001[Music] e e okay good morning the time is now 11:27 a.m. on December 10th 2024 welcome to the regular meeting of the Los Angeles Unified School District Board of Education I'm going to take role uh Miss hendy nubel present Dr Ras present Mr schmon present or I should say board president sharlon Mr melne uh here miss grigo here miss gones present M Franklin who who will be joining us shortly I believe and student board member Cortez Lopez present okay the floor is yours sir good morning everyone we're going to begin our agenda with labor Partners do we have any labor Partners who would like to speak to the board then come on down let me activate your microphone we can hear you but those folks can't all right good morning board members Georgia fles Lee
002utla Nea vice president welcome to the newly seated board members I have several topics to address this morning first the black student achievement plan which was created in collaboration with students families community and Educators who recognized and acknowledged the ways in which black students in La unified had historically been neglected marginalized and criminalized and together sought ways to address the harm those students and their Community are now being told that the harm can still be addressed even when the Black is removed from Bap we don't believe it and so I'm inviting this board and specifically the newly seated members of the board to join us students Educators and community and collaborate with us in our struggle to ensure that this District continues to do the work to repair the harm it has caused and does
003so transparently and diligently like I said I got a bunch of stuff second the issue of school closures whether it's called a merger a consolidation optimization reconfiguration the bottom line is that a school Community ceases to exist as its own entity that's a school closure this is currently proposed for two elementary schools lyola Village and Westport Heights lyola Village Elementary with a predominantly black and brown student body will lose its identity and become a part of Westport Heights I point this out because when school closures are propo proposed they disproportionately impact black and brown communities yes Equity should be a weighted Factor when the district considers combining schools third the financial presentation we see that once again interim CFO Chris Mount bitas is choosing not to present any actual cost by function or object in
004his financial report slide deck his preferred metric appears to be staff headcounts versus enrollment if his primary objective is to eliminate staff rather than present to the board a factual analysis of actual spending Trends we believe this is a disservice to the board and to our community we also see that his budget calendar states that School site budgeting begins in January which is not what teachers are being told at the campus level so we would like clarification on why schools are being told to get their budgets in this week unlike in past years and then lastly on the issue of the housing task force can y'all confirm whether staff has acted since or joint letter with Ace regarding the housing task force have changes been made to the district's appointments to the task force and
005does the district plan to bring land swaps with Charter Schools or housing developments affiliated with B ster back to the board those are questions I'm hoping we'll get answers to today thank you all I'm going to pass it over to two of our community school coordinators good morning my name is Lura scavo and I am a science teacher and the utla chapter chair at Monroe High School which is part of region north located in Board District 6 represented by Miss gones I also serve as utla's Valley West Board of director for those of you not familiar with my school it is a comprehensive High School in the San Fernando Valley with three Public Service themed magnet programs an engineering and design Academy and a thriving CTE program which includes culinary arts Woodwork and video production
006we recently established an international newcomers Academy and a dual language program to support our growing population of English Learners and newcomers and we are in our second year as a community school superintendent carvalo I believe recently visited our school um as part of an etto initial review because we were designated a priority School this year I'm here today to share with you the difficulties we are experiencing as a community school due to the district's new interpretation of our utla contract regarding Community Schools and our professional development last year as a community school when we were planning our PD plan we had a 100% purview over our PDS and our school was creative in using the time to work collaboratively to communicate our goals and to form connections with our students and our families last year
007we were not told to implement District trainings that take up 50% of our professional development a requirement for first year Community Schools is to look at data collected from all interest holders students parents and staff through an assets and needs assessment and one of the main findings in our authentic data dig was that students and families wanted to have more opportunities to connect with our staff and our school all interest holders agreed that it was important to work on building relationships and connections across our campus last year one way we were able to use our PD time was to plan develop and prepare an interactive open house to engage current and future Monroe families visitors like Miss gonz's representative and staff alike stated it was a successful event in building Community moments like this are
008not created overnight and they are not created in a single meeting however because we are being told that we now have to include the district trainings there is little to no room for us to complete the goals of our community school implementation plan and presentations or preparations for additional opportunities for parent and family engagement is basically gone as a result our collaborative plans are being overrun by The District's on siiz fits all modules whereas last year we embedded time to work collaboratively within departments and specialized programs like the ones I mentioned at the beginning this year we have not been able to provide time to build upon last year's success due to the district mandated PDS in addition knowing that the district is moving towards an inclusive classroom setting at the end of last year
009our local school Leadership Council allocated $440,000 to bring a specialist to our school to help our teachers and our PA professionals prepare and plan how we will support our students and staff in this new setting again given that we had 100% purview last year over rpds we were making sure that we were using all 39 Bank days and now with the district demand again to implement this one-size fits-all module our PDS are left empty and we're trying to prioritize what we have left for the rest of the year but in all honesty all the PDS are a priority and we need to have a say in all of them we had the opportunity to meet with Miss gones and we shared some of the other ways the district PDS are restricting our progress it as
010a community school I appreciate the support she shared in a letter to our school but now I'm here in front of you asking for your support as well support for my community school and all Community Schools because to become a community school it requires commitment and dedication it requires buyin from all all the interest holders it requires time which we use through our professional development dedicated to addressing the needs of the people at our school we are aware that our school needs to improve in certain aspects but as a collective our students our staff and our families agreed to become a community school in order to address the specific needs of our community by taking away half of our PDS in order to present generic information that most of a staff is already aware of
011the district has essentially hindered and stopped our progress the voice of our students our parents and staff is being stifled by The District's PDS which don't address the results of our own data dig thank you good morning everyone um my name is Ivan Nasco I'm the chapter chair at North Rich middle school and I also represent um Valley West on our utla's board of directors I'd like to start off by taking um taking the time to thank this board for creating the spaces where you can listen to and and see the people who are directly impacted by the decisions that this board makes um I'm here to talk about how your uh one-size fitle model of PD is in fact affecting us at our school site not just at the school sites but also in
012our daily lives because as you know we all take home um all the issues in the trauma that we experien at the school sites every day um I think that most of you uh this board if not some of you are aware of all the incidents that have happened at my school at northri Middle School um we have had a series of incidents that have caused serious con for our safety for our mental health and for the way um we really see the future of northri Middle School um we have had so many incidents that have caused uh serious concern however due to the district's mandated PD modules we are not able to come together as a faculty to heal from all these incidents that have happened at our sites to come together as a
013community to discuss how these issues have affected us and more importantly we haven't had an opportunity to discuss next steps and how we respond to these incidents when they happen at our school sites um most of you are aware that um we have had so many incidents that continue to perpetuate a lot of danger in our community we are working in conditions that that really are violent but we don't even have time to come together and and look at our crisis team our safety plans our PBIS plans because constantly we are inundating with District PD that tells us what the needs of our school are um we have actually designed PD previously we spent a great deal of time last year developing PD for this year and I was told in writing that we were
014not able to conduct those PD s because we had to prioritize the PDS that the district has sent which really don't prioritize our school needs we also are considered a priority school but we are definitely not seen as a priority when we look at the PD modules that are set forth by the district they are very one-sized fits all to the point of they they are scripted we are told what to say we are told what to do we are told what to think and all of this does not allow us time to come together as a community and really design meaningful relevant PD that is needed for us to continue to function as a school as a community so we're asking um this board today to really consider meaningful relevant ways in which you
015can support Community Schools and advocating for and implementing meaningful and relevant PD that that impacts all of us on a daily basis I wanted to ask this board to really consider ways that you can allow us to function as a community school and be be together as one we never have any opportunity to come together again because we're constantly being mandated our PDS are inundated by pdsa Cycles followed by mandated modules that as as ludus pointed out our one Sid fits all and obviously a lot of those PDS are are scripted to the point where we have heard the same language over and over and over again rendering them pretty much meaningless and insufficient to the needs of our school I'd like to thank also Mr schmon for for taking the time to meet with
016us and listen to our concerns in Valley West and for crafting a letter in support for our PD I know Mr schmon has been really involved in the needs of our community and has seen firsthand just how these traumatic events affect as I mentioned not not just the mental health of our students and every Community uh interest holder but also how it impacts our daily lives not not only are we taking home the trauma that we experiened ourselves as Educators but that of our students as we absorb their their trauma so we have our own trauma followed with our secondhand trauma they absorb every day but we are never allowed to be in one space as a community to design steps or even talk about the trauma that we are all experiencing together which I
017think is contradictory to the philosophy of a community school and a priority school so we're asking for you to please consider how you create um systems that are meaningful and relevant for each School site thank you thank you for your time I believe SEIU has a representative here to speak SEIU come on up sir thank you good morning my name is Walter Lopez and I'm a proud seciu Local 99 member working as a stock worker at Al USD procurment Center I've been in this road for seven years and during that time I have firsthand firsthand the strength and solidarity that comes with being part of seu Local 99 as a SEIU Local 99 member we play a vital role in making sure schools have what they need to function and students have what they need
018to thrive whether it's nutritious meals or keeping schools stock with essential supplies our work behind the scenes supports students success and strengthens our community we address urgent needs every every day and as a SEIU Local 99 member we know the importance of standing together to make sure that work gets the respect and investment it deserves like many of my co-workers I have faced rising cost and uncertainty the threat of sub subcontracting isn't just an attack on one of us it's an attack on all of us losing this job would mean I couldn't pay my rent or take care of my family and I know my co-workers feel the same way when one worker is attacked we all feel the impact but at SEIU Local 99 member we know that we stand in solidarity we are
019stronger together we fight for each other and for the resources we need to live and work with dignity we are calling on Al USD to end subcontracting for the safety of our schools and our students as a SEIU Local 99 member we know the value of experienced dedicated workers who have undergone rigorous rigorous background checks and are committed to the students and the schools we serve unlike the for-profit companies like Amazon the AL USD has subcontract this is about protecting good jobs and ensuring safe well-run schools let's continue to stand together as CIU Local 99 members to demand an end to subcontracting and to fight for the respect and investment our work deserves thank you Walter hi Bo hi superintendent carvalo you guys all already know me but for the record my name is Jana
020Tyler I am here in my union capacity today Local 99 proud I am the parent and Family Center Director at Hamilton High School um and a lot of you guys know that I have been in parent engagement and parent and Family Center Director for the past 17 18 years in LAUSD so as the parent and Family Center Director as Community reps as parent reps you guys know that we're the liaison between home school and the community we're the ones that are providing the mutual Aid and the connection the resources that our families need in order to remove the barriers to student learning and to their academic success I connect parents to resources I show them how to navigate District systems again we support the school in every facet often to often being pulled to do
021jobs that are not under our job description in addition to literally being the essential workers that can stop a family from being homeless by connecting them to Mutual Aid through our homeless programs as well as in their community resource Hub on the top of that we are still responsible to provide our own parent training and workshops at least two times a month so with that we are clearly a key part of our students learning experience and not only that we are the families of La USD at least 70 to 80% of us have our own children in the school so we're not just essential workers we're actually your families we're your constituents we're the parents of La USD with my LAUSD salary if I had to depend on what I make as a parent and
022Family Center Director alone that would only cover about 2third of my rent none of my bills none of my high none of my health care needs let alone take care of the children that I have even now with winter break approaching a lot of my co-workers are trying to negotiate whether they actually buy Christmas presents for their children or be able to pay rent in January because with our position and our status other than three days of winter Academy if we're selected to work we don't earn income over the winter break but yet we're the glue that actually keeps our families and our schools together classified workers in unit G would never be able to survive without a secondary form of income by the grace of God a lot of us do have secondary forms
023of income however that pulls us away from our children and our family while families while we're serving other people's families all day long so again if we didn't have a second source of income I know if I didn't have a steady second source of income I'd be one of those almost 20,000 homeless families that we also serve in LUSD and so with a lot of my co-workers in the second largest school district in the country we should need a second form of income to just survive we deserve to also Thrive as human beings and for our children to have the best experiences that they can have also so alongside our teachers the classified workers here in La USD are the ones that make that our children have the type of learning environments that all students
024deserve and that's why I'm here today congratulations again to the new board members but now you guys are also charged in order to give us a fair contract so I'm here to let you guys know respect us by paying us thank you hello board members and super superintendent uh carvalos and all the new board members here my name is Elizabeth Thomas Parker I have been a special education assistant with LA USD for 36 years I am also the vice president for seciu Local 99 and currently on the bargaining team negotiating our next contract with District as stated by Walter and Jana we are fighting for a contract that lifts dedicated workers above poty line and Ure high quality for our students High wages and increased work hours will ensure the hiring for more Staffing being
025a special education assistant I can tell you that we are severely under staff and diely suffering because of the students and the staff alike there are not enough assistance to provide the coverage when someone is out ill when a nonpublic agency bii is absent a special education assistant is pulled from their classrooms to cover that vacancy leaving students vulnerable yet again this is further Evidence when there is a lack of training or experience with new hires and no regards for providing in-person training to enhance our skills subtra subcontracting to non-public agency does not work not only are they limited to what they can do with our students but the agencies do not send a substitute when their employees are out this leads to yet another disruption in education when District PA professionals are being there
026to work that the agency and further not being properly compensated all of these changes impact our students everyone deserves stability especially our special education students yes yes when stability cannot be ensured it gives away from many safety issues in our district that impact both students and staff this change lays in your hands we urge you to work with us to improve wages increase hours and improve training opportunities so that more workers can be recruited and promoted within LAUSD many of us have dedicated Our Lives to helping children of this District finally we go on to winter break this should be a joyful time however it's a struggle for Local 99 members there are many non days in the month of December and January many of our classified workers won't be allowed to use their vacation
027time to cover any of these unassigned work days dedicated education workers should not only live pay should not be having to live paycheck to paycheck the average wage should not be at property level I urge you all to ensure the commitment to importance of fully Staffing that is needed for our student services you can do that by providing us with living wages more work hours and increase training for those of us on the front line Thank you thank you and when we fight we win when we fight we win when we fight we win that's right you thank you for your time I believe uh Maria Nichols is here from Alla to say a few words and then following Miss Nichols I believe we have representative from um Gil Gomez I believe you're here also
028so after Miss Nichols it will be your time good morning I am the proud optimistic hopeful president of the associated administrators of Los Angeles and first of all I want to introduce myself formally to our new board members some of you which I know some of you which are new congratulations to our new board member sitting today with hope and optimism to do good work for kids Teachers principales Community our labor Partners sciu utla so that we can all do better for students Miss newbill congratulations Miss gregio congratulations Miss Ortiz welcome back to a second term congratulations on your baby adorable I want to congratulate Mr Scott smaron a dear partner of mine a dear advocate for students and communities and teachers for the last eight years I had the privilege of working with him
029as a director congratulations on being voted in as president of our board you will do good work alongside Miss Dr Rivas for being elected vice president of the board congratulations to all of you I come to you today because I look forward to our continued partnership I do have monthly meetings with the board with the sole intent of ensuring that we have open Communication open collaboration and Partnerships for transparency and shared accountability and I heard you loud and clear clear miss greo that you believe in shared accountability as do I I'm also here today to remind us that working together with our labor partners seciu who are so critical to the work that we do as classified employees a principal of 11 years a director of 10 I know how important their roles are in
030our school communities and as uh president smaron said every person matters when we serve students teachers principles School communities in in a school every person matters so I stand with my labor Partners in advocacy for what they stand for the long work hours the increase of pay and stopping I urge you to stop the Outsourcing in addition I stand handin hand with my utla partners I was a teacher for 17 years before I was asked to move along to become a coordinator and then went back to school to get my admin to become then an assistant principal principal and director we have very very many common things to work together on one Community Schools I was a very proud director to take vanai Elementary School to that through that process and Community Schools are just
031that Community Schools they serve the Community they serve the interest of the communities because it is not a one-size fits all so when they talk about those PD modules when they talk about Community Schools and the constant discussion that we go back and forth on with extra duty pay versus um the other type of pay training rate it is not and was not the two intention when principles and community and teachers and students entered into that agreement I ask you to revisit that I stand here today full of excitement for the new board to continue to work with our labor Partners to continue to support all our workers because we do all matter and I agree with SEIU together we win so thank you so very much today for your time Mr gz come on
032up good afternoon my name is Gil GES I'm the president of the LA School Police Officers Association um I've heard uh from fellow labor Partners talking about Outsourcing and I I think my group is the the number one group that has experienced that and there was even a transference of wealth in regards to the defunding and I won't get into that the money went into Bap on the other side I say make sure Bap stays intact fight tooth and nail I I think it is a a great thing I'm sorry I'm not an educator I don't have the words I I didn't do my career speaking in classrooms like the the speakers before me but protect that is as much as you possibly can period we'll be okay but protect Bap um I'm not speaking
033out of both sides of my face I'm just being very realistic we're here to Ser serve children um and Outsourcing does not work we could we could work with the safe passage group but we' we've seen what Outsourcing does and in my line of work they don't get a d or an F or a dirty a dirty bathroom which is which is all bad they get killed and when you Outsource police work to to people that aren't trained how to do police work people get killed and and I'm sorry I have the the unfortunate job to come up here and and talk about this publicly and I try to do it with the utmost respect to the family and everybody else involved and I do understand politics as well um yesterday and I'll leave the
034name of the school out of it there was an unfortunate stabbing on campus and and and kids do crazy things males do crazier things than females usually I'm sorry for being like that but we just we just do but we we rely on the adults in the room to keep people in check to to make sure that the adults make the decisions and it's the decisions were made a few years ago which pulled our officers off campus we don't have the amount of officers to put back on campus but yesterday's unfortunate event on a high school campus there was tagging so there was literal writing on the wall saying that there's a problem here something's going to happen when we have a school police officer on campus the the principal would call it would be
035like uh principal to one one being the school police one go can you come over here to look at some tagging and then they would call the at the time the counselor or the restorative justice coordinator and you would try to figure out what this tagging means and then you would pull key players out to the students um to figure out what happens to stop incidents before they happen um we don't have that anymore and not asking for that but I'm hearing a lot of Labor Partners talking about trauma in school I'm hearing a lot of Labor Partners crying for help they won't say the police word they won't they won't say things like that but what do you how do you stop people when uh doing violent things from doing violent things if you
036don't have the authority how do you stop them if you don't have the training how do you stop them if you don't have the tools PDS are great but you will not stop incidents when they happen there's there's the medical field there's acute and chronic we have chronic we have a chronic condition of maybe student apathy or student um depression or certain things with students and then we have and that's on The Chronic end and then we have the acute problems the things that are happening right here right now that we need somebody to stop that's right here right now um I I want to be a team player and and you could tell as I'm searching around for the words I'm being very sensitive toward these things and and specifically the incident yesterday two
037students were stabbed on a high school campus the the still shots on social media the knife and the stabbing the video on social media shows that we don't we can't keep our our campuses safe enough I'm very masonian in the way I think you there's there's safety before self-actualization graduation things like that we can't do the basic things right now because politically we don't we don't agree for some reason um it's it's it's it's hard to play family when other people don't play back but I understand the need of people that are frustrated with police officers but it's been a very long time since since the uh three four years ago and I'm speaking vaguely but I'll leave it at that um congratulations Miss nubil Miss grigo uh Miss Ortiz Franklin once again Mr sharlon
038again um hopefully we could open up lines of communications I get principles calling me to help solve problems I get Deans and counselors calling me to help solve problems um I I think we all need to sit at the table and try to collaborate for the the student safety but thank you very much thank you for your time I have to note that uh Miss Ortiz Franklin was here around 1138 I just want to call for her her rooll vote present thank you okay thank you sorry about that uh board member are there any other labor Partners present that's a no okay thank you very much we're going to have committee reports right now and I'd like to start with the procurement facilities committee uh Mr meloy thank you board President we have not had
039a meeting since our last update a couple weeks ago so I will pass thank you uh we have uh Charter Schools committee with Dr Evas any reports no no reports we did not meet um this past month uh we'll meet in the coming year and uh Greening schools and climate control committee same as well same as well well I do have a report for the cal um this meeting was on Tuesday December the 3 at 10: a.m. and the allocation of elop funds is based on TK to six grade average attendance and funds several after school programs including Ela math Arts summer school winter Academy field trips and more elop funds must be spent within 2 years therefore $364.14 [Music] schools and 14,320 students around the district the cultural arts passport the Arts acceleration and
