CorpusRecord 4017

02/04/2025: School Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Anchorage School District
Date
2025-02-05
Location
Anchorage Municipality, AK
Material
Transcript
Extent
27,830 words · about 155 min
Collected
2026-05-16

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e doing a quick mic check for Zoom audio quick mic check for Zoom audio and okay there we go so for e recording in progress e e at 6:01 PM I'm calling this business meeting of the Anchorage School District board to order um asking board members to find their seats uh we do have all board members in attendance in person tonight and um I'm going to ask student representative Pac to lead us in the flag salute thank you and I'll Alo ask member pack please read Our Land acknowledgement we acknowledge that we gather here today on traditional lands of the Deni of people of the upper Cook Inlet for thousands of years the den of people have been and continue to be the stewards of this land est's committed to diversity and inclusion and is

002with honor and respect that we recognize all indigenous people who live and learn in our community thank you very much also going to remind board members to please uh get close to your microphones use a loud voice also if you do turn your microphone on it actually puts your name on the screen right in front of me um and so initially we I think there's a different system that we'll actually be using down the road uh but that's maybe the best way tonight to make sure I you get my attention and get in the speaking order um would entertain a motion to approve the agenda as presented move to approve the agenda as listed second moved and seconded to approve the agenda if there is no objection the agenda will be approved as presented to

003you that brings us to section B reports and first up we have our student representative report thank you Mr President um biggest item for me to report is that our next Sab meeting is next week it'll be on the 11th um from 12:30 to 2:30 pm and in this meeting we're going to have service High School Frontier golden View and Highland Academy present U videos or presentations on their schools so our students can share the unique programs that we have in our community um we're also going to consider a bylaw Amendment so that we move our some of our executive board position elections earlier on and in this in this meeting or this coming meeting we're going to elect our new oncoming president-elect so hopefully whoever is elected will join me on my side by

004the next school meeting um and then of course the big item that um the elephant in the room is the proposed budget and it's crippling simply put um for especially my school and all our schools obviously but with this issue um in mind we're hoping to have our sabb delegates learn how to equip themselves and their peers on how to you know properly advocate for themselves and express their opinions to their legislators um in this month in the coming months so that we can do something about this issue and then finally we will um have our vice president secretary in public relations um elections in the March meeting that concludes my report thank you and do we have any um reports from board members on conferences or committee reports seeing none we'll move to section

005c goal monitoring student achievement grades 3 through eight uh map growth testing and assessment superintendent thank you Mr President so today I'll just briefly walk the board through our technical presentation for map proficiency we'll talk about this in two weeks this report will cover uh two inter term goals one for map growth on grades three through five and the other for map growth grades 6 through eight let's start with three through five so on this Slide the board and public can see that the the district has a goal to increase the percent of three through five grade level students out or above math benchmark on the map growth assessment the goal is to increase to 65% from 51. 2% um by Spring 2028 on this Slide the board can see a high level overview of

006where the district is at um for this current school year the evaluation of performance for the school is currently near the annual Target um our Target um you can see at the chart on the bottom on the right hand side the the target for spring would be uh 55.3 for 2425 and you can see right now we're at 53.8 for the winter snapshot um so this goal is Within Reach next slide please uh we're also providing board members with this data disaggregated by grade levels this is the goal on three through five you can see that group compared to uh itself for the fall and winter snapshots and uh this is the same type of breakdown but disaggregated by uh race ethnicity gender special subpopulations this would be a core component of our discussion in

007two weeks and then as I mentioned this is a two-part uh goal monitoring conversation we'll also look at the interim goal for grades 6 through eight students next slide uh and we'll leave the board with this data to look at over the next couple of weeks but you'll see that we are near the annual Target um the spring Target is 55.9% BAS on our winter snapshot we're at 54.5 so this is Within Reach between now and spring and similarly this data will be broken down by grade level for you to to review the next couple of weeks and similarly this data is also disaggregated and you can compare the winter to fall snapshots and then uh another piece of our conversation will be the Strategic plan for math proficiency see if we could go to

008the next slide and the the next one after that uh we'll see an overview of everything the administration is working to date um everything from data discussions the multi-tiered systems of support curriculum implementation strategies as well as direct instruction uh we'll have our content experts here in two weeks to discuss that and that concludes the technical presentation board members have any questions member Don thank Mr President um Mr superintendent um we got some really concerning numbers about a month ago about overall proficiency on math that we were we fell 1% overall from 35% to 34% where's the where's the biggest gap of occurring this this time if our as this report indicates our 3 through five MCH proficiency is moving up slightly um there must have been a pretty dramatic problem in some other grades

009good question member dley if I'm not mistaken I think you're referring to the nape scores that are recently released for the state so for the Public's understanding I know the board members are aware the nape and map growth are two very different assessments so the nape is actually what the district uses to create what they call the national report card that is really intended to provide just a snapshot as to how different states are doing between other states because it's very hard to have all 50 states complete one assessment I would say that this data is more timely and responsive to what our students know and are able to do now um so unlike the nape the nape for example again is a national assessment it's not conducted at every single School in in Alaska

010and certainly not every single School in the country and it has a limited scope and it may or may not be aligned to the scope and sequence of map instruction for Alaska the what you'll see here on the map growth assessment is three snap shots tied within a year between fall winter and spring so we can see for our for every single um grades three through eight student um we can look at that growth so I would encourage the full board to pay more close attention to the map growth assessment versus the the more higher level broad nape scores there could be some overlap but I want to be very clear that they're two distinct assessments member wson I think that member Donley is referring to um the mathal monitoring that we did in October

011about student proficiency on the AK star test in I mean you didn't name it but I just chucked on our goals what have we recently looked at and we did discuss um the AK star for uh I guess it was last year's eth graders um right who tested last spring were now this year's ninth graders and I I think that's what you were concerned about it was characterized as being across all grades this this evaluation um and I I looks like we're doing pretty we're making progress with grades 3 through five and so I was trying to relate that to the the the the reporting that that these other the decrease was occurring across alls aggregate thank you for that I misunderstood and let us s a rabbit hole so I'll go ahead and let

012our technical expert clarify was there anything technical that you wanted to clarify I believe the report uh a while ago was based on the Alaska star data which is the summative test at the end of the school year whereas this is map growth and it's based on growth reports and these are the interim goals yep now I understand so we will talk about this in two weeks wonderful question any other comments or questions if not we'll move to section c on the um I'm sorry section D on the agenda uh superintendent update we set aside a little bit of time for the superintendent and staff to talk about budget issues thank you Mr President so this report is happening a little earlier in our agenda today uh because for the next several board meetings we'll

013be talking about a very important important topic which is our uh budget development process for the upcoming fiscal year so this will be a brief report that'll be led by me and our Chief Financial Officer Andy Ratliff and uh we'll have some slides that we'll show to to board members as well um I'd like to start off my remarks by showing the the audience and the board um a slide that we're pulling up right now this slide so I want to talk a little bit about what's going on I I know that there are a lot of people tuning into this conversation who are very familiar with the budget process in Alaska or ASD but I also recognize that there are new people entering the conversation who may not be aware as to how school

014funding Works what are the timelines what is this budget about so I I thought it would be important for you to hear directly from me about what is going on and what can you as community members do um if look at this budget and see that there are just gaps here and you know I'm looking at an audience full of people and I can see the the concern the exhaustion and the questions that are on our faces so I'd like to really provide just a high level overview as to how we got here what are some next steps so what I prepared for the board that the general public now has access to is our initial budget proposal so this is an exercise that we go through every year and the district is preparing to

015release a balance budget to the Municipality of Anchorage closer to March um why this budget it has been prepared the way that it has is for one very important reason which is that this budget was prepared assuming that the district will not receive any additional funding in Revenue Beyond what's outlined in the law and for those of you who understand school funding it really comes down to this blue bar that you'll see multiply 10 times at the very bottom of every single column on this graph that's what's called the base student allocation so this chart that you're looking at really Tak school funding and you're viewing it through the per student funding experience so that blue bar you may not be able to read it if you're looking at it from the audience but um

016it says 5960 beginning in um years fy4 prior to that it said uh 5930 so the bottom line is that's the amount of funding that the state says that every student um in Alaska it will receive through the foundation formula they put uh that number through this more complicated formula they add multipliers based off of factors such as special education and what have you we'll talk more about that in a minute um but this is the Crux of the school funding conversation that's happening both in this room and in school districts across the state so what's the problem the problem is you'll notice that that blue bar essentially looks the same height um and we're looking at 10 years we're looking at the 2016 2017 school year all the way on the left and then

017we're looking at the um the 2526 school year all the way on the right that's the budget that we're trying to balance right now um there are a couple things that I want to point out here so what what is the core issue here the core issue is that the base student allocation hasn't substantially increased um in about 10 years um you may hear some some people many of whom reside in Juno who will say that we did have a BSA increase back in uh you know FIS school year 2024 I'm going to editorialize this a little bit and say that's a laughable increase and it's laughable because what the legislator said through action was that our students are only worth an additional $30 between FY you know the previous fiscal year and that fy2

018for 30 additional dollars for the entire year so I'm seeing some faces in the room I mean think about um how much more a tank of gas costs in 2025 compared to 2017 there's probably $30 right there thinking about the the cost of eggs the cost of utilities and insurance all these different things and when you really boil it down school districts operate very analogously to a household budget so when you think about the cost of energy for our buildings when you think about the cost of fuel for the school bu cles when you think about the janitors and custodians and teaching assistants and nurses who are all trying to Grapple um with their realities I mean for those of you in the room you don't have to raise your hand but whose rent or

019mortgage payment has gone down since 2017 I know mine has not gone down since 2017 and these are the everyday realities that our staff members have to go through and what the legislature as a body has communicated is that there's not a political will for sustainable predictable school funding reform so what this conversation that we're about to have over the next month is really about this idea that school districts are having to continuously plan their budgets around this blue bar so the punchline the key point that I want you to hear in Earnest for me directly is that the budget that's being presented deliberated discussed uh is not a reflection of the school district's aspirations this is a reflection of about 10 plus years of systemic NE neglect from those who are in charge with

020providing the funding that our kids need to to be successful and what this budget reflects is the Assumption of zero Revenue because the sad reality is that between now and July we don't know if there will be school funding increases and if there were we don't know when we'll have that information and it is a very complicated process that requires both a bill to be passed by the legislature and it also needs to be agreed upon by the governor so you can imagine how this process takes months and months and months but for those of us who are in the room today um we're here wondering what does this mean for my child's education next year and that's where this conversation will move forward so this budget entails reductions to programs that I know are

021valuable and beloved to um one or more if not every person in this room and if something was removed from the budget it's not a reflection that it's not valued it's not a sign that this is something that the district doesn't support it's really a sign of how this budget was prepared so I want to be very clear for the how this budget and why this budget was prepared this way to be completely honest with you if you look at this chart you'll notice some uh Orange um it's at the very top of most of these individual columns that orange represents onetime funding that the state has awarded districts outside of the base student allocation you'll see that they awarded about $220 student in 23 $340 in 24 um a historic $680 one-time increase to

022funding in FY 25 um so there certainly is precedent that we could see uh more funding come to the schools but again we may not know this until well after the budget has to be submitted so how does one prepare a budget when you don't know if or whether that that 5960 will be the the bottom line that you have what it means is that I was forced to prepare a budget that does two things one I wanted to make sure that we avoid massive reductions in force so Anchorage School District is one of the largest public employers um in the state and I take that responsibility very seriously and I want to make sure that if you're a member of Team ASD that we can do whatever we can to hold on to as

023many people employed by our organization as possible while we see what happens in the legislature that's number one number two we're an educational organ organization so I wanted to look at the distribution of funding between direct instruction and student Support Services those are the two most important things you can invest your dollars in that goes directly into kids activities and all the things that they learn from their wonderful teachers um this past year that represented about 81% of as's budget we made sure that that stayed about 81% for this budget too so there are a lot of cuts um but they're trying to work around um what I'm trying to prevent which is a widespread reduction of force with an ASD um so we can mostly lean on attrition and other types of you know

024es and flows to cover this deficit but I hope that this is just the beginning of a long conversation that I hope will end positively but it's not going to end positively until we all come together and figure out how we want to to make our voice is heard so I definitely encourage you if you're listening to my voice today virtually or in the room we want to hear you here at the boardroom table we'll be here several times this month um we'll finalize that number but um I also want to be clear if you're new to the conversation that the the school board and I are really tasked with figuring out how we allocate the resources that were given so if you have feedback for how we can better allocate our resources to provide

025the best education for your child I want to hear that but if you're interested in advocating for the actual funding levels I I do want to be clear that that is a function of the state legislature and Governor so if you want to bring them in the conversation every Community member is empowered to do that and I think that in this in this very dire time this would be a great time to to consider that so those are my opening remarks and our Chief Financial Officer is going to walk Community through a few specific oh I got a clap never got that several claps for the record we thank you so we'll walk through some of the nuts and bolts of the budget um just kind of quick give you a quick overview of you

026know what a revenue picture is going to be like what are some of the things we're reducing and then kind of what are those next steps and a lot of these slides that we have there's a table over there by the entrance that has budget summaries you can pick up one of those it has this in detail if you want to look at them otherwise they're all online digitally as well so right now we're uh produced a balanced budget to uh give the school board um to consider for approval uh the reason we do our budget before just about any one other school district in the state is based on our municipalities Charter that requires we have our budget done by submitted to The End by the first Monday in March so that backs us

027up to getting our budget prepared all the reductions made by the January to submit to the school board in February um also in January the school or the legislature starts their budget development their conversations around funding so we're certainly watching that we'll give you a little bit of updates about what's out there as well um should be noted that process it does take a long time last year we did not know what our final funding was going to be until I think it was June 28 so be able to produce like a long range financial plan you don't know your coming revenues until the year starts is um and that makes it really challenging so as far as our Revenue picture goes um a couple of the things you'll see the property taxes going up

028by about 4.7 million that's reflective of a $7.5 million increase in What's called the required local contribution that the state mandates that we pay as a community into education and then it's offset by a little bit of a reduction about 2.8 million in the additional allowable contribution that's uh districts can it's up to a state cap uh we're fortunate in our municipality that our city's been willing to fund us up to the cap for many years now but we are limited on how much we can collect from the city to help offset some of these losses so you'll see an increase there it should be noted that 75 million million increase in that required local contribution is uh there's a direct $7.5 million offset in state revenue so as you see about $12 million coming

029down a foundation formula um that's just kind of a one toone thing where they cost shifting $75 million to the cities uh other reductions would be generally for uh like enrollment declines our fund balance we're going to use about 12.6 million more than we are using this year that brings us down to about 5% fund balance which 5% is the metric of really what's your um unrestricted fund balance divided into your total expenditures is of that 5% about 4% of it it's used for a a bond rating Reserve that our city has to get better interest rate so overall under this plan we spend down to about $6 million of unassigned reserves for um a a district that's a budget that's you know $8 or $900 million so really not enough money to any sort

030of natural disaster to account for that any sort of large drops in enrollment um just makes it really difficult if we don't have those reserves to cover some of those potential losses overall we're looking at about a $43 million decrease in Revenue based on what is currently in statute from what we received ref plan to receive for fy2 that coupled with about $20 million or so of just kind of natural inflation that you see on that 25 budget of 637 million um that's where you get to about a $65 million of reduction that are needed and that infl inflation the district's about 87% of salary and benefits so that's where most of our money goes is people so as we have contract increases medical insurance increases all those things that go with paying our our

031employees more to help our recruiting and retention efforts it's got to come out of somewhere um so as we go through there and you can add up 60 or 65 million in reductions uh this is really wise because our funding is going down how we allocate our money based on just kind of the state functions um our direct classroom instruction makes up about 58% of our total budget that's teachers PA Professionals in both our special ed and General Ed classrooms um directly working the students all day every day pretty much and that's the supplies the materials equipment um some Services software that goes with those teaching positions um their student supports that's counselors nurses librarian security Student Activities curriculum support development behaviors principles the clerical staff of the schools all those things that allow uh

032school to operate um and have those additional supports for students are really classified in there and then operations and maintenance that's keeping the the buildings safe keeping the utilities on clean um just anything that kind of goes with those uh just maintaining our facilities and then Administration that's generally the folks sitting at this tables the Departments we run uh payroll accounting budget HR it risk management uh Communications the school board the superintendent that's what really uh District administration is the table at the bottom shows those percentages for both 25 and 26 so really we've this is really used to illustrate that we've been reducing from everywhere uh there wasn't a whole lot of places that were held harmless in this budget um we're just kind of finding as much things we possibly could before we

033got to a a PTR increase so getting to our our school based changes um I don't want to go through a lot this is in our budget pan just to kind of give you a high level overview our PTR adjustment is a plus four so on average that's plus four kids in every classroom um in elementary it's less teachers in the building higher class rooms and secondary a lot of times it's higher classes and less electives uh enrollment we did lose a considerable amount of students this year over a thousand this year from what we had projected expected to lose a couple hundred more next year but that was about 70 FTE um hold back teachers then the list goes on principes counselors librarian nurses Library assistants uh clerical staff all kind of these reductions

