001started um with our meeting thank you very much um welcome to the board meeting uh we could ask you all to please silence your sell phones um and we will start our meeting I guess I first need to report at a close session uh we have yeah report at a close session that the board upheld the level two by unanimous vote of five to zero um with that I would like to invite up uh calabases ASP president Devin Aaron to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance please stand place your right hand over your heart ready begin I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you thank you Mr Aaron let's
002see uh report out a closed session um approval of the agenda I will move to approve tonight's agenda I'll second any questions about the agenda hearing none uh all those in favor student vote I board I I I motion passes unanimously I should note for those watching uh Miss cupel is joining us via Zoom today uh so she'll be on the screen up the upper right hand corner so you might hear her pipe in from time to time as the voice of God throughout the uh house that's that's where she's coming in from so from God's country as I understand where she's at right now so it it makes sense um great that'll move us to approval of the amendments may have a motion to approve the minuts to approve the minuts I'll second any
003questions in the minutes great uh all those in favor student vote please I board I moot motion passes unanimously um staff board communication Dr stanowski Mr President I believe uh we'll start off with a a presentation by the amazing students from a right Middle School principal Foley come on down and let us know what we're about to uh experience the board wants to head down we can go head down all right well um Mr President members of the board thank you so much for having us here we really appreciate it uh cabinet thank you Dr Stephan oi thank you um this is our Advanced choir a right Advanced choir and um I want to just say thank you to them and uh this is Mr Morales Mr Morales big round of applause for Mr Morales
004he is our first year music teacher first year music teacher he's doing a great job so uh I want to thank these students for all their hard work they're amazing and without further Ado this is the wave [Music] you [Music] e e e all we one and W that was amazing thank you guys um uh just beautiful um all right let's move us along Dr step back to staff board communication Mr President members of the board a couple of exciting updates for you oh Mr Klein fired away first up is Staff Development Day we completed uh a whole bunch of training yesterday uh this is um Universal uh design uh Universal lesson design udl training um put together as obviously Miss faul and I during the presentation some of the different topics covered um you
005keep advancing the slides Miss chamber uh we did cutting math and structural practices uh lesson design like I mentioned writing calibration performance tasks we also did Performing Arts collaboration TK curriculum along with a number of other curriculums there's the G building at Agora high school and our main and staff met uh this is a session from the um Robert kinsky uh TK it was fantastic to have our um TK 12 Math teachers all together in one room with Robert kinsky that was an awesome session um next slide Elementary grade breakout later on in the day fantastic to everyone everyone together our M staff you can keep going uh met did leadership comms um safety extensive safety work there's a um maina staff right there at a drama room in a right next slide and uh
006maybe to Me Maybe the most exciting all of it's exciting especially math math is super exciting I want my directors to hear that um but two teachers uh Brad Bowman and Jason Busby organized a trip for the entire social studies Department to go visit the um Holocaust Museum of Los Angeles and Mr anol shared what Mr Anal accompanied uh those teachers those are some photos from some of the sessions they had there and this was yesterday Mr hanold sent me an email about his experience and I quote exploring this profound chapter of history in such an immersive way was invaluable not only in deepening our understanding but also in strengthening our commitment to ensuring that these lessons continue to resonate with all our students the sessions that included encountering and combating anti-Semitism in the classroom
007was particularly pertinent And Timely your leadership Jason and Brad uh in guiding these discussions and providing tools for Meaningful engagement in our classrooms is truly commendable and I couldn't have said it better so I a deep deep thank you to Brad Bowman and Jason Busby uh for that next slide we have La parent um sorry Los Virg a parent series continuing um this is a confident confident confident conversation series we appreciate Tim Johns for putting this together these are free available to all of our parents uh there's a number I think one per uh month next slide Sports Camps sent an email out to All Families I believe it was yesterday about our camps sign up will be January 31st starting at 9:00 a.m. there's the basic super excited to be offering this to our
008families and our community and our staff and uh much thanks to Dr GLE and the team for putting us together with a short Runway but it'll be a great experience for all of our students next slide B laand is coming up this Sunday um if you you know busy getting ready for the Super Bowl and want to be hyped up a little bit as you prepare to cheer on the Eagles to a Super Bowl victory uh battle ticket sales are plummeting as we speak okay well Mr gel told me he was voting for The Eagles I believe is it um maybe there not a lot of Eagles fans here I'm trying to read the room uh but if you're looking for something do on Sunday come on out there's fantastic bands from across our district
009students from Agora calabases round Meadow Elementary several of our middle schools as well that's all the band names up there will be a lot of fun it's at The Canyon Club students have so much uh talent and we'll also have doc stepping Expendables which is a combination of students and staff together in a band which is so much fun getting a chance to play with our talented staff and and our students is so much fun I believe Mr lazar's daughter will be joining us on trumpet as well rumors she can hit like a triple High SE y outstanding uh next slide wow I don't know what that means but wow so we have some awards super high note if you know mayard Ferguson mayard Ferguson he those high notes we belong to AXA Region 13
010it is a massive region it extends from Los virgins all the way up to St Louis abiso unified and so uh we put in a number of our staff for awards and we hit uh on them all uh so many of our staff uh that we put in for awards received Awards and great recognitions to my right Miss Faulk was uh recognized for her leadership and student support Val Lothian central office leadership Jesse Sweeney classified leadership Miriam worth secondary co-administrator our very own Miss Chambers to my left uh leadership in the Human Resources realm and principal Jackie Duncan as as Elementary principal of the year for Axel Region 13 so really quean clean sweet super exciting and that's just uh just breaking news so congratulations to all his outstanding Educators and leaders next slide speaking
011of Dr Duncan she is also the recipient of the California Association of Asian and Pacific leaders in education principal of the Year Awards so we're super excited to celebrate her in that way I just cut a video for her award ceremony so Dr Duncan um super proud super excited and super well well deserving of you we appreciate your leadership and your great work with your students staff and community at bayoro I think that's it for me and I've covered all of Staff Comm so that concludes staff communication oh efficient all right um let's see here um while we're moving forward here if you have a if you're planning to speak on an item on the agenda um you can put a card in if you're planning to speak I'm on the agenda we ask you
012to put a card in so miss Brook's back there can help you um fill out the cards if you want to speak on a topic today with that we'll start with uh board Communications miss westg Mr President members of the board Calabasas and aora have been very busy recently at Calabasas students have been giving back by signing up for the blood drive and participating in the donation drive for those affected by the fire this week students are preparing for finals at both high schools at CHS to distress students can join a meditation at lunch in honor of new Lunar New Year students are searching campus for a dragon cutout today in exchange for candy next week CHS is celebrating kindness week and holding a student Senate meeting where students can come speak to ASB Representatives
013over at Agora students have also begun preparing for finals last week they held a fantastic student L production of the Diary of an Frank in addition to Su successful gift card Drive benefiting local fire victims winter sports have had a fantastic stretch throughout the league play the Chargers have been have had quite few activities on tap as they enter the new semester Agora has an upcoming Spirit Week Valentin Val's day rally Talent Night Show and More We wish all students good luck with their finals thank you very much Mr Lazard um well had quite a busy week uh I did first of all actually want to give a a shout out to Dr Duncan uh because I had the great pleasure of working with her for four years in the bay laurel schoolside Council and
014these Awards she's getting it's like a no-brainer to me she's fantastic principal such a great person as well uh so shout out to Dr Duncan on the subject of bay Laur I attended the fourth grade music performance at B Laurel uh which is always a joy to see the elementary school kids uh singing uh experience in music um and parents absolutely loved it was fantastic to attend and hopefully they will join the aw Choir in a in a couple years um Miss cutell and I visited chapparel Elementary last Thursday and uh I think Miss kuto will agree it was such a lovely visit uh we visited many classrooms together uh always inspiring to see kids uh in their classrooms um it was also fantastic to see chappel's new maker space uh which uh only got
015going this year and I was very very impressed by it I'd love to see it in every single Elementary School in our district I must say um and yeah that's about it for me thank you Stein thank you very much at the very last minute I ended up being invited to um a meeting with the assembly the California State Assembly Speaker of the House revas he held a meeting with assembly members who were head of of the Utility Commission and um the head of housing with our assembly member Jackie Irwin uh supervisor Lindsey Horvath the Mayors and city council members from aora hills Calabasas Westlake Village Hidden Hills Thousand Oaks and Malibu to hear about our experience is in our region during these last fires what what support we need over here what community ation
016didn't work hello Edison um and so literally the woman I can't think of her name right now who's in charge of utilities said well I'm leaving and calling right now so um it was wonderful to be a part of that because our um local leaders in our cities are looking forward they're trying to prepare for future you know emergencies thank you great oh should we go to miss cupel next vir go comments cause it just feels strange remote so and and Mr lzard covered our school visit so thank you great miss megas so um on on the vein that U Miss Stein touched on uh we had a finance committee meeting and um discussed that because of the fires in case you haven't heard um the people in this area don't don't have to file
017their taxes by April 15th this year they it'll be October before they have to file and that makes it even more challenging for us to work on our budgets because we don't have really final numbers and makes that Crystal Ball even murkier than usual um and then this morning I was able to attend the uh calabassas uh chamber Ed meeting and um Miss Tina Johnson was the guest speaker today and she did a fantastic job of um espousing all of the great programs that we have going on in the district and that we have uh open enrollment going on right now everyone's been busy uh a couple things I would like to take uh thank staff uh Miss sign I had a good Pathways committee meeting uh earlier this this month um was it's just
018uh really thankful for all the work to keep moving forward on math adoption in particular um it was really rewarding to see what persistent and grit and determination can bring about um it's been a long process but it's happy to see that we're Landing in a place where um there's buyin there's excitement the test scores are moving in the right direction so um I really app it's been over I think year and a half now I've been working on this so um I know that the end is INS sight but thank you very much for that great work um also want to thank the finance staff we had a chance to meet a lot of the finance staff and the finance Acy this I didn't realize how young a staff that is young in the
019sense of new to the district um uh really really is new uh which even makes our completely clean audit even all that more impressive that we received a couple weeks ago with such a new team so congratulations to Mr gleon and the team um while miss Stein tackled the State Assembly I was invited by the state senate uh president protm to join their meeting that was held here in uh Los Angeles was yours as a slog as mine was we had to go all way down to the LA Science Center ours was our oh my mic is on ours was at the agore hills re Center five minutes from my home mine was a three hour round trip on a Saturday but um it was it was really great to be around that it was
020an off the Record meeting uh it was with the governor's staff um SoCal Edison senior leadership the Senate President proam all of our state leaders um and it was a a very direct conversation uh and so you know I managed to advocate for a couple things but the the key thing that I'm pushing for um and I think there was a lot of receptiveness to it is if if uh the state back filling and funding uh battery backups for school districts in PSPs shut off zones um I think it's a no-brainer if we're going to Contin to be suffering through power outages uh the state should fund battery backups of protections for our campuses so our schools can switch over to battery power and continue to move forward it would cost us millions of dollars
021to do that it would make sense for us to do that um but it was actually one of the recap action items of the day they recap they're going to fall up on so hopefully we see some movement there um but I think one of the things that I think you probably experienced it as well there is a 100% attention being paid on this region by the state um and I think they realize it's going to be years to get us where we need to go I'm very proud of the fact that we've accepted how many students so far we are now at 50 50 students we've taken from the Palisades fire um it will take three to four years to rebuild a school in California at light speed speed um so these are kids
022who are going to be displaced that need a home uh and I know that Dr Steph I think you've personally called every family member who's applied so again above and beyond but like for a family it's gone through such a terrifying experience to give that welcome mat out to them we really appreciate that and I know the community is welcoming these students with open arms as they come aboard um so with that I will conclude uh our uh board comments are there any uh Miss burom do we have any comments from people about items not on the agenda okay great um that moves us to uh consent a I'll move to approve consent I have fire away um just on the uh ratifying the assignment of contract from Forefront license in LSC to CSI electrical
023that was part of the solar uh panels that we installing I wasn't privy to the conversations last year about that why why was that contract uh transferred over so Forefront their expertise is to do the design work CSI does the in station and so the contract was uh designed to have a handoff after the design was completed and all um all obligations were met on the DSA and design front for CSI then to have the handoff and take full responsibility for the remainder of the contract great thank you great any other questions or items on the agenda for just okay may I have a motion to approve cons a please oh wait we don't have we don't have a motion yet I said I have a motion did okay so moved I'll second for a
024second there's been a motions been made and seconded um no further discussion all those in favor student vote I board I motion pass thank you motion passes unanimously uh consent B move to approve consent b i second this is a board only vote any questions on consent B no seeing none all those in favor Board of approving consent B hi motion passes unanimously that brings us to action items uh approval revision to board policy 51318 mobile Communications devices if you have cards please fill them out for Miss bergom so we can have them and with that Dr stephanas I'll turn it over to you Miss Funk Mr President members of the board as you know last uh board meeting this was presented as an information item uh we had discussion based upon the discussion at
025committee meetings and at board meetings and with various board members the district has brought forth I proposed policy in line with csp's recommendation and in particular up per the governor's um order the board has the responsibility to make a recommendation for a policy specific to Los virgines and the current policy as written and proposed is that um the district continue with the off and Away uh Bell to Bell at elementary and middle school continue with the current high school policy for this year which is off and Away except at nutrition and lunch and the new part in this policy post is that next year in the 2526 school year that high school will be in align with elementary and middle school and that will be Bell to Bell which would mean no cell phone use
026during nutrition and lunch as written great um if there I'd love I think what worked last week worked well I prefer to hear from folks first before we deliberate but I would like to maybe set a couple just clear kind of clarifying rules um or not rules to insights uh one we're not voting on Yonder bags Yonder bags are on the agenda item uh feel free to app about Yonder bags yeah you're nay we're not voting on them today um they're not they're not on agenda for discussion I think two um off and Away means uh what it says it does not mean locked in a way it does not mean the student won't be able to access their phone so I would say respectfully we've heard from a lot of people concerns about emergencies
027and students being able to be contacted in emergencies this board policy passes if it passes there will be zero Z restrictions on your students being able to have access to their phone in case of an emergency they will have it on them at all times 247 365 with no barrier to them to be able to get to it so I think those are the two things I wanted to make sure we're clear anything else can I ask a clarifying or or just say something so last board meeting we gave direction for um beltel K8 so that um is the we we didn't vote on it but we gave unanimous direction for that we also gave unanimous direction to not move forward with Yonder under bags at this time so just so that we're clear on
028that everybody has an understanding of that we didn't vote on under bags so right but we gave clear direction we didn't vote on them so the board can't give guidance like that without voting on it so we didn't we didn't make a policy decision we just didn't decide well we gave clear if you watch the meeting for anybody who did we gave clear Direction on that but okay we'll table that for another time okay so with that let me go uh let me turn over to we'll just go through the list that I've got we ask you to speak for three minutes if you could there will be a timer uh I'm really going to ask you stick to it because there's a lot of cards that people want to move through so respectfully would
029like to have everyone get a chance to speak um so with that I will start with uh Negan gafari and then on Deck would be Megan Rousey want to be first oh sorry someone's got to be first forgive me as I forgot my glasses but um I'm a I'm a parent of an eighth grader and um and Alum who was a first year at in college and um um I'm just going to read what I wrote um please um so my belief is for K through 8 and I'm not going to speak on high school but I'm my I really feel very strongly about the k through eight um I'm an educator I've been an educator I'm 50 years old so I've been an educator since I was 22 when I got my first job
030I have a doctorate in educational studies so I'm I I'm speaking to you from my expertise and as a parent um Banning small um smart youth um smartphone usage by students during the school day can significantly enhance their academic performance and engagement with fewer distractions and social media notifications and games students can focus more on their lessons leading to improved test scores and overall um learning outcomes additionally liit limiting cell phone access encourages face-to-face interactions among peers fostering stronger social skills and relationships reducing screen time also helps mitigate issues related to anxiety and stress linked to constant connectivity creating a healthier School environment ultimately school um a smartphone banding um or off and Away um can create an um a conducive to an atmosphere that is more um warm and loving for a thriving environment
031um just what happened a couple of weeks ago my eighth grader um I sent him a text hoping that he would check right after school saying I you have an orthodontist appointment and I'm here to pick you up he didn't see it he got on the school bus and sent went on his way home and as I was waiting there I didn't see him so I checked an app and I saw him on the bus Mo moving and instead of being upset I was really happy I was so happy that my child got off got out of school and started talking to other kids and he didn't go focus on the games and the and social media and all the things make can feel terrible about himself and he would be very upset to hear
032me talking here um about this but I I really believe that we can do it and coming from the classroom environment have been having been a public school teacher for many years um I think that we can ask the teachers warmly and kindly to to help enforce it in a in a loving way and I think very quickly in a couple of years it'll become part of the culture so I hope that the board will consider off and away as a strict policy for K through a thank you very much um Megan Rousey followed by um Caroline I think it's wheeler hi good evening board members I appreciate the opportunity to speak with you my name is Megan and I have a fifth and an eighth grader here in lvusd so I'm going to be
033going to middle school and high school next year um and I'd like to ask you guys a question do you um think that you've ever said or do you hear any adults your age say gosh I wish I really had a cell phone when I was in Middle School and High School my guess is that the answer is no because I have heard so many parents while we raise our kids say oh my gosh thank goodness I did not have a cell phone when I was that age um maybe it was because we would be caught doing things but I don't know I'm just saying like we all know what the dangers are and we know that it's because there's so much uh constant connectivity and the pressures of social media so our kids are
034living in this world of YouTube and cameras all the time and social media and just like constant dings all the time so that their brains have literally been rewired and the amount of research that has been done on how detrimental this uh the smartphones have been to our children is staggering and it's truly horrifying if you really dig into it um so now that we know better and we have this research I think we really need to do better so what I'm asking for is simple um I want my kids to have the gift of being discon connected from their phones from first Bell to last bill and I'd like that to be from kinder through high school I would like it to be enforced equally by all the principles I have found by talking
035to people at different schools this has not been the case um I will go off script and say I am happy at the way the my kids school has handled it so that being said I have heard from other parents that a lot of the teachers have also spent class time valuable class time riling up the students about how stupid the policy is and how they won't be enforcing it so I would really think that if we could have a cultural shift of buyin on this it would be a huge shift um I know that you guys are not voting on y bugs but I'm going to give my two cents really quick anyway I think that's an I think they are an amazing idea and I think that there I've heard the com the
036complaints the concerns about them I just have a few responses to those um for so for the budgetary concerns I totally understand I get it I think that's probably the biggest concern that people have um and what they want to what they are fighting with uh for me I think this would be the single most important investment in our children's mental health because I heard some people say let's invest in mental health um programs if we have this money I think that is the mental health the mental health problem for those with emergencies um I'd like to note that we drop off five year-olds at school without cell phones and we trust that the teachers will take care of them also overwhelmingly the police and the FBI say that it's better for students not to
