CorpusRecord 4019

1/30 ASD School Board Governance Committee Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Anchorage School District
Date
2025-01-31
Location
Anchorage Municipality, AK
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,370 words · about 41 min
Collected
2026-05-16

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e good morning everyone I we'll call this meeting of the as school board governance committee to order today is February 30th 2025 at 11:02 in our boardroom present physically in the room Miss myself member Jacobs um the svan online can you read us the members who are present yes absolutely we have uh member Wilson Pres hman member bamy and member Les right and then member Higgins just joined us here in the room and for our record can we ask our staff to introduce themselves to starting with Mr Lang on my left sh Marty Lang Chief Bart sherff BR superintendent Chief academic officer ex assant ex assistant Mr all right anyone else on need to introduce Sol of them before we get going that is it great okay I'm sorry Mr mikenstein is on as well

002great okay welcome all um we'll get started straight to our agenda uh B1 is a policy review um this is our rotating trianal policy review that is starting at BP 4020 um suvan if you are able to bring up the first um board policy that's listed there we can go through that as a committee look for any changes or anything we need to flag for future review and if there are no changes consider those reviewed now just this one was in here uh because there was some updating that we had done that ASB was still working on posting and so I brought it back this time around great okay so does this reflect the um current version or the ASB version It's the current version okay and do we have the ASB vers Administration interested

003in having us review that as a committee today or something we're doing later just to make sure I'm tracking so we have an ASB version wanted to replace this am I tracking that uh no I'm sorry this was supposed to be in our last meeting but it it it's on this list because um we had made some changes a little while ago so this was just reflective of those changes so this has the changes in yes so I think that unless there's anything new we just go ahead with it with the next one tracking okay yeah so we just Mo this one okay thank you foring my confusion um any any comments from board members on the relatively recently updated VP 4020 okay hearing seeing none ass Sol we go any board members have a

004question suggest a change on DP 4111 certificated Personnel Recruitment and selection uh Mr chair thank you I don't have a change but I was wondering if uh the administration had any um concerns or uh re or or uh comments that they wanted to make happy to respond to that member Bam um I think from the administration standpoint all of these uh components are important in our recruitment selection process we have something that address ISM in our um principal hiring handbook and this is something that we routinely insert service um newer administrators on um and remind folks of annually as we go through the Staffing process so um I feel like this is an important policy and one that we've got pretty well established in in our administrative practices great thank you um any other questions

005member Bellamy are you good to go I'm good thank you seeing no other questions uh Mr eist is this new um so this is book yeah this is just a rotating policy review I think ASB and Council gra schol suggest we review these recently we just happen to have relatively newly updated policy on our list as well thank you for the clarification question we'll move on to our next item BP 4112 [Music] yeah perfect 4112 42112 and 43112 legal status requir uh the chair may I um just offer a housekeeping suggestion the these policies that have three separate numbers that um occurred when we went through our uh the process to change from our old policy book into the new one um the old policy book had um certificated classified and business Personnel policy separated

006out so there was a lot of redundancy the ones that have three numbers were actually listed three times separately and I was I I think that that was the um committee's way of kind of navigating that but I don't think that three numbers are needed I think we could just do a housekeeping America could reach out to ASB and have them just takeen back to that first number okay and so is I'm just curious do we know if this is what the ASC uh template manual reflects okay yeah so I I don't even would that require a board vote if we're just updating I think it's just how for me I would think it's just housekeeping we're just uh fixing duplicate numbering yeah makes sense to Mr and Miss Grant approached me to just to

007kind of get my thoughts on this and I think this really was uh something we did as a bridge when we were moving from one set of policies to the other so that people could cleanly um track with the Trans position in the way that we were doing business but most of these were duplicated across all three they are umbrella policies that are meant to capture all employees and I agree that the numbering system the way it is currently has is just now a point of confusion for folks sure um president Hollman do you have any objection to allowing staff to update the number of this board policy without changing any content to avoid confusion I have no objection to that great okay um are there any other board members who have a question or

008clarification or requested revision to the sport policy and I appreciate I want to give the flexibility of changing the numbers but I like the idea that when you do it to update the void so that we go look for things or we make reference to it some other policy that we know that is changed that would be beneficial in this case we I think we just updated the majority of the board is this sufficient for your purpose I think the governor committee has the right to be a to you know wave it I think it just gives us an opportunity to do that it could go out with announcement but I don't think it's really necessary but I do see we're getting an update that way if we did have a question how it was

