001e e e all right good evening everyone we'll call ourselves to order it is Tuesday January 21st at 6:03 pm here in the as school board boardroom have a regular business meeting of the anchor School District School Board present in the boardroom our members Bellamy Higgins Jacobs lesons and Wilson and online joining us is our president Hollman serve as chair for this evening also joining us is our student representative Joshua pack uh Dr Bryant and his team called ourselves to order and G through a roll call we'll um perform our flag um Mr pack if you'd lead us I pleas we of the United States of America to the for IT stand One Nation God Mr P if you'd read us the land acknowledgement please we acknowledge that we gather here today on the traditional
002lands of the denying the people of the upper Cook Inlet for thousands of years the den people have been and continue to be the stewards of this land ASD is committed to diversity and inclusion and it is with honor and respect that we recognize all indigenous people who live and learn in our community thank you Mr pack and again good evening everyone we want to welcome you to our meeting and thank you for attending and supporting the work of the anchored School District in this board the board thanks students parents teachers staff School business partners and the entire Community for your investment in our district with your time your talent and your tax dolls so we've performed our opening we have an agenda um Miss is there a motion to approve our agenda as presented
003Mr chair I move to approve the agenda as presented there a second second made by member Bellamy second by member Wilson is there any objection to adopting our agenda as presented all right seeing none we have an agenda thank you everyone we'll move on to reports uh B1 is our student representative report Mr pack the floor is yours thank you Mr chair um so the majority of my report today um is just a update on our last student Advisory board meeting which happened last Tuesday in this room and we had an exceptional meeting um and in the theme of the new year we asked our student delegates from across the district what resolutions they would come up and present with in our next Sab meeting if they wanted to and this kind of just gave
004some insight into some priorities of our student leaders across the district and here are some examples of what students brought up um begic wanted to get to class on time so they would make a resolution telling students to get into class faster East or Betty devis East was um looking to enforce stricter rules about School attendance mirors wanted to help fix the bathroom um or bathrooms at their school apparently they have a lot of broken and um not locking stalls which problem South is looking to mandate a anti-racism campaign at their school because of their um apparently they had some notable um encounters with or incidences of racist something um this school year a lot of schools wanted longer passing periods and I think one that set up to me is that a frontier Charter
005School wants to change the Mas cut because it's very very Bland that's what I've been told so can look into that um and then after that we had a cell phone policy discussion so I there was just a draft policy that District was circulating and our students got to give some feedback um it was there were points on both sides of you know not permitting edcs or electric um like communication devices um within our schools and right now I believe there is a feedback form that students get to offer deeper and more thought out feedback for this policy and I think they will also communicate with their own students our schools and then not in this meeting but our next meeting our student Advisory Board is looking to propose a constitutional amendment so it would
006amend some part of our Constitution and this would basically change the election dates for the rest of our executive board positions outside of President so like DP or secretary into the second to last meeting of the school year and this will just allow um our incoming executive board members to spend some time with the current board um I also want to thank this district for once again sending our students or ASD students to the ASB legislative flying where students get to learn to advocate for themselves and their peers and so we're looking forward to that and finally our president-elect application packets are open um and we'll close on the 4th so probably why not next meeting but the meeting after this we'll have next person here at this meeting so I'm really excited for that
007and finally our next meeting is on February 11th 2025 and it's 12:30 2:30 pm. and that concludes my report thank you Mr pack are there questions for a student representative hearing seeing none thank you sir um our next update is for B2 military report Colonel Hanson is here tonight welcome sir the floor is yours new microphones okay thanks so good evening Anchorage school district school board members uh our ASD team as well as our parents here tonight my name is Colonel Dustin Hansen I am a joint based elidor Richardson's mission support group Commander here to represent J bear have five points to make tonight uh and it's going to be a little bit of a thank you sandwich so let me begin first of all thank you for uh for allowing us to use the
008Ursa Major school as a uh basically a training campus for our law enforcement uh entities and agencies uh we have I've received a lot of good feedback from our security force uh Defenders as well as law local law enforcement agencies for being able to use this uh this high school before it gets demolished um to to use it for uh training particularly in close quarters uh as well as just training with inside of a school itself uh in case that ever needs to happen uh we've had exceptional training being able to use that uh that school number two I'd like to uh announce uh J Bear's uh effort to uh basically begin a a job U not again to conduct a job shadowing event this spring uh this this is where we're going to um
009encourage our units there on Jaber to to Showcase to ASD students a variety of jobs anywhere from engineering to Logistics to Aerospace to meteorology uh including uh crafts and trades uh we want to open this up to our students expose them to what we do on J bear expose them to Unique job opportunities as they uh eventually graduate uh and move on into the professional Workforce we are a partner here number three I'd like to uh sit on along a similar vain uh just announced that we are going to begin advertising for uh summer hires every summer we have about 40 positions uh where we bring or or encourage uh students uh at age 16 and above as long as they're in high school to come work for us uh for the summer and make
010some money uh some hard-earned cash uh we'll have positions whether they're admin clerk positions they are manual labor positions even recreational assistance positions uh we have about 30 of them or about 40 of them this Summer uh and and if it's if it's a popular program and I hope it is like we'll even expand it you know more for next summer as well so so we hope that uh parents and teachers encourage the kids to come work on J bear like again a community partner um and then uh I would also like to say that we are going to resurrect a program that probably we bless you we probably haven't had for a while uh and it's a reading program and so remember lessons your your comments haunted me from before in terms of thinking
011about what we can how we can be a better partner for you know encouraging reading and building that that um that academic rigor within our students early on and so uh we're going to be encouraging our our students um our war fighters to integrate into the schools uh and either read or be read too uh my schoolly aison officer uh this is probably the the best title of an of a program I've heard it's called readers or leaders readers or leaders now in the military we like to say leaders or readers and and we get this quite a bit but I think as a student I think I like to flip that and say like students we encourage you to read and as you read you will become a better and better leader that this
012world needs readers are leaders it's uh it's coming soon uh and finally I just want to say thank you again for um opening your I strings I've had a lot of positive comments from military families whose kids are are uh doing sports right now particularly like hockey and the fact that the ASD has their school uh School Ice Rinks open to local teams has provided a lot of positive value for our families and so I just want to say thank you for keeping those open for supporting the local teams uh it's been a big hit for our military families just getting kids integrated into a sport they love quickly uh that's all I have for tonight and I open myself for any questions thank you sir there questions from the board for Colonel Hansen we'll
013go with member Wilson first I I don't have a question but I would like to share some information um in working with the junior RC program at West High I learned that and and I'm going to read some of this but I learned that two of the cadets at the West High J Joc received a scholarship to attend an accredited Aviation University participating in a private license training program in the summer of 2025 um they are two of of 194 Air Force Junior Roc car Cadets around the world to receive the scholarship from headquarters Air Force Junior Roc uh Maxwell Air Force Base in Montgomery Alabama um anyways the there's there's more information on this but it it's just a very very cool opportunity for for those two students to receive their pilot license and
014it just shows that our our partnership with the military extends past J bear um so I wanted to highlight that I think it's amazing thank you for sharing congratulations to those thank you member Wilson we'll go with member lons um thank you for um circling back to the previous meetings conversation um if we can call this a conversation um I think that what you're conceptualizing is really exciting and if I may I would challenge you and your team to not limit it to young readers if you and your team were to look at any of the asb's data dashboards um you can go all the way up to like ninth graders with map growth I'd wager there are hundreds of students in ninth grade who might respond positively to a program like what you're offering
015and and there are people in this room who can who are smarter than I am about you know how you address older students needs uh but I think that needs are there and I'm really um I'm really excited for you thank you thank you yeah I I think that the the war Fighters are able to connect whatever the age group will be if they want someone to read to to them or be read to like we are there for them and it only helps everybody knows you member lesons member bamy yes thank you Colonel good to see you again um I love the job shadow um I recall a couple of years ago we had it was Russian imersion students actually participating in military life what was that called NSA yeah NSA yeah so I
016think I think um that job shadow program is uh impressive uh our kids have such opportunities so I I appreciate you being to partner with that and how do kids find out about the summer hire so I'm going to work with my school leas on officers to make sure that message gets pushed out to every school here that would be great and that's open to all kids or is it just military family yes so all kids as long as you're over 16 years old and and you're able to get a background check to get on base access yes awesome thank you thank you thank you member Bellamy there other questions for the military representative and seeing none thank you so much Colonel for being here tonight we'll move on to item B3 on our agenda
017which is Board conference and committee reports um in that vein I did want to read um into our record language from our bargaining units which pertains to board policy 4143 the district and the board have received notice that Teamsters Local 599 959 is requesting to begin bargaining for food service and bus driver attendant contracts the notification I'm here and there by satisfy board policy 4143 um are there other board committee reports hearing seeing none we'll move on to C1 goal monitoring College current life ready pathway concentrators grade 12 um because we missed our first meeting this month my understanding is we are going to be performing both halves of our monitoring process so read our standard scripting now we're going to have our goal monitoring conversation on the uh technical report that was provided to
018the board we want to confirm the four components for of the monitoring report are present the report shows what is being monitored and is focused on a specific and interim goal uh the data for any applicable previous reporting periods the superintendent's evaluation of performance and supporting documentation that evidences the superintendent evaluation via tables provided and indicates next steps with the components present we can begin progress monitoring conversation Dr Bryant and team the floor is yours thank you Mr chair so as you alluded to uh this is our first school monitoring conversation of the new year um and we didn't meet last earlier this month because of the Ice event so we'll kind of combine both structures into this meeting so with that said I'd like us to go to the next slide so just to
019remind the community and as the board knows uh we spent a lot of time working on our college career and life readiness scho and what the school board um ended up making the decision for is to set a goal on increasing our graduation rates so you'll see that goal on the the top of the slide but for the Public's awareness ASD has a goal to increase the percent of graduates to 90% by 2028 now that's the board's role the superintendent's role is to set three interim goals for this particular goal and just so we can zoom out for a minute before we talk a lot about CT concentrators what the superintend and his team my team are looking at our one CT concentrators we'll walk through the definition for that in just a moment two
020we're looking at GPA and three we're monitoring the percent of students that are on track to graduate um so why did we choose these interim goals it's because in different ways these three interim metrics are a proxy for making sure that we understand whether or not we're on progress to meet our goal so our theory of action is that if we can increase the percent of CT concent graders if we can make sure that more students are on track to graduate prior to the 12th grade year and if we can have GPA uh at or above a 2.75 on average for our students those are strong metrics based on the research and other factors that would culminate into a higher graduation rate so we need to look at all three of these factors um within
021the the large uh CM that is the Anchorage School District so with that said I'm sure a number of people listening to this conversation may not understand what is a CT concentrator that's the interim 3.2 goal that you see on this slide so essentially we're trying to increase the percent of those students that complete a concentration within Career and Technical education to 90% by 2028 so at a high level what do we mean by CT concentrator that means that you've earned at least two credits within a specific Career and Technical education program of study um and that would be Beyond of what the district has asked freshman to take which is a course called um The Freshman Academy career exploration course let's go to the next slide so I'd actually like for our leadership team
022to brief the public and the board what is a CT program of study how do we measure it what does this mean for our students at a very high level hi I'm Devon Roberts director of CTE thank you um superintendent Dr Bryant um in terms of the infographic here um in the world of Career and Technical education at a very high level There are 16 clusters they've actually just revised those so there's 14 clusters and three cross cutting but let's just say 16 clusters Health Science if you look at the right of the infographic is an example of that uh science um technology engineering and math stem as it's referred to would be an example of another uh construction and architecture uh would be another so those are some examples of very broad umbrella reer
023clusters within those clusters um there's different ways of organizing curriculum and program um and one of those ways is in that um sort of the orange circle there Pathways um there's 79 nationally recognized Pathways um that fit into those uh career clusters but the focus is really on the program and studies the uh sort of the gold um or yellow um Circle there and a program of studies is uh really a what I would call the Strategic plan um we work with industry partners and postsecondary partners um to create a um coordinated group of courses um that uh um fall within one of those career clusters or Pathways and um those classes typically build on each other and build on Technical and skills and knowledge for students uh embedded in those classes is career ready
024practices um so that students whenever they they they end up in a career they have um they have the uh these career ready practices that will prepare them for um for being great employees those things include things like teamwork collaboration creative thinking um those sorts of things teamwork um and addition to that the program of studies uh encompasses uh placing recognized post-secondary credentials in the program so that students have credentials that are recognized by industry um once they've graduated from high school um there's um additionally these courses or sequences are built in order to make sure that they articulate into post-secondary involvement and into post-secondary training programs um including um graduate programs Bachelor programs associate programs apprenticeship um and uh military for instance so that's a program of studies is is is really just a
025very intensive planned coordinated group of of CTE courses thank you Mr Roberts so uh as we are developing these interim goals the district team came together and tried to determine what does the evidence say what does the research say in terms of what can we invest our dollars and time in to ensure that we have more students graduating from the inor school district and I would encourage the public and the board to look at a couple of stats because first I want to start this conversation by looking at National statistics and then I'd like us to spend the bulk of this conversation on the Anchorage School District statistics but um just one example would be from the national Center for Education statistics they did a study in 2018 that showed on average uh there's a
02694% uh graduation rate for those that complete a CTE concentration compared to a national rate uh for of 85% for those that are not completing CT concentrators that's one National data point of many that our team looked at um the second one uh this is actually a peer reviewed study dor uh 2018 uh found a 7 to 10 point increase in graduation rates uh they did a study on high quality CT programs it's very interesting it even goes so far as to uh determine when of the best times within a high school career for students to be engaging in CT coursework and they did find some statistical significance when it comes to CT concentrators all of that to say part of this conversation will be around the universal utility of current technical education programs you
027know I'll be frank that when I was growing up there were many that would often um you know assume that a current technical education program or what was known as vocational education programs was for a certain type of student but when we look at data a little bit more deeply we'll actually see that there are very positive outcomes that lead to students being both College Bound and career bound when they complete CT concentrators in fact when you look at the different types of CT concentrators you'll notice that there are some that are are within the vocational or technical Fields but you also see many within the Realms of healthcare and um in terms of healthcare jobs many in our community understand that those are high demand um potentially high-wage jobs and many of those don't
028require any Beyond some uh training um that you can actually take during high school and that leads all the way up to medical school and PhD and Beyond so there's actually a really nice spectrum that are complemented very well by a very robust and strategic uh Career and Technical education program of study so with that said we'll go ahead and move to the next slide and um we we'll begin to open up our our conversation with the board members but this first slide shows our progress to date the one thing I want to remind the board and the public is that uh CT concentrators for this board goal relate specifically to 12th grade students um with that said we set our interm goal last summer so this is very much a lagging indication of where
029we are and is not a reflection of where we aspire to be in fact the group of students that we should be focusing a lot of our attention on are for the rising sophomore students because this was the first year that we actually had all of our freshman complete uh Freshman Academy which is both a class but also a set of really great experiences for students um ranging from care exporation opportunities you may or may not be aware we have a lot of folks in the room tonight so I'm going to use this opportunity to inform you we brought in all of our freshmen um to the denina center and we had hundreds of booths set up for different careers uh for Great Alaskan jobs right here in town and uh these people went above
