CorpusRecord 40066

1.14.25 Board Meeting Video

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Vimeo / Livermore Schools
Date
2025-01-17
Location
Alameda County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,648 words · about 37 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Good evening. This is the January 14th board meeting of the Board of Education of the Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District. Our boardroom is open with in-person format. However, we will continue to broadcast our meetings over Zoom to provide the opportunity for our community to observe in real time. The Board of Education of the Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District is now reconvening to open session and it is 7.03 p.m. Please be advised that our board meetings are televised on local channel 28 on Wednesday and Saturday evenings and on Monday, Friday and Saturday mornings. All actions approved in closed session must be reported out. I believe we had no actions taken. So we're going to move on to our Pledge of Allegiance and we would like to invite our Junction Avenue TK through 8 students

002to come up to do our Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. You may now be seated. Thank you to our Junction students. We're going to move on to number seven of our agenda, which is a deletion or correction on the agenda and I'm going to ask Superintendent Gibson if there are any changes to the agenda. Yes, we have tabled item 13.1 for the February 4th board meeting. Okay, thank you. We're going to move on to recognitions and invite Ms. Garza, our proud principal of Junction Avenue TK through 8, to come and recognize our students who are here. Okay, good evening Board President Prusso, members of the board,

003Superintendent Dr. Gibson, cabinet and community. I am Jeanette Garza, the very proud principal of Junction Avenue TK 8 School and I'm here with Mr. Wilkins, who is also one of our vice principals. It is our honor to share details which showcase Junction's Chamber Orchestra. This group of students is a representation of the music program at Junction. Under the direction of the incredible Mr. Smart, Junction Ensemble participated in two music festivals last year, one of which was a competition where Junction was a first-time participant. In that competition, the band placed fourth, choir third, both with excellent ratings, and the orchestra received second place with the highest possible rating of superior. While all of our music students deserve to be recognized for their collective contributions, these particular students are some of the most skilled and dedicated members

004of the program. Our Chamber Orchestra exemplifies the qualities of dedication, detailed analysis and reflection, perseverance, and passion that our Junction musicians have to offer our school and our community. It is with great pleasure that we publicly recognize their efforts here tonight. Without further ado, I would like to call these individuals up to the podium so that you can meet them. So as I call your names, Mr. Wilkins is going to hand you a certificate. I'd like you to walk up and stand up and join us. Starting with the incredible Mr. Smart, Morsal Hashimi, Madison Haydayat, Carlos Lopez, he's not here tonight, but we still need to say his name, Alexander Marchand, Natalie Ngo, Alexandra Nuno Gonzalez, Henry Plummer, Ruby Plummer, Aurelia Taylor, and Lorraine Vildosola. Thank you all very much. Thank you to our Junction

005parents as well for showing up tonight. We'd now like to invite Principal Tammy Rankin to come up for recognition of the DelVal and Vineyard Alternative School Teachers. Good evening, Board President Prusso, members of the board, Superintendent Gibson, cabinet, and community. I am Tammy Rankin, the proud principal of Alternative Education, DelVal Continuation High School, and Vineyard Alternative Schools. In spring 2024, we started the process of creating an alternative education school site. Through the process, site members have worked together to create a shared facility and staff members. Today, I've brought all two members of both schools to recognize their collaborative efforts through this process. Through the move, everyone was always positive and student-centered. We have created an environment that fosters a positive collaborative atmosphere where all in the school community feel valued, supportive, safe, and encouraged. Through

006this process, we created a new logo, and so it's behind your, yeah, you can kind of see it. It is both of our mascots, and Leila Witherspoon, our art teacher that's here with us today, created it so we all felt included as one, so you can see it as you come into our school site. It has our raven and our wolf. I'd like to thank Denise Kear, Jill Hout, Gretchen Reynolds, Leila Witherspoon, and Spencer Phillips for all their collaboration through this process. We are enjoying our new alternative school site together. Thank you to our DelVal and Vineyard teachers. We're going to move on to our student board member reports. This is one of our favorite parts of the evening. We have two student board members from our comprehensive high schools, Livermore High School and Granada

007High School. Addie Hart represents Livermore High School, and Gabriel Benitez represents Granada High School, and we are going to start with Gabriel tonight, and we'll finish with Addie. Good evening, Board President Perusso, members of the board, Superintendent Gibson, cabinet, and community. At Granada High School, our community spirit and dedication to excellence remain high. First up, some recognition. Granada alum Juliana N. Flaherty has published a scientific paper exemplifying the lasting impact of our strong science programs here at Granada. As for athletics, Granada hosted the 24th annual MAT Classic Wrestling Tournament on Saturday, welcoming teams statewide and showcasing our athletic leadership. Safe and sober grad night fundraising efforts continue with numerous fundraisers on the horizon gearing up for a fun-filled night after graduation. For some unique community engagement, the bike mobile event on campus on January 8th

