001member Higgins are all in attendance um and everyone's preparing to vote using their laptops tonight um would ask our student representative pack to lead us in the flag salute I pledge algi to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God IND also like to ask member pack if he would read the land acknowledgement we acknowledged that we gather here today on the traditional lands of the denina people of the upper Cook Inlet for thousands of years the denina people have been and continue to be the stewards of this land ASD is committed to diversity and inclusion and it is with honor and respect that recognize all indigenous people who live and learn in our community thank you we want to thank everyone for
002coming to the meetings uh participating in the process of the school board whether you're an observer or you're here to testify uh you do make the citizens of Anchorage make our work possible and we thank you for being here you do have before you an agenda would entertain a motion to adopt it as presented move to approve the agenda as presented I think I heard a second second moved and seconded um if there is no objection we will adopt the agenda as presented to you we move to section B under reports and first up is our student representative Mr P thank you Mr President so for my report i' would like to talk about our December meeting um December Sab meeting it was on 10th this month so last week this meeting was both festive
003and productive our student delegates were dressed in Holiday wear and hot chocolate was present as promised and voted on the most sent takeaway from this meeting is that we passed the first resolution of the school year and it was presented by service high school and this resolution was titled uh resolution 24 2024-the of a buzzer system in service high school and it's much longer than what I'm going to say right now but this resolution in essence is as follows requests funding from the inor school district to purchase and install the buzzers into the g-side and dside doors of service high school so this is request from the students delegates from service and this is for their safety and also efficiency for students who can go and get access during uh during and before the school
004day and as a student rep I have sent this past resolution to the school board and our Administration for their consideration and I look forward to further updates in our meeting we asked our schools um how do your schools support uh students during the finals or what does our schools do to celebrate the holiday season and most schools decided to answer the latter and some takeaways are some noticeable answers include one from Bartlett they have their language classes sing to the veterans houses during the holidays Clark Middle School has their annual Falcon games um golden view has holiday candy cane sales to support Salvation Army Highland Academy do does lockin lers does a Giving Tree in the library where teachers can request things for their classrooms and West has their student governments go to the
005Pioneer home to decorate the holidays so some very nice things um after all our discussions of the the resolution we had our Roundtable discussions um one of the Round Table discussions was on the topic of late start times and the general consensus on this issue is that our buses are either always late or really early um a lot of students are getting home late and since students come out during rush hour many students are unsupervised during that time and this is solely from the delegates so I mean take it as you will and another discussion topic we had was on the transition from sixth graders to middle school for some of our sixth and seventh graders there or for seventh graders there some of them have answered that it has been a little bit stressful
006um and a bit challenging but I think that is how it is when students go into middle school and now on the topic of freshman acmy there was a bit of a bounce on both sides um students thought that is beneficial to explore professional interests but a lot of ins students request that it be optional um some students have reported that their classes are repetitive and although the concept is great there's not enough resources um and that there or additional stress on teachers because they have to give lessons on things that they aren't fully um knowledgeable about and then finally we had a discussion topic on the greatest challenges that the students perceive are in their school number one that I've seen repeated from different students um is vandalism especially in the restrooms a lot
007of schools are having to close their bathrooms because students are putting uh inappropriate signs in them and also doing the devious Le lck Trend if you know what that is um a lot of students have also mentioned that social media has decreased our attention spans for our students and um students aren't prioritizing schools and that's what they're seeing between their peers and so students are asking that there be more Hands-On activities to help stimulate these students who may have decreased attention spans and finally uh students have also mentioned that um school spirit is an issue so that concludes my report the last thing I can say is I hope everyone has a wonderful holiday season and a restful break thank you thank you very much any questions from the board member Don yeah could you
008further explain the buzz system at service so the resolution do you want me to read the resolution or someone else what's the current status of those doors and how will it change with the buzzer system so I believe that they can only walk in through the front door currently and if they're not adult clearly they will just allow be allowed to be walked in um so they are saying that possible threats can come in as as long as they look like not adults um the buzzer system would basically mean that some schools are doing the buzzer system as in there's a video camera uh system so you can see who's buzzing in or requesting to come in and that is what they're saying is going to increase safety and they're also asking to have it
009in the g-side and dside doors of service high school so they are more points of entry with more security and that is their proposal any other questions seeing none we'll move to the next item which is the military report from Colonel Hansen Mr President just a point of personal privilege I guess can I get some tech help but I can't I'm having hard I need some tech help with my log for voting I'm guessing a password reset on board docs okay and I see Mr Brown is on that um military report from Colonel Hansen thank you good evening good evening Schoolboard members uh and Anchorage Community my name is Colonel Dustin Hansen I am the uh J Bears Mission support group commander and I would just like to take about three and a half minutes
010uh to convey remarks regarding our support for the academ enemies of Anchorage Readiness as one of the commanders on jar I spent a lot of time thinking about building a force that is ready therefore it's no surprise that team J bear supports Anchorage school districts academies model we support theem of Anchorage because it Fosters our students Readiness for the workforce for college and for Life students who are equipped for the rigor of advanced degrees and the demands of a professional Workforce are valuable Assets in helping communities thrive in adversity and grow in Opportunity as a partner we want to help Anchorage grow as a vibrant prosperous Community recognizing the Anchorage School District's goal for students to be college career and life ready graduates team J bear is a loyal dedicated partner in theems of Anchorage
011we also serve as a major employer for local graduates attracting and retaining home homegrown talent to accomplish the mission jaber's mission to protect the Homeland and project combat power aligns with the Academy's model because our students are learning the skills needed to power the base and defend the Homeland especially within J Bear's civilian Corp our civilian Corp is filled with jobs such as law and public service education culinary and Hospitality management business and administration engineering construction Tech technology project management Logistics carpentry Early Childhood nurse AIDS Automotive Maintenance aviation maintenance Transportation marketing and design Environmental Management computer science and it Behavioral Health just to name a few again team jar supports the acmy as it grows and develops our talented students shaping fulfilling careers while reinvesting back into this epically Grand state of Alaska one of
012the most most strategically important locations in the world Alaska's proximity to anywhere in the northern hemisphere demonstrates anchorage's inherent Perpetual geostrategic importance and our adversaries are keenly aware of that as the military reades for an era of great power competition theem prepare our students to compete for and Thrive within jaber's Workforce while the acmy bolster Readiness within our student population jar expands that Readiness by focusing on Warf fighter Readiness installation Readiness and Community Readiness so this begs the question ready for what exactly the answer is both simple and complicated to win a fight against an equally powerful adversary in an environment that's violent uncertain complex and ambiguous by leveraging capabilities on the ground Sea Air cyber and space and to win that fight we need to be ready our Airmen and our soldiers need to
013be ready to fight and win our Joint Base needs to be ready to project combat power and our local community needs to be ready to provide holistic support finally theem of Anchorage plays a key role in this holistic community support because it readies our students for technical careers and advanced education both integral to our National Defense J bear remains a steadfast partner with theis because we fight and win through technical expertise and academic rigor jar offers a robust menu of Civilian careers as mentioned that are mission focused protecting the Homeland projecting power many careers that a student may see elsewhere are uniquely available on jar because of this Strategic Mission so we will continue to support the Academy's model through partnership opportunities at the individual schools districtwide events and across the Anchorage Community team jar
014knows that ready students make for a robust Workforce that leads to a prosperous Community resulting in a secure Nation thank you for being a community that is passionate about our students education committed to their Readiness for careers college and life we are in this together thank you for your time stand by for any questions thank you uh member won thank you very much sir this past spring three out of 53 students leaving fifth grade at one of our high schools was were considered proficient in Reading I think that everybody here in the boardroom supports the notion that all of our students need to be Mission ready no matter what they do in life but I don't see us having the funds to do so right now I don't see us having the funds to get
015the other 50 now sixth graders who are in Middle School ready given the class sizes they're facing and given the accelerated learning they need to make so I would respectfully ask if you have any solutions to helping the district not just Implement acmy and Pathways but supporting St students core competencies so that they can succeed in high school kind of a rhetorical question but it's one of our realities well noted ma'am yes and uh Beyond just uh words that support the Academy's model we are all moms and dads brothers sisters aunts and uncles that are absolutely interested in what's best for the community for our kids for our students uh we want to get to 53 out of 53 reading at that proficiency level uh and and we will also invest our time time and
016our talent of which there is much within our community to to get our kids um our kids being the community's kids to that level of proficiency everybody wins when that happens and we're interested in that thank you any other questions or comments from board seeing none thank you very much oh I'm I'm sorry I didn't see down there member bellam thank you um thank you Colonel um I appreciate your comments uh and I think um while we struggle to do while we are struggling financially uh I do know that the superintendent and his team is looking for a cost neutral way uh to make some uh part of the academy work work um because I think in in the long term I I agree and I applaud your willingness to uh support the district in
017these efforts and so while we don't know what that's going to look like uh for me that is a very um real and and and I think valuable experience for our students to have everybody's not going to college but everybody has to make a living and everybody has to um they have they deserve to be the best that they can be so somewhere in in the middle of not having money and trying to figure it out I think we'll we'll do it uh it it might not look like we thought it was going to look like but uh thank you for your support um and I look forward to talking to you more about it thank you absolutely ma'am thank you member Wilson I I would like to acknowledge and share my appreciation for the
018continued partnership with J bear there I mean it's huge resources that our kids are having access to and um with that partnership it it it's an amazing opportunity for our students to learn about all of the the the opportunities available close to them and and when we talk about theems and we talk about school Business Partnership and we talk about those Partnerships jber is is a shining star in that and and I really absolutely appreciate that because those opportunities for our kids for our students are are not just the students that aren't going to choose College as as their option these are opportunities for kids that are going to choose to either go into the workforce directly or want a higher degree higher level of of academic Giger um so so it's the whole gamut
019and I know Jaber offers all of that and I know many of of um the jar folks come in and read to our students they they partner with our students so I know that partnership is at K through 12 level I've seen it and I absolutely appreciate all of that work because it's it's a an absolute continued effort to keep building that partnership so thank you for that work absolutely thank you member Jacobs yeah thank you Mr chair and appreciate the report tonight thank you for your service um and the update I I guess I'll I'll Echo appreciation for um the support of academies of Anchorage and that as many opportunities as we can provide our students to be life ready is um a critical um focal point for this board um that we've um
020had that focus on now for a series of years and as a a therapeutic foster parent to youth who don't always test well um and so proficiency isn't the perfect perfect measuring stick um but who have had numerous students participate um in join the armed forces I'll say that there's um a a just intersection there between how the district can focus on CTE education um and the pathways that that can provide um to our J bear community and so um thank you for your service to our country again and being here tonight and expressing the sentiments thanks it's a privilege thank you I will add uh I do recall time when we counted on the military to take the kids that we really couldn't do anything with and somewhere along the line that shifted to
021where it's competitive now and they they've got to have skills to qualify and that that way we think about that a lot um we will try to turn out students that are ready to be molded in the way that that you folks do an incredible job of and I know the average age in the military surprises people because it's very low and yet does remarkable work so thank you for everything you do and we will try to send you good candidates we appreciate your support thank you thank you um next to our West we do have a report from the WAN Club about our remote Area Medical Clinic at begich Middle School Mr campaign I think has a video for us and is going to talk about what's happening there thank you show on the
022video before after let's go ahead and do it now sure uh so hello uh my name is Dr Patrick campaign I'm a mountain good Lions Club member and actually the lead coordinator uh for the uh free popup healthcare clinic that we held at bage Middle School uh in April of this year uh and this video is just a short summary kind of showing you the overall aftermath uh and then I'll follow up with a short blur well offering my personal thanks for letting it happen that's frightening the amount of supports not only just within the state but like nationally is insane the amount of people that popped in just to support like not only just this event but Ram in general it's impressive impressive that's the the greatest thing to see just that level support
023uh 99% of what we accomplish is done through volunteers we do have a paid staff but it's very small according to I guess in relation to what we provide which is uh I guess healthc care for about close to 20,000 people per year uh through about 16,000 volunteers over 95% of the people here are locals so it's honestly neighbors helping neighbors you get a chance to meet a lot of new people people you get to understand what kind of demographics and what kind of people who need the help are uh and you really get a great sense of camaraderie being able to work hand inand with sometimes people who you never expected would be able to help out with the community like this there's more people in the community that care than you realize because
024when you're out there working and you don't have medical insurance I'm a long haul trucker and Driver trainer and this event made it where I could finish getting well I have a chance to be able to go back to trucking and it's just a well-coordinated event there everybody is so helpful and friendly to the people coming in and such a diversity of people find out about it and come for help and there's a whole lot of people that can't afford to get their Vision Care and if I can help them that's a blessing to me and a lot of people in the other clinics I've done have not had primary care and also gives them a chance to get Women's Health done on and I believe they'll have resources here to give them referrals if
025they need it plus we're fortunate they're going to be able to give some immunizations and if they need blood drawers so there are a lot of services here more so in this Clinic than some of the other clinics I've done which is really wonderful and it really helps a lot of people and just seeing how happy and how appreciative the people are when they come here the patients it's just an absolute wonderful thing um I would highly recommend this to anybody who's been in the same position that I am um where you just haven't been able to afford that care and there's things that you need to get checked up on or even if you're not sure if you have anything going on um you're going to be treated as a human being no judgment
026for your situation or circumstances you're going to get the health care that you need and it's going to be one of those things that benefits both future you and present you so absolutely people should come out and use this service um everyone who needs it I would just like to thank the community for having us um Dr campaign and his lovely wife Anna and everyone who has helped made this event a success and the Middle School baggage middle school thank you so much for hosting us and letting us work here we are super excited to be here and we hope that you'll have us again next [Music] year so uh for those who are here uh about the same time last year uh actually came up to this very same desk uh requesting permission uh
027to do an early rental for baggage middle school for April of 2024 uh and this is obviously partnered with remote Area Medical uh these large events usually require at least a minimum of a year of planning in advance uh but I really felt that the symbolism there of holding it at one of our local schools to advocate for uh families helping families and locals helping out locals uh we offered as you saw free medic vision and dental care for anyone who came in on a first come first serve regardless of ID ability to pay or insurance needs uh many many of our volunteer base uh bases were local but we also had doctors who flew in as far as from Michigan Florida and even Malaysia who came up to be able to offer this weekend
028first of free healthc care uh this was all funded by private donors including myself as well as a grant through the Anchorage Health Department uh all funding that was raised stayed 100% in Alaska to help out with fellow alaskans uh among the very long list of thanks to Anchorage School District uh it does include the Anchorage Health Department the Alaska State Department of Health uh the president of the National dental association who actually flew up from Washington DC to be able to help out for this event here in Anchorage uh International Leadership of the Lions Club who actually flew in from Europe who wanted to come in to oversee and see what Alaska is also like Regional Hospital tote Maritime uh Beans Cafe the Anchorage Coalition head and homelessness as well as many others which
029I do not have time to listen to uh if there are handouts uh we do have those also listed on the back of your guys' pamphlets there as well uh for further Insight over the two days in Anchorage alone uh we saw over 410 people and we had about 370 volunteers to help out each person got an average of over $500 of Health Care given for free um besides the basic Vision medical and dental we also offered free glasses uh free lab work free SDI and STD screenings Women's Health vaccinations um cognitive health and Alzheimer's screenings and multiple other things as well every person who left also had a shelf stable box of food for four courtesy of Beans Cafe uh out of all the people who came we also saw not only Asylum Seekers
030but also referrals from school nurses uh for family at least to come specifically to this event cuz either Healthcare is hard for them to allocate or frankly are not able to sustain uh the livelist necessary for their kids uh for those who came over a quarter of people there mentioned that they' never actually had an Healthcare examination before uh and that's that's a much much larger percentage than even I expected um I am saddened that we cannot be accommodated to rent the school again though this year uh but I do hope for a continued partnership as I coordinate for the following years's event event for April or September in 2026 uh I again really appreciate ASD for letting us use baggage Middle School this year and I'm more welcome to stay here for questions and
031I'm going to stay for the duration of meeting for questions after as well thank you thank you very much do we have questions from board members member Wilson oh I'm sorry member pack I just want to say thank you so much for your humanitarian work here my only question is are you planning on doing this again in Alaska this year or this coming 2025 uh unfortunately not for 2025 uh venue options fortunately fell through this year uh but Ergo that's why I'm hoping I can try to continue part ship for 2026 member wion no I just I just wanted to say this is an amazing opportunity for our amilies and it sounds like there was a tremendous amount of work and a tremendous amount of commitment from many individuals to make this happen so thank
032you for coming back to share and and Report um how well this went and how many of our families got to uh receive Medical Care um I I've been to many different events um backpack giveaways things like that and the liance club is as always there so um doing their their Vision tests and things like that so I I just I appreciate all of that work I know it's a a tremendous amount of time that your volunteers put into um really trying to serve the families in Alaska so thank you thank you very much M Wilson member Jacobs yep I just wanted to Echo appreciation um Dr campaign and then please keep the board in the loop as we can support um further events that that benefit our community and ASD families thank you thank
033you member B thank you Mr chair and thank you uh your organization uh you guys started planning this two years ago or a year ago uh officially about about 18 months prior to yeah it's been it's been a long time in the planning but it was I knew it was a hit um my neighbors several of them went went and um were able to get some care that they've been long overdue and so we need to have programs like this I thank you for the report um and I'm glad that uh we were able to partner to get this off the ground and I hope we do as our student representative uh hinted that we we're able to do it again thank you even if it's a different middle school or High School whatever whatever
034the location is I think we can partner we'll find a way to partner thank you super grateful build thank you I do want to had uh it it is a tremendous thing and and I think I saw a little bit of it when the school district was able to stand up a free vaccination clinic there are a lot of people that really have trouble navigating the medical industry and and it can be difficult even if you have insurance even if you have money in the bank it can be confusing um and for people that lack any of that the ability to just show up and be seen and be treated emotionally is just a huge thing for people as well as physically I'll also say any of us who have worked in schools know that
