001our website under Tab four student Discipline matters pursuant to Education Code section 48918 CF um and now those so everything we're going to hear public comment on aside from the general public comment is relative to those tabs and we will begin that general public comment right now so we have conference with labor negotiators the first public commenter on that is Mr David to kovski applaud your efforts immediately to uh rebuild and help these schools and communities while Altadena and the Palisades are not quite Amish communities they are powerful communities that have a strong faith-based history and we'll come together uh your efforts to add five days is a good start but uh quite honestly uh it could be much more significant I remember mayor Reen and my colleague Helen berstein Union President we would have
002had an agreement with all the hotels to to provide for our employees so keep pushing on the labor negotiations with respect to litigation of the ninth circuit court case which you'll hear about in close session is about the lawyer fees but I want you to look at uh the case at satoi elementary school that it is uh about special ed services and it has some points to bring up in your future meetings on special ed additionally on litigation you have uh a court order on Miramar the school next door let me suggest that when you do do any RFP or you do anything that you consider putting criteria uh and collocation where you could put an affiliated with an independent Charter and make sure they're all Union Schools uh and um the um the number
003of cases you have uh a do cases you should have a public account ability of all past present costs it must be soaring over a billion on Personnel matters hopefully you will uh try your best to uh keep our current police chief to and entice him to stay the work he and his team have been doing has been absolutely tremendous and finally you also in evaluation I don't think people need to be impressionistic about evaluation that you have a contract you should use the contract and have specific criteria that you like we measure our schools measure the performance of a superintendent thank you very much thank you for your time now on to tab two Personnel uh we have two folks who are calling in Carl J Peterson I see you're on the line please
004press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Carl Peterson hello yes hello Mr Peterson please go ahead it is disappointing that the superintendent's evaluation is occurring behind closed doors during yesterday's board meetings the district labor Partners pulled no punches as they criticized him for the breakdown and Leadership during the ongoing crisis parents supporting teachers the largest parent-led education advocacy group in Los Angeles also issued a press release accusing carvalo of sacrificing safety using our children as political theater they called for his immediate removal from leadership in the district the public should know if the board accounts for these criticism Ms as they evaluate the superintendent even before the current crisis there has been repeated criticism of carvalo for his lack of transparency and his prioritization of publicity
005over results for me this was first evident after the district's computers were infiltrated by Russian hackers one of his first public comments about that crisis was in front of the special education committee he not only lied about the extent of that attack but threatened to pursue legal action against anyone who dared to tell the truth while carvalo insisted that student data had been released the media uncovered sensitive data about LD students with special education needs on the dark RB this included medical records and other extremely personal information interestingly the superintendent never returned to speak at the sped committee during my tenure to address the victimization of these families or any other issues facing the special education committee Community under carvallo's leadership the community advisory committee CAC has been eliminated as an independent adviser to this
006board for the past two years the selection process outlined by the bylaws and state law has been ignored so that the district selects the membership instead of the committee's peers in violation of the law the Sela was approved without the required involvement of the CAC since the superintendent's evaluation is conducted in private the public will never know if these violations were addressed or if anything has been done to ensure that they will not be repeated thank you thank you for your time the second caller is Vicky Martinez Vicky Martinez I see you're on the line please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have 2 minutes to speak once you begin Vicki Martinez good morning can you hear me we sure can please go ahead thank you as you stated my name is Vicki
007Martinez I am calling today Wednesday January 15th because the LA USD school board will meet to evaluate superintendent carvallo's performance as the largest advocacy group for parents and staff in Al USC we are calling for the immediate removal of superintendent carvalo from leadership in the district we did not make this statement lightly but as we have watched our City's largest tra tragedy be mishandled and politicized we believe we have a duty to advocate for the students and staff of Al USD the decision to keep schools open on January 8th as city leaders were calling for people to stay off the road and remain at home was one that was done for no clear reason and put lives in danger our neighborhoods faced down electrical wires and power outages that led to disastrous conditions for children