008supported active transportation with free bike tune-ups and maintenance workshops, encouraging sustainable and healthy commuting options. Overall, Granada remains a place of pride, achievement, and community involvement. Stay classy. Good evening, Board President Perusso, members of the board, Superintendent Gibson, cabinet, and community. My name is Addie Hart, and I'm representing Livermore High School. In December, the instrumental music department held their annual holiday concert. The jazz bands participated in the Stanford Jazz Festival and performed in a separate holiday bash for the community. In January, the music department will be hosting 8th grade band and orchestra students from East Avenue Middle School, Christensen Middle School, and Junction K-8 for two combined concerts in the LHS Theater. The combined orchestra concert is on January 22nd at 7 p.m., and the combined band concert is on January 29th at 7 p.m.

009Boys basketball is off to a great start at 13 to 3, including winning the Rockland Tournament. Girls basketball is off to their best start in 8 years as well. Boys soccer took third in the winter soccer classic against 16 other schools. Wrestling has had several successful tournaments, most recently winning the Conquered Contest of Champions. In December, Green Engineering Academy students within the PLTW Civil Engineering and Architecture class presented their affordable housing project proposals to the Livermore Housing Authority. LHA is looking to develop new affordable housing units on underutilized areas within the Lee Square community. Our GEA juniors proposed potential designs and provided feedback that could influence future developments at Lee. PBIS theme this month is on academic tips and behavior expectations. Congratulations to the following students who won Heroes Awards in December. They are recognized

010for going above and beyond by their teachers. Nathaniel Elmido, Collin Smith, Lail Tegni, Erica Strenudu, Gage Santucci, Samantha Vasquez, Amanda Tumi, Kailit Hong, Grant Von Heater, Suhey Thi Lin, Vincente Correa, and Angelica Berrigon. We are thrilled to celebrate the exceptional achievements of our Rotary Winners, Jacob Bogage, Milana Island, and Jonathan Espinosa. Each of these remarkable students exemplifies excellence in academics, leadership, and community service. ASB is hosting a blanket drive until Thursday, January 16th. They're collecting new blankets which can be dropped off in the main office in preparation for TVLC, the annual Tri-Valley Leadership Conference, which is on Friday, January 17th. Leadership cannot wait to be the most spirited school and show off their poke pride. Thank you. Thank you to both of you. We move on to item 10, which is our Employee Association reports,

011and it looks like we do have some representatives from our bargaining units, so I'm going to invite first the president of the Livermore Education Association, Amy Thompson, to come up, and just as a reference, Tara Lutz is also here. She's the vice president. It looks like we have CSEA president, maybe Chris, maybe Kristovic here, and maybe you could come up after. Are you okay? STIU president is Kirsty governor, and CMC is Lily Lopez's representative, so we'll turn the time over to Ms. Amy Thompson. Thank you. Good evening, board president Prusso, members of the board, superintendent Gibson, and cabinet. I'm Amy Thompson, president of the Livermore Education Association, representing teachers, nurses, counselors, psychologists, speech pathologists, and teachers on special assignment. I need to update that to include social workers. We have those now. It has been

012a very busy start to the new year. Some of our middle school teachers had raised concerns about ELD instruction, and I want to thank Michelle Pichette for providing the time and a form for the concerns to be heard, and Matthew Hart for providing a plan to address the concerns. The group is going to start their work this Thursday, so right on it. The first meeting of the special education work group was last week. LEA members were happy to be in the room with their colleagues. It was a very energized environment. They felt valued and heard throughout the process of the first meeting. The first meeting was a really controlled, scaffolded brainstorming process that resulted in the group defining goals for the work that will be happening over the next year, two years, three years, and

013the next meeting is scheduled for February 19th. We're looking forward to our joint interest-based bargaining training that's coming up later this month. Interest-based bargaining is a negotiating approach where the parties really focus on understanding and addressing each other's underlying needs and interests rather than just having positions aiming to fully understand and find beneficial solutions through collaboration and problem solving. I'm hopeful that through training and taking time to build trust that our teams will become truly collaborative in our negotiation sessions with new people on both teams. This is really an ideal time to have the training and for us to work together as a group and to find how we want to work together. In a data-driven district, for me, I think the measurable outcome we'll know when we're really doing this when we look in

014on a room where people are bargaining and what we see is that the teams are sitting with each other instead of across the table from each other and it will be lively. There is going to be conversation. There's going to be brainstorming. People aren't going to be afraid to throw out whatever thought they're having and dissect it and work together to problem solve. Ultimately, that will end up with us being able to provide what's best for our students. Lastly, the annual Alcosta School Board Breakfast is scheduled for February 8th. For our new school board members, Alcosta is our service center council for CTA, and it includes all of the districts in Alameda and Contra Costa Counties. I will be sending all of you invitation and details. Hopefully, you're able to attend. It's a nice event.