034that we're having to make at the school level um par professionals noon duties and then there's some of these other kind of outside of the Personnel things like Battle of the book Summer School uh we're cutting hockey gymnastics swim and dive from high school sports uh the Dome contract came out of this budget which usually supports track and soccer um all Middle School sports uh secondary Summer School uh Family Partnership we kind of listed some of these other special programs um outside of that but they're lost enrollment so their budget's coming down as well and then there's a couple things that had small increases we try to just get those the total amount to balance out with Alaska Choice version virtual going up a little bit as we anticipate a few more kids taking virtual

035classes that maybe they can't get in their high schools so special services about 54 FTE this includes ignite um some smaller reductions in some programs including the the school for the de and heart of hearing wh and Elementary special education so you see those about 54 FTE um coming down about5 and a half million dollars uh we've been able to reduce out of there of note we haven't reduced special education funding in uh many years this has been a really hard one to to take I mean this is these kids these students need Services um but this is kind of extraordinary times and you know all my years doing this this is like probably three times larger than any budget reduction we've ever had to weather this single proposal uh we went through all the

036Departments Administration we're going to have have uh for finance payroll or human resources purchasing it we're going to have less support to be offered our um to our staff this is really kind of the backend functions that we have to operate the district uh we're taking Staffing out of teaching and learning we're petting a senior director at academic services and then some custodial which are that's more related to school closures we are closing two elementary schools in this budget lak hood and Thea Valley and then we're cutting mercal or maintenance personnel and a whole host of other add of Duty service supplies and equipment to include you know food travel maintenance contracts um extra help coming in during busy times there's just all these other things that we do to help supplement our Workforce that's

037maybe not be a full-time FTE but uh heavy equipment depreciation those things that we can kind of get around doing for a year so we take out of this budget to help get the balance took about $9 million out of our admin about 42 FTE out of our our departmental or codes so back to this slide that Dr Bryant went through really our funding Gap um from 2011 had it been inflation proof would be about $1,960 more than what it is today um we can use about $700 BSA equivalent in our savings to help Shore that up a little under 50 million but that's all onetime things it'll go away next year and if nothing is addressed it really is going to come back again next year we're going to have a very similar problem

038so we can't really pull any levers ourselves to increase our Revenue we're essentially Beggars of funds we have to ask the state for any new money we get as they either give us the money directly from the state or set the contribution limits by the city so we're at the cap for the city so we're really kind of on reliant on the state but this chart really shows how the state other state budgets have fared since 2017 uh inflation's been about 25% over the time and mostly a lot of these departments do track inflation and really that's what you would expect to see uh just with the normal course of business for salaries supplies equipment that goes up with inflation some of them are two or three times that based on need but if you

039do look up in that gray shaded part there's deed the Department of Education is separated into two components one is the K12 support for districts which has gone down by about 74 million dollars over the last uh nine years and then other deed operations which is kind of the normal staff at DED that are are directing education and that's generally track inflation um so that's part of the pro that's one of the issues that we see is since other departments seem to be inflation proofed uh K12 is not and at the end of the day it comes down to uh K12 education is generally held to the end of the session and it's generally spoken to in conjunction with the PFD so as you're looking at giving folks the choices through this budget process of

040PFD or education that makes it really difficult on our legislators so I really feel for them going in this process but um something needs to change because we cannot sustain this level of funding or lack of there there are a couple bills out there that we wanted to highlight that's in the legislature going through the process now uh HB 69 would base student allocation increases to the preceding three years of average inflation starting in 25 and 26 and then add an additional $1,000 to that base student allocation to help catch up for lost ground um the same in 26 and 27 where they add the three-year rolling average of inflation plus uh 44 each year so at the bottom you can see what those BSA increases would be by year and then this kind of

041shows how that money would be or how much money that would realize so under the the First Column is what we have this year the second column is what we're budgeted on based on current statute and in the third column is what would change based on HB 69 passing um about $92 $92 million additional funding for the current year which would allow us to if we added back the roughly $65 million of cuts and that's kind of what we could do not necessarily what we would do but kind of that illustrative example um adding add that back we would spend our about still spend about $23 million our savings but be in a healthy range for having enough to WEA any emergencies and then in future years it might allow us to add back some

042uh either decrease class size or add other high value interventions that could be uh to help our students succeed this would enable and then it's inflation proof thereafter after those first three years so that would really enable us to do long-term planning both financial and instructional um that's really kind of what we've been missing for the last 20 years that I've been in uh governmental accounting so hb76 and S sp82 this was the ones the governor submitted at the for his request it includes a $450 per k6 student incentive for reading proficiency so for every student you have proficient you get in those grade bands you get $450 I'm not exactly sure how many students hav gone back and how many students that would apply to for us but if it were you know 10,000

043or so that would be $4.5 million uh one of the other things would be Charter Schools approved by the state board which would allow the State Board to insert Charter Schools directly into a district without school board approval um there is a transportation increase of $13 per non-correspondence amm in there um which is good we do our transportation fund has been increasingly uh had to been Shor up by property taxes as well well uh it does extend the moratorium on bond debt reimbursement from 2025 to 2030 and this is when a new bond is voted on by the approvers or the the voters um prior to 2015 state would pick up 60 or 70% of the cost of repayment of those bonds they put a moratorium on that in 2015 it's supposed to expire in

04425 this would just continue that moratorium where the cities are paying 100% of the bonds it would move correspondence ADM in the foundation formula from the end of the formula where it's multiplied by a 90% Factor versus uh moving it up to the front where it goes through the the rest of the the foundation formula and I'll explain a little bit of that here kind of show you how that works mechanically and then it would increase there's a multiplier in the formula that would for CTE that would go 1 and a half% to 4% and then also provide $5,000 feature recruitment retention bonuses paid by the state so how that looks for the correspondence it would generate about $3.8 million in additional Revenue about $8.4 million in course or CTE Revenue with that multiplier and

045about $4 million in new transportation funding um and probably a little bit more on the incentive for the $450 per proficient student uh but really if we were to add that back the $12 million back based on the budget additions that we got this year we we would still have to make you know 5253 million in budget reductions um this year and then another 68 or so next year so it doesn't really have a long-term uh solution to our to our problem what that looks for correspondence programs you'll see two different colored bands the light blue and at the top is how the funding currently works for schools um I chose Family Partnership as the largest correspondent School in our district and West High School is the largest High School in our district so for

046Family Partnership right now it goes from you know a little over, ADM that gets multiplied by 90% and that's how their uh funding work there is generated into a basic need little under $5,400 per student um for West High they go through a school size factor which if you have more than 1,22 students in the state formula you start getting less than a 1.0 uh adjustment for school size Factor so State Foundation formula set up where smaller schools get more money per student than larger schools and this is the mechanism in which they uh apply that so it gets adjusted down for the school size Factor there's a 20 20% special ed multiplier for special education elll gifted and um indigenous education and then it goes through a CTE multiplier that's currently one and a

047half% to get to a a basic uh a total basic need not including intensive need students those are funded separately and wouldn't change but about $6,800 per non-intensive student um under the new proposals the correspondent schools would go to a 1.0 uh and that's adjusted by school size Factor they metric add the 20% and then add the 4% CTE multiplier eventually get to a little over $7,400 per student per correspondence for correspondence kids um conversely for West High that would go to about $7,000 per student so now we'd be getting about $500 less per student for comprehensive high schools than we would for correspondence um other schools in the district that would we would get less money per correspondent student would be Bartlett East Diamond Service South roig and MIRS um so really that's the

048there's it should be less expensive to do correspondence but this proposal would put more money towards correspondence programs than it would towards comprehensive high schools of that size so that's really kind of the big moving pieces that we have in the legislature um and then what we're reducing in our budget and kind of the why behind it board members have questions or comments member Jacobs yeah thank you Mr chair I appreciate the presentation Dr Briant and Mr rff um you know a question and I um I'm prefacing it by stating that I'm referring to the um university of Alaska's Institute of social economic research um study I think the last two that they produced on a state comparison of Education spending indicated that Alaska is now below the national average once you adjust dollar spent

049for cost of living I'm just curious if Administration can share perspective as to why it's helpful to um factor in cost of living and things like the price of Utilities in a given State Health Insurance both of which tend to be higher in Alaska when you're looking at um adding additional context versus Raw dollar spend on education things thank you member Jacobs really when you're comparing the amount of resources that can be bought with a certain number of dollars I mean if you can per have a teacher on staff for 120,000 130,000 in Alaska um somewhere in you know Oklahoma Kansas where it's considerably less expensive to do business for that same amount of money uh you could probably hire two teachers you know it's uh it's really is important to factor in that geographical

050differential and that's why there's a big component of it in the state formula too to because it's considerably more expensive to do business out in Gnome or C than it probably is in Anchorage uh that District cost factor in Anchorage really hasn't been looked at for you know 20 plus years that data is about 25 years old now but to be able to having to consider as you're looking at why states spend more per student um those cost differentials between regions are really important other comments or questions member Wilson the board has heard suggestions that selling a physical school property or diverting F funds from a voter approved school bond might help mitigate this future the future budget deficits can you please explain why this is not a feasible option certainly so we don't actually

051own the school buildings that's a function of the municipality we have designated management rights over our land and Facilities so if we declare a building or piece of property excess that just reverts back to the city then they can do what they want with it um and really for if they were to sell it they really couldn't give us the money because it's that required or that maximum local contribution doesn't really count or care where the source of those funds came from from um whether it's property taxes or inl of property taxes they can't give us more money even if they were to take our property and sell it and what was the other part of the question oh for the bonds um yeah those are narly focused by approved by the voters so they're

052uh more narrow in what they can be spent on so we couldn't sell a bond instead of doing capital and appreciating it just say we're going to use that for operating expenditures for a year so it's more about the language actually have in the bond proposals uh limiting what we can do with the money any other questions or comments remember B me the um maybe not well it is a question but more of a clarification so listening to some all of the testimony and not all of it but a lot of testimony in Juno there was a suggestion that we hold salar flat as a way to balance our budget um we are currently settling is it two or three contracts uh there's three I believe there's three that will end at the end the

053year and so I guess my question is uh I mean I think we've done our best to do more with left or kind of keep things status quo but can you explain how how failing to provide a competitive wage and Affordable Health Care uh would impact the challenges of our ability to recruit and to retain and recruit quality I'll make an attempt to respond to that one Mark Miss bamy but um we already see significant challenges in attracting and ret retaining quality ified staff in the district um we turn over somewhere between about three and 400 teaching positions on average per year the local university only produces about um 100 licensed graduates per year for the whole state um who are ready to enter the classroom as teachers and so the state of Alaska right

054now isn't even producing enough teachers to fill the need that Anchorage has so that means we have to Source every year about 2third of our qualified staff from out of state and sometimes from out of country and right now we are not competitive with many of our West Coast peers when it comes to teacher salaries and benefits and so if we don't make um increases in wages that at least keep up with local inflation then we really are um behind in terms of our ability to attract and keep those teachers in the the district that we need in our classrooms in order to see the student outcomes that we want and so that's a particular challenge that rubs up against the challenge of this budget deficit but um not providing any meaningful wage increases for

055our employees just means we'll have a more difficult time holding on to those employees and if I could add some color and anecdote to that rather um when I started as superintendent back in 2022 is some people remember we had this transportation crisis and one of the first questions that I asked it was like my first month on the job was wait um why have transportation professional wages been held flat and as we dug and dug more into it it turns out it's because transportation funding had been flat um from the state um for years so we are essentially paying 2019 wages in 2022 and when the labor market is thriving at the time we had an incredible tourism season guess what happened uh our transportation professionals took incredible opport unities in the private sector

056in adjacent areas and our teachers are are very similar um all of our bargaining units uh we need to be competitive because if we're not competitive those vacancies will be empty and then I'll actually close with a quote um from a member of the state board on uh salaries um this is a former um commissioner actually um he said if we're really going to have a system where anybody can run for office and be able financially to do it we we have to have salaries that are commensurate to that need so that's regarding increases for elected officials including the governor and legislators and I would replace that line with teachers and I think that's very true thank you thank you any other um member Donal and member J thank you so Andy um can we

057go back to that like the bar slide that shows a series of years okay so could you explain the yellow Parts in the last three fiscal years there what those are sure so the yellow bars at the bottom are the fund balance so this is the district's General government equivalent of savings accounts that we've spent each year um those funds are either were either generated by Saving onetime funds from the state or uh just kind of really just accumulated because of attrition so we have all these vacancies we saved money having those vacancies so for 25 we don't expect to have that same level of savings we expect to spend the 37 million or so that we put into our SA or we allocated from savings as we got those attrition rates up our estimates

058really pretty high right now um so yeah so that's really what it is is that that kind of that fund balance that's propped us up over the last few years U generally by Saving onetime funds so I was asked a question today if you have this these one-time funds that have been recurring the last several years why do you budget to include those funds again in a future year why couldn't you just begin your budget from without those one-time funds we budget we didn't budget for the state onetime funds we budgeted for the onetime resources we knew we had in hand based on our projections for our weav savings at the end of that particular fiscal year yeah I'm not referring to the state one time funds I'm referring to the the fund balance rollover

059which isn't the majority of that because we couldn't hire people for all the positions we have some yeah a lot of it but a lot of it was saving the state money um so as we didn't hire them particularly in 23 24 we did incur we did have a lot of savings those years in 25 we're not expecting to but as far as the amount that we actually budget of our savings it's really a measure of when we're starting to project out for the end of like when I'm projecting out for the end of this fiscal year I'm projecting a little under $50 million of fund balance to be at Hand by the end of the fiscal year and that's what we're putting towards next year so we're really making a calculation of how much

060money we expect to have retained a net of all those vacancies and everything um this year we're quite a bit closer than we were in past year so we are going to be spending down our fund balance um that $516 equivalent we anticipate spending that down but we also anticipate having about $700 in a BSA equivalent for next year thank you member Che yeah thank you Mr chair um another question for Dr Ryan's team um you know about a year ago something pretty remarkable happened in the text of legislative inefficacy in that 93% of the the Alaska legislator 56 out of 60 of our state legislators from around our state um in urban and and Rural districts voted to support SP 140 which would have provided a a permanent statutory increase to the based in

061allocation that bill was then vetoed and a number of legislators who have since um know longer been retained by voters in Alaska chose to to change their minds um when there was an override vote I'm curious um how would our situation be different when we're looking at our FY 26 budget had if we had a statutory increase to be able to count on as we build the operating budget I'm sure it's a good question so if we were to have that $680 BSA increase in hand now that would provide a little under $50 million of additional State money um which means that's about 50 million doll of things we wouldn't have to cut this year we'd still make reductions in the about $15 million range depending on how much fund balance this board would be

062willing to spend down to member L um thank you this spring the graduating class of 2025 will go through their commencement exercises they were by and large less than one year old in June 2007 which is when um judge Sharon gleon in Mori Alaska articulated that Alaska's obligation to maintain public education Encompass the legislature's creation of Standards its assessment protocols its allocation of adequate funding and its satisfactory oversight of District's activities um assessment of the state's maintenance of Education which is written into the Constitution uh she explained would boil down to whether all students receive quote a meaningful opportunity to achieve Proficiency in Reading Writing Math and Science and are also accorded the opportunity for Meaningful exposure to the state's other content standards uh at the time when this year's graduating class of 2020 was

063by large in diapers um she did find that it was education was being maintained 17 years have passed and my question is really a judgment call for the administration given our deficit our projected deficit our projected levels of State education funding for Anchorage going to be quote adequate to provide a meaningful opportunity for all of ASD students to meet the state standards I would say it's inadequate based off of my math um based off of that 5960 alone I had mentioned that it's been stable for 10 years um frankly it's worth about well a little over $44,000 when you adjust for inflation so I would say that's inadequate personally is my professional opinion any other question member Jacobs yeah thank you Mr chair um another question I I know I regularly get community councils um

064and and something we've heard um in Juno as well is that there um is a decrease in Alaska student count um in some large urban districts like um ASD over the last decade have lost um some percentage of their student population and I think there's um a struggle to grasp the intersection of inflation driving fixed costs um things like utilities and salaries um which comprise the majority of our budget um contrasting that with the loss of student count is it possible to shed some light on how those two things interact and why how an operating budget can still go up when student count is is not Turing the same direction I'm sure and it's really all the kind of based on the rates of the increases and decrease we decrease students by about 1% our

065funding goes down by something similar um but our costs go up by 3% I mean Medical's been going up by seven eight 10% Clips every single year for a good part of a decade so we have these really kind of inherent costs that keep in outpacing inflation and then um as the population declines we do get less money from the state because of population we're not getting the same amount it does go down based on that ADM counts so we're getting less money to pay for you know fewer Services too because we don't need the same number of uh of teachers to have the same PTR if we lose students and we did show you know the the decline in uh the enrollment related students so that goes down but the costs are have been

066exceeding um are the inflation has been exceeding the amount of loss in students essentially member Jacobs follower member W um yeah this is a maybe a restating a question or an observation that I raised during the work session but uh there are a lot more folks in the room at this point um could you perhaps explain the degree of risk that we're taking on by uh pivoting below by requiring a super majority of the board to take on a level of risk to the district by spending our fund balance down from an 8% best practice board minimum down to 5% which my understanding is less than a week's worth of operating reserves sure so if we spend it down to 5% that really gives us a little over $6 million of truly unassigned uh savings

