CorpusRecord 39017

12/16/2024 - Spanish - Chula Vista Elementary School District Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Chula Vista Elementary School District
Date
2024-12-17
Location
San Diego County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,297 words · about 69 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001If you can, please. I want to invite the president of CBE, Rosi Martinez, to take the oath. Raise your right hand. I, Lucy Ugarte, will uphold and respect the Constitution of the United States. I can't hear your English, hers. Ah, the Constitution of the United States, and I take this obligation freely. Excuse me, people I am interpreting for, but Mrs. Lucy Ugarte, president of the board, does not have a microphone. Congratulations. And now I am going to call Mr. Francisco Tamayo and also the president of CBE, Rosi Martinez, please. Oath. And again, the person administering the oath doesn't have a microphone. So, we can't hear what they're saying. Excuse the people I 'm interpreting for. I'm saying, " Many congratulations. There's a certificate to recognize him. He's worked here for 10 years. Mr. Tamayo, would

002you like to say something? There's a lot to do." So, let's begin. Congratulations to both of you, and I want to continue working with you. Okay, all the members are present. Let's try the agenda. I have a motion. I second it, Mrs. Tamayo. Mr. Tamayo said it, and Mrs. Cervantes seconded it. Everyone in favor. The motion passes unanimously. And now we're going to have the organizational meeting of the Board of Education to elect the officers, appoint the superintendent as secretary, adopt dates, times, and places for the regular meetings of the Board. Oh, you can vote on each item individually, Dr. Reyes. Thank you very much. We call this organizational matters, and it's the election of the president and vice president. As Mrs. Urgarte said before, the motion can be made individually. You can vote, or

003you can do it one by one. So, after we do that, the next thing is to appoint me. As secretary, I would like to make a motion to appoint the superintendent as secretary of the Board of Directors for Education. I second the motion. The motion was requested by Mr. Tamayo and seconded by Ms. Domínguez Cervantes. With the superintendent as secretary, I would like to make a motion to adopt the dates, times, and places for the regular meetings of the Board of Directors for the year 2025. I would like to propose, as I have done in past years, that the following candidates be nominated: Madam President, for President, Mr. Ugarte; for Vice President, Mr. Tamayo; and for Member, Ms. Domínguez Cervantes. Is there anyone who seconds this? I second it. Ms. Cervantes. Any discussion? There isn't

004one. Everyone in favor. President, Vice President, Mr. Tamayo. And Mr. Tamayo, say I. The motion passes unanimously, Madam President. Now I would like to make a motion to appoint the superintendent as secretary of the Board of Directors for Education. I second this motion. Mr. Tamayo requested it, and Ms. Domínguez Cervantes seconded it. Everyone in favor. With the superintendent as secretary, say I. The motion passes unanimously, Madam President. I would like to make a motion to adopt the dates, times, and places for the meetings as stated in the document. I would like to revise one of the dates. I would like to move the meeting from April 9th ​​to the following week, and it would be April 16th. Sir, put up any budget issues or anything related to human resources. Don't give it to me. You

005have some dates, but then you're making the meetings six weeks later. Okay, I'm fine with it. Everyone agrees to the amendment to change the April 9th ​​to April 16th. And I have someone to second it. Mr. Tamayo requested it, and Ms. Cervantes seconded it. Everyone in favor of the amended April meeting dates. Everyone say I. The motion passes unanimously. Okay, oral communications. This provides the public for the opportunity to address the board only on closed session matters. Individuals who wish to be heard may attend in person and must complete a request card to be heard and submit it to the recording secretary before the start of the meeting. Speakers are requested to limit sub-absorptions to 3 minutes and to speak respectfully and professionally. The board will limit the total time for public participation on each

006item to 20 minutes. With the consent of the board, the chair may increase or decrease the time allowed for public comments. There is no one who wishes to address the board. Then let's go to closed session. 3 5 49.1 of 5495 7.6 of the Government Code collective bargaining employee negotiation agency Adam Silva and Magnal employee organizations Chula Vista classified employees organization Chula Vista educators unrepresented employees and Chula Vista administrators association section 54957 B1 of the Government Code discipline dismissal release of public employees section 54957 of the Government Code appointment employment title of a director and section 549 56.9 D1 of the Government Code conference with advisor to the Superior Court of the State of California County of San Diego case number 37 202400 3941 cu wm ztl al ... al ... Ms. Ugarte, due to

007a conflict of interest. Thank you. The Chula Vista Board of Education is now at order. Welcome, everyone. Welcome, all members present. Mr. Romero, if you would lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance, please. Please, your right hand over your heart. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you very much. Now, let's approve the agenda. We have a motion. Mr. [Name] requests the motion, and Ms. Cermes seconds it. Everyone in favor, say I. The motion passes unanimously. Recognition [Music] Winners of the Dr. Reyes Holiday Card Contest. This is a very exciting time. This was a competition that was conducted in our schools to encourage students to enter and submit artwork to

008the holiday card contest, and this truly was an art gallery. The first place card is the official district card, and second and third place are also recognized. So, for our third place winner from Parkview School, we have... Riley Perez, I'm going to lower them here. Oh, the second place winner is Avery Lee Carns from Olympic View School, fifth grade. And the first place winner is Adriana Elizabeth Tantra from Heren Camp School. That's it, that's why it does n't come back. And bravo to the winners of the holiday greeting card contest! Comments from the board: It takes a very brave person to submit their art. I appreciate that you shared it with us because it's a magnificent piece of work. Thank you very much. I say the same. I am always impressed every year with the

009quality of our students' work. Especially with art, it's very hard to decide who is in first place, and I think all of these are good. I love them, but congratulations for sharing your talents with us. I think that's something that's important to be able to share. But also, one of the things we can see as a member of California Coast Credit Union is that every time I go to the bank, I see the card there. So it doesn't matter which branch you're going to see this art in, and that's a magnificent advertisement, and we should continue to inspire these creatures. Congratulations to the winners! Thank you for Sharing their talent, I can add one more thing, and it could be our mural in the future. Every year, I marvel at the work of our students,

010and I was watching the social media when the voting was taking place and all the work that was being exhibited. Any of these cards would have been great to represent us, and we are proud. It was very difficult for the judges; I saw them around the table. We are very proud of the work they did, and we already have the official card. Thank you and congratulations on the recognition from the Country Music Association ( CMA). Our person who will receive it today can see here. Thank you. Today I am very excited to share with you the Teacher of Excellence. He is a teacher, and it is the Country Music Association. Every year, several teachers who are bringing music to their students are selected, and a $1000 award is given for the classroom. And on September

0117th, Jonathan Seligman, a teacher from Castillas, was given this honor in the Hall of Fame in Nashville, Tennessee, for his work and dedication to the Chula Vista Elementary School District. So, we are very proud, Mr. Seligman, and we appreciate it every year. of the service you have given to the students and community in Casillas and in the Chula Vista Elementary School District. So please, the board will present the certificate. Board comments: Sir, you want to share that it was truly something great. Excuse me to those I'm interpreting, the person speaking doesn't have a microphone, so I ca n't hear. Thank you very much, congratulations on the work you have been doing. Not just this year, but every year, many times. I want to thank you for everything you do. Not just the recognition you are

012receiving, but also the work you do for the students, because the winners of all this work are the students, and sharing this and at least showing them all the opportunities that are out there. Thank you very much for sharing that passion with the students and thank you for everything you are doing. When I review the agenda with Dr. Reyes, we look at each item and say, "Why is this on our agenda?" And he explained it to me, and then I saw your name and I said, "Now it makes sense, because I see you here, I see you in different presentations, and the way the students respond to you, you truly deserve this award." And now for this part You're making our great district very famous, even Nashville. It's very important in our profession as teachers.

