CorpusRecord 39107

2/12/25 Special Board Meeting - Duarte USD

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Duarte Unified School District - Media
Date
2025-02-13
Location
Los Angeles County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,174 words · about 79 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e all right uh good evening I'm hearing myself um we'll go ahead and get started with this uh meeting it is 5:35 p.m. on February 12 2025 um we're going ahead and get started with a roll call uh so board member Diaz board member Finley here board member hogin here board member hoso here board member Rees here excellent uh all right we'll go ahead and go with our flag salute and uh Mr Kevin Morris could I have you do that excellent thank you all right we'll now move on to the adoption of the agenda do I have a motion to adopt the agenda so move all right I heard a motion by Mr Reyes is there a second second second by board member Diaz uh any discussion seeing none all those in favor

002say I I I all right do we have any requests to address the board none thank you very much um all right we then move on to item number six which is the California dashboard uh December 2024 release thank you good evening and thank you everybody for coming here tonight the California school dashboard is more than just a collection of numbers um it is a critical tool that informs the work that we do every single day to support students learning and overall experiences in our schools these data points are not just measurements they guide our conversation shape our actions and help us ensure that every student in the D the Unified School District receives the support and opportunities they need to Ser to to thrive so leading our discussion this evening will be uh Dr

003Kelly Lawson our senior director of Educational Services who will walk us through some key insights from the dashboard and also joining us tonight are are theed dedicated leaders of each of our schools Educators who regularly use these data and drive decisions and continually improve the learning environments for our students I encourage us all to approach this discussion with curiosity reflection and a shared commitment to using these insights to strengthen our school schools and the futures of the students we serve and at this time Dr Lawson I'll turn it over to you all right well good evening everyone and welcome um I'm going to give you a little outline of how this night will go I'm just going to give you a little bit of background about the school dashboard some facts about what it is

004how we use the information what information is included just to make sure we're all on the same page with our understanding of what the dashboard is and then I'm going to do an overview of the districts data this is all of our students in uor unified school districts um I will talk a little bit about our subgroups as well as some of our subgroups that need a little more support I'll go over a little bit some of the strategies that we are using and then we'll have lots of time for questions and answers the site administrators are here tonight um and they are here to answer any questions as it relates to their data and particular strategies and techniques that they're using at their School site in front of you you should have a very

005nice binder a little little book here it has all the information it has all the data it has the district's data it's pretty thick I heard someone say this is thick it is pretty thick we wanted to give you a lot of information so it has the um information about the district's data as well as each School site's information and then behind each School site at the very last page the there are strategies and goals that the school sites have listed in their single plan for student achievement that helps them meet the targets um and help us improve our data on the dashboard okay so I'm GNA without further Ado I'm going to go ahead and get started as Dr hman shared a little bit about what the dashboard did it it gives us meaningful

006information about how we're progressing as a district as well as how we are progressing as a school as our school sites it informs our decisions so we can make um data driven decisions on how to improve student achievement it gives us um data on different indicators so it's not just test scores I think that that's important to note because it also gives us information about attendance about our graduation rate College and Career Readiness those are some other indicators so what I want you to do as we go into the study session tonight is I really want you to have this holistic view of what it means um to achieve as a district it's not just one measure that we're looking at there are multiple measures that we address every day on the school sites multiple

007measures that we address at the district level and all of those come together to determine how well we're progressing and let us and it informs our decision and helps us to know what we need to do in order to continue growing and making sure we're meeting the needs of all students in our district okay so some things that you'll see on there on this dashboard this tool it gives us um it presents the status levels from very high to very low it also gives us information about change and I think that's important because it's not just about one year of information we want to look at our students and determine how well that they do last year how did they do the year before that so we can determine are we progressing where we need

008to make adjustments and then it gives us information on our various student groups and it is released annually every year in December so we're looking at information from the spring because the information that we have in our dashboard some of the academic data comes from our Casp assessment that was in the spring and so that was from December of um well spring of 24 so this is December December 2024 data okay so how do we use it um we use it to evaluate our progress on the district's lcap in our LC cap we have various goals and priorities that are indicated um that are listed in our lcap and we use this dashboard because a lot of our measures are directly related to the um lcap um and informs the single plan for student achievement

009at the school sites which is what the schools develop determine how they're going going to meet the needs of all students and the way I see this like the dashboard contains all the measures um schools do a sipsa single parent for student achievement the district does a lcap which is a big big sipsa for the district and all of it goes together to help us um determine our progress um another thing that the dashboard allows us to do is focus on Equity because we want to make sure that we are meeting the needs of every student not just one group of student we want to make sure all of our subgroups are making progress and if they're not we need to then identify what are the needs um what curriculum needs do we have what

010needs do we have in terms of instruction what assessment data do we have what Benchmark data do we we have um our facilities as well as professional development all this information is something that's available in our dashboard and we do use it to help us with our decision making so um we are looking at the 2024 California dashboard information and at the time when we our data was obtained we had 2,980 students U 53.5% of our students are socially economically disadvantage we are 21% uh English Learners and 8% um are Foster youth okay so what does the dashboard include there are State indicators which will focus on the academic indicators which are English language arts um mathematics we also have science data we will look at the English the progress of our English language Learners

011as well as graduation rate the suspension rate College and Career Readiness and then chronic absenteeism all that information those are State indicators that we'll look at and then there are the local indicators um and on those local indicators they're listed here looking at basic services are implementation of state and academic standards parent and family engagement School climate um access to a broad course of study and then there are some specific ones for the county level okay and so these State indicators as well as these local indicators give us a well-rounded view of our students and a well-rounded view of the district and what we need to do yes is it is it okay to ask questions while you're going or would you prefer us to hold them so what I would prefer if you would

012hold me if you want to write the notes on there but if it's a burning question and you want me to stop I have no problem because this is a study session so it can be it can we can make it is we can make it whatever we need it to be it it is smoldering not a burning thing so I can wait if it's burning just say it's burning you need to get your question I'm totally okay with that so you if you want to you can go ahead I just it's up to you I it was just I it just really quickly the under the local indicators here it talks about different priority levels are those priority levels that we set or are those set by somebody or these are the priority levels

013that are in the LC cap uhu yes gotcha thank you okay all right so the student groups that we'll look at um you see the the groups listed there as well as as the program um that these students are in and I think that when you when you think about the dashboard this to me is probably one of the most important pieces to note because we want to make sure that we are providing Equitable access for every student and we know that students come in at different levels we know there are different factors that may support or hinder a students ability to be successful in school and so as a as a public institution we have to be aware of what the needs of all of the students are and we need to be able

014to track and monitor those students and we cannot just rest on one particular group of students being successful because if one group is failing we need to make sure they are um their needs are being met as well as the highest achieving to the lowest achieving students so these sub the subgroup data is very key the way information is reported um we get reports if you have at least 30 students in a group um reporting for students between 11 and 29 we do get a performance data for we don't get we don't get performance information we do get status and change levels but we do not get the performance uh information and then there's also reporting on our long-term English Learners which is a new group it's not a new group to our school sites

015but new to the dashboard this year um and these are English Learners that have not been reclassified as fluent English proficient students and they've been in our schools for at least um seven years and so we do have data that's been disagre at for that group of students to see how they are achieving um and so when we get to look at our LP data which is our English learner performance indicators it has data for our English Learners as well as our long-term English Learners now there is an exception to the rule of 30 um for a group that has reporting for fewer than less than 11 students um our foster foster youth Foster Youth and homeless and our lels we will receive a score for them if they have at least 15 students from

016the current year and the prior year so just know that is the exception to the 30 rule so for each measure you'll see you'll have we have current year data and then you have the current year minus the prior year which is the change and this is key because when we get into uh our data on the future Pages you'll see you'll see indicators that say maintain decline increase that information is important because we want to we want to um kind of function from a value add model we want our students to come into our schools and we want to be able to move them from where they are and the best way to see that is through their change right so we want to we want to see Positive Growth every year for students

017because it's not just uh a score these are students this is their achievement and we want to make sure that we're moving them along so as I stated earlier you see the range from lowest performing which is red up to highest performance which is blue this is our grid here also that also shows the those colors and as you can see kind of where it connects so you see the where they achieve what their scores were for the current year compared to where their scores were for their previous year and where it intersects is where you see their color so if you see here um the current year was at a high level performance and that was an increase from the prior year and where it connects that students right there showing that they are