067to respond to emergencies such as when we had the earthquake in 2018 U Back in the early 2000s I believe Russian Jack burned down we able to start re-building that facility immediately even if we have a loss in unexpected loss in students if we were to lose 500 students instead of 200 you know that's millions of dollars that we would have to uh take from somewhere and gener we have our staff on contract we need to pay out those contracts for the remainder of the Year regardless of how many students we have on staff or on in our buildings um so really you do take a considerable Risk by only having six plus million dollars sitting out to address those emergencies other questions or comments uh member Jacobs and member Wilson yeah thank you Mr

068chair I'll ask my my last one I think um I we we've discussed in previous work sessions how Alaska's experienced over a decade now of net out migration where we're seeing more alaskans leave than new alaskans join our great state um the last census indicates that I think over a third of our young people 16 to 26 year olds are are leaving for other Pacific Northwest states and um states in the lower 48 I wonder what if we if we if we were to Advocate and we were to receive funding and we were allowed to continue Innovative programs like theem of Anchorage could we see um that be a plank in the plan to begin to reverse that Trend and out migration if we as a state implemented a sustainable long-term fiscal plan and invested

069in our youth and the next generation of our Workforce through the president um I think one thing to consider is that there is um light at the end of the tunnel if you will so if there were more resources for students in the district were to receive more funding I would recommend that that the district invest in more um grow your own programs for example so to incentivize our young people to remain in Alaska perhaps get some subsidy to go to education school at UAA and come back and teach and programs like that um I think that that's one tangible thing the district can do to tackle our own Workforce needs and then broadly speaking we can talk about things like the academies that would tackle some of the more um you know broad labor

070shortages in the state but specifically for teachers were my eye is on given the limited resources that we have member Wilson I've had many conversations with community members regarding charter schools and ASD has amazing opportunities for for families and and a variety of of choice different choices for um our students to participate in different educational opportunities uh but there seems to be a continued I I know we we've talked about it quite a few times and I I would like to bring it up again or have it explained again because there still seems to be um a lack of understanding of how charter schools in Alaska are funded particularly our our ASD um charter schools so if if you could go ahead and explain again how our charter schools are funded and how inflation um

071coupled with the unpredictable funding might impact our Charter Schools I'd appreciate it sure through the president U yeah our charter schools are funded through the foundation formula really like any other school um so you roll them all through the multipliers of the foundation formula and then by Statute all that money goes to the Charter School uh for their use minus like a 4% indirect cost uh taking off the top to papay for things like budget HR accounting um it all those kind of the business side of it um but when they don't get that that base student base student allocation increased either and they're kind of a microcosm of the district where they either have to take in more kids and have higher class sizes there if they can or they're going to be reducing

072staff as well um so a lot of them have facilities to pay for too uh but you know even if you're in a district building you still have to pay for operations and maintenance and utilities there so yeah I mean there funded just like other districts they have more control over how those funds are spent um versus a districtwide pool and kind of allocating out resources they're doing it more internally but yeah if they don't have inflationary increases for a decade that hurts them too their cutting staff and cutting programs that they have any other questions or comments comment I I would like to add based on some of the emails that I've gotten just to make sure folks in the room know in all this talk about deficits we're not in deficit this year

073this is strictly about next year's budget um it is the changes we'd have to make if we tried to do what we're doing this year and only the BSA was allocated to us um and unfortunately while we're going through the budget process that's the the only thing we really feel confident about and as someone pointed out we don't have 100% Assurance of that uh but it is a case that the legislature has always funded the BSA and so we do use that as our budget number um everything else is more speculative and that's why we can't just assume a large number and assume it will cover all of our expenses but this is about what would have to change if we went forward with just the BSA out ation and ask any of the financial

074people to correct me if I'm misstating anything on that you you folks get the wi these numbers every single day so if there's no other questions or comments uh we'll move on our agenda thank you very much to staff to the superintendent for that um this is the time that we start to hear from the public we welcome your comments which are very important to us the board has set as an hour at the beginning of the meeting for those who have signed up to give public comment those not heard during the first hour will be heard at the end of the agenda this is an opportunity for Schoolboard members to listen and for members of the public to inform the school board about their views please note the following all public comments are limited

075to 3 minutes there is a timer in front of the Das you'll be able to see while you're speaking all speakers will receive a courtesy alert when they have 30 seconds remaining which is a bell sound that Miss solivan will make speaking time may not be given or shared with others when your name is called please come to the podium please state your name and direct your comments to the chair please understand that this is not a time for dialogue the purpose of this agenda item is for you the public to inform us about your views if you do have handouts to share with board members please give them to Miss Sullivan on my left and she will distribute them to us um finally we do have detailed boardroom decorum guidelines at the uh door

076where you signed up we also do allocate time at the beginning of public comment to hear from students first because we want them to be able to speak to us and still get home and go to bed at a very reasonable hour so we'll be starting with students and then uh follow up with parents that have students in the room so that they can complete testimony and go home as well uh with that uh the first two people to speak are Matthew Hancock and um Aiden Sarah if you can come forward and sit down hello my name is Chung my English name is Matthew hanock and I am in fifth grade at Alaskan culture Char school cayana for listening to my testimony and all the work they you provide for students as school board members

077we only have three views at AB Loop build at the ab Loop building and we don't know if there will be open building where our temporary home has served its time please consider us to move into Lake H elementary it will be hard to move again but hopefully Lake hood is a permanent home for us to live in because I don't know where we we will be when I'm in eighth grader when my mom is my teacher as a kid and a student I need the stability of a safe School my classmates come to school because we have fun here at anccs at anccs we teach kids through traditional y if our three years years are up before we find a safe home we will be homes and we'll have to do school online if

078and kids don't get the face to- face learning experience like we do have now we will have to move into a place like Easter somewhere else please help please help provide answers you as the permanent homeor can teach kids traditional cultural ways thank you for listening to my presentation thank you very much next I'm not sure if this down like we we Aiden Sarah the parent is Denise Ray if you're in the room and if you'll come forward yeah and have a seat and state your name and you have three minutes my name is Aidan s and I am a student providing testimony and support of the relocation of the alas cultural Charter School to lakeood Elementary as part of the right sizing initiative anccs provides a specialized learning environment that enables Alaskan na students

079to academically socially and culturally our school has consistently delivered positive academic results for us Alaskan students and serves as the only title one child school I am a seventh grader at a I love an so much I have not missed the day of school since I was in fourth grade no joke I have had perfect attendance and straight A for most of my time at N I am in the ignite program due to the Quality education I received at anccs I have been to anccs since kindergarten and nccs has impacted my life for those eight years because I have felt very welcome by mycs family even though I went to three different locations throughout my lifetime uh atccs and anccs moved to five different locations I still feel comfortable in this school I think anccs

080needs a new home and somewhere where we can feel safe and comfortable like a permanent place if we get to move to Lake could then AMCs students can stop moving over and over if we get this school we can have room for more students the more students we have the more we feel like family more native kids will be able to th academically socially and culturally like me we use native values and new teachings to help guide us emotionally and be in our digly educated we learn you to help us with our cultural identity I love ancs because it has changed my life for the better and prepared me for my future the NCS is so special to me because the love and nuring I have felt from all the staff and friendships I made

081since kindergarten it will help me relieve the stress of not knowing where we will be in the future anccs has educated me and prepared me for life please help us find a permanent home so we have a place to go on thank you very much and next we have pepper Draper followed by Elizabeth Robins you can state your name for the record and you have three NS hello my name is pepper and I am from Wasilla and I come here with my friend opilia and we are here to support the school for the deaf I've been coming to the school for the deaf for two years and and I have direct communication Services compared to what I had in Milla which was nothing I have grown up since moving here and I've been able to

082learn so much I've been able to interact with my de staff and have communication with the Alaska school for the de and heart of hearing I'm able to be a part of De culture and work on my deaf identity and I very much cherish my school in the program and working with my counselors and please keep our staff and counselors and thank you for your time thank you very much for coming tonight next we have Elizabeth Robbins followed by Allison cus if you'll get close to the microphone and you have three minutes hi my name's Elizabeth Robbins and I'm here to testify about the proposed budget cuts in the inchor school district these budget cuts will have several negative impacts on students particularly on their educational experience and extracurricular opportunities with the elimination of Middle

083School sports and cuts to high school sports programs like hockey gymnastics and St and Diving students will lose important opportunities for physical activities team building and personal growth outside of the classroom Sports s often serve as a critical outlet for students promoting discipline time management and a sense of community for student athletes this means losing avenuers for competition college recruitment opportunities and social engagement through Sports The increased people to teer ratio will make it harder for teachers to give individualized attention to students third grade classroom could have up to 30 students while grades 6 to 12 may see classed with over 35 students which can create a crowded learning environment where students May struggle to keep up with the pace of lessons or get the help they need this will likely lead to increased stress

084for both students and teachers and could harm academic outcomes the cuts to support staff like nurses and Librarians at elementary schools further reduce the resources available to students especially younger grades without enough nurses there could be delays or lack of attention to student health issues and the loss of librarians could diminish access to learning materials and resources further limiting academic opportunities all of these factors contribute to to a less balanced and supportive education system which leave students especially those in middle school and high school at a disadvantage academically emotionally and physically the reduction of programs and resources will have a long lasting negative effect on the overall quality of Education in this District thank you thank you for your tonic Allison Koso you'll state your name for the record my name is Allison Koso I

085am a former Alaskan native cultural Charter School student and I'm currently enrolled in Betty Davis East High School although I am a former student I continue to stay involved with the school by working as a teacher assistant for the 21st century program as well as volunteering for anccs events throughout the school year I am very eager to advocate for the relocation of the Alaskan native cultural Charter School to Lut Elementary as part of the right sizing initiative anccs is a Guiding Light for Alaska native students encouraging Success Through traditional cultural learning and empowering students to flourish academically socially emotionally and culturally not only providing its students with structure but also a sense of belonging I attended anccs starting in kindergarten and therefore have been in all three different locations we have moved into over the

086past 5 years I have experienced the inconvenience and disruption moving has caused our anccs families but regardless of these set facts our families have continued to stay dedicated to our community because at NCS we are a family as someone who has endured a good deal of trauma I can truly attest to the fact that our teachers and staff members are heavily committed to the care and nurturing of their students this family oriented support system has helped shape students like myself to grow into emerging leaders anccs has shown me what it is what it means to truly be a part of something and has positively shaped me into the person that I am today that is why I urge you to consider the importance of giving our school a permanent solution to ensure long-term stability that

087will further Elevate the remarkable difference anccs makes on both ASD and the Greater Community clana thank you for your consideration thank you very much for your customers I believe that is all of the students that were signed up to speak um first on are adults uh and we are trying to pick up the parents that have students in the room uh to get them done um Elizabeth Hancock followed by Carolyn wisman good evening my name is Elizabeth Hancock I am one of the founding parents of the Alaska native cultural charter school and a member of the anccs Middle School teaching team three of my children have graduated from anccs the youngest one is in fifth grade I'm grateful for the amount of work that you do as Schoolboard members to provide All Families living in

088the anchor area I'm encouraging you to consider to consider seriously that the Alaskan native cultural Charter School move into lak Hood Elementary as part of the right sizing initiative currently underway ancc isccs is lucky because we've always been supported by the anchored school district and through that support anccs students have flourished academically unfortunately anccs has no permanent home as our move to Abbot Loop is temporary I have been part of every move from our startup malun Community assembly to our locational malun and then into the old Wonder Park a hasty move into East Anchorage high school and lastly into our current location in the old Abbot Loop Elementary this has created Strife in our community and stress in our Learners as they don't know what is next my children can tell you stories about getting

089lost in the M Community assembly maze playing in a dirt patch that was 20t by 50 ft and the pure joy and excitement of moving into what was considered a real school what it was like not to return to school when other ASD students did because our building was in Co safe and then what it was like to sit through multiple lockdowns because of the fights that happened at East or the negative and positive interactions with high school students there our families were happy to be out of the East but were very Leary of moving into our Abbott location because it carried a 5year lifespan even though this is another move it would establish a sense of permanency that anccs has yet to have and our community deserves having my children graduate from anccs I

090have firsthand seen the positive impact because I now have members of the Anchorage Community who contribute positively two of those children are committed to attending college in Alaska and returning to anccs to teach because of the impact that anccs has had on their education my children have always received praise from their High School teachers because they were knowledgeable respectful and had a desire to learn this is true for every eighth grader who has left anccs and if you talk to other High School's teachers they can identify the students who have attended anccs and those who have not our data speaks for itself to show you that the impact that anccs has Alaskan has had on Alaskan native students of last year's 8th graders 54% of them were at or above 50th percentile in reading and

09146 at or above the percentile in math many of our students like you see return to anccs and by giving us a permanent home it would allow us the long-term stability that anccs needs I encourage the school board to continue supporting anccs and accepting our recommendation from our academic policy committee to move into Lake K Elementary Quiana again for listening thank you for your testimony um Miss wisman no good good all right un uh good good evening Caroline wisman U my name is my English name is Caroline wisman and I am a huge community advocate for the Alaskan of culture charter school I my involvement in the charter school is as a former teacher a former APC member a coach and now currently a substitute teacher within the Anchorage School District my time at anccs

092has been amazing and sitting in front of last time I sat in front of you we were talking about leaving East High School and going into a building since then the Alaskan new cultural Charter School's enrollment has gone up our attendance has increased the activities that we've been able to do because we have an A bu a building has been amazing our students are so awesome and they have an a tremendous ability to be leaders and the students who spoke with you today are a testament to that having a building in a permanent solution would provide the stability for students that your District our district serves is so important our Alaskan native students are commonly underserved at many schools they're the minority and at our school they're the majority and they Thrive and they learn

093and they build their success through traditional cultural learning the Alaskan native cultural Charter School means so much to so many families and having a stable place can create a sense of stability for themselves for their families for our community and to continue the progress and the momentum that we've had just being an Abbot Loop Elementary clana for your time clana for your service for our community thank you very much thank you for your testimony next we have Jennifer Phillips and followed by Kristen bonio and we are getting our hand out right now you'll state your name for the record you have three minutes all right good evening my name is Jennifer Phillips I've worked with the ASD since year 2000 I'm asking all of you are elected and esteemed school board members to not pass

094a budget that cuts the elementary gifted program known as ignite last year a team of Veteran teachers worked to create a scope and sequence for the ignite program under the direction and guidance of Dr Beltran the school this school year high quality curriculum is being taught across the district night students are benefiting from similar educational opportunities and experiences each unit contains critical thinking skills in which students work with new information make predictions test these predictions and draw conclusions this year ignite students have dissected a variety of specimens from squids worms clams lizards frogs chicken wings and cow eyeballs just to name it you embedded in the ignite curriculum are the 16 habits of mind please see the hand out as you can see on the handout these 16 habits of mind coincide beautifully with ASDS

095portrait of a graduate within the ignite class room students are challenged and guided by their teacher to work through these 16 habits of mind students are given opportunities to practice these habits and reflect on their use of each one this semester ignite students are focusing on the Habit persisting as are all of our ignite teachers because for the past 16 years ASD is proposed to cut the ignite program why is gifted programming essential gifted students are a unique population within our schools these students have strong academic skill sets often two three or more grade levels above their academic peers their social and emotional needs don't always match their intellectual abilities which without proper guidance can lead to anxiety they don't like to fail so they may give up rather than fail when things get beyond

096their skill set this can lead to underachievement and student drop out without guidance gifted students can often use a fixed mindset expecting to figure it out the first time they need to learn how to creatively solve problems that aren't quick to answer many struggle with perfectionism some gifted students struggle to work in groups and work with other people and when bored and not challenged in class gifted students become extremely disruptive at times ignite teachers use their training and help students work through these struggles in the ignite classroom students are given multiple chances and challenges in which they may fail or hit the wall and with the guidance of their teacher they can learn strategies to move through these complex problems all right so mainly since I have 30 seconds left I was looking through the

097budget and if the budget for 2526 is 5946 million in the general fund the gifted program is just over three million that's 0.5% thank you for your testimony okay uh Christen Balon at star six to unmute and you have three minutes we're unable to hear you star six to unmute your [Music] phone oh yes we can hear I'm I'm an educator in the Anchorage School District um as well as a mom of two ASD students um obviously the news of a 100 million um dollar budget deficit is devastating not just for staff but for students and the community alike um which is why I am testifying uh while reviewing asc's budget proposal I ask that the school board request absolute transparency and Fidelity when it comes to cuts at the district office that cuts to

098our schools are plain and direct they show us which buildings are losing how many teachers Librarians nurses Etc um the reductions listed at the district level however are a little ambiguous a budget shortfall hurts everyone I realize um buzz but is it sustainable to only cut from the bottom and not from the top educators are constantly being asked to do more with less can our top Administration not do the same when teachers are disproportionately on the chopping block is they usually are every year you lose more of those who directly support our students I know tonight you've already heard and you're going to continue hearing many requests and pleases um from the community uh to save our teachers to save programs to save Sports and our community is undoubtedly angry and upset um so I

099want to take this opportunity to speak directly to the parents the neighbors community members who are listening now after you say your piece tonight I implore you to do one more thing and I want you to please please call your legislator um you need to tell our elected officials that they must take immediate action in order to adequately fund education in Alaska we need to pass House Bill 69 which will increase the base student allocation the BSA if we are going to be able to serve our children and our students at the level that they deserve as we've already heard today we are past the point of doing more with less the School Board cannot keep these cuts from happening until we demand that our state fully invest in our education thank you thank you

