001us back from Clos session hold on okay one second sure s right hi everybody Welcome this evening we're just having a few little technical difficulties so just give us a moment please thank you so much oh I got you got real quiet so thankful everybody's here tonight yeah just see is it sh let me see if it's sh two people Ed waiting room too by the way people in the wa we're making sure you can shut screen yeah we're just gonna go with it um can you yeah I'm not sure right now if you're gonna see close captioned or not we not on YouTube is it on an agenda item no okay so that's not on an agenda okay want me to inv you can always exit right now hold on one second are we
002good to go good to go since it was impacted when okay should we redo it well let's if we're if we're do me a favor have somebody check with I bar just to see if she's seeing the meeting but I'm gonna have go okay okay let's go ahead let's go ahead and start yeah let's go okay all right um I'd like to reconvene us into regular session um tonight at 60 whatever time it is 6:02 PM welcome welcome um Dr Cutler do we have any actions to report on from close session I don't believe we do there's nothing to report thank you and then item number seven are communication reports these reports are limited to five minutes um first I'd like to ask for the board member reports do I have any reports from the
003board board members sure Val um I attended the Marcela foundation's reading pal training and also have started the reading Pals with them it's um a program of volunteers at Taho Valley and to reach motivate and improve reading abilities one child at a time we only have 16 people we could use more talk to Melissa upand doll um and then also we had our board retreat last week and had great conversations um and getting to know there are new trustees and um setting priorities um bottom line out of that everybody on this board wants to do what's best for the kids the staff and the parents of our community so I was really happy with the retreat and that's it thanks thank you anybody else Bob okay John a trusty heav yeah I'd like to just
004reiterate uh what truste field said it was a great Retreat um for the high school students Honor Society you know this go home and study got one more day of finals tomorrow and then you got new classes new excitement for the spring term so um keep pushing on and keep making us proud excellent all right any other reports none I've seen none um I just want to say yes thank you I I just really appreciate that the board all gave their time and attention to our our goal setting on Friday and Saturday and um I too also a reading pal so I'm very excited I I trusty Mansfield's been teaching reading for her entire career and um it's new for me so I'm really excited about participating on that as well um all right we
005have student board member report and tonight we have Mia Valenzuela hi everyone I'm so excited to see you again this year since I haven't been since last year so I'm so excited for our new board members and our reoccurring board members for a new year and I just wanted to talk about a bit on change I know that we are navigating change in our country this can be for the better or the worse it sometimes brings feelings of stress and anguish I just want to continue to encourage staff administrators and students to be kind and respectful during these times to truly promote campus safety apart from this I know that a lot of seniors are doing senior projects scholarships fast fun like it was pre previously mentioned it's finals week so if you see a
006student or even yourself just give yourself a pat on the back um and apart from this I'd like to discuss about our ASB relationships with counseling and admin I know as I previously mentioned uh there is some support sessions to all students for any stress going on you can talk to me if something like that is happening and I can direct you as well as something that I found really interesting was that they were talking about finding a dress code that's conscious of all body types and I really love the way that they're bringing this to the table is it might not be as conventional as a conversation as we think it is and overall I'm so proud of us for getting through half the school year yay thank you Mia that was excellent I
007look forward to hearing more about that dress code but I I and all the work that the ASB is doing with counseling staff um to help support our students thank you um all right we have super attendent report president kber members of the board thank you so much first of all I want to number one thank everybody for their patience um we have some folks out in regards to our use of technology and um and so we're navigating some components there and a shout out to Sher Ross that's working really hard to to support us and and and figure this out as we go here so thank you back there Sher um and as long as it sounds like people are on people can see us people can hear us that's the most important thing
008so this looks a little different in here so so just be patient with us tonight um sometimes when life happens um we have to navigate so I appreciate that um you know welcome back from into 2025 we actually haven't been in the boardroom other than our board retreat so and thank you for everybody to be here tonight looking forward to the work ahead of us um and really excited to to get into the material there's a lot happening and and on tonight's agenda whether that's material about the governor's budget or audits or or some of the bond activities lots happening in our district and really excited about that I do want to say that there's some concern happening and I know that many of our families have shared concerns regarding the decisions and actions of
009our federal government regarding immigration enforcement our schools must be a safe place for our students to learn and grow it is important for us to reassure our families that our efforts will be to protect protect the rights of all students and keep them safe in our care together we need to ensure that our families that they are welcome supported and safe and I just want to uh speak on behalf of Staff um but I believe I can speak on behalf of our board and our community that we care about our students our families and we're here to protect them and make sure that they can learn and grow in an environment that they feel comfortable in and so we stand on that speaking of uh that we did have a board retreat this last week
010I do want to thank all of the board members and staff that participated in the board retreat um I felt as though uh one matter of fact one of the board members in the in the final debrief said it was just really a nice cohesive working group and that meant a lot to me as as your superintendent um really felt as though we came along and learning the how we work together and also what our priorities are and just to give a shout out to the priorities um we do have posters up that that highlight our priorities from the previous year the board reviewed those and discussed and really in the end thought that those priorities literacy Innovation whole child were really still uh relevant and and needed um and they discussed also when thinking
011about when we think about whole child there thought about the the whole of everybody and so we end and are working on an additional priority it's still under under work but I thought I'd want to share it and the board wants to make sure that everybody matters in our our community and our organization all staff students families parents community members and that we focus on how we become a more tighten connected group so I I I hope I'm I'm okay speaking on the board's behalf on that but that's of course something we're going to continue to work on um I do want to say this that on March 19th we have the state of the district and we'll talk about the board's priorities we'll talk about our lcap and we'll talk about how we're performing
012as a district and and the look ahead to what's in the future so I want to make sure that folks are marking their calendars for that you know there's a lot happening in the activities um and I just want to say thank you to our board repres student board representative Mia for thinging you know if we could all be kind to one another and have that process we'll be at a lot better place and so thank you for for leading that statement tonight um and once again thank you for everybody being here look forward to uh 2025 thank you Dr Cutler all right uh we now have uh time for the employee Association reports and I see both uh Miss DeBerry and U Miss Santana in the audience so who's gonna go first I have
013some right here too all right we have Bernadet Santana good evening president ker board members Dr Cutler on behalf of csca I just want to say welcome to the new board members uh we look forward to working with you collaboratively and it's the beauty of a small town that I all know one another and it's kind of ironic in the roles that we play but I just want to welcome you and I know you've all hit the ground running and gone to csba and had a great Retreat so thank you on behalf of our group thank all right Miss Dy good evening Dr Cutler members of the board and the public my name is jod debery and I am here representing the sou Tahoe Educators associate I want to welcome our new board members some
014old no I knew i' say that wrong old faces No old friends what I meant but as a parent of some their students and co-workers it's really great to to see you all here and appreciate you giving your time I have a couple of things that I do want to um speak about and Dr Cutler you um brought it up in in your [Music] um conversation with the board um and it's about our students our families our community in light of the changes in our uh government and kids are scared we have had children that are telling their teachers that they might not be able to come to school their families are making tough decisions to keep their CH children at home in light of the new um executive orders that were were passed or
015were signed so there's a couple of things here first and foremost it's the needs of our students and their need to feel safe and secure as many of you may be aware um ice was up in the community and many families kept their children home this potentially can be an ongoing and and continual problem and it will also affect our attendance and so that's something I think that we need to be aware of and look at in ways that possibly students that are not coming um may be able to we may be able to get some type of an independent study going for them for those days that they may the families may decide that it's best for them not to be at school the other thing I I do want you to be aware
016of it are the laws and alls I can say is thank goodness we're in California um because our state has taken some very good um measures um as far as protecting students rights um in recent articles on education weekly there is information about how it's a parents guide and also for School Employees and how we can best support our immigrant students hands and cannot that we as a district can can ask there's a real quick uh one pager that outlines these rights and especially for our front office people that may be the very first people that have to put up the stop signs um what we should be doing um and so also you may want to familiarize yourself with um Rob Bon the Attorney General of California's report in December which is promoting a
017safe and secure learning environment for all it specifically deals with guidance policies um to ass assist K12 schools in responding to immigration issues um I can give you the link or you can just go right to um the website the State website for that and so with that I I think we at the school sites all staff um we probably need some guidance and and po potentially uh professional development and also in helping our families get them to the resources whether it's Family Resource Center there are things in the community there are people in the community that can also help to support I also moving on to um the extension of of our retirement incentive um I want to thank Dr Cutler um we have worked closely on this um and decided that we can
018offer not just the ons schedu incentive but a sliding scale to um if other people are indeed wanting to leave and they don't meet the 10year threshold so we see that as very positive positive thing along with the Social Security Fairness Act that was passed I know of two people that went ahead and looked up what that looks like for them and have made a decision to go ahead and um start the retirement sooner than they anticipated so great for them and then lastly um I have a request um Miss kamach Mr Anderson um I am a Shameless promoter of Arts and Music um and you may be aware of the proposition 28 that was passed by the state voters and as the district is looking at determination of needs for next year I would
019want to ask you to make sure it's on your radar that we look at fully restoring Elementary music we've taken some steps and what we're really looking for is to fully restore Elementary instrumental music to where we were and in the long run it will help get our kids to where they need to go into the middle school program and the high school program both which have been um have lost students of interest and we very much believe it's because of eliminating the instrumental music so with that thank you I look forward to working with all of you have a good night thank you all right um we now have public comment and um I have a statement to read about that if your comment is on an item that is not on the agenda
020your name will be called at this time if you would like to make a public comment on an item that is on the agenda your name will be called after that item is discussed and prior to the final action being taken if any please limit your comments to 3 minutes or less if there is more than one speaker on a particular topic the the board president May limit the comments to less than three minutes however no more than 20 minutes of public input will be taken on any one item we appreciate your cooperation and helping us to facilitate the timeliness of our meetings also I'd like to remind everyone that the brown Act only allows the board to address items that are on the posted agenda the board is listening and cares about your comments
021but we cannot respond to any of them at this time Dr Cutler are there any public comment yeah we have a couple public comments this evening we'll start with chess Chelsea Vermillion parent teacher uh specific topic is infant daycare program chse see all right everyone hello my name is Chelsea Vermillion I'm a South Tahoe graduate and now a full-time math teacher at the high school and I have been for the past 7 years I am returning from maternity leave this Monday um and i' like to inform you all of how this process has been um for my return I'm going to cut to the points real fast just in case everyone have time um so after being told yes that my second daughter does have a spot at the infant care um I was just
022informed this Tuesday that she currently does not have a spot um we have 3 days or less than a week to figure this out now um so um this is a staff infant care um I'm also concerned that this program is being overlooked um and that it might possibly be getting shut down I don't know I'm just nervous about this now of how this whole process has gone which has 20 plus teachers full-time teachers Staffing their um their children there um so I'm not sure what the plan is for that but it is very hard to get daycare and you are weight listed for very very very long um in this town um so my question is um is this how we value our employ employes being told yes that we do have a spot
023and then given 3 days of notice to try and figure something out when I'm trying to prepare for my job and help my students um to do my job um so and my other question is what are we supposed to do um I now want to go through the facts of my process that I have been doing in this um so as of December 2023 I notified the staff daycare enrollment teacher that I am pregnant and I would like to add my second daughter to the program for January 2025 um I knew this process with my first daughter that it is a long process so that was a year in advance um she told me I sure I had a spot for sure by March 2025 um and that I could be on the wait
