CorpusRecord 40063

2.13.25 Special Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Vimeo / Livermore Schools
Date
2025-02-13
Location
Alameda County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,263 words · about 63 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Okay, welcome. We're going to start before we begin with anything else, we're going to begin with our flag salute. And I would ask, Trustee Vanden Heuvel, if you will please lead us in the flag salute. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Well done. This is a special board meeting of the Board of Education for the Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District, where the primary focus is the education of students in this district. During the public, do we have a public hearing today? Sorry, we're going to we're going to begin with our discussion action items. We have our school site reports, and we are going to go a little bit out

002of order and invite our principal for adult education Ms. Sarah Walk to come first. She is not feeling 100%. So we are going to let her go. And then we're going to force her to go back home and go to bed. Good morning, President Prusso, members of the board, Superintendent Gibson, cabinet members. Yes, thank you. I know I have not had the pleasure of meeting all of you. My name is Sarah Walk, and I'm the principal of Livermore Adult Education. And those who have seen me before know that this is something that I get very excited about and very passionate about. And I don't have the same level of energy to this morning, but that doesn't mean I'm any less passionate or excited about what we do at Livermore Adult Education. A couple of highlights.

003For this year, we implemented a new computer literacy course for our students. We know that computer literacy is such an important aspect for everyday life. We have continued to offer both in-person and online instruction when many of our peers have left online instruction to the side. We are well into our second cohort of our child development associate certificate program, and it has doubled in size this year or so. We're very excited about that. And this is the second year that we participated in the Livermore Holiday Lights and Sounds Parade, and it was a great... We used to have an internal Christmas event or holiday event, and it turned out to be more work and less fun. So we decided to shift and do something more fun. So we have a float. We've had a float

004in the parade for two years now, and we will continue to do so because it seems to be a great success. This is our demographic breakdown. This is pretty steady. We always have more females than males. We always have 25 to 44-year-olds as our largest group. The percentages shift a little bit from year to year, but this is a pretty steady number, and it reflects the state numbers across the whole state. Here in our district, in Livermore Adult Education, this is our ethnic breakdown, self-reported ethnic breakdown for our students. This is not the most updated version of my slides, unfortunately. You have it? Okay. But I don't have it. But what you could see is that from the paper that you're looking at, the number of the percentage of people in our English language program

005has reduced, but it has not reduced in broad numbers. It's reduced in percentages because we've increased enrollments in other programs which are taking away those percentage points. So we're very pleased to be increasing the numbers of the folks who participate in our citizenship prep course, our child care, high school diploma. So that's what the shift is there. I can see what you see. Thank you, Amy, for sharing. And then if I go down to program enrollment percentages for online versus in-person, this number has dropped for a variety of reasons. We have some challenges. Finding an instructor who is really comfortable and embraces online instruction is our biggest challenge in this area. So we are continuing to pursue that. All right. Here's a story. I'm going to tell you a story about adult education. We have

006a different model than the K-12 model, although we are part of the K-12 school district. We are under the California Department of Education. In our enrollment process, we have a series of benchmarks. So our first benchmark is the number of people who actually come and register for our program and complete a pre-test. Every person has to take a standards based pre-test before they can start classes. They take post-tests after a certain amount of time. That is a requirement of all of our grant funding. So as you see, we enrolled and pre-tested more people in 22, 23 than we did in 23, 24. Our second enrollment benchmark is what the state and the federal grant defines as an attendee. An attendee is an individual who has completed completed the pre-test and attended one or more classes.

007So as you can see in 23, 24, even though we pre-tested fewer people, we had more people who actually came to class. So we're happy that we're proud of that. Benchmark number three is what the state of California defines as a persister. A persister is an individual who completes the pre-test, attends 40 or more hours of class, and then completes a post-test. Again, as you can see, we have steadily been increasing post-COVID the number of students who get to that persister point and take the post-test. So even though we have registered fewer, we have more people hitting this benchmark, which is great. And then our benchmark number four is what the state and the federal government defines as a level completer. This is an individual who completes the pre-test, attends 40 or more class hours,

008completes the post-test, and advances to the next instructional level based upon their test scores. So again, we have steadily increased the number of students who have been able to complete a level since post-COVID. So we're very pleased with that. So that's our story. That's our data story. And adult ed is very much pay for performance in that our federal funding is dependent upon the number of students we serve and the number of students who become level completers. So this is a very important number for us. This persister rate, which I mentioned, is something that the state started tracking, excuse me, the federal government, the WIOA grant office started tracking persister rate. Again, that's the people who pre-tested, attended 40 more hours of class, and post-tested. As you can see, we have across history, with the

009exception of during COVID, we have a higher rate of persisters than the state average. So we're very pleased with that. As of this time, the 23-24 state average hasn't been published, which is why it's not there. So we're very proud of that, too. One of the things, just to make another comment about persister, the thing about adult education is that it is not compulsory. Students come because they find it of value in their lives. And there's a statement in adult education, students vote with their feet. If they're not getting their needs met, they don't come to class. And so to have a high persister rate, higher than the state average, again, is something that we're very proud of as a program. The state each year gives us, based on numbers that they get from the

010federal government, again, level completion goals across our performance levels. You'll see here there's three programs, ABE, which is adult basic education, which is any learner who tests below a ninth grade level. So if I want to come and get my GED, I take my reading test and my math test, but my skills are below high school level, I will be placed in adult basic education. The second group is ASC, which is adult secondary education, and that's high school level. So basically ASC low is ninth grade and 10th grade. ASC high is 11th grade and 12th grade. And then the English as a second language program is divided into six different levels. So in 22, 23, we met or exceeded the CDA goal for each of our levels, except for ASC high. And then for 23,

01124, this one looks a little odd because for ABE, the lower levels, we didn't have any students. And then for ESL, the lower levels, we didn't have any students. And then the ASC high, in order to complete a level for ASC high, you can't do them on the post-test. You have to get either a high school diploma or complete your GED. So they have to reach the end goal to be a level completer if they're in the high level. So again, we're very proud of how well our students perform. I know this is a vocabulary lesson today, and I'm breaking all rules. You're not supposed to have any more than 10 vocabulary words in one day, but here we are. Here's another vocabulary word, payment point. This is a unit of measurement used to calculate

012future WIOA federal funding from adult education. So like I said, for our future federal funding, we are pay for performance. So a payment point is earned by level completion through the test or getting your high school diploma or your GED, like I just explained, or by achieving another set of predefined goals, such as getting a job, getting a better job, becoming a U.S. citizen, things like that. So we are very pleased, again, to see that our level of payment points has steadily risen over the last few years, meaning that our students are achieving their goals and our teachers are working really hard and our students are achieving their goals. So it's, again, very proud of that. So here are our areas of focus. As I mentioned, in the enrollment pathway, there are several points at