030and beyond to really uh tell their story for what does it mean to enter this career field from the lens of a nth grader really great opportunity on top of that we actually also asked um University of Alaska Anchorage to host our freshman where they got for for many cases got to visit a college campus for the very first time and then um every day first semester our students took the Freshman Academy career exploration course which was version one of a big initiative that we want to continue within ASD um but essentially what we want to do is to give all of our freshmen the opportunity to explore colleges explore careers and to understand the landscape of the Alaskan economy and to figure out where they want to fit in that bubble or perhaps even
031in a different state um so with that said uh you'll see that right now our goal is far below the target that's the snapshot of our current seniors but over the next few years we want to see the the rate of CTE concentrators go up right now that goal is 90% which is very bold ambitious I know there may be some questions for board members as to are we still aiming for 90% I know we're kind of going slow to go far with our Academy's of Anchorage plan and uh at this point in time I don't see any reason to adjust the bar because I've certainly seen some very positive postsecondary outcomes both within the college space and the career space for those to complete CT uh concentrators so I think this could be a
032very good thing for all students and this is also a great complement to the robust advanced placement dual credit and international baloran opportunities our students also have access to so um it's not the intent for those to go away but we need to be strategic about which postsecondary programs to which we expose our students so um with that said there's some data here that shows the percent completed the the concentrator also the cohort let's go to the next slide for a moment and then as always we break down this goal by uh special subpopulation economically disadvantage our male and female students and I we sent this to board members about two weeks ago so I'm not going to belabor this but what you'll see is that we have a lot of opportunity with an ASD
033you know one of the things that we should be proud of of is we have a strong uh four to fiveyear graduation rate for students compared to our peers right now you know8 and 10 ASD students are graduating um within four years and even more within five years um we're seeing a similar success within CT concentrators to a smaller degree but what you'll see is that there are gaps within various subpopulations of students so as we transition into our board conversation on this schal I'd love to really talk about how we can make sure that all our students have exposure or access or knowledge of these courses and how do we make sure that we leverage this opportunity so that it translates into higher graduation rates so um with that said I'm G to let
034this slide sit here and I'd like to open it up to board member questions as relates to to outcomes and how we can improve graduation rates in CT concentrators thank you Dr Briant team we'll start at the end of the Das member bellamine work our way left uh thank you um Dr Bryant you really hit a couple of the questions I had uh relative to the concentrators um I I kind I'm I'm really intrigued that it's 12th grade but I also know now one question does the ninth grade academy and the University of Alaska visit that's part of ninth ninth grade academy does that count as a concentrator at some point or is that just part of does it not count I'm just curious it doesn't count for this for the purposes of this goal
035really the vision would be to cast a wide net that's the vision behind the Freshman Academy course we really want to make sure that as the Baseline every ASD freshman has a core set of competencies and this goes back to not anything that me or any individual board member thought about those values actually came directly from the community where we surveyed hundreds of people and it culminated into the creation of a portion of a graduate um which is really our North Star as organization so what's really neat is that beyond the CG concentrators with that course we have a huge opportunity to increase the percent of students that are self- selecting into into a CTE program because it's interesting to them my theory is that there are many students that are not enrolling in CTE
036because perhaps they were not aware that's my theory for this group of 12th graders because they didn't have the opportunity to visit a college campus for the first time some of these 12th graders they may not go onto a college campus until after they graduate so we really have an opport here to invest in our students and buck those Trends by thinking early so my question is Mr chair I just needed that clarification but my question is do we uh were we able to capture uh what programs or Pathways had the highest participation among those students that did complete the concentrator thank you for that question member py um yes we do have U we have uh we have 14 of the 16 clusters just as a general context that the in the Anchorage School
037District however certainly there are some programs that um enroll more students than others and uh the top three of those are health science uh science technology engineering and Mathematics uh and construction some others worth mentioning that also um have heavy enrollment include the Arts AB Tech Communications cluster and then transportation and Logistics thank you I'll wait thank you member bamy member leses um great uh looking forward to tonight's conversation um later on I'm going to circle back to the face class but um we had the opportunity last month to review graduation rate data and now we're reviewing um CTE concentrator rate data and um happily they both look at 2020 uh FY 23 and FY 24 so I put those two together and I saw no relationship between graduation rates and CTE concentration we actually
038had um upticks in like when I look by gender um graduation rates increased great and even though CTE concentrator rates decreased uh between FY 23 and 24 so I didn't see a relationship there this is like speaking to my question I about like what why do we have this inter own goal um and when I look at um looked at uh graduation rate and um CTE concentration rate by uh race things just seemed all over the place so what relationships does ASD see in its data for the past two years since we're monitoring progress sure and if I could also put the data that I'm looking at on the table so that Administration can clarify for both me and member lessons because when I'm looking at our supplemental data just as one example I'm looking
039at our male students just as one subgroup because it looks like graduation rates for male students is lower than females so let's look at them for just a moment so for those that completed a CTE concentration I see that they have a 96.5% whereas I look for those that did not complete a concentration the non-c concentrators it's an 80.5% um so that would actually a 15o increase for those that are completing CTE I notice an 18-point gain for those that are economically disadvantaged I notice a 14 point gain for Hispanic students and I notice a 24 percentage Point gain for Alaskan native students so with all of that to say um I do agree that there is not a uh causation that we can prove because of this data but based off of what I'm
040reading on the supplemental data I certainly see uh a case for a correlation can the team clarify what I'm reading and what member lesson is reading yes thank you Dr Brian that's this is all great news I mean when we started really looking at some of the questions that were asked we took the time to reflect and really dive into our own data I know that we we often misconstrue the idea that the grass is always going to be greener on the other side but in truth it's always greener where you water it and when we look at our own School District we have a lot to be proud of um I think it's really important that when we look at that concentrator data that you pointed out we do see a strong correlation between
041the number of students that have of the the cohort of students we have 2348 total students in the anchored School District graduating class right of that 514 of them are actually counting as concentrators those students that had concentrator data are graduating at a 95.9% we just call it 96% graduation rate and of the students that did not have concentrators they graduated an 82% rate and this and this if you peel back the onion and you start looking at all the different layers of the different subgroups you're going to see in that supplemental data that we have a lot to be proud of and a lot of areas that we are actually targeting as goals to see some numbers move we see that not only in the gra graduation rate but we also see it in
042their attendance um you can look at 90 the 90% of our students that are economically disadvantaged they are actually if they have a concentrator they are attending at a 44.8% rate versus their economically disadvantaged um partners that are not having concentrators who have a 36.5% attendance rate so for us the simple math is an 88.3% gain and that's that's big when we're talking about we've we've already decided our goals are moving at a two and a half% each year and just by having a concentrator you're meeting that at almost four times rate you have a followup number lessness um well this is just an early request thank you um I know I submitted a number of questions ahead of time I I would appreciate the chance to more substantively think about uh the detailed response
043so if you could you know if we can get those in board connect I would appreciate that opportunity um one of the areas of concern well I guess maybe the followup question since we're we're talking about numbers uh let's just say on slide four um and this is the we have these interim year goals or a percentage increase and I know that there was an adjustment which I appreciated um on the chart that we received it looks to me that in order for FY 25 to reach a 38.9% Target we're going to need to have something like 9 47 you ever take a few uh concentrators do do we have that many students um are we on track for that this year do we have have we seen a 400 and something student increase from
044last year to this year because those students should be should have been enrolled you know last semester or or this semester we should have a sense of who's eligible to I think we are on our way to being on track you know there's a few of the headwinds that we have ahead of us because of um we're not doing a schedule change we're missing the opportunity to increase for offerings so being be that as it may we still are meeting with our high schools in fact we met with three of them today to talk about what are their paths moving forward and how are they going to continue to grow CTE in their schools even when they're facing uh FTE loss or the budgetary crisis that we have and I and I think that if
045we can hold to what we have and we build slow to go far we're going to be able to get very close to what we've hoped in our master plan maybe I'll step back um in just talking about this chart are we talk I ass I guess I'm assuming that for each of these years we're looking at graduating seniors right so well the fy2 24 data was for last year's seniors the fy2 data is for this year's seniors the f26 goal will be for next year's seniors is that correct that's my assumption okay so I guess my question for this year's class this year's graduating class are we on track to have over 900 graduating seniors who are considered pte concentrators because that's where the line would put us I guess I'm a little bit
046confused by that this is still the first year of our this is our first year of the the master plan for cies of Anchorage so like our a theory of action was placing it well this is year one we're moving with this court cohort through so we may see some increase in the years to come as schools continue to water that grass a little bit more at their school for the CT concentrators but in order to meet that kind of line I'm really looking at what is our freshman cohort right now and what are there going to be the next year is that sophomore cohort that moves in and then eventually you know in those four years later we should see tremendous room you I would dare to say spectacular okay so really this shouldn't
047be a straight line we I mean we're we're we're not really monitoring this year's seniors next year's seniors or the class of 2027 we're really monitoring the class of 2028 only and not interim progress over each of the next three years we'll still be able to have that goal but we our eye on the priz is really because we're trying to we're implementing okay and being at this is the first year we should really be focusing on the class that's being implemented with right great M may I continue to appropriate time okay um I'm going to Pivot to the Freshman to the face class and this is not a pre-shared question uh but I do appreciate the ability to sort of peer into the lens of our data dashboard and you can there's one called
048like rates of fail you can see who's failing and where um and what it what my reading of that was that 392 freshmen failed the face course and that of those 84% of them were economically disadvantaged students that's a lot of students that who for whom I think the face course was conceptualized um and I also noticed that the rates of failure among freshmen in all first semester courses significantly increased this past year over the previous year uh over FY 24 um and I also noticed that districtwide rates of failure among freshmen in four courses just Math Science Social Studies and language arts increased this past fall my understanding of the face course is that it was supposed to reduce the rate of D's and Fs and that's not what my reading of the data
049suggest has the administration looked into how well of our our students have done in the fall semester with Bas since everybody had to take it and what are your thoughts The Freshman Academy course that's a that's a very thought-provoking question we actually have member lessons we we're looking at it and and one of the things that I always want to try to remind myself as as I look at data as I I talked with our team about looking at data it's it's it's not I wouldn't call it a fortunate thing that we had 392 students that failed this class it's 14% there's also 86% of that gradu that class that actually passed it um and when we look at some of the other classes like if you were look at um our math classes or
050some of the cores that you referenced we'll see higher numbers than that 14% And that's and that's not to dismiss anything this is the first year that the face class was offered and I started to look at that same data dashboard that you referred to and what I noticed is that the number of students that failed classes had been increasing before we implemented things and it was actually just a an increase of students that were failing and it seems to be if I had to make a guess my own personal opinion is it's the the covid pig and the snake that we're seeing some students that are missing some skills and we're trying to catch that up but I think the beauty of this is in that noticing is that we're actually solidifying our choice
051to have Freshman Academy where we have groups of teachers caring adults and Educators that are actually tracking students at a high rate trying to follow up and make sure who is attending and who's not and they can do that with the Freshman Academy model so it's actually a blessing in disguise for us to have this noticing and say what are we doing about this and how can we improve it for the future and then I'll just add to what Mr Prince shared I think our two interim goals duvail very nicely when we look at both CT concentrators that we're talking about today but our team will also be looking at the percent of students that have a 2.75 GPA so really is there is accountability and urgency to make sure that our students are passing
052their courses and the reason why we chose that GPA interim goal is because the data shows that if you can maintain that GPA you're much more likely to enroll in college and be successful and of course potentially enroll in vocational coursework or what have you uh so there needs to be urgency not just to focus on the passing rates for the face course but really all of our classes because we need our students to be prepared for success in life thank you member lessons we'll go to member Wilson and member Higgins and back to member ban well I just wanted to clarify um in in the data that was provided are the uh classes the students taking at King Tech High School incorporated into these statistics as well yes all CTE courses at the secondary
053are are included member Higgins yeah mine mine has to do I know that if we expand seven eight credits uh we're going to have to change High School graduation requirements it's going to have to impact some stuff but um U I know in the past we've had issues that the electives may not have counted this credit when it should have or could have because who's teaching it and things of that is there a issue right now that that from a graduation requirements and from a course credit kind of issues that that might be impacting um either participation or graduation rates uh because you need to get credits for math for example you take carpentry you can get if you got it linked up with a math teacher you get credit uh I know they do
054that uh in some schools and I and do we have issues in regards to the making sure they get credit in a way that helps them graduate or are graduation requirements thank you for the question member Higgins um so yeah you raised an interesting point um one of the things that oftentimes um results uh whenever we have a an increase in PTR is that that we oftentimes do see a reduction in electives including CTE electives it's not just Career Technical education unfortunately it impacts art and and World Language and others um um and that that is like that is a relationship between that of course and making sure our students have the opportunities to meet the graduation requirements um that being said there are a number of Career and Technical education uh courses and programs
055that are CTE in nature but also provide academic credit so for instance uh we have a couple of engineering programs around the district that provide physical science uh to students who take it um we're piloting a natural resource Environmental Management course that provides science credit um we're looking at developing a a laot public safety course um that could potentially offer social studies credit so there are opportunities um where where and sometimes they're they intersect as at electives we're looking at a digital art and design course that could be cross-listed as both an art and a CT course in order to provide some more flexibility for students and the other question of a followup whoops oh one is is is location sometimes I know at one point because King career center was the place for career
056technology that you know freshman couldn't take classes because he had to have an hour of Transportation you lost credit you had so many St uh you know core classes is there any issues and I know that some students are trying to go to different types of classes I know some optional programs trying to take uh the programs that may not be uh available in their school but they've got it in other high schools so they can go to that has is there a transportation or timing issue in regards to getting access to all the students in regards to that um in terms of Transportation there there really I don't believe there is um we have um Regular opportunities for students to interface in particular with King Tech King the problem with King Tech is that
057um in terms of CT concentrators it it really is limited uh there's only so many seats the class sizes can only be so large and um there's a you know an a PM session as you mentioned um but um the the it is doing well and it is it is contributing to our our concentrator status for sure um we we do see that there is more limited involvement and Career and Technical education at some of our big eight schools um so um for instance we see a um 16% 15 to 16% uh engagement with uh CTE program at Eagle River and South High School for instance um and we see uh more moderate um engagement at Diamond at 12.09% and there are other schools um that that are closer to 4.23 and 4.66% um including
058um Bartlett and Betty Davis East and so we do know in part of our plan is to increase access to Career and Technical education and one of the ways to do that is is to put it in the buildings where the students are thank you member Higgins we'll go back to member Bellamy thank you Mr chair and I want to H thank you uh Dr Bryant for this this data um this is a work in progress uh I've not really focused on the concentrators uh until I guess the last years what when I really focused on what that meant um so I understand that it's a work in progress but we're also having this conversation because 43 is it 43% of our kids go right to college 40 something percent of our kids go right
