CorpusRecord 4018

02/04/2025: School Board Work Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Anchorage School District
Date
2025-02-05
Location
Anchorage Municipality, AK
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,906 words · about 44 min
Collected
2026-05-16

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e it is 4 pm on February 4th I'm calling this meeting of the work session of the anre school district order um in the room we have member Lessing superintendent ryant myself Andy Hollman as a chair member Carl Jacobs member Pat Diggins um and um do we have any oneon-one member Wilson is online and we are ready to begin um starting up with board requests for information um you have should have that on a piece of paper in front of you and we do have one uh particular request uh that the administration felt like would take a a substantial amount of resources time to deal with um and that is down at the bottom and the question is does anyone on the board wish to move and prioritize that we're joined by member

002Donley member Jacobs yeah thank you Mr chair um a question on an RFI item that I think was listed since approximately our last meeting I'm just curious if um Administration could clarify when it might be able to produce its stance on how to best funnel gifted education feedback and if I missed it in a board Ducks that's totally fine I just thought I saw them on list of the last time I looked thanks um through the president U member Jacobs that should be available able on Friday pardon there's a lot going on last week but we can definitely put that in Friday it's readily accessible thank you Mr chair thank you Dr Bress I uh don't have this written out in advance um I am interested in understanding with the proposed budget cuts the courses

003that we expect to be lost at the 8 Comprehensive High Schools whether that is that information that we would have at this time is this too early in the cycle um Mr Gus would you like to speak to that this is probably too early in the cycle um this principal just got this last week and they're working through all the different scenarios and whatnot as far as what they can offer for the next year so some principles probably have that but overall it's probably all over the place right now especially with the high schools thank you I guess is there a way once that becomes universally available hopefully in the not distant future um that the board can can more granularly understand what is at stake with these proposed budget cuts uh I mean so

004so I'm interested in understanding the classes that are going to be lost especially in person learning opportunities that's why I could follow up with more detail but I just wanted to share my um curiosity and desire for a better understanding yep through the chair we some school some principles are waiting to see kind of how this is going you know what's going to be happening because it's a lot of work it's a lot of work to be able to cut multiple if not you know in some schools up to 10 teachers out of their out of their Staffing so that's a huge project and there what I've told them is just hold on for now just give us a moment read through look through study this see what it's going to do to your schools

005and how is how can you actually maneuver it that takes a while and for me to be able to say we'll have it in a week I could tell you we won't have it in a week or two it's probably in a few weeks and it's just a huge undertaking any other information requests M Don thank you Mr President um I'd like to know what training our coaches um re see for for different sports programs and whether a knowledge of board policy is a requirement for coaches they actually get a copy of our sportsmanship board policy and other policies that would directly affect how they conduct themselves and in being a coach you're the president um we can prioritize that request member Don Lee for the next board connect thank you anyone else and I'll

006ask again if anyone does want to make a motion in regards to the fouryear graduation data uh based on the ninth grade reading efficiency scores the the estimate is it would take about three staff members a week or so to compile that data that's not an inconsequential undertaking not seeing or hearing anyone um we let that one slide off the list that brings us to item C uh the budget and the administration I think is prepared to give us some information thank you Mr President so we'll go ahead and transition into our budget conversation uh we'll provide a preview over the budget proposal that we've developed as the board knows but the community may not be aware of this budget was developed assuming zero Revenue so that's assuming no increases in school funding and the

007other guiding principle for the administration was protecting the proportion of spending on student support services and direct instruction so That Remains the Same um from this budget to the next budget but really the um the difference would be uh the fact that we're budgeting over a a stagnant BSA that's been flat for essentially a decade so uh Mr Ratliff and team will go over the the logistics mechanics and what's at stake in this budget thank you for the record Andy Ratt Chief Financial Officer so we're going to go through our budget which I mean before we start I have to say that this is what I told our principles when we spoke them on Friday this really is the most depressing document I've ever had to prepare in my professional career uh it's going to

008have far ranging impacts on our students our staff our families uh the services we're able to provide U the electives Sports whatever it is there's just this huge impact on all of our students and staff that um it's going to be felt and it's going to be it's going to disrupt people's lives if this is how it goes through so really just kind of wanted to couch that is I mean it's going to affect my children everyone every one else's children that has people in in the district um but right now where we're at is we have prepared our budget based on what is currently in State Statute um introducing it tonight with uh potential approval on the 18th or 25th depending on the how the how the meetings go the state is in legislative

009session so they're actively debating some of the House and Senate bills that have been proposed to increase education funding so we'll go through some of those at the end of this as well but um really we're just in the process of making the initial draft budget and then kind of waiting and seeing what the legislature ends up doing but this is how we got to zero uh so the headwinds we're facing really is that that base D allocation has been losing ground to inflation since at least 2011 uh it's increased by about half a percent since 2017 uh meanwhile inflation since 2011 we'd have about $1,963 more uh in a basee dent allocation than we do currently had it just kept paced we're using about a $700 BSA equivalent to be able to balance out

