CorpusRecord 4026

12/12/2024 ASD School Board Governance Committee 12/12/24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Anchorage School District
Date
2024-12-13
Location
Anchorage Municipality, AK
Material
Transcript
Extent
5,739 words · about 32 min
Collected
2026-05-16

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e part one of the December 12 um I'll call part one of the December 12th governance committee meeting to order and I was not part of deciding how this is going to be done but we're having a couple of items that we take care of this morning and then at 1:30 governance will reconvene um Mr Jacobs will be here at that time uh but this part we're just looking at the policy review in section 4 and discussion on war policy 5138 possession and use electronic devices uh before we really get started uh let me go around the room announ member and of thise J senior director of midd schools Eric pman senior director of high schools Bryant Super Chief K Johnson Deputy Chief of schools Katy gr executive assistant Kelly L board member

002Cory a AA president and we have the Press here with us would you like to know you're online oh and is anyone joining yes uh member Bellamy is online um and Mr Anderson and Mr Frankenstein okay thank you very much thank you um with that the first item under Section B is a policy review section 4000 um question is does anybody changes they wish to make or suggest and say usual we're not going to take time to read it detail I don't have anything I'm bringing taking of hand um consider that review item two is board policy 5138 stud possession and use of portable electronic devices including m w would you like that I'm sorry I miss something are you going through each of those four policies one by one or all four of them

003um I was just look to see if anybody had anything they want to say about any oh okay that was a broad yes we' been very bro okay great um thank you so much for the pivot then to item two uh regarding cell phone um policy uh potential changes this is with respect to or policy 51 38 and to refresh members of the committee um this was something that I felt was necessary to work on um back in June it's something that I began kind of solo and then I approached the administration and we had a little bit of back and forth um throughout the fall most recently we had a um a follow-up meeting where the administration was able to take an original draft that I had brought run it by principles and um

004we had a great discussion and members Bellamy and Wilson also joined us for that conversation and so the document before you is um I wasn't sure which one which document is before us um I do have the track changes I also have the accepted changes and the feedb I think that that is a lot of red okay um so maybe okay so the one that looks like the current posted policy with track changes that is the one that you have oh that's the one that you had up that's um pivot to the accepted changes maybe let's pivot to the accepted changes uh because it's clean um and just uh starting at the beginning um this would be a change in the name uh it's small but perhaps meaningful a pivot from uh the use of

005portable electronic devices to these personal electronic devices including cellular phones uh because as opposed to a decade ago the you know the district was not then providing Chromebooks um and hotpots to students and um now we are we're really at we are doing those things and so this is a policy really focused on those personal devices that students are increasingly bringing to our schools um so there's an acronym that's used frequently in this policy and we can pronounce it peeds heads PS but it stands for personal electronic devices so um there's a lot of acronyms in education we just added a new one um the main changes um I think at at a high level this policy uh looks at our students well the policy really seeks to get uh cell phones and devices out

006of instructional spaces and it treats students differently based on their age so for elementary students there's really no reason that a personal device needs to be in a classroom at any point on the school day um or on the playground for that matter um I think the same holds true for middle school students however with our high school students right this is a part of becoming digitally literate becoming a citizen in the world is learning how to navigate um responsibility um we still want to keep those personal devices and distractions out of the classroom but um maybe to paraphrase one of our principles there there may only be one principal and you know 1,200 or500 or700 students um and so this policy allows uh personal electronic devices to be available for high school students um

007at lunchtime and in passing periods um so I'd say that substantially like those are the biggest substantial changes maybe I'll pivot to the administration to talk about um what your principles have um discussed and provid feedback yeah thank you for the opportunity to share that um one of the handouts that um is before you right now is really an overview of the feedback that we received from our um School administrators um based on the changes that were um drafted um two weeks ago between the school board um and administration we shared that updated policy with administrators through a survey and we solicited their feedback um just to see what what do they see is um the merits of the changes what potential challenges are out there with those changes that they might anticipate you know