009going it could be resolved some people may see an issue and I don't I see that for our purposes um hearing from our chair and hearing a lack of concern and hearing member hi request has been accommodated I think we're good to go um hearing no other comments or requested changes to this board policy we'll move on to 41121 certificated Personnel contracts just to read that any questions or suggested changes to 41121 certificated Personnel contracts Mr Lang Mr a um it probably is um this policy as written uh is not the way that we have done business in the district for decades um I believe this was brought over from the aasb book and just was probably overlooked in the transition but we don't on an annual basis re issue contracts to employees and have

010them resigned for the next year we have um essentially what are continuing contracts unless we notify individuals of an intent to non retain them at the end of their contract or um lay them off or if they've notified us that they are resigning from the district um I think for smaller districts this is the common practice in the state of Alaska they actually have folks sign a contract to make a commitment for the following year but for larger districts um I don't think that this is the practice um and I I've been in District for 26 years the only contract I've ever signed was the one in 19 follow 99 when I joined the district and so um I would request maybe permission of the committee to uh draft something that captures our longstanding practice

011so that there's alignment between what's in the policy look and what's in practice all right Mr a we go to member Higgins any additional comments Mr a Mr L said perfect sorry Mr Higgins anything else yeah it it goes back to a biger broader issue when we got policies that wen't being followed or because they need to be changed it need to come to the board because I do believe the boy has made a decision with a policy say You must do this or you can't do this and sometimes I know we've got some this not current this is I've been around too long where where they G but we don't need to change that if you don't follow it anyway I mean that's quote uh from Administration and we really don't want a policy

012manual that that you know uh dismissive uh and if they're writing a policy policy is a firm statement what must be done it must not be done how um then I just would like it brought back to the board rather than the administration deciding to alter it without bringing it to the board and that's a good example it's long time before you I understand it's been out there but it's just it's a good thing to make the changes m is there a revision date on that was last time towards the bottom maybe and I I think Mr Lang was was talking about bringing a revision forward to the goverance committee and then it by policy Pol policy has to have two readings to be changed yeah one and I just want to FL member Higgin

013I think what your comments are fair I think that that in part is why we are responsible as a board for looking at these every three years is to make sure we're in alignment andless things that are here make sense and so I think that's exactly what we're doing right now is the remedy for what you're alluding to we looks like haven't reviewed this policy um so at least this board hasn't reviewed this policy because the last revision was in 2020 so this is our first look at it um sounds like Administration is going to provide an update um I guess the only question I would have is we can update this if we'd like if we have a process that works that um aea is certainly monitoring I would imagine other um certificated Personnel

014would be as well do does there need to be a board policy about it or is contractual langage language the better place for it the question is do we need this policy I know it says that every contract's got to be signed by two school board members we're not doing it we're not so is this policy have any value what we're doing if not then let eliminate the Mr I would I would obviously this Legacy language right to some past and so I think what Marty proposed is probably a best way of saying he I'm sure Marty will capture he wants consultation with me absolutely but capture not only the current practice but potentially how the district function moving forward so it does capture future you know changes based on the electronic electronic format Mr

015I guess my question is is this a situation where we're trying to do a policy on an administrative practice or is it something where we have an interest in putting restrictions on how it must be done that's it is just an administrative process then do we need a policy I'm G to take that not as rhetorical so in my not having thought through this not looked at this beforehand but just off the cuff my thought is teachers need a statement from the district that they are employed so they to recertify to share with other school districts there's no change in jobs so there does probably need to be a policy that states the district will provide that information and then let the district provide it Mr and and we do provide that I mean it's

016available under District connect for every employee they can go see their salary statement which effectively is their contract for the year so like I just had to recertify with the state for my administrative certificate they asked for a contract we just upload that document and the state accepts it so I didn't realize there was this disconnect with the policy that we adopted from aasb so this review process works right we're catching things that are inconsistent and so yeah I I would propose I don't have anything today on paper I haven't really contemplated what would be policy versus AR but I'm happy to go and sort of do that thought experiment and then bring something back to this committee for consideration okay sounds good so yeah um sounds like Administration is going to bring forward a

017revision or um another recommendation as to how to move forward and I think member hien's comments are well taken and I would second them which is if there are policies as we're conducting this review that may not need to be here based on our practice and the fact that the ASB policy manual tries to capture um you know more than best practices for more than 50 school districts and ASD is unique in many ways please feel free to make those suggestions going forward as well any other comments or suggestions or question questions on this board policy before we move on um just clarification is there a certain date that you're bringing this back or would you like to just work on it let me know um I will try to get something um on the

018books for for March or April thank you why don't we plan for M don't we plan for April just to be safe that we've got a date certain all right we'll move on then to BP 41124 42124 and 432 for Miss Grant would our suggestion to rename renumber this um stay consistent for this one too I think all of them that have the three numbers should be just clean that way all right perfect aside from the numbering change then are there any other recommended changes or questions about this board policy is this limited to employees or is this applicable to applicants we talking about both you do it for employees maybe but for applicants says you know I'm just wondering why employes apply employees but not answer remember question I might have to do a