018green I don't particularly like this one but you know some of you may like that one I don't like that one too much I like this one um so when you go to the dashboard and you see our overall data you see this information and it's you know it's a stop light it has different colors you see the different arrows but this page alone does not really tell you how our students are achieving or how we're doing as a district because it just has the colors and those colors don't mean anything if you don't know if that if that means the student if they grew if they declined if they maintained so when you look at the dashboard on your own on other days don't stop at this page you got to go deeper which

019is what we're going to do tonight so we're going to go deeper right now we're going to start I'm looking at our data for our English language arts as measured by 2024 cast data for grades 3 through eight and grade 11 the current year we're showing 11.2 points below the standard um the current year minus the prior which is the change there was a a a change of 1.3 points which was basically we just maintained our achievement where the students were the previous year and the current year there wasn't really much much difference um so the students kind of stayed where they were which can indicate the practices that we were using you're kind of maintaining students but we do want to look and see what we can do to take them to a deeper

020level um this page here looks at our subgroup data and when you get into the subgroup data this is where you start to see some disparities in our subgroups and so the first group here you can you see there's um various ranges on here um we have groups that increase their performance our African-American students our homeless and our our socially economically disadvantaged students all of those students increased in their points um and I think that's important to note they may not be in the green but they definitely are moving forward we want to move the arrow to the right and not to the left um so those students have made gains so if you just looked at this screen and saw yellow you would not necessarily know if that meant they maintain or increase or

021decrease from the previous slide so on this slide you can actually see the number of points um and their distance from the standard which is the students that the number of students the average of the number of students um the distance that the average group of students have for meeting the Baseline level of proficiency that's what that distance from the standard represents Okay so we're looking at our English language artarts data here and this is a comparison for our English Learners and we have a lot in our district and so I think it's important that we track those students So currently our current English language Learners there was a decline if you see there were 291 students in that number we have students that were reclassified so our reclassify English Learners they are 14.8 points

022above the standard these are our students who originally were identified as non-english speakers or non-proficient English and they obtain their level proficiency and they were able to be reclassified and as you can see there students they're making progress and we we like to see that and that's important and then you can see the the achievement of our students that are English only and their data came in one point below the standard they maintain from where they were from the previous year now from that data looking at our subgroup data we do have two groups on that were in the red um and because these two groups are in the red we are have been identify for needing different differentiated assistance for those two groups which is our long-term English Learners and our students with disabilities

023and so when we talk about equity and really making sure we're meeting the needs of students we really want to dig deeper to determine what it is that we need to do to help one our long-term English Learners become proficient in English that's huge and so we're seeing if they're not becoming proficient in English we're not seeing the growth in their academic achievement as well so those are two areas that um we will we are are targeting and I know that the schools have also identified those groups in their single plan for student achievement they've identified some goals and some actions and some tools to monitor their performance to determine if we're able to if we're making progress and then with our students with disability that's a huge gap there and we but one thing

024I just want to note when we look at each of our subgroups we look at those groups of students for who they are and their level achievement where they started and where they're going and so we don't say like if if what group of students is 150 points above the standard and a group that's not as close to that another group can achieve at the same level if there if the levels are off so we're not going to be able to take a group of students well notless we are miracle workers but in one year we won't be able to take students that are negative 131 and move them up 200 points that's not realistic but it is realistic that we can move them and make progress and so if we make progress we will

025then see that Lev that arrow move forward because it's about change so just that's something to note we do have a plan in place to Target our our students with disabilities as well as working with the teachers and working with the administrators we do have some actions and some plans that we put in place because he recognize that that is an area of need and so we definitely have put some things in place to to Target that do want a spotlight and on each of the sections I I've identified a couple of schools just to kind of Spotlight some of their data and then when we get to the point where we have have discussions if you want to talk to them a little bit about how they did that that's that that's your prerogative

026um so on here I chose a spotlight Valley View's Ela data their achievement for all stud students they scored in the green so when you score in the green or the red that's huge and that's something to celebrate because that means that the students have made um sign they've made progress every year they they did not drop and so here this at this site the students scored 19.2 points above the standard and from the previous year that was an increase of four point 9 points so I just want to highlight that um that they were in the green yay yay for big shout out to valy view good job miss fish um then moving into our academic performance for mathematics um as measured by the 2024 cast so the current year right now when we

027looked at our data it was 47.3 points below the standard that doesn't mean every student is below the standard so just want to make that note so if you're looking at like oh my God it's not every student 47% of students um and then if if you look at from the current year to the prior year that was an increase of 4.2 so that the year before I believe it was orange and that's why we move to the yellow so we are making remember we want to move to the right not to the left except if there other areas okay so again looking at our subgroup data because it's important to note so we can see are there are there achievement gaps where are the disparities where do they exist so for all students they're

02847.3 points below the standard that was an increase of 4.2 but there are some groups that um increase our African-American students our English Learners and our socio economically disadvantaged students they did show points increase from the previous year to current year there are some that just maintain which means they didn't really grow too much at less than three points so they just kind of maintain their achievement and then of course there are a couple that decline which they had some drops and that's just noted here in the data so if we were looking at this and saying what do we need to do to kind of close that academic achievement Gap we would look at these particular particular groups and say what's going on what do we need to do differently for them or what's

029working with one group of students can it work with another um how do we differentiate our instruction how we provide additional supports to increase our student achievement again um comparing the data of our English Learners we have our current English Learners you can see where they perform um we see some negative points like Negative they dropped a little bit but wasn't significant so these three groups they kind of maintain from where they were from the previous year to the current year mathematics they just kind of held steady um at where they were from the previous year two groups in the red again are long-term healers Learners and our students with disability and so because they were read in two or more areas that's why these groups have been identified as um we're getting a differentiated

030assistance and we're working with Leo we have some plans in place to Target that and how we can address those needs mathematics is also an area that we are targeting in our learning walks this year um walking through and looking at our instructional practices and working with the team to figure out ways that we can improve students understanding of mathematics doing it for reading in all the other areas as well so don't want to make it seem like it's only math we're looking at all areas but highlighting that one um just Spotlight on Maxwell's achievement for mathematics if you look at what Maxwell they did they had an increase of 9.9 points from the previous year so just want to shout out to Maxwell for their achievement in mathematics with the increase there we do

031have science data so you can see the science data there's no color because there's no comparison um this is the first year that we have that science data so um there's no color but you can see where we are now moving into our English language learner progress our LP data um 47 45.7% of our students are making steady progress and becoming proficient in the English language um the current year data minus PRI year there was a decline of 5.1 that put us in the red um this total 486 students and with their LP data as well included in that data is also information about our long-term English Learners so if you see here are there's the two groups the of students the data is listed here Spotlight on darty high school on their achievement with

032the English language learning progress they are in the green let's get a shout out thank you whoop whoop yes that's something to celebrate when you celebrate the green and red that means your students are making some significant increases it doesn't mean they may not be every at the level where we want them to be but it does say that these students have made significant progress they're doing some great things at DOR high and addressing the needs of our English Learners and so we just want to note that and recognize them publicly for the hard work that they're doing because we it's important that our English Learners become proficient because if not we have those long-term English Learners and as you've seen in the data that can that can be problematic in their achievement so um

033good job on making that progress there they had an increase of 5% now if we look at absenteeism chronic absenteeism in our looking at what it is um as you can see on every one of these this is positive there was a decline so that's good we want kids at school we want to see declines here we don't want to see declines on the others but on this one this is where we want to see it so our students are coming to school and if if you look at this data even across the boards across the subgroup data you see it's pretty pretty Equitable there so that is awesome our kids are wanting to be at school we want them there um looking at the conditions and climates for all students in terms of the

034suspension rate um this is also an area that is a shout out we we are in the green on this one so if you see the decrease it it was a decline of 3% so what the data says 3.9% suspended at least one time one day in that school year so that was um that's that's better than what it was so if you see the current year to the pre the prior year to the current year you see where we had a decline there and so we're celebrating that we're doing some great things in there teaching kids our PBIS is working creating those positive environments where students want to be at school holding them accountable and teaching them um Behavior like we teach our academics and I believe it's definitely working making a difference and

