CorpusRecord 4013

02/18/2025: School Board Work Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Anchorage School District
Date
2025-02-19
Location
Anchorage Municipality, AK
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,917 words · about 39 min
Collected
2026-05-16

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e uh 43 I'll call this work session of the encorage school board to order um everyone is in attendance except for member Wilson who is joining us online and we will start with Item B a budget discussion I'll turn it to the superintendent thank you Mr President so today's work session uh will be facilitated by our Chief Financial Officer Andy Ratliff and myself and uh at this point I anticipate that the bulk of this time will be for board member Q&A and of course we're happy to Reference last week's slides as the board would like um so we'll give Mr Ratliff a moment to get to the front um so um as Mr atlff get seated Mr rlif is there any opening statements that you'd like to provide um prior to opening up

002to board Q&A um uh I don't believe so I think we've got all the documents ready if you want to go back and view some of the slides from the previous work session or any items within the budget book I have that ready too to share um so yeah we can just open go ahead and open it up for questions member Jacobs yeah thank you Mr chair um so I was watching um a work session of the Fairbanks um School Board last night and I don't remember what time it was but they went pretty late um and they talked about their budget and I um was just watching as a a matter of professional curiosity and they're baking into their budget cake if you will an assumptive $680 BSA increase and what the um their

003their administrative staff said is that there was a two-pronged approach for why they were doing that the first was um that they would like to assume um that the state wouldn't cut year-over-year um education funding dollars even if they fell with outside of the um Foundation formula and then two that they um aren't utilizing the maximum capacity of fund balance that they have available to balance um their structural deficit and I'm curious um if you could walk through it for no other reason if someone's watching and curious you know why differing approaches right we've gone in a different direction we're resumptive no state revenue and leaning heavily on our fund balance um and then cuts to programs um how we got to where we did thanks um sure so historically we always have built our

004budget based on what's in State Statute which is the current BSA of 5,960 um or last year we did add you know that modest $100 BSA to restore some programs at the at this time last year essentially it ended up being $680 but um that's never guaranteed right that's just what's we go by what's in statute which even then it's technically not guaranteed um you know and we are going to spend out all our fund balance so if we did get some money back I don't know where that would go to but um I don't know it's kind of it's a it's a hard question to answer to say what we would do different than Fairbanks and not know exactly what position they're in some something that I'll add is that to Mr ratliff's point

005we have no idea what the funding would be from the state we have no idea when it would come and if that final number comes very late then and we're incorrect on our assumption it puts us in a very precarious situation um because by then uh releasing teachers will not be an option so we'd have to look very deep um into whatever is left within the District uh whatever doesn't conflict with collective bargaining agreements and that would be um our very worst case scenario um with that said I will acknowledge that uh Juno School District seems to also be projecting $400 so there does seem to be pros and cons but the thing that I would caution the board about is that we have two different bills right now on school funding one of them

006would be House Bill 69 which we're very familiar with um which would very much support our educational goals but the other one would be the governor's bill which spins uh a similar similar amount of money I think it's the equivalent a slightly under $680 BSA increase but um the specific ways that those funds are allocated may or may not align to how the districts are developing their budgets so there is a lot of risk when it comes to projecting Revenue when bills have not been passed at this point member Essence um could you speak to whether it would be easier or more difficult um to build a but I'm trying to understand whether it would be easier to walk back a budget that say was predicated on a BSA BSA increase of 680 or a

007th000 is it easier to walk that back at the last minute or is it easier to build up Staffing at the last minute um I guess easiest for whom would be the things like for easiest for Staffing would be to put it in now but then at the end if we don't get that money and then we have to go walk that back and tell people they don't actually have those jobs that we staffed for then it gets really difficult for the folks making those decisions um of course it would be easier easiest for me to add that thousand do now and not have to go through all these conversations with people saying here's all these important programs that my kids use your kids use that are going to have to be cut um so

008I don't know I mean it's kind of there's not but yeah it's really hard to put those in place then walk them back especially once you get past May 15 in that statutory deadline for um layoff notices Mr chair member B so this last uh week I've gotten several the same question over and over again and I can't remember if I sent it in or not but it has to do with this alleged property that the the District owns that we have that's been kind of set aside for schools well we don't own it but can you talk about really what that is and that we don't confirm that we do not own that property and that it is not up to us to sell it to mitigate the budget I suspect this um similar

