001e e e welcome to the organizational meeting of the Board of Education of the Chula Vista Elementary School District the meeting is now in order Dr Reyes good afternoon everyone we'll start with the oath uh administering the oath to the newly elected board members if I can have uh so we'll do them one one by one so if we can start with trustee president uh Lucy Ugarte if you can come forward and if you I would like to invite president of the cve uh Miss Rosie Martinez to administer the oath raise your right hand St congratulations [Applause] and next I would like to call trustee Francisco Tamayo and I would also like to call uh CV president M Rosie Martinez to ad administer the oath e congratulations [Applause] I don't know would you like to
002come [Applause] tra May would you like to say anything there's a lot of work so let's let's get to it that's it same thank you all right congratulations to you two look forward to working with you again thank you all right all board members are present we will now approve the agenda do I have a motion second moved by truste too seconded by truste dominga santes all those in favor I motion carries unanimously we will now conduct the annual organizational business of the Chula Vista Elementary School District Board of Education two one elect officers two appoint superintend attendant as secretary and three adopt the dates time and place for the regular board meetings in 2025 the board May um vote on each item individually or all at three at once if voting for each sub
003item individually there will be three motions and seconds Dr Reyes thank you so correct so this time every year we do what is called organizational uh business which is basically basically the election of officers which includes president vice president and clerk as president ugar mentioned before the motion can be done for individually you can vote for each position individually or you can do it as a slate and so after we do that then the next item will be appointing me as the secretary and then the next item will be adopting the dates time and place for the the regular board meetings for the year Madam president I would like to offer a slate as I have done in the previous years um for president I would like to nominate um trusty Ugarte for vice president
004trusty Tamayo and clerk uh trusty Delia cantes doming sorry is there a second I second any discussion no hearing none all those in favor of the Slate president ugar vice president Tayo and clerk Dominguez cantes please say I I I motion carries unanimously Madam president I would like to make a motion to appoint uh the superintendent as uh secretary to the board second motion by truste too seconded by truste Dominguez santes all those in favor of uh having uh having superintendent Reyes as secretary please say I I I motion carries unanimously Madame President I would like to make a motion to adopt the dates time and place for the regular board meetings as stated in the document i' I'd like to make a revision to one of the dates all L I would like to
005move the April 9th meeting to the following week I believe that would be April 16th uh Mr BR any issues with budget or anything that we have to turn in okay HR okay Delia do you have any issues with that uh I I don't but we do need to note that it's 6 weeks makees some meetings six weeks like later that's fine by me okay I'll I'll accept the friendly amendment to change uh the dates of April 9th to April 16th okay and do I have a second second moved by trusty too seconded by trusty Dominguez cantes all those in favor of the dates with the April meeting amended please say I I I I motion carries unanimously all right oral Communications the oral communication section provides the public with an opportunity to address the
006board on close session items only persons wishing to be heard May attend in person and should complete a request to be heard card and submit it to the recording secretary before the start of the meeting speakers are requested to limit their remarks to three minutes and speak in a respectful and professional manner the board shall limit the total time for public input on each topic to 20 minutes with board consent the president may increase or decrease the time allowed for public comments depending on the number of persons wishing to be heard no board action can be taken do have any speakers we have no speakers we will now adjourn to close session in accordance with the following government code section 35491 D and 54957.6 collective bargaining employee negot cations agency negotiators Adam Silva and MCN
007LLP employee organizations chista classified employees organization Chula Vista Educators non-represented employees administrators Association Chula Vista government code section 54957 B1 Public Employee displ discipline dismissal and release government code section 54957 Public Employee appointment employment title principal and government code section 54956.9 D1 conference with legal councel superior court of the State of California County of San Diego case number 37-20 24- dc- wm- CTL e e e Clos session announcements will be made by clerk Dominguez santes on government code section 54957 Public Employee appointment title principal 2 Carl H Kellog school on the motion by member tomayo second by member Dominguez santes the board approved the employment of Elizabeth carzoli as principal to at Carl excuse me at Carl H Kellogg Elementary School by the following vote a Lucy Ugarte Francisco Tamayo deia Dominguez [Applause] cantes on
008the government code section 54956.9 D1 conference with legal councel suprior Court of the State of California County of San Diego case number 37-20 24- dc- WM dctl on the motion of to Mayo second by Dominguez cantes the board took action to approve the settlement agreement concerning employee number 201924 981 by the following vote by the following vote I the A's Francisco to Mayo and deia Dominguez cantes recusal luy Ugarte due to conflict of interest that's it thank you the Open session of the regular meeting of the Chula Vista Elementary School District Board of Education is now in order welcome everyone all members are present Mr Romero if you will lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance please I Al to the FL of the United States of America and to the for stands one nation
009under God indivisible with liy and justice for thank you we will now approve the agenda do I have a motion so move second mooved by vice president de Mayo seconded by clerk Dominguez sedantes all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously special recognition Awards and honors presentation of the district winners of the holiday greeting card competition Dr Reyes so this is a very exciting time uh so there was a holiday C green card competition that was conducted our uh our schools to encourage student artists to provide artwork for the district uh District's official holiday greting card uh the judging of the entries by District staff took place through a gallery of student artwork at the district office the first place winner artwork was used for the district's official holiday card and the district's communication
010channels recognize the second and third place winners so for our third place from Parkview we have Riley George Kapa Perez [Applause] you and per [Applause] all right second place winner from Olympic View Avery Lee karms [Applause] per [Applause] and the first place winner from heading camp we have Ariana Elizabeth Tantra [Applause] yes [Applause] board comments it takes a brave person to put their artwork out there I just want to um appreciate that you were brave enough to share with us because it's amazing work thank you very much likewise I'm I'm always amazed uh every year with the quality of work that it's coming out of our students especially with art um it's really tough to decide which one is first place I mean they're all all three of these are good um I mean I
011I I love all of them and but congratulations for for sharing with us your talent right because I think that that's something that um it's important to be able to share your talent but also one of the things that we would get to see as I'm a member of the California Coast Credit Union um every time every time I go to that bank I see that card there so no matter what branch in chil Vista that you go to you will see that artwork displayed and it that's a great advertisement especially for for a young kid to to help them get inspired to continue doing this artwork and continue sharing their talents so congratulations with uh to the winners and thank you for sharing your talents can I add more one more thing please they
012might be our future mural right uh every year here um I I Marvel at the work of our students and um as we were W I was looking at social media as the voting was taking place and I could see all of the participants artwork that was displayed um and it was an incredible job and I would have been proud to have any of these cards represent us for the district um and congratulations to those of you that did win um first second and third place because it was I'm sure it was very tough for the judges I watch them walk around the table via social media um and so uh and our names go on them so and cvd so we're very proud of the work that you did and we're very proud to
013have this as our official Christmas card for the district thank you for your work and [Applause] congratulations all right recognition of the Country Music Association foundation's music teacher of Excellence recipient Miss Carol thank you president Ugarte so tonight I am very excited to tell you a little bit first about the music teacher of excellence in um and we have one here from chil Vista the music teacher of Excellence is the Country Music Association foundation's commitment to the music teacher who exemplify ex excellence in the field each year 30 honores are selected for their commitment to Bringing highquality music programming to their students and local community honores receive a $5,000 award to be split evenly between their music classroom and personal use on Tuesday September 20 I'm sorry September 17th 2024 Casas music teacher Jonathan Seligman
014was awarded this honor at the historic Country Music Hall of Fame in downtown Nashville Tennessee for his outstanding work and dedication to the chil Vista Elementary School District students so we are so proud of Mr Suman and appreciate all the years of service that he has provided for the students and Community both at Casas and for chist Elementary School District so on behalf of the board then we'll be presenting him with a certificate Mr Suman you want to come on up [Applause] board comments Mr svin you'll have to share it was wild yes thank you very much we'll look forward to awarding you next year too congratulations I mean that the work that you've been doing not not just this year but throughout the years because you've been here several times in the board receiving
015other types of recognition so I want to thank you for everything that you do and not just the recognition that you're you're winning uh and that we get to plug our our district in there but also the work that you're doing on behalf of students because that's really really the the the winners of all the hard work is those students right the passion that you bring to the table and show sharing that passion with the students is at least showing them that there's other opportunities outside the academic world into music right so thank you for sharing that that passion with our students and thank you for everything you're doing I um whenever I go over the agenda with Dr Rey as um we go through each item and I looked at this and I said
016why why is the Country Music Awards on our agenda and and he said he explained it to me and then I saw your name and I said okay that makes sense because I see you out here with all the students I see you at different performances and uh the way that our students respond to you um you're welld deserving of this award and um the fact that you're making our district famous all the way to Nashville um is is like a my uh colleague said it's it's very important that um the in our profession as teachers that we get this kind of recognition because what you're doing is truly making sure that our students have a love of music and that they'll carry that with them for the rest of their lives and even when
017we forget sometimes they're going to come back to you when they're old they're they're older and grown and say that you made a difference so thank you this made sense and congratulations okay recognition of Chula Vista Elementary School District staff Dr Reyes so I'm really honored to recognize someone who has contributed so much to education so much to our district and for so many years and I'm talking about the one that we all love and respect relle Carol so [Applause] R so relle has been uh at chest Elementary for 36 years however she actually been in education for 40 plus years and if you can think about the impact that she's made to so many students thousands of students throughout her uh life and education the impact of so many staff members and parents and
018the reality is that relle is someone that truly believes truly believes in the power of Education you know she has always you know she always says I'm a teacher at heart but uh yes she's a teacher at heart she's a coach she's a mentor she's instructional leader and most importantly she's a friend to so many to so many of us relle I know you're going to be um retiring soon you're going to be having a great time in your new chapter but I can tell you that we're going to be miss you you know you're going to be missed truly missed um you are leaving a huge void and uh but on the other hand you're leaving so many things behind that are in place that we will continue to honor your work and your
019legacy so congratulations [Applause] there good [Applause] board comments I've only been here two years but miss Rochelle the seeds that you've planted in so many individuals from my grandson my daughters other teachers your colleagues it it's it shows your passion for what you do and the kind heart that you have there's just no hiding it you're a beautiful person you will be missed not just for what you brought to the school district as far as curriculum but for who you are there we will build on what you've planted but you will be sort [Applause] missed I mean where to start 36 years in the district the am the amount of lives of students that you have touch the amount of lives of Stu me staff members that you have changed and improved it's it's an
020amazing journey I mean uh we've been here for for a little while um but you know it's it's some we definitely I'm sad that you're leaving because you have brought so much to this District so much knowledge so much care because if I can sum up everything is that you cared and because of that a lot of things happened and a lot of good things continue to happen and we will like my colleague said we'll continue to build upon what you your legacy has been in this District because nobody leaves a district after 36 years and not leave a legacy I mean your commitment to our students to our our population especially it's it's a tremendous gift that you have given us and it's a tremendous gift GI for me to have known you and
021shared um some of your wisdom with me throughout the years so thank you so much and congratulations on your news [Applause] job wow I want to be like you um I first came when I first arrived on the board I know a lot about secondary I know a lot lot about curriculum in the secondary I know what it means to teach in secondary and I know that when teachers say that you guide them and you teach them and you influence them in a gentle way that that's true because when I came to this board and I was learning about curriculum in the elementary school district you never made me feel like I was not enough or didn't know you taught me what I needed to know and you were gentle and you were were kind
022and it I I felt like I could do what I was doing right and so I know that whenever someone comes to me and says Rochelle helped me I know I know what that means because you help me a lot you help me understand the difference between what I knew and what I needed to know um but I think you do work a little too hard 36 years is a very long time plus 36 plus I hear people tell me that you're helping them at all hours of the night emailing them back and returning phone calls and um you even told me that if you I if I needed help with something to call you after you're gone and I'm like see you're working too much and and hopefully you as you uh scaffold your
023way into retirement um it becomes more of a fun fun place and you stop taking our calls that's my My Hope for you um because but we I think we know that you probably won't so I I appreciate everything I appreciate that you've been so helpful and supportive to all these people um to us included and I'm going to miss you at all the events because I run to you so that I'm not standing there out there by myself um and um you you made a huge difference um I think we saw that today I think we see that now and I think that you're going to continue to see that so congratulations on your new step in in this path great [Applause] job all right onward communication to the Board of Education Chul Vista
024classified employees organization Miss Angela Reed oh I'm not turned on oh thank you for that okay I'll start again but I am going to need a little extra time as we enter the winter holidays I believe it is a good time to reflect on what we've collectively changed for this current school year and assess on what we can improve the nearest and dearest part for me has been the inclusion of dedicated professional development training and resources to better enable classified support across the board as we carry out the rewarding work of educating students as I've I iterated more times than I care to remember more capable and knowledgeable classified staff is a force multiplier because highly trained classified employees require less daily input and by extension would not require redirection and adjustment at the cost
025of student instructional minutes furthermore it demonstrates that the district is invested in its employees and empowers all staff by by raising capabilities and knowledge while I am very happy that time to accomplish professional development has been implemented I believe that the execution is fundamentally flawed and as a result will not lead to the improvements that it could and should while time to train and locations to support the training is beneficial and necessary it is insufficient to merely create an opportunity for Effective training like with many things there needs to be an overarching plan to make sense of this it is useful to think of training in four tiers which I'll briefly walk through to help make sense of where I'm going the first tier is knowledge which is to say that it is the terminology
026and background Concepts and the topic or field what is important to realize is that tier one is only valuable in so far as it provides a common Baseline to recipients but it provides almost no value to towards the developing the trainee it's a stepping stone yet it is unable to provide more than that unfortunately to this point most if not all of our training has been at this primary level the next tier is for practical skills and the purpose is to practice the implementation of the skills and knowledge from tier one such skills enable complex reaction-based implementation of the knowledge and the skills from tier one in Short no knowing what to do is not the same as how to do it for example I may know that a fire hose must be connected pressurized
027and routed to the scene of a fire I may not know how to pick the right hose might incorrectly attach it to the system or pressurize it prematurely knowing about doing a thing does not necessarily mean that the trainee is able to actually accomplish that thing tier three implementation is a regression of the previous tier on practical skills the purpose of tier three is to put the individual skills learned together in a complex environment to demonstrate the ability to utilize the correct practical skills on the fly as well as improving the performance of the skills to do this effectively requires the most difficult of the tiers the fourth critically important tier is assessment simply doing any tier is insufficient and will provide precious little return on investment to develop knowledge skills and ability really requires
028two essential things first what did we do well this allows de emphasis on some of the tier one items for the next time through the train doe assess revised cycle ideally to make room for second what can or should we do better this input helps create effective changes to our plan for the next cycle to get better at doing what is need needed most by now you probably notice that this is an outlier this outlier is circular ideally even at the outset you need some level of tier four assessment to know where to start I would argue that even for the first time through we have initial tier 4 inputs these inputs are internal as in self-identified areas of weakness from the employees themselves and external colleagues staff and supervisor identified areas for improvement as
029determined by direct feedback evaluations or identified problem areas within the confines of the professional development plan I realize that this is a challenging proposal yet I also realize its vital importance the majority of our professional development to this point has been at the tier T tier one level without I might add an assessment based input on what would be best for the training the first step needs to be an assessment phase across the district each of the classifications must utilize internal and external assessment to determine what to focus are limited yet valuable professional development resources upon from there training should focus on identified knowledge skills and abilities the ksas from there those ksas should be implemented and over time assessed to determine if improvements are needed or if different ksas should be addressed during the
