001e e e good afternoon uh this is the inage school board finance committee meeting um the chair Kelly lessons go for introductions Carl Jacobs board member Chief Andy R CFO America suan executive assistant savn director development and online we have President Hollman and um Mr Jim Anderson great um thank you for here um I I'm assuming the other board members and or staff may uh May operate um at some point during this meeting um we just have two items on the agenda today the first is a broad FY 26 budget update umbrella and um do see that um Katy parrot just walked in after another meeting um one of the items that I was hoping to lead with and I'll let you get settled so I'll just keep talking is um um a report on
002the community input we elicited from The Balancing Act tool so I was hoping we could uh maybe load that up and the administration could speak to what we learned from um oops community members who gave maybe not that one America uh this is me I'm just trying to figure out how to hide these float controls I can get I can't see the tab name okay so anyway so that just to remind members of the public uh back in December the board beta tested The Balancing Act tool during uhal Saturday work session and that launched a 3ish 4ish week window I know that it was extended until early to mid January um and we got responses in the hundreds some community members but I'll let you guys take it away sure for what what information we
003received and we did receive preliminary report yes uh but this is really a followup uh to sort of pin things down yeah so I'll let um okay Mr R pull that up okay perfect um so if you can move to the first slide uh this just essentially shows um the budget development calendar and the way that The Balancing Act simulation was kind of situated within that calendar um so it it was released uh December 11th I believe um kind of in conjunction with the uh proforma budget and it was open until on around uh January 13th so we did extend that a little bit so that staff coming back from um from Christmas break could have a little bit more time to provide feedback um and uh so that was kind of how that uh
004informed our budget development process next slide please um this as always is just the kind of the slide to situate us into the circumstances that we find ourselves in in terms of when we're talking about budget um we're talking about increasing costs versus um the resources that have been provided and that was how we set up the budgeting tool to kind of reflect where we are as of uh FY 26 you go to the next slide so uh if you'll remember this is kind of what it looked like like and there were some default settings that were established um based on the projected deficit which ended up being very very close to what our actual deficit was when we spun up a a budget um and then it had uh the kind of the areas
005of the revenue and the expenditure side um that we kind of used to encapsulate and um provide opportunity for uh the public to make um suggestions and to toy with it to see how we could or they could uh produce a balanced budget but of course there were some of the areas of that budget if you'll remember that were locked because things for example like Charter Schools uh we have a statutory obligation to provide for those and to provide for those according to um how the statute says that we're required to fund them so that can't really be changed so that accounted for for those as well you go to the next slide um so on the revenue side um these were kind of the parameters uh the both on the revenue and expenditure side
006this only dealt with the general fund so it was primarily um uh only on that no Transportation no food service and for the record we did get some questions about that um but because we had a section of um the simulation and the survey that was open to any suggestions we did uh get some feedback or questions related to those other funds but the tool itself was really to balance the general fund uh we did start with the true operating deficit of 107 million that is the uh difference between the revenues we expected to receive in uh FY 26 versus the expenditures that were planned or expected in that same period of time we provided options for the use of no fund balance versus using fund balance down to 8% or 5% we included options
007for U maintaining the current BSA for state revenue or increasing um at the level that we were funded to the um equivalent of 680 of a BSA increase for the onetime funds as well as numbers a BSA increased it was inflation adjusted for um using fy17 as a baseline versus fy1 um if you go to the next slide and then for the expenditures they were grouped based on school-based Services operations maintenance Administration and then some of those other fixed or restricted components so some of the fixed costs you know the leely required things that we have to spend money on the charter schools that kind of thing uh there were options provided uh scenarios for PTR change as well as school closures as well as options for maximum reductions throughout each one of the areas
008within um each section so you know nurses counselors um some of those other areas and then um some of the expenditures also were locked as we mentioned and then there was kind of that catchall that you could submit kind of anything you wanted in text um so this is essentially uh the dashboard um we ended up receiving 840 uh submissions from the public um the average time on the site was about 67 minutes um to work through those you know the the simulation and then there was a total page view of almost 7,000 um this is uh interesting because the initial results this was different from initial results where people spending a lot more time in the module um it also uh can be you you can account for someone coming into the module looking
009around doing things and then coming back later and taking a shorter amount of time before they submit their response um uh this was also something that we talked about we can see based on submissions uh where people are submitting from so this looks about what we expected I think that there were you know there was one from I don't know Missouri or Tennessee or something but this was also open during or during Christmas break where people were traveling um so uh but you can see this tells us the vast majority of our responses are where we would assume to go down and Keek grabit all really quick sorry do we know for a fact that the respond was from Missouri or could that have been like a VPN oh that certainly could have been just