035at times people need help there's not always a resource to be able to say hey on this day this place you can just go Um it is a a terrific thing I regret we weren't able to do it this year I didn't know that but uh if we can help make it happen next year by all means want us know thank you very much thank for your count seeing no other questions from board we'll move ahead thank you for the video and the presentation uh Board conference and committee reports anyone have anything they wish to bring to the attention of the board seeing No Hands we will move to section c college career wife frdy High School graduation rate to the superintendent thank you Mr President so uh our team will go ahead and come
036to the front and uh we'll go ahead and have our formal uh goal monitoring discussion on our CCL goal which is to increase graduation rates so um the board had the opportunity to review the data over the past couple of weeks and we look forward to answering whatever question board members have about this goal and our metrics to improve graduation rates moving forward so we'll let the team get settled and then we'll welcome any questions from board members member lessons hi thanks for the opportunity um so I use this as an excuse to look at The District's publicly available data dashboard um where you can um get more granular detail by School uh by year uh to better understand change over time I mean there's a lot of information in their report but there's more
037information beyond the report and what I noticed is essentially that the gap between the highest performing the highest this the Comprehensive High School with the highest rate of graduation in 2023 and the lowest graduation rate in 2023 um actually grew from about 15.7 percentage points in 2023 to almost 20 percentage points in 2024 and the schools are slightly different but essentially the Gap grew and I wonder if the administration could speak to that in some way wonderful question lessons thank you right out of the gate uh before we get started I'm just going to invite each member of the panel here to introduce himself so you know who's here start on my far right um I'm Ally sule I'm the director in mental health and students for for student support and I'm here today because
038I oversee school counselors K through 12 and bringing that lens today I'm Robin Harris I am the senior director for choice schools and oversee Charter and alter some alternative schools I'm Dean Carol director of assessment and evaluation and I'm here as I get the pleasure of putting together the report for you and she did a great job and of course I'm Eric pachman a senior director of high school so thank you um yeah and board member lessons it's a great question very astute question um I guess I would lead with a with a general statement and that is that um graduation rates increased this last year from roughly 81% to over 82% and that was done during a period of time with uh decreasing resources everyone has pointed out painfully so um and we're also
039doing at a time to to address your specific question when we're seeing um a diversification of the district uh Trend which I've looked at for the last five years which shows an increased number of students who are learning English as a second language and an increased number of students receiving special education support in our high schools this set a time when enrollment in the high schools is also decreasing so our high schools in effect and the programs that support the high schools are supporting more diverse students with more needed support uh and to have an increase graduation rate while all that is occurring I think is a is a point of Celebration so shout out to our principles and all of their staffs and most importantly our teachers um in terms of the schools you
040specifically pointed out the two schools um Bartlett and Betty Davis East representing title schools have very high percentages over 70% of students who are economically disadvantaged um and these schools more than others are seeing increases in second language Learners and also special education support so I think that is a a succinct answer to the question and if I may add you know uh in light of member lessons question I did notice that there is a gap when it comes to four-year graduation graduation rates rather between our highest graduation school and our lowest graduation school but I also think it's notable that when you look at five-year graduation Trends actually our lowest performing in uh High School in terms of graduation um makes a fivepoint jump in our second lowest graduation rate high school jumps by
04110 points between year four and year five graduation rates according to the data dashboard so my wondering is what resources can the board and myself provide so that we can close that gap between a four-year graduation rate and a 5-year graduation rate because clearly a huge percentage of students are showing success but they just needed a little extra time so one of the things that we had spoken to the board about was potentially adjusting the schedule which has been delayed but one of the reasons why we put that proposal forward was because it offers more courses within a student's schedule so if they're missing a credit or failed a course they now have more attempts to make up that credit so that was one potential solution that we did put before the board but now
042is the time given the pause um what are some other ways that we can really leverage the potential that our students are showing but they just need uh clearly an extra semester or two semesters to get there so I wanted to add that context to the four-year versus 5-year graduation rate thank you Dr Bryan remember Bell did you guys get my questions oh good good for some reason I had this right here I had this flash because I had one that I wanted to talk about um ident you know we've identified the gaps especially when it comes to special ed and uh elll or language English language Learners uh H how are we how are we addressing them th that those gaps I mean what what kinds of things and uh or are we doing
043and then what are the resources that we need to be thinking about when we develop this budget I think it would that was number seven on my list just looking at the gaps and how we address them yeah I would imagine that other members will have input here but um yeah the report should shows notable disparities between different student groups so it's it's really important to acknowledge that ASD serves certain student groups very well and we're struggling with others um and the struggle is significant you know there's a 30% or so gap between our highest achieving subgroups of students and lowest achieving subgroups uh one common denominator as we mentioned earlier is socioeconomic status there's almost a 20% G graduation rate gap for students who are disadvantaged versus those who are not um so first
044and foremost in terms of our strategy to address graduation rate generally is early early intervention with our ninth graders and we've talked about that in various settings this year but our theory of action is if we can identify ninth graders of any and all groups who are off track when they enter high school that is receiving one or more fs and we intervene quickly um involving the family and wrap around supports get them back on track in time we're going to have a higher graduation rate um that's evidence-based uh We've also put forward to the group you know the the interest in expanding our uh CTE offerings in ASD uh students who are CTE completers completing more than or two or more years of a of a pathway course work their grad rate is 96%
045wow that's very significant and again that's that's an ASD metric that's not from outside of our district so those are the two general theories of action that we're moving with um once students are identified depending on what groups they're part of we can individualize support and at all of the high schools of course we have Indian education coordinators uh we have CT CIT support migrant Ed support um alli's here representing mental health support and counseling uh an area that's incredibly important for students who struggle or off track so perhaps with that I'll turn things over to Alie and she can talk a bit more about added support I'd be happy too I think that's where the strategies really come in and some of specialty roles like a school counselor come in especially in a teaming
046model with Freshman Academy or other teaming it's creating that smaller learning environment where those interventions really can be targeted to groups of students whether it's Credit Recovery or social emotional learning I think um some creative ideas that high schools are currently implementing curriculum principles recently shared out and they are really targeted at special population groups to close that Gap um to Dr Bran's Point um a really targeted summer school program that a few of our high schools have offered really have increased the credits that students are earning prior to their senior year and getting them on track for their uh four-year graduation rate so those specialty roles and utilizing them in targeted Services really can increase um the graduation rates and um while some of the moves that we're making right now won't always show
047until that group of students reach that graduation cohort the environment is really changing for all of our students and that's where we can also layer in the implementation of PBIS our positive behavior intervention and supports in all of our ASD schools speak to creating that environment of consistency and rigor that all of our students are accessing so those tiered approaches are really proving to be successful all right thank you member bam one other one other addition to that um I would just point out that the whole group here and others are are working on bolstering support for our credit recovery programs and you'll see in the report we're we're quite proud of this but um Benny Benson and save most notably show really significant increases in their graad rate um one of the reasons why
048the overall rate went up and we're doing a lot to support those schools we've added some staff to those schools trying to extend the school day um to longer periods of time trying to be more organized and intentional um in keeping track of student progress toward graduation um and so that seems to be paying off as well great so going back to the uh identifying students early ninth grade um what does that look like I mean who is it the counselor that's going to follow up uh with with the student and and is the parent are the parents involved at that point or at another Point later yeah great question so in this last year the the school district adopted and has done a lot to develop a data platform earli intervention data platform called
049unified insights which allows any educator in the building administrators teachers certain staff members um to identify students who have fallen off track in terms of attendance in terms of GPA in terms of course marks um and there are a lot of different ways to do that we've we've spent a lot of time um and invested a lot of of resources in in building the capacity of our Educators to use this system uh in the high school certainly our counselors are using it we can filter for different student groups by ethnicity by special programs by grade level um those lists of students who are struggling can be handed off to teacher teams we've organized our ninth grade teams into acmy so cohorts of teachers are working together meeting in plc's they're reviewing that data um I've
050seen the meetings take place where an educator will commit to following up with a family of a student who's struggling with attendance or with grades uh those lists are created and then the team will meet the following week to discuss what's steps have been taken um it's systematic but also highly individualized in terms of Outreach to individual students and this is where the rubber meets the road with on track work early identification and then action right yeah I appreciate that thank you other questions or [Music] comments back thank you uh this is a question submitted by Augie Martinez from Polaris K12 he asked uh might there be a correlation with the number of students decreasing in ASD and the graduation rate increasing yeah just a note we Chris hitz and I who's the leader of
051evaluation assessment and I had the opportunity to meet with Josh pack and his team from Sab to look over this data the other day it was a great privilege and um shout out to our Sab leaders and and Josh pack they asked tremendous questions this is one of many examp examples um some of them were so difficult and challenging we had to punt and say we needed more time so shout out to our students um so yeah Josh we do see a decreasing enrollment districtwide and also in the high schools as was pointed out we're seeing less of a decrease in high schools and more of the decrease in elementary schools for whatever reason um over the last five years we've seen a decrease in the comprehensive high schools of about 500 students stud it's
052about 100 students a year uh interestingly the the majority of students who are leaving the High School Division uh tend to be among our highest achieving groups and you can actually see that in this study when you look at the students and the difference in the cohort numbers the students who are leaving uh are English Learners or nons special EG and are not socioeconomic disadvantage um and you you might draw the conclusion that because those High achieving students are leaving our graduation rate would drop but it hasn't it's actually gone up which is where I began my comments tonight just as a shout out to the incredible work that our high schools are doing teaching more diverse students many of whom have higher needs and we're seeing an increase in grad rate it's a modest
053increase I don't mean to overstate but it is an increase and there's a lot more to that question Josh so thank you member Wesson um thank you I first of all it's great to hear that um there's additional Staffing and resources being directed at areas of I think our most acute need which is the credit recovery schools because the Delta between those schools and the big eight schools broadly is uh tremendous it's like 40% something like that um it seems to beg the question of again looking at a more granular level uh and and this is a tough question but we're going to be talking about the budget when you look at the combined enrollments of our two smallest Comprehensive High Schools they are on par with one of our larger high schools but the
054combined FTE for those two high schools exceeds that of the comprehensive school by about 14 those two small schools are getting some disproportionate to their size resources which seem to be helping and I just wonder if we were to disproportionately allocate resources to all of our schools to to dose them additionally if we would see similar growth it's a great I'm looking for a yes an exploration um what I don't want to do is engage in a a conversation about price sizing at high school um this is this is a yes and yeah yes and um I think yeah and your question we received it in advance I spent some time with it and um important to note that the the comparison that you provided um I think presents some really important questions about Staffing
055Resources indeed and and when we look at the comprehensive scy schools grad rate when we look at our credit recovery program grad rate um we have to ask the question are more resources needed uh and if so what kind of resources um it's important to note that the comparison you offered the the FTE comparison um is true but comparing FTE related to teachers certificated teachers they're the same it's the same metric where we see differences are in counselors and administrators and Librarians and nurses and office staffing that's where you see the difference in in FTE so I think that's an important clarification um for me when I think about our District's work to support grad rate and our theories of action uh the most important thing I think we need to focus on particularly for
056our lower performing schools is making sure that they have highly qualified teachers in the classroom and I know our human resources department is working hard on Recruitment and Retention uh all those support positions most importantly par professionals that those positions are filled and those folks are in classrooms supporting students where needed um and I also think counselors and mental health support that those staff positions are filled and right now for example at a couple of our high schools we have unfilled counseling positions right so I I would begin there um beyond that um I think I I would um I would think we would need to bring in a large number of people to to look at the specific scenario pain um we're talking about two thriving schools with incredibly High graduation rates and I
057wouldn't want to take that away from them I want to emulate elsewhere um yeah was a scenario that thriving schools had more FTE than struggling schools was that your scenario yes okay we have schools with better graduation rates for lots of reasons right but also because they still need their assist principal and librarian and fractionally available Specialists on site to serve those students needs U but they may there's just the ratios are not perfectly aligned yeah all the schools follow the same metric that's really important if you were to combine two you might see a different yeah you would see a different that would be a different in areas like Nursing Office counsel that's worthy of thought but yeah you would if you combine randomly combined two schools and compared it to a diverse school
058as diverse as Bartlett and uh and I'm not trying to answer your question I'm just thinking I'm just saying uh to me what it what it seems like to me is that um just given the the the diversity in in Bartlett and in a school like East you would have more challenges you would have those kids would have more headwinds and all of that has to be taken into consideration so and I agree with you I don't care where our kids are I want them to graduate from I want them to graduate and I want them to have the support that they need in order to do so and uh so for for me as a board member you know I I just want to know I just want to know what is it what's
059working and I have a good idea from some I mean you guys answered several of my questions already um but do we have a way I I want say do we have at one point we talked about having a way to track our not track but follow our kids when they graduate um were we able to do anything with that or can anybody talk about what that looks like given our given the uh 81% that we did graduate last year that would have been 8 yes so just uh cursory response uh Alaska deed provides us with postsecondary enrollment numbers okay we looked at those a little earlier in the year and just to remind the board roughly 42% of ASD graduates enroll in postsecondary schools or year twoyear in military enlistment 42% yeah 42% which
060leaves 58% I yeah of our of our kids who presumably are looking for employment that's really significant and see for me that is a reality every I'm go on I'm sorry yeah and so beyond that the district has subscribed to a platform called National clearing house and I'll hand off to Dean to can explain a little bit more about that and what it what it can do for us we do partner with the national student Clearing House to gather data on our students who are going um to postsecondary education programs accredited programs across the country and um so we do gather that information part of that information also is partnered with deed um to come up with that 42% we're also looking at um through the Academy's of Anchorage work in our special weed Department
061partnering with um the state to explore a Statewide data dashboard similar to um what other states like Wisconsin um in Minnesota are working on and um so with the Department of Education the Department of Labor um the governor's Council on disabilities and an organization called dat quality campaign where it sort in the process of exploring what that would look like and what what would need to happen to make a Statewide dashboard not just for anchor School District but for the state on how well our students are doing after after they leave us okay so that 58% they're not in college they're in the community somebody's Community somewhere and they're either looking for work or had or have jobs I mean I'd like to think they have jobs but uh my guess is is that they're
062probably um they're probably struggling but they could be an apprentice did you did did that 42% go into some kind of apprenticeship or do we not know unless the apprenticeship involves enrollment in a twoyear two or four year okay okay and uh if I may add this is really important data for the administration and the board to look at because one 42% of graduates enroll in college and I'm not going to put um our team on the spot but if you look at the six-year postsecondary outcomes only a fraction of those students actually get a degree either so it's actually a much greater number than 58% that need additional support to be successful in life and having done this work in different shapes and forms over my career uh one of the things that we
063need to look at are ways to equip students with more vocational credentials earlier on in their uh High School careers dual credit opportunities as well because the more students are essentially building equity in their post-secondary future uh the more invested they are to stay on track for that so um it's certainly a wonderful thing that 42% of student stud enroll in college but we have to keep our eye on what is the outcome of that and when I looked at the outcome of six-year secondary outcomes for I think maybe two or three classes ago it was actually only 25% of ASD graduates that received any sort of uh post-secondary credential so it's really more like 75% of our students we need to intervene whether it's doing something like theem of Anchorage whether it's more CTE
064Pathways whether it's more dual credit or even thinking about innovative ways to shrink that gap between High School graduation and College summer melt is a real thing of those 42% that enroll directly in college I guarantee you that there are more that actually apply to college that year but they didn't make it to the first day of school in college so this is of the utmost urgency and I feel that this issue gets a little lost in the sus because we think about enrollment in college and that's it but I actually think of the hundreds of students that had chosen their post-secondary path didn't have the perhaps the skills out of the box to be successful in their first and second year and when they stop out of college uh one of my mentors once
065told me the most expensive degree that you can have is the one that you don't finish so when these students leave um with before four years not only do they not have a degree but they potentially have debt and the point of theem of Anchorage and the work that we're doing is to really provide our community a chance at Financial Freedom and prosperity and to really invest in the future of our economy and all that comes down to how do we prepare students to want apply to college and get through college and two um if they're interested in the workforce how do we get them these credentials as quickly as possible and for as cheap as possible because many of our students are in poverty so they can be successful that's my soap bux I
066did this for almost 10 years but this is really important work just to followup uh on the superintendent's comments but also something I think um Mr Pac mentioned in his report about uh teacher te um the Academy's adding more work to teachers so I I guess my question is how are Educators being supported to contribute to improving graduation rate and in our uh college career and life Readiness yes so I organized a response to this this question it's a good one thank you for um I organize it in terms of of structures and tools and programs sort of in those three areas so the structures of course we have the districtwide uh adoption of plc's which is incredibly fruitful structure um that allows our teachers to meet every Monday morning and work together on a
067variety of different topics um in terms of graduation rate perhaps the most important topic is intervention and support um I was just in plc's on Monday at King Tech High School and saw one on on literacy I saw one on engagement I saw one on Intervention and one on growth mindset incredible very well LED um the other structure I would mention is Freshman Academy which I talked about a little bit earlier about organizing our freshman teachers into cohorts they work together as a network of caring Educators to support cohorts of about 100 120 students if you organize large comprehensive schools in that Way teachers get to know students better and more quickly and can of intervene on their behalf more readily in terms of tools we've already talked about unified insights which allows our Educators
068to identify students early who are falling off track in terms of attendance GPA or grades and then programs we spent a lot of time today already talking about the acmy of Anchorage um it's it's an uncertain time time for theis but but the the vision is incredibly important uh because it centralizes CTE classes in coursework and as I mentioned earlier graduation rates are incredibly High when students are enrolled and invested in CTE programs and that's a cross-section of students representing all the demographic groups uh including those from lwi income backgrounds um and then PBIS which how we mentioned earlier um and I would just mention to the the board that we're seeing very significant reductions in exclusionary discipline since the adoption of PBIS at high schools uh it's two years in a row we're keeping