037have cell phones during an emergency um and lastly I just want to say if there's parents that complain that they can't be in touch with their kids throughout the day sadly that's just proof that whatever we're doing right now is not working thank you so much thank you uh Caroline Willard followed by Emily Richie Hello um good evening members of the school board my name is Caroline Wier and I'm the mother of a senior and a freshman at calabases high school so in response to my personalized letter that I sent to the board this week regarding this controversial ban in high schools I received a reply from Mr Lawrence and he was speaking on behalf of the entire board tonight so my remarks tonight are going to represent the voices of at least 50 calabasis
038High School parents both in 9th and 12th grade who share my point of view as a full-time working parent in a two-person working household I can confidently say that cell phones are critical tools for families to coordinate their lives phones enable the smooth operations of families with multiple moving Parts whether it's scheduling changing plans working with their employers and with their jobs or addressing last minute needs Taking this tool away would create unnecessary disruptions making daily life significantly harder for parents and students Mr Lawrence's response suggested that a phonefree environment would alleviate students anxiety about missing a midday text actually I believe the contrary is true restricting access to their phones would create more stress for the high school students who rely on the ability to communicate with their families their employers their tutors their
039SAT prep people Etc during the day it's also important to address the lack of enforcement of the current cell phone policy which already requires phones to be stored away in classrooms this policy has been in place but it hasn't been consistently enforced some teachers follow it diligently While others ignore it entirely instead of Reinventing the wheel with an entirely new and extreme policy why not focusing focus on enforcing the current rules the in theclassroom rules which by the way I think are appropriate in certain situations less the fact that some classes do have to use their cell phones for work such as my son's three years of broadcasting in which a lot of work gets done on those phones in the classrooms so given the current policy give the current policy the time and attention
040it needs to truly take hold bottom line is I want to know that the kids can reach me when they need or want to and I know that I can do the same this isn't just a convenience it's a fundamental part of being a family in today's connected World high school students are young adults and in many cases they are adults so we're taking away something that is going to create an unnecessary unnecessary it's a unnecessary barrier that created that's created for them I'm going to have to ask you to wrap up thank thank you thanks uh Emily Richie followed by Andrea kamacho hi it's me again apparently I'm the only person who's brave enough to come talk to you I'm just kidding we all love you hello president Lawrence members of the board and
041lvusd cabinet my name is Emily Richie I'm currently a counselor at calabases high school I'm also the foster parent have fostered four boys two of whom are now adults and two who are teenagers I speak onal behalf of teachers counselors union members and other staff on our campuses I would first like to address the need for improved transparency and communication to site staff in regards to changing policies and their implementation it seems apparent in the last few weeks that inconsistencies in communication have caused confusion and concern across many secondary campuses while recent Communications from board members to school pfcs and pfas have clarified that students will retain unobstructed access to their mobile devices under an off andway policy it's critical that communication remains clear and consistent across all levels speaking on behalf of our school
042staff we are surprised in a bit disappointed that board members have not actively sought more input from those responsible for enforcing these policies on the ground it seems to be a pattern emerging for the board to pass updated policies without consulting the key stakeholders who were boots on the ground doing the work we have seen this already this year with our new concurrent enrollment policies passed earlier this school year counselors were never asked to be a part of the convers ation even though we are the primary staff members on our high school sites responsible communicating and enforcing these new policies to students parents and our community we've also noted that the proposed bellt Bell policy only reduces School use by approximately one additional hour during school hours given that students have an additional 14 to
04316 hours a day outside of school where their phones would be the responsibility of their parents or Guardians to monitor wouldn't resources be better spent on parent education regarding healthy screen time habits parental controls and apps already exist to help monitor phone use and high school students in particular benefit from open discussions regarding responsible digital habits rather than outright restrictions I speak from experience additionally enforcing a phone ban during school at nutrition and lunch will require additional Staffing at CHS for example many students leave campus for lunch and existing security staff and administrators are already stretched thin it takes anywhere from 15 to 20 minutes for our current security staff and administrators to check students off campus and I'm not sure where the additional Staffing would come from to walk campus and tell students to
044put their phones away during these times implementing this policy without proper Staffing support will create enforcement challenges and impact overall campus supervision I truly believe that if board members could make time to visit our campuses during nutrition and lunch talk to our students walk through our classrooms and see how technology is being used you will see that our current policy is doing its job in the classroom our current policy has also only been implemented for a few months we are working out the glitches we need to trust that our parents can make decisions that work in the best interest of their own kids and families and both monitor their use and limit it if they see necessary I have to ask you up I urge the board to provide transparency seek meaningful input from all
045stakeholders and carefully consider Logistics of enforcement before implementing new policies thank you thank you Andrea Kam followed by Elena I think it's Sant good evening high school students are not just children they are young individuals on the path to adulthood and the law increasingly recognizes their growing independence by the age of 18 they are legal adults who can sign themselves out of school enlist in the military or even be drafted to serve their country at 16 students can take High School proficiency exams and leave High School entirely in California 16 and 17year olds can even be tried as adults for some serious crimes these laws reflect a growing recognition that while still in school students are already making important decisions that shape their future it's important to note that the minimum age to join the
046US military is 17 years old with par parental consent these young people take on the immense responsibility of serving their country often risking their lives if we trust students with these life-altering choices and respons responsibilities why can't we also trust them to use their phones responsibly during their free time at school this should be part of a growing autonomy that high school students experience as they prepare for adulthood this issue is especially personal for me my own son 17 and a half years old will be entering the Air Force after graduation I have seen firsthand the maturity and responsibility that many of our students possess these are young people capable of making important decisions about their future and yet we question their ability to manage something as simple as using a cell phone during their
047break denying students the ability to use their phones during nutrition and lunch periods times that belong to them undermines their autonomy and disregards the trust we place in them to make other more consequential decisions at a time when students are asked to be responsible for their future we should be fostering a culture of trust and respect our policies should reflect the maturity our students show in many aspects of their lives from their ability to serve in the military or the decisions about leaving school or getting a job policies that restrict students from using their phones during their personal time send the wrong message one that says we don't trust them to make responsible choices we must also consider the broader implications of policies like this if parents and students feel this policy is restrictive or
048unfair they have the option to choose other school districts that treat High School schoolers more like adults we've already seen what happens when family families feel their voices and needs are ignored when the 2hour block bell schedule was implemented there an exodus of students and when we lose students we lose teachers jobs every policy we we enact should be mindful of how it impacts not only our students but all the staff who work so hard to support them thank you thank you and thank you to your son for his forthcoming service that's awesome thank you um Elena hello by uh Carmen Shan good evening my name is Elena saan I have one child uh seventh grader in Middle School uh thank you for giving me the opportunity to share my thoughts um um I definitely
049support the of and Away policy with students uh cell phone I would like to express the need of Peace of Mind as parents currently having to be able to communicate with our children should there be an emergency or a natural disaster during school hours I know the school has policies to assure us parents uh are informed of their well-being of the students should there be a safety issue however in case of an emergency not knowing um immediately if your child is safe or not every minute feels like an eternity um I understand disciplinary actions against misuse of cell phones are um in place and I fully support those and I also feel like discussion at home on these consequences uh should happen uh lastly I would like to share my strong wish to avoid the
050Yonder bags in the future if that fits in thank you thank you Carmen followed by Amanda Martin hi my name is Carmen Shane I have a child in um this district and uh I am in support of off and away all day through High School uh I don't have a um beautifully prepared statement for you uh I just learned about this issue actually a few few days ago um but I do want to say that I'm passionate about um this issue and uh I wanted to make some comparisons in my opinion um and the research I've done through several different organizations um for an argument for off in away comparing it to uh a driver's license so for driver's licenses we need getting a driver's license is a milestone that signifies a person has reached
051a level of maturity and responsibility it's a privilege that comes with those rules and failure to follow those rules can lead to consequences and loing losing driving privileges of and Away policies similarly have a cell phone being a privilege that requires responsible use just as a license holder must be responsible on the road students must be responsible with their phones using them at appropriate times and places and not allowing them to distract from tasks at hand like learning um same with distraction and focus driver's license a driver must focus on the road and follow traffic laws avoiding distractions to ensure safety off and Away policy is the same just as driving requires full attention students need to be able to focus in class without a distraction of a cell phone a policy that demands phones
052be off and Away promotes an environment of concentration allowing students to be fully engaged in their learning um same with gradual privileges um I would like to say for the record that all the data shows that our that humans prefunctional cortexes are not fully formed until 25 how are we allowing and right now there's no regulation from government I truly believe in my heart that in 20 years this is going to be like smoking in a hospital this this issue um and so gra gradual privileges just like driving a car none of us want to give up our driver's licenses none of us want to give up our cars but would we give that with no training to Children um grad so again I will say the gradual privileges drivers licenses teenagers typically go through
053a graduated process before they learn the full rights and responsibilities of a driver they first have to get a learner's permit and then move to a full license once they prove they can handle the responsibility are do we have any of those regulations no um and so an off and Away policy is different than a Yonder bag that's what we're talking about today is an off and Away policy this is during class time um similarly some schools Implement a graduated use to cell phone use allowing phones at specific times or certain situations um increasing Freedom as students demonstrate they can use their devices responsibly I'm sorry but I've driven by Agora high school and I don't see the students using the phones responsibly um and that's all the time I have and um but thank
054you so much for your time thank you um Amanda Martin and I think Jacob sestrin is on Deck hi thank you um my name is Amanda Martin I have three students in the lvusd district I have a fourth grader at sumc elementary of a sixth grader at Lindero and an eighth grader at Lindero um I would just like to say that I'm a strong advocate for our off and Away Bell tobell policy from K through high school I believe this is a absolutely essential policy that we should adopt because I think the data is starting to become very clear that cell phone usage with children is detrimentally harmful to their social welfare their emotional well-being and their capacity to learn um I have seen from my own experience with my own three children none of
055them have really any good free control over um themselves when it comes to cell phone usage without heavy-handed monitoring by me my husband my family members and everyone when we tell them hey don't go off into that corner and look at your phone but they are allowed to have their phone and go off and do things they cannot control that themselves I think we are ignoring the addictive um Ness of cell phones and I actually think off in way is not enough I think we should revisit other options in addition to that like Yonder bags like a physical barrier to self phones I don't think that ignoring the addicted of cell phone usage with children is smart and it is making an assumption that they all have equal ability to self-regulate which we know that
056every child's brain does not have the equal ability to self-regulate itself when told what to do and what the consequences are one out of five kids will not be able to do and take that instruction on their own if you allow them to have their phones in their pocket and say don't look at it you allowed to have this all day long but don't look at it here are the four things that will happen to you if you do one out of five of those children maybe even even greater will not be able to take that instruction and limit themselves from actually looking at it um I know that from experience being a mother of three and I think that we should revisit Yonder bags we should revisit any kind of solution that is a
057barrier to them having a phone on their body all day long and US requiring them to have the onus entirety of responsibility of making that choice do I look at it or do I not I'd like to ask you in this room what adult in this room has had their cell phone in their pocket for eight hours ever and not looked at it not answered a ping not answered a phone call have you ever even challenged yourself to do that if you have it why are we expecting our children to be able to make those decisions why are we not supporting them in a way we would support somebody you know who can't make those decisions on their own we have rules for alcohol we have R rules for Narcotics because we know that not
058every adult when you tell them if you drink this much if you take these drugs will be able to make those decisions right time thank you thank you very much Jacob followed by an K I think I got that right can I begin all right good evening my name is Jacob saen I'm currently a sophomore adore high school we all Rec we all recognize that phones can be a disruptive and detrimental influence on academic experience but the benefits of maintaining access to our phones clearly outweigh the costs access to cell phones is also an integral part of our educational experience we use them regularly for research and access to lesson plans from our teachers in this regard this band will not only harm students but also impact how teachers communicate with their students and run
059their classrooms students also use their phones to notify their fellow students of upcoming events and Club activities which are vital to building and maintain buil to building and maintaining a strong student Community we also need to we also need phones to maintain a vital link of communication to parents especially in a case of emergency additionally middle and high school are meant to prepare PR students for college and adult life during this period of a person's life they learn important skills for the future including study skills and time management phone usage plays into both of these things and not exactly in a positive light however it also gives students the opportunity to learn and manage their time properly and avoid other distractions an outright ban on phones would make it much more difficult for students to
060learn these skills when they're in an environment where there few consequences for their mistakes I understand this intention for the restriction and comes from a place of concern for student well-being and also in academic success but a blanket prohibition on cell phone will cause even more problems than Solutions I'm not equating the band with a Prohibition area but I think we all know I think we all know students we're agile Nimble and resilient we'll also develop eventual workarounds for the band that may prove to be more disruptive and harmful than any current negative influence the misuse of phones presents in our academic world in that light I strongly encourage you to reject this new bound cell phones thank you for your time consideration uh and Carrie I believe and then carlay I'm sorry followed by
061uh Julie fan hi my name is Anne carlay I'm a licensed clinical social worker I have a private practice in the area I'm also a college lecturer and I'm a mother of two young kids um I want to thank the board for taking the time to listen to these many many many comments uh I am here to discuss my support for an off andway cell phone policy through high school um I do want to start off by acknowledging how incredibly anxiety provoking this topic is for parents um and for and for students and for children um and what anxiety can do is it can close us off it makes us inflexible or scared um and it makes us not want to listen to ideas that challenge our strongly held beliefs um which in this case
062is this idea that we need constant contact and access to our children um we've decided that phones and access and our constant contact with children somehow keeps them safe or makes our lives easier um when in reality it just makes them and us more anxious and less capable and less safe um I think we all want to think of ourselves as open flexible people who are trying to make decisions based on evidence and research and most importantly the best interest of our children I don't think any of us would identify as people who make decisions based more in our own personal anxieties and our children's anxieties than reality and facts I'm sure we can all agree that having smartphones in school is a major distraction to learning my husband's a high school teacher he comes
063home telling me about students watching movies during class buying concert tickets when they're supposed to be taking a test um you know and leaving it up to the teachers to to manage that is incredibly challenging um I know a lot of us are like oh that's not my child yes it is it's your child and it's us it is adults as well um a phone is simply too distracting and it was made to be addictive and made to be distracting it was designed with this in mind the creators of the iPhone send their kids to schools that don't allow phones they don't even give their children smartphones until they're adults um and I I hear a lot of the pros and I'm not one to say oh cell phones there's no there's no Pros but
064the cons to me far outweigh the pros we know that smartphones in school increase student loneliness bullying anxiety depression and rates of suicide schools without cell phones have reported less Cyberbully fewer fights improved attendance less cheating improved teacher morale and retention and a decrease in stress reported by kids to me this is far more important than me having constant access to my children let's choose a policy that actually keeps children safe not one that just gives us the illusion of safety let's enact an enforcable offin away phonefree policy through high school to address these issues and make our schools a Bastion of learning and safety and fun for our kids let's take the burden off the teachers in enforcing individual phone policies and let them focus on teaching let's do what many other local schools
065including ventur unified more Park unified Oaks Christian Harvard Westlake as well as states and countries I think Greece and Brazil just did this um have already done and let's be on The Cutting Edge of policy for our kids thank you for your time thank you Julie fan followed by Steve price good evening trustees faculty and fellow parents my name is Julie fruman I'm a licensed marriage and family therapist and in private practice and have spent the last decade working as a therapist to our community's youth and as many have mentioned tonight we are in the midst of a youth Mental Health crisis that sadly I have been witnessing up close and personal I'm here as an expert in the field of Youth mental health and I'm here as a parent even though my kids are
066in schools in CVUSD We Are One Community my daughter plays for Wags which you guys know is Westlake Agora girl softball my clients go to your schools my kids friends go to these schools I care about these kids and frankly I need these kids to be well because they're my kids peers this is a collective action issue and we need new Norms across our whole Community the research is Crystal Clear smartphones and compulsive media use are harmful to kids twins and teens many argue that they are not even beneficial for human flourishing this world where everyone is addicted to their phones has resulted in disrupted attention severed connection and has gone hand inand with a decline in learning outcomes additionally every hour over the American Academy of Pediatrics 2hour time limit increases one's chance of
067having depression anxiety Eating Disorders self harm and horrifyingly completed suicides this topic is serious screen time battles are wrecking havoc on homes and parents are trying to do things differently as a parent educator I work to empower parents to delay devices and social media to remove devices from bedrooms overnight and from playdates and hangouts but we need help from our schools it's our job to make new Norms in our homes and it's your job to help Foster a healthy culture in the schools we all got a smartphone free education even 10 to 15 years ago smartphones were used far less compulsively by all groups including students no one videoed and posted Us in drama or in PE we weren't worried about our privacy in school bathrooms we got six hours a day away from our
068parents which I would argue is a really good thing while we can't go back in time we can do again what Anne said what Oaks Christian milin Harvard West Lake Viewpoint all of La USD and many campuses are doing as well we can do so much more our kids deserve a full off andway school day putting phones and hanging bags on the back of classroom doors doesn't allow for the brain to reset and it just results in kids having a catchup period of scrolling while they're changing classes and eating lunch if you have taken the time to visit schools all around us with a true off andway policy at lunch and then schools without you will undoubtedly know what is best for lvusd schools and you don't even have to visit the schools to know
069you know that this is the right thing so do the right thing the majority of parents truly will applaud you but honestly even if they didn't your job is to pass the best possible policies for these schools and I beg of you to do your part thank you thank you Steve price followed by Tara manard yeah hello good evening uh Phil for each and every one of you understand this is somewhat like a foot loose type of topic where we're gonna have very divided opinions You Can Dance go ahead um right right we need to find the county line in this argument so from my perspective and I was originally going to come here to talk about locking up phones right little little concerned about that I had a prepared statement I don't have a
