001It's okay. Sorry, I was going to say something but then you turn around. Good evening everyone. This is the February 4th board meeting of the Board of Education, the Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District. Our boardroom is open with an in-person format. However, we will continue to broadcast our meetings over Zoom to provide the opportunity for our community members to observe in real time. The Board of Education of LVJUSD is now reconvening to open session and it is 7.07 p.m. Please be advised that our board meetings are televised on local channel 28 on Wednesday and Saturday evenings and on Monday, Friday, and Saturday mornings. All actions approved in closed session must be reported out so I'm going to ask Trustee Druhan if he could report and then after that Trustee Vanden Heuvel. Yes, by a
002vote of five to zero the board took action in closed session to approve the confidential expulsion pursuance to education code 48918. And by a vote of four yeas, zero nays, and one abstention the board voted in closed session to approve the settlement agreement for OAH case number 2024110873 and the vote readout is as follows. The yeas were President Prusso, Trustee Bueno, Trustee Kaplanis, Trustee Vanden Heuvel, and the abstention was Trustee Druhan. Thank you. I believe that covers all of our closed session items. We're now going to move on to our Pledge of Allegiance and we're going to invite some students from Sunset Elementary to please come up and give us our pledge. All right, if you are a Sunset Safety Scout come up front and I will start us off on the Pledge of Allegiance.
003Our flag is up front and you may chime in. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. And to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Oh wait, before you start, before you start Ms. Fletcher, just one really quick thing. I don't believe we have any changes to the agenda but I'm going to just check and make sure. We do not, you're correct. Okay, now we will turn the time over to Mr. Tom Fletcher who is our proud Principal of Sunset Elementary and he has some recognitions for us. Good evening Board President, Pruso, members of the Board, Superintendent Gibson, members of our cabinet and members of our amazing supportive community. I am Tom Fletcher, the Principal of Sunset Elementary. I quickly
004realized that no matter how closely I monitored the playground, the moment I turned around someone would be going down the slide backwards. It was inevitable. It became clear that the only real way to transform school culture was from within the student body itself. The most powerful shift in culture I ever saw happen when I was at the middle school and enough students joined the kindness club that it created an environment where unkind behavior wasn't corrected by adults but by peers. Hearing students tell each other we don't do that here was a defining moment in my career and that is how true change happens. So I shared this middle school story with our PBIS team at Sunset and Allison Osser, one of our fifth grade teachers who couldn't make it tonight, shared this idea of the
005safety squad. Tonight I have the honor and privilege to introduce our Sunset safety squad. These students have taken on a true leadership role within our school demonstrating responsibility, integrity, and a commitment to making Sunset a more positive place for all. As safety scouts, our fourth and fifth graders voluntarily step up during primary recess to reinforce our PBIS expectations. They actively model kindness, respect, and safe play while recognizing and rewarding our younger students who do the same. Through their efforts they are not just keeping recess safe but also building a strong foundation of community and positive behavior for our youngest learners. What I appreciate most about our safety scouts is their dedication to service and their willingness to support others. They are not just handing out stickers as all of you got tonight, they are building
006confidence, they're encouraging inclusion, they're reinforcing the values we hold dear at Sunset. Their leadership has had a ripple effect throughout the campus, creating a culture where students celebrate one another's successes. These students have embraced the idea that leadership is not about authority but it's about inspiring others to do the right thing even when no one is watching. So it is my honor to recognize these remarkable students tonight and I want to personally thank each of them for their hard work, their commitment, and their positive influence to our school. Please join me in celebrating our Sunset safety scouts. Oh yeah, okay. Yeah, I know. Yeah, I know. Thank you for being patient while we let our safety scouts exit. Okay, we're going to move on to another recognition. We're going to invite Mr. Chris Connor to
007please come up. He is going to present the recognition of the Carl Mellius Awards. Good evening Board President Purcell, Superintendent Dr. Gibson, members of the board, cabinet, and community. My name is Chris Connor. I am the Director of Elementary Education for Livermore Schools and I am absolutely thrilled to honor two amazing teachers this evening with a Carl Mellius Science Award. The Carl Mellius Science Award is awarded annually to elementary teachers who do an exemplary job teaching science to their students. For the past several years, Dr. Carl Mellius, who is a practicing theoretical chemist at Sandia National Laboratories, has generously contributed this monetary award for excellence in science education. This evening, it is an honor to recognize two outstanding educators, Laura Morgan and Katie Warmerdam, whose dedication and innovation have transformed science learning for their students.
008Laura Morgan is a dedicated transitional kindergarten teacher at Lawrence Elementary, with a strong academic background in science. Having studied science at the university level, she seamlessly integrates hands-on exploratory science activities into her curriculum. By incorporating scientific concepts and inquiry-based learning, she fosters an engaging classroom environment where students develop essential background knowledge, expand their recovery, and build a strong foundation for future science standards in kindergarten. Miss Morgan's dynamic teaching approach ignites curiosity and critical thinking in her young learners, inspiring a lifelong passion for discovery and learning. Tonight, we also recognize Katie Warmerdam, a dedicated fifth grade dual immersion teacher at Junction Avenue TK8 School. Miss Warmerdam seamlessly integrates science instruction with English Language Development, ELD, ensuring that all students, regardless of language proficiency, have access to a rigorous and engaging science curriculum. To support emergent bilingual
009students, Miss Warmerdam strategically incorporates targeted language instruction during designated ELD time, focusing on academic vocabulary and language structures to develop the scientific writing. This approach enhances her students' ability to engage meaningfully in whole-class science lessons, increasing their access to and comprehension of scientific concepts. Additionally, Miss Warmerdam facilitates collaborative inquiry projects where emergent bilingual students work alongside their native English speakers, fostering both scientific understanding and language development. Utilizing the district-adopted Twig Science curriculum, Miss Warmerdam creates dynamic, hands-on learning experiences that bring science to life. By incorporating real-world artifacts and interactive activities, she deepens students' conceptual understanding while cultivating critical thinking skills. Miss Warmerdam is highly committed for her commitment to delivering rigorous differentiated instruction that ensures all students excel in science while developing strong language proficiency. We are immensely proud of these dedicated teachers whose passion
010for science enriches their classrooms, deepens student understanding, and inspires the next generation of young scientists. Congratulations to Laura Morgan and Katie Warmerdam, who are the 2025 recipients of the Carol Milius Science Award. All right, thank you. We're going to move on now to our student board member reports. This is the time of the evening where we have our student board member representatives report on their school activities. We have a board member from each of our comprehensive high schools, and we will begin this evening with Gabriel Benitez, sorry, from Granada High School, although it will become apparent really soon. Good evening, board president Prusso, members of the board, superintendent Gibson, cabinet, and community. Granada High School has had an exciting and eventful few weeks. In academics, our ethics pool team, led by Mr. Thayer, traveled to
011UC Santa Cruz to compete, showcasing their critical thinking and ethical reasoning skills. Congrats to Elena Neuen-Scherzer for winning the City of Livermore's Poetry Contest. In the realm of student engagement, leadership students attended the Tri-Valley Leadership Conference, further developing their leadership skills. The highly anticipated Winter Sports Rally will take place on February 7th, featuring a blacklight theme to energize students before the big rivalry basketball game against Livermore High. Finally, Sphere Games, a two-week competition celebrating school spirit, is also underway. Winter Ball is set for February 8th, with ticket sales wrapping up this week. Students can look forward to a night of dancing and community building. Fundraising efforts continue, including class hoodie sales and buffs to support student activities. Granada's music program is in full swing, with upcoming competitions for the City of Livermore Guard and Drumline.
012The Campana Jazz Festival at Amador Valley High School on February 8th will showcase our talented jazz musicians, while the PageMill Twilight Tasting on February 20th will feature student performances and fundraising for our music programs. Granada High School continues to thrive with academic extracurricular and community-driven initiatives. Stay classy. Thank you. We'll now hear from Addie Hart from Livermore High School. Good evening, Board President Prusso, members of the Board, Superintendent Gibson, Cabinet, and community. My name is Addie Hart, and I am representing Livermore High School. Rivals week is this week. Our girls and boys basketball teams play Granada this Friday, and we have a school wide spirit week and a rally on Thursday to get our students excited. EBAL playoffs for winter sports begin the week of the 10th, and NCS playoffs begin the week of the
01317th. Our wrestling team won the City Championship against Granada on January 29th. Winter sports are having senior nights to celebrate their dedicated athletes as their seasons come to an end. Our Livermore High School students showed compassion for the Palisades Elementary Charter School community who recently lost their school in a fire. During a weekly Heroes mini-lesson, students wrote and decorated heartfelt messages to send to the Palisades community, offering their love, support, and hopes for their safety and recovery. In honor of kindness week, LHS students decorated coffee sleeves for Panama Bay Coffee Company. These sleeves adorned with kind words, affirmations, and creative graphics were a hit with both the coffee shop and its customers. This tradition continues to spread joy and inspire others to pay it forward with kindness. February's PBIS theme focuses on gratitude and kindness.
