CorpusRecord 40065

1.16.25 Special Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Vimeo / Livermore Schools
Date
2025-01-17
Location
Alameda County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
19,731 words · about 110 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Good morning, everyone. We're going to begin our board meeting. It's 931 a.m. Is our special board workshop and We will we will begin with the flag salute. I'd like to ask mr. Jason Kroolikowski if he could please lead us in the flag salutes I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God Indivisible with liberty and justice for all Thank you As I stated before this is a special board meeting Board workshop of the Board of Education for Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District Where the primary focus is the education of students of this district during the Okay, I believe that we can do comments on agenda items only So it looks like we don't have any comment cards anyway, but

002just for everyone to know if you have Comments for agenda items, please fill out a blue card and we'll put you in that in that time And with that we're gonna move on to our first We have our school site reports. We're very excited today to have our high schools here and We are going to invite mr. Conover the principal of Granada High School to please come up and we will put him out of his misery and Just a reminder to the board members. This is a more casual meeting So if you have questions throughout just feel free to jump in and and ask questions Yeah, I just want to while mr. Conover is getting set up over here that mr. Bueno is not with us today Because he his family just welcomed a brand

003new baby girl So he is off being grandpa this morning getting to see her for the first time. So many congratulations to Mr. Bueno and his family and we've asked him to send lots of pics. Yeah, okay Good morning board president Prusso members of the board superintendent Gibson cabinet and community My name is Clark Conver and the proud principal of Granada High School We move the microphone just a little closer. Sorry. I'm sorry. It's okay. There we go I'm gonna show you the tell you a little about Granada. This is our demographics I've been at Granada for 26 years and our demographics are becoming more diverse. We find strength in that This last year we held our first Cultural cell of multicultural celebration that was student driven and it was great. Here's our dashboard the

004blue and greens are areas of strength where the orange and yellows are areas of her concerned and focus If you just by looking at this you can tell we have a low suspension rate and a high graduation rate Some of the areas that we're working on is our math and our ELA, but we'll talk more about that in the presentation This next slide compares Granada High School to other schools Which are similar makeup based on size demographics, socioeconomics Same thing with the dashboard the blue and the green are areas of strength Where the orange and yellow are areas of concerns The night this gives us a chance to kind of compare apples to apples What I've done with this slide here I've it's given me the chance of reached out to other schools that have

005been Similar to Granada that are succeeding in some areas and I'm able to connect with the principals To see what they're doing to help student achievement. So I've got some conversations going This our school board school board school success data I'll go over it real quick. We Increased a little bit in our ELA scores our math efficiency dipped Well, we always have a pretty high ABC grades in our core classes that continue to rise a little bit our Attendance dipped a little bit, but it's still pretty high. We're over the 94 percentile We keep encouraging students to come to school Our UCA to G completion Went down a little bit and This one, I think might we're encouraging our kids to complete our A to G completion rate One of our challenges we have such

006a great community college. We have about Anywhere from 35 percent or 40 percent of our seniors continue to go on to Las Vecitas College. So they think hey Why should I not take why should I take a more rigorous path if I'm gonna end up at Las Vecitas anyways? So we're having conversations with their counselors. We're having one-on-one conversations To kind of encourage them to keep taking those challenging classes continuing our Percent of our English learners progressing at least one LPAC level went up to four percent Percentage of our ninth graders proficient on the algebra one final was a large increase 22 percentage increase Our suspension rates dipped a little bit, which is great and our college and career readiness And our college and career readiness Went to six point two percent Increase it was

007sixty two point eight percent, but it was an increase And now this is the slide that kind of actually gives me some sleepless nights is all these are our data for ELS and our students with disabilities and Their attendance level is great. You can see the 94 percentile and the 93 percentile. So we've got them at school Come to school they want to be at school But it's just we need to figure out how we can do better. These are some of our most Vulnerable students and so we're giving them Supports we've done some PDs. In fact, we just had a PD with our staff yesterday about some supports They can do with their special ed students earlier in the year. We had our PD about some strategies with our EL students We have three

008teachers working with their EL classes we have them They're all the same class period. So the students FC Progress they can move from one class to the other This is our suspension rate. You can see over between 2022 23 to 23 24 our suspension rate went down so we just finished our first semester and If things stay on pace we'll have about a 2% suspension rate for this year. Hopefully it's a little lower. I Contribute this to our PBIS emphasizing connections with the students in the school building staff and student relationships and a restorative approach to discipline this next slide demonstrates our The participation we have at Granada Last year we had about 57% of our students participate in some sort of team at Granada Athletics team This year we're at 30% but that doesn't

009include our winter or spring athletes So I think we'll be right back up there at 57. Hopefully a little higher But our students at Granada we emphasize getting involved with the school from athletics to dance to band a choir to orchestra Leadership theater. We have a lot of options for our students We have a lot of options for our students things we'd like to I'd like to point out and celebrate A high level of our Granada high school graduates enrolled in post-secondary education Granada high school produced 10 national merit scholarship finalists and nine commended scholars We have approximately 1,100 ap exams and 218 ib exams have been registered for this year We had a successful wasp accreditation in the fall We were awarded the golden state planning pathway grant This will help with some of

010our career pathways including biotech and foods We have over 65 student-run clubs on campus Of the eight athletic teams offered at Granada high school in the fall This year six were represented in the north coast section championships go matadors And then in the spring of 2024 our baseball team won the state championship And we hope to have another run this year my priorities for the school Increased math achievement my goal is to increase the percentage of students scoring standard met or exceeded mathematics to 50 That'd be up three percent from this year in this past year in order to do this We hope to encourage students to utilize our ace period and our study lab Uh, we hope to identify struggling students and provide interventions as such as tutoring math labs and co-taught classes to

011address the gaps To inform students and parents have promote and promote outside support such as tutor.com In-person tutoring at las recitas college and our livermore public library And we also have professional development through a mass task force And our math finals data review The second priority is our english learner achievement Goal is to increase the percentage of english learners that are reclassified to 10 percent Um In order to do this, we encourage students to utilize our academic support enrichment program and our study lab During ace to provide targeted intervention for students in english provide english learner support throughout our targeted eld software Increase attention to the identification of our el students to all staff members And ongoing professional development to support our english learners Are there any questions comments? Hello, mr. Conner great presentation love

012it again, just uh Something jumped out of me. Um Regarding uh, you know the the math scores to 10 percent is it or? Upping that by 10 percent or getting all the way to 50 percent. That's the that's the actual number there um That that seems low to me, but how does that compare to schools around us? um, so because it's we're talking about batches really being proficient and so What this number says that less than 50 percent of our students? are Are not proficient More than 50 percent of our students are not proficient in math Yeah, and so are the cast is given to our junior Our juniors um students and so We're working on there. It's around as if I go to excuse me here Right here Math is if you look across

013the state, it's a challenging when i've talked to principals there's challenges that they're doing that other Schools are experiencing as well What we're doing to address it is so like right now we have a study lab after and we're experimenting with right now We have a teacher Like we have a math class and we have a teacher kind of on call so to speak And if students are struggling in one area With one subject those kids are getting sent to the other teacher's classroom to help build those gaps around us if you can see a lot of Schools are having the same challenges we are and so of these actions that you that you put on the slide, which ones are kind of new ones because You know, we're going to try something new to

014up these scores Yeah, um, you know what the the study lab is new this year, which is after school. We've had In the past our wednesdays are ace day typically in the past and students go there But now we have our study lab is kind of basically tutoring every day after school There's somebody available for him. This kind of math support is new as well And also our district is doing work on the math task force where they're looking at The re they revamped the math the alzheimer one final and they're doing that with all the classes And they're looking at the data and seeing what where we're where we're struggling with teaching with subjects So those are all new do do students attend that after school? Not all not with athletics and all those

015things, you know Our coaches are really good about saying hey if you want to go get help get help But we we do have a challenge of getting kids there all the time, but there are some that take advantage of it, especially When parents know about it, they'll try to get them in there But I would like to have more of them attend Yeah, because I think field math is that one of the subjects where if you get a little bit behind Sure It becomes almost it feels impossible, you know, and we're not super good As schools are you know at helping students, we just don't have the resources or the staff to catch somebody up so um Yeah, I i'm glad that you're doing that but I I just i'm really concerned about that

016Yeah in our you know what our teachers i'm fortunate to have great teachers at granada high school and If you go down our math hall during lunch You'll see many of our teachers giving up time to have students go in and help them during there as well so And then um, I saw the the club involvement. How many students? Do you keep track of that? Even is there probably not attendance taken in a club? No, we we have Clubs like it's on our website. Look we have clubs from everything from interact club to Um, I think to the harry potter club to the dungeons and dragons clubs if there's an interest center for students They have the ability in the vehicle to start a club So yeah, but you don't have I don't know how

017many kids are involved with them But it's pretty it's pretty active when we do our club rush in the fall It's it's a busy time. Okay is a busy time. That's exciting And then I noticed that the the involvement in theater program keeps dropping off over the last couple years Is there a reason for that? It's um, no, you know what we I don't know that we're trying to our theater teacher Is drama teacher is trying to do some things different and i'll be honest i've been this my third year as a principal and when I went to the I went to the the show and I had a great time. The kids were excited I was excited to be there and they did a presentation that um I didn't understand, you know, I and

018I told them afterwards. I said hey, I this is great the kids are happy but I don't get it like I and so they've done now they're bringing kind of more mainstream Shows like last year they clue the musical and it was sold out this year. They did the outsider They're doing the outsiders in the spring. They did a christmas story And so I think more kids are seeing it and hopefully those numbers build Great. Thank you. I went to a christmas story. It was really cute. Yeah Yeah Thanks for the presentation appreciate it Seems to be lots of awesome things happening at granada I'm curious about the switch to the semester system and wanted to give you a space to kind of talk about students Faculty staff and admins kind of perspective of the

019the switch over and now that we're halfway we're in semester two Yeah, you know what? I think at the beginning of the year there were some there were some bumps Um trying to fit everything in and just I think changes can always be difficult um There's some positives and negatives. I like that our Students have the same teacher. There's more continuity with there I know with coming from the trimester which was Great for certain things too, but there was gaps like with math for instance, I used to teach math A student could have trimester one math math during trimester one nothing trimester two and the math again trimester three And and that was a challenge. So with now it's straight across. I think next year's schedule will work even better because There's some weeks with

020this strat with this schedule our teachers only see the students Uh two days a week where next year they're seeing them four days a week And I think the more contact between student and teacher the better thanks, and then secondly, um, I know that creating a culture of uh positivity and inclusivity was a focus for granada both Your team as well as students and teachers on campus um You know, there's a focus on stamping out hate speech and uh, so I was just wondering How's that going? Are there any you know, uh Benefits from from that action now that we're a few years down the line from you know, those uh initiatives you know what I think it's a constant mat message, but if and I'd have to look and I can tell you just

021The data I haven't it doesn't seem like i've gotten as many usually if there's hate speech or Some kind of graffiti that i'll get notified right away And I haven't had It's been very minimal this year. So hopefully it's working good, and then lastly I share your area of concern regarding the a through g requirements for um, uh el students and uh students with special needs and I think that that's something that's Being multilingual does not mean that you are deficient, you know and I think that that's something that you know, we need to make as as a system and a District need to look carefully at because You know just because you speak multiple multiple languages doesn't mean that you can't but You know They're even having the label english language learner has a

022deficit orientation to it So I think that's not really a question here just appreciate the the focus on that and recognizing that this is something that's You and your team need to focus on so thanks so much Good morning. Thank you for your presentation and congratulations on All the achievements you guys have been making Even the baseball win last year. That was pretty exciting. I was following it pretty close I did have a question I had a bunch actually and then i'm learning this new system and they all got deleted but As far as when you guys were talking about attendance And then you showed the special education attendance When you showed the general number is that including the special education or Yes, so if we go back to Let me find it in here

