CorpusRecord 4025

ASD School Board Finance Committee 12/12/24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Anchorage School District
Date
2024-12-13
Location
Anchorage Municipality, AK
Material
Transcript
Extent
5,189 words · about 29 min
Collected
2026-05-16

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e is there anybody online okay we are now unmuted you're ready to go um we have uh no school board members online um Mr Stein is online he um well good afternoon it is 12 about 12151 16 on Thursday December 12 this is the finance committee I'm Kelly lons chairing the finance committee and we'll just go around the very small room uh Andy hman board member Bryant superintendent Katy parrot senior director of management and budget Katy Grant executive assistant and building plans to be back shortly plans to be back shortly terrific um okay well we have three items on the agenda for today the first is the pro forat review and as a reminder we have seen the pro forat as a non-action item at our recent meeting it will move to action

002status at our upcoming meeting and we also received um a slide deck at our work session giving us an overview of our situation but I'll be happy to turn it over to miss Carr for um additional followup all right thank you uh so yes so we have presented the proor of budget and just to kind of review um what that uh document does and what it outlines uh we take a look at what is in current law uh based on what we are expecting to receive for um revenues in fy20 six and planned expenditures and the Planned expenditures are based on taking a snapshot of all of our staffing Personnel programming as it is right now in the fy2 approved budget and applying incremental increases based on what are in uh ratified contracts um what

003uh we believe to be for some of the discretionary or non-personnel items what we believe to be a moderate uh inflationary increase most of those Lin items uh were increased by 1 and a half% um as well as taking a look at some of the uh projected or known rate increases uh for things like utilities uh we build in different percentages depending on what um what information is known at the time or what is expected uh for the future years's uh expenditures in those areas um some of the things that uh we've kind of disclaimed in putting together proforma are the unknowns um or the uh items that are not yet currently in law so we don't uh put together a proor of budget uh with uh any one-time supplemental funding uh assumed uh we

004also uh have some outstanding contracts that will be entering uh negotiation for aea uh for food service and for bus drivers and attendance uh one of the uh caveats I would say about the bus drivers and attendance is that ballot measure one uh with an increase to the Alaska minimum wage does change um the base pay for cost drivers so uh we did take a closer look and an analysis on how that would impact um those wages and benefits and we did build that into the proa budget so with all of that kind of combined uh we have presented um a a projected deficit in the operating fund of uh 107 million uh with an additional uh I believe 3.9 uh deficit in the transportation fund um and so those are the numbers that we're

005working with uh we're very very pleased to have launched a budgeting tool um which I believe went out uh yesterday and is now publicly available that uh essentially is based uh on the proforma budget it ties out exactly in revenues and expenditures to the proforma budget and is available online to uh for the public uh to be able to go in and look at those different amounts and levers within the budget and play with that uh try to balance uh explore some of the areas um in the budget that uh could be changed to try to balance and to go through that process um we'll also in a minute go through uh fund balance projections that are pretty much on par with what has been projected for the proforma budget we know that because of

006the sizable deficit in the operating fund that it's more than likely that in order to kind of lever down the dramatic um I mean excruciating really impacts of trying to make cuts at that level that we will need to bring in a sizable amount of fund balance to help maintain core programming so with uh the available fund balance of 47 million should the board uh vote by super majority to uh come to down to that level of a minimum of 5% that gives us about 47 million that we've planned and with that 47 million applied to um the very real 107 million deficit and that takes us down to about 60,000 or I don't know why I do that I'm so sorry yes I wish yeah but yes Milli thank you one thing that I'd

007like to maybe explore a little bit um is could you talk about and and Dr Brian as well what are the risks I understand the benefit of spending our fund balance down from an 8% or minimum which is in policy to 5% we did this last year as a means to prent as many Cuts as possible to the system to prevent PTR increases it's very possible that a super majority of the board could vote to do that again and that would leverage my understanding an additional $20 million so it's you know 27 million in fund balance if we spend down to 8% 47 if we V to spend down to 5% could you talk about love the risks involved in in that tradeoff sure okay um yeah so so really fund balances your savings account

008and cash flow so when you spend your fund balance um and we're talking about when we're talking about the numbers that we would bring forward to balance the budget we're talking about essentially unreserved fund balance um that is money that we don't have for contingency purposes that we don't have in the event of an emergency for any financially healthy organization you want to have enough resources in the bank set aside um to be able to um wage any storms that unexpectedly come so for example perfect example is the earthquake um those resources help to be able to respond really very quickly without uh the certainty of any kind of other relief funding that might manifest later on but it really allows the district to be able to be very quick and responsive to things that