014Heroes lessons this month will center on fostering these values within our school community. Get ready for Operation Needle Drop. This year's music video and lift up featuring the entire LHS community is happening on Friday, February 7th, 2025. The video will be shot in one continuous take starting from the Science Quad and ending at the Wellness Center. This year's theme is the movies. The celebration will include performances by the dance team, various clubs, and more, highlighting everything that makes LHS extraordinary. Thank you. Thank you. We're going to move on to our Employee Association reports and it looks like we have Amy Thompson, president from LEA, and I want to recognize that her vice president, Tara Letts, is here. Yes, and then after we'll have Amy Kristevich, our president of CSEA, and then Kristi Govner, president of
015SEIU. Good evening, board president Perusso, members of the board, superintendent Gibson, and cabinet. I'm Amy Thompson, president of the Livermore Education Association, representing teachers, nurses, counselors, psychologists, speech pathologists, teachers on special assignment, and our one social worker. We have concerns for the impact the current proposed budget cuts may have and are hopeful that solutions can be found that will have less of an impact on direct services for students. We're also interested in exploring ways to increase revenue, such as increasing student attendance. We have negotiations scheduled for this Thursday. Our bargaining team is feeling energized after our interest-based bargaining training. It seems counterintuitive to request a compensation increase during budget cuts, but we must keep in mind the need to provide the best for our students. This includes the ability to attract and retain teachers, to
016be sure that our classrooms are fully staffed and our students receive the care and attention they need. The LEA bargaining team looks forward to working collaboratively with the district team to reimagine our budget and find creative solutions. We're looking forward to breaking bread with our school board this Saturday at the Alcosta School Board breakfast. I want to thank you in advance for taking time out of your Saturday to spend some time with us and get to know more about CTA. Thank you. Thank you. Mamie Christovich, want to come on up? Good evening, President Prusso, members of the board, Superintendent Gibson, and cabinet. I am Mamie Christovich, president of the Livermore chapter of CSCA, the California School Employees Association. Joining me tonight is our chapter's vice president, Victoria Storti. I had not planned to be here
017tonight, but after the January 16th board workshop and subsequent news coverage, many of our members expressed concerns regarding this information about classified layoffs. At our last board meeting, I shared with you that CSCA has 39 different job classifications in our Livermore chapter. This high number is indicative of the vast and diverse range of responsibilities carried out at our school sites and district office. Each classification has a distinct job description, distinct job description, purposefully negotiated between CSCA and our district, and approved by our board. Our classified professionals play vital roles in supporting student success and ensuring schools operate smoothly. In student support roles, library media specialists, paraeducators, instructional assistants, intervention specialists, and instructional specialists provide direct services to students. For administrative support and beyond our schools, executive assistants who are at the right hand to the
018principals, administrative secretaries, office specialists, child welfare attendants, staff, and campus supervisors help to manage operations and maintain safety. District-wide, we have network and data specialists and technicians in IT that we depend on to maintain the stability of our infrastructure and student information systems. Classified staff in departments such as fiscal services, purchasing curriculum, human resources, student services, and special education perform essential functions that sustain the entire district. I'd like to specifically address the special education office, which was mentioned during the January 16th board workshop. This office is staffed by four classified employees, an executive assistant, an administrative secretary, a transportation specialist, and a data specialist. These employees all have a different job description, job title, and salary level. Their roles are not interchangeable and they do not perform each other's duties. It cannot be assumed that
019eliminating one of these positions would result in others absorbing their work as reassigning responsibilities would require negotiations. These are challenging times and I know that our superintendent, district leaders, and our board must make difficult decisions. I do wish that reductions could have been more focused away from employees and wonder if we have looked at every option. I urge the board to ask those probing questions. I do not doubt that everyone is trying to lessen the impact of our budget reductions. However, that does not make it any easier for the dedicated employees whose lives will be turned upside down. We understand a desire to minimize the impact on student education, but employees are essential to that mission. They matter too and no one likes to feel that they are being cast aside without regard for their
020contributions after years of service. Finally, we need to ensure that the impact of these reductions will not be a burden on those who remain. While we optimistically hope to improve efficiencies, improvements require research, time, and resources. I cannot stress enough that eliminating a position should never mean a simple redistribution of that employee's work to others. I need to also emphasize that CSCA work must remain in our bargaining unit and not be assigned to others. I hope that my message tonight helps to guide your decisions in the coming days. The classified employees on the budget reductions list have dedicated years of their lives to our district. They are not just numbers on a piece of paper and they would appreciate your consideration. Thank you for your time and support. Thank you, Mamie. I don't believe that
021Kirsty Governor is here, but she is our president for SEIU and then our representative for CMC is Lily Lopez. We'll move on to public comments on non-agenda items. If you'd like to address a topic that is not on the agenda, now is the time to do so and I don't believe that I have any cards for that. So we'll move on to our communications from the public. Oh, you do? Oh. Oh, yeah. Come on up. Sorry. I didn't know because I didn't have the card. Welcome. You're fine. So we'll put up a timer. There's a three minutes on the timer and I will remind you as you get close, I'm not trying to be rude, just trying to make sure you're on time. You're good. Yeah, you're good. Sorry. Sorry we missed you there. Push
022the button so we can hear you. There you go. It's time. Okay. Better. Good evening board. My name is Wanda Hunter. I am a parent of a student for Livermore High. So I'm going to just make it quick because I'll have two minutes. Okay. So good morning. Good evening board. I'm here to express my deep frustration and concern regarding an incident involving my daughter and her classmate at Livermore High School. It has come to my attention that both students receive what I believe to be unfair and excessive punitive response to the incident that could have been handled with more understanding and compassion. As a parent, I am committed to ensure that my child receives a fair and supportive education and educational environment. However, the treatment my daughter has received in this matter have left me
023feeling disheartened and concerned about the approach, the school's approach to discipline. I believe that the circumstances surrounding the incident was not taken into account and consequences imposed do not reflect the nature of the situation. I have made multiple attempts to address this issue through proper channels within the school. Unfortunately, my concerns have not been adequately addressed. I feel lack of communication and transparency surrounding this matter has only added to my frustration and it's essential for parents to feel heard and supported, especially when it comes to the wellbeing of our children. In pursuit of a fair resolution, I have reached out to the NAACP for assistance. Their involvement underscores the seriousness of my concerns and my commitment to advocating for equal treatment for all students. I believe that every child deserves to be treated with dignity,
024respect, and the disciplinary action should be fair and proportionate to the circumstances. I respectfully urge the school board to review this incident thoroughly and consider the implications of the current disciplinary measures. I am hopeful that we can work together to create a more than just the understanding environment for students at Livermore High. Thank you for your attention in this matter. I look forward to constructive dialogue and resolution that prioritize the best interests of our children. Thank you. Thank you. Having no other, no other, uh, TAN cards. I actually have an appointment with her tomorrow. Okay, great. Okay. Would it be, would it be possible for us to after that meeting for us to get an update? Sure. Yeah. Thank you. All right. Thank you. I'm going to move on to our formal written correspondence. This
025is acknowledged if received by the board or in the superintendent's office by 4 p.m. the day before the meeting. Formal written correspondence received after the cutoff time will generally be acknowledged at the following meeting. And just as a note, our board electronic communications is received via the Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District website by accessing the formal written correspondence of the board of education link with all fields, fields completed and verified. That will all be treated as formal written correspondence. So I'm going to ask trustee Drew and our clerk if he could please summarize for us. I can. We had four forms of correspondence. We received a letter from the Alameda County Office of Education regarding the 2024 25 first interim budget report. Second, we received a letter from the Alameda County Office of Education
026regarding the 2024 2025 eligibility for assistance under California's system of support. Third, we received a letter from the Western Association of Schools and Colleges, also known as WASC regarding Livermore High School's accreditation. And lastly, received correspondence from Kate Sorrell, retired teacher and previous LEA president commenting regarding board meetings and the high school schedule. That's it. Okay, thank you. We're going to move on to our discussion action items and I'm going to turn the time over to Kayla Wasley for our, sorry, measure J bond audit report. Good evening. I'm presenting before you today the annual measure J bond audit report. This bond focuses solely on our measure J bond, general obligation bond, that we passed in 2016 and just goes over the financial accounting as well as other requirements associated with our bond, such as our
027CBOC or the citizens oversight committee. So in the bond audit report, which you have a hard copy of, the first four pages review the independent auditors report and their opinion on the financial statements. It was an unmodified opinion or a clean opinion, which means that the financial statements are accurate and comply with the generally accepted accounting principles or gap. And then the next few pages, pages five through 12, go through the balance sheets and statements of revenue expenditures and changes in the fund balance. And then supplemental to those pages are the notes to the financial statements. So it's a little bit more detail than just the overview and the balance sheets on pages seven through 10. And then the next few pages cover the other auditors reports, which indicates that the auditors conducted the audit
028in accordance with the government accounting, our auditing standards. And then the performance audit comes next on pages 13 through 14. And so it reports on the performance of the program and they tested approximately $6.8 million in invoices or 46% of our total activity in 23-24. They were able to verify expenditures and align them with our ballot language. And they also reviewed a sample of projects to ensure proper bidding protocols were followed. I'm happy to report that there were no findings in 23-24 that were found. Any questions? No questions? This doesn't look like we have any questions. So I would entertain a motion. This is an action item. President Pruce, I move to formally accept the 2023-24 Measure J Bond audit. I second. So I have a motion by Trustee Druhan, seconded by Trustee Kaplanis. Any
029discussion on the motion? Ask the board clerk if he could please take roll. Myself, aye. Trustee Vanden Heuvel, aye. Trustee Kaplanis, aye. Trustee Bueno, President Pruce, aye. That motion carries unanimously 5-0. We're going to continue with Ms. Leslie. She's going to now present the governor's proposed 25-26 budget. This is a discussion item. Just looking for the clicker and I already have it. Okay, so this is a presentation on the governor's proposed 25-26 state budget. So this proposed state budget was released during one of California's most devastating natural disasters, the fires in Southern California. At this time, we don't really know the impacts to the state budget as well as to educational budgets from these fires. We do know that tax refund or tax filings are now postponed and due later on in the year, which
030means that we are yet to get in a time where the state may not know exactly what their revenue is for 25-26 as they adopt the 25-26 budget. And just knowing that the LA area has the revenue source of a small country and it's a huge portion of the California budget. So keeping that in mind as we look through a pretty positive state budget outlook. This year in the Prop 98 side of the budget, there's a current proposal to actually under appropriate the minimum guarantee for 24-25 by $1.6 billion. So what this means is based off of current projections, it appears that California should owe Prop 98 or the education budget $119.2 billion, but the budget is built on the assumption of only $117.6 billion as the minimum funding guarantee. So as long as revenues
031come in according to current projections, the state will actually owe the education side of the budget $119 billion instead of $117 billion. It's kind of a complicated maneuver. It's not quite as challenging as the maneuver that was proposed for 23-24-25 in which it was another year that state revenue was much lower than anticipated due to late tax filings. And so I think this is kind of an effort to look at maybe tax filings won't come in as high as anticipated. So trying to plan conservatively, but it's definitely an unseen avenue that the governor is taking in this budget. But with stable Prop 98 funding, the governor is proposing investments in core instruction and learning this year. And it is key that we consider the protection of every Prop 98 dollar. So as these maneuvers or
032under appropriations are considered, just really advocating that the education budget is fully funded every year. So in Prop 98 and the governor's budget, Prop 98 receives over half of the available state revenue. So we are very highly funded by the state in comparison to other programs. It eliminates the reliance on one-time funding to support our local control funding formula and other ongoing costs. So part of the maneuver that was proposed for 24-25 was due to having to fund the education budget using one-time dollars like our rainy day fund for education. So a lot of that was wiped out in order to fund our 24-25 budget, but luckily state revenues have gotten better. And so that is eliminating that one-time funding, which will make our funding a little more stabilized. And then it also provides significant
033one-time discretionary resources to help with rising costs and other liabilities. And then they are fully funding the estimated COLA, which is at 2.43%. That is actually a slight reduction from what was proposed and used at our first interim budget, which is a hit of approximately $700,000 to our LCFF funding, which was actually noted in the ACOE letter for our first interim budget. At the time first interim was adopted, the current projections had 2.93% as the COLA, and now we're at 2.43%. So the 25-26 LCFF funding factors, these are all of the updated base grants with the 2.43% COLA attached to them. The main change on this slide is our to our TK add-on, which is our per ADA amount that we get for TK students due to our lower staffing ratio. Moving into 25-26, TK
034will be fully implemented, meaning that we will be offering TK to all four-year-olds as long as they turn four by September 1st. And so with that change, we are also reducing our staffing ratio. So currently TK is staffed at a 12-to-1 ratio and an overall class size ratio of 24-to-1 by site. In 25-26, the expectation is that we will be moving to a 10-to-1 staffing ratio, so that can be achieved either through lower class sizes of 20-to-1 with one teacher and one paraprofessional, or having a class size of 24 with one teacher and two paraprofessionals. So the state, this about doubled our TK add-on for this additional staffing ratio, so it's an increase of $3,252 per ADA. And so looking at our current LCFF funding projections with the 2.43% COLA and then our funding for
03524-25 to 25-26, based off of current ADA projections, it appears that we will receive approximately, or it's projected that we will receive approximately $1.5 million increase in LCFF funding. This is about a 1% increase to our funding overall, so that 2.43% actually equates to about 1% for our district due to our declining enrollment. Some other proposed funding within the budget, categorical programs are also receiving the COLA of 2.43%. These programs include our child nutrition, which is funded both through the federal government as well as the state budget, special education, our state preschool, as well as managed block grants. And then there's a new student support and professional development discretionary block grant. They like to name our new discretionary block grants very long. The proposal is $1.8 billion in a flexible one-time grant. Districts may use
036it to address rising costs, but highlighted the priorities to be professional development for teachers, teacher recruitment, retention, career pathways, and dual enrollment. At the time I created the presentation, they hadn't specified the funding allocation, but the omnibus trailer bill language has since been released. And if this comes to fruition, it will receive approximately $3.94 million in this one-time funding. So it is a pretty significant pot of one-time dollars, but until we get closer to the state budget adoption and kind of the negotiations that occur between the governor and the legislation, we really can't plan on these dollars to happen. As I mentioned, our TK staffing ratio, so that totals $1.5 billion across the state in ongoing TK funding. And then the learning recovery emergency block grant, this was actually a funding source that was allocated
