001recording in progress e e off e turn red just the same right here and uh let good afternoon everyone today is Tuesday January 21 at uh 4 o'clock pm we're here in the um YY Schoolboard boardroom for a work session of the anchor School District School Board um present in the boardroom is member myself your chair Carl Jacobs member dor Wilson member Kelly lesons member margle Bellamy present online is member Andy Hollman and we will announce when member Higgins joins us we've conducted our call to order and roll call and we'll move to discussion B1 facility repurposing plan Dr Bryant and team the floor is yours thank you Mr chair so the purpose of today's work session is to discuss the repurposing plans for two facilities um which would be lakeood H in unaka Valley
002uh a final recommendation for me to the board will be delivered by our first meeting in February as an non-action item but before we get there the purpose of today is really to walk the board through our various options to walk through pros and cons um we'll present some scenarios for which we've done quite a bit of analyses and there may be others that board members would like to discuss so we're happy to do that I'd like to get your feedback before I prepare that final recommendation within the next few weeks um and again with any decision point that we make there are pros and cons so really the point of today is for you to provide me and the team with some feedback as we prepare that recommendation so uh Mr Anderson will walk
003us through a few slides okay good evening is this working oh I can so the first thing I wanted to do was refresh everyone's memory um went through the original board memo 07 three um America helped me go through the Amendments make sure I captured it just to make sure after 10 Amendments set the floor that everyone's still tracking um what the final uh decisions were and then we'll be talking at least on one of them um perhaps more about possibly some unintended consequences and um just try to get the board's feedback so we can move forward so everyone knows that the board board memo after all of the Amendments um did approve closure for lakeh Hood in new NAA Valley and then there was um the very first amendment included um all those you
004can see on the screen um we'll start working on uh Wonder Park totem lot um those kind of things over the next couple months and uh build up a plan that um meets the intent of those as well as looking at piloting some type of Transportation Sy system that may be able to um allow students to leave their boundar schools and go to schools with special programs and or Charter Schools um and naturally of course we'll do an after action review this summer after we've made that transition of uh all the school equipment and curriculum to the gaining schools um one October might be a um a little bit early if we're trying to get feedback from all the principles as to how they got integrated into their new schools um but we certainly will
005have something um then of course there was the amendment that was split out from Amendment one um having tutor monor become a case six next year as you look at these one of them focused on uh making sure that we have one more school for closure or repurposing at least and then it was very specific in that we were to not exclude special programs like immersion and optional and uh to ensure that we look at those programs as well and of course secondary schools so as we looked at amendment number four we we pretty much looking at the reauthorization or the authorization to close unaka Valley in Lake H um and being able to revisit those um if the legislature and govern corrected funding shortfalls prior to the second board meeting in February we've been
006looking at what we need to get done um in order to close the schools and there's been kind of a uh some families at these schools thinking that the decision really hasn't been made yet um from comments from different people um and so we wanted to make sure uh that there's some things that really are causing some consternation that we're working through but um because of that particular Amendment it's causing some disruption in our processes now first one is usually we would and we have them all ready right now to send out to those students families about where they would be going next year we' be doing that this week because the lottery opens on February 1st and if like we would want to give all of those families the opportunity that if they didn't
007like which school their students be going to that they could actually access that Lottery on February 1st and then we have a lot of early Staffing decisions we' have already gone out to Nuna Valley and lakehood our HR department has been working with those staffs because we need to get those um early Staffing um things done earlier than the regular Staffing and and then towards the end of February is when that actually occurs so we're really looking at making sure that that particular Amendment if it is what the will of the board is going to do um if we come back by the second meeting kind of need a little guidance as to should we go ahead and move forward because at this point we are really wanting to move forward so that we because
008it it just backs things up way too much um and the next one and also if you talk to uh the principles at the schools are a number of Staff who believe that um really the final decision won't be made until the end of February and it's it's certainly i' I'd really like to hold and discuss here because the rest of this brief is kind of pointless if we're not going to move forward or have any discussions and legitimately pulled out until the end of February to see if the governor and the legislature can come up with um a solution for funding our schools member L all right I've successfully tried out the new system um just a point of clarification you mentioned the lottery um which is a factor it opens on February 1st
009when I just checked it doesn't close then it looks like it closes March 20th is that correct so there's a bit of a window for families consider the lottery guess I just want to know if I'm correct enough that's that's correct uh member Bing well Mr Anderson if I'm understanding correctly do you want to know whether we go forward with the discussion or do we just wait is that the question yes because we'd like to get a board member in front of the board on the first meeting in February as non-action based off comments tonight so we can make decisions on the repurposing plan on the second meeting in February so we can go ahead and start getting all of the synchronization the moving pieces everything from field trips to swag bags for kids matching
010up friend groups all those kind of things really start now and starting to pull it together and I unfortunately technically if we follow specifically this amendment we wouldn't we wouldn't be able to submit a memo on the first meeting in February because we would have to wait until after the second meeting in February to see what happens before we can even start the process moving forward and it and it really puts us a a couple months behind or certainly a month behind I think so I guess my question is is it easier not easy or none of this is easy but it does it make sense for us to I mean to me it makes sense for us to continue uh and to uh because if we do get money then we it's how hard