015We get the opportunity to break bread together. You get the opportunity to mingle with board members from our neighboring districts and learn more about our organization. Thank you. Thank you, Amy. Amy, good evening. There you go. Good evening, President Prusill, members of the board, Superintendent Gibson, and cabinet members. I am Amy Christovich, president of the Livermore Chapter of CSCA, the California School Employees Association. My VP, Victoria Storti, is also here today. By day, I am the accounting analyst in the business services department that reports ADA attendance and reviews and approves purchase orders for our district. Some of you may recall that I served as president before five years, to be precise, from 2016 through 2020. I never imagined being in this seat again, but you can never say never, as I could not decline the

016honor this year. CSCA represents about 250,000 classified employees throughout California, which includes over 450 here in our Livermore Chapter. We have 39 different job classifications, which is quite a lot. When we think of schools, teachers come to mind, and they should, as we cannot educate our students without our dedicated teachers. While we have incredible CSCA members you may see at our school campuses, many of us work behind the scenes to make sure the wheels continue to turn district-wide. In the coming days, I will acquaint you with the essential work that we do and the issues that we face. One of the top issues for us at the moment is our budget reductions and how they will impact our work and our lives, and like everyone else, we are eager for closure. I appreciate Dr. Gibson's

017efforts in exploring innovative ways to minimize classified employee layoffs, and I look forward to more updates. I serve as a conduit for my members, and I take that role very seriously, because the absence of information often gives rise to anxiety and inaccurate speculation. Before I close, I would like to share something profound that happened right before winter break. In 2017, my negotiations team and I proposed the Job Experience Program, which allows CSCA members to apply for long-term but temporary vacancies that occur at our district due to leave, such as family leave. The impetus for the Job Experience Program was to provide professional growth to existing employees so that they may develop the needed skills and experience to be competitive for promotions later. It is my firm belief that developing our employees is smart succession planning

018and makes them feel valued and appreciated. The district did not disagree, and a Job Experience Program went into our collective bargaining agreement that year. To my dismay, while the premise made sense to everyone, it was never put into play. There was always a reason to not approve it. That changed a few weeks ago, however, when a six-month substitute opportunity came up in the Business Services Department. After analyzing the possibilities and working through the details, I approached Dr. Gibson with the Job Experience Program, and without hesitation, she said two words, do it. With these two little words, we're offering Abra De La Torre, a paraeducator of seven years, the opportunity to learn new skills as an accounting specialist. And in return, we have a happy employee who will do her best work and continue to be

019an asset for our district. I told Abra that I would be talking about the job experience tonight, and she wanted to be here. She's sitting right there next to Victoria. Now you know that this is a true story and not something I just made up for effect. This is truly the right thing to do, and I applaud Dr. Gibson for trusting me and recognizing the value in developing classified employees. It may seem like one small act, but for Abra, it is life-changing. She is extremely grateful for the opportunity, and I am beyond excited to finally see our Job Experience Program put to use. Hopefully, this is the first of many more to come. I look forward to working with Dr. Gibson and our district leaders and engaging you with CSCA news and events. Thank you

020for your time. Thank you. I'm going to move on to item 11, which is the public comments on non-agenda items. If you would like to address a topic that is not on the agenda, now is the time to do so. I have not received any TAN cards, so we'll move on to communications. A formal written correspondence to the Board of Education shall be acknowledged if received by the board or in the superintendent's office by 4 p.m. the day before the meeting. Formal written correspondence received after the cutoff time will be acknowledged generally at the following meeting. Just as a note, our board electronic communications is received via the Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District website by accessing the formal written correspondence to the Board of Education link with all fields completed and verified. That is

021what is treated as formal written correspondence. I'd ask our clerk if there's any correspondence for the board, and if so, if he could please summarize for us. Yes. Christy Starkovich, Lawrence Elementary Principal, received a letter from Leader in Me congratulating them on earning recognition as a 2024 Leader in Me Lighthouse Academic Honor Roll School. Page O'Callaghan Jones, community member, commented in regards to LVJUSD's current budget situation, the assistant superintendent positions, and the HR changes. George Macris, parents, commented hoping action could be taken to ensure that accommodations can be made for his daughter's disability. Lainey Pascal and a group of parents, students, and community members and organizations who are deeply invested in making sure our schools are safe and supported spaces for LGBTQ plus youth. So there was a letter on that. The following correspondence were

