CorpusRecord 40067

12.17.2024 Regular Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Vimeo / Livermore Schools
Date
2025-01-08
Location
Alameda County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
30,230 words · about 168 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening welcome you guys quieted down so quickly nice job this is the December 17th board meeting of the Board of Education of the Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District our boardroom is open with an in-person format however we will continue to broadcast our meetings over zoom to provide the opportunity for our community to observe in real time the call to order and it is 5 33 p.m. before we go to our first item which I think is part of the reason why we have so many people in the crowd it's very exciting to have so many people here I was not planning on having to search for a parking spot when I got here so something exciting must be happening and that is going to be our second agenda item I'm going to turn

002the time over to Dr. Gibson to introduce our newly elected board members thank you and welcome to all of our community for coming out this evening to welcome our two new board members at this time I would like to ask Dr. Dina Caponis and Mr. Christian Vanden Heuvel to please come here and I will do the swearing in portion when you're done we will have you come up and just take a seat in one of these two open seats we will most likely do kind of some juggling in between but for now we'll have you come on up after I swear you in congratulations welcome thank you could we have our brand new trustees please come up I told them both that for the for one year they're allowed to say I'm new here can

003you please explain this and after that then then that's it they're experts after that okay so the next part of the meeting is our organizational meeting and the organizational meeting is a traditional part of the end of the year calendar so that the interesting thing about education is the majority of everything we do is on a fiscal calendar meaning July 1 through June 30th then they throw in election cycles and other rules to us that split up the year and this happens to be one of them in addition to our organizational meeting which is where the board chooses to elect a president and a clerk of the board that is a portion of the meeting that I also run so at this time we will take a motion for to elect president of the board

004for 2025 is there a motion I move to nominate Emily Prusso to serve as board president miss miss Prusso do you trustee Prusso do you accept that position that nomination I do is there a second I second let's take a roll call vote trustee Bueno trustee Kaplanis aye Prusso aye you get to vote for yourself yes trustee Druin aye and trustee Vanden Huvel aye motion carries congratulations to Emily Prusso as the next continuing as the president we will do the same process for election of our clerk for the board for 2025 is there a motion I move that we nominate Stephen trustee Stephen Druin as board clerk trustee Druin do you accept that nomination I do is there a second thank you trustee Bueno we will do a roll call vote trustee Bueno trustee Kaplanis

005aye trustee Prusso aye trustee Druin aye trustee sorry Vanden Huvel aye motion passes congratulations so at this time we have about 22 minutes we will go ahead and have a short reception the board can come to the community and we can interact do congratulations if you like photos please this is the time to do that we will need to start our regular meeting right at 6 p.m. so please enjoy and we have some some refreshments over here and again a warm congratulations to the both of you and we're really excited to have you both on our team thank you welcome this we're reconvening back into our open session and this is the December 17th board meeting of the Board of Education of the Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District our board room board room is

006open with an in-person format however we will continue to broadcast our meetings over zoom to provide the opportunity for our community to observe in real time the Board of Education of the Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District is now reconvening to open session and it is 7 o 7 p.m. please be advised that our board meetings are televised on local channel 28 on Wednesday and Saturday evenings and on Monday Friday and Saturday mornings we will continue we will move to agenda item 8.0 which is a report on a closed session action all of our actions approved in closed session must be reported out and I have asked trustee Bueno if he would please report absolutely or took three actions the first is in closed session we the board voted 5-0 to release one temporary certified

007employee from their position pursuant to Ed code section 44 954 the second action the board voted unanimously in support of the superintendent's recommendation pursuant to Ed code 48918 to approve the stipulated expulsion of student D the third and final action in support of the superintendent's recommendation the board the board voted 5-0 pursuant to Ed code section 48918 to approve the stipulated expulsion of student E as an Edward that is all thank you we'll now move on to agenda item 9.0 and I'd ask superintendent Gibson if there are any changes to the agenda yes sorry is my microphone working there we go yes at this time I'm going to request that the board take action to remove item 17.3 B and C at this time those items have not been ratified yet by SCIU and we'll

008bring those back upon ratification from that particular bargaining unit so I request that we have a motion and a vote please through remove those from the agenda present Prusa I move to support this superintendent's request to remove items one seven point three B and C at this time I second we have a motion by trustee drew in seconded by trustee Kaplanis is there any question on the motion or comment on the motion and I'd ask the clerk to please take roll trustee Kaplanis aye trustee Vanden Heuvel aye trustee Bueno myself aye president Prusot aye that motion passes unanimously we're gonna move on now to our Pledge of Allegiance we would like to welcome the Livermore High School Shooting Stars to please come up and lead us in the pledge come on up and stand up

009here behind. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands one nation after God indivisible with liberty and justice for all. Thank you to the Shooting Stars I believe that was our best Pledge of Allegiance and it is a high bar and that was really absolutely the best so thank you. We'll now move on to our recognitions we'll invite principal oh principal how would come on up thank you okay I like having my sister right here. Good evening president Prusot members of the board superintendent Gibson and cabinet members thank you for the opportunity to recognize outstanding students and staff at Livermore High School. Shooting Stars is a program at Livermore High School dedicated to fostering inclusion teamwork and meaningful connections among students of all

010abilities. A corner shown of the program is the Shooting Stars cheerleading team composed of students in the special education program. This inspiring team performs at spirit rallies, junior varsity football games, and other local events promoting school spirit and inclusivity throughout the community. The idea for the Shooting Stars cheerleading team came as a way for Livermore High School to foster an environment where students of all grades and abilities can participate in spirit activities, showcase their talent, and strengthen the sense of unity within the student body. As part of their recognition as a sports team, each member of the Shooting Stars will receive a varsity letter at the end of the season, a testament to their hard work and dedication. At its heart Shooting Stars is about creating a school community where every student feels valued and

011supported. Participants gain personal growth, leadership skills, and the joy of making a positive impact, exemplifying the very best of what it means to be a cowboy. The student participants with us tonight from grades 9 through 12 are Craig Walkup, Eleanor Eklund, Lars Harvey, Wyatt DeBurry, Landon Berg, and Eric Valdez. Other students include Priscilla Beltran, Santiago Fuentes, Trevor Kiran, Aaron Valdez, Leila Patrick, Liz Bacuris, Caitlin Storm, and Margaret Gleason. Now, so none of this would be possible without the dedication of the coaching staff, who generally volunteer their time twice a week during lunch for practice. The student coaches are Abby Darling, Addie Hart, Alyssa Ramon, Ava Rogers, Kara Denison, Finley Seif, Jordan Houser, and McKenna Couch. The staff coach is Kennedy Self, who I think is going to say a few words. Shooting Stars exemplify the

012power of unity and the impact of creating opportunities for all students to thrive. Thank you for celebrating their achievements and the supportive community they inspire. Hello, I'm Kennedy Self. I had the opportunity to be a part of this team when I was in high school, and it meant so much to me. The program was ran by Tracy Dreher and Julie Wright, and it was created by Erica Grudel. They really set the standard for the inclusions for the students at Livermore High School, so that was really awesome to experience. So when I came to work at Livermore High School, and I saw that no one had volunteered to coach yet, I was excited that I could potentially be a part of the program again. I was even happier that the staff at Livermore High School was

013even more enthusiastic to let me take over the program. I just wanted to say to all the students that your classmates, teachers, and I are here to support and encourage you every step of the way. We believe in you and everything you are capable of achieving. Thank you for being who you are, and for allowing me and all of your friends to be a part of your lives. You are truly amazing, and I'm so grateful for each you guys. So thank you. I've been told that the shooting stars perform at the Livermore High School basketball games, so anyone who is interested in watching a performance, that would be a great place to catch them. So thank you so much for coming here tonight. Now we're going to invite Principal Starcovich. There she is from Lawrence

014Elementary for our for our next recognition. OK, good evening, Board President Prusso, members of the board, Superintendent Gibson and cabinet, and of course, our community members in the audience. It is a great honor for me this evening to recognize two incredible individuals who make a world of difference in our school every single day, Rebecca Pareta and Erin Vanchak. First, first, let me say that our school community is built on dedication, energy and collaboration of so many people. But there are some individuals whose contributions truly stand out. And Rebecca and Erin are two of those exceptional individuals. Rebecca is our office specialist, is often the first face that students and visitors see when they walk into our school. Her warm and welcoming spirit set the tone for an entire school community. Rebecca does more than just

015manage the day to day tasks of our office. She handles them with genuine grace and care that everyone feels. She has an incredible ability to juggle multiple tasks, meet deadlines and make it all look easy. No matter how busy things get, Rebecca stays calm, organized and ready to pitch in wherever is needed. Whether this will make some people laugh, it's answering questions about the enrollment process for Lawrence Elementary, which is different and can often be time consuming or handling an urgent situation or offering support to our staff. She does it with a smile and a heart full of dedication. And then there's Erin, our executive assistant to the principal. Erin is the pillar that keeps everything in our school running efficiently. Erin's attention to detail and commitment to excellence ensures that nothing falls through the

016cracks. But what truly sets her apart is her proactive nature. She's always anticipating the needs of our school and stepping in before we even realize we need her help, whether it's planning school events, coordinating communications, supervising students or keeping me on track. Erin's contributions to our school cannot be overstated. Her dedication, expertise and tireless work make all of our jobs easier and more effective. And like Rebecca, she brings a contagious, positive energy to the office that uplifts everyone around her. Both Rebecca and Erin embody the spirit of teamwork and their unwavering commitment to our school and its success make them irreplaceable members of our community. This recognition tonight should have happened many years ago, so I'm super excited that we're able to have it tonight. They are more than just colleagues. They are role models

017for all of us and friends for many. Their work ethic, their care for others and their ability to stay calm under pressure show all of us the true meaning of dedication and service. Rebecca and Erin, I want to personally thank you for everything you do. Your contributions go far beyond what's expected and you make our school a better place every single day. I'm incredibly fortunate to have both of you on our team, and I'm deeply grateful that I get to work alongside of you each day. Please join me in celebrating Rebecca and Erin. Thank you for all you do. Right. Thank you. That was very exciting. We're going to move on to agenda number 12.0. This is our student board member reports. We have two student board members who belong to our comprehensive high schools.

018We have Addie Hart from Livermore High School and Gabriel Benitez from Granada High School. And we're going to invite Addie to go first because today is her birthday. What a great way to celebrate your birthday is to be with us tonight. Your best friends. Good evening, Board President Prusso, members of the board, Superintendent Gibson, cabinet and community. My name is Addie Hart and I am representing Livermore High School. LHS had 15 students recognized as all league recipients for fall sports, with Kamari Robinson receiving the Offensive Player of the Year award. Our PVIS theme for the month is managing holiday stress and celebrating the many holidays that take place in December. Lowe's donated time, labor and over two thousand dollars in materials and supplies in order to help beautify the campus with drought resistant flowers. This

019would not have happened without the efforts of Junior Lillian Speckhauer. Our fall play, Putnam County Spelling Bee, was sold out every night and was a huge success. The Family Resource Center is sponsoring a winter coat drive. If you have a new or gently used coat, please bring them to Livermore High's main office. Choir will have their holiday performance on December 13th. Our winter instrumental ensemble concert will also be performing. Our leadership class participated in this year's shop with a cop and had so much fun helping all the kids shop for Christmas gifts. It was so heartwarming to see the smiles on so many of the children's faces. Students are getting excited for winter break while preparing for the end of the semester. Good luck to all students on their finals tomorrow. Thank you. Thank you,

020Addie. OK, Gabrielle. Good evening, Board President Peruzzo, members of the board, Superintendent Gibson, cabinet and community. Granada High School has had an eventful and exciting month showcasing the achievements of our students, staff and programs. For athletics, our cross-country team had many students qualify and compete at the CIF state meet. We also celebrated National Signing Day where we had students committed to schools such as ASU, George Fox University, CSU East Bay, CSU Fresno, St. Mary's and St. Mary's College for baseball, Auburn University for softball and Clarkston University for volleyball. For academics, college applications are wrapping up for seniors with early decision results starting to come in and many students receiving acceptances. But this week, students are focused on finals as we close out the semester. For leadership and recognition, Haston Chen was honored as the Haston

021Chen was honored as the November Rotary Club of Livermore Student of the Month. Additionally, we recently had our WASC visit during which our school received high praise, particularly highlighting the work of our leadership class. For arts and music, our music program continues to excel in competitions and our drama department is currently performing a Christmas story to enthusiastic audiences. For community involvement, Mr. Willis, our beloved PE teacher, had the honor of serving as a grand marshal in the Livermore holiday parade. Granada's vibrant community spirit and accomplishments continue to shine. Thank you for your ongoing support. Stay classy. Thank you. We now have our Employee Association reports and it's really hard for me to see back there. So I see Amy Thompson from LEA. If you want to start coming up, Stephanie is here. Stephanie Wagner is

022the president of SEIU or I mean, sorry, CSEA. You come up next. Is there anyone is Kirsty Governor here? No. OK. And also just as as Amy's getting settled, our SEIU president is Kirsty Governor and our CMC representative is Lily Lopez. And we also have our LEA vice president, Tara Lutz. OK, we'll turn the time over to Miss Thompson. Thank you. Good evening, board president Pruso, members of the board, Superintendent Gibson and cabinet. I'm Amy Thompson, president of the Livermore Education Association, representing teachers, nurses, counselors, psychologists, speech pathologists and teachers on special assignment. A very warm welcome to our newly elected board members, Christian van den Huvel and Dina Kaplanis. Like, oh, where does everybody sit now? It's discombobulating. Thank you for volunteering your time to serve our students. We look forward to working with

023both of you. This Friday is the end of the first semester for our comprehensive high schools and nearly marks the halfway point for this school year. We're looking forward to the approval of the MOU for next year's high school schedule, and you will hear more about this from Noel Matern and James Petersdorf a little bit later this evening. We've been working with Dr. Gibson to establish a committee for special education and a strategic plan committee. We are looking forward to these groups beginning their work and very hopeful that we will produce plans that have intended outcomes with measurable results. Our most recent negotiation session was preempted by a preview of the district's first interim budget report. We look forward to resuming negotiations on January 9th, where we will hear the district counteroffers for our salary

024and benefits. I am hopeful that we will complete negotiating articles 16, 21, and 22, and wrap up these negotiations before we sunshine for next year in February. Some observations from our preview of the first interim budget report. Over the past five years, our enrollment has decreased by 644 students and our average daily attendance has decreased by over 900 students. These numbers do not match. Improving our attendance rates will have a positive impact on our budget. Hopefully we have a plan to improve our attendance rates. During the same time period, it appears that our staffing has increased by over 200 people, but I'm waiting for accurate staffing numbers. Adjusting to right size our staffing should help with budget issues, but as we're looking to right size staffing, we need to keep in mind that over the

025past two years, we have cut over 45 classroom teaching positions. In comparing the percentage of revenues that our district is spending for teacher compensation to that of our neighboring districts, I can see that Livermore spends significantly less at 39.7%. Our neighbors spend between 43 and 44%. A few percentage points may not seem like much, but 4% of a $207 million budget is $8 million. I'm interested to learn more details about the projected cost increases, particularly for management salaries and the cost for contracted services. We look forward to working with our district to analyze the budget situation and find a positive path forward. I would like to wish everybody a very relaxing winter break. Thank you. Thank you. And we have Stephanie Wagner. Good evening, President Prusso, Superintendent Gibson, board members, and cabinet. My name is

026Stephanie Wagner, and I am the California School Employees Association President. Our members include accounting analysts, accounting specialists, administrative secretaries at the district and school site, benefits leave specialist, bookkeeper, campus supervisors at the high school, career technicians, child welfare attendance aides, child welfare attendance specialists, community liaisons, data and assessment specialists, data specialists, special education, district receptionists, executive assistants for the district for principals, expanded learning assistant, expanded learning site leads, facility technicians, health technicians, human resource specialists, instructional assistants, instructional specialists for the computer lab, instructional slash P.E. specialists, intervention specialists, I.T. administrative assistants, I.T. specialists and I.T. data specialists, I.T. technicians, library media specialists, network technicians, office specialists, outreach recruiters, paraeducator for adult transition, paraeducators for special education, payroll specialists, preschool program instructors, property control technicians, registrars at the high school, registered behavior technicians, senior office specialists

027at the district, transportation specialist, senior program assistant, speech and language pathologist assistants. We have a lot of different job classifications and a lot of people who do a lot of different things within CSCA. I wanted to thank Kristi Wong and Yuna Guzman for being part of our school board and for all the hard work that they put into it. I also want to welcome Dina Kaplanis and Christian Vanden Heuvel. CSCA looks forward to working with both of you. There are a lot of changes going on at the district. I'm still receiving a lot of emails, phone calls asking what's going on, what is happening, are their jobs secure, people are struggling. For my members, it's hard to discuss layoffs with them when we are hiring people at higher salaries than in the past, giving raises

028to management and promoting others. This isn't a conversation about whether or not people deserve it. It's about justifying layoffs to them. They see management with high salaries, raises, promotions, and they think, wow, I'm looking at a layoff. I know no one wants to do this and no one is looking forward to these conversations. I'm very interested in hearing all of tonight's presentations. I needed to let you know that this is my last meeting with the U.S. president. I want to let you know that it's been a huge learning experience for me. Speaking at these board meetings is not an area that I am comfortable with, but I am thankful for your grace and understanding these last three years. I know my successor, Mamie Krstovich, will keep you informed and up to date with all CSCA

029matters. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Stephanie. We're now going to move on to our public comments on non-agenda items. So if you would like to address a topic that is not on this evening's agenda, now is the time to do so. We ask that you limit your comments to three minutes and that each speaker may speak once. I have the 10 speaker cards. If you'd like that, they're over on the table. And I'm going, we have, I have two. So I will invite first, Alexandre Azar. Azar is. Azar is. I'm going to get it right one of these days. Azar is. Thank you. It's been a while. Welcome. Push, push the button. There you go. And you have three minutes. I'll remind you when you get close to the end. Okay. Perfect. Good

030evening. I'm here to address an incident that happened recently at Granada. My son shared that he overheard a teacher making disparaging remarks, remarks about Christians after the election. According to him, the teacher expressed hostility by saying she wanted to kick Christians and throw Bibles at them, even using profane language in the process. I haven't attended a board meeting in over a year and I've kept quiet about a lot, but now our faith is being attacked and I can no longer sit silently. When I brought this to the attention of the principal, I was informed that an investigation took place, but the response I received was deeply disappointing. I was told that no staff member made the comments in question, which frankly feels like an outright dismissal of my son's experience. As a parent, I trust

031my son's account. It's disheartening to see that his concerns and by extension, our family's faith are being minimized. This incident speaks to a larger issue, accountability. We have had many issues with teachers in this district since my own school board run and there has been minimal accountability. Teachers are entrusted with creating an environment of respect and neutrality where every student, regardless of background or belief, feels safe and valued. If the roles were reversed and a Christian teacher or student had made derogatory remarks about another group, the response would undoubtedly be swift and severe. Respect and fairness must apply equally to all students and it is this board's responsibility to uphold that standard. Furthermore, in light of recent events, including the tragic school shootings that specifically targeted Christian schools, it is more important than ever to

032address these issues. Hostility or bias toward any group, including Christians, must not be tolerated. Protecting our children means fostering a school environment where no student feels unsafe, marginalized, or targeted. I would also like to congratulate both of our new board members but have one comment for Christian Vanden Heuvel. As a pastor, your role carries additional responsibility to uphold the principles of faith, fairness, and morality in every sphere you serve. As someone who carries both spiritual and civic responsibility, your role demands accountability and transparency to those you now represent. During your campaign, you blocked me on social media for asking difficult but fair questions. Now, as an elected official, you can no longer silence or dismiss the voices of those in this district, parents like me, who demand answers in action. You have a responsibility not