023the first scoreboard to this one, so if you look at the Ninety-four point eight three percent attendance last year. That's our whole student body and then this one is just Those students identified as either english learners or students with disability, right? So, um, was there any follow-up as to why it's been a drop? Anything you can speak to you know, you know what? Um That's a good question. You know what? I don't I'd have to look into that and figure that out. But I know We're encouraging our kids to come to school through Clubs athletics events on campus I know our leadership classes started there because looking at our data For whatever reason kids kind of get families have kids get sick on fridays. I don't know why but it happens and um We've started

024doing friday lunch activities and to try to increase our attendance on fridays. So oh good. Okay. Um Yeah, because I was wondering If it was the change in the trimester to semester schedule of kids just thought they had a little bit more free time or If it has anything to do with like the mental health at your school, how is the wellness centers being utilized? Do you? Have any feedback on that? Yeah, so we have a Well, um wellness center at granada high school that we're Developing we're actually in the way We're hoping to have one that we we're moving location to a larger location on campus Did more space more welcoming? being utilized so We do have needs that we have some students that with mental health. We have some supports there In place

025for okay Awesome. Thank you Thank you clark for coming. It's great to see what's happening at granada I have a couple of questions So when I was when we were you kind of briefly touched on the a3g completion And It kind of got me thinking about How we look at that number because as you said we're not going to ever probably or need to or want even to have 100 of our students completing a3g if some of them are going to community college like you said or into careers, so I guess my question is this probably isn't just you but in general How do we look at that number because I mean? Right, does that make sense? I don't know if i'm making sense to my question I mean, I think it's important. I'm not

026saying it's not important but as far as What do we what do we think that should be or does? You don't know. Yeah, you know, we're not being very articulate with this question. I think with the a2g completion I and I Could have had students in my office saying hey, i'm my plan is to go to A community college so I don't need to be Right a2g completion and I but I would I advise the students is is hey Correct. You don't need that to go to community college However, when you get to community colleges, you're going to need to take classes That are the you can take the same classes here So when you get to community college, you're prepared or even overly apparent for the next level. Yes and But I think it

027too as far as goals go I mean it looks like you're writing around 60% which to me seems Reasonable for the idea that not everyone is going to go On to four-year college. Yeah I don't know. It's just something I thought about. I don't know I think that one of the or do you have any thoughts? it's You raise a good point um, but I think that part of historically paying attention to a3g requirements is You know when I started teaching in 2005 it was the first year that tracy high school and tracy unified school district was not offering a Non a3g history class because you used to Be able to take classes that were not a3g, right? So we largely don't have that So that's true. I'm assuming that people that don't meet a3g

028requirements either Um, you know are not passing, you know the class that they need or something something along those lines It's kind of a metric of opportunity Some of that is language, right? If for you see they want two years, but you may or may not take a language Is that am I thinking of this wrong? It could be word language. It could be our math math So to whatever level that you reach Yes Jason looks like he wants to say something. Do you want to say something jason or no? Sure. Yeah We'll allow it. We'll allow it Get the man a mic While he's coming up I also um, mr Hart came up to the front as well because um, there's a couple things I think that are pertinent as it relates to high

029school Um with some of our testing things that have an impact on some of these scores and so mr Hart's going to provide that explanation as well. Yeah, that'd be great I just on the a3g if a student is a3g most likely they can get to wherever they want So we encourage a higher number so they have options not just limited A lot of that number you'll see is because students do need a c or better in the classes So we might have kids getting d they pass the class, but that's the class graduate But may not be a3g eligible So most of the kids I think that are not kind of fall into that category where the grade level wasn't at the highest level So it ceases to make them uc eligible So it's

030more about that and less about the choices of class that they're taking or a little bit of both It's probably a little bit of both. Um, but I think it it's mostly Yes, the the students will walk in and they will say I don't want to take this class or that class because i'm going to Go to community college But I think a lot of them are in that spot because they have that lower than c grade in a class or two So they might have come to that outcome already, but please jump in if there's more opinion Yeah, the our our focus on uca through g by the way, good morning And also mr conover and I went and saw christmas story, uh, and it was great It was my nephew was in it

031I just felt like I should say that but I thought it was great even if he hadn't been it was Uh our our focus on a3g even for students that aren't necessarily heading to a four year has been about making sure that students Have options for a long time. We want students to Choose to not go to a four year but still have the option to if they wanted to right like if so And that's actually just on a personal level like I have a son who's off at college and he's uca through g I have a daughter who is working her way towards high school graduation and she through she will be uca through g compliant Although right now her goal is to attend a culinary academy afterwards and she just she just don't

032have options She just wants options. Yeah, and so we want to make sure we want students to choose what they do to best fit their own goals rather than being limited by something that's you know, sort of outside of their control and Far and away the number one thing or number one reason students don't qualify for uca through g in our district Is because they have not passed algebra too Okay, that's yeah Um, I I did want to uh, you had asked about math scores a little bit and there's actually some interaction between different numbers on here That I think is kind of illustrative and I just wanted to kind of point it out I'm actually going to start with with with ele up there a little bit So there's a weird thing that happened

033with ele at granada where the proficiency went up, which is great And from 72 to 77 that's already very high. Once you're already very high. It's it's harder to even go up further, right? So that's an impressive jump, but you'll notice actually it's back here You'll notice that actually They're in the yellow on the dashboard And here comparatively it's a little bit lower. And so what actually happened here is that they went down on the dashboard So how possibly could a school go up in proficiency and yet go down on the dashboard? And the reason is because of what we call opt outs on the casp assessment So we've had a growing number of opt outs on the casp assessment, especially at both high schools But especially granada over the past few years. So the

034rules for this are these The dashboard placement is play is based not on proficiency but on distance from standard This is a thing i've kind of talked with you before I know two new two board members are new But basically the point of proficiency is point zero And so if a student is in proficiency, they're at like plus five and if they're under then they're at like minus 10 And what the state does is they take all of those distances from standard for a school They average them together and then that puts you on the dashboard grid somewhere Well, there's also what's called the the the loss rules So the state expects you to test 95 percent of your students overall and for every significant student subgroup So let's say for easy math you have

035a hundred students the state says you're supposed to test 95 of them But let's say you only test 90, right? Then what the state will do is they will take those five students that did not test And for ela the score that they put in for the averaging for distance from standard is negative 277 and for math, it's negative 245 So last year granada's proficiency increased but they had 15 opt-outs So it just hammered the school on the dashboard And and livermore had a similar issue I I didn't want to get out of this without discussing the the changes that the schools are making to address that problem We used to have a system where like juniors would come in and test and everybody else kind of stayed home And I think maybe over time

036that was like, oh do I want to go take a three-hour test? Or do I want to sleep in we want to take away that choice? So both high schools have worked really hard to develop a very complicated schedule that will test All Juniors while everybody else is on campus so that it's not like a choice between a test and a vacation There's some other things as well But it's just it's just so important and the change over the last like four years has been so remarkable but I thought it it it it it just would you know, I thought it bore some uh, some well, I think that's an interesting point because I have my kids have all been through this junior year and I My daughter and I had a fight last year

037She didn't want to take the cast none of her friends were taking the cast and I told her I'm on the school board. You have to take the cast um, I told her that if she wrote If she wrote an essay about why she shouldn't have to take the cast and send it to the superintendent and he agreed That that she wouldn't have to take the cast. She did not do that So she took the cast but I understand the importance of the cast and I think For a lot of parents and students. It doesn't it doesn't matter to them, which I agree It doesn't and I kept telling my daughter that don't worry about how you do on the cast It's not about you as an individual, but it does help us As a

038district to know where we are and where we're going If there's a way to communicate that to parents, I think that's a great idea to not have the day off because that was Honestly as a parent every year fighting this with my kids That was the thing and if I didn't understand what that test was about I would have completely let them opt out Because why would I send them to school to take a test that doesn't matter to them? So I think maybe just education not only with the students but with the parents as well Um, especially parents who have kids that are still coming up like they want our schools to get better We want our schools to get better and the only way we're going to know where we're at is having

039an accurate Test so I think I'm glad you guys are looking into that and I think I know even though i'm sure it's a nightmare with the schedule That's going to help because now they just get a move. They're going to be taking a test which Maybe some kids prefer rather than sitting in class. I don't know but it is An easier choice than staying home like everyone else. So That helps a lot that helps a lot Yeah, and it's some of what I discussed with ela is very similar on math, although we have more sort of math issues We did granada saw an incredible jump on the percentage of students who were proficient on the algebra one final But those students aren't tested On the casp math for another one to two years depending

040on when they when they took it, right? So on the casp test also just really quickly are there questions on the math math on the math casp section that are algebra two Yes up to algebra two. So if we have students who? Don't take algebra two that's going to affect the math scores as well. Yes. Yes to some degree It all all grades nine ten and eleven are also algebra geometry and algebra two are all represented On on the casp math tests, but yes, it is it does go up through algebra two Yeah, so we hope I mean certainly we hope like looking forward We hope that increased proficiency ninth grade year on the algebra one test Means more students will go will be prepared for geometry and algebra two will go on to those

041And then you know, it's not the only indicator that matters But it is an indicator that matters that you know, the the indication of proficiency on the casp math We expect that we'll see improvement on that In the next few years the interrelation between the numbers is is The last thing I kind of want to point out is this issue with math also affects uca through g In fact, they had nearly identical drops like about four percent essentially If if you need to get through algebra two to be uca through g and if casp tests yes through algebra two Well, then if you're not getting through algebra two, then you're probably not going to be through if you write there's going to be some Uh, the the numbers while they're not where they want they

042kind of make sense And so that at least gives us a path forward. That's really helpful to know Appreciate the clarification because I didn't I didn't know that opt out was Penalizing and it's hard for me to describe how frustrating that is As a former high school teacher to try to get people to to buy into this But then to know that people are penalized we we're penalized. That's One of the discussions that we had in our high school schedule work group was around Just what a lot of those days looked like whether it's finals week testing week um, and the one of the things that we were able to do is make some adjustments and agree to to those adjustments with teachers around Ensuring that then students are there and this was a very

043hot topic Around making it a school day and all the things it also provided us then additional minutes back into the schedule Um for our yearly minutes that we have to have instructional minutes So it allowed us to use those minutes back in so that we could play with the schedule to get it right Where staff wanted it to be if that makes sense Because that was impacting that finals week and all kinds of other things that happen In the high school schedule that we see behind the scenes that goes to the state for approval for instructional minutes That all had a huge impact on how our schedules worked So really simplifying that was a conversation that we had with our team of teachers as well I have another question. Yeah, unless you're I do

044too, but you go. No, you go. Okay this question Maybe matthew state um I'm sorry that i've been on the board for six years and I don't know that i've ever Thought to ask this question or even understand it and I just it just popped into my head as we were talking about the el numbers what constitutes An english language learner besides their learning to languages like once they get their biliteracy Are they now not an english? Does does that make sense? I'm wondering what What is an english language learner? technically Yeah, so uh, if a student is classified by the state as an el then the way that that student gets reclassified Is that the student has to score a four on the l pack? Okay. Uh, the student has to Has to show

045proficiency in in grade level content So like getting a three on the casp proficiency is an easy way to do that. We have some other Uh, you can you can achieve proficiency on the district, right? You can achieve low risk on easy cbm depending on what different level So basically you have to demonstrate that you are at grade level with your peers and the content And then the teacher has to uh, the the teacher has input and the parent has input so of those four things We have to meet three of them if we meet three of them, then a student is reclassified Okay, so once they're reclassified or they reach that that level they're no longer counted in our english language learners So those are those are learners who are actively Still learning english.