069more kids in school they're missing less school as a result of disciplinary action um and we're seeing more predictable and caring and restorative responses to behavior um which is a good thing that is a good thing yeah I think uh from our vision to our to the outcome we just we miss so many we miss a lot in between because it is there are lots of challenges that kids have it's not that they can't do but they come to us with different skill sets they come from different backgrounds they have uh they may have some discipline problems and so we expect Educators to take them where they are and move them right through but that is just not going to be easy for some of our kids without some intervention so I'm glad to um
070or something that excites them so much about school that they are going to they're going to hang in there no regardless so anyway um I I appreciate it I have more questions but I will yield any other questions or comments member Wilson I I know we're tracking four year graduation rates but it it really is important for me to see some data on the five-year graduation rates and and the importance of that for me is to see of our students who is taking a little bit longer to graduate who who's needing that additional support um so and actually using this these metrics um I think would would clarify that for me not for today but future um so that we can see is it I I mean I can make my assumptions but it would
071be nice to see that that data for for everyone to see it would it would be nice um I think to be to be part of this this presentation so um we we because it's important that our students are graduating and it is a higher graduation rate at 5ye versus fouryear and and for me that is significant that our graduation rate rate is higher and to find out maybe how we can support those students even if it is within that 5-year graduation rate to continue to um and and which of our students are needing more time and trying to figure out why uh member Wilson I'd love to address that I've actually been spending this week looking very deeply at the four-year versus five-year graduation rates and to be transparent one of the reasons why
072is because we're putting a lot of thought into how we can move forward forward with the work of the acmy of Anchorage in a cost neutral way to the general fund but in a way that actually moves our goal forward when it comes to four-year graduation rates so you'd be interested to know that um our 5year graduation rate is 86.5% and um foure is 82.2% so you do see that modest jump on the aggregate but what's more fascinating is if you go a high school by high school so for example I noticed that Bartlett High School forear graduation rate is 77.4% but you see a 10 percentage Point jump with the 5year graduation rate so those are dozens of students that were capturing who just needed let's say a summer or an additional semester to
073get across the finish line for Betty Davis I think it was a five-point jump when you look at the fivey year graduation rates and uh some also South High School even uh gross Five Points between four year and fiveyear graduation uh between a four year and five year graduation rate so all of that to say when we think about all the levers that we can push to Advance this goal forward one of the things that comes to mind for me in addition to incredible CT programs is the role of credit recovery and intervention when it comes to our students uh High School careers and I say this as a high school a former high school math teacher as well um another thing that we need to realize is that when we increase PTR at high
074school which happens but one of the trade-offs is one you lose electives but two you also risk uh losing support courses that could really help students get on track I guarantee you that one of the reasons why some of these students don't make it to the Finish Line is probably because of math and it's one of those types of courses where if you don't intervene right away by adding an additional course into that student schedule to learn the fundamentals that they missed maybe in middle school or elsewhere they may not get caught up and again I don't want to beat a dead horse but that was one of the rationals behind contemplating expanding our course schedule from six to seven or eight periods and I understand that one of the reasons why that's not going
075to work in the short term is because of the loss of instructional time but my rhetorical question to the team and to the community and to the school board is well what do we need to do in order to advance that goal forward because my theory is is that students need access to more time to recover and relearn foundational skills that they didn't learn um perhaps in middle school or perhaps even elementary school so as we think about ways to Resource our schools one of the way one of the things that I have my eye on like a hawk is the degree to which students can receive those extra Support Services whether they're academic or whether they're social emotional so that they can make it to the Finish Line because a 10-point jump between a
076fouryear and a 5year graduation rate between one high school tells me that those students had the skills um the entire time they just needed additional time my initial theory was perhaps they needed an extra class in their schedule that's not an option going into next year so let's think about ways to recover those credits during the summer or during the day or during creative ways that happen um before after the formal instructional day I mean it is a matter of urgency when we look at our board goal to get to 90% in a few years we're talking about 200 students so where are we going to find these 200 students and give them the resources they need to make it at the Finish Line because they're there because we see them pop up in the
077five-year graduation rate and that's with no additional intervention conceivably so what can we do before they complete their uh senior year so they don't need that extra summer semester that's just an open question and that's kind of the heart of the work when it comes to doing something like moving our graduation rates forward member Higgins yeah I guess I'll I'll comment I appreciate the superintendent's uh issues and we go to seven and eight and I I I don't fault that but if we go to an eight schedule we're going to change gradu graduation requirements my assumption we're not going to have people graduating after two and a half or three years and uh so that's going to be a factor that works both ways I support the concept completely but my concern is that we
078got to get the the the staff behind it um we got to make sure that we have the the the teachers and the Staffing to pull it off we need to do this I am not disagreeing with that at all we've got to get it done but if we don't get the resources from the state if we can't work it through that we can't have can't start losing teachers because the case load how many students each teacher is going to have is going to go up if you you you have to do it that way but I I'm totally in agreement with the with the issue the acmy is critical I we heard that from the uh military today as well the base I appreciate that I just I just want to make sure that
079um we're listening to the concerns of teachers and we on the all the factors that need to be laid out to make it work it's just overwhelming and I appreciate your decision to hold back on that a year and see what we can do because I hope we do move forward in some Direction member won great conversation everyone thank you all for the questions and answers and and comments um This falls into the comment line um you know it has struck me before that that truly we're talking about 15 to 30 kids at some schools uh in any given year and maybe 30 to 60 kids at you know larger schools that need that targeted assistance and I think that that's one of the fundamental problems that I've wrestled with with theem because certainly how
080we've been allocating our fds funds has been equal and that's not the dosage that I believe we need we need targeted dosage to meet targeted students and I think think that when we direct needed resources to where they will most acutely be received that's when we'll see the greatest gains because um that's just going to be more effective member Wilson I've spent years partnering with King Tech I use King Tech as as an example because they their programs are are amazing and and the the work they do with their students are amazing I've talked to countless number of students and countless number of parents who so many of them have said my my son or my daughter was not successful in a traditional academic setting because they just they weren't interested they weren't and it's
081not that they didn't have the capabilities it's not that they weren't smart enough to be successful they just they there was that missing element and when they got to King Tech and they found something that interested them that really excited them whatever that was whether it be Automotive or child care or whatever health care then their grades sworded and not only did they graduate but they graduated with an intention to move into whether it be post-secondary education or a job many of them signed on to a job I've had so many of those conversations so I I completely agree that we need to make sure our kids are reading absolutely we need to make sure that they have that solid foundation in math but if we don't keep our kids interested if we don't allow
082them to be exposed to enough career opportunities something that that really grabs at them to make them want to be successful academically many of them we will continue to lose I've had over 55 kids in my home in the past 20 years I can attest to many of those teenagers having the capability to be successful and choosing not to be because they didn't find that spark that really drew them into choosing to be successful so when I talk about ourmes when I talk about King Tech when when I talk about our school business partners I talk about them with such great appreciation because I really truly believe that it will make a difference for so many of our kids and not just our kids that need to find that that job when they're when they
083graduate that career when they graduate that post-secondary education I mean it covers all of them they all need that spark regardless of how well they do academically or how poorly they test because I've had those kids do also that test poorly but sore academically when they get out of high school so when I think of all of our kids when you when you're targeting to just a few students you're you're still missing so many of them so I I need to be very careful that we are not choosing to Target a few and let so many of them fall through the cracks remember [Music] bman this is my last question comment and other I love your theory of action can do because I think I I don't know why but first time I heard it
084tonight I mean really heard it so if you if you would um restate I think there were two could you restate those please that you said it was I know we believe if we do early intervention and something else what was that other something yeah I and off yeah early intervention to support on track to graduation status okay beginning with our ninth graders and also to the degree possible the expansion of CTE offerings and again both of goals are research based we've got a lot of evidence and metrics to support those right here uh in ASD with former graduating classes so the of action that we believe in um based on the evidence yeah all right thank you done any other question um back so I would like to kind of flip um what the
085questions have been like today and to more of the student Side by tying in this data set into our climate and connectedness Survey that most of our students across the district took last year um in that survey students are asked about their perceptions of school safety peer climate student involvement Community Support cultural connectedness for example uh for our schools who do have students who are graduating at you know favorable levels do you think that there are certain attributes from this survey that can be indicators of successful graduation rates and if so have there been plans to you know prioritize those areas across District sure I really think that's important because we know that when students feel safe they have trusted adults and they're motivated to come to school we do see the correlation and that
086they can really reach every dream that they have so I'd love to see the climate and connectedness Survey overlaid with those graduation rates I think it's important for our systems to recognize that our staff want to encourage students in their goals it's not our goals it's their goals and one tool that we haven't talked about tonight that is important in thinking about aligning students and staff is like a College and Career exploration platform which School links is is one that we've been starting to utilize where staff can see what students goals are for their postsecondary and help them course plan their high schools um and and that aligns to the idea of having trusted adults in the classroom as well as support staff so that we can then follow up with alumni and other to
087see what success they are showing in having but it really starts with that safe environment that students want to and are motivated to come to and that parents want to send their students and recommend coming so that we're partnering with parents on that um and so that overlay of climate and connectedness and perception being reality is really important for us to look at and that is one of the keys in implementing our high leverage practices so I really appreciate that more questions or comments seeing that I would like to add that as a board member um when we're talking graduation rates I always do want to see fifth or sixth year graduates as well I'm hoping one day we just call them graduates uh I think there will always be kids that need more time
088uh we'll always have students that have something happen in the midst of their High School career that that disrupts for some period of time and uh I I hope we can get away from I mean four years is a good Target but when it doesn't happen it doesn't happen and five years is fine for for students that need it so I'm I'm hoping in our statistics and everything we do look at that I'll say also that yes uh if you ever feel bad about high school graduation rates look at College Dropout rates and you'll feel like you are really in a marvelous spot if you're back in high school it um 20e college student so what can I say um but yeah other other than that I really do appreciate the the analysis and the
089data um no question if we can offer kids something they want we will improve and I hope that we can move to do that um yes sorry Mr President um we will be providing some supplemental data for you regarding the fiveyear graduation rates and the board connect this weekend any other questions seeing none thank you very much for your work and we'll move ahead that brings us to our first opportunity in the evening for public comment we normally Reserve an hour for public comment uh at the beginning and then do later comment uh at the end of the meeting due to the turnout that we've seen so far what we're trying to do is take all public comment at the beginning so that members of the public don't have to stay with the board Through
090The Bitter End of the meeting uh in order to be able to speak um so we I think we will be able to do that again tonight um during public comment board members will not answer questions or engage in discussion with members of the public this is the time for the public to come speak and for the board to listen the school board welcomes the public to observe and contribute to our meetings through our comments but to be productive our meetings must be structured and civil we do follow Robert's Rules of Order we ask that people not attack a member or speaker's motives no profanity or foul language uh and we ask you please refrain from disturbing the meeting no cheering Applause Outburst waving signs I think we've got a well-mannered crowd tonight so I
091don't think that'll matter too much but we do want to hear from everybody and we want everybody to feel comfortable coming up to speak uh whether they're in agreement with most people in the room or not um with that the other thing we do is we allow students to testify first because we're hoping they will do that and they go home and get a good night's sleep after doing all of their homework um secondly we will take any parents that have students in the room with them to speak and uh then we will complete with everybody else so when I call names so ask for a pair of people to come up to the P or to the Das in front each person has three minutes and there's a timer you can see right in
092front of me facing out um and we will begin uh the first two people on the list are students K pardon me um students Cadence belard and wna Chico I apologize if I didn't say that correctly but if you can come up and have a seat at the microphones yeah one of you will state your name for the record and then you'll have three minutes to speak the floor is yours hello I am Cadence B A Fifth Grader at I'm sorry to interrupt you I'm gonna ask you to get that microphone closer to you it has to be right in front of you that way we can all hear you thank you hello I am Cadence bord a fifth grader at bter elementary I have been at backer since third grade backer is like a
093second home the teachers are great they they get to know us and help us learn in fun and exciting ways please think about how B how much backer means to us it is more than a school it is a family is that everything okay thank you very much for coming and speaking and if you'll tell us your name you have three minutes it's on hi my name is Lana Chico and I'm in back to and I'm going to read a something I wrote Because if you close backer I will be sad because I have been in backer for 4 years years I have loved all my teachers they made learning fun backer makes me feel like I belong so if you close backer down I will feel sad because I will have lots of friends
094I love so if you close down clo backer I will most likely never see them again thank you very much for coming and speaking to us next on our West is cassia Chico and Dwayne Davis you'll come forward uh my name is cassia Chico and I'm going to tell you why I don't want to close backer I always sad that back closing cuz we cuz teachers make learning fun and the teachers are really nice and our friends are really friendly to us and when we have friends then uh you get to know them and you get to know your teacher some to when you you uh first come so you get to know them thank you thank you very much and if you'll state your name for the record hi my name is Dune Davis
095I am currently a fourth grader grade student at Baxter Elementary School I am opposed to the proposed right sighing plans specifically the idea of closing neighborhood schools to address the budget shortfalls I am in battle of the books on student council and was selected as an alternative for fourth grade class in the upcoming spelling be I will I participate in after school programs such as running club with Mr no which provided my friends and I the opportunity to race in Bartlett High School Jubilee event I got I helped set up and attend PTA events such as the turkey shoot where we can partner with high school basketball players and a basketball shooting contest I won the turkey shoot in shoot my second grade year this year it was fun but I didn't take home the
096prize I live on the other side of bter bog and love walking home home from the school or being pulled over the snow in an inflatable boat by my f father our school feeds students and encourages them to take fresh fruit home for free we provide a safe space to learn and participate in short I have created a community of friends and peers at Baxter this community is supported by dedicated talented caring and Priceless sta some of these staff members are trust are the trusted adults I have in my life outside of my family I really care about my school and want to stay and I want it to stay open please allow Baxter to keep growing and fostering a loving commu Community please keep bter open thank you very much for your time have
097a good day thank you to all of our students that came and spoke tonight we appreciate app it um I'm going to also we have Vanessa Chico on the speakers list if you'll come forward and speak and then uh you'll be able to take these kids home so they can do homework uh hello my name is Michael Davis uh thank you all for your time and diligence through the pre your your presence and participation uh in gathering the information and perspective for the community I've seen a lot of the individuals faces around not just at these board meetings so I appreciate that um my wife daughter Dune and I uh moved to Anchorage in 2022 uh education's really important to us uh my wife is an educator she's an educator of service um so uh
098when we moved she actually has family that uh is at the Waldorf School um so we toured the Waldorf School and we toured Baxter her second dune's second grade year and we decided to go with Baxter um I was very strongly uh an advocate for Baxter even though my wife's family had um family at Waldorf um the second grade year was amazing uh our only like apprehension at the end was like it's seemed like the classes were really big big classes Miss G did wonderful and dune made a lot of bonds so I didn't have as much a footing to stand on to push back against the Waldorf School so we tried that out uh dun's third grade she started at Waldorf um the class sizes were smaller um it definitely has a different structure
099of learning uh they didn't have a library there which to me was you know not for me um but we tried it out nonetheless and uh it wasn't the right fit so we ended up moving back to bter in the middle of dune's third grade year and it was like we had never left the teachers were very welcoming the Friendship Bonds were still strong in there so uh we've kind of had the experience with the big classrooms and still made the decision to go back um so um let's see uh uh after losing the principle in replacing with like the interim uh Baxter really hasn't had the leadership support um beyond the the teachers and the staff and the retired teachers that come and invest there um surely the most fundamental moral measure of any
100social system is the status of the children and the qualities of their childhood I would like to assume that most of the individuals in this room and listening online would believe to have a strong quality childhood individuals must have a strong foundation and access to educational opportunities and support unfortunately the schools I see presented on the list for closure are the very same communities that most desperately need the access to the supports provided from the neighborhood schools the population of families near or below the poverty line at Baxter is vast and English as a second language is also uh very large uh also children need of Behavioral support um it seems like the right sizing proposal and as's response to the community feedback seems to have only yielded what appears to be a trojan horse
101of further confiscation of the opportunity and service of the wealthy the expense of those in Greater need thank you your time has expired thank you and Miss Chico if you wish to speak hi um my family and I moved here in 2020 due to my husband's work um we were actually due to move again this year um but chose to stay we chose to stay in a deciding factor was that we love our community and Baxter is a community school and it would be detrimental to the children um if it were to close and you know we have conversations about social and emotional well-being and I just don't see a situation where splitting up all of these kids is what's best for them um I think the conversation should be um how we keep backster
102open and not um and what we could do to prevent that and not um a yes or no to closing it um and that's it thank you both very much for coming and testifying and I believe that's every every parent that has students in the room tonight I believe um so switching back to our normal schedule we do have some people signed up to speak speak on non-action items and I'd like to call them forward right now uh first on the list is Cameron Vincent Lang and then uh Brandon St Str you're here and could come [Music] forward you'll State a name for the record you have three minutes all right dear members of the ASD school board and District leadership my name is Cameron Vincent Lang I am the AP at Roa schula thank
103you for the ongoing engagement with the community during right sizing discussions and also I want to say thank you for our Charter renewal a few weeks back as we move forward with right sizing I urge you to make timely decisions especially around facility locations extended timelines can impact Charter Schools particularly around Recruitment and budgeting facility costs represent about 20% % of our budget and uncertainty around lease terms complicates our ability to plan effectively and provide stability to current and prospective families rasula has grown rapidly we're now serving 484 students making us Alaska's largest in-person Charter program our success is due to our strong Academic Program dedicated community and increasing Community interest in ASDS Choice programs however we sign we Face significant challenges in our current facility including space constraints that can hinder our ability to