008arriving at school campuses opened with trees down no power and with half of their staff available for students early closures that were announced have Hazard created a chaotic and dangerous Scramble for families and staff while we continuously hear the refrain that the district's top priority is safety this was one once again proven false under carvalo although schools were closed for the rest of the week the decision was announced hours after it was actually made and was only allowed to trickle out through a game of Telephone by principles and community members communication organization and Humanity seem to be all sacrificed for an image that must be upheld at a press conference our children are not political theater we also would like to highlight the fiscal mismanagement that has taken place under carvallo's tenure prop 28 alone
009should be enough for removal and he has overseen what is tantamount to theft of State funds we have seen very little in the way of transparency about data breaches or the $6 million mistake that was Ed the AI tool furthermore his elimination of successful instructional programs such as primary promise thank you very much for your time we appreciate your time Miss Martinez thank you okay now we'll move to General public comment I'll call in the folks who look to be in the room first and then we'll move to those who are who listed themselves as calling in uh remotely so uh Maria Lisa Palma I see you're here so come on up you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin [Music] good morning unbelievable yesterday's agenda item 37 presentation of the review of the
01023 to 24 annual audit the financial statement audit didn't happen Mr carvalo said that that can be available to you all in private ha I want to hear from the audit from the CPA Simpson and Simpson here in public so they can present in their own words their concerns the findings what you have said are the potential corrective actions the public has no other way to hear about the net position do you know what that is okay I'll explain it to you in regular terms that's the balance sheet assets minus liabilities which equal net worth your net worth here at the district is in a net negative or deficit position total net deficit 2.4 billion but even more damning the unrestricted net deficit 11.8 billion why the public deserves to hear why I hope all
011of you know why I'll tell you why because of unfunded pension liabilities unfunded other post-employment benefits opep this is happening in secret the public does not know that you have liabilities promises you have made to current employees for their pensions and and benefits that you are not paying for right now you are booking them as liabilities this is the only place that happens and I am calling for a special meeting on behalf of the public that you present this financial statement that the Auditors stand here and answer your questions in public not in private not behind closed doors I have here the citation of the law if you're not familiar with it section Ed code section 41020 point3 where it says that the uh education agency shall review at a public meeting the annual audit
012and you can look at this now my information I brought to you on the incidents are still here apparently Mr McLean you didn't uh pick it up please distribute this to all the board members and we will take this further if you do not have a public meeting with the CPAs thank you thank you for your time Jenna noise are you here Jenna come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin thank you good morning members of the board my name is Jenna noise and I'm a PTA Executive Board member representing Valley Hills Council Apperson Street Elementary School and mount glea Middle School in region north I am also a former special ed teacher with Burbank Unified School District I'm here to speak the importance of school safety not just in my
013area but across La USD schools when we discuss school safety it's about more than just the absence of violence it's about creating an environment where students can focus on their education grow without fear and develop the skills they need to succeed safety means enduring ensuring that students are protected from physical harm but it also encompasses their mental and emotional well-being a safe school is one where students feel free to express themselves without fear of bullying discrimination or isolation it's one where staff are trained to recognize and intervene early whether it's a behavioral concern or a mental health challenge before issues escalate into something more serious so when situations do escalate additional support is essential to manage acute issues like physical alteration altercation which was recently seen at Verdugo Hills High School at a as a
014special a teacher I felt safe in my classroom and on campus Because I had access to trained staff who could assist in de-escalating violent outbursts today however students and staff don't have the same Safety Net in the video of the Verdugo Hills incident it's clear that staff were left on the sidelines for crucial minutes waiting for help to arrive in fact it's hard to imagine how situations like this could be handled now especially when discipline measures like suspensions seem to have been significantly reduced school safety doesn't happen in a vacuum it requires the collaboration of teachers administrators law enforcement mental health professionals and families to ensure the comprehensive approach every individual has a role to play in creating a safe and nurturing environment we need to ensure our schools have the resource training and support
