CorpusRecord 4023

12/17/2024: School Board Work Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Anchorage School District
Date
2024-12-18
Location
Anchorage Municipality, AK
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,621 words · about 71 min
Collected
2026-05-16

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001progress e e e lights up we'll call this work session of the Anchorage School District board to order at 303 uh pm on December 17th [Music] um presid in the room we have member Bellamy member lessons member Wilson superintendent Bryant myself member hman member Jacobs pretty sure that member Higgins is wandering around the room somewhere pretty close and we'll be back shortly member Donley I don't believe is here yet [Music] um but with that we will move into the discussion Part B on budget development and to the superintendent thank you Mr President so this afternoon our first topic will be budget development uh there have been a few developments since we uh last met at our Retreat on Saturday or a couple Saturdays ago uh one of which we went live with our Balancing Act

002software we'd love to show you more about the reporting and the data we've captured to date and then also uh provide an overview of the performa as we move towards our budget development process so I'll go ahead and hand it off to Katy parrot our senior director of om all right thank you so some of this will be um overview of uh some of the information that we've previously provided to the board um in in starting the budget development cycle uh we'll just give a very brief refresher on that as well as doing a very brief review of some of the high points of the proforma and then providing the board with an overview of some of the initial feedback we've received um as part of our Balancing Act tool um that is the budgeting

003simulation that we've pushed out to the public um and are beginning to receive some results from that um as you know uh this is our budget development calendar uh we're right in the middle of the cycle that we um uh go through to be able to get to an approved budget uh you'll see that uh the school board approval of the proforma is exactly where we are where that green star is and we're moving forward to the full approval of a budget in Fe February this is just to review the uh the true uh Gap really in our budget as it relates to um the BSA in terms of how the district has been in the past balancing the budget and that fairly large gap between um what we've been funded and really the inflation

004proof number um should the district have been provided uh inflation adjust adjustments from the new base year which is that fy1 and if you'll remember that was adjusted from the base year of fy7 after analysis that was conducted by legislative finance that took a look at what year did districts in the state of Alaska have the highest and best purchasing power and if we use that as a base here how would that compare with current funding levels and this gives you a pretty good overview in terms of the revenue of how uh we're fairing for this the outlook for FY 26 um you'll see that our proforma budget was built on a couple of assumptions that are highlighted in red here one uh we did not include in our initial uh projection the use of

005fund balance which is currently set in the approved fy2 budget for 37 million um and then we also budget based on what's in current law um and as uh the legislature did appropriate one-time funds those are exactly what they sound like one-time funds that require another appropriation to continue um and therefore the proforma is based on uh no one-time funds outside of the BSA formula and this is important I think for the public to know and understand that a a balanced budget really includes what projected funding and revenues the district or any organization is expected to receive in any given fiscal year versus what the planned expenditures or expected expenditures are for that current fiscal year um and that when we're talking about budget deficits really is the true deficit there's some levers that we

006can pull to make that number change and we'll talk about that um but really the true deficit when we're looking at a budget is the difference between those projected revenues that we're going to receive that we can rely on receiving and what we're really truly planning on spending and this proforma includes uh does not include any new expanded programming it's really just the cost of doing business to continue uh the programs and services that we're providing right now and this is very much based on our actual approved fy2 budget here you'll see what that true Gap is um and that's the 107 million um but then you also see in this graph that if we pull in a sizable chunk of fund balance what that difference is that we have left to Grapple with and

007so over the next month uh as we move forward in our budget development that bottom number depending on guidance from the board is what uh District administration will work through a process of trying to get uh settled that also includes an assumption that's based on an adjustment to Staffing um uh based on our enrollment so uh one of the things that the district does is we have uh metrics that we use to um allocate certain staff positions and when we put our current uh enrollment through those uh formulas and through that process we are projecting to have a reduction of about 50 FTE and so that's also important for uh the board to remember and on one last note uh this has come up in a previous work session and so I thought I would

008highlight that here especially as we're seeking uh feedback from the public uh one of the concerns for Alaska school districts and particularly Anchorage is the um essentially the cost of District ad Administration and how that fares uh we've heard lots of feedback that um Anchorage School District is topheavy and that that's an area to uh take a very close look at as we look at budget reductions uh based on an analysis of uh the fy2 budgets and this is information that um is provided by the state of Alaska that's publicly available when you take a look at the percentage of of the total operating expenditures um as a percentage of uh the total budget for specifically for the District administration costs um ASD is actually tied for third lowest in the state in terms of

009the amount of uh District administration costs that are built into our budget um so that's one thing just to remember as we're working through this process so as many of you know we introduced a new budgeting tool um and this is uh both for Education um it has a lot of information that we've pushed out um in the module to be able to provide information about how our budget is structured uh and we also are using it as a way of seeking feedback from the public as a way that the public can express their opinions and their Solutions and their ideas um on how we can close the budget Gap and so we do have some some initial results uh that we've been able to pull together and take a a kind of a a

010cursory look at um to be able to present how um how that's turning out a couple of things to keep in mind uh we did use the pro forma budget um to be able to build out that simulation um a couple of things to remember is that this is based on general fund only um so this uh budget simulation does not include Transportation fund or food service or grants or some of those other funds uh we started with the true operating deficit of 107 million as a Baseline and then have uh options for the public and for users to be able to adjust the use of fund balance either at the 8% uh minimum threshold or the 5% which roughly equates to the 27 million and the 47 million we also have an option built

011into the simulation for the public to adjust the BSA to make their voices heard in terms of what they believe uh should be the state revenue as part of the budget process some revenues are locked to any changes because uh some of the the uh Revenue we receive we just don't have a lot of say in how those adjusted um and how those come to us so it it doesn't make a lot of sense to make adjustments to those we also included on the revenue side and the expenditure side a section of the simulation that is really just open to suggestions any suggestions um that a person wants to implement as part of their uh submission to the district they can add any amount and then provide any justification um kind of as an open-ended

012um area similarly for the expenses side uh we have uh these grouped into main categories of school-based Serv and that really is the bulk of the budget um also operating um sorry operations and maintenance The District administration components and then a section for restricted uh areas or fixed costs that are also locked to changes because there are some things that we're legally obligated to do and don't have a lot of of discretion in reducing or pulling out those budget items um additionally we had options for a PTR change either to the positive or negative as well as school closures um these and there's also options to add uh or subtract increments throughout the budget um line items uh but there are some some guard rails that are built into that system so that there's a

013maximum number of reductions that are built in so that you know you can't go below a certain thresholds either because that would impact student safety or that would impact compliance or we legally can't uh for example not have a principal in a building and this is just an image to kind of see how that's displayed I know the board uh looked at this in your work session um but if anyone in the public or in the audience uh still hasn't taken it I would strongly encourage you to do so um and provide your suggestions So based on uh an initial look uh since we launched uh The Tool uh we've had around 1,500 page views uh one of the interesting things that I was I was a little bit happy and surprised with is that

014the average time on the site is about 10 minutes so of course there are outliers that are factored into these averages but what this does tell us is that people are spending time in the simulation and taking time to look and to read and to to kind of um make make those adjustments um and we also have received uh just over 200 uh submissions so as you recall uh someone can go in and and play around with the tool and then not submit and we do have some information when people do that but those submissions really do capture the full kind of gamut of uh what the the proposed Solutions are uh we do have a dashboard that provides some uh basic uh information you can see the top Revenue increase which this this makes

015sense because these uh the state revenue and local Revenue really are the only ones that can be adjusted um but by and large uh the average of all increases was to the state revenue um also you can see in that bottom suggestion uh that says your suggestion that's kind of that open-ended free range area where people can make recommendations and so an average of about 11 um 11 a half uh million dollars of ideas uh was was placed there uh you can also see that the top expenses that were proposed for increases were in school-based Services um and then also there were some smaller increments proposed in operations and maintenance and the suggestion box and then the top expenses for decreases were also in school-based Services um to a degree as well as a a