009to any property we don't own titled any real property the city holds that so if we were to declare a property excess um such as the totem site that would go back to the city and they decide what to do with the property at that point we don't get revenue from the sale of it um to my knowledge I mean I guess there could be some agreement with them but there is none in place that would actually give us a financial benefit from them doing something different with the property thank you appreciate it member Higgins thank you uh one of the issues that has come up which I find somewhat amusing is people take a little Snak bit of something and then use it and they in a way that isn't intended at all and

010that has to do with the budget um reserves we have the proposal we have out there and I want to get your input on this is cutting it down to the the minimum what we required to keep so I have seen what the impact is with Mount spur blows and East High School has problems with its roof I've seen the November 30th I've seen a lot of different times Insurance uh Provisions that cost things and and damages in schools we don't have the Reserves under the budget proposal we have in front of us so my understanding is is that one of the comments you made is that when we get additional funds we've got to recognize that we don't have adequate reserves there and to put something in savings some people including A legislature apparently

011is saying they don't need money because they're just going to put it in savings let me see if I have this right we're not going to add anything to savings what we're talking about is taking less out of savings when we the budget so that we are being responsible and we can respond to an emergency within the school district that requires funds and and everyone needs some emergency contingency funds so uh Provisions that or arguments that we are have more than enough money we just want to put it in savings is is so um I I I know people want to select certain things and make a big deal out of it but uh any comments in regards to that is that a pretty accurate statement that that we're not adding money to savings what

012we're talking about in the final budget is to take less out so that we have enough for a contingency right that would be correct I think that was probably in um on on this slide that we presented at the work session last which shows the impacts of HB 69 if that were passed as is and really what it was showing is if we added back about $65 million and stuff that we that we need that we had to reduce out of this budget we would still be spending 23 million of our fund balance um that would get us down to probably a little bit over our 8% Mark which is about the board minimum currently uh to get down to the 5% Mark you know you guys have to have a super majority to go

013below board policy but really I mean that's that's all it was was showing if we were to add back most of the stuff we've reduced this year for next year's budget we would still be spending a significant amount of savings and getting down to that lower end of the board policy and really I mean the 10% cap comes back into play after this year too so there wouldn't be a mechanism for us to hold on to that money even if we wanted to right because that's that's what's going to limit the amount that we can carry over I the chair would be willing to bring policy to governance prohibiting board members from using the term savings it is fund balance um and and I think it's also worth noting that we don't have a fallback

014that um if we run out of money we we can't turn to the city or the state um we we do have to meet our budget every single year and that is a factor in the fund balance that we we try to maintain other questions I'm sorry member Donley Andy I I know in your pres your explanations of this budget um there were a a small number of security Personnel cut could you explain what those cuts are and what their potential impacts are so I I'll take that member Donley um I don't know specifically which ones you're talking about let's try that now I think that's better um one of the positions is a position that we recently added we added a couple few positions here to work on overall District uh security that go

015out and uh supplement some of the stuff that's going on in our schools with some the metal detectors and that kind of stuff um so one of those three new positions is in the budget to be cut and I believe if there was another one to be cut it would have been around the metric do do you have that I don't believe we cut any around the metric base I think that was the only one that we had in there to be cut one from security now one of the things that isn't showing up in this you know we we have five assistant principles in this that are being cut due to metrics um but there's also four that we're um displacing because we're changing um the AFA uh Grant taking the assistant principles out

016of that and then there's 15 elementary assistant principles so at the end of the day we are literally cutting 24 assistant principles right now due to the 15 at elementary due to title funding going away so there's there's a lot to do with security in our schools that are going away around those assistant principal Cuts as well but as far as security security goes I think it's just the one based out of here remember Che yeah thank you Mr chair um so I actually wanted to was on my list to ask about um the assistant principal role and how we use it um I was touring Eagle River High School I think a year ago and uh was talking to principal heli and he um indicated and and was I hadn't heard it before um

017but I think it made made sense in hindsight that one of the assistant principles at Eagle River High School was was functioning and part of their duties was the athletic director role um that the district went away from at some point due to budgetary constraints um and not being able to dedicate um an FTE to that instead choosing to funnel resources into the classroom and so we we Heap that on another person's plate who maybe wasn't the job description doesn't specifically entail that could you provide context as to how ASD utilizes the assistant principal role um I think when when I think of an assistant principal um you know at least what what mine looked like growing up it was someone who sat in an office and was signing forms or something like that's before