011of that to go back and put things in place well once you do early Staffing and now principls have worked and they have staff that were at a closing school and now they're expecting them and the staff members are expecting them to go to their schools and then at the end of February hypothetically um there's no early Staffing if you're really going to wait it I I'm sure the intent of This was um I think it unintended consequences are are impacting our ability to move forward and part of that was the discussions with staff on taking care of the staff of closing schools early before you do the main Staffing events um and and as long as I have at least four board members who are okay with expecting a board memo on the first
012week of February with the repurpose plan knowing that a decision's going to be made at the second meeting then at least we're moving forward and we can have a lot of things in place otherwise you could look at this amendment and say don't do anything and wait until the end of February and we'll just see if you know by a incredibly large surprise we got a $2,000 BSA increase I'm wondering if uh Marty would have any insight as far as the Staffing piece if we were to go through with the February stuff and then go back see if I can pass my first test with the new microphone um like Sven said we were out in the schools last week with talent management team surveying the staff starting to collect their interest in where they'd
013like to go we won't make any moves um to place those folks until February 20th right now is our proposed date for doing so that's a Preferred Staffing timelines before any other displacements would will be notified or placed um but we wanted to make sure and take care of those staff if we are indeed closing those schools um if we are moving away from that plan then um the next sort of Waypoint on the Staffing timeline is right before spring break when would be considering General displacements and so um it would basically push any decisions into that sort of General Pool for consideration at that point other board discussion on the timeline being proposed by Administration specifically to have a memorandum related to repurposing on our agenda as a non-action item at our first meeting
014in February or is there um if there any board members who object to the proposal for the timeline that would be a time to mention it member Higgins I see a question in your face go ahead yeah let me make sure I understand how to do this right uh um The Proposal was basically we would act on it the second in February but if the legislature after that point in time decides to approve the you know couple, BSA type increase that we at that point we won't reverse it because we get kind of sent a message out to the community and to the legislature too that you have a deadline if you if you want to save the schools provide the fun money and be upfront with it and you want to you want to
015say I don't have a problem with saying the sank meeting in February will make a decision contingent on that but then you want to basically pull back that commitment is or we just saying let's commit let's go ahead and make a plan say this is what we're going to do contingent on and then we can reverse it if that happens yes that's that's correct what we what we want is to move forward as if those schools are closing put all the systems in place if a 52-year Miracle occurs in the state of Alaska provides the largest funding they've ever provided um then the board by this amendment could reverse and do a stop on all actions but to not do anything um at this point will put us behind especially when you're looking at the
016focus on taking care of kids we did a lot of stuff very early on for the Abbot Loop kids to make sure that everything was going to be in place for them to go to their new schools we certainly didn't wait until March to start moving things forward we started actually now um so I'll put myself in the speaking queue and then I'll go back to member lessons um so as the one of the drafters of the amendment that we're discussing um I'll say that one I want to highlight that this amendment didn't just um call for the legislature to address education funding but also ask for the legislature to um Implement a a long sustainable long-term fiscal plan as we are already hearing um although folks are just now getting to their offices and
017after being sworn in um that the state um lacks adequate Revenue um to effectuate reasonable policy positions which not only is um adequate education funding but also funding um to pay state employees um which is why a salary study that indicates that um they are due significant raises hasn't been released by our Administration um um there are a number of needs facing our state and we can't afford any of them and so um the an ask for Education funding and which was why this amendment was very important to me should be paired with asking our state to get their fiscal house in order um and so um I think that was kind of the underlying thought and I was grateful the board approved it um with that said I I don't see um that we
018can assume um bipartisan cooperation given recent legislative performance and so I I think we should ER on the side of needing to go forward with this plan so for me the time on being proposed is appropriate with that said we'll go to member lessons and thank you for that um maybe this is a procedural comment or question would it' be procedurally incorrect for the administration to move forward with preparing the memo for the board's consideration non-action the first meeting of February you know ready to be action in the second meeting in febru and if that 52-year Miracle were to occur there would be a memo that was ready that the board could vote against or ignore or redact from the agenda itself but we we wouldn't be here tonight if we didn't think that procedurally
019it was okay to move forward what we wanted was board approval for us to do so um so you're not surprised next Tuesday or two weeks from from today when you see the non-action memo um there's so many operational reasons why we need to move and and if amazing things happen and the truth changes then the truth changes I'll also add just for my purpos in that if if action which aligns with this amendment um actually generates Steam and and bears fruit this board will know well before that process comes to an end and we can um generate additional meetings to discuss further and audible if need be um with that said is there other discussion or there board members who object to the timeline being proposed which would um absent objection we can move
020on with the rest of the presentation we'll go to member Wilson and member m so I have no objection just just so I can clarify that I do support the opportunity for the administration to have that extra time to plan I think it's important to to make sure that that you have that time to plan and and give our our families and our staff in particular the opportunity to know what their their choices are what their opportunities are coming up so I would support um the plan moving forward and member B yes thank you I I do support moving forward we owe it to our kids and our family to move forward and uh do what we can when we know that we can we can affect some kind of change uh but we can't