016much smaller amount in administration and then uh operations and maintenance uh so this gives us some kind of cool graphics that we can use to take a look um and it shows us the difference between people kind of going into the module and clicking around and and kind of um looking at that information versus submissions and you can see here this just displays that information a little bit differently uh one of the things that we were really particularly interested in is the specific uh solutions that the public was offering in these two areas so yes they were proposing increases by and large but but how and where uh so these graphs kind of show that breakout of where the recommendations uh lie and how that was proposed um you can see on the state revenue

017side uh a large percentage of individuals did believe that uh a BSA increase based on the inflation adjusted to fy1 uh was the best solution in that context on the expenses side it makes sense that most of the submissions um and also uh the the changes that were proposed were in school-based Services is that's the vast majority of um the budget but this kind of demonstrates in each one of the areas where there was a significant increase or decrease in the submissions and so we'll go over those in detail uh so one of the things that we found was that there was uh really two metrics that we can look at that show us different kinds of information so one of the metrics that we can look at is uh for the average recommendation what

018was the dollar amount so what we did is we took a look at the largest dollar amounts um that were recommended for change across um all of the recommendations and we also took a look at um the percentage of the total budget so um you'll you know that some of the portions of our budget are a lot smaller than others and so an impact of a million dollar reduction can be very very high in some programs and very very minimal in other programs so we took a look at both of those and have uh provided some information related to the top 10 that we saw uh by and large in terms of dollar amount school closures was proposed and uh if you remember the approximate uh dollar amount for savings that was set in the

019module was uh around 900,000 and so this approximates to about two schools as the average recommendation for closure and then you can see uh through uh the the different rankings that the amounts after that are around $1 million or so one and a half to just under one uh for uh sped Services uh one thing that I'll note though is that of all of the average um the the average responses all of those were reductions except for pupil teacher ratio pup pupil teacher ratio was the only uh component of of all of the budget line items that uh there was an average recommendation for an increase um and so that's kind of why that one is set aside and then you'll see for the other items uh down the list the impact there to those

020different line items is different and that will be um demonstrated here uh so this uh slide shows the uh top average expenditure Suggestions by percentage of the total budget and so you'll see at the top language immersion was recommended for a reduction um that the impact was approximately 22% of the overall budget so the dollar amount was lower so it didn't show up on that first list but the impact to the total budget um was fairly significant in terms of the dollar amounts that were being recommended for reduction um and then you can see next is summer school um add of Duty and sports and activities and you'll notice that uh the dollar amount was fairly substantial for sports and activities as a reduction that also reflects a pretty significant reduction um to the total

021budget are there any questions about the rankings I would just take a moment to say we've been joined by member donway and member Higgins please continue so to some there's there's a lot of data there we're still looking um through the availability to pull out certain data points to see um what the impact is of those recommendations however uh some of the um some of the data points that we think were really important to note is that uh we did allow in the simulation for public uh the public to be able to submit a a budget that was not balanced um and the vast majority of people did submit a budget that had a deficit uh so it it it proved to be um I think in the data we're seeing that the public grappled

022with the same things that the board and the administration grapples with that under the circumstances it's very difficult to get to a balanced budget uh a couple of of the um indicators that I think are important to demonstrate that um of the responses that recommended no use of fund balance um in their budgets there was an average deficit in those budget uh solution models of 30 to 40 million um so that's very similar to um you know what we what we could expect uh without a use of any fund balance um additionally uh when there was a decrease in the PTR as a proposed solution there was also an average deficit uh in those budgets of 20 around million um additionally and we kind of already know this but it it definitely was very much

023demonstrated um in the simulations is that local revenues alone cannot close the budget Gap and so even pulling in the top amounts of the the local Revenue that we might have available doesn't uh doesn't get us there so the next steps for us is we do have the uh Balancing Act tool open for responses through January 3D and the reason we selected January 3rd is because we want to be able to compile all of those uh responses and the analytics and provide a full report to the board by January 7th so that that's information that we can actually use um and the board can give us guidance on uh based on those submissions um so I would strongly encourage anyone who hasn't uh explored the tool and submitted their um feedback uh to go ahead

024and do that as soon as possible um and and we're trying very hard to compile those and and really use that as a decision-making tool so for um Administration uh we are seeking your guidance uh we on a on a couple of notes uh number one uh specifically uh the administration is seeking guidance on the use of fund balance so for our current fy2 budget the board did vote to uh reduce the minimum um to 5% so that we could pull in the greatest amount possible to be able to balance um we're seeking guidance on whether or not the board would advise uh taking such an action um that we can build a budget on moving forward as well as a general understanding of uh preser serving or adjusting class size as it relates to

025PTR and then any other guidance that the board would have uh for om as we're putting together a preliminary budget so that's all we have M Jacobs yeah thank you for the presentation um did I track that from the the data uh from those who utilized the the new tool to submit suggested budgets that there were some um participants who suggested the district invest in decreasing class sizes in our current environment and if so how many of those individuals who suggested the district decreased class sizes submitted a balanced budget thanks um I would have to go and look into the data to provide a precise number but that's exactly correct um increase or sorry decreasing CL or yes uh adjusting class sizes to the benefit of the PTR ratio uh was the only item in

026the simulation that the average number of respondents wanted to add to just a quick followup the reason for the question is I I don't think that's mathematically possible um but if someone found a way that would be of great interest to me so I appreciate it um thanks member Higgins yeah thank you uh there are two things here one is back in the 90s we had a big crisis uh Finance the school district went uh really almost belly up but there was a lot of different Staffing that took place as and during that result it would be interesting to look back at that what we had for Staffing and different programs um and how that you know may be something we can reflect back on as to what they did and that could be something

027that's interesting out there um I think there's um uh the other issue is just are there any reductions recommended by P aodm that we haven't implemented um I think there were some changes in there when we did it we're fighting to get the funding but uh anything in there that showed it to be um a high level that we never respond it to may be something I just don't want to ignore a recommendation that um directly related to adequate funding remember um this this may be something you have available or not um I was interested in some coverage of the governor's budget where uh and I haven't watched it so this is hearsay but um my understanding is that the governor said something to the effect of a $200 million increase to school funding could

028be included on a permanent basis if he and legislators could um reach an agreement on changes to State education laws back of the envelope math U makes me think that the increase last year in onetime funds was 175 million and so he's talking about 750 BSA give or take $25 um what I mean what would a 20 00 million increase at the state level mean for ASD do we have a sense of what his BSA concept might be so uh the onetime funds that were provided the 174 million are portion of that the equivalent was meant to be around that 680 number right so our portion of that was the 49 million um that was built into the budget um I think that uh we discussed this previously and we would still have a budget

029deficit uh if we received approximate funding this year um we would still have a budget deficit of around 15 million 10 15 million just kind of depending on where we land um uh and so if we received about the same amount uh we'd get close not all the way so we would still have several million to be able to close um yeah thank you I think that maybe the followup for the more focused question would be what does what would a $200 or excuse me a 200 million BSA truly calculate to and maybe we have that and maybe we don't but you know when you just shared um in one of your pie charts essentially about 65% of the respondents were comfortable basing their budgets on some kind of a BSA increase 680 or higher

030yeah um so I'm just trying to reconcile um potential right forward this is oh sorry this is Andy rff the I was gonna jump in and say you know the ex we're going from 175 million Statewide to 200 million Statewide you know that might generate another five five to 8 million or so for ASD it's not going to be a whole lot more than what we got this year thank you um remember B me yes thank you uh in the survey in the in the uh Balancing Act did they did they the PTR was it across the board or was it like K3 keep K3 low and incre do we know did in terms of I I think that so there was some feedback that was provided at the work session for kind of separating

031that out I believe we did make an adjustment I would need to go back and look and see exactly what it okay I'd like to know that yeah um I was just looking at um so the current budget I mean in our current 2425 budget we used how much of our fund 5% or was it eight I believe we uh used five yeah we used a lower amount yes okay all right that's all I have sorry other questions by board members and does that complete everything that's all I got okay I'm sorry we don't have more questions but I thought she she did she want us to give us guidance I mean she I think she wants us to give some guidance do we not have any um do we want to do that in