019little bit of followup on that because we do in some of our job functions that require a lot of manual labor require a fitness for Duty um Health examination right to show that somebody has the basic level of Fitness in order to be able to perform the job but I don't know where that happens in the workflow so I think they apply this my what I need to fact check I think they apply once they're selected then it's conditional on them being able to pass that examination and then they get they're in permanent employment with the the district but this also leaves open the much more rare circumstance where if we have an employee who is out because of injury or a mental health concern we can require a fitness to return examination um so

020I think it it probably works functionally on both of those scenarios do you get a preemployment question a field out medic at all that um you know have you had this do you have that do you have anything like that that you do without going to a doctor that you get this because then it makes a difference on you liability for workers comp it makes a difference in other issues but you get a statement from them at all I believe there's a a something in the job description about you know this here the the requirements to perform the job can you do it and there's some attestation to that generally in our application process I don't know if there's a more thorough qu set of questions for those jobs like in maintenance and operations and

021transportation where there is a much more pronounced physical component to the job um I'd have to I'd have to run that down I'm not familiar with that specific because of liability work comp when you have a pre-existing condition it makes a difference and you gather patient in front and you have and it makes a difference and that's considered to be a physical examination even when you're not doing it physically you gather medical information they're going to put it in that category that's what I've been doing so because that's very important because you can't gather that information until job offer is made otherwise you violate adaa um so um uh it could be flushed out littleit about applicants versus employees is what this is a uh if you're doing something like that if you want if

022you want to consider it but there's some Financial advantages if you do have somebody who has a medical condition even a teacher you may want to know certain medical conditions or exposures or whatever you've got that you may bring into the classroom Mr Lang is this something you'd like to address with the board and board connect or do you think you have enough here to review for a change and bring this back um yeah I don't know that there have been any issues that have surfaced around this particular board policy I could run to ground some of the questions that M Higgins has and if I think there is any conflict then I'd be happy to bring back some proposed revisions great So the plan is for them this to consider this reviewed and then

023um Mr Lang you'll are you going to be following up with any information response to Member's questions to be clear or if there's no no need and we're good to go that this will be the end of it is that fair unless there's something noted great understood okay um see no other questions regarding this board policy will be renumbered and then um we can move on to the next I think last one which is 41 12.5 41 42 12.5 40 43 12.5 all Personnel Security check we'll reum this one as well for clarity are there any other questions or recommended changes to this for policy what does effort will be made to investigate what does that mean um are you are you um that's it's odd witing to me it's not an efforts done yeah

024and it's not it's not a choice that sounds like a choice that sounds like a choice and discretionary what effort constitutes um so are we calling five employers are we calling uh we doing but maybe you know if we're going to do something like that be specific is more about what we're doing rather than ort sounds like maybe another case where this template War policy isn't in line with current practice Mr a little bit more descriptive are you interested in changing it to reflect current practice which I think includes a background check through Deeds I'm confident in our process as it exists um I don't know I mean the the little bit of uncertainty in the language there certainly hasn't hindered our commitment to making sure that we're doing a sound criminal background check on

025anybody that were playing in the district especially those who would have any access to kids um if it's the interest of the board to you know tighten up the language I got no concern there because I think we are tight for practice only a will one issue that came out and it was because you limited back whe check to seven years and nothing more and then some history out there which was pretty I mean including fatalities lot bad so if if we that would be the issue so remember if we change this and Mr L if we change this to the administration shall instead of effort will be made to so the administration shall investigate the background of applicants I mean does the rest of that track um or is there some more of this

026more significant revision required I think it stands for reason we should reflect current practice on this policy and when we're hiring somebody temporary be different to somebody long term you need them yesterday and you got a crisis going on it's all kind of issue so it's appropriate investigation will be conducted something like that um because you know if you're hiring Somebody To You Know sow remov got a crisis shut the place down I don't know what the difference would be but that would be I'm not it's just a waiting of it so usually you say an appropriate investigation the administration will conduct an appropriate investigation into the background prior to H distri may be just that may be clean enough it Le it leavs it it is discretionary I don't think you that third sentence

027um is what we do yeah the second sentence in that first paragraph is a little unclear to me what exactly it's pointing to um okay um and so Mr Lang would you is your preference to have the board clarify language in line with the suggestion made by member Higgins um or would you prefer to take this back and bring clean up language to us and ail either one's fine with with me um I think it's really just a matter of clearing up the second sentence to award any uncertainty right don't have any um personal need to change anything in the policy but would like to tighten up the Lang it's the board's language so okay so um I'll work with Mr Higgins we'll get a quick change um get this to president Hollman for adoption