010our budget for for this year through our um our fund balance or our governmental equivalent of savings in the past years we've been able to balance the budget through either onetime funding from the state fund balance Esser funding or budget cuts or combinations there throughout throughout the last several years here's our upper limit summary uh this is the total amount that uh our upper spending Authority that we're going to request from the city um pending on changes to this it's about $28 million or so less than what we have the current year about 43 million of that's in our general fund and um with some increases in Grants as we're expecting or at least applied for more federal grants however with the grants if we don't get them we can't spend them so there is

011contingency in there for that uh we're reducing The Debt Service fund as it's tied to our payment schedule for bonds and our Capital project fund as that's related to non-bond funded projects the amount we just expect to spend through there um and then some increase in student nutrition so with that I'm going to turn it over to our senior director of om to go through some of the um the revenue calculations all right thank you so this is a slide that you're familiar with this is essentially the state Foundation formula that establishes a metric by which the uh factors that are in the statute are multiplied by our adjusted average daily membership to give us our final number that's multiplied by the BSA which is the amount that's said in statute to give us our

012kind of the the bulk of the funding that the district receives to operate um one of the things to note here is that on step two you'll see that Anchorage is a one uh multiplier which is essentially the Baseline for uh the geographic uh differential in that District cost Factor um and that's something that has come up several times uh and hasn't been reviewed in many years simply because uh this the formula was set many years ago and um it's hesitant you know there's hesitancy to review that but what we know is that it costs more now to operate and to live in Anchorage and operate these kinds of programs in Anchorage than it did 20 years ago 30 years ago just like to interject we've been joined by member B one so this is

013the foundation formula that's essentially kind of pencils out uh how the district adjusted average daily membership is multiplied by what's in statute as the base student allocation to give us a number for basic need this also uh the formula calculates what is required for the municipality to contribute for our local required effort as well as the upper limit cap the state cap for uh the discretionary amount um so this kind of just shows you the breakout of those amounts um in numbers uh this slide uh just kind of shows the different parts of our Revenue um that uh we use to operate for general fund dollars uh you'll see that there's uh some amounts that are are circled there in red um in the local Revenue you can see that's going up overall by about

014uh 1718 million and the bulk of that really is that shift to the local required contribution um in the upper uh red box you can see that the local taxes the required portion is going up by almost $5 million um and that we're also pulling in a fair bit of uh fund balance we've discussed with the board um previously to be able to balance the budget um in the state revenue section you can see that there is a decrease of the foundation funding um as well as uh that amount that was taken out for the operating Grant or the on-time supplemental funding um that was used in the current Year's budget to balance uh so one of the things to point out for this slide is that it it does show the cost shift from

015the state obligation to um the local uh taxpayers uh it shows that for um the overall contribution the local required actually goes up by about seven and a half um and then uh in order to stay within the state cap um the additional local maximum goes down by about 2.8 um so you can see that there's a cost shift going on there um and so that gives us a total uh decrease in revenue for our from our current adopted budget of about 43 million do have a request from our technology crew to be a little closer to the microphone or speak a little louder I think we're going to go through a period of adjustment uh member chist did you have a question yeah thank you Mr chair um and just a question from this

016previous slide but um I think it pertains to the rest of the presentation um I think I saw on the on the breakdown of Revenue that we are allocating $49 million in fund balance to make this balance make the budget balance correct cor okay um it would be helpful to the extent that this is information that's readily available or was recently discussed by Administration that the board could hear if we didn't have that fund balance available what impact we would see in the budget that's effectuated um in that hypothetical because it's we won't have that fund balance available to us next year and that insight's important given the legislature is debating um a bill related to the VSA and it's increase right now thanks sure yeah so without the fund balance point of information can

017where does the 49 million show up on these slides it's on the slide was showing at the very top level in the preliminary budget for 25 26 the the general fund Revenue slide second line down fund balance I see it okay fund balance got it thank you yep so without having that fund balance available you would essentially be cutting $ 49.8 million more out of our budget than what we would um what we are already have so in addition to the 65 is million that we cut out it would be another 49 Mr chair can I follow uh yes go ahead yeah thank you and and I appreciate that I'm tracking that it might might help make um things more tangible if we could understand you know when we get to class size increases and

018PTR increases or cuts to programmatic um changes to to understand what that would be visualized and so if there were other items considered that were left on The Cutting Room floor because we got to zero and didn't have to consider consider it it would be helpful for us to know whether that's today or later at some point the board might have to consider those cuts as well and so any information on additional context as we go through the rest of the slides would be appreciated by me thanks yeah and we didn't get to a point where we were calculating out that big of a BSA increase at this point or you know really taking everything we could off the table or or putting on the cut table before we got the PTR to begin with

019member Lon thank you I just sort of following up from that line of questioning I think it's important to underscore that this $ 49.8 million reflects spending the choice that a super majority of the board must make to spend our fund balance down below best practice and board policy of 8% which would allow us to have roughly a month of operating expenses should bad things happen down to 5% which gives us about less than a week of operating expenses so we are gaining we're leveraging another essentially $20 million between a 27 28 million or a a 47 or 48 million spend down and so I just I feel like that's an important thing to say out loud the district is shouldering a massive amount of additional risks we are being asked to do something that