046It depends actually where you're looking. So if you're looking at state data Um, like if you're looking for example at the at the performance of english learners on our on the casp Uh, then then that number does include our feb students for the next I think it's five years I'm, not sure I could verify that later But five years after they're reclassified those students are included Um in the in the english learner count if you're looking at our local data, we don't count it that way Right, we just we just look at who is who is currently classified as what by the state That's an interesting thing to think about too when we're looking at these numbers Okay um I think though I i'll i'm gonna let christian ask those questions. Uh, I I just

047did want to say I like the idea of study lab um I wonder if there thank you matthew. I wonder if there Is a way to let parents know if students I mean trying to get more students there. Yeah, I don't know I know not um I know like we we often send out an email and say this is available But if if a teacher specifically saw that a student was struggling and specifically reached out to A parent and say I think it would help your student to be here Do you know what i'm saying as opposed to like a blanket? Hey, this is available if your student is having issues Because I know as a parent in the green engineering academy They have to um meet a certain standard to stay in the in

048the program And they will meet with the students and I'm not asking this is a lot But I know the green engineering academy has separate funding so they were able to do this But even if you just had a teacher They meet with the student and then they also reach out to the parent and say hey your student is struggling in this class These are the days available. They need to attend the study session or whatever. I don't know if that would help if it was more specific Rather than like hey, this is available is is if if if teachers were able to send an email to a parent saying hey I think this would really benefit your kid I don't know just a thought But thank you. I think you're thank you for the

049presentation. I'll let christian ask this question now Um, I I have another question about the the numbers behind the numbers. I look at slide six. It's the the school board uh student progress if everything that we do including this meeting Helps students get ready for the next step. It looks like that 37.2 percent of students are not ready for career or college Is that correct? No, so the college are you looking at the the college and career readiness? This slide right here. Uh Yeah, yeah the bottom so the college and career readiness Slide there is a And I might turn over there it's a there's we could have do a whole workshop on what Constitute as being college and career ready. There's different kind of check boxes you can do if I go just because

050I am Qualified like if i'm a if I qualify for college doesn't necessarily mean i'm I count towards the college and career readiness metric here I'm going to turn it over to matthew Yeah, sorry for our two new board trustees there's been some like pre-work on understanding this number And so you're at a bit of a disadvantage I'm, sorry if you want to meet separately to fully understand this then i'd be happy to to kind of provide you that That number is is both I would say the most difficult number to achieve on this and also the most complicated That's not one number. That's actually the interaction about eight different numbers. Um, as mr Conover was saying you qualify like for example If you get a three on casp la and a three on casp

051math you qualify But you can also get a three and a two if you have a cte pathway Or if you are uca3g or if you get a four on an ap so there's just it's the interaction of about eight different numbers So it's it's it's sort of vastly complicated because of that. It's also looking at it's a very high bar I would say right it is looking for I mean, I think it's um It's complexity hides What I think is a like an appealing awareness like an a value for the variety of ways that students might go on to have A post-secondary life. It's more than just uca3g is what the college and career readiness number says But because it takes all these different numbers into account students have to achieve at a high

052level in different places, right? And so that's The six point two percent climb on that for granada and our climb as a district Is actually it's really striking. It's very difficult to get that number up Given the the issues with uca3g that six point two percent is quite a climb That's actually one of the more that and that and the suspension drop I think are really the some of the most impressive bits of data Who's in that who's in that group the graduating seniors? No, see who's in the group that is not ready who graduates from high school But is not ready for college or career according to this number. This is the only number we have It's the number that we send out to the public That helps them to evaluate us Yeah, I

053think i'm gonna answer i'm not Correct me if i'm misunderstanding the question Basically, it's students there are about eight different ways that students can qualify for college and career readiness And it would be students who do not qualify within any of those eight ways It might be helpful Like he said to meet with him to discuss this. This is something that's been newly developed that we've we've Learned about let's get together might be helpful. I will speak with dr gibson about yeah Because when you look at english learners, it's ninety five percent of them fall outside of that So are we just really bad at testing them or getting them ready or what? What what does that number say what we can do is we can schedule kind of a training during one of these

054workshop times Coming up so that we can move move on and move on to the next school site Um, and so we can we'll add that to the agenda coming up. Thank you Yeah, I do think that that is a keen question That was how do we help if we have a climb of six point two percent with everybody? And yet an under representation of our more vulnerable student groups Then what are the things that we can do to help those more vulnerable student groups achieve? And that's um, I mean that's that's a high impact school It could be a number of different ways which could fit the student, you know, make make it fit the student Whether it's cte h or g whatever it is very much. Okay I Do want to put a

055time on this because we have um, we still have a lot to cover But I wanted to thank mr. Conover For his presentation And I believe we have our liver more high. Yes Next so we're gonna invite over. Thank you. We're gonna invite. Thank you very much. We're gonna invite miss mohammed to come up and um, and then After miss mohammed and he grabbed this market now for yeah for all of that. What did I do? No, I said now you owe clark Man, I just want to say we did I think a lot of I do think that a lot of the About all of that I do think a lot of the questions that we asked to apply To will apply to all of our schools. So it was it was helpful and

056Thank you. Mr. Conover for enduring All right. Yeah Yeah next year your first rock I'm telling you the the amount of bragging that went on about him going first We'll show you i'm just kidding Good morning president prusso members of the board superintendent gibson and cabinet members um, thank you for this opportunity to share highlights of our achievement and um, The areas that we are working on to Support our growth and improvement. I live in more high school. Can you guys hear me? Well, okay, I think if you could get it closer No, i'm so loud I worry speak to us like you speak to your students. Oh lord. It's really It's gentle All right So, um, this is our demographics We have a total enrollment. Um 18 18 Um, the number fluctuates each time

057I look at it, you know, it goes lower it goes higher But if you look at our demographics, we are Actually becoming more and more diverse from when I first started here 13 years ago Currently we have students who represent 43 percent actually are white 35 percent hispanic 16 percent asian and 2.9 percent african-american that Those numbers in the other Areas when I first started White students were at 70 percent and now we're sitting out 46 percent And african-american numbers were below one percent. We're we're moving up to close to three percent This is our california dashboard. It's our front-facing data um This is actually really good information for me and for my staff and my team As anything to the left of that arrow is indicative of areas of growth And areas that we

058will need to work on which I will Show us later. What are some of the strategies that we're putting into place to ensure that we are meeting meeting dashboard qualifications, but also Supporting our students and their achievement It does provide us with the baseline So it's good information So this is a data chart that is showing comparisons between schools with similar demographics As you can see we are trending upwards with most of our metrics. If you take a look at the ele in math They show an upward trajectory with student performance so What we have here is what our scoreboard is if you look at ela We declined four percent and talk a little bit about that in just a bit master proficiency went up one percent. I'll take it abc grades Two percent and

059then our average daily attendance declined by one point seven seven percent And so to address the decline in our casp, uh, ela Scores our 11th grade teachers are meeting while they met and they continue to meet in their plcs To align curriculum with the casp standards focusing on literacy They are proctoring interim assessments and each teacher Then takes that interim assessment and see where their students are struggling and then focuses on the building Those skills in their students in those areas This year as mentioned before all of our ela and us history 11th grade teachers will be proctoring the casp test during the school day With students they know and I think that's very important for us to recognize is that It's no longer just a random teacher that they were assigned to but it's

060teachers that they know Who are who will be proctoring these exams? In addition to that our 11th grade el students will test in a cohort They will be pulled out get the additional support They will be tested by our el coordinator our and our el support staff which includes our el liaison as well as our Newcomer counselor who will support them in their testing So some of the english department initiatives they were holding, um, they're reviewing common assessment data They're also discussing effective The effectiveness of their instructional strategies in the classroom And then building on their tier two interventions and then they're also collaborating on successful practices Our eld teachers they're increasing the regular use of technology. And so what we're doing is monitoring That's what our eld coordinator is doing is ensuring that there

061is a Consistent use of steady sync which is one of the programs that we have in place but also using listen wise And they're all using strategies to engage el students in practicing english skills Within with differentiated support obviously but within the classroom in addition We have el we have the biggest cohort of teachers that are attending the el achieve Training and as I walk around classrooms and I see it. I see a lot of conversation happening between our teachers about some of these strategies um and so what they're doing is not only are the teachers who are Using it to to support the yield students, but it's also good for teaching For all of our students. So it's the strategies are working working really well Our eld coordinator, uh, he is leading the Students

062and administration of the interim lpac for our students But he's also helping assist in the outreach to families and I think one of the things that we learned Is that we weren't doing enough with family outreach about the importance of the lpac So that's one of the things that we're actually focusing on a lot this year all right on reviewing our average daily attendance, um, I had a conversation with my attendance clerks as well as our Zwa's and what we have found is that our their average daily attendance We think one of the root causes. Okay could be the independent study form. We have a lot of students who travel during the holidays and what what they need to do with the independent study form is to get the work and You know bring it

063back and the work completion is what what shows positive? attendance And what we're what we're doing is we're finding it really hard To have our students bring the work back So this year what we did is we had the counselors get in On supporting students with their coursework and so they're helping them collect coursework And they're encouraging them and sending them emails while they're on their trip To make sure that they're getting their work done. So we're interested in seeing you know the with the added addition of the counselors reaching out to our students who are going on independent study to see if If that's going to have a positive effect on their attendance because if they don't turn it and it turns into a pux which then negatively impacts our attendance All right, so

064This data Gives us a very solid foundation on what we're doing in terms of the work the efforts that we're putting into place If you look you see our english learners passing the lpac at least one level we increased by seven percent Our math score students proficient on algebra one final increased by eight point twenty two percent See the number of students suspended decreased By one percent and then the college and career indicator We increased by point eight percent so we If you take a look at this number, this is a very concerning number And I think what you will see is that there is a a lot of focus happening for these vulnerable populations we As a result of this and and you'll see this later in my slides because it's one of my

065main priorities Is that we've added a coordinator to support? Our el students, but also for our students with disabilities. We're looking Implementing we're getting our teachers trained right now. I think this piece so you're very much aware of this program But it's the career launch program and career launches We're looking at incorporating it with our special education students so that they can have a more focus on On life after high school they can see you know a dream of a future that they can work towards and so Our teachers will be trained In the next couple of months our special education teachers will be trained the next couple months and they will implement it next year to see You know if that brings more focus on on academics Suspension rate So as of The writing

066of this report We had 30 students 1.6 percent of our students who were suspended At least once from school And then a total number suspensions have dropped but to date 35 so if we continue in this trajectory, we'll see that the our suspension rates will decline continuously and so We have fostered, you know quite a bit in terms of what we're doing with our suspensions and students who do get in trouble We're looking at restorative practices And one of those practices is that students do have to complete a reflective module that we create right on the spot For them depending on what the behavior is and we can see them as they work through Their module because we have access and we're watching them as they write and sometimes they go. Oh, you know They

067write some funny things in there. But anyway So they do the restorative modules, but we also have our students who are peer supporters and peer mentors that work out of the Wellness center also supporting our students in in behavioral Support We have a very robust PBIS program. We have the cowboy heroes Which we ask in all teachers actually have to incorporate all of that into their syllabi syllabus and every wednesday we do a PBIS lesson and we tell the students this is the Area that we're focusing on we're if we're doing h which is heroes honoring education You know, we say this is the PBIS model or part that we Are covering this year this this particular wednesday and so in that You will see that we Did get a PBIS gold For livermore high

068school, which is I don't know if you guys know this but it's a really hard thing to do at the high school level and so we have put a lot of effort into making sure that we are offering support before we Um are giving consequences to students. I for me personally, I feel like if we teach them then they won't repeat so That's one of the philosophies that we have embraced and so we're trying to work with students about their behavior as opposed to automatically sending them out for Whatever behavior they did or whatever Thing that they did to get in trouble Okay, so celebrations the PBIS gold um And then we have a family resource center that we opened officially in january Our family resource center. We're very proud of um, it is a

069center for our english learners and newcomer families It is manned by our newcomer counselor and also a liaison from the county office who comes in and also Is housed there in the in the family resource center for for two days a week. So it's open four days a week and that Families come in and they can get any kind of support that they want In the center whether it's community support whether it's counseling support whether it's you know They're asking questions and we refer them out to um Where to get legal advice where to get you know, so it's still working for us We just you know opened up in january, you know in january officially So we're looking out with some of the needs are okay. I'm going to it's my time running out.

