CorpusRecord 4024

ASD School Board Governance Committee Extra Session 12/12/24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Anchorage School District
Date
2024-12-13
Location
Anchorage Municipality, AK
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,154 words · about 35 min
Collected
2026-05-16

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e and you ready all right good afternoon everyone we'll call the second half of the Anor School District school board's governance committee to order today is Thursday December 12th 20 4 here in the boardroom at 1:33 p.m. um we will go around the room and do introduction starting here at the table I'm your chair car Jacobs right Pat Higgins scho board member and member of the committee andyman Kelly L board member exective assistant Johnson deputy chief schools Jim Anderson chief of operations we'll start with our back r Cory young assistant director ktie senior director of management and great welcome all and do you want the online no yes please uh we have Mr guson online America Sullivan online and Mr great welcome all if any new Bo additional board members Miss Grant Po

002in online please let me know um I wanted special thank you to president holl for caring the first T of governance today it wasn't available appr appreciate that we've called ourselves to order we've conducted our roll call move on to B1 which is a discussion on right sizing amendments um in L of a formal Communications meeting uh this month I asked the chair of communications member Wilson to allow some additional time for discussion on potential amendments to the right sizing um initiative and memorandum proposed by District administration and so we want to provide space for any conversation questions or discussion for administration ahead of our work session which occurs next on the 17th this upcoming Tuesday um with that said I believe in front of members available online on multiple different agendas as an amend

003Amendment to the memorandum uh I drafted which I think has been well covered and discussed certainly am available to answer any questions on that um if there are other members who wish to either propose or discuss conceptual or actually written amendments now would be a great time and if there are members who have questions for administration I think this would also be appropriate this time so I'll open the floor there member Higgins I see a hand half raised yeah two things for the agenda for the future but I uh want to include a discussion about policy limiting access of of school board members to talk to staff uh that was surprising to me but that's an issue we need to I think need to discuss and uh bring that up and then the other one

004I I really do it right now we need to talk about the audit process of what audits we going to do and timing of that so that we get that moving along at some point as well sure happy to talk about with you those with you about those things offline we'll go back to our agenda which is a discussion right sing amendments questions um and otherwise is there a member who wishes to ask a question discuss an amendment address a question or a point regarding an amendment that's already been raised m l so I have um I don't know a number of potential amendments since this is up currently um one of the areas that I think um could be strengthened is if really we're we think about how we can use the FY 26

005budgeting process to best support staff and students going through transitions um so one thing I would conceptually be interested in and amending in in this area maybe adding bullet point a couple of bullet points at the top would be to allocate funding um as needed to provide District level support for the the closing and receding principles and staff um sort of immediately following passage of memo 73 and through some point in time you know I don't know the first quarter or so of the school year uh just knowing that there are a great deal when I visit schools there are areas that are filled with books you know boxes of materials and there's just a lot of work that's going to be required to move people and things and I thought there's there's just such

006a large scale at this point that it may be useful to budget appropriately in the FY 26 budget to support that sort of transition work um a second sort of bullet point that I think I'd be interested in proposing is that um we don't know how the FY 26 budget is going to be balanced it very likely it could involve PTR increases right to help mitigate our deficit I would be interested in essentially holding receiving schools harmless basically keeping them at um the uh the PTR levels responding to their increase enrollment but at fy2 PTR levels because we've talked about staff following the students and that's not going to happen if we have PTR increase that are I'll just say through the roof so I yeah the one thing we would have to look at

007to see if we could do it is the disparity test okay if we fail the disparity test um and what Katie do you remember the percentage that you can be off from the lowest funded school to the highest I I think I want to say it's like 25% off so if it it were to throw off the disparity test of schools against schools like you would have a non Title One School making 25% or more or budgeted more than a title one school then you would fail that title one disparity test and I think we we'd have to we'd have to look at that to see if it's possible or if there's some like Middle Ground to where you don't fa the disparity I think the point is I'd like to make sure that those