033just to uphold your faith but to ensure that all students are treated with fairness and respect they deserve. Our schools must be places where students feel safe to learn and grow without fear of being targeted for their beliefs. We teach our children to treat others with kindness and dignity and respect and it's time we hold our educators and leaders to the same standard. Thank you. Thank you. We'll now invite Debbie Gibson to please come up. Good evening board members. I would like to congratulate Dr. Dina Kaplanis and Pastor Christian Vanden Heuvel on their election to this board. This past school year, record numbers of parents showed up to speak out at school board meetings, joined education action groups, and ran for office. For the first time ever, the crisis in our classrooms superseded political affiliations

034and united fathers, mothers, and grandparents. These concerned parents and grandparents ran for every position from mayor to governor in order to protect children and the rights of parents to know what was happening in their children's classrooms. Politicians, school board members, and school officials who were not listening to their concerns were removed from their positions and replaced by those who would. The roots of education in America had been strong in the Lord and honored by our founding fathers in every way. They actively sought his involvement in their lives and forming a strong future for America. They knew the education of future generations had to be established on the word of God if we were to be a nation of wisdom and prosperity. Without him, that is not possible. I ask for God's forgiveness and delight of

035fire within us. We must shine his light brightly in this place of education, doing everything possible to turn it back to a system that honors him. Regardless of how far our education system has turned from God, we know he can reverse it. May our leaders have the strategy to repair this, bring a revival of such proportions that it generates the necessary willingness and determination to reform the education system. Lord, give us breakthrough, give us wisdom, influence, and favor for the task ahead. Be glorified in our schools. In Jesus name. Amen. Thank you. I'm going to move on to communications. This is the formal written correspondence to the Board of Education that is acknowledged if received by the board or in the superintendent's office by 4 p.m. the day before the meeting. Formal written correspondence received

036after the cutoff time will generally be acknowledged at the following meeting. And please note that our board electronic communications received via the Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District website by accessing the formal written correspondence to the Board of Education link with all fields completed and verified is treated as formal written correspondence. So I'd ask the clerk if there is any correspondence for the board. And if so, if you could please summarize for us. There was Contra Costa Contra Costa County elections divisions regarding the summary of elections. We received a letter from them. We received a letter from Alameda County Registrar Registrar of Voters regarding the certificate of election results and a copy of the official canvas. Melanie Sadek from the Valley Humane Society requested a public records request for written communication regarding dogs on school

037campuses discussions. Dorothy Phinney Slod, parent commented about the need for more community input before trustees vote on by trustee area district elections and the following correspondence were received after the agenda was published but before the 4 p.m. cutoff time the day before the meeting. Kate Saraya LVJUSD retired teacher and former LEAA president commented in regards to the creation of the Superintendent of Special Education Services position. Alan Allison Barode Saboraria, parent asked about the opportunity for students and caregivers to provide feedback regarding the re-examination of the special education program. Tara Boyce, president asked the board not to hold a final vote for the election map pending execution of effective community engagement. Rebecca and Timothy Gutierrez, parents commented in regards to concern about assistant superintendent of special education and changes in the HR. BJ Reynolds-Kunz, parent expressed

038concern regarding the transition from at-large board elections to by trustee area board elections starting in 2026 and BJ Reynolds-Kunz, parent expressed concern regarding the assistant superintendent of special education position and that's it. Thank you. We're going to move on to our discussion action items. We'll begin with 16-0. We'll invite Dr. Tori Gibson, Ms. Amy Thompson, Mr. Noel Maddern, and Mr. James Petersdorf forward. Is that, I don't know, that's who I have on my list. No, that's good, it's great. So while they are making their way up to the podium, I'm very excited to have these two gentlemen here to walk you through. I thought it would be much more beneficial for you to hear from them as they were participants from start to finish in this process of how we ended up with this MOU

039and this particular high school schedule. So I'm going to pass it over to these two. All right, thank you. Good evening board president Perusso, members of the board, superintendent Gibson, cabinet, and everyone here and at home that cares for our students. My name is Noel Maddern and I've worked in our school district for the past 20 plus years as a social science teacher Granada High School. I wanted to take a moment to acknowledge the incredible collaborative effort that has gone into developing our new 2025-26 schedule for Livermore and Granada High Schools. This process has been a testament to the power of partnership between teachers, site administrators, district management, and the school board. Under the guidance of Dr. Tori Gibson, we've engaged in a series of productive meetings that have truly transformed the way we approach

040challenges. Dr. Gibson's ability to facilitate open dialogue, encourage diverse perspectives, and identify common ground has been invaluable for consensus-based problem solving. By prioritizing teacher input and utilizing the results of a comprehensive survey, we've ensured that the voices of those who know our students best are heard. This data-driven approach, combined with transparent communication, has allowed us to make informed joint decisions that will directly impact student learning and well-being. Thus, we've not only addressed concerns, but also identified innovative solutions, breaking free from the status quo and embracing new ideas to create a schedule that optimizes instructional time, supports student success, and fosters a positive learning environment. The highlights from this teamwork include a stable and consistent schedule for students and teachers, three anchor days and two block days per week, an increase of instructional minutes as well

041as increased frequency of class sessions, optional A and B periods outside of the traditional school day, and two days per week students will be assigned to an access period with the purpose of providing additional support to meet their educational needs. I'm incredibly proud of the work that has been done, and I'm excited to see the positive impact this new schedule will have on our students. A fact that supports the sentiment is that 84.4% of our members voted to approve it. By working together, we've demonstrated the power of collaboration and the commitment to excellence that defines a new era for our district. Thank you so much. Well, real quick, while it's getting pulled up, I think I've been on three of these scheduling committees over my 20 years here in the district, and I don't think

042any of them have ever gone anywhere. This has been the first one we actually collaboratively came to a good decision, and we kind of worked through stuff, and then we had an end result that teachers actually liked when we walked out of the room. When the email came out about, hey, let's join a committee, let's put together a schedule, it was like, oh, okay, let's go through the process again, let's do it. This one wasn't like that. It was actually really fun to be a part of, and walking out of the room after a couple days of having a schedule we all liked was amazing, and it was a fun process. So it was nice to be a part of that. I think this is the third one I've done, and they've never gone anywhere,

043and this was the first one that we walked out feeling good about it. We have a new board agenda system, so it's going to take just a second. We have a new system for our board meetings, and I'm going to make 25 mistakes tonight, I'm pretty sure. So we're still, we're going to get really good at it, but right now we're still learning. So yeah, just appreciate your patience. Do you want the MOU, or do you want the schedule? The schedule, the other one. Yeah, there you go. There we go. Perfect. All right. So the schedule on the board here, you can see we went back to kind of a six period day. Teachers teaching five or six, which is more in line with what other districts in our neighboring school districts are teaching. Over

044the last few years, you know, obviously we've had the trimester teaching 12 classes over a length of a year. Now we're down to teaching 10. And then obviously this year teaching in the double block to having a lot more students come through our doors. So this one, being able to walk it back a little bit to more of a traditional schedule for teaching wise and taking the load off a little bit there and giving a little bit more attention. And then on top of that, kind of trying to mesh the world we've been living in the last few years with having a longer block period to be able to work with students and then still be able to see students almost every day of the week, which was a big complaint that we got that

045just no one knew what day of the week it was. You know, is it an A day, B day, who are, you know, it was hard. So the consistency factor of the schedule and what we've been able to put together, building in access periods twice a week for larger chunks of time, be able to help more students and connect more. I know we're still working on some of the details on how that's going to look, but looking at this compared to other district schedules, I think ours is better. Honestly, I think it's good. And I think we took the best of what we saw out there and we kind of made it our own and we turned out something that's great. That's great. Thank you. Don't go anywhere, but we do have a blue card

046on this. Jerry Yellen, if you would like to come up, maybe just move over for Jerry. And then if you'd stay in case we have any questions for you or comments from the board, that'd be great. Madam President and trustees, Madam Superintendent, I'm here tonight not to complain about the schedule that's been selected. I think it's great that you worked one out with the teachers. Where were the parents? Where were the parents? Now, every one of us here have attended high school, if not graduated. We all had different schedules that we lived through. We're all here today. This schedule is important, but I've talked about governance before. It's not just important what you decide, but how you do it. And I don't see that here. This is a wonderful concept and I hope the schedule

047works. I have faith that it will. The teachers work hard on whatever schedule they have to teach. That's the nature of the jobs. And so this isn't about the specific schedule, but how much is it going to cost? Are there going to be increases in the number of students per class? I don't know. Were there public hearings to discuss the options? What other schedules were looked at? None of these things happened. And in particular, it is a bad, bad idea to adopt programs when you don't know what you're going to spend on it when you're running a deficit, which you are. And I'll come back to talk about that in another couple minutes when we get to another agenda item. But please, don't vote to approve a project that you don't know the cost for.

048That is bad government. Do you think you're going to have to do some cutting? I've heard estimates exceeding a million dollars for this change. And you guys are telling me you don't know, but you're going to approve it. You probably should delay this until you've got a cost estimate, don't you think? Wouldn't that make more sense? Wouldn't that be good government to know what you're spending money on? Ten seconds. That's my thoughts and I had to share them. Thank you. Thank you. We'll invite you to sit back down. I believe that this is a discussion item only. This is not an action item. Oh, it is an action. Oh, it is an action item. Board members, do you have any questions or comments for our committee? I would ask in light of the question, do

049we have any type of a rough estimate in terms of implementation, you know, a range in terms of costs? So the current situation that we're in with the schedule that we have currently, there will come certain cost savings from that. It's something that we have to get an approval of the MOU and all the particulars first, and then we'll start working with our students and our staff to figure out what periods we'll put in the A and B periods. Those are really the pieces that will cost us more than what we currently cost us more. But we have to remember that our current schedule really wasn't much of a cost savings compared to the trimester system. And so the goal is that we will be working on limiting what we offer in periods A and

050B and have staff in those outlier spaces that will come with the costs. But we are pretty confident that we will be within the means of where we need to be budgetarily. But it's something that we can't work through that process until we have an approval of the MOU. I don't know if Ms. Walsley, if you want to add anything to that. Any other comments? I just wanted to ask a little bit. I know you don't have all the details, but it sounds like there was a group of teachers that came together and administrators, I believe, to work on this. How many days did you guys work on this scheduling? Do you remember? We were here for two days, all day for two days working on it. The first day was kind of ideas and

051kicking things around. And then we brought it back to our staffs and then shared kind of what we came out with. And then we brought it back the second day to kind of fine tune. In addition to that, there was a subcommittee and I was part of that group. And we looked at some of the minute details in a little bit more focused kind of manner. In addition to, we had a plethora of email fun along the way with going back and forth with data and just different concepts and questions as they went back to the staff and had questions that came up in their staff meetings. They would send those in, then we would respond or we put together spreadsheets for them. So the couple of weeks in between the two meetings were not

052just quiet, stagnant time. It was work group from afar, if you will, via the internet. I mean, I would say we looked extensively at schedules, all kinds of schedules. I don't know, I've got like three or four Excel sheets with like 25 different tabs on different versions of what the schedules could be. We talked about the potential costs to a large extent. I mean, we got more data on all of that than we've ever seen ever before when we were making considerations. As an incredible group, there was, I don't know, 40, 50 people, I think, that were involved here in that and it was really special. That's good to hear. I also, 84.54 percent of the members approved this. Is that typical to have a high, I don't know, I'm looking kind of back at

053President Thompson back there. Or maybe you can answer that question. I would just chime in that, you know, the current schedule was just imposed. This is really collaborative and I think, you know, getting 84 percent of anybody to vote in favor of something is pretty extraordinary. Yeah, I just wanted to commend the folks that were involved. I know that the superintendent didn't play an active role other than kind of mediating it. What that did was it kind of, I don't want to say forced, but it allowed for collaboration. And when you have new folks coming in and new administrators and people coming together. And we had, we can't forget, we had a situation where we had a new schedule that was relatively untenable and we had a lot of issues. So we're trying to repair

054something. So that effort of collaboration, I've worked with both of you and so I know that in 20 years a lot can happen. So to say that this is the first time in a couple of decades where people came together and you got a finished work product out of it, that's great. And I respect that. I do have a little concern over the cost, but I'm going to take the superintendent on a word that it's a manageable cost because everything costs something. You know, maybe this one isn't as easy as an executive summary where it says it's going to cost this exact amount because there's some i's to dot and some t's to cross. But Dr. Gibson says this is a manageable thing and it's better for kids and the teachers support it. I'm going

055to support this. That's great job. Thank you. Any other comments or questions from the board? And if not, I would entertain a motion for approval for the MOU. I move in support of the superintendent's recommendation on this item. Second. So we have a motion by Trustee Bueno, seconded by Trustee Vanden Heuvel. Is there any discussion on the motion? If not, I'd ask our clerk to please take roll. Trustee Vanden Heuvel. Aye. Trustee Capuanis. Aye. Myself. Aye. Trustee Bueno. Aye. President Prusso. Aye. That motion carries unanimously five zero. I would just like to say one quick thing. A huge thank you to again, and I know I've said this before, but a huge thank you to the LEA leadership who helped us put together a really truly diverse group of people in that room. It did

056not go always with rainbows and unicorns throughout the two days. It was some good hashing some things out of wants and desires, but I think at the end of the day, we landed in a really good place. So a huge thank you to both Tara and Amy, as well as to these two gentlemen who are definitely leaders in our district with our teachers and to the teachers who participated. We even had teachers who didn't participate in those two days who showed up for the subcommittee work group after hearing more about it. And so I think that's a testament as well to the work that they did going back to the sites that we did not participate in at all from the district office and the work that they did on their own to go back

057and do their own surveys and bring us new data and all the things that made this effort successful. So huge thank you to both of you. President Prusso, can I ask a question real quick? Yeah. So Superintendent Gibson, moving forward, is there a plan for evaluating this moving forward for how it's working for students, how it's working for teachers and how it's working for the community? And I just want, I mean, I know we've just literally just voted on this, but I'm just curious about the next steps to see, because we just changed the schedule last year and so now we're changing it again. And I would imagine that there may be an opportunity to fine tune or to get community input if this is not working or to try. So I'm just curious about

058your perspective on that. Sure. So we haven't gotten down that road yet of next steps. We're just trying to really go one step at a time with all the things we're doing. However, clearly we meet with LA on a regular basis and we'll be checking in with our high school teachers. Students usually have no problem giving us good input as well. I think the hard part with, and I 100% hear in regards to the parent input, that there are just some things, unfortunately, and I think you all know me well enough by now that I would just kind of say it like it is. Unfortunately, there are just some things that as a school district we have to make the decisions on. This is something that is a negotiable item with our teachers unit and

059our bargaining unit that I fully respect. And so when it comes to those things, unfortunately, it is a business transaction, 100%. As much as we can make it personal and we can bring us together as a team and we're all on the same team together to come to a solid resolution that we can all get behind is fantastic. When we can include parents and students, of course, that's always going to be our goal. Unfortunately, this just isn't one of those items that we could do that with. Can we get some feedback going forward? Absolutely. I think if I'm looking at the most immediate piece of our next steps, now that this has been approved, will really be to start looking at our master scheduling and what we want to place in period A and B.

060That's going to be really our next step for success, whether it's different things related to sports, music, drama, leadership, all the different things. So we'll be working closely with both high schools on those functions first and foremost. That's a good question. All right. Thank you. Just a clarification. As we do move forward, I'm looking at this as a pilot program. We take an incremental step towards achieving it. We have good collaboration. Could we get some of the measurables as they're developed that we are looking for? You know, maybe in the near future, as well as when we start to see the dollars hit the line so that we can see the cost estimates. You know, I know you have to put the package completely together and it's not all the way together. So this is

061your profession. So I'm going to respect that. When that does develop, can we ask that we were apprised of that? Absolutely. The other piece too is, as you know, in this item, I'm going to pull it back up on my computer. As you know, the language around how this works is what we call memorandum of understanding and MOU with our teachers union. So this is not built into the CBA, which is the collective bargaining agreement yet. So this is strictly for the 25, 26 school year. Now, that doesn't mean I don't want to freak out parents. It doesn't mean that we're going to throw out the baby with bath water by any means, but that is correct in that throughout the year, as we implement this, we might think, oh my gosh, why didn't we

062think of this, right? As adults, we often think things look great. And then we come up with something and we're like, oh, we didn't think of that. So as we move forward, we will be looking at this. I will say though, one of the things that this committee did when we first kicked off our meeting is we brought in multiple schedules from across our area. We also started looking at other bargaining unit contract language around what was in there, especially those districts that are really near to us that we compare ourselves to. So we have some really good examples of what's happening. And we have been outlier for many decades, starting with trimester system. I mean, we were only two in the state left with trimester system up until last year. A lot of districts

063are moving away from the current block schedule that we have because of the high cost. And so we will be examining all of that as well. But absolutely, trustee Bueno, we can start bringing that forward and that will all naturally come anyways, as we start doing our budget meetings and having those conversations. Okay. Thank you. All right. I'd like to thank Mr. Petersdorf and Mr. Maddern for coming and presenting that to us. Yeah, give him a hand. I think that's something to be to cheer about. Move on to the approval of the appointment of members to the citizens oversight committee for a major a parcel tax. And I am going to turn the time over to Ms. Kayla Wasley. Thank you. And good evening. Let's see. Okay. So I'm bringing forward to you today two

064new appointments for members of our measure a parcel tax oversight committee. So just a little background on measure a so measure a was approved by the voters in May of 2022. And it's known as measure a and then annually we have our independent citizens oversight committee that reviews our expenditures as well as produces an annual report that is presented to you. And I think May or June, and then committee members must live within the boundaries of our school district and committee members serve a term of two years. The goals of measure a funding. We don't have to spend money on all these items, but these are the allowable expenses within measure a are to provide elementary science and TK technology specialist retain and attract highly qualified teachers, maintain academic achievement in math, science, reading, writing,

065engineering and technologies, keep classroom technology and instructional materials up to date, maintain small class sizes, keep schools well maintained and to the extent that funds are available to maintain and support academic programs, including the purchase of instructional equipment, materials and supplies. So those are the expenditures that our oversight committee is reviewing each year to make sure we fit within those funding guidelines. So the committee conducts meetings as needed in accordance with the Brown Act and are open to the public review the amount received and expended in the specific budget year as well as present to the board of trustees by the final board meeting of the school year. So our current board members are listed on the left side of this slide and we have one committee member that resigned this year and then one

066committee member whose term expired this year. So we are bringing forward Charlene Birchfield as well as Richard Stolen to be appointed as the new members of measure a and they might be in attendance this evening. I'm not sure. Yes, thank you. There we go. Okay, at least there's Richard. And so it is the superintendent's recommendation to approve the applicants as presented and appoint them as members to the measure a parcel tax citizens oversight committee. Thank you. I have no blue cards on this. Any comments or questions from the board? If yes, go. I just wanted to thank all the people serving on the committee. I think that trustee Bueno can probably speak more elegantly to this point, but I just appreciate the time commitments. I think that when the school district seeks funds from the

067community, that's important to have oversight so that the community knows that the dollars are being spent on what they're supposed to be spent on. So thank you. I have no other comments. I would entertain a motion. I'll second. We did have, but we got to get a motion first. Wait. Sorry. The language though, it's like to approve. I motion to approve the applicants as presented as, and appoint them as members to the measure a parcel tax citizens oversight committee. Second. So we have a motion by trustee Coplanis, seconded by trustee Druin. Is there any discussion on the motion? I'd ask the clerk to please take roll. Clerk, can I start with myself? Yeah. Okay. Myself. Aye. This is trustee Bueno. Like I said, we're still learning. Trustee Bueno. Trustee Coplanis. Aye. Trustee Vanden Heuvel. Aye.