070prepared statement because based off president Lawrence's comments I realize that's not what's being discussed potentially being voted on it's it's not locking up the phone it's coming up with what I think is reasonable policy which is to say if you're k through eight phone don't really have a place in school but I think what I've heard and the most compelling Arguments for me so far have really been about with the teachers with the counselor saying come and learn what it is that we do find out the support we need to enforce the current policies we have because the current policies sound like the right policies and as a parent of a senior and a sophomore in high school I understand when you have younger kids you want them to have as little screen time as
071possible because they're not capable of understanding where they're going on the interwebs um but from a high schooler standpoint and I think a couple of the younger students have even mentioned this this is where they need to learn the skill if they don't learn it in high school what do they do once they complete High School is it in college is it at a job where they're staring at a phone not understanding how to regulate and they have to get fired a few times or they get in trouble with a professor and so what I would just implore this group to do is to listen to I think it was a Calabasas C counselor attend some of these schools see how the kids are actually operating but but equally important get feedback from those who
072are responsible for actually deploying these policies it's important that you understand what tools they need to be successful and I think if we do all of that the kids will end up in a much better place and they'll learn how to use these devices more appropriately thank you thank you uh teram followed by Lauren Brun uh good evening Mr President members of the board and cabinet my name is Tara Maynard and I'm parent of a junior and freshman at Agora high school as well as a sixth grader at Lindero Canyon Middle School I am former president of Willow PFA and Lindero King and PFC and I also co-chaired the measure s campaign I'm here tonight to share my concerns about the proposed cell phone policy it's important to recognize that a cell phone policy should
073not be a one size fits-all plan Elementary School students are at a very different developmental level than middle school or high school students high schoolers are emerging adults and some are already legal adults should they really be subject to the same cell phone rules as a four-year-old for high school students cell phones are essential tools for managing their responsibilities my teenagers have jobs and sports with everchanging schedules they need the ability to communicate with their coaches and employers at appropriate times nutrition and lunch are the perfect opportunities for these communications restricting access to phones even during these unstructured unstructured times challenges them to break the rules which is counterproductive to building trust and responsibility I also want my children to feel like school is a place they want to be even during their downtime right
074now my junior often chooses to stay on campus during lunch to attend club meetings or hang out with friends however if a bell-to-bell off and Away cell phone POC is enforced I'm concerned students will choose to leave campus whenever possible pushing them into parking lots parks nearby neighborhoods or businesses simply to use their phones even within my own household my children have different rules and allowances when it comes to their phones if a one-size fits-all policy doesn't work for a single family how can we expect it to work for an entire district with students ranging from 4 years old to 18 or older I urge you to consider a more flexible and develop L appropriate approach to the cell phone policy one that recognizes the unique needs of students at each stage of their educational
075Journey thank you for your time and thoughtful consideration thank you luren Brun followed by John Crest hi I'm actually Laurel burn that's okay um good evening Mr President and board parents Educators students I am an Agora High parent formerly of Lindero Middle School PFC and Willow PFA I was also the talent show coordinator so a lot of your kids know me as that talent show lady when I was a sophomore in high school I came home with a copy of The Catcher in the Ry I think most kids at this point read Catcher And The Rye when they are 15 like Holden Caulfield the classic anti-hero of the book my mother saw a copy of the book and said thank goodness you get to read it when you are 15 just like Holden as it
076should be I asked her didn't you read it in high school and she said no in 1958 when she was 15 she had to wait until College because the catcher and the Ry was a band book but by 1988 when I was a sophomore more it was okay we read it we discussed it and we had evolved because we learned how to adapt with as we have these open discussions about cell phones with students and parents and Educators and community members and leaders let's consider the many factors student health is number one Student Success is another and we are in a unique position as parents and educators to raise and lead and teach our children not in Banning not in controlling but in learning digital literacy digital health and digital courtesy while we decide if
077students should have access during nutrition and lunch in high school obviously of and Away during class is important we must recognize that education around devices is as important as any other facet of this discussion as I understand it we currently do not have a digital educational approach phones are still new Boomers and Gen X and Millennials didn't have digital access like gen Z does so our challenge is as much about learning and teaching and parents too we could be Trailblazers in this teaching our children appropriate use use and misuse of devices addiction as well to use them resourcefully respectfully let's give us all a chance to evolve let's really test the off and Away in class while letting our students learn appropriate use of these devices thank you thank you Joan CR by Darcy Miller
078if you have not filled out a yellow speaker card and you wish to speak if you could fill one out please thank you no of course you can of course you can of course you can we wrote a joint statement because it's longer than three minutes so hi my name is Darcy Miller I'm a teacher at AE R Middle School I'm sorry okay do you want to use this do you want to have the time go you you want to have the time go together so we give you more than three minutes that we were asking for the two sure okay is that okay or we could do three minutes and then she can finish it yeah go ahead okay hi again Darcy Miller um I'm the president of the Los virgines Educators Association this
079is Joanne Crest she's a parent and a teacher at White Oak Elementary and the chair of our bargaining um Team here so we're here today to express our frustration with the disappointing um the disappointing addition to the approval of visions of the board policy so we specifically want to talk about three issues one the lack of collaboration with the board the community it represents and the Educators who serve the District Two the inclusion of high schools in the policy requiring off and way to be for the entire day and three the addition of language stating that teachers must seek their principal's permission before allowing smart use Smart devices Ed in their classroom so first let's talk about the lack of collaboration so at the January 14th school board meeting we heard heartfelt comments from families
080and students particularly about concerns with middle schools and the cell phone use naively we believed that the board would listen reconsider and return to the drawing board with stakeholders that's include that includes parents Educators and students we wanted to make sure that um the new policy would align with all parties best interests unfortunately in of collaboration what continued to happen was a top- down decisionmaking process sending an email to PFC presidents to clarified the board's stance is not the same as seeking input statements made at the last board meeting about the policy being discussed at various meetings including the safety and wellness committee were misleading the minutes cited in support of this claim are not available to public on the lvsd website discussing an issue on the day does not equate to collabor ation nor
081has this ever been the standard practice for lost lost virist lvusd has always prided itself in a strong culture of collaboration this policy however lacks buyin from staff students and parents as Educators who have dedicated our career to serving children we can confidently say that this culture shift the board is seeking will not occur without genuine collaboration change cannot happen through top down mandates now the inclusion of high schools what has changed since the last board meeting to Warrant the expanding and off and Away have board members tour our high schools during the school day to observe what's happening on campus where's the data showing that the existing offin away policy during class time is not working no such data has been presented and it's troubling that the significant policy shift is being made without
082concrete evidence or meaningful research without these critical pieces of information it's hard to understand how such an addition to the policy can be justified feels rushed and unsupported by the realities in our schools look at that third we find it insulting to add language about our teacher professionalism the addition to this proposed language is particularly insulting I'll quote what's in the agenda tonight the board encourages teachers to permit students to use Smart devices in the class CL room only one essential and no other means of technology is available it is the board's preference that teachers seek the principal's permission prior to permitting students to use Smart devices in the classroom this language is unnecessary and shows a lack of trust in the professionalism of our Educators we are trained professionals who work with our students
083daily we understand how to use technology how to enhance learning when it's appropriate and manage its use effectively it's also our job to help our students know when it is appropriate and responsible perhaps this language would be less offensive if board members spent time in our schools during the school day to see firsthand how we teach and how students learn however as of now all board members have not done so reading books on Theory or searching for studies to support a particular stance does not compare to observing real classrooms and real students here in Las virgines historically the strength of the relationship between Educators and the school board has been our ability to work collaboratively for the greater good of students this proposed language undermines that relationship and diminishes the expertise of our Educators our
084final thoughts it might sound like we are repeating ourselves from last time but Las virgous Educators Association urges the board to slow down we currently have a policy in place that is working please give it time no empirical data suggests that it is failing why are we rushing to implement changes that lack broad support clear evidence or collaboration thank you for your time and considering our concern we'll go to uh shellene Martin Martin followed by Nicole Cullen good evening Mr President board members and cabinet my name is shellene Martin I am the proud pres uh parent of a sixth grader lcms and a ninth grader at Oak Park High School I'm also currently serving on Lindero PFC board and I'm an alumni of Lindero and Agora High School clearly we didn't have that problem then
085thank you for the opportunity to speak to you today about the proposed off andway cell phone policy for our high school I firmly believe that cell phone Management in schools is critical to fostering academic success and minimizing distractions however I urge us to consider it a balanced approach while the evidence supports cell phone restrictions in classrooms there are also compelling research and practical reasoning for allowing students to use their phones during breaks or transitions adolescence is a time when students are developing self-regulation skills and highly rigid policies May stifle their ability to demonstrate responsible decision-making strict off andway policies risk sending the message that we don't trust our students to be reasonable High School is critical period for PR preparing young people to manage their time technology and responsibilities when we provide structured opportunities for
086phone use such as lunches or breaks it demonstrates that we see the as capable young adults this trust can turn and bolster their willingness to adhere to rules I urge the board to consider a balanced off andway policy that restricts phone use during instructional time but permits access during transitions lunches and breaks by doing so we can achieve the Dual goals of minimizing distractions and fostering trust and responsibility in our students such a policy recognizes the reality ities of modern adolescence and and prioritizing academic success and wellbeing thank you up next Nicole Cullen followed by Amanda pulos good evening Mr President board members and cabinet my name is Nicole Cullen and I have two children attending lvd schools in the fifth and eth grades my son will be going into high school next year I
087am currently a co-president for the Lindero Canyon Middle School PFC I understand that this evening you will be voting to approve revisions to board policy relating to mobile communication devices I've reviewed the new language that is being considered and I'm here to urge you to change the phrase secured in a manner and device determined by the district before adopting the revisions I speak for many parents when I say that I take issue with the two words and device although device doesn't explicitly mean Yonder bags or cell phone lockers it potentially could allow the use of those tools which concerns many parents in these times of natural emergencies sorry like woy Palisades and Kenneth fires remove that language give the policy of off and Away a real chance at our schools and revisit the need for
088that language down the road if it is deemed that stricter policies for phones are necessary I'm not a good public speaker no you're doing great you're doing great I have been asked thank you by many Lindero parents whether we are still going to be the pilot program for Yonder bags this year to be honest I heard the question asked in the last meeting two weeks ago but I didn't hear an answer can we please have a clear answer on that tonight parents have said that they would like to have more more of a town hall discussion on this subject so that questions can be asked and answered I encourage you to host a few at different times and days of the week um as week weekday evenings are not always feasible for some parents also
089pull the parents pull the students visit our schools not just charter schools and see how often away is working um as parents we all under understand the issues of social media addiction and brain development ET Etc based on this information as parents we can allow or restrict access to certain apps and websites we can set screen time limits for overall phone use or even dial it down to limits for specific apps we can discuss these limitations with our children and explain to them our concerns from the data that this that is emerging uh hopefully helping them to understand the importance of self- Regulation off and Away during instructional time so that our students can have distraction-free learning environment is a solid policy but Banning phones during lunch and nutrition or from Bell to Bell feels
090punitive that is their free time that is not instructional time some students need to communicate with coaches or buses for after school jobs for the policy language you are considering tonight that relates to high school students I urge you to add wording that allows them to use their phones or devices during lunch and nutrition not of and Away Bel B like the younger elementary students thank you thank you thank you Amanda pulos followed by Kya farore good evening Mr President board members of cabinet my name is Amanda pulos I'm a parent of a freshman at agor High and a fifth grader at Willow uh you probably know me I've done all the things volunteer here volunteer there that's me that's me I'm there all the time um I'm speaking just a high school policy I'm
091all for off and away for K through 8 and it does does have a nice little rhyme so feel like should we Market it that way um I completely understand the desire to reduce phone use among students I struggle with it myself as a parent at times but ultimately that is my challenge for my family to address not the school district I believe it is the districts is overreaching and its efforts to restrict cell phone use data from schools with high front hybrid phone policies where phones are allowed during non-class Times show that students are more like to comply with restrictions during instructional hours when they know they have a designated time for access this approach Fosters a sense of mutual respect and trust between students and staff additionally students already have access to social
092media and text messaging on their school provided computers by Banning phones entirely what are we really taking away instead students might end up using their computers during class time or during their offtime leaving campus is for no essential reason um I urge you to consider a balanced approach that addresses the concerns of phone use while still respecting students Independence and their ability to self-regulate during appropriate times since I have some time I'm going to go a little rogue and just say until you have a freshman a sophomore or a junior you just don't know you don't know and I see these kids and they are totally they got this you got this they can do it they can put it down they can stop the four-year-old the 5-year-old six yeah no no bueno but for
093them they got this so that's my [Music] speech uh Kimia uh followed by Grace fiser hello everyone um I'm not very good at public speaking but I'll try my best my name is Kim fatur and I'm a freshman at Agora high school and um I truly believe that I agree for the off and away for k through eight but I don't agree for high schoolers um we first of all we recently just changed the policy and I think we still need some time to adjust to it I know all of the students speaking for the student body that we all are very like still adjusting to it and another thing is that um as I was just last year in middle school and I had I'll be honest here I had the urge to go
094on my phone more when it was full off and away from Bell to Bell than I do now and that's really difficult because after I finish High School what will happen in college when I get it or when I get a job or anything like that I would need to learn the responsibilities of having a phone and just in this semester alone I've already I I could can recognize myself and my habits with my phone have changed greatly and I've truly learned to not be addicted to it because I will be honest phones are very addicting because a lot of things can be addicting but I truly believe that there are more severe issues in schools than just cell phones like I have witnessed things at our schools that nobody not a lot of people
095know about and it's traumatized in truly like there are severe stuff going on that the board members don't know about because they I've never seen a board member ever come to our school once to even talk to us or see how things are running and I've spoken with multiple teachers and multiple staff and they truly believe that the board is moving too quickly with these decisions and that we need to slow it down and we truly need to let things happen and actually give time to see how this new policy is working and what the data is going to show from just having this and um I really don't have much to say I W I wasn't I didn't have anything prepared because I was supposed to speak on Yonder bxs I prefer for that
096um so you did great thank you I'm just I'm just trying to Freestyle it right now but um yeah so I just think that we need to give it more time and we really need to have more data and we need more board members to come into our school and see firsthand because I understand all of you are parents and I truly respect your viewpoint but it's completely different from what actually happens at school and you you you wouldn't believe how different it is from what your students come home and tell you to what actually is happening so um thank you for listening and um have a good night everyone Grace Fischer and then Mike Hazen hello L USD Bor um so I actually want to thank you for proactively taking a science-based approach to
097the cell phone policy at last summer um when I heard about a lot of the recent research that had come out and what La UniFi had done I was like thank God our district is on board with science um I agree that students should not have access to cell phones during the school day and I have also closely examined cell phone use after school hours that of other um screens as well based on the recent research I have three children in this District I have boy girl twins and seventh grade at a right and a first grader at zmac I was also a former PFC president at cherel again firsthand how cell phones and technology can disrupt learning behavior and social interaction when my twins first started at a right I like many parents gave
098them a cell phone in order to communicate with them on a daily basis of who was picking them up they'd be taking the bus I wanted to be able to reach them so I know what that feels like but this is selfish convenience for parents okay I'm sorry selfish convenience I've since I gave my son a cell phone we saw such drastic changes in his behavior that I ultimately took it away um my son has ADHD he's also very intelligent and maybe some of these qualities and him being a boy actually make this cell phone and Technology particularly more harmful and attractive we all know ADHD brains crave that dopamine fix with the interactive technology and device these kids are also highly impulsive they have less abilities to self-regulate um and because he's so smart
099he was able to quickly overcome every single obstacle I threw out him the passwords the restrictions the blocking my sweet son quickly started to lie and deceive in order to get more and more access to his phone additionally he would hide in his room I felt him withdraw from the family and he spent more and more time on his phone and on his school provided computer and less time with our family um in school he started missing assignments and getting in trouble with his teachers not for cell phone use at school actually which was great but from his school provided laptop which he was able able to play video games on um perhaps this is more of an issue for children with ADHD but however with the rise in the diagnosis of this disorder are
100questions arise as to how much this actually may be caused by what they are calling the great rewiring and also I'm just really curious if our schools should be giving children who already have an academic disadvantage in the classroom a device which that puts them at an even greater disadvantage for learning um so this is somewhat of a different issue but as while we're on the topic I don't think that we can evaluate the cell phone policy while simultaneously not evaluating all the technology that's being used currently for edtech purposes um I know that our district is a onetoone and we all thought that was the best way about time time up sorry you finish up two more things okay so that's just one Divergent request is to evaluate the onetoone thing I just want
101to say we have to respect the learning environment of our teachers I cannot imagine like we want to text our kids during the school day but I cannot imagine like walking into my kids elementary school classroom and being like hey Timmy I'm gonna pick you up at the gate today instead of coming in later I mean you just wouldn't do that so you shouldn't do that with text message thank you very much uh Mike Mike Hazen followed by Leanne Willet hey Bard hey everyone hey everyone thanks for coming out I'm very impressed with uh with all the students here high school students uh my name is Mike Hazen I'm a parent a graduate of uh lvusd as well um I have a eighth grader Lindero and a second grader at Willow um I honestly am
102a big fan of the off andway policy I didn't realize that we were going K through 12 until very recently initially I knew it was a k through eight topic and highly highly uh I'm a proponent of the k through eight excuse me I believe that there's a added element that is not being spoken about enough and that is the education of the younger kids about cell phone usage and safety and and how to properly operate them um these sixth graders fifth graders fourth graders whatever they're given a cell phone and it's just the wild west for them and they don't know how to use them so we're talking about all these terrible neuro you know issues and neurological issues and and psych psychologic issues but we're not talking about how we can actually teach
103them responsibly to use the devices we're just sort of like throwing it all at them right now and saying hey don't use them and I believe like we all say a balanced approach is important however K through 8 there really is no reason to have them in their hands during the middle of the the school day it's just not necessary the safety issue some of the parents complaining about oh I need to get in touch with my kid with there's an emergency you dropped your second grader off at school for the whole day without having access to a cell phone they were fine right so we're okay we're going to make it um but I really do implore the board to talk about how can we educate the kids maybe in sixth grade of how