100for your testimony back in the room we have Tim pack and Erica Arnold if you'll come forward you state your name for the record and you have three minutes and we ask you get close to the microphone so we can all hear you thank you is that close enough good evening my name is Tim Pac and I've been an educational interpreter for the Alaska school for the de and heart of hearing since 2017 I'm here in the face of our financial crisis to advocate for The Unique importance of our dhh support staff each team member delivers their services directly to our students through ASL as best practice demands for our students facing language deprivation and the risk factors it brings these responsibilities cannot be absorbed by professionals not fluent in the unique language culture and

101psychosocial implications of our students cutting dhh support staff that directly serve students literally means cutting off our students from accessing their legal right to ASDS education and Mental Health Resources my greatest example of this is our akd counselor Courtney Westman who is irreplaceable in every sense of the word and here's why Courtney's work is specialized to directly serve dhh students a demographic that is statistically highly likely to be isolated victimized and underserved with 76% of dhh children reporting child maltreatment and as much as 86% experiencing language deprivation these children face mental health and wellness challenges not only in greater numbers and severity than their hearing peers but also that present differently necessitating an entirely different intervention plan further glickman's research shows that the language deprivation many deaf students experience leads to behaviors which are misdiagnosed

102has thought disorders by professionals lacking experience and training with deaf clients without expertise in mental health as it relates to De use these childrens are mislabeled mistreated and severely harmed by the professionals charged with their care or simply fall through the cracks of our system within akd these students are seen understood and reported as soon as they show need because of Courtney's expertise the administration might think that they can make up the deficit in these counselors training and experience by leaning on us educational interpreters to bridge the gap we cannot interpret counseling sessions because we are not trained in the field and hold none of the necessary credentials meaning the district would need to contract mental health interpreters for every meeting across all of our school sites Outsourcing this care would not only be expensive

103but extremely challenging due to the the scarcity of qualified interpreters we aren't considering Shifting the workload of one counselor to another we are considering inding Courtney's Legacy of Rapport and Care over the last 15 years with every student from prek to graduation and Beyond this cut of the district's expert in mental health supports for dhh children would be an unbelievable hardship on all of our students and a tragedy for those most in need please I implore you find the money elsewhere thank you for your testimony after Miss Arnold we have Amber King good evening um my name is Erica Arnold I'm an ASD educator um my children are students here in the ASD and I am a proud graduate of ASD which makes my testimony almost impossible to deliver it's time to make the dec

104the difficult decisions ASD did a very comprehensive analysis on the schools that need to close it was made very clear that we need to close some schools we cannot keep them all open there are almost 43,000 kids in Anchorage School District and every single one of them will be affected by the cuts proposed in this new budget we have to think big picture why wouldn't we close these schools 350 educators will lose their jobs each classroom teacher will acquire four more kids in their classrooms and in my school alone that would be 34 students in a second grade class and 29 kindergarteners it's simply not acceptable we can transfer our students and move our students they are very flexible we can give them another home a school that will love them thank you Russian Jack

105for preparing for your new students at Nuna how about our Abbot Loop students from the closure last year they are thriving at their new schools thank you kassoon and Trailside students are resilient and teachers will love them elimin ating all activities in middle school high school swimming hockey gymnastics dive all eliminated these kids need these activities to Anchor them close an Eagle River High School and combine the 700 and 900 students into one amazing High School full of unbeatable sports teams and a plethora of academic wants and needs let's combine our resources and close some schools imagine a kiddo that has fallen at recess and had a bad head injury of course course you send them to the nurse imagine now this school has less than 300 students chances are the nurse is gone for

106the day who takes care of them do we call 911 Imagine Schools imagine there are schools that are less than a 50% capacity with little to no growth potential closing these schools could help fund those ASD nurses what should we do we should close the school there's a quiet kiddo that's in your class that won't open to any open up to anyone and your school librarian with them they just want time to look at the books and find one with the character that they can relate to a your librarian is at the other school go back to your class kiddo a student comes to school with a broken heart a parent has passed or a family member that has gone to jail and they feel hopeless they want to talk to their counselor we don't

107have a counselor that day there is a school that has kid enough kids to fill only seven classrooms and there are five schools within five miles that are not full and would love to take them close the schools reone our district save our Educators save the programs that bind the kids to schools think big picture and make the difficult choices thank you guys all for listening to me tonight thank you for your testimony we have Amber King followed by Amanda Huffman you'll come forward you'll state your name for the record you have three minutes okay hi my name is Amber King and I'm a kindergarten teacher at Ravenwood Elementary before moving to Alaska four years ago I taught in Texas each year in the district I have experienced growing class sizes shifting curricula and increasing

108demands from the district and the state by November of my first year in ASD I felt defeated I called aea explaining I wanted to quit teaching due to these demands I feel that to ASD I'm just an employee number but to my students and families I'm so much more after sitting through the budget cut meeting last Friday I struggled to hold back tears currently I have 25 kindergarten students in my classroom I struggled to meet their needs every single day many students have never attended preschool and arrive with vastly different academic and social skill levels some need early intervention for speech Behavioral or learning delays interventions that are already difficult to provide now class sizes are expected to grow by four more students while reducing our support staff I fear for the future of my

109students and my ability to provide for them the Alaska reads act requires by law extensive intervention documentation and frequent parent meetings for students performing below grade level with more students and less time these required supports become harder to provide we all know ASD has a problem retaining educators I see my colleagues having the same experiences and they're choosing to explore opportunities outside of the district or leaving education many of our newest staff members after investing time in building relationships and establishing themselves within a school Community are being involuntarily displaced this uproots not only them but often their own children forcing them to start over in an entirely new environment we know the detriment Al effects that changing schools has on our students and yet we're asking our Educators to do the same thing this disruption

110affects not just their careers but their well-being morale and ability to provide continuity and support for their students we are being asked to do so much more with so much less and at the end of the day it's our children who face the consequences of these proposed changes there has to be another way to resolve the budget deficit one that does not come at the expense of our children's Futures thank you thank you for your testimony by telephone we have Amanda Hoffman and Then followed in person by Martha may gold Le and Leah Lions if you want to come down um Miss Hoffman at Star 6 to unmute and you have three minutes good evening my name is Amanda hofman I'm my aabas name is kushino I highly recommend the move for the Alaskan native

111cultural chartis school for a permanent home at lakehood elementary I'm a parent of a student in the 24 Century coordinator atccs my previous positions with the district I was the indigenous Ed were with indigenous education I was a community counselor at East and the cultural enrichment specialist as a community counselor I've seen firsthand many students move to Anchorage from the rural area and were in complete culture shock with urbanization more people coming to Anchorage from rural areas for medical Financial education and more resources and CCS moving to a larger location will be able to help more of these students succeed in education with feeling more comfortable and having a little piece of home within the school our school currently has a weight list for many grade levels my stepdaughter moved in with us beginning of

112the school year and is still on the weight list for seventh grade our parent committee committee's goal is to grow our school serve more students and lakehood will help with that having to move to to several locations within the past five years is destructive on our students education having this permanent location will also help with our families I know several families have moved move closer to the current location we are at and please consider anccs for the lakehood location for final move and the home thank you thank you for your testimony M gold wig if you'll state your name for the record you have three minutes I'm Martha G Lee I'm a Founder for the charter school and um I recognize several of you on the board and I want to thank you for the

113support of Anor School District in the past we struggled in the beginning um barely making our 150 count which we were in a church and still families came later that year we moved into an old furniture building and uh we could literally open the door and yell across to the next teacher to keep an eye on our students while we use the bathroom and from there we went to uh the old willowa school which was then owned by and um the Northern Pacific Academy until the air quality there the air vacuum system whatever didn't work and didn't circulate the air then we were moved to East High School all those years from 2008 to 2023 when we finally got to over to Abbot loop our students never had a playground we never had adequate storage

114we had several obstacles we never had a real kitchen but our parents came that old adage if you build it that they will come there is a need in this community for our school we fill a unique position and we really our desire is to be on the east side of town but there is no school open here right now for permanent we thought Daxter was but that was taken off the table so we do implore you for a permanent home because in 3 years we have to move again the Fire Marshall only gave us the 5year grace period and we're in our second year so we're asking the school district please consider we know there's many things you guys have to do but please don't forget us we have struggled we're still here we

115intend to stay Thank you thank you for your testimony Miss Lions followed by Robin wetheral thank you for allowing me to speak today my name is Leah lions and I am one of the few de education teachers that works at the Alaska state school for the de and heart of hearing I am here today to ask that you consider removing the akd council position from the list of proposed Staffing reductions a deaf counselor can serve as a role model for students who are deaf and heart of hearing represent presentation matters and having someone in a position of authority who shares the same cultural and linguistic background can help students feel understood and validated it can also reduce feelings of isolation and promote self-empowerment deaf students may feel more comfortable discussing sensitive issues with a counselor

116who understands their experiences and their struggles related to being deaf there is a shared understanding of the challenges faced in navigating a hearing dominated World which can make students feel more at ease direct communication allows for quicker clarification of issues if a student is trying to explain something the counselor can ask follow-up questions or offer feedback immediately without needing to wait for an interpreter or risk losing the meaning during translation both the counselor and the student can get to the heart of the matter more effectively in Urgent or emergency situations direct communication with the counselor can be critical time sensitive issues can be addressed more quickly when there's no need to rely on finding an interpreter or waiting for them to arrive this could make all the difference in providing timely support having a counselor

117with direct communication access is a valuable asset in ensuring that students feel supported and understood and empowered throughout their counseling experience it can significantly enhance the quality of relationship support and build stronger more effective relationships thank you for your consideration thank you for your testimony Robin leol followed by Courtney Westman you'll state your name for the record you have three NS you please turn the microphone there you go it's on oh sorry did I get to start again good evening I'm Robin weatherall and I'm part of the gifted identification team I'm here to talk about budget cuts last year Dr Bryant said it's past time to close some campuses and consolidate our schools I agree the district needs to close some elementary schools over the last decade ASD enrollment has dropped 10% that is the

118equivalent of six of the 60 plus elementary schools yet only one school was closed this year most sixth graders across the district were moved to middle school this change affected over 40 schools with an enrollment move equivalent to six elementary schools yet only two schools are slated to be closed the district could save billions of dollars by closing 10 to 12 elementary schools from building costs to maintenance to supplies to Staffing I was informed the district does not have the ability to close more than a few schools at once the closures would be Consolidated into already established schools focus should be on moving items such as class furniture and curricula other items can be moved as time allows it is far cheaper to pay extra for staff to prepare for closures and to hire outside

119movers than to needlessly keep schools open to date the three schools that have actually closed or will be closed are Title One schools closures need to happen in all areas of the city not just in lowincome neighborhoods consolidating elementary schools will help keep the programs that make our schools robust the school board's Vision includes the statement every student deserves the opportunity to achieve to his or her potential the ignite program helps our brightest students reach their potential the ignite program encourages the skills and characteristics highlighted in ASDS portrait of a graduate the district's vision for college career and life Readiness ignite incorporates the habits of mind through our lessons we strive to help students become self-directed Learners our Hands-On units of instruction encourage fully engaged Learners whose curiosity repeat students connect with their peers as

120they work in teams to learn how to actively listen and collaborate students use critical and creative thinking as they solve problems they learn as they fail adapt and try again in a safe environment they gain confidence and believe they can improve with practice they learn to be resilient and to persevere we need to keep ignite so our brightest students reach their potential the district's administrators constantly talk about rightsizing in order to meet Financial constraints let's change that talk to action close some Elementary your time has expired thank you for your testimony we have Courtney Westman followed by Nick Sur and rosin grey wish on by telephone you have three minutes hello my name is Courtney Westman I am the Alaska state school for the Deen heart of hearing counselor as I and I've been in

121this position for 15 years I wanted to thank you all for allowing me the opportunity to share my testimony I would like to request that you remove this counselor position from the budget cut proposal my reasoning is is it is crucial to have a counselor who is fluent in American Sign Language and understands the needs of Deen heart of hearing students for example I am able to offer emotional and academic support during one-on-one counseling communicating directly in American sence sign language every student has a different signing ability and I'm able to adapt My Signing to match their level allowing me to interact with them effectively when a student experiences a crisis they deserve the opportunity to express themselves freely in American Sign Language without the need for interpreting Services by contrast if a student is

122paired with a hearing counselor with an interpreter it must be a contracted interpreter and they're only facilitating communication and what this results in is students often missing out on important linguistic features it is important to know that this interpreting process cannot be done by an educational interpreter it is essential to include the grammatical nuances in American Sign Language for linguistic and counseling support and I can help in with the intonation and signs as needed some students experience language deprivation meaning no one in their household is fluent in the language that they understand and these students come to Alaska State School for the Deaf and receive 100% access through ASL fluent staff members our students have the right or direct communication with their educational environment deaf def plus and heart of hearing students have the right

123to direct communication with their staff personnel as well as the de plus population and what this means is a student who is deaf and also has another disability and this can significantly delay their language development there is a significant shortage of freelance and contract interpreters in the Community right now and we have a separate group of educational interpreters who work with the district although educational interpreters build rapport with their students it's not ethical for them to replace to interpret these crisis or other personal issues that their students face and to comply with best practice a contractor would be required to interpret as we often do with the children office of children's services as well as law enforcement visitation often times these contractors are not readily available and our students deserve to have their crisis addressed

124immediately as every other student in the school district does when it comes to Suicide risk assessments we also need to have these conducted immediately by a school counselor to measure the level of risk having to wait on a contract interpreter causes more harm I am proud to say that I am an Alaska State School for the Deaf alumni I graduated from here and I have experienced the mainstream program and the educational struggles with an interpreter it was a struggle for me and having that experience enables me to better support our Deen heart of hearing students on how to use interpreting Services how to advocate for themselves and how to learn in this educational environment I'm also there to guide them on how to advocate for a note taker if needed and these self- advocacy skills

125are essential for succeeding in education and again I am proud to be an alumni of my school I am a role model for our students who may not have ever interacted with a de professional in the way that they do with me I am one of [Music] them the Alaska state school for the de and heart of hearing is considered the largest operating bilingual deed program in the state with other districts collaborating with our school counselor in person and Via Zoom for distance the remarkable aspect of our program is that all participants are in are fluent in American Sign Language and provide direct communication access to all the students around the state of Alaska thank you so much for listening to my testimony have a wonderful evening thank you very much for your testimony we

126go to um Telephone Nick Surah if you can get star 6 to unmute you have three minutes thank you uh dear Anchorage schull board I'm deeply concerned about the proposed budget cuts for next school year particularly the impact on students at hu middle school with the student population of over 800 eliminating an assistant principal Position will significantly reduce the support available to students teachers and families one assistant principal alone will struggle to effectively enforce school rules address safety concerns bullying and resolve conflicts Additionally the loss of 10 instructional positions at hu will lead to significantly larger class sizes as it will in all other middle schools in Anchor School District in over clouded classrooms struggling students will receive less attention and teachers will need to spend more time managing behaviors rather than focusing on instruction

127this will result in lower academic performance furthermore without the AP position teachers and students will lose a critical source of support making it more difficult to maintain a productive learning environment the proposed elimination of all Middle School sports will further harm students Athletics provide students opportuni ities to build friendships stay active and stay engaged in school without these essential programs many students will lose a key source of motivation and connection to their school I urge you to consider the detrimental effect that these Cuts will have on all families and students we are here to serve thank you for your time thank you very much for your testimony also by telephone Rosell and Grady wish star six unmute good evening chair Hollman and members my name is Roslin Grady White most of you know me as

128Ros my students call me Miss Ros and as the education chair of the NAACP Anchorage Branch I am an advocate for our students our teachers and our community I am here for advocacy so I hope I don't get into trouble let's talk about it I could follow lead but I won't because let me be clear my issue is not with our school board or our ASD cabinet my issue is with our governor who session after session has refused to invest in education choosing politics over the future of our children we need people to understand that this is not just a funding crisis this is a constitutional violation the Alaska Constitution is clear education is a fundamental right our state government has a a dut a duty a legal IM moral obligation to fully fund public

129education more versus Alaska reinforce that responsibility the courts ruled that the state was failing its students especially those in marginalized communities yet here we are again fighting the same battle this is not on our school district this is on our governor this is on our legislators who continue to undermine education while pushing dangerous agendas like project 2025 they tell us there's no money for schools but somehow there's money for prisons pet projects and everything except our children enough is enough Anchorage is home to the most diverse School District in the nation that means our responsibility is greater our challenges are unique our investment in public education must reflect that but instead of investing in our future in our children and our Workforce our governor is choosing to starve our schools of the funding they need

130for his agenda this is a moral failure because when we underfund education we push teachers out of the profession over crowd classrooms take away resources from students who need them the most all of our students and families We are failing our superintendent has called us to use our voices in advocacy and I Echo that call we must hold our governor and our state legislators accountable demand a permanent increase in based student allocation a long-term commitment to fully funding public education and an end to political agendas that put our students at risk call to action to our school board and our district leaders I see your efforts you shouldn't have to beg for resources our schools need to our community now it's time to take this fight to Juno because if our governor won't fight for

