001Andy we missed you Monday night at the uh Recruitment and Retention work group I meant to send an email letting you know I was out of town [Music] um it was interesting down there yeah you were down in Juno I I think there's optimism that something significant is going to happen um but nobody can put a number on it yeah and there's a lot of interest in trying to figure out things that make the governor happy but don't really hurt us so yeah well the conversation on Monday was good we got into our first deeper dive around um you know one of the topics that was a priority for all the different bargaining units so we talked about workload burnout and initiatives and just those impacts on people's desire to stay and what makes those
002things difficult and what keeps people buoyant you know in the face of some of those things and it was good it was good to kind of dig in on a single topic yeah I uh I heard I think Julie colum talk about something she's doing to limit class size but I I don't I couldn't find a bill about it I didn't get a chance to follow up and ask her about it but I don't know how that would work it uh and we can't bargain it um but yeah I I'll try to do some research and find out what she's talking about but um I remember when I came in the district um there were statutory caps on English and social studies really theyed uh 24 or 25 kids per class and then that went
003away like 2002 2003 I me early 2000s that that language was removed wow I didn't know that was ever in there that uh I remember having to schedule around it at chat when I was a department chair wow when when I was at hu as a student teacher in 94 I had over 40 kids in my science class yeah it was just English and social studies and it was at least at the high school it was just nth and 10th great yeah so what happened if you ran out of teachers I think there was some I don't know if there was funding tied to it or or what I yeah that that's the thing I I wanted to find out what Kum was talking about because if you if you do that and you run
004out of Staff does that mean you get more money or I don't know of course the other thing now is you can have funding for the positions but you that doesn't mean you can hire someone right uh Andy and Marty sorry to cut in real quick I just wanted to uh make sure that you were both aware we are uh live on YouTube and I'm about to start a reporing ah okay sounds good yes for March schedule so council is going to present to the F governance committee okay their findings and you can adjust as you'd like I'm going to go get some so group is GNA do present to the board they'll present their fings on the mark analysis hopefully right after spr it took a long time to get the business to agement
005worked out so we share information from directly with them that kind of we're still waiting on inform as well so teacher side so my hope is to come oh we're live streaming yeah e e e okay good morning we'll call this meeting of the as school board governance committee meeting to order today is Thursday the 13th of February at 1108 a.m. just starting late um present in the room I see myself our committee chair Carl Jacobs member Higgins online we have other board members uh yes member Wilson and president great and I'm sorry member uham as well awesome okay then any staff introduce online uh let's see here no other staff um U Mr Anderson is on I'm not great okay and then Pres the room we have our executive secretary America Sullivan KD grants
006with the superintendent's office Dr Brian HD superintendent and Marty Lang um we will get started with introductions out of the way our first item under B1 is our rotating trianal policy review um our first item on the agenda is 41126 -42 12.6 43126 great and then am I recalling right that or is this is this um brought over from previous month or is this new new okay great so I think we were talking about in last week's meeting potentially consolidating these numbers down but I think in in conversation afterward we decided we want to keep them with the three numbers as if is that correct okay great so we'll do that are there any other um for board members reviewing this policy are there any suggested Chang changes amendments or updates that we require before
007we notate that we review this policy hearing seeing none I think we can move to our next item Sol 41261 same question for board members are there any changes to this policy that we think are required before we notate that this one has been reviewed to ask the issue you do references indidual do we don't um formal reference comes to HR we will verify the uh when the employe worked for us and what job dier positions they occupied while working for ASD um we don't in order to maintain you know a neutral posture that's all information we share officially from our human resource division um make reference curious about that it's not a big deal to me you us cont all over the place so covers it but um we have the right to do
008reference checks when without when it's appropriate we had it someone terminated associated with abuse of child we implications of that liability to us if you're with State form employ big they had somebody they terminated they read to just State nights reference you know just nothing at all went across the street got hired and it killed the supervis talking lot a behavior extreme so there an unsafe situation there an obligation don't see anything in there and I that's appropriate or not but state laex from giving a reference it's not knly false and malicious you good thing but there we do have some obligation to give references at times from HR perspective I'm familiar with if it's if it's something where they used to have going from hospital to hospital killing people den and all that kind