104to properly use these devices how to put them aside when you're having a conversation with somebody how to you know manage and use the tools on them use the the timer on there to to time block and and manage your time a little bit better but uh not just lock them up and say goodbye to them and and we're not talking about that we're not talking about a full-on band I like the Foot Loose reference we're not talking about banning dancing you know in the city we're talking about allowing it not to happen not allowing it to happen during school hours it's okay we can survive right I feel my phone buzzing right now it's time for me to go um but that's it that's all I'll say thank you guys appreciate it uh lean
105Willet and then uh Jody mcneel on Deck hi guys um I just want to say that we're all in agreement the kids should not be on their phones during school time so I think it's a bit of a Mot point that we all talk about statistics for mental health with the phone because that's not what we're really discussing we all completely everyone in this room agrees I think the real topic is how we handle the off and Away rule efficiently and how the board plans to implement it so I'm just a little concerned about the um the board policies wording particularly the phrase in a manner and device determined by the district so while the goal of keeping kids off their phones is really clear this wording doesn't provide Clarity on what specific measures or
106methods will be used to enforce it without that crucial detail it becomes really difficult for anyone to make an informed decision or vote confidently transparency on how this will be implemented is essentially is essential for moving forward it's impossible to make an informed decision without a clear understanding of what has been proposed and how it's going to be implemented um I have a lot of other things to say but I'm not going to say them um I just basically my biggest thing that I really want to emphasize is that I really am truly here for the teachers and they're the ones on the front lines they're your boots on the ground and they're your voice in the classroom and ignoring any insights and going against what they believe is best for their students feels really
107counterproductive and I hope that it's not going to be disappointing and that you listen to them thank you thank you who it Jord mcneel right all right and then uh uh Devin Aaron our ASB president on Deck hi my name is Jody mcneel I have three daughters and lvusd two fifth graders and a seventh grader my fifth graders do not have phones and my seventh grader just recently got one but she has zero social media and the reason this is the case is because I was fortunate enough to be educated on how bad cell phone use is for kids and social media when they were younger but I feel privileged that I had that a knowledge and my kids have been away from that I feel like that's lacking in the district and with my
108friends and parents and that's what I think needs to change is you need to understand that there we can put a Band-Aid of a Yonder bag we could put even a Band-Aid of the off and away which I think I strongly think off and away is great and I also think it can teach some type of social responsibility because just because you take these phones away doesn't mean they're we want to teach enable our children how to use them in the future because they're not going away it's a part of our life but with that being said it's really important two things on the communication part one I've heard from multiple parents half the people don't even know these meetings exist half of them don't know what's going on or being talked about which I
109think that needs to improve number one number two the education of what's going on with the data with the studies all of my friends that I asked do you know what this is going on oh yeah they're bad no do you know how bad it is it's really bad my husband is an emergency room physician and he does see girls who do self harm he's in Beverly Hills at Cedars he's also in oxar and Camaro and at different locations and variations it's an education you see it more or less I think it's important for us as a community to teach the stud students and the and the parents how bad cell phone use is in a responsible way so they can learn to do it when the bell rings at 3:05 and they can turn
110on their cell phone or unlock the Yonder bag then they can still be responsible I also think it's really important that we go back to the good old days of soda drugs and they had a speaker come to our school and have the frying pan the egg mentality that stuck with me I honestly was scared to death because Nancy Reagan went Non-Stop about say not to drugs now I think that needs to come back into our school system that would be revolutionary I think if LV usds had speakers and maybe a slogan off and away every day woohoo something you know and then really back it up with the facts of how bad it is to have the cell phones and then I do think it's really important to respect the community and let us
111know what's going on in the school board perhaps with um a flyer I also think it's important to listen to the teachers the ones on the boots in the ground God love you teachers I could never do what you do I salute you and then um I had one little point I think I just lost it come on Jody it was H what was it just I really think we should listen to our students and our teachers and educate and give everyone to do a book report on the anxious generation both sides both sides of the table both sides thank you um Devin Aaron and then on Deck um Ain Gordon Mr President members of the board I am Devon Aaron senior and student body president of Calabasas high after much much deliberation among my
112classmates and understanding the full scope of this issue by speaking with teachers School administrators District leadership and surrounding schools I hereby stand before you firmly against a new mobile device policy the current offin away policy at cbas is working under this policy students are not permitted to use phones in the classroom and while teachers enforce this policy they have the discretion to allow students to use their phones for if necessary for learning this gives Educators the flexibility the flexibility they need while teaching students have how to use their devices responsibly I fully support the idea of disconnecting from phones while in the classroom we are there to learn focus and engage with our teachers and peers however when we step outside of the classroom it's our break lunch is not instructional time these moments are
113ours to recharge connect with friends and prepare for the rest of the day phones play a huge role in that whether we're checking in with family coordinating carpool plans scanning QR codes for campus activities or catching up on Club updates our phones help us stay connected and informed this year I implemented the fstar student engagement app which 96.6% of students have downloaded five star is now the main source of identification in the morning scanning release periods throughout the day and signing up for Teacher support since it's launched we've seen tangible results increased School attendance more student participation and an overall boost in engagement phones have been critical to that success Banning phones during breaks would negatively impact student engagement make it harder to stay informed about school events disrupt the balance we've created with the
114off andway policy and undoubtedly decrease enrollment within our schools during passing periods or lunch when students are spread ACR across campus having access to phones could make a difference in responding to a crisis in addition if the board leaves the door open for Yonder the fiscal impact is significant it at approximately $54,000 per school just for the pouches and the funds needed for more campus supervisors this seems to be an unnecessary purchase down the road if these funds can be reallocated to reduce class sizes that are up to 40 students and school buildings and equipment that needs to be updated however my biggest concern is College and Career Readiness I have served on both our elcap committee and School site Council and we often emphasize preparing students for success in the real world in college
115and professional settings phones are tools for networking staying organized and communicating effectively Banning mobile devices during breaks takes away opportunities for students to practice these practice these skills now prep leaving them later prepared for nothing in for nothing after high school we are no longer middle school students many of us have jobs drive cars and can even enlist in the military we are at a point in our lives where trust is essential trust us to use our personal devices responsibly during non-instructional times this statement I just shared is on behalf of 1,701 student of Calabasas high school and was unanimous unanimously approved by the 32 Associated student body Representatives thank you for your time thank you are you Ain yeah Y and Then followed by Charlotte Meyer Mr President and members of the board I
116am Ain Gordon ASB vice president of calabas is high I'm here today to explain the context of Devon's statement and the document passed out before you the Calabasas ASB executive board compiled a list of beneficial usage of cell phones in high school during non-instructional time and negative impacts of restricting cell phones use during non-instructional time we would greatly appreciate it if you would thoroughly review our arguments at this moment I would like to focus on our LC cap goals in his statement Devon highlighted College and Career Readiness now I would like to draw your attention to goal number three whole child while we can appreciate the arguments regarding cyberbullying and social interaction we cannot ignore the tools that cell phones present in mitigating stress cell phones act as a liaison between the students and their
117outside support system whether that be mental health apps like calm or better help contacting a trusted adult or connecting to the suicide hotline as outlined on the back of our student IDs and the five star app for another way of implementing this policy another way that implementing this policy would adversely affect the student body is by violating the family educational rights and privacy act this protects the rights of this protects the students rights for our students with I APS or five of four plans allowing them to use their personal devices without limitation this would highlight them as an outlier thereby violating their confidentiality ultimately we respect the position of the board however Devon and I are disappointed that no one came to discuss off in away Bel with Representatives at calabases high school as we
118believe that rules and policies are more effective when they are agreed upon collaboratively we hope that you will take our perspective in into account and I would like to add off the script that we would allow we would like for you to allow us our autonomy and Independence the the principles that were outlined in our curriculum and that you taught to us by allowing us the responsibility to by allowing us the ability to be responsible thank you so much for your consideration carlot Meer followed by Nicole Perkin readings um I retired from the school board after eight years of service in the year 2001 um this is the first time I'm speaking in this capacity down here um I've had a chance to listen to all the speakers this evening and I've come to some
119conclusions based on some generalizations the first thing generally speaking the K througha parents children with K througha students have a point of view it is their point of view based on their experiences raising these young children the high school parents have a different point of view because their experiences include being parents of e8th grade K through e8th grade students but have now been expanded to understand the needs of their high school students as a grandmother of four grandchildren I have the unique experience of having these children hang out at my house I have two high school students hanging out in my house and I have a middle school and an elementary school student student hanging out at my house I can say with a little bit of understanding of what their challenges are that the
120needs of the middle school students Middle School student and the K and the fourth grade student are different than what the high school students need so passing policy one size fits all would be incompatible with the experiences I've observed thank you thanks you haven't filled out a card you want to speak please do so and get that turned in uh Nicole Perkin you're up followed by Karen I think it's Speen Spar yeah good evening Mr President board members and cabinet members my name is Nicole Perkin and I am currently one of the co- PFC presidents at chapperal elementary I have two children in the fourth and second grade just to State the obvious everything I'm saying tonight is my own personal opinion I'm here today to express my support for off and Away throughout the
121school day at a high school level as well as continuation of the policy at middle and elementary schools I would support something further than off in away but I understand that's not where the district is now but I do want to make one important Point I've listened to a fair amount of the meeting the last meeting and I think it's important that the board note that we cannot equate all of the opposition that you heard to the Yonder bag policy to be opposition for off and away well I know that you're hearing many different sides of the uh story and the viewpoints tonight opposition to Yonder bags does not automatically equate to opposition to off and Away throughout all School levels while I don't have high school age children I quickly observing the impact that
122phones have on our children when one girl in a group of 10-year-old girls with my daughter has a phone it becomes all consuming you cannot get through to these girls to get them to even pose for a picture something that most 10-year-old girls love to do I am hope that in speaking to you as a parent of younger children I can tell you that many of my friends who only have Elementary age students also feel the same way that I do we hope that as Jonathan hate suggests in the Ancients generation that we are at a Tipping Point in terms of recognizing the detrimental effects that cell phone use is having throughout our children and every age and we hope that we may be able to implement a change moving forward in watching the video
123from the last meeting I heard a number of concerns about safety and emergencies and I've continued to hear that tonight well of course emotion as a parent tells me that yes it's nice to have that Lifeline to your child in an emergency I can think of nothing else that I would want other than their safety than to know in the moment that they're safe but logic tells me that that can change in a heartbeat and in those moments they need to be listening to teachers they need to be listening to other Personnel who I trust to be telling them what to do safety experts will tell us that in those moments of emergencies seconds matter and I don't want them to be distracted by texting me while I commend all of the students who have
124spoken tonight and they have done an amazing job I want to give you a second consideration there are we really going to have self-reporting from students about how problematic the school the cell phone uses at school I would suggest no and so I support off and Away throughout um all levels of school thank you Ken Speen followed by Benjamin seagull good evening thanks for having us here today um I wanted to bring my name is Karen sparen I am a substitute teacher in the district and I wanted to give a little bit of um uh interesting share observation that i' had made um I'm also a parent I have three daughters in the district as well and um I wanted to share just an observation that I had while I was subbing I was subbing
125at the high school and I happened to be um in a classroom with another teacher and it was during their block schedule so it was like a long class period and they had they were given a five or 10 minute break and I was alarmed to notice that every one of them picked out took out their cell phone and started scrolling on their phone and like laughing to themselves and texting their friends or whoever but nobody interacted with each other at all and I was really caught off guard it was really shocking to me that in a very social environment where you're given a break from your school work that you they would choose to like scroll scroll on their phone and some some watched videos some texted but like nobody was interacting in person
126and I feel like so much of why we send our kids to school is for the social emotional interaction and I feel like that's super important I think that you know I'm I'm worried about the kids that are not here like the kids that did that spoke today did such an amazing job and I'm very very impressed um but I I'm worried about some of the other ones that are not as proactive about their like social they don't have like a budding social life that school is it for them and I really want them to have these interactions even like uh just proximity based like interactions with people I think are super important at that age um I also wanted to share that um I when I generally when I go into a classroom I
127follow the teachers policies for all the things and I have found that you know when I when teachers have a policy that if you need to go to the bathroom you have to turn your phone in um and I just it sits on the desk that you know when I go to enforce it some of the kids are like I don't have to go anymore and it's it's you know fun but it's also like kind of disappointing to see that some of these kids like have to go to the bathroom and you know they don't actually have to go and so um you know I I trust teachers like Miss Miller who I know my my daughter goes to a right and I know that um kids are not messing with that like she's very
128like she uses technology in her classroom in a very I you know I've subbed her class like she uses technology in a way that really enhances the experience and um I trust that um but I I I'm more concerned about the um the like break time that I want the kids to be interacting with each other and um to be socializing even if it isn't like the you know really social kids I really am worried about kind of some of the kids that are a little bit more lonely and so I didn't want you to go to vote without having that unique perspective shared so thank you for having me thank you very much Benjamin seagull followed by Matt gel good evening members of the board my name is sorry my name is Benjamin seagull
129and I'm a junior at Agora high school and also a member of agora's ASB let me tell you something right off the bat the current policy that we have now is working by limiting phone usage in the classroom it allows us for a focus on academics and has also personally helped me with my academics it allows oh sorry however outside the classroom during nutrition lunch times and passing periods uses of cellular devices uh being limited or completely revoked simply does not make sense for high school age students lunch lunch and nutrition are students break times uh sorry therefore limitate yeah I already said that our break time should be our break time and being allowed to use our personal cellular devices during this time should be our choice I compel members of the board to
130actually visit our classrooms and see the changes that the original policy has brought however a complete blockage of phones during breaks shows students that there's not only a distrust of them by the adults in charge of this District but also a blockage of our confidentiality and autonomy as young adults this new policy would not allow for us to self-regulate let me put it this way I'm 17 and next year or sorry I'm actually about to turn 17 and next year I'll will be turning 18 I've held numerous jobs including places of Health Care and I can confidently say that I have been allowed during my breaks times at those important places to be able to utilize my phone again let me put this another way imagine 16 17 and 18 year olds whose own personal
131phones cannot even be used during their allocated break times I believe this and I'll say this again our current system is working working in a new policy such as a complete ban on high school campuses is something that I don't believe is a smart decision or the solution I'd like to ask a question if we are focusing on mental health issues which I do believe phones can bring I'd like to ask members of the board and also anyone else who has commented about mental health to explain how outside of school or how sorry a one or two hour ban of foods foods of phon phones during that break time would allocate for the after school effects that phones could also bring lastly I'd like to point out another fact there are far better things to
132focus on besides a total cell phone ban for instance money if we're going to use Yonder bags or another form that's a lot of money that could be used for other things like Athletics at our school I'm a wrestler at my school and we're severely underfunded we've had to make funding from our parents to get to and from places I believe people at CHS have also had the same exact problem as well with some of their sports teams that's all I have to say thank you thank you very much I have Matt Gil followed by Brendan McClure well hello everyone it's a little little bit different speaking to you from down here I'm sure used to sitting up there but since I'm not up there today I still want to give a student perspective I
133know I won't be able to have that same back and forth but I'll try my best to um represent the students um even though I'm not on Das first things first I just want to say nobody from high school is opposed to off and away we are all definitely in support of it it is clearly working and we can see the impacts however and this is a big however we are against off way during breaks and the options for future restrictions a big thing that I've noticed is that we are looking to cater to the minority that small 5% of students who um might need that extra help however 95% of these students are um are being able to show that self-restraint and they are keeping their phones off and away when they should and
134for those 95% it's working I don't understand yes we should be um we should be supporting all students however when the majority of those student we should be supporting the majority of the students not that small minority off in away also works during instructional time 100% uh someone brought up when students go to the bathroom a lot of kids want to take their phones with them I believe that to help with that um with that mentality of your phones must be off and away we need to have better classroom enforcement we need to have it all comes down to classroom management teachers should be requiring students to leave their phones uh in the classroom while they go to the bathroom because I I know from experience that a lot of students will take their phones
135with them to go to the bathroom not to actually go to the bathroom but rather to use their phones once again classroom management teachers it's it's a responsibility of the district through these staff um development days for the district to say hey here's how teachers should be managing their classrooms when it comes to cell phone usage we don't need a new policy to tell um staff what to do we need education to tell staff what to do and that also goes to students as uh other parents were saying for younger grades and also for older grades and it also comes down to education for the parents cell phones should be a par a parental issue parents should have the right to determine whether or not students can use their phones during school um well parents
136should have the right to determine whether or not they have these these heavy restrictions I know from exper uh my brother actually um we he really struggles with his phone usage and I'm sorry if he watches this later on that I'm putting him on the spot but he really struggles with his phone um my parents have had to put on tons of screen time restrictions and he's been trying to bypass those and sometimes succeeds and that just requires further and further restrictions however that doesn't necessarily mean and not even necessarily that does not mean that the district should be putting these restrictions on on his phone my parents should be the ones who determine whether or not he's able to use his phone and able to use these certain applications the district should not um
137take away our phones throughout the day we should be able to use them during our breaks thank you thank you our last speaker unless we have any other cards will be Brendan McClure so I don't have a prepared statement uh I support the uh the Bell to Bell ban all the way through um and I think a lot of the points uh have been really well laid out uh by the speakers earlier today uh this evening I'd like to make one point though that hasn't been made which I think is really interesting and we're in a really privileged position to be able to have this data and that is that the the clinical data and the wellness data has come through we know about the challenges that students face and the the impacts these have