104provide high quality education we currently house 484 students and 45 staff members and a 39,000 foot facility this is crammed yet we need those numbers in order to pay for the facility that houses us I ask that Rula be considered for relocation to a repurposed ASD facility in the 2526 school year move to a more suitable facility would ensure the long-term viability of our program hopefully align with the these goals of expanding access to Choice programs and create opportunities to build new Partnerships with local communities being housed in a neighborhood provides greater visibility and access to families who have expressed interest but currently lack nearby options ear least expires this August and we need clarity about our facility this helps us prepare our families for potential moves and make necessary or uh potential moves or
105make necessary reductions to our program over the past two years this is what we've done we increase our class sizes we cut positions and we use savings to maintain our program this is no longer sustainable in a facility that we can't afford staying in our building Roa will drastically look different moving forward many charter schools are operating overc capacity struggling to meet students needs due to space and rental costs especially for students with higher needs like with IEPs and 504 plans who require specific environments for instruction or small group testing in some cases these accommodations are being made in space like closets or hallways the same time some schools have underutilized space being used for non-academic purposes believe there's an opportunity to repurpose these spaces to better support students last I'd like to note that
106as a charter school leader I've seen the positive budgetary impact for anccs and Aquarium being housed in ASD buildings encourage you to review the data provided by ASD their plan is based on months of input in a data- driven process aimed at better supporting students I look forward to further discussions on how we can ensure the success of all ASD students including your ASD CH thank you very much you'll state your name for the record you have three minutes yes I'm Brandon stroke principal of real casula hello good evening ASD board members and Leadership I want to begin by thanking you all for renewing the 10 uh the 10-year Charter for rasula we are very excited to continue our academic success in partnership with ASD reala schula is an ASD program of 484 students from
107all around Anchorage reala students are ASD students Rica staff are ASD employees the right sizing initiative as currently proposed will benefit many ASD students whether they attend neighborhood schools or Charter Schools students at neighboring schools will receive more academic Services since those services will be Consolidated and not spread across multiple bill buildings Charter Schools will have a stable facility and can redirect funding that is currently spent on rent for staff and student support this is a win-win for everyone our current facility has served us well over the last 10 years however as you know through previous communication Rel casula is at the end of its 10-year lease and we are in need of facility for the 2025 26 school year the current lease costs are no longer tenable and real Kula has cut staff and
108used a sizable portion of its rollover savings to cover Personnel costs for this school year we cut 2.0 FTE and the evening custodian the approved 2526 real Cula budget cuts another 1.4 FTE and has no funding allocated for textbooks student technology office supplies or classroom supplies while these expenses are are being cut R Kuli is using $600,000 of rollover savings this year and next year is planning to spend $700,000 to avoid making further Staffing Cuts in the end we are un if we are unable to reduce facility costs the rollover savings will be used up and we'll have to make drastic cuts to personnel which will impact our students a different facility would reduce facility expenses provide stability to the program provide more square footage as Cameron previously noted our building is 39,500 sare ft
109and provide more outdoor space all these factors are beneficial to ASD students who attend R Kula I want to thank you all for giving me the opportunity to speak today I know you all will do your best to make the right choice for our school district thank you all thank you very much next up we have Rebecca covin and Erica Monahan come forward you'll state your name for the record you have three minutes am I close enough excellent my name is Rebecca culvin and I serve as the APC chair for the real Kula German emersion School let me start by thanking you and the administration for working with us to renew our 10-year Charter recently we are now on a path to educate another 10 years worth of ASD students in the German Immersion program
110rula's APC has advocated on many issues that had the ability to impact our school and our students when high school immersion programs were reviewed for possible elimination APC expressed support for their importance in immersion education we have contacted the legislature and the governor to request an increase in the BSA now we are advocating for an equally important issue our school's facility as we've stated in previous Communications to the district rasula is currently in the final year of our 10e lease on a commercial building while our time in the building has been fruitful we are no longer able to afford to remain there in the current fiscal situation and terms just like ASD and all other Public Schools the BSA is our primary source of funds our operating expenses have steadily increased while suffering under flat
111funding from the state over the past two years we have increased our class sizes we have cut positions we have spent significant portions of our savings all of these have been done in an effort to continue to provide our 480 students the highquality dual immersion program they deserve we come to you again to request consideration for an ASD facility should one become available as part of the rightsizing mission our current facilities lease expires August 2025 we need to know as quickly as possible if a facility may be available we need to discuss with our families and students a possible move or to prepare for significant cuts to our program let me end by saying we appreciate the work ASD has done to support your students in charter schools and other schools of choice thank you
112thank you very much you'll state your name for the record you have three minutes thank you my name is Erica manahan I am a mother of two children in the Anchorage public school system who are on the wait list for rasula by the way I began my teaching career in a high school program dedicated to Career Readiness for at risk students I am now a history Professor affiliated with a global and national security policy Institute at the University I thank the Airmen who spoke earlier I too am deeply concerned about Readiness student Readiness life readiness academic Readiness career Readiness and geopolitical Readiness and I am here to voice my concern about theem of Anchorage model even as currently revised I offer the following analogy the holidays are coming many of us may have or be
113guests soon if you had a house guest coming you would not knock out a loadbearing wall to build a cardboard addition that you could not afford to heat nor furnish given where budgets and Staffing are that is kind of what the Academy's model is asking of Anchorage importantly no good guest would ask such a thing of a host or Hostess it is great for this Foundation to visit Anchorage with this temporary monetary support yet the model needs to be reworked significantly to be one that works for Anchorage students in aist stainable manner the revised proposal still intends to implement the Academy's plan in a way that implements the CTE curriculum across the entire District I feel that it's fiscally irresponsible for the district to continue with this proposal for a variety of reasons not every
114student is college-bound CTE should be a robust part of the high school curriculum as member Wilson pointed out exposure to career opportunities can can help hones One Direction CTE must not come at the expense of teaching fundamentals that undermines the chances for Anchorage high school students who aspire to go to college and to return to Alaska with Advanced degrees the current plan as I understand it handicaps students by providing less instruction time to master the same curriculum I reject the suggestion made at the October meeting that t student teacher Direction uh time was not critical another problem it's easier to grow government than to shrink it um but we'll leave that watering down the CTE program and all of our existing secondary fundamental programs is no way to prepare Anchorage Alaska or the United States
115for a robust and ready future I urge you to accept this grant funding only if it can be rolled out with a more modest scope thank you thank you very much heroin storm you will state your name for the record you have three minutes good evening Caroline storm education uh sorry Coalition for Education Equity school board members thank you as always for taking public testimony I would like to encourage you to pass a resolution similar to the Juno school board that um opposes the proposed deed regulation that will be rolling out in March and secondly I just wanted to say I don't EnV you this evening um you have a very difficult decision that you have been forced into because of the state's failure to adequately fund public education for everybody in this room the
116Coalition for Education Equity commissioned an evidence-based study similar to the Anchorage School District um and it shows the base St allocation should be higher than $113,000 which is more than double than where it is now I'm encouraging everybody in this room as I did last week or two weeks ago the last meeting to please call your legislators and ask them to significantly raise the base student allocation so that our schools can be adequately resourced thank you thank you very much for your testimony that is all of our speakers on non-action items turn now to speakers on action items uh [Music] first on the list uh Carissa Silva and Shannon dwang champ um and Shannon is uh connecting by telephone point point of order Mr President um doesn't action testimony come once the appropriate memorandum has
117been introduced we'll take a five minute edes e e e I apologize for the more than five minute recess um I do want to explain for everybody we are deviating from our normal process uh in that usually action items would be heard when the motion has been made and it's being considered uh but for the past five or six weeks because of the volume of testimony we have wanted people to be able to testify and perhaps have another life board members don't get that but members of the public do so we are hearing all testimony at the beginning of the meeting uh so that people don't have to sit through the the whole agenda in order to get there so that that's why there was some confusion on this side and uh I do want
118to clarify that so uh we do have I believe 16 more people that do wish to be heard tonight um go ahead and start with Carissa Silva and Shannon dong champ and Shannon dong champ was telephonic okay and she's on so um Miss Silva if you're here if you would come [Music] forward and not seeing um the next two people on the list are Megan Garnett and enan raid I apologize if I'm not saying that right uh and we'll ask M delongchamp to testify by phone Miss delongchamp if you can hear me star six we'll unmute you and you have three minutes uh yes I'm here thank you um I speak to you not just as a six-year backer employee but also a backer parent I brought my 5-year-old daughter with me this year not
119just for convenience but because I wanted her to experience the Bobcat Pride I have experienced these last six years and I also wanted her with Miss Wilkerson for kindergarten um the first announcement on November 1st placed Baxter on a three-year plan on November 8th we attended an optional meeting where we were reassured over and over to just wait until December 17th um you'll never know it Could Happen well they were right because on November 27th the day before Thanksgiving break three schools received what they called a Christmas miracle and Baxter lost two and a half weeks to get people together backra was left with only 20 days and one school board meeting before decision day to research and get folks together to show that we should also stay open more research needs to go into
120schools that are proposed to receive Baxter and unaka students the move will put the three Baxter incoming schools at 92% or higher capacity this will be a problem if there is a bigger influx of students than estimated Baxter has the largest SLC program in ASB at the beginning of the school year there was a big shift due to zones changing these students thrive on consistency with their peers their teachers their routines and their school shuffling them around again will cause unnecessary hardship on them and their families Baxter is a walking school we have one jet bus that picks up a handful of students that live across busy roads other than that our students are transported or they walk closing backer would place a tremendous hardship on these families that will need to go to a
121school further away from their home this will also require more bus routes and drivers that ASD does not have Baxter is a title one school this allows us to have family nights that are free for our families and students where staff can build relationships with families in a more relaxed environment also just because Baxter and unaka are Title One schools does not mean it will automatically go to the incoming schools when they receive our students our SLC program came to Baxter uh third quarter of the 21 and 22 school year and we were not title one until 2324 ASD could lose two title schools in Anchorage and gain none next year at Baxter our breakfast and lunch are not reduced they are free this is something a lot of our families count on with the
122rising prices of groceries knowing their students will be fed at school is one less worry for our families bter also has a food tantry that we use to help any of our families that might need a little extra help around around the long braks we have a lot of food drives and dedicated partners that donate food winter gear and other items to Baxter we also have a YMCA program that our family relies on after school because our parents work later than School open um there are other options that could be looked at instead of closing backer we could take on a prek program this has been an inquiry by multiple families over the years or Baxter and unaka could combine at Baxter this would keep both School populations intact that would be very beneficial for
123the students and the staff of both schools bter has the space to take on nuna's entire population it would still leave room for fluctuation and if Baxter and NAA are both closed the probability of Staff following students is a lot lower than is being estim or Bor could share space Witham thank you very much for your testimony and either of you will state a name for the record you have three minutes um my name is Megan garnot and I am the secretary and registar at Baxter Elementary um I've worked there for three years but before that my son also attended Baxter for all of um his Elementary um Baxter is quite literally my home away from home I know every single one of our students names um as well as most of their family members
124um and I work there not for a paycheck but because I love our students and our community um I'm writing because the school because closing our school is not the right decision um backer is a title one school we offer free breakfast and lunch to all of our students many of our families are low income and struggle to provide food for their homes this means oftentimes the only meals they get are at school um many families never have had to pay for school lunch before and would not have the means to do so uh backer also operates a food pantry and we provide food to many families throughout the year um taking away these resources I feel like would be detrimental to many um as we know not all of the receiving schools are Title
125One or provide free meals um kind of echoing what Shannon said Baxter is a walking School meaning most of our students live so close that busing is not even available to them we have one gened bus at Baxter that picks up just a small handful of students shuffling them around to different schools will require more buses more bus drivers families having to drive further and other unnecessary logistical challenges um we also have the largest SLC program in all of ASD at Baxter these kids need structure they thrive on routine each time they're moved around it takes months mons for them to get comfortable again losing losing important academic time last year many of these students from this program were moved around for the second time in three years causing anxiety and uncertainty um the district
126claims that our neighborhood is aging out and we don't do not have as many kids being enrolled as previous years but when I look at the data they put out it shows our enrollment is actually up from the last few years um every year amilies apply for the lottery to come to Baxter um but we have not been able to take any kids off of the lottery so that is just kind of confusing to us um yeah thank you for listening thank you very much if you'll state your name for the record you have three minutes thank you school board and good luck tonight my name is Olen ridme I have two kids one in first grade and one in fourth grade in the Russian immersion program I know your decision has already been made
127but I feel it is my duty as a father parent volunteer taxpayer and concerned citizen your timing of the announcement before Thanksgiving did not give parents or officials time to react when I found out about this was Tuesday December 2nd it was on a thread for parents it was not well distributed to the public the strongest asset you have is us the parents we built our lives around the schools and Community I talked to you about turning in elementary and the Russian emersion program turnig again is a vibrant Russian immersion program where kids are immersed in a second language by native speakers the loss of just one of these teachers would be detrimental to the program and the kids enrolled in it the why is Yet to Come the concern I have is adding eight
128and up to 33 kids from the sbbs program to turnig Elementary first off is training for all the staff at chigan Elementry going from a no touch policy to a new physical hold slouch policy we've heard during Testament that the in implementation of the sbbs program to Baxter Elementary had staff quit that could be one to two immersion teachers due to the teachers not willing to or not physically being able to deal with possible outbursts that these students might bring what will the so what would the parent volunteers have training or will we lose that special group of individuals on also we will need added security I.E security systems equipment updated rooms glass if we don't have all this in place we we get sued by the Department of Justice once again the effect of
129seeing these outbursts will have a detrimental effect on the kids and decrease the morale in the Outlook of the school the sbbs program is slotted to take up three classrooms taking away the potential growth of the immersion program since the conflict in Russia I am sure the feelings for the program have decreased the the end is coming and so will the feelings the program the feelings and the program will grow Russian speakers will be darly needed in the future these speakers will help heal the negative connotations that the word Russia holds I would suggest placing the spbs program into Inlet View Elementary where the security measures could still be added and implemented into the construction saving time and costs in the long run whereas most upto-date features can be easily added instead of trying to
130retrofit an old existing school good luck and godp speed you're going to upset a lot of people who purchase houses built communities around where they are about to move and close thank you for your time thank you for your testimony next we have Lesley Eden and Mary ferson you will state your name for the record you have three minutes thank you my name is Lesley Eden and I am the Baxter PTA president and a former District parent and teacher from Baxter I would like to thank you for your service and dedication to our students and Community I'd like to share with you why Baxter should continue to be a neighborhood school this is Baxter's 50th year as both an educator and a parent I understand that schools like Baxter are more than just places of
131learning they are Community hub s that provide stability support and a sense of belonging baxer is an essential part of our Comm our neighborhood and district and I believe its closure would have a significant negative consequence for not only the children but the broader Community we have an a large SLC program that you've heard Baxter is a title one uh school and it benefits our Eastside student baure serves a high percentage of students with lowi income families who depend on our nutritional uh daily nutrition at school breakfast and lunch they come very hungry as a title one school Bacher is able to um have a full-time counselor we have an interventionist to meet our social emotional and academic needs of these student populations two of the schools where backer students are to be relocated are
132not title one they don't have those Services don't think you can get them because I hear we have money problems and um I don't believe that um they have the capacity to fully support these populations we have a food pantry we provide uh food for our families on Long weekends and breaks we have an after school program Baxter is a vital neighborhood School fostering a sense of community and connection while offering its students a safe and positive learning environment our students walk to and from school our general population only 25% uh are assigned to ride the bus but they don't they walk there's only maybe 20 students on those buses so many walk students might not be able to participate in after school clubs Dune might not have been able to she walks the bog
133um if um with all these great activities because parents face Transportation challenges baxer would make a perfect receiving school for another small school or a charter school in Baxter's 50 years we have had the Spanish Immersion program that left we had multi-sensory instruction program that left um then we had the sbbs program that left and then we had SLC which we still have the building was extensively remodeled in 1999 and updated for sbbs and the SLC now everything that was said earlier about graduation rates just confirmed that backra Elementary should remain open with its specific ability to nurture and support our East students thank you thank you very much for your testimony good evening my name is Mary Fulkerson I'm a kindergarten teacher at Baxter um I feel like I could say ditto to a
134lot of the things but one of the thing I wanted to ask you about if you received cassia's petition to save Baxter she i' had given that to a gentleman in the back and he said he was going to give it to you she a lot of the students thought it was a petition to save her but it just goes to show like how much they care about each other so um you know again we are a title one school I thank you for this opportunity to testify I think that when they said that the plan was built on community of significant Community input it really did include us because we thought we had the two years to figure it out and the announcement the day before Thanksgiving as others have testified did not give
135us a chance to come around and make a cohesive plan as um be Valley and monor schools have been able to do so we do have that SLC program another one of our teachers will talk to that they are uh very vulnerable and we really want to protect them and make sure a really good decision is made for them because I feel like any right sizing discussion cannot be made until you take those students into accounts they can just cannot be moved you know willy-nilly um secondly Baxter is going to be splintered into three possibly five schools if you take into account SLC and the loss of community will be staggering we have a lot of kids with trauma you add that trauma on top it's going to take a lot of time to build
136up the academic and social progress that they're making depending on the school you know if they move there they might be the only New Kid in that school and that again is very isolating and then how many more buses are you going to need I know like I live in a dis I live in one of the neighborhood schools and I don't consider Chester Valley to be my neighborhood it's on the other side of the lake they can't just walk to it so two of the schools are immersion have you looked at how those students are going to fit in on the neighborhood side of that they can't jump in it third grade second grade fifth grade they can't just do that and I know they said that they would um with our Title One