028recognizing that the intent isn't to change current practice and just to clarify the second sentence um Miss Sullivan I don't think this is something the committee will need to vote on and so if we could just flag this as a followup item to send to president hman that would be very helpful although if there's any board members who object to taking that path forward please now would be a good time to state so okay great um so that takes care of our r ating um for annual policy review um we'll move to B2 our next agenda item which is 4120 adult student boundaries this has been carried over from a previous meeting and I see a an amended version version six attached to our [Music] agenda and I think this is administration's item is that

029accurate yeah this was one I can speak to it um that originally was was in our policy book prior to the adoption of the aasb policies um it aasb did not have one specifically speaking to adult student boundaries so Matt tford um feeling like it was important to have this in our policies um started a draft and I think has worked worked with the governance committee starting maybe back in 22 um this is version six so it's gone through a lot of consideration um with the governance committee uh we last had it on the agenda in September um member lessons and member hollan both had some suggested edits um mostly uh about Midway down the page um uh member lesons had requested just moving some sentences around so that they were grouped more appropriately um

030that uh those edits those changes have been made and your pre-existing outside relationships with students um just noting that for purpose of consideration that that section is really designed to call out the fact that we know that people have pre-existing social relationships with students they're going to interact with professionally um the important thing is probably in that second paragraph that if that were ever to be um something that could be concerning that they notifi their building administrator of them that um you know proactively of that pre-existing relationship and that when they are um executing their professional duties as an educator they have to abide by this policy um to make sure that there's no appearance of impropriety or appearance of favoritism towards any student they might have a social relationship with um and then member

031Hollman had uh suggested um under use of technology that we uh craft some language a little bit that more specific or pointing people towards the use of those tools that are made available by the district I think that is an important change here and there's new language in this section that attempts to capture that so that people aren't using informal means of communication like social media and text messaging when interacting with students they're using those things like the remind app um that allow us to have an archived copy of that communication um and it also communicates that uh appropriate adult student boundary that this is an official Communication channel through the district from that you know person's position as an employee of the district um it carves out a little bit some exceptions like when

032folks are traveling with students they have to use some of those more informal means um it creates a carve out for that with notification so um I hopefully this version six captures um those uh suggestions of board members and um bringing it back for overall consideration just a question the last section of the policy references developing um administrative regulations and guidance to further Define adult student boundaries is that do those currently exist in the manual or is that that be a new document that's going to um follow if more adopt policy that would be a new document that would follow an adoption of this on an basis I guess should just to clarify then and as needed basis is will the best word there should that be may just reading that I I assume that

033to mean that there will be something else coming and if there's not then I think that could lead to some confusion later so we change World de May if that's the intent anyway I'm find either way we already have training that we deploy that would link back to this policy so that does exist okay um we have protocols for reporting and investigating allegations of boundary violations the will tied to the very first item on that of developing the ARs is the one thing that's um consideration okay um understood all right uh hand raised M lons the floor is yours I just wanted to comment that I really appreciate the edits and um think that they capture my thoughts you know a couple of months ago uh very well thank you so much are there other

034comments I remember the famous case in 1990 relationship teachers and multiple students with that police wa the school district U because I hired the person love school district that's why but I I'm wondering has there been any any I mean there was statute say that basically if you had a teacher student relationship regardless of the age of student he's got all kind of restrictions before it used to just be 16 and that was a problem is there anything out there want a relationship that ended tach that they have losted a relationship the child was 19 20 or something teach out there you aware I don't think so I don't think they would do it but I was just was kind of curious because of what took place in 199 it's been a little while since

035I looked at the um you know the charges that can be brought against somebody for that type of violation um you know the statutory rules around that and and um so I can't speak specifically to that today um I don't I think the policy is quite fine because it makes reference to fostering the relationship is unhealthy and not professional and all that I think that covers it all I was just kind of curious because I knew that that was a major legal issue yeah th this policy is more an attempt to call out those behaviors that might be boundary blurring and make sure that folks aren engaging in those because those can be the precursors to those more egregious offenses like you're pointing to um certain certainly an egregious offense like you're talking is something

036we would refer to uh to APD immediately for consideration questions regarding the version six just clarification uh will we be changing the first world to Shell yeah in the last paragraph So I guess that was my question for Mr Lang do we want to leave this and I don't object either way I think the chance for confusion is probably pretty low and the rest of it sounds like it's already in place so if you are comfortable with this language I'm not going to force the issue further just want to flag it I'm comfortable with it as written um also comfortable you want to propose a change yeah I think I think it's a a stand my standing understanding that when um the administration wants to propose and develop an AR the do so for the