035also building those relationships so looking at academic uh engagement and looking at The Graduate ation weight the percentage of students that graduated with a diploma um there we go big shout out to Dy high school and to mon Olive both of our schools we see a 95% graduation rate there that is an increase at DHS from um increase by 10% and at MIT increased by 12% I think that's worth some snaps right there because that's awesome because that's in the blue and the green and we're very proud of their achievement congratulations there so next turn look at college career that College and Career indicator and so listed some of the areas that we look at so in order for we want to look at are our students leaving school prepared to go to college are

036they ready so here's some um they have to meet one of these criterias and you see those criteria that are listed there and I will then go on to the next slide and show our data for that so if you look at um College and Career Readiness by student groups for all of our students in the green snapsat on the green that's great um but we do have some disparities when we get into our subgroups which just means we need to focus in on all of the studs to see what is it we can do to improve um this data for our students so particularly our English Learners and long-term English Learners we did see a decline but we saw an increase in College and Career Readiness among our students with disabilities and that's awesome

037because we were in the red on some of the other areas but we are making some Headway so I think that's something to note too and I think that's the beautiful thing about the dashboard is that we're not just looking at one indicator it's not one indicator that says your your district is doing well or your school is successful there are multiple measures that we're looking at and there are areas to celebrate and areas and room for growth and we will continue to work on those as a team to move all of our students so you see we had an increase with our students with disability there was an increase with our homeless an increase with our Hispanic students as well as our um social economically disadvantaged students and some of them are in the

038green so that's awesome we want to see increases because remembrance about change and growth right that's what that's what we're striving to see then there also local local performance indicators um and we had a standard met on all of the local um indicators as listed there now what's next what's working what's not working so I just kind of compiled a few strategies about what's working what's not uh some of the things that some of the strategies that are being implemented at the school sites as it relates to English engl language arts they are doing weekly collaborations the teams come together to analyze data to look at where the gaps where can what what do student students need um how can we uh provide um instruction to increase and challenge our students and support those that

039are in need what type of diagnostic assessments are we using to kind of diagnose where the challenging areas are looking at reading intervention schoolwide small group I'm looking at the small group instruction having reading incentives in place and um targeting that comprehension those are just a few um in your books you have like I said a summary of each School site and you may see some more strategies that is that um the students are schools are using specifically there some areas to continue to focus on with our growth is we want to continue to focus on um evidence-based interventions and targeting our deficits we don't just want to randomly select strategies we want to make sure that they're research based that they're they're backed and that they can also help make a difference we need

040to look at additional tutoring for our students um professional development for teachers I know teacher um self efficacy is huge we want our teachers we want to know that they're confident and they know that they can make a difference in the lives of our students and I think that that alone makes a huge difference for teachers so we want to continue to pour into our teachers we want to pour into our site administrators they're the instructional leaders on the campus we want to make sure they're equipped with the Knowledge and Skills that they need to continue to monitor the instructional programs at their sites and then we want to look at how can we really build that critical thinking and problem solving for our students because just being able to read uh words on the

041page is not enough we need them to be able to read we need them to be able to understand we need them to be able to ask questions we need them to be able to think critically we need them to be able to analyze and synthesize that information so then we also want to look at how can we continue to provide differentiated instruction the data tells us and we make datadriven decisions that we do have subgroups of students that need different type different levels of instruction and levels of support um and we use that that's how we'll use that information to kind of Drive differentiate instruction which is the first instruction happening in the classroom with the teachers and then schoolwide interventions more of those if we're not how can we have schoolwide more schoolwide

042interventions and making sure the content standards are being addressed particularly identifying are there particular standards where students are having the most difficulty and how can we target those particular standards to move our students along as well as looking what are the key standards that are students are lacking because those key standards are fundamental to their their progression and their growth what's next for our English Learners we want to continue to uh Implement these practices here explicit vocabulary instruction we know that language development is key so you want to make sure that we're doing the tier vocabulary making sure it's very clear very explicit for students that they have multiple opportunities to use and practice the language we want to make sure that they can access the learning that we're scaffolding providing visual aids where when

043we have opportunities to use the home language I know at beers we have the Dual emersion program and our students are learning in in Spanish um and I know that that's making a difference we're offering Spanish and at other at our other sites as well and then what does English language development look like we have to be very intentional and very strategic in how we address our English language development we cannot um just assume it's being done so we want to make sure that we've identified what it is that we're doing who are the students that actually need that development how can we track and monitor to make sure that they are actually accessing and learning what we are teaching we have um using the Kagan strategies and different collaborative strategies at all the school

044sites as students coming together not just completing an assignment but it's the mental work that's involved right so when we talk about what is collaboration I think we'll have an opportunity to do that too is the brainwork it's the thinking behind what we're doing and students actually have an opportunity to engage in that discourse about their thinking and the strategies and problem solving together that mult that bringing the multiple brains together and then frequent speaking opportunities for our students we want to make sure that in the class we're holding them accountable for speaking in complete sentences we want to make sure that we're giving them opportunities to speak um providing them with sentence frames if they're having difficulty being making sure they have good models and we're guiding them along the way and that consistent

045practices are being implemented because consistency is the key uh across the board and then um our professional learning communities that's bringing our teams together to talk talk about where our students are and what do we need to do okay and then in mathematics again what's working in mathematics because we know and we have groups that have increased in their achievement we have groups that maintained and we have some groups that in that dropped and so some of the strategies that are being implemented we have um at some sites math intervention schoolwide math interventions some are just grade level interventions but we know that we need to intervene and go back and retach whatever those Concepts where students were struggling and then looking at math remediation because you know that's a different level where we have

046students that may be struggling multiple years with some math concepts and so we're not just reteaching the concepts for the current grade level we're going in and we're remediating to kind of fill in the holes from some of the previous years of learning and we know math Spirals and it buil so we really want to make sure we close fill in those holes for our students some sites we have iel which is a an online program that helps with mathematics and then one thing that we cannot Overlook that is extremely important is that direct instruction that first instruction so we can bring in programs all day long but it's the people not the programs that make a difference in the learning for students and so that direct instruction that Hands-On that interactive instruction for students

047we know that that's key so some of the areas of growth continue to implement evidence-based practices looking at our math pacing to make sure we're covering all the content that needs to be covered that provides the solid foundations for our students providing interventions making sure students are developing the conceptual knowledge and the procedural knowledge making sure our students are able to communicate their ideas and Mathematics write their ideas and Mathematics that discourse is so important and then we need to make sure our students have you know the winess that they stick the grit that they can persevere in all subject area so if they come across a difficult math problem or if they're struggling with their language proficiency or if they're struggling with their reading that they have the ability to persevere and we have

048to teach that and we have to hold kids accountable and make Provisions for that for our students so that's kind of in a nutshell our district level data um you can explore it more you have information in your booklet as well as this is a um website for the California dashboard and then in summary just for my part before we get into the question and answer part of our session is the dashboard is a comprehensive overview of our performance on the state and local indicators as you see it enables us to make data driven uh decisions to track performance identify those Trends what are the trends and patterns in the learning and to quickly respond to any issues that we have identified it's also a tool that our educ educational Partners can access to look

049at our progress so there's no it's full transparency when it comes to the dashboard You Can't Hide it's like the data is right there so you can look at it and you know we don't we're not trying to hide behind our data we want it we want people to look at it we want to be able to talk about it like what can we do better this is a team effort we know that in public education it's a collaborative effort a community of people working together to make a difference in the lives of students so we want people you have if they have better ideas that they can offer us we welcome those we welcome the opportunity to collaborate with others so I want to thank you for paying atten this portion of the presentation

050and I'm happy to answer any questions or to dive deeper into any measures or any indicators discuss and the site administrators are here to answer any questions that you may have regarding their goals and actions or if you have any questions about their data but I'm I'm going to remove myself from the platform and come and sit down here because now we get into the study sessions for questions and answers comments concerns ET thank you thank you very much Dr Lawson appreciate uh yes yes deep breath deep breath excellent excellent presentation thank you for all of this and and for giving a lot of uh great explanations uh to all of us here um so uh board are there any uh questions that you have for Dr Lawson or for any of the other site