013It's very important to receive this recognition to ensure that students have a love for music, and sometimes we forget that sometimes we have to recognize them. This made a lot of sense. Congratulations. Okay, recognition from the district's staff department. And I'm very honored to recognize someone who has contributed so much to education and also to our district for so many years. I'm talking about the person we all love and respect, Rochelle Carol. So Rochelle has been here, she's been with us for 36 years. However, she's been in education for 40 or more years, and if you can think about the impact she's made on all these students during her lifetime, the impact on so many staff members, parents, and the realities, Rochelle is someone who truly believes, truly believes in the power of education. As

014she always says, "I'm a teacher at heart." Yes, she's a mentor, she's an instructional leader, she's a guide, she's a friend to all of us, to many of us. Rochelle, I know you're going to retire soon. You're going to have a wonderful time in your new chapter, but you're going to We will truly miss you. You are leaving a void here, but on the other hand, you are leaving so much to continue your work and your legacy. Congratulations. A few comments from the board: I have only been here two years, but Mrs. Rochel, the seeds you planted in so many individuals—my grandson, my daughter, my other daughter, other teachers, your colleagues— show your passion for what you do and the heart you have. You are a wonderful person. You will be missed, not just for

015what you brought to the School District in terms of curriculum, but for who you are. We will build on what you planted, but you will be missed. Where to begin? 36 years in the district, the number of student lives you touched, the lives of staff you changed and improved. Well, you have been here for a long time, and we will be here for even longer. I am sad because you have brought so much to this district, so much knowledge, so much concern, so much care, and because of that, so many things happen and so many things continue to happen. And as my colleagues said, your legacy has been in this district because nobody leaves the district after... 36 years and you're not leaving a legacy, you're committed to our students. This is a great gift

016you've given us, thank you so much and congratulations. Oh, I want to be like you. When I came to this board, I knew a lot about the high school curriculum, and I know that when teachers say you guide them, teach them, and influence them, it's true. Because when I came to this board, you never made me feel like I wasn't enough or didn't know. You taught me what I needed to know, and you were kind and gentle, and I felt like I could do what I was doing. And when someone comes to me and says, "Rochelle helped me," I know, I know what that means because you helped me, you helped me understand the difference between what I knew and what I needed to know. But you work so hard. 36 years is a lot.

017I hear people telling me that you help them and that you email them in the middle of the night, and you also told me to talk to you and to love you after you left. You know, you're working so hard. And we hope that if you really start to retire and stop taking our calls, etc., I appreciate everything you've been, how helpful you've been to these people, including us. We're going to miss you at all the events. You made a big difference; we saw that today, we see that now. Congratulations on this new step you're taking on your path. Very good work. Okay, communications to the Education Board, Chula Vista Classified Employees, Mrs. Angela Reed, thank you. It's not audible as we come in from winter break. I think it's a good time to reflect

018on what we've collectively changed. Thank you, thank you. That's why I'm going to start again as we come in from winter break. I think it's a good time to reflect on what we've collectively changed for this school year and evaluate where we can improve. The part closest and dearest to me has been the inclusion of dedicated professional development and resources to enhance the capacity of classified staff at all levels while we carry out the rewarding work of educating students. As I've repeated more times than I care to remember, a more skilled and knowledgeable classified staff is a force multiplier because classified employees Highly trained staff require less daily intervention and, by extension, do not need to be directed or adjusted to cost. The reduced student inclusion time also demonstrates that the district is committed to

019its employees and empowers all staff to enhance their skills and knowledge. Although I am very pleased that time for professional development has been implemented, I believe the execution is fundamentally flawed and, as a result, will not lead to the improvements it could and should. While the time for training and the venues to support training are beneficial and necessary, it is insufficient to create only one opportunity for effective training. As with many things, there needs to be an overall plan. To understand this, it is helpful to think of training at four levels, which I will briefly explain to help you understand where I am going with this. The first level is knowledge, which means the terminology and background concepts about the subject or field. The important thing to realize is that level one is only valuable

020insofar as it provides a common foundation for the recipients, but it hardly points to any developmental value for the trainee. The next level is practical skills, and its purpose is to practice the implementation of the skills and knowledge from level one. These skills enable the implementation Reactive and complex knowledge and skills from level one, in short, knowing what to do is not the same as knowing how to do it. For example, I may know that a fire hose connection must be pressurized and directed to the fire, but I may not know how to choose the correct hose. I could connect it incorrectly to the system, pressurize it prematurely, etc. Knowing about doing something does not necessarily mean that the trainee is actually capable of achieving it. Level three implementation is a progression from the previous

021level one of practical skills. The purpose of level three is to bring together the individual skills learned in a complex environment. Doing this effectively requires the most difficult level of all. The fourth and crucial level is evaluation. Simply doing any level is not enough and will provide little return on investment for developing knowledge, skills, and capabilities. Two essential things are really required: first, what did we do well? This allows us to emphasize some of the elements of level one for the next time through the cycle: enter, do, evaluate, review. Ideally, this leads to the second question: what can or should we improve? This feedback helps generate effective changes in our plan for the next cycle in order to improve what is most needed. By now you have probably noticed that this scheme is circular, ideally

022even when... You need some level four assessment principles to know where to start I would argue that even for the first time, we have initial inputs at level four. These inputs are internal— areas of weakness identified by the employees themselves—and external— areas of improvement identified by staff and supervisors, determined by direct feedback, evaluations, or problems detected within the professional development plan. I recognize that this is a challenging proposal, but I also recognize its vital importance. Most of our professional development up to this point has been at level one. If I could add—without being able to— I could add an evaluation-based input on what would be best for training. The first should be a district-wide assessment. Each classification should use internal and external evaluations to determine where we should focus our limited but valuable professional development

023resources. From there, training should focus on the knowledge, skills, and abilities identified ( KSAs). From there, those KSAs should be implemented and, over time, evaluated to determine if improvements are needed or if different KSAs should be addressed in the next cycle. This cycle of training, implementation, evaluation, and improvement is development. Anything less than this is simply putting information in front of people and expecting them to know what to do with it. Such an approach provides little value and often results in a presentation of things the recipient already knows. It does not improve performance and, by extension, will not contribute to better student learning. I am urging you, the board, to direct CBCD to sit down with CBCO to discuss a memorandum of understanding on training, mentoring, and professional growth signed in June 2023. Thank you,

024Chula Vista educators. Mrs. Rossi Martinez. Good evening. It is a very exciting night of celebration. It was wonderful to see the hall of former and current CBSD employees. I want to congratulate Mrs. Carol; she has been a pillar for this district, and her dedication and legacy remain. Her unwavering professionalism has benefited students and teachers. It has been a privilege to work with you. I have learned so much from you, and you will continue to be my inspiration. I also want to congratulate Jonathan on his recognition of music, and I had the privilege of seeing him during a presentation with his students. I had so much admiration for his quality instruction for his students. Congratulations to Patti Mon Montoy on her retirement. I worked with her at Harbor Site, where... Having served as secretary for so

025many years, she has been the heart of that school. For so many years, having a district that has been so important to our lives is very important, especially when changes are made. This is the case in CALOG, where Luis Aparicio has been an asset to the community, and we know that the new principal will be the same. Anyone who knows me knows the special place that Harborside holds in my heart. I know that Mr. Aparicio will be there. He is very supportive of the community and the community schools, and I know that he will strengthen the work that is happening there. Now, there are some items on the agenda that I want to highlight. One is the conversion of 27 teachers to probationary status. We want to acknowledge the district for listening to our advocacy

026for them, for those who have served so much for so many years. We tell CBE and CBE that the negotiations are going well. We have worked hard so that our members can cover health benefits for their families. We are closing our open items. One of the items we have focused on is safety. We have heard that this is an area Of concern, we know it's a priority that needs to be addressed. Another is the staff in special education. We have the opportunity to have new staff. Oh, and a bonus that you're voting on today. This will alleviate some of the challenges we're facing, and we're already halfway through the year, but know that there's much more to do. Oh, we all deserve some holidays. Thank you, Chula Vista administrators. Teresa Corona, good evening everyone. We

027have an agreement that was finalized in July 2024, and it has to serve as a foundation for how we collaborate. As AACB president, I've said many times that we want to work together with the district, and one way to do that is to work within our agreement in all the areas addressed. As director, I always refer to our agreements, whether reviewing terms, checking with colleagues, or interpreting the contract. I do my best to ensure that my actions are aligned with these agreements. It's about respecting what has been negotiated and honoring the members of these organizations in the same way. It's critical that the district does the same with the same commitment and that these agreements are followed when working with members of the district. I want to give a positive example, and that's the establishment

028of the advisory committee that I spoke about last month. This is an example. You see, representatives have been appointed, and we have meetings to do this. It's not good. I want to tell you that this agreement is on the district website now, and you need to use it as a resource. This will ensure that our work is respected and done professionally. I'd also like to take a moment to emphasize the importance of clarity. I've spoken with the board about this. Our members need clarity in all programs and procedures communicated by the district and your AC department. You see, in this last month, they need clarity. And I want to say that we saw actions that were taken. These actions need to continue and should be changed in the next quarter. I also have to say

029that clarity is vital because most initiatives and changes go toward principals, teachers, and staff. When principals don't have clear guidance or procedures, it's much harder for our teams to function effectively. Finally, I want to talk about our district, which used to be decentralized. Centralization will probably have benefits. It's a significant change that needs careful planning and systems that need to be in place. To do this with all stakeholders, like AACB, this change is for rigorous learning for all. It is essential that everyone is included in the planning and decision-making from the beginning of this 3- to 5- year work. I want you to ensure that all our stakeholders, including AACB, are involved and that we also share experiences and ensure that the plan also supports schools and students. Thank you, good night. Thank you. Before

030we move on to oral communications from the board, Mr. Romero, after our recognition, please introduce our new principal. Thank you, President Hugarte, Vice President Tamayo, Superintendent. It is my pleasure to be here tonight to introduce the new principal, Elizabeth Carsoli. She has approximately 20 years of experience, the last 7 years as an administrator. She has experience as an assistant principal and principal. It is a pleasure for us to introduce L, our new Kellogg's principal. Thank you for that introduction. I am honored to be part of CBD and have also been in the community. My children also came to AC CBD, and I believe in this system. My daughter is a classroom teacher. I want to give back to this community and hope to make a difference in the school and continue what has been done.