024list for January I needed to check back in with her um to see how many Tac students had babies that were going to be enrolling their children in the program and and so I did that in um August um unfortunately one of our employees at the infant care had left the program and went to the Boys and Girls Club so leaving us short-handed um so they had posted a position um so we were hopeful we were trying to hope that they had hired someone we had overheard that they had hired someone in the beginning of January um so I kept checking back if they had hired someone yay I'd get to start in January um we have not seen that had not seen this person um after break winter break January 6th that Monday I
025went to go see if anyone was back no one had been hir or no one had started yet so I then emailed um John Simmons to let him know that he has two fulltime teachers at the high school that are planning on returning our both of our infants that were told yes that they had a spot um that we would be returning to work on Monday um the 27th um and that I was a little bit more concerned because there was now no person that was supposedly hired um John had reped to me that night and said that um I needed to keep rechecking with the infant care teacher um and so I did that to wait and see time keeps going on we um didn't get have any anything back so on Friday this
026past Friday he had told us that he needed to get back on Tuesday this Tuesday and he would have an answer for us um so that was the answer we no longer had a spot so I just feel like this how would got a little bit out of control and could have been notified back in the fall when they lost the employee that we were a maybe at least so we might have had another option so just wanted to make you guys aware I'm unsure what you guys know and don't know so thank you for your time I appreciate it thank you all right any other hi good evening um I'm the other parent and also staff um teacher at South High School I teach Spanish um I apologize I did not plan on speaking
027at first so I don't have anything written out but I don't want to get too repetitive but I also want to give my account of my situation as well um I had my baby in May um so about a year ago I notified the daycare because as Chelsea said you know sometimes there's a wait list um anywhere in town There's a weight list um so I let them know um in June they told me there was a couple families ahead of us but in June I got the paperwork and was told turn this in and you'll have a spot great um I planned for an extended leave um after a lot of planning I decided to go about a month and a half unpaid which was hard for me to make that decision um this
028is my first third sorry and last kid so I decided to take the extra time but I found first I made sure I ask all the questions made sure I had the spot for the daycare I made sure that I asked the question that I'm not going to be charged for any money while I was paid unpaid leave there's a lot of things that I feel like were not organized and I was trying to get all the information ahead of time I was all set I got my leave I went on leave if it wasn't for Chelsea starting to ask if few weeks ago I would still to this day think like today was the first day I was going to bring my daughter in actually yesterday and I would have found out yesterday that
029she didn't have a spot um at this point Chelsea started asking a couple weeks ago that's when I found out my spot was at risk as well I was never told it was a maybe I had a spot um I'm still don't have an explanation other than staffing issues of why my spot because there's other babies that have been getting in in the year right um the Staffing issu I completely understand but we were not short Staff last week or two weeks ago we've been they've been short staff since the fall so I would have at least expected a heads up or short staff now in August have a plan B right now I have to go back to work on Monday and I had this last three days I've been running around everywhere trying
030to find daycare for my daughter the only solution the district gave me was well we will help you extend your unpaid leave well I have bills to pay I can't I would love to be at home and stay with my baby but I can't I have to go back to work I want to go back to work I've been trying to go back to work um but I have three days to figure it out the only solution I found on my own is a daycare that's going to cost me $1600 just for my one kid um to be able to be back on Monday so anyways I just feel like I do not feel valued I feel like the answer is okay you extend your leave like how much are we actually value how much
031do take care and I understand this is a personal matter but I wish I would have given the chance or been told that it was a risk and not have to find myself looking for their cares everywhere instead of prepping for my classes on Monday so thank you thank you thank you that brings us to the end of a public comment public comment all right item number eight is our students celebration and tonight we have the South Tahoe High School National Honors Society and I see um principal Zunino I also see um the thank you the woman who I know is in charge of the can't think High School principal Mr zenino and Miss McDonald thank you so much for being in here turn it over to you president keer board thank you very much
032for this opportunity tonight we have yet another celebration some outstanding uh individuals here part of our National Honor Society led by a fantastic teacher here Miss McDonald so I'm going to turn over to them share a little bit about what they've been working on plans and and a little bit about their four pillars that they are all about so thank you for the time tonight good evening um thank you for giving us this time we wanted to share a little bit about what National Honor Society represents so I'll start with telling you that National Honor Society was established originally in 1921 and at South Tahoe High School it was established our chapter in 2007 um excuse me my name is Amanda McDonald I should have said that first and currently I serve as the chapter
033adviser um and on the screen in front of you you have the names of our student members so what does it take to be a member of National Honor Society and why do our SS students strive to earn membership well National Honor Society is founded on four pillars um scholarship leadership service and character and NHS defines scholarship as a commitment to learning all of our members achiev and they maintain a minimum GPA of 3.8 unweighted for their entire School career NHS members take initiative to exert a wholesome influence on our school and community at every level and they lead through formal and informal roles whether they're in clubs sports teams study groups anywhere our students are they are leading and influencing student conversations um excuse me uh service is Ed in our membership by a
034minimum of 20 hours of volunteer work each year for the benefit of those in need financially academically or socially and through all of their daily interactions our club members are striving to make the right choice they're committing their time and their talents to cultivating a better tomorrow um tonight a selection of our membership is going to share with you some information regarding our goals and projects this year and we're going to begin with our club president Miss Lily Irwin and then our vice president Sasha P hi everyone I'm this oh there we go okay hi everyone I'm Lil irin and I'm this year's NHS president besides leading me leading meetings organizing events and creating killer spreadsheets a big part of my role is helping my fellow members leverage their impact at CHS everyone in NHS
035is incredibly involved and it is so wonderful to have such a diverse group of students who all have passions in different subjects this year I made it a priority to start projects that our members are personally passionate about each community service project we do whether it's an event fundraiser volunteering or a project we created we assign a student chair who plans out what we are going to do and initiates communication with everyone involved everyone in NHS has to be a chair of at least one project during their time in the club so even though not all members have leadership titles we all have leadership experience my NHS presidency allows me to show gratitude to the community I love through projects while also creating similar thoughts and passions in the members I lead which is equally
036important to me I hope my leadership will show others that a big part of being a leader is having passion and cultivating other people's passions too now now my vice president Sasha picket will highlight how NHS student leadership is engaging and supporting our community this year hi I'm Sasha picket I'm a senior and I'm this year's NHS vice president and part of my obligation to NHS is finding community events for us to be involved in and through dedicated volunteers helping other organizations and club- hosted events NHS has an undeniable impact on our school and Community we've partnered with Primos Italian beastro and leveraged our part participation in several community events to raise funds for the community benefit events and programs that we host and this year we've even applied for our first grant through NHS
037National at three different Marathon Aid stations throughout the year NHS volunteers provide water food and immense encouragement to Runners as they pass by and this year we even got to hand out medals to rock Reno finishers as they cross the finish line other NHS members show their dedication to helping their broader community and environment through spending hours planting and watering Sugar Pine seedlings with thear sugarpine Foundation NHS requires 20 volunteer hours with at least five being from Club hosted events however most of our club members go above and beyond just the that requirement and are heavily involved in many more than just the required volunteering events to create positive change in our beautiful small town community here's to Arya to share a little bit more about how we impact our school community there we go
038hi I'm AIA and I'm a junior in NHS this year volunteering is a big part of what we do as a club and in addition to General Community projects we also look for ways to have a positive impact on our school before midterm and final exams we host cider and study cocoa and cram and pop and prep study sessions giving STS students a space to productively prepare for tests while providing snacks and tutoring in various School subjects during Winterfest in collaboration with other clubs on campus we sell cider and host a booth helping visitors Express their artistic creativity through painting pine cones our members spend eight hours over the two nights of the festival facilitating the craft station of our for our younger community members one of our biggest contributions to the students of ss
039is winter wishes a project that nearly every St excuse me NHS Club member participates in each year in November every STS student and staff member is able to make a wish or request a gift for someone else we then use NHS funds to buy holiday gifts and fulfill as many wishes as we can this year we gave about $800 worth of gifts to 36 students and teachers and the gifts range from stress balls a full Christmas dinner winter jackets and shoes to stuffed animals and sports equipment brightening the holiday season for our classmates and teachers now let's hear from Ava about a new project we started this year good evening everybody I'm Ava and I'm a junior in NHS this year me and my partner Bry DeFranco who's in the audience tonight started a new
040service project our goal was to run a community service project that directly benefited the students of STS as a result we created our version of backpack buddies which is a pre-existing program in other places that provides food for students in need however Brody and I wanted to provide students with more than just snacks including items for personal hygiene and mental health during the longer school breaks so far for Thanksgiving and winter breaks with help from miss marumi and miss Homen we successfully successfully identified and provided 32 middle and high school students with bags full of snacks such as crackers granola bars Gatorade and so much more then for winter break students were provided with a larger variety of snacks along with personal hygiene items we recently applied for an NHS National grant that we hope
041will cover the cost of our spring break backpacks filled with snacks and mental health items while also covering snacks for all St students taking state in advance placement test to continue our NHS chapter gains new members via application process that students begin in February of their sophomore junior year each student typically spends two years in the club which allows them to be become more involved and carry on the projects that they enjoyed participating in from previous years for example Ari and I have really enjoyed taking part in backpack buddies and winter wishes and have seen the positive impacts it has made on our community so we hope to carry on these projects into our senior year overall NHS has a huge impact on both of the members in the club both the members in the
042club and the community we involve ourselves in we will continue fostering passion in high school students and prioritizing the NHS pillars leadership scholarship service and character again thank you so much for your time it's a pleasure to be here thank you thank you number one board members any any any comments yeah congratulations I'm so excited to see that you guys are doing and 20 hours of community service is going to help everybody and I like all the different things that you were doing whether it's cocoa and cram I'd be the one leading that one but um so congratulations you guys you're really an important part of of your school and our community and our board what else you know I Hest say Amanda I just really appreciate your leadership and all that you bring to
043this and helping and supporting this program that is so rich in our school and obviously you have such amazing young people that you get the chance to work with and and yeah can I I just want to make sure I know the number how many students are in our our Honor Society 29 okay thank you okay 29 and bringing in some new members short this this spring right very good I appreciate and we do have some more comments too I'm sorry sorry to cut you off are you oh no I just didn't see anybody no Mia and trusty Anderson both so go ahead Mia okay uh I just wanted to say thank you for National Honor Society for bringing so many events and passionate people together to truly have impact in our school you know
044from backpack Buddies to Coco and cram it's been a pleasure to work with you guys too yeah all right Mr Anderson quite simply bra bra Bravo and Miss tresse kamacho thank you very much I was so impressed with your presentation you stood up there so smooth and I love how you turn the microphone over to each other so thank you for the great presentation and the great job you're doing very nice thank you all we'd like to get a picture with the the the students in the board so so guys come on up there you guys just stand right there it's perfect you're going to jump into the yeah why don't you jump out with then yeah yeah come on yeah get all the students up here slide slide down a little bit that's good
045that's good leaving the tall gentleman over on that end is a good idea let's maybe get that other tell gentleman there you there you go there you go perfect perfect thank you guys good job all right hey hey Justin when you're when then let them know they can obviously leave right now and then let's close the door good job good job all right that was excellent all right we always love having our student celebrations so now we're moving on to item number nine which is recognize January as Schoolboard recognition month you know president camper members of the board I I just wanted to make sure it was on the agenda to to number one um I want to say this I I know and I and I know that you know this as members of