131our children we will tell their tell your legislators that our children's education is non negotiable Anchorage let's rise together when we fight we win I know you I know you guys remember that this moment will not Define us how we respond will we must stand together Advocate seriousely and refuse to let our children be short changed because if nobody cares about our babies I definitely do and I know you do too pay attention to your school board members that are working in favor and do your research the time is now Advocate and calling your legislators to do their job thank you thank you very much for your testimony coming back into the room we have Andre Howard and Michael Patterson um M Howard you have six minutes for our citizens that need an interpreter we

132allocate six minutes for Testimony hello members of the school board my name is Andre Howard and I'm an ASL interpreter I'm here today to address the impact of this budget proposal that we'll have on on our deaf students as someone who is committed to the success and well-being of our deaf students I strongly encourage you to recognize the vital role that these de professionals play in their education whether teachers PA professionals counselors or Specialists these professionals offer more than just academic support they provide crucial emotional and social guidance deaf professionals offer an individual an invaluable perspective rooted in shared experiences their presence in schools allows deaf students to communicate in their first language American Sign Language without relying on an interpreter this creates an inclusive environment where de students can express themselves openly ask questions

133without hesitation and fully engage in their education having deaf Professionals in school means that our students are not only learning academic content they are also learning how to advocate for themselves build relationships and develop confidence in who they are this kind of support is vital for the personal growth in academic success I understand that budgets are tight and difficult decisions must be made but I ask you that you think in the longterm social and academic impact on our de students if these professionals are taken away without them we risk isolating these students limiting their opportunities for growth and undermining the very purpose of our educational system to provide every child without support that they need I strongly urge you to keep deaf Professionals in our schools so our deaf students have the opportunities they deserve

134to thrive in an environment that recognizes the values and their unique needs and perspectives thank you for your time and consideration thank you very much for your testimony we have Michael Patterson followed by Nicole lson hello my name is Michael Patterson and I'm a parent of a student at the Alaskan native culture tar school I'm also a member of the academic policy committee and I'm the vice president for the board I'm providing testimony and support of the relocation of Alaskan native culture Char School the lakehood elementary as part of the right sizing initiative anccs provides a specialized learning environment that enables a lasing native students to thrive academically socially and culturally as a vital component of the anchored school district anccs has consistently delivered positive academic results for Alaskan native students and serve as the

135only title one charter school and to be clear charter schools are public schools um and I just want to add that my son who's in third grade now uh I was concerned that he was going to be behind because when the lockdowns were happening he was in kindergarten and I had to teach him so I was he entered school with a deficit um but now my son is in ignite my son's in third grade and he's thriving he's talking about his culture he knows way more than I do but don't tell him I told you that and I just you know and on a less positive note I do want to add that something I've been thinking about a lot lately given what's going on is the more things change the more they stay the

136same and to me when I talked to my son's grandfather who went to a boarding school who was abused for speaking his language and then I get to see my son at a school like anccs you know that's the only thing that I feel like has actually changed and anccs to me is a way to write a historical wrong that has been brought upon the Alaskan native peoples in this state and I know you don't have the power to tell Juno what to do but you do have the power to give anccs a home a permanent home so that every two to three to five years we're not in survival mode our school will grow it's already grown with just the one building that we've had we will deliver programs that intervene when our kids

137are struggling with math and reading the school works the school is the antithesis to the historic tyranny of boarding schools and it's really your responsibility as school district officials to support this school and it's my responsibility as a parent and as an APC board board member to tell you that it's your responsibility to support anccs and so I'll end on a positive note I really appreciate the communication that the school district has had with us like I said a long time ago when I came here this is the only interaction I have with local government that I actually feel is productive uh and I appreciate all your professionalism and your communication but it's time that we grow thank you very much for your testimony next we have Nicole Warson followed by Clara Baldwin hello members

138of the school board my name is Nicole Larson and I am an ASL interpreter maintaining a school counselor position is essential for supporting the emotional social and academic well-being of our students counselors provide a safe space for students to express the themselves work through challenges and develop healthy coping strategies they also play a vital role in addressing the mental health concerns promoting positive behavior and fostering a supportive School environment by keeping a counselor on sta we ensure every student has access to the resources they need to succeed both inside and outside the classroom we risk delaying or denying Support Services to students because of the need to arrange for an interpreter to ensure that students who require assistance can still effectively communicate and receive the support that they need when we remove an on-site counselor

139who is capable of providing the direct communication access to these services this additional service will incur extra costs as providing professional interpretation Services ensures that all students regardless of language barriers can access counseling support in a meaningful and productive way it is important to understand while this service is crucial for maintaining inclusivity and accessibility the added expense emphasizes the value of keeping the de education program counselor position available on site to directly serve students needs in a timely manner I strongly urge you to reconsider this decision not only from a financial perspective but also in terms of ensuring the best support for all students and staff including those within akd the impact of cutting this position could be far-reaching ultimately cosing the district more than we anticipate thank you for your time and consideration thank

140you for your testimony next we have CLA [Music] Baldwin good evening ASD School Board my name is Clara Baldwin and I currently serve the district as an assistant director for special education I oversee the Alaska state school for the dep and heart of hearing I'm here tonight to address the proposed budget cuts that will directly impact our DEA and heart of hearing students I will be speaking in my primary language American Sign Language you see the seat that I'm sitting in tonight is made possible by the great educational upbringing I had while growing up I accessed a rigorous bilingual education program and was constantly surrounded by American Sign Language fluent peers and adults these ASL fluent adults have enabled a lot of confidence in who I am and how I approach my de identity I

141am forever grateful for their presence in my life in which I eventually saw myself as a leader I found myself in Alaska because I truly believe that death and heart of hearing students deserve the same experience I had but better we want to raise the future generation to excel I found myself in Alaska because I want to be there for deaf and heart appearing individuals they deserve the same experience I have but so much better the Alaska state school for the Deen heart of hearing has been informed that there are four positions up for cut well I completely understand the dire situation of our budget and the lack of increased nbsa funding I still would like to stress the importance of consideration in retaining these positions our staff members are fluent in ASL and by

142our standards using the sign language proficency interview score the slpi is the Nationwide standard that assesses ASL fluency and we use this to identify our staff members fluency it makes our program special because not everyone in the district possesses the skills and fluency and ASL that we require when we lose those positions we lose ASL fluent professionals our students deserve the access to direct interaction with any akd HH staff member our students should not have to wait for an ASL interpreter to be arranged so they can interact with non- ASL fluent District Personnel our students deserve to look up to adults who are fluent as ASL in their language model this will not only enable them to be successful productive members of society but to develop a healthy sense of identity sure our program is

143small but we need to remember that deafness is a low incident disability we have collaborated with other districts and we are the largest running body bilingual which includes ASL and written English program here in the state other districts rely on us for support with their DEA and heart ofering students and we have utilized counseling and intervention coaching services with them the proposed cuts will have a dire impact on the program and other District's ability to access ASL fluent professionals tonight I am confident that you have seen the scale of our program and the support our communities have for the Alaska state school for the death and heart of hearing we are small but our impact is so immense thank you for your time and consideration tonight thank you very much for your testimony also we

144have uh by telephone Nancy Bale if you are ready star six to unmute and you have three minutes again at star six to unmute our system for your phone and if there's a difficulty we can come back in a few minutes and I'll check and try to get you again we did show her is being connected um we'll wait and try and Miss bail again at a later point we have reached the end of our first hour of public testimony um is there a motion to continue public testimony until everyone's finished or do we want to go back on a regular agenda member Higgins I I'd like to move to continue public testimony um to hear everybody thank you okay I'll second moved and seconded uh if there's no objection from anyone on the board

145we will complete testimony what I would uh like to ask just for a 10-minute recess for board members to take a short break we'll come back and hear from everybody else that's here at that point we're in recess thank you e e e we have almost all of our board members back member Higgins if you're in the room if he'll come back to your seat e e member Higgins if you can return to your seat we are ready to resume testimony thank you call us back into order at 8:27 um we're going to continue with public testimony and looking to um Nancy Bale by towel phone Miss Bale if you can hear me at star six to unmute good evening chair Holman thank you for extending the period of time to comment and tolerating my

146fickle phone um my name is Nancy Bale and I've been a school nurse in the ASD since fall 2005 I understand how difficult the situation around our prospective budget is and I sympathize with those of you who've had to create it that said and with understanding and compassion for all of those present and affected by this budget I have a few points to make about the particular impact of the nurse Cuts in this proposed budget on our kids first going to 0 five FTE for 26 schools of less than 300 students is unrealistic and will not work and it jeopardizes students safety here's an example a school with say 275 students with several unstable diabetics or students with seizures who may require rescue medication or students with care plans for allergies these students need care

147over the full school day not 05 FTE simple numeric cut offs do not take into account Acuity and are not safe second in modern schools we welcome students with chronic conditions in this day and age they receive complex Nursing Care in classrooms not at home or in an institution this is why we as a society have decided to do it but it only works with robust full-time nursing staffing and third reducing nurse staffing unreasonably burdens other already decrease staff in this budget perhaps those who prepared the budget did not realize that when a nurse is not in the building the nurse must train paraprofessionals or teachers to perform delegable tasks keeping in mind that not all nursing tasks are delegable without a nurse on site the already overtax staff must either perform these duties or

148these particular children with chronic conditions won't be able to attend school safely there are many other concerns about Staffing for School nurses but I won't go on past my three minutes only to just say that I'll be in Juno this year advocating for a statutory increase in the BSA as I have been for the School nurses for several years not only because it helps to retain essential professionals such as School nurses but because our kids deserve coverage from all levels of practice we with our voices can help a BSA bill pass as we did last year but then after that we'll need to stay on it to continue advocating to help it survive a gubernatorial veto thank you for the opportunity to justify thank you for your testimony back in person we have Manuel Akuna

149and Lizzie Akuna as our two next testify s you'll come forward and state your name for the record you each have three minutes hello wome my name is maniaa and I've been the BR proud parent of the anccs community since 2008 I am also the academic policy committee board president for anccs I'm here to provide testimony and support of the relocation of the Alaskan native cultural Charter School the lakehood elementary as part of the right sizing initiative anccs provides a specialized learning environment that enables Alaskan native students to thrive academically socially and culturally as a vital component of the Anchorage school district anccs has consistently delivered positive academic results for Alaskan native students and serves as the only title one Cher school this school is special and is so much more than just a school

150to most of our families it's a community that helps each other have you ever heard the term it takes a village to raise a child that the phrase emphasizes the importance of a supportive Community for a child's growth and our school exemplifies this Alaskan native value to its core I'm at our school quite a bit so I personally see the positive impact our program has on our students it's a safe place for many of them and our student attendance shows our kids want to be there because we make a difference but the stress and difficulties of not having a permanent home for our community disrupts everyone involved anccs requires not an improvement but rather a fundamental need a dedicated facility to ensure the continued provision of its high quality program achieving long-term stability will only

151serve to amplify the positive impact anccs has on both ASD and the CR Greater Community our school only has until the 2728 school year to stay at our current location of 8427 Lake Otis Parkway that does not give us much more time to secure a permanent home for our school we cannot gamble on speculation and the hope of another school closure our school needs to act on what is available now so we can secure a bright future for our children I also just want to add next week I'll be traveling to Juno on behalf of the ibw I'll be speaking to legislation and I'm happy to say that one of our top priorities is increasing funding for public education in the state thank you thank you for your testimony you'll state your name for the

152record you have three minutes W my name is lizia cunia and I am here as a parent and as a staff member of a of Alaskan native cultural Charter School I've been part of this school for the last 15 years and within that 15 years I have watched this school grow we have humble beginnings my oldest daughter went to a CCS when um when it was an old furniture store when we found out that we'd be going to willowa Elementary the old willowa elementary school we were so excited um but unfortunately we had to leave that school because the covid-19 pandemic and the ventilation issues in that building since then we have yet to find a place to call home we have had temporary housing at East High School and at Abbott element country for

153which we are extremely grateful however I am worried about our future with only a little over 3 years left at loop our students need a place to call home a place for stability to continue our students academic and social growth a place for our students to learn about Alaskan native people and culture a place to meet our full potential I am asking you tonight to consider anccs to relocate and finally give us a home at lak Hood Elementary thank you for your time and consideration thank you for your testimony Ken and I'm sorry my mispronounce Str or stry thank you uh followed by Paul Neil hello my name is Karen sty and I am the parent of two students who receive special education services in the Anchorage School District I'm here tonight to express my

154concerns about the proposed budget cuts to the Alaska state school for the deart hearing or akd which includes eliminating the positions of the intervention coach and the counselor my daughter is death and she does attend akd she is bot Bing bilingual and uses clear implants as well as American Sign Language or ASL she has and always will be given the autonomy to choose her language um we feel that it is crucial for her to be able to communicate in ASL for many reasons but definitely when she just is disregulated struggles in school ASL is unique as in that 90% of De in heart to hearing children are born to hearing parents like my daughter is um most of these families do not know or learn ASL and making School the primary place for these children

155to learn ASL and work on their linguistic developments while my family is learning ASL we are not fluent yet and cannot provide the language uh exposure that the native death signers can provide to her it is imp imperative for her language development that she receives direct communication in ASL by De adult role models for students like my daughter who need additional support for their social emotional development uh attention difficulties or behavioral concerns having professionals who are available immediately on site to address and deescalate any issues in their chosen language and at their language skill level is invaluable and not only this but the de professionals are able to build rapport with these students in their language through their shared experience and offer culturally appropriate help that hearing professionals even with an interpreter are not able

156to provide effectively bringing in a hearing professional would incur the added cost of a certified interpreter every single time an issue arises um this would also cause delays in the services that the child would receive um while they try to find an available interpreter and get them onsite into the classroom um during this wait that could potentially be hours while they find a Ser uh an interpreter the child could be escalating and be disrupted not only their own learning but the the learning of their classmates um for my daughter who has difficulty with attention it would also further complicate an already challenging situation by expecting her to split her attention between a hearing professional and The Interpreter this would not be effective or in her best interest the anchored School District I believe would be

157doing a disservice to our hard hearing children by removing any de professionals from their academic environment these professionals create meaningful interactions with the students promote inclusivity and have a deeper understanding of the needs of our children than we could ever understand given that hearing loss is a low incident disability and the last has such a small deaf Community we must do everything in our power to retain the few DEA professionals that we do have here thank you thank you for your testimony we have Mr Neel followed by Amy bobit my name is Paul nect I'm here on here on on behalf to speak on half of the Alaska native cultural Charter School a spectacular Charter School success story I'm a 15-year plus education volunteer in Alaska schools and particularly in the Anchorage School District as

158a babon coach I have visited 50 plus schools around AK including Villages and 100 plus schools in the lower 48 Anchorage native cultural Charter Alaska native cultural charter school is truly special three things are special about anccs and why they deserve a permanent home participation rates at the school in sports and these are club sports these are not the uh the high the high uh expense either are like flag football whatever partition rate participation rates are phenomenal one and a half years ago this school didn't have didn't have a gym now 80% of the students participate in one or more after school sports related activities other thing that makes anccs special they have a weight list of 100 plus this is even after increasing the enrollment for 2425 by close to 100 anccs education is

159in demand some of the most of the students are indigenous but it's not a requirement that you have to be the other thing that's important is native values are Universal values and it's on the wall at the school I'm just going to read them and then I'm done share what you have accept what life brings see connections the next one I love honor your elders know who you are live carefully have patience show respect to others and take care of others thank you for the opportunity to speak to the school board thank you very much for your testimony next we have Amy bobich if she's in the room oh Julian schroer and Pasha y apologize for butchering name yes you have three notes hi my name is Jillian Scher I'm the parent of two children

160my son Matias attends third grade at College gate gok cougar and my daughter attends kindergarten at the Alaska state school for the death and heart of hearing I would first like to thank my mom for staying with my kidos so my husband and I can be here and I would like to thank you all for the work that you do and your dedication to the education of every child in the school district I do not envy you the position that you're in and I certainly do not blame you the failure to fund State education in a meaningful and sustainable way Le squarely with State leadership and trust me they will be hearing from you I am here today to advocate ha for my daughter lanaa was born deaf and this came as a huge surprise

161to me and my husband we have no family history of deafness I never really met a de person before my own daughter as you can imagine this was an overwhelming experience for us especially in the beginning the Alaska state school for the death and heart of hearing has been a Lifeline for our family when my daughter was just a few months old we began attending a family centered American sign language class once a week in the evening a class that has is taught by a Prof profal in one of the positions proposed for cut 5 years in and we are fully invested in ASL instruction for lanaa my daughter loves school she is thriving the de Professionals in the positions of school counselor and intervention coach are essential to my daughter's education and the functioning

162of the de School these positions are held by De professionals fluent in American Sign Language with expertise and the needs of deaf and heart appearing students I have worked hard to learn American Sign Language since lanaa was born born but my husband and I cannot give lanaa the fluent access to American sign language that has been so essential to her language development for this we rely on the instruction and support lanaa receives at the Alaska state school for the death and heart of hearing including the school counselor and intervention coach by the way I can tell you my daughter adores the Professionals in these two positions and so do I I fear that if these positions were removed they would not be easily restored Rec recruiting and hiring de professionals to Alaska is difficult we