009of stuff I don't know whether that's something to be captured or not but there was a limitation there where we have obligation and to address that I would say in those instances the action the district would proactively take is we would file a complaint with the ptpc and that would potentially uh endanger their credential and ability to reapply for those positions and we would refer that matter to the Anchorage Police Department as appropriate thank you Mr Lang thank you Mr Higgins president hman your hands up um yes I wanted to ask it's my understanding that we do provide information about whether someone's eligible for rehire is that true or not yes okay and as a followup um CU it involves a specific case that the person reached out to me about the state law in
010Arizona requires an applicant to have a letter of recommendation from their last supervisor which was a a school principal um if a request under this policy was made like that would that then be passed to the superintendent's office or or would a a principal be able to respond we haven't done anything to limit a principal or supervisor's ability to um you know upon exit write a letter of recommendation for employee or fill out a reference with the future employer um this I think speaks more to formal requests through the HR department um and it ites you're right it does not differentiate that level um of requests that might come in right as I'm reading it it says the superintendent or designate to process all requests for references so it it I I would read that
011as saying any requests that came into the district at any level would go to the superintendent's [Music] office I guess I would highlight Mr chair that uh it says design and I I would interpret that would assume reading that that that would be our human resources or talent management area um but I think these are good points and good discussions are there any proposed changes to this policy before we move on what generally is in there is a statement saying that individuals not on behalf of the school district individuals can do refence can do letter recommendations for staff without you know limitation but they have to clearly identify they're doing it as an IND individuals what typical policy states and so official letters of recomend or recommendations or reference checks would come through HR but
012that individuals are uh may may prepare letters or recommendations as but but not on behalf of the district it needs to be clearly identified respond as by supervisor School District then you R into that way but that's typical most employers do within it with the state law changing rights of to involved in that pretty prot liability withous you're going to be safe still so uh request for L his recommendations to a supervisor they're responding as a supervisor could be a problem so you could pick up some standard language and I have of me right policy has it you want to I don't we're fixing a problem that probably doesn't exist so only be fair about it okay yeah we wouldn't be opposed to that like addition side just this has not been anything in my
013experience that has been problematic felt like we had R risk exposur and other is when they're eligible or not eligible if they're not eligible because they got terminated cause is one thing I feel different about it when they're terminated P employment at will you've been here three month they just don't think you're the right fit or whatever and then going out saying they're not eligible if they're not eligible they're not but I question whether or not that's a good management practice anyway for being to be viewed as thank you Mr hiin um not hearing any um formal amendments to this we'll consider it reviewed and move on to our next board policy 41128 42128 43128 give folks a minute to digest there any suggested changes amendments to 4112 4 41128 to 4228 or 4312 the
014only problem I have with this one is that we've had an immediate uh family member hired by a um principal and when that happened board approved it but they approved it just on big sheet these are people who are being hired without a disclosure to the board that it was a relative and that was at East High School the big issue that happened there so um and that was investigated by the umus said it was a violation but um the I guess we'll get to the point of just having reports but if we had something um that clarified and made a comat that you know immediate family may be in if most and has been appr you know you know somehow language in there that say it has to be disclosed and approved or something
015like that that has been disclosed and approved by the school board maybe that would be good language because the board didn't know they were approving it okay they they just had a name down there we didn't know it was a daughter uh and not for a position in which there wasn't more qualifi more applicants okay um and I don't know if you know um and I know best qualify that kind of eliminates that gives you a two qu BL type thing but if if if the has been disclosed and approved by the cl to the school and improve the school board maybe adding that language in there might be good because that was a problem it happened I'm reviewed it within the last five years I think six years and gave a report that shouldn't
016happened but it wasn't disclosive it was it was a name on an approval list that's not disclosive so member Higgins is this something language you're prepared to offer now I think we could I think we could say you know uh maybe employ most qualified uh uh has been uh and let's see the relationship has been disclosed and approved by the school that relationship has been disclosed to the school board you know something like this closed and approved by the school board and we're talking about the end of the first line of the third paragraph um I guess my question is and from a functional standpoint for it to be approved by the school board would it not have to be disclosed to us first um no because we get a whole list of these are