031Mr. Carsoli appeared throughout the school year. I want to mention thanks to the board for believing in me, to the administration team. I promise to do my best for the students. Thank you. Welcome, and I think it's Dr. Carsoli, right? Dr. Carsoli, oral communications gives the public the opportunity to address the board on topics not related to the agenda. Speakers are asked to limit their remarks to 3 minutes. They are told to hand their request to be heard to the board secretary and are limited to speaking for 3 minutes and to be respectful. The board limits the total time for public participation to 20 minutes per topic, and they can also increase or decrease the time, and no action can be taken. These are points that are not on the agenda. So if you start

032talking about an agenda item, I'm going to ask you to wait until that item is presented. For example, something that has to do with the vacancy or the process by which we are going to fill the vacancies. That will be item 13b. So someone who hasn't brought up the topic, if you start To talk about that topic, I'm going to ask you to stop and wait until we get to Article 13b. Thank you. With that, our first speaker is Maribel Martinez. Good evening. I would like to request extended time. After my time is up, how much time are you requesting? Friday, December 6, 9:07 a.m. I sent an email, and then another one on December 9 with no response. I sent another email on December 11 with no response. I have sent a total of

033four emails since December 6, 2024. No one has followed up or even called. Nothing, zero, nothing from our board members, superintendent, or assistant human resources director. Tell me why a CBSD parent has a concern and is being ignored by your elected officials. It's the same thing they've done with Principal Porras. I have been a Rogers parent for six years. Over the years, I have developed a community of parents. We have supported the district, we trust each other, and unfortunately, our conversations with some of you members have gone against Principal Porras. I have seen many changes. The many administrative changes at Rogers aren't ensuring my son's well-being either. There's a very large population of special education students. Principal Porras has been at Rogers for a year, and she has ensured the safety and well-being of these

034students. I can guarantee you that no one in the administration sent emails when my son's life was in danger because they had a prohibited item in the classroom. The letter was sent on December 6th, which Principal Porras saw. It's an insult to abandon her community in the middle of the year with all the plans she had. They're removing her. Have you seen the positive changes at our school? When was the last time you visited? Have you read our blog? She welcomed our entire community. Dr. Reyes, you're asking us what the quality attributes and qualities are for the new principal. Well, let me tell you, Dr. Porras had all of that: a bilingual principal, a voice that Rogers has been lacking for our students. This instability is not good. Give us resources and support Principal Porras.

035A new principal is not the answer. I have signatures to support her. We ask that Principal Porras remain at Rogers School. We ask CBSD to keep Principal Porras, who has proven to be a very good fit for Rogers School. I will send you the signatures, but they probably won't receive them by email. Jane Faulkner: Hello, my name is Jane Faulkner. I am a resident of Chula Vista and a proud mother at Chula Vista Hills School. We met here last month when we were talking about soccer. Today, I bring you two stories. On the left, we have the champion Chula Vista Hills community, Title One, who paid for months to have a water station. The lady wanted to remove the drinking fountain because it fell and hurt a student, and then they were able to put

036up an identical one. In the end, it was another Pink for CBSD, leaving the students... Before leaving, I would like to say how important this request is. The Chula Vista Hills School water system is very old and not safe for our children. Remove the metaphors of fighting and soccer, and what you have... And these messages... It's that we are concerned, and we hope that the board... I listened and took action. What we are requesting is what every child deserves: clean water and, more importantly, a station to fill their water bottles. Thank you. Next up, Noel Cravens. Good evening to the board members, Dr. Reyes, and the administration team. I am a mother of students at Fajar Jeffers. I have attended the last few meetings here and discussed issues from different schools. As a committed parent,

037I am grateful to have a platform to speak and address your concerns. I believe we all want the same thing: we want all students to have the best education. I have no doubt that the best years are coming and that the district will continue to make improvements and be one of the best districts. Thank you, Ashley Barba. Good evening, sir. I am a mother of four and have a student at Kellogg. I am here to express my displeasure that Mr. Aparicio is being taken away. But what I understand is that he is being sent to Harborside School because he needs to teach there. They need a leader at Harborside. At least half of our families speak Spanish, and Mr. Aparicio spoke it. The other principals didn't. As you can imagine, the lack of consistency... This

038has had consequences for our staff and also for our students. Mr. E's leadership has been magnificent, and now they are taking it away from us. Why does Kellogg have to suffer to be a good leader in our school or another? Why does Kellogg have to suffer? It takes time to build relationships and establish trust. How can students learn to trust if they keep changing people? It's not right to do this mid-year. This happened to us last year at Cook. They shouldn't change principals, especially when the community is happy. Mr. Tamayo, you're wearing a union shirt. Please, members, amend these practices of changing principals like this. If it ain't broke, don't break it. Thank you. Claudia Pérez Chica. Good evening, Superintendent and members. My name is Claudia Pérez Chica. This is my 24th year in the

039district, and I am now a behavior teacher at Rogers. I hope you will continue to support our school. We are a unique community with preschool classes, special education, one-on- one services, and 60 members classified as having the most vulnerable population. Members of our H-team have come in and been ignored. They have been evaluated, and that's why they are asking for more. They are losing talented staff who are leaving for other schools. Rogers only has one playground attendant for 70 students at lunchtime, and the same thing happens during recess. Our classified representatives were appointed by our principal instead of there being a vote. We had a special education classroom, and the children and assistants were only given a walkie- talkie. Please be open and transparent with the new principal about the challenges of having the school

040with the most classified staff in the district. We need something unified; we need open communication and very strong leadership. We, the classified staff, want to work with a principal and work together, and we want to be able to work on relevant training. Please support the new principal as we transition to a school that has had insecure leadership for so long. I hope you understand that Rogers deserves better. I appreciate your time. Thank you and good night. Good night, Christie. I am a Rogers parent, and I have been advocating for more resources for our school since June. We wanted a PTA committee, and the administration never responded. As a school board member, it is through these committees that I was able to learn about the challenges our school faces. I wanted to thank the District, especially

041Ms. Sharon Morales, for taking the time to meet with me and address my concerns. It's wonderful that they gave us a full-time counselor. I also appreciate the district and the members who took the time to come to our school, observe my daughter's classroom, understand the dynamics, and recognize how much we need the district's intervention and support. Andy Falconer has made many changes in our classroom, and we want to learn more. How can we receive an award someday? On another note, we hope the district will bring in impact teachers, since even though we are in the midst of a pandemic, the ramifications are still present, and children need additional support. I believe that impact teachers can help students who are falling behind understand that the district... I am a regular parent, and I want to show

042the students that there is power in advocacy. I am where you are; we have to persist for the well-being of our community and our children and never give up. Thank you, Steven Vazquez. Good evening, Dr. Reyes, Superintendent, Mr. Romero, and Sharon Casey. I am a... The grandfather of two students who attend his school, what I shared with some of the concerned parents was that some years ago, I believe you were here, Dr. Reyes, where there was a representative from Fegan Friedman, and he gave a presentation, which I was able to see. It was discussed about the work of the school board, and part of the information everyone received was that one of those roles is community leadership, monitoring student performance, and supporting and maintaining a safe and appropriate environment. They were also given tips on

043how to interact with others. I personally appreciate all the board members here who take time out of their lives to truly communicate with us when we have questions or concerns. I think that for any of the parents who have questions about what the board members do and what they can't do, I 'm not sure if the district has a contract with this company. I'm not making an announcement, but I think it would be in everyone's interest to perhaps have a meeting for the parents. Thank you, Linda Garcia. Mrs. Porras is a... A very kind person, but I don't think she's good for the school. I think the school requires someone so special, a very special educator with knowledge and background in this particular school. She has everything that needs to be checked. But Mrs. Porras,

