CorpusRecord 40268

Regular Meeting - Martinez Unified School Board - 1/27/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Martinez Unified School District
Date
2025-01-28
Location
Contra Costa County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
34,709 words · about 193 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e good evening I would like to call the regular meeting of the board of education for January 27th 2025 to order we have do we have any public comments related to closed session I don't see we do not okay so we will adour e e e hi we're regular we're ready to reconvene the regular meeting of the board of education we do have one um item to report out on Clos session and um we have accepted the retirement of superintendent Helen Rossy effective June 30th 2025 and now we can do the Pledge of Allegiance do you want to start us Lizzy to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation godible liy and justice for all and next is the approval of the

002agenda do we have any changes there are no changes okay um do I have a motion I'll move to approve the agenda second student rep Lizzy I all those in favor I I motion passes okay we have comments from the student representative good evening everybody at Los hunus Elementary our third graders started their Environmental Education Program with kids for the bay last week thank you kids for the bay thank you to Contra Costa fire for teaching our fifth grade students fire safety and prevention this past week Los hunas Elementary staff started the year off with our first staff lunch potluck thank you to our amazing Los hunus Elementary staff for creating such a wonderful culture on campus Los hunas Elementary student leadership elections are this week and election results will be announced Thursday Los hunus

003Elementary will celebrate our 100th day of school and Miss creso already has her outfit our third graders will visit the John Mir house for their upcoming field trip John Mir Elementary had its second family movie night on Friday they ate pizza and popcorn and enjoyed watching the movie Mitchells versus machines martinus jior High School's Orchestra and band visited John mir's fifth graders to give them an opportunity to learn about the music program at martinis jior High our Kinders learned about water flow and were given a coloring page and stress ball of the world during their time in the science room John M Elementary will SE celebrate our 100th day of school on Wednesday January 29th students are participating in after school enrichment on Tuesdays Wednesdays and Fridays these enrichment classes include robotics Mathnasium and Glee

004Club third grade recorder paloa assembly is on Friday February 7th at John sua Elementry the fifth graders visited the Lawrence Hall of s science planetarium in Berkeley to support science curriculum with Hands-On Adventures second grade has been buzzing with activity in math we are diving into the world of money learning how to count coins make change and solve real world's problems they recently wrapped up their personal narrative writing unit and now are gearing up for the non-fiction reading and writing unit this will be especially exciting as we bring the life cycle of a butterfly to life and work on animal reports fifth grade had a fun-filled musical visit from the junior high band second grade has an exciting field trip coming up we will be visiting the dean leer theater to watch Peter Pan it's

005sure to be a magical experience the missula play is coming up on February 3rd on Friday last week at Mela Park Elementary we had our monthly Spirit day students and teachers dressed as their favorite book character they had a whole host of characters in school from Harry Potter to Dogman the martinus junior high school orchestra and band dazzled our fifth graders with a small concert getting them excited and ready for music in middle school this week they have a Vigilant parent Initiative Program from the contracosta District Attorney's Office parents will learn all about Online safety for students on Thursday January 30th is the Vigilant parent initiative from 6 p.m. to 8:30 p.m. Friday January 31st are color Wars Tuesday February 11th is a PTA meeting and Friday February 14th there will be no school for

006Lincoln's birthday and on Monday February 17th there will be no school for President's Day at Martinez Junior High School our academic counselor visited the four Elementary's fifth graders last week to share important information about martinus Jor High our curricular and extracurricular programs as well as the elective choices to prepare for the registration this week congratulations to our boys eighth grade basketball team who competed and did well in the annual tournament over the weekend today all classrooms joined in across campus for an admin live where we would discussed important info around progress on imp approved tardies re review of safety expectations and kicked off our commitment to kindness with the great kindness challenge students will have a chance to complete the kindness check off list throughout the week as well as participate in home room and

007lunchtime activities to help spread kindness across our campus on Friday January 31st is an elac meeting at 8:45 in a107 on Friday January 31st there will also be a student Equity team seminar on Thursday February 6th is an 8th grade panoramic picture and on Thursday February 13th the quarter 3 prog report period ends from alhamra high school we are grateful to our students and staff who volunteered to help sort and pack donations sent to support those impacted by the LA wildfires academic counselors wrapped up one-on-one meetings on Friday the counseling and admin team continue to do the preliminary work needed to build the master schedule for next year there's a blood drive this Friday in k106 and k108 the winter ball is this Saturday in the gym the student L Equity committee committee seminar for

008students and advisers will be on February 4th Vicente and bionis had an all school assembly with the TB representative Derek Kirk on January 14th and January 21st Derek kept the students engaged and motivated to participate in the Hands-On assemblies the psychology Club recorded a new episode of their podcast where they interviewed a representative from the Contra Costa County Office of Education Program Wellness in schools program also known as Wisp Mr Harrison's computer science Discovery class will begin working with their robots bente enrolled four new students coming over from AHS the mindful life project will be visiting vicente's classrooms at Martinez adult education on Wednesday January 22 we had 10 students complete the optical assistant Apprenticeship Training Program they are all eligible to take the American Board of Opti exam in February and we look forward

009to them passing and becoming state licensed dispensing Opticians the next Diablo Valley College class that will be held at Martinez adult education is business Communications there are a few Open Spaces left class will start on February 28th look for our new brochure that should be arriving soon featuring spring and summer classes registration opens February 10th Spring quarter starts on March 10th thank you very much anything else no that's it okay thank you all right um next do we have any organizational reports do we have any comments from the PTA no okay uh staff reports superintendent Rossy good evening um let's see this may be difficult but so on January 31st 1994 I began my career here in the Martinez Unified School District as an eighth grade math teacher at the junior high tonight as you

010heard our board president report out from closed session I turned in my notice of intent to retire from the district on June 30th the last day of this school year I want everyone to know this was not an easy decision for me to make when I accepted the pos position three years ago as superintendent I agreed to do two years as it was my original plan to retire in June of 24 I'm sorry but with the state of negotiations I felt I couldn't and I chose to wait another year I'm putting in my notice now giving the board ample time to find a qualified successor who will work well with our unique Community supporting our staff and students as I look back over the last 30 plus years I applied for four of the eight

011positions I have held here after applying for for and accepting the position of principal of Martinez jior High in 2005 I was appointed as the Director of student services and secondary of support in 2013 moved to the assistant superintendent of Personnel in 2016 the assistant superintendent of sup of administrative services in 2017 and after a couple of interim superintendent St I was made the superintendent of the district in 22 I have tried my best to model a strong work ethic and make decisions that I have felt were best for students staff in the district I tried to be reflective of these decisions and when in the long run they could have been better I corrected them made amends and moved forward I also realized that there were many that did not agree with me and

012I was okay with that a well-respected teacher once said to me and I quote we may not always agree with your decisions but we always know that a lot of thought went into them and the Stu students were always at the center I think of that conversation often and it gives me the strength to move forward as I reflect on the years weeks days and hours I gave to students staff the community of this District I realize the impact both positive and negative that it's had on my family both here and on the east coast and it is now time for me to focus on them my children my many many nieces and nephews are grown and starting families of their own and I want to be part of their lives not just Aunt Helen

013who lives in California on a plane in the sky I can't even describe the feelings that come over me when I told my three grandchildren that I was retiring and the first comment believe it or not from my 14-year old grandson was does that mean you're going to actually spend more time with us and my mom and although she does have five other children she needs all of us and I want to be part of her remaining years as I did not take that time and opportunity with my dad so I thank you all [Applause] do this so I thank you all for the honor and privilege of allowing me to serve you your children and your patience while I learned alongside them you have my word that I will do everything in my power

014to help make the transition to a new superintendent as smooth as possible having the least amount of impact on our students over the next few meetings the board will be discussing an open session their plans for the hiring of a new superintendent now for the business side because I always have a business side on on February 1 the district will hold and that's Saturday will hold a special meeting from 9:00 am. to 3 pm here in the boardroom this Workshop is based on cba's four building blocks of effective governance and during the six-hour workshop the consultant will facilitate discussions among the team members to begin the process on developing an understanding the four and beginning the discussion on the options of hiring a new superintendent they will talk about the unity of purpose the roles

015and responsibilities of a board the posi positive governance team culture and supportive structures and processing or protocols for discussing um different topics like gold setting and superintendent evaluation this meeting is open to the public and the agenda will be made public as soon as Nikki and I can get it out tomorrow so thank you again thank you Helen for all your years and for being our superintendent and also giving us such long notice and we will really miss you not going anywhere yet I know I know okay public comments under government code 54 954 three members of the public have the right to address the board on any matter within the board's jurisdiction however the board may not take action on any non-agenda item individual speakers will be allowed three minutes to address the board

01620 minutes have been allocated for this portion of the agenda additional time is allowed at the end of the meeting if there was not enough time to speak during public comments uh let's see so do we have any comments on non-agenda items I don't have any comment cards so I I think we're good here okay thank you uh consent calendar are there any changes yes as a matter of fact um we have one change on uh 13.3 on the extended overnight field trip request and the change there's an new paperwork in the back on the alham high school student leadership field overnight field trip request uh the appropriate um California yearbook Academy Camp paperwork is on your desk and it's also copies in the back we accidentally put on the 20 2024 paperwork instead of

017the 2025 we kind of liked last year's um conference so we wanted to repeat it we got so excited so but we did put the right paperwork on now so thank you um I wanted to acknowledge the donations we had Los hus bin Hill PTA blackbot giving fund um CAF America torren Stratton and Martino's refining company I did want to take just a moment to mention mention the Martino refining company uh this was a field trip they did for the AP environmental Sciences class and um it wasn't going to be on the agenda I just so happened that my son's in that class and I was a chaperone um but this trip this field trip was worth $21,000 they provided buses the Black Tie buses um breakfast and lunch and they let the kids go

018back and have more lunch um and they had giveaways they had a nice bag a nice little notebook but they also had headphones um originally they thought they were going to have about 20 kids and then um the teacher said oh no it's all five classes so they had 104 kids um and also I just wanted to mention that um they also had the noral Carpenters the ibw UA Local boiler makers local and processed technology programs speak to um some of their programs their internships and their apprenticeship programs and um so for kids that maybe don't want to go on to a four-year college and it was just very informative and I know a lot of kids got a lot out of it um they did a fabulous job and so I just wanted to

019acknowledge um they're very good Community Partners and I know they sometimes don't get the recognition but they've also made other donations to PTA which we don't record um so they have buses for field trips so I just wanted to um thank Martino's refining company for that um do I have any motions to approve the consent calendar with changes I'll move to approve the consent calendar as amended second student rep I all those in favor I I I motion passes right um so I just want to give a couple of speaker guidelines I realize there may be a few speakers here this evening to speak on one or more agenda items and want to remind everyone of a few housekeeping items speaker cards and pens can be found in the back of the room on the

020credenza all speakers must fill out a card prior to stepping up to the podium speaker cards are to be placed in the basket in front of assistant superintendent Janelle aat public comments on an agenda item must be made after that specific item speakers will be provided no more than three minutes each a second speaker may not continue a first speaker's speech if there are more than seven speakers on an agenda item um I may limit each speaker to two minutes I'm not going to do that um if there's not enough time though um to exceed our minutes we we can vote to extend it um if you turned in a public comment by email that comment has already been shared with the board and entered into the minutes so it cannot be read aloud again

021during the meeting public comments on a non- agendized item should have been made earlier um let's see so our first item is the musd special education and implementation of Ida we've got Matthew Jensen and Kesha Emma dorer hello everybody it's kind of hard to follow up after superintendent Rossy shared that but um we're very sad but also happy for her so I am here today and Dr emendorfer um over there in the seats uh principal of alhamra high school um and today we will be talking about a couple of things giving a brief special education 101 which is really hard when there's a lot to do with special education and then looking specifically at some of the programs at the high school and some of the indicators that we've been reviewing as the district okay

022so so the idea is a federal education law and again it's been around since 1975 but it's been reauthorized several times actually not on here it was um reauthorized in 2004 as well um it's very complex but at the very basic core again it's federal education law um there's various categories 13 to be exact um and a child must meet one of 13 or more categories to be eligible for special education um and then within that plan which we call an IEP or individualized education program we look at Specialized academic instruction or other services that the child needs to make progress on their goals um and these IEPs are established by an IEP P team and are individualized to meet that student's needs um the idea can really be defined by the following six core

023principles we won't be focusing on all six today but just to summarize again it is a federal education law um you'll hear the term fatee or free appropriate public education meaning if a child has a disability they are entitled to an education that is appropriate to their needs at no cost to them um the IEP is the document that we create alongside the family um the least restrictive environment is a core principle of the idea that we will be focusing on today um of course parents and depending on the students age and ability levels um their input is very important and then procedural safeguards are that long list of documents that parents and legal Guardians receive at every IEP um going over their rights as parents of a child with a disability um the in

024so the Ida again it's very complex but it also has a strong intent on various asps ects um one we want to prepare all students for the future um we also look at special education and talk about it as a service rather than a place so we provide services to students with special needs we don't place them in a setting um at the core we have to look at providing access to general education curriculum and we'll talk a little bit more about that um we want to strengthen the role of and responsibility of parents and by parents we also talk about legal Guardians and um support providers um and then one of the core principles we'll be talking about today is the least restrictive environment um and then finally when we talk about eligibility again

025there's 13 categories that are defined by federal law um autism speech language impairment other health impairment to name just a few um but on top of meeting eligibility um under one of these 13 categories or more um they most must also have an educational impact so the disability must adversely impact their educational performance um and on top of that they must require specialized instruction to remediate this need so there's three prongs to eligibility when we're looking at um if a child requires an IEP and again these are the 13 qualifying disabilities um that the idea defines I'm not going to go through them today because we could go on all night but just to give you an idea of those categories um today we'll be focusing primarily on the least restrictive environment and the least

026restrictive environment is a core principle of the idea EA and it really talks about the necessity that we educate students alongside their non-disabled peers or peers without disabilities um to the greatest extent feasible and we only remove those students from the general education classroom when their needs cannot be met um in such an environment with the appropriate AIDS and services um and that's where it really comes down to um as you see on the third bullet point that the general education class is always first so we look at students with IEPs and we don't say they're specialed students right we're all guilty of using that language but in reality they are students who require special education services um and then again I included that bullet point towards the end there that we have to consider

027how we utilize current services and supports in the general education classroom it's always the first choice for students um and then here's just some examples of accommodations that we often want to see in a general education classroom or any classroom I want to preface this by saying each child is unique and has individual needs so of course this is a non-exhaustive list but here's just some examples of accommodations that I've seen personally work effectively in some of our um classrooms today it's good um and then I wanted to show this last piece because when we're looking at special education I always like to remind people not everybody is treated equally because nobody's the same right children have unique needs and the idea is that we provide them the supports they need to access their education

028and to level that playing field so you'll see on the left um everybody has the same support yet the child on the right can't see over the fence right that that child on the right needed additional support but it was able to level the playing field so they're all able to see the same game and so that's really the core I mean it's very much broken down in this image and special ed is far more complex than that um but it's just something that I like to share with families and with um all of you today on really what our purposes in special education um so to focus a little bit more on alhamra high school um we have one comp Comprehensive High School here in Martin unified um this data is likely a little

029outdated in terms of it was found in December and you know there may be additional students added to these numbers in January but at the time that uh we created this presentation um there were 187 students at alhamra high school eligible for special education um and there are various programs at the high school level um which we won't necessarily go over all today but we had um a mix of students very few students for example only receiving speech services um the majority in resource so like co-taught programs Learning Centers as well as um skills or SDC programs um I wanted to share this document here as well um on the left here you'll see the national average I will say this national average is not the reality anywhere anymore this was definitely the goal at

030the time that the idea was established was 10 to 12% of our students in the district will be eligible for special education I think um in conversing with other districts I think 14% is probably the more realistic um expectation um currently in Martinez unified we're at about 16.8% and then at alhamra high school we're um encroaching on 18% um of students at alhamra have IEPs according to December 2024 data um I wanted to also share um further data um we all all students take the S back or if they have a ibility that requires them to take an alternative assessment so um but these are all students that took the sback which is our Statewide assessment um in a pre prior meeting um Amy Espinosa our director of Educational Services actually shared data from the

031California school dashboard on performance in English language arts and math and I wanted to further break it down into student groups specifically students with disabilities um so as you can see here in the area of English language arts and I realize that writing is a little small um at the bottom there 53.9 4.94% of students in the district met or exceeded standards in ela um compared to about 177% of students with disabilities met or exceeded so about a third of our students are of the students who took the esac um they performed at about a third of a rate as the students um all students in the district um and so you'll see there's color indicators there that um our director of Educational Services Amy Espinosa reviewed um so all students performed in the yellow

032and students disability um performed in the orange subgroup and then this is math here so again as a whole District 29.2% of all students in the district met or exceeded standards for math um compared to students with IEPs or students disabilities about 11 and a half percent um of those students performed um met or exceeded standards and again you'll see it mirrors very closely to our Ela in terms of all students perform performed in the yellow um and students disabilities performed in the orange range um so I wanted to share a little bit today about the CDE guidelines um when it comes to special education so special education is a federal law but there are also a lot of State involvement um so we have the US Department of Education requires states to submit a

033state performance plan or SP there's a lot of acronyms in special ed um every six years and then to measure progress on this state performance plan each state must subit submit an annual performance review every year um and within the review there are several indicators that measure quality of our education compliance on state and federal laws and then provides areas in which we can improve um and this annual performance report is submitted to the state but also as districts or leas as we call them local education agencies we receive a report with areas in which we need either targeted targeted or intensive supports in various tiers and then they also provide focused monitoring in ways in which we can improve our programs and this is something that's tracked yearly so um one of the indicators