020is financially unsound and that doesn't seem fair it may be the best we can do by our kids but in my opinion that's not fair for the district to shoulder that additional Financial Risk and I feel like that's a message that I'd like to make sure that people understand Y and then that would leave us about um you know 5% of a based on the state's calculation of um fund balance reserves which is the fund balance divided into your current operating expenditures um however of that 5% 4% of that is going to be held for our bond debt rating Reserve so that technically would be unsp as well that leaves us about6 million a little over $6 million in um unassigned fund balanced in case of emergencies earthquake happen School burns down things that have

021happened in the past that um even just drops an enrollment that we un anticipating that would resulting less Revenue you know I've thought of I mean last year I remember thinking I remember thinking about oh if an earthquake were to happen we're taking on that risk because we spent down to 5% last year um and then the onetime funds we received helped Shore that fund balance up it has struck me over the past couple of weeks that there's a different kind of earthquake that we might need to anticipate and that could be um the sudden and unexpected loss of you know any of the tens of million dollars of federal funds we receive and I just wonder whether we it would be who us to have fund balance available in case a critical program that's

022currently funded by the federal government were to disappear overnight I don't know if there are any thoughts that the Administration has right and we would currently have fund balance available this is anticipating it being spent over the next uh the 12 months starting in July 1st um so if we did have to make adjustments here soon for next year's budget this money has technically been spent yet and I'll just add for the record that we are actively monitoring the conversations around presidential executive orders and directives around funding and at this time we don't have any reason to believe that federal funds that are statutorily approved are at risk um but this situation evolves every day as you can imagine please continue um so wanted to look back too about the history of our property taxes

023that required local contribution and the cost shifting that's gone on through the state um so here's a slide that shows from 2011 to 200 or FY 26 the change in state and local re Revenue as what's in provided in the the governor's original proposed budget so the required local contribution has gone up by 25% or about $26 million uh over the last you know 15 years that's a direct dollar Ford dooll reduction in state funding that we've received um our additional local contribution has gone up and then we've had to start supporting uh Transportation which is used to be 100% uh funded by the state meanwhile over that DEC you know 15 years the states reduced their contribution by $19 million or so to Anchorage in terms of real dollars this isn't inflation adjusted this

024is actual dollars and I don't I think it's been since 2009 um 2009 or 2010 that we've got um less than 2000 or less than $300 million from the state in aggregate uh so really is where for for the general fund anyway so that's kind of where we're the some of the headwinds that we're facing now is just that that it just hasn't kept up with um the needs of districts around the state so as we went into the FY 2526 budget uh build we were really looking at different functional areas in in a whole this chart shows uh how we break out our broadcast categories of where money is spent direct classroom instruction has our teachers PA professionals those are the ones that are in the classrooms every day with the students um and

025all the supplies materials equipment software that goes along with those U those positions and those functions our student supports counselors nurses Librarians uh professional development we put Student Activities in there curriculum the clerical staff at school social services and then our operations and mainnet really what keeps our buildings running uh our maintenance workers contracts repair of buildings custodians utilities rents and then Administration is really the folks sitting around this table by and large so it's our superintendent school board our our um business functions payroll budget HR uh risk management all those things that uh back in part of a business functions uh that table at the bottom if you can see that that shows the the percentage that we spent FY 25 on those categories versus FY 26 so you can see we've been reducing

026in every single area kind of across the board um to be able to get to a balanced budget and it's fairly proportional from one year to the next uh percent we spend in each one of those categories so now we'll get into what reductions we're actually making to be able to get this budget to balance uh the first is we use the first of all we spent the $ 49.8 million to help help um preserve additional increases in PTR so we're really trying to limit that as much as possible we did have a enrollment decline this year of well over ,000 doll ver or a th students versus what we projected so you can see by by uh area how many uh teachers we were a were trimed out of the budget just because the

027enrollment declines and we're expecting another couple hundred student decline next year uh there were 12 ft from elementary immersion program so are outside of the metric or this year that are budgeted outside of the metric for next year we took those out um so they'll schools with immersion programs will need to work out their schedules to be in line with the PTR uh metrics that we have in place and then we increased the PTR by four across all grade levels for this year and that result resulted in the following reductions down there it's about 195 FTE and then we also reduceed 21 FD from our hold back pool which is really these unassigned teachers that we can push out to schools when they have um higher class sizes or grade level Bubbles and they need

028support there or have trouble making a master schedule work at secondaries so here's the snapshot of what that PTR looks like going from 22 in kindergarten to 26 uh for next year and then from 31 and a quarter to 35 and a quarter at middle and high schools our Elementary staff specifically uh their schools are going to look differently in addition to the plus4 PTR uh we Chang Librarians and nurses to go to halftime at schools with less than students uh we eliminated all Library assistants out of elementary schools there was only a few of them um we continued our 10% reduction in Supply funds we eliminated the second agenda for all the books we eliminated three level one agenda that were at each school and then we eliminated the ignite program that serves uh

029gifted elementary students and then we also closed Lake hood and naaka Valley and those are the staff that um will show up as reductions there for middle schools the here's the metrics that we use to calculate out the um Staffing and then the changes in Staffing you can see on the far right two assistant principls a counselor and then we're adding some BO support due to having additional relocatable buildings and more lunch periods at our large two of our larger middle schools we're also eliminating all Middle School sports they'll have a small pot of money for some activities but it's not but it's uh in aurate a little over1 and a half million dollars we're trimming out of Middle School uh sports for high schools uh we also adjusted their metrics they three principles that