008to the idea of changing this policy we already have a number of schools that have implemented similar changes at the building level and so we really did use their feedback and their experience to help drive on what these changes could practically look like uh at the building level so looking at the um the feedback sheet we did have um about about 60% of our principles uh 30% of our assist principles filled out the survey um across the different divisions we had anywhere um between 50 and and 60% of our administrators from those division levels fill it out and again we asked you know which if any aspects of the policy do they support specifically challenge do they anticipate we asked them to look at the current board policy and the revision to see if there

009was any discrepancies or or um portions of the current board policy that they preferred um and then we asked um what sort of revisions might be put in place that they don't see currently and so what I'd like to do is just share a real high level overview of what their support for the revised policy look like um and feel free to stop me at any time as I um give a little more um deeper information on that but the first thing they really appreciated was the C definition um and the guidelines that exist in this updated draft policy um it's clear it's specific um it creates that coherence between our buildings and our levels so that um teachers and administrators and more importantly students and families know what's expected from um division to division

010um they really like that it prohibits Elementary Middle School students from using peeds during the school day where there really isn't a need whereas a high school um family needs potential job needs they might need to access those Technologies so it provides um that that open door for passing periods in lunch they really appreciated the strong language with enforcement um and knowing that staff have the authority to make those decisions and that they will be um supported with that from Administration it really eliminates the gray areas by making those expectations explicit about being off and away and what that looks like at the building level uh administrators really do appreciate the idea that we need to have some flexibility and Case by casee considerations for these Technologies because some students do need to use Technologies

011for medical reasons for academic reasons and so while we're you know prohibiting the use during the school day for elementary middle school students it does acknowledge that there is a need for some students to have them um and that's going to be part of the communication efforts that the district needs you know to put out as you may some see some students with these Technologies but there's a reason for that um it provides Equity across the levels of again standardizing uh grade level and school level expectation just it takes the the question in gray area out of out of the policies that currently exist the policy is focused on safety um with phones as you know it it provides unsupervised internet access for students if they're just using a network so by not having access

012to their phones they're not accessing any Technologies or sites that we don't want them to be doing during the school day and it increases engagement right and time on task for students in the classro that's really one of the the chief merits of this policy is that um it acknowledges the importance of students to be engaged in their academic Pursuits during the day it's in alignment again with what a lot of our schools are already doing who have implemented a lot of these changes and they're seeing and we've seen it time and time again they're seeing really positive benefits from this and a lot of the challenges that the community has brought up um which which Mr beckon is going to speak to have um you know those concerns really falling away by and large

013because um it it works um it supports instruction making sure that um students are engaged and it does provide an opportunity for parents to to call the office and still get a of their student if need be and then those those specific Provisions um securing PS and lockers or other locations is welcomed by administrators and they really like that it also addresses earbuds smart watches smart glasses some of those other technologies that we're starting to see more and um when you're looking at um following through and enforcing a policy we want to make sure that we're considering all possible avenues for students to um you know to to make mistakes and you know all through so um those are the the pieces of the policy that administrators really supported Mr bman can speak to some

014of the challenges that they have identified yeah great thanks Joe um so as you see on the the survey we pushed out the second question uh what if any challenges do you anticipate in enforcing the draft of the P policy um so we summarize those in bullet points here I'll speak to each one briefly um as a cabin it's important to note that every one of these challenges currently exists none of them are new we could have anticipated this list um we begin with parent push back um it's important to note that we have very little parent push back right now in the schools that have created policy that's more restrictive namely South and and Wendler and there are others but we're receiving very little but um there will be parents who resist the policy

015um particularly when it comes to to confiscation um we get push back when we confiscate uh and there's also some push back from parents um related to their interest in in constant communication with their student being able to to get in touch when they feel like they need to so we can anticipate that um there will be student resistance because they're young people um they're going to hide their devices as they currently do they're going to try to use them in the back room um we can anticipate that um principles were were good to note the the use of smart watches which is expanding and other wearable Technologies could complicate enforcement make it more challenging so that's going to be something we'll we'll want to train uh our our principles and staff on um and