009happen that we don't currently have planned resources for so when you get down to the very very minimum levels that we're talking for an organization of our size that you only have six million dollars available to do that with that's it's it's scary it's it's concerning um um it's yeah it's not a great position to be in um so uh that I guess that's the danger is when you're using those resources they're not there to use for what they really need to be there for um the other thing is when you're balancing a budget using onetime resources they're not available in future years so the more that the district relies on onetime money um to be able to continue just core operations just exactly what not not doing anything new or extra but just doing

010exactly what we're doing right now and preserving those core you know core Services um if you're if you're planning on onetime money to keep doing those things it makes the future years choices much more dramatic if that makes sense yeah if I could just add so there's obviously an alternative which would be just to spend down to 8% the issue with that is we would need to identify additional dollars to uh balance the structural deficit and given that the bulk of our budget our Personnel we would need to make the choice to reduce Force prior to knowing what the actual Revenue change would be from the state so in other words when the district has done that in the past we've U reduced our force and then we received more money from the state in

011the summer and then we were in a position where we're asking people to come back so really that's the choice that we're making is do we want to spend down our fund balance and take risk and again as Katie mentioned the risk would be a major health event potentially natural disasters even a state government shutdown are all very valid reasons for why you want to have a healthy fund balance but on the flip side the trade-off would be reducing our Personnel prior to knowing what the outcome of the revenue situation in Juno will be um so when you release those people it's very likely that a lot of those individuals will not come back because they will have position so it really is a very difficult tree one time I know that we had to

012send out layoff notices to people because of the delay with the state when they approved the budget but I understand at least they they they changed that they there was some legal changes within the judicial system not judicial but the legislative process so that that didn't have to be by June 1st or some what is the you know what the current process is a much notice we have to give them if we don't get a budget approved by a certain date do we have to send out l notic this or how does that look like now you know so by code we have to have um an approved budget to the m municipality by March 1st so um by Alaska statute we have to have a balanced budget submitted to the state by July 15

013um I believe the statute says that layoff notices have to be submitted by May 15th if I remember correctly um maybe don't quote me on that um but but I believe it's May um and so there certainly is a timing issue we have heard indications that the legislature may try to FastTrack uh education bill um and there were attempts to do that in the last legislative session um that were you know we know where where that went um but I think that it's a fair point to say that uh that the use of fund balance um down to the 5% we're prioritizing real people and programs Now versus maybe uncertainty in things we might need to respond to in the future um hopefully knowing that there will be some legislative action that can provide resources

014that then we can potentially use to backfill the coffers I believe our chief of HR is online if he'd like to clarify the layoff deadline sure happy to um Dr Bryan yeah um we have a statutory requirement to issue layoff notices to 10e teachers by May 15 and um it's the last student day for 10e staff so it's a little bit of a bifurcated process um we would have to look at non-tenured first obviously um before we issued any tenur layoff notices and that would throw in just for perspective and the early all non-ed staff were laid off every year that's just a standard operating procedure so we come from there um you had made reference to the adjustment factor for the cost of minimum wage adjustment there was also adjustments in the course Cally

015that may apply to some of our contractors has that been an issue at all uh that is something that honestly we haven't C it out yet so uh but that would be something that we would build into uh the preliminary budget so we'd update those numbers there and then the contingency you make from medical insurance because of the the the potential cap there how much I mean you come back we' come back to us for additional funding as well how much contingency do you calculate in when you have such a tremendous liability uh that is a great question um that is also something that I think we'll be evaluating very closely and putting forward a recommendation when we put forward the preliminary budget um so this the proforma budget does include an increase to that

016liability that's kind of planned for um but what we'll want to do is really um kind of hone in on those numbers so that the preliminary budget includes what something a little bit closer to what we think will happen Okay so we we will plan for a a increase to that liability so they maybe still come back to the board asking for additional money this year if needed for because they lack if cost increases really do outpace what we've budgeted but we're trying to set a budget for FY 26 that that meets the need is what I would say so that we don't have to come back to the board to ask for supplemental requests so we're trying to to hit the nails so that we can so that we don't have to ask you

017for additional money later um one you touched I appreciate that you touched on the budget tool that board members explored at our Saturday work session and for folks online if you go to uh the new budget um Hub page which is asdk12.org f26 which stands for fiscal year 26 there is a button that says launch the balancing tool and that's where you can it was in the email that went out to ASD community members and families yesterday um and so I'm hopeful that folks will spend the time it's not an easy you know click here you actually have to dial in and and toggle your expenditures and your Revenue to try to create that balanced budget but I'm wondering whether the Administration has had a chance to review board members initial use of the tool