010where so this uh accounts for there's a couple of different places it looks at IP but it also there's area where they can submit their um uh ZIP code so it's a lot of these were probably like the the location ones were probably where someone was physically someplace else but you know they could very well have just beening that's thank but we also have to take into account that we have families that might be split and living other places that are stakeholders of the district right so all right next slide okay and this shows uh essentially the breakout of the respondents um here you'll see that we had uh kind of uh five options and we wanted to account for that group that was parents and ASD staff not just ASD staff alone but the
011combination of parents alone and then parents and staff um that was approximately 74% of our total um responses um so and then of of course a good chunk of ASD staff responding a smaller chunk of students which was about 3% and then community members which was about four four and a half% um so that's looks about what what I would see now you can't read these numbers I very small but I'm gonna I put put this here because this is the dashboard that essentially shows us some of that basic information and I'll walk through some of these to provide a more detailed explanation um you see that um no one but some of the relevant you know no one's proposing a decrease of Revenue I don't actually know that that was like was able to
012do um um and then there's specific areas where um you know people had had thoughts about increasing decreasing expenses but you'll see there that the vast majority of the responses were really focused primarily um for Revenue in terms of uh increasing that state revenue so next slide please um and these are some of the um charts and graphs that are available to us on the dashboard um just to give you kind of an idea and this obviously shows that when people were taking a look at what to um what to increase it's primarily state revenue which is the area that of the scenaria that we provided right um we know that local revenues cannot close the budget Gap so we could you know put a scenario out there which you know we allowed someone to
013raise that a lot more but that's just not um relevant so this looks about what I would expect all right go ahead um so one of the interesting things uh compared to our initial survey was that people did the the responses did Trend away from relying on an increased use of fund balance and an increased use of um state revenue and that could be for a couple of reasons um so one is that people are not recommending that we use as much uh fund balance or um that that we're not there wasn't as much of a response to increase to for example fy17 inflation so there was a little bit more um respones saying yes increase uh to fy11 um and then uh but a lot more people said none so there's a couple of
014different things that we can take from this when we look at the data Al together especially considering that those later responses brought down the average of um uh for amount of time spent in the simulation so one of the things that you can kind of um think about is then when someone went in there to provide recommendations there might be some people that popped in and only looked at the expenditure side and didn't really focus on the revenue to see how that impacted the overall budget and then also during that period of time knowing that um you know the board was looking at a scenario which we didn't know what the revenue was going to be so um that was kind of an interesting uh difference can I ask a question so going back to
015the previous Slide the um the number that suggested none of that percentage the state revenue increase do we know how many of those submitted a balanced budget so the 56% how many of those folks in the balanc budget that were required to do the a statute uh that information actually comes a little bit later um in the presentation so we have kind of a a finer breakout of of this group that chose no new state revenues how many of those so right that sounds good we're getting a there that'll be the big reveal um so this is essentially just the same chart that shows us the areas uh where there were the most focus on increases or decreases um and then this looks about like what I would expect as well so that when people
016were trying to balance the budget they were looking at um you know the areas where there was more room to balance which is in the school Based Services um but you'll also see you know there's a trend on on um Administration um can you encapsulate school-based Services is that classroom I mean is that PTR yeah is that what's PTR it's all the special education services we think we put Sports in there principles when I think of children going to school the the services they are getting in a brick and mortar facility is what's encapsulated in Services yeah yeah okay okay so the next couple of slides we'll get into a little bit more of the detail when we're looking at some of those top highlevel um uh recommendations and we also need to remember that
017this information is aggregated of all of the responses they reflect averages of all of those responses um so that that should be factored in um this is the this uh slide stayed pretty stand there were there was a couple of movement in priority of some of these items um but essentially they remained about the same um so there was a recommendation at the top of the list for the dollar amount of change in a specific area was towards school closures um and that's approximately two schools in that figure um on average and then of course uh the let's see um and then you know moving down the list I don't think we need to go into each one of them but I'll point out a couple of the differences one of the key differences here
018is that in our initial uh batch of responses there was the movement to or the recommendation to increase um sorry decrease PTR um which was an increase to the budget and in this scenario the aggregate was a recommendation to um in increas PTR with a um decrease to the budget if that makes sense so that was a change that was a significant change from our initial PLL of those responses to the full um group the other one that came on to the list that was not previously on the list was the front office claric um so that was a new recommendation this part of R too understandable did did that trend line um of PTR increases align with the amount of budgets that were able to be balanced as well those yes so we'll talk