030next cycle this cycle of training implementation assessment and Improvement is development anything less is merely placing information in front of people and hoping they'll know what to do with it such an approach provides little value and often devolves into presentation of things that the recipient already knows it does not improve performance and by extension would not contribute to better student learning I am imploring you the school board to direct cve SD to sit at the table with cvco to discuss the muu on training mentoring and professional growth signed in June of 2023 so we can create and Implement a robust professional development program for all classified employees thank you thank you Chul Vista Educators Miss Rosie Martinez good evening it is a very exciting night of a lots of Celebration um it was wonderful to
031see the room of of previous and current CBD employees here to honor Rochelle Carol on her retirement she truly has been a pillar for this district and her dedication and commitment leave behind a legacy of service professionalism and genuine care for the staff and students that have benefited from her expertise it has been my privilege and honor to work with you I have learned so much from you and you will always continue to be my inspiration I also want to uh congratulate Jonathan on his recognition from the CMA foundation and um I've had the privilege to see him during a presentation with his students and have so much admiration for his ability to bring such quality instruction to the students and allow them access to the Arts congratulations also to Patty montoy and her retirement
032I was lucky enough to work with Patty at Harborside where she has been so much more than a secretary she has been the heart of that school for many many years leaving a school or District that has played such an important part of our Lives is not only difficult for the person leaving but also for those Left Behind to continue the work especially when the change is midy year this is the case at Kellogg where principal Lisa paricio has been such a positive addition to the school Community I'm confident that the new principal approved tonight will also provide Kellogg with the needed stability and support that they deserve anyone who knows me knows the special place that Harborside holds in my heart I could not be happier to know that Mr aparicio will now lead
033the work there I know that he is a strong supporter of Community Schools he understands the needs of that community and has the tools to um strengthen the work that's currently happening there on behalf of cve I extend our full support in this transition there are a few items on the agenda tonight that I also want to highlight one is the conversion of 27 temporary teachers into probationary status it has been a challenge to have so many teachers dedicated to this District while continuing year after year to be brought back in a temporary status we want to recognize the district for hearing our advocacy on behalf of those who have served this district for so many years and having this be a factored to be considered for this conversion cve and cvd bargaining teams have
034been meeting and I am pleased to let you know that it is going very well tonight we are very excited to have on the agenda for your approval our health benefits article we have worked hard to ensure that our members who cover their family members and their insurance will be given some relief in their outof pocket costs we thank the district for recognizing this need and being open to our proposal we are very close to finalizing the rest of our open articles and are confident that we will be done soon one of the articles that we have been focused on is safety you have been hearing month after month both from staff and parents that this has been a huge area of concern we know that this is a priority that needs to be addressed
035another big challenge has been around Staffing and special education we are excited at the opportunity to bring in new staff to our district through the signing bonus that you are voting on tonight we feel that this will help alleviate some of the challenges being faced by unfilled positions also it is a great opportunity for our current teachers who hold a special ed credential that are currently in General Ed positions to take advantage of this bonus and as we close out the first half of this year we are proud of the work that we have done so far but know that there's still so much more to do we look forward to continuing our collaboration with District leadership and serving our students in the meantime we all needed deserve a happy and restful holiday season I
036wish you and all the chil Vista Community a good break and a happy holiday season thank you thank you administrators Association Chula Vista Miss Teresa Corona good evening to all uh tonight I want to begin with addressing the cvesd aacv aacv agreement although this agreement was just finalized in July 2024 it should serve as an important foundation for how we collaborate as president of aacv I have stated on several occasions that we seek to work in professional partnership with the district one way to work as professional Partners is to work within our agreement in all areas addressed in the agreement as a principal I often reference the cve and CV CEO agreements in my day-to-day work whether I'm looking something up reviewing terms or a checking with colleagues in District departments on interpretation of the
037contracts I do my best to ensure my actions are aligned with these agreements it's about respecting what has been negotiated and honoring the members of those organizations in the same way it's critical that the district approaches the aacv agreement with the same commitment ensuring that it is consistently referenced and followed when working with a ACV members I would like to point out a positive example of this professional partnership that has been taken recently and that's the establishment of the consultation committee which I addressed last month this effort is a clear example of how we've put the agreement into action aacv has appointed Representatives we've already had our first meeting with the district team and we have future meetings scheduled this progress is encouraging and I'm optimistic about what we'll accomplish through the consultation committee process
038uh but it's important that we have this following of the agreement in all areas I would like to note that the aacv agreement is publicly available on the district's website and all our district Representatives who work with our members should use it as a resource to help help guide their interactions and decisions this will ensure that our work is grounded in respect and in professionalism I'd also like to take a moment to emphasize once again the importance of clarity which I have addressed to the board our members need Clarity in all structures programs and procedures communicated by the district and its departments aacv in this past month reported areas in need of clarity and I do want to state that we saw actions taken right away to begin to provide better Clarity in those areas
039we noted these actions need to continue as we end quarter 2 and move into quarter 3 and four so that our members can effectively do the important work that they do in their school communities I would also like to point out that Clarity is vital because most initiatives and changes flow directly through principles to teachers and staff when principles lack clear guidance structures and procedures it becomes much harder to support our school teams effectively providing Clarity at the district level ensures that we can deliver that Clarity at the school level which of course benefits everyone finally I want to address the district's transition toward a centralized operational model historically cvesd has operated with a more decentralized approach a structure that contributed to our reputation as an outlier and as a high performing District by many
040metrics while centralization possibly has some benefits it is a significant shift that requires careful planning and alignment of systems and should be done with input from all stakeholders such as aacv this shift also ties into the rigorous learning for all initiative and for this plan to succeed it's essential that aacv and other key stakeholders are included in the planning and decision-making process from the beginning so uh this work on the 3 to fiveyear plan is uh beginning I know and I just want to make sure that all our stakeholders including a ACV are included so that we can identify potential challenges share our expertise that we have from the school principal perspective and ensure that the plan delivers meaningful support for our schools and students thank you have a good evening thank you before we
041go to the oral Communications portion of the meeting uh Mr Romero um I after our recognition I neglected to ask you to introduce our newest principal thank you president Ugarte uh vice president too uh governing board members and superintendent it's my pleasure tonight uh to introduce our newest administrator to uh the Chula Elementary School District Elizabeth carzoli Elizabeth so Elizabeth has over 20 years experienc uh the last 7 to8 years as an administrator uh she has AP experience principal experience and higher level experience and it's our pleasure to introduce Liz to our community and our new principal at Kellog [Applause] Liz thank you for that wonderful introduction and just I'm honored to join what a wonderful team at Chul vist Elementary School District and yes I bring a strong background in educational leadership however I
042do have a a wonderful background in being in the Community my children also went to chil vist elementary school and I believe in the the school system here and they are wonderful serving their Community my son is an EMT my daughter is a school teacher so uh giving back to that Community I just love uh that I get to be part of that and hopefully uh make a difference at Kellogg and continue What U Mr aario has done uh throughout the school year and through many years hopefully um I want to also just mention that uh thank you to the board thank you to the administrative team for believing in me and I will promise and commit to doing the best by our students at jist elementary school district thank you thank you [Applause] welcome
043and I believe that's Dr carzoli correct thank you all right oral Communications the oral communication section provides the public with an opportunity to address the board on non-agenda items persons wishing to be heard May attend in person and should complete a request to be heard card and submit it to the recording secretary before the start of the meeting speakers are requested to limit their remarks to three minutes and speak in a respectful and professional manner the board shall limit the total time for public input on each topic to 20 minutes with board consent the president may increase or decrease the time allowed for public comments depending on the number of persons wishing to be heard no board action can be taken and I do want to reiterate with some of our topics tonight that these
044are non-agenda items so if you begin to speak on an agend an agendized item I will ask you to stop and wait for that item to be presented for example anything having to do with the open vacancy or the process that we will discuss with the two board seats um I have move we have moved those speakers to item 13B some of you put item agenda number nine and we moved you to 13B anyone who did not put a a topic for their agenda or for the item if you begin to speak on that topic I will ask that you stop and that you be that you wait until we get to item 13B thank you with that our first speaker is Mrs Maribel Martinez good evening I like to respectfully ask for extended time
045after the buzzer goes off um how much time are you are you asking a minute go ahead Friday December 6 2024 9:07 9:00 with 7 minutes an email was sent to the Chula Vista board members and superintendent I received one reply an email acknowledgement of receipt only no followup Monday December 9th 2024 11:02 p.m. email resent no answer Monday December 9th 2024 at 11:20 a.m. new email sent no answer Wednesday December 11th 2024 at 9:59 a.m. new email and send no answer I have sent a total of four emails since December 6 2024 I have gotten no acknowledgement no followup no phone calls no nothing zero n from our board members superintendent assistant superintendent student services assistant superintendent of Human Services make me understand why is it that a parent of the Chula Vista Elementary
046School District has a concern and is being ignored by our elected officials is this the same behavior you have supported with principal boras you have in support of principal boras I have been a proud parent of Rogers Elementary for six years my child's teachers have been nothing but incredible throughout the years I have develop a strong parent Community a community which we have been proud of a district we have supported we confide and lean on each other and it is unfortunate that our recent conversations are of the allegedly one of you board members have colluded with parents to go against principal boras I am requesting an investigation on this matter I've experienced several changes in Administration in my time from the departure of our previous principal to a temporary principal who by the way did
047nothing to ensure the safety of and the well-being of my child when his life was threatened verbally not once but twice the administration did nothing to ensure the well-being of my child no administrator checked up on him no one reassured him of his safety at school the demographics at Rogers Elementary are unique in that there is a high population of special education students principal boras has been at Rogers for one year and she has demonstrated leadership positive changes in our community to ensure the safety and well-being of our students not to mention the immediate leadership in action taken when an email was sent out October 2024 to All Families regarding school safety when a certain word of a prohibited it item was mentioned in a classroom I can guarantee you no one in the previous
048administration cared to send any notification out to the parents when my son was life was threatened using a certain word with a prohibited item the letter sent out by principal boras at Rogers Elementary announcing her departure on December 6 2024 is a disservice and an insult to our community and sounds nothing like her she's never carried herself as a quitter leaving her community halfway through the year with all the plans she shared with us at coffee with the principal is she being forced out who's being catered definitely not families or children of Rogers Elementary have you seen all the positive changes made in our campus when was the last time you visited have you read our School blogs have you seen all that mpas has accomplished in just one year not to mentioned the recognition
049of the city mayor when she put together the very first district autism walk welcoming the entire Community now imagine what she can do if she completed the school year and the next and the next Dr Rees you asked us parents in a letter that went out on the evening of December 6th what our thoughts were on the qualities and attributes important for a principle look no further principal boras has met all those qualities we have finally found stability support a by lingual principle a voice that our community has been lacking at Rogers an interim principal does not know the needs of our school I can attest to that another change and instability will not sit good with our students including my child who depends on reals and consistency give us resources and support principal poras
050a new principal is not the answer please accept this petition of 68 signatures I collected Friday and Monday in full support to keeping principal bores are Rogers Elementary pres school we express our appreciation for out the outstanding leadership dedication in children's education the campus has seen an enormous significant Improvement in both academics extra activities and school safety enhancement enhancement we ask the Chul Vista Elementary School District to keep principal boras as she has demonstrated to be a great fit to Roger Elementary thank you I will present to you copies of those signatures I would email them but I might not get a response them to the clerk over here thank you Jen fauler hi my name is Jen Falkner longtime chiv Vista resident and proud parent of a student at Chula Vista Hills Elementary School
051we met here last month as we spoke football metaphors about the dire water situation at our school this month in light of the proposed Secretary of Education being Linda McMahon of the McMahon wrestling Dynasty today I bring you two stories from the top rope picture this in the far left corner of the Ring we have the champion the Chula Vista Hills Elementary School Title One Community who battled for 18 months to raise more than $1,000 to pay for a water bottle refill station a quote they received from this exact Elementary School Board but oh no coming down the aisle is that very same Chula Vista School Board looking to send an elbow drop with a revised quote at nearly double the cost and less functionality ding ding chiv Vista School District wins that round with
0521 2 3 the main event though is a brawl between an 80 lb Tula Vista Hills student and a failing battered water fountain the student narrowly avoided Serious injury and the community waited to see if the district would rise to the opportunity and boot the old Fountain permanently by replacing it with the water bottle refill station a few months later though however a new identical water fountain was put in its place in the end it was another quick pin for the chiv Vista Elementary School District leaving the students of Chula Vista Hills down for the count before I leave you I'd like to stress how important this request truly is the current tulv Vista Hills Water System is outdated unfair and frankly unsafe for our students take away the football metaphors and the wrestling analogies
053and what you're left with in these messages is that we're concerned and hope the school board hears that and takes action all we're ultimately asking for is what every child deserves clean water and more specifically a water bottle refill station thank you thank you Noel Cravens uh good evening to the board members Dr Reyes um administrative team and everyone else uh I'm a proud parent of two cvsd students at fahari Jeffers I've been attending and or listening to the Past board meetings since last school year and have heard several issues from different schools as an Engaged parent I'm thankful to have a platform to speak up and address concerns but what I mostly appreciate is that the board does their due diligence in the betterment of the district I believe we all want the same
054we want all of our students to have the best education I have no doubt that the best years are ahead of us and that the district will continue to make improvements and be one of the best sought out districts to be in thank you happy holidays thank you Ashley Bara good evening Dr Reyes trustees and admin my name is Ashley BBA and I'm a mother of four and I currently have a first grader at Kellogg Elementary I'm here to express my disappointment and frustration with the decision to strip Kellogg of our principal Mr aparicio whose last day is this Friday we were just informed of this change last Friday so forgive me if I'm wrong about the details but from my understanding Mr a is being sent over to Harborside because they are in dire
055need of support and strong leadership that Mr a has proven he can provide I can certainly empathize with that our Kellogg sixth graders have had four principles since kindergarten at least half of our families are Spanish speaking and our two previous principles before Mr a didn't speak Spanish which hindered the trust and connection between admin and our families our new principle will be the fifth principal our sixth graders have had at Kellogg it's been a revolving door every couple of years as you can imagine the lack of consistency has taken a toll on the staff students and their families when Mr a came along it was like the scene in Wizard of Oz when everything is suddenly in color and there's hope I've served on Kellogg's PTA School Board PTA board I'm sorry uh every
056year since 2008 18 including last year when I didn't even have a student attending Mr A's support and Leadership has been a much needed breath of fresh air and now that support and consistency is being taken why why does Kellogg have to pay the price for the inept leadership allegedly of another school we finally have some stability and the rug is being pulled from under us yet again it takes time for admin to build relationships with the students and families and staff it takes time for trust to be established how can students learn to trust and look up to Authority if yall keep changing it we are starting over every time admin changes the expectations the goals for the school it's not right to do this in the middle of the school year by the
057way this is the second year in a row my six-year-old son is impacted by midyear unforeseen principal reassignments this happened to his last year at Cook I implore you to revisit the decision to uproot principles midyear specifically when the school Community is happy with them as Kellogg is with Mr a uh trustee too I see that you're wearing a cve shirt I know Kellogg's union members expressed frustration with this decision it appears as though their pleas fell on deaf ears I want to make it clear that none of this is directed at our new principal Dr C none of these frustrations should be absorbed by you on behalf of our PTA board we welcome you with open arms an open mind and an open heart and we look forward to working with you trustees please