016that's a a fluid topic as the technology keeps changing um it's so always a challenge to ensure that policy is clear and consistently enforced and implemented uh and though this policy is far clearer than than the current one um we can imagine challenges um from classroom to classroom as teachers interpret what it means to have your phone put away believe it or not some will interpret that differently and perhaps school to school so it's going to be really important that our principles are direct and clear about what expectations are um same goes for implementation and mod monitoring um I think this is particularly true probably at Middle School where we have off and away all day with more flexibility at the high school perhaps monitoring will be a little bit easier as the focus will

017be on the classroom where there's more control uh and supervision um special accommodations the challenge there is just making sure that that the special accommodations aren't abused uh it's important that our students with IEPs um medical um assisted technology um students who need translation service are all able to use those but but we need to limit those accommodations to those special groups of students uh and then lastly L logistical challenges making sure that um we're we're careful planners when it comes to storage and security of devices particularly at those schools elementary and where it's off and away all day um and what Joe has pointed out is that our students in middle school for example are using lockers responsibly now and actually locking the lock because their phones are inside so um our principles also

018did a good job of suggesting um ways that we could um get in front of or address the challenges um most importantly really making sure that we're clear consistent communicators with our parents and Community stakeholders about why we're making the change we really want to lead with a message of this is uh to enhance the educational environment to ensure focus and engagement uh and there's an important health and mental health component here too that we want to communicate uh and again we're not experiencing much push back if any from the schools that have move to more restrictive policies so that's a good sign we want to make sure that we're um offering our staff uh training uh and consistent messaging so that they're able to implement and they have policy to point to when there

019is if there is push back from families or students really want to make sure that our our parents understand that there are always ways to communicate in alternative ways with their students if there's a family issue going on if they need to get in touch they can always reach out we want to make sure that our parents know how to do that similarly we want to make sure our students know how to get in touch with their parents without using their personal advice in inappropriate uh environments we want to make sure that um we've got a good plan for Secure Storage and then lastly uh we want to work very closely with our principles and with ASD communication on a a comprehensive rollout plan it's great that we're addressing the potential for policy change now

020because it will give all of our schools the spring semester to begin a soft slow roll out they can experiment they can uh get out in front of messaging their stakeholders and communities um so that we have strong clear well supported roll out in the fall and that's really the summary of of the challenges and ways we can address them I'll just add that I talked anecdotally to a few principles um and were really supportive of the policy moving forward they felt really like supported by the policy um you know often as a principal if you make those rules independently um it's a hard place um to be as a leader um but with a board policy behind them making those decisions they felt like it was a b forward s so um so they

021appreciated the efforts I'll say I really appreciate the fact that we've had a chance I mean I I leaned on existing principles practices to help create my draft of this but it's exceedingly helpful to know that they have had a chance to review the proposed policy and um I would be interested you know to that end also hearing from Educators what does that look like in the classroom um member Bellamy shared that she was wondering if she could if we could hear from a few principles perhaps during a work session um assuming this moves out of governance on how they're effec navigating these changes she some specific schools but I would you that discretion but I think that could be a good conversation to have perhaps in January or or some other timely fashion um

022I wanted to note that um just to clarify that in the document that is the track changes document there were a couple of items that maybe were not totally flagged well yeah I had to do it it it just to clarify so again it is the use of it would be the use of personal electron devices and then also on the very under prohibited conduct uh it's a small change but I think it's meaningful one of the the items that uh we we added was that um generating um harassing threatening or inappropriate photos or videos would also be prohibited conduct and generating things didn't really exist you know a few years ago or even you know two years ago um so just there are a number of small but I think meaningful components to this

023policy um so I believe that it's there in the in I just to that the that the the draft document that was presented to principles which is available is is correct I quickly put together a track change and didn't have uh the time to have it proof read by the experts here in the room so and I appreciate that'll just be swapped out online so then it'll be correct perfect um were there other board member questions M race I I have two uh thoughts one is uh and I have not talked to many Educators about what's been going on in schools that are following this practice I think it's been pretty supportive uh but I am concerned about the impact on Educators and expectations on Educators and the consistency following a policy of this nature