032the work session we can I mean I don't know I'm just is that any other guidance um I think by this time last year we probably came up with about a six or seven bullets of guidance most of which won't apply this year but anyway member Wesson it seems that if I were in the administration shoes I would want to know whether the board felt comfortable spending fund balance down to the 5% or 8% level that seems to be a major piece of the puzzle yes so I I guess I would recommend that we try to gain some consensus today about our comfort level with a 5% or six seven or 8% utilization of fund balance remind us of the policy please you oh uh off the top of my head a super majority of

033the board would have to which is five of us five of the seven would have to agree to spend below the 8% board policy I don't recall the board policy number off top of my head but it is in board policy um that we have the 8% uh board minimum to allow for emergencies as you've articulated um in Prior meetings and then the recent Finance meeting so that is something we could let members put themselves on the record in the work section um I don't think we really want to do a motion in the business meeting about it but does anyone wish to speak to them I I'll lead off just to say that um this time of year when the governor's budget's just been released and the legislature has not done anything yet official

034uh including even being sworn in um but I'm still optimistic that the legislature will lever some significant funds for education but I couldn't put a number on it um other than the fact I feel like both the house and the Senate will be working together um under the under the ceiling of a vitao um given that and given that that will be the legislature next year also I'm inclined to to take that risk with fund balance um unless things change and and it begin to look more dismal and then I think we do have to to maintain a bit of a cushion uh just as a safety measure uh and that we could be looking at several years several more lean years that's not very clear I know the best you're gonna get in December

035I appreciate that um I think that one of the ways we talked about it in the finance committee was um preserving fund balance for contingency purposes for emergencies for uncertainty is really important to the Financial Health of an organization but the situation that we find ourselves in is um balancing the priority between unknown potentialities and very real known impacts uh should those resources not come to the table to preserve programs and services so that really is the um the the decision um and I also feel optimistic that there will be some kind of um you know manifestation of revenues that we can rely on later um at what level that's just very hard to plan on so utilizing fund balance to the greatest extent possible would probably be our recommendation and request um so that

036we can to the greatest extent possible especially based on the size of the deficit we are having to work through that we can protect and Pro Reserve as much service for students as possible other comments by board members uh member Chens yeah thank you Mr chair um so I apologize I misunderstood The Prompt as to Happening Now versus later in the memo um when we pass some memo and a guidance um I um it was I think my suggestion a year ago for us to con consider um a roughly assumptive $100 BSA increase as a um a measure to balance our budget and prevent some really harmful cuts um I didn't make that suggestion lightly and did it in part because um it was very clear and and elected officials from the executive and legislative

037branch had gone on record at that point um because it was the second half of the 33rd legislature and made progress on a bill to increase the base student allocation um this year is much different and um we don't know um the intentions of the 34th legislature um we know what individuals have campaigned on and we know um and the governor certainly has a very clear track record um and how those two things Square I think is yet to be seen um there's a narrow majority in the house and um a larger minority in the Senate um and so I'm less inclined I would really want some clear um evidence versus prognostication as to why we should be so optimistic before assuming a BSA increase um with that said I think what we can do

038with certainty is utilize the resources we have now to mitigate that uncertainty in other areas um and so I I would be um open to going down to the the 5% minimum um which requires a super majority vote of the board um you my question earlier regarding you I admire the individuals who took the um budget tool and and um reduce class sizes that is my goal and I think the seven of us enter this conversation every year with with that goal um I don't know how we can make that that goal of reality without more resources from the legislature and I think that um that data point um highlights the need for additional communication to the best extent we can in education that um the resources aren't there to make that investment right now

039um and that if the legislature chooses to act and the governor chooses to um allow that action from the legislature maybe we can look at making those Investments um on the contrary I think the only way to balance the budget that I was able to find is to consider PTR increases so I think we're going to have to utilize that to what extent um I I think I would lean on administrative recommendations um I and then in terms of other budget thoughts or perspectives the third bullet point um you know I personally would like to see um investment um regarding Transportation as I've alluded to regarding our Charter and optional programs um I think making those more accessible in turn makes those uh programs um more viable to a larger portion of our student population

040um and the legislature or at least there are some within the legislature that value a Char programs um and uh and as a um an indication of success and innovation that um warrants their consideration and investment in public education in a way that um success in neighborhood schools doesn't and that's their prerogative as elected officials I even though I personally disagree with it um and so I think it's a a worthwhile investment there and I also would like to see um a counselor to student ratio um in the elementary um in elementary schools um I recognize that that currently doesn't exist to the best of my knowledge um but if that doesn't exist now I would want that to exist later and so I think those are my thoughts for now um I certainly will

041have other perspectives to share later but I think I addressed all three bullet points thanks other board comments member Wilson I would support also um decreasing the fund balance down to 5% and where I stand with that is I really I have hope I always have hope that the legislature will um increase our BSA will continue to um will choose to prioritize education for Alaska students so I I will throw that out there that I I do have that hope and I I really hope that they they will um move into this next legislative session prioritizing Education First I'm going to throw that out there first but um I also believe that we should make sure that we have if you think of it um from a family standpoint have make sure that we provide

042food and have food on the table for our kids um rather than keeping that extra money in the savings account so I feel like right now we are at the point and continue to be at the point where our discussion is consistently focused on what we need to take away from our kids um what what we have to decrease in Services because of the lack of funding um and and having that additional money in savings account while we continue to um so to speak take food off the table um I I I could not support in good conscience so I would support moving down to 5 per. thank you member B yes thank you so I ALS support uh the 5% um spinning down to the 5% it these are desperate times it causes causes

043for desperate measures I also think though that depending on what happens with the legislature uh we should be able to we need to reimburse that account if at least some of it if possible so I would want to see some I would want to put a guard rail somewhere so that we can we give ourselves that permission um I've been thinking a lot I mean I don't I don't spend money I don't have but uh it did help us last year to do that uh to assume a $100 um at least a $100 BSA increase and while I really don't want to spend money we don't have I think that that's uh part of my desperation uh is to perhaps um do that again this time around no I'm from well I'm assuming we're going

044to get like 1808 the reality is uh I mean for the purposes of building our budget just assume put in that $100 like we did last time um into our budget like so that we don't so that at least we'll and then we can make that adjustment whatever we do we can always go back and adjust but uh for right now I think that's pretty much where I am um class size is is I mean I can't see we K3 if we can not touch it this year would be one of my priorities uh but then I don't our our secondary classes middle school and high school I guess I would like to see a a where we look at that look at those numbers again because I from what I'm hearing they're all o

045in the 30s at the secondary level um so I I really want to keep I'm sure about K3 for me Margo Bellamy but I need I need more information on Middle School and High School uh class sizes because um they have crapped up even higher than I think the board really understands and and I get why um because we still have over 200 jobs that hasn't been filled yet and that has an impact as well so yes to the 5% member Higgins yeah I'm not sure how from a classroom side standpoint I remember the National School Board Association focused on examples where K through three having a lower classroom size had the 90% effectiveness of having low classroom sizes in all the grades but that K through three was critical for outcome in fact a

046number of studies out there one in Philadelphia that I recall watching the presentation on was kind of interesting I don't know how for Middle School when we've got two that are so overcrowded that there's anything we would be able to do there it's if they're using the storage rooms right now for for meetings with kids um uh at I guess two middle schools where we said we wanted everybody to be sixth grade in Middle School and so we've got two overc capacity by a large amount what we're going to do with that so I I I am concerned about class sizes I am concerned about the outcome but my biggest Focus I guess would be the Kate through3 and how we're going to handle everything after that is I I feel like we're going through