017H these are transfers and this was a transfer this is this you know terminations we don't get a disclosure on there that there was a relationship at all and and at times that has come through I know we had relationships B botl and others that we the boy was aware of but and others who haven't in the past and that's where I want to make sure that it's disclosed I I I think I understand what you're saying because I just I'm wondering if the language change you're suggesting effectuates that desire I guess uh um how I read the first end of the first line and the start of the second line is that right now an immediate family member of a school board member can be employed by the district if um that he or
018she is the most qualified applicant and has been approved by the school board um and so if we if we add in there that that it should be disclosed to the school board and approved I I don't know that that functionally changes any process um I feels like you're asking for an additional disclosure of some additional information which is fine I just don't know that that adding those two words will get us there and I'm not sure either appreciate the comment because it but it is it has been an issue in multiple cases that I'm familiar with with the school district and uh the most glowing one was East in which a daughter was hiring and that's public information that's in the Mr L uh the way that I read this that third paragraph is
019specific to uh family members of school board members and or the superintendent oh I think the first paragraph is the one that more broadly captures immediate family for supervisor generally and to your point member Higgins I think at the time that this board policy was brought in adopted there were two known situations High School ones that you referenced that were um grandfathered didn't I don't know what the approval process or who was notified at the time principal and they didn't want to lose somebody who was uniquely qualified for certain class in school neither of those situations persist today and to my knowledge we have not created any new ones and so um just wanted to make sure that for purpose of this conversation there are no current Arrangements um as there have been in the
020past we used to get a report page two relationships had been approved we didn't always approve them directly in the past but we got a report but the report was not so hearing that no situations matching the description of the first paragraph exists hearing that um disclosure and approval required for um situations that described in the third paragraph rting a family member of a board member superintendent are there other proposed Chang any proposed changes to this board policy before we transition to our next item to review okay hearing seeing on we'll move on a good discussion thank you everyone next item is 40 113 certificated personnel Mr um through the regular updates we get from aasb there was a recommendation uh for a slight change on this one it was under the United States code
021Title 20 um just updating the the name of that act uh it's no longer the No Child Left Behind Act but it's the every student succeed act so that's the one administrative change that we would recommend in this review cycle cont a question for Miss Grant when there's a citation change and update does that require a formal update in board vote in past press that is a good question I will research that okay we can we can vote on it I don't think it's a but the policy itself isn't changing and so um but really just a matter of updating the references to reflect the names of the current laws and so if we need to vote on that we certainly can but I also think it's reasonable and maybe we could get some guidance
022from ASB as to I'll reach out hows are handling it okay great so um any anything else on 4113 okay hearing sign we'll move on to 4115 evaluation and supervision difference between proficient and basic a question is Exemplar proficient basic or unsatisfactory I don't have those working definitions from do you think it means I mean to me in Danielson they are uh specifically defined and there are criteria tied to each of those designations for all 22 components that are part of evaluation standards um the expectation is that a teacher will be proficient anything below proficient is uh is something could potentially uh get a certificated person on the planet of grow their Planet the last time the evaluation system change I remember mle School Board they were they were asking uh principles for a or
023b option kind of thing and they said a and the superintendent said no it's B and they went forward I remember that but I remember hearing it from everybody before your time in fairness to the current superintendent but it was interesting and uh I'm just kind of curious there's been any changes since be more effective Danielson was adopted as the framework um when Ed graph was the superintendent so I can't place that specifically in a year but that was the last time we changed the audiation systems I think they did the ab type option and it's one of several that are preapproved by the state for us by school districts yeah nothing to do with this policy but nsba has really promoted the idea of getting feedback from multiple sources for the evaluation actually stud
024see assessment that's money and we're not going to talk about thank you Mr Lang I'm not hearing any suggested changes to 4115 we'll move on to our last policy to review as part of our trianal review portion of the meeting today 4116 Personnel C statutes and all that kind stuff puty much to it then because they get control they get involved real fast okay any proposed amendments or updates to this board policy hearing seeing none we will move on and complete our B1 item thank you Mr Lang and board members for good conversation our next topic is um AR 3515 access to secur camera footage as this is an ER I'm assuming Administration is leading the conversation here um and I think I actually received uh do remember an email now is this the item