068President Peruzza. Aye. And that motion carries unanimously, five zero. Just so people know, so you end with the president because there's a power dynamic. So there's kind of a cultural aspect to how and why, but thank you. I'm the queen, so I get to the last. She is the queen. I was going to say she is the queen. Okay. All right. We're going to move on to our public hearing. We will open the public hearing and we'll have a presentation from our demographer on the draft trustee area maps and a public hearing to gather input regarding the draft trustee area maps. So I will invite Mr. Douglas Johnson. Nice to see you in person up to start, begin with our presentation. Do we want to have, do we have legal counsel here? Do we want

069to just have Harold come and sit next to Doug? We may as well just join the, join the fun up here. Okay. Nice try. Nice try. Yeah. Just as a reminder to the board, this public hearing is discussion only. So good evening. It is my pleasure to be here in person and to see you all in the flesh instead of on the camera. Oh, it's, yeah, it's on. Can you hear it? Is that better? Oh, that's better. Just got to get closer, I guess. Okay. So as was mentioned, I'm Doug Johnson from NDC and I've been working with you remotely through this process. So here to present in person and to answer any questions you may have. I will go through the PowerPoint, walk through the maps. I'll touch on the maps briefly as you

070hopefully realize the maps have been posted for a week on the website. I will, I think I have that actually live. So hopefully folks have gone to the dedicated page on the, it's not switching over. There we go. There's been a dedicated page on the district's website throughout this process and all these maps are here and I do recommend that folks scroll down and there's an interactive map link that takes you to a map where you can zoom in and out. So as we get into detailed questions, especially in discussion, I can switch over to this map and we can really see the individual lines up close to look at exactly where they go. With that said, I'll jump in. So we are at the final stage of the board's consideration of this process. We

071started with informational and educational hearings back in October. I started with, then we released draft maps, held two hearings on those draft maps in November and we continue to improve and revise those maps and look at other options for maps throughout this process. And so we have a handful of new maps to look at that were not part of those earlier discussions. And tonight is the board's action, both this discussion hearing and then the next item is actually an action item on the agenda. But as we mentioned before, this is an unusual item in that the board's vote is not the final vote. After the board selects a map, then the map goes to the county committee on school district organization, which through state law has the final say on making this transition and approving

072the map. And that hearing has not yet been set. We'll request that they schedule that after the board has chosen its map. So the county committee is the final authority adopting the map in the end. The criteria we've gone through in each of those earlier hearings, but just as a reminder, we have the federal requirements in the left, which are that we have to have an equal number of people in each of the trustee areas with a small 10% range. And it is a little unusual because by law we are using the 2020 census data. Now we're here in December of 2024 using four-year-old data. So I'm not too worried about if we're right at perfect balance versus off by a few percent, as long as we're in that statutory requirement range that the federal

073law lays out. And all the maps we'll show you are in that range. We also have to be sure that all the maps comply with the federal Voting Rights Act and that there's no racial gerrymandering. And we can confirm that all the maps we're going to show you do comply with all those requirements. So after that first set of federal requirements, then come the state requirements. These are listed in priority order in state statute, and they are that trustee areas must be contiguous. All the parts of a trustee area must be connected by land. We have to avoid or at least minimize as much as possible the division of neighborhoods and communities of interest. We have to avoid or at least minimize the division of cities and census designated places. Then the fourth state criterion

074is following easily identifiable boundaries. So rivers, railroads, streets, things like that, that make it easy for the voters to understand which trustee area they're in when it comes to the election time. And then the last state criterion is to keep them compact. To the degree we can, after following the higher ranked criteria, we want to avoid bypassing one group of people to get to another group of people. The state also prohibits, as you can see in the top right, the language there, we shall not adopt election district boundaries for the purpose of favoring or discriminating against an incumbent, a political candidate, or a political party. Then if we have two maps that are equal on all those requirements, then we can look at trying to adjust for future population growth. But maps these days, now

075that the state rules are in, very rarely get to that point. So those are our statutory requirements for what these maps have to do. But as you've seen throughout this process, there are lots of ways to do that, lots of ways to approach those different criteria. We started with the four maps you see here, green, orange, purple, and yellow. The green map in the top left you can see has kind of a central trustee area five, shown in orange. And then really a western, southern, and eastern seat. And then in the northeast and all the rural area in area one. Going to the orange map, it's more of a five regions. You can see the rural area is still in area one, but area one, instead of being up in the northeast, now comes down

076and gets kind of north downtown area of the city. Then there's a western orange seat you see there, southern, kind of one eastern, and then one northeastern and far eastern seat. The purple map you can see has pleasantin, and it's often a surprise to folks to learn that there is a small piece of pleasantin that you can see down there in the corner, right down here. It's really around, for those that know pleasantin, it's around the golf course there. So that goes with west Livermore. Then you can see a very different green seat, really a horizontal both sides of the freeway seat, and then a downtown to south eastern Livermore orange seat, and an eastern blue seat. And then yellow, yellow admittedly looks a little funny because the area five in orange is coming from

077the north through the middle of town and going out. The reason for that is that the four other trustee areas really match the city council districts. Now there are only four city council districts, and there are five trustee areas, so we're always going to have that fifth, but each one of those four only consists of territory that's in that city council district, and then area five gets the middle where those council districts actually come together and divide things. This unites them plus the rural area. So those are our original maps. In the second round at the last hearing, we talked about three more maps, and one of the ideas that came up from the original hearing was maybe the whole rural area should not be in one seat. There are different communities in the north

078rural area as opposed to the south rural area. So these each take a different approach to the rural areas and also put more of a focus on major roads as boundaries. And you can see in the top left of the maroon map, we're trying to get, oh the other piece that came out of the first hearing was trying to get three northern seats really following major roads. So there's not enough population up north to have three trustee areas entirely north of the railroad and first street. So in maroon, we get that extra population needed by the western, the purple seat you can see there coming south of the railroad, the other two stay north of it. In tan in the top right, we come across the railroad in the eastern portion. So you can see

079the green trustee areas north and then south of the railroad. Then in the olive map, you get three seats that are predominantly in the north, but in order to do that, both the which sees the pink and the green seats both have to come south every way to get the additional population needed to make three full seats. So looked at those maps and then received more feedback from the public and the board focusing on the yellow map from the first round and the olive map from the second round. So we have a couple more maps. The goal coming out of the yellow map was that there were to divide the rural area of the freeway. So yellow was one of the original maps. So all the rural area was in area five. So the request

080was to try to split that at the freeway. And then there were three neighborhoods that kind of were divided by the yellow map, largely for population balancing reasons, but to try to see if there were ways to put those together. And so we have three maps, yellow two, three and four. Yellow two puts the north rural area into two area two and the south stays in area five. And then in order to make up and trade off for that population and put neighborhoods together, you can see the arrow there where the neighborhood around Portola Avenue gets put together. Otherwise it's essentially the same map as yellow. Yellow three does not fix that Portola Avenue neighborhood. Instead it gets a clearer boundary between four and five. You can see if I go back to yellow, it

081kind of veers off the major road there and where we're between four and five. In yellow three, we're using cone cannon there, much cleaner line. And that is made possible by putting the north area in the area two. Then yellow four, attempts to address all three of those concerns. You can see the cleaner line between four and five following the major roads. We get the Portola Avenue area put together. The way that that works is that area two comes farther south. It comes down to, oh, Mines Road. That's right there. So area two is picking up both the north rural area and coming down to Mines Road to pick up that area. It is a large population deviation. But again, while being that close to 10 is pretty much as close as we want to

082get, the data are almost five years old now. So it's not really a representation distortion there. So those are the variations that came out of the discussion about the yellow map from the last meeting. Then following that, we received some email correspondence from a resident and some additional feedback from board members asking for looking at the olive map. So we have two versions of the olive map to show you. Both of them really concentrate on trying to consolidate area two in the central area. So you can see this one has a really small population deviation, 1.45. Each of the trustees is within 1% back in 2020 at least. But we do get, you can see here that area two consolidated kind of north and south downtowns. And then it goes out along East Avenue a

083little bit to pick up the areas over there. It comes down into downtown south to fourth street. There is the southern boundary of area two. To make that happen, you can see where one and four shift. So one comes down, gets the Granada High area of that region around there. You get a little bit of an unusual U shape there in area four, which is a compactness concern. But remember compactness is last in the criteria. So if we can be a little bit non-compact if we're putting a community in a neighborhood together and following major roads. So that's all of two and then all of three, the last of the new maps. You can see this takes that southern area four, but shifts it over to the east. So we're getting the Buena Vista unincorporated

084area and that area on the south side of East Avenue all into area four. Because that area is in there now, we don't have to wrap around. To make this work population wise, though there are lots of small changes that I can go through in the interactive map if you want to see them in detail. But area three comes a little bit south. You can see again we're going to Mines Road there in the north. There's a little bit of a triangle in the north side of two there. You can see around Livermore on the east side of Livermore Avenue. It looks a little odd, but actually we have a bunch of community input from the city's process and then a little bit of community definitions here. And that area was not part of their

085definition north downtown in that north area. It is a distinct neighborhood. So we're not breaking up a neighborhood with that triangle there. And then in order to make this all work population wise, area two in the middle comes down to fifth instead of stopping at fourth. So it's just one more block south for area two in order to make up for losing the area south of east that it had before. And then you can see we have the nice Cone Cannon and Holmes boundary there between one and four in this map. So again, I'm going through these very briefly because they have been posted for a week. Hopefully folks have had a chance to look at them and review them in more detail. And I'm happy to go back and really zoom in on any

086of them that you wish. But again, we've got the five kind of non-yellow, non-olive maps that are still available. Nothing's ruled out at this time. They're certainly legitimate and viable maps at this point. And then we have the four yellow maps, each kind of taking small adjustments to try to unify those neighborhoods and to divide the north and south rural areas. And we have the various olive maps trying to consolidate that area two around the downtown and central portion of the district. So that's my quick presentation. Like I said, I expect and I'm happy to engage in discussion about any maps you want to focus on. One thing I do suggest, especially when we get the action item, is there's a lot of maps. So don't feel like you have to walk through and eliminate

087anything. Just focus on what you want. We don't have to vote on each map. We only have to pick the one map that you want to move forward with. Okay. Thank you. I'm going to open the public hearing for this item. And before we have a discussion, we do have a blue card on this and that is Marilyn Dijkstra. She wants to come up. Dijkstra. Sorry, Marilyn. If I pronounced your name wrong, please just let me know. Yeah. Push on the button there. Can you hear me now? Okay. That's better. Good evening, members of the board, our two new members and President Emily Prusill. My name is Marilyn Dijkstra. I'm here as a voter and a resident of the city of Livermore. As such, I'm afraid I cannot support any of the maps as shown.

088They all seem to separate where at least my family lives, our residents, from the rest of the community with which we closely interact. So I ask you to please pause the decision on voting for districts, voting districts for board of education trustees until you can acquire more research and more data concerning the need for voting districts and the boundaries of voting districts. And especially until you receive a great more public input on this issue that affects all of us voters and residents of Livermore. Short message. Thank you, Marilyn. I have no more comment cards for this item. So we're going to close public comment and we're going to turn the time over to the board. I wanted to make a suggestion that maybe, obviously we're not voting on anything yet, but just to have a

089discussion to maybe narrow down the maps. So maybe if everyone would like to offer a suggestion of what map they like and why, and we can maybe narrow it down to less than 25 or how many we have. Would be helpful. I think it's less than 25. I like the idea of going and talking about just a couple of the maps. Maybe like a green and a yellow and some olives. Those are the colors I like. But I would like to have a little bit more information about representation, especially when it comes to the number of schools within a district, because there's one map in particular has just one school and then they're kind of bunched up in other districts. And I think the public feels there needs to be equal representation a little bit.

090Can you speak to that? Certainly happy to. And I should note on the website, we do have a list of the school locations in each map. So one thing to remember is that, you know, I was normally at the end of this process, I remind what board members know, the public sometimes forgets these trustee areas matter on election day and on filing day. And hopefully those are the only two days every two years that these lines matter at all. And because every board member still represents every kid in every school. But it does come up a lot. Will board members feel more engaged in the schools that are in their trustee area? And one thing I remind folks is it's not so much the school as the kids. If a board member has a family

091in that board member's trustee area who attends a school, the board member is going to care about that school. And so we often will look at, you know, at the attendance areas and that kind of thing more than at the school sites, because the board members may say, this is my school. But if one of your voters has kids at that school, you're not going to walk away from it. Even if we're in the bad situation where board members are only responding to their voters, which hopefully you don't get to anyways. So there are differences. Part of looking at it is depending on what we look at. Are we counting the alternative school? Are we counting the continuation high school? That kind of thing. But if we're just looking at the K-12, the elementary, middle

092and high schools, we do have a wide variety of maps, a wide variety of numbers. I think the one that is eliciting the most concern is really where trustee area four only has one school. We're only looking at the elementary, middle and high schools. Again, it has kids and families who attend multiple schools. It just has one school site in it. So that, I believe, if I look at it's the olive two and three maps as one elementary, middle and high school. And I think it has, and it has a continuation high school as well as the second, the second one. We also have, I think in the olive map as well. So it's the three olive versions where area four only has the one plus the continuation high school in it. So I have

093two follow-up questions to that. First of all, from our veteran school board peoples, how often do you get presented with decisions that you're making that affect only a few schools or only a school or only, you know, so where in the future, if a school lies within a district, a trustee area, that a trustee will be more likely to vote for a particular, is there anybody that? Yeah, I mean, that's a good question. And it doesn't happen very often. The only thing that I could think of is perhaps bond. But even then, I think we had, we had every school had something from the bond. I hear where you're coming from. I thought about that too, about having, but then I, the way that I looked at it was that we're talking about the physical

094school because I looked in that same area and all of two district one, I believe. No, is that the district? Yes. It's four. Sorry, four. District four. Even though Sunset physically is the only school in the district besides Stillval and Vineyard, the folks in that district all go to Smith, Meninhal, Joe Mitchell and Granada. So you're really representing all of those schools. I mean, if we're talking about the difference between the physical school and the people who attend those schools, that's kind of how I looked at it. I actually made a little chart for myself because I just wanted to see where I had the schools physically that were in there, in those districts, and then also just the boundaries of the schools that go in that district. And it's at least in all of,

095I did it for all of two in green, because those are the two maps that I like. In both of those maps, there is a pretty equal number of schools represented in each district. Do we have good, do we have good maps that show us what the area of town is where students come from? Because we've got this open enrollment situation. Do we have, do we keep track of that? So I did ask that we would have some information on, because we are an open district, what is the percentage of students who attend their home school? Do you have an idea of that? And what percentage maybe is transfer? Unfortunately, well, I'll look to Mrs. Shet first, but unfortunately, I don't know that we have that data. We have never tracked it in the past,

096which we will now start tracking it, but I'll pass it over because I know she'll probably have a lot more information. We are refining that process within our student services department. So I can tell you that there is some pretty deep investigation going on right now as far as those transfers. So I can give you numbers, but I can't give you them today. We've been told in the past, different folks, but we've been told in the past that that number of kids attending their neighborhood school was greater than 85%. And there was kind of a give or take, but it was great. And then the displaced students was a very low, like really like single digit percentage of kids that are displaced. I live next to Joe Mitchell, but I have where I am going

097to another school because I've been displaced. It was very, very low. Despite the open role, most kids appear the overwhelming majority to go to their neighborhood school. That's been my impression over the 10 years I've been on the board. The question that's in all of this is related, so I'm not meaning to dismiss any of the conversation because I think it's all productive, but is that, are there decisions that we have made that address like a single school site? And I think, I mean, sometimes there have been, and it's usually on capital items. A school will come and they'll say, we're looking at getting shade structures or we're looking, but most of the things is looked on a global view most, but there are times when a particular school will look for something and we'll

098work with some of our community partners like the More Value Education Foundation, LVEF, to try to help facilitate it. Sometimes we'll work with the PTA or the PTO to do that. And then one of the things since we've had open enrollment that we've done collectively is each year we use clusters and the clusters were intended to equally distribute the schools amongst the trustees. And so you may get three or four, you try to give everyone a middle school, a K-12 or say Mendenhall, that's, you know, or East Avenue. And maybe you get a comprehensive high school, maybe you get a DelVal in those clusters. And we rotate that annually. And the reason is like when they have their fundraisers and things like that, you have more of an attachment to that school for that time.

099And some people kind of stick with certain ones because, you know, we had Yannir Guzman and Christy Wong, they've worked a lot with the English language learners at Junction. So they requested each year to stay at that school. So there are things that are kind of defined by that. But, you know, most of the stuff is budget and personnel. But I think part of that intent is that we are making decisions for the entire school district, even, you know, we have our fingers on the pulse of some of them, but the goal is for all of us to be making decisions for the entire school district. Yeah. Yes. Yes. I would say the other thing that is going to be a common occurrence, and Trustee Buena just quickly brought this up, is the personnel piece.

100Sometimes that comes with some controversy, sometimes it comes with celebration, but that is it that can be and usually is a very site-specific type of action that we would take. Okay, that's. Yeah. And since the being voted at large, the five of us, we have that understanding that we represent all the students. But I wonder going forward, starting in 2026, if that in other school district, if that changed, if there's now more tension or more discussion, let's call it that, between the different representatives of different trustee areas. But I have not heard that, but I think that's some of the concern in the public too. I look at this, and one of the things when I asked for empirical evidence to show that there's been what the outcomes have been, it didn't appear as though

101there is any in the few hundred that have happened. But I do believe that it has to be. And if you look at city councils that have gone to it, I mean, the underpinning of this whole thing is to help communities of interest. And so if you have a segment of the population that we're looking to serve better, then it would just stand to reason logically to me that each person is going to lobby, work for the constituents within their specific, the greater the whole as well, but primarily the people who elect you. So, you know, we're looking, the community of interest we're looking at is in the areas of Junction in Maryland. I would completely understand, and I would expect nothing less than whoever is in that seat, that they're strongly advocating as intended

102for the community of interest within the parameters of that district. So it would logically follow that the people who are in whatever area three and area four and area five would do the same. So it's, I mean, to me, it does drive a sense of competition, but, you know, that's why we're looking to make a number that's high and, you know, costs that are low within there so that you can advantage a disadvantaged population so that you can get better outcomes for students. I was just going to say, with that said, to me, the green and the olive two are the two maps that keep that community together. So those were the maps that I was drawn to, and I believe we got a lot of community feedback regarding those maps. Those would be the

103two that I would like to look for, but look at, but I'm also open to any other suggestions. I like the idea of all of two, and I spoke with our superintendent about, is there a way for us to tweak things a little bit? Just add a little, you know, use a sharpie, as some people do, to add a school or two to that map. So, yes, we can change the maps. The challenges we have these populations, very, we have population requirement and we have these fairly rigorous state criteria and school site, equal number of school sites is not one of them in the state list. So, you know, what has been looked at is could we just, you know, take the little corner here, which would get you, this is Emma Smith and Maidenhall

104schools. The problem is, is that then you're drawing a line right through the neighborhood. You're taking the boundary off of Merdell and Concannon and going right through a neighborhood there. So, I have looked at it. But that's the neighborhood we created, that you created. You know what I mean? It is a neighborhood, but. But if you look at that, because I was thinking the same thing that you were thinking, Trustee Vanden Heuvel, and then as I was looking at it and I thought if we carved out that little piece, most of the families, a lot of the families that will be going to those two schools are going to be already outside of that area. You know what I'm saying? Like we care about the physical school, but we should care more about the families

105that we represent and the schools they go to, whether or not the physical school is in our district shouldn't matter more than what the families, what schools they're going to in our district. Those are the schools that we're going to, that we're going to care for. Does that make sense? Because that's what I was thinking too. And then I'm like, wait, but then above Emma C. Smith is a whole bunch of families that still go to Emma C. Smith. And I think we have this idea that we have to have the physical school in there. And then when I started looking at our boundaries for our schools, it is more equal in that there are several schools in every district as far as maybe not the physical school, but the boundaries. That was my thought