018and that's something that's sharable at a at a high level I mean for example were most board members willing to spend down to 5% or not willing to spend down to 5% so we haven't pulled all the analytics on that yet so this will be the very first time that we're doing it so we need to dive into that a little bit more but I do believe the plan is to provide that information back to the board in a report okay uh no later than the the meeting of the 17 so at our upcoming board meeting we will get an initial Glimpse at what the board members who participated in the exercise uh indicated they would be comfortable with so one of our work session topics is um allocated for budgets I would imagine during

019that time we can preview some information board members okay great um yeah Mr a are we allowed to jump to the last page on this yeah by all means I don't know if you guys were okay so on line 29 it says purchase services sorry Cory how far down is the I can the very last page just the end this under the six year outlook everyone online sick bying that quickly oh sry page 19 oh a different document no that's it okay yeah line 29 keep going purchase Services what all is in that because this is all I'm not I'm not sure if that's including everything that we yeah what that's pretty much including um let me just pull it up and refresh my that's more than just instruction oh yeah for sure no that's

020pretty much all all contracted Services um instructional and administrative that includes things like equipment repair uh technology maintenance agreements that would include any contracted services for custodial grounds or building that also includes legal fees um contracted Transportation um all utilities um any uh rental equipment or rent for rent and leases for lands and buildings I just want to make sure it was more than just instruction yeah for sure yeah um I appreciate you pulling this page when I was reviewing the proforma um as I was completing some of the details in the joint resolution uh that's being brought forward for an action item uh for the 17th um if you look on line 22 here um line 22 and under the FY 26 column you'll see 558 and I I confirmed with our CFO but

021miss carrot you're here as well and that's the number of staff that would need to be laid off or or that's the number of positions that we we cannot afford under our current reality I don't know if you can share more about that um sure I you know one of the challenges when we have the sizable deficits that we're facing is that for our general fund expenses 85% of those are our um 15% of those are non-personnel and of that 15% there's some of those non-personnel items that we cannot cut if we have the existing buildings we have we have to pay for the heat and electricity to we have to pay for our liability insurance there's some things that legally we're obligated to pay for um and so when you're looking at a a

022deficits of this size um you cannot make meaningful reduction without hitting those Personnel costs um and so those are people those are are things that would have to be positions that would have to be reduced and they're not entirely just classroom teachers right it's just sort of taking the district as a whole it's just across the board that's sort of the average cost of employing you know the deficit divided by the average cost of employing people leads to that number correct yeah and so the six year outlook takes a very highle look um and you know projects out through um FY 31 um if some things kind of if the environment that we're operating in Remains the Same in terms of funding and expenditures um and so so this is a very high level look

023at what the ongoing impact would be of flat and would that say that if if flat funding were to continue through FY 26 and then again into FY 27 is that an additional 40 staff in FY 27 or an additional 598 yes staff yeah correct okay because you know there are some things some adjustments that are made year over year right so we can assume that inflation continues to exert upward um you know upward force on the cost of doing business as well as if we're you know if we're doing right by our contracts and our employees we're providing those increases that we have planned for and that have been ratified in the negotiated agreements so this Outlook does incorporate those increases and so here's you know our model that we're operating in right now

024to do business costs increase over time if funding stays the same you have to make larger and larger Cuts over time in order to um absorb those um costing the lack of funding to support operations um appreciate that um if I could pivot to Mr Lang again um we spoke about you know a May timeline but I'm also aware that after we pass the board's budget at the second meeting in February there are some things that happen very quickly and I wonder if that's something the administration could speak to what happens after the budget is passed in February assuming that we have to pass balanced budget and our reality doesn't change like what happens February 19th uh February 19th um thank you for the question member lesons um we would start our staffing timeline uh

025contractually um there is an order of operation um that we have to follow so if we know we have FTE changes that are going to result in um Staffing changes for the year the first thing that we have to um address is any displaced teachers um from their current positions at their school so that's different than a layoff that just means their position and the FTE occupies that that school doesn't exist in next year's budget so we would notify them on the 19th um of that displacement principles would also need to post any known openings that they have based on retirements um or other folks that have notifi them that they won't be returning and then we start the process of looking at placing those displaced teachers which we typically try to do before we