034there are 17 indicators one of the indicators that we're focusing on today is the indicator least restrictive environment and we're really focusing this on this indicator for uh ages five and up so this really isn't applying to preschool at this time so as you can see here the CDE looks at the data and Compares students who are in general education classrooms for 80% or more of the school day versus students that are in the general education classroom less than 40% right so the more time a student spends in a general education classroom the less restrictive that setting is for that child so the target set by the California Department of Education is that less than 60 or no greater than 62% of our students with abilities are educated in the least restrictive in or in

035um 80% or more uh of the general education setting um as a district we are at 51.3 6% so that last column there shows that we did not meet that Target meaning as a district we did not meet the target set by the California Department of Education for students who are educated 80% or more of their school day in general education below that when it looks at the L regular class meaning general education setting for less than 40% the state looks at less than 16.5% of our students disabilities are educated less than 40% so clearly the CDE favors students being educated in the general education classroom so the target is less than 16.5% and we're above that Target at 17.46% so again we did not meet the target um and this is all data that

036is provided typically in February of each school year so this is last school Year's data we have not received the school's data yet so I wanted to break it down a little bit deeper into looking at each School site so again you'll see Martinez unified up at the top um this data also breaks it down into 80% or more of the school day in general education 40 to 79% and less than 39% so it just breaks it down a little bit more deeply so as a district again we didn't meet the target as you can see at the top um we are a little bit behind compared to Contra Costa County and the entire state in terms of our percentage of students um educated in general for 80% of the more of the school day

037um and then if you look at and break down each School site we can see that alhamra high school has the lowest percentage of students um with disabilities educated 80% or more of the school day in general education classrooms um and it's you know quite substantial difference compared to the rest of the school sites in the district um and then I also wanted to preface here if you look at the regular class 40 to 79% as a district we're at 23% County 14% % at alhur work um approaching 50% of our students educated 40 to 79% of the school day um so the CDE looking at this is providing us with um guidance on how we can improve these programs to lessen the number of students that are removed from um the general education classroom

038so on top of all of this the CDE uh uh partners with uh a project called the system Improvement leads and they work with with the CDE for each indicator each Target to provide guidelines for districts so it's like a handbook that's sent to directors and they say okay look through this and here's all these high leverage practices that we recommend you as a district utilize to improve within each Target that was not met so on the next slide um there's a lot of information here but I wanted to include these are all high leverage practices that the CDE recommends that districts Implement in order to improve their programs so again as I mentioned defining special ed as a service not a place um I wanted to emphasize collaboration and co- teing between General Ed

039and special ed um looking at the harmful effects of removing a child from General Ed there's always harmful impacts when we do so um regularly examining and updating our service delivery approaches and models which is something we've been focusing on this school year um training for inclusion training for Paras and General Ed teachers setting long-term goals again a big theme of collaboration amongst teachers and parents in improving this process so really the goal here is to ensure that ensure all students have access to the general education curriculum this is a requirement that all students access grade level standards and the same curriculum as their non-disabled peers and really focusing again on that principle of least restrictive environment that is a core principle of the idea um so again the why we're trying to align the

040principles as a district with this uh federal law and the princip lease restrictive environment um supporting students in mainstream settings with ultimate goal of improving academic and social emotional and behavioral performance and then also supporting that integration meaning students of disabilities being educated along their non-disabled peers to the greatest extent possible so um as a district we've really reflected on our current courses and programs also looked at students individual individualized needs to determine exactly what we needed to do to improve um at the high school we have a variety of special education programs um for the sake of time I won't go over all of them but we have caught and learning center programs uh we have uh SDC or skills programs which in which students are taught by a special education teacher in a

041self-contained uh setting and then um and those are all across content areas um for math science uh social science formerly history as well as English um and so in the area of math um we're looking at maintaining caught well actually adding caught algebra sections so formerly we did not have a caught math section at the high school so we saw a need based on students performance in the e8th grade and decided that it was necessary to add the algebra 1 co-taught Section um and we're going to continue with our math skills sections um both algebra and various other programs uh in our SDC sections um for science we're looking at maintaining our physical science which is like chemistry or physics SDC sections um but collapsing the life skills sections which is um biology in other

042terms um but ensuring that those students are still supported alongside their non-disabled peers through um the support of peras who are supervised by uh case managers um social science and uh AKA history very similar um collapsing those skills classes and then providing Paris support to ensure they're accessing the curriculum um and then for English we're making no changes we continue to have Co taught English as well as SDC or skills English um if a child requires the Learning Center per their IEP we continue to offer that so those are just some of the changes that we're looking at shortterm and then we're also reflecting on long-term goals as recommended by the CDE um there are a lot of benefits of inclusion and a lot of research on it um I could go on and on

043about the benefits but here are just a few to name um we find that children who are included in the general education population alongside their non-disabled uh peers per per better academically um have more diverse friendships we see less disruptive behaviors and just overall better outcomes um and also I you know like to mention that the law really does want us to challenge students right just because they have a disability we aren't here to lower the set or lower the expectations and so we're really setting them to high expectations while also individualizing their needs based on their IEP goals so in terms of supporting the transition the CDE really recommends looking at how we can support families as well as um students as well as teachers and a district so for teachers and staff um

044we have a professional development opportunity coming in March on co- teaching strategies as well as a professional development for um general education science and history teachers um on how to support students with IEPs in the general education classroom um we're having conversations about the I and IEP individualized grading and how we need to look at a student IEP and how we grade them appropriately um and then we're also doing parat training um during finals week as well as at the beginning of the school year on how to support students in the general education classroom um for parents we had a public discussion on new course offerings and then we're obviously here tonight um and then keys to success again going back to those CDE guidelines we want to make sure we're collaborating with special ed

045and General Ed teachers and then continuously monitoring looking at the data to see are we seeing improvements for all students and if not what do we need to do to ensure that Improvement happens does anybody have any questions thank you thank you Matthew that was a lot information any questions um I was talking to a couple of parents over the weekend about this that are not very happy about the changes um and I I think the feeling is that they're they're just scared that their student is not going to get the support that the student needs um and I and I I want to apologize because I misspoke I think I said to somebody that this was a mandated change by the state and it's not mandated right it's recommended is that the how would

046you how would you explain that so the CDE sets guidelines and they monitor it so to say it's mandated I think is a strong word but the CD has suggested that we review this and improve our programs if we don't improve and we reach a level of intensive supports the CDE steps in and works with me um to develop a plan so I would see it as more being preventative rather than waiting until the CDE has to provide intensive supports okay thank you um I think that clarifies a lot and I'm curious what what is going to be um done to monitor this to make sure that students are receiving the supports that they need great question um so I'm constantly reviewing alongside my special education department and Kim is an amazing program specialist she's

047not here today um we're reviewing data on a regular basis we have spread sheets upon spreadsheets that I can barely keep track of um but we look at individual student performance we look at their IEPs see how we can improve programs so part of the world of our jobs as special education administrators is monitoring this um and you know the CDE recommends short-term and long-term goals on how to improve our programs and in the short term we can come up with a plan and the long term but at the end of the day it requires constant refinement to ensure that we're seeing success um obviously you know the end goals that we see in improved academic performance but we also want to see that students continue to meet their IEP goals so I think when

048we talk about Improvement we look at individual students and how they're performing based on their IEP goals and then looking as a state assessment standpoint of how are they performing based on these State benchmarks and standards that they've established sorry it turns off she's telling me my microphone's not on and do you want to put that slide up there the number 16 yeah it's it's this it's the one that has the tables with all the percentages which are the percentages of IEP students correct yes so I can go a little bit into that so yes so if you look at the top Martinez unified of student this is of students with IEPs 52.5% of them are educated 80% or more of the school day I know it can be a little confusing but essentially think

049of the general education classroom whether it be general education or co-taught counting towards general education and if they're pulled out so an SDC math or SDC biology that counts of outside of general education so the higher percentage in general education the less restrictive the environment is and so of I would let's say about half of our students with disabilities in the school district are educated 80% or more of the school day the previous slide shows the target of 62% so as a district we have we have to improve right we didn't meet the target so when I looked at each School site below that um you know you can look at alhamra John mure there's other sites that don't meet the target um Alhambra senior high or alhamra high school had the most Stark uh

050contrast if you see the 37 .7% um that's nearly almost half of what we want to see in terms of students educated um alongside their non-disabled peers 80% or more the school day um and that was definitely the data that really stuck out to me when I was analyzing this and realized that we're doing students a disservice by not um looking at how we can support them alongside their non-disabled peers and it stuck out to me too and I'm looking at the condra Costa um Contra Costa on average is at 5 % and I'm curious if you've talked to any other districts that have made this change and how that's going for them yeah so um we have what's called a contra costa special education local plan area or Contra Costa Sala again lot of

051acronyms and special ed um and they govern about I want to say 17 school districts in County Office of EDS in the Contra Costa County I'm not sure if it's 17 but quite a few um and so we have regular collaborative meetings as directors um once once a month and this has come up a lot amongst other districts because a lot of other districts fell out of compliance in terms of this area and so we worked collaboratively um I will say most other districts have already shifted to more inclusive models um we're a little behind and it's okay it's never too late to improve our programs um but there are very few districts that offer um SDC or skills classes across all content areas um I actually spoke with oura director and and others and

052we were reflect on um you know other districts and how they've taken this stance um and many have kind of Taken The Stance already um and so I was able to get feedback from them yeah so um a CO talk class is a taught a class taught by a general education teacher and a special education teacher together um and by doing so those count as percentage in general education because it's being taught in a general education classroom um and then you know Paras supported are the same um and just to kind of elaborate this SDC sections are taught solely by a special education teacher so they may not even be credentialed in the content area in which they are teaching um but they're teaching the same curriculum um just in a smaller class size does

053that mean that this change will also help with the number of teachers that we have in a good credential like properly credentialed area so I might have to defer to HR on this one but what I can say is if you have a credential in special education you can teach these courses because they only have students with IEPs um however one of the concerns that I've had is that you know if they're teaching biology and they have a special EDG credential but they don't have a biology credential we're asking to teach teacher technically by credential can teach that class because they all have IEPs but they don't have that specialized knowledge in the content in which they're teaching um and I do want to preface to that when we look at these courses because these

054students majority of them are receiving diplomas we should be using the same general education curriculum um so we can train them in that curriculum but they're not those content area experts as uh their their general education colleagues who have that [Music] credential anyone else no so thank you for all this information um I attended the parent night at alhamra as both a board member and as a parent of a child with an IEP and I have spoken with some parents since and so I I first and foremost want to say that like I live this world and I think every single person in attendance at that meeting and all of the people that we're hearing from are really coming from a place of wanting the very best for their child and being fearful that a

055change might not accommodate their child's needs and I really I hear that and I empathize with that um some other things that I've heard is that this is cost-saving measures on the part of the district um can you I'm so sorry that I did not even tell you I was going to ask this question so I'm not trying to put you on the spot but I but if you could kind of clarify that because that is definitely not what I'm hearing from this but it is something that I've heard out there absolutely so I will say when analyzing this data the cost was not my primary focus um again the CDE isn't looking at it and saying oh it's all this cost right they're looking at programs and how we support students so the intent

056was to look at students needs look at programs and see ways which we can improve um and that's where the CDE came in but by no means was this a cost-saving measure um in fact when I was discussing this with cabinet and with um everybody else that wasn't even a thought of mine it was really looking at we need to support students better okay thank you and then the other angle that I'm coming at this from is that I was a I not Special Ed I was a general ad teacher I held an English credential I taught in this district and I another concern I'm hearing from parents that I really also connect with a lot having been a general ed teacher is that their concern that the general ed teacher teachers are not going

057to have the support to really be making sure that the IEPs are being carried out appropriately what I'm not hearing and I really want to clarify I don't think anyone is saying that the General Ed teachers are not good or that they don't want to serve kids or that they're not um trying to but that they that the parents are concerned that they're just really not going to be equipped to be able to do that so can you speak a little bit to what the plan is I know that there's some plan for some professional development I also know that like things need to be continuing so um that's a big consideration for me yeah so I do want to say this is my first year of the district but I'm aware there was some

058Universal Design for Lear of learning training um that has gone around and that's very valuable I mean the core principle of udl or Universal designed for learning is that you support all students and you look at access um I'm not a udl expert um but when it comes to special education absolutely so we're looking at um professional development as you mentioned um specifically in March I was able to secure um two professional developments um through somebody from the Sacramento County of office of education who is an inclusion coordinator for their County um and she will be doing presentations to All co-taught General Ed and special ed teachers as well as to General Leed science and history teachers on how to individualize your curriculum how to support students um work on grading equitably um and really

059what's necessary to support all students in your classroom um I also recognize that this isn't something that's going to be a oneandone and that's a conversation we're having as a district of this has to be an ongoing collaboration ongoing support um our general education teachers are wonderful all of our teachers are wonderful um the reality is is all students are students and it is the general education teachers job to support all students right and I'm not saying that as a negative as you mentioned our teachers are wonderful but that's part of their training they have to be supporting all students and that's where I come in and when I've had conversations it's been around how can we ensure that they are able to meet those students needs um you know and not let leave any

060other student behind if they're in their classroom they're on roster um they deserve to receive Equitable Services um so it's really those regular ongoing conversations um and also you know reminders of like hey you know don't forget that this is your student you what's what's missing you need to talk with the IEP team um also general education teachers are part of the IEP team right they're all part of the IEP team they should be in attendance and they should be sharing their concerns the case manager should be collaborating with them um there's a lot that goes into it um but at the core of it it's that general education teachers are part of their team and should support them thank you so you guys have asked a lot of great questions some of the questions

061I wanted to ask I just wanted to clarify though um how many you said par educators are in the class as well um what is the ratio of par educator to students in the class so we don't necessarily have a ratio of par Educators to students when we're doing the master scheduling we try and and I have to admit Dr em andorfer is the expert at that but um we look at students how many are in each classroom and then do we divide our Paras up um appropriately so there isn't like a set ratio obviously we do not want all students with IEPs in one classroom um so we try and look at making sure that they're equitably distributed um because we want to set the students up for Success right we also want to

062set the general education teacher up for success and ultimately the perah up for Success um but there isn't ass set ratio you and then um one more question I forgot what it was now I can't remember okay just move on then thank you very much um so now we have public comment um on this topic let's see first one I have is I apologize if I pronounced your name incorrectly Megan benad Dondo B I'm so sorry e okay okay so hi everybody Megan Bando concerned parent so I just want to say that an IEP stands for individual education plan this blanket statement of putting all kids in SDC classes into gen ad and uh for Science and History is not an LR the lre is different for each kid and that is determined in their

063IEP meeting at my son's meeting last week I was told that this was going to happen my son would be in gened for history next year there was no discussion or data to determine if my child was ready for a gened court class no talk of support or backup plans if he has trouble this is not how an IEP meeting works the team is the team decides and not the district my son is a senior next year if he is put into gen ad econ and civics class and struggles or fails he doesn't graduate our SDC teachers work hard to make sure the curriculum is at a reading level every student can read and understand SDC teachers are trained to work with children um with learning disabilities and behavior gen Ed teachers will not have

064the time the help uh the time to help each student with an IEP along with 30 plus other kids in the class A parah is not a credential teacher and a teacher having to train a perah along with all the added work is going to risk good teachers staying here in Martinez there are major changes to the special ed education at alhamra I don't understand why are they pushing to make these changes so fast without parent support without evaluating each kid individually and without board approval I am not okay with you rolling the dice on this idea and gambling with my son's education thank you thank you next we have Amy Ross uh good evening my name is Amy Ross the parents of a sophomore at alhamra and a lot of what I had written

065I Megan I don't want to uh repeat what Megan has said um we should have coordinated better um but I do want to say um that I did homeschool my son for four years uh one year in elementary school and all three years of middle school I'm not credentialed in biology I'm not credential in history I'm not credentialed in math but I was certainly able to provide him with an excellent education um so that's just from from my experience and from my perspective um I don't know that every child needs to learn biology from someone who has studied biology um okay so that leads me to just what I really wanted to what I really have a problem with is the definition of LR and I don't know that it's being used um as as

066it was intended um and I think it it's a very broad term that can be used and I don't think it means to um pull all the SDC options to for kids and to not let them have without any other um option other than Jed I just don't see that as being um the of what L stands for so um I had a bunch of stuff written but it was a lot of what Megan said so I don't want to take up any more time I appreciate your time thank you thank you next up we have Alexis Rainey hello um please bear with me as this is my first time public speaking and I'm very scared um I will be talking for my friend and then I'll be talking for myself I Alexis Ry I

067am in 12th grade I don't think this is the right choice to make for uper coming upcoming and current students because of my personal experience I was bullied a lot as a kid because I was forced into the same environment as others forcing the kids into gent Ed classes will cause them anxiety and depression it is hard for me to go to class or even go out of bed some days because of the bully I experience I fear the kids in these classes will hurt them and you will have bigger problems my two little brothers are like my babies and I don't want them to go through the same thing I went through every day do not hurt my brothers like you hurt me um I had the same problem I was bullied and I

068didn't even want to go out either and it sucked too cuz I really wanted to be in gened classes that's what I always wanted but I knew myself well enough to know that I wouldn't have made it it was hard from my friends telling me that it was going to be hard and a lot faster than the classes that I was in it it is still hard for me to go through the classes that I have now even as an 11th grader in IEP classes with a bunch of support that I have I am still struggling and it hurts cuz I always like I said I always wanted to be in J classes to be normal I was in I have had an IP since I was in third grade basically my entire life even