138but now what we're seeing is that many schools and many districts have implemented these bands and we're seeing immediately that the positive outcomes that you would associate with those bands are very very rapid and really quite pronounced but I think one of the important points is that those outcomes are being seen by the schools and districts that implement the full bands and and so if we're looking at this Choice ahead of us there's a lot of information that suggests that the full ban is what's going to result in the immediate benefits that you see by taking away phones and addressing some of those challenges that we see across people thank you so this time I think it's our last speaker sand Mone you want to come on up no other speaker cards this will be
139our last speaker h hello and I'm so sorry to put my card in last I really was hoping somebody would make the point I wanted to make so I wouldn't have to make it um but I am very impressed with all the speeches that everybody has given tonight I have nothing prepared I didn't even know I was going to speak until I got here because I speak to you as a parent of four in the district well three one future but I also speak to you with past experience I used to be a career counselor on the East Coast before I had kids I worked for 11 years at Stevens Institute Sean Hall University and Ruckers University all topped here engineering and Business Schools and I worked with college kids the kids were trying to
140prepare to go to college and I can tell you a lot about college kids uh first thing I can tell you that at the time I was working there was Megan or Ashley hands down those were their names I never go wrong and the other thing I could tell you is that they only about half of them knew how to look me in the eye only a good portion of them knew how to shake my hand so I really was taken aback by The Substitute Teacher I'm sorry I forgot your name when she spoke about that free time that they had and they didn't interact with each other because I went into the counseling field but my husband's a CFO and he talks about all the deals that he makes and stuff he doesn't make
141them in meetings he doesn't he makes them during dinners he makes them in the hallway when people are trying to catch his ears hey you got a second learning how to converse learning how to build that grit and that tenacity in Worlds is not only during the classroom time which is very important yes off and Away absolutely let's listen to our sees what a thought right but what about learning how to speak to our peers the ones we will be working with when we go to work the next day the ones we will be doing deals with I just and I know not every kid's going to college I got one that I'm like yeah you know we all do we all have that one right but he's gonna be fine because we have taught
142him how to ask for the check since he was a little kid we taught him that his cell phone the answers aren't there they're in somebody else's they're in his friends he knows how to socialize he also deals with anxiety and he's not going to get any better at that by looking at a screen so kind of to Grace Fisher's point about why kids in third and fourth grade need to come home with their computers to play Pokey and all those other little games that's another conversation I really just want you guys to think about it's not what we're taking away from them is what are we teaching them how are we teaching them to interact so if I don't know if Yonder bags or whatever the answer but I do believe that we it
143is time to educate our kids because they are anxious now now they are I I'm in the field and I'm dealing with it and I see it all around me people are so much more anxious than when our parents were are when we were in school and it is something that does need to be addressed now whatever you guys decide you should look look at the facts that right now it is an epidemic of anxiety mental health issues but also people that just don't know how to talk to each other so thank you for your time I'm sorry I was completely unprepared and I hope you have a great night thank you everybody uh Mr Lawrence yeah uh before we start our conversation can we take a five minute break because I need to go
144and check my phone yeah one more oh we do yeah Hannah stof hi thank you for letting me come and speak I'm doing this off nothing so excuse me if I mess up um my name is Hannah sof I'm a senior at calabassas high school I'm a part of the ASB class I am the um my God I forgot my title I'm my I'm the I'm in charge of spirit at school um so um sorry I'm a little nervous pep I'm pep commissioner oh my God I forgot my own title um but I want to speak to you on more of a personal note because you are hearing from a lot of people as from parents' perspectives but I'm a student that lives out of district and so I'm in charge of driving a carpool
145I'm in charge of three other students one at um acell middle school and two at Cal bass's high school and as a high schooler there's a lot of things that come up um out of the blue I'm also on a sports team which means that practices could get moved due to weather or other sports um restrictions so I need to be able to communicate with my carpool very quickly as long as they're parents because I am responsible for getting them home I access to my phone during the school day because I'm sorry but lunch and nutrition are nowhere close to the end so sometimes I need to do it during a fifth or a sixth period um so having that opportunity to do it during class and use my phone is necessary because I'm in
146charge of students well-being um as well as being the path commissioner um we have sta and increase in spirit with our five star check-in um and I want love to see it because that's what I do but um without festar checkin last year if you came to our schools which I don't think you guys have come to our schools in the first place um but you don't see a lot of spirit and having this checkin method when they get rewards from five stars improved our school spirit and I think that's really nice and I think that if you came and saw that you'd see how beneficial the phones are in schools um the other thing I want to mention um a lot of parents have talked about anxiety and how phones are decreasing our mental
147health um I've diagnosed um high anxiety disorder none of it came from my phone I've had it since I was 5 years old I didn't get a phone until I was late in middle school years um just for car pooling purposes I don't see how phones are the direct correlation to anxiety um the other thing I think you're missing is the suicide um Prevention Hotline is on the back of our ID cards and that's not something that you type into a computer and call you actually have to call on your cell phone and for the some students those are life and death calls and taking away their access to cell phones is rest restricting access to maybe saving their life um and that's something you should really consider if you're really talking about the mental
148health mental health gets so bad that the suicide hotline sometimes has calls backed up and if we can't call that line then I don't know if you really care about students Health um other thing is I really do think you guys should come to our schools and see that the current off andway policy is working um I seen the teachers take really well control of it and some parents are saying teachers aren't well the teachers back there have been doing a great great job with the off and Away policy um we have phone catties if you're really think of Solution phone catties have been an excellent solution to that and it's a much more affordable version too um so yeah I think that's all the time I have thank you sorry that was a little
149over the place but thanks well thank you everyone for com out speaking tonight um we're going to go ahead and let the board uh engage in a discussion you're welcome to stay um I'm going to just go down the line um I'm going to take the privilege of going first uh today and I and I was thinking a lot about how I wanted to structure my thoughts having heard from a lot of people in the community having gone to parent meetings at houses having been to PFC meetings um and so I put together a little slide deck that I think Parts kind of the key things that I'm focused on as a board member and why I think it's so important to move forward and so I would say Jim if you could go to
150the first slide that'd be great the second slide um so when I was thinking about what is the single most important thing for a board member to do uh our top responsibility was for Jim if you go to the next slide was student safety and I began looking at the data and I started hearing about student safety on campuses and the things we need to do to make sure our kids were safe um and when I saw that a 10 to 14 yearold is 33 more times more likely to kill themselves um than to be shot in a mask shooting 134 times more likely to commit suicide in the 14 to 18 uh then from a school shooting it was a real wake up call for me that we need to dig in a little
151deeper and start having an understanding when we talk about student safety what do we actually mean about student safety so if you go to the next slide what you begin to see is what's driving the student Mental Health crisis so overwhelmingly our students are suffering from a just an epidemic of student mental health issues um uh you see the number one cause of suicide today amongst youth is depression and anxiety um you see that one in five 12 to 17-year-olds experienced at least one major depressive episode 50% of Youth suffer from depression will attempt suicide at least once and what I took away from this as you dig in even deeper and deeper is what is causing what is the root cause of this depression what is the root cause of this anxiety it is
152overwhelmingly the cell phone addiction and the dopamine addiction and the challenges that's causing the developmental brain the developmental brain of these children was never meant to come in contact with this device there's a reason why there's a great quote there's a reason why the smartest Engineers on the world the smartest engineers in the world tried to figure out how to create the most addictive device possible and put it into the hands of our children and then our expectation is our 16y olds are going to be able to outsmart the engineering of those addictive Engineers who want to create a device with one goal to draw you in deeper to keep you hooked to want you to continue click through is just not a fair expectation for our students so if you go to the next
153slide that led me to really start thinking about well it's not just student suicide rates which are terrible it's also the self harm rates when we're starting to see Skyrocket and it's are girls who are most at impacted the social emotional well-being of our young girls I have a daughter I have a high schooler I have a middle schooler I have Elementary School student uh are are being impacted at radically disproportionate rates 300% 400% increase in young girls who are self Haring since the 2010s since cell phones became prevalent in our lives there is a onetoone correlation 1 plus 1 plus 1 equals 3 here we're not having to look and draw correlation points together that don't connect to one another so Jim if you go to the next slide um what this leads me
154to is you know how do we break the cycle of addiction then we kept being asked here today why do we have to ban it during lunch why can't we just have uh it during the classroom off in away and then you can run to your lunch and and you're able to use it and what you see is students are telling us they are addicted they are addicted to their cell phones it is an addiction like a drug like a cigarette we don't let 18-year-old students in this District Vape even though they're legally allowed to buy a vape we don't allow it on our campus Because it's not good for their health and it's not good for the health of the students next to them we don't let them to smoke cigarettes for the same
155reason we don't even let them bring laser pointers into the classroom because the damage it can do but we're willing to bring in a cell phone that has more Dam has been medically now proven to charge to cause more damage um 46% of Youth report they're almost online they're online almost every second they cannot break the cycle they need the school district to create the safe space that is our mission we create safe spaces we put up fences to keep out uh external threats we have yard monitors to make sure fights aren't happening we ban vaping to make sure that schools are safe uh this is our responsibility if you go to the next slide Jim um so a couple more things about breaking the cycle of cycle of addiction 50% of teens in a
156study get 237 or more posts a day a quarter of those happen during the school hours our students are not able to unplug when you dive in a little deeper what you start to hear is that nearly half of teachers and principal say that parents are the ones texting their kids every single day and we heard it today with all due respect to the parents who came up here and said that I want to be able to reach my child when I want to we don't want you to do that you were disrupting the school day your student doesn't need you to do that we need your students to have the trust and faith that they believe their parents trust them to go to school to build the resilience determination and grit to make decisions
157for themselves we don't need to be having jobs coaches medical professionals you know trying to change appointments texting kids in the middle of class we haven't needed that for the last century of American Education if you need to reach your kid you can contact the school worst case scenario the second they leave the school ground to this board policy where to pass they have their phone they can check the text and know what's going on give your kids those six hours a day I would implore you it's six little hours but what the data tells us is that break is a Miracle window for kids mental health and the development of the brain so I would ask for just two more slides here Jim if you could move to the next slide what about emergencies
158and I've heard this from a lot of folks what about in case of emergencies I want to be very clear about two things off in away K through 12 would not remove the phone from the students pocket I wish we would I support Yonder bags all the data tells me Yonder bags will be great I visited Yonder bag school principals are to the roof Yonder bags were just rolled out in Newport Beach we were here last week at a couple meeting and people said we want to know about a school that looks like us because apparently a school in South Central didn't look like us enough so Newport Beach has rolled out yonder bags at cor corad Mar School overwhelming teachers love it staff loves it students love it the parents love it it works
159they weren't afraid they move forward and they embraced it we're not talking about Yonder bags today we are talking about saying you can't be on your phone for those six hours I think it's also important for us to just take a deep breath and recognize what law enforcement tells us your students being on their phone in an emergency increases the risk that something harmful will happen to them just that's an all stop that's not debatable that's what law enforcement tells us that's what a teacher will tell you if there's an emergency in the classroom and their students are on their phone texting and not listening to life-threatening life-changing instructions if they're texting or talking or getting a phone call with their an with their with their with their announcements on and somebody God forbid is
160in the classroom looking for them these are not situations that make things better for our students um next slide Jim so what is being done because a lot of people throw up their hands say well I guess we can't do anything I guess we just have to let it go eight states have done bell-to-bell bands New York is introducing one now their governor had the had the courage to come forward and say we're going to introduce a bell-to-bell off and Away ban 3,000 US schools use Yonder bags including 500 in California but more importantly folks who keep saying people are going to move somewhere else La USD is passing a bell-to-bell ban K through 12 that will be implemented next month so it is going to be and it's it it is this is where
161the world is going 75% of schools have cell phone banss today we are not blazing a scary Trail here into unknown territory the science here is is Rock Solid we now know the damage that can be done um next slide Jim um improved academics we talk a lot about that I heard student here today talk about how we're damaging students we're taking away something we're going to impact their their ability to learn the class unfortunately my friends the data is just 100% in the opposite direction every single study that's come out has has shown that a bell-to-bell ban K through 12 improves academics whether that's the 83% of teachers I respect and love our teachers here the reality is they don't have all the information the National Education Association the head the national teachers union
16283% of their teachers who were surveyed said a bell-to-bell full ban is good for the schools because they've seen it happen in real time they weren't swayed by the fear they implemented the program and they gave it a chance to work and they saw that it worked UNESCO tells us that one cell phone beep on a student's phone takes 20 minutes for their brain to reset 20 minutes we just saw data that said the students gets on average 503 during the school day the school day is gone we've eliminated their ability to focus on the classroom with those 53 text Facebook posts LinkedIn posts Tik Tok posts whatever it might be that they're on it's coming through to them how about how about academic performance the average Studies have showing a 6 to 10% increase
163in grades and academic performance on students in often schools and Bell to Bell bands these these are just data points these are facts that are peer-reviewed studied they're not things you're going to find when you go you know dig in the dark web these are out there peer reviewed by medical scientists if you go to the next slide which to me is probably the most important and this is positive behavioral changes in so student emotional health 86% of students in one study were observed improved academic Health in Australia one state did a full cell phone ban day-to-day and then did a study of the students 86% saw student mental health increase 88% of teachers at that Newport school I told you these are the teachers who were surveyed and said what was the impact when
164you did a bell-to-bell ban on your campus 86% they saw an improvement in peer interactions with students they saw students talking to one another and engaging and creating peer relationships um it it what impressed me the most in talking to the principal of C Delmar is he said don't give up lunch whatever you do don't give up lunch and I said well what does that mean he said that is the most important time of the day for the student emotional health do not give in if you can hold the ground on lunch hold the ground on lunch you will see immediate improvements in student interaction you will see students be less stressed and less anxious you will see social bonds come together that weren't there before um next slide Jim U this is just the
165Newport case study I'll skip it I want to go to last slide um reiterating why this is important to me the single biggest thing I cared about is student mental health and well-being and the data is telling me the single most important thing that we can do easily today today is get cell phones out of the kids lives for six hours of the day so that's my position that's where I stand on this I I value everyone's opinion I know this is uh emotionally charged I appreciate people who come and speak about this um I I'm living it every day as a dad with a sophomore and a dad with a sixth grader and a dad with the fifth grader um and I I would encourage us to just think about what's the worst that
166can happen by trying a pilot for this program passing it now and having it implemented next year in high school and seeing what happens the worst case is we undo it thank you Miss sign I would like to make a I would like to make a clarifying statement on here I've been on the board a long time when we deliberate I don't think I've ever seen a PowerPoint presentation presented by a board member which is fine but I just want to go on record that this is not the district's position and it's very um interesting to me and and very rare I don't think I've ever seen this when you look at the actual agenda item under alternative if you look at Agenda items in general the district will give a recommendation there is no
167recommendation here we are a divided board as you are a as we are a divided Community we've heard lots of different opinions tonight we are a div Ed board we have been discussing this since last fall so we are divided so I want to make sure and the very beginning that this is not the district's position this is great data we've all been studying the data we know it for me I'm looking for a balanced approach um and I know how policy development Works successfully in our district I wrote some things down I've changed it by basically listening to speakers but here you go so I want to First stop start by saying thank you all for attending tonight's meeting and sharing your P perspectives and passion this is a really tough thing for parents
168and students and all of us really phones are you know we we all live with these struggles your input is invaluable as we navigate these decisions that impact our students and community and I want to give a special shout out thank you to our students you know our students are starting finals this week they come out here for this they are that passionate about this they are living it every day and they're starting finals and honestly it breaks my heart that you're giving up this time where you should be home studying having a nice dinner relaxing resting and getting sleep so I do want you to know that I take that to heart so thank you we all share a deep commitment to the wellbeing of our students particularly their mental health we do social
169media um and so and cell phone overuse poses legitimate concerns and we agree we all agree that class time should be uninterrupted with phones turned off and put away at our last board meeting as I said we unanimously directed the superintendent to implement an off and Away bell-to-bell um schedule for K8 we all agreed with that and trust me this is a very tough issue for us um so now today we're we're task what's faced with us is voting to now add High School while I appreciate the intent behind this proposal I have reservations regarding its feasibility and effectiveness at the high school level I'm concerned with a one-size fits-all approach a successful policy I've been doing this a long time I know it people spoke to it or in the trenches a successful policy
170requires an inclusive process involving teachers administrators staff parents and students lvusd has a strong history of consensus building which has been a corner Stone of our success I would have liked to have seen broader stakeholder engagement in developing this policy enforcing a bell-to-bell ban during passing periods nutrition and lunch poses significant challenges and yes I visit schools many of us do and I have been out this year the schedule is that I've been out at Calabasas High School I walked the campus with a principal wety and the assistant principles I talked to stud students and I saw for my own eyes and the principal reported to me that they are out there if they see students on their cell phone or a student alone they walk up and check in at Agora I spoke to
171administrators and teachers there and what I heard was that if a student is struggling academically the counselor will pull them in and talk to them about their cell phone use and the and they are offered with the parents the option of checking their phone in during the day and there are students that take advantage of this so when I'm looking holistically I'm doing I'm reading the research I'm talking to our folks I'm talking to parents and students and out at our schools come to Agora soon if you want me to come in your classroom let one of your assistant principles know and we I'll visit that one as well um but High School administrators have told me that cell phone use and I've seen it with my own eyes during these times has decreased significantly
172with students actively socializing studying engaging with peers and aora a bunch of them play a ball game that principal didn't know the name of it um and a bell-to-bell ban May risk undermine the positive relationships between staff and students they need that trust they need that trust to be able to trust a trusted adult at our high schools my fear is this is going to undermine it High School faces unique responsibil high school students face unique responsibilities such is driving jobs extracurricular activities additionally as we heard tonight the five star app which relies on cellphones to monitor students safety they know where your students are on campus are they leaving campus are they in the bathroom too long they know where your students are and they care and they want them to be safe engaged
173um uh to monitor highlight the Practical value of Technology on campus a key goal of high school and this has been said too but I'm I really feel strongly about this a key goal of high school is to prepare students for life beyond graduation where technology and cell phones play a critical role rather than prohibiting use entirely we should focus on teaching dis digital citizenship including phones and social media we have digital citizen standards I've been asking this questions since the start of these conversations last fall but we need we as Educators need to help students develop the skills um to manage technology responsibly at this time I'm sorry to say I cannot support extending the belda belda high school instead I advocate for a more inclusive and collaborative process to develop a policy that