018joining The District in this capacity that was kind of my picture of what that might look like and in practice that isn't the case but I I'm curious if you could share more thanks so we have almost on every different level assistant principles look different um at elementary schools there's a wide range of things that the elementary assistant principles do many of the assistant principles at elementaries are halftime at one school halftime at another school so they're there every other uh other week they'll do things like working with groups working on evaluations of Staff working with discipline working with other behavioral issues um working you know on the plc's and working through um looking at the different data and working with different groups of teachers um at middle school they become a little bit of

019everything disciplin sports activities um it depends upon um in some some of the schools have two assistant principles now because of their metrics with at Middle School um and so those are sometimes broken up by Alpha sometimes they're broken up by uh age group sometimes the principal will divvy out specific uh tasks for each of them to do be it different committees safety committees discipline committees um special education 504s I mean there's a plethora of things that that they'd be doing at high school um depending on how many assistant principles are assigned to buildings will depend upon what kind of job duties they would have um almost every school will have somebody in student services dealing with things such as discipline and behaviors and and uh safety they're the ones really responsible for emergency action

020plans and that kind of thing um usually one is working specifically around curriculum and all of our col curriculum initiatives um some of those schools that have less actually will double up some of those with sports and that um maybe some work with the facility stuff um and other schools will have if they have more it's because it's just a mass of people in the buildings and and the level of which the complexity of which is uh is just huge so it just depends we have a metric that we follow um and uh you know it all comes down to everybody's responsible for school safety student safety um and that's an that's number one in all all of their job descriptions is is that safety piece but all of them have all of the the

021the pieces of really running a school so it's instructionally safe um and uh you know anything a principles has to do those assistant principles are doing and and then at the end of the day we've had such a turnover especially at our elementary level with head principles um it really is getting people ready to be a head person once they move into that head role because it's important and it's you're on an island right so I hope that answers your question follow up Mr chair um I'd like to throw in real quickly having been in a building for a long time as you mentioned it it's whatever principal has to do it also is whatever principal doesn't want to do um and and I'll just say there there are days when you walk through the

022office and I have seen them sitting behind a desk answering emails but also there are days when every single person in the office complex has a student in front of them and there's five sitting on that bench that is reserved for students that have a special project that day um you know they simply are backup in every situation in the cafeteria and if the BPO is not available they're cleaning up vomit in a hallway somewhere so I mean it it is extremely wide ranging they're they're able to go anywhere and and do anything um I I do think a lot of people miss some of the critical Ro roles they play but yes you had a followup also did want to add for the board real briefly when you turn your microphone on it now

023puts you in the speaking order on my screen and I can get you in the right order and know know that um I haven't missed your hand or anything thank just for uh disclosure in our record all I've been using that process since last meeting to ensure I get to speak first so thank you um now everyone's on the same playing field I um thank you Mr custon it did answer my question I guess I follow question in that vein um the the ratio that we have for principles where does it come from um I know that there's a a national accrediting body for school counselors that suggests uh a ratio of student to school counselors um that we are not in compliance with um I'm just curious if there's a similar body I tried

024to find something online and I I didn't I'm not saying it doesn't exist and then the second question I have um which which is maybe a bit more nuanced is my concern with eliminating those positions is I I want to go in eyes wide open I think we should as a board to putting more workload on Educators and I guess my question is either directly by if we were to remove a principal from um or two assistant principles from West High and um and East High which I think are two biggest high schools um will that directly or indirectly cause a realignment of Duties that ends with us asking Educators to fill in any additional work or is it possible that we will either just eliminate some workload or allow the workload that currently exists

025between 5 FTE to be accomplished by three or four so as a former principal of West High School I would tell you that if you know right now we've already recommended one um cut from West and East both now they have been outside of the metric the last number of years um just because of the high number and high incidence of behavior the vast number of students in those schools once you get to a certain level you just have a massive people in these big schools and if we were to take away two positions I could I could see safety being an issue um it's important uh because of all the different measures that we have and people that we have in those buildings um we have most of them have four security the big

026ones have four security also and that's not enough I mean some of these buildings are a quarter of a mile from one end to the other end of the building and just making sure we're spread out enough um to I I would say that probably in today with plus4 PTR also we aren't going to find people willing to step up and do those extra things um you're probably just going to have to figure out out how to do it do less um as far as the job goes and I wouldn't know how to what that could be as far as at like a West or an East because there's just so much there's so many staff members that you got to be able to do evaluations to do evaluations well you got to spend time