037in the 22-23 school year. And then through that time period is when the state realized that they'd really over allocated resources to schools. And so they clawed back some of that funding to help balance out the budget for LCFF funding and other areas. And so now included in that clawback was a proposition to return the funds to the districts as the state budget was able to. So the budget is proposing returning $378 million to schools that were taken back. We have spent all of these funds to date. So if we do receive any of the funds back, we will have to do a needs assessment and that will have to be incorporated into our LCAP plan in order to spend any of the return funds to us. There's also additional funding for TK literacy and
038mathematics coaches. This is a $500 million one-time grant and it would be prioritized based off of high poverty schools. Based off of the last time we had a TK literacy grant, our district did not qualify for it because the free and reduced rate was much higher than where our district currently sits. So if it has the same level of free and reduced rates required in order to qualify, we likely will not qualify for it again. Educator investments, the budget does propose $150 million to create new teacher recruitment incentive programs as well as $100 million to extend the national board certification for credential clearing. And then for our meal program, there is an additional $106 million ongoing to fund the universal meal program. We don't know yet with everything that is happening with the federal government
039how this could impact universal meals in California. Right now universal meals is contingent on the federal portion of our meal funding. So hopefully that remains stable as well as this universal meal funding. And then another $150 million in one-time funding for kitchen infrastructure and training dollars. So with all of those programs, these are the recommendations for what will be included in the 25-26 adopted budget at this time, the 2.43% COLA for all applicable programs. We feel pretty solid that this will occur. The additional learning recovery block grant additional funding, the TK add-on, the new discretionary block grant, as well as any literacy coaching funding, we'll kind of talk about and develop tentative plans but not include in our adopted budget at this time unless we get better news in May that it feels confident that
040these funds will occur just so we don't over plan our expenditures in 25-26 as well as our revenue. And then so this is just a slide on the state budget process. So in January, the Senate and assembly both had an overview hearing and then the subcommittees develop as the negotiations start and bills are introduced. And then the governor's May revision will occur in mid-May. And then in early June, both the Senate and the assembly will have their budget heard by both subcommittees. And then in mid to late June, the legislator and legislator leaders will continue to negotiate with the governor to enact the final state budget by June 30th of 2025. So our next steps with this information is to update any budget assumptions such as the COLA for our next budget update, which is
041second interim. We'll finalize our budget reduction measures necessary for 25-26 due to our qualified budget status, preparing the second interim reports that will be presented in March and then attending the governor's May revised workshop in May and then adopted budget comes in June. That was a lot of information. So any questions? Stephen. So just clarifying for my own knowledge. So for example, slide six, the student support and professional development discretionary block grant. So when you say grants, so is it that the state is going to, I think you had cited 3.9 million. So do we need to do anything to get that? It's just the state is, it's a categorical fund and the state is saying, we're hoping to give you 3.9 million to use for that. And so for most of those, that's kind
042of the gist of it. Yes. So for this one, it's because it's a discretionary block grant, it's non-competitive and it will be distributed based off the trailer bill language on a per ADA basis to all schools in California. So it depends on how that trailer bill language is written, but for discretionary block grant, typically it's kind of given across the board based off a specific formula. This one is specific to P2 ADA or average daily attendance generating the funding. And then secondly, which you kind of addressed and so you had said to develop tentative internal plan for funding because some of this may stick, some of it may be reduced, some of it may go up. Right. So what does that plan look like? Do you have two kind of a very conservative, we're not
043going to get any of it or I was just wondering if you could comment on doing your job twice? Yes. So I would say there's definitely the plan that we only get the bare minimum COLA and not much else. And then I would say as cabinet, we'll talk about what potential revenue, additional revenue sources that we would have and how we could best utilize it. What are our highest needs that we haven't been able to address? I know one area that has come up recently is technology that we haven't really planned for our replacement of devices. And so with that, we have our one-to-one student devices as well as staff devices that were replaced with COVID dollars and then not really planned for. So then it's looking at, can we incorporate any of that into
044that funding as well as expanding our professional development? And then of course, compensation is always a consideration as well as our, how it could offset our future spending. All of those things would be considered and talked about just so that way when we do get the good news that it is what we expected or goes up, then we have kind of thought about that and are better able to use it in meaningful ways. And then kind of lastly, I think I have a question relating to the Prop 98 maneuver because the last time this show came to town where we had taxes were being filed late, we were building budgets and then it turned out that the state revenue came in significantly lower and the governor was trying to figure out how to balance the
045budget. So my assumption is that this is kind of preempting that the budget is going to look very different from, or it could look very different from what we anticipate because of the fires and because of the delayed taxes. So is that kind of accurate? That's what I'm guessing at. It's never been, it hasn't really been fully explained yet of why there's a proposal to under appropriate Prop 28 where last time the governor was really trying to reduce the Prop 98 guarantee. This is not trying to reduce the Prop 98 guarantee. It's just planning a budget that under appropriates it. So the only thing I can think is it's planning for the eventuality that revenues will come in a little bit lower than anticipated and it's easier to add money than it is to take
046money away as we well know. I worked at Nordstrom. It's under promise and over deliver and so I think saying that be conservative may look good and I think that that's a good course for us to do because it's easier to add on things after the fact than to take things away. Thank you. You mentioned at the end there an explanation 28 but I'm guessing that was just a slip. It's 98. Prop 98, yes. Not 28. 28 is the music one or something. Yes, Prop 98. I apologize. Okay. All right. I just want to make sure on that. And then on the $1.8 billion block grant, is it intended or may it be used to supplant budget? Yes. Well, based off a current language proposals, it is a flexible one-time block grant so it can
047be used to supplant current expenses. I would say so when Jerry Brown was in office, he gave discretionary block grants and put zero expectations on how they would be used. It was just a discretionary block grant used to really pay down money owed to school districts that occurred during the recession in 2008, 2009, 2010. Governor Newsom has it to where he puts what he would like to see it spent but then gives complete flexibility. So we had our arts, music, instructional materials block grant that had arts and music as a focus but then said it can be used for any rising costs, any operational expenses. So even though he calls out some specifics of maybe where he would like to see it spent, there's no actual requirements to spend it in those areas. So maybe
048the sound bite in reality. Yes. Okay. I just look at it like that because sometimes when you have money that you can move somewhere else that we're not spending it twice because it has a title of one thing, it gets spent when we could preserve bodies. Yes. You know, teachers, CSEA people. Okay. The meal program, do you feel, I mean you were waiting on some more information. I know it's real difficult right now but the Department of Ed at the national level trying to dismantle a lot and I know a lot of our money for that comes from the federal government. Do we feel confident that we're able to maintain at least in the short term the meal program? Yes. Thankfully we have a pretty decent size ending fund balance in that program. Our ending
049fund balance was about three million dollars I believe as we closed 23-24. I was looking and we get about 2.5 million dollars from the federal government every year for our meal program and so it's not a long-term sustainable plan but at least in the short term we do have the ending fund balance to sustain the program if we were to receive abrupt notice that we, the federal government was no longer going to fund the meal program. Okay and then and lastly, do we have a toll on the total amount of money that we receive from the federal government? I know some of it is unfunded mandates but in terms of the actual dollar amount, title one, you know the English language learners, all the different things that we get federal money for. If it was,
050let's want to look at by comparison what percentage of our budget comes from the feds? Percentage wise I want to say it's around seven percent of our funding or in the first interim we had 12.2 million dollars in federal funding and then next year anticipated eight million dollars. We did have quite a bit of carryover in some of our grant programs but some of those are grant programs that we don't know if federal funding were to be cut, if we would receive that carryover that we previously had or if they would wipe out the carryover as well. So between eight and twelve million dollars. Okay I guess I'm looking at the recurring funds versus grants that we've been awarded like at Maryland Avenue. I'm looking at recurring money. Recurring money we get 5.1 million dollars.
051Okay all right thank you. No questions? Dina do you have any questions? Okay I did have a couple of questions on the the block grants. I think there were two of them, the learning recovery and the declining? No. Student support and professional development. Yeah um so that funding is one-time funding is and it's is it restricted? It's somewhat restricted correct? Um based off of the current language of the student support and professional development that would be pretty much unrestricted. Okay. They'll put some caveats like I said of what they would like it to be spent on but based off of the current language it appears to be unrestricted be spent on but based off of the current language it appears to be unrestricted in nature by based off of the broadly written language of it
052saying that it can go towards rising cost operational cost and things. But it is one-time funds. Correct yes. So you have to consider that when you're. Yes yes you cannot plan on an ongoing basis that you have to plan for it to either support a cost that you add on for several years or only use it on one-time expenses which is the most advisable. Oh you know what we have we do have a comment I'm so sorry we'll do that we have a comment for this correct no the next one oh it's the next one oh good sorry I'm trying to to keep all the all the all the balls in there at once okay thank you um and then I maybe you don't know the answer to this but the the maneuver I I'm
053curious how the maneuver works in that for prop 98 and maybe you don't totally know but it feels like it's lowering the floor for educational funding in perpetuity is that true I mean it just seems kind of risky as far as like now it's he's trying to like help now but then does it lower the floor for funding in the future the maneuver that was proposed for 24 25 would have lowered the floor for education funding and that is why that's the 1.6 billion um that is one that was proposed going into the 24 25 budget year and that education advocates pushed hard against um to say that you can't lower the floor because that not only affects us this year it affects us ongoing I would say the under appropriation it would still set
054the floor at the correct amount but it underfunds schools so it shouldn't lower it on an ongoing basis it would only lower it in the current year because that's what I wasn't quite sure about yeah yeah okay no great question okay uh any other questions if not I think this is not a this is just a discussion item only so we can move on thank you um so okay sorry let me get so next we're we are going to move on to our budget discussion and just for protocol you guys you present then we'll go to our comment card and then comment comment card first comment card first so that way throughout the process we can probably answer question or that that way we know what to make sure we touch on great so then
055I will invite uh Wendy I'm sorry I can't read will you okay thank you come on up and so you have three minutes I'll remind you when you get if you get close okay just so you know okay um good evening President Prusso members of the board Superintendent Gibson and cabinet my name is Wendy or Tiaga and I am the data specialist for special education department I would like to take this opportunity to read an email that was emailed to the board members from the office staff in our department we the clerical staff of the special education department would like to clarify a statement made at the last board meeting as you are aware it has been recommended that 1.0 ft one of our four positions be eliminated in response to the district's budget deficit
056during the special board meeting it was suggested that the four clerical staff in our department are able to do each other's jobs we would like to respectfully clarify that this is not an accurate representation of our duties and roles each of us have specific positions and tasks that are distinct to our unique job classification our positions and duties we perform are not interchangeable we cannot perform data pools or calpads reporting and maintain data accuracy as a wendy and tiaga our day specialist does we cannot process and schedule transportation for all special education students conduct investigations on vehicle incidents or accidents or manage time sensitive record requests as victoria story our transportation specialist does we cannot handle medical billing and reporting or submit purchases for the entire special education department as taylor reeves our administrative secretary
057does we cannot write contracts or process settlement and reimbursements as amber basses our executive assistant does while we work very closely together and support one another particularly when someone is out of the office we want to emphasize that the tasks of our desk cannot be substituted for one another in addition it should be reiterated that the special education department is already operating with fewer fewer staff due to the elimination of other positions such as the coordinator of special education which is a 1.0 ft in june 2024 and the executive director position 1.0 ft in december 2024 like any other department in the district they all still have directors as a clerical staff we fear we will not have the capacity to absorb the responsibilities of an entire clerical position also it is worth noting that
058any change to our job description would need to be negotiated as a protected right please understand the work we do in special education is critical special education services are bound by law and if tasks are not completed or fall behind we risk violating ips facing cd complaints falling out of compliance or dealing with potential litigation the parents and students we serve have rights that we must uphold and the clerical staff plays an essential role ensuring these rights are met we understand a difficult decision the board is task making and respectfully ask that you've considered the recommendation to eliminate a 1.0 ft position the clerical staff we believe that rather than reducing staff the district could explore other cost-saving measures for example implementing a hiring freeze reevaluating all district that's your time service okay thank you
059thank you all right thank you so much now we'll turn the time over to dr gibson so in the packet we included an updated round three recommended reductions i'm only going to go over the boxes or line items that are green anything that is white was already on here there's two gray lines i want to talk about those very quickly those were on the round two recommended reductions they have not changed at all we just are still working on the reorganization concepts for those two departments and i wanted to at least highlight them just so that they don't get lost in the shuffle but they're not new so they wouldn't be green and i didn't want to make them white because they're not specific yet and so they're gray so if we start with line
060i line 11 you have that we have the aquatics coordinator position so mof was on here it was listed originally as a reorg of that department this is actually a change in the position an elimination of this position we also had an employee who has since resigned and i'm going to pass this over to miss wasley just to explain a little bit of kind of the reorg of mof as she worked with our amazing director of mof on that project yes so in january we had a resignation of our maintenance supervisor in the maintenance operations department and then there was interest by our operations manager to move into the man the maintenance operations role which then opened up the sorry the maintenance role which opened up the operations role we also had our aquatics coordinator
061who has vast experience not only in the pool management but throughout the district and grounds and so been talking with him he expressed interest in that so that position is actually currently open and so the plan is to move from three um management level positions the direct well for i say the director plus two supervisors and the aquatics coordinator to then one director and two supervisors within the maintenance department and then it would not be a layoff of any employees due to having a vacancy currently can i ask a question just really quickly so obviously the the duties at the pool manager are still going to be happening is it through one of those positions or yes so the pool duties have been added to the operations manager job description which is included in the