024consistently across all schools all classrooms the challenges there and so i' really caution Administration in terms of how to how do you message that out to Educators what expectations you have on them playing a role in this not only in terms of following policy but in confiscation uh keep you know who's responsible for phones if they do get dropped our care all that type it raises a lot of right those issues and then alternative schools and Charter Schools are they do they have to follow this or they have can they choose their their own policy so it applies to all schools yeah and you know we did one of the one of the questions and the feedback was okay we and we heard it from Polaris right there at K12 they have students that are

025that are expected to practice all manner of this right and so what does that look like when you move from the elementary to the middle of the high school areas of Polaris and what those expectations of like and that's something that t and her team are going to have to develop you know an expect understanding and maybe that's something where students realize when I get to that area of the school in a couple years I'm going to get to use that during passing because students of that age and grade level get to those are the those are those really specific and I think one thing that administrators like about this current draft is it does give some um agency to schools to make some of those individual decisions for their community and um it's not

026so restrictive and prescriptive that there isn't some some flexibility in some areas no I'll also add particularly that our secondary um alternative programs they typically have been ahead of the curve in this in a lot of ways um for a lot of reasons due to the needs of those schools so um so this this wouldn't be necessarily A change in practice for some of those alternative programs and then my last comment or question is just on trips field trips anything off campus what what's the expectation off campus something about a little bit Yeah and just to interject we did talk about that um with with with field trips in mind because often you know kids want to take pictures and things of that nature on a field trip and and those are things that are

027built into the policy that would be allowable and actually one of the conversation one of the that came up during our our convers our most recent conversation and one idea was that if the field trip permission slip were ever revised that you could have some kind of language or a box or something how the field trip permission slip itself might dictate yes by all means you know bring bring this on you know your school trip to XYZ or no leave your device at home you don't need it at the Performing Art Center whatever so I thought that was a great solution Mr um I appreciate the comment about the charter school because I was about to jump on that because our policies apply to everybody uh and but it gets a little interesting because we've

028got classes like Estella on AI we got people using computers for different classes and different issues and they're going to have them with them for when they do that um I'm just kind of curious about how we're going to make sure that we're providing computers to every class they get with them that's not school district or but they were using their own for generating reports and and college credits to different types of events I'm just it's going to be difficult to me it seems to separate that out within the school say you can't have it in the school but you're bringing it to one class but not to another so I just to me it's a I agree with the goal but I also think the complexity here is that it is a tool that's

029used some of these or in the class and how are we going to segregate out that without identifying we have situations where leg legitimate uses to use in the class and with the school and that's going to expand more in the future obviously for the per technology standpoint so I'm just I'm curious about where we draw that line and what what we can do not to impact the classroom because it is part of the classroom so I don't think we're after computers per se um like weed laptops so um we issue Chromebooks so and if it's a like if a student is bringing their their own device because they have that option as well um and there's educational use for them like that would be part of the instructional program of that classroom some of

030our curriculum is even online at this point so um accessing canvas and things up like that is is necessary um so those are those are not areas that we're interested in managing it's the the extracurricular usage um that disrupts the instruction and so you have it in the class from Full class for one class and you got it in the school I'm trying to read the policy the way it's written sounds like that's not allowed but is going to be a natural outcome you're using right so I mean teachers are navigating it already um daily um but if there's language edits that you'd like to see member Higgins like we're happy to to make those changes to make it clear it seems like perhaps we could double back and sort of look at the the

031wording about tablets and laptops and maybe create some sort of a carve out for that if they're used in an educational right purpose in a classroom setting yeah and so maybe we can create some new language um I just know that the whole issue of AI Compu and all so big that the national employ confence focused on AI okay what are other school districts doing make still included into it I just I don't know I don't disagree with this policy a step forward but I just see it as something that needs to be coly for the types of classes information and in school that they're there for one reason kids are using their laptops for class how do what do we do with them and say okay you walk right so I think we could