019about that all right thanks not trying to get ahead yeah no but that's like totally we had to dig into that a little bit and to take a look at that because that's totally relevant um so here's the uh top expenditure Suggestions by percentage of the existing budget for that item if that makes sense so as you know you know a million dollars for one area of the budget can be a very very small percentage compared to maybe the entirety of another budget so um there was a recommendation um these recommendations stayed fairly similar as well um uh and they're based again on the percent of the existing uh budget recommended for reduction um so there was some movement of priority for these cuts from the initial responses um so for example uh preschool came
020onto the list that was not initially in that top level um so that was kind of an interesting change um for a pretty sub substantial shift to about 6.5% of their total um budget so if you go to the next slide here's where we get into taking a look at the individual scenario responses and what the impact of making those decisions was in aggregate um so we had that option for pulling in fund balance um on average for the respondents who included no use of fund balance the average deficit was 57 million um uh the for foundation funding so if the the recommendation for no new state revenue if that was the the position for respondents there was an average deficit of 75 million um for school closures that there was no um uh option
021for recommending a school closure the average deficit of those responses was uh 50 million and then if there was no change to PTR the average deficit again was was 50 million and so what we saw from this is that the participants largely encountered the exact same challenges of the district and budgeting um if you don't make some of these changes that are really structural and substantial on the revenue or the expenditure side there's no way of balancing the budget um the and to kind of capture the the the percentage of those uh no change to PTR that was about 40% of the responses no school closures that was about 35% of responses um and uh let's see sorry I'm trying to read my notes and I'm not remembering that's in reference to but um so
022it gives you a scope of what the challenge is um okay oh okay so that was a note on this as well 44% of respondents did submit a balanced or Surplus budget but only with substantial adjustments on the revenue side and some of them with suggestions that were outside the bounds of what is actually possible so for example in some of those your suggestion um options there was uh you know request to Levy a sales tax the district can't do that um there was uh there were some suggestions uh to restructure certain revenues um that would not make a meaningful impact there were all kinds of suggestions that were provided that that really were outside the scope of what is possible or um amendable to balancing the budget so here's here's kind of getting into
023the brass tax of the situation without new state revenues only 48 48 individual responses were able to achieve a balance budget out of 84 840 of 840 so 48 of the the respondents did that um but these are some of the ways that they achieve that a PTR plus six or higher closing three or four schools in Partnership also with significant um significant Cuts so then sor well the the next slide might give you some of that individual um so this kind of provides that average look of all of the um responses for those who close the gap without any additional state revenue um so this kind of shows you the breadth and depth of the decisions that were made in order to achieve that um and as you can see there's really nothing actually
024yeah um and if you go to the next slide that this is everything that I think was uh yeah so this is the full list of everything um and those the ones at the bottom those were we couldn't people couldn't touch which is why there's zero change for the charter fixed cost indirect cost attrition vacancies um and some of those areas on the bottom were were areas where we did receive a lot of those um your suggestion comments say you know do eliminate all Charter Schools um you know uh stop paying I don't know insurance or I mean just these things that we just can't do you know um well I mean I mean just from a pure functional standpoint the district the board could revoke every existing Charter but I don't that doesn't address
025this right got your s with the kids you don't I me still charter schools are suffering from the same foundational funding issues that we are and so that that actually is a budget saving measure at all is that right right okay well and I mean you know there's there's statutes that also provide guidance on how a board can choose to do that you know so I think that that would be it would be one of those things okay you choose to do that is that going to solve anything for FY 26 not if there's going to be charter schools that want to take you to court you know or go through a process with the state to appeal that decision or whatever it may be right um but you can see that closing the Gap
026with no additional state revenue is highly challenging and also very disruptive to almost every single thing no matter how you slice it um the yeah that's the reality so can I ask a question about the so we're getting M it's okay yeah please um so and I asked this before the start of the meeting but I guess I'm curious and I think it would be helpful for the for a record um do we think as we I mean I think this seems like a valuable tool and I don't know um the administration's intend to continue using it in in hindsight or maybe looking ahead do we think it might be valuable to require participants to balance the budget that's required by Statute recognizing that there's other methods to if the goal is just to express
027a department um should experience Cuts or a particular program should be a method of how the B budget's balanced and there's other ways to do that fundamentally while making the exercise more meaningful for individuals who truly want to Grapple with what administration and the board are grappling with so should we lock it to require the budget be balanced I just wonder if there was meaning to those who complete the exercise without applying La that was the kind of analysis that was really required to get at some of the more meaningful suggestions right or to understand the challenges um it it might produce a result that is closer to what we would take and then have be an actionable but but you'll see on the next slide if we can go to the next slide um
