respect and value teachers undermines the foundation of our schools and the quality of education for our children thank you for your time and to consider my perspective I'm confident that together we can ensure that cvsd remains a place where collaboration respect and a shared commitment to students success Thrive a concerned teacher thank you thank you there are no more speakers we have moved into the interview candidates for provisional appointments to the board um I want to reiterate that the process um was detailed in last board meeting in December and any questions or concerns can be directed after the meeting to the board Clerk and um we will respond I'm uh we will be calling our candidate candidates who have drawn numbers in uh random order and we can uh we

033will go over the process um the same way with each candidate questions will be asked um by the board members in the same manner for each candidate we will not ask follow-up questions and um you'll hear how that is going to proceed once we have the first candidate here um Armando faras I I have it okay for thank you for being here Mr FAS I'm going to describe the process to you and then we will start um you'll have your three minute introduction followed by one question from each of the board members in which you will have 3 minutes for each response and I won't be rude it's just cutting you off if you go over the three minutes um you will then have the opportunity to present a one minute closing statement are you

034ready I am okay what do you want us to know about you as it relates to the position you're applying for first of all good morning good morning good evening uh president nugar trustees cabinet staff and Community it is my honor to be here before you uh seeking the opportunity to sit at the Das the way I did a few years back do you mind repeating the question again please just for context yes what do you want us to know about you as it relates to the position you are applying for thank you I want you to know that I'm deeply committed to the success of our students the well-being of our staff and the strength of our community with nearly 25 years in education I worked in a variety of roles from school custodian

035to teacher to school principal to Director of Human Resources to assistant superintendent of human resources and now presently assistant superintendent of business I believe that I bring a wealth of experience from all these positions which has given me a unique comprehensive understanding of the challenges we face as a district but also the opportunities we have to make meaningful impact not only on our students but on our staff and these amazing communities including families of course I've had the privilege of working in Partnerships with multiple businesses and organizations to directly and positively benefit every single one of our students and families whether it was getting in touch with freedom America America to provide food assistance or working with law firms to provide advice to our needy uh families when it comes to lawyers to safety to

036securing over $200,000 in um annual annual yearly contributions from our foundation to truly support academic programs these experiences have truly taught me how to build strong lasting relationships that result should intangible support for our schools but beyond that I am someone who values collaboration and teamwork I truly want to work alongside this board the superintendent and the entire Community to address the needs of every single one of our kids I believe that I'm the only member or candidate in the 91911 uh zipa Community I am and I understand and I know how important Equity is for you and making sure that every community has a voice at the table when it comes to making decisions I want to close by stating that some of you might know that I come from deep and generational poverty

037I used to sell ice creams in Mexico then I came over here I was a school custodian for 17 years I became a professional and now I'm here before you advocating for this opportunity why because I believe that the same opportunity best upon me thank you absolutely thank you truste Dominguez cantes my question excuse me my question is if appointed what is on your agenda to do in the first 30 days thank you trusty servantes the first item in the agenda there are multiple items in my uh wishful thinking because I don't have an agenda I come here to meet with the superintendent first and foremost to ensure that I understand what are the successes of the district and at the same time what are the needs although Chulavista Elementary School District is has been

038a beacon of life for many years for many other school districts to emulate there's still work to do especially when it comes to students with special needs that has we have been able to move the needle a little but there's still a lot of needs in that regard second item in my wishful thinking is I understand that there is a deficit of about $50 million when it comes to the 2425 school year it is so important to ensure the fiscal stability of our district if we want to keep maintaining the programs that we have the Staffing ratios that we need and also ensuring that we provide the conditions for every single one of our students third and this is not in order by the way ensuring the safety of our students making sure that every

039single one of our teachers and classified staff have the training on how they can support our kids every single day many times we talk and we say oh it's only 20 24 kids per teaching in the lower grades possibly 27 in the the upper Grace 29 but it's the teacher who knows what's going on in those classrooms it is unfortunate that lately we've have a a an increase in social emotional needs when it comes to our students I know that there is anou I was able to read the minutes in the agenda I believe it was November 13th there is an mou but at that point in time there has not there had not been scheduled meetings or professional development for our teachers I will push for that and if that is already in place

040I will look into how I can support that again not only meeting with the superintendent but making sure that I collaborate through the power of the collective to ensure the the my fellow board members and I were align as to what are the needs of the school district it is well known that as a single board member I have no Authority and no power and I'm good with that because I believe in collaboration I believe in working together together to ensure that the superintendent is supported and that every staff member and Community is as well thank you thank you trust Tayo what are what are your thoughts on providing social emotional support for students and how should it be provided do you remember repeating that question please sure thank you what are your thoughts on

041providing social emotional support for students and how should it be provided I just mentioned that um from the outside even when I used to be a site principle I knew some of the needs of my um school when it comes to students when it comes to Social and emotional supports but the ones in the trenches are the teachers the ones in the Tren the ones who communicate to leadership in chista educators are our teachers I believe we have the vice president here and the president hi Miss Martinez and uh uh I really believe in the part of collaboration just the way I said it making sure that those conduit conduits of communication are in place those um meetings that need to take place happen but not only that but that we take action it is

042my understanding again that there is anou that I'm sure was crafted between cve and cves making sure that that is in place and that we're taking action social emotional have uh needs have increased dramatically I have kids myself I have felt it and I have lived it especially in the last few months what is it that I want to do I I'm just here to collaborate to ensure that those needs are brought up to our attention and that we take action and last um in Mexico we say if our kids are hungry there's no letters or numbers that are going to go in if our kids have social emotional needs there are no letters or numbers that are going to go in until we address those needs also surveying the parents and looking at requests

043from them to ensure that we're not only serving our students but our families as well thank you thank you teachers use adopted curriculum and textbooks for their lessons sometimes they also bring their own materials to supplement instruction how much flexibility do you feel teachers should have in adapting the lesson plan using their own materials thank you for that question Madam president I used to be a teacher for about 11 years and I had the flexibility to beef up we used to call it our curriculum depending on the great level that I had and the great level that I uh had as a team in today this time I truly believe that um as board members we have policies um we have administrative regulations that in a way oversee that I think that is our job

044as a body to meet again with our teachers leadership to ensure that we are on the same page that we are allowing a multi-diverse curriculum that really represents the students and community that we serve thank thank you thank you you have 1 minute for a closing statement she just give us it's going so fast okay MH I just stated a couple things about who I am and why I'm here and why again I'm here because of the power and promise of public education and I'm here because teachers believed in me when a lot of people didn't I'm currently doing my PhD at the wonderful University of of of San Diego that is also a reflection of who who were my teachers and the power and promise of public education I want to work with you

045to ensure that to together we provide those conditions for every single one of our kids general education special education diverse lgbtqia every single one of them deserve the opportunity and have the ride to be the best self that they can be that's why I'm here thank you thank you next is Noel Cravens nice see you all thank you right for good evening thank you for being here miss Cravens um I'm going to describe the process to you and then we'll start um you'll have your three minute introduction followed by one question from each of the board members in which you will have three minutes for each response and it's not me being rude when I cut you off it's about consistency um and then you will have the opportunity to present a one minute closing