022received after the agenda was published, but before the 4 p.m. cutoff time, the day before the board meeting, Junelle Harris, parents, requested a vote no or postpone to delay the LCAP responsibilities for PCIC. And Don Juan Troba, parents, expressed concern over PCIC converting to LCAP and requested to postpone the action item. Thank you. We're going to move on to our discussion action items. And I believe 13.1 was removed from the agenda, postponed actually until February 4th for people who are interested. And then so we'll now move on to 13.2, which is our formal acceptance of the 23-24 fiscal year annual district audit. So I'm going to invite Ms. Kayla Leslie to present. Thank you and good evening. I believe we have our audit partner Jeff Nigro from Nigro who will be presenting the results of

023the district audit from 23-24 fiscal year. So I think right now Michelle is getting him and I believe he is on. Good evening. We've had a little bit of technical difficulties getting our video feed up, I believe, from Zoom. There we see you. All right. Great. Good evening. And is there, Kayla, is there a slide presentation? I don't see. I don't see it. No, okay. Do you see it now? Yes. Okay, perfect. So yes, I will advance for you on each slide. Okay, very good. I can't see all of you right now. All I see is myself in the slide. So I'm going to go ahead and present. First of all, thank you for the opportunity to present the audit tonight. I've been the district's primary audit partner for the last six years, which means

024this current fiscal year, I won't be able to be the partner anymore. So I'm handing off my partnering responsibilities to one of my other audit partners, but it's been a pleasure serving the district and looking forward to this presentation. So the 23-24 fiscal year is well in the rear window now. We're well past the halfway point of the new fiscal year, but obviously the timeline of the audit is different. And so here we are presenting it in January. And so I'm not going to go through every bullet point in the slide, but essentially I think this is one of the more important things is to understand what the audit is, why it's important. And yeah, it's an education code requirement, but essentially what the primary objective of the audit is for the auditor to give

025an independent opinion of the district's financial statements. So in September, you adopt those unaudited actuals. And we give assurance that those financial statements are prepared in accordance with what we call GAP, G-A-P, that stands for generally accepted accounting principles. Now, during the course of our audit, we also look at internal controls, and we have to look at a number of state and federal regulations. The audit's not designed to look for fraud, waste, or abuse. I know that usually disappoints a lot of people because they think that's what we're doing, but that's really not the type of audit that we're doing. There are those types of audits, but that's not what the annual audit does. Next slide, please. So the audit's done in phases. We begin the audit in the spring or actually sometimes as early

026as late winter when we go out to the school sites and we'll do attendance testing at some of your school sites. We'll look at ASB funds. We'll do an audit of some of the ASB funds and look at the internal controls over money coming in and money going out. Then we do an interim audit at the district office level where we'll come out and look at internal controls, processes. We'll look at a lot of state and federal compliance areas. The books aren't even closed yet at that point, so those are the areas that we focus on there. And then we come out in the fall after you've adopted the inaudited actuals, and that's really where we start auditing the numbers and start looking at the financial statements and finishing up a lot of those compliance

027areas. And then thanks to GASB, the Governmental Accounting Standards Board, we also look to make sure the districts implemented all the latest GASB standards for accounting and financial reporting. Next slide, please. And in our independent auditors report, I'm going to walk you through the next three sections. We're going to hit the report highlights. The independent auditors report has what we call an unmodified opinion, which is a clean opinion, and that's what you want to get from the auditor. Basically, that the financial statements are in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles. Any exceptions would be noted in that report. Now, as we go through the report, after our opinion, which actually takes three pages, is management's discussion and analysis, MD&A, which is I like to refer to this as a section of the audit report for

028those of you who just want a quick overview. You don't want to read through the whole report. You just want to see the highlights. That's the section for you. It's meant to be written a little more in layman's language. It gives a lot of comparative information without getting into all the grubby details of the report itself. And so, the MD&A section is in there to highlight that. Go ahead. The actual financial statements themselves, again, I don't want to take up too much time or get too technical here, but there are different types of financial statements starting off on pages 11 and 12, or what we call the government-wide financial statements. And they're there to present the district's financials as a whole. So, it looks at all the district's funds combined. And it also includes things

029like capital assets, long-term debt. So, it's really a big picture look at the district. It's not the financial statements that you're typically seeing when you look in the SACS forms that get filed with the state. These are required under GASB, but essentially it looks at a big picture of the district, district-wide. We can go to the next. And then, the fund financial statements are after that. And that's the type of financial statements that you're more used to seeing, where we just focus on current assets and current liabilities. And we look at the fund balance. And that fund balance is really a better measure of liquidity and district solvency. Now, after the financial statements are the notes. And the notes are there to provide more detail, more information, kind of the story behind the numbers, really.

