CorpusRecord 40161

January 14, 2025 - 11am Regular Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / LAUSD Board Meetings
Date
2025-01-15
Location
Los Angeles County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
66,854 words · about 372 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e okay good morning the time is now 11:06 welcome to the January 14th 2025 meeting regular meeting of the Los Angeles Unified School District Board of Education I'm going to go ahead and take role and so we can establish Quorum uh Miss nuel present president Dr Ras present Mr melvoin here president uh Miss Grio here miss miss gones here miss Ortiz Franklin Believe Miss Franklin is remote I saw her earlier we'll come back to uh take her attendance when here and board of president schroen president and student member GES Lopez here here okay so we have a quorum all right shall we do the Pledge of Allegiance yes okay please please stand put your right hand over your heart ready begin thanks all we'll now move to board presidents reports which the first

002portion is labor Partners I know we have some labor Partners here I want to remind everybody there about a f minute time limit for labor Partners um is Miss Nichols here miss Maria Nichols I think I see you you want to come on up first all right here she comes and after Miss Nichols I believe uh Miss parish is here or signed up to speak I don't yet see her in the audience um and I believe we also have a member of utla who will be speaking so uh first Miss Nichols and then we'll ask for Miss Parish again and then a utla representative thank you everybody for coming today we appreciate your patience particularly with the logistics um for those watching we have a very full boardroom right now so all right the five

003minutes is yours Miss Nichols thank you so much thank you good morning uh superintendent carvalo and distinguished board members first of all I want to start off with uh thanking you Mr smaron for ensuring that our Alla Teamsters 2010 initial proposals were included in today's agenda please feel free all board members U members of the public if you have any questions I will certainly I'm here and you are able to reach out first I want to start off by um stating the obvious that uh our city has just gone through a tremendous crisis and I want all to know that all the LAUSD family members that are going through some very challenging times right now we they are in our thoughts they are in our hearts um Allah Teamsters 2010 has established a relief fund

004and we are currently ensuring that we have list of our employees and our folks that would benefit from any support that we can give them and I know that the district is also looking at ways to support I want to start off also by thanking and bringing a tremendous amount of gratitude for our LAUSD employees especially my unit J facilities classified members my administrators my school support administrators my directors the region Ops coordinators cpms who worked tirelessly to ensure that our schools were open today cleaned with safety measures in place and that um the school opening yesterday went smoothly they deserve great gratitude and thanks for the work that they did over the crisis and putting themselves In Harm's Way uh for what they did for our city and our students it's just a testimony

005of how our employees always Step Up and come together to do the right thing for students and communities I want to talk a little bit about what occurred on Wednesday uh with waking up to the fires and driving down Silmar I live in Valencia so driving down Silmar that morning we hear that the district's top priority is safety and that day we struggled with that statement the city's largest tragedy was a bit mishandled with the lack of communication communication systems for administrators who received no information schools opening during state of emergency city leaders asking for people to stay offroads and remain at home electrical lines down power outage led to disastrous condition to even make it to work disastrous conditions for staff and children arriving at schools what schools experienced that morning and in what

006I received for my principles at sites where that trees were down there was no power there were no phone lines there was a high number of absences as folks were dealing with personal crisis so there was insufficient staff folks were dealing with loss of dwellings or evacuations across the city of Los Angeles early closures added to an already unstable situation have hazardously created a chaotic and Scramble for students and families and staff to do the right thing for safety of students LAUSD employees parents and communities it took a coalition of Labor partners with a demand to close schools the rest of the week due to safety air quality concerns that should not have been we trust on the district leadership to work under ambiguous situations like we do at school sites and we trust on

007you to make judgment and decisions holistically thinking about all including all our employees because we all matter classified certificated we need to think of LAUSD as a huge family because we work and live across the city of Los Angeles the lack of communication organization and just Humanity we felt were sacrificed for an image that has been uph holded or upheld through social media posting and press conferences I understand that social media and press conferences are important but not at the time of crisis at the time of crisis a leader stands with their people there is a serious concern right now moving forward and what we ask of you are three things one please establish an emergency task force within the district this is not the first time our great city has gone through crisis for

008God's sake we lived through a pandemic I was a dor at that time responsible for 21 schools I ask that you really analyze and examine the actions that were taken or lack of actions that were taken during this crisis and learn from them and create systems of communication and transparency for all the one thing that I have learned and over my 38 years in La USD and 24 years as a leader is that when there is is people need to know what's going on it gives people comfort and it gives people hope and optimism that together we will move forward it is a critical system to develop and the last thing I ask as we go and enter into negotiations with our different labor Partners work is work and people need to be compensated for

009what they do currently there's a lack of parody between our labor partners and I am actively reaching out and working and connecting with my labor partners because we have a responsibility to do the right thing for all our employees it doesn't make sense to me for some folks to get a $100 stien and others not to get anything that makes no sense that shows no Humanity on our end and it shows a lack of caring of caring for the people that are doing the most important work so I look forward to working with you I look forward to continuing to work with my labor partners and I also want to extend gratitude for my principles because they are the ones and they are the hearts of this District in the communication with parents and ensuring

010that they work and support their teachers who then the teachers have to come in with a very calm and and confident and secure way to support our students think of our students in the transition that this last week and in the last couple of weeks and this is a time to really show leadership demonstrate humanity and P pay people Fair wages across our labor unions thank you very much thank you for your time Miss Parish are you here m Franny Parish okay are there any other is there member of utla who would like to come and speak hi I guess I don't know you my name is CES Myer Cruz I'm the utla president nice to meet you I'm Michael McLean great all right before I get started I actually want to say um my

011heart our hearts go out to all the families who have been affected by this devastating tragedy it's there are no words so I want to say that to our community because right now our community is hurting and um they need some love in all the ways that we can possibly do that we started a uh assessment of our members um and 10% of our members have put forward information and um 550 of our utla members have been displaced as of 3 p.m. yesterday 550 148 have had a total loss and more information is still coming in one of the people displaced is uh my good friend will here um and uh families just broken apart not only in the Palisades but also in the eaten fire in Altadena and Pasadena our folks live all over

012the city because our folks can't live where they work and so this tragedy affects everyone and I wanted to state that right from the top and also thank every single employee who has tried to put this together in some kind of sense and I am really standing with you so I am cesley Meer Cruz uh the president of United teachers Los Angeles and I want to talk about my disappointment and I've had times of Rage um over the course I've spoken to some of y'all um but I stand here in disappointment and frustration and urgency uh coming you to you today speaking on behalf of 38,000 educators of La USD but our school communities once again when faced with a crisis District leadership failed failed failed to move proactive AC l or consider the safety

013and health of the community a response unacceptable and inadequate for the nation's second largest District after the delays in decision making that we saw this week from the district and after once again seeing and hearing the voices of parents students Educators education workers folks on the ground doing the work they were ignored it should come as no surprise to anyone that United teachers Los Angeles is announcing our intent to Sunshine our collective bargaining agreement with LAUSD and for some reason it was left off the docket I can get into that later we sent a letter last week on Thursday January 9th notifying The District in accord with the education employment Relations Act to our demand to bargain a successor agreement utla's agreement with LUSD expires this summer and we will not wait quietly while our

014schools Educators and Community continue to be left unsupported and unprioritized this past week itself is not the reason why nor what prompted it but it remains a reflection and yet another example of District's leadership lack of communication and failures to consider the needs physical mental health and safety of our entire School communities the district continues to hold on to more than $6 billion dollar in reserves enough to pay Educators fairly enough to maintain safe healthy environments enough to provide the resources our students need excuses don't hold up when we see money sitting there while it could be invested in our students our classrooms our schools and the people who work there every day it is about priorities it is about compassion we talk about pillar two as the joy and wellness pillar I I'm not

015seeing that it's about basic human imp empathy and caring about the needs of the people you serve pillar five investing in your staff and as demonstrated this week in those Realms the district is failing us the district time and time again demonstrates to Los Angeles that we can't wait it's up to us along with our colleagues and Union siblings and here up and down the state to win our vision for the future of our schools utla members are committed to fighting for educator recruitment retention and support through better access to mental Wellness supports Equity across positions protection of educator rights increase salaries to attract and retain Educators support for new Educators with additional investment in bipac multilingual and immigrant Educators smaller class sizes smaller case loow ratios support for special education fully staffed schools including

016AIDS custodian and more support for students parents and school communities through increased investment in Community Schools protection and expansion of the black student achievement plan and ethnic studies more support for students mental health more support for immigrant students and newcomers English language Learners lgbtqia plus students and staff students and families facing homelessness especially in light of this newest disaster campus safety through support and not criminalization free Early Education for all support for College and Career preparation healthy and clean green Public Schools including clean and Safe Drinking Water facilities upgrades green spaces shade and playgrounds on every school campus programs and policies for environmental justice climate resilience and yes proactive procedures for disaster preparedness this platform of Demands is so much more it's our message that the status quo is unacceptable and we will continue to

017fight for what is right the schools our students and communities deserve because we can't wait thank you for your time are there any other labor Partners present okay that concludes labor Partners you have a statement yes we uh do not have any committee reports but we do have our student board member report beginning now and going on forever so that's a new feature of our board meeting go ahead please I'm sorry I got to jump in really quick uh Miss Ortiz Franklin has been here for about 15 minutes remotely and I just want to get a chance to call her for the roll call so got it good morning good morning okay thank you present all right she's present thank you board president sharlon I would like to begin by extending my deepest gratitude to

018my peers who have once again shown their resilience in these unprecedented times my peers show an inspiring sense of unity and desire to help others in their times of need which goes to show of one of the biggest things my peers have taught me is that in times of adversity our strength lies in our Unity I've witnessed extraordinary acts of kindness and support within our Leu family particularly within our own student population donations volunteer efforts and peer-to-peer care I am proud of my fellow students for finding different Avenues and promoting resources on social media to ensure that those affected by the fires receive the resources that they need I and many I and many of my fellow peers have volunteered to support those in need and it is again absolutely inspiring and in times like

019these it is vital for our students to know that we see them hear them and stand with them student leaders representing our multiple student advisory councils shared with me comments that fall under four main categories of need following these unprecedented events these categories include health and safety issues need for temporary housing educational disruptions and mental health challenges to begin students have reported widespread poor air quality around their campuses causing respiratory issues like coughing and Asthma flareups they appreciate having upto-date air purifiers and recommend changing those existing filters in those classrooms regularly for educational disruptions power outages school closures and unsafe air quality have impacted attendance and academic performance students suggested flexibility and deadlines extensions for assignments and online learning options for those affected by the fire and for students with under underline health conditions that

020were made worse with the poor air quality following this are our students mental health challenges many students are experiencing heightened anxiety due to the evacuations and uncertainty about school schedules emotional distress has been particularly impactful on students in our impacted areas what they recommend is amplifying the district's multitude of resources since many students and family are not aware of the student and Family Wellness hotline it is recommended Ed to continue advertising this tremendous resource our students are overall seeking empathy and a chance to be heard as a student from Belmont Senior High shared for me it is very mentally daunting to think about it I think having these open conversations fully open and honestly and truly listening to the needs of the students would be most helpful today more than ever I believe in the

021power of Youth advocacy and resilience our students comments reflect their dedic ation to uplifting one another in these unprecedented times and ensuring that their voices are heard that concludes the student board member report thank you board president Schon and thank you very much and we look forward to more reports at each board meeting thank you so much thank you so before we start our meeting uh several of the board members including myself have comments to make about the LA county fires and I'd like to start with our superintendent for his comments thank you very much much uh president Schon uh I'll try to be rather brief but a lot has happened over the past uh over the past week let me begin as the previous speakers Did by acknowledging thanking appreciating the hard work uh

022done not only by our Workforce who under difficult conditions not only shut down schools inspected schools cleaned schools readed schools for a reopening bringing some degree of normaly to very unstable Community conditions I also would like to acknowledge and and appreciate the contributions of First Responders across the community even yesterday in the Palisades during our second visit to that Community to survey the damage sustained by three of our schools it was evident uh that schools were a priority of First Responders I'd like to start uh by describing I also want to thank the board and your support and vision and concern for our Workforce our students and families doing very very difficult and unstable times I'd like us to go back to uh Tuesday night and then very quickly look ahead to what Wednesday morning

023looked like this District going back to 2021 has had a set of guidelines and protocols specific uh to fires and high winds this uh this set of guidelines this guide which basically dictates the steps the procedures to be taken in a proactive manner I'm going to admit upfront failed to work adequately considering the conditions that our community was experiencing this guide was developed after 2021 set of fires and this guide actually contemplated a single event maybe with wind or no wind the guide and by the way this is consistent with level of Readiness and response that fire departments Municipal entities calfire uh have declared at no point has there ever been a level of preparation for three four five or six simultaneous fires with hurricane level strength winds with a degree of instability and wind

024shifts that were hard to predict so Tuesday night after reviewing all of the protocols monitoring evolving conditions as late as 11:00 at night uh the protocols and the factors that are prescribed for us to monitor appear to be stable our last conversation as a district team particularly individuals in the Emergency Operations Center were looking at the containment level of fires distance of fires from impacted school areas looking at air quality indices and air quality dashboard is the most important element we look at and they were all moderate to good at that point there was nothing that we were looking at any advice at that time regarding imminent danger to schools at 4:00 5:00 in the morning things significantly changed in fact we began to see that amazingly and surprisingly air quality concerns were real on

025the eastern part of our district according to the guide when air quality concerns reach a threshold of 300 the shutdown of the schools impacted takes place that was the first action I remember driving into the downtown area early that morning and what the dashboard was revealing was inconsistent with what I was seeing and breathing and that is a true admission we began to hear from principles in in areas throughout our community in some instances far away from the fire saying we see the dashboard for the guide actually tells principles to look at the dashboard but then look at conditions in and around their schools and what people were observing and feeling was inconsistent with the data that the dashboard was revealing so we decided to air again on the side of caution this did create

026a degree of communication hindrance we decided last minute to go from a threshold of 300 as far as the air quality index to 200 therefore having to notify a lot more schools than previously notified we know that this was a burden that this was after our Workforce committed Workforce in many instances had already beg traveling to school arrived at the school and yes in some instances students students in schools impacted by this secondary shutdown but we felt that based on what we knew that we did not know hours earlier we needed to do it that the 300 air quality index threshold was not adequate and that was the air quality threshold that was in the books that represented the problem and represents a problem so we made the second announcement resulting in the late notification

027of some school communities we understand that and it is regrettable but we decided to do it I'll be it late because it was necessary we began immediately looking at other criteria that should be looked at beyond what was prescribed in this fire response and preparation guide and it was very clear that air quality index alone was insufficient the model that that dashboard reveals We Believe breaks down when you have three four five six fires simultaneously happening the model that the county is currently relying on for those decisions is inadequate so the idea of having an entity a group that looks at all of the measures all of the data all of the conditions all of the factors is one we already began the days that followed we expanded the level of consideration to take into

028account not just air quality index by region by area but also a whole host of additional factors such as number of fires level of containment propagation wind speed wind direction yes air quality indices across all of Los Angeles we kept being mystified by by the fact that the County's air quality dashboard continue to indicate that the vast majority of areas within our jurisdiction the air quality was decent that was mysterious and mystifying to us so we began incorporating into our decision-making process a whole host of other factors that's what led us to uh notifying the community that Thursday and then subsequently Friday would be shutdown days for for the entire School District conditions Friday Saturday and Sunday improved significantly in terms of direction of winds in terms of containment of fires in terms of air

029quality conditions throughout the community putting is in a position by Sunday to actually uh bring students in the workforce back but not before taking measures to inspect School sites and I am once again grateful to the workforce members who did so inspect work sites ensure that filters in HVAC systems would be replaced if needed accurately time on those or date those filters to ensure their subsequent replacement may be in advance of the quarterly replacement which is the decay of replacement of filters we also decided to do a number of things specific to at the workforce the preliminary data and I heard just a bit ago a new number of individuals impacted by evacuations and loss of homes uh during the weekend we had that number just below 400 uh distric white specific to evacuations based

030on the address of record that we have within our system we recognize that there may be some inaccuracy specific to that information but we knew that it was a significant number we decided immediately with the support of this board to provide 5 days beginning with 5 days of flexible time paid days for these individuals to normalize their lives also working with a foundation we decided to provide an initial stipend provided to every Workforce member impacted by evacuations we'll be making additional announcements based on the availabil of resources uh to us we partnered with a number of agencies to provide mental health support and emotional support not only to our family students but also our Workforce based on a recommendation from labor we initiated a process of Buddy assistance individuals who may have capacity in their

031own homes to temporarily house other needy families all of those efforts are ongoing we're in aggressive conversations with Sacramento and federal entities to wave requirements and obtain the necessary resources to further expand and augment financial support to the impacted Workforce we're paying uh constant attention also to what we're hearing we know the reality specific to substitute uh employees whether they are certificated or classified and taking measures to alleviate the burden on them I believe we'll be increasing the 5 days to a new number that will be announced fairly soon after discussions with the board and members of Labor as well for the need will continue for days and weeks to come conditions over the past uh couple of days including today um have been stable in our district as far as school conditions are concerned

032but we know that for families impacted for members of the workforce impacted this is a new day in a different world I want to speak specifically about U the Palisades we had two elementary schools that sustained immense damage one completely destroyed one the Legacy building a small building probably intact very old building but its resilience uh survived the fire but the vast majority of the classrooms burned to the ground Palisades High charter 30% sustained damage as a result of the fire this impacts close to 3,800 students we've made accommodations to accommodate those students for the students in schools that we directly manage at nearby schools and tomorrow will be the very first day back in the secondary sites we decided to move these students and the workforce as a unit not fragmenting or facturing the

033school unit so all students from Palisades Elementary will travel together all students from Marque Elementary we will travel together it's important for kids to be with our colleagues to be with our trusted teachers support personnel and principles I am grateful for the Fantastic work that M School staffs did in preparing the accepting schools to receive these students I am thankful for the quick pivoting for continuity towards continuity of learning digital content that we were able to achieve for all students in the district I am grateful for the Extraordinary Measures that have been taken by the seven schools that continue to be shut down as a result of mandatory evacuation orders I know these are not easy times and I know that considering the unpredictability and what has been said and repeated time and time again

034the unprecedented nature of this crisis nothing like this of this magnitude has ever happened in this community or across the country so no doubt there will be plenty of time and opportunity and we commit to that to re-evaluating every single process including communication protocols which I agree were late based on rapidly changing early morning conditions Wednesday morning we did the best we could in pivoting quickly but not without some degree of inconvenience and certainly delayed communication we are grateful over the fact that not withstanding the challenges people Rose to the occasion and safely evacuated schools and then safely return students and families back to the normaly that schools bring I have been to a number of schools over the past couple of days and I've seen the heroic efforts of individuals at work in preparation

035but also as they resumed instruction with their students the last point I'd like to make is one that reflects the urgency of sources from state and federal entities with the changing Administration in the near future we are working aggressively with the current Administration and will work with the future Administration in landing the necessary femo reimbursements for all our efforts that includes the rebuilding the Reconstruction of the schools impacted that includes the battle pay the necessary pay that our Workforce needs and deserves in light of the additional work during difficult times they perform formed that includes the cost associated with relocation that includes the improvements to air ventilation systems and equipment that has been deployed and will continue to be acquired we will push these individuals to their best in terms of delivering the resources to

036our community last point I want to thank the parents and families for their resilience their determination and their patience empathy love and compassion understanding is something I've heard and I believe in the initial hours of this crisis because of their unpredictability were difficult to navigate we pivoted as quickly as we possibly could based on the changing nature of conditions since that time Thursday Friday the weekend and now Monday and Tuesday we've reached a new level of normaly that our community needs We Stand ready to continue to follow science and data based on all the factors available to us not just those initially prescribed under previous protocols considering the fact that this is the new normal specific to this type of Crisis we will pivot quickly improve communication protocols and fight alongside our labor leaders our

037Workforce in obtaining the necessary resources to provide for all of those who stand and in times of adversity and challenge we will do a postmortem that will be accurate transparent and deep in terms of what must be done better based on what we've learned as a result of this crisis without precedent I speak with Mayors Fire Chiefs um individuals in Emergency Operations at the city and the county they have all struggled with the unpredictability and prec in nature volatile and unstable conditions that they all faced this is a new day a day that had never been experienced before in the history of our community our state or our nation one additional point we are working with state and federal entities in seeking the appropriate waivers whether they deal with attendance funding whether they deal with

038red tape bureaucracy to expedite all efforts to rebuild schools but also instill stability in the workforce and we have commitments from the Governor from the state superintendent and many others that the appropriate relief as far as legislation and policy will be provided to our district alongside a promised $2.5 billion doll in committed revenues to bring La back to a sense of normaly will be fighting for our fair share here out of that initial promise made by Governor Nome so members of the board thank you for your leadership to the workforce we understand and feel the confusion caused by impr precedented conditions we also appreciate the hard work that was done in the aftermath in terms of restoring normaly and conditions appropriate to return students the workforce and families back to our schools we know that

039when you reactivate 1,000 schools there will be one-offs we continue to aggressively look at circumstances conditions in a very small number of schools that may not necessarily reflect the the actions we took districtwide we have identified a team to respond specifically to those cases and there are a handful of schools that have declared some additional needs and we are ready to provide assistance with that said Mr President thank you very much for the opportunity to provide some degree of information regarding what we all have experienced over the past 5 days and I thank you uh Mr superintendent I also have a statement to make we we we must show our love and our appreciation for all of those people who have helped us during this crisis so to the entire Los Angeles community on behalf

040of the LAUSD governing board I would like to convey my deepest sympathies to those who the recent wildfires in our County have significantly impacted we are your neighbors we are your friends and we feel the pain of those who have lost their homes their livelihoods and even some their lives our message is also a statement of gratitude for the brave men and women on the ground who helped during this difficult time we thank the firefighters who call Los Angeles home and even those who come from different counties and different States and different countries and we thank the incarcerated firefighters battling these fires you are our heroes and we will never forget what you are doing to save our communities we thank the police officers who have assisted Us in evacuations guiding citizens to safety hold

041on to our most profound appreciation the doctors the nurses the hospital Personnel also deserve much recognition to our L USD staff workers who have come through time and time again the cafeteria managers and the cafeteria staff plant managers and b& workers all those people working at the Grab and go program the office of emergency management all essential staff who have assisted during this emergency because of you la USD continues to fulfill its mission for communities finally a thank you to to all of our students and parents for working with us during this challenging time my responsibility as board president as well as the responsibility of all of us board members will always be the safety and the well-being of our students parents and staff many families have been affected by these fires and will continue

042to be affected in the coming years however as a school district we are ready to advocate for you and your needs you are not just a constituent you are our family you are our friends and you are our neighbors this is the time for us to come together as a community we will get through this together and over the past few days I've seen people volunteer to help at shelters and I was at moland Middle School to see the food program being distributed and what a wonderful site that was others have donated their time their supplies or their money it serves as a reminder that when a community comes together it's not just a simple donation they are providing hope they are providing relief please continue to monitor local instructions and check the LAUSD website

043if you're looking for resources Los Angeles you are our home so stay safe and in community the Los Angeles Unified School District governing board thanks you I let not move over now to Mr melvoy who Board District Four for has really really been impacted and I have to say when I see you at our emergency meetings I can tell how it's wearing on you and I felt very bad you can see right in his face how horrible this was for him so go ahead Mr melne thank you uh board president smon for your kindness and your words and thank you superintendent as well and I I do want to start by thanking my colleagues on the board in the district for their outpouring of support to me and our team and our community and our

044district um I would say it's been an unimaginable week but I think as Educators you know you all possess a well and a reservoir of empathy to uh to imagine what a horrible week it's been and and not only need to and there's not even a need to imagine because we're living it our teachers our students our uh our staff our neighbors I mean as the whole region continues to Grapple with these fires I want to acknowledge the immense challenges so many of our families are facing and my thoughts with every family who's navigating the weight of this moment and especially those who uh remain displaced who have lost their homes in this devastating crisis many of which uh are in my district in the Palisades we have faced many crisis um together throughout my

045tenure on the board but this past week my team and I have been navigating the devastation not just as a board office but as neighbors my parents evacuated to my home this week and are safe my district director friend and colleague Allison holdorf pohill is among the many families who lost their homes their cars possessions we know we have other District staff who have also lost their homes both in the Palisades and Altadena and Pasadena I also am acknowledging and want to thank our board colleague um and a Schoolboard member from Pasadena uh Patrice who is here and we are thinking about you and Pasadena and La unified opens our our heart and our um physical doors if needed to you as well uh and to your colleagues and and family and friends uh I

046don't think there's a single person in LA right now who doesn't know at least one person who has lost everything and the magnitude of the destruction is staggering uh and when schools are so often lifelines in times of Crisis it's especially heartbreaking that we've lost two of our elementary schools among the damages in the palates fire but as staggering as the devastation has been uh it has been outmatched by the outpouring of support and community and partnership and love and action that I've seen in the last week and so a few words of thanks one as the superintendent mentioned you know a week ago today I was sitting up in my office seeing smoke come in from the west side and by tomorrow morning at 8:00 a.m. we will have new school communities for the

047kids at P elementary and at Marquez Elementary and not just seats for them in La unified but they will be with their classmates and their teachers and their principal relocated fully as a school community in nearby elementary schools and that is thanks to the Herculean effort of this district and the teachers and the staff who worked overnight I was at those sending schools almost every day over the last few days and it's remarkable the teachers at Brentwood science magnet in noris der who came in over the weekend to move their classroom so that the displaced schools can be together and feel as one Community their principal who is hosting uh this new school Community the Marquez and pal elementary teachers who were also there over the weekend setting up their classrooms even as they are

048uh weighing the displacement and the loss of their school Marquez I will say in particular it's amazing I met you know at least a dozen teachers who went to that school themselves as students met one teacher who is an Alum whose daughter is a teacher's aid there she went there she went to p and this is a community that's rallying around one another and so the teachers for their flexibility and the school staff just thank you uh to the for the district support of P High P high is an independent Charter but it's on District property and it's also the resident School given its conversion uh status and I want to thank H UniFi we've been on calls over the course of the last few days with Hino and facilities and HS and others to

049think about how to get that campus up and running as soon as possible and to find the 29 900 students at P High one of the largest high schools in Los Angeles uh a temporary location uh the donations of clothes food essential items toys home items everything people could think of for families who have lost everything have been pouring in not just from LA but around the state and the country uh our grab and go sites that helped get food uh to families who had as we had to keep schools closed the parents at some of my nearby elementary schools who have organized drives to get new school supplies for the students and teachers whose classrooms burned the district custodian employees who tirelessly worked to get schools safely open this week and who are there

050in the middle of the night and over the weekend with air filters masks and more to our school police officers who have been escorting District Personnel uh through the through the region and protecting property and people uh they've been absolutely heroic and a huge thank you to our school police force you know I've been seeing one of my my favorite Mr Rogers quotes circulating the internet over the past few days and that's look for the helpers You'll Always Find people helping uh and I think La unified is a place to start if you're looking for people helping and so I'm immensely grateful to all the helpers from staff to parents Community Partners everyone just jumping in asking what can I do um thank you for your kindness and support as we continue to meet and

051overcome the moments of these crisis I know it sounds trait but I think crisis can bring out the best of us I've seen it in LA unified I've seen it in these teachers and their kids um and you know throughout my tenure on the board folks often ask you know how how do we stay so optimistic and a world that seems uh so chaotic at times and I think it's when you spend time with young people and our students you can't help but be optimistic uh their resilience is inspiring and and you know they've helped get me through the crisis of the last seven or eight years uh and it's our time to stand up for them so thank you uh to the district for its incredible response to the teachers and and Educators who

052are working with these kids and to my colleagues and we'll get through it uh and uh you know I just appreciate the opportunity to to share some some thoughts and also to really thank everyone for helping lift Board District 4 through the last week thank you Mr meloine any other board members Miss Rosio um first of all you know my heart does go out to um Board District 4 and all of the families that um lost everything and the devastation and Palisades I have been non-stop watching the news and the fires and just um it's just really heartbreaking the devastation and the suffering that's taking place but what I do see in our community in Los Angeles and surrounding communities is the love the humanity as we reach out and the donations and the funds

053and all that beautifulness of us as humans as we comfort and let everyone know that you are not alone and um I want to thank uh from the bottom of my heart all the principles the admins the certified classified all the employees who in the middle of an evacuation while students were there they were on it I went to several of my schools within my neighborhood and I saw such togetherness uh making sure that all students were taking care of they were calling parents yes there was a lot of confusion um I called it um organized chaos there was a lot of chaos but it was organized um and and I saw um a lot of love for our students so I want to thank everyone in the middle of this you know situation that

054unprecedented as it uh as we are experiencing it coming together for the protection and the health and safety of all of our students and the families as well I also want to bring I want to thank anelli um our School Board member Miss Cortez Lopez to mentioning that um the voice of the students which is very much important a lot of our students were triggered by this because they were triggered by covid and what happened in the isolation and the fear and and the anxiety and the stress so right now if anything we really want to take care of our mental health the mental health of all of us because this was very triggering I know it was for me um and you know seek resources come you know ask for help you know our

055mental health is is so important um so reach out for one another take you know the mental health resources that the district has put forward um through you know social media and through the website please reach out and it's okay to say you were scared it's okay to say you were stressed out and not knowing what's going to happen um I know we all received that alert that that was sent mistakenly to everyone in Cal in in LA and when I saw it my son and I our heart just stopped I was like oh my God what's going to happen and we had our bags ready we had everything ready and you know um it was s by mistake but even then we were all triggered in the moment what's going to happen what are

056I I take care of you know my cats my pets or everything is just a moment that it's just um just very scary and so please your children parents talk to your children teachers I know that's what they're doing right now in their classrooms is is checking in um having discussions and um that's very important so thank you our Schoolboard member for being that voice and I do appreciate that because we must um hear that and for my staff you know we were on it we went to our schools and um making sure that everybody was you know had the required um supplies and I know everything is not perfect but we will get everything that you need as soon as possible I know that throughout the weekend we had staff um the cleaning crews

057that were out there and just working really hard and I want to thank them so much for making sure that our schools are as prepared as possible and uh we yes this District must reevaluate those policies that were not um add more to uh the pro the procedures and the factors that must take be taken into consideration um and clear communication and um and I know as I say this for our board members this district will do better because we will make sure that this District does better for everyone involved um so just um just wanted to say a few words and just thank you thank you to everyone and moving forward we will continue to be resilient together in solidarity and this district will continue to take care of our family thank you thank

058you Dr Ras before we go to Kelly gones uh Mr superintendent what is the best way for people to donate to the district thank you for the question so the most effective way is direct donations to the uh to LD Foundation it is an independent Foundation is of direct support to our school district I can tell you that we're receiving a lot of love and resources from across the country uh CIA creative uh artist agency just made a major announcement that they're rallying the Hollywood Community to donate to us and calfire efforts a number of private sector entities National foundations are doing the same and the revenues are coming in fact when I spoke about the Investments we're making uh in in terms of financial support to the impact of the workforce members that are

059coming Direct out of that fund the funds are being provided for this purpose are categorical uh exclusively for the benefit of those impact and meaning we're not going going to use these resources for any other purpose it's not for arts or music those are important but this is the crisis at the moment so easiest way go on lusd.org there's a button there to redirect you directly to the foundation and you can make a donation online or initiate a communication with Foundation entities for ex exptic contributions thank you let's go to miss GGO right now thank you um f so thank you uh first I want to extend by condolences to all of those who have experienced loss I think that almost everyone knows somebody and uh I see Will here and I want to extend

060my condolences to you will and your family um one of my colleagues that I worked with at mallister high school texted me at 2:30 that she was evacuating and in the morning let me know that her house was gone so it's very close to many of us we've all we're all feeling it and I want to thank everyone today who showed up our labor Partners who shared their experiences the experiences of their members and also for your assessment of how this situation was handled as your board member for all constituents and as part of this team that makes decisions for the whole District your experience and your feedback is very important and it certainly impacts how we advocate for you I encourage you to continue sharing it I want to thank our student rep twice

061I've heard her speak and she speaks so beautifully and so eloquently about the needs of our students you always speak to not just the academic supports that our students need but all the social emotional well-being that it is our duty to provide for our students and I thank you for that and I know that there are a lot of needs right now both material and emotional and I want you to know that I will continue to advocate for support for our employees and for our students that are just and fair that are empathetic and that are compassionate and that honor the experience you are having right now and I also want to thank our employees who were out there cleaning our schools some who also went Educators who went over the weekend I heard I

062didn't know this but I heard they were there on the weekend preparing um some may not know that on Tuesday night our schools were still open and we had employees working including our night custodians who were out there trying their best to keep our schools clean under those very strong winds and I want to thank our classified and our certificated staff who came to work yesterday because they showed up they showed up for our students I know that's what drives them and they want to ensure that our students when they come in they feel safe and they feel Comfort they don't want our kids to be under stress or to be fearful and I learned that some of these employees had to evacuate themselves and probably were not at their house the night before they

063showed up to work and they still showed up so I want to thank you because that's a big sacrifice I am not surprised because that's what we do when we work with students we do a lot of this we put them first and so I know we have shared about compassion in our communities and I want to acknowledge some of the compassion that I witnessed in my own Community um our council members immediately jump to have um host clothing drives and uh donation drives and so I want to thank that I think that these are the moments when all institutions come together because people depend on us to provide and to lead and so I want to thank our I want to mention them because I'm very grateful to Ugo stto Martinez who immediately uh

064jumped on try on removing a tree that was at at Water yesterday that tree had fallen and then also Isabelle hurado who's been diligently working hard to bring supports for her community and one of those includes um Eagle Rock which is where I live and where a lot of our students attend so thank you again my heart goes out to you and um I hope that we continue as a district leading and that we um heed your demands to keep you safe and to keep you healthy because that is our duty thank you and thank you Miss grigo Miss gones yes um I will just Echo the words of my colleagues it's been um an incredibly heartbreaking time knowing knowing people who've been affected um by this crisis across our County um I will note

065that my district was impacted by the Hurst fire in Silmar um many of our families were evacuated in the Silmar area but we are grateful and blessed that the fire burned in the direction of the mountains rather in the direction of homes um but still it is it is a Collective trauma that we've all experienced and um I appreciate so much our staff our First Responders um our families who have come together in the wake of this crisis um one note when I was at our food distribution centers I had the chance to help with my kids um at three of our sites at San fernan middle at saula middle school and at bird middle school and the first day when we only had the one location in my district the uh Regional food services

066manager said he had so many Food Service workers f uner to be there more than he could even accommodate which I think really just speaks to the desire um of our school communities to help one another and to really be there in this time um of fear um I also want to appreciate our staff who were there um our principls our teachers our classified staff who were there on Wednesday I know I picked up my kids in the dark they they were there with power out the entire day um one of my kids has asthma we don't have n95 masks and so on the one hand I think it speaks to the need for those conditions never to repeat themselves in in in the future um and for us to heed the voices of of

067community who are experiencing these crisis in real time um but also just I want to extend my sincere gratitude because I knew as a parent that my kids would be safe at school because of the people who work there um and I also want to appreciate just all of those who have helped with meal distribution with the cleanup efforts um this is not a small task we have a thousand schools in LA un ified um almost all of them who are impacted in some way by the environmental conditions um and for this to happen and for our schools to be open yesterday um is a true accomplishment and so I want to thank everyone who who was a part of that because we know that our schools are not just about learning academics but they're

068really that source of stability for our kids and in a time of Crisis being with their peers being with their Community um just matters a lot I think for their social and emotional uh development when it comes to the future um obviously these crises are unprecedented were unprecedented but now they are the precedent we know that climate change and extreme weather are interconnected and that unfortunately these this could be the way of the future um and I just I I want to uplift you know the call of our labor partners for for an emergency task force I think it's really important um it's critical that we have a board approved comprehensive of policy addressing climate related crises um emergencies weather events um so that we can do the best possible job as a system to

069be proactive in these instances to respond to buildin resiliency at our school sites physically um both in terms of air filtration um access to generators so that we don't have extended power outages um we we need to adapt rapidly to what is becoming The New Normal so that we can uh protect our School communities as best as possible so I appreciate the superintendent noting that we will be doing a full postmortem analysis I appreciate the superintendent noting that we will do a full postmortem analysis I hope that that includes not just including the voices of our employees and our community members but also experts who can help us prepare as a school system for what the future with the climate crisis will look like and how we can best uh protect and support uh those

070that we have the privilege to serve again thank you thank you so much to everyone who has been there for our students and families during these difficult times our hearts are with you and I know that together we will get through this thank you Miss gonz let me go over to miss nuel yes thank you um and again just to reiterate some words that have already been spoken but just on behalf as a parent you know as we look at La unified and we know it's Grand and vast as we said we have 11 you know thousands of schools to service but the fast and vast response I know it's not always timely and it's not always exactly perfect but what I can say and to my colleagues that sit here at this day is

071that we're working tirelessly to serve this community and so I am grateful to be part here but as mentioned want to say thank you thank you thank you to those in our communities to those First Responders that were out there that rush in when people are rushing out and I know with py I know many of folks there as the fire trucks were coming in they were going out I know the students and those that were on that campus that were there CU as a coach I'm very connected with the coaching community and those are the ones that were there during their time off and so as we look and reflect and to thank all of those that tirelessly continue to work and we say we are in the people business and I'm so excited

072that we have those people that go in when others are rushing out and so to our principals as mentioned to the staff and those that cleaning crews that were there on the weekend and folks were shocked to know that yeah we have people there on the weekend putting in time to make sure that our families were safe and to all those that have lost and mentioned here I I know my phone was ringing off the hook for those that have lost and I can't even imagine one mention all I have was the clothes on my back that is it and to hear that and know like what you don't even have the words to encourage individuals at that moment but as mentioned we will get through this because we are resilient that way this district

073has been that way and I am proud to be a product of it and know that as we continue to stand together and as we say Unified and continue to work on being unified cuz it is you know we're a family and I feel like that within this District we're a family and we'll continue to put our families and our communities first and continue to take the feedback of our families to improve in areas in which we do struggle and need to grow but definitely want to continue um the work and I know I had questions about h back systems as we mentioned wanting the experts to come in to make sure these done timely and that our families would be safe within our schools and I too on that day took my students to

074school because I knew that they would be safe with the individuals there um to oversee them and to watch them and to take care of them and to provide for them while they were there and they were and they felt encouraged my students came home and my children were like Mom sharing with me how they helped within the system of the school so I was just proud to see how everyone came together and we continue cuz this is not um a day a week a month this is going to be a a time for us to get through and so as we continue to Advocate and receive feedback and continue to improve our response systems and continue to do this on a unified front and as I said we putting the unified into La unified

075and continue to keep that there and I just want to continue as mentioned Carla said you know all parties um across the board um all levels of uh government has been working tirelessly and because La unified is such that uh pivotal Point people look to us um we continue to tweak and change so that we can be excellent for those that we serve and uh during this time it's obviously a time to come together and I know we will and so again I want to just say thank you to all those that have and will continue and my heart goes out to those that have lost um and again uh if we can continue to save space for those and continue to reach out to those that have lost because it is not right now

076it will be for time to come to see this um transition and change and so just thank you for the opportunity to be here to be able to serve and be a part are those Solutions as we continue to go forward and uh continue to be that voice for those that need uh the support and the love and as mentioned today the empathy and compassion and appreciate anelli just continue to bring the voice of our students um which is so critical and we can never forget them because often time we can lose sight and I just appreciate being able to hear your voice speak on behalf of them so thank you so much for everyone that has been here today today to be able to share and just bring our hearts together so we'll get

077through this together thank you thank you thank you Miss Nill I think we've heard the same message from everybody every board member here we care we consider you we love you and we will help you there's the same message from all of us and our student board member just want to extend my gratitude once again to all the board members to continuously uplifting The Voice voice of students in these unprecedented times and would also like to include another aspect of fear that I've seen within our own student population um regarding the fear of immigration officials within our school campuses I have seen on various social media platforms um in in terms of ice raids uh based on what we've seen in CERN County Bakers field and students were triggered by this and false reports of

078immigration officials spread all throughout social media and although these reports were proven to be false the fear is certainly real and I would like to say again to students who are watching this that this district is a sanctuary District that your right to be here will stay with to stay within this district is real that you belong here and that no sense of false fear would deter us from protecting your right to stay here it is important thank you it is important to ensure with these scares that our undocumented newcomer and immigrant populations are aware of the fact that we are uring protections for them because we are living in moments of unprecedented fear and in times of fear our job is to promote hope and protection because ultimately our protection has to be greater