046statement are you ready okay um what do you want us to know about you as it relates to the position you are applying for good evening I would like to begin by thank you all thanking you all for considering my application to serve on the board my name is Noel Craven I am a proud mom of two daughters enrolled in the Chula Vista Elementary School District I've also been a registered nurse for over 20 years I'm seeking an appointment to advocate for the needs of our students and our educators and to rebuild and strengthen the relationship within the district and parent Community as a school volunteer I've had the privilege of serving on our schools School site Council and PTA I'm currently in my second term as the PTA president working with 13 amazing executive

047board members and parents I was also recently appointed as a cvsd representative for the community advisory committee or CAC CAC is a group of parents teachers and school districts that support students with special needs for everyone else I'm sure you guys know um I have been attending cvsd board meetings to help keep me updated and informed on the district's policies budget curriculum personnel and much more these roles and experiences have allowed me to bring to build trusting relationships with teachers parents and community members not just in my school Community but other communities within our District giving me a deeper understanding of our District's current challenges and strengths speaking of strengths our testing scores for English Learners has been improving over the years uh free Afterschool programs such as lead Hub learn andrich aspired develop which

048my daughters participate are available to all students giving them an opportunity to try to new to try new skills and hobbies and and also the initiative of rigorous learning due to the impact of the covid-19 pandemic challenges the challenges that the district is currently having are accountability transparency and collaboration with teachers and parents as a parent with no ties to any school district as an employee nor have any political aspirations my main focus is ensuring our district provides highquality education to all students training for all Educators while also ensuring their well-being I believe my fresh perspective combined with my leadership experience passion to Advocate and relationships I've built with within the school Community I can help Drive positive changes and improve transparency trust and collaboration within our school Community thank you thank you truste Dominguez

049cantes good evening my question if appointed what is on your agenda to do in the first 30 days um okay I would like to as I mentioned earlier I would like to aim to rebuild the trust within the school district within the school district and parent Community by Focus focusing on transparency open communication and inclusive collaboration um this would include welcoming and promoting and increasing parent engagement and Community engagement um improve improve teacher and staff morale and improve student outcomes addressing the unique needs of each school like e east and west side of Trula Vista by promoting Equity thank you truste Tam Mayo thank you what are your thoughts on providing social emotional support for students and how should it be provided socio emotional um I do it it's something that's really important for students

050and it starts with the school if the students are in a learning and nurturing environment they will strive and um by ensuring that the students Thrive uh we need to ensure that they do feel comfortable they have a safe envir when they go to school it they're in a safe environment and um and yeah that's all thank you thank you teachers use adopted curriculum and textbooks for their lessons sometimes they also bring their own materials to supplement instruction how much flexibility do you feel teachers should have in adapting the lesson plan using their own materials as a parent I feel like the teachers are I trust the teachers they're educated they are going to training and I feel like they should be flexible to bring any material to school that that they believe will help

051with um with educating our students but as long as it stays the mission of our school district thank you you now have the opportunity for a one minute closing statement okay I was not prepared for a closing statement but just wanted to let everyone know I am I'm just a mom a parent a friend a Community member that just wants all our students to thrive and whether they're from East Chula Vista or west west CH Chula Vista that's that's why I'm here thank you thank you then our next candidate is Jessica tolston for for thank you for being here miss tolston I'm going to describe the process to you and then we'll start okay you'll have a three minute introduction followed by one question from each of the board members in which you'll have three

052minutes for each response and I'm not being rude if I cut you off it's just the 3 minute Mark has been reached um you will then have the opportunity to present a one minute closing statement are you ready okay what do you want us to know about you as it relates to the position you are applying for okay good evening trusty ug trusty Tamayo trusty Dominguez serantes Dr Rees when I learned about the board opening I reflected on the wonderful experiences my son has had and how I could contribute to ensuring other families have the same opportunities my journey as a mother has taught me that while we may have a set plan for our futures life may take unexpected turns as did ours schools play a critical role in shaping those outcomes and I

053am committed to helping every child succeed regardless of their circumstances when my son first joined the district in transitional kindergarten my husband was diagnosed with terminal cancer he passed away shortly after my son finished TK my husband was a distinguished 22-year Marine Corps veteran his illness was certified as service related after having serving having served in the first gol War this was an incredibly challenging time for our family but the support we received from the staff was extraordinary the school staff rallied around us providing unwavering kindness and care that continues to this day their actions show what it means to truly serve and support students and their families I am deeply grateful for their compassion and for the sense of community they cultivated during such a difficult time since we joined the school I have

054been actively involved d as a PTA member and I truly value the many opportunities a District offers students and families through events activities and programs these initiatives demonstrate the commitment to providing a positive and inclusive environment for all professionally I am a federal Civil Service employee under the Department of Homeland Security I hold a master's degree in organizational leadership I am bilingual and bicultural and I am also a veteran of the United States Coast Guard over the course of my career I have held various leadership positions with US Customs and Border Protection and currently with ghs headquarters in a law enforcement support capacity my entire career has equipped me with extensive leadership and problem solving experience as a veteran and the spouse of a marine I understand the unique challenges military families face and I

055know that the district serves as a significant military and law enforcement Community I am passionate about advocating for these families while ensuring that every student regardless of background has access to the resources they need to thrive as my son has a child's success in their education should not depend on luck but on a system designed to uplift every student and accommodate their unique needs if given the honor of serving as a board member I will fully be committed to working with you to ensure our students receive the highest quality education that our teacher and that our teachers have all the support and resources they need and also I will encourage transparency and strong Partnerships with parents as I firmly believe that parents in schools must work as partners in education and should always be informed

056of their child's progress and experiences I'm ready and eager to continue to the continued success of the Chul Vista Elementary School District again thank you for this opportunity thank you truste Dominguez cantes good evening my question if appointed what is on your agenda to do in the first 30 days um in the first 30 days my agenda would be to start communicating to start maybe even introducing myself cuz I'm sure the schools are going to want to learn who I am and who we are I believe in communication um I want to have open communication with all of the schools I want them to be able to access to have access to me to us um for them to be comfortable I want to be able to advocate for staff parents students teachers um so

057I do want them to just be comfortable introduce myself and start I'm eager to start working and to start learning what it entails the full entailment of being a board member thank you trusty Mayo you thank you what are your thoughts on providing social emotional supports for students and how should it be provided um that is something we have relied on extensively obviously with my introduction and what we have been through my son has taken full advantage my son and myself have taken full advantage with with what the district has offered um I believe that every student should have access to any need that they have um any social or and emotional support that they need my son has been in uh the school has been fantastic and offering uh self-regulation he's taken self-regulation groups

058uh emotional support groups any any anything that he has been offered and that is available I strongly have encouraged that he is involved in that and I would want that other students I would hope that other students have that same access because it's been instrumental for his emotional well-being um I also I've learned that um we just recently the district had um what is it it starts at home I think this week and I I thought that was very important I'm too bad I couldn't join because I saw I saw it on Instagram and I I thought it was great um because I do believe that it starts at home um and it's supplemented at home too so with that said I think all those programs should be accessible to every student that needs it