046the board that you put a lot of effort commitment into doing the work that you do and um really we should have every month be recognizing the Ser service of our board members and it truly is service it's the opportunity for you to to give to your community and what is there to me there's no greater organization than to impact the youth and the children of our of our community and and the work that you do here will have lasting impacts and Lasting effect for for years and years and years to come our organization will be in the future what it's going to be because of your guidance your leadership and your efforts and and it and I don't know if people really take the time to realize that and to take the time to
047appreciate you with for that and as this month has been dedicated to be recognized board member month um from me and I believe from our entire team our entire staff we we appreciate your willingness to give of your time your service and your commitment to help our district be a better place so thank you and know that you're appreciated and recognized thank you thank you Dr Cutler appreciate that I didn't catch itton said it is January 23 I said January 23rd recognition well I hold on I get you know there's some joking going on and I want to share with the audience um I do want to tell you we had a little competition on the morning Saturday morning to kind of get us wake W woken up um for our Retreat and and I
048gave a a prize to the board member that won and also um gave them a little stress ball you know by the way if anybody wants but I mean I they're right here it's it's called it's really a stress Star right so but but no I mean um I know it's the 23rd we're recognizing you towards the end of the month but I appreciate you guys thank you we felt it all thanks for not forgetting about us all right um item number 10 is uh under Personnel Services we have item 10A determination of District need and this is an action item president keer and trustees good evening before you uh is the annual determination of District needs for the 2025 2026 school year for the Lake Tahoe Unified School District the determination of District needs
049is an annual document dealing with the rules governing layoffs um for certificated employees it outlines procedures that school districts must follow when they decide to reduce the the number of Staff key Provisions include criteria for layoffs uh seniority system notice of layoff and rehire rights the determination of District needs resolution ensures that the district follows a structured and Equitable process in managing Staffing reductions while provid providing employees with protections regarding their seniority and potential for rehire uh we have been working closely with our Union Representatives our business office and our superintendent and at this time we are happy to announce we do not intend to lay off employees this year this is an action item and it's a staff's recommendation uh to approve as presented thank you do are there any questions from any of
050the board members all right do I have a motion well let's go to motion motion and then public yeah motion first and then the public comments so do I have a motion I move to approve the uh determination of District need for the was it 2526 or 2425 no 2425 2425 I'll second that all right all in favor hold hold on one sec oh I'm sorry are there any public comments and and and and I want to apologize toid keer obviously first meeting you know navigating through this um so we have a motion made by trusty Heatherton second by um did I have that right yeah motion made by trusty heatherington and second by trusty Mansfield and now um are there any public comments we didn't receive anything from any public input on this I'm
051looking out just in case okay before you move for Action I just I do want to um this is an item that we usually place on the consent agenda um is is we just annually do this we of course work with our our our our association and our our our team um but I wanted to make sure it was on the regular agenda this time number one just to make sure we learn about it also that we did have riffs in the last year we need to do this annually just in case there's there's the need but it truly is Our intention that we're going to do do everything we can to not to go through that process and the intention is to not do that so anyway I just wanted to add that additional
052information um so thank you all right there are no public comment now now I will take the vote all those in favor say I I I all those opposed say nay all right the motion carries sorry item number 10B is an update for the retirement incentive program and this is an information item thank you president kimer and trustees before you this evening is an informational update uh for our retirement incentive program for the 2024 2025 school year for Tahoe Unified School District the Lake Tahoe Unified School District has entered into two agreements with its employee organizations South Taho Educators Association STA and California School Employees Association CA to provide early retirement incentive programs for the 2024 2025 fiscal year uh these opportunities aim to support retirement transitions for eligible staff while preserving future retirement program
053offerings first is our memorandum of understanding between Lake Tahoe Unified School District and sta we've agreed to a one-time sliding scale early retirement incentive under Article 19 for the 2024-25 school year uh key details participants must be Cal's retirement must meet uh caler retirement requirements incentives of $5,000 annually for one to five years based on years of service uh interested particip must sub submit retirement intent letter to the superintendent by February 7th originally that was February 1st I'd like to just note our mou originally said February 1st however Jody DeBry suggested giving staff extra week since February 1st is on a Saturday and that would cut short the time to submit an intent uh to retire so we thank her for that uh next is our memorandum of understanding between ltusd and CSEA we have
054agreed to a golden handshake early retirement incentive for classified employees for the 2024 2025 school year key Provisions include participants must be at least 50 years old participants must have 10 years of service with a district uh employees must notify Human Resources over their intent by March 14th and this is a one-time offer that expires June 30th these agreements underscore ltd's commitment to supporting retirement transitions for both certificated and classified staff while ensuring the continuity of existing contractual benefits and future opportunities these efforts are intended to help uh not lay off employees despite declining enrollment uh this is an informational item only thank you and do you have any questions any questions from the board and I would just like to say this usually isn't an agenda item we also to not necessarily place on
055the agenda right we work with our associations work with the negotiated agreement um in an effort also then to just make sure that everybody's fully aware of how we're processing and moving forward we just had the previous agenda item talking about riffing and we're saying we're not going to do that obviously one of those efforts is to to to help and support our our our staff that are ready to be retired it also then benefits Us in regards to having that ability to not not look at the reduction in force so I just wanted to add that few few comments than thank you all right thank you Dr Cutler thank you Mr Simmons and thank you Jody and bernardet both thank you for working together on this yeah all right item number 11 business services
056and operations we have a number of items under this category starting with the governor's January budget proposal it wasn't on it wasn't thank you there in the it's working now now Teresa good evening president keer and trustees of the board tonight I be I will be reviewing the governor's budget proposal for the 2025 2026 fiscal year and there's our short introduction of everything I will cover trust everyone knows how to read here's the reminder of the timeline of budget events you can see we're currently looking at the yellow area we'll revisit the budget proposal again in May after the governor distributes his May revision the key initiatives for the Governor's budget highlight transitional kindergarten or TK and the increasing funding for the expanded learning Opportunity Grant one adjustment made to this proposal is the cost
057of living adjustment as of last June the projected Cola for the 2526 school year was 2.93% this was adjusted down to 2.43% the primary goal of this plan is to close the opportunity gaps with TK and expanded learning as you can see here $137.1 billion is the total funding for Education across the state $8.5 billion for proposition 2 435 billion no excuse me million uh for expanded learning and funding prop 98 the proposed funding for proposition 98 is at a lower level than the test predict and there's some question if this is constitutional the 2526 school year completes the full expansion of TK to include children who are five by June 2nd to enroll in TK and funding to go along with it this will complete the full expansion of TK and provide additional support
058for low-income families expanded learning opportunity expands to include before and after school and summer school for students in grades TK through six with a focus on the whole child we currently partner with boys and girls club to provide our Afterschool programs and summer enrichment this expansion is again 435 million for the state there is funding to help increase dual enrollment and develop career Pathways for Career Technical education or CTE there's also a proposed additional investment in literacy and math coaching of $500 million there's 150 million proposed for Teacher Recruitment and incentives and 100 million for support of teachers to earn their national board certification specifically for teachers who work in high poverty schools there's 8.5 billion proposed for proposition 2 for K12 facilities specifically 3.5 billion for new construction 4 billion for modernization 600 billion
059ion for CTE and 600 million for Charter Schools unfortunately about 6 billion is likely accounted for by districts who already have approved projects waiting in the queue also priority will be given to small school districts we're not quite small enough and districts with facilities over 75 years old of which we' have none overall this is a positive budget proposal for Education we will be waiting to see if the governor is allowed to fund prop 98 at a lower level than the test predict also we'll wait to see how any of the trailer bills impact the funding in the coming months I'll be back in May to review the May revision this is an information item only are there any questions any questions from the board of truste of Mansfield yeah I have a question on
060your slide that you showed where his money's coming from you talked about prop 98 and I mean prop two and and 98 um okay that one yeah total funding go backward I know I did it um what about Miss DeBerry mentioned prop 28 is there any money coming that's not additional funding that's the ongoing funding okay that makes sense the budget specifically for the 25 26 school year prop 28 was started last year um and then it's ongoing funding that we have several years to spend okay thank you any other questions and I know I heard on the news today and you probably hearing it too that the the prop two money the the bonds a lot of that money May will go to we go to build yeah we'll go to rebuilding schools that
061were lost like five schools that they have to rebuild and some others that are damaged so the so I I guess really the bottom line is there we don't expect to have to leverage funds as part of our bond unfortunately unfortunately yeah yeah the real reality of of that question is is is there if you're not a small small school district certain size and you don't have facilities that are built to pre to 1950 there's a minimal amount of money and actually I know Brian whitmore's in the room and others are that are be going to become more expert in those types of areas as we work with them but there's going to be a minimal dollar for us thank you all right that's it thank you thank you Kelly Martin let's see now we
062have I know you're up here for item 11b which is the uh fiscal year 2324 audit presentation and this is an action item the district is required to part to have an independent audit completed annually here to present tonight's audit from cwdl is Stephen Curry this is an action item for the board and he's joining us via Zoom hi good afternoon everybody can you hear me yes we canar we sure all right so my name is Steven Curry I am a audit partner with cwdl um I'm going to be presenting the results of the June 30th 2024 Financial audit um with that maybe just to start out and thank Kelly and the team um I know the audit is a huge undertaking it takes a lot of time out of their resources I know they
063already have a lot on their plate um so we as Auditors request a lot of information from them and I really just want to thank her and the whole team and everybody at the district for getting us what we needed to do to ultimately complete the audit so with that um on Slide two I'm going to talk about the uh what today's agenda is so we're going to go over the services and deliverables the components of the audited financial statements and then the summary of our Auditor's results on the next slide we have our services and deliverables um so essentially what we're doing as Auditors we're getting the district's financial statements we're conducting an audit and we're issuing three opinions and assessing the district's internal controls so we audit the district's financial statements for the
064year ending June 30 2024 we assess the district's internal controls over financial reporting and compliance we also conduct the audit of the district's compliance with the audit requirements described in the 2324 guide for annual audits of K12 leas essentially what that is is our state state compliance opinion and then lastly we do the audit of the district's compliance with the types of compliance requirements described in the OM uniform guidance and that would be our federal single audit so what I'm going to do is kind of just go over the main portions to the the financial statement so beginning on page one of the financials is our independent auditor report um that's the slide just before this one um so what we did is we were giving our opinion on the financial statements taken as a
065whole um we did Issue an unmodified opinion which as Auditors that's the highest opinion that we can give the district so essentially what we're saying is in our opinion the financial statements referred to above present fairly in all material respects the respective financial position of the government activities fiduciary activities each major fund in the aggregate remaining fund information of the district as of June 30th 2024 after the independent Auditors report we get into the next section which is Management's discussion analysis better known as the mdna so what this is is it's a narrative form that has a very high level comparative financial information comparing fiscal year 24 versus fiscal year 23 and then also providing some uh significant events during the year after that we get into the basic financial statements beginning on page 11