137friends help them figure out how to fill out a freeer reduc lunch form but that doesn't change the hardship like we've said we have the food pantry we have the free breakfast and lunch you know we have the counselor we have the interventionist are our students needs going to be met so um we I'm also wondering like if we will literally fit into the schools I provided you a document that shows that when you take your capacity numbers your enrollment numbers and divide that by the capacity we don't fit it's 92 to 98% whereas if you take nunaka Valley it's at the bottom and you bring it to us we can still fit with our um as C program intact so we hope that you will consider that we really care deeply about our students
138as staff and families and we want to really make a good decision for them thank you thank you very much for your testimony Sarah pedet uh by telephone um if you will star six and unmute and Brian Fulkerson and Libby Pon in person miss pet um if you will go ahead and unmute you have three minutes okay um iep's 504 plans speech therapy I'm sorry say again excuse me um okay I sorry um 54 plan speech therapy counseling these are all the things that have been met at 100% for my children while being Bobcats friends who've turned into families teachers whove who've turned into lifelong friends who've also turned learning into core memories we've been with Baxter for many years my oldest child is second is in her second year of college my youngest has
139grown up in backers she was a bobcat before she even knew it Baxter's future should not have a price tag Baxter has been our home away from home between or sorry we've watched our children grow through baxer from kindergarten to college bter staff has helped my children grow into the successful young children team and adults they are today take into consideration to take the money out of the PO out of the pockets from the board before you take an entire School away from the children to uprate to uproot and rearrange their lives to fit the budget isn't fair to a child it's the board's responsibility to do what's right your poor budget planning should not cost Bobcats their home away from home and then I have faith here who wants to say something as well
140what you got one [Music] minute we don't normally let people share time but if your daughter wants to speak for a minute that would be fine she got phone shy that's okay thank you we can understand thank you very much for your testimony and back to the D yes if one of you will state your name for the record you have three minutes my name is Libby Peterson I'm a special education SLC teacher at Baxter Elementary I'm here tonight on behalf of the 50 families that attend the largest structured learning program I want you to focus on that word structured students who attend the structured Learning Classroom require just that structure in January of 2022 just three years three years ago students were up uprooted from tarmigan elementary and moved to Baxter just this past
141summer due to resizing more students were uprooted again and moved now ASD wants to move the most V vulnerable students again making students attend four different schools and they haven't even reached fifth grade students who require the most intense structure of all in this district and ASD wants to yet move them again with every move students are losing out on months and months of academics and social skills our students in the SLC program can take up to six months to regain their academics and social skills every time they are moved remember they have never moved homes it's ASD that is moving them from school to school they do not deserve this treatment they need stability they need structure at Baxter we focus on the school as a whole the School focuses on our student students
142being included through inclusion students in the SLC program Walk The Halls they join classes the entire School knows them because they are a part of the school like every other student it has taken years to build rapport with the teachers and students the combined efforts of the SLC staff and parents has created an environment within Baxter in which all students are accepted the typical developing students are the peers that these students will have when they move on to Middle School those students will be their advocates in the general education setting closing Baxter and moving all students around is extremely hurtful to their social life and their academics I'm asking that you consider the detrimental impacts closing backer is going to cause to the SLC program and to the Baxter families thank you and if you'll
143state your name for the record you have three minutes good evening my name is Brian Fulkerson and let me just start by saying the amount of irony of starting this meeting talking about interventions to help high school kids graduate and then moving to talking about closing elementary schools where those basic core skills are learned just gives me a headache um my wife Mary uh has been a teacher at Baxter for 15 years and when she started there Baxter was a thriving slingerland school had 350 students and a principal who had a vision when sbbs was moved to Baxter 100 students moved out and those students have not come back and in the last five years Baxter has had four different principles three of those principles were firste principles and two of them are no longer
144in education a school cannot survive without strong leadership and that is laid on the district if if you close Baxter what you're doing is you're just admitting defeat Baer has a a population base well there are 179 students who are zoned for Baxter who do not attend Baer if even half of those students came back Baxter would be at 360 and would not need to be would not even be on this list so it all it requires is for you to give Baxter a CH chance give Baxter the two years give Baxter a principal who is committed to the welfare of its students and in two years you'll even you'll wonder why bter was even on this list because the community of Baxter as you have seen believes in Baxter and there's absolutely no way
145that there would be a reason for it to close thank you thank you for your testimony liby Peterson and Sarah mcau oh I'm sorry okay um Sarah mcau and Michael Davis oh okay oh sorry I gotcha um Rachel Gage the second person thank you and if you'll state your name for the record you have three minutes my name is Sarah mcau thank you for hearing my testimony this evening I sent an email a few weeks ago trying to appeal to the cerebral part of the decision you have to make tonight I came in person today to appeal to the emotional part I spent a day trying to figure out what my best method was and at the end of the day the only thing I could come up with is the thing that I have
146to offer you is my heart I'll giveit you to hold until you're finished voting I ask you to be careful with it there's nothing more terrifying than living with your heart outside of your body which is what happens when you have children Hearts bruise and they break I need mine I need it to work for another 30 to 50 years I don't know how many consecutive life sentences I going through right now but I'm going to serve my time and I need you to keep my heart intact autism spectrum disorders run in my family at least four people in two generations that I'm aware of I don't know about my extended family my nephew's a young adult who suffered greatly through his school experience his school was concerned about his academic achievements but not his
147social achievements if you know kids on the autism spectrum they have a lot of quirk his school didn't tolerate his quirks they didn't teach the other students to tolerate his quirks and he was ostracized by the time he finished grade school he was such a pariah that it followed him into Middle School my sister was left with the choice to pull him out of that school district and drive him 30 minutes each way for the rest of his school career so that not only could he have an education but he could have friends as well when my son was diagnosed with an Autism Spectrum Disorder I went to my family for guidance because after my nephew's experience I did know not know how to get my son through that experience himself and what they told
148me is that whenever you go to a meeting for your son you bring your husband because otherwise they are going to look at you like you are just a crazy helicopter mom and they will dismiss everything you have to say so I did and when I brought my son to first grade expecting to have an adversarial relationship with his school I never found it because Fire Lake has always been a supportive Community to their children in their special learning classes if you keep Fire Lake open I'll continue to look for my adversary I don't think I'm going to find it thank you for your time thank you for your test moment and if you'll state your name for the record you have three minutes my name is Rachel I'm with Fire Lake Elementary um I've
149already talked about the SLC and the significant impact moving the program will pause I stand by what I said um but if you haven't heard me already then you truly do not understand and you won't hear me now so I chose to speak again today because I wanted to reut some of what Mr Anderson said to you earlier in the meeting today but I do want to start by pointing out um that the schools in Eagle River are clustered to one side of Eagle River we have alang glow Ravenwood Homestead Eagle River Elementary and then Fire Lake Birchwood and Chugiak by Clos in Fire Lake you risk setting up our community to have the same issues you are currently dealing with in Anchorage when the while the district is trying to close schools that are
150clustered together and if you look at Eagle River Building is going to occur on this side of town as is already happening so I want to talk about what Mr Anderson said earlier today uh he talked about boundary exemp exemptions into Eagle River Elementary he said the vast majority of which is the optional program 50 to 80 plus parents driving to Eagle River Elementary and he said a significant number are from the firelake boundary Zone he said if fir Lake was to close those parents would then likely receive busing and that would alleviate some of the traffic the same could be said if the optional program were moved to Fire Lake only those families would receive busing because they are in our Zone then he said quote although we can't prevent or change the roads
151the parking lot or the entry of the school I think you would see several buses come to this school and eliminating quite a few Vehicles end quote there he is wrong we can change the roads we can change the parking lot we can change the entry because at Fire Lake we don't have those issues then he said quote they are correct it is a crowded Street like many other schools in the district end quote but again that is not the case at Fire Lake I'm not suggesting that you shut down eag Elementary instead of us I'm telling you that the district made a mistake in choosing Fire Lake they did not do their due diligence and now their arguments are solely made to justify that mistake so again I thank you for listening I thank
152you for reading our letters for coming to our school for hearing us letting us know that you are listening and thank you for your consideration for fire Leake thank you for your testimony Charles mcke and Dr Amber merits I believe I'm not sure if I can read it correctly [Music] I [Music] have thank you and Dr Bamber if you can spell your name we're having trouble reading it we just want to get it right for the record capital b a m b r g hyphenated capital m e r r i t t first name is Gloria thank you you have three minutes I uh come before you today as a concerned citizen as a taxpayer and a mental health professional I would like to thank you for letting me appear and to just provide my
153information on some research in reference to our district the question is if East Side Elementary Schools closes will the education budget change and how much would it help with the right sizing plan of the Anor School District to fix the infrastructure of the anchor School District the Anor School District rightsizing plan is to close underutilize elementary schools and consolidate students because of the decline of students enrollment of 6,500 students actually the research was provided by the superintendent and he went as back as 2010 over the same period a large student population switched to number one correspondent schools number two District supported schooling options number three future reducing of the number of students in the classroom in the enrollment in the correspondent schools though it went up to 118% that's uh some research from 2010 also
154some research and information from December 11 2024 our governor spoke and he said that he has a plan to introduce an education Bill paing funding increase reform he says quote we're going to introduce a bill on education funding that believe will com come be comprehensive period I'll be a uh there will be a combination of increased funding and again out comes like we discussed last year number one charter schools that's that was a discussion number two correspondent schools and number three the neighborhood schools well some information I would like for you to consider before you vote tonight have we provided adequate Staffing and support for the current staff members and are res supporting special education and special needs students according to the laws that we have on the books and also the right sizing plan
155what is it specifically because I didn't see it on on the website your time has expired thank you very much for your testimony Mr mck you state your name for the record you have three minutes my name's of course I'm a beneficiary of the mcke trust my name is Charles at key and you have those documents to affirm that that I turned in I also like you to look at uh recording District 301 Anchorage under my name Charles mcke filed and uploaded and that was last Thursday and title of that is a um prejudicial fix and you'll see in there an astounding representation of our shall we say civil injury caused by representatives in the legislature in the past so I would bring to you the the the fact that I have recorded to CES
156K trust and that is under fiary relationships on page 553 out of Black Law Dictionary and you page to turn to page 54 754 it talks about the sesate trust and its relationship to me to anybody else and the response of the public officer involving tier one Federal tier 2 State tier three corporation if they're involved in undermining you substantially then the corpor the the activity of the agency and or agent can be held responsible and that is the case with me and uh the corporation of court and its agent involving himself personally into my Affairs here in Anchorage and uh so I bring that to your attention and my trust is $900 billion I have a claim for at $80 million plus and growing and so when I acquire that remedy then the residual
157impact of that would obviously impact the educational system in Anchorage because I've been here since I was 13 I'm 71 now that being said I already went to the school I mean I already went to Anchorage assembly the 10th of September and voiced that because I owe an obligation to the Lutheran and Catholic Social Services because I'm indebted to their so you can look at that thank you thank you very much your time is expired that brings us to the end of our west of people who have signed up to testify do thank everyone who has come you got all of them I think so um do appreciate everyone coming and and speaking to us with that we move to section e on the consent agenda does anyone wish to pull items on the consent
158agenda member lessons I'd like to pull memo 061 please with uh no objection from other members on the board that will be moved to the first action item there's someone that needs to to uh be available for that that needs to be owned as quickly as possible so we yes item 12 under the consent agenda and rather than putting it at the end of the action items it'll be the first action item anyone else wish to pull an item seeing no hands is the president moved to approve the consent agenda as amended second moved and seconded to approve the consent agenda is everyone prepared to vote by machine I know this takes us back a few years and you have approved the consent agenda that brings us to action items and the first one uh
159number 61 if I got to have a motion Mr President I move to approve AC memorandum number 61 acceptance of Grant award FY 2025 student support and academic enrichment ssae grant program as revised to accept the FY 2025 student support and academic enrichment ssae Grant award from the Department of Education in the amount of $3,238 642 for the services provided between 10124 and 9325 this funding supports year two of a 5year grant is there a second second okay moved and seconded for ASD memorandum number 61 discussion member Wesson yeah just to refresh everyone's memory this memo is before us tonight uh because it was tabled from the November 4th meeting um it is the acceptance of the grant award fy22 student support and academic enrichment or ssae grant program essentially it's the second year of
160funding from the US Department of Education to support implementation of the academies of Anchorage in the five-year um award that uh sort of has broadly been announced um or was was announced uh you know 15 18 months ago um prior to the the November 4th meeting I had drafted and submitted to our secretary a substitute memo for potential board consideration but that uh document was never uh brought to the board's attention during that meeting because this memo was tabled until tonight um that substitute memo was however attached to the agenda and um in the interim the governance committee really graciously allowed me to share uh the substance of the substitute memo in the late November governance committee meeting and I really appreciated the robust discussion that we had at that time um tonight the existing
161memo that you see before you uh has a slight revision courtesy of the administration and and I do want to say that it uh likely reflects reflects the conversation from governance uh and I appreciate the administration acknowledging uh the pivot that happened on November 18th uh which was to not move forward with theem uh as initially uh conceptualized with respect to that um schedule change so the current addition in the the revision that you see before you in the memo 061 uh asserts that the administration is currently working to refine the acmy of uh Anchorage implementation plan and may adjust the use of Grant funds in future years and I think that's really important however I still see when I look at the memo as it stands kind of a fundamental disconnect uh because the
162pertinent fact section of the memo remains unchanged and it still asserts that we're going to be implementing wall to wallmy in essentially year three which is FY 26 with the Grant and general fund funds even though um that's not necessarily the case right we've been advised even in this meeting that there's going to be an adjusted approach reflecting our fisical realities um so I really do appreciate um that that adjustment uh it's a challenging adjustment to make um that said I am interested in bringing before you um a substitute to my substitute um which is I believe you have a paper copy it's uh it would be memorandum 061 S1 so I mve to substitute memorandum 061 S1 for memorandum 061 we have a short edes e e e we can come back to order
163at 857 I apologize to the audience we had something of a confusing situation which I believe we have worked out out so we are currently um on item number 61 um we do have a basically a substitute motion that has been introduced and I believe we probably have a member that wants to uh make a procedural motion about the substitute motion perhaps yeah okay and let me say first of all we don't have a second yet so I I do need to step back and ask for a second on the substitute right Mr chair um yes member Bellamy I I appreciate the Ed EAS um but it seems like when I did my prep for this board meeting on Sunday mhm this was not in the packet MH that is against our our process come
164and which means the public has not had an opportunity to um to do this as to to look at this uh memo as well correct so so let me ask is there a second to the substitute motion seeing seeing none um it fails to be considered and we are back to memorandum 61 as was entered on the uh entered on the agenda and I I'm going to have to apologize we did not actually get a motion putting number 61 on the floor yes you did K second did you yes okay obviously my memory is not going long term here so the original item number 61 is on the FL for consideration if we do not have a second for the substitute motion it dies so act of a second and I'm not seeing anyone second
165okay what before us is item number 61 as on the agenda originally and this could all be reintroduced at a later time is there discussion on item number 61 seeing none uh we will put that to a vote op and it should be on your screen for you now student member Pat if you would vote yes thank you and if members will vote you have passed item number 61 on a 6 to1 vote okay now move to ASD memorandum number 071 Mr President I move to approve AC memorandum number 071 fiscal year 2025 2026 profor of financial planning Outlook and budget development Guidance the uh recommended actions to approve and authorize the superintendent to prepare the ASD FY 2526 preliminary financial plan and budget in accordance with the financial projections and budget guidance set forth
166in this memorandum s a second second moved and seconded to consider item number 71 is there a discussion member B me did you have a comment or okay thank you um seeing no no hands or comment I will ask the the solving to put it on your screens for a vote and student member pack if you would vote on the item number yes should be on your screen now and you have accepted the proor of financial planning Outlook and budget development guidance that brings us to item number two under action items number 79 Mr President I move to approve as memorandum number 79 as Anchorage assembly joint resolution regarding State funding for schools recommended action is to approve memo 79 which is titled a joint resolution of the Anchorage Municipal assembly the Anchorage school board
167and support of the fair inflation adjusted State funding to require uh required to maintain a public school system uh and increase student performance a second moved and seconded for the joint resolution on state funding is there a discussion member Higgins just for the audience sake um the working with the assembly on trying to get additional funding from the state their support in working with the Anor School District I greatly appreciate it um it it got it's a unified effort here to help kids and I uh just want to say thank you for them thank you other com member Lon thank you um I think we had a chance to speak about this in one of our uh committee meetings last last week um but for uh tonight's purposes just a quick reminder that this would
168be the second year should our body pass a joint resolution the second year in a row that the board and assembly would pass a joint resolution in support of the fair inflation adjusted funding required to maintain uh our school system and um so the uh pertinent facts uh are by and large very similar to last year's the figures have been updated um there's a little bit of a history lesson and part of it um I think a couple of critical pieces that were added to uh to this resolution were um analysis from the end of September uh by the state of Alaska's legislative finance division regarding uh the scale of uh education funding if the BSA had been adjusted for inflation all the way back to July 1st 2010 which is the start of our
16920 fy1 school year 20 20101 is fy1 so the division so it incorporates the state's Z data and the division determined that the peak year over the past 15 years adjusted for inflation is fy1 which would be 7579 and FY $24 while the fy2 that's this year's figure is 5815 in fy4 it's a little technical anyways if you adjust the fy11 figure to projected FY $25 uh that would total 7 768 and here's the core to match the buying power because ultimately we're buying Services we're buying health care we're buying salaries we're buying reams of paper um to match the buying power of the fy11 BSA this year the BSA would need to increase by $188 uh from 5960 to 7768 however that's this year and we're talking about next year so the second main
170piece of information incorporated into this joint resolution adjusts the the state of Alaska's legislative finance division the 1808 figure for this year by 2% for FY 26 and so that's where this figure of 1963 comes from so I just wanted to take a little moment to clarify that there's a lot of um information that is very similar because our situation has not changed uh but I did want to make sure folks are understanding that it's incorporating the best um data that we have and so I would urge um unanimous support and it would be wonderful to send uh the document over to our colleagues in the assembly any other comment member Don thank you Mr President I just wanted to highlight in the second resolve items two three and four and that's directing and appropriating