044she is intelligent and educated. I think her experience would be better for middle or high school, not for Greg Rogers. I understood that she made changes. You have three PTA members, you do n't have a Security Patrol, you don't have children doing what they used to do. There is still bullying. You have to listen to solutions and ideas because the only way is... The fact that these people are your teachers and the staff, the girls who run the office, the nurse, everyone else below the principal and the teachers, this should raise a red flag. Many parents from kindergarten through sixth grade have contacted Ms. Porras. You see what has been done and what hasn't been done. Francisco Martinez, all the speakers who wanted to speak about the vacancies died at 13b. Before we move on

045to the oral presentations, I would like to acknowledge that our lawyers are here regarding the fact that we have three members instead of two. I want to introduce our lawyers. If we now have three members of the board, I would like the lawyers to review for clarification what a quorum is and if to pass it is one vote or two votes, how does it work? Good evening, members of the board, Dr. Reyes. The way the law works is that the quorum is the majority of the members of the board. So you have a board of five. The quorum to call a meeting requires three members to be present. It requires a unanimous vote of the three members to pass, adopt, or approve anything. So that This is the situation that occurs when you have two

046vacancies on a five-member board. Sometimes there are exceptions, but it's an extraordinary case. I don't want to give any indication; it's a very rare situation. Can you give us an example? During the meeting, let's say one of the members had to leave. What would happen if someone had to leave and it's an action item on the agenda? There would no longer be a quorum. One thing that could happen is that the meeting would end if a member left, but they wouldn't be able to take action. If one of the members left, there would surely be more questions. When we got to the 13b Safety and Health Updates, Mr. Romero, we had our committee meeting. It was a very large agenda. The district has been working with the Chula Vista Traffic Division to ensure we have

047good pedestrian crossings. We have five schools where projects are going to be done. So, in Valle Lindo, Casillas Rogers, and Soto Mayor, we're going to be installing different crossings, putting up signage, and also collecting traffic data and identifying areas that need to be redesigned. We're excited about these projects in the city of Chula Vista, and our camera project. All the... Schools have been evaluated, we are very close, and we are prioritizing having every school in Chula Vista with cameras by the end of the 2024-2025 school year. We want to make sure and also to have all the ideas from all the principals, and we would like to have them by the end of the year. Also, with EEX, which is our platform that we have been using to prioritize security and real-time security notifications, one

048of the things we are working on now is that substitutes have access to the IG platform, and our next step is to give tablets to our schools and give them a tablet so they also have updates in real time, like any other staff member. These are trainings that have been taken at Otai; we had an incident management training, and also at Montgomery, Sotomayor, and Silverwing; we had a lockdown drill, and also at Laback School and Lom Verde, an incident management training last week. And we also had our Heritage Community Forum, and we were all in attendance. Some parents were there, and we were very excited to ask questions. The one they had was about access control and some Schools have limited access. There are some freedoms we 've had in schools, but if we want

049to keep them safe, there are things we have to do. Some of those things involve changing the school culture and how we communicate. Our camera project—all of that was discussed in the forum we had at Heritage. And this is about an incident that happened in our schools. It's very important because when someone raised an alert, many people in the district knew what was happening. This was a case of accident, but an employer sent a notification at 7:45 to Ms. Beña. They responded, and they started responding to make sure he was okay. He was there, and so was our custodial staff supervisor. At 7:47, we recognized it was an accident, and within two minutes, we knew it was a false alarm and that no one had to be called. This was a false alarm, but we

050want to show the community that six people were in this situation, and it would have been different in the past. The teacher would have had to call the office, and the principal would have had to call the district. We saved a lot of time and a lot of minutes in the process. Question: No one here? Questions or comments from the board? Yes, the school crossings. I know that many schools have entrances in the back. This requires Chula Vista Police approval for this crossing. Dr. Reyes, can you explain the process? The City of Chula Vista has a traffic department, and where we have concerns—I know of the school you might be talking about—the flow of traffic. Excuse me, no, not all of our schools recommended those priorities. In some of the schools, we've been contacting the

051city. These are the first five, but at least there are maybe five shared. These are all the first ones. We have a timeline. We can start, reinforce, or change. None of the traffic patterns you were talking about are cars parking on both sides, some parents parking, and kids running. Do you think it requires the superintendent to meet with Maria because this is student safety? Ah, I have to cut to the middle name. Talk to the city manager. I can work with her to see what can be done, and I'll mention it to her. I have another question. Can we... Giving feedback, they can give us feedback on what they said. I want to wait for the next meeting. And also, access to vendors, but access to the distributors. They have access during the school day,

052and sometimes the children are still there. I would like to know what the protocol is, Mr. Romero. Can you speak? All the people who are going to our distributors need to have a complete report. Oh, yes, we work with our facilities department. If there is a project that is happening, whether it's on Saturday after school, there is always a district employee with those people. For example, there is always a district member there, and the people who are accompanying them. If they are, for example, those who are going to fumigate, all of this is true since the offices are closed. So what is the process? Well, they can send a substitute if the people who were already updated are not available to do that job. Yes, I understand your concern. You 're telling me that our

053custodial staff is going to be following this person. I'm not going to say shoulder to shoulder, but I think what they do is that they are doing their job on campus. They are not available. They have communication radios. They are not given a Key to the classroom, but if they need to go to the roof, then they're given access. It's not shoulder to shoulder, it's more supervision. It's not a statement that they're being followed, right? I mean, they're being monitored, let's put it that way. I just want to make sure that our language says what we do, that's all. Yes, yes, I understand your question. I wouldn't use the word " cort," but I would to the people I'm interpreting. Who are you? Uh, with no removal, or the one from the consent calendar. Is

054there any article that needs to be removed by the board? Yes, 11c subsection m. Sorry, F and m, 11 of H, p and q. Mr. Tamayo, do you have any article? Yes, 11t of Toño. I'm going to remove it, and I have a motion to pass at least 11c FM d h i pq and t. Mr. Tamayo requested it, and Mrs. Domínguez Cervantes seconds it. Everyone in favor, say: I, the mission passes unanimously. Jorge, we remove this. No, you don't want me to remove it? Oh no, no, it's fine on the page. Yes, we can elaborate on the position, which is on pages 12 and 13. And also, if we can clarify about essential requirements. I want to know what those two articles mean, Dr. Reyes. Ms. Cassy, ​​can you please share what it entails?

055What work will they be doing? And does Ms. Dominguez Cervantes have any experience related to education? I think that question is mainly for Romero. Can you talk about this? This is a position that will be under me, working with me, to support the departments I oversee: special education, community schools, litigation, all those fun things, so that I can support our district and students. And regarding the question Ms. Dominguez Cervantes had, I just want clarification on where it says " essential job requirements." The third one says " Education experience related to anything undesirable." So, for example, we have multiple licenses that are required: special education, preschool, and others that are related to education. I appreciate that because I'm looking for someone who can truly be a Section M, page 7 of 13. Where are you reading

056this? This girl, these two, are paid with a fund Regarding Special Education, I have questions about this. There's a non-public agency that's supporting providers of special education teachers, and I'm asking because one of our negotiators said that by frequently using hiring agencies, we're earning $45,000 a year. For two of these agencies, that's almost a million dollars just for these two agencies. I'm wondering if we could be more productive and see, and hire these people, do an analysis or evaluation because we're just approving and approving. So let's see what we can do to hire these people because these agencies take a percentage of what you 're paying them. So these people are being paid $7 or $20 an hour, but we're paying them $5 or $27 an hour. I worked with some of these agencies in

057my past life. So, if it's cheaper to keep them, well, one of the reasons is that one of the items we have today is a memorandum of understanding to have a bonus for special education teachers. And this is to bring in special education teachers so we can hire them instead of using agencies. The idea is to hire, attract, and retain these teachers. It's only for teachers. But what about the people who aren't licensed? My understanding is that these are for teachers. Yes, right? Yes, also for speech and language therapists. They're filling vacancies. I think Mark will agree that we better have the money. So I think we want to keep an eye on this to see what we can do to keep them. Thank you. I want to know what it's about, where. Thank you

058very much. This is a Safe Schools Ambassadors program. It started in Marshalls and Murca, and essentially it's an anti-bullying program that gives assemblies and sessions for parents, and it really works with students who have a lot of capital in the fields. And teachers, so it helps to help the anti- bullying culture with natural leadership among students and teachers. Invite me when this is happening, when this is in action. I think you had something to say about this, in both the therapy and there healthc Sharon or Mr. Romero. We have approximately 12 Special Education vacancies. Some of them are being filled, and the rest of the support is there. So now, yes, I'm going to join. There are two of the 12 vacancies. Thank you. The next one is Lexia Bers suppress These are services in