027you got to be working with your Educators you got to be talking with them and that probably will have some piece kind of drop off also but yeah we're we're concerned about those um but again we also are really concerned about how many kids are going to be in each classroom too and I can speak to the metrics too those were developed you know probably maybe eight years ago with the previous administration when they came on um there wasn't anything defined at that point so really how we did it was here's the Staffing that we have at each of these schools for principles and kind of back into a metric from there just so we can say okay now we have a lever to pull you know if you in the event you need to

028reduce Staffing do you want to go to one five 00 for principles you know just to so you can kind of make that Equitable jump but it really was based on the Staffing that we had in place at the time that the metrics were developed um it wasn't anything that I read on best practice or anything was just saying okay we have or you know four principles at this school how that's about 1 to 400 or so so really that's kind of how they came into place and just to be able to have kind of something you could adjust because before it wasn't ever defined and that's what the intent was to be able to do was just uh Define what that metric is and have a lever to adjust if we need to and

029then of course there are going to be some that are outside of that metric based on uh size of size the facility your school need Mr gon you mentioned that title funding going away was a factor in reducing principles so can you elaborate we have 15 assistant principles at the elementary level that are funded through title funding and that extra it was because of rollover funding for the last couple years well that rollover funding isn't available for next year so we don't have and what's happened is in years past we've had enough open head principal positions that it was a we were able to um higher enough to make it work and this year we are not seeing resignations like we have before as far as head principal jobs positions going and so that's probably

030going to end up in some sort of displacement and we're that that has nothing to do with the general budget or anything I just wanted to explain that we are there's a thing where assistant principles are coming back member Wesson thanks um I would refer member Jacobs um you to the pikus Ain evidence-based model which um does share its rubrics and that's one principle for a 450 student Elementary School one principal for 450 student Middle School school and one principal and one assistant principal for a 600 student high school so those are metrics that perhaps we don't align with but at least they exist and there appears to be some rationale for those metrics that you can put in your pocket member Jacobs thank you Mr chair um so I just I wanted to to

031highlight something I think they heard and I I don't disagree with it I you folks are the subject matter experts but I just want to highlight that what I think I heard which is that we think we're going to lose capacity to do some things at our buildings due to cuts to building administrative staff um that have the title of assistant principle but really function is glue it seems like the more I hear about their workload um but we aren't sure exactly what yet they the full scope of what that might look like and then what we think might happen is that our we might experience some additional challenges with properly evaluating our Educators which I think is a pretty big um factor in professional development too um and I know board members have have

032keyed in on in the past is to ensure that we're um helping Educators develop and and that evaluation process should be a piece of that I youan up professionally that's how I check in on how I'm doing annually and so I would hope that um we're utilizing the process to the same effect and so I just want to confirm that that check my understanding there and then the other other question I guess I have is but if we were to reduce Staffing further then or um if with the cuts administrative staff that are being suggested in this proposed budget can administrations say unequivocally that we won't be adding to educator workload by reducing staff aside from the plus4 PTR are we sure this won't add to educator workload and the answer if the answer is

033no that's fine I just really feel like we need to go into the conversation eyes wide open I can't answer that question I you know there's every school is a little different in how they staff their assistant principles and you know we we are this year we're we're removing the academy the fourmies at the high school level also and so there's going to have to be some kind of reassumed of duties there as well um I I I can't say that unequivocally we won't be putting something on to with the deletion of some of these assistant principles I'd hope not but I don't I can't say no member Essence thanks you've said something now a couple of times and I just just wanted to ask for a little more clarity I think my understanding of

034the master plan for the acmy of Anchorage involved um utilization of um some existing assistant principles at some of our high schools would become Academy principles and or is what I'm hearing that that's not happening can you update can you please just explain what you mean by saying that we have four in the in the grant that we have there are four assistant principles there have been and we are looking at another way to utilize that Grant um to be able to support and promote our CTE offerings at schools and so we needed to get that out to people now so that every kind of at the same time as we're working on any of these assistant principal positions we had to make that decision early and so we're still working on what does that

035look like for 2526 and 2627 moving forward okay thank you for that clarification um this is not a question but I it came through in board connect and I just thought it was such an important um sort of set of bullet points that I wanted to read them aloud we've heard a lot about the impact of cuts at the elementary school level you know people were talking about immersion and ignite and class sizes and it's a very granular thing I think at an elementary school and a lot more nebulous at the middle and high school level but what I read from the administration in response to a board member question about the effect of the PTR plus4 at secondary is that these are the things that would be eliminated in middle and high schools next