021keep our kids and families in limbo they we need to move forward I think that's why AB luk uh was so successful and kids felt so welcomed and warmed is because we gave staff and family time to make the shift and uh if that's not if that's I mean I I don't have a CAL ball and I'm I'm optimistic uh but but at the same time a $2,000 BSA you're not we're not going to get a miracle we're not going to get a miracle so I think we owe it to our family so my vote would be we're not voting but my I would support moving forward thank you member B any other comments before we move on M yeah just when we get the recommendations we'll get recommendations of Who You proposing go into
022the facility but you're also going to propose where the existing kids are going to go to and and give us a estimate of the cost Associated because I mean we heard that the part with you know um tonning in elementary and other issues what how the sbbs program will go what we have to do in order to make that work good because that was so controversial for them and and I'm concerned that whatever location we're going with I want to make sure that that's that people are aware of that they get a chance to provide some feedback because it's going to impact their neighborhood schools too sure so in terms of where the students are going to go it'll be in accordance with the briefings we gave with the exception of spbs because it's such
023a small number that you could easily start identifying individuals and we wouldn't do that so we'll take care of the spbs kids and um we'll figure a way to brief it without violating um once you get down to five it could be really easy to identify somebody and we we don't do that um but we will make sure that they have a school they're going to but we wouldn't publicly probably talk about a group that's small in the original memo for the closure it actually lays out where the kids from lak Hood go and where the kids from nunaka Valley go so we have the list of those kids um then there's a list of kids that live out of the zone for each of those schools and so that's some of the work we
024have to do and that's why we want to get them into the lottery stuff early on so that's part of the stuff like probably by the end of the week we'd be looking at sending out letters to families to let them know where their kids will be pointed towards or if we need to have more conversations with them because they're out as that's really what drove tonight's meeting was we do plan on sending letters to all the families by the end of this week letting them know where their child is um by School boundary going to be reassigned and what their other options are we didn't want to wait a month month and a half to do that um so families will know this weekend where their children are slated to go so if I
025understand correctly you don't think we're going to run into a cost issue of of redoing a school to be able to accommodate those children uh that's a factor that the board should be aware of no I do not I mean it's Elementary to Elementary um when it comes to Charter Schools moving in um that would be different that would be individually working with each Charter School principal to see what their short and long-term needs might be but not Elementary to Elementary it's really moving curriculum desk says needed cafeteria Furniture um and the the first choice is the gaining schools for the losing School Furniture um it's really a transportation um event yeah I don't see any benefit to delaying the process did not get it done in selection by in February the second meeting because
026that all we're doing is unnecessarily delaying it and if we do get the issue then we can always use the Eraser at the other end of the pencil and we'll figure out what we do then but that would be a surprise at that point that no one's expecting I I do want to add on Mr Higgins that with there is a there is some small costs to the move because we're just the transitional pieces we need to have money for a bus to be able to bring the kids from one school to the other to do tours we need to be able to do those activities h a uh eat family evening events and stuff so it's very minimal amount of money so it isn't zero but but it isn't we're rebuilding a school yeah
027just the feedback I got at one time was because of safety concerns and other things they had to do it was more substantial than that and that's why I was asking that question thank you member Higgins um not seeing any other discussion Mr Anderson Mr gust it sounds like you guys have consensus from the board and please proceed with the rest of presentation thank you I think everyone's familiar with Amendment six and seven um there are a few more that didn't pass and of course we do plan on coming back prior to 15 April uh to discuss the merits of inl view being a k school so um president Hollman asked to make sure that I provided a good understanding of what are all of the programs Andor schools in the facility in the district
028that are using lease facilities that really are looking for new homes or we could provide them a new home out of a least site merely to save money and better utilize um the capacity we have left in our schools so you can see at the very top the ACT program um which we'll talk about later uh that least does expire at the end of June we need to move them somewhere regardless um for both of those least um costs and so for that $400,000 roughly um we'll either look at potentially um moving them well somewhere in a district owned facility or a district other District lease facility and we'll go into a little bit of depth um also you I think everyone is aware that rula's lease which is the most expensive in the district
029um among the charter schools it expires at the end of August which really they either need to renew it or we need to move them before the beginning of the school year and then I I I really did want to point out because I don't know that everyone realizes that one of the reasons you you would move a charter school into a district owned facility is our schools are custombuilt and designed to support education whereas the vast majority of Le spaces are not and lunchroom rooms is just one of them so we don't have other than um Charter Schools operating in District facilities they don't have lunch programs so when we talk about Equity it really is bigger than Transportation um some of those schools have a school store where they Mark the price up
030a little bit where people can buy stuff from just to be able to provide some snacks to those who otherwise would qualify for free and reduced lunches but there are no lunches available for them we've tried numerous times to try to figure out how we could provide hot meals but the national school lunch program says you either do it for all or none so there was no way other than incurring debt to the general fund of providing hot meals for um families in economic need so as we look to moving charter schools into our facilities all of them have lunchrooms we may have to modify a cafeteria a little bit add some new equipment uh but for the most part that probably gets after Equity a lot quicker and gives other people who otherwise wouldn't