013which a student or a potential student can stop out. And historically, one of those biggest stopout points is between pre-testing, taking that pre-test, and then coming to that first class. Or, and then again, coming to that first class, but maybe not coming to the second class or the third class. So we, as part of our continuous improvement plan, which is something that we have to do for the adult education program at the state, we wrote a goal to have a technology-based orientation for our students. So they come and they take the pre-test. And rather than going directly into class, they go to an orientation in which we give them all of their accounts and all of their logons. And we give them the opportunity to log into our digital textbook and poke around and learn

014how to navigate it. We help them get an email address for their teachers. We help them send their first email to their teacher to introduce themselves. And for many of our students, our adult students, this is really the first structured introduction to technology that they've had. Many of them have not had lots of educational opportunities in their home country. So we designed this and implemented it this year. And we are looking forward. Initial numbers indicate that this alone is going to reduce our drop-offs between pre-testing and attendance that first class or attending the second class or the third class. So preliminary numbers look good. We're excited. It was one of those things that we thought, okay, we have to do this, but it looks like a huge monster. And how are we going to do

015it? But everybody just jumped in. We made a plan and it's been going great. We are continuing to collaborate with the curriculum department, working with our English language newcomers. There's a lot of overlap between our adults. And many of them are parents of our ESL students and newcomers. And we, again, are working, continue to work with our human resources department to find creative strategies for staffing and how to get our students who may have the educational credentials or the experience but don't necessarily yet have the English language capacity or they haven't had a chance to translate their work experience, their resume and their transcripts. So we have lots of people who are teachers in their home country in our classes. So we want to work with that. We have lots of people who have advanced

016degrees, mechanical engineers and veterinarians and attorneys and things like that. And so we are working to help them get the first foothold into what might be an appropriate job here at the district. So we're very happy about that. And that's it. And like I said, those of you who've seen me present before, this is definitely not my normal energy level because I do, I've been in adult ed since 1999. And it's where I belong. Each elementary school was not my gig, but adult ed is. And so I'm happy to be here and I'm happy to have the support of all of you. Thank you for presenting. Any comments, questions? Craig? Thanks for the presentation. How long have you been in your current capacity? Well, I joined our district in 2017. And so when I came

017in, I was the vice principal at, so Vineyard and Adult Ed were together. So first I was the vice principal under Carla Estrada, and then Carla moved on and then I became the principal of the two of them. And then the decision was made to split Vineyard and Adult Ed out right, I think in the middle of COVID. And so since that happened, I've been only the principal of adult education. So two years, three years? Yeah. Okay. I'm just noticing when you look at that slide, benchmark three, and it shows enrollment, the persister. In four years, you've doubled from 186 up to 406 on the persister number. And I'm just wondering, are you getting the resources that you need? Yes, of course. I mean, are there more, do we want more? Of course we want

018more. I mean, there's always things that we would love to have, but I feel very supported by the district. I feel very supported by our grant. We are granting structure for adult education on the state level is through a series of consortia that are arranged around the community college school district. And we're one of the smaller schools in our consortia, but I feel that yes, we are fairly funded within that group and we do receive support. Amy is my mentor and I appreciate that. Kelly has helped me a lot over the years and yeah, I do feel like I'm getting the support that we need. Okay. Well, my compliments on the presentation too, the way you presented it to me is unique and it's very thorough and I appreciate it. Thanks. Thank you. Thank you

019so much for coming and presenting. We're going to, I think we're, are you? Okay. One, just one question. Sorry. Look, it's really nice to meet you and thank you for what you do for our district and for the adults learning. And I saw that there are 66% or so of your students are English learners or English as a second language. And then only 7% are there for citizenship prep. Is that because they, is that normal? Is that or is that not necessarily the source for that type of preparation to get your? That is normal because the citizenship prep class is specifically designed to prep students to take the tests that they have to take during the naturalization process. So we teach much of the same content integrated through our classes, but the citizenship prep classes,

020usually for people who have their appointment, you know, it takes sometimes three years for them to get their appointment. They have their appointment, they know their date and they're going in to study hard to be ready to take the test. So yes, it is generally a rather small number in that class. And do you also provide other services like, like legal services or, you know, refer them to somebody who can help? We do. We have as part of our consortium, we have a person whose job title is transition specialist, which is a little confusing. Sometimes people confuse that with transitioning in special ed, but it's a different, it's a different person. And this person's job is to connect our students with community resources. And we share one transition specialist between Pleasanton adult school or Pleasanton

021adult and career education, Dublin adult school and Livermore. We, and the Tri-Valley ROP, we co-fund one full-time person rather than having, you know, smart. Yeah. Yeah. Great. Thank you so much. Thank you. Right. Thank you for coming. Thank you. Go get better. Lots of fluids. Okay. We're now going to invite principal Andrea Tapia to come up. She's the principal at Altamont Creek to give her presentation. Cheetahs, right? Wildcats. The cheetahs are cross the way. That's okay. Same area. Yes. Same side of the freeway. Okay. Well, good morning, board president Pruso, board members, superintendent Gibson and cabinet. I am Andrea Tapia. I am the proud principal at Altamont Creek where we're celebrating our 25th anniversary this year, which is super exciting. And all of our Wildcats work every day to be safe, respectful, responsible and always

022awesome. Don't forget that one. Okay. So looking at our demographics, we've held consistent right around 620 students. We have a ride range of different ethnic groups with 40, almost 40% of our students being of Asian descent. Within that, I kind of wanted to disaggregate that a little bit. And it was kind of amazing to see that at our school, we have 23 different languages spoken, which is pretty incredible. And we have our diversity day. We have about 25 to 30 countries represented every year. So it's pretty cool. Overall, our English learner population continues to decrease, but that's partly because students are being reclassified. And both our students with disabilities and economically disadvantaged students has been consistent the last few years. Looking at our dashboard data in both chronic absenteeism and suspension rate, we've stayed consistent

023at yellow. It's concerning, but we're absolutely addressing it. Our chronic absenteeism, it's a few students that are having a really hard time coming to school. And so we're working with our CWA and our cost team to see what additional supports we can put in place. But then looking at both our English language arts and math, we again have been consistent at green, kind of trending in a positive direction, which you'll see in another slide or two. Looking at the comparative data, we're very proud of our progress in both ELA and math, and wanting to make sure that the two metrics in both chronic absenteeism and suspension are moving in the right direction. Our suspension rate has kind of maintained right at 1.4%. I am surprised to see the chronic absenteeism digging in, finding exactly what

024is going on. It's not a widespread issue across campus. It's particular students who have a hard time coming to school. And so working with those families, and we have a really great relationship with our CWA this year, and we're already kind of seeing it trend in a different direction, which is great. Okay. So looking at our scoreboard data, it's positive movement in all areas. You'll notice we're slowly making gains each year in both ELA and math. Our average attendance rate improved by almost a percent. And what I'm most proud of is looking at our panoramic data over the last three years, where we just keep moving up and improving, with last year being at 78%. Continuing to look at our scoreboard data, our biggest jump, which is amazing, is that we had a 27% increase