015necessary to protect both students and staff in real time thank you thank you for your time di Guan come on up miss gan's going to speak in Spanish so if you'd like to hear what she's saying in English please put on these translation headsets okay listos thank you so when uh and we've collected more than 500 signatures for that police can come back as parents and a community we are seeing how you're making decisions and you didn't respond the question to Miss Shirley and you still voted so it's like it doesn't matter you just you're making decisions where you don't even know where the what the consequences will be and right now you're are giving absolute power in these emergencies to the superintendent and I say okay fine I hope they don't stop him when
016he tried to put you know school police and schools because there was a lot of violence that to us is an emergency you want schools to start burn so that you can start talking about an emergency when violence and drugs usage and overdoses in the schools have incremented 180% even when 10 or 15% would be a lot so you have a great indifference because you haven't touched that topic and you're ignoring us you're talking about democracy Miss GGO what is that give power to the community we are the community we're the people not utla not the unions utla right now is sending people to speak poorly about the superintendent and I say if they want the superintendent to go they you should all go because you all have the same responsibility and the same actions
017that you're taking so when the superintendent wants to do something proper for the community let him don't stop him because the community needs that school police to defend us because not only is it to stop but it is so that it things in our community are prevented like they are now safety is something important you're telling to everybody about Behavior but when these disasters and the teachers and the Personnel did an excellent job but right now we in our Community need the school police because we don't want more kids overdosing more death due to your lack of experience and all you care about is your political agenda here the agenda is the parents democracy is to be listen to on our from us Isabelle Gonzalez Isabella Gonzalez come on up thank you [Music] sees uh
018everyone I'm here to remind you your promises while occupying your place members of the board I demand that you fulfill your promises when you took our votes the reincorporation of the school police should not be up for discussion the school safety should be the number one priority for you all the lack of safety in and outside the schools is the responsibility of the LA Unified School District we demand the financing of the Department of the school police may it be reinstated as fast as possible the safety of our children should never have been negotiated respect the rights of our kids respect the rights of our kids to receive education in a safe environment school police plays a crucial role in the in The Cordial education of our kids a behavior of respect a safe environment
019first of all our schools would function in an optimal way and with a better academic achievement this should not be in discussion when it comes to a shooting violence fighting shouldn't be up for discussion it shouldn't be up for discussion when there's fist fighting hitting we send them safe and that's how we want them when they come home return uh bring back the school police thank you for your time Maria Daisy Ortiz I see you're here come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin are we ready perfect good morning everyone my name is Maria Dai Ortiz I am here well first of all tell saying that there was a lot of authority given to the superintendent and hoping that in his uh priorities the school safety is there because we need
020to create a campaign where we we have all some kind of signage that says that the our priority is the safety of our kids because every life matters secondly I was seeing yesterday that the the unions and the labor partners and even the students spoke in here but the parent voice I did not see it here and we are the ones that brings that product to the district so I ask you all that you please make those changes where the parent voices is considered and the leadership in the those positions and the efforts of the superintendent and in the work that you realize because when you delegate or accept things you turn into accomplices and you're responsible in answering us and those in the community with what you do with public funds there should be
021more transparency and equity and results lastly I know we're talking about Mental Health and yes it's very important for everyone students teachers and the rest but you're talking about it in an ample General sense you need to be specific if it's going to be group or therapy whatever it may be so I have group support information and resources we have 18 support groups in all the community where we work different topics every week and I suggest that you do group supports within the schools for the students or incorporating it into the emotional in intelligence curriculum because they need to have mental health and wellbeing have a great day uh Marcela Garcia you're listed as calling in Marcela Garcia but I don't have you online I thought you might be in the room uh Monica Rola
022I see you're here come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin mon good morning my name is mar uh Monica I have two children in the district yesterday I came to tell you about this girl who stabbed this other student and I highlight again and I tell you again that it's important for school police to come back to school if the school police had been in the school I assure you that this girl would have not done such thing a student that is in 12th grade has destroyed her life the student in grade 12 has also destroyed his life if the school police had been there I assure you that it would have not gotten to this level because the girl just came stabbed and then left it's something that's so
