CorpusRecord 40019

2025.01.14 School Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Las Virgenes Unified School District
Date
2025-01-16
Location
Los Angeles County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
31,548 words · about 176 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001all right welcome everybody Welcome to the first meeting of the New Year thrilled to have you all here quick mind if you please silence your cell phones and we'll start with we'll start with the Pledge of Allegiance U happy and thrilled to have a great Lindero student and boy scout Jacob Rosen lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance you can please come to the microphone here and lead us in the pledge we appreciate thank you e right for that we have report Clos session uh that brings us to uh it number one on the agenda today approval of the agenda I'll move to approve tonight's agenda I'll second a motion in a second to approve the agenda any changes or discussion if not all those in favor of approving the agenda student I just included

002all us I assume um motion to pass Dy um next item on the agenda approval the minutes uh may have a motion to approve the minutes I moveed to approve the minutes of December 10 second any discussion no all favor student member I board I I motion passes unanimously with that we'll turn over to staff board Communications Dr uh Mr President we have two wonderful staff we'd like to start off with recognizing so I'll meet you Dr Cy uh and then we'll get some principles and the individuals up at the podium Mr President the board each month lbsc uses our core dispositions to identify our employees of the month use criteria such asiance community at our school site and positive mindset uh we are so thrilled to have two folks with us uh tonight two

003things I think they very much share in common are that positivity that they bring to their sites and making learning fun some ofic that here miss Ken Eng I look right there from high school I think someone who brings joy to M absolutely if you go in her classroom you see real world problem solving opportunities they on her walls shirts on her walls that have all these fun math problems for students and she's truly as we enter her math adoption truly so know we want to leave way uh for our district and someone who also Ms that positivity or classified employee J poen uh po she is someone who I've known for a long time and I've never seen her not with that smile on her face um and she truly uh lifts people up

004around her so it's our pleasure to recognize these two folks tonight would love to begin uh with Miss Poland and Miss suzan ver if you both come to the podium and I'll pass it back to you good evening board members and uh Madam president and um all those here tonight thank you for joining us as we celebrate Jane um she is amazing uh Jane came to us just this year H from a right stole her and um she had really big shoes to fill but let me tell you those shoes are busting at the scenes so she's amazing she's always ready to do whatever is as of her and beyond always ready to take on any challenge and help us in any way possible so thank you for everything you do we are a much

005better campus with you there excited this is the first Apple I did to give away there are so many people who make this District work so amazingly well that they go UNS and what so amazing is the opportunity to highlight and call on out who does who who is not always in front center isn't seen all the time by everybody in the community doesn't see the impact you make but the smile on your face and the positive attitude you have I see it the meetings we've had together the past where you've been presid it's just it is infectious um and have that be kind of part of the Campus Community I'm so thrilled that you're there so on behalf of the whole board the very first Apple of 2025 thank you for all that you

006do thank you you know what I a little something I'm oh sorry I am truly honored to be named employee of the month it's a privilege to be recognized but honestly it's just an honor to be an employee of the lvu estate this district has always held a special place in my heart because my kids have had wonderful experiences at B Laurel stelle and now at CHS stelle specifically means so much to me my kids were lucky enough to have Miss be as their principal and now I'm thrilled to work alongside her and be part of the incredible stealth family um I if you told me years ago that I'd be working in education I probably wouldn't have believed you because my background is TV production and entertainment but life has a funny way of

007guiding you to where you're meant to be and once I stepped into this field I found my happy place middle schoolers are snarky loud and wacky with that's me actually may that's why feel such a strong connection with them they're perfect mix of chaos and potential and every day brings new challenges new laughs and new opportunities to make a difference working at lvusd isn't a job it's a calling and I'm so grateful to be part of the district that celebrates its people like me so thank you honor it means the world to me [Music] certificated Mr President uh members of the board it's my honor um to celebrate Miss Ken englas today a well-deserved certificated employ Employee of the Month um not only a wonderful math teacher but also has spearheaded our peer tutoring program

008and and has really grown it over the years so I just want to say thank you for all you do for our students at aora high school we appreciate you so much have heard this the last 12 months um for those of you who don't know we are spearheading an entire uh kind of new approach to teaching math uh that is a completely different approach that is guide by state standards that is requiring to bring the entire her along in a way that is unprecedented you have done it with such Grace and charm and pivots and you know smiling but I'm sure you didn't want to smile um but I I as a board member but also as a parent of a gr high school math student and grateful that you are helping leading this

009effort but also just grateful for the energy you put in the classroom every day so on behalf of the whole District thank you very much for all that you do and thank you for all that you can do this year I'm truly honored and a bit overwhelmed to stand here before you today as teacher of the month I want to take a moment to express my heartfelt gratitude to each of you your support to me as a teacher as well as me the person the mother the wife the daughter the sister and the friend are part of what makes me proud to be part of L virous unified I find myself telling my daughter that sometimes you are who you associate with so surround yourself with people who make you a better person and make

010you proud of the person you are this is very true of my workplace I want to thank my colleagues and everyone I work with for helping me when I need to smile giving me advice when I don't know what to do and for helping me grow I'm so grateful to be surrounded by such an incredible team to my administrative team Mr Leo Mrs Brock Mr doson and Mr Oakman thank you for your support and confidence in me thank you for giving me the freedom to try things in my classroom and the voice to speak up when I have opinions and I have my of that even though my family can not be here because soft doesn't stop for anyone I want to thank them for their support through the hours of grading on the weekend

011weekends and the bleachers at softball games with the stories of the silly things my students say and the frustrating scores on many tests as I try to connect the boring hard unrelentless math lessons that don't relate to anything to the lives of high school students who cannot seem to see past Friday night I learned from them too they teach me that it's okay to try new things because sometimes the way we've been doing it for years just isn't working they remind me that there isn't one correct method to solve a problem in math or in life for that matter and most importantly they teach me how to interpret all the new slang that my 13-year-old so to my students I want to say thank you for reminding me why I became a teacher and constantly

012challenging me to be the best teacher I can being a teacher is a profound responsibility and an incredible joy every day is a new challenge a new experience and a new life it's not hard to smile when a student who hates math comes to class and tells you that I ruined their trip to Magic Mountain because all they can think about with the polinomial roller coasters we built in class it's hard not to see a smile not toile when you see a student have that aha look on their face when they've struggled so much it's hard not to laugh a little when a parent finally schedules a meeting with you only to get there and tell you that they thought they were coming to their English class not their math class I might be Miss

013English but I don't teach English in all seriousness I'm very honored and grateful to this recognition thank you the down here take a quick photo you want the last one I staff couple of updates let's see I'm so to start off with appreciation for all of our First Responders we have all seen we yeah they've been outstanding um it's been a tough tough week for the enti LA region I think we've seen a city that we love um uh you know some Bron's knes in the devastation is very impossible for me at this point to even grab get my arms around um so um Los VG we've been relatively blessed unfortunately we've been through this before with the Wy fire in 2018 so we've been here before with the 100,000 acre fire um but can't

014our First Responders and we were able to be in constant communication with them throughout this and appreciate they to keep us safe keep our community safe keep our people safe and our schools safe and up next Legend So a couple of details about that uh when we go through situations like this and this is again unfortunately not our first Ro and won't be our last bro um we're talking to lots of agencies um you've got Ellie County Fire which is massive they cover this area and all of the county this is the largest county in the United States with almost 10 million people inside the county the city of La alone I think has two or three million people in it so we talking LA County Fire we've got great relationship with County Sheriffs the

015larg sheriff's department the entire c as well there's 42 different stations just like Lost Hills so Captain C2 is our local Captain she's fantastic she's got kids in Las virgin schools and she and I text and call each other uh several times a day throughout the whole situation um uh Southern California Edison um yeah I paused intentionally um they've been a bit of a challenge um their Communications have been a bit of a challenge I think they um for 36 hours or so they show the power out to this building in a right next door um of course last couple days this building have not lost their power so um they've got a Monumental task on their hands I don't envy their position U but I will say they have posted several evening um phone

016calls with council members local leaders and Mr Lawrence and Miss Stein have been on those calls I joined one of them and I tell you Mr uh Lawrence was um one of the first to ask questions and one of the first to advocate for Clear Communications to our schools about what's going on making sure we're a priority at least in the information standpoint um so I I do want to publicly say thank you to M laws for you know um not you know raising quickly raising his hand being on these calls these calls are about an hour and a half long um and sometimes painful and um so I appreciate this time Mr L being on there and advocating for our schools and advocating for communication so that we can make the best possible decisions

017and really keep our students and staff safe City officials we've got four cities um and they've been fantastic to work with um near Conant communication with our two largest cities Gora HS and calasses um Mr hamburger and Mr Meeks we both fantastic to work with lot of communication with h Hills as well in westle um and local donation center has been part of what's going on along with our local Partners Boys and Girls Clubs YMCAs different groups like that so constant communication um when these kind of things my phone kind of blows up um and we kind of delegate different Communications and so multiple members of cabinet and the board talk with different agencies uh throughout all of these things so you don't see much but but trust me there's a not going below the

018service I wanted I was about do now you're coming I want to just commend you and your team for the amazing talk now the amazing work I don't think folks realize just how they think that everyone was off Wednesday Thursday Friday and what what struck me that I was perhaps most touched by was that with power out here power out to the community you all still came in managed to do handwritten checks for our hourly employees so they could get paid um that is not something most people would think about they would think that well we can't we can't mail the checks we can't process them the PO is out the do what do we do we recognize we have a significant portion of our community that is living paycheck to paycheck or not having

019a paycheck but be critical so I'm I'm tearing up because I was extremely touched by the fact you figur out a way to get by candle light or by I don't know how you did it but you hand wrote checks to all ourly employees and make sure they got paid on Friday and I know you did a million other things but that one thing to me I think speaks to the level of commitment you had to do all the big you did all the big things but the fact you figured out those types of things and took care of our people really spoke volumes to me so extremely appreci I know that every decision you made was based on a ton of coordination law enforcement a ton of coordination with sois and with the belief

020that we had to keep our students safe so I appreciate you your entired staff I know every time I called you everybody was out Fanning out as power out as not out like you didn't sleep um and so I it's very grateful appreciate onal of the whole board yeah I I just really want to Second what Dall said you know looking after one's own family was so challenging during the past week and the fact that the administration was also you know working on the response to this fire 24/7 and I saw it kind of firstand as a board member for the first time I I was just so impressed and so grateful to everybody I you promise I try to lose sleep so parents out there can get some sleep I promise I try some

021so as m just mentioned there's no priority uh that was a post that was up today on one of the Facebook pages we so appreciate that um you know we safety of course is the priority safety of our students our staff our community as well we don't want to do anything that you know endangers the areas around us but at the same time we know how valuable certainly after coming out the pandemic but beting together is what a grounding experience it is um and that isolation is not good for little ones or adults either so next slide uh picture on the right hand side is white o elementary yesterday um which was fantastic to see so some of the factors when we go into this uh there's a lot of things we do we look

022at fire condition surface wind speeds relative humidity droughts unstable air um we're looking at everything we're watching all different sorts of websites we're texting communicating all the time 5: in the morning sometimes I think Mr CL was up at 4 this morning checking stuff out for us powers of schools a priority we're working with Edison to figure out that along with our cities which are super helpful I believe the neighborhood right next to us is out of power right now which is quite a challenge um we get constant reports from Edison we spent the last two nightes on you know hour and a half long phone calls with them from across the region and of course information for our First Responders we're checking with them all the time we offer our facilities as well we're

023not just asking for help we're offering help as well many times the fire department's used our schools as headquarters or command posts AC was used um if you saw the bulldozers that pushed cars out of the way on Sunset uh Kern fire County brought those in and parked those at AC cell uh and actually left the truck several other fire vehicles there the trucks dropped the bulldozers off and then came back and they used AC St as a staging ground for those very own bulldozers next slide here a couple photos of course the P fire was devastating and heartbreaking and again kick the arm of course around us we had the cannon fire um and that was 1,000 acre fire or 1,50 Acres um the top red photo is is um from um Mr anholt's

024yard in fact Mr anh's with us right there so that's the fire coming out he lives just above loopin on right bottom right hand side is how close it came to the houses I really came right down kind of like a on top of the entire region the fire came up to the edges and a left- hand photo there you can see smoke a b over looping um I know the principal I know Miss Davenport Miss faul and I were out there was it Saturday morning to check yes Saturday morning 9:00 a.m. to check the campus it was our closest our most exposed campuses checked air quality check the facilities was fantastic all our principles got out Sunday morning as well sorry Sunday to all their campus that check them uh maintenance operations with checking

025them the entire time with all the wind you got trees you got branches that kind of thing one things to be safe uh so herculan effort uh on that we also do practice a lot of question about evacuations we do practice evacuations we parking RoR we bring in buses we do a police escort um so we we do work on these sorts of contingencies um and we don't like to work on them we don't like to think about them but they are a reality of ours and now you've had you know two significant fire events in the last six years next SL um M we were here so on the top left hand side we're at Linder Canyon Linder had power the entire time so lindera became our district uh uh headquarters uh this building

026had no power no internet no Wi-fi no communication so Mr an was very generous to let me use his office for uh probably about 4 days in a row I appreciate thatal that's the lobby of Lind Ro multipurpose top left and bottom right Mr Lawrence mentioned on Friday we have about 100 of our staff that don't have direct deposit they're part-time or substitutes and so we arranged for hel County to drop off those checks that morning and then opened up for several hours so those staff could come on by and pick up a check and it was great to see staff and they really appreciated seeing us in the lobby the building because the building had no power we Jim U Mr Clen was able to rig uh Wi-Fi and internet so we gathered in

027the lobby um because we like each other number one um and number two because we had some light uh and enforceable companionship some of the things we think about regarding our buildings facilities I mentioned that we check them connectivity our sites medicine we have a lot of medicine Store to our campuses and we lost Refrigeration so students lost medication so we had to figure that our nurses uh had to double up and get to work on that piece of it um at the bottom there's meals we lost Refrigeration if you lost power you lost refrigeration and all the food in there quickly went bad so same with us we got 15 campuses with refrigeration that went you know down and south on us and so when we get back up uh how can we uh

028be prepared to offer meals we have about 30% of our students on free reduced lunch payroll we mention of course counseling support services and resources family and staff and families next line photo from White o on the right hand side just today uh super exciting so display students um obviously uh you know we've seen the devastation know how many structures were burned in several fires throughout La region um and number of schools have gone up and so families have reached out and we've had five students so far enrolling and of course our welcome man is out and we've briefed our office managers on that uh it's quite unusual circumstance because they'll show up and you know they'll say my school doesn't exist anymore and my house doesn't exist anymore and say can't you know we

029have a number of documents request and they're not going to have those and so we need to have special procedures in place and certainly empathy and heart uh ready to receive them because they're going through a lot um you know just to find a school is is just such a grounding experience and to you know to build a new community temporary or long term so our welcome as that we appreci appreciate our office staff and our office managers and our principles for being uh so welcoming um and we will be offering support uh throughout the region I continue to be in contact with law enforcement uh fire and see what they need as things evolve next slide I think that might be yep that's it little to the to the fire so um got a

030lot of Staff in the room so I appreciate our staff and their flexibility appreciate parents flexibility we're going to have some more eroms go out real soon we had a great day yesterday great day today Edison took power down for about an hour and a half out of board High School medison thinks the power is still down we've tried to tell them the power's up it's been up for about 36 hours um so we appreciate the staff flexibility there um and we're still making some adjustments obviously high schools and there there aren't many exams in midle school but um majority of the high schools move the exam schedule uh back a week for students I know uh several exams two exams took place beforehand if they could go have math exams before the winter break

031they've started shifting both high schools have shifted some ofar exams to before the winter break um so that's fantastic that those are already out the way so aren't many left but we wanted to push that uh timeline back appreciate High School's working quick to do that next slide of course we have showcases I think uh showcases are do start tomorrow uh and so we want to give everybody more time and maybe keep a few cars off the roads and so we're going to put those showcases back calabases is tally rescheduled from Fe 6 6: to 8 p.m. aore is still working on a date um but just know those those um showcases that were scheduled in g c for this week are not happening they are postponed we push that out on social media next

032slide ending on a positive note some positivity we' got the battle bands coming up a bunch of talented students and we take the stage at The Canyon Club and so uh we're excited about that I think there's some of the band's names up there in fact the foundation is putting that event on for us it's uh Sunday February 2nd it's the week after the NFC championship AFC championship games are the week before the Super Bowl so there's no football come on out I think the Gram's might be later on that day so come by The Canyon Club um and get a get some great student music support the foundation all of our schools and get warmed up for the Grammy Awards later on that evening Rel to school safety um we are working on some

033really Innovative approaches because we know unfortunately hopefully if this is our last but it certainly might not be um if we see the trends in in increased ferocity and size so we are working on Innovative approaches to make sure that we can keep everyone safe as possible and Communications are a big part of that something happen with quick evolving situations the Kenneth fire is a great example of that which about 1,500 1,50 acres in 2 hours right so we need to be able to get information out and we've got some you know a lot of canyons in the area difficult Sal signal those kind of things in challenging areas so and if power goes down it makes things more complex so Mr Klein um he's super Innovative and we' been talking about this for a

034while but we're hting the gas on this initiative and move forward a little bit faster so he's got um something that's going to we're working on to get out to all School sites to increase uh connectivity communication and student safety what we have CL all right Mr President members of the board uh uh I am the one who usually brings the toys so I get the the lucky job of doing that and as you know SC has been both somewhat illogical and relatively unreliable they shut down our power for days and days at the time for no reason I know my uh my secretary actually still has her power out up the street for no logical reason uh and they're keeping it off for days and days at a time which they've never done in

035the past if you recall the last fire the last fire we lost power for maybe 24 36 hours and the power came back and we were able to fun function this time it with days and days one of the things that we have talked about in safety and wellness actually before the fall before all this happened in anticipation of this is we are building out uh some kits that we're going to have build at all the school sites for an emerg situation it looks like this gra all right so this this is basically what we're going to call Go kid and this is essentially going to give us connectivity internet access phone service Emergency Radio Service everything in a pinch if we really needed runs entirely on a battery it's in a Pelican case like

036this it can be wheeled out to anywhere it doesn't weigh a ton uh and basically if we have a situation where everything goes out everything goes down no Communications whatsoever a principal or administrator School site will be able to just wheel one of these anywhere they need to go office wherever and open it up and light it up and they would have internet access and they would have phone access and they would have emergency radio access all of that so this little case is kind of cool this inside a case you'll see they've got a phone and a wireless access point so this would actually give them access for their phones or for their computers as well if they need to give any systems we have a starling mini dish right here that they would

037just set out it's going to have a really long cord a long cord like this that they can pull out the side of the case and set it outside a door if they needed to and have the rest of the kid inside the door uh it has network switch so they can plug in a device as well so we basically have full connectivity for any School site it actually we rigged it to run off of DWT batteries the same batteries that you'd have with drill or saw or something along those lines readily available we can charge tens of them hundreds of them at a time if we needed to we have a swap batteries on the Fly and keep this thing running for days and days to days if necessary so this would give us