079than fear that is all thank you thank you right thank you student board member Cortez Lopez uh a final word from our superintendent thank you very much Mr President let me Begin by saying thank you once again board member Cortez Lopez for your eloquence your courage and your excellent representation of the student body let me begin with the last point that you made um this board has taken a number of steps to declare boldly and loudly that uh we are Los Angeles and we are unified in the protection of all of our students and Workforce members and the appropriate support for their families regardless of immigration status will be adamant about protecting everyone uh not only did this board adopt resolutions uh we have initiated and continue to train individuals we're publishing uh know your

080rights cards that uh are being distributed to everyone in our school system ready to pull out and let people know that we know our rights as a student we know our rights as an employee the issue of fear and Trauma is not specific only to students we have over 350 employees who are beneficiaries of temporary protection status meaning their future is not guaranteed should we just open the doors to those who want to inflict harm upon the unity of our community we're going to stand strong and we're going to ensure that the jurisdiction within our schools is not penetrable by federal entities who may seek to enforce uh immigration actions uh we remain partners with the city and the county who've also adopted these T types of policies and practices uh secondly um I spoke

081briefly earlier about uh employee support systems that we have put into place I want to be a little bit clearer about those and we know there are a lot of questions so let me Begin by providing a hotline number for any employee who have been relocated or is experiencing hardship that's 213 2222 213 241 2222 the first thing we did was to stand out pay time off for displaced employees we continued to assess survey the workforce to determine true impact we know we don't have all the information we need we will be getting the information from labor Partners In addition to what we're picking up directly from the workforce members um we know sometimes uh the residence that's uh designated in our computer system may have changed certainly has changed since this event so we'll

082continue to update those processes we began with 5 days of District pay time we'll be reviewing and revising that and we are ready to increase that level should there be a need secondly the employe relief fund for employees dis displaced uh by the January uh fires this is through the foundation uh we have calculated right now we are pushing out as much resources we currently have beginning with $500 per displaced employee to assist which with short-term C costs these are just short-term costs we know that there will be additional need and this is why contributions to the foundation are so critical at this point I can tell you based on what we've heard clothing non perishable food blankets it appears that there is plenty of that in the community right now what we need are

083Financial Resources to support our Workforce and to support students and families mental health support we've stood up uh mental health supports available to All District employees uh staff uh parents and students through District provided health benefits as well as private sector entities the sponsor an employee initiative uh displaced employees May self-refer and provide information about their specific needs so that their wish list may be fulfilled by other LD employees this was an idea that came from labor um emergency vacation cash out this again was an idea that was brought to us from employees so vacation earning employees displaced from their primary uh residents uh May request to cash out up to 40 hours uh of ACR vacation time should there be a need emergency access to 403b and 457b withdrawal loan from their 403bs employees

084impacted again can take advantage of flexibility specific spefic to their Investments and then obviously um this is specific to both employees as well as as students we know as a result of the fires that many lost their laptops to the fire uh they were left at school uh we stand ready to replace those on an expedited fashion if you have such need once again the hotline is 213 241 7,000 for the replacement of devices 213 241 7,000 we will continue to assess the voice of our Workforce the voice of parents and students for additional support measures that we may take at this point Thank you very much and thank you superintendent so right before we get to our new business for Action we have a last Labor partner come up please uh Miss Franny Parish

085from CA and then we will start our new business for Action go ahead Miss Parish my sincere apologies my sincere apologies um being in the dark being without power being without cable being without internet being sitting with your suitcase packed evacuated and everything else what looked like 1:00 looked like 11:00 I 11:00 and look I you know got all the time and I'm so used to 1:00 on the uh time there hi there new people how are you so nice to see you miss Grio Miss Nill welcome welcome oh I have to take a breath here you know I had to rush down here to get here so my apologies again uh for coming down here uh really uh superintendent what wonderful wonderful news you have pushed out um I have two Library AIDS who

086had their homes burned to the ground um and I will read something at the very end from one of them but thank you so much uh for all of these wonderful services that you have all approved for our members uh all of the our labor Partners I must say so um good news bad news whatever uh let me start off by saying uh first of all L usd's decision to expand Outsourcing to Amazon and other for-profit companies uh threatens to the stability of our schools and waste precious public resources as a result members of CCA have been let go it is this uh is this who you really want to do business with a company such as Amazon who is cozied up with an incoming Administration that is held bent on destroying public education and

087special education a company that destroys smaller businesses to give you a better deal aren't we better than that aren't we better plus we're letting go our labor Partners um it's also come to our attention that there is a new it support technician budget model now since technology is key and essential to every single day for students and staff at the schools this new budget model calls for the schools to begin paying for a technician no longer I know that the erra funds and the code of funds have exp uh have expired that has paid for this but they're no longer providing centralized support it's no longer providing free technology why one day a week is only $ 26,1 151 three days $78,400 and where will the schools get the money for the technology and the

088support well wait wait a minute they can just get rid of the library AIDS right they can use that from the flexibility right Mr solo after all anyone can do their jobs if you give them mous of cookie he'll want a glass of milk we do need we do need technology you have emphasized that we need technology for everything that goes on in the schools but yet you have taken away so much money away from the schools how are they supposed to have that support everything keeps breaking down what are we supposed to do we need those people I depend on them my printer all of a sudden the power went off and now I can't get back online with my printer I'm not a tech wizard God knows I keep trying um now because

089I cannot stay for the entire meeting uh ca ca wants to urge the Board of Education to adopt the district's findings of fact in support of denial of the renewal Charter petition for creed Academy this Charter is low performing and is failing in English and language arts math and chronic absenteeism indicators among numerically significant student groups the board cannot continue to allow Creed Academy to fail our students in addition as you're all aware our district is already confronting a variety of challenges around student enrollment fiscal management and Community engagement low performing Charters such as Creed Academy erode our public education system by siphoning away funds from our traditional Public Schools pushes students out of our district and creates a privately managed School structure shielded from public oversight and Community input in conclusion I again urge

090you to adopt the district's findings of fact in support of denial of the renewal Charter petition for creed academy uh we want to commend the district for all the hard work for what has been done to clean up after and while the fires have been happening it has been I must say incredible um we have like to have been at the schools not to have been at the schools on Wednesday absenteeism was rampant from students and teachers not coming in because of being evacuated the air uh and multiple uh things that were going on it was frightening to be at the schools um but I would also like to read something from one of our library AIDS and now our new name technicians we have changed our names we are now Library technicians for Marquez

091if you don't mind after 11 Wonder year wonderful years in our beloved Palisades Village our hearts are Shattered by the loss of our home we stand in solidarity with our P friends who have become family and our neighbors who are also facing this unimaginable reality you think it will never happen to you until it does adding to our heartbreak my cherished School Marquez Charter Elementary where I serve as library and has burned to the ground yet amidst the devastation I want to honor the extraordinary courage and compassion of our school Community as the fires Advanced our magical teachers and staff work tirelessly to ensure the safety of our 300 plus students we calmed Panic parents soothed frightened children and coordinated evacuations with bravery and Grace together we loaded children onto buses and accompanied them to

092evacuation locations staying with them until they were safely reunited with their families some of us were the last to leave the school office staff custodial team cafeteria manager and others braving Smoke Filled air chaotic traffic and even abandoning our cars to run for safety though we lost so much we did not lose a single precious life I am overwhelmed with love and pride for my colleagues who ensured every child felt safe and loved even in the face of their own fear their courage is what matters most to me and it gives me hope that we will rebuild stronger and more connected than ever we send so much love to our first Love waverly's Elementary School pal sades Charter Elementary School it burned as well and we are heartbroken thank you to everyone who has reached

093out to us with love and support your kindness has meant the world to us during this incredibly difficult time we're safe and focused on taking our next steps with our main priority being ensuring our daughter Waverly feels safe and secure I got to tell you this is a Shiro isn't that what we heard on Saturday Shir Ros wasn't isn't that what we heard new word for me Shiro the exact person who stood with her students and she didn't rush to her own home she didn't rush to her own home to save anything it burnt to the ground she only had the clothes on her back it burned to the ground while she helped to save the children of varquez Elementary I wish she was here today but she's out trying to find someplace to live

094she was so busy it took her four hours to reach her husband and daughter find safety and reunite with them in Santa Monica and this is the exact position Mr Sal if you weren't so busy talking in the back you might hear me hello Mr salsi he always talks when I'm up here talking it's a bit rude but he's so busy hellbent on putting the library technicians on the flexibility list because he doesn't see as do many people who have never worked at an elementary school how valuable our positions are how valuable many of the classified positions are these are the shirros that nobody talks about all of those library books that's the first thing everybody said you're okay but what about all those wonderful resources for the kids they're not all online sometimes they're

095physical she's a Shiro that position does not belong on the flexibility list Mr Salo I don't know why you're so hellbent on keeping in that position there shame on anybody who keeps trying so hard to do that I wish you were here she deserves the medal thank you and thank you for giving me the time I'm sorry I was late thank you Miss Parish Miss gones I just wanted to ask a quick question um superintendent uh thank you so much for sharing the resources available to our impacted employees I was checking the resources on our website and I could not easily find those employee resources can you share where they might be located so that it it's most easy for for those who've been impacted sure so thank you for the question we're actually in

096the process of uploading all of them some of the ones that I just announced particularly the caching out of vacation time and some of the flexibility specific to uh uh to retirement Investments were just negotiated so with with the entities so they will be up uh today on a special button specific to uh relief efforts and the sponsor and employee um will that be included as well correct correct thank you everything that I announced will be there one one quick question um I just wanted to ask if you mentioned all the resources for for our uh s of fight staff were they able to use miscellaneous National disaster leave instead of using their um sick or vacation time for the absences that is correct that's actually the decision we made and by the way this

097is not only for certificated the Personnel certificated and classified the the measure the decision we made is rather than relying on individuals to use their own sick time or or leave time is that the district will utilize uh that natural disaster um uh condition to support uh employees beginning with 5 days I I will be supporting an expansion of that which will be announced fairly soon anyone else we're getting ready for our new business for action but before we get to tab one and two as the board president I would like to mention some things that I've noticed about tab one and tab to in in past board meetings so um there's a pattern in in tabs one and two over the past few months that I've noticed we see renewals on the agenda and

098we ask as many questions as we possibly can but with a lingering question and that lingering question is is this contract fulfilling its purpose so starting today as as board president I'd like to see an updated report along with the renewal proposals for example these reports should have the following it should have the vendor the scope of work the day serviced at LUSD and a short analysis of whether this work can be done inhouse or not and an additional context which I'll explain now and that is not every vendor's value is reflected in the numbers so for examp example elevator repairs and elevator maintenance may not even work half the year on elevators yet somehow our superintendent and his team got the contractor to agree to be on call 365 days a year they are

099also quick and responsive to the calls they receive and they have a particular skill that makes them essential to La USD skill set that is not readily available inside the district so I'd like to include the context in the report so we the public can understand how our school system operates see sometimes we got a whole bunch of bench contracts and I'm not exactly sure how they are working out within the district so um this board would appreciate having reports for all vendors but not it's not possible for every single time to begin with I like this to be done maybe for renewals over $15 million starting in March 2025 if we can lower that threshold in the future we can do so because during these evaluations of vendors it will lead to a better

100understanding of how LAUSD operations for the public and for a more transparent budget process so go ahead Mr Mr mle okay now it's time to go through the consent calendar um it's a number of items that are on the agenda and the consent calendar is a procedural mechanism that the board uses to efficiently take action on more than one item at a time if there is unanimous consent for that particular item so I'm going to slowly read through the items if a board member would like to have comments or questions on the item it will come off of the it will not go on the consent calendar if there are no questions or comments to be had the item will go on the consent calendar and will be voted on as as a single item

101there have been a couple of changes uh to the agenda that I will read through as we go on um when we come to them and there are a number of public hearings for which I will have to read a public statement prior to actions taken on that item so this is all very procedural in nature and we'll we'll strike ahead okay tab one approval of procurement actions question question also can can I clarify because we does that mean we're pulling enough discussion per the way we used to do it under Miss Goldberg or does that just mean it's on consent with a question I apologize it's going to be just like how uh former board president Goldberg did so for example tab one will now be up for discussion correct okay tab two approval

102of facilities contracts uh question uh discussion tab three certification of the final environmental impact report adoption of the mitigation monitoring and Reporting plan andent Tab four project approval for the Washington Irving uh middle school math music engineering magnet major modernization project and uh tab five Define and approve seven playground and campus exterior project upgrades and and amend the facility service division strategic execution plan to incorporate therein question uh I have Dr Ras and Miss Gro uh tab six to find and approve two projects to provide critical Replacements and upgrades of school buildings tab seven authorization to finalize negotiations and execute renewal license agreement uh for use of radio tower space at Palace veres 1 Rancho Palace veres California I have a question yeah St eight to find and approve 16 Board District priority and region

103priority projects cons tab nine that was for consent tab nine donations of money to the district consent consent Tab 10 report of cash dispersements consent and tab 11 I will note that attachment D has been withdrawn so action taken on this item will not include attachment D consent consent consent consent tab 12 provisional internships tab 13 request for board approval of Education compact with the city of Lomita consent tab 14 request for approval of 2025 advocacy agenda and guiding principles and priorities question I have comment okay okay so I have um Miss gones I'll I'll add AO and what I'm doing now is I'm just noting the folks who have questions so that we can be efficient about it tab 15 Proposition 39 Charter facilties compliance for the 2025 2026 school year consent uh tab

10416 denial of the renewal petition for cre Academy discussion tab 17 denial of renewal petition for Ivy bound Academy Math Science and Technology Charter Middle discussion uh tab 18 approval of the renewal petition for Kip kazon Academy discussion uh Dr Ras uh tab 19 approval of renewal petition for Kip philosophers Academy Dr Ras Mr schmon no comment just oh understood understood so that will be on discussion for a question uh tab 20 approval of the renewal petition for Kip Scholar Academy uh discussion question uh tab 21 denial of the renewal petition for Kip Soul Academy discuss uh tab 22 denial of the renewal petition for Los Angeles leader ship Academy discuss discussion uh tab 23 approval of the proposed material re revision for Alliance uh Judy Ivy Burton Technology Academy High I so for discussion

105uh tab 24 approval of the proposed material revision for Alliance College ready Middle Academy for consent 24 is on consent 25 approval sorry there are okay so 24 so 23 is for discussion 24 is on consent moving to 25 approval of the proposed material revision for alance skirts wrestler Richard mkin 6 through2 complex uh 26 approval of the proposed material revision for aliance odonovan 6 through2 complex I apologize for my pronunciation of Alliance uh was that for consent okay all right moving on to tab 30 um I'll note that tab 30 it takes a village expanding La UniFi housing waivers will not include a waiver of board rule 72 what this means that this this particular resolution tab 30 is going to be for initial announcement only an action will be taken on it at

106the next board meeting in February so this is for initial announcement only um tab 31 commemorating The Life and Legacy of Dr Martin Luther King Jr I'd like to sponsor that me too wow and consent unanimous consent uh it's also seeking waiver of board rule 72 uh tab 32 national day of racial healing 2025 similarly seeking a waiver of board rule 22 sponsor please consent sponsorship okay to too I'm sorry uh board member could you say it again post sponsor on both as well please thank you so much thanks tab 23 is for initial announcement um tab 34 uh charters for public hearing that's not for Action this is uh folks will be heard the statement will be read and folks will be heard on this item it's just for announcement um tab 35 report

107of Correspondence consent consent uh tab 36 minutes for board approval uh tab 37 is not for action it's a receipt of the 2023 2024 annual audit financial report we may have a presentation on that is that right okay can ask question and if there are questions they can be taken all right uh Tab 38 request for board authority to pursue a 2-year extension to the waiver of a portion of Education code a uh and then we have a version two for Tab 3 9 which has been distributed to the board there are copies available for the public and it has been posted online for public viewing adoption of authorization to execute certain contracts without advertising or inviting bids to respond effectively to the January 2025 severe Windstorm and fire conditions SL resolution declaring emergency conditions

108exist at Los Angeles Unified School and offices question discussion discussion okay uh and tab 40 is just U initial announcement associate administrators of Los Angeles unit J uh initial bargaining proposal for 2025 successor and unit M um so no no action is taken it's available for public viewing uh for the sake of clarity I'm just going to read through this really quickly if everybody wants to review the records and make any corrections if any if any need to be made so tab one is discussion tab two is discussion tabs three and four are consent tab five is discussion tab six is consent tab seven is discussion tabs 8 9 10 11 12 and 13 are consent noting on Tab 11 attachment D has been withdrawn uh tab 14 discussion tab 15 consent tabs 16 17

10918 19 20 21 22 and 23 are for discussion tab tabs 24 25 and 26 are consent and we have tabs 31 and 32 are consent tab 35 and 36 are consent Tab 38 is for consent and tab 39 is for discussion is that comport with everybody's okay so at this time we uh then begin taking public comment on the consent items we have public comment on tab two it looks like oh three so Andrea Palmer are you here please come on up to speak on uh procurement services division facilities contracts and while I know there has been a lot of sign up for many of the uh public comment spots here I would respectfully request that folks when they sign up for an item uh speak to that item so this one is uh

110approval of facilities contracts actions all right come on up Andrea and I've already made a mistake tab two is for discussion thank you board member gones for all of your experience pointing my errors out I appreciate I really do um okay so for tab 24 is the first consent item that also has public discussion associated with it so tab 24 we have a number of inperson and callers so I'll call in the inperson folks first to speak to tab 24 so Ava lores cops come on up Eva uh yudi Nava Judy are you here I'm going to check to see that folks are not also signed up online let's see uh Hugo Hernandez are you here Hugo Hernandez estefania Vasquez estefania do you have some Intel for me on folks who are not here they

111taking away from the L okay so I've just been told that folks for tab 24 are making their way in from the lobby just so that the folks who are streaming can't hear what's going on so um I'm going to see if we have anybody who's on oh you're here okay please announce your name because I've already marked some folks as as not here so that I can keep an accurate record absolutely good morning good afternoon my name is Eva Flores CPS awesome esteemed members of the LUSD board my name is Eva Flores CPS and I am the proud principal of Alliance College ready Middle Academy 4 I have worked with the alliance CMO and our South La Community for over 15 years because the work we do is transformational however we have always been

112limited by space this material revision will allow us to expand and thereby increase our reach and impact in the Watts South Los Angeles community we serve more classrooms and a multi-purpose room will translate to Dedicated classrooms for each teacher increased enrollment and a protected indoor space for our parent engagement Sports and meals on rainy and excessively hot days additionally we'll be able to expand enrichment programming and ensure Scholars have access to the well-rounded Equitable education that creates access to high school college and Beyond by approving you are investing in continued excellent education and the future of South Los Angeles I appreciate your time and your unwavering support thank you very much thank you for your time I just want to note uh this item is on consent for for folks who are who are here

113um all right so uh yudi Nava are you here uh Miss Nava is going to speak in Spanish so if you'd like to hear what she's going to say in English please throw on these headphones and you will experience simultaneous translation my name is Judy Naas I am the proud grandmother of Jason Vargas student of sixth grade at media academic I am here to express my support my total support to the revision of the charter schools of the school knowing that firmly it was created and all the in the installations are essential to the well-being of our students the multi-purpose room will be a big benefit for our community this space will offer an adequate cafeteria a place for events reunions and something where like the fires that are happening in Los Angeles and this

114will proportion a safe place for students teachers and Par parents and this knowing that this is a new topic of equity and this will give a quality education to all students in our area if this Charter revision is not approved it is will be another default or fault for our community knowing that we are expressing or going through difficult time this will be used for important use like educational events or to prevent drugs and informative information something that is crucial for the well-being of the students one of my worries is my grandchild's health which he suffers from nasal problems in the winter and in the summer because of the climate change this multi-purpose room will help protect the health of many students knowing that you will be offering this the whole year I thank you

115profoundly and I thank you for the time and dedicating the public service and I ask with all respect and the respect and I ask for you respectfully support and your vote in favor will be a great step to secure security and education for all students of our community thank you very much I I also want to reiterate for every single item uh on the consent calendar that was designated as consent it's basically a um a procedural mechanism where the board has decided that it's going to approve unanimously the item that's been placed on consent okay thank you appreciate your time sir thank you I've just been notified that those speaking in favor of the item have uh seated their time so I I'm just going to call through the list uh because otherwise I don't

116want to skip someone who decided to speak in some manner different than what uh the gentleman has just informed um Ugo Hernandez you going to seed okay he's telling me he's going to see this time estefania Vasquez also seating um Amalia Rodriguez Amalia seating time she okay seating her time okay good morning steam members the board members my name is Amalia I am a mother of a seventh grade student at attending academ academic number four Middle School I am here to express my support to the Rev to the revision of the charter schools knowing that the new installations are fundamental to guarantee the well-being of my daughter and for all students of our school these new installations will continue need to offer spaces high quality spaces like a multi-purpose room additional rooms and offices these

117are very necessary these resources will not only contribute to the academic success of my child but the emotional development and and give a well-being to learning aside from these installations that will not only benefit benefit the students but it will also strengthen the community with a better structure helping many students in the future and so that the schools can find different topics but this school represents a positive change an opportunity to contribute and the for the future of our children I want to say the importance of the multi-purpose room knowing that as a mother I wish to participate in many parent meetings with the com a space without the interruption of the airplanes and the airplanes that are flying through minutes after minutes and this noise is a distraction a noise distraction and this affects

118the school day of our students I thank you sincerely and I thank you all for your service and for the time and the dedicated to listen to our families like mine your support will not all only guarantee a better condition for our children but also reaffirms the permission with equity and Excellence within our education thank you Alfredo Marin moral Morales would you like to seed your time or are you not present not present uh itel Ronson seeding her time okay great thank you thank you so much for those who can't see what's being pictured a member of the audience uh um administrator with the with the school has let us know that that person has seated there time and I'm just announcing that out loud so that everyone is on the exact same page um

119I've been notified that uh as to tab 23 um just a statement uh uh would like to m board member greo would like to just make a statement she doesn't have any question or doesn't wish to vote against it but would like to make a statement on it if we can put that on consent and then make the statement or do you have thoughts I was going to say I think Dr Rivas similarly on a few just had comments I heard saying so maybe when she's back we can put those back on consent too okay so let's um then go to tab 23 if you'd like to uh make your statement and then we can add it to consent yeah so this is tab 23 which is um um material revision on for Alliance and

120I'd like to make this statement um for Alliance um whereas I'm really glad to learn that allian has finally recognized the union memberships of the Educators at two Alliance sites Burton tech and gerts murkin and are currently in negotiations with their Union utla I encourage you to have these negotiations in good faith a lot iance Educators first voted to be unionized back in and just uh two schools have barely begun their negotiations in 2023 this is far too long um there are two more Alliance sites whose Educators had voted for representation and Alliance continues to refuse recognition holding up the process by consenting the educ by contesting the Educators votes in the courts much money has been spent on fighting this recognition instead this money should be spent on your students and the Educators because

121as you know working conditions for our Educators your Educators benefits your students your Educators and students deserve to be heard and have their needs met so that they can focus on teaching and learning I encourage you Alliance to bargain in good faith with your Educators okay this item is now technically on consent and we have speakers who signed up to speak on this item but the item is now in consent I'll read through the names and if you'd like to seed your time please let me know and I'll announce it that way um the folks who can't see what's going on can know what's going on Liliana Martinez okay all right so these folks are all signed up and they're going to seed their time and I know this because the individuals have listed their

122organization in the sign up information and I will save that we move on to tab 25 also similarly on consent um let's see I'll call names if they would like to uh let me know if they want to see their time or continue to speak um Justin shabas Justin shabaz see their time okay thank you can you do me a really big favor and and say it into the mic so I have so we just have sort of a record yes for all the alliance school that are in the consent uh we like to time for all speakers please appreciate it and and what's your name uh Jay Stewart chief of strategy uh at Alliance appreciate it thank you Mr Stuart and I think I need to turn up the mic volume can the folks

123in the back hear what's going on or no okay thank you thank you I I'll turn up the volume can you hear me okay I'll I just announce what what's occurred for the record again tab 25 has seated their time and and the announcement was made uh by the school itself uh Mr Stewart moving on to uh let's see tab 26 it will be the same so I'm just going to make the announcement for the record that this time time has been seated and we very much appreciate the procedural efficiency that you're uh you're engaging in here no need to re announce you you said it for all the alliance schools thank you Mr Stuart I appreciate your help okay moving right along so for uh we are now at the resolutions on Tab 30

124looks like 31 we have two call-in speakers let me make sure that they're here with us for tab 31 okay Miss Lucy garciaa I see you're on the line please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Lucy Garcia hello Miss Garcia it sounds like you're streaming Us in the background if you just mute that device I just I just got rid of it okay and then uh one last request speak extra clearly into the microphone and I'm going to also turn up the volume so folks in the room can hear you okay can you hear me now hello can you hear me hello I'm trying to turn it up if you give me one sec M okay take it away hi thank you for this chance

125to speak up about this great American great human leader the Reverend Dr Martin Luther King Dr Martin Luther King was precious he envisioned the Beloved Community and he saw this as created first through restraining uh through the law restraining through the law the behaviors of people in the vicious who had been trained in the vicious totalitarianism of racism against black people for 350 years at his time then he thought to change the hearts and the minds of people through religion and through education this is what he said about education quote integration in our Public Schools is different different from uh public facilities and so on and transportation in that setting you are dealing going qu quoting him again in that setting you are dealing with one of the most important assets of an individual the

126mind a large percentage of white people have a very low opinion of our race and people with such a low view of the black race cannot be given free reign and put in charge of the intellectual care and development of our boys and girls in other comments he spoke about the loving leadership that black teachers had given to their students in the segregated schools and the importance of maintaining that support today I want to urge you to put the black black in back in the black student achievement plan put the black back in it don't roll over in front of some white ladies from Virginia making backward comments where that we're supposed to be colorblind in a society that's structured to maintain racist divisions every one in this District knows that children have distinct needs

127and that all must be addressed in kind black Educators and support staff have proven to boost the success of our black students we need black love for our black students because the job is not yet done we have many many people who still hold a a hateful and frankly scared view of black people we had an attack back in December on a student a black student at the very school where my grandchildren my grand black grandsons are let off after school thank you very much for your time we appreciate your time and uh we need that let's see Carlos Montes I see you're also online to speak to this item Carlos Montes please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Carlos Montes Mr Montes please press

128star six to unmute yourself to speak to tab 31 I see you're with us sir I'm asking you to unmute um please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin M check M check am I on yeah you're on but uh you're a little bit muffled can you please uh speak directly General yeah is that better that is a little bit better thank you sir yeah yeah sorry I'm at the General Hospital in the basement yeah thank you very much my name is Carlos Mones I'm the cro CSO in Bai and you know in favor of the motion by Miss new everyone just had personal experience with the Martin Luther King and the southern Christian leadership conference is a young activist in 1968 SCC invited us to

129participate in the PO people's campaign in Washington DC obviously or excuse me unfortunately he was assassinated but the invitation still continued with the Reverend J Williams uh abna and of course Jesse Jackson so I just wanted to share that we participated as young Cho militants fighting for education in the Poor People's campaign where we learned that the white and the Hony was not the enemy that black folks navajos Puerto Ricans even poor whites uh were part of the Poor People's campaign so I just wanted to express my support for this motion and also that many of our young folks don't know their history you I I even speak with young adults in their 30s and 40s that don't know the history of martic King they don't know the history of the Poor People's country they

130don't know the history of organization is not onlyc but NAACP black cancer party us organization always reached out to the chano community talk about working together and building black and brown solidarity that is a lesson that I learned as a young militant in 1968 that I continue today to advocate for solidarity not only black and brown but all working people so thank you very much for this motion again miss new bill and hopefully our young folks can learn this history and continue the struggle and again you know uh in January 20th we're going to have a learning experience in Bight in Mari Plaza but we're gonna have speakers uh to talk about the leg Legacy of marar but also bring it up today that we have to continue today to work for solidarity and equality

131for all working people especially you know January 20 what's going to happen you know we're GNA have a new new Administration so we all have to work together and fight for equality thank you very much thank you very much sir we appreciate your time uh Miss newbill did you have a comment to make on your resolution you're not being okay timed out might I even start um yeah thanks for the comments that were already mentioned and um and those that have wanted to join on and I just wanted to just say some things um as you know Dr Martin Luther King day is a Day of Honor for Dr King's Legacy and to spread the message of love and equality and especially during this time uh Dr King was a civil rights leader who fought

132for the rights of African-Americans and the economically disadvantage through non-violent means Dr King was Central to historical events such as the Montgomery Bus uh boyot the March on Washington and the Birmingham campaign uh Dr Kim became one of the youngest persons to receive the Nobel Peace Prize MLK day as known was established as a Federal holiday back in 1984 and became a National Day of Service back in 1994 Martin Luther King Jr Day of Service this year in 2025 will be held on Monday January 20th on this day Americans are encouraged to volunteer and improve their communities in light of devastating wildfires as we have all talked about here in Los Angeles and for our angelinos we are encouraging them to participate in this year's Day of Service by supporting recovery initiatives and helping effective

133individuals and families some activities supporting impacted families by putting together meal kits assembling hygiene kits um other MLK Day activities to consider are visiting a local Museum or exhibition or reading about Dr King or watching a movie as mentioned by our caller being educated on his work and his life and most importantly I think as Dr King in his words would say the time is always right to do what is right and so I would just want to thank you guys and urge you to continue to support and the support of this resolution thank you thank you okay moving to the next uh resolution Tab 3 2 we have a couple of public commenters on Tab 32 um in person Amir Casmir are you here Amir uh Marsha Marsh Ian kiry and niji Ali are

134you here these are folks for all slated to speak in person okay one of two I'm told we have some comments we were just finished um hearing public comment on resolutions 31 and 32 that we on consent okay sure um I just wanted to make some comments for uh miss hendy new Bill's resolution um and I've already um uh mentioned that I want to be a co-sponsor so I wholeheartedly support Miss new's resolution to commemorate The Life and Legacy of uh Dr Mar Luther King Jr and the National Day of Service Dr King's message of Justice equality and service continues to resonate deeply especially within our diverse School communities this resolution beautifully captures the spirit of Dr King's work by encouraging active participation in community service providing our students with opportunities to engage in meaningful

135service activities not only honors his legacy but also empowers them to become active and engaged citizens I will be honored to be co-sponsor which I am and I believe it's essential that we as a board demonstrate our commitment to upholding Dr King's values and Inspire our students to carry on with his dream of a more just and Equitable world so thank you so much for bringing this forward and it's something that we definitely need to um renew and remind our communities of his legacy thank you so much thank you I'll note that those are 31 and 32 are on consent and received a unanimous co-sponsorship yes of course thank you I would also like to be this I'd also like to be added as a co-sponsor for this resolution and uh ensure that our students

136acknowledge the presence of Martin Luther King's Jr's actions far beyond his assassination he was a vital figure not only for our students who learn our history books but whose lessons can be transformed into everyday actions hearing my peers joy for the continuations of culturally relevant material that addresses The Faults of history and the rebuilding of our soci Society at large deeply interest them one student one lesson and one action at a time I urge my peers to continue in the legacy of Martin Luther King Jr with every step we take towards equity and through the service to improve our communities at large thank you okay thank you so we have next uh Tab 38 which is on consent which also has public comment associated with it uh let's see uh di guen are you here

137in person di guen uh I'll call the folks who are listed as in person um uh Monica arzola Monica Rola uh Mr David tolkovsky I think I've seen Mr tolkovsky here missen come on Miss Ken's going to speak in Spanish so if you'd like to hear what she's going to say in English please put your hands up and we get you these headsets okay list us good afternoon members of the board my name is Di guen and I'm chairperson of the district committee uh will pack for short this committee had a meeting on December 9th of 2024 with the legislative offices and government agencies with Miss Martha Alvarez where you're asking for this extension for the classified Personnel so pack the pack committee with the information presented had objections and I sent you all an

138email so that you can be aware of this number one the Personnel that deals with special needs will not be properly equipped to do their job if they are not in the first three ranges or pick levels so secondly the district is not being responsible by trying to to lower the qualifications for the employees the district is not assisting this the first three ranks and their Specialties and continuing to uh solve the problem but to update the state so we want qualified people to deal with the students the district should offer trainings for the applicants so that they can get to the standards needed to be considered and the most important thing that we're seeing is that maybe all these people that are graduated from L USC with a d and maybe that's why they're

139not able to pass the testing required um they should be able to be in the first three ranks so they should be focusing on the solution for this problem not just ask for an extension to the state where our kids are undervalued and unsupported in the way that they should be if the state asks for these requirements ments that are usually the minimum you should comply and we understand that through the pandemic they could have been an important thing to have to consider but we're beyond that now and we want our students to have the qualified Personnel they deserve thank you and this is on behalf of Pac so I will have the letters here in case you did not receive it so Mr M can make C thank you for your time uh Maria

140I'm sorry Monica Rola Monica are you here uh David tolkovsky I saw you just a moment ago come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin sir item on the Personnel commission yeah okay thank you very much um I'm here to speak in favor of the waiver uh this shows that if there's any law code or any problem that prevents you to do something you tee up a waiver to the State Board of Education and so there used to be and the Personnel commission has done that and David Greco the executive director has used his authority with his Personnel commission which is independent from the superintendent board to ask that we get a waiver so that instead of just picking from the top three so principles can get the people they need

141at their school as fast as possible they're putting in for a waiver so anytime you hear uh from anybody oh we can't do that there's a law there's a rule you just say can we set up a waiver and I remember as a young teacher the president of the teachers union Helen Bernstein coming back one day to to Marshall High and saying oh my God I realized there's nothing we can't do all you have to do is Tee up a waiver but what you'll see here is these things come maybe like the the gandr in San Clemen or wherever they come in once a year we hardly ever ask for a waiver but we complain that the law the policy the air condition rules whatever it is are preventing us from doing something so I

142want to commend the Personnel commission for modeling this and occasionally uh Mr uh Pedro uh Alberto Pedro whoever you are there they haven't changed your name plate yet um does that because he used to do government relations so as new board members anytime you hear the we can't we can't just tee up a waiver and I'm here to support uh the help to both cssea who initiated this as well as the Personnel commission thank you very much thank you for your time uh before we move th on further on Tab 38 I'm going to read the um the public statement Tab 38 board report number 112 2425 request for board authority to purer a 2-year extension to the waiver of a portion of Education Code 45527 2A this statement is to be read before action

143is taken on this board report request for board authority to pursue a two-year extension to the waiver of portion of Education Code a constit uh a public hearing must be held this constitutes that public hearing on report 1122 2425 um and a maximum of of 15 individuals who wish to address the board and item will be heard those who wish to speak should sign up online and they already have speakers are being called by name and on to our next speaker we have a number of Callin folks that concludes our iners folks for Tab 38 uh Juan Carlos Delgado I see you're online Juan Carlos Delgado please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Juan Carlos Delgado yes Mr delato we can hear you please go

144ahead I will say in Spanish okay good afternoon everyone anything else may God bless you I'm member of pack newly we're going to the same thing with the same discussion about everything that affects us and the following is inaudible uh our kids have certain things what they need and the state of California has certain needs and they're not doing the minimum to meet the needs for the people that have invested years in the schools they want to do things in a different way and give these options to people that haven't even done the minimum uh our kids that are newly arrived to this country and need the at least the minimum to be oriented and this is very concerning I'm very concerned to see that these funds needed to train the necessary people now you

145want to hire people that can't do the minimum we already are out of the pandemic there are there is no need to continue that it doesn't cost the district anything to prepare and uplift them and not comply with a a lower standom let's comply with the the prerequisites needed we can't put in their hands of people that we don't know our children and we have problems today with safety and even then then the district wants to to amplify that problem and sometimes we don't know who the person will be that will be in charge of of that School site here I'm giving you the life of my student as a member of Pac we will not be in agreement with this the best option for the district two minutes to speak once you begin Maria

146Louisa Palmer good afternoon uh my name is Maria Lisa Palma and I am speaking on behalf of oada Inc a nonprofit organization I spoke to you on this topic back on November 12th to the committee of the whole uh I brought to your attention the lack of information that had been provided on this waiver to the parent advisory committee it was intended to be provided to them as an announcement as it had been done in Prior years for the prior to waivers that were approved by you that's how it was presented however the law requires that a parent committee be consultant for these waivers you did go back then that Alvarez and her team presented this waiver with a special request by the pack to them in December there were many extensive questions concerns and

147objections as were already read off to to you now I see this presented to you the board for consideration today but your board package does not say anything about what came out of that Committee of that special session it does not say that there were objections presented it all it says is that the waiver was presented to the labor partners and to the parent advisory committee and here today you put this item on consent did you not expect to have a discussion on what those outcomes were did you not want to know what the parents said on this point so it's a bit unbelievable that you continue to hide this information this information from the public how can this be a public hearing if the public doesn't know what the committee said what the labor

148Partners said on this point so I emailed all of this information to all of you back on November 14th I want the record to show these facts and also you should know that I will follow up with all of this information with the State Board of Education when and if you present this waiver request to them if you are going to have more waivers please make sure that you're not just using the parent committee as a rubber stamp please consider the parent voices uh with the documentation of what they have said please don't just consider this as a formality as a compliance item thank you thank you for your time I don't have any other folks signed in to speak uh remotely but I'm going to read through the names nevertheless to make sure that

149nobody inadvertently misidentified where they're where they're going to speak from juuv science juia Juan Jose mandhi are you here Mr Mr mandhi Maria Ortiz Marcela Garcia Karina Lopez Nelly Mendes Maria Torres and areli cabera okay those were folks who were signed up to speak remotely but um hold on I'm getting a call okay that concludes the public comment on Tab 38 and that concludes public comment on hey what's up we have a late arrival on Zoom so let me toggle over and the Maria Daisy Ortiz please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Maria Daisy Ortiz Miss Ortiz is going to speak in Spanish so if you don't have headsets yet please put your hands up and we'll get them to you good afternoon to everyone

150my name is Maria Ortiz I am a member of the community imp parent of La USD student and we are here as same as my colleagues in objection to the waiver that the district wants to create or wants to do because this makes the student not be able to be with capacitated employees and it's important that our children are competitive and for them to be ready for the world uh just like the superintendent has a slogan but in practice it looks very beautiful in the local but in Practical we are leaving and we are failing our students so that we can have Personnel that are not qualified and to displace Personnel that has been working gear but that the district is not giving the adequate prepar ation to this personnel and it's important for them

151to continue working within the district with the expectations and all the regulations that you have so that our children can be competitive and so that they can enter for your University a university a UC University but what happens is that many of our children graduate with a d so that the CH to the district says that we have 100% of graduation but the competitive when we don't have 38 or 40% therefore we can't force the future of our children with lies we need to be force of the future we need to secure a future not removing a future where is not compromised therefore we are an objection and many of the parents are asking for transparency for this information within all levels of the dis district and the district is far from complying with transparency

152and the training in all levels School levels District levels regions and Central districts and the connections and we also need to make that two-way connection and this is not happening this is why it's very important to make effective changes and necessary ones thank you and have a great evening okay that concludes public comment on the consent calendar it's now appropriate for um someone to move the consent calendar and a second so that the board may take a vote on it move it second so board president smelson moved and Dr Ras vice president seconded um if the audience could indulge me I want to encourage the board members who are probably taking lunch break to come in and to vote on this item now is that okay just take one moment e okay consent has been

153moved by board president schmon and seconded by vice president uh Dr Ras uh and U oh yes I believe we have a statement to be read by um board president schmon and let me just read you a statement about Charter School denial or approval so we're clear so as the fiduciary agent of the largest school district in the country with an elected board New York is the biggest but we have the largest as an elected board it's my obligation to protect the Integrity of the LA unified which includes serving as a responsible Charter School authorizer So currently LUSD authorizes more Charter Schools than any other District in the entire country and it is our job to ensure a fair consistent and Equitable process for all charter schools and make sure that the systems that we

154have in place follow the requirements set forth in law and policy for that reason the Board of Education relies on the expertise and the analysis of the charter schools Division and its related staff over the years my position has been to vote according to the recommendations of the superintendent through the analysis of the Charter School Division and now to provide some background for the general public I'd just like to start by explaining what it means to vote Yes and what it means to vote no specifically for the denials so for the denials a yes vote means that the board will approve the denial recommendation the school would then have the opportunity to appeal to Leo the Los Angeles County Office of Education and if Leo's board approved their petition they will be allowed to remain

155in operation under the oversight of Leo if Leo's board denies their petition then the school May appeal to the State Board of Education for a review under legal guidelines a no vote means that the board will not follow the staff's recommendation and that the school will be allowed to operate therefore staying under lausd's oversight jurisdiction and in order to avoid any confusion on this project I'd like to invite Mr Co Gutierrez so he can briefly explain the criteria that are being used when analyzing Charter renewals and my questions would be what are the most significant concerns that may lead a charter school to not be approved for Renewal and can you also explain any other information that is relevant for the charter schools division to consider prior to providing in a recommendation to the Board