028this is kind of the comparison of the difference between those average recommendations that came in and what the district ended up implementing into the preliminary budget um and but here's the qualifier on this that those recommended average reductions are the aggregate of all of the responses including the ones that did not balance the budget so because that average reduction column doesn't add up to our actual deficit correct I think there was a they left an average unaddressed deficit of like 35 million yes yeah and so oh yeah you see the the note on the bottom um so uh but in a lot of these areas the district was able to implement um some of the recommendations into um the budget and um but you can also see that uh the district had to implement some
029of those and these are just the top ones this isn't across every single line item that was offered but this is these are just those top ones that I reported on the top 10 for the percent of um you know the highest percent of a cut from a a programs budget or a highest dollar amount um so uh you can kind of see that reflected in In the comparison um and then uh this is just to kind of uh Center us back on the Strategic direction of making proportional reductions throughout the budget and trying to hold um uh not really having an area of of the budget that was held harmless from those reductions as a percentage um so with that we'll take any more questions or comments okay first thank you very much for
030a really robust presentation thank you to the administration for following through uh with this you know pursuing this new tool um and thank you to all of the community members who did take the time to Grapple with uh our Collective situation so I guess I'm expressing a lot of gratitude yes go ahead what what does the $1,000 BSA if that get what does that translate to for us how much money um so it wasn't it's an HP 69 yeah with inflation yeah because it was an inflationary component which ended up making the put me like 1200 or something you know it's like 12 it's 1289 what I've seen yeah I did the math on a one time don't have it up um but like $1,000 would be about 71 million extra so I think it
031was like 90 something it's 91 a little over 91 million I think we had it in the last presentation there was a slide in the in the budget presentation at our last meeting that shows that um it it would essentially allow us to balance this budget without overspending fund balance and then it produces because there's an addition 404 in inflation the following year and a 404 in inflation the year after that it produces a small Surplus then the board could direct towards targeted areas right it would allow us for the first time in a long time to actually make investments you make a long-term plan right I mean that's we could have a plan right so it's a good question whereas the other the bill 76 uh the governor's bill does not get us that
032far along a shot um question yeah so um if I missed this on the the slid somewhere um let me know I wondering if um I think we had a breakdown of who submitted a balance budget without use of State uh without use of additional state revenue did any of that subset was a 48 um not use either one the maximum amount of fund balance or two any fund balance there was a few of them that the yeah it had like either the 27 million or the or zero but I mean it was just you know you had to cut nearly everything to get to zero I mean it was fair to say that the class Si would increase even further than I think the six plus 6 PTR yeah if we were just to
033narrow it down there I don't see how they wouldn't have right gone High okay we can certainly pull that information I I I mean I it's and to be clear I'm I'm extremely grateful for anyone who took the survey I what I find the most valuable information um and I know that we put guard rails around you know you can't remove this expense because it's legally required I in hindsight I guess I wonder if we should have had that same legal requirement you can't submit this budget because it's not balanced and so um and so the ones that I find especially valuable are the the 48 that um were balanced and then the others I think I look to as a statement of priorities for what where things should be cuted where shouldn't be um
034but I I think I I I guess I'm I'm curious as to if from the administration side after with with this new feedback how was this primarily Vindication that we were grappling with the right set of challenges and the right levers is there any any new information or growth that occurred internally within the administration that we can use to um address the budget proposal that's currently drafted from my perspective it affirms that this is a really difficult budget to balance and there's no way not to touch programs and and things that people really value like class sizes I'm not sure how many additional responses would help us improve but it would be something would it is there material in here and we're not to this point in time yet should there be an increase to
035the BSA of $30 or $300 or 680 or 1,000 or whatever is there anything that we could use to prioritize what gets layered back in right it's sort of in a sort of a triage you know what teally use the same tool to add the like set up a model where you could just here's what it be to add them back if you go to the one of the first slides that has it it can track like where the increases the black bar sorry go down that one so you'll see in the bottom there's the top expenses increased so we can go in and take a look and see what those individual items were as well and where people kind of prioritized adding money into the budget yeah I guess I mean that that could
036be helpful should there be some resolution in Juno about adjusting education for inflation yeah we could also take a look at those responses that help certain F harmless you know so my my problem with this these are all this is a wor case scenario so we're having people line stuff up and we're getting phone calls in or information in saying please don't cut this and they think that's that that we making the decision already to cut it truth is we've got a budget that has to meet unrealistic type of scenario that's not going to happen so I'm not going to fight over what goes in a budget that's make believe at this point in time anyway and we're going to then the public will be providing input when we have additional money where they want