174balances the need for structure with the realities of high school life by engaging all stakeholders and fostering digital responsibility we can create a meaningful effective and enforceable policy in LV US state um well just first of all uh I also wanted to express a big thank you to everyone who came tonight uh I understand there's a very wide range of opinions here and uh you know please know we all listen very carefully um I do want to State as well that we received the number of emails as well they've been going solidly for the last uh week and of those emails I actually looked through today and did a count just to figure out you know what are those folks saying uh 81% of the emails that we've received uh are in favor of a
175bell tobell ban K through 12 uh so that is a just a factor to put into the conversation um thank you also to Mr Lawrence for your presentation I appreciated the data and I think we do need to take the data uh into account I also just want to say that the policy that is in front of us now okay uh the full board policy uh which maybe we can put up on the screen even that is a compromis policy already um it has already been substantially substantially discussed I mean to speak of myself and and my process a month and a half ago I was firmly in favor of Yonder bags okay uh I had done the research and I I saw very very clearly the the benefits that yonder bags had for schools
176for communities and abble for the mental health and the academic success of students uh and it's uh from the data I've seen it was very very clear I made an effort to speak to many stake stakeholders uh I had an excellent discussion with teachers uh who outlined you know why y was not going to be a good solution for our schools uh I also heard from many many parents particularly in the wake of the fires that happened uh at the end of the day in an emergency parents want to be able to reach their kids and a Yonder bag could obstruct doing that and moving from supporting Yonder to a strong off and Away policy okay was a very thought-through decision but I I want to be clear there's many folks in the district who
177support a total ban on cell phones support Yonder bags and then there are Folks at the other side of the spectrum and what we have in front of us is a compromis solution it is an attempt to find a compromise and no one is going to be happy like that's the thing we we all going to have to get on board and find a a consensus with all of this um at the end of the day I also I just want to state that this is not something new we are talking about in my experience the discussions began organically five or six years ago on our schools side Council on our pfas and it first came from teachers in my experience teachers who recognized that from 2013 or 2014 on there was a significant change
178happening in the focus the concentration um and the the the behavior of our students and we were all wondering what was this we kind of were could see it was somehow connected to technology but we were debating what was going on parents were seeing it absolutely clearly with their kids that the moment a cell phone was introduced into the situation kids Behavior deteriorated the ability to form friendships with other kids deteriorated I see this every single day I have two daughters at school one is 14 one is 10 uh I'm always at Social Gatherings with them seeing them around their friends I still see this absolutely clearly these organic experiences led to a sthe of data over the past couple years culminating with books like anxious generation where it is absolutely and indisputably clear from
179the data on a global level that these phones have had a profound effect on the mental health and the S the academic success of our students this is not a new discussion in our district I know that we were mentioning it two three years ago and the district was well we don't have bandwidth to deal with it and you know and I applaud Miss catull and I applaud Mr Lawrence for finally raising this last year at a board level and making an attempt to do something about it uh as much as it is a very uh emotional discussion for uh for everybody um just in terms of the specifics of you know high school first of all I've been so impressed by all of the high school students here tonight the way they've spoke and
180their eloquence you know the one thing that struck me though is that why is it such a punishment to say that for 40 minutes of the school day for lunch and recess you're going to hang out with your friends you're going to going to be face to face and you're not going to have phones involved in the equation this should be a joyful thing for kids you know my grandfather always used to say to me school days are the best days of your life and I truly believe that and what I remember are those social times with other kids why is the scene as taking something away or you know some sort of punishment for kids um I I I do just want to speak to our teachers as well um you know I I
181truly truly heard you when I met with you I I I listened and saw y y's not going to be a good solution looking at the wording in the document uh which I just want to read uh very very clearly actually um number four in the in the document we have in front of us says that a teacher may continue to use uh to give permission to a pupil to possess or use a smartphone it then follows with wordage we added which says the board encourages teachers to permit students to use Smart devices in the classroom only when essential and no other means of techn techology is available I know from my perspective This was meant entirely respectfully and it's just saying that teachers as parents you know that we we want mindfulness in the
182way that is done at the end of the day it is still a teachers's decision as to what they do all we are asking is for mindfulness in that way I understand uh if the teachers um you know felt that the wordage around board's preference teachers seek their principal permission is going too far personally I would be okay with that line being taken out of the policy uh but I I do want the teachers to know we have you know very very clearly heard what they said um just another note um k through eight versus high school first of all Elementary School uh parents here tonight Middle School parents y t night their kids are going to be going to High School uh at some point very soon so their view is also important uh
183and the other thing and this is a personal anecdote but my daughter had a birthday party last weekend it was 10 14 year olds they all in e8th grade they were going to high school next year she has been on me about the Yonder bags like you can't imagine dad those Yonder bags are totally stupid you cannot have them okay and I resisted her opinion for a long time on that she was very very clear when I said no what we're discussing is you know meal times uh and recess at high school and she was like oh we already do that at middle school that's totally fine for us so this is also you know a question of the experience that kids have had if kids are used to in middle school you know having
184Meal Time and recess with no phones they will go to high school and be completely fine about it I understand this will be an adjustment for our current high school students um but please know that face Toof Face Time can be you know great time for you um the the other thing is this notion of you know parents being in touch with their kids uh you know during the school day all the time I had a very interesting discussion with um a UCLA educated Psy psychiatrist and his observation is that um this is adding in a sense to anxiety and stress for kids you know allowing kids to be independent at high school be away from their parents for seven hours a day and live their lives and be independent and not have text from
185parents is actually potentially a beneficial thing for mental health and there's growing data um supporting this I often get the urge to text my kid at school and I say to myself no don't let her have a time at at at school um just finally you know in terms of the one of the speakers mentioned wording and off and away and uh that there was a concern that we were still going to go back to Yonder bags this is an evolving discussion there may be apps a year from now which limit cell phones only to texts and phone calls and uh we may you know go in another Direction a year from now I can say very clearly to all if it reassures you tonight I am definitely not in favor of Yonder bags I'm
186clear but I want a strong off andway policy pay to 12 um Bell to Bell because I truly believe that's best for our kids I think we should note that top private schools like Harvard Westlake there's a reason why they are taking these steps and finally a lot of people mentioned uh digital education and regardless of what policy we take I truly believe that is very very important uh to develop at our schools and I think everybody will agree with that so that at whatever time our kids are still going to have their their phones when they leave high school they're still going to be on their phones the rest of their day um and I do think digital education is is very very important um I I see this as a divided board I
187still hold out hope that we can come together five of us this is a compromise policy in front of us it is a compromise we are looking at it's not what all of us wanted uh and I hope we can come together um with a consensus I truly hope so thank you thanks um uh Miss bu yeah thank you um I wanted to talk about the statistics you provided specifically the one uh talking about how suicide is leading uh cause of death among the use uh my cell phone I don't think has ever really damaged my mental health if I had to speak on it I would say an overwhelming amount of school work has uh and honestly the thing that has taken me out of that is being able to communicate with my friends
188and doing study groups reviewing the work double checking an with each other I would say that really helped as well as also being able to take pictures of the work and ask like things like photomath chbt to explain it to me and like show me how to do it because I'm confused and that makes the work that much harder um sorry uh another thing at school during lunch and nutrition I can communicate with my friends to meet up and decide whether or not we're going off campus or not um sometimes my friends have club meetings and they need people to come participate and that is a way for them to communicate and say we have a club meeting today please come and support another thing about lunch nutrition is it's a break and students should
189be trusted with their phones to be able to use it during their break and I'm not really are there any studies showing that the current Bell thebell policy is not as beneficial as having it lunch and nutrition it's like that big of a difference that they need to take away lunch nutrition from these students also uh parents should be responsible for teaching their children to use their cell phone uh ly if they feel that the harmful side effects of using a phone are too much do not give your child a phone I don't think it should be the district's regulation or up to the district to decide whether or not you should be able to use your phone during school time if a parent provides you with your phone thank thank you very much appreciate
190you much Miss Bas thank very much um thank you all for being here um this has been Hot Topic for almost six months now and thank you students for taking time out especially during your finals to come to this board meeting um I also want to thank all the people that wrote emails to the board voicing their views on cell phones and um and schools we have a policy on the board that only the board president responds to emails received but I want to assure you that we all read them I saw a common theme to these emails and that is what I feel is the common thread that we as a board have uh we we want the best for our students and we want to ensure they have the best tools at their
191disposal to succeed academically and uh we are concerned about student safety and students uh mental health and wellness um I feel that off and Away during academic instruction K through 12 provides uh the best learning environment for our students I also feel that it is the role of the board to listen to the people that elected us implement the policies that we feel help to guide our employees in keeping our district the outstanding District that it is the board has been United uh from the beginning about off and Away during the school day for K through 8 since the school year started this year uh information from our school sites tell us this is working we have not had testing or test results returned to compare data to prove or disprove this we agreed back
192in August to return to the cell phone issue at the high school level in January I believe it is the board role to provide clear Direction and I believe that we as a board agree that off and Away during instructional time is what we warrant um I how how our sites implement this board policy should be determined by the school site I feel we cannot dictate at a high school level if a student uses a cell phone during nutrition or lunch there are too many reasons that are not social media related that a high school student needs to use their phone during a school day I do think that the no cell phone Bell to Bell k through eight is working and should continue and I think High School cell phones off and Away during
193instruction time is the right answer also thank you Miss cutbill hi just make sure I'm unmuted um first of all I want to say we don't often have um board members give slides and dat for their comments but it's certainly um okay if not welcomed I appreciate any board member who wants to um demonstrate I've done this before um shown photos or something illustrative of of what the point I'm trying to make so I appreciate um the deck actually that uh president Lawrence brought and I I think it was clear that that that was information he was bringing for his comments um you know what we're talking about here is half of public high schools in the country have pretty much bell-to-bell bands and I think that's only increasing exponentially I I want to say
194we have a lot of policies that affect Kids 4 through 18 uh even when they're more impactful on some age groups you know because they are policies so they are by definition they reflect the values and intention of the board which I think is meant to reflect well is meant to reflect the values and intention of the community and you know I I still am haunted by that conversation with an an administrator of a district next door to us who is meant to um deal with high schools and told me they cannot do their job because they spend all of their time chasing down social media bullying that happens during the school day uh not outside school hours and I know that isn't most kids but um you know and we heard a lot of
195of of great speakers I want to thank everybody who came tonight and um I did listen carefully to everyone I made notes on everybody's comments and I want to thank everyone who um who emailed as well I think it takes a lot of Um passion and presence to come down and share your thoughts with us so please now um you know as Mr Lazar said I don't think anyone will be fully happy with you know whatever happens um and the high school students are particularly wonderful and I know that they are managing things well but at the end of the day a lot of that is anecdotal and you know there's the old saying the plural of anecdote isn't data um I want to address I think what um miss cres and miss Miller said
196which is that uh we aren't visiting classrooms and that um research doesn't impress uh them um I I feel like maybe that was either aimed at me or Mr Lawrence so I kind of want to take that on um I certainly get out of schools I I think other board members do we get into classrooms that's highly unusual for a district um most districts board members do not get into classrooms I spend a lot of time talking to teachers to students to parents um and I think um I you know maybe that was for me because in August when we first talked about this the first meeting in August uh I had spent I didn't travel the summer I how I Spent My Summer Vacation was diving deep into a lot of research a lot
197of data reading a lot of books um and you know data is important and the research is important and it's consistent that there's a clear correlation between effective phone bands and better school performance and significant Improvement in scores on what what were referred to as high State tests and the interesting thing about that is um that it all these studies consistently Define the same thing of what was an effective ban and it talked about transparent communication and and being uh consistently enforcing something but one of the elements that it said was what it called a rock solid policy and it said it really had to be from Bell to Bell the entire day and that the research said that checking up on notifications as Mr Lawrence said it completely breaks um those six hours that
198are supposed to be and it creates this catch-up period not for every kid for a lot of kids and the interesting thing about this is a lot of students a lot of parents who spoke I'm sure your students managed this very well but as a board member I have to think about all students and where they're at and consistently in these studies that took place across the US in California uh I I even dove into the World Health organ iation and UNESCO stuff the increase um was especially large for the lowest performing pupils when there's when there's a bellt bell off and away and that they saw jumps in their scores more than twice as average as as twice as big as the average student I guess I want to say and the greater effects
199of that Bel to Bell was that higher achieving students are actually better able to manage these things the distractions The Lure of the phone and focus on their work and that so not having an aggressive policy will actually increase achievement gaps over time and I'm haunted by that that um we're going to play to the kids who manage it well and not thinking about all kids and where they are and when I think about this I think about you know the lunch and nutrition what we're really talking about is I mean I thought there would be more concern about classroom day because I actually very much trust that there's a lot of educational use devices in the classroom not not the we have 10 minutes spare you can play on your phone but you know
200we have robotics classes we have um an amazing sports medicine program that they have phone-based apps that they use you know and I'm I'm fine with that I I totally that's you know as Mr Lazar said that's meant to be respectful um of our teachers so uh there's a photo I think I showed back in August M Mr Klein if you have that photo um and this goes to what Mr Lawrence's thing about the 237 notifications something kids get this is one period this is all the kids in a class not a huge class every time they got a notification they went up and they just silently made a mark So what we're really asking to protect is lunch and nutrition to spend their time on this and that doesn't seem the best use of
201of that time and you know I think about the speaker who talked about who had worked in College and Career and about students not being able to have those interpersonal and social skills um and again our higher performing more engag students will be able to but we're talking about protecting The Lure of the notific ations and that's something that's really hard to get behind and it strikes me as I sit in meetings where we discuss curriculum and we discuss budgets and we discuss all these things um that we're not doing the loow hanging fruit we're not doing the easy thing you know we can talk we get into deep discussion sometimes about pedagogical you know approaches and um different things that secondary and Elementary and you know and our lcap goals but we're not going
202to do the one thing because some people will be unhappy about that um I think people will be unhappy about this you know whatever we do but I feel you know someone said as Educators as our job we are not Educators um that is not the role of the board the role of the board is to transmit the value of the community and the value of what we want our schools to look like into polic and there's a reason um you know I agree with everyone else you know I I had actually thought a lot of interesting things about the Yonder bags I I didn't just go to Charter Schools um and there was a lot to said but I could also see that we didn't have the buyin on board at the levels we
203needed to make that successful and I struggled with how we rolled that out without doing it all at once everywhere so it became and it and and the cost effect effectiveness of a lot of that so the Y bags for me are off off base but um I I just find it hard to not do what I believe um it would be unconscionable to not do something that I think is based um in the interest of student mental health and student safety and um best student outcomes for all students but I thank everyone for coming thank you um yeah just Qui public comment is closed but as kind of a courtesy with our teachers union U Miss Miller want to come up and speak again so we're going to extend um just for Miss Miller
204the opportunity to come up and speak and engage on this topic thanks it won't take three minutes I promise um it's actually probably good that I had some time to calm down because um in my 20 plus years in this District coming to these meetings watching Mr Lawrence I appreciate that you reflected on things you did your research but presenting a slide deck as to audience to people who are watching and it not have been on the agenda is totally misleading not transparent that's the stuff that we're talking about if we would have had this if we would have had these discussions with the community with ourselves differently things it wouldn't be so contentious in this District the board does not give presentations without giving ample time for um the public to review it so
205now after all of your statistics they're all great we all agree with it but now we don't have a chance to respond and that seems very unfair I just want to say that she has a question um I just had a quick question are there studies that compare the difference between the Bell to bell schedule versus our current policy of just during instructional time so I'll speak for what I found uh when take care for what the folks are more than welcome to do their own research I encourage you all to do it and to focus on the science and what the science tells us and that is unfortunately International countries are way ahead of us on this so you look at Australia you look at the UK you look at Norway uh those countries
206have done exhaustive studies about the difference between Bell to Bell and they show significant improvements um if you've read the anxious generation what you see is that uh whether it's United States Canada uh like socioeconomic societies of ours um we see consistently the same numbers of student depression student mental health the same exact spikes when they occurred they all started spiking right right around 2010 to 2015 when we shortened the age we we gave kids phones at a younger age um and those All Began spiking the student Mental Health crisis that we began seeing but I encourage everyone to feel free to dive in and do their own research on the data um it it is uplifting when you actually look at the science um and see what it tells you it becomes um pretty
207clear um other thoughts so those international schools had the studies they had the sorry studies they had had the in during instructional time only and then switched to Bell the bell and compared the two they didn't compare the two no okay so are there any studies comparing the two I don't know if they're actually we know anecdotally I'll tell you what I was told by the principal of Newport beaches k delmare um he was a principal out of school that had belt a bell but not off and away and he said it didn't work he said the pouch we're not talking about pouches but he said the pouch and the off and away is a tool you need that tool to enforce the mechanism to expect a kid who is addicted to a device that
208was designed to be addictive to them to not want to take that device as we heard from our fellow students today and take it to the bathroom and sneak it out like they're doing every day as you've all acknowledg is happening is why BTO Bell off and Away has to be the policy otherwise what you see is that addictive pull pulling you in and saying I just check one last time if I just check one last time we'll get there R those argu um I I don't know if every uh everybody's ready to um move to an actual discussion of the policy in front of us I mean if anyone wants to speak further of course well uh what I wanted to do is before making a motion to approve the policy I did want
209to move to amend the policy in front of us and remove the wordage that says it is the board's preference that teachers seek their principal's permission prior to permitting students to use Smart devices in the classroom uh I I feel like that sentence was um triggering to teachers um but I I feel the wordage before which says it doesn't require teachers to use use cell phones in any way all it says is the board encourages teachers to permit students to use Smart devices in the classroom only when essential and no other means of technology is available so it's still leaving it up the teachers discretion but it's it's just expressing uh what our desire or point of view is uh and asking teachers please to be mindful of that I feel like it's a completely