051administrators I do um my question is what's the difference between English learner and long-term English Learners I was a little confused with that that but okay so students that are English Learners are when they come into the when they enroll in school they do a home survey and they they indicate what the language is that the that's spoken in the home and if they say the language is anything other than English then they are considered in English language there's another language that's the primary language long-term English Learners are students who came in they were identified as English Learners which see they were not their first language was not English um and they have not been reclassified so they've been identified as an English learner they have not met the level proficiency to be reclassified as

052a proficient English learner as a proficient English speaker so an English learner and a long El a long-term English learner they're they're the same just one has been it been in it over seven years so you can look at E's new they long-term is multiple years over seven years and so our goal really is we want to really Target those ltels because when they get to high school it's difficult right and as you see in the data when they're at the school sites if you look at the the our lels were identified um in the red for two sub two of the areas and so and those are academic areas right so we really want to make sure we're targeting those students helping them become proficient in the English language so then that will transfer

053into like English language SS and their mathematics and help improve their achievement thank you you're welcome so I'll piggyback a little bit on on her question so when an English language learner is reclassified are they reclassified as like different levels or are they just not an English language learner anymore they are called rfps reclassified fluid English speakers okay yeah so then they when we look at our data and they're not in our English language English language learner data anymore um and if you look on that one you know that I gave a comparison slide on the um for English English arts and for mathematics there were three groups of students on there we had our students who were reclassified those were students who came in as English learners but then were reclassified and then we

054had our English only students and then our English Learners so they're a group of students and we still track their data each year and then we also have to monitor those students after they've been reclassified we have to have a plan in place how we can monitor because we don't want them to slip or decline in their achievement so we do have to monitor their achievement as well okay and then uh I don't know this this might be a question more for uh Beardsley um so I I I just I don't know if there's any data out there about this but I'm just kind of curious because we we have a a phenomenal dual immersion program does does that seem to help students become reclassified more quickly or does it take them more time because

055there's more Spanish being spoken at school so that's a good question um as far as the reclassification um we I am happy to say we're we're looking at that data right now um and so you will see students reclassify I don't have the exact data of how many more are reclassifying who have been through the program but I could get that information to you I have done a deep dive into the students overall in like English language art and in math who are progressing through the program and this year the data was significant for the progress they're making and um you know I can share that with you at a different time um it's not like on the dashboard but um I do a deep dive just to see the difference of the students in

056the Dual emergent program as opposed to the English only of course we have success in both um but that is interesting data to look at um and statistically it does show that they they will achieve at a higher level long term um and I'm seeing that data come come through but as far as the reclassification that's a great question and because our first cohort is in eighth grade um they could start reclassifying obviously much younger than that but it would be interesting data to gather so I'll get that to you great thank you very much other questions board um I have several questions but since we're talking about English Learners I'll just kind of go to those so just for clarification when we're looking at the subgroup of English Learners does that continue to does

057that um pull together current Els plus those who are being monitored after being reclassified no okay because I'm just curious looking at the English language arts by subgroup we have that our E's maintained Point 2 points but then on the next page page where it has the data comparison for English Learners it says current El's declined 8.5 points whereas recently reclassified English Learners maintained point4 points so I was just curious um where that difference in data comes from can you repeat your question again you saying yeah so I was just wondering and I look at this stuff all the time and it's the first time I was like oh hey I never thought about that so on um your the slide that starts with English language arts by subgroups that looks like this on that

058one for the El subgroup they are let's see here 55.7 points below standard maintained point2 points and then if you go to that next page below it has current English Learners and recently reclassified English Learners and those that's why I'm asking like does the they are in they are included got it okay for for the portion of time that they are being monitored Monitor reclassification and can someone remind me the time um for that monitoring is it two years three years four years okay all right excellent okay and then just in just on here just within the within the prior four years for the Recently classify prior for yours okay perfect thank you so much and then I'm super excited that ltels are being included on the dashboard because I think it's a really critical

059uh subgroup for us to focus on I mean our goal is to not create them in the first place right and and move them through those proficiency levels so I'm just curious now that it's here that the phenomenon isn't new and it's been talked a lot about in California for at least a decade now um so what are some things that are in place I know you called out you know uh what's working what's next uh Focus um on growth have you guys considered anything that really just focuses on that LEL population um and I'm thinking more Beyond just strategy and program placement those things are super important but just like do the kids know what it means to be an LEL do they know what the reclassification criteria is are there data talks with

060them do their families know do we party when they get when they classify and I yes yes to all of those because and we're actually currently in the doing the summit of elpac now yes and so they are the the teaching and learning coaches have met with students and they talk to them so yes they know reclass they know what it takes to be reclassified um some of our students that are like right there on the cuff they know in terms of like their Lexile scores what they need to achieve on their Lexile scores and give them that extra push there are meetings with parents we do have um our elac meetings at the school side we do talk talk about this as well at the daac meetings with the parents about reclassification we just

061talked about that at our last meeting about what is reclassification why it's in important to reclassify our students and yes we do celebrate them at the school sites but I think the site's good I'm talking I'm I'm thinking of the celebrations I had when I was at Maxwell last year but I'm going to allow the principles at the site to talk about um what they're doing um with their English Learners and their ltels and how they celebrate them so I just allow them briefly to kind of share that said briefly when you looked at me actually I was looking at my calendar because we're recognizing them on March 26th um he'll be recognizing all of um the reclassified students um and we do meet with the students we we um also do some I don't

062want to say test prep but like one-on-one meetings in all honesty to let them know like what is the criteria where do you need to be um not just on the lpac but also on the you know cast um and so that's important but um I was just meeting with um the TLC today and she was talking to a teacher and about three kids who she was just so proud of because her eighth graders going to the high school um more than that but she was just talking about these specific ones and they'll be reclassifying and so they were really really excited themselves to hear that today so that's wonderful it's a big deal yeah and you could come by March 26 invite the board to those things I think when we're available it would

063be really nice to to celebrate along that because it's 26 and the parents come it's really exciting for the parents too because these are parents of um you know previous English Learners and so they have they have seen them you know progress and make that progress and they're very proud to see that yeah so and I think it's a beautiful thing you know at our elementary sites I know we don't I think that's just Valley View right but just if we could work together and not send them on to middle school as um long-term English Learners or not send them on to high school so that they have you know the access to a through G all that good stuff can I ask one more question sure okay it's still on E eel so um

064under kind of what's working what's next you list or you bulleted bulleted out English language development and so are is each site with El's um doing like their daily 45 minutes are they doing it by proficiency level what curriculums being used go ahead outside administrators you can respond to that um I can speak for us and yes and that's been a focus this year on what that actually looks like so we've done some pilot of some programs but um as the data has been driving our instruction it looks very different at the different grade levels what the sort of hindrance is as we can on the elpac you can do a deep dive where is the area um and so in terms of helping our students it tends to be writing with our middle school

065and so that tends to be the focus of the ELD specific instruction um in Middle School particularly not in their English class and so one of the things that the elpac requires is a broader knowledge so a lot of times they're writing on a subject that's it's not a creative story or the listening comprehension I actually just came from school set Council and we were talking I took the test one time like I was just listening and you get one chance and I was like oh I'm an adult and I know I'm going to take a test on this and yet I'm still having trouble focusing um and so that's a lot of the coaching as well but in terms of ELD it looks a little bit different at each grade level targeted based on

066their lpac data specifically so um many of the K1 for example it's the speaking um they they either overp or under speak and and so it's really helping them to learn that structure um and then um writing their letters it's really they're supposed to be able to write their letters and they're just learning them and so um their their instruction is very targeted um and the K through three at least at Maxwell is doing rotation of groups so organizing kids by their area of need not always their level good sometimes their level in conjunction with their area of need because sometimes a student for example the elpac score might be a two but they actually might be a four in listening and speaking and so um less about level and more about specific skill I

067appreciate that I think that's a really important point to consider kind of going back to the ltel we have a student who's been having ELD support for five years six years seven years and there are two on the L packet makes no sense to continue to give them beginning level English instruction and say why aren't they progressing what they need is Advanced instruction in English so very good can I just add also think the other piece is being very intentional about teaching English language development and not just assuming this we use visual aids and we use those sadii strategies with all students but being very specific and intentional and targeting who the English laners language Learners are and making sure they are actually making that progress and so I think that that's key when you're