032create some language that gets at that point um so it's clear in the policy language cuz we do want kids to use their Chromebooks and if they're bringing their laptops for Education we want them that what we don't want them to do is be gaining in the middle of a classroom you know that that's the intent of the policy right so just if we wanted to as a sample amendment to this you could strike tablets and Toops from conditions of use and add a sentence to the effect of personal tablets and laptops if they are used in a classroom setting maybe used to complete assigned academic work and that allows them to be brought to school for that purpose but that that allows them to be on F you know focus and on task not

033also playing you know chess online right we just don't have administrative extra staff to take them in and hold while they're doing it that's not possible then we got lockers that may or may not be lock safety issues you know from a security standpoint I just see this as difficult for some of the kids with the computers they're using because I know I've got grand kids they're bringing computers to work at home they're doing their homework on it and they're doing the homework outut and we at school they got classes that they that's how they access their information start screening that out for the entire day when in that school situation they may be chter schools with the same issues so the one the one issue I do have with the policy is that we're

034using a restrictive policy instead of teaching better practices and responsibilities right privileges come with responsibilities so just to think about that for a moment and how we might articulate that moving forward because still I think the thing we want to support especially because you got none of us are fools these kids all have workarounds they're all many who have locked phones or carrying burner phones uh or old phones that are basically Wi-Fi only and and I just want to like not P ourselves in we're giving them one toone technology they have workarounds within our own devices that we're giving them and so I just again coming back to that responsibility piece the technolog is there it's in their hands we we must also follow that path I just want to make sure that there was

035enough control still at the school in there cases where people are taking classes doing anything else that that has to be reviewed improved at a higher level you know from the principle or something like that I don't want to see it you know just ignore it level I think that's a reasonable and that can be reported to the superintendent want to keep track of it I think but I just I just know the flexibility is going to become complex with the types of classes we capable of and how we can use the the internet I just see that is being um not going to change we're not going to stop the future that's what I'm who that talking to people in encorage and other cities that have policies um a part seems to make it

036work really well and it's right on the edge between what should be in policy and what should be in an AR is that if a phone is confiscated it goes to the office and the office holds it um and I I think that's a key part that you will have some classrooms where if the teacher winds up having confiscate five or six fs and the question is do they give them back at the end of the class which means the next teacher goes through that um if we actually got to the point to say where we had an odd color envelope and the phone goes in the envelope and high school security can come around pick it up it goes to the office to a secure spot um and then the student has to go

037get it at the end of the school day uh it exercises a l of control and Mild electronic punishment um I think is more of aurr but also it unws classroom teachers from having to potentially deal with a handful of devices um and the associated risk we can say we're not responsible if anything happens the reality is that can always be challenged and that's kind of cons as well so I'm a little hesitant to write it into policy um but but I also feel like it's really important for that reason and for the fact that unless the office is proactively engaged in this teaching staff doesn't feel that supported by it if if it's a policy and we're going to let them totally take the hit on making it work uh as opposed to engaging

038the office and it's the office staff that can have those conversations with parents um I I think it make it work better if that is a key part of it can I can I speak to that for just a moment please so um you know within our buildings we have we have varying processes from school to school about how we deal with certain behaviors right so one school maybe the first tardy you know one thing happens and and it's Progressive right I think currently at many of our schools the first offense for a student having their cell phone out as a reminder from the teacher that those need to be off way today right and the second time it might be the teacher takes it and puts it on the desk and returns it at

039the end of the period and maybe that third time is when it gets turned into the office right and so giving schools local control of what those processes look like um because they may already be in place and working it really I think with an AR in place I think it's important for us to note that there should be a process and a written process and for what these procedures look like for dealing with technology but really leaving it to the building to decide what that looks like we want to make sure that families and students are clearly communicated with about what that process looks like and by the way the fourth time you might get a call from the office saying you need to come pick up your student c phone right because we've