058make it a point to discuss and amend the practice of these midyear reassignments specifically when the schools are happy with their uh admin team if it ain't broke don't break it thank you thank you Claudia peris chica good evening Board of Trustees and superintendent Dr Reyes my name is Claudia Paris chica this is my 24th year in the district and I am currently the behavior specialist IIA at Rogers Elementary I want to thank the district first for allowing for staff input at our listening tour and I am hopeful for your ongoing support at our school we are a unique Community with diverse needs including 10 special day classes four preschool sdc's and several students in gen Ed with wonder One Services all of which translates to over 60 classified members working hard with the most
059vulnerable population served by the district members of our classified team have begged for support from the current principal and they have been ignored AIDS are feeling disrespected and undervalued and this is why Rogers has been losing talented and dedicated individuals to other schools in our district Rogers has only one noon Duty assigned to 70 students at our primary recess and there are no yard duties to supervise our students with extensive support needs at their recess this leaves aids to fulfill those roles and responsibilities without adequate resources such as walkie-talkies or even first aid kits our classified representatives for our School site Council were appointed by the principal rather than being voted on removing our voice to choose our own Representatives we even had an SDC classroom where the teacher was absent and the AIDS were
060only given a walkie-talkie by the principal they had to send an email at 1:15 in the afternoon after being ignored all day to request assistance with their own breaks and their own lunches please be open and transparent with the incoming principal about the challenges of having the largest classified staff in the district ask them to respect our contract our roles and our responsibilities we need a unifier in Chief at Rogers with open communication skills and strong proven leadership we the classified look forward to working together with a new principal who wants to focus on relevant trainings Staffing for safety and uniting the two sides of our campus please support the new principal as they transition into a school School atmosphere that has had unsteady leadership for over a year now please please keep our fledgling
061assistant principal who has worked hard under an incredibly challenging atmosphere My Hope Is That You Now understand that Rogers deserves better I appreciate your time thank you and have a good night thank you christe m good evening I'm a parent at Rogers Elementary and I have been diligently advocating for more resources and support on our campus since June our requests for Parental engagement such as PTA and various committies went unanswered by Administration since the district's involvement we have since been able to form an SSC in September and a PTA in October I currently serve as our PTA president as well as chair our School site Council it was through these committees that I was able to directly engage with the staff and parents and learn more about the challenges of our school I would like
062to start by thanking the district specifically assistant um superintendent Sharon Casey and Jessica Morales for taking the time to meet with me and addressing my concerns I'm grateful that you have provided us with a full-time counselor as the part-time Arrangement was not adequate enough to fulfill the needs of our students at Rogers I also appreciate the district and trustees who took the time to come to to our school and observe my daughter's classroom and understand the Dynamics and recognize just how desperately we needed the district's support and intervention I appreciate your efforts in breaking up the classroom and bringing PBIS mtss to assist Andy Falcon has made tremendous efforts within our classroom and I look forward to learning more about how Rogers can achieve a platinum recognition award one day on another note I hope
063the district will consider bringing back impact teachers although we no longer are in a pandemic the ramifications are still present and children need to that additional support I also believe teachers can help assist um children who fall behind in school as a result of being bullied I understand that the District offers the support to the bully however um we cannot forget about the children who fall behind as a result of being bullied in closing I'm just a normal parent and Incredibly introverted one at that but I'm here tonight to show parents that there is absolutely power and advocacy I've been where you are I've still where many of you are but we must let the faith drive you we must persist for the betterment of our children and our community and never give up thank
064you thank [Applause] you Steven Vasquez good evening uh esteemed board members uh Dr Rees superintendent and recognize a few people Mr Romero and Miss Sharon casy from a few years ago um I am actually great great parent of two children who attend your school district uh I also have a lot of friends in contacts who uh also are parents or grandparents of children that attend your school district uh I I've recently um have been expressed concern by some of the parents that the school board members uh are doing too much in regards to communicating and trying to help parents and what I shared with some of this concerned parents is that it was a few years ago I believe you you you were here Dr Rees where there was a representative uh the main attorney
065from a law firm Fagan fredman and F brast and he gave a presentation and and I was honored to be able to view that and it was discussed uh what is a board's job and part of the information that everybody was provided is one of those responsibilities is community leadership leadership and advocacy uh plan for slm monitor student performance promote and support and ensure a safe and appropriate environment and also there was uh some tips provided for effective communication with members of the public and one of those tips was uh be patient with members of the public they often do not understand the procedure or the substance of what is being discussed so the point I was trying to make is that I personally appreciate all the board members who are here who take time
066out of their busy lives and probably while they're off from their responsibility of being board members to actually communicate you know with with with those of us who have questions or or may have some concerns and I I think for any of the parents or anyone else who has questions about you know what the board members do and what can they not do perhap and I'm I'm not sure if the school district here still has a contract with the law firm uh which anybody who has access to you know to the internet can simply enter ww. F3 law.com and I do not work for them so I'm not advertising uh you know and I think think it would be to a lot of the parents and members of the community's interest if that's something that
067you know maybe in the future could be addressed during a a board me meeting so that parents are able to understand that uh members of the board are supposed to be helping us and talking to us thank you thank you Linda Garcia evening I appreciate you taking the time to hear me out I am here to back up what uh Miss Christy Cano had presented as well as Miss pz chica miss poris the principal of Greg Rogers school is a very nice lady there's no doubt about it she's a very nice person but is she the right fit for this school I don't think so I think this school requires some one just a special educated background and the knowledge that is required at this particular school I see you have a new president that
068you have just promoted from what I can see she has everything that checks the Box Miss poris she's smart she's educated but I think her experience and her background would be better fit for junior high or High School level not at the level that we have at Greg Rogers I heard someone say that she's made all these changes and that's incorrect you have three PTA members you have no safety patrol you don't have any children's doing anything like they used to you don't have enough people on the playgrounds the amount of children that are eloping from the school classes is still high the bulling is still going on money that is funded for this school could be better fitted for more Specialists more teachers more people like Miss Perez chica that have a vested interest
069it needs a principal who is going to listen to the teachers back up the teachers and hear what Solutions and ideas they may have because the only people that really know these students are your teachers and the staff the ladies who run the office the nurse everybody else below the principal between the teachers are all vested in the school and they do a darn good job at it it should raise a red flag to you that we the parents had to come to you with a problem with Boolean two months ago that should raise your red flag if you check your principal's emails you will see that many many parents from kindergarten and up have reached out to miss poris and what has been done I think you'd be quite shocked what are in those
070emails and you'll ask yourself what has been done just something to think about I hope you consider someone else that is better qualified thank you thank you Francisco Martinez Francisco Martinez okay um all other speakers um put specifically on their AG on their card that they were going uh wishing to speak about the board vacancies they've been moved to 13B um I would like to take a moment right now to before we go into uh the oral presentation to um acknowledge that our attorneys are here with regard to having three board members versus five so Dr Reyes hi so uh I'd like to present uh our attorneys from dwk that would like to there were some questions since we right now currently have a three member board uh I would like to uh have the
071attorneys just go over uh for clarification purposes the what constitutes a quorum and for a vote to pass is it three votes two votes how does that work sure um good evening uh board members Dr Reyes others assembled this evening the way the law works is a quorum is a majority of the membership of the board so you have a five member board so a quorum in order to call a meeting to order in order to take action would require three board members to be present um the same rule applies as far as um taking a vote or taking action um there too it would require actually as currently configured it would require unanimous vote by all three board members um in order to pass or adopt or approve um anything um so that's the
072situation that arises when you have two vacancies of on a five member board there's a very rare exception based on a rule of necessity um but that is really um an extraordinary case it would probably be based on some kind of conflict of interest and where the board is is required to take immediate action but I don't want to I don't want to give the indication that somehow that rule of necessity would apply more often than it actually does it really is a very rare situation um could you uh give an example what would happen if uh during the course of the meeting let's say one of the trustees had to leave yeah what would happen if if a if a if one of the members had to leave and there was still let's say
073an action item on the agenda then then a quorum would no longer exist and the board could not take action on that particular item really the only thing the board could do without the three of you present um would be to adjourn the meeting so if one member left there are two remaining they could stick around essentially to adjourn the meeting but you really would not be able to take action on any on any items so not the not the best thing to look forward to okay all right uh trust this any questions I think some questions might arise later when we get to item 13B correct yeah we're going to call them again for regarding uh explanation specifically regarding 13B all right okay this was just for the voting right okay okay thanks thank
074you thank you all right oral presentation and written reports the district district safety health update Mr retto good evening uh governing board members superintendent Rees and our community it's my uh pleasure to present uh our monthly safety update so uh we had our regular chesa Elementary School District uh safety committee meeting it was a big uh agenda that we had uh working towards so the district has been working with the Traffic Division in uh Chula Vista to make sure that we have uh wellapp appointed crosswalks uh as some of our school sites so we have five schools uh where projects are going to be worked on and getting completed uh so at violo Casas Rogers hail Crest and Soto mayor uh we're going to be installing different types of cross rocks and uh putting up
075signage across those areas that will help uh with collecting traffic data uh looking at uh areas that need to be uh rezoned and re uh uh designed um and four-way crosswalks that will be next to School site so we're excited about those projects with our Chula Vista city uh our camera project all Sites have been assessed in camera placement locations have been recommended uh to our vendor um so we're really close to getting our next steps and we are prioritizing having every single School site in Chula Vista with cameras by the end of the 2425 school year so uh important work that will happen uh we're hoping to um uh over uh deliver and have it done sooner but we want to make sure that that we're respectful of getting uh all the ideas from
076our stakeholders at our school sites such as our principles for camera location so we're shooting for the end of the the school year uh eix uh so eix is our platform that we've been using uh to uh prioritize safety uh and um notification of safety uh in real time uh one of the things that we're working with right now is uh substitutes now have access uh to the eix platform uh through platform check-in uh at School sites uh our next step in this is providing uh tablets uh to our school sites that they can assign to substitutes for that day so if a substitute doesn't have uh the the app on their phone uh we can now assign a tablet uh to them and they'll be able to have the same safety uh updates in
077real time as our regular staff members so uh we're working on that and we're still training at multiple School sites uh throughout the week um and I'll share some data information with you and and an upcoming slide uh so these are some site trainings that have taken place so at otai we had an incident Management training Montgomery a lockdown drill so the mayor another incident U Management training uh we had uh Silver Wing lockdown training we had a radio drill on uh the 20th uh lockdown drill at laud Brock and Roar an incident Management training and L ver a dual training of Incident Management and eix training um last week uh so we did have uh our third uh uh Heritage Elementary Town Hall was a great meeting uh we had our safety team and
078attendance and um a couple dozen parents uh that were there it was a good good turnout um we were super excited to uh a answer questions some of the things that we talked about was access control and what we've talked about in the past is um safe schools come with some limited access and what I mean by that is um there's some Liberties that we've had at our School sites that if we want to keep the safest schools there may be some things that we we need to do so we've really talked about and worked with our principles thank you to aacv and the rest of our uh labor groups um we have what we're calling a bell-to-bell schedule which means before school starts after school sites uh you know the the gates are open
079but when the bell rings we're locking our gates and making sure that anyone that comes onto our campus is checked in uh some of our school sites have had um a more flexible uh start of the school day um or end of the school day so some of those things are a little bit change in the school culture but ultimately is going to be uh well received when it's standardized and creates the safest environment so uh access control is one of the things that we're talking about our quarterly trainings um we want to provide uh cheat sheets uh for our schools that can be placed in all classrooms near phones of our emergency um uh processes lanyard tags can be used for scripts so like on the back of their badge little sticker that can
080go in that can provide some of those safety uh quick bullet points that we need to have um eix as we've talked about and our camera projects all of those were things that we highlighted at Heritage Town Hall so this is an actual snapshot of uh an incident that occurred at one of our school sites uh and uh we we thought this was really important to share with you guys because uh when one person was uh set off and an alert uh multiple people from the dist District were aware so uh thankfully this was a a misuse an accidental use of this uh but an employee uh triggered uh a notification at 7:45 uh Jenny vgnc um uh uh responded uh really quickly our uh safety protocol team our safety team uh started responding uh
081so we we had a lot of responses to John making sure that he was okay uh Amed was on this Jenny vgnc uh even our custodial supervisors um and then within one within 2 minutes so this at 7:45 by uh uh 7:47 we we recognize um that uh this was an accidental push uh we thanked them and uh we were done Miguel uh within two minutes of everything we recognized that this was a false alarm no one needed to be called and we were we were safe although this was false alarm we wanted to show you show the board and show our community that six people were on this text uh you know immediately when we get notification which would have been different in the past in the past you know a teacher would have
082to call the office or call the principal principal would then have to radio to the district and we would be able to you know we we saved multiple minutes in in the process but that just happened last week we thought it'd be exciting to share with you guys the the process of how things happen all right any questions there are no speak speakers any questions or comments from the board yes School site crosswalks I know some schools have um entrances on the back side some so um does that require the chil Vista PD to approve a crosswalk I know of some schools that do not have a crosswalk but they're out there kids are crossing the street and they're running across and I know of a particular school where it's like on a curve so
083even more dangerous so what does that entail Dr R Mr ROM you want to explain the process and how we work with that city of Chul Vista yeah thank you um and we the city of Chul Vista actually has a traffic uh Department uh a division within uh the city that manages this so where we have concerns I think we may have the same concern ered at one of the school sites I think I might know the school that you're talking about um there's a couple things that they look at so the natural flow of the traffic uh you know how to prioritize that to make sure that there's um uh enough space in that natural flow to not disrupt the the the flow of traffic yet create the safest environments so uh in not
084all of our school sites but what we've done is our soble report that we shared with you recommended those uh priori prorities uh at some of our school sites and so we've been reaching out to the city these are the first five but there's at least 5 to 10 different more recommendations that we're going through in that process so um if there are other reports that are needed to be looked at and other incidents that need to be shared we can share that with the Traffic Division and meet with them um Amed has been meeting with them monthly on this project and so these These are the first five but like I said there's at least five more why do we start with first five let's start with first 10 so it's all great great
085question and so we did so we we've shared all of them with him so uh these are the first five that they're working on so that I I may have misspoken I apologized for that there was not one that we held back this is just the first five that they're working on right now okay do we have a timeline uh it's on the city's timeline because we can't enforce or change any traffic patterns so for example one of the areas that I I think we might be sharing about uh there's what they were talking about is there's uh cars that Park uh on both sides one of them is an illegal park right they're not it's a it's a no parking area but parents park there and kids run across the street right so what
086they're they're doing right now is traffic studies to look at that and determine do they put a red traffic area a red uh mark on the curb and so that that way would eliminate that or do they actually go through and do a traffic a study do do you believe that it requires superintendent to meet with Maria kadori because child safety I know that's your priority as well um I mean I'm about cutting out the middleman that's just how I am just go straight to the source she's the city manager have a chat with her so yeah I do have a routine uh meetings with her I can work with Mr from Merc which was uh are yet to be worked on and I can mention it to her MH thank you I have other