008students and who are going to be going through the move and their family and the educators are just some how supported as best as we can and to me maintaining no less than this year's PTR levels uh would be a way to do so um and can also consider allowing uh creating sort of voluntary agenda to for the staff who are moved from building a to Building B um to settle into their new building um maybe to par do that okay so so that's always that when we close a school there's major amount SP not only okay so there's voluntary there's agenda available to support that process um great and then just it seems like it might be useful to create you know some kind of an after action report I mean in the way

009we sort of received that uh with respect to the Abal Loop students but you know if sometime like at the end of by the end of September of 2025 um it seemed like that might be a useful um might be useful to the board um to have a general understanding of what went well what what were challenges and um you know should there need to be additional consolidations in the future uh it would be a a place to reflect and learn um so that those are some conceptual maybe additions to member Jacob's Amendment um then maybe they can just sort of be combined ahead of time since it hasn't formally been we wouldn't need to amend an amendment um there's another bullet point maybe to add at the end of this which would essentially D

010I guess this is directing the administration to um work with any Charter EPC which accepts placement in a district facility to really create a plan to align its enrollment levels to what the building is capable of doing so you know if if a charter currently has an enrollment cap of you know x amount but moves into a building with Y amount let's make sure we support that APC in letting them grow into that facility so they don't just have a bigger facility but we are offering more students the opportunity to take advantage of that facility and do so in a way that would be in line with the board's adopted guardrail uh so these are things that I have written out um I did just um yeah so and we can continue to have these

011conversations but those were a couple of potential amendments to member Jacob's um preliminary cut at it yeah um so as chair I'll just put myself in the queue to address some of the conceptual um proposals put forward I think by and large I I don't um disagree with much that was proposed I I think it might be helpful for the board to be reminded of what the proc the process that occurred at AB Lop Elementary and the um heroic effort put on by District staff to make those students feel welcome to receiving schools I think there's probably um it's been some time since the board was made aware of how hard the district worked to make those students feel welcome in the process we would use um this year and I think that might address

012some questions um I don't know what the feasibility is of holding any particular School uh harmless and how that would change um impacts at another neighborhood school and so I'm definitely interested in more information as to what that might look like um I don't know that I'll be to incorporate that into this particular Amendment but I do think it's a a conversation we can continue to have as we proceed with our operating budget conversation which of course will extend months Beyond this particular conversation um with that said um I I I do see um Synergy between um The Proposal discussed about um expanding Charter and particular programs en rolling cap as a part of this process I think that there's a larger conversation that should be had which I think was alluded to at our

013Saturday work session by member Donley which is um you know as we move Charter programs into a ASD facility um which I think Aquarian kind of built the template potentially um we need to talk about what it looks like to begin caring for those buildings through our bond proposition process um while also addressing and ensuring equity and access through things like Transportation meal service transportation for me was a hard stop recognizing that this train leaves a station so to speak in regards to Transportation once um this this proposal passes um and so I wanted to include it um at this juncture to make sure it was um considered early and often by staff as well as the charter program seeking potentially a place in a in a school in a space made available through the

014right sizing initiative um but I am interested in addressing the guardrail through increased enrollment caps as well as through seeing these buildings that have potentially may have access to a space that have a kitchen for example begin to utilize that to provide meal service in a program that doesn't have it otherwise so I think it's it's the the um that portion of the amendment is intended to to allude to um the tip of the iceberg of a conversation that needs to happen and not to say that I'm not interested in those as well and so um I think potentially tweaking the language to to give a thought to that further conversation that probably can't happen in its entirety before we take action on memo 73 but again alluding to budget conversations um and the conversations

015with Charter programs should the board approve this memorandum make a ton of sense um and so I'm happy to connect to you offline and brother L to tweak and improve um the memorandum to discuss kind of comments and seditions um ahead of the meeting I don't think there's a need to uh make sausage um from scratch live during a school board meeting I'm happy do appreciate that member lesons um if I may continue um this is not directly related to member Jacob's proposals um but one of and I think I spoke to this at our Saturday work session um but one of the things that I'm considering perhaps particularly in light of the governor's uh press conference today which I have heard here say maybe flat funed education may be flat funded um right now