040the Arts Fest of 2024 were part of the expansion of the Arts and in part funded by elop elop paid for college and enrichment field trips in part to explore interests that included arts and Sports Camps 52 schools participated in internships and five 564 students participated in the internship program to explore careers in education and our next meeting is January 28th 2025 at 10 a.m. thank you very much that's the end of the committee report um and I believe it's time to move on to the consent calendar um there's a number of action items on the agenda that you'll see if you have it in front of you and some of these items get placed on a consent calendar it's an efficiency that a business meeting uses in order to take a group of things
041all at once instead of voting on many things one time that everyone would vote the same way on so I'm going to read through the action items on the agenda and if a board member calls um consent or question or discussion it will either be placed on the discussion calendar or will be kept on the consent calendar um so approval of procurement actions I actually do have a question so me too that will be on discussion approval of facilities contracts actions consent consent report of cash dispersements request to reissue expired warrants donations of money and materials to the district uh 2024 2025 first interim report uh multi-year projections and resolution to release committed fund balance December 10th 2024 cons there's also a presentation on that so that will be on discussion with the presentation uh
042fiscal year 24 capitals facilities fund School impact fees was that all consent okay approval of routine Personnel actions consent uh provisional internship permits approval of the California Community Schools partnership program Grant you'll see uh item 10 education compacts has been postponed to the January 14th 2025 meeting for those in the audience uh tab 11 we have a 1M time certain for Miss gonz's readers to leaders advancing Literacy for every child in Los Angeles a resolution uh and then tab 12 uh from board member GNA celebrating and accelerating access to Computer Science Education in the Los Angeles Unified School District including a waiver of board rule 72 as amended actually yeah there will be some friendly amendments at the table I hope yep okay uh we have public hearings Charter petitions for public hearing um report
043of Correspondence and we have um this doesn't go on this isn't for action but we have a resolution for initial announcement from Dr reos and uh board president schmon Community centered Greening initiatives strengthening Equity through parent engagement and external Partnerships so that's an initial announcement the text of which appears in the agenda for public review and then at the next meeting there will be discussion uh potentially on that item when we get there okay okay so typically uh what happens now is we go through the um let's see I'm going to relist so number one was for discussion we have questions from Mr melin and Dr Evas uh two is consent three is consent four is consent five we have discussion and a presentation uh six is consent 7 89 n are consent 10 is
044postponed 11 12 13 14 consent and 15 is not for Action does that make sense to everybody yes yes okay we'll now go through and hear the um public comment on the consent items so those uh before the board takes action on the consent items or anything uh first here's public comment on the items that are on the consent calendar so let me pull up the list of those who are registered to speak uh we have under tab nine one oh Tab four I'm sorry we have Tab four we have one speaker uh David tolkovsky are you here I saw you here earlier Mr David tolkovsky are you with us okay he is not here so that's a tab four public comment and then tab seven public comment approval of routine um Personnel actions we
045have Mr Eric White to speak on Tab seven oh David toskov is here so uh Mr White please make your way down and Mr tolkovsky will speak on looks like Tab four donations of money and materials to the district you have two minutes the floor is yours sir thank you very much and congratulations to the new board and everything you look at today uh it's a new board so it's important to find out what the previous board has done and then confer with your colleagues and decide if that's still the budget allocations that you want to do or not do this item obviously is a no-brainer uh anybody who's donating let's support them but the two big ones are the first interim which is required under assembly Bill 1200 that you get a since uh
046uh the Richman School District went bankrupt in 1992 school districts are required three three times to publicly present their budgets and so what you can do is look at that first interim and compare it now you have a new CBO so everything he's presenting to you is different than David Hart the previous CBO so you kind of want to put out there and ask for the comparison so you can look at where did the $2 billion of committed monies that used to be presented how did that transfer into other places because you talked about a 6 point something billion dollar Surplus and you look at it today and it doesn't have that number so the question is where did it go and that's what's important about the good use of the first interum is to
047ask key questions the other big budget item is the um developer fees and those are everywhere you see a new building going up that the developer like in Lincoln Heights must put uh um $4 per square foot into the facilities budget that can be used for neighboring properties it's supposed to the impact on the neighborhood and in fact we found out through the inspector General's report over a year ago or two years ago that there were cities like hunon Park that were not paying the district their monies and we have had no progress report on whether or not the district through legal has gotten that money and there are other cities 26 cities that may not be paying the amount owed to the school district so I I leave you with those thoughts on this
048day on this good day but please dig into the monies it's the most important piece along with your leadership thank you very much thank you for your time okay now we have a speaker on Tab S Mr Eric White are you here Eric White are you gonna come on down okay Mr Eric White is coming down to speak on Tab S um and while he's coming down we're going to um after discussing with board member gonz put Tabby 11 on discussion because there's a one pm time certain and there's a chance we're going to dispose of the consent calendar prior to hearing that so procedurally it seems to makes the most sense the floor is yours sir thank you all right hello everyone uh I wrote some notes okay first I wanted to congratulate miss
049grego and miss hendy newbill on the being um sworn in and Miss Ortiz Franklin on being reelected and um yeah but I'm going to be honest I didn't I'm about to speak about is not related to this topic so please forgive me for whoever this impacts I just I had to get in um the public comment filled up fast so just a little bit about me so you all know my name is Eric White um um I'm organizer of reclaim our schools La I'm also a youth Minister I'm a basketball coach I'm a husband of 10 years and a father of two boys okay I serve on the School site Council I serve on elac and I'm also on the parent advisory committee for this District right so just so you know a little bit
050about me and um the time that I spend when I'm not here my son was sent to the office over 90 times last school year and he was in K kindergarten um he was in kindergarten it was his first Public School experience he had the school police called on him as a six-year-old uh me and my wife were acrossed at the gate by parents six different times his teacher Mrs Ros Alvarado took a stress leave and blamed my six-year-old child as a scapegoat for her inability to manage an oversized classroom instead of administration as a l andaren father I came to that school every single time that school called me and um I tried to volunteer to support him right so I was told by the school staff that if I didn't shop her around
051his school his field trip that he would not be able to go to the zo with his classmates so I did and a week later I had a Mee him with the principal and my volunteer status was placed on um discontinuation without telling me a reason she told me that it was the face unit in the region South that was doing it and um she continued to emphasize so after weeks went by uh the in there was no conclusion on the investigation she called me into a meeting in June 11th and a last day of school that's when she informed me that it was uh discontinued um all I just want to say is after 7even months of phone calls and emails she still barely just gave me a reason in October why my reason
052why I was even suspended so all due respect to principles and everything like you know that just I feel like they shouldn't be able to just revoke people like that you know without giving a reason and so I'm bringing this to the board right now um I've been emailing her and Rudy Mendoza who's um in her director and I also been emailing um Leticia estado in the face unit and um I'm just and I'm just receiving conflicting information she's telling me the district is doing it they're saying she thank you for your time sir we appreciate your time thank you very much thank you Mr M appreciate you all [Applause] right on topic let me just mention to everyone a couple of things for this new uh board we are hoping that people will actually
053sign up for public comment to speak on anything that's not a consent item and I appreciate I appreciate what Mr White is going through I understand that and we have people to help to do that here but you should sign up on a consent item when you want to speak on that consent item it's not fair to others but we certainly will help Mr White absolutely go ahead Mr cran okay on Tab eight we have one speaker approval of California Community Schools partner uh Lucy Garcia you're signed up is speaking remotely but I do not have you online with us are you in the room Miss Garcia okay Lucy Garcia is not here okay that was tab eight uh tab nine under tab 11 that's going to go on to discussion so there are two
054speakers for that we have four speakers under tab 12 uh celebrating and accelerating access to Computer Science Education in the LA USD um kishan H are you here kishan H Maria Torres has signed up to speak remotely but I do not have her on the line Karina Lopez also signed up to speak remotely are you in the room Miss Lopez uh and Maria Daisy Ortiz is signed up to speak remotely are you in the room orz that's no so that was for tab 12 uh tab 13 we do have public speakers and it is a public hearing so I'm going to read a public hearing statement prior to going through that tab forgive me as I look for this sheet of paper tab 13 is a public hearing a maximum of 15 individuals who wish
055to address the board on this item will be heard those who wish to speak should sign up online and this constitutes a public hearing for cre Academy Kip Scholar Academy Kip Soul Academy Los Angeles Leadership Academy Ivy bound Academy of Math Science and Technology Charter Middle Kip guazon Academy future is now Career Technical education Preparatory discover Charter Preparatory 2 montue Charter Academy for the Arts and Sciences Kip philosophers Academy in Watts Learning Center uh the board will be taking action on the charter petition at a subsequent meeting petitions denied may be submitted directly to Los Angeles County Office of Education or directly to the state for Action so to be clear the board isn't taking action on this item today but is hearing comment from the public regarding those names and Charters that I just
056read so uh I have the list in front of me and um folks if you're in person I'm going to call on four names so the first person could come up to the podium and the other three folks uh wait in the wings uh prepared to give to give comment Keith deila are you here Keith D come on up you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin uh Valerie Amaya and then um Veronica genel and then Carla Davalos so come on up and uh Mr deil you have two minutes to speak why you begin thank you so much good afternoon my name is Keith dequel I'm with the California Charter Schools Association I'm excited that you're hearing the public hearings for several Charter School renewals um today um to miss grigo and to miss
057heny newble congratulations um it's exciting to see you up here um honest honest and sincere wishes of uh congratulations and excellent uh success on the board um as you serve these students as you consider renewals uh it's helpful to know that one in four public school students in Los Angeles attends a charter school um to what that means for this school year is that there are 120,000 students in charter schools in Los Angeles 100,000 students of color 95,000 of those students living in poverty 25,000 English Learners and about 177,000 students with disabilities um in short the children attending Charter Public Schools are the same children in District Public Schools we come from the same communities have the same um hopes and dreams in fact there are about 60 charter schools in La unified that are
058also Community Schools um miss hendy newbille you now represent 41 uh charter schools in your District it's about 16,000 students um Miss grigo uh for for you it's about 23,000 students across 47 um Charter Schools um we're excited that you each bring perspectives as Educators who understand that schools are not one size fit all that all Learners are different that educators are best prepared to support kids in the classroom when when they have resources when they have supports when they have the flexibilities to meet those children that are actually in those seats um we're excited you bring perspectives as parents um who understand that there is no more important responsibility than ensuring that your child is safe secure valued and uh nurtured too frequently the experience of families who come into this room is is
059one rooted in fear and that's not always the intention um up here but it is an experience that people don't feel seen don't feel valued and don't feel like their choices are really understood and so we ask you to help us change that experience to work with us in tandem um to visit our schools to meet the Educators to meet the families um and to stand in partnership with the charter school Community thank you so much and congratulations thank you for your time Valerie come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin congratulations to the board members sworn in today hello my name is Valeria Maya and I am a proud graduate of both Los Angeles Leadership Academy Middle School and High School where I had the honor of being valid dictorian
060of my class After High School I attended UC Berkeley where I graduated this spring with a bachelor's in psychology today I've come full circle and returned to Lala working as an instructional aid for students with special needs and the girls high school soccer coach because I want to give back to the community that gave me my start Lala is more than just a school it's a place that Fosters hope and provides students with a chance to turn their lives around it's where students who received the cold shoulder from the larger public school system find a sense of belonging care and support I know this from experience I watched my best friend who arrived at Lala her junior year on the path to gang involvement and drugs pulled back through the mentorship and one-on-one attention that
061only a small dedicated Charter like lala can provide this spring she will transfer to a 4-year University something she could have never imagined when she first arrived to Lala when I attended the high school it had just reignited its sports program I joined every every team and elective I could because I believed in the hope that Lala offered it was a place where no student was overlooked where every voice mattered and where opportunities were embraced with gratitude today laa Sports programs APS and electives have expanded and can only continue to grow from here Lala continues to nurture the kind of small victories that transform lives Lala doesn't just C create Scholars it creates resilient hopeful young people who believe in themselves Lala took a girl with immigrant parents and an older SI with autism and
062cultivated a young educated woman of color Lala gave me the support to become the first in my family to not only graduate high school but University my future children will be able to check Bachelors or higher when it comes to their parents education Lala gave me a future full of possibilities a future full of hope that is why Lala's Str should be renewed Lala isn't just a school it's a Lifeline a community that transforms lives one small victory at a time thank you thank you for your time Carla Davalos Carla Davalos Carla G come on up you have two minutes to speak when you begin sorry good afternoon board members and congrat congratulations to our newly elected board members and superintendent carbo my name is Gad Davalos and I am the proud product of La
063USD District 5 I'm also proudly serving as a third my third year as school leader in Kip Soul Academy on behalf of 460 students their family and our Community Partners in East LA I ask for your support in renewing kipo Academy's Charter for a 5-year term over the current Charter term we have established a track record of success in 2021 superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurman recognized kol Academy as a California distinguished school on the basis of test scores in ela math suspension rates and conditions of climate for learning nearly 21% of our students are English Learners so I'm especially proud to report that our school English learner progress indicator pass the state of California La USC in 2022 2023 and 2024 it is no secret that Kip Soul Academy like many public schools across
064the country has faced some challenges in addition to a once Ina generation pandemic academic performance has been impacted by ongoing teacher shortage here at Soul the teacher shortage was felt most acutely in math and science we take these challenges seriously our renewal petition includes detailed action plans to improve outcomes in ela math and attendance and I hope hope board members and staff will review these action plans closely we are seeing these action plans pay off today I am ecstatic to share that we are fully hired as this board knows the post-pandemic path to academic recovery is long but we have hired a team of Relentless Educators who see the unlimited potential in our East LA children and their commitment to our student is evident in our academic progress our students are now on track to
065make over a Year's worth of progress in ela and math on January 14th we ask board members to vote in favor of in our Charter so we can continue serving our community thank you thank you for your time I'm going to go ahead and call the next four folks Lilia Santos come on up Lilia are you here and then Tommy McConnell and then Shantel Wimberly and then David Richardson so we've got Lilia Tommy Shantel and David Lilia is going to speak in Spanish see okay so please put your hand up if you'd like to hear headsets to experience simultaneous translation and we'll pass out these headsets uh please put your hands up if you'd like to have translation and after we get these passed out we'll uh we'll begin okay gracias hola hi good morning
066everyone here honorable members of the Board of Education and uh congratulations to the new members thank you for your time and space my name is Lea Santa and I am a mother of two students at monu charer Academy Science and Arts I want to share a little bit about my story and the support that I have received from this school I came to this country four years ago and the first thing that I did was to enroll my children in school in which my family members and other people in my family uh attended and my home language is Spanish and for me the language was new but thanks to montue which created the uh program in 2019 that is intervention for those learning English as a second language which is given by Miss Martin and
067she is a student highlighted by the educational Council sharing her abilities and her learning with students that come from other countries with a different language my son came to this program with a student at the first level and during three years he has gone up to level three which puts him close to reclassification and he has learned to develop different abilities uh listening speaking and other programs Elon after the the school all of the students that need support in math and reading Arts music and science I there's also help them to integrate themselves as new citizens with respect to this country I also want to mention that it has helped the parents do through nutrition and help with free food and resources in the community I want to highlight that monteu Charter Academy uh deserves
068to continue because it has met the needs of all this students at the educational level along with the principal personnel and teachers they have done a good job in the education of all students I thank you for listening to me and and I know that you will uh make a good decision regarding to school and congratulations to the new members thank you for your [Applause] time uh Veronica Gentile come on up Veronica G good afternoon school board members and congratulations to all those today my name is Veronica jinti mariscal and I'm the parent of two recent graduates at Discovery Charter Prep graduating class 2022 and 2024 after graduation my daughter attended na University and my son is currently serving for the US Marine Corps I'm here today as in our community currently there is no
069room for small schools all we have in our areas is large classroom sizes and no individualism when we were looking for a high school in our area the draw was to Discovery simply for those small classroom sizes simply for the individualism that our our students of today deserve Discovery Charter is unique in comparison to any of those local high schools in our area again it has those small classroom sizes that we deserve and the individualism that our students strive for as they enter into our communities Discovery Charter serves Community by providing students with a strong personalized education plan and the drive to continue their education After High School years this gives the students the foundation that everyone's important and the school and its Administration is ready for the challenges to think differently Discovery has fostered
070Partnerships where the college uh the local community College Mission College has the ability now to come teach on our college campus our students no longer have to attend class in the evenings uh to ensure that some of their AA courses are completed they have the ability now to just have their uh courses taught to them on their campus Discovery listens and understands that every student parent and Community member is important and what the needs of our students future has evolved over time so when we need to think differently to be different over the years Discovery Charter has been able to create specialized classes such as Finance Management to help hedge against the struggle of our financial literacy again thank you and ask for the support of renewing Discovery Charter Preparatory so that every student ensures
071uh capacity to learn and importance of themselves in the communities they serve thank you for your time uh Tommy McConnell come on up Tommy and then Shantel um good afternoon honorable board president smarson board members and superintendent carvalo I am Tommy McConnell the proud leader of Kip Scholar Academy a college preparatory Middle School located in South Central Los Angeles in District One welcome to District 1 Miss hindy Nill um since our founding in 2012 KSA has been recognized as one of the top performing middle schools in California by US News and school and World Report our success is rooted in high expectations personalized instruction and a supportive inclusive environment for every scholar at KSA we focus on the whole child we understand that every scholar is unique and we provide the targeted support they need
072to thrive academically and personally our curriculum and school culture has been intentionally designed to celebrate diversity and create a sense of belonging ensuring every scholar sees themselves and their peers in their learning one of the things that sets KSA apart is that we are one of the few Performing Arts focused middle schools in Los Angeles every scholar learns an instrument or participates in choir promoting creativity self-expression confidence and character development alongside academic Excellence like all schools we Face challenges the disruptions caused by the lasting effects of the covid-19 pandemic have been significant to our community both academically and emotionally this the disruption to our Scholars learning and emotional well-being has been profound and we are still feeling its impact today but we are committed to helping our Scholars recover and Thrive through trauma informed practices
073focusing on mental health and reigniting our commitment to academic excellence in service of helping our students close academic gaps towards achieving academic Mastery today our respectfully request the renewal of Kip scholar Academy's Charter so that we can continue providing an inclusive iive highquality education that equips our students for success in school and life thank you for your time and consideration thank you for your time onal Shantel come on up good morning uh my name is Shantel Wimberly and I'm a proud educator at kid philosophers Academy but I also had a student who just formerly graduated from kid philosophers Academy she was in eth grade so I'll be speaking to that experience I currently serve as the ELD instructor Humanities content lead and I'm the cheer coach uh my daughter attended K philosophers Academy is now
074thriving as a high school student at Hamilton High School in Los Angeles California I am here today to express my strong support for the renewal of the charter Petition of Kit philosophers Academy in Watts California as both a teacher and a parent I have seen firsthand the incredible impact kit philosophers Academy has had on its students and mine I deeply believe in the mission and goals of this school which is why I entrusted Kip in my only child's education uh at Kip philosophers Academy my daughter not only received a rigorous academic Foundation but also gained confidence in leadership skills that have shaped her into the exceptional young woman that she is today she serves as she served as student body president for two consecutive terms seventh and eighth grade um and excelled academically she developed
075a profound love for reading and writing and these skills have carried her forward enabling her enabling her to thrive in her honors classes in high school Kip's dedication to personalized learning and student growth is unmatched thanks to this school's commitment my daughter consistently re has always read above grade level and has tested into the 80th percentile on her I ready Diagnostics Beyond academics Kip philosophers Academy provided a safe and nurturing environment it's a sanctuary for many students who may face challenges at at home and the school Fosters a sense of belonging security Community for both students and their families um ultimately what I want you guys to understand is I truly love kPa I truly love my school my daughter values our school um I could cry cuz that's just how much I really love
076um this charter school and what is done for me and my family thank you thank you for your time David Richardson David Richardson come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin understood you have two minutes to speak once you begin thank you very much good afternoon now to all of our board members and congrats to the new board members with a special shout out to Charlotte newbill uh board member of district one where Creed Academy has served thousands of kids and families over the last eight years my name is Dr Deandre bront and I'm here in three capacities today one as the friend of the founder of creed Academy Hattie Mitchell the former be board chair and as the senior adviser for Brotherhood Crusade I succinctly want to state that I
077unequivocally support the charter renewal of creed Academy the work that they are doing for atrisk and unhoused black and brown youth in South Los Angeles is unmatched because of this work the Brotherhood Crusade is a partner of creed Academy and they are addressing the needs of our youth today day today and in and day out so humbly we ask that you renew Creed Academy's Charter so they can continue the work our community so desperately needs thank you I'll now yield the remainder of my time and bring up Brett Mitchell co-founder and executive director of creed Academy good morning board members my name is Brett Mitchell I am the co-founder of creed Academy we are an elementary school that is designed to break the cycle of child homelessness we um are aware just as you are