059different schools, and we don't get feedback on whether they work or not. I'm not saying they do n't, but if they could share the results, perhaps other schools could adopt or invest in these programs. They don't give us any feedback. One of the reasons or ways we could expand on that a little more is, Ms. Morales. Yes, of course, this contract is a professional development opportunity for a writing program that we have in many schools. And if a principal is having success with a program, they can share it with their groups. And what we're also doing is using these programs throughout the district and testing their effectiveness in our schools. So all the stakeholders are creating Leadership action plans. We have many programs that aren't just Leadership plans, but they are in their schools' SSPs,

060and we're going to determine what we're going to move forward with. And no, Ms. Jessica, when you say "we," you mean "you." When I say "we," I mean the Leadership team with our principals and our lead principals. We have lead principals with these projects, and they also have meetings where they take work. I hope that's happening. And the last one, Dr. Reyes, is Turbo Escape, page 8 of 13. Lastly, $1,000 for mulch is a lot. How many of our schools are doing it? And remind me, this was done in a contest. Mr. F, Mr. P, I don't have an update here on how many have mulch, but we didn't have a formal contest. It's not a formal contest. These contracts are considered maintenance, but they received three proposals. I want to ask, are these the

061little wooden boards that are in the yard? That's what we're talking about. I just wanted to verify. Do you want to make a motion now? I'm worried about $1,000 for the yard boards. Oh, Mr. Pong, do you have information on this? Yes, I'm going to get it. This is an urgent item. I have to check with the department. Alejandro, can you come to the podium? Are you Mr. M? No, but almost. It's a service for all the schools to control all the weeds, and it's for all 50 schools. It was an agreement not to exceed $ 100,000 a year. It's a service agreement. You just saved Mark. I appreciate you being here. Thank you for 11C. We're done now. So, I accept everyone from 11C. Everyone in favor, say... I'm excited. It passed unanimously. 11d

062Mr. Romero shared about security. Mr. Tamayo requested it, and Ms. Cervantes seconded it. Everyone in favor. Say, "I'm excited." It passed unanimously. 11H I started to see some of these plans. We had the agenda Friday night. In the afternoon, I haven't been able to see them all. So my question is at this point, but I'm going to review them. Who in the district is reviewing these plans to make them accurate? Dr. Reyes, there are many plans. It's Ms. Lan Pérez who is in the back here reading them. I'm going to try them, but I'll be reviewing them and then we can talk. Thank you. It was approved by Mr. Dominguez. Ms. Dominguez, please. Mr., the motion passes unanimously. 11 and I need to correct. This is to approve the agreement and the purchase of library

063services for the San Diego County Office of Education for the period December 1, 2025 to June 30, 2025. There was a correction for December, and it should say January 1, 2025 to June 30, 2025. In 2025, if we have to pay 8,970 from January to June to the Education Office to serve as librarians for CBSD, we shouldn't call it a service to do x, y, and z. Why are we paying for these services? Because they're talking... Well, it's not free. We pay them 8,000, Dr. Reyes. Thank you. According to the Education Code, we have to have a librarian. If we don't have one in the district, that's because we're contracting with the County office. It's 49 cents per student for the entire school year. This is a prorated portion. Yes, you think it's... it seems

064like it's free, but that's not the intention. Some other districts charge them because they don't have the contract, and it helps them select books and have some of the tools and catalogs in the system. Yes, it spreads a little, but I would amend it to remove "free" and replace it with a discount if they're going to provide those services. Yes, but shouldn't it say " included, free, and discounted"? Oh yes, of course, we can fix it before we vote. I have a question, lawyers. I work for the County Education Office. Normally, I... I abstain from voting on these contracts even though they're not directly related to my work, but since I work for them, I abstain from voting. What do I have to do? What 's the process? Will it be one vote, or can

065I vote? Can I ask where you work? Are you involved in any way? Then you can vote. Just to clarify, let's say he works for that department, he would have to abstain, and at that point, two votes are enough. That's what we have to consider when you have the agenda. So, my colleague would have to take notes to consider what should be used. I think you can vote with her confidentially. How can I vote? I'm going to speak. She says she's lying down. It does n't matter, we can keep moving forward. Everyone in favor, say... [ Music] Approve the award of the request for qualifications and the request for proposals 2425, a software provider for a behavioral health initiative for children and youth at Healthy Campus. It's an implementation plan, training materials, record functionality, and

066skill. I'd like to know why we need this. Who's going to use this program? Who are the patients? How are the patients involved? Who is reporting? What to whom? And I have more questions after this. Thank you, Mr. Romero and Mrs. Cassy. This program is for young people, and we receive a subsidy. We have staff who meet with the students. So, this program is going to help us... excuse me... to record all the services. So, this subsidy requires that you record interactions with the children, and that is the condition for them to give you this money quickly. And to clarify, when we record, we are not recording the interactions themselves; what we are recording are the times we meet with them. So, if they met for 54 minutes, we are going to record that counseling

067was given, not the conversation or the interaction. Currently, we do this with Medical. This subsidy... this has happened to many of our districts, but it will allow us to notify parents that their children's information... There must be some identifier; you have to put something in. You know what the software looks like? Yes, we have seen it. We have seen three companies. They have this; it is the only resource they have, and I don't remember the certification they have. Oh, the data that is collected cannot be shared with any agency. To answer your questions, the only way the services can be provided is with the authorization of the... Parents, and what is the timeframe? This is going to be implemented in January. So it needs to be updated right now. As far as you know, this

068doesn't change anything we 're doing. We're already doing all of this; it's just a way for us to collect for billing purposes. It's solely for billing, to justify that we're using the money appropriately. I just want to make sure I'm clarifying that. It's just collecting from the child because it says " from the patient," that's where I needed clarification. Thank you. Mrs. Dominguez Cervantes requested it, Mr. Tamayo seconded it, all in favor. I say the motion passes unanimously. 11q Yes, it says to ratify the amendment to two suspension agreements with the San Diego County Air Pollution Control District. First, to clarify, and then the question: batteries don't make electricity; they produce batteries primarily with uranium carbon. So, a but regarding the fiscal impact, and we're looking at cutting money, I think we just have to

069buy what the subsidies cover. Thank you very much. These trucks have a program that helps us replace diesel trucks with electric trucks. We already replaced four, and because the subsidy was reduced, we were able to buy three, but we're only going to buy two now. I'm still hearing, or not hearing, that we're going to... When we have a subsidy, it's 889,000, and I'm not approving it. The reason we need these is because the electric trucks aren't going to reach the sixth-grade camp. Yes, because the subsidy only gives you a hundred and something per truck. So we're at 89,000. We don't have gasoline trucks anymore. Yes, we do, but they're getting very old. That's why we want to replace the old ones. I'm proposing that you use the money for what you can buy and not

070buy other things because we're short. So what are you proposing? We're using a reserve. Not restricted. I'm hearing that the trucks have to be replaced eventually. So at this moment, how many trucks are you proposing to buy? Three, two originally, three. And if we take the 89,000 to the 889,000, it's not a total amount, it's what they're going to give us per truck. So there's still a... So if we don't buy the trucks, well, we lose the subsidy, or we would have to pay completely out of our own pockets to replace them. So you're telling me you're buying them anyway? Either we buy them or we lose the money. Eventually, we have to buy them. Yes, in this year's budget, I have a problem making this decision like this and not being more prepared to

071ask more questions. When does this subsidy end? We have to have the truck in full operation by the end of February. It didn't exist before; they didn't have it, and now they do. I have to check where they are. We need to receive it or buy it by the end of February. It's a long time without this subsidy. How much would it cost us if this subsidy weren't available? How much would it cost us? Well, I approve it. Oh well. Mrs. Dominguez Cervantes requests the motion, and Mr. Tamayo seconds it. Everyone, Mr. Tamayo, everyone in favor. Say: I, the motion passes unanimously. The 11th to ratify the agreement for the provision of services between the superintendent of schools of San Diego and the Chula Vista Elementary School District. And this is with the induction program.