037it but I've encouraged them to say Express what you want today anyway but please understand that we're doing this in February and April going to know how much money hopefully we're going to get and it's going to change and then we're going to be putting things back you know or changing the budget entirely so um uh the public seems to know that community councils and talking to people they they understand this is you have to if they did this budget proposal the way it isum no additional money everybody had everything had to be cut and you didn't have any choice and so I don't I don't think we they understand that we've made a choice right now we just had to survive by doing it I don't want to read too much into this personally
038because nobody wants what they have cut we going to cut 28% of technology I hope not but or emotions or all the others I just I don't want to read too much into this because that's not a realistic scenario yeah and I'd like to continue doing it really I mean there's a a real educational component to the people that take it when you can go line by line and see where the district spends their money how much it costs what leverage you have to pull um certainly want to refine some of the things we did there some learning experiences on there but um yeah I think it's I think it was really valuable frankly to get um both from the feedback perspective to see that you know this is probably everyone else is going to
039do about the same thing um and just to have that that educational component is huge because we don't really have that anywhere else that's in like a format that's pretty easily to access and change I think there is something to what Madam chair suggested about getting feedback on how we would use the money that that we would receive with the new Revenue the BSA increase or what have you because theoretically if there were a BSA increase then we could use that to create the Strategic plan for our investments moving forward it would be Community Driven so there if we were to continue conceptualizing that I mean but we have our board goals and our board guard rails and I think it would be also helpful to maybe indicate which things the administration thinks support reading
040which things the administration maybe support you know math which which support I mean they all support one another uh because it is a complicated environment but um you know we do need to make sure that we keep our investments aligned with our board goals but I we we have bit ground go I want to be cognizant of time um still under thank you so much um under the FY 26 budget update item um there's a a quick slide deck um just on Staffing and could we just look over this and and maybe the administration can give a high Lev summary of um you know there's there's sort of just a couple of quick Pages showing what's happening in schools which is to my understanding a summary of the budget book in one very quick page
041sure I'm going to start with secondary because I messed something up and put the alternative on a different Tab and I'm going to go back and reshare it okay so we'll do this one first um uh but really this is what this shows is for the secondary and alternative uh this is all our all the classroom teachers that we have budgeted so this one actually match up to the budget for that total the fy2 classroom teachers and fy20 six um the whole back are just those positions that that we were able to reallocate to different schools um just out of our holdback pool but so we wanted to factor that in so you could really show how the school is going to feel like if you don't have that extra 1.8 in central then it
042only show shows a lesser amount in the total change but they're going to feel a total change of 4.4 FTE um so this is incluses of both the PTR increase and then the rollment declines um so it does have both of those components in there um it's not just aggregate we're losing teachers due to enrollment it's like 60 or so FTE due to enrollment and then another 194 195 due to the PTR plus4 yeah is that about right okay so this that was one of my questions this is the combined enrollment and P yeah yeah so this is everything kind of the changes we made and that's why you kind of see like hand you see a bigger drop there and Mir these things that like had a bigger enrollment decline than what we were
043remember j a question maybe well yeah so my my question relates to I mean I think how how how many examples of the PTR ratio how many examples of us deviating from the PTR ratio exist in these two charts are there any other multiple is that what the whole backs are yeah essentially and then I mean part of to is we're projecting you know 6 months out before or eight months out before we actually get the kids into school so you know if you lose kids but have the same staff your PTR is going to be a little bit lower um but yeah this reflects the number of teachers that were that were added to those schools some of us if they had an enrollment uptick a little bit or like class size Bubbles and
044things like that but there were so um I just want to make sure I'm tracking then so so the the the total change um is what we're proposing based on projected enrollment and the and our um proposed budget for the upcoming fiscal year um and it's based on those total changes do not include any remaining holdback teacher FTE that exists it does so it like so we took here's what was budgeted for Central 21.8 we added a hold back to Fe out of the pool which we're going to take away just like kind of reset that holdback pool for for next year right um so they actually had 23.6 FTE to staff their building currently so next year they're going to have 19.2 before any hold back before any hold backod okay it's really that
045change they feel in the building more than so then I think my question is the F the second to last column FY 26 classroom teachers that is purely the PTR formulas that we've adopted or we're proposing in our budget book right adjusted for also adust General and then but and then I think just to put a finer point on it because I think I saw an email where there was one individual that indicated that at their school the PTR um count um and the the teacher allocation count based on PTR wasn't done equitably is there any example where we're not going by PTR uh alternative schools generally do like if you look at King Tech we have a big uh SE section of teachers added to that school um because some other class sizes need