156of Education Mr Co Gutierrez thank you board president and good afternoon to all appreciate the questions as a brief overview and again this this will be as brief as possible the district analysis of Charter School renewal petition applications first relies on the California Charter Schools Act and is completed within the timeline specified therein thus Upon A submission of a charter petition in the final school year of the charter term in which the charter school provides a certification that is complete District staff including the charter schools Division office of general councel and others comprehensively review the renewal petition application to determine whether the school has met the requirements set for forth in the Education Code and board approved policy further provides further guidance consistent with law to inform the district's implementation of the renewal process board

157president and board members the renewal criteria prescribed in the Education Code essentially require a three-pronged analysis think about this in three buckets again this is a brief overview first we review different aspects of the petition for example to do they have the required elements do they provide a reasonably comprehensive description the applicable affirmations and declarations among other factors secondly the district must consider whether the charter school is high middle or low performing as assigned by the state and we consider schoolwide performance and performance of all student groups on the California school dashboard and pursuant to law provide greater weight to performance on measurements of academic performance moreover Charter Schools may elect to submit with their petition verified data in accordance with the rules set forth by the State Board of Education and related definitions from

158the approved assessment providers showing either a the school has achieved measurable increases in academic Achi achievement as defined by at least one year's progress for each year in school or postsecondary outcomes equal to similar peers and thirdly staff considers whether the charter school is serving all pupils who wish to attend or if the charter school has substantial fiscal or governance issues each staff report for Renewal submitted to the board of education and posted publicly enumerate said criteria in more detail and so obviously won't go into everything this is based on a holistic review of the Charter School's performance to date and their petition application as noted with a focus on academic performance as stated now board president you inquired as to some main reasons for denial certainly the materials will enumerate those briefly for Charter

159Schools classified as middle performing of which there are three on this agenda recommended for denial respectfully the district must for example find that the charter school has failed to meet or make sufficient progress toward meeting standards that provide benefit to pupils of the school and the closure is in the best interest of pupils and its decision provides greater weight to the performance on measurements of academic performance to to determine closur is in the best interest of pupils pursuant to board approved policy staff compare specific areas of academic performance to that of applicable resident schools medians this is stated in board policy for a charter school classified as low performing of which there is one on today's agenda recommended for denial respectfully the law notes in brief that the author authorizer shall not renew but may

160Grant a two-year term if it makes both the following written factual findings one charter school is taking meaningful steps to address underlying causes of its low performance and those steps are reflected in a written plan adopted by the governing board of the charter school and two the board shall consider whether there is clear and convincing data demonstrated by verified data showing either the school achieve measurable increases in academic achievement as defined by at least one year's progress for each year in school or be strong postsecondary outcomes equal to similar peers finally sir to provide clear expectations and communication regarding Charter School renewal the charter schools division posts and provides charter schools with several technical tools and guides to support Clarity in the renewal application process including a webinar and other materials as well as all

161of our posted materials for all the renewals in this cycle I hope that answers your questions happy to answer any further at this time or later it does thank you so much Mr McAn okay moving on to the roll call vote uh for the consent calendar Miss nuell yes uh Dr Ras yes Mr melne yes Miss Grio yes Miss gones yes uh Miss Ortiz Franklin yes that was a yes uh board president president schmon yes and Miss Cortez Lopez she's at lunch we'll call uh so thank you very much the consent calender passes and now it is time to move on to the uh discussion items would you mind if we go to um 32 there's oh I I am so sorry yes uh Dr Dr revas and and Miss Newell thank you and I

162know there were some speakers I'm not sure if they're still here I get message that they may be outside so I think one one I was just notified that one speaker um is here now for uh tab 32 okay shall we hear from Mr Ali yes if we can hear them first thanks he here I can start and if maybe there okay yeah so we'll hear comments from uh board member nuel and Dr revas and then maybe the the speaker N I have it listed as nji alier but it might be njir Ali okay so again thank you for this opportunity um national day of uh racial healing for this year um this was established back in 2017 the national day of racial healing as a day of reflection in impacts of racism engagement in

163meaningful conversation and collectively working towards healing and creating a more just society and so in 2020 we want to create the national day of racial healing this Tuesday January 21st on this day people are encouraged to acknowledge the historical and contemporary realities of racism including systemic inequalities racism intersects with other forms of Oppression like gender class and sexual orientation this day of racial healing is a time to create space to open dialogue across racial divides where people can share experiences and build genuine relationships it is important to move Beyond just the conversation to concrete action like supporting policies that address racial disparities advocating for change within institutions and promoting racial Justice initiatives so we must emphas emphasize the need of comprehensive education about race and racism to promote awareness and understanding from a young age

164and as we are in the business of educating our students this is what we do as always education has been the key and this day national day of racial healing is not a one-time event but an ongoing commitment to racial Justice within this District thank you Dr Ras um I just wanted to make a few comments I also wholeheartedly support board member Hy new Bill's resolution to recognize January 21st 2025 is national day of racial healing within La USD and uh would be honored to be added as co-sponsor this resolution speaks to the very heart of our District's mission to create a just and Equitable learning environment for all students now more than ever with a new federal Administration seeking to Target our communities it is critical that we stand United against hate Division and

165discrimination this resolution reaffirms our commitment to equity and education Community engagement and internal practices addressing implicit bias and racial disparities in our schools I also encourage everyone in our school communities students parents teachers and staff to participate in the national day of racial healing resources are available at uh day of racial healing.org uh this can guide us in fostering understanding connection and systemic change together we must remain steadfast in building a foundation to a more just and Equitable future so thank you so much for bringing this forward thank you I'll note your added co-sponsorship and uh last call for Mr Ali are you here to speak to this item I be signed up to speak to tab 32 Mr Ali okay well we we generally make an effort for folks to have a chance to

166speak if we've missed them so maybe we'll hear from uh Mr Ali later and um board member Cortez Lopez can I get your advisory vote for the consent calendar that's a yes thank you so much okay so the consent calendar is uh concluded and now we move on to discussion items we have a number of discussion items to uh address some of which have public comment and some do not and let me just mention Mr McAn that from time to time you'll see board members moving to the Board Room uh there's always going to be four board members here including on screen for Zoom so we come back but we are watching we have a screen where we can watch what you're saying at the boardroom so you'll be seeing back and forth sometimes but

167we are watching what you are saying and the first item up for discussion is tab one approval of procurement actions and I believe we have questions or comments and input from Dr rias and board president sharlon um my first my only question I have for this um item is um or tab is item a the American institutes for research um so I don't know if we have somebody here from the Department so I'm excited um it's exciting to see the new multilingual Multicultural master plan and development it really is this is such an important work and I'm eager to learn more about it which is what my questions are alluding to and how and about how it will support our diverse Learners and Educators um to help me better understand the scope of this work

168and the direction revised to be revised in the plan I just have a few questions that weren't present in the board book or in the questions that we asked or the answers that we received um could you elaborate on specific areas uh where the revised multi lingual and Multicultural master plan will differ from the previous version and what new researcher insights have informed these changes and I have three other questions but I'll start with that one for the I'm sorry thank you for the question good afternoon board members Angela Sandal from Med representing uh Lydia Costa Stevens so some a lot of uh changes since our 2018 master plan which was uh English Learners and Standard English Learners now our master plan our 25 multilingual Multicultural master plan is inclusive of all our multilingual students

169in the district some of the uh new initiatives to mention and as well as new policies and account and accountabilities that will be reflected in the 2025 are for example the Strategic plan the expansion of the Dual language programs uh the increasing um identification of gifted St African-American gifted and latinx gifted students uh we have American Indian and education uh migrant education in our in our plan um we have the expansion of our world languages or World Language um multilingual Awards as well now at the state level and some accountabilities we're looking at the exito and promesa that will also be part of the new Master Plan we're looking at some changes with um assessments LP being a huge one lpac we have new policy changes with regards to uh secondary placement reclassification a lot

170of the new changes um I ready the inclusion of I ready and utk the exemption of utk being assessed so Ju Just to mention just a few of the major policy changes and accountabilities that have happened since 2018 there will also be changes in um the capacity building of our uh teachers professional development and new ways so all of that is included in there absolutely a lot of major changes with with uh regards to our instruction ction a lot of great resources or trifolds will be um showcased so not only will this be new policy or or updated policy but it will be an instructional resources for uh an instructional and a social emotional resource for our schools and we'll also include services for multilingual newcomer students essential services that they require that also be

171in there and partnering with different organizations yes my colleague Dr bosal can expand on that good afternoon uh board members yes of course uh given the large population of our International newcomer students and the areas where they reside there will be a whole chapter dedicated to our International newcomer students that will involve not just placement or coursework that they might uh need but also social emotional um resources and how that impacts obviously they're learning in the classroom as well as that family component that is so key and essential in making sure that our International newcomer students are successful great thank you so much I appreciate that um my next question um the item mentions research based instructional resources and guidance can you provide examples and I think you sort of mentioned some of these resources

172that might that might be included um and how will they support Educators in implementing the plan I'm sorry can you repeat the question um it's mentioned here research-based instructional uh resources and guidance that the American Institutes of research will be providing and just wanted to understand some of the examples of these resources what they might be including and the support for uh for educators in implementing the plan yes so um one of the major reasons uh with why we selected air American Institute for research is because of that National experience they have around research um some of the major pieces that we will be bringing in that they're going to support us with are the um the key practices for instructional and social emotional that they're seeing as being effective throughout throughout the different um

173um leas that they've supported and my last Christian um what is the anticipated timeline for the development and roll out of the revised plan and will there be opportunities for stakeholder feedback uh during the process I know the last one was in 2018 prior to that was 2012 2018 and now in 2025 so there been some changes so just wanted to see for this one just a timeline um for its development and feedback from the community our goal is to get this master plan finalized by may we are moving swiftly but cautiously to make sure we meet that timeline we realize that the current events have set back some of those timelines were completely being um flexible with our timing um the Community Partners School partners are the heart of this world work we need

174to ensure that we have their feedback we have scheduled some meetings um and we are looking at day byday to see what we need to reschedule uh just considering the current situation but we have a plan where we are meeting with various Partners in this work so that we get their feedback and we're also looking at um various surveys that we're putting out feedback forms to reach um as many people as possible wonderful thank you so much I just wanted to put on Rec everything that's going to be included in this new plan and also want to thank your staff and U mosa Stevens the executive director and all of you I know you're doing so much to provide for not only academically but social emotional and all the services that all of our multilingual

175Multicultural students and it's it's a big you know uh population very diverse so I know it's a lot of work so I want to thank you for your focus and all the work that you do so I'm looking forward to the plan in May and I know it's going to be fabulous thank you so much we appreciate your words and we're very excited as well yes thank you that's all okay my uh item is item H tab one Johnson Controls page 34 $1 million okay thank you for coming down Miss toes thank you so much so here's my question question uh it's really good when you've been a teacher at our schools and also been a principal at our schools because you have all different experiences those as a teacher and those as a principal

176and I know as a teacher I always wanted to have my own Bungalow room I didn't want to be in the building cuz I know that I controlled the temperature in my little Bungalow and I think you if you're a teacher you understand that so let's get to uh uh chillers and if everybody knows what a chiller is it's very interesting looks like waterfalls coming down a giant piece of equipment but when that Chiller stops there's no more air conditioning for the entire building so it's really important to make sure that chillers are maintained so that's my preface but here's my question as principal I remember seeing that our filter and the chiller had not been maintained for many many years and how did I know that I knew that because it was painted over

177and there was not a break where if you put a new filter in you'd see the break in the paint and you know it was done so it's very important that principles make sure that their chillers are maintained principles making sure that their Chiller is maintained don't they have enough to do at school yes of course they do but you have a plant manager and it's so important that the plant manager and the principal work together to make sure that these Chiller filters are changed and I think it's supposed to be every year so that is my question to you Miss toes how could we make sure that our filler uh filters are chained and our chillers every year like they're supposed to be uh good afternoon members of the board Christina toes Chief facilities

178executive so first when it comes to filters our maintenance schedule for replacing filters is quarterly every year um with the event as I'm sure many of you just heard with the fire event we were able to inspect all of our filters and replace those that needed to be replaced so please know we regularly um inspect them and change them out quarterly with this invent we were able to look at all of this this particular contract item H is um for Johnson Controls to do the service and repair of a specialized it's called a York branded Chiller um and these are at 39 schools we also have contracts for other types of chillers obviously their specialization and we want to make sure that we have the contract capacity to address all the different types of chillers

179that we have across the over 115,000 chillers that the district has in the district and I appreciate that and I know that our air filters are changed all the time that I can guarantee cuz I see it myself but I guess it's important that the principal and the plant manager coordinate to make sure that that maintenance for the chiller is being done because when that goes down everybody in the building suffers and complains to the principal so thank you so much okay are there any further questions on Tab one no further questions on Tab one more questions for coming on Tab one sorry one more one more so sorry I was uh too excited with uh Chillers um tab one item I Yonder Yonder bags pouches I never heard of a Yonder pouch in my

180whole life until now just so you know so thank you Mr jate sure so uh there's a $3 million contract for Yonder Incorporated so now that the schools have decided what methods this is about cell phone storage by the way everybody cell phones now that schools have decided what methods will be used at their sites and some have Place orders already for Yonder bags I'd like to request that the board receive the data by Board District on the percentages and the numbers of schools that have chosen pouches or other meth methods of storing the cell phones these bags are very expensive and I'd like to know how they're being purchased by District we'll be happy to get that for you okay thank you okay thank you any further questions on Tab one um would anyone

181like to move the item to for vote I'll move it okay move by uh board member gones seconded by Dr revas uh Miss nuel yes Dr Ras yes Mr melin yes uh Miss greo yes Miss gones yes Miss Ortiz Franklin uh board president schmon oh I hear a yes is that a yes um Miss orti Franklin yes thank you so much and board president schmon yes an advisory vote from Miss corz Lopez yes seven eyes now on to tab two uh approval of facilities contracts actions it's up for discussion I believe Mr mvo has a comment and I believe we have one speaker to this item uh Andrea Palmer are you here Andrea Palmer to speak on Tab uh two procurement services division facilities contracts on tab two Mr tolkovsky you're indicating to me that

182you you are also signed up I don't have you signed in and you you prior spoke on a public hearing that's correct okay okay Mr toosi to tab uh to procurement services division uh Miss Palmer has not showed up so it's your time to shine sir you have two minutes to speak once you begin board members um I'd like to speak uh to you about the Fairfax uh High School um there's a comprehensive or major modernization project there and uh I go back to 2016 when I was given a call because the high school was not responding to an alumni who was calling to donate to the school in fact he had been trying for two years we had changed three principles during the time and wasn't getting a call and this is somebody who

183now is donated to uccla USC and his other Alma moders uh lacc's build building a major gallery and so I met a person who was not like other people in my life who was a giver made a lot of money and he wanted to give in fact I chose to advocate for him and I chose to Advocate and many of you know him many of you don't know but I would say to you the item before you is not as comprehensive of modernization as it should be and uh they'll you'll have to make an amendment to go from the 149 in item J to add the new cost because there were only two biders in the entire State of California who responded to this and that amount of money should also be advocated to show

184your commitment to the Arts this is one of our our most successful magnet schools has over 400 kids in the Fine Arts and the idea grew to be to add a community and Art Space show your commitment by adding not just the 149 but add the new cost and add the uh successful addition Monies to put for the students additional classrooms and additional um uh space for the community to commit to the Arts this was started before proposition 28 start was passed this was started before measure us $9 billion was passed this is before CBS Studios just sold and is building 2 million 2 million square ft which will be 10 or 11 million of developer fees impact fees for that Community show your will and show your commitment by adding what is necessary from

185148 to 175 and add this space thank you very much for your time thank you for your time sir and I believe uh board member Melvin you have a yeah thank you Mr McLean and and thank you Mr takowsky as well I was not on the board in 2016 but since being on the board have engaged with uh this incredibly generous Alum and others on on a vision for his ization and also this specific space and potentially the opportunity to do this at more schools you know I don't want to delay this project today um I think it's important it goes forward for the Fairfax Community that's been working for a while to get uh their their modernization approved it's this is an iconic La high school that I'm proud to represent and we have

186a new gym and we have um a lot of uh structural uh repairs that are part of it I I agree that there's not as much cosmetically um that I think the school deserves and I'd like to see us do more including potentially this building I'd like to maybe ask Miss toes you know the I know that we have not and the board report says as much identified uh the funding for this for this project uh I hear and what Mr tofsky and others are saying around developer you know impact fees and uh in the bond dollars I also think when I when I looked at the actual bid for this Arts Fairfax space which you know back of the envelopes comes out to like $44,000 a square foot it just seems insane to me

187and doesn't passed like a basic smell test of that that's feasible but I also understand um that uh that just adding kind of this this this number without kicking the tires when there are other District needs it might not be prudent so I'm hoping if you can talk a little bit what my what my interest would be today is approving the project but asking you potentially to kind of rebid working with this Alum uh the specific project the approval the designs that he did himself and that are already approved by the division of State Architects and come up at a you know come up with a reasonable number for what this might cost and then work with the the Alum of Fairfax and maybe the philanthropic Arts Community the city council Office television City and

188others and then potentially get ask this board to commit some of our public dollars for a true public private partnership that benefits the community and the Arts so I guess you know it's I'm not I'm not comfortable going forward without addressing this I also think that adding the 11 million for a project that I think should be significantly under is not the course of action too and I know I've spoken to the superintendent about this as well but if you could just address that sure good afternoon um definitely we appreciate moving forward with this contract um and we can reserve the right to continue to identify funds and bid out this project separately if needed yeah because again I think it's a it's a model of of what we can do not just as a

189as an art space for the school but given where this was located on Melrose as an art space for the Community I think it could be something that could be you know there are certain things like the greenway core theater on Fairfax which is on Fairfax there are also such a community benefit this could be a new one and I'm really grateful to Steve uh the the the um the alums Vision on this I think we just need us identify the funding and identify the true costs and then work with some philanthropic Partners to see what we can do so we'll continue those conversations and come back soon uh but let the rest of this project go forward understanding that the footprint will stay okay thank you are there further questions on uh tab two

190okay uh would there be a motion to vote on this tab move to approve all right moved by orgones seconded by Dr Rivas uh Miss nubel yes Dr Ras yes Mr melne yes uh Miss G yes Miss gonz yes Miss Ortiz Franklin yes that's a yes and board president Schmelson has stepped away for a moment uh and student board member cortz Lopez yes seven that's seven eyes okay the next item is tab five to find and approve seven playground campus exterior pro upgrade projects uh we have public comment on that item that we will take just one member Rachel T is signed up to speak remotely Rachel t for tab five Rachel T is not on the line Rachel T are you in the room so that concludes public comment for tab five and we

191have a couple of questions on Tab five it looks like from Dr rias and uh board member Grio yes um well I I'm voting yes I just wanted to ask Miss Christina toes there she is just to um answer maybe some of the concerns that the board of um the bond oversight committee made at their meeting if you can just address some of their concerns there were I know there were some and also some um some requests from information so if you can just address some of their points absolutely good afternoon members of the board Christina toes Chief facilities executive um there were really three issues that the bond oversight committee expressed concern of the first one was a um request that the district look at increasing shade from 20% um we did provide them

192with information that the district's uh green schoolyards for all plan referred ref to a goal of 20% shade that exceeded what the board resolution called for which was 30% green because we know that there may be spaces that you could have green but it would not have shade on it so we included 20% and that comes from the 2019 California Green Building standards code called Cal green which requires shade tree planting to provide shade of 20% for landscaped and Hardscape areas um with specific parameters so that's where that 20% came from um the other issue that they wanted uh to make sure we addressed had to do with enrollment and to ensure that these schools were not being considered for possible consolidation we did provide them with that insurance these schools were actually identified as

193having the worst Paving conditions um but also having the highest enrollment in those board districts of those schools because these are large budget projects um just due to the extent of the work that we have out there and we want to ensure that we're impacting the most amount of students there was also a concern about cool coating um we are where we are putting asphalt back we are putting cool coating typically in like the striped areas of handball courts or basketball courts um we do receive positive impact or feedback from our schools about cool coding um as it is perceived to be much uh um sought-after than just black asphalt the office of ecos sustainability is doing an analysis comparing cool coating to Black asphalt um they anticipate that that will be done in the

194fall they want to make sure that they're capturing temperatures in the summer heat um which is why that we'll have those results after thank you that answered all my questions that I had here which is in terms of the cool coding so we're doing an analysis of that so thank you so much appreciate that thank you hi thank you um I have a question regarding Community excuse me and parent input was there any uh parent input and Community input as to how these were going to be done the kinds of things that the community wanted to see and if there was um how was that done and when was it done thank you so the action here today will allow us to then incur the funds to start that Community engagement process on the planning

195and the design so at this point there hasn't been any planning or design done we don't start that until we go to the board for that funding approval that kicks off our ability to then hire Architects planners do our due diligence and that starts our community engagement process with the school we include both the School site the staff and the parents and Neighbors from that Community um we have a very robust Community engagement process where we first share with them what the kind of goals of the project is lead them through preliminary designs get their input before we do final design and then we carry out that process even during the construction process so that they're assured that all of the safety considerations are taken into account and they know when construction activities are occurring

196and then just a follow up on the co coding how do we decide whether we're going to use cool coating versus getting rid of the asphalt and pl putting in Greening yes so the intent of these projects is so that they would meet the board's resolution of uh 30% green and then in those um activities that happen on hardcourts which is like the ones like basketball handball the little tracks those are where we put the cool coating back basically anywhere that we have asphalt on these projects we want to include cool coating because we do find that it relieves just the overall conditions of the area that will still have asphalt for those particular play um functions okay goes go ahead um thank you uh I look forward to the analysis on the cool coding

197I know that that's an ongoing topic of discussion I think as far as the particular schools that we're serving I know that that has been a question that's been raised with regard to the PACE up projects in the past and obviously this first set of 30 schools is already identified and we're moving forward but just uh for future Bond implementation work I I hope that we can uplift the needs of the schools that are at the very bottom in terms of Greening we know that so many you know 205 right of our elementary schools have less than 10% um of green space on their playgrounds and well these schools certainly have um asphalt and pavement needs um I think in light of the climate issues that we are already experiencing just want to uplift those

198schools the very neediest to hopefully the top of the list for future Pace up projects um I think there's a way that we can balance both the safety with regard to Pavement but also the the urgent need to to provide that green space for those highest need schools thank you any other questions on this item okay so we can uh call for a vote just a a motion to move it second moved by Miss gonz seconded by Dr Ras uh Miss nubel yes Dr Ras yes Mr melbin Miss grigo yes Miss gonz yes Miss Ortiz Franklin so sorry yes yes from Miss Ortiz Franklin and board president schmon has also stepped out and Miss Cortez Lopez advisory vote Yes okay we will keep that item open just to record Mr uh board president's uh vote

199so now I know that we have item seven that there was a question so go ahead Mr mcy okay um so who had a charlet there you are sorry I had a question um not sure exactly uh if facilities can answer this um with our Towers um because obviously I know nothing about radio towers but that there's one that we have in Rancho uh Palace verus where uh now I'm knowing that the ground is Shifting and so um and we've been leasing this one since 1997 and we must obviously have a need for more uh and so the question I have is how many of the towers do we have do we currently have and uh what is the total cost for radio transmission so I'm so Kettle Chief Information officer uh we are in

200charge of Main in and supporting ra emergency radio communication system in the district uh in its and as far as the number of towers we have five Towers across the city they are strategically located north south east west across the city to cover the all the areas of the jurisdiction that we have um the cost it depends on the Tower and the location we have multiple locations some of them owned by the city and we rent them in a different rate sometimes they rented by the from the private Tower owners and this is one of them and I believe this Tower uh is about um if I'm not mistaken is about $130 or $150,000 uh for the uh essentially rent of the tower itself as far as Shifting the uh Palace verus we evaluated uh

201the location is not in the danger zone so it still it provide us the coverage and is not part of the shift and movement um although that can change if it changes uh we need to find a new location for the tower but it's not just us entire city relies on this including LAPD uh fire department lafd everybody utilizes these towers for the same type of coverage okay and then one other question how does it affect TV like our transmission TV or no this is not for TV this is for um radio communication that being used for emergency from schools to the dispatch from our transportation services and from our school Police Department okay and then last what is the plan if it does go down what is our plan for that so on top

202of these five Towers we have uh seven site we call them microwave sites that essentially they connect the sight to site connection between the sites as a backbone to hold the connection up and running if the towers goes any of this Tower goes down additionally um as part of our program we deploy we procured the portable Tower at the time of emergency any of these Tower goes down there is a special truck we deploy to the location to Temporary replace the tower until the team can re restore the service on the tower to come up uh there is another alternative the third one if you lose everything uh we have an our school police has an agreement with the uh LAPD to use their frequency at the time of emergency thank you especially in these

203times just wanting to know thanks thank you okay next item any further questions on Tab S and a motion to approve so moved second move by Miss GES seconded by board president schmon here we go on the vote Miss nubel yes Dr Ras yes Mr melbin Miss Grio Miss gones yes Miss Ortiz Franklin yes or president sharlon yes and Miss corz Lopez yes okay let's return to the vote for um board president Schmelson on Tab uh five yes and say yes on Tab five and how about on tab two yes okay so we are awaiting uh votes on Tab five and seven moving down to tab 14 request for approval of 2025 advocacy agenda and guiding principles and priorities I have questions um from most of the board members so however you'd like to take

204them uh board president sharlon I I'll go last okay I'll do mind I go um hello Miss Alvarez I just um wanted to I I noticed that in the priorities I didn't see Community Schools um at least for in our legislation I don't know if that was something that we failed to ask um if to add that if it's too late to just had Community Schools that was something that was brought up it's a good afternoon Martha alvare chief of governmental relations um it's so uh thank you for for this opportunity to address any questions you may have um the board will be asked today to adopt two items one is the advocacy agenda which includes our local state and federal priorities and and our proposed um sponsor legislation for 2025 in addition to that

205um advocacy agenda we also have um uh updated guiding PR principles and priorities a seven-page document that highlights various um different priorities aligned to the Strategic plan uh the board and superintendent priorities um that we've discussed previously uh it's my recollection that while you don't see it here since this as you can see it's a two-page document very focused um my my recollection is that we did include in this document the seven page document um a reference to Community Schools if you give me a minute I can try to identify where it might be located but uh if it's there I just wanted to make sure that we highlighted not only in in the in both in the priorities and that it's consistent on both sides just to make sure that it's highlighted because we

206do have a number of um Community Schools and want to make sure that we are advocating and um that we have the budget to sustain those schools so if if I may I found it thank you for the 20 seconds so it's on the last page of the document uh on the guing priorities supporting the whole child um what we have here um so explains what supporting the whole child means and we have um supporting ongoing funding for Community Schools yeah we just added on the other um the the one and you know for discussion for you know should you want to discuss with the board um the one concern as at the staff level is that this document if we were to add seven pages worth of priorities from this document then this would

207become a 20page document so we we wanted to focus um on what is uh not to say that this won't be be priorities but they're complimentary um and that's what the what this document was meant to be um this document has a lot of other priorities the board has identified previously uh for example one example I have mentioned beforehand is uh gun safety it's a priority that the board has outlined in previously um in through board resolutions and other items um instead of including uh that we'll advocate for legislation or funding run gun safety uh we included gun safety as a board priority prity under the guiding principle priorities under the safety aspect so again they're meant to be complimentary but if we included everything from what is a board resolutions what is in this

208very comprehensive document then this would no longer be a two-page um focus document but we intend to look at legislation funding proposal from Sacramento and the federal government uh to be able to um advise what we pursue in in our advocacy um well thank you for explaining that that makes total sense I just know that there were some concerns that didn't see it so now it's on record that it is part of the overall priority so thank you for making that clear to us and I just have one other just you know question you know given the limited resources and hostility from the incoming Federal Administration how do we strategically allocate our time and energy between defending existing policy winds and advancing our key advocacy priorities for 2025 and Beyond so knowing what is to

209come come um on January 20th what you know what what is just the focus on your office and and um tackling that challenge yes so um in in the under the advocacy and we have can have two complimentary much more extensive document um under the advocacy agenda we do have outlined some of those key areas for for advocacy uh we do mentioned um proactively How we'll be focusing around immigration related um supports for our families newcomers and other impacted family members um but then we also um acknowledge in this document much more extensive three paragraphs of federal federal priority um it is under uh page five uh three paragraphs we go into much more detail that both is um uh proactive and also ensuring that we can be reactive to anything from the federal Administration

210um uh so so I believe I I uh that our current language will allow us to give us the opportunity to address both uh proactively and also address any areas that we um uh we foresee coming um I also want to acknowledge um since it was a request from board president shlon at the committee of the whole meeting when I presented this um draft emerging priorities on November 12th board president Schon made a request um to work towards a congressional uh delegation from La uh convening uh is something that myself and my team are working on over the hopefully sometime in February um uh more to come uh uh about the participation um and any any potential limit ations um uh regarding um the scope of the the conversation um but that would be an

211opportunity to be able to address with our Congressional Delegation some of the areas for example uh proactively continue to advocate for increased funding for special education through Ida this year 2025 is a 50th Anniversary when Ida was passed so that would be an example of proactively advocating but at the same time talk to our delegation about concerns we have around the Trump Administration um uh immigration enforcements ction to our budgets through Title One or other um other potential reductions that we might see from the federal government so um thank you for bringing that forward and um would' be happy to provide more feedback to you um in the coming weeks as and of course let us know what you think also thank you and let's you know please you know keep us AB breast so

212that us board members can also be a part of that strategy I know that um I've been you know in communication with both our state and federal uh Congressional leadership um so I know that they're looking for us also to help and of course I'll let them know that you're on top of it but I know that you know if whatever support or help that we can also provide in making sure that the priorities that you've that are mentioned here in the strategy is you know being as forceful and um effective and efficient as possible so thank you for all your work I know that your staff um worked very diligently to make it very succinct and include all of our priorities um and and sort of focuses for our um Board District so thank

213you Miss elvers that's all for me yes um well I thank you Miss Alvarez and your team um you are such strong advocates for our district and I think particularly as we Face uh not the friendliest Partners in different parts of our government um I just appreciate all of your work and I know we have a very strong team um in Sacramento and in Washington DC um I also appreciate just the uplifting of um our most vulnerable communities our immigrant students our early Learners our greeting efforts and then the incorporation of federal recognition for our first peoples um following up from our land acknowledgement resolution in November um as well as the inclusion of our before and after school programs um and getting the appropriate reimbursement rates for those programs um two uh two things

214I wanted to uplift one is our efforts to secure an alternative reimbursement rate methodology for our child care programs we know that the low amount that is provided for child care programs which include our District programs as well as home and family-based providers um mean that our childcare workers do not get the types of supports and resources that they need to really support our youngest Learners so I appreciate that the guiding principles includes this um in in the list of items and I hope that we can work to Advocate and partner um with all of the many child care providers in LA county to ensure that our state funds child care and early learning and support support for families at the levels that we really should um so that our babies and todders get the

215supports that they need um I also wanted to raise um sort of a a unique and specific issue uh so here in the district we have the Carlson Home Hospital which operated until the until the start of the school year an online program um Carlson services our students with temporary disabilities so who either through an illness an injury or other extenuating circumstances cannot attend school in person and for many of these families the Online Academy that Carlson offered um was really a Lifeline I heard directly from over a hundred families on this and due to a an update to the statute and guidance this program was no longer allowed to continue um a temporary online program for a Home Hospital School I hope that this is an issue that we can take up I know

216that our Virtual Academy does provide long-term online options um but the students who were serviced by Carlson were there for temporary circumstances and I think it makes a great deal of sense that if our students are immunal compromised they're facing severe illnesses that an online program would meet their needs but they may only need it for a temporary basis and so I hope that uh through some of the broader language in this document we can ensure that we're meeting the needs of these really vulnerable students um and finding Partners within our federal or state government excuse me either through regulations updates guidance um or statutory changes so that we can bring back a program like this thank you thank you Nick go ahead thank you Mr smon thank you Miss Alvarez I was watching the

217discussion in the back um just echo my colleagues uh sentiments around gratitude for your team um when I meet with uh um uh State officials and and legislators as unfortunately I've had to do more this week given the emergency response they always just have the nicest things to say about you and your advocacy um so appreciate all that you're doing I guess the only thing um you know uh one thing that's not on our advocacy list but I know we've discussed is and maybe we can have a followup at some point is it's it's been a priority of mine and I I know this board to open up our school communities as parks on the weekend um given we're a park poor region and we have you know nearly a thousand schools in every neighborhood

218not a thousand schools in every neighborhood but thousands of schools at La and we have a partnership where uh with the city where we've been opening a few and some neighborhood councils and philanthropists are also helping us open more but it really if it were up to me we'd open every school on the weekend and it's a question of funding but also liability um and you know my understanding is that we've been haggling with both the city and the county over some of that liability and so potentially I know there's some uh similar ex uh exceptions at the state level for shared use but if we could get something in state law that says there's either limited liability or joint liability I think it would enable us to move forward those Partnerships so that would

219be a big one just because I think schools should be open you know on the weekends um the second one which I know is in there but just given and I know the first week of school has been overshadowed by other things but this is the second week of our phone- free school policy um and you know since the board passed that resolution uh months ago I think half of America's schools are under some sort of cell phone restriction and think we're going to see more CU it's so important for kids mental and physical health and so just you know anything we can do to continue to support legislation and funding I know we talked about Yonder patches earlier around limits on smartphones and social media which have proven harmful to kids um learning and

220their well-being and then finally you know and I I don't feel the need to say make a a physical amendment to this because I know it's on your in the superintendent radar but I just assume we're also going to be advocating at the state and local level around uh emergency relief and response efforts um you know I know that I've given my constituents my assurances that we'll do everything we can to not let bureaucracy or regulatory burdens get in the way of of relief rebuilding I know I think even today the city council may be taking up an issue uh a motion for some short-term regulation or short shortterm um relief uh or waivers to certain conditional use permits you know if a school and this is not as relevant it might be relevant for

221p high it's it's not as relevant for our elementary schools cuz we found District spaces so quickly but if there's temporary office space uh or warehouse space or factory space that is safe and can temporarily house P high or a school in Pasadena or even an independent school making sure that the city has waved what's needed so that they can you know we're not take uh delaying kids from being back in person with their community and their teachers because of unnecessary burden so that would just be the one I I don't I'd want to advocate for uh in the immediate term is both at the city and county level but also the state level relief efforts and just you know I don't want to hear that any bureaucratic burdens are in the way of getting

222kids back in school Mr uh president if I may briefly address that the two thank you for the feedback board M regarding the the city uh School District sites for Community use we do have a bullet point under local priorities it reads expand joint use facility agreements and programming for students through continued Partnerships with regional Recreation and Parks departments um so it's in the spirit of that intent um and we look forward to continue to work with the city and the county um regarding the the current emergency uh facing our communities um we do have some flexibility that we wanted to build into the agenda I'll briefly just mention this for the board's awareness um under the advocacy priorities first paragraph on this um handout it says in addition to the issues identified below the

223office of governmental relations supports and advocates for legislative proposals and initiatives that are consistent with the Strategic plan and will pursue so necessary policies and funding in 2025 as new issues arise so we we I built in that flexibility to ensure that we had the opportunity to work on issues like the ones you're um bringing up today thank you in in addition to the maybe local uh you know cup um relief the other one uh just to put on your radar that I think will be relevant for the superintendent as well is we we're already hearing from some of my constituents who don't know where their kids will physically be for the next few weeks and so even though tomorrow we will quite miraculously open up P elementary and Marquez Elementary at their new sites

224we know that there are families who won't be there tomorrow um it might not be there next week uh but might be there in 3 weeks or might have to temporarily enroll in another school and so just you know attendance flexibility both so that those uh kids aren't deemed Trent but also so that the school is not losing funding or getting penalized for things that are outside of their control and so I know there's already some relief in state law but you know I I want to make sure that you know families are taking care of their needs and if that means their kids aren't back in school in a few weeks because they're just physically not here want to make sure that we can provide as much relief as possible so thank you thanks

225he Carla thank you uh Miss Alvarez um I want to Echo the appreciation uh for the work that you do and your sta with your staff does and also for laying out what the priorities are and some of the strategies that you're going to use to uh make these things happen I also want to thank you clarifying that Community Schools are part of our priorities I see Community Schools are not only the Hub of resources but they can be places that can really help fight the Trump the Trump agenda um secondly as you know we all work with different elected leaders local or at the state level um as well as uh Community organizations that are on the ground who are going to be fighting this um agenda and so I'd like to know what

226can we do to support your work um in both not only with elected leaders but also with Community organizations that are going to be doing this work and it's important um that we not only support our legislators who are doing this but also the community organizations who are building this movement to fight back um any attacks against our immigrant students and our lgbtq plus uh population thank you very much um I work very closely with uh my colleague saroni uh from our Communications um Community engagement and uh salong title I'm forgetting one other word um Community engagement um office um around Partnerships with our government uh local um nonprofit uh Partners um I convene as part of the stre plan one of the goals that we have is to increase participation of Our Community Partners

227um we are having another virtual comenting on February 26 at 10 a.m. specifically about advocacy um so we aiment of quarterly briefings with our Community Partners um we typically get about 100 participants uh give or take um so should anyone be interested that you know would like to participate uh you can refer them to ceremony or myself I would be happy to engage them uh once um we get underway uh both in Sacramento the legislature has until uh the third week of February to introduce legislation um with the Trump Administration starting next week um taking office uh we'll definitely be having a calls to action um we have a large distribution list where we engage our partners be able to do um uh Coalition letters that's another metric that we have in the Strategic plan

228trying to increase the Coalition letters that we build um the good rapport with our local Partners or Statewide Partners um and Al also at the federal level um so rest assur that we'll be doing a lot of Coalition building um specifically on our immigration we already have a working group uh with many dozens of local uh Partners um uh many of them that you you work with and know uh around immigration related um uh just not only how do we work together but also how do we share information and ensure that we're serving our families and those most vulnerable so more to come um but we have um many areas in the coming weeks where we'll be engaging the partners student board member anything to add from the students point of view yes again just

229would like to Echo my gratitude from my peers the students on your continuous efforts to Advocate especially for undoc undocumented populations especially with the current federal opposition that will come in the next coming weeks um um I look forward to seeing how this continued advocacy will pan out and see how the protections for our undocumented student populations um will turn out in in light of federal opposition I do look forward to the expansion of uh newcomer students and their insights on these current ideas and to ensure that our campaign that ensures that our district remains Sanctuary District that the protections are advertised correctly to students that this information is is made aware to our to our student populations and that the information is best distributed uh to all students to whom it may be relevant

230so thank you thank you okay thank you uh Martha you know you must have read my mind about the uh uh Congressional Delegation because I was going to ask you that question so it's going to have to happen as soon as we possibly can and I know you're doing your best to do that but not only can we ask questions about uh the trunk the Trump uh inauguration but other questions to them about special ed funding about title funding climate change and other topics at the same time so that'll be a great meeting that we can have and they are our elected officials and we vote for them and I think they should respond to our needs can you answer a question about what advancements we're making in housing advocacy for students staff and families

231anything off uh the top of your head you think of what we're doing uh specifically around our our um unhoused student population or just housing uh just more housing for for housing in general yeah um so we have um I am proud to say that in my five years plus with the school district we have sponsored a minimum of three maybe four bills um since 2020 uh regarding housing flexibility at the state level the most recent bill was two years ago um at this time working with our attorneys to our office of General Council and our facilities Department um we do not have a at this time um uh impression that there's anything else any barriers in Sacramento that we need to modify um much of what uh the the potential next steps would be

232uh private capital and other needs at the local level um but at the state level um there has not been anything else that we have been able to identify that needs to be changed um as much as finding those Partnerships with the developers or private markets or others who can help Finance um but we will stay tuned should it be something that the state legisl um looks into in the coming year thank you very much and my last question is not directly to you but I guess I guess to the superintendent and staff uh the 20th of this month is when the new Administration will be installed and I'm just wondering how much information our schools have about what to do if there's a problem with people coming onto campus regarding immigration I mean there

233should be a script that the principles the assistant principles and office managers and Office Clerks and teachers know exactly what to do so they don't have to get worried and think about what am I supposed to do they know it because we practice it just like we practice drills go ahead thank you Mr schmon uh so in the week prior to the wildfires we had already distributed guidance around the reference reference guide that addresses exactly what you brought up protocols for schools if someone representing themselves as an agent around immigration should arrive at the school this week if not for the fires would have been when we would have done at every single school we would have done a faculty presentation and we also would have done a parent presentation of course that did not