025that we need to push for next month pushing till next month okay all right um and that's because the administration aren't here today who can speak on this yes okay great so then with the without any objection from the committee we're going to push this to our March meeting and then we'll move forward to a conversation on our board bylaws 9271 code of conduct um as a refresher this is something that um we began to take up at our last Retreat and the plan was over the next couple of months uh to take a a stab at continuing to uh provide updates um as board members want to do um uh want to discuss them and then the goal I think is to have a version adopted before we gble out for the end of
026the school year um so our last meeting I think is of June early June so we want to adopt it by then have that non-action status so we still have March April and May is governance meeting to get that ready for non-action status in late May um and then those will take effect um after our board reorganizes going into the next school year so we have two attachments on the agenda the first is the original and the second was the document that we left and ended with um after the retreat are there other changes that we want to discuss at this time member Higg I don't want to make any changes but I want to point out the 25 it says board members May request information from ASD staff that is readily available if the
027information is not readily available the staff may return the request to the superintendent as a request for information I think that's a very important issue because this has become a point of contention that we're dealing with that board members can be blocked from talking to certain staff members because it might disrupt them when this clearly gives the authority to the board superintendent uh to be able to make these contact get information I think what's missing here where there's an agreement here is that uh the process contacting them giving them contacting them giving them a chance what do we do if they feel uncomfortable putting language in like that may be appropriate I don't have a problem with that um and if the superintendent SAR that then disclosing that the bo M should accept that immediately
028uh within that that's F but I don't want anything that the administration would do to interfere with with this process so any comments or statements going out that reportedly has been shared with me uh would happen and but I want to also say is a void responsibility to notifi staff when possible in advance schedule time so it's not be disruptive to the to to ASD staff but that it won't be interfered with anything from the administration and uh they have the option backing I was thinking about this a little bit always been frustrating me 25 is to me explicit uh clear we have the right to do this and if no one has the right to say you can't talk to people because that would violate the policy but there's a there's two sides to
029this coin and I accept that don't want to be disruptive uh to them you want to give them advanced notice and if they're un comfortable let them bail out so I'm not sure how to put that language in there I just thinking about I was wake up sometimes dreaming about this stupid thing uh but I do feel like that may be something the administration may want to include in there as well how you feel about it Dr Bryant team any any additional thoughts since are Retreat on this item and how to make this something that accurately reflects our current practice um and how to best um ensure that we're respecting staff's time workload as well as getting information to the board of timely fashion um again I'm I'm ready to play ball to figure out
030a way to improve this process um just two questions listening to what member Higgins said I think um based off of what you share member hiin I think it sounds like you want the board to be able to go to staff members for questions around information and if it's readily available they would provide it directly to the board Absolut right okay the issue I'm trying to solve is how would I make sure that information is disseminated to other board members or are you saying that the readily available wouldn't need to go at all board it doesn't need to if I'm asking what does sbbs stand for you don't need to know that I don't know who knows it who does it but if anybody wants to know that that's fine uh if they want to
031get overview with that that's fine we're not providing good overviews of every Department I've got questions about uh contracts I have questions about facility that have questions about academic things uh if there's a question there that is uh something that's not you can't take off the shelf it's not there then then all the board members can't go get it because they all want to ask for the same question but it's readily available I've had times when I said well I got this document right here I give it to somebody walking off the street but because you're a board member I better give it through this system you have to request it to make sure everybody gets it if everybody can get it off the shelf if it's readily available you're going to prohibit us from
032having a discussion and I got to tell you my discussions with people I I have always follow-up questions when I'm talking to people and I'm not going to be able to get a question about well SPSS or SLC or something and I'm gonna say well what about what about what about I'm asking questions that are readily available anybody can go get it the public can get it um I follow question I don't know if I had a a breakthrough on this or not but to me readily available is the is a challenging term because I I think I think you alluded to it actually um it kind of that could be a moving Target if if that were changed to publicly available does that resolve um or just do you object to that well that