059or that requests it in the district however I do believe that parents should always be informed of of those um of that opportunity and they should always be informed of what the materials are going to be provided what is going to be taught and shown um in those special groups and I think because I again I believe that parents and teachers should always work together for the wellbeing of the students thank you teachers use adopted curriculum and textbooks for their lessons sometimes they also bring in their own materials to supplement instruction how much flexibility do you feel teachers should have in adapting the lesson planned using their own materials um that's funny I have I have often wondered about that to be honest with you because my son is in first grade in dual immersion

060for example and I do believe that they should be able to supplement with their own materials and they should bring in um anything that they feel would assist or would supplement what the District offers um my son in dual immersion I've always wondered I there's a few books that I've been interested in that I used when I was younger and a lot of the Latin American communities use themselves um it's called ELO and there's another one that's called like let's play reading and they offer great uh phonic sheets and materials you know when the kids are learning the vows that um or MIM mimu you know all of those things that I have wondered if I donated it to the teachers would they be able to even use it um so I do think that

061they should be allowed flexibility if they find something that would be great to supplement what the district already offers but I do feel that those worksheets or additional materials should always be vetted and approved by the district or at least by the school by the principles before um before they're presented to the students thank you um you have the opportunity now to have a one minute closing statement okay you start getting less nervous as as you go um well again thank you for the opportunity um of you know based on my background I think that I can offer the the board a fresh set of eyes um I'm newer to the district my son is only in first grade we've only been involved two and a half years um but I think that my excuse

062me my my government experience my leadership experience can bring a fresh set of eyes to the table um my security experience I want children to feel secure physically emotionally um so in closing again thank you for the opportunity and if if appointed I am ready to get started and hit the ground running thank you so much thank [Applause] you uh next we have Fernando Parra thank you for being here Mr par I'm going to describe the process to you and then we'll start okay you will have your three minute introduction followed by one question from each of the board members for which you will have three minutes for each response and I'm not being rude if I cut you off it just means that the time has elapsed that is completely fine you will um

063then have the opportunity to present a one minute closing statement are you ready okay okay here we go what do you want us to know about you as it relates to the position you are applying for well a little bit about me I suppose I was born in Mexico at the age of 15 years old uh I'm sorry I was born in Mexico and at the age of 15 years old my parents brought me to the United States um it was very hard adjusting to my new life since I didn't speak the language and I didn't know anyone however with the incredible help and um perseverance for incredible health for my teachers I I persevered sorry I'm not a public speaker and I haven't actually interviewed in over maybe 16 years I persevered and and

064successful and successfully ex um uh I persevered and success and had a successful experience that helped me become the man that I I'm today now I have l in Chula Vista for over the past 40 years I love this community I think there's no better city than Chula Vista to be honest with you I'm also a proud father of two wonderful daughters that went through this school district and now they're in high school and thriving now professionally I have spent the last 18 years as facilities and and uh project manager for profit and nonprofit organizations um my expertise lies in construction um projects Capital Renovations budget management an an 8 standards now I believe this expertise aligned with the board with the board member uh uh work especially in budget control and construction management I

065know that the board plans to build more schools and teaching housing and that it really excites me uh since is one of my passions I'm e to bring this expertise and support these initiatives now as a community member giving back is very important to me whether by working with Jewish familyes service doing community service helping homeless or those that need any support I really enjoy what I do and it's very important for me to make a difference however thank you thank you oh okay truste Dominguez cantes good evening if a pointed what is on your agenda to do in the first 30 days well as I mentioned before in these courts I want to make sure that I uh bring my expertise uh in construction and budget I want to make sure that the district

066uses these resources for for the benefit of our students um I also want to make also want to make sure that I get to know every one of you and support you in any possible way that I can uh now that you know my expertise I think that we might be able to share information and I'm here to help thank you truste Mayo thank you what are your thoughts on providing social emotional support for students and how should it be provided well uh this question I think touches my heart um as mentioned before I have two daughters that at an early at an early age they went through a very traumatic uh situation when I um my gosh when I regain custody of them I found out that providing them with just a home was

067not enough they supported they they needed I'm sorry they needed that uh emotional support to heal and being as a single father with no one no family to rely on I was pretty lost without knowing uh where to start or how to help my children fortunately their school stepped in and it was a blessing their school stepped in and they became our Lifeline um um now my story might actually sound very personal to you guys but I know there's many families out there that are struggling with maybe trauma uh life-changing events that just like me they probably feel lost and without knowing where to start or where to go for counseling or help um this is actually a subject that is very important to me and I would like to make sure that if I

068become a board member uh I can address that subject and be able to get parents involved more into these issues with their children um that's it thank you teachers use adopted curriculum and textbooks for their lessons sometimes they also bring their own materials to supplement instruction how much flexibility do you feel teachers should have in adapting the lesson plan using their own materials H well I know for the fact that this happens all the time with teachers and I think it's okay to give them some flexibility when it comes to bringing their own I don't know tamplates uh uh or maybe use maybe using some Internet Resources but at the same time I think we should be careful for example uh in a subject like math we know that math has its own language it's

069its own language and regardless of how you put the numbers and depending on the equation the result will always be the same right so there's no issues in actually bringing or outs our resources to teach this class now for a subject like history for example then that's a subject that needs uh for the future to be more careful way history is written by many different people in different times many countries and depending on the affiliation or belief of these uh people that wrote these books the teacher without knowing might be indoctrinating or bringing information that is not aligned with uh the school district's protocols so in a nutshell I think it's fine to give them some flexibility but at the same time I think that they should be careful into what they bring onto the

070classroom to enhance their classes because again and there's many different subjects that are of very delicate uh um conversation and I don't think we need to take the chance to touch topics like politics or religion and and indoctrinate uh our students I don't know if this is something that the board monitors so thank you you now have the opportunity to to provide us with a one minute closing statement well as you can see I get very nervous when I when I have people in front of me so I'm sorry for that but I want to thank everyone right here for the opportunity to be here and I want to make sure that you know that if I'm given the honor and the opportunity to sit by your side I will work side by side with

071with you uh into making sure that our children get the best uh academic support and emotional support which I think it's very needed in every single School uh at not only the Chula Vista but pretty much everywhere so my support for you and with you will always be available thank you our next candidate is Victor Zavala thank you for being here Mr Zavala I'm going to describe the process to you and then we'll start you will have your three minute introduction followed by one question from each of the board members in which you will have three minutes for each response and if I cut you off I'm not being rude I'm just being consistent and holding to the time you will then have the opportunity to present a one minute closing statement are you ready

072I'm ready what do you want us to know about you as it relates to this position you are applying for well good evening first first and foremost and and um um trustees superintendent um I want to start by um thanking you for giving me this opportunity uh it's a truly exciting opportunity uh for me as I understand the enormous responsibility it is to um be a um a board member um I grew up in the city of chista within the community and my I met my wife my family and um married my wife my kids uh went to this um um district and they excuse me I'm I'm shoking up a little bit um they um I have a profound positive influence um uh that this community created for me um shaping my values and