036year immersion programs at all secondary schools World languages primarily French and German and all Middle School World languages other than immersion Fine Arts including choir sculpture drawing Middle School band Etc Student Government peer mentorship courses School Business Partnership classes yearbook math CTE combined courses like ampton algebra and geometry and construction biomed Auto teacher at a biomed Auto teacher at King Tech High School mechatronics AP coursework um courses with less than 25 students would not be offered um co- talk classes like for special students in special education um at every level in course subject Credit Recovery opportunities Apex courses and then the last two bullet points were that increased class sizes in PE and health uh would be evident at all levels we'd see 50 plus students in those classes and that all remaining classes would

037have have high class numbers close to or beyond the PTR of 35 is is that list something that parents and Educators and students can expect to see truly at every middle and high school is this a compilation of can you just talk about that list please uh absolutely member lessons great question I'd like to add a bit of context to what preceded that list of bulled points which was um this was in response to a board member question as to what are the different scenarios if this budget were to pass how would that impact secondary so from there our senior leadership pulled all the different secondary principles and asked them what are some things that you're considering so it's very important to note that the bullets that were read off are not um exhausted set

038in stone but it's a really hard look as to what's at stake if this budget is passed in the way that it is AKA if um we don't receive adequate funding from the state to get us through this fiscal year if I could add a little bit that's that's just a compilation of what came in from everybody it isn't like all of immersion at every school is going away that's just in some schools some courses may have to go away some of them might be emerging courses and as well as the others it isn't like every every school has a different set of classes that they're looking at and that's the list of all of what all the schools had and I guess this is a followup the effect of passing the budget in a

039week from now is to initiate a principal's ability to act based on their school budget for next year and that principal would then take action based on uh their Staffing their student body and that's when these decisions would begin to be put into motion is that is that correct yes that's correct um and once you all decide and vote on the budget then we analyze what you've decided upon we go back and look make sure we know what things are cut in this particular budget and then we act upon that moving forward in the planning Mr cheer have one followup I want to get back to an earlier question I asked about uh you know is it easier and that's a maybe a not great word but there are different effects for the different choices

040that we have before us I'm curious about what the effects are on our overall Revenue when you consider local Revenue so if we were to pass a budget based on a, BSA what would that do as far as producing or procuring local Revenue versus a budget that is based in statute based on a z increase or something in the middle like passing a budget based on a $680 increase what is that due to sort of an Ask of of our local community yeah good question um I don't think that would have any effect on what would our ass is going to be particularly this year because we are at the what we've calculated as the local tax cap um so we're limited on how much we can collect by that so this slide really did

041show how we calculate that out and we do we are taking the most we can uh and that's primarily because there's a you know one is the $ S7 A5 million shift from uh the state to the local taxpayers on Via the required local contribution and then we're going to have an increased ask for people transportation to help Shore up that since that hasn't been increased since 20156 so we're asking for money in these other areas part of it's going to be required part of it's going to be um optional to get kids to school but it's um but that does take up that the city's cap for how much taxes we can collect and right now you know we've taken as much as we can I think based on uh what our portion of

042that would be uh there would be a scenario if the city decided to let us go above that then we could potentially um get more but at this point you know I think they're at the tax cap as well Ember jackob yeah thanks Mr chair um so if we if we turn to optimism for just a quick second I'm assuming everyone's still has that gear um if the legislature wasn't usually productive and um was uh more effective than it has been in years and was able to um adopt and get consensus to adopt um a BSA increase and adjust the foundation formula for the first time meaningfully in in years and the board adopts our budget status quo with minimal changes when are the points of no return I understand there's a lot of cuts

043in this budget and so I understand that there will be a lot of relatively speaking small points where where things are happening happening that aren't positive but what are the broad points where we're entering into um a time where a cut can't be restored a staff couldn't be brought back um how long does a legislature have to get their house in order um from the fire perspective it's really not I mean once as soon as they pass that we can go back and do any revision we need to at the city or you guys can make the revised budget I think the impact is mostly on our staffing component I turn it over to svin or Marty to more accurately describe that and like when that window is for getting the best folks in place