087questions could I could we get a some feedback as to what they said I don't I I think I don't want to wait till next board meeting to get a response yeah I'll do a board update thank you vendor access so it kind of goes hand inand with the incident we last had a couple months ago at Heritage but as far as vendor access uh sometimes they have access to our schools during the school day and sometimes after the school hours but sometimes children are still there there's after school programs children have you know little soccer games things they're doing um I'd like to know what the protocol is and what assurances we have that established protocol is being um adhered to Mr Amer can you uh talk about not just the vendors but also
088if there's any work to be done inside the school what the process is for people to check can Etc yeah so all of our vendors are required to provide us a full report that their employees have met all the safety requirements uh as far as safety but also pass background checks so all of them have fingerprints um and if they don't those vendors aren't able to access our school sites so we do have a clarification um that all of the the people who are accessing have passed our security um uh standards for being able to access uh and just for clarification purposes they provide us with a list of folks that would be going to the school yeah not necessarily the CEO yeah so so yeah yeah the ones who will be accessing the school
089the on will be accessing the school yeah so and we do so there's a few things so we do work work with our facilities department and we we don't give blind access to our school sit so if there's a project that's happening let's say Saturday or after school there is a District employee that's also present with those uh people so we we're having uh a district employee part of our School site so for example one of the projects that we have uh when we do HVAC and we're using an outside vendor one of our employees one of our custodial staff operation staff is present with them so we make sure that there's some oversight of what they're accessing at our school sites besides the um the escorts are they being cleared through Raptor because I
090can only imagine that hey someone's calling in sick they don't want to go in on a Saturday to fumigate they don't want to go in on a a Friday night to clean carpets whatever the situation might be and uh since the offices are closed what is the process then are they they could be sending a substitute if they don't the persons who were cleared aren't available to do that particular project yeah that's a great question one of the things that we we prioritize is uh Jenny vignac in our risk management department is very clear with the expectations of what we require from our vendors so the vendors uh and I hear your concern uh they do sign into Raptor um and they need to provide us a list of all employees that could be accessing
091the school sites so not just their the people that they're sending but if they do have a substitute pool they need to include that substitute pool in that list of possible employees so for example someone that's doing HVAC they may be three people that they're using but they submit a list of 10 and so it could be any of those 10 and they pass that background check that safety check to make sure that they're qualified um so some of those may be substitutes in case they they the original Three aren't included or not available for that Saturday and and if you're are you telling me then that our custodian then Shadows this vendor around the whole time and doesn't do his job because he's shadowing the vendor so I wouldn't say it's like a a
092shoulder-to-shoulder shadow um but I think what they do is they you know they're doing their work on campus um and then creating contact opportunities so uh they're available they have radios and so often times with a classroom so we don't give them a key to their classrooms right but if they need to they're on top of the roof and they're fixing the HPA system and they need access to the classroom to come in they'll radio the the custodian to let him know um but no it's not a an elbow to Elbow shout or shoulder shoulder Tosh shoulder it's more supervisory and uh observing what what they're doing in in at the school sites so it's not a true statement to say that they're being escorted they're just available if needed yeah I mean uh so
093the I I I understand what you're saying um uh we we don't I just need to make sure that that our language says what we do that's all yeah and I think you know um I I I understand your question um I I'm but an escort yeah I probably wouldn't use the word escort I believe that we're supervising the staff that's on and most especially um when the children are around but they're just strange odd awful things that can happen if we're not being mindful so that's different great when you're talking about having access to our school sites during the school day uh we have people that are escorting our employees in regards to Ajax thank you Mr Romero in regards to Ajax substitutes they are they getting the training how would they respond I
094know we had an incident where a substitute was there and she was confronted with a situation was she trained Mr Right uh so our substitutes um as we shared are going to be going through this same process uh they did did not have access early on uh partly because the way that the app is set up is it recognizes your email address to your assigned site and so since it was based on email uh accessibility we've had to create uh basically these U mock emails um so like let's just say for example Heritage substitute one Heritage substitute to and we're trying to create uh um 10 right now at each of our School sites and then we're going to provide uh tablets to each of those School sites so when uh you know when Lucy
095checks in when Francisco checks in when dilia checks in we assign them a tablet and then we have access to that at that point we'll provide them training we have not provided them training right now um this is our pilot year for the program so we're learning a lot uh from that and we're going to make recommendations and and uh things as we go along but currently right now as of today we've set up the system so sub students can have access but we haven't had the tablets purchased yet so we're going to go through that process right now but we do have substitutes that we use frequently right it just to provide them the training at minimum would give us a head start if you look at their record and their just historically uh
096substituting a few times a month even a few times a week we should train them already because they already show a history of being supportive of our schools so Mr what we can do is uh the ones that we use um every day the the 10 that we use every day we should start training them yeah so that we're working on that right now the the problem with that is the app is assigned to the school site so if I have a long-term sub we we're providing them that that access but our substitutes that are used regularly they can't put it on their phone site on their phone for example because if I hail Chris one day Harbor Side the next day it doesn't follow them right but the training on how to use it
097it's Universal so you can train them yes regardless of the app right because when they get to the school they can get the The Substitute app or the tablet or whatever the going to do yeah we haven't had those we don't have those apps yet but as soon as we do we we'll provide them training we don't have those tablets yet yes but as soon as we do we'll provide them training thank you yes I don't have any questions to you all right what else falls under um this category for for uh District safety and health update the reason I'm asking because in relation to our uh needs that we have in special education uh last month during public comments uh a parent from Wolf Canyon asked asked about adding additional parents to the special
098education parent committee and after the last deck deac meeting I shared with some of the parents that we had an in-house sped parent committee where parents could come together to share their concerns to hear about what sped uh leadership had to offer and that would I would get back to them about the meeting dates but I don't have those meeting dates and I'm afraid that one of the parents that left earlier she was one of the parents that uh I had told her that this uh committee was um that we had this committee and there might be some misunderstandings about what it entails and yeah so what I can do is I going to have uh Shon Casey uh provide that information to you think maybe she could share a little bit for the community
099since we have yes so I'm not talking about the KAG I'm talking about the the inhouse committee yes so we formed a special education parent committee where we took applications for um parents across the district on different sites and communities we chose 10 parents to represent that committee but the committee meetings are open to the public so any parent can attend uh I'll have our director of special education send out those dates we can put them on the website as well thank you thank you all right consent calendar approval of the consent calendar the following items listed under the consent calendar are considered by the board in one action there will be no discussion on these items prior to the time the board votes on the motion unless members of the board staff or public
100request specific items to be discussed and are removed from the consent calendar there any items that need to be pulled from uh by the board yes 11 C uh subsections 11 CF and 11 cm uhu also 11d 11h 11 I 11 P and 11 Q vice president Theo do you have any items yes um 11 t t is in Tom orto Mayo orto Mayo yes thank you I was going to pull I so we're good um do I have a motion to approve the consent minus 11 C sub subsection F and M 11 d h i p q and T So moved second moved by vice president de Mayo seconded by clerk trustee um Dominguez santes all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously 11 C subsection f um clerk Dominguez cantes yes on
101page three of 13 I just like uh if we could elaborate on the senior director of student services position which are Pages 12 and 13 and of 13 I just wanted and also if we could clarify uh under essential job requirements the third dot point I'd like to know what does and then quote or related teaching experience de desired mean those two items Dr Rees uh Miss Casey can you uh share about uh the position for a senior senior director of student services what it entails what kind of work they're going to be doing and then uh uh trusty doming serantes also has a question about or related teaching uh experience so maybe that question is more for Romero but uh can you talk about the job job duties absolutely this is a position that
102will be directly underneath me working alongside me to support the Departments that I oversee so early childhood special education student placement um Community Schools uh and health litigation yes all those fun things I will have a senior director working directly beside me so I can help build that capacity to um support our district and our students as we move forward and Mr R in regards to the the question that trust doming santes [Music] has can you repeat the question trusty it uh I just want to clear ification under the under essential job requirements the third dot point it says or related teaching experience desired what does that mean give me some examples so for example we have um multiple credentials that are required so uh multiple subject credential special education uh credential Early Childhood other
103single subject other credentials that are educationally related so the list is going to keep growing credentials but yes I apprec I appreciate that because I'm looking forward for Sharon to have someone that can really be equal to Sheron well I guess that's wish will thinking but thank you thank you 11 the subsection m m Aya Healthcare Incorporated page seven of 13 Dr Rays at the rate of 45,000 per month and etherapy intermediate also at the rate of 45,000 per month both paid with sped teaching funds sped funds okay so a healthcare Miss uh they they they're a healthcare and etherapy if you jump over one they're e very connected M I have questions about that yes so this is a non-public agency that's supporting our vacancies for teachers and special education service providers so with
104the if the board approves a new mou we're hoping to not be using these agencies right and why I bring it up is because one of our labor Partners has brought up frequently the use of um continual use of um agency hires when we're spending 45,000 per month that's 540,000 a year time two for these two agencies that's over a million dollars a year for these two two agencies alone I'm wondering if we could be more productive and start looking at hiring some of these people and uh I think an analysis um an assessment being done because I don't I mean we just keep approving and approving and approving well let's take a look at what we can do to hire these people because all these these hiring agencies they take a certain percentage of
105what they're getting paid so those folks are getting and I'm making up a number for the lack for the conversation so that person's getting paid $7 $20 whatever an hour but we're paying them $25 or we're paying them $27 an hour I used to work with these some of these agencies in my past life so if it's just how do they say cheaper to keeper just keep her so one of the reasons why uh tonight one of the items that we have is anou to provide a signon bonus for teachers uh special education teachers and the whole idea behind that is to attract teachers special education teachers so we can hire them exactly uh for what you're saying instead of using the agencies the whole idea is to be able to uh hire attract and
106retain but that's just for the teachers what about our are our non-credentialed staff that we bring over correct so my understanding is these two are for teachers correct yeah for teachers and then the E therapy is for speech language pathologist and and um occupational therapists they're covering vacancies and they're also covering our when we have leaves people that are out on leave and we can't hire those and these are not to exceed so it's not that we're spending that much money so we not to exceed that much money in the school year right but I'm sure mark would agree that we better have that money there in case we don't in case we do need them so I'd just like for us to monitor that if we're going to hire folks because of the incentive
107that we might be approving then um I think we want to keep a close watch on that to see what we can do to keep them absolutely thank you community manners I just like to know what this program is about what page Community matters in between a and eery MH Jessica is that yours Consultants yes thank you this is the safe School ambassadors program we currently having having it run at several schools in our district right now we had it start at Marshall we have it at moroka and some others and essentially it's an anti-bullying program that provides assemblies and some sessions for parents as well and one of the unique components of this program is that it really works with students who have high social capital on campuses and teaches them skills not to
108be bystanders and so it helps to support kind of an anti-bullying Culture by building up the school um with natural leadership skills among the students and the staff that are involved with the program I'd like to what well invite me when this is happening I like to see it in action yeah of course and on that oh I think you had something to say truste yes thank you uh on both the I Healthcare and the etherapy how many vacancies do we have posted for teachers right now that could potentially be filled uh or are being filled by these two Consultants Mr R or or Sharon so we currently have 12 uh special ed vacancies um that some of them are being filled and then the rest of the the uh support from a those are
109for basically substitute for leaves so right now if I go to Ed join I will find 12 vacancies posted okay thank you welcome the next one is Lexia Voyer Sopris Incorporated we approved these Focus services at different schools and uh we don't get feedback as to whether they worked or not I'm not saying no to it what I'm saying is if they could share the outcomes maybe other school dist other schools could um you know piggyback on it and maybe adopt it and invest with in these programs we don't get any feedback how is this happening in the vacuum yeah so uh one of the reasons one of the ways they provide feedback with uh among principal is through our lead principles but uh would you want to expand that Mr Morales sure so um
110this contract in um is actually a professional development opportunity for a writing program that we already have at many schools in our district this is a step up to writing program and so what is very customary is that if a principal is having success with a program um they might share it through their lead through their cohort or what we're also doing is we're curating some of the programs that are used throughout the district and right now measuring their effectiveness on our school campuses so all of our principles are creating turnaround uh leadership action plans and they have won around academics and so we have several programs that are not only in their turn around leadership plans but they're in their spsa and what we'll do at the end of the year is we'll measure
111the growth based upon the implementation and outcomes of those programs and then determine what we move forward and what we take forward to share Miss Jessica when you say we does that mean you I mean we and uh the leadership and learning team in conjunction with our principal group and our principal leads so we have excellent principal leads that lead cohorts are special projects we meet with them monthly um and then they also have cohort meetings that they take work out to their principles that they support so we're part of this kind of network of right I just want them to be able to share with each other what their successes or their concerns and I'm seeing some nodding down over there so I'm hoping that it's happening thank you thanks and the last one
112Dr re is is Turbo Escape page eight of 13 it's the last consultant so $100,000 for mulch that's a lot of mulch yes a couple questions con uh connected to that how many of our schools are they doing and remind me was this a bid was this bid out or a soul Source contract sure Mr pong so we can prepare in an update how many have mulch because I don't have that right in front of me right now but um this is below the bid limit so we did not go out for a for formal bit so Mr bu do we I know there's formal and informal bids do we go out for informal bid or was it a s Soul Source it was um it's not a soul Source it's for these contracts it's
113um considered maintenance so it's under um the threshold of 10 I believe 19,000 right now so so that threshold is for RFP but do you get three quotes I'll have to check with the Department I have a quick question on the mulch is this the wood chips that are on the playground that the kids put in their mouth is that what we're talking about the ones to get splinters with yeah I just I just wanted to okay just wanted to check is that do you want to make a motion now I'm concerned about this 100,000 M me too so that not to exceed yeah okay Mr Wrong okay do you have any information on this because uh that you can provide the trustees like right now so B they're going to vote on it we're
114going to I'm going to pull it is this an urgent item it started July 1st 2024 is what it says here I mean it already started right so yeah especially I need to know how many schools I'd have to check with the Department do you have more information Alejandro actually we used to rescape to provide the for the school we have ale can you come to the podium please oh are you are you Mr Mulch uh not but close enough we just to escape as a service to provide the MCH for all the 50 schools that we have to maintain the landscape and control the weeds around all the bushes and everything so it's all the 50 schools yeah it's for all the 50 schools and we are under aceptance agreement so we don't exceed
115$114,000 a year and that provides material and application because sometimes it has to be imp sites it's a service agreement well I appreciate you being here you just saved mark thank you no problem thank you thank you aleandra thank you no problem so for 11c are we I'm good so move to accept them all of 11 C okay second all those in favor of item 11 c i i motion passes unanimously now was motion by trusty doming Sant is seconded by trusty too 11 D actually uh Mr Romero shared um already addressed it in under the district safety so I approve 11d second move by vice president Deo seconded by clerk Dominguez svantes all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously 11h well I started looking at some of the school plans we just
116got our agenda Friday night late so I have not had a chance to look at them all so my question at this point but I will be reviewing them in the next couple of days who in the district has a responsibility for reviewing these plans for accuracy Dr Reay that's a lot of plans yeah so it's our executive director uh Lonnie press was in the back somewhere raise your hand I can see your hand she's reading them right now yes so I'll move to approve this item as well I just want to let the board know that I'll be reviewing them because I think we need to start looking at Apples to Apples and see what the changes have been since the last time we looked at and if you have any questions please let
117us be happy to schedule a meeting with uh uh Miss Press thank you second moved by clerk dominga santes seconded by vice president the Mayo all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously 11 I um and I need to correct just before let me read the item this is approve the agreement and purchase of Library services from the San Diego County Office of Education for the period of January 1st 2025 through June 30th 2025 there was a correction from December 1st 2024 so it is accurate and to say January 1st 2025 through June 30th 2025 all right thank you uh if we have to pay 8,978 from January 1st 2025 to June 30th 2025 for the Office of Education to serve as the quote librarian of records for cvd we should not be calling