033publicly available can do a request a for you request and get everything but I understand where you want from I I look at that what does readily available mean um I look it readily available it doesn't require any research or anything else information any any any investment of work other than sharing you know that's uh already prepared kind of and to me to me that seems like a definition you can probably use it as a definition of publicly available as well yeah I don't have a problem with it being because the public has the right to come in and ask for readily available information with the exception that some people may say I don't you know I won't respond to the public I'm not going to tell them this I'm not you know formal meetings
034or something else because it's a Dr Bryant does does changing readily available the publicly available provide any additional Clarity because I in addressing remember why I was thinking of this is you know if a board member requests something that isn't publicly available um U but is data that that may be available to staff after some brief or significant amount of research I would value getting that too in case I have the question that comes up however if they want to know what spbs means I know I can find it out whenever I want to with or without staff assistance um and so I think if we change it to publicly available that provides a really fair bar of making sure that all board members get information that um they wouldn't be able to find out
035otherwise but then two um setting a clearer bar that's defined as to what staff should be expected to be able to be provided to board members upon request I don't know Dr Bry does that help at all yeah I think that solves um part of what member Higgins was sharing sometimes he just wants to get a definition that takes two seconds but I think the other piece though you mentioned you like the follow-up conversations and dialogue and thinking through scarios I don't know if that would be publicly available I think that would be more kind of a technical a consultation with the technical expert so that's where the line that that what you're describing goes past the line that member Jacob is sharing well but I guess the other thing I would I would ask
036for is if there's follow questions and I guess when I know I'm going to have follow questions on something I typically say ahead of the conversation do you have time for follow questions is if not when is a good time so that I'm not being short changed on my time to ask as many questions as I want and so I think if we tweak publicly available I think we get halfway there and then I think somewhere we need to acknowledge that if we have questions for staff we just need to find time on a calendar to do it versus um popping in and assuming that there's time because that might not be wise of our time or staff's time and given um resources are thinn all around I think that's probably the the best way
037to to proceed yeah I think that that that's Point number one I think the other thing that I think all board members should keep in mind really my only concern was about popping into offices you know unannounced hypothetically right because my issue is that there could be a situation where a board member enters someone's office or tries to just get routine information but from that staff memb perspective they may not see it that way that staff member doesn't know whether or not I asked the board member to go into the office they don't know what will happen if they don't provide the information I I think member Higgins has done a good fith effort to give them an option to let me know they feel uncomfortable but realistically speaking they're probably uncomfortable as they're providing
038information because of a perceived power indifference and that becomes even worse if they find out later that I didn't even know that that board member was in the office it creates all sorts of internal issues um and it could make police feel uncomfortable um hypothetical my concern is discouraging people though from talking to board members and if stuff is going out I'll make a request for that stuff's going out that's done that I I would want that disclos I don't want I want to make sure that board members and I don't think we need it in policy but I want to make sure board members are respectful when they come in and say i' like to schedule of time and you got uh you know uh that somebody is there and they say come on
039in I don't see a problem with that which you're asking for a time in the future uh but you're right the person may say well I'm here I got do it right away uh because it is a a power difference and I understand but I also know that sometimes you just need brief answers and follow-up questions like SP SPSS well what percentage how how many do you have any idea of how many schools have it that that's a follow-up question but that's publicly accessible as well so questions doesn't mean it's not publicly available but they may not spend the time with the public that they will with Schoolboard I agree would be we're being asked to make decisions and we got questions that are relevant to those decision makings and that you're trying to get
040it quick so when I'm asking a question rightsizing and be the Wednesday before we're going to vote and I'm being denied being able to have that type of conversation I view that is is it appears to be intentional it's disruptive uh and that's a concern to me I don't want that type of relationship to be happening again um so M if we could if you have the working draft up to make edits if we could replace readily available with publicly available into our um ongoing edited version uh for 25 that we can continue to have dialogue on and the board will eventually vote on and this committee will eventually um vote to uh at least recommend go to recommend um that we move it on to the full board that would be helpful I would