023serious because of dumb things and I want to highlight again it was not just people who have lost their homes now there's a lot of us in the community who have lost their jobs or those that used to care for the children who were the gardeners or the construction they're doing the work that Community is being affected to and it's not fair that PE aside from losing their job they're worried about safety in school wondering what's going to happen in the school today I took my daughter to school and I don't know if I will pick her up today and every single day is like that five days and I would like for the week to be over soon because I can have my children's close to me because it's a fear looking at my
024phone if everything's well it's something that is so serious that we're going through so I please ask you to return School Mr Nick if you have the school police in your Fairfax office please Place back school police in our school we have a office there so that they can take those calls it's so important that we have our safety we want students to graduate in A and B not with a d we want them to be someone in life not just to go and work in McDonald's or cleaning bathroom which are not bad but we want something more because our students are bilingual trilingual we want the best for our children and so I thank you so much and thank you again thank you for your time Karina Lopez I see you're signed on to
025speak remotely but sometimes I don't have the right information Karina Lopez oh Juan mandhi you're listed as speaking in person but I don't have you in the room and nor are you online Nelly Mendes Nelly Mendes uh hin Beltran hin belron come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin good morning my name is hakiman um I went to um La USD as a child um also was student body president for C State Los Angeles um I've been helping with the aid efforts uh from night one day one uh to provide n95s um and air filters uh to evacuation sites uh recently an LA USC um classroom as well who requested it and so we placed all of these do it yourself filters they're called Cory Ros and doll boxes um we
026provided them I think it was about um 15 um to keep all their classrooms safe now I notice here in this room you have 1 2 3 four five air cleaners which is great good for you guys um this room is the size of about three classrooms when you take into account that classrooms do not have air filters but there is disproportionately clean air in this room why is that the case who can I work with to make sure that right now when there is wild fire smoke with par matter with toxins that will affect long-term Health that will potentially lead to higher cancer rates as we've seen before with these types of events that we can place either the optic clean filters that you have here or these do it yourself uh which are
027being dominated there's no reason reason that they can't be I like to work with you to do it at scale much quicker we can continue to just work with the teachers and the admin at specific schools uh but since you are the head of the LAUSD system uh let's just do it right now let's work together to make sure that the students the teachers that the administrators at these schools have clean air thank you so much um who can I speak to someone will come down and see you all right thank you okay you're welcome oh also note that these air filters that you see here uh for everyone in the audience and people listening were placed in this room about 3 or four years ago at the outset of covid and so we we
028brought them back in they're Dual Purpose right because respiratory season Co is still around flu is increasing right so let's make sure we protect all the students teachers and administrators thank you there are many more students lungs in those classrooms than our lungs in this room julip Thomas julip Thomas come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin hi my name is julip Thomas I'm an L USD parent student safety is our top priority every communication from the district or from the school I hear student safety is our top priority but honestly I'll believe it when I see it there are longstanding air quality issues that still haven't been resolved and if they had the current air quality crisis wouldn't be nearly as impactful what I want to know is where is
029the leadership the district is in a unique position to educate families is it not where is the messaging alerting District stakeholders our families to the dangers that they face breathing in the vaporized remains of thousands of houses garages cars Etc whereas the signal boosting of warnings from the Department of Health that proper masking is recommended due to poor air quality not reflected in air quality index dashboards I've heard from several parents across the district that some students were only provided surgical masks at some schools we need to be educating all district families in the importance of well-fitting highquality respirators not only to suppress the transmission of respiratory illnesses which would improve the attendance of students which we all know is a huge District concern but particularly in situations like the current fire crisis facing La
030many times we have called on this board for better handling of indoor air and I'm asking again today for a commitment from the board with the passing of measure us to upgrade all district schools in a timely fashion to the new ashray 241 standards that will ensure that we are giving our students and faculty members a safe environment with Clean Indoor Air our district families deserve the transparency and accountability offered by the Boston Public Schools their air indoor air quality dashboard provides realtime data for all classrooms including PM 2.5 carbon monoxide carbon dioxide Etc thank you guys thank you for your time the remaining folks are calling in uh let's see erinda Morita I see you're on the line please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you