078of the 177,000 students in L USD who identify as homeless unfortunately this number is growing by about 20% annually the number of students is also disproportionately black and brown of that 17,000 these are the same students that our school serves as a small charter school we are home to over 300 students 35% which also identify as homeless so what happens when a child is homeless how does it impact their education there are extreme physical mental and emotional challenges that these children endure I can continue correct uh please continue and then like thank you wrap up uh the time was conceded for the additional so the way that the time works and we're going to add this to your time is that if there's two minutes total the first minute went to the first individual and
079the second minute goes to you we don't add had more time but because you have more to say and we realize it's important please take another 30 45 seconds and then the audience now knows that when you see time you're just giving the remainder of what happened to be there so pleas please go ahead I'm also already speaking so I have two minutes of oh so you're also making presentation on behalf of the in addition to the public comment okay that's not clear to me so I guess I would say um there two minutes yeah okay thank you um so what is being done uh to address this issue fortunately LUSD allows charter schools to operate on the condition they have an approved condition that has an Innovative concept that's meeting a pressing need that
080pressing need is child homelessness in our school um we have developed a Harmony program uh our founder has dedicated her professional and academic career towards researching and designing something that will help the students in our city the harmony program is a restorative whole child concept that addresses all the basic needs that a student will need to be academically competitive we support housing counseling medical dental vision hearing uh food in security as well as transportation and we do that at the school at no cost to each of the families the harmony program is also working it has very promising results we have housed over 160 students and their families we have provided over 1,100 uh mental health supports to our students we have had a 1% or lower suspension rate over the last several years as
081well as having less than a 5% chronic absenteeism rate amongst our black and brown students when the question comes up as to who is doing this work we are extremely great F to have the opportunity through LAUSD to continue our Charter and continue doing this incredibly important work for our families and I would like to concede the rest of my time to Dr Hattie Mitchell thank you okay have 13 seconds just want to thank the the entire board uh just for your dedication to public education I know you all wouldn't be here if you didn't care in particular uh Mr Schmelson thank you for your ongoing support Sylvia Martinez um Miss uh charlet Newell thank you for coming to our school even before being sworn in Miss Patrice Marshall McKenzie as well as um Mr
082meloy who's not in the room uh about a month ago do you want to start the time or you're just going to give me well the time has now officially lapsed so there was the two-minute public speaking time and then additional two minutes to the and then I'm the a third speaker for two minutes a third for a single for a single Charter correct is that the rules can I get a can I get a amen oh you're Al are you all are you listed later as a public speaker no I should be listed right behind may I have your name Mitchell Hattie Hattie okay I have you as number 14 that's it's just out of order come back you're up here let's do it two minutes all right thank you please go ahead we'll
083restart the timer thank you and congratulations also so about a month ago uh my office manager went to lunch at Taco Bell across the street from our school on crch on 60th Street she noticed a boy School age about 10 years old he was in a school uniform sitting in a booth alone she thought it was odd but she left ate her lunch and decided she likes Taco Bell she went back the next day same boy same booth same uniform no parents and he's at Taco Bell so she calls me and she's like what do we do I said let's call the mom he has a phone let's figure out if we can bring him home and assess the situation we get permission we go to the house when we get to the house there
084are two other school-aged kids under nine in pajamas the house reeks of urine the kids have bite marks from bugs all over their legs and scars um there's absolutely no furniture in the home there's an air mattress in a bedroom that we can see from the living room and a Baby mattress in the living room the mom is in a wheelchair wearing a diaper and a t-shirt clearly unable to care for these kids and we complete um A needs assessment with that family the kids are malnourished um and they are enrolled in school but they're not attending school and no one's checking on them so they enroll in our school about a uh this is about a month ago so last week we do a follow-up on Saturday to check on the family same situation
085same issues we do a full comprehensive assessment to see what they need on our way out my uh staff member says that's what makes cre different we're trained to see kids like that somewhat agreeable I said no actually I don't think that's what makes cre different what makes cre different is that we actually took action and what would have been a DCFS call was actually support and rallying around a mom that needs help to care for her kids um there's no statute law or uh policy that says you have to care about kids but that's the principle that we live by each day and while I don't know the outcome of this situation I know that they're better off with us than without thank you thank you for your time okay [Applause] Monique Woodley are
086you here Monique W come on up and then after Monique will be Jude Pinkney and then Sean Hunsinger I'm GNA yield my time to our founder Mr fiser okay Mr fiser the two minutes is yours sir good afternoon Mr chairman members of the board I am Eugene Fischer chairman of the board of directors of was Learning Center Charter Schools I appear here today to request your support in approving our Charter renewal requests for another another 5 years of Educational Service to our community having opened the Watts Learning Center in 1997 this year represents the fifth five-year opportunity to request your formal Charter renewal Support over the past 25 years of our commitment to academic Excellence we strongly believe exposure and experiences are important to higher student performance with this in mind we have taken educational
087field trips to South Africa Sagal Ghana Brazil South uh Costa Rica and earlier this year our second trip to Egypt in 2025 we are planning our next passport to the World trip to Kenya we deeply appreciate our teachers administrators and staff as First Responders to a community educational crisis and their service to our families we appreciate our journey and see it as not as mer not as a but more as a marathon not as a Sprint where whether the learning loss impacts of the dev dating covid-19 Health pandemic as it hit hardest in our community we have responded to this crisis with added technology insights and improveed staff development methods we are looking forward to the results of these very aggressive and Innovative efforts in conclusion I thank you for your partnership with the L
088with the LUSD in mission for improved academic outcomes for all of our students that are entrusted to our care I respectfully ask for your support thank you for your time we appreciate your time are our staff members uh Jude Pinkney are you here Jude come on up you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin then Sean Hunsinger hello superintend dude can I just ask you thank you for coming could you just yeah lower that so we can hear your words thank you okay hello superintendent Carval and honorable board members my name is Jude and I'm a fifth grade student at Ivy bound Academy my family has been connected with Ivy bound since 2007 when my mom helped write the original mission statement today I want to talk about what makes Ivy bound such a
089special place there are so many things to love about our school first of all our teachers are fantastic Miss robertonson really cares about us and strives to make learning fun and exciting from cool science experiments interesting history lessons and fun art projects she always finds ways to make sure we are engaged and learning another thing I love about our school is the sense of community everyone here from the students to the staff is like one big family we help each other out celebrate each other's achievements and make sure that no one feels left out this supportive environment makes coming to school every day something we look forward to our school also has some really awesome programs and activities there are events throughout the year like movie Nights Thanksgiving feasts and restaurant nights additionally Ivy bound
090has many opportunities during school to give us the chance to learn new skills with leadership programs and our robotics Club lastly I love how our school encourages us to be ourselves we are all unique and our school celebrates that we are taught to respect each other's differences and to be kind and inclusive this helps create a safe and welcoming environment where everyone can thrive in conclusion Ivy bound Academy is special because of the amazing teachers the strong sense of community the fun programs our commitment to making a difference and the encouragement to be ourselves I'm really proud to be a student here and I hope you can see why our school is such a wonderful place thank you thank you for your time Johan come on up you have two minutes to speak once you
091begin good afternoon I actually go ahead and uh yield my time to the next speakers thank you uh Ruth kazad are you here Ruth C come on up you have two minutes to speak once you [Applause] begin this is my son good afternoon superintendent carvalo and members of the LA USD board my name is Rus casades and I'm the proud parent of a sixth grade student at Kip korason in Southgate I'm here today to voice my strong support for the renewal of the kip corason Charter my son has been a student at Kip korason for over six years and choosing this school for him has been one of the best decisions I've made from the start Kim korason has shown an unwavering commitment to supporting my son's academic and personal growth today he is not
092only thriving academically but also feels safe supported and valued as part of this school Community our journey has not been without challenges from a very young age my son faced significant struggles with behavioral and social emotional development at just 3 years old he was expelled from pre School a heartbreaking and isolating experience for any parent when I applied to Kip korason I was drawn to their philosophy of revolutionary love a commitment to changing the Status Quo by empowering children to reach their full potential Kip korason has more than lived up to this promise thanks to the Relentless support and belief korason staff my son has made remarkable progress so much so in fact that he no longer requires a 504 plan this mile stone is a testament to the dedication of the school's educator and
093their Educators and their ability to meet each child where they are they have always seen my son's potential and work tirelessly to help him succeed for that I am forever grateful at Kip corason my son is more than just a student ID number he is part of a family the administrators know his name they listen to my concerns and they are always just a phone call away I urge you to support the renewal of Kip kon's Charter every child in our community deserves a chance to attend a school like Kip korason a school that sees their value supports their growth and fosters a sense of belonging losing a school like this would be devastating for our community especially for families like mine who have experienced its life-changing uh impact firsthand thank you thank you for
094your time Brett Mitchell Brett Mitchell and I think you may have spoke already is part of that Collective thank you uh Deandra bremond are you here Deandra bremond come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin DeAndre are you here oh she was already she's part of that group as well okay thank you my apologies for the inefficiency uh that concludes uh the public hearing comment we have two folks on the report of Correspondence so that's um Veronica Gentile again I think you already spoke so that would that's uh not on the list and Mr Juan mandhi to speak on Tab 14 are you here Mr Mandi I thought I saw you earlier Mr Juan mandhi are you here all right and so it's now appropriate to take a motion to to
095vote on the consent calendar move it moved by Miss gones I'm so sorry actually I was hoping to make a comment just on my resolution which is on the consent calendar of course if I can temporarily take my motion off the table um I just wanted to note for everyone that we did bring an amended version of the computer science education resolution that removes the reference to an annual report so that's the amended version that you have at the table um I'm really excited about this resolution just uplifting our District's commitment to Computer Science Education for all in LUSD by 2025 and to promote the great Computer Science Education week activities that we offer at so many of our schools um through this resolution we are also encouraging the state to continue making progress to
096build the pipeline of computer science teachers um by streamline streamlining the process to become a computer science teacher and supporting a diverse pipeline of Educators we know that this is a shortage of computer science Educators is uh creating a barrier to access for many of our families um finally I just wanted to encourage all of our schools to participate in this week's events um including the hour of code as well as teen Tech live which is being hosted at Valley Oak Center for enriched studies in the valley voes um it's an interactive virtual event that our VOA students will be broadcasting themselves um and principles and teachers can find that in the computer science education week toolbox um there will be some exciting guests and students will have an opportunity to dig into technology from
097various Fields um with that I hope my colleagues will support this resolution solution and I can move the consent agenda outstanding do we have a second I'll second okay by board president schmon it might appear to the audience that we lack a quorum but we have one member who is remote and the other members though not offsite are probably grabbing a bite to eat so if I could uh have your Indulgence for a moment I'm going to go see if we can here's here's one I'm going to go see if we can grab uh one or two more from the um they might be eating so I'll be back in one second and Miss gones let me add that yesterday I was at uh one of my schools um we had uh coding day at
098the school and it was fantastic it was really really fantastic I just want you to know that it's working and it's going well and that was silven park by the way okay your former school right uh Miss GES would you allow me to co-sponsor that resolution please yeah I welcome your thank you thank you okay uh we're going to now take uh the um to the role on the consent calendar it was moved by Miss gones and seconded by Mr schmon uh Miss Hy Nill yes Dr Ras Mr Schmelson Mr Melo oh I'm sorry that's right Mr Melo yes Miss grigo yes Miss gonz yes Miss Ortiz Franklin yes board president schron yes okay and Miss Lopez Cortez Cortez Lopez sorry yes that was a yes would also like at it as a co-sponsor okay
099thank you and then uh we have Dr revas uh still grabbing some lunch and she'll come back and Lodge her vat so on to the next piece of business okay so we have for discussion tab one tab five and tab 11 so under tab one we have um Mr Mel I believe leave questions on one we have questions on one and we can either take the public there's one public comment okay okay and then let's see in person is Sophie Ryan are you here I thought I saw Miss Sophie Sophie Ryan I do not see you now uh Dr revas we just took the consent calendar vote would you like to logge your vote Yes and it's a yes it's a yes okay the consent calendar is unanimously approved and closed I'll check online I
100have her I have her listed as in person yeah she was here and I do not have her online so uh we have uh discussion item tab one Mr melvoin had questions and I believe Dr Ras had questions and then the chair will recognize you as we go along okay Mr meloy thank you uh board president I have a question on oneg which is the um partnership for Student Success bench and I don't know if that's if Mark's here or okay superintendant but um the this is was born out of a board resolution a few years ago it's evolved we have a number of great Partners on this bench and I appreciate that we're prioritizing our priority both capital P in terms of the priority schools but also s High and highest need schools um
101but I'm also wanted ensure that schools who aren't on the list who have been contracting with some of these partners for things like computer science appropo of the resolution we just passed um or Arts still have an opportunity uh even if it's with their own discretionary dollars to partner with them and so my question is um how many partners are on the proposed bench that aren't on any other benches and based on that is there a way to still ensure that schools with their own funding can access those Partners hey good afternoon interim chief curent officer Matt fredman um so right now there's roughly 12 vendors that aren't on um any other bench uh we can provide a list to you after uh a little bit later today um and specific to the question around
102using um the bench without uh the pfss funding um so that that funding is allocated specifically to that program so if a vendor or excuse me a School site wants to use one of those vendors they can certainly go through the the typical procurement process so I guess my question and maybe if we don't have answer right now maybe we can Circle back is that the um for those 12 vendors if so those and just to clarify those are 12 vendors who are on this bench but no other District bench right so if we've already vetted them I'm just trying to save the school sites some headaches by saying like do they have to go through that informal RFP process and select you know have three biders to select one or for those you know
103um vendors who are on this bench uh can a school if they're using their discretionary dollars just maybe have a streamlined process to partner given we've already vetted them as a district so two types of situations number one if they already if they've already been vetted than they are on any bench with the school district uh whe It's associated with this uh source of funding or not uh principles would be okay to contract with them without having to do the okay if they're not however then they would have to go through a modified simplified um informal RFP conducted at the school site great so so cuz there are two things that we've done different with some of these Partners one is putting them on the bench and then the other is the matching fund so
104let's say if you're School a who a few years ago could apply for a partner and get matching funds now you're no longer on the list I understand and I'm not advocating for the matching component because we want to prioritize schools based on Equity but if you're a school that that that is still interested in contining with that partnership what I hear the superintendent saying is with your own discretionary dollars you can partner and you don't need to go through an RFP process if they're on one of our benches if they're on the bench great okay that's what I was hoping for thank you both I believe Dr Ros you had a question on one my question is for 1 a the um Legal Clinic Services um the the reason I just want to bring
105this up is just you know for for public record and for all of our schools to know uh given the increase in school requests for Legal Services um I've been receiving a lot of requests from a lot of my schools even schools not in my own Board District um due to the heightened threats to Immigrant families under the new you know elect Administration how is the district tracking and sharing a comprehensive list of legal Partnerships andus by Board District including the specific services offered to address these urgent needs of our of our students and our families I can address the procurement item itself um the follow-up items we can get back to you on but for the procurement item this will expand to 18 schools who will have services available to them we started with
106RFK and the UCLA clinic in 2016 and now we're ready to further and expand services and referrals to these 18 schools at that site depending on how it goes with UCLA and what we see in the different communities then we can look to expand even more more depending on UCLA's availability um the determination of need and cost to the board members question uh considering the likely significant increase in demands uh or need for legal assistance uh particularly understanding the political climate we're living under just yesterday I participated in a community conversation with state legislators uh with Advocates uh with City leadership and philanthropic entities to address just that to really create the Clearing House in a community where the referral process for families experiencing this type of situation would be expedited with clear understanding depending
107on where you live where the closest agency that could provide services to you also we began the conversation uh regarding rapid fire uh response to possible law enforcement Federal entities uh taking action in and around our schools which we obviously will partner with h with the city and other entities so it is being coordinated at the community level and as we land additional information and concrete plans we will provide them to the board and do we have plans to assist our principles um as their families and students are reaching out saying um for instance I had one in one of my schools where the father was detained uh by ice and they reached out to support so is there a guideline for principles letting them know you know what to do in case a situation
108may may happen to one of their family members um yeah so I think they need the support certainly so uh as you recall one of uh former president Goldberg's resolutions addressed specifically the training for the staff uh we are in a final Thrills of preparing the documentation to uh train our our staff across the board in all schools with specific information on how to deal with a variety of different cases that I believe our staff will will face and by the way not just principal assistant principles really staff as a whole including the first person who may be in the office who may be the first person of contact with the federal entity and um the referral process that I mentioned earlier that is part of the training so the agencies are available whether through
109the school system or through Partnerships uh entities agencies are available to answer the legal questions and and also provide legal services to to those individuals great and I hope we're also working with um City city hall because I know they're also um um you know coming up with guidelines and and getting resources together so we can so so we're not working in silos and we're all sharing all the resources to support our students and I know that ogc has also been exploring potential Partnerships uh particularly with you know um colleges and other organizations and I know and I and I thank you all for working for that and I know it's been long because I've been here for two years and I I've been advocating for the past two years and I know facing challenges
110and funding and resources so I hope we can work proactively in addressing those challenges so we can make readily um expand the services and Partnerships for our students so so please thank you board member grigo yes I remember back in 2016 um or 2017 we held a series of know your rights workshops at every school right in January and so I'm wondering when we will start doing that for our families as a lot of not only our students but their family members um need to be supported with knowing their rights and what they can and cannot do uh so I'm wondering when that will start and then two um like uh Dr Rivas mentioned the Partnerships with other organizations I think that's very key there are a lot of of knowledge and experience in our
111city and working with groups who have been doing this work and the research on that would be great and part partnering our school sites with those local organizations would also be um good for uh for our community schools our schools and their communities so I'm wondering if that's part of what's going to be rolled out in January um it is uh and to to address at greater level details uh we have Mr Andreas ch a chief of operations uh so to the point that Dr Rivas made earlier and he just made board member Grio obviously we cannot do this alone uh we believe and this has been uh part of the conversation in fact just yesterday with the Dozen the two dozen are so leaders at the same table we believe that the Lion Share
112of potential Federal actions will not be taking place in in in our schools it will be at size of employment of parents um certainly outside of our jurisdiction with deep implications for our kids because obviously who will be there when the child arrives home who will be there to pick up the child as they leave school so whether it happens in school which will not happen or outside of school the implication will still be felt that's why uh we are in deep collaboration particularly with the mayor and and her staff the city of Los Angeles as well as other municipalities philanthropic entities who have a deep interest in this advocacy groups state legislators uh who we learned yesterday uh are intent on passing legislation that reaffirms the rights of uh individuals in our state regardless
113of immigration status and in fact we are pushing some some of those ourselves but to give you the details about when the training will take place this by the way will be more than Town Hall meetings these are informational educational sessions specific to the point you just made for people first and foremost to understand what their personal rights are what their civil rights are what their constitutional rights are well- defining law pler versus Department of Education 1982 declares uh compellingly just like the Constitution under the equal protection Clause that our kids regardless of immigration status have a right to a free public education so we're going to use a law to protect the legal rights of our kids everyone ought to know what those rights are and be able to recite them very very quickly
114and everyone ought to be able to know who to refer someone to in case there is an imminent or threatened action Andreas thank you superintendent uh certainly couldn't say it better than you already said it but uh to vice president rias's question to board member G Diego's question absolutely we're actually finalizing this week the schedule for trainings for schools as we all know we will be back on Monday the 6th so we will be doing trainings for administrators beginning on Wednesday the 8th we're looking at a number of different resources at the base level we're looking at the reference guide that continues to establish and promote that our schools are safe zones so that our administrator and our school staff do know how to respond if and when an individual presenting themselves as a representative
115of Immigration Services shows up at their counter so we'll have those resources similar to 2017 and this is what uh board member GGO alluded to uh we have a lot of resources with our Community Partnerships and so on uh Sarah Mooney Antonio Placencia that team has been working on those resources so what you'll see at every school will be on that week initially we will train administrators then the week of the 13th aka the second week that back every single staff member will be trained so we'll start there at a faculty meeting of course we'll have our staff we know that not all of our staff members attend faculty meetings because of different schedules so we'll ask principes to also ensure that they train our campus AIDs that may be gone already by the time
116of faculty meeting of course our community reps will be one of our Point people on this so we'll have that training we will also host coffees with the principal for our communities for our parents so they may learn resources we're looking at a high school component for students that we still kind of mulling over what that piece would look like we certainly understand that particularly with that age group those are kids that can advocate for themselves but we're trying to navigate what that would look like in an educational space and then of course we will augment all that with trainings and supports at the regions we're being very deliberate about identifying for our folks who the point persons are or actually let me take that back to a singular who the point person is at