068breaking them when you when you group them according to their levels as well as when you're providing that intentional writing instruction and making sure that the level of the questioning that they were Hearing in the classroom that the expectation of their response meets the level of questioning and I think that that's also key thank you um I have a question this was a great presentation by the way thank you uh we adopted back in 2016 a resolution uh for the read by third grade initiative where are we at as far as those scores are going and how are we tracking and how are how are we ensuring that our kids are reading our ch our children or students are reading by third grade because I I I know on here there isn't the third grade

069scores okay but uh I'd like to know um what we're doing uh to uh reach that goal thank so this data includes third through 8th grade and 11th grade so they are part of this dashboard data we do have that information on their scores so they do test at third grade so if we if we were to look specifically and I'm going to have this memorized our our cast data we do get that data for third graders for their English language arts and so we get the different levels of their achievement the four areas on the C score and so I would say the focus is we're looking at we look at K2 because we know that when it get to third grade it's not just the third third grade teachers are not the ones

070that make the difference it's K TK preschool up to third grade when they test that's a that's a a representation of what they've learned over the last you know since TK or kindergarten right so um some of the things that they're doing at this I know in our primary grades they use the esgi assessment that's in in Kinder in first grade to track students Reading Readiness um they're targeting the phonics influence instruction in the in the primary grades to teach kids to read we know that in K through two we're teaching kids to read and so that's like all the the Deep the foundational skills and then when they get to third grade on up they need to be able to demonstrate that in their reading comprehension I think that that's where we start to

071see some gaps in students ability to really um dissect the text that they're reading reading that complex text and really demonstrating their understanding and their comprehension so we do have our star Renaissance data that we use at the school site which is our Benchmark data we do administer those assessments um every six to eight weeks we do meet with the we meet my mouth with right he drinks water excuse me talking a lot we do meet um the instructional leaders aside Ministry we meet to look at the Renaissance data we disaggregate that data by subgroup we look at the standards that are targeted we look at the students Lexile levels so they're able to track it and so we want our students to read by third grade as well we know that there are some

072challenges there but it definitely there is a conscious effort in targeting fluency and literacy from Preschool On Up um and so using our Renaissance data that star data we did recently add Accelerated Reader at the school sites which is a reading incentive um program it allows us to our kids to read in order to become read to read by nine you have to read by five really you need to read read read every day and part of the challenge is getting kids to read just recreationally right not just reading the books in the class but reading on their own because that's where you're going to build your reading skills that's also where we're going to build their ability to be more proficient writers and so we do have Accelerated Reader where we um they can

073read the books they can take assessments it gives them a score in terms of where they are of their their comprehension and some of the foundational skills kind of identifying what some of the gaps are and there's a there's a tool that can be used to identify where the skill gaps are so the teachers can provide some explicit instruction in those skill areas so we do have that districtwide at our school sites so we're targeting it but we know that there's more work to do but we definitely are making a conscious effort to Target Reading by by third grade could you send me those numbers please for for third grade yeah thank you no problem I'm also wondering just piggy backing off of Tom's comment if it would just something for us to consider um

074might be nice to include even a mini study session just to kind of correlate this to the what's the other data Quest is that what I'm thinking of where you can break it down by grade level by School site or yeah just just to look at it you know what I'm talking about data Quest information then there's a caps data and then there's the information for the dashboard those three different measures yes yeah just not today I mean but and when you go on the just so you know when you go on the California school dashboard which by the way although it's printed out here and very dense um going in uh sorry I'm just going to interrupt from a second is on the on the on the dashboard itself for the for the community

075for everyone to see you can go into any school any school district and it's very flu flexible you can kind of poke around if you will but it also connects directly to that data quest to too there's a way to it kind of links into that as well got it okay and anytime you if the board anytime need more data please let us know and we happy to provide it as well definitely and then a follow-up question um so we had covid we had interrupted schooling we tried to teach kids how to read over a computer which isn't effective and so I'm just wondering have you started to see some shifts now that that cohort now that our second graders have been in school for kindergarten first second grade are we starting to um you

076know they call it like the co slide are we've seen some of that shift I'm going to allow the uh site administators respond to that Miss fish you like to chime in on that and if I put you on the spot and you'd like to respond later that's fine too okay I definitely think that we see where the gaps are whether it is um I don't need these to see you um whether it is students with their writing where they're missing saying the conventions is a huge struggle because they didn't have the practice of writing on paper in a classroom with their teacher that those kinds of things um any with when they're developing their reading knowledge just learning the phone names all that basic foundational skills you don't even have the practice with how

077you move your mouth to make the certain sounds all those things so what we look at now is when we identify those gaps is targeting them specifically and if we identify certain students who even by first or second grade like to Tom's question when we're trying to make sure they're reading by third grade even before then but looking at how we can utilize response to intervention our RTI to Target those kiddos who need those foundational skills some it's not as significant others it's very obvious who needs the more intense intervention so old old school programs at first instruction the direct instruction reading Mastery is something that we utilize consistently we see that it makes the difference for our kiddos and to hear a first grader I have a video of him singing it um saying

078I am so smart I can read now and then he started singing this boy is on fire and it's literally the cutest thing I've ever seen but they know they know where they struggle but they know also when they're making those gains but it's very clear to see where these gaps are because it's pretty consistent across the board and so it's easier when it's consistent it's easier to Target that whole group large group things like that but when we see those kiddos who need them more intensive direct intervention that's where that real intense RTI comes in so thank you um more than questions I have comments and one of my comments was exactly what Dr hasso just mentioned how covid affect our kids and our students and and personally I know a lot of families

079that have reached to me and say parents that they don't even know how to read or write and how can they help their kids and when Co hit it was really hard for them and they can see how behind their kids are now and they just trust on the teachers and I can tell you right now we have 10 people 10 persons in here sitting around that are responsible for the entire education of the uh our students and is in our hands and we as working make decisions can make recommendation can ask but all of you are the ones who know what's going on in your classroom and even you as a principal because you were teachers before you know most of the students but there every teacher that is working with these kids and

080sometimes I believe that it's hard for them and and not hard but it's a challenge to make sure that the kids understand everything that they're explaining and I would say I would ask parent and family engagement is standard met how do we measure that so we use there's a a reflection tool that we use to um score rate ourselves on those different standards and so I have a copy of that hold on it's a self-reflection tool and it so it has various questions that you answer as it relates to those different local indicators and then once you do your score you get a score and then it determines if your standards met not met Etc um do you believe that um team together played an important role for the for these kids to be able

081to bring their homework the next day if it wasn't for them our kids will be way behind of at the point that they are right now our after school program right so um anytime our students get additional support we know that's important and uh our families are you know working and not coming home not able to be with their student maybe after school and the the the support that they receive there is one component of it we know that our think together um Partners work with our uh our prin site principles to make sure they know what generally the goals are for the students um you know think to the after school program they're not teachers there but they are adults who are there to support children so we know any additional support that we

082can provide children is excellent um many of our schools also have after the bell and other types of programs that maybe teachers are conducting with students um after school school and even before school as well that's a little bit different but that's another additional support out there as well so we know that we are doing everything that is possible to help our students right we'll just exactly everything that's possible and more and we'll continue to explore those options as we have the resources and just add one thing just to that and also um the think together program they they do work to try and have like make it a seamless progression from the school day to the um after school day and so they have a meeting at the beginning of the year the program

083leaders meet with the site administrators they do goal setting and then I do meet with things together monthly and they do talk about their focus and how they're supporting our students so they are definitely there's a collaborative effort to to work with our students to help them make progress um we are um something that I have noticed in our community um is that I would say unfor unfortunately many of our parents um have give access to probably students in second grade to be with the phone when they get home that's a a huge disadvantage for our students and I have seen many many kids playing with their phone and it's hard for parents um to tell them you better do your homework or do this because cell phone was not available for the parent so

084he wants to help give their kids what they think is the best so sometimes technology is making you know harder for the students to learn because they are playing they are not really reading or doing something that will help them in education and and I see that that is a challenge beside what Dr Hass just mentioned about how Co hit and and and I will put it in a different ways that I I have talked to some parents and I say when Co hit is like if a person have cancer in order for them fully recover from cancer they have to go through a tough time and it's going to take a long time to recover our kids are behind and that's no way I mean there is no doubt about it but life is