070Sorry Um, and then instructional support center we have in the center of the school We have what is called an instructional support center Which is for our el students and it's where our el liaison and our para educator for el students is housed And so students are now being pulled out for testing So like if they have an algebra test all of the students at that time Who have an algebra test are pulled in into the resource in the learning resource support center and they're tested They're they're taken just kind of like how you would do in a resource class, but it's doing we're doing it for el students Are they also if they need additional support? Are they coming into the Instructional support center during the school day during the class, okay So if

071they're struggling with then they go the teachers send them over to that. Yes So but also what i'll see what what I have witnessed is that the el liaison will go to the classes where the kids are They have tests So like they have a test today all the physics teachers are or not physics I'll say algebra all the algebra teachers are having a test on a particular day They'll go pull the students out from all the different classes that they're in and then test them within that In that during that period during in the in the support center yeah so again, we sent the largest cohort of Teachers to the el achieve and it's it's a mixture of teachers that went so it's from math english All of them. We took a random number

072of teachers that are attending You'll achieve and again, like I said, it's been really positive the feedback has been positive from our teachers our culture keeper program We started an interim program this year And what our kids are doing right now are doing outreach and support to the elementary and middle schools that have emerging emerging wellness centers And so what do we teach them and then they go teach? um at the elementary and middle schools, so Uh, and the feedback from the counselors in these schools have just been They're blown away by our kids that are going out there to do the support and so they go Every time that they are are scheduled to have a community service in the wellness center We have seven american degrees for lhs. I don't know if people

073know how important getting seven american degrees are um, if you look at any other school, um I won't challenge you look seven Because you'll probably do it, um, but Across the nation, you know schools sends maybe one or two every other year every few years we consistently send upwards of seven to more to more than that a year for These awards for these american degrees for lhs. That's amazing So that's a huge accomplishments for our students and we're very proud of the work That our staff do with these kids and then i'm going to go ahead and add on the algebra one pass rate because Any increase in algebra for me is a is a win and that we will continue to build on All right progress for my main priority, uh el development and

074so To this end we want to ensure that 45 percent of our EL students advance at least one level on the lpac and we've put a lot of energy into what we're doing for them Um, our el coordinator is tracking students academic progress and providing professional development for our stuff In fact, we just did one yesterday on accessing reading so it was the whole staff who Were able to participate in this and take some of those strategies back to um back to their classroom We're increasing access to eld classes. We have opened lunchtime tutoring We have three eld support classes and then we have pullout support for coursework and testing as well And providing the professional development we're offering workshops to the family resource center to educate parents That's the biggest push that we've done

075this year is that we're pushing Just awareness of the importance of the lpac test to our parents and We're using tools like study sync Off to class and listen wise to support el set el students and then in in addition to all of this We have a support group for el newcomer female students we have about 17 newcomer students and all of them were assessed through the hughes center to see if they needed any social emotional support and all 17 of them Need We're deemed needing additional social emotional support The next one is improving algebra proficiency We want to increase the number of students who are proficient in algebra and that's something that The numbers that we're always looking at conversations that we're having constantly with our algebra teachers And what we did this year

076was to reduce the class size for algebra one We took it down to 25 as opposed to the 33 that it was at We have wednesday after school math tutoring as well as lunchtime tutoring We have tier one instructional support and intervention And then all of our algebra 1 teachers are piloting standards-based grading. They're trying it out And this came from them i've been wanting standards-based grading or equity-based grading for a long time and so um, they're trying this and seeing what you know, if this is something that's going to work for them and they've asked me to Give them official training or get them official training on standards-based training standards-based grading so We'll see where we i'm going to i'm in the process of looking for something. Um the math task force from the

077district. Thank you Um, mr. Kolaroski, um, our teachers are engaged actively in the math task force and I think with that um you can see the the the level of engagement in our with our math teachers in the areas that they um Which you're on right? You're still on that. That's pretty so I love that's my favorite. That's why I learn all my mouth Okay And then um, we're also looking at math finals and doing a data review in fact Um this week we are looking at how our students did on the finals um for algebra 1 and so Currently next week. I think they'll have their plc in which they'll be able to analyze Um their data, um, and we're at areas that we need to build on But in addition to that we

078have a fundamentals of algebra class that the the students that are not doing well Meaning they're getting these Or lower In math they are they can move in and out of the fundamentals of algebra class And so basically what we're doing is students have algebra, but then they have an additional support class at the end of the day In which we're teaching them the the foundations of algebra And um right now we're in the we just the last week Solicited names from the algebra teacher saying which students need additional support after first semester With algebra and so we're enrolling those students in the fundamentals class and That's it. Can I just call matt up here already? I'm just We're gonna try to do this without matt. Okay, let's go. Yeah Okay Sorry, I want to

079go first or I can go first Stephen um first just kind of generally speaking. I appreciate the clustering of like to like schools in the district Superintendent gibson, I think it helps it's something that when we were doing it having these presentations at each of the Regular board meetings it was difficult to track and kind of see those things Whereas now I can have them all three up at the same time to kind of make to ask questions and that kind of stuff and then Secondly, I also appreciate the data highlighting emerging bilingual students rels and students with special needs To know that that was a choice that we made and i'm going to double down and stand by that Choice, I think it's good for us to look at that all of us um,

080and then to I appreciate the time and energy to share with us and to share with the community about the successes and challenges I know that some people could view this as busy work or you know as stressful But I think it's important for us all to take stock of what are the what are the priorities and what are the successes and challenges? so That being said um What's the hume center? Um hume you had mentioned i'm not familiar. I can't tell you what the acronym is But it is an organization a partner organization that we work with and it focuses on social emotional Support is the counseling center. Cool. Um, and so they come in and they came they they were actually uh, We asked the county to help us with providing support for

081the students and they that's what they found and then Secondly, um, I appreciate the informing families about lpac And I think that the more that everyone understands the test from parents to teachers to administration to students to understand What's going on the test and I think that When we switched from celt to lpac I think people kind of are like didn't really lean in and so I think the further we can lean into helping students understand You know what that assessment is? the better and then along those lines, I think that was a separate point, but No, I was just going to say that that I know that as as students Move up in grades the test becomes more challenging because they're you know, it's kind of a moving bar of uh, english language Reclassification,

082so just appreciate all the hard work on the focus on the student the students. Um are emerging bilingual students um, I had asked pre uh, uh Clark conover about the switch to the semester system. So thoughts Joys challenges. I mean, I know that things are changing for the next year but i'm kind of hopeful for the the continuity from semester to semester, but Any thoughts that you'd care to share publicly at this point? You said publicly? um the You know initially, you know the students They they like having a consistent teacher. They like having classes every other day. They love that Yeah, yes, yes on mostly Um The teachers for me, um, there was some work that had to be done with the pacing piece of it So they were allowed some time to re

083Realign their pacing with the every other day aspect of it I think the teachers struggle with seeing um students every other day I as a teacher would have struggled with seeing students every other day Um, I like the new schedule in terms of seeing you know kids daily I think the the contact the daily contact with students is very important Um, what also is important when I heard from our teachers this year was oh I didn't have to start over I can just jump right in into teaching Um the kids because they have the same kids Again for second semester. So I love that piece of it and then and then there is as mr conover had indicated there is no lag or Or a course a trimester in between where you're not taking classes

084So there's a lot of good to that I think one of the things that I had to do with our teachers was to give them permission to say You can teach the standards But you don't have to teach them all four books or all five books because I think that they were really worried about what that would look like and so with that With that permission they they they're able to teach all the standards they needed but within Using different types of resources to do so And then kind of lastly, um I think i'm excited about this switch to standards-based grading. Um I don't i'm going to be honest. I don't know a lot about this so kind of reaching out if if anybody wants to share or um Help inform me or other board

085members about what that shift is Um, but I do know that change is challenging and that teachers tend to some teachers Tend to teach the way they were taught so I can see that this is going to be a cultural shift. So um, just uh What do I say supporting you in helping with that transition? Um as as uh, uh teachers are Changing both culture and pedagogy around how they're doing what they're doing and I think it's important to recognize that this was um, a teacher decision Okay, it wasn't a decision for me. It was a conversation that we all had it was something that I had wanted but there was a Very strong resistance to standards-based grading From I want to say 12 years ago when we brought it up So it's taken this

086long for teachers to recognize the importance of it And a lot of it was a conversation about how it was working for my own child in a different district You know the standards-based aspect of it And so having those conversations and showing them, you know exactly what they were doing um in his school Got the light bulb going and so what I told them this year was that you have the ability to experiment Let's try it. Let's figure it out Let's see what we want to do And so what i've heard from them is that that this is the direction that they want to go down And so this is where we start doing the training and then putting some pieces in place for next year Yeah, i'm also excited about the standards-based grading and

087I know I think even before Steven before you were on the board. We saw this anomaly happening over at christianson middle school and the math scores and Went to them and said what's happening and there's they still had started doing standards-based grading. I know granada also Does some maybe not all but I know that there's some happening there and at mendenhall as well so it's something that we Recognized early on that's really helpful and again be nice to have A little less on it, but not today because we're on a time crunch. Sorry It's okay um Are you done? Are you finished? Sorry, I jumped in and Okay, uh, i'll just go and then you guys jump in. Um, there's just a couple of things I think steven hit on a lot of it I

088did see the standards-based grading and I think that's great. Um And I think that'll be helpful and I see the work that's happening in math task force and and also analyzing the data from the from the Assessments, I think is really important and i'm glad that we're now doing that across the district And also that I see that you're putting a lot of effort into your english language learners and I looked up the achieve training and I think that that looks Fantastic, so i'm glad that that that's happening as well and I see At livermore high, even though the numbers aren't where you want them to be I do see that there is an upward trajectory and I think that's important and that's something that we should definitely celebrate And then continue to move Forward

089and on and it looks like you have some good plans in place for that um as always I think what's happening at livermore high school as far as Mental health you guys have and wellness you guys have come out in front of the the rest of the district with the health and wellness center And like you said you're going out and and teaching the other schools how this is happening It's now coming filtering down to all schools including our elementary schools Which is obviously we're recognizing as something that's really important for student achievement is is um a state of of Mental health and wellness and and that's been really important um Yeah, so those were just some of my comments And i'm going to turn the time over to mr. Van or trustee van and

090who will and some of the things i'll talk about I think we'll just need to put a pin in it and later on maybe dig a little bit deeper into those things with with maybe uh, uh, yeah, uh, First of all this the celebration you kind of I or maybe I missed it the community closet. What is that? Oh, okay. Yes. So we are one of three schools I want to say In the district that has a community closet closet and basically what that means is that there is there are supplies for families from blankets to under clothing to socks to toiletries Uh blankets everything that you know things that our families had indicated when we took a server that they needed um, so those and do you keep track of uh, You have some

091data around that and see how what the trajectory is on that if you know if that increases or decreases over the years We will be we just opened it. Um, and so what we'll do we are going to track it Yes, we will be tracking that information to see what um is coming in and out and then what are what is being asked for? From our families. Um, this way we can better plan for for needs. That sounds great. But we yeah, we do have a um We do take inventory and looking at your suspensions. Um, uh slide What's your relationship like with the parents and everybody that you know stands behind these students? um Do and do you kind of track what's behind the suspension like what's the reason and is it a specific

092demographic? Is it always the same group of students or is it across the board? How do you track that information? So, um, we do Take a look at who is being suspended at least one time as well as multiple times um, what we're finding is that um in terms of How do I put this? um that you know, uh There are many parents that do support us in our decisions And then there are many parents that we need to have down and have sit down and have in-depth conversations About why the behaviors are happening what we are finding is that the students are owning their behavior And so when we have these that's part of our pbis model is that when we sit down We have the conversations with the students first about what their