047a game that I hope is a absolutely wasted e effort and that things won't turn out the way it looks like the worst case scenario but we need to make sure the public sees the worst case scenario I don't want to hide it I want them to see everything that's on the plate so the legislature and the governor and the public uh clearly understand it any other feedback on the budget member Wesson um about a year ago I spent an awful lot of time uh in the district's uh physical budget archives and uh going through the online budget archives which are actually part of the fy2 and also I think the FY 26 budget web pages you can kind of go down the rabbit hole and one of the things that I noticed and I

048just thought it's useful to share here is uh and maybe member Donley will recall from your time in the legislature a couple of decades ago um think things did not look good in the encorage school district round about 2003 and as budget after budget in the early 2000s were being prepared more and more uh items were on the table for cutting and things had to be reduced and class sizes were increasing with the transformation in the funding uh formula and funding patterns um in 2004 uh a number of the p increases like there was like a k through 12 BTR increase of one and a half that had been slated to go into effect um swimming was eliminated as a PE instructional class and the sort of the budget adoption process the c teams were

049eliminated in the budget adoption all of these things that we're kind of grappling with again today um however uh By the time November of 2004 rolled around there was a class siiz report that the um superintendent prepared uh that fall and she was able to report in November 2004 that the additional funds enabled no classes in elementary that were over 32 students in size and only four classes over 30 students in size um as of October 1st 2004 um the high schools had reported 458 classes under 20 which was an increase of 37 from the last school year so more small all High School classes my point here is that is that making sense so with the increase of funds the district was able to increase the number of small classes right dollars went to

050classrooms and I think that is what there are folks who are skeptical that we could do again and I believe that if the dollars were made available we could put aside the PTR increases and allocate additional Revenue towards class size reduction efforts courtesy of walking back the PTR that's that's kind of the point that I was hoping to make um history shows it's that that's possible um I think I feel another year older from from where I was last year and maybe a little grumpier um and I I feel a little less willing to spend our fund balance down to 5 % it seems a little bit more fool hearty um I feel like earthquakes can happen here um we could have other emergencies but I also understand that this is an emergency and so

051I'm really I'm really torn about um my own Comfort level with spending fund balance down to 5% so I don't have a yes or no answer uh for the administration right now um it's something that makes me the 5% makes me deeply uncomfortable from a financial stewardship model maybe not spending down to 5% also makes me deeply uncomfortable uh considering our class sizes any other comments just a question member B so uh I know we're not going to do it today but um I it's just clear that for me that we're going to be cutting programs there is no other way to balance this budget so I think the sooner we can at least uh not this month maybe hopefully not not till mid January but we've got to come up with a list of

052of programs um I don't know what that's going to look like but if you know I'm looking in the you know the top expenditure Suggestions by percentage I mean that kind of gives us a an idea of of all of everything on the list is wonderful and amazing we just cannot afford to continue as we have in the past so I don't know how long at some point it's actual Pro programs it's actual people I I I really don't know how we're going to all this conversation is wonderful hopeful Wishful in the end we're looking at cutting programs and I and some will be cut so drastically that they probably cannot function so not too sensed I I would back set up and say that sometimes when we say we're cutting programs that doesn't sound

053so bad but it is always people that we're cutting um in the multiple discussions about uh cutting Middle School um it's not the sign out front that has Middle School on it that cost us any money it's the extra staff that makes the schedule function and makes everything happen and so if we reduce these other programs we are in a sense somehow increasing class SI es in a way that might not even show up in the PTR but um people have to go away for us to save money really and that has um we're finding that those people matter to somebody in the same way that we cannot seem to find an elementary school that nobody wants to go to um in this town which is reassuring people are doing their jobs well but uh

054unfortunately we can't reward them for it like we should any other comments on the budget before we shift to right sizing Mr chair yes I guess yeah I guess I just um want to check in with Administration before we move on do you need additional Clarity not everyone's spoken I want to make sure we accomplish what's listed in the slide deck thanks thank you member Jacobs so uh based on my Tally it seems that we have um support from four board members to spend down to 5% so that's vote shy um from a reduction that we would need to actually operationalize that uh so the decision point that I'll need to make is what to present to the board in the preliminary budget guidance and um my initial Instinct and I want to say this

055out loud so I can uh receive push back if needed but I I would imagine I will prepare a budget that spends down fund balance 2 5% knowing that the board can amend and adjust and change course but I want to be clear that the differential between spending down to 8% 8% 5% is millions of dollars um so if we were to build a budget based on an 8% fund balance spend down we would need to plan exactly which positions would be eliminated between now and the time we submit our budget to the municipality and in attempt to preserve as many jobs as possible because I realize that if we were to go into a layoff scenario we may not get those individuals back by the time we hear back from the governor in July

056uh I'd like to put that budget forward to the board knowing that um it's the will of the board to make that adjustment back to 8% if needed but currently I have uh four of the five votes we would need to make that happen but I want to be transparent with where my head is at based on the conversation we've had tonight thank you very much any other questions or comments if not thank you very much and we will move to right sizing Mr President so we're going to transition to our right sizing so we'll provide some additional analyses uh this will be our last work work session uh I anticipate on the right sizing topic um we'll also show some additional Graphics in terms of where um students live geographically versus where they attend

057school and some other metrics uh to to give the board final information that you might need prior to the decision you'll be asked to make tonight so with that uh I'll hand it off to Jim Anderson and St gson will'll walk you through a brief good evening um we've been talking about this for a long time um and certainly it amped up in August and September you know I think uh first I would like to thank all of the staff behind Sven and I um there have been over a thousand hours of effort put into this by dozens of Staff members who have really given their entire semester to trying to give the board the best possible guidance they could and uh I just want to make sure that they get the recognition that that

058they've earned and and deserve for all of those efforts and and we all know that in a city of just under 300,000 um you're always going to have people disagree with everything just as with a a board of seven you're going to have people disagree with something almost every time but uh I'm certainly proud and I know Sven and Jared are uh of the effort they put in and uh it really has been a very difficult ride and a very difficult ride for the board and and even more so for the staff families and Community uh of the original list of the seven schools so um I for one I'm am pretty happy that at least a decision will be made and then and then we'll move forward because there's a lot of work to

059do um so I'll go through real quick some of the slides that we've added for tonight and then we'll answer questions so everyone's seeing what we were really attempting to go after which is what does a properly resourced School look like and we're well aware after Katie's brief and Anan Katie's two weeks ago that we're facing a big deficit but really it is about the resources at a school and what does that school look like for each child at every different school and are we providing the same level of academic service and support to them and and I think we've been somewhat consistent in trying to maintain our focus on children um even though adults obviously have a lot to do with um everything so some additional feedback and it's it's not a lot this

060time because I put out a pretty big uh board connect update last week on some of them um on the first one about the um both the community and the board members um certainly one board member expressed specific concerns about Baxter's ability to um if they were to close could the gaining schools receive those students and we have validated um that it absolutely can work if due to parent choice the situation on the ground would change we know that 60 students worth of space is available at susitna which is literally right down the road from Baxter so um you know we never know ahead of time what parent choice will be um but I think we can support this plan um regardless of that choice within fir Lake um there obviously have been a lot

061of recommendations from that Community to either change boundaries which draws students away from homestead or Eagle River um sorry Birchwood or Eagle River Elementary School and that would put those schools closer at risk of um being candidates for closure but it certainly would save Fire Lake um there also has been discussions about closing program s at other schools specifically Eagle River Elementary moving that to fir Lake and naturally that would increase the number of students at Fire Lake but at the end of the day you're really looking at three schools sharing the same population and which group do you move around because it because the population doesn't change and so there's a winner and a loser no matter how you do the math on on that group of schools um I did meet with the

062municipal uh development office for quite a while last week and we did a deep dive on Powder Ridge the two multif family buildings that are being built across the highway currently in Birchwood Zone and the 136 houses that are being planned to build near Fire Lake and I thought I would give a quick rundown um the first one is the acuta OWN Powder Ridge area they do have a concept to build up to a th000 houses in that area but they have not submitted a plan and there are no um there's there's no requests to actually move anything forward um so at this point I think at some point in the future when Anchorage grows and it will grow again as Anchorage has many times in the past and in fact our whole state in