016the board has no idea no ability to Divine the intentions of the 34th legislature they have not yet GED in um however there is a window of time between when they begin their work in January and our second meeting in February where something could take place um and the BSA or other levers could be meaningfully adjusted and so I am considering an amendment that would say effectively if the B student allocation is statutorily adjusted for inflation since fy1 and if additional legislation is passed which would adjust the BSA to account for inflation on an annual basis prior to our second meeting in febr I think I think that's a game changer the amendment would say if those things happen uh the board would reconsider any authorization granted in passage of memo 073 um and we

017would need a certain information from the administration what does a budget for for school number one look like uh if we proposed that it was closed December 17th but something happens you know February 1st by that second meeting in February um it would be nice to see what the budget for that school might look like and a big part of my rational is um I believe that a fy1 a PSA that's adjusted for inflation from FY for fy1 um would allow us to predictably hire enough Educators to reduce class sizes in especially in those Early Elementary grades and deal with the fact that ptrs have increased over time and so all of a sudden that changes our building utilization doesn't necessarily change the number of students in a class um in a school but it

018may change from having one classroom of kindergarteners to two classrooms of kindergarteners and one classroom of first graders to two classrooms of first graders so all of a sudden that may change how the buildings are proposed to be utiliz so just if these things happen in a timely fashion in Juno I would be interested in in making sure that we would have a known time and place to review any authorization that was granted um by this passage uh it's it's a bit of a carrot if you will but um I think it's a necessary one because I do think it's pertinent new information uh relevant to the FY 26 budget um I think that another potential Amendment you want to do you want to pause feedb on that okay so any conversation or questions or

019perspective on an amendment which would ask the board and in carot a um a roll back provision essentially should the legislature drastically and dramatically it sounds like um increase education funding in 34th the first half of the 34th legislature ask a Qui clarifying question um is the intented the amendment that the legisl pass a BSA Bill equivalent to about $1,900 and the governor sign it or is um uh well I guess it would need to I would want to be certain of it so I think it needs to be either a veto proof majority uh passes it or um or or I I guess I haven't thought all the way through but I think it's a great question great question um member Higgins I'll just say no I requested earlier and I don't I don't

020have it all hand but we questioned what the impact be capacity and getting that earlier I think Str provided that last fall huh last fall yeah last fall so that gives us at least a perspective it doesn't completely because we got sixth grade now moved out but it gives us pretty good perspective of how dramatic it would change and that makes a difference on space as well then I think uh one other kind of just thought bubble around this topic um if we were to pass an amendment like this we're also essentially um forecasting what board members would want to use the BSA 4 um one thing I want to flag is that we have two outstanding contracts that still need to be negotiated that could limit our capacity to do something like decreasing PTR

021because we'll need to make sure we can make the payroll for whatever those unsettled contracts amount to just I'm going to jump in then we'll go back to member Higgins and then we'll go to Mr Anderson um one of the just in a conceptual I I'll say that um if we're going to carve out a a plan to consider walking back a plan to reduce our footprint the elementary level I would hope it's not purely attached to an allocation of resources to public education but a broader long-term fiscal plan at the state level um why we're losing um residents year-over-year without migration and a third of our young people are fleeing to the lower 48 U really is a byproduct of of a couple of different things not to not limited to our lack of

022a long-term fiscal plan as a state or over Reliance on the volatility of oil prices our lack of one of the worst retirement options for Public Employee and teachers in the nation um the lack of affordable housing and child care in major urban areas and so um allocating money to public education is certainly one fix of a multi-prong solution that really our legislature has been trying to work on and has failed year overy year to implement um in conjunction with our governor but it it is not the um Silver Bullet to bring back um 30% of our young people and keep them here um and not to mention attract the necessary professionals we need from the lower 48 because the University of Alaska system can't produce enough certificated teachers at this point so um I