234happen given the circumstances so our plan again all conditions permitting is that next week we will train up our principles which is again what would have happened last week and therefore they'll be ready to train their staff and inform parents in Greater detail yeah thank you Mr CH because that preparation is what really counts thank you critical any other comments we're good thank you thank you Miss Cortez Lopez one more question um in regards to our priorities for increased College awareness and access I'm wondering if increased access to standardized testing material is included in that um regarding the increase in colleges that are now requiring SAT and ACT um to be admitted or for their application for colleges this was recently um included in many colleges Across the Nation and increasing our access to standardized

235testing material would greatly bring down the burden for students who may not have access or the economic freedom to get a private tutor or any other college access materials um I can follow up with I don't know Dr would like to um to address this issue but it might be something that we can mayble to support locally with that any advocacy at the state level we will definitely explore that further because that's a wonderful opportunity for our students we already offer some of that testing and prep work but we can explore that further thank you very much Martha last chance any questions okay Mr McAn okay can we have a motion to take the tab motion second so moved by uh Dr Ras and seconded by sound of sounded like got to it okay uh

236Miss nubell yes Dr Ras yes Mr melne yes U Miss Grio uh Miss gonez yes Miss Ortiz Franklin yes that's a yes from mortiz Franklin and board president scharon yes okay uh Mr M can I register my affirmative votes for tab five and tab uh seven seven tab five and seven affirmative votes from Mr Melo okay that brings us to tab 16 I have a uh public hearing statement to read on Tab 16 before any action is taken on on that item uh this is for tab 16 board report number 152 2425 denial of the renewal petition for creit academy uh before action is taken on this board report denial of the renewal petition for cre Academy a public hearing must be held this constitutes that public hearing on report number 152 d2425 denial of

237the renewal petition for creed Academy and a maximum of 15 individuals who wish to address the board and item will be heard those who wish to speak should ALS o sign up online good morning before my time starts I did want to add two things I wanted to hand this to the board please I'll get them yeah of course it's a support letter from Dr Tyrone Howard at UCLA as a resident of the crch district and also of Altadena this has been a really tough week um my sister lost her home my uncle uh lost his home and my parents are currently staying with me they've been evacuated um and so at the same time there is a school in Pasadena the rosebud Academy where um my mentor is the founder and she also lost

238her school and her home so as we do these relief efforts um I would implore this board to please support the Altadena Pasadena Community uh she gave us our first start in education and has been a huge support to us thank you um um I'm also doing a uh slide presentation that has not uh been started so I just kindly ask if my time could restart and the slide presentation and I was also supposed to have a clicker there it goes in the clicker is this theck all right my name is Brett Mitchell I'm the co-founder of creed Academy we have a very unique mission to break the cycle of homelessness and South Central Los Angeles um as you can see I am black my wife is black um and we are uh natives of

239the kral community homelessness in our city is skyrocketing um it's up 45% with the families that we serve since last year and across all uh County Schools it's going up 25% every year since Co the only place that it's going down is at Creed Academy our founder has designed a program called the harmony program which is aimed at meeting the basic needs of all students um and making sure that housing mental health support Medical Dental um counseling parenting classes is all provided on site at no cost to every family that attends we currently have 300 students 105 which are unhoused um 2 minutes isn't a lot of time um but we have been um low we we've been deemed low performing because one out of the eight years we've been at in action um we

240have low test scores and unhoused students face significant challenges their test scores are have been low for the last 80 years in our district um when you're unhoused there are significant challenges daily that the average student in the state which only 2% of the the other schools in our city have unhoused students we have 33% we have 15 times the amount of unhoused students and we serve them daily we've housed over 100 families this year we've housed 10 families we provide a th000 students yearly with mental health support and when they ask about my action plan which is what I've been uh told to speak about and we will my action plan is to keep serving my community and making sure the most vulnerable members of our community are housed their basic needs are met

241and we continue to do the work that is most important uh not just now but since we've started in 2016 thank you thank you for your time and now we have a number public speakers also speaking to the item correct we do but um I I've told that we would be discussing um some of the findings I'm looking forward to discussing the findings with um absolutely let me explain to the audience how the process goes so for each uh Charter School item that is uh heard on discussion first we take all the public comment and then the discussion period for that item begins with the board so that all the information is had from the public comment and then a full Thro of discussion can be had so um does that make sense perfect sense

242thank you okay so I'll call on the folks who are here in person and then we have um just a couple that are calling in remotely barington more are here come on up obviously feel free to y'all stand up there there's no need to sit down and stand up and all that so please go ahead the two minutes is yours sir afternoon to the board my name is baring toore and I'm proud to serve as the assistant principal of curriculum instruction at Creed Academy four years ago I started and I began my journey as a teacher here and today I stand before you as someone who not only works in the community but was was raised in it I grew up just a few blocks where Creed Academy m stands and I know what it

243means to be a part of this community and I also know what it feels like to be homeless riding a two-hour bus ride to an affluent Community chasing the opportunities that I deserved Creed Academy is now that beacon in our community right here and it faces challenges but we've taken bold and decisive action we've adopted a data driven plan to raise test scores we've revamped our curriculum to align with the district standards we built tiered intervention systems and implemented I ready as an intervention to meet every student where they are today but we don't stop there this year we worked diligently to ensure that our petition patient rates are well and far beyond 95% for the fall and winter assessments currently our teachers have been progress Mar students every month to ensure academic growth and

244through our consistent communication with families targeted Outreach and building community and a culture of accountability we've demonstrated how every voice and every student matters in our Collective growth we've also hired a MTH specialist to implement a cast plan that includes practice tests targeted fiab questions established onetoone technology for all of our students computer literacy and for all third through sixth grade students we've incentivized academic achievement with field trips culture building presentations and we provide instructional coaches and professional development for our teachers we partner with programs like the cymc and schools on Wheels to provide toting for our unhoused students we've taken initiative by providing Saturday school and parent workshops to have further strengthened the bridge between home and school ensuring our families are equipped to support learning a vote for to renew Creed Academy today

245is more than just a vote for a school it's a vote for justice equity and opportunity it's your investment in our community that refuses to let black and brown voices be silenced it is your belief in a school that is actively working to empower our students to speak to lead and to thrive thank you thank thank you for your time Haddie Mitchell had Mitchell yeah before my time starts though can I respectfully ask Miss greo and Miss Ras to return I'd like them to hear this is an important decision um so I well we do they might be eating lunch but we do have the playing in the other room I know I'm just making the request I'm asking them to come back into the room I'll make I'll go make the request on your

246behalf I'll be right back thank you but I don't make any promises I I can't I can't make anybody do it's it's just it's a really important decision so I would love for them to be a part of it and thank you guys for all the work you do I'm tired just sitting here for 3 hours so I can't imagine all day once a month so thank you you thank you I know you deserve a break I know this is a long day so thank you without being IND delicate I um The Other Board memb is indisposed so you can proceed or you can uh pass it on to another speaker um she said I'm sorry what she's not available not available okay oh got you okay um no I'll go okay thank you all

247right start my time hit that button so um let's see tonight we will all go home and we will all go to sleep and we will either sleep peacefully right knowing that we did the right thing by kids or we will wrestle at some point maybe tonight might be another night with the fact that we chose a political agenda um because that's what we all know this is a political agenda to close Charters let's just call it what it is I'm not one to uh be phony for those who know me um and so either you'll protect your political position and the authority that God has given you cuz it's not your own you've been been put in this place just like me that's why we're here to make decisions for kids those who can't

248make decisions for themselves um and in our case we're talking about a lot of black kids many brown kids many immigrant kids many homeless kids um our most vulnerable that we've talked about all day and that the city knows about and so you'll either make a decision to support them um or you'll make a decision to protect your political agenda as a district and that's a decision you'll have to live with um I'll live with my decision which is to wake up every day um serving the kids in our community and um Mr schmon when you approved us 8 years ago I'm the same person um and Mr mvoy you as well same person that stood before you then as passionate um and enraged by what's going on in our city with homelessness we are

249the only School uh with a mission exclusively to serve kids experiencing homelessness and Mr carvalo as someone who has experienced homelessness you know exactly what our kids feel see and hear every day I would implore you to make the right decision sir especially based on your own experience um that's really all I have to say we all will live with our decis decisions we'll all answer to God someday and I appreciate each one of you I know you're here because you care thank you for your time uh David Richardson com on up you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin good afterno afternoon everyone superintendent carvalo board memb staff and Community my name is David Richardson and I'm here today as an advocate a charter school graduate and a proud product of South Central

250LA and also a representative of the California Charter Schools Association today I urge you to vote no on the superintendent's recommendation to deny Creed Academy's renewal not as a final endorsement but as an opportunity to give the school and its students another Fighting Chance Creed Academy is more than just a school it's a Cornerstone of stability and opportunity for some of the most undeserved underserved students in South Los Angeles mostly black students and mostly students that look like me many of cre students face unimaginable barriers including homelessness food and security and system systemic inequities this school provides a critical wraparound Services through their programs like the harmony Center addressing the most pressing needs of the children and their families it's not just about academics right now it's about giving these students a foundation to succeed

251in life we recognize that Creed's academic performance or data is not where it could be but let's consider the context Creed only had two years to establish his foundation before the pandemic upended that progress since then the school has made significant strides and implemented targeting interventions and programs the results are tangible students who graduate from CRE and matriculate to schools like Vox Collegiate are performing at or above grade level as emerging leaders and it's a testament to the school's ability to prepare them for Success what we're asking for is not leniency but a fair opportunity two years under AR stringent oversight and accountability measures is a reasonable request these two years will allow cre to fully realize the potential of its programs and further demonstrate measurable progress to deny this renewal is to destabilize a

252community that already faces significant hardships it would uproot students who rely on creep for more than just education students who deserve stability and a chance to thrive decision goes beyond numbers it's about equity and Justice and the question is will we support a school that's addressing the systemic barriers faced by South LA's most vulnerable students or will we just let them fall through the cracks Creed Academy embodies resilience deter mintion and a commitment to lifting up our community I urge you to vote no on this recommendation not just for the school's sake but for the students family and Community it serves thank you thank you for your time uh japa Giles or KES I'm sorry about any mispronunciation there and then if I could just ask you to lower the microphone so we can hear

253you when you speak thank you hi um I'm J um I've been at Creed since the opening second grade and I'm currently in ninth uh Creed Academy has helped me become the person I am today um has be yeah help helped me become the person I am today through um make it helping me build up to be intelligent and emotionally aware and you guys shoot sorry um you guys trying to close down the school that helped me build up myself from who I am now is really hard for me to take especially when it helped me build especially when it helped me build connections that I never thought I would achieve in life and truly it would hurt my heart for you to break down these Charter Schools Kip included and anyone else who was

254here I really think hope that you vote no on this decision because like as many people have said that we help uh homeless people we help people who have had trouble and normally wouldn't have the normally wouldn't have the opportunity to gain the educ that they're having now focusing on just the political way of just our um test scores is just plain stupid forgive my language when we're trying to focus on something bigger we're trying to focus on things that y'all have been going through more than we have been open Los Angeles has a lot of homeless people and us trying to focus on that situation is much more than focusing on some stupid test score cuz there's many people like Elon mus he didn't even go to college and yet here he is making

255stuff happen so why focus on the test scores when we can focus on building a bond that will push us more through the world thank you for having me thank you for your time Andrew Ramirez are here there you are okay thank you for having me um I would just like to say one I'm actually pretty disappointed with this board simply because the fires happening right now are leaving so much more homeless people in La more than ever and Charter Schools like these are helping homeless students across the city and you guys still want to take that right away it kind of seems unfair to me that people without a home are left without an education as well and honestly it just it's kind of dumb honestly to for you guys to shut down a

256school simply because we're having one bad year and the rest of the years we've been in operation it's been pretty perfect and Mr Calo you yourself um I'm sure you were at the performance for Jackie Goldberg's retirement at ERS middle school and I was there I performed for you sir okay and I want you to know that I studied here I came from this charter school and I'm going on a path where I can learn more and appreciate this city more than you guys are appreciating us and I would like to thank you guys for having me here in the first place because it's a good opportunity to learn but I would also like to tell you guys that you guys are very political with how you treat us and it really shouldn't be that

257way because we are students after all and it shouldn't be treated like we're Pawns in a chess game for the political side of this nation surely it's kind of dumb to me how you guys are so political I while upstairs I was hearing you guys talk about Trump which literally has nothing to do with students and how we learn in this world so I would like to just thank you that's [Applause] it we did not that our student speakers were allowing them to speak from their hearts thank you for your time uh Andrea Palmer I know I called that same name earlier but I suspect you're waiting to speak at this time so good afternoon everyone um you know as I stand here before you guys today I want to also introduce you to my

258daughter Nia Lewis um and in about a year and a half time she's going to be going to college um and that is with absolute help from Creed Academy I want you guys to understand something my daughter went to actually three of my daughters um one still attending cre one of them um I had teachers 109th Street School they said I need you to put your daughters somewhere where they're going to they're going to thrive that's your own District that's your school and that's what I was told and so I looked around and I looked around and I looked around and something that came to me was that I have to find a place where my kids can see people that look like them thriving and unfortunately as much as you might think so you

259don't offer that and that's the truth that's the sad truth I need my kids to see people I need my kids to see more people that look like them up here that's the only way any of this advantageously changes another thing that I need you to understand and and I really hope you grasp this my daughter has traveled the world because of this school literally traveled the world your none of your schools can have have have even tried to give that as someone who has worked in social work for the past 17 years of my life one of the things that I see politically is housing first my kids and I ourselves coming from a place where we didn't always have housing housing first is something that my kids can't study if they don't have

260somewhere to study come on my kids cannot focus on schoolwork and I'm sorry but if you test me on something today I may not have all the answers but guess what if you come to me and you question me and you stop putting all these tests in front of our children and saying this is what you're supposed to do and this is how you're supposed to perform that is not okay you need to come you need to talk to them it is not one way to judge a child there are many and it's on you guys to start doing that and if you don't I mean God we have to change the way we we're really voting it's important guys really please let the politics go thank you for your time Erica Garcia hello everybody

261good afternoon I had a speech repair but I'm not going to read it I'm just going to tell you how I feel I'm Erica Garcia I have two children I began this journey of Education since she was in my belly now I have a 15-year-old thriving in school why because she had a foundation where did she get this Foundation Creed Academy Creed Academy is not just a school you see everybody here it's not just a school it's a family they are still with my daughter till this day we're talking about colleges my son right now 7 years old he's at Creed Academy who is going to tell you mom hurry up Mom I'm going to be late I'm going to be late what seven-year-old is going to say that seven-year-old is going to want to

262play play with his Legos watch YouTube but no my son is dedicated why because he has adults he has Educators that believe in him that tell him you can do it Nathaniel you can do it we have students here that are showing you that are sharing their experiences I come from an education background but how am I going to think about a about a test if I don't have anything to eat if I don't have stable housing I come from an immigrant family the fear of immigrant parents now but we have a school that supports us all the time I heard our student advocate here talking about our immigration Community it's not just here it's at Creed Academy and all we're asking is for you to give us that opportunity give us that opportunity for

263our children to continue to thrive Co happened 2020 my daughter was in school my daughter is committed since since then she has been in honoral since then she has been in honoral perfect attendance my son is 7 years old TK Kinder by the way he skipped first grade second grade and as of third grade continues to be perfect attendance why because he has a place to go to and it's called Creed Academy please reconsider thank you thank you for your time AET Garcia good good afternoon Schoolboard my name is akali zasa I am currently 15 years old I am in alumni of Creek culminating in 2021 I am currently a sophomore attending St Pas detent St Maas Academy Creed Academy has always been a welcoming environment that cares so much about their students and their

264families in 2018 I began fourth grade at the crenchaw campus as I was to the school and I was afraid I was afraid I wouldn't belong or make friends once I went inside the classroom that changed backpacks were placed on each chair full of notebooks folders and pencils for each student to use for the new school year my teacher the staff and Miss Mitchell were very welcoming every morning we began an anoing meeting reminding us that we could all accomplish anything we set our minds to during those three years I attended Creed Academy Miss Mitchell's always inspired me to work hard and do my best in school she taught me the importance of dedication and commitment as I now now have honorable for the last last six years my accomplishments are a reflection of creed

265cord values Creed Academy has always provided all that they could to help my community for years they have provided clothes backpacks uniforms and school supplies for their students they make it possible for students to attend school by providing shuttles to take students to and from school for parents and Guardians who are un aable to I am now a sophomore but Creed Academy will always have a special place in my heart a place I call home has taught me the importance of Education responsibility and dedication it taught me I can do anything I set my mind to I am now a sophomore ending my last semester with the 3.9 GPA participate in theater and in cheer I am thankful for creed Academy and Miss Mitchell and Mr Mitchell for continuing in supporting me and being in

266my corner I plead to this board to give the opportunity for future Generations a future generations to be a part of the creat academy family experience thank you for your time have a great day thank you for your time Nia Lewis come on up Nia Lewis you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin hi my name is Nia Lewis I am uh I'm I'm from Lakewood now but I started out in LA and before I got when I started out at creep I was a completely different person than I am now I was shy I was easily intimidated I was just knock this open and caring person and your pillar your second pillar is well and jooy us and for kids at cre that's what we get we wake up we want to come

267to school I wanted to go to school every day I wanted to be on time and it was because of the education that they laid out for us the plan that they laid out for us the foundation that they laid out for us I even in high school now I do not receive the same the same education or the same um phys mental health that I did in elementary that I should be receiving as a high schooler because high school is hard and Elementary is when kids need this like if I didn't learn how to speak up for myself or open up to people or if I didn't know how to um be as creative as I am like I wouldn't be here today I wouldn't be speaking to you advocating for creep because the

268kids that are there they need this they need the food that is being provided the clothes that are being provided the supplies that are being provided the housing that is being provided my mom and me had she used to put me on the shadow every day too because she couldn't afford to get us to work every day so there was something that was there for us to supplement that to people that were there to take care of us in those times and to find out that you're taking it away is really hard like I need like my sisters need this too it makes my mom's life easier it makes adults around us life easier and it's not even just just about even though they're like one bad year of Education they're still finding ways to

269push these kids to where they need to be it is not like they're just trying to hold them down like most of your um elementary schools are doing but that's all thank you for your time all right thank you for your time barington Moore barington Moore I can see my time to Stephanie Moore hi my name is stepan Moore and I am Stephanie Turner is my daughter we suffered from homelessness her dad died when she was six and they help my baby write a book she's a straight A student now I have an ongoing job because of them I'm able to maintain living I have a place to live and they also put my baby on the shuttle to go back and forth to school in times when I didn't have a car it was

270times I didn't have a lot going on mentally and physically they put me and my daughter in to a program to where we were provided a counselor to counsel both of us they also um put me put I was going to write a speech but I mean I did write a speech but I just want to speak but they also put me in a position to where I can get up and cope every day now even though my daughter is at another school she still gets support from Mr and Mrs Mitchell and the staff Mr Aaron Mr Moore she gets that full support I was introduced to this school by my auntie Theodore and she put me in a position to know that I can have that help and that support coming from two people

271they have not only been parents to my daughter but a parent to me it's a Unity at this school it's a family it's a foundation they do fight with homelessness being hungry cleaning clothes washing clothes putting forth what they need to do for the foundation of the community the community needs this school to keep going to keep going further I am also pregnant right now I I pray that my new child can attend that school if this school had a prek a middle school a Elementary a high school I would let them attend everyone that's just it based on how they support the community by being a good good school for our children and not only that the support they give you when they're not on the school grounds you're able to contact each and

272every staff you're able to contact each and every person that works there and my daughter again wrote a book wrote a book about her feelings thank you for your time Carmen loera Carman Lera I'll be yielding my time to theora Smith oh good afternoon superintendent cavaro board member new bill all of the members of the council parents teachers and students my name is Theodora Smith I a proud parent and advocate for the Creed Academy thank you for giving me a chance and opportunity to speak on behalf of many families whose lives have been positively transformed by this incredible School my connection with Creed Academy began with my two oldest children Diora and Zion joined the fourth and fifth grade Diora who faced Jan received the support and tools from Creed Academy to regain her confidence

273and Thrive Zion discovered his passion for music nurtured by the school's encouragement which has inspired his aspirations when my youngest maai started kindergarten he struggled in separation anxiety common developmental challenges the staff's patience medication helped him grow tremendously from potty training him communication and becoming The Confident extroverted child that he is he's in the fourth grade now crit Academy does more than educate it builds resilience confidence and a sense of belonging my children are living proof of its impact and I know many other families had can share similar stories thank you I want to say this too as well my son Zion he's in the going to the 11th grade now I got 21 seconds left my son is not here he wrote a speech but I didn't I don't have time enough to read

274it but the only reason he's not here is because of Mr Mitchell and Miss Mitchell because he never wants to miss school cuz he don't want to miss school he never misses school and he won't so that's the reason why he's not here to speak with them cuz he wanted to go to school thank you for your time Tiffany price Tiffany price come on up you have two minutes to speak when you be again um hi my name is Tiffany price um I didn't prepare a speech and I think it's it has a lot to do with I just understand and appreciate what cre Academy has done for me and my children um we live in South La um I'm a former foster kid so you know the odds were already against me um my

275old my 13-year-old started Creed in the sixth grade and I had found out about by creep because their sixth grade class um they didn't have to switch classes and I felt like at the time my daughter wasn't ready to have multiple classes and she started at Creek and then she thrived you know she enjoyed her time at Creek and now she's you know at Obama but during that time like she became more confident she enjoyed the staff um and now I have my 9-year-old who started in kindergarten excuse me first first grade he's reading now he wasn't able to read at first like he's reading like when we're out he's like reading and that's because of creep there was times last year that we struggled like with food insecurity I was able to call Mr

276and Mrs Mitchell they literally took me to the store and like gave us food bought us food and even now like if they have extra Food they'll call me like hey Tiffany do you and the kids need anything that's a big help it's no other schools in La unified that I know of that's doing that it's none when we moved into our new place um my son they had a bunk bed one of the staff from Creed Academy came and put that bed together for us I'm a single parent ain't no man in a home so that staff came and put that bed together for my son so he could have like a safe space you know to sleep so what Creed Academy means to me is it's important like for kids like my it's

277important for single parents like myself that we have that safe space thank you thank you for your time uh Linda Harris Linda Harris okay what are we doing she signed up for uh us to speak during public comment so you're going to speak yeah I'll speak she's not here yeah so I I just would like to highlight some of the um data uh because we've been asked a lot about data and the data for students in our community is that 7% um of our black students are being suspended daily which is four times the amount of their white counterparts um our suspension rate has been zero for the last three years uh we don't suspend our kids uh we focus on maso's hierarchy of needs at the bottom of that triangle you'll see food shelter

278right above it you see love and so we train our staff in restorative justice we demand that every one of our administrators knows how to do conflict resolution with kids that they don't miss school if you visit our school you will most likely see an administrator with one two or three students with them at all times because we've made a commitment not to suspend our kids I speak throughout the state I'm traveling to Sacramento to speak to other schools about how to keep their suspension rates low um we also have a chronic absenteeism that is below 5% when the CSD came to our school during the same time they talked to us about our test scores they raved about our chronic absenteeism they said we can't do that in any part of the district how

279does your population with the most vulnerable kids in the city want to come to school during this this time of of of need and crisis and we we told them about the harmony so we have a Harmony staff of 20 staff members mental health professionals most of them are working for free finishing their Ms dedicated to our kids daily the resources we're doing all of this on our general budget and we make sure to do it at the benefit of our community because our kids are the benefit they aren't a burden we intentionally recruit from skid row because even though la is 6% black skid row is 60% black it's the only place where black population is rising and we have to do something about it because all the schools in our district are not

280thank you your time we have a remote call caller Carl Peterson Carl Peterson please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you beun uh on Tab 16 Mr Carl Peterson you have me yes hello can you speak up a little bit and maybe a little bit closer to the receiver Sure hold on one second Mr Peterson are you there is this better is this better it's a little bit better I'll turn up the volume okay um before I begin I'd like to point out that the first Speaker stated that 33% of the students are homeless according to the sork report it's 21.1% $39,988 this is how much comp compensation the husband and wife team who founded creete Academy received from the school in the fiscal year ending in

2812023 when opponents of charter schools talk about how these schools turn public education funds into profits this is what we mean yes California law requires Charters to be organized as nonprofits but this only applies to the schools it does not stop suppliers contractors Charter management organizations Real Estate Investors and in this case administrators from lining their pockets with money meant for educating children what did the 283 students of cre 87.7% of whom are classified as socioeconomically disadvantaged received for this $390,000 they each contributed $1,381 to receive an education the state rates as low performing the Charter School Division lists 14 Communications with the school regarding ongoing areas of non-compliance some for repeat reasons indicating a history of operational deficiencies last month one of the founders Dr Addie Mitchell came before you and bragged about a

282case where she ignored mandatory reporting laws for three students to stay in an environment that Reed of urine where they were malnourished ravaged by bug bites and were living with a mother who by Mitchell's description was clearly unable to care for these kids the Mitchells are not the only ones profiting excessively off the education system and homeless students records show that David takowsky the former board member who regularly appears before you received Consulting fees from this school how many of you heard from him and the run up to this vote did he disclose to you that he is a paid lobbyist it is time to end this grift please vote to approve the charter school division's recommendation to deny the renewal of C's Charter thank you thank you for your time uh let's see we

283have one more remote caller Kaylee Cortez you're listed is speaking remotely but are you in the room Miss Cortez okay come on up miss cortz you have two minutes to speak once you begin I need to turn your mic back back on one second you're all set please go ahead hello my name is Kaye Cortez and I'm alumni from Creed Academy I believe every child deserves access to a quality education regardless of their situations for many families charter schools are not just an option they're a Lifeline create Academy is more than an educational institute it's a family they provide hope growth opportunity is for our community um now I want you to imagine a classroom full of eager students each with the potential to change the world now imagine that room closing its doors because

284you want to close it robbing their opportunities to an education they may not gain anywhere else as I've grown older I always has been told my education is something no one can take from me right now speaking to you I'm beginning to question that your quote is ready for the world but you aren't letting me along with others the opportunity to get ready for it however Creed Academy has for me cre Academy has helped me in ways no other school has ever done for example when my case was first being opened for foster care the founders of cred Academy helped Me by providing a safe and loving environment and letting my three siblings and I into their home with welcoming arms or when my father passed away and the school found programs to help the

285grieving process not just for me and my family but for multiple students who have lost their loved ones to Me closing create Academy is like tasing taking a piece of me as they have molded me to who I am please take note of what I've said and think twice before CL Inc and Charter Schools as a whole and thank you for your [Music] time thank you for your time uh that concludes the presentation portion and the public comment portion now it's appropriate for the board to discuss I just have a question about the process please will um CSD be coming up here and will'll engage in discussion as a group or CSD is present to answer questions I think that the board might request of that them do we stay yeah right so to be

286clear the if CSD has questions they can only come from the board uh the cre is welcome to stay and observe the um the question and discussion between the board and CSD or whoever else they may have questions of and then a vote will be taken do we have questions from the board Miss go yes um a couple things uh one uh I do think it's challenging um given that the pandemic affected numerous years of test scores for the board to be looking at just a couple of years of data I do think that that makes it hard to see a long-term picture of how um how students are doing how schools are performing I found as I was reading my materials I found that to be just a question across the board um in

287that uh we're we're missing a picture um and I also just want to validate the experience of the school that you know test scores certainly don't reflect everything that our schools do we know that um our schools strive to provide so much I I know you all sharing from your your perspective of your school I know many of our district schools are also focused on our students as whole people the whole child and and that isn't always reflected in test scores okay that being said to my question um Mr Cole guus um the school in in their presentation uh made a mention the slides aren't numbered but maybe it's the third or fourth slide that uh Creed students have made one year's progress in one year's time as demonstrated on Renaissance star in reading and

288math and the I believe the CD's analysis says something different about the verified data if you could just help help explain and contextualize what why there's a difference there what does that mean thank you board member gones and board president superintendent as I addressed that question I would like to make a brief state first of all we hear the voices of everybody here our hearts are also breaking for all the families impacted directly colleagues it's during this very difficult time we take these matters very seriously very seriously and it's with that humility and integrity in a process that tries to be consistent and focuses on consistent a process data analysis under law as I explained earlier that we make these recommendations to honor all students so we we remain steadfast while our hearts do break

289given the context around us respectfully I want to just note that on behalf of all of our team and I know our superintendent for a low performing charter school there are two critical findings the board would need to make and one is regarding the verified data one is regarding their their meaningful steps to address underlying um the underlying causes of the underperformance and verify data our our assessment of their verified data which is star Renaissance which is one of the approved uh assessments that the state board has authorized is the following concerns which are not on the materials so yes we disagree with their assessment that it me one year's progress first as the publisher itself notes for Star Renaissance and we've had many conversations with with various vendors on these the school needs to

290at each year when you do the follow spring you need to um pull that data save that data it does not roll over so what the board and the public has in the materials are three years of data that have were printed out in October 2024 but they're not differentiate they're not the data from each year for those for said students we also have concerns about the participation rates and as noted there's even if we were to look at it you have missing information mixed results because you don't have the the information for students who have matriculated so on that note staff cannot recommend to the board to make a finding that they have met the criteria for verified data we do not have that and then we also have concerns about their plan as

291noted and I'm happy to dive into the plan but just on the verified data piece does the statute does the statute require multiple years of data I know again that was an issue noted in some of the different um denials um I read it as one year's worth of progress for a school year um so I'm just trying to understand if that's a disqualifying Factor based on the statutory requirements let me address that point it just goes back to the board president's questions earlier verified data under the law speaks to one year's progress for every year in school therefore in Lo thereabouts it may not be exact quote but that is that is uh related one year's progress for every year in school now one could read that to say because this this was the

292state board approved this in around 2020 in terms of the I think the assessments one can say do you have the verified data for each of those years in the school most Charter Schools do not have that In fairness but that's in we've noted publicly and we've discussed with charter schools in fact every school middle performing and low performing after they submitted and they signed it was complete we made sure are we looking at the verified data that you had intended to submit make sure we're clear on what it is you were going to submit for verified data in this record the school had not submitted it was with that call where they said oh well yeah we may have forgotten to submit when they submitted it okay so well we we have looked at

293is multiple years to get as much data as you can to show the one year's progress pursuant to law we've noted publicly in our materials that some schools have only submitted one year we've looked at it we've given the board the information as to did it meet the the terms of verified data but we also noted why we didn't consider it clear and convincing evidence the limitations of the one year and in many cases the mixed record in ela math or the applicable areas for the assessment therefore I Believe by state law and the language they're in the ongoing discussions we've had with schools in oversight as well as in the renewal process prior to that that is evident and lastly I will note that often times in these discussions about verified data we have

294heard directly since you're making a broad note as well that some schools have told us we will not be giving you more data and for various reasons in some cases they have assessed that's not favorable for them and so those are um uh some of the issues uh to your question and related factors related to verified data I think I think it says for each year I don't know that that's different like based on each versus every in in the English language but just to note that's our assessment of got it okay um so it might it may be an issue more that it doesn't meet the clear and convincing evidence standard um and then I wanted I appreciate that the school spoke about the academic um supports that are in mind um I was

295certainly concerned in reading about the variety of operational issues that the school has experienced over the years I think there's a note in our report about 14 um notices of concern or notices to cure even as recent as like six months ago um so I wonder if um if I can ask the school a question um if if they might share how are they addressing and remedying these operational issues yeah absolutely um just first to have an opportunity to speak because I I believe we're supposed to get equal time to talk about each subject just to talk to the verified data piece and I do remember your uh question and I will address that right after our verified data our participation rate was 94% and the threshold is 95% however our stability rate for students

296because we serve 34% unhoused students unlike the caller said I know every name of 105 students at my school that are unhoused 34% of our kids are unhoused so the stability rate is lower it's much it's much more difficult to get families into test but we were 1% under the threshold which we've since corrected to 98% which we we tested in the fall at 98% in Allstar um secondly uh just the the the caller stated um about David tofsky and he he talked a little bit about uh my wife and I and our compensation I have two law degrees the first day I stepped into Howard law the professor told me looked us all in our eyes and said Charles Hamilton Houston who was a foundation of this law school says if you were an

297attorney you must be a social engineer or you will be a parasite to your Society so I'm using every ounce of my law school degree at Howard I then with four four children during covid went to CLA and all my kids attend my school and I got a master's in- law from the best CRT professors this country has to offer and I'm learning and I lose sleep over how to take care of my kids and the kids in our community because they are forgotten about there is a level of apathy in this city that I am not okay with that my wife is not okay with so the mission of our school is to break the cycle of unhoused kids that's the mission and when we were approved in this District we were celebrated on

298that mission every year when you look at that same finding report when we scor twos in academic and and it's okay and we're labeled middle performing there's no issue for the last five years there there there's not a problem and and our kids are supposed to be held to an alternative dashboard because 80% of our kids are eligible for the alternative dashboard we're supposed to be on Bap because most of our kids are black and there's not enough people doing enough stuff for black students in our community but but we've dedicated our life to doing this so that caller I guarantee he's never been to our campus and we've invited every council member and we invite anybody that wants to come see the work we're doing and we've never asked for help in eight years

299we've never asked for anything we wake up and we do our work every day and I use I have four four kids I bought a home because that's a smart thing to do I have two law degrees my wife has a doctorate from USC where she developed our Harmony program and part of her doctoral thesis and we understand how important academics are because that's why we're at where we're at that's why we're able to help our community her doctoral thesis pointed out what it takes to serve the black unhoused the brown unhoused kids in our community and we fight that out every day whether or not you support thank you for your time sir no it's not I I still have to answer her question related to the 14 notices to con of concern and

300to cure nine are repetitive and to give you example if you look at the finding sheet we had a daycare provider come pick up her students late we have a late policy after 10 minutes after 5:30 we a dollar a minute please pick up your students on time because I have to employ two staff members and pay them overtime to make sure that the kids are safe that are still there after school we have a lot of families that have challenges with Transportation with housing so we have two staff members to make sure all of our kids are safe that daycare provider came we asked her to pay $6 because she was six minutes late after the 10 minute she came at 5:46 she said these aren't my kids and I'm not paying you $6

301then we told her hey we're just trying to make sure kids get picked up on time she reports that to the district that's the notice to cure that's three of those notices are that one call that we corrected immediately we changed our whole handbook because of that call but none of our parents have ever complained that was a daycare provider who didn't want to spend her own money on kids that we do everything for and that's an example of the findings that's an example of of what's going on with um the documentation notices of concern six notices of concern only three to cure we've answered them immediately they're all resolved and at any point if the district felt like they were serious enough to shut us down or to revoke our Charter they could have

302but they didn't because we answered immediately we want to be a great School we look to partner we look for opportunities to understand we're a young couple we understand we don't know everything we ask for advice we ask what can we do better and we perform we execute on that we don't just talk it we ask we get it done and that's why they're no longer notices to cure thank you thank you board president and board member just briefly I want to note couple quick points for for the record one per per board approved policy per board board approved policy the uh equivalent time does not apply for question and answer period That's the board approved policy just want to note that petitioners have received two minutes for presentation staff did not make a two-minute

303presentation on this item we're responding to questions secondly as noted in the the findings regarding uh the notice the notices that's part of our concern uh and I'm concerned with the response regarding the charging of fees that's noted here and there other fees that were charged that we noted um and so that is part of the the overall concerns as noted in the findings thank Youk okay I'm gonna make a quick quick announcement so if if the students um could have a seat because the podium is getting very crowded if there's questions directed to the administration the Mitchells please come on up and answer but until then let's give uh face up front I really really appreciate that um cuz the questions will not be posed you're good there the questions won't be posed to

304the students and so if the board continues its questioning please please go ahead uh if he's responding to questions that are relevant to the was issued by the board I I think it's fully appropriate questions board members questions Mr melvoin thank you Mr Schon and um thank you Jose I'll say um a number of charters before us today and uh I've appreciated your you and your staff's thorough briefings I don't know that I agree with every conclusion we'll get into that but I have felt that this process has been neutral and fair and objective and I uh appreciate you engaging with the board on this and answering a bunch of our follow-up questions so I'm not I'm not saying I agree with all the conclusions necessarily but I just want to State for the record

305that I think the team has been very professional and thorough and neutral in their analysis thank you sir um I also want to thank the school Community for your incredibly heartfelt words and support and to our F the founders I was it's hard to believe it was what seven eight years ago that I was there cutting the ribbon with Dr McKenna and I appreciate that invitation uh not in my district but giving uh serving a population I care deeply about um I think there's uh a lot of Admiral things things about your school and your community we're hearing them on display now 0% suspension rate the low chronic absenteeism rate I think the district's concerns around academic achievement with the caveat that not test scores don't tell you everything those are the metrics we have

306and I think we have to be consistent because particularly there are folks in the Charter Community who say you get that flexibility for that autonomy and we have to hold ourselves to a standard and so I think we have to you know take a step back and and have some neutrality around that I have some questions though about whether the school is applicable for the traditional assessment but I guess two questions Jose for you one is that in response to concerns uh submitted by CSD the school submitted an action plan and I know that the district has deemed that action plan insufficient but what back and forth has there been with the school knowing that this has been a school that's gone through not only the population of homeless students but covid and other challenges

307and like what is you know just for the board and the public what's that oversight you say there's a concern are they not addressing the concerns was their action plan did it fail to meet uh your standards across the board or was it just on some academic achievement like what's that back and forth because to the extent that we've given the school an opportunity to correct certain concerns I just would like you to speak to that a bit thank you for that question also consistent with the process and policy if a school is recom going to be recommended for denial pursuant to the board of education's policy there is not a back and forth on the petition review process that's plainly stated in the policy the petitioners did inquire with our team Miss Mitchell I

308believe uh asked some questions and we understood she was also maybe confirmed with her councel but she did ask us questions on I can't remember everyone and our team responded with references including to the policy Charter School submit their petition they sign a certification of completeness we review that material and so Mr melvoin no there's not an iterative process to go back and forth on the plan that they are to submit one piece I will note there is a chart multi-page chart that the that the school submitted they also noted that they would be submitting a detailed writeup with the strategies that is not in the materials so we have a chart and yes some may be relevant but in terms of even by their own suggestion of a more detail to explain those items

309that was not in the materials so just to give you a couple notes in our concerns there so and this process has changed in in recent years and so not everyone's familiar with it but the state the state deemed schools high middle or low correct and the state deemed the school low correct and it's still within the discrection discretion of this district and the board to approve for a two-year term one of the things we heard you know mentioned if not explicitly implicitly from the the from the school was around this this uh alternative assessment or the you know so the the dots the dashboard alternative school status and I'm curious given the high need population why the school hasn't applied and maybe we can hear from that you know I'll let you conv but

310but why the school hasn't applied would they be applicable and if and I thought I saw something in some of the materials that they may be applying now and like how would approval or denial or no action affect that status because it does seem to the extent that there is a state framework for schools that serve a very high need population I know we have a charter that serves uh pregnant and parenting teens that's on the Dos system um we have two we have two uh and it seems like this one could be applicable so curious why they're not and and your thoughts that question if you'd like would be asked to the petitioners the short answer is I won't speculate whether they would meet or not meet that's a process that they would have

311to submit documentations to the CDE to to receive that classification we're not aware that they have done that certainly they don't have that classification for this renewal now brief context because we do have two other charter schools that are in the Dos program as approved by the state by law we then have to exchange with that school and agree to metrics per law that then would would be um reviewed at renewal we have done so for the two schools that are DOs and and the board has received information previously to that so that's some overview responses and we do not have that the schools can res if you wish as to why they're they're Cur why they have not done so to date in terms of for this renewal officially yeah I'd appreciate that thank

312you board member uh Melo and to respond to why we have not applied to the alternative dashboard as um recognized by many of our our stakeholders in our school Community um we do not hold normal hours so we're working around the clock with our families for the last 8 years there's been no notice to us that we've been anything other than middle performing because we scored Twos for the duration of our Charter last year after we scored a one and the the district this was the first time they said due to 18 uh ab55 there's a a presumptive denial we called our attorneys to see what that meant this is the first time we've heard of the alter alternative dashboard we're focused on fixing the root of the tree and not the branches so we

313work non-stop with our families we've never heard of it never thought we needed it because even though we're 33% unhoused our kids perform and they have been performing at the level that was sufficient for the district for eight years and then all of a sudden we have one year of testing that is below and they tell us it's a presumptive denial what the the what was not also mentioned is that we were placed in prop 39 after covid happened we had over 150 additional students that applied to be a part of our school because of the services we give less than a year after being awarded a a site on Prop 39 we were told we had to leave our site and move in the middle of the school year Christmas move Christmas we moved