066so we have the Govern wide financial statements which is the statement of net position and the statement of activities and then we get into the the fund financial statements which are the governmental funds balance sheet income statements the balance sheet income statement for the fiduciary funds and then the reconciliation statements and those reconciliations help you go from those government-wide financials into those or from the governmental financials to the government-wide financials after the fund financial statements we get into the remaining financial information um the first one starting on page 20 is the notes to the financial statements um this takes up a big majority of the report so essentially where you have the mdna which is a very high level you get into the basic financial statements which is more detail the notes will give you
067even more detail so they have various um areas in there such as cash um AR AP deferred revenues um even the the debt Capital assets opep and pensions where you can get some more detailed information on those specific accounts after that then we get into the required supplementary information um this includes the budgetary comparison schedule and then this has um some information on uh the OPB and the pensions and then after that we get into the supplementary information on page 65 um which is various schedules that were put together um including schedules of expenditures of federal Awards the schedule of ADA schedule of instructional time and the non- major fund statements and then lastly which we'll go over on this slide in just a second is our other opinions which is the other independent auditor
068report on page 76 and the summary of our auditor results on pages 85 so as you can see right here this is our summary of what we are rendering the opinion on so as you can see we issued an unmodified opinion for both the financial statements the federal Awards and the state awards for fiscal year 2024 we're happy to present that we did not have any findings or question costs we did in the previous year had two State compliance findings which have been cleared up in the current fiscal year so on that next slide I was just going to talk about those two findings from the previous year the first one being the independent study program that was where we're out looking at various independent study contracts and we just had contracts that were out
069of compliance essentially uh worked with the district and the district has since then gotten um all the contracts in compliance and then the next one is the continuation education program when we came out it was just the how the system was set up was the way the minutes are being reported and that has such been remedied and with that that would conclude the fiscal year 2024 audit presentation any questions all right thank you um are do we have any questions from the board the student rep okay all right thank you and um I appreciate all the hard work uh from staff and that and congratulations that we have no no uh things we have to follow up on this year like we did in the past do lean on uh cwdl our audit Partners quite
070a bit for asking for clarification questions they're always so willing to get on a phone call a zoom with us and um support us in any way that we need so they've been great partners with us as well this is an action item and it is staff's recommendation to approve the 2023 2024 final audit all right um see no questions do I have a motion I'll move to approve the 2324 for audit presentation I have a second a second okay I have a motion by trusty Heatherton and a second by truste Anderson do we have any public comment we didn't receive any public comment looking out all those in favor say I I I all those opposed say name all right motion carries thank you thank you Bard I I just want to compliment uh
071Stephen and his team and how they worked effectively with us just as as Kelly stated I also wanted to just reiterate something Kelly said one of the the key aspect of making sure you have a clean audit is making sure that you're really clear with your Auditors you know that we are doing everything that the the right way and I want to compliment Kelly and team for making certain of that thank you very much thank you thank you Stephen all right thank you Stephen and Kelly all right item 11 C is the bond sale resolution 2024 uh sl25 d07 and it's an action item part of the process for measure you uh the bond that passed in November is for the board to pass a resolution to sell the first round of bonds tonight we
072have merth Johnson an attorney with danis woliver Kelly or dwk joining us to explain this process and procedure and she's on so it's on mered if you there I am here good evening we got you very good okay president keer members of the board I'm gonna try to hide my excitement at this item as I know this has been a long time coming and we did it we are here um this resol resolution is the formal step that is necessary to gain your approval to issue the first series of bonds from measure U um you may have noticed that the resolution authorizes up to $35 million in bonds that's because we don't issue the whole authorization at once we issue it in Parts based on Project need there are no limitations on when you issue
073other than the tax rate limitation so once you have you're into that 35 million you might need more you can always come back and ask for more this is this is there aren't any time constraints on there you may have noticed the resolution is pretty long um if you had a chance to read through the whole thing or if you had a chance to skim through it I'm just going to touch the Highlight so that you um know what you're approving so there's a long section about the relationship with the county because as you know the county will be the one that uh collects the property taxes that are uh used to repay the bond so there's a request to elado County to do that in there the county will also hold the funds related
074to the bond so when those property taxes are collected um the alerado county will establish something called The Debt Service fund and put those tax collections in that fund the monies the proceeds of the sale of the bonds which is the monies that you will use for your projects will be deposited in the building fund held by the county so it's separate and apart from your general fund that the two don't get mixed so there's a request to the county to establish the building fund in there there are also three very important documents related to selling the bonds that the resolution will approve and you may have noticed that there were some additional documents attached to the agenda and they're in draft form because we can't finalize those documents until we have your authorization to
075do so so the two documents that you saw were the preliminary official statement that's the marketing document that gets handed to potential investors who might want to invest in LT usd's bonds and it has information about the repay payment of the bonds about property taxes and tax collections within the district it also has a lot of information about the district itself your audit will be attached as an exhibit um it goes into how school districts are funded generally in California and that's because investors oftentimes just want to know something about the issuer who's issuing the bonds they might invest in um the other document that was attach to the agenda is the bond purchase agreement that's the agreement that you're going to enter into with da Davis the district's underwriter to actually sell the bonds
076so that da Davidson can go out and resell them to those investors who read that POS so we'll fill in all of the principal amounts maturity dates um interest rates once we get to the day of sale um for the bonds they the uh resolution also talks about the tax exemption on the bonds as you know investors get to um not pay income tax on the interest that they earn on your bonds which is kind of a perk that that incentivizes investors to invest in uh bonds of school districts and then there are some general parameters for the bonds the most important one of which is that we're selling about $35 million in bonds um I'm happy to answer any questions if you had anyone you had a chance to take a look at uh
077do I have any questions for Meredith tonight all right and I just have one question Meredith because I've been asked it by by some of the voters when we were you know trying to pass the bond two years ago as well um do we ever consider interest rates in like pausing the sale like waiting for something to happen if we knew interest rates were coming down or or up or whatever just looking at how does that factor in when we're um selling bonds yeah absolutely um I'm not your financial expert I do the legal side of things but I having done sold lots of bonds I am familiar with how we work in the financial markets and how interest rate sensitive we can be and we actually we have a date targeted for when we're
078going to sell your bonds but of course if there were something to happen in the world that might impact interest rates or if you're the financial people on the team knew that there's going to be a preferable date to sell bonds they would buy all means pause and the way this works is that you're approving this resolution so that Dr Cutler and staff have the ability to move forward but they will not move forward unless we're in the absolute best conditions and we don't we know that there isn't going to be something more favorable coming up in the future so by all means there there's no we're not pressing play without the ability to press pause as well yeah let me let me add because I've been through this before and that's something as we
079get closer we working with our financial uh advisers da Davidson who will actually go about the the the sell of the bonds um they're in close contact with me they when we've done this in the past in my previous District um and making a determination of yep we we've got what we think is the absolute best we can do um and we feel like this is a good place or hey we may need to wait another day or maybe we need to pause um and and uh you know it's it's never a perfect situation right when you think about rates and things but um that's something that I know that we've kept in mind and looked at as we've moved forward with the cell all right thank you as Mia Valenzuela said earlier change is
080possible as we know I mean we're living with a lot of change so yeah we don't we don't know at this point where we might be you know when you're ready that also and merid pointed out mean we're thinking 35 million you know there that could be that could be a slide scale one way or the other too if we think oh my gosh we got a real incredible rate is it do we have the ability to go for a little more right now with Incredible rate or do we have to stay at that rate that number it's why it's it's an approximate component is that correct Meredith we could go down we would need board authorization to go higher okay thank you that's good to know okay thank you appreciate it all right um
081do I have a motion I can I interject there's nothing I need to read you sure this is an action item District staff recommends adoption of resolution number 2024 25-7 titled resolution of the Board of Education of the Lake Tahoe Unified School District authorizing the issuance and sale of not to exceed $35 million aggregate principal amount of General obligation bonds by a negoti iated sale pursuant to a bond purchase agreement prescribing the terms of sale approving the form of and authorizing the execution and delivery of a bond purchase agreement and a continuing disclosure agreement approving the form of and authorizing the distribution of an official statement for the bonds and authorizing the execution of necessary documents and certificates and related actions that is a very lengthy resolution title so hearing that fabulous resolution title do
082we have a motion um I make the motion to ex approve the bond sale res resolution 24 25-7 all right and second second all right I have a motion by truste Mansfield and a second by trusty kamacho uh is there any public comment I didn't receive any we have no public comment all right um hearing none any last comments no okay all those in favor say I I I all those opposed say n um I said I and the motion carries thank you okay item number 11 D Bond oversight committee roles and responsibilities this is an information item with passing measure U the district is required to assemble a bond oversight committee to review and Report expenditures to the community mer Johnson is again here to share more information about the bond oversight committee process
083great thank you so we can go to slide one so you may recall or maybe not prior to 2001 when a school district passed a bond measure it needed 2third of the voters voting on The Measure to pass it I think the state legislature looked around and said we have a lot of school facilities that are in dire need of improvements and passing bonds is just too hard let let's try and make it easier for school districts so prop 39 was added to the ballot as a constitutional amendment that changed that threshold from 2third to 55% which is a significantly easier threshold but in exchange for lowering the threshold to pass a bond measure there were certain accountability measures that were added one of which is that the voters have to be given a specific
084list of projects on which the bond proceeds will be spent before they vote Yes or no so they're allowed to see how precisely how the money is going to be spent so in order to make sure that districts actually comply with the project list and they spend the monies the way they told voters they would a Citizens oversight committee is now required so that's the reason why we have citizens oversight committees next slide so the their job is to tell the community and to kind of be the loudspeaker for the community in about how the proceeds are being spent they get to receive information from a school district after the money has already been spent after the proceeds have been spent about how it was spent and then report that back out to the community
085and really issuing a report on an annual basis is the only real requirement of the committee that's the only activity that they're required to undertake next slide um so the kinds of things that an oversight commit committee typically does um when you have Bond proceeds on hand in the building fund there are two additional audits that are required of the district there's a financial audit and a performance audit both of the bond fund and usually those audits are provided not only to the board and to the community but they're also provided to the oversight committee so they can review them and kind of um assure themselves that they're finding as to how the expenditures were made or in align with how those what those audits look like um at their meetings typically the um agenda
086is mostly receiving expenditure information from you and reviewing it and then comparing it to the project list because that's that's the um that's the charge they have that's what they're supposed to be doing um sometimes it's a good idea also to let take the oversight committee out to a project and let them actually look around to see how the project is progressing it's kind of a fun way to give the oversight committee some um tie into the projects and so they're not just looking at spreadsheets next slide so although the committee is independent and although they will elect their own chair and really run their own meetings the district has the onus of supporting them technically and logistically so there is a requirement that the district provide a website for the oversight committee typically it's
087just a link from your own website to their to their information the oversight committee is also a brown act committee and often times the oversight committee members are not familiar with the brown act so it would be up to you to help them with that those brown brown excuse me Brown act procedures such as posting an agenda 72 hours prior to the meeting um and sometimes even creating the agenda for them making sure there's a space for public comments on the agenda um and then of course someone from the district needs to be the one to compile that expenditure information and share it with them so they have data to use to do their job to make sure that the the bond proceeds are in fact being spent um for projects on the project list