117a school site what we don't want to happen is that when a parent or a family is in a space of need that they're told oh for this you need to go to this person and for this you need to go to this person we want it to be one individual who is helping them as needed you can share these trainings with us so as um community members or stakeholders approach us we can let them know this is a process and also direct them to the correct person I mean I'm sure the principal we can direct them to principles but at least let them know what the process is so that we're also informed as well absolutely board president board vice president any other comments go ahead Miss GES just a quick follow question um
118uh as part of the conversations are we also looking to potential funding opportunities that can help support these Services I believe that the state is contemplating some additional resources as well as the County of Los Angeles um so just want to see whether those might help us expand our efforts and ensuring that schools are eligible entities for these funds is really important as we provide these direct supports to our families so there was some uh light conversation uh last night at this this meeting I referenced about some additional resources from the state we certainly do not expect any resources from the federal government but any any available State funding whether it's a categorical direct or competitive will be uh will be taking advantage of those opportunities it was the County of Los Angeles that's I
119think made an additional action to allocate funding for immigrant families so perhaps we can also add them to our ongoing collaboration efforts any senior staff oh board M cores comment on the um roll out of how high schools will take particularly in place on how to address these needs of of immigrant families I would like to add that we I have seen specifically within the superintendent advisory Council how peer-to-peer mentorship work has worked greatly not only within our students but also through social and emotional well-being um the peer mentorship network with the well-being Center showcase that lusc schools have been proven very effective and I look forward to seeing how peer-to-peer mentor ship can work especially um with students and in high school who have a desire to continue advocating for their school communities and
120I also look forward to seeing how social and emotional well-be will play a factor in the in the distribution of these funds for immigrant families because as we know and seen these repercussions being showcased in our students are traumatic migrant students have a higher chance of developing PTSD and Refugee students have a higher chance of developing uh mental disorders I look forward to seeing how those play a role in the allocation of resources thank you Miss Cortez any senior staff want to add anything more to this discussion we're good thank you board member GGO for bringing up this discussion Point really very timely I'm glad you did that thank you thank you so much okay if that concludes the discussion on the item should we move the item to vote Yes moved by uh Dr
121Ras I'll second seconded by uh Miss gonz uh Miss Andy nubel yes dras yes Mr schms I'm sorry I'm still not used to the board presidency I apologize uh Mr melvoin yes Miss Grio yes Miss gones yes uh Miss ortis Franklin yes and board president smurls yes and student member Cortez Lopez yes that's seven eyes okay we have a Time certain of 1M that we are 14 minutes late on so I think we should get to it get to it now um uh Miss gones yeah um well I am excited to bring forward uh readers to leaders a resolution focused on literacy um early literacy is one of our main goals as a district and the district has been doing tremendous work in our classrooms our Educators have been working so hard to help ensure
122that our stud students develop that critical right of being able to read um so that they can reach their academic goals and be ready for the world um today's resolution is really about continued focus and energy to those efforts in alignment with our strategic plan um ensuring that we are taking stock and putting a spotlight on our literacy efforts ensuring we can monitor our progress and close gaps that may exist for our most historically underserved students and importantly something really critical for me as a mom of Elementary age students is support our families as partners in our our work we know that our parents are children's first teachers and are critically important in developing reading as a skill um so I'm very much proud of the uh goals that we have set and the progress
123that we've made and I hopeful that this will help continue to push us um to reach even higher for our students and their literacy development um with that I'm hoping when Mr McLean can get back that we can hear um from our speakers on the resolution we have seven speakers one call in six of which are here in person so I'll call in on the four folks first who are in person with the first person please come up to the podium uh where the microphone is located and the following three just being uh ready to go so Mar Maria Lisa Palma I see her out there please come on up then Martha Mesa and then Rosio lorsa and then vieta Montero good afternoon and welcome to the new board members and the new officers uh
124for the next year my name is Maria Luisa Palma I am here today representing oada a nonprofit organization which is focused on improving parent involvement and removing barriers to that involvement uh thank you board member gones for this resolution to advance Literacy for every child and I seriously hope that this aren't these will not just be empty words but that there will be actions to back those words to remove the barriers from keeping families from accessing understanding and acting on their children's true level of proficiency in reading but not just reading also math hopefully we know that parents experience great inflation they frequently see grades of A's and B's on their report card but then see that they're not proficient below grade level on their exams smarter balance and I ready why does this disconnect
125happened I asked this very question of Mr carvalo uh back in September when he appeared on the live Town Hall Mr carvalo did not answer the reason for this disconnect and I hope that this resolution can move us forward to keep that from happening I hope that if you do create a family guide that you will have a method for parents to be able to truly interpret the score uh for the I ready not just with vague words like approaching or needs Improvement for their grade level but to tell them actually how many grade levels they are below something like this this scale exists for the I ready exams it tells a parent exactly of course we had to go find this on an iady publication this isn't from the district website or anywhere anywhere
126that can be found here to tell a parent based on the scaled score exactly what grade level they child is at um at the State Board of Education we have now found that they are attempting to change the description of the labels on the smarter balanced exams Le level two is proposed to be called foundational instead of nearly met level one will now be inconsistent instead of not met so these factors will continue to obfuscate a child's true level of proficiency in exams please consider that as you consider this resolution Miss gones thank you thank you for your time Martha Mesa Martha M Rosio Ela no Eng oh English okay no need for the translation thank you very much the two minutes is yours thank you very much hello honorable member board member and superintendent
127carvalo my name is Martha Mesa I am a past PR member of Thea ssse and Ela comedies in my children's school I have two children a daughter who graduated from Garfield Garfield High School and now attends Cate Los Angeles and a son who is currently a 10 grader at Garfield High School I am here today to express my strong support for the readers to leaders resolution as a leaders Ambassador with families in a school I know how critical reading is for a child's future this issue is personal to me I recently learned that my daughter has dyslexia looking back I realized she was a struggling reader all along her teacher said she was doing fine but she wasn't my daughter recalls working three times as hard as her classmates just to keep up especially with
128comprehension sadly sadly she thought this was normal what made a difference for her was my involvement at home I have spent hours helping her with reading and writing but not every family has the times or resources to provide this level of support what if I had been working full-time I thought she would have graduated ready for college this is why I believe this resolution is so important parents need tools timely updates on their children's progress and guidance to recognize issues like dyslexia early early support can be the difference between a child who struggles and one who thrives thank you all for listening to me thank you for your time uh Rosa are you here come on up uh Miss Lara is gonna speak in Spanish so if you'd like to hear what she's saying in
129English as she's speaking Spanish please put your hands up and we can give you these translation headsets uh hands up no one upstairs okay gracias okay graas thank you to all the members of the board and all the new uh new members my name is Rosio lorsa I'm a mother of two students in the district I'm grateful of Miss Gess for taking this initiative of leader readers and leaders it's so important not just for me but so many students and so many families of LUSD so I will give my time to the director of Reed LA and thank you again for the association she has for our voice to be heard in person uh I'm speaking today as a representative of the r l campaign as well as a former English language learner and first
130uh generation daughter of immigrants who now has the privilege to stand before you and you know support in support of the readers to leaders resolution uh we'd like to thank superintendent carvalo Dr estr and Dr bz for their leadership and leading the way in addressing the literacy crisis uh with bold systemic Solutions you know the resolution uh reflects the fundamental truth that literacy is the foundation of success for every student in every subject and in every future career yet in La USD we know that too many students are still notg grading at rate level with only 42.1% meeting or exceeding Ela standards and the data is even worse for our low-income students and so we know the consequences right uh who students who are not proficient uh readers by the end of third grade are
131eight times less likely to graduate high school and again this is just this isn't just an education issue but it's a civil rights issue and so the readers to leaders resolution really provides a road map to address this challenge emphasizing the need for the district to stay on the course on ensuring evidence based literacy instruction And Timely and accessible data sharing and family engagement uh you know as someone who's deeply involved in the literacy efforts I can tell you that firsthand and you know you're witnessing with our parents here that we're eager to support and collaborate passing their solution send a clear message that La USD is committed to a strategic plan of academic excellence and engagement in collaboration thank you all thank you for your time thank you uh vieta Montero Violeta Montero com
132M up you have two minutes to speak when you begin good afternoon uh hello honorable board members and superintendent carvalo my name is vieta Montero and my son is a seven grader at Canoga Park Middle School I am very passionate um about reading I have always tried to insist that passion in my son but I noticed that the joy he once had for reading was sleeping away this year I discovered that my seven grader was reading at a second grade level my son is very smart and his teacher reassured me that he was doing well so you can imagine my sh when I learned the truth I immediately set Solutions and I am proud to say that with the right resources and intervention he's now reading at a sixth grade level he's made incredible progress
133because he is capable and we act early enough to make a difference but what if I have never learned about his struggle what if I couldn't find the resources to support him this resolutions this resolution ensures that families don't face those what ifs by prioritizing early identification regular progress updates and the tools we need to support our children s success I urge you to support the readers to leaders resolution parents need timely information and resources to act early and prevent challeng challenges from becoming barriers thank you for commit for your commitment to advise advising litery so all children can reach free and Thrive thank you thank you for your time Olga Corona de la Cruz Olga oh I'm sorry you joined the I apologize and Maria da Ortiz come on up you have two minutes
134to speak when you begin Miss Ortiz is going to speak in Spanish so if you'd like to hear what she's saying in English uh please use the translation headsets put your hand up we got one in the back good afternoon to everyone welcome to the new board members and to those who were reinstated I hope every year is a new hope to start a new well I am here in support of this resolution because we know that one of the tools that our kids need to have is the ability to read so we need to develop strategies that are specific and efficient so that our kids can read as a mother who had a child with dyslexia I learned so many strategies in order to help my son my daughter who was an English learner
135was able to pass elpac did not P passed to the alternative Alpac worked very closely with Specialists teachers and with different Personnel who had she had to work with in that aspect I want to recognize that not all the people are are able to with the knowledge but I specifically would like to ask Miss gones that she please expand it to the strategies available for parents and with the science of reading and the methodology oron Willingham because if we don't put a parents as as the knowledgeable Associates in this academic development we can't connect then the class with the home so I beg Miss Kelly gonz since I'm here to work I love to work I'm fascinated by reading I worked in Franklin as a volunteer doing open cord to show strategies to parents in
136order to to F reading so that it could be a model of reading because we can't work with reading being a punishment so teaching the parents can't be go read but have a designated time to read and work one of the strategies that worked a lot with my daughter is that I would have her read and then after she read she would read and write it that's a strategy and it was very efficient just like repetitions just like also working with the colors lots of ways thank you and have a great afternoon that that concludes public comment um there's some board board input I would like to express first of all gratitude on behalf of the student body uh for his resolution and request to be asked uh added as a co-sponsor it is vital
137to address literacy needs through assessments to increase student achievements through the examinations of ready and smarter balance I would like to see how to expand this resolution towards nationally recognized standardized exams many of my constituents have expressed a need for enhanced preparations especially for example like SAT and ACT in the years of the pandemic many universities and colleges who decided to go test optional in the year 2020 decided to reinforce mandated test mandatory for the admission cycle many students were not aware of these changes and required adequate material support in this area besides online modules and admission fee wavers and increase awareness from the teachers and administrators uh many of our uh High School age children primarily Juniors and seniors who take this exam are primarily lwi income in our district and they need help
138accessing in-person individualized support for this test preparation early on and I look forward to seeing how this increased access to nationally standardized testing can improve the rates of college admissions within our students and increase awareness overall about college admissions primarily for our low-income and minority students thank you you I I'll thank um student board member cores Lopez and um I think your your comments are really helpful and hopefully Dr Bas and Dr STA and the implementation of the resolution can look at um our high school students and how we can ensure they receive the support that they need as well thank you go ahead yeah I mean just I want to thank the parents for their advocacy and being here and appreciate what you all had to say also Echo what our student board member
139said and just thank Miss gonz I'd also love to be added as a co-sponsor thanks thereo yes I want to thank parents as well and I'm I'm very excited to see your enthusiasm and desire to be involved in your children's reading uh progress I think it's wonderful that uh you you want to be so involved um but I'm wondering in this resolution is there any space for any Al alternate assessments beyond what I'm assuming is probably I ready since it is mentioning beginning middle or end of year so is there space for any other types of Assessments that teachers might give students since I ready is a one-time uh moment it's a moment in time when children take that test um so can I don't know if that's possibility and then um the other thing
140is in terms of uh supporting parents with supporting their children right um how can we also make that accessible to parents who may not be able to for whatever reasons may not be able to do that kind of work at home with their children um I've worked with many parents who are not able to spend even 10 minutes not because they don't want to but because just capacity either they're working two jobs and have other children or there's just a million things million reasons why that can't happen so how can we make this accessible to those families who cannot do it board member if I may start and and then I'll hand it over to Dr by is um definitely in our curriculum as well as our intervention and supplemental tools we have other resources
141that teachers can use to assess the progress of our students based on grade level standards or as well as their actual skill need so she can share a little bit more about that so we do have those resources already exist so that's such a great question cuz we need to Leverage those and then also we can speak to more of some of the work that's already happened on improving some of the communication tools we have around I and I think what we've heard here today there's a lot more opportunity to do that so I'm going to hand it over to Dr Bas absolutely a good afternoon everybody my name is Francis bias Chief academic officer so we do provide um various types of Assessments to determine the students's reading ability such as Dynamic indicator of
142basic early literacy skills which is called Dibbles and it's taken as a progress monitoring tool as well um the corrective reading is a a program that's being used in the secondary level that also has um some assessments some screeners to see how students are performing in the intervention programs uh and then we also have other digital tools that are used as well that can determine um students who participate in tutoring those tutoring providers also provide uh types of screeners and assessments to to uh check the students progress towards meeting uh grade level learning so absolutely there are alternate alternatives for to determine to see how students are progressing in their reading of course there's Running Records and so yes there are alternatives um in addition to I ready um with respect to the communication that
143goes out to parents uh during parent conferences this uh this semester we provided at schools with a toolkit to make that communication more seamless and so that it's more understandable for parents the document that was referenced earlier um actually it it exists in the in the parent portal so parents do have access to that in the parent portal we provided that toolkit so teachers could have communication with the parents on how to how to uh read those reports in the I what do they mean how to help our students improve uh and giving them those those tools we have a lot of strategies at this time to help our students as the middle of the Year assessment results come out we're going to have an additional resource for schools to see exactly what to do
144um to mitigate the learning the uh anecdote that was provided earlier today about the student who was performing you know at a second grade level now it's at sixth grade that is what we're seeing when we have predictive tools and then that's what we're seeing when we have interventions and supports that we can provide students right away and I'll just say I think for my part the the resolution doesn't specify any particular it doesn't name a particular assessment because I think we do want to be Universal and include all forms of assessment the goal is to be able to see that progress districtwide and make sure we're seeing how different student groups uh progress and then also for families to get that information in a way that they can understand I know even me as
145a parent those reports are not necessarily accessible to understand what does this mean and what can I do to help um so I appreciate the work that the division of instruction is already doing to help make that um more understandable um and then I hope that the guide will also address kind of a spectrum of lightest touch you know if you're a family who doesn't have a lot of time to support your child what are high impact strategies you could use versus you know if you have more more opportunities what what could you do with time um but I thank you for the question so sorry go ahead please I just had comment to the guide and I think uh Kelly appreciate you making a comment to that because wanted to make sure the guide
146because we don't want to assume I mean and then often we say you know our parents are able to read this guide to be able to figure out how to help their students and often time that is not always the case and so to make sure that we get feedback on making sure that the guide is appropriate for some of our families who may not be capable and able to do what we're assuming that they can do and then just um just the effectiveness of those guides to make sure that we do get that feedback because I think that's very important in order to see um Fidelity in US putting this out and us getting the input back so and I do want to add to be a coast master of that thank you great
147so happy to have you and um yes that's we definitely mentioned accessible and digestable to parents in their home language was a key portion of the guy I think that ongoing feedback will be super helpful thank you Dr Rivas well thank you Miss gones for bringing this forward um I I just have a question because I know you mentioned here and one of your whereare as is that the district has embraced the science of learning of reading so wondering what that really what that what that means um have we fully implemented it or or Miss bias or uh Dr estr can let us know um the implementation of of Science and reading here at the district Yes actually actually we have implemented the science of reading it began a few years ago uh the structured
148literacy approach has been provided through multiple Prof professional developments and it's scaled up now with the district-wide implementation of the core knowledge language arts reading program which is uh which embeds a science of reading it is a lot more um understandable to teachers uh two years ago we provided professional development for all of our teachers on the science of reading and then last year on the science of writing so that teachers understand how to incorporate literacy uh instruction into their various disciplines uh in addition to that we've been able to provide sessions on ort Gillingham uh and and get teachers certified and we've also offered a micro credential for teachers and reading so it's all based on the science of reading and how has science of reading been differentiated for English Learners or emergent bilinguals
149want to ensure that the science of reading uh really emphasize the language development as well science of reading is not just phonics and phic awareness it's also listening speaking and vocabulary and comprehension and that's why that uh the current reading program that we have captures and and provides students that instruction in all of those areas so uh we really want to emphasize that and clarify because there's a um we want to clarify that that the structured literacy approach the science of reading is not just phonics it's not just foundational reading it's comprehension our English Learners especially if their home language is uh Spanish in particular that easily translates into English they can decode the words but may not understand them and we don't want to create that misconception so that's why that language and vocabulary
150comprehens ension are really important in science of reading in our dual dual language um practitioners or teachers are also receiving training to help them in in implementing that as well that's correct yes yes they are and have you been seeing results since um the implementation of scier reading or also in combination with structured literacy we have seen an improvement um and structured literacy is is the science of reading uh and so we're what we're seeing is that students are improving in their reading skills and in comprehension and in vocabulary uh so we're seeing lots of benefits there and of course it was also seen in our Smarter Balance assessment results recently so the information here and the resolves um that m going is is which I I totally agree and and support is is will
151be providing us more data and information as to the implementation of the you know the literacy we'll go deeper program deeper in that okay well thank you um I just wanted to understand that because um I know that throughout California there are only very few districts who have fully implemented science of reading and I know that there was a bill by Miss Rubio that was did not pass uh legislation and I know it was um opposed by CTA and also some um English learner organizations and um and so I've you know just been doing some research as to some of their I guess concerns with scier reading so I just that's why I wanted to ask those questions to get that um fully understood so thank you I I support and um and I'm thankful
152for this because you know as an English learner myself um I learned by both languages my mom was teaching me Spanish well at the same time I was learning English so I was able to my brain was wired differently so all of our brains are wired differently so we're thinking in both languages at the same time and so um you know literacy is it's so important I know I definitely learned by reading a lot of books which I'm glad that the P Los Angeles Public Library is endorsing this because our libraries need to be uh fully accessible to all of our students and and then just having the joy of books um so I appreciate um this um resolution particularly with providing some detailed information and I'm sure that um we'll be briefed on the
153proc on the um I guess the progress of the data to come so I look forward to seeing the data thank you okay thank you thank you again miss gones for this resolution and this always gives me a chance to talk about our school libraries and how important School libraries are to all of our children you would be shocked when you go to an elementary school and see how many kids are in the school library especially during uh recess and lunchtime some kid you know I believe in socialization kids should get along and talk to each other but sometimes you just want to be quiet and sit down and read a book and our library AIDS in our elementary schools are the perfect people for engaging children to read and it's been shown that kids
154who read often their scores improve greatly so I'm going to encourage all my principles out there you should have an elementary library in your school and I'm encouraging you to have a full-time Library Aid in your school very very important very very important so thank you thank you Miss GES thank you and I just wanted to add I think the point about our multilingual Learners is is very important and um they are specifically called out in a couple of different places including as we're supporting families we should be supporting um the unique needs of their students including if they're a child with disabilities if they have dyslexia if their kids are multilingual Learners so I'm hopeful that that will ensure that the support we provide is really differentiated I know we also have missa Stevens
155here I don't know if she might be able to speak to um just the ways in which we are um ensuring that our English learners and I multilingual learner students um are supported as part of this uh transition uh to structured literacy thank you Miss gones yes we work very closely with Miss B's team we're working diligently on the CK portion called language Studio which is a designated ELD block that protected time that is to support specific language needs for the variety of students and we also have great work happening in our senior high schools as well with designated ELD but we work very closely together training everything thank you okay thank you very much Mr McLean uh I believe we need to log a motion into second for the I will move the resolution