025in the number of English learners that have progressed at least one LPAC level at 58%. We are very proud of that. We've more than doubled than we had just three years ago. Our major referrals have consistently gone down every year. Looking at the EZCBM data, it didn't become a required assessment until last year, so that's why there isn't comparative data. But right now, we just did our winter EZCBM, and we're at 93%. So we're trending up, which is awesome. And then similarly with our first graders, you'll kind of see, initially, we didn't start out so strong, but we're making great gains. And last, you know, going down 0.7%, it's pretty minimal. Again, just finished our winter EZCBM. Our fluency rate for first graders is at 90%. So we have a lot of data to be

026proud of. So looking at more specifically our English learners and students with disabilities, some of the positive areas are looking at our EZCBM data in both math and reading. Both students that are English learners and students with disabilities, we've had high percentages of students in the low risk range, 87%, 67%, 94%, and 87%. I was very concerned when I pulled the data and saw that only 10% of our English learners in both ELA and math were proficient. In digging, kind of looking at that data, knowing that CASP is only made up of our third through fifth grade students, that equates to 15 students with over half of them being in our mild to moderate SDC class. So that presents an additional challenge, right? But now we know exactly who they are. We have a lot

027of supports in place working with our mild to moderate teacher. Our intervention specialist this year is pulling students to work on Lexia, and I'll kind of go into that in just a few minutes. And so I'm very positive that we will make some gains in that area. Looking at our suspension rate, we've seen a downward trend with the number of students being suspended. I contribute that to, we have an amazing PBIS team at our school. Really every month we're digging into the data to see exactly what's going on in campus. Is it a specific age group of students, a specific time of day, and being able to offer those interventions so that we can curb and kind of solve the problem before we have to potentially lead to a suspension. Okay, so now to celebrate.

028Our Positive Behavioral Intervention and Supports, PBIS, it's our second year at GOLD. We are actively seeking platinum, the platinum level working with Mallory Rachel within our district office. Again, our PBIS team is a small but mighty group that's really looking at ways that we can continue to support our students. One of the programs kind of within that that we started my first year at Altamont was our Peacekeepers Program, which is our third through fifth grade students who are trained in conflict resolution. We've added proactive strategies this year, so our students, especially with our little ones, are going out and helping to teach them games, right? Because like kids don't know what the wall ball is these days for some reason, and so we're going out and showing them how to play wall ball and how

029to play four square so that when they're learning from peers seems to be, you know, they'll listen more to them than they will to us sometimes. Looking again at our panoramic data at 76% of our students reporting positive student teacher relationships, a huge gain from just a year ago. That number initially in the fall has stayed consistent at 78% and so we're hoping to either have it again stay the same or a boost by the spring. And then looking at the percentage of our emerging bilingual English learner students moving at least one LPAC level, 58% which is huge, an increase of 27%. And why? I would say we have always had a continued focus of looking at how to support our students. We have targeted groups. We have our intervention specialist besides working with our

030students during universal access time. She has pockets of time where she's helping to pull students to work on Lexia because sometimes it's the computer that can be the barrier, especially with our younger students. And so if she's just there to kind of help them make sure that they're following along, that seems to help. We've also administered the interim LPAC this year so that our students, we can get that data. Our intervention specialist went into the mild-moderate classroom, was able to work with our mild-moderate teacher in Paris to make sure that all the accommodations were in place while they're taking that interim assessment. Our CWA, we've been working with families to see, you know, sometimes it's just that they're having to walk kind of far and so if we had a little stroller or a skateboard

031or something that might help out. And then our LPAC meetings have never historically been attended and so we decided to mix it up a little bit instead of making it in the evening. I made it right when school started, offered some donuts and we had like 20 people show up so that was awesome. And so we plan to continue that just to try to engage our English learner families. Okay, so now looking at our priorities, our first focus is on math. So looking at our baseline data, 67 percent of our students on the CASP were proficient. It is, you know, small gains. We went from 64 to 66 to 67 and 63 percent of our students were performing at grade level or higher on our unit assessments. And so our goal this year is through

032consistent tier one instruction and then targeted tier two instruction in math. We're going to use a different metric, our easy CBM and see if 75 percent of our students are performing at proficiency or higher while also really trying to push for having a five percent increase in our CASP scores. So we are doing a lot of things at Altamont to ensure that we meet our goals. Working with our district office and we're adding some math PLC units this year. We initially started with our fourth grade team. Our fifth grade team is now going through that process and we have multiple grade levels doing math UA time. We just had our PLC half days earlier this week and because we are seeing such high percentages with our ELA scores, most of our grade levels now have

033shifted to math as the primary focus during our UA time. We are having a school-wide commitment to Dreambox this year. It's a program that our district has offered for years now but I would say at our site it hasn't been something we've totally been committed to. So this year we're committed to five lessons per week and we're already seeing gains in that area. Our MTSS TOSA is working with some of our paraeducators. We have some paraeducators that are within the TKK class and the students leave at 1 30 and so we're leveraging them and using them in the afternoon to do some additional math intervention with some of our students. And then within our staff meetings a lot of our professional development is math focused using SVMI, Joe Bowler, and other resources. And then our

034second priority is continuing strengthening our professional learning communities. Some baseline data is we have 70 percent of our students that are proficient in CASP and ELA, 67 percent in math, and 82 percent of our students at each grade level are proficient or higher using the easy CBM reading. And so what we want to do is again using consistent tier one instruction and then really targeting at tier two in both those interventions in English Language, Arts, and Math increasing the proficiency rate on our CASP by five percent in both areas. And so our teams meet every Wednesday along with the half days that our district provides. They're creating common formative assessments to ensure that we're tracking students progress throughout the cycle and making adjustments as we need. And from cycle to cycle making adjustments right in

035the fall we were primarily looking at ELA now we're really focusing on math based on our data. And then cross articulating so that means second grade is talking to third grade and fourth grade is talking to fifth grade so that we're seeing exactly what the students are in say for example in fourth grade where are they exactly so that we can best prepare them for fifth grade and then also talking to the middle school in preparation for most of our students going over to Christiansen. So I think that is my presentation. Thank you for listening. Yeah thank you. Board members who have comments? Dina go ahead. Yeah great job presentation. I just applaud you for all the positive like scores you've gotten on the scoreboard. I just had one quick question. What do you think

036improved your panorama scores? Do you think that had to do something with engagement with the parents for your English second learners community? I really think it's a partnership with all of our different community groups. We have a very active PTA at our school and we have parents that are on most of our committees obviously on our school site council but also on our PBIS committee and on our safety committee. But in terms of the student teacher relationship I think it's also you know teachers are greeting students at the door every day. Teachers are checking in when they notice a student is a little off today and it's not just our teachers. Our yard duties know our students by name. Our paras are moving within classrooms and so I think it it says student teacher relationship