030And so, most of the information in the statements is detailed there, in greater detail. There's a lot of information about pension plans, STRS and PERS, about the district's retiree health plan, about debt, and so forth. So, a lot more detail in the notes, more than most people care to look at, but it's all there. So, the next. Okay. And then, we have supplementary information. So, this section is information that's required by GASB, as well as by the state controller's office. And they're the agency in Sacramento that receives and approves the audit report. So, they require certain information in the audit, as well as what GASB requires. So, there's schedules in there, a budgetary comparison schedule, which shows the budget from adoption all the way to the end of the fiscal year. So, when you look

031at that schedule, you'll see the budget that was adopted in June of 2023, and then the final budget, how it looked when the books were closed for the fiscal year. And then, it compares to actual results. Then, there's some schedules required for other things, a trend schedule, which is required by the state controller's office, which shows the district's either deficit spending or surpluses over the last few years in the general fund. Next slide, please. These other independent auditors' reports, there's basically three letters towards the back of the report. And I'll just summarize what each of the letters is talking about, but the first one is really a letter that says that, yes, we looked at your financial statements, but we also were looking at your internal controls. And if we found any areas of weakness

032that we felt was a significant deficiency in internal control, we would report it to you as a finding. And then, the other letters talk about state compliance and federal compliance. The state compliance letter lists out all of the different areas of state compliance that we have to audit. And every year, that list gets greater and greater as the state adds more and more restricted programs to the list. This past year, the biggest addition to the audit guide was for the Expanded Learning Opportunities Program, ELOP, as well as TK. And those programs, the states invested a lot of money in those programs, and so they put a lot of compliance requirements in those programs, which caused a lot of extra audit work on our part to make sure the district was complying with those areas. And

033again, those letters are just saying that if we found any areas of noncompliance, they'd be reported in the back of the audit report as findings. Let's go to the next slide, please. Now, the schedule of audit findings, this is towards the back of the report, but it's usually where most people go to first. I know that. I'm very pleased to report that we have no findings in any of the areas, the financial statements, the state compliance, or the federal compliance for this fiscal year, and that's quite a rare achievement. Our audit firm audited close to 70 school districts this past year, and I think there were only five or six that had no findings this year because of all the new areas. And there were no prior year audit findings either, and had there been,

034we would report those back to you and tell you what the district has done to correct those. But there were none. That takes you to the end of the audit report. And again, I appreciate the opportunity to do this remotely. Not that I don't enjoy coming up to Livermore, but I do appreciate the chance to just stay at home this one evening. And I'd be happy to answer any questions you might have. Thank you. We have no blue cards, so I've asked board members if they have any questions or comments. That's one question. Yeah, go ahead. I know there's Craig Bueno. I'm not sure if you can have a visual on us yet. I actually can see you all now. Although I feel like I'm up on the ceiling looking down at you. It's a

035bird's eye view. In your role as an auditor, so be it. I'm wondering, is there going to be a rotation? Do you know how that goes? I know that there's some kind of mandate in terms of the personnel. Yes, Mr. Bueno. So actually, this audit just completed was my sixth consecutive year. And the education code requires a partner rotation at the end of six consecutive years. So there will be another partner assigned on the audit for the 24-25 fiscal year. So I won't be able to work with you this coming year, but you'll be in good hands. I kind of had a good feeling about that. So that's why I was asking because you're the second rotation since I've been on the board and you guys have done just an outstanding job. The nature and

036how articulate you are and the attention to details greatly appreciated. And also calling out publicly, the no findings. And I think that some people may not realize how convoluted and complicated these budgets are. It's not just the dollar amount. It's the methods, the methodology behind it, both income and outflow. And you guys are able to capture that and down to the level of ASB. So it's greatly appreciated. It's been great working with you. And I look forward to continuing working with Nigro and Nigro. Thank you. And I would just ask one question. In the past, we've always gotten a hard copy, a spiral. And I just wonder if those are available to us this year. This is the first year since I've been on the board. We didn't get a hard copy. Okay. Good to

037know. I did order additional copies so I can make sure you get a copy of them. Okay. It's nice to be able to keep those from year to year because they're so concise in their auditing that you can go year over year and you can do comparisons to see where changes were. Absolutely. Yes. I will make sure you get those. Thank you. There are no other comments or questions. I'd entertain a motion. This is an action item. I move in support of the superintendent's recommendation on this item. Yeah, I'll second that. So we have a motion by Trustee Bueno, seconded by Trustee Vanden Heuvel. Is there any discussion on the motion? If not, I'd ask the clerk to please take roll. Trustee Kaplanis? Aye. Trustee Bueno? Aye. Trustee Vanden Heuvel? Aye. Myself? Aye. President Prusso?