023I do agree that it would make sense to Revis it if the legislature takes a certain course of action but I think it goes beyond education funding we need them to have a vision for the future of our state which they've not been able to implement over the last decade um Mr Anderson then we'll go to member Higgins so I I think I I think what we're going to see in February is the governor's education bill will come out really early um and it probably likely is going to have a different number than what the Senate and House Education committee has come out with in theirs in February and so I I just you know I I think I think it's going to take more than four weeks for them to come from the governor's

024bill um to them and try to find compromise he talked about that a little bit in his press conference um and he mentioned how great the charter schools were how great home school was and then he went straight into I'll come up with the education Bill and then we'll have to work our way um through the legislature and come to an agreement but he he did imply that he is he is going to want the state control of new charter schools and things like that because he still feels um or believes that that's um a component of a strong future State education system so I mean however it's written I think realistically it it it doesn't appear that those all three of those tripod legs are all in sync right now yeah fair enough if

025you do reference towards the compensation being part of the factor with the money I I think they link hand in hand we're not going to be able to recruit and retain teachers unless we use money that we get in for low in classroom size you can't be dedicated to that if you don't hire people I made a comment um in community council I said look we've got a really complex issue even if you know we still have to be able to hire people if we can't do that with the UAA sh so far behind and then Define benefit on top of it is a nightmare I I still recall the governor making a comment as the senator saying he's going to cut they School District you want that money to go to school home school

026and so this has been consistent with what he has been saying over and over and over again but it's really the legisl that's open side so I don't think we count on anything but I think contingency as putting lesson saying seems to beate to let people know where we stand and where we want to go put myself in the queue just really quickly to say that in line with your vision for the conceptual additional language I think it could still be crafted in a way that alludes to that right sizing won't be just a onee conversation for ASD and so those fixes could address potentially future years of right sizing I know that the the report on 2050 analysis for a population didn't forecast strong um results in terms of migration Trends so um yeah

027leave it there remember list yeah thank you and I will have to leave in just a little bit um to elementary school KS out at 2:30 um so I have two potential SE separate amendments one of them would remove one one of the named elementary schools on the list if that were to be approved um you need to change the recommendation from four to three to sort of corresponding language um but if that were to move forward then a second amendment would be uh would involve uh would essentially say that given that the administration removed three schools from the initial right sizing recommendation and perhaps the board were removed a four um and the reality that the district may still need to be optimally Consolidated to provide Educational Services to students um that this amendment

028would also say that uh the superintendent would recommend no less than three additional schools um sort of in the fall of 2025 for FY um for the 2627 school year so we' be revisiting the consolidation conversation um that we would be it would be focused on reducing combination classes at the elementary level um improving secondary students course offerings or access to secondary access to course offerings at secondary levels um improving the district efficiency um and and just to clarify that U maybe reflecting on the right sizing rubric that the guidance to leave special programs intact would not this time preclude um the movement of one or more special programs or even existing charter schools to Alternative locations um if doing so would ensure the continuation of the special program and maybe facilitate the expansion of

029students served by the charter so it's essentially I mean and I will I will be blunt when I look at the neighborhood side of things um in um the schools that are proposed this year as well as some other schools where there's a neighborhood and special program um it's it's those kids on the neighborhood side of special program schools who I think were in some cases um not serving through this particular right sizing rubric I mean I can think of eight kindergarteners on the neighborhood side of one special program and 11 first graders on the neighborhood side of that same special program and I think moving forward that those kids are going to be in combination classes their entire Elementary career unless something changes and so I just I wonder whether moving special programs around

030so that they can still have access to those programs but that the neighborhood students are ultimately better served um in that process and so this I'm sort of discussing bigger conceptual amendments that of course will take time and reflection um but I at least wanted to air some of my thinking um into the special meeting so I thinkk thank you for that opportunity I think my only comment is when the district comes out to close schools it's all consuming for the senior um staff and and and the board in many cases and doing it every year um really takes a lot of the focus away from the first semester I think even doing it every two years this year was still um really very much all consuming and emotional for the entire Community however Tuesday