072I don't have any direct line. I work for the county, but I don't have any direct line with this. For the same reason, Mr. Tamayo requested it, and Mrs. Dominguez Cervantes seconded it. Everyone in favor. Say: I, the emotion passes unanimously. We need a break. Yes, Tom, let's take a break from 5 minutes and we'll be back at 8:20. Oh, what a scare! Thank you, Jorge. Okay, new employees and employees who have been promoted quickly. Superintendent, community, it is my pleasure to announce our new employees: Mario Cabada, who is a handsome man. Congratulations, Mario! Franky Carbona from Hardy Equipment to a technician. Congratulations, Franky Eugene Gutiérrez, from manager to leader. Congratulations, Guillermo Guzmán Junior, from manager to leader. Congratulations, Verónica Hernández, from yard supervisor to Special Education instruction assistant. Congratulations, Verónica Alejandro Herrera, from locksmith

073mechanic. Congratulations, María de Jesús Méndez, from manager to leader. Congratulations, Pablo Murillo, also from manager to leader. Congratulations, Pablo Carlos Ortiz [Music], from systems analyst. Congratulations, Carlos Pérez, CNS 1 to cn3. Congratulations, Guillermo Robles, from manager to leader. José Luis, from Irrigation Control Specialist to supervisor. And lastly, César. Zapata Olivares also went from van driver to truck driver. Congratulations to our employees. I want to congratulate all our teachers who changed status. 47 Public Hearings. Public hearings offer the public the opportunity to address the board on specific issues. The board will limit the total time for public input at each public hearing point to 20 minutes and speakers will be asked to limit their remarks to 3 minutes and to speak professionally and respectfully. With the board's consent, the chair may increase or decrease the time

074allowed for public comments depending on the number and length of requests to be heard received. We have no ad who wants to address the public hearings. This is to hold a Public Hearing to receive comments on the Chula Vista Educators Agreement, to ratify and amend the agreement with the educators of Chula Vista, to hold a hearing for Article 51 Health, and also to hold a Public Hearing to receive comments on the tentative agreement with the Chula Vista Administrators Association, to ratify the tentative agreement of the association. From Chula Vista administrators regarding Article 17 health benefits, we have questions. First, I want to have a statement that I do need this increase in health benefits. Ah, but I'm trying to understand. Or maybe I didn't understand question C on page two. It asks if the cost

075of the agreement needs budget reductions for the fiscal year, and the answer is no. But then on page 7, there is an increase for certified staff and directors. Dr. Reyes, Mr. Pong, that's right. That statement says that we were able to continue with that 3% from the State reserve and we're going to continue with this going forward. Okay, so you found money elsewhere? Thank you. I want to thank the district director and ACBE for having an agreement that honors the work of families and employees plus one, and for the district to recognize that health care is something that is unfortunately going to get more expensive every day, and every day our employees have cuts because of that need, and it continues to increase. And I'm glad that we were able to do it together and

076that we were creative and thought outside the box and how we can look at benefits from a different perspective because this is something new, something we haven't... Done before. Thank you very much. I want to emphasize something I learned during my meeting with Dr. Reyes preparing for today's meeting. I asked about AACB's negotiation conditions, and they said they didn't negotiate. I asked what I wanted to see in the language, and it also requires organization, mobilization, and motivation. I want to emphasize this because I want to acknowledge the work they did. And with that, I want to approve this item of public hearing. I requested it, and Ms. Dominguez Cervantes seconded the motion. It passes Article 13, Elements of Administrative Action, to approve the revisions to the fiscal year 2425 budget, to approve the first interim

077financial report as of October 31, 2024, and to certify the financial statements for fiscal year 2425. Thank you very much, and good night, President Urgarte, members of the board, Dr. Reyes, members of the community. Today we have for you to review and approve the report, the first interim report. We just transitioned to PeopleSoft; we are all learning about this process. If we look at this, we have adjustments from 16 million to 4 million, and in the We had expenses of 417 million, and there were adjustments of 18 million. The first expense was 436 million. So, with these adjustments, we had expenses that exceeded that amount. So, it's a total deficit of 36 million in our first report. We also have unspent funds, which are commitments of 48.5 million, and restricted funds of 58 million, and

078also our reserves for economic uncertainties, which are 26 million. When we look at our budget, we have to look at our restricted and unrestricted funds separately. In the unrestricted section, we can see that we have less, and we have to make some adjustments there. And in the restricted section, we also have... So, what are some of the changes in the local control formula? Our attendance increased due to Transitional Kindergarten, so we had more attendance. So, we had a total of 2.2 million in the federal section. We are recognizing that these are federal funds. In state revenues, we had more money from community schools, so we had an increase in our revenues, and also in transportation and in our local revenues. These are when we get paid for medical expenses and other things, some reimbursements, and

079also salaries and benefits. Here, books are also included. And materials are $17 million, and this includes school funds, and we're also projecting free textbooks at the end of the school year, as well as devices for students and staff. In services, we have an increase of $1.3 million, and these are medical services, for which we're receiving revenue and also money that we had left over from last year, and it's a total increase of $18 million. For our district commitments, we have security measures, and the replacement of heavy equipment is $3 million. We're also talking about tractors, lawnmowers, and devices for students—a replacement plan for staff and students, and we're doing it through a lease. Textbook replacements— we have some adoptions that we 're taking, and we're also saving for one- time expenses, and this will also

080help us reduce the cuts we need. When we look at our multi-year projection, we can see in the blue section that we're continuing to have a decrease of $ 12 million. This is for our projected $24 to $25 million. This is information from our finance department analyst. We're also monitoring our enrollment, and when we see Our restricted funds may see a reduction from 23 million to 10 million, and this is with respect to one- time funds. Oh god, when we're looking at a multi-year projection, nothing happens, no, it's already over. And with all this, I'll open it up to questions. Yes, on slide number six, it's referring to textbook replacement only. I'm curious, how did we get there to 12 million? Ma'am, can you tell us? As you know, we're preparing to order for next

081year. We're at the end of the cycle for the materials we have now. So, in order to replace our English or Spanish books, we need to be able to buy these for the following years. Determined to ensure that our students have them. They come with the books; all the materials are together. But what's interesting now is that every year these books that come with [Music] are replaced. We're going to continue having these. We also have math, and we also have to have these materials because we're not under any contract for math. So, we're going to spend 12 million between now and June. We're talking only about language and literature and math materials. So, 12 million? No, it's not just for one year. This is for several years because it's a lot. We have to spend

082from the reserve. It's going to be for third through sixth grade. First, it's 8 million. How much did we spend in the last two years on science textbooks? It was for fifth and sixth grade, they still don't use it. I want to see that strategic plan then. I hope to see it here soon. Thank you. We have 12 million for textbooks, but in the previous year we had 17.5 million for books. What's the difference? The 17 million is for Benchmark, which is the language and literature curriculum, and the 12 million is for the following adoptions, which is what Ms. Carol mentioned. The 17 million is for... if I understand how this works. It's not just Benchmark. The printers are from the district, or teachers can bring their own printers. They are HP printers; there are

083some cheap ones, there are better ones. If I'm donating printers, will the district cover the ink for the printer, or do I have to donate a standard printer? If you can donate an approved one, if you go and buy a Canon printer, they will be responsible for buying the ink, and our technician will help you install it, but we won't... Thank you for your support. I do n't want anyone to be confused on slide number five. Yes, the numbers are correct, but I want to know that what you have is real. Thank you. I just wanted to make sure, but I didn't want any of us to be confused. Thank you, Mr. Pong, for your presentation. The motion was requested by Mr. Tamayo and seconded by Ms. Cervantes. Everyone in favor. Say: Are you accepting

084the revisions to the fiscal year? Say: The motion passes unanimously. Article B, subject to the approval of the board of directors, the provisional appointments described in Stat. 9223 of the board, approve the vacancy, schedule and process for the selection and appointment of members by Vision of the board for position A and position C, and schedule a special meeting. If you could please tell us what we can do, either to appoint or offer special elections. Can I say something, Mr. President? I want to make sure that this is emphasized because, as the agenda says, it says appointment, it doesn't say that we haven't decided one or the other. Thank you very much. The PowerPoint presentation... When a vacancy arises, when we are already here... No, it is my understanding that in the past few days... Once

085the resignations were made, we have a 60-year period where the board has the right to make a provisional appointment that will be effective until 2026. That's one option: to make a provisional appointment. Or the second is to take special action. If the members don't take either action, then the authority goes to the County Superintendent. And then they have to hold a special election. The reality is that one is a very expensive proposal because you have two vacancies, and I think—I don't know if the district has already done it—but it's probably more than a million dollars. So it's 1.2 to 2.9 million dollars. That's an estimate. Thank you very much. So it's very, very expensive. But before talking here with the board, the reality is that an appointment has to be made, and it has to

086be a unanimous decision of the three members. And if it's going to be a provisional appointment, it's in statute 9223 and also in the government section of the Government Code 509154. Those are the key sections of the code, but in fact, if a provisional appointment goes What will happen is that you have to be motivated and it has to happen within 60 days, but then your statute 92 23 gives you the option of what you can do, and it gives you two options, Ms. Cervantes, and the other is where you have an application process where you have candidates who can be a subcommittee member appointed by the board of directors, and there is also an interview process that will happen during a board meeting. All these things happen in an open session, and I think