037board's consideration anyway so I'm okay with that all right um any objection from the committee to referring this to president hman for placement on a future board meeting agenda hearing and seeing none we'll consider that disposed of and move on to our next agenda item 5138 student possession and use of portable Electronics including cell phones than there there's multiple attachments on our agenda including an original copy some changes and then the government's version member lessons the floor is yours uh thank you Mr chair um I wanted to thank everyone for the collaborations that have gotten us this far um I will share that I was invited to provide um testimony yesterday on House Bill 57 and that feels like at least a reasonable thing to bring up at this point in time uh and I've

038also asked America to to load the State Board of Education um you know it's about a week old it's sort of a draft model policy so I guess that's what's up first um if you look at uh if you scroll a little bit further down under policy implementation and enforcement um you know what the state board seems to be spelling out is that students are prohibited from accessing devices or wearing device accessories during the school day unless explicitly authorized for classroom use devices and accessories must be stored in lockers backpacks or as directed by the school district that's a pretty broad um recommended policy if we could please pivot over to House Bill 57 um those both look like the same apologies I well I can read it uh if that's a problem and we

039can post it later so essentially House Bill 57 as read uh across the floor and as discussed in House labor and commerce yesterday has two two main sections the first one says that the department shall of Education shall develop and adopt a model policy that prohibits the use of non-school issued Wireless telecommunication devices in public schools during regular school hours including lunch and passing periods um the policy may allow an exception for students to use a wireless telecommunications device for emergency purposes so maybe we don't have the right link here um so I'll just keep reading the so on one hand uh House Bill 57 is written says the department will make a fairly prohibitive policy the second section of House Bill 57 is that each school district and this is where I would see

040it applying to ASD shall adopt a policy that prohibits students from possessing or using a non-school issued Wireless telecommunication device during regular school hours including lunch and passing periods possessing as I pointed out to the committee is a pretty strong word um and um I and and of course it is also uh if if House Bill 57 were to be passed as written it would prohibit the access that students may have um according to their principal discretion um during those lunch and passing periods there was definitely some strong um interest by the commissioner of Education in in maintaining more of a blanket uh prohibition during the entire school day um one of the questions that I received from a Committee Member uh was sort of what's the role of local control and all of this

041um and what I shared with them is kind of the process that that I as a board member and as a few you know from gates with the administration over the past few months that other board members have engaged in this that we discussed it in governance and I did as an individual board member suggest that perhaps the blanket um bell-to-bell prohibition uh may be hard to implement in the Anchorage School District I did share um part of a spreadsheet with uh those members of the committee that ASD administrators have drafted collecting you know what our secondary schools are doing what's happening at Bartlett is different than what's at East and that's different than what's at chuak or Wendler or roig um so I guess I'm saying all of this because I think it would

042behoove us as a board as board members to to pay attention to what's happening in the legislature if I were a betting woman I would say that it's likely some kind of uh you know new bill is probably going to make it across the Finish Line um I think that there is a lot of interest uh a lot of bipartisan interest in maintaining classrooms as you know device free spaces but I encouraged the legislators in the labor and Commerce Committee to consider drafting a committee substitute that would look more like what we have put together thank you for putting the house bill 57 um so I really do appreciate the the version of or policy 5138 that we have produced thus far and last spoke to in December and America if you could please just

043uh bring up the version that I produced for today um I did want to raise a couple of I items for the committee's consideration um currently the the new text that I would suggest and I spoke to yesterday and the slaves and Commerce Committee uh is in bold um you know currently we have uh with the administration and board member input sketched out that elementary and middle school students and I think this aligns very well with State Board of Education and commissioner and and legislative intent are not permitted to access their devices during the school school day um but could do so before or after school hours um our policy differs from what has been discussed thus far in the committee um because it would permit um high school students to have their devices during

044passing periods and at lunch um although later in the policy I think there's still language that allows a principal to enact stricter practices um but I me before we go down there America the one the section in bold that reads um the section in bold would essentially allow teachers to direct or request that students use their devices to accomplish a specific academic purpose which could not otherwise occur with the district provided devices and this came directly from Educators uh to me suggesting that there are times for example when a district provided Chromebook just isn't engaging with the district uh you know the local um internet system um and students will use their phone as a hotspot or a student in a special class for example um student government or yearbook um might need to use

045their device to take pictures to record things uh that are happening around the school um you know I I haven't engaged with any advanced math or science classes but I would be curious about whether for some students maybe in calculus um are they using you know apps on their cell phone I used to have you know a fancy graphing calculator 30 years ago are they using their cell phones in that way to not have to buy a TI whatever it is TI 85 um so this is a carve out that would allow um Educators to permit students to access their devices for specific purposes and I actually think that it aligns with an item in what the state board has proposed um America if you could back to the State Board cell phone draft with