118that service to do X Y and Z as free or discounted so why are we paying for these Services because they they speak about how they'll do this for us and they'll do that for us for free well it's not free we just paid them $8,900 $897 Dr Rees M Carol thank you so according to California Ed code in several sections we are required as a district to have a librarian of record um either if we don't have one you know on site or in our district then that's why we are Contracting with the county office so what it equates to is about 49 cents per student normally for a whole Year's worth of service this is that uh portion of the pro rated portion for the remainder of the year and you're right it
119does sound a little misleading to say that it's for free but what I think really it's more intended to uh Encompass is the support that they provide both with um providing professional learning opportunities that they do actually charge other places for other school districts who aren't contracted with them it provides them guidance on book selection it helps them with learning some of the um tools that they use within the library their cataloging system things like that it they will provide you know um coaching and support for perhaps new people it does get really extensive but then I would um amend it to delete free and discounted it's fine we paid for it they're going to provide those Services that's fine for that fee but it should not read includes free and discounted because you're paying
120for it okay can we live with that AB absolutely we can fix that yes okay move to appr before we vote I have a question for our lawyers yes yes CU I know the question I know the question too I bet you do so lawers that's so I currently work for the San dieo County Office of Education this contract is with the san dieo county of Education normally I would abstain from all these contracts even if they're not directly with my work but because I work for for them I would uh abstain uh or recuse um what should I do and what is the process that we would this be an exception or would he be allowed to vote um may I ask which department you work with it technology with it and so do
121you have any involvement relative to the librarian of record no no I would say on this one you can vote thank you and so just for clarification purpose let's say he did work for that department then he would have to abstain and then at that point two votes would suffice um that's I I don't want to create it's one we would have to consider cor it's why it's why when when you look at when you have the agenda coming up I think my colleague and I would love to have notice so we could have some time to consider whether that rule of necessity would apply but in this one I think it's it's so attenuated from what you do for the county office and also the amount that's an issue I think I heard it
122right about $8,000 right I think you can vote on it with confidence okay thank you you're welcome so because I'm able to vote on it let me speak on it so um it says that it's costing us 800 8,000 oh 8,000 never mind we can I'm okay with it second moved by clerk Dominguez Sant seconded by vice president Deo all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously P yes approve Award of requests for qualifications and RFP number 24 25-6 Children and Youth Behavioral Health Initiative software provider to Healthy Campus my questions involve around the exact description implementation plan training and materials electronic health record functionality custom mil custom ability and patient engagement data integration and Reporting billing functionality and administrative considerations I'd like to know why we need this who would be using this
123software who are the patients how is the patient engaged who is reporting according what to whom Mr and I've got more questions after that thank you and I might have to rely on some of my colleagues Mr Romero or Miss Casey um on some of the questions but this contract is for um The Children and Youth Behavior initiative software um and we received a grant um through the state of California for this implementation of this um of this software um so we went out to RFP to find a provider that will help us design the software um to meet our needs and um we have staff that meet with students um on various there's about 52 um claimable claimable um services and so this software will help us record all of that and um request
124reimbursement back from the state for those services to students so so this Grant requires that you record interactions with the child and that's the condition to them giving you this money it's the proof of service that was provided real quick on clarification on record so we're not recording the interactions we we be recording the times that we met with them so if child a met with our service provider for 54 minutes we were record that we met for this reason maybe as Council for 54 minutes we wouldn't be recording the conversation or the interaction with the student just one point of clarification on that yeah so there's no discussion on what the meeting was about yeah so it's just to for billing purposes we saw child a b c for 15 minutes minutes yes we
125currently do this uh right now so uh with our medical reimbursement we already do this what this grant is allowing is students that don't qualify for medical that are funded through insurance so we can Bill back for that so this is happening to the Thousand school districts up and down our state um so this is just a standard thing that's happening but it's going to allow us to have a uh the software to track the usage of of those meetings so we we'll be notifying parents that their child's information obviously you have to put some identifiers in there a seven-year-old a 12year old a 4year old you have to put something in there do you know what the software looks like yes we have looked at the software and we uh we did uh were
126there three three three three software companies that we looked at um and so they have this one is the sole source the only one that has and I don't remember the the the certification for safety uh that they have but no other one h no other software company has this safety certification they are the sole source for this safety um uh process uh that the information that that of that's collected uh won't be able to be shared by any any Outside Agency but yes to answer your questions the only way these Services can be provided is with parent consent how what's the what's the time sensitivity on this uh the grant was funded the time sensitivity is immediate because we're looking to implement in January so so so just you know this right here um
127does not change any of the of what we're doing right now we already doing all that this right here is just a way for us to collect uh for billing purpos for billing purposes so all the service everything we're doing that right now it's only for billing purposes only to justify that we using your money appropriately and not going out for coffee exactly completely exactly so so I just want to make sure that clarify that okay it's not additional Services none of that nothing else is being collected on the child on the student nothing okay because it does say patient engagement so that's why I need the clarification thank you thank you move to approve second move by clerk Dominguez santes seconded by vice president de Mayo all those in favor I I motion carries
128unanimously 11 Q yes it says ratify amendment to two Grant agreements with the San Diego County Air Pollution Control District first to make a statement and then the question number one batteries did not make electricity they store electricity produced elsewhere primarily by coal uranium natural gas powered plants or fuel F diesel fuel generators so so to say an electric vehicle EV is zero emission is not quite that true but in regards to the fiscal impact and in light that we are looking to cut approximately $15 million from somewhere I propose we amend the motion to only buy what the grants cover Mr BR thank you and so these um these buses were um applied for under the San Diego San Diego County Air Pollution Control District um they have a grant program that helps us
129uh replace uh diesel school buses with the electric or CG and so we've already replaced four of them through the first round and because of the decrease in the grant originally we were projecting to P be able to purchase three with the grant funds but we're only going to purchase two now so um yeah so I think I'm still hearing or not hearing that it's going to cost us when we have a grant says dollar amount fiscal impact yes 9,371 I'm not approving that so the reason why that we really need these CNG buses is because the electric vehicles um will not make it up to the sixth grade camp and so um that's the main reason why we really need the CG ones because they have the longer distance um versus electric ones so
130is your issue the $89,000 that's saying um that is going to cost in addition to the mon money from the grant correct correct uh the grant only provides 165,000 per bus which doesn't cover the whole bus so there is estimated out of pocket do we not have gasoline buses anymore we do but they are getting very old and so that's why as the grant come up we're replacing the oldest ones with um with new vehicles so I'm proposing that you use the grant money to buy what you can buy we're not giving away money anymore we're short on money so what budget are we using for this uh we're using the unrestricted Reserve yeah so currently uh we use the diesel buses for trips that are like for the camps Etc correct and so what
131I'm hearing from you is that those buses are eventually they they need to be replaced right I mean we have buses that are breaking down every day that you know we're constantly repairing and so that we're in a um replenishment or cycle we're cycling out the oldest Vehicles so right now how many buses are you proposing to you buy here three two originally we had planned on buying three but since they lowered the grand amount we proposed only buying two and if we take away the the 89,000 you're only going to buy one none none none because it's per bus correct so it's it's not a total amount it's uh they give you an amount per bus and so there's still a gap it's applying it to USS so if we don't purchase the buses
132we lose the grant correct so otherwise we would have to pay fully out of pocket for these replacement Vehicles so you're telling me you're buying them anyway we we need to buy them or lose the money that's what I'm hearing and eventually we need to buy them because with the the buzzes without a grant and we'll cost they are budgeted for in this current Year's budget m I have a problem with being pressed with making these decisions on like this at a drop of a hat and not having been better prepared giving a little bit more time to ask a little bit more questions would what is the sensitivity of this item because if trusty Dominguez just needs more time we could table the this item and bring it back at the next board meeting
133when does the grant expire so we have to have the fully operational bus by Fe end of February but didn't didn't I read something that says that you couldn't even get the buses they couldn't come and that's why you're ex keep extending right so that was the initial case but now the vendor has it in stock and where is the vendor um in California or I'm not not sure I'll have to check what I'm saying is we need to receive it or or buy it no we should receive it we need to receive it yes by when January February 28th it's not a lot of time so without this grant it would cost us how much let's say this grant was not available you would still be before us asking us to purchase this bus
134mhm yes how much would it cost us there're 280,000 each and at this point it would be 89,000 I beg grudged approve second move by trustee dominga sedantes seconded by vice president too all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously um vice president Theo 11t 11t um similar I um issue as the previous item where I do work for the Sano County Office of Education uh this item is with the induction program and professional development Workshop Services which I do not have any direct line so I will follow the same guidance um it's an item for $3,375 are we still good same reason okay all right thank you okay move move to approve second move by uh vice president Deo seconded by clerk Dominguez santes all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously
135do you do you need a break anybody yes five minutes we'll take a five minute break and return at 8:20 e e e our newly hired and promoted employees thank you let me get to that page really quick governing board superintendent in our community it's my pleasure to announce our newly promoted employees so our first employee Mario kabada who's a lead painter to facilities maintenance supervisor congratulations Mario Frankie Carmona from heavy equipment uh to after school emergency respon technician you'll hear them as acert congratulations Frankie Eugene Gutierrez from bus driver to shift lead bus driver congratulations Eugene GMO Guzman Jr who's going from bus driver to shift lead bus driver congratulations kmo Veronica Hernandez who's going from a noon Duty supervisor to an instructional assistant special education congratulations Veronica Alejandro Herrera who's going from heavy
136equipment mechanic to locksmith uh congratulations [Applause] Alejandro Maria de Jesus Mendes who's going from bus driver to shift lead bus driver congratulations Maria Pablo muo who's going from bus driver to shift lead bus driver congratulations Pablo Carlos Otis who's going from technician equipment uh technology equipment technician to systems analyst one congratulations [Applause] Carlos ulalia Perez who's going from CNS one to CNS 3 congratulations Miss Perez guo robbles who's going from bus driver to shift lead bus driver congratulations guo Jose Joseph excuse me ru who's going from lead irrigation control specialist to irrigation systems and ground supervisor congratulations Joseph and last but not least uh Caesar Zapata oliveres who's going from Van Driver to bus driver congratulations Caesar that concludes our newly promoted employees thank you I would like to give a congratulations to all of
137our reclassified temporary teachers who have moved on to probationary status 27 [Applause] thank you Mr RTO all right public hearings the public hearing section provides the public with an opportunity to address the board on specific items persons wishing to address the board on any public hearing item must complete a request to be heard card and submit it to the recording secretary before the start of the meeting speakers are requested to limit their remarks to 3 minutes and speak in a respectful and professional manner the board shall limit the total time for input on each public hearing item to 20 minutes with board consent the president may increase or decrease the time allowed for public comments on each public hearing item depending on the topic and number of persons wishing to be heard we have no
138um speakers for public hearing I'm now opening the public hearing conducting the public hearing to receive input on the agreement with the Trula Vista Educators and ratify amend the tenative agreement with the trul Vista Educators for article 51 Health conduct a public hearing to receive the input on the tentative agreement with the administrators Association of Chula Vista and ratify amend the tenative agreement with the administrators Association of Chula Vista for article 17 health benefits I am now closing the hearing do we have board comments or questions I have a question first I want to make a statement that I do recognize the need for this health benefit increase I appreciate that it was able to be resolved uh but I I'm just trying to understand I may be un misunderstanding question C on page two
139it asks if the cost of the agreement necessitates budget reductions in the current and subsequent two fiscal years the response is no but then on page 7 there is combined uh a million million 648 to increase the health cap for certificated and uh principles is that correct I just want to understand Dr Rees Mr pun correct so that statement means that we're able to continue to meet the 3% um minimum State Reserve in the three years um if we continue with this moving forward so without any Cuts we're still able to maintain our 3% Reserve okay so you were able to find the funding in these other Pockets to cover this yes all right thank you vice president the no I just want to thank the district and cve for coming to a agreement that
140uh honors the work of families and also employees uh plus one and for the district to recognizing that health insurance is something that's continued to go go up every unfortunately every year and um every year our our employees take a pay cut because of that need for insurance and the continuing increasing of that so I'm happy that we were able to come together and and I thank uh cve for being creative being thinking outside the box on how can we look at benefits from a different perspective because this is something new uh something that we haven't done before um but it's it's created enough that it provides the much needed help uh for for some of our employees uh in honoring their work so thank you so much I just want to emphasize um something
141that I learned during uh my meeting with Dr Reyes um in preparing for tonight's board meeting I asked about the bargaining conditions for aacv and was told that aacv didn't bargain um because of a me too clause and in contract so it's in their contract language and I asked to see the language because bargaining is not an easy task it's a heavy burden it's one that requires preparation tenacity and resiliency in addition it requires organization and mobilization and motivation of Association members to act for the benefit of all over the wants of the individual and I want to emphasize this because I would hope that aacv recognizes and acknowledges cve and the work that they did in carrying that burden um and with that I will move to approve this this public he these public
142hearing items okay so move by Me seconded by truste Domingas cantes all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously 13 administrative action items approv revisions to the fiscal year 20242 budget approve the first interim financial report and certify the district's financial status for the fiscal year 2425 Mr pong thank you and good evening president Ugarte members of the board and superintendent Dr Reyes and members of the community tonight we have for your review and approval the first interum budget report and I just want to start off by thanking the fiscal service fiscal services staff um we did recently transition to people soft so um we were learning throughout this process um so I just want to thank them because it did take a little bit longer this time around because it was a new
143system so when we look at our general fund compared to our adopted budget we had Revenue adjustments of uh 16.8 million bringing us up to 400 million in the first interim and revenues on the expenditure side we had at the adopted budget 4177 million budget adjustments of 18.9 million bringing us up to 436 million in expenditures so with these budget adjustments we did have um expenditures that um exceeded the revenue so we uh have a total decrease of budget adjustments of 2.1 million um so it's a total deficit of 36 million in the first interim budget we started with a beginning balance of 170 million and we are going down to a ending balance of 134 million in this 134 million we have um different allocations so we have nonspendable funds which is our warehouse
144supplies and our um revolving cash then we also have commitments which we'll see on another slide 48 and half million uh restricted funds of 51 of sorry 58 million and then our reserve for economic insurgencies 26.5 million which is about 6.1% of our budget when we look at our budget we want to look at the unrestricted and restricted separately so um on our unrestricted we can see that we have a decrease to the reserve of 12.5 million at the adoption we were at 18.8 million so we did make some adjustments in the right direction um and then on the restricted side we're at a um decrease to the fund balance of uh just under 24 million so what were some of the changes on the revenue side under the local control funding formula sources we
145did increase our um Ada mainly due to transitional kindergart um because that part wasn't budgeted at the time um so we had an increase in our Ada and also an increase in our attendance Factor so um that increased up to 95.3% um in a total of 2.2 million increase in revenue on the federal side uh we are recognizing revenue from the previous year and this is um federal funds that uh are carried over and federal funds funds are offset in expenditures so they wash um because we don't receive federal revenue until we actually spend the money so there's 2.7 million um in increases there on the state revenue side uh we have just under 4 million in ex uh Revenue increases a large portion of this was due to the Community Schools Grant um we