087the key here is that we could share the steps with you, or I can review them, but what is important is that once you identify the process, the subcommittee, the subcommittee working with the superintendent, perhaps working with us, and know what the procedures are, I think the key is to go to your website and publish it so that people who are interested know what the process is and also see the timeline, etc., before the board of directors makes a provisional appointment, perhaps also a subcommittee, but also ensure So that the people who are submitting their applications are eligible to create. What are the application requirements? What information do they want from the candidates? Their qualifications, their experiences, their points. I recommend that you announce it because, as we said, this is a timeline, and we're

088going to make a provisional appointment. You should consider submitting your application and having a meeting where you'll review and discuss the candidates and interview them. I want to make sure that I'm not the one making the sound, and also that the board debates and talks about the candidates, and there are opportunities for public comment, and then there's a vote, and it has to be unanimous. And something I'm going to add is that although the board has the right to make a provisional appointment, after 10 days of making that decision, there has to be publication in three public places in the newspaper of who you're nominating. Also, members of the public can request a special election, but it requires 1.5 percent or 5% of this. I'm not going to go into the details, and even if

089the board makes an appointment, a special election can be called. If you have more questions, I can answer them. Ask then. My opinion, and I'm not a lawyer, the way we listed this on the agenda, it should have been B and C because they are two different agenda items. I think it gives the public enough information about what's happening and the different options. Then, when we come to the decisions, we can distinguish them as two different agenda items, if that's what you want. Yes, thank you. I can share with the public that I sent several questions to Dr. Reyes to clarify some of these things so that you can tell the public what you shared with us. I also want to share with the public that these are not our legal advisors. We hired an

090independent firm to help us because we want to provide transparency. We are lawyers who are hired by you, but we do not advise the board. [Music] Our law firm is Adams & Silva. That's what I was trying to say. What we want to do is have a different firm in this case. Okay, thank you. Any other questions? We need you to stay. Thank you. Needs water, a break, thank you. We have four people who want to speak. Manny Rubio. Good evening, Tamayo Cervantes cabinet. My name is Manny Rubio. I am a father of two students in the district, and my wife and I belong to committees and volunteer. I just want to say that this is a great opportunity for this district. We definitely have two vacancies on this board. It's an opportunity for the

091district, and what I want to say is that there is an opportunity for the members of this district to create a legacy of what comes next. And by this, I mean we have to follow through on the decisions of many things that are happening. I think there is an opportunity for us, outside of politics, favors, and self- interest, to appoint someone whose sole interest is always the students and families of this district. I think this is an opportunity for us as an organization, and I say "we" because I am a regular part of this district. I think this is an opportunity for us to do something and really show the whole county that we are focused on our students and families. I am sure there will be a number of qualified candidates, and at the

092end of the day, what we will have is clarity. that the two of us who are appointed... And I understand that this is an opportunity for an election, and I understand why the opportunity would be... It would be better to go for an appointment, that hasn't been lost, or anyone else... But again, this is an opportunity for us, truly. I know that many families want this District to succeed, and I believe it is an opportunity. So I hope that this board recognizes it and takes it into account. Karen Ramirez Dominguez, we have no relationship... says Mrs. Cervantes. Good evening, members. My name is Karen Ramirez. I am here, as we heard, today a special election is almost 3 million dollars. I would also like to put myself forward for that appointment with my background in

093child development and also as a playground supervisor in this district, and also as a mother of two children in this District. One that combines hands-on experience, an investment in this District so that this District will be successful. In my previous campaign, I had 20,000 points. I was honored to also receive the support of community members. Yes, I believe that going with an appointment is better, although we already know that a special election is very good, but it goes... To delay the process and also increase expenses, an appointment allows us to have and focus. If I am appointed, I will get there immediately. I have listened to the parents. Today I have called, I have sent emails, and one of the things I want to do is be available. I want to collaborate. I want to

094have communication and collaboration with the families of the educators. I appreciate you considering me for this position. Thank you, Elizabeth. Good evening, members of the board. I am Elizabeth, and I am here to nominate myself as a candidate for board member. I have lived in Chula for 13 years and graduated from Oran High School. I am very passionate about our schools. I would love the opportunity to contribute to this mission. I have diplomas in child development and mental health. Many members of my family are military in this country, including my mom and dad. In fact, my family's father is still serving. His service and the values my parents taught me are respect for humanity and also conversion to Islam. I value our values. I come from generations of hardworking Americans. We share a common desire

095for the education of our children. As an educator, including Children with disabilities, intellectual and physical disabilities—I understand the obstacles these children face, barriers that go beyond this experience. This experience strengthened my commitment to supporting the diverse needs of students. Every child should feel valued and supported. I want to emphasize that my commitment to children's rights is not just an abstract value; as a community, it is our duty to make it happen. I seek your support. My name is Elizabeth E., and thank you for your time. Good morning, everyone, said the superintendent. It's a pleasure to be here. My name is Ina, and I am a mother of three children. They all attend Chula Vista Middle and High School. I am here to express my interest. I have been a resident of Chula Vista since 2009,

096and I am a chemical engineer working in the pharmaceutical industry for the past 17 years. For the last 3 years, I was also a substitute teacher at a non-profit organization in Chula Vista. And of all these roles, I am a very proud mother here in Chula Vista. As a parent, I am very involved in my children's education. It is very important to encourage our students to have successful careers. I appreciate everything you do here, and I truly thank everyone who is currently... at the board or working behind the scenes, and they are truly supporting our children here in the Chula Vista district, giving me the opportunity to serve here. It's my passion. We do n't have any more speakers or people who want to address the board. As I shared earlier, this agenda item doesn't

097allow discussion of the special election or appointment option, and it would be important if it says we have the three options available on this agenda. It doesn't have to be detailed, so we can choose. We have to take the position of what we have to do. Is anyone in favor of an election? I don't want to say in favor of an election, but if we're not going to agree, then it's going to be a special election, right? And because of the cost of a special election, I would say an appointment process with very clear guidelines, as mentioned by the legal department, and that it be called two different agenda items so it's not a motion of two. It could be one item with two vacancies, or they could be individual motions. I agree that the

098election is expensive. I agree with the doctor; we could have done it individually, or we could have... Doing it as a group, but I prefer the fact that when we're doing this, and there are two vacancies, well, you know what I mean. So we have to be very careful with that, and looking at those options, we can talk about it. I like the idea of ​​a subcommittee, I like the idea of ​​the questions, and I agree not to be on that committee if it were a nomination of Domínguez Cervantes and Tamayo. I have faith that you can do it and all those questions, but I'm open to a conversation here. The reason I'm requesting this is that there are only three of us, not 20. The three of us were going to be the officers.

099For me, I wasn't volunteering to be the president, but for this, for the selection of the nominees, I think, let's say, I nominate number three and number seven. Maybe you might be okay with number three but not with number seven, or vice versa. I think that if we're all in, if we can all agree on one in particular, one who goes all the way up, then we nominate that person, or we talk about the three most important ones. Then we have one vacancy filled, and we move on to the next one. An option would be that in the application process we ask, "I don't know, it makes a difference, but I just want to be in seat number five." Or maybe they choose two. I do n't know. It could be something specific for that

100individual. They would have to take the oath, then you can appoint them, but if they don't, they ca n't vote, Madam President. What I'm hearing is that the board is trying to avoid a special election. So what Ms. Dominguez Cervantes is asking is to list each of the vacant seats individually. I think it's something we could work on because even though we have a discussion and a process with legal counsel, when we're discussing who to appoint in the end... Oh, I ripped out my earpiece. There can be a consensus, right? On that point, that could be something. I don't see it as a precaution. The short answer is: they have to have two special meetings. One is for the subcommittee to go back and see what the application process is. Then you have to see

101what the 60-day deadline is. You have to outline the process. of the application process and give them enough time, and then establish a meeting where you'll be reviewing the paperwork of the applicants, and maybe at that meeting you could call for a vote. It might be possible for the board to discuss this today, and that only at one meeting are the finalists interviewed. I believe the board can provide sufficient guidance for you, Doctor, and then we'll work with you depending on what the board wants. And then the website will be posted, and then a meeting will be held. We've been here until 1:00 AM, and the lawyer responds, "I'm going to sleep." At 9:45 AM, I'm also hearing that if we have to make a decision, and if one doesn't agree after many votes, then

102it automatically goes to the County Superintendent, and she holds a special election. So if we don't agree, then it will go to an election. [Music] Right? Then the board can take a motion to initiate an appointment process and have a subcommittee, and Assigning the members of the subcommittee. I request a motion for the board to take over the appointment process and create a two- member subcommittee to develop the process. I'm confused about how to direct the process. Can we do it here? I request a motion that we take over the appointment process. Since we are voting on the appointment process, the motion passes unanimously. Now, to direct the superintendent to develop an application for interested persons or candidates, what I heard is to direct the superintendent, which is consistent with the law, Dr. Reyes. Where