030will be uh being reduced two and a half counselors all the library assist assistance there with the exception of one that is split between the West Roman campus as they only have one library in between their uh large library and then one office admin as well as eliminated hockey swimming and Diving and gymnastics those are the three most expensive per student sports that we have in the district um the ice time and pool rentals that go along with those that's really the the high cost of those we've also reduced the or eliminated the Dom Le and continued their 10% reduction in Supply funds as well Mr President Mr thank you this is just a a point of a clarification um in these middle and high school staff allocations um we have enroll it says total

031housed is that this year's numbers so for FY 25 or projected forward to FY 26 that is our projected in okay are we sure that they match what's in the budget book they do now they do now okay great the original I think I showed you for high schools did not so that's thank you uh for alternative they largely stayed the same there was one principle at um Family Partnership that we didn't build this year and it'll come out of the budget for for next year uh they did have a reduction of activities for some of those schools that do participate in Middle School sports as well here's how that all kind of shakes out as you turn that that list into dollars so about $48.5 million of 357 FTE of reductions um a cost

032to kind of those broad categories of teachers principes counselors Librarians Library assistants um there's a few other things that we were um added based on projected uh need uh one of the big ones there at the or one of the big ones at the bottom that AK Choice virtual um I think we may need more have it we may under this budget have more students taking those virtual classes to so that's going to be necessary to offer some uh increased options for our students for special services this did change this slide changed a little bit from uh when I saw the board or when we showed it to you it had some contracted Services employees in there we've really just adjusted for that so you can see the net change in service um so these

033are actually the positions that are being uh coming out and not necessarily show the actual tradeoff for the contracted versus full-time teachers so this paints a better picture of what is actually going to be changing um and what people see as as their experience for department administration changes uh we reduced about 42 FTE out of there and about 8.9 million um that's really coming out of all different areas you can expect slower response times from accounting Human Resources uh it as they cutting taex we're cutting an academic senior director some staff out of teaching and learning um some custodians the custodians are actually tied to naaka Valley and lakeh Hood closing as um those are the nighttime custodians the bpos were shown on the other slide but these are here and then some maintenance cost

034as well as the administrative and um or just some of the stuff non the non FTE related things in administration that's generally legal fees we removed all nearly all like food purchases travel soft all sorts of software equipment maintenance contracts capital equipment advertising uh professional development any sort of a lot of extra help we really did go kind of line by line through a lot of these all these departments to see what we could get out of these that wasn't just absolutely necessary to operate member checkups yeah thank you Mr chair about the slide in particular I think in a previous work session we looked at a a breakdown of um school districts and a percent of their budget that was allocated to District administration and I think we compared pretty favorably on that list

035and amongst the most efficient in the state if we're taking these changes into account have we done the math does that put us that that that smallest number or have we had the bandwith to look at that yet we have not and that's actually the indirect cost rate is based on um like a preceding prior year to the way they do it and they have some like different calculations where they catch up actual cost of budget and it's kind of a uh it's not really something we can easily predict and if you're going to compare it to other districts and not know what they're budgets are then that makes it even more difficult to predict um we'll expect it to remain uh low though I'll turn it back over to all right uh so this

036slide uh shows our uh revenue for projected revenue for transportation fund uh you'll see here that that top portion uh shows an amount from property TR taxes that that amount is helping to uh essentially balance this budget um over and above the state revenue uh because there's been a deficit in this program to be able to maintain the same level of service and operations uh so transportation funding used to be reimbursed 100% by the state of Alaska um but in or around uh 2015 there was that change to essentially a per student uh dollar amount that was multiplied by um our enrollment um and that's set in Statute in the same manner that the BSA is that hasn't actually changed or been adjusted since uh around 2015 2016 either uh there's no inflationary proofing for

037that uh source of Revenue um either and one of the things also to remember about transportation funding is that because it's driven by enrollment um as the enrollment declines that Revenue also will decline except that our loss of enrollment isn't kind of equal let's say in certain areas of town or certain routes so in order to maintain bus service to uh certain neighborhoods um it costs the same but we get less revenue for that there's no hold harmless provision uh for transportation Revenue the way that there is for uh Foundation formula revenue for you know steep enrollment declines or consolidations or that kind of thing uh so by and large the municipality taxpayers have also picked up the tab for um maintaining this service to the community um and we're projecting to request approximately um

0383.8 million more um to be able to maintain the same level of service there are a few things that are coming into play for transportation specifically uh one is that there's a mandate uh that we provide a certain level of um of wages uh it's double the Alaska minimum uh wage and as you know ballot measure one uh adjusted the minimum wage uh for Alaskan and so we have to bring our contracts up to uh par with uh with what the law is um so that does factor in as an additional cost but transportation overall has been um the source of cost increases uh you know inflationary cost increases as well as other areas of service um so you'll also see here that there's a little bit of a loss of the State uh Revenue