031be able to go to one of these programs an option to go there especially if they're looking at H how does my kid eat during the day um so I didn't want to point that out and you'll see both act and Ric aou in follow-up slides so these are the fund balances and the enrollments for each of our charter schools and I just wanted to point out that um the impact that that the district has had on the lack of a BSA adjustment in inflation proof funding has over time really impacted our Charter Schools um as well as it has the district they're not immune from inflationary drivers anccs when we first had them sign the contract to go into Abbot Loop part of that contract was putting the money into a school fund where
032they could start building up um their fund balance but when you look at Highland Academy they they really their fund balance is is extremely low and really on on none of them is it an exorbitant fund balance um and I just thought it was something to think about between now and the next six weeks before decisions are made as to how we talk to I've been to three Community Council meetings in the last month or so and in all of them they asked me why would why would we put a charter school in the first thing I explained to them is that they're all our kids they're all ASD students and then I started talking to him about this um the fund balance that that quickly goes to zero if we can't get them out
033of lease facilities over the next several years or if we don't get um a significant increase in education funding and in every case there was a lot more heads nodding up and down when I was able to explain you know they're all ASD students every one of them and these buildings are ASD buildings or at least managed by ASD U but the fund balance is what Andy and I and many others have seen really go down over time with the exception of anccs since they hit East High School and then Abbott Luke so here's the revenue impact for the school closures and naturally this doesn't account for um any modifications that might be needed on those buildings depending on WE who we put there um or how we repurpose those buildings but everyone I think
034is pretty comfortable with knowing that the hold harmless Clause um really allows you to get that smaller school size equivalent in terms of revenue for the first couple years now on this the numbers are different if you're going to put that building into cold storage because we still are paying electric bills like we are in U major for the next month or two um until we finally can shut off um Power and Water to that school but if it was Charter Schools going in um then they would be taking over minor maintenance utilities all those kind of costs and so roughly as we build the budget over the next week um the preliminary budget um you know it really would be this is about just under $2 million which is not a lot but when
035you're looking at 60 plus million any $2 million you can find certainly is helpful so when we get to actually looking at the repurposing of the two buildings we did a lot of research we did a lot of looking at different programs we looked at um existing programs um and CCS we looked at wh um we looked at um different things for specific schools for Lake hood and unaka I'd like to talk about um lakeh Hood to begin with um our recommendation is for Loc shul charter school to go into lak hood and some reasons around that rulle is our largest charter school for in-person learning um in the district they don't have a declining enrollment um and they we don't anticipate a declining enrollment in their near future the school fits really well into
036that uh facility um again we like Jim said their lease expires at the end of August so it's pretty important that we have a decision for them um looking at the other options we're going to talk a little bit about wh here in a little bit but and then like anccs that's really uh needing to be closer to the east side of town with who where the kids are located and the families are located and so we really uh our our recommendation will be ruli now when we look at nunaka Valley again we looked at everything we looked at a lot of different options and we have two options that we'd like to propose for you and kind of get an idea from you which direction you all feel like would be the best that
037you would feel comfortable with the first recommendation would be Highland Academy currently Highland Academy is housed on the East end of this building um as you saw there there fund balance is quite low um they really aren't in a position where they uh can grow in the facility that they're in and another thing with Highland Academy is if Highland moved to nunaka Valley we could also fix our act program um problem where we can move the ACT program down into this facility and have them here on the facility in the ad Center the aded center is a really great spot for the ACT program because it is right on a bus line if we don't put act in this somewhere here on a bus line we would end up putting them into like three high
038schools in the area the problem with putting a kid the ACT program in three high schools is we're really looking to move those students out of the high schools that's why we have the ACT program we want to get them into the community into um really getting them out to learn those life skills if we were to move them into the high schools we would then need to purchase some vehicles in order to transport because of the ability of the bus lines um so that's one option option the second option we are putting out there is for anchored stream Academy um their current facility doesn't um include growth options for them their Charter has a growth um goal of 300 currently they're at 183 um if we were to go that route uh we would
039still need to find somewhere for the ACT program for sure the other thing that I want to back up for Academy the other thing that we're looking at is we think we would have enough space for Highland Academy and possibly Family Partnership in the facility at the end of this building Family Partnership is currently um in a lease in an in a strip mall Office Buildings over off of tutor um and their their contract their lease comes up here in a year or two right yeah a couple years so um that's we're looking at for uh for the repurposing and that we're going to be you know we're going to talk a little bit more here about these but really uh kind of wanting to get your thoughts about if these options or one there's
040any particular option that you would think would be a a better option than the other um some just kind of looking a little further down we have if you go to the next slide so R shili delay could again the lease expires at the end of the year um it has 700 $ 38,000 Pere lease and then that's expected to increase in fiscal year 26 the and on top of the 738 they pay about 85,000 in utilities so they actual cost per year for that building is already over 800,000 per year and the current facility again has no cafeteria and those students that qualify for in roduced meals we'll have meals available in the school um there's minimal renovations if that would need to take place at Lake Hood um to house reala and then