093behavior is why they did it how they can avoid it and then we um And then we have conversations with the families say this is the conversation we have with your child But overall you feel you feel like you have a good relationship with parents I would say so you're able they pick up the phone when you call or they when you text them and Yes, you can have a conversation with them. Yes, and then they text our works all the numbers too. So that's really good. Um Something that I also I didn't really Hear from either you. Mr. Conover is Your the use of ingenuity. It's not in any of these slides On how to how some of these students are getting to our passing classes. Um And maybe that's something for another Another

094time like but although it does tie in with our next presentation um You know this that that particular aspect I think is important to talk about Because I am not sure if that's a really good tool to use to help students move on to the next class or To feel like hey, i've got the credits now to move on and I wonder if that's related to To some of the scores that you're seeing Because ingenuity kind of patches. Oh, it's you know, you know ingenuity is um It does meet the uh, uca2g requirements. So it is it is an accredited um program and so It's not easy It's not an easy program. It is actually quite difficult for some students but it's very easy to cheat on That would be accurate it's very easy to

095just sit there and and plug in the you know, find the answers online and Um, so that's why i'm not sure that students actually learn Anything after take doing doing the work and we're paying for it and we're so that's and um yeah, that I think that's an important conversation to have maybe going forward and Not to throw shade on any student that comes your way from other schools Uh the the middle schools But you know you're being asked to Forge steel Out of these students and so you need what? coke iron core Limestone, I think that's but instead you're getting paper and cotton and and salt, you know sent to you. So your math scores also a reflection on Our middle are your math are your math staff members telling you that hey We

096cannot start with this curriculum because our students are not prepared. They're not graded well in middle school So when we get them We we don't you know, we can't just start from Page one in the book. We have to first catch them up You know, yes I've heard that from our teachers I especially clear our algebra teachers and and so what I tell them is, you know, you have an end goal You know where you want those students to go And if you recognize when you do You know your basic pre-assessments that this is where they are and you know where they want to go Then you have a road map You know what you need to do to support the students to get there I still you know get the grumblings, but You have

097a road map I want to say to mr Krulikowski looks like he stepped out but because i'm on the math task force I could say That the math task force is middle school and high school teachers working together And I think that that's really helping because they're able to communicate what their needs are and saying we're not getting prepared students at this level Which is why we changed it from algebra task force to math task force so that we can include some of those math teachers that are teaching not just algebra, but math six seven and eight And helping them That kind of communicating with each other to figure out How do we get the students prepared for algebra by ninth grade? You know some of them obviously before but by ninth grade and I

098think that that's been really helpful And then those those math teachers who are in math task force do go out and and speak to the other Math teachers in their schools now. We have representatives of every school We didn't always have that and now we do which I think is great And so that's something that I think will help with that obviously it's going to take time But i've seen it happening in while i'm on the the task force and it It's it's great to see the teachers communicating with each other. You know, what what's what's what are where are the gaps? What are we missing? So I think that'll help but it's you know, it was interesting I had walked into a Collaboration that jason was running at our site with our teachers And

099they were analyzing questions, you know talking talking about this many kids didn't do well this many kids did Why is that and so they were actually deconstructing the problem and looking out where they where they struggled Okay, and so some of that work Again is in the second year Third year second year. We've had the algebra task force for a while But we changed it to the math task force for this reason and so it's starting to not be focused just on algebra, but like how do we get math all the way and then also the Mr. Connors has a program for the elementary that's starting at that level as well and with the svmi we're using svmi for both of these which is the Silicon valley math initiative any way you can look now.

100I feel self-conscious. Thanks for coming to my onboarding session here But but but Working together seeing the correlation from our third graders and what's happening in third grade and what's happening in ninth grade that that That stuff is starting to happen and I think it's really exciting Okay, it's my turn. Yeah, I'll just go quickly. Um Thank you for your presentation and congratulations on um All the recognitions and highlights you guys have achieved at livermore high school um I know that your guy's softball team did really well last year as following them And your choir is phenomenal and I really appreciate their performance at our holiday district event anyways, uh, I really Appreciate how you said that you built in the algebra fundamentals class into the children's um Their schedule so that it's not an

101option for them to take it. It's already built in I think that's a great step in the right direction to improve their math proficiency And then I just have a quick question about the community closet How do you guys get the funding for that? Is that a separate thing or is that the the family resource center? That's That came from our district district supported us with some of the funding through um carla estrada um who helped us with She gave us some funding to to buy those those materials So so with that is that like who's in charge is like keeping like the inventory like keeping the so we have a uh, we have a Administrative secretary who is in charge of keeping track of our inventory She actually helped us order the inventory and

102then helped us um Is helping us keep track of that. We also solicited from our staff to donate Yeah, and so our staff did donate. Um quite a bit of toiletries To um to the community closet so um to keep up with the supply demand will the funding be able to cover that for a long time or is that Community partners is what i'm getting at to keep that going because I think that's really helpful. Well For now our district has supported us in this area. And so I don't know where we are Well, we will be by the end of the year And so I will have to reevaluate the types of resources that we'll need at the time and what other supports Will be necessary All right. Thank you. And I really appreciate

103the goals. I have working towards The improvements. Thank you Thank you Your eyes, thank you. Ms. Muhammad you are excused Wonderful Um, I am gonna say come on Tammy welcome Come on up Um, we are on a little bit of a time. We would like to finish this meeting by noon. We have additional meetings after that so if do you think 11 15 for Tammy till I'm gonna say to the board members. We're doing amazing work But if we We are we are doing like We've yeah, we we're gonna have to we're gonna have to we're gonna have to pull rain ourselves in you guys are doing great we're gonna have to rain ourselves in and and So I I think if we if we can finish this Section by 10 15 10 20 we

104should because we do have the budget to go over as well Um, so I will just say if there are additional questions about vineyard and del val That's maybe something that we can address later. So just keep that in mind as we go through this presentation That we're on a little bit of a time crunch I think a lot of the questions that we've been asking for book for For both schools affect all three of our high schools So I think we're getting answers for all of them as we go, which has been really helpful, but I just want to Let everyone know we're trying to uh, we do have an end Time that we're trying to reach and we also have the budget to talk about and if there are additional questions that we

105don't Get to if you just email those to me. I'm happy to work with tammy and and we can get those to the board That's not a problem No pressure miss rankin, please welcome Good morning board president pruso members of the board superintendent gibson cabinet and community. I'm tammy rankin I'm the principal of alternative ed and I Will start with del val today so del val Typically the last couple of years runs between 80 and 100 students depending upon Where students are we do? Variable credits so students can graduate at any time when I did this we had 97 students and If you look at our demographics, we're proud of our diversity We look at our california dashboard we're proud of our graduation rate and our suspension rate When it comes to college and career

106readiness as you've heard There's a lot of factors that go into that and our real goal with continuation students is to make sure that they graduate We don't we haven't focused on the college and career readiness portion When you look at the dashboard for del val comparative to other schools Our test scores as you can see are similar to other other schools our students are struggling when they come to us and We do a lot to support them academically and to get them to pass their classes When it comes to Suspensions and graduation graduation like I said, we're doing Better than some of the other schools. I'm on a group meeting every month with a group of principals from all over the state and they And we talk about graduation rate and I think that

107one of the reasons why our graduation rate is higher than Other schools other continuation schools is they don't do variable credits and our variable credits help our students And then like I said college and career readiness is one of those things. It's a struggle for us So if you look at our scoreboard We have we last year we worked on trying to you know Get our students to realize that the test was important so we could see how they were doing that our students come to us really struggling academically and we hand hold them through their academics and so We we do struggle with our cast scores when looking at attendance Our students haven't been going to school to begin with so Really getting them to go to school is hard, especially first period But

108we try to encourage them we So attendance is is a focus that we work on Every year And we we encourage them. We support them. We talk to parents We do all those things we can do and i'll go through some other things that we do later, but Attendance is a big big focus Last year we started using edge and off to class for our english learners It was the first time we'd done that And um, I think that helped with our english learners that we've that had come to us and this year We have a teacher from both schools Going through the el achieve training And so then they're taking that information and then sharing it with our staffs We don't have ninth graders and then our suspension rate is low we do a

109lot with When students come into our school, we talk about expectations on our campus how safe it is our pbis is Is up and running and we use that for getting kids to For a positive atmosphere and then our staff is Is available is available at all times so if you come on our campus and it's a break every staff member is in the hall If you come on campus and it's lunch every staff member is where student is And so we really try to make sure that there's adults everywhere and so students can Use adults if they needed and that kind of helps with our our problems with behaviors And then like I said college and career readiness is It's difficult to focus on when we're at continuation school When you look at our

110english learners and students with with disabilities Um We our class sizes are small so our teachers know who those students are and are able to support them as needed um, we have a para that goes out and supports our students with disabilities in their classrooms and um, we recognize that um that they are our most needy students and so we Try our best to support them as needed We also this is exciting we also have every one of our office staff members speak spanish And so that has helped with people families calling in families coming into the office They can talk to anyone that's in the office. So it's it's just happened. So it's kind of exciting um, and then Sorry I'm talking there's that there's that that's our english language suspension rate. Our suspension

111rate is low um oftentimes in the past like last year suspensions were happening from kids were going on other campuses and um not behaving and so like we we just have a lot of adults on campus that are Um communicating with kids and making sure that kids get what they need We're watching where kids are. We have a campus supervisor in the hall The campus isn't very big and just try to be positive with kids and make sure that they get what they need so that We're not having Behavior problems on campus. We're trying to reward kids for acting for they they love whenever they get a gift card for You know habit or whatever that we've gotten donated They love it so That's that's one of the things that we use for positive behavior

112Social emotional learning is a big focus on our campus this year Especially since we brought both schools in together um we're really Last year it went both of both teacher student relationships and sense of belonging went up And we weren't together but this year we're hoping that um, our numbers are higher. Um We want students to feel connected and they not feel connected where they came from And so we really want them to feel connected And so our leadership classes at both schools have come together to put together activities on our campus On our campus so that we're all everyone's doing them You know participating in the activity. So it's been really fun some of the activities that they've done, you know, just dress up days or Halloween we had an activity where At lunchtime

113and so everyone with everyone on campus participated on both campuses so both campuses have really Are both schools have really? Kind of united together and those kids like being around each other. So it's been fun celebrations We are all um at one campus now. So that's a big celebration It's been really positive if you come on campus, the atmosphere is positive the kids Um are enjoying it. Um, when I talk about vineyard later, um You know moving them over has been really positive the del val Kids come on campus they're on campus for a full five periods Have lunch there and just interact with the vineyard Students, so it's been been positive We have three cte programs a culinary program, which if you haven't had their food you will at some point Um, their food

114is really good We have a bike transportation program. So If you need a bike And or you find a student that needs a bike where the place to come Or you have a bike to donate donate to us and we will fix it up and give it to someone in need So it's a great program Our students love it. And then we just started a residential um construction program with ctwi which is very exciting for us Um, and then we are awarded a gold pbis award, which was exciting So that shows you why our suspension rates are low and um, how we were doing With the atmosphere on our campus And we just got a six-year wasp myth of mid-year accreditation So which is which was exciting priority one, um For average daily attend attendance

115was 75.1 percent and we're trying to get it to 80. That's a big goal um, we have Attendance we talk about attendance at intake meetings Our students don't generally have homework. So in order to get Credits they have to come to school And do their work and they have to be in the classroom And so they start to learn that once they're on campus and they like it once they once they start coming They start to like being on our campus. Um, we have a cwaa that makes phone calls twice a day for students to try to get them to come to school and we have lots of meetings with students and parents about Attendance and credits We talk about credits Every time a student can get a credit so we have credit cutoff times.