146received um a state Grant to implement Community Schools at additional schools uh we also had an increase in our state lottery funding and then our transportation reimbursement and then in the local Revenue this is mainly due to a recognition of higher interest um and Medical reimbursements on the expenditure side we had um salary and benefits adjustments a reduction of 2.2 million um this reflects our payroll through October 31st on the books and supplies this is um 17.5 million increase this contains um carryover funds from the school sites uh budgeting for that Community School Grant uh a textbook um replenishment that we're projecting um to come in before the end of the school year and then also student and staff devices that um we need to replace on the services we have an increase of 1.3
147million um this is from some of our medic health services that we had received some revenue for and also carryover and then the other expenditures uh an increase of 2.2 million uh we have budgeted for vehicles and some of our heavy equipment so a total increase of 18.9 million for our district commitments we're looking at Safety and Security measures uh reserving 1.5 million for those uh vehicle and again the heavy equipment replacement another 3 million um and heavy equipment these are um some of our really big mowers tractors and those kind of items that are pretty costly um and they're towards the end of their useful life staff devices um we're looking at uh placement plan for student and staff devices um and putting those on a lease so that way um it becomes an
148operational cost for us um textbook replacement future textbook Replacements we have a couple of adoptions coming up and then we also are reserving for future one time expenditures so as we're doing our input tours um we're getting feedback and um looking at some of that data that we're receiving and what are onetime expenditures that we can help support the schools this would also help us to um reduce some of our cuts that we need and um be able to take time to make those reductions and provide a soft Landing when we look at our multi-year projection we can see on that blue bar that we continue to have a $12 million um decrease to the fund balance and right now this is only estimated this is based off of the 2425 budget um we have
149received um information from the legislative analyst which is a um impartial to the Department of Finance that we're looking at a potential lower Cola than what was um projected in the current budget so we're continuing to monitor that but that'll affect um the $12 million reduction we're also continuing to monitor our enrollment so um we're looking at our demographic studies um and we know that we're increasing um attendance for transitional kindergarten and there's development within the district but overall um our larger cohorts in the sixth grade are not being replaced with um the same siiz cohorts in kindergarten in first grade and when we look at our restricted funds we can see a dip from 23 million reduction down to $10 million reduction this is due to some onetime funds that we're spending down and
150when we look at our overall combined we can see at the bottom that we have our restricted ending fund balance going from 6.1% down to 3.1% um in the second year so we can see that we're pulling from our commitments um the commitment line and then the reserve for economic uncertainty to um to meet that reduction of $12 million each year so when we look at our multi-year projection um on this part on this chart the top line is that 8% um goal of of the board the blue line is our actual reserve and then the red line is a state minimum requirement and again this is all based off of the current 2425 budget um and what we're looking ahead to is the governor will be releasing a new proposal for the 2526 school
151year in January where we've already began planning for the 2526 budget so we're monitoring the enrollment and Staffing projections along with uh Human Resources the implementation of the uh children and youth Behavior Health Initiative Grant um there's potential for that to provide some Revenue to the district and we're looking at an lcap update at the February board meeting and then we're continuing to monitor our facility needs and prioritizing projects and with that I'll open it for any questions or comments questions yes on slide six there's reference to textbook replacement I'm just curious as to how we came up with that $12 million quote Dr Rees uh M Carol can you talk about the the cost for testbook textbooks and then can we have uh Mr P add to the cost of devices so as you
152know we are getting ready to um look at ordering for next year and being ready we are at the end of our cycle for our the materials that we have right now so in order to replenish our English language arts and English language development programs in both English and in Spanish we need to be able to um purchase that out for the next however many years is determined in order to make sure that our students have they they come with the books so the set all the new materials come together but what is interesting about now current adoptions is that every year then those replenishables Come Those student consumable books that come each year instead of a big hard-bound textbook so we continue to get those in the following years until the next round of
153an adoption cycle for ELA we also have math that we need to get those materials as well each year because we are not currently in a long-term contract with any math program until we go through a formal math adoption process and then we'll have a longer period of time there so we're trying to to get all of that uh squared away so that teachers have their materials before they leave for summer break and they're ready to go for the next year so we'll spend $12 million between now and June no no that's that's not I'm sorry I misunderstood that's not all 12 million will not be spent for this year we're talking about just for language arts and for the the math materials that we would be getting now yes so so 12 million is
154not for just one year uh because we look at so can you explain Mr sprong how it um it's for the the following years and how how we include the devices yes so um this is setting aside funds for future years because um it's such a large amount where um we need to spend from the reserve to be able to um um do some of these adoptions um and then the student devices we're looking at um over 15,000 devices so it'll be grades 3rd through six that'll be um replenished and then we're also looking at all of our instructional staff um and devices that need to be replenished so um well that's 8 million student and staff device replacement yes that's not the 12 million we're speaking of oh sorry I moved on so the
155textbook replacement that those are for future adoptions the multiple years okay and then the student devices right now um technology is in the process of piloting some Chromebooks and then we're also how much did we spend in the last two years actually spend in the last two years on textbook replacement so if you include uh the just sence yes so the last two years we did science benchmark and I already right so if we were to look at that that's that's over 12 million right there right because science was five to six plus Benchmark plus math and we do know that many teachers are not using twig right that they're not they're not being used we do know that right but that's they're not using it yet so we bought them and they're not using
156it well we we're going to continue to help support them in using it because we know that's an important part of every child's education all right well I'm looking forward to that Str strategic plan the project plan that I've been asking for so looking forward to seeing that on there thank you thank you just all right so we have 12 million for textbook um the same 12 million you were talking about um textbook replacement but then on the previous slide we have 17 and a half million for books and supplies what is the difference so the one in the 17 million is for a a benchmark of replenishment which is the ELA curriculum and then the 12 million is for future adoptions that Miss um Carol had mentioned and no no so the 17 million
157would be all total right if I'm understanding the the way that this works the 17 model would would be all total that's not just Benchmark right now and as we look at the so for Benchmark right now that would be a portion of it and then as we move out for the the 12 million takes us out multiple years years for the different curriculum that you're going to need to purchase by year or by groups of years depending on how you want to contract with them so for this 17 million and 17 A5 million what are we going to do this year before the end of the school year it is my understanding that I say we still yes we we still that we will be purchasing the um language arts and Lang language development
158program for the new school year and continuing with math the current program that we are use utilizing until we go through a formal adoption so that will H and the math program will have to be um purchased each year until we go through a formal adoption where then you may be considering a multi-year purchase so with the 17 A5 million we're buying language s and with the 12 million we're going to buy no so so and and so I'm I'm not the the money expert on this but right now the the language arts and in ELD and math for this year that's a portion of that 17 million that's not all it won't cost 17 million for all of that so so so so yeah part of the expenditures is for this year but also
159we're looking at a multi year projection of expenditures plus the devices right so so so each year the difference is that each year even though we're not doing the adoption we have to to replenish replenish materials replenish all and so we're trying to be ready for those multiple years coming up and so it would be this year be helpful for me to better understand this if I could you know maybe on a Friday update get a breakdown of how we're going to spend it when are we going to spend it uh because right now in my mind we have 29 and A5 million for textbooks that so that's 17 million in books and supplies that's not all textbooks only six million of that is for the the ELA Benchmark right see and that would help
160if if I can get a breakdown of of the 17 million six million are for books and then the rest of are toilet paper because you know um or supplies or supplies right um the other thing is um these one-time expenditures if I can also get a breakdown of what are we spending for on onetime money uh 24 million and I would love to know more about your $8 million investment so for devices so are we looking to do we're looking to do Opex on here so you're buying this year and then you're going to replace them three four years down the road so if you're going to do that then every year we're going to put $2 million in in the bank to save for that four year or or these 15 devices are
161they enough to replace the whole thing that we have how many devices do we need so we're projecting just over 15,000 um right now and it's projected to be 10 million over five years so um you know we're splitting the cost 2 million per year so this will represent the four future years that we would have to make a lease payment for um setting aside funds for that okay this inclusive for four years so this this is a commitment but it represents four years correct okay for that for for the devices so while we're committing to this we're really only spending two in the current year in the current year yes okay all right can I ask one more question I'm sorry Tristy president one more question so up here in the SE in the
16217 million books and supplies supplies does that mean ink because I hear teachers all the time talking about not having Inc is that coming out of school site funds I mean they're shaking the cartridge and all of this stuff trying to get the last piece of anything and they're doing fundraisers I don't know if you look at nextto app the nextd door app parents are on their asking for um pencils paper and so that shouldn't be the case right that should not be the case Mr Punk right so that's kind of a broad category but in fall under that books and supplies category so is that something we pay or coming out of the school site funds it's coming out of school site funds that we allocate so so so principal should be ordering that
163for the for their sites so in that scenario printers are those standardized from the district or are teachers able to bring their own printer I have to defer to take if if that's okay they purchased one of our approved printers from the the bid the North County consortion bid they're HP printers there are some cheaper ones there are more expensive ones that do fancier things we will permit donated Printers Home printers to be brought in but as a USB printer only connected to a computer with some security stipulation if I'm donating printers am am I also is a district going to cover the the ink for the printer or do I I have to donate a standard printer how did that work if you were to donate one of our approved printers to the school
164site okay so only approved printers I can Don it if you went to Best Buy and bought a Canon printer and you gave it to the the School site with the ink in it they would be responsible to purchase the ink for it and our technician would help them to install it but we would not provide support on the printer because it's not one of our supported units we would help them set it up and that's about it got it so that's probably was happening thank Youk my only comment or question was going to be that um on slides five and six that um trusty the Mayo already asked that we get a breakdown of that and then I think in our printed version just so that none of us are confused on Slide Five
165um the total expenditures um the numbers add up but on ours it says decrease and it's in parenthesis and we all know what that means so I just want to to clarify that that what you have up there is accurate it's not a decrease okay it's an increase to the total expenditure okay just wanted to make sure thank you right right right but it's on here so I didn't want any of us to be confused about that you didn't have any ink thank you Mr pong for your presentation uh move to approve second move by um vice president the Mayo seconded by clerk Dominguez serantes all those in favor of accepting the financial status the first interim and the revisions to the fiscal year please say I I I motion carries unanimously what you've all
166been waiting for item I know but I need to read it Item B contingent upon board approval of provisional appointments described in board bylaw 9223 approve the vacancy timeline and process for ction appointments of provisional board members for seat 1 and seat five and schedule a s a special meeting Dr Reyes hi I'm going to ask uh our attorneys to please provide us with uh some legal content of some of the things that we can do or or the board can do to either appoint or call for a special election and what are some of the timelines uh per Ed code sure well hello again might I interject right now president I just wanted to make sure that that was emphasized because the way the agenda is read reads it reads about only an appointment
167it doesn't specify call specifically call out that we have not decided on one or the other so thank you for calling that out okay um so when a vacancy arises well first of all a vacancy on the board arises when the resignation is filed with the county superintendent so my understanding is that within the past several days um both resignations have been filed with the super with the county suit once that happens then there's a 60-day time period where the board has the right to um either make a provisional appointment which would be effective through I think two 2026 would be the next regularly scheduled election so that's one option that the board has to make the provisional appointment or the second option is to call a special election if the board members do not
168take either action then the authority goes to the county superintendent who then as a matter of law has to call for a special election the reality is a special election is very in a very expensive proposition um because you have two vacancies I I don't think it would be I don't know whether the districts costed it out or talk to you have but it probably exceeds a million dollars so just for clarification we did call the count rears it's uh anywhere from 2.2 to 2.9 Million oh right because it's two say that again from uh 2.2 to 2.9 Million and that's a it's an estimate you called it County records we call it yes we call it County Register voters register rep register voters thank you so it is it's it's very expensive um but
169to get back to when I was up before the board earlier this evening the reality is is to make an appointment there has to be a unanimous decision by all three board members um so if in fact there's going to be a provisional appointment made by the board your um board bylaws it's 9223 is the relevant board bylaw to uh review and also the relevant Ed code or government code sections actually Ed code sections are uh sections 591 um through about 59045 those are the key sections um of the code which sort of spell out the requirements but if in fact a a provisional appointment is is going to be made um you will need to be unanimous it has to happen like I said within that 60-day time period but then your board bylaw
1709223 essentially gives a choice um as to what you can do um and there are as as you pointed out uh Miss Dominguez cantes it it it gives two options and in summary um one is a nominating process where there could be nominations for to fill the vacancy um and then the other one is really where you have a detailed application process where you have candidates who first of all there could be a subcommittee appointed by the board the subcommittee would review applications um so to make sure that those um board member candidates are actually eligible to run then there's an interview process that would happen at a board meeting and then the board has to make a selection all of those things happen all of it is open session um consideration because it is
171a board member and I think the key thing is and and we'd be happy to sort of share all of the different steps that we recommend happen or I could review them if you want me to go into the details of that um but I think what's really important is that once you identify the process or you identify the subcommittee the subcommittee working with the superintendent perhaps working with us as far as what those proced procedures are I think the key thing is to get it up on your website and to publicize it so that those people that are interested know what the process is and then also the public knows what the process is going to be and sort of the timeline and the different steps um that are at issue or that you're
172going to be following before the board actually makes um a provisional appointment but in a nutshell I think the the different the different steps would be I think think establishing that subcommittee so you can sort of figure out your process and the subcommittee would be to board members um but figuring out what the making sure that people who submit applications are eligible um create sort of what the application requirements are what information do you want to receive from different candidates as to their qualifications their experience what their views are on on being a board member um I think also I recommend that you add ad vertise um widely disseminate hey this is this is the timeline we're going to be making a provisional appointment on this date if you're interested in the position then you
173should consider um you know submitting an application and here's the process which is on our website um and then really having a meeting where you would review and discuss the candidates and interview them is that me that's uh feeding back not sure what that is I know it's some humm okay just make sure it's not me okay um and and then the board deliberates talks about the different candidates there would be opportunity for public comment from those that attend the meeting to give input or suggestions that they have for the board and then ultimately there's a vote and like I've said the the vote would have to be unanimous and then the one thing I'll add after that is even though if if the board exercises its right to make the provisional appointment within 10
174days after that decision there has to be publication in three public places one newspaper of General circulation about who you are appointing and even then if certain petition requirements are met members of the public could still call for a special election that's their right after the board exercises it's right to make a provisional appointment but it requires you know 1 and a half% or 5% of this I won't go into those details right now but that is a possibility that even if the board does make an appointment decision if there could be a petition calling for a special election question and I'd be happy if there are any questions you have I'd be happy to answer them yes question so my uh opinion and I'm not an attorney the way we're listed this on the
175agenda should it have been B and C vers you know versus it all be clumped into one because it should be two different agenda items no I I don't think I I think it gives the public sufficient notice okay as to what's being discussed by the board and I think if people were interested in the vacancy process or the different options I think it's it's sufficient substantial compliance right so when we come back around with whatever decisions we're making we can distinguish them as two different agenda items you you can if that's what you choose to do of course thank you thank you may I just share with the public that I submitted several questions to Dr Reyes who submitted it to uh legal to clarify some of these questions and they're kind enough to