069with the enough support that the school gives us and with our parents and with everybody and the counselors It's still not enough like I said I am still struggling with the classes that I have now and I have to be on top of that because if I don't I don't graduate and it's sad and it's depressing now for someone who has been in who has had an IEP for a very long time thank [Music] you thank you and next up is Jasmine long oh okay you did okay thank you anyone else have any discussion any more discussion I did have a question um if there is a um student in a CO talk class and they are not um making the grades what extra support do you have or how are you going to make

070sure that they do actually um get a passing grade if they've been successful so far so I'm a big advocate of not waiting until a child fails to have that meeting right and so often what I find is that oh semesters or quarter whatever system the high school uses um is failing so now let's have an IEP to figure out how to make it up right versus looking at it like oh this child is struggling they don't have an F yet but we see that downward trajectory so maybe we should have an IEP meeting before we see that failing grade so when it comes to a child struggling that should be the first indicator that an IEP meeting is being held um and then when we have that IEP meeting that's where we look at

071what other supports um for example sometimes it's as simple as accommodations that to be included um for example sometimes a student doesn't need to know or demonstrate Mastery on every single content standard there's hundreds of them can we focus on those essential standards the ones that are really required for a student to go from algebra to Geometry or or whatever course you're going to um and I don't see that in many IEPs and so that's something that I might recommend if I see a student struggling right what are you focusing on can we reduce some of those assignments can we shorten them um but ensuring that they are still accessing the curriculum and being challenged and you know at high academic rigor um so I think it really comes down to of course having that

072IEP meeting um but really there's so many accommodations that we can put in place that either are in place and maybe need additional support to implement them with Fidelity or simply we need to look at those accommodations and other supports and how to improve um I think a lot of times when a child fails the solution is okay let's pull them out right let's put them in a skills class versus let's support them in the environment that they deserve to be in um in that um that's what I think about that and just to clarify this is starting next year that is correct and are we looking at any kind of um more meetings to give more clarification and is the um student are we gonna have like a different criteria possibly for the IEP

073students um so like you said maybe not as much homework or a little bit more time to finish projects just curious it's it's difficult we can't just make a universal like support plan for students with IEPs because they are individualized um and I want to preface you know these are IEPs right and so when we're looking at courses that we're offering next year we're looking at individualized needs and then looking at what courses we need to keep or modify to support these students so I wouldn't say like all students with an IEP need this type of support um there's a lot of accommodations that have been researched and proven to be successful for students with example for learning disabilities um and so I would really encourage the IEP team to look those um but you

074know for example a student that struggles with projects can they work on individual assignments those are accommodations that help support the student to continue to access the joural education curriculum can we make a note just to um after it starts next year to come back to us and tell us like after a month or two how it's going and are the students overall are they doing better are they accommodate just FY I put it on the calendar yes thank you any other questions no I'm sorry no usually no sorry let me let me do it for you sort of um Matthew I don't want to give you additional work because I know that you have a lot already but um I'm not a special education expert I'm not an education expert um I hear what

075you're saying I also hear what these folks are saying and I understand that like somebody said everybody just want what's best for their student do you have some sort of plan to follow up with some of the folks that have expressed some really serious concerns about this yes so I've been communicating quite regularly with parents that reach out to me I mean I try and get back to them as soon as I can um so communicating with them but also you know encouraging them to Loop in their case manager to hold those IEP meetings um but absolutely you know I've even talked about having more parent nights and it doesn't have to be specific to alhamra but just I some events um that I've talked about with my program specialist on ways in which we

076can improve that family District communication um so that's one idea but definitely in terms of communicating regularly with your site Administration Dr emendorfer Vice principles U Miss plumber and and Mr calva but also that case manager being that first point of contact UM to make sure that they have the support that they need to be successful okay so this is what I'm going to say so correct me if I say anything wrong so if you have a question that was not answered tonight please email your case manager or call them if you don't get an answer please follow up with the principal if you don't get an answer please follow up with Matthew and if you need to then come to us to get an answer please do that I don't think you're going to

077have to come that far but if you didn't get an answer that's that's your plan to get some answers that you need okay I don't think we have an answer to that do we so sorry I don't have an answer like I said when I was making these um looking at these programs I was not looking at the cost and what that saved um and uh Mr Canon who's here virtually um you know is going to be presenting very shortly on budget cuts I don't specifically know that answer because that wasn't my priority my job here is to support students and to support you know their progress in education so that was really my focus when making these decisions um so I don't have an answer for that unfortunately well and if I could just

078add in my understanding from the meeting was part of why we don't know is because we don't know if we will need to like hire additional PA Educators for example like depending on numbers enrolled in the class so that is true of every year every I mean special ed those numbers are changing all the time so I think part of it I hear you that it could seem like it's being evaded I didn't see it that way from Matthew because I don't think we have the an so we don't know on the enrollment and so it could end up saving us money it could end up costing us money but I think that we don't know because we don't know exactly the student needs and then that will be written into their IEP specifically if

079they are having to be in a class with AA like they're guaranteed that so depending on the number of students that have that written into their IEP those numbers could fluctuate from year to year we just don't know yes and also it can be a little unique and that at the elementary level for example um we have special day class programs that although not within the IEP we try and staff them um well when we go to the high school and middle school they are dispersed throughout different courses right so it's not one teacher one day with exp peras it really is um breaking up students into sections and a per goes here and a per goes there so that's why it's not that I'm evading it I don't have the best answer until we

080get down to master scheduling how many students are in each class and therefore um how many Paras we require um but that is all part of the conversation that I have with for example Mr Canon or Miss AET our um assistant superintendent and Personnel um when we're looking at Staffing thank you okay somebody missed we have a comment card for this topic so let's see okay Amy you can go ahead and come up hi thank you very much um my name is Amy Scott slovic I think I know all of you um and I don't envy you at all for the decisions that you're going to have to make tonight because I know you all care a lot um and so this is a hard hard Choice um but I do want to share that

081I've had three children with IEPs in this District um one that ended up in a special placement at the district expense at Marcus for contracosta Board of Ed and he graduated last year thank god um and then I had I have two other kids that actively have I APS at alhamra and what I wanted to share is is that you know you're talking about the least restrictive environment but I want to share that with kids with autism or with kids with you know that get very stimulated or kids that maybe don't feel safe being able to ask a question or do something because they know they're really far behind um having that um space to be able to do that it is a place because I can tell you with kids that were in junior

082high and especially in early high school I had two kids that had horrible times with um it was looked at as like it was a behavior issue and it was kids that were hyp stimulated in classes with 35 other kids that were being taught in methods that were way over what they had learned already because of what their disabilities were so I would argue that the least restrictive environment is an environment where they can actually learn and if the environment is loud or it's busy or if a teacher has 35 kids to keep track of um that they're not going to be able to be seen when they start following through the cracks have kids that have been in resource and still gotten way behind on classes without me knowing that that was happening if

083it hadn't been for the SDC classes my son had freshman year at alhamra I don't think he would be getting ready to graduate in a year now I don't think his grades would be what they are right now and I don't think his self-esteem would be what it is right now I would be very worried about the mental health situation for him and for my other son that had to go to Marcus because of the smaller environment that he need needed and having thinking that kids can just all sit in a class with that level of stimulation go about at the same Pace with very different things doesn't show that little stool that we were looking at that was putting that kit up because it doesn't give the same kind of supports that they need

084to have I would also argue that I think it'll also be setting up the district for a lot of lawsuits I worked a lot um in the past had to go through a lot with working with Dre and the rights about idea um education I had to do a lot working with um the care parent Network who was helping support and having parents being told that you're We're Not Gonna your kid isn't going to be in an SDC class even though the IEP placed them in an SDC class just because well we don't have it and it's not doing a favor for your kid I would argue that it could be um so thank you please consider that thank you so now we're moving on to budget reduction proposals for 2025 2026 school year is

085Andy on the line good evening board can you hear me can you hear me yes we can hear you someone for un muting so I could hear you back um at the prior board meeting I presented on strategies to produce or to reduce our um deficit spending I was entitled strategies to balance the District budget which at the core um talked about a couple of different strategies either we needed to increase our Revenue we needed to decrease expenditures or we needed to do a combination of both of those things um the presentation before you tonight um should help inform the board on what potential reductions could be made for next year to make sure that we can um so that we can make sure that uh that we were able to meet our balanced budget

086so before we get too far into it I want to go over our beliefs and assumptions um this is not something that anybody in the district wants to go through um but we do have to have a process by which we look at how would we reduce either Staffing cost non- Staffing cost and so we go by these General practices here that are listed in the slide in front of you we do know that any decision we make um does affect people and it affects programs at the school um it has a a a an actual impact um and to the most degree possible we want to avoid the negative impacts on what happens in the classroom um nobody wants these um nobody wants to see things eliminated unfortunately we do have to go through

087a process process to say what programs do we need to keep through this year and that's the board's role in determining how they want to proceed um any item that's listed here is not based on um a staff member or based on their ability to to do well in a program or to implement a program and ultimately we know that if we do not make reductions we're not going to be able to meet our um fiscal um goals for the end of the year and for the next two years because we're re required to show a balanced budget um all the way until 2026-27 when we look at where these reductions are come place again we want to make sure that we minimize the impact to the classroom as much as possible knowing that there

088are times when these reductions are going to hit the classroom level we want to promote safe schools and we want to make sure that we have the appropriate supervision and Staffing so that those schools can be um safe where kids have resources to be able to make sure that they're able to learn to eat lunch and to pass through classes successfully we also want to look at budget flexibility um we always look at ways to balance our unrestricted restricted dollars to take full advantage of any dollars that we get in through the district whether they be donations um State funds local funds or federal funds and then lastly in this um the board has for the last couple of years prioritized um the maintenance of counseling services for kids because we understand that through covid

089and through other conditions it's been important for us to work with mental health professionals and provide those levels of services for our students Andy can I pause you for a second um is there any way we can get um this screen up in the lobby so that um because I know there's a ton of people and I see them all kind of crouching to see the screens uh the TV is unable to receive any of this information okay um it it doesn't have any sound or anything so we're unable to project that TV all right sorry for Interruption okay go on Andy sorry no problem um we talked quite a bit about why we're in this position um at the last board meeting and I think pretty much every time I speak on the budget

090I go through some kind of iteration of of this slide and the chief of what we're dealing with right now is declining funded Ada um so the state has gone to a process where we can choose the greater of our three-year average of average daily attendance our current year or the prior year and so when look um that this year and for the next couple of years we notice that our funded Ada is declining so next year on average we're looking at somewhere around 45 students and then in the following year 2627 we look at a reduction of 12 students and as you know we get funded per student so as we reduce these number of students um we see less Revenue to the point that um this current year we have dropped over a

091million dollars in revenue from the previous year because of the funded ad a loss we also know that um based on the governor's projected budget that he just came out with in January that our main State funding our lcff um is going to be reduced from a cola of almost 3% down to 2.4% that half percent reduction is going to cause an impact um a negative impact that is for the next couple of years we've also talked at length about one-time funds we had a lot of money coming in for specific purposes mostly restricted to support kids with learning loss with counseling service and various other things those funds continue to expire and we are getting close to the bottom of that pot and so because of that we've known that we've had to make

092um reductions in future years and now that's kind of coming true at this point um we also know that we've seen a lot of increased cost um special education is the one that's listed here um we know that there's a teacher shortage especially with our special education teachers and that requires us to seek outside contractors when we can't fill those positions internally we know that many of the programs where we have to send students out for additional Services um those costs have gone up and overall just our cost of materials and supplies because of inflation and other reasons has increased so not only are we dealing with a loss of Revenue we are also dealing with increased cost and again those are all making it so that we have to seek out um other reductions

093so to look at those we always want to start with our non-staff reductions we want to start with things that we could eliminate and reduce before we look at um people in their positions um so here you're going to see a listing of about $1.15 million of materials and supplies that we can reduce um from textbooks to kitchen equipment um sped contracts um this one is about um about contractors um we're hoping that next year that we can fill our vacant special education positions with uh internal teachers ver versus using contracted services so we're hoping to save almost $200,000 there um we are looking at our school's budget so you see a drop in $55,000 there and then some other costs between conferences fingerprinting and other contracted Services um so this is going to make

094up the Lion Share of what we're produce or projecting should be reduced for next year um as we look at our our next slide here with classified staff um we are trying to minimize again the impact on the classroom but we do understand that each people each position that's listed here has real people associated with those people um do a service for our schools and for our kids and so we don't um put this out lightly we understand the impact of it at the same time in looking at overall what our staffing is um we feel as though these are some areas in which we could potentially reduce um from our college career Specialists library media um Specialists accounting technicians and so forth through here including groundskeeper custodian uh partial office manager and some of

095our um PA professionals um to the tune of about $460,000 in our next group we look at our um certificated Staffing um in most of the time when we Show a slide like this people are wondering well what school what area what are they at in this presentation when we're starting this first round of looking at reductions we don't talk about the individual names of teachers or locations we give General descriptions based on positions so in this sense um we're looking at potential of two elementary teachers U reductions and this is due to um our overall enrollment and looking at our Staffing ratios and so we feel as though through attrition that we'd be able to reach uh a drop of two ft and elementary teachers um special education you saw that in two slides

096ago where we have um contracted staff and we're looking for savings there our teacher on special assignment that's not a full teacher those are two partials um that we'd potentially be able to reduce um secondary teacher again looking at our enrollment and class size we believe that we can reduce by one position there um psychology ologist um always in need but we do have a contractor filling a role right now and so the hope is once again is to be able to eliminate that point2 from a contracted position a0 6 counselor and an mtss counselor which um is currently unfilled so we are looking to reduce that unfilled position um and that total amount is about $655,000 as a summary and looking at this from our certificated group we're looking at about 29% of the

097total amount of potential reductions comes from that group 20% from classified and the majority of the proposed reductions would come from non- Staffing um cost and that is to the tune of almost $2.3 million so that's the the negative side of things and looking at just purely reductions um new kind of new information that we just received because we um both uh assistant superintendent uh aatt and myself went to the governor's budget in Sacramento just a few days ago and there was some hope that there could be some increased Revenue but it's still really unknown um the governor put out a budget that said these are potentials but nothing is going to be confirmed until we get closer to um the May revision time so at this point in time we can't say that additional

098funds are going to come into us but we kind of have that hope and earmarked and we'll know more in the next couple of months but if what the governor proposed were to come true um it kind of looks like what you see on the slide here um there's a potential for additional money almost a little over $3,000 per student that could be increased for each of our transitional or TK students and that would give us close to $500,000 in new and ongoing Revenue um but again it is primarily earmarked for TK and that would help to fund our change from a 24 to2 ratio or 12:1 ratio for adult to students um down to a 10:1 ratio which is what the state is requiring us to do next year there is a potential also

099for a one-time block grant um the governor is proposing about $1.8 billion for this but he is not stated um whether it was going to fully come through and if it does how that would be allocated to districts it could be completely based on enrollment it could be on Ada it could have some amount that's for UND duplicated or students who are in poverty numbers um and so again until we know that we can't count on any revenue from that um there's also um a suggestion that we should be able to get some of the money from the learning recovery emergency School block grant refunded to us um the board may remember that a couple of years ago we received a sizable Grant the state then started thinking we may have budget issues and they

100pulled back money so from our district we lost about $400,000 that we had to return back to the state now they're looking to make that whole um so if you look at all this um if all three of these were to come true we would have ongoing money of almost $500,000 we know a onetime of 400 would come back and then the onetime block grant we're just not sure of yet what we do know for sure is that without some type of action by the board to reduce either expenditures increase revenue or both um that we will have um a f problem to deal with over the next couple of years we want to maintain our standing of a positive um budget um but we know that we are dealing with the impacts of that

101declining funded a that ADA that I talked about we know that Cola is going to be lower than we expected we know that our one-time funds continue to um to go down to the point that we are going to be out of those within a year or two and we know that there's a lot of expenditures coming in especially in our special education um Department um these proposed reductions are not enough to reduce and keep us from doing deficit spending but they are sufficient that we can get through the next couple of years um looking at either potential cuts for next year or possibly looking at ways to increase Revenue again depending on how the overall state budget does um we know that there's some potential for increase which we just talked about um but

102at the same time if the board does not act and make um at least these reductions we are looking at not being able to meet our final Reserve numbers for the next three years um as I will report in March at the 2 interim so what's next um tonight is this budget presentation it's brought to you as an information item so no action will be taken um this evening um as we progress into our next meeting which should be February 10th um that's where we will bring back this information and ask the board to make um or take action on these reductions and then leading into um the final meeting in February where um assistant superintendent IAT will bring forward resolutions for certificated and classified layoffs and with that I'm open to any questions that

103the board may have thank you Andy any questions can I start off you may all right um so first of all I want to preface this with the fact that I've been asked about any budgetary concerns from students over the last weekend especially um and so I want to share what I've discussed with them for the good of the public but also please correct me if I'm wrong um first of all the school needs to cut the $2 million in spending at least and that won't necessarily that will not cover everything in the future years however it's what we need to do now in order to set us up for that we have a loss of funding from declining enrollment expiring covid funding and extensive special education contracts either for individuals or for contracts because