046your third tab that one if you look at e item e is sort of authorized for classroom uses to find is device use explicitly approved although here it says in writing by the district superintendent or design aligned with educational objectives that cannot be achieved using District owned devices students must must receive clear usage instructions and approvals may be revoked if objectives are unmet or Diss occur so I think I would feel comfortable and would request the board's consideration incorporating that carve out so that teachers could use um their discretion to permit a cell phone if needed uh in their class classroom um so that is the one edit uh that's one of the main edits that I want to Su the governance commit can consider and then the second one America if you could go

047back to the Kelly lessons document yes please is on the second page and this is in response to student questions and concerns raised during the student Advisory Board uh meeting in January students were concerned about um what happens if my you know my phone is confiscated um really the district assumes no responsibility and so I took that to heart and said that administrative regul and I so I suggested adding I would suggest adding that administrative regulations should be developed to promote the safe storage of confiscated um devices so that's probably going to look different at every school but perhaps Administration could create a best practices uh you know guideline for schools to abide by for when devices are no longer in student possession um so those are my two suggestions for board consideration at this

048point in time um we Kelly sent these to us I think last week or earlier this week um and we had I had my staff go through these uh two changes the second one is Administrative regulations we have no problem with that probably do that anyways so we agree with that but the principles and the administration over here is very concerned about the change um allowing teachers to have that ability to um make the call in their classrooms because that's what they do now um so it's not really um putting another level of uh onto the expectation that the students wouldn't be able to use them the other thing is one of the examples of using the hotspot because it gets around and we aren't able to access District um uh technology that goes to

049the point of then we're accessing stuff that may not be appropriate in the school and the classroom setting um what we have now is we have filtering we have um Our IT department overseeing what is um safe for kids and when we start opening up things like this it just can become a Snowball Effect um so Administration would highly um recommend that we don't include that language in the um in the new uh member I'm trying to separate out here whether it needs to be a board policy or Administration can tell people they can't do something uh you know teach to do it without high level but uh you you don't see a situation where this basically the way it reads right now high school student are not permitted to access it during class time

050period right I mean that's really what it says under no circumstance and it seems like there would be circumstances where for different classes types that they may want to make exceptions well this doesn't allow for any exceptions so that's the thing that we are hoping that a policy would do is not allow for exceptions um due to the fact that it just snowballs there's one exception there another exception then a teacher is saying well we want kids to relax so you can put in earbuds and then that's Le it up to the educator and then we have Educators against each other and that's not something that we want um our schools our principes would like something coming from the school board that says they cannot use these and if we're using um you know if

051they if the high schoolers can use them during lunch and passing like the original one says we think that's enough um we do have one to one and we do have the ability for one to one and if there are things then maybe we need to have that come to the if teachers are saying Hey My My Lesson cannot be completed without something like this then they maybe then they're coming to um District administration saying we need to look at this but at this point our administrators really wanting this to not have that exception rule um M uh president hman has his hand raised president hman the floor is yours yeah thank you um I'm going to say this as someone that has worked in a room with 34 reasonably fast workstations and a high-speed

052network with middle school students um the I was doing that at the time the district implemented the filter to begin with and for a while the just having a filter itself is a little bit controversial that didn't last too long uh the reality is is the the filter prevents a lot of accidental things from happening um as well as a whole host an unimaginable array of intentional actions by students um so that that is one of the things we haven't talked about a whole lot just a student who has a phone has um a level of access to the internet that we normally don't allow to happen inside of our buildings and if we ever actually made that normal um the idea of students using their phones as hotspots on other devices that can immediately

053be shared it can spread um and really could have some unfortunate consequences in a very short period of time I wouldn't want that to be normalized at all it uh it's I can I can give you specific details I won't go into all that on this particular time uh the reality is as a classroom teacher you have to be ready for technology to fail and for the network to fail it happens and it's a little more challenging when you're a computer class than maybe just your run-of-the-mill social studies class as bad as it can be for them as well but I would not want us to ever suggest that turning private devices as a routine or or a um a w thing uh that would just be a step in the wrong direction I think

054thank you member hman a question for Mr gustaffson about the B language there in the high school paragraph is there ever um a a situation where there might be a legitimate pre-approved use where I I don't know if it's like a photography class or something like that that is there ever any carve out if Administration knows and it gives a green light ahead of time where we're getting away from the creating one loophole that can turn to something much bigger you know we might have some digital photography things that you know we we we've purchased in most of those classes a lot of cameras and being able to do that you know I I think that as we're trying to um you know the overall goal limiting cell phon the ecds in the in the