314our school from one site to another because the district threatened to punish us with a thousand a day penalty so our entire School is moving right before testing this is the most vulnerable population so it's not a coincidence to me the kids did not perform like they usually do we're looking for housing for our school not just for our kids and when you're a Founder when you're a charter founder you're also a real estate agent you also have to find school property you have to negotiate leases you have to work nonstop Around the Clock make sure you get all the permitting make sure you get furniture make sure you get the school ready and we had about nine days we had nine days to to move an entire school campus and get ready and we

315did it and we didn't complain we didn't complain cuz we were told not to complain we were said we were told that it wouldn't be good to go to the district and say this isn't un this isn't fair but it didn't really make sense to us because my my parents attended butl long Elementary they grew up on 51st in Budlong it is designed for 1,000 students the school that was there had less than 500 and we had less than 200 so it didn't make sense while we were being asked to leave a School site and displace students right before testing and expect them to perform the same as the other students in the state where their schools have less than 2% unhoused students it does not make sense they also don't have as many black

316students as we have so that didn't make sense but we didn't complain and now that we are aware after our presumptive denial of the opportunity we've already did the research we've worked with YMC we're at 80% we're well above the Benchmark to be considered an alternative dashboard evaluated school so although the the the and and the question that you asked why didn't we know that how come the district have never presented that to us knowing the amount of kids we have that are unhoused knowing the Foster knowing that we're at 95% free and reduced lunch knowing that why have they never talked to us about it I don't know but I'm I'm I'm grateful we've can we apply I'm grateful we found out about it we're we're we're applying right now our application is nearly

317done and we're hopeful to get an opportunity to make that application so that in two years we'll be able to be evaluated properly based on the demographics of our school and and and just lastly the submission deadline for this year was um July 8th uh it's our it was our um it was in it was of those days in July YMC reached out to us we have the email correspondence we're trying to get it in before the deadline Mrs Mitchell's uh father is admitted to the hospital he's been fighting cancer he lives with us he gets admitted that same night she stays at the hospital with him he passed away last year due to complications with cancer and we asked if there's any way we could still submit we talked about the deadline line we

318talked about the the the family issue we had we had no response the district has not responded there has been no correlation and and during the time when we submitted our action plan we did reach out as um Mr Gutierrez said we we did reach out and we received nothing we reached out to our CSD Specialists we reached out to the CSD office they said we can't talk to you about it because of the law of a ab55 says we can't discuss anything except your pro presumptive denial and I said that law doesn't make sense we're trying to make our school better we're trying to improve this action plan that law does not make sense to me and as a young black man laws AR always in your favor so I challenge laws that don't

319make sense for my kids because I have to fight I don't get the luxury to spend months wondering or not if my action plan is sufficient I'm ready to work on it but they did not respond to our request thank you thank you Mr Mitchell I'm going to let Mr Co Gutierrez respond if you would Mr Co Gutierrez first to the point of Dos as the leader mentioned that that's that's in their uh court and then they have not done so to date I won't speak further about it for this renewal it is not present to present to the board secondly so sorry Mr K so for the their the pending application for do status doesn't have any bearing on renewal status for this year the renewal is live now and the statutory timeline for

320Action is as noted in the materials I believe it's by tomorrow so at this point something in process no I would not if there's a legal question there I would defer to miss Nea Reed but in short we do not have the material to consider them dos and the aformentioned agreement that would have to take place for the metrics to present to the board we do not have that and the the decision maker for whether a school can be accepted as a Dos school is not the district right that's the state and so if the school is is non-renewed and then we find out the state approv like that's the process question I'm trying to figure out if they're not renewed and then they get approved for that status do they have the right to

321come that that that may me more of a detailed legal question what I would say is uh apart from that if there are material changes to a charter petition in the appeal process should the board take the action to deny that appeal could be remanded back to the local level but again there would need to be those agreed upon metrics and what I've mentioned I I want just note one other thing to to to Mr schon's uh question uh because in response regarding um prop 39 and Facilities I won't say much because there was also a dispute initiated by the charter that issue was because the charter school did not meet its obligations under law to apply for that space as required that was one of my questions my my final subst question is just

322that we heard from the school that there were seven years of academic achievement in progress and then one year stag stagnation what's your assessment to that the oversight record which notes on page not withstanding the the the other points that the leaders have made um but the oversight record is noted in the in the findings let me just go to that page present a record where data were available of developing as the leader noted and in 2324 which is uh developing and then in 23 24 was unsatisfactory based on their results so uh I would disagree with the broad characterization that there have not been concerns with their performance and other operational issues ETC as noted in in the documents great well I appreciate you both the school and the and you Mr Co Gutierrez

323answering questions I think I want to hear from my colleagues you know I guess the question is just whether for for me whether they're you know two years with uh benchmarks and an opportunity to improve particularly under an alternative status is worth it or you know if whether the school had it shot so that's why I want to hear from others thanks do we have any more questions board members because if we don't we will vote any more questions from any board members okay I guess we're going to vote Mr mcle all right can I have someone move oh just one question because obviously this is compelling and and I guess this is for uh Cole as we vote u based on the evidence that you've shared with us um The Next Step or process

324for the the students because obviously um we're here for students correct for sure um and what does that look like so that we're all on the same page for our students should the board of education adopt the recommendation to deny the charter under law this the charter school has the right to appeal to the Los Angeles County Office of Education and then also has the right under law to appeal should it be night denied there we won't speculate but the process then they could go to the State under an abusive discretion standard that's one parallel track miss that new bill is because there's certainly High sensitivity to supporting students and we want to balance their rights to appeal but also supporting families superintendent has always directed us in these difficult times we make sure that

325we provide those supports so we've already our our strategic enrollment team our regions and others will be engaged as appropriate and certainly we'll need to connect with the school balancing the sensitivity but to support families uh to be able to provide options should those families desire those options that will be their choice but the supports will will be present uh but it will require that appro corate cooperation um respectfully thank you okay we're ready to vote Mr McLean someone like to move the item move it moved by board president schmon oh that's right um we need someone beside the board president to move to move the item that's correct move move by Dr Ras second seconded by Miss Nill all right um Miss nubel yes Dr revas yes Mr melb no Miss grigo yes Miss

326gonez yes Miss Ortiz Franklin Miss Ortiz Franklin uh board president schmon yes that is 1 two 3 four five eyes uh one no and one not present so the item passes now time for general public comment up and and think about what you just did I'm bless child and my kids is going to be successful and they are right now successful because of Mr and Mrs Mitchell so okay nobody here take n that away from she also assured all of us before we came in here that we going to be okay regardless of [Applause] this okay we're GNA do general public comment now there's 20 speakers signed up um I'm going to call on the folks who are listed as speaking in person in the room and then we will go to the folks who

327are listed as speaking remotely so the first person is listed as Nyla Nyla are you here yeah I'm here please go ahead you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin hello board members and super intendent carvalo my name is Nyla young a fellow a core member and a longtime leader of students deser my name is s ly Ray and I'm the vice president of the student deserve Gala chapter as well as a fellow Corp member we have come forth to address a set of Demands regarding the Lawrence Middle School assault on the day of December 6th salvon Torres was helping carry items to his grandmother's car when he was brutally assaulted by John morial a wide ex-military parent whose son also attends Lawrence Middle School while kneeling on salon's neck he hurled racial slurs

328at the 13-year-old making this a racial hate crime the tourist family waited 17 days days for a response to their son's assault and all they got was an email saying that counseling will be provided when school resumes on January 6th a whole month after the initial assault this had not been the first incident regarding John moral he had also previously verbally assaulted another black student Gregory King attending the same school by calling him racial slurs and threatening to physically harm him when we initially heard of these incidents we felt horrified and disgusted to know it had happened outside of a school why is it that the police you constantly fight for were not there and where now in this time you oh no what would have happened if we had safe passage or arrested a

329Justice counselor instead thank you salvon wouldn't wouldn't have gone to the hospital in the first place and the issue would have been addressed after the first assault we feel as though things turned out the way they did because of the parents and races VI because of the parents and victims races if the assaulter were a person of color and the student were and the student were white then ell would have provided Justice expeditiously we know that if the school board recognized race in the black student achievement program the Torres and King family would still would not still be fighting for the board to bring their children Justice today we demand that La USD protect their black and brown students by reinstating the be in the B saap program which would have provided its students safe

330passage eliminating the chance of salvon and Gregory King's assault counseling is not a replacement of judgment thank you thank you for your time okay Mao tro Mao tjo I see you out there come on up and then after Mao is Maria Luisa Palma and then Kean hamler Mr treyo are you going to seed your time okay great step on up thank you appreciate you please just state your name so we can write it down first name is fine Eliza Frank thank you please go ahead I stand before you today not only as Gregory King's mother but as someone who has served for two years as a parent representative on Bap region West my direct experience with bap's implementation combined with my personal experience as a mother gives me a unique perspective on both the program's

331potential and where we are feeling our black students my son Gregory and his friend salvan Torres have experienced firsthand the devastating impact of anti-black racism at Ernest Lawrence Middle School the principal's failures are not just administrative they represent a dangerous pattern of enabling racism and violence when my son Gregory was verbally assaulted with racial slurs and threats of physical violence the principal did nothing when salvan became the victim of a hate crime assault by the same white parent again the principal did nothing his inaction has spoken volumes during my two years serving on Bap region West I've seen both the transformative power of the program when properly implemented these incidents at Ernest Lawrence aren't isolated they symptoms of a deeper system uh systemic antiblack um antiblackness that pervades not only San Fernando Valley but LAUSD

332at large the principal Andreas Flores and assistant principal Carlos renderos at Ernest Lawrence Middle School must be removed I repeat that the principal Andreas Flores and assistant principal Carlos renderos at Ernest Lawrence must be removed their failure to protect our children their willingness to allow racial violence harassment and his contribution to an unsafe educational environment make them unfit to lead as someone who has worked with Bap structure I can tell you the level of leadership failure actively undermines everything the program stands for thank you thank you for your time Maria Louisa Palma and then kesan hamler Maria Lisa Palmer here come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin and uh so just before Miss Palma Begins the folks in the audience who are waiting for the other items to be heard

333we're going to finish the remainder of general public comment and then we will take up those uh the REM remaining items in order uh so please go ahead Miss Palama the floor is yours thank you good afternoon my name is mar Luisa Palma I am here representing oada Inc a nonprofit organization so as we continue to come together as a community in this time of great crisis we want to extend our thank you to all our First Responders in the city don't we and we have a renewed focus on safety improving safety and we have a national and worldwide level of focus on our city and not all of it is positive right so what if I broader tragedy hits our students in our schools I want to uh send your attention back to the

334reported incidents that have been reported out of the iar system this is a summary of some of them back from September of 2023 April of 24 and September of 2024 these reports are unacceptable we've asked a number of times for ongoing public reporting of these incidents but we are at the mercy of waiting to see when they happen to be released we don't have any information on the calls for service uh for the school police department but these reports I want to point out to you I've created a spreadsheet here that I will email to all of you for you to look at if you look at closely at these reports for the year 22 to 23 has been reported three times you know what's curious about this all the numbers are different and yet

335they're for the same time period how could that be so I put them all together when I compare the years 2018 to 2019 before the pandemic when we had school scho police on campus to 23 and 24 that none of this has been reported in the media or here in the district uh fighting increased by 186% threats 173% illegal control substances 117% and weapons 90% so we just want you to recall and know that I'll leave this here for you to look at uh we shouldn't have to do a public records act request to get this information and imagine if there would be a need for a postmortem if there was a huge incident here in the district would we you've never reported those percentage increases here are you aware that this is the level

336of the increases when we had school police versus when they were removed please take a look at this I will send you an email this evening thank you thank you for your time Kean hamler come on up Kean uh Hattie Mitchell I Believe Miss Mitchell just left good afternoon carve Hollow and the rest of the school board my name is Kean I am a senior from Hamilton High School and there's just a few things I want to share with you guys I stand before you today to speak on the behalf of the family students and community members who are deeply concerned and heartbroken by the recent Unthinkable attack on a 13-year-old student salvon in Lawrence Middle School this incident has shaken our community to its core leaving us grappling with anger fear and urgent need

337for answers first and foremost our thoughts are with the young victim and their family we cannot begin to imagine the pain and Trauma they are enduring they are not alone our entire Community stands United with their support however this tragic event raises critical questions about the safety and well-being of students in our schools schools should be Sanctuary places where every student feels secure support and valued when that sense of safety is violated it is our Collective responsibility to take immediate and assessive action to our own hands I demand that there be a community-based team that interferes with anti-black and racial tension among students and staffs at schools this should be on campus Because black students should not have to deal with the constant harassment and discrimination against us for the color of our skins with

338this it allows us black students to move and navigate more freely without having to deal with the constant harassment and so racial Rising tensions in schools this means that people are part of this program and community- based team should be people who understands and truly get the issues us students face these people should allow us to come to them for help but also watch and protect us from any racial tension that rises in our community now I ask that school should be treated like a place for all students to learn and grow it should be not treated like a social status where black students are treated as less than I hope you come to understanding that all communities should be treated equally because if a situation where your community is being harassed and racially abused

339by the color of your skin you'd act quickly on it so I hope you guys get a grip and act quick on this incident cuz this is just highly unacceptable thank you thank you for your time okay I'm going to call on the next I'm going to call on the next four people please the first person come up to the podium and the following three please just prepare yourselves to speak uh Ruth cazarez come on up to the podium Ruth and then after Ruth will be Jade and then after Jade it will be Rosa ban Sanchez so Ruth I'm sorry then Joelle I'm sorry Ruth and then Joelle and then Jade so Ruth are you here what does that mean you you don't wish to speak okay uh Joelle is Joel here come on up

340Joelle you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin hi my name is Joel and I'm a senior at Hamilton High School Bap was created to address lausd's historic and ongoing failure to meet the needs of black students it is a Lifeline not a luxury and it is long overdue for La OSD to make Bap permanent and expand its funding this program represents an overdue acknowledgement of the systematic inequities that have left black students behind to walk back this commitment or fail to strengthen it would be an act of negligence and betrayal LD must not only maintain but increase Bap funding by an additional $100 million to truly support black students and ensure their success to make the black student achievement plan simply just a student achievement plan is just standard schooling it doesn't address

341the unique challenges that we as black students face or the systematic barriers that have been baked into the education system for Generations upon Generations Bap was fought for because students were being left behind it was fought for because the one-size fits-all approach has never worked for black students Equity means giving students what they need not just treating everyone the same L usd's commitment to Bap needs to reflect this understanding black students have been ignored for far too long taking the black out of Bap further pushes the idea that LUSD doesn't care for its students it's time for La LAUSD to fully invest in our success there seems to be a lack of care responsibility in regards to Bap and black students in general I was appalled to learn about the treatment of middle schoolers who

342were assaulted by a white parent in Chatsworth and by the district's slow response to ensure the safety of the students who are attacked I'm equally as disgusted by The District's poor response to the fires and the Hazardous air quality it led to Across The District choosing to keep students in school during a crisis only compounds the negative health and mental effects that black and brown students are already fighting in under resource schools stop leaving black students behind and learn to actually uplift and appreciate them like bab does why is it that we are consistently having to come down here and talk to you about your lack of care towards black students just do right by us it's not as hard as y'all try to make it out to be figure it out thank you for

343your time Jade Jade are you here come on up Jade Jade Santini Rowan are you here Rosa bellan Sanchez are you here Rosa sit L are you here are can anyone say if some of these folks might be and okay yeah let's do it thank you I know you all have only two minutes I've come down here to tell you about the black on black domestic uh terrorism that is happening to black kids in the sanfernando valley thank you sir for acting quickly you implemented a 24-hour a plan a safety plan within 24 hours I appreciate that and I'm glad that you've been reelected but what I do want you to understand is in no way in no y'all can hear me in no way is it ever appropriate for an adult to put his

344knee on a student's neck and then say I'm going to George Floyd you every one of you should be at that school every one of you need to be in the San Fernando Valley whether or not it's your District or not black people black children are being persecuted we got kids sitting in this room one over there who's need was broken one over there who's who what somebody said they were going to put a gun to his head this is what is happening and none of you all are doing anything you're talking about test scores then you find a school that is serving 34% of unhoused people and you shut it down are you insane are you insane anybody who is willing to work with the unhoused should be applauded on every single level how

345do you expect them to compete at the same level as everybody else how could how do you do that have you ever been unhoused have you ever been at under resource schools have they what we're telling you I kind of don't want you to do nothing because I kind of want you to see the power of black people in this city we are left in I want you to see the power that we're going to Garner and you Mr superintendent I know somebody that knows you they know you from Florida they're going to see they're G they're going to be reaching out to you at the end of the day you either do something about what is happening to black kids in this school in these La USD schools whether they a charter or not

346or we will take it upon ourselves as black and brown people in this community and create a a problem for you a real one thank you for your time let's see it looks like Jana is going to speak for Jade oh there you come line up you have two minutes to speak y know I got a lot to say but I'm not going to speak in replacement of her I'm actually going to read for Jade she took ill today and so I'm going to read for her hello my name is Jade Santini Ron 33-year-old single mother of four children my 5-year-old daughter goes to mag Olia Elementary I'm a parent and leader of students deserve and I'm a black lives matter member Los Angeles before I speak she just wants to give a moment of

347silence and we will do as she's asked and give a moment of silence for those that died due to the fires Jay wants us to know that it hurts me just like it hurts other people of the fires that happened in Los Angeles and I know it's not you guys fault and I know was out for a few days due to the bad air quality but I'm still a concerned parent my 5-year-old daughter has breathing problems and I don't want her to be at school and her breathing problems get worse due to the bad air because of those fires my demands are to the extent that you guys please extend that there's no school until the for sure the air quality is better also recently December 6 2024 in the afternoon there was a racist

348dangerous incident about on a black student that goes to Ernest Lawrence Middle School named Sal Torres he was brutally attacked by a white male parent for no reason calling him a and other bad names the white male parent gave this 13-year-old black student a concussion a head contusion a neck sprain and a knee injury he literally had his knee on his neck like George Floyd why am I bringing this incident up because you guys the district removed race as a criteria for targeting resources through the Bap program if sa Torres had to be set in a program and if the system wasn't so broken what happened to sou Tores wouldn't have happened and justice for him would have been served I don't want what happened to S to happen to my children or these children

349behind me these children want to feel safe want to feel like someone has their back genuinely they should have they should not have to worry about being attacked due to race or worry about air quality or any of the things that schools are supposed to to take care of for them they should not they should be able to live their best life worry free and feeling free knowing someone generally has their back I didn't have that growing up and I was alone and in bad foster homes and bad group homes do what God blessed you to do which is to be that seed and be that change be that someone who genuinely has these kids back put the black back in Bap and when you leave today know your heart and soul has a changed

350mindset and that you were that seed that helped these kids live their best life worry free a thank you for your time Emanuel are you here Emanuel come on up you'll have two minutes to speak and then after Emanuel is Joseph and then Monica so Emanuel n Joseph Bernie Monica arizola two minutes is yours sir hello everyone my name is emmanu waly a senior at narbon High School in Harbor City California and a leader with students deserve uncontrolled wildfires encroach across thousands of acres of land news reporters and k95 mass stand in front of dismantled homes smoke evaporating in all directions from fire extinguisher gas while the Los Angeles wildfires were 0% contained thousands of students across Los Angeles high schools were expected to come to school maneuvering their way through the restlessness of the

351harsh air quality due to ashes from the wildfires 300 350 297 these are the numbers that reflect the air quality index surrounding many Los Angeles high schools among the severeness of the Flames January 7 and onward well I'm thankful my school isn't impacted I'm certain students especially those impacted with respiratory diseases and conditions were coughing restlessly around campus seeing scenarios like these at my own School a more prompt response should have been issued to the matter to the matter of the effect of the wildfires would have had on school campuses we should not have also come to school that Wednesday and masks should have been provided in in abundance especially at my high school where masks are of low of high purchase needs and we are underfunded in addition to this issue of coming to

352school in the height of the wildfires because there's more I also demand Justice for Savon a 13-year-old black student at Lawrence Middle School who was slammed to the ground and unprovoked and physically assaulted by a white parent this white parent also kneeled on his neck and in addition called him racial slurs the same parent had also previously racially harassed sa's friend Gregory one of the very other few black students at Lawrence Middle School in Chatsworth California despite the brutal nature of this attack the school Stood Still and still L USD has not taken meaningful action I demand that L USD be more more prompt to addressing student matters and concerns in all aspects and conditions thank you thank you for your time Joseph Bernie are you out there Joseph B all right come on now

353miss Jordan good afternoon Schoolboard members um president smon um I come here to you today as a member of Los Los Angeles Unified School District as an educator of 22 years a former student of LUSD and a former parent of a student who attended LUSD schools and I must admit that I am a proud member of United teachers Los Angeles um I feel compelled to be here because I taught at Lawrence Middle School for 14 years um and it hurts me to my core that things like hap what happened to salvon and Gregory that's not new to Lawrence I left Lawrence because of the the climate and the culture that permeated in that school and I will say that when I met with the family and the administration it literally brought me to tears once

354because I was triggered from my time spent at Lawrence and the the the hostile environment that was created for not only black Educators but also for lgbtqia plus Educators as well and when I tried to speak up I was attacked and black bald for lack of a better word and so it was extremely triggering for me to be there but more importantly I was embarrassed by the actions of the administration towards our black parents this is not new this is not an isolated incident I've seen it time and time again as an educator at Lawrence where black parents were disrespected and ignored and mistreated and so to see this new Administration treat with such lack of care and concern for a student that was assaulted as his school a situation that could have been avoided

355and this principal showed zero apathy forget the fact that he ignored requests by parents to meet forget the fact that he failed to to provide a safe environment for salvana Gregory post the incident I urge you to meet the demands of the parents and to seek real systemic change not only at Lawrence Middle School but at schools throughout the valley in this District it's not a coincidence that we see an overwhelming amount of black students attending unaffiliated Charter Schools we need to do better by our black students and especially our black parents at La USD thank you thank you for your time okay we have Monica arzola come on up Miss arzola is going to speak in Spanish so if you'd like to hear what she's going to say in English please put your hands

356up and we will get these translation headsets to you so we're going to pass those out those out for a moment before we begin okay graas two students that assist the district or attend the district excuse me I am here uh once again I'm worry as always yesterday at Hollywood High School a student was stabbed the student stabbed another student this is something that worries me every day as a mother because to yesterday was that child it could tomorrow could be my child this is a worry that as a mother is hard for a mother because we can't have this peace as Tranquility knowing that our children aren't in good hands we know that children need to have be there there academically and it breaks my heart knowing that this girl or this student disgraced

357her life uh because she stabbed this boy and he's now at the hospital we don't know how he's doing but it breaks my heart because today was him today tomorrow could be mine or if not it's a shooting there are fights and November and in during November December Bernstein students went to Hollywood High so that they can beat a student inside the bathroom this is something that I honestly need to be there because it my heart why is it that children are not where they should be academically Mr Nick this is your school and I asked that you pay attention to the school because you know very well that we are trying to graduate and we don't want a d we wanted to be a b preference uh when it has to do with graduation

358but based on everything that's happening this is something that's breaking our heart yesterday I spoke with many parents and we are all worried we continue on insisting that us H at Hollywood High School we do want school back at excuse me want police back at the schools we gave you several signatures we also have 5,000 around the district and we are asking please support us support the Latinos because our parents are also going through bad times because they lost jobs because there were women that would clean these homes they would take care of children and the fact that these houses are burned parents are left without jobs and this is a worry that we are going through and I ask please return these documents so that we can be voluntary parents we can volunteer because

359we have to create a parent portal and this is very difficult to create a parent portal thank for your time and now Maria Daisy Ortiz come on up I think I saw you out there miss Ortiz Miss Ortiz is also going to speak in Spanish so if you'd like the headsets and do not yet have one please put your hand up and we'll get you one no no moment okay list gracias good afternoon to everyone my name is Maria dais Ortiz I am a leader Community leader and I am also a parent of students that have graduated from LAUSD first and foremost I want to say or I want to tell Mr McLean the incoherent that the meetings create I want you to remember that one of the parents gave me the time you didn't

360give me the time I'm not sure you work for the board meeting and I believe that you work for the public you don't work for this building or to look good in front of the superintendent I'm not sure if they need to train you on that I didn't want to be rude because we know that we are going through difficult times where we all need to be United working in a proactive way and elevating each other hand shaking each other but when some something is wrong I do have to say it I apologize for that another thing Mr superintendent that I want to say and board members please support translations unit at schools we are having meetings that there are no interpretation available because translation unit is not equipped adequately we do need funds for

361that department therefore that's what I wanted to say and I will leave the second part for another day Miss gien go ahead well 30 seconds that I have left I want to say that honestly we we give our condolences all the parents we give condolences to all the people who have lost homes and all the employees but also for the parents we you heard you heard them speak we heard you speak you never spoke in regards to the parents or about the parents superintendent are creating funds or they and how is it that these funds are going to be used because the district as a committee we have done or we've asked the numbers they're not being given to us and I've told the public I ask you to look at the counts of your

362schools you need to see how these funds are being used in each of these schools and sometimes the school that brings them to the leadership are not giving you the truth investigate people please see what's happening at the schools because there is a lot of politi political issues happening here and we need this St thank you okay so the next uh people who are up are Sierra Leon please come on up to the podium and then Linda Harris and then M Segovia so Sierra Linda and M got it thank you so much the benefits of having PSW they can provide support and guidance to students who need it helping them to succeed in school and life they also can help to create positive and supportive learning environment for everyone but what if our school doesn't

363have enough funding to pay for PSW this could have a negative impact on our school communities students might feel less supported and overall learning environment could suffer finally I want to encourage everyone to think about what we are what we can do to make sure our school has the resources in needs to provide the best possible support for all students we can talk to our teachers administrators and community members about the importance of PS PSW and we can also work together find solutions that will benefit everyone thank you now I'm passing this on to ilila hi my name is Leila King and we are calling on the LD board to take immediate and decisive action to reinstate black student population as a Criterion for Bap School allocation first we would like for you to honor

364your commitment to black students by immediately restoring this Factor and reaffirming Bap as a reparative program designed to address the Decades of racially discriminatory practices that have violated the civil rights of black students second I would like a formal AP apology to black students parents and families and issue a formal apology via letter a public hearing for the harm caused by L USD policies and actions that have negatively impacted black students thank you thank you thank you your time Linda Harris Linda [Applause] Harris okay uh Mira Segovia Mira armeny armeny are you here okay Armani is listed as in person but I I will I'll return back okay I'm going to call on folks who listed themselves as speaking remotely oh hi yeah yeah please two minutes is yours once you begin good afternoon I'm

365actually here with LA Leadership Academy um good afternoon La us board members my name is Maria seia I am a staff member of Los Angeles Leadership Academy I am also a Community member but most importantly I am a parent of the school I'm here to ask you to for your vote in favor of La Leadership Academy charter Ren my three children began their education Journey at La Leadership Academy since kindergarten my eldest who is currently a sophomore is aspiring to be an orthopedic surgeon throughout the years he has struggled medically and emotionally La Leadership Academy has been there to support us with various resources such as counselors tutoring and much more but most importantly they made him feel safe and known when he began school he came in with an IEP for speech within within

366three years he was able to exit out and joined the gate program due to the dedication and resources provided by the school he became one of the top students in his grade level unfortunately in Middle School his father and I decided to switch him schools to focus on his future career he was accepted to the his L USD home school which has a magnet program but it didn't go well his grades went down drastically his mental health was bad and when I seek support from the school it was non-existent at La Leadership Academy we know everyone by their name when I went to one of his parent conference at this new school they asked me what is his ID number I provided it when the teacher realized who he was he said Oh you mean

367the loner at the corner sorry that response did and said well I then decided to return him to La Leadership Academy he graduated as a latorian in e8th grade and he is now an A 10th grader with um um sorry m Kum L my middle child who is currently seventh grade student has achieved academic success including earning met and exceeded ratings and state exams constantly earning honorable placement Dr Ras your recent statement on the 2024 elections Pro powerfully underscore the need of her commitment to our shared goals values and vision you reminded us that now more than ever we must make our voices Stand United your call for Unity resonates deeply therefore I urge the L the board to stand with LA Leadership Academy by voting in one for our Charter renewal help us continue

368providing a sanctuary for all of our students thank you board members thank you for your time I have Gerald Ivory on the line Gerald Ivory please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Gerald hi hi this is uh Gerald Ivory hi Gerald if you could just speak up a little bit you're coming in a little bit muffled oh sorry about that um actually I would like to yield my time to uh uh Pastor Janes Thomas uh sir you already I'm sorry you've already you've already spoken so we we have a board rle that only allows for one one a but I I I just want to say I want to say that this particular School my kids went to this particular principle intervene e do what

369I have another caller on the line called Armani Armani are you on the [Applause] line Armani are you in the room is there an Armani Armani are you there I don't have Armani on the line in front of me uh Mr Mr it might just take a moment but if he's speaking remotely we're going to give this person a chance M Mr Armani is on the line apparently I'm waiting for it to show up um Jana do you know what number he's calling from because he might be calling from a different number than that we have listed no um correct it's the last speaker is he calling from the last number 6620 can I can I yeah that's novel let's do that you have two minutes to speak once you begin uh hello my name

370is Armani and I am in 11 grader I am a student of I mean I am a member of student deserve and a rise uh Club member which stands for resilience in group solidarity um education program at norbon High School uh we call on the LA school board and sub carvalo to pass a motion to reaffirm that the Bap program is a beneficial program specifically to re address Decades of in imparable harm caused by LUSD racial uh discriminatory uh policies against uh black students black students in La USD have um historically had the lowest achievement scores of a racial group black students are more likely to receive a d or an F than Asian Latino right students black students are under uh represented in Upper levels of steam courses which is pretty sad to help

371with this Lac has uh developed the black student achievement program for black students this has been going well while still in work early data suggest that Bap has been helping to improve academic performance among black students in La USD at the 5,000 role model of um excellent uh project event it has helped me shap my view on VAP as well uh um receive it as a organized program for black students and I really do see a fature for black students if we continue to keep the black in the be up uh thank you thank you for your time armman there's actually one more person listed Marius Moore come on up Mr Moore you'll have two minutes to speak why don't you begin hello my name is Tara Welch I never been here before but I

372did want to speak in regards to the Lawrence Middle School incident with I think is seon I met her um and I thought her situation was very alarming and concerning to me I myself have been dealing with racism with my two sons since 20122 at a school called lick and now Tarzana my two sons are here here um when it comes to racism and you guys don't respond I don't think you understand the outcome of the children and the reason why I wanted to speak is because when those things happen to children and you don't address them you make it hard for parents like me my two sons Now call each other my two sons fight each other every day and your plan is to put my sons in a juvenile H system so you

373guys can make more money so with that I choose to keep my sons out of school sometimes they're late and I don't care I've been to the district today I also emailed you it's such a pleasure to see you I emailed you Mr Alberto about six seven times you didn't even respond to me about my kids when he had a gun threat that his face was going to get shot off you ignored me you just ignored me but now I get to see you in your face and tell you that that sucks now I still break my sons apart I have a light-skinned son and I have a dark skinned son how do you fix that in the school system now I have a problem at home where these officers in the back they waiting

374to pick up a kid especially a black kid but you guys make the problem because you know why at schools you don't say nothing I just went to the schools today and nobody said nothing so I'm just here to support the parents all the parents and I don't think it's really a like a racial thing I just think that you guys just don't understand understand how powerful we are and you just want to crush spirits and you shouldn't do that think about kids these are children and guess what also when they go to Middle School by the time they get out they go to jail at 12 do you guys teach them about the laws you don't Implement that it's no amendments nothing why you don't give these kids no real structure so they know

375what's going on but that's what I'm speaking on protect the kids thank you thank you for your time that concludes from are here in the back right there sa's Mom and Dad right there um and the community about antiblackness that's happening in I'll note for the record that we're getting some papers that um I'm going to distribute to the board right now okay that concludes the general public comment period and we have remaining on the agenda tabs 17 18 19 20 21 and 22 Each of which have uh robust public comment and are also um public hearing so I'm going to grab those papers read the public hearing statement for tab 17 and then we'll take uh the public comment from those from those folks e e okay tab 17 um denial of renewal petition

376for ivybound Academy of Math Science and Technology Charter Middle School and I believe we first have a presentation from Dr Steven B blin executive director are you here Mr bline great we're going to um put up your PowerPoint make sure that the clicker Works to your satisfaction and then you'll have two minutes to um go through the PowerPoint and then we'll take the um looks like 15 public commenters on the on the item good thank you is the the microphone sound okay when you use it thank you yeah you got it good afternoon superintendent carvalo and honorable board members my name is Steve blin and I am the director of ivybound Academy previously having worked in La USD for 26 years including 10 years as your principal in both in District Board District 4 and

377six ivybound Academy has been serving the students for the past 17 years since 2007 with a thriving small Learning Community Middle School since I last saw you in the 1617 school year our demograph our demographics at ivybound have changed markedly our socio economic disadvantaged student body was 35% then and is 75% now our El population was 2% then and is 20% now our RFA population was 25% and now it's 38% we have been adapting to this changing landscape to be sure throughout our 17-year history Charter Schools division staff has consistently given us high ratings on the annual oversight visits as you can see up here including our most recent review less than one year ago we have been rated in the middle tier by the CDE and compared to the state ratings on the 2023

378dashboard we are at the same levels as the state in ela and math and significantly higher than the state on the elpi average and the suspension rate Although our post pandemic performance saw a decrease in 2324 like many other schools have part of the part of the seventh grade cohort decrease in performance was due to a couple factors one we are very proud to welcome the students that were displaced by the closure of North Valley military school they were turned away from their traditional schools and they found a home at ivybound honorable board members as you read the CSD report you will find there no findings regarding our Charter petition and in fact CSD asked very few questions about our petition during the process and we bring you today accomplished ratings from the CSD annual

379oversight visits for the past seven years Mr blin I just have to there was the two-minute warning and I apologize one one more line please thank you I urge you to substitute the CSD recommendation for denial for a petition with a motion to approve the petition that includes benchmarks the closure is not in the best interest of the students thank you superintendent thank you honorable board members thank you for your time sir we'll now proceed to take the public comment on the item there are 15 speakers I'll call on the folks who are listed as speaking in person and then we'll transition to those who are listed as speaking remotely we have all one two three four five um about half of the speakers are remote so we'll do the inperson uh first let's see

380Amir uh a are you here Amir come on up and then after Amir um Dr blin is also signed up to speak after Amir and then after that um Andrea Palmer I am actually remiss let me make my public hearing statement so that we are have all our ducks in a row on this all right so this is for tab 17 I apologize for the wait sir uh denial of renewal petition for Ivy bound Academy of Math Science and Technology Charter midle Middle School before action is taken on uh this board report denial of the renewal ition for ivybound Academy of Math Science and Technology Charter Middle a public hearing must be held this constitutes that public hearing and a maximum of 15 individuals who wish to address the board on this item will be

381heard those who wish to speak should sign up online which they have and speakers will be called uh by name so Amir please the two minutes is yours um honorable board members good afternoon uh I'm first of all would like to say that I'm a proud um I proudly attended La USD middle school and high school so I'm proud of that uh my name is Amir Ali madani and I'm one of the founding members board members of ivybound Academy I stood before this board 18 years ago asking this board for a chance to serve our community we opened our doors in August of 2007 and from 2007 until 2017 we were the district's highest performing Middle School District's highest performing middle school and one of the top performing schools in the state even after that

382we've been still a high performing School except the last couple of years we were the district's poster school we had two campuses serving 250 students each which was our capacity and we had close to 900 students on our waiting list what happened was that our director went and we actually had somebody we had actually prepared someone from inside to take control of it but unfortunately she had a massive heart attack and she passed away after a year she had taken over then we had another person who took over the school and that person also within a year died of cancer at age of 30 so we were left with the administrative staff being sh in shambled this forc us to look outside so once we got a new person on Dr bluin which I'm very

383proud of uh covid happened and um so with covid a lot of things went astray we are still in your report it shows that we are a middle performing School we're not a low performing school we have exceptional finances if you look at all of our other scores every single visit that CSD has done um we' we've passed it with flying colors all I'm asking you is give us another chance renew us for two years and we will show you what school we are thank you for your time sir uh Dr blin and then after Dr blin will be Andrea Palmer and then Faith Park hello um super intendent and honorable board members not just in academics as I spoke about earlier but the very much necessary social emotional learning that goes on as Ivy

384at Ivy bound is what you should know about also this is clearly evidenced by our dashboard color of blue for suspensions and expulsions we don't suspend children not because we can't suspend children but we don't need to suspend children our students are empathetic they're not impulsive and they're problem solving this is something that is taught to them it's modeled by everybody on campus it's taught to their parents it's learned and it's practice which is what Ivy bound is under the hood and why our teachers and staff stay with us for years and years in academic or pre-pandemic performance saw increasing Ela metrics post-pandemic we decreased in seventh grade as I spoke about earlier but our instru instructional staff has implemented a detailed action plan and address to address the achievement which is on page 19

385of our petition and includes robust supports in programs like mtss the multi-tiered system of supports and udl in fact in the two nwaa benchmark assessments completed this school year already at the beginning of the year and before Christmas break we are seeing growth in all areas we are seeing growth in all areas we've hired an intervention teacher and and 30 additional school days to the school year for the past two years with our elop money I respectfully urge you to read the letter I sent you yesterday and substitute the motion before you with a motion to approve Ivy bounce petition with Ben benchmark Mar s that you see fit thank you thank you Dr blin next we have Andrea Palmer Andrea Palmer if Andrea is not here we'll have Julie Chu oh she's on the

386phone I don't know how to work this thing very well thank you okay I got it I got I got you sir see if so Andrea Palmer is not here correct and then going to Julie Chu a little out of order uh uh Miss Chu I see you're on the line please press star six to unmute yourself and you have two minutes to speak once you begin Julie Chu hi thank you for your time today my name is Julie chow and I'm part of our Administration team I've been with ivybound for almost 7 years now and it's where I began my career and now my passion in education ivybound has become a family a home and a part of my identity the sense of belonging and purpose that ivybound provides is truly rooted in our

387common goal of providing our students with an enriching educational experience in the safest and most supportive environment possible all of our teachers and staff serve our school upon this Firm Foundation our Ivy bound family Works more more collaboratively and collectively as a team than anywhere I have ever worked and we take pride in the example of teamwork that we demonstrate to our students daily our close-nit community within the team and with each student and their families is something that cannot be found anywhere else the connections we have with each other at ivybound is truly special and fundamental in providing a school where students and teachers are excited to come to every day I humbly ask the board today to allow our school and our team to continue to work together in providing our students with

388this enriching place to learn and for us to continue to stay in the most purposeful place to work thank you for your time thank you for your time next up is Mr David tolkovsky and then after that Jennifer Robertson so uh Mr doovi the floor is yours thank you very much for the opportunity on this public hearing to speak um I know a school of 80 kids is probably not financially doable but there are schools that we do have 80 kids at that we have a large Organization for to send resources but when you're a standalone it's very difficult I want to ask the question uh at any point is there a letter from the charter school office that asks this school if they would become an Affiliated Charter and be part of the school

389district is there any documentation email letter or otherwise is there any documentation on the previous item that the school district sent a letter to C and said you know you might be better under the alternative dashboard over the last eight years nobody from the district sent that now granted they could have asked but it's a two-way street it's a relationship that's what a charter is it's an agreement between two parties is there any documentation uh from the Charter office that suggests with that level of African-American students that they might benefit from Bap was there a letter from the Charter office an email or any documentation where they actually said you know superintendent's got this great program there's another one priority schools there's these are all our kids I think is the rhetoric we use all

390of these are our kids so could there have been affiliation could there have been an inclusive in Bap could there have been inclusive in Prior schools Foster youth is the biggest challenge that school that you denied has a population of foster youth that is significant not only on the homeless so could we have brought a school with that kind of passion into the organization we have gone now a long time 30 years Mr smon has the largest collection of Affiliated schools district internal schools in the entire country let's advocate for bringing them in this is M Goldberg would sort of ask that well why aren't we asking each one of those you would be better off if you were helped by the district's steam thank you very much thank you for your time okay Sean

391Hunsinger Sean come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin and after Mr Hunsinger it'll be Jennifer Robertson floor is yours sir good afternoon superintendent carvalo and honorable board members my name is Sean Hunsinger and I'm the principal of Ivy bound Academy I stand before you today to Advocate passionately for the renewal of our school Charter I have been lucky to have served the students and families of ivybound Academy for the past 13 years first as a PE teacher and worked my way up through the administration ranks during this time we built a school Legacy of Excellence built on a strong Foundation of commitment to high standards and educ education over the years we have consistently demonstrated our dedication to nurturing well-rounded individuals who Excel academically socially and emotionally this is evident