088um you'll be submitting those audits that I mentioned to them and then if there are any they have any findings responding to those findings within three months next slide so there are certain statutory requirements for the members on the committee there's a minimum re re ired seven members two at large anybody who wants to serve and then there are five prescribed representatives of the community that need to be on the committee so someone who's active in a senior citizens organization someone who represents a taxpayers Association someone who represents the local business community and then a PTA member or like a School site Council type member and then just a parent of someone who was enrolled in the district so really there's there's two parents one of which is parent and one of which is someone
089who's active in a in a PTA or um parent teacher Association type committee terms need to be at least two years and the members can't serve more than three consecutive terms Meredith before we go on to the next slide I just wanted to take a moment here because we had an application process for our bond oversight committee which closed last Friday we received eight applicants um and we've worked with Meredith um regarding making certain that we had all of the categories that could match up and we've been able to do so we and and we had but one of the eight was actually determined that it was a conflict for that person to serve so we ended up having seven which is perfect and um and those names of those committee members uh will be
090coming forward for you to approve to be the bond oversight committee and then we'll have our first meeting we're tentatively scheduled for our first meeting um February 28th it is tentative where we'll actually ask Meredith to come up and train and and get them started in a positive way I do want to say that um as I've worked with Meredith in regards to the Dynamics of this that these are the requirements of it and no no staff member of the district um or anybody that has a connection really to the district can serve but um I have wanted to make sure that our associations felt part of it and so that we will ask and send an invitation to every single one it's a public meeting everybody's welcome but encourage um uh the STA president
091Jody debery um as well as csca president bernardette Santana to be engaged and involved with those as well so just want to make sure it's as public and and engaging as possible but these are the seven and we're excited to tell you that we'll be bringing them forward to you next meeting thank you Meredith yeah I mean Dr Cutler has worked very hard on this and we've been in close communication often um it's not often that a school district actually fills all five of these slots there are lots of school districts out there that have an empty membership because there just isn't someone in the community who's willing to serve so the fact that your community is willing to step up and that you have found people for all five slots is really tremendous it's
092really great um the next's go to the next slide which is going to hit on something that Dr Cutler mentioned which is the conflicts of interest and this is important and it h and I can't tell you how many times I go to an oversight committee meeting and I someone has to leave or someone has to be excused from the committee because it turns out that they're conflict so the Education Code actually says that an employee a vendor or a contractor of the district cannot serve on the committee this isn't just for conflicts principles in general this is this is um explicit in the Ed code um and employees of a vendor or employees of a contractor all of those folks are not allow to serve on the committee and really the reason behind this
093is that we don't want anyone to have any kind of financial stake when they listen to you talk about expenditures you want to make sure that the community has objective independent people to hear the information you're providing them and and analyze unob objectively um and it's important that probably immediate family member should also be independent so it's unfortunate when we find people who are willing to serve who we know will do a good job but they just fall Within These categories we unfortunately have to excuse them from membership of committee next slide um so appointment to the committee there is no legal um guidelines for this it's any way that um that works best for your community members can be appointed they can use an you can use an application they can be solicited directly
094um and if you would like to it's possible to adopt your board policy I know there is a 7214 I'm not sure if you have adopted or not yet that establishes some guidelines for the committee it's pretty statuto based so most of the rules are right there in the Ed code um so it's not necessary but it sometimes uh districts like to do that we can talk about that later so so we'll R we'll review that and in the absence of that as as as you just C discovered it us us having applications and having the board select matches up with the requirements yeah good next slide think that's it any questions on the oversight committee so then also mentioned board members are welcome to attend but it's a brown act committee so only two
095only two okay thank you for that clarification Meredith um so yeah it'll be a publicly yeah we would be attending as members of the public basically right if a board member went to a um Citi yes that stated it is it is District business so that's why she's pointing out that you wouldn't want to have yeah you can only have up to to up to two in the room yeah okay um any other questions from board members okay this is an information item only we'll bring back the committee for Action at a future meeting thank you Meredith thank you so much thank you Meredith my pleasure all right good evening thank you item 11e we're going to move on to the bond architect Master contract this is an action item after passing measure U the
096district moved quickly to post a re or request for qualifications for an architect for the bond the RFQ was issued on November 20th 2024 with responses due by December 11th we received eight proposals for architecture Services Dr Cutler facilitated the process and the proposal committee narrowed the selection to three for interviews we interviewed the three finalists and the interview committee narrowed the choice to one Studio W architecture Reed Shannon from dwk assisted in the develop development of the RFQ documentation as well as the contract negotiations on behalf of the district Reed Shannon is available to answer any questions you have may have and review the process Reed thank you for being here thank you so Reed would you do are you prepared to just share with the board anything about the process and the negotiations
097for the contract yeah absolutely um good evening everyone um as noted my name is re Shannon I work with Meredith Johnson at danis Waller Kelly um and have been assisting in the procurement of your architect for measure you Bond program projects just for context this procurement is governed by government code section 4525 that means that the district must use a competitive selection process that allows for selection on the basis of demonstrated competence uh and professional qualifications necessary for satisfactory performance of the services required meaning uh this is not a bid contract or a bid process which is why an RFQ request for qualifications was used um I worked with um inter term CBO Kelly buttery and we reviewed and revised the RFQ for the architectural services we dwk prepared the form of agreement which was
098published along with that RFQ um during the scoring process we assisted in providing sample scoring Matrix and Sample interview questions and then once District staff had scored those proposals um we finalized the form of agreement which is a form of Master agreement for architectural services with Studio W um under the master agreement uh the agreement can be supplemented for individual projects on an as-needed basis there was some U minor negotiation based on suggested changes by Studio W in their proposal response those are fairly standard um and then finally I'll note that the fee that is noted in the master agreement is calculated on a gradual uated percentage basis which essentially means that there's a percentage of uh the construction cost budget that is used to calculate the fee and there's different rates for construction or
099modernization and that's a fairly standard approach as well for architectural projects thank you Reed are there any questions for Reed regarding the process and or his negotiations okay no questions and um on one side go ahead we also have Brian Whitmore from Studio W and his team would you like to up and introduce your team well good evening members of the board superintendent cabinet Brian Whitmore Studio W aritex obviously very excited to be here uh this evening um also have our team members which I'll introduce very quickly to my far left is Brie Gargano our client leader and senior project architect we have Melissa spec who is our uh senior project architect and then uh Jason masty who is our construction administrator uh this was the team that we proposed for your projects and so
100um these will be the team members that will stay with you all the way through uh we're also part of the interview process um of course part of our excitement is because we're of course very excited that you passed your bond um and given the uh the very uh regimented and fierce competition that we had to go up against of course of course we're very pleased to be here tonight one of the things I will mention is I appreciate the fact that you're moving forward swiftly um because we talk about cost and other sorts of things with all of the bonds that have been passed and proposition two along with um some of the other issues that we're seeing across the state with fires and things like that we anticipate construction costs will probably start
101to Boom again so the sooner of course that you can uh get to implementing your projects as a result of your bond sales I think the more value you're going to see so we're very excited to get started started um and very glad that we're here literally almost two months after you passed your bond so thank you all right thank you Brian board members any questions for uh Brian Whitmore any questions I all right and one last thing here we go this is an action item and it's staff's recommendation to approve the bond architect m b Bond architect Master contract thank you all right do I have a motion I move that we approve appr the bond architect Master contract second all right I have a motion by trusty Mansfield and a second by trusty
102Anderson um before I ask for the vote any other any other comments I just want to uh I want to make a comment that I just appreciate it I sat on the um the panel so I know that um Reed Shephard thank you for talking about the process and um we didn't just include staff we included uh there was a board member I was a board member who served on the panel that reviewed the actual proposals and then trusty Heatherton um served on the interview panel and in addition to that and I really just want to applaud the The District staff for inviting um a woman from the city of South Lake Tahoe who has a lot of experience in construction construction management and uh she served um on that panel an actual architect she's
103an actual architect thank you because I was like she an engineer and architect I couldn't remember because she's with the she's a new uh it's a new role for the city to to have an architect on their staff because I know a lot of the Public Works Engineers there so anyway she was very um valuable it was a great asset uh to the um review process I really appreciated that um we included her and um I'm happy to have been part of the process too so um thank you and um vote we're gonna take a vote all right all those in favors public comment I don't believe there's any public comment this evening thank you NOP there you go and uh I got to keep all these things in the right order um all those
104in favor say I I and all those opposed say nay all right motion passes and thank you welcome aboard thank you exactly excited I am excited that we're getting we're we're keeping the momentum rolling so just to note that uh Brian Whitmore stated um I've talked to several that that are that are like you guys are really getting out there and going and I said yeah because we we want to get moving we want to get processing and and it is money and it's also time right the faster we get going get into DSA with our plans which takes a long time so yeah so thank you thank you all right um item 11f is Energy savings sustainability projects it's an information item in January 2021 the board passed a resolution with a focus on
105sustainability sustainability and Energy savings I've attached the resolution to the agenda if you'd like to review it at a later time with the passage of the bond the district sees an opport to refocus on these types of project to help further our advancement advancement to establish goals for Energy Efficiency clean energy and carbon neutrality Brett Gallagher from verie is here to present ideas for the possible energy saving projects good evening Brett is this m clicker okay all right uh well president keer uh um Trustees of the board uh Dr Cutler uh Mr Zebo uh Miss buttery where there you are uh thank you for having me thank you for inviting us out uh to present to you tonight I brought a couple of my colleagues uh Ben Matson uh who's on our California Partnerships team
106and uh prod bagary who's one of our developers and engineers and they're here to correct me if I say anything wrong so we'll start there um so I'm going to start with our what we call our playfully our our ego slide just to tell you a little bit about who we are uh ver is the largest tk12 Energy Solutions company in America we've done a lot of work across the country that being said we're still pretty Nimble and we we're still pretty responsive to uh the needs of small school districts uh in fact one of our big Partnerships here in California is with the small school districts Association uh as you can see by the map we've done a lot of work across California um and in that time we've we've learned a lot about
107uh the needs of California schools um and and everything that goes along with that oh excuse me so one of the uh the biggest values of working with ver is our long-term energy planning um sorry I'm going to stop touching that um we're we're here to partner with the district long term obviously you've just passed a bond and there are some very specific projects and work that needs to be done um when we work with a district we tend to it is on autoplay so we'll we'll get to where we need to Tod would M that's okay um uh we're here for the long term so not only did help you to help you achieve the goals that are that are in your bond and in your lcap and in your resolution number 18 but
108also those needs and goals that you may not be familiar with may not even know about right now in energy uh the regulations are constantly changing the Technologies are constantly changing and so as an energy partner we're here to be that energy Champion that person you can lean on um to look at things through a lens of of the energy world uh and so that's a big part of what verie does so we're here this is moving on its own um so I also want to thank Dave Zebo and his team for walking with me and pra uh We've walked every single one of your sites we've taken pictures uh we've talked to your facilities folks including Mr Zebo um talked with Kelly for a little while we've obviously been talking with Dr Cutler and
109we feel like we have a good understanding of of the needs of the district after obviously looking at your bond and everything else this what we're talking about tonight is very preliminary and so this is mostly informative um but one of the things that we noticed when we first got here is it's really cold now I knew that I knew that but my partner prod is from Southern California um I live right down the hill I'm right out of Camino so uh we're neighbors and frankly being here is really exciting I've been coming to Tahoe my whole life um so one of the things that we do first when we start to diagnose a building or a district is just like when you go to the doctor we need to do the blood work and