073opportunities that I hold here um throughout my children's educational journey I was involved as a parent actively um participating under school events and many other activities um I have experienced uh firsthand how much schools teachers can en reach um a child's life um and contribute to a strong and positive uh Community professionally um I bring a a strong background in commercial sales and management um these experiences um have shaped my ability to U make thoughtful balanced decisions and manage um resources um effectively um my experiences uh in within my background uh it's with budgets management and and this um will allow me to contribute um discussions um about financial um sustainability this will help me um um help the and strongly um become um a part of the team of the board um as a

074board member um I want to prioritize initiatives that directly uh benefit student learning um to ensure every child in our district has um an opportunity to reach uh full potential I'm passionate about serving our our community um so I'm I'm truly um grateful and I truly hope that you allow me the privilege of being a part of your team um I promise to um work tirelessly uh uphold the values of chilo Elementary School District um and make decisions that not only make you our district proud and finding common ground fresh innovative ideas thank you trust Dominguez cantes good evening if appointed what is on your agenda to do in the first 30 days um great question thank you um first and foremost to um get involved as much as possible with the team uh get

075acclimated um um take um not full initiative but follow your guidelines and collaborate um find what the issues are uh engage them fully and um try and to come out with solutions that um work for um not only the students the teachers but the parents of this community thank you CH Mayo thank you what are your thoughts on providing social emotional support for students and how should it be provided um that's a great question thank you um as a parent being involved uh with uh throughout my life uh with my k my children's uh life in schools um emotional support um gives you um great opportunity to get involved with um Educators and help them in any way possible because their influences on our kids the Educators um shape the life of our kids as

076they grow up um our kids have tremendous um ability to um listen to um other people other than the parents at home the ability to Educators uh that can provide ideas um values that can make them evolve themselves and become successful in life um it's it's it's it's part of um what I feel that would be a great emotional support um as as he shapes the lives of all the children's in our community thank you teachers use adopted curriculum and textbooks for their lessons sometimes they also bring their own materials to supplement instruction how much flexibility do you feel teachers should have in adopting the lesson plan using their own materials great question um Educators nowadays have um a tough task of engaging kids with um a strict guideline of of specific um um uh

077elements that um the district provides um as long as and I feel that as long as um the structure that is applied in the curriculum is um sh pertinent uh age appropriate I believe believe that it could be implemented at any level um I I believe the the minds of young kids are very impactful with information outside the curriculum that can affect U the way they learn um I believe um that every kid should have a a different approach every educator should have a different approach because no one mind is the same and if you um use curriculum outside of the guidelines that it is not appropriate um not only you going to have issues with the parents but may affect the growth and the thinking of the young mind thank you you now have

078the opportunity to provide us with a one minute closing St statement thank you um I I I truly truly hope that um you um I I know you have a tough task and and you have very um appropriate candidates but it would be a privilege for me to um be a part of your team um I I I do again promise to work TIR lessly um amongst you and with you uh to provide not only uh the best um Solutions the best ideas and um finding a common ground on on on innovative ideas for the entire uh District um most importantly um the uh beneficial um be um so that students can be proud of our our district and and and and um all collaboration and and and be proud make this community very proud

079thank you thank you thank you our um final candidate is Karen Ramirez Dominguez thank you for being here Mrs Ramirez Dominguez um I'm going to go over the process and then uh we will start okay thank you you will have your 3 minute introduction followed by one question from each of the board members in which you will have three minutes for each response and if I cut you off it's not being rude it's about the time elapsing um and then you will have a one uh minute the opportunity to present a one minute closing statement are you ready yes okay what do you want us to know about you as it relates to the position you are applying for good afternoon ladies and Gentlemen of the board superintendent and everybody else here I my name

080is Karen Ramirez Dominguez as we have said before and what I want the board to know about me is that I am the fruit of Felipe and marz now in English um my parents they've taught me that real success is when we serve God and we can serve others I am the fruit of my husband enri Ramirez whose support has empowered me and his love has actually made me stand here before you I am the fruit of Po L Nazarene where I received my studies a place where I was thought that servant leadership is possible a place where we I learned that in order to serve children we must first serve the parents I am the fruit of the local church and local community organizations where I've been able to serve for the past 15

081years I've been able to lead I've been able to guide I've been able to be part of the community help them Thrive I am a fruit also of community organizations like stepping higher a company that has given me the opportunity to educate families and countless community members about the importance of mental health spiritual wellness and behavioral issues uh information that we've shared with the community just like how important it is to add mental health and spiritual Wellness together and when you do that 98% of the people that actually do this receive Wellness receive healing how important it is to give resources to communities that have for many years now even heard of these resources existing I am a fruit most importantly of my motherhood it is this stage that has actually lit a fire in

082my heart to be able to stand here to be able to come and and not only want to fight for my children but for every child in chil Vista it is my goal for them to thrive and now I know that all all the um experiences I had sum up to the point that fruit's purpose is to bring more fruit and that's who I am I'm here for this community to to bring out the fruit in the students in the parents and in that Community it is my role to be a a stepping stone for the next generation and not a stumbling one it is my role to be and leave a legacy of of um thank you thank you truste Dominguez cantes good evening good evening if appointed what is on your agenda to

083do in the first 30 days one of the things I want to establish uh first will be open communication with parents I want parents to know that they can come up to me and they can um share what is troubling them I feel that when we strengthen that relationship with the parents our Community will have more um buyin into it um and I want to do that that is one of the first things I would do thank you you're welcome trusty Tamayo thank you what are your thoughts on providing social emotional support for students and how should it be provided per right into what I wanted to say perfect thank you so much I believe that social emotional support is one of the building blocks of children and actually not only for students I want

084us to be able to share that with parents as well because again when we educate the parent when we empower the parent the children actually Thrive thank you teachers use adopted curriculum and textbooks for their lessons sometimes they also bring their own materials to supplement instruction how much flexibility do you feel teachers should have in adapting the lesson plan using their own materials I think and it's important for the teacher to have um the ability to bring more material um as long as we're going for the same goal what we want to build is for us to have flexibility but again our goal is to make sure that our children are learning and thriving um so I am willing and I'm thinking of being flexible to the material as long as we are reaching the

085goal that we want to reach which is for the students to raise you know scores for them to read better for them to learn better and that is my answer thank you thank you you now have the opportunity to present a one minute closing statement I want to thank you all for being here today I want to thank my community behind me for for stepping up and speaking on my behalf I know that the community is supporting me I know that I have the favor um and it is all thanks to God and I know that it is him who has brought me to this place and that the sum of all my experiences have qualified me to be the best trustee I can be I just want to thank you all for the opportunity

086and also I just want to speak a little bit more um about leg Legacy and the Legacy I want to leave as a as a board member I want to make sure that the children of the Next Generation know that they are that they will that they will have the building blocks to live to their fullest potential and that is the Legacy I want to leave in chil Vista that is why I'm here and what I've served so many years thank you all right that concludes the interview portion of the process the board will now um work together um in conjunction with the written materials and uh the uh information that was presented tonight and um then we will present motions um regard uh that recommend any uh particular candidate so tring sedantes if you

087would like to present any comments or have any questions for us I think I'm going to pause I need to process some of this information so I'll allow you guys to go ahead are you pausing as well I could pause but [Laughter] why um now first of all I want to thank every single candidate that um made it to the final round um obviously it it it is difficult to be in that uh Podium I have stood there a couple times and it it's a struggle so I I thank you all uh for your commitment to to this uh process to wanting to share your strengths with all the students in ch Vista so I want to thank um I feel thankful that uh we got a good pool of of candidates here um having