063a boom and bust economy um autus certainly does have at least a concept to grow that area out at some point in the future when needed there are seven housing units being built um just Northeast of Fire Lake and those actually already are being built they're going to range between $750,000 and a million dollars per each home so probably not starter homes for the average person um and certainly with seven homes not going to bring in a lot of um Elementary AE students there is right across from Fire Lake they have the permits to do the groundwork for 136 homes worth of space um I expect that they will put in the permits for approval after the groundwork is complete the next year 26 would probably be starting to put in Road sewage uh Power

064those kind of things assuming the developer is still on track in the summer of 27 would be the first permits expected to actually start building building those houses the developer development office um is is suspecting um it's an educated guess that if everything stays on track and if the workforce allows it to occur and if the demand for the houses exists that there would be by 2030 up to 136 houses um generally across from Fire Lake but obviously it expands out quite a bit now these are truly um I think what the city is is calling attainable housing these are three-bedroom houses for the most part at $350,000 to $450,000 estimated obviously the housing market continues to change annually um I think most of us have seen that over time but at least at this

065point um not inflation proofing for 2030 the estimated cost would be roughly 350 to 4 $50,000 homes so assuming everything's on track and everything is optimistic you'll have about 136 houses um built in the fire Lake zone or mostly in the fire Lake Zone um by 2030 and when you look at the average Anchorage number of children per house um if you go really optimistic um and and guess that there'll be a lot of military families buying houses in this particular area even if you go with with one per family on average and if they happen to even be of the age group from K to 12 that 136 kids would still be split between K12 if you go to um some of the multif family dwellings where the average certainly if you go on

066base where the average is closer to 1.9 children per family that would be the most optimistic possibly um you're really looking at 0 to 18 years old um still at about turning 50 kids at all grade levels across the district so we know that Eagle River continues to be just like the rest of Anchorage um very assertive about parent choice so even on the absolute upper end if everybody had children that were only between the ages of five and nine um which is unlikely yeah um it still wouldn't be to to completely fill that school and that's kind of what I found out um there is 256 room multif family um buildings being built across the highway in Birch Birch uh I'm sorry birchwood's Zone and those are looking to be two-bedroom mostly so at

067two bedrooms you're not going to see a lot of children coming out of a two-bedroom apartment um not at school age and certainly not large families um and that's that's what we learned I do appreciate all the input from the community um I appreciate the municipality taking a significant amount of time making sure I understand the projections and um all of the permitting and everything that's been accomplished so if you were to look at the absolute most optimistic which would also probably be an unrealistic scenario um those numbers really wouldn't show up till 2029 and 2030 so that's kind of the the lay of the land on housing and Eagle River naturally people move to Eagle River all the time and people move numbers change every single day um and and developers can speed things

068up but that's that's what we found out so then I looked at EIG River Elementary School traffic multiple times and when I looked at it and you look at all the boundary exemptions going into Eagle River um I don't know by family name every single child were they in the optional program but certainly the vast majority of them are optional and there's anywhere between 50 and 80 plus parents probably driving their children to e River Elementary um a significant number of them actually come from fire Lake's boundary zone so if firelake were to close then it is most likely almost certainly that those families would now be offered a bus because the um bus routes would be built on where all the current housing areas are for those children zoned for Eagle River and although

069we can't prevent or um change the roads the parking lot or the entry of the school I think you would see um several buses come to the school and eliminating quite a few Vehicles so that's pretty much how we see um those primary issues being raised and Again Naturally you could live two blocks away and still drive your child to school um people do that all over town especially in inclement weather so um they are correct it's a crowded Street like many other schools in the district so I wanted to give you a laydown of so you can get a picture and if you go to the the Board conference room after this you'll see some um posters that have been rolled up into tubes and and um Miss Katie Grant working with it uh

070developed a really good spreadsheet um and it shows the lives in attends in or lives in or attends out and you'll be able to see every single School in the district and where all of those students come from within their boundary Zone and um it took about a week to make um it was last made in 2015 and and I think this Schoolboard members it will be very enlightening to look at that what you will see as as we did the analysis was we really are a district of choice 34% of our students are not going to a school within their boundary and naturally a lot of them are going to Charter Schools and alternative schools um and immersion schools but they're also going to other neighborhood schools that don't have a special program um

071and of course there's not the data in that post that shows you how many are faculty children or or just it's on the way to work and or they just know someone at that school and that's where they want to go um but you know when you're looking at a third of our district uh really going outside of their boundaries it it prompted me to get some visuals so I could try to portray what does it look like at our different schools and knowing that transportation and meeting the board goals on Equity of choice um I I I came up with a few other visuals which I'll go through now so if you look at the far left you'll see alen glow Elementary it's a typical neighborhood school if you look at the big circle

072that's where most of the students who attend that school actually live and on a typical Elementary School that doesn't have any other special program I I looked at about 8 or n of them that's really what you see the vast majority of the students that go to that school live in that neighborhood and then I started looking at some of the other programs and and so of course I wanted to look at shinook and a few others and I didn't put all of them because um eventually the hook would come out and I would be pulled away but um you can start seeing that that the optional program which which isn't widely um it's not really drawing a lot of people from outside of their neighborhood program but it is drawing a few and it's

073drawing a few from upwards of 15 different other school zones so when we start looking at equity and transportation you're really looking at at this this real challenge of trying to to move people all around the city from um really Potter Marsh all the way up to Mirror Lake not not as you look but as you get to Government Hill and you look at immersion most of the immersion programs start looking like this and a lot of them look like right in the neighborhood of course you're going to see a lot of local neighborhood people go to that immersion program but then you start seeing these large numbers from all over the city and this one goes not quite to pot Marsh it's a little bit north of that but um all the way up

074to Fire Lake Elementary and then we look at our big programs those programs that that um in lotteries frequently have had um people that they they couldn't accept because they were full and then you start seeing what is a really mean to have a special program in ASD and where are those 34% really going so when you look at that poster you're going to see a lot of people um really going from Mir Lake to Potter march on all of these schools and it's Northern Lights Polaris chwat and and then when you go to um the charter schools it's the same thing and the reason I wanted to show this was was not to um do anything else but to give me an opportunity to explain to the board that when we look at this

075kind of complex problem where we're looking at a board guardrail that says we need to increase Choice um starting in January we're going to put a team together and we're going to come up with a pilot that we want to use next year and it may or may not be supporting um the charter schools directly that that um as a part of right sizing move into facilities but we need to try to hit as many Alternatives SL charter schools in a relatively small area that doesn't outc cost the district's um ability and start trying to figure out can we Hub and spoke within the cities so maybe we can't take um Mirror Lake and send those students to eager River Elementary optional or burchwood or maybe we can't take someone from Potter Marsh and send

076them to North Anchorage um but maybe within the Northeast Anchorage area we can put or the east side we can put a hub and spoke system to meet that Transportation requirement where parents can drop someone off their CH their children off um at a location close to their house where we can still get them to multiple different schools and I think that's one way to approach um this challenge of equity I I'll be honest that one of our biggest challenges in equity is many of our charter schools don't provide uh free food for those who qualify for free and reduced meals we have multiple charter schools that by Design designed and built buildings without cafeterias in them um and and then some just where they leased it just wasn't going to happen and you can

077look it's it's really the the bulk of our charter schools so you know when we when we do next semester depending on tonight's outcome however it may turn out uh if we move other charter schools into one of our schools that has a cafeteria one other way to meet Equity that need is those children who really are food insecure that might be the reason they're not going to another school um and and I certainly don't want to Discount the school they're going to all our schools are great I think the board guardrail is not about forcing everyone out of a neighborhood school so they can go to a special school I think it's about giving Parents Choice chice um and then providing an environment that supports that choice so you know I I think the