055school is getting back to where we're actually teaching and focusing and and not having that chance of looking at a social media post or looking at a text or anytime you have a phone out those are going to happen no matter what and um you know teachers aren't able to look at those and see what they're doing you know they could say you know what you can take it out you can use it for this purpose but at the end of the day day it's not going to be only used for that purpose and um you know I I think that anything that we I think if a policy is made we go with this policy like this if there are things that come up that's something that we put into the AR there there's

056a policy and here's the here's the way in which you go get an exception to the rule for a class that you were teaching and then maybe we're upper District admin ministration is looking at is there another way rather than a cell phone thank you um another question um so I think if I'm tracking right that we this policy would allow cell phone use during passing periods what I I know from fostering dozens of Youth in a number of District buildings is that passing periods I hear many grievances in my home by the way specifically they've asked me to contact the superintendent thus far I have acted as a heat shield for about the length of passing periods and I'm I'm wondering you know practically speaking of someone who uses a cell phone myself and

057I think you know uh cell phone makers are recognizing this that once you look at a cell phone that isn't a 10-second ordeal there's a oh wait this happened oh I had to do this I'm I'm wondering if it's realistic and and and maybe we've waited I mean how how realistic is passing period use of cell phones allowable um and then two I what I my question as to how we were going to decide to do this from a practical standpoint of cell phone restrictions is you know there are districts in L 48 um and I think Pennsylvania made a Statewide purchase of um sleeves for all the districts that provided funding available um Alaska and I don't think the draft bill has included any such language even though I hoped it would um so

058the onus is on us to figure something out to secure those devices and it seems like if I'm reading the language is that's going to be on teachers um whereas if they're in sleeves maybe they're a little bit hard to access during passing periods how are we weighing how we're going to manage the devices that get confiscated and then is the allowing usage during passing periods realistic or we going to see a spike of tardies and um additional activity hallways in between classes I think we're going to have a learning phase be a phase there where you know we'll be pushing the envelope and stuff um if we're if we're doing sleeves you know our our our schools are open at lunch we would have to do sleeves before and after lunch that takes a

059while you haven't been to a concert lately they do that the concerts it takes a while for a good big group of students 1,00 kids coming in the door 1800 that becomes an issue um you know uh as far as uh tardies and whatnot we have it now right part of the one of the things that happens right now is during class time teacher kids are texting each other snapping each other hey let's meet at this bathroom let's meet at that bathroom go to pass there's a lot of shenanigans that can occur right now and what we're trying to do is focus during that class period of time have Focus Beyond instruction and learning not necessarily on social media and I think that's the biggest goal behind this um we just as far as Administration

060goes we we agree with the whole thing that we've had before we just have we have some angst around giving teachers the ability to um make exceptions at there at their room level and that that just there's some teachers that are just going to they're going to be butt up and then against each other and then some are going to be upset about the whole thing because other teachers are not okay last quick follow up I have just on that thread of conversation am I tracking right that the students will be allowed to have them on their person yeah okay and then if there's a violation those go to those cell phones become custody of the educator there's there's it will be a Progressive Progressive consequences on that and that would be written up into

061the um okay I I guess I'm curi and I mean from a liability perspective I I think and I track that in some occasions it's a it's at least been a past practice sporadically that teachers take possession of devices is that a concern at all that we're I at least in the early stages drawer could become a depository you know with every teacher does things differently most teachers don't want to be responsible for that and they call security or something if it's going to be one that gets put off further wrong um that's why that's why we're in agreement with the this back page thing of administrative we want to set be able to take some time get a committee together because this doesn't go into effect I don't believe we do this until next

062school year to be able to have those in place so that teachers know exactly what they should be doing thank you for heing those questions we'll go to member Higgins and sounds like we got someone online yeah my only question was with the language the way it is right now if you decide there needs to be an exception you have to go back to the board to get the exception before you go forward you want some flexibility not the teacher but the administration some level that has to be approved at that level so it doesn't have to come back as a that might be nice I think that might be something good idea to put into you can come something how you want to put it but I just don't want to see it where

063you don't have that control um Mr Sullivan do you have someone online yes member lessons then president H good member lessons the Flor is yours uh thank you I guess for I am not on the governance committee but I am certainly aware that we have six of seven board members uh in person or online and I it seems like there can be consensus about keeping the the addition to this draft of the the AR shall be developed I guess I'd like other board members to sort of you know I don't know if people are ready to say thumbs up or thumbs down to the proposed uh addition America could you scroll up to that again please and maybe may I just I'm cognizant that it's noon so if it's the will of the board to