038the capacity to maintain communication to to deal with all the emergency situations talk to First Responders talk district office Ure our radios work all of those things on already that's so is the plan to have these already deployed at all the schools or you bring these out of the schools the plan would be to have one for school so we're going to make sure every school has one in their office and is kind of like the emergency backpack this would be the emergency communications kit so grab plug in so it's charged at all times yeah it's going it's going to have batteries so batteries you just grab the batteries plug the batteries in thing lights up and you're Off to the Races so pretty good it's common batteries so if you need to drive down

039the street where there's power you can drive down to Home Depot you can pick up some more batteries you buy some more batteries or we call M guide and say hey guys you can bring some of your deol batteries out and plug them in and they'll continue to work so you also saw that we use the pickup trucks the electric trucks that we purchased remember we talked about using those for Generation we did use those doc step showed the U the lobby and has having internet access the way we made that happen was they actually pulled the pickup trucks up to the building did a long extension cors up over the roof into the server room and lit up the servers and and the switches so that we can get on the internet so that

040is an additional strategy to keep a School site up for a short period of time but this is kind of the super emergency you know earthquake catastrophic kit that we'll be able to use no matter what thank you thank you appreciate you being Forward Thinking and uh as we always say Jim has all the best chys all the best tech that concludes [Music] St all right let's see start with go for there we go um Mr President members of the board uh gor calabasis are gearing up the new year really by diving into the books and getting ready for finals uh to offer a little bit of a reprieve uh gorah High has the Diary of B Frank play coming up it will yeah the first show will be Thursday it's running until Saturday night

041there will be four shows it'll be in the black box if you haven't bought your tickets yet make sure to do so they're going out really quickly um aore High School is also planning an event to um benefit those who are affected by the nearby fires we really feel for everyone in our communities and we want to do our best to help uh on a little bit of a lighter note tonight was senior night for a girls waterf where they 12 to 7 and and a lot of our a lot of our other sports are really revving up as they visional play we have boys and girls uh both soccer and basketball as well as wrestling Cabas sports teams are also beginning leag play as well we're really excited to see how our teams do

042um lastly I we really want to offer our condolences to all impacted by the fire and we continue to wish the for the health and safety of everyone in our communities um I'm really looking forward to seeing D Frank by the way s great um so uh it's obviously been a very challenging week for everybody uh as I mentioned very grateful for the administration uh I did also just want to mention the um responders particularly the fire department you know around when the Kenneth fire got started Calabasas was pretty apocalyptic brought back horrible memories um of the Wy fire uh we were expecting the same thing to happen and literally with a couple of hours our local firefighters showed that fire who was boss and I am so so grateful to them as I know

043everyone year is uh it's big hand for the I'm very very grateful um that no one in our district has suffered a loss of life property to our knowledge um I have 25 friends and colleagues who lot of homes I think every everybody here probably knows somebody or was connected to somebody uh who has gone through this I'm so very grateful our district was unscathed um you know for our 10,000 students I think uh this was of course very challenging though many went through evacuations uh I know the kids have all been sharing really um scary videos and photos and stuff on their phones um and I'm very grateful that lbusd has strong support for mental health uh and that it will be here uh in the weeks to come um on a more positive

044note I had the pleasure of touring sumac with Miss Stein Miss cutle and I will be touring a bunch of schools shortly uh Mr Lawrence and Miss mangas I would love to tour School schools with you too I want to check in on every single campus in the district and very much looking forward to it thank you very much thank you very much I just want to Echo what everyone else said it's been a uh very kind of heartbreaking and devastating start to the new year so of course our hurts go out to all the communities that have been um that have that have uh weathered this uh destruction so far and again I just want to give a shout out to Dr Steep and this cabinet team because I know Dr step um has

045been working 247 so please know getting the communications out getting everything um all of our cities too trying to get the best information out to you um it's been a herculan effort and as we've all suffered outages with power and uh there's nobody that I'd rather be in a crisis with than Dr Steph so thank you but no more we don't want any morees so um I I just also would like to Echo everyone's thank yous to the First Responders to our teachers and to our faculty and uh cabinet members um it's been a Herculean effort I have a family out of the area out of state and they they're reaching out to me and I keep saying you know I think today is the worst day and tomorrow's going to get better and then

046another fire breaks out and so I just really appreciate everyone's endurance and um everything that they're doing to keep our district moving forward I'll just be brief I want to and my heart goes out to all our families and our staff who um were affected everyone was affected to some degree I think the stress and the the power outages there's a lot to process a lot to deal with uh it's scary for kids um you know I think we've all seen the devastation I know we all know someone I know Miss Stone and I were just discussing a mutual friend who um we've known forever who is the pastor of the Palisades Methodist Church who's lost both the church and his home and we um you know but we're very lucky I was so worried

047about L and hill during Kenneth fire um apart from trying to get myself stucked together so over the moon that that they they did get on top that so um hopefully you know so far January hasn't been terrific but um so I feel you can now still say Happy New Year to people like we've extended we're going to start over uh thank you you know the only thing I would offer is um because I think it's I think it's important we're not quite at the look back postmortem phase of this but I do think it's important that we that we collectively there's a good audience here um if you unhappy with how your power was shut off or your level of communications you need to stay engaged the next six months um SoCal Edison was

048an unmitigated disaster when it came to how they communicated their Community um they didn't even know grow high school is out of power till I called them um and even when I called them they said it's not out of power and that's how bad their systems are uh this is just not officient and this is not what I would expect from the fifth largest economy in the world that you find in California it's what I expect to find the third world country where I've spent a lot of time um so we are going to need to collectively keep their feet to the fire or they're going to do what they do that is hopefully a year goes by we forget and they take their $1.5 billion do in profit and don't reinvest it back into

049the GD um so I think it's it's going to be a hot button topic I mean there were people not happy on those calls um you had state senators and state legislators who weren't able to reach SoCal Edison who joined the call just to scream at the CEO of SoCal Edison uh but collectively people in this room in the community if we if we stay engaged this can change um soal can change and the culture of ineffective communication and um just just not really thinking um is what it comes down to um not really thinking about the impact of the decisions on schools on hospitals on other activities and understand the role they play in our community so I would encourage you all to please stay engaged um with that on the on the tone

050of Engagement we have a couple uh items uh people who join speak today and items not on the agenda most of you were here to speak about cell phones that is on the agenda so that you're going to have to wait till that time comes up we have a few call a few items people want to speak I done on the agenda and with that I will start with our very first one Gavin tesser you want to come to the microphone you'll have three three minutes uh will there be a thing Y at what point when it's over or just when it's over but there's a timer on the screen there's a timer on the screen that gives you we won't start this there a timer on the screen that tells you please say your

051name and uh so my name is Gavin um and I'll get to that later but so imagine a world where our children inherit a planet crippled by environmental degradation is this the Legacy we want to leave behind now imagine the opposite a world where districts students staff everyone comes together to actively address climate change to ensure the future of people of all ages I understand this may be a challenging time for many reasons and I and I know many of you know people who have experienced great loss or tragedy and my heart goes out for everyone who has been affected um however I firmly still believe that addressing climate change is still important um even during difficult times like these um and I did uh consider postponing this discussion but after several delays I realized

052they may there may never be a perfect time so here I am um and to that my name is Gavin tesser and I'm a junior at cabasas high school and I want to dedicate my life to environmental reform and like all of you I have been affected by the recent fires um and tonight I am here to speak in support of the climate emergency and action committee resolution which will one declare climate emergency and two create a climate um action and resilience committee or carf and I'm asking that this resolution which has been shared with staff and um the school board be formally added to a future agenda for discussion um and we are in the midst of a climate disaster that directly affects our schools our students and our community um the the carbon

053dioxide levels in the atmosphere are over 420 parts per million which is over 40% higher than they were in pre-industrial levels and our students are directly affected through this through heat waves through the recent wild fire smoke which um threatens student health and um we can no these are challenges we can no longer afford to ignore and we Are Not Alone um in in addressing the urgency of climate change there have been many other school districts such as LV USD um San Diego us USD and Berkeley USD that have taken action to address climate change for example in 2021 LV USD School Board passed a climate action plan um which they are currently working on implementing a climate literacy um program for all grade levels and this ensures compliance with State of California Senate Bill

054AB uh or assembly Bill AB 285 and I've heard um many concerns from the district that climate change may not be within the School Board of Education scope um but the reality is that climate change has already deeply impacted our school district um as seen through the recent F wildfires and supporting this resolution would demonstrate um LV usd's responsibility to not only prepare students academically but for the challenges we will inherit in the future um and that is climate change and yeah I'm uh just I wanted to reiterate that I'm asking for this um resolution to be formally Place placed on a future agenda and thank you for your time and consideration and let's save our planet together thank you thank you for coming in thank you for your passion you're such a great speaker

055nobody knew your microphone wasn't even on because your you present so well so you filled the room well done our next speaker um Noel MCM Morris I believe hi everyone um my name is Noel like Davin I'm a junior at cabasas high school and I'm also very passionate about climate change and climate advocacy um I'd say that I first really got inspired about climate change five years ago when I saw in the news that this girl who was you know just around my age G thunberg was sailing across the Atlantic on a little sailboat and she was speaking at a United Nations conference and her dedication really inspired me and ever since then I've been very involved in climate action I did a lot of research about how animal agriculture is related to climate change

056which led me to adoptive even lifestyle and um through Peta to LA County which I've been co-leading for the past couple of years I've organized many events to educate the public about how important it is that we are taking climate action in our own lives and I've also done many things through uh my school and through my school district like adopt getting plant-based lunches at my um high school and also working with Gavin to get a composting program at our school and I see so much potential for even more climate action through our school board and um I'm not the only one who feels that way we actually conducted a Sur survey of cabasas and aora high school students and we saw that 93% felt that it was very important that lbusd be taking climate

057action and 83% were in favor of creating this um youth board that would uh be helping with this climate action in LBD and I just truly believe that it is such an important issue especially in these times with the wildfires we're seeing that the climate catastrophe is truly starting to affect us and it's so important for Our Generation especially as we really don't know what the future can hold and we want to be doing everything we can within our power to be uh allowing ourselves to have a future and our kids to have a future and and so on and so I feel very passionately that there is so much that our school district can be doing with climate change and I feel that this passing this resolution would be such a great way for

058students to be getting involved and to be taking action um through the school board which really does have a lot of potential um again I feel very strongly about this resolution passing and I thank you so much for your time and everything that the school board has done throughout all of these fires and these difficult times just goes to show how much we can do when we come together for our planet thank you thank you one more speak Antonia I can't quite make out [Music] lasta three minutes thank you um everyone my name is Antonio Dre and I'm here with my friends Gavin and Noel I'm a junior cal bassas high school um and I wanted to talk to you about a slightly different lens of the this climate crisis so mental health is something

059that I've always been incredibly interested in and this passion has only grown and intensified as I've gotten older I've recently founded a nonprofit organization the youth Minds initiative and uh we raise awareness for mental health importance in schools and we're currently advocating for a political change towards an increase in uh resources and services in California schools um because of my activeness in the field of mental health I'm here today to advocate for the climate emergency and AD resolution um the reason that I believe this resolution would help is because of its relation to a new phenomenon called ego anxiety uh ego anxiety occurs when someone has chronic fear or stress about environmental issues and climate change and especially in light of the current events of so many people have um so many relations to happening

060in our area including the multitude of tragic wildfires um we want to do everything we can in order to address um the impact of climate change and to promote a sustainable future um for my for future Generations as my friends Gavin and the well said and all things considered I wanted to I'm just here to explain that there are serious ties between mental well-being in students and um ego anxiety that's been prompted by climate crisis in general and by these fires thank you so much I have any other cards for people who want to speak at items not on the agenda is that correct wonderful with that we will move to um our first items of the day uh item schedu for Action uh consent a I move to approve consent I just have aou

061questions let's get a second no questions I'm sorry motion a second while we go discussion um I have four points so I I'll just mention all of them all quite simple points uh just the items around National University for student teachers and interns I was just interested if we already have agreements with other universities uh to do this okay great um the other thing is the two items on the pool at a gura I'm fine with but I I do still need to be updated on the pool in general um you know I I need to get out the feet on some of the measure s projects and just kind of want to understand where it's at and what the process is but I'm assuming that doesn't need to happen at this Mee that can

062happen I mean h to take 6 seconds you want to update we can I know I know we're Full Speed Ahead going as fast as humanly possible but yeah you want to is it is it more detailed do you want to take it offline or do you want to if it's gonna hold us up can wait I'm happy to approve the two items um there's a fourth the uh third thing is the item on the toilet room upgrade at chaperel when I looked um the word is referred to around me so it which needs to be fixed um and then the final question might be a dumb one one but I noticed that basketball hoops were being attached to the solar panels of year before and uh if kids are kind playing basketball around panels

063that's a very good question something I can definitely look into tomorrow I do know the B Administration is put safety first so uh got to figure out what's going on out there uh it's not where the Bal panels are is not really a place where you would shoot poop so it's interesting you I think there was four basketball GRS being attached to the structure for the solar panels which I don't maybe it's you know seems wrong yeah me the Hoops are the Hoops lit up solar I I would I would suggest that we continue on and approve it and uh if it's if if it should come back us he can pull it I want to make sure I you want where what I number was that check it is theal for acceptance of notice

064of completion for the toilet room upgrade Elementary okay it refers on the background to round meow Elementary and I know there was a contract for threee elementary schools but I believe that should refer to Sher okay well just maybe amend your motion motion to approve consent a with the change item 16 to make sure it reflects shaer Elementary School is that okay great we have a motion at second all those in favor student vote I board vote I I gets his toilet all right need those consent B I'll move to approve consent B motion second this is a board vote only uh board all those in favor I I I motion passes unanimously action items item number one approval the 2025 board committee appointments the most controversial thing vote on today uh um I like

065a motion I'll to approve the okay there I got right there's a motion to second to approve the 2025 Bo committee appointments all those in favor student vote board I I wonderful uh approval acceptance of Auto report for 2324 Mr President um we have the audit report presented for the board tonight and two board members individually the Auditors the auditor is on the screen and we'll be able to answer questions uh and present to the board as well I want to thank Dr GLE and staff for their hard work on this audit um got a lot of new members on the team uh including in the new role and they've been very serious about this very detailed about this a lot of improvements with this audit so I want to publicly thank him for his

066hard work on that he's restructured the team brought in fantastic people um they they excellent communication up and down and working hard to ensure the highest of standards in our fiary responsibilities Rel Dr Mr President members of the board excited to share with you we have Jessica Barry here from mro and mro I'm G hand it off to her of course the audit is an independent about it conducted by the board two board members on our finance committee have met independently with Miss Barry I just want to thank Miss Barry her team who's uh has the highest level of professionalism support and it's a pleasure to work and collaborate and learn uh from her which is a big part of this question so miss Barry thank you appreciate the introduction as was said my name

067is Jessica Barry I am a partner with Nigro and Nigro and we've been um retained as your independent auditor what I normally do for these presentations is spend a little bit of time going through our audit process as it takes place throughout the year and then go through the audit report itself and kind of highlight what the main sections are and then I'm more than happy to answer any questions you might have at the end of that or dig into more details in any specific area so as it comes to our audit process it's really something that's taking place throughout the year before It culminates ultimately in the report we start with site visits usually kind of early spring actually our firm is gearing up for these right about now at this point we're taking

068a sample of your individual School sites and we're on location at those sites and we're testing controls and compliance over attendance taking procedures as well as ASB transactions that are handled at a site level if that's a site that has asbs obviously attendance is a main driver for a lot of your different funding sources and so I want to make sure there's proper controls and compliance over the attendance taking procedures move forward a little bit later on into the year usually kind of late spring early summertime we do our first district office visit at this point we're not looking at final numbers because the books are not closed yet for the year but we're really looking at controls and compliance so we P sample of a lot of different types of transactions this can be

069um checks going out money coming in payroll transactions some different journal entries and we look at those to make sure there's proper checks and balances they're supporting documentation that ties out to the individual transactions again really looking for those controls those checks and balances we conduct questionnaires with different staff around the district have them walk them walk us through their processes and make notes on that as well and then we also spend some time on state and federal compliance so there's certain level certain items of State compliance that are required that we go through this is quite a variety this can be anything from certain notices that have to go to board by a date or whether or not particular expenditures are allowable under a certain program so really a lot of different things that

070are prescribed by state so we spend some time going through that as well as Federal programs you have a lot of different Federal programs that you receive money for and so we have a rotating basis of federal programs we're testing a few of different ones each year based off how large the expenditures were out of those programs on any given year so fast forward again and then later on into the fall we come back for our final District visit and at this point books are closed we're really shifting our Focus primarily to the financial so we're working our way through your unaudited actuals and tying out the numbers that are presented there to actual documentation so this can be tying out your cash balances to cash and County reports or bank statements tying out the

071accounts payable to individual invoices things like that again really working through your un audited actuals and your various funds and tying those numbers out to different exhibits or documentation all of that leaves to leads to this lovely audit report maybe a little bit on the dry reading side but I'll just kind of go through and give some highlights and how this is laid out the very very beginning of the report after you get past table of contents is our opening opinion letter and this is what's known as an unmodified or a clean opinion it's what you would be hoping for the opinion is stating that we agree that the financial statements as presented here are presented fairly in all material aspects so that's really the heart of that opening opinion letter after that the next

072uh roughly 10 pages or so is what's known as Management's discussion and Analysis so this gives summarized financial statements the full financial statements follow it but summarized financials and it also gives comparative information so it has the current year being 2324 as well as the prior year financials and some very brief explanations of kind of what went down what went up what kind of the reasons were on that so I sometimes jok refer to this as the cliff notes of the audit report that's presented in the front there after you get past this there are the full financial statements for the school district governments are a little unique and that they have to report under two different accounting models so there's really two sets of financial statements with reconciliations between each and so that's what

073the bulk of the financial statements are there after those financial statements really the main part of the audit the most number of pages is related to notes these are different accounting policies and procedures that have to be disclosed there's also a lot of required disclosures when it comes to debt your pensions your OPB obligations have the lengthiest disclosures that are presented in those notes and then following the notes there's several different schedules in the back uh again pension and OPB are really probably the lengthiest schedules that are presented there but there'll also be a budgetary comparison schedule a schedule that shows your average daily attendance your instructional time as well as your federal expenditures and what different Federal programs you spent money out of so that's really what those main schedules are following the notes

074after we get past that we get into some additional letters in the back so that we had that opening opinion letter on your financials and then in the back there's three different letters there's one according to governmental auditing standards one for State compliance and one for federal compliance and all of these were unmodified or clean opinion letters in the back and then after you get past the opinion letters we have one table in the back that shows which federal programs we audit and then the results of the audit and a findings that were noted throughout the audit process so touch on those just briefly for this year there were three that were noted in the audit report there were no financial statement findings for this particular audit report there was just a single federal finding