110the blood work is in your utility bills so we've taken a very cursory look at your utility bill so far but we've been bugging uh Sierra in the district office for the past two days getting a lot more information and anticipation of moving forward in a bit more depth but from a from a very um uh BAS basic perspective these are the numbers you spend about $3.5 million a year in total utility um your your total students about 3700 kiddos and your total square footage is about 750,000 40,000 excuse me where that puts you is $457 per student the average for districts similar to yours in similar climates is about 200 to220 so you're about 2x there utility cost per square foot is 482 and again when compared to districts similar to yours and similar
111climates it's about a dollar to a125 one of our big goals is to get you closer to that average um and just save you money is step one uh but there's a lot of other things to do in the meantime in terms of uh hitting climate goals and and uh decarbonization goals and all of those things uh this is a bit more depth this is what we call a heat map you can see the red areas are a little worse off the green areas are doing pretty good um but there's you know there's several culprits to where these costs are going uh and before I go any further I just want to compliment the district on what you're doing right now these numbers are simply a function of the age of the buildings the equipment
112other things but the people uh running the district and the people doing the work every day are doing a really impressive and commendable job so thank you for that um one of our first observations here I'm going to skip through that we're going to go to lighting to start off this is and we're going to go pretty quick because I know I only have a few more minutes um um lighting is is one of the lwh hanging fruit interior and exterior lighting um Sports lighting um we can get a lot more efficient in those lighting um uh fixtures uh interior lighting there's a lot of cool things we can do we work with a lot of districts who do tunable lighting uh dimable lighting you know kids come in they're hot they're sweaty it's been
113lunchtime you dim the lights you settle them down uh it's 2:00 they're getting a little sleepy you raise the lights you wake them up uh all sorts of special ed education applications and lighting as well um I'm going to find my spot again controls controls is another place um where where we could really help out um right now there's there's really no Central controls to turn things off globally schools shut down for the day it's a holiday it's an emergency for whatever reason school is closed scheduled uh closures we want to turn everything off and right now everything is on and that's contributing to a lot of the costs um no it's not going water efficiency upgrades uh lot of irrigation the uh Tahoe uses a lot of water from what we've seen so far
114probably a lot of reasons for that you have boilers that could be one big reason outside irrigation is another regular fixtures toilets faucets those sorts of things could be another reason uh taking the time to dig in a little bit deeper um is a big part of how we're going to you know find out what these are uh or what the the best path path forward is speaking of your boilers um there's no Cooling in in any of your buildings and as we know it's getting warmer um I think I read one of your documents where the average temperature in Winter was about 28 degrees a few years back and now it's about 32 so we know it's getting warmer how we cool those buildings whether we keep boilers whether we move to you know
115Central HVAC those are all questions that we can help to answer but we answer together all of this thing all of these things are in collaboration with the district with the board with the bond commit we want to be a part of that team we don't have any of those answers yet and we need to do a little bit more investigation before we get those answers and and and can help give any guidance on that uh but it's a big opportunity frankly and then finally solar people go solar and Tahoe yep solar in Taho uh we've done solar in Colorado we've done it in npen we've done it in Durango um but it is possible to do solar and it could be a really hugely impactful piece of the puzzle um reducing energy uh usage
116by 60 to 70% um which it just gives you all sorts of flexibility to do all sorts of other cool things with your buildings um essentially oh now I don't know where I am well give me one second timeline for this project this is a typical timeline this is not a Dr Cutler timeline which is accelerated as we've seen um but we have we've already uh spent the past couple of months doing these initial assessments and audits uh typically The Next Step would be something called an investment grade audit it where we're just getting a little bit deeper uh well quite a bit deeper frankly and and getting some some real hard numbers uh moving you can you can read the slide but this is a general typical um uh timeline we're here to be
117flexible we're here to work within the team uh whatever uh the folks at Studio W the rest of the bond team members feel is appropriate you know we're here to to be a good teammate um for the for the district and for the team um and then last but not least I just want to express really our sincere gratitude for being here uh we're really excited about the possibilities um we think we can help you achieve a lot of the goals again around your lcap around your bond and around your resolution 18 uh and we think we can save you a lot of money um and have a lot of fun doing it so thank you so much um I should ask anything to add okay and and by the way this is from your
118website I absolutely I don't know whose quote that is but I absolutely love it so I wanted to it so thank you excellent hey by the way I'm not sure if that was why this was happening but it was just going on its own and so you know that was first time ever seen that yeah sorry questions members of the board yeah Brett real quick um when you talk about um our comparison to you know say similar districts and everything is there um is that taking into consideration like or is there parity between the energy sources the energy companies or our rates particularly higher than other areas is that contributing to our 2 X yeah I think when they're when they're doing benchmarking there's all sorts of considerations to take into take into account um
119climate being one of them local utilities and the rates they charge being another being in California being another so yeah there's there's a lot there but generally all things being equal the usage is still significantly High yeah for sure oh no great question thank you Brett on the on your slides I I noticed a discrepancy and I and just because I we've got Studio W in the room as well I just want to make sure we have our fact straight because um on that chart that shows the $457 per student per you know per year per student uh um the math seems to be it's there's like we spend three and a half million per year on utility costs and we have 3600 students that's more like $979 I'm I'm not doing the math in
120my head but I'm just saying it's more like twice the 450 per student and on your next slide that's the number that's on that more detailed chart that's very hard to see on the screen right so I just wanted to understand the yeah that chart shows the 957 per student okay come on to the mic come to the mic please thank and just for if we're not if we're not twice we might be four times as high or whatever but I want uh I guess discrepancy is that your water data is sort of skewing the data set uh there's a lot more water consumption uh in in terms of you know dollar or gallon per student um so if you look at the math in the kpi heat map uh the math adds up uh
121but um on the the other summary slide we just took uh sort of the weighted average of only the electric gas and wouldn't really show the water data there but uh you are right it's around the 900 markk okay thank you appreciate that well trusty keer asked me the other day and when I was looking at it I was like all right we're just gonna have to see what you said today so yeah thank you any other questions um so I want the board um to know in your in the planning of how we move forward um we've been working we we had had a resolution was called out tonight a matter of fact I told Kelly just put it on the agenda so that people can go back and and look at that resolution
122so it's there for you that resolution and we've been want wanting to work on this energy and sustainability um yet there hadn't been dollars and if we go back to our facilities Masters plan there are components of the Energy savings Energy Efficiency and I appreciate that Brett called out Studio W in my excuse me in my thinking of all of this is it's all part of a plan right and we are building a team we have our architect we're we've got and another genda item item coming up building getting a project program manager we have our energy sustainability partner um and then of course we'll eventually have a construction team this team will work together to implement what what's really in our in our B in our facility master plan along with the board's resolution
123and in government code 4217 and read you're still on here if I don't say this right you can always straighten me out was very clear that you know when we work with an energy company the Energy company has to show that the projects they do save us money so I think it's a really important imperative component to to the whole project right because we have for example lighting and windows and and and heating and air systems in the in the facility master plan um but we also want to make sure that we're also showing that when we do that we're going to save the district money and and that's a requirement when we when we engage and work with a company like vary so I just wanted to give the board and Community just that
124thinking re did I hit that 4217 right uh Dr Cutler that's correct government code section 4217 I just wanted to calling you thank you thank you all right thank you and I and I recognize that the what I really appreciate that we're moving forward on sustainability and saving um just uh our carbon footprint you know reducing carbon emissions and I I'll say that the water even though we pay high water bills part of that is the cost of water in this town is related to the electricity cost of pumping the water around so if we can find ways to reduce our water use um we have the added benefit of you know further reducing our our responsibility in terms of carbon emissions related to electricity because that's most of the water costs so agre and
125then we save money all right thank you next item is item 11g project program management request for proposal continuing to move forward with the bond the district posted an request for proposals or RFP for project program management on January 15th all proposals are due by 400 p.m. on January 31st and we plan to review the proposals by February 7th and hold interviews the week of February 10th it is staff's plan to bring the recommended firm to the board for approval at the March meeting no okay e on I've been speaking without mic oh Reed I've been speaking without the mic and so I just talking all about you holy moly that's a that's a foa on my part I never turn my mic off um hey so Reed I just did share with the board
126that we've been working with you on the development of our project program management RFP RFQ and just wanted to give you an opportunity to give highlights of what youve pulled together for us um and any additional information yeah well I I didn't hear what was said I don't want to repeat too much just in case um so I think the two high points I would note is this is a procurement process similar to the process that you went through for the architect it is also government by government code section 4525 so it's qualifications based selection not a bid and in putting together the documents uh we worked with Kelly in the focus was was primarily on the project and program management side as opposed to the construction Administration or con our construction management side um
127so we adjusted the scope of services based on the district's Focus all right thank you so that again tonight this is just information we wanted to make sure we brought it to you um as ke as Kelly outlined the process um we will be asking and scheduling board members to be part of both the review of the submission as well as the uh inter interview um we will then once again whoever we select ask uh Reed to negotiate an agreement and hopefully bring that to you on the March 13th board meeting so it's only information and if there's any additional questions we'd love to answer them any questions all right moving on thank you and any volunteer I guess Dr Cutler will reach out to all of us if they want to if you want
128to participate on the uh review process yeah okay item 12a facilities and transportation and item 12a is Bond construction delivery method options yeah information items good evening Madame President members of the board I'd like to formally introduce myself to the newly appointed board members my name is Dave Zebo I'm the facilities and transportation director I'm happy to be here this evening to talk about some construction delivery methods and options we have moving forward with some upcoming projects pertaining to our bond we will go over both the traditional delivery method as well as some alternative delivery methods and help identify the one that may pose least complications or risks for our district I do have Brian Whitmore with here with us this evening to assist and share his expertise on each of these delivery methods as
129well as the pros and cons to them so at that time I welcome Brian to the podium thanks Bri thank you D um I wanted to talk a little bit you know preemptive manner about um some of the options that you have available when it comes to construction delivery um we work with a variety of districts obviously across the state in various locations um and have an opportunity to work with all of these different types of delivery methods and so we wanted to kind of just bring forward what we see in terms of U what some of your districts are doing um like yours um throughout the state let's see does this there we go um so generally speaking most people are familiar um at least under public contract code of what we consider the
130traditional delivery method cons um being identified as design bid build um so design bid build is exactly what it says architect designs the facility project goes out to bid lowest responsible bidder is typically selected in that process and then um that bidder construction um Team then builds the project um and you can see here the under 2500 um student population there's no requirement um to pre-qualify for districts over 2 200 students there are requirements associated with pre-qualifying uh prior to bid some of the alternative delivery methods that exist um that we see often really is lease lease back which I'll describe at a moment CM at risk or CM multiprime CM stands for construction manager also design build um really it's all about risk um and trying to manage your risk as you go through
131the process of constructing your facilities and so we'll talk talk a little bit about what we think maybe some of the pros and cons are associated with each so traditional design bid build again as I mentioned before architect designs the project contractors bid um the project lowest responsible bidder is selected and um that is the individual that builds the project the pros is of course it's very competitive it explicitly meets public contract code requirements um but some of the cons are there's really no familiarity with the design prior to the bid um when the bids are advertised that's when the contractors begin to become familiar with the project and of course uh respond with their um bid results um so it's not really a team atmosphere we're not building a team here from the get-go