044yeah so typically we would start our staffing process right after the board approves or adopts the budget for the next year um we've intentionally pressed pause on starting that Staffing timeline just knowing how disruptive that potentially could be in the optimistic hope that something will materialize out of Juno that will allow us to as um Mr Ratliff said revise the budget and maybe um reduce the number of proposed cuts that are in this budget the sort of point of no return is probably May 15 that's the point at which we have to issue um any layoff notices for positions that we know we can't afford going into next year uh we can recall those later those folks um but just as a cautionary Tale in 2017 we laid off um for just a period of

045weeks in mids spring about non-tenure teachers we were able to recall them pretty quickly and when we did 32% of them said no thank you and they left the state citing just the instability was was too much for them and and they went elsewhere and so um that's to consider as well so right now where we're at is we're on hold for our internal Staffing process uh where we displace folks and consider placing them and voluntary transfers and the hope is that we can get to that as soon as possible because we have to go through that process first before we can get to new hires and we will have a few areas of high need where we need to hire folks from outside of the district for next year and the longer we wait

046on that that pool is always diminishing as well Mr chair can I quick followup yes yeah thank you um so I want to make sure that I'm I'm capturing that correctly because it was was good information so anytime between when we adopt our budget on 228 and then May 15th with the recognition that as you get further away from 228 um the likelihood that those folks are still present and available to come back to work is gone was it was that the right date and and a right assessment of of where we're at so 228 would be the soon as we would begin the Staffing process um I'm not sure you could rephrase the question not sure I my my question really is is um I want to I want to get when the point

047of no return is when I think I heard was 5:15 um and then what I think I heard also is as we get closer to that date and further away from when we pass a budget that removes an FTE adding that back in adding the FTE back in doesn't guarantee that the human that filled that position I'm thinking of a librarian or a school nurse um is still available and willing to come to work for us next school year so if we haven't notified them that they're displaced yet we haven't taken any action as a district in that interim period um but certainly they may be aware you know and and considering other options and so there was a high lik hood that if we were to adopt the budget as proposed currently that a

048lot of folks would would quote unquote see the writing on the wall and start looking elsewhere just out of concern for their position and so um yeah even though we put pause on Staffing and the hopes that more money would come I think some folks would start to make those decisions member Wesson um I am looking at the room which is not yet full but I do see our um director of immersion programs which makes me when I think about timing I know that there have been some folks writing in talking about visas um for perhaps some of the immersion teachers is there a different timeline that they are working with that we would need to know about from an HR perspective or anything there's really not those folks that we hire um on H1B

049or j1v visas are um you know full-time employees uh they're uh under the aea contract um they're subject to all the same rules and rights um that are outlined in the contract and subject to the same you know displacement and and potential layoff protocols um if we did um issue a a notice of layoff to someone um who was a Visa holder then they would have to return to their home country is my understanding or seek employment with another District under that Visa thank you I wonder if we can also ask the question in another way um if you need an emersion a a language specialist um and you don't yet have them on staff or you know that you if you're a school if you're principal with an immersion program and you would like

050to continue to conduct business as usual do you need to get your um employee and Visa hiring ducks in a row sooner rather than later I mean if you have an open position or a need to hire someone I guess my assumption is that if you were that principal you would want to Source your educator sooner rather than later H having been an immersion principal for two immersion programs yes you would like to get it earlier I mean sometimes you find people that don't need to be on visas that's like the bonus um and if they can teach in both Lang English and the world language that's even a double bonus right so you're out there looking but yeah the ones that need to have the Visas worked on do take quite a bit of

051time and Brandon is probably the one that would be able to answer that more specifically and and I'll add to that that you know that's true as we go into the spring the pools of applicants for any position start to dwindle and that would be true of our applicants who might come to us on a Visa or somebody who might come us to us from you know one of the um teacher preparation programs in the lower us so it there is always a sense of urgency for filling all of those positions that we have to from outside the district every spring because the the longer we go the fewer qualified applicants there are um we've also learned especially with our J1 um Visa holders that uh if we don't hire them by mid April they

052typically don't have the runway they need to relocate to Alaska they have to arrive here um and set foot on us soil before they can apply for a social security number which then allows them to apply for an Alaska CT and in order for them to get all those ducks in a row so they're ready for the first day of school for student instruction um usually takes several months M bellam me oh thank you kept going to the bottom of the list for whatever reason going back to the aps you said we're Miss we're not missing but we're going to be losing reassigning 24 of them what are we telling those people now and what how are we uhing that's we're working on that okay um Kiren and Marty are going through a process K