039that kind of corresponds to that uh drop of enrollment um and as well as not being able to count on an additional uh supplemental one-time uh contribution from the legislature so you'll remember that they did appropriate about $2 million worth of of supplemental funds uh for the current year that we are not expecting to receive again member Higgins these estimates include additional cost with buses because when we close a school we have to bus amount those kids to bring them to a different school right so that that would that's factored into this cost that would be factored into this cost yes so we have projected out some cost increases for um maintaining essentially our same routes but then also being able to um align all of our contracts including our um contracted Services transportation services

040with uh some of those other cost increases so yes member Jacobs yeah thank you Mr chair um so regarding Transportation when the board passed Its Right sizing um plan on 1217 um it directed Administration to develop a plan to begin utilizing funds allocated in statute 14910 to begin U planning for um how we would utilize dollars allocated to students that are in um non-district brick and morar neighborhood schools to support those programs is is that something we'll see n work something we'll see in the budget book or is that allocating existing resources um will that look like a change to the amount that we're requesting the municipality to contribute how if it all doesn't show up in the budget book thanks um so that wouldn't show up in the budget book quite yet as we

041don't know what that repurposing plan is um if we do in a revision to the budget book and there are changes and we certainly incorporate them in there but it really depends on uh the needs of those and what other funding sources might be available to help uh sh those up so we're not quite there yet but um that'll be something we working on member bman this is not specific to Transportation but one of the questions and I know we've addressed it before but one of the questions that keeps coming up especially from the public is how do we how can we be in a 100 million 100 over $100 million deficit and people's property taxes just keep rising and rising and rising and I know we've ex we've explained it I think I understand

042it but I think this might be a great opportunity to explain it to the public again how is it that you know people we are giving the community is giving all they got to in in terms of uh property taxes yet it's just not enough and so I think and I Know It Go goes back years but if we can if you can address that if not here somewhere else all right I'll go back to the slide that showed our change in local property taxes so that change and that required local contribution that 26 million goes up and it's gone up every year it goes up along with Anchorage property values um they did make some statutory changes back in the early 201 that changed the calculation on it but it's so now every year

043it goes up it'll be the percent change in property values is the exact percent change of local contribution so as that local contribution goes up the required piece of it um the state's contribution goes down dollar for dollar so we don't have any additional money for um Services it's just who pays so that cost shifting from the state to the city and that's largely why you see that state Foundation Revenue going down is because the that required local contributions been going up the other part would be the within the recent years adding people Transportation into the mix for U what we're what we're asking local contributions for U just to help maintain the same level of bus services we've had uh since the state has not made any structural changes since 20156 member Higgins it's

044a good question on the local tax issue I'll make sure I understand this correctly because got a little confused on that one the the the local tax amount that we allow to get is limited because they want to make sure there's equitable distribution throughout the state and we've been getting the maximum allowed by the by within that so if we don't get any additional money from the state and if we don't get um uh and and it's is the same and so the maximum amount that we can get from them doesn't change is that correct but you know because we can't increase it above disproportionate compared to other districts in the state as I understand it so when we get an we have eligible for an increase in property tax doesn't mean we're going to

045necessarily get it now so we've got the tax on the the cap on the tax local tax property tax is not limited separated between the city and the school district it's a cap for both of them so every year that we've had increases that money and when it can't go to us it can go to the Municipality of Anchorage and they can have additional funding that way that we wouldn't be able to get so when we see the increase go up because it's allowed it doesn't mean it's being shared with the school district in in a proportional way is that pretty accurate um it depends on the year uh like this year we'll get to a slide that shows that we've requested because we do a separate calculation based on um that follows the city's

046tax cap to say here's new construction here's the fiveyear CPI and um uh I guess CPI and uh what is it we'll go population grow so that fiveyear average of CPI in population added together is what kind of makes up that tax cap growth um and we are going to be this year going up to the local max if that was assigned to us so I pulled up the slide here it really should kind of walks through that calculation um but we pulled in the extra money we could to help support the transportation fund so what was allowable under the local tax cap for at least how we would calculate our portion of it if it was split equal we took up to the max for the local side just going back to the growth

047that we bet from the state limited compared to the cost of living and and other things that would tell you well maximum keeps going up based upon their limitation without the adjustments but the property tax cap is allowed to go up based upon a formula based upon property values and and like so uh there's I'm just saying that the formula for property tax increase would have provided a lot more in the last 10 years than what we've been allowed to get because the state has limited giving us the additional money I think that's pretty accurate is it yeah and for the local tax Gap too that required local contribution goes into it so even though we're not getting more money um $7.5 million of that required local contribution it goes up against the city's tax

048cap but the district doesn't see that because the state takes it from us it's it's the bonds calculated into that tax cap at all or they're exempt from that it's shown in there but it's not part of the cap it's like an in and an out yeah you're right okay and then okay I appreciate that thank you please continue thank you I I wanted to go back to the sort of concept of $12 million or almost $13 million that uh we are using from local property taxes to pay for transportation my understanding is that if statute regarding how transportation is funded was changed and adjusted for a decade of Life inflation uh to be be accurate um to reflect the true cost of transporting students that we could use that 12 or 13 million to