041looking at um stream Academy into nunaka Valley their current facility again doesn't supp support growth for their Charter of 300 po the current facility doesn't have no cafeteria so the students who qualify for free introduce meals would have meals available the current facility has no gym sports that it does this the new ACA Valley um campus does support outdoor and experiential education better than their current facility um we did look at even like looking at Baxter as an option for stream Academy and we're g we're kind of diving in and looking that as another option possibly as a collocation kind of thing but um in that backer would also have the sports outdoors and experiential education and the school is large enough um for their enrollment growth then you look at Island t AKA Valley
042um again we talked about their B their fund balance lowest of 270,000 to provide Financial relief for that program once again it has no cafeteria and students who qualify for free meals would have meals available the current facility has no gym the school is large enough to support enrollment growth and then it would free up space here at the end Center to consolidate the ACT program and Family Partnership another thing that we've talked about in regards to Highland and new NAA Valley it is it is actually very close to here right down the street the students that go to naaka Valley primarily live on this side of town and it is close to a bus stop and many of our students that go to Highland tech ride the city bus to get here so it
043has that option as well questions I see two questions we'll go to member lessons then over bill um I just wanted to go back a bit uh in time to the um I think it was I think it was the December 17th work session it had pictures uh these pictures of um like maps of where students live and I don't maybe this is just a administrative point of order I don't see it on this so I might got I might have things a little bit mixed up but I have a print out from the administration and it does show that certainly there's a concentration of students um there are many students going attending the Alaskan ultural Charter School on the east side but there's a there are blobs all over so could you just help
044me understand a little bit more about where our students who attend anccs right I I could expand that I could expand those Maps um there was a lot of different circles and some of the circles were as low as one student and so when you have these little circles everywhere and now you're trying to make those Maps fit in and covering 50 miles and make it fit when it's 1 in tall it does it it doesn't really provide the best possible uh view that's why we we handed um to get to make it a little clearer um we gave all the board members that big chart that showed um where students were in boundary for schools and what schools they actually attended and and it is true for alternative and Charter Schools um they're they're
045all over the map but when you look at something like anccs I think there's it's a really small number less than five so I I won't um living up near Mirror Lake in that vicinity so although it's true they stretch from Mirror Lake all the way to to um cdwood this the numbers are smaller um the farther you get away and and anccs has historically typically been on the east side um and and that's why originally we were looking at you know potentially if if Baxter would have closed that would have been a really optimal place for them as well as what what they have done in the Abbot Loop Community has picked up students who still could walk to school um and of course we'll be talking about anccs shortly a little bit more
046um but you know when you look at stream their Charter says they're an Eide school um I'd have to check anccs to see but I think if you look at that big graph we gave you you can see where all the kids came from and what school they went to it's very interesting to look at where like how many from the kassoon area go to nccs now you member lessons we would to member vamy then member so on page four I just have a claric clarifying question uh under the um facility leases so Highland currently pays ASD ASD that okay that's there a subas there are sub so if we put so we're putting if they're plan to put so we're not doing anything I guess with um wayy right now is that um I'm
047going to talk about them short are okay I'll be quiet yes thank you member you know we actually did look at lak hood for way um either way we're gonna spend a lot of money on way and that's why I want to talk about them at the end I will thank you thank you member Bell member Higgins oh I'm up okay sorry I got questions on both of them one in regards to nunaka Valley what where are we at as far as plans or anything at all with Alaska native cultural Charo school now they're currently in a facility you you were successful last time of adding that that school is going to be eliminated leveled uh here in a couple years and they have nothing and so regardless of the cost uh it it why
048W they into consideration of this as well they are they're on my last slide for today's briefing okay so they're they're not off the list we are going to talk about Alaska native yes okay then the other one is lak Hood I've talked to uh staff and parents and parents get pretty emotional both sides of the way but the issue of possibly moving Stella into lakehood and freeing up Stella because Stella is 44,000 square fet at lak Hood 61 Stella's got three uh Portables you push sixth grade in there so it's already uh uh put some issues in regards to it the number of digal optional uh classes they can have is limited I don't know whether or not parents would go for a Lynch Mob at me or not or I don't know whether
049they would worship it there's a lot of mixed views on here I'm going to be honest but I I don't see that being eliminated for consideration the optional schools charter schools are similar I mean funding is different but it does seem like that's a a potential to at least throw out there for consideration and I think it would benefit that school I think uh Rula could benefit with Stella as well uh so that would be it but that's 61,000 that's that's larger than what Stella is right now I think Stella is about 44 but I have to go look and then compare that to where U will Kula is at that's still larger than what they've got right now and it gives them a good location the only concern with that has been bus service
050but I found out there's very few actually doing the bus type thing so um and that facility would provide them an opportunity to do additional programs they haven't been able to do now because there when we added sixth grade there it makes a difference on doing it and and within that so has any thought been given to that school as well you know honestly until uh until I found out you've been over to Stellar a few times talked to the principal we had not considered it um so I know there must be some small group that's looking at moving Stellar um I think you know that that at Stellar most of those kids leave during lunch and they eat in the the restaurants and stuff near Stellar there's really nothing at Lake Hood but we