053do you want to um answer that sure I can weigh in um so we'll have two separate processes and Marty can certainly chime in to but um tomorrow we'll be meeting with those uh affected employes at the elementary level um and we're able to do that now because it's related to title funding and not our general fund budget um when the general fund budget is um approved by the board later this month um then we will engage our secondary process um and notify those employees that are affected by that process at that time so um two separate waves of meetings one for elementary and one for secondary but um they're different timing because of the budget Source thank you uh and that so that 24 is really mostly Elementary um 15 of the 24 are

054Elementary M Jacob oh I'm sorry if you have a followup go ahead I I just had another I I wanted to just get a sense of without talking about negotiations just kind of how are we situated to absorb I mean I H what's going to happen do we know I mean we're going to move forward with the process of negotiations I think we're doing is it two or three two or three we have three contracts need bargain three contract okay and so we are moving forward with what we have already and that's reflected in the the budget that preliminary budget that we have um yeah we do have some modest increases built in those to uh account for some increase in wages and benefits if that's the question it's the the aea the bus drivers

055and the food service are the ones that are expiring so something is built into this budget for that for both of those uh to continue the negotiation yep when will we know if it's enough I don't know I know it's a bad question I know but I I really I don't know how to ask it any differently uh we have to let the process play out frankly to see where we get to to know if what we budgeted is enough frankly okay or too much my projec yeah thank you sorry that last comment from Mr R um okay um so I want to I want to go back to Mr Lang and we we had a conversation of few conversations now regarding educator Recruitment and Retention and one of the data points that I had

056written down in my notes that I I think we we knew or we estim rough estimation was that it costs ASD roughly $26,000 or so per educator to to find and replace them I want to confirm if that's roughly accurate because that's going off of my notes and then I imagine that that cost has gone up um because I saw the figure from iser which I think estimated it to be $20,000 a few years ago um across the state and so um I think my questions are how much do we estimate it cost for us to uh recruit and train up a teacher um in in dollars and then two does that cost estimate in any way translate to a librarian or a school nurse or is it um totally on analogous so to the

057first question um after presenting to the board I think in January we had some dialogue around this number and we went back and we recalculated it because it had been a few years since we had really looked at the how we Define that number and and looked at updating any of the specific metric items and so the the total estimated cost now to replace a teacher in ASD is $ 29,37 um that is an AE aea member generally we don't break that out by teacher counselor nurse librarian related Services um I don't think we've ever looked at it that specifically um so that's just an aggregate number in general estimated cost from replacing a certified uh position I follow Mr chair yeah thank you um I I think it's helpful to to tie a dollar

058amount to the legislative inefficacy we have in our state um that in action costs us real money that we could be using to put into the classroom um quite literally the the other question I have is I've been I'm staring a lot at the municipal Charter which I don't know is wise um and I understand that there's a provision requiring that we submit our budget to the assembly in the first Monday in March um is have we ever explored moving that and from the municipal side are there other other reasons why that date couldn't be moved from a functional standpoint or is it purely that we haven't had an assembly willing to have the conversation about pushing that date further back yeah and I believe the date stems back to when they have to have

059the tax request out to taxpayers they send the notice out they develop the mill rates and send those out in April so that means they get our budget and approve it the month of March and combine it with their Theirs to send out those tax notices so that's my understanding of why it's in there on that date um if we were to move something the city may have to change their fiscal year because right now they're on a calendar year um and the state requires us to be on the fiscal year so we don't have the latitude to actually change our fiscal year but they might although I suspect it's a fairly heavy lift follow um so I i' I've heard a couple assembly members speak to their interest in changing to a fiscal year

060model versus a calendar year um would a I mean should we be considering having conversations maybe adding to a future joint Schoolboard assembly work session the topic of some kind of joint Charter amendment that allows us some additional flexibility and then changes the fiscal year for the municip municipality because if we didn't have to adopt our budget by 228 the legislature could have some extra time to do their homework which would hopeful would be helpful to them as they move forward and and passing HB 69 um one of the things that came up yesterday is that that Fairbanks um you grappling with some of the same challenges on on a smaller scale um and but they've got extra Runway that we don't have um and I would I'm assuming that their burrow runs on a