075and then two State compliant so again non-financial these are compliance related areas the first one is dealing with documentation regarding uh graduation cohorts so Rel um to dig in a little bit um there's certain documentation when a student leaves the district or transfers out this is not necessarily saying that anything was recorded wrong it was just two students that we couldn't find the full details of documentation on when it came to how they were recorded again no Financial impact for that finding really just a compliance area second finding is dealing with the expanded learning opportunity program this is a brand new program it was the first year that it was under audit so 23 24 was first year for audit can you hear me I'm just randomly curious um I understand the point to be

076very detailed but why would it why would we have a finding in our financial audit for something that's not financially related so as part of the audits there are numerous different areas of federal and state compliance that were required to audit some of those carry Financial impact some of them carry no Financial impact but we are still required to audit those and just so that I'm clear because I know people will be watching later none of your findings had Financial impact correct um so none of them were related to financial statement presentation the other two could potentially have a financial impact but it wasn't related to financial presentation the first one would not have any type of financial impact at all so actually I'll jump into the next one then this was expanded learning opportunity

077program again new program this is the first year under audit I will say we audit quite a few school districts throughout the state this was probably the most common finding that I wrote throughout the year just because it was a new program kind of some growing pains for a lot of my districts a lot of information that was kind of released midyear clarified midyear by CDE so again this one's kind of it was a a work in process for a lot of my districts but but this one in particular really dealing with Transportation during the initial summer time that was offered so not issues with the program during the school year when it was offered during that time but having to have transportation when you had it just at one site during the initial summer

078session so really specific to that um this one could have a potential audit penalty CDE has still been a little um honestly wishy-washy as far as how they're implementing this so it's kind of waiting to see for some of my districts how that actually shakes out but we do have to report the potential there and then the very last one on here is dealing with attendance accounting so this was some actually pretty small Ada adjustments uh primarily as it dealt with non-public school attendance that comes in um typically speaking this was actually noted fairly early on in the year and normally for this is annual reporting there's a revision window that happens later on in the year in this particular year uh LA County was not allowing any districts to do revisions during that revision

079window so I actually did wind up with this at a few of my different um districts that work with Leo because they didn't wind up having that typical revision window open for annual reports again pretty small um unfortunately there's really no materiality threshold when it comes to anything state so even if it's just a tiniest bit off we still have to show it as a finding so that's what's stealing in that very last finding and then just to wrap up the end of the audit report after those findings um is the a list out of previous year findings and then the status of those and so actually all the findings that were noted in Prior year audit report were implemented we didn't have any repeat findings so again pretty brief overview but I'm more than

080happy to answer questions or maybe dig in more detail in any particular area um make a motion to approve first and I'll open for comments still move there a second um have for comments I just want to make sure we clearly hear because a lot of people listen to meetings don't hear something's correctly we received the highest level clean audit that you could give correct there's that there's there's there's no like 20 point scale on a 19 we got the we got the the clean no finding I forget the exact term for it um UniFi unmodified audit which is the gold stand correct yes it is an unmodified there's not different radiations of unmodified it's it's that is the standard thank you question uh yeah I had one note about on page 78 of the

081audit report where it does detail um the findings it says the district was unable to provide any written documentation to confirm that two of these students transferred out of the district and further down in the report under views of responsible officials it says the student in question attended a residential treatment facility was not tracked beond that placement which is completely understandable what were were both students ones that attended residential treatment facilities and were not tracked or was it just one okay it was just one of the two but I can let somebody else jump in on that as well this w so the other was result of some other issues um Dr uh I I believe it was one student to residential treatment facil so what happens with uh when you when you accept Federal

082Ming t one two three and four um we are supposed to by the law track when a student who received those funds leaves our district to make sure they land in a uh in a new laa the student in question uh left for to a residential treatment facility and that the facility received the care that they needed and then went and enrolled into school Beyond it's very hard to track a student after they leave an RTC and then where they go um certainly TI tighten that up um but I think Mr point is doing know with the second student the second student did you call the second student yeah I actually was just grabbing that one so um a little bit different on that one that um they had done an exit I'm sorry I'm

083just pulling up my notes on here but they had exited and we had notes or the district had notes that they had exited and where they were planning on attending but there wasn't like an ultimate confirmation that they actually landed at that school so it was kind of just not quite following the full end of the documentation Trail um just one other note just for the public and anyone watching that the audit does not refer to budgeting so there even though there's a lot about budgets in yeah this is not a meeting about budgeting where we would discuss bu budget items right um and also just to say there were issues with last year's report if we had had a change of leadership just congratulations to Dr de and his team because none of the

084the findings were repeated and it's clearly been you know really great Improvement and I think it's fair to say none of the findings from last year were material either yes as well I think yeah I don't think any school district gets five out a single something wrong so other questions no thank you uh Miss Stein and I met as part of our finance committee duties with our auditor earlier today so questions one of the reasons why there's not so much of reut for those in the audien is we have committee assignments the finance committee delves deep into this all year long and then spends half a day with the auditor in person in a back conference room going Page by Page to this and then comes forward and as our committee representatives are kind of

085the eyes near the board to take the Deep dive bottom line it's a clean audit and I want to thank um yes Miss Barry for taking the time out today meet with us and for everything that you do and Dr gleon your team it's still a relatively new Young team and again you are what we heard from Miss Barry is you open everything very easy to work with as far as sharing information and learning you know you're still as a team learning and and constantly improving and want to know you know how to do things better and again I think the big big thing here is nothing financially material here and the findings from last year all corrected so so they went in again and examine those and so who do to plan call to

086vote student vote you can't protest you I Mr CL he's getting a red flashing blindly um item number three resolution 1124 determination of seniority among certificated employees same already date I break from resolution Mr President M of the board look forward 256 school year there's also potential for flu fluctuation and program offerings du to fiscal considerations and or student preference anticipation potential fluctuation as it relates to Staffing Education Code 44955 requires that we provide tiate criteria for seniority and employes same start date resolution 1124 represents that affirmation pretty straightforward we this over here is there support well I think I think for people watching who haven't heard this before what happens is Teachers tend to be hired in groups so that if a lot of them start at the same day if you have layoffs

087how do you know which ones everyone has the same seniority so because some positions are harder to find certain um in secondary so we have to establish some criteria and that establishes seniority to that situation Happ and so that you don't have 40 people started on the same dat excellent there a motion to approve so move I'll second great there's a motion to Second all those in favor of resolution 1124 uh excuse me student M hi board members hi motion passes number four approval B6 with qualia Madam president members of the board uh we have a property down the street in Los virgus Road uh that used to be Indian Hills High School uh as we have shifted and evolved over time that's uh that property is now rented by Paia a private school they've

088been a um a good tenant and are interested in renewing um our lease with them for an additional five years with the option on the district side to continue that Ral moving forward recommendation from staff is to approve it does bring in about three $300,000 in annual revenue um of course this has been discussed with financing facilities commit F okay any questions just one question are we getting fair market value for that property right or fair market value or better when uh when you have I'm GNA give you there's two two things consider when that lease I I pretty close to when that lease was formed it was a very different time it was coming up of uh right around the pandemic commercial property was not interesting it was hard for us to rent a

089space and so we made we have a an attractive agreement for a tenant if we were to make that agreement again today we would structure it differently on the current economic model the challenge is if we were to renegotiate we would need to reshow reopen re um and uh go through some high cost to try and get a better value cost benefit wise uh for dollar for dooll given all that and this is the best fiscal recommendation we can make to the bo absolutely and with what you said um prior terms have to be included or you have to go basically out the bid right out for okay and and there is it uh there is a CPI increase or 3% whichever is larger every year correct correct and uh yeah it is the Public's

090property which means there's a lot of protocols great any other questions with that I have uh motion to approve Le extension with call motion to approve have a motion and a second all those in favor got M um you can be third though motion second uh student member I four I motion passes unanimously um moving right along to information items uh superintendent committee assignments Dr stanowski Mr President the board there are two types of committees that Mr L mentioned earlier and those are board committees and superintendent committees do much of the work before items presented here open session uh this list there's no ask to take this list is the superintendent committees and one committee that was discussion was safety and wellness and my agenda item has miss cutell and miss Mingus on that that's

091correct okay terrific uh I thought the one who called it out is talk any questions from the board about the superintendent committee assignments I'm sorry I'm asking so many questions mind driv everyone great just to say that we obviously have theur Hills West Lake committee which I think is great um I do think there should be more regular set meetings um but as I'm going to be calabasis representative I have shaded to the city council members and two or three times a year we'll set up a meeting and have a formal meeting so that we have similar Communications to the gur which I think that's great I would just um I want to beat you I think you're probably say just you bring a board member with you to those because I'll probably bring two

092council members so bring two board members I'm happy to do it but of yes if they have two board members you take okay so there's two of you yeah great any other questions no next item a revision to board policy 5131 conduct Dr St Mr M of the board I believe uh Miss fa has the next I over to hands of M Mr President members of the board as you know csba periodically updates its policies based upon changes in law and or Ed code board policy 5131 was last updated in 2013 and in that board policy there was information about mobile communication devices that has since been taken out of this board policy and csba has created a new board policy which we will discuss next that does include information about mobile communication devices this

093proposed policy sets expectations for appropriate student conduct that's that does not infringe upon the rights of others or interfere with the educational program the policy lists a broad range of prohibitive behaviors and describes consequences for actions that violate district and school rules to the extent possible the policy minimizes specific references to technology and instead focuses on the big picture in terms of desired conduct I have a question okay Miss ful it says the superintendent or design shall ensure that each School site develops standards of conduct and discipline consistent with Bo policies and administrative regulations um and students and parents be notified of the uh district and school rules are they consistent if they develop them among School sites are they consistent with levels and so consistent with Ed code and what can be disciplined in

094Ed code sometimes the consequences may be different based upon the level of elementary middle and high our elementaries are the same our middle schools are the same and our high schools are the same terrific that's my question thank you very much other questions this will come back before the board in our next meeting to correct correct exist a board POS great really quickly sorry question um regarding there's a quote um talking about when a student uses any prohibited device um the a district of employee May conf confiscate the device even though technology is being removed from the specific policy could this policy still be used to apply to technology if me or is that addressed in would that be address the new be addressed in the next policy which is 5131 .8 yes so that's

095what we're going to discuss we'll include all of that okay so device does not necessarily refer to any technology would refer to a different project like no it would apply to any kind of device like a a laptop computer for example would be considered smart yes a smartwatch also okay so is this going to be cover in multiple policies or is this you you need to list so once the board adopts this it will be revised in all of our school bues okay was that a question yeah okay absolutely adopt new board policy 51 31.8 I um we have about 20 cards for folks who want to talk on this so what we'll do is we're going to have Miss SP give the presentation um we'll hear from people who want to speak and then

096the board will have discussion about it we're not voting today on anything um I seen the folks say Yonder bags on here there is no agenda for Yonder bags today uh this is a board policy related to um our off and Away policy U but looking forward to have you guys speak I would also say if you want to come together and if you all some you have the same to say want to stand next to each other in support and not go one by one you're welcome to do that too um but if you do want to uh speak or more than welcome to we'll call your names one at a time and you'll have three minutes to go ahead and give your statements with that Miss faul I'll turn it over to you

097again okay great um so this is a new policy csba adopted this policy 5131 .8 in 2019 Los virist does not currently have this policy because it was in our previous policy 5131 that was now been taken out and this new has been developed in alignment with 8272 which the governor signed which allows districts to limit or prohibit student smartphone use at school Under specific circumstances it also outlined guidelines for searching students devices confiscating them when necessary and disciplining off-campus shes that poses a threat or disrupt school activities in addition the proposed board policy includes language specific to Los virgines as directed by the governing board at the August 13 2024 board meeting and also has been discussed numorous times in the district safety and romness committee meeting with that said I have a short

098presentation and Alignment to that and if I could ask um Miss to come up do I have one so just to be clear I know Mr La said it the district has not adopted any policy so this is going to be what our current policy is and what options districts have in terms of what is allowed under AB 272 but to be clear none of this has been adopted by The District No recommended by the district just is simply an information so on July 1st 2024 AB 272 was signed into law this law allows but does not require a School Board to adopt a policy to limit the use of smartphones for by students when they are at school so it doesn't ban cell phones it allows the district to limit the use of cell

099phones the bill declares there is growing evidence that unrestricted use of smartphones by students during the school day interferes with the educational mission of schools lower student performance particularly among low achieving peoples promotes cyber bullying and contributes to an increase in teenage anxiety depression and suicide these findings are in line with numerous studies and recommendations for mental health providers some of which the district has provided to parents um in previous years so here's our current policy whoa what happened sorry trying to keep trying to keep up with [Laughter] you devices which are include smartphones and cell phones uses banned during school hours at the Middle School level it is the same policy uses banned during school hours currently at the high school students may use their mobile communication devices during nutrition and lunch except for

100exceptions that are permitted by law and they remain in place in L virgous and let's talk about what those exemptions are right and this is out of Ed code so this is not a lot virgous exemption these are exemptions in California Ed code one in the case of an emergency or in response to a perceived threat or danger when a teacher or administrator grants permission to the student to possess or use a mobile communication device subject to any reasonable limitation opposed by that teacher or administrator three when a licensed physician or surgeon determines that the possession or use is necessary for the students health and well-being and four when the possession or use is required by the students individual education plan so those are the exceptions in Ed code that the district would follow should

101they ever adopt a policy um across that for use all across the district during school hours Los virgin has conducted two surveys to teaches at the beginning of the school year and after I read this I'm gonna have Miss Miller chime in about some of the surveys um the union has done um 59.8% of student teachers reported cell phone use was a problem at their school 76.2% of teachers supported a bell-to-bell mobile communication device be at their school currently with a recent uh policy enacted which severely restricts the use of selles during LA Times teachers are reporting a significant decrease in student mobile communication device during school hours for example last year we tracked the Middle School principles and how many sell on violations were do good enough last year there was an average of

102138 office referrals per month for mobile communication use and compared to this year we're at 66.5% average of office referrals related to mobile communication devices so in middle school when they catch a student with a cell phone when they're not supposed to be they're sent to the office and an office referral is made so there has been a significant draw in the data that we have so far and I know you have conducted the staff survey to CH on that please sure so one of things as the hi Dar president of the Teachers Association um so one of the things that um lva was concerned about is that we were late to the conversation we thought that there wasn't many stakeholders involved in this conversation like parents students um like what SE Valley Unified is

103doing right now serving the their whole communities so we did um Mrs fa did mention that they did survey us twice but this was after the off andway policy was already sent to us to enforce the first day of school so together as um a representative council we created six questions and I just have a that and you have those in front of you um a summary of what we found is that 72% of Middle School teachers reported that offen away policy has significantly impacted their classroom in a positive way this year 83% of Middle School teachers report that the use of cell phone policies by um by students during class time is significantly better than before ask question sure I think the color coding is off on the chart because we have the exact

104opposite number our chart so that 72.6 say it has not change anything 71 point so did the charts all good I don't know I will have to check on that thank you for pointing that out yeah looks like the color coding is off I'll send you an updated email sorry about that so my numbers that I have in my summary are correct um 78% of Middle School teachers reported that cell phone used during non-instructional time is significantly better than before 77% of Middle School teachers disagree that the district needs to be more restrictive with cell phone use during school hours and 90 almost 94% Middle School teachers disagree oh I know why it doesn't match it's because you're looking at elementary that's why the first is Elementary we're talking about Middle School sorry that popped

105in my head Sor and almost 94% of Middle School teachers disagree that the district should spend additional money to lock student cell phones during the day I have a lot but I don't I know there's a long list of folks here keep going well to summarize our ask as an association is slow down our Educators um are with students every day and they say off and away is working the Lesser cell phone infractions and our survey tells us that it's working there are no metrics telling us that it's not 4 months is not enough time to evaluate a culture shifting policy so why use at least $162,000 of taxpayer money to solve a problem that our data shows is not significant often a way works because it reduces distractions Fosters focus and encourages social interaction

106while respecting students responsibility for their belongings um in essence we believe that off and Away the off and Away policy strikes the right balance between limiting distractions and teaching students to manage their devices responsibly preparing them for future environments where self-regulation is Key um our current board policy states um and this is the one that we just revised students May possess or use school campus personal electronic signaling devices provided they are use within the rules do not dist the educational program or school activity and are not used for illegal or unethical activities such as cheating un assignments or test and that was the current policy not the one that we're proposing tonight to be changed um and like I said csba revised it we just talked about that um elementary schools have the following in

107their in their handbook currently students shall have all electronic devices turned off kept in backpacks at all times except as approved by school Personnel SM Smart Watchers warrant to school must be in a locked move and that's the current policy in all of the handbooks for elementary school middle school says cell phones and all electronic equipment may be used at the explicit discretion of the classroom teacher only votes are taken when in use of when use is in violation of classroom and or school rules students may use phones before school after school students may not use phones or any type of headphones or earbuds during passing period or lunch and phones must be stored in backpacks and then the high school current policy is students are allowed to have mobile communication devices while attending school

108and school sponsored activities phones can't be used in the classroom without teacher permission many classes have locations where phones can be stored for classroom policy to which students must adhere students violating this policy may have their phones confiscated and returned at the end of the day school officials will meet with parents after the students receiv receives a second infraction and a third infraction will lead to disciplinary action so what have we done proactively as a district on April 9th of last year uh Los virgines and the Calabasas uh pment Faculty Club sponsored a dop online presentation with a focus on social media and it's impact Los virist will continue to be in Forefront of offering similar presentations um and this past summer Los virist purchased classroom cell phone pockets for all Middle School classrooms and

109the pfcs and PSAs of the high schools had pre ly purchase that so all of our Middle School classrooms and all of our High School classrooms currently have cell phone pockets for Teacher use so the proposed changes are as follows um and this is for the board policy revisions mobile communication devices are to remain off and Away during school hours students must abide by this unless given explicit directions for instructional purposes by School staff cell phone or smartphone device used is not permitted on campus during school hours and the district reserves the right to issue a device for the purpose of the implementation of this policy so I know there's been a lot of discussions about Yonder bags the district has the right to require something like that but at this point the district has

110not taken that position this is just an information item so these are your proposed changes a couple questions can you go back to that because we we have to come up with a policy so um one question is the high SCH school right now they can use them at lunch and nutrition corre so with this proposed language it says that they should be off 100% so I'm gonna ask Mr G was this have you discussed this at school because initially we've had two meet board meetings where we've discussed this for the public and one of the things that um that we uh one of the um directives we gave the district is to uh collaborate with our high schools on that including students and teachers again speaking to um Miss Miller's uh Spirit of collaboration

111are you aware of the discussions been going on about this yes so um a lot of my fellow students have um been talked about the policy it was a little bit of a shift from the at the beginning of the year um something we weren't used to but given where we are at this point in January um we've all gotten used to off away policy um I've talked to my teachers they've all been very supportive to the offen away policy they've been really enforcing it and there had like as the data shows there hasn't been near nearly as many cell phone interactions and disruptions as there have been in years past a lot of students are keeping them in their backpacks as opposed to at the beginning the year where some kids were trying to