062board packet tonight for approval yeah i saw that okay yeah go ahead when we brought in the aquatic center right around that time there was a tragedy happened at one of our neighboring school districts was it and um there was a lot of special attention that went into this position and and in terms of direct supervision on those aquatic centers to make sure that something like that didn't happen here and then we had adequate if not superior supervision and coordination of that effort is the elimination of this in any way are we cognizant of that and if we're cognizant of it have we mitigated any of that all of that risk factor yes um so we are that is absolutely a huge focus of ours is making sure that we do have the appropriate supervision
063and oversight of the pools part of that is that where the maintenance supervisor oversaw mostly just the maintenance staff they will also be working with the operations staff which is our custodial staff more and then the operations manager will be focusing more on pools and grounds so that way the position is not overextended as well as looking at potential options we used to pay stipends at the school sites um to help with some of the monitoring of the pools if the person could not be on site or the aquatics coordinator when i looked at some of the ratios of how many pools can be overseen by um aquatics like coordinator or that's a position like that and they can be up to 25 pools and we have our two pools so we do feel like
064with that split duty and moving some of the custodial um piece away from that operations position that we will still be appropriately staffed for the pool oversight piece okay i i guess i guess my concern is that at the time the discussion in the surrounding district and it came in here there was a lot of you know it's kind of heartfelt and so um very heartfelt so a lot of people looked at that and it wasn't that we wanted to be adequate or we wanted to have additional support because it was so easy that something like that a tragedy like that could happen and i want to make sure that from a safety perspective that it's not i think we should be okay that it's where i don't want to reduce anything in the area
065of student safety when it comes those two aquatic centers the public invested millions of dollars to put them in the community benefits from it and i know that the people that were overseeing those in terms of i'm not sure what his exact job i mean his exact title was but the people that supervised those pools took great pride in making sure you know doors were closed custodial when outside you know groups came in and used them when there was tournaments that no one got left track of that all those rules were followed and that the district didn't get exposed and the community didn't get exposed to a loss like that so if you're comfortable with that and you know i'm good with it on that one line i think too also that position they were
066also over the lifeguards and so i but that could continue would be that person okay sorry where's i think it's just organic here but yeah yeah it's okay yeah no we we definitely want to make sure that you know safety is always our number one priority so a hundred percent on that that we've had those conversations as well okay um on line 12 the only change um is the dollar amount which did increase and that's just um as miss wasley is having um conversations with staff around the possibilities of that reorganization um and that will be uh made that'll be on here the reorganization will change to green um at next week's meeting so when you move down to line item 15 the only change on that line item is we had that same line
067item on here it said um at the last meeting um either eliminate a 1.0 fte additional um elementary tosa or a funding shift and a huge thank you to mrs pachette she has been working so hard with miss wasley to figure out just really shifting around our funds and using our lcff supplemental as well as well as our lcap funds and other things um first instead of our general fund money and so we were able to save that position and do a funding shift the dollar amount also changed because this is a funding shift of the current person in the position and this is the cost of the current position if you go back to the last position um it would be i want to say it was like 99 000 or 98 000 roughly
068give or take some money but it was um and because we had to change that dollar amount because then when we were going to eliminate it this teacher would then bump a lower paid teacher out of you know so we're taking all of that into account as we're doing those calculations so i just wanted anything that's changed from the last one to this one if you put them up next to each other i made the box green just just so that you know okay one of the things is we're going through these and and i know it's not on here so i don't but but imagine it somewhere i'm just wondering when we get the next copy even if it's one of those a longer sheet of paper that we can fold over is that
069when i've seen these in the past when we've gone through this exercise it's the same columns but there's an additional column that shows causation effect mitigating factors we heard from csea tonight relative to positions and special ed it's because it's not always just oh it's one fte if there's four specialized positions and we eliminate one is it fair or we are we creating chaos and anxiety that people are like well what are how are we going to do this these are certified positions and are we supposed to absorb it and it's negotiated could we see a column added to this that would actually reflect the thought process that's gone into this so that when we're looking at the sheet the thought process behind this like yeah we're currently meeting with csea or safety factors have
070been taken you know those type of things sure yeah we can we can add that on here for next week's meeting um i mean a lot of those are going to show as just funding shifts which is a pretty easy that's explanation of just that's easy yeah those are easy so when we eliminate two fte sure what does that mean sure yeah that's that's absolutely um on line 24 this did say reorganization and student services and just through conversation and really evaluating job duties and and different functions that position is specifically to an office specialist we had it as a reorg of a 1.0 fte and this position currently sits as a 0.8 and so that's why the next column was changed to green on line 30 we had a conversation of sub rates so
071during the pandemic and post-pandemic fridays were just really difficult to get subs and so we had increased our rate at that point in time i'm going to look over at miss robbins to 255 a day our regular rate monday through thursday is 215 a day we did an analysis um miss robbins did an analysis i won't say we she did an analysis of our neighboring districts and no one is um any longer doing the friday rate everyone has gone back to the basics so this was a good cost savings that was noticed um both by she and miss wasley um line 32 is the transportation specialist um that is green because this was a reorganization uh change last time but that was the only piece that has changed since the last meeting line 33 is
072um so the ib piece in the past the ib section was just a reorganization we did um have a meeting with some ib um credentialed people i will say um as joe mitchell it was perfect timing just happened to be going through their ib and what is it called um certification like certification thank you yeah so which was great because it allowed us to have a really in-depth conversation with the visiting team um and really come up with some ideas and it was it was apparent that we needed to make a change here so it's not as big of a cost savings as we had originally anticipated but for all the right reasons so um this is so originally we had i want to say 3.0 fte on here we've eliminated one of the coordinators
073off of the list completely for joe mitchell they will maintain their full-time coordinator position because they are an ib school campus wide the certificated librarian is not a requirement of ib and comes at a at a cost that you can see here the 97 365 um 97 365 is the cost of the teacher that's the lowest paid that this employee will bump can bump out because this employee has rights back to a classroom so that's that's why that number is there can i ask a question related to that kind of in all of the bumping is there priority to certain specialized teaching positions like let's say the lowest on the you know least seniority is at like a first grade dual immersion teacher that isn't can't like exactly sub into it so how does that
074factor in or does it factor in or yes so some of that comes with the collective bargaining agreement some of it automatically has a language over do you want to do you want to talk about this um maybe just you can give a little bit more detail because that's a great question great question um as our superintendent said the bargaining agreement really outlines the order we will work closely with lea and the members um because we recognize um some of the hard to fill positions to make sure that our employees go back in appropriately either by the cba or negotiations with the lea leadership work in tandem with them so when we were looking at the second ib coordinator the program at granada is still very very small it's something that we need to come
075up with a new plan on how we are going to grow that program in order for it to sustain itself um mr kolkowski and i met with a group of ib parents they were very supportive as well as the granada administrative staff to brainstorm some ideas um but the conversation we had with the the credentialed team that came from ib really kind of spurred the conversation around keeping the full-time person at at mitchell and then having the coordinator at the high school be part-time because it is a much smaller program it's not ideal but our goal is to grow that program and attempt over the next two to three years to expand the program and if not then unfortunately having the conversation of can we maintain the program or not long-term financially so but for
076now we want to try and maintain it and and reinvent it as we know it just because we aren't getting the enrollment in the ib program currently on how much of the ib program did we look back historically you know when there was an arbitrary action taken a couple years ago that eliminated the the program and kids had to change their classes and i wonder if the enrollment is relatively the same like we recovered from that no it's the same okay we just looked at all that's a great question we just looked at all of that data and it has not changed at all since then and really that's our concern is that it has become stagnant and or even slightly decreased but we have a plan and i'm confident that we can grow the
077program long term and everyone can code that there's there's just a little bit of a struggle you know ap versus ib and and we're going to work hard to make it so that both programs can sustain themselves and coexist because we have students who actually enroll in both and they they both serve a purpose some for students who are just ap track great some that are just ib track much much smaller numbers and we do have a few that that dabble in both and so we just want to make sure before we go down any drastic measure route of doing any type of full elimination conversation that we really have put all of our effort in to really reinvent the program if if that's possible i think the the thing that i would say regarding
078that is trying to get metrics like set goals and then hold the program accountable for rising to those goals setting reasonable goals that that are to grow the program grow the program regarding certain students so that we're not just making anecdotal decisions that it's based upon like we all know this is where we'd like you to be and you know let's provide the support to get you there so i think just communicating that and setting that expectation is going to help make the decision to grow or further support the program or else yes and and the other piece too is if let let's just say down the road and i don't i don't want to go down this path tonight but just so let's just say we did we would never just cut a program
079especially for students who have been in the program so we'd have to phase it out if we choose to do that and that that conversation won't happen for a couple years we're going to put some very strong goals in place and really do follow up mr kolkowski is going to be working specifically with mr conover and other staff members at the site as we move forward oh okay um on line uh 35 um we actually updated this i don't know if you saw on the cover sheet we updated it today because there were some changes in the number so line 35 um one two three the the column right next to the purple that actually should also be highlighted in green um that was a and and the dollar amount so there was a flip
080around with the numbers from earlier today um it's the same overall fte if we just collapse line 35 and 36 for del val and vineyard and it said alternative education it still would be 4.5 fte our original plan was 5.0 fte um and i really i really commend the staff and the administration at that at those two programs for really working hard together to um to come together and really try and again reinvent where they are and and where they sit and you know they came to us and said hey we managed to get to 4.5 can we can we make that work and and we absolutely supported that so that was a change from 5.0 fte total between those two programs line 41 math lead stipends that's a funding shift and you can see
081the dollar amount line 42 so our um these stipends are currently used across the board at all of our school sites um sites have anywhere from um i don't i'm gonna look at mrs pichette uh anywhere from i think that the high schools have 12 i know when i talked to mr conover today it was 12 and i know some of the elementaries have nine um and that whole system has now kind of caught up with itself and i'm gonna let mrs pichette just explain a little bit about the vision of where that will go next um as far as those i am instructional team lead stipends what the thought process here is that we would give a specific amount of stipends per um level so elementary k through five would have a certain number
082and then middle school would have a certain number i can look those up right now for you and then um our kates would have a certain amount of stipend so the amount of the stipend will not go down because that's a negotiated item but the amount of stipends we we offer to each site um will be a set number um and so as we took a look um let's see let me get my notes here the stipends will be uh four stipends um at our k through five schools three stipends will be afforded to our middle schools and five stipends for our k through eights thank you is there any consideration for the size of the school given that some schools are maybe double if not close to triple the size we took more of
083a look at grade level spans and and inclusive of our special education staff to be representative of the grade levels um rather than enrollment but that's a really good question obviously high schools well i shouldn't say obviously high schools will have a larger number than let's say an elementary school site but after talking with the principal if you know we we did kind of some polling of a few principals just to get a feel for their thoughts and one of them happens to be one of our largest elementary schools and that perception was that this was a good move just to make the transition into a new way of the site collaborating across grade levels versus just in their grade level bands by themselves we will make sure that there is one ilt person on
084the sites though that is a special ed person just especially because of all of the special education work we're going to be doing now and in the future moving on to line 43 that's a funding shift of the liaison stipends item 44 is a funding shift of dual immersion stipends and then the bottom below the dark gray line those are non-personnel things that we have been working on docuSign is a cost that we have and google now has that and it comes as part of our google suite so we don't need docuSign so things like that that we're really trying to dig up and add to here that we can shift over to elop supplies and staffing that's a funding shift adult education custodial costs that can be a funding shift the site allocation reductions
085and we'll be working with staff on that and we're going to be completely changing just the philosophy of how we do site allocations district departments last year took a big hit and so we were hoping not to reduce at the site level for their site allocations but we're at the point where we have to make a slight adjustment there however the sites may or may not even really feel it that much when we roll out the new plan for site allocations my philosophy is for site allocations principals have the responsibility we we provide them the funding and we do not tell them how to spend it they put it in their school site plans that and those goals and those desires align with our l cap and they create because every school is different what
086one school is going to spend their funding on is is different from another school we also have some schools that are higher have higher enrollments of and duplicate accounts and different things and so we'll come up with a funding formula that will make those adjustments for us and so we'll be working on that later this spring and then the last one that is not a personnel is the ib research database we continue to pay almost seven thousand dollars for a database that is now online there's other databases that are free so we're hoping between now and next week we'll be able to add below the dark gray line that's our goal the higher you know we've met the threshold of the six million based on this sheet but the further we can get that number
087higher than obviously we can concede some things further up on the top of the of the document again this is just a draft and and just things that we're putting out there to move us forward or closer to that number so happy to answer any additional questions in in walking through that this document i i think maybe some one of you said that it's about 85 percent of is human cost right and so i did it a quick calculation and i think it's about three percent non-human reductions and then the rest is all coming from humans so i would really i'm really looking forward to seeing what we can add to get maybe closer to a 10 or 15 reduction in non-human uh yeah impact and some of that could come after march 15th as