031begin erinda Morita good morning my name is first of all I am so sorry for what's happened with the fires my condolences for everybody today I want to highlight the safe safety with with police in um schools it's energen because to be prepared we want to avoid energency is to act in critical moments just like what we are facing right now I wish that it does not happen in our school at LD or at the board are you prepared do you already know the consequences for fires shootings and earthquakes are you updated are you organized and is everyone on the same page in case of an extreme emergency do you know what to do when at what time in what moment so that you don't feel sorry so that you are prepared on time in
032the academics we already know that you have failed students and that you have lied and also you were halfway they're halfway in their studies I have witnessed that and I am so sorry how you are so you lie and that you are feeling I also want to highlight about the emergency with the fires I would like for that Tuesday that you have said that you would have said that there would be no school on Wednesday so that we don't put students at risk because many parents in certain schools there was a lot of Chaos uh unorganized and they were concerned so I would like for us to be more organized the schools that we demand the principles and also that we can help in school safety and that we are organized with the parents so
033that we know what to do during an emergency not like the things that have happened right now that it was a total chaos thank you so much Maria Torres are you in the room uh Miguel Sanchez Lucy Garcia these folks are signed up to speak remotely but I also do not see the room Paul Hennessy uh Juan C Delgado I see you're on the line please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Juan C Delgado yes hi please go ahead we can hear you good afternoon everybody first of all blessings yes it is concerning honestly to see that we waste our valuable time as parents as volunteers we don't get any paid so that our students are able to to move forward but it's even sadder
034to see the way that the Los Angeles Unified School District do how they act the district acted in this last emergency honestly it is concerning to see that L USD does not even have any idea any kind of organization in schools in case of a true emergency such as the one that we lived all schools had a lot of pro problems they had lots of conflicts to be able to react and get their students out of school during the emergency that we lived it is so concerning to see that the topic of safety in schools is really affected and it's affecting where schools do not have any kind of idea no idea or any kind of option of support from the school why because L USD has dedicated itself to leave the schools abandoned without
035the support of the police any kind of support for that matter and that cannot continue it is time for the L USG takes this seriously that student safety the school safety is one of the priorities that you need to have in mind and that they should work because all of the schools have a lot of Abandonment and their safety today as of today we are not really prepared as a school Community or as a district for an extreme emergency such as the one we live there are schools that honestly are continue to be abandoned where the LUSD hasn't even taken the time to see what have been the harm that was caused or what things need to be fixed or what kind of um conflicts the parents had to take their children during the emergency
036to me it's concerning that as L USD there is no really plan for safety and that we as Community can really trust that in the case of an extreme emergency such as that that the District LA USD will guarantee the safety completely of our students thank you good Scott Squires you're listed as uh calling in but I don't have you online it looks like uh okay Scott Squire is not here but uh Paul Hennessy I see you showed up online please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Paul Hennessy can you hear me can you hear me can hear you please go ahead thanks the wildfires and La make it clear that air purifiers are needed in classrooms and common areas even after these current ties
037between smoke voc's and burned building particles including ASB bestus the current indoor air infrastructure in your schools are not adequate so why is it when clean air groups offered free free air purifiers in your school they were turned down this is not the last Wildfire we need carbon boc filtration MV 1 HVAC filters and air scrubbers in all schools parents have been asking for this for years apart from pollution and smoke upgrading air filtration helps stop Airborne spread of viruses norovirus flu RSB and Co are all airborne and spreading unchecked in schools right now leading to absences and learning law and even mild Co is linked to long-term issues like diabetes and children air purifiers and air scrubbers belong in the classroom and for years LD has made it incredibly difficult to get them into
038schools and lead them on Boston Public Schools have CO2 monitors and upgraded ventilation transparent way of showing and improving air quality in classrooms LD would be wise to do the same studies even show that lower CO2 levels result in more alertness amongst children but even CO2 monitors don't account for microplastics ASAS andlet so they must be used in conjuncture with higher standards of Clean Air additionally measure us funds need to be applied to upgrading HVAC units to ashray 241 standards are better and having filters that are mer 14 or higher only then will La schools be protected against easy to mitigate disasters like wildfire smoke and illness please tell the bond oversight committee we want measure us invested into ashray 241 standards I'm begging you to act on this and distribute n95s in schools as