104we don't have those teachers in those positions um and that money has to come from somewhere so with that um I've been asked by many students what they can do to help those things specifically in regards to they don't want to lose the people who have impacted their lives so much and they believe made a significant impact and will make a significant impact on the students and so what can we do as students um and as the parents listening to this as well to generate funding or minimize costs at our school and I just wanted to start with that well I think I think the question is tough to answer from this stance um the amount of money that you see there you know for example if students wanted to do um some type of

105uh fundraising um that would require quite a bit of money to be able to save even one of those positions um you know when you look at the screen there um one of the positions might be up to $50,000 and that would be you know I think a lot asking on students to go out and fundraise for that because once you start that process it's not just a one-year fundraiser it's multiple years because that person you know is requiring that you would be able to put in that type of effort every single year to do that and that's not to say that students aren't capable of really you know amazing Ma and a lot of self-service and working through that but I think it' be really tough I think the other part of that is

106that um I think there's a point when we continue to look at programs throughout the schools and say what are those programs that are having the most um impactful um uh results for kids and working towards you know meeting goals about math and reading and how do they support with counseling and continuing to look at those and prioritize what those are um so that it might not be that we get to keep all programs but we can make sure that we're keeping the programs that have the most impact and are the most successful can I give you a couple of ideas just simple ones real simple um take care of your textbooks don't lose them there are some of them are $175 a piece uh your Chromebooks take care of them baby them just a

107fix a screen is $200 when you break one not everybody Pony's up when it's broken that's $200 or 250 for a new Chromebook maybe 300 by now um pick up your garbage instead of leaving it on the ground all those things save cost and they sound silly but it adds up um I'm serious those those types of things take care of your school um manage the equipment around the school so we're not constantly replacing it it I'm there I'm on campus I see a lot I see ch-ching ch-ching every time I walk around but but those types of things um really have a heavy cost the you know just sitting in the chair and and leaning back on the chair those chair sets with the back they're they're about 275 a piece and the kids

108do this and they snap the bars that pull them back those types of things that helps so any little thing like that could help that we don't have to replace okay that's that's just a start everybody can help with that okay simple thank you I want to thank you for that um great questions and a lot of thought to that so I appreciate that any other questions sure no I'm not I'm not so this isn't really a question but um this sucks I'm just going to say it it sucks and we had to do it last year too and it sucks and I hate this so just I just want everybody to know that nobody likes this at all um I am looking at this list and it's really hard because every single position and

109I know we can't talk about individual people but every single position is a person that had we're a small District everybody all these jobs are important jobs I'm looking at I want to know how the students are going to be affected by each one of these Cuts because that's really why I'm here and I'll just give an example like are our library Services going to be reduced because we're reducing half a library media person or is somebody else going to be doing that job instead the College and Career specialist I have a really big problem with because I see the services that that person is providing to our students and I think it's worth much more than $23,000 and so I would really like us to see if we can find somewhere else somewhere else

110where that $23,000 is there's got to be something else for $23,000 that isn't having as as big an impact on our students as that position so I'm just going to leave it there I know it's tough I know that a lot of thought went into this and that nobody wanted to put anything on this list we're doing it because we have to do it and you know the other thing I want to say is I see the online discussions that happen and I see the discussions about salaries and I really think some of that is misplaced frustration and I get get it it's frustration because nobody wants to see any of this cut I don't want to see it cut um but you have to look at even though we're a small District we have

111to keep and retain employees we talk about that a lot right when it's negotiation time that we want to pay our employees so that they stay here because it costs more to get new people in and train them than it does to keep the good people we have and that goes with administrators too so when you're talking about these big numbers that you think are really big you have to consider who else are we going to get that's going to do that job that's qualified to do that job and why would they stay here and not go to a different District if somebody else is going to pay them a lot more so I just want people to keep those types of things in mind because none of these decisions are easy and I I'll

112leave it at that for now Courtney I really appreciate that because I've I've seen that also and I think you know we are talking about numbers here but we are talking about people and I think from you know every single position in our district does impact kids and it is important we do have that discussion about attract and retain and so that's at every level um so I have a couple of thoughts first I want to say we did receive a lot of emails at least I know I did but I think they were to all of us um about our College and Career Specialists and so I want to thank people who took the time to do that most specifically students who took the time to do that because I really love to see

113um kids engaged in our process and so thank you for for taking the time and for letting us know what's really important to you um and so I had I do have a few questions so along those lines I know last year for example our library media Specialists were on on these cuts and then they got backfilled through um a Martinez Education Foundation um contribution donation so along those lines are there any other like grant opportunities or any other funding opportunities where we could backfill some of these positions that we know of or that we could seek out some of these positions are positions that were cut last year and were backfilled with onetime money and have to go back on the list again because they were onetime money filled and we can never assume

114that we're going to get onetime money again so every year and the employees were told when we sometime between this this time last year and the time we got the funding we have to put you up every year until we can District fund you because we have to go out and find funding otherwise we're going to if we don't lay you off and we don't find the funding we're going to be back in the hole again for that position so there are I can see on here three or four of these positions that were backf funded from going out and finding funding so we're still working on it we have until probably miday there are retirements that will come in there are people that will resign or move away and those will um automatically shift

115people around and so on and so forth there's rarely a year where we don't start with a big year in a big list in budget reductions that doesn't end up with maybe one or two we find a way through just normal um patrici to to get it done okay so so to follow up with that then is there a way or what would kind of be our process as a board to say okay here's this list here are these Cuts we know we have to give notice as you said even if some of these positions come back what would be sort of the process for us as a board to say here's what we would most prioritize in case we do have additional funding in case some of these things that Andy discussed come back

116in May kind of what is our like number like sort of an order of priorities is that something that we can do or discuss Andy we went through this proc are you still there andy yes I'm still here okay we went through this process last year that's where you prioritized the mental health okay so same type of process maybe um talk about it now so we know because it's going to come back for a vote do you want to do that now care it well I have one more question I don't know if anyone else has any but then I think I mean I would be I would be happy with that so my last one is really a clarifying question I I think I understand it but I want to make sure especially because

117we do have so many students sorry so many parents and families here and students um who were here specifically for the special ed presentation so I want to confirm we're not talking about here reducing needed special education teachers we're talking about we're hoping to fill these through our like mea salary schedule these would be employees of the district which is preferable I think to everyone they're part of our labor group um versus having to go out because of pretty severe teacher shortages specifically in special ed and get contracted teachers which cost a lot more am I understanding that correctly um so it's both actually um what we do and this is the same thing we do with general education is we look at our our student numbers for each of the schools and then we

118go through a process as cabinet to review what those Staffing levels should be based on our contractual obligations so what we do is when we look at that that decision is independent upon any programmatic changes um that that Matthew has put forward you tonight is we look at the number of students in each of those programs by grade level by school and then we we determine overall Staffing and so through that process we're looking at being able to reduce um you know a few different positions of those are also going to be the special education positions that you see before you now those special education positions right now are covered by contractors so they wouldn't necessarily be our staff because again we have the shortage that you described um but there is a reduction overall

119in special education not just filling un or vacant roles at the time okay thank you so um I know last year we had a meeting where we talked about what we want to cut and stuff but um I'm looking at the clock and I know we've got a lot of people here and I believe on this topic we have 17 speakers um so if possible I would like to defer that um at the rate we're going we're going to be here till 11: um if we have more discussion uh so I don't know what you guys think about that but to to when what's that just to to next board meeting so we can right but we can still talk about it about what we what's most important right we have to vote at the

120next according to Andy's schedule Andy correct me if I'm wrong at the next board meeting on the 10th I see that we're taking action it's not coming back for review we're taking action on the 10th we cannot take AC setion on the 24th that's correct we we're prioritizing that because any type of messaging that needs to go out we need enough time to be able to communicate that to employees and so this timeline is tight um but also doable and so yes the the idea is that we would come back and you could take action next week at the same time based on board discussion we can look at um adjustments if we need to um or we can also look at I think what you described as prioritizing of those roles that if we

121were able to get additional Revenue um like I suggested in the presentation that we would prioritize certain positions over others that's something the board can give us Direction on okay thank you Andy so um I guess we will have a conversation then we um hopefully not go too long but um so I appreciate all the comments everyone's made and I agree with everyone and this is a really hard decision um I think the good news is we generally get onetime funding or more money at some point so we don't have to do the reductions but I do think we need to kind of discuss it and yes we all did get um a number of emails about the College and Career specialist so um I'll just start with saying that the College and Career I

122was just gonna say do why would it be helpful if we listen to the public comments and then we can come back and discuss I don't know what how you want to handle it but because people might you know that might sure so I'm going to um that's fine so for this particular um topic we have 17 um public comments so it we do have a policy that if there are more than seven speakers on agenda item the president May limit each speaker to two minutes in order to hear all the speakers um right so try not to repeat something that someone said but um we'll go ahead and limit you guys to two minutes on this um I'm I was trying to be mindful and have everyone do three minutes but again it's um

123it's already 8:15 so um we're going to start with natia Goodman and then after her is Megan noala and I apologize if I'm butchering your names all right so hi uh again I think this is an emotional topic budget cuts definitely appreciate everybody's time I'm Natasha I'm a parent of two alhamra high school students maybe that's better um so again here talking about College and Career specialist again um this position really offers support for students and families that feel college or trade school I'm shouting out to to to many future careers that are unaffordable by offering resources options that really make higher education attainable for all students that's really important this position offers support for DVC enrollment my daughter participates in this and assists many seniors pursuing the JC route which my understanding is about

12450% of the high school students or more um this position helps maintain compliance with financial aid packets for seniors um I see a lot of emails going out on that my my kids are younger um my children and others benefit firsthand from seminars offered by speakers that talk about their career Journeys um and the the college and CIS specialist takes the lead on this this really has a pos positive impact on Future Leaders and our community by empowering um these kids out here with knowledge that's what this is all about um as a participant in the equity review Forum at the high school I know that one of the things that we're going to be looking at in the future is trying to align standards with the a through G requirements and honestly um if

125we're going to eliminate or partially eliminate hours that a vital resource that we have out there it is really moving Us in the wrong direction right we're really trying to um focus on these requirements for all students including socioeconomically disadvantaged and those with learning disabilities it's about having avenues for everybody so um again focusing on future opportunities I would say that ultimately reducing these hours for the College and Career specialist is a detriment and disservice to our students uh most importantly and our Community where these students will go out to and I respectfully ask that you maintain this position [Applause] full-time hi I'm Megan nicolella um there are some data and some questions that I'd like everybody to consider after reviewing this presentation the second Focus States safety but our current elementary schools are experiencing

126a 1 to 150 adult to student ratio at the lunch periods so I'm not sure how safety can be a focus if we're already at these unsafe numbers the fourth Focus States counseling meanwhile students are waiting minimally a week for services which also doesn't take into account the events that are occuring over the week while the school Waits For The Counselor to return back to campus how are these valued areas if we're already at these current conditions the increasing sped costs are continually referenced if the district doesn't seem to appear to be making timely shifts towards intervention or literacy programs that are based in the science of reading a system that has shown dramatic shifts in student achievements and progress across a variety of ability levels um having these foundations in elementary years would also

127provide a stronger Foundation heading into the secondary levels support students to reach their goals and exit from IEP supports or wherever they're going in their uh future years when will the board board and extending teams start to problem solve around these budget reductions with a greater variety of sourcing and grants and other community funding to balance these drops of ever shifting reductions how else can we come together to make solutions to keep more staff members on campus consistently so engaged learning teaching and supportive environments can happen thank you thank you next we have Cecilia Kerr and after her we have Jerry Tom Totino sorry dream hi everyone so I have a request that's both vital and Urgent for the students and families of alhamra high school and indeed for the broader Community we serve that

128request is simple yet incredibly significant please keep Janice Collins at her current 40-hour work week next year Janice Collins is not just a college and career counselor she is a Cornerstone of the support network at alhamra high school offering guidance Direction and expertise that have helped countless students plan and prepare for their Futures I want to take a few moments to paint a picture of the profound impact Janice has had on our school Community First consider the sheer breadth of the tasks Janice takes on each and every day her work with college applications which often involves ingate multi-step processes that can take up to two weeks to compl complete is vital for students navigating one of the most stressful times of their lives she doesn't simply help students fill out forms she helps them shape

129their Futures brainstorming ideas for personal essays refining application materials and offering strategic advice on how to present themselves in the best light possible but Janice's role doesn't stop there she's also instrumental in helping students select High School courses that align with their career interests she helps them research career Pathways provides them with interest inventory and assists in mapping out the steps to achieve their goals she ensures that every student has a clear and actionable path forward whether they want to attend college enter their Workforce or pursue a technical career Janice serves as the alhamra high school liaison for dablo Valley College and Los Madonna's College playing a critical role in guiding students through the dual enrollment process this is a multi-month often complex process that requires careful attention to detail and individualized support she helped

130students access college level courses providing them with invaluable opportunities to get ahead academically in addition to this Janice creates and organizes numerous workshops for both students and parents where she shares Vital Information on college applications financial aids scholarships and career exploration she creates a monthly newsletter filled with resources I'm sorry your time's up okay well please keep ganas thanks for your time and consideration [Applause] hi my name is Jerry Toman I'm a mother of a junior at alhur high school and a seventh grader at mjhs I wanted to speak on the proposal to cut back the paid time of Janice Collins the college and career counselor at alhamra high school I believe the proposed decision would put the students at alhamra at a severe disadvantage and have devastating consequences to not only the students who

131are currently attending alhamra but also the incoming high school students in the years to come I repeat all of the things that Miss Janice does because uh the woman before me already shared that but um she spends an innumerable amount of hours most of which currently are not paid uh she volunteers her time outside of work um she's the one person who truly bridges that gap for students between high school and college or vocational and trade schools if that's what they want to do her unique set of skills her Mastery of the college application process and knowledge of financial resources make her an indispensable part of alhamra High School staff as I have already said she already volunteers so much of her time many times cutting into a time with her own family to help

132students in need not because she has to but because she loves each and every student like they are her own children in light of this it would be unconscionable to reduce her hours and pay given the amount of time she already volunteers without compensation helping students who legitimately need her I respectfully request that you reconsider the proposal to cut her hour hours which would cause irreparable handicap to the students of alhamra who desperately depend on her thank [Applause] you the next two speakers Dennis Franco and then Katherine Franco good evening my name is Dennis Franco um I'm an administrator at Los Banos College although I'm here talking as a parent um I've known Janice for a while now she's amazing in what she does uh my daughter loves working with her and she does great

133work for the colleges as well she helps our students their students see the programs at our colleges that they wouldn't otherwise see that fit their values and interests and get them in the direction that they need need to go we know as College uh administrators that when students come to us with a career already picked they're much more likely to be successful in their college journey and as we as Educators we want to make sure that students get jobs and then that gives back on the tax burden that we carry as citizens of this County um and helps us be more successful in that when I think about a loss of of a 25% FTE as an administrator what I think about is a job that's going to be hard to fill over and over

134and over again recruiting people because it's a part-time job you're going to lose people and it's going to cost several thousand dollars every time you go to hire and then refill and onboard that individual so while it might look good on paper to cut $22,000 um it's not going to be good longterm with the costs that are hidden um in that kind of proposal um Miss Janice is great to work with I'd hate to see her go um and I know none of us can take a 25% pay cut in this environment so I'll I'll yield the rest of my time thank you very much hello um I'm here speaking on behalf of Miss Collins as well um I wrote up just a few words uh my name is Katherine Franco and I am here

135as a concerned parent of a sophomore at AHS a seventh at mjhs I'm a board member on MEF and I'm an administrator at dabla Valley College and I've worked there for 20 years I'm speaking tonight to urge you to reconsider the proposed 25% cut I can't imagine how that's going to benefit our district in any way to lose this amazing coordinator Miss Collins um I understand the district is facing significant financial challenges and difficult decisions must be made however reducing Miss Collins role is not the solution she has gone above and beyond for alhamra students creating meaningful opportunities and Partnerships that directly benefit their Futures her leadership has expanded dual enrollment programs organized impactful college tours and workshops that I've been a part of and seen her on my campus um she's fostered relationships with

136local colleges including DBC my campus losis madonis college and countless others uh she's strengthened the connection between high school and the colleges and Rel relationship building is one of the primary keys to these types of roles you can't get stuff done if you don't know people and you don't have the passion behind it um from both a personal and professional perspective I've witnessed the positive and transformation transformative impact of Miss Collins work um in my two decades at DBC we have never had such a strong partnership with alhamra as we have over the last few years thanks to her efforts she creates a welcoming and safe environment for all students while all also taking the time to educate parents about the importance of higher education for every child so many parents have no idea how

137to support their students in transitioning out of high school and Miss Collins is an invaluable resource for these parents she's more than just a coordinator she is an advocate she's a relationship Builder and an innovator um I understand that you're under a lot of pressure but please think again over reducing this role thank you so much for all you're doing I appreciate it so I see the theme Here is don't cut um College and Career specialist and I think that's I know it's on my list as well so um you don't have to repeat things that we've already heard but if you want to just say you know yes I agree with that that's great um but if you want to talk that's fine next up we have Paula mccauly and then reading classes on

138um loopy MO you'll yield okay thank you very much um lupy [Applause] ma hello good evening members of the board my name is Luffy Ma and I am a sophomore at alhamra high school last Saturday when I heard that Miss Collins was among the proposed budget cuts I knew neither I nor or any of my classmates would just stand around and let that happen our College and Career specialist Miss Collins is crucial to academic success at alhamra we are all incredibly grateful for the help she does with college applications course selections programs with DVC newsletters personalized academic advice and career exploration opportunities not to mention the diverse and vibrant culture she has fostered without her full-time presence on campus we will lack the vital support that we have come to rely on within just 12