106as I was doing the same thing. I'm like, can we just carve this little piece out? And then I thought, wait, it kind of doesn't matter. But again, I'm open to that. I wish I would have looked at it. Well, let me just add, given that that is kind of carving through there and that raise again, I did look at, can we do a bigger kind of neighborhood based switch? And we should can, rather than moving at Smith and Main Hall, we can actually move Granada and Mitchell. And there's the river basin that runs through here. The Arroyo. Yeah. Essentially everything from the Arroyo over would go into four and then everything from Homes and Concannon, all this would go into one. So it's a big change. It would also get rid of the U

107shape, which would be nice. So one would pick up all the area west of Mundell and then Concannon and Homes and an exchange lose the whole area from the Arroyo to the west. So that would move two schools. And the Arroyo is one of those, remember the clearly recognizable features. It certainly is. It only has a couple of roads across it. But that sounds like a whole nother map. It's only changing those two trustee areas, but it is a big change. And we already have 78 or so maps. I will say 12 is a lot and it's a lot to go through. We've had 50 to 60 before. But yes, it is a rather large change, but that's because it would avoid that state criterion. I think one of the hard parts for us is

108when you look at the interactive maps, no matter what you layer on here, I think the one thing that is really obvious is just how close together all of our schools are located. And that just is basically showing the growth that we've had from the center of town over the course of many, many, many decades as we expand further out. I mean, if you think about it and you go up into the Springtown area, I mean, how long ago that didn't even exist, right? So I think that's the hard part is they are so close together. Now, if we could pick up schools and move them, we've clearly probably really truly spread them out in our community and make them truly much more neighborhood schools, which in suburbia world, when they're building suburbia and Roseville

109and Rockland, because I've watched it happen when I lived there years ago, that's what they do. You put in a ton of housing and they pop in a school right in the middle. And there's a park and a school and all the functions. But unfortunately for Livermore, that's just not how we're constructed. Okay. Trustee Pina? Yeah. I'm going to say, I wish I'd read the, I went back and I looked at the law portion of it. And I tried to extrapolate as you eloquently did very quickly, you know, these are the points. These are the salient points and this is why we do it. My understanding was we're doing this to avoid litigation. Well, that's like maybe not even tertiary to the thing. This is something in order to gain better service to communities of

110interest, to dissolve inequities and to help boost people up. So when I look at that through a different lens, I liked green. And I think green met most of the bullet points that you mentioned, you know, continuity or contiguous areas and not dividing neighborhoods. And maybe there's some things that maybe could be a hair cleaner, but I would be splitting hairs there. When I look at the breakout and the numbers trying to achieve higher numbers, concentration, the community of interest that we're looking at seems to be one of our highest numbers. It was at 25%, you know, citizen voting, you know, population. When I looked at the cost, because to me, that's one of the things that's going to preclude someone who's in a disadvantaged community is the cost of the election. So I looked

111at the voter turnouts within the areas, because we're not dividing these based upon who votes and who lives. And so when we look at an 18 to 19,000 person, it's hard to get those. Our concentration of population is in the southwest corner. That's where the majority of the homes are, you know, the neighborhoods were built between 58 and 72. But when I look at that, green has by far the lowest number of, it was 5,737. So it's going to be less expensive, I believe, in the green model for a community of interest to run a campaign. And it also keeps the community together. The community of interest that we're looking at is contiguous. We include Maryland and Junction, and we also maintain the school sites. If you're looking at school site distribution, we're looking at,

112I believe it was three schools in each of the districts and maybe five or six within district five. I believe that's what I had on one of my, on my sheet. There's five in area five, and there was three in each of the other districts. There are, and there could be a small tweak at the top there. If you zoom in, Doug, on the area five for me, there is a small tweak that you can do with Lawrence. You just move it across the street. I don't know where that would be, but that's just Portola Avenue. I mean, if you're looking at balancing schools, I don't know if you want to do that. Lawrence is literally on Portola. It's not off of Portola. It used to be called Portola Avenue School. Here's the other thing

113though about Lawrence that's important. Maybe why we don't move that line is all the, all the students who attend there is not a neighborhood school. So that is one of our only schools that doesn't actually have an attendance boundary. So every student gets driven to school. Right. Aren't there two blocks that are homeschooled to Lawrence? Yes. Yeah. Which is a very small number of children. So in that case, it has that extra school site in there, but they come from all over the district. So that means that those, however many students are at that school site, I don't know how many are out there. I'm looking at Michelle three, 400 kids, all of those families live scattered throughout all the areas. Yeah. The other, and the other model that I have somewhat favorable to is

114one of the clean versions of yellow. And the reason is not that it has a yellow with the plain yellow or yellow. It was one of the cleaned up versions where they tell us which one I'm not looking at because I don't have the graphics and like the computers just load real slow, but it's the primary focus on that one on the yellow is that I see that we have the community of interest is split between one and five, but they both have very high margins within them. So we have 26 in district in area one and 20 in area two. So perhaps you might even gain influence because 40% of your board seats would be actively engaged in your community of interest. So for that reason, you know, a clean version of yellow would,

115you know, whatever we found satisfactory with neighborhood lines. Most of those neighborhood lines seem to be between area four and five south of the freeway. I think it was maybe yellow two or yellow three. One of those, you cleaned it up quite well. Yeah. But, but I think in my opinion, the green seems to hit every, every check mark in the criteria that you mentioned. And in addition, it equally distributes the school sites amongst the four, with the exception of the community of interest and the community of interest would actually gain influence by having five or six disproportionate amount of schools within it. And their voter turnout would be the because of voter turnout, they would have the least cost of an election. So I think we could make the most impactful statement and serve

116that the COI. All of two. No, I, from the, from the initial maps, green was, green was the really the only one that I viewed as, as possible from the original maps. But, you know, at this point, if we're just trying to identify which ones were interested in that, I'm most interested in all of two. What about, what about all of three? What I like all of two, three. I also like the green. For me, all of two, having had a chance like you to knock on a ton of doors that you shaped sort of made sense to me. Like it, it just fit with who we meet there in those different areas. So I like the district four U shape for all of two. Do you mean the pink U shape? It's a purple,

117purple U shape at all. Oh, I see what you mean. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I lean, I lean all of two as well. I don't hate green. So that helps, right? That is not what you said. We should just say what we didn't hate. Yeah. Okay. Good. So I feel like I'm doing good. I'm hearing all of two green and the cleaned up yellow, whatever that is. And all of three. Oh, and all of three. Yes. I think we have four so far. We did. Okay. We didn't do great. We did. Okay. I do like the yellows, but which one are you thinking? I like the yellow too. I'm looking at it. No, I got it on here. That's no, it's that yellow. Yes. That's yellow too. Yeah. I believe it's yellow too. Just,

118just for those watching on zoom or whatever the, the odd southern boundary here that jigs and Jags all around, that's the city border. So, so folks there will be aware if they're in the city, they're in the green seat here. If they're out of the city, they're in the orange. So, and this, and this somewhat mirrors city council as much as we can when we have five versus four. This is a reminder as to why this was originally drawn. And then with the two, three, and four yellows, those were just kind of clean up items here and there. Right. Right. Yeah. Okay. So I think what we're going to do next, I think we have an idea. We have a few maps to look at. Um, we're going to, we're going to close the public.

119Oh, we already did that. Yeah. Sorry. It's still closed public hearing. Yeah, I did. Uh, we're going to move on to our next one. But before we do that, we're going to take a break. We have more public comments that we're going to get to. Um, it has been challenging for me to work out the public comments because we have so many on different items. So if you are concerned about your public comment, let me know. Okay. But I am, I think we're good. So there are more public comments coming up. There is another public hearing coming up, but we are going to take a quick bathroom break first. Okay. We are back. Um, we are now going to move into, uh, 16, six a, I don't even know. What is that? 16.4 a. Thank

120you. I'll get it. Uh, we're going to open our second public hearing and we do have some blue cards. So I will invite Tara Boyce to come up. Following Tara will be Joanne Morrison and following Joanne will be Kyoko Takeyama. Welcome. I think you know the drill. I do. It's way past my bedtime. So no niceties. Um, so I have written very long letters to sitting board members, the superintendent, associated people in the community who care about this issue greatly. The underlying theme of my letter though, um, for those of you who have read it, I hope it came through, is that community engagement in our school district is at risk here in Livermore. Um, exhibit a 2022 failed to pass a bond, uh, polling for 2024 didn't even take a bond to the ballot

121because the polling showed it would not pass. When we just got those, uh, pretty election numbers in our packet today, it showed that 22% of people in Livermore didn't vote. They're registered to vote. They did not vote. Of the people who voted, 33% of votes were skipped for school board. So only 67, 67% of the people who voted in Livermore cared enough to even look at names, the voter guide and vote for school board. The effective engagement for this process has been zero based on comments, based on attendance, based on questions asked. People out in the community, I talked to a lot of different people in a lot of different areas. Sports parents have a lot of time to chat and most people don't even know that it was happening until I talked to them

122about it. So I understand we had a community engagement program. I understand that, uh, Ms. Dawson worked very hard to use the outlets available, but the reality is the communities of interest we're talking about, they're still unknown. Their theory, we think we know who they are. We think they know where they live based on flat data, but do we, did anybody go out and talk to them in their space? Did we go out and talk to the parents at Junction who are important members of that community? Did anyone go talk to the parents at Maryland? I connected with the PTO president at Maryland and nothing was done within the school site and I'm at Junction, so I know it wasn't done at the school site there. So my request to the board and based on

123the questions tonight, there's still a lot of open questions. There's still a lot of things each of you does not understand about the maps. To choose a map to send to the county tonight is irresponsible, too early, and even if we are held to a 90-day time frame based on when we kicked off this puppy, you still have more time, right? The 90 days can be extended under the law and I welcome that conversation because we have not gotten a demand letter. We need to explore all avenues. I see it, thank you. We need to explore all avenues to make sure we talk to people, we produce maps that actually show us our community of interest, and I would hope in Livermore we have more than a single community of interest that we care about

124in this process. Thank you. Thank you. Joanne Morrison. Hi, I'm kind of going to echo what Tara said. Good evening, President Purcell, members of the board, Dr. Gibson, and cabinet. There has been very little explanation of this whole process to the public. There was a resolution, I believe October 5th, that we should go forward with this project, and the only reason I've heard for it is to avoid some possible threatened litigation, although there has not been a demand letter. There was no discussion about the process, the desired outcome, how it would improve things for voters in the district, whether there's any evidence that it would improve things, and the timing of this whole thing has been really most unfortunate. We started it during election season when there were two places on the board open for

125election, two board seats. Now we have two new members who have not been a part of this process all along, and they may not be able to vote responsibly tonight on a decision that's so important for so many years to come. We have a very full agenda tonight as well. We have the swearing-in and welcoming of the new board members. We have an important financial report coming up, and we have restructuring the cabinet. I feel like we're rushing to meet a deadline that's a self-imposed deadline and not a real one. As I said before, as has been said before, there has been no demand letter. I think we should pause for 30 days. We're not at the 90-day deadline yet anyway. I think we should look at what other districts have done that have transitioned

126successfully. I think we should have a town hall type of meeting where the public can have more meaningful participation. We need translation into Spanish. We need outreach to the Spanish community. Has that been done? How has it been done? Does it look like it was very effective? Will delay cause liability? In 30 days, we're unlikely to receive a demand letter from anybody. If we did, it would cost 30K, but it's worth it to have a better process and better results. Finishing within the deadline does not guarantee that we won't be sued. For example, was this meeting properly noticed by folding it into the agenda for the board meeting? I don't know. We need to ask that question. You could be sued on that. Good evening. My name is Kyoko Takayama. I'm a community organizer and

127I engaged Aramida County and Livermore City Council's redistricting back in 2021. The one thing I can tell you is yes, I agree with previous two speakers. Outreach was not well done by any means. However, to get those communities voice, it is super difficult. So the demographer just told us that the northern part of the Portola is not part of the Hispanic communities. However, the part of them is actually is. The reason it doesn't show up is mostly the outreach effort was successful amongst white and wealthier population, but almost zero input from the Hispanic community. And that is the community I work with. With our family, I conducted a door program with Aramida County knocking doors on those population. So I did not talk to those population, but the community is extended to over the north

128side of the Portola. And thus I have actually submitted my community of interest for them. And that is pretty accurate. To me, the most vulnerable community of interest should never have been divided. And that's exactly what yellow map does. So I cannot accept that. And olive two is the only one which actually completely protects that particular population. And that is probably your focus to actually engage and more participation from both parents and students. Therefore, I highly recommend you to take olive two if it has to be done today. Thank you very much. Thank you, Kyoko. Okay, we have no other comments on on this item. And so I'm going to close the public hearing. And then I thought maybe before we move on, we could maybe ask some clarifying questions about the legal ramifications of

129this, because it did come up a few times. And maybe Harold, I don't know if Harold or Douglas answers, I was about to call you guys Addie and Gabriel, sorry. Happy birthday, Addie. If you could maybe explain the legal ramifications of this, why we're why we're on such a sort of short time constraint, and what that means fiscally, I guess, for our community, that would be helpful. And then if you guys have any questions in that, any other questions before we move on to the next item, which is the actual adoption of this, feel free to jump in. Thank you. I'm happy to give at least a brief overview. So the California Voting Rights Act is an interesting creature, because it since it was created, since it's been on the books, there is a group

130of plaintiffs attorneys around the state that go around sending demand letters, essentially, accusing school districts, city councils and countless special districts of violations of the CBRA. And the way that the law is written, if you receive such a demand letter, you then have 45 days to commit to moving to a by trustee area election. And then if you make that commitment, you then have another 90 days to get through your map process to finish it. And what's happened around the state is, and Doug probably knows the numbers better than I do, but when I first started doing this work, maybe 5% of the school districts in the state were by trustee area election. And now we're probably up to around a quarter of the school districts in the state because of these demand letters. And

131once the demand letter is sent, if you haven't started the process, as this district did start the process, that attorney is generally entitled to recover statutory fees. You heard from one of the speakers, $30,000. It actually goes up by inflation. So now we're up to about $40,000. So districts are faced with a choice. Either you wait to receive one of those letters, and statistically, the odds are very high you're going to receive one of those letters, in which case you're paying the extra $40,000 or you decide to do it yourself. And more and more school districts are starting to do what this district did, which is to get ahead of the curve and do this. The other thing I should note is that in this county, there are two different plaintiffs' attorneys that are really

132maybe the two major ones in the state that have sent demand letters to different school districts within the county. One of those attorneys listed the school districts that they felt should move to trustee area elections in a letter that they sent to the Alameda County Office of Education in relation to Hayward Unified's process. And your district was one of those districts identified as essentially a potential target, which certainly caught the district's attention. Once you're in that 90-day safe harbor period, we call it, you cannot be sued for a violation of the CVRA. And one of those demand letters does not result in having to make any payment. When you get to day 91, literally when you get to day 91, you're out of the safe harbor. And at that point in time, a letter can

133be served on you. And again, it opens that door to potential $40,000 demand on the district. And if you don't, to the plaintiff's attorney's satisfaction, then go through the process, you may then end up in litigation with them. One of the other interesting things about the CVRA is that if you go through this process and you adopt a map, you have complied with the California Voting Rights Act. You have done what you need to do. There are questions that then can be raised about the Federal Voting Rights Act, which it's much, much harder to show a violation by a public agency than it is the CVRA. So the safe harbor is real. I know we also heard from a speaker about the 90-day extension on that. And again, the law is written in a very

134interesting way. What it says is that if somebody sends you a demand letter, you can negotiate with them to get an extra 90 days, so up to 180 days instead of 90 days. In the time I've been doing this, and I've been doing this for quite some time now, I don't think we've ever successfully negotiated with the prospective plaintiff's attorney to give them the extra 90 days, either because their demands are not something in exchange for that the district wants to do, or if you have a jaded attitude about it, it doubles the amount of time that the plaintiff's attorney has to wait to be paid the $40,000 because it extends the process. I'm not going to comment on which it is. It's one or the other or some combination thereof. So at this point,

135the board had decided to move forward, as again, many other districts have. You're in the safe harbor. Once you're out of the safe harbor, you are literally out of the safe harbor. And it's almost as if you've done nothing to date, as it can just start over again with the demand on the district. In our conversations, you also refer to or alluded to, well, $40,000. That's just kind of the beginning because there's many other things that are triggered in that process. Can you talk about that? Yeah. So once you receive a demand letter, a few things happen. One is you are potentially on the hook for that $40,000. Two is you've now essentially invited the plaintiff's attorney, whoever that may be. And some of these attorneys represent very distinct organizations. And you've heard of the

136organizations and others. We don't know who they represent. They claim to be representing particular groups. Once that attorney is involved, they will be more involved with this process. And you won't just be hearing from the public and from one another. You'll be hearing the voice of usually somebody from out of town who is an attorney who's coming in, who may have their own interests, who are going to be advocating for particular approaches. The other thing that happens is that if you don't complete this process now within the 90-day period, you not only are susceptible to a demand, but potentially then that opens the door to actual litigation because you haven't adopted the map. If you get into that actual litigation, one of the interesting statistics is that in all of the litigation in California over

137the CBRA, a public agency has never won one of those lawsuits. The only one that did got overturned by a later appellate court. So it's essentially an unwinnable case. Regardless of the facts, the way that the law is written, it tilts towards moving school districts in this direction. And again, it's why there's been such a rapid growth in the number of districts that have gone to buy trustee area election. And by my projection, probably in the next four or five years, we're going to see not just 50%, but probably 75% or more of the school districts in the state have gone this way. And again, more and more of them are doing it of their own volition instead of rolling the dice and waiting to see if they get one of these demand letters. And

138I should note too, once you get the demand letter, there are clocks that start. And so you're right back into that period of, okay, now we have to do this quickly. And for you, if you receive that demand and you restart the process, there is a perfectly legitimate argument. You have to go through all of the public hearings you've had. Again, you have to publish the maps again. You have to pay your demographer to go through that process again. I would only add to that, that the 90 days for schools can be particularly bad because it includes summer. So we have had letters arrive in April and the jurisdiction had to do this whole thing over the summertime. And if you think it's hard to get the word out during the school year, imagine trying

139to do this in the summer and parents go home at graduation and they show up in September and they're now trustee years. So controlling your own timeline also has advantages of not being stuck over summer. I think one of the criticisms that I've been hearing from the public is the lack of community engagement. So I'm wondering if you can comment on what are some of the things that we've done that represent best practices? And are there actions or things that we as a district haven't done regarding best practices of engaging the community to understand communities of practice and engagement with the maps? Or if you're in a position to comment on that? Yeah, I mean, I think we have Michelle convention as well, but I can add to that. The 90 days is also tough

140when you hear what a lot of jurisdictions do, like the city went through in 2021, they weren't under a 90 day clock and they still, you know, we've been using the input the city received. They received 10 community of interest comments and city councils always get more attention than school boards do in this process. So keep in mind, even when, and the city took six months because they weren't under a 90 day clock. So keep in mind that you can do all you want, but it is a tough issue to get people out on, certainly. I'll defer to Ms. Gibson to talk about what they've done. So in the board packet under item 16.4.B, there is, and I'm going to ask Mrs. Dawson if she'd like to come up to the podium as well. We

141did include the community log and all of the functions and where we have posted all the different things. And she did bring, she and I met today about this exact topic as we knew it was something that was being discussed across, you know, a couple of different, from a couple of different people essentially. And one of the things that I found interesting too, is that she was able, I don't know if she has this data on her tonight, but we were able to actually look and see of all the platforms, how many times things were clicked on, read, whatever the case may be. So I'm just going to pass it over and I'll chime into and help out. Sure. Hi, everybody. Yeah, I put together kind of, so as the attachment that Dr. Gibson referred

142to, does kind of give a laundry list of all of the different forms of outreach that we've done since October 1st. But I've kind of summarized that, even drilled down a little even further. And so I'll just kind of go over some of that information to kind of give you some additional perspective. So in terms of, you know, like flyers that we've put together, they've been posted to our online platforms. They've been posted on our social media. We also had support from our local libraries who posted our flyers in all of the public library locations. And that summarized all of these different public hearings that we've been having and spreading the word that way. The Livermore Valley Chamber of Commerce included it in a newsletter that they send out to their membership. So we've had