039well because you're making our children and staff breathe in toxic air thanks thank you for your time it looks like Karina Lopez is online now Karina please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Karina Lopez good morning yes my name is thank you my name is scina Lopez and I am calling because security is a worry that we have it's been happening for several months and honestly we felt ignored from you guys and it seems like you're playing with everyone's life you're playing with the children's life every day at every moment at the same time and more because of the catastrophe that has occurred this exposes the necessity and this is that we have a necessity to reestablish the element of school police we need this
040we need this urgently we need to reestablish this that is based on the necessity we can't blend or mix the services the budgets and we can't play with students security thank you Squires you are now you appeared online for us so please Scott Squires press star press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Scott Squires hello hello hello sir please go ahead can you hear me hi I'm Scott Squires I'm a grandparent of children in the uh school districts uh I just want to say and you follow up with what others have said that clean we need clear clean air in the schools it's frustrating so little has been done until the last year or two but still not enough clean air reduces the number of absentees
041from illness including respiratory illnesses clean air also deals with outside that has high particles and toxins especially important now with the LA fires studies are showing CO2 levels greatly impact attention levels in students keeping the CO2 levels low keeps students healthier and more attentive sadly us LUSD dropped masking for no real scientific reasons so there was an increase in illnesses of all type an increase in absences right now schools are not following the latest specific guidelines for clean area the measure us funds should be put into schools to meet the ashra 241 HVAC standards we need education of teachers and administrators Regarding why clean areas are required and what their responsibility is many teachers are turning off air purifiers which defeats the entire reason in process of upgrading ventilation to provide clean air teachers and
042administrators should also be educated about Co and its impact on children there are 5.8 million children in the US with long covid today that number is growing daily 70% of covid spread comes from children but schools have done little to mitigate illness there's a great video available to schools and parents that covers clean air and covid in schools specifically it's called covid safety4 schools.org the deaths should stop being arranged and child facing each other arrangements without masking this is simply causing a spread of illness there's simple te things that schools can do but it fail to do we need the respirator mask always available for students including children thank you for your time protect themselves we appreciate your time sir thank you okay that concludes public comment I'm going to run through our list one
043more time and that concludes public comment the time is now now 11:05 and the board is going to recess into close session e e e good afternoon welcome back the time is now 3:59 p.m. on January 15 2025 the meeting is now resuming from closed session I'm going to take rooll uh Miss nuil present Dr revas present Mr Melo here miss grego here ah there he is board president schmon okay that looks like 1 two 3 four and five I'm going to report out um the language from Clos session and then the meeting will adjourn under tab two Personnel Public Employee discipline dismissal and release the Board of Education authorized the dismissal of one classified employee the vote was seven Eyes under tab three conference with legal councel uh pending litigation the Board of Education
044authorizes settlement in EMV LAUSD terms and conditions will be available upon the finalization of the agreement the vote with six eyes and one absent miss gonz the Board of Education authorized a settlement in the following cases Jane mm do v l USD Jane BJ do V USD Jane I do v l USD and John ZD do V USD the with six eyes and one absent in monez the Board of Education authorized the settlement in the following cases John E S do Jane omom do Jane m d do Jane LG do Jane Ms do Jane re e do John TBE do John Tac do and Jane TBM do the vote was six eyes and one absent miss gones the Board of Education authorized a settlement uh in the following case Jane do LUSD the vote was
045six eyes and one absent Miss gonz as I mentioned earlier all of these case numbers are listed on our website if you'd like to look up the cases individually by case number on the Los Angeles Superior Court website um you can get those numbers from our website and then punch them in to the LC website okay and tab four student Discipline matters the Board of Education approved the expulsion of student in case numbers 43 44 45 46 47 49 50 51 52 53 54 and 55 with the recommended dispositions the Board of Education approved the conditional enrollment of the student in case number uh 15a 2425 with a recommended dispositions the vote was six eyes and one absent uh thank you very much that concludes the board's business today are there any objections to adjourning
046no objections no objections the time is now 4:02 p.m.