088well the biggest struggle for us right now is that takes us a little bit of time to be able to to dig those things out once we hit that march 15th deadline if we have not given notices then we can't so we can rescind notices but we can't add notices after march 15th so we may not be able to remove things from the top of this come the the the next well the next regularly scheduled board meeting on the 18th but it doesn't mean that we won't be able to between march 15th and may 15th right and and the re and yes that's really good to hear so from what i understand is that you because you've moved really fast on this like just you know even just from from the from the beginning of
089the year but it seems that this has been much slower this the the non-human reductions have been much coming in much slower because you've just really been focusing on getting to that march deadline correct thank you yes thank you for bringing that up because our goal i mean obviously our people matter we we want to keep as many of our people as we can and some of it's just going to come with time as we're continually digging in and looking we appreciate the partnership with our our union groups because they have also been helpful in bringing some of these things to our attention and we'll continue to do that post-march so that by may hopefully you know a lot of this has been has been either through our ticket through attrition or through below the
090the dark gray line and we'll go we'll make sure that we add that other column as well okay yeah that was my question i i think that that you brought up was could we resend the the notice yeah final final layoff notices are due may 15th okay yes there's a lot of shifting around of people and i really like that super creative how many actual layoffs how many people will based on this just today how many of those are actual people that are going to have to look for a different job elsewhere i don't know that we'll have that number just yet because we also have bumping we have attrition we have retirements we're still waiting for so i don't i'm we can try and have a number by the next meeting by next thursday
091and add that to the sheet as well that might be helpful yeah we'll make sure we add that as well it's a great idea one thing that i don't see um on here well there's probably a few things but um what is then what's the number that we're kind of looking for like in terms of percentages like you know across the board are we looking like when i look at you know i and i'll kind of dig in a little bit online say seven where says cabinet lma there's a number there for some five days this is it like is that 2.5 percent i mean 220 workdays eliminate five days about two and a half percent um 22 days would be 10 percent so five days would be two and a half percent yeah about
092that it ranges depending on the type of employee like classified employees they're paid over i think he's talking specifically about the management line well there is management that is classified that is paid 260 days versus certificate management 220 days so that's why a percent of it's not so much the yeah the exact number about as it is you know everyone's making cuts yeah there's a small little i call it a stipend whatever a couple hundred bucks a month that board members get you know i suppose just as one person that whatever that number is if it's two and a half percent that that same thing would happen i would be in favor of doing the same thing to the board you know whatever that number is i mean you're scraping acorns together to try to
093make something here and and you know it's sure and it's across the board and it's i mean that's just me and and it's i mean it's not like you're given much because i mean like a couple hundred bucks but but when i was looking at and that's a true my interest was line seven is that just rough math where it says reduce these positions like i'm not sure like as much as i understand i think there's maybe 50 54 positions five days so you're kind of figuring maybe rough math thousand bucks a position could that be 25 days at 54 positions would be 270 000 yeah it's pretty it is based off of i took it based off of our cost of one percent kind of the average number of days for both certificated and
094classified and then use that to then calculate the five days so it is a rougher math that's not like person by person looking at it but yeah it is kind of looking at an average cost of a day and then multiplying that by five and how much of that at least you know having been through a couple of budget crises some that were very very severe and looking at furlough i didn't see furlough on here what i see is reduced work days to get to that number and what i'm wondering is when we're talking about reduced work days should we at least in in the management sense there's a couple things one when you're when you're sinking you don't take on anything right we're and so we have step in column should we freeze step
095in column during this period and how much would that save us relative to management and and also when when we're looking at this if we work five days less that's going to change the calculus because it changes your multiplier for anyone who might be retiring correct correct so should we keep the days the same work the same amount of days and make the same amount of money less like we could do a cost share where it doesn't hurt anyone in their retirement where that person would contribute towards their pers or stirs cost the equivalent amount so it doesn't hurt them in retirement but the kids don't lose anything because that's one of the my reasons for seeing the actual impact if our entire administration works five days less how does that affect kids you know
096i'm wondering what that impact is well as administrators we would take those days off when students aren't present so but their work day the same our our jobs get done i mean we just get the same work done in five less days in all reality um it's just the way administration goes and we're willing to our entire administrative team lma has agreed that that is the best way to go they would rather do that than lose any amount of staff if they can help it right no i get that i mean it's there's there's two separate issues one is we don't want to lose staff but as a manager especially like and i know it's a typical conversation but do we but do we want to continue to work the days because we can do
097it in five less days because if i if i'm not mistaken it used to be 225 then it went to 220 and now this would take it to 215 well everybody has different numbers of work days but it's if you're talking about there's only a couple groups but there's only a couple groups right no we have multiple people who sit in this category and every there's multiple different days that everyone works and so all of them across the board would just work five less days correct okay it's just i would like to see like you know whether like what's the impact if we first off stop stop falling so if we didn't do step and column like how much of an impact is that i mean we're looking at some of these things that are
098relatively nominal saving seven thousand dollars but if we didn't take step increases for our higher earners in the for this one year and we didn't take anything like we just leave it where it's at you know um what does that save us we can provide that number i think i think the step and column not increasing step and column has a larger impact on retirement than a five-day furlough because a five-day furlough we can put right back in the system once we get our budget under control a step and column you lose forever unless the board opted to at some point then step everybody back to where they should have been and that's what we were trying not to do is we were trying not to impact people's retirements we also didn't want to impact
099the rest of our staff with furlough days we you know we could have gone and asked for those those things to be done and that wasn't something that was brought to our attention by our labor unions i mean i know staff had talked about it privately and but i don't think that there was interest from our labor groups to do that for all the right reasons and so as management it's a little bit easier for us to do that than it is for them and so that's why this was put on the sheet at the last meeting right i know it's because it's difficult you you know i'm looking at like teachers they're going to lose 20 positions it looks like roughly on this sheet that's 20 positions and i know you can't say well
100we're going to lose a proportional share in management because they're key to a complete program so sometimes the sacrifices in the actual wage where it's we're going to take an x percent a 2.5 percent we don't have to call it a reduction because you're still going to make the money but we're going to take that money and we're going to offset the employer's cost and pay our purrs or stirs for this period in that equivalent amount it's a cost share i know that it works because it was a it was a strategy that was implemented during the 07 08 and a lot of those strategies were eliminated with the pension reform act and so unless you are really honest when there's one retirement plan that you can do a reduced workload that allows you to
101keep your same level of contributions but only work half the time and receive half the pay you can't increase contributions and maintain the same level of like credit reporting oh no it's not it's not it's not spiking it's not airtime but this this pays what the cost share plan allows for you to do is pay the employers a portion of the employer's cost towards stirs it doesn't increase it doesn't change your stuff it's just the employee gets constructive receipt of the money and then pays back under a cost share but they don't allow that any longer those rules have all significantly changed and stirs does not allow that any longer okay so we'll have our next update at our meeting on thursday and we will add all we're going to add the column the explanation
102column we will try and calculate the number of people it's a great question and i feel like there was a third one what am i missing was that it was it was that it those two okay just those two okay if i missed one and somebody remembers please shoot me a text so i can add it because those are great things to add on to here just as information okay we're going to invite mr jason krulikowski please come forward we have some class approvals for some new courses we're going to send our student board members off to do their homework test good evening board president pruso members of board superintendent gibson and members of cabinet i'm here tonight to present eight new courses for approval as we enter the spring i will be presenting multiple
103new courses for our students at the high school level creating new high school courses involves assessing student interest through surveys or focus groups followed by district-wide teacher collaboration to develop the curriculum the curriculum must align with a through g requirements ensuring that it meets the standards set by the university of california and california state university systems for college readiness after the curriculum is developed it undergoes curriculum review for formal approval and is brought to our school school board for approval also once it is approved the course is marketed for students during the registration process and as we move throughout the year we receive feedback from our students and educators to improve improve future offerings the courses i present tonight are not new in the sense that you have all approved them in the past it's
104not like we haven't had art and ceramics for years but it's a renaming of our courses given the shift into the semester system our first course and i apologize unlike years past each course we paused for a recommendation for approval we'll read all the courses and then take questions and ask for approval at the end our first course is art ab this course will teach students the elements of art and principles of design guiding them to create original pieces using techniques like drawing and painting they'll explore various mediums improve their analytical skills and engage with both their own and others artworks in the latter half of the course students will create art influenced by global and cultural themes while also learning how to professionally present their work the next course is advanced art ab this
105course is designed for fine art students who want to continue their learning about art while focusing on personal skill development enhancing both knowledge and technical abilities the course includes visual and written assignments that align with state visual art standards offering opportunities to work with various mediums like drawing painting collage and possibly printmaking and digital media the goal is to help students create a professional portfolio and set career objectives catering to dedicated and motivating motivated advanced art students third new course is animation ab students will develop foundational skills in cartooning claymation stop motion 2d and 3d computer animation through theoretical study and hands-on practice they will create high quality artwork incorporating animation stop motion video and audio production while critically animate analyzing animation works and collaborating on projects additionally they will explore the impact of influential
106figures in the animation industry you're going to see four new or four ceramics courses and i'll explain the difference this is the elective courses that virtually all students can take this course introduces the fundamental ceramic techniques including hand building sculpture glaze application and kiln firing firing while incorporating artistic principles and design elements students engage in critical discussions receive productive feet constructive feedback and develop creative problem-solving skills practical experience with the potter's wheel is complemented by an exploration of historical and cultural pottery and sculpt and sculpture the next course after ceramics ab is advanced ceramics ab this offers students the opportunity to refine their their skills in hand building wheel throwing and sculpting while emphasizing creativity and high standards of design the course explores contemporary works and professional studio practices allowing students to develop their artistic
107voice as they progress students gain greater autonomy choosing project themes that will align with align with their personal interest the difference in these next two classes where they have a cte annotation with it is that these are part of a sequence pathway with a teacher who has a cte credential students will develop a strong foundation in ceramics as they embark on the first of two courses in the design visual and media arts cte pathway through hands-on projects and creative exploration they will gain technical proficiency in shaping glazing and firing ceramics while also deepening their understanding of artistic principles and design concepts the next course in the pathway and if students complete this course as well they'll be considered a cte completer and i reference that because we've done some work with our college and career
108readiness and we've talked about the multiple avenues our students can take a cte pathway is is one of them advanced ceramics cte is a capstone course in the arts media and entertainment sector focusing on design visual and media arts pathway it blends artistic exploration with industry relevant skills emphasizing creative problem solving technical execution and project management no no we'll just wait we can hear you but the people at home might not be able to hear you through hands-on learning students refine ceramic techniques while following professional standards and design principles equipping them for further education or careers in creative industries i lost that last slide i apologize the mic threw me off our last class is the course this course is designed excuse me a studio ceramic cte ab this course is designed for advanced ceramic
109students who wish to continue their studies independently but cannot attend the regular advanced course due to scheduling conflicts running alongside ceramics and advanced ceramics it offers flexibility while requiring students to develop their own project ideas and meet regularly with the instructor for guidance and feedback super its superintendent's recommendation is to approve all new courses thank you and if you have any questions or comments i can take those yeah go ahead uh is there a is there an enrollment threshold for each of these courses so they can they you know you open it up your market into the students but you know what is the uh two students two students we're in you're good uh let me make sure i understand your question at do we have class limits or how many sections of these we
110know what is the enrollment threshold you're marketing it to students say hey we get this new course and what if we just see a very limited interest it's just like any other course that we offer so some courses if we don't get the registration numbers if we set cut points at around 22 to consider classes to be run so if we don't get that much student interest unfortunately that's of course we can't offer these courses are not new in the sense of our students know these courses and they will fill pretty regularly okay yes and do we have all the necessary specialized facilities to hold these courses yes wow awesome yes again we've had these courses for for many years they're different names different names yeah love it thank you and mr carpenter keeps asking
111me to come and audit one of his his classes so he's the cte i just may ceramics enroll there yeah it sounds super cool absolutely thank you okay no other questions i will move in support of the super and the superintendent's recommendation to approve new courses art ab and advanced art ab animation a and b ceramics ab advanced ceramics ab ceramics career technical education a and b advanced cte ceramics a and b studio ceramics which cte a and b as somebody who applied to take ceramics every semester as an undergrad at sfsu and never got in i second yeah he was really wanting that motion okay we had a motion no ceramic blade to grind there we had a motion by maybe you should come visit and take the class with us yeah you might
112need to seconded by trustee druan any discussion on the motion all right i'd ask the clerk if he would please call roll trustee bueno aye trustee vanden heuvel aye myself aye trustee caplanis aye president prusso aye that motion carries unanimously five zero fine job mr polikowski yeah great job okay we're gonna invite we're gonna turn the time over to um miss michelle bichette and she is going to be uh discussing our revised educator effectiveness plan this is the first reading and for discussion only thank you just waiting for mr warner to bring me my clicker thank you mr warner run good evening board of trustees i am pleased to present the revised educator effectiveness block grant expenditure plan for its first reading this plan reflects our district's commitment to ensuring educator quality and effectiveness through