037but it really is kind of that staff to student relationship as well. I just want to make one point too. Being on Mrs. Tapia's campus when you walk through the campus with her the students just flock to her. So that culture begins with her and I just would like to applaud her for establishing that culture at that site. Thank you. You're welcome. Yes definitely. I actually have been to your school I think last year or the year before for your fun run and they do an excellent job over there. So I'll be back to visit soon. Awesome thank you. It's great to meet you. Another question something that you reported on that jumped out of me is the number of mild mod students at your campus. What percentage of your SPED students fall into that

038category? So we have a variety of special education on our campus. We have three mild to moderate SDC programs. We have our and so that's a total of 45 students just within that program and then we have our resource learning center model which has about 20 students and then we also have the therapeutic neurodiverse program and between levels one and two we have about 25 students. So 45 25 and 20 almost 100 or it's a Yeah and I would just add that they have specific program that some of our other sites don't have. So our therapeutic neurodiversion program is specific in our district and it's placed at that school site. So students from their other home schools are going to Altamont Creek right now in that program. So that's what makes their numbers a little

039bit different than some of our other school sites. Yeah very rewarding but also pretty challenging I'm guessing some of that. It's never dull but we love it. That's great. So yeah that totally answers my question. Thank you. Yep I just wanted to appreciate your digging into the numbers regarding English language learners and SPED duplication. I think that's important to have a realistic understanding of the situation and appreciate you communicating that with us. I was hoping you could tell us when and how did did you administer the interim LPAC assessment? What did that look like? How was it received by teachers and students? Yeah so it was our first time sort of trying it this year and we focused first on our third through fifth grade students. Our intervention specialist happened to previous be an LPAC

040administrator and so she worked with Elizabeth Freitas at the district to become trained in the interim LPAC and the way we kind of laid it out is over a week time because we didn't I think sometimes students just want to click and be done right and so we wanted to give them an opportunity to really focus on each area and so over the course of one week they just did one section per day and we started with our students within general education first and she pulled them in the afternoon when she had that pocket of time where she's not seeing any of our UA students and just did one section at a time so she was able just to go grab them and bring them to her little room that she works at and then

041before and that was the last week of January so it wasn't too long ago and then before that I met with our EL or excuse me our mild mod teacher who does a fourth and fifth grade and our intervention specialist just to kind of proactively determine what the best setting would look like for our students within the mild mod program and so we decided to have them stay in the classroom and because we have the teacher we have two pairs in the room and then our intervention specialist would be in the room and we could strategically ensure that all of their testing accommodations are being met within using that LPAC interim as kind of almost like a a practice for the LPAC and for the CASP coming up. Is there when do you when and

042do you see the results of the interest interim assessments? I'm assuming this is both feedback for the students to kind of understand what they're doing but also you the both the administrator and the faculty all some yes. So our the entire student body that was taking the LPAC interim just finished earlier this week so literally two days ago I was printing them all and then planned to meet with ILT and also share those with the individual teachers of those students to see what are some trends what are what was positive and where some areas that we can focus before they both take the summit of LPAC and then the CASP later this spring. Awesome and then just two comments I appreciate the ELAC divergent thinking about when and where and how to connect with parents

043I think that's fantastic and then lastly Joe Bowler is a state treasure. Yeah for real. Thank you very much for your your presentation you've done a consistently good job there I mean since I'm here I remember your interview and coming in and the progress some of these things are probably going to be it sounds like maybe with some of those persistent attendance issues things like that I just want to make sure that you as well as our other principals and folks here don't feel like you're ever beating your head against the wall so if you need additional resources and feel free to to ask us sometimes we may not know that. No I appreciate that I think we especially in that area are well supported I really like having our CWA and we meet every

044single week she's on our campus every Tuesday and that's really allowed us to kind of dig deeper and she can kind of help with some of that communication with parents that was a little harder when we didn't all have CWA so I really or it was structured a little different where I feel like I'm offered more support now and I really think that will help with our numbers when we go into next year. Appreciate it nice job thank you thank you. I think one of the things too that I just want to add as we start to see as we're getting further into these presentations we're starting to see some themes and one of the great things that's going to come out of our strategic planning process in March is having everyone in the room

045at the same time where then we get to collect all of those themes on paper so then then I think that's a perfect example Trustee Bueno around then we'll be able to have those conversations as a team to ask principals as a whole what is it that you need from us in order to make these goals achievable over the next five years and attendance will be one of those that's on our list of conversation topics so I just wanted to provide kind of that on the back end of that piece too. Thank you. Thank you Ms. Tapia. Thank you. First of all thank you and I just feel like there's such a good first of all there's just a good feeling in your community but also just to see that the upward trajectory in almost

046all of your areas I think is really important. What I can tell is that you are really looking at the data and trying to figure out what to do with it which I think is really important and I feel like we're seeing that more and more as a trend throughout the district but I just really appreciate the effort that you've put into looking at and analyzing your data and for your team as well to be coming along with that. For sure your English learners is a bright spot I feel like I think it's so great that you're figuring out the interim LPAC your ELAC meeting whatever it is that you can do to support those students I feel like there has been such a tremendous jump in that school and it's not something that we

047typically see so I feel like it's just wonderful to have to see that you being able to figure out how to best serve the needs of those students and then I just had one question about the math UA time and this is probably a question for any school you did the UA timer and originally with ELA and now you switched it over to math is that correct you can't do both ELA for both math and you can because our individual teachers right can pull different groups and so most of our our intervention specialist I would say is stronger in ELA and so I would say there's a pocket of four or five kids right that are still going to see her but then the teachers groups are primarily shifting okay all right that answers my

048question all right thank you so much for your presentation wonderful job okay yay yeah cheers okay now we're gonna invite principal Jennifer Burkholder up she is the principal at crochet elementary school which are right now I'm afraid to say it is correct oh so close yeah that's all right we're we're neighbors they're all cats right we're all cats okay I'm in the right general area okay good morning president board president Pruso members of the board superintendent Gibson and cabinet I'm Jen Burkholder I am the very proud principal of crochet elementary I've had the honor of meeting most of you some of you at my most stressful day this school year which was the crochet spelling bee where I had to be the pronouncer so it's nice to see you all again I'm pleased to be

049here this morning to discuss the celebrations and action plans of our wonderful school you got it I I have been told I feel like I'm shouting but I've been told that I have a very soft voice so crochet has a diverse population and we pride ourselves on our inclusion of students with disabilities which makes up nearly 27 percent of our student body and that is because we are the only school in the district that has a program dedicated to our preschool students with disabilities and at the end of the school year we have the great honor of educating up to 92 preschoolers so this slide obviously is the one that is available to the public and you know green is growth blue shows lots of growth crochet has done great work around suspension data as

050well as our achievements in math chronic absenteeism has had a great trend over the last few years we're actually down from 30.5 percent but still an area of growth for us as a school on this slide when when we're comparing crochet to other schools with similar ethnic and socio economic status crochet is doing as good as or better than comparative schools in our area on this slide crochet's made gains in all areas our ela scores have risen three percent since last year and nine percent since the 21-22 school year our math proficiency is also up nine percent over two years and our attendance continues to rise and our students are feeling more connected to their teachers we did have an eight percent decline and our english learners progressing at least one lpac level that equates