078pilot program for a hub and spoke type system is certainly a way ahead um and I think that moving schools into a building where they now are going to be part of the um national school lunch program and and you can look at every Charter School we've talked about in the past three years that doesn't have a lunchroom a lot of them have asked student nutrition to figure out can you just get me nine meals for my free and reduced qualified students and there's no way to costeffective do it and you know that other people are likely not looking at that school because maybe they can't don't have the time or or the capacity to be able to to send them to school with snacks and lunch and and all those things so I I

079I do want the board to know that we are taking that board guard real seriously I do think a pilot program of some type of H Hub and spoke um we can have ready um by next year and I do believe that if you move a charter school into a pro into a school building that has lunch capacity and breakfast capacity that that might even be more important than transportation for some kids especially if they move into a neighborhood area um where they still need to eat so here's the timeline um no no one's going to be comfortable tonight I realized how difficult the decisions are um but at the very least we we will have a lot of work to do um to move this forward once decisions are made so at this time

080if you have any questions for Sven or I or we are more than happy to call up any of our staff members at anyone time um please please ask um with a question um first the lives in and enrolled in is really eliminating and uh I know I would not have guessed that as many people that live in the Eagle River Chugiak area are bringing their kids to optional programs in the Anchorage Bowl I mean that's a it's a a pretty big lift um but it's interesting to see the one number I couldn't come up with I was a little surprised at how much Mato has grown as Anchorage has uh shrunk a little bit have you come across a number for whether or not Eagle River is gaining or losing population overall not just

081in our schools but as a an area has has it had the same amount of uh population loss as the Anchorage Pole or has it been growing no I was I was told that it is it has seen only very mild growth um although obviously there's a housing developer who thinks he can sell 134 homes um a lot of them moved out I think because of affordable housing uh the military base is at 98% capacity on base the other 2% are in maintenance and renovation they have they have no extra space um I know I've talked to multiple um military families through the liaison who when they're trying to get a house online before they come out here the houses are cheaper in Matt which is why you've seen Matsu growing at 3% every year

082for the last seven or eight years although I have heard that it if it didn't decline it certainly reduced in the amount that it was growing this past year I mean at some point Alaska's total population continues to decrease so um that would be expected thank you other questions from board members member Higgins yeah my question it's it's the unknown to me um you know when we moved sixth grade in the middle school because everybody because we you know we wanted everybody to be on the same level we ended up with two middle schools that are very very crowded and um uh and I saw those and I saw a storage space where there and I don't remember the administration providing any information about the impact of that beforehand it makes a difference on on

083this outcome last board meeting I heard from turnig again in regards to the impact of the plan that would be involved in transferring some students and the amount of money that may be involved in preparing that school was pretty significant too something I didn't hear from the administration I'm looking at this not you're asking us to go ahead and approve changes and you're going to figure out later or you've got information that we're not getting that's a concern to me I'm I'm concerned of the repercussions that aren't out there I don't know when you learned that that mirors en Ric would be so o you know overcrowded and I think that's a safe State 120% capacity is called overcrowded but I didn't hear that from the administration beforehand and I didn't hear it even afterwards

084so that was that's surprising to me and I like I said didn't know what turnig again was up against until they told us I didn't hear it from the administration so my concern is the the the game plan here what's going to happen in E School the way you're preparing it and then the other is options you're looking at the issue of Early Childhood okay that's great that can be done in existing schools as well without vacating a school and while I agree with this issue of we got kids all over the place going every place else I know that but you've got a whole lot of families around a school that can participate and be involved with that school where if it's further away they won't be because they the we've got a lot

085of different income sources and and issues out there top to bottom and uh parental involvement impacts academic outcomes that's my big thing at the end academic outcomes right so I guess I'm I'm I'm looking to say what is the options that's out there for you want preschool I don't have a problem with that uh but that doesn't vacate a school we got wh that could be maybe that should be over at lakehood too because we've got other special programs there is the only one that doesn't have it in elementary where they can go back and forth to a regular school so that would be actually a real benefit that way so we've got other options but I'm not seeing the these are other options and it's more please let's close it and then we'll figure

086it out I I don't know the outcome I don't I don't want to be surprised with an outcome like Middle School that was a big out big surprise to me when I saw that and I remember went there with an event at Ric and heard from so many staff members talking about how crowded it is and how difficult it is and that's difficult for staff difficult for kids not not what you'd want to call an ideal outcome but that wasn't disclosed to us so I'm I'm interested in options I'm in op interested in options with with kids with special needs I'm interested in options of where we could move kids to different schools different than what's being decided by the administration I like options and I like looking at that and listening to the public

087you know because they're concerned about their transportation needs and their involvement with those schools and I agree with you we got a large percentage of them all over the place with the optional programs no question but we've got a lot of them in Title One schools that don't have that opportunity and and moving them away is going to impact academic outcomes that impacts that impacts AC I mean that impacts the involvement it's it's academic outcome so I'm just still looking for for that kind of information so I don't want to be surprised like I was with sixth grade when I went to say how are things working and I get a chance to walk around school and see how crowded it is and how every story space has been emptied for for kids because if

088that was known before the board approved I would have expected to hear it if it wasn't known but it occurred I still would have expected to hear it and I would expect to hear from what I'm hearing from parents and turn again from the administration not from the parents for the first time so mine is what are we not hearing what what options are out there and that's what I'm interested in knowing okay it was a a pretty multi-art question I I will try to so um let's go with why we didn't bring up some of the rep purpose options early and I think that was a direction the board president went with early in his replies that the very first thing the board was going to deliberate and make a decision on was um

089the right sizing School closure plan and then the discussions would be started on repurposing whether it's child care or Charter Schools or whatever it may be so I think that was intentional by Design um out of respect for a school that might close um but I would defer to the board president for that piece of it um but I would sus I I plan as as early as possible in second semester to start talking about what are those options are now I I will tell you that that I have heard from the parents as well um the same as the school board and sometimes not always but actually frequently people will get information from social media that gets shared very quickly and the actual source of the data ended up being not completely accurate um

090so when they first started talking about large numbers of rooms that would be needed for sbbs students um it did take us a couple weeks before we could get out the reality that it was five students only and then honestly because the other programs have drawn down as well we could actually move those five students to programs that now have space um but even after we briefed it a couple weeks ago unfortunately the truth on social media lives forever and so there are still people who believe there's 31 kids going um I I would also say that um and we've seen this with every single school on the list that every school can point to three other schools that should close instead and that um by and large if we were to switch um lak

091Hood with turnig as much as the tan families were concerned I think they would adamantly be against them closing and having to move to Lake H um and I think that's human nature they will have the exact same discussions I bought a house it's close I can walk my K can ride a bike all of those same justifications as to why um you know those are natural human emotions and and they're Justified um but I know you asked a lot of other questions Pat and I'm not sure I could I'm not sure I could answer the if if you could maybe give me a a help here yeah it's difficult for me to say um I have a particular question about uh getting information I don't know that you you haven't been provided so that's

092that's a wide open area in it would not have known to ask about sixth grade uh crowding in schools last time when we moved sixth grade I didn't I didn't even think of that being an issue and it would have been an important issue for me I'm looking at this and saying okay what are the options of you're talking about uh preschool now putting those is in many locations closer to populations is the best option anyway so vacating a school to be able to do that is not the ideal so that if the option of moving wh into lakehood and then having free school or doing something there as well that would fill up that school so there are I'm looking at this and saying you I remember you talking later earlier about wh needing

093to move uh for a number of different reasons and it was being proposed out there well um and what I heard from way is the fact that their location is too close to certain schools and uh there's no way for elementary kids to when they out going back and forth like the other areas this would be a more ideal situation and that would keep the the the uh neighborhood school as well um I'm listening to parents listen to the options of putting naaka in with uh backr and they said and all the reasons for special ed and all that type of reasons that they're promoting that um within it so I'm I'm just these are options out there that just pros and resp to all of them I understand but I'm I just don't know