113strategic strategic use of allocated funds education code 41 480 appropriates 1.5 billion in one-time funds to public education agencies across the state these funds are designed for professional learning opportunities for teachers administrators paraprofessionals and other classified staff who work with students the educator effectiveness block grant supports efforts to promote instructional quality and improve educator effectiveness district-wide in compliance with state requirements our district developed and adopted an initial expenditure plan before december 30 2021 this plan was shared at a public meeting on november 16 2021 and adopted by the board of education on december 14 2021 the funds are available for use through the 25 26 fiscal year giving us an opportunity to revisit and refine our plan as needed the educator effectiveness block grant funds may be allocated to any of the following 10 focus
114areas one coaching and mentoring two enhancing instructional effectiveness across all subject areas three strategies for pupil re-engagement four social emotional learning five creating a positive school climate six developing inclusive practices seven supporting effective language acquisition eight professional learning networks nine ethnic studies and 10 early childhood education these focus areas allow flexibility to address our district's specific needs and priorities annual expenditure and data reports must be submitted to the california department of education by september 30th of each year with the final report due in 2026 this ensures accountability and transparency in the use of our of our funds our district was allocated two point nine two two million nine hundred and eighty eight thousand seven hundred and twenty nine dollars in educator effectiveness block grant funds from 2021 to 2024 we have spent nearly one million
115dollars the remaining funds totaling nearly two million dollars will be strategically reallocated for the 24 25 and 25 26 school years to maximize their impact on the attached plan there have been updates two years 21 22 22 23 and 22 3 24 to reflect the funding that has been spent an update to expected expenditures are notated in years 24 25 and 25 26 the updates to the specific focus areas are as follows in focus area one coaching and mentoring there's an additional line item to include the funding of our tv tip coaches and coordinator that support our newest teachers with their induction program in focus area two standards aligned instruction there is an additional line item for history social science professional learning to support our curriculum adoption an additional line item to support professional learning
116in the area of assessment and accountability professional learning in the area of writing and an overall line item to support our instructional leadership team in the major content areas in focus area three re-engagement and accelerated learning there is an addition to the existing line to call out our plc work in math specifically which our data shows as a need in focus area four social emotional learning there is an additional line item of advanced tiered supports that would aid staff with professional learning and suicide prevention in focus area five positive school climate there is an update to the funding expenditures to the leadership capacity line item and additional line item was added for pbis restorative conferencing and partial funding of our psychologist on special assignment in focus area six inclusive practices there is an additional excuse
117me there is an addition of multi-tiered systems of support training coordination of services team or cost training at all sites and the funding of an mtss teacher on special assignment in focus area seven language acquisition there are only updates to the expenditures in focus area eight professional learning networks there was a line item added to the area of strategic planning that will begin in march to co-create our five-year plan in focus area nine ethnic studies there has been no change and finally in focus area 10 early childhood development there have been updates to the funding but no additional line items this evening i'm presenting this revised plan for your review and consideration the plant the plan is informational only at this stage and does not require board action tonight thank you for your attention and
118for your continued commitment to supporting our educators and students and i'm happy to address any questions or comments stephen so on page two we have the i'm just using this as an example the history social science professional learning five thousand dollars so what does that lead to is that paying for mr kolokowski to provide professional learning experiences for the teachers or is it for now what is yeah um that would be for to bring in professional learning or to pay teachers to attend professional learning so it can pay for their subs it can pay for their um hourly pay or it can pay to bring in um professional learning for those now i would say that that is going to be with the adoption with the adoption comes professional learning but the adoption when we
119pay for the actual adoption it doesn't pay for our times hourly and subs correct you're welcome i just want to comment positively on the fact that it looks like some of these expenditures we're going through general fund correct and it looks to be excuse me protected or restricted money that for some reason wasn't getting paid down correct once it was allocated and so um when you see it being expended at this rapid rate are any of these services in danger once this money is expended any time i'm not going to sugarcoat this but anytime you put personnel into funds that have a sunset date there's always the unfortunate decision making that has to happen at the end when that those funds sunset so yes but i am always thinking ahead and always thinking of additional
120funding sources and categorical funds so i just want to assure the board that that's always something that's at the forefront of my of my decision making okay no it's it's a compliment in that you found it and are utilizing it in this manner it's just that organizationally there could be a perception as you see services kind of rise it looks more like a you know like a bubble and a snake going through all of a sudden it's kind of flat and all of a sudden there's just a lot of expenditure going out and then it just drops off unless there's like a safety net or something that's established yeah thanks thank you i was just going to comment i appreciate how you said you're looking ahead so that it's not personnel and yeah i appreciate
121this presentation thank you thank you can i ask about slide number six the district received three million a million was spent and we're going to do another two million so we received the block grant is nearly three million okay we spent one million over the course of four years that's it yeah okay thank you for so noticing that yes so reallocating those two million to be able to spend this year and next year of that which is good i mean if we look at it i'm going to be the glass half full silver lining it's good that it didn't get spent the right way because we wouldn't have it now kind of to help us great timing yeah it's really good timing for us to be able to push some of these things in there
122and then for us to look down the road at some other funding options to be able to pick this up and there are some additional new grants and new things coming out from the state all the time on this because they know this is going to sunset they know we've all used these funds so usually something behind it comes with a new name but it's the same thing essentially so it's good right thank you well but we'll let you keep going with our board policies and i believe we'll be doing this like we did with the will we go through all of the board policies then we can ask questions except i think can we pause just do the a and then and we have a public comment and we have a public comment on
123b so maybe we can get through a first and then we'll take b as a separate entity and that way we can get our public comment perfect okay i pledge it there's a public comment on a not on a no on mine it's on mine okay yeah you're good you can go for it girl okay so tonight the educational services department is presenting updates to four existing board policies and introducing a new board policy i will go briefly over each board policy and then i will entertain questions from the board so our first board policy in line item a board policy zero five one zero school accountability report card or sarc better known as sarc our updates align with a state and federal reporting requirements to ensure transparency in school performance data including student achievement
124school climate and resource allocation in policy b line item b board policy five one three one point nine academic honesty updates clarify definitions of academic dishonesty including ai generated content misuse outline prevention strategies and align disciplinary measures with best practices to promote integrity and fairness in student work line item c board policy six one six two point five student assessment reflects revisions reflect changes in state and national assessment practices emphasizing the use of data to inform instruction address learning recovery and ensure equitable access to academic opportunities line item d board policy six one six three point four student use of technology this update addresses the integration of artificial intelligence or ai cyber security measures student data privacy and responsible technology use ensuring compliance with updated privacy laws and digital learning best practices and finally line
125item e our new board policy six one six two point six use of copyrighted materials this newly proposed board policy provides clear guidance on the ethical and legal use of copyrighted content including digital and online resources to prevent copyright infringement while supporting instructional needs and i'm happy to take questions from our board of trustees we need to make sure we do the public comment first oh sorry that's on mine is on yours i'm glad we're thinking ahead though i'm trying i just didn't want to forget about joanne over there any questions yeah go ahead stephen so i'm interested in passing policies related to ai is one thing but ai is a cultural shift that is going to be life before ai and life after the introduction of ai knowing how it impacts the classroom personally
126i'm just curious about our thoughts about how we can shift both students understanding of ai as well as teachers staff and administrations understanding of ai and i don't really need to answer now i just think it's something that we as an organization and an institution have to take seriously and so that we can prepare students to be successful and it's just a cultural shift and i think that we need to pay attention and be you know it's here so i don't know if you want to respond or just like yep i appreciate those comments it's like i would say with anything that comes out you remember and i'm going to notate something that was in one of these old board policies it speaks of myspace and chat rooms and you remember when those those items
127came out it was it was unnerving as a parent it was unnerving you know as as an educator when when those when those types of accessibility to technology and and social networking came out for students and so it's always been a matter of how are we going to arm and educate our students to be these global citizens and ai now is the new cusp of that and i appreciate that comment and please note we are making plans and really looking at how to provide professional learning for our educators as well as our students i don't want to be draconian ai is not bad and it's not good it's a tool and i think arming our teachers to understand where and how like in my class we talk about where and how to use ai to
128support you and you know thinking about topics for educational research so i think it's just something that we need to focus on because i don't that's it thanks thank you trustee druane if there's no other questions i'd entertain a motion i don't know the question um is there any uh this is not related to governor newsome's request that every district puts some sort of cell phone usage rules in place right this is this has nothing to do with that no yeah good question yeah i have a question is it possible that um that we could do some type of community engagement with parents so that they could understand about this ai stuff that's a great suggestion will be implemented that's a great suggestion we have a lot of avenues to missus doc we're just going
129to say we have livermore learn livermore that's a great idea that we can incorporate some of that into there yeah if there's no other questions president prusso i move to support the superintendent's recommendation and adopt board policy 0510 school board accountability report card board policy 5131.9 academic honesty board policy 6162.5 student assessments board policy 6163.4 student use of technology and new board policy 6162.6 use of copyrighted materials in their entirety okay we have a motion by trustee druane seconded by trustee bueno any discussion on the motion okay i'd ask the clerk to please call roll trustee kaplanis aye myself aye trustee vanden heuvel aye trustee bueno aye president prusso aye those policies just one one comment it's not on not any of the things just kind of in general okay pass unanimously go ahead yes
130yes i'm sorry um on this just one this is going to be a challenge you know to a lot of people you know and some people will never catch up to it but one of the groups i think is going to be disproportionately hit hard is the socioeconomically the sed kind of community english language learners and just whenever we do and do a piece to engage i hope that we actually spend a little bit extra you know that because some people don't even have connectivity yeah you know and then their kids are often they've got ai on their mobile device so it's yeah whatever that is it means it's going to be kind of a kind of a holistic approach where you have to go to a lot of different groups you know clergy uh
131you know the community centers this i was good this is because we have the resources here we do you know i mean we're right in the middle of between the national labs and silicon valley yeah i appreciate that thank you trustee bueno okay now we will move on to uh board policy five one four five point one three and we are going to invite our commenter joanne morrison to come on up we've been waiting all night apparently we're trying to get you up here at the right time i think you know the drill myself i'll let you go thank you and good evening president prusso members of the board superintendent dr gibson and cabinet i wanted to let you know that livermore advocates for public education supports the new board policy 5145.13 but i also
132wanted to remind the board that it might be good to review board policy 1250 which has related provisions that we revised back in 2017 the last time we were in this kind of a situation and it's sad that we find ourselves back here again but it appears now that the keys to our institutions have been handed over to the oligarchs and an unelected unappointed unaccountable billionaire now has access to the federal payments division of the u.s treasury the administration is seeking to destroy the u.s agency for international development at the instance of this oligarch and none of this is normal and it's clear that the department of education is in the line of fire next so federal payments to schools have already been threatened and although that didn't really happen yet they haven't given up
133i'm sure authoritarian regimes always come for the weakest among the population first and who is more vulnerable than our children authoritarians always try to destroy public education and why because an educated populace will always fight for justice and resist dictatorships that's why we must all fight and defend our kids right to a free public education so a lot of people are saying that they feel overwhelmed by the daily onslaught of attacks against our institutions it's like drinking from a fire hose they tell me i tell them that we can't fight all of the battles everywhere but we can each of us focus on one area where we can make a difference and that's the philosophy of lape i say to everyone listening tonight that we can come together as a community to protect our kids
134and their families every one of us could do one small part for example one thing we're doing is trying to inform members of the immigrant community about their legal rights we are working to distribute these little red cards among the spanish-speaking population these are available from livermore indivisible everyone can do something and together we could support the most vulnerable kids and their families in this community thank you that's your time thank you yeah so new board policy 5145.13 as response to immigration enforcement so one thing i want to put a caveat on this is this is not a new policy with csba this was actually published by csba in 2018 and unfortunately was not was not approved or brought forward to the board in 2018 when it was originally created so this is one of
135those policies that as we moved into this situation that we are currently in we went to pull our board policy we went to pull the administrative regulation to see if we needed to do any updates and just to review that and we discovered that we did not approve this prior so it's new tonight to us but it is definitely not new across the state of california i think the most important part of this policy is that it really just outlines what the law states which we are required to support regardless of this policy it's about district staff not soliciting or collecting information of documents regarding citizenship or immigration status of students or family members that is not something we collect currently that no student shall be denied equal rights and opportunities within our schools that
136students have rights to a free and public education regardless of their immigration status that teachers school administrators and other staff shall receive training which we are providing and that and that we report any requests for information to the board in addition to this we are we are putting things in place as we are moving forward so that our school sites know what to do regardless of this policy but our families have very much been vocal with me an email and phone calls requesting you know our policy and what are we going to do and we were waiting to get to this board meeting tonight so that we could if approved by the board hopefully that we can then push this out to our families and show them what our policies are provide them additional resources