031night turns out um I'm strongly supportive of starting every school year with which schools we're going to close as opposed to how we're going to focus on education and letting an entire school year at least every other year focus on students instead of adults which is really by Pleasures end up being within the community is discussions but that's I mean obviously for votes I'm all in but um it it takes a lot out of the out of everybody and not just the staff it's it takes a lot out of everybody if if that's an every year thing clarifying question Mr so I I I don't I don't dispute any of that I think the the administration originally proposed a three-year closure plan which I think had the board approved um without any modification I I

032think it's fair to say that there would be some in the community who R viiew each year as an entirely separate discussion despite what the board passed initially is is there any way to mitigate some of the starting from the bottom of the hill at this year while still looking at potentially including a second year whether it be in year two two or your three does that make does that make sense we haven't started the analysis on the next round and I just I don't know when we I mean this has been six straight months of community discussions and involvement really really three if you want to talk the whole Community um I mean honestly if it's I I just think at some point it it it certainly does take your most senior leaders Focus

033for the for the whole first semester out at least much of it and that that's my that's my concern I've been through this twice now everyone in this room has been through this twice we we know exactly how all consuming it is and I think this past fall I was grateful that I had one year um to focus on everything from snow equipment to all the other things that fall underneath me that I should be looking at all of those other systems for efficiencies and and and I'll be honest um for several of us we have not been looking at those the last few months it's really been 90% right sizing 10% everything else and and and so there's there's a a cost to efficiency of operations if every year that's your focus for half

034the school year and you just to clarify that you think think that would have been different if the board in one year approved a threeyear plan it it depends if there was any belief that approving a three-year plan would automatically mean it could never be repealed then a three-year plan has benefits but if you pass a three-year plan and then every year you get to review whether the original passage because every April there's potential for new board members who did not approve of that original plan and that's what I've seen talking to Coos in the lower 48 is on these multi-e ones that's exactly what happens by year two there's three new board members who don't feel obligated um to comply with a prior approval and so it's really hit or miss in the lower

03548 is whether it actually happens appreciate that eight I i' like your approach recently where they went out Bond if with the budget issue and asking people what we should do and all that to me that focused on a better process because it talked about this is the problem these are the options now when you talk about the selection kind of bypass that by saying the selection to see what you want to do when they're saying what are the other options out there and we did we never had that discussion I don't think on talking about this is the problem let's let's play it out see the budget these are the options and this is the selection and then hear from them what they say I'd rather have another selection that's what I think been

036missing I think this is going to go a long way to say the problem is funding people will agree with it it's not just a ease of administration it's not just a or C it's all of that that's going to be out there so um I appreciate when you know member lessons makes reference about what if we get additional funds things like that because that plays into that budget as well but somewhere along this line we've jumped to this is the conclusion we want without selling what the options were and and having the public Buy in that those options are important to them as well if all the surveys come back every time I see them surveys for teachers come back pretty hot when the school is lower for as for the the district is

037lower and for the education country it's a very bottom they know most is what gets the highest rating and we're tacking what's in rating so I'm just that's my concern I just I like the idea of the discussion now about what the options are rather than foring on on the public that doesn't want school closes that this is the solution member um appreciate some feedback um because I think even if we had closed all the schools that it was going to be a temporary thing and we'd be back at it um and and it is a problem when it's so many schools and we're so spread out we are a large District if the administration was tasked with choosing one school a year for the indefinite future because that unless something changes in Alaska I

038don't see this problem being solved is that significantly less of a burden administratively I do get what you're saying they spent a lot of time first of all just getting a small list and and then doing the further research into whether or not there things we don't know and all that um you know as a board member is supposed to vote on Tuesday night I I haven't had a chance to go to Eagle River yet and they're it it has been a lot to absorb in a relatively small amount of time if it was one school I I one I have a feeling we would probably be able to come up with a good candidate each year uh that might be less controversial it's still going to mean a lot to people affected by it