210respectful request of teachers I'm fine with that so but I I don't know how uh I'm fine with that change I would have a question for Miss fa though my understanding is the that subsection was specifically related to academic uses in the classroom we are still not saying that teachers can say uh all right I'm gonna be out for 30 minutes you guys can all be on your phones I'll be back um it's it's the uh I have a lesson plan here's the academic use for the day I as a teacher I'm going to lead an academic use for this I'm going to use it for this is that correct I mean Ed code isn't that specific that was clear the intent of Ed code but it doesn't specifically say that okay so our language
211is mirroring Ed code for the most part there's a couple tweaks this this but is or cba's policy we made some tweaks to it ourselves but our but what is the well that's I'm fine with that change I'm fine with it I mean the implication is that it implies to educational you know instruction but you could add when essential to instruction to the sentence yeah I think that if you're looking to be more liit and connecting I would prefer that I think I think I am more than free to have teachers make decisions about how they want to lead instructure on their class but I would think the policy should be clear that um it's not up to it's not up to individual substitute to decide they're going to have cell phone day today um
212I did just want to make it clear to the um members of the public that are here as well can we possibly get the the policy up there on the screen just so folks can see it clearly that this whole policy uh has exemptions in the case of an e Mery or in respon to or in response to a perceived threat of danger a student may access their phone um if a licensed physician or surgeon deems it to be essential for the health of the pupil there's an exception there's an exception for a students's uh indivi individualized education program as well uh so it does allow for very specific purposes where a phone would be necessary for a student so can can we do we have consensus to we'll move we'll move these one at
213a time because we probably won't have consensus on some of them but do we have consensus on striking the line um can we put the line up there so we can get consistency on it we can see um it is the board's preference that teachers seek their principal's permission prior to permitting students to use Smart devices in the classroom where is that uh it's on page four uh yeah top of page four so this is the proposed policy yeah I'm good with that uh so yeah right uh so uh so we're striking the second sentence of the first paragraph of page four correct I'm fine with that okay anybody Mr Lawrence to answer your earli question Miss Falcon I were discussing it so if your question is does Ed code specifically state that teachers can
214only use mobile devices in classrooms for instruction edod does not say that it's vague right it's it's speciic yeah it's it's it allows teachers but it was it allows teachers to supervise the use of students phones in classrooms it is not specific or limiting yeah to instruction or education so for purposes of just trying to go line by line on this I'm I think we have board consensus on striking sentence number two of paragraph whatever paragraph that is are we clear what I'm talking about here okay uh I I would love it to say if we're comfortable that the board encourages teachers the board encourages teachers for it students to use Smart devices in the classroom for academic purposes only one essential and no other means or or something like that for or instructional purposes
215whatever you're whatever ever word you just suggested well they use the F star I don't know if that's academic but we're moving in that you know that direction so how about in instructional structural sign with me so we're just inserting the word instructional you use Smart devices in the classroom only for instru for devices in the classroom how do you want only when essential for instructional purposes there you go only only when essential for instructional purposes is that clear do we have to do we have to use the word essential we just take out instructional purposes I I think it should say essential because it is our intent uh to that we communicating to teachers um they at the end of the day have discretion to use phones how they wish this is just the
216board's intention and we saying we only want phones used when they are essential for instruction I think that's fair moving forward um we normally when we have board policy it's very typical General to have have an administrative regulation with it and that really outlines the discipline and the how and so we don't we haven't gotten that far yet so I would ask that um in committee somewhere safety and wellness wherever that you work on an administrative reg regulation because one of the things that I've heard at our school sites also is that the discipline is not all that clear and it's not all that consistent among schools so we can do that and um and if the board can also be updated as to how we're going to implement imp this because you know this
217is a big change so how we're going to implement this as well okay thank you I assume you were going to do an AR anyways right is that kind of the Plan F AR usually follows a BP uh and we would expect to have an AR well before this would be implemented in next school year okay uh I think safety you think you're on safety Wellness right yeah oh and this is again this is for implementation for the 2526 school year I don't have any other amendments from my side okay Miss coule I'm mindful of how hard it is to be remote on these things so did you want to anything you want to add or no I I would agree with that oh loster okay you yourself is there a motion yeah I move
218to a m i move to excuse me I'm still new at doing this um I move to approve the cellone policy in front of us correct is there a second I'll second second it I'll second it there's motion a second any further discussion on the topic U before we pass the board policy I just want to be clear that the motion you made included the changes that were proposed by as amended yes thank you for that great great all those in favor student vote nay board vote I I no I no okay uh vote passes uh 3 to two thank you very much for everyone for coming out for sharing your thoughts I will say the hard work is now ahead of us we're going to spend the next six months figuring out the best
219way to implement this uh as we would any other policy after this Tye of deliberation discussion stay engaged uh if you have uh passionate feelings about how if your students in particular uh about passionate feelings and how we could uh implement this more effectively um we love hearing those processes it moves forward all right move to the next item on the agenda uh which is um I've lost my place here approval of resolution 12-24 authorizing filing of applications for State allocation board administered programs Dr M president members of the board stay on think my my ears are clogged I apologize Madam president members of the board uh with the passage of prop two uh this resolution affords uh the district uh to be able to complete the next steps in developing A Five-Year Plan which
220is a requirement for the we could ask folks to maybe take the conversations outside that'd be great thank you very much appreciate you coming tonight thank you a lot of enthusiasm out there for my resolution start over in case cameras missed it no we got you keep going you keep thinking that Dr gleon okay so we uh this resolution is uh is recommended to the board so that we can uh complete our obligations to meet uh The Five-Year planning requirements so that we can continue to file with the OPC to for matching funds for all the construction projects were completing this is straightforward we do this regularly or is the first time we've done this before this is directly related to proposition two and is tied into a new law that requires a five-year facilities
221plan which will also be tied into how we uh connect with developer fees while the um specific requirements of the 5-year plan that will eventually be brought to the board are not yet clear in the law and uh we're working with legal to continue what is clear is that to be eligible to pursue those next steps we need the board to pass this resolution um just a question when I was reading about prop two um it appeared that most of the funding was going to go to um districts which had very large amount of low-income students and so on um uh will our application be successful do you think I mean how much funding would we potentially receive so uh it our eligibility is determined based on the construction and the timing at each of
222our sites uh basically about 60% of any modernization or new construction costs will eventually be able to have matching funds it's all about timelines so anytime we have a proposition two or any construction bonds passing it just moves us forward in a timeline that usually takes four to five years to see um low-income District or not districts moving forward in the process just moves us forward even if we're in a different line thank you uh if there's no questions I'll ask for a motion so do we have the five-year master plan how do you what do you do the five-year master plan will have to be developed uh it's one of those things where the law p was passed to include it but the specificity around what needs to go in it is still being
223determined by uh districts across the state um so this is just the first step we're only asking the board to pass a resolution understanding that we need this plan even though we don't fully understand everything that's needed right and we have no idea when it when when um the status of it or when it would be due I mean are they going to give you a nice Runway well definitely get us the runway we have um we're advised by uh the tower Rini firm which is known worldwide and is the best in California at this um we do I do anticipate we'll be bringing some form of a five-year plan or Clarity within the next couple of months because this relates to our collection of community impact fees as well is there a motion I'll
224move is there a second I second motion a second without any further discussion all those in favor student vote I board i i i i that one went by quick all right um revision of board policy administrative regulation wait am I the Right item sorry no I skipped ahe by accident I'm sorry uh pardon me approval of Chinese honors all right excellent Dr SC Mr President members of the board um at our curriculum Council in November we had four courses that were presented and approved by um our curriculum Council and I would like to introduce Miss Kirby Brock who is bringing forth these courses so we'll start with Chinese 4 thank you for waiting of course good evening um Mr President members of the board Dr stanowski cabinet it's my absolute honor to be here
225tonight with four incredible teachers from aora high school but we'll start with our one of our amazing world language teachers Miss Helen Yap who's here to talk to you about a course proposal for Chinese for honors um and I'm gonna turn it over to her niow niow and um uh president Lawrence and members of the board uh Dr panowski and members of the cabinet it is my pleasure to share with you uh tonight about proposal for updating our existing Chinese for program level course to have an honors distinction here are some important points to acknowledge and consider um first of all it's a same course is the existing Chinese for level but will reflect the rigor and challenge of the honors level course the second second um point is we use the same textbook and
226curriculum as AP and IB as L2 um the third is the content reflects the difficulty of an advanced level language course including the cultural competent competencies um according to the uh several language standards we're all language standards California World Language standards IB standards as well as the uh common core standards and uh the different the fourth point is that the differentiation has been historically with the length of writing uh which can now be adjusted with honors level credit and the last one is the scope and sequence um are the same and these students are diligent eager and ready to continue their growth uh with in this difficult language as an honor student so thank you for your consideration and we're happy to answer any questions you may have we could see U questions pretty straightforward
227thank you for doing this and bringing this forward this is wonderful thank you what is where are we at with the Chinese uptake and I know last time I really dived into it it was you know the second biggest language on campus it was kind of growing rapidly where are we kind of is it maybe fill me in on we we at um at our school um there isn't one at Calabasas high and there's one in gorah high uh we're doing well although we have um at the upper upper levels which I teach uh we're doing really well in fact we have more students they're very eager they they want to skip levels they want to do AP do more advanced and that's why they're all a lot of them have tested into honors uh
228to four level four skipping level they study on their own um however on the lower level we don't see as many students coming in from um middle school so yeah I'll add to that just to Echo what Miss Yap shared is that we are seeing students continue in the program longer however our introductory levels we are seeing a slight decrease over the last at least my four years at Agora High School it is of course our second language second most popular language out of two language offs on campus um and as you all know that we are the theater school for our dual emersion Spanish language program from our Middle School So that obviously takes a little bit of a precedence in our language offerings as well yes okay great well just I don't know
229just give a quick plug what we would like to do is possibly start um a program at the theater Middle School I was that's what I was asking I was curious about when we first introduced the the concept of this and are we thinking about bringing it into eth grade I love that because I taught at Oak Park which um we have one um California this uh distinguished U Golden Bell award and um I was one of the recipients involved in that at the middle school level we also brought it to fifth grade wow so it's a a continuation so with your support we would love to proceed with it love it thank you so much um is there a motion I move to approve Chinese for honors all second uh no further discussion student
230vote I Bardon I I I cacy thank you for coming appreciate it um approval of culinary arts specialist step oh we're still say this is me again um so Kirby Brock crowd assistant principal edore High School of curriculum instruction the next three courses are all um led by the aora charger team and I have the pleasure of introducing them all um but joining me tonight is our amazing corner it's teacher at Agora High School Miss Amanda Jacob so I'd love to welcome her higher for me sorry uh Mr President members of the board Dr stepnowski and members of the cabinet thank you for having us this evening to present our new course at the high school level I'm here to present the course proposal for culinary Specialists a unique class that benefits the culinary arts
231program both at AHS and CHS uh this course would provide Advanced instruction in the fields of culinary arts supplement our exciting culinary arts program and enhance students learning provide culinary application in laboratory and classroom settings offer learning opportunities side by side with culinary professionals to increase their Knowledge and Skills allow Young Chefs to learn all the components of laboratory from the proper setup and safe cleanup and to be able to provide and support feedback to their peers prepare students for jobs in the field of the professional culinary setting the culinary art specialist position would be intended for students who have progressed through the current culinary levels at both sites this would be a specialized co-seeded course that would support the new students in our level one and level two courses culinary Specialists would apply to
232work alongside me along with Chef Allen at CHS to help support our Sue chefs as you would call them instructors in the broader culinary classes we have modeled our course proposal um for the UC doors off of existing courses and schools around us and intend pending your approval to submit to the UC approval as the G elective course this spring in the intent to offer the class this thank you yeah it is no it is it is am I don't we usually get am I gu this wrong don't we usually have them a through G approved before we approve the course no it's we approv the course and then we submit it because this is not a course that's currently like on this is a brand new course that doesn't exist anywhere in the a
233through G Universal can pull out it does and oh yeah it it completely exists in other institutions as a UC approved G elective course we model writing the course but we would not submit it to UC without got it district and I'm and I just want to say I'm so impressed thank you I I love options and opportunities for students and I'm so impressed that you included the syllabus or whatever it is the course overview from a a school district that is already that's that has the UC CSU doorway approval the UC doorway approval so that's wonderful to have in here so we can really get get a taste for what this course is because this is not just like a straightforward course so thank you for that un and i' say our team our
234CTE team and we'll turn it over to them in a second as well but including our culinary team models this idea off of existing courses but also we have a current science assistant course that we wrote right um to that is g elective approved as well so we have done this before yeah no this is great thank you can can I just jump in and say I could hear but not I got out of range I needed to take a quick Break um I want to add my vote to support the um Chinese honors oh okay okay sorry just I want to be on record as yeah it's like midnight from this couple so thank you nobody is getting there okay I just wonder when are we gonna get like a gur yes chef like
235hats or shirts that's what I want like that would be actually pretty awesome awesome onf oh yes I love that okay would you like a motion I move to approve of culinary arts Specialists I second all those in favor student vote i boardon i i i i motion passes unanimously um back to Dr Brock uh um approval of IV Sports exercise Health Science hl1 hl2 I will take the Dr Brock it's a gold of mine to eventually one day Dr Brock and not yet um oh okay sign me up um Battlefield promotion it doesn't count for like Doc Brock has a nice ring to it um I again am joined by two incredible Educators on our campus who are not only part of our CTE um and Kinesiology program but also embedded in our IB
236program in the IB Sciences so we're here to propose a new IB Sports exercise and health science course to our existing IB diploma program good evening Mr President members of the school board Dr seenosi and cabinet um thank you for having us tonight uh the course for IB Sports exercise and health science would be offered at AHS in conjunction with our Kinesiology and Sports Medicine Academy as well as within our IV program the course would focus on three major top topics exercise physiology and nutrition biomechanics and sports psychology and motor learning um this is a course that students have been pushing us to offer for a number of years and the IB Program has been wanting us to offer for a number of years and Miss Dison and I have finally been able to get
237together on it and I think she and I bring different strengths to the table for this class and we're excited to be able to hopefully do it um it will allow us to differentiate our second level Kinesiology class so students who are traditionally going into Kinesiology too will now have a choice between our traditional class which is more focused on injuries and Rehabilitation and athlete treatment and this one that's more focused on human performance and collecting analyzing data um the it would be an IB science course within what they call group four um and it traditionally other schools are offering it under um UC lab science area D um inter disciplinary doesn't as opposed to just life or um physical science the it aligns with our current CTE curriculum um in addition to the IV
238program and we would love to be able to offer it and would like to answer any questions if you have them could you maybe take 60 seconds and just or longer and just update us on where the program is today on kind of like which program CTE sport the whole the whole pathway that we've SP because I I I know um I've had kids friends who've gone through it who love it who are now off in college doing it but like where are we at today from the little the little program that could a long time ago to now how many courses and and where we at yeah so um right now we're excited we have three different levels uh we have Kinesiology 1 Kinesiology uh two and then our Advanced Kinesiology um and then
239we also have some supplementary classes medical scribing and Rehabilitation we currently have 207 kids in the program and um with the addition of like Kathy Prader coming on and we just um we're able to hire Michael Carter so um we are able to expand the program because we have teachers um and we have the interest it's been here every year we have more and more uh we actually have our interest meetings coming up uh in the next two weeks uh for next year um our all of our level three students now do outside internships so that's something we started about three years ago so every Advanced Capstone student which this year I believe there's like 56 of them have outside internships at medical facilities Kinesiology facilities in our out and in the community um and
240then all three levels do internship hours either on site or with facilities and we're hoping to just keep expanding that we also have very um competitive competition teams where students can compete uh both in sports medicine but also in other Medical Careers so um we had some students place in veterinary medicine and um physical therapy as well as was Behavioral Science last year um and so we have been able to go to these different groups and allow students to delve either into the Kinesiology or the medical aspect of it and this course will correlate with that perfectly I don't know if it's coincidence or not but I literally over the last month four different friends have have been raving to me about sports management program so you really have a great reputation I'll add one
241thing in because she doesn't give herself enough credit they don't give themselves enough credit but I mean we have some amazing programs at agore high school this is by far the most requested in the core selection process great I just had the pleasure of going to the Lindero Canyon PFC meeting it was one of the first questions asked how do I get involved in sports medicine um so it's it's ever growing nice great work um may have a motion to approve I'll move to approve great any further discussion nope uh all those in favor student board student vote board I I I great I pass is five- Zer thank you very much thanks for all the great work you're doing it's amazing really great to see um approve us approve us wow I'm tired approval
242of office laboratory Specialists hi again um last but certainly not least um we're proposing a course tonight with uh in conjunction with our CT but really our entire staff at both high schools uh Agora and calasses for an office laboratory specialist position uh Kristen donon alongside doing all of this important work for our Kinesiology program helped in writing and submitting this course approval so we're going to kind of tag team on presenting this course to you all tonight um Mr President members of the school board Dr seasi and members of the cabinet thank you for having me talk again um we um are excited to present this office laboratory specialist um I've actually been able to have the science specialist students in my class um in our Kinesiology program and being able to expand this
243to all of the educational programs at Calabasas and Agora I think will be great for both students teachers and staff um it's uniquely designed to provide Advanced instruction in fields of communication office and teaching a lot of those soft skills that we're talking about when we were having the discussions earlier um of communication and working together um it allows the students to work work side by side with teachers and office staff and all of the staff on campus um to learn classroom management office management and all of those skills they'll be able to take an into any career um it also prepares a student to work in a office setting um teaching or in education uh working towards developing their skills specifically in leadership communication technology and problem solving so this office laboratory specialist position
244would be intended for students to apply to participate in the program right they'd need teacher or staff member approval as along with along with administrative approval to be able to participate similarly to our culinary specialist course and our existing science assistant position this would be a specialized co-seeded course um that would be co-seeded with current classes so no impact on our existing master schu schedule the office laboratory specialist would apply to work alongside teachers and supporting learning in the classroom we have also modeled this course against a pre-approved UC uh doorways exist ing course in other schools around us and pending your approval would do the same to submit this course this spring um in the open UC doorways window for a for a through G approval and again I want to thank you for