137about their rights in addition to this i received a call this evening from um chief young at livermore police department i know that the same group met with him earlier today and he wanted to update update me on that meeting and one of the things that we also plan to include in our push out hopefully tomorrow is their current policy from the police department as well we both felt that that was a much more effective way they are committed to supporting the school district and whatever we need in these situations and then they have their own policy separate that have to do with federal government with people not involved with the school which is which is not our our lane so we're going to let them do that lane and we're going to do our
138lane and then we're going to we're going to do what i call carpooling in the lane that we need to carpool together in and so he and i are very committed to really having that voice together that we are here to protect all of our students and we do have those functions in place if and when this or i'm hopeful when this policy is approved we will then update our administrative regulation to reflect the documentation that we have created that we've already sent out to our school sites within the last week that provide an outline of protocols that they are to follow should they need to get support from us i'm happy to answer any questions i don't really have a question but i think understanding where this comes from is important to understand the
139kind of constitutional foundation so the supreme court decision was plier versus doe which at its root was a school district in texas was trying to force undocumented students to pay tuition in order to attend public school and as was raised the court based its ruling on the 14th amendment that said that they had a constitutional right to attend school no state shall deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws the court found that the school district had no rational basis to deny children a public education based on their integration status given the harm the policy would affect and inflict on the children themselves and society as a whole and the court said by denying these children a basic education the court said we deny them the ability to live within
140the structure of our civic institutions and foreclose any realistic possibility that they will contribute in even the smallest way to the progress of our nation the court also said that holding children accountable for their parents actions quote does not comport with the fundamental conceptions of justice i think it's important to understand the constitutional foundation of children's right to a free and public education and i think that's um i hope that people agree with this policy thank you if there are no any comment go ahead dina i have a question uh or it says teachers school administrators and other staff shall receive training is uh retraining is the training regarding this new policy or how to handle situations yeah the the training will be around what our administrative regulation looks like so what what are the
141steps that they are to take if certain things happen making sure that they understand that we do not collect certain citizens citizenship documents which we do already so a lot of this is just a formality of what we already are doing within our schools but with a new layered situation that we currently have we are starting to provide additional training um specifically i mean i'll just say that specifically if ice agents were to show up on our campuses what are they to do our site our office staff and our principals and our vice principals really want to be prepared if that were to happen and so um miss dawson and i've worked uh this last week late last week and early this week to put together a step-by-step guide for them and i realize that
142it's a difficult situation i watched that uh csba offered that legal kind of podcast or whatever it was that they put on and it's a lot of their advice it i don't want to say that uh it lacked direction but it was it almost seemed kind of somewhat futile like it's it's very difficult for especially someone at the layman's level to fly in the face of a federal agent it just so it's i know it's a very difficult situation and in that circumstance um pushes a lot of fear in a lot of people you know that you know that and anxiety and stuff so i mean do we have anything in place like welfare checks in terms of like if kids just don't show up to school and we have reasonable beliefs that maybe something
143happened or maybe they're not coming to school for a reason i know as maybe that's not customary but is there something that we do to kind of follow up on that yes we do we have our um child welfare and attendance staff that um are attendance as well as they're out in the community cwas yeah so that those particular staff members are are out and about regularly we've had a lot of staff reach out specifically our teachers um who are just fearful because they're hearing it every day from their students of their fear and so um i know that they are the eyes and ears on the ground for us and so we have those protocols in place and and through our psychologists and you know some of the aid are we gonna have we
144offered or do we plan on offering any type of services for some of these kids i mean i i don't want to say i was shocked but i was actually a little taken back when this happened last time um i was part of a little group and it was the police chief and a representative from congressman swalwell's office and superintendent and we went and we met with some of the kids um and some of them were you know hey i can't come i'm not coming to school and it was it was a it was real difficult and and it's just um that psychological side just as an aid and just trying to help and you know maybe if they have to do some stuff promote i mean whatever it is it just because you really
145feel for kids because they really don't have a choice they're just they're just here they're minors correct and i i think that's where i also in addition to feeling for our students our families i really feel for our staff who are the ones really carrying the weight every day as they're seeing the students faces come in the door and they're seeing that fear and students are expressing that fear so um unlike last time we now have our wellness centers um which i think is a huge added benefit um onto our school campuses that every student i mean anytime you go into a wellness center on a campus it is they're packed um and then any school site without a wellness center um we will make sure that staff do consistent check-ins at those school sites
146um the principals and the and the teachers are doing a really great job of just keeping that pulse and then they're reaching out directly to us if there's anything that just is uneasy for them that they need additional support with um i think it's really important that we just continue to provide to our families publicly that these are the resources just over and over and consistently state that you know we are here to support our students and to keep them safe and um and i i agree when if federal agents were to show up it's a it's a different ball game but we do have specific things per our legal counsel that i am to ask for um and it's a it's a process that i go through with them if they were to show
147up and depending on their answers will depending will depend on on what happens from that point so um i have those those directives from legal counsel so that we are legally compliant but also making sure that we are forcing those documents to be presented prior to um anything else happening do we have do you have a confidence that we're able to reach um the more marginalized people in our community especially those who do not speak english or do not have access to you know to easy um internet access that they have this message that these parents especially know um what they can expect from us yes we do um we have a specifically at a couple of our sites that have the higher numbers of of those particular families have great outreach and and they've
148been having meetings with their parents they've been having one-on-one meetings on a consistent basis very regular um just giving that reassurance and so um every school site's a little different depending on you know the students and the families that they serve and those principals are are really doing a remarkable remarkable job of that reassuring i really just want to say i'm very very glad that we as a board and as a district are taking these steps and being really forward about that um as an immigrant who also was between you know having the right papers for quite a while i never had to worry about that either because this is a policy specifically targeting marginalized groups people with that look different from me and so i'm really glad that we're saying out loud we are
149behind you you're part of this community and uh we'll we'll be here to to keep you safe yes 100 percent i'd entertain a motion president pruso i move to support the superintendent's recommendation and improve the new board policy 5145.13 response to immigration enforcement i second we have a motion by trustee druan and seconded by trustee vanden heuvel any discussion on the motion i ask the clerk to take roll trustee vanden heuvel aye trustee capuanis aye myself aye president prusa aye that motion carries unanimously five zero thank you so much in the next um day or two um miss dawson and i will put together an additional document that we will send out that will include this policy it'll include some of our administrative regulations as well as resources and we will um add the policy
150from livermore police department as well okay we're going to move on to our consent items and i believe we have six i don't even know five six but one does not have an item on it we always i always leave the out of state field trips on even if there isn't anything because sometimes it'll be the day of the board meeting somebody panics because they forgot to do it in their trips next week okay so i just always leave it and then if there's nothing we just say there's nothing on there so just so you know that's why it's on there with nothing because it's happened multiple times in my 10 years as superintendent poor teachers all right does any board member wish to discuss it discuss any of these if not i'd entertain motion
151to have them moved in their entirety president prusa i move to approve consent items one through five in their entirety i second we have a motion by trustee druan and seconded by trustee capuanis any discussion on the motion i'd ask the clerk to take roll trustee vanden heuvel i myself i trustee capuanis i trustee bueno president prusa i that motion carries unanimously five zero okay we're going to move on to our board reports we'll start with trustee bueno thank you okay uh a couple things i just attended and one of them because we talked about a little bit tonight was the ib orientation over at granada high school and i gotta say it was the they had it in the theater room and it was packed and so maybe mr caribou and um i think
152it's uh summer were they've done a good job maybe recruiting it that was i think it was i think the group was maybe eighth and ninth graders or something it's quite a good quite a good showing and uh it is risky when you put kids out there and kids did largely did some of the presentation about six of them you know and so um yeah so we're pretty excited about you know showing off there's the the the program there are some pretty good questions asked um so we'll see if it grows um i know that uh just from talking to some of the folks over there it did when it was taken away uh just momentarily uh it did send a little shock wave so i'm glad to see that it hasn't been a lag
153in terms of lack of attendance so we'll have to see what they do to grow it um it also was able to go and mr krolikowski was putting uh with a whole team of folks math counts over at granada and so that's always uh that that's a big program and uh it's fun to watch that and watch the folks that run it and watch how the kids compete it's a dead silent room literally you could hear a pin drop when they say go um one little girl kind of had a little emotional kind of breakdown because i think she was a couple minutes late or something mr krolikowski did an outstanding job of calming her down getting her inside she made the top 10 oh i'm sure she did she was she was she was
154very high strong she was like five yeah yeah yeah so so i i like watching the beginning i just i just like watching all the kids prep how they interact and uh so it's a really good event and i appreciate that the district does that oh and my just my my last thing is just it's the last is yeah one more thing not colombo it's just it for those who might be watching it's it's a difficult time i mean there's like every day when information i mean the stuff that's coming at us through the news is just it's it's almost incredible um whatever your political affiliation is there's going to be people that might be marginalized there's people that are can't wait to you know act on things um but it's just a matter of
155tolerance and being kind that's not a political persuasion just being kind to people being tolerant uh taking a little couple more minutes um being civil those things that's what builds a good community and this is a community we all have to live together we're not living in the middle of the serengeti all on our own and it's you know dog eat dog or something it's not that we're in a society and uh we have to be good to each other even if we disagree and completely disagree we still have neighbors and they might be completely opposite from us and kids tend to get caught in the cannon fodder of of it all and that's our only responsibility here is to provide for the kids of this city so you want to make sure those kids
156are doing well and we as adults set good examples and that we're civil and that we're kind to one another we can still be critical but um i'd just like to say you know outward to the community thanks trustee caponis okay um i've had the pleasure of visiting different school sites and meeting with different administrators staff teachers um students parents and members of the community um i was able to make it over to croci earlier um last month um for a very competitive spelling bee i think it went 20 over 25 rounds um and then i went to junction for their zumba glow night fundraiser um i was able to visit maryland um for a special needs parent meeting which is very informative to me as well as touring the campus and um looking at
157the new developments that they were able to um they're almost completed it's like in the works um but it was nice to go visit over there and see um how the new classrooms will help facilitate the growing enrollment over there and of course their um stem um academy and then also um i'm very excited to see what's going to become over um at maryland for their future students um and then also um between meetings at the do office i was able to um attend the math task force training at livermore high school um not only did i appreciate the training that was going on but i also got to participate in the live um lessons and i got to brush up on my exponents and my congruent triangles um so that was a lot of
158fun to be alongside the students and to experience um what that is like and i think that's it um aside from this i was able to complete 25 hours of continued education for my professional license um and enroll in the csba um courses as well and i started two hours of that last night so in the governance yeah masters of governance that all right she's going to be able to teach us now i know yeah yeah i just want to have a better understanding on how to serve our community and of course this role yeah good job yeah that's great thank you uh trustee vanden heuvel i also went to the spelling bee at croche and you know 28 rounds and um i was out at the first word so just so you know the
159word i did it in my head you know the word was bolts the mechanic tightened the bolts b o l t bolts no there's an s at the end so anyway it's just terrible so i told my wife it's because it's my second language she loves that when i say that she's like stop saying that so dumb uh the math task force at lhs was was awesome so cool to see the collaboration between teachers from all the different sites and mr kolokowski did a great job there um here's something new i've i never did this but i was invited as a school board member to um attend the open house at the new masjid of the islamic center of livemore and it was amazing so cool to have these other neighbors who want to participate
160in in in in being community together and it was really really cool never done anything like that i was really nervous that i was going to do something wrong but i didn't so um i went to the rotary of livermore valley they have a meeting where they gave grants to all these teachers who did are doing really cool initiatives really cool programs of course i'm thinking why aren't we paying for that particular you know whiteboard but we'll talk about that later now it was really really cool i love how the community comes together and says hey we're we're gonna help you we're gonna bless you we're gonna uh help your job get easier so it was really cool um i was also excited to be part of the approval of the new cornerstone housing project
161north of 580 uh they're going to build 253 housing unit units including 114 affordable homes so that's gonna speaking of ada y'all we're gonna like a lot of kids there in that community that we're going to add affordable homes will allow young families to move to livemore so i'm really excited about that thank you also to several staff members who had one-on-one meetings with me where i they just pulled the curtain back on all the work that they're doing it was really appreciated that was me i attended my first meeting of tri-valley salpa with assistant superintendent minky um so our salpa just so you know is comprised of and collaboratively supported by senol glenn unified school district pleasant and unified school district dublin unified school district us mountain house elementary school district in alameda county
162schools which i thought it was just dublin pleasant and us but i'm learning a lot about salpa and it's going to continue to happen um let's see suppose manatee is complex but one way to think about it is providing pooled special education resources so that we don't have to hire as many contract specialists that's a very robust oversimplification but uh laura walker walker from pleasant and unified school district uh was elected the chair and i was elected the vice chair yeah first meeting and you look like uh chair material um i also attended the eighth grade um oh i also attended the crochet spelling bean i also would have gone out in the first round i think it's sobering to be in there to think about all of the different types of intelligences and uh