038Aye. That motion carries unanimously five zero. Thank you once again for coming. Thank you very much. Okay. We're going to move on to our consent items. We have 16 consent items on the consent agenda this evening. Is there a board member who wishes to remove an item for separate discussion and approval? 1A. Okay. Trustee Bueno would like to move 1A. Okay. You can discuss it first. Okay. And then it either all gets voted on or we pull it and don't vote on that item at all. Okay. So we'll go ahead. Yeah, because the format's changed. Yeah. Yeah. Thank you. Go ahead. Yeah. Let's see my question here. And I just want to let Jen know, our board secretary, that I appreciate the revisions. This has to do with the board minutes from November the 18th.

039And I just wanted to clarify, because I did capture the changes, and so thank you. I just want to ask our superintendent, because at the meeting, I just want to clarify this. It was my understanding at the meeting that the district issued credit cards were in fact new. I did understand that. But in that they were being issued to new personnel. But it was, it is my understanding also that the issuance isn't an expansion of the district credit cards. And what it comes down to is the question is, it's not an expansion. It was just, we had new people. So if we had three cards before, it's three new people have cards. That was my question. No, I don't think that is correct. Do you want to answer that question, Kayla? Maybe that is correct.

040So with the credit cards, I know replacements occurred from my position and the turnover to get everything in my name versus prior assistant superintendent of business services. And then I'm trying to remember if the superintendent's credit card was new or had been a replacement in that position as well. Typically, I know I looked at it when we were starting into all of this, but I can confirm that and get back to you. Okay. And it just, I know how, because I actually made the motion after the clarification. And then when we caught the minutes, it didn't capture the comments. And my question comes as I want to determine, my impression was when making the motion to move for the credit cards was that it is not an expansion of our credit cards. So my question

041would be, does the authorization expand the number of district issued credit cards, the personnel authorized to use such cards or the parameters by which any of these cards may be used? Additionally, will there be oversight? It says there is, but will the oversight include unredacted credit card statements reviewed by the full board? And I asked this as a board member who's been on here for a decade, there was quite a problem just prior to me coming on this board with credit cards. And this isn't just a matter of ethics. It's a matter of fiduciary responsibility and also perception and maintenance of the public trust. I've been in government a long time and credit cards, when you expand those programs, all it takes is a perception that there's a problem. And so I want to make

042sure that the public watching that if it is an expansion, then we see, yeah, it's an expansion. They're easier to use and it's more convenient. We can save money. That's fine. But I want to make sure that the oversight component includes unredacted review of the credit card statements. So the credit card statements are a public record. So at any time, of course, they can be viewed by anyone at any moment. Absolutely. The only people that actually have district credit cards are cabinet members. We authorize our staff to use those, let's say to pick up lunch for a meeting or whatever the case may be, always receded, those types of functions. So in that regard, then no, it's not an expansion. It's not as if five new staff members have credit cards at different levels that

043we didn't have in the past. Okay. If that makes sense. That makes sense. Okay. Thank you. Sure. Okay. Yep. So we can, yeah, because of the form, we can put it right back in and just move them all. All right. So I would entertain a motion of the consent items in their entirety. A second. I didn't move. So we have to move first and then a second can happen. So I move that we approve consent items. Would it be just one through eight in their entirety? I think that's yeah. Okay. We're working with a new system. So we're all, we're kind of learning. And then trustee Kaplanis, if you want to, you can second now. Yeah. Yeah, I'll second. So we have a motion by trustee Druin. Seconded by trustee Kaplanis. Is there any discussion

044on the motion? I'd ask the clerk to please take roll. Trustee Bueno. Aye. Trustee Vanden Heuvel. Aye. Myself. Aye. Trustee Kaplanis. Aye. President Preso. Aye. That motion carries unanimously five zero. Then move on to reports and requests. We're going to give each board member some time and we'll begin with trustee Vanden Heuvel. All right. I, it's been really fun to get to know some of the staff here at the district, both through, you know, some, some Christmas parties with the MOF and the administrative office or the administrative staff and site staff. Perfect timing to be onboarded and get hazed at these, at these meetings. Also really enjoyed the those, that GEA housing proposal presentation from all these different groups. I think we laughed a lot. I mean, it was, you know, you'd think that we'd