392by the numerous students that come back and visit every year to thank the staff for all they have done for them year after year our students and families are proud of the choice they make to send their school to send their child to our school our team ensures that our students have a safe learning environment where they can thrive parents are able to drop their child off knowing that they will not have to worry about fights they don't have to worry about drugs or bullying on campus when an issue does arise they feel comfort in knowing that they can communicate with me or other staff members quickly and often times without an appointment our school is not just an educational institution it's a vibrant and diverse Community our school emphasizes the importance of inclusivity respect

393and mutual support all stakeholders are committed to fostering an environment where every student feels valued where diversity is celebrated and where strong relationships between students parents and staff are nurtured over the past few years we have been able to open our doors to numerous Ukrainian and European refugees fleeing from a warn torn country many of them have little to know English proficiency and by the time they leave are able to hold conversations and are prep prepared for high school it has been difficult to rebound from covid-19 we will continue to strive to educate our students to the best of our ability while our doors are open I urge all of you to support the renewal of our school Charter so that we can continue to uplift our students and our community thank you thank you

394for your time Jennifer Robertson come on up you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin thank you for your time and good evening to to superintendent carvalo and The Honorable board members excuse me my name is Miss Jennifer Roberson and this year marks my ninth year teaching fifth grade at Ivy bound and I distinctly recalled during my interview that the executive director at the time asked that he wanted talent that was not just looking for aob job but for a home and that is exactly what I found at Ivy bound excuse me the faculty and staff are very deeply invested in the students both academically and socio emotionally the positive School culture at ivybound that we have developed is immediately apparent evident and utterly palpable the moment one crosses the threshold we focus on

395the whole child excuse me Ivy bound is a school that is a welcoming environment where everyone belongs feels safe to learn be themselves and to thrive though Ivy bound is a small community we are Mighty we are not the conventional School of a large population but we are compassionate and passionate about teaching holistically the whole child Ivy bound fulfills a need in the community where parents feel safe and confident that they have entrusted us to teach their child and where they can be safe I ask that you please vote your confidence and vote no to not deny the renewal of Ivy bound Academy I can truly say that this is the only school where I've taught where I actually look forward to the professional development and the staff meetings because we actually like each other

396at these meetings and it's a chance where we can get together to learn about how to meet the needs and challenges of our students as they arise and we have the flexibility to be able to change our strategies as the students needs present themselves so thank you so much for your time thank please vote no to deny our Charter thank you thank you for your time uh Faith Park I see you're on the line Faith Park please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Faith Park uh this F to park I us my time yes this is your time if you could just speak up a little bit you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin we'll uh make sure the timer restarts uh I

397would like to yield my time okay who would you like to yield your time to to um next person to the next person okay thank you for your time um Miss Park thank you okay I see Carl Peterson is on the line Mr Peterson please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Carl Peterson he can you hear me uh yes sir make sure you speak up and then I'll turn up the volume a little bit and if you could speak a little bit slower okay in an email to the Charter School Division on December 31st 2024 I detailed issues with Ivy bound Academy's website ignoring requirements of its Charter parents were not being notified that the electronic application could be completed in person at the school

398they were also not informed that all students are admitted unless there are more applications and spaces how closely is the Charter School Division paying attention to the schools that overseas if they miss these avert failures to follow the terms of the charter as of this morning some changes had been made to the website but it is still not in full compliance these requirements Were Meant to ensure that all students have equal access to the school and that the school is not manipulating the demographics of its student body the school's refusal to comply and the charter schools division's failure to provide proper over oversite have resulted in the student body with a lesser percentage of students of color than the closest LUSD middle school and the district as a whole the same is true for students

399with special education needs and those who are economically disadvantaged Ivy bound has a lesser percentage of English language Learners than the LUSD 51.1% of its students are white compared to just 5.9% at the closest La USD School the screening of students from ATR communities is delivered it and marketed by the school in a promotional video the principal brags that the special thing about our school is that you have to apply and go through the lottery system despite the demographics and the failure to follow the terms of the charter the Charter School Division has determined that it is not a basis for denial while agree that the charter should not be renewed I ALS also asked that it's failure to include all students be listed as a reason thank you thank you for your time okay

400the next caller is Jared donon Jared please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Jared D good evening uh members of the LAUSD board my name is Jared donon and I've had the privilege of working at ivybound Academy for the past 10 years over this time I witnessed the profound impact our school has had on our students and Community I bound as is not just a school it's a place where students are nurtured challenged and inspired to reach their full potential our dedicated teachers constantly go above and beyond often giving their own time to ensure every child has the tools they need to succeed our staff Fosters a culture of collaboration and support that helps our students grow both academically and personally additionally our school operates

401with financial responsibility and transparency um I assure you we're probably one of the most financially healthy Charter Schools you've seen if you look at our finances uh we sure that every dollar is utilized to benefit the students and sustain our mission we prioritize not only academic achievement but also the health and wellbeing of our students providing them with the resources they need to thrive it'd be a Pity if those resources that we've saved for Financial Times had to be spent on shutting down the school instead of supporting students um I'm proud to be a part of the school it values Excellence equity and the success of every child who walks through our doors I thank you for your time and I hope that you will support Ivy bound by denying this denial and approving the

402charter thank you thank you for your time uh re I'm sorry the first caller Eric Lopez are you on the line Eric Lopez I see you're on the line please press Start six to unmute yourself Mr Lopez and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Eric Lopez hello can you hear me we sure can please go ahead wonderful hello superintendent carvalo and esteemed members of the board my name is Eric Lopez and it's been a pleasure and an honor to call myself a teacher at IBU bound Academy for the past seven plus years to me iy bound is not just a job but a family we have a tight-knit community of staff students and parents who come together to create an educational experience unique to any other place that I've ever worked our

403students receive top-notch education in the core subjects along with a looping strategy that gives them the benefits of really knowing their teachers by the time they graduate from eth grade every year without fail I have alumni visit and state that they cherish the time that they had at our school and how well we prepare them to succeed at the next level in addition to the standard coursework our students are enriched with online programs that supplement their math and English learning the school also offers a voluntary peer tutoring program as well as a before and after school program to boost student uh work completion called a assistance and homework club respectively we also have added a math intervention specialist to assist them our small population allows us to offer students who would otherwise be lost in

404The Fray of a large school an opportunity to participate in clubs and programs that further enrich their education such as creating editing a student video news yearbook robotics peer tutoring and school leadership furthermore our school has a diverse ethnic population with over 20% of our students designated as elll representing different corners of the globe as well as a multitude of socio-economic statuses with over 70% receiving free and reduced lunch this exposure to different cultures beliefs and World Views allows them to gain a deeper appreciation of cultures and a way of life other than their own we have initiatives that focus on promoting positive character traits among students such such as respect responsibility honesty and empathy by emphasizing these values our school creates an environment conducive to building social capital and expanding students networks these relationships

405help students navigate not only their school environment but also their social emotional growth while fostering cultural exchanges building relationships with families promoting inclusivity creating shared experiences and ultimately strengthening their Community ties I would like to encourage you to think critically about this decision please prioritize student opportunities and Community needs by supporting our chared together we can ensure that every child has access to an excellent Equitable education in conclusion I would like to end with the word of my answer people will forget what you said people will forget what you did people will never forget how you did them feel and I be bound we encourage every student to feel that they can succeed thank you for your time we appreciate your time okay Rema aak kanyan Rema agak Kanan I see that you're signed up

406to speak remotely but I do not see you signed in at this time all right uh Raina lomova Raina lomova please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Raina lomova hi my name is Raina lomova and I have worked in many different roles as an ivy bound employee since 2015 but Ivy bound has been part of my life for 17 years now my daughter graduated from I bound Academy back in 2011 and as a parent I could not have been happier with the choice I made made for her to attend i b Middle School what truly touches me how welcoming and supportive the teachers and staff were and made School feel like a second home seeing her grow not only in knowledge but in emotional strength

407watching her discover her passions pursue her dreams and slowly build the foundation of the person she become proven to me that I made the right choice for her she's been part of Team projects school events and volunteer activities that have shown her the power of working together what makes iy bound special is the gift sense of community support and belonging that it offers every single student it's a place where children are not just taught but truly seen and understood in our school we believe in every student potential no child is ever overlooked and no dream is too big it's place where students are empowered to achieve to Excel and to become the best version of themselves not just academically but personally working at I bound has been a wonderful experience the staffs here are not

408just colleagues they're team United by a shared passion for helping students Thrive their sense of trust friendships and support that makes the school feel like family we work together to ensure that every student feels valued understood and encouraged to do their best our goal is to provide the best possible experience for our students ivybound is a place where every child no matter their background or ability is embraced and encouraged to reach their full potential I feel incredibly lucky to be a part of communities of Educators who care deeply about each other and the students and I'm deeply grateful for the opportunity to work alongside such a passionate dedicated individuals together we're making a difference thank you for your time and consideration thank you for your time Stephanie stassel you're signed up to speak remotely but

409I do not have you signed in are you in the room Stephanie s I think she's on the phone okay I I have her listed as being on the phone but I do not have uh her having called in in front of me we can come back to miss stessel uh let's see Ida Flores I see you're on the line please press star six to unmute yourself Ida Flores good afternoon my my name is SAA Flores as both a former parent and current employee of IB bang Academy it is with great pride that I stand before you to before you today to discuss the reward of our CHS as a parent I have I have seen the power of Education with those WS my children my children grow so much during their time at IB

410bound my husband and I could not have been happier to make their right decision to elect I bound Academy for all all child all children to attending Middle School I be I bound Academy housing then in so many ways for example they Foundation they receive from the educ educated teachers and the high level of education education made them successful with their Advanced education once one one great example that made me so proud of then was there they were attending High School assistant the math teacher to toring other students and this was only possible thanks to I bound which has been provided a high quality education through throughout those years as an employee I've been been lucky to work with amazing teachers and staff who care so much about the students every day we all come

411to work with a a smile and our faces and do whatever is taken to help educate educate our students we are dedicated to giving our students a great education and supporting other each renewing or sh is a a chance to make our school even better for everyone as a both a parent and employee I am aware of the important importance of being part of a school Community or families are always ready to willing to help our school students and families ready enjoy being a part of IB bang Academy thank you thank you for your time the next caller caller is Erica Pia Erica P please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Erica penia hello my name is Erica pania I'm a parent Ivy bound Academy

412has been part of our Lives since August 2015 when my daughter started fifth grade the school encouraged students to be scholarly honorable and Visionary in a safe and small learning environment my daughter excelled the school provided the tools to excel in math science technology and English my daughter with the lessons from her teachers and computer program Alex she excelled to math and on the standardized test ranked in the 90th percentile during all her years as an eighth grader she took the high school placement test and placed in 11th grade math her iy bound Academy English teacher covered the same books used in High School AP English with this knowledge it was the foundation for successfully passing both AP English language and literature exams she graduated with honors in 2019 from ivybound Academy and with honors

413from the science Academy's gem magnet in 2023 in North Hollywood in August 2022 my son started fifth grade at ivybound Academy he has excelion math scoring in the 90th percentile on the CPP his scores exceeded the standard level four for English he has consistently improved with a score of Standards met level three I credit the scores to his teachers Alex and Alexia he loves coming to school and the safe learning environment his teachers are amazing and encouraging along with the core subjects he enjoys art and PE every day the school is a second home to us and we only hope the district will support the school and encourage more students to attend thank you thank you for your time last call for Rema agak Kanan and Stephanie stassel neither of whom appear to be on

414the line that concludes public comment in the uh presentation for this uh tab 17 it's now appropriate for board discussion any any questions or discussion from from the yeah Tanya is on the line and it looks like um board member grego stepped out just briefly let me go make sure that Miss greo doesn't have any questions I'll be right back e uh Miss uh Franklin do you have any questions either for this item no I don't thank you okay thank you uh are there any questions do you have any questions on this item tab 17 uh and I don't believe Miss newbill does either so uh would anyone like to move to um vote on the item I'll move second thank you so the item is moved by uh Dr rias and seconded by board

415member GGO we'll take the vote um board member new bill we are voting on Tab 17 questions did you have any questions on Tab 17 I don't believe you did okay thank you all right now for the vote uh Miss Newell yes Dr Ras yes Mr melne yes M GGO yes uh Miss gonz let me see if Miss gones has rejoined uh Miss orti Franklin yes yes that's a yes uh board president sharlon yes okay Miss gones is absent for this call okay so item passes moving on to tab 18 tab 18 is renewal approval of the renewal petition for Kip corazone Academy and I believe we have a two-minute presentation coming okay Miss Angela Martinez okay outstanding take your time uh and and so are you just for procedure procedural are you gonna speak

416on each one individually as they come up okay perfect perfect just want to clarify let me just see if this work works okay this way this way okay and I know it's uh short amount of time but it's two minutes for the presentation and then we jump into the public the public comment yes thank you so much thank you uh good evening I'm Angela Martinez the CEO of Kip soow public schools and Lead petitioner for Kip gason a school that has not only brought Southgate together but also achieved excellent academic results on behalf of the school's 1,000 67 students and their families I asked the board to vote Yes on the recommendation to renew Kip cotone for 5 years Kip koson is a beacon of Community Pride and connection our annual tiangi brings together 40

417local businesses and hundreds of attendees our students families and staff are perennial participants in southgate's annual 5K Kip kon's impact goes beyond community building it's also achieving excellent academic results time and time again our school and its student groups have posted higher results than the state and L USD in ela and math I'll pause here so you can really look at that and the chart here shows that in nearly every instance Kip kotone has also posted higher Ela and math results than and with our students and then their students most frequently assigned resident schools for all of these reasons it is in the best interest of students and The Wider Southgate Community to keep cottoon open our 1,67 students their families and their neighbors deserve a school that continues to bring people together they also

418deserve a school like ours with excellent academic outcomes I urge the board to stand with our families and in support the continued success of Kip Kone by voting yes on the superintendent recommendation to renew our Charter for 5 years my team and I would be happy to answer any questions that board members may have thank you hey thank you for your time I will call on the folks who list listed themselves as being in person first and then we will go to folks who are speaking remotely so the first four people to come on up would be Ruth cazarez come on up Ruth and then David toosi and I'm reminded that I need to once again read my public hearing statement before we get to these so Ruth then David then Jennifer Ara so this

419is tab 18 approval of the renewal petition for Kip corazone Academy before action is taken on board report d2425 approval of the renewal petition for Kip Corone Academy a public hearing must be held this constitutes that public hearing approval of the renewal petition for Kip Corone Academy and a maximum of 15 individuals who wish to address the board on the item will be heard those who wish to speak should sign up online and I'll not that they already have and speakers will be called by name and our first speaker is Ruth C please go ahead good evening superintendent carvalo and members of the LA USD board I was here last month and I'm going to repeat the speech I gave last month because I think it should be fresh um when you vote my name

420is Ruth casades I'm the proud parent of a sixth grade student at Kip korason in Southgate I'm here today to voice my strong support for the renewal of GI kon's Charter my son has been a student at Kip korason for over six years and choosing this school for him has been one of the best decisions I've made from the start Kip korason has shown unwavering commitment to support my son's academic and personal growth today he is not only thriving academically but also feels safe supported and valued as part of th this school Community our journey has not been without challenges from a very young age my son faced significant struggles with behavioral and social emotional development at just 3 years old he was expelled from preschool a heartbreaking and isolating experience for any parent when

421I applied to Kip kotas I was drawn to their philosophy of revolutionary love a commitment to changing the Status Quo by empowering children to reach their full potential Kip korason has more than lived up to this promise thanks to the Relentless support and belief of the corason staff my son has made remarkable progress so much so in fact he no longer requires a 504 plan this Milestone is a testament to the dedication of the school's Educators and their ability to meet each child where they are they have always seen my son's potential and work tirelessly to help him Su succeed for that I am forever grateful at kib korason my son is more than just a student ID number he is part of a family the administrators know his name they listen to my concerns

422and they are always just a phone call away I urge you to support the renewal of Kip kon's Charter every child in our community deserves the chance to attend a school like Kip korason a school that sees their values supports their growth and fosters a sense of belonging losing this school would be a devastating loss for our community especially for families like mine who have experienced its lifechanging uh impact firsthand thank you for your time thank you for your time David toosi then Jennifer ARA and then Melissa to is so David Jennifer and then Melissa thank you very much uh as you all know Kip quarter zone is located in Southgate and as as you all know Southgate belongs to four school districts Downey La unified permont and Lynwood four I represented it for four

423years now Downey Unified has declared its open enrollment so kids are leaving La unified not because of affiliation but they've said you can come on over so people historically La Unified Schools scored higher than Paramount unified and Lynnwood and because of the racial composition of Downey not so much the city council used to complain to me why don't you do something in La unified and then when I looked up the five city council people of Southgate they all lived in Downey UniFi area so they representing four school districts were complaining about the second highest performing School District LA unified I turned to them and said why don't you help out your citizens and and constituents in paramont and Lynwood why are you complaining about a school district that's doing very well again I bring us

424back to the topic of three years or more of me talking about Affiliated Charters as a vehicle you close down a a a a a u a continuation school or a strange school called cre let's look at the performance levels but we have at least continuation schools in our district these other districts don't even have kind of schools that we have and yet we not inviting people in by breaking down the borders Downey is doing it they've always done that so let's as you refill the position at the end of the year about the uh Innovative schools or whatever it is Mr superintendent use your energy your creativity and your intelligence because others are moving faster and more thoughtfully and so I have no opinion here you you you the metrics are here on this

425school okay but let me tell you Downey Unified has thought it through and they always do and they're doing it to the damage of La unified as they've always done it and we're sitting flat standing flat footed while we lose students thank you very much thank you for your time Jennifer ARA come on up you have two minutes to speak once you [Applause] begin good afternoon superintendent carvalo and La USD board members my name my name is Jennifer ARA and I am the proud School leader at Kip gason Academy upper school a538 middle school in the community of Southgate I am here today to ask for your support and that you vote Yes on the renewal of Kip gason Academy since gon's founding in 2018 we have dedicated ourselves to not only the academic Excellence

426of our students but also the cultivation of a restorative community-driven culture in 2020 korason Academy was recognized as an Innova Innovative top performing LA County public school and in 2025 we earned the distinction of being named one of the best middle schools in California our students outperformed our neighboring schools average in both math and Ela standards on the Casp last year and we continue to push ourselves to innovate on best learning practices for our students that said we believe these recognitions are not only the result of academic achievement but a reflection of our dedication to meeting the needs of every student our commitment to building a community grounded in restorative practices high expectations and authentic relationships with families is what sets us apart like many schools across the country Kip guason has faced significant challenges

427post pandemic among these the teacher shortage has been the most impactful despite this we made a firm commitment to ensure that every classroom is staffed with committed Educators so our students continue to receive the high quality instruction they deserve every day our dedication to maintaining a consistent learning environment has been a priority and we've worked to overcome these obstacle to support our students academic success voting yes on the renewal for Kip gason is crucial as families students and staff are united by a shared goal to create a space where we lead with both pride and purpose knowing that when we come together as a community there is no limit to what we can achieve Kip SoCal and Kip gason are the white right choice for many families we ask for your continued support in renewing

428our Charter so we can keep keep impacting lives and building the Future Leaders our community deserves thank you thank you for your time Melissa Torres Melissa Torres good evening my name is Melissa Torres and I'm the proud School leader at Kip corason lower school I um I just connected with Melissa and we are we're we're grateful for your support for korason but we're going to wave our time um to make sure that we can and get to Soul's uh vote thank you thank you for your time yareli Martinez we're going to wave the time for all of the rest of the speakers for Corazon okay I just can't guarantee that they're from corazone so I'm gonna read the name and then as long as somebody I don't want to skip someone who rightfully is here

429to speak in some other different voice coach Rico weave okay uh let's see CC Garcia oh CES W okay uh Laura Flores wave Diana Dominguez wave uh saret Lopez wave Sheila van demier wave uh Priscilla esel wave Elizabeth delosa wave okay and then I have uh let's see Carl Peterson calling in I don't think he I don't think you thank you that is Rich uh Mr Mr Peterson I see you on the line please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin uh Mr Peterson okay you got me yeah I just uh reiterate the same request maybe speak up a little bit and uh maybe slower and we can hear you just perfectly okay on January 17th 2022 the Charter School Division published a report showing the

430path due balance owed by charter schools for over allocation fees was 13,745 310 3 months later that balance was $ 5,174 $29 while $665,000 accounted for by payments 7,678 22 and mysteriously disappeared from the assessed fees no explanation was given for the reduction Kip cor isone benefited from $ 28,1 of this gift it is my understanding that the board was also kept in the dark about this reduction the Charter School Division and the superintendent's office acted unilaterally and did not seek the board's approval for lowering these State mandated fees unless the district's selected Representatives gave them authority to take these actions they are not valid the Charter School Division needs to provide a legitimate explanation for the deductions otherwise the 7,678 th000 should be returned to the balance sheet it is important to remember that

431under District policy 90% of these payments go to the schools that were directly affected by having Charter Schools take more space on their campuses than they were entitled to under law this includes children with special education needs who receive services in stairwells and closets because Jose Cole Gutierrez decided that the space used for these purposes were empty and could be given away with Kip cazon seeking renewal of their Charter this may be the only opportunity you will have to get answers what were the specific reasons their balance was reduced by $ 28,1 if a sufficient explanation cannot be provided then the charter renewal should be contingent upon the school paying what is due plus interest thank you thank you for your time we have one more person listed as calling in remotely at Rachel T

432but I do not have you signed in Rachel T Rachel T are you in the room all right that concludes comment on this item it was pulled for discussion from consent so I assume there's some discussion to be had right I believe that our first question is from Dr revas yes I just want to uh raise um just an area of concern so I know that the school has um benchmarks for students with disabilities and the data also presents a mixed picture for long-term English learners so while there's been growth in math Ela scores show a concerning decline even though the school is performing higher than the state but to ensure that students receive the support they need with uh why weren't any benchmarks considered for long-term Learners in both subjects but particularly in ela

433so just wanted to know um your thoughts on that testing there you go thank you for the question board vice president in short you did note it's a little loud now sorry you did note um the benchmarks that have been assessed for students with disabilities as a as uh to score for our analysis and be to be as consistent as we can with benchmarks we're assessing if a student group is below the state and also in the red category okay so with the latest data those uh students with disabilities fill into that category have the benchmarks the others did not while there's still as you knowe some areas to to continue to monitor so while they don't have specific benchmarks called out every student group we monitor each year an oversight and we'll assess that

434very closely as I've noted in Prior uh discussions and so that's that's the rationale just there will be continued oversight on on all are but also on on Long long-term English learning every single student group every single student group we just noted those that met those criteria for the specifics but every student group is the data are monitored uh and discussed with the school okay thank you that's all my questions thank you any other questions from board members Miss orti Franklin any questions for you or miss gones any questions okay all right okay so I G I guess we're ready to vote and this is for approval correct Mr approval of the petition approval Zone Academy I'll move a second moved by Dr Ras seconded by Miss nuel okay now the vote Miss nuell yes

435Dr revas yes Mr M yes Miss grigo yes Miss gonz Miss Ortiz Franklin yes that's a yes from M orti [Applause] Franklin hey I get a vote too okay one more vote uh board president sharlon yes okay item passes okay now on to tab 19 this is a board of education report 155 approval of the renewal petition for Kip philosophers Academy going to read the same uh public hearing statement then we will receive the two-minute presentation proceed just as we did for the prior School uh tab 19 board report uh number 15524 4/25 uh before action is taken on this board report approval of the renewal petition for Kip philosophers Academy a public hearing must be held this constitutes that public hearing um approval of the renewal petition for Kip philosophers Academy and a maximum

436of 15 individuals who wish to be heard wish to address the board on the item will be heard those who wish to speak should do so online they already have speakers will be called by name and now for the two-minute presentation followed by the public comment floor is yours thank you hi again my name is Angela Martinez I'm the CEO of Kip SoCal and Lead petitioner for Kip philosophers Academy a fast improving School in Watts on behalf of the school's 393 students and their families I ask the board to vote Yes on the recommendation to renew kit philosophers for 5 years our verified data results translated into exceptional year-to-year gains on the 2024 dashboard our year-to-year gains in ela and math far exceeded LUSD in the state this progress proves that our targeted interventions are

437working for students Kip philosophers has also posted a higher English learner progress indicator than LUSD and the state for three consecutive years last year we surged ahead with 71.2% of English Learners making progress on the lpac it is important to note that our Ela results are also higher than our students most frequently assigned resident schools you can see this up here pause it is in the best interest of students and The Wider Watts Community to keep philosophers open our 393 students their families and their neighbors deserve a school like ours and their Community I urge the board to stand with our families by voting yes on the superintendent's recommendation to renew kit philosophers for five years my team and I would be happy to answer any questions board members may have oop sorry Dr Rivas

438I believe you had a question yes okay I just um just some areas of concern no specific questions I just want to say that is it is commendable that Kip philosophers Academy has shown consistent Improvement in both Ela and math scores across all student groups particular students with disabilities in math however given the school's history of low performance compared to the state average I just want just one some areas of concern that I just want to point out uh while improvements are noted scores of black students and those with disability still lag significantly behind State averag in both Ela and math uh specific measurable benchmarks um would have been um helpful to accelerate the progress and ensure that they're on track but I do know that this Char School Division will be um having uh

439some strong oversight there for social socioeconomically disadvantaged students this group makes up a significant um portion of the student population and mirrors a schoolwide trend of improvement however there are still they still fall significantly below state aages I highly recommend focused over strong focused oversight to ensure that they're making adequate progress and closing the achievement again in the next five years and and the same for all students in math all student groups in math given the school's historical struggle in math it's crucial to focus oversight on all student groups in this subject so it's just some areas that I just wanted to raise but yeah any other questions from board members okay okay we will go to public comment we have 15 folks signed up Michael Wimberly um we'll Kip will wave all of our

440public sweepers but I know you have to go one by one okay great let's do the same we'll do the same dance I'll read the name and then you let me know if that person's affiliated with your school if not and it's someone with another opinion we will take them at that time okay uh Michael Wimberly okay David tolkovsky hi David stovsky former School Board member of 12 Years teacher in the district I don't know if I spoke too fast last time but I was trying to say we need to be more Innovative we need to to pursue growth and enrollment and sometimes it might piss off a superintendent in par Mont or Lynnwood or Compton or or Hawthorne or somewhere around the district but if our schools are better and Performing more we need

441to open up our Excellence to other people okay that's what Downey is doing but not necessarily they're doing it more on sces than performance and and I know the elementary schools in South Kate if you look them up and you just ask your staff to do a comparison of of Paramount's performance Lynwood's performance La UniFi and Downey you'll start to see it you'll see that the schools in Torrance that are La unified outperform many of the elementary schools in Torrance unified okay and and on it goes on and on and that goes as well for um the um option schools we have such an incredible we have challenges with our option schools but they perform well and they're there and I know our Deputy superintendent comes from from the option schools we have a leader

442who understands option schools a deputy superintendent of the second largest District but we're not making them available instead people lie they change their address so they can get into our option schools okay why not make it part of the policy of this board and superintendent to do that to get people in now the same thing is true of a a kip School in South La 5 through 8 they're doing it ask the people who come up and speak and say oh where do you live and you'll find out that in Kip Schools they're moving kids from other District into a kip School happen to be your Authority and lastly I want to introduce the topic of special ed Kip schools used to have a horrible problem in some parts of the country with special ed

443they fix that tomorrow you have a major court case in the ninth circuit case in your closed session and you ought to read it tonight so you understand what that ninth Circuit Court the highest court in the land said about our special ed program thank you very very much thank you for your time uh Maria Elena Gonzalez is it a wave okay uh Mirna Medina Vera Portugal Antonio Fielder Zion Grant Freeman uh for the people watching there's a member of the audience who's associated with the administration of the organization who's telling me that these folks who signed up have agreed to wave their time I'm just saying that into the mic because it's recorded for all of posterity uh Roberto Espinosa uh Karina mirz uh Megan Brown Destiny balazar Ashi moton uh Christa robern uh

444chanta or Shanta Wimberly okay we have one more person listed as having called in uh Mr Carl Peterson will you please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Carl Peterson hello yes we can hear you Mr Peterson okay okay when the public hearings for these Charter School renewals were held last month vice president from the California Charter School Association took his time to talk about how in his view this board is supposed to serve children in in charter schools one of the areas he pointed to was a responsibility to ensure that children are safe in the schools that they attend I do not say this very often but on this specific point I agree with him it would seem to me that a charter school chain

445concerned with the safety of its students would not attempt to build a facility on a site that had been used for approximately 90 years for a manufacturing metal and stored the resulting hazardous materials at the location this would be especially true if soil samples at that site showed levels of arsonic 200 times the amount that is identified as safe for human health at the State of California for a school it would definitely bck at a site contaminated with toxic gases which can cause cancer cognitive and motor impairments liver damage kidney damage and impair one's immune system development reproductive system and fertil fertility this all describes land that Kip purchased in cut and then convinced local officials to forgo complete Environmental Studies if it had not been for the community activists who took the charter change

446Accord and halted construction until these studies were performed there might be children on that site right now keep abandoned that project and those students rather than conduct those studies any organization needs a court to tell them that a hazardous way site must be fully investigated before building a school has no business caring for students in the interest of keeping children safe all of K application should be rejected today thank you thank you for your time time let's see that concludes uh public comment on this item so I imagine we are ready to vote go ahead Dr Ras comments um just you want want to point out that it's encouraging to see the upward Trend and academic performance for Kip Scholar Academy particularly significant gains by Latino students in both Ela and math however recognizing the

447school's history of lower performance compared to State averages I believe it would have been um probably um you know good to have to have had measurable benchmarks but I know that the charge school will provide some oversight so I just to that end I just want to um raise some concerns for the following student groups for black students while some improvement is noted this group still lag significantly behind State averages in ela and math and students with disabilities while a benchmark for math Improvement for this group is already recommended by the Char School Division I'd like I would have liked to have seen a corresponding Benchmark in laa but I I trust that the Charter School Division will provide oversight but I just wanted to raise those concerns uh for those two student groups that's

448all so now we are ready to vote would someone like to move this move second okay moved by Dr Ras and seconded by Mr melbo um Miss nuil yes Dr Ras yes Mr melbo yes Miss Grio yes and it looks like Miss gones has joined us online Miss gones yes uh Miss Ortiz Franklin yes board president schmon yes [Applause] [Music] okay we are on to tab uh 20 Kip Scholar Academy um Miss Martinez are going to cue your deck and then I will read the public hearing statement tab 20 this is board report 156 uh- 2425 before action is taken on this board report approval of the renewal petition for Kip Scholar Academy a public hearing must be held this constitutes that public hearing on that report approval of the renewal petition for skip Scholar

449Academy and a maximum of 15 individuals who wish to address the board on the item will be heard those who wish to speak should sign up online and they already have speakers will be called by name and now to the two-minute presentation thank you I keep forgetting to turn on the mic this is practitioner for Kip scholar a fast improving School in South La where the Performing Arts takes center stage on behalf of the school's 416 students and their families I asked the board to vote Yes on the recommendation to renew Kip scholar for 5 years by seventh grade yes by seventh grade our students choose to pursue choir piano or band which is a unique and invaluable opportunity in our community in addition to being a place where students can perform and shine Kip

450scholar is also a place where students learn last year's verified data showed every grade level made more than onee progress in Reading in math our verified data results translated into exceptional year-to-year gains on the 2024 dashboard our year-to-year gains in ela and math far exceeded LUSD in the state this progress proves that our targeted interventions are working for students it is also important to note that Kip Scholars Ela and math results are higher than our students most frequently assigned resident schools for all of these reasons it is in the best interest of students and The Wider South La Community to keep Kip scholar open our 416 students their families and their neighbors deserve our deserve our school where students can shine artistically and academically I urge the board to stand with our families by voting

451yes on the superintendent's recommendation to renew Kip scholar for 5 years and again I will be happy to answer any questions that the board members may have thank you thank you for your time all right we have a Full Slate of speakers for this item I will call the names and if the folks would like to seed their time we're going to do the exact same procedure that we did for item 19 um Tommy McConnell uh David toosi I raised some questions about the lack of questions um positive or negative uh when board members receive briefings those briefings can only be informative and they cannot be a conversation that yields a decision prior to the public meeting and therefore you may not give any indication of your Vote or be asked what your vote is

452that constitutes a violation of the brown act and it constitutes what's called a Serial meeting and Mr McLean as your Defender and two of the board members who are lawyers of our association should be very wary about coming to any decisions prior to the public meeting but celebrating the facts that the the charter school the the amount of questions that were brought on cre were wonderful good questions from Mr meloy Miss gones thoughtfulness about what was happening so I bring again the idea of Affiliated Charters Mr schmon the president represents the largest number of Affiliated schools in the entire country advocacy is needed to bring more of these into the district call them IND District Charters bring people in open up that kids from Pasadena unified don't have to do a per MIT but they

453can come kids from other districts if they choose to come in times of Crisis or in times of academic you made over here we have an empty building Miramar School the Garcia high school it's empty and finally the district stood up and tried to tell the court we'd want Affiliated Charter in there and you were beat back because the Ed code had changed but at least in private you did one effort and it still sits empty and there'll be an RFP or something coming up soon although there's been two rfps try to celebrate your successes not just in rhetoric but by moving to do Innovation and as that position of the Innovative office opens up at the end of this year try to drive change if you reject four Charters today I suppose we will

454also diminish the number of people in the Charter office thank you very much thank you for your time uh Ana giri hi wave okay uh Lorena Gomez wave Kiana Williams wave Wendy monteroso wave Mariah brron wave Annie Patterson wave rain Riley wave Erica Garcia wave rodri Hines wave Eva Beltran wave Anthony Harvey wave David Jeremiah Russell wave and Tiffany Moore wave okay that concludes public comment on item I believe we had some discussion thank you any questions from board members well I realized my error my La my previous comments were actually for scholar so I just didn't realize I was on the wrong that's quite all right so I already I already made them so I don't have to repeat them again anyone else for questions okay thank you anybody would like to moveed by

455Mr mvo seconded by Dr revas uh Miss nubil yes Dr revas yes Mr melvoin yes Miss grigo yes Miss gones yes that's a yes Miss gones Miss Ortiz Franklin yes yes sir Mr Ortiz Franklin um board president schmon yes that's seven okay we'll now move on to tab 21 I will read the public hearing statement and then receive we will receive the two-minute presentation uh tab 21 uh board report number 15724 sl25 before action is taken on this board report denial of the renewal petition for Kip Soul Academy a public hearing must be held this constitutes that public hearing denial of the renewal petition for kipo Academy and a maximum of 15 individuals who wish to address the board on the item will be heard those who wish to speak should sign up online and

456they have speakers will be called uh by name and uh we have 15 speakers to go after your presentation thank you thank you well I'm Angela I'm the CEO of Kip SoCal and the lead petitioner for Kip Soul Academy a California distinguished school and East laa on behalf of the school's 459 students and their families I ask the board to vote no on the recommendation and motion to renew kipou for 5 years L USD policy calls for using the full oversight record and renewal decisions our full Charter term goes back to 2017 and here we see that more often than not Kip soul and its student groups have posted higher results in ela and math in the district and state despite a temporary setback Kip Soul has achieved a higher English learner progress indicator than

457LUSD and the state for three consecutive years this accomplishment can't be overlooked because 21% of our students are English Learners I'm also proud to report that this year's verified data already shows that students have made one year's progress in reading and nearly one year progress in math with more than half the school year remaining this is a California distinguished School home to a nationally acclaimed Mariachi program alumni that have gone on to Columbia Dartmouth UCLA Berkeley why would LUSD close [Applause] kipo anything less than renewal defies the laws intent and the community's needs Dr Ras we know you believe that the fate of a school Community should not be decided by select test scores alone and we agree and that is why kipo must remain open it is not in the in best interest of

458students to close kipo not on the basis of a temporary setback when the school's trajectory clearly shows growth I ask this board again vote no on this recommendation and motion to renew Kip soul for another five years thank you time okay the first speaker is Carla Davalos [Applause] hi quick um we reached out to the Secretariat earlier this afternoon to request that the the speaker slots for sold be rearranged to a different order so you should have that um hopefully I do Carla being the first one then Rosa Michelle Carla Jose does that sound about right uh Carla Rosa Michelle Carla Jose yes thank you so much my name is Garla Davalos and I am the proud School leader at kipo Academy I am here to ask the board to vote no on the recommendation

459to deny and instead motion to renew kipo for 5 years soul is a community school that honors and serves our greater East LA from culturally responsive curriculum to our vibrant performing arts program of Mariachi and fororo and establishing ourselves a as a hub for resources such as food drives job fairs and more to close Soul would be a great diser not only to the 459 students we serve but to our greater East LA Community Dr Ras you visited our school and you talked about transparency um after reviewing the rationale behind the recommendation for closure it feels unjust that the full story of soul and our Improvement is not being acknowledged our team has worked tirelessly to improve the quality of education and I stand here today asking the board to carefully consider our Improvement plan

460to actively listen to the voices of our speakers and to review our middle of the Year student academic data this data is clear concrete evidence that our school is in fact making progress and providing a strong academic experience for our students don't stop our growth now I'm excited to say that my leadership team has motion traction I'm in my third year here at my assistant school leader in her third year my two deans are in their second year and are all committed to returning we are a fully hired team of well-qualified teachers our team's experience is yielding success this year's I ready data already shows students one year of progress in reading and nearly one year of progress in math and we still have half of a school year left to improve on their success

461we are deeply proud of our English Learners who have achieved higher results on English learner progress indicator than their Statewide and LAUSD peers for three consecutive years you all spoke about the importance of keeping communities together so is our students home it's their safe space it's their community and your recommendation to deny would take that from them during a time when stability for La communities is crucial its closure is not in the best interest of our students no uh I urge the board to vote no on the recommendation to deny K Souls renew and I strongly believe that renewing our school is a responsible decision that supports the continued growth and success of our students and our community thank you thank you for your time okay Rosa ban SZ Sanchez are you here Rosa B

462and Sanchez Rosa Sanchez sorry it's not CH Sanchez my last name is gavara bang gavara sorry okay good evening my name is bang gavara and I am a proud alumni and founding student of kipo Academy I'm here today to strongly support the renewal of the charter petition for kipo Academy in East Los Angeles I enjoyed my time at kipo because as a student I was aware that this was a place where I could do any anything I put my mind to where I was safe and protected by everyone around me not just physically but mentally and emotionally I received support from my teachers administrators and counselors as I took on portions of my education to make sure I did not go unnoticed from data driven lesson plans to incentivized supports educationally and behaviorally I was

463set up for Success from the beginning kipo was a safe space where teachers brought the curiculum to life and related it to outside world which is one of the most vital components I've taken with me in life I've learned the importance of values and how to apply them in my future and the student that I've become who graduated with honors and is now attending to be an engineer at one of the top engineering schools in the state was due to the strategies of effective learning and the importance of Independence taught within the walls of kipo I wholeheartedly support kit because they provide not just an education but a nurturing Community which is why I decided to come back as an employee I currently work as a Kinder instructional assistant at Kip R's Academy in East

464LA where I get to help make make a positive impact in the lives of students through Kip socal's Mission the way that all of my former Kip teachers did when I was a student as an employee I now get to be someone students can look up to and feel safe around the way I was able to at Kip Soul at Kip students are safe and supported emotionally academically and socially I feel strongly about this because as an alumni who was now an employee this is the community that I gravitated back to I ask you to please support the renewal of ksol Academy's Charter petition the school is a Cornerstone for our community and it provides opportunities that every student and child in East Los Angeles deserves Advocates that's what we were called at kipo and

465I can proudly say kipo did me Justice by showing me how to be an advocate not just for my education but my community and now for Kip itself it is not in the best interest of East LA Community for soul to close thank you superintendent carvalo and board members for taking the time to listen to an alumni like me thank you for your time Michelle Espinosa Michelle Espinosa and then after Michelle is Carla contas and then Jose Diaz hello everyone um my name is Michelle sposa and I'm I'm sorry to interrupt we'll start we'll start the timer over but if you could speak a little bit closer to the mic so we can that's cool too sorry all right the two minutes will begin once you're all set up okay my name is Michelle espanosa

466and I am proud to share my testimony and support of Kip Soul Charter renewal my family's Journey with Kip soul and Kip luminar has been transforming I am grateful for the opportunity to advocate for these schools that means so much to us I grew up in Balden Park and moved to East Los Angeles with my husband who attended La USD schools our son Pablo is a fifth grader at soul and our son Dominic is a fourth grader at a luminar our youngest son John will hopefully attend in the future Dominic's excitement about joining his brother has reinforced how special these schools are we chose Kip for its incredible sense of community Kip creates a closet environment where every student is supported the teachers go above and beyond for example paa's uh music teacher stays after