176bring it bring you guys in so you could share with the public as well what you've shared with us oh thank you very much thank you thank you for you go ahead can you let them go wait no wait wait so I also want to share with with the public that uh these are not our uh District lawyer um legal council uh we asked that we had an independent legal uh firm to come in and help us with us because we wanted some we wanted to provide additional transparency that is not uh legal council that is um um Contra contracted uh ongoing that has an ongoing contract or are they're really tied to yes they are they are I don't want to may I Dr yes yes I don't want to mislead the public we
177we are um one of your law firms that is under contract we do not regularly advise the board though on these kinds of issues okay so so to clarify normally our legal council for issues of the board go through Dean Adams and Silva that is the legal firm that we typically use for anything that the board has uh questions or the district or the superintendent has questions um that is what I try to meant there so what we wanted to do is have somebody different uh in this case didn't want to thank you okay thank you um other questions you have any more questions Delia I'm sure they'll come okay yeah you dismiss them or do you want them to stay we do need you to stay Thank you do you need some water or
178just if water if you need a break you're good thank you yes it just thank you we appreciate it as we proceed and just finish this agenda item thank you we have four speakers take it them now sure Manny Rubio good evening president Ugarte vice president to Mayo trustees domingus cantes Dr Reyes and rest of the cabinet my name is Manny Rubio I'm a parent of two students in the district as well as my wife and I are I like to think we're super volunteers and a number of committees and organiz through different things that we do um here at the district and for the students um I just want to say you know I think this is something that is um a great opportunity I think for this District I'm going to take it
179from The Stance of you know definitely we have two vacancies on this board um but this is definitely an opportunity for the district and I think in in what I mean for that is that there is an opportunity for the trustees and for this District to create a legacy of what's next um by that I mean that we can move forward with a decision regardless of a lot of things that are going on we know that there is quite a bit of attention to things that have gone on in terms of South County politics and South County happenings over the last several years uh me having firsthand experience in some of those issues but I really think that there is an opportunity for us regardless of politics regardless of favor regardless of interest to appoint
180somebody who only interest or I'm sorry two people whose only Interest Who the only interest should always be around the students and the families of this District I really think that this is an opportunity for us to as an organization and I I say us because I am part of this District I am a regular part of this district and the going on so I really think this is an opportunity for us to step forward and do something that really shows the entire County that we are focused on our students and our families I'm sure there are going to be a number of very well-qualified candidates there's going to be a number of people who are interested in this and I think at the end of the day what we really have to just make
181clear is that the two appointees that we bring to this and I understand that yes there is that opportunity for an election and I understand why the opportunity would be to go towards an an appointment I understand that whole process I'm not that's not lost on me or anybody else really but I think again this is an opportunity for us and I just really want to just Echo that and I think there's a lot of folks that you know we come in contact with my my family and I come in contact with different students and parents and families who really just want this District to succeed and at the end of the day that's why I'm here that's why I do what I do for this District and for my for my students and for
182others um and I think it's an opportunity so I really hope that this board recognizes that and seizes that opportunity thank you thank you Karen Ramirez Dominguez no relation yes unfortunately there is no relationship good a good evening members of the board superintendent than everybody else around my name is Karen Ramirez Dominguez and I am honored to address you in this evening I am here to discuss the choice between that you are holding either a special election or making an appointment of we as we heard today a special election it's 2 almost $3 million I will also like to humbly propose myself for that appointment with my background in child development and my daily work as a noon Duty in this school district and a parent of two children in this District I bring a
183unique and valuable perspective to this role one that combines handon experience Professional Knowledge and personal investment for this the school district to succeed during my previous campaign I ran and I earned over 20,000 votes I ran against Caesar Fernandez and other previous School members I was I was honored to also receive the endorsements of respective Community leaders this level of support demonstrates the trust and confidence our community has placed in my ability to serve effectively I strongly believe that moving forward with an appointment rather than a special election is the most responsible and practical decision for our district a special election will delay progress and divert significant financial resources funds that could instead go forward improving classrooms supporting our teachers as we've heard today also ensuring the success of our students an an appointment allows
184us to maintain stability and focus on whatever is most important which is providing the best possible education to our children if appointed I am ready to step into the role immediately my priorities are clear I propose putting Family Values at a Forefront of ensuring that parents have a central role in and shaping our decisions I've heard parents today I've heard him say I've called I've emailed and one of my one of things I want to do is to be available I want to collaborate I want to have communication and collaboration between the board the family and Educators I believe that we can create a stronger more Unified District when we every child could drive I thank you for considering me for this position I am ready to work alongside you to move forward the district
185without delay and to make a meaningful difference in the families of our children thank you so much thank you Elizabeth efford good evening esteemed members of the board faculty parents and community members my name is Elizabeth eford and I am honored to stand before you to nominate myself as a candidate Cate for the Chula Vista Elementary School Board I have lived in Chula Vista for 13 years and even graduated from otai Ranch High School I'm deeply passionate about the mission of our schools to nurture the minds and spirits of our children I would love the opportunity to contribute to that mission I hold a master's degree in child development an advanced certificate in education and mental health and a bachelor's degree in child and family Development I've P I've pursued this educational path with the
186intention of giving back to my community a moment that deeply resonated with me was the November's tribute to military families many members of my family have served uh this country including both my mother and father in fact my family uh even fought in the War of 1812 I owe much of my academic journey to my father who enlisted in the United States Navy before I was born and serves to this day his service alone afforded me to go to college his service and the values he and my mother both instilled in me respect for human dignity equality and justice have s shaped who I am today and as a recent uh convert to Islam I also deeply value the freedoms we have especially the First Amendment which guarantees our right to practice our beliefs freely
187and to use our voices as I am doing right now I come from generations of hardworking Americans and I see The Same Spirit in the people of Chula Vista we are a community built on perseverance and we share a common desire for better opportunities for our children as an educator with years of experience including work with children with disabilities such as autism ADHD intellectual disabilities and physical disabilities I have gained a profound understanding of the unique obstacles these children fa um face barriers that go beyond academics and touch on emotional social and physical challenges this experience has fueled my commitment to a more inclusive education system one that supports the diverse needs of every student in today's sometimes polarized environment We Stand we must stand firm against discrimination every child regardless of race gender identity
188or background deserves to feel valued and supported and I am committed to fostering a safe inclusive and affirming environment for all students in closing I want to emphasize that my commitment to children's rights protections and dignity it's not just an abstract value for me it's something that I've lived learned and believe in deeply as a community it's our duty to serve these young people who look to us to help them shape their future I ask for your support as I seek the opportunity to serve on this board and continue and to continue working towards a brighter safer and more Equitable future for all students again my name is Elizabeth eford and I thank you for your time I'd also like to leave this behind thank you you Zenith KH okay well good morning everyone morning
189board trustees and um superintendent a pleasure to be here um my name is Zena Khan I am a mother of three children all attending Chula Vista elementary middle and high school I'm here today to express my interest in applying for the vacant Chulavista Elementary School Board seat I've been a proud resident of Chula Vista since 2009 and have a background in chemical engineering uh have been working in a leadership role within the pharmaceutical industry in San Diego for the past 17 years past three years I've also served as a substitute teacher for a Chula Vista based nonprofit organization uh additionally I've collaborated with various um nonprofit organizations to serve as a career adviser for immigrant and Refugee youth despite the many roles I'm most proud of being a mother of three children all of whom
190are currently attending as I mentioned uh Public elementary middle and high schools in Chila Vista as a parent I'm heavily involved uh with my children's education within the public school system um it's the it it is of the utmost importance to uplift our students by harvesting their confidence and encouraging them uh on their paths to higher education and successful careers so that um so that they too May ultimately be contributing um and uh influential me become influential members of our society I really appreciate everything that you guys do here I've seen the fruits of it uh by being a parent and um really appreciate and thank everyone who is currently in the board and in the Committees and visible or or working in the background of uh investing themselves um and really um supporting our
191children in the Chila Vista School District um given the opportunity to serve in the board I'm ready to hit the ground running invest my passion resources to Foster and Achieve successful learning for our children I'll strive to work together with fellow Schoolboard members to serve the community by preserving improving overall student academic achievement ensuring safe and productive learning environment um for all students and also focusing on um education programs curriculum with a focus on science uh technology Arts Engineering and math um again it's an honor to be here and be heard um I would be grateful to serve and protect our students here our parents honor our hardworking teachers um appreciate the time for your consideration support and again my name is zenat Khan and congratulations to uh relle um really appreciate all your time
192here thank you very much thank you [Applause] there are no more speakers thoughts thoughts as I shared earlier this agenda item didn't offer the opportunity to discuss the option of special election or appointment and I believe it'd be important for us it actually does the way that it reads it says may fill the vacancies through provisional appointment or election and then it only lists the other two because with an election we don't have to have those options so we have all three options available under this agenda item it's just that it doesn't need to be detail because it says right yeah I know it's it just we can so we can choose between all three right so do we want to take a position on what do we want to do is anyone in favor
193of an election I don't know that it will be in favor of an election but if we can't agree then by default it will go to special election correct correct if we can if we can agree Onision on appointment on appointment and um as we move forward because of the price tag on a special election um I would lean towards a appointment process uh with very clear guidelines as previously mentioned by legal and that it's called out as two separate agenda items so when we make motions we're making a motion on seat one and then motion seat three seat five so that it's not a slate motion uh just for claric clarification purposes the item can be one item with two seats and then the way you handle it it could be either by slates
194if you choose the the the you could be a slate or individual motions yeah and and I would have I would have no problem with I'm in agree I'm in agreement with regard to the election that it's costly um I we've been through the process before trusty Tam mayo and I years ago um and because of that we the cost um I wouldn't I would I'm I also agree with what Dr Reyes is saying in in the way kind of like this evening we had three options with appointing the board or doing our board um reorganization we could have done it each individually or we could do it as a slate but it was still only one agenda item and I and I I I would prefer that in the manner that when we're doing
195this and it's two seats that it would put the person if we're interviewing everyone the person we're we're almost favoring if we don't if we do two agenda items and we choose why are we choosing this person first versus this person second do you see what I'm saying so we have to be cautious with that realm um in looking at our options and I'll just throw it out there and we can talk about it um I like the idea of a subcommittee I like the idea of the questions um and I'm perfectly okay not being on that committee if it were to be a nomination of trustee Dominguez adantes and truste Tayo um I am in complete faith that you could handle that policy and those questions and doing all of that um but I'm
196I'm open here to conversation as well the reason I requesting that it's called I I get what you said about the Slate but it was simple it's just a three of us it wasn't 20 people so it either was going to be me the president or one or the other just the three of us were going to be the officers so that was uh for me anyway I was not volunteering to be the president and but um for the for the selection of um the appointee I think it's more Troublesome to say okay I nominate F you know number three and number seven as my appointees it just you might be fine with the number three but not fine with the seven you might be fine with the number seven but not with the three
197I think if we would all agree if we happen to agree on a particular one the one that rises to the top then we nominate that person or we discuss the top three or the top four or whatever that might be and see who Rises to the top so we get one seat done and then we move to the next seat so that we can have that discussion and it may be the same individuals we were just speaking of but which one's rising to the top another option might be in the application process do we ask and our legalists here do we ask and I don't know that it makes a difference to someone but our um interested uh candidates well I just want to be in seat number one or I just want to
198be in seat number five or they pick both I don't I don't know so it may be something particular for that individual which brings up a question if we were to do individual seats like that and that member became a seated board member before we F we determined the next board member would that board member be required to vote we have got the answer here in our so uh they would have to take the oath gotcha so they so so you can you can appoint but if unless they take and if they don't take the oath they can't vote once they take the oath then they can vote right and our legal gave us that well that was one of my questions I didn't I okay good so Madam president from what I'm hearing the
199board say I think uh the board is of the position to try to stay away from a special election so if the request from trustee the m Fernandes is to list the each seat as an individual item I think that's something we can work with because even if we have the discussion if we come up with a process with legal councel when we're discussing um at the end of who to appoint there might be consensus right that hey we saw fabulous applicants we saw two that all three of us um will would agree right at that point that might be a position but if not we can take uh an item at a time I I don't see that uh that as a prevention right now I think there's still a lot of that we
200need to work on the process with legal council on how the subcommittee is if that's what I'm hearing that the subcommittee is also acceptable um the subcommittee can develop that process with legal council and then bring it back to to the board and say here's how we're going to choose the top candidates yes please the short answer is yes you can do that but I would I would urge the the board to schedule two special meetings I think one is for the subcommittee to come back and say what's the application process process that they've developed and I think that should be you know you got to you got to figure out what the 60-day deadline is and then work backwards so you need to develop that application process give your candidates sufficient time to submit
201their applications and then I think you need to set up a meeting where you would be interviewing those applicants and then probably making a decision if if people are persuasive and convincing and you feel like you're there hopefully at that meeting you would be um calling for a vote um could it be possible for the board to have that discussion today come up with a the the timeline and the process so there's only one meeting where there would be interviewing the the finalists um I think that that is I think that the board could provide sufficient direction to you Dr Reyes and then we would work with you to to put what the board wants as far as the different components into a process and then distribute that on the website and then like you're
202saying then have do it in one meeting we've been known to stay here till midnight and 1:00 am. my bedtime is about 9:45 so if if I'm hearing that I'm also hearing that if we have to do a unanimous decision right basically all three have to agree if by virtue of not agreeing of one of us not agreeing even after multiple votes then that automatically triggers a sending it to the county superintendent and then she will trigger a special election right that is correct okay so if we agree on one which is a question you already answered but for the public sake uh so we agreed on one but not the other vacancy it's quite possible then that other vacancy is what would go to special election if we could not agree on candidate is
203that correct that is correct and i' I know you sent that but for the Public's sake so would the board be okay to take a motion to do an appointment process and to do a subcommittee of the board and assign the subcommittee members yes I'll move that the board takes the appointment process and create a subcommittee of two board members to develop the process to develop the process or to direct direct the I'm confused to direct the process or so to review can we I mean can we do it here so let let me let me B forget the the motion I move that we take the appointment process route okay I make I second that motion so moved by vice president de Mayo seconded by clerk Dominguez svantes to to go to move for
204the appointment process all those in favor I I okay motion carries unanimously all right now I will move to direct the superintendent to develop an application for interesting uh interested people or candidates to apply um and to be published at the district website three places you said right or three places three places okay so that's another motion that's different but but to to publicize your what I heard as far as the motion is concern directing the superintendent to develop an application process that's consistent with the law and hopefully generates a lot of interest within the commu community and then to publish that application process on the website ASAP yes okay okay so well Dr Rees where does the subcommittee or the ad hoc committee come in we're not there yet okay so in in this
205scenario okay the subcommittee would come in to review the applicants right and then we would work with legal counsel to gener uh generate the process on how we're going to select from those candidates sounds good do you agree on that I agree on that so the motion right now is to direct the superintendent to um develop the application and to do the publishing of the the process yes um do I have a second second motion by vice president Deo seconded by clerk Dominguez serantes all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously next third motion I move that we that this board creates a subcommittee of two board members and appoint truste Del cantes Domingo cantes and truste Tamayo to that uh subcommittee a second all those in favor I I I moved by truste