156fantastic second Miss gon has moves Mr Melo seconds um and now the vote uh Miss handy nubil stepped away uh Dr revas yes uh Mr mvo yes Miss grigo yes Miss gones yes Miss orti Franklin yes board president schmon yes and student board member Cortez Lopez yes okay we'll come back to miss Hy new bill uh so this item certainly passes uh we have some folks who have been waiting patiently as a result of a small clerical error in my office in order to give some public comment I apologize to my high viz folks um please come on up and introduce yourselves you have one minute to each to speak under tab uh 13 so I apologize for for the miscommunication from my office and we're gonna we're going to set the clock at at
157uh four folks for for one minute each there we go good afternoon I think uh we're the people that are keeping you all from lunch so it would be brief I'm Steve bar I'm the founder of green. public schools and um and future as now um this is a unique CTE partnership some of you um uh that were here uh last year we presented the school a Partnerships um CTE school with um IB Local 11 and La um Trade Tech and and then it was inspired by two great um um leadership offers one by the superintendent um who came in and threw a big moonshot right away and said we want to Electrify and and get us off of fossil fuels as fast as possible and then uh and our former board president Jackie Goldberg
158who every time a charter would come up would say hey did you ever think about being Affiliated I wow that that's something I used to talk years ago with with uh with Governor RoR about like how do we become part of of the team here and not be us against them and so this is a school that um take the best of um what ibw local 11 does and they're they're Second To None uh Apprentice program in in in Commerce a lot of you have been to that that amazing training site and um professors at La um Trade Tech who get kids who come in at all kinds of different levels can we prepare them better if we're going to do college prep we got to be serious about CTE we should do CTE prep
159and also thank you Dr reers for the inspiration um in your green committee um we're going to create a climate core by those most affected by the the pollution thank you come on up you have one minute to share good afternoon committee my name is Chris Rosalez proud 15-year member of ibw Local 11 International Brotherhood of electricians we represent um all the union Electrical Workers Across the Nation and in Canada um we are in strong support of uh future is now uh future is now technical education prep um as a as a native of e La um I can I can definitely attest to uh growing up in the ' 90s there wasn't too many Charter Schools or prep schools or or programs like this kind of geared to um aiming Us in the right
160direction the youth right um You don't have too many choices in a neighborhood like that it's either go to school to be a doctor or a teacher or join a gang right so um something like this I think is a great benefit and not only is it um is it a it's a it's a great resource but it's a great way to develop initiatives um that promote job creation and Workforce Development so thank you thank you for time how you doing everybody first of all thank you for what you do for our children on here seems like you guys really care um my name is Benjamin Frank I'm a 14-year member of international brother of Electrical Workers we do a lot of work with uh with the youth out here especially disadvantaged children uh I'm
161a proud father of three um two of them that went through Charter Schools two that are now going into college and a younger one's probably going to be a Tradesman so um we advocate for these schools and what steveen Mar are doing and uh with Finn's CTE this is a this is stuff that that really give you know our kids a why and gives them a career instead of a job so we really look forward to working with them and having a direct pipeline to our apprentiship so thank you appreciate your time thank you uh good afternoon everybody uh my name is marra hildr thank you my name is Myra hildr a 30 years member for I IW uh Local 11 uh as a matter of fifth grader uh and 11th grader I would love
162them to uh to see me follow my footstep but we'll see about that um my 11th grader is actually taking construction class in her high school and it gives her a confidence and a safety and an understanding the safety part of the construction uh trade uh I think the uh program is actually amazing learning trade during a high school will acel accelerate their inclusion into the construction Workforce so in 10 years or sooner you will see them uh succeed and running a job in a future thank you thank you for your time and I apologize for any inconvenience that I have caused okay that uh concludes everything except uh item number five the tab five 2024 25 first interim report multi-year projections and resolutions to release committed fund balance um Mr superintendent I believe we
163have a presentation from we do thank you very much uh before uh our very own Chris Mount uh addresses the board i' just like to make U some introductory comments obviously we are uh carefully monitoring um the the evolving nature of budget considerations in Sacramento uh we continue to read reports about a growing deficit position then offset by some degree of good news uh by and large driven by stock market performance which influences uh the state's budget viability uh today's report focuses on the first interim financial report uh the first interim financial report is a midyear update uh to the current um fiscal year 25 which covers the 2425 school year general fund budget and a forecast of the next two fiscal years and um and the reason why those two additional years uh was
164actually mentioned earlier today uh we need to assert that in three-year periods uh we remain viable we remain solvable solvent um and I can proudly declare that at this point where we stand today through our continuous strategic budget uh budgeting efforts we were able to achieve positive certification for this first interim financial report through a number of actions I'd just like to briefly detail what some of the actions that we have taken are number one uh We've eliminated 331 non-school site non-school site vacant positions from the general fund as of the first inum for a reduction of just short of $50 million secondly uh an estimate a reduction of $15 million from a general fund from non Labor uh revenues thirdly a review of all positions to be filled in a central office by a
165cross functional committee that has resulted in not filling a number of those positions uh looking at replication of effort duplication and making decisions to protect school funding by celling non-school funding or central office spending and lastly a reduction of the local Reserve fund uh to attain um positive certification this is to take place not currently but in 2027 from 5 to 2% uh by doing so we're still at state required levels for for the Reserve I am pleased that we can recommend a positive certification but um we need to be mindful that we continue to carry a very significant very large structural deficit that requires future planning or current planning for future implementation of strategies that will lead to solutions to address this uh this very large structural deficit there is no indication that uh
166unfortunately that additional state or federal funding uh will necessarily be available in the near future to help us address our deficit position I in fact rather pessimistic about a federal Outlook uh that drives in excess of $600 million annually to Los Angeles Unified that um running off to be about 7 to 8% of our general fund balance so that is a problematic uh position that we Face we will not know more about appropriation levels until uh sometime next year obviously the state condition depends on uh economic conditions the performance of the stock market and how much the state once again decides to Kick the Can down the road to address the immediate needs uh specific to its budget going to this coming year uh while we continue to explore ways to increase our revenues like
167increasing uh enrollment uh through early aded and utk enrollment and we've been very successful at that uh we need to do the work to identify areas uh to address and strategies to address um this deficit that we face and to reduce in very careful ways not to impact student services levels of spending I'd like now now to invite Chris Mount our Chief Financial Officer to the podium to provide you with a brief presentation on the first interim financial report and to address any questions that you may have Chris thank you superintendent good afternoon board good to see you all congratulations you uh that are new as well as those of you that are in new positions uh it'll be good to work and continue to work with you this year uh so we are here
168today to address the uh first interim report this is our first report after budget adoption of course you adopt a budget in June the first interim accounts for all changes for the first four months of the fiscal year so through the end of October so all of the changes that we're discussing today are through the end of October and of course the associated recommendations uh are actions that the board takes to get to that positive certification that the superintendent was just addressing meaning that we are paying for all of our known uh expenses for the current and two additional fiscal years uh so with that said we will looks like we're launching yeah this referred to as dead air yeah great so folks should now see uh the report on their screen uh feel free
169to interrupt at any time I know folks are always curious when can we ask questions anytime that you'd like if you want to do it on the on the slide that we're looking at or if you want to hold it that's really up to you board members great looks like we're running so the purpose of the first again it is due by December 15th of every year it is to look at all the changes in your budget between July 1 and October 31st and we always have to recommend to uh that you adopt the first interim it is a revised budget that you're actually adopting and act acting on with all the changes that you either adopt a positive certification meaning that we can meet all of our obligations for the current plus two additional
170years a qualified certification which means we may not meet those obligations or a negative certific ification which means we will not meet them so we are uh advising the board that they adopt the budget with a positive certification highlights uh really high level before we get into some of the granularity uh so in 27 that's that second year out that we have to project we are looking at a fund balance of $86 million at the end of that year under $100 million but if you remember the adopted budget we were only uh that is a $73 million increase over what the adopted budget was that reflects some of the work that we've been doing uh not the typical fund balance we'd be looking for but that does mean that we can meet our obligations at
171this point of time for fiscal year 27 for fiscal year 25 that's this year you see a significant change that we're going to dive into a little bit and that is that our fund balance is 1.7 billion higher than the adopted budget and that went through some very specific uh reasons uh that the board had discussed with us as as we were onboarding as far as making the budget more transparent and clear and we'll go into what we did to get to that point the budget timeline just illustrates for the board and the public that we are always working on three budgets at the same time we are always closing out last year's budget we're always working and modifying this year's budget constantly to make sure that we can pay all of our bills and
172our commitments and we're always planning for the next year we are indeed working on all three of those fiscal school years right now uh for you to make sure that everything is as accurate as possible so we always talk about which budget Year we're working in I know that can get a little confusing you have to sort of split your brain into those different parts so we are focused today specifically on this year fiscal year 25 context for first interim this is uh in regard to those uh big increases yeah I have a question and on the timeline yes earlier we heard that school sites are hearing that budget uh plans need to be turned in by the end of this week but your timeline shows that it's happening in January when the process begins
173can you clarify that and correct sure uh so our budget development not just for school sites but for all offices is in January so the data is developed in December but no one has to do anything until we get back from the break in January so so if if people go in and look at their resources that they're used to using for budget development they will see that that information is already appearing but there's no action that's taken or needed until January so like the surveys and meets assessments all of that is happening right now correct all right thank you uh so the the large items that to focus on as far as context for for this interim report uh we did three things that shifted these fund balances significantly from budget adoption the first
174is that we expended the learning recovery emergency block grant the lre BG this was a covid era block grant that was given to schools to spend as needed for expenses to help with Associated expenses whenever we needed to we we held off on using it and we were planning on actually spending it next year to help balance the budget but they changed some of the accounting rules on us so that we had to use it this year or have a whole bunch of different accounting rules to follow so we moved the expenditure of that up to this year that allowed us to move some of our general fund unrestricted expenses to the restricted side and to spend this Grant out which has already been which has already occurred uh we reviewed and released committed and
175assigned balances uh to the general fund balance what does that mean uh returning board members will remember pages and pages of assignments that used to be a part of the budget document uh that we would keep rolling over from year to year most of those those assignments were between 13 and 17 years old uh we went back and researched all of those and we looked for the reason that the assignments existed those assignments mostly exist existed because they were they were there to start up a new Department a number of years ago or to do a project and when the project ended or when the department was fully funded no one ever managed to close those so it was a lot of Cleanup in the assigned balances we have left current assigned balances uh commitments
176by the board or by the superintendent ined ones that we had to research and we found out were no longer necessary were revie were removed that increased fund balance same thing with commitments so commitments existed over the the past two years for the board for two particular reasons uh some of you are new to hearing this so just to review we were under test one in the last two fiscal years that's a state test as far as our funding source test one means that we were only allowed to have 10% in reserves to get under that 10% Reserve we were permitted to commit balances to show that we actually had a purpose for them so that we didn't have to return that money to the state as an over Reserve so we committed those balances
177this year we are no longer in a test one environment our reserves are allowed to show as higher than that 10% during the time that we were doing commitments we did receive a number of comments that it was harder to figure out what the actual reserves or or or residual balance of fund uh one was our general fund and so in releasing those it's a much more transparent simple accounting of what the board has those commitments when the board made them permitted the budget and finance office to release them to pay for those expenses in the budget as the years passed that is how we were balancing the budget so the budget is balanced in the same manner they are just not in artificial commitments to get us under a 10% Reserve uh strategic budgeting
178this was mentioned by the superintendent this is where we've gone to all of the different departments every single Department that exists in the district office and positions that were aged more than 6 months with no activity meaning that no one was working on them we've removed the position as well as the budget authority to help shrink our overall deficit why is that when we create a position in public education we required to provide the funding for it even if the position is never filled so imagine that you have $10 million of positions that money sits on the sideline while you have a deficit it's not a good use of money when you're deficit spending and so if they were more than 6 months old and some of them were years old and there was no
179activity then we closed the position to help close up that deficit that activity actually got us to that positive certification for year three in this report uh in addition to removing some budget Authority for non-labor costs what does that mean that means that your discretionary budget your non-personnel cost your non-compensation costs if you're under spending it year after year after year then we looked at how much you weren't spending every year and we asked that you give a portion of that back um it was not re re ired but we asked that you do analysis you worked with your uh cabinet members and that you gave a portion back and that yielded about $15 million in savings those savings numbers were as of the time that we published this report that project's not quite complete
180yet we will update the board at a future time with the total savings that those activities yielded fund 17 was a fund that was brought to the board in November to approve fund 17 is a place where boards can hold their general fund reserves uh it is not an activity fund meaning that we don't do charges in fund 17 we don't do expenses we don't do revenues it is just a separate fund for the Board of Education to hold its reserves in so that there is less confusion in the components of the remaining general fund balance in a school district the goal is to give our stakeholders our community members a better idea of what what is actually in and not in fund balance so the general fund 17 the only action anticipated in this
181report is moving the board's local reserve of 5% which currently this year would total $593 million in fund 17 so there is not an unlabeled component of your fund balance in fund one so now we're going to get in the actual yeah and if I may I know that this is uh this is an issue that we've discussed previously and the board authorized but I want to bring additional clarity the creation of this fund 17 which is uh perfectly allowed under ET code and it's a general uh generally accepted practice as Mr Mount said seeks to create the process of analysis of our budget and really identify what the the general fund balance really is in a much more objective and easier to see way than what the district has utilized in the past it
182does not reflect any addition or deletion removal of any funding whatsoever just a transfer from where it currently sits which is mixed with other uh other funds to a single fund where we can point to as the true general fund balance this is the 5% that I alluded to in my introductory comments as being proposed to be reduced to 2% by 2027 correct so uh just some background uh this has been interesting as I've interacted with your staff uh it was not until I did a thorough reading of all of the addendums that that all of you have have gotten and approved over the past however many years the 5% local Reserve was actually created over 20 years ago it usually appears around page 200 or so it's been interesting because before I read the
183details because we get hundreds of pages of details and I know it's a lot I don't think that there was a great level of awareness that the board had created a specific 5% Reserve that money is not earmarked for anything that was just the amount of money that the board wanted to keep on hand and not spend right and so moving it to fund 17 identifies it specifically as a reserve it was it was a fascinating interaction with with your staffs to say oh my gosh we never noticed that but there it is yeah c can I just ask on this thank you for clarifying that so just a few things that you said so one the only action the board has asked to take today in the approval of the first interim is the
184movement of that $ 593 million is that what I just heard you correct uh we're just saying move your reserve to a place where it can be recogniz as a reserve and we're moving it from prior commitments the artificial commitments that you just said to a reserve correct in an effort to be more transparent yep and just for going for the public and for the board going forward when the board commits the board can then uncommit I mean what the board giveth the board taketh away even though commitment sounds like a promise well so uh not only can you so actually fund 17 requires board action so you're the only ones that can put money in there and you're the only ones that can take it out but we're not labeling it as what you're
185spending it on because a reserve means that you want some you want some money in your savings account that isn't spent until you say spend this report does indicate that in fiscal year 27 if we don't address our deficit that 60% of this Reserve three of the 5% would have to be taken out to balance the books in the third year so then I guess and I know you're not alone and I think some surprise are on this 5% policy so where was that that policy was just held in the budget materials it's been in the budget materials we actually uh it was an interesting conversation I went back and spoke to uh one of our budget gurus Victoria who's here today and I said I never saw that and she said oh yeah it's
186been there I said can you find out how long so we've looked back through we've never seen it not appear in the it's adopted in the budget book in June and it's noted under the budget and finance policy so you have your debt management policy that's adopted there as well as your budget and finance policy and you outline the various reserves and the 5% Reserve is noted and then just two questions about that the charts that we've seen including ones we may see today that show that 5% is embedded in that just not explicitly as fund 17 until today but that 5% it's not like there is a hidden 5% Reserve that exists right and then the second thing is I guess based on the approval today of fund 17 if that's where the board
187goes does that mean that in essence we are changing that 5% policy because we're allow owing for a draw down to 2% over the next few years and therefore not requiring a 5% or would there be a subsequent action where we have to approve right so so your approval of this would do both right so it would say that yes we want to maintain our 5% with the recognition that in 2027 barring any other changes that you need a portion of that Reserve to balance the books and Achieve positive certification so in in addition to the movement from commitments to fund 17 we are also in essence amending that 5% Reserve policy for that contingency in 27 if we don't do if if if everything else stays the same and we don't do anything correct
188yeah with that said should conditions change going to next year should uh the state of California increase the coal allocation should there be a significant alteration to the financial Outlook Statewide then the board could authorize a reversal of that and in fact maintain it 5% or 4% uh or anywhere in between correct and and if I could have found it anywhere else for that third year I would have because that is your reserve the the one important point is that staff cannot unilaterally without board approval make changes to whatever you approve today uh it it it stays static in that fund until such time as a different recommendation is brought to the board and the board approves it had a question so with the 5% that we're moving to 17 and you mentioned earlier about
189there's some total savings that we may have from other lines that we don't see today so you said that there's some closures that you've closed but we don't see that savings today so the amounts that we've saved that are published in this report are reflected in the report however we weren't complete with the process so we're continuing and and finalizing additional savings so where would those funds be today uh well until we until we take them and then they'll show up for the board in the second inter room unless the board would like uh for example an informative uh to to share the end results of that process if I understand the question correctly so those additional reductions are for example in non-labor accounts in the division of instruction uh it has a certain budget
190we're going through an analysis so they stay there until such time as they are captured removed from that account and then invested it either into fund 17 or any other fund or as I introduced Chris Mount I discussed the closure of non-school site central office positions that had been opened for in some cases 30 60 up to 180 days those funds are already captured but we continue to do budgetary examinations of non-school site budget these are divisions outside of schools right in central office to the extent that from this point on we are able able to capture additional dollars either through the closure of vacant positions or the reduction of non labor budgets IND divisions and why would we do this because we've looked over years a disconnect between what's budgeted and what's spent and
191this is a continuing exercise of ensuring that we are not budgeting more than what's spent on an on an average year otherwise those dollars just sit in those accounts right those dollars need be liberated from those accounts and be available to solve School side problems so what you're being presented with today are the actions that we've taken uh non- labor costs at non-school sites reduction the closing of vacant positions that had been open in some cases up in excess of 180 days uh as well as a number of other Maneuvers but that doesn't stop there there are additional efficiencies that we'll be looking for as we continue to do that we'll bring back reports to the board in terms of where those dollars are invested whether they are invested directly into school accounts School protection
192programs or the protection of the fund balance so just to follow up so is it possible because obviously we haven't viewed the budget in this way in these lenses to be able to do side by side from where they were to where they're going so we can actually see because it's it's still moving right now because you share that it's not a total vision of the savings quite yet yeah so the budget is always moving I always say that that the numbers change and if my staff is doing their job they they'd better uh because it means that we're accounting every day currently any savings that we're yielding from closing positions is falling to the bottom line of the general fund if it's a general fund position we also did close non-general fund positions but
193we can't move that money to the general funds that just Falls to their own own fund to reuse or repurpose um as we complete the process this year we will share a a summary report uh with the superintendent and and executive staff and and certainly we can we can share an update with the board as well thank you um I'm still confused about fund 17 so hopefully you can um enlighten me how is this fund different this Reserve different than the previous Reserve reses we've heard of in the past and um this money is going to sit there and when will we use it and how will we use it is it to close the gap at the end of year three or is it to support our schools and how will that decision come
194about and at what point will we say we need to start using that money uh so fund 17 is specifically designed by the state as a place where the the board can hold its reserves so nothing happens in that fund the state's not giving us money we aren't charging expenses to that fund we actually can't um it is a set aside so that the board of education has a has a designated savings account if you will that they move their savings their reserves into so that it's clear how much they have in reserves and that they can track it over time and that it's not just sitting in the general fund not called out is that separate than what we had last year when they said there were $6.2 billion in reserve so a lot
195of those items were in assignments and commitments and they were just being held in the general fund and once they are assigned or committed they didn't show up on the bottom line of unassigned balances so our unassigned balance looked very very slim and we were re we were releasing those amounts in the budget office with the authority of the board to balance the budget after they had passed those commitments right but a commitment is a lower so so moving up an assignment is just a verbal statement that we have to accommodate in the budget it has no board action behind it a commitment has board action typically in one of our financial reports and we set it aside as not being just fund balance which is confusing to some folks because they're like well that's