064remove that suggested language then then that then I'll recognize that's the will of the board um or the committee um if there is interest in retaining it I think that would be good to know as well but I appr appreciate the administrative feedback um although if Mr a is in the room it' be nice to hear uh as well from a teacher perspective okay and then um we had member hman yes okay me member hman FL yours um yeah have some other comments I'll wait for a different time I'm just gonna say I do have to sign off because I do have to come to the aded center um so I'll only be on for a few more minutes on this thank you and so um thank you member hman so member leson just a

065quick question for you then is your ask that we finalize this in a way that it goes to a future board agenda without continued conversation in committee is that your preference um well I'm just I'm recognizing we're at the end of the hour and for you know I I think I you know if you were to ask me I I respect the administrative input but I also recognize that our classrooms and our schools are complex you know the example of a hot spot was actually uh sh it came up in a conversation saying actually you know a student was trying to connect for purposes of testing and the computer wasn't working and so we configured the phone as a Hotpot um it wasn't to just roam the internet willy-nilly um so I guess I I

066see the value in allowing specific language um to to allow our Educators to be treated as as experts um although I understand the administrative push back that golly that's a slippery slope so my personal inclination would be to ask board members to consider incorporating the language but if it's the will of the board uh members in this meeting to not have that language then we can withdraw it at this point in time um but I would like to see this move forward because I think it's timely so yeah I guess my my personal feedback on I I think that there probably is a universe where then I want to go to Mr a member Higgins um there is a universe where I can think of a reasonable um call for building Administration on a teacher

067to collaborate on something a bit more flexible I I don't know for me I what it generates concern when we're talking about that we're using personal devices to mitigate for dis distri technology issues I don't think that that's the battering ram that breaks down that door for me my question would be why why aren't we engaging with someone to fix that is it something with a device that that needs to be repaired should we be looking at budget allocations to make sure that our devices aren having those issues it's an older device I've got a million questions from a um from a a board member perspective then I also am thinking about you know the the the loophole that that grows bigger in size over time I've been um told by number of times by

068my teenagers that um they were having trouble um accessing um you know the internet on a district device and they had to use you know a device that didn't have those filters or tracking on it uh to be found to find out later that they were hoping to not have their internet usage tracked so that they could do something else besides homework and so um I I'm worried about adding teacher workload frankly about once we open that door then it's a teachers's responsibility to make sure that they're um tracking internet usage when I don't want I want them to focus on what they do well and so I feel like there's some Middle Ground there somewhere Mr R sir I just Kelly since you asked I'll just make two comments I I think this policy

069is a little bit of a can of worms there are times when we get directives that put us in a compromising situation because we want to do what's best for the students or we feel what's best for the students and the directive goes against that so our integrity is put to the test uh do I anyway so I think that this policy may find itself doing that at times and I'll just say uh the easy answer Kelly is if if we're not allowing them to find an Al alternate means to access the internet versus the ASD system then then the work doesn't get done that day I mean that's the then that's just either the teacher goes to another topic um but generally it's not nearly at or it's just it could be a lost

070day or a lost um hour of work so and and if we're willing to if we're if that's the cost that that's the cost I guess the other other thing I'm thinking about is you know just a a point of equal access right um not all children are going to have a cell phone with hotspot ability and so we're lifting up those students who have that ability and making that accommodation and others are going to have to go without I just I I remember I appreciate the language and I understand the intent I just I really take I have some concerns about using that issue in particular to wedge that language in there so I would prefer us to to continue working on it but I'm fine with asking the committee to or the I

071guess consensus from the board um because we have folks present and we've often operated that way if we want to send this forward I may just work on an amendment um in collaboration with member lons to address at a board meeting I'm fine with that member Higgins the floor is yours then we'll ask I I I just want I I agree with the administration in this case I know nobody want to sit down on that that's okay um you know they can set rules anyway in addition to this that you can't do it they we can't stop them from from supervising and doting St and by keeping the language the way it's been requested where they can have an exception but it's at a higher level I think it it it keeps the pressure off

072the principal it keeps the pressure off the teacher and it still gives them some flexibility we know there's going to be some out there that will be whatever you want versus those that will be very strict I I I'm want to support make it easier for them from an administrative supervisor standpoint to say no and if you want to say yes make it an exception that I think that's okay um and is there any objection from the board to moving this forward recognizing that um we likely will recommend as a committee that that language Administration expressed concerned about be peeled back and the rest of it sent forward and then I I admit I'm probably going to try to add something else I just don't know what it is yet so it's this isn't a

073finished product but we're going to send it Forward is there any objection no okay hearing seeing none we'll um consider that done and refer this to member Hollman for placement on an agenda um any other we're going to we have two other items but we won't address those today we'll hold those over for a future governance meeting um our next meetings are February 13 2025 and March 27 2025 um as we are over time I'm going to adjourn the committee meeting at 12:07 thank you everyone

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.