041mind something coming out from Andy just reminding look we're trying to do this this this without doing a policy just to be play because you're not going to say I won't talk to somebody I've run into hey you got ask questions and say oh we violated the policy I don't want to go over but I I think going out from Manny if you want to kind of lay some expectations for people in um the other the other thing I'll just note U is what I found with information that I think would either be publicly available or readily available is I've had the best and quickest response as a board member when I need something right away reaching out to the superintendent's office which includes um you know administrative staff that um it's usually Katie or
042America um that will get back to me I mean within minutes with the information I need or an indication that they will find the information and give back to me when they can um if it's something that's readily available and publicly available um and that's helped me out of Council meetings that's helped me prepare for uh meetings during the day and so that's something that and they will converse with the appropriate staff who they they can identify as being the right individuals to have that information and so that's something that I think as the board desires to work um smarter um something we should lean on because it's a great way to get information because we may not know we may not we may know what we need but we may not know where to
043get it from I tell you publicly available is anything that's not confidential I can make a point not publicly but that's actually much more information I think about I'm comfortable with it because it may be comfortable for other people um anything is publicly available that's not confidential if I may just add some clarity on the publicly available when I think publicly available I think something that's a record in our system that's factual it's on the website um discussions around things that are publicly available that you wouldn't get that with aoy request you would only get that if you were authorized to have a meeting with the technical expert it's a little bit all you know all there's a overlap between the two I understand yeah I I admit that the um my my view of
044publicly available isn't everything that's obtainable via a Freedom of Information Act request it would be um anything that that is that you could obtain through publicly available information that is present with without that request frankly um not the but a board member has um unique processes that the public doesn't um through the RFI process to obtain anything that requires research and so um I think collectively those two things cover um anything that could be made publicly available but um we don't have every piece of information that the district could produce is on the website for instance um notc you ask somebody just to share the information they know and the public be a to go and ask somebody to do it they could but the person may or may not spend the time to answer
045it so once again I'm open with it either way I think as long as we're not discouraging people from Talking the board members and make sure they know that well I I I think we may want to consider just putting that in the policy on some level too because I I don't think that's I and I'll speak for myself I don't think that's happening now um and I haven't seen any evidence that that has happened um and we don't want it to happen and so um but that that I don't think would would um would be mutually exclusive to a statement about us wanting to go through the appropriate processes that honor staff time um I think those two things can coexist um and so but we don't necessarily need to Workshop that today and
046we've got a few months but really the the goal was to open the floor for any quick changes and then if anyone brought language uh they wanted to add into this working document as we move forward in and outside of future committee meetings this is a great place to have that conversation um anything else on our code of conduct today knowing this is going to be coming back for future months okay hearing seeing none thank you for the conversation we'll move on to board bylaws 9320 meetings I admit that I'm not familiar with this item on our agenda m suvan is this something that a board member brought forward um no actually Katie and I would thought it would be a great idea to bring this forth because of the uh language it had in
047there for the time frame that it was released to the public um to meeting information which um got it so this is regarding I think our our current practice and and ask of board members is that um everything be attached to an agenda multiple days before a meeting and I think um a lot of it just has to be revised as well as there's a lot of outdated language in there um like telephonically um information for the meeting which we don't do anymore teleconference teleconferencing I'm sorry okay um so I agree that this could use some updates I don't have any updates ready to discuss today um is there a board member um who's interested in bringing forward an amendment to 9320 today if not we could hold this over for next month and we
048could have folks spring revisions if they so isues then I can work on kind of modernizing this board policy for bar V has there been any changes that the St meetings act I don't think so but I mean this thing the way it reads it always cracks me up it says anytime three board MERS present and collectively consider a matter the school board so as long as they're together and they're not talking about school issues so if we show up at an event with the everybody's showing up it's no big deal but I again I I'll say that I don't to the best of my knowledge I want to say I confirm it relatively recently the open meetings act hasn't been touched in recent years I think part of that because the legislature which would