103does the committee come in? In this scenario, the subcommittee will review the applicants, and then we will work with legal counsel to generate the process. How are we going to do with these candidates? Direct the superintendent to develop the application and publish the process. I have someone to second that. Everyone in favor, say: I. The motion passes unanimously. Oh, I request a motion for this board to create a subcommittee, and that it be Ms. Domínguez Cervantes and Mr. Tamayo. Does anyone second that? Everyone in favor, say: I. Mr. Tamayo requested it, and President Ugarte seconded it. It was unanimous. Next, what else do we need? A date for the special meeting? We already have a date, January 17th, as a special meeting, an extraordinary meeting, at 6 p.m. to review and interview candidates. I believe

104that reviewing the eligibility requirements is something the subcommittee will do. January 17th at 6 p.m. will be the interview process and the selection. And there's one more motion. Delia, that's fine. January 17th at 6 p.m., we have a special meeting to interview candidates. If Dr. Reyes is going to develop an application and publish it, we have time for them to return it. I want to see that we have enough time for January 17th because there has to be a deadline that applicants have to submit, and also enough time for Mr. Tamayo and me to review the eligibility. How much time does the subcommittee need? Two weeks. I have more time than you. You have a lot of work for the subcommittee to review the applicants. If we have 1,000, yes. Well, it depends. We can

105publish the We can publish it this Wednesday, the 18th, because it's the holidays. We can give three weeks; it closes on the 8th, and that gives you a week and a half to meet and review. I'm going; I don't work, but I'm going to visit between December 27th and return on the 31st. The motion is to establish an extraordinary meeting on January 17th at 6 p.m. to conduct an interview and select. Mr. Tamayo requests it, and Ms. Dominguez seconds it. And there's one more motion in statute 9223. There are two options: one is to have an application process, which I believe is what you're describing in your deliberations. That's option one. Or option two is to accept nominations at a public meeting. So it seems that action one is where the discussion is happening. So

106this has to be amended. Yes, well then. Give me the correct version. With that, you're good. Okay, since we're good on that, I'm going to make a motion for the elective board to use number one for a provisional appointment, and the subcommittee of the board moved it. Mr. Tamayo seconded it, Mrs. Cervantes, everyone in favor, say I before 94. Thank you very much, first and second reading, review of the board's bylaws at 9200, Dr. Reyes, this is the one we talked about last month, I was fine with that. So Mr. Tamayo requests it, Mrs. Cervantes seconds it, then, calendar of reports to the board. Yes, last month I asked for information on the number of instruction assistants who were retiring. It was sent in a board update on Friday. No, but I'm going to do

107it this Friday. Thank you, but I think you had to include it with this month's report because I want the people to hear and see if you can present a report. I want the public to know how we are running our business. So you want it included in your report? Salary comparison? Yes, I sent it. But you want it to be an agenda item for salary comparison? You two talked, right, and did an analysis? Yes, in my weekly report I sent San Isidro National and Chula Vista. And compare where we are, and I can present it. I want to present it at a meeting of The board of directors, I want to share this with my colleagues, with the unions, and with our workers. So, at the next meeting we have, they'll share the comparison

108chart, and also the Sweet Water Authority. The news was about the water, and we've been asking for this for several months now: to put solar panels on the water reservoir. And the truth is, they come and take the water to go and put out fires, and also the concern about the particles, how it's going to affect our water. I think we're already starting to do something to test, to do laboratory tests on our water. Yes, I had a meeting with the person from Sweet Water Authority. I told them that we had a concern. Someone on the board had a concern about the solar panels. We were doing water tests, but our tests were for very different things. It was for... what's it called, what's in the sweets? We can bring a contract for the next

109meeting. And Dr. Reyes, you were going to report on the Tijuana drainage. You were going to have a meeting, and we haven't had anything in October and November. This last meeting was canceled. This last Friday, they canceled the meeting. So, at this moment, the last meeting that... We were supposed to have it, they canceled it, and we're going to meet after the holidays. I'd like to see some very intense participation. We want to see the standards we 're using. Okay, thank you. The standards we had before, we talked briefly. Obviously, the past isn't where we're living now. After COVID, the kids came back with a lot of behavioral problems, and oh my God, I don't know how they can do their other jobs when they have to try to save a child from themselves because

110they're running away. We have to review that, and also with the achievement plans we just received, I think we can see—okay, okay—recalibrate. Where are we? What can we do differently? We're seeing new numbers. For example, Harborside didn't lose its double- investment school status; they have fewer students. So I think we have to look at all our schools, and that was one of my intentions, but I don't know who can be involved. Have someone from our administrators' association help us? I can help. Well, I think that's what I do, but to see what we can do to reevaluate this, President Ugarte, reevaluate to have an assistant principal supported by the district that qualifies a school to have an assistant principal. Because if The current standards, what we're taking into account, one of the things we're doing

111is having these discussions. We're going to have different scenarios, and everything has a price, and we're going to show it to the board. We have to maximize what we have; it includes a physical impact. If we're using what we're using to measure right now, well, the numbers have changed. I think that, like the other members who are no longer here, well, it's going to be Tamayo. And I, what's happening with the cell phone policy? And we've also talked before about the Title One funds. We needed to see how much was left on the board. There are instances where a school or schools didn't use their Title One. Could you send me that, please? That's all. Thank you very much. I want to ask when Chula Vista Hills is going to have its drinking fountain with

112quality water. And I think water quality is something that is a basic need and that the district should pay for. No, the school... I do n't remember... The next school year is when the cell phone policy is taken. There are some schools that don't have problems. And Jenny Randon invited me to the Metro Hall of Fame conference on November 21. 453 turkeys were distributed. Most of them went to Vesta Square, but Barbie and Osi made this happen. I think we cleaned out a lot of Walmarts for those turkeys, and Mr. Romero was magnificent. We had donors with Andrea, and we want to thank her. The families were so happy to allow people to have dignity at a time that is so special for them. We have an idea for the turkey in the future—to distribute

113turkeys in the future. Thank you, Mrs. Dominguez Cervantes. This time of year is always exciting for the Human Resources department to put the human lament into the community. So the Human Resources department was very excited when you had this idea, and in conversations that you and I had, we talked about how this could be an ongoing thing. [Music] We had to do this very quickly, but we could make this an annual event and maybe make it bigger. And some of the ideas we're sharing could be like a 5K race to get the community involved and see how we can expand it—not just the turkey, but the additional items that come with Thanksgiving dinner— and have an annual celebration. Thank you so much for considering the Human Resources department. I'm still sore from carrying all these

114turkeys, Mr. Romero. Thank you so much. Tell him thank you. And I also visited Rise School and they had a great time. Magnificent! Thank you so much for inviting me, Dr. Reyes, and at McMillen School. I was also at your holiday celebration, and you have a magnificent teacher. The children were singing and playing musical instruments. Thank you. I hope everyone has a wonderful Christmas holiday with their children, their loved ones, and their families. Stay warm and healthy. Thank you so much. I want to thank Mrs. Dominguez Cervantes for arranging this. I think this was magnificent. There's nothing more to communicate; I think that's enough. But I want to wish everyone a Merry Christmas and happy holidays. Rochel, no more texts, no more emails, please. But really, take care of yourselves and enjoy this time with

115your family, and I'll see you next year. I want to say that the Starlight Parade was very fun and very cold. The children had a lot of fun. The children really did use a lot of hand sanitizer. It was very fun, and I like this and always have suggestions for improvement. It was much better this year than last year. Very fun, lots of people. Yes, I want to wish everyone a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year as well. And also a Happy New Year. Oh, very happy! So we have three weeks and I've enjoyed two, and sometimes it's very difficult, also for the person who is organizing everything and making sure it's magical for all the children. And I want to thank Mrs. Dominguez Cervantes for the Thanksgiving turkeys, and I hope her muscles

116are recovering. And hopefully we can continue doing this and expand it to all the schools. Thank you, and see you in January. I just want to thank everyone. We're finishing our second quarter in four days. I thank everyone for all you do, and I wish you all happy holidays and the best for 2025. The next Chula Vista Elementary School District Board of Trustees meeting will be held on January 22nd at 4:00 for a closed session and at 6:00 for an open session. We have a motion to adjourn the meeting. I have the motion. May you second it? Yes, I second it. Mr. Dominguez Cervantes, I second it. Everyone in favor? I'm excited. And if anyone says no...

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.