143additional support there. In terms of news and media outlets, we've had multiple postings in both print and online through all of our major media outlets here in town. So the Independent, the Livermore Vine, the Livermore Patch. The mayor even spoke about it on his mayor's report, which was televised on TV 30 multiple times between October 21st and November 3rd. He mentioned that we were going through this process and gave information on that. We've posted 10 social media posts over the course of the last several months. We've had 17,283 views on those posts alone, just from the posts that we've put out. And then we've had tremendous support from the city in terms of pushing out on their social media as well. So every time we've posted, they have turned around and posted on our behalf

144in order to get it spread even further. They also have a Nextdoor account, which we know is very active. And they have shared all of our posts there as well. And while I don't have access to their analytics, they were able to share that at least a couple of them. There was about 2,000 to 3,000 views on each post that they have put out as well. So it's definitely getting eyeballs. It's definitely been seen. Whether that generates interest or not is something that we don't control necessarily, but it is being viewed quite a lot through social media platforms and through our news media outlets. We've also done in-person presentations. So at DLAC meetings, multiple PCIC meetings, Livermore Valley Education Foundation meetings multiple times, the same with the Chamber of Commerce and the Business Alliance, which

145has representatives from all of the major nonprofits and businesses in town, our Faculty Communication Council. And then we've done tons and tons of parent communication and staff communication as well. So we have staff newsletters, weekly newsletters that's been shared multiple times, the superintendent's monthly newsletter to staff, her fall newsletter, which got a total of over 20,000 views, talked about this process again. We've sent text messages and emails. And every time we do that, we're touching about 17,000 parents every time we're sharing out. And we've made sure to keep updated on every time we've added maps, every time we've taken that next step in the process to keep people informed. So that just summarizes how we've reached out. And I've worked with colleagues in other areas who have gone through this and used some of their

146guidance to help us with ours. I just want to add one quick thing too. On the platforms that we have been utilizing, those are also the same platforms that often generate a lot of chatter, if you will, good or bad, that end up in the boardroom, on all of our desks, whatever the case may be. Perfect example that I'll refer back to was something that was just firestorm very quickly was at the beginning of the school year with the drama band theater situation over at LHS. So those are the same platforms that also generate a lot of discussion and conversation that does end up to us that we hear about. So when we can see some of those analytics and some of those functions, and I think our community member Kyoko said it very nicely

147that it's very difficult sometimes. And I hadn't heard the statistic yet from about the city, that they went through this process, it was longer than 90 days and they had 10. So I think that I mean, it's just a topic that's really hard to do that. But we have spent tireless hours posting, rewriting, rewriting, reposting, being out in the community, having discussions. I also know that as board members, you have all had those discussions. I think it's important for the community to also hear that the two new trustees, and I'll let you speak for your own, but from my perspective, we have brought you along nicely in this process. You've attended every single public hearing to date, as well as having meetings and conversations, both with me during onboarding on this topic, as well as

148informational meetings with Harold that our board had prior to to bring you along to fill in those gaps. So I think to say that the two of you may not be prepared is a far cry from accurate. You guys can speak to that or not, whatever you want to say. I just wanted to put that out there too. Yeah. Thank you, Dr. Gibson. I would say that Trustee Vanden Heuvel and myself, we were attending the board meetings when this was an ongoing discussion back since October. So we're familiar with it. And then now being onboard, just seeing everything more in detail, it helps. And we have access to look at it multiple times. So I feel prepared. Yeah, I had it was really helpful to sit down with you and really look at a detailed,

149I don't know, kind of like a cost benefit or risk reward type of situation, thinking that the benefits of voting in favor of a map today definitely outweigh the cost or the risks. I, of course, based on your analysis, I also believe that the risk of litigation is very real, very imminent and should be avoided. I think in our current fiscal climate, I want to make sure that we don't rack up any unnecessary costs and illegal costs that can easily run into $100,000 or more. And I think most importantly, I think that sticking to this 90-day deadline will not cause any harm to our community and specifically the most vulnerable and marginalized parts of our community. I honestly do not think that this will affect them in a negative way. And in talking to, I

150don't know, maybe 30, 40 people in the course of the last months or month trying to receive input and feedback from parents, from other stakeholders. Yeah, I was met with almost 100% people going, okay, that sounds okay. Why should I care? And that sounds complicated. And don't we have elected officials who can help make that decision for us? Can you just go and do that? In not so many words, but I also don't subscribe to the opinion that it's incumbent upon our district or on Ms. Dawson to increase interest somehow in something that the public feels like, fine. It sounds really fine. Even when you sit down with them for 15 minutes to kind of explain what this could do, they're like, yeah, no, sounds good. We should probably follow the law on this. Additionally,

151I'm convinced that there is no perfect map. Can we just say that also? Out of all these, I don't think there's a perfect one. We just don't have that. And I'm really comforted by the fact that we will have an opportunity to revisit these district boundaries as soon as 2031, as we look at 2030 census data. So I mean, that is three elections, but I think we can, I think we can manage. So those are some of my reasons. If that answers your question, Dr. Gibbs. Ms. Dawson, how many comments did we get from the public? I believe it was 28, or is there more? We had 29 unique participants provide feedback. I think in my mind, the question, first of all, I appreciate the clarification, knowing that you didn't officially start until a few

152hours ago, and that's to know about your experience. Yes. But then the next question is, what is the, you know, one way of approaching this is a cost benefit analysis. If we delay until January to make a decision, what is the benefit that we are going to get? And I've heard from some community members holding a town hall, you know, may give us more inputs. But I haven't heard other unique things that we should be doing that we haven't done. Well, okay, I have some, there's some, you know, more, we have done some outreach to our Spanish speaking community, but there could be more. I think for me, though, the opposite of that is this is to some extent, an unfunded mandate from the state to try to do this. Like I hear, I heard

153the comment previously, can you do door knocking? And how do we do that? How do we as a body get that information? Who in the district is, you know, can we place that burden upon and at what cost to the students? So I'm very torn on this. But I also go back to this is a state law. And I think that, you know, when I was sworn in, I swore to uphold the, you know, the federal constitution, the state constitution. And I think that, I don't know, I'll stop talking now. Yeah, just to your point about the town hall. Yes, sometimes those can be useful. But you're going to, you often run into the same issue of there needs to be a sense of controversy, there needs to be a sense of outrage, which you

154would have already seen. I'll say we just worked with Lammersville and they were going through this process as Mountain House was incorporating. So Mountain House was talking about a fired up community. They were engaged. They were a well-to-do active community. They were engaged in the process because they were incorporating their newest city and they held a town community forum and four people showed up. So a town meeting can help, but usually it's informational when there is an engaged community. It really doesn't engage people on its own and it is expensive. Are there any legal requirements for us to do, to check off certain boxes? Like I've heard the town, sorry, the workshop, like having a workshop where we all sit around and we all get to draw, we all bring our crayons and we make

155maps together as a workshop. Is that a legal requirement and are we in, will we be in trouble by sticking with all the things that we've tried to engage the community? Let me answer that by saying first that what is legally required is you have to have a total of five public hearings. You've actually now had more than five public hearings. So what is required you've done. There are some other laws about what you have to do when you're doing redistricting, which is the process that you do when you relook at the map after the 2030 census where there is supposed to be a community meeting that occurs as part of that process. But the statutes specifically say it's school districts and other entities that are not in that process yet. You're just making the

156decision now. You don't have to do that extra step. There are also some changes in law that are going to go into effect on January the 1st. One of which really, there's just one that affects school districts, which is starting then when you have your public hearing, you have to have it at a specific set time within a board meeting. So if you have your board meeting start at six, you have to say on the agenda that the public hearing will start at eight. That's not the law now. It will be the law starting January 1st. But you have literally complied with all of the statutory requirements. In fairness, it's really confusing because these laws are found in, you have to look at the elections code at three different bodies of law there. You have

157to look at the education code. You have to add them up. But we've been very carefully tracking as we go through to make sure you've checked every box for what you are currently statutorily required to do. Before we move on to the next item, I did want to make a comment. Kyoko came and spoke with us and she has been really helpful during this entire process. She is a community organizer here in Livermore and for the county. And I was able to meet with her a couple of times and she really walked me through this process and helped me to understand and encourage me to go speak to as many people as I could about this, which I did. She also helped us to come up with the all of two map, which is my

158favorite map. And I just wanted to say I just appreciate her willingness to jump in with her expertise. And not only did she help us with the mapping, which I think has been extremely helpful, she also reached out to the community in as many ways as she could. And to me, that's just what Livermore is all about. And I appreciate her willingness to do that and for her expertise and her being willing to meet with me as many times as she did. And I think there have been other people like Kyoko in the community have been really helpful. But I just wanted to mention that her specifically, she has been extremely helpful in this entire process. And if there are no other comments, we're going to move on to our next item, which is the

159adoption of the resolution. Dr. Gibson will speak and then we have some comments. I don't have anything to add at this point. I think you've narrowed it down to the four maps of green, olive two, olive three and yellow two, if I heard correctly from item 16.3. Can you repeat that? Yes, green, olive two, olive three and yellow two. Not to say that you're stuck there by any means, but those were the ones that were discussed as the of the favor of everyone at the dais among the board. The next step in this process and item 16.4 B, if the board so chooses, is to narrow it down from there to one map. And then from there you would approve the resolution incorporating that map into the resolution. Correct. Did I do that correctly? Okay,

160good. I didn't know when I became an educator 27 years ago, I'd have to learn these topics. Sorry. Thank you. I do have a public comment for Tara Boyce. Is that right? You're good. Okay. All right. So we begin. We got to narrow this down. Let's do this. I would like to submit that all of two is a great start for our city. I think my issue is with the California Voting Rights Act that forces us into this as quickly as we do and also forcing us into what Trustee Bueno said at the last school board meeting. Where is the data that this helps students? I also think that there's not a lot of data that says this is going to harm students and that's why we're here. That's why the five of us are

161here to protect our students, to help their education. That's why I'm fairly comfortable just saying let's vote on this map and I like all of two. Trustee Bueno? In my comments that I made prior, I'll succumb to the fact that sometimes your arm's just getting twisted. I don't believe that district elections will immediately benefit. I mean, you can have a tribal sense, but it's the law. And I think that if you look at it closely, in which I tried to, trying to serve a community of interest is of greater benefit than the risk of that. And so you try to make your best adjustments so that you can serve that community. And we were only able to identify, correct me if I'm mistaken, a singular community of interest. The other communities of interest seem to

162be negligible in terms of their percentages. There was no direct concentrations that we could focus on. And so we focused in on Maryland and Junction in that area. Just a wording thing. It's more that was a protected class in question. Communities of interest are different as I can move on. You're right in the idea. Well, when we were looking at, I mean, the way that the data was broke out, it was broke out demographically. And the demographics were to try to keep Maryland and Junction, those areas contiguous so that we could increase the voting percentage in that area. I also believe that looking at equal representation is a key factor. And I can look at olive and I can look at yellow and I can look at green. I see very little difference between olive

163and green, with the exception that the distribution of school sites within the respective areas is more equal. It's actually very equal under green. But the layout of the map is very close. It's just that by the way it's been adjusted, that little dip, the U on olive two cuts out the schools that the people in that area go to. And so you're not going to be able to have one of your moms or your dads or uncles or someone elected from that area. But it's a large area to be elected from for a single school. And for that reason, I think that green achieves that, that blue core in olive two seems to be maintained in area five on green. And maybe there's some adjustments. I just like the idea that each district has three

164reps or three schools and that a higher concentration is within the area of concern where we're trying to draw more support. And I think one thing that's going to be remarkable is because people haven't really seen it is in the at-large configuration that we're in, we're starting Maryland STEAM Academy. We've brought in millions of dollars in program money and capital money to do the improvements with an at-large system. So, you know, the focus of this board in the time I've been on it has largely been this area to try to improve our students' outcomes. Hopefully, by going to these district elections, we can continue that if not gain traction. And I don't want to do anything detrimental. And to me, the olive two, the only component of that that I see is detrimental. If it

165was adjusted, I'd be in full support. But to get closer to having equal representation of campuses within each of the proposed districts. I think one of the, we had talked about with regard to communities of interest, the difference between the northern rural population and the southern rural population is something that we talked about. And so I think all of kind of stemmed from that conversation about that those are, you know, different, whether they should be part of one or be separate, I think, but recognizing that those are communities of interest that we were trying to pay attention to. And I would agree that everyone's different. Every neighborhood's different. I don't, I mean, most of that area, it appears outside of the, I don't have the district on my thing, but Springtown are largely unincorporated, you

166know, the the rural areas. I mean, we go on the north side, all the way out to Morgan territory, you know, the base of Mount Diablo. So they're very broad. So there might be a common denominator amongst the rural community where it's rich in FFA and some other things that they share, you know, so I don't want to make them like they're a monolith, but they but there is a lot of commonality in the unincorporated area. And we also have the urban area growth boundary that surrounds the city. I think another argument for all of two is that green happened just by Doug putting it together. And I think all of two kind of represents a how do I say it, it had community input to buy into it. So I agree, none of them

167are perfect. And I agree, if I you know, if it had equal school sites, then I think all of two might there's no perfect, but it might be closer to that. But I think I'll go back to trustee Vanderhoeven. It's only been an hour, so it's good. You're fine. It's late. Comment about because I think the school site comment is an interesting one, because it gets at what is what is the community is the community around the school site or is the school site the community. But entrusted trustee Pruso also mentioned that even if you don't have the school site, you're going to still going to be paying attention to the people. I don't know how you said I mean, the people in district four that I looked specifically, the communities in district four are

168go to Sunset Smith, Mendenhall, Joe Mitchell and Granada. So I mean, even though there's one physical school site, you're representing and DelVal. So you're representing six schools. I mean, people who go to attend six schools. So my question is, how important is the actual physical school? Is that more important than the communities that attend the school? You know what I'm saying? Yeah, I understand the point. It's just the pool of people that you have to run. You have to live within that area to run for that area. So it could make it difficult. What do you mean? I don't know if I understand what you mean. Well, you have if you live right next to your kids, it's hard to see because I don't have the streets on here. But if you lived right within

169the area, the pink dip down on all of two, you're correct. Some of those kids go to Sunset. Some go to Joe Mitchell. Joe Mitchell is kind of an anomaly because a lot of kids go there from all over because of the IB status. You know, it was a magnet school. But in drawing people to run, you're going to have a collective effort. It's just when you are focusing on those school activities, when you're representing the people within a single school. And so you're not going to be visiting Smith or you could go there. But it's why wouldn't you? Well, I think you're going to. But it's just when it's no different than, you know, city councils. I think you're going to be elected from an area and. But to President Pruce's point, like if

170you look at the green map and let's say you live in in area four, probably your kids are going to be at Emma or at Mendenhall. That's so you're right. And so you're going to be visiting if you're the trustee for that area, you're going to be there. And because most of the most of your constituents will have their kids there. So I had not really thought about that, by the way, about not just school sites, but school communities. It is a community. And the green map has a whole area that's just, you know, anything west and south of Mendenhall, east and south of Mendenhall or Emma Smith, they're all part of that community. They're all part of the district three community, so to speak, because those are the districts of three community schools, but

171they live in district four. Well, yeah, OK. Yeah. And one of the things that's in that area we had before we got rid of Sonoma, we liquidated Sonoma property, which is right by Granada. There was five elementary schools. Joe Mitchell was an elementary school. There was five elementary schools within a mile and a half as the crow flies. When they developed that area, they built all those community schools. But we have no schools south of Cancannon and there's a large population out there. So all of two, you know, the only issue that's my only issue with it is, you know, if there's a way to carve out a single one, it's just simply might be just the relevance of of the seat. And, you know, and, you know, in full disclosure, I do live in

172that area. That's not the intent. It's just in future. I've been on this board for a long time and I won't be here, you know, forever. But when you're looking at people that to recruit for an area, it would be nice. That's why we did the clusters so that people rotate and they had, you know, more relevance as opposed to the collective effort. But if that's not a concern, then it's not a concern. I mean, if the board feels all of two is the one, you know, I may not like that, but that's that's fine. I just think looking forward, it's as close to equity as you can get the better. That's the intent. To me, I look at this whole thing about equity and serving an underserved area. And both of those maps seem

173to do that by keeping that underserved area contiguous and keeping it concentrated and keeping it relatively low cost. If if the sharpie idea that I brought up earlier only hits California criteria, number five, the compactness. Right. Or is it is it more than that? Is it are other parts also? It's more than the neighborhood concern where we'd be leaving instead of following Mondale and Ken Cannon, we'd be carving. I think the census, let me see if I go down to El Caminito and El Padro. Yeah, kind of down that way. Exactly. We we have to kind of carve through here. And one of the things I love about this, you can switch it over to Sally View. If I get the blocks out of the way. Well, Ken Cannon is a clean line. We have

174no schools south of it. I know. Yeah. So you'd be carving. You get the school and you get the houses that back on the school, but the houses across the street would not be moving. So that that's the concern in terms of the state criteria that that brings up. And the other piece of it, to make it population balance, we do the same thing over here. You have to go south of Ken Cannon with a little balloon, the same piece that would again carve through one one block of a neighborhood and put that north. That's where that concern comes from. And since, you know, the this process is already kind of, you know, we're during the election season, right before Christmas, I feel that if we're making another change that would land us between Christmas

175and New Year's to try to get to reach the January 1st deadline, I think that to the public would be even more of a like, what are they trying to pull? Like, I don't think that's a that's a benefit. I think that's a more important criterion for me to just say we've got to come to a conclusion today. Trustee Cablanes, do you have some thoughts? I'm kind of torn. I am listening to what you guys are saying. I originally did like the green, too. I kind of liked all of three, still more than all of two, but there's not that much of a difference, really. Those are my thoughts. So are we safe to say that yellow two is out? I'm going to start backwards the other way. Okay, so yellow two is out. Do

176we have any other takers on all of three? We haven't had much discussion on that map yet. Is that one pulled? Is that the one that's up there now? Is all of three? Okay. I think it does break up a little bit that community that we were trying to keep together at the north the north side of town with the little that little triangle coming down. I think so. Is that a change right there? Is that triangle, Doug, between two and three? Yes, yes. So just to clarify, in the city process, there was a north downtown community map submitted, and this was not part of it, which is part of that. So you can see the break there. So is anybody stuck or really sold on all of three that wants to still discuss that

177one, or can we eliminate that one as well? It's like a multiple choice test. We're going to do process of elimination. I suggest based on that triangle that we eliminate all of three. Okay. With the people that live in that little triangle, I travel it daily and it feels like it's cut through by Portola, but I feel like it's part of that area of town and not part of that whole spring town area. Okay. Anybody feel strongly if we do eliminate that? Okay. Okay. So we'll eliminate three. So we're down to green and all of two. I think what it really probably comes down to with those two maps is really the schools and how important it is that we have a balance of the schools in that particular. Not a complete balance. Yeah. Nothing's

178completely balanced. I will say even in the green in district two, adult ed is one of the schools, which is not a community of interest school, in my opinion, that comes from all around the community. So really the only two schools in that district are Jackson and Saco. So even though- How about Lawrence kind of? Lawrence is not in that district. I just wanted to point that out. Yeah. Actually looking at green for the east side of town, all of two is just much, much more beneficial for all those constituents who have kids in those schools, with the exception of Little More High, but that's just how it is. Mm-hmm. Yeah. So I'm comfortable with all of two. Would you like a motion? Sure. Is that where we're at? Are we ready? Sure. Let's do

179it. Let's just go for it. We have a lot of- President Prusso, I'm, oh gosh, I don't know if I have the language for it. Yeah, this is a little complicated motion. Is it 16 4B? 16 4B, correct. So you're going to approve the resolution that will include whatever map you're motioning to make, correct? All right. Well, I'm going to try, and then we'll go from there. I move to support the superintendent's recommendation to approve resolution number 20-24 slash 25, which will include all of two as a proposed by-trustee area map and election sequencing schedule associated with all of two map. I second that. So we have a motion by Trustee Drouin, and we have seconded by Trustee Vanden Heuvel. Is there any discussion on the motion? I have a motion. Okay. Ask the clerk

180if they call a vote. Trustee Bueno. With reluctance, but out of appreciation for the community input, I will vote yay. Trustee Kaplanis. Aye. Trustee Vanden Heuvel. Aye. Myself, aye. President Prusso. Aye. That motion carries unanimously. Just a reminder for the community, as I mentioned at the beginning, this is an unusual process and that the board's vote is not last, but now there'll be a, the county committee will hold a hearing and hold their own vote based on the district's petition to them. All right. Thank you. Appreciate you guys being here, and also thank you to our community for your input. Okay. We're going to move on to 16-5 and invite Ms. Amy Robbins to come forward. This is the approval of an MOU. Are we not here? It's done. It's been working hard all night.