467class to work with him one-on-one and inspires him to join Mariachi Dominic who dreams of becoming a doctor eagerly completes extra credit and thri is currently thriving at Kip luminar ready to continue at Soul Pablo who inspires to be a baseball player and a graphic designer feels empowered to dream big Dominic's dreams will be shattered um if he could not join his big brother at soul I feel it is an unjust decision if um we if the renewal for soul was not completed another reason our family loves Kip soul is the exceptional Community the exceptional um sorry exceptional communication teachers keep um keep with us informing us and about concerns their academics and they prioritize their academics their vigorous uh curriculum pushes our children to excel we started on the wait list for Pablo when

468he was 3 years old so please please consider um renewing their renewal thank you thank you for your time Carla contas and then Jose Diaz Carla and then Jose Diaz hello my name is Carla contas I'm a parent to an amazing sixth grader at Kip sold Josiah Jones we have been a kip family since 2020 and enrolling my son at Kip has been the best decision I've ever made I am here today to ask the board to vote no on the recommendation to deny and instead motion to vote Yes to renew Kip Soul's Charter I've seen a huge Improvement in my son's academics since he started at Kip Soul he's made honor rooll each semester I attribute this directly to all the support he has provided by his teachers what I appreciate most about soul

469is that they don't only prioritize academics but also ensure all of my students needs are met unfortunately my son had to handle some adverse situations and has experienced bullying K Soul was proactive in addressing these issues ensuring my son's safety and also going above and beyond in ensuring his emotional wellbe needs were met by connecting him to a school counselor through queso's guidance Direction and enouragement my Josiah feels confident self assured and supported every day after school when I pick up Josiah from school he's excited to share how his day went his days are always filled with highlights of his teachers providing support getting to know him more the new dance move he's learned in florico which he always tipitos he's learned and all the fun interactions he had with his friends he is especially

470excited to have his little sister Anna Marie join him next year deciding to close our school would be a huge interruption in my students learning and would break up the community we have build we would be heartbroken of the school we have to known as a second home is closed I am certain that Kip soul will continue to inspire our students in the community for that reason I urge you to please vote Yes on the renewal of kipo by doing so you're giving us a chance to continue to transform the lives of our students and families and help strengthen our community it is absolutely not in the best interest of my family for soul to close this is my choice I will not enroll in my local neighborhood school thank you for your time and

471consideration thank you for your time Jose Diaz and after Jose Diaz ourlet Morales and then Manny castanada good afternoon board board members my name is Jose Dias and I'm a proud staff member at kipo Academy who has served the community and school for the past eight years as a social studies teacher to educate as a practice of freedom is the teaching that anyone can learn right Bell hooks these are the words that help shape My Philosophy and about the purpose of education and why I stand here in support of my school's renewal for the charter petition for kipo Academy in 1999 my formal learning began in East Los Angeles as an undocumented immigrant within the USD adjusting to the educational system in a new country was challeng alling as I often face obstacles like cultural

472differences PTSD facing discrimination and overcoming language barriers which ultimately impacted my success in school often my mother spoke about a source of as school as a source of inspiration and joy as a student but on the contrary student School often felt like a source of stress hopelessness and mixed feelings as an undocumented student having a wealth of experience and insight as an undocumented student within the system I aim to continue my educational pathway in order to change future experiences for students like myself as an undocumented immigrant I can testify that Kip so has altered my career as a teacher he has not only provided me with a pathway to earn my credentials but has provide me with the tools and development to become the ideal teacher for my students now I stand in a unique

473position as an undocumented teacher to empower my students families and communities continue the work that hooks describes as a practice of Freedom further more kipo has continued to show great Improvement having struggled with covid-19 and a staff shortage over the past 3 years this year is an indication of the positive impact as shown in the growth in the student I data and reduction in vacant positions our Administration has worked tremendously hard to ensure that students receiving quality teachers the roles of teachers in our spaces have been Central and critical to the success of schools I ask you to please support the renewal of the CH the kip Soul Charter petition the school is a Cornerstone in our community and it provides opport that every child needs in the city of Los Angeles thank you so

474much thank you for your time arlet Morales come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin and then it's Manny castan good evening board members my name is arlet Morales I'm honored to serve as a music teacher at kipo for the past eight years I've had the incredible privilege of working with this amazing Community during my interview The principal asked me a question that stayed with me what is your long-term goal for this school without hesitation I said I want to be the face of consistency someone who can teach multiple generations of a family 8 years later I'm proud to say that I've lived to that promise and it has been one of the most rewarding experiences of my life when I started I had a dream of building a program that

475would challenge our students musically push them academically and support them emotionally today that dream became has become a reality through our music program our students have a achieve things they once thought were impossible they perform on some of the most incredible stages on National Television theaters and even Dodger Stadium these experiences have not only showcased their talent but also built their confidence discipline and believe in their own potential but the heart of this program is much more than performances it's about the community we've created together the music room has become a second home for our students a place where they feel safe supported and in inspired even during the challenges of distance learning we stayed connected proving that this program isn't just about music it's about sense of belonging and resilience I stand here today

476to ask you for your Vote for This renewal this school and this program are so much more than a classroom or curriculum they're a Lifeline for our students their families I deeply believe in the greatness of our community I see it every day in the determination of our students the pride of of our families and the strength of our teachers renewing kipo Academy means continuing this Legacy for future Generations providing them with the opportunities and to dream big Exile and to make the mark in the world thank you thank you for your time I have an announcement to make about parking uh if you parked in the Visconti parking lot um that lot closes at 7M so if you leave after that time your keys will be in our front lobby if you dropped off

477your keys with v visconte just want to let you all know um so if you have to leave here after seven your keys will be in our front lobby Manny castanada hello my name is Manny and I'm going to give my to [Applause] Evan uh hello uh before I start I would be combining speaker thoughts seven and eight for a total of four minutes typically we don't um allow for that but I feel like uh you are ready to go so [Music] let's thank you so good afternoon everyone my name is Evan Martinez and I am a proud alumni of kipo Academy and I'm an alumni of kipo Academy's Mariachi program I was lucky to be part of its early years when we when we were just starting to build something special since then the

478Mariachi program has become a big part of our community it has brought people together and even gained national attention through CNN ABC7 NBC dundo Fox Good Morning America and more Mariachi is not just about music it's it is about celebrating our culture and connecting with each other the music room has always felt like a home a place where alumni like me can come back to remember where it all began today I am asking for your support to renew our school so that future students can experience the amazing program that I've been part of let us make sure that Mariachi stays alive for generations to come thank you and I would like to present the kipo academy mariachi [Music] me [Music] forx America Mexico America [Music] [Applause] so [Music] America [Music] thank you for your thank

479you for your time I believe that was two speaker slots combined so that would have been for um Manny castanada and Sebastian sto uh let's go to gu Lup Riva come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin and if we could just reset the timer to uh 2 minutes instead of six thank you so much the floor is yours good good afternoon ofl so um if you'd like to hear simultaneous translation please put your hands up and we'll get head sets out to you from our translations unit they're going to come crashing out of that door any second now there they are please put your hands up and we'll get you the units okay gracias hi I had already introduced myself good evening everybody it's a pleasure to be here I

480was saying I just wanted to introduce my family the kip family we are everybody I'm here to to represent Ian Rosales my son from fifth grade he's in Kip and I ask you that my son have the right to study in Kip without it being closed Kip soul is a second home for my son where the education and the skills he needs to have success is where he can find them it's a community within the school that is securing these big opportunities for his academic success today Kip is the favorite place of my son because the work that he does gives him personal satisfaction and It prepares him to become a professional Kip Soul gives us solidarity in a place where we as a family have benefited from these resources that have made a big

481difference in our lives in these Economic Times Kip has provided this solid place where we've been able to solidify my son's education today he can work in his homework and it's very gratifying to see that how a person who has attention deficit disorder can still have and give big leaps in the school who worries about his education there's no words to express how painful it would be for my son to not be renewed I can't imagine my son outside of kipo we're in very difficult days and times in these changes in government and the children feel fear so closing this school would be something not agreeable for us in these times so he is safe and secure in this school and for this entire Community to have one less thing to worry it we're already

482living these uncertain times so please keep in mind that it's not in everybody's best interest for the school to close thank you Mr carvalo and Miss Rosas my personal representative thank you Nancy San Nancy Sano and then after that will be Edward or ornelas and then Gabriel Gomez Kip Soul parent I here today to ask for your support for the renewal of Kip Soul before I was a math teacher I was a single parent working as a substit substitute teacher in which I had the opportunity to work at schools throughout Los Angeles this is where I noticed the exemplary ways in which Kip schools serve their students during this time I was also deciding which schools to send my eldest daughter to for Kinder I decided to enroll her at Kip at a kip Elementary

483which is the choice I am forever grateful to have had later with the encouragement and support from The Amazing staff members at her school I applied to Kip to teach middle school math my now my oldest daughter is with me at Kip soul and with your support my second daughter will be with me next year as a teacher I have seen Kip Soul improved significantly in the short amount of time despite the many challenges it had faced years prior all of our math classes are now facilitated by patient and passionate teachers their their dedication has resulted in promising student growth we also have a dedicated intervention time for all students to receive extra targeted support in math many of our students are on track to meet or exceed their annual growth goals based on I

484ready math data our middle ofe data shows our students are already performing at the levels that they did at the end of last year this progress is a clear indication of the positive momentum towards the academic Excellence soul is known for being a kip parent for 6 years and teacher for 4 years I wholeheartedly support Kip Soul because I know they provide not just a well-rounded education but a nurturing and uplifting Community for families like mine I ask you to please support the renewal of K Soul Charter petition this school is a Cornerstone of our community and it provides opportunities that every child in the city of East LA deserves thank you thank you for your time Edward ornelas Edward and then uh Gabriel Gomez hello my name is Edward orelis I'm a proud special

485day program teacher at Kip soul I have been in the field of education for six years three of which I spent teaching speo education including one year at ksol I'm here today to strongly support the renewal and Charter pedition of kib so in the city of East Los Angeles since I started at kib so I've witnessed incredible growth in my students academically personally and socially as you may know when it comes to students with special education it's much more than academics I whole hardly support Kip because it's not just a place of learning it's a place of being I have parents who speak highly of the special education program of so because not only do they see growth in their students academically but socially they are proud that their kids feel safe seen and heard

486I have three sixth graders that are on track to exit the special day program and transition into general education two students are on track to exit their eighth grade year and with a possibility of one exiting at the end of next year it would be a huge disservice to them and their families who have put so much time and effort into their students and then having it all taken away not only are we seeing students on track to exit programs but we Al we also have seen growth in all students in math all have made progress and more than half have advanced at least one grade level in English all students have made progress including one student who who has advanced three grade levels in reading this year this is all possible because of the

487supportive environment created at Kip soul and a high standard uphold for both students and teachers I kindly ask for your support in the renewal of Kip Soul Charter petition thank you superintendent and board members for your time and listening to those of us who believe in this school renewing the charter of Kip soul will ensure that we continue to transform lives and strengthen our community for the next 5 to seven years deciding to close K soul is not the best interest of our students families and staff thank you thank you for your time Gabriel [Applause] Gomez okay uh he's going to speak in Spanish so if you have the headsets uh you're already ready to go if you'd like a headset to experience simultaneous trans put your hands up and we'll get you one right

488now okay Gomez hi good afternoon my name is Gabrielle Gomez I am a parent a father and very proud father of a student at Kip stol my daughter is in eighth grade and she will be graduating this uh June she was accepted to one of the best high schools in Southern California Alliance Mar manth and science known as math that was recognized as one of the best schools according to US news thank to Kip soul my daughter dreams with going to stand for a very ambitious goal but that is something that she can reach Kip Soul has given her the mentality to dream big and the tools necessary to be able to do so and that is what we want as parents that our children have the best opportunities and to become the best they

489can be thank to Kip soul my daughter started dreaming with Stanford oh sorry when my daughter was little many of our children just wanted to explore and have fun I as a parent of course wanted to have the best education option and once I when I found out about lud School schools and then the charter schools I was happy to know that I had options since my daughter came to Kip Soul her vision changed she started mentioning universities like USC and now aspires to get to Stanford this shows that kipon not only offers us excellent education but also um cultivates uh leadership and and confidence so that they can meet their goals Kip Soul has spent a great choice for our family and that is why we ask not to be taken away the right

490to choose and to choose the school that we want for our children be at L USD or one of the charger school just like Kip Soul we all want our children to have access to the best schools and universities just like Stanford Harvard y Davis America's about options and we as parents deserve to decide the path of our children and today we choose Thank you for your time betth Salinas come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin counselor of kol Academy I am here today to strongly support the renewal of the charter petition for kipo Academy in the East Los Angeles I have been a counselor at kipo since 2020 over the Last 5 Years I have built strong relationship with my peers students and families I love this community my

491love for this community encourages me every day to show up to soul and give my very best self to the students it saddens me to think that our school could close mainly because it makes me think of how these specific changes will impact the lives of our students our families our staff and our larger EAS community over the last five year over the last three years students have built strong relationship with teachers and other their staff members our staff have created a safe School Community for our students that nurtured their development and growth making the decision to vote queso for non-renewal will have a direct impact in our students mental health as you know these years are crucial to the development of our students mental health our students have already experienced instability due to the

492pandemic staff turnover and challenges like losing family members housing friendships and as we look around at what is happening around Los Angeles there's our already been so much loss we are concerned that closing our school will will further impact their mental health as you make this decision please take a minute to think about your own experience as a middle schooler and how those years were crucial to you please empathize with our students and believe us when we say our school is like a second home to them every day we work hard to impact our students lives positively we are working hard towards becoming a trauma-informed school by using pvis practices and meeting students where they are we are also working hard towards teaching student Resto restorative practices and teach them that we can learn from

493our mistakes without being punitive while the data are that you are looking at while there is data you are looking at please look Beyond and listen to what our fam staff in school Community is sharing made the right choice to keep our school open as it is not in the best interest for our families and school Community to close thank you for your time thank you for your time okay Lee Rosenberg Lee Rosenberg come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin good evening my name is Lee Rosenberg and I proud to be legal council to this excellent school I ask that you please carefully consider that ab55 and the Education Code provides that middle performing Charter Schools like kipo are entitled to presumptive Renewal and that they may only be denied

494based on Hard Evidence well-founded facts not speculation that the students served by the school would be better off if their school closed this is a very high bar meant to protect students against closure of their schools unless truly necessary to meet the best interest of students if each of you is not personally 100% certain that the facts and reality align with the staff report that kiple students would be better off if their school closed you must vote against the recommendation you must not in good conscious simply defer to the CSD this is what academic integrity and commitment to truth and Justice and Equity require csds assessment overlooks historical and current positive academic performance data that is not okay in the face of a consequential decision to close a school you must make a decision that's

495informed based on all of the data available today if you have not talked to the students and parents and teachers of Kip soul and ask them if Kip Soul students would be better off if their schools closed I urge you to vote against the recommendation non-renewal will disrupt the educational journeys of 459 students and Veer them off course from the path to college that is enabled by Kip's model non-renewal deny is the agency of hundreds of parents of color of our community who believe in and choose Kip soul for their children as president schmon said this morning these are our neighbors our friends our community we must not in these trying times arbitrarily put children through the trauma of school closure when their school is serving them well incredibly the staff report recommends denial the

496school despite recommending approval of schools with a very similar academic data profile schools the board approved less than 60 days ago and this is completely arbitrary adopting the staff report would be an abuse of discretion I ask that you give full consideration to the law and that the evidence does not show that 459 students would be better off if Kip Soul were to close thank you thank you for your time is there a Mr David tolkovsky here think so Mr tolkovsky come on up you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin that's uh quite a legal document um okay so what what we hear now is that a strategic enrollment team will help this community out what is a strategic enrollment Community not one of the people I've talked to has been contacted by

497La unified to be ready to be assisted okay what will happen is that these Charter School parents will go to another charter school so if you really have a strategic enrollment plan You' be wrapping your arms around this community maybe you'd even offer in some way they could affiliate with the district for 5 years as a district school because their their their data is you know I represented badier middle school and we're putting $200 million into rebuilding badier have you looked at the data at badier Middle School oh my goodness and they've got two magnet schools in there to tweak the data for them I'm not saying close beler but it's a priority school hopefully and this kind of place ought to be an Affiliated District school that's a priority this school probably brings in

498kids from uh montabello have you looked at the scores in East LA of Bell Gardens High School Bell Gardens Middle School compared to La unified area schools number four the principal who spoke to just a moment ago is a Southgate high school graduate onto UCLA couldn't have asked I mean the personnel office should have been out here trying to hire her okay okay they should have been trying to hire a strategic plan to make these kids and families feel part of La unified is lacking whatever your recommendation is I know you'll vote based on the recommendation but east please ask some questions ask some questions comparing this school with beler and you may still come up with the same conclusions but I think it's a good idea to take a look and ask some questions

499and I thank you very much okay that concludes public comment on Tab 21 so board members I assume that we'd like to have Mr Co Gutierrez come down to answer our questions is that correct thank you Mr Co Gutierrez what isn't the school going to present their slides or I'm sorry so tab 21 the school presented the slides first then we took the public comment and now it's for okay um so continue coming down Mr K no problem no problem long night no I know who would like to ask first um yes I'm glad Mr Jose keres is here I would like you to address address just some some questions but um I have three questions the first one is um concerns the application of a fair process can you walk us through the renewal

500process for Kip soul Academy and confirm or let us know um how a fair process and consistent process was applied with communication and opportunities for the school to respond to any concerns just walk us through your the process in analyzing the data and the whole your report certainly thank you board vice president and I won't repeat every comment I made before when board president Schon asked about the process but I will highlight some key points so first I will say our analysis of Kip s is consistent with the process isign earlier in looking at all of the aspects of the renewal and placing greater weight on the academic achievement this has been a consistent process looking at the data that is available as well as the verified data that the charter school provided now let

501us take a moment to walk through some of those data okay and again I want to reiterate what I said before every uh deny recommendation is a tough recommendation and so I respect all the voices we've heard but in laying out the analysis we landed with this recommendation based on that consistent process so first as we look at the data we start on the with the dashboard analysis and comparison as I noted earlier so we look and we provide uh the board and consistently with English language arts indicator starting in 2122 and we do note as has been said that the school was higher than the state all students in numerically significant subgroups that was the year they also received that California distinguished School award and the US News and World Report award that they

502site that's based on that 2021 data not current data we acknowledge in the report very transparently the strength there in 2223 we start seeing declines okay so in the state in ela you have now all students and English Learners lower than the state and the other three subgroups are higher okay and 23 24 all students and then the majority of their student groups four out of five are lower LTS are higher okay so in our view with that data set and you have significant declines um they did not meet the criteria on its own on dashboard that's consistent with other renewals that we've reviewed here to for now we look to mathematics and we see in 2122 all students was lower and you had three of of the four higher okay than the state in

5032223 now you have all students lower English learner and students with disabilities lower than the state Latino and socioeconomic disadvantage higher okay so you start you're seeing some further declines and then in 23 24 the latest data all students and four of five numerically significant student groups are lower so the dashboard analysis alone does not does not say the the U increases are there in pursuant to law in our consistent assessment as you as you and the public have seen in our reports okay then the charter school as allowed as I noted the law allows the provision of verified data Kip Soul provided one year of I ready data in their submission so when they signed the completeness they submitted that as I noted earlier in terms of consistency for Middle performing schools and low

504performing schools where that's really implicated our team reached out early in the process making sure we're seeing the same thing on the verified data because we know it's of import okay so we had that conversation the school selected very clearly and told our team we're only giving you the one year okay we looked at it you see Ina they met for the majority they met one year's progress we have some grade levels where they did not meet it's noted in their report in mathematics they did not meet for the majority in one year's progress and we note the specifics in the report okay now one year and we State this very plainly given the limited data and those results that does not constitute clear and convincing evidence okay but again I want to underscore the

505charter school verified data has been known for several years it's been part of oversight this chart is going all of them have a choice to bring forward the verified data because dashboard may show you the status verified data is intended to show quote unquote change or growth so the verified data analysis does not pass muster now I want to know parenthetically to again to underscore the consistency and equity in the process has the board considered other schools that may have been lower than the state and then had stronger verified data three years for example the short answer is yes and we have to look at that under law therefore and note the school talked about their middle of year that was after the fact not part of their initial submission in the spirit of transparency

506we looked at it and we told the school this recently in an email one it's not the full year this fall to Spring I already specifically in their materials talk about the one year's progress fall to Spring I understand the schools saying hey well here's where we're at and some of the way they characterized it looking at the schoolwide numbers is not 100% accurate in ela they did meet if you were just to look at it uh three of four grade levels we making the progress in math only one of four again raises still concerns I understand middle of the year but I would tell the board that's not the verified data for being consistent but since it was raised here and they we'll give you those brief notes since we had a little bit

507of time to assess that now per policy as I noted earlier then we go to is closure in the best interest of pupils board members superintendent this this is not easy we understand that the greater weight on academic performance in the way the policy currently defines it is we look at that Resident schools comparison because greater weight is on academics we can point to many schools and assess a variety of excellent programs and supports Etc I hear the student voices and the beauty of those for but then we have to we have to assess are we going to be consistent are we going to choose I like this program not that one when the data are what they are in the final analysis at this juncture and therefore we see for the resident schools in

5082122 in in ela this is Page 591 of the materials the schools were higher than the resident schools comparison this school is a unique grade level 5 to8 we don't have five to eights in the district to my knowledge but the methodology of comparing the aggregate data with 5 day8 with the the data the comparison school's elementary middle in this case schools uh in uh further consultation this has been the process for many years with our Oda experts it Remains the soundest at this time uh and it should be noted that the school itself Compares itself to the many of these same schools and has said in the current Charter as well as the renewal that they were outperforming these schools that's not the case in the final analysis at this time 21 22 23

509La higher and then 22 2324 lower in all for all students in all subgroups except for long-term English Learners and yes that does mean that those district schools also were they performed better this last round and so that comparison at this time Falls as it does the math was higher in 2122 then lower in 20223 for all students and four and three of the four numerically significant student groups in 2324 lower all student and for four of five we acknowledge very transparently in the report the school has strengths and servant LTS a new student group listed on the dashboard and their LP scores it's very transparent in the report not the majority of students or student groups and so we note the lp is higher part of the policy asks us to review the cast

510met and exceeded so you'll see in 595 2223 higher for all students in all the subgroups and 23 24 lower and all mathematics is the same I will note um you know to to to just drill down a bit further because I know there's you know um a lot of a lot of layers on this when I said the resident schools analysis 10 schools in this Bas based on this recent year we looked at this for all of the schools um this school was lower in all students than 10 out of 10 resident schools in the 23 24 dashboard data and nine out of 10 in mathematics and these are schools that are listed in their petition and some have noted them some public speakers have noted them and so that's the consistent academic analysis

511as challenging and heartwrenching that it may be I share with you the process that we've gone through with all schools and yes we do note some concerns that our team has also discussed with the school over the years the the the leadership turnover um we understand the current leader has been in the position since 2021 prior to that we note in the report some of those concerns as well as Staffing uh and so that rounds out our recommendation respectfully to all the voices that are here so you did um my second question was on the verified data so you have answered that question so just want to just read about the process sorry process okay as we noted earlier um we do not have go back and forth in terms of the petition process with

512schools that are being recommended for denial per policy and so we did not have that interchange though certainly the school received petitions for three of their Charters and then did not for one um and so that's that's the reason for that um difference in process because of the recommendation internally but you did sh to them like is this the only data you're going to submit and he said yes that's the only dat early on in the process for all middle performing schools and low performing given the the verified data piece we just wanted to make extra sure hey are we seeing what you had intended to submit is there anything further um to be submitted that that was the case consistently with all the schools so for Renewal and just um my last question is

513when did your office or we know that the school was facing issues was kipo Academy given efficient opportunity throughout the their petition process throughout the 5 years uh to address declining academic performance and other concerns before the recommendation for denial or before you received all the information all the data so overall did the school have an opportunity to turn the situation around yeah I won't speak for the school but in our view and I discussed this even recently with our team and we certainly reviewed this in our recommendation the oversight conversation our team started seeing declines like I mentioned to you you had conversations with school leadership around what was happening showing them the data and school leadership noted there've been the turnover challenges some other pieces Etc um they were certainly trying to work

514toward that with their own action plans and the like and Kip did submit uh their plans for improvement it's one plan for their schools that they submitted um and it was the same plan for all the schools which is fine but you know maybe there needed to be more differenti or other needs so our team did have those conversations noting some of the the the data declines um and I would say based on my team's sharing with me that there was an acknowledgement that there was work to be done given said declines well thank you I appreciate um you answering those questions so you know like Mr Hol K ter has mentioned and and I know for other board members here it's not easy to deny a school and we do understand and I hear

515you that um this is a family however you have to understand that we this is based on Ed code this is based on the law um and there are given specific um Ed codes and it's mentioned throughout the process in the report what has to be taken into consideration So based on Ed code we are only allowed to look at the data and the the data was provided and submitted um and and the dis the Char School Division has been consistent they do not deviate they look at every single school they compare apples to apples the framework is consistent and so um just know that this is not a hard decision for either the district or the board thank you thank you Dr Ras any other questions on this side I Believe Miss gonz has

516a question go ahead M GES thank you um I appreciate you walking us through this U Mr um just a couple of follow-up questions on that piece um I think what you've outlined makes it clear that the process that we follow um that CSD has followed is consistent across schools you're you're looking at all of the criteria that the statute specifies and doing those analyses compared to State averages and then compared to resident School averages and and looking at the verified data I think one challenge for me is in comparing even to other schools that are uh that were recommended for approval today um in some cases the the substantive standard so not the process but the outcome standard that we're comparing the schools to is not consistent um what I mean by that is

517you know if I look at um the kip philosophers I I believe um and sorry I have a lot of different tabs open so it's hard to follow but it looks like Kip philosopher's um math score is lower than Kip soul but Kip Soul was recommended for denial and Kip philosophers is recommended for approval um and then in looking back at other Charters that have been uh recommended for approval during this term uh in some cases kipo is higher when it even when it comes to the 23 24 data where they did have a a market decline which is obviously very concerning if that's the start of a a more significant Trend but I wonder if you could help help me understand and um how schools again like I understand the the process that you

518walked through in that explanation was very thorough but when the outcomes data is is very similar H how does one school get to a recommendation of approval with v benchmarks versus um a denial recommendation um like in this case thank you board member gonz I appreciate the question and that's a question our team in our analysis also looked at um because those even looking at Kip with four renewals here uh we obviously looked at the consistency but across the board and so your question would beg other questions for example is the board would the board set a numerical standard for any area across the district and if you're lower than a DFS across the board that school would be recommended for denial our concern with that one it's not in policy at this point secondly

519would be maybe the unattended consequences of setting those how would we set those numbers and then what are those local contexts the resident schools median which has been in policy for multiple years before 1505 as well as after 1505 in public discussions and debates but that's what's enshrined at this time doesn't mean there can be future discussions and to Echo the superintendent's charge to us is ensuring Equity consistency in accordance with law and policy and so because of those pieces AIP philosophers in doing the same analysis I won't repeat it all they they also the Statewide dashboard data were challenged though they did show more significant improvements doesn't mean they landed a lot higher than say a kip their verified data was a bit stronger still only one year we went to the resident schools

520analysis and there they are higher than I think all or maybe save one of the resident district schools that's something the district needs to look at but the bottom line is that school is providing a an option that right now is showing stronger results now we can we can indicate that those results are unacceptable but that respectfully would be a broader policy discussion and decision as to are we going to set a certain standard across the entire district for distance from standard met an exceeded percentages and I think we can all understand that there could be some challenges with that and so just to round out the that that is why you might see and again prior items that maybe were challenged with the dashboard but the verified data pass muster and I'll save comments

521on verified data and the challenge of it it's in law we have items in writing from the vendors we cannot ignore those verified data that are presented by the charter school and so those are the different factors that we look at um in trying to you know when we wrestled with these to be candid with you I understand it's it's it's not easy and it is nuanced and of course I'm very familiar with the resident school's meeting and how we've used that in the past yes um I do think it's it's challenging uh from a consistency perspective when the absolute outcomes of one school might be higher in half of what we're supposed to prioritize which is the academic outcomes right um so I do I do think that's a challenge that we should contemplate

522as a board um because even though the process is this is consistently applied the outcomes maybe are not being consist consistently held to the same standard and and that's just the nature of comparing in in different neighborhoods um versus just at the state averages um and then I was wondering if if the school might be able to speak to their Improvement plan both what is included in that plan and whether whether they're taking particular steps right now to implement that what those steps might constitute any other details that we should know about that thank you so we have submitted an um Improvement that's 15 pages in fact my staff is prepared to send it directly to all board members so that you can see the Improvement plan um but it is very extensive the the

523way the Improvement plan is framed is that we go over we're very transparent about our data and the you know declines that we've talked about um and then very specifically for each of the areas of improvement we go through what a root cause of that would be again being very vulnerable and being able to say you know things like we try to implement you know you know curriculum and it it's very challenging or we had you know teachers that vacancies in the key content areas um and so we put ourselves out there as part of the Improvement plan um because we believe in transparency and so those are listed um on p on pages two through I don't know seven of our Improvement plan um but some of the strategies that we're using to deploy

524for each of the areas uh for example improving the ELA performance is reestablishing and responding effectively to and intentionally to data and that's why you see that our I ready data that we have shown progress for for this year that were very specific and intent intentional about if you know anything about I ready it very clearly tells you where students are at the beginning of the year what does their learning path look like assessing students in the middle of the year which we did and you can we've shared that data for this year and then what are those steps that teachers can do for intervention and it comes with the suite of interventions um so our leadership team who you got to hear from uh working together to hold teachers accountable hold students accountable hold

525each other accountable hold all of us accountable to responding to data and real time we also have invested in improving the instructional coaching we use um a group called research for better teaching that uses Landmark studies uh improving the quality of instruction to strengthen the instructional coaching so that team members teachers can get the highest quality uh instruction support feedback uh we also build are building the expertise amongst our teachers um and you were fully hired this year that's something that's we're very excited about [Music] and a part of the reason why you see the demonstration and Improvement of results now the the responsibility of the board especially for a middle performing school for all schools is to look at the full record um and so to have this really what it's it's irking me

526is this like one year of decline we are very aware of the decline it is like constantly being told to us in addition to our own analysis of that it's like what are we really doing about it and that's why we have the Improvement plan plan so we're building the content knowledge of all of our teachers we have a standardized internalization protocol uh we have a year-long scope and sequence that our teachers get trained on we have content team meetings learning team meetings um Etc to help Drive student outcomes we have in increasing student attendance as one of our strategies we have attendance support team meetings those meetings haveen twice at least twice a month where the leadership team and other team members look at specific students how can we get our students to school

527um also developing our teachers expertise in our ELD curriculum our our integrated ELD program what are our supports how are we having those groups be dynamic this is part of the reason why our LP scores continue to outperform the state and the district because we want to elevate that you know with and I think that we have a significant number of English leurs at our school I don't want that to be lost 21% is a large amount and to think about the school closing and where those English Learners would go that is not in the best interest of those students and that's nearly a quarter of the students at kol analysis so I we will that probably in your inbox already my staff has probably sent it Kip Soul's um Improvement plan with the action

528steps with the progress that we're meeting in addition to our oversight records over the course of the charter term uh we were blindsided actually by this and I I know that Jose and I have known each other for a very long time um but this process did not see seem Equitable from our perspective would we we have consistent oversight we're very well aware of our where we need to have gaps we have constant communication with the district when it came to the actual Charter petition process you know receiving three Charter petitions that we going to get approve recommended for approval and then a nothing when we when we got solds and I called Jose and I was like what's going on and I didn't get any information so that dialogue that back and forth about

529like hey you know what we think this is heading in a recommendation that's not favorable we could have shared our Improvement plan in June when our board approved it with the Charter School Division if we thought that that the possibility of a non-renewal was actually viable we're a middle performing school we know we have work to do I have a dedicated team I have amazing families and parents I've got dedicated students and we we'll take benchmarks like we understand like we need to meet a standard we want all of our schools to be high performing like we're all not knocking out of the park right now we all have work to do and we would just like to chance to continue that work and the progress and the momentum that we have should not be

530disrupted interrupted um because we've had one year that it was really challenging for us thank you I had one more question Mr Co yeah Mr Co Gutierrez any response to uh what was said I'll just make a couple brief notes uh first respectfully uh there's been as the data show two years of declines back to back our team had noted that in oversight we've had those discussions secondly respectfully I do recall that call that we had and I said very clearly we're not at that point in the process with this school based on our analysis and per policy this school may not receive any feedback in the final analysis and you may receive your 15-day notice uh with the materials Okay so soon thereafter we received lots of Outreach and information the school understood that

531position okay thank you thank you other questions from board members Mr melvoin oh I think Miss gon has still had her hand up if she wants to finish her sorry I had just just one more um I I was curious mrz just noting that you know typically when we look at a five-year term we're looking at the five most recent years of data of course in this case uh several of those years were impacted by the pandemic and therefore we don't have those recent years of data how do how are we kind of utilizing or incorporating the prepandemic years of since that is part of the current Charter term can you just speak to you know how sta way that are included it in their analysis thank you for that question so I think there's

532a there's a couple pieces certainly we look at the oversight record and there's with the current data that are available the state provides the classification based on the most recent two years of data so that's where that concept and construct comes from and then as new data are made available those data are also reviewed presented to the board and the public and the school also has a preview of those data okay so miss gones to be to be very specific then based on the classifications which is one part of the criteria being uh ascribed based on the data that I noted that is the primary uh the first start in terms of the academic analysis it is it obviously there was a three-year reprieve on renewals where data were were very limited so and then

533going beyond that it becomes very far removed so we're anchoring in what the state has guided in terms of the renewal data the criteria and I want to underscore we're comparing this school to the state on the dashboard verify data according to its criteria and then if we need to the resident schools medium per policy thank you just just really quickly so there are three areas that the schools can demonstrate three opportunities to show some positivity right and if the schools are not meeting any of those three areas then right then you have to consider denial and there are other reasons you could deny but for the academic where the law says provide greater weight that is is um why this is form of the recommendation and we did review the action plan as I

534noted while for low performing schools that's a that's a Criterion um for Middle performing schools what I laid out is is that process certainly looked at it and while there may be some differentiation obviously the results are still the the the the bottom line analysis and if they don't show any positivity or if they show positive say for instance in their dashboard but not in the other two areas and they're of they're you know you recommend for Renewal but if right so they have to at least show some progress in one of those three areas in some cases in this if the dashboard analysis on its own stands with those increases and higher than the state in majority of student groups or and schoolwide for example then you don't necessarily need to get to verified

535data even if the school provides it because the aformentioned is strong enough if not you go you continue down and then again per policy best interest of peoples the law doesn't Define that specifically to my knowledge I'll certainly defer to council but our policy in indates here's how we're going to the other data we're going to look to compare in the Resident schools Mr melin thank you I'd like to yield my time to the mariachi band again actually um I uh no it's um thank you Mr scharon Angel it's nice to see you we're glad to see you you doing well and that you're here we've been thinking about you um and uh um I just want to re reiterate again the professionalism of the the charter schools Division and Mr Cole Gutierrez I think

536there's been thorough analyses done I appreciate it back and forth with our staff I don't need to belabor the point I think most of the questions I have have been answered I also appreciate the charter sending a lot of information including as recently as two minutes ago um I I do think it's a close call I think that you know as we heard from the executive director there's one year that we're focus on focusing on they're they're quite aware of it I think the in my mind the totality of the circumstances both the the history preco their Staffing challenges that have been solved for the veteran nature of their staff their performance Improvement plan the size of the school you know I think it's a close call I go the other way um and so

537I am when when we hear from all of our colleagues and I um could to bring a motion for Renewal with benchmarks that I want to read and I don't know if that will get support from my colleagues but I just I I hear the school also acknowledging that there's academic work to to be be done and so I've sent this to Mr McLean but the the benchmarks that I would propose as part of a renewal recommendation or motion would be the same for ELA and math and it would be that the school shall demonstrate academic growth in ela for all students and for the majority of significant student groups as reported in the dashboard Ela performance indicator by achieving a distance from standard that has increased or increased significantly over the course of the

538charter term or achieved a dist from distance from Stand standard that is equal to or higher than their respective student group State average distance from standard for ELA and math and so I've shared that language with Mr McAn and I I know I'm not the last to speak but that would that I will bring that motion with those benchmarks I acknowledge the work the school's doing and what I also appreciate is the accountability for that year and the work work ahead so thank [Applause] you okay Miss grigo I keep hearing one year and then two years we look when you made this analysis you were looking when they performed lower it was two years correct yeah two years in declines yes so I went through they were high not just one year right the decline

539the as I noted and I went through I won't repeat it again because I noted for each air each year all students in subgroups where they were higher and lower MH they've declined in most areas two years okay in in one in the in ela as I noted maybe it's maybe it's worth repeating yes there was a mix some were higher some were lower as I noted then in 23 24 further declines and then the majority were lower mathematics the second year was even lower and then the third year lower so two years of declines in most areas regardless of where they landed I already went through that detail by detail so there there are two years of those declines and then the AER mentioned uh on the full analysis thank you any other questions

540so Mr McAn are we going to do discuss Mr Melvin's yeah so I guess I will officially move um uh I will move to renew the petition uh for Kip Soul um with the benchmarks that I that I uh read earlier do we have a second all [Applause] second please don't call out go ahead and take roll on Mr Mel's motion miss newbill this motion just so I'm clear uh we haven't read it so I'm just my the motion on the table that I brought reverses the recommendation so that would be a recommendation for approval for a 5-year term with benchmarks in ela and math no Dr Ras no Mr melb yes M GGO no Miss gones yes uh Miss Ortiz Franklin Miss Ortiz Franklin okay hearing nothing from Miss Ortiz Franklin uh bo board

541president schmon no so that's one two three four NOS sorry Mr mcen I I missed my round no it's okay how do you vote on the proposed motion on the proposed motion [Applause] yes so there are seven board members we have one two three four Nos and one two three yeses so that motion does not pass original are there uh fur Is there further discussion on the original underlying motion for uh this tab would someone like to make a motion to vote I motion I move I'm sorry so that a I'll move move for this is to move tab 21 correct yes yes Dr Ras is first all second and a second from Miss greo uh Miss nuell yes uh Dr Ras yes Mr melin no uh Miss grigo yes Miss gones no Miss Ortiz

542Franklin no board president shurson yes there one two three four it's a 43 vote passes on to tab 22 uh yeah leave them there and I'll I'll I I'll pass them out in just a moment we're gonna Mr McLean did you want to take my votes on the tabs that I've missed we will Miss gones if you're there I'd like to return to take your vote on tabs 17 18 and 19 I'm a yes on all three okay so that's a yes on 177 18 and 19 thank you I Mr I think I missed one too give me one moment to track back or might have been two Miss orti Franklin I don't have you missing um I don't have you missing a vote oh great okay thanks foret I thought maybe yeah let let

543me double check that's correct you do need do need a loger vote for creete uh it's a yes I'm sorry a yes that's a yes thanks okay tab 22 I'll pass those out right now for okay please Pro do we expect other board members to return for the presentation uh yeah Miss gones is remote U Miss Ortiz Franklin is also remote um and and we can proceed as long as we have Quorum okay which we do and I'm sure that they're going to return uh momentarily would you like to begin or do you want to wait till they're back I'll can I wait few it's very important that Miss Grio and Kelly gones and everybody's in the room okay Miss GES is on the line okay she's on the line Miss cgo I'm sure will

544be back in just a moment as we'll miss Nill okay I guess we can go ahead and get started to respect everyone's time dear respected board members I stand in front of you as a proud CEO superintendent of Los Angeles Leadership Academy unionized was accredited Community span school for grades 6 through 12 that have been serving Lincoln Heights Community for 27 years years our dual immersion program K5 was successfully renewed in 2020 under AB 155 most of the students that attend our Middle School and High School transition from our elementary school about 70% our school offers amazing access to stem Culinary Arts Visual and Performing Arts College and Career Readiness CIF Sports after school tutoring social emotional Services we have multiple Partnerships to support our school and our community another Unique Piece is CTA is

545right here supporting our school we work with our Union we work with our teachers their voices are heard we work with our families we are unique in that sense and we are your partner Dr Rio you always talk about the well-being of the kids the rights of the workers we are that we are your partners we take full responsibility for the education of our students we serve the most vulnerable population and as it's been mentioned many many times I'm looking forward to partnership let's now work against each other let's work together to uplift the community that we all serve let's work with our labor Partners let's work with our board members let's do this together denying middle performing unionized was accredited school that it serves the most vulnerable population it's not in the best interest