088said that I think that it's important for um the district to look or for the board uh to look at the Mission Vision and values that the board has adopted and has hold held um as our our Beacon of light for the board as we make decisions um this is not an easy task to select or appoint and file board members uh to the seat um or to the two seats I think there's there's an opportunity for us to to make a decision um I think that it's it's a lot of um information that we have um and through the application that was provided and through these um comments here today um I I do think that having parents and their voice of the parent Community uh it's important I think that uh it behooves

089us to to look at that um as one of our guiding factors um but that's my opinion I also want to thank everyone tonight I know that it is very nerve-wracking to um speak publicly and um it is why that when it gets to my point in the board comments that I have very few things to say so um so with that being said um I also think that um it's important to note that our decision this evening is based on not just what we heard tonight but it is based on the written the information here in the packet it's also um based on um the mission and values of the district um in alignment with that and so it's going to be very difficult to to to decide it's it's a it's a rough

090process for us now that you're you've gotten you've you've done the hard part for yourselves and now it's up to us to to make that decision um as the board president and facilitator of this meeting I often hesitate at to make the Motions um because that largely isn't my role and so um I'll be listening tonight I'll be listening to your commentary I'll I'll jump in when I need to and then um I will um I look forward to our our motions all right I paused so um I think how I'm going to share my my thoughts what I'm processing the applications that we received what was shared I'll share some of what comes to the top for each candidate and as we move forward and like trusty Taya was just saying um the mission

091the vision and the values is what I'm looking for that their ability to share it obviously to really cons put somebody into a box and give them five minutes to share who they are and write your life here it's impossible we get it but it's all we've got okay it's all we've got so with your understanding we're sharing my I think out loud most of the time so I shouldn't have a comp a very hard time doing it now you know but um please bear with us and uh do not take anything personal although it is about you you how do you differentiate that but um you know ask for your Indulgence okay so um it looking at our mission is to nurture every student's potential through the collaboration of teachers staff parents and the

092community it's on our website so the last person who spoke Miss car Ramirez Dominguez no relation whatsoever she conceptualized that very clearly I believe that that was one of the strong points when I'm looking at the mission it was something that apparently comes from just who she is as she credited everyone in her life as to who she is I can appreciate that I think most of us are that some of us just are not able to articulate that or aren't as it doesn't come as easy to just put it out there in regards to the mission in the collaboration for um Mr Savala I did feel the passion that he felt about the social and emotional support that uh that he was sharing but I just didn't get the connection to how it related

093to our schools as much does it mean he didn't try to do that I'm just sharing and thinking out loud Mr Bara was very um Vivid about how the social emotional supports received by the schools received by her students by the schools but again the uh it called out clearly the collaboration between the teacher staff parents and the community in that regard the social and emotional but we're also very uh it's very important of our purpose is not just supporting the student in the social emotional area but academics I didn't hear as much being mentioned throughout but I haven't read all my notes I'll go back and Miss tolston we appreciate your your journey a very tough journey and uh your ability to know that your your son and your child needed those additional supports

094that the schools that the teachers and our community of a school was able to provide you uh you know you shared that quite vividly and um parent you mentioned the parental engagement as as well um I would wonder with your very important job that you have everyone has an important job but one that takes you away a lot I'm wondering how much and I'm just sharing because I don't know we haven't sat on a one-on-one how much of how available you would be for sometimes our meetings start at 2:30 3:00 we're at midnight sometimes we're here not too many of you out there but we're here we've been here till 1:00 and they don't happen as often but more than likely we're here by 3:30 4:00 and we hardly ever leave by 10:00 in the

095evening and being out with the community um is is not as as uh easy task because we only have one employee and that's Mr Dr Rey is excuse me and uh it it can be uh splitting of hairs on how much we reach out to parents and and staff where it it it's just a fine line but I understand I'm there um Miss Cravens your dedication to your school your volunteerism PTA and uh the different organizations they belong the CAC I just don't uh believe you were able to articulate as well what you wanted to to share the connectivity of the mission the um and we haven't even gotten to the vision and the values and I I believe you short changed yourself quite a bit by not taking advantage of all the time you

096had on the clock there but um bringing a fresh perspective is great and there's always a balance what we hear from our parents what we hear from the staff and what we hear from the supports that our our cabinet is providing somewhere in the middle is the facts and because we are human we're not robots you know our our feelings sometimes and our emotions take us in a certain direction and somewhere in the middle we have to find the facts and that's Dr rus' responsibility get the facts so that we can address the issues but um and then excuse me Mr FAS I had to write smaller as you spoke because it just you have a very elaborate application your experience uh right out the gate you touched on the students staff and community that

097was the first things that came out of of of your mouth you understand the role of uh of a board member and I could probably learned a few things from you and the rest of my colleagues here you've been a board member and uh your understanding of the collaboration with the teachers staff parents and the community that resonated throughout almost everything you said so um I'm just at the Mission Part I don't know if the rest of my colleagues would like to speak to anything else that the mission so I'll talk about values I think that that is one of the key components um that this board relies on when making decisions because every decision we make impacts thousands of students thousands of Staff members so having similar values while we might not agree on

098and everything and we often don't because we have similar value systems we're able to come to agreements that I may not like but I'm able to support and that's important when looking at who sits in this Das often we we share different thinking different perspectives that continue to to improve on past mistakes that we have done um and opportunities moving forward I think every single one of you showed that there's a potential to sit in this uh seat today obviously um some of you have a little bit uh more understanding because uh you've been either on this role role prior or you're um currently involved in a PTA or a commun um a committee at the district level but I do think and I do uh also share that we need to grow beyond that

099and include more of a parent voice on the seat or one of the seats so I think instead um instead of going to each one I think a generic value statement I'll leave it at that and I'll speak to the role of representation as a board member um we're going to have to obviously we everyone presented everyone is capable of being a board member and um I I see the alignment in in the mission the mission statement um that being said with seven people we're going to have to narrow this down and when it comes to the me the role of representation part of that is listening to the constituents part of that is listening as a board member throughout the entire time that you've been on the DI and there are a number of

100things that I've experienced in the last four years that I've listened and take taken to heart um repeatedly especally esally two years ago during the election it was often said about having political aspirations and being political and representing means listening to the constituents and representing their interests and the main thing that keeps coming up over and over is that there's no political ties we have two candidates and and unfortunately um this is this is my my representation as a board member listening to constituents is the ask was that there was no political connection we have candidates before us tonight who ran in previous elections and that is a political connection when we talk about listening to the voice of the constituents and running there was they were not successful in those elections and I think

101that if we screened anything at all like at any point in this process and held to that then it's only fair as representing constituents that we have to take that into account and that is something that I am taking very seriously with regard to listening to constituents because there is the opportunity to run there is the opportunity to be a candidate in a political race and some people have taken that and and they've they've done that and they have that experience um there's also the aspect in representing our labor partners and who are also our constituents many of them in regard to hearing their experiences with collaboration and meeting with um certain groups right so if we are to get this down to a we have to all three of us be in consensus and