045be dry, but no, it was really, really fun. So and then of course also the, the instrumental music department holiday concert at LHS since my daughter played percussion in that concert. Love it. Love to see all the amazing talent here in, in the district. It's kind of fun to see that coming through Mr. Smart here at junction as well. That's it. Thank you. Trustee Kaplanis. Okay. I just wanted to say like trustee Vanden Heuvel how much it was appreciated to be a part of all the holiday gatherings to meet with different people in the district and different administrators and teachers while traveling to different school sites. And then of course, during the holiday gatherings, I also want to say that this has been heavy on my heart. My heart goes out to anybody that has

046any loved ones down in Southern California that's been affected by the fires. Just kind of make mention of that. But to get back to my reports and updating, I've been learning a lot, engaging at different school sites, going to the presentation at LHS. I also made it out to an LHS women's soccer game and quickly realized how cold it is in January at the stadium. So I'll be prepared for more, more games. And I plan to make it out to Granada's sporting events. And I do want to say that I really appreciate it. The band, the orchestra, or what was it? The music that was at the holiday party. Oh, it was spectacular. The choir, it was spectacular. So I will not miss one of those again. That was awesome. Thank you. Trustee Bueno. Thank

047you. The holiday stuff is always good. And the hospitality of maintenance and operations facilities was very much appreciated. They do a lot of work in it and all the facilities, including where we're at right now. Sometimes I think a CSCA made a little comment about people always focus on the teachers. And we should because that's the direct connect. But it's one component. It's a very important component. But it takes the clerical and it takes the maintenance folks and the janitor. It takes everyone to make this place tick. There's somewhere an area of 1600 employees, 1700 employees, something like that. And it takes everyone that's here. So people are appreciated. And I'm one who appreciates them. I know we're coming into just in a few days, we're going to have an inauguration. And I was on

048this board when we had the last couple inaugurations. And I know that it caused a lot of consternation among some of our folks in the district, especially some of the kids because I remember going out and meeting with our congressman's rep and the police chief and our superintendent and meeting with some of the kids that felt fear. And I want to make sure that those kids that are there and those parents, they know they have a receptive ear. If that should come up, if it should percolate up. And so that's an important component. And I've always voiced that my own father didn't speak English when he started school. And our family is one of immigrants and I completely empathize with their situation. And I want to make sure that kids feel safe. Someone coming out

049of public service. And speaking of that, I got two sons that are in the service. I got a lot of brothers and sisters, not literally, but from the profession that are down there with some even some extended family that live down there in the Palisades. And so that is devastating. I responded to the Oakland Hills fire and a lot of those fires down south in my career. And I don't think we can be generous enough. It's devastating to lose a community. And this isn't a block or a home. If you have a fire in your apartment complex and you get smoke in your house, it's a life-changing event to lose blocks, let alone miles of homes. The infrastructure won't be ready to build those homes for a long time. Look at Paradise and the Tubbs

050fire up north. They're going to find a lot of people, unfortunately, in those houses, but to rebuild those communities is going to take a long, long time. And so I just hope that this great state is able to stabilize around that and to help those people. And I think that in our current president, and I hope in the next one, that we're there for those people. It's going to be a truly life-changing event for the state of California. Thank you. Trustee Druin. I enjoyed all the holiday events. I agree with Trustee Kaplanis. Livermore High School's choir is phenomenal if you have a chance to hear them. But I went to other music programming as well, which was also phenomenal for different reasons. Today I attended PCIC, which is the Parent Club Information Council. And lastly,

051over Thanksgiving break, my family had the privilege of visiting friends that live in Germany. And we were invited to tour the secondary school. And our children were allowed to attend class for a day, which was a fun experience. In Germany, secondary schools are mostly similar to schools in the U.S., but there's a few stark differences that I'd like to share. So first, tracking. Most students in Germany are tracked into one of two middle slash high schools beginning in fifth grade. One school is for college slash university schooling, and the other is for preparation for vocational education. I did learn that it's not as rigid as it used to be, and some students do move between, but it's rather rare. And there are some schools that are some newer, more progressive schools that are mixing to

052try to have these two kind of groups of students mix. Second, language training for students whose primary language is not German is rather limited. They're offered one period of German language instruction, and the rest of their schooling is kind of sink or swim. Third, there are no substitute teachers. If a teacher is ill or out, student schedules are modified that day, and they either have a free period or attend a different teacher, and their schedule is, again, updated. So in the morning, students pull out their device, and they look at what their schedule is for the day. And even at the school that we visited, their classrooms change from day to day, so you don't go to this classroom every day. As such, students have to check their mobile phone app schedule each morning to