059to college that's approximately correct the rest of the kids our kids are getting jobs so hence we have Life College and Career Readiness so when I so with that backdrop if we a concentrator class takes are there quarter ones or semester or could it be either remember belly largely at the secondary level CT courses are either being offered as a semester course a year-long course or in the case of King Tech Career Center those are 1.5 credit Am Pm sessions all right so um thank you for that so do we H do we know how many of this these 12th graders might have gotten um industry certificates or apprenticeships or whatever when they graduated um because I I you know I do know that some of our kids are coming out and they're making uh
060not on their way to college right they're they're making a good pretty good living uh and part of that is because of what they get uh of the exposure that they have in high school so do we have any data do we or it may be too soon to know where in the industry are kids ending ending up yeah currently we report uh to the state CTE Department um workbase learning and and one of the accountability reports measures work-based learning um exposure um for our concentrators and so our concentrators are engaging in excuse me our concentrators are engaging in in receiving recognized post-secondary certifications that's what the CT department and the state calls them um and uh out of the 500 or so concentrators 33.9% received a recognized post-secondary credential uh for the 2324 school
061year that's a full year of data we're monitoring it right now for this year but we're halfway through the year so that is 232 24 data thank you uh and if I might one more follow sorry um so so when our kids graduate and I think I've asked this question before is there a way or are we getting better at tracking where they end up like that 40% that's going to college they're going to go to college no matter whether they get a concentrator or Not Right But there might there are kids who will graduate and because they had an apprenticeship or an internship or some other industry connection they're going to go right into a job so are we able to uh track that now or will we be able to in the future
062so member bamy we are still working with the Department on labor and the governor's office and a few other Statewide organizations including the University of Alaska to create a a dashboard um I mean that's sort of the goal um years uh it'll take a lot of resources and and funding to to work with all of those departments but the hope would be that we would be able to track our kiddos once they graduate where whether they go to college or enter the workforce in the state of Alaska um and what industries they're actually working in thank you and if I may add to miss Carl's question so I've been looking closely at the national student Clearing House data so there's obviously a missed opportunity until we can get this information from the Department of Labor
063and other relevant stakeholders but I find the data on post-secondary outcomes for college very sobering um I I'm looking specifically at class of 2018 because that's the most recent class for whom we have six-year outcomes data so just some data for the general public and the board so the class of 2018 had uh 3318 students over 3,300 um 888 had a degree within six years um so even though we have a very high College enrollment rate compared to our peers about 42% that is something to be proud of only about a quarter of our students get any sort of degree and I even went so far this morning to to do some finer math on that so uh essentially if you you do a couple of additions and subtractions that means that we have about
064600 600 students that end up in debt presumably we have a lot of low-income students the cost of college is very high we have a ton of students who enroll in college but don't end up with a degree and I know I shared this four weeks ago with the boore but I'll say it again um because we have a lot of people in the room the most expensive degree you can pursue is the one that you don't complete and that's why I'm approaching this topic with immense urgency because we need to put our students on track for Financial Freedom and when we're setting up our students to be in debt after they enroll in college that's something that we need to look on as a district and of course work with our higher education Partners
065too but I mean the the fact of the matter is is that thousands of our students within the senior class will not have any sort of degree so we really need to think about what are the opportunities to set our students up to get more dual Credit in advance so that's something that I'm very passionate about in my previous life um that was one big theory of action if we can get our students more dual credit then they'll have more equity in the you know postsecondary piggy bank if you will and they'll be more likely to enroll in college but on the flip side we need to think about ways to connect our students to vocational training and uh technical credentials too because these are thousands of students that they're not in college they don't
066have a degree we need to figure out how we get these students engaged in the Alaskan economy so they can at least figure out their path to postsecondary if that was their dream but you I you know used to teach high school and you know my I actually taught at a college prep school and one of the reasons why I'm a superintendent today is because um one of my students was a graduate a highflyer straight A student um had gotten into college I I went to the movie theater um I'm a teacher at this point in my career and I actually saw my student serving popcorn at the movie theater a high school graduate straight days enrolled in college but she lost her way and she ended up and I know how much a popcorn
067person makes that was my first job it was 575 at the time the minimum wage has gone up since I was a popcorn guy but the fact of the matter is is that we um we need to set our students on the right track to to be competitive in this economy and then when you look nationally the landscape really is putting more students towards looking at these high demand jobs that are out there and don't take my word for it um our watermark for college enrollment as a district was 46% and we decreased um to 42 uh per. so that's a 4 point decrease just with an ASD alone so really the purpose of these difficult conversations around resource allocation and theems and all of this work is to really kind of be ahead of
068where I see the nation going which is more and more of those with Social Capital are going to Vibe for those jobs that are in the technical fields and we can offer those credentials here at free or little cost to our students if we set our programming right so that's why this sophomore class is going to be hugely important we think about ways to investor very limited dollars for their their uh cour workor all right member lessons um I wanted to Circle back to uh the extended conversation that we' been um you know moved on from um Mr Prince you were um I think that you and I are onto a similar uh red flag which is we have students this in this year's nth grade class who were in third grade when a new
069reading curriculum rolled out um they were in fourth grade when Co shut the world down they were in fifth grade when we started remotely and then many of them moved on to middle school and I think we all know that a focus of literacy is really on the early grades and I will just share that one thing I'm conc concerned about and I sort of made a nod to this earlier when Colonel Hansen was here is um I'm concerned that a number of the kids the students who may have failed who failed the face for this year um I'm concerned about their literacy can they read can they navigate you know do they have literacy and quite frankly numeracy needed to succeed and when I think about our core Mission there are a lot of
070really lofty aspirations that I know that this board in administration should have but I'm concerned that we're going to be graduating or trying to graduate students who are fundamentally not equipped with the core literacy and core numeracy that they have and I think all the career initiatives in the world are wonderful but I think that this face class and maybe other classes I mean there are some big red flags going on and I I guess I would be interested in and and challenge the administration to have a you know let's put the pulse on these students mean when I when I put a dipstick into the fall you know map scores uh for for our high school students um I mean I really do count hundreds of students at our big eight high schools who
071appear to be you know low or low average uh in their Ela math scores that that doesn't prend good things for the classes they need to pass um biology um and you know the Sciences there's some big words in there you have to know how to break big words down and I I'm just genuinely concerned that a lot of those students the nearly among the nearly 400 how many of them can't read or can't read where they're supposed to and I guess that's that's not this that's not in you know this report but I think that that's a core of the disconnect that I'm feeling with the focus on the academy so that we're not actually all already attaining our core mission of getting our kids set up to even graduate right I I appre
072I really appreciate all of those kind of questions um and I I would agree that you and I are aligned in the fact that we have the same concern like if students aren't reading and they're not writing and they have basic arithmetic skills that are subpar it's going to be a concern for all Educators um when you do speak about the face class I would say that the face classes part and parcel with the with the Freshman Academy model and uh my teen today we went to three different high schools and at one of them I was very I was very inspired by the work that South High School is doing uh with their dedicated counselor for their freshman they have U wraparound services with the Freshman Academy principal and they spoke at length about
073each individual student that they were tracking and we had a long conversation a robust one that I mean at the very least it was robust talking about the fact that we spend a lot of time in high school right now currently and the years P it was always reactive how are we going to get these seniors to graduate how are we going to get them to graduate in that last hour you know when you when you look at the number of credits that students are achieving their senior year when everybody realizes like oh my God we don't want to have to call Grandma until they're not to come up to Alaska to see our wonderful one that we've waited so long to graduate and it's not going to happen and that's that's just reaction but
074the positives for the way that we've set things up this year in particular across all of our high schools is that proactive nature that proactiveness of we see freshmen coming in and we see them in the face course that right right away first semester and we have teams that are looking at the students that are struggling we have teams that are saying like I'm gonna break this group up and I'm going to have this security person talk to these parents they're going to make phone calls and we're going to make sure that we connect with every one of our parents of our students that are sliding just a little bit behind we're going to notify the students um that need to go to what was it that they were following the uh the learning lab
075they actually set up a lunchtime learning lab for students that were not meeting the expectation of South High School for students in in their English classes in their math classes they had support for their elective classes and those things that were done are just above and beyond and I think that in four years you're going to see not so much reaction but just pleasant surprise at the growth they've seen students make you're going to see students that feel more connected and cared for because they were watched after very carefully they're freshman year which we know statistically if we look at it is the most impactful time for a student to make a transition into high school if they have two or more failures their percentage in chances of graduating on time go way down like
07630% which is it's horrifying you know and I think that it's really our our just cause and our theory of action is is is a good one we just need to hold what we have and let the system work because the Educators at each one of those schools are doing their very best and when they get their teeth into a system and they figure it out they're going to master it it's going to be a beautiful thing we're going to see that but we have to wait and be a little bit more patient and say we don't want to keep cycling through initiative after initiative after initiative you know I call like the the new car Theory like I need to get a new car because I don't know how the steering wheel fits or
077I don't like the seat so I get a brand new car that has the steering wheel that I like but now I got to figure out how I'm get third row because I had another kit right so then got to go get another car then I'm back to that whole thing unless we figure out how to drive the car that we have and make an adjustment to that car so my encouragement to all of us here is that we just do our best to water that grass and keep watching it get greener right here in as follow up M lessons um I want to Circle back to a comment that Dr thank you um that Dr Bryant made last March at the Joint board and assembly meeting and it caught my attention and it was
078to the effect of the academy are very vulnerable and I believe that was the word that was used um to a PTR increase um I don't understand part one of the reasons that I understand South may have had a a positive experiences here with this investment in the face course is that they were one of the schools that received additional um Staffing allocations um not all of the schools received that right think things were things were not doed uh exactly the same when it came to Staffing some schools received more Staffing based on their low lower enrollment numbers our bigger schools generally did not receive the extra Staffing dose funded by the AC the US Department of Education um and 10 times as many students failed the Freshman Academy course at another high school as
079they did it at South I mean this is where I'm thinking that we are in we haven't had the budget conversations yet but we are in a resource starved uh scenario um can you can you guys share how this is GNA work moving forward yeah thank you member lessons and I'll I'll go ahead and address my comment so during the joint meeting I I did mention that we have a very um very tough deliberation when it comes to the budget and one of the levers that we'll need to seriously consider is a a pupil to teer ratio increase so what that means is that we'll have um fewer teacher allocations amongst all of our schools potentially this has happened multiple years this is a common occurrence because of about 10 years of inaction from the
080legislature so that really applies to any program so for example a PTR increase could put into Jeopardy any specialized program that may be in existence at ASD even if it were to not be cut quote unquote a PTR increased good impact prog programs like an ignite like an immersion program like the ways that a third grade reading classroom is staffed it could be more combination classrooms and similarly a PTR increase could mean fewer opportunities at our high schools it could mean fewer electives it could mean larger class sizes these are all things that could be impacted when at the end of the day you have fewer teachers that you're allocating to the same number of buildings so the vulnerabilities are certainly not unique toies but um the resource allocation challenges for us as a team
081of eight to really think about over these next um few weeks um because we will need to discuss PTR increases the decision that the board ultimately makes when it adopts the budget will result in tough decisions at the school level what electives will I offer how many combination classrooms will I need to have these are terrible decisions that we' never want any school to make but what I'm trying to convey to the board is that given the fact that when we look at our underserved population including economically disadvantaged they're not graduating at the same rate as non-economically disadvantaged students I'm very proud of the fact that with an ASD we have a graduation rate over 80% but when we just look at the um the that number we forget that that's not the experience of
082various other sub populations within our school district so when we bring statistics before the board that suggests there's a correlation between completing a CT concentrator and higher rates of graduation I think that's a really strong rationale for prioritizing current technical education in our schools the final number of staff that I'll have to work with is a function of the school board's decision but my eyes are wide open to the impact of a PTR increase but at the end of the day our students will have to have classes that are not their core classes that they're enrolling in within the high school and the purpose of the day is to make the case that well let's hope the CTE is one of those choices that they have you member lessons member Wilson I have comments more
083than questions um while remember lesons was talking I could Envision many of my kids um struggling through through freshman year for for many other reasons um that because of their home lives because of many other things that because they don't really think about academic Excellence until their sophomore or Junior year and there's a lot of freshmen that I've worked with and talked to that um it really starts to settle in that they need to do better after their freshman year so the numbers um don't always surprise me when they're I know that they're not um our our F all of our freshmen aren't doing extremely well in all of their classes um only because I've worked with quite a few of them but one thing that that really I've learned does work for a lot
084of our kiddos um who are not just naturally or are academically driven um coming up through school is if they're interested and if they have connection and and that's why I really advocate for CTE so hard because so many of our kiddos who Maybe don't see the relevance of math but then really like Hands-On work and they get to do some construction and they learn the relevance and they learn the understanding of why math is so important to something that interests them then they pay attention and the connection having that connection you were talking about having that connection in in that Freshman Academy class and and having that opportunity to to reach out to family to to have just have that connection with a kid with with a student to make that connection with a
085student that that can make all the difference for many of our students that connection with not just the staff but with the opportunity to connect with our business partners the CT CTE also brings has brought in and continues to bring in more business partners which continues to bring in an opportunity for more connection for our students and that connection ultimately and ideally for our students will connect them to the academic content but often times I I have seen without that interest without that connection they they don't understand until later on in their high school years because of whether it's immaturity whether it's things going on on whatever it is at at that point in their lives and age it's it's just so tremendously important that the other factors are present and for me that's that
086is one of the reasons one of the main reasons why I advocate so heavily for CTE because I've worked with so many kiddos who once again once they are interested once they find something that's interesting to them once they can find that connection then they're academic paths change and it changeed for the better thank you member Wilson um I'm gonna jumping with a question regarding implementation stages and next steps um one of the things that's highlighted by Administration is that the goal is to increase the amount of financial literacy coursework as a part of the face itative that exists next um is the desire to supplement the existing cours work that exists in economics class um or is to replace that because we do have it in theory as part of our graduation requirements now
087through existing coursework and so curious what that Vision looks like or if that's still being workes yeah great question um Mr chair so right now um ASD has a requirement that students take four years of social studies um freshman typically historically had gotten that credit through usually through a course called ancient civilization though that was not required but it was um an offer course that many many freshmen took I envisioned that um our revamped freshman academ course will take that social studies uh credit um right now fresh the the face course is not a social studies credit um but we're reimagining it and revamping it so that it's even more relevant um to to what students need to know when they're in ninth grade one of the ways that this would be a social studies