040let you know about that um and at some schools it might be the second time but just making sure that families and students know what those expectations are ahead of time I think a AR that clearly articulates a need for that at the building level um is enough to to um to cover us so that we know that schools are doing the great things for students and managing and mitigating that risk I I am reminded of a conversation I was in Mr a position with the board member was startled on homework policy for absenteeism that we might weav students to do a lot of work even if they didn't have an excused absence and he said that's against board policy I go yeah if we can make kids learn stuff we'll do that and he

041was still bothered by it um I guess the key thing i' want is if teacher does choose to come confiscate and wants that to go to the office that that becomes a clear expectation of the office that um that no one's going to going to be told no you just hang on to it deal with it um but yeah the progressivity like you're talking about I can see a classroom teacher doing that despite whatever policy we might every day for any kind of behavior for all the right reason um but yeah if if that was in an AR that there's always the expectation phone can be sent to the office and retained there for the student to pick up and as you say after a certain number I think that's what schools are doing now

042that the parent has to come pick it up um as one principal expressed to me and I tell them it can be at their Leisure we will be happy to hold it as long as they want and that tends to win parents over to our side for a change so yeah that's my only hesitation about it I I would want at least an AR or some very yes um I wanted to maybe respond to about a comment about five minutes ago um and just share that you know this is something this is a conversation that's taking place Nationwide there was an education week um report in June uh and then it was updated again in November um about which states ban or restrict cell phones in schools and at least as of November 4th there

043are 18 states that have passed laws or enacted policies either ban or restrict students use of cell phones in schools um Statewide or recommended at local districts and act their own bands and certainly recently in Alaska um there was a resolution passed by the State Board of Education urging local school boards to formally review and consider implementing policies restricting students use of cell phones and other electronic communication devices so I feel like we're checking these boxes um during instructional time and that's really the core of this policy of revision is protecting instruction protecting and enhancing the learning that goes on in our schools um and then again the state board's resolution recommends that such policies allow designated areas and times for students to use the phones at school and again this does that for the

044littlest ones it says before or after school please and thank you and for the older students it says um use you know be a little bit more responsible and uh use it at passing time or put it in your pocket for when you know if you leave campus during open lunch uh so you can be a safe driver um so I think I think this hits a lot of important notes um for for our community and I think it has the potential to help guide other districts around the state as a whole should it be adopted get a couple comments first of all I got my phone out only because I use it for adjustment my doing it justy that um and and a couple years go I didn't mean to press um the uh

045couple years ago when I was at a National Conference School Board of conference one of the two people that created that was there and he made the comment he kept saying in 10 months it's going to accomplish what the internet 10 month 10 years to do so the changes that we see I put in state law wow but the changes we're going to see and how that's going to impact so it's going to hit us over and over and over again and so I just I just I think it's good to go with some statement now and go forward with it and we just know that there's a race who at the end of the princi we adjusted we need to and the last comment is just a surprise that the board member that uh

046president was to was not me that um one other thing I wanted to bring up um I don't think it's talked about very much at all the the filtering system that the district uses really is kind of amazing and I was teaching technology classes before and after the filter came on board has been interesting to watch it evolve over the 25 years or so that we've had it um but we're not acknowledging if a teacher does allow student to use their personal device like a phone they're bypassing that phone and it really has become um it it's an awesome fence around all of our devices that keeps kids out of a lot of bad places unless they really work at it and even then they they have a tough time being successful I think um

047and I I don't know if that would be but but one is making teachers aware uh for some of our less technologically curious staff that if they allow use of a device that uses a cellular network in a building they relinquish that vilder and and there's some liability there especially if they show things to other students or help navigate or God forbid set up their own hot spot filter I had thought about doing that makes me kind of wish I was back in school um I I I do think there needs to be some staff education about it and just more awareness um because it has gotten so unig with us that I think it's the protection we live with without even thinking about it but it's it's very real um in terms of what

048it presents day to-day basis and I don't even know what to write or put words so yes did you ask oh thank you uh so I'm gonna have to pop off in a minute but I did want to um just share a few thoughts and ask the committee to make a couple of uh considerations um you guys have done h a great job with this I love the input from the principles I love that uh we have identified High highlights high points challenges um but and that we're talking about ARS because I think we're going to have to have the ARs in place what whatever they end up being but I'm wondering if if this moves in moving this forward which I I'm for I'm not on the committee though um can we I would