026head into spring break once we come back from spring break then we typically have a staffing event um where we would look at um any voluntary transfers folks who um have submitted a transfer to another building or another program um where there's an opening principles have the opportunity to um to basically pick Folks up in those voluntary transfer positions and then we would look at new hires so all of that is the Staffing process assuming there's no layoffs um if we thought we were headed into a layoff posture we would certainly have to look at whether or not um you know we we execute all parts of that especially we would probably put a pause on new hires other than in the critically hardto fill positions so um anytime that we head towards layoffs one

027of the things that is required in State Statute is that we develop a layoff plan um so as the budget is developing um knowing the size of the deficit this year we will probably start the exper you know the thought experiment of you know looking at all possible scenarios and starting to pencil out what that plan would look like um so nothing obviously definitive at this point but that's that's kind of the process as it would unfold through the spring semester once the budget is approved would it be fair to say that we're replenishing our fund balance each year by all the positions that are unfilled that unspent money I think the answer to that would be yes or no so and and I'll explain I know it's not so so pre we do build

028in as a budgeting tool we build in an attrition line into our budget right so when there are reductions on the expenditure side or or for vacancies right so that money isn't spent some of that is already planned for in the budget um and then used to plan the projected fund balance as we're moving forward right so those numbers are accounted for why I would say um however in previous years we um used a much more conservative number on the attrition line so that if those um if the vacancies were higher than what we've projected and included in the budget for attrition yes then that that would impact the fund balance and increase fund balance so partly I'm wondering if we did take our fund balance to 5% and then in November there's an earthquake

029and half a dozen buildings damage by suspending any hiring on those unfilled positions does that money become available to act as fund balance if we were in that kind of a straight I guess the way I'm asking is that real money yeah and we can get it back at any moment if we just pause that given that we're sitting on a couple hundred on right so potentially but we would have to do a really really close analysis to see to shore up our projections to see where we're at right so um one of the things that we discussed in the last budget cycle is that when we increase that number that we're using for attrition in the budget that increases our risk because in order to have a balanced budget at the end of the

030year we really those those have to stay vacant at that level we don't want that because it impacts our ability to provide services it taxes our employees that's not a good position to be in but yes so if something were to happen mid year there would be some emergency levers potentially the district could pull to ensure that there were resources available maybe at the end of the year but that would be a very hard atypical thing to have to do and it would take a lot of work to really um hone in on what level we would even be able to do that so the next part of the presentation we're going to be talking about fund balance and so that might be a place where we can look at some of those areas and

031see how that does impact our fund balance and kind of where our position is at the do we adjust where we're at with unfilled positions through the year or only you in terms of budget yeah I mean you know if we at a position for a whole year and it's December and we haven't fed it we pull that money back into uh the budget is unspent funds uh or do we let it sit until we finished out it sits so the only time that we Tinker with the budget is um you're used to seeing a revision that we put forward right if um if there's something atypical that happens that's a large enough or significant enough nature that we would want to reprogram right what we're doing so we've done that we did that last

032year when we uh realize the onetime funds um but the way that it kind of works is that some of those some of the costs are already taking place other places so sometimes when there's a vacancy um we're covering that with um additional staff time so people are giving up their planning periods they're maybe working over to make things work or to cover for a position uh we're paying for increase in sub costs so in the last few years um our sub budgets have not been enough we've had overages in substitute costs every year and so there's all of these little lovers and things that kind of currently happen in the budget so that that money is kind of taken up someplace else either by the attrition that we're budgeting or by the additional cost

033of trying to cover and make do without that um maybe this is a good time to Pivot to uh the fund balance projections which is officially the second item on our um agenda today so we'll just kind of go through it step by step um similar to I think how the CFO goes over these reports uh first we'll take a look at where we're at with Revenue um you can see from the local sources that our interest earnings are higher than the budget so far this year that tends to be um the trend over the last couple of years um where the rates are are have been fairly high but of course that could always change with the marketto market recognition of earnings um so uh we'll be watching that but that's good to see

034uh you'll see that from the state revenue sources um the state revenue is down and that is just due to having lower enrollment than the projection um that we had and that also seems to be on Trend um for from the last uh several years uh we also for uh our federal funds uh it looks like we're uh realizing a little bit more impact Aid um than the projected budget and uh not as much Medicaid Revenue uh one of the things that um I would kind of uh say about the Medicaid revenue is that uh that did come up in the uh I believe the board meeting or the work session uh we're going to take a close a very close look at that but there is a retooling going on in that program but