112sneak out their phones and teachers were saying no put them away and there's a little bit of tension there that has complet that is just about gone um few months later um I don't necessarily have any quantitative data just yet I can get back to you with that and um conduct a survey at aore high school and reach out to Cal for rep and do the same in calab and I can present that at the next board meeting if You' like I I don't really have an opinion so I'm not comfortable you know as you bring this move this forward for a vote I don't really have enough information for at the high school level to have fums off at lunch and nutrition I I don't have enough information I so I don't feel one

113way or another so I will need however you decide to bring back information I will need some more information and this is for our discussion earlier in the year several months ago when we talked about so this current policy so starting from the 2526 school year okay so policy even if you adopted it next it wouldn't change this year perect so starting in the 25 26 school year the intent original discussion was off and Away across except if students left for lunch at the high school they're obviously able to use their communication devices we can change that right and I'm only one board member so I'm just sharing what my feeling is about this and could be a plenty it we do we do so some options to consider proceed with the current policy of

114belto bell ban at the elementary level and ban at high school with the exception of nutrition and lunch provide schools with a district issued classroom pocket for students to use to place their cell phones in during class times which are currently in all the schools provide a cell phone Locker which is another form which some of us saw Miss CLE and I saw when we went to um dorsy high school and then of course you can always purchase Yonder bags for each middle and high school student which will require cell phones to be locked in the Yonder bag Bel to Bel so these are the options the district has and this current policy we're adopting does not require us to adopt a specific policy it just gives the board the Right Down the Line to

115purchase something like number four without coming back and getting approval or or three right because the policy allows you to to require a district issue device but it doesn't specify what elre um we'll go I think we'll go to audience are we done not so let's go all right yeah one more Ju Just very quickly just some things to consider with the current um School staff report a significant decrease a small number of students can cons to use a cell phone despite the current policy we know that um but we have seen a significant decrease and since phone access is still there the effect Sy of breaking the addiction is unknown at this point I do want to add one thing that's included in this current proposed policy is and this is an ed code

116is that if a teacher or a school member confiscates a phone and uh the school is not responsible to replace that phone or for any damage to that phone and that is actually written in that code um very quickly if we go to the classroom Pockets it relies on staff members to enforce it students can put burner phones in it since there's no monitoring of the the phones in the pouch um the majority of Los virgines teachers who currently use these Pockets do report a significant decrease as Matthew said in cell phone uses but they don't address the use of mobile communication devices outside the classroom and the cost is approximately about $15 per classroom you you share this before what percentage of your classrooms have teachers that require you to put the cell phone

117in the pocket currently we don't have we're not necessarily using the cell phone pockets in my classes I know that there are in other classes uh in my teachers my um they've adopted the uh cell phone off your person type thing so if you can't be away from your cell phone and you need to put in a pocket then you're more than welcome to do that otherwise these teachers are expecting you to put it in your backpack and have it off of you I also have one more question about um the nutrition and lunch is this time brought up earlier um do we have any data showing that cell phones have an impact one way or another during these nutrtion and lunch periods in terms of the psychological correct sorry I mean I just think

118overall the data shows that when students have their cell phone they're less engaged socially um you know there's anxiety there seems like social media bullying that kind of stuff but not specific to lunch and nutrition just in general the addiction to cell phones yeah um very quickly if you did cell phone lockers again it relies on individual staff members to enforce it students can still put burner phone since there's no monitoring classroom lockers do not address the use of mobile communication devices outside the classroom and it cost is approximately $60 for classroom and then when you go to Yonder bags um Yonder reports 83% of schools that use their pouches have seen an improvement in student engagement and I think what we're hearing here from the teachers union and the students that we're seeing that

119currently what the percentage is is is not quantifiable at this point beond report 74% of schools that use their pouches have seen an improvement in student behavior and we are currently monitoring that in terms of referrals for Behavior y reports 65% of schools that use projects have seen an improvement in academic performance is too early for us to be able to monitor that yet um over 20,000 search options on Google on how to break opening onto that so currently it's and we've heard from students uh Mr Anal and I heard from a couple of students at lero um So currently as with kids if there's a rule they find a way to get around it they're very smart and obviously y's the most expensive item which can cost you about on a good day $25

120per bag plus the cost of additional staff and we're estimating about four additional glassified staff will be needing two hours each morning which could be roughly $54,000 at each site per year um so there's person cons for each option which the board will weigh um and then um if we do if eventually districts do go to the Yonder bad uh they'll have to buy Yonder bad for each middle and high school which will require the cell phones to be locked locked in the Yonder bed Bell to Bell unless a district decides to issue the teachers individual magnets which would they have to do because Ed code allows teachers to be able to ask allow students to use their cell phones during class time so again I just want to rate this is just an information

121item there's no recommendation at this point except to continue I believe with our current um ban and collect data on that and just before questions you arrived the $554,000 uh site per year based on expecting to keep the same level of tempo uh on day one of students and staff at a check-in versus having it scal down as the other sites have told for the first month you no longer need to have the same The Surge effort at the gate and it also anticipates the most labor intensive option which is scanning at the gate versus home room or the honor System other schools are doing don't increase actually did scale up at the initial thing because we figured that we would have all hands deck as you know the schools we visited had more admin

122than we did so we kept it at what we think we would need throughout the year and then we'd have to work on how we could get additional support so we didn't scale up and back down we started at what we thought the base would be throughout theer um do you want to show the board policy that we're going to be adopting I mean that actual I don't know if I have it's in the package great but up to the speakers first because so they can stay or go if they want but I don't want to force you to stay so we um why don't we start I'll just call you up come on up you have three minutes you'll he a beep at the end when you're done um we'll go with rachal after

123no order so the order they were handing me I'm sorry focus on one thing um okay um I know this wasn't specifically about the Yonder bag but I think that's my main concern with the policy that you guys are planning on adopting is that it least an open road to implement those bags and I have a problem with them and here's why um I'm Rachel Asher mom of two boys Zach is an eighth grader at Lindero and Evan a fifth grader at y bua I've been an active PFA board member at y bua for seven years and have been involved in this community for nine I stay informed about District matters I don't love screen time if you ask anyone I hate social media and I hate cell phones however I'm deeply committed to what's

124financially best for our schools that's why I believe these high-tech cell form bags are a waste of our school funds at an estimated cost of what you're saying is $250,000 to outfit our middle and high schools plus the need for additional staff to manage them there are better ways to spend LV USC money just a short four months ago our district implemented an often away policy for phones and we've already seen positive results for example my son's eighth grade language arts teacher at Lindero uses a simple $15 shoe storage bag which we talked about um where the students store their phones as they enter the class and retrieve them when we leave it's effective and it's low cost the school sites if the school sites have trouble with kids on phones between classes there are

125more costeffective ways to manage it than locking phones in pouches consequences are okay confiscate phones and make parents come and sign them out let it be a parental discipline issue not a financial responsibility of our district telephone bags break they can be broken into with magnets a lot of Manpower and time is required to activate and deactivate let's continue with our strictly enforced off andway policy and focus our resources where they'll have the most impact perhaps we should remain open to revisiting the bags in the future if it's Crystal Clear that the current policy is not working this is a lot of money to spend on something that is not a guaranteed success thank you Jackie Wexler and mle cins on De hi everyone my name is Jackie Wexler and I've been a proud member

126of the Calabasas Community since I was 5 years old I actually attended floss virist school since kindergarten I went to Chapel AE right in calabases high now as a parent my children have been part of the Agora Hill schools and within this wonderful School District they've gone here for seven years I've had the privilege of serving on both the yab bua PFA and the Lindero Canyon PFC and I hold immense resp for our school district and its incredible School Community I hadn't planned to speak today but a recent experience compelled me to share something important I am a local real estate agent and I received a frantic call last week from a family affected by the devastating fires in the Pacific Palisades fortunately I was able to find them a rental home quickly but their

127story deeply resonated with me my client a mother of two was off work that day and she was driving down the hill near her Children's School when she saw Flames this was before any many major alerts were sent out and the school district hadn't notified anyone yet her Instinct as a mother drove her to the school to sign her kids out immediately she rushed home packed a few essentials and evacuated later that night she learned that the school along with her entire Community had burned down sorry thankfully her instincts led her to pick her kids up before it was too late can you imagine if her kids had seen the flames and wanted to reach out but couldn't in an emergency this could only add chaos it's very unsettling as a parent looking up at

128my CH looking at my children's phone as a daily basis is unnerving and imagine the anxiety would feel the child would feel if they were not able to connect with a family member at such an urgent time I'm sure all of you have seen the devastation that these fires have caused it's a stark reminder of the unpredictable nature of such disasters I believe that this is not the time to consider restricting access to our children during emergencies it is a significant safety concern and more real than ever we must prioritize the safety and well-being of our children and ensure that our systems are equipped for such emergencies let us work together and Safeguard our community ensure that we are prepared to always protect our most precious assets are kids thank you press and then Jeff

129love it you want to be on deck for two of you I knew she would make C good evening Mr President board members and cabinet my name is Nicole Cullen and I'm the proud parent of a fifth grader and an eighth grader I previously served on the yua PFA for four years uh three of which were in the capacity of President and I'm currently serving my second year as co-p cpfc president at lindera County Middle School I was also a proud Committee Member for measure UPS I am here today to voice my concerns about implementing ybs in our schools I share many of the same opinions on safety cost anxiety and kids and the development of trust with our kids that will be voiced by others in attendance today I would like to utilize my

130time to point out two additional concerns first there are some students who have medical reasons that require using their phones as well as students with iups and 504 plans that provide accommodations allowing them to use their phones in relation to classwork these students will lose their right to privacy when they have to line up in a special line at the gate or be assigned a bag with loud Velcro that will draw attention every time they need to use it these students with challenges for reading and writing or Visual and hearing impairments can currently use their phones as assisted technology to discreetly take photos of the Whiteboard utilize voice recordings zoom in on hard to read symbols or use specialized learning apps the special velcro bags will only serve to single them out when their accommodations

131are meant to level the planing field second as a PFA and PFC board member I feel it is important to relay the Deep disappointment and sadness that was expressed to me by many parents this past year when the ele elementary schools lost 50% of their Visual and Performing Arts instruction time due to lack of funds sorry the cost of purchasing the under bags and providing the proper Staffing to ensure that roll out enforcement is done properly could have instead been put towards maintaining those B instructions hours for elementary students I realize that there is a lot of behind the scenes thought research and balance that goes into budgeting for the year but we have to consider how it looks and in this situation it looks as if the board cares more about spending money on

132an unnecessary and expensive gimmick than furthering quality educational experiences in closing I agree with the off andway policy that is working at our middle school and I support the idea of kids being office screens more and relying Less on social media but I'm not in support of locking our kids phones up I implore you to adopt the new board policy on mobile communication devices without implementing the use of the Yonder bags or classroom lockers thank you for your time and [Music] opportunity me next can I let Hudson Powers go first and then I'll take his spot when his name comes up I know you like to take charge has to Goat the back 7:30 they hard out where is it Hudson Powers okay Hudson why you go next just go next Jo can you get

133on De mess get on next hello hello everyone my name is Hudson Powers I'm a seventh grade at lcms I would like to talk about my experience the phones and why I think the Yonder bag idea is quite disrupting personally in my in my experience the use of the phones has mainly been to contact parents or loved ones it is never I wouldn't say never but it is 99% of the time not used for harm or for bad intent it is simply used for either either help to learn or to contact parents sorry I I I would also like to say that the Yonder bags would cause a big distraction between the students there was so much paranoia what could be going on in your phone that is just locked away for an entire day

134and we can't even imagine with how many emergencies we've had how that could be a distraction trying to get out of the school when you need to worry about phone getting unlocked especially in these the case of these fires there are many inconvenience inconveniences about the Yonder bag such as the cost which I'll get to later and just a lot of the a lot of the disruptive a lot of the disrupted disruptiveness that it will cause now cost is a big thing to me because we definitely have some things that we could improve about our um about our district and about our schools that this money I think it was $250,000 that could be used for so much more to help students that can't learn like we can or to improve a lot of our

135facilities thank you for your time um thank you for nice job Jeff Love It On Deck after joh thank you for letting him speak and I apologize for my voice it came back um Mr President members of the board and cabinet thank you for the opportunity to speak with you today I was very excited to see the board would be discussing the possibility of amending board policy about the use of smart devices on school campuses the off andway policy implemented this school year has been working beautifully and I hope hope it will become permanent board policy many people believe this is a middle school high school issue but as someone that teaches both kindergarten and first grade I'm here to tell you that is not exclusive to just older students in the last several years

136I was stunned by the number of kindergarteners and first graders that had smart devices mostly watches more than phones these children are five and six years old having $1,000 doll around the wrist while at first I it was a novelty it was a toy they played games on it it soon became something that seemed to be unmanageable and used for constant daily communication the number of kindergarteners that would send messages to their parents to bring a warmer sweatshirt or bring me a snack I like better or can I have a play dat with Johnny after school became so disruptive and the number of parents contacting students throughout the day was just as much actually if not more than students contacting their parents as their teacher there was nothing before this school year that I could

137do about it since the adoption of off and away this is not only sign significantly improved but it actually has gone back to how it was before we allowed these devices on campus this year none of my students have a device and I looped with a lot of my students so they had them last year I'm looking at the same students parents trust us to take care of their children we need to be able to do that without the interruption of devices I tell my students all the time your parents know where you are you're here with me if they need to get a hold of you they will call school and in the event of an emergency I need them listening to me I don't need them dist distracted by what parents are telling

138them what they're or things buzzing or beeping or chirping um I need them to listen to me listen to the other adults around this year with off and Away there are no devices on our playground at recess no children are talking to their wrist as they approach the Gate of school to ask their parents Mom where are you simply to look up and find that their mom is standing at the gate children are looking up they're using problem solving skills before immediately feeling like they have to text an adult in fact in the last few years the hottest gift talked about in January what did you get for the holidays was a smartwatch this year not a single student in my classroom or my colleagues classrooms that I talked about this with received a Smartwatch

139for the holidays instead they got Legos puzzles video games other typical appropriate to toys for five and six yearolds I absolutely attribute this to the off andway policy in our schools since children can't use them at school there's no incentive to buy them in the first place oh wa 23 seconds on my most important paragraph I'm so important I'm so happy to hear the district believes that there's money to spend y let's create some phone free schools after reading the anxious generation I too felt the pressing desire for change I'm really excited about play based schools and playgrounds where they can take risk and mental health and zero seconds left but it was very good you guys thank you got and if we could have sh Martin on deck which means maybe come to the

140micop your Amanda and then Terra give your full name please hi my name is Jeff La thanks everyone uh I so appreciate this discussion I mean even just a few years ago this would have been uh you know thought as blasphemy just the fact that we're we're having this and uh I uh grew up also in this District met my wife in second grade at Willow Elementary School um I I stand here um surprised that I I it sounds like I may be the minority in this um I was also principal in this District uh Marosa School of global education at that time uh we were a slow tech school and we were then called the hippie school because it our kids were going to be left behind uh there was a lot of worry

141about you know that particular that we weren't engaging technology but we had no phones throughout the whole campus way back when it started in um so I guess uh I wasn't going to come tonight actually um because my kid knows what my policies are and my wife's policies are and these are my choices and he knows he's not going to get a cell phone until his summer before his freshman year high school and oh my gosh wow what a what a small island I'm on amongst his friends um and I'll tell you a couple of little stories that the second week of school actually um he's a middle schooler seventh grade um Wednesdays are short days as you know and sure enough I forgot that it was a short day and he doesn't have a

142cell phone uh what' you do dude uh I walk back to the office and I asked if I could borrow the phone to me that skill was is not something I could have taught him or told him how to do he had experience it himself um you know we we've taken some bold steps here in this District I love this District um I've dedicated myself to this District in in for for many many years and um to limit the use is not enough my son came home today what prompted me was um again the the off and Away has has worked pretty well for him he came home today and said Dad what's going on with fires I said' what do you mean he said well in English class phones were Ding and there were

143warnings about what's going on in the fire updates oh really so the off and way I know I've sat on both sides of the table I know what policy being in practice I really do um but in reality um there's a lot of cell phone usit going on uh that that we're not aware of um I asked the the board to um look at the amount of hours that Administration is spending and add that up and see how that adds up to what it would cost to get these Yonder bags and the reality is uh many other districts are using it I can't believe La USD has beat us on this to be perfectly honest um but the concerns that have been raised are simply just not panning out to be uh what what has

144been brought forward tonight so I'm in full support of these younger bags thank you [Music] much Amanda next good evening Mr President board members and Council my name is shelene Martin I'm the proud parent of Jude Martin sixth grader at lcms I'm also currently serving on the Lindero PFC and I'm an alumni lcms and Agora High School go cougars Go chargers born and raised in agore Hills California and a proud citizen of this community thank you for the opportunity to speak tonight I'm here as a proud parent to voice my support of off and Away the policy has already shown positive results with infraction decreasing month over month as our students teachers and staff continue to adapt and uphold expectations the vast majority of students over 95% of approximately are following the rules regardless of

145what you're hearing and demonstrating responsible behavior only a small fraction less than 5% have struggled to comply and I believe this does not warrant the extreme measure and investment of implementing Yonder bags or any lock down of cell phones locking students phones up in anyway is not a solution to the challenges the board has raised such as bullying classroom distractions and lack of social capabilities there is no substantial evidence nor significant beta testing of likeminded districts like ours to show that yonder bags would effectively address the issues in fact the lack of Imperial research supporting this is deeply concerning to me as a parent and a Community member introducing such a drastic cost measure especially when our teachers only receive a 1% raise this past year is not justifiable I urge the board to really

146carefully consider whether this expense aligns with our goals as a community furthermore adopting y bags sends Yonder bags or locking up our kids phone sends the wrong message to our students and our children by locking away their phones we are telling them that we do not trust you to make the right decision we do not trust you to follow the rules this undermines the progress we have made in fostering a responsibility and accountability through the current policy why are we punishing the majority of students who are doing the right thing adhering to policy here's an analogy for you to consider if the phone is like a drug why are we sending all of our kids to rehab when the majority haven't touched it used it or abused it as an alternative to the lockdown I

147would urge you to reconsider off andway policies with data driven adjustments and positive reinforcements digital citizenship education inclass designated cell phone storage areas focused intentions on repeat offenders peer leadership programs with student ambassadors and peer support let's Foster a positive school and District culture celebrating success and building a successful digital Citizen Community without har and costly interventions I believe in our children I believe in myself as a parent and I hope you do too thank [Music] youa on De to move this down because I'm short good evening Mr President board members and cabinet I'm Amanda kulos and I am a parent of a freshman a Gad and a fifth grer at will Elementary and I'm a former PFA uh will Elementary president and PFC president at lero and I am also the co I was

148also co-chair of the measure s campaign but enough about me uh let's talk about cost as you know we fundraise for literally everything teachers AIDS assistance class trips equipment sports teams Etc every Club every extracurricular expense and I understand why I really do I've been behind it how can we justify hundreds and thousands of dollars over all these schools being spent on a program sign significantly the number of teachers and AD mines I honestly feel like do not want I have full faith in them we've heard from our teachers union I've had full faith in our staff and our faculty to honestly go with what we have going on with off and away rather than the glorified freezer bags and if Effectiveness quick Google search will tell you how to open a Yonder bag and