139hours on Saturday our petition amassed well over 200 signatures from alhamra freshman sophomores juniors seniors and alumni from the class of 2024 many of those students are with me today Additionally you will find in the email over half a dozen personal emails detailing the transformative impact Miss Collins had on their academic Journeys the purpose of our school system is not simply to hand out High School diplomas we are here to be prepared for the future we want to be leaders I strongly urge the board to reconsider the proposal to cut Miss Collins on behalf of alhamra students thank you if you're not on a debate team you should be on one that was very impressive thank you okay next up we have Isabelle and then Olivia and I'm bore bow good evening as you have

140already heard a lot of us are coming to our support for Miss Collins I'm coming here as a student as well as someone who is involved within the school committee and on many committees apologize I repeated myself with her newsletters DVC kick Start programs cash for college lunch and learn one-on-one meetings her room has not only become a place of learning about our potential interests colleges and many Pathways that we can all take it has become a safe haven for all of us we all know and including staff members have learned that her room is where anyone is welcome she will support any student whether whether the future career choices that they may choose my sophomore and junior year I met with her to make sure that I was require fulfilling and meeting the requirements

141for my a through G systems my a through G course requirements and taking the correct classes for the major despite my major interest might be have been changed I didn't have to go to the other counselors because I knew that she would direct me in the correct in the correct path please reconsider this we as committees strive for our academic achievement as a school we do not want that achievement to be suffered thank [Applause] you did we have Olivia Bower also bore sorry here um I'm not going to go through the long thing that I um wrote up but I also want add in addition to what everybody else said um that you have to keep in mind the school ratings and College and Career Readiness is a rating and if that goes down your

142entire rating goes down that doesn't just affect the kids which it will it affects the entire Community the people who move into the community are looking at the school re ratings when I moved to the Bay area for a job I looked at all the towns that I could actually possibly kind of a little bit afford to live in found the school districts that had the highest rating and in my my uh budget level this one was at least decent enough that I would feel somewhat good to let my kid go here and if that rating goes down any further it's going to affect the community they just built 50 new houses over in our neighborhood Hood those houses are going to have families in them that are going to be sending their kids to

143this District or not if they see the rating is bad so I urge you to cons reconsider cutting this particular um budget line because she is she's been a huge help to my daughter as you heard and it's been a help to all the other kids so thank you [Applause] okay we have Dylan forar and after that we have oh my gosh twon good evening um I just wanted to say that as a sophomore applying for colleges is a very important thing to do and it affects your future indefinitely and if we don't have a college and career counselor then what how are we supposed to know what to do I mean we are students but we haven't been taught how do you apply for a college successfully how do you choose the classes that

144that college is going to look at and go we want that person because we all have goals but if we don't have the adequate um people to achieve them then we're going to struggle to achieve those goals and we go to school with the end goal of a college we want to go to and a degree that we want and a career that we're going to enjoy and if we're limited to only what we can get from an academic counselor and don't get me wrong our academic counselors are wonderful but a college and career counselor is there to help us achieve those goals and in the long run achieve like a life that we want to live and that's very important to me as a student and I I'm only assuming it's important to my

145fellow students so thank you [Applause] hey we have miles Wallin and then Avalon Dwight hi I'm so sorry when I first spoke to Mrs Collins I mentioned to her that I wanted to major in mechanical engineering ever since then she's emailed me countless times with these new programs and opportunities that she found that she made her think of me when I went to her about an exchange program that would send me to China over the summer she was so excited for me and she offered to teach me Mandarin every day during lunch that is the kind of person Mrs Collins is she is someone who takes time out of her day to help you no matter how busy she is who takes pride in your accomplishments and celebrates them with you and who treats you

146with this love and respect that is increasingly hard to find it's been incredibly hard to be a student from cutting AP classes to applying to college there's so many things you know you can't rely on in the time I needed it most she has been my constant and unwavering pillar of support whenever I had a question or freaked out about my future I always knew I would be all right because I had her this isn't unique to me either every student you've seen here and you will see later will say the same exact thing Mrs Collins has helped us in a way no one else could you reduce her hours and you reduce the number of students who can benefit from that guidance if you had known anything about her and what she does before

147you cut her hours you would have known that she is an integral part of Alhambra and is directly responsible for our students successes thank [Applause] you good evening my name is miles wallenstein one of many here to speak on behalf of Miss Collins Miss Collins has provided me and thousands of other students over years of service with invaluable College advice just speaking from personal experience she's helped me from with everything from financial information college application data to just being there when I needed it most I remember I once mentioned how I was unsure of my DVC grades and how would I was nervous as to how they would affect my UC application instead of just brushing my concerns off like many others would she took time out of her day to give me a realistic

148to to give me realistic yet hopeful advice that is the kind of person and adviser that Miss Collins is one who cares about every person who walks through her door in no small words Miss Collins has been a pivotal resource in our community and one that our school as a whole would be harmed without I am just one of many others who will testify to this you have and will hear about how Miss Collins has provided a safe welcoming and engaging environment even outside of her duties as a College and Career ADV counselor by cutting her hours you are depriving us the student body of a friend an adviser and a critical resource in our journey towards higher education thank [Applause] you good evening everyone thank you all for taking the time to listen to

149so many of us here today my name is Avalon Dwight I'm a senior at alhamra high school and addition Al I preside as Alhambra student body president so many of you here are parents like you all my parents want the very best for me they want to be able to provide me with opportunities that they weren't even aware existed and while I'm endlessly grateful for their help and support I'll be honest with you all the college admissions game has evolved significantly in the last 20 to 30 years in 1994 UCLA accepted 50 1% of their applicants by 2024 that number has dropped to just 9% this brand new landscape of personal Insight questions incredibly competitive applications and outrageously Rising GPA is practically impossible to Traverse alone and I would know as of this month myself

150and many other members of the class of 2025 have finished and submitted our college applications with the help of Janice qu Collins Miss Collins has been an invaluable source of help to the students of alhamra high school within the first two months of the 2425 school year Miss Collins had over 290 visits from students and their families concerning their children's future in order to gain admission to some of the most prestigious schools some families employ private college Consultants to help students with their essays their college lists and more these Consultants can cost on average upwards of $200 an hour to dep to decrease Miss Collins and other staff members hours at alhamra is to deprive 1,00 students the opportunity to reach the same Heights as their more affluent peers there's no doubt in my mind

151that everyone in this room wants the best for our children in our community but cutting Miss Collins and others hours takes away the opportunities to achieve higher education and that alone is irreplaceable thank you we're down to our last three we've got Lillian Matt and Amy hello my name is loline H menz and I am a sophomore at our hambur high school the first time I met with Miss Collins was of my freshman year at the very beginning for dual enrollment and no matter what she has been helping me consistently throughout the years even though there was only one of her and she has thousands of students to talk to from grades nine to 12 please be considerate that we only have two counselors and the other one is for M mental health other than

152that we have two counselors for academics and they do do not specialize in what miss Colin specializes in so therefore we need [Applause] [Music] whole Matt's next uh hello hello members of the school board I'm Matthew Blackford I'm a sophomore at alham high school and I'm also going to talk about Miss Collins and why we should not cut her hours Miss Collins is an amazing teacher at our school who has helped I and many other students with their Futures Miss Collins fought for me to get into a summer class that I was told I would not be able to get into she communicated with the professor of the class and the principal of Diablo Valley College to help me G she's helped me plan my school schedule and led me down a path to help

153me succeed she has always welcomed me into her room with her easy to access scheduling and her walk-in appointments she's also helped my sister in 8th grade apply for taking geometry over the summer which without her help I don't think we could have done if I ever have any questions and I do have a lot of questions she always helps me find the answer and she always helps me learn like about she always helps me decide what my future could be and how to better get there recently she had a program called lunch and learn where she brought in a pharmacist from one of the local pharmacies and I realized say that that is one of the jobs that I would greatly want to do after the speaker came in I talked to her about

154what classes I should take at the high school what I should major in and what I should minor in at schools and which schools would be good for me to go to to get to where I want to be without Miss Collins I would not be the student I am today and she has helped me with all of my classes she's helped me all of my grades have gone up since I've started talking to her thank you for your [Applause] time hi I'm still Amy Scott svik so um I just wanted to say first off 100% to what everyone just said about um M Collins my my two Juniors wanted to be here tonight but they're off working on their Eagle stuff because you know they want to get into good school so anyway but

155um I just want to say you know obviously what she does here is so important and no one can follow what all these kids have said I mean they clearly love you and you make a big impact um the other thing I want to speak for is also about the counseling um the counseling hours I think it's so important right now particularly when you're looking at what you're going to be doing with getting rid of some sdc's which I hope you don't but um if you do um that's going to be super important for the kids that are going to need more support I'm also just going to put it out there that in this world right now there are a lot of kids that are really scared they're really really scared about the things

156that are happening out here in our world in the last particularly the last few weeks and my kids are coming home talking about being worried about their friends being worried worried about immigration issues we have a large immigrant population here we have kids that are having um feeling at risk being lgbtq um and it's super important that we have these counselors to be there so that these kids have the support that they need they can't all go in I'm an RN they can't all come in and get care people are terrified even though they're they're supposed to be protected right now to be able to come in and do that people are scared to do that so we need to have these counselors here working with these kids helping them problem solve helping with the

157issues that have been around bullying for a lot of years helping kids that are um going through a lot of transitions so please I hope that you would hold on to both the hours for the career um in college and as as well for um the counseling hours that are on the Block thank [Applause] you okay thank you all um for your wonderful uh presentations okay so um I for one I was going to start off by saying that um I think we should keep the career the College and Career specialist [Music] um I think we're all going to be in agreement with that at this point uh so other thoughts let's see what else we have on here um so the only one that really kind of jumps out to at me um is

158the custodian and I only say that because um is this a custodian that is cleaning the bathrooms I mean I want to make sure that you know kids aren't getting sick and that we're still you know having the cafeteria everything cleaned well I mean what kind of what custodian are you looking at is it just um a second custodian is it um Andy are you still on yeah I'm still here so this is the custodian that was hired with car's money the extra daytime the second daytime custodian that we've kept um since uh cares act correct we actually have a a floating custodial position that has been able yeah that's been able to help us when we've had issues with um you know just not being able to keep enough staff or vacation or for

159um sickness illness especially through the winter time so this position is the floating position that was brought on I believe last year they primarily work dayshift at alhamra correct that's their that's their post yes that's correct but I also want to be careful in these conversations that although there may only be one person in the positions that are described here we want to be very careful about not talking about individual people we're not we're just I just wanted the position it's the position of the daytime custodian who works as a [Music] floater thank you [Music] um now and also had a question about the elementary teachers um with I thought we're doing we're hiring more for the TK um this would be because we have less students enrolled or is this through attrition or how

160is that elementary school teacher teachers factored in Andy I'm happy to answer this um Andy referenced um during his presentation that at cabinet we do a thorough in depth St Staffing analysis based on enrollment so based on our projected Elementary out enrollment outside of TK so just K through five we're projecting that we will be able to reduce um to FTE and we anticipate that those um reductions will be addressed through attrition perfect thank you thoughts yeah that um I thought of two more things that folks can do to help us with this um California has this really silly funding model the Ada funding at Ada is average daily attendance so it's not only the number of students enrolled which as you saw in the presentation has gone down but it's also students in attendance

161so if you don't come to school the school doesn't get money for you even though they have to have a teacher for you in a classroom and books and all of the things so um Lizzie if you can tell your friends if you are not sick if you're sick stay home if you are not sick please come to school that really it sounds silly but it really does help um the other thing is is that um write to our our state senators and our state assembly people and tell them they need to come up with a better way to do this I do it I just talked to one of them over the weekend about it um so if if folks are willing and that can go to the parents and the teachers as well

162if you're willing to do that we've been talking to them for I know Annie and I several years about this and they it's very complicated how California funds the schools and I think that they don't really understand why it's a problem um so if I can help with that if anybody wants to contact me about who to contact and what to say please do um okay back to the list yeah I mean I think we have to find something else to do without cutting the College and Career hours um I also have concerns about cutting the counselor hours because that's something is is that a mental health counselor that's on our list there's two right mtss and M and counselor the mtss counseling position is the one that was at the junior high school that

163we did not fill fact we had someone in the position but um it did not work out so that position has already been um collapsed during this year but we put it out there because we want to talk about the position itself being eliminated okay and then what about the0 6 one what what does that look like who who is that going to affect affect secondary we're not getting into specifics because people have not been noticed okay I know I know but the thing is we only have so many in the district we're probably going to identify it so if it's not it's not an mpss it's an academic okay um yeah I mean we we've said we said this last year that our mental health is one of our priorities so I just want

164to make sure that's still reflected in this I don't think that's changed um at least it hasn't for me no it hasn't it's still on the list but like we said if we don't cut this we have to find something else to cut right right I understand and you know that's that's a really hard part of this because everybody gets up and says don't cut this but we have to cut something and I know nobody wants to tell us what to cut but it would help if you did um it's because yeah this is this is really tough but I I'm I I really feel like we need to find some other way to something else for 23,000 instead of the College and Career hours so the direction I'm hearing is don't cut the mtss

165and don't cut the college in career and don't cut the custodian is that correct yeah I agree with that yeah yes yes I agree with that but the when Andy comes back because it's got to be made up elsewhere can we have a couple of options or it comes back for a vote next time okay so I guess whatever we replace it with is going to go up for a vote so Andy do we have other options that were next on the list that we just didn't use um we did create a list of other potentials so we can go back and look at what those are and bring that back to the board um it would be helpful if the board not that you gave us individual you know positions and things um but

166maybe I think I've heard so far that you want to prioritize what superintendent Rossy talked about so that'll help us I guess my reluctance here is that those costs if you look at the stal cost of over $100,000 you look at the cost of the college career about $26,000 um and then the mental health which could be up to $160,000 it's not just a one-year savings it's going to be a two-year impact to the budget right because those cuts are for 2526 and those cuts go into effect for 2627 and on down the line so anything you take off the list consider at least twice that to the bottom line of what the budget is so we can go back and look at different things but it it is going to be difficult to do

167that the other option is if those were taken off we can always look at additional Cuts but that moves things down the line to 2627 so whatever Cuts you don't make for the 25 26 year are going to be pushed out for 26 27 and I want to remind everyone that the onetime funds that we did get was intended for Staffing but it was always intended that that Staffing would come through for a short amount of time and then we would have to lay that off our internal hope in the district is that we've been able to do that slowly over time mostly through attrition but that's not always going to be the case so I I guess my short is we can take those off the list but we are going to have to

168make those cuts eventually down the road unless we see an increase in state revenues and let's let's take a look at this in cabinet in the morning at timeline okay and and you can phone in depending on your flight time um we'll take a look at it and I will look at it tomorrow morning okay and we'll uh we'll talk about it when you get back tomorrow and I just I I'm sorry to interrupt you Logan I know I just want to finish my thought um I I'm my priority is the College and Career specialist I I I understand what you're saying about custodial but at the same time that's not somebody that directly is going to affect the students the way that does um I mean like none I you know none of these

169cuts are ideal we don't want to make any Cuts but that's just where I'm at um Can Can you and not doesn't have to be right now because I know you want to talk to but is there is there any um I know last year we had to we were able to take some of the cuts off the tables because the parcel tax passed and just to be clear none of these positions can be funded through the parcel tax is that right uh the partial tax um we remember that we passed the same partial tax we had before and wages and costs have gone up so the current partial tax um covers every position that we had before and actually we've had to cut back on some of the other things like stiens and materials

170and supplies and move them into other sources to be able to pay those expenses so in short the partiel tax does not have enough additional funds to be able to cover any of the positions on this list I was just going to be clear about um that we're if we're going to not make those cuts of those positions that we would replace them with something else and not just push them back to the following years we're going to figure a plan tomorrow morning and then you'll hear from me all right okay so just to clarify too I agree that the College and Career specialist is if you could only pick one item on here I would pick that item to keep I'm just saying I think there's some other potential ones that we should try

171and keep as well but I I know we have to cut something and um so let's look at what the other options are because we don't want to impact the kids understood so I guess I kind of saw it a little differently when we started this or maybe I understood it differently but I think given the amount of the you know 025 reduction the 23,000 I think we're all very much in agreement that we'd like to keep that but aside from that I guess I understood it to say let's let staff know what our priorities are should we have additional funding in May to bring those things back so that is I didn't if we're not all on the same page I think we should get on the same page about what exactly we're talking

172about but my my understanding was we would just direct and say like so I'm hearing from Courtney that priorities would be College and Career Specialists maybe we'd say we don't want to make that cut at all but for everything else these are the things we would want to bring back first should we find ourselves having a additional funding I don't know if that's more like an easier way to do it for that sounds a little bit easier to handle staff than rather come up with all these other things so that's what I kind of that's how I understood it going into the conversation maybe I didn't understand that well we we all haven't met as a team since the governor's budget so we need to take a look at that um and we probably won't

173tomorrow depending on Andy's schedule we'll we're going to figure this out okay so it's been a crazy week with all the travel so got it so are we good with this item for now I think we can agree that the career specialist College and Career specialist we do not want to cut we don't want that on the list and other than that we you'll look at something with Andy tomorrow is everyone in agreement with that yeah yeah okay great so um it's almost 9 o' I would is make a motion for like a five minute recess no I would you okay do we want to wait until after the action items so that we can finish those traditionally those go pretty fast and then we could do a break before the provisional appointment we do