061FY the fiscal year versus a calendar year I just didn't take time to look up two charters last night so um I guess would to ask a question is that something the board should be talking about with our assembly about considering that would that make our lives easier as subject Banner experts yeah I mean uh just it would make it easier if we could push that timeline back a little one we'd get things more accurately because if we get closer to completing a year of this budget before we try to put in the next one just having more data around that is going to be helpful U and then to like you said seeing where the legislature lands or giving them a little more time to figure that out because you know right now we

062balance a budget um within the first two weeks there in session uh we you guys don't approve it for the next month or so but it's it's balanced at that point um so yeah I mean it's definitely something we could explore to see if that could be pushed back I mean ideally you just have something in statute that makes your funding more known and predictable in perpetuity but uh if that's not going to happen then any additional time we can get to have our budget prepared on our side would I think be beneficial that one last follow up Mr chair so um is it fair to ask to make an ask or uh maybe the administration wants to take time to to consider it I'm inclined at this point to ask at our next joint

063meeting that we take this up I'm trying to think from a functional standpoint who wants to lead that conversation I feel like uh Mr Ratliff is a great candidate I assume he's pretty busy right now um and so if Administration could take some time to consider if they're comfortable framing the conversation and the benefits I I feel like the assembly would benefit from hearing our support but hearing from the folks doing the work why this would be helpful um that would be great certainly could we probably want to connect with the uh City budget Department CFO to see what their limitations are on as well because it's not something you really want to drop on them is something we really really want to do so sound a great yeah we certainly have that conversation I

064think it's probably worthwhile to do so member less thank you um I guess I have two questions one uh is following up from this conversation and circling back to uh an earlier question about the effect of you know a a zero a680 or ,000 BSA ask and and what I think I'm gathering is that given the scale of our related asks really whatever budget we pass is not going to have a an actual impact on the taxes that would be generated or or levied right I don't since we're at the we're asking for about the max that we can ask for now under the city cap even if we were to get a $1,000 BSA um under that local cap from the state we certainly could ask for more under that but we wouldn't necessarily

065be able to collect it from the city side because they only approve our tax request and then our upper limit spending the thing we might have to do is if we were to get you know an extra $70 million or whatever it is we may have to go back to the city and ask for for that upper limit authority to be uh lifted but we can do that at any time it's not uh sometime certain like getting those tax request okay excellent and then uh the word optimism was offered a little bit earlier and I'm going to take it and run with it um what would the co and this could be an RFI but maybe sooner rather than later what is the cost at this point given our predicted enrollment for next year of

066decreasing pupil teacher ratios to levels last seen in fy16 it would require a little bit of math uh which is why I'm not asking it right now but I would find that very helpful prior to the end of the week if that can be done certain I can get that forward to I just need to run the model so just going back to fy6 fy16 is before uh based on my records um right we had a PTR plus one in FY 24 we had a grades 6 through 12 increase in fy21 we had a grades 9 through 12 increase in fy19 we had a grade 6 increase in fy18 and in fy17 we had an increase in K through 3 and 7 through 12 so I want to go to the way back machine and

067see what it would cost to have class sizes people teacher ratios which would shrink our class sizes to a level that looked more like 20 this start of the 2015 16 school year yeah we do that great thank you like to remind members we do not have items for executive session tonight so if we need to run along on the work session we're able to member Jacobs um yeah so I a quick question I think it falls under budget I'm going to try and shoe hornet in here um I I want to make sure we provide adequate time not just in the work session tonight but in our meeting um for reset here so I'm gonna I want to make sure we're we're providing adequate time for public testimony as well as um the conversation

068for the superintendent report regarding our budget um is does Administration have any heartburn about us moving goal monitoring to our next meeting with with an agenda that doesn't look quite so daunting uh through the president member Jacobs I have no issue with that we can uh reconfigure the calendar so Mr chair I would recommend and then ask if you're comfortable just asking for objection as chair um if any board member has real reservations about being able to engage in a more meaningful conversation regarding goal monitoring in a space where we don't um aren't at the same time imposing on you know over a 100 families allowing them to return home I think we should consider postponing that work um it it is disappointing because it is something that I know it was very important to

069us but I think this is the one meeting where I think we should air on the side of prioritizing um hearing from the public given the nature of the decision in front of us thank you yeah um I would support that change in the agenda if there's no objection from board members we are looking at I think something north of 150 testifiers tonight any other questions during the work [Music] session seeing no microphones lighting up um thank you to our presenters and thank you for the clarifications and we are adjourned from the work session for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.