149I'm sure we can the kids will find out and way to break into anything else um or we expect our kids specifically the ones who are abusing the current phone restrictions are not going to destroy the bags or what happens then side note further proof on how easy it is to open the bags just on the base on the conversation in my household my 11-year-old got in his algorithm a recommended video of how to open the bags so he's ready distractions if the goal is to eliminate the distractions of the device during class time the least expensive more efficient way the policy is leave the phone at the door I think it's working it's $15 for the shoe bag it's gives parents a peace of mind my final questions would be who's going to mon

150these pouches who's going to take them away if things aren't working out who's going to be the one at the door who's going to be one that unlock them how is going to be how are we going to like make our kids not buy the magnet online how are we going to not buy them a burner phone like a drug dealer I don't know and so uh thank you for your time sorry for us Laural burn on Deck followed by Cooper uh good evening Mr President board members and cabinet my name is Taran Maynard and I am the parent of a junior freshman at Agora High and a sixth grader at Lindero I'm currently on lindo's PFC board and I'm treasurer of the Agora Spirit booster club I'm former president of Willow PFA lundo PFC

151and I was also co-chair of measure I'm here today to express my concerns about Yonder bags um my um first concern is logistically what is the plan to get these cell phones into and out of bags in a timely manner um if we're doing it during home room is this taking away instructional time from our students um is the teachers union on board with this um if doing it at the gate are staff members tasked with this checking for burner phones how long will this process take what if a child says they don't have a phone with them are they calling their parents that seems very timec consuming when we're dealing with just under 800 students at Lindero at Agora this will be an even bigger problem at what point do the students figure out

152that they shouldn't enter campus immediately and they're wandering around the neighborhood or Lo lering outside of Campus a dangerous situation and an already crowded traffic problem how will the neighbors feel about this also I have a few personal concerns for me as a mother as a parent I want to be able to text or call my child if necessary especially with the fire situation these past two weeks I need to be able to have access to my child in the event of an emergency speaking once again logistically how many calls will the front office get if we don't have access to our children through text how will I be able to relay a message to my child in a timely manner and vice versa I would like my child to be able to contact me

153when necessary without having to go through a staff member some things are personal and private and with today's technology there shouldn't be a need for my child to inform anyone but me as a mother of three girls I'm sure you can understand where I'm coming from with that uh in conclusion let's trust what already is working without spending a dime let's trust the students and staff to do what is asked of them and give consequences to those who don't follow the rules let's not punish the majority for the infractions of the minority thank you for your time well and then Cooper good evening Bard parents Educators and students I have nothing as beautifully planned as the previous speakers but I just appreciate that we are in this collaborative Community where the concerns for our students

154and for our Educators come first I never thought I would stand up here and be against controlling screens in any way people know I'm a hippie at heart and I control my daughter's screen time very strictly she's a freshman at Agora she went through Willow she went through Lindero I was involved in the board all through for eight years and I find myself in a situation where I want to look at the exceptions not the rules most kids have a normal day off and away is working and this year I had a student with an injury an inner ear injury she missed three months of school and starting high school after this posed challenges to her I never expected on my parent bingo card inner ear injury from Orthodontics was not there I could have

155done a lot of of parenting with girl drama academic drama anything but not that and my child who never took her phone out of her bag in Middle School suddenly needs a little bit extra that connection to me that little support of text uh Mom I'm having a bad day it's an anxious day and that's just per unique situation and that's one student for her phone to have been locked over these last few months of starting at aora high would have been absolute disaster in my household and that's just one student she's an honorable student she's still getting great grades and cheering on the Cher team what if she didn't have that communication I also am wondering the Sinister side of what is the private investment in Yonder bag by anyone involved in our district

156why this what are our other Solutions I think the pouches are working today I asked my daughter okay when you go to class where are the phones and she said in every class except for her AP class they have the pouches and then in the AP class like you're saying right high level academic students don't seem to have the problem and they just don't have the pouches at all it's not an issue they don't take out their phone I want us to all consider like one of the previous speakers said let's slow down let's really look at how often away is working which seems to be very well and where our investments at our entire District are we're very fortunate we have these wonderful Minds everywhere the board these parents these Educators and these incredible

157students and now Cooper thank you superose Julie fanan on deck and Leanne wallet after that good evening Mr President board members Council my name is KS I'm a freshman in aore high school I appreciate the opportunity to speak with you about the proposal to ban phones for the entire day while I understand the concern behind this idea I believe it is neither practical nor beneficial for students because phones are an essential for safety and communication in today's world phones are more than just distractions they're lifelines many students rely on them to communicate with their parents while away from them especially in emergency for example if there's a little thing as a last minute change in pickup plans or big thing like the Kenneth fire having these phones in emergencies is crucial for a lot of

158students likely I could not imagine a world where the Kenneth fire broke out as close as it was to a high school and I was not able to contact my family now moreover most of us balance our extracurricular activities jobs important responsibilities outside of school now coordinating these activities takes a lot of work including texting people during breaks texting people during lunch you know coordinating these things that really build our character taking away our phones the entire school day creates unnecessary barriers by keeping phones accessible during appropriate times we can maintain this vital connection without disrupting learning Beyond this our culture has adapted the phone usage as an integral part of daily life from workplaces to higher education technology including phones is used to enhance communication organization and productivity schools should be preparing students for

159the real world by teaching them how to use phones responsibly rather than enforcing a policy that feels like a step backwards by adapting what Society has already embraced schools should move forward in a way that reflects the realities of Modern Life while while supporting students safety and success thank you for your [Music] time and lean wette you're next and Jacob roosev our flaged flag sing is jie good evening um my name is Julie fan I'm a licensed marriage and family therapist in private practice as well as the kho Valley Chapter reader of Mama which stands for Mothers Against media addiction mama is a Grassroots movement of parents fighting back against big Tech grip on childhood and aiming for a world filled with real life interactions and experiences I had a lot of things I was

160going to say tonight but I've heard some some comments I wanted to to talk through because now what I'm was going to say doesn't make sense so from what I've heard um you have a successful bellt Bell program but then also what I'm hearing is that there's a lot of texting going on between parents and kids during the school day so I'm not quite sure um you know if it's a total ban or how that works or if it's during the school you know if people are pulling them out during nutrition and you know so it's you know I'm just a little a little unsure um I know that it can be a Herculean task to get kids off their phones for an extended period of time um and the reason why I'm here in

161the minority speaking for a product like Yonder bags is because they're the gold standard in not only getting kids off their phones during the school day which is imperative not just for academics I mean I care about academics in so far as it's you know it's important to be successful in this in this life but we can't be successful when we have no social skills and when we can't um interact and pull up on our own two feet during the school day and ask for help like we need to so um Yonder also removes enforcement duties from teachers so as my role in mama I'm in coordination across the country with a bunch of different Mamas and Papas who are working in this organization and working with school districts all across the country using different

162methods and what we've seen and what I've handed to you is a very similar District to yours to L virist it's Corona delmare which is in Newport Beach they implemented in their middle school a pilot program I know cost has been brought up a lot um cost is of course extreme if you talk about you know oh gosh we're going to do it for every single student you know Elementary K per 12 but if you do a pilot program it's less and that's what they've done here just to test it out what they've seen here if you look on page two this is my favorite one here as a therapist for young people in this area um has the cell phone ban affected seventh and eth grade students interactions with their peers and what you

163all can't see but um it's 87.9% of teachers teachers said that kids are having more positive interactions um 9.1 no noticeable difference and then one no you know more negative so we've got 88% saying that positive interactions between peers has gone up that is truly you know my that's one of my main concerns I was able to present yesterday to 50 plus PFA presidents at the Newport Mesa School District in Orange County where everyone raved about this pilot program and they hoped that the rest of the district move forward this way a bell-to-bell policy in having couches isn't punitive it just gives students the right environment to succeed in all ways thank you so much thank you very much and then Jacob hi I'm not Leanne but Leanne said that I could read her last

164paragraph because my son has homework is that okay I'll take 30 seconds sure I did my name is Kelly hitz and then Ryan scy can't speak either go see okay here we go I am so happy to hear that the district believes there is money to spend on creating phone free schools after reading the anxious generation she too felt the pressing desire for change she knows the school board and cabinet have talked about various ideas like lockers bags and other phone storage but she hopes that you've considered some of the most important from from the anxious generation book since we have started laying the foundation in elementary school already we can use this set aside money for so many creative and innovative ideas we can truly be on the Forefront of the new wave we

165can be the first school district in Southern California to allow for more re ESS and more free play at all ages creating schools full of play was one of John ha's strongest recommendations for what children need to avoid continuing as the anxious generation it's not about banning phones it's about educating children how to live in a world ignoring them that was [Music] good we can spend money and resources on true problem solving tasks we can build playgrounds that allow for risky play these playgrounds are what she is personally the most excited about for our lost virgous students we can buy games and toys to increase the amount of play based social Alternatives we can host screenings speakers and discussions for both students and parents to help guide us in our transition to phone free schools

166we can add to our robust counseling and mental Health Services gosh I can't breathe okay we can have staff devoted to helping Implement off and away until it's second nature to all and then use those staff for more fun things in the future yes this all takes time and money but she's so glad to see that we're already doing the most important things off and away is working let us continue to make it right for all of our students thank you took longer s followed by Bren Wester and dor for Jacob Jacob against the get them there's many cases in which already school in the morning is really hard to get to and there traffic getting in and out of school there sometimes it even takes up to 15 minutes just to get to the

167front gate school by using our cars the Y bags would create more of a problem people who have permits to be at schools would like people get kicked out of our schools because it'll be late and have forc to like like show up on time also the funding for these bags can be spent in so many better ways including better desks whiteboards our schools have need more computers we have assorted of them right now we need better things for students better lunches even there's so many better this money could be spent on and the sometimes in certain classes our Fones are needed to help us learn in science we're using them in multiple different ways to help us learn we're taking photos and using them to experience things this is why I believe the Y

168bag shouldn't be adapted to our school system thank you sorry I hope you I hope you'll be sitting up here in about 4 years as a student bo am go for it be back to you okay yeah okay got okay sorry go ahead i' love listening to everyone's point of view it's been really really awesome um I think it's true what the uh lady was saying when she was speaking about the other well she was speaking on behalf of someone else about the that we're we have kids that we want to live alongside technology we just can't avoid it and um but I I keep flooding I'll just go to why wa um I'm going to speak from my personal experience I have a child with um anxiety specifically separation anxiety um and I've had

169amazing support from lero from the district I know I'm not alone families have faced a lot of these challenges especially since the pmic and you know what the statistics are like on mental health so my fear is limiting access to phones is going to have a negative impact on their mental well-being opposite to what the other lady was saying um today's society is just different from the one that we grew up in children face anxieties and fears that we never had to deal deal with and a lot of them the ability to contact a parents in these in the case of an emergency is crucial if my child doesn't feel like she can reach me in an emergency I know for a fact I'm going to have school refusal and that's not just going to

170be me I'm not speaking for myself I know that's going to be a lot of parents um and I'm just wondering even I'm thinking in my head you know what about the parents that bring like a doctor's know or specifics is somebody going to be able to have a phone and then somebody not able to have a phone I don't know how you're going to deal with that I was also thinking just off the C if there is an emergency and the phones are in a shoe box or in somewhere I don't know if you've ever seen a teen in fight or flight my my kid will she's pretty you know she's she's going to go for that phone and I tell you what there's going to be a lot of panic and it's going

171to be very dangerous in the classroom I think if they're in there um I mean you guys know the people that are adhering to the rules are the people that will adhere to these laws that are that are happening right now which I can't believe boots on the ground all the teachers that 95 % anyway I'm going up I've got a lot of things written down but um you know I also really believe that you're taking the choice away the that basically the kids should have the consequences of right or wrong and they should be able to be held accountable if my child's breaking the breaking the rules I expect her to have consequences and I think that's a crucial lesson that middle school high school provides and it's part of growing up these situations

172like working alongside of side of phone that's supposed to be put away your opportunities for the kids to learn and grow by removing the consequences we're taking away that valuable lesson for them uh what else um I do believe in giving my kid Independence um but I do believe also that I should have the ability to contact my child if there is an emergency and if it is really necessary um I don't see why um yeah it just feels very controlling to me um sorry I got aot thank you very much uh bradden followed by dorah and then Ryan Ryan um I'm gonna try there's a Ryan here after hi I'm Ren Wexler I participate in the G Tech program at Lindero where I act as a general manager kind of like a class president

173I am very against the idea of ybs for many reasons the first reason is legality issues California Ed code section 48917 States a pupil shall not be prohibited from possessing or using a smartphone in the case of an emergency or in response to perceive that of danger now you may be thinking that a student should just cut open the bag in an emergency but this insinuates that a student should always carry a pair of scissors or other sharp objects from C nobody wants my second point is my asthma as a person living with asthma I feel it's essential for me to have my phone as a means of communicating in case of emergency it brings me a lot of stress thinking about that I may not be able to have my phone in a situation

174like this my third point is that many budget cuts are being made dis wide one of these Cuts occurred when ordering a new shipment of computers for students we were meant to order 2,000 new systems but instead we ended up with only 1100 the money being spent on these bags can be put towards so many other things more vital to educational purposes than these bags the final issue I will cover today is the issue of students prolonging their time off campus I believe and it has been shown at other school sites that students will hang around outside campus to prolong the time with their devices this issue um this issue with students car rating like this it could cause serious safety issues to distract the driving and the students standing in area with many cars

175it could also cause issues with students being very late to class making life harder for teachers the new cell phone rules put in place lendo have been enough to prevent most cell phone related issues and Y bags are an extreme solution that I believe should not be used there are much better and more cost effective ways to go about this like a hanger on the wall for cell phones in each classroom this ensures that students have access to phones if they actually needed and keeps them off of it as a distraction in a very cost effective way thank you for your time thank you followed by Ryan and then Emily Richie Hello I'm dor 10 and I'm in seventh grade and Derk candy middle school I'll be speaking about the Yonder bags Yonder bags will

176not be good for our school for several reasons to begin you guys are getting rid of the Y you guys are getting the Y bags to get rid of phones when there are many other ways students can access the same stuff from their phones for example if You' have an Apple computer or a Mac but can just connect your phone to me you can access the same stuff like messages Snapchat so getting the Y bags would not solve this issue secondly I think y bags are a huge waste of money when you can spend the money on more important things and phones another reason is in case of an emergency myom would want me to contact her just like you want your just like you want your child to contact you lastly I think a

177free solution could be teachers doing other things like giving you detention Saturday school or even just TR to pick up if they see on your phone that is why I think hbags are not a good solution thank you ran ran okay um Emily Richie followed by JD mcneel and Lauren aru hello everyone president Lawrence members of the school board Dr stefanoski and cabinet members thank you for giving us the opportunity to speak today my name is Emily Richie and I've been a high school counselor for 17 years and I'm currently serving at Calabasas high school I'm also the proud adoptive mom of a current High School senior not in Las virgines I'm sorry sorry but also of a Calabasas high school graduate from the class of 2023 I know that teenagers are fun I seriously

178never stops um I am here on behalf of many dedicated teachers counselors and other School site staff who are concerned about the proposed use of and postive devices such as the Yonder bags um that have been introduced as a response to potential new policy options we believe that our current off and Away policy is already showing promise and we appreciate apprciate the opportunity to share our perspectives on why additional monetary Investments are an unnecessary course of action both practically and fiscally at this time as many have already shared the off and Away policy has only been effect for a few short months while it has been a short period initial observations and our lvea survey results indicate that it is working many of our staff report improved focus and engagement in the classroom and have

179students as students have shared my husband keeps texting me the initial growing pain have decided is premature to judge the policy's successes or failure without additional time to collect more comprehensive data issuing devices such as the presentation option of Yonder bags at this stage would be an unnecessary expense when we haven't fully assessed the current policy's Effectiveness moreover the funds required could be better invested in other areas that directly impact student social emotional learning and academic achievement for example enhancing Mental Health Services providing additional training training for teachers onal strategies and investing in technology that supports learning quite frankly my graduate cell phone often worked faster and better than his school issued Acer device given the challenges our students face particularly in light of recent fire days and evacuations our focus should be on providing

180stability and support for students and staff alike and allow time to engage in additional conversations it's also worth noting that the school's tour to gather information regarding the use of Yonder bags are not comparable to those in lvusd our district has unique needs and Dynamics and decisions should be based on what works best for our specific Community not necessarily on examples from fundamentally different environments we would welcome board and cabinet members on our campuses to visit our classrooms and engage in dialogue with our staff and students this feedback from the very professionals who are implementing District policies on The Daily should not be overlooked but should be prioritized we would welcome the opportunity to be a part of an ongoing conversation regarding how we can better direct our resour ources towards initiatives that directly support

181our students wellbeing and academic success thank you for your time K GI is she still here she I can't see sorry okay yes you're Cher given um then juny mcneel then Lauren AR we're in the home stretch I'm now yes sorry hi I'm thank you so much for letting me speak I didn't think I'd be able to speak because I was here a little bit later than I think the expected time to do that so thank you for allowing me to speak and congrats on your new and returning positions on our board um those who may not know me I'm Sher given and I teach dual ersion and ELD at and Canyon that I was previously suat um came to this District in 2016 moved to the secondary in 2018 um and to be those

182of you who know me I'm very transparent I'm very honest I'm very direct so nothing I say is meant to offend anybody I'm going to say that up front um but I am that is me I am I am what you see and you get what you get um and you don't throw a fit but anyway um and I can say this again in Spanish if you give me six minutes um I wanted to start with a few things that haven't been been said because I'm a teacher as many of you have spoken and I can see it firsthand um when I came to Lindero the cell phone policy I have high expectations and I think many parents can agree but the students every school year meet them without fail there's an exception here and

183there it takes a conversation they come around and they get it when this policy came around this year it wasn't a big change for me because I've never allowed cell phones in my room except for exceptions when there when their computers actually don't work which sometimes does happen their computers sometimes don't work then they use their cell phone as a plan B um however when I moved into the ELD position this amazing app called Google Translate came around and you can actually translate sheets of paper live in front of you my ELD kids are now able to receive now science teachers hand out packets correct that Lind the long thick packets it's impossible to have them translate that on their aners imagine right and for me to do that into Korean and Korean Japanese um

184to galag Spanish and a few other languages in my El classes with 12 kids a different language almost per kid I couldn't possibly go around with my phone and do that for every kid which I was doing before I got permission from the administration for them to use their phones the answer was quick and easy yes of course have them use their phones they don't like being different they don't like to stand out they like to blend in and so for them to have to take a phone out of a Yonder bag because right now even with our policy they're uncomfortable because it's a good policy they're uncomfortable taking out their phones when other kids can't so to them for them to have to stand out even more and open those Yonder bags or not