035of course there's always a delay in setting up a a new system and then realizing the revenue so that's something that will be on the agenda for doing a deeper dive at a later time and so you'll see that the total variance is about 38 million that's that number at the bottom there and after we account for the use of fund balance that's about uh 900,000 um so that's uh seems to be pretty on target with our projections so if you'll go to the expenditures sheet uh for the expenditures this seems to be pretty consistent with prior years uh the largest variances uh from the budget tend to be in the PA professional area and certificated staff um and but then as we just discussed that's directly related also to an overage in substitute costs

036uh so the total salaries show to be a little bit over budget um but there are funds uh being held in an allocated that that are going to be transferred we're in the process of kind of matching up some of the unallocated with our actual positions and salary line items for things like summer school and and other things so that will kind of even out um after we process those transfers for benefits uh the medical attrition and waivers make up the majority of that variant um and so the overall salary and benefits are showing a little under 1 million in total variance once all of the attrition factors are kind of included in that and this uh should be also positive once all of those unallocated funds are transferred to cover um some of those

037sign items um so uh also to note um as a reminder the other contracted services on um at the bottom there under those Services those are are everything from software licenses operation and maintenance contracts um they're also the instructional contracts um but it's kind of the catch off for all of the services that we pay for and that would include the special education contractors so that's one thing that we have re programmed some positions salaries and benefits um budgeted items to cover thoseo about that yeah sometime not long ago but not immediately recently and so yeah so so in the last few years I think there's been a few of those actions that have been put forward to the board for approval to move funds from the special education positions to the contracted position so

038that we could cover those services and is it if my memory serves me I mean those positions are significantly more expensive it it it depends it kind of depends on the service but yes but but for the most part generally speaking Yeah Yeah Mr a you had so that contracted servic is a different number than on the other page I referenced is that because this is only instructionally based uh no that's because some of the um so some of the things like utilities rents and leases travel and registration some of those other things that were rolled up into that one number for purchase services are broken out in this one so this one is just has a little bit more breakout of the different components and then um if you go down to the last

039section um equipment shows just a little overbased um it's just a little over based on the actual depreciation and that that is also a number that was built into the proa budget um which was a difference and so um when you look at the budget to Gap basis the that reconciliation uh the transfer amount um there at the bottom is includes um funds that we've received from the FEMA reimbursements um and those were transferred to capital projects and transportation um and there was also 120,000 transfer to uh Child Nutrition for unpaid meal balances um and so that kind of is uh the overview of that page and if you'll go to the last one the summary page so overall um we're currently as is demonstrated by this uh summary we're currently projecting expenditures to exceed

040revenues by about 37.8 million which is actually really really close to what was budgeted um so things are pretty on track with what we were projecting um historically we've been um pretty conservative um and hopefully as the year goes on we will get more savings um as you know the projections can go up and down um but as you know um our CFO tracks that really really closely through the year uh for the 10% fund balance calculation we expect to end at about 12% which would give us just 1 million more than what we were projecting in the proforma for available fund balance so that would give us about 48 million to spend down to the 5% minimum or 28 million to spend down to the 8% so rather the 27 and 47 it's 28

041and 4 48 yeah so uh that would be reflected in the preliminary budget like eight people maybe nine so that that's kind of that um do you have any questions about fund balance no helpful but so yeah um okay well then um I'll let you go ahead then the third item on our agenda we're doing pretty well with time today is ility costs and this was really um it came up in our Point meeting member Broly uh on the assembly brought it up and I reflected that we could had maybe a somewhat of a conversation I don't know a year 15 16 months ago but um you know Heat Is Real uh water rates appear to be going up yes um and if you have information can do uh I think it'd be a great

042time and we're talking about a natural gas shortage um so what does that mean for and's biggest customer correct um so uh yeah so utilities costs were brought up in the joint session and um essentially what I've provided is the historical information related to all of our major utilities um as well as kind of the projections that we have established for um the current year and then we might forecast for future years so the district has done a really good job of um projecting out and including those rate increases in all of the budgets uh that have been approved by the school board and so uh for the current proforma budget we have built in approximately a 5% increase to those line items um that looks to be about on target for where we would

043want to be even with a significant rate increases to some of our utilities um and you can see from these uh slides this essentially is the just the screenshot of the tool that we use to track all of our spending so the um uh your finance department keeps really close track of what's happening with every line item across pretty much the entire budget um and incorporates all of the updated um expenditure information on a month-to-month basis um so anytime the CFO puts forward a fund balance uh report to the finance committee that's based on the actual spending that um is registered through our system and then taking a look at making sure that we're projecting out appropriately and seeing where we're Landing budget um so for any of the uh utilities that we have heard