196a very general thing it looks like it's just going into the budget why are you committing it because we had to get under our 10% Reserve level for test One Fund 17 is a place for you to hold your savings so that it's not confused with just general fund balance in fund one to the point that that I think board member grego's question reveals so you asked one important thing so the fund the funding is now in fund 17 it's the board's general fund Reserve fund Reserve uh how can it change the board can change it by board action I can bring a resolution to the board a recommendation to change and then the board has to say I can not unilaterally go into that fund and use it when could it be changed part
197of your question could be changed this coming year as we finalize the the budget for the next fiscal year the board could say we want to accelerate what you were planning to do by fiscal year 27 by one year so we want to access those dollars so the board is ultimately in control of the decision of that level of uh general fund balance Reserve to the extent my recommendation that two things happen we comply with state law regarding the the the percentage of fund balance reserve and secondly whether or not the board wants to maintain a fiscally solvent position on the third year which right now we are a few months ago we weren't because we had not completed the exercise of closing vacant positions looking deeply at non-school site budgets in essence the board
198has ultimately the control over the level of the of the reserve the fund balance and what it is used for should the board decide to go into it that cannot be done unilaterally by Administration C can you one of you two to maybe just helpful for the board to explain the difference between a reserve and an ending balance because I think sometimes we use them interchangeably but they're actually two different concepts they are that's a that's a great question so your ending balance is after all of your revenues are put into your account your checking account and all your expenses are taken out it's the amount that's that's left over um it's specifically called undesignated unallocated because the board hasn't assigned a purpose and the budget office has not assigned a purpose to those dollars
199when we're in a deficit spending situation it's like you're keeping your extra money in your checking account so as we spend more than we're bringing in you're just spending down your checking account balance a reserve is a specific call out it's setting up a savings account that is not spent without the knowledge of the board very different and so the the number that miss that board member GGO was referring to that 6.2 billion in the past was a reserve or was an ending balance fund balance fund balance right which is and we're doing something can just help us explain to what's different about what we're doing today because the 593 million will be taken away from the fund balance to go into the fund So currently the 5% local Reserve is sitting in fund balance
200you have to read through the deal the details of the investment and financial management policy that assistant Deputy superintendent Cel was pointing out to figure that out we are just saying hey if you have a true Reserve let's put it here so that people stop confusing it as just money that that can be spent without permission actually a reserve requires the board to spend or not spend I appreciate CL I appreciate Mr gr's questions too because I think this is one we get from I know constituents all the time which is what money are is sitting there why if it's sitting there why aren't you spending at school sites especially when we have a lot of need at school sites but then we have to budget in three-year increments and we see the writing on
201the wall with state and federal allocations and so we want to make sure and I I'm I'm hopeful and I think slightly confident that in a few years when um the economic winds are still kind of you know uh blowing in the opposite direction that we're going to be solvent with the actions we're taking here today but I do think it's important to explain these the differences absolutely because otherwise why aren't we spending more money on all the things we know our schools need and that is why we're required to do these interim reports exactly well my question was you know aligned with the discussion right here um you know you mentioned the goal was to increase transparency for stakeholders by separating the general fund balances into fund 17 which is I guess we're beginning
202to understand um but could you elaborate how the separation specifically benefits our stakeholders like our parents who are trying to understand um the budget so when would this fun 17 come in so that folks you know apart from ourselves are able to understand this and um what key insights would this provide that weren't there before it it just provides Clarity right that's the only Insight there's been a lot of conversation uh we've seen it in in public comment uh as well as as communication between our Departments of what are those components of fund balance why are you committing and assigning so much what is the local reserve and so the only item that this this gives Clarity to is it calls out that the board does indeed have a local reserve and it's set aside
203from the money the fund balance in fund one that is that is the only point it's just a Clarity transparency maneuver if the board would rather leave it in fund balance that's also permissible uh but that's the board's choice but it's going to continue to have that drive that conversation of it's not called out there if it's a reserve why is it sitting in your fund balance it's it's just a it's just a technical clarification so will this be provided for our stakeholders in the new budget uh transparency dashboard that the district is working on will it be there and specifically explain exactly what we're we're saying now this is fr 17 and have an explanation as are are are looking at this new budget cash for because is a this is additional information right
204so if it's not there it's it will cause some confusion if you're looking at at the hadn't hadn't contemplated that but it's it's possible uh and so I know all of the board staffs are working with because I'm half of the budget transparency tool and then strategic uh planning and initiatives uh if that's asked for I'm certain that we can do that that's not a heavy lift but no one's asked that yet so I think it's actually a strong recommendation to makes sense since this has been a point of confusion for since I arrived here you know the confusion about what the end ofe fund balance is and then we need to qualify it explain it right particularly it was even more difficult when we were uh when we had access to Esser funding right
205which was short-termed so that was included then you had Federal inment money there as well then you had general fund money there and it just became very very messy very very confusing to try to explain that to someone who does not have Financial Training it's really very very tough uh sometimes even tough for those who deal with budgets every single day so that makes a great deal of sense we will endeavor to include that as a feature in in the dashboard that the board by resolution uh has asked for yeah I could see that being more transparent than having to look through the entire budget and the interim report I mean if anything that's it will be more confusing for folks um okay yeah I think that's my question for now thanks I really like
206your question Carla I really did because people were so confused about what was what so now fund 17 that is our Reserve that is our Reserve could we ever dip into fund 17 if we need to use some money yes and today's report actually asks for permission to reduce Reserve to 2% in two years if we don't do any other savings because we have to balance the budget okay and getting back to Carla's question again when people kept saying the ending balances in different funds H how do we know what we could use for our schools and those ending balances how do we know so an unassigned uncommitted balance is entirely at the discretion of the school district however the other thing to look at is how rapidly you're spending that balance already with what
207you're doing so currently we are spending that balance down rapidly because we are spending more than we're taking in as a school district okay it's getting better okay we will have aition informational sessions with the board both individually and collectively uh moving forward uh on on this topic but I think there were a number of key takeaways and I think the questions as our board president Schmelson detailed are good is that number one what you're approving here today is not adding money to anything subtracting money to anything is simply moving what is already known as a fund balance into a proprietary fund fund 17 that cannot accept anything other than the general fund balance that's it the other important action is which can be changed but I don't recommend it being changed at this point
208is that that level of funding represents 5% of our expenditures of our expenditures the second recommendation is not only to move this funding into fund 17 is to also automatically authorize for us to remain fiscally viable and not have to certify a qualified budget to Leo which puts us under the microscope of Leo to begin with and then the state Allah San Francisco to maintain fiscal Independence then that third year which doesn't come in until 2027 needs to be addressed so your second action today authorizes that 5% of expenditures to be reduced to 2% for that future 20 20 28 fiscal year 27 and is the 2% inclusive of the 1% statutory Reserve or on top it is not so to answer that question always in your fund balance the state requires that a school
209district keep a minimum Reserve in their fund balance in fund one that's called a statutory Reserve it's one of our components of that fund balance most districts in the state of California are required to keep 3% minimum LAUSD has a specific carve out that we are own only required to keep 1% because of our size however looking outside of the district this is just my knowledge from working outside of the district uh so much as a CFO small districts average 28% reserves in their fund balance mediumsized districts 18% large districts 10% right so we are authorizing the 1% requirement in the general fund and the board's local resolution has been an additional 5% on top of that 1% and the proposed action contingent on no additional action by the district or the board would then
210reduce the board you know the reserve by board policy to 2% plus the statutory reserve of 1% correct 3% Bing any other action correct anyone else have a question okay you can continue thank you thank you uh so now we're going to look at the general fund this this is the main operating fund of the district uh and what we do is that we are going to be providing the board a consistent view report after report of what you did at the adopted budget versus where we are now the difference and the reason for that so this is a view of general fund unrestricted and restricted restricted is all of our title programs our federal title programs as well as our for example our Ada restricted money uh so that's the restricted side the unrestricted
211is the money provided by the state that we get to use for any educa educational purpose that we determine so for the adopted budget the beginning balance that was the carry forward from the prior year for both restricted and unrestricted was about $6.3 billion today I'm reporting that at first interim it's $6.4 billion it's gone up by 57 million uh a little less than 1% and that's just from TR up the books at fiscal close last year and moving into today so you see a slight increase in the beginning balance revenues for both sides of general fund restricted and unrestricted adopted we were at $9.4 billion in revenues this interim report we are at 9.3 billion we're seeing about a a reduction of about 132 million that's on the restricted side largely and that's because
212our multi-year grants are title programs as the as the most uh identifiable example those grants we only get money money in as we spend them so that they are reimbursement grants so our spending is tracking a little bit under what we budgeted for which means that the revenues in our restricted side are going down just a little bit our expenditures at adoption we had plans in place from all of our departments and schools that equated to 11.2 billion uh at first interum that total is $ 11.6 billion and increase of about 430 million and that's mainly due to that transfer out of fund 17 because we're moving it out of fund one into fund 17 if that's the board's desire the important line here is the revenue less expenditures this is the structural deficit that
213was referenced and this is the current size of that structural deficit so at first interim we are at $2.3 billion on both the restricted and unrestricted side um and that is a significant structural deficit and the important thing to pay attention to is what that does to our ending balance so go back up we were at $6.4 billion that was carried over from prior years and at the end of this year if we continue our spending pattern right now we will be at $4 billion so our so our ending balances are going down by a little bit over $2 billion this year on the restricted and unrestricted side so then we're going to move into looking at restricted and unrestricted separately yeah just uh because I'd like to go back in time and and address
214some of the comments or questions that have been made over the past couple of years staff has asserted that while we look really healthy from a fiscal perspective in terms of end of year fund balance and actually in some instances it grew we said once Esser is gone and Esser has been gone now only 3 months September 2024 is when those $5 billion of federal investment to our school system came to an end once that once that happens the burn rate the burn rate the expenditures compared to revenues coming in that burn rate is going to accelerate a lot because as you will see and this is just a function it's not an indictment it's not a judgment you know I think this board and I agree wholeheartedly that during the pandemic and in the
215aftermath of the pandemic actually it was the first time in the history of Los Angeles Unified and many other districts across the country where we came close to adequacy and funding it took a crisis for the federal government and the state to actually pump in additional dollars that got us pretty close to an adequacy level that should have been the trend all along once you remove that now but we still made additional commitments uh whether to negotiated negotiation negotiations with labor or other Investments that made sense the burn rate now is is very high and this is proed positive so $2 billion by the end this this year this fiscal year and that's not the end of the calendar year it's the end of uh July the end of June uh June 30 of 2025
216will be down two billion compared to where we were at the beginning secondly from the time that this board approved the budget for this fiscal year to now we're down a half a billion dollars so the burn rate is going to be very accelerated that's why taking the steps we're taking now and envisioning the strategies to really reach FY 26 27 and 28 in a solvent position are critically important and the earlier we start taking those steps the less deep the pain is as we approach those Milestones um would you mind explaining again why uh on under expenditures it's due to fund 17 I mean the increase in expenditures is due to the transfer of fund 17 but fund 17 is available I mean I just want to know why it's a function of expense
217rather than just beyond an accounting maneuver uh because in California for schools we do fund-based accounting so if we move fund money out of fund one into fund 17 it shows up as an expense in fund one if we move the money back it shows as new Revenue even though it's not new Revenue it just means we're moving it between two funds it's the only time that we're actually allowed to what they call mix funds move money from One Fund to the other yes um yes just to follow up on Dr rias's question and um the superintendent's comments obviously the the size of the deficit is concerning but isn't most of the growth in the deficit from adopted budget to First interim due to the movement to fund 17 so it's not that we're spending
218500 million addition we've spent 500 million between June and now it's that we weren't anticipating it's that we transferred those monies out of you're correct and that's what I I provided to your staff during the briefing is you're actually not seeing an increase here in in the growth of the deficit you're just seeing us transfer money out of fund one which then artificially accounts for that difference between the 1 Point nearly 1.8 billion and and 2.3 billion uh the the important and I'll get to I sorry I'm leaping ahead in the presentation but I I'll show you actually where uh the deficit spending is impacting and how we're verifying that but I'll get into that on another slide okay yeah I just wanted to clear I mean obviously uh receiving less Revenue than we're spending
219on an annual basis is a is a problem and is something that we'll need to reckon with as our savings get smaller as we're you fully utilizing onetime grant funding Etc um I just wanted to be clear that this the the problem doesn't appear to have grown uh truly since the adopted budget in June it's it appears to be more consistent just due to fund 17 and also the piece that you mentioned around some of our revenues not being reflected um at this moment correct and you're going to see in in our look at the funds more specifically how we're mitigating that by moving some of that deficit for example from the unrestricted to the restricted side okay yeah just want to be clear you're right the problem didn't grow beyond what we expect the
220the problem grew at the level that we were expecting because what you saw earlier was not just this transfer was also a number of mitigating strategies closure of positions Etc so if we had not done that uh we would have had a bigger liability than what we're looking at so you're already looking at a clean process after the non-labor budgets were reduced the the vacant positions were closed Etc so yeah the problem is is is is growing at the rate that we expected that's why uh Mr Mount is predicting by the end of this fiscal year will be 2 billion below where we started at the beginning of this year so now we're just going to look at the restricted side again as a reminder these are our Federal grant programs as well as our
221uh restricted uh for example our special education funding uh so the difference between beginning balance and our restricted is is not a large net it's 4% $84 million uh so we at the beginning balance at adopted we had 1.8 almost 1.9 billion and at first interim we have 1.8 that's just from True up from fiscal close revenues uh we were projected to have 4.2 billion uh we're projecting down a little bit to about 3.9 billion about $274 million difference uh and that is again uh because of our multi-year grants and that we don't get the money until we spend it and we're spending at a slightly slower rate that also uh so this confuses it a little bit our expenses went from 4.375 to 4.9 billion and you're going to say well wait a second
222that's an increase that is reflective of the $600 million of the learning recovery emergency block grant that we spent to help assist with expenses in the general fund uh which is why we're able to get the general fund unrestricted in slightly better shape what you're looking at here is also that transfer of some of that deficit from the unre restricted side to the restricted side so you can see that our deficit in the restricted side went from about 200 million to slightly over a billion right again about 600 million of that was us spending out the learning recovery emergency block grant to provide assistance uh and we want to be able to spend our restricted dollars first as appropriate because they're the harder dollars to spend it's called the first dollar principle you always spend
223your most restricted hardest to spend dollars first before you dipped into that unrestricted side which are the easiest dollars to spend and and they're also the the solvency of the school district so that means that we're our ending balance in our restricted side we're looking to go uh from a $1.6 billion projection to about a $750 million projection uh at the end of the school year for the revenues um in the first should we see that number increase by the end of the year as money comes in and as spending it and money gets reimbursed only if our rapidity of spending increases right so the way that our budgets work when we submit our plan in January for the following year all sorts of things can happen between January and when we start spending right
224we don't have the capacity to implement as many new initiatives or programs or maybe we didn't get as many people to hire that we had had uh that we wanted to hire and so if we don't do as much activity as we planned if don't spend it out on the restricted side then we don't get it in this time in the school year so we're reporting out as of October 31st I know we're both teachers you'll get this if you haven't found somebody by October 31st we assume at this point you probably aren't going to find somebody right because midyear hiring is extremely difficult especially of certificated employees right and so it's a it's a really hard lift so if you're seeing that underspend it's because you can't execute on maybe all the plans you
225had the year before for the following year year and so if you aggregate that all up for a big school district that's the difference that you're seeing so you don't think we're going to see inrease I I don't think so because our past Trend indicates that we don't so if we move to the unrestricted side this is really important to pay attention to this is where I will always say to the board look at the general fund unrestricted this is the solvency of the school district it's the most important aspect of fund accounting that we do uh so in our budget adoption our beginning balance was $4.4 billion notice that we've increased that slightly uh for TR up our fiscal close to $4.6 billion this is just on the general fund unrestricted side revenues we
226projected them at being $5.2 billion in budget adoption and at the first interim we're reporting that they are projected at 5.4 billion notice that those increases are due to some minor changes that total $142 million so some higher leases and Rental incomes I know that we had a question I got a response during this meeting that's because we are seeing more rental activity at our schools from things like the YMCA Boys and Girls Club Etc throughout the district uh increase in home to school transportation reimbursement and a slightly lower contribution to special education this year expenditures uh at budget adoption at $6.8 billion we are slightly down we've moved some of those things out of the unrestricted side to the restricted side better money management and so our deficit has gone from a an adopted
227deficit of about $1.6 billion down to $1.3 billion uh which is definitely better it's not ideal but one I'll take the $1.3 billion deficit over the 1.6 our ending balance at this time we are projecting to be at $3.3 billion just pay attention that that is a declining amount of money uh that we have to cover our expenses uh year-over-year M um just curious when you talked about closing position that were vacant for 180 days what types of positions are we talking about oh goodness I I'll use one of my departments as an example so I might have had I did have some budget Texs uh or some accounting positions that hadn't been filled in in and in 180 days was the minimum 6 months some of them had been open for a year and
228a half they hadn't been recruited for we're doing the work we aren't booking a lot of overtime so it begs the question of do I need it why haven't I filled it why haven't I actively been able to find somebody some of those POs positions are open for years and so it begs the question of why are we just tying up money in the budget by keeping a vacant position on the books what about teaching positions do we close only central office positions only only central office I didn't get that okay thank you thank you any other questions on the general fund unrestricted so this is a a stacked graph uh which shows our ending balances for the next three years this is our multi-year projection so these are ending balances for this year fiscal
229year 25 fiscal year 26 and fiscal year 27 this is unrestricted and restricted you can see the rate at which it's going down um it matches up to the charts that you saw before and then more importantly is when we look at the general fund unrestricted this is taking out the restricted resources and notice the changes the the spendable money to Prior questions that money that is available for us to cover our overspend is that green bar notice that our assignments and commitments that orange bar is going down rapidly as we release them we're doing that so that we have more in the green to cover our overspend and then the top little portions we include those because they're technically there but the gray is that 1% reserve for economic uncertainties that's the statutory Reserve
230that we mentioned earlier that's the 1% and the purple are nonspendable that's cash in and out um that is not spendable in the accounting structure this slide is important to pay attention it to it just illustrates the difference between what the budget looked like in the general fund at budget adoption versus what we're doing now so this is where the transparency comes in in releasing all those assignments and commitments notice that with all the assignments and commitments that dotted Blue Line kept us just barely making all of our commitments all of our our financial commitments whereas when we release all the money you can see that the ending point is pretty similar but we aren't just tucking them away in little boxes so that people say well where is all that money we know you
231have a big fund balance the fund balance is just there now it is what it is it does go to paying our overspend until we balance our budget but there's no point in tucking it away we don't have a reserve cap you can see and everybody can see exactly what it is um the columns on the right are really important because they are reminding you what we have in this report and what we don't have in this report so the leftand column is what is not in this report because we're not allowed to guess in finance what might come up we can only put in what we know so we is not in here any changes in compensation or any of our negotiated agreements the governor's January budget proposal so any changes that he makes
232are not in here any potential reductions in federal funding are not in here not until we know them concretely potential new major programmatic Investments so anything that we decide to augment is not this report unrecognized claims those are claims or settlements against the school district we are not allowed to recognize them until the board approves them and they become a known quantity those are not in this report what is in this report release of commitments and unre the release of our commitments and assignments to our unrestricted unassigned balance central office assigned balances changed to no carry forward so we made sure that no central office departments were trying to carry forward money transfer of balance to a fund 17 that is an assumption in this report the maximization of our grants on the restricted side
233to give relief to the unrestricted general fund and not this year but for the next two years trying to get towards our Arc the recommended contribution for our retirees uh benefits over time which we have struggled to do as a district that liability is growing so we do always try to get there so that is still planned for future years structural deficit so we've talked a lot about that but what is that that means that we are spending more money than we're receiving from the state so earlier you we always talk about the third year I've heard here the third year never comes here are some things that we're checking on for a genuine structural deficit we haven't had to do these in years we are doing them now it's part of our responsibility to
234you we're doing cash flow reporting so we are actually checking on the amount of cash that we have on hand to pay our bills and I can tell you on average we're spending $120 million more a month on average than we're taking in right that's what's leading us to that $ 1.3 billion dollar of deficit in the unrestricted general fund now here's the good news during Co during all of those additional monies that we got we did a good job at saving that's why you have so much in that savings account that's covering an overspend of about $1.3 billion okay uh however however a a structural deficit is not because of anything that has been done in the state economy or an economic crisis in the federal government it is a result of us simply