051to two students we have a relatively small number of el students given our population we're certainly concerned with this number however given our numbers we know each student by name and need and we feel like we can wrap around this and i'll talk more about our el students interaction plans in a few slides i do want to point out that crochet has had good growth with students who have received major office referrals which is down 3.5 percent and our fourth and fourth fourth and first graders have made gains on the easy cvm with fourth grade gaining two percent and our first graders have made almost a 30 increase in those who demonstrated low risk since the 21-22 school year something we're very very proud of on this slide i want to start by highlighting the

052positives as it relates to our english learners and our students with disabilities both student groups showed zero percent for receiving two or more major office referrals and both students are doing really well on the easy cvm and fourth grade with our english learners showing a hundred percent at low risk and 73 percent of our students with disabilities showing low risk in math for fourth grade we also have some very obvious areas of growth with only 17 and 18 percent 18 percent of our students in these populations showing proficiency and ela and we certainly have continued need for growth in math our suspension rate at crochet has decreased from nine total suspensions in the 22-23 school year down to three last year and so far this year we have had one suspension and we attribute this

053to all the work around pbis we meet monthly as a group we talk about our data we dig into what those referrals are for we try to find trends and then we also present this data to our staff this is a fun slide and it was hard to narrow down to three things because there are a lot of fun things happening at crochet we do have a lot of work that we've been doing around pbis or positive behavioral interventions and supports my background is a behavior analyst so this is certainly an area of passion for me around behavior and mental health crochet has received a gold award for pbis we anticipate another gold award and we're actually flirting with going for platinum but we'll probably push that off for another year we've also welcomed our

054wellness center at school which has been an immense support as a tier two intervention at crochet our counselor as of a couple of weeks ago has had 23 group counseling sessions which were specifically targeted out of areas of need from our cost referrals we've had 48 one-to-one counseling sessions 103 check-ins with students who either self-referred were referred by teachers or their parents she's helped out with six risk assessments we've had several restorative meetings with peers as well as she's been into the classrooms presenting to students and having students tour the wellness center program so we're looking at some amazing growth with our wellness center as our counselor gets to know our student population and our needs i also have to highlight our fifth grade math team because they made a 20 gain last year in

055our math scores and that was because of their shift in our plc focus to math it's impressive i mean we still have a lot to go but even this year we've already seen a 12 gain on our scores compared to last year and our teachers are really really really excited about this so with the focus with our tosa's and mr connor we're really digging into this we're bringing our fourth grade students and upcoming third or fourth grade teachers and our third grade teachers will be joining the separate so we're really really really excited about this i don't think it's a surprise given our data but my first priority is getting our english learners casp scores and math and ele up there's a number of ways that i want to attack this starting with getting more

056teachers on campus trained in guided language acquisition and design or be glad that's a research-based program that gives teachers strategies on how to support our english language learners which also in turn helps support our students with disabilities and it focuses on making content accessible interactive and engaging and so we have a number of staff that are super excited to be doing this and to implement these changes we're also working on our professional learning communities and we meet regularly to dig into that data and see where students are at we're shifting constantly our groups on where their need is and where it's a monthly shift where teachers are really looking at the data and student needs so super excited about that also our fifth grade and fourth grade focusing on math during our universal access time

057and then just making sure that we're consistently providing the math blocks that are recommended at the school um for our second priority is focused around students with disabilities and my priority here comes from obviously our data around this population we have a large number of students that we have the privilege to serve at croci and with my background as a special education teacher and behavior analyst this really speaks to my passion currently only 18 percent of our students with disabilities are proficient in ela and only 34 percent in math and my goal is to get that number up significantly i'm super excited about the work that we've been doing so far this year we've been working with our tosa's we've dug into every single iep on campus every single goal and we've been trying to

058ensure that the curriculum that our resource teachers are providing is not only research-based but addresses all areas of need in addition to that we're what we're realizing is that a lot of our tier three students we're getting less intervention than our tier two students and so we're making sure that that is flip-flopped and that our students with ieps have more support across all areas i've also been working with our special education team to make sure that oh i am on the right side okay good that our special education teachers are also engaging in those plcs and digging into the data and analyzing data for students with disabilities just like our general education teachers are because that's hugely important for them and i've started creating communication systems between our special education teachers especially our resource teachers

059and our general education teachers and parents so they know exactly what their students are working on every day when they go to the resource room so i look forward to seeing the results of all of this work any questions thank you trustee why don't you have any comments trustee capuanis i'll just say something really quick i think you're doing a great job as well your school site um i did enjoy the spelling bee and um i know that your school has the special needs community and the preschool my sister actually used to teach there um but i really liked how you said you're going to start implementing the plcs for the students with learning disabilities supporting the teachers i think that will really help a lot um i had a quick question about um your

060wellness um would you say that the use of having your wellness center has any correlation to like the decreasing like suspension rate um i yes behavior um it's that's been primarily focused around mental health although they have she has helped out with um some of the conflict resolution so i would say absolutely yes we've been working on some of those restorative meetings um and we're hoping to increase what she's doing there around that area okay great thank you you're welcome thanks for your work and your presentation i appreciate the focus on prioritizing your emerging bilingual learners um and students with special needs uh i the sooner you can get more of your teachers be glad trained the better i think the be glad strategies are fantastic for emerging bilingual students as well as students with

061special needs but they're also just good for everybody and i can't think of teaching differently i can't think about instruction the way i did before i was be glad trained so i think that's fantastic um and then along the lines with the um the measures for prioritizing your emerging bilingual students i think similar to some other sites having your teachers look at the lpac assessment and try to understand the components of it both the the computer literacy components to it and then also just like the content and language of it is something that i think would be really beneficial both for the students taking the assessment and then also the the teachers just to know how they can layer the the language they're using the class um to help them with that assessment i absolutely

062agree yeah we've talked about it as a site on doing the interim assessments as well at crochet and it was a pleasure listening to miss tapia talk i've been furiously writing notes and have a million ideas already so including shifting our our meeting times to better accommodate parents so thank you okay all right uh i just just to finish off i you definitely are seeing a trend happening over in springtown there's some really good things happening at both of our elementary schools over there and um just looking at the numbers as well and what an amazing bright spot for you guys with your fifth grade math that's something that's going to be really important i know it seems silly fifth grade math but if you can do that in fifth grade then by the time

063you get to high school you'll be able to pass algebra so it's really important and i appreciate that the teachers are excited about it and are figuring out how to help the fourth and third grade teachers along because that is really what we are looking for at the district level so i think that's fantastic and i also appreciate your background in special ed and what you're doing for your special ed teachers and community and i think that's going to be we're going to probably see some really good data on that in the coming years so appreciate appreciate you coming down thank you to both of you thank you okay all right now we're going to move on to our 3.2 which is our budget discussion and we will turn the time over to dr gibson