053confirm what their day will be like. Finally, there are no school counselors and limited socio-emotional supports. So we were walking past kind of a row of offices, and she said, this is where the social worker works. And I said, you know, what about the counselors of the school psychologists? And she looked at me like I was insane. And she said, we don't have that. And we kind of moved on. And it wasn't until later that I talked to other people. So I was a little confused and shocked by this. And then I realized that given that Germany has universal health care, the psychological needs of students are not handled by the school, but by the health care system instead. And this was kind of mind-blowing for me. As we within, you know, California take on

054more as far as students' psychological needs, students' general health and well-being, to not have that be part of the school system was, again, it took me hours to figure out why they didn't have counselors at the school site. So it was a remarkable experience that helped me better understand the strengths and limitations of our public school system comparatively. And it's not that we should jump to them or that they are wrong. It's just different ways of providing for the needs of students. So thanks. Thanks, Stephen. That's really interesting. I saw our student board reps perk up when they thought, oh, free period when the teacher can't be there that day. Very exciting. That's like college. You'll be there next year. Thank you, everyone, for your reports. It feels like forever ago that we met. Christmas

055break feels like three years, smashed into two weeks. So I just want to touch on several similar items as everyone else. Of course, the green engineering housing, I think it was the water drainage that we were laughing at. There was a lot of focus on water drainage in an area where we don't really have a lot of water, which was great. It was really fun. But I also wanted to draw attention to the budget workshop that we had in December, where we discussed our budget and some ideas for how we can make cuts to our budget. We're going to have another workshop this Thursday. Obviously, this is a big focus of not just our district right now, but districts all over the state and probably the country, as many districts are in the same situation.

056And I just wanted to say I appreciate very much the collaboration of cabinet, of the unions who are all working together to come up with some creative solutions for this. Obviously, we're going to do our best to keep the cuts away from students as much as possible. But I just wanted to say that I am grateful for everyone for understanding and for working hard on this as well. And then just in closing, I also wanted to just say that my thoughts, my prayers are out to the people in our state in Southern California who have experienced such heavy loss, and that loss may not be over. And it just seems very surreal that we're so close and yet feel so far from where they are. And in the next years, as Trustee Bueno has said,

057there's going to be a lot of recovery and a lot of rebuilding. And hopefully, there are some things that we can do to help those communities down there. I'm sure that within our community, we'll be able to come up with some solutions and some ideas. I know we did so with the Paradise Fire as well. And so I'm looking forward to working with our community and coming up with some ways that we can send our support to them. And with that, I'll turn the time over to our superintendent, Dr. Tori Gibson, for her report. I always like going last because you all cover everything that's on my list. Everything from all of the wonderful holiday things to some of the upcoming things that we have going on. I was going to talk about the SPED

058work group. So thank you, Amy, for covering that. Again, a huge thank you to Amy and Tara. I think I said this every board meeting because we're always working on something. Huge thank you to the two of them. They put the work group together and it is a phenomenal group of people from all aspects of our district. It was a little bigger than we had anticipated and I was a little nervous. Coordinating 50 adults is not an easy task, let me just tell you, but it was seamless. It was great. From there, we are going to, within that group, they created what we pair down to actually six, I think, action items. And so we're going to have to break those up for a time frame. It's going to take us a couple of years

059to get there, but the goal will be that we provide them some options of work group teams that they'll work in so we can be doing multiple things simultaneously. Otherwise, it'll take us 10 years to get the action items done, but we will do those work groups all in the same room at the same time so that if they're working on something and somebody across the room has the knowledge and the team does it, then they can collaborate. I've done this process before and it works really well to get multiple things done all at the same time. So I'm really excited for that February meeting. We have a February meeting scheduled and a March meeting for now and then two in August right before we come back and then we'll see how we feel about

060April and May, which tend to get a little crazy. Might try and fit one into April, we'll see if we have room, but I'm really looking forward to working with that group. Super excited about IVB training coming up next week. We have two days of that. I think the only new thing I have that nobody has this information because I have it in my email about 20 minutes ago is our by trustee area county committee meeting has been scheduled for February the 11th at 6 30 p.m. here in this boardroom. So we'll be working with Ms. Dawson to get that information out to our community, all of the community partners, and Michelle and I will be presenting kind of the process that we went through. It looks like we have satisfied a lot of that,

061but this is the next step in the process. So I'm excited that that is scheduled and we can move forward with that. Other than that, yeah, the budget is weighing heavily. So that's what we have been working on day in and day out. So other than that, that's all I have for now. Thank you. So we have a special board meeting that will be held this Thursday, January 16th here at 9 30 a.m. And then our next regularly scheduled board meeting will be held Tuesday, February 4th. Also here at the district office, which is 685 East Jack London Boulevard. And the open session at that meeting will begin at 7 p.m. This meeting is now adjourned at 8 3 p.m.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.