094what to ask that I I didn't like I said sixth grade I never would have thought to ask about the middle school being so crowded uh so and I would not have known about uh turn again and as far as the cost and the impact and how it's going to affect things of at least being revealed to us before before it's rolled out that's what I'm looking for is to know if there are other options like what the parents are telling us at backfire or um uh what they would like to see those are things that I would like to discuss I don't know that we have time everybody as informed as they wish they could be in the next three and a half hours um you know we did put forth a board memo

095um for the sixth grade to middle school that had a budget Authority so we could put things like reloads we did talk about how initially they were going to be at very high capacity but showing the next 3 years at 2 to 3% decline that it would level out um did we know in December whenever that decision was made exactly how many relos no because parent choice um sometimes impacts things and then we had some schools where students with mobility issues um came to the school where previously they hadn't been there so now we needed to spend more on ramps but we wouldn't have known that until after they chose to go to that school um I don't think it it keeps coming up about turn again um saying that they we need to spend

096$200,000 for sbbs I will I will just one last time the sbbs those five students we we're not planning on moving them there and we briefed we briefed that a couple weeks ago but we don't talk about individual students and where they're going to go because the number is so small it it would be in violation of of of law so um so no we we can't give everything out our senior directors have walked through with principls in some cases assistant principles and other staff through every single school that was a gaining School absolutely I can guarantee you somebody at that gaining school doesn't want anything to change and I can't I can't compete against any reason they may say not here not my school I just can't compete with that I know that we

097have a plan to put all students in the gaining schools and we can make it work and we know of no reload requirement we know of no construction major requirement that's going to prevent that gaining school from receiving um and then something changes another school has a rough problem and it closes and I mean if something like that happens between now and next fall then we'll have to deal with that I I I can't for that but I'm not looking at I don't see any major issues other than um always always always the gaining and losing schools will think the other person either shouldn't sometimes shouldn't join or maybe not in that volume or that it should be a different school that closes and that has been consistent I think it was 2018 maybe when

098we Clos Mount spur um I don't know I think that's just a standard just throw in one more thing I've gotten a lot of complaints in the last couple of weeks uh it goes back uh a bit and and part of it because of the violence yesterday makes it bothered the number of of issues and concerns people have and how they're being stifled from speaking out or saying things and it it surprised me a little bit so I just say even if if it's a different position people have and it may not be Maring in line with what we what we'd like to see i w it and I just um I just want to make sure that we're not you know shooting the messenger or anything else the people that have disagreements within that

099and that's that's is a concern that I've got because like I said last week I got um quite a bit from some different people surprised me a little bit um and it's something we as a board going to have to address I believe member Jacobs yeah thanks um I'm I'm going to speak specifically about the the three amendments that that I have either sponsored or co-sponsored with member lessons I'm curious from Administration there's anything you'd like us to know or consider about Jacob's Amendment 1s um or lessons Jacob's Amendment one or two thanks other comments no that was a question Mr chair thanks I'm sorry apologies I don't personally have questions about it um I think uh you know the board has received all the information that we had and and I see that two

100board members want to save lak Hood um the amendment doesn't talk about the details as to whether the intent is to close a different school next year or if it's just to save Lake good um and I don't know if the board members want to publicly discuss that during the board meeting tonight or during this work session um I think um there was some general agreement that at some point once an initial list came out that you could detract from a list which the board has frequently done and unlike bonds and and budgets and other things um I think there was General agreement that new names wouldn't be added at the very last minute to surprise people after the public process was complete that now in the last hour their school is closed and they

101never saw it coming um but I think that's up to the board as to whether they want to talk their um personal thoughts as to how it's going to play out and provide foretelling for those amendments or or not I think the transportation piece I tried to cover that because I think it's bigger than Transportation um although I think we need to make progress and I and I agree with you completely but I think it's it's a so the food and and the other types of things that that hopefully we can provide for those communities so Mr chair I don't I don't know if you'd like to utilize the rest of our time for board members to go through the Amendments that have been offered at this point um I'm H I'm personally happy to

102provide Clarity um from things that that I've either sponsored or co-sponsored thanks um I'm going to say I think if members have questions about rationale behind it um or accuracy of assumptions this would be a good time to bring those up um obviously when it actually comes to the four will be the more serious discussion anyone have other comments member Wilson I I just wanted to say for the record that I I believe the decisions that board members make individually and I I'll make for myself are because we're trying trying to do what's best for kids we're really trying to make sure that they're provided the the the best possible academic experience that our district can provide to them I also want to say that I believe that our staff has really gone out of

103their way to make sure that we have as much accurate information as we can have provided the information you have so that we can make those best possible decisions and and I also appreciate that the community has been allowed the time to provide that input so that any additional information that we were not looking at that maybe we didn't have access to particular information so that they had that opportunity to provide that additional information so for for myself I appreciate that effort I really I see the work that that has been done um I I I really do feel that that you as staff have gone out of your way to make sure that that this process has been transparent for for both us as as a board and our community and and our schools

104so I want to thank you for for all of that effort I think that needs to be acknowledged and I did want to clarify as well the comments that I'm making to uh people that are writing to the board um any of the impacts on destination schools that are receiving students I I do want us to analyze that um that's a that's a critical part of it what I've tried to avoid or what I've tried to make clear is I think members of the board want to decide straight up should a neighborhood School continue to exist as a neighborhood school or not uh and I I don't want anyone to think I'm my vote is influenced by a desire to make space for another program to come into a vacated school um so and there

105may be problems when when that happens but that's a separate issue uh that I think we should take up only once uh We've made our decisions about the neighborhood schools but the the impact on receiving schools of other students is certainly uh very much a topic of discussion and and whatnot but I am saying that to members of the public I think it reflects what everyone feels although I didn't get a chance to really ask in advance but uh that's what I'll convey to the public member Higgins yeah my concern is that if we're looking for options the options include whether we keep the middle keep the um the neighborhood school and add to it or whether we remove it out and put something else into it cuz all the options have have different things

106that could be contributed to it for some of the tital one schools really makes a difference that we you know expand we can we can combine we can do a number of things so selecting them without looking at the options is my concern if for that year we're going to select the school and then later figure out how we're going to work with it what are we going to do with it now to me it's just it does it doesn't do it's not fair to the school we listen I'm listening to backst to uh last week you know talking about we have these options we have this they want to lay that out as well and I I just don't want hesitate against the idea of making decision without realizing those options because it makes

107a difference on whether the elementary the the um neighborhood school could stay there or not because there other ways to fill up the school fully utilize it and uh make it you know still maintain that connection particularly Title One schools and all but to maintain that connection and and for the success of the ne member Bellamy then member W thank you Mr chair so the pl first of all thank you for the enrollment those numbers um we have created a situation of our own doing out of doing what's best for students and families where our neighborhood schools are suffering because when we make a school special or alternative or immersion uh it's that shiny object that people want to go to so now we're stuck they're going to the shiny object and now we've got

108to figure out how to provide uh the best services within our diminishing resource ources I mean we don't have it's diminishing resources how do we how do we uh keep our neighborhood schools and still allow for Choice it's a dilemma and it just might be that we can't have both and we need to start thinking about that as a board uh so it was never a surprise to me that uh a couple of our middle scho would be overcrowded for at least 2 years that's where the bubble was and we talked about that bubble and what that would mean when we approve the plan I think the difference now is is that parents it is now no longer on the paper it is an experience that kids are having and I totally get that I

109mean I was at Windler and we had if you can believe it 12 reloads on the on that campus and as the bubble went through and we were able to get rid of those reloads was it crowded it absolutely was crowded but I don't think it impacted the teachers doing everything they can to make it work for every single student so that they could be successful um I Heard Jim you said we will we will grow again and this is this has actually been a something that's been coming uh to me in several different ways uh from parent from from from parents and community members and I think the whole thought is and there's a question in here somewhere but we don't want to downsize so much that we can't handle a future growth and