049put into our classroom right potentially right now we're requ in our general fund we're requesting up to the state Max okay um if there were additional State dollars that came in that would increase that local Max then yeah we could potentially use some of that to um fill that Gap but it's kind of dependent on if the general fund local tax goes up if if we can accommodate it within there because we're requesting to the state Max in the general fund please continue um so moving on to our food service fund um we are projecting an increase of Revenue and expenditures in that program as well um and there's a few reasons for this so this is kind of one of the uh I guess highlights or happy points in in the presentation is that

050uh food service has seen an increase in program uh participation kind of across the board this year so there's been a higher level of student engagement uh they were able to bring in uh five additional sites in the current year FY 25 and they are planning to bring on an additional five more sites for FY 26 to expand uh the the lunch and breakfast programs uh they also were able to uh hire the as you remember there were some sites that they were struggling to hire a manager to be able to uh provide the the student nutrition program to Fidelity in a way that would capture um that federal revenue and be able to um provide hot meals uh they were more successful this year in Staffing those positions and so that was an increase

051in the reimbursable meals that were uh brought on and they're planning to continue that um they also saw a higher engagement in their breakfast program and they're planning on bringing on more breakfast program sites in FY 26 as well as some necessary meal uh price increases and a a pretty good adjustment as well to the adult meal price um that we're providing and so there's also a higher rate of local sales that they experien as a result of the sixth grade moving to middle school so there was kind of a combination of factors where they're expanding they're growing um and projecting a pretty good uh increase in Revenue to be able to sustain those programs and here we have our projection for Debt Service fund um it's somewhat on par except that with a decrease

052of uh the local uh tax appropriation and state debt reimbursement this is just kind of matching uh what we're projecting to happen in FY 26 uh for a total decrease uh there of about $7 million add on there on we are using some fund balance in that fund to help um offset the ne the request for taxes um fund balance typically accumulates in that fund as we either refinance bonds and get lower interest rates and lower our payments uh or we project out a bond sale and if it comes in the interest rates come down a little bit and the payments are a little less we accumulate some uh funds in that and it's all restricted for the repayment of bonds so after every several years we'll come and spin that down as kind of

053a property tax relief and that really shows up on this slide where this is our total tax request from year to year um so you can see the required local contribution going up by about 7 and a. half million align with the property values the 2.8 million reduction in the additional local ask up to the state cap and then the increase in transportation and a decrease in debt so overall we're looking about a 1.3% increase in our property tax request uh to the city and then again here's the property tax cap calculation as it that's where it takes it starts with the current year it puts in those population and CPI averages to increase it increases by new construction and then that really sets what your base is for how much you can request uh

054on the on the local tax cap so we're going to request up to the max allowed uh if we were to calculate it for ASD as me member Higgins referenced it is just one overarching cap so generally work with the city and make sure that the city stays under as a whole um so really for the key takeaways on this we balance the budget based on our known revenues our class size are going to increase and school supports are going to be diminished Sports special programs are going to be reduced or eliminated uh administrative and maintenance services will be diminished our flexibility for enrollment declines or any sort of increased costs uh that that really changes our increased risk for our emergency reserves being depleted hold back positions eliminated uh so there's a lot of

055things coming out of this budget that are valuable to us and valuable to our staff and community and our students so right now like I said the legislator and there's bills out there to support education have been introduced and we're going to go through a couple of those to make show you guys kind of what's in them hopefully the legislature and the governor can come to an agreement and fund education appropriately so we don't have to make these kind of draconian cuts um again our the issue is that that underlying base student allocation number really hasn't been adjusted much in the last 15 years um however if you look at even just 2017 to now now here's the state budgets for their departments um from 2017 to 26 uh you can see a wide range

056of increases across theirs uh the gray bars are deed separated out into two components the K12 support for students which is the money that comes to districts and then the other deed operations which would be the folks just at deed doing the work for the state um so overall decrease in the total number of dollars that are allocated to K12 education and this is based on the governor's proposed budget that was submitted back in December um inflation is about been about 25% over that same time period uh most departments have either exceeded that some departments have doubled it even tripled it so as we're looking at education and it being a minus 6% it's kind of a tough pill to swallow for us to be able to um it really just makes it difficult and

057just trying to highlight those this is the change that needs to be made and it just hasn't kept up with other state departments um an unfortunate kind of byproduct of not providing budget upfront or not having an inflation froup like every other department is when education comes down to the very end of the session and it's pitted against that in the PFD it's either education or the PFD putting these costs in at the front end May alleviate some of that conversation so uh that's just just kind of you saw a new story out probably today that was talking about either PSA or education that's what it's going to come down to or PSA or PFD so really you know the history of the state shows that other departments are increasing much more rapidly than uh

058K12 education um so HB 69 this is uh proposed through the house uh this ties our B BSA increases to the preceding three years of a average of inflation starting in 25 26 and then adds another $1,000 on top of that does the same thing for 26 and 27 adding $44 uh plus the inflation thereafter so in 26 and 27 or 26 you see about almost $1,300 BSA increase and then 691 and 557 respectively for 27 and 28 what that does in terms of total dollars for the district would be see see the columns the first one is our adopted budget for this year our preliminary as we proposed it and then what our 26 might be with HB 69 intact it would allow us to add back that $55 million of cuts uh preserve