064and kayla wasley and oh thank you i was going to ask for this and that looks like yes got it it's coming around so like previous um renditions of this this is our fourth round um we don't have a lot of additions at this point in time we do have just some minor changes on here that we're going to walk through from the last copy to this copy and then we can have a larger conversation about um some position control things and other items that i think are really pertinent so the first thing is online so um things that are green and we're going to walk through the green and the gray so the greens are things that are new that were not on here last time we discussed them possibly but they've actually been

065fully added onto the sheet and then the gray are things that were updated so if you look on line one um the second box over that did say originally the reorganization that now has the accounting specialist position actually noted on line six um we did have a brief conversation about evaluating the bond department that is not a general fund but because we want everything to be on here that could or will show up on the resolution next week we wanted to add that on here we had discussed scaling back the bond department further than this but after conversations and really digging in we may also be receiving some other funding from the state for bond projects in the near future we just don't want to get ourselves so thin that you know we're out of

066compliance and and those functions we need that department to continue to run we do have quite a bit of money still left in there about i'm going to say 16 million is what we're anticipating uh 16 million in new funds coming in this year okay great and possibly more yep okay so um so that's just the the one position instead of three i think that we had initially discussed among ourselves we hadn't discussed that publicly but it's just the one position the it position there's two grade boxes there because we originally in the change column the fourth column over we originally had elimination of 2.0 fte we've updated that to one fte and then we added that position title of the network technician that is line seven line 22 is new on here that position

067is a position position that's been vacant since the fall and we have not backfilled it but again for transparency purposes we wanted it to be on this sheet because we want this sheet to ultimately match our resolution correct miss robbins okay um and so we added that on here it was not previously on here but we wanted to make sure that this is going to match so there's no surprises come next week but that is currently an unfilled position and then line 28 the maintenance worker two position um i'm going to let miss wasley explain this yes um this was a position that was added in the fall of 2022 when we received some one-time funding we received the arts music and instructional materials discretionary block grant which really could be spent for any purpose

068meeting the district's needs so this maintenance to worker position was added at that time at the end of this year we'll be exhausting those funds and so we are reducing a maintenance to worker and shifting around some of the maintenance to worker duties so those are the only changes you'll notice at the bottom when you look at the bottom line of the five million nine hundred ninety three thousand three hundred sixty one dollars and fifty cents that number has shifted and that is because of the gray box online item number seven where our original estimation was an elimination of two positions and now it's an elimination of one but we do feel comfortable with this draft we feel like um even though there's not a six at the beginning it's only seven thousand dollars short

069so we feel like we we we hit the target so we're very comfortable with this number um so let's start there and then i can go into the rest of the discussion that i know we'd like to have just around process and some of those other functions if there's any questions about any changes or updates to this sheet the line 16 curriculum and instruction elementary tosa's can you remind me you know just hearing about the hard work that the tosa's were doing and i know we're not in the same place that we were financially but is this is this reference to those tosa's or is it more broad than that i'm going to pass this over to miss mrs peshet to answer because she'll be able to provide all that information so it is in

070reference to those tosa's we have currently this year we have four what's called we call them mtss tosa's um one is funded out of lcff supplemental and three are funded out of general funds and so this is a reduction in two of those tosa's um so yes some of those those job duties will be shifted to those two and the are the tosa's the the two positions that remain their district wide or are they linked with specific sites district wide okay elementary district wide what one thing i'm having a hard time following and i get that with these these um documents are dynamic but is there a way that we could see these documents to me they should be time stamped and dated and who altered them because like we got this one last night

071at five o'clock and then just now this one was just passed out to us but they're both round four records they got the same title but their revision dates and who revised them is not and then any changes so that we can actually do comparisons so we can keep a running total so that's all noted in the board packet online whenever we do an update we note it in on the cover page of when we updated it the color coding is what we so if you were to print from the last board meeting to this board meeting and put them side by side anything now that i mean yes we can absolutely time and date stamp them however this is our last and final but all of that has been in each board packet with

072the numbers the the document that was from last night versus this morning is really just color coding change and updates um it had nothing to do with actual things that were on the sheet i understand and i'm looking at the thing on the little ipad here and it says last modified two thirteen at 0751 by kayla wasley but it doesn't show the previous version it just says when it was last touched so there's no way to go back and say well what did the document look like at five o'clock and i get it because you know we meet in closed session and we're able to actually follow it even though it's a little difficult but my concern is that when the public looks at the agenda and then it changes and it's a different document

073and they don't know what it is it's the perception that the transparency may not be there so it's just to me if someone's printing the doc that it has a date on the bottom like i can't find like last night's doc i don't see it on there i see no we wouldn't leave both because then i think that would cause more confusion um i just want to look on the updates here um so it explains an update that a revised spreadsheet spreadsheet was updated to this item to highlight new lines in green and highlight changes in the previous spreadsheet in gray so it explains that on there so i mean going going forward yes i yes i i i'm not quite sure exactly what answer you want for me at this no no i just

074so but the answer is yes of course yeah i just i would just like to see like whenever you do financials when you do documents like this and people are training them and you have version one now we're at version four that this is actually not version four it's version four b or c because it's been revised okay that's all i mean i just want to be able to track it so when we keep a running total that we can do comparison so when we get a question and i had a couple of questions last night people say hey the documents aren't up okay here's the you know do you guys have something that's different than what we are seeing i don't believe so i think they're all the same sure and then this morning

075the document changes but it has the same title it would be nice to be able to say so we'll add the old document back up and we'll label them a and b okay sure i have a broader question that maybe is for later but i'll ask it now i've had several community members ask about um cuts or reductions are they equitable across bargaining units and to what extent is bargaining units part of that and the way i have a response to that but i was just hoping you could provide how does that fit in or where or how does that kind of fit into reductions so um it's not going to be equitable because some bargaining units are much larger than others so as an example lea um you know they are much larger than

076any other bargaining unit seiu is our smallest bargaining unit so i think proportionately it's you know we could look at it that way um but it's really around what areas do we have extra staff sitting in versus where we don't um of course we want to try and keep it where it's across the board across bargaining units but as you can see as an example on these charts you know seiu has not been on here they only have a total of about 80 staff members approximately 80 staff members versus some of our other bargaining units that have 200 to 700 yeah i just that's a great question yeah i appreciate that because i think some what lay persons from the public look at that i'm like why don't you just do 20 from each bargaining

077unit and that just doesn't work realistically with the needs of the district correct i mean if we did certain numbers across the board then let's say if we did 20 percent of seiu that's going to be a much higher number um you know with the math then let's say if we did 20 percent of lea it's just not proportionate when you when you look at it that way because each person is weighted heavier well i guess you could look at that in two ways but i don't know that it would be proportionate percentages by definition right are proportionate 20 is 20 so 20 of 80 would be equivalent to 20 of 700 the number might be different but the impact could be different based on what they actually do correct that's but when we're trying