088credit is by incorporating more um more uh more curriculum strands on economics for example financial literacy financial literacy is a huge deal even right now there's a pre-filed bill in the in the legislature um that underscores the urgency for financial literacy I Envision ASD going above and beyond that um as early as freshman year through this course so there are really great things in that course right now that we want to keep there's expiration of colleges and careers and that sort of thing but I really want to push the team to make sure that this course is geared towards the lens of the Alaskan economy and figuring out what skills and opportunities there are when you understand the e economy through the lens of in Alaskan you learn a lot about uh and in fact
089this slide is very um is very relevant you learn a lot about the role that natural resources play in the Alaskan economy and then we'll dig deeper and figure out what are the jobs within that area and what are the skills needed to thrive in that particular field be it a vocational uh course you could take within high school or college credit so you can go and get a degree in it um and and that extends to Health Science and what have you so really the vision would be all of our freshman first semester take this 0.5 social studies credit course um that will be reimagined and more aligned um through the the personal finance lens and then from there we'll encourage as many students as possible to seriously consider opting in um to to
090one of several Pathways that we'd like to offer at our schools there were dozens of curent Pathways that we wanted to offer to all of our students through the acmy of Anchorage because of the schedule change in our financial limitations we've really parsed that down to the most essential Pathways that we feel that we can offer with the staff that we have and of course contingent on whatever the final uh people to teacher ratio is that the board ultimately adopts but we do feel confident that there is a chance that we can pursue um some if not all of the CT Pathways that are listed on this slide so it would be a really nice way to continue to offer the course to all of our freshmen make sure they have um these you know
091competencies in financial literacy and uh career exploration in college exploration and then um I hope that many of those students will pursue a variety of these Pathways um I want at least um two at every high school but again this really depends on how the final budget shakes out but I think that the aspiration is appropriate if it's not ambitious enough maybe it's not ambitious enough I really wish that we could open more spots for students but I think this is a step in the right direction and it'll start with that re revamped um Freshman Academy course uh Mr Prince is there anything else you'd like to share about the new class uh just just to add a little bit more Dr Brian and to answer member Jacob's question I really appreciated that the question
092we're not trying to replace economics I think one of the important things that we see as Educators is that you get one touch early you get another touch later and it continues to build on itself and right now our social studes coordinator um is looking very very closely at the newly adopted Alaska state standards for social studies and making sure that we are adding as compliment to and not trying to replace right so we're looking at how can you add personal finance to a course that all freshmen are going to give because we know as freshmen your prime time this is where you're gonna start looking to get a job right you're GNA be that guy standing in the movie theater like Dr Bryant serving up popcorn and you're going to have to figure out
093like how am I going to save what I make here what am I going to put aside for maybe my hopes and dreams for the future and then later when you're a senior and you take your economics class then you remember back when you were a freshman way back when what that actually built on and we also want to make sure that it's done um deliberately and intentionally to support the curriculum that's going to follow through in Alaska studies and then the other courses that they're going to take through their history strands as they as they continue on high school yeah thank you appreciate that Clarity and I'm I'm glad to hear that it's going to be continuation of yesand um and I I am just for context I know personally that um the financial
094literacy bill that's that's been introduced now I think this will be the second session wasn't was modeled off of the work ASD has done to implement financial literacy within our curriculum so I'm grateful for the the work and the attention to detail on this topic in particular um Mr P you have a question sir this is a question for super attendant Brian I'm sorry if I misinterpreted the data that you shared the beginning I mean the gra the High graduation rates that you mentioned is definitely appealing but I am wondering if that data or if there is data that shows like such high graduation rates along with students taking the CT concentrators in such a scale that ASD is envisioning like on districtwide for most secondary students um because I could see 100% the individual
095benefit and motivation for students who actively seek out the career versus you know just the rest of students who are considering college or not really sure if they're pursuing career just yet and I see if it's really autonomy skill sure uh member pack if I understand the the question I think you're wondering about the feasibility of as many students as were proposing taking those CT Pathways uh it's certainly a possibility I think that's the aspiration but I I want to add a caveat that these are not the only ways that you could take cour work that that is correlated with higher graduation rates I do know that students that um are successful in advanced placement cours work they're often more likely to to graduate from high school and do well in postsecondary um but it
096is interesting when you look at the the current technical education like can we um structure the district such that if 90% of students were interested in CTE could they enroll I think we could get there but I think a big part will be investing students and teachers and families into this idea I think one of the biggest things that I'm trying to tackle a superintendent is really breaking down I think Decades of discourse that really pitted colleges against the careers and I think that and then I went on to work in the College and Career space for almost 10 years um personally because I'm very invested in the topic but I think what often goes forgotten is that most of us will end up in careers um a lot of us went to college to
097get there but um some of us don't and for that reason there is a lot of um Universal applicability ility to these career programs of study you know I was really heartened when I got a call from uh one of my colleagues in the community when she let me know that uh her son uh got into Harvard early and I was really excited to hear that ASD student we have great counselors and great teachers that that led to that um but then um she just volunteered um the information that her student had completed one of our CT programs of study like oh wow isn't that amazing um that really Harvard understands um how relevant completing a CTA concentrator is to the rigors of of Harvard right and it wasn't just that person then like we
098got the thank you email from the student another ASD grad that got into an mdphd program and specifically cited the fact that they completed a current technical education program of study as one of the reasons and um rationals that they were so prepared and for those of you who don't realize this an mdphd program are typically fully paid for by the university so uh there are very few doctors that can say that they graduated debt free but this particular ASD student will be a doctor completely debt free and that's in large part due to this fantastic program of study that we offer so imagine if we offered it to 90% of students and we could afford it and they were successful wouldn't that be transformative I certainly am compelled by that add thank you Mr
099pack member Les um I appreciate the administration uh reviewing the new Alaska um social study standards the State Board of education um did revise them um as recently as um at their December meeting um I don't see based on the current Bas content and it sounds like there'll be a revision um I don't see alignment with uh time management and personal presentation with areas of inquiry and content knowledge to me those are two fundamentally different classes and I think it's fundamentally Wrong by this board to require all um freshmen at the eight Comprehensive High Schools but not at the other high school so it's not a graduation requirement to take this course and for the administration to consider calling the face course an elective when students are going to be required to take it is
100um a misnomer at best and so I um just want to underscore my opposition to the plans that are being laid out and I realize that we're goal monitoring but I need to say what needs to be said Thank You member lessons noted member lessons and if I could just add that the intent is not to ask the board to adjust the graduation requirements for the face course really we would just uphold the board's requirement that they complete four years of social studies and um essentially this course would be just as required as the ancient civilizations course um very similar where many students um do take that course but it's not explicitly required by the board that's the current plan just wanted to make that clear member B I was GNA try to make that
101same clarification anyway I I just want to thank the team for I know I sent in a few questions and I think all my questions got answered um I you know we have had the Freshman Academy uh one semester one semester and while that gives us some data we got a ways to go and covid didn't just give us struggling readers across all grade levels we've always had struggling readers but we've also had amazing teachers to make sure that kids get what they need as they you know you know that they may have missed so while as awful as Co was and as much of a challenge it is I do not think bringing it up in the same context of this uh of of of of this strategy um when I was a principal
102years ago we always struggled with how do we transition ninth graders so that they we set them up for Success this is what this is we're trying to Fig we're still trying to figure it out except the difference is we have a path and IA one is really appreciative of the path of that pathway so I think thank uh the administration and the team for uh bringing forth the concentrator data and I look forward to looking at more data in the future uh relative to the Life College and Career Readiness goal thank you thank you member bellany I'm not seeing any other questions or comments and so I think we can um close our work session on or close our our session of goal monitoring regarding the concentrators thank you team for um making time
103for the presentation thank you so much move on to item D1 on our agenda which is public comments and specifically student public comments I want to welcome everyone to the boards first opportunity uh for public comment the board has set aside a one hour time slot at the beginning of the meeting for public comment public comment an Nexus of 1 hour will be heard at the second opportunity for public comment at the end of the meeting or comments M will be submitted in writing during public comment board members will not answer questions or engage in discussion with members of the public this is the Public's time to speak and the board's time to listen uh the school board welcomes the public to observe and contribute to our meetings through their comments however to be productive
104our meetings must be structured and civil ASD conducts our meetings under Robert's Rules of Order a set of rules for orderly meetings that have been used since the late 1800s those rules require the board and the public to be civil and respectful of each other's opinions and statements here are a few requirements under Robert's Rules of order do not attack a members or speaker motives no profanity or fall language refrain from disturbing the meeting no cheering Applause Outburst or waving of signs or posters if you have handouts that you wish to share with the board please hand them to Miss Sullivan who is seated to my left as president of the I'm sorry as chair of this meeting it is my duty to enforce these Rules of Civility and the Quorum as such and consistent
105with reference Rules of Order um we will rule any speaker out of order for violation of these rules or failing to conduct themselves in a civil manner then additional details and information can be found on the handout located near the door regarding audience participation with that said I want to begin with our student testifiers tonight uh for anyone not familiar we prioritize student testimony here in our boardroom during our meetings and so we'll call students first and then prioritize parents who have a student present tonight so we can get those uh students home and ready for school the following day uh first listed is Miranda adne welcome please state your name for our record and then you have three minutes dear members of the ASD School Board superintendent Brion School District leadership my name is
106Miranda Adney I am in the fourth grade at Lula junor school I have a little sister will who in Kinga my sister and I love attending Ro SCH and learning to speak German so my my favorite things about rushu are participating in battle the books with my teacher far Robertson and doing math with my teacher proud Reinhardt art class with prer and having my mom as a school nurse I enjoy playing at races with my friends some of my friends I have known since preschool and others since kindergarten I love to read my I love to read books and my favorite subjects are history and science my dream is to become a veterinarian to live in Alaska and take care of pets of my hamster Pearl my dogin please help the students and staff of
107vua I hope you will think about moving our school to a different ASD facility next year this move will would help keep our school open and allow the other as students to learn at our great ASC dual language charter school thank you for your time and your support of ASC students including your as CH students like me D thank you Miranda our next test of fire I will be Marina pamus welcome you set your name for a record you have three minutes please begin ready hi my name is Ser um I'm a student in eth grade at Rua first I would like to thank you for doing what you do and helping us have schools in anage um wel I believe has an exceptional program and has led me to learning many things like reading
108I think our reading program is spectacular um recently we have won many reading competitions such as Battle of the books um my team won the 2023 and 2024 State competitions I think that it's mostly due to our teachers and our bilingual programs um learning in different languages really does help especially you know with um laa because you learn how other languages work as well I think learning others leads to a deeper understanding of the original um it's a little Mula it can be a little cramped at times the Halls they're a little small um it would be useful to have a bigger school um our music room which I think might be the pride of Rula is a room without room a little unfortunate um I know that there music teachers dream to have a
109bigger room a bigger space and an easier space to teach um the current students more material um I know wilka I know that the board is concerned about reading due to co which is fair um but Roa with its programs can read like there is no tomorrow as has been shown um I think that Roa could continue to teach students better and better if we had a larger building please consider putting Roa in l c seeing as it empty and would had a better with students in thank you for your time thank you for your testimony our next testif testifier is bingit Wilder and then folks would ask if we could just provide maybe one round of applause at the all end of our student testifiers that way we can ensure all of our students
110are honored for taking time out to speak tonight welcome you have three minutes please state your name and then you can begin when you're ready King I am in first grade at Rula German school I would really like to move our school to lak Elementary so that we have more staff in our classroom thank you very much for your testimony appreciate it our next speaker is Juliet Peterson not seeing Juliet here moving to the front we'll go to May and Hill welcome please St your name for our record you have 3 minutes and you make ready hi my name is Marin Hildy and last year and several years before our school has done amazing in the state Battle of the books competitions last year all three of our teams from three different grade levels went
111to State and my team one um and our reading is just super good at our school another problem that we have in such a small building is that our Music Teacher here Downey we have several different musical programs and we like to call our Music Room the room without room because there really is no room in there we're all getting kind of like scrunched in with all the instruments and kids but we really do love playing music at RKA and it's a really fun thing that we do our other thing is that our PE room so our gym is also our lunch room and it's also our assembly room so on days when we have assemblies the PE class just has to go outside because there's nowhere else for them to go like um and
112also our lunchroom it'd be really nice for our PE teacher trainer Maddie to be able to not have to plan her classes around when the lunch periods are and that would just be really great overall for those three different things that have each their own room we also have a foreign exchange program where 15 of our students go abroad to Germany every summer which I was part of Last Summer and then those students that we went and visited our partners they come back to us in the fall and it's really fun if we had a great time last fall but with adding 15 students to all of our Middle School classes well not all of our Middle School classes five students each classroom it just got really cramped and crowded and we had to add
113a lot of extra chairs and there was three like three students to a desk sometimes and it'd just be a lot easier for that Exchange program if we had an extra room maybe for the exchange students to meet each morning or just more space to add in another table or something like that thank you for your time thank you for your testimony our next speaker is Daniel AIS welcome Daniel you have three minutes please begin when you're ready good to love beh [Music] and good evening Schoolboard members my name is Daniel I am a first grader at rasula I'm here to ask for your help Ro is a special place for me where I am learning both English and German but right now my school needs a new home I hear my mom say that
114if we don't move our hair princip [Music] to pets like letting go more teachers but I love my teachers if we move to a new building my teachers can say and we can have more room I hear it new building outl could has bigger classroom rooms a real g a real lunchroom a real Library it also has hu a huge playground for races and rooms for kids that need extra help things that we don't have at broker store right now by letting my my school move you are helping me my friends and my teachers please say yes to giving my school a new home so rul continue being a a special place for my friends my teachers and me Jonica thank you and thank you for your testimony our next speaker is Roland iory welcome
115if you could please take your name for a record in you have three minutes you can begin when you're ready my name is R I would like rushu to to move to L I like speaking German thank you and thank you for your testimony our next speaker is Georgia Moyers welcome George if you can state your name for a record and begin when you're ready you three minutes my name is George good evening thank you for the opportunity to speak to you I am a fourth grader and my brother EMT is a second grader at rasula I am here to request that rasula be allowed to move into lakehood Elementary School it really seems like the perfect fit for rasula and the timing couldn't be better but I'll leave those right size right time points
116for the grown-ups and get to the top three reasons why my brother and I are so excited about this opportunity first is all of the additional space at lakehood including a huge outdoor area at Roa I think we've done a good job being resourceful and working with the space we have but it's really small about 25,000 Square ft of playable area lak Hood's outdoor area is about 250,000 Square ft that's 10 times the size it has a huge playground basketball courts swings giant field s b square and funnel ball so many more activities second the space inside the school is so much bigger our current building is about 40,000 square ft we are cramped it's like my music teacher her Downey always says of our Music Room there's no room in this room without room