245including the course overview from another school school district so we can see what this looks like and what this entails so thank you for doing that that's great this was the one I was most kind of just didn't really fully grasp it wasn't it wasn't it wasn't so at first I thought it was a TA role um and then I so I so because there's no curriculum right there's it says na for for course no I'm sorry no um there's no there's no books there's no textbooks did you scroll down and read I but but so I was trying to get my sense for like um what um maybe unpack a little bit more like what what skill set is this providing that the college-bound student doesn't currently have or is it more of a
246CTE um more more of a non-bound focus skill set that we're trying to I'm trying to understand like what what we're um I can kind of relate it to the science specialist position which obviously they learn about like laboratory setup and tear down um but in the office laboratory specialist I think it's really is the communication and the mentorship and the leadership like those students are normally going to be coming into a class or a program that they have done before so when students are struggling on assignments or need that like differentiated instruction like I can have my science Specialist or the office specialist That's maybe taken that course before sit and help guide that student so I think it's really that mentorship and communication skills um some of the other assignments we had like
247brainstormed was like interviewing different staff members and getting like what is their job skills and then how can you apply it to any of like your career Fields so I think the mentorship and the leadership the communication those like soft skills are really going to be brought out just to Echo and add on to that um incorporation of appropriate use of Technology email communication with other people amongst staff um but then also we hear the buzzword like ta a lot My Hope and goal in talking to a few different um educational leaders who have offered programs like this at their schools is that this really would be like an application based program students would elect to take this course not because they just need something to fill their schedule or want to hang out with
248misties on which they probably all do right um but the assistant principal of curriculum instruction would really oversee kind of almost like a application and training of being part of this course and seeing the consistency through across all subject how many students do you envision taking this per semester is it like three or is it like 30 I would I would not say 30 maybe 10 okay depending yeah and it's and it's wonderful that they can get you know Real World experience and and the a through G credit so they can apply to college with the a through G course so this is great and I think because we offer the science specialist we're now yay thank you offering The Culinary special just like some of our unique programs do have it so to be
249able to offer it to other content areas would be great too thank you yeah course um if you if you get four past you get like a gold star so you get four one meaning so suspenseful uh uh is there a motion I would like to move to a bir this course okay there's a motion I second a second uh student vote board vote I heard Miss couple say I so um I motion pass Dy thank thank you very much thank you for all the work that went of these I know it seems like we kind of went quick but there's you know it's a lot of trust and faith in the process but also as Miss Stein said I remember years ago we would spend 30 minutes complaining about how soft and light the
250packet is was attached and we had no idea what it was this was very robustly yes it might have been last year but but it's great when you come in you see um cyers your corner got it's not even natural already but thank you very much we appreciate it thank you all right uh Miss Stein reminds me that we have a a board policy likew a by board bylaw that says as we approach the nine o'clock hour I am to uh pull the board sorry not a staff um to say do we want to continue and press on uh or table some of the information items so my question to staff is is any of this um information items pressing or we wait till the next board meeting or or are there people who came
251here to present to them I see anybody left well I don't I don't want to um and the fact that staff has been working all day this is this is now a a 13 hour day for staff so I but Dr step we're we're happy to stay so the board is happy to stay but is there anyone here for cerx uh the team had to leave but I can phone it in if you know what I mean I don't want I don't want to make but I don't want to make them come back if they were already here then left so I don't make them come back in two weeks I can do the presentation in 45 seconds or we can bring them back in two weeks either way if you're the only ones doing
252it why don't we bring it back I mean what I want to they already came once on an evening then went home wait a minute who does it do you have do you have Centex staff that should be coming or did come I'm so confused they they did come um just thank you for letting them they had they have small children that I don't mean but okay there's still a wrong answer here but if if if they're okay not coming if it wasn't like their deepest desire to present to the board and would rather have the night off with their family in two weeks I'm happy to have you do the presentation if you if they would if if this all you're saying saying right so you decide the board is happy with yeah no
253I the board is very familiar with the center for educational Excellence Graduate School of Education uh I can do a quick one minute summary just because you are so familiar with it uh we have this item feel free to take a little extra time but I I also don't wa feel rushed we think it's very important sorry she there but I don't want you to feel rushed but uh the goal wasn't to rush it's yeah to be respectful of your guys' time so sure appreciate that Dr Stat what are we doing proceed I mean the question is you know does the leader of the program does Miss laugh you know was it does she want to share the program and want to share some appreciation on her and the staff that work on it the
254the staff would be uh grateful to have the time as you know uh in their credential programs uh we spend most night many nights a week till 7 o' 8:00 at night so uh another night not out would be appreciated by that team right let's move forward then let's you do it great Madam president members of the board uh sharing with you the annual update for the center for educational Excellence Graduate School of Education there's slides in the and an annual report in the agenda however I don't uh I don't need to go through them I know the board had a chance to review them unless the board wants me to go into an Extended Cut we don't need Mr Klein to put them up uh we have uh had the since 2017 uh the
255board uh gave support on an Innovative idea to launch three credential programs with uh our Center for educational Excellence uh the annual report is to bring to you as a condition of our accreditation through the commission on teacher credential in an update we uh will share with you that our three programs continue to thrive as outlined in the report our admin programs for preliminary administrative credentials and clear administrative credentials have both grown with the are growing exponentially uh and our teacher induction program currently serves 25 teachers within our own district with a coaching based model um our $2.2 million grant that we received uh which was the second largest in the state to prepare TK Educators I believe we are on our 10th cohort now and have served over 200 Educators across the state if
256I had to summarize in an elevator and we only had 30 floors I would tell you that the programs continue to grow we have 30 Partners it's a three4 3/4 of a million dollar offset to the the general fund and we continue to diversify opportunities such as with our micro credentials and our classified leaders so what's that you bu delad oh three quarter of a million dollar offset of the general fund right but I the I'd say and with um one of the wonderful things about it is because we have 30 District Partners we've served over 500 Educators we've attracted great talent and we've positioned herself as a district as lead as a thought leader in leadership and teacher development and uh over 95% of our administrators have had a hand or have been a
257student in our programs uh as was the 4 and0 Kirby Brock who just uh just represented to the board so it's been a a a great pleasure and honor to be part of it I know the board is involved uh with it as well it continues to grow it continues to thrive and will continue to uh Branch out throughout the state not because uh we need to become bigger but because it has a net benefit in terms of talent and uh dollars for our students well I would just say success has a thousand forefathers as they often say but I I think at least three four of us here will remember very vivly who where this came from and the thought process and uh the there was not not an ins amount of angst from
258the board like oh another program oh my God we didn't understand and we didn't understand it and we were trying to get our head around it and uh as I recall that meeting the first meeting was not a great meeting from uh it was we were I'm sure you remember it I can see you coming to the L uh uh just because I don't know the history did Dr gleon come up yeah Dr gleon is the is the he had the vision for this and brought it forward and and and you were you had you were patient enough to bring the board along uh and I think it was a great example of uh bringing the board along helping us understand ask a lot of questions um and you know almost a decade later to
259see it become this great program is a big credit to you and of course the whole team that did it but I as as one of the board members it was particularly um uh not to agree so much uh questions I I think it was I think it's great to see this BR to to Mr lazar's um comment you know of all the things we do policy budgets curriculum we're we we didn't have if because we're none of us are Educators by profession we didn't have experience in credentialing so we had to kind of be brought up to speed about that process and why this would make sense for us and how this would affect and not you know and it's and so once we kind of had that education that professional development and got
260on board it's been amazing and how it has enhanced us both in terms of personnel and I think educationally how it has enhanced our core Mission not far from taking away from it has been you know we appreciate his his long-term vision and holding our hands so that um you know this leap of faith was um really based on something quite solid so uh huge learning curve for us and um it just keeps getting stronger and stronger board took a very a very big risk we were the first school district to do this and it's very um it was a risk because it's Uncharted Territory and it took at least two years of work before you ever saw a result so we appreciate your confidence and faith and goes without saying but Miss L and
261Miss Jesse Sweeney Miss Megan Jones are three full-time staff they are who are behind this growth they work every day uh through all the calls Partnerships and all that work of relationships that grow these programs uh if they could be here tonight they would uh extend their gratitude and also their enthusiasm for where we're headed well please let them know how much we appreciate them so thank you I I did want to say uh that I I just have such high regard for it and you know reading the whole presentation as well I think it's wonderful and my notes it was to congratulate everybody who was involved both in the administration and the board side for just developing such a a wonderful program and I think it's so great that many of the administrators and
262teachers uh stay in our district I think that's just wonderful great uh moving on to revision of BP and a no we have three more information we could bang these out in five minutes are we okay to bang him out five minutes because she has to bring them back in two weeks so then everything gets pushed back to if we don't do it now you can you do them quickly I can do in less than five okay five notes less than five notes I to throw a span in the works but I did have thoughts on these I mean they're not very long thoughts but if everyone wants to go home we can hand with later let's do it we can do it let's do it I've tried twice to get us out of here
263but I'm feeling mrly all right revision of board policy at AR 6115 ceremonies and observations Mr President members of the board um board policy 6115 ceremonies and observations was last updated in 2001 um the policy in front of you and the AR in front of you reflects recent legislative changes including um the uh new cultural significant events that were not previously on and then um really codifying the commemorative exercises in terms of the pledge allegiance Andor um the cultural events surrounding that um that were not in our previous policy Mr Lazar uh thank you um uh just a couple of thoughts um from actually speaking to a lot of folks on the campaign Trail when I was out there and just from the last couple years what folks have said I had three suggestions for
264um potential days to add not not as days of school but I see there's like another category there of things we observe in The District in some way and uh the one the first one which is in line with our focus on math is that I think we should celebrate Pi Day districtwide everybody loves Pi Day and it's kind of fun as well you can bring pies to school and uh I don't want to add work for everyone though uh but it was a thought uh the second one was just surprising number of folks uh suggested to me um was to codify observation of nurus the Persian New Year in some way which I know we already are doing shout outs on social media which I think is great uh but you know we have
265a big Persian population in our district and I know it's very meaningful to them so that was one thought um also yesterday was International Holocaust Remembrance Day uh many in our district do observe it uh just on a more somber note uh but you know I was looking at the footage of uh the commemorations at alitz and uh you know all these Holocaust Survivors are getting old uh there aren't going to be many left soon and uh it's going to be up to the new generation to to preserve the memory of the Six Million that perished so um again these are just thoughts I understand putting in practice and you know observation it can be a lot of work for everybody so uh but thought I would throw it out there so so my question
266on that those are great questions and great thoughts my question is what is the criteria that Los virist uses to choose to celebrate so this new policy permits under Edco 37 3722 to Zer I think it allows the board um to designate holidays specific to a district and and and includes a negotiation with um the unions in that process so this this policy doesn't prevent you from doing that it's actually adding language that permit you to do that per Ed code so it doesn't specify which ones but it does give the board permission to do those exclusively to the district so the policy that's in front of it is in front of us if we approve it today we don't necessarily have to add things right now that can be a later discussion it does
267give you the right to do that yeah I mean if no one else wants to well and I I think that what you were talking about U Mr Lazar is more of a commemorative um exercises as opposed to a holiday which absolutely right yeah so and so maybe we can also um you know in a Friday letter or something um get some information for all of us including Mr Lazar on the criteria what we actually celebr and how you choose uh which ones to celebrate within the classrooms within schools does that make sense absolutely okay happy you do that what what's an example of a um patriotic daily exercise that a high school would do as opposed to saying the Pledge of Allegiance it's actually pretty broad under red code so I'm just wondering for
268like a real like what's a what what happens I don't think is do you guys see the pledge allegiance at calabas high school every day I think they do yeah every day yeah really once a week I'm not advocating for I'm just curious because this says daily so so so high school it doesn't say daily it actually does the way you have it worded because you've changed you've moved the sentencing around so it says each School shall conduct patriotic exercises daily which may include the pledge of allegiance to flag un it just say each School in that section right so they're not required to say the Pledge of Allegiance they can also do a cultural understood but yes the change of the BP this what we're changing is before it was this elementary schools were
269required to do something every day and the flag pledge leaders was an example of that now we're saying each school so I'm just curious if we're going to go through the effort of passing a board policy and an AR what's the was this just because we feel like we had to do it because csba said to do it or are we actually going to have the high schools do they get guidance on here are the 10 things that are um patriotic that you can do and one must be done each day so this is a change for Ed code it's not it's from SBA but this is actually the wording is actually taking from Ed code which we didn't previously have um which is actually saying this is what we have to do um Matt
270says that Agora High School does it every day College of Allegiance I think they have red white and blue in their colors that's probably why Cal you're black and gold come on uh no so is it is it is that required so it's not not the not the pledge allegiance but so learning about patriotism love of country how the country developed in terms of the Pledge of Allegiance those would be all the things that would meet this requirement as opposed to just saying the Pledge of Allegiance I'm just again curious sorry but but how are we how do we know that's happening every day I'm I'm not advocating that we have to we're passing a board policy that says it has to so it does per Ed code and we'd have to further look into
271that which we're happy to do Dr scan andite to give you guys that information in a Friday letter in terms of what each school is doing it sounds like Agora is doing the pledge which fulfills that if calabases is doing cultural and are patriotic events to take the place we're happy to get you that information I would maybe love that Fray yeah we come back and vote on it in two weeks great idea we approve the uh board policy well that's actually in the AR okay oh we don't we don't approve ARS do not come before that's actually but this is a bpn AR RW correct but the won't come back no I just want the BP to come back right right what you're talking about is in the right oh it is so yeah
272so you know what can you can you when we vote on the board policy can you give us that information at that time even though it's not 100% you know specifically in the board policy it's covered under the AR it's blanket so thank you than you uh can we move on y revision of board policy and AR 61 41.2 recognition of religious beliefs and Customs so again ours was last updated in 2001 there have been pretty significant changes since that time and this updated policy reflects recent guidance from the US Department of Ed regarding constitutionally protected prayer and religious expression in public schools also from appendix F of the California Department of V history and social science framework which offers guidance and support for educators recognizing um religious beliefs and Customs additionally this policy was
273updated to add that instruction regarding the role of religion in society is be consistent with adopted instructional materials and state standards question um so uh I'm I'm broadly very much in favor of the policy uh I know we welcome all faiths into our district we also welcome non-believers uh and just a state I unequivocally believe in the separation of church and state um but uh you know one thing is that in terms of public Communications from the district I just wonder if we can wish uh folks of different religions uh you know to say merry Christmas happy Easter to those who celebrate uh Jewish holidays Rosa Passover puka uh Muslim holidays Ramadan perhaps Dali for um our our our Hindu students um you know I just think doing a shout out like that on on
274social media is not promoting a particular religion but it's it's kind of embracing the joy and the meaning that uh these holidays bring to folks and um you know I think they're often cultural large much more than religious anyway um you know I only ever see a sort of happy holidays reference or so um again this is not something I feel particularly strongly about but I I I thought I would throw it out there since this is a discussion about religion and it's not observing those holidays in any way but it's just it's nodding to students of different Fates in our district which I believe connects um it it it teaches other folks to respect other religions too and and be open-minded tolerant and and so on you know um again I don't know if
275this is a discussion relevant specifically to the policy that we have here but um more macro question um there was a belief at one time I'm not sure if it's still there that Santa hats are not allowed to be warn by staff on campus during the holidays is that accurate Santa Claus hats we've never discussed that it it has come up I I have received emails about this in the past i' never thought not allow to wear Santa Claus hat they Santa Claus hats were a religious item and could not have them uh uh be worn have one Santa Claus hats Dr Gleason has had and Dr cyer have had some interesting festive suits which I think bring joy to all those who gaze upon them so okay good let's want to get it out
276there let's keep those yeah all right again uh maybe in a Friday letter criteria for this the rationale behind this and we changed this many many many years ago from not getting into religious but more cultural things in our schools and in our you know so I don't I mean the policy is very clear just not to show a preference of one religion over another absolutely and that's really I mean it's not there's nothing else about it seems very straightforward I mean they literally Chang a couple words here and there so I was you know I'm sure somebody at the Ed Department gets paid by the PS they change um okay revision of administrative regulation 345 345 1.02 transportation routs and services home to school and return Transportation this is a very quick one I'm
277going to turn over to Dr Scot Mr President members of the board this is a quick revision um it's on line so currently our our policy states that for trips over 200 miles that um groups cannot use Rental Vehicles however um as time has progressed it's becoming very cost prohibitive for some of our smaller groups to travel um like to Sacramento for example um and they really need to be able to rent vans so an example would be um here we go um so to travel to Sacramento the cost for Vans would be about 4500 versus a bus would be about 10,000 versus a flight which is 13,000 and so we're requesting that we could just with the approval of the superintendent or design for groups that need to travel 200 miles or more um
278could seek that approval so this came through Safety Committee uh and the the we had a couple coaches I think speak or maybe was yeah uh yeah who spoke and I was not in favor of this actually uh because I was nervous about stepping away from a professional bus driver for Long Haul um where parent or teacher could be tired um but my understanding was so it was very compelling they laid out the reasons that it's for for some of these groups that are Booster funded it was becoming they couldn't even afford to go to some of these events because they were so expensive but we did am I correct to put in there that each and every one of these has to be I thought it was approved by the superintendent not designate it
279can't be done it can't be kicked down at the school level we want this kept at the district level okay so it wouldn't be like the because we want like someone taking a look at this and it still is only in the state of California if you leave out outside the state of California you still have to have a separate bus driver cross the state line is that correct so we we discussed that and because some there might be some trips to Vegas and so we we just narrowed it to 200 anything above 200 miles whether it's up north or okay to the East 200 miles that it's just with the approval and all secondary field trips come to me before I even give them to you guys and the driver is a district employee
280correct or could it be a volunteer parent it has it has to be somebody who's cleared by um the Department of Motor Vehicles to able to transport kids so okay I mean there are coaches who drive Who Who Are You know but it's somebody who's been licensed to be a TR that is correct great well like the the um the trip to Vegas for the um car team our engine team SEMA yeah um then those are usually they're driven by their own parents and that's okay okay no I it was a really good discussion so it made a lot of sense so appreciate you bringing it forward it was not it was not obvious that we would need this until they discussed it any other questions uh thanks board for a long meeting and a
281good discussion and I appreciate it and thanks staff for uh sticking through it and uh we will adjourn unless we want to stay for more BPS and ARS