051did not do a deep analysis because we honestly aren't aware of a critical need to move stellar and I would also add on to that is we didn't push sixth grade into Stellar Stellar's Community requested us to allow six graders to go to stellar and they knew that all of the different things having a relos all that kind of stuff when they did that vote and they they came to us asking to actually increase six grade into the school so that Stellar just hasn't been on our radar um as they haven't really had issues thank you member Higgins uh member Wilson you would mention that it is in streams Charter to stay on the east side um is is it does Highland have it within their Charter to to be on any particular side of
052town or serve any community I'm going to phone anybody right now I I don't I don't know I can find out and uh we can put it in board connect this Friday I have a follow yeah um my only other question is it's currently on on the list of um regarding Highland is it would lower the balance of the their charter school would be it would provide a financial relief to move them to newa and just if you could clarify how that would provide a financial relief in in that they are currently in an ASD building thre no so Highland pays 500,000 a year a little bit over 505 to ASD for the past Andy I don't know how many years at least 10 years um ASD has picked up 75,000 of Highlands lease because
053they couldn't afford the full equal split of that lease so if they were to go to um Nuna Valley they would I mean literally be saving a little over 500,000 a year they'd still have utilities to pay for they'd St have custodial all those kind of things um but it would put them in a a a better position so for Anchorage stream because they have such a cheap not cheap a much more affordable lease at just over $300,000 and their lease includes custodial um it actually would cost them a little bit more um per year to move to na move to NAA Valley but it would be offset by the ability to go from 180 to 300 and have all of those Trail systems and outdoor areas um that go all the way up to
054Russian Jack which they don't really have that kind of Outdoor Classroom space at this time so um sure they would pay a little bit more but for what they would get out of it uh um if they really grew to 300 they would get more revenue and they would quickly overcome the fact that it costs a little more because they had to pay for custodial thank you member Wilson I'm gonna jump in with a question um which I think may be where member Wilson was headed but at least for my own Clarity purposes as well as for anyone watching um what I think I understand is it's current practice that school districts can't charge rent for a district facility in this case this the facility that Highland is using is not District facility is that
055why they're paying a lease payment it's a lease and they pay for the square footage of our overall lease so it's we're it's not a building that we're the building manager for because we're attendant as well so we're a tenant they're a tenant they pay their portion and um which is different from having an ASD building sure plotted as um a school zone and then just one final point for clarity is the lease that we have with the um the owner of this property is it with is um does Highland have a direct lease with the owner of the property or is the lease between us and Highland yeah it's it's just with us understood and and I think you'll remember last year um when we redid the lease we had we got an incredibly
056favorable um rate so we did reduce how much we were paying um certainly curbed the growth that was going to happen happen for sure I appreciate that uh member L um please correct me if I'm if my memory is wrong here when clat Elementary was proposed for potential closure a couple of years ago what I recall is that Highland there was a there was a prospect for moving Highland to clatt and one of the objections that I feel like I heard at the time was that bus service was not readily accessible for where many Highland students were and where clat is and I guess the question is what sort of bus services of if bus service is important to the Highland community what sort of bus services then are available um sort of in the
057area last time immediately when we asked Highland if they wanted to move to clatt they just said no they said it's too far away this is our area the kids are going up and down um Northern Lights to get here and in this and and they just said no it wasn't it wasn't Transportation it was this is where we live this is our school thank you member lessons other questions before we allow Administration to wrap up I think May the final portion of the presentation member dony apologies thank you um so do any other of the charter schools get um a similar lease subsidy as Highland is $75,000 not that I'm aware of is it as we've been you know we've only had aquarium in a in a school district occupied building correct for about
05820 years yeah yeah 20 plus years so it really hasn't been like a big pressing issue but it seems to me as we move more of these schools into District facilities and it's and the costs decrease fairly dramatically for some of them there ought to be some consideration to balancing out the benefit among all the charter schools that are still paying for lease themselves and I um I didn't know about the Highland 75k but that's an example of what I would think would be fair if there was some sort of balancing out for other people's costs too has the dist has the administration thought about that at all I mean if you just got one school getting it it doesn't seem doesn't seem fair and Equitable yeah and the 75,000 was generally because um if
059they vacated the space or they School ceased to exist then the district as we said is the leas is between ASD and the L or so we're on the hook for that extra ex ra 500,000 so it was an incentive for them to stay in this building thereby not uh settling the the district with an extra 500,000 in cost that someone else wasn't paying um but there is the you know in State Statute we can't legally charge like simic Aquarian who's in a district facility rent um so that's really kind of what precludes us from being able to make those adjustments like I couldn't take money from Aquarian and give it to other Charter schools because they're not uh because they have a lease so I don't know that we have the legal authority to
060kind of Shuffle those funds around between Charters that are in District facilities and not in facilities yeah that's not exactly what I was suggesting what was suggesting was if we're subsidizing one lease for 75,000 but none of the other charter schools have leases that are being in any way subsidized by the district wouldn't it be better to have a policy about that like a a set policy for dealing with that so everybody was treated equally sure and we also have the issue with real culas where they borrowed $2 million 10 years ago for their to get that facility and they still owe us another 10 years on that so they did get a benefit from the district as well um so I don't know but yeah can see probably want a policy surrounding that thank