181There we go. Good evening, President Prusso, Superintendent Gibson, and members of the board. Tonight I bring to you the approval or approving the memorandum of understanding with the Livermore Education Association, or LEA, regarding the administrator designee. Through our partnership and working with our sites to ensure that there's coverage when the principal has to be off campus, we've worked with our Livermore Education Association to put forward tonight the MOU that's in front of you, and it really is focused on ensuring that there is that support needed at the school site when that principal needs to be off site. This would be LEA members who have supported in the past gaining that experience as administrators in that capacity, as well as leaving their classroom to provide that support in the office as needed. This is a voluntary

182position, and those people that would volunteer to be in this role would support with student discipline, parent communications, and assist the site if there were to be an emergency. The compensation as outlined in the MOU would be $100 per day of service, so these designees would have a substitute in their classroom. They would be primarily located in the office or out on the yard and the blacktop around site, providing that support with supervision, and the $100 compensation would be to support them as they work in this role, supporting our administrators, and ultimately the operations at the site. So it is the superintendent's recommendation to approve the memorandum of understanding with the Livermore Education Association, or LEA, regarding the administrator designee. I have no comments on this from the public. Any questions or comments from the

183board? If not, I would entertain a motion. Turn on my microphone. What did you ask? No, it's kidding. Following the recommendation of the superintendent, I move to approve the memorandum of understanding between the LEA regarding administrator designees. Second. Oh, you can have it. Okay. We have a motion by Trustee Vanden Heuvel, seconded by Trustee Kaplanis. Any discussion on the motion? I'd ask the clerk to take roll. Trustee Bueno, myself, aye. Trustee Vanden Heuvel, aye. Trustee Kaplanis, aye. President Prusso, aye. That carries unanimously. And now we're on to 16-6. I'm going to invite Dr. Tori Gibson to present to us the restructure of management and cabinet positions. So just a little bit of background first as I walk you through this item. So around August of 2022, there were two positions created at the district office,

184the executive director of special education and the executive director of human resources. The special education department has really faced some challenges over the course of the last few years. We're seeing a huge uptick in our identification rates. And I would say probably somewhat of a slight dismantling of our intervention programs. Having special education sit at the cabinet level is something that we are drastically missing here in this district. It's something that has not happened in the past. And I'll walk you through how that change could positively impact us. There we go. Oops, sorry. I forgot when I hit the button. I'm not looking at my screen, so I'll look up there. Okay. The assistant superintendent of special education would be dedicated oversight at that cabinet level that would sit here at the dais and be

185accountable for all the programming, litigation, and so forth. It's a strategic direction that we have as a board and as a governance team with myself included in that have put as part of my goals for this year. And it will honestly be an ongoing goal probably for the next five to eight years to be realistic with the amount of things that we need to be working on in our special education system. It'll have clear accountability. It'll help us ensure better compliance. And it's a high level role that will work both with myself and other cabinet members as we really need to work strongly in connecting our assistant superintendent of educational services with this new position. We have to start building a bridge between our gen ed classrooms and our students with special needs. And when

186I say students special needs, that's not always our lowest level students either. We have a lot of gate students who are classified in that realm as well, which then also includes educational services as we support teachers and provide training to them at all levels on how we scaffold up and down the system for all of our students in our classrooms. The assistant superintendent of human resources. Currently in our human resources department as a whole, and this is across the state, we have a huge increase in legal requirements with hiring. We have mandated state level reporting like we've never had prior. We have been working all year to really refine those systems in there so that we can improve customer service to both current and new employees who walk into our organization. It ensures compliance and

187it also provides another layer of support. One of the biggest issues that we are facing right now, and we will get there even though it's 1009 at some point, Ms. Wosley will get to walk us through our first interim budget as we're all a little fried, but that's okay. And one of the biggest struggles that we're having is that there has been a disconnect between human resources and our business department. And when that happens, you can't, and I think Ms. Thompson said it very eloquently earlier that when those two things happen and you don't have that alignment, then we get in a situation where it's really hard to track some of these functions. Every single piece of this attaches to another. I like to think of us as a Venn diagram. Everything over intersects with

188the other department some way, somehow. Our goal is to start getting some vertical alignment across the district as well as also looking to save some money and we'll get to that. So this recommendation includes the following eliminations. The elimination of the Assistant Superintendent of Administrative Services effective December 31st of 2024. The elimination of the Executive Director of Human Resources effective December 31st, 2024. The elimination of the Executive Director of Special Education effective June 30th of 2025. The elimination of the Executive Assistant Confidential Assigned to Human Resources effective June 30th of 2025. The restructuring then would put back into the system the Assistant Superintendent of Human Resources and the creation of an Assistant Superintendent of Special Education. Both of these current positions, and you can see in the packet tonight in the contracts, both of these

189positions are not a cost increase at all for those two new positions. They are people who would sit at their current pay, of which one of them, the new Assistant Superintendent of Human Resources would sit at her current pay for this year and next year, which is an additional cost savings. The ongoing cost savings to fund 01, and fund 01 is our general fund, which is where Ms. Wasley comes into play a little bit later. The ongoing, and this is long-term savings, is $380,401 going forward as of July 1st of 2025. And one of the things that we are looking to do is obviously we, as you'll see a little bit later, we have a $6 million deficit. The plan from my view is unlike everything else I like to do from the bottom up,

190this is unfortunately is a top-down approach. Really starting at the top and refining how we work and what we're doing, and rebuilding the system so that we're more efficient and collaborative so that we work smarter, not harder. At this time, it's my recommendation to approve the restructuring of management and cabinet. In the packet, you'll see the management salary schedule was adjusted. We added on the front end of the schedule, not the back end. So it also allows us over time, attrition happens at cabinet-level positions, hopefully not anytime soon. But as those do change, it does allow us to bring in people at a lower pay range, which does align more closely with our neighboring districts, which is something that we've talked about for a while since I got here. You'll see the job descriptions for

191the two assistant superintendent positions, as well as the updated contracts for those two individuals. I'm happy to answer any questions. I did have a blue card. It was Tara Boyce, but I believe that she left. Is that okay? So no other blue cards on this item. So any comments or questions from the board? Can you talk a little bit about why this takes six months to get or longer to get to July 1st with all the changes and the savings? So we have some people still in those positions currently, and those are all built into the budget as of now. So those positions, all administrators get at least a minimum of a one-year contract that unlike corporate America, we are subject to ed code rules that force us into kind of handcuffing ourselves from July

1921 through June 30th. It's a great question. I have a couple of questions. So regarding the assistant superintendent of special education, it calls for quote, general administration, standard administration of administrative service credential with appropriate basic credentials. And I'm just curious. I think I know the answer, but if a specific special education administrative credential exists. It does not. No administrative credentials are all very general. All of us hold the exact same credential. So that was my assumption. And so I looked into other job descriptions for assistant superintendents of special education, including Sonoma County office of ed, Sacramento city schools, Modesto city schools, and San Francisco public schools. A lot of it broke down to education credential and experience education masters or equivalent in a related field credential, holding the credential that you just described. And so

193for me, the big was the experience. And a lot of them use very similar language along the lines of any combination of education and experience that would likely provide the knowledge and abilities is qualifying. I'm interested in that kind of language because having somebody that is in charge of all of special education, to what extent is it important that they have or tell me about the choice to not say something along the lines of must have a special ed credential, must have five years in special education. So I recognize that administration is something different, but there's administrative skills and then like content areas, specific skills. So can you just talk to us a little bit about why it was designed the way it was and why you think that's the right choice for the position

194for this district? Absolutely. So as an administrator, as you come up through the ranks, often the pecking order, if you will, from the bottom up is you're usually a vice principal. Typically you become a principal. Sometimes you're a principal at multiple levels, whether it be high school, middle, elementary, some people do all three. And then you work your way up and depending on the districts, it's coordinator, director, assistant superintendent along the way in all of those processes. Even if you start as a teacher, as a counselor, you're still working with special education students at all times. All students belong to each of us as an educator on a school site. And so as you come up through the ranks, especially coming from a principal role, you are in charge of special education at your school

195site. I've mentioned this previously, and I'll just kind of explain it again that in our roles here, it's as if we are the large corporate office and all of our school sites are little mini franchises, if you will, around the city. And as a principal, you wear many hats and one of them is special education. You are in charge of all of your IEPs. You're in charge of the instruction that your students get, whether it's gen ed or special ed. You're in charge of scheduling all of those. You're in charge of scheduling all of your aids, all the functions at the same time. And it's not that having a specific special education credential isn't something that is desirable. However, first of all, it's there are few and far between usually. But more importantly, having somebody

196who sits in a role, if you were a successful principal along the way, you also have the other lens of the other side of the gen ed side of the house. And those two pieces have to speak to each other in order to create a successful system along the way. So it's not that it's good to do it one way or the other. I would just say that having somebody in a high level special education credentialing role, they're going to have the same administrative credential that everyone else. There is not a specialized credential for that. So maybe they were, let's say they were a mod severe teacher or a speech therapist. The only difference that they're going to have is that lens that they had while they were in that role coming up through the

197ranks to get to an assistant superintendent level means that they've had multiple other things along the way as well. No different than somebody coming from the gen ed side. If that explains that. Yeah. And the new job description does say master's degree in five years experience in a special education environment. So would you consider being a principal as that? Yes. Because I think part of me thinks there's a difference between, you know, being a restaurateur and being a chef and understanding the ingredients that are required to make something be successful. And so I think that I don't part of me is concerned. I mean, in an ideal situation, you have someone with administrative level expertise, as well as special education level expertise. But as we just saw with our maps, we can't get everything all

198the time. And to some extent, it's important to be open to people that, I don't know, are stellar on one or the other. So I appreciate the clarification. Sure. One of the questions I had, I had asked it a while back, we were developing it. Do we have, because I understand the discussion behind, you know, vertical alignment. So my first question is, do we have an org chart yet that we can actually see this is what it looks like? Well, we have had multiple renditions of the org chart. And this was kind of the final piece that we were waiting for to put a new one out. Okay. We have done a lot of movement with various departments. So if we were to give you an org chart, let's say from July one, that org

199chart would have special education in a different place. Let's say in June, special education was under educational services at that point in time. Throughout time, it became very complex. Educational services is its own beast by itself. So to take on educational services and special education, it's honestly not doable in a district this size. So as when I came on board, we started internally making some of those movements to start some of that vertical alignment over time. There were many things that were under administrative services that truly were just, it was just kind of a catch all position. So things that really align with business were not under the business department, including bond, MOF, tech, who, what else am I missing? Those are the big three. Those are the big three. Those all traditionally sit under

200business. So we move those over there. We moved student services and wellness coordinator under ed services, because what was happening is we had three directors of ed services under, let's say Michelle, and then we had one director of student services over here. Well, all four of those directors have to align and they need to funnel up into one vertical alignment. So we made that adjustment. They also work very closely with our wellness staff that is part of our educational services department. So we moved that. So then it just came down to SPED and HR being under educational services most recently. And we still didn't have the expertise of one thing. Miss Minky did an amazing job, but at the same time, it's there are two major systems that have nothing to do with each other.

201So as we've been slightly tweaking and making adjustments, that was when we opted to go down this route. It also has a very considerable cost savings long-term. And what it looks like on the short-term too, but it's the elimination. It looks largely it's due to the elimination of the executive assistant, like that position is not being replaced because they served the executive directors. All right. Another question relative, and I think it says on 16.6, looking at the contracts, we'll do the special ed one first. Can we bring up the, well, not really a need, but like the salary schedule, because it looks like it was expanded both downward and then like the whole, the total number. And so there's rather than having what looked to be six steps prior, there's now eight steps. So what

202we did is we added onto the front end. So the elimination, that's a great question. So the elimination of the executive director, the executive director of both those positions sat at the current step one of the proposed salary schedule. So to eliminate those, we started there. It just happened to be that it had a perfect breakdown of steps one and two to step three that between what was step one, that is, that would now be step three between three and four, the percentage there is the same as when we backed it out down to the highest level of the executive director. So by the, by eliminating the executive director, we then started, we'll start the salary schedule here. There's no downward movement. It's just a cross. So it's an eight step system. And then we

203just changed it from letters to steps by number. And that makes sense. So I understand the rationale behind it, but when I look at the language within each of the respective contracts, we'll go back to that one, the human resource one, when we go to that on page two of seven, item 3.2.2. Hold on one second. Let me get there. Which, okay, we're on contract. It says Livermore Valley. Yeah. Yeah. Human resources contract. And it's page two. Okay. And it's a 3.3.2.2. Okay. It says a blah, blah, blah. And the second to last sentence says the assistant superintendent shall be eligible for five step increases. But if they come in at one of eight, how to five, they would never top out. That is correct. So we will bring that back at, at the end

204of the year, when we do the updated contracts each year, we'll bring that back on the amendments. Okay. But should it be spoken to in the specific contract? And the reason I ask that is if we go to the other contract for the special ed, it has the same language. It's just boiler plate language. Yes, it is. Given the salary that they're coming in at, they're more relatively almost top step. Sure. So they were at step three of six. Now they're at step five of eight. If you go to the same clause, it says the assistant superintendent speaking to this specific one, it's not general language, shall be eligible for five step increases. So that language. Right. So we can do two things. We can either, if the board opts to approve this as proposed,

205we can do one, two things. We can leave this as is. We will fix it in June when we bring back the new contracts to include the eight steps, or we can do a table change on these contracts. We can also just bring the contracts back next meeting as well. Okay. It's just because we're entering into a contract, they're contracted employees. And, you know, one wouldn't be eligible for top step and the other can't achieve what it says. So I just like clean language. That's it. Anyone else have any comments? Do you want to make a motion with an amendment? Is there a way that we could, I'd like to get it moved, that we could do it and then perhaps you could come back to us, you know, with just, I think that if

206each, because they are individual contracts, they're not boilerplate. It's not like when we do an organization, these are specific to the employee, that if we could literally clean up the language and say, yeah, you know, and it's just contractual language, of course, you know, with the special ed one, it's going to have to say, we'll be eligible for a maximum of, it looks to be three steps. Well, but it's going to depend on, no, this is, this was written actually from an attorney from a prior contract. Um, this is the same contract that we've used for prior people when we had five steps. So it's a maximum of eight steps access, depending on where we put people based on that. So we wouldn't necessarily change that number, but we can definitely have Michelle can and

207look at that and get some discussion. Yeah, that's what I'm concerned because it doesn't say, it doesn't say may or can it says the assistant superintendent shall be eligible for five steps. So to me, it's imperative that five steps exist. If they don't exist, then we're unable to meet the contract. And more importantly, the other superintendent in HR would never be able to get to top step and top step allows them to achieve longevity. And so they would never be eligible. Right. And I think the way that the attorney wrote this, though, is how many steps are eligible total for that job title. So as an example, Ms. Manke's, well, actually all three of the assistant superintendents have this exact same language in their current today contract of five steps access. So all of those

208are going to have to be fixed. The step isn't written based on where we place them on the step. When they come in, it's based on how many steps are accessed to them. That's how the attorney wrote it. If that makes sense. Yep. And that would be language. It would say something like upon placement, they'll be eligible for an annual step based on whatever to a maximum of five. Correct. Not to exceed level eight. Right. Correct. And so that's something I can definitely take back to our attorney because this is all drafted by them. So we can bring back an amendment to the next meeting. That's no problem. I do want to move it. I just want to make sure that we're not because we're going to vote up to approve a contract. And once

209we vote to approve a contract, unless there's a contingency in it, it's approved. We'd have to come back and revoke the contract. I don't want to do that. Agreed. And also want to put someone in a situation where they can't achieve what's written. Okay. So I'm comfortable. However, you would like me to do it. We can bring back an amendment. It's probably the cleanest way to do it. We can just bring back a whole nother clean contract in January. Approve these with the motion being that we bring back another one contingent. Yeah. I mean, yeah, we don't have another meeting before January 1st. And we want to keep. Yeah. Okay. But I see what you're saying. I will get with legal and figure out what language they prefer in there. Okay. Do you want to

210make the motion? Sure. And where's is it? We're going to do this one. Well, there are there. We can do these because they are different. You can make the motion though, for the entire packet, for the entire item, for the entire thing. Yeah. Cause we want to do it for you go to six zero. It says it right there. Recommendation 16.6, 16.0 16.6 a through E. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. And my thing's not coming up. I'll just say it. It's I move in support of the superintendent's recommendation on item 16, which the approval of the memorandum of understanding for the two things. The salary schedule contingent upon a contractual language changes that are consistent here with, with the salary schedule, because you may have to amend one or the other of both. And that's a three.