185have one at all in the other case to look at them and say that's not fair that would further impede their progress and their willingness to participate in learning class um nothing something else personal um wellness centers I really really miss those I really wish we could staff those and as much as I love this district and I'm happy here I have to admit that there are times when policies come and policies built my concern is that lots of money is going to be spent on this and it's not going to last and I hope it doesn't I'm not saying it should but I'm saying it could be I don't want this to be a race with lb with uh sorry with L USD this is is not a race this is money I don't

186live in Agora as a I don't I can't afford to live here I can't afford to buy here I'm a renter I love this city and I would love to purchase a home but I can't on on the salary that I make and my husband's a substitute teacher so how great if there is money for it to go towards salaries and Recruitment and finally my daughter never uses her phone during school so know her she's like the biggest rule follower you ever meet ever meet in your life she texted me during the lockdown at aora which was a long one and what a relief it was that day to get that text from her from a kid who never used her phone at all during the school day so I have a lot more my

187little chicken scats feet but that's the gist I'm sorry okay then Lauren on Deck followed by Jen CTS and then June Martin who wanted to go last who wish just granted you're last didn't think I was going to speak tonight but I found out about the meeting last minute and I think there does to be more of an effort to let the parents know what is on the agenda I spoke to many families they had no idea this discussion was even happening I don't know if that was their lack of knowledge but I wish I the further push to let the parents actually know what's on board would be great my name is Jody mcneel I have three children lbusd one at Lindero two at Willow love this area love the teachers cannot speak highly

188enough about the teachers at L amazing experience we're very lucky to be here when when it comes to the negative effects on cell phones and children and the usage I agree with the studies I agree with the the mama organizations I agree with that but there has to be a different way I don't see how locking phones up will keep this issue from happening the children will still have access to these devices after the bell and it's up to the parents for the usage and to teach that to their children I believe the current policy of off and away is effective as long as it's enforced last year off and away was not enforc in fact quite opposite now last year my sixth grader was asked to take her phone out to take pictures and

189whatnot yes I disagree with that that's not the policy but things have changed things have changed since the last board meeting I watched on YouTube last time the fall semester of my daughter has told me that the enforcement of the phones the phones are not out the teachers are asking them not they're not asking to bring them out and the enforcement is working I believe there needs to be a continuing education of the teachers and the staff and the students of off and Away um and the severity of not complying with it what will be their that their punishment if the students break these guidelines or rules the students perhaps should have their phone locked up in a different location or disciplinar and those who don't agree or follow the rules I do not feel

190the students who comply with the rules should be made to have a phones locked up lb USC has spent millions of dollars on securing our school there could still be bomb threats or people could bring wild weapons to school God forbid it's that this would happen I would to know immediately my child's safety while the school is in lockdown I would not be able to get in touch with the child or the office immediately if there's also natural disasters like last year there was an earthquake my daughter was on the second floor of Lind darl she's shaking totally freaked out texting me I'm okay the inant I'm like Lexi you're fine we'll be fine it's okay it's just it's a comfort to us and the children and it's something to where this the office staff

191all you say we have your kids we said I trust you I trust you with our kids but in those moments I don't you can the children the teachers themselves are sh Sheltering in place and the desk protecting for their own well-being I don't again don't want to regurgitate the money of money this would cost and the resources and um I believe it's up to the Educators and staff to enforce the current rule of off and away and everyone should read the book The anxious generation I think there is something to that and realize the dangers of cell phones but these these need to be addressed at home with the family Rules my students have already um yeah just like the other student said you can break the Yonder bag my daughter said just hit

192it on the desk car enough and their scissors I don't think that's the answer I think the current policy have Allen away thank you thank you then kks Laura I'm sorry all right good evening Mr President board members and cabinet my name is Lauren aru I have two Agora high schoolers I've served on the PFC at sumac and lero School site Council dance boosters Etc um and in my other life I work closely with my Ventura County school districts as the Director of HR and operations at first five Ventura County I'm here today to express my support for the current offen away policy and to not Implement locking away students phones in bags or taking away their access at uh nutrition or lunchtime I worked diligently with my children to be responsible digital citizens and

193to self- regulate their cell phone use before I send them off to college in a very short amount of time where they won't have anyone to regulate own cell phone use the proposed policies undermine the trust between me my student and the schools by locking away the phones you're sending the message that they're not able to make responsible decisions or to regulate themselves with their own cell phones I need my kids to be able to practice that self-control when I can still give them some feedback before they go to college phones are also an important tool for safety which many people have brought up already I won't get too far into that but I personally prefer the option to be able to text my kids and let them know that they have a last minute

194doctor's appointment they need to go to the office and pick up their early dismissal pass instead of the office having to try and track them down or that if my kid wants to check a message at lunch see what's going on that they not feel pressured to leave campus to go and check the message or even thought would they leave campus leave their cell phone locked up in the bag and then if they get a flat tire or get in an accident they can't call for help U I think that there'd be a lot of issues around the practicality and enforcement of this policy people have brought up using their own Magnet or a burner phone it'll only frustrate the kids who are already doing the right thing and be a fun challenge for kids

195who are trying to use their cell phones if we can't stop kids from vaping in bathrooms which I think is a much bigger concern I don't think that bags are going to stop kids from using their cell phones or accessing a computer to to send messages the proposed policy seems to have a lot of different questions that people haven't had answered are you really willing to spend $54,000 per School and all of that staff time when we have packets in in the classrooms that we can do the off and the way with um in ventur County Superintendent Morales is advising the local school districts to plan on budgeting for double to Triple the insurance costs after the most recent wildfires I imagine that this school district will be even higher and so I wouldn't recommend

196spending all the money when you don't know what those are to cost will be next year and if we had other options maybe we could pay for my kids at tests or te um I'd love to see more focused groups with st students and teachers and parents to talk about is this actually going to be an effective tool or what would be more effective the stat the statistics that the company is citing related to engagement must not have come from school districts that already have this off and Away policy so in conclusion this seems like an oversized reaction to a really small problem with a small number of students and let's focus on education digital literacy and guidelines that help students balance phone use while respecting their autonomy and safety thank you June Martin thank

197you Mr President board members and cabinet I am a parent of three students in the Las virgines disal 2 and one alumni I have been actively involved in the school districts over the past 14 years many of you know me as is holding many positions at sumac including the FAA president for 3 years and I'm currently the president El at AHS I here in agreement with many of the other parents tonight who are against the Yonder bags I believe the off and Away has been working well and we can save thousands of dollars by having a shoe bag or cell phone holder whatever you want to call it hanging somewhere in the classroom I want to remind you guys that woly fire did not happen very long ago we know what it's like to go

198through emergencies and for fire and other things to be able to have quick access to those phones also having been at AHS during the recent fishing school shooting where I can attest to the craziness I was there the day the school went on lockdown I even happened to help with the dismissal of students nobody quite knew what was going on parents were trying to get in kids were trying to get out and I have to tell you honestly it was the kids on the cell phones going that's my mom over there and then us saying hey Mom if that's you raise your hand we need to know where you are how are we going to control this if we don't have ways for people to get a hold of one another I guarantee you this

199was and also this was high school these were the high school students who knew kind of where to go what to do some of them could drive I guarantee you it'll be Mass area um and could be catastrophic if parents could not get onto campuses and reach their elementary school kids who will not know what to do and will be freaking out you'll have a whole other problem on your hands during an emergency um also we are a district that prided itself on being the first such as when we were technology Advance over many districts we gave our students laptops before many others districts did and continued to do so you brought technology to the schools so it is up to you to teach students how to use and when to properly use it and

200how not by doing it by locking it up I urge you I urge you all to become leaders in an alternative way to remove cell phone distractions without having to De utilize the Yonder BS um and just a quick little note of observation while being in here while everyone was talking I would like to ask the board and cabinet to put away all cell phone and board a cell phone and computer uses um next week during the board meeting uh I would like you guys to have maybe an hour or two without your computers without your phones we can go back to the old school ways of using paper um and we can see how you guys feel like that is uh to do that thank last speaker J Martin Sor hello my name is

201R Martin and my name is m mayard and we are 12 years old sixth graders at lero Canyon Middle School thank you for giving us the chance to speak with you today we are here to talk about the proposal to purchase Yer bags for our school while we understand that some people think locking up phones in it is a solution we believe it's not the best choice for several reasons first our school already has an off and Away policy for cell phones and it's working well most of us follow the rules and when someone doesn't they face appropriate consequences instead of locking up everyone's phones we should focus on teaching students how to manage their fure sponsor phones are a part of our lives and learning to use them wisely and safely is a real

202world skill we need second Yonder bags are expensive and we don't think it's fair to spend so much money when there are better ways to solve this problem problem that money could be used for programs that could actually help students learn to use their phones in the right ways finally locking up phones all day feels extreme phones aren't just distractions they can be tools for learning for example we use them as calculators and Ma or to look up definitions in language arts always with teachers permission of course and in emergencies having access to our phones can help us stay safe and contact our families in my opinion education about responsible phone use is as much better investment walking phones and bags won't teach us anything and it could even cause more frustration and stress let's

203stick with the off and Away policy and work together to improve if needed thank you for listening and for considering our perspective thank you so I think a couple things um I want to give maybe everyone a chance to react to what they heard today but I think first it's important to correct a couple things there is no board there is no decision being voted on discussed or even considered today about y um so that's one um I think that's important to get out there um I think board actually made a decision to not have that discussion today uh to to wait and continue to listen to the community U that's why I'll tell you for one I told hundreds of parents who wanted to come here who were in support of it not to

204come because we're not discussing that today um but I think it important to let you guys all share your opinions I want to make sure everyone knows we're not voting on y BS if the board policy passes today which we're voting on today if it passes in two weeks it does not include the word Yonder bags there will be no purchase of Yonder bags that's not happening so so that's one I would say two I I want to give her i' let the a chance to to react to what they heard but then I would like to shift us back to a discussion about the board policy if we could so maybe we take a couple minutes each person react but then back clarifying question okay because um I'm not on safety and wellness committee

205that has been discussing this and I have been contacted I've been reading the Friday letters at the superintendent and I have been contacted by some parents and peers at Lindero because Lindero is supposed to be the first school to start this so hence you have a lot of Lindero parents and teachers here who are feeling like okay you're going to roll out yonder soon and what is that timeline I mean I think that was decided already a timeline on yers for Lindero and so I said I need clarification I I think unfortunately the discussions got way ahead of the board the process um I think that that should we we can we can dissect that later down the line but uh Communications got out to parents and students well before the board was ready to

206have those conversations while I was still I don't know if you're well all you're in Comm Dr step wait Dr step can you speak to that because my understanding from I believe a Friday letter you had was that the safety illness committee meeting that Mr anhold attended was a direction from from Mr Lawrence or from the committee to send out a communication to parents prior to prior to break and so I think that I was surprised to see this agenda item because I'm a board member who doesn't know much about this and again I think we have parents here and staff here who want to know are they when to expect the your vs because they have been told and in my opinion as a board member rightfully so you you know if we're rolling

207this out I don't I can't make the connection of we you you we got ahead of the schools or the schools got ahead of us when they're supposed to be implemented we're buying it what do we just hand it on the doorstep and that's the first time we we tell them about it that's that's never happened before so I'm completely in the in the dark about this and I want to have a discussion because y bags was on the screen and I'm hearing from Lindero parents teachers staff that they're going to be rolled out shortly so my question is again the why when off and away is working have we given off and Away enough time what are we using to measure it and again when were these bags supposed to come and then reading

208again that then it's going to go to the other two middle schools and you're right parents don't know we're discussing this it's an agenda item during a fire a crisis I applaud all our parents for and staff for coming out tonight this is important and this is something in my opinion that I've heard from the parents and I have my own notes but I did hear from them something I'm thinking about is this feels rushed to me it feels like a lack of collaboration a lack of discussion and rush to me I I think that's why we were that there was nothing happening like this was really a discussion of the policy that the change in the law and I let me finish and I appreciate that the parents who understood that we were that

209that was one of the options up there that that could be discussed further down the road right but but wait a minute would again when Yonder bags linder's been told Yonder bags are coming out and the parents all got an email directed from the Safety Committee to send the email saying Yonder bags are coming no I think something went out saying that that the board would be considering the board would be considering a number of things that's exactly what came out and the the entire board got that email you got that email I just say from a process standpoint again this is I appreciate all the feedback this is the third board meeting we've talked about cell phone policies in the last year we've had half a doz safety committee meetings of which the minutes

210I think you have access to have discussed in detail the discussions about Yonder bags we've briefed out two different meetings that Miss faul has organized with school board members administrators going to schools that have Yonder bags we briefed them out here at the feedback from that we've met with the CEO of Yonder I'm not sure why someone thinks there's some investment that we have with Y that I didn't that was a little insulting but um there's no investment here we're all trying to figure out the best things for our students uh who came in here and talked to us about about the need to pass about the need to bring a positive social emotional change so uh I appreciate what you're saying I think process is important I think that uh so my question really

211is in everybody's question here is there they are assuming nre's going to start at lindera I don't even so is that happening Dr step Miss FAL that's not and and I know and I I know that know that but I I would like the chance to talk about some of the things I heard today one of the things um and we've spent a long time talking about this researching this nobody's come to a conclusion one of the things that I've come to the conclusion of is if you're going to change policy in terms of how you do business on a day-to-day basis how we run things you have to have buyin and the first place you have to have buyin is at the administrative level you have to have everybody on board who really believes

212it we're not even at the the point of having parent and student Buy in because I don't I can see it's very apparent you don't have administrative buyin I mean I feel like people were blinking hell postage you know with their eyes uh every time we discussed possibilities of what a cell phone Beyond off in away looks like um so that's one thing one thing that um I've continued to be concerned about is how do you roll this out to the high schools because now if you roll it out to the middle schools then next year you've got incoming ninth graders well they've had Yonder bags now do they not have Yonder bags now know is it at the high school and you know you can't have some kids at a high school who have

213their phones off you know so the fact that we and we talked about this every time we talked about the cell phone issues is that high schools a very tough not to prep because they use their phones much more for educational reasons in and out of classes and it seems a little rush to be doing something at the middle school level when we haven't yet put the runway to the high school so I want to see more time of what we're looking at for off and away so I mean the fact that we're looking at this policy because we now you know directed by the state we need to have a policy that allows for you know that says what what is our policy on communication so that's where I am so I appreciate all

214the input and people coming and um I appreciate that people understood that you know there was nothing on the table no one's bought any bags no one has any bags I mean so we're not there rights like you're there so good to hear you say that not yeah I can't have you address the board sorry I appr go ahead Al so um obviously this is the first time I'm speaking about the whole issue of smartphones phones as aard M so you know if you can just give me a little attitude with My Views than three minutes okay thanks very much to everyone who came tonight I really appreciate it really appreciate all the input um you know from the the meeting in mid August where this was originally discussed I was surprised that how contentious

215it was when I was on the campaign Trail uh you know spoke to probably thousands of people um people felt very very strongly about this in both directions uh it was a very emotional issue a very contentious issue and I truly hope we can all come together as a community as a board teachers parents kids the administration uh in formulating a compromise and would probably not everybody is going to be happy but that that's compliments um where I have landed is governed by two sort of contradictory impulses actually and this is after having listen to everybody and trying to figure out a way we could thread the needle the first is that uh it is very clear to me that parents in our district want to be able to get in touch with their kids

216during an emergency um and I think the specifics of our district that we are in a fire has its own this has now been proved in 2018 and now 2024 I sure hope not that it is likely there will be more emergencies in the future uh this is the reality we deal with we don't quite know how those emergencies are going to P out so that's the first thing which has got me my my thinking the second thing is that as a parent myself who grapples with these devices on a daily basis um I I viewed firsthand and every family I know this you firsthand that these smartphones and I want to be very clear there smartphones not traditional flip phones smartphones okay have a very negative effect on child behavior on Child Focus uh

217the data is extremely cleare on a global scale uh that since the Advent of smartphones they have had a dramatic effect on student learning they've had a dramatic effect on mental health um many statistics have been bounced around there's been a whole lot of data the one that's really struck with me more than anything is that the the decade with the most um mental health issues globally now are people in their 20s it used to be people in their 50s okay which quite a few of us up here who may for what decade um but people in their 20s faced with depression anxiety directly correlated globally the Advent of smartphones in 2012 and we as a society and us as a district we have to take responsibility for that and make sure that our generation

218of kids when they go out into the world are not going to be part of that P so these are very contradictory impulses um where I would suggest we move um is yes off and Away has definitely seen improvements we are still seen a whole lot of infractions though and there are many teachers who do not necessarily monitor in the costum every single interaction and neither should they have to monitor every single infraction um so I feel like our policy needs to be strengthened um in in certain ways my suggestion is actually based around the proposed board policy that we have tonight I have some amendments to the the text which I would like to propose want to hold those we come finish coming and then we'll shift to the board policy those things so

219I appreciate everybody coming and speaking tonight it's nice to hear um with the community the temperature of community and what you're feeling um I I personally I like the board policy that the state and I am all about enforcing the state rules and regulations I also um uh Echo Miss Stein's concern about um people feeling like the Yonder bag decision has already been made and um I would like to keep an open mind I think that there are better ways to spend our resources than spending them on Yonder bags but I'm just one board member um and I would like to see more um data data on how off way is working and I would like to give press pause and give um get a feel for how test scores are improving or not and

220um I don't think that we have ever as a board operated um in a rush to to implement policy I think we've always taken data and weighed the pros and cons and and looked carefully at the issue and um and I hope that that we will spend some time with this policy and enforce I I think we have some good options here and I think ofen way is working from what I've seen But as there there could still be Improvement thank you I have so many notes and I already spoke but I'm just going to say that I agree with um three three other board members that have already spoken I think we need to slow down I think we I think again there's some H confusion especially at Lindero um over you know when

221Yonder is going to be implemented I think we slow down i' like to see us wait at least this rest of the school year GA gather data I don't even know what metrics are being used um of course there's still going to be infractions of course students are going to abuse it they abuse everything it was on test before I was in school and you were in school so I mean cheating and bullying you don't need cell phones for that so I think I love the thing and I wrote it down on my own but I love the thing about being responsible D digital citizens that includes devices and I really feel strongly about that we have digital citizenship I don't even know Mr Klein is it included in what we teach do we strengthen

222do we need to strengthen what we teach I've also heard I won't let you speak I also heard that um you know what what you know we want the kids cell phones off or the student cell phones off you know in case of an emergency well are we teaching those when we do lockdown drinks I mean there's so many questions here that everybody said a lot of kids in I mean we don't tend to get in the weed but this is weedy and I have been asked a bunch of of technical questions that you know I'm never I'm not going to have the answers to but I hope that the district is asking and talking to schools and teachers about this there are middle schoolers definitely elementary schools but there's middle schoolers who don't have

223a cell phone so somebody brought up and somebody called me about this and said so are they going to search my kids back because I come to school with an empty Yonder so there's just I think this is wonderful discussion that we're doing it's important honestly this policy doesn't need to be adopted until 2026 I was pleasantly surprised to realize this would no end next school year but we have time I was on our side to let off and Away work and I think we do have board consensus up here Mr Lyn so you'll get a chance to speak but that's amazing thank you but I I would really like to and I do thank you all for coming because we need to hear from you and we need to clear up some of this