174have some public speakers and I have to go to the bathroom so want to move go on without me you can but I'm going well these people are all here for 15.2 so are you folks okay if we take a quick break and use the restroom so I'd like to make a motion that we have a fem minute recess second all in favor I oh student rep yes sorry e e e so our five minute recess is over and let's see computer's not up hello five minute recess is over okay so we are on to our action item and the first one is review and Adoption of resolution number 202 5-16 criteria for deter determining order of seniority for those employees with this same date of first paid service deterrent tiebreaking criteria Janelle aat good

175evening um related to the prior item and discussion of budget reductions we know we will need to eliminate certificated employees due to a reduction in particular kinds of services the order of termination is generally by seniority um tonight you're being asked to consider an approve resolution 2025-the breaking criteria in the event that there is a need to resolve a tie and seniority between certificated employees okay thank you so we've done this in the past we do this every year when we have potential reductions okay um any discussion any public comment okay any motion I make a motion that we approve the resolution second student rep I all those in favor I I motion passes next up we have addendum to project labor agreement dated 2018 okay Andy you on still yeah I'm still here okay

176I'm going to go ahead and start this off and then you jump in where um where you feel you need to this is a um on the pla so at the December 16th meeting the board directed us to bring back an addend more side letter um for Section 1.9 of the original 2018 project labor agreement which is still in effect um which um told us or which said in part that the district and the council can mutually agree in writing to add the additional projects add additional projects to the scope of the projects to be covered by that agreement and when measure o passed we now have another uh 90 million or so dollars to add into the PLA and it would this side letter would move all measure o projects above a million dollars

177into the current pla dated 2018 and Andy went ahead and worked with our um dwk uh law firm and Drew had a side letter drawn up um which is attached um which would take our measur o dollars and put them into the existing pla um as it stands and that side letter is attached for the board to review and vote upon yeah and if I could add in there the intent behind this was listening to the board's Direction is to continue the the pla agreement and so what this does is allows us to continue the same status quo with our partners and to be able to make sure that we have um facilities and schools that when the construction projects are undertaken that they will end up being on time and under budget because that's

178been the key for the district's position all along is working through that thank you um any discussion I'd like to hear the public comment so okay so um kind of my thought let me see no other discussion from anyone nope I'll just um say I you know we I think we've I'm trying to remember what meeting we first talked about this I think it was in December December um and you know I I support the pla um I I I'm happy we're going to continue the agreement with our labor Partners we did um have some um I heard from some folks in the community because the Carpenters council is no longer part of the labor coun of of the building and um construction trades Council and um we have been talking about ways to try

179to include everybody um because that just seems like the fair thing to do um but we also don't want to we want to keep the pla we have because as you've all just heard we don't have any money to try to re you know hire lawyers to sit at a table to renegotiate it so I would like to hear some ideas about the way we can do that so that it includes everybody and I know one one thing that was proposed was to add the Carpenters Council to the S letter so is that something that we can consider and talk about doing tonight well my understanding and Andy you actually spoke to De before I did but my understanding and Andy will correct me of course when I'm wrong because that's what he does best

180is um when the side the way that it's written there I think there are 15 15 um unions that signed I think there were 13 or 15 pages that were attached I sat at the table for a very long time um but everybody signed a different page and everybody signed it and everybody was included under the whole thing but it came I think um then the Carpenters um signed separately on there as well as the other unions all signed I don't have all the sign pages in front of me but um everybody was included in the one thing but when we made our side side letter uh dedre had put a signature line for The Building Trades and the Carpenters on that um side letter itself just as but it doesn't have to be there

181but she put it on there itself so I believe that's what she did is that correct Andy um yeah and what what essentially has happened is our legal council has told us that um our agreement is still binding even though we're adding on measure o so um regardless of how um different groups kind of move in and out from the trade Council um we still have this agreement in place the Carpenters Union along with the sheet Metals the operating engineers all of those different groups that are signed here would still be a part of this agreement as it stands with the side letter so we would not be from the district's point of view we would not be reducing or eliminating any group that's already a part of this pla from any future projects with

182measure o so I understand but so I I understand where you're coming from Andy but at the same time uh that was at a time when they were Affiliated and they're no longer Affiliated and you know I don't understand you know anything and everything about these plas I'm still kind of new to it but I think what they're asking is to have themselves listed as a distinct group should be an easy change but yeah I think we would just go to public comment to hear feedback okay first up we have Rick Solace time do I have three minutes three minutes okay great thank you uh so good evening board member superintendent staff uh my name is Rick Solis I'm the senior field representative with car Carpenters Local 152 and a 32-year member of the United

183Brotherhood of Carpenters uh first I'd like to congratulate you all uh as well as the students that occupy the United or the Martinez Unified School District on the passage of measure o this $90 million investment in your students allows the district to continue your commitment to meeting today's educational standards as well as your further commitment to the hardworking men and women that perform the construction of your school buildings by implementing the projects that are funded from measure o to the existing project labor agreement which brings us to the task at hand tonight when this pla was negotiated back in 2018 the Carpenters Union were Affiliates to the Building Trades Council however as you are all aware we disaffiliated from the BTC back in April of 2023 for reasons that don't need to be brought up

184but which is the reason that we simply cannot agree on the addition of these funds being added to the current pla without additional language that identifies the Carpenters as a separate entity so I know it's been proposed the signature line but it's not enough we're requesting that we have our name because we are the only Union that is not affiliated with the Building Trades Council so as it stand the agreement states that it is an agreement between the district BTC and their Affiliated unions and again since we are no longer Affiliated the Carpenters seek to be named to this agreement as a third party making this a tripartite agreement and solidifying the fact that we are in fact autonomous and a separate entity therefore we have sent the entire board as well as superintendent Rossi

185an ecopy as well as a hard copy of an amended version of the staff recommended side letter that dictates that specifically and legally for the record with the intent to compromise we have had multiple iterations on how this should go down tonight but have come to the conclusion that by doing it this way it would be the easiest path to success for all parties the board will have implemented the projects to the pla the BTC will have the exact agreement that they negotiated and the carpenters will have documented inclusion to this agreement making it a win-win for all in conclusion I want to thank each one of you for your commitment to your students first and foremost then again for your commitment to ensuring that Union trades people have the best opportunity to continue to

186build this District while earning family sustaining wages and benefits as well as the ability to keep the pipeline filled with a skilled Workforce we look forward to working with you and our brothers and sisters in the labor movement thank you for your time and allowing me to speak tonight thank [Applause] you thank you next we have Tom Hansen and after that we have EJ sire well my name is Tom Hansen I'm the business manager IW local 302 and also the president of the contracosta Building Trades Council to start off I'd like to make one thing clear the Carpenters quit the trade Council on their own their own bition no one forced them out no one made them to go they turned their back on the rest of Labor that day when they left they turned

187their back on us and now they're attacking us this is just a game that they're playing to get their name next to our so that now they can say they're an equal entity they're telling people all over the state that they're the sane alternative to the Building Trades that is not true they've walked away from the labor movement and gone off on their own and attacking the other trades and with the plans of destroying us it's obscene that people on this Council who or on this board who have been supported by us for years are now going to let them play their game here you should know better than that we should all stick together all have one signature page because we all equal we don't need anybody out there playing by themselves this is

188not the time in this country's history when somebody goes out on their own and screws around with democracy or screws around with the labor move we need you to stand up to them and say no we're the Building Trades they're part of the trade they left on their own give us all our own signature line and let it go in that and stop letting them get their way good evening everybody uh EJ sire Sheet Metal Workers Local 104 nobody ever get gu my name right so no no no hard feelings um first as Rick said earlier I do want to congratulate folks I worked on about $3.2 billion worth of school Bonds in those steering committees to get that passed in the November election and I saw uh two different areas where it was a

189total of about $300 million didn't get pass because the communities didn't see that benefit so um for your community to see that benefit is remarkable and that's awesome for the for the students especially in those classrooms um with with $990 million there's a lot that goes into that and there's a lot of construction that into that and there's a lot of revamping of classrooms and the HVAC systems that are outlined in there and that's a lot of what I did was those energy efficient systems and the indoor indoor air quality and stuff um as Amy said earlier there's a lot of really hard decisions that you all have as elected officials and and there's a lot of them that I I I don't ever want to be a part of but in one situation like

190this where you know that one one simple vote one I vote for getting this can really impact the lives of hundreds if not thousands of different people within your community with that Local H aspect getting those kids another pathway into into a career um I knew I wasn't going to college whenever I was in high school that's why I signed up for the military when I was 16 years old but I'm from Texas I didn't have another option I didn't have unionized trades to go to I didn't have anywhere else where I can make family sustaining wages if I didn't go into college or I didn't go into the military um here students have have realized that that's not the only option um students do have a pathway if they don't choose to go to

191college um for our for our program it's self our students actually get a college degree whenever they graduate their apprenticeship so it's a debt-free college degree and they're making a family sustaining wage with good health care good benefits and those those good Pathways into into the career opportunities that we really hope for all of our kids especially me as a dad of four um I I look at it as a viable option so in this moment I am jealous of the fact that you get to make that that decision that one I vote that can really change the lives of hundreds if not thousands of different people within your community in the surrounding areas thank [Applause] you okay you know what um before I get on to the next speaker um we need to make

192a motion to extend the meeting I'll make a motion to extend the meeting how long are we extending it for do we have to make that decision um 10 o'clock okay I'll make a motion to extend the meeting until 10 o'clock I'll second all in oh student rep I all those in favor I so passed okay um Bill Whitney is next good evening H board members and staff I'm gonna take some of my time to take a moment and on behalf of all of our Union brothers and sisters in the room to say congratulations to Helen on your retirement it's deserved it's earned um we understand hard work and that's what you put in and congratulations on that and our paths have crossed in many ways I think positively most of the time Helen uh

193but one of the things that I want to give you some advice on is right in here in my cell phone and it is called the countdown app okay because uh I have about four days left and uh that countdown actually helps Focus you because the days go tick tock tick tock I'm pretty soon they're gone so um call me later I'll get you that up so now we're here to talk about um this this item uh look we have supported everybody up there we've supported people in this in this room we negotiated this pla in the room Carpenter sat in this room nothing has changed in this agreement they're included we're not changing one word in the include it's a red herring to say that just because they've disaffiliated if you look at that

194sentence in there it doesn't say Affiliated unions it says unions that decide local unions that decide to sign so if this if the Carpenters don't want to be part of that that's a decision on them you shouldn't penalize 20 locals and 35,000 working people because they don't like it there's nothing that impacts them hurts them in any way shape or form without meas without us we we supported measure R we walked for measure R we put money into measure R without the Building Trades and if CJ was still here he would tell you the same thing doesn't pass and it's the same thing with measure o contracosta Building Trades put money in there we walked and you know what we were led to believe not a problem we're going to put meuro into the PLA

195and now all of a sudden we got some people here that have hesitation in their voice you got to be kidding me this is what this is what it's all about this is what you said you would do I'm expecting and hoping that that's what you do I have nothing against the Carpenters I have a lot of friends over there they after I get done talking I may not have as many friends but I've got some friends over there and and I see them I shake their hand but at the end of the day they're the ones that are whistling this tune it's not us and you shouldn't be dancing to that tune and if they if they want to be part of this we want them to be part of this we'd love to

196have them come back to the Building Trades Council but again as uh brother Hansen said that was their choice they left based on their decision not anything to do with the contra cost of building traits so we want you to be part of what we're asking you to do what we've been asking to do from the very beginning which is support measure o into the pla thank you we have Amy and then we have Eric I okay a different hat now um I am still Amy Scott slovic but I do now I'm I'm representing the contracosta um contracosta labor Council I'm the sergeant-at-arms there have been the last four years will be the next four years um and I just wanted to speak out here and say um speaking to what Mr Whitney just shared

197um we endorsed meuro we had people out every Saturday walking passing lit including stuff about meuro trying to get it passed the current agreement that's signed does not exclude any any Union that's here does not exclude anyone everyone here has the right to work um and and so I just want to speak out and say that it's super important that we don't like get into something and have to get more expense we've talked about all these things that are getting cut and all these problems that are having we need to get this work going um as a mom of kids at alhamra I had two children that were stuck in a room during the time during that seventh period when they had that um call in about whether or not there was a armed person

198on um the campus and for an hour and 10 15 minutes or so I didn't know if my babies had somebody with a gun near them they had said that two people possibly had been killed we didn't know what was happening and the moment that we can get this money to close that area of that campus have it around have a Central Area can't happen fast enough so please let's let people get to work move the money you know we have the money from the measure let's put it towards the pla that's been there that's worked well that includes everybody and let's get to work on it thank you good evening uh erican Street metal workers business representative um yes congratulations on getting this pasted I I believe two years prior there was an effort

199to do something and didn't quite work out so I'm glad to see that the this board was able to get the the city the residents to be behind a bond to help the school district um you know I'm in support of pla's until I die and I'm in sport of school bonds until I die I'm also in support of this Bond being adopted into the existing pla I'm not sure what the side letter is I did read it it concerns me a little bit because it's not consistent with what we've done as the Building Trades Council in the past and if you're going to go down the road of using this side letter I would just ask that all of the signatures are the the same and it's done in alphabetical order it only makes

200sense if we're going to go down that road make it consistent make it alphabetical that's all I have thank you thank you no other public comments okay um so on to discussion any discussion I feel like I'm being looked at so I can I I will start um I have consistently supported this pla none of us that are currently sitting at this dayas save for Helen um worked on the existing pla but it does represent the document represents months hours a lot of district and labor resources time efforts collaboration I think think that the existing document resulted in on time on budget in some cases under budget projects when measure R originally passed we thought we would be able to rebuild one school and do some Renovations at some others we rebuilt three elementary schools

201and renovated the fourth I'm really proud that we have utilized labor in this way um I do understand that there's a conflict that is outside of the school district and being a supporter of Labor I do hope that we can find a resolution that makes everyone happy but I do want to make clear that my priority is number one to our students and number two to our fiscal responsibility and I'm not willing to abandon a document which I think has given us a great deal of success in this District so I do hope that we can find a good solution because I think that all of the people who have shown up regardless of sides internal conflicts external conflicts I think that everyone here represents hardworking folks that made our schools possible and as a

202parent a lot most of us are parents here um who sends my kid to one of these schools every day it gives me great pride to be able to have done that um and I want to continue our projects so this is where I am I want to make everyone happy but I my priority is to use these measure o funds responsibly and quickly because that's what our voters expect and I think that the pla was done with Fidelity and it has served us well so um I'm not sure if there's more discussion uh that other people have I don't and again I don't understand everything obviously there's some back and forth uh but I believe we have to come to some type of compromise and in my opinion I think adding them as a

203distinct party uh for this future agreement it doesn't penalize anybody and makes everyone feel included so I'd make a motion to uh um make uh an amendment to the uh side letter to acknowledge the Carpenters as a separate enery do we have anybody who wants to second that what beyond what it says now on the agenda or correct [Music] okay I'm making a motion for the Carpenters to be listed as a separate entity in the S side letter uh if that's the process okay okay before we get into making final decisions I would like to ask purely from a student perspective of what effect does making this change on the side L letter have on our student population will it prolong the amount of time that it takes to be able to um have this

204pla agreement in effect and be able to produce those facilities will it create a greater cost on our budget um that's going to cause more problems or is it simply a simple matter of dispute of whether or not it's going to be there I'm gonna I'm going to turn it over to Andy because obviously there's a cost for legal I don't know I mean we could have it drawn up fast but as to whether or not it's going to be signed is not up to me um so I'm gonna turn this over to Andy well and just before Andy um I think we have money in fund 35 to at least start the process so I think the fences for the safety of alhamra was something okay all right all right but I'm just saying

205we're still moving forward with measure o though okay Andy go on um see if I can address it this way um right now we we are working on a timeline in which we would sell Bond uh money um and once we receive those funds then we can start putting them to projects as of today with timelines on how we would go through those those projects um we are still working with our community to develop um kind of the nuanced plan we have the facility master plan but it is from a couple years ago so we'll continue to look at that with the community and get their priorities and so we're really early in that all that is to say is that at this point in time we do we we probably won't see shovel to

206ground um if that's a good expression to use until the summer of 2026 at the same time we are looking at a few projects that we may be able to in earlier things like Carpeting and those such of things that don't necessarily hit within this pla so we may be able to address that but right now we don't have and don't plan on having funds um at least in this school year um probably looking at next fiscal year at the earliest we would sell bonds is probably in the fall um but so this discussion although is timely and I think people would like to do that the key here is that um the board instru Ed us um to move forward with the pla um and we are conscious of the cost that it would

207take to renegotiate the whole amount and we do understand that there's some conflict in there about how we should proceed but again that's up for you as the board to make those decisions on how you want to um direct staff I'm sorry I thought she was talking about the this part of it forgive me the other both yes and then the other part of that is is that um the suggestion as I know it to be is not going to have um any impact on student um student achievement that I know of um because it's the district's intent that we would continue if the board approves the pla we would continue to use the same labor groups as we have in the past and so our thought process is that we would continue to do

208so and so there would be no negative um outcomes for students or staff if we were to redraft the S side letter agreement as is currently being proposed then would that add an additional legal cost that we would have to go back to and is that I I think in light of the budget discussion that we just had is that going to mean another position that we're going to need to cut back on wouldn't these are going to be different dollars so we wouldn't have to cut back on a position but it's my understanding from talking with various members that are in the room tonight um that they may not support it and so that lack of support or disagreement would most likely create a protracted approach that we would have to involve legal and