546of students nevertheless I have outmost respect for the charter Division I have been working with the charter division for about okay please finish your thoughts thank you for 19 years and I respect their process on data but there are flaws in the process and I just want to bring up to your attention please consider the letter that I sent you and what's in your folders not all the data was considered for us and it's nobody's fault it wasn't our Charter petition but post secondary outcomes were not considered in this renewal decision that's number one number two comparison to resident schools I had to follow up I had to call multiple times to ask what resident schools are you comparing us to for transparency so our teachers know our families know we were compared to two

547middle school and two high schools and you will see the demographics some of these schools have magnet programs some of the schools do not resemble the demographics of students that we serve thank you thank you for your time I apologize I know two minutes is a short period of time thank you but we appreciate your time we have 15 folks signed up to speak and I will call on the people who are here in person first and then we will transition to people who are speaking remotely uh the first person signed up to speak is Mr David tolkovsky okay uh murea sovia come on up and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin good evening board members I'm here with my daughter keani sovia but I will be yielding my time to syvia

548saravia good evening my name is siia Christina Saria excuse my emotions I want to express my half gratitude for the special education program at Los Angeles Le Academy as a mother I have witnessed firsthand how this school committed to excellent exclusive education has transformed my children's life and provide them with opportunity that I couldn't find somewhere else after transferring from other school that were unable to meet my children's need I made a decision to commute from the city of Upland to bring my daughters to Los Angeles Leadership Academy it wasn't an easy choice but it was the best one for my family the protocol service and genu care that this school offer set apart is way that no other institution has offered to my kids when my daughter first arrived at Los Angeles Leadership Academy

549in third grade she faded significant academic challenge she struggled to read had very little confidence in herself however the school individual approach and wearing dedication helped her overcome these obstacles the special education program gave her the tools instructor and support to drive one of the most rewarding moment as a mother was hearing my daughter say mom did you know I did not know how to read in third grade now I learn to read fluency this Milestone was not only life challenge for her but also as proud profound moment for her family seeing her grow into a confident and capable student who has even been recognized not once multiple times as a student of the bth has been incredible Joy the extraordinary commment on Los Angeles acad Academy to its students and families why I'm proud

550to commute long distance every day to this school is a matter of what education should be a partnership between Educators students and parents build a foundation of respect and believe that every child ESP special needs deserves the opportunity to succeed thank you thank you for your time and before we go further I'm going to read the uh public hearing statement for tab 22 board report number 15824 25 before action is taken on this board report denial of the renewal petition for Los Angeles Leadership Academy a public hearing must be held this constitutes that public hearing denial of the renewal petition for the Los Angeles Leadership Academy and a maximum of 15 individuals who wish to address the board and the item will be heard those who wish to speak should sign up online speakers will

551be called by name speakers have signed up and the next speaker is Mr David tokov [Applause] I am proud to advocate for this school to you I was there 29 years ago when Roger Lowenstein with the chair of the Democratic National Committee in present and my colleague from Berkeley the most wise scholar I had met in the history Department asked me whether or not this was a good idea it was one of the first Charters that I was sitting on the board in your role I said to him it's a great idea try it let's go for it they opened up right across the street from utl on Wilshire Boulevard I said to him there's one challenge you're going to have he said what's that I said the kids have to learn to read it's

552not just an adventure they have to learn to read and over the years they've had ups and downs Richard Lee koven if you looked it up the school at all the LA Times wrote a cover story about the idealism of of this location but then the challenges of the new immigrants that were coming into the United States in the Pico Union area when this school formed from the outset as a Union School a charter that was unionized like El Camino but a startup not a conversion they opened up today you have recently approved their Elementary School for Renewal that elementary school graduates into this second school which is a a span school this span school is not the same thing as Lincoln high I represented this area in fact I was the one that helped

553Anita Lander find the building this 1920s beautiful building that they are in that was abandoned in the community and they've strengthened the community dramatically in a community that has has lots of challenges as Miss Ras knows in the Lincoln Heights and where the development of the new apartments are coming and those apartments ought to bring exciting new park space and school and so I tell you that this this Union School has a high school that is more like a continuation school it is not a span school like Eagle Rock junior senior it is a junior high and it is sort of like an high school that is not like that because many kids go to Lincoln High to be part of the sports programs and the music programs in a larger high school I advocate

554freely and clearly that this is a school that has great PR and you haven't once again offered again that they become an Affiliated school thank you for your time Danielle lore Danielle lore come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin Danielle lore thank you board um I commend you guys for hanging in there it's been a very long day all right um so I attended LAUSD elementary schools in Carson I've been at laa um for many years as an English teacher ELD teacher volleyball coach and rep I also the elected president of the California teacher Association or CTA Affiliated teachers union uh Los Angeles Leadership Academy United in that capacity I work very closely with our CTA uniserve director Omar Joseph I even consulted with CTA president David Goldberg on how

555to best address the board today we are one of the few Charters with an active Union our Charter leaders and Union have a great partnership that works together to ensure that we teachers are supported from day-to-day teach ing issues to substantial issues like covid and the recent fires teachers feel safe and supported at laa having a union means that teachers are supported so they can then in turn support our students we serve an extremely high population of students from critical backgrounds socioeconomically disadvantaged unhoused English Learners and Hispanic my school serves a larger population of these students than the nearby district schools this means a great deal to me because I was raised by a single mom of four that needed food stamps to get by sorry Lala offers our students more than just a high

556quality education for example we distribute food from our farm on a regular basis we often take students that other schools have expelled or deemed hopeless we're a humble public charter school that does not cherry-pick or turn students away we give all students a chance and equip them with the necessary skills they'll need for the future we are also a social justice School our our Charter was built on the belief that all students deserve a high level education taught by qualified teachers especially those aforementioned vulnerable students who do not typically get enough support we do not have dlet grades so the students must have a 70% or better to pass each class or assessment this helps our students strive for excellence denying our Charter would mean that the most vulnerable students would fall through the cracks

557thank you thank you for your time uh Israel Garcia and then after Israel is Narita and then Alexia sovia all right uh good evening members of the board my name is z Garcia president of school side Council and student body Council After High School I want to Major and I will major in my count engineering where I'll transition into the mot automotive and Motorsports industry currently I'm a 12th grader at laa and I am proud to say that I've been with LA since kindergarten over my time with Los Angeles Leadership Academy my main takeaway are the opportunities that teachers Administration and my school site have provided me which is helping me and aiding me practice skills I need in order to be a successful student and member of society one example of building skills is

558a teacher student relationship with my teachers specifically the one with Mr stto he's not only my baseball coach but also my leadership class teacher on the field I've learned to be mentally tough increased my focus and this together has been beneficial to me in the classroom another example of building relationships is building working with administrators community members parents teachers and staff during school site Council meetings this year I have the pleasure of serving as a president of School site Council I look forward to continue bringing a student perspective while building my communication and Leadership skills and because of my school site I have been able to network withu students from other schools via the boys and girls club and fing uh learning LP over six sessions I was introduced to the legal field and participated

559in workshops and talked about how legal processes work in the real world I believe that due to this program I grew my critical thinking and my team building skills these opportunities are just a few of the resources and activities available available to me at laa and that's why strongly advocate for the chart of renewal of our school thank you thank you for your time Marita [Applause] Lopez and then after Narita is Alexia and then vivana good evening my name is n Lopez I'm the principal of Los Angeles Leadership Academy middle school I will be giving my spot to Mr Omar Joseph [Applause] good evening board my name is Omar Joseph I have been a staff member with the California Teachers Association since 2017 I the CTA representative for the unionized teachers and other certificated employees

560at the Los Angeles Leadership Academy as well as several other district and Charter Schools La Leadership Academy United is a CTA affiliated Union and I represent them in collective bargaining and other Labor Relations matters with the employer I'm here to express my support for La leadership Academy's Charter renewal petition and to Pro provide you with Insight regarding the leadership team at La Leadership Academy and its relationship with its Union I have worked as a unions side attorney and labor advocate for over 20 years representing union members across a wide variety of Industries in California as well as the East Coast in my experience the best working environment has been have been in situations where management and the union are collaborative I'm happy to report that the school's leadership team led by Miss Arena Goldring has

561a very positive relationship with the Union Miss Golding and her team are always eager to work with the Union on improving working conditions for teachers retaining teachers and investing in their professional growth and development I've personally been involved in several difficult situations involving employees and I've been impressed by Miss Golding and her team's willingness to work with the Union to find mutually acceptable Solutions the administration's problemsolving attitude and collaborative nature and dealing with the Union also leads to best practices for the educational process and strengthens decisions made to improve the classroom environment I'm happy to express my support for La leadership Academy's Charter renewal petition thank you thank you for your time Alexia sovia and then vivana euphio good evening board members I am Alexa sovia I will yield my time to Zoe takes I

562would like Miss Maya to stand with me if that's okay I didn't quite catch that can you lower the microphone is it all right if Miss Amaya stands with me while I speak yes of course my good afternoon board members my name is Zoe takal and I am the President of the middle school student council at Los Angeles Leadership Academy and I am also in the honors cohort with the 4.0 GPA since sixth grade I have gone to laa my whole life from kindergarten to 8th grade Lala has always been a safe place for me they are always available for anyone at any time the feeling of knowing that we can depend on each other no matter what is something to cherish for me my mother recently passed away in October as soon as the

563school knew about it the community was always there for me hoping and reassuring me that everything would be okay they helped me through through a dark time of my life and knowing that I had such a big community on my side always made me feel safe the the school also set up a a fund for me to help out my family and our financial problems we encountered during the situation I felt comforted and knew that whatever happened to me or anyone else they would have the same amount of support that I had I know most schools wouldn't put the effort that they put in for me Lala always makes sure that every student including staff members is attended to the rare times when anything happens on campus or outside of school that involves severe negativity

564or that puts someone at risk they immediately try and resolve the issue before it escalates by doing this my peers are always kept safe laala also takes into consideration students who have a language barrier or have disabilities that affect their learning they never fail to make someone feel important and valued then the activities and groups that they provide for us are always an enjoyable experience students often display gratitude for supplies that are provided for us most if not all the time teachers and staff use their money to buy us pencils books notebooks binders and more laa also provides us food that we can pick up from time to time for those in need la la always makes everyone feel welcome no matter what thank you for your [Applause] time thank you uh let's see Alexia

565that was Alexia I'm sorry about that uh vivana come on vivana thank you good evening uh members of the board my name is Iana Elio and I'm a teacher at Los Angeles Leadership Academy our commitment to Excellence is reflected in our numbers this past year we've seen growth in our student scores this didn't happen by chance our teachers underwent intensive training in New mathematical strategies with West Ed and this training is reflected in our 2024 CP scores we have implemented rigorous progress monitoring to support all of our students academic achievement is just one piece of the story through our schoolwide PBIS program our students aren't just learning they're developing into leaders who understand responsibility respect and community service from our active student council to our competitive sports program we're creating opportunities for leadership at every

566turn with this I can say our current attendance rate is 96% every day our school our students walk through the front doors of a school that has a positive School climate culture what truly sets us apart is that we are committed to serving every student our Halls are are filled with diverse voices each bringing unique perspectives and needs through our Hors classes we challenge High achieving students to reach further through our support programs we ensure that every student regardless of their point their starting point has the opportunity to succeed the impact of our work extends Beyond test scores and academic achievements we're building Future Leaders who understand their responsibility to their Community as we look to the future we see unlimited potential in our students by renewing our Charter you're not just supporting a school

567you're investing in the Future Leaders of Los Angeles you're saying yes to Innovation and Ed education to diversity and learning and to the belief that every child deserves the opportunity to excel I stand before you today I as as I am someone who has witnessed countless Su success stories within our walls the renewal of our Charter isn't just about maintaining a school it's about continuing a vision a vision where every student regardless of their background has the opportunity to become a leader a vision where academic Excellence meets character development I urge you to renew Los Angeles Leadership Academy help us continue our mission mission developing the leaders that our community needs needs thank you for your time and consideration thank you for your time hey I have Carmen loera here in person I am yielding

568my time to Omar Joseph okay come on up Omar oh you already spoke only because it's just a matter of procedural gamesmanship to not let you do it so please please go ahead thank you I do get to speak good evening respected board members I had a a speech prepared for you but by now I think you've already heard all of the key words key phrases that a charter school can give you I just want to highlight that each one of you that has been in the classroom I have in been in the classroom you know that numbers of data is not all you know that there were times when your data didn't tell give you what you wanted to see but yet you walked away and closed that classroom door knowing that you had

569made a difference this is what we are working on I um had the privilege to renew the primary Charter as a principal with Mrs golden without any benchmarks and three years ago I joined the middle school because I Believe in Us I believe in La Leadership Academy I'm asking you to give us time to get those numbers to where we want to be we want them to be at she asked me and we met and we had a plan let's improve attendance the attendance is now at 96% we talked and we met we created a plan and we said let's get suspensions down suspension at the middle school has been at 0% for three consecutive years since I've been there so the plans work the teachers work we are teaching our students but it's more

570than just teaching we are cultivating their love for learning Lincoln he had been played with high crime rates as dras as I'm sure you know I last week I checked your nearest um distribution center for food and if we were not in the community our students would have to walk an hour and 20 minutes to the nearest site which was 3.6 miles away we are needed in the community I urge you to please vote to renew our Charter thank you Joseph Lopez come on up Joseph Lopez come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin um good evening Al div board members um I just wanted to tell you that I'm here representing um our school and organization Los Angeles Leadership Academy and I would like to yield my time to my

571peer Ashley [Applause] Reyes hi everyone good afternoon my name is Ashley Reyes I am in 11th grade and a proud student of Los Angeles Leadership Academy where I serve as Student Council secretary Los Angeles Leadership Academy has been essential to my growth as a student and a member of my community our school's commitment to providing scholarship and program opportunities has empowered students like me to excel both academically and personally through these opportunities I've discovered my passion for medicine and recently I participated in an online medical program hosted by a Harvard University student an unforgettable experience I could never forget counselors teachers and staff constantly support us forming deep connections and giving us the confidence to pursue our goals Beyond academics our school Fosters community engagement with the products we grow on our farm we distribute

572free fruits and vegetables to our community organize cleanups and promote Red Cross blood donations I've also had the privilege to volunteer at the Verizon St Achievers program at Cal La thanks to our student council's efforts these experience allowed me to make a positive impact in my community while developing important life skills our Charter renewal is vital because it ensures students like me can continue benefiting benefiting from these learning experiences and Community contributions Los Angeles Leadership Academy has shaped my high school journey and remains a critical foundation for our future students to begin and complete their own thank you for your [Applause] time okay let's see we have Joseph Lopez did I just call Jose J I did that again I'm very sorry about that Francis Moreno Francis Moreno are you here no Francis Eric tomasini

573come on up Eric sure please just announce your name and and take the two minutes definitely will good evening board members and the superintendent uh my name is uh Tim Petty better known as coach um hope that your family and family and friends and loved ones are safe during this tragic time I'm going to try to keep my speech within this two minutes because I don't want to hear the elev elevator sound excuse me I am the K through nth grade athletic director at Los Angeles Leadership Academy and has been there since eight for eight years since my arrival at la la I knew this is where I belong la la has always been a positive outlet for our young Community since introducing Sports to La La Community it has been an immediate impact on

574our attendance grades and Social Development laa is a potential Pathway to education and future opportunities being from a broken home myself I understand the challenges that our young adults have experienced but la la has always been a sturdy bridge to help our community feel like home laa Sports has has helped with keeping the young Community engaged and part of something the most important thing about la la Sports is that it continues to give we have former la la alumni and college back with college backgrounds on my coaching staff and give and they always give back to the la la Community we might be a small Charter but we are a family facing challenges has always been our Mo Bala has always risen above and beyond to make every effort to make everyone feel important thank

575you for your time and I hope you take the time to renew our Charter thank you for your time uh Fatima Gonzalez are you here [Applause] Fatima good evening distinguished board members my name is Fatima Gonzalez and I'm here to talk about why the tarted renewal for Los Angeles Leadership Academy is important number one enrichment pro programs Beyond core academics Beyond core academics our school offers a rich and diverse range of enrichment programs that are crucial to the development of well-rounded future and ready students the availability of electives such as art coding Spanish cooking and music allows students to explore their passion and talents fostering creativity and critical fostering creativity critical thinking and cultur awareness these opportunities provide a foundation for students to Envision their future pursue careers in diverse fields and become leaders for

576tomorrow to empowerment and Leadership uh development at Los Angeles Leadership Academy we priori prioritize nurturing the next generation of leaders through through a culture of support and encouragement we help students gain the confidence Knowledge and Skills needed to excel not only academically but as Future Leaders in their communities and Beyond our approach emphasizes personal growth responsibilities and resilience preparing students to meet the challenges for an everchanging World a pillar of the community our school is more than just the place of learning it is the heart of the community students and family families and staff are all part of the network that provides not only educational opportunities but also a sense of belonging and pride the closure of the school would be a significant loss for the entire Community leaving many families without a local without

577a local supportive and effective educational environment I started off as an instructional Aid at at Los Angeles Leadership Academy I worked my way up to become a substitute teacher and I am currently a seventh grade uh math teacher um my son is in second grade um if the school was to close down I would no longer enjoy the card rice as I would have to leave him on another campus where I don't know if he will be safe from all this shootings and other things going on for this reasons I strongly urge the district to keep Los Angeles Leadership Academy open the investment of our students staff and Community is an investment in the future of of Los Angeles we believe that with the support with the continued support our school will continue to be

578a place where students Thrive grow and become Leaders of Tomorrow thank you thank you for your time Francis Moreno I believe I already called that name but it's not saying saved on my system so I got to make sure I save that again I apologize we have a couple folks calling in remotely uh let's see Carl Peterson I see you're on the line Carl Peterson please press star six to unmute yourself and you have two minutes to speak once you begin hello please go ahead you have two minutes to speak why don't you begin Mr Peterson in reviewing the paperwork for this recommended denial I am concerned by the fact that the last day to act on this renewal request is today if last week taught us anything it should be that life is unpredictable

579why leave the possibility open that the district would miss the statutory deadline I also noticed that the school was sub the subject of three benchmarks when it was last renewed due to concerns about academic performance these resulted in the following Benchmark one the charter school met this benchmark three of the seven years Benchmark two the charter school did not meet The Benchmark in any of the years in which the data was available Benchmark 3 the charter school met this Benchmark in one of the years for which data was available now the charter school division is recommending denial the charter renewal after determining that the school's verified data does not provide clear and convincing evidence of measurable increases and academic achievement shocking maybe I do not understand the definition of Ben marks but was their purpose

580to only collect data or wasn't it assumed that the act that action would be taken if the school did not achieve results when they were added as a condition for the school's renewal the charer School Division and the board let let seven years go by where this school was failing at educating its students did we just not care there is no doubt that you should accept the charter school division's recommendations to deny the rendal of this Charter an independent investigation must then be conducted to find out why it took the L to rescue these children from failure thank you thank you for your time okay we have Mona field or Mona field signed up to speak remotely are you here Mona he monar is not there and we have one more person Rachel T are

581you in the room I have you signed up to speak remotely Rachel T this is Mona field can you hear me I sure can thank you Mona please go ahead you have 2 minutes to speak I'm sorry it took a moment um I would like to start by thanking the board members of La unified for their dedication to educating our community and all their staff and the hardworking people involved in these complicated issues my name is Mona field I'm a lifelong educator in the classroom as a union leader and for 16 years served in a member of the Board of Trustees of the Los Angeles Community College District for the last 10 years based on the values and beliefs I have in educating everyone I have served as a member of the board of directors

582of the LA Leadership Academy you've already heard everything about our Union relations about all the extra offerings we have for students in including Sports and a farm and by the way mental and physical health services to students and their families we are truly the Nexus of this area of Lincoln Heights and I know there's data there's process there's so many variables I urge this board to ask lots of questions and to seriously consider voting against the motion to deny and creating a substitute motion for approval of the continuation of this Charter there is no point to disrupting the many students and families that attend our school especially since Almost 100% of our student population are from immigrant families already undergoing the enormous anxiety and stress that you all referred to earlier today today as we

583await what goes on after January 20th I urge you to allow our school more time and yes we are not happy with the test scores our board is constantly asking what can be done how can we improve show us better results we are not oblivious to the demands of educating students whose lives are full of challenges thank you for your time we appreciate your time thank you okay last call for Rachel T you're listed as a calling in but I do not have you on the line in front of me Rachel T are you in the room Rachel is not in the room so now this item is open for discussion amongst the board for tab 22 denial of the renewal petition for Los Angeles Leadership Academy it was noted there might be some discussion

584or questions on this item yes that believe was Mr melin correct for 22 discussion sure um I uh again I'll reiterate the things I said I think this is another one that's that's a close call I I lean in the other direction than the charter schools division um and just will note a few of my reasons you know I think that we've heard from the school uh and also from from CSD and kind of and weighing this one High graduation rate compared to the state in neighboring district schools uh postsecondary success as we were hearing from the executive director verified data from last school year shows make progress for a majority of grade levels in student groups positive gains for English Learners um I do think I have questions about the resident schools comparison and

585one note Mr Cole Gutierrez um that I I do think we should be more transparent and collaborative going forward is I think the schools uh that are up for Renewal should see the individual resident schools that they're being compared against ahead of time I know we do a composite median but especially for span schools like this one I think that could be helpful I'll note you know this school which has operated in lincol Heights for over two decades has it was only compared to two middle schools both of which house multiple magnet programs including uh a selective admission highly gift you know High ability gifted program so it's not really an Apples to Apples comparison um I also know the growing percentage of students at La leadership uh that have met or exceeded standards on

586esac and cast tests um and you know ultimately one of the factors the board can weigh with these middle performing schools is uh and to me the most Salient factor is the best interest of the students and giving the schools longstanding service in the community I visited the school uh actually before I was even on the board um and uh and uh like we heard from some of the speakers believe in the school's um The Village that supports the school I'm going to support it so I will I will bring a motion in a minute for Renewal without you know much hope of Passage but uh just acknowledging the hard work of the charter schools division these are the Clos calls and I I think uh in this case the tie to me goes to

587the charter school so board members with your permission may I ask Mr Cole Gutierrez to go over the reasons of the denial and then we can discuss it okay go ahead sir thank you board president a little Mr melan thank you for those comments also and prior um and all of you I'll also reiterate Again difficult all these recommendations for denal especially but I will again um for the sake of uh clarity and going through it I'd like to enumerate our um our findings and our analysis pursuant to the process that I noted and then I'll touch on some of the other points that you that you uh noted so in looking at the the findings document so we start with the dashboard comparison um in 2122 in English language arts uh the school was

588lower all students and all of the four numerically significant student groups in 2223 the same all students and three numerically significant student groups were lower than the state and then 2324 the same lower than the state as the materials show they did have Charter change was positive you see about 5.6 5.7 3.8 4.0 we certainly looked at that but the school still remain lower than the the state as noted in all those areas now we go to mathematics 2122 lower all students and it's two numerically significant student groups in 2223 lower all students and all numeric and four three numerically significant student groups and in 2324 mathematics lower all students and all numerically significant student groups on the dashboard I would note again in mathematics in 2223 and 23 24 as the data show transparently

589Charter change was positive still landed them lower than the state so we continued the analysis because dashboard alone there did not pass muster as I've explained okay now we go to the ELP and as a material show 2122 was high higher than the state 2223 higher than the state 2324 lower and then we see the introduction of English learner and LEL student group okay in College and Career which is another academic indicator in 2223 was not available prior 2223 lower all students and the two numerically significant student groups and lower all students and two numerically significant student groups so on the dashboard analysis does not meet the criteria as I've enumerated now we go to the next phase the verified data and also with that call with the petitioner um with the team as I

590noted we did with all middle and low performing where that was um that is consequential the focus was on nwaa and I'll talk about the postsecondary and the petition shortly okay so the focus was the nwaa from that discussion and so we analyze that that's all in the materials there's a lot of data there and I won't but in short the prior two years uh 2122 22 uh 23 um we're not clear and convincing based on the data showed in terms of met and not met 2324 is our material state in that last year as stated um on 653 the majority of grade levels and applicable student groups demonstrated one year's progress in that one year okay but consider and we did note and I understand there may be debate NWA does not published the

591official participation rate we provide information to give you a best sense and then we knowe that it does not appear that they included at least 95% of eligible students now so we did not stop at the we continue with the verified we continue with the analysis to go to resident schools comparison and I'm going to go back to a couple other verified data points in a moment because of the process and Communications from the petitioner in the Resident schools comparison um and Mr melan I took down your comment regarding that list okay but I will also note as I've said in looking at the charters this school and others I'm not saying it's every single one schools know the resident schools this has been in place for many years and they understand where their students

592are coming from okay I will say that respectfully in 2122 for ELA compared to the resident schools median and since there's a uh I'll say it here Abraham Lincoln woodro Wilson hi uh Florence Nale middle ELO middle Holland be middle so lower in compared to those residents 2122 all students in Latino 20 uh in ela um higher in English learner and lower in social economic disadvantage lower in students with disabilities 2223 lower all students in all three numerically significant student groups compared to the resident schools median in a moment I'm gonna ask my colleague Dr Bill Johnson to address the magnet question because Oda office of data and accountability pull that I'd like to introduce his voice in the conversation uh 20223 compared to resident schools Ela lower higher in ela lower in in all

593students and the other two numerically significant student groups in 2324 I misspoke on Holland sorry my teams I told them to correct me if I have anything um that's my understanding 2324 lower all students and two numerically significant student groups hire in in uh English learner math 2122 lower all students and all four numerically significant student groups compared to the resident schools median 2223 lower all students and all numerically significant student groups 23 24 low lower all students and all numerically significant student groups LP 23 2122 higher 2223 higher 23 24 lower for English ster and LEL in that year College and Career indicator compared to the resident schools 2223 again we're available there lower all students and two numerically significant student groups compared to the res in the school's median lower in 222 and

594sorry 23 24 all students and um two numerically significant student groups then we go to the cast met and exceeded per policy and we see in 2223 where they were lower all students lower in two of three numerically significant student groups this is Page 659 in the materials in 2324 lower all students two numerically significant student groups English learner higher m mathematics lower in 22 23 all students and both numerically significant and and three numerically significant student groups 23 24 lower all students lower in two of three numerically significant student groups graduation rate compared to the resident schools per policy um lower all students and two numerically significant student groups in 2223 lower all students not in both numerically significant student groups in 23 now uh recently the and then also I noted the materials

595I won't repeat everything but the benchmarks were noted that's part of the analysis that is in the policy and so we note that the school did not meet three or four benchmarks in the majority of years and the data are in the materials this includes graduation rate uh performance standards in ela and math it's it's laid out for you and the school has been aware of that now a recently the school reached out to our team and our team did want to listen and hear they reached out to us and they said we want you in addition to nwaa to look at Casp made an exceeded as verified data it is on the list of verified data even though we did look at it um but you have to have mutual agreement and how that's

596going to be analyzed the example that the State Board gives is core data for example Visa V Casp as one example we do not have that this was this is prior to their submission the follow-up call later recently they noted that but I but I but we do not have that as verified data and we've already shared some of the data on the Casp in comparison to resident schools most recently uh I think yesterday we see in their presentation as well as in our process but to be clear on postsecondary the charter school has um a section in their petition regarding postsecondary outcomes okay while that was not the focus in that followup making sure that we were looking at the right verified data yes we see it in the petition and looked at that

597pursuant to the state and we did give some Grace here but I'll state it here in terms of what's in there and what the state would require for the full analysis of the postsecondary and that includes multiple data sources to be consider to present College enrollment persistence and completion as well as identifying similar peers okay we have enrollment in the chart that the charter school placed in in this public information everyone has that do not have persistence or the completion rates uh as we reviewed that now we want to be fair in the process and so those are the the different factors in the analysis and should there be a desire to review new information from any school in the process there are different choices but we'll pause at that and deal with the data

598that we have here and so that rounds out the analysis on the academics we did note some low enrollment piece that's just the schools in the black Etc but we did note we've noted to them the the decline in enrollment um so thank you for your question and and I know I took some time but again this is consequential and I wanted to lay out the analysis comments from board members any comments from board members Mr Melo well hearing no other comments I'll I'll make I'll move to uh uh approve the to swap the recommendation and to um I'll move to renew this petition for a 5-year term do we have a motion sorry a second Mr Mev has moved to swap out the re the current recommendation is it stands before the board and

599to approve the charter for a fiveyear term is that correct Mr melb correct and can you let us know are miss gonz and miss Ortiz Franklin on I do not have um miss public I do have uh Miss Ortiz Franklin I'm just because we can't see people I'm looking for a second yeah we need a second second so we've received a second from Miss Ortiz Franklin and now we'll take a vote on the swap out does it are we clear yes okay I apologize I'm just making notes everyone for posterity uh Miss nuell no Dr Ras no uh Mr melne yes Miss grigo no uh Miss gones absent Miss Ortiz Franklin no so no for Miss Ortiz Franklin and board president president shurson no the NOS have it we can now move on to take

600the vote on the underlying motion if if uh if that's appropriate any other questions before we go okay go ahead Mr can someone move it I can't move second I heard it but I didn't see it by Dr Ras moved by Dr Ras seconded by Miss newbill and the vote Miss nubil yes Dr Ras yes uh Mr mne no Miss Grio yes Miss gones absent mrti Franklin I'm sorry you're I believe you're muted Miss Franklin we can't hear you I'm a yes you're a yes Mr schmon yes okay yeses have it passes okay okay we are now moving on to tab 34 I have a public hearing statement to read for that tab all right T 30 4 statement to be read this constitutes a public hearing for pente Charter Justice Street Academy Charter Community

601magnet Charter Elementary and center for advanced learning a maximum of 15 individuals who wish to address the board and this item will be heard those who wish to speak should sign up online um following the public speakers this is a reminder that this item is not for Action today the board will be taking action on this on these Charter petitions at a subsequent meeting petitions denied may be submitted directly to the LA County Office of Education or directly to the state action so today is just a hearing uh no action will be taken on these items and public comment will be heard on these items so we will move directly to the public comment uh on item number 34 Dian harez come on up you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin good evening

602superintendent carvalo and esteemed board members my name is Diana htis and I am honored to serve as a vice principal at bu the charter school a neighborhood School in the heart of boil Heights as someone who was born and raised in the boil Heights community and continues to live in boil Heights as a resident I am deeply committed to the success of our students and families at Puente our students are at the core of everything that we do we serve students from TK through grade 5 providing a supportive and engaging environment where learning is meaningful talents are nurtured and every child feels safe valued and empowered one of our staff members said it best I see myself in my students this powerful connection reflects How Deeply our teachers and staff relate to our students experiences

603many of our Educators come from similar backgrounds as our students and understand the challenges our students and families face this shared experience fuels our passion to serve not not only as Educators but also as mentors Advocates and Role Models guiding and encouraging every child to reach their fullest potential our beautiful campus strong School culture and dedicated team make buente more than just a school it is a Cornerstone of the boil Heights Community where students and families truly feel they belong we are humbled by the challenges we've overcome grateful for the progress we've made and fully committed to supporting the student students of boil Heights as they reach their greatest potential thank you thank you for your time Isabelle cadon come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin good evening board members

604I'm Isabel Calderon director of special education at Puente Charter School at pente students with disabilities have made significant strides consistently meeting their annual goals and showing notable improvements in cast data for ELA and math this year they met or exceeded standards surpassing both previous scores and the state average however the true impact is not just reflected in data it's visible every day in the lives of our students it's in the progress of a non-verbal student who now uses full sentences or in the child who once cried at drop off now walking in with a smile these achievements are due to our teachers deep understanding collaboration and flexibility it's also due to the trust our parents place in us I know this because I am a point the parent I have firsthand experience with the incredible

605work our staff does I have so much confidence in our school and its team that I chose to enroll my two boys Miguel and Valentino when Miguel was about to start TK every day I told Miss Rosales Miguel's going to cry on his first day Miss Rosales was there to welcome him with a smile ready to catch him if he ran aside from her warm smile she had an inviting classroom environment Miguel walked right in and waved goodbye the only tears shed that day were mine Miss rosales's patience kindness and dedication made all the difference she created a space where Miguel felt safe welcomed and supported she listened to my concerns and made sure his needs were met just as she does with all her students this is the spirit that defines our faculty and

606staff a team of caring professionals who go above and beyond every day to support our students thank you for your time and consideration thank you for your time Mr David toosi come on down uh you have two minutes to speak once you begin thank you sir thank you very much um the these four schools two of them are affiliated Charters you don't seem to have any standard that's different following schools have not met standards and have been Ren red 107th Street Elementary School did not meet standards became a priority School 109th Street Elementary School did not meet standards became a priority School 112th Street Elementary School did not meet standards 28th 42nd 49th 52nd 54th 59th 75th Street 93rd Street 95th Street alala Elementary School Dr Maya Angelou Aragon Elementary School aabon bankr Middle School

607all did not meet standards are priority schools beun middle school for two years also ble Tom Bradley Global budong Avenue Elementary School did not meet standards did not make progress sufficient to come out of priority schools Bushnell Avenue did not meet standards chamelia Avenue George Washington Carver Middle School centry Park Elementary Cesar Chavez Elementary School in the superintendent priority School simmeron Johnny Cochran Johnny Cochran Johnny hochron school did not meet standards Coliseum Street Elementary School Columbus Avenue Elementary School Compton Avenue Elementary School contras K sha High did not meet standards Susan Miller dorsy did not meet standards is a priority School Charles Drew mvin DIY Thomas Alva Edison and I go on for 60 more schools in the district's priority schools which means that they did not meet the standards that superintendent has set for

608Progress they have not come out of the priority schools with the additional investment I ask you to reflect on equity which is a language that is used all the time Equity of standards and progress I am somebody who believes in high standards as an AP teacher as an academic to celon teacher but sometimes you are not looking at the fact that a school has almost 35% homeless kids and you hold them because they made a mistake and the charter rision didn't help them with respect to becoming an alternative assessment thank you very much thank you for your time Anna Hernandez Anna Hernandez are you out there Jerome Greening Jerome come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin good evening board members uh good evening superintendent uh thank you all for being

609here for the late night really appreciate it uh I am Jerome Greening I'm the CEO of Point Learning Center want to give a shout out to our community Bo Heights I hope all the kids are in bed already uh The Point Charter School Community demonstrates that that high performance is achievable it does take key Investments it takes collaboration it takes a healthy home to school relationships it's also compliance as a public school and continuous quality improvement we are continually inspired by those we serve and it motivates the school team to level up our practice to ensure we deliver on our pledge to provide a meaningful relevant and impactful school experience that does lead to high achievement Just Want to Thank You board members and superintendent carvalo for your consideration for the buente charter school renewal

610which is upcoming on the March 2025 meeting thank you and together we do lift others thank you thank you for your time Brenda Mesa come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin good evening board members I hope you and your loved ones are doing well after the tragedy that we are experiencing my name is Brenda Messa and I am the principal of bua Charter School our school has been a place of growth uh for over 20 years we only served kindergarten students and starting in 2018 we began to expand and now we serve students TK to 5 during this expansion um we this really meant that we expanded through the pandemic period and the remarkable thing about this is that the team did not lose sight of the quality of service

611every single classroom is intentionally designed to support student learning uh every teacher every prayer professional is trained to support all types of Learners our amazing staff Works tirelessly for our school Community this has led us to accomplish test scores that surpass State averages and we have also reached High performing status I believe in the work that takes place at when that every every single day thank you for your time thank you okay uh let's see Stephanie beltron are you here Stephanie beltron come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin thank you I think at this point I should say good night good evening uh I do want to spend most of my time uh just saying how oh I'm sorry I forgot to introduce myself my name is Stephanie Wan I

612am the principal at center for advanced learning I am honored to work for this school it is my first year and I already call it my home um center for advanced learning is a school in South Central and it has proudly been a Cornerstone of our community for 17 years so today we are seeking your support to renew our Charter and continue the vital work we do in shaping our future for our students thank you thank you for your time uh tomasa Martinez tomasa come on down if you're out there tomasa Martinez okay so tomasa is going to speak in Spanish so if you'd like to hear what she's saying in English um please get these translation headsets so that you can experience simultaneous translation okay gracias good afternoon members of the board my name

613is tomasa Martinez I am member of Ace I have a son at Roosevelt High School who is in 12th grade I am here to ask that not to renew the contract with the school and also I am also comfortable so that I would like for student voices to have to be taken into consideration about the chares that are coming to our communities that are only buying off the community with gift cards uh theater tickets and because I am a member of my community at boo Heights I need need to know what they would bring to this community from extera a uh consultant called pis pach because I didn't take my son they told me that I couldn't be there I if I'm not welcom there neither is my son we need to stop privatizing education

614in our communities our children are not for sale the education of our children is not for sale thank you next we have Lisa Galindo are you here thank you and you'll speak in English correct in espanol okay good night my name is Elisa Galindo I have a daughter in La USD today I am here to say that you should be very careful in renewing Charter School petition I say this and I hold it we know that this is a very serious problem because people are resting right now at home like M Mr wiisard Monica Garcia Antonio vosa and LC esto and those uh the administrators of the California school Char school syst and those that want to privatize public education we know very well what is happening we know that this is a dirty game

615of the corporations the parents know who are the executives that are leading charger school do they know how they move money around do they know that if they're accountable do you do you know how much they owe L USD when the students return to Public Schools without money this is in Justin this is not democracy we're talking about students I saw so many students outside their parents knew that the California Charter School Association here on a bus that they can pay for like Miss tomasa said they were giving uh gift cards from Panda IHOP theater to be open a school that is in danger now we're seeing the fires and I saw precisely the firefighters asking the supervisors to return the money that was taken away and that's going to happen to you if you

616don't make the Charter School charter Association be accountable of what they're doing why are they working in those schools like a business what is their marketing why do they have private entities to mobilize people exad a school was going to be a new school they were going to have a new school that was affecting the community and and that way they're still affecting the community and this is not de democracy this is an injustice and you need to have this taken to Kaza or it's going to be the same thing as the fires you're going to close public school and the vouchers will come here we have Donald Trump on the way announcing this so be careful so so that we don't are not without public education the remaining folks are speaking remotely Casey Kenda

617I see you signed up to speak remotely but you are not remote are you in the room Rachel T also not here uh and then let's see I do know we have antona Garcia is on the line so please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin antona Garcia yes hi um can you hear me we sure can please go ahead okay yes hi everyone um good good evening um board members um superintendent carvalo my name is antona Garcia and I'm a proud mother of La USD a proud graduate from L USD and now my daughters are in L USD I'm also the co-chair of Centro CSO education committee and I am here to ask you guys for to ask the to please um deny the renewals

618of a pente charter we no longer need more charter schools in our community especially in boo Heights there are plenty of there are plenty of um public schools that they're that they're achieving and they're giving the students a pathway and they're help and they're helping the black and brown Community by having our Public Schools more and by you renewing these um these um all all of these renewals with all these Charter Schools it's just giving them more it's just giving them more especially now that Trump is coming on board we do not we do not want for our L USD to to to be PR um for the privatization to end I mean we want privatization to end and by this it's for you not to please renew to please not to renew their um

619their permits many of these charer schools they lack of um transparency they lack they don't they don't they don't want this um the board to see The Chronic absentees and also especially English Learners thank you so much and have a great day thank you for your time let's see we have one more person speaking remotely Carlos Montes Carlos Montes okay that concludes public comment for this item so there's no action to be taken on this so we're going to go directly to tab 37 which also is an item with uh no action associated with it uh it's the receipt of the 2023 2024 annual audit financial report and I believe the superintendent has a comment and so does the board president no no he does yes thank you very much much so the presentation of

620our annual uh audited financial report is is a routine yet a critically important item that independently validates the accuracy of our financial uh data and reports back in September the team presented the UN audited financials which represents our internal review at the end of the prior fiscal year talking about 23 24 uh today's report reviews that information along with several other elements to obtain an external assessment of our financial reporting uh the conclusion is that uh we always try for an unmodified opinion and uh that represents a clean audit and I'm happy to share that that is the designation we as a school district have received now we have uh individuals here with us and they are prepared to do a presentation however had a brief conversation with our board president and uh what we

621can do considering the late hour we can send the presentation to the board that then schedule individual meetings based on uh your need necessity or desire to have those meetings all right thank you then okay and I just have one small procedural step to take right now which is to uh log Miss grego's vote on Tab S authorization of the finalized negotiations yes as a yes thank you very much on Tab 7 um for those paying close attention we have one more piece of business that's tab 39 uh we are not going to get to that business tonight this meeting is going to recess until tomorrow morning at 950 a.m. that's 950 a.m. in this room tomorrow uh morning and we'll post notice and all the appropriate spaces and send out notice so with that

622the meeting is recessed until tomorrow at 9:50 a.m. so you'll send it to all

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.