206vice president Tayo seconded by President ugar all those in favor we uh vote voted it was unanimous okay next next what else do we need special meeting date special meeting date do we have a special meeting date uh 17 I move that the special that the that the district uh adopts January 17 as a special board meeting date to 6 pm to review and interview candidates the candidates have been wait is that well I do think that reviewing eligibility requirements would be something that the subcommittee so the subcommittee doesn't need to meet in in a session a special subject to the brown act and it's less than right so January 17th interview and the process 6 p.m. will be the interview process of the candidates and the selection right yeah and the selection yes and
207then I think there's one more motion but we'll so Delia is that uh good with you that uh January 17th at 6: PM uh we have a special board meeting to um interview candidates only have to clarify some other dates go ahead so if Dr Reyes is going to develop an application for interested candidates publish it we need a turn around time I need to see that we have enough time here for January the 17th so there should be a turnaround time a due date that the applicants will have to submit their applications to you and then enough time for trustee tamay and myself to review for eligibility uh how much time would you would the subcommittee need a week and a half two weeks week and a half how many well how much time
208this is my life so I have more time than you guys do you guys have eight to five jobs so what a week and a half suffice so are you saying a week and a half to publish no no for the subcommittee to review the the applicants one the eligibility I mean if we have a thousand yes well yeah it depends well no no but I want to give you time there's work commitments and other commitments yes a work uh week window will work okay so then uh we can go ahead and publish by today's uh Monday by uh by the 18th so this Wednesday we can publish it and we can give uh because of the holidays we can do three weeks so we're publishing the 18th we we were close on the 8th
209close on the eight uh and then it would give you a week and a half to meet and review okay well I may not work but I do have family across the country so I'm going to go visit my great-granddaughter uh between December 27th and returning December 31st for four days okay that's fine okay it works yeah right so your motion so my motion is to establish a special meeting board meeting on January 17th at 6: p.m. for our selection for our selection process interview and select to interview and select two seats do have a second second okay motion by vice president de Mayo seconded by clerk Dominguez cantes all those in favor I okay thir uh fifth motion uh and then I think Bo and Dr Rees I think there's one last um motion
210um in in board bylaw 9223 yeah go ahead yes there there are two options um one is um to actually have an application process which I think is what the board in your in your deliberations you're describing um so that's option one or the second option in the board bylaw is board shall accept nominations at a public meeting and select provisional appointee from among those nominated by a majority vote so it sounds like option one is where where the discussion has been going but I think there should be you know a motion along the lines of following either opt following option one as set forth in board bylaw 9223 may I ask option one and option two seem to be a little blurry now for me based on what you're saying right now I thought
211we were describing option two that's what I thought too I'm looking uh you were describing sounded like option two yeah no this option one describes advertising in the local media having a having a committee uh consisting of less than a quorum of the board to ensure that applicants are eligible and then announcing the names of eligible candidates and then the board at some point interviewing the candidates at a public meeting and accept uh written or oral public input and then um select a provisional appointee by a majority vote that what that's what I'm sort of calling the application process that's option one well because uh the way we have it here uh it implies those last few steps as if they were part of provision um option two excuse me oh I'm reading I'm reading
212from what I believe to be board bylaw 9223 first page yes so you're correct the differences on option two the one that you're reading is that if you would tell me to for me to set to come up with a committee versus two board members okay the two board members uh is which is the one that you chose the the the the board approved would be option one so now we just need a motion on that we're going to do the application process and that still involves everything or option one is what I think I'd call it are you okay with that I am well I just his opt his options are different they're not reading off of what our what we have here but for transparency purposes and the public seeing this they see
213it it's not someone who's here listening to all this we need to amend this that option to so we we're talking about um and and I agree following board bylaw 9223 so the public May reference that board bylaw and in that board by what we've been describing and what I hear the board uh describe is uh utilizing provisional appointment option one correct so have it backwards so we have just have it backwards on on this side right so this needs to be amended [Music] so so we can you actually want to amend it she can do it yeah we can yeah we can we can do it on the minutes so it shows in the minutes right yes and then give me the correct version please okay so with that you're you're good I'm fine
214okay so since we're good on that I will make a motion to for the board to utilize provisional appointment option one with the application process with the application process thank you for that Amendment Pro and the subcommittee right of the board okay and and a second second okay by move by vice president to Mayo seconded by clerk Dominguez santes all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously are we good good are we done right before 9:40 94 thank you very much thank you so much thank you thank you first and second readings board bylaws um first and second reading board by 9200 by laws of the board so this is the one that Dr Reyes this is the one that what uh we discussed uh last week uh La last month that we were
215bringing against this month the one that um two of the trustees uh had some concerns with I I was good with it okay second move by vice president de Mayo seconded by clerk Dominguez santes all those in favor I I motion carries unanimously report calendar to the Board of Education trustee santes any reports you'd like to request yes last month I made a request for information on the number of ia's sped staff resigning the salary uh comparisons and I'd like to know when I'm going to see that Mr was that sent on a on a on a Friday update no no we were doing uh I can do that this Friday thank you but I believe um you were supposed to include it with this month's report but I I'd like the public to hear
216and see also there oh you wanna oh yes you can do a you can do a report to us but I want the public to know how we're running our business here so you would like it included in his report yes please okay so so what exactly okay so salary comparisons not just for our information because we get the briefing but our Union Partners do they get what so we already did the salary comparison um information do you want so is that uh something that we want to share I did send that in a weekly so you want it coming to a Bo a board item that's why I'm clear for salary comparisons I believe that our labor Partners um classify uh CB CEO you both of you talked right and did an analysis of
217the salaries yeah no and then for on my weekly I did send where San cidro South Bay National and Chula Vista and I compared and showed where we were so I can I can present that at at a so do you want to present that on a board meeting or do you want to share that with our labor Partners I want to share it with our labor Partners okay yeah the salary comparison where we at versus yeah I did that so what I'll do is I'll I'll include so the next meeting uh the next one one that you have with you with our labor Partners go ahead and share the the graph yeah the comparison and then trusty Domingas can follow up and ask them if they got if they got it right and then
218the Sweetwater Authority their their water was in the news this past week and we've been asking about that here for several months about their intent to put the solar panel on the water reservoir and the Very panels the very water that our fire comes by and gets buckets of water out to put fires out in hamu and uh on the 54 there was one month and a half ago so on top of that the concerns of the uh particles and what it how would it affect our water so I know we were starting to do something about testing our water for our students and staff correct so just you know I did have a meeting with uh I'm not not sure if he goes by CEO or what the T the main person uh I
219did share that uh we had some concerns from the board uh and from the district regarding uh the solar panels uh they are they were very firm on that they are going to be continuing to explore that that possibility not not nothing set in stone according to but but it's they're they're very firm and continuing to explore that um uh we know that um we were testing but our testing was for very very specific items it was for um uh for lead for Le and we were we were going to be expanding to other different I mean there's like hundreds of substances so we were where were we that Mr bong we can bring a contract to the next meeting thank you and Dr Reay you were going to report out on the Tiana seage
220meetings you were supposed to be having the second Friday of the month we haven't had anything from October November correct so so this past uh meeting they cancel the the the meeting um and so right now so the the last meeting that we're supposed to be having they canceled it and we're going to be meeting after the holidays um that's I didn't report out right I yes I'd like to see a very deliberate very intentional involvement in um looking at that thank you and um I brought it up very cursory uh this past time that we look at the standards we're using when we're determining uh District supported assistant principles versus site supported assistant principles uh whatever whatever standards we had before we spoke about briefly um obviously the past is not where we're living
221in now the uh after covid the children came back and many many more issues with behavioral issues uh I shared with you that I've shadowed uh a couple of principles and oh my gosh I just don't know how they can do their other assignments when they have to juggle trying to uh save a child from themselves they're eloping and the parents and I I think we need to re really need to relook at it and with the school plans for achieve the student achievement plans that we just got I think we can take a look at okay recalibrate where are we what what can we do differently we're looking at new numbers for instance Harborside didn't they lose their dual immersion with a community school well we we so they have less students and they
222have two principls the principal and the assistant correct whereas others I think we need to relook at all our schools and that was one of my one of my intentions but there was just so many and very short time for me to look at so I don't know who is could be involved involved whether we get someone from um our administrators Association to help us out us me I'll help well that's what I just kind of do anyway but to look to see what we can do to reassess this and um president I don't know if this requires a motion to reassess just reassess what what what qualifies for a district supported assistant principle okay so what qualif so let me just reiterate the question so your question is what qualifies a school to have
223an associate principle right right because if we use the current current um standard well we would be taking the assistant principal from harbor side I mean not physically but then now the the cost would be out of school sight funds so I don't think we want to do that it's a community school but I think we we need to take a look at yeah so one of the things that we're doing actually right now with CET is we we are having those discussions now uh we're having those discussions because there are many VAR variables it's not just the number of students demographics well the number of uh uh um uh I APS for example the number of I understand so so we'll be coming up with a uh a couple of uh different scenarios um
224uh everything comes at a price tax so we'll bring we'll bring it to the board right but if um Harborside needs to give up their assistant principle and go to another one we need to maximize what we have and it has to be Equitable out there for the principles they're just they they also need help absolutely so what's my deadline what's your deadline better better state so we can bring you uh January February yeah will that include a fiscal impact with since it's yeah we have to it has it has to be it has to be included with the fiscal impact with a general fiscal impact so it would have to be after January because of the May revi sure so we we'll bring it in February see and at this point we're looking at
225I know that most important the the finances piece but if we're to use the yard stick we're using now it would be moving players because the the numbers have changed so anyway I'll wait till February thank you and um I guess with the other trustees being gone it's now going to be tomorrow myself on the I was going to ask on the update on the cell phone usage policy we're um we we'll take a look at that and we had asked before about Title One monies and um we needed to know how much of it was left on the table there had been some certain instances where uh a school or schools did not use their Title One monies that was sent correct I saw I saw on the Friday update mhm that was sent
226the title one can you resend that to me please and what's left yes okay thank you and okay that's it thank you go ahead um can I get a timeline on when is chil Vista Hills going to get a quality water fountain water ballet refill not a water fountain water refill that so so by next board meeting we're getting a uh a contract or something yeah we'll look into that okay there actually a couple of schools good and and I think that water quality water is something that is a necessity a basic necessity for the school and the district should be paying for it not the school so let's look into that um bless you the only report um I know that I I can't remember the assembly bill number off the top of my
227head with regard to the cell phone phones takes effect July 1st 2026 which is the next school year um just in in relation to that what um some of our what are our school sites doing right now because some sites I go to and they say they don't have a problem at all kids put them in their backpack they walk on campus and they're not seen um just to get a feel for what the school sites are doing other than that um board Communications trusty gu I want this I was invited by Jerry renon old friend of ours to the Metro conference Hall of Fame I just thought it'd be nice for everyone to know that uh his father was um was inducted into the Hall of Fame and I thought just it' be nice
228to know he's been in education for a very long time they also inducted School administrators coaches athletes one of the athletes was Adrien Gonzalez that was there so uh on November 21st we handed out 440 453 turkeys I believe 438 alone went to Vista Square School families and staff the rest um Mr Romero's Mr Romero and his staff uh were they they they delivered them to other people that could use them but uh Barbie and uh Azie we're just instrumental in making it happen uh we cleaned out a few Walmarts I'm sure and for those turkeys and uh Mr rero was amazing and um we had donors a few of our my husbands and I uh friends and another acquaintance who's preferred not to mention his name although he works here and a friend of
229mine Andrea Hayes and uh we want to thank everyone we were the families were so grateful there was a few families lady a moms that came up to us and twice and doubled back to thank us because she had just lost her job and she was not going to have anything and uh I think um allowing people to have a little bit of dignity at a time that's so special for the children when they're talk their friends are talking about having a turkey dinner and they're not having anything so I want to thank everyone but I did want to allow Mr Romero a minute if that was okay um Trust youed we've developed an idea for the future moving forward on the turkeys would that be okay with you thank you uh and thank you
230uh Mr M santes uh uh this time of year it's always um you know uh exciting for the human resources department to put the human um element into our our amazing Community um and so the uh HR department was super excited when you came up with this idea and shared it with with Dr Rees um and in conversation that we had you and I uh you know we talked about how this could be ongoing um this idea you know was was was something that you know we had to do really quick um and we were excited to get engaged with it but we talked about how we could uh continue this uh to be an annual event and and maybe even grow it and so uh some of the ideas that we were sharing was
231maybe start like a a Turkey Trot fundraiser like a small 5K um that can get you know more of the community involved um and then looking at how we can expand it to include not just the turkey but some of the the other additional um items that that come along with a Thanksgiving dinner and um just be an annual celebration of um the Chul Vista School District's uh commitment to to our families so uh we're excited to engage in further conversations with you and the board about how we can continue this to grow um but uh thank you for for bringing in and considering uh the HR department to help you with this Mission and and we're committed we're all in well he volunteered on his own I did not ask Community Schools yes reach
232out yes well and we will be reaching out for Manpower because this woman had no business picking up that many turkeys I'm still hurting really bad it hurts um so that was a thank you Mr Romero please thank Azie and Barbie and the rest of your staff helped and I also visited the uh Rice Elementary ribbon cutting they had an amazing mural it was just beautiful and um thank you for inviting me Dr Rays or having them uh let me know and McMillan I was at their celebration their holiday uh celebration and they have a vapa teacher there that's amazing um Miss Kono and um that that was just really great kids saying singing and playing musical instruments so thank you and I hope that everyone has a wonderful wonderful Christmas holiday with your family
233your loved ones stay warm stay healthy and get some sleep ladies and gentlemen all of us thank you I wanted to express my gratitude to trusty Dominguez cantes for arranging the the turkeys uh I think that was great um a lot of the community benefited from that so I'm grateful that you took the lead on that um not not nothing much to communicate I think I communicated enough today um but I do want to wish everybody a a merry Christmas and a happy holiday I hope that you get to unplug and and enjoy this time with family uh Rochelle no more texting no more emails please um but really take care of yourselves uh enjoy this time with with families uh and and really use it to re-energize yourselves and I will will see you
234next year uh I just want to say that the Starlite parade was super fun and super cold um and the kids had a blast um all the kids high-fiving and I used a lot of hand sanitizer um but that it was it was really fun and um I look forward to that and always have Improvement suggestions it was great last year it was even better this year and we were thinking of things as we were walking um uh just a lot of fun a lot of people out there um I do want to wish everyone um a Merry Christmas and this year a happy Hanukkah around the same time and then right after that a joyous K Quanza and then a very Happy New Year I know teachers and people in education at takes you
235the first week just to unwind and feel like you're on vacation so it's nice that we have three weeks um and then really really enjoy those last two weeks um and I don't want to not acknowledge the fact that the holidays can be very stressful especially on the person who's having to do all the organizing and the preparing and making sure that it's magical for all the children which is is really important and I do want to take uh time to thank trusty domingus santes for the um thanksgiv giving turkeys and I hope your muscles are are recovering um and I do look forward to us continuing to do that and expanding with our community schools those food pantries for our families in the district so thank you and I will see you in January
236Dr Reyes I just want to thank everyone we finished we're finishing our second quarter in four days I'm sure every everyone's looking forward to the break uh again I want to thank everyone for everything that you do and I want to wish all of you happy holidays and the best for 2025 the next regular board meeting of the Board of Education of the Chula Vista Elementary School District will be held on January 22nd 2025 at 400 PM for closed session and 6 PM for the Open Session do we have a motion to adjourn motion to adjourn would you please second sir second MO by truste domz svantes seconded by vice president Theo all those in favor I motion carries if one of us says no Then we