085changing technology what is going on right now with the parents uh kids are worried the mom and dad was going to leave them and I mean I have received a lot of phone calls from parents that are really concerned and so it is a huge challenge that all of you have right now and that we have but you are every single day at your school sites so I I am very blessed and pleased to see this report and um I think I believe that what the program The Institute that was from parents at the high school uh this last year H what was the name you PK I think it was an amazing tool for many parents that have reached to me and say now I know what I want for my kid now I

086can help them to do just to motivate them keep doing it just do it and do this and parents sometimes they have they have a full-time work and so they get home they cook they clean up and then they have to be ready to do the same thing for next day but now they're taking the time to push their kids and say yeah you can do it I know you can do it and they give that time so I think the programs like that will help parents too and and if anything that this board can help we are not here just to approve or disapprove any any of the uh items that that our um Dr Hillman bring to us it is our responsibility to to make sure that these kids receive equal education no

087matter if they are English Learners Learners or I mean if they are fully English um no matter what their situation is all of them deserve um our attention so I appreciate all your input all your insights and I have a lot of questions but I I also when I make the questions I also make the answers I look for the answers and before I ask I respond myself and I think that I've been here a long time and I would not say too long no because every year has been a challenge since I stter it was nothing I can name you all the superintendents that I went through but it is a challenge it is a challenge and and I am very proud to serve in um in this board on this board because all

088of you because you help to show that we can do it because you help us us to look good also and sometimes not too good but we're doing our best I mean what can we do I can't I can't believe that Dr Lon is doing this presentation right now when did you start how many month how long ago four months five months four months 32 years ago I've been prepping for 32 years what one thing I just want to just say I think this important when we look at any data especially the dashboard data is the change we want to make sure that our students are making gains and we know that the different subgroups different students they come in at different levels and they're not all it's not they're not all the say at

089Point level five when they come in and so you have level six and 12 and 24 and so the school sites have to look at all those levels and say how do I take the student from where they are and how do I move them forward and it's not just a simple one strategy doesn't work you have to figure out what's going to be the best approach to meet the needs of these four students and these six students and and it it's it's like a nice little Balancing Act but I think that knowing that the sites are supported and they know that we're all on the same team and we want to we're looking for growth and that value added piece is what's going to make the difference for the work that we have to

090continue to do because we have a lot of work to do you know we look at our students with disabilities and with our long-term English Learners we have some we got to cover some territory but I I know that you know we have a great team um a great collaborative team they're very knowledgeable with our teachers our teaching and learning coaches our instructional AIDS our directors you know our custodial staff everybody with everybody working together I believe it can we can we will continue to make a difference but never forgetting that it's the change we're looking for are the students moving forward and so even if you if it's 17 points 100 points we just don't want negatives we want to see them make that positive um progress every year I think that that's just

091very important to remember thank you last question promise my for me um I'd like to ask uh the principles um if you can give some examples to the board uh what your reading incentives look like at your school sites um some of our aside from just our regular um I that the regular but aside from our trimester Awards things like that where we recognize students for achievement or for effort in the area of language arts as well as other areas we also look at um we before we had Scholastic Reading Counts and now we have Accelerated Reader but recognizing students for um reading books taking quizzes and they get recognized but they are rewarded with more books and prizes as well but things like that just to incentivize being a reader and um being motivated

092and excited about reading but they get Miss Jansen will come around um our teaching and learning coach will go around with her cart of books and they get to choose books and that's the incentive but recognizing the students for achievement um you know a lot of our kiddos are doing um their data notebooks data binders so they are tracking their own progress as well which is just knowing that you're setting goals for yourself and achieving those goals even recognizing kiddos for you made your goal here this is huge celebrating them so within the classroom but schoolwide as well so those are just some examples um I'll add um so it's funny you asked that question because this year as our leadership um we're looking to create a new reading incentive program um because we didn't

093feel we were um recognizing reading as we should we had our our um Reading counts and our Scholastic but now we're moving to or we have moved to Accelerated Reader which now they're taking quizzes and they're getting points and so teachers are starting to play with things um in within their classroom as how to incentivize their students and we're every time we meet um at least once a month with leadership we're talking about okay what do what do we want this to look like schoolwide and we were pretty advantageous and it was it it failed I'm being honest like it failed because it it didn't it we were like we're not recognizing enough students and so once we um thank you to the board and and um Dr Hillman for um bringing in Accelerated Reader

094um that's making the difference so even from our little ones um reading isn't always just about a book it's site words um you know when we talk about our foundational skills so like our little kiddos they'll get like little charms for reading certain words or meeting that goal um even our kids as as um Dr Lawson shared from Reading you know our our most struggling student who might be in first grade but still on that kindergarten it list but wow they've now mastered 30 words you know to see them so excited for that so we try to take reading not just in like here's a book read it but making sure it meets all levels but um we're actually in the process so I will share with you when we have finalized we are having

095a family literacy night to bring that um awareness to our parents and that's on March 11th we're very busy in March because it's a long month um but that's exciting too because um since we've been talking about this since last year we were like we need to get families involved as well so that they see the importance and we're having um a new a new um we always have Scholastic Book Fairs but because of our duel and and the and and supporting um families especially of our English Learners um we're having it's um a new book um Fair coming called Miha books um and they're coming the last week in February and they're they have um multilingual books that we know our population needs for both The Duel but also for the homes so we're

096bringing a awareness this this next month and and that's thanks to our leadership and that's our teachers and staff so that's that's what we're working on we had a similar struggle what are we recognizing kids for right if it's a fifth grader when we used to do Reading Counts it's like a fifth grader who reads a book that's super low level to achieve the point gets all their points are we are we rewarding the right thing and so that's been a huge discussion um as well we've tried different iterations um of a pastry proficiency party um all sorts of um different ways of looking at what defines a reader because is it site wordss is it being able to read fluently is it comprehension um is it passing a test um so kind of looking

097at all those things and one of the things that I think really got parents involved last year in that is we asked for donation of prizes and so that really put a different spin on it because now you have parents going oh I can contribute to the reward system and so um we got far more than I think we ever would have imagined and a wide variety of the students to pick from so we had Middle School families donating gift cards to Starbucks because they knew that was motivating for their own children and so um kind of opened our eyes to different ways of rewarding this year in a couple of our intervention classes I challenged the students to say what would make you want to read because I think um similar to what Dr

098Lawson was saying it's that in we want that independent reading too that reading for Joy um that so many lose when they struggle to read and I will be the first one to say it because I was one and so I kind of ignored reading unless I was forced so I challenged the students in one of our in our two reading intervention classes to say what would motivate you to pick up a book what would motivate you to keep reading it and finish it um and I got all kinds of things that I would have never thought of but not not difficult things um some of them really just want a certificate to hang on their wall some of them want an ice cream cone you know so um trying to personalize it because I

099think the other thing with um like missz was suggesting the world is changing the things that rewarded us as kids um no longer are motivating in the same way some are some are not but um so that's something we're looking at to is as we start to reward and incentivize reading we want to make sure we're rewarding and incentivizing the right thing um so stay tuned but yeah for AR especially it's like you take a onepoint test you know or onepoint book but you're reading at a 30-point level we want to make sure so I just wanted to add one thing because we talked a lot right now I think we're talking about the little guys right our youngest students I actually saw something really wonderful at the high school um in one of the

100English classes the teacher there was really having an time giving the students some time to do some independent reading and it was really kind of Miss alred was doing alred was doing that and uh we she and I were talking about that and just really about how to in incentivize you know older folk older students um even adults right to take the time to read and it's it's a much different world that we all live in But continuing to to find ways to connect with literature to connect with books and connect with reading so I was really encouraged by that and I know our Middle School I've been in enough of our Middle School classes too that many of them are doing novel studies which really then is is another way although it's not independent