078to stay away from classrooms teachers csea those type of things but it all ties in right we need the janitor to clean the to clean it i just want one group to feel as though they're not as important no they're all equally important it's just a matter of where cuts had been made in prior times where positions hadn't been filled out with attrition over time prior to this current school year and so forth i think one of the things that i think that the simple answer is that we many of us have said is we're trying to keep keep the cuts away from students but i think that there's a realistic pragmatism to that it's not like we're cutting all custodians because those are they're not in front of students that there's there's a level

079at which we don't go i don't know so i just want to try to communicate that that you know the goal is to keep it away from students but a pragmatic keep it away from students correct so i think the other part of this conversation and i'm going to pass it over to miss robbins to explain just some of our position control updates and some of the things that although we have all of these reductions on here just how it actually affects people versus a number in a computer i think that's really the difference thank you so as our superintendent mentioned um we're really looking at streamlining and making sure our processes are really more formalized in the past we've been able to make some staffing adjustments to right-size classes through attrition and that means

080through resignations or retirement that is what our hope is with this excuse me our notices need to be out by march 15th however as we look through these lists we do have a considerable number of retirements and resignations in certain of the bargaining units that will allow us to absorb some of these reductions through attrition um really this list will be more formalized come to you next tuesday for resolutions because we are trying to take positions that are in our system the position control and we are trying to formalize that in exiting those positions to really be transparent and open to the community as to where those reductions have occurred and so this will be a resolution that we will see that will not excuse me necessarily equate to the number of notices that go

081out and again those notices are very preliminary in nature because a lot can shift between march 15th which is an imposed deadline that we need to meet and may when we come back together for more formalizing any notices that may have to go out to see if those are notices that need to stand as far as having to reduce staff through the more formalized layoff process as opposed to right sizing through attrition with resignations and retirements i do want to give an example of that because it it is a broad statement so if we look up there and we look specifically at our seven positions for general education our elementary positions trying to right size those classes based on enrollment so those seven positions that are listed up there for general education teachers we have

082significantly more than seven teachers that have chosen to retire and move on to the retirement life so those seven positions will not need to be noticed because we have those retirees and so therefore we can right size through attrition like we've done in the past but those positions will still remain on the resolution on Tuesday night to formalize our official reduction taking those positions out of our position control system so that we can run reports and invest budget as we move forward a question relative to the terminology as it relates to position control are we eliminating the positions completely or are we freezing the positions and keeping them authorized so in other words for purpose of discussion are we our number floats based on enrollment with declining enrollment one would naturally once you get your

083ratios right your number would stay but relative to our conversation as it relates to position control moving forward the board would see position control so if the district chose we want to increase our fte in a specific thing from x to x plus four we would see that and it would have to be in relation to something say student growth or enrollment growth so in this case we would be um formalizing the removal of those positions from our system so that if and when needed so i'm thinking specifically earlier this year when the human resources department restructure came back that was the board voting on adding a position into the system so really looking at the formalization of taking those positions out of the system and then how do we bring them back to the

084system so that you as a board are aware of department structures and overall organizational structures we do have a couple of positions that we have special agreements with our unions that we have frozen those positions and so there are some that are not listed that are on freeze based on what you just said if there's some structural shifts that need to occur then we can do that with those positions that are frozen they would not be on this list they're not going to be pulled from our system but with the frozen position it would still realize the savings if a position is authorized and funded then it would it should reflect on your savings if it's frozen and that that position is built in or we we are aware our assistant super business services aware

085of those positions that are frozen that no longer have staff in them and so those allocations have not been included in our overall budget so they are cost savings that are already assumed in this year's budget as well as the out year's budgets i guess what i'm saying is if they're not illustrated here on the bottom line if if the number is included in your overall budget your and your proposed or projected budget and frozen and unfilled you're realizing the savings until such time is there unfrozen and filled so it should show as a savings here i i think i think there's a couple issues so i'm just gonna i'm just gonna call it out number one we don't have a good handle on position control we've talked about this many times so the fact

086that i'm having to say it again is frustrating because if we can't we have to clean up position control in order to be able to know what our bottom line is our unions have asked for the position control as they should and we can't provide that and then there's no blame of anyone sitting up here at this moment so i'm going to acknowledge that i'm going to push back i'm going to acknowledge it because it's frustrating that's it that's it yeah okay can i ask uh just in your professional estimation of the 40 almost 40 fte's listed how many of those are will be connected to to an actual person you think so i don't want to throw a number out because i don't want to cause panic or mislead and there's a lot of

087work that's going to happen between march 15th and may 15th um we are bound by the timeline so a lot i'm talking about march 15th i'm talking about the actuals i'm talking about like i think you know looking at the number of retirements and um and resignations and just and uh positions that are actually not even filled right now i think we're looking at you know yeah do you have a number i will have a better answer for you on tuesday's meeting so you can ask again um because there's a lot of work that we're going to be doing between now and tuesday night i do feel that it will be very minimal compared to this what happens with our bargaining agreements is specifically for like for example csa if a position is eliminated then

088it creates bumping across different classifications into formal roles and so then there will be potentially more notices because of the bumping so people will need to know that they're going to have bumping rights and so for certain bargaining units it becomes a tiered effect which will create some more notices than maybe what you see up there for example lea they most of them have been in one position and so our teachers on special exam assignment for example those have temporary teachers behind them filling so those teachers will be able to go into back into the classroom where they were prior so in that bargaining unit it would not necessitate as many notices so i don't want to throw something out to give false hope ask again on tuesday and i'll have a more concrete understanding

089but i do want to emphasize that there will be far fewer notices for certain bargaining units because we do have positions that we anticipate being open we also have positions right now that are we say we're in a hiring frost so any position that comes open we are opening that for our internal applicants hoping that if they are you know a position up here or someone who is interested in moving that all of those pieces of the puzzle when we put them back together will make it a more solid stable puzzle and that some people may opt to move in positions that actually reduce the number of notices that we might have to do as precautionary notices thank you i just wanted to say like i know this is difficult obviously to to be in

090this situation i also know that we're not alone that everyone in probably most districts in this state are dealing with this for sure our neighbors are dealing with very similar budget issues that we are as i just want to commend all the people who have been working on this including the people sitting up here at this dais and also for the people sitting in the audience who are bargaining units and they have been working together on this and i really appreciate that the fact that we are sitting here in this room and it's fairly empty and that we haven't had a lot of pushback is to me a tribute to the people who are working really hard to make sure that not only that there's communication to our employees the people that this affects the

091most but that that i've been on the board for seven years now almost seven years and i have never experienced a more involved or transparent process with the budget now we haven't had as many budget difficulties in the past as we are experiencing now again i just want to point out like this is a statewide issue but i do want to commend the superintendent and her team and also knowing that we have two new people who over this coming in and having to ask as many questions as we all are asking and then find the answers to those questions so i just want to say that i really appreciate that this process the transparency and all of these meetings that we've had for in in front of the community and yeah i just appreciate it