171necessary funds to pay for a state funded iser study of the district cost factor is item two um we actually um never envisioned when we when we drafted the current funding system uh for education in the state that we would go 20 years without a district cost Factor study um and discriminates so objectively against our students in this community it's an outrage and the fact that the legislature has failed to appropriate you know a DI Minimus amount of money compared to the overall education budget to accomplish something which is objectively unfair to this community is an outrage in my opinion um we so bad that about five years ago working with u chair trainy of the assembly at the time we actually uh the assembly appropriated the funds to conduct an iser study of the
172district cost Factor but iser said that since it would be funded by Anchorage the other the rest of the state wouldn't trust it then we went to the uh School uh this School Board Association of Alaska and asked if we gave you the money would you do it and they said no we're afraid to do it because the Anchorage you know it's a too politically Hot Potato there'd be winners and losers we don't want to get blamed with that so we won't do it either so we made every attempt to find some neutral third party that would do it and we've been unable to do that so it's all way back on the legislature now to do this um and um we just recently hired an expert analysis of this and in talking to him
173his guess was pretty much the same as mine financially that this is costing our students something close to $30 million in Fair State funding a year um and so that was the expert we had hired here um number three passing additional legislation that would update the uh District Cost U factor on a trienal basis is just a great idea it's something that I wish we would have thought of at the time we wrote These laws we just never occurred to us that we'd go this long without having one done so mopa I I wish I would have thought of that 30 years ago um and then passing additional legislation number three passing additional legislation that would update the district well number four actually the return to the historic models of cost sharing for capital projects
174I think there's a clear constitutional uh question in the suspension of bond reimbursement for only some citizens in this state on Capital Construction of schools I don't think that passes the redface fairness test uh to this community that that was suspended impacting us so desparately from other communities around the state and so I think that's just an essential element of this resolution thank you thank you for your comments any other member B just a real quick couple of comments uh first of all um if for the members of the public who has might not have had opportunity to read the resolution please read it it actually gives not just a historical but historical and our current um overview of our current historical and current situation um so I do want to thank we had a
175work group that worked uh with the um with assembly members uh I think it was brona Broly and Rivera who oh Martinez and Mr Martinez you're right and then we had uh our work group uh member lessons was it Andy and me anyway member lessons uh did Yan's job in putting all this together especially when you know looking at trying to make sure that we incorporated all the things that member Donley just referenced uh but also what what it means for us I mean if it if we have to cut 500 58 positions that's not that's true I mean that's true we don't want to have to do that uh but it does um it really is a uh it's aspirational uh but I think these are the things that that our legislators need to
176know and so I do want to thank um the assembly we discussed it with them at our last joint meeting uh and I think they will be approving it first of the year if all goes well so thank you I urge every uh the full support of the resolution thank you any other comments seeing none I'll ask Miss Sullivan to put it to a vote and member pack did you want to do an advisory vote yes thank you done and we have unanimously passed the joint resolution on state funding that brings us to Revis number four memorandum number 73 ASD right sizing plan Mr President I move to approve ASD memorandum number 7 3 ASD right sizing plan the recommended actions to approve and authorize the superintendent to implement the closure of the following schools
177at the end of the 20124 2025 school year in order to right siize the district's infrastructure Baxter fire lake lake hood and new Naka Valley elementary schools each of the four buildings would be repurposed for an existing ACD charter school is there a second second moved and seconded to approve memorandum number 073 is there a discussion Mr President member Jacobs with your Indulgence I have a series of amendments I'd like to walk the board through first is I'd like to move Jacob's Amendment 1s there's a second I'll speak to my motion second yep so all right for the record I'll read in um Amendment 1s unless you don't think it's necessary Mr chair um it is posted door agenda I'm trying to remember how long it is um I don't believe the whole thing needs
178to be read in but perfect then I then I'll just speak to it um the memorandum which is posted to our agenda and has been um since the agenda was posted online publicly um addresses a few different items um in an attempt to make uh this motion more palatable for at least myself and also address is um known potential improvements and adjustments to this plan which I think benefit our entire community and um promise to improve access to transformational uh educational opportunities for ASD students um it it does not and should not reflect um a an effort to um remove uh the option for board members to continue modifying this memorandum and should they support this amendment with that said uh the um Amendment first would propose that the repurposing plan for lakehood elementary school
179include um consideration by administration of not just a charter school but also an existing District special program um we've heard multiple board members Express um skepticism and concern U myself included about locating a charter school um in the corner of West Anchorage and so I think um we want the I would prefer the district du due diligence to ensure that the best possible outcome is um present for that facility should it be repurposed the second is to bring um an equal enrollment cap for tutor ele tutor Elementary monory program to make a case six which is in line with denelli monory program um we've heard from families at least I've heard from families which I think that that is a solution um which brings parody and would be appreciated by those families that choose to
180make that choice with minimal impacts to programming uh the third item is uh prompts the administration to provide a amended six-year Capital Improvement plan to the board which reprioritizes uh capital investment Wonder Park Elementary for those who may not remember Wonder Park um had a prominent place in our six-year CIP as recently is just a few years ago um then was removed this would restore that um place in the CIP and um related process as administration reviews to see what capital uh what level of capital investment best suits um ensuring that the building has increased educational adequacy uh the amendment also relinquishes management control for the uh large parcel of land which is about 25 acres at 2955 molding road to the mo MOA uh for a purpose that they will deem fit um I
181personally have thoughts but I want to stay in my Lane as a member of the school board um and then we'll certainly Advocate as a citizen once the municipal um leadership has that parcel of land available to them next the um memorandum Amendment would prompt District administration to begin collaborating on a student transportation support plan with any Charter program being considered for placement uh at Baxter fire lake lake Hood in Nuna should this memorandum pass as currently drafted um the proposed plans will leverage statutory funding along with um savings that'll be available from the U charter school program budget um as we know our transportation budget is subsidized heavily uh through investment by the Municipality of Anchorage because the um Alaska legislature has failed to adjust those costs for inflation since fy16 um and so
182uh the um plans for supporting our Charter programs and increased Transportation uh where currently there is none will likely require additional subsidy as well and so that's why the collaboration will need to take place and then lastly um is a I think a improved um item which hasn't gone addressed but was it stated by um Administration which is um was suggest by member lessons which I appreciate which is to begin collaborating with Charter Schools to um work to prioritize placements inside a neighborhood where a school may be placed um and then present an act after Action Report uh to the board uh no later than 10125 um on the progress and process of right sizing would be happy to answer any questions and I think those are the highlights and much of this should look
183familiar because I've been talking about this one for quite some time thank you thank you very much other comments answer questions member Higgins yeah I guess I just want to hit the first point expanding the repurposing plan review is the intent of the administration to bring that back to us to give us a chance to review it and approve a change or is that being delegated right now we're being asked to basically remove kids current kids in in the school to move out what's going to happen to that school is that something we will be reviewing again um through the president member hiin my understanding of the order of operations is right now the board is focused on the closure conversation for neighborhood schools should this uh me memorandum and Amendment passed the next step
184would be I believe it's the fifth bullet point where we'd start collaborating with ASD Charter programs to start determining who um may or may not be a good fit for those schools then the next step would be working directly with the charter schools to work on some sort of um shared memorandum of understanding that would lay out all of the different uh requirements uh that that we would have as a district to ensure that the charter school um has uh various underrepresented groups represented given that they will have new capacity um should a charter school occupy a neighborhood school I hope that answers the question so essentially first the memorandum then should it pass we will work directly with various charter schools to identify candidates for the space but that would go back to the
185board for final approval similar to how we did um with the um Abbot Loop transition well the language in here talks about repurposing for both an existing District special program and or an existing ASD TR to school that's why I ask oh and that I might need to lean on the writer of the amendment to clarify Mr chair if I might yep so to answer the question directly um this prompts uh that particular bullet point prompts Administration to consider not just a charter program but also um a special program um we've heard just one example a member bring up um the possible match of um wayy as a a fit in um at least one of the buildings um and so I think this provides additional flexibility to Administration while we're providing some basic level
186of Direction um in this memorandum um it is not intended to get ahead of the conversation as to what happens next but since that language is included in the memorandum um it's intended to provide additional flexibility to make sure that we have the best possible fit as administrations begins their work um on what's next thanks member Don yeah I'd move to divide the vote on the second sort of whereas here um which is to expand the tutor Elementary monory program to grades K through six um and have a separate vote on that section there's a lot of unrelated things rolled together here and that particular one is a particular interest to to me and I'd like to be able to vote on it separately there is a motion to divide the question uh by making
187bullet point two uh a separate Amendment I'll second moved and seconded discussion on a motion to divide is that I can't remember if that's debate you can have it but it's I appreciate the second it's kind of self-evident that it stands alone as an issue it's not related to the other things in this proposal um um thank you Carl yeah um and so yeah we'll vote now on whether to divide the question yes point a clarification oh okay question ADV answer member bellam me did you have a question member bellam me did you have a question okay e is there an objection from any board member about dividing the question since it was second by the maker I don't think so strong endorsement um if no one has an objection then the motion will be
188divided e the amendment before the board now is the second bullet point expand the tutor elementary school monor program to grades K through six for the 2526 school year and Beyond which will align the program scope with ASDS other close Reed program to noi monor do we have any discussion on that Amendment member Wilson I just have a question because um I just wanted to confirm that that is the request of tutor Elementary or tutor monor that is their request or is it our request for them Mr chair I can answer that question if you'd like yep so I uh thank you for the question member Wilson I I did I have spoken with stakeholders at um tutor Elementary specifically with our monor program um they value this opportunity for Choice um some of the
189students and families may not opt to elect it but having the opportunity um in line with what exists elsewhere in the district seems fair thank you I I would like um the administration to respond to this as well thank you uh through the president uh this is certainly um feasible for sure the only drawback that I would bring to the board's attention is that given the fact that the district has moved districtwide to 68 middle schools we are seeing a trend where some schools are choosing to go um to a K5 model from a k6 so for example Aquarian charter school I believe um on this agenda or an upcoming one um will be asking the board to move from a k6 model to a K5 and that's because they're seeing um fewer sixth graders
190enroll in that grade level so they can pursue other opportunities and other District facilities um the same um could happen to tutor monor but with that said I have heard from many community members where they've expressed an interest in having uh a high fidelity monor model that's multi-grade up to sixth grade so I think the the amendment is appropriate and poses um small um but transparent risk to the district other discussion member Higgins yeah I'm very familiar with the monasi program with family been in it for a long time and the in the in mono program you got the kindergarten by yourself but then you have one two three and one class four five six in the other class and so the the social interaction the kids teaching younger kids and learning back and forth
191is a component of the mono system with all of their various special types of learning um focused on you know the the visual touching and and sounds and and so this allows it to complete that sixth grade is being with Fifth and fourth graders is part of the program that they like uh I know there's interest uh with some of the monoy family and being able to do that uh some of them feel like since everybody else is going on to six I'd probably be better go ahead anyway so I'm not sure how every family is going to react but I know that there's real interest with the mono program for the purity of the program that they've got they they didn't opt for trying to go a charter school do something else they want
192to be just part of the district but uh this is an important issue to them thank you very much any other comment seeing no hands I ask Miss suvin to put this to a vote should be on your screen again this is a vote on the amendment to the main question uh strictly bullet point number two member pack if you'd like to offer an advisory vote yes oops oh sorry we have a technical difficulty on voting okay the amendment is before email so a yes vote just basically takes it out of this memoranda I mean out of this amend a yes vote amends the motion as an amendment to the main motion right there was no objection to dividing the vote so bullet point two became a new main motion Standalone motion and now that's
193before us to say yes or no to okay I took that as it became a stand one Amendment no it's not an amendment it's a new main motion separate motion and the rest of the text I'm gonna ask if everyone else on the board understands that correctly as well no no no when you divide the vote you've got an original main motion that has multiple things in it they may be unrelated and so if you if the first of all the chair proves that these things are possible to divide make it fair to vote on them so you don't have to vote for something you don't like or something you do like because they're all mushed together right so you when you divide you know which we did we unanimously agreed to set this as
194a separate vote so now what's before us is a vote on whether or not we like this idea and approve this which is the bullet point two so my reading is because the question that was divided was an amendment to the main motion it then became two amendments to the main motion it it's not an amendment because if it was an amendment to the main motion then it would rejoin the motion that would deat the entire purpose of dividing it it's now a separate motion on its own to be voted up or down based on the merits of it I see logic in both ways so the the main thing to me is the clarity um and I'm going to accept member Don's explanation but I do want to make sure that members understand yeah
195if in essence we passed or we are voting on bullet point 2 as a stand along motion yes is everybody clear on that okay and and we can always go argue about Robert some other day Okay so it is a stand one motion on its own and and it did pass 70 member pack did you want to give a advice vote yes thank you [Music] um yes she and then to the board just to make sure so what we are left with is the remainder of that Amendment which is still an amendment to the main motion okay so open for discussion while Miss Sullivan gets everything back together again um you still have the rest of the amendment to the main motion and one of the things all asked while she was doing that um
196does the administration have any comment about relinquishing management of the 24 and 3/4 acre parcel on moldun Road thank you Mr President uh so my assessment is that there's little risk to the district relinquishing that land um we do have quite a bit of excess capacity as the the board understands um and should there be an increase in enrollment there's always the possibility that we can look at other models of renovating or rebuilding schools for example we could build upwards um instead of having a single level elementary school as an example if we were so stretch for capacity that we needed um more uh facilities for students and with that said um by relinquishing this land back to the municipality um it could be used for a high impact Initiative for the um betterment of
197the entire Community I would leave it to the municipality to Define what that looks like but it opens up the potential to do something positive for the community um with that said uh Mr Anderson do you have anything to add no not at this time yeah thank you very much other discussion on the remainder of the amendment not seeing any hands what's before you is the motion to amend the main question by adopting the remaining part of Jacob's Amendment 1s oh lessons M [Music] lessons that should be on your screen and member pack if you wish to give an advisory vote Yes and we have amended memorandum number 73 Mr chair the main question is before you again member Jacobs yep U with your leeway I would move lessons Jacobs amendment number one if you'd
198like I can read this into the record it's a bit shorter half a page otherwise it has been publicly posted as well so I can just speak to it if you'd like okay I'll just move to speaking to it and not read it verbatim um this amendment in particular um I would First Express appreciation for uh member lence and the collaboration that took place which made this possible um it um acknowledges that the right sizing plan is currently constituted um is is missing a number of buildings that we we started the conversation with which were um taken off by Administration after the initial proposal was released which I think um reflects the process was refined and that we heard and listened to the communities of District um with that said um I think there's a
199a need to acknowledge that there are sections of the municipal of Anchorage that are left unaddressed and the excess capacity that exists in our elementary schools by the current proposal which is really focused on West Anchorage East Anchorage and Eagle River at present um this memorandum would First Direct the superintendent to recommend one additional school for um consolidation or right sizing um this uh the next school year um it acknowledges that we should uh prioritize um removing the number of combination classes and amongst elementary students and improving um access to course offerings um and providing additional supports and um and then additionally provides flexibility for the District administration to um alleviate some of the guardrail that existed regarding special programs um which um Exempted some facilities um preventing potentially an Optimum um candidate for consolidation
200of right sizing uh to be presented by the administration happy to answer questions um thank you and also I failed to ask for a second second I'm thinking member was wanted to do that so thank you moved and seconded other discussion on the proposal uh member Wesson yeah I appreciate member Jacob speaking to this as the co-author of uh this potential Amendment it really came from uh time from my end of things it came from the time I have spent looking at um enrollment information and the CIP and all the other sources of data that I get my hands on and I'm I'm quite frankly really concerned uh not just about school size but when we have special programs embedded within schools funny things happen to FTE allocations and in a number of our schools
201the students who are on the neighborhood side of a school with a special program um maybe their enrollment is drifting uh to less than optimal numbers so they're having challenges standing up even one you know first grade class one second grade class um so we have a number of schools with very small neighborhood side enrollments and I I don't want to propose the path forward but I Envision that some kind of a Tetris moving some of our programs around one or more programs around could help optimize FTE that's the Staffing that eventually gets to the students that are the neighborhood side of our neighborhood schools and so that that for me is the core of this um and there are certainly areas of town which uh are not in the current um proposal which as
202member Jacobs um shared a moment ago uh they may also stand we may still improve student outcomes uh by consolidating students thank you member wison so we have not yet discussed the four schools that are on the list for repurposing today so I just I want some clarification is the request we're asking the board to recommend to the superintendent and the administration to continue this process in future years essentially that's how I'm reading it is is we have not voted on these four schools yet but we're asking for already asking for future years to look at repurposing member Jacobs yep no appreciate the question member Wilson I think this portion of the conversation is especially relevant because before we've started our conversation tonight Administration has removed buildings from the right I think conversation um representing
203significant parts of the Municipality of Anchorage so in my opinion before we can talk about um addressing the the buildings still on this list I think we need to acknowledge that um at least in Midtown and South Anchorage we aren't talking about right sizing any longer we're talking about right sizing in West Anchorage East Anchorage and Eagle River um this acknowledges that Gap in addressing excess capacity and other corners of our municipality um where we should be having that conversation which is why there were schools originally listed um Administration has made the decision that the candidates that were originally presented um weren't the best candidates and so I this admin this amendment is intended to direct Administration to work to identify another candidate um what I would hope and expect is it's a region of
204town that is under represented on this current memorandum um and that's the ask and that's what the underlying amendment is for thanks and I have a question to the makers of the motion when you say they for the board commits to revisiting the authorization oh I'm sorry I had fli that just I apologize and withdraw that other discussion see no no hands or we'll pause for a moment are we ready for a vote I'll ask Miss Sullivan to put a vote on your screen member pack if you wish to give an advisory vote just e we have adopted uh Lon Jacobs amendment number one Mr chair yes member Jacobs thank you and appreciate the leeway while we get through the I think the series of amendments which can help lay the foundation for this conversation