163have these valuable Human Resources here now do not put that away again I do not envy you the position you are in but I am asking that you keep these two specific positions the school counselor and the behavioral intervention coach at the Alaska state school for the de because my daughter and every death are heart of hearing student in our community has the same right to an education as any other child the access to American Sign Language and the services the Professionals in these two positions provide is unique and essential thank you thank you for your testimony Tasha yman and followed by Janelle casperson it take your name for the record you have three minutes thank you hello my name is Tasha yman and I am a parent providing testimony in support of the relocation

164of the Alaskan cultural Charter School to the lakehood elementary school as part of the right sizing initiative I want to thank you for your time um today in hearing my testimony and when I consider best interest of children I think about continuity safety least restrictive connections well-being and permanency so much of the work that we do is tied to keeping children connected to their identity sense of belonging and community anccs does that for children but they need the stability of a permanent building to create long-term stability to be a permanent fixture in our community anccs does amazing work with the children families and Community their positive impact will be Amplified if that was their only focus I understand the feeling of displacement and the negative impacts of temporary housing and the uncertainty that brings this

165that brings that it brings this is yet another location disruption for anccs students families and staff the abbit loop Ed location has been a great environment for young students and I see the Boost of morale it brought students and staff to have their own appropriate space that was safe but it was never a long-term sustainable fix lakehood elementary is and CCS embodies passing down traditional ways of knowing and being that are integral to this community they have been Innovative in their approach to an education environment that gives Alaskan native students hope empowerment a sense of belonging and connection they are an asset to ASD with their pos positive outcomes and being the only title one charter school anccs needs a permanent home lakehood Elementary is a long-term permanent solution pagas for your time thank you

166very much for your testimony denell casers followed by Kevin Zen who is telephoning you have nots hello my name is Janelle casperson as an educational interpreter at akd I not only facilitate communication between students and staff but I demonstrate a shared responsibility I work collaboratively with deaf staff these interactions are crucial to highlight the value of Deaf culture I come from a small town of metla cataa and so I know what it's like for other rural areas where there are limited de Role Models for our students since I moved to Anchorage The Hub of Alaska for this genuine de Community with amazing resources and staff has been so amazing students from rural areas fly in from other Villages they leave their home to seek the opportunity of having direct communication from deaf staff and learn

167alongside with their deaf peers language deprivation sometimes with other disabilities in addition to being deaf requires experienced native signers de adults who have gone through the experience of navigating through a hearing world as a hearing person myself I am telling you that it is so vital to think about the background of each individual deaf student and their thought worlds and how important it is to have a deaf role model in their lives we have de members of the akd staff that have provided services for more more than a decade and can speak from their own experiences as an alumni looking at their accomplishments and what they do for our students it is without a doubt these kids can see a future for themselves and see that they have an endless realm of possibilities as they

168move forward through their own deaf lens working with deaf staff has helped me to understand the deaf perception better but I will never fully understand students should be able to connect with their counselors and teachers in a direct way through death eyes whenever possible think about the isolation some students must face especially in rural areas where there is little access to other individuals that are fluent in American Sign Language I imagine your plan is to expect our akd students to be assigned to one hearing counselor's case load and have an interpreter present and your problem is not solved I can't stress enough how much of a disservice this is it is a crippling blow to their development and as they navigate how to become working members of society we have perfectly qualified and experienced DEA

169persons here willing and able to do their job and thinking of this practically let's say you need an interpreter immediately following a high-stake situation with a student educational interpreters who are part of the akd staff are meant to stay in their role as interpreters for mainstream classes if there's any reprimand of any sort or you need emotional support you must call a contracted interpreter which is somebody outside of the school district so your only other option is to possibly wait for hours you have all that you need already here within the Alaska state school for the death and heart of hearing listen to your community when we tell you that you cannot afford to lose these critical positions ignoring our voices here tonight thank you for your testimony we have Kevin Zang by telepone uh

170he's not online Mr Zang if you hear me call back in we will Circle back around um Byron jensenon and followed by Erica [Music] Monahan okay I'm sorry Eric manahan will be telephonic you have three NES hello good evening my name is Byron and my role at the Alaska State School for the Deaf is intervention coach behavioral intervention coach I wanted to share a little bit about my background I have a fortunate to have a background similar to CLA I grew up in a rich language environment I am deaf and so are my parents I come from a deaf family I went to a school for the deaf and I was lucky to have that rich language environment where everybody around me knew sign language I could communicate directly I was able to go to

171college I was able to graduate from Idaho State University and I thank all of them that it's all due to my ability to have communication and language my whole life I really wanted to come and check out Alaska and see what was going on here and one thing that I noticed was how so many things here are challenging compared to the lower 48 the cost of living um jobs and also being a member of the de Community I worked at whey school for a while as an intervention coach and I also worked at Northstar hospital for a while I've been around a lot of the here and I've seen a lot of the behavior intervention needs within anage School District when the intervention coach opened up I applied for it and I really connected with

172a lot of the students that I work with one student in particular was mainstream they were the only deaf student in the whole entire program and there were many many issues until I showed up there as another deaf person they were not alone anymore they were able to communicate with me somebody who knew their language and understood them I worked I tener within the inor school district as well and one of the most important things about having my position as well as the other de professional positions is again that direct communication where students are able to use their language naturally to communicate with their [Music] education and a little bit more about my background as well I just wanted to say I was really lucky and fortunate to be the first person in my family

173who is all deaf to graduate from college and also Al being here at the encorage school at the Anchorage School District and seeing the limited resources that are here for our de students and seeing what is accessible for students and what the limitations are as well myself as a deaf professional and having had the life experience that I have had I do have the ability to really adjust my language needs to what the students need to really communicate with them effectively I also wanted to talk about the Asm class at enourage high school I heard that that position is going to be U affected as well and I would like to consider keeping that ASL position um at the high school which is teaching ASL as a second language it's been really great to see

174how many hearing students are learning American Sign Language and it really provides a sense of of place and self for the the deaf students in our program to have peers that they can communicate with it's wonderful to see that connection and how it's positively impacted the DEA students East High School there are students who took classes at East s High School in the ASL program and now they have come back to work within our program under akd as teachers assistant par professionals it's wonderful to see that growth so I'd like to also advocate for keeping the position of the ASL teacher at e inage high school I know that you guys have some very difficult decisions to make and you're all under the micros scope right now and the community for the decisions that you

175have to make but I do want to thank you for your consideration and your time for letting me share about what's really important to me in my community thank you for your testimony we have Erica Maham by telephone Monahan if you hit star six you can unmute yourself and you will have three minutes still muted again star six to unmute we're unable to hear you at this time but we will check pardon can you hear me now yes we can you have three minutes thank you so much thank you so much for the opportunity to testify my name is Erica manahan and I am a parent of two children in the anchor school district and I'm calling tonight to testify about the budget I recognize that the um the real beef here is with the

176state legislature and I plan to Advocate and encourage other people to advocate for the legislature to come through with more funding and I appreciate the comments of so many of my students um especially ruie um to that effects that said there are a number of hard choices that SCH board is faced with right now I don't envy you your decision and so I want to share a bit of my prioritization those who have heard me testify so far know that I am a fundamental person we have an obligation as number of lessons pointed out articulated in the State Constitution and other judicial decisions to educate towards fundamentals Reading Writing math science and those are the basics that we cannot Escape in straightened circumstances we need to attend to that first um second well and you

177know how do you do that it means and this is so un untasteful to even hear these words coming out of my mouth that you cut teach your experts before you cut teachers but counseling coordinators before you cut counselors I'm glad to hear the superintendent's comments about an a for a formula of 81% um of the budget goes towards people with direct contact given the how dire the circumstances is maybe it needs to be higher if 60 teachers are proposed to be cut what are the middle management positions that are being cut um and to share more about my priorities um if I don't know if have time I I um I haven't prepared so much because I am a history professor and my students are preparing a paper on what Aristotle's P politics says

178to them about how to form government and how that may fit or diverge with a 21st century View and I've been talking I've spent an hour and a half talking with students prior to this meeting um but kind of off the cuff fundamentals first but enrichment in high school is also so important what does that you cutemy and vocational training before you cut Sports and art music and I my daughter is in ignite they dissected a cow's eye um since then she's come home and she's saying hey maybe I want to be a doctor isn't it crazy how the H the mammal Body Works maybe doing s what does it take to do surgery lasing these more thank you very much for your testimony your time has expired um moving on our list we have

179Jesse carlstrom followed by Dwayne Mays get your name for the record you have three minutes if you'll turn your microphone there it's on there we go back on there we go got thank you I'm Jesse carlstrom I'm the father of lanaa she's a uh kindergarten student at the Alaska state school for the de in heart of hearing I am so impressed with the staff at the um Alaska state school for the de and Hardy hearing and the um progress that my daughter's made in her first you know few five years of her life is is amazing she's thriving with this program and I see it's a direct result of of the staff the the talented and invested staff and I can't fathom uh losing any of these folks um we're we're not talking about a

180large number of employees of Staff uh but their loss could would be a huge impact on my daughter and the entire deaf Community not not just at the school but the community as a whole um and and in that token too I'd like to advocate for the the president reservation of the school for de and Hardy hearing staff and as well as the uh ASL program at East High School so as my daughter grows and thrives in Anchorage she'll have other um ASL speakers to to grow with thank you very much thank you very much for your testimony Mr May is followed by Charles mcke can you hear me very good everybody that's testified on behalf of the Alaska State School for the Deaf um it's in my presentation here so as I was walking

181up here I would just be saying the same thing over and over again so I'm going to wing it um I'm retired from State Service uh I worked for the state of Alaska 35 years back in 1989 I started out as a rehabilitation counselor for the death Hardy hearing and depth line for the alasso division of ation reabilitation I did that for nine years I work closely side by side with the Alaska state school from the death and in particular the counselor at that time I then moved up into management within the division vocation abilitation and I had statewide responsibilities when it came to Service delivery uh around vocation reabilitation to those that are deaf are hearing in depth line you might be wondering well he has done a lot of that well I'm a

182CO I was born and raised in death family and I have a lot of either immediate or extended family that are adapt and so I was considered the minority in our family so I'm fluent in American Sign Language hence that's why I work in the field I've moved my way up I taught at the University for 24 years American Sign Language and I've served in executive positions I was the director for the Alaska division of senior and dis services for eight years appointed Ed by Governor Parnell um I was called to serve over at the Alaska psychiatric Institute when they were in crisis and I was there for a while as their CEO and then I came back to the division of location abilitation to assume the role of director of that division for 5

183years and then retired the Alaska state school for the death and heart a hearing of all the Partnerships that I have had the connection to other state agencies uh schools nonprofit profits and so forth by far is one of the most powerful for me truly make a difference you heard about direct access direct communication that is absolutely critical I've seen the school counselor uh function for the last 42 years and so uh to see that go away today uh would just break my heart to be honest with you because we've done so much in terms of success in this state the intervention Coach position that's been in place now for 3 years I've actually watched the intervention coach work and it's truly amazing when you have a child that is blowing out in the classroom

184to go in and be able to diffuse that and help the teacher so that's important House Bill 39 Senate Bill 8 death education Bill of Rights U we are moving forward with that in the Alaska legislature we expect it to pass this year really Shores up the Alaska State School for the death and what it can do thank you very much for your testimony time is expired Charles mcke followed by Grace D you will state your name for the record we have three minutes my name is Charles mcke I'm beneficiary of the mcke trust and uh I indicated on uh that sign up sheet I was advocating for codified account at 31 USC 1322 that's Federal you know and uh the thing that uh you people hear and most left now that we have a

185Dr Jared Bryant why does he have a doctor's degree or Dr in front of his name that's because he has listened and he's retained his information and was tested on it and graded on it and was successful and acquired that designation so it's critical thinking that you have to apply to yourself when you go before a judge and he ask you to raise your hand and he says to you um you swear to tell the truth so hope you God on record and before the court on record and you say yes you do and then he says lower your hand and then he ask you tell us who you are I in my mental capacity was freaking out because he asked me and the clerk of court is the most strongest person in the room

186not the judge and they use this letter all cap when they're typing your name out you just said if you speak your name they're going to put you down as a liar blaspheming the Holy Ghost on record as well as telling a lie to the court too so the combination of the two things now then I said to myself why is he concerning himself with something that's um non-tangible in other words blasphemy and the Holy Ghost why would they be concerned who they working for so I call ify myself with the fact that when I talked to representative himo Tuesday about the house bill 69 I indicated that the governor went live Tel the live broadcast and said to the nation that we can rely on the jail system and the prison system for a

187revenue for a budget if nothing else if we cannot drill and extract re resources he's referring to the incarcerated people and that's why I gave you my private Rister bond for set off of $900 billion each and one each and every one of those individuals sorry your time has expired thank you for your testimony next we have Grace DOR followed by Danielle Rio hello my name is Grace store I am a special education PA professional testifying in support of the Alaskan native cultural Charter School moving to the lakehood elementary building as a part of the right sizing initiative anccs is a shining example of educational Excellence that inspires Alaska native students to reach New Heights AC I Ally socially and culturally anccs is a treasure in the angri school district boasting academic achievements among Alaskan

188native students and proudly serving as the only title one charter school we are an inclusive charter meaning that our students who are in special education are in general education classrooms and do not spend their entire days in pullout groups at this time we are working out of Abal Loop Elementary on borrowed time anccs wants to be able to expand its capacity and grow as a school welcoming more students having an inclusive environment for all all students is so important all students should be able to experience working in general education environment rather than being isolated from the rest of the school and their peers I have learned so much in my time at anccs and have made deep connections that will stay with me for the rest of my life anccs is grateful for the space

189we have now but we know our time is limited to less than three years having to constantly move schools and working space we know is not permanent causes stress and strain on staff students and parents we are not looking for an upgrade or luxury we are looking for a permanent and consistent space where we can grow our student population and provide a cultural learning environment thank you thank you for your testimony Daniel Ria followed by Gabby I wela I'm Danielle Ria a member of the Alaska native cultural Charter School's Middle School team I have been a teacher atccs for all 16 years recruited from rural Bush Alaska and new STW I have a sincere passion for our school and how our community strives to close the learning gap for Alaska's indigenous and non-indigenous students we

190are an award a national award-winning school with honors from the National Distinguished schools program national teacher of the year program National math teacher of the year progr program and natur National cultural teaching awards were awarded to our school and staff members almost every year this speaks volumes of our school and our school district because you guys support us I am here to testify in support of the anrick school district right sizing initiative and the opportunity for anccs to move into the lakehood elementary building especially with the daunting budget cuts and low occupancy of several schools I sincerely value the board members dedication to maximizing our limited funding and our high cost um this is a de there is a strong demand a need for anccs and what we have to offer I want you to

191consider the high enrollment that we've always had except for when we were at East High our current enrollment and how anccs has always had waiting lists especially in our Upper Elementary and mid Middle School grades we even had to revise our Charter when we moved to the baras site to meet the demand of our L Lottery applicants and we doubled our enrollment at that time anccs offers small class sizes and much smaller class sizes than larger neighborhood middle schools and that appeals to our families especially as you're increasing the class sizes at other schools as a middle school teacher I am particularly proud ofc cs's growth from a k6 program to a prek through 8 e grade program our middle schoolers are engaged in leadership opportunities such as being ambassadors for the afn elders and

192youth conference which we take our whole Middle School to every year not just 10 students our whole Middle School students and we participate in the Alaskan native language Summit and the Artic climate Summit where our students are involved in Social educational and environment environmental change every year the majority of our middle school students have been with anccs since preschool which shows our families are committed it shows our teachers are committed and it shows your commitment to us long-term stability with a Dependable building will further EV Elevate the remarkable difference thats makes in both ASD and The Wider Community without having to relocate as we have had to do four times in our six 16 years of service your time has expired thank you for your testimony yeah Miss side followed by Alexander Rosales you have

193three minutes thank you I'm Gabby ad Chapter Chair of moms for Liberty Anchorage I'm grateful to be here we educate unite and Empower our community to improve education and protect parental rights you may remember when moms for Liberty rightfully sued the Federal Department of Education in May of last year for their unconstitutional rewrite of Title 9 Alaska joined the suit and we were grateful to get the injunction to stop the rewrite from taking effect earlier last month US District Judge Danny Reeves vated the title n rewrite that undermined the civil liberties of children and their families across the country recent executive orders dissolved the federal Dei department and and further clarified that gender and biological sex are synonymous please allow me to be clear to my brothers and sisters in humanity this does not erase

194you this empowers all of us to accept the one and only body we were gifted with upon arrival in this world being uncomfortable in your body is understandable many of us were at one time or another opening up to family helps seeking qualified therapy through parents helps being removed from reality undermines one's health and ASD is not qualified nor does it have the authority to assist only a parent or Guardian has that capability reach out to us we love you and we're here for you it also stands for reason a school culture is to further align with reality students stand a much better chance of success this brings us to our understanding that the board and administration were awaiting this decision to course correct the unlawful gender non-conforming guidelines under the department of diversity Equity

195inclusion and Community engagement that requires parents to audition for mental health information about their children it's way past time my fellow civil servants not only can you meet this entire 10-page pamphlet but dissolving this department will save you a much needed $400,000 approximately each year this action has the added benefit of improving student outcomes teacher retention and staff morale this step toward common sense is rectification sorely needed by this community our hope is that you will welcome the opportunity and act appropriately and expeditiously we support the dissolution of any guideline policy Rule and Department that diminishes parental rights without due process and undermines a child's primary support system any decision to endure these aggressions against families and their values is evidence of ethical misconduct and ought to be dealt with accordingly moms for Liberty Anchorage