039but but this is going to be something we deal with every couple of years for quite some time until something changes I was just wondering if that if that would be easier more manageable orther pitfalls I I do see what you're saying if we pass a year plan absolutely I think some people's campaign to to get on the school board to change it and so it would get retried every year anyway um so I don't know if this is better or not yeah I I I think a smaller number is easier than trying to fix the problem and one fell I could see that working but I would need some assurance that the school board is interested in exploring additional schools over multiple years because we could certainly do the work but I think part

040of us just wants to understand where the board falls on the topic of school closures right if there's no interest in doing it let's say on Tuesday night or next year with one school at what point do do we stop or change course that would be my only concern it could easily go back to the Carol com days of every year when we're doing pink slips talk about cutting hockey I mean if the board's not really serious about it then then well I mean it happened like multiple years in a row oh we may have to cut hockey and or or other sports if the ports really not committed it's just something where the public at some point um becomes a little jaded yeah I see it being follow I see it being driven by

041the need um and I at the spreadsheet that member lesson Had where we've got an elementary school that doesn't have enough kids for a grade level class at any gr level and and in the foreseeable future won't um as a board member if that was the only thing we were going to be voting on I think it would be a slam D and and I absolutely do get the need um but yeah it's it's a swirl of schools with really different issues and impacts of closing that just makes it a lot for the public to absorb at one time makes a lot for the board to absor time I I think we do have to do it the real question is what what is the way where we do it as cleanly with this little

042trauma and without soaking up all the administrative resources of the district every year um is be a problem too much but that's just and taped off so I'll turn on the issue as well I think um if if the board chooses to adopt um memorandum 73 on Tuesday um with changes or even with a minor change I I think that the board will have to and and owes our community an answer for how we achieve equity in the right sizing process given we've um the administration took programs from different parts of town off the list and we have we still have excess capacity um in areas of town that are no longer part of the right sizing plan to me the job won't be finished if the board adopts a right sizing plan that doesn't

043include excess capacity in all parts of our municipality and so I feel like it's a natural caring as to how we have that conversation I admit that I'm not the one doing the bulk of the work um and so I I think that probably should be a collaborative effort as as president was alluding to but I don't know that I'm comfortable with um addressing issues of over capacity only in West Anchorage East Anchorage and Eagle River leaving Midtown and South anchor done address and then not having any ideas as to when we will Circle back to that conversation um I think that message changes kind your community deserves to have that full context to so I'll say that with that said I think it was a great conversation hopefully that was helpful I no member

044L has had to leave and so I assume her um amendments will come forward I president Alman I guess just one piece of from a governance perspective at some point I think we may wish to have an amendment deadline um for memo 73 um so those any amendments can be published by Saturday um there is a different levels of governance either municipality or at the State Legislative level a at some point a point of no return where everything's on the table in terms of what's going to be considered so we can have the most meaningful testimony possible leading up to Tuesday um if there are amendments introduced on the floor which have had not any a very limited opportunity for review that that haven't been posted publicly I think that's I think we can do

045better than that and I think that there shouldn't be a problem given the board's been looking at the same data set for quite some time to ask for an amendment deadline and so I would ask that we consider setting Saturday morning um when our agenda goes live as the deadline for any amendments to be considered um and then you know there need to be modifications or language workshopping from there I think that'd be appropriate but broad Strokes I think we want to consider that um with that said uh Miss Grant do we have any other members online that have raised their hand or joined us since we started no okay um we'll go to Mr Ace I have two questions or about the bullets about the memo I guess the first one I see that

046tutor is going to go k6 instead of K5 have we I don't know does anybody in here know how many at Denali actually chose to stay I mean sixth graders chose to stay versus going on in middle school yeah I think significant if the board doesn't mind me um kind of bringing some information to the table on sixth grade um there the sixth grade question at tutor um I think it's a valid one um there both Denali and Aquarium Charter have opted to stay k6 um this year um even though we've moved most of our district to sixth grade at Middle School um Aquarian is actually getting ready to come to the board with a memo to request to go to K5 because of um kind of dwindling sixth grade population um Denali has not