046have like ocean requirements like welding Auto those things where you can't have 30 or 40 kids in a class that's that's that's the only example like I'm thinking I think the email was regarding one of our um schools that had a language immersion on the neighborhood side right okay that's a yeah good question and we'll get to that on the elementary so on the elementary side we did have um those 12 emersion teachers that were put into the the the PTR metric essentially or outside of the PTR metric to shore up the neighborhoods side the immersion programs if that's what you're so it was extra FD in those and that was really what was removed for that next year's budget with regards to and that's why the immersion school schools that host a neighborhood and
047immersion side may feel like they're being hit especially hard because all of a sudden they don't have that additional support that has been of propping up that was above and beyond that was already above and beyond okay that that is what I was looking to clarify thank you yeah so we got like almost 6 so the middle schools will fill almost 64 FTE coming out High School is about 60 and then the alternative schools um almost 17 I'm kind of interested in the Middle School look at additional Staffing like wind and M M different ones M and and I hear their over capacity you know their capacity the school is well over it how we and they sounds like they're using storage room for meetings with with student what where would we add what can
048we add for teachers there without adding Portables are we really out of capacity can that be done but this even if we had more money this puts more kids in every classroom they're not going to need the storage room shrink the number of room you fewer you have few fewer you have fewer instru if we if did that do we have even the capacity to to reduce it given the how full it is right now yeah what is the what is the total hold back pool it was 31 and we cut and we're cutting 21 of those so we have 10 remaining hold back teachers versus a few dozen okay so significantly less ability to adjust to enrollment bubbles next year yes all right so that's the secondary I'm stop there for a minute and
049pull up the other find this was the elementary no here I guess I have as long as we're you're waiting to pull that up we have um you know secondary schools of different sizes we're starting to receive emails suggesting this is going to be cut from this school and this is going to be cut from that school I think as maybe individual principles are starting to make those really challenging decisions um again if that information uh is more centrally available I think that would be helpful so that an email from a Community member is not our first time hearing about cut of XYZ from from a particular school um but I I am con concerned that with our smallest secondary schools I'm concerned about our ability to deliver core education and I you know are
050we going to have the ability to teach math and science and social studies and language arts to the extent that our students need those core courses I mean my senses that things like choir will go by the wayside in order to focus on language arts um I mean electives are going to be diminished but but will we be able to deliver core instruction to our schools with the smallest number of staff at this I can make an attempt at having having filled the master schedule at e high school for seven years which is one of those smaller high schools I can say that I think these will significantly diminish the number of elective offerings but the schools will have to prioritize those course offerings that meet basic graduation requirements but what you're going to see
051in an area like sciences and example right now a junior might have the choice of Marine Science forensic science or AP Chemistry they may only have one of those three options or two of those three options so I think there still will be the ability AER as it is to meet basic graduation requirements it's just not going to be with the menu of options that people have experienced and the smaller the school the more challenging that's always been but then schools like Eagle River from its Inception because of its smaller size always used more online programming sent more kids to KCC sent more kids to Alaskan Middle College you know and leverage some of those other choices that are available to kids if the menu of options at the school couldn't need there do we
052provide transportation to kids who want to do the last the middle college there's a bus they can take the king Tech bus to King Tech which is where the base classroom is where the support teachers are for AMCs and from there there's a campus shuttle that can swing through so it's it's a hub and spoke model um that does allow for them to have transportation and that's particularly important for those folks like farther to travel interesting we're losing when we lose teachers we get others in can't replace what we have planing we're losing what they teach too so I mean like we lose Ric skill set with thing are we are we finding that a curriculum or changes on El things like that are being influenced at this point yet so you don't have a
053music teacher you don't have this you don't have that have we had that kind of problem um there are couple different your core content areas right your science teacher who's no longer able to teach forensic science is probably teaching ninth grade science or biology or some of those core sequence courses right so what they offer or what they're teaching changes but other areas like choir once you cut a choir teacher you've cut the choir program essentially that's what I mean yeah even if they were only teaching point4 choir and 6 something else once you lose that person in that area of expertise it's very difficult to offer that as a was than turn to cut into the position I'm thinking of somebody leaves and you can't find a replacement with that that's that's kind of