092i know it's not an easy thing it's it has been difficult i just want to say i know we've talked about it a few times and i i just want to maybe clarify point out that you know we're really trying to get through this for the march 15th deadline because we do have to by law we have to let people know whether or not they may or may not have a job next year but in the time between march and may there's possibility that as you've been saying that things may shuffle and through attrition through other means maybe the state is going to magically come with i not really counting on that but um that there may be an opportunity for for some of these to change but right now we're on a deadline and

093that i appreciate that we have to get through that deadline and that's important that we do that and then after that we'll have a little bit of breathing room room is that correct that is correct and we want to be very very thoughtful and so while the notice is that we will have to go out the few that do those are precautionary and there is going to be a lot of thought and creativity we we are committed to keeping as many of our staff members as possible we value our employees and we'll be working very diligently while we are breathing um but being very intentional about the decisions that are made and the information that is presented to us as you said it's ever-changing state and federal funding um possibilities but really engaging in the

094process of how do we minimize the disruption to our workforce to make sure that we maintain the great programs and opportunities we do in livermore thank you yeah dina um i just wanted to say that even though um trustee vanden heuvel and i are new to this um i appreciate that we've been working on it you know in advance to the deadline in march and so um as we keep repeating that it's a draft it's a draft we can go through and we still have a paper form to see the changes that have been made so um i just want to say along with um president pruso um the work that's gone into it it's not an easy thing by any means um i think it's very difficult but um yeah i just appreciate that

095there that we're working on this in advance not saving it till the last minute because it's it's a hard thing to do thank you okay thanks i've got a i'm just thinking about unintended consequences that in this process of of um highlighting some of the cuts that we have to make or some of the change changes to what's available who we can hire that we lose somehow really um high quality people because but you know you were talking about this affects everybody in the state so maybe there's not as much losing to other districts and whatever but i just want to make sure that you know livimore stays is really attractive place to work and where we value teachers and we don't just uh flippantly um use them to fill our budget shortfalls um anyways

096does anybody have any idea how that works like do people decide to retire much quicker or decide to move over or resign and then do something else or how does that work can i jump in real quick because i think for me that the big uh the big at least part of the unintended consequences which is the unfortunate reality that we're in is that um we will likely have to administer some pink slips right to to humans and if that happens that's not a neutral thing that's the district saying to you we may not need you and that hurts for some people to get that and back in i don't know what was it 2007-8 something like that teachers were constantly getting them and one of my colleagues was like i'm going to move to

097france and teach english for a couple years so because you know if if if the district can't commit to me and we have a financial responsibility we have to you know so it's it's not a neutral thing but at least in my mind that's part of it is thinking when we send those out we need to make sure we need to recognize that this is this has to happen from a perspective you know from a financial perspective but that it's also not a neutral action that whoever receives those is getting a signal from us we can't you know we can't make promises about so i think in my mind that's that's part of this piece but again us as a body we have a fiscal responsibility to to make sure that you know our district

098can be solvent and so i think that's that's the one of the at least one of the unintended consequences and one of my comments is exactly to that uh trustee vanden heuvel was that when i first came on this board it was a practice of this march 15th it was just part of it but to your point um trustee joan it's not just a neutral thing i believe having been in government for you know four decades that most people that come into government one of the components of that is the stability that that employment offers if it becomes unstable they tend to look elsewhere either to a stable form or to something else a higher paying job and one of the things that's always impressed me in education coming on to this board and i

099didn't come from education but is the level of education and expertise that the people the 1500 people have here they have options we talk about a teacher shortage statewide in california and i don't think that having a qualified budget um is a statewide issue i think it's an isolated issue there are others who share that but we in that situation have that and if someone else is more stable than us just like if your pay and benefit package is lower people will look elsewhere and that practice when i've since i've been on the board of the march 15th was ceased because there was a lot of work that went in behind the scenes to see well we're hiring 55 to 75 people a year and we're issuing pink slips to 55 to 75 people it's

100not the same people but as um assistant sup robbins mentioned there's a lot of backing up and things like that that have to happen so i think it's one of the worst things we can do outside of our primary mission of you know focusing on kids but it's one of the worst things that a district can do is issue march 15th it's part of your fiduciary responsibility but i would like to see us not normalize that process to make this just a one-off that we have to because of a circumstance and we get past this that we do the work in advance so that we never have to do this again it's horrible your best and brightest people that don't have their two years in the people you put all your work and recruitment in

101and the net that hr cast to go out to the colleges and grab all these kids up and bring them in and say teachings for you and these and they get in and they're doing a co-op and they're trying to find housing and all of that you get that pink slip and what do you do i mean you have to pay your bills i wouldn't stay you know personally i mean as someone who's a breadwinner i how do you do that it's very difficult so i think this is a it's a terrible thing to do but i do understand the fiduciary responsibility we have in that deadline but i do not think that that overrules or outweighs the practice of being just abolished i know we have to do it but i i absolutely can't

102stand it i can't stand what it does to an organization i literally was thinking of like like when that march 51 and going forward in the that the two months to hold a moment of silence for every person that we end up having to you know pink slip it's just it's just terrible terrible this is a preliminary budget and it's fairly easy to look through and go this you know this really solves the problem but i can see through that and see some of the humans that are attached to that and it stinks right a lot yep and that's why i don't want to see us normalize it or accept it as though well we value our teachers but we value our c you know ea's it's we value them and i think we have

103to work very diligently i do appreciate all the work that's gone in on this and i also acknowledge the fact that the majority of the folks that are dealing with this are relatively new to the district and so they're fixing ratios and doing a lot of fixes behind the scene having to become familiar and i would and i would also ask the question on this position control we're going to do strategic planning but as we do move forward on the strategic planning do we have the assurance that we will have position control you know clarified because it's difficult if not impossible to do strategic planning without position control no um well i mean yes we will but strategic planning has no impact on position control strategic planning is about the larger ticket items of what

104our five-year focus will be not on position control but i mean we're working on position control right now every day okay so it's just well it maybe that's a perspective um i believe that when we're setting goals and we're looking at things in terms of strategic planning um position control allows an oversight board to see where the resources are allocated it lets you understand what's frozen it lets you understand what's eliminated and as a board who sets priorities it allows us to direct those resources into the positions that will allow us to attain the strategies and so i see it as essential i mean i it's just a matter of perspective my perspective uh it goes towards that that you need to have clear position controls otherwise you're looking over here and this is happening

105over here how do we how do we prioritize how do we put more resources in this area resources 85 percent of our budget is people if if we can't account for the people it's difficult to allocate resources that's how i see it so i would like to see clear position control prior to engaging in strategic planning and as we've already discussed privately we are planning to bring that back at the next meeting correct thanks anything else okay all right so i believe that's it i don't have any we're going to adjourn our next regular scheduled board meeting is going to be held on tuesday february 18th here at the district office and open session will begin at 7 p.m so this meeting is adjourned at 11 09 a.m

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.