044rumor of expected rate increases we do build that into our uh forecasting and make sure that we have available resources planned out in the budget um so I as I said right now we're planning a 5% increase to our our budgeted line items with the understanding or assumption that where we've set the budget for the current year seems to be very adequate for what the current expenditures are trending yeah um I'm interested in anything that's been tracked as far as efficiency increases that that impacts there two issues there that pop up but one is you change Oiler systems that are so unbelievably old in probably 8 % efficient compared to 96 but the other is there was a device I know that a number years ago and I thought they put on some school that

045controls uh how much electricity is used and shuts down certain parts so that your your utility cost is based upon your highest use uh time so if you're using tremendous amount in one hour then your whole day is choice on that as I understand it and they control it so your laminators may not come on at the same time to come on in the school because suddenly your cost goes up 20% who knows uh but is there any attempt here or you seen anything that shows the savings whether how you do comparisons of things that the board could look at um and either with the administration or through bonds or something that would show the efficiency and how much money we is saving um that would probably be something that I would have to ask

046uh Mr Anderson um related to the the uh Facilities Management I'm sure that we have that information some of that information I think we actually have to report to deed um on an annual basis in conjunction with the CIP so um that's something that I believe that we can pull together for you okay I'll put together request was the highest use so that day month we don't have many options like you know Sol because you open during the summer and that's what you say I have SOL at my house and it cuts it off getting get used nail but because the snow's not there but but you know there's no benefit to a school kind of stand point because some of you not using it it break even otherwise but the boil system really pay

047eny efficiency studies they window this is sort of anecdotal but I recall when I T green was being rebuilt this is right when I on boarded and I was shown you know the LED lights and the energy fix energy saving fixtures were being thoughtfully integrated into a number of our projects um and so I believe that that is a track there's still programs out there even with the vendors that will pay the for the for the for the new boiler system and you pay for it back out of savings kind of thing all kind of programs that we've never taken full advantage of and so that's kind of why I'm interested in this to say let's why don't we just move forward but that makes a difference on contingency funds on our reserves so because

048we have that liability out there we paying it back still liability in future years so I guess it shows up the reserves and liability we that way yeah yeah that sounds right yeah it's a little tricky but I I just I heard that argument before I just say but there's got to be a way to take advantage of Oiler systems that aren't even relable is a good example that could actually go in there and do it and paying out of savings I know that capital projects and major maintenance they keep really good track and lists of all of the Aging infrastructure um and I think that they're always looking for ways that we can improve and simplify and save money I think they're very well aware of that um just as a to to kind

049of Center ourselves in the utilities conversation as a part as a a percentage of the overall operating fund it's about 3.4% of our total operating fund budget um so um and that's based on what we're projecting for the performa um so um well I'm just I'm looking at the second page under heat for buildings because this is just something that I think is relevant um can't ultimately save a whole lot of money by turning down the building thermostat so cold students find the learning environment challenging um hate to do that but you know it really and inflation is real and since um fy16 you know you're we're looking at you know $1.7 million in in growth and I know that we've offloaded a couple of schools during that time um so I think that that

050it's remarkable to me and I think that there are going to be projected in I mean I think that in buildings will continue to go up perhaps other areas may not see as much growth but I think that's one it's real and I would be grateful for continued tracking and you know you seem very confident that you've got about a 5% push you know projection um but that's also another thing that we'll as we move forward with the preliminary budget that we do um Shore up those numbers yeah like across all of the things that we plan for in the proforma budget we go line by line and update um Shore up the numbers kind of build in some more technical detail into the preliminary budget that we present to the board than what's in

051the great well I appreciate the complexity of everything that goes into um having a sense of where we're at and where we need to be the budget process is not for the fainted heart um and it's valued and they appreciate here any final questions comments okay seeing and hearing none you want to just here in person not not just online um okay great well then um happy to adjourn this committee meeting um I know we have a resumed governance committee meeting in about half an hour um and I believe that our next finance committee meeting will be around about mid January mid January late January January 30 end of January that's what is that's right so um so the November and December we kind of stacked close together and then we'll have uh the holiday

052break and resume um right before the budget conversations really kicking to hi here um but I saw I was before we formerly adjourn I did see going back to the balancing tool that it looks like um it will be open until January 3D yes um so that'll be a nice window of time for folks um to hopefully have the opportunity to um use it and and provide their feedback in my way with that to Jo okay I'll be glad to second

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.