110I guess my question is have we thought about that and uh how does it fit within the plan that's one that's one question and then my my final um my final question I guess or you know when we got this plan we got we got the best I think the recommendation from the administration we knew for whatever CL whatever school we repurposed Consolidated or closed there was already a recommend a recommendation for it so if we are now and and you we can you can we are now disagreeing with the plan uh I I I mean I I don't really know what to say about that because I don't have all the pieces I can't see this as much as I know about education and learning I can't I can't I can't see all of

111the impacts that the administration would have to deal with if we're going to keep switching and trying to accommodate every every request this has never been about a a a competition of schools for me it hasn't been that it has been about diminishing resources and how do we continue to give every kid in our district the best that education that we can so I don't every school is special every school is doing amazing work but I don't have the lens to see if we if we don't take I mean I I the work that's gone into the plan I mean the board can do what it what it wishes to do with it but at the same time none of us have have the the the the vision of I mean you have the vision

112because you've you've obviously given we've all given it some thought of what we hope it to be but the reality is is that I don't know how we're going to rightsize ourselves and I if we keep kicking this ball down the road and not making a decision so um the plan as it stands right now now makes sense to me I don't I don't I I'm kind of with the with uh with uh the president here I don't I think the next conversation after tonight is who where who goes where somehow it's all gotten mixed up into uh you know I mean I can see you know if we can repurpose this we can consolidate here um but I'm not ready to have that particular conversation I I I just want to know if the

113plan if we're going to approve the plan later today then then we go to the next step if we're not going to approve it then we delay or whatever it is we're going to do and try to figure it out but anyway if you can if you can just respond to that uh the growth potential so up until this year I think everyone thought that at 2030 we were going to start growing again because that's what the state demographers said and just a few months ago they said we're going to keep declining until 2050 I I think depending on I we have so much mineral wealth in this state we have so much to offer it just needs to be the cards need to line up and and and there's no one out there predicting

114other than Willow obviously Willow will be coming online within a couple years and that'll be you know a significant increase in the amount of oil they're talking about um drilling gas again to uh help solve some of the LG what we don't know and no one's really has a model to predict is are the people with those jobs going to move up here or are they going to continue flying from the lower 48 up here and I I think we've really got to start seeing as you get closer to Willow one when we get close to Willow anybody we have that's driving a bus is going to be offering a lot more um to operate two weeks on two weeks off up at Willow um and every CDL driver in the state um so we

115don't want them to take all of our bus drivers but it's certainly something we'll compete with but I I I think when you see Willow come online I think there's going to be some increased jobs it's just hard to tell if they're coming from um the lower 48 or not I think um there are some houses being built in Anchorage where currently there's a lot of J bear folks who are living in the valley and maybe they will move closer to where they work when they can find attainable housing so um that would provide for some moderate growth but of the 6,400 plus students that that we have lost in uh the last decade plus 4,000 of that 6,000 are ele age and with the declining birth rate any even being an OP Optimist I'm

116an optimist longterm um but the reality is our elementary schools the reason that elementary schools were selected is that's where two-thirds of our enrollment decline exists and and it's it's causing us to not provide the same education level of service at every school and I know there's people that say look at look at secondary we really need to focus on secondary but they haven't lost the students and and so Elementary is where when we have these huge populations over a third of Anchorage residents taking their kids to different schools but the numbers are stay in the same um that that's really why we focused on Elementary that's where 50% of all ASD students are at and that's where a significant portion 2third of the decline occurred so you know but do I think it's going

117to grow yes I just don't know if Willow is going to do it or if it's going to be the one after Willow member W um I guess I had a couple of comments but I'll I'll begin with a question and I haven't really aired this question publicly since a private conversation with a principal a couple of years ago and that we had a thought exercise of what would it look like to change elementary school education at least in like a pilot program so that you have a Congregation of you have a school that's dedicated to like K2 or K3 and a school that's dedicated to Upper Elementary so for the purposes of this conversation we call K2 and and 35 and I'm not proposing that right now but my question my question I think

118is um do any of the I'm not yet sure whether any of the proposed consolidations create the sort of The Suite of three classes at every grade level that kind of were set out as a goal at the front of this exercise but it seems as if you could concentrate the students from you know the youngest students you could really get three kindergarten classrooms three SE first grade three second grade classrooms and improve the level of service that we give those kids kind of at their grade level um so I guess the question in that is do any can you just help me I've asked a lot of questions uh up until this point can you help me understand whether I know that many of the receiving schools would end up with like two classes

119at a grade level do any of them get to that three yeah I believe that we would have some like we get to the three um the model you're talking about even Matsu has that but it's like both schools are in the same area and so they have like a K2 a 35 um we don't have any adjacent that close schools right now we haven't looked at that as an option because we've been just looking at K5 schools after sixth grade moved up to the middle schools um as far as uh your resources are going to be you're going to need the PE teacher doesn't matter if they're K kindergarten or fifth grade you need librarian doesn't matter if it's kindergarten 5ifth grade music teacher kindergarten fifth grade so those resources that we've been talking

120about are going to be where the kids are and it it doesn't really help the actual resource spread at that point I don't believe um when the other school districts added those extra schools because of a growth they grew so they did that specifically for the growth um I don't I haven't really seen or explored what it looks like as as we cut the school all right it seemed thank you it just seemed like an interesting opportunity to air an idea that had percolated some time ago um I think one of the concerns that I've had throughout this process is I've really started to pay more attention to how buildings are utilized at at a classroom level I mean we have calculations of of utilization rates but when you go to a school you see

121that there are you know two or three classrooms dedicated to special education resource teachers you see that a classroom space is maybe being utilized for um delivering PT or OT and and maybe that's the best use of available space I mean can can other Spa there are many in many cases in schools you have small kind of cubicle areas where I could imagine one adult meeting with one student in like a one-on-one conversational setting but how do you effectively deliver all of the supports in spaces that are not classrooms so as a former principal of 20 years I'll tell you that whenever I had extra space I spread out and as we've gone into some of these schools we we really have seen principles utilize the space in different ways than it's designed for um

122when we when we look at like OT PT those kind of spaces they don't need a full classroom for that but they're being utilized in those schools um as we've literally our senior directors along with maintenance and in some cases Gemini we've literally gone and looked at every single classroom as we've decided whether or not a school how many kids can be moved into a school or out of a school and whatnot um we have seen more and more more where we have one-on ones especially once we have the mental health component going into the different schools and many schools were designed to not have all of the different like little office spaces the smaller kind of spaces um I I'll tell you as as a principle I I utilized rooms that might be used

123as a book room for for classes sometimes for the smaller classes but that doesn't mean that the education's different because we can make those work um Ed specs are are a thing that we're constantly looking at and adjusting I think that the most recent one happened to be with Inlet View and as we move forward with that um but constantly looking at what the needs of an educational space are as we move forward into the the reality that we have now not the reality we had 40 years ago um so I I I don't know how to answer the question any better than that but we I do know that we spread out a lot in some of these schools I would add in um someone I knew proposed what you were talking about with

124um building specializing in a smaller number of grades several years back and looking at it as we have built an Anchorage it would mean multiple buildings with much larger attendance zones you'd have to have an attendance Zone big enough for say k through two to fill a building and so the the transportation issue becomes big um and the fact that you have these multiple schools for parents that have multiple kids um potentially even though they might have two or three kids in elementary they they might be in different locations throughout the day uh so from a practical standpoint it's got some real challenges is um there is there are some real bonuses within the building once it once this bell rings and people are working um it's a neat environment because it is kind of

125homogeneous and you do have people that can trade off uh but um at the time we just never could see a way it would actually work that at least in Anchorage as um Mr gson pointed out if you have two buildings right next to each other it becomes easier but then of course it's like well maybe just one larger building might work in that case and you share the library and the cafeteria and gym and all those things but um it it creates even more redundancy within a city that's grown up like Anchorage by any means but it has been thought about and pushed on every so often for a very long time here other board comments or questions we are coming up on about five minutes left in our work session um we we

126could actually end early if no one else has more to add or I will say I'll entertain a motion for us to recess until our general meeting at 6 o'clock okay re

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.