047made any moves that direction but they are noticing similar drop in enrollment in sixth grade as well um at monor it is a little bit more flexible because they are multi- AG classrooms to absorb that but it's just food for thought around that part of yeah thank you I can see that being moving forward and then the second one is um are we not considering a child care facility at one of our closing facilities so I can address I think both of those um I'll take a step at the the first um my language regarding the tutor Elementary monory program specifically would only apply to the monory program and is driven inart from conversations I've had with the parents of the monstory program um they value their parents has been given a choice to remain

048in the program to sixth grade recognizing that it is effectively a combination classroom um at least as I understand it with fair enough yeah um and so um there it wouldn't be where we would have to allocate um additional staff and the program at tutor as I understand could especially use the enrollment um at least in the short term and so I think it's uh there won't have to be much um Staffing realignments and there will be minimal impact besides to the families that choose to utilize that option it's really just a a a very little downside choice to those families it isn't being driven by myself as a board member I don't I haven't had any student in the monory program either tutor or Denali uh simply a request that was made um going

049back to the decision by the district to actually pull six gr out beforehand a call for Equity between Denali and tutor so I think it's a chance while we're um while the roof is off so to speak to paror Capital planning project language again to make a slight tweak to provide um equity in a program and then also makes some parents pretty happy from what I understand um I believe the monory PTA side of tutor specifically had a meeting they had a conversation they sounded generally in favor of this proposal again with a little downside appreciate that um the second I'll speak to the the plan which I think right now is pretty clear from Administration um there there isn't a concept that's proposing right now child care to coexist to be collocated in a

050facility but I know the board is very passionate about addressing this and my hope is that in the near future we can begin a conversation as to the intersection of excess capacity in our buildings at the elementary level specifically and uh opportunities to collaborate with Community Partners to provide that space um but speaking as a board member not having to do the work I'll say that even I'm running against bandwidth limits as to how many questions I can ask Administration as to what they can do um so I can't imagine where their bandwidth is at but it is something I anticipate addressing as a district soon um at least from the board level and then Mr Anderson if you I think you're going to see that when we talk about the repurposing of the schools

051we're also going to bring up repurposing questions of schools um obviously I have been talking to people um not about school closures but in in the child care world and I think that that we'll be ready um in the second semester to come forward with some potential options uh that would help provide a valuable resource for our our staff and and in some cases the community um within our schools and as you would expect it would it would be something that would have to grow over multiple Years A lot of people that cross Anchorage are already in leases they can't get out of I mean there's lots of reasons plus there's a Workforce shortage in Anchorage at almost every single level um but I think that that the board will be pleased to see that

052we will have a plan to have something moving forward sooner rather than later and and I guess for clarity Purp is how I view the conversation of child care and an intersection with excess capacity is it will help alleviate and mitigate potentially future rightsizing conversations but it does not negate the need to revisit the items at memorandum 73 as listed right now and this is a yes and solution um so that's how I'm um president Hollman and then we'll member um I was just going to touch back to your suggestion about a deadline we know Amendment deadline um I'm thinking if somebody did something dramatic say like add a school to West that would be an unnoticed action even though we're considering closures that's such a significant change um but if somebody just wants to

053do like say word smithing or technical adjustments that could be done uh to achieve what you're asking about but that that's my inclination because we don't normally have a de for that agreed and I think it's I I I think it would be the board engaging in additional transparency and just good governance of saying as many amendments as we anticipate bringing forward um we should be posting ahead of time again this is not a surprise to the bo we've been talking about this since the start of the school year um in some form or fashion really we knew we were going to be revisiting this topic the last time we talked about right sizing um I think that there would be an opportunity for board members to get their amendments not publicly noticed and then

054if there's additional amendments we really would want to carefully analyze as to why they weren't posted previously and if it is really just word smithing or if something isn't timing any longer um we should be justifying why we waited until just the last second to bring something up without proper notice because again I I question we able to get community feedback on those amendments is kind of my concern so and I'll just say for my part I'll be I'll be laser focused on better understanding why if someone didn't we multiple opportunities now we've had a Saturday work session we've had a governance meeting if if I'm not aware of an amendment that get brought up that our business meetings on a topic that is so heavily been discussed I'm don't want to know why and