101reading it's about digging into a novel in a new way so that they um see themselves as readers in a different way not just an excerpt or something like that so forgive me for interrupting these are like the coolest mics I've ever seen okay um um I definitely wanted to Echo um what all the other principles were saying as well um one of the things that really has stood out to me at Royal Oaks is that direct celebration from the teachers themselves in class the immediate feedback um that's been really meaningful it stood out and just kind of um that instant connection I mean it's building the the classroom community and uh it's Dem demonst to students like at the moment that this is important I'm on the right track I'm engaged so something that

102stood up I just want to add one thing that it happens at most of the sites are the book buddies so the older students read with the younger students and I think that's a huge motivator right because you have kids that are the kindergarteners and some of those first graders are reading with fifth graders and they probably reading a fifth grade text but they're working together and you have big sisters reading with little brother and so I think that is also making a huge impact in students wanting to become more proficient readers and what it also does is allow students it doesn't matter what level you are as a reader you can read with a buddy and they can be engaged and they can have discussions and they can build the comprehension and they can

103they can extend the text and so I think that that's also one thing that we don't want to overlook because I know it happens that most of our sites those reading buddies I just want to piggy back on that really quick too because the other thing that we're starting to realize is to capitalize on the second language and so we purchased some books um different levels so parents can read with their students so the parents page might be you know a little longer and a little more difficult and then um differing levels for the student but we also did that with bilingual and so it's really fun the parent might read in Spanish but then the child reads in English um or vice versa and so I know some of those books are also getting

104used by book Buddies um to just help them to let both both buddy buddies read um or some from some of our newcomers to allow them to uh see text in their home language so yes book buddies I have a real quick question um do any of the schools have any book clubs or reading clubs sometimes you know if the kids are reading together maybe they can encourage one another help one another sometimes I think they they they feel more comfortable with their peers versus um being criticized or feeling bad with an adult just an idea within classes yes yeah so I don't know about like a like a club per se but within classes yes there's absolutely uh in that small group instruction sometimes they do a a book club and um last year

105we did do in the Middle School level have a outside person come and run a book club um that I think was quite successful for middle schoolers just making sure choosing a book that was perfect for them and then allowing them to discuss in a way that makes sense so yeah I'm just going to talk about it from the perspective of Mount Olive and our high school students one of the things that we utilize is a building up their confidence to read because a lot of students are coming in they're struggling academically or they're struggling socially emotionally so what we try to do is build on their passion so we find out what it is they want to do so I'm G give you a perfect example so Azie via um Mr Harold is a

106very familiar with him great kid um want to be a nurse that's what he wants to do um this has been quite a ride for him over the past three months he was accepted uh for the interview for the Kaiser program um he just passed his uh um English class as citrus today got a 90% or better but it was all built off of you can do this and it's going to be a challenge and it's going to be tough but you can get through this and with the support of the teachers you know motivating him and helping him through the process I mean now he's just running on his own and he reads for example he's taken the uh medical terminology course right now because he wants to be a nurse I think that's

107important to build on their passion find out what it is they like and then just they'll take off on their own and they'll want to read they'll want to write they'll want to get involved and get engaged uh couple definition questions I had so um number one how do we classify a foster youth is that just someone who's in a foster program or is that like somebody like a grandparent taking care of a child is that person considered a foster youth so on the on our form it asks if they if they are with if they're placed in the home with someone and they're identified as a foster youth not just living with the grandmother because you can be living with your grandmother not be fostered okay so these kids are um Foster or homeless

108as identified by um this the system yeah okay okay um and then I I think you mentioned this in your presentation but I was not very familiar with it Kagan strategies yes those are great collaborative strategies and so um we love the G strategies those are fun so they did the Kagan strategies act um Royal Oaks and beerley are in year [Music] three they they did a two years they did year one year two and then Maxwell and and valy viw are now in their second year and so it's this different collaborative strategies that they can use to work with students and um you guys want to talk a little bit more about how you use them and you see them across the board they have some there's some great ideas on how you can

109level kids and play them place them in groups and um different ways the teachers can indicate who those students are so you know what types of questions to ask them what type of ways to engage them in the learning um one of the things that's beautiful about the Ken strategies is you start by by focusing on something that is non-academic so that all kids can kind of access those particular strategies they'll feel comfortable engaging in the discourse and the dialogue that's taking place so it may be like you know the water toss the water ball how many times can you how high can you toss the water ball bottle toss it to the left toss it to the right talk about that piece there's they did an activity with with um balloons where you had

110four groups of kids in the in a group or it was actually adults and they threw one balloon in you had to keep the balloon in the air so they had to work together and then you threw a second balloon in there so we should do that that would be fun they put they threw that in there so then they had to keep that balloon in the air but they had to work together as a team so it helps to kind of build that camaraderie so the students know they have to work together before you get into those complex uh Concepts in mathematics or science or history Etc so um if you guys want to add to it I think that if not we're good to go um the focus is on collaboration so requiring

111them to collaborate all the structures require multiple students to be and then the other piece is the engagement so rather than for example calling like Mr Reyes M Dr hos so one at a time the structur is provided so all students are actively engaged um sometimes it's 100% but the lowest that they ask for they're in teams of four generally and the lowest would be 25% of your class engaged in answering at one point so high levels of Engagement high levels of collaboration um and then a lot of the structures allow for you to differentiate without having to think about it so in the group of four you know where your English learners for example are sitting so instead of having to be like okay I'm going to ask I can say every two stand

112up here we go with your structure and give them and so you can there's a structure to even setting up the collaborative group but focus on collaboration and engagement great thank you very much um oh oh no no please miss I was just going to add that um with the Cooperative structures the focus initially as Dr Lawson was talking about is a lot of those engagement strategies but it's focusing on community building within your classroom and then it narrows it down to team building within their team and ultimately you're giving students roles and responsibilities so that when they are engaging it's purposeful conversation that student discourse is guided in that they know what they're supposed to be doing they know like if you did um uh inside Circle outside Circle example kids are with their

113partner you have kids partner a is on the inside partner B is on the outside they're facing each other and it could be okay you're going to take before you go back and do your independent practice for your math problem partner a tell your partner B how you're solving this problem they're teaching them okay switch now partner B tells partner a it gives students that opportunity purposeful conversation they have roles they have responsibilities they are engaged and I I watched it in a classroom where a teacher was not as comfortable with it tried it for the first time in a formal observation and kids walked away from that engagement that um Cooperative structure literally the statements were oh my gosh this is going to be so easy I've got this because they had the opportunity

114with a structure to practice how they were going to do the work um but that community and team building within a classroom provides a safe environment where they are safe to learn safe to ask questions safe to give their feedback and their thinking so it's amazing all around and ultimately that student discourse just enhances their ability to learn so great thank you anyone else I didn't want to speak over anyone uh and and so do do our teachers get formal training in this okay all right that sound I mean it sounds amazing so it's yeah the two schools when they went first were a looks and beards Lee had two years so that was two full days of each year of Kagan um training and then Maxwell and valy just did it over last year

115and this year we did our it's ultimately four full days of um training great um all right so then this is this is more of a a higher level question maybe for you Dr Lawson so so you mentioned that this this report comes out in December and it is it is going back and looking at data that were collected in the spring um and then you know it it finally gets you know a deep dive you know now in in February I mean are are we do we find that these data are still relevant given that they were sort of collected almost a year ago and do we have other methods to sort of attack the problems before having to wait this long yeah so it's trailing data that they would kind of Define it

116as that um but absolutely so when we we get the data in the the beginning of the year our administrators do look at the information so we are having the study session in February but it is linked to our cast data so when the cast data came out the site administrators were able to look at that data and take a deep dive into where students scored proficient non proficient exceeding the standard Etc so that is that's how we get the academic data here so it's not so there's not a lot of gaps in the time when they analyze the data but we also use our Stars uh Renaissance Stars assessment data and we do that at the beginning of the year we do it every six to eight weeks and so that gives us data

117on our our reading and on our math and so we use that data to drive instruction we use that data to meet and talk um a leadership team to look at where our strengths are where the areas of growth are it gives us um some one of the reports that um we can look at gives a tells you where students are in terms of meeting the standards for the classrooms you can look at the the pacing and where your students are um if they continue at the same progress will they meet standards at the end of the year if not what do we need to do there's data it's like a it's kind of like a stoplight data so we can look at that data vertically if it's up and down and say it's red