102have to all agree um I'm making it clear to you that those with political ties who have run in races will not be considered by me here we go let's go yes that here we go that's okay and that's okay yes that was one of our or it was the overall um concern and uh some of the applicants are not here several of them called me and I had to immediately cut them off and said quote I have it memorized and I have people calling me to give a good word for someone my quote uh is and was I do not encourage anyone to contact me call me if it is about the appointment once the appointment process is done I'd be more than happy to sit down and speak with them we could chat

103now understanding that I probably I'm going to venture to guess and um it's just a guess but I not a gambling person but I bet you I'd win I bet you everyone here has either an r or a d after their name if they are a voter registrated so are they political no that's just how they tend to vote some people have an RD after the name and cross party lines and that's just fine because when uh Mr Tomo just said and you Tristy uhar the values is what's important what do we care about the overall overall well-being of our children the students and that can only happen if we have that strong partnership between our staff our classified and not certificated and our parents Community it's the only way that we partner to help

104those students be successful now the fact that someone may have ran before are they political I don't know they ran but then anybody who ran for something are they political I don't know it could be could not be but I think what we should be focusing on here now after we've already vetted the politicals and we had several we had several in our batch that had called me I mean they had all these people contacting me to sway me one way or the other and I'd have to stop him even after telling them stop kind of feel like Wily Wonka stop no stop they still talk so sorry goodbye because we don't want it to be that that's why these applicants are here because they Rose to the top now my preference would have been

105a special election bottom line it would have been because the people deserve to elect their person they deserve that I deserve that we all deserve that but in light of I listened to some of the other moving pieces which are $15 million that we're going to have to shave off somewhere do we have the money for that Dr re I believe he said it was about $3 million to to um run a special election trusty domingus sanes I do want to remind you that the conversation is between us and and not the not the not the audience or the or the or the people and but you were speaking to them so I did the same no and I was just I was let I was letting I was speaking directly to you all um

106that and saying that I would not consider that but but on that note I would move based on that last mission statement that we spoke about nurturing every that's the mission that's the overall the mission is to nurture every student's potential through the collaboration of teachers staff parents and the community I would move to appoint Karen Ramirez Dominguez to what seat to the F uh seat five is that the first one on our agenda the first seat five seat five second because yes thank you okay uh moved by truste Dominguez serantes seconded by uh truste Tayo those in favor I those opposed nay motion does not carry so does that mean now we go to special election right no we have six other candidates five five sorry no we have six why does it have

107to be the ones you want I don't have anyone I don't know anyone I don't it's we have five other candidates to tell tell us why you don't want Karen Dominguez I I I express to you my concern if one of the filters is that they are not political when you run by definition you are political and filtering by whether or not um why I don't the question whether or not we're going to run in the future um that that to me and I'm saying no one's gone I mean the people who contacted me I haven't responded to I didn't answer the phone um but I'm talking about the last four years that I've been on this board and the contentiousness in having candidates who the people did not pick who didn't were not successful

108in the races who come back and I as a representative and listening to those to those previous interactions I will not be supporting any candidates who have run in political races that was speaking to you and giving the rationale so we often well often there's times that we do not agree right um but that doesn't mean that we need to close the door right so I I think that there there's there's value on all the candidates um you spoke of parents I did I did speak about parents um I move that we are point to seat five Victor Savala you're not going to second no so so subcommittee you had no you had no qualms with putting through any of the seven candidates um and you were fine with all seven and yet you could

109you give us a rationale for not seconding that yes the presentation okay so motion dies no second do you want to do another second another motion okay I'll do another motion is that how you wanted to go trusty up between us okay then I would motion to appoint and seat I guess we're still stay at seat five or do we try to change our look and go to one okay F St all right okay so then I would motion to appoint Mr Armando faras going to Second it you're going to second second I'll second it motion by truste Dominguez Sant seconded by truste too all those in favor I those opposed nay motion doesn't carry all right I'll motion to Appo to seat five Noel Cravens I'm going to wait for the president to share

110her opinion I think there has to be a a second okay then I abstain motion's going to die okay you want to do another motion I motion to appoint in seat five Karen ramz Dominguez can a motion be brought forth that's already it would have to be a motion to reconsider and then then we need all three to reconsider now we have to have all three I'm going to share with the board here that those are my two selections and uh I'm not going to budge so we might as will move to special election and I appreciate the opinion um that we have two two candidats right and but again we have said and this is part of our values and part of the mission of of the district that we need to move with

111the understanding that yes a special election is probably the best way however you have stated and we all have full knowledge of this a special election is anywhere from $2 and5 to $3 million this it's expensive are we are we ready to consider what options or what programs are we going to take away from students for in exchange for those $3 million and I would ask you guys to consider that yourselves I mean and and and I I understand that but the there's other candidates here and by you saying that this is it or we're whole Hostage to to a special election that is not the value that we are saying that we need from people well we said that we often sometimes don't agree and this is one of those times that is going

112to be difficult to agree but the value of making sure that we put our students first has to be our guiding principle I agree so you've got my my motions and yes we passed you and I both did and um I didn't want to bring this up earlier because I felt it was uh not nice but um one of our candidates the one you just mentioned earlier our teachers union got up and spoke against the person right so miss that's not my decision that's not what I haven't I haven't made a motion I haven't that motion died I didn't speak to that um I I I'm urging you to consider um your choice in and and I was going to say it's I if I'm hearing clearly can you share with me besides that is

113there something and it's please do not take it personal uh Mr uh Armando faras has extensive background he's in business services that the equivalent of our Mr Mark here HR experience TR doming cantes it's not your job to sell to me right now I I I want to I want to point something out this is what I'm hearing we have six candidates before us and you're saying that if I don't vote for those candidates you will not be putting forward any of the other four and we will be going to a special election I have no ties to any of these candidates that is the except for Mr FAS uh he was an opponent but he also ran against another seat I was very clear the incumbent you he was the incumbent he was the

114incumbent you ran against him yes but that's not the issue the issue is and I was very clear I heard multiple times about making this political and if we are screening everyone who's political who's run who has connections to people who have run then those coming through were not I don't even know who the other candidates were that the other I don't know how many there were I just know the seven that came to us today I'm telling you that I am holding true to what I have heard in in the last four years in the last special election or special appointment and throughout the time because I've seen and I've been here and the target of the repercussions when that does not happen so I just want to make it clear that if you're

115saying that that's what you're saying that if I'm not going to be in agreement I and I don't understand because you the the committee put through seven and then remove we had one that was technicality removed that there's a problem with the other candidates I I have had the most limited or least amount of time with any of this so I just want to be clear if I don't vote the way you want and these two candidates we're not moving anyone else through or or making motions and we're going to go to a special election you you've summarized it well okay so part of the subcommittee um as you all know it was me and and and trusty uh deia cantes we spent six hours reviewing going through every single application my understanding was that

116these seven were viable candidates why are we closing the door on the rest of the candidates because the other half of the decision was based on the presentation and that's what I based my decision on so you're saying that the in other words if it would if matter then we would have just called them up based on their application but it did matter so that's why we had them come to speak so that was the other part of the the application process I don't think the other candidates did terrible or did or said something that would trigger an alarm in my head that we shouldn't appoint or they shouldn't serve I and I have stated all these candidates are capable of serving I think that it it would be a waste of taxpayer dollars if