049be the person the body to update it doesn't have to abide by it so it's not on their radar um which is fine um with that said though the when I read that that paragraph the first paragraph um you know it adds an additional qualifier in there which is to say that they collectively um consider a matter in which the school board is empowered to act um that tells me that board members can gather in a social Gathering and I I think I typically give the example of like a hockey game may be in the audience um watching um you know UAA play um but that doesn't mean that there's a open exact violation or we may be at the same um social Gathering or a a school function a school carnival Carnival for example
050and so I don't think that that's intended to say that I don't think it practices to consider that way I do believe that that language is straight yeah just for the record I believe the court has said this does apply to the legisl but they have to enforce it they don't they just the court so it's kind of fun that's really what the with the court rulings all matter to us okay so yeah I'll um I'll add this to my workload and commit to bringing back a more modernized version of this recognizing a good chunk of this um does fall under law um thank you Miss Sullivan and Miss gr for bringing this forward okay not hearing any other discussion we'll move on to board policy 1250 volunteer assistance um there's a revision here something
051was brought forward by a board member from Administration this is um a policy that came through from the a okay and it was reviewed by Tony Riley and uh Sven gson and the uh approved it coming forward okay we've got a revision here for the committee to take a look at you have a second for folks to digest and we'll see if there's any questions the only thing I would throw in here I know that there a lot of places to do it and I had to do it m but where uh when you have volunteers they still have to meet the same legal requirements to perform the work that if a volunteer does that a regular employee could do so if there's a um uh there's a b I'm trying to think of where
052this would be you obviously you see it a lot Medical but you see it also in schools if you got somebody performing a job that has state requirements for certifications they have to meet those obligations volunteers have to be checked background check for kids like the background check program applies to volunteers when they have uh control custody of kids as I understand the BCU um because I used to deal with it all the time so I don't know whether something like that I guess that could be H policy but from the background check point if they a background check to work kids deal directly classc and it requires for volunteers as well that's my understanding so I think the backround check program um is something that's operated from the the state of WKA Department of
053Health I think that that deed uses a different background check process yeah um but I don't know I don't know and I I believe and I'm trying to find a more policy I believe that lives somewhere else okay we can deal with it later I just thought that normally when you sometimes you see reference to that in the volunteer and it's not run through the HR function of the district it goes through Community engagement they have a volunteer assistant who verifies it does it performs those background checks on volunteers before they're cleared to working schools I just don't don't know where it lives in policy because it's not something I provide schools know that you have to get clear for back volunt that's all I we allow parents to sit in the classroom they don't
054have control C your kids when they doing watching show any other um propos changes or items to address with this update was driven by something ASB revision as well as feedback from St hearing and seeing none we um is there any objection from the committee or from board members present online um to sending this forward to the full board um and the president for replacement on agenda hearing saying none so done thank you Miss thank you Miss grants so we'll move on to our last item on our agenda which is VP 51311 bus conduct is this another aasb revision yes okay we'll get board members chance to digust this raise any questions and this one was reviewed by uh Mr Anderson and um I believe he's online if you do have any questions okay I
055know we've had issues in regards to kids dropped off their wrong places and all the ODS and and not having busers and to do with other people so I'm not sure but I don't think there's anything policy issue of BU conduct that would be relevant to that issue any um discussion before we close this one up um just real quick we already follow all of the federal and state laws so this a be revision um we didn't have any issues with this at all okay thank you Mr Anderson not hearing any any other discussions any objection from a Committee Member or a member of the board to sending this to the president for placement on a future agenda consideration by the hearing seeing none so done that is our last agenda item on our agenda
056today um our next upcoming meeting meetings are 32725 and 42425 member Higgins do you have a yeah we put new business for discussion we've got other audits out there and how we're going to process those other Audits and where we add on that is is we need to make sure Administration and governance is in agreement with we want those discussions about doing Human Resources uh we talked about uh special education and we talked about curriculum um but we haven't made any plans on how we forward with that who's handling what and I think that's important I think the the opportunity that whether we're contacting Council of great City Schools district the district normally is the one that has contacted in the past but we've had agreement over the scope before they did it and then
057we get engaged with the audit committee uh once they've done that I I I don't that problem at all we need to make sure that we got something going for we can get that done um Dr Bri is anyone online or yourself are you able to discuss the current status of administrative audits sure the most pressing one uh is the uh purchasing audit and the council City schools has agreed to present to the governance committee at the March governance meeting so that has been set and then from there the board can ask questions to the those who conducted the review and then we can go from there um Mar would you like to speak to the um health benefits overview that that will be session yeah so um we contracted with uh uh the erera