055I hope the rest of the bo will too um Grant I just wanted to let you know that member lesons is online no hands are raised but great okay yeah thank you member Les for joining us online we'll go to member hi com sure yeah do you have so you don't have a comment on right sizing on right sizing just make comment in general about this the the two Elementary came up before and I know that they want to keep everybody the and that was an issue so it wasn't considered I don't know if there's any other schools that fall in that category that the same concerns but you're right monor is a different scenario it's four five6 in the same grade and it disrupts the the plan of what they wanted to do I

056know the staff the parents they were looking at trying to come forward with even a Charo to make it okay to eight uh and so that they wouldn't be held back by the administration so I think this is a good move if we did that I appreciate that uh within it and I I totally agree with the trying to do something to provide more access to these various optional programs that we have in our guard rails mean those guard rails we got to look at each one we don't we're not meeting them we said we're not going to operate without a plan that does that without a plan so um we need to have an honest discussion are these Bo rails valid are they achievable and if they AR then we need to say we

057need to have that discussion because I think three of the four gold will not being met and and so I think we need have a discussion be honest about appreciate that M so I'll say that for my U my perspective some of the um leadership around G needs to come from us which I think is part of the reason why I'm proposing this I think pretty significant and and and um noteworthy Amendment regarding Charter School transportation this um I I I've made a point to connect with with leaders of charter schools that have contacted the board and I I think this really hasn't been considered previously so I think it's on us to think outside of the box too since these are on guard rails but I appreciate the send Dr Bryan and if I

058could just comment I agree we need to make some movement on the guard R but I would be remiss if I didn't point out that we do prepare reports to the board that outlines the progress that we've made on application rates specifically for charter schools and in the most recent report you'll see that we're actually on target number two we've decided to put as part of the repurposing plan potentially charter schools and buildings that are closed the idea being that if a charter school is in a neighborhood school that has kitchen facilities and is more walkable for families that's a step in the right direction and then number three we're supportive of aspects of what member Jacobs is uh supporting via the amendment which would be added Transportation opportunities for students um something that logistically

059will be ambitious to pull up but I'm committed to working with the board to make that happen so I just want to clarify we're making positive movement towards the guardrails they're not going un addressed but there there's a lot more that we can do and I'm excited to do that thank you um is there other conversation on right sizing um questions for administration conversation on amendments that have either been proposed or conceptual at this point okay hearing seeing none um our upcoming meetings for governance include January 30 2025 and February 13 2025 um if there is no other business for our governance committee meeting I will yeah I want to make sure that that we include items on those meetings one of those is the uh submission of request for information through the superintendent on

060a recent event I tried to was going to talk to someone about information superintendent advised me I had to go follow that process when I said I'm not looking for a report or anything else it's just questions I'm told I still have to go through the superintendent I don't and it said that's my policy requirement as he interprets it so I'm not going to be prepared with the questions I would have had on coming up right that had a question he knows that's what it was talking about he included email and said that I don't know of any other school board members that's being told you can't talk to people till you get submitted to the superintendent and that that policy is being done that way just from a history standpoint when I got on

061school board originally people expect it to spend you were assigned of departments to learn that department everybody got a different one then we moved forward what we had a request come through that was rather time intensive on academic data we wanted to gather superintendent said it would cost a lot of money so they went through this process of saying it needs to be submitted and approved it didn't get approved because of the cost when that superintendent left one month later we found out all that information was available all the time it was rolled out to everybody and we had three years worth immediately so there's been a process here making it difficult to get information this is a new barrier that surprises me and I think that if we have that kind of thing the

062president of the board gets involved in interpretation not the superintendent on board policy but I it is a it is a concern I think we need to include that item on the next one and I'll bring it up in the board meeting on Tuesday as well y sure sounds great um president hman can decide if he wants to talk about um R RFI process and how to best um get information as a board member either at a retreat or during governance um I'll leave that up to him appreciate your points um if there no other conversation we'll adjourn our government meeting at 2:23 pm. thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.