117at lak Hood Lake hood is almost 57,000 sare ft that's like adding another floor to our current building at rasula we have one multi-purpose room that serves as gym lunchroom and Auditorium lakehood has a dedicated gym and cafeteria among other things while having a cafeteria doesn't guarantee we'll be able to have hot lunches it gives me hope that I could take a break from my dad's packed lunches from time to time lastly I'm also excited about the library we really appreciate the volunteers from our community who have put together a small library in an Al Cove at our school we are doing the best we can with what we have as an Avid Reader and battle of the books competitor I love reading new books a full Library would offer so much more Roa schula
118is a great school despite our small space the teachers staff parents and kids make it great I think it can be even greater in a bigger space especially considering that this bigger space would save money and allow us to use the school budget on things that would help kids the most kite thank you for your time and consideration thank you for your testimony our next testifier is Ava kelon hi my name is Ava c and I'm in third grade at Rula and I want R to move to lak hood so we don't run out of money paying rent real good teachers are great and I I want them all to stay Thank you thank you for your testimony our next testifier is tesina Russ welcome you can say your name per record you have three
119minutes please begin when you're ready dear ASD board leadership my my name is tasina Russ and I am a fifth grader at Roa my mom will talk about our school growing to its full potential and here are a few things I'd like to share about I heard other schools have cafeterias but our school has a small space so we use our gym as our lunchroom that means less time for gym classes sad face our music is also our music room is also very little with no room for instruments sad face one of my favorite classes is Art but our building is so expensive that we have less for art supplies said face I would love to see our art program grow not shrink please help us move to lakehood Elementary thank you for your time
120thank you for your testimony our next speaker is Laura gerer thank you for helping us get through all of our students so they can get to bed at a decent hour tonight we appreciate you guys hello my name is laor Galler I am seven years old and I am in second grade at gerer school seven years old and I am in second grade at Roa G thank you for this opportunity to about one we hope that we can convince you to consider allowing Lo to move to Li Elementary School is a special where we get to half our speaking we get to learn all about the German culture and celebrate special events throughout the year like October St Nicholas top top and top so thankful can no longer Tre space which we have outr if
121we want our school to continue we need a more affordable building Elementary School would be a perfect fit for fish we want to expand our German cultural events to include more of the anguage community and we cannot do so in our current faulty there so many wonderful teachers who work so hard who help us learn but those of us who supp in Reading Writing and computers are holding classes in the H because we do not have enough classrooms to hold these lessons in I love attending local because I love my teachers and I love the German language I am so proud of how much I have G so far and I hope to have a chance to continue learning at Rish belong into the future one day we hope to go to Germany with Roa
122travel club and maybe even attend college in Germany someday Roa is a great school full of amazing teachers and staff we feel so lucky attending this school we hope that you will allow our school to move to lakeood Elementary in order to allow many more students for years and years to come with a chance to learn Generations thank you both for your testimony we typically ask each testifier to testify separately so everyone can have their three minutes but we appreciate you guys coming out tonight um so Laurel and Elizabeth appreciate your time our next speaker is Amelia Kinski seeing Amelia we'll go to Dylan Frey welcome you have three minutes please St your name to the record and begin you're ready good evening I am Dyan fry fifth grader at rasur our school is really
123special because we learn and speak German for half the day I have loved this school for 6 years but now we need a new building to keep our school strong secret is out about how amazing we are and now we have outgrown our space and it's really cramped moving to Lake Hood would give us the room we need to learn and grow this move would help us keep all of the awesome teachers and staff who make our school so great I have a brother in second grade and a sister starting Kinder Garden next year living till I could would mean a bright and long future for so many more kids I love my school and I hope you allow this move to likeh could D and have a good night thank you for your testimony
124tonight our next speaker is Katherine Cole welcome Catherine you have three minutes please take your name for our record and then begin when you're ready guen my name mama is [Music] Catherine for [Music] thank you for your testimony for our record I want to note that member dony joined us at 7:37 PM our next speaker is Joseph Gunz oh I'm sorry please go ahead good evening my name is Catherine K I've been attending o for six amazing years it would be great to move to a larger School building because I would love to have a library our current library is super small and does not have that many books it would be very helpful to have a separate lunchroom from the gym then parents would not have to pack lunches which also helps if a
125student forgets the lunch your parent would not have to leave work to bring it to them some other benefits would be how big the playground is in all the fields it would give space for students to run around Life by moving to this school we could save a lot of money be able to get a night janitor a counselor and other helpful staff moving to L code Elementary would create a Better Learning environment and help our German and English education thank you thank you very much for your testimony our next speaker is Joseph gunzinger we'll go to Kent Roth Fisher Roth welcome please take your name for a record you have three minutes you can begin when you're ready hello everyone my name is Fisher Roth and I'm in fourth grade and I'm going into
126fifth grade I have many reasons why I want to move to lak could but I will only give you four to save time here are my reasons our first one our our amazing music teacher her Downey doesn't have enough space to keep all his instruments he he turned down a few Tim upy drums because he didn't have space that isn't right up for the students because they don't get enough experience with awesome instruments the second reason is Lake could would have a cafeteria at reala each day some people need to pull benches out of a storage room in to the gym for lunch that is way too much work each day we were trying to get someone to make hot lunch up for the students as well not only does that help other students but
127it also helps other the parents because they don't need to pack lunch up for their kids each morning it would be awesome uh the new school would also have a bigger Library basically everyone loves the new library they made at reala imagine that that a library but just even bigger it'll help other the kids read more books especially when they're comfortable and finally Lake could would have a way a bigger playground a kids can play football baseball hop scotch for square and much more students need space to have fun at reala behind the school there was a swamp and and so we couldn't build over that it would mean a lot to me if we can move uh thank you up for your time thank you for your testimony our next speaker is Alexi music
128um after Lexi we have Conrad Spain welcome you have three minutes um pleas please beginning when you're ready I'll stay turnning for a record hi my name's Conrad and I want a bigger school and a bigger playground and we need a bigger classroom so we have to get a new school and we have to make our teachers get better and we have to get some more practicing of ger and we have to [Music] teacher thank you for your testimony um our last student testifier is Anton and last name starts with s can't make up the last name though so if you could um say your full name and then spell your last name for our record that would be really helpful thank you you have three minutes you can make um I'm Anton and my
129last name is schwager spelled s c w a i g e r uh I'm in sixth grade and the German emerging program is really important to me because I have an entire half of my family that speaks primarily German and in the last four years we've gone to Germany twice and it's nice that I can talk to them comfortably without needing to like speak in English and our we our school is but we have our our our lunchroom it it would be nice to have separate lunch room and our like PE class cuz right now um our PE room and our lunch room and then our um like um presentation room is all like in one room and it's difficult to have PE class and then immediately after need to clean up for lunch and
130then if we have a oh like guess a presentation or a ceremony we can't have like our PE class and we need to go outside and it would be nice to have a separate lunch room from a music room or our lunch room from our like gym and our um our two like music rooms are pretty small and it's there's not really enough space for both of us with the instruments and all of the kids and it would be nice to have a larger music room thank you thank you for your testimony I want to give one last ask to see if Juliet Peterson Emilia Kinski Joseph kinger or Lexi mus see anyone move to the front and that concludes our student testimony tonight if everyone could join us and giving them a round of
131applause that'd be great okay we'll move on to our public testimony to be heard on non-action items our first Speaker tonight is Amanda Thompson and um our second testifier tonight will be amand Amanda Adney if you could come to the front as well we're GNA try and pair Folks up so we can hear from as many people as possible so Amanda ad me if you're present please join us up front GRE anandra my name is Amanda Thompson I'm an ASD employee and I am also a rela APC board member but I speak tonight on my own behalf and I have a story for you once upon a time in a forest between mountains and sea was a poor musician's home where he lived with his 10 children and their new stepmother though the home was
132small for their needs they enjoyed being together playing all sorts of Melodies growing out their hoodies squabbling a little but always caring for each other the home also was full of sweet memories that they had of the musician's first wife and mother and all 10 children who had inherited the cottage lease from a her good Godfather who was well connected Ed man who had many dwellings in the area farms and the luxurious addresses in nearby cities the musici himself had some help from the rulers of the land but each year their support waned soon his new wife grew angry with him for as the 10 children grew formed Mara bands created huge art murals and conducted elaborate science experiments she had barely any room to grow her cottage industry business also The Godfather seing his
133goddaughter no longer here gave no mercy on the poor musician and charged them even more to lease their crowded Cottage one day to escape the scowling stepmother two of the older children snuck out of the cramped Cottage they had no idea of where they were going they knew their beloved father and mother wanted something better for them soon they were lost a fog rolled in they had walked arms gripped together sticks broke wolves howled and loons mournfully called just as tears brimmed in their frightened eyes the fog lifted and they found themselves by a Serene lake and a sprawling series of connected Cottages rimmed beautiful water out of nowhere nine sparkling people floated from The Cottages toward them one held out their head kindly children do you need a what's the end of the story
134are the children in their crowded Cottage going to have a nice spacious home for them to be able to live and learn that's really up to you you board members thank you very much thank you and welcome you have three minutes please St your name for the record and again when you're ready good evening members of the ASD school board and superintendent Bryant my name is Amanda Adney and I am the school nurse of Rula German Immersion School as you know rasula is an ASD dual language charter school with students in kindergarten through 8th grade we serve 480 students our success is due to our strong Academic Program dedicated staff and increasing Community interest in ASDS Choice programs however we Face significant challenges in our current facility including space constraints and infrastructure issues that hinder
135our ability to provide high quality education we are crammed into our facility yet we need the student numbers that we we have in order to pay for the facility that houses us seeing that our facility costs represent about 20% of our yearly budget as the school nurse my office is located in the front office of the school it is also located directly under the stairs that our students use numerous times a day this noise level makes for a less than ideal environment for the sick children who seek Refuge there in hopes of feeling better I have done my best to to make the nurse's office feel cozy and comforting however there is nothing to be done about its location under the stairs in this office I also conduct the mandated Health screenings which includes hearing
136as you can understand this can be tricky to accomplish I would greatly appreciate having access to an alternate quiet space for health screenings but unfortunately all of our classrooms are in use during the school day I observe our staff working with small groups in the hallways because there are no open rooms for small groups to work in I acknowledge the hard work being done by all of our amazing staff members you see these are not only my colleagues and friends they are also the teachers of my two children Miranda and Willow I have seen firsthand the academic benefits of my own children being enrolled in an ASD dual language immersion Charter School my daughters are flourishing in their studies at RKA and I am so proud of their accomplishment ments we are requesting rasula be
137considered for lakehood elementary for the upcoming school year a move to a more suitable facility when sure the long-term viability of our program in align with as's goals of expanding access to Choice programs for rasula to be housed within a neighborhood it would provide greater AB visibility um and expand access for ASD students to benefit from the enrollment in a dual language Emer program I kindly encourage you to vote in support of frula and to provide our school with a permanent home within ASD building at lak Hood thank you very much for your time and your support of Kula thank you for your testimony our next two testifiers are P Piper Foster Wilder and Alicia H you join us up FR please welcome you have three minutes good evening um I'm actually Piper is not
138available tonight I'm her husband Nathaniel Wilder hope that's okay um uh and my daughter Bing gets a first grader at rasula there're about 25 kids in her classroom and only one teacher it's a classroom that is quite disrupted because the student to teer ratio is so utterly poor the teacher is creating engaging lessons for these students but they're not getting the best of those lessons because there are too many distractions among the students in the classroom and the sole teacher doesn't have the resources to keep the students focused on the lesson my German speaking uh wife has experienced it firsthand while volunteering in the classroom because 20% of the real Cula budget goes to the rent uh for the building alone the school cannot afford to properly staff my daughter's classroom the repercussions of this
139is that the distractions that plague this overpopulated classroom makes learning quite a challenge here in the final year of a 10-year lease our school is in need of a building that meets our program structure and that would allow our budget to be focused on accommodating learning the classro Via additional Staffing an actual ASD building would make R's budget sustainable and the current shuttered lakehood Elementary School is a perfect option for our student body of 480 plus staff members uh thank you so much for hearing us thank you for your testimony and welcome you have three minutes please begin when you're ready thanks good evening my name is Alicia Hildy and my three kids attend real Cula uh first up I want to acknowledge the tremendously difficult decisions you all made to close schools it is
140the most painful vote a board member makes even in the most practical of approaches you're ending years of time and energy that those students Educators and Families invested into their school and I know none of you made those decisions lightly but as stewards of public school funding you also have a responsibility to make the best use of our school buildings to keep as many resources going towards student learning in rula's case we've excelled at maximizing public education dollars we've been paying rent the entire duration of our Charter while consistently achieving the same high educational outcomes as other Charters and special programs but with fewer dollars after years of exceptional Financial Planning and good governance by our a PC we are just entering into making some of the hard budgeting decisions that ASD has had to
141make for the last decade higher class sizes teacher with two grade bands having to cut positions thanks to our apc's long-term planning and our required volunteer hours by parents our students have been spared much of the chaos that ASD regularly has to deal with caused by one-time State funding loss of bond debt reimbursement and explosive health care costs our apc's declaration that we can't deliver the same high quality education with less money is a truthful statement and one ASD continues to make to the state legislator Charter School parents are your strongest Ally in advocating for inflation adjusted school funding but now this board has something additional to bring to your advocacy you made the hard decision to close schools and now you can show legislators how the superintendent is maximizing building Space by welcoming charter
142school students into a taxpayer funded building so instead of having public education dollars going to our landlord they'll go directly to Student Learning we want to honor the legacy of lak cood Elementary and be a neighborhood school we want to see kindergarteners walking to RKA next year I'd like to have us have a neighborhood Lottery priority like stream does um there was perhaps a time where it made sense for a charter school to run out commercial space if all of ASD existing facilities were full but we're certainly far from that now there is lots of space for ASD students to learn in ASD facilities you're bringing ASD students back into ASD buildings demonstrates your commitment to making sure public education funding is directly supporting student learning morning thank you thank you for your testimony our
143next two speakers are Cassandra AIS and Jolene corus both come forward welcome you have three minutes please state your name for the record and makeing when you're ready dear ASD school board thank you for this opportunity to speak my name is Cassandra Uris and I address you as a deeply concerned parent of rosula student I'm here to urgently ask you to consider relocating rasula into ASD facility as part of the right sizing Initiative for next year Rula serves 485 students with a curriculum rooted in academic rigor and cultural enrichment despite dedicating half of the school day to German language immersion our students consistently exceed as's benchmarks in mathematics and English language arts yet the very program that has earned these accolades is at risk our financial reality is dire the least on our commercial building
144consumes 20% of our annual budget a financial strain that has forced R to make heartbreaking sacrifices we've had to cut critical staff positions all to maintain the high quality education our children deserve the impact on student is undeniable we no longer have a dedicated counselor and our vice principal is juggling multiple roles including filling a social emotional learning capacity while this highlights their dedication it's an unsustainable situation that short changes both the students and the staff our current facility is 39,000 square feet which is inadequate for the need of our growing s school Community a move into an ASC facility such as Lake Cut Elementary with 60,000 square feet of space would provide larger classroom space and designated breakout rooms these spaces are critical for students with 5504 plans and IEPs who require small group