116We talk about attendance and credits with families So they're well aware where their child is with their attendance and credits so that's a priority one and priority two is Is a sense of belonging like I said before We really want students to feel like they belong on campus We did a unity tree this year with both schools where students wrote information on a a Like a leaf and put it on the tree and that um And they were supposed to write how the school could be inclusive for of all so that was fun for all the students to do it Still up. Um, like I said, we had Halloween activity. We had the thanksgiving feast if you were able to attend We have spirit weeks we've been doing drives and collecting canned foods and clothes

117we had gingerbread houses We did a murder mystery game one day at lunch at lunch at pack time, which is once a week we've done bingo games and just Time for students to go out and ask each other questions about themselves to learn about each other Just trying to get the atmosphere better as the students to get to know Um staff and staff participates in a lot of that and all of this with the students so it's it's been fun That's del val Do you want me to do vineyard and then maybe do vineyard and then we'll do the the questions at the end. Okay? I'm trying to yeah. Okay Okay So like um del val we're about the same size 93 students um Vineyard right now is a k um K-12 school. We have

118one third grader. I think we have 17 middle school students Seven of those students will go to high school next year. I think if I have the numbers, right? There's 10 or 11 of our sixth and seventh graders. So most of our students are high school students And that should because you if you look you can see that diversity and we're very proud of our diversity in our school Um, like del val most of our students that come to us weren't successful where they were and so We do have the same some of the same struggles at both schools with getting kids to come to campus If you look at the dashboard Our suspension rate is in yellow only because we went up from zero to two Suspension, so we had two suspensions last year

119Um, but our graduation rate's high when you look at our test scores i'm working with Teachers on and students to try to get them to understand or families to understand How important the test is and get them to bring their students to school for the test? This year, I think it'll be easier because more students are on campus We're using the iab Um And then as far as college and career readiness, i'm not sure they knew what that was we have that problem with Kids being okay with just passing and if you got a c then you would be college and career ready. So We're working on Educating not when we or do a four-year plan with the students and so work on educating students on And families on what they need to do to

120be a through g compliant and what they need to do college and career So what that means? So if you can remember Last year when I talked I spoke about all the visits i'd been on At different schools, so it's really hard when I look at this It's hard to compare me with compare compare vineyard with other independent study schools because we all look so different Um, I know I was on a call the other day and almost everyone was doing ingenuity. That was their how they Their education for their for their students and so we all look different. So it's hard to compare but this shows our comparison Um with our with other schools And we are continuous continuously working to improve our where we are at our school um Once again our ele

121and our math proficiency scores. We are working on those we are doing things different this year So our students attend school two days a week for every class whether it's in person or online and that Those two days are instruction. It's not just check-in So we are doing it's for the first time we're doing a full instruction for those for those two days So in math we teach alex in the past I see our scores. Um are 19 but our our Our students would take the alex class and that would pass them and that would be the end of it if they had questions the teachers would support them now the teachers are are going through the algebra and or Geometry or whatever they are they are math and teaching two lessons a week to

122the students And then they're also available on wednesdays for more help. So kids are coming in for more help So we're doing we're doing things a little differently and we're doing that all across the board. We're doing instruction Two days a week in every class and then our teachers are available on wednesdays and students are coming in either to take tests So one of the things I talked about last year was checking for understanding Students are coming in to take tests so we can check to make sure that they understand Or work on projects on wednesdays or we have students that come in because they need extra help on wednesdays with The teachers so things are being done a little differently. So that's how we're focusing on that And then our grades attendance at vineyard

123is work completion. So it's a little different So we are trying to monitor also Um students showing up to those two periods because we feel like that's what's going to Help achievement student achievement is them actually attending in our two periods because they still have independent study work to do But that's and then a through g completion. I think that's just education One of the things that we did this year that wasn't in the past was we would i've sat down with the teachers and went through Our courses that we were offering and some of our courses we were offering were Um We're offering an a through g an english class that maybe wouldn't didn't fit Into the a through g so we changed we switched which class we were offering So that we're offering

124classes that are all a through g and then we're educating the students on what that is And then our english learners and we don't have a lot of english learners So our teachers know who they are and they work to support them We try to get them to come in person as much as possible So that um, we can see how we can meet their needs I appreciate you giving us the total because that makes a big difference with the percentages. Yeah. Thank you um and like I said college and career Is one of the things we're focusing on so we can teach our students what that is and like I said our english learners our students with disabilities are Um Our students will that have the most need we do have a an sdc

125class and we have a resource class at bidner And um, we have a pair that goes out and supports students during the day For and during the day if they're on campus and we she also goes out If there's a student that needs supports online, she'll go online and Be part of the class and see how they can help the students Suspension rates we Are we're proud of our suspension rates um, we talk about positive being positive and not going on to other campuses and doing what's right on our campus why we're there so there's been two rates And like I said, some social emotional learning is a focus for both schools because we wanted the merge between both schools to be positive and to be able to have both schools on campus where Um,

126everyone's doing activities and so we are we've been able to have lots of activities on campus um during the school day with both kids students from both schools and The students are enjoying them. In fact, I brought a small group of students in to meet with me to talk about the campus and how things were going and The feedback that I got from them from both schools was they wanted more activities where they could do things together So that was very positive And our celebrations are we're now on an alternative school campus vineyard has increased our a through g offerings to make sure that we can Be a through g compliant because I when I looked before it was very difficult to just be on our campus and be a through g And some of

127our students are not ready to go And take classes at other places and then we received a silver pbis award and we are I just turned in our wasp report So we're getting ready to go through wasp so and then a priority, um We want to improve our students that are college and career ready and 10 is not high but when you're starting with You know the seniors and they haven't done much, you know, they haven't seen it before So we're going to we're starting small but we're trying to educate all of our students on what it means to be college and career ready And and a through g and hopefully we'll improve that score And then priority two is our daily attendance. So Each student has a mentor teacher so all of our teachers

128have a group of teachers that are a group of students that they're in charge of and they go through their attendance their attendance, which is work completion and their other attendance every week and They contact students. They contact their teachers. They contact parents and we have We've just created an attendance flow chart So it tells them what they need to do if a student is struggling and we put in stuff in place there So that they can be successful so we can make sure that they're successful at our school There we go. I tried. All right Maybe do you want to start this time? We keep pushing you to last. Do you want to go first? Yes, uh, thank you for your presentation. I had a quick question. I know you did both schools So

129I just wanted some clarification why the college and career readiness is a focus um or a goal at vineyard as opposed to del val because del val has the um the culinary program has now the construction program so so Many of the students do take the cte classes at del val, but it's a continuation school So they don't take they're not required to take the same number of credits as The comprehensive schools, okay and so It'd be very difficult for them with the number of credits they that they have to complete to be College and career ready got it. Okay. Thank you, but we do Encourage the cte a lot of the time they end up going into the you know that area Right Okay. Thank you Stephen just quick wanted to share my appreciation

130for the successes that both school sites have had And also thank you for your leadership and the transition of helping to merge I I recognize that school sites are very unique and different but that they do have similarity So thank you so much for all your hard work. Thank you Um, I too, uh, I love what you're doing. I I especially love just seeing in the last couple years how this stigma about You know a continuation school has slowly eroded and I think it has a lot to do with your staff It has to do with the program and I love when students actually get a chance to see what happens on campus It's really really positive. So Keep up the great work. I love that. I think that's that's so good because you know

131We all have our potential and we got to get there But my son had his bike stolen and mr Kerseshi hooked him up with a new one because of delval so way to go How do you get the to these social emotional learning numbers? Where is it a test or is it a assessment? Assessment we do is it once a year or we do them twice a year twice a year. Okay, great. Thank you That's all. Okay. Thank you I just wanted to say as well closing out really quickly that There's a great community on campus At delval and vineyard now I had the opportunity to go and tour and I would invite you especially the new board members to go And miss franken was happy to show me around It was really great to

132see How they've incorporated the two and I want to give a big credit to you For being so positive about that and I think that your willingness to do that and your positivity Is what is what made it possible? I think as someone else that would have been more resistant or had That would have made it a really difficult year But you've made it really a positive experience for both schools Not just for the students but the teachers and staff as well And I want to commend you for that because that is has been really We can see and i'm excited to see the data next year to see What that has done for our students because it sounds like you've also made a lot of changes In how you track and help the students

133and it's going to be interesting to see next year what the data does Coming out of this year. So I just wanted to say thank you for doing that And if you would just go back to your staff and just be like thank you for being so Great with the with the students and with the community. It's really a really cool place to be. So thank you so much. Thank you Okay, we're gonna move on so we had to rush through that one Thank you for to our teeth for our principals for coming. I know this is a big ask but it's really important For us and for our community. So we appreciate it. We know that you are very busy So if you need to leave you are welcome to do so and now

134I will turn the time over to Miss lawsley, I believe for our budget or is it tory? I don't know both everyone Okay, here we go our favorite part Oh, yeah old man And many thanks to our principals as well. I'm glad that um, Thank you for your feedback trustee druane on regarding just Kind of the cohort groups. That's what we were going for for that reason So i'm glad that that was noticed and is working out Well, I think it's much easier when we can do some comparisons of ourselves as well as outward Because these teams of principals do work Very collaboratively together. So although they are at different sites and at moments are very Festive and competitive with one another at the end of the day I know that that the three of

135them very much embrace all of our high school students Under one big umbrella. So thank you to the three of you so much Have a great long weekend if I don't see you before Okay moving along So on the board packet you may just need to refresh if you're a community member and you are Looking online Just refresh the screen and the attachment is there we uploaded it at about 10 38 this morning Um, as we were just putting a few final touches on this before it went public. So This is round two of recommended reductions for 25 26 A couple changes on the sheet. So first of all, we have highlight we have color coded Um The management versus the sca versus lea You'll notice that there's not any seiu on here and that

136has been brought up as a concern and just a question Which is a really great question and there's a couple reasons for that number one. Um, we are doing kind of a deeper dive It of as part of round three into the sciu positions also Some of our seiu positions come from other type of funding sources that don't affect The general fund budget so all of these are actual general funds. So anything in the green column That says general savings slash costs These are all general funded Things that we're looking at currently um we also Unfortunately sciu just has a much smaller number of employees. I want to say Miss wasley looked it up earlier and I want to say it was like 48 Compared to i'm going to look over here At miss Kristovic

137how many approximately how many members do you have roughly? 480 so that's also the the difference So when we put it in that perspective I think it's important because it was a great question that was brought up and I want to make sure that Both our community and our staff have that lens as well that 480 versus 48 very different lens It doesn't mean that things aren't happening there. It just may not have an impact Necessarily on the general fund and that's really what we're honing in on with round one around two Just to clarify so you said Like the total membership of seiu is 48 Is that what you said? So or the year funded positions. I just pulled up because I was like i've been looking at numbers all morning So I wanted

138to make sure I had the correct one. So general funded position. We're at 84. Okay Um, not counting any of our um You were close because the custodial is closer to the number that oh, okay. Well, there's a few other positions We're kind of cross-eyed with numbers. So i'm glad that you clarified that Thank you for clarifying that because I post those two numbers But 84 versus 480 is still a pretty large difference. So Thank you so much. Um, not quite as big but still pretty large gap So so on the sheet you're going to see the management is in yellow. You're going to see csda is blue and la is purple Um, and then you're going to see that some lines are highlighted green So the highlighted green section or lines so that's line

139eight 10 13 16 25 30 31 38 39 and 40 and i'm going to walk you through those but those are the additions from round one to round two The other change on the sheet the only other change on this sheet from round one to round two other than the green highlighted rose um, uh Is line six where we just put a strike through for the two Um site administrators, which are the two high school vps, which was the request of the board I did not want to remove them because it's still something that needs to be on our radar if needed But we're doing everything we can to um to keep them whole. Thank you So let me just walk you through line by line So, um, one of the cost savings measures that

140we're proposing is on line eight, which is cabinet and all lma members So that superintendent cabinet and all lma would take a reduction of five work days um, that is something that We are proposing it comes with an estimated cost savings of about two hundred and seven Seventy thousand dollars. Um, the nice thing about that too is it's something that you know can easily be undone down the road As we continue to improve with our budget How is that? How how can you how can we do that? Is that um? Because are they're not contracts or is that um, because I I mean You know, we were just looking at the contracts with uh, our assistant superintendent of human resources So how does that work like legally or contractually to be able to do something