224confusion so thank you I appreciate that too I'll just share a couple thoughts um I I probably you know I've been on the board now for what 12 12 years 11 years uh I did not anticipate this being as contentious I honestly thought this was an Noor um based on the parents that I've talked to based on my parent experience based on the Surgeon General telling us to remove the phones based on the governor asking us to do it based on every single medical study at the UN showing us that cell phones are destroying our students and they're destroying the educational environment they operating them um so all the studies were there um and uh you know but I also understand that we're a unique Community um and we have uh parents who have concerns

225are probably different than others but I think there's a couple things that we should be factful about we're not getting picking here there are 3,000 school districts in America that have deployed Yonder bags we're not the first we're not the second we're not the third we're not the second, 3,000 schools that who look to deploy these and they work uh and what's really interesting is when you talk to these school districts like the one and Falls Church that I talk to and talk to the school counselor there what they'll tell you is parents were more concerned than the students U our biggest issue was with the parents and once we in once we put it in place the parents saw how amazing it was they saw the culture change it brought about they saw that

226their kids were happier they saw that the social emotional well-being of their students improved they saw that their grades went up they saw what we heard from the principal who went and visited in South Central Los Angeles zero cyber bullying they went to zero not one Cas on their campus when they implemented Yonder bags uh so their trade-off and cost he said straight up I saved the amount of time I I now spend on Yonder bags personally is what I saved as a principal I used to have to do adjudicating student bullying student mental health so I think that's one for me two look the cost is a red hair uh we want to talk about cost we spend millions of dollars every year on student mental health Millions we have more student counselors in

227any school district of the region and no one's complaining about that um because it's for student mental health this has shown where it's worked in the school districts that it's in to have probably one of the single biggest impacts on student mental health so if we can move the needle on student mental health for 0.1% of our annual budget I'm all in I'll do it every day of the week and twice on Sunday uh I think everyone in this room would probably feel the saying what 0.1% of our annual budget compared to Millions we spend on counseling rightfully so for student emotional and social wellbeing which are very important causes than to everyone on the sport um I would say a couple last things um I think you know the challenge was off and away

228when my school district and priv this you guys visited one uh that's moving away from it is that it doesn't inculcate the culture change it doesn't help students understand that they are a phone- free environment it doesn't break the dopamine drift with the student young brains developing to the phone in their pocket and respectfully to the parents who say they want to text their kids during the day about pickup changes or doctor's appointments we don't want you doing that you were disrupting the student day it takes 23 minutes for the student brain once it receives a text to be able to refocus back on what's in the classroom so they have lost half of that class because of that text you sent and I would say we we' been just fine for the 75 years

229before where parents would call the front office and say I need Johnny or Susie to come for early doctor's appointment so I would say there's a lot of discussion we can have on this but I think we need to put aside some of the the falsehoods or the misinformation out there and focus on what I think we all collectively agree on is that we want to move the needle on student mental health I think that's critical and the most important thing um you talk about wind and slow it down I don't know how much slower we could go where passing a board policy that won't be implemented until next school year we spent the last 12 months having more than a dozen meetings in discussions in public about this topic we've done site visits so

230this has been a collaborative process uh we are now voting on a board policy change that we're required to by law we're having the first reading at this board meeting no one's voting on it it was agendized we're going to have another board meeting in two weeks will the same board policy will come back when we agendize it and then we'll have six months before it's implemented for our school district well excuse me the part of it that's not um on the board policy there's a couple things with the board policy one is I want to know about high schools and I want High School input let's shift sh that but that and and I want these people to leave here tonight with some answers about Yonder so Dallas we know you support Yonder which

231is great I don't have enough information yeah we know you don't support you have since so stop both sides a little a little any proposal I don't see I don't see us I mean we'd have to be rolling out yonder now it's not it's not wasn't it supposed to be red out now this is the part I it wasn't supposed to Dr Stefan and Miss fa were you going you were talking all spring about February rolling out yonder at lindera correct yes we often Dr Steph where are we with that are where were we with that we two board members of the I that's not for the super us here's here's the reality we asked staff we asked staff to put together what a plan could look like if we wanted to implement ybs it

232it be done without coming to the board said yeah because because you would have played both sides the fence and but UPS said the other way so so so what we did to sta is we said before we drop this on a school before we Dro this on a district before we say let's do it investigate the time cost effort analysis of what it would take go find the school go visit the school take the principal to the school identify the campus that makes the most sense if we were to Pilot one we looked at all the middle schools lero made the most sense because it has the most limited access points in and out all these things were done by staff each step of the way so they could present to the board a

233decision that says here's here's the options before you here's the pros and cons here's the effort it would take to implement I don't know what more the staff could have done more effectively to bring this to the board they did all the research that we asked for it's not what I'm that's not what I'm saying I'm saying that we did get notices it's saying that yonder are going to be start like you know February March or something like that where is that notice it's in Friday it is absolutely isn't itay was to be considered okay but they met with L okay anyway so I yes I'm against Yonder bags at this point I have an open mind but I don't have enough information as far as off and away yet I want metrics on it

234I did hear again from three other board members who are saying maybe some more time and more explanation exploration and some more stakehold involvement I think there's a lot of things I spent a lot of time over the break doing a deep dive into there's a lot of tech that's right on the cusp of like simple jamming things that can block social media and texting for certain hours during the day with campus parameters like I'm very interested in that that seems to be like I don't want to be buying a beta max if the VHS is about to come out if I an AG s there um but you get the gist so there's a lot of things that we would and and if we went down that road we would ask what does that

235look like how does how does it how does it go a campus can we have a principal tell us how they would deploy that so anything that we would do we start to roll out in terms of what does it look like and how would it how would it work and it became clear as the more we discussed this to me um in the last several weeks as we've discussed this that that we just weren't there yet that this was rushed and uh but I don't think but that was never a decision made and that was never a decision to the board so I mean I think there's a lot to look at and discuss here of how this you know how this rolls out so I'd like to shift us to the actual agenda

236item if we could and then happy to take disc maybe SL turn over you for discussion on the changes you wanted to propose to you put theard policy up on the screen is that you puty have policy in front of us which I think can we strengthen and I would like to to do can we put it is it hang on I I got in um I have um I I have five specific points I'd like to mention regards to the policy indul okay so the first point is the first line of this policy says the government board recognizes the positive and negative impact mobile communication devices have on student I would suggest we just strike line or that we replace it with word that says which will give at least a culture in the

237schools a chance of taking root of the governing board recognizes that smartphones in particular not flip phones have a negative effect on student learning and mental health I something let me just finish my points and then this point of course um the first one I don't think it's necessary because honestly the four positive benefits of having smartphones in schools are already listed further Below in this policy in the case of an emergency um no one should there medical reasons mental health reasons uh if an IP is involved or when a teacher specifically requests for a smartphon to be used we've covered any positive usages and I truly do not believe there are any further uh positive uses for SP and the usually usually with a policy the opening sentence kind of is the opening sentence

238that guides it and guides like I agree don't beyond the ones which are already listed there which many of the parents here tonight have expressed concern about being able to contact their child in case of emergency if there's an IP if there's a doctor's reason if there's a mental health reason or if a teacher and I want to be respectful to the fact that teachers want to sometimes use these so that's open governing Bo recognizes the negative impact or you want to go Califoria I I would personally like to add change the wordage to the governing board recognizes the ne negative impact that smartphones have on student learning and mental health if the board does not go with I would just first I would just take the first L can you read the one the

239one you just said the governing board recognizes the negative impact that smartphones noton smartphones how about smart devices because you got watches fa um have on student learning and mental health that means that our entire culture is going to be oriented around trying to mitigate the negative effects in our schools and take it really seriously even if we don't have the Y let's take one time that works for me that works for okay than um the second thing is I very strongly support having Bell to Bell paid to 12 fans on using the phone except for the reasons which are listed here if there's an emergency if there's an IP if there's a doctor or if teacher specifically requested okay so I strongly support that that's that's that's in the board that's that's in the

240proposed board policy no no just let's take them one at a time so I just have a quick clarifying question for Miss f is that in the current policy is that what the high schools are doing right now no the high schools are allowing it so before before I would agree to that change I would want to get input from the high schools I disagree I so we can have a we can vot that later we're not voting that was a change he was he supports the starting with 2025 but wait let's make sure sure that we have a majority of board members who support that language because I'm asking for more information that's in I think about that I don't I don't know it's an information item and we're but we're rewriting but we're

241rewriting is we're talking so do we want to well when we vote we can that I strongly support that um the the third thing is is you know first of all having heard from our fantastic L the USD teachers tonight who you know as I've said many times uh on on the campaign Trail they the life blood of our district and I think they should be heard very very strongly and I'm hearing them with regards to the under B I'm hearing them that they feel that ofen away has truly U made great progress although there's further progress to be made what I would ask of the teachers okay uh is that the wordage here we have um for number four is when teacher or administrator grants permission to a pupil to possess or use a

242smartphone okay subject to any reasonable limitation the the way it is currently worded it says that a teacher if they just decide to okay can let kids in class use a fund and of course we want to give teachers the ability to teach in the way that they want and so on but I would like wordage added to that that says teachers will use their discretion to ensure that smartphones are only used okay when there is a need that cannot be fulfilled in any other instructional way in other words don't put a head on a phone unless it is absolutely necessary uh in if there's an app that they absolutely must have in order to teach in a certain way or uh I mean we survived in classrooms very very well for 250 years without

243smartphones we have computers in our classroom we have all sorts of things in our classrooms do we have to use smartphones in the classrooms unless they are absolutely necessary so saying to teachers you can't use them I'm just saying if teachers can use their own discretion that they will only uh suggest use of these funds when it is absolutely necessary I think that violates Ed code doesn't it so it's two separate things so we can't change what edcub says but the board can put like you can't say teachers can't do it correct right but as so this will St as is because this is directly edod but the board can add language after saying that it is the board's direction that so you can do that what you can't say is that teachers are not

244able to use phones in their classroom yeah no I was suggest you how are power are the public school districts that are doing it that are requiring the teachers to get permission before they use the cell phon just like they would have to check out a trolley of iPads getting around that so there are currently I know two teachers I mean two principls Mr ANH and I know Mr Foley are currently having their teachers do that that if they want to use their cell phones for a lesson they come to the principal to tell them that it's not required by Ed code and again we can't really put that limitation that we can rep that but we can say it is the board's directive that and whatever it is teach teachers will endeavor to only

245use these smartphones when it is absolutely necessary and cannot be accomplished in any other way and that is truly what I would ask of the teachers that they use that sort of view when they're using smartphones in classrooms that they don't it's so easy to go to a phone for everything there's an app for everything that it's easy to reach for a phone I'm a little uncomfortable with this because I Happ to trust our teachers themers you know if a teacher violating they're on their cell phones like watching movies or playing games I think it's you know accountable that picture that pretty much has to have a photot one is that it is true there are teachers who say we have 10 three minutes you can do and I think that's what iar is trying

246to avoid uh it's also true that we have for instance um robotics at Lindero or sports medicine at aora they have some things that are phone based apps where they do things so so I I I'm I'm happy for that the practice of of so I I I don't know how you lock that down but I know what Mr Lazar is trying to avoid the the time killer with your phone the board desired I would just say something that isn't a shall shall B I heard a lot from the parents today that I appreciate it about letting us parent our kids with the rules that we want and I have to say you have to respect both sides that because there is not an insignificant number of parents that are adopting weight to eight or

247parents who are saying I don't want my kids to have a cell phone and you completely violate that parent's right and that child's privacy when the teacher says okay everybody take out your $ thousand phone and we're now going to do something in class with it and that student doesn't have one it is so upsetting to me that we don't respect that side of the equation as much as we don't respect the other side I do not think there is a single educational purpose a teacher should be using phones for in the classroom that they not CED with the principal and set up and had phones ready for kids you may not have one I I think it is I am shocked it hasn't been sued for a fairness issue we can't require kids to

248bring colored pencils to school unless we fund them for them and now we're saying you have to bring a $1,000 iPhone because a teacher is going to say bring out your phones because we're going to use them in class it is wrong um and it takes away a parents right to choose if they do not want to have a kid have a phone environment so if we're going to respect both sides I think we have to you know you gota you gota gota be you got to be consistent I do agree with Dallas on this um I I feel in terms of teachers input we're hearing what teachers are saying in terms of the improvements under off and away we are hearing what teachers are saying in terms of Yonder device we hearing all very

249strongly but we we we want the out side of the equation heard too from parents okay that these smartphones need to be limited in class as much as possible that for me is meeting in the middle finding a compromise you want you want to think on that and come back to us in two weeks I just want make I didn't write edod so I I did but edod is clear that it is the teacher discretion correct so instead of directive I can word it so it's right I can work something like that and bring it back next time I get the gist of what you're saying but I I do think it would not be restrictive for a teacher to have to seek permission uh to use cell phones in the classroom for an assignment

250um schol are doing that teach disagree but Ard allows teachers to Grant permission without so are we able to say it's our preference um just the the other point with regards to the proposed policy is discipline is talked about I'm not uh familiar with the language enough to say is strong discipline uh that that teachers and administrators can use to enforce the off and Away policy and no phone Bell to Bell except for the cases we've mentioned emergencies and so on um is the wordage in strong enough on the discipline front so that we can truly enforce this I mean honestly if we enforced a strong policy for six months you know the Y discussion would go away that's the thing to Mr lazar's point I was going to ask do we need an AR

251an administrative regulation usually has the Reg ation the discipline listed in it and that was the next step that I was going to ask I think we need an administrative regulation Mr um lazar's other point or same point is we really need um and I don't know what they are consistent by level uh discipline um measures actions whatever and so we need to see that in an administrative regulation the other thing that I was going asked to your point too is do we need some I I we have a um uh d uh Tech technology acceptably use for the parents and students sign I I'd like to know what can we have one for for parents and students to sign on on devices you know these are our rules and so our kids do sign

252that but it's for devices that we provide no but I'm just you know onell you know the cell phone and this is the discipline can we do that we use I think there couple we actually talked a little bit about it when we talked about it it's a little bit ahead of a little bit where we are we want to get the procedures in place there's a lot of discipline that we have in the student handbook that's not in a board policy but it's developed as a result of a board policy and that code usually isn't as clear on what the discipline should be just that you are allowed to do disciplinary measures as long as it's within one of the Ed codes that that you don't violate like you can't suspend for willful Defiance

253for example so we have to kind of look at what we adopt and it plays out and then at levels come up with with the disciplin is which is what we currently have and I don't think it's out of the question down the line to develop an AR in that direction and we had previously talked about and I think I think at some point you know like we said like tonight being we got some information but to again mr's point is the discipline and what is being done at school and the enforcement part piece of it I think we need more information on the uh enforcement one of the things that we heard I one the parents had said that was spot on when they said that we need to make this a parent discipline

254problem as well parent there needs to be consequences for the par and that the the what we saw worked one of the schools we visited was uh I think if we ought to put it in the AR to Mr D's point we shouldn't leave this to each individual school to really is you know what worked very effectively is first time you get caught you pick the frun at the end of the day the second time you get caught your parents come pick it up and it's only picked up two days a week uh it's on Friday and Wednesday think legally uh it was a public school they're doing it just fine yes you can yes you keep breaking the rules or to your point I think one of the reasons why it's so important and

255I've heard from a lot of people that once this is in place is because right now there's nothing in our policy that if somebody takes possession of the phone and somebody says it's damaged they're responsible this now right lays out that we are not responsible for that I think to miss ste's point I think we should have clear they on what the so that it's or if you think of another way to do it once we get this in place and and we were able to sit with the principles is it really has to be uniform between Elementary their policies middles there which is going to take a little more time again to the reason why we we're voting on a board policy in January that we're not implementing until August so you have that

256amount of time to get it well we're not implementing the high school plan we are keeping the exact same policy at elementary and middle school so yeah we had already talked about n AR we just didn't feel like we were there yet until we see where the policy landed then we'll develop that and yes I do think it needs to be codified in N AR great um I just have one more comment on all of this and again I'm not sure if it specifically related to this proposed board policy uh but it's something I feel very strongly about is in this whole discussion we haven't talked much about the difference between smartphones and flip phones and if you read someone like John height anxious generation yes y bags mentioned but flip phones are also mentioned

257is a very very strong alternative I know for myself with a 10-year-old daughter the first phone I get her will be a flip phone which is capable of text it is capable of calls uh it is a great way to communicate with parents when you need it um and this doesn't have the addictive qualities of smartphones if you look back at 2008 2009 when kids had flip phones there were none of these issues with mental health there were none of these issues uh with with academic success so I I don't something that can included ENC they usually have several of them have BB apps several have a Facebook be a specific flip You' have to You' have to investigate but again if they were of away Fund in school yeah okay you you wouldn't have

258phone calling you like Gollum from the bag my precious my precious flip phones don't do that they just purely Y and need call my dad let let me get him on the phone it's not like I want to play that game or I want to go on Tik Tok or they don't have the same addtive effect I agree but we do have parents who are calling students during the school day are and Mr we we you we TR discussed that so we apply that research and it's a spectrum of flips and unfortunately Spectrum includes ones you describe which is texting and also that are Facebook social media 100% capable we think the flip phones is the '90s phones that we had the new the new flip phones and they're not many they do unfortunately have

259spectrum of capabilities no just I mean flip phones off no though yeah I don't mean flip phones in in someone's pocket I'm just saying that that would help parents because many of us are pressured into this decision to get a Fone because of of peer pressure from uh other kids from it starts very very early if everyone started getting flip phones a lot of us would feel a lot easier I I would say one of the reasons why I'm comfortable why we discussed pulling the Y item and not having on the agenda is exactly the comment you made uh and that is um I think within 18 months um I know that um one of the largest one of the largest private schools in the Beverly Hills area is adopting it now is a new

260technology that puts a cell phone gamping blanket the kids have to put an app on their phone if they want to bring the phone to school they're required to download this app and that app blocks all functionality with the exception of phone calls that's what I it's still being a lot of stuff we're on the precipice of a lot of simple adoptable tech for school districts that will block they will not be able to be calling their May years ago when we went to Las Vegas to look when we were looking to bring in um that's why Apex we we actually two schools that actually had the capability within their classrooms to block cell phones and that was what 10 years ago maybe so it doesn't weren changes so what I took away is one

261agreed upon thumbs up change from the board which was to the opening sentence to set kind of a thematic tone this board polic is in complicating a culture but we believe that overall self onus social media and students is in that negative and this is the policy to help mitigate liit that environment SCH um in two weeks we'll discuss we're not changing L this for now but in two weeks we'll have the thumbs up or thumbs down we can make edits on whether or not we want to embrace High School um I I think you know CH would love to hear from you and your uh you know put a surve I think it's great I think we'd love to hear what the students feel I think we'd be surprised what some of the students