235spending more than we're taking in in other words it is our control okay what is the total deficit at this time so total general fund deficit is $2.3 billion of that 1.3 is in the unrestricted general fund what are the impacts of a structural deficit in other words as long as we're paying our bills who cares right well there's definitely impacts if we don't address it number one the 55% of rate 55% ratio of classroom teachers that we have to certify at the audit period for fiscal years 22 23 and 24 we did not meet that minimum however that was because we were spending federal dollars and then we had a variance so that we didn't have to meet that 55% I'm happy to report to you on at this time we are on Trend
236to meet that 55% for this this fiscal year however after this year because of our declining enrollment in students and our increase in Staffing we will not be able to meet that after this fiscal year so I I'd heard before as I observed the board and listen to questions why are we finding out so late so I am telling you as far ahead as I possibly can next year that will not be a ratio that we'll be able to meet there are penalties for that which we would also not be able to meet uh we are also looking at a I say a possible down downgrade of our credit I am telling you that our credit without a plan will be downgraded I go every year with other folks to do ratings presentations I do
237updates to them throughout the year it was messaged our last rating presentations uh this past May and June that if we did not have a plan to solve for our deficit spending that our very good credit will be downgraded that impacts our cost of borrowing both for the bond program as well as for intermediary borrowing that we're doing for uh School District expens enses that we need assistance on um so just be aware that that borrowing becomes more expensive we also will be looking we didn't we were able to get a positive certification this interim but in the future we will be looking at a qualified or negative certification if we don't address our deficit spending so at some point we won't be able to get to positive and that last bullet pretty much explicitly
238says it says conditional it's the same thing as qualified that we will be at that point for Budget adoption for fiscal year 26 because we don't have enough money for that third year barring not making any changes at budget adoption so at budget adoption at this point that's where we'll be is a qualified certification I just ask you uh uh the last time there was a um a deficit was in the year 2019 2020 I know you weren't here right I wasn't either was I here no I wasn't here uh and it was less than 100 million what do you think if you know caused that structural deficit in 20192020 I was trying to think what was going on in 2019 2020 that would cause us to have a structural deficit of aund million I
239believe that we were notified of a of a two work twoe emergency notice closure uh Statewide of all of our facilities that was covid that occurred in March of 2020 uh and what what school districts had to do uh school districts became the place where essentially local organization happened for the state government throughout the state to manage covid and all the things that we were asked to do we were front funding all of the expenses to respond to the the pandemic prior to federal and state commitments coming in which gave us much more money to not only handle those but to handle the changes to schools so there was a dramatic deficit as a result of the of the pandemic yeah thank you thank you have there been other times besides that time where we
240ended in deficit uh so again I wasn't I wasn't here but in speaking to colleagues that we had uh times and in fact we had deficits projected in uh prior to 08 and 10 which were significant layoffs uh but then year to year prior to the laws changing we used to do incremental uh layoffs of classified they used to be able to just have 30 or 60 days notice it's now on the same schedule as teachers so that's not possible anymore but to mitigate those deficits those things used to be done annually um but as far as which years they were I'd have to look more into it we had a we had a number of qualified budgets approved in the district from 2012 through 2018 2019 um look as we look as as Mr
241Mount cited our budgets are always changing as conditions change at the state level make adjustments and that's part of the work of our budget team and Leadership to really make adjustments in our budgets to respond to oute challenges and so during those times we were making adjustments to programs uh being able to be more flexible when it come came to particular fund sources and utilize them for particular staffing needs and so that comes as part of the process and today this is part of the process it's creating awareness about what the challenge is then what are the options and steps that we need to take to address those oute challenges um I take it just to summarize the reason you're bringing up here in the structural deficit the possible downgrade of credit rating Bond program
242is if the district receives a negative um certification then that would impact borrowing and then we won't be able to make our payments for Bond and if we don't make our B payments for our bond or or or debt um then it's going to have to come directly from general fund uh actually no the way that bonding Works in California is our property taxpayers are are on the hook for it once they approve the bond so what will happen is the the cost to borrow that we roughly borrow uh about a billion dollars in bond a year to keep the bond program going the cost of borrowing that billion dollars will go up which means that our taxpayers will pay more for that borrowing they don't only have to pay back that billion they have
243to pay back the interest and our interest rates will go up so it's very much like a mortgage right just like if your credit's not good the cost of a mortgage can go up quite a bit in interest rates it's the same thing for our borrowing but we borrow on behalf of our taxpayers uh and so the taxpayers would be on the hook for increased uh expenses at that point so why is this coming up here if if borrowing costs are finan this way um and not by General funds so why bring it up here as a structural because I so I serve as the district's fiduciary right so anything that is a material impact to our financial well-being it's my responsibility I have to bring it up to the board at the interims there
244can't be any surprises so for example if our credit is downgraded in 6 months I don't want Dr Rivas to come to me and say why didn't you tell us that was a possibility so my job is to tell you in advance of that happening so that it's not a surprise because it will impact the uh Bond program as far as our tax ta payers and our voters having to pay more and a public credit rating reduction will also impact the reputation Financial reputation of the school district and that would result in a structural deficit uh that is the result of a structural def structural deficit got it okay thanks absolutely but again I think uh vice president re was asked an important question so the the structural deficit and the failure to address it
245could certainly result in a downgrade of our credit ratings which we have struggled and worked hard to improve over the past couple years the the impact should that happen should there be a downgrade in the credit rating would not necessarily be reserved only to Capital expenditures uh funded through the bond so we as a district borrow um against general fund as well right and there would be a direct implication to general fund so for example um and I don't want to belabor the issue but we're venturing to uh judge obligation bonds we're venturing into um other uh borrowing mechanisms to create a a financial Bridge those are general fund liabilities so this would not necessarily just be an impact on bond would be an impact on any financial institution where we're seeking relief from via
246borrowing like a tax anticipation note uh if we need to get one and that is basically a stop Gap measure to access money uh to maintain cash flow until the state invests in in Los Angeles Unified the cost of doing business that that credit rating downgrade could impact uh the interest that these financial institutions currently charges uh so we've already covered sorry sorry um on the previous slide if you could just speak to the 55% ratio of classroom teachers in the general fund um the specific requirement and how it's how it's calculated whether or not you've met that requirement yeah great question so uh every year when we close the year and we go to audit so we'll be bringing you the audit of last year in January uh that part of that audit test
247is of all the general fund money you spent in a fiscal year restricted and unrestricted was 55% of it spent specifically on the compensation for classroom teachers and it's very very specific it is certificated uh members in the classrooms directly teaching children right so I know a number of us are certificated teachers so if we were in the classroom that would count as a yes if we are not in the classroom teaching children it does not count towards that 55% I turned it off um in terms of other certificated positions that provide Direct Services to children like um counselers or psws or School psychologists or nurses are those all also are they in the denom they they don't count towards they're not roster caring teachers so I assume they don't count towards that piece but
248they are included in that calculation so that is part so we spend general fund on on paying those folks absolutely but are they in the classro no so they don't count towards the 55 there's no differentiation between staff that uh let's say are in central office or other administrative positions versus certificated staff who are at schools providing Direct Services to students correct so if you are a certificated employee and you are serving in another capacity outside of the classroom you do not get counted towards that 55% even if you're let's say you're spending your whole day providing service to children it's just not in the classroom they're not counted in that calculation and it is a required calculation by the state got it and um would you anticipate that you know in in previous contracts
249the district made a decision to basically take an equity approach to lift up our lowest paid employees which are our classified employees um especially represented by CA and SEIU is uh providing was providing that type of approach and compensation therefore harmful to meeting this 55% requirement because you're maybe changing the proportion or the you're addressing paid disparities I guess that previously existed yeah I mean um so my role is not taking a moralistic view of how we're spending the money you are never going to hear me say that people don't deserve enough money to live in La uh so is there a right or wrong associated with that no especially our lowest paid employees that are struggling to make ends meet we have to take that into consideration because if we don't they become really
250hard to find right uh so it's not about that I think as as the issue and one of the next slides is going to illustrate uh for the board the issue has been that we are a declining enrollment District uh we are losing students every year and we haven't been actively uh addressing the fact that as we lose students we should also have fewer employees because we're getting fewer revenues uh we actually have more yeah and I think just to to clarify I I was not seeking your um as much as I value your opinion I I I have my own views on you know the moral rightness of ensuring we take care of our lowest paid employees I think it's more trying to get to the context of what's leading to us potentially not
251meeting that requirement and um what I would hope would be advocacy in Sacramento I my assumption is that the the state in implementing such a requirement was not trying to prevent schools from being able to have a full-time nurse finally at our school campuses or provide psychiatric social workers to provide much needed Mental Health Services or to um undermine our ability to raise the wage for our lowest paid employees so I just wanted to further understand the context and why we are getting to that particular position right couldn't couldn't agree more this has become an issue for school districts as we've in included more and more more professionals that address the social emotional well-being of our students that work directly with students but not in the classroom and that has been a huge increase across
252the state right whether it's social workers whether it's psychologists whether it's counselors whether it's nurses uh also frequently members of the same Union as our certificated teachers but the rule for calculating it has not changed it's an old rule um I have just definitely discussed and I I know Martha might have been coming down but I said is this something we can work on uh and she said absolutely but it's been tried for a number of years with without a change uh but it doesn't mean that we shouldn't keep trying thank you and Mr Mount let me just say special ed teachers count or only gened teachers count to the all teachers count as long as they're working in the classroom with all special ed how about the well yes how about an rst a
253resource specialist teacher RSP teachers would count as long as they're working directly with children in the classroom but they may not have a roster yeah okay technical very technical okay it is it is a technical calculation yep I I was just going to ask superintendent if we might begin to discuss with our labor Partners whether this is an area we could um we could collaborate on um because I know that you know the growth in some of these other positions was very much something that was called for by our labor Partners um so I hope we might be able to work together on that front so uh this leads us up to the point are the questions that you're disc discussion what are the main things that have been contributing to this deficit uh the
254board um has intermittently seen versions of this slide before um and so we have two versions to share today just as a as a gentle reminder this is only the last 10 years we've been declining enrollment for 25 years we are averaging about 2 2.5% roughly of decline per year so this just shows you in the last 10 years we've gone from 5 166.000 students down to 43,000 students um at the same time time that we have that declining uh orangish reddish bar of our students enrolled uh notice that most of our employee groups if we add them into one group or another uh have been increasing right so the number of adults per student has contined to increase now people say well does that mean you're hiring a bunch of folks well it could
255be that we're hiring more it can also be that as the decline happens there's more adults per student right unless you adjust that out so this slide this version of the slide shows you the number of positions by these different types of of groups right and then there's always the question of but how many of those positions are filled how many Warm Bodies how many heads are in those positions so the the next slide just gives you a comparison it's not a big difference but it gives you a comparison of those positions that are filled with a person we call that a headcount view doesn't matter whether it's part-time or full-time it's the number of actual headcount in those positions we also want to review our other major funds with the board so our adult
256education fund uh the story here uh is that the adult education fund uh has also deficit spending going on they're continuing to try to increase their enrollment post pandemic to try to address that of course more enrollment means uh more revenues for them however uh in the near future we are going to have to address uh the deficit Ed if they're not able to gain back enough students this is separate from the general fund remember our cafeteria fund this is actually a a great slide I really enjoy looking at this this is the efforts of Our Food Services Department to stay within the funding of the uh that they receive from providing meals to our students and so they are a able to balance their budget they've continued to balance their budget it has certainly
257helped that we are getting reimbursements for all students for all meals now but this speaks to uh some good management in the food service department in balancing their budget our Child Development Fund uh also struggling with balancing but we are working on that year-over-year uh and you can see that their deficit is starting to Trend downward so fiscal Outlook uh State fiscal Outlook is stable uh the state is being cautious uh the Lao is advocating for any additional prop 98 money to be put into the prop 98 rainy day fund we don't know the governor's reaction to that yet we will not know until the January uh Governor's budget presentation he might agree he might disagree as soon as we get that information we will certainly share it with everybody uh the budget office the
258lao's job is to be conservative and they're saying although stable they're seeing deficits in the state budget as well which is why they are recommending to the governor that he not share any additional prop uh prop 98 Revenue La unified fiscal Outlook that's what we SP the time doing we continue to be challenged with a significant deficit uh our enrollment is declining uh between 2.3 and 2.5% per year however that attendance really helps every 1% of attendance is $21 million a year or $63 million in the 3E view that we take uh assistance to the budget it's the biggest impact is attendance and at as of today that enrollment is trending upward uh so that's excellent excellent assistance any additional discussion or questions at this time go ahead Carla yeah first thank you for that
259report and um Scott brought up um the question when the staff cut the staff cut came up any cuts to any staff and you clarified that um it was not going to be any teaching positions and superintendent said nope no teaching positions but I'm hoping that it's not just teaching positions but also classified staff positions at school sites I'm hoping that it's not any of the folks who support our students at the school sites including our social workers our PSAs our library uh AIDS a lot of our our schools don't have Library AIDS right now so anyway just wanted to say that because it's um these reports create a lot of anxiety at our school sites our principal start to struggle when they get their allocations and they're less every year and so I I
260empathize with that feeling because I know what that's like and um and I'm hoping that as we continue having these conversations about the budget that our schools our school sites and all of the employees that take care of our students and work with our students are at the center of our decision- making thank you very much for your your report Dr Rivas um I understand that you know our biggest expense in relation to enrollment is Staffing um and I think you know I appreciate the graph but it would be great to add like how much um just number signs you know the how much you're spending on certific uh certified support um certif certified admin just so so we understand we see the percentages but it would be good to see the actual amount that
261we're spending on everyone but um but my also concern um as we're you know um when we're with the contracts come up and we're voting on these different contracts I do see that you know there are other budget categories that they're not here that we're also spending on particularly when it comes to professional Consulting um I know that we were spending at least 560 million um for 23 24 on professional Consulting so although we are you know we in comparison to ROM we have a lot of Staffing but then we're also spending a lot of money on you know external um Contracting for Consulting part today we did 5 million for uh two firms for you know our debt servicing which I understand but I think we also have to be cognizant that um where
262are we're also spending on contracts that as like do we actually can we do this inhouse or can we maybe uh reduce the contract in that so you know professional Consulting is also increasing so just wanted to bring that up that you know there's a lot of money going out in other firms and in other contracts that you know we should probably be conent of reducing the amount that we're spending on professional Consulting Mr melbo sure thank you it was helpful to ask questions throughout so found this helpful and I think the clarity around fund 17 and reserves and all that um are important um you know on the charts I'll say two things one I do think that the the scale because staff and enrollment numbers are off it's a little misleading but the
263trends are helpful but what I've said every time these come up is we still don't have except for teachers and I guess a few other Norm positions we don't have as a district a sense of Ideal Staffing ratios and so you see classified going up 42% well when I was teaching in the district and we cut during the recession like 42 up 42% even with declining enrollment may just be getting back to a baseline level of Staffing that we think is appropriate so I still think we have to have a question as a district and as a board like yes you see enrollment going down and Staffing going up and on one level that could be problematic but if it's just to get back to the numbers of uh caring adults we think should be
264supporting our kids at each School site then it's not as problematic as it seems um I guess the only question that uh um piggybacks off of something that board member Greg mentioned earlier around School site budgets are are there can you share with us yet what if any changes are are going to be incorporated into budget document um budget development docs for school sites that the board may want to know about ahead of time whether that's around carryover or cap or elop or Ci allocations or is there anything we're going to hear from school sites that will surprise us as a board so the assumptions are the same as last year uh the only difference is that budget development is earlier uh we realized that we were significantly behind where we should be every year
265last year I don't think we finished until almost May uh so we need to align more with the January timeline which is when most districts are developing their budgets for the following year uh so that essentially is the only significant change but the assumptions that schools work with are are currently I'm not going to say entirely I'm going to look behind me and check they're yeah they're the same as last year there are what particular positions when it comes to support especially for it technicians that's Personnel that currently was funded via Esser and onetime resources where we're working with schools uh to either share the cost and this is actually developed with some of our um principal leaders um to think about like how do we sustain that support that actually matches the demand and
266need and so that'll be part of the budget development at the school site right let's help yeah let me ask uh a question suppose you're a little school that has little money is there going to be a a place where the little schools with little money could get it help it would it be the Local District helping with a pool of people that can come to your school is that how it'll work because not everybody has money yes okay all right thank you go ahead Mr oh no I guess the other thing and you alluded to the budget transparency tool but can you remind us when that will be live for the public uh I believe we're demonstrating it almost well it's more than monthly I know that we've done lots of demonstrations for board
267offices and communities it it is a collaboration between my department and strategic planning uh that's also come with an increase in our own tools that we're developing it's it's actually really helpful stuff I believe the resolution called for it to be public by July 1st of this uh coming year if my memory serves correctly um but we are doing iterative versions of that with the board offices and Community to get feedback to make sure that when we release it we will probably always be improving it that's just the way but that it's something that's useful and helpful for the community and for as well as for our colleagues thank you that's it for me you know I think it was really oh go ahead Kelly sorry go ahead I I appreciate the slides as well
268and I think obviously as we continue to be transparent on this budget and learning as we go um one of the things that obviously you mentioned on the slide with the I think it was slide 15 as we see the numbers increased with our other certificated support and the number of teachers go down U being clear to be able to distinguish exactly what that looks like because I think when we moved into uh transition this year and we did see some decreasing in our APS and our coordinators to be able to explain exactly what that increase in 91% looks like and what are the names that are attached to that as far as positions is that something that we can share so people are clear because I know often times that's not very clear um
269and I know when we moved into the R2 ratio show many did not understand um exactly what that meant to the district and how that affects and to Kelly's comment of advocacy at legislative how do we change that for this district and what would that look like in a recommendation so so uh agree that the advocacy would be great and I've spoken to Martha about that um so I'm sure she'll be giving us updates as as she moves forward I she did reference as I mentioned that it's there's been advocacy around that for a while with an unwillingness to change um but I don't know the background of that uh so not as familiar with that um any of the information that that we have as far as positions uh if there are requests we
270will do our best it does take us a while to there's tens of thousands of positions but we will work through whatever the request is and then the other thing as far as teachers are concerned here I know because we obviously don't want to touch anything at a school site um and we're wanting to make sure that our students are cared for what are some positions or areas where we see we obviously need to work on think about um consider as we move forward um to make sure that we are going in the right direction as a result of if I may so as a result of uh potential signif potential labor implications attached to your conversation we actually have a different venue we plan to bring these issues up to the board's attention much
271more detail than we can do here got it yes uh to follow up on on those comments I I too am interested in kind of more explanation and context around the chart certainly um Staffing is one of our largest costs but um again I think the context matters as to why we've seen some of these trend lines you know whether that you know a doubling and other certificated support from 2018 um you know 2019 is when we approved a new contract with utla which included the you know teacher librarian uh requirements at our secondary schools our nurses um Etc so I I think it's just helpful to provide that that color and context um and I know not to repeat myself Mr Mount but you know the start date of this is post uh Great
272Recession so I think on our classified positions in particular we are not necessarily seeing um you know the most appropriate Baseline because we know that many of those positions are cut and yet we continue to hear about more needs for clean and safe schools um throughout our district uh because that amount of space continues to be the same I also wonder you know we've grown our preschool programs during that time and our transitional kindergarten programs which require in addition to um you know smaller adult child ratios they require classified dedicated classified support so I think that there's a number of ways in which these various factors could be impacting this chart that we see and um just want as a board for us to have all that information in front of us as we as
273we make different decisions um I also wanted to take a moment to just appreciate your team and the superintendent for for making those adjustments um from what we saw in June to now certainly uh when I saw the third year at that time I was concerned about the the place that we were in but it sounds like you all have made a lot of prudent decisions um making changes that don't impact what happens at school sites but are in the financial um interest of the district so just want to appreciate the leadership there um and then similar to others you know my continued concern is how to protect School sites and ensure that they have all of the Staffing that is necessary services that are necessary for our students um I hear you that the
274assumptions are not changing but sometimes there's policy decisions that are made that do affect School budgets I think last school year you know there were changes around AP a APS in response to R2 that were a policy change but had budget implications so um I would just say that I that I hope that those kinds of things don't occur mid School budgeting cycle um because it doesn't put our schools in the best place um to be able to make those decisions in a collaborative way with their stakeholders thank you okay and I and I thank the board for asking questions during the presentation because sometimes we wait till the end and we all have a million questions to ask and it's so much better to get it done during the presentation so I hope it