132um often say it's a little bit like a arranged marriage typically in a marriage you want to date that person get to know them for a while before you walk down the aisle and certainly um we we want that from our Contracting Partners when we go through the process a building um so sometimes it has a tendency to breed change orders and we we often use this funny little slide it's a little bit pixelated but there's a yacht there and there's a little dingy and the dinghy is named the original contract and the yacht is named the change order and the joke is that you know contractors I know there's some contractors here today so I don't want to speak too poorly but um of course the idea is that you know we want to
133avoid the big change order potential that comes on later because the idea is when you're bidding a project you want to be competitive you want to make sure you bid to the plans there's any ambiguity you're not going to identify that that's going to come out and result in the change order later so whatever that price is come bid day is often times not the actual price when we're completed and so it's a bit of a guessing game you know potentially how much did they actually include we want to make sure it's responsible uh but of course we we don't really have a good sense until um you know some of the some of the negotiations ensue um lease lease back is an alternative um this is really where the contractor is selected based on
134qualifications um and it's part of the um architect owner and Builder team typically through what we call pre-construction contract of some kind um so they would be brought on as a team member early on in the process um typically um doing cost estimation constructibility review other kinds of things reviewing the design as the design is progressing um before it goes into the department of the state architect before uh it gets approved it was originally developed through the Ed code I think it was 17406 it was a financing mechanism um a bit of a loophole in the Ed code there for a while where essentially um the contractor leases the area of the site or the facility or whatever it might be back to the school district for the cost of construction um and so you
135have lease payments or total base rent um rent payments if you will rather than traditional construction payments like you you'd pay a contractor um the pros as you can see here team member from the onset it's a true partnership it establishes what we consider a guaranteed maximum price or sometimes referred to as total based rent so that's a ceiling often times we build in enough contingency um there are other unknowns that are identified early on in the process so that again if there are any change orders that occur they generally come out of that contingency contractor doesn't necessarily have to come back to the board and ask for more money later we really try to identify that as a as a true guaranteed maximum price um it's it's really good for complex modernization projects with
136unforeseen conditions sometimes in that preconstruction element contractors will go out and actually investigate do some destructive testing really try to understand what's going on there um reduce risk better value um time cost quity all of those things generally pretty positive one of the cons that arose however was a number of years ago we saw legal challenges associated with this primarily from contractors that couldn't compete on the qualification side um low bid contractors that would come in and say wait a minute this was a financing mechanism this shouldn't be a construction delivery method um and so the Davis versus Fresno um um um piece came out number of years later I think it was in 2017 we saw some regulation associated with that um we saw districts actually go away from lease lease back for a
137while and then after the legislation came through and sort of normalized things we saw most if not all of our districts come back and utilize this as kind of their preferred method um CM multi-risk excuse me cement risk multiprime CM um contractors is also selected based on qualifications manages the owner risk through multiple prime contracts again team member from the onset um sometimes perceived not as competitive um more cost upfront the same can really be established for lease leasee back and sometimes you see a higher cost up front but again that includes contingencies and other things that we expect to sort of work with so it's more of a known quantity the price generally maybe not as attractive for smaller scale projects because of um High complexity of actually implementing this and generally used on
138projects exceeding 10 million that's kind of what we've seen think of it more as um when you're building a pool if you're a general contractor and you hire out your own multiple primes um that's kind of what this is um and that's sort of a generalization but we don't see a lot in K12 um I haven't seen it in years personally but it is something that that um does come up design build um design build is where the contractor carries the prime contract and hires a team of architect and Engineers to complete the work beneath them um we are seeing more design build projects get delivered in K12 um we see a lot of them at the higher ed level um it it's um essentially a competition um sometimes called stipulated sum some times we
139refer to as Progressive design build where it's more focused on qualifications um but nevertheless you as the district would have to put some sort of criteria documents out first to identify what the scope of the project is at a very um um sort of high level and then hire in uh a team have a competition much like your your RFQ but more of an RFP where you would have a team come in and compete it would be a contractor and architect team together um we do see this on large scale projects like um sax City Unified for example is is utilizing design build for the purposes of replacing some of their entire campuses so it makes sense on that large scale to have the whole team day one contractor architect uh move forward um I
140think in your particular case because of the type of projects that you have this can be very complex may make sense that one one or two might go a design build route um the architect that that participates in the criteria the bridging documents cannot then compete later on in terms of the architect as part of the the uh design build team because of conflict potential there um so keep that in mind in terms of you know the team members that you might use if you consider this as an alternative in the future um but I would say generally speaking based on the type of projects that you have the things that you're considering really obviously the traditional delivery method designed bid build still makes sense and maybe on some smaller projects where you think hey
141we want to get this out quickly and move forward great um there is risk involved in that obviously um but I would say generally speaking you can manage some of that risk by um hopefully having a very tight set of drawings and um you know very clear methodology in terms of how you're going to go about that I think from an alternative delivery standpoint the CM doesn't make as much sense um design build unless you want to get started with that on certain projects um you'd really have to identify the scope clearly first to try to get that design build team on board you know part part of the process if we're going to start underway is really trying to Define scope on a lot of these projects and understand what it is that you
142want to implement so that's where I think lease leaseback makes a lot of sense um and again that's that's assuming you you consider sort of the new terms as a result of that January 1 2017 legislation um there are things that you have to follow through that process one of the things I will say um with least least back is there is a requirement for skilled and trained Workforce um so a certain percentage of the subcontractors have to meet that skilled and trained Workforce uh component um and that's been a bit of a sliding scale that's been increased over time I forget the percentage that it's at now um but that is something that that needs to be considered um as well as you know the the the regularized payments um all of the sorts
143of things that go along with that process um so it's very important that the district follow that U moving forward um again as you consider hiring your program management team they're going to have a lot of experience in this sort of thing and can certainly administer those kinds of contracts I I know dwk for example administers a lot of lease leaseback rfqs uh contracts things of that nature so of course they have a lot of experience in that as well so I think that's it and of course we do have our um folks from dwk still on if there's any questions specific with our attorneys um were you finished I'm sorry yeah I I forgot that the slide was on there I apologize I can add one more really kind of the next steps um
144working with your your legal team your legal counsel um adopting if if you want to consider least leas act let's say for example uh board policy um and then um going through the process of then you know pre-qualifying General Contractors through that selection process at RFQ um and then issuing you know your RFP to select that Contracting group um sometimes we see a combined RF RFQ RFP I don't know um dwk can jump in say how they they be like to handle this sort of thing but generally this is kind of how we see things going um in the context of everything that's been discussed tonight I think the idea is having your design Partners on board having your program management partner on board and potentially having your Contracting partner on board um so that
145you have sort of this a team together early on through the process that can really take things uh through fruition and and like I said this is um the way we see things being I me that is the intention that I would have as your superintendent is that we're working to get a team together and get going um and and obviously I think that in in essence um the board will make the decision I would say that in essence we're leaning towards that you know the least leas back is is a method that we feel brings a whole team together you know as I talked even earlier when when ver was presenting you know I want this I I I think it's important to think about this whole team together now working and going out
146and getting the projects done um you know and and that's that's a key but it is up to the board um and uh and and there is a process we have to go through to make if we're going to go for lease lease back right um and and the quicker that we do that then the quicker then we can get to then if we're going to do that go out for RFP RFQ for construction team um if not then it's a little bit different because now we might still do some projects um that would we would do design and bid it and build it so that's not out of the question but if we're going to move forward with some with the concept of lease lease back then it's about getting this moving getting getting
147your decision to say y we would like to do that and getting that team together again I'm using the example of Argy since they're here tonight what are the reason why I want them side by side with this if they're going to be do we're doing work with the Energy savings and and following the code good we want them here right now they need to working you know with our facility master plan and and and engaging with our architect and then we if we have at least lease back we want want to make sure we're looking at is there projects that we need to bid out is or you know these which projects are we going to utilize a construction partner with so lot happening um and yeah I want to make sure we're just
148moving that and clicking that along are we going to vote in February or March so my well so Our intention right now is to as we always go through our process of information discussion and action is that we'd have a discussion item on this in February and then act in March unless the board said you know what I think we we know which way we'd like to go and direct me otherwise So the plan plan would be if you choose through our discussion in February that you'd like to go lease lease back then we'd bring the we'd work with our partners at dwk bring forward what you need to do to be able to make sure that we can do lease lease back resolution board policy and then we go out in RFP RFQ for
149the for construction company right that's so I hope that answered the question okay thank you would you want to have Reed or Meredith talk some about or you just I wanted them here just in in case there was questions I don't know if either Reed or Meredith Reed I probably lean towards you but or amerith um if there's anything you would add uh to to the conversation um maybe just a couple things really quick I thought it was um you know very informative presentation I think this was hit in the presentation um but just to emphasize it's not necessarily an All or Nothing decision um you'll have potentially different options for different projects um and then there's been discussion about adopting a board policy uh for leas leaseback projects uh that is something that is
150required under the lease leaseback statute Education Code 1746 because you have to have a guideline for the selection process it looks like you have already undertaken that in 2021 I'm looking at uh regulation 33 111.2 so you may have already crossed that hurdle but we'll take a look at it and make sure that it's comprehensive for what you need um so Reed I'm not to interrupt you I apologize so so that with if if the board policy is in place and there's no other need for any other additional action from the board on on that that I guess that's my question at this point that that's correct on that item but there is one another area where board action um may be needed and I'm you know trying to look at this at the moment
151I was mentioned during the presentation that you would need to have a pre-qualification process well no sorry you would not need to have a pre-qualification process because you're below the Ada so you would be you would be good okay and again tonight's effort is to try to be really clear on on the options and make sure that the board um feels comfortable with the direction what I think that's really important for me that I was in the presentation I think I stated already and Reed reinforced is that really if we want to do lease lease back that doesn't say that we can't do like design bid build if there we determined there were projects that we needed to do that okay very good thank you Reed are there any questions from the board members trusty
152heon or trusty kamacho thank you I I kind of I guess I do have a question um the two different options that we have to go the selection of contractors would it vary if would it be do they have to meet different qualifications like you said they had to have the best value scoring for the lease lease back or lease similarly to I'll say the the RFQ that was published for the selection of The Architects and same one that I think is out now for program management um there would be some sort of RFQ um process now a little bit differently in that you can ask questions about things like um what's your percentage of uh overhead and profit what would be your percent let's say of General conditions a cost so there is sometimes
153a cost component that we see as part of that process so more of an RFP not an RFQ but there would be some sort of scoring rubric more than likely I'm going to imagine um and then there would be a selection process interviews that kind of thing so again you're almost selecting that Contracting partner as you would your architect or your your program manager yeah and I just want to go back since what Reed has shared and and I my apologies to the board that may Mis understood so there may not need to be a specific action by the board but of course we want to make sure that the board feels favorable to the actions of the staff right so um you know well I sorry go ahead okay I have a question about