211Excuse me. That's a through E. Yeah. 16.6 a through E. Yes. Yes. 16.6 alpha a through E. Edward. I second. Okay. So we have a motion by trustee Bueno, seconded by trustee Vanden Heuvel. I'm going to get it. I've been practicing for three months. Is there any discussion on the motion? I think we got the motion down correctly. I'd ask the clerk to please take roll. Trustee Vanden Heuvel. Aye. Trustee Kaplanis. Aye. Trustee Bueno. Aye. Myself, aye. President Purcell. Aye. That motion carries unanimously. All right. Here we are. Finally to the, the, we're going to turn the time over to Ms. Kayla Wesley for the, yeah, for the approval of the first interim financial report. All right. We're having major technology issues. Just one minute. There's some technical difficulties. Sorry. The wrong blasters presentation accidentally

212got put into the folder. The right one is on the board packet. It's just not in the folder for Jeff to share. Yes. I'm turning. I'm just trying to get there. Unfortunately thing. I just want to thank our audience. You guys are killing it and the millions of people watching online. We love you guys. Yeah. We have those on our TV. Yeah. We're close. I think we're just getting it up on the screen. There we go. I was like, wait a minute. That doesn't look like my new slideshow. So sorry. This is, I think what happens when you present at 10 30. So good evening. Okay. Ready? Okay. Perfect. Okay. So tonight I am presenting to you our first interim budget for 24, 25 fiscal year. So the purpose of first interim, it's our first

213required and you'll update to our adopted budget that was approved in June of 24. It covers the period of July 1 through October 31st and is required to be filed by December 15th. I will say with the new requirements for organizational board meetings and election cycles, it's kind of made first interim kind of a difficult deadline. So our County office to give us approval to submit to the County office by December 15th that approved tonight on December 17th. And then our next update will be second interim, which covers July 1st through January 31st and is reported on by March 15th. And then depending on your certification status with your qualified, there is a third interim that I did not include on here that would cover the period of July 1 through April 30th and be

214June due in May. And then our unaudited actuals are when we've actually finalized the fiscal year and it is due by September 15th. First interim updates the budget based off of the state adopted budget, as well as any known date at the time, your final staffing numbers, revenue changes, as well as your year to date information. So I've incorporated kind of a view of our budget cycle. We're at first interim in December. Our next piece of information that we'll receive is our great governor's budget proposal in January. That's in mid January. And then from there, we will be moving into second interim report, which will come to you in March. And then we jump right into adopting or developing the budget and LCAP for the rest of the school year, as well as continuing to

215monitor the current year budget to then adopt next year's budget in June. And then in June, July, the state adopted budget is presented. And then we complete the fiscal year prior in September and then move into updating our current year budget. So we're kind of frequently operating in two fiscal years right now is kind of the one time that we're really only in this fiscal year, even though we're planning kind of for next year already as well. So just an overall summary of where we are sitting at first interim, our projected unrestricted reserve is at three point nine three percent of our total expenditures. It is being recommended that first interim be certified as qualified, meaning that we may not be able to meet our three percent required reserves in the current year or two

216subsequent years. If we do not make reductions, budget reductions will be required in twenty five, twenty six and twenty six, twenty seven in order to meet that minimum three percent reserve that is required by the state and return to a positive certification or statutory COLA for twenty four, twenty five is one point oh seven percent. We received that COLA on both our LCF funding, which is the bulk of our funding, as well as special education and mandated block grant and some other funding sources. Our school districts, LCFF funding actually decreased by one point four two percent in twenty four, twenty five. So with the impact of declining enrollment and lower ADA, as well as a low statutory COLA, we actually had a net decrease in funding. Our enrollment, as well as our unduplicated pupil percentage

217decreased from our prior year actual counts, as well as our current year projections that were projected at the adopted budget in June, which is attributing to an additional loss of LCFF funds that was not projected at the adopted budget. So overall, in our unrestricted sources, we have projected one hundred and fifty five million dollars in revenue with one hundred and twenty three million dollar in expenses. And then we have a plan transfer out of sixty seven thousand dollars and then contributions to our restricted program. So those are things like special education, our routine restricted maintenance account that's a required contribution and other programs. And then our overall net decrease to our unrestricted ending fund balance is six point six million dollars. Our beginning fund balance was fifteen point six million dollars for a total projected

218ending fund balance of eight point nine million dollars in our unrestricted balance on our restricted expenditures and revenue. We're projecting forty eight point nine million in revenue, ninety nine million in expenditures with four hundred eighty one thousand dollars being transferred in from our child nutrition fund, which is funding that gives us some more flexibility by keeping it in Fundo one. You'll see an offsetting amount of contributions to restricted programs from unrestricted and the equal amount of three thirty eight point eight million dollars for an overall decrease in fund balance of ten point eight million dollars. Our beginning fund balance was twelve point nine million dollars, leaving our projected ending fund balance at two point one million dollars. Here's a depiction of our revenue sources showing that LCF sources account for seventy three percent of our

219revenue. So it really is the bulk of our revenue. And then federal revenue, other state revenue and local revenue make up the rest of our revenue sources. So I'll go into kind of what were some of the changes that we have seen in our revenue from adopted budgets. So LCF funding decreased by one point three million dollars. As mentioned, our projected enrollment at adopted budget was thirteen thousand one hundred students with funded ADA of twelve thousand three hundred seventy eight students based on our actual enrollment in twenty four twenty five. We had an enrollment of twelve thousand nine hundred and sixty nine students and our funded ADA will be twelve thousand three hundred and seven students, which is a loss of seventy one ADA. The average LCF entitlement per ADA is twelve thousand and ninety

220dollars. So even though seventy one may be in twelve thousand students doesn't sound like a huge hit when it's twelve thousand per student. It definitely adds up quickly. Our unduplicated pupil percentage also decreased from twenty nine point two percent to twenty eight point two percent. Our unduplicated pupil percentage is given to us on a rolling three year average. So they take our current year and then the two prior years to create our average. So our current year actually decreased by about six percent from projections. And so that number is going to keep hitting our funding, not just in the current year, but in our out years as well, depending on if we stay at the current twenty four percent that we are sitting at or return to our higher percentage that we had last year

221or continue to decrease as well, which brings other concerns as it reduces funding for our populations that need some additional services. And then our TK enrollment was also lower than projected as well as the TK ADA. TK ADA was projected at four hundred and eighty one based on our twenty four, twenty five enrollment. TK ADA is now projected at four hundred and forty eight dollars. We receive additional funds for TK students due to additional staffing requirements in your grades, kindergarten through third grade. We are at a twenty four to one ratio for class size reduction and class sizes for TK. It's twenty four to one, but your adults to pupils is twelve to one. So we have to have one teacher as well as one other adult, like a paraprofessional in the classroom. So we

222do receive some additional funding for that. And so that also had an impact on our funding. So the net result of all of those changes was one point three million dollars lost in funding in our federal revenue. We had an increase of four million dollars that was largely due to increases in carryover funding both from our magnet grant had five million dollars total budgeted this year with three million dollars being from year one and two of the grant being carried forward in this year because it remains unspent. We also had some unspent funds in Title one, Title two, Title three and Title four. I am working with educational services on making sure we are best utilizing those funds and making sure we're fully spending them. We had a slight increase to our Indian education grant.

223We had some final dollars to spend in our piece of the American relief plan homeless assistance funding that we received several years ago where we spent out the balance of that as well as the balance of our youth built grants. And then we did see a decrease in both our special education funding and Perkins grant and other state revenue. We had an increase of two point four or five million dollars. I listed all of the programs that had increases. Some of the larger ones were our manatee block grant lottery, ELOP, our UPK planning grant. That's a grant that we received several years ago that we recognize the unspent revenue each year. There are two different types of funding sources that you can receive as a school district. You either have a grant that has an

224unearned revenue type. And so if you don't spend that entire grant within that school year, you don't recognize it as revenue until the following fiscal year when you spend it. And so if you have a grant that you have five years to spend and it's five hundred thousand dollars and you only spend a hundred thousand dollars in the first year, four hundred thousand dollars would carry forward as revenue potentially for the next year and then so on and so forth until you fully spend it. But you only recognize it as revenue once you've spent it or you have unearned revenue types where you say receive five hundred thousand dollars and you recognize the full five hundred thousand dollars as revenue in the current year, you maybe only spend a hundred thousand dollars. So the remaining

225balance falls to your ending fund balance. And then it almost appears as a deficit spending in the next years because you're not receiving the revenue, but you are expensing the revenue. So then it shows up as your expenditures, but not as revenue. So that is the part of U.P.K. planning grant that it's not a new grant, but it is one that we haven't fully spent. Green partnership grant also had some carry over that we're recognizing as revenue this year and then same with strong workforce program and then our state mental health related services. We had about an eight hundred thousand dollar increase in that resource because we were previously participating in a program that they charged us about eight hundred thousand dollars to participate in that program. We're no longer participating in that program. And

226so now we are keeping those funds and providing the services to our students directly. And then we received a new college and career pathways grant and then our classified employee summer assistance program. We received higher revenue based off of participation. We had decreased revenue in our special education, early intervention funds, which those are funds that we received to provide preschool intervention to students and our Prop 28 arts and music grant decreased slightly. Our STRS on behalf revenue is projected to decrease. That is a book entry that we make on behalf of the state for their contribution to the STRS pension retirement system. And then we have an equal amount that we recognize as benefits for STRS and our home to school transportation reimbursement decreased slightly in our other local revenue. We have an increase of

227two point two million dollars. There are some sources of local revenue that we don't recognize as revenue until we receive the funds. Sales of equipment is one as well as donations and gift accounts. But then some other areas that I updated were leases and rentals based off of current leases and facility rentals to date are Tri-Valley ROP MOUs. Those are MOUs that we have in place with Tri-Valley ROP for services that the district provides, whether through sections of teaching staff, the business services that we provide to Tri-Valley ROP as well as custodial services. We had a decrease or an increase in our special education funding that kind of helps offset the decrease in federal education special education funding. I projected an increase in our community redevelopment property taxes based off a prior year. We have

228Medi-Cal reimbursements that we received to date as well as some increases to our SBHIP and MHSSA funding, which are both related to wellness centers and counseling services for students. We have our project build grant that is newer and kind of taking over for youth builds. And then we had a little bit in miscellaneous restricted local revenue and then gift accounts that we received to date. And then so on to expenditures. This is an overall depiction of our total expenditures, both restricted and unrestricted. The large bulk of it from the darker blue area to the red to the green and the purple are all salaries and benefits. So the largest portion of our budget is on salary and benefits. And then the rest is comprised of books and supplies, services, and capital outlay and some other

229outgo. So to go over some highlights of expenditure changes from adopted budget, certificated as well as classified salaries and associated benefits were adjusted based off of the actual cost of new hires and projections for current vacancies. Some other notable changes, I transferred funds from our certificated salaries to services based off of non-public agency contracts that we have in place for certificated positions that were required to hire, but we have not been able to fill with an employee. So some of those costs, we see a decrease in our cost of certificated salaries, non-management. And part of that is the shift of those budgeted funds over to services, which is in a different object code. And then we added positions for our magnet and school-based mental health grants, as well as in our management salaries, we saw

230an increase due to a contract payout. In books and supplies, we had an increase of $9 million. That was pretty much all in restricted categories. We had carryover in ELOP, Title I, Title III, and Title IV, as well as our magnet and school-based mental health grants, our UPK planning grant, our restricted lottery, Prop 28, kit funds, an A to G learning loss, ethnic studies, Medi-Cal, and gift accounts. So all of those are restricted sources that roll forward and then we budget them based off of the needs of the program. And then in services and operating supplies, we had increases to our insurance due to our AB 218 liability, which is additional insurance costs that we are facing as a result of the statute of limitations being lifted on sexual harassment and molestation cases. Legal costs

231increase, as well as our non-public school and agency contracts increase. So both of our placements in non-public schools, as well as the contracts that we have for services for students increased. And then grant funding, we had carryover as well as one-time carryover in ELOP, Title I, Title II, magnet, Medi-Cal, and our gift accounts. Our routine restricted maintenance contribution increased. Routine restricted maintenance is 3% of our expenses and so as our expenses increase, our contribution to routine restricted maintenance also increases. And then we also have our new college and career pathways access grant that was budgeted for a total increase of $4.5 million to services. In capital outlay, we had an increase of $435,000. We needed a new forklift for our warehouse. We had concerns of catching on fire due to it being very old. And

232so we needed to do a new forklift in order to access all of the items in our warehouse. And then we have purchases for our magnet grant as well as kit funding, which is kitchen infrastructure and training funds that will go into our food services kitchens. And then project build also has some capital outlay purchases. And then in other outgo, we have an increase of $291,000. That is largely due to funds that we received in 23-24 that I would say the state didn't really notify districts about this new pot of money that they were providing for preschool grants and our contracts. It's called cost of care. And so we received that first round of funding in 23-24. It got put into a district account with some other state funds. And so this year as we

233were cleaning up, we discovered that we actually owe this money to CAPE because they are our preschool subcontractors and receive all of our state preschool funds. And so we are going to pay that out to the CAPE this year. And then our inner fund transfers out increased by $78,000 in total due to an increase to fund 67 for increased property and liability cost claims. Fund 67 is our self-insurance fund for our property and liability insurance as well as claims. So based off of all of that, I have updated the multi-year projection revenue and expenditures. So in 24-25, our ending fund balance for unrestricted is 3.9% with a total restricted and unrestricted ending fund balance of 5%. In 25-26 and 26-27, we have identified $1 million currently in cuts but need an additional $5 million in

234reductions in order to meet our minimum reserve. With the total $6 million in reductions in 25-26, we will have an ending fund balance in our unrestricted reserve of 3.2%. And in 26-27, we will have just 3%, which is the state minimum requirement to meet our requirements for the state. And then a huge part of our funding in a school district is related to our enrollment and our ADA. So I wanted to include kind of a history of where our enrollment has been, where it's projected to be. So the first line is 19-20 school year. We were at 13,722 students enrolled. And as we all know, 19-20 school year was a crazy year. And going into 20-21, we saw a decrease down to 13,305 students or loss of 3% of our population. And then going into

23521-22, we saw another 2.2% decrease in our enrollment. And then we've kind of stabilized since then at right around 13,000 students. But then in the bottom graph, you'll see I included our funded ADA information. So going from 19-20 to 20-21 school year, while our enrollment decreased by 3%, our funded ADA did not decrease at all because there were COVID ADA reliefs that were given to school districts to hold us harmless during that time. And so that occurred in not only 20-21, but 21-22. And then 22-23, when our enrollment had started to stabilize is when we started getting hit with decreases to our funded ADA. So we have a decrease of 1.8% in funded ADA in 22-23. And then going into 23-24, we have another 2.7% decrease in funded ADA. And then into 24-25, another 2.5%

236decrease in funded ADA. So that COVID relief kind of kept that hit of our funded ADA change at bay until the last couple of years. And so this year is kind of the final year that we're really feeling the hit of that ADA cliff, as many refer to it, that has happened since COVID. Does that all make sense? No, that's okay. Just on that one, the percentage that you're showing reflects a percentage in the change in enrollment, not necessarily that that percentage correlates to a dollar amount. Right. So if the amount you received per student increased, while the amount of students you have decreased, you could essentially net out additional funding. Yes. So if you get more per kid, but you have less kids, yes, we had the declining enrollment, but if the amount we

237got for each kid that remained was greater than we got before, it's just a different way of presenting the same thing. This shows declining enrollment by numbers, but not necessarily monetarily. Yes. And we do receive COLA increases to our LCFF funding, which does kind of offset that, but then at the same time, our COLA is also helping to do things like compensation increases, as well as keeping up with the cost of utilities and services. And so when you put all of that into play, it is where we did see an increase overall to our LCFF funding. I don't believe the increase is kept up with keeping similar levels of staffing while also keeping up with the cost of staffing and services and everything when it's all combined. So that's kind of where those increases come

238into play is that you don't receive your full COLA when you do have declining enrollment. Well, yeah. The number of students you get, you're not going to get the full COLA. I'd be interested to see like a chart like that, because those were the years where we see the declining enrollment. One of those not the years, what was the year that school districts in California got the record base increase? There was two years consecutive. Yes. In 22, 23, we received a very high COLA as well as an augmentation to our LCFF base. So I believe the total increase was 13.26 percent. And then in 23, 24, I believe it was 8.22 percent COLA. I believe I could be one year off in that. And then this year is at 1.07 percent. And when we get

239those increases, that establishes the new floor. So we're not going to drop below that. And that's under Prop 98 or something. Yes, Prop 28 is the minimum guarantee. So once that increases, and that's what I'm looking at. When we see this, one would look at the, you know, I would draw without knowing that I would look at this and say, well, your declining enrollment is driving the deficit. But if the amount of money we received, a record base increase in those exact same years, right where we see that cliff, that decline enrollment cliff, we also got a 13 percent COLA raise. And then the subsequent year sounds like eight point something percent. Okay. Yes. And then we, yes, there are other factors in there, but we did that help offset kind of some of this.

240And then some of the challenges that our district is facing as we look at our deficit spending is our declining enrollment, as well as our lowering unduplicated pupil percentage percent, because we received 20 percent on top of our base for our unduplicated percentage. So as that decreases, we receive less funding. And then our attendance rates prior to the pandemic, they were at 95.92 percent in 17, 18 and 96.3 percent in 1920. The attendance rate in 23, 24 was 94.2 percent. An increase of one percent in our ADA is equivalent to about 1.5 million dollars. I believe Amy referenced it in her report that if we can get our ADA up, that could be a huge benefit to our district. So that will be, I think, a continued focus of the district, which it already has

241been, and we do seem to be projecting better for this year. But as we get into really what I call golden flu season, only time will tell. And then deficit spending, we're facing a structural deficit in our multi-year that we will need to address sooner rather than later due to relatively low unrestricted reserve balances. So we can't continue to deficit spend at the level that we have been and still meet our minimum reserve requirements. And then we have largely exhausted all of our COVID relief dollars. We just have, I believe, one pot of money left going into 25-26, which is our educator effectiveness grant dollars. And then next steps, first interim budget is being recommended to be qualified for first interim. We'll continue to move forward with some additional reductions in 25-26 and 26-27 of

242the six million dollars. And the district must evaluate staffing at all levels to ensure that we are stopped appropriately. And then we'll continue to evaluate contracts as well to ensure that they are necessary and align with district initiatives. We'll be looking at supply budgets as well. Pretty much every dollar that goes out, we will be looking at. And then initial options will be presented to the board beginning this month. And then we'll continue into January 25. And then no later than March 4th of 2025, we will need to bring an initial board resolution if we're going to be reducing any staff based off our current board schedule. And then the final resolution to reduce staff would be May 6, 2025. And then we'll continue to develop our 25-26 budget and present that per approval in

243June. Additional questions? Okay. We do have a couple of comments from the public. So we will begin with that. Jerry Allen, come up first, and then we'll be followed by Amy Thompson. I've got to again say that governance is what every public employee, every elected official needs to learn. Governance means not only what you do, but how you do it has to be done correctly. If you don't, there will be consequences down the road. They can be political, or as discussed in the meeting today, this topic, it can be financial. Several years ago, the board elected to provide a massive pay increase to all of the employees of the district. The reason that you have a deficit is because of that pay increase. And if you're going to reduce the expenditures by $5 million, what's

244your biggest expense? It's your employees. So now you're going to go around and have to save money through employee reductions. That was the choice that you made. And I know that you don't have a crystal ball, neither do I, but this is what governance is about, is understanding the consequences of the decisions that you make that carry forward multiple years, sometimes forever. So that's all I have to say. You've got a... In September, when the financial presentation was made, it was announced that you had a $9 million carry forward. Well, I know what that means, and you know what that means, but the public doesn't know what that means. They thought you said that you had a $9 million surplus and that everything was cool and dandy. You've got a deficit you've known about for

245how long? You're not telling us. You are not telling us how long you knew about the deficit. And you have voted to expend more money. I haven't seen any cost reductions take place. I haven't seen you delay expenditures that were coming before you. And you're the ones that make the decision. The superintendent makes recommendations. I appreciate that. You have a tough job. I wouldn't want it, but you're the ones that make the decisions. So when you get a recommendation, remember where you're getting it from. Don't have a circle of yes men, because if you do, it's going to be trouble. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. So I have to start with what Mr. Yeh Long just stated as far as compensation increase creating a deficit. I've done the math. The compensation increase did not

246create the deficit. There was enough new ongoing funding in the record increase, the base increase, which was COLA, plus a base increase, which was 13%, to completely fund all increased costs of compensation over the last two years if we had kept staffing levels flat. But we didn't. We had declining enrollment and we increased staffing levels. So it's not because we got a compensation increase that we're now facing a deficit. That's inaccurate. I have some questions on the first interim budget report. Okay. The first one on pages 149 to 155 of the first interim report as you're scrolling, which for the school district criteria and standards review report, if that were separated out, is pages 23 to 29. The number of full-time equivalent positions for certificated, classified, and management are reported over a four-year period, which

247includes last year, this year, and the next two years. Are these actual numbers or are they estimates? If you have, do you have more questions? I do. I mean, because you have one minute. So maybe ask your questions and then we'll do the answers. Is that okay? Yeah. Okay. So if they're actual numbers, can we extrapolate them from previous year's reports and find a year-over-year staffing FTE, not number of people? In slide number 12 of the presentation, it shows a total increased cost for salaries of $414,017 and the corresponding increased benefit cost is $778,345. Why would the cost of benefits increase more than the cost of salaries? The major difference between the adopted budget after the addition of the unaudited actual adjustments, so the carryover funding, seems to be an increased cost for salaries and

248benefits of $1.1 million, of which nearly half a million dollars is for management salaries and an increased cost for contracted services of $4.5 million. Why did the management salary costs increase by half a million from the original budget? Is the cost for the restructuring done tonight included in this? What impact will the restructuring have on the cost for our district? That's your time. Sorry, Amy. I'll email you the rest. Yeah, we'll get back to you. I think what should happen is, Ms. Tomlinson, if you can submit those in writing to Ms. Wasley and we can respond to those at a later date, because we'll have to take some time for that for you, but that's no problem. Thank you, Amy. Okay. Any questions or comments from the board? We were talking about, yeah, this is

249just for, just to approve the first interim, the discussion on what we're going to, how we're going to do this is happening on Thursday. Correct. So I did have a question, if nobody else does, and that was the unduplicated change. Do we know, is that because of classification? Is that because people moved out of the district? Do we have an idea of why? Yeah. I think it was a 3%. Yes. So in prior years, we really did a push for our meal applications, which is great, except for we were asking families to complete it even if they didn't want to. And so they were putting $0 as their income. And when you put $0 income on your meal application, you automatically qualify per the meal eligibility guideline. And so this year it was more of

250a push and repeated request that if you believe you qualify, please fill it out. So we're trying to find that balance of how much to push our families versus how much, if you push too much and then they're filling out inaccurate data and you're kind of falsifying some of the information. Just to clarify for someone who might not know, does this have anything to do and how does it correlate with the free and reduced lunches? Because we used, if I'm not mistaken, we used to use that as the measure by which to track. And when the federal government allowed for free and fair meals, for full funding of meals, that we no longer had a means. So we had to solicit the data as opposed to just simply extrapolating it from a known source. Yes.