059a lot of our savings probably down to about the you know eight or n% Mark and then in the future potentially allow us to either reduce class size or add high value interventions that um that really could help our students uh moreover really enables that long-term financial and instru uction planning component that we've been missing since I've worked for the district not having a known Revenue increase or what the plan is until nearly when school starts is just not conducive for long-term planning um it does not this bill does not address Transportation though so that's one thing we do need to continue to advocate for is having that that Transportation fund short up number checkups um yeah think it spoke to Mr rff's comments um maybe on the last slide although I don't know if

060it was directly related to but I just want to be clear that from a school district perspective the um the legislator's um choosing to not Implement a sustainable long-term fiscal plan um by default pits the Permanent Fund dividend allocation with any increase in spending um which could be in this case um an increase to the statutory funding formula but also is um Department increases um the way study that still needs to be released for the state of Alaska Workforce which shows that those folks are probably underpaid significantly and and so our position is not that those two things should be linked and I hope um and I know this board is is choosing to advocate for a a long-term fiscal plan um that completes the legislature's work and the group that um the previous legislature

061put together and so um just want to strongly push back um and make sure that we're acknowledging that um we deserve better than the current situation that pits those two things together and we're not asking for it thank you right frankly you'd expect to see inflationary increases in these departments if you look at s that's got 25 30% increase that's really what you wouldd expect to see is the con cost of contracts go up medical Insurance liability insurance all those things increase over time and it's fairly reflective in most of the um the state's budgets member Higgins I know that the legislature is not going to be to balance the budgets longterm this no matter what they do and I know that there was an effort here to have a session outside to try to

062come out with a long-term fiscal plan and and even the governor thought that was going to happen within the last couple years so I think that what we're going to get at best is a this is what we're going to give you and this is what we hope to accomplish and without the long-term fiscal plan they won't be able to deliver but they're going to have a balance without coming out long-term fiscal plan their their Cliff is here um and so I I I think the legislature is aware of that I think everybody's aware of it and I'm I'm not going to assume anything I'm just going to look at what they're promising what they're committing to and if they commit to it they're going to have to be the one to come out with

063the revenue whether they're going to rob the Permanent Fund dividend whether they're going to or the Permanent Fund itself or whatever they're going to come out with or they come out with a sales tax or an income tax or some other start Charing the oil industry or competitive rate or whatever would we do I'm not going to I don't know what the legislature is going to do I'm not going to assume it and I'm going to assume that's their responsibility and let's see what they offer and before we wipe it out member lessons and we've been joined by member Wilson in person thanks I just wanted to clarify before I know we need to move on that uh under this projection that for FY 26 should House Bill 69 uh be adoped be approved um

064voted into existence um we would be able to maintain that 8% fund balance level that threshold and and so that's an 8% fund balance utilization for FY 26 and then we'd able we'd be keeping that steady level of fund balance thereafter uh yeah so and really if you look at that second line down the estimated revenue is about 91 million so this all this really does is show adding back to things it doesn't um even decrease PTR anything it just kind of gets us back to where we were so if we did get that uh those those funds it would you know we'd come back to the board and prioritize where they're at and what what we want to do with them so this is just kind of an illustrative example of what could happen

065with them remember B microphone please just making sure that in our language that we are pretty specific that we could bring things back but not that we would um because it if people are expecting that everything's coming back because we might get a a miracle um they're going to be surprised uh and also I had can I one more so when it comes to there was a discussion um I think Monday I think it was yesterday these days are gone by so fast regarding other departments uh doing inflation proofing like part of part of HB 69 is is the dealing with inflation right and so in in in your in our opinion is that legal I mean and is that something that's commonly done because there's been a lot of discussion um regarding whether or

066not that's even um the state can even do it um I believe they could do it statute where they could put the the BSA increases and tie it to inflation whether they fund it or not that's a year-to-year issue um but at least would be statute of like here's what fully funding education means okay but yeah I it wouldn't necessarily have to happen and obligate the future legislators than you thank you uh member hins yeah yeah I think you raised a good point the legislature one legislature can't commit the next legislature to the budget they can cut even what we've got today if they want to so there's no limitation on that the only Advantage we have is issue of non elction year and next year is so that's going to make it more interesting

067because you've got the you've got the legislature issue is already elected in for two years the house and the Senate Hood but then next year if they reever or what they do at least it's an election year this year and that can make a difference but you're right there is no the Mind stain is very clearly one legislature cannot commit the next legislature to any budget expenditures uh unless it's actually taken out of the budget issue and and put and put it into a different category oh remember bman on the key takeaway slides um you mentioned less flexibility for enrollment so I'm assuming that means if we got an influx in students next next year there's no way for us to guarantee that that would be impacted is that what that means um if we

068got an inlux in students and we've had this happen in like past years we kind of we went back to the school board I think in August and said hey we've got all the students coming in can we increase our our budget so if that were to happen if the increase in students is there then yeah we have some flexibility there we can go add Revenue to it um however if we lose students and we already have the staff in place to service those and we have to make up that Revenue by using additional fund balance that's where the risk comes in that's the risk okay and then kind of the other part of that as on those holdback teachers that flexibility to be able to kind of plug those holes um so if we