205in Earnest um I would move leson Jacobs amendment number two second moved and seconded do you like to speak to your Amendment yeah thank you Mr chair um this amendment in particular um addresses um a a positive potential outcome where the board specifically would um revisit the conversation should the legislature take action necessary to um reverse um the underlying causes of of why we're seeing um decline in of enrollment in elementary schools and um stagnation uh in um flat funding of Education um it is essentially indicates that the board is committing to revisiting the authorization of this amendment should the um legislature and the governor Implement a long-term fiscal plan um enact legislation which adjust the BSA to account for inflation since since fy1 and enact legislation uh to address the BSA for inflation on
206an annual basis going forward s subject to legislative appropriation that is the the what it does um Mr President I appreciate the opportunity to speak and again the leeway um we've heard a lot of truly impactful testimony over the last few months about our extremely dire Financial deficit circumstances and the challenges facing our districts um District um we've heard a lot of positive uh and impactful testimony um just tonight regarding passion for our Public Schools um I'd like to take just a moment to express my appreciation and then my own personal perspective um I think it's time to to do what's right it's time to bring Financial stability back to public education for more than a decade no long-term fiscal plan focused on fixing the funding flaws in Alaska's public education formula has passed the
207Alaska state legislature let me say that we do have a strong group of legislators who have been fighting for us and and I do thank them I'm talking about particular legislators who continue to fail in strong leadership and fail those who elected them next month we have another chance to get it right we are one of many Alaska school school districts grappling with daunting structural deficits declining in enrollment and a broken teacher retirement system that does does not even fully fund Social Security benefits nor a pension what elasa needs now is the same thing Alaska needed more than a decade ago we need courage from our elected leaders and state government to put personal agendas aside and adopt a Clear Vision for our future as a state via sustainable long-term fiscal plan it is the
208legislator's responsibility to adequately fund our schools and while I applaud the legislators who voted to override the governor's veto of sp40 we need to be clear $680 of per pupil funding was never going to fill the growing hole a lack of inflation proofing education funding has cost I sincerely hope the 34th Alaska legislature quickly adopts fiscal policies which allow appropriate funding of public education the University of Alaska system an investment in a values-based retirement plan and increased supports for working parents to include quality Child Care imp improved public transit and access to Affordable Healthcare a prim Ary goal of government services should be to catch residents before they fall through the cracks government can't fix everything but defunding the systems government does well as our state at a breaking point I appreciate the leeway and
209I'm glad to answer any questions before we vote on this and would urge you yes vote thanks other questions or comments member Wesson um thank you member Jacobs for introducing the amendment um just to focus on what this would do um so if the legislature and the governor take those actions that support the state that support education in an extremely timely fashion before the board's second meeting in February which is when we have to pass our balanced budget the day after we pass our balanced budget whatever that entails the staff as we talked about in one of our committee meetings last week uh February 19th Begins the Staffing procedures so timeliness for for FY 26 and that's going to start at the school level and um and and just it will Encompass a lot of
210uh the HR movement of Staff um so given the additional resources that these actions should the legislature and Governor take uh would generate um I think it would be us to um reexamine closures approved tonight to see whether additional classrooms in each of these schools would still fit right instead of two second grade classrooms maybe we need three um so on and so forth so this is a um a possible path forward should transformation take place in a timely fashion other comments member Don my concern is this isn't essentially just intent language because there's nothing in this language that couldn't be accomplished by four votes of the board at any time um the other thing is it says um that we would only be revising potentially talking about revising after these three elements are are
211adopted I think there's times we might want to consider revising without each of these three elements being adopted there's so many variables that can occur during the legislative session and different schemes for funding it may not fit the these exact three items and I think we ought to be free to reexamine if there's an appropriate amount of funding to justify a reexamination whether or not these particular three items are passed so I I understand the the bealing behind it but I don't think it's necessary to include in this particular um memorandum member Jacobs yeah thank you appreciate the points and wanted to answer just a couple direct questions um as with all intent language it's it's never necessary um but I think it does provide a a critical function as to the board's um intent
212and perspective and I truly believe a majority of the the board would um support this amendment should these items happen um these are um this is what our state needs to reverse a decade about migration this is what our state needs to retain our Educators this is what our State needs to um meet its constitutional obligation to adequately fund public education frankly and so if these three items are addressed I'm confident the majority of this board will uh value revisiting this recommendation um the board could choose to take other action separately if um something else were to occur and this passing this amendment wouldn't preclude that from happening um this is purely intended to um lay the framework for the leadership we need from Juno this next legislative session thanks other comments and I would
213add in that that in conversations with legislators uh particularly ones that aren't necessarily inclined to vote for Education funding is frequently the question of what is this going to buy us are we going to increase the BSA and just see that money disappear um I think this makes explicit that we would commit to revisiting neighborhood school closures if the legislature will take these steps um but I don't think it precludes us from considering it if other things change that that we think are relevant and make it possible to so I I support this as a way of being able to send a message to legislators this is a critical thing it matters to your constituents but really unless we have a BSA increase unless we have a long-term plan we feel like our hands are
214tied on it I I support this amendment any other comments member Bellman thank you I I do appreciate the um the board revisiting being able to revisit uh and and and I think uh as this board has done many times we're we're not limited to just these three things um but I do think these three things are most important uh before before um you know as a pathway to revisit so I I will support it thank you any other comments I'll ask Miss Sullivan to put it before you to vote member pack if you'll give an advisory vote Yes e you have adopted uh lesson Jacobs amendment number two 6 to one this puts us back to the main motion member lessons yeah I would move uh lessons Amendment one which reads I move to
215strike the words lak Hood from the section labeled recommendation and to make a corresponding change by replacing the word four with three to read as follows it's the administration's recommendation that the school board approve and authorize the superintendent to implement the closure of the following schools at the end of the 24 25 school year in order to rightsize the district's infrastructure Baxter Fire Lake and unaka Valley elementary schools each of the three buildings would be repurposed for an existing ASD Charter School do I have a second remember Higgins I couldn't hear you seconded by member Higgins um member Waton do you want to speak to your motion sure I thank you very much for the opportunity to speak to the motion um I have spent a great deal of time with the information the Administration
216has shared I've pursued other sources of information in existing District portals and taken a number of site visits um and I will just say this is the most challenging vote I been asked to uh make as a board member um since joining the board in 2021 um so well I I do believe that a turnig again like Hood pairing actually has its merits um fundamentally I see the the benefit of school consolidation line and the fact that additional teachers will be able to collaborate lead learn from one another um have additional adults in the building to uh support reduced combination classes um however I don't think that Lake Hood in this situation is the right school to close for purposes of allocating to a charter school which is the proposition directly before us tonight um
217at a numerical level fewer K5 uh students attend turnig again on the neighborhood side than attend lak Hood um while lak Hood's capacity is 469 turnig is actually larger um in addition turnig has Superior access to to a major thoroughfare including a pull through Lane just off Northern Lights um Lake Hood by contrast is tucked into a neighborhood where uh for me it's challenging to imagine 400 or so cars at pick up and drop off um I am I have been worried I'll Perhaps Perhaps this concern is no longer relevant that the proposed consolidation of lak hood into turnig again could potentially undermine the future of the Russian immersion program by prohibiting a kindergarten class larger than one classroom um which given K12 attrition rates for immersion programs could be problematic in the long run
218um the I recognize that there has been a trend of declining enrollment in recent years um I wouldn't want to kneecap um the Russian emersion program given Alaska strategic Place uh in world affairs at this moment in time um and then I will just speak at a personal level um I recognize that lak hood is a newer facility it's a 1990s model facility although turnig again had a beautiful renovation recently but I think that the fundamental design of lakeh hood is more developmentally appropriate for students to use especially those who may be coming from um traumatic or challenging backgrounds in so far as it remains quite walkable for its current students and would either be walkable or a short bus ride for absorb turnig again students it was built with restrooms and primary classrooms to
219allow students to practice ages geny in small but meaningful ways um and when I went to lak hood for the first time I was really struck by Lake Hood's extensive green spaces which it's hard to put a figure on green space but uh I believe that green spaces are um exceptionally important for students uh mental health and well-being physical activity and I believe they would be really supportive of uh maybe the higher risk population my understanding of the lakeh hood facility is that it's it already has uh defined classrooms for the spbs program um it already has a defined classroom for music which is different than where the music classroom is at turnig again which is positioned with an HVAC duct which conducts the music classroom directly into the classroom adjacent um so it's a
220subtle thing but it it matters um so those were a number of the factors that uh really came to my mind um but procedurally so my fundamental belief proposition before me as a board member is do I close Lake Hood in this case to bring a charter school there and um for the purpose of public and and I think the answer is no but I also think that the for the purpose of public process it's not appropriate for me to recommend the closure of an alternative school at this time so I'm left as an individual board member either voting for something that I don't think makes sense or amending the recommendation given to the board by redacting an element with which I disagree so that's why I have redacted lakehood in this case other discussion
221member Higgins well I thank you did and and I my my purpose here is that I can see Lake Hood existing and expanding and bringing other things into it and we'll focus on emptying out the school completely when we can we can utilize it more effectively I mean we got the issue of wayy that they that I heard from wayy you got other issues where you don't have to take the kids out of the school neighborhood school and you can expand the utilization you you want you want the um um um the preschool you want the various odds and ends one of the things that was discussed with uh um wonder wonder Park was the idea of we can put other things into it and everything's fine that way but that's kind of what my
222concern is we're focused right now on saying that these kids are going to go out we're not focus on how we could do it in a different sort of way so this request is consistent what I think we should be focused on uh a little bit in all of them and there was a lot of special ed issues and we we saw a little bit of that blow up with um uh when we talked about tunig and Elementary and all the things that would be involved I don't know what the plan is for all of those but I think retaining it and expanding it just to me those things make sense because we'll being responsive to what the community wants and I'll vote for it member Wilson so two points but I I'll start with
223the first much of what actually most of literally most of what the maker of the motion said about L could I could replace Baxter into all of what was said and it's and it's all relevant so that that's one point the other point is I I I'm I'm a little confused is this amendment requesting that turnig again be Turan Elementary be repurposed instead of L bu thank you for the question no because it would not be appropriate to the public process at this point in time to bring tarigan in I am simply saying that because I disagree with the movement of lak hood into turnig again I'm redacting the closure of Lake Hood turnig again would stay as it is like Hood would stay as it is I was explaining the foundation of my disagreement
224does that help it it it does help um it doesn't help me move forward in that I I to continue to take schools off the list that are dealing with the same issues they have the same questions they they have the same levels of levels of support that they want to provide their kids that they want to provide our students with special needs I mean these are these are all like I said you could repace Place one for the other so my question would be are we looking to remove continue to remove schools from the list are we looking to not close any schools I'm I'm just going to throw it out there my response would be it's any board members prerogative to bring up any concerns they may have uh I have been deeply
225concerned about uh other schools that were brought up uh in this process 100% I agree that Baxter uh much of what could I said here could be said about Baxter um I raised my concerns about uh the fullness of some of the receiving schools from Baxter with the administration and they reviewed it um I ultimately decided not to submit an amendment but I wouldn't necessarily be opposed to another board member bringing Baxter up uh but for the purposes of this amendment I felt that the lak hood closure when the turnig facility to my mind would be a better charter school facility that seemed relevant there has not in this process been an opportunity for board members to bring actual suggestions to the for we've had opportunities for questions and work sessions but there's never been
226much of an actionable time for board members until this moment so just to to double down this is not a recommendation to do anything with turnig again it would stay as its own school like Hood would stay as its own facility at this at this moment in time should the board support the amendment member Higgins I oh sorry uh member Jacobs y thank you um I I'm interested in hearing from Administration as to um I guess I just want to check in and confirm that we still feel like um lakehood is with the other feedback and conversation we've heard from the board tonight is want to reaffirm that lakehood stands as the best possible recommendation uh for right sizing in this particular area of town um that is Northwest Anchorage um and I guess yeah
227I guess I'll love that question first and so thanks thank you member Jacobs uh I guess to start off uh as we've shared with the board in the past that there are more candidates for closure consolidation than there are on the list even when the lists were seven um we do have a capacity issue and we provided rational information for why these would be good candidates but as was shared earlier at this point it's the board's prerogative to explore amendments or revisions to the list based off of everything that we've shared to date um Mr Anderson is there anything you'd like to add particularly about the lakehood facility no I I think um member leson spoke repeatedly about turnig again as a better option for a charter school I don't think uh that's part of
228the the amendment for tonight but the board certainly always has the prerogative to um remove a school and Mr chair if I might so with my question on the way I appreciate that um appreciate the the intentionality with a board member not um suggesting at this point in the process that we should add a new um school to the list um that hasn't been considered um and so that that much I appreciate I I am having trouble separating that there will be another school um and that lak Hood in a year's time lak Hood might come to be um the best candidate in this portion of our municipality and so I don't know if turn again or there's another candidate that makes a better sense and I've heard nothing from the administration um to indicate
229that they've strayed from the recommendation and so I think where I would um land is trusting administration's recommendation and then really doubling down and spending my energy in advocating our legislature to take the ne necessary steps not just to address education funding but to address why young people and families are leaving Alaska and why we're experiencing that migration year after year after year uh times well over 10 at this point and so I think that's where I'll spend my energy um but I do appreciate the amendment I don't really that have enough information to say that this isn't the right and most appropriate um decision at this point thanks like to ask as a followup to the administration one of the things that's been asserted in a number of emails is that this will completely
230utilize all the classrooms at turnig again and I'm wondering if if that's known or not sure I can answer that I know there's a at least one um I'll look at the back at the senior director um I think I I did brief in the work session and we briefed two weeks ago that the spbs program had actually dropped down to five and and it is so small at this point that it easily can be um have students move to closer spbs programs um to their homes so quite honestly the spbs is not not really a factor anymore and that would free up additional space as well when you say it's not a factor do you mean the sbbs program would not be going to turn again or it would just take one classroom no
231we briefed it uh two weeks ago that um those is it four now four students okay there'd be four classrooms with no spbs there but the 5 sbbs students I know there's multiple numbers out there I understand exactly why there's multiple numbers um but the um you know social media has a lot of facts on it um and and sometimes they're they're a little bit off and and so um I understand the confusion but it is going to be down to five next year because some of them age out and um I'm special at has looked at those five students and I think it's an appropriate to talk about individual student placement um but there are other programs where they can easily be moved where we wouldn't need to move them to Tagan so that
232program um as it stands oh I'm sorry turn again sorry I'm getting confused now with naming other schools sorry turnig again um I I don't I don't think there's a plan right now to move that program to turnig again and there hasn't been for a couple weeks since we last briefed it and so would it be correct in assuming that that after consolidation of Lake H could into um turnig again there still would be classrooms that could be used for various purposes correct for classrooms thank you other questions or comments member Higgins I just want to respond to member Wilson's question in regards to vure I intend to propose what baure that be removed for the same reasons we heard a lot of testimony in regards to it I was at back show listening to
233um U staff and parents activities associated with it um and they have the ability to SB stuff from NAA Valley they're trying to work together they realize the closure and I just think it's it's not in the best interest of the kids and the program and I think there's an alternative so your your question is does it include back to it will for me I will be requesting back should be included but I was going to do it on a separate uh motion and I know that uh we you know um just wanted to respond to that other comments for questions seeing none I'll ask Miss Sullivan to put a vote on your screen the vote is on lesson's Amendment number one uh basically to strike wake H from the list of consolidations e and
234member pack if you wish to give an advisory vote and no and the amendment fails I believe 4 to oh uh five to two we are back on the main motion we have any other comment or member Don one um Mr President I move on I guess we're moving on to my amendments is that appropriate okay um I move to strike the words Fire Lake from the section labeled recommendation and to make a corresponding change by replacing the word four with three to read as follows is the administration's recommendation that the school board approv and authorized the superintendent to implement the closure of the following schools at the end of the 2024-25 school year in order to rightsize the district's infrastructure Baxter lak hood and nunaka Valley elementary schools each of the three buildings would
235be repurchased for an existing ASD Charter School essentially this just takes Fire Lake off the list of schools to close and if it's seconded I'll speak to it is there a second I'll second seconded by lessons Mr President yes if you'd like to speak to your motion thank you I just think that there's um a tremendous amount of potential for growth in this specific area we've heard that there is planned 130 new housing units already going in there um I understand the administration's arguments that it still wouldn't be a sufficient number of students um to fill up fire Lake but I do believe that there's going to be more and more momentum for affordable housing in the Anchorage area and this is one of the few areas where we're going to see the growth of
236housing um so I think it's premature to look the closing down fir lake at this time because of the potential growth there discussion member Higgins I had a chance to view it and and you know you got a school there you know it's not full but then you got a um a charter school which is about the same size so it's kind of interesting and we're looking at replacement I I I just see utilization of that school in a larger capacity makes more sense rather than just replace one with the other and there's other options with it so um I know how the community feels we're pretty strong and I realize the impact it's going to have as it continues to grow and um um I just think is not the best interest of kids
237and keeping the involvement of the parents member Jacobs yeah thank you Mr sure um I think I'll land similarly as I did um on the previous amendment that I would prefer to to focus my energy not on trying to find a better candidate because I I don't think this boort will be well suited in trying to find um candidates that are more deserving of um right sizing than others um I think all our schools are amazing and doing amazing things that that portion of the conversation really isn't what administration is referencing with this memorandum um I I think the the better question is to address maybe remember Don Donley's underlying points which is it relates to potential housing um you know I I think that I could express similar concerns with East Anchorage where it's
238one of the most affordable places to live in the entire municipality and if this memorandum passes we'll be seeding additional property which could be used for housing at some point in the future um should the municipality decide it and um we might need additional capacity in East Anchorage someday um but I think knowing that the building won't remain dormant and unused um is a factor and knowing that it'll have another quality program in it is a factor but then also knowing that I I hope this board will join me in advocating for um the changes we need to bring families and young people back to Alaska and retain those that we do have um which will estall not just future conversations but also will allow us to revisit this conversation um is probably the best