118up and down that's an indication that we need to make an adjustment with instruction if it's um this is this is vertically horizontal data tells us all this particular student is struggling with these particular standards so we do have some data points where we check every six to eight weeks to see where our students are that's one measure that we use teachers also use their um teacher created assessments they use I Exel at some of the sites so they use that diagnostic assessment data um we use um assessments from a math um so yeah we have different data points that we're collecting and we're not we we don't only just look at the academic piece though I think that it's also important to know because we look at um we have to look at you

119know Behavior how well our kids being successful in the classroom are they things that are hindering their ability to learn um they're having um Med at the sites where they do student study teams in the RTI and our mtss so we can look at where our students are how can we support them early on what are the red flags so that we can meet those meet the needs of those students early on we're not we don't want to wait till the last minute we don't want to wait until we get this data but this data does say all those things that we were doing throughout the year did make a difference or not and then that's where we can then go in and make adjustments in these areas where we see significant increases we can

120say yeah those strategies that we were using for math in this area those May a difference oh we don't see any gains in our reading perhaps we need to go back and adjust some of our strategies and practices that we're using yeah great thank you sounds like we we do have a lot of ways to get more real time data so that's excellent um so what one I guess overarching question that I have in in looking at the the California dashboard in general is you know I think the vast majority of people if they do go and look at the dashboard are going to land on that page and are going to see those initial little meters right and and their initial thought is going to be I you know the school or the district

121I want my kid to go to I want them to all be blue all of them right and and they're going to look and go oh my gosh they're not blue um and and I think you've eloquently uh described that you got to dig a little bit deeper and see increases and and the this you know the progress that that we as the district are making and that students are making um so I guess my my question is um for for you know people that that we encounter in the community on a day-to-day basis that we don't have um you know coming up on an hour and a half of time to spend talking to them about like hey this is what all the data mean how how do we talk to them about this

122and say hey don't just look for it to be in the blue there's a lot more there than just that I would say for them to look at the the change data so if they see that stop sign and it's on that signal and it's saying yellow go deeper where you can click on the link and it'll take you deeper into the subgroup data to get more details about what that what that color actually represents so if I'm looking at a school district and I see that it's all blue I mean that would be like spectacular um but that doesn't mean that every student is scoring 100% proficient on every single assessment so you're looking at the change so if every year we're increasing and gaining every year we're making growth and that you see

123on that one grid where you say like this year was significant and the following year we make significant we're going to keep moving the color is going to keep changing and so you can hit blue and it doesn't necessarily you could doesn't necessarily mean that uh every student I guess is the entire district is proficient so I would say look at the the lever go deeper and look at the detail dets and look at growth is this District making a difference where students are improving are they increasing every year or are they declining and are they or are they just maintaining because you can be green and just maintain and just in for example in a school site in a school site you can have different levels of students right and you can have students

124that come in green and they just continue to maintain and they don't change we also want to accelerate that as well right and so how do you look at are we continuing to move our students forward dig deeper into the data dig deep into the subgroup data to see if I put my child in this school district and my student is the English learner can they achieve if my student is a student who's African-American student can they achieve in this District if my student is a student that is a reclassified student can they achieve in this District what does their data say and if that data says yes those students are increasing they are making gains then yes this is a place for them so we can't just go looking at a color that one

125page that doesn't give any more information doesn't help them so always encourage them to dig deeper and look to see if they see change from the prior year to the current year and also on the dashboard there's another you can go a little bit deeper and you can look at four years so you can see more so they need to you know do their research go deeper and just track it to see our kids moving all right so click around okay okay can I can I add one thing to just because I had this conversation with a parent it's important to know that you can be orange up from excuse me you can be yellow up from Orange but you can also be yellow cuz you're down from Green and so really the color isn't

126what's important it's how you got to the color MH um that matters and you have to you have to click to go deeper to determine if you went up to yellow or un you know down to Yellow okay yeah that's a really good point thank you for making that distinction I appreciate it um La I think this is my last question um chronic absenteeism we were at almost a quarter of the students um I think it was 23 and a half% um that seems like a lot to me um but I I don't know historically what it has been and and if I remember correctly was is that 10% or 10 days or more I remember one I believe it's one feel like there was a 10 in there somewhere 10% so so they're they've

127been absent for 10 more or 18 days because it's 180 days been a stubborn I will just I'll just jump um sorry because I just have this in my head um prior to covid we were in single digits for chronic Cs and ISM Co I'm not going to make that an excuse but it's a Statewide issue Nationwide issue um it was in the 30s I think we were probably as high as 35% at one point a couple years back so we're seeing gains okay we're seeing improvements um but it's something we're still continuing to work at yeah and and I mean are we um on par with other districts in the state I mean they Al they're also seeing numbers this High okay yes this is a Tren unfortunately it is a trend across gotcha

128okay um all right thank you on that same note um kind of going back to the idea of having reading incentives um are there um attendance incentives in place to incentify or incentivize students to come I see head's nodding so yeah okay and our and our sites have attendance meetings as well so many times there are other factors that that need to be done on an individual basis I know the principles do a lot of that Outreach um working with uh families who may have uh maybe some trends that way but and then we also know that when students are students are ill they they shouldn't be in school either so there's that balance we have to be sensitive to I was just thinking back to you know perfect attendance like that's kind of not

129quite the goal right so all right Bor any more questions or comments I just have Mr President I just have a comment to make um last Friday I went to visit school and um I got into one of the classrooms and I was talking to one teacher and the principal and um I hear the kids playing and laughing outside the the entire school was about the side of this room where we are right now the entire room school but I hear the kids playing and happy and and I thought why can these kids be so happy in here and so I I asked the principal how can we help and she said and she say first first we need water to improve our bathroom second they need like a basketball um playground to play and

130I thought but the kids are playing basketball outside and they were playing any sport they want is playing so but I keep myself quiet when I went outside back again to the to it was just this for this part was the classrooms and this area was the playground when I went outside these kids were so happy playing basketball the basketball ring how do you call that the poop was a plastic hola hoop Tie by with core tied to two threes and they were happy playing basketball and she say you don't see that many kids playing in here because some of them are working with the their parents picking coffee the kids want to be at school every day because they don't want to be doing that all their life in the future I can tell

131you there is no other country better to this country where we live there is no other and I would say it because it's my own School District there is no other better staff that way is here tonight thank you all of you for making the difference in these students lives and parents that they don't want to see their kids going through what they do they want a better life for the kids I just can tell you I am very very pleased and blessed to be part of this big family do we disagree among brothers and sisters yes we do even we disagree with our parents but we know we are in a better place so thank you to all of you for tonight yeah I said that school that you spoke about that did not

132have the basketball court and the it was the when you guys went and visited um e Ecuador right guala Guatemala yeah thank you all thank you thank you and I just wanted to make one final comment um I know it's getting late but I just want to acknowledge and celebrate um your Collective efforts when we look at I mean El progress at um DHS being celebrated that is you know the collective work of those kids who you know have journeyed through our Elementary and high and middle school programs and looking at the um Improvement in graduation rates again those students have navigated a k 9 10 11 12 well 12 right if we're looking at graduation rates and so just want to applaud your Collective efforts and um you know together we're getting kids to

133where we want them to be which is um 12th grade we want them to leave with a with a high school diploma so thank you and thank you for everything that you presented tonight it was really helpful just want to say thank you as well and um I think it's important to get our parents and families engaged with our kids especially the English Learners and I think if we involve them um they'll be more confident and they'll be able to help their kids with their homework or whatever it needs to so look forward to that and going to um the first day that you guys do that thank you and thank you Dr Lawson you did great all right yes thank you very much uh very very informative I think uh I and I think

134everyone on the board learned a lot um Dr Lawson from from your presentation and the discussion that uh you helped to Foster here um so uh I think Dr hman that's everything um so if there's no other questions or comments then I believe we can go ahead and adjourn this meeting and we will be adjourning this meeting in memory of Laura caperon um if I hope I'm saying that right um um that is the mother of Grace Reyes um so we're we'll adj adjourning in her memory um so do I have a motion to adjourn the meeting so move is there a second all right we have a motion by board member Diaz second by board member hogin is there any discussion seeing none all those in favor say I I I I thank you

135board thank you everybody

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.