049want to hear I would want it to go to meak I would want it to go to the student advis board uh I I think we have the teacher task force that's still working I would want them to take a look I just think we would be it would be stronger I mean if we go slow to go fast uh we're not going to put it in in motion I mean in in uh uh we've got time I think uh to kick off the year with the policy and do and making sure that all the pieces are in place that education piece the um I mean because this is going to change um how you know I I know some schools are already put have PL you know policies building policies in place but this

050is going going to systemically change our district especially at the secondary level so I would uh want the committee to at least consider having a period of input a more input I don't know what you want to call it um so that we do get uh we get what we're thinking out there and we invite people to give us input uh before we uh take a final vote on it so uh that that's all I had thank you any other reactions or comments I I don't know that we normally do this except through the agenda process um and that would be a place where we could make a link but uh distribute a link to the proposed policy so that there can be public discussion and feedback from committees we don't to my knowledge we

051don't have a direct pathway for requesting that say the student Advisory board or M or others but um certainly committees that anybody here meets with ask people bringing that up and and providing that take back any other comments to say it's unusual that we reach out as much as we did to the schools on this one so I appreciate that point because that's a little bit not common policy changes I I also agree with me that this is going to have some public interest concerns when they become aware of it a lot of them have their kids cell phones they you know things come up they contacts all the time and they're going to be concerned about that process yes I guess I would maybe member belly if you could clarify um would you want

052input from Sab and meak um prior to this policy exiting the governance committee and moving on to like the non-action and action cycle or for example the next meac meeting is January 8th that is sort of coming right and looking at the calendar and I assume Saad met earlier this week so they're probably not meeting again until mid January um which off the top of my head if this were to move out of committee today you know that would allow those committees opportunities to review it prior to the a board vote know in a two meeting cycle or or would you rather come back to governance in January and have these conversations again oh is she still there I don't see her actually okay she said she had off yeah all right any anybody else

053I can see advantages either way um I'm kind of neutr we we could table it here wait for feedback um I'm not sure how much feedback would come directly to this commit could be gathered by people that come or it could be moved to the board um shows as a non-action item and it could be tabled after that if we haven't had a chance for everybody to see it find feed back there s flexibility in this I don't want to open it up to phones to computers to everything else through all those schools regardless of feedback that it would be beneficial for any of for all the kids and so when we look at whether this policy goes forward whether we it based on parents that want to be a to contact kid at any

054point time what do we think best all I agree with this might make you know be important I just don't know how much flexibility we want to say okay well they want kids who by carry class and and and use con that would be a Ser yeah I can't see it soon but there might be something we haven't thought of yeah procedurally I'm not a member of the I Know M is so I think it's just human see you you're not you're an ex official but today huh but today I like a real yeah who the who's the other missing so you and me so we can split the V any way we want I I don't want to hold it I think we want if we want to we can board thing recommend we

055delay it for another period to invite the the public to provide input to make sure they're aware of it we can notify them of what's going on and give them a chance to BU feedback it just take we just this Tuesday wouldn't be the first reading we lose a first first meeting to tell everybody about it and then next two meetings go ahead and act on that would that work for you I I think that's it won't really get a lot of people's attention I think so it does interest the legitimate concern that b raised that this is and I'm just looking at the sib calendar I mean I'm I'm under no Del this should not go on the meeting agenda for next week because we're beyond that period of time but we will have

056a meeting in early January Sab meets January 14th meac meets January 8th so there's no who to be in their meetings we can send this to those committees and invite them to maybe submit responses for their their feedback and that would arrive prior to the board discussion if it were an action item perhaps a second meeting in January someone a to this from committee and to the board I'll suck any objections yes seeing and hearing and feeling no objections um this is moved to the board for consideration thank you otherwise um it is noted upcoming meetings for the governance committee on January 30th and February 13th that brings us I don't St we are J

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.