262said I think you know I I'm still very touched by the students we talk to that campus and while the community might look different than ours kids are very similar and when we pulled a random kid out of the crowd the principal said pick anyone you want and we pulled this kid out of the crowd we said how's it been she goes you know what the biggest change is I used to be on my phone six hours a night when I got home now I barely use it I know I don't need it it it it literally broke the addictive cycle for her home as well as in the school these kids are like yeah stop a deal it was the fear of what the unknown consistently research shows the two worst things for young

263team girls is texting and social media which is why the pandemic of par isolation was so hard on that that group was because what did we leave them with texting and social media so I think about that a lot about you know and like I said I I've mentioned before I talked to an administrator in a neighboring District who said he didn't do his job anymore all he did was deal with social media bullying that happened during the day at school so you know I I'm happy of in a way is producing things but I'm also not deluded that you know we have a ways to go and you know to protect kids and that's what I want I want them to have that safe space in the day for learning it's not to punish

264anyone it's not to make them unavailable to their parents and it's it's very difficult and right no one will be fully happy probably with whatever we do um but it is it isn't done without a great deal of thought and research are we are we good yes feed we have six more items to go I'm sorry I know you but I just no far away um with the opening sentence I totally understand the tone of the negative impacts I do think board should also realize that there are positive impacts that come along with um cell phones on learning I remember a few years ago there were some teachers who came and listed all a bunch of positive impacts that cell phones have um once again if the tone is um intended to say that there

265are negative impacts that's totally okay I just feel like we should recognize that there are positive impacts as well um regarding Bel to Bell at high school level um you tou as well I'm definitely do a survey um I'll talk to students and staff members hopefully next meeting um for phones um um when you were saying phones are only if they're necessary um I feel like a lot of Compu and this was also touched on earlier a lot of computers and by Speaker a lot of computers but phones have very similar functions by taking away phone you're not necessarily going to be taking away all those capabilities if the issue is getting R to text and getting rid of social media there's plenty of other opportunities to do that on a computer there the the

266intention behind this is definitely positive one it's just difficult to kind of take that away by just removing phones because that issue is still present with computers um I also wanted to mention that I know a kid he's currently a junior at my school he doesn't have a cell phone um and he doesn't necessarily feel discriminated against he some things might be a little bit more difficult for example we'll have a group chat to work on a project and instead of having group chat we'll just have an email Cham but he's still tot gets by he's not being discriminated from anything he's still part of the groups he's still getting that communication and that's mostly because self phones I I'm I'm a student I'm a senior in high school I will admit cell phones are

267not necessary they're not they're prevalent in our lives but we can get along without them however they make life so much easier with so many things um there was a um this giens I think was talking about um how uh students need to use these phones to translate uh all these different documents you can do that with a computer it's just so much more difficult the cell phones really streamline everything when it comes to taking pictures of product projects when it comes to doing these translations when it comes to those minute things that you don't necessarily think are that b the deal but they all add up it takes so much more time to do all that via computer there are and if you're looking at the impacts of both cell phones and computers you're

268having the same impacts taking one away is not going to mitigate that and you're just going to make students lives a lot more difficult no I was just um one more thing with off and away it does I don't in my opinion it doesn't matter what if you're doing off and Away with a cell phone or with a flip phone because of in away is of in away you're not going to be using those devices regardless it doesn't matter what device is being off in away i' like to add something that Mr said said is uh Dr step and Miss is instead of you running you doing a survey and and is doing a survey of students really like it to be more organized and more um inclusive of a process with staff and discussions

269and students instead of just a blanket survey I'd really like them to to kind of help help craft what what you know how they should look at the school sites I mean obviously everybody knows our values our values is uninterrupted learning what does that look like so I'd like a little thought put into a process or something at the high school level instead of just a survey I'd love you to work with your counterpart with Miss fa with the principles and and see how that that looks great um Miss fa you're still up next I can go quickly uh 5141 point21 uh L Virg last updated this Bo policy in 2024 and they are in 2023 and one of the major things we're ahead of us all of our campuses currently have Nar can we

270are currently doing the training but what this adds is which we currently do not have is it includes language prohibiting the administration of medical cannabis on our campuses which we currently do not have in our policy that's the major update we do have n can at all of our campuses just really updating the board poliy to reflect what we have I have no speaker cards in that one you're good to go wait and I have a question so who is trained because in reading it it needs to be somebody then more than just the health clerk at the schools the nurses went in and trained the staff during STS oh fantastic thank you do do we have a long issue with kids with addicted to ulates and stuff at the schools are not we have

271a large issue no do we do we even not administer any than F yeah but this is a state law is a state law a state for it's not a state for the Cannabis Cor yes for yes for educational purposes yes state law makes a difference between being able to use medical marijuana and not on school campuses so we oftentimes have kids who have medical marijuana licenses or prescriptions through doctors who believe that they can do that on campus and this pleas states that they cannot which prior to that was not intive this um so now we are on 51 41.24 so the deletion of the board policy and the revision of the AR csba um currently does not have a board policy anymore 51 41.24 but does have an updated AR which we asked

272last updated in 2001 and it's really part of stream lining and making all these policies not so redundant and it really focuses on Specialized healthare for students with dis abilities it clarifies the qualifications needed for credential nurses or licensed Physicians guidelin for maintaining confidentiality and ensuring student safety dign dignity and privacy when they're having their health care services delivered on than um the revision to board policy 6.11 uh Los virgines last updated the bpn AR in 2014 and the most recent update focuses on providing students with flexible Pathways to fulfill graduation requirements um under the new board policy students can Al meet certain course requirements through alternative means such as independent study work experience CTE and college coursework these options are intended to accommodate diverse learning needs and help students earn credits through practical applications

273including supervised work instruction and the AR which I'm going to let uh Dr scan talk about further specifies um about um how students can alternative credits toward graduation Mr President members of the board um the key highlights for the to the a is um that we would be allowing students 10 credits per year so 40 credits total with um college credits um it also specifies which previously um not doing this this was a disservice to our students so this is a benefit to them that college courses that are three units or more would be equivalent to 10 high school credits so it specifies that um and then it clarifies our concurrent dual enrollment so it's very clear to students what's allowed what's not allowed and then it also specifies which we currently have in our

274policy English is taken with us for all four years and then adding that they would take math with us for the first three years and that's probably one of the bigger changes you're no longer able to take math off site over the summer uh for your first three years at if you want to take accelerated math correct if you want to take a fourth or fifth year you can but the first three have to be here so it would be that they have to be enrolled in math during the first three years however if a student wants to take math to accelerate over the summer in those first years they could but they would still be required to take inct with us the first years could take making it up albra 2 somewhere else but

275they have to take physics or whatever you know not physics here whereas if they take the first three they could take calculus offsite corre okay a couple questions did you delete the foreign language requirement and the driver okay so that was deleted uh map is a big change for us uh how let me see what else that was the BP and I have questions on the [Music] AR uh uh what do it say uh the AR right above military service no more than 40 total semester periods of course subcriptions are credited to a student towards graduation is that the same as the 10 This is 40 semesters so is that the same as a 10 per year right and everywhere else it's talking 10 per year and here it says 40 I think that was

276a little confusing for consistency do you want that's from that is from say okay is ours okay and then the intent of the language I remember this is the district sh Grant credit for foreign language studies it in a private school so it's the judge was not in like any private school because that could be a private college or whatever uh uh it it was um that uh private like Chinese school private hebu school it was a private language school so if you want to add that back in that was the intent of the original language um so what's the asking where are you Lon yeah I'm number I'm I'm foreign language instruction the district shall Grant credit for foreign language studies successfully completed in a private school should say private foreign language high school

277that's the on for students who want it on their High School transcript and take it at a foreign language we we added that years ago when we found that a significant amount of students um taking uh uh he Hebrew as a language at a private new school and I know there's private Chinese schools and I don't know what else so I think we want to say because because first of all foreign language is not a graduation requirement and loss vergence a lot of students some a lot of students take it in our school obviously goes on transcript a lot of students don't take it in our school either can go on our transcript if it's a college or not so the purpose of this I think needs to be clarified which it was for private

278uh foreign high schools so that was does that make sense to anybody would it be okay if I there is a school that I know many calabasa students attend for Hebrew and I'm not sure if it's a specific Hebrew language school I I would need to double check with calasses what is the school that most of our kids are going to for the Hebrew foreign language um I don't think you need to name them I would just say um it's a high school though I believe it's a high school right well is a private or you could leave it as a private foreign language school right well you want some level of accreditation right you don't want to be Jo's and I don't know if they're I don't know if they're was accredited so that

279comes you might want to do a little bit more flushing that out because that came from that and I don't know if it's was credited and there was I remember this discussion a million years ago and there was lot of it would have to be was president to get C to get high school yeah don't to call you have to have two years of for language to UC uh eligible cor so it would have to we'd be doing them a huge disservice to let them go to a non-w accredited school which thinking they check the box on their foreign language at the Hebrew school they're going to only to find out they can't go verly I would I would confirm that yeah that's what I would say okay and then in the um math one

280down down below conditions for accepting credit for concurrent enrollment classes the change about um all students must take English every semester during every semester of attendance and math during the first six semesters I would spell that out for consistency that looked odd to me but that's just me um and then the concurrent um so is it for the first six semesters or they must take it for six semesters here because that's no they have to take it in a row three years graduation requirement is three years so they can't take offsite math over the summer yes exactly they could if it was for the purposes of acceleration but it would not count towards their graduation requirement for the math they can't take per say algebra one let's say in ninth grade geometry over a summer

281and go right into summer elsewhere and go right into this is a big change they could go right what's happening is students are taking one algebra one then geometry and then maybe they not enrolling in math their sophomore year and they're waiting then again till the following summer to take math so they're not taking math with us and what we found when we did some data analysis is that the students that were taking summer math courses and then not necessarily enrolling in with us about 15% of those students had standards met or exceeded in cast only we also didn't you also do some research as far as like I said you take algebra let's say you take algebra one in nth grade you take geometry or something outside over the summer and then they come

282back and they do Algebra 2 which but they weren't successful right so now we want them to take all three years 9th 10th 11th grade that's the graduation requirement in our schools okay we often times have kid because we do the cast in 11th grade we have kids who for two years have not taken a math course with us and then our math scores are very low I think it was less than 5% in some of the grade levels were meets are exceeds in math um so we're really drilling down on making sure that kids are not taking just six weeks of a math skipping year another six weeks of a math so it was really important to us that we we are ensuring these kids are receiving a quality math instruction not that they

283all were not but we have some control over that how many students were taking math at during those three years outside L virgous um we had it was like 150 I cut off nth and 10 grade but we had 58 12th graders we had um 37 11th graders we had upwards okay so this is going to be a big change of culture yes um so is this go when is this going to be communicated out to schools I mean we'll be voting on it the next meeting but then immediately because it gets into the second semester they're making plans and it should also be communicated to eth grade parents because if they won't affect doesn't affect right well because schools would likely have already signed off on second semester or the year for math so

284it'll be as new ones come up we can't go back now what I'm saying no no no what I'm saying is eighth graders going into ninth grade May skip a math which is exactly what you don't want them to do then right once it passes it'll be point is you are a student who is currently planning to take right geometry over the summer over the summer this summer and that's been your plan are they being nipped and this policy we have period I might be open to thinking about a grace period for year some people really plan that out well that's what I'm saying we've got it communicated so I'd like to get it communicated out like to vote on this get it communicated out this what she wants to rush she would D that

285you know our focus in math in particular has really been to drill down and improve and so if we really want to send that message I think it's important that we start as saying now to get that message Point let's make sure we don't just pass this that we do a parent communication and counselors need to be aware principl everybody thank okay go and then I have one more the a oful guidance are waiting for updates on this because they're ready because it's all part of the course selection process for next year and no one's saying that a a kiddo that wants to take geometry over the summer can't it's just that they will then be expected to take Algebra 2 the following year you can wait them until they're going to be okay based

286on the bo conversation well I didn't get that either okay but I'm okay um I have just one very quick question is no cost of the district right if the student goes outside to take F get credit well no there there is a hidden CA right so it decimates our foreign language part so we have we have we've had to cut our forut SE because kids were not so we don't have to pay for that but we lose we lose the ability to have great foreign language teachers who are teaching it and and teaching a year-long course so there is a there is a hidden cost but I believe that even with foreign language like as Miss cville and I know with our kids it is um I think the foreign language has gotten more

287robust school's correct so it's bounced back which is we're not here more tires we used to have no no no right well they stay we're not the number side go back a little B nothing nothing like the yeah I think service has done a tremendous job uh trying to reinvent how IB and honors and AP can all integrate um and that has really increased our Spanish in home yeah I think Chu of that's probably also the Su F extension it is the popularity Chang okay one last question um number seven at the end the last page concurrent enrollment AP and honors L courses will not be waited for the purposes of appearing on the high school transcript all concurrent enrollment blah blah blah 4.0 not very weighted break is that current that's current we just

288didn't have our policy but current not anything new it just wasn't in our policy okay thank you that's it on this one all right next one is an AR 617 sorry sorry still on this um couple questions um you were asking about the independent Lang language pools um I do have a few friends that go to school called kho Hebrew High um I'm pretty sure it is credited for the past years it has gone in transcript and when it comes to uc's and CSUS it's still sh me that they have language so I agree with you miss Stein like that sort of thing should students should still be able to have that sort of program um when you you mentioned something about uh if you take a college course that's worth three plus credits that

289would equal I think you said 10 high school 10 high school credits would that be a one semester College course is equal to a full year of and does that go for everything like dual enrollment such as anthropology and business marketing and things like that or would that be specifically for subjects like English or math it would not du enrollment because those arees that are taken on campus it's whatever those credits are for that class on the campus but for any courses outside concurrent enrollment which have to be courses we don't offer correct so that's that's the you can't you can't take your class that you would like to that that we that we offer at a community college for one semester and then get a years with a creditor do you offer that if

290there are students whool if there are students who are trying to take a course but it doesn't fit in their schedule so and they still would like to take that class they're forced to take it out of commun college but they still be able to get as school credit for that there are some exceptions we need your mic for the video micone flashing okay so there are some exceptions in those scenarios where like they SCH that work all right and then last question um would math outside of aora high school count as a high school credit but not necessarily towards those three years for graduation yes yeah we just said it one are you asking if it goes on your transcript it would go on your transcri your high school graduation requirement you'd still have

291years yes but those students would still get the credit so we is it going back to that policy is it the first three years do we wanted to take consecutive years on Ma yes okay and and make sure that's spelled out that's why I say it's the first six semesters okay that's why okay I don't think that's clear because you because you can take it in the summer you can you can take an off-campus geometry class in the summer as long right under this current policy some get home you can you can go take geometry in the summer under the new on the polic we passing come back get Geometry count towards college and everything else uh and then take two more years uh uh of M so it doesn't it's not clear that we

292say the the six semesters that we're not counting the summers in between because make sound like you you am I being CLE yeah off we don't offer Su right well that's what I'm saying the first six semesters are only your freshman sophomore and junior year can we can we spell it out 9 through 11 also can we say read in parentheses 9 11 your ex example you go off and you take geometry over the summer and you come back as a sophomore now you have to take out you can't you can't take it for advancement to open up for an ele understod but you can take it off campus yes in your first six semesters no you can yes you take it in the summer between your first your third second third semester that's why

293it's you have to wait until after sixth semesters before you go off campus and we're not saying yeah okay thank you we need some clarity on that thank you all right [Music] so all right we ready to move on ready ready um csba does not have a BP or an AR 61723 we talk to the assistant principles do you want to keep this it very much mirrors what we just discussed the only thing we basically changed besides what we just talked about was out of Pathways we talked about parents were not really clear about what concurrent enrollment was so we clarifi that we're [Music] not that that's really change the other changes are what we already talked about in the previous discuss okay so I have a question on this one on number five there's

294a word that's stuck out that I don't love but I may be alone students are responsible Prov for providing official verification from the College of the grade ear ear isn't it a transfer number five is that last offal verification students are responsible for writing official verification from the College of the grade earned at the conclusion of the semester colleges have transcripts um and then back down to number nine is that new or is that not new college or any advanced honors level that's what we currently do okay great so we can put put transcript in parentheses is that okay yeah you want do all right two more sorry um just curious why aren't college courses weighted as a 5.0a when we have AP classes that are college level but they in high school uh so

295with college classes the we don't you can think about the the just the breadth of how many college classes you could take from me there's no way for us to discern the quity university the thing that we we have always gone with is that the high schools or ex the colleges will recalculate GPA based on all the transcripts us whether it's the high school or the concurrent uh transcript call so regardless of if we put it on our transcript or not if we had a counselor here there would be saying it's really a move point because the Admissions Office at the college and the university is going to recalculate and reweight that based off of theirs are we done this is what so we are adding BP and they 61721 you can paid by how

296many PPS um what's the word night and Miss fall as the board policy AR Queen because I don't know if I've ever seen any of this m on board meeting so thank you for bring but thank you um so we currently do not have this this is a policy that csba adopted in 2020 we do not have the BP L the AR um and it focuses on concurrent enrollment in college classes for high school students their recent updates emphasize expanding dual enrollment opportunities through College and Career access Partnerships with community colleges and these Partnerships aim to prepare students for College and Career Readiness improve graduation rates and provide CTE Pathways we are doing a lot of this already we just don't have the BP and the AR to quantify this okay and then we come

297to the last one uh 61 73.1 education for foster youth are our last update was 2013 there have been a lot of updates since that time mostly expanding the definition of what a foster youth is making sure that schools immediately enroll students who are Foster youth despite the fact that they may not have the proper documentation providing transportation for those students at which we currently have an agreement with Lego to get reimbursed for that transportation and then provide a dispute resolution process ensuring that the Foster youth is able to remain in their school of origin no matter where they are placed so even if they're placed in Downey they have a white to attend less virgin to schools if that was their school of origin I I have a question that just as an aside

298that you may know the answer to I had a uh someone I knew who was a foster parent suggest to me one time that perhaps one of the reasons we have such a low number is if you're a foster parent in LA county that there's all these kind of you know there's meetings there's and they sort of require you to go like downtown LA like we're as far on the county Edge as possible in fact this person moved to the Ventura County side of wlake so that they could like not have to drive to downtown LA anymore and they said that they met a lot of people who wanted to Foster out here but didn't do it because LA County was so unmovable about some of the requirements of making that connection is that still

299the same no leers made a lot of improvements and thene we currently have about 23 Foster youth in the district um it still seems low to me for it's I mean it's pretty much on average of What like us have um so they don't require them to go to Downey and almost everything through Lego now is virtually which is nice so when I meet with families and their Lego liaison it's all virtual they don't make families come in anymore which is nice I'm not sure people out here know that you know and they try to yeah that's good that's good to hear and that is it for me well thank you to staff for a long day after a long week we appreciate it um and I would say thank you to everyone on the

300board for uh I think good conversation on I mean what's clear is we're all passionately focused on trying to improve student mental health um so if there wasn't a passion discussion I'd be disappointed um so with that we will adjourn

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.