275was okay with you too I I I enjoy that because then I know that you're more clear in that we are we are thank you thank you so much uh now is time to vote on the item before us so is there a motion to hear to vote on t five I'll move it move by um I'm Sorry Miss gones and then seconded by my eyes are failing I'm Sorry by Dr Ras okay and uh Miss handy nubel yes Dr Ras yes Mr melbin yes Miss pgo yes Miss gones yes Miss STI Franklin know she's been here but we will come back in board president shos yes so it's six eyes okay just a quick comment I really want to thank the bo for your for your very very um objective reasonable questions uh and
276participation in today's conversation this is not an easy one you know we keep telling uh the board the community that tough times lie ahead they they do they do we cannot deny that but uh thank you for for the objectivity with you you tackled this this uh in-depth presentation I also want to thank Chris Mount and his team for the very deliberate and strategic work that's been done I know that uh he has been briefing the board and your board staff's in advance of today's meetings and that will continue specific to two points that were brought up at the end of the presentation we really don't anticipate significant changes uh to the budgeting process going into this coming year um whether they are are in practice or policy number one I think that we did
277that last year we still have to fix the structural deficit that that's a much deeper longer conversation that we will have with the board uh the second point is and I think this was brought up actually I think by most of you um we made a commitment uh in advance of the approval of the budget for this year for 2425 that there would be no impacts at staff uh at any level at schools uh we're living up to commitment and hopefully with continued prudent management of of the budget condition and some degree of assistance from Sacramento particularly in terms of of cola uh we are hoping for a decent outcome uh that would prevent uh Draconian impacts at any level of District particularly the School site where you will continue to see and you will
278hear some noise where you'll continue to hear and see reductions are in non-school site budgets and that includes central office bodry Investments contracts at all levels and we've actually taken big bites out of what we contract out uh but also the you know the Pacman conversation that looks at vacant positions questions uh their worth their value and more than likely those positions don't get reauthorized don't get filled uh we cannot sustain a budget process where we protect the schools and everything else and hope that we emerge out of the conditions that uh that Chris eloquently detailed for the board so Chris and your team thank you very much I really want to thank the board for your patient consideration of the recommendations that you ended up approving thank you thank you board okay that concludes
279all the business for Action before the board at this board meeting we will now move on to I don't know if I added myself to co-sponsor the computer science Miss gon's resolution I did okay I could remember welcome your co-sponsor okay I want ah thanks let me make that note any other sponsors co-sponsors that we want to kind of get to while we're here yes charlette and then Nick this is for 12 12 he yes for me let's let's do this right how about so for tab 12 I have uh Mr Schmelson Dr Ras uh Miss handy newbill and Mr meloine okay and then for tab 11 I have have um the student board member Mr Melo Miss handy newbill and m board president sharlon oh okay okay all right Perfect all right now we'll
280move on to public comment I see folks have started to show up which is great we are just about right on time um I'm going to call on the folks who I know absolutely are here in this moment and then we will return to the actual order as people signed up all right so Michael Gray are you here Michael Gray come on up you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin hello I am Michael Gray and I work at Thomas Jefferson High School a community school in region East music teacher for eight years and chapter chair uh this school year La USD has revised its stance on Community Schools PD autonomy and schools have been instructed to follow the district's PD bulletin at our first lslc meeting of the school year our principal made
281it clear to all stakeholders that the district mandated PDS were going to happen and that lslc had but a few open slots this was just after we reviewed the contract stating that this shared decision-making body has 100% decision making perview on PD this essentially shut down the conversation about what our school needs are in terms of PD and turns the group into a rubber stamp committee why would our Community Partners continue to show up if their voices are not being heard utla and Community Schools are asking that LAUSD comply with article 25 section uh 25- c section 4A of the agreement which grants LSL se's the authority to have decision making purview over site based professional development part of being a community school is getting all teachers egi certified Equity grading and instruction within two
282years and sadly this is not going to happen at our site we were able to squeeze in a 30 minute presentation on the topic while the certification process is a six two is six 2our PDS our School site has a disproportionate number of Ds and Fs and this egi training is crucial for all staff this District's own bulletin 1 353.com man that La USD respect the autonomy of the lslc to determine the subject M matter of Bank time professional development thank you very much thank you for your time okay Brian Z brano are you here Brian Z come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin hello my name is Brian I'm an 11th grader at Edward or royall Learning Center and the leader in students in students deserve I want to
283share with you the demands I have for superintendent carvalo and the school board we we we demand you to assign $100 million annually to Bea to ensure the sustainability and effective Effectiveness in meeting the needs of black students and I repeat this is a need not a want I understand that there are some new members which are Garla GGO and Char Neo and I want to welcome you both and hope that you join join us in this fight and put the black back in Bap furthermore in the American Constitution it states that it is the right of the people to alter or abolish any government that is not meeting the need of the people and to Institute a new government I will state this again if you don't assign $100 million annually to Bab to
284ensure the sustainability and Effectiveness to meet these needs of black students we will take you down from your positions as the school board members and we will get better people to be up there this money can generally help a lot of people like my friend I was not I will not State his name but BF can help my friend who has stated that he has problems with money like not having enough money for groceries or rent he is my age yet he has a job all the way in hotor Imagine going back and forth from here to hotor every day getting home late at night and and bra have any time for school imagine trying to learn that situation and having no one to go to no one to go to seek support Bap has
285helped many others through targeted support and programs and staff that understand and can focus on their situations I believe that bf can help my friend too but imagine many black students getting what little academic support they have cut due to to Black being cut from bab it would be a big tragedy if you were to remove the black from bab so please for my friend and many others put the black back in Bap and assign $100 million so that Bap is able to to be sustainable and effective thank you for the school board members who are on our side in this fight and I hope Carla grego and Char new um just finish up you're good you but the the new members join us on join on putting the black back in Bap and folling
286to whoever isn't on our side then just remember we the people have the right to change this government to meet our needs and that you work for us thank you for this opportunity to speak put the black back in Bap thank you for your time Brian simile Brian s a different different Brian Brian s simil please come on up good afternoon my name is Brian Simley and I serve as a chapter chair at Woodin Hills Academy a proud Community School unfortunately the district has now imposed a one-size fits-all approach to professional development which has negatively impacted our school as a new community school we have significant work to do but much of our PD time has been consumed by District mandated sessions that are not tailored to our community's needs the interest holders at my
287school within Hills Academy have been attempting to align our PD with our school's Vision this includes fostering culturally responsive pedagogical practices Equitable grading and instruction project-based learning grounded in a real in real world issues improving School climate through PBIS utilizing relevant student data to guide decisionmaking and advancing authentic family and Community engagement as you know community schools like ours not only support the whole child but also aim to transform communities to achieve this it is essential that LAUSD respect the autonomy of lslc to determine the focus of Bank time professional development empowering lslc to lead PD ensures that schools can address the unique needs of their diverse communities effectively Educators staff and families must have the authority to to collaboratively plan professional development that reflects their school specific challenges and opportunities this tailored approach ensures
288that resources and support are directed where they are needed most creating better outcomes for students and stronger communities overall we are urging L USD to honor the contract by immediately granting interest holders full autonomy over Bank time professional development as school board members we ask you to Advocate on behalf of the community schools in your District by engaging with LD and ensuring compliance with article 25 of the contract thank you thank you for your time Emily grihalva Emily grihalva come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin then after Emily will be Christie I can't pronounce the last name serak or carck Carrick so first Emily and then Christie hello my name is Emily Galva and I am the proud community school coordinator at Mendes High School I am also a new
289member of the community school steering committee and an LUSD parent I'm here to ask that you all support Community teachers and their intellect and professional experience as a community school we go through a thorough process to assess our school Community needs and assets this includes our students families and staff we know what our students needs are not all our communities and their needs are the same just recently Mendes high school went through a traumatic removal of their beloved principal our school Community is hurting and needs time to rebuild we have had five interim principles and hope for some stability next semester with a new principal unfortunately these cookie cutter PDS are denying us meeting these needs and growing as Learners I am in fact reminded of the failed open court curriculum as our admin is
290forced to play really poorly produced videos and presentations pause ask for questions reading off a script while teachers are disengaged and not given the opportunity to learn and plan together we talk a lot about the whole child Project based learning social emotional learning egi linked learning and more and yet when our Ed when are Educators supposed to plan to do these important and research-based learning strategies what about aiming also for a whole teacher approach where we treat our teachers with respect as the lifelong Learners they are and don't get me started on the silly videos we are forced to watch during faculty meetings this is why the super majority of Community School coordinators and chapter chairs have signed on to the petition demanding PD autonomy I have copies of the petition which I will distribute
291to all of you I am here to advocate for our teachers and students let's make sure we truly are student centered and relationship focused and let's uplift our community schools contract that clearly states that local school Leadership Council have decisionmaking over all site based professional development it takes a village to support our students and yet you are excluding the most important stakeholders our teachers as Maya Angelo once said when you know better do better thank you thank you for your time all right chrisy come on up you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin chrisy Carrick hello my name is Christy Carrick and I work at Town Avenue Community School in Carson we are in our second year as a community school and I am the proud community school coordinator I am happy to
292say that I've been educated by L USD and my children attend La USD schools I am here today to emphasize the vital role of community empowerment in shaping and determining professional development at my school and at all Community Schools this school year La USD has revised its stance on Community Schools PD autonomy as you know schools have been instructed to follow the District's PD bulletin well at Town Avenue this shift has posed a challenge to our efforts to prioritize the specific needs of our students and Community as a community school we value collaboration and we have relied on stakehold stakeholder input to create PD opportunities focused on strategies like project-based learning social emotional learning and culturally responsive teaching practices we at town have identified as essential to Student Success with specific presenters in mind for
293our trainings our school has gathered unique datadriven insights into the specific professional development needs of our faculty carefully identified through surveys collaborative discussions and Analysis our lslc at Town Avenue is strong and our Chapter Chair and admin communicate effectively however due to the new District mandates we are no longer able to leverage this valuable information to tailor specific professional development to the needs of our staff this shift undermines our ability to address the targeted areas that could most effectively support our students and enhance our Educators growth we are asking l l USD to follow through on the contract immediately and Grant Community Schools full autonomy over the bank time professional development as school board members we ask you to exercise your Authority on behalf of the community schools in your board District by speaking with
294LA USC and telling them to follow article 25 of the contract thank you for your time thank you for your time all right I'm going to call up four folks with the first person please come up to the podium and then the other three just be please ready to go uh Emanuel and walli Emanuel come on up and then Romy grego then Macky Draper and Cheryl koono I'm sorry okay yeah as soon as that person on we'll um maybe you could tell Emanuel that we'll take the Callins after all the inperson folks just out of respect for those who are here um Romey grego are you here come on up you have two minutes to speak once you begin my name is Romy greo I'm a senior at Eagle Rock High School and a student
295leader and students deserve I go to a school where I'm welcomed by people who look like me my college counselor pulls me into her office to make sure that I'm on the right track with my college applications and my counselor checks in on me to make sure that I'm doing okay whenever she has a chance these are the people these are the people who look like me who know me and who care for me and although there's definitely not enough of them they're the reason I come to school every day if I get to see myself in my education and in my teachers and in my psws then why are you keeping those resources and opportunities from black students why did you remove race as a criteria for Bap why did you take the black
296out of Bap most of you made a promise to black students and families four years ago to make sure that they have people on their campus that they feel safe with you promised bap bap academic counselors psws Bap School climate Advocates safe passages Bap field trips and for black students to see themselves in their curriculum most of these promises haven't been fully realized you promised black students fully funded schools for the first time in history and after four years you're taking that away you failed to inform the students who fought hard for Bap that you were taking the black out of it students trusted you parents trusted you community members trusted you and you're losing our trust by changing the program without consulting us or Consulting the BPS here in committee two of you just
297got sworn in this or more than two of you but two new ones just got sworn in this morning that you would take care of the Youth of Los Angeles you both weren't there to make a promise to black students but now is your chance to make one students need you to fight for us we need you to renew the promise that the board made before you came on and we need you to follow through on it you need to fight for the black students that you promised you would take care of by committing that every resource that has been promised to black students remains in place and focused on black students we're calling on all of you the board and the superintendent to pass a motion to reaffirm that Bap is a reparative program
298especially to remedy the Decades of irreparable harm caused by L's racially discriminatory policies against the civil rights of black students you all have the job to put the black back in Bap thank you thank you for your time Mr Draper come on up Mr Draper and then after Mr Draper is uh miss koono good afternoon returning and new board members my name is m Draper I am a senior at dorsy high school and a proud leader in students Reserve I first want to welcome Miss GGO and Miss newbill uh to the school board I'm looking forward to a school year or more so for me as another semester as an LD student with you representing me with this being said I have some things I'm expecting to be accomplished by you all as a board
299I'm going to bother you guys again about the terrible and quite disgusting decision to remove race as a criteria for Bap this decision was influen inuenced by people across the country the people in this room this community this city all want you to restore Bap protect Bap and for expand Bap and we are expecting you to do so we have the funds and the support for this so let's get this going next I'm expecting you to to issue an apology to all black families and Bap students about this instance you have stretched resources from black students and families and when you guys fix this issue we are expecting your most sincere apologies in a very professional letter we are also expecting for you to all commit to empowering the Bop Bap steering committee and sharing
300information and updates with both the Bap sen committee and the public this doesn't take much of your time or effort to do and I'm expecting for you all to accomplish these minute things finally I want to speak directly to the newly elected Carla grigo Charlotte hendy Nill and the reelected Scotch marlson with you guys coming into this position of power I wanted to be remembered that as board members you work for the students and not the other way around you have to make sure that you guys are making decisions that will actually benefit students of all identities with that being said us as students deserve and in and those in the community are willing to work with you to make LD better than what it actually is so please work with us to fix this
301District thank you thank you for your time Cheryl koono Cheryl K Miss koono are you here all right let's see I'm gonna call on the next three or four folks kishan are you here kishan H come on up and then Carla Davalos and then Zep G so kesan Carla and Zep May Happ thank you thank you sir you have two minutes to speak once you begin all right good afternoon superintendent carvalo and the members of school board welcome to the new members my name is kesan I go to Hamilton High and I want every single one of y'all to know how to hear me out right now it's important to advance literacy to every student in the district and that's connected that's directly connected to the resources that black students were supposed to get through
302Bap to support education and achievement I just want to ask those to the ones who've been here of the school board already I just want to know what's wrong with y'all like what is going through your minds to think it's okay to take Bap out the black out of Bap cuz it's not okay to me and I'm highly upset about it I don't think y'all really fully understand how important and valuable Bap is Bap is a program based to support and guide students down the right path of success throughout high school and set them on the right path of success for college Bap offered us the support the help and the opportunity to connect and bond with students in the community bap Bap isn't just a program Bap is seen as a helping hand and
303support in for care for me Bap implemented character growth and development Bap helped me navigate my way through high school with support and the help to set me on the right path to success as a black man as a black team making his way through life Bap impacted Me by helping our community grow as one and build together as a whole Bap isn't just any program it's a program that became valuable and important to thing important thing to our black community in lsusd to help not just me but other black students like me move and Thrive throughout high school so you either reconsider your thoughts and actions to remove the black out of Bap or you would just have to hear us all out until you understand why Bap is important to us and UCL
304and lsusd thank you thank you for your time Carla Davalos Carla d z NEP G ZB let's see aania Nolasco ivania joasia are you here uh Delilah Irwin are you here Delilah Irwin uh lordes Keo lordes are you here uh Marcela well actually M tro I see you're out there m Treo okay you're going to seed your time thank you appreciate you being here and doing that and then we've got you both in the house so uh please just say your name first name is fine two minutes will be yours thank you hello everybody this is my first time doing this but I'm just speaking from my heart um hello my name is Jay Santini rone I am 32 years old I'm a single mother of four children I'm a parent leer of student deserve
305also a black lives matter member of Los Angeles and an advocate of reclaim our schools LA and I'm also Advocate with thriving families I want to share with you the demands I have for superintendent carvalo and the school board Bap needs to be made permanent and needs to be expanded we need we need L USD to reaffirm their commitment to black students and expand funding to Bap by additional hund million and honestly a lot of people they write stuff from their heart but I'mma just speak from my heart um because that's who I am as a person I know you all you guys are tired you've been here all morning but honestly this matters Bap matters these kids matters my kids matters you guys matter I matter and honestly I wish they had beap program
306when I was growing up cuz if they had a beap program when I was growing up up I wouldn't have been in bad foster homes bad group homes homeless on these streets my four children tooken away from me because of the broken system you know and all it takes is that seed you guys can be that seed to make that change you know God puts you where he put you for a reason you got your La USD job for a reason you know this Bap program matters to these kids it's really making addition you know uh a change in their lives you know don't look at them not saying you guys are but don't look at like they're just another number you know like okay hurry up next person I'm ready I'm ready to go
307home we all got trauma we all got a story you know and honestly this Bap program is helping these kids and I want to fight for these kids and you guys should fight for these kids honestly I'm speaking from my heart not because okay this is another day let me go back to my life I really excuse my language give a about these kids and I really care about you guys keeping the beap program honestly I else I wouldn't even be up here I didn't like compare this or anything but you guys need to keep Bap and put the black back in Bap a thank you for your time Jorge B Jorge B Jorge B are you here all right Shelby Richardson are you here Shelby Richardson I think Shelby just signed up Shelby Richardson
308are you here all right here she comes floor is yours you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin hey folks how are you guys doing today um thank you for having me here this is my first time speaking at a la USD board meeting so I'm super super excited to be here um but also more importantly to advocate for my students who I work with um I work at the social justice learning Institute in Englewood a nonprofit organization dedicated to advancing education equity I have the privilege of working with black and brown high school students across La USD and I see the direct impact of the black student achievement program of their lives for the past four years BP has been a Cornerstone of support providing vital resources that benefit students who have long
309been underserved that's why I'm here today deeply concerned about discussions around removing black from Bap or it's not even a discussion it it happened right and I'm just wondering for purpose what does the racial Focus need to be erased or why does the racial Focus need to be erased when the program is already proven to benefit a student body that is a majority in so many La USD schools Bap exists to address inequities specific to black students and those needs have not disappeared changing the identity of this program RIS erasing is very purpose black students in LAUSD have historically been disproportionately impacted by systemic inequal qualities inequities and Bap was created to address those disparities directly and it has been working for the past four years again it is working why change something that is
310clearly benefiting students I urge the board to recognize the power and purpose of keeping the black and Bap this program is not just a name it's a promise a promise to uplift and support black students who deserve Equitable access to resources and opportunities and let's not abandon that promise thank you thank you for your time all right let's see Emanuel n is not on the line yet let's see uh Karina Lopez I see you're on the line please press star six to unmute yourself and you'll have two minutes to speak once you begin Karina Lopez Miss Lopez is going to speak in Spanish so if you'd like to hear what she's going to say in English please put your hands up we'll get these translation headsets to you thank you he's coming he's getting you
311one more he'll be right there okay here he comes I'm not sure he knows exactly who perfect okay Karina Lopez please please press star six to unmute yourself and you have two minutes to speak when you begin Kina Lopez oh yes my name is Kina Lopez and I am calling because to give a public comment in regards to the lack of school security uh recently in at one of the schools where one of the LUSD schools a student with dis capacities had f in his blood and that's what a medical provider said we have the results we have the laboratory results with us the student expressed that he felt bad and he was feeling really terrible for 3 days he wanted to leave the school there were he had aggressive behaviors he didn't want to
312go to school he was declared six the school would allow him to leave and finally there was an incident where he was taken to the hospital the results were he had fentanyl in his body another student was giving him candies but in reality it was drug I can't say the school the name of the school or the name of the student we don't want an investigation to open but I do want to say that we need school police inside and outside the schools it is necessary it is a necessity everyone can have their own business but enter a sanctuary place like the schools that shouldn't be allowed that should not be allowed now in regards to the early resolution how will you project the and consider the parents parents don't even know the budget that
313the schools have to be able to in to be able to help the students where are all these funds going what are you doing with all these funds we need more security and that is it sir thank you and she is not here in person so that concludes general public comment just yeah let let me just say uh we really appreciate everyone's following the two-minute rule for speaking it's fair and we always let you finish a thought or a statement so thank you very much for following the two-minute rule I appreciate it thank you so much okay um it's time to adjourn the meeting are there any adjourning motions are there any objections to adjourning the meeting no okay the meeting is adour the time is now 3:53 [Music]