145settings and testing and individualized instruction this expanded space would also allow us to better serve all students and create a more supportive Equitable learning environment the larger facility would address long-standing challenges and offer new opportunities for our students for example schools like the Alaskan native Charter culture the Alaskan ultural charter school has thrived in an ASD building showcasing how access to such facilities can Elevate programs and improve student outcomes without relief the sacrifices we've made such as eliminating critical positions will only depend directly affecting the quality of education and support available to our children we respectfully request that the opportunity to move br Kula into an ASD facility such as lak Hood Elementary to ensure the program sustainability this move would relieve the immense Financial pressure on our school and allow us to reinvest in
146essential staff positions and provide the enriching education our children deserve the urgency on this decision cannot be overstated we need clarity about facility availability now so we can plan and communicate with our school families thank you thank you for your testimony and welcome you have three minutes please state your name for the record and make in you're ready Jolan pess good evening Anchorage Schoolboard members thank you for giving my son and I an opportunity to speak at tonight's meeting my name is Jolan poris and my son is Roland Ivory my son is currently a first grader at real Kula I beyond proud of the progress my son has made in all aspects of learning in the last two years real Kula was a definite selling point for my husband and I as we were deciding
147to stay in Alaska my family is from Germany and I was stubborn and never engaged enough in German in the German language as a young person to be fluent I'm happy to say my son is currently able to have conversations with his om man German and understand her learning German at the same time as his peers is priceless immersion Works real casula provides many cultural opportunities for students and families to engage in and the community throughout the year rula's academics are exceptional the students often surpass the ELA and math blls for benchmarks while half the students are learning in German or half the days learning in German real cula's rent is about 20% of its annual operating budget for the school I cannot imagine the additional opportunities real Kula could provide to the students and
148the community with the cost Savings of being in an ASD building we're asking for your support to move rasula into lakehood Elementary School to strengthen the positive work real Kula is already doing I would love for my two younger Sons to have the same opportunity as their older brother supporting this move into an ASD building will give my younger son similar opportunities thank you for your time thank you for your testimony our next two speakers are Danielle kelon and Ora Russ welcome please take your name for the record you have three minutes please begin when you're ready okay Danielle keles good evening members of the school board my name is Danielle keles and I am a parent of a third grader and kindergartner at rasula German emergence school I am here tonight to advocate ilka
149to move into the lakeh hood building you have heard from many people about the financial burden our school is under with the high rent at our current facility but I'd like to mention another reason why a move like this would be beneficial for our school RKA has been growing out of the space we are in currently we have students engaging in interventions in hallways and closets because we don't have enough space outside of actual classrooms our school has a thriving before and after school program but we are at capacity because of limited space therefore not being able to meet the needs of our families if RKA is moved to Lake Hood we will gain approximately 20,000 square fet with this space we can invest more into our students success and the future of our school
150RKA has been providing quality instruction to students since 2007 we have 480 ASD students and 42 ASD staff this is the right opportunity to set RKA up for growth in the upcoming years and ease our financial burden moving RKA to lak hood is the right choice for right sizing thank you very much thank you and welcome you have three minutes please state your name to the record and begin when your ready or a Russ dear Dr Bryant and board members my name is Ora Russ and I'm a parent to two real immersion kids one being an Alum who has continued with the German Immersion program via service high school and the second of who is still attending R and you heard from earlier sad face girl thank you for your leadership and for the chance
151to share how R has shaped our family's ASD journey of the last decade Plus for our family and many others in ASD alternative programs like charter schools and language immersion are highly sought after over a decade ago with our eldest we can recall the intensity of applying for the lottery and waiting with great anticipation to see if we had been selected for our top pick which was real gay the parent interest and desire to attend far outweighed the spots available the very picture of an ASG ASD Charter School success story compare that to what we have all heard in the news for many years of late now that ASD is shrinking that families with young children are moving away to other districts not drawn to ASD that story of an Ever shrinking District does not
152have to be the legacy of ASD and can be reversed if we identify what draws enrollment and provides sought-after offerings then ASD can be known as the district where people purposely move to for the utmost education offerings then ASD can be known as the district where people MO I am here to boldly say that R demonstrates such a recipe for drawing enrollment and being a success as the first k through eight language immersion program Ro is a charter school Success but has not been immune to the budget challenges that every school in the district is facing Ro's commercial building rent costs are increasing at an unsustainable rate and R is now facing choices that will dramatically affect the quality of our program things like losing teachers support staff enrichment programs and beyond that will hurt
153our long-standing history since 2007 of our school and its trailblazing success yet a solution does exist that is the chance to move into an ASD existing School otherwise set for closure like lakehood Elementary Ro is a no stranger to moving in our period for our family alone we have experienced and assisted with one move um a stable facility will allow ROK to continue the quality of Education we're known for and support our amazing teachers and staff thank you thank you for your testimony our next two speakers are Ellis and Galler and Ashley calinski welcome please say your name for the record we have we have three minutes and we can begin when you're ready Al Galler hello esteemed members of the Anchorage school board and superintendent Brian thank you for the opportunity to speak this
154evening as an advocate for reala schula German emersion School my name is Allison Galler I am a mother to three real Kula students my son Grayson the third grader along with my twin daughters whom you met earlier Laur and Elizabeth both in second grade I also serve as president of the reala Arion the parent teacher organization at rasula German Immersion School we understand that lately you have been faced with many extremely difficult decisions brought about by as's rightsizing initiative the Anchorage Community is so grateful for the immense amount of thought and Care you've dedicated to making these tough choices I am here today however to advocate for a decision I'm hopeful you will find to be an easy one reallocation of lakehood elementary school to serve as the new home to Rel casula German emersion
155School in an opinion piece published on January 11th 2025 in the Anchorage Daily News Governor Mike Dan leevy Sayang the Praises of Alaska Charter Schools citing a Harvard study published in 2024 which placed Alaska's Charter Schools amongst the best in the nation the governor then went on to specifically name Rula as a school which with its focus on bilingual education delivers exceptional results through individualized teaching methods smaller class sizes and a commitment to meeting the needs of families and students it is certainly true that R Kula is an exceptional School its leadership is unparalleled and its teachers and staff for wholly dedicated to the highest level of quality education and character development while our current facility is bursting at the seams with nearly 500 students every single student entering through the front doors each morning
156is greeted by name r Kula as Alaska's only independently chartered language immersion school as a testament to Anchorage School District's commitment to providing high- performing alternative educational opportunities to the Anchorage Community the outcome of this commitment with commitment which you uphold will undoubtedly be a generation of Global Citizens confidently communicating the values and information instilled to them across borders and around the world it is also true however that rasula can no longer afford to remain in its present facility and maintain the Staffing levels and teacher student ratios which have allowed the school to achieve the exceptional educational outcomes which they have lately been the subject of commendation on a national level the opportunity is now at hand to ensure the long-term sustainability of real kul's Mission by granting the use of lakehood Elementary school to
157Rula German Immersion School in doing so it will not only allow the nearly 500 currently enrolled students at rasula the opportunity to opportunity to continue their bilingual academic Pursuits but it will also ensure that the opportunity for bilingual German English education remains viable for anchorages students long into the future thank you thank you for your testimony our next two speakers are Jessica Frey and ritaa Ginger welcome you have three minutes please take your name for a record and then again when you're ready good evening ASD board members inrage community and superintendent Bryant I'm Jessica fry I'm a parent of a fifth grader and a second grader and I have a daughter entering into kindergarten this coming fall I've also been a school volunteer since the day we stepped into the building as you've heard from
158those before me and will continue to hear from the long list of people here to advocate for Rula uh oh we repurposing lak Hood to be the new home of rosula is hopefully the easiest part of the ri sizing efforts as you can see by the Sea of yellow red and black rasula is far more than a school this is an amazing Community fostering bilingual education and C cultural enrichment however our current situation is unsustainable and we Face significant challenges that that threaten our ability to continue providing high quality experiences our family and Community have come to expect our classrooms and and facilities are stretched to their limits making it difficult to meet the needs of our growing student body lakehood Elementary offers a space that aligns with our needs adequate room for our students
159and the potential for a stable long-term Solution by relocating we can focus our efforts and resources where they belong on students teachers and staff preserving our exceptional teachers and staff staff is critical they are the heart and soul of rosula and we cannot afford to lose them due to financial constraints a move to a more sustainable space will allow us to retain our talented Educators and ensure that they have the resources they need to help our children Thrive the opportunities that our students all of these kids behind me are getting being enrolled in this program are far beyond what I had expected when my oldest started school six years ago and something that I'm sure will only grow in the next eight years that we are students there something that I hope can continue for
160more families for many years to come this will be made possible with the move to the lak hood footprint thank you thank you for your testimony our next two speakers are are Paul musk and Evans Sheldon welcome please say your name for the record you have three minutes you can begin when you're ready uh my name is Paul music um thank you all for listening to me this evening uh my son is a first grader over at RCA U my daughter hopefully with any luck will be a kindergartener Roa next year I just want to uh share this with you um we had sent Alexi to kindergarten we brought them home what did you learn today nothing what did you learn today nothing and repeat repeat repeat repeat for several weeks into this and we're
161getting a little concerned Saturday morning he comes staggering down the stairs at 7 in the morning and he's speaking in German full sentences had a dream in German you imagine that and I knew just enough German to say Y and then he went on and on and on and on it was a full paragraph is amazing so it's just say it works later on in the year we went over to Europe to visit my wife's family and uh got on Condor Airlines and you know he made it a point to go to the flight attendant I speak German and had whole conversations with them the whole way over everything was conducted in German not only has his German been fantastic but his writing is is improved incrementally his um his his English is amazing his
162math is amazing the he's really getting a quality education at this school and I hope he'll give it the uh opportunity to continue um and I wanted to comment on the lak hood the neighborhood put the ver neighborhood it's ideal imagine putting it a an immersion school in a neighborhood with that diversity it almost welcomes it it's it's to me it just seems so natural we did a Parks tour with the family a couple years ago and we went to all the neighborhood parks we went to Balto saala Park which is right down the street on Wisconsin tremendous just a great reception everybody welcoming and wonderful shared the food it was just a tremendous experience so I hope you'll just give us a an opportunity to move the school there great neighborhood and a terrific
163program thank you for your time thank you for your testimony Mr Sheldon would you like to come forward welcome please state your name for the record you have three mats you can be in your hello um hello my name is Evan Sheldon um I'm here to speak up for my son um I know this is way off the subject from everybody else's but um I need my son to be heard out um I think he's being um he is being treated unfair at the school he goes to over at West High um my son gets in trouble every now and then but um um my son Evans Isaac Sheldon um he was just he just left um he gets treated bad at West High um Before Christmas on the 18th of December he got uh
164suspended there was an incident that took place in His science class during during finals and um my son was attacked he was attacked by a student um and uh the student had had uh problems with him because I had previous last summer we had issues I even had to send police officers over to the bid's home but um on that part um I'm not we're not being Hur by the school I tried appealing this his suspension and he got attacked with the busted lip he was sitting down class and um the teacher wasn't paying attention and um there's a whole bunch of stories and they they do not they do not go together for him to get the suspension and um one of the reasons I know it's not true is they're first of all
165they're trying to say my son was recording them on his sell it on his phone and which his phone was in my was my possession because I had taken it from him and I even cut out the service he was going to school at no phone teacher would know that but the teacher didn't wasn't paying attention to the school wasn't paying attention to the kids my son told me that the teacher was at his desk on his personal device and um it's like I tell everybody don't text and drive same same same thing you know pay attention to the kids um my son was uh he was on ink monitor because he got in trouble uh outside of school a few months back but then when he went back to school um the kid the
166kid had beef with him he knew he was going to get in trouble and um I tried appealing this tried talking to to to the school to and uh nobody's listening in honest and I'd like to talk to every one of you um get my phone number from uh Miss Peggy and I'd like to talk to every one of you about this issue thank you for your testimony Mr Sheldon our next two speakers are Smith and Hans schwager oh at Hans F schwager I think we've got two Hans schwager signed up welcome you have three minutes please begin when you're ready good evening my name is Katherine Smith AKA Conrad's mom um I'd like to say this the picture perfect opportunity for the school for the School District in order to move the immersion program
167over into lak Hood Elementary not only is it going to help everybody with the expenses it facilitates the ability for the program to grow um by growing the program it also gives the opportunity for more students to enroll in the emersion program that has Excel um so I would like to request that the board bring this to an agenda for a voting opportunity and um it would be sooner rather than later because time is US of the essence with the lease expiring at the end of this year um it also provides the school the opportunity to put that money back into the school to the kids if they're spending $750,000 a year on rent they're not putting it into their school they're not putting books into the hands of the students they're not giving them
168pencils to write their name um they don't have the the ability to provide balls for them to go play out in the in the schoolyard um I do volunteer my hours at lunchtime I do encourage you all to come see how that works you have uh first graders kindergarteners all in the lunchroom which is their multi-purpose room they eat their lunch in their 20-minute time frame they pack their books they put them all in the cart they go outside to play um when it's 20 degrees outside when it's raining when it's snowing they're playing outside if if the weather doesn't permit it they have a dance party in their classroom while the other students eat their lunch um I think it's a fiscally responsible decision for the school board to make to move this program
169into another facility um with that said I'm going to leave it as time is of the essence guys I would like to see this come to a coordinating and agenda meeting to where it's a votable actionable item for the board thank you thank you for your testimony our next two testifiers are Hans fager and Hans M schwager welcome you three minutes sir please begin with your ready hello my name is H schwager and I'm a parent of three kids that are currently at Rula uh one just is finishing up in eighth grade and two are in sixth grade Anton schwager is one of them who spoke earlier today I'm speaking here today mainly to encourage you to consider allowing Ula to use one of the ASD buildings that be vacated through the right sizing initiatives
170such as the lakehood elementary rosula has been an excellent school for my children it's a high has a high parent involvement and a challenging curriculum with kids that rise to the challenge I wish that a school such as uh rasula existed when I was a student at ASD 40 years ago it's a tremendous asset for the ASD to have a quality immersion program such as provided by rasula German immersion programs are fairly rare with less than uh 10 across the country in fact a friend of mine considered moving his family to Anchor so that his son could have an early education in Germany for imersion programs to be successful they really require sufficient interaction with the students and faculty and Roa has been forced to increase the student teacher ratio which is really to the
171detrim of an emersion program this could be alleviated if Lake could Elementary would become available to R it has been really satisfying to watch my kids develop their German fluency it has made them feel like Global Citizens and has allowed them to be comfortable traveling in Germany has enabled them to interact with relatives in Germany it has opened the doors for my kids to consider working abroad for the Summers or maybe even pursuing um university options thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak here and to advocate for Roa and uh the other Han schagger who is going to speak he graciously went to go pick up my daughter so he's unable to speak right now understood thank you thank you for your testimony our last speaker for the first hour of public testimony
172tonight's meeting is Lauren Hugh welome please take your name for the record you have three minutes and you can begin when you're ready my name is Lauren Hughes this is my son Hatcher student at real Kula I feel like everybody has stated very adequately and sufficiently the reasons we're excited and hopeful to move to Lake Hood so I just want to take this opportunity to thank you all I know you have busy schedules and I just want to leave my hope with you and our hope is that next year uh we would be going to lakehood with more space um a bigger parking lot and a more adequate facility um to just house this amazing program that our family hasn't been able to stop talking about uh ever since Hader began last year in kindergarten