251Great question. I should have explained exactly what makes up our unduplicated percentage. So it is a combination of our free and reduced meals and our students that qualify for free and reduced meals, ELs, qualified students, homeless, foster youth. Those are the different buckets that make up a new unduplicated student pupil count. And so if you qualify for just one of those, you count towards our percentage of students. And then when universal meals went into effect, we received less meal applications because there was no longer an incentive because all students are now getting meals for free. And so now we're kind of combating that all students are getting free meals. So there's really not a incentive to submit a meal application. And so we still request the meal applications. They just don't really have as much

252of an impact on our families. And that's part of why we're seeing the decrease. Have any other jurisdictions, this is a shared issue, have any other jurisdictions or us collectively with other agencies look for a way to mitigate this? Because some people may not understand how that unduplicated works. All those needs are present, but you can only get paid for one. And so the overwhelming, the underpinning of almost all disadvantaged is socioeconomically depressed, the SED. So people who are low on funds tend to drive everything. People who are English language learners tend to be coming in, they tend to be on the lower end of the socioeconomic scale. But if we were using that and that was our best means, is there any other thing that's derived from all this, like a better way to

253track this? Not so far. I know that advocates across the state have been trying to talk to our legislators about how the universal meals has now impacted LCFF funding. Some districts have a really high unduplicated count or direct certification, which is the state certifying students as qualified. And then the districts receive that information. So if you're a district that has a high number of direct certified students, you're not as impacted by free and reduced at lunch applications. So when you're kind of in this 20, 40, 30, 40% percentage, it is tougher as a district when you really have a smaller base that you're working with. Just because you're not getting as many direct certifications, you're relying more on your meal applications. And there really hasn't been answers that I found. We try to do as

254much push for it and explaining of how not only does it benefit the district, but it could still benefit families as well. Through various reasons, you get lower AP test fees, as well as SATs, college applications, sometimes utilities. But that doesn't seem to be driving a lot of response. I have one quick question. On slide 13, it's the major expenditures changes from budget adoption. The books and supplies went from $4.6 million to $13.6 million for a difference of $9 million. So why? Largely carryover of funds in our restricted sources. So restricted means that we can only use them for a specific purpose. So ELOP, for example, is our afterschool funding program. We were receiving large amounts of that in the beginning years of ELOP. And we were trying to figure out most districts across the

255state were trying to figure out how exactly to spend those ELOP funds. And so we're right now experiencing a large amount of carryover that we're trying to whittle down and get our programs as robust as possible. But we still do have that carryover. And so as we carry forward those restricted dollars, we're then planning to spend it within the required timelines to ensure that we don't lose the funds. Same with all of our title funds, our magnet grant, our school-based mental health, UPK, those all have spending deadlines. Restricted lottery does not have a spending deadline. We did have a million dollars carryover from restricted lottery, which can only be used for curriculum. And so the hope is that we can eventually get the social science curriculum that was adopted. So that has been set aside

256for that as well. Prop 28 kit, the A to G learning loss also have spending deadlines set by the state that we are trying to make sure we spend all of those funds appropriately and before we lose the funds. It's been mentioned that we also, we know we have declining enrollment, but have we increased staffing during that same time period? And what I'm looking for is do we have, I'm not sure what the name is here, but we used to call it a positions and salary survey. And it basically, it's an allocation for all your positions. You have X number of positions, some are FTE, full-time equivalent, some are part-time, but do we have something that's, I know we were kind of working on that. It's been kind of a desired thing. There has to

257be some, we have employee ID numbers and we know how much they work. So it seems like you could just put them all in a column and do an Excel sheet and print it out. Yes, we have what's called position control in our financial system. And so that really ties an employee to a position which sets their hours, their calendar. So I've been working closely with HR to try to clean that up. We had a lot of vacancies that hadn't been filled in many years. And so trying to figure out for projection purposes, what is actually going to be filled? What are we looking to fill currently? What's being filled by contractors? So we are tightening down our position control. Prior years had a lot of vacancies that weren't looking to be filled. And so

258it does make it tough when you pull reports, it's hard to tell from year to year. I can see actual what has been filled, but it's hard to derive what the true vacancies were that may have been filled by a substitute or by a contracted position and that such thing. Okay. My concern is I saw when I first came on the board, they used to issue March 15th notices, but what that does to morale and what does that sound uncertainty and it's your new most newly hired people looking at it. It was like, well, the people that you're bringing in happen to be about the same number of people that you're noticing, 55 to 75 people a year. That seemed to be about the hiring and that seemed to be about the people got the

259notices. So they're not all the same people, but we kind of went by the wayside with the March 15th and we were able to kind of mitigate it in that way. So what I'm looking for is if we have unfilled, but yet funded positions, that's going to show us an expenditure, whether we, until you scrape it back, an accrued style of accounting, you have to allocate the funds towards the expenditure, but if you don't incur the expenditure, it's still going to show on your expenditures, correct? Correct. So you could see a deficit, but if you don't actually realize it by expending the money, then it's not real until it is real. And then if we're funding those positions with temporaries or contractors and things like that, to me, that's not as concerning. Serving seating the

260students, yes, but putting our people in a position of vulnerability, that is concerning. I mean, because the stability of the district is the unity. It's what glues us together. It does everything, the kids, everybody. So I would be really concerned. To me, it would be highly desirable to see something like this positions and salary service. We can actually see, have we like our ratios off and is it real? Like I believe your numbers, but I'd like to actually see if we had X number, whatever you want to call it, I'm going to say 1300 employees. And over the same period of time, we had a decline in enrollment where 1500 employees, where does that show up? And how did they get back into the system? Where are they focused at? And I'm not so concerned

261with some of the maybe, because when you get into the bickering and things of who got what and who's getting raises, I'm not going to look at that, but I would like to see if our numbers went up, where they went up. Yeah. I have been working on trying to pull that data as well from prior years to current year. One of our issues is that in the budget build in the last couple of years, position control was not necessarily used. So it's not trackable. So Kayla had to go in and rebuild all of that and escape. And then our system to be able to get us to this point in our budget management. So those are all functions that I mean, I'm just going to be honest, we couldn't track when we got here

262in July and August. So that's some of the struggle that we're having is it's not trackable. We don't have snapshots in time. And now we're recreating that system. So moving forward, we can have those snapshots in time to do exactly like what you're asking for. But do you feel that we could, I mean, we did make payroll expenditures and we did have, we have records of employee ID numbers. So could we like reverse engineer it and look and say, well, we paid this much money to this many people and these are the employee ID numbers. I mean, it seems like that would be a record that would be creatable. I'm sure it can be. I guess the question is, where do we want to spend our energy? Because revamping this whole system by itself is

263a huge feat for us. And I think going forward, our biggest piece is cleaning up whatever was in the current budget that was, that were those vacancies, figuring out what can we take out? What are true vacancies that we don't need? And that's something that Kayla and HR have been working on very collaboratively in the last couple of months to clean that up so that we could get a true sense of what's in this budget versus where we have been in the past. And then I think going forward, I just don't know that going back and recreating old records is going to really, no, I'm not looking at recreating old records. I'm just simply looking to see if we can see definitively if we increased employee numbers, if the people went up, yeah, kids are

264going down. Yeah. I don't think we have anything in our current system that would allow us to see that because things weren't entered in the system that way. Okay. But they will be going forward. I appreciate that. Yeah. If there are no other comments, I'd entertain a motion. I move to support the superintendent's recommendation to approve the 2024-2025 First Interim Financial Report as presented. I second. We have a motion by Trustee Druhan, seconded by Trustee Kaplanis. Is there any discussion on the motion? I ask the clerk to please take roll. Trustee Kaplanis? Aye. Trustee Bueno? Trustee Vanden Heuvel? Aye. Myself? Aye. President Peruzza? Aye. The motion carries unanimously. We move on to 16-8 nominations for the 2025 California School Boards Association Delegate Assembly. So this is something that the board has the option to do.

265You can nominate somebody to go into this position or run for this position or not. So it's just something that we always bring forward. Either way, we can go through the presentation or you can decide if you would like, it's 11-22. So it's up to you. Do you need a presentation? Would anyone like to be nominated? No. Just a little bit on the history. Trustee Ann White, who was on the board for 32 years, she was a long-standing delegate to CSBA. And so there was kind of a tradition. It's a regional position. I think it's District 7. And so you get some of the, we're members. We go to the conference each year. You gain a little bit of maybe insight into some things. You can bring back some recommendations and you kind of liaison.

266And so Mrs. White was on it for a number of years. I don't know how many of her 32 years. When she left, Trustee Wong took it on and brought us back information and things like that. And it's one of those things where you kind of, it just gives us more of a regional kind of input to some of the things you go to. I think it's two things a year. It's in the middle of May and the beginning of December, if I remember correctly. And that's about it. Is there anyone that would? That sounds like something that's up my alley. Yeah. With that being said, I would, and this, we put him forth, we would put you forth to a broader vote. And so you would come on a list of candidates and we

267would be one of those. And that's how it would come back to us for a vote, like regionally. So it's kind of a cool thing. You didn't really face with the Alameda County office education stuff. So with that, I would nominate trustee Vanden Heuvel as the delegate. Okay. I'll second that nomination. So we have a motion. Sorry, it's really late. Motion by trustee Bueno, seconded by myself. Is there any discussion on the motion? Clerk, could you please take roll? Trustee Bueno? Aye. Trustee Vanden Heuvel? Aye. Myself? Aye. Trustee Capuanes? Aye. President Pusso? Aye. That motion carries unanimously. Yeah. I appreciate you stepping forward. Yeah. Because it's kind of, you're putting a foot into the dark, stepping in the deep end, because, you know, it's just, it's just been kind of a long-standing tradition for Livermore

268to be part of it. And, you know, so I appreciate it. Yep. Okay, good. So we have 19 consent items, but I believe we polled. Yes. Two. Could we get the numbers of those again? Yes. So when you make, whoever makes the motion for consent, it would be that you would approve consent minus item 17.3 B and C. Please. 17.3 B and C. Correct. Hang on. I got one too. Do you want to do it? Hang on, I got it. Okay. Does anyone wish to pull any other items? Yeah, I do. You do? There was two corrections. Okay. It was on the minutes. Oh, on the minutes? Yeah, both minutes. So you want to pull the minutes out? Yeah, I'm just waiting on this thing now. It's ready for bed. Gremlin's got these computers or

269something. I don't know. If you're online, if you're going in online, it'll log you out. It's done to me about four times tonight. If you use the app, it won't. I don't think, I think it keeps you logged in. That's the difference. Which number is that? It's 17.1 A and 17.1 B for the minutes. No, no, no, but. It's coming. It was the, it was the approval of the board minutes. Yeah. It's 17.1 A and B. Okay. So you know what to do? We're going to put some previous C and everything else. Yeah. Well, you can pull those and talk about them. And if there's a table change, then we approve the consent altogether. We don't move them. It was going to pull for discussion. Just pull it for discussion. But then once we're ready,

270then if... We fix it, then they go right back in. We used to do the discussion after, but that's fine. Right. But we, what we were doing is we were pulling them and then we were moving the items, which then changed the board agenda, which is... Oh, this is great. This makes way more sense. And that is, that is the point of the change in the minutes is the catch on that is exactly what you just explained. Yes. So the minutes of, oh my God, I apologize. I get nothing I can do with this thing. I know. Sorry. We'd need to get a third grader to come help trustee. Why now? I can make a comment about the connectivity, but I'll go to hard copy. I brought hard copy too. It'd be easy. Thank you,

271Steven. On 17, 1A on the minutes, it was, I highlighted, there's an asterisk 10.9 approval of gifts to the district under 12, section 12 consent items removed for separate vote discussion. It would, it was that, and it says asterisk 10.9 approval of gifts to district. But under there, there's no vote. We, we did vote on it there, but there, the comment says that I, board trustee, Craig Bueno asked that 10.9 approval of gifts to district be moved to 13.1, which is reports from trustees. And that's not where it was moved. It was voted on 12.1. Because this would reflect that we never voted on it. Yeah, that's true. Wait, I see it says it was moved to 12.2 for separate vote. Correct. And then when you go there. Okay. When I go down to 12.2,

272where's 12.2. Oh, no, it's there. It is there right here. Asset 10.9 approval of gifts to the district be moved to, oh, 13.1 right there. So it just needs to be that table change needs to be 12. Yes. Correct. Yes. Okay. Right here. It says that it was moved to 13.1, which is board member reports. And the other thing that needs to be fixed on here too is under 10.0 consent where the note says approval of gifts to district moved to 12.2. It should say 12.1 there. And then it, it should, and then it should say 12.1 down below. Yes. Correct. So that both those table changes. Okay. We'll make those table changes. Okay. And then 17.1 B. B item 3.2. 3.2. Okay. Is it our intent to include any discussion or eliminate the discussion?

273This was approval of new district credit cards. And we, we have that we made a motion. It was seconded and then it was a five Oh. Yeah. And there was this. I had a clarifying question on that. Correct. And I was looking at the intent of my clarifying question to see if the credit cards were an expansion or if they were simply replacement one-to-one ratio. So if someone left the replacement, the person who came in, filled it, or was an expansion of the program and the clarification was that it was a one-to-one exchange. I'm saying that off top of my head. I don't, I don't have the recording in front of me, but I would like to have the clarification that the credit card, the issuance of credit cards was not an expansion of program.

274That was simply an exchange. Why don't we pull those minutes and this areas can go back in and watch the video and put in a little bit of the discussion. Cause I want to make sure if we're going to put. Yes. Specific. I don't want to give a quote. That's what I'm saying. Let's just pull, let's pull item third. Sorry. 17.1 B. Let's just pull that. And a also, or no, it was good. We can just do a table change. So 17. One B or we'll pull it and we'll bring it back in January for approval. And then we'll add the, we'll add the narrative in there. That's the question. Yep. Okay. Makes sense. So then if there are no other, I would entertain a motion to move consent items minus 17.1 B, 17.3 BC

275and everything else. Does that make sense? Yep. 17.1 BC, 17.1 B and 17.3 B and C. Yes. If we pull, so that's a motion. You guys good with that? Second. Okay. All right. So I have a motion by me, a seconded by trustee Druin. Any discussion on the motion? I just want to say thank you to superintendent Gibson for walking me through warrants and PO like line by line by line for an hour. So thank you. That's all good. Not the sergeant arms, but we have a motion on the floor. That was my, that was my comment. Is there any discussion on the motion? There is none. We'll please ask the clerk to take roll. Trustee Kaplanis. Aye. Trustee Vanden Heuvel. Aye. Trustee Buena. Aye. Myself. Aye. President Parisa. Aye. And the motions carry. Are

276we down? Board reports and requests. So we'll start with trustee Vanden Heuvel. I've been a board member for several hours now and I appreciate the hazing. I get it now. Just leave him here till midnight and he'll know what it's like. So appreciate it. Looking forward to the next several years with y'all. Okay. Trustee Kaplanis. Board reports. I'm just thankful to be here. Thank you to all of you that are still hanging out, either watching this online or here in person. And I look forward to the next four years. Trustee Buena. I'll forego everything other than the fact that we were able to go to CSBA together and that onboarding of the two new board members was quite valuable to bring them up to speed and, you know, gain perspective from one another. And I

277think that going forward, we're going to be a high functioning board. So appreciate it. Trustee Juen. I'll, you know, second what Trustee Buena said about the importance of CSBA for us to learn about each other and grow as a body. My family also visited Germany and I was able to attend a German school, which I will not go into now because it is 1133. But I would like to share some insight, which I'll do at a later date. Later. Thank you. Ditto to what everyone said about CSBA and getting to know our new board. We're a new board now. Every time there's a change, it's a new board. So we're all getting used to each other. And also just wanted to say good luck to our high school students this week on their finals and

278to wish our community a wonderful winter break. Happy holidays and a Merry Christmas. And then we'll turn the time over to Dr. Gibson. I'll keep it quick, I promise. But I think there are a couple notable things to just put out there in the universe. Number one, special education is spotlight. As you are well aware, we sent out a survey to our staff, both certificated and classified. Through that, one of the things that we gained some insight on are some topics of professional development that they want to participate in, both as general education staff and special education staff. In addition, we're starting a special education work group, which I'm really excited. So now that the high school schedule work group is done, we're gonna pick up where we left off with a similar concept with

279special education. I think it was very exciting out of Ms. Thompson. How many teachers roughly do we have? 500? Okay, LA members. We'll just go with that for the sake of time. So 700 members, we had about 400 respond to the survey. And of those 400 and something, over 200 wanted to participate in the special education work group. So I think that speaks volumes to staff desperately wanting this focus. So thank you to the board for approving the crazy things that I continue to bring forward in the last six months. Yesterday, we kicked off our professional development with, I think I emailed the board today, just an update where we had over 50 site administrators, district administrators and site designees, which are predominantly teachers. Most of them have administrative credentials. And so we were very

280excited to kick off that training and there's much more to come in 2025. We did also complete our special education site visits last week, which was exciting. Just a couple of quick comments about the budget. I just want to acknowledge that the decisions that we have to make as a governing body are not going to be easy going forward. We do have to get out of deficit spending sooner than later, and it needs to happen definitely within the next few months. They're not things that we take lightly. The decisions that we have to make, we have to be committed to really staying student-centered and be collaborative with our bargaining units. We'll continue to be very transparent, good or bad, whether we like it or not. Sometimes it is what it is. And so as a

281team, our cabinet team and working collaboratively with our bargaining units, we are really committed to that transparency. And again, we know that the decisions, we acknowledge the decisions that we all have to make in the coming months impact everyone in our system in some form or fashion. With the approval of the restructuring of cabinet tonight, and like I said during the presentation, usually I like to go ground up and unfortunately we're starting from the top down looking at positions and all things, spending, positions, whatever it may be. And so the restructuring, I think is a really good place to start. And I think hopefully our staff can see that we're really starting with management first. I just want to remind everyone that at the end of the day, we're all on this path together and

282this journey together. It's going to be some bumps in the road. We have a few hills to climb, but we'll definitely get there. On a fun note, I wish everyone a really wonderful holiday. In two weeks, please unplug staff, unplug Amy, watch some extra Hallmark movies, whatever you need to do to unplug. And when we come back in January, we are going to hit the ground running. Our first sped work group meeting is January the 8th. There's no rest for the wicked. So enjoy your 16 days of break time. And I wish everyone a wonderful holidays in whatever capacity that you and your family observe. So thank you. Okay. Thank you. We, our next meeting, we have a special board meeting held Thursday, December 19th here at the district office. And the open session will

283begin at 10 a.m. Correct. So session is at nine 30. Yeah. And the next regularly scheduled board meeting will be held Tuesday, January 14th here. And the open session will begin at 7 p.m. With that, this meeting is now adjourned at 11 38 p.m.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.