209I think what's already been discussed is that the last time the pla was um went through that process it took months with lots of legal um on both sides on on many different fronts so I think it would take a lot of time and it would take an increased cost for us as a district and if we simply um accept the pla now do we have to go is is there any possibility for people to not sign it or agree to it so the the S letter that's before you tonight if the board were to agree to what is there or if they were to amend it depending on your guys's um um choice but if you were to sign the the S letter tonight then it would just continue current status quo and then

210we'd be able to move forward with um with no additional cost other than what we've already spent to get to this point okay and then if parties did not want to be a part of it any party could choose not to sign it and not be a part of this agreement but on our end we would continue to work with labor if the board approved it okay so I don't think um anyone wants to or that we would do a new pla that's not the intent here at all I think um Logan is trying to say let's try to make both parties happy and since the Carpenters um would be a part of it per um The Building Trades that um because they signed it and everybody signed it so they're part of the agreement

211um I think he's trying to um kind of keep both parties happy and and since the Carpenters did leave put them on the name and so it's a very small it would be a small legal fee and I think we have a draft that's um that we could certainly run by legal that wouldn't cost that much I think that's the intent let me speak to that you're you're correct that legal could change that document and it may not cost a large fee but that is the assumption that every party would agree to those changes so if all parties do not agree to those changes that's where it could be more protracted and cause and increase cost for Legal Services yeah I I'm I'm gonna I I think I I heard Bill saying they're not going

212to agree to it um and you know this is really tough because we in December we thought this was just a really simple thing we were going to do and now it's become very complicated um and it feels and I said this both to Bill and Tock so I'm not speaking out of turn it's going to sound flipping but I feel like Mom and Dad are fighting and putting the kids in the middle a little bit um which is unfortunate to me I I don't know how to to make everybody happy I I and I would like to um but it seems like the best thing for the district is going to be just to keep the status quo do we have any more public comment or anything no I guess okay um so I

213guess um we we can sure sure go ahead so I think the big concern here is that it's going to cost more that it's going to take a lot of time and there is no time we just simply want to add our name to it and that's it there there's no NE renegotiation there's no further cost there's nothing we're just going to add our name and I don't understand what the big problem is because like I said I think this is the third iteration that the Carpenters have compromised our position initially to make sure that all parties are happy and for some reason I don't know why that is not okay we're the largest construction union we cover the largest scope of work on any school project say between 70 and 75% Carpenters do from

214the beginning we're the first on the job and the last on the job we do everything from concrete formwork wooden metal framing insulation drywall acoustic ceilings Furniture we do cabinets we do hardwood floors we do toilet partitions we do cabinets so to exclude our members that do all of that it's kind of um it's kind of a waste to do a pla so some of the board members had mentioned that they feel that the pla has served them well and it has but the thing that has changed is that the Carpenters are no longer Affiliated and I said in my initial comment that I didn't need to explain why and I don't understand the Hostile comments that came after I spoke because I was trying to be civil and then kind of was attacked that

215way and I could very well bring it up but I'm still not going to do that I just feel that the bullying has has gone far enough and the Carpenters need to insist that we have our name on this agreement so if you want to move forward with the pla we're not fighting the pla we're are proa we just want to be named as a separate entity that's it and I don't understand why that's a deal breaker so um okay no so here's here's where we are should I okay so here's here's where we are there's a motion on the floor you have not closed public climet I'd like to have a rebuttal please okay here's where we are just one second you allowed Rick to come back up Tom can come back up you're

216going to close public comment you've got a motion on the floor and then we're going to move on because we have to do a provisional vacancy and the meeting's going to end in 15 minutes first there was no second to the motion I know there was none I know but we had an open right so what was just said was ridiculous nonsense and it's not that Mom and Dad are fighting one of the parents has left home and abandon the family that's what the real truth is the Carpenters don't do 75% of the job site they don't do that it's all myth and Legend it's trumpism what you're getting right now the contra cost of Building Trades are 22 are 22 locals against one they left they want to get their name on this agreement

217outside this because they want to set themselves apart they need to get back in the house of Labor you need to tell them they need to stop you can't afford this fighting in your house they brought this fight into your house we did not we just asked can you please apply o they're the ones that are threatening you if you don't do what they want they're going to have a fit they're attacking us they're attacking you they're the ones who brought the fight in this room not us don't let them get away with it don't let them run this game around the county going around and screwing with other councils and other boards because they want to get their way make them get back in the house and labor behave themselves so you can have

218a construct they have not signed multiple agreement all those projects have gone by fine they sign this one they don't sign the next one it's random don't let them get away with it hold them accountable make them get back in the house of Labor okay thank you so we're going to close public comment okay he's going to keep it he said the motion as it is can I ask a question with Andy first before we second or not second yeah we're leaving his motion there for right now Andy um so correct me if I'm wrong so if we did what Logan suggested and the Building Trades that they're not going to sign so they're not going to sign then the pla goes away and then we just do I mean we're a union town but

219if they don't want to agree we just move forward with getting bids is that how it would work no what what the board is going to decide is whether they're going to agree with this S letter as it's written or amend it from there the various Union groups are going to decide whether they're participating or not right you are drafting language about how you're going to change um what was originally listed as measure R projects to add measure o projects with the same letter information in there and your decision is on whether you want to authorize that part from there it's going to be the trade Council the carpenters union and all the various unions on whether they're going to sign to agree to that or not okay so I'm gonna second his motion you

220can do that I just you can of course you no of course you can I just I want to clarify where we are that your motion is the amended not what is on the agenda but in a can you say the motion again and I'll write it so I'm making a motion to make an uh a revision to the side letter stating that the northern Cal Northern California Carpenters are a separate entity if we did that if we move forward with this motion does the is the building Trad is going to sign that agreement well it matters in terms of our pla it does so I'm trying to figure out what will happen if that goes my due diligence hold on a second hold on a second our pla Andy correct me if I'm wrong

221our pla is still active we still have money in that in measure R our pla is still there that's going to stay there we made an addendum according to 1.9 to add measure all projects in you made an a motion and you seconded it you're going to vote on whether or not to revise a side letter you're either going to pass that or not if you say yes you're going to pass it we're going to take it to legal and we're going to revise it we're going to bring it back here after we do that and they're not going to sign it and it's going to sit there that pla is still in effect for everybody the 13 or 15 however many I forget how many signed it and that's still going to be an

222active pla until that's done if the board directs me to get a S letter back to where we were I'm going to bring it back back here and we could try to put the measure o back in just as we plan to do tonight and then we bring it back here and the Carpenters don't sign it and if they don't sign it that PLA stands and with the builders and the other 13 or 14 however many were the original signers do but the Carpenters don't go in it but that's as it stands right now the one that we have attached here according to our legal department if you guys voted in everybody's in it as it stands everybody all signers from the original if the Carpenters don't want to sign it they don't have to

223sign it but they're not in it so if you want to change it you change it and that's the way it goes but the pla is still open and active with everybody involved in this room right now as it stands because everybody signed it to begin with right that that's correct that's correct okay so we could still move forward ultimately as long as there's still you can't move forward with measure o only with completing measure R which is very close to be being completed could you start measure o stuff until measure R is done I can spend measure o stuff on my own without a pla right I saying okay that's just gonna happen without a pla you know that's the only difference okay do we want to do that no we've been very successful

224with our PLA and again we we we like the unions we are Union but our tax pay taxpayers did vote for measure oh $90 million was which isn't chump change for us to do our secondary schools and we want to do our secondary schools and they're not going to want us to sit on this money for a few years while people work out their differences so we got to do something well is what I'm saying there's a motion do we take a vote I seconded so do we have a vote yeah student rep no no no yes yes yeah two eyes so I would make an alternate motion to approve the pla as agendized second student rep yes yes no Annie you have a vote well I made a motion but so yes yeah we

225say yes CU just because so it looks like it's going to pass anyway [Music] um I'll say no but it's gonna motion passes because we have three board members voting for it no she's not that's right she doesn't count because it's money related so we have a tie so we can let I am the tiebreaker I don't want to be the tiebreaker why' you say that or or alternatively we are about to make a provisional appointment if we want to have a full board vote on this and we can't be in a TI table this till the next meeting and do our provisional appointment yeah let's do that we're going to table it because it was a tie and um no do you need a motion to table no no well just to be safe

226I move to move this item to our February 10th agenda I'll second I you I I saw that I'm just thinking I so let me just take that back for a second real quick so if we move forward since I'm the tiebreaker and we say we're going to go with the amendment that Logan suggests and then the the Builder trades don't sign it we can reevaluate it at that time we'll have a full board so let's do that wait a minute it did pass because no it did not okay the the motion that passed was or not the mo the motion that Lizzie voted for was to adopt the pla as amended in the agenda as agendized which has a side letter which has a signature line for so made a motion you seconded it

227yes you all voted and it was a tie right and then Annie made a motion we didn't make a tie break in time okay there was no time you just moved on to the next thing so the tiebreaker with Lizzy Lizzy does not have a vote count right so it's still two to two it's still two to two on Logan no it's two to two on the amendment as here yes on both no it's tied on both okay so do I make an the same motion again to bring that back you guys I'm going to move I'm going to break the tie and go with the Carpenters on the motion that Logan made we have to do it again then wait please please please please so go ahead first motion e no I think we're

228should should we take like a two- minute recess and or so you can think so okay okay okay okay no well so the second motion though so the second motion was a tie so I can say no on that one and then we can have a discussion again so Logan make it motion I'd like to make a [Music] motion so do you need a moment superintendent can okay so I have a motion to extend the meeting to [Music] 10:30 can we make a quick to extend the meeting second Lizzy I'll make a motion to extend the meeting until 10:30 second make it to okay all in favor it was student rep sorry I thank you superint superintendent Rossy so just as a point of order uh we do have a motion on the floor to

229table whether so that motion would need to be res sended uh so that we can begin discussion on additional motions in my opinion uh uh our student trustee seconded that motion so we do need to address that point of the meeting in order to get to this point um I feel that the uh we probably need to also resend the vote because it the motion was tied and then I believe a new motion should be made and a new vote should be taken I could be wrong I'm just a technology director uh but I am a very astute political scientist so um but I do feel that that would be necessary to make this a clean vote okay so with that reading then we still have the motion on the table that needs to be

230rescinded then technically the first vote tied and is now the motion dies so for us to continue with the meeting and this point uh this item a new motion of the board desires would need to be made and a new vote would need to be taken or you can entertain other motions at your discretion okay again I'm not a lawyer so so I will resend my motion to table this vote until our next meeting with a full board no vote needs to occur because no vote did occur but the motion uh ER I guess would has now resented that so now you've UND that point of order so we now are at a point where you would have your first vote I believe so I make a motion to make an make a revision to

231the side letter that the northern Calfornia Carpenters be listed as a separate entity seconded student rep no no no yes and I so it's a tie so we'll motion passes a tiebreaker all right item 16 um okay background in process for selection of applicant for provisional appointment Helen Rossy oh okay I thought you were saying something first okay because you have you have 16.1 we'll provide an overview of the process yep I got that yep got it okay so you want me to start because on here on 16.1 you I have no are we just taking turns with this okay yes it says our name who say okay all right Martinez Unified School District appointment process the agenda item in regarding the provision appointment of an applicant to fill a board candidate vacancy as background

232a vacancy in trustee Area 3 was created by the departure of trustee lus effective December 13 2024 within 60 days of the vacancy the board is required to take action to either make a provisional appointment or call a special election to fill the vacancy created by the departure of Miss llamas at our meeting on December 16th 2024 the Board of Trustees selected the provisional appointment process to fill the vacancy the board invited applicants interested in serving on the board to submit application by the close of the application period the district received two qualified applicants those applicants in alphabetical order are Britney aala and Brenda leil all board members were provided the opportunity to review the applications submitted by the qualified candidates this evening the board will interview the qualified candidates and take action to appoint

233a new board member for board bylaws 9223 the appointed board member will hold office until the next regular scheduled election for board for District board members in November 2026 the board appreciates the interest of all applicants in serving the district as part of the board while the board may only select one applicant to fill the vacant seat we want to let you know that there are many ways besides filling the vacancy that you can support the district and we hope that you will take advantage of those opportunities before we get started superintendent Rossi will provide some information regarding the interview process first we will need to determine the order of interviews applicants names will be pulled from a bowl to determine the interview order I will ask board clerk campel to pull the applicants names

234out of the bowl to determine the order of the interviews and ask our executive assistant Nikki green to read alloud and record the orders the order that the applicant names were pulled Logan can you oh she's got to take him out of the sealed envelope like the Oscars is E just one just one I'll J Britney is first Brenda you're second when it is time for the interviews the applicants will head to the waiting room which is actually the front lobby each candidate will come into the boardroom one at a time for their interview and will be asked the same questions as the other candidate in front of the Board of Trustees when called upon as a reminder in while you're in the waiting room candidates are prohibited from using their cell phones and other

235electronic devices each applicant will have the opportunity to make a two-minute opening statement then the board will each ask will ask each applicant the same five questions and Lizzie you will ask a question as well allowing two minutes for each response after each question applicants will be provided two minutes to make a brief closing statement Joseph gangler director of educational technology will end close um and um board consultant I should say will keep a timer for each question an opening and closing statement after their interview each applicant will return to the waiting room well actually after the first in applicant interviews they can stay in here and listen to the second one if they choose to the board will then complete their note sheets for each applicant the board will then engage in discussion on

236the candidates which will result in a member making a motion after all discussion is had and then a second will be made nominating a candidate for a vote the board will then take action to appoint the provisional member and the oath of office will be administered to the new member by the board president so we will now give the public the opportunity to comment on the appointment item each speaker will have three minutes to speak please make sure you have filled out a public comment card prior to speaking have placed it in the basket located in front of the assistant superintendent Janelle aat first up we have Megan thank you hello again as a resident of Area 3 I would like to share my support for the appointment of Brenda Leal to the vacant School

237Board seat Brenda's experience in the district and inquisitive nature will bring a fresh and fresh perspective and team player to the board thank [Applause] you next we have Marissa lrico and then Paula mcau Helen Congratulations by the way dear members of the board I'm writing to express my enthusiastic support for Brenda leil as she applies for a position from the Martinez School Board Brenda is an exceptional candidate whose extensive experience and deep commitment to education make her an outstanding choice to serve in this capacity Brenda brings with her an amen's 36y year career as an educator during which she demonstrated unwavering dedication to her students and colleagues makes me want to cry she's always been a pillar of support for teachers earning their trust and respect through her actions and advocacy her ability to bridge

238the gap between Educators and administration is precisely what our district needs to ensure a harmonious and productive relationship between all having Brenda on the board would be an incredible asset her unique perspective as a former teacher and Union Leader provides a vital connection between the board and Educators who work directly with our students her knowledge and insight would undoubtedly lead to informed decision-making that benefits both teachers and students alike I can speak for many many teachers that I've spoken to that we strongly agree and recommend that Brenda leel should be one of your school our Schoolboard members she is without a doubt the best choice to Foster Unity collaboration and pro progress within our distri District selecting Brenda would demonstrate a commitment to valuing the voices of Educators and prioritizing the success for our students

239please consider this opportunity to bring an exceptional leader into the fold a decision that will be celebrated by teachers and the entire School Community thank [Applause] you good evening Brenda was one of the first teachers that we had our first full year in the district and that year was filled with a lot of issues for our family um not one of which was a district problem that has since plagued our family for the remaining years of that student however Brenda took time and effort to deal with each of those issues with us as she was our one of our students teachers the difference in how she handled the situation is that she facilitated dialogue and discussion and did not engage in conflict or combat that is a skill that is strongly missing in a lot

240of discussions in our current day and age and that skill being brought to the board I think will only be an asset because I see that is what you were aiming and and trying to achieve and she will further that process the other thing that she did was become a creative Problem Solver so some of our issues that we had needed to have some uniqueness brought to the table so instead of just pushing one side or the other of an issue she brought third fourth fifth options since that time I have worked in committees with Brenda and seen her collaborative work with the variety of our community so as you saw tonight that is often the case in other meetings as well in this district and she has always come with a voice of reasonableness

241she's thoughtful she's historically accurate she is datadriven in her discussions and she's collaborative in her work but the final thing that you have also heard from is that she is a commitment to her District she's not doing this for any personal gain there's nothing that she's going to stand to benefit from other than the fact that she loves this community and it's evident in all that she's done she's supported our family not just in school activities but in some extracurricular activities that we have done as well you would think that I have a long-standing personal relationship with this person I don't it is only her community activity that I'm speaking to and those interactions that I have with her I strongly encourage you to have her be our next board member in area three the

242skills talents abilities and gifts that she could bring to this district will go beyond our decision tonight will be go beyond the decision that you make in the pla discussion and it's going to go beyond what these kids are going to see because the effects that you as a border are making is longlasting now as a parent who just added some $88 to this District this week by bringing you some more students I could be here for a really long time I have a lot to lose by the decision that you make that is why I'm here please please please vote for [Applause] Brenda okay we have Katherine Hearn and we have Yasmine next good evening uh I firmly believe it's important to have a variety of backgrounds on the school board to bring different

243perspectives expertise and fresh eyes it is also very important to have a person on the board with firsthand experience in the classroom at the moment we only have one and quite frankly that's just not enough uh it's an indisputable fact that it is the teacher who spends the most amount of time with our students firsthand seeing their struggles and their victories reading their faces and body language to day knowing what kind of day they're having hearing from students things that they may not tell anyone else it is the teacher that sees firstand the impact of budget cuts made too close to the classrooms and students who weren't able to take their class because there weren't enough sections or don't have enough art supplies for the upcoming project it is the teacher who knows which curriculum