117we go to a special election when we have viable candidates right and those two that I mention are viable they were brought forward so because someone has decided to call the if you look at your party's affiliation and your groups you'll know if these two people are active active doing political stuff yes and and as you said as and you're saying that and and in your own words in in some of our discussions in past board meetings have discussed the fact of not being political this is a nonpartisan seat then but your I am holding to your own filter and I'm not saying filter in this case but filter in the past with regard to political by definition anyone who has run in a race is a politician and is political you are now saying

118that if I don't vote for those two candidates you're holding me hostage we are going to an election without even considering the other candidates and the other candidates are not being judged by me solely on this interview tonight they're being they're being evaluated based on the values and Mission and according to the their application trustee Ugarte you had the same opportunity to review the all the applications that we do you could have sat for six hours and review well then that but I'm not basing it on the interview tonight I'm saying they're quite they're there are four other candidates four other candidates that we can motion through and we can have as our potential board members you're you're you're telling me you will not accept any of them I'm saying there are candidates on here

119that I'm willing to accept that are not in that realm that are not in the political and as you you stated because you said uh the someone spoke out they're other candidates and you put those candidates through based on their paper screening right and the other part of the decision was going to be their presentation so what part of that do we not understand okay the other part of it is the presentation okay it's there's different perspectives right so again as part of the subcommittee I think that we vetted these seven candidates and yes the other the second um there's seven candidates that were vetted six participated on this presentation um so from the seven candidates that we vetted we knew to truste cantus point that there's still the presentation part however from the presentation

120I still don't feel that any of these seven did or six did bad I think for the effort that they have done the commitment to the students that they have showed emotion at least is to serve for each one of these and with that I will motion for Jessica tolston to be appointed to seat number five since we're doing five is there a second if we second if I second she's just going to I will second it for discussion second motion by trustee Theo seconded by President ugar all those in favor I I all those opposed all those abstaining and should I explain why my exstension was as I shared earlier because of my concern of the availability but that's my concern and but I would have the same concern about faras right because he

121he is uh an assistant superintendent of ceio oh in falbrook he's he's busy um I have a niece that works for Homeland Security himself and a drop out of the Hat she can be called away that's different but my point being is why I was motioning for Mr FAS was the because we're entering an area of the the deficit the $15 million that his expert I never thought you guys had that much reservation about him and I'm still not buying the part bet because he ran before but that's my personal feeling but uh his expertise in the area of finances in the area of uh running you know being on the board of understanding processes of understanding curriculum that other I think is just becoming a like a I'm not going to budge kind of

122a thing and the I see that as like what's more behind this I'm not going to speculate any further than having made that statement but I can say the same thing I can say you're holding mine hostage it's just a matter of definition and perspective you're saying I'm not refusing to accept anyone you're refusing to except for those no I just and and here's the thing um we're making assumptions about someone's job that we don't have the ability to know just based on your experience which I appreciate your experience but because we can't answer ask follow followup questions we don't know that that's the situation with her job so you're you're making an assumption and you're using um which is valid you can do that but as far as saying why you don't want to

123support someone that was not the only reason I did share earlier also that what was presented to us and how and Mr Tomo knows from when we were in the sub our subcommittee we were reviewing as to who better articulated and connected it to our cvesd school district the mission the vision and our values and I was looking forward to having that same thing done here no not a negative on anyone else who spoke because I agree with you but I I can't compromise on who I believe was the better qualified candidate that's lying to me and that's lying to the community it it's it's it's not right we can't keep doing oh oh let me instead of the person who got an A let's give it to the person who got a b or

124that's not right it it's not a matter of right or wrong trusty theing said this no it's it's a matter of advantage and and here's here's the thing I did have the ability to go through and because of the way the board policy is right and and because of brown act I was able to go through these and I did say and I did read them and I did go through them the advantage is I did not select the seven that went through you had the advantage of selecting the seven that went through and so you chose not only that aspect I'm given the six now that are here and I'm choosing from that and I'm choosing from this and I'm choosing from my my elected official position of being a representative of the community

125and making sure that I follow the conversations that I've experienced and the board meetings for the last four plus years I've had conversations too and I am also elected and I I also have constituents yes you do yes so it's not one being over the other is I also have constituents what and if and we're not going to talk but if you were to speak at the two that uh that I'm moving forward each of them has a different letter after their last name that as I said it's a nonpartisan seat exactly and that my choices are nonpartisan by virtue of the very people I've nominated I move that we appoint Fernando par to seat five I'll second moved by trusty Tayo seconded by the uh myself trusty ugar all those in favor I I

126all those opposed nay and motion doesn't carry if you'd like to you can explain for the very same reason the ability to share the Mission Vision and values and like I said earlier this was the other part of the process and it was the presentation if there's no value to it we shouldn't have had them waste their time up theread hold on go ahead so and and I so you you're talking about presentation but then you're referring back to their application because it's a two-parter right so if that was the case then we should have just moved two or three sure we we want to do a do over we might have to well no we're going to go to special election if we can't decide that's I don't see a pathway right now to

127decide because we have now completed a motion to every single candidate that was uh here present well let me share with you what will happen because of that now I won't be on the next vetting committee right no no we don't start the process over we go to special election and then next board meeting on we need to look at cuts to what what are we going to cut to make up the the funding for the special election right and you will take responsibility for it because I have forwarded two names from this list you refuse you forwarded through the committee and now when OED me to yes I did appoint you to it and and you came through and the names are here however I had no choice in that here's here's the thing

128this is not who what when right the choice of going to special election will not sit on an individual board member it will sit on all three of us because we are not able to come to an agreement and if that's the case then so be it we will go to a special election if that's what the board is deciding but when the cuts have to be done to pay for that we all have to own them that's right it's not trusty ugar didn't choose trusty Tamayo didn't choose or Delia Santas didn't chose uh is the board did not choose and now we're uh having to cut $3 million or up to $3 million and if that's the case as often I have said it we we might not agree but as once we have

129taken a determination we all own it and if that's what the board says I don't agree with it but I will own it can you say something yes uh Dr Rees has a recommendation if hello if I would like to recommend before um you know I know that that um this is a very sensitive matter for the entire board and so before you know we still have time to appoint so um something to consider is that if you come to an agreement today great if you don't come to an agreement today um maybe you want to not make the decision today tonight for the for the board ele for the special election and maybe have another conversation I mean next week we have a a board meeting maybe you can have a followup conversation uh

130next week to see if there's still a way to to come come to an agreement be before making the decision of special election recommendation I don't know how that works so basically we would table this item today and bring it back at the next regular War meeting to continue the discussion and see if our pillows tell us something different what tells us something different our pillows our pillows oh oh sleep sleep I I don't know that I mean and I if you're TR santes if you're not going to budge from your two candidates or consider the other candidates that were presented um I don't know where that I I've I've offered I've voted on three motions and with no qualms but if you're staunch in your position and that positions not going to change then