196looks forward to working with the district and board to implement Positive Solutions that improve education and protect parental rights thank you thank you for your testimony Alexander rosalo is followed by Cynthia gelen I'm sorry if I'm mispronouncing that you have three minutes thank you my name is Alexander Rosales and I am a father of two kids in Anchorage School District and I'm here just to speak on behalf of them and all the other kids so about a year ago in April I came down here to speak on behalf of safety in our schools um and what was told to me from this board and all the emails that I got was student safety is a top priority and that is continually said every single time an email is sent out however now we're looking at

197a $100 million deficit uh you're not not thinking about the big picture you're looking at just the school district what we see with our legislature uh they're looking at uh an increase of $1.5 billion doar just from education from The increased spending that you all want to do in the board so what that's going to do it's going to enslave our children in the future we are going to be overspent and under performing in our schools so safety wise what I understand right now is that you guys are offering teachers that are Bing the district for a long time an option to leave well that doesn't help because those are the experienced teachers that know how to deal with the students we have a lot of teachers that came up here and spoke for the

198de school I hear you guys I don't I don't speak very well ASL but I can hear you you know that's easy for me it's not easy for all of you those kind of support systems need to be in our school district so then we look at sports sports are probably the most influential thing on our children's mental health right now our teens are experiencing suicide rates that are higher than military members with PTSD I know that because I'm a veteran and I've lost a lot of friends so when I see you guys cutting school like sports I see an outlet that's being erased we need to further engage with our kids and what matters to them and what's most important so how do we fix it resp responsible spending you have one job actually

199there's three of the school board one of them is budget you do have to fix it it's not just complaining to the legislature because I've engaged and talked with them as well but they're going to be increasing spending as well they're going to be looking at increasing the retirement and pension and that is going to tie our kids into spending for all of you on the board and then they have to try to find a job after that that is not preparing our students or becoming an adult or transitioning to something else what they're doing is they're seeing that it's too expensive to live in Alaska because our spending is too high you all on the board are the ones increasing the inflation in Alaska that's simply put don't spend so much inflation won't go

200so high be responsible teach our kids what what we should be teaching them make sure they're safe and with 5 thank you for letting me speak and everybody else so last time I wasn't able to so thank you thank you for your testimony we have Cynthia gush openen followed by Jessica Hardy and if you'll state your name for the record I'll try to remember how to pronounce it uh Cynthia Gip um so my name is Cynthia gine I'm the mother of three ASD students um one in a in CCS one in a brick and mortar high school and then one in a COR correspondent school um first I want to express my gratitude to ASD for taking proactive measures to Shield our students from the trauma that could arise from immigration officials and train ASD

201premises personally I truly appreciate the stance ASD has taken on this issue with this in mind i' would like to discuss how ASD can further support our students especially our indigenous students by securing the lak hood Elementary building as the next and ideally permanent location for the Alaskan native cultural Cher school when I applied for my youngest child to enter the ancs lottery I was very hopeful that he would be picked and I was incredibly excited when he was for me his enrollment atccs represented an opportunity for him to engage with his culture in a way that my two older CH children never had during his first year of school my son attended a small section of East High School and even under these circumstances I witnessed him Thrive both academically and culturally when anccs

202relocated to the Abbott building it was clear that not only my son but also other students and staff truly valued having a dedicated space for learning they've been able to have extracurriculars like jny practice batmon choir and family activities such as family nights and holiday events these types of activities are crucial to fostering student family and staff connection they're also crucial to fostering the cultural identity of our students and nurturing pride in their indigenous Roots I can't say enough about how appreciative I am that anccs exists and the impact this school has had on my student and other students I ask that you please consider giving anccs security by offering them the lak hood Elementary building thank you okay for your testimony Miss Jessica Hardy Jessica Hardy still here now seeing not seeing anyone approaching

203the podium um that does complete our testimony for the evening uh thank you all for coming and spending the time making the effort to talk to us um a lot of it has been very compelling back to our agenda that brings us to section F the consent agenda um do any members have consent agenda items they wish to pull Mr chair move to approve the consent agenda is listed is there a second second okay moved and seconded to approve the consent agenda my understanding right that if we are all present we can simply say without objection the consent agenda is adopted does anyone have any objection with that we have passed the consent agenda we do not have any action items for tonight that brings us to non-action items anyone have any non-action items they

204wish to call for discussion Ember lessons thank you I would like to pull memo 096 which is the FY uh 26 preliminary financial plan and budget yeah are there any other items any members want to discuss this evening if not we will have a discussion on item 096 Miss lessons would you like to speak to it thanks I know that this is just the start of the conversations we're going to have I just thought it was timely I appreciated that we started the evening with a superintendent's update and deep dive um on what was happening we had a really good work session on the budget uh we did hear public testimony and it seems like a timely chance to Circle back um I talked a little bit about the more case earlier tonight and and

205shared part of the precedent that I understand more established um what I didn't say though um was this that in in the more case to my knowledge and I'm not a lawyer but I've done some reading the plaintiffs failed to and I quote present any evidence that all of these District level positions were essential to the operation of the district end quote this is a very specific case talking about specific districts at a specific moment in time and Anchorage was not involved my point is that my takeaway from part of Judge Gleason's finding here is that how money was spent was very relevant in the Court's determination of adequacy um and so judge glean wrote at the time that uh the evidence at this time referring to that court case is inconclusive as to whether

206the resources in that District are being adequately directed to Student Learning so as to Accord the children in that District a meaningful education end quote my understanding as I've looked at different budgets that ASD has prepared over time is that there has been for many years an intentional effort to align dollars with instruction and you know language to that effective use what I noticed and maybe I'd like to just flush out a little bit more or ask the administration to flesh out is in this budget what I my my basic understanding is that we took the FY 25 budget and we we kept the proportions um to different areas relatively the same we sort of shrink the budget proportional and maybe I mischaracterizing what I guess I want to see spelled out more clearly here

207tonight or in subsequent followup is how this budget specifically aligns dollars with instruction and I know that we tried really hard um and I know that this was in the words of our CFO the most depressing document that the district has ever put together and I guess maybe I'm wondering whether there's any way to further shift resources towards instruction and that's a broad question but but it's really it's coming out of my my general understanding of the more findings so I guess I wonder if we could talk about that a bit sure member lessons I think this would be best for followup um with an additional analysis on instruction but I will leave you with one of the intentional decisions was to try to rather than fully budgeting for vacant positions consider to not prioritize

208a vacant position so we can use that to buy ourselves time to know what the full Revenue Outlook is if we there is a universe where we could invest more dollars into direct instruction but it might actually mean more layoffs and more reductions because we're budgeting to positions that may or may not be filled so part of the strategy initially was protect as many people currently in jobs as possible so given um some of the great points that you brought up I'd like the team to give some thought to it and maybe present the data in a different way so the board can make the the right um cost benefit analysis great thank you any other questions or discussions on the budget member Wess yeah and again I've only just only got my paper copy

209I can only start fumming through it so quickly but get my pens ready and my sticky notes um I am concerned about some of the things that have come before us tonight um some things that have not come before us one of those is uh my understanding that there's a reduction um 150 something thousand to the third session at King Tech High School and you again correct me if I'm wrong my understanding is that that allows ASD students to attend and get CTE experience after the school day and it is also a revenue generating partnership with the lower Yukon cim School District so I guess I'm wondering what trimming that third session for King Tech in this budget will do to CTE access and which is an objective and to the opportunity to generate Revenue

210um and if that needs to be followed up in the future that's fine I just wanted to raise that that was a particular concern that popped up great questions M lessons um Mr guson do you have any initial thoughts would you like to wait my initial thought on that is that the actual money that has been proposed to be cut is actually for the transportation that is not used very much most of the third session um students are actually students that drive themselves and one of the things that we have is those students that need to ride the bus if they take a the transportation to King Tech when they go back they go back to their home schools and then they don't have access to their houses so we have a lot of kids

211that can't access that specifically and so they don't use that Transportation piece so again that's this is a proposal um it won't affect anything that we're doing for third session we still have the the um partnership we still plan on having third session the money is just at the at the transportation piece thank you maybe this gets to some of uh I mean we've talked about the um you know we the board has accepted the second year of the uh student the ssae grant the the 5ar department of um education funding for the cies which at a base level I understand is to improve access to CTE opportunities grants are kind of a funny thing in my mind because I don't see the board as being able to direct funding but it seems like a

212transportation to King Tech item might be incorporated in a grant that's all about CPE and access I'd have i' I'd have to look at that because we'd be looking at supplanting um something that we had this year we took out of the budget and putting in a grant is probably supplanting so we'd have to look into that okay I guess I appreciate the followup other questions or discussion by the board M Donal thank you Mr President and we had a lot of discussion earlier in the evening about the big picture of Education funding in the state I just wanted to raise a couple other points related to the big picture uh some 22% of alaskans live in areas of the state that pay no local taxes for public education you got a really well-paying job

213you don't pay anything you got a job with the state government or federal government you don't pay anything you don't having to have millions of dollars in real estate own a business you don't pay anything towards your local education nothing on a local level now that ought to be reformed as well when we talk about increasing the BSA it's a broken system the legislature many years ago passed the mandatory buau act that was intended to eventually organize the state into so that everybody had some form of local government I defy you to find a place in the United States of America where the people in the local those areas have zero form of local government um everybody has a local shareff I mean in the smallest Community the most poorest Community anywhere in the United

214States they provide for their something for their local law enforcement and something for their local schools this is um ad not this is just I think unacceptable that there's such a large percentage of alasin aren't shipping anything in towards the local cost of their own Local Schools um so that's a fundamental issue of fairness for this community um this community not only pays the current assessed uh minimum but we pay the maximum where as the cost of our local schools and then we even go beyond this because this community is such a strong support of local education that they're working very hard the assembly and we've all expressed our gratitude for them for helping out with Transportation costs and other costs that we're not um at least previously we haven't been forbidden on funding locally

215um I'm very concerned that that policy might be changing in the near future which will put another challenge to this board um but and then let's take a look at why that is I defy anybody to give me a logical reason for the current limitation amount in statute on local contributions I've never heard one I heard it was a completely just a madeup number that was what they needed to do at the time to get it pasted you know there ought to be a logical basis for limitations on what communities can do for their own schools but I don't think it exists in this state the current statutory limitation on local contri tions is not based on any federal law there's no federal mandate saying that's what we needed to do in this state it

216was a completely arbitrary political decision that was made some 20 years ago and I think it's strongly inappropriate and it restricts communities from even helping out their own schools locally it's we're we're restrained by that from helping ourselves in this community and that's not fair and it's not right it ought to be based on some sort of logic or some sort of federal specific guidelines but I do not believe I've ever heard a justification for that particular dollar or percentage amount that or dollar amount that limitation of Statute that's another thing that needs to be reformed from the big picture of Education funding in this state um so I think there's other things other than the BSA that also need to be considered and of course the final one which I greatly appreciate the unanimous

217support of the Anchorage assembly and this board for adding to our priorities is the incredibly unfair lack of a accurate area cost differential in the education funding formula and that is due for because we haven't had a valid assessment of the differential between District costs in the districts different districts for something like 20 years now it was never Invision when we adopted the when we I remember when people told me and Randy Phillips and Gary Wilkins and John torguson but we were crazy to try to get a state funding formula for Education we were told you could never do it and those guys talked me into working with them on it and we went all over the state working on it and back in 1996 or so we got the first time the state ever

218had a a formula for funding Local Schools public education that was based on some form of logic and not just politics and it's remarkable it's held up this long um and there's been a few tweaks over the years but it was never intended not to be modified for the existing economic situations and that's why the area cost differential it's essential that it be updated periodically to to actually legitimately and accurately reflect the actual cost for delivering education in in those particular regions of the state and it hasn't been and there's no justification to that um I've told this story before I'm going to tell it again um about six years ago worked with the Anchorage assembly and actually got the money in the Anchorage budget to pay for a new area cost differential study by

219the uh University social and economic HST who were the ones that did the original studies and who have all said very frequently have said this this current study you know is needed and the current analysis is broken Anchorage is no longer the most inexpensive place in the state to deliver education um and so we actually got the money to do it and I negotiated with iser because they give a different rate for their projects you know for for when it's a government paying for it versus the private sector and and iser said well we're not going to do it and I said why not well if we use Anchorage money to do it then everybody will think it was bias in favor of angor okay so let's try to find a neutral third party do

220it we went to the Alaska Association of school boards they refused to do it they said we could give you the money and you could pay for it oh no we can't do that it's too much of a hot potato for us we don't want to make other people mad at us if it came down so you know that Anchorage you know turned out you were being treated unfairly oh well then people would get mad at us for doing it um so they didn't want to do it um I'm just so grateful that this community is recognizing how unfair this has been not not to not to the parents as much as the kids it's unfair it's unfair to our children they're in schools that they are objectively discriminated against with a fair funding system

221against Anchorage kids and I'm so glad that the all the local officials in this community have recognized that and asked for it to be you know dealt with we're talking about a DI Minimus amount of money compared to the giant education budget in the state and it's not getting done and the legislators from this community need to become brave enough to represent their own children and to fight for this as part of Education funding reform in this state thank you any further discussion on memorandum member lessons I guess I don't know whether this is appropriate to ask now but why not um have there been any further conversations about um maybe coming to when we would be voting on this currently it's scheduled to vote on this at our February 18th board meeting I suspect

222that we'll be hearing a lot of public testimony and I think previously previously I have asked that we have additional listening opportunities kind of like in the way that we did last year I realize that ask that ask places a disproportionate burden on staff to pull a budget together at a later point in time closer to the end of the month perhaps than February 18 I guess so is there is there any additional information about whether we might might um have an additional meeting this month to talk about the budget meeting or meetings um my understanding was we it might be considered just because of the volume of testimony uh in relation to which schools we might move into vacated schools along with the budget um but looking at at the amount of testimony that's

223been contained within the meeting um I unless pardon me unless we feel like we can't actually have the testimony during our regular meetings by inations did not schedu one um I I'm quite willing to change that by the will of the board but um would seem to me that we're we obviously are getting a lot of it but we are getting done in our regular meeting in a regular time which I think is benefit to the public as well as our he so if um anyone on the board wants to suggest that the addition meeting for that purpose um certainly consider certainly go by the will of the board M Jacobs yeah thank you Mr chair um I just want to flag that I've had on my calendar um the date of 225 as a

224potential date where um we could still have our decision made on the operating budget and then be responsive to any latebreaking changes from the legislature regarding HB 69 um or um choose to um defer the decision if if we for some reason feel like action is imminent um so I think we have that option available to us it would be the last Tuesday of the month I believe uh with that said and on a different thread um I would ask uh is my preference and I think it's it's the best governance option um for transparency as well as U to hold our board accountable for us getting our work done that we set an amendment deadline for the operating budget of um the publishing of the uh board um book uh being the meeting book

225for our meeting where we take action on the 18th um we have the document in front of us we have weeks ahead of time to make literally any proposed amendment we'd like um having the opportunity for the public to see any potential amendments and then be able to speak on that um just Mak so much sense and um allows us to adopt better amendments potentially um and then have more informed conversation when Administration has additional time to review those proposals and so that would be my ask um regarding the meaning flexibility I think we can um play that at my ear as we see what's happening in Juno but um I would ask and frankly would support um us getting our amendments written beforehand on time um so we all know what's coming and can

226have inform form dialog thank you would it be the will of the board that we have February 25th is an option depending on the volume of testimony and and business at the February 18th meeting and determine at that point if we need additional Ember less my personal preference is that we dedicate the 18th to testimony whether that fills up an hour or five hours we can then take that testimony and use that and any new information that maybe coming from Juno produce I I do appreciate member Jacob's um suggestions to bring amendments ahead of time but there would be an interval between the 18th and maybe Saturday the 22nd to produce amendments in a timely fashion for a more action oriented meeting on the 25th I just I think it behooves us to produce amendments

227if we will following and not prior to public testimony I do think that we will hear more public testimony as information continues to come out with my sense other comments MERS yeah if um it produces a a process where we can have a more informed and deliberate dialogue and potential amendments I'm happy to schedule or to be support a motion scheduling the decision on our budget on 225 provided that um we utilize and um prioritize public testimony on the 18th um and then use that additional time to have that more informed conversation um and then draft amendments in preparation for a decision on the 25th um I think that's fine and I wouldn't object to that but um I think that in the past our board has um and other other school boards too have

228drafted amendments that when we're right up against the um first Monday in March deadline has can place significant stressors on staff and we're continually coming Administration which is reasonable given um you know we're trying to prioritize classroom instruction as best we can the downside of that is there's only limited folks that do the work when we make significant amendments to our budget and I would like to be able to digest um any consider any considered amendments before well before uh we are asked to vote on them and not just a few minutes but more thanks any other board members wish to weigh in I guess I just missed the whole thing I thought we got an email for you from you to hold two dates to like flag two dates I think it was the

22917th and 25th so all of this is I mean I don't care what we do if we can have one day two days whatever it takes but I thought we were we were holding two days already we weren't um and then as it unfolded looking at the amount of testimony coming to this meeting it was manageable um my understanding prior was that we might consider another dat if we were just simply going to run out of time to get our business done um we we do seem to be fitting within it but I also understand what they're saying about the greater Clarity um if we have testimony one night and a week later actually conclude our work on B and I guess the other thing my other thought is is to be real people I