054out there as well that make sense saying it's a quiet teacher retired or we're going to go upon Qui future like I think I've shared with the group before at high school we have not seen the same challenges in Staffing that we have at elementary our highs areas continue to be special ed and the last couple years surprised ly Elementary classroom teachers um Middle School and High School content Area Teachers have not been overly difficult to to Source okay there was a question from I'm actually switching back to the secondary teacher allocation pool um I'm curious about school within a school at East um so East wasn't awarded any holdback teachers now for 25 and um and then they're losing 10 teachers how does school within a school work um in terms of teacher allocation
055and would that program being sunsetted offer any relief in terms of um class sizes at East and or budgetary savings for the district you I wouldn't think so we've never allocated extra staff because they have that and I think their class sizes are probably in line with our district metrics so if we were to cut that program skids have to go somewhere and we' be all within the same metric that's true most Choice programs so school with school the seminar program at you app want service the medical program at B that's always been done with the school's regular ftation so all classes will be getting bigger whether or not they're defined in a in a group or Hub and so would it be fair to say as a follow would it be fair to say
056that I mean is East going to be the East Building Administration be in the driver's seat whether or not it can still be able to offer that program I mean are we confident that with the the new allocation of teachers of you know drop going from 62 to 52 do that program can continue to exist that I don't know I can't give you defend Fair okay I me just something for the Bolton board and RFI um I was just curious because I noticed it was a breakout and we haven't talked about it much so Dr Johnson just shared with me that um principles have been curating a list of what cuts they think they might need to make based on these proposed reductions um and they're pulling that together um it's challenging to do it
057this point because it's it's sort of a chicken or egg conversation with your high school principal until you know for sure you're FTE and you know how many people might be leaving retiring moving out of state it's really hard to know exactly how that's going to impact your schedule because you may elect to cut a program where you have a teacher leaving versus try to hire that teacher who's left and displace somebody else and so there's a whole set of variables that really until you get to March are difficult to sus out and say exactly what the the cuts may be thank you well um great questions everyone um I guess you know because you know there are emails that are coming in saying this is going to be cut if there are you know
058indications from principles of what they think they may have to resort to doing um sometimes I think that the process you know thinking in process thinking back to the bus TR transportation that uh challenges that were here when you first arrived you said you've added two you know two bus drivers today and you were able to give us real time information um so I mean personally I would be interested in just understanding what our principles are considering but I also understand that could be sensitive and misconstrued so and for 90 locations I don't know how you would ever keep up I mean I well just mostly be for secondary right because so even with so eight secondary so eight middle schools schools and everybody's got everybody's thinking everything right now so I don't know how
059to keep up with those rumors because that's what they are rumors until but I hear what you're saying until it becomes a until we hear it from the administration so I don't know that we can chase rumors but I think we can um we can just get the best advice possible from from from the administration um because all the schools are going to be different and principles do have some discretion in how to reallocate I mean how how to assign staff I mean teachers might not want to do it that way but I mean that principles do have they can take whatever they have and do what they feel the community needs um I want to be cognizant of time um maybe just really quickly let's talk about the elementary and then maybe we might
060we might to go over a couple of minutes uh so we can get to the um disc right a window uh so the elementary one is was formatted a little bit different and this is just to show the classrooms we pulled out the specialist the art music Health PE those uh just allow for planning time um so it's not going to like FY 26 classroom teachers is not going to match up to the budget because we don't have those specialists in there H but the request was what's the number of classrooms we're going to lose in in this budget um so that's really how we' prepared this the fy2 classroom teachers would have those extra allocations for immersion programs um shows the hold back they're given and then their total same model then minus what's
061in there for 26 for that same those same metrics um so overall that gets to I mean there's some pretty significant reductions in here a total of 150 FTE um and this is also inclusive of the enrollment declines at elementary which we saw a pretty hefty uh decline overall can so I'm concerned about all of this um but knowing the delicate balance that I'm looking at Sand Lake because it's an immersion program right at the top of this page you know Sand Lake has an immersion in a neighborhood side um you know Al has immersion and neighbor side we have six of these immersion programs that are that are sixish six or seven six or seven what are these principles going to do I mean just create massive combination classes I me how how is
062this going to work well will grades K through the enrollment is going down but if you lose five of 18 teachers at Sand Lake and I I don't know how many are dedicated right now to the Japanese side and I don't know how many students are on the neighborhood side but I just and maybe that's the question how many are regular General it just it just I'm struggling to wrap my mind around how immersion Will Survive and how neighborhood Will Survive uh because you can't just shore of immersion by making one giant cake through five classroom no um that's not fair I don't think anybody would do that but no that mean that's an that's an extreme that's an extreme it happens in R Alaska but it does it does happen in R Alaska that's