163trustee vannon who will inform me that's uh uh and i didn't think spelling contests are like you know i think everybody does it's clearly not the case because some languages are completely phonetic it would be a waste of time to have a spelling be where it's completely um anyways um i also attended the eighth grade transition to high school webinar hosted by livermore learns and our community coordinator of community engagement say that three times fast michelle dawson a wonderful job to the facilitators director of secondary education jason karlakowski principals roxanne muhammad and clark conover and school counselors i'm going to mispronounce her name joni and edris joni theron and edris waziri um the video is uploaded to livermore learns webpage and it includes a version translated into spanish so if you didn't make it you
164can go check it out it was informative um and the next livermore learns is february 11th at seven on the topic of coping with divorce so lastly i have heard um a tremendous amount of anxiety confusion and tension from community members as well as teachers about the impact of federal government policies and what they may have on our students in this body as uh this body's ability to make local decisions for our own goods so just to kind of speak to that point i'll reiterate what california state superintendent of schools tony thurman said quote in california all still means all while the trump education department announced that they will no longer protect all students from discrimination the california department of education still has your back california law which is unaffected by recent changes to federal
165policy continues to provide safeguards against discrimination and harassment based on gender gender expression gender identity and sexual orientation while federal guidance devolves our commute commitment to safeguarding the rights of all students persists to any students families and educators who may be fearful today in california schools are still a safe place to learn and play thank you thank you steven like i've been to many of the same events with trustee druane at the joe mitchell ivy um meeting forgot to mention uh i've been to two math task force events uh one of them was the live lesson day at livermore high school and and then the other one was regular math task force here at the district office we had the tri valley rop board meeting um last week and a big topic there big surprise
166everywhere else was was also about the budget um our teachers there have a there's a 13 pay gap there between our rop teachers and our district teachers so we're trying to find ways ways to close that gap um luckily rop continues to receive lots of grant funding due to julie and susan's hard work that will make it possible for us to close those gaps without incurring additional costs for our three districts currently so i think that was a good sign and we're on the right track there um i just wanted to mention about the math task force live lesson day at livermore high school that lunch and breakfast was provided by the livermore high school culinary class and it was amazing yeah it was really good um and then also just like trustee bueno i
167was able to attend math counts he went to the beginning and i was there at the end it was also very exciting um event to see all of our middle school students there competing the our mathletes um they were so great so cute it is our 29th year doing math counts which was pretty exciting we'll do something special next year i think and then lastly the elementary spelling the elementary spelling bee district spelling bee was also uh last week here at the district office and it was very exciting i don't know how many rounds i came i come as close to the end as i could possibly manage it is a hazing event for our new district board trustees we don't tell you how long they're going to be we just say come at the
168beginning and then four hours later you're still there so um it was just super great and the kids are amazing and yes the spelling is what they do with the every time they spell i go oh they got that wrong and then no they got it right i got it wrong so i think i know how to spell but i do not so anyway it was really great and um just as everyone else has mentioned i just wanted to say i know i think i think trustee bueno was on the board when we had the resolution for all kids are our kids and i think that still stands and it's something that um we as a community we all feel so appreciate uh all the work that's been done and and being done to help
169our community to um find some peace in this sort of turbulent time so i'm going to turn that time over to our superintendent for her report so a couple things number one um i just want to update the board on our board policies you are going to be in and i'm looking at cabinet because we're all just a little underwater right now when it comes to board policies um we have determined i'm looking at miss pichette because this is her department but i think we are 318 i knew she'd know the exact number policies behind so we are going to strategically roll these out to you um uh so each board packet you're going to see board policies so what we're going to do is we're going to be somewhat strategic and some of them
170are just going to be let's get these done and as things happen among cabinet and we have conversations anytime we have a discussion we are going to pull board policy right in that discussion just to see if that policy has been updated hence some of these tonight and those will become our immediate ones that go on board packet and then if we have room so i would anticipate um in order for us to do this in a timely fashion if our board packet is smaller we're going to add more policy so if we only have a couple action items you might see 20 policies i greatly apologize in advance i do appreciate sorry to interrupt but the way that you've been setting up so you can look at the edited all the edited versions that's
171really okay good i was that was just going to ask that so when you look in there if it's new it's all going to just be blue it's just the one policy you can read through that the other one because sometimes it's just a few words it might be an edco change is they're very minor changes but our goal in the next six months is to get caught up on 318 policies so we will start adding those into every single board packet that we have so just so you know i just wanted to give you a heads up so you're not all of a sudden thinking like why are we being bombarded with board policies i just want to let you know that's where we are yes so not a mystery just a disappointment that's
172all not in you yes we we agree so what let me just explain really quickly since we have two new board members and then just for the public so what happens is california school boards association they have attorneys and people who write board policies and they provide us with policy based on ed code they are constantly monitoring these policies so what happens is we have our online system which is the same system that we now use for our board packets which is one of the reasons we wanted to move to this system because then our board policies actually talk directly to our board packets so everything is seamless so in the board policies we actually now we receive the updates like we were supposed to be getting so all the time so every month these
173are from csba these are the board policy updates they give us a paragraph overview of what those are what the contents may be and then it triggers us to say okay now we need to go now what we're going to be doing is we're going to be assigning them to an assistant superintendent or myself depending on what the topic is and then we are responsible for reviewing that policy and determining is it something that's really basic that we can put on a packet or is it something that might be controversial that we need to pull the policy committee together so that policy committee still will happen but we don't have time for the policy committee to go through 318 policies when some of them are just very stagnant changes but the ones that are very
174much things that that we need input on as we move forward we will make sure that we pull that policy committee together what a concern that i have yes and that's part of my disappointment is that i openly publicly asked why we weren't doing policies and we just didn't do policies for a couple years and we did a couple but we didn't we were way behind and because the the flow of policies should always be stopped yeah and we knew what it was like for my first eight years on the board and so my concern is is that that there's not even a public perception that because we're backlogged that policies come running through and so i appreciate when you're putting them through strike through underline and if there's a notation in the policy that
175says many of the policies when um mr villa he used to do that and he would bring them on and what we came to as a policy on policies was that some of them are just boilerplate as you've said it's just cspa legal requirement this is the thing we're simply adopting it to be in legal compliance yes some were amended a bit and those sometimes are the ones you know when you get into some issues that publicly might but it's on those that if we could have just some maybe hypersensitivity yes well that's where we'll pull the policy committee together yeah and some of them there are it's it's rare but it happens from time to time where they give us an option for an a or b sometimes the a or b 100 makes
176sense and sometimes hold on making sure my computer is not going to die okay that was a little fearful because my notes are on my computer sometimes those policies are very simple it depends on the type of school district you are whether you choose a or b and there are a few i can think of one in my career that i had to manage at a board meeting that was very controversial over a or b so those are the ones that we will absolutely make sure that we are hypersensitive about that we take to a policy committee we get the feedback from that group we might do two readings on those but the rest of them that are the boilerplate we'll we'll put those in we will always have the edited and the clean version
177ready to go and every single one unless it's a new policy may i ask just a maybe a favor on that when you're going through that process maybe not assembling a whole committee but we do have board reps that have been on that historically steven is on it yes yeah steven's currently assigned to that yeah it just would it be too cumbersome to at least you know even if it's just a not going through and mulling over it but it's part of that a or b selection could that get in front you know if you're picking number you know if it's a or b well it's usually if you're like a unified school district a joint unified school district or an elementary so those that's those that's what i mean it's a great question that's
178what i mean by the a or b usually it's clear which one we choose but the ones where it's not clear we're definitely going to send that probably to trust edrew and and say look this over we probably should pull our policy committee together what do you think and then we'll get that feedback and then we'll we can pause that and then move around that one we can drive around it and then bring that to the board at a later day after the policy committee can come together i i really think when we looked at this list um that a lot of these policies are just really boilerplate a lot of them are go back some of them to 2018 and since then yeah so i just wanted to give you that update just so
179that you knew exactly when you're getting a plethora of them and then once we catch up then it's just a constant small flow then it's just three four five at every board meeting usually and sometimes we don't have any because they skip a month or whatever okay oh real quick when i was at csba in december i actually attended the policy um course and they were saying that it's actually very common to have a bunch of policies for districts that have not been updated is that true to your experience i think if yes i think so um if you are if you don't use this online assembly program for your board policies it's very easy to get behind yeah there are some districts that still manually do their board policies i don't even know how
180you'd keep up the the board policies have expanded exponentially in the last 10 years since i've been a superintendent so without assembly i don't i don't think districts can function we've had the assembly policies and i don't i don't have the answer for why we don't have them and i just want to look forward and fix it so that we are compliant with our board policies i don't i'm not one that likes to be behind on policies because the minute you need one tonight's perfect example when you need one and it's not approved it's like then you have to wait okay will we make it a practice because there was a time when we did when a board policy and there's the ap and the bps the board policy ar ar admin when sometimes they
181dovetail they support one another they speak to the same thing so that they're both coming up at the same speed so the ar is our internal document the board has no um we the board approves your policy and then we write the administrative regulation that says so you're the how or the what so so so how does the policy um be happen and you know how is it in the being and then we write the what and how we're going to um make that go forward you have a great question and the ars we are changing all the time when we're even now we've changed some since we got here because they just we go in and go well what does our air say and we read it and be like well this isn't up
182to date so then we go in and change it to our current practices that were practices that we had before we got here and miss dawson uses those often to send those out to staff to parents to community members whatever the case may be for policy revision yeah so that was one um just a reminder to our community and to the board that we have our by trustee area approval from our county committee next tuesday february 11th at 6 30 p.m here in our boardroom so what happens with that is the county board sits in our boardroom at our dais as if they and they hold their actual county meeting here and we are in the audience which is fantastic both myself our legal counsel and doug johnson and miss dawson will do our presentation
183of all the things that we did to get us to that point they have a chance to ask questions we present our recommendation for the final map and then they vote for the formal approval so that will be next tuesday one of my favorite events that i got to attend since our last board meeting was the reclassification ceremony for our english learners at granada high school and it was such an amazing moment i want to say i should have pulled up the picture i want to say there were probably 15 or more students with their parents both their moms and dads were there and just the the moment of pride for them as these students have achieved just such a great accomplishment in being english language proficient and i really want to give a shout
184out to martha garcia who is the teacher there who who really supports those families and those students and there were multiple languages that were spoken with the students it wasn't just one language but it was such a wonderful event and i really thank mr conover for inviting me to attend i got to shake all their hands and hand them their certificates and and just really thank their parents for their support because it was clear their parents were very proud of them the ibb training as was already mentioned was a great success we're really excited to move in that direction with our bargaining units and i just really appreciate you know these budget times are not easy i had a meeting today with our neighboring superintendents both from pleasantin and dublin and we had some great
185conversations just of where we all are and just the challenges that we're facing and if it's not the budget then it's the everyday whiplash that we're currently experiencing in the last 14 days it's been 14 days and every day is something new that is just whiplash for us so we've kind of gotten to the point now where i just don't pay attention and i figure at some point because we have work to do still and i want our staff to really focus on the work that we need to do and as we need to know and need to pivot because something truly is going to be implemented then we will go there but right now it's about the safety and the care for our students and the work that we are here to do for
186them and our staff and really moving the needle for everyone and so you know 14 days and and we'll just keep plugging along and see what tomorrow brings we do know that the education committee meets tomorrow in washington dc so i'm just gonna eat my popcorn at lunch and see what they what they tell us i also attended math counts i know emily was there and michelle was there as well and it was just such a fun event it was obviously new to me i've never experienced math counts and oh my gosh some of those kids can i mean the answer is red and they are hitting their butt i'm thinking it would take me like three minutes i mean clearly i'm not a math person in that way just the way their brains work
187it was it was a really phenomenal moment and thank you to mr kolokowski for being the mc because he he really did a great job so he has a good fan base uh with the students who have been there for multiple years mr mr math counts yeah so he was he was quite the celebrity with students who wanted photos with him so um but that was a real highlight perhaps a hat or shirt that said mr math counts i would well i have a feeling that something like that might appear at some point in his life in our building we'll just leave it at that um but those those were the the significant events that i attended this last week this these last few weeks so um and i think that's it like oh i
188was just going to finish really quick about the budget stuff that you know i really appreciate our union reps and their leadership and support we sit for hours and have conversations about every single thing that's on these sheets the ones that come out i know you've seen three versions behind the scenes i think there's probably 318 versions of the same document from each meeting um and it's not easy it's not easy when people are involved it's not easy when students are involved and um you know we are really committed to to fixing the situation so we don't get back in the situation in the future so thank you to kirstie and her team and to mayme and her team and to amy and her team so that's all i have okay thank you um we
189have a special board meeting next thursday on february 13th at 9 30 a.m here in the district office and then our next regularly scheduled board meeting will be held tuesday february 18th here at 7 p.m we'll adjourn our meeting now at 9 57 p.m