141like this? That's a great question So for specifically for cabinet members and myself We actually have clauses in our contract that say x y or z happen unless the board does something different Um, so at any time salaries can be frozen like there's lots of things that we can do um unfortunate fortunately slash unfortunately depending on your lens Um administrators are at will employees and so um, we do have a little bit more flexibility. It's not negotiable It's not something that we have to negotiate Um with our administrators. I did get some fee. I sent out an email yesterday to staff We have been Furiously notifying staff of what additions were on here so that there was no surprise to anyone or any department um, I did send out an email yesterday to everyone in

142this category and I received a ton of feedback from Specifically principal saying I would much rather have the five days off than than really cut staff You know, we need our people so um, so that's where we are. That's a great question Really good question um line number 10, um Is the business department and we're really Diving deep into doing you know looking at just what does every single employee do? What do they do? How do they do it? Are we working? Smarter not harder. Are we utilizing? Our online systems. We've discovered that we we do a lot of things by hand entry Instead of pulling reports and doing things one example is you're going to see in upcoming board packets That the warrants are going to look slightly different because someone in the district

143office bless them has been hand entering Every single thing on those documents to present to the board and there's a report that you click a button and a report spits out So it's it's things like that that we're really looking at to you know, kind of right size us a little bit more Um, so we'll be evaluating all of the business re or the business department for a possible reorganization Of eliminating one fte from that department But it says or funding shift But that's a big that's a big or it is a big or but there could be some funding shift options because um, we have That department support to everyone which includes all kinds of grants all kinds of different departments whether it be Let's just use cafeteria, you know type Services as an

144example Bond department some of those functions where you know, we may be able to do some shifting Of how we pay for people so I We always just like to put it all on the table of what our options are. So Line 13. Um, this was on here previously, but it was a 1.0 fte the more, you know We did a little bit more digging into this and we will need to do more between now and our next meeting on february 13th Um to really analyze who does what and how and when in the it department? Um This unfortunately it is one that isn't an or it would be an elimination. There's multiple classifications That's why we don't have specifics on here yet round three anything that is a reorganization So as an example, if

145you go up to lines four and five, you're going to see community engagement On round one that actually showed as a reorganization These actually now show positions so going into round three any of these areas that show as a reorganization If it stays on the list, um, it'll actually have positions on here going forward So that's um it We're looking at um line 16, which is elementary tosa. We had one left that we were drastically trying to hold on to in In our general fund and we really just need to find a way to shift it and that is our goal Ultimately is to shift that funding not to eliminate it But I didn't we can't guarantee that because that means that something else has to shift out of other places in order to shift

146that in um, but i'm pretty confident that miss pichette will 100 find a way to make that work. I forget exactly which lines they were in last in the last report, but it seemed I remember it being in ed services that there were some funding shifts But it was you know We're talking about having somebody getting paid through kind of temporary grant type situation where we You know year by year. We're going to have to try to figure out if we can still get that is that is that sustainable? Is that It's sustainable if we put it over into the l cap, which is really where these positions should be housed. Anyways, okay one thing that's a really great question for an explanation one of the things that miss wasley has discovered is that we

147have I'm going to say multiple but maybe the multiple is a small number a few Positions that we have discovered are 100 funded out of one-time monies and that's how they were key entered into the system and they're Full-time regular positions so they either have to be eliminated or moved This wasn't one of them, but those are the other things that we're finding that end up kind of on these sheets Um because we can't continue to fund them out of one-time monies that don't exist any longer Well, I think related to his question I do have those concerns as well. I know we just got that huge mental health Grant and I know that we're hiring counselors eventually over the next five years at all the elementary schools What happens when that grant? Money ends

148does do those go into the general fund? We have to make sure that we go out and get additional grant funds Okay, because I mean that 100% or they have that is something that I worry about or they have to roll into something Whether it be l cap lcff supplemental or general fund so those Those grant funds are critical for keeping those positions thriving Okay, 100. Yeah, I just want to make sure that we're not flipping about that that we're you know, because We've got to set it and forget it kind of attitude and we can't have that with people's jobs, correct So as grant funds start to expire and we know they're three. Let's say they're three years out Starting in you know during that time frame is when we're going to start adding

149on to the back end of those so that It's just a constant cycle And we have a way that now that we're tracking that To make sure that we don't miss any of those deadlines Okay, that's a great question I think we were on like line 15 16 so when we say eliminate to Tosa positions that doesn't necessarily correct me if i'm wrong, but that means that because they have We call it retreat rights is that the case? So they would go back to the classroom and the potential bump or would be that we have You know 20 some odd Uh temp teachers that are not under contract correct Correct, and we're working very closely with miss thompson and miss letts in regards to Those temporary teacher numbers i'm looking over at miss robbins. Um,

150I know we just sent those today over to them so that our Truly our goal is to hopefully don't hold me to this because there's never any guarantees in 2025 But our our goal is that we can make those adjustments through those temps As well as retirements and just general resignations that happen as life happens for people So that come later on down the road. We won't be giving layoff notices to our for our Permanent staff and I kind of want to recognize, you know, this isn't just like shifting You know, like i'm wearing a red tie and now i'm wearing a pink tie kind of thing We're talking about people and yes, you know credentials, you know that The the toast toast is here may have a secondary credential and there may not be

151a fit there So I want to recognize that this isn't easy um, but i'm also um uh curious I don't know if there's like a line in the sand between when we go beyond the temp teachers that we have and are now into um cuts towards teachers that are fully Certificated and so I don't If we get to that point I think that's something that I want to know because I think that's something that we have to talk to the Be aware of to talk to the community about a hundred percent and that's something that we're going to start working on now Um, I really really encourage people if if you know, you're going to retire Please let us know now so that it saves the position of somebody else the other thing too that

152is Really critical for everyone to keep in mind and our two new people may not may or may not know this When we do the february or march notices, let's say we we notice five teachers By may we have to come up with our final numbers and we may be able to retract all of those that that does happen Very frequently. It doesn't make it any less stress unsettling and stressful for those that are impacted But if we don't notice people by the march 15 deadline then we are in you know, we are stuck there So we just want to make sure but that's something that we are really Going to dig into between now and we have some time We have a month to really sit down and go through those seniority lists and

153make and see where where where things line up because The credentialing is a hundred percent part of the problem. It's not that a credential is a credential is a credential Um, it's not that one credential is more important than the other It's just that some are easier to slide people in and out of than others So we have to go through those lists as well So that's all the behind the scenes work that we will be actively working on asap with the lea leadership team So I think I just want to clarify what you're saying We're hoping not to but if we do have to give layoff notice on march 15th, it doesn't necessarily mean that Those people will be laid off we will know by may but that is the date that we have

154to otherwise We can't that is correct. So So just keep that in mind because sometimes People don't know that they're going to move out of the area until april, right? Maybe a spouse has a job or you know a parent becomes like people have lives and so and life happens So sometimes then those come down the pipe later that aren't anticipated Um, but we will get as close to where we need to be as possible with the most minimal amount of impact that we can make 100 percent Okay Great questions. Um line 25 is also an addition of we're really going to dig into student services um And just look at you know, what does each person do? What are they, you know? What happens within you know, each of these departments and so I

155mean just By putting it on this list and having a conversation with that department some things came to light Thank you to miss christmas for that information That we were not even I don't think any of us were aware of even those who have been in the district We're aware of some things that could that need to be shifted that could make this Less impactful just on the daily work of certain employees So I don't want to get into the nitty-gritty of that because we need to still work on some of those functions But you know, I think the beauty of some of this although it's painful and it's difficult and it's very unpleasant Is that we it does force us all to really examine what we do and how we do it and why

156do we do it? um going we're holding everything up against the light and I think this is a This budget shortfall can also be an opportunity for us to To just be better as a district and i'm i'm i'm hopeful for that and I really appreciate the work that you as a team are doing To to do all the work to hold everything up up to the light including things that are near and dear to your heart So yeah, thank you. Um, the other thing too that's taking place is miss wasley is doing a really deep dive into some comparisons With various departments from other districts that are neighboring to us that we compare ourselves to often I think that's a really important piece for us to look at as well. So she's she's doing

157a deep dive into that Um human resources and we added the district receptionist. Um, you know, this position is great. We love it. It is Busy all the time because we have a flow Um, but it's it's not something that we 100 is required we can You know, we have other things that we can shift within the hr department to make that work. So That's why that's on here. Um special education clerical staff You know as we know special education has a huge magnifying glass on it right now And so having you know, the conversations around again who's doing what and looking at a possible reorganization of clerical staff in that department on line 38 We have a counselor position that is a first generation uh counselor It is an addition to Our regular high

158school counselors Again, it's something that we is near and dear to us we you know, we want to maintain this position But it is not something that is required if needed now As we um, I want to talk a little bit about the counselors because we have a couple on here Um as we receive grant funds, we're hopeful that between now and let's say may As we receive grant funds that we can recoup these people They may not sit in the same position, but we can at least retain the employees. That's our goal We just don't know exactly where we're going to sit yet with those grant funds this early in the year But that is our long-term goal between now and may is to get that sorted out as well The high school athletic

159directors They have assistant athletic directors that receive a stipend And so we're looking to eliminate those stipends from the general fund And we will work with the athletic directors at both the high schools Um As to other ways that maybe that those positions can be funded if they're needed how um Tell me more about that It's probably teachers who yeah, I'm assuming classroom teachers who receive a stipend to support the athletic director Okay, so they receive a stipend goes away The work goes away then as well, correct the work then goes to this the athletic director. Okay Correct because I don't want people doing work and not or a vice principal or that is correct Yeah So so that person just would not receive that stipend and we would not expect them to continue on

160doing that unless they volunteered but that would never be recognized that would then likely place more burden on the athletic directors, but athletic directors vice principals, I mean you have to remember we're maintaining vice principals that we Very much acknowledge. We might be heavy on especially when we're reviewing our neighboring districts System that they're going through simultaneously while we're doing this And they have set ratios for high school vice principals specifically to student ratios and We are far lower than than them So we have to keep you know, it's like it's a give and take Of course, um back to to line 31 real quick. Sure. Um that that You you kind of just yeah, can you describe it a little bit more more in detail what what this Um, yeah, so there's multiple um

161clerical positions in that department um everything from a Gosh, there's the titles. Um, i'm looking over at miss wasley There is an executive assistant and administrative secretary district looks it made me to transportation specialist as well as a Data specialist. Yeah. Yes. Okay. So there's four positions. They all kind of co-mingle and do things They work as a really great team. And so they I mean if I had to Explain what they do They do all of each other's jobs depending on who has the time depending on what projects they each have on their plate So it's kind of a workload kind of situation. We need all these people but if if push comes to shove like it does today We we can maybe consolidate some of these tasks or Spread it out a little

162bit differently correct. And so it doesn't touch students the way that some may fear what about um just i'm I look at lines 33 through 36 and and a reduction of 10 fte's Correct. That sounds like it's gonna touch students Well, not necessarily. Um, we so if you look at line 30, uh, due to do 33 34 and 35 Um Mr. Kolkowski and miss wasley and I all went Actually, it was such a great time We went out to the site yesterday and met with both the del val and vineyard staff and had a great conversation with them Around these particular changes when we sit and look at their enrollment numbers There we are currently spending $35,000 per student to educate students in that program on average Uh On average we spend anywhere from seven

163thousand to ninety five hundred per student across the rest of the district Okay, so it's a matter of having class sizes sit That there are some sections currently today right now that sit at that school in these programs at five We we cannot maintain sections of five with five students in them So it's just a matter of doing business differently. It's not a matter of watering the programs down You know, we want to maintain culinary we want to maintain the art We want to maintain all the things that get students to come to school To do the abc's and the one two threes because they are engaging in other skill sets that will help them in the future Um, but again, we we just we cannot sit at numbers that are currently this more like