061you member Donley are there other questions or comments before we allow Administration to finish up their presentation hearing saying none Mr Anderson anything else before you open up for questions okay so this is our last slide we have uh five minutes but we all also have two weeks so any input that the board wants to uh provide as as we're building this memo I I did want to bring up some other discussion topics though to think about um we saw how emotional to an entire Community a handful of students were when we talked about moving them into a school um I I personally and and I hope the board uh agrees as we look forward to next Fall's CIP I think it's time to do the right thing for wayy um I I plan barring
062um big push back from the board uh to have a way design renovation a multi-year during each summer to renovate that building because even as you look at elementary schools there would be a significant amount of renovation required in any of those and I I just feel like they've been pushed to the side long enough and um you know I I know Jared and and Spen feel the same way it's time to take care of wayy and so not having a facility doesn't mean that that uh we don't plan on making it a priority next fall and and of course you know the board will get to vote on on the design first then a renovation of the facility and we'll discuss that probably um on one-on ones or or in other conversations the second
063one is the last time we tried to get a fire suppression system for anccs there there weren't any biders um it wasn't a project that anyone in Anchorage was willing to take on um if the board believes that we're going to close more schools and create an option for anccs um but between now and and the next several months before we start talking next year's CIP um I think it's I think it's um prudent to contemplate do we do a little bit bigger renovation on anccs with a plan of having a long-term keep them there um similar to what we did for aquarium we just put $7 million in their facility um so I think there's precedent to do that although I know just like I started this meeting saying we have an amendment that
064says I can't talk about this but we're going to do it anyway and we also have a decision to close a school but I want people to think about and be prepared to talk about um we got to take care of the only Alaska native Charter School in the district one way or another and hopefully we'll have some conversations over the next few months but I think I think um it's either find another facility for them that got a little over $3 million that's not enough to buy a building it's not enough to really anything on the Apu campus if that's where they were to build a new facility and their their school um committee hasn't really raised a significant amount of money it's really been the money they put back when they were at
065East and Abbott Loop um for the most part other than about a 100,000 so this doesn't need to be discussed necessarily tonight but but I thought it was important um to to be transparent about the direction we're headed because we only closed two if backer had closed we were going to recommend anccs um but but then the board chose to retain that school and and anccs is on a a two plus year Lifeline at this point so I think we do need to discuss it one way or another um sometime in the next five months six months um we also are going to continue looking at other charter schools and other District programs to try to fill in some of that um space that's not being used for the schools because they're low capacity and
066that process will continue through the summer Mr Anderson does that get us to theend end of the presentation or do you still have more okay um so I'll jump in the queue with a couple questions I've been saving to the end and then move to member lessons um we touched a bit on collocation for Baxter um I just did some quick math with what's in our current CIP and then the what's in the enrollment dashboard it looks like they're 52 to 53% uh full based off of the state's programmatic capacity which I think we recognized isn't a per perfect formula but it gives us a ballp part um it seems to me that the situation at Baxter is pretty ripe for potentially collocating either anccs or um um one of the charter programs we discussed
067tonight and so I guess my question is have we talked about that with any of the Charter School academic policy committees because if their current enrollment is um at backers roughly 220 or so and we're projecting that to continue to decline and it declined I think 50 or so students just year-over-year um there's space for something else there and I guess the question is where are we at an examining how we do that you know I I that's a good question I looked at Baxter and and if we were to have hypothetically move stream there uh we would have had to move the SLC program The Head Start in the prek to another location to allow them any possible chance at actual growth um they're chartered that is is approved um says that their goal
068is to get to 300 and so um but I did also talked to the principal and I know at least one board member has and the APC is not interested in sharing a school um they like Baer they like um everything about it that's similar to NAA Valley about trails and green space and all those kind of things but they don't want to share a school especially middle school kids who are much taller fact they're taller than me for the most part but they're certainly taller than the elementary kids and trying to use one very small lunchroom for a middle school and an elementary school desync that desync the gym um and knowing that they still couldn't grow very much at all um and they couldn't achieve that objective to try to get to 300
069I I was told that the APC is not interested so um nccs is is 300 strong right now and so putting them in with Baxter you would have to consider pushing out some grade some of the grade levels at Baxter and by the time you did that there would be no need to have a backer because SLC Head Start prek would also have to go because you'd have a school of 300 coming in and again now you would have a principal for a really small number of students trying to share a gym and schedules in cafeteria and it so for them and stream it it didn't the math didn't work um either the math didn't work or Baxter was not going to look like Baxter anymore in order to make it work and then um
070just a quick followup Highland Academy is there any match there you know the only reason we didn't look at Highland was because High School mixed with Elementary um and trying to segregate that school schol and and it's this the same challenges with um two completely different types of meal service um because high school kids don't eat the same portions the same types of food that the elementary eats with the shrink wrap stuff we would it would take some some pretty significant renovations to really make that kitchen much larger to be able to cook and serve like what we do for high school kids thank you and then um one other question then we'll go to member lessons regarding the the plan thus far um at what point if it hasn't happened already um has will