069have shifts in enrollment from one school to another and some amount uh then it gets a little trickier without having those those staff in place to be able to push out and so this budget actually cuts out all the flexibility relative to the whole back we'd retain 10 of the 31 here we have please continue all right so the last thing we have out there is the this is hb76 sb82 and this is the the governor's education bill that he sent over um it includes $450 per k6 student as an incentive for reading proficiency so if the student is proficient I believe we'd get the $450 per student um I haven't actually done the math to see how many students might qualify but um that's one thing we get we'll get to uh Charter Schools

070would be approved by the state board to be inserted into districts Transportation increase would be about $13 per noncorrespondence ADM um so right now we're at 481 it' go to $584 per student um but it also extends the moratorium of bond debt reimbursement from 2025 to 2030 so any new new bonds wouldn't be eligible to for State reimbursement until then um and it moves correspondence ADM in the foundation formula from the end where they're multiplied by 90% up to the beginning where it would go through the special ad and CTE multipliers as well as increasing that CT multiplier from one and a half% to 4% and then for Anchorage it would provide $5,000 teacher recruitment retention bonuses um and then for the rest for other I think that's for like five districts we get 5,000

071and handful that would get 10 another handful that' get 15,000 per teacher how that looks in terms of dollars um I don't have the like I said I don't have the 450 per student in here yet um but we'd get about 3.8 million in additional correspondence money and about $8.4 million in new CTE uh money based on that on that uh on on that metric changing um about .1 million in new transportation funding to to help alleviate some of what the taxpayers are picking up and then it could help with recruiting and retention efforts so um but overall you know if we were to put that $12 million back into the system or restore some of some of those additions with your additional uh with the additional Revenue next year we would still be looking

072at cutting out about $ 52 million or so 50 a little over $50 million of stuff this year and then addition additional $68 million next year to get to to balance um so no longterm it's just kind of the one-year approach although we continue getting that 12.2 million or so and in perpetuity as that would be in the statutes um what that does though we kind of want to focus a little bit on the correspondence programs as well to show you how that would change because at this point it get starts to get a little bit inequitable between large high schools middle schools and um correspondents so up there in the blue it's the formula currently and these are current adms and bull scenarios not projected um The Family Partnership the correspondent school um takes

073that ADM multiplies it by 90% to get a basic need without intensive need students of about 5.4 million or about a little under $5,400 per student whereas West High he roll them through the formula through that school size Factor then adjusted for um the special ad and CTE multipliers gets about $6,800 per student under this proposal the Family Partnership would go to uh 1.0 as a school size Factor any correspondent school not just family don't want to pick on them it's not uh it was just the largest correspondence program we had U that goes to the formula for special ed the 20% multiplier then I've added the 4% multiplier on CTE you get to about throughout the formula a little over $7 $400 per per student per student actual student and then for West High

074you run them back through the formula you get to about six or almost 7,000 per student so almost $500 less per student for a large Comprehensive High School under this proposal than we would get for a correspondence program um right now the way the formula is written on that school size adjustment anything less than a thousand and or School larger than 1,22 students gets um a negative or a less than one school size Factor adjustment it's just kind of and it keeps going down the larger the schools get So currently Bartlett East Diamond Service South roming and mirors or above that and we would get less money per kid for those uh schools than we would for correspondence programs um so we might be renaming some schools correspondents but I I don't know what the

075I don't I don't know what the solution is on that but it's any chance for school board members to go correspondence rather than in person um thank you I did have one quick question CTE multiplier is that a multiplier or is that a percent it's saying 1.4% to 4% so it's but it's actually a factor is not it's part of the foundation formula and we'll go up to the slide it shows it so and really there's no anything that says you have to spend this amount just like the special needs 20% multiplier you don't necessarily have to go back and show that you spent it all on that those certain categories but it is right now it takes that uh school size adjusted amount multiplies it by 20% in the special needs factors and then

076another one and a half percent in that step four for uh CTE just to help district bu provide it that one and a half goes to 4% got so that's really the structural change in that which certainly not opposed to any other questions we are over time I'll remind folks member Jacobs yeah I just want to revisit um something that we touched on earlier but I I really want to highlight and just ask if there's any context that we can provide so um if if the board chose not to um the super majority of the board CH chose not to vote to use all available fund balance to mitigate some of the risk um that we're taking on by um spending fund balance down to the minimum what sort of reductions would Administration consider and

077I mean I we talking High School sports which what I think from memory is $5 million are we talking about other steeper reductions from something that's already in our budget book that we've looked at um any insight would be helpful right we've already taken some of the sports out so we don't have five million left in there um that'd be about that proposal if we were to stay under the 8% kind of board minimum or over that it would be about extra 20 million that we'd have to reduce out of the budget but no I mean I don't know at this point it was really a struggle to get to where we're at now um a lot of things on there that we didn't want to do so another 20 million is going to be

078really painful and just to put a fine point on it and I'd like Mr R to correct me if I'm overreaching but I can't imagine a scenario where we could avoid a massive layoff if we're trying to find that amount of money and that's the fundamental difference between the way the budget's prepared now and what it would look like if we spent down just to 8% it would truly mean that folks who are in positions now would have to be told they won't have a job next year any other comments or questions if not I would entertain a motion from a board member that we recess into our executive session move to adjourn to Executive session for the purpose of contracts negotiations and personal matters moved and seconded we recess to Executive session RI

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.