239area of focus for this board because um pairing down this list um only delays the conversation for these um sections of our municipality what the only solution to addressing the conversation of right sizing and the question I know I've been asked and I'm sure other board members have too as to how long will this be a topic of conversation really involves legislative solutions to bring people back to our state and retain young people from leaving um that is a solution housing is is definitely a piece of that affordable housing is definitely a piece of that but only that's possible uh by addressing a state long-term fiscal plan and only that's possible uh by investing in K12 education thanks other discussion member West uh I appreciate the the making of This motion I will support it
240U many of um my sentiments in the previous Amendment apply uh to the fire Lake facility um I appreciate the administration's um you know analysis of the timeline for new Housing Development um the land was certainly cleared next to the school and I visited on Friday um um I think supporting it will allow me to sleep better tonight and I think it's what will in this case best serve the students at that school other discussion or comments seeing no hands I'll ask Miss solivan to put a vote to your screen member pack do you have an advisory vote Yes by a vote of 4 to3 we have removed fir Lake from the list of closes this puts us back to the main motion member Higgins I don't know if you were able to draft it
241or not what what I was uh uh what I'm going to do is move to strike the wood uh Bartlett I'm you know Baer but but we going to leave the high school just relax a little bit people uh from the section labeled recommendation and to make a corresponding change by replacing a word four with well three with two I guess uh to read as follows and it will call the same identical language that is in the motion from um um that Dave dony has presented is there a second second moved and seconded um to remove baxer from the list discussion member Higgins this is a one I thought would pass easily uh I'm glad F Lake went but um I mean this school it's got the special ed issues it's got the uh title
242one is one of two of the three in that area the title one schools it's it it is it has the ability to absorb um anaca Valley into it they have the additional space there for the program that was discuss whether you want to do preschool or something else it's just a perfect fit for that we're going to load up the some of the schools like Chester Valley heavily uh and make that 90 plus percent it it this one um heavily commitment from the community the the the support for the special a I think we heard a good emotional response in how we're going to hurt kids by transferring them at this time uh after what everything they've done um it is going to hurt the community it's going to hurt the kids in my
243opinion we need the kids involved I want those kids to have the tital one uh funds uh the resources that that within that type of community and not to divide them up so that they're not out there um it means a lot to those kids it means a lot for Parental involvement for academics everything about it is a doable solution without moving it out there will ways to move things in and to and to accomplish what you want to accomplish so to me it doesn't make sense that Bartlet would even be on that list just like you know the I think huh a b backer okay I'm I'm not going after the high school I promise you it's not the case uh within that it sounds like it but it's not but I just it's
244it's being responsive to what the community needs and what the kid need in that school I just think it's the wrong thing to do and I'm I'm hoping that this one will not uh be added to that list thank you other comments or questions I would like to ask of the administration and I realize this is a lot to ask on the spur of the moment but do you see the possibility of students being moved to Baxter if it is taken off the West Mr Anderson we've only seen a decline in the last several years um so it's really hard to project um as I briefed earlier today about 34% of all the students in Anchorage choose a school outside of the Zone in the backer area it was closer to 50% um and it
245was a little bit less than 50 off the top of my head it could have been 46 um but it was pretty high number that chose an optional or some other school from that area um with parent choice being so free it would be difficult to make any sort of accurate projection as to whether they would leave the school they're at to come back to backer as a a follow-up question um if NAA Valley stayed on the list but baxer did not would that be a situation where students would have to be Bust or would you or I guess to back up a little bit you would would you still see the destination for NAA students being the same um as was outlined in the right sizing plan to begin with um right now from
246Nuna there would be 57 going to Russian Jack 39 going to Chester Valley um you know I don't know that that those locations would need to change um you know we've looked at Chester Valley it does get pretty close to Max with obviously some that whole area if if a charter school were to move into Baxter that happened to be also an adequate neighborhood school um we moved a charter school um from an uh unacceptable location or certainly not optimal location to uh um a school that that we were able to put them in a couple years ago overnight their enrollment went up by 100 so what we what we have seen and that's only in one case um is that when a school can move in that provides a K5 experience a lot of
247the same students that normally would have walked to Baxter may choose to continue walking there regardless of what the school name is but we have not done a survey with every parent um to be able to accurately provide that [Music] information thank you other discussion questions by board members sing the hands on Miss Sullivan to put the vote up member pack if he wish to make a recommendation I'll obstain from this one e by a vote of four to three the amendment has passed that removes baxer from the list of closures that brings us back to the main menu or I'm sorry the main motion any further discussion see no one raising a hand or turning on their microphone I will ask Miss suvin to put them member Don thought there was going to be
248more discussion uh Mr President I'd move to add to the memorandum the following language before the April 15 2025 before April 15 2025 the superintendent shall report to the to the school board on the merits of the new Inlet View school once construction is complete utilizing a k through eight format here you go um I guess I could have held off moving it till I talked to it but is there a second second for discussion I appreciate move second um roic's significantly overcrowded after our move of the sixth graders there we got a brand new school right next to Ric within a mile I think of Ric that's that the projected capacity has about a 100 positions places for almost up to 100 students is what I heard at one meeting here and Mr Anderson
249can give me more specifics on that so there's a lot of capacity there um and we could take some of the crowding out of Ric we've got the potential here to almost immediately relieve that overcrowding at Ric by utilizing Inlet View in a K through 8 format um for years we before a lot of you guys got here Abbot Loop was going to go k through eight um because it's a national movement uh when we had the experts here looking at right sizing the first time they said yeah that's what we're doing with most uh school districts nationally nationally we're looking at k through eight and I just am a huge fan of that format we've got two k through eight schools here we've got Girdwood and Northern Lights ABC um I think they're very
250successful ful um because of the continuity of the kids much like in Polaris uh for going through those really tough Middle School years with kids they have cycled through with and and new kids coming in in it's I think it's a really positive positive format so um the district was moving in that direction with Abbott Loop before we made the the board the board made the decision to shut it down um as an experiment um and I really think it's a a viable option for relieving the overcrowding at in the overcrowding at romic that we're faced with right now which we know is really serious so that's that's the reason and would all this would do is ask the ad the superintendent to examine the question and come back in four months and let us
251know uh what the administration thinks of it other discussion question member B so in view has the IB Program does that is that do they I mean what will that do to that program uh great question member B so this is all hypothetical but theoretically um the district could move towards funding a a middle Year's program so that would be the 6 through eight International Balor for those students again this is hypothetical we've not done any analysis on on that um but that would be something that I would ask the board consider with that said there is a pretty high cost um to being an IB School so we need to weigh that but that's what I would recommend if um they were in a building that's currently International baloria and we would go through
252that application process member Higgins yeah Mike I I like the concept I like dealing with the over uh overc capacity issues in the middle school I just uh my concern here is that I think Inlet View even when it's you with the revision the demand for that for the people that want to get in there is is pretty substantial um and so I don't know how the impact of trying to add 678 is going to do because that school wi isn't built big enough I don't think to go from K to 8 and still with all the program that it's got that's my concern I I I agree with the concept I think I would prefer for the administration to come forward and give us ideas on what they think can be done there may
253be other schools other locations but I do think it needs to be addressed but I'd rather have from them uh suggestions on how to do it Mr President oh yes and and I may just add that uh my understanding is that most of Inlet views actually zones to Central Middle School so what we would be embarking on is a domino effect when it comes to middle school capacity I do recognize that middle schools are currently over capacity in some instances but there are bubbles that we do anticipate um and there will be a time where we're grappling with how do we manage um our operational footprint if we're essentially adding a middle school um and we anticipate enrollment declines in the long term um so that that's just something food for thought if the board
254were to move forward with an amendment like this um it wouldn't necessarily relieve roig it would probably more be more relief to Central um which may have its own enrollment challenges 10 years down the line other questions or comments member donaly member wson I actually agree with member Higgins in that um I I would not feel comfortable voting to for Inlet View to become a K through 8 school without additional information and research and oh I'm just not comfortable voting on it tonight um in support of it I should say um Mr President member Donal just to clarify the motion I made is different than what's on the piece of paper in front of you it it doesn't doesn't say to do it it just asks the superintendent to come back and giv us a
255analysis in four months of the merits of it so it is not to actually do it as it's in the original draft but to simply request the superintendent to examine the issue and see if it's a v viable solution to roic or it's a viable option and come back by um April 15th with some sort of report to us the a question to the administration April 15th would be would that be after Staffing for the 25 26 school year is completed so guess my question revolves around the timing of that yeah to president hullman if we stick with our current Staffing calendar the majority of um our staffing process that unfolds over the spring wraps up by usually about the third week of March so at that point we would have placed any displac teachers
256considered um the bulk of voluntary transfers and begun our new hire process and so by April 15th we're really looking more towards the end of the year and the bulk of Staffing is completed at that point M Don but Mr President the school won't be completed yet so I don't think it's going to be ready for occupancy during that next school year so that's a still a year more off yeah is yeah occupy would be in the 26 27 yeah yeah okay thank you um yeah I for some reason thought they were going to really do some fast work out there I apologize any other comments or questions on this amendment if not I'll ask Miss member Wilson just clarification is would this not be an RFI rather than uh this would actually direct the
257superintendent to report to us so difference between that and an RFI is um we're passing a motion to ask him to consider a specific option and report back to us on it member Bellamy uh so I have a similar concern I I don't know how we can I think we can ask the superintendent to do a lot of things but I would want to hear from those families I mean the school has invested a lot in its structure and what we may not see as impacts might be impacts so I I would want more information on it whether or not it's possible but to add it to the amendment in this manner I would be voting no any other comments or questions seeing no one raising a hand or turning on their mic I'll ask
258Miss Sullivan to put the vote before you member pack if you wish to make an advisory vote Yes that amendment is defeated by a vote of 52 so we have not passed that Amendment we are back on the main question again anyone else have comment or any amendments seeing the microphones lighting up except Miss Bellamy and I don't think you need to say anything or hands being raised I'll ask Miss Sullivan to put the main motion before you uh this is uh whether or not to approve memorandum 73 the ASD right sizing plan as amended member pack if you wish to make an advisory vote a very painful yes well said member Wilson a point of information Mr chair I don't know if it's appropriate now or after the fact but I would hope we
259can um have unanimous consent for um Miss Sullivan to adopt conforming language throughout the memorandum given the number of amendments that have occurred I'll ask the board if there's any objection to um changes where we may have failed to do the right math technical changes um that do not change the the primary intent of the motion if need be and that would a us to go ahead and vote on this there may have to be some fours or change to threes Etc Etc um but this would um this would close Thea and and white could okay I didn't want to say the wrong thing so yeah if we will go ahead and vote on that by a vote of five- two you have adopted the right sizing plan as amended thank you that brings us
260to uh memorandum 074 which I'm going to rule myself out of order in having that placed as an action item um that really should have appeared on this agenda as a non-action item um so it will Mr President as uh for Robert's Rules I would move to postpone this item indefinitely thanks um there is a motion to postpone this motion indefinitely it's moved and seconded any discussion yeah happy to discuss um this isn't um a relevant timely or um in my opinion important topic for the board right now um given our budget and other challenges um we can talk about this next year thanks member Higgins oh me um if you have something yeah the other one we we should be um uh advocating for schools with Juno and we and that's a travel expense
261we have nothing in there right now and there are some other issues out there so that's what this proposal is the idea if we we we're voting it up or voting it down but postponing it indefinitely is just a way of voting it down so um I think that we've got to be the lobby group to the to Juno I think we need to play that role I think there are some other activities we've talked about before uh I'd be glad to go through it but I'm recommending a vote member checkups yeah thank you Mr chair um uh nothing in this motion to postpone prevents us from um joining our lobbyist and superintendent in Juno so I'm I'm happy to say that um all those rights are preserved and we can still will be effective
262when we travel to Juno thanks and and I'll put in the the reason I think this has come up is we did take the action of removing any money from the budget for board travel but we have continued to have some requests and and what's happened is the Administration has said they do have money allocated for travel that the board could make use of and it has placed me in the position of have we said to the public we're not going to spend any money on board travel but then if I turn around and approved travel for a board member to me that's that's not being transparent to the public so the I I guess I would seek guidance one way or the other uh does the board wish to not reimburse any board members
263for travel period or do we want to allocate a modest amount um I don't think this would be enough to really cover going to conferences at least not any out of state uh but it would cover some travel back and forth to Juno and so if we if we don't vote on this I I do need guidance from the board on what they consider to be proper member Jacobs yeah thank you Mr chair um I intended to to move the motion to postpone indefinitely to act as that guidance you need um that this isn't something the board should be expending money on right now um given our our budget challenges um at least from District funds um we can and should consider traveling um at our own expense as other districts do and other school
264boards do um but this again conversation isn't timely um or reasonable given the other options available to this board and um I think we can take up this conversation next year would urge a yes vote to postpone it definitely thanks other comments member Bell on me yeah so last year I think the answer to anybody who wants to travel should just be no we don't have the money this year I mean that's what we that's what we said and and I think um we can revisit that at another Point some some other point in time but um now do I have places I want to go I do but will I make them probably not I might make one or two on my own expense but I think our what we said to the community
265when we approved the budget is that we would forego travel for this school year so until this school year is over and until we revisit that decision I think we need to kind of Hold Steady other it's no member Higgins I don't mind paying my trip to Juno but I'm going to do it because it's important and it's important for kids and important for the school district that we connect with the legislature over these issues there there are other issues out there the nsba is what bothers me the most is that it's going to be focused on AI and other issues and I think it's critical that from my standpoint the superintendent and probably Chief academic officer would love for them to go to that one because that's out there glowing on what we're going
266to do but it seems to me that some board members should attend that because we've got a connection with with q at the law school districts and the other and we get a lot of benefits from it we've gotten a lot in the past um from the everything from the vendors to the programs and I just think that we have an obligation to to it's just part of our job other comments seeing none I will ask Miss Solin to put the question on your screen um this is to table the motion to add to do a budget transfer of $1,000 into board travel to uh table inde definitely and by vote of 5-2 this has been tabled indefinitely that completes our action items uh does anyone wish to discuss non-action items seeing the hands um
267that would bring us to the superintendent update thank you Mr President I'll be brief uh within our community given the decision of this evening there's a mixture of emotions um ranging from relief to emotional Devastation so I think the most appropriate thing that I could say is that we're here for you as team ASD regardless of what the outcome was for individual communities tonight and we need to focus on an intentional and compassionate transition for those communities that are affected so that will be my top priority moving forward given tonight's decision thank you thank you very much any questions to the superintendent seeing none uh school board and school board comments believe I've been starting to my left I will start to my right with member bomy no comment member lence thank you for the
268robust public process um to the board members who participated to the administration he prepared a challenging slate of options and to the community members um who engaged in it in some capacity thank you member Wilson this has been an incredibly difficult night um as a board member and I I really I hope that community members um continue to advocate for education at the legislative level um the need for the increase in the BSA is is so incredibly important I I I really don't want to continue to discuss and vote on what we have to take away and would love to start changing the dialogue to um what we can provide what we can provide in in addition to what our our fabulous staff and educators are providing our kids now you member donl yeah I've
269previously raised my concern about some of our Algebra 2 classes not having textbooks and I want to renew that concern I it's I you know I talk to my own kids and it's really challenging for them in Algebra 2 without a textbook it's it you can in a textbook it's just a more substantive useful tool than trying to be online going back and forth back and forth trying to figure out what to do and I think our children our students deserve on something as complex as math and Algebra 2 to have a textbook and maybe it's just having some available for the kids to have a particular challenge with doing it on the internet but I I think we need to find a solution to this um I can't imagine doing it uh without a
270textbook um and and there's no handouts available either apparently too I mean it's just something that they're just completely reliant on being on a website and trying to figure it out um so I'm I remain very concerned about that um thank you member Jacobs no comments member Higgins I know this I agree with member lessons this has been an extremely stressful period um much more so and when you walk away somewhat frustrated and somewhat happy that's usually the way it usually ends that means something good came out of it but um um my concern is something that uh Mr Anderson is a little while ago that when you're so distracted with this you're not focus on all the other issues that we've got we' got so many issues in the school district that I think
271we need to be addressing and we just haven't been focused on any of that we we couldn't and I appreciate that because I appreciate the feedback I'm from all the parents um and we I had a chance to attend the schools and and getting that kind of information out of got it was very beneficial and the voices were heard and I think that's what we were hoping to accomplish um and then beyond that it's just a matter of coming out with a list of all the other things that need to get done and it's a lot because we are flooded with u challenges because of State funding and is distracting us from what we should be doing and that is looking for opportunities so um thank you for everyone who spoke out thank you um
272to wrap up I uh do want to apologize to the staff and students at baxer and at lak Hood um I know it's it's just it's NAA I'm sorry um it is painful and I say that as someone who taught in a school and like there were several times where the district enacted policies that sort of wiped out what we were doing and and that was painful but that's nothing like finding out your school is going to be closed uh I know it feels intensely personal to those folks and there isn't any way to change that it is personal and I I think the vast majority of our staff goes in and works really hard every day with whatever they've got to do the best they can and we've heard the parents come forward and
273talk about it and explain it um but there is a reality as the number of students keeps drifting down it becomes remarkably inefficient to continue to keep this many buildings open uh and I think until the uh population decline reverses we will be back doing this next year uh and the year after uh because it simply it simply doesn't make sense to try to staff a school in elementary school that's got 60 or 70 kids in it or 70 or 80 kids in it um so it's a reality but it it doesn't make it any less painful for the people involved in it so I um do know that the administration is going to work very hard to make this transition happen as painlessly as they can to try to take those best elements and
274move them uh that doesn't always work so we will be watching and trying to learn from this because we will be coming back to it again and again do want to thank everyone that came to testify we do hear you we can't always alleviate some of the things and it is just a really difficult choice and uh I I will to a time I think when Alaska begins to really support public education again and we can begin to look at what we can add to the experience for our students and how we can improve things on a day-to-day basis and not simply continue to keep shaving people off shaving programs off uh in a in an effort to come in under a budget that keeps getting hit by inflation year after year thank you all
275and uh if there is no objection who we are in adjournment