173and we're very excited and I just want to leave my hope with you guys and thank you so much thank you for your testimony that concludes our first hour of public testimony um we'll take a 10-minute recess thank you e e e those back to order and we've concluded our first hour of public testimony thank you for everyone who took time out to attend we'll have an additional opportunity toward the end of our agenda um we'll move forward with our consent agenda right now I would entertain a motion to approve the consent agenda well before we do that I'm going to ask if any board member wishes to pull an item from the consent agenda for a discussion hearing n I'd like a motion to approve the consent agenda as listed Mr chair I move
174to approve the consent agenda as uh listed second presented made by member bamy seconded by member Wilson um is there any discussion seeing none then will um Miss suvan can you please call the rule student representative pack yes member bamy member lens yes member Higgins oh yes member Donley yes member Wilson yes president Hollman yes not yet chair Jacobs yes the consent agenda is approved by a vote to 7 to zero thank you uh we will move on to our action item or F1 we have a student hearing um is there a motion to approve I move to approve the recommended expulsion of student associated with ASD incident number 14324 as discussed in our executive session second motion made by member Wilson second by member Bellamy is there any discussion hearing seeing none Miss can
175you please call the RO member Donley yes member lesons yes member Wilson yes member Higgins member Bellamy member Jacobs yes president Hollman yes action item F1 is approved by a vote of seven to zero uh we are now on our non-action items listed under G is there a board member who wishes to discuss a non-action item this evening hearing seeing none we'll move on to continued public comments on non agenda and non-action items list our next speaker is uh next two speakers are Strickland and Jean Kut welcome you have three minutes please take your name for the record and begin when you're ready Strickland I'm a proud parent of a second grader at Rula uh you've heard a lot of testimony today about reasons why moving to lakehood would make sense for our school but
176uh what I want to testify about is just what a special Community reala is and how it dovetails with ASDS uh stated goals and policies I mean it it really creates Global Citizens I came to Alaska I was St stas on J bear and my wife and I decided to stay and raise our family here uh in large part because of Roa and the community that it it Fosters um it's an incredibly diverse Community I was pleasantly surprised by that um just in diverse and always socioeconomically racially religiously um you know we had a conception that it was going to be a bunch of little blond white kids and it's not that it's it reflects the entire community that Anchorage has and moving to lak hood would continue to support that diversity being in a
177neighborhood School setting right now it's I me most of you probably seen where Roa is but it's in a really Industrial Area it doesn't facilitate any interaction with the community and uh it really is the community of the school that is what makes realus special um my wife volunteers even though she's a full-time professional with the pub Scout Troop um we have parents that come in and do jobs that most other ASD schools have employees to do because of our budget constraints with the rent that we pay we've got folks that come in and volunteer their time to sweep floors to um you know act as parent Volunteers in the classroom uh one of the things that personally impacts my family is my son is on IEP for a speech language pathology issue and um
178they've got the kids at R our current facility doing those one-on-one or small group meetings just in hallways or in closets um you know things that a move to lakehood would really make a difference having dedicated space for those kids and also you know becoming bilingual it's not something that's in a vacuum I mean this is something that has real effects on the community um I've taken up learning German alongside my son and I can tell you that I've built a client of German speaking people here in Anchorage as an attorney I mean people know that I'm an attorney that can speak German and um you know our son you we hope that he continues with his German through high school and college and then comes back and contributes to Alaska with such an outmigration
179of people in Alaska right now we really should be investing in programs and schools that are going to Foster these kind of skills that are going to help in college but most importantly bring these ASD graduates back to the community and we have such an influential germane speaking Community here um having these kids that grew up in this program and having them stay here in Anchorage is going to benefit everybody thanks for your time thank you for your testimonies our next two speakers are Elaine Squire and Brandon stro welcome please state your name for the record you have three minutes you again when you're ready all right hello and good evening board members my name is Elaine Squire and I'm currently a special education par professional at rasula as well as a parent of a
180fourth and sixth grader there thank you for your leadership and allowing me to speak here today I'm speaking tonight on behalf of real Kula is both a staff member and a parent of this community we are a wonderful school full of bright students of the district and I look forward to seeing them Thrive there is currently a high demand for Education through charter schools and ours is no exception currently we are occupying a building that is having difficulty accommodating our needs with struggling and increasingly unreliable hbac and a lack of space real Cula is the largest in-person Charter program in the district with a population of about 484 students it is crucial that we have the Staffing to support them and our current budget is heavily constrained by the cost of the facility we are
181currently occupying if we were to continue this course we'll be forced to cut Staffing and programs which would us and our ility to sufficiently meet the educational needs of the students of this District I believe being able to move into a repurposed ASC building as part of this rightsizing initiative will help us accommodate our student population as well as continue to grow and provide our excellent educational standards to other amazing children I am a special education par professional at rasula and I have the perspective of assisting the students who have need for IEPs to better achieve their learning goals because of the unique circumstances of teaching in two language is it creates the need for Flexible Staffing in our department in our current budget crisis I foresee an increased difficulty meeting the minutes we are
182required to give each student causing them to be unable to reliably reach their goals by allowing us to occupy a repurposed building will be able to continue providing strong Educational Services I would now like to speak to you as a parent of students at RKA and a member of this community my children as I've mentioned are in fourth and sixth grade this year my sixth grade daughter found out that she had has a strong aptitude for learning a second language and is excelling as she enters Middle School my fourth grade son is a fast learner and a wiz at mathematics and a strong emphasis on learning at RKA has set him on a course with a love for learning both of my children have made strong connections at RKA and I wish to see them
183continue to access the incredible feature of this school thank you for taking the time to listen to our testimonies and to continue to look at the data gains the right sizing initiative to better help all ASD students including ASD Charter students thank you for your testimony and welcome if you can begin when you're ready please take your name for the record you have three minutes uh good evening esteemed board members and District leadership I'm Brandon strau principal parent and educator at Rula thank you all for the opportunity to speak tonight I'd like to encourage you all to repurpose Lake Hood Elementary School for Rula as would benefit so many different students I've shared testimony a few times with the board over last couple of months tonight I would like to speak to three different points
184that were brought up during the work session earlier today student access timelines and funding real Kula is interested in expanding student access to our dual language German Immersion programming currently rasula operates a robust before and after school program for roughly 200 students through our parent organization RSI which removes one of the barriers as family space when accessing a charter schol this program provides a safe and educational space for students until parents are able to pick up if RKA was relocated lak Hood a kitchen could open up the possibility for a lunch program open a preschool is also an interest of mine as we look to expand access to real Cula for our youngest Learners I know Transportation has been discussed several times and I would be interested in collaborating on that plan however at this
185time I have not had one family approach me to share that they would not be able to attend next year do if we were relocated to Lake Hood ideally we want to share rasula with as many students as possible we believe in the impact that a dual language immersion program can make on student outcomes if real Kula is re relocated to Lake could it would be an asset to that neighborhood and would have more and would be more accessible than ever also want to talk about the lottery timeline as it is an important factor as Jim Anderson pointed out during the work session today the lottery opens on February 1st and while it is open until mid-march herka is holding weekly School tours over January February and March and we're recruiting kindergarten students at school
186fairs at the end of January and beginning of February making a timely decision on repurposing Lake Cod would greatly impact our recruitment of kindergarten students lastly I want to speak about funding Jim Anderson noticed that Ila has roughly 1.6 million in rollover Savings please be mindful that just 13 months ago rela schula APC approved a budget to spend roughly $600,000 from that account for this school year fiscal year 25 additionally just last month reala shul APC approved a budget to spend over $700,000 from that fund for next school year this school year 26 at the same time R Kula has has approved cuts to 3.4 FTE and removing the evening custodial position thank you for your testimony our next two speakers are Rebecca coven and Aaron mofin welcome Rebecca you have three minutes please state
187your name for a record and by you when you're ready my name is Rebecca Cen APC chair for Rula German Emer school I come before you again to request that lakehood Elementary be repurposed to house real Kula I was very happy to see the administration recommend this very thing in your work session this afternoon as we've stated many times the lead on our commercial building expires in August the rent is no longer affordable due to Flat state funding we do not have time to wait and see if the legislature will increase State funding one-time funding will not get us out of this urgent need for a permanent facility we are steadily draining our rollover fund and cutting program resources to maintain the level of education and services our students deserve we are uniquely positioned to
188move into lakehood for several reasons classrooms tonight you have heard many rasula students and parents and staff speak about square footage of the building I'm going to speak about classrooms due to our immersion model our program alloc allocates classrooms differently than neighborhood we are operating out of 25 classrooms which meet our basic instructional needs Lake hood has 32 classrooms which would allow us additional space to hold specialized small group instruction and testing among other beneficial activity facility the building would require no structural or other modifications we are move and ready with no need to remodel there are benefits to ASD and our future families and staff if we move into late Hood Rula would take over the operation and maintenance cost for the building which reduces costs for the district this would help decrease the
189large budget shortfall the district is facing Rula would finally have a permanent home in our 17 years of existence we have moved at least four times being housed in an ASC building would help to ensure our long-term sustainability it would provide dependability to families of our location for their many years with the program for these reasons and more I implore you to repurpose lak hood for r at your February meeting 484 students their families and our staff are waiting on your decision I also want to end by thanking all the real Cula staff teachers parents students that came tonight in support in the audience and they gave public testimony and many gave written testimony as well I thank them thank you for your testimony and welcome Erin you have three minutes please state your name
190for the record and makeing when you're ready yeah my name is Aaron mofin good evening folks thank you for giving me the time fing in with others and asking the board to consider reassigning the former lakeood Elementary facility to real Cula by definition the ASD right right sizing initiative is one of efficiency and working to respond to pressing needs and changing Community Dynamics I can assure you that the facility needs for reala are very pressing here stra the other staff teachers and volunteers run an exceptional program students consistently surpass Benchmark goals even though 50% of their instruction time is in English and the other 50 in German as many of you know from its very beginning using relocatable buildings in a parking lot Roa has provided exemplary education with limited resources however at this point
191that ability is reaching its Breaking Point current facility lease costs are no longer sustainable and to make it thus far Roa savings fund has been almost depleted continuing on this track will yield an increased class size as well as other Cuts while that is not unique to RKA what is unique is that there's a simple fix that benefits both in school district as well as RKA again I would like to ask the board to join others in the AF Administration strongly consider assigning the lak hood building to RKA this would allow for growing the program even further lesting restrain on the ASD budget and provide an excellent neighbor and Community member to build a vacancy left in the west Anish neighborhood thank you thank you for your testimony our next two speakers are Caitlyn wolf
192and Elizabeth Robertson welcome please state your name for the record you have three minutes and can be when you're ready goodin my name is uh Elizabeth Robertson um good evening board members and head Dr brand um I would like to speak to you today I have been teaching at real Cula since the days we opened I have been through all of the moves I have already emailed you about what we've lived with with buildings fully furnished with mice and things like that but through all of this we have persevered and we have provided an excellent learning opportunity for students we consistently score higher in English language arts and in mathematics and surprisingly in science significantly higher and it's taught in German and so with the Latin based uh science words that really floors me that
193we score that High um in addition to that we have provided a really strong Community with many many people taking part with our activities Chris kendle Mark and we have the um St Martin's tag fashing all these great German cultural activities the other thing that we've had great success with that people haven't spoken to is we have a long-term exchange with uh partner schools in Fula and frankurt Germany so our students and seventh and eth grade apply for a program and they go and attend a regular German gymnasium that's their top 40% students and they go for two weeks and they hold their own in fact the CH their teachers come to me and say we don't know how you do this because they speak German that fluently and that well and so we would
194love to have a building we didn't move into the building we have because we thought we'd have 10 years of flat funding and not be able to afford it but we can't afford it and so we really do urgently need you to give us Lake Hood repurpose Lake hood for us because otherwise we're looking at serious Cuts we've already spent a year with no night janitor where I spend my afternoons after the kids leave sweeping the floors helping take out garbages as does my principal and my our associate principal the children help vacuum um we've done very a lot with very little and for us to continue a sustainable program we need a bigger building with more room and we need something where we're not paying so much money and rent it would be the
195best use of your resources you were not paying for upkeep on a building that could be very expensive and you could let our program grow and continue with this great success so I really hope that you will help us find a forever home and give us like hood for our next occupation our next place to live thank you thank you for your testimony our next two speakers are Paul brelis and Wendy Mo okay you have three minutes you can begin when you're already and pleasee state your name to the record good evening uh my name is Paul brues I am a uh father of a first grader Ed Eis at Brer schoola and if you're like me you learned a lot about the school I had no idea that the musical space was in such
196Dire Straits and the kids had a did a wonderful job of advocating for their school I want to say as a as a father rivo school is a place that I never heard of until my wife mentioned it uh I have no connections to Germany but my wife in Eddie's uh grandfather uh lived there as he his grandfather was uh a general in the Air Force and stationed over there and she went to high school and learned the German language and then afterwards went back as a service missionary and uh serving the communities in East and West Germany it's been a wonderful experience though to get to be a part of the community at Roa and see the students and the culture and the excitement and the strong uni Unique Kind of um feeling there
197my son is an energetic little first grader and it's a place where he can express himself and be himself and is supported and he's been able to uh you know do well in math Express himself in art uh explore himself with music music and uh also participate in the extracurricular activities uh after school and as a resident of West inridge uh I live right across the street uh from lakehood elementary it's a beautiful Community um with paved sidewalks and school and you know public buses uh for transportation needs and uh just just a Wonder kind wonderful area so I just want to say thank you for your service on the board and this for the community and for listening who are you know advocating for the for the school thank you thank you for your
198testimony our next two speakers are Laura mcnown and Eric Vorhees welcome have you have three minutes please sign me for the record and begin with you're ready my name is Laura MCN feeling the German Vibe tonight but I'm still breathing nunaka Valley air um through and through so I would like to speak with you about the next steps in the process of repurposing nunaka Valley into a charter and the transition of our students families and staff first of all I want to inform you that the Northeast Community Council is gathering Comm Community input um through an online survey on the repurposing of nunaka Valley Elementary the questionnaire aims to find out what school and program qualities are important to the community to support you in making the best decision possible to choose the right program
199for NAA the survey is still ongoing and final results will be shared with you in the upcoming weeks before the final vote on February 18th if you are interested in taking a look at the survey I'm happy to share the link with you via email knowing that the data is not final yet I still want to share with you one program quality that currently stands out with an overwhelming amount of support and that is priority enrollment for neighborhood students um on a personal note the priority enr neighborhood enrollment is an important factor for me as well I'm a parent of nunaka of a nunaka student and a nunaka valley resident and I feel like we've been robbed our walkable neighborhood school a school that was a big reason for why I wanted to raise my
200family at the nunaka valley neighborhood to do right by us affected families I'm hopeful you consider giving neighborhood kids around nunaka Valley this opportunity um I think there's a lot of positive effects to the neighborhood priority enrollment such has potentially reduced traffic since students might be walking also a lot of community buyin um from the neighborhood which is important um and I guess um I would think that there is also a lot more volunteer um opportunities also um as a teacher at nunaka I had a recent conversation with an anxious parent at the school whose kids attend the school with a Zone exemption um she made me aware that these kids need to be brought up to your attention specific specifically when dividing up students into the two schools Chester Valley and Russian Jack Park