063true so will you guys will the administration be offering guidance to those immersion and Rogers Park is probably also in the similar mod with the HG and the Rood side me any any school that houses multiple things is going to I think feel this stress perhaps more acutely particularly the ones like those immersion programs or Rogers Park you can't just add kids in the program that's where it gets difficult yeah because those kids have to like some of the optional programs they'll have it where you can okay we just pull more kids in right I would hope get into a discussion about all the options out there have this situation I mean I remember ch ch 3000 where you got one taet but everybody gets a different grade other things like that so we have
064basically every student get doing and you have that capacity to do that all VAR classes if we wanted to I think moving in that direction is going to be critical to flexibility and give the students that type of of instruction I just want to get into a discussion of all the options that other places are doing and what we might want to adopt here to make these things work better because it's going to continue to be um was GNA ask a question I think along the same lines maybe just ask for a specific number but I'm assuming we don't know here do you have any idea how many how many projected combination classrooms this creates above last year yeah that analis very because we have projected enrollment right based on the preliminary we're so we're
065allocating teachers based on projected enrollment I'm thinking that would give us a number that's at least projected number of combination classrooms you know it's still projected right so that's I'm curious about what that would do I think that's a good number to have in our conversations um internally and then with Juno and then I think and I don't maybe this is something I can schedule a meeting offline but I am interested in kind of walking through maybe with Administration what what would Sand Lake look like with 13 teachers um and you know I mean do they are they okay having one K through five classroom one K through five immersion um you know per class and they have a couple extra is that does that really what it looks like they pending any holdbacks yeah
066or do you or do you say let's not start immersion until fourth grade I mean I mean I feel like this is the kind of hard question that a principal is going to have to consider and I think we need to keep in mind that that is a principes that's probably what's eating that's at the top of every principal's mind that's what they're trained to do that's what we have to trust them to do and they should be able to explain that if I can follow so and I agree it's a principal's decision but if if I I think it would be helpful for me to know as a board member choose to vote if that's within the range of outcomes for if we adopt this budget as drafted um that that's possible I I
067I would want to go into the discussion that happens next Wise Eyes Wide Open as to what that looks like I don't know what I don't know what the right venue is if my goal is to get a look at what the function at Rogers Park Sand Lake malun Elementary what it looks like in this new scenario with what compared to what they have now is that something I should be requesting a meeting with Administration offline work session yeah so I mean how do we do that I I really want to look like building samples and see what this does yeah uh my initial thought is we could put some thought into three different scenarios of three kind of types of schools and maybe share that with board memb so we can walk through what
068it looks like think that might be the most efficient use it will be different at each school I mean like I know um like Rogers Park well Rogers Park might not be the Sand Lake maybe they're losing five but of the of the 13 that will be left are those like fulltime right with them or are they sharing St are they sharing um that te with somebody else like because that that would make an impact too yeah the 13 that would be left would be just dedicated teachers at Sand sake no okay specialist will come in on top of that right okay but that's inclusive of the immersion and J so my underlying ask is and it sounds like maybe other board members are interested I would appreciate doing like a deep dive popping on
069certain buildings to see what it looks like to help contextualize this conversation I don't know when that's probably maybe more of a call for um president Hollman and you Dr Bryant but I whether it be a private conversation offline just to catch me up or whether there are all board members want to be a part of it that's my ask yeah let's try to see how fast we can spend up scenarios and I'd like to create like a traditional neighborhood school and one that shares a program and that way the board understands the the full impct and it's a devastating impact I'm not going to Shield that in my mind I'm more thinking about how do the number of holdbacks factor into the because when we limit our back we our ability to save programs
070or subsidize under schools and Dr aware that um Ken and her team are meeting with principles at merant principles next week and some of these other specialized groups as well to have these conversation so it may not be by next Tuesday's board meeting but I think there will be some of the work samples you're talking about available after have those conversations maybe when those products are available especially if delayed board vote on the 25th maybe there's a little bit of an extended window at least we could be sent that information um we are at the end of an hour and there's a really nice robust presentation on discretionary grants and I hate that you've been sitting here waiting to talk about it but I also want to give it the time and respect and thought
071that it deserves would it be okay to delay that until like the first item next at our next finance committee meeting yeah okay thank you very much so our next meeting is going to be um March 27th although perhaps if there is reason to call another Finance meeting before then um you know with appropriate notice we can always do so know knowing that there's also a spring break so you know we have a meeting we have our board meeting on the 18 we have a special meeting on the 25th a lot could happen between now and March 27th so I'll put a little but number one you're number one okay great thank you so much everyone for uh your contributions and participation today um with that I'd like to end our me thank you so
072much