058group for the market analysis of both the ASD Health Plan and the PHD plan for our teachers um it has taken a little longer to work through some of the back and forth and agreements that need be in place in order to share sensitive health information um we finalized all that at the end of January they think they will have findings to us in early March and are on Deck we hope to present at work session uh to the full board after spring break at second meeting in March um and so that uh looking forward to that presentation so we have those two and then after the purposing audit and the the human resources benefits analysis are completed then do we have something else on that's next yes uh so the third one that's happening
059in parallel is the correspondence allotment review so Andy rless team is processing that that one's very um very detail oriented obviously you need to look at the expenses for the allotments and and make sure that we're following our policies and guidance um I do know that he is working on it I don't have an ETA for when the board will receive those findings but that would round out the three audits that the governance committee requested last spring and then I was I I think we need to discuss process moving forward so once these three audits are complete it was my assumption that then the governance committee would reconvene and decide um if and which additional audits they'd like to pursue um and that's I I'll say that's what I recall as well is that we
060decided on audit plan administratively at the start of the year and their goal was to get those three done and then reevaluate um remember you have a different recollection no I I think like said wanted to do two or three a year right now not get this time govern just to I just want to clarify just want to make sure we're on the same page Dr Bryan well is Administration on track before the end of the school year to complete the audit plan the board adopted at the start of the year I we should be so the purchasing for sure because that's March um health is scheduled tentatively pending Andy hollman's approval for the second work session in March um correspondence I don't have an ETA I I don't know why we wouldn't have that
061by the end of the year okay but I don't recall there being a deadline of a year to complete all three audits that's the part I'm missing from the conversation okay well I I'll admit that it was maybe my understanding that we would adopt an audit plan annually so I think the assumption is before fall when I think we I think we adopted our last plan in August or September meeting um that we adopted a plan for the following year so maybe it's not um you know August to June it might be September to September but I I think the goal at least my understanding was there would be a plan that's adopted every 12 months and that 12 month period in theory we could complete those items I suppose we could carry something over
062if it's significant um that was my understanding I think yeah I think what's going to happen is we'll get the findings from these Audits and some may require a lot of changes to how we do business right so I think from there I would like the board to be sensitive to the fact that to implement the new recommendations on top of three additional audits will create work workf challenges so I don't know if it it should be three every year but once the three are done let I want the board's direction as to should we focus on these findings and um following through on the audits or do we want to add additional audits in addition to resolving how is it really an audit you're going out from being with consultant with that audit something
063that most business is do every two to three years anyway so I don't view that I view that just administrative process that's always going by every business so I don't you you did the you brought somebody in last year to look at that not this year it came out with now you're using a to go out there Bally that's done by you you got that they do for you I'm not sure why it's okay but that's a little bit odd that's usually you're already paying for that so we're paying twice that's not an audit okay compliance type reviews administrative is an oversight to make sure things are being run right so we run to audits which is really looking to see whether or not our efficiency that policy somebody Council comes in and looks at
064it so I view that we're doing one audit this year with the government right now that's all last year we did one but it got we didn't come out from us Tak by Administration so we haven't got Anye one issue I think I would just clar by that I think this isn't um we this this board and a committee meeting agre to the plan that goes through next fall I don't I mean I I don't think this is a new conversation we break ground on I think it was already agreement on the plan for this year and I think there was those three topics that were addressed um you know purchasing um on health benefits and then on I mean whether or not we want to call them on or something else we agreed to
065ask Administration to look into these three topics during the 204 25 school year and I we have another opportunity as we get gather back together in August to address how we want to handle other administrative I know that I I want let us come in with a AUD committee recomendation to do that and if we can put that on the agenda next time we try to have something drafted that yeah as soon as I get as soon as there's something drafted please get it to me we'll take a look okay um all right um that that completes our agenda for today we will end our governance meeting at 12:01 pm thank you