131I don't know that tabling is going to do anything other than prolong I would agree with just uh president Ugarte if she staunch on not voting on those two from the your two candidates pick one and make a motion I did that twice do it again please do you know something I don't know what do you mean I don't want to go to a special election you neither do I no one does I'm offering you an opportunity to let's try one more time I do to be clear that's not where I want to go and that's what I've said loud and clear because I do feel that special election should have been the route that we took because of the people have a right to vote but the the issue of the $15 million doll

132that cut is what had me step back okay take a look you know programs staff all the different things that can happen but by that very virtue why should I have two very qualified candidates here that we brought together here that did wonderful presentation to and that's not to say anything about the negative about the others is I as a teacher teachers they know oh yeah just because he's he'll be okay I'll give him an a no it's what they did here that's what I graded on that combined with this I will make another motion again okay my first motion I will repeat again was to vote a a motion to U approve uh Karen Ramirez Dominguez second moved by trusty Dominguez sedantes seconded by truste Tamayo all those in favor I I all those

133opposed nay try it again I thank you I move to recess for five minutes is there a second please take yes the uh I will second the motion to take a recess for 5 minutes I I I e e e hope everyone had a good break had a nice walk thank you uh president ugar for the the break often it's it's good to calm emotions as this is a process that um emotions could be high if I know the values of this uh of this board uh I've been working with you for quite a long time now um I think that all of you want to put students above everything and that that is our primary goal we often might see it different because we have different perspectives there's no doubt about it you have

134seen it today that that we do share different perspectives but at the end of the day I still believe that we can come to an agreement an agreement that values the work that our staff is doing values the programs that we offer to our students and values the opportunity for us to continue working on the Mission Vision and values of this this having said that I will put in the following motion I move to appoint Karen Dominguez to seat five and to um appoint Miss Jessica Tolson to seat number one as a slate is there a second wait we can can't do that it's two agenda items yes we can they're under the same heading and so you can combine them as we've done in the past the other route this is where you would

135need to show some trust uh is do it individual but I think for us to come to an agreement and make sure that we're not cutting classified that we're not cutting certificated that we're not cutting uh programs for students this it's a viable option that meets Us in the middle of the road um it's a it's a 2year um commitment I think that this is something that we will bring us together and make the best decision um that is fiscally sound and that is able to move us forward I think the first motion would be thank you for saying that and I'm not I'm just thinking we're under the same agenda item administrative action items you can make a a motion to combine items B and C and then you would be allowed to move

136a slate I'm concerned about the repercussions of doing that uh elaborate there was a reason why we did them separately to begin with and so then now to merge them back again can you elaborate on the reason I mean because from my perspective was to not necessarily hold anyone hostage right because we have 01 then uh we might think that there's favorites now I think that if if we're trying to do what's the best for kids in a spirit to make sure that we move forward I'm proposing that we do it as a slate that way we look we honor what you're saying about the candidates that you proposed we look for a way to get somebody that Lucy can support um and we can move forward I think this is a a way to

137do it if I need to merge um first then I would um suspend my first motion okay then I would move to well I'm still thinking before we yeah before we move truste doming santes the last when when we met last and I asked you why and then agreed to doing it separately we had the option of doing it and under one item it's just a matter now of reversing that choice right and back then is when I said no it needed to be two separate ones because it's like um not to compare it with any children like but it's like I saved this child but not that child it just somehow it doesn't seem but in this case we're Mo we're we're doing it to move forward with the board right and so that

138we don't get stuck here or get it do you want to speak to legal counsel is that is that your fear no legal legal council allowed us to do it either way okay the last time we were here so that's not my issue my issue is that um the person who could help us through this $15 million is now off this slate right but I have the same training and we do have a CBO I just can't help but think that this is something more personal between you guys and Mr FAS I there's just no other way to expl explain it because if you're willing to then now allow Karen Dominguez who ran now now be approved then what's the reason then for Mr faras not being allowed he also ran so it sounds to

139me like that's where there's a personal issue and um and like you've said trusty too and Trust we have not agreed on several issues but we've been respectful of each other and I respect that that's your opinion it's my opinion it's your opinion that has nothing to do with it which is I would not vote for you because you chew gum in front of me which I hate I would not vote for you for that I would be looking at your qualifications I'll put it on my notes no um I think that um that's what I'm it's I don't it's not it's not person it's there's nothing personal in this for me um I'm willing to compromise and make this this this slate a reality and to combine the items it has nothing to do

140with personal I think trusty Theo is listening to you and to your concerns and your best like who you put forward and is trying to make an a compromise so that we can move forward I don't I'm I'm telling you it's not personal for me it's and and if we're if I'm sticking to my what I said before politically Miss do Ramirez Dominguez has the least political you see what I'm saying she has least political experience than Mr FAS and that would be why I would be willing to move that slate forward when I make important decisions in my life I can't make that decision in one minute right I have to process this take your time I'm not going to snore but I am going to put I would I would rather take some

141time and save the district money some millions of dollars our kids I still think it's personal for for for I'm sorry I'm going to have to excuse myself to pray thank you we'll take a we have to take a recess before you do so oh you you're not leaving okay here she's not leaving she's not leaving for for for and ready okay so I will move to combines items a b and c into a single motion is there a second I'll second the motion to combine items 8 B and C uh moved by truste too seconded by trusty all those in favor I I all those opposed no I want it to stay as is and I will vote okay I move okay want to do this I move to a point Jessica Tolson to

142seat number five is there a second no I I have an alternate motion I move to appoint Karen Ramirez Dominguez to seat five second moveed by truste Dominguez cantes seconded by truste Tam Mayo all those in favor I I I thank you I move to a point Jessica Tolson to seat number one I second that motion with an explanation sure if I may yes I want to apologize to Mr faras from the bottom of my heart because I feel that this was personal and I apologize to you for having gone through this because I believe quite frankly that you're the most qualified not just based on the application but also on your presentation please accept my apology I will hold that burden for a long time can I say a word no he can't I

143second the motion for Miss tolston because I do believe that you have the strategies which is one of your strongest points that you're very strategic in all your projects and such so I will burden you with helping us through this time of uh the $15 million deficit and I apologize to the rest of the applicants for not giving you a better opportunity I think you guys would have all been great but I can't compromise for what was presented in the application and what was before us that that I would be lying to not just you but to myself please accept my apologies and I encourage you not to be discouraged to please continue in being involved in our schools you showed your love for the children and the parents and the community as a whole

144I just ask you to please support us in this next motions so that we can come out stronger in the end if I could please ask you for that I you know it's only for the children and the staff that need you and us so much all right call the question moved by trusty too seconded by trusty Dominguez this all those in favor I I I motion [Applause] carries Dr Reyes will now administer the oath of office to our newly elected board members after the administration of the oath we will be congratulating our new board members so Dr Reyes yes and because we are let me and I'm going to get so confused supp support and of the United States the United States and of St en en uned States oblation fre obligation fre without

145anyal purpose I will am congratulations yes shees we'll get theer okay you're going to get to warm it up for two seconds all right I would like to thank everyone for hanging in there with us this evening um we are now um a full board do we have a motion to adjourn the meeting motion to ad the meeting do I have a second I second all those in favor I motion carries unanimously

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.