230mean it's not not not the only way for them to it's not the only way is to give public comment they can write to us they I mean they can't text at least not me but they can write to us they can I mean I I just think we need to and if the public if the public testimony is is really um if we got a lot of people then uh U Mr you might want to consider reducing the testimony to two minutes instead of three five hours of testimony is a lot I don't know I I might just pass out but I'll I'll do my best to to to hang in there but um yeah it It's Not Unusual to uh for for you know major conversations and lots of people and of course

231we we're guessing at the numbers but I think it'll be a lot I mean it'll be substantial people wanting to remember what question I think just if we are able to come to a determination tonight I think that's helpful should it the board the will of the board be to say we will accept testimony on the 18th people will come share their peace and not be waiting until 11 o'clock at night or who knows when um for the board to come to a decision um I think it would be helpful for the public process process to just know that there will be additional listening opportunities and then we can pivot perhaps on the 25th you know right at a 6 PM start time to deeply engaging with the the matter at hand which seems like

232a more appropriate time for critical thinking and public engagement I'm gonna ask uh member J um I I will support that timeline provided we um as a group commit to having an amendment deadline of the Saturday um before the 25th and I need to pull up a calendar but I would say at noon so that those can be attached to the public agenda and available for for comments so I'm going to ask the board to vote on this and what I'm hearing is a proposal that February 18th would be dedicated to public comment only and that February 25th would would actually be our business meeting if my understanding is Right without public comment um where we would then have a matter of the budget before us member Don so the 2015 is not a regular

233meeting is it no it's not the 18th be I don't think we should have the budget vote on something that's a special meeting called I think it should be a regular meeting that would be a consideration as well because yeah you know it's a major action normally you would want that to happen at a regularly scheduled meeting it's my reason also because we plan our lives around when meetings are going to occur um so something that's important should be handled in a regular meeting um I'm I support getting amendments in time that when do we have to have the budget to the the 1 or the 15th what's the latest week okay and I don't trust y'all to get it done on March 3rd if we wait till my I just don't remember Wilson just

234wanted to make sure I'm clear um in the past we've had meetings that have gone over I mean we we finished at midnight and then had to literally go over till the next day is that something we need to plan for I mean if inevitably if we have because we we can't predict how much public testimony we will have but it's happened in the past when we've had so much public testimony that we didn't complete business at midnight we had to schedule for a Wednesday so oops I'm sorry could we potentially plan for the ninth teth just in case or I I'm just trying to to gauge if we plan for a second day or if we wing it and end up having to complete business on the 19 I mean it's apples and oranges

235here but it feels like app apples I personally can't remember a time when the school board has gone to midnight and had to have a meeting the next day we the assembly no I was I was on board at the time I guess I was I forgot I don't know I caught up on sleep during that meeting perhaps um I'm I'm quite happy to go with the will of the board um in any direction on this B Higgins you haven't spoken to it yet I I do have the history of having do it the next day um so uh that is not uncommon and I know that when we did that and we did it the next day then everybody had a te chance to testify at that meeting it's just that we continued it

236rather than having a separate meeting which was kind of good that way too so I like the idea just plan on contingency of having that second day there with the testimony of the first day and then if we need to continue it because of the testimony amount then everybody knows in advance that we will have to carry it over I I I just think that makes a lot of sense to me to do it that way and I appreciate the member Wilson's comment member uh Jacobs and then member Wesson yeah thank you um so it was pointed out to me correctly it looks like that our process last year included something similar to I think what member lesons and I will spoken to which is um utilizing two regular meetings in the month of February

237and then scheduling a second or third special meeting to actually take action on the budget and our line of thinking last year as I recall was that um we recognize the legislature was in the process of navigating um passage of s sp40 we're currently navigating passage of HP 69 in Juno um and if memory serves that bill passed and then we scheduled our special meeting and made a decision um in this particular case given the gravity of the cuts were being that are being proposed and in an effort to be transparent as a governing body I think utilizing or two regular business meetings to your public testimony and then scheduling another special meeting as we did last year to take action on the budget I'm recognizing that we will have those two meetings to to

238harness public input um seems as as transparent and accessible as we could potentially be given this collapse timeline um while also giving a ton of runway for Juno to take action um and potentially change our our Outlook in the short term um so that's the process or the um yeah the process for this month that I would support I think it's pretty logical and um something we've done again as recently as last year I do recognize and I agree with member Donley that we you know I plan for these meetings well in advance I work full time um but this is something where I'm willing to make that sacrifice because I recognize that this process needs to be as inclusive and transparent as possible and so I will make that work with my schedule I'm

239recognizing that that's it'll be a challenge but I'll make it work thanks thanks I think member Jacob shared largely what I was goinging to if you look at our at our agendas for February of this year you'll see the the two regular meetings and uh this something called the special school board the school board special meeting and the only item on that special meeting was our budget at that point in time on the 27th so member do so our next meeting if you're if you're talking about doing something on the 25th or next scheduled regular meeting is actually what like six days later five days later no the next regular meeting is February 18th as scheduled right we would simply create a special meeting for the 20 um 5th but I'm saying that there's another

240scheduled regular meeting just like four days after that right the third yeah because that's the first uh Tuesday in March right yes yes I think you'd be correct because then we'd be reverting back to the regular schedule so we're only talking about five or six days although we have to turn our budget into the municipality prior to we have to turn the budget into the municipality on Monday and we have a a school board meeting on Tuesday March 4ish so we can't defer the budget until the first meeting in March what this is really aligning this would align with the precedent we set in February of 2024 which allowed for public input board responsiveness to action in Juno and um I think a better product in the end well then why don't we just do

241two days in February 18th and 19th if if it's if it's crucial that we get it moved forward then why don't we just have the time done on the 18th and extend over into the 19th and get it done well in my perspective the the difference between those two models sort of an 18th 19th versus an 18th 25th is that we as board members have time to reflect on the public input contemplate amendments submit them allow those amendments to be publicly posted and then come together it's it's just it's not as condensed um or as rushed yeah I think what we're grappling here and I think it's okay to acknowledge and I I sense some challenges as well as you know I won't characterize this frustration but I think it's Justified if it is um

242is this timeline is broken and it's not our timeline um municipal code and Charter require us to do this by March and the state doesn't figure out what it's doing until um later in the year and so we're we're caught in the middle and so I think this process presents the best possible path forward for our wisely using our time this month recognizing that it wasn't our idea to pass an operating budget before the state decides its level of funding for the same fiscal year in months later thanks I'm going to call five minute recess so I can go to the bathroom and let people talk amongst themselves um when I come back I'll propose to you that we schedule a special meeting for the 25th with the idea that the 18th will be testimony

243if that's voted down I'll propose that we meet on the 18th as regularly scheduled with the idea that that may run over and we would have to come back on the 19th and whatever third option everybody thinks of while I'm taking a short break we in recess e e e calling us back into session with the hopes that we do not have to schedule a special meeting to vote on this um so what I am thinking I will do is put it to you sequentially um and we'll see what the will of the board is the first proposal is that the 18th be primarily dedicated to public testimony and there could be discussion of some amendments at that point but that we would have a special meeting on the 25th um for the purpose of

244actually passing the budget at that point that seems clear yes just just to clarify I think my suggestion was that on the 18th we go through the normal meeting and all the other items that would be moveed from non-action to action on the 18th it's simply that on the 20 um 5th the special meeting would be dedicated to the budget so it would take care of normal business on the 18th and all public Tes money yeah on the 18 yeah um all those in favor if you just want to raise a hand I'll do a quick count rather than that's three four um that's going to be a majority um is there any objection to adopting that as our plan going forward can we confirm our CFO still in the boardroom before we move on

245I'm sorry to confirm our our CFO is still here an employed game play okay thank you he appears to have not abandoned us yet thank you sir okay when we meet in our planning meeting um tomorrow we will did someone have a comment oh oh um I can put it to a formal vote um just to put everybody on the record I I would need a motion to that effect yeah Mr CH I would move to um schedule a special meeting on um Tuesday 2:25 for the purpose of adopting our FY 26 uh budget and um in so doing utilize our 218 meeting for primarily public testimony um on that same action item it's we're referring to as memorandum number 096 is there a second second moved and seconded I ask Miss Sol and call

246the rooll Hicks remember Donley no and Bellamy M Les yes member Jacobs yes member Wilson yes president Hollman yes we have adopted that as our plan going forward and uh we'll begin posting the agendas in our normal sequence um with that in mind with that uh we don't have any more public comment we have reached the point for school board and administration comments I will start to my far right with member Bellamy microphone sorry okay so I had a great visit over at uh stream acad Academy if you guys have not seen their little micro structures um you really need to see them I mean they're they're they're building these little structures that could serve as um little places for the for homeless people they're building the furniture that goes in it I mean it's

247it's really uh it's really great uh the Betty Davis uh healthy family Summit is this weekend uh at East Anchorage High School um um that's the uh Saturday the 8th starts at 10: with the concert um and then uh and Then followed by all day there's all kinds of stuff going on so if you are out and about and uh want to participate will'll be there from 10: to 5 this year the youth Summit is combined with the Citywide sum so that's kind of how um I'm involved with it and then I did H I took a um the the Council of Greater City Schools executive board met in West Palm Beach and uh I flew down for that meeting um right in the middle of all the executive orders so there is uh I'll

248be sharing some information with um the board regarding uh uh just information on what how the Council of Greater City Schools can support districts and I know Dr Bryant has been attending some of those uh uh meetings and Andy and I had a was online I guess two days ago or was it Friday maybe it was Friday when they had um they gave a legal review of all the executive orders so uh that travel was on my own dime but it was great thank you andess yeah I thought I would relay um um a school visit that I conducted this morning um a principal reached out and said they had 32 first graders in a classroom and I thought oh I want to go see what that looks like and what was really interesting it

249was a beautiful well-mannered and um you know structured classroom um in a lot of our maybe every single you know early Elementary classroom there's like a carpet or a rug and you know you hear about like oh you need to sit down on the rug for a certain part of the instructional time and I've heard people talk about well there's not enough room on the rug well the classroom didn't have enough room for the rug the classroom has to have a secondary classroom or is taking advantage of a secondary classroom um because you can't easily fit 32 first grade desks and that sort of floor space in the same conin classroom space um and that was you know every day I learned something new or I think about something new and that was my takeaway

250that you can't have sort of the pedagogical um learning interaction you can't have the learning interactions where you know a teacher is really seeing you know looking at eye contact and seeing which kids are are listening and paying attention and getting it uh when when they can't all be in the same sort of directed space together and um 32 kids in a first grade classroom is what the budget is more inclined to produce next year so it was a good example of of um what we might see more of if there's not an appropriate level of funding from J that's it but I will say that another classroom that I visited at the same school I had a chance to talk with the kids and I said what are your favorite things about school me

251with friends specials um math and then another kid said three digit three-digit Edition so top top four things from that classroom straight from the horses M remember Wilson uh I wanted to send a reminder that the alternative schools and programs Expo is coming up on Saturday February 8th at bit Middle School from noon to 4 and battle of the books is happening this week I wanted to recognize um all the staff that's making that happen for our students that I know that's a that's a big big thing that's happening uh for our elementary school students so um thank you for all that work I'm excited to I'm always excited to hear from the students uh who participate in that win or lose they they learn so much and I wanted to recognize uh the the

252ASL program the the families the staff the students you don't hear a lot ironically I say you don't hear a lot about our our um uh school for the death and heart of hearing um but I was I was very impressed with with everyone that that came out today um that is a a small But Mighty community so thank you for for your advocacy member Donal so uh over the last couple weeks I've really unfortunately witnessed some really concerning behavior in some of some of our sporting events in the district that's why I thought it'd be really appropriate to um review some of the board policy regarding sporting events our current hopefully our um our leadership in some of the schools is is listening I would remind them of board policy 6145 point21 sportsmanship the

253school board expects athletes coaches and Spectators to demonstrate good sportsmanship during all athletic competitions District staff and parents Guardians have a duty to promote an environment of good sportsmanship by serving as models of fair play and proper conduct students and employees are responsible for maintaining sportsmanlike Behavior at all times and may be subject to disciplinary action for improper conduct the superintendent or designes shall provide for the proper supervision and safety of students at at events under our BP our board policy 0214 goals for student learning it says morals and ethical values based on the rights and responsibilities of individuals and their relationships to each other and their community and our nation is is emphasized and the ability to exercise self-discipline is also part of that goal under uh board policy 5000 Concepts and roles it

254is incumbent upon the School Board District and School administration and teachers to provide for the physical and intellectual welfare of students in their charge further on it states the values of self-discipline responsibility and respect for others in their country and its governmental processes a part of that um we have a we have a board policy 5131 .41 against violent and aggressive conduct and that carries over into sporting events we have a board policy 5142 regarding safety the school board places a high priority on the safety and the prevention of student injury the district shall make every responsible effort to ensure the safety and proper conduct of students from the time they come under School supervision until they leave school supervision whether on school premises or not so that clearly applies to sporting events also board

255policy 51314 3 harassments intimidation and bullying bullying students and staff are expected to demonstrate positive character traits and values board policy 5137 positive School climate um all members of the school Community including staff students administrators school board members and visitors are expected to serve as Role Models by demonstrating positive attitudes cultural sensitivity and respect for students and staff members BP board policy 5142 safety the school board places a high priority on safety and on the prevention of student injury the district shall make reasonable effort to ensure the safety and proper conduct of students from the time they come under School supervision so I hope that some of the leadership in our schools are listening to those board policies and I hope that all the individuals in the school district that are involved in a leadership

256role regarding sports are aware of these board policies and understand that bold policies take precedence over what might be the actual rules of a particular SC sporting event just because something that violates a board policy isn't in the specific rules of a sporting event doesn't mean it's allowed within the Anchorage School District M jcob um yeah I just wanted to thank everyone who made time tonight to come speak about our operating budget and um even those who are taking time to write it it is invaluable feedback which the board can and will be using to help shape the direction of our operating budget and um I'm grateful for the heartfelt remarks hearing from individuals in our community about what matters to them um I wonder if we shouldn't be spending some time to clip individual

257pieces of testimony and forward and on to um house or Senate education just for their awareness but um yeah thank you am hiin I'll start by just saying I'll be in Juno this weekend along with the Las Association School boards talking to uh legislators and having a chance to meet with other representatives of school boards uh throughout the state and I look forward to that I want to uh before I do anything else I'll go ahead and throw in a thank you to the ASL interpreter I haven't had a chance to really pay attention to that as much as I have tonight and I pity them having to listen to me and Dave Donley and others and have to actually pay attention to that to the interpretation so it must be kind of difficult at

258times but uh I do have an appreciation for that as always I really do appreciate the the public testimony we get I love it when the kids come in with their presentations um I think it's a really moving kind of situation and within that uh um I want to express my appreciation to the administration for delaying the process a little bit on the right sizing so to listen to a Alaska native cultural Charter School the difficulty we have is there only one school large enough to accommodate two requests that we've got in and whether or not future schools closing will actually be large enough to even accommodate that gets to be a real interesting question and challenge I hope that we can come out with a solution that will work with both but I'll look

259look for the administration to I know they're going to they're interested in helping uh all the schools that they can and so it' be an interesting process and in regards to the budget process with the state I um I don't know if I want to go on record but I agree with some of what Dave Donley said uh with it um but you know the budget process of what we need for schools and how they fund it though the funding is an issue for the legislature their obligation is to the kids and and I do agree we are not being fairly compensated relativ to other school districts uh Matsu I think was last time I remember was 7% lower cost of living and K 14% And they are both making getting more than us so

260that distribution is not fair to Anchor school kids I understand the political concerns if I was in matso I wouldn't say let's have a review of it so we get less money uh I understand the politics associated with it but there were kids who are being impacted by this we heard a lot of good testimony about the impact of the classroom sizes the uh Staffing and so many different levels the importance I me sports do play a mental health issue a lot of people stay in school for reasons outside the classroom whether it's career technology and sports and all but he keeps them engaged and uh success is tied to it so um I'm hopeful that the exercise we go in with the budget coming up is a uh preliminary exercise to what we do

261with a final budget so that's kind of an important issue from my standpoint I don't believe that's going to be the final budget we're going to be reviewing some stuff we'll make some changes but um I don't believe it's going to be the final and if it was we does it mean that we won't make changes even after that but I just don't see that happening so um I'm optimistic but uh the feed in at this particular point in time plays a key role and so I really do like the the public input at this point in time is significant and my appreciation for that uh means a lot so we'll see where it goes from there with that it's getting late thank you I just say real quickly that I have been associated with

262Anchorage schools for 30 years now and um this is one of the bleakest outlooks that I can recall ever see and I you know it turns people away from the profession it drains people of their enthusiasm um I am hoping the legislature can turn things around but it it is a real battle I I think there are people in the state that do want public education to fail and at the moment I would say they seem to be winning and and it's depressing to look at that um I'll be in Juno also as part of the ASB fly in we hopefully be part of reversing this and getting the resources we need to do the jobs that our educators are trying so hard today did the administration no further comment anyone on staff wish to

263make a comment wisely not I would entertain a motion to adjourn have a move to adjourn second moved and seconded we are adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.