154um using local trade so um I mean if if we do a least least buyback Studio W would bring in their preferred team I want to make sure we clarify Studio W Studio W would not be bringing in know that would be it would through an RFP RFQ process that we could include Studio W and I think it would be worthy of including Studio W in the selection but it's not them bringing anyone okay that would be through an RFQ process I do also want to re reiterate that if a local company um had the capability could meet the qualifications and and and be selected that they could do that okay because I was looking at the um the design bid build as opposed to the lease lease back and if we did a lease
155lease back um one of the pros was a partnership with the architect well well absolutely is so so but it's not I just want to make sure we're clear it wouldn't be the architect selecting it would be us selecting we would want I mean I think it's worth worthy big deal I would make it's worthy to have our partner now we've selected Studio W to be part of that because they're going to how this thing works and just to to really talk about it and I mean look I'm a superintendent I was an educator right I mean but because I've done a lot of this work and worked with such fine people like merth and Reed and others in my past I've learned a great deal about doing this work but it's in my in
156my experience it's when we bring a team together and it it works right and so part of this project program management piece is making sure that it that we have someone that with the expertise of delivering on this project and program of of measure you um and and is is making sure that we have all the pieces in place and makes it happen right but when you have an architect they have to work really closely with the construction company right and that's that that I'm getting I I got that last little piece and that made it all light bulb came on so's that I said can I jump in of course yes um I think your point is very well taken about sort of local presence and being able have those local Contracting teams subcontracting
157teams be part of this even um interestingly enough through design bid build the traditional method there is no requirement obviously to have a local U presence um you could have a a general contractor from Utah come in and be the lowest responsible bidder probably not because they're so far out of town they wouldn't be maybe the most competitive but they could um in which case there may be no subcontractors as part of their team they're they're part of that there's no requirement the only requirement for selection is that they're the lowest bid um in lease lease back there is still a bidding process often time so what we see is that general contractor that's selected is still going to bid out all of those subtrates but one of the nice things is is it's open
158book so another words you're not required then to take the lowest responsible bids of each one of these subcontractors and often what we see is that general contractor bringing that book in after the bids have occurred and said we got four bids for electrical and um you know we felt some of these things might have been left out so we're going to build in some contingency of that um but oh by the way this particular um folks are local now it's a little bit more let's say if we want to use them but we're recommending because we think they're local they're going to do a better job etc etc makes sense to actually include them as part of our sub subcontractor list so in some ways it actually enables you to get a little bit
159more control over that process than you would traditionally through design bid bill you know just I note and this is not this is specific to this item but even in conversation with verie prior to tonight's presentation talked about how we would want to utilize local contractors when possible if we were work with them right so then I think that's important part of it thank you I appreciate that trusty Heatherton yeah so um I'm I'd like I'm going to do a little more research on my own but uh just my comment right now would be leaning towards the lease leaseback um I like the um I like establishing the ceiling and knowing that we can actually complete a a project that's been designed rather than you know having to come back and now we got to
160scrape something out towards the end of the bond that you know that we were Desiring so I'm going to do more research and get back with different thoughts again I I I I was and and I really appreciate uh Reed I was thinking that if we were going to go that direction we had to do some additional action by the board um if that's not the case I want to talk speak you know with Reed um following up on this is that we would then just want to make we may not need action but just need the board's confirmation that you understand we may go that direction along with the possibility of design bid build um that's that's so just so you know what I'm thinking aloud right now is if it doesn't need action
161just making sure we're looking at you going okay is that m match with the board's interest as we go forward um and again I will have a follow-up conversation just to make sure that we have done all that we need to do would um thank you and would you possibly put like the just like you've done today um with item 11g you've had the project management the program management project management request for proposal like as an information because we'd have a a request for qualifications for this contractor that would be so if we made that decision to move just because I thought we were going to need to to actually update board policy and I appreciate that Reed's being our policies looking right now um if we don't need to do that and we have
162a sense that the board is supporting moving forward then we'll work with Reed and pull together that RFP RFQ and of course we bring that for you so so you can see what's out and what we're doing absolutely may could accelerate that work which is a good thing as we get um because I've recently said to Brian as soon as uh as soon as that that your contract's approved I need you to have a list of what we're looking at projectwise so that we can get work Rock and if we go leas lease back that's a good thing to get that that group into just as like we're trying to get the program project management in so that we're we're we're all lock step yeah so it seems like I mean this is a complicated
163I appreciate all the discussion because it is a complicated um thing for us to get our heads around and I guess really what I'm hearing is that um and I one question was like this notion of how do contractors pre-qualify I mean it seems like the big difference is that you're asking contractors to describe their services so I appreciate you saying Brian that we could ask for what their percent of overhead is but we're under the least Le spec we're going to when I say we whoever the team is reviewing proposals is going to have to decide what contractor is the best one without having a lot of information about how much they charge to do things which in a traditional thing you'd have the specific design and you'd get a cost and yeah it
164might you might have to take the lowest bidder which I understand isn't always the best but you have you have much more concrete things and so now we're going to be having to pre-qualify essentially this contractor and base our review or our you know our Judgment of them um on their past experiences and things like that but it seems it's very different than than having someone submit you know their cost you're operating a bit like a private entity right you know if if you were a private you know not a public school district you probably go out and say okay talk to me contractors have you done work like this before do you have experience with DSA do you know what's your experience here in Tahoe you know those kinds of things can't do that
165obviously in design bid build um but one of the things I will mention is because of that sort of best value that came out of legislation and other things that allowed you to sort of then make sense of okay what's our overhead and profit General conditions as percentages um sort of like where where our fees in the future are governed by that that sliding scale you you now kind of set some parameters under which really it's it's how big or how little are the sub trades that ultimately get bit out and and what's that because then they're really just applying those percent of overhead and profit and general conditions and other things to that piece and you know one of the bits of feedback we often get through lease lease back is well you know
166sometimes you get a general contractor that's out of town or maybe you know and it's perceived like oh my gosh you know all the funds are going to these folks when we look at those contracts the general contractor piece is actually a small part it's all of those subcontractors that really make up the bulk of that and again the the possibility a lot of that's local the possibility that you know you get some really strong teams that have a lot of experience doing this have worked with that general contractor before that's kind of the beauty of that ability to sort of say hey we don't have to necessarily take the lowest responsible numbers in each one of these cases thank you and then I have a final kind of I don't know I think it's
167my last legal question Meredith I just the terminology lease lease back and you know it sounds like we're giving um up control over our buildings while we have kids in them I I mean these are the when I hear the words it it confuses me in terms of why is it called this and what what are we really um you know what's the risk in terms of us leasing um property if that's what we're actually doing in some sort of process back to a contractor and then they're leasing it back to us this these terms are um they are a little befuddling for me well and I you said Meredith Meredith if you feel comfortable or having read sorry question I what I say is Merit is really our bond counsel just so you know
168that's going to be her focus is our on our bonds and then of course Reed is our Council on all these these items that relate to um RFP rfqs and this stuff cool maybe Reed can help me think yeah no AB absolutely it's a great question um I think there were two parts of it the terminology and then the risk so the terminology lease leaseback comes from you are leasing the site to your contractor sometimes we use the term developer and then they're constructing tenant improvements on that site which is the project that they're going to construct and then they're going to lease that back to you for a time period um and that goes to the financing element that Brian mentioned in the presentation earlier that's still part of the statute but the statute
169has been amended to formalize the selection process so it's no longer sort of the loophole that it was one time uh viewed as that's where the terminology comes from what's the you know potential risk the way that the documents are drafted there's not there's risk in any construction project but there's not risk tied to the lease because title remains with the district at all time you're just simply allowing them to access the site for the purpose of constructing the tenant improvements that you will then buy out there's also a purchase option included in the leas lease back portion um that gives you the option to buy out that lease term early so that you're not incurring you know interest on the lease payments thank you that that was helpful yeah it's still I mean it's
170I mean this is why we wanted to do this agenda item tonight as well as making sure that the board feels comfortable with whatever we move forward with um and again uh obviously we lean towards that that that that the process of leaste lease back based on building the team and making it happen okay all right thank you I think that's all we have on this item thank you all right Meredith and Reed thank you so much for joining us tonight um all right sorry we now have item 13 the consent agenda um do I have a motion I move to adopt the consent agenda second I'll second okay I have a motion by trusty heatherington and a second by trusty kamacho um all in favor say I I I'll oppose nay all right the
171consent agenda oh there was no nay there was there there was no nay I'm sorry all favor say I I asked for Nays but I said I um all yeah so the consent agenda has passed and um we now have item 14 items for consideration at future board meetings does anybody have anything they'd like to consider at future board meetings seeing none then I will adjourn the meeting at wait I have something too you have something I do okay retract the adjournment Mia talked about it earlier and Dr Cutler talked about it earlier about um creating declaring that LTD is a safe haven is that something that we can just do or does it have to go come from the board so um we I've been in multiple convers ations with several people up on
172this topic over the last two to three weeks sure um and if the board is interested in doing some form of resolution um the partners that we've been talking with are very cautious and careful to how we word what we say um that's up to the board really in regards to that um but there's some concern that has been shared with me about what attention we may draw to ourselves in declare Declaration um it's my intention and I was actually uh sharing with Teresa earlier my intention to put out a statement uh following my statement tonight with additional information for folks um but if the board is would like to do some formal resolution we uh you know some formal statement that you would like we can bring that back at the February 13th meeting
173yeah I mean I I read something similar that Los Angeles Unified and you mentioned Napa I think trusty Mansfield so that there are some resolutions out there so I that's the board's interest I will start to pull that together if the board wants to to do that type level of action we'll bring that on the February 13th meeting all right and I appreciate you putting out a statement that'll be in the newsletter um yeah we'll put out we'll to put out a statement um we've had our we've asked our principles to start sharing directly information as well um so and and oh the principles be yeah communic to their folks have resources and that we have the um professional development attendance problem they're not at school so I I I will say this um I
174think your resolution makes a statement um I'm not not certain that there are some folks and we've been engaging with some families uh Karen Goldberg and I have had several conversations and we've actually engaged with some families that um no matter what and I think that uh that as was stated by Jody de earlier tonight we have to maybe take a look at and consider what are some other additional options for those families so there's lots to to work out and that yeah and that may require board action if we change independent study possibly I don't we have have okay again I I um if the board's feel is that hey we want to make a statement then we'll bring something forward for you absolutely that is up to you and so that's what I'm
175hearing um I will visit individually with each of you to make sure that I'm capturing what your interests are there um and then bring forward to you that um our general statement is going to come out as going to be that we're here to keep people safe and secure and and and make sure we work on uh students being able to be here to learn and grow right and and we'll be making sure we push out resources and availability of those resources um that's from The District in regards to the board saying we want to make a a stronger statement and have a resolution we will pull that together for you if that's the direction okay okay thank you thank you okay uh on that note I'm now going to adjourn the meeting at 8:21
176p.m.