164a right sizing It's right sizing. Well, it's a database decision and I really like that how quickly though. Did you guys talk about? What if you have to Scale it up real quick because you've got an influx of 20 more students Whatever great question because those are very specific kind of teachers. Yes, correct So we are not planning on on making them full to capacity. We will always have buffer. So as an example Per the cba they can have up to 20 students in their class on their class loads We're not saying that we want to load them up to 20 We're saying we need to go from maybe five to seven from five and seven to maybe 12 to 16 Um, so we'll always leave that buffer It just really depends on the on

165the subject area and the different different functions Um, this is something that miss rinkin and her race principal have done such an amazing job already of really examining And looking at how they do business. I I do appreciate as well And I think probably this came out of conversation with the teachers And the administrators and thinking of the students in mind if not just eliminating maybe the extracurricular classes like art And and instead just having a little bit larger class sizes so that we can keep those The art and the music and the culinary and the construction classes Yes, especially for I mean as a great example the culinary program at del val If we were to close that program, it would have a huge impact on our adult transition students Because they participate in

166that they you know, they transport over from laurence So there's other impacts that those would have more importantly though than the impact on other programs from my philosophical view Is we have to have the things at school that keep kids coming to school? um, and it can't just be because I like math because not everybody likes math and it can't be just because social studies, right? So we have to have the other things that Whether it's comprehensive site or whether it's at our altar Our alt ed sites. I know one of the concerns from the alt ed staff really focused around Credit recovery at our comprehensive high schools around edgenuity courses And the impact that that ability to offer those credit recovery systems at the comprehensive high schools have on their program And one of

167the conversations we had a long Discussion about yesterday was really around that all of these programs can coexist at the same time Everybody's going to find their niche. Everyone's going to find their student We have everything from dual enrollment to middle college to multiple functions of alt ed to comprehensives So it's it's far more Offerings than students have ever had in the past 35 years ago. You just you went to this or that Was it there was there was there were not five or six options And so, you know that obviously has some impact on this program as well um, but as the ebbs and flows happen of that that program they will Alt ed will not be treated the same as comprehensive for all the right reasons It's it is a different student. It's

168a different teacher. It's a different work mode completely and we we recognize that wouldn't wouldn't you say just A blanket statement that a continuation school is just better than doing some remedial stuff at the Comprehensive high schools, but it's a lot cheaper Um, I I can't say that because every student is different and I think we have to allow students to make the choice There's a danger that you That as a district we go Hey, let's try to keep these students at the comprehensive high schools because we are we've got a budget shortfall. We want to We can save fifteen thousand dollars every student that we know somehow No, I I know I I may have misspoke So the the students who are staying at the comprehensive high schools are maybe down five ten fifteen

169credits They're not down a whole semester or a year There's a there is a tipping point for students when they have to do something different. We're talking a student who So we have to remember kindergarten through eighth grade. You can fail fail fail fail fail and you always progress to the next grade level High school is a whole different animal and students kind of have that shock and awe factor their freshman year Sometimes where or sometimes their sophomore year who knows when they fail a course and you have to make it up And so it's really for those students the the remediation that happens at the comprehensive sites are for those students Who have maybe those one or two moments of stumble? um and often we have students who opt to go over to alt

170ed not because they're credit deficient But because that's where they feel comfortable So the offerings are all it's not just one size fits all for students Thank you. That makes sense. Yeah, that's a great question um, so the final line on uh item 40 is is a Position and it has a 2.3 fte. It's across the board. It's like little smatterings here and there at random schools this is a position instructional PE specialist position where um The positions were created years ago and it just never was really evaluated It was never talked about and it's like a point three here or a point four there or a point two here And so that was just one thing that we talked to the principals about that It's not consistent across the schools. So why did these

171schools have it in these schools? Don't Especially when a hundred thousand dollars of it is general funded. Um, it's it's really an equity issue across our sites Yeah In that question that you asked it. Do we know how many? People are affected by uh line 39 the stipend elimination two One at each school site. Yeah Okay, um a couple other just hold on. I pull up my notes. I don't forget anything So I discussed just kind of the reorg when it shows on here the reorganization that it's really just us doing a deep dive And in round three will provide a very comprehensive list um This current document should be and then we're hopeful that this is the bulk of people That we might have a couple tweaks here and there going forward But when

172we come back on february 13th, we're not going to have we will not have added like 10 more people on here Just so you know, it might be part, you know pulled apart but by department or whatever But just know that this really is the bulk. We're at five point 667 million. So we're really close to where we need to be um, so I just wanted to convey that both to the board as well as our community and our staff that you know None of this is easy. We we wish we weren't in this situation. We are not alone for obvious reasons And we are making every effort to make cuts away from students and impacting them as much as we can in the school sites um In addition on the 13th, we will also

173to get our number higher where we need to get it we'll be adding kind of the behind the scenes things like maybe cuts to School site budgets and things that aren't people related My main goal was to get the people related portion first and we're always talking about the other pieces but just because people knew it was coming and I wanted us to have an opportunity to have conversations with staff to learn and really evaluate I did not want to wait until february 13th to have this Conversation so it's an ongoing work in progress On the 13th, it will be a comprehensive list the board will not be asked to vote on it on the 13th It'll just be informational only and then the last thing Just as a reminder as well The other thing

174the other positions that that could be will be added onto here Our positions that we will be proposing to cut that are not general funded related So we do have some other programmatic things that maybe funds are running out or Those types of functions But right now we're really just focusing on the general general fund balance to make sure that we can get out of qualified status So we'll keep you updated on that as well Do you have some examples of? Roles that would be affected by that Sure, I mean our bond department is one of them. Yeah We have a couple other areas that have that are funded differently Through other types of funding sources that we're examining just to make sure that we don't go in the red Anytime you go in the

175red on any special funding It you have to then pay for a general fund So we want to make sure that those are all secured prior to us moving forward. I would say In all reality. Um It's it's the the bulk of it will be our bond department that we're really examining as those bond funds are are Really shrinking down quickly and yeah Hmm I I have one I keep i'm sorry slow processor. Um going to the semester I'm sorry to the new schedule and semester Are we going to see more students needing? Uh that are credit deficient or are you know where there? Is that we won't know the end. That's a great question. We talked about that yesterday also with the del val and vineyard staff We don't we don't know what the

176impact will be Until we get further down down the road It could because in the past students if you failed trimester one you had two other trimesters to squeeze something in to make it up and so that's something that definitely could have an impact and um, you know, we'll have to find ways to do remediation and And you know use ingenuity and period a and period b for students to be able to make up those credits So that's something that we're working on with the high schools currently That's it. I'm so glad to hear that you that you are talking about that and are super aware of all those factors Yeah, we we have a lot of moving parts all at one time sometimes fortunately sometimes unfortunately it can be a lot but We have

177a meeting with our high school staff tomorrow To really hone in on master scheduling. What is that going to look like? um You know all the functions that come in january of the school year as we're planning for august Eight months later, so it's a great question But I think on that point um An extra semester to make up a class you know, um Can also hopefully be offset by having a continuity with the same instructor for the entire year and building those types of relationships So I think it's not there's not just like one metric of success I think the the most important word on all of this is draft and I think that's for me Um, I want to recognize that there is a push to get to a dollar figure But we

178also want to get there strategically and so I appreciate you and your team focusing on the You know the positions linked with humans first because i'm hoping that as this is a draft We can work or you can we can work with um Organized labor to make sure that we're not cutting off our nose to save our face like 30 39 for example It might be this is going to be catastrophic like it's going to have a cascade of problems because if there's a couple of these that's you know are like like the vps something like that like we Let's let's see if we can find another way because I mean there is a you get to the end and be like We've made it but I think um, so I just I want to

179lean into this as a draft And we want to make sure that we're open to if there's things in here that are going to be Catastrophic or something like that that we can compensate for it in a different way The one thing I will say that I really commend our staff on across the board is this As we are having these conversations with whole departments They are really digging deep to be creative with each other and making suggestions to us That just that happened twice today already as we have had conversations in the last 48 hours with various departments around like You know, can we go to our our organized union leadership and talk about Also doing furlough days for ourselves because those can be temporary, right? That may be a two or three year

180fix and then over time as we improve our budget we can then Put all those days back on Um to save a colleague and to save a position So I really appreciate the creativity and the thoughtfulness that they're putting Into it as a team and as a unit and as hard as this can be sometimes these tough times really bring people together And so I just I really want to thank our staff for that our leadership as well as those in the trenches who You know are affected every day, you know by these conversations, um, because it's it's definitely not easy And you know, we want to be creative We definitely do not want to cut us cut off our nose despite our face We have to be very strategic Which is why we wanted

181to start on this in december and not wait And I mean a lot of districts haven't put any I mean not in this area but Across the state a lot of districts have put nothing out yet Yeah, um and haven't even started the discussions and then they scramble and there's it's I just don't feel that we have that need You know, we know it's happening and we we just have to take it head on I just quickly want to say like steven or sorry. Uh, trustee druane was saying Um that it is a draft and that we're going through and I have to compare draft one to draft two And you know making the notes on it I really appreciate that you've put it out there and for the community to see as well And

182how you are like you said you're collaborating with the unions and you know getting their feedback as well It's just I know it's difficult, but we appreciate the work And for community members who are watching or who see this down the road if you have input ideas by all means You know email us send them call me, you know, we we try to think of everything We try to turn over every rock but you know, we're human too and And we we sometimes miss something. So by all means, please, you know reach out and provide your ideas well in craigs not here But i'm sure craig would also say along the lines of you know, and I don't need a response craig doesn't need a response to this But incoming funds are also part of

183this So if there are community members that would love to help fill the coffers Organizations that can make those lovely donations that also addresses this problem that it's not just has to be cuts If we have more revenue then I was thinking about that too first for like these these stipends What if there's just you know boosters get behind that and go we want to keep these people and And that's what I had a conversation with one of the athletic directors about we had called about something else and then five minutes later he texts and said If it's this or that like i'd rather Have this versus that and this is why because I can I can backfill this with booster like yeah, they're being very crazy I was like, okay. Well, never mind scratch

184this So we're really out we're making those phone calls. We're sending those texts like hey, call me. Let's meet about this Let's have a conversation. Um, I think um, mr Kolkowski and mr Connors and I have had multiple conversations this week about various things and people and so it's it's just a constant conversation that we're having so Um, I also want to say and I would have said this if trustee, um we know it's here, but based on the conversation we had last time in regards to You know capital advisors group that you know He made a really good point that although that may cost us money that it also brings in money for staffing so, um miss bachette met with them and we we found a way to move all of those costs to

185our general fund We have to do a bunch of paperwork fine. We're going to do the paperwork That's the easy part into those grant funds so we can maintain them so that we can start to pull in something because Things like our counselors we we we are building these amazing programs We don't want to be cut out at the knees five years from now from that system So, um, and it's it's expensive It's costly and so we want to make sure that we always have people out there that have the vision of that And so we were able to make those shifts and retain that contract You you alluded I think at the last meeting to also looking at all the service contracts that we have and things like that That's not on the sheet

186correct. So all of that will be added later We have additional programming and different things too that we really need to take a deep dive into but that is going to be In the out years between now and then that just are a little bit more complicated. Um, you know, we have a lot of Um, we have a lot of facilities that are used by outside um organizations that um, we actually We take the brunt of the cost for To be very delicate because it's not that we don't appreciate them and and love them and want them and need them. However Um, we have to also look at ourselves as a business to a certain extent When it comes to some of those things and really take care of us also So it's it's a

187fine balance, but that's those are the other pieces that we're looking at if i'm Being politically delicate. Yeah Well, thank you. I wanted to say just before we end the meeting Um, I really appreciate bringing us along on this From the beginning and and appreciative that we started this as early as we did um I that hasn't been my experience being on this board that we have not been involved this much and this heavily and also neither has the community And so, um, I just appreciate the transparency of it and I think coming from this Hopefully we are getting ideas and thoughts and from the community and from our from our community and from the livermore community at large So I just appreciate you bringing us along on this and with that I think I

188will um Are we good to adjourn the meeting? I know we're kind of on a so we're gonna we're gonna adjourn the meeting at 1203 Here we go Thank you everyone for who came

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.