201it's important to give students who are currently in nunaka with a Zone exemption the option to follow their classmates after all these students are also part of the nunaka valley family they've been there for many years and they should have the right to be part of a gentle transition into the two receiving schools just like all the other kids do um concerning the transition of moving out of the current building nunaka staff is eager to get guidance on the logistic and the time frame of the move as soon as possible please keep in mind that the teachers move um on into various career path after this school year so a one-sized fits-all pack up and go plan may not be applicable a big concern to me is when should the packing process start um so
202to not interrupt ongoing instruction at the end of the school year um why shouldn't we engage the community as a thought um there could be some volunteer thank you for your testimony our last speaker tonight is Paul gers um there's Paul all right welcome you have three minutes please state your name for the record and begin when you're ready uh my name is poers um I don't have any more facts and figures for you guys I'm just here to let you know that world CA means the world to us and we'd greatly appreciate it if you uh helped us move to a sizable building and help the sustainability of the organization I'd like my second daughter to have the same opportunities that my first daughter has um and i' like Herta continue to have the
203same thank you so much for being here thank you for uh allowing assistance and thank you for your testimony that concludes the individuals who have signed up to testify tonight's meeting I thank you for everyone for making time to do so next on our agenda is item i1 superintendent update Dr Bryant the floor is yours thank you Mr chair uh so this is our first board meeting of the new year so first off Happy New Year to everyone here um in the room tonight uh just a few things that I'm focused on one of which would be our legislative session which gabbled in today um and I've been collaborating with various stakeholder groups Statewide um to uh really Advance as's legislative priorities which would be the the BSA our transportation funding and restarting that conversation
204on bond debt reimbursement but within parallel we're doing a couple things so one uh that the board is very well aware of which would be the development of our budget for the upcoming year and I just want to manage the community's expectations that as we know we always go through the cycle of having to prepare a budget based off of known revenues and we won't know what those revenues may be until between sometime between now and July but most likely much closer to July than now so that means that when the when we unveil that initial budget proposal um which I intend to do the first meeting in February as a non-action item those cuts are going to be very very deep when we're talking about a structural deficit of the magnitude of $100 million
205there's no way to not impact aspects of our core Mission which is to educate students so our team has been going line by line to reduce spending in as many non-classroom categories as possible but I want to be very clear that the nature and magnitude of the structural deficit is going to put us in a very dark place when we see that initial budget as I shared with the board uh last week I've directed the team to put thought into other scenarios too the legislature has come to the table with funding in past years usually it's one time and uh very usually we don't know what that amount will be which makes it very difficult to make decisions around funding recurring costs such as staffs but we'll uh give it a go um for various
206scenarios so that the board can understand what things could look like going into the the next fiscal year so I just wanted to put that out there the budget is coming uh we're getting closer to February it will be a very dark p picture and I certainly hope uh that there is a pleasant surprise coming from Juno but that that remains to be seen uh and then uh you know lastly I just want to uh address one of the elephants in the room which would be we had uh a federal Administration change yesterday and I know we're getting emails and we'll probably hear from some community members about how uh changes specifically at the executive order level could impact operations within ASD and the answer is I don't have enough update to share tonight and
207because I need to do my due diligence to make sure the ASD complies with local state and federal law as well as relevant case laws that impact a number of things that we do as an organization so uh thank you for your patience as I do my due diligence to ensure that ASD is committed to making sure that our schools are vibrant and safe places to be for all students because that is our mission at the end of the day so again thank you for your patience I will not have an update tonight that concludes my remarks thank you Dr Brian other questions for the superintendent before we move on member Donley thank you Mr President um Dr Brian I've brought this up before when the board connects um there's some sort of default there
208that identifies um reports and sections that should be clearly public information as private and and I I I would really like to see that practice discontinued because when I get a memorandum and it's labeled private um I I try to follow the board's rules about confidentiality but it it implies something that's not legal even I mean those are open records unless there's a specific reason for them to be private it shouldn't be identified as private on on the board connects thank you member dley I've attempted to explain this in the past but I think we're essentially talking about a technological feature of bordo you're correct that anything um of the nature that we're discussing is a public record so we are in compliance with the open records act as it relates to Alaska we can
209talk more about norms and protocols and expectations perhaps at are a Saturday Retreat it would be prudent yeah I I just I wouldn't want to you know I mean it's an important issue to separate things that are confidential that the board members shouldn't discuss from the things that are public and I think it's it's very problematic that these things are laal private um I also wanted to follow up on the question I brought up about a month ago about Algebra 2 classes not having textbooks um you were going to look into that and I just wondered what what you identified because I'm very concerned about the classrooms continuing not to have textbooks yeah thank you member Donley I I believe when this was brought up in December we took urgent action I believe the next
210day we deployed consumable Algebra 2 materials to the schools I'd like like to ask a member of the team to follow up with you if there's a specific instance of that not being made um but to my understanding that has been resolved so I'll we'll talk to you about that offline either today or tomorrow there other questions for the superintendent before we move on hearing and seeing none we'll move on to a Schoolboard comments um we will start with on my left with member Higgins floor is yours thank you I I want to start by expressing my appreciation for how many people turned out um uh and the comments that were made in regards to schools being you know repurposed uh and the Char schools because what I heard uh which wasn't as strong in
211the in the work session was the impact on the kids I mean not having a counselor not having um uh other events like that not having things in the school not focused on the reserves not focused on the cost of the school but how that impacts directly the children because that's really what we're all about and and it it really filled in a gap for me uh with some of those comments and um I always enjoy when we've got lots of kids testifying as well they got to make sure they include that in their resume it goes a long way uh particularly when they're trying to go to go to colleges when you have lots of community activities that helps but I I really do appreciate the the the comments I think they were addressing
212the impact in the classroom in the school and um and how that might impact outcomes for kids and that's really what our decisions is going to have to be focused on it's going to be an interesting process uh that we want to do but I am uh so glad that the board itself views that um all kids regardless whether it's in a regular school and optional programs or a charter school is our responsibility safety for those kids in buildings is important giving them the access to in uh to the same types of facilities that's something the board I feel like really cares for and I know I care for passionately so that's important uh so I appreciate that and I also uh will comment and appreciate is got a lot of unknowns that's going to
213come on from the federal level I'm glad that the superintendent raised that because there's a lot of comments and questions going on we just have to wait and see what happens before we react to it uh but it is going to be a challenging time for us between the state funding the federal programs and support what they're trying to accomplish uh so it's it's definitely going to be a an opportunity time on the board and within the district and um just we're going to play it the best we can and feedback from the public is always appreciated thank you member Higgins member Donal the floor is yours thank you Mr President I I brought this up about a year ago but I I I wanted to talk about it a little bit again um um
214you know this board has adopted priorities and I think they're good priorities we've really tried to and our three top priorities of course are English art language arts U mathematics and um life preparedness and I agree with that and it's hard to get everything done and you have to have priorities and I think those are the right three priorities for this board but one of my biggest regrets of the last seven years is our inability to also prioritize the teaching of civics in government and it's so repetitive over the last year to hear people talking about protecting our democracy referring to United States as a democracy and it really happened a lot this week uh with the events in Washington DC and it just really amazes me that people who should know better are forgetting
215that this nation is not a democracy it's a constitutional republic and in a republic that people typically do not make um most of the decisions rather they elect the people who make the decisions and history is very convincing that pure democracies fail uh once the majority figures they can get whatever they want they take take things away from minorities um and in this country that's not possible because we have constitutional Protections in our Republic so minority rights are protected in our constitutional republic where they're not protected in a pure democracy and I think that's really important and so I just want to you know encourage the members of the public and all our officials to remember that this is not a democracy for very good reasons and I stand with our Founders that consider considering
216the Alternatives the constitutional republic that protects the rights of minorities and individuals is the best form of government and what can de devolve into mob rule of a pure democracy is not the best in the best interest of this nation um I wanted also to mention that back in 2023 I submitted a memo to uh uh to the board to adopt a new board policy something the board's never voted on but does currently appear in uh guidelines that were adopted by the administration several years ago uh regarding um parental notification of gender and name changes by students and at that time I was advised that by the board and the administration wanted to wait until pending by the administration guidelines were published and those Biden uh White House Administration uh guidelines uh uh were put
217out about a year ago and they were blocked here in Alaska by court order um and now a few weeks ago they were completely overturned by federal courts Nationwide so they're gone they're dead um and so I would really really appreciate support of this board to consider the resolution and the memorandum that I submitted back in 2023 that would shift overrule our existing administrative guidelines that have never been voted on by this board um to make it clear that notification of parents is the presumption is is the default position the administration is going to take uh on all issues uh including the ones that may not appear that way in these administrative guidelines um I I know it takes two votes or a co-sponsor to get things before the board I've been waiting on this
218for more than a year and I really think it's it's a serious enough question of parental rights that it be addressed in a board policy and not be left to a mere administrative guideline um it's the board adops the board adopts policy the administration adopts regulations administrative regulations based on that policy the existing controls in this district for neither one of those over this issue of parental rights they're down even below an administrative regulation but called an administrative guideline um I this is a serious enough question I think parental rights deserves a vote of this board of what should be the correct policy for this District when it comes to notifying parents of these very significant matters thank you thank you member Donley we'll go to my right member Wilson I spent um some time
219at uh Wendler the had a ja in a day Junior Achievement it was uh it was amazing they had a um in in some cases two volunteers from the community who um went into a classroom to teach the Junior Achievement curriculum financial literacy curriculum um taking over the the entire school which was amazing the the volunteers came from um different businesses from the community um and and just being able to provide enough bu enough volunteers from um our community businesses to to take over an entire school again some some of them had two Volunteers in the classroom was amazing um the the kids really seem to enjoy it I popped into a couple of classrooms the the the volunteers really enjoyed it I I heard from a few of them as they were leaving saying
220I absolutely greatly appreciate all of the the work that uh our our teachers do do every day to educate our kids it's it's a tremendous amount of work so it was a great experience both for for the students to hear from our our community leaders and Business Leaders and our Business Leaders to be in the in the schools and um step into a teacher role for for a day so thank you to those volunteers thank you to Junior Achievement for for coordinating um ja and a day for that school and and the many um other schools that they coordinate those events for also wanted to share that the AL alternative schools Expo is on uh Saturday February 8th and so you can look on the ASD website for details about that and and there was
221one thing that Dr Brian if you would just take a a minute and share about the US Secretary of Education Miguel gona going to serve a visit service High I know you didn't you didn't mention that but I would love for you to talk a little bit about that sure Mr shy you permit that me to address uh so yeah I I would love to talk about it so the irony is that uh he chose to come to Alaska on our ice day as we know so that through AR wrench into the plans um but he was very uh excited to see an AS school and I'm very thankful um to principal aam and the service team who live pretty close to the school and they were able to safely uh get to the school
222as well as a few students and family members to greet the secretary and he was just um really just uh loving uh that we offer programs like the um the service bi medical uh program which is a CTE program of study um that has made such a difference in the lives of our students as well as the other great programs at service um I was actually iced in to be frank with you so um my entire neighborhood Road was covered and ice so I couldn't get to service myself but the secretary was gracious gracious enough um to offer me a few minutes of his time just to debrief on his visit and he was just very thankful it was a first visit to Alaska and we made a fantastic impression thank you thank you member
223Wilson member lesons FL is yours um I wanted to share with the board that I took the liberty of cancelling the finance committee meeting which is scheduled which has been scheduled for the 30th uh and that's to allow our staff just more time to prepare for the meeting on the 4th I don't know that there's anything that's yet sharable about the budget and it just seemed like a better use of their time um to focus on the the bigger task at hand which is getting getting documents prepared in time uh to be posted publicly I assume sometime Saturday is about 72 hours before um so uh anyways I wanted to put that out there um I feel like I've brought this up before I would request that the board president and administration consider adding additional
224meetings uh between February 4th and February 18th um in order for uh our board to um receive the volume of testimony that I expect we will receive about the budget given the scale of the very deep cuts the the very dark picture that you you know the words that you just chose um I think we're going to have hours and hours of testimony I really valued the additional listening session we ended up with last February um so I don't know whether that looks like another regularly scheduled Tuesday meeting Saturday options um so I I guess my request is let's let's see if we can find some more time um and options for the public to to chime in where the board can just receive public testimony um I also wanted to share with the board
225that uh I took the liberty of um relaying um memorandum 079 which received a unanimous 7 to0 vote um at our last meeting uh this is regarding the joint resolution um along with the assembly side of things AR 20 25-16 um with both the with the chairs of both the House and Senate uh education committee so they have those documents um uh on hand and uh I received responses from those chairs indicating they will be including our joint resolutions um into any future Bill packets regarding the DSA El subject took the liberty of just watching the recording of the assembly talking about the joint resolution and it passed uh 11 to zero with one assembly member um unavailable at the time of the vote and um assembly members uh spoke very highly of it the
226sentiment behind it and their desire to have a strong public school system so I really appreciate that that uh collaboration and the willingness of the the chairs of House and Senate um education committees to um sort of have to receive that information um and I will say that I I've checked AK l.gov and it looks like those committee meetings are going to be held Mondays Wednesdays and Fridays 8 am on the house side and 3:30 p.m. on the Senate side so just something to pencil into calendars and keep a breast of what will be happening in Juno um that's all for now thank you member listens member Bing thank you Mr chair just a couple of uh um reminders really uh for just so that people know that if you you can live stream our
227you know our our meetings but there's also a recap that our Communications Department puts out an internal um recap for staff to just kind of track our meetings so you can see everything we talked about everything we worked on in our work sessions and then if you go to our on the to the website under School Board uh you can find the recap there as well I find that extremely helpful especially with our community councils and uh people who want to know um almost Verbatim what happened at the meeting but they didn't have time to attend so we have we have uh uh expanded that uh opportunity The Balancing Act is still online I I hear what member lence is saying about the the making more time but we've also given people more opportunities to
228engage in the in the budget process uh so um using that tool um and maybe somebody's out there can come up with a magical way to balance its budget but it's going to be tough and so we do want to hear the input um but people can use that tool to give us some feedback you can write to the board uh you can testify before the board um and really you can write us at any time uh or or even phone calls um I did want to just mention the upcoming um Betty Davis Healthy Families Community Summit uh that event will take place on uh Saturday uh the 8th of February at East High School we had the opportunity to meet with the student Advisory Board um last week was it last week yeah last
229week it was last week and we just basically shared some volunteer opportunity uh there is a concert uh that is a a a family focused concert uh by a a outstanding motivational speaker uh actually Entertainer so that information is also on our website uh because the district is a partner and I think those are all the oh and I think our Retreat is this weekend um Mr chair I might have to be remote for that but I will be in attendance thank you thank you member Bellamy we'll move on to president Hollman Who's online FL is yours no real comments for me I just can't wait to get back to ankorage where it's warm and sunny thank you member Hollman um for my comments I just want to Echo appreciation for those who T took
230time to come out and testify and looking forward to a retreat on Saturday with that said that concludes board member comments I'm absent any other business to attend to I would entertain a motion to adjourn move to adjourn second made seconded seeing no opposition we are adjourn thank you everyone re