071Administration connect with um the r APC regarding um transportation um well we've heard the board's heard from current parents of the program whove expressed concern and indicate that they won't be able to attend um if the proposal which has been widely discussed in the school and and been widely um sent to us via um electronic testimony is approved by the board and so um hearing from current parents of the program who have said will have to withdraw from the school is disheartening and so my my assumption is that the the school will want to partner with ensuring that those students can continue to attend and so have those conversations started happening yet between Administration and the academic policy committee um or is that something that will be done before the proposal between now and then
072before when the proposals goes to non-action status next month I think after tonight it would be appropriate to talk to them if if it looks like the board is at least aware that this is going to be on the board memo as a recommendation but I think it was it was certainly inappropriate um while we were still waiting on the board to make a decision which schools would close to talk to any of the charter schools about Transportation or anything else and then of course we had Christmas break and here we are um but yeah I assume that would start pretty soon thanks Mr Anderson member lessons be brief I recognize we're over time I guess I'm interested in understanding whether there's space capacity at um a couple of our middle schools to collocate any
073sort of the next uh iteration of member Jacob's questions um you know is there space to collocate any of these programs where there appears to be space at least on their face for secondary students we can relook that um I I don't know that there's space anywhere to put a full Charter School in um if if anything that was even remotely close it' be Mirror Lake which is so far away from any charter school that that that would be a challenge I think to pull off but we haven't looked at it um I can't think of any other Middle School that would that that really would have that kind of space I've walked through all of them I've seen some rooms that are vacant and some schools but not like an entire Wing which is
074what it would take member lesons member Higgins and then we'll need to wrap up for there I'm up okay um I want to go back back real quick to the Alaska native cultural charter school because right now you said there wasn't anybody interested in doing it you went out for an RP I hope to get a copy of that later I'll ask for that officially and and and and when we I know but then we then you you argued that even fixing the the the fire expression system wasn't a good investment because of the school condition and you recommended strongly against it we had to destroy it now we're at the point that if they're going to do it if we went for Bond it would have to be next year you said there's two
075years and the state and the city's always said they're going to close it so we have to hope that a bond gets approved or whatever the money is and then go forward or else they're going to be without the school I want to know what the plan is if if we if they can't stay at abot Loop for any reason nobody's willing to fix it you say it's not a good investment what what are you proposing that happens to the ataska native cultural Charter School go back to East High School or what so it's a little pre mature to to know what is going to be on um the CIP next year but my guess would be raise the roof put in a real fire suppression system with a taller roof and on that type
076of project we're almost certainly going to be able to get bids but we haven't we haven't done a design yet we haven't when you ask for what's the detailed plan I I don't have one because we only closed two schools so I don't have the plan but when we only close to then I I wanted to bring it up now saying let's start talking about anccs because we've got to come up with something and I don't know exactly what that something will be but I agree with you I'm in violent agreement with you which is rare but but tonight I am that we need to talk about anccs and we need to find a solution prob feels uncomfortable huh um that's pretty awkward and and the other question I have is with Will Kula if
077they go into that into Lake hood are they willing to continue to allow space in there for the preschool or for other things that are there that that area is right now benefiting from and because that's a lot of square footage or is it a All or Nothing type of approach which many Char schools have we we don't want to share anything we don't want anybody else to have anything we're we're separate from you where they want seate they're part of the ASD and is that has that been a discussion Point again because we hadn't got to this point where we were putting together a memo for repurposing we haven't had any of those discussions with anybody um but once we put a memo forward and the next Schoolboard meeting is non-action it will be
078time for for those discussions with each of them and then as we figure out what's the art of the possible or what are the hurdles from an APC perspective or a Jer School perspective or frankly even from a district perspective um you know we'll we'll bring those back to the board but it would have been inappropriate to have a detailed plan with Roa schula on a school that we didn't even know if it would be recommended and at this point we have gone through planning for where to move preschools and that kind of stuff we have a detailed plan we're moving forward with that already but we haven't had any discussions about the COO on that thank you m Higgins um it is now 507 um to the administration is there something you need from
079us today before we end our work session to move forward I just want to take credit for agreeing with uh Pat tonight duy noted gu one thing that I I would say I think we would like some ideas over the course of the next couple weeks as to what direction the Highland Way if you have any strong opinions on Highlander stream for nunaka because we'll be putting needing to put one of those on that memo sure um do you want to do that now or are you asking for board members to connect to Administration offline I think it would be best if board members have questions you can set up a meeting with their team or send an email um between now and the next couple of weeks otherwise um we'll begin the process of
080deliberating okay member lessons um maybe this is good for a follow-up conversation but when I look at the CIP Clark has program capacity of over 12200 students and a current enrollment of 685 students so I guess when I just look at the numbers without thinking about phes it's one of the schools in my mind that's really underutilized right now and I guess I'd be interested in learning more if there's a way we can collocate programs or options to that school thank you member lesson sounds like we have a new RFI um hearing seeing no other conversation we'll end our work session today at :9 pm thank you everyone