244programs work or instructional methods that are working or not working for the students with all due respect truly uh to all others involved in a child's life it is the teacher who is on the front lines of the daily Battle of public education and it is the teacher who really knows what's going on in the classroom on our campus and where our priorities need to be focused this teacher is Brenda Leal Brenda's tireless work as mea President also uniquely qualifies her to understand the roles responsibilities and inner workings of a school board holding the school board and the District administration accountable for the highest quality education for our students comes second nature to Brenda and she has already spent a lifetime doing so Brenda's life work as a teacher and teacher leader has earned her

245a well-deserved retirement uh but rather than wanting to go on a beach somewhere here she is less than a year later wanting to give more of herself to our students this alone is testimony to where her heart is and her intentions LIE there's usually a lot of talk about collaboration with teachers for what is best for our teach our students well I can think of no better collaboration uh than to have another teacher with a seat at the table thank [Applause] you Yas Meine um I'm gonna take her spot because I have to at the airport but my name is Sandra and I'm here in full support of Britney aella I want to see diversity I want to see somebody like representing me my children my Latino Community that's very high and important in this

246community I want to see Britney out there with you guys um I think she could represent us I don't see us being represented and I would like somebody that's my community representing us also um I don't feel and and no offense to anybody but I don't feel that um Brenda is the best choice there's a lot of to me conflict of interest I understand the teachers because they have a bond with her but to me it would be a conflict of interest we're here for the kids remember it's the kids that we're here for and we need to have somebody that's going to be here supporting our children I have a I have a son in special education I have um nieces and nephews here and I want somebody representing that looks like me I

247want to see diversity and I think Britney would be a great choice um also I would like to express there would be more people here supporting her but I've talked to people in my community and right now with what's going on with I and the raids they're afraid they're afraid to speak up they're afraid to come and I really wish you guys would have also sent out something letting the families know that they're safe that the kids are safe like other districts have done and I haven't heard anything from you guys so it would be great if you guys can also reach out to the community and let them know that their kids are safe and they could come and speak because a lot of families aren't here tonight because of that thank [Applause] you

248so Anna Marie and then yasmi good evening board anamarie Avala FAS um first of all I want to thank the applicants this is very difficult to uh always come to a public space and put yourself out there so thank you both of you for you know putting your names out there um I'm here to support Britney um we are at a Crossroads uh not only here at the state but nationally uh representation matters uh and qualifications come to our space and education in different forms Britney is a mother Britney has children in this District uh and kindergart you know in elementary to Middle School Britney is an education and higher education uh she is what building the benches she is the future of public education she is a strong Advocate and most importantly K through

24912 right now is over 50% left in the state of California and in Martinez you all know the stats even more we need representation for all children but in particularly are children that are the most vulnerable and marginalized in the school district we need to have people that are reflective of the demographics of this County and of the city and our school board I grew up in Martinez I grew up in the public education I did not have one single Latino teacher I did not ever see a School Board member in fact your former School Board member Yasmine was the first to have that honor to occupy that space please do not regress this board by not bringing the voice that has been so marginalized in this community we need especially under trumpism we need

250to have Advocates that are going to speak for those marginalized voices in our community connect with our community to speak to those children and their parents to reassure them that public education is here for everyone including our children who are unseen consistently so I urge you all to see this Beyond credentials and to see who is going to be the biggest impact around education and advocacy in our community in a space where we have not had a voice so please support Britney tonight good evening yasine yamas I have a 10th grader at bionis and a second grader at mola Park and I'm here to support Britney I actually met Britney I didn't meet her I actually heard about Britney 12 years ago when one of my friends who's an educator in the mount D Unified

251School District told me about a teen mom who was being pushed out to Crossroads um and about how brilliant and impressive she was that was the first time I found out about Britney Britney overcame those odds graduated from the high school she resisted going to a continuation school graduated from the high school moved on to Community College excelled in Community College moved on to UC Berkeley excelled at UC Berkeley and now she's in a master's program at St Mary's um I had been keeping my eye on her through the years because I had always heard about all the wonderful things and how she had been excelling so much and I actually connected with her again last year when her her and her sister came to my office because they wanted to buy a house so

252I looked at her out this I'm like hey you live in my district um and she started telling me about all the wonderful things she's doing at UC Berkeley with higher education as a transfer specialist and helping kids at the high school level and at the community college level get into uc's and to CSU schools so that's when I was like wow you're really impressive you're doing really amazing work our district needs you um so the seat came open and she shared with me that she was in the master's program and I asked her hey would you want to run for this seat and she said yes so I thank her for that I think she will be a very valuable asset not only because she graduated from high school 12 years ago she's probably

253going to be the youngest one on the board so she's going to have the closest connection to the students but the amazing work that she's doing at UC Berkeley and all of the tools and resources and connections that she has at that University that she can bring to our district and help our students with aside from the fact that she has a sixth grader at the at Martinez Junior High and she will have a TK in a few months um at John sweat no John M lasas oh Lunas um and I also wanted to add to the fact um e say Express what sanra had shared earlier I had reached out to a lot of Spanish-speaking people in trusty Area 3 and if you don't know trusty Area 3 is the Pacho Corridor which is

254where I live I live right off the Pacho Corridor the intersection of morelo and poo there's a lot of immigrants a lot of Spanish speakers and that is where I reside reached out to a lot of people in that area asking them to come and speak in support of her but they're afraid of the raids people are afraid to come out and speak so I want you to know that there are people in our community that are afraid and I communicated with them in Spanish she is a fluent Spanish speaker her parents only speak Spanish similar to my background so when you have her up here I the last point I want to make is she is Lizzy 10 years later this is who you're putting on the board thank you [Applause] I'm gon do

255so we have Todd Navaro good evening um I'll make it quick it's really late um and I'm tired um I am a member of area three and for someone who uh had the commitment not followed through by the prior board member I think it's time that we move forward with somebody who has an extreme amount of passion for our students and that's Brenda leel no offense I don't know you um I first met Brenda years ago when I started serving on District level committees I think it was the calendar committee something I don't know but one of the things that impressed me most about Brenda Is Not only was she teaching class all day she was represented at almost every commit every committee that was available to be served on and I don't know if

256she was doing that in her role as mea president or what I got out of it was a very concerned teacher and parent she graduated a student out of this District as well um she I think it's time after some of what I witnessed go on here tonight and no disrespect to any of the board members I think it will go miles right now for us to have somebody that understands how a classroom Works how the district operates and Brenda has Decades of that experience so I hope you'll consider [Applause] that I make a motion to extend the meeting to 11 o'clock midnight I don't know I make a motion to make the meeting go uh to extend the meeting to midnight if it goes that long I don't we don't have to go that

257long okay what 11:30 if we endly that yeah I'm making a motion to extend the meeting up until midnight all right I second student rep yes all those in favor I I so moved okay we had one public comment come in um that has to be read so dear members of the Martinez Unified School District School Board I strongly encourage you to appoint Brenda Le to the vacant Area 3 seat on the Board of Trustees with over 36 years of exemplary Service as an award-winning teacher in her eight-year tenure as president of the Martinez Education Association Brenda brings a wealth of experience dedication and insight that unique iqu qualifies her to serve the needs of our students and Community Brenda's work as an educator has been nothing short of exceptional she has always been committed

258to the academic and personal growth of all students her deep understanding of the district's culture priorities and the martinis way truly sets herart she knows the intricacies of our District Operations making her an ideal candidate to step into this critical role on such short notice Miss liel's time as mea president has equipped her with an index knowledge of the district's contract and board policies as well as the challenges and opportunities faced by the district th this experience enables her to Advocate Advocate effectively for both Educators and students ensuring that decisions made at the board level are informed by a firsthand understanding of the teaching and learning conditions across all School sites she has a proven track record of successfully working with all campuses and community members across the district one of Brenda's greatest strengths is

259her in-depth knowledge of school Finance she knows how funds can or cannot be spent she has the ability to analyze and prioritize the district's budget in a way that maximizes resources for both students and teachers she will ensure that funds are directed toward the areas of greatest need in order to get the best bang for the buck in light of the current and future public education funding her knowledge of school finance will be inval valuable to the board I strongly believe that Brenda's qualifications passion and commitment to the students and educators of Martinez make her the best candidate for Area 3 vacancy her leadership will ensure that our district continues to thrive and move forward in ways that benefit every student and family thank you for your timeing consideration I trust you will make the

260choice that best serves the future of our community and I hope you honor the tremendous value Brenda Leo can bring to the board sincerely Jen Jennifer Dart okay I think that's the last one right okay Janelle okay we will now begin the interviews I would like to invite britania to join us at the podium and ask Miss em Espinosa director of educational services to show Miss leel to the lobby and remain with her until such time she's called into the boardroom to interview oh um me Matthew Jensen director of special education will go out to the lobby when it's time for the second applicant to come in um Miss aala I'd like to remind you that you will be given the opportunity for an opening state M um asked a series of five questions and

261given up to two minutes to respond to each after all questions you will be given up to two minutes to provide a closing statement okay um so good evening with Cala and thank you for your interest in filling the board vacancy you will now have the opportunity to provide a two-minute opening statement which will be followed by the five questions you may proceed with your opening statement good evening thank you so much for having me my name is Britney aella and I would like to be on the board serving as trustee for Area 3 I believe that my personal experiences and my professional experiences in higher education have really allowed me to take in a wealth of knowledge and expertise um in this field and I believe I can bring that into continuing to serve

262the Martinez school board's Mission and duty to our students our Educators and our families currently I work for UC Berkeley's transfer transfer prep program and supporting community college students get on to the next step of their academic career and prior to that I was a College advisor fellow really working with students figuring out what is it they wanted to do after high school whether it was the trades whether it's CET whether it's um higher education and Within These two Fields I have really allowed myself to be immersed in this field of work and build meaningful relationships and strengthen relationships with families with parents I have worked with administrators I have worked with um Educators to really Foster an environment which students can learn and student and students can learn about all the resources that they

263have at the disposal to continue on that next step of their academic Journey I've also worked with um folks um to develop Data Systems and um data to inform us of our work um and see what resources are available to students that are serving them and uplifting them uh what can data show us in terms of are we making sure that students are successful are we making sure that our students are College and Career ready are we making sure that students know and parents and Educators know perhaps um the best course of action that needs to be taken um and I'm very passionate about it I'm very passionate about the work that I do and hope to bring that um with me on the board uh if put on as trusty Area 3 thank you

264thank you we will now start thank you so much okay we will now start with the first question from board president buer G to let her drink some water first I know it's in the hot say you need are you ready okay I wasn't you need water okay um what are you proud of in this district and what would you like to accomplish as a board member what I'm really proud of this district is just the amount of effort by the district to be be very responsive uh to parents to make sure that there's a very open line of communication that parents are always aware of what's what's going on the opportunities that our Stu uh for our students and parents alike the amazing work that our educators are doing in fostering and Collective environment

265where students can Thrive and feel seen and heard at every level and every tier um like mentioned before I'm a parent and so I'm always up to date with what's going on in the incident um because I'm also a concerned parent right right um about what's going on and the transparency and the commitment to that connection is what I'm really proud of in this District the reason why we decided to move here um because we like the tight of this community I've come across folks who've been here for 30 60 years and I think that's the community that I want to be a part of and also have my children grow up as a school board member I will continue to work with an awesome amazing team that's doing the hard work I like to

266call it heart work because it's also in the heart that we do this work and value it um and like to add on to what's already been done um like to add on to um the hard work the difficult decisions that must be made whether they're data informed whether it's informed by the public whether it's formed by public comment whether it's informed by our students again is just making sure that we're adding um so that we uplift the voices and amplify those voices of our community and I would like to continue to do that work with you as a board member thank you board member masalo O'Brien has the second question uh as a trustee what do you see as your primary purpose or primary role what would you like to accomplish as a board

267member which is your highest priority and why sorry can you repeat the question one more sure it was kind of a lot as a trustee what would you see what do you see as your primary purpose or primary role what would you like to accomplish as a board member which is your highest priority and why I think as a board member I'd like I like to serve the community of Martinez along with four other board members right we just passed me measure o and making sure that our students are getting the facilities upgraded making sure they're in a classroom what they can learn making sure that educat have everything that they need to be successful in the classroom making sure our parents have that line of communication that I mentioned before and so again just

268really working with you guys to Foster um Partnerships with our community our Educators our students we are here we are here to most importantly first and foremost serve them um and allow them to be involved in any way possible um and also again working with you um in regards to getting the work done making sure that we are prioritizing our students mental health and wellbeing making sure that we're putting um security measures making sure that our students feel safe and seen um there was a lot of um discussion about Safety and Security um and so making sure that our students are safe as well in the environment that they learn to Foster that growth um and ultimately as a board member I just like to accomplish making sure that um we are a collaborative team

269and informed team and making sure that we are really uplifting the voices of our community of our Educators and of our students students board member Campbell has the third question all right identify a recent board decision that you felt strongly about and describe how you would balance Community concerns students needs state and federal law staff considerations and your personal value and uh value and beliefs to determine how to vote on that issue say that one more sorry you're question a two- part so identify a recent board decision that you felt strongly about and describe how you would balance that out with Community concerns students needs state federal law staff considerations and your personal values and beliefs to determine how to vote on the issue that you would have felt strongly about um I think I

270more so would carry that in making sure that I'm informed about the issue at hand um making sure that I am aware of the laws the states what they say um making sure that I'm aware of the risk uh scenarios that come after in making that decision um that I felt strongly about who is it impacting um why it impacts our students um in the form that it does um what are our stakeholders um talking about this issue um how does it represent them how does it personally affect them um also making sure that um taking into a collaborative form of um discussing the issue at hand and what that might look like in terms of is Effectiveness and whether or not um it's it will serve his purpose um making difficult decisions is always

271something that we try to shy away from um because it's going to impact someone in you know not the best way possible but just being informed on all ends and making sure that we have data assessment when possible um in order to make that you know decision and again just making sure that um we know the the laws the policies um about you know something that I felt strongly about okay board member um masalo O'Brien has the fourth question describe three priorities you would like to see the district focus on during your term as a board member um so the measure o just passed so definitely upgrading our classrooms making sure that the developments at alhamra high school take place to upgrade everything that needs to be upgraded um and then making sure that Educators

272have everything they need making sure that um uh parents also know about the whereabouts of what's going on in terms of progression um I think another thing I would prioritize as a board memb is continuing to Foster that partnership with our community and our parents making sure that they're up to dat with all the information that's going on in the schools whether it's from elementary middle school or high school I think it's really important to have the parent the parent involvement it's not just uh students and teachers it's also parents part of the community and I think as a board member I would also leverage my my Partnerships outside of this community that I have built upon um worked hard and been dedicated to to be able to bring that in terms of fostering that

273relationship with our with our wider community I think another um goal of mine as a board member would be to uh really secure and make sure that we um find new ways and new avenues um and creative ideas to secure and to and to minimize the impact of budget cuts right we just talked about um how all these different um vital resources um and people are going to be impacted um by these budget cuts and I think I would work really hard as a board member to make sure that we find creative Outlets to ensure that we have special education to ensure they have mental wealth mental Wellness to ensure that we have the music and the Arts um to ensure that again we continue to Foster an environment where our students can Thrive and

274learn student representative mcau has the fifth question what is your understanding of how the district's lcap guides the budget development process and which of the district's lcap cap goals would you like to PRI would you like to prioritize sorry can you say that one more time yes what is your understanding of how the district's lcap guides the budget development process and which of the district's lcap goals would you prioritize so the lcap um deals a lot with finances it's um it's uh deals with um how the money is spent how the money is allocated making sure that um everything is funneled uh properly and transparently and making sure that um things are getting done in terms of what things were designed to do um and to uh pay for and to create um and they

275also make again make sure that everything is established there's proper connection between the board um and its members and making sure that the information is passed from point A to point B in terms of what those finances look like um there's data informed to also to make those difficult decisions um again and to show how the money is being spent um that's uh being designed to again like repair our schools and and you know teacher salaries and you know all the um all the money being spent and so forth um and sorry was the other question that was part of it which of the district's lcap goals would you prioritize um I think just I think I would prioritize just making sure that or adding to the work that's already been done in regards to

276the public is aware of what's going on um making sure that um there's transparency in the proceedings that takes place with this committee um making sure that all parties involved the impact um what's to come out of this in terms of meetings um really sharing out the information um and making sure that our members are well informed um so that they know that we're continuing to do the work that we do okay thank you you will now have up to two minutes to provide a closing statement so as a teen mom um I was constantly told that I didn't have a space um I was constantly shunned by others and forgotten and put in the shadows um and even though I may have took that and ran with that and listened to that and stayed

277in the shadows I did not I persevered I showed persistence and passion and dedication to the work that I do I love working with students I changed my my focus of career from wanting to be a civil rights attorney to being in an education because I know the work that goes behind it and the intentionality that goes behind it um and just fostering an environment where students feel seen and heard um and making sure that they are valued um is what really brought me into this field um and I will continue to bring the level of grit and dedication and passion that I have in serving all of our students and making sure that they're thriving at every level and making sure taking their feedback and making sure that they have the tools and resources

278to amplify um and uplift their voice is the reason why I'm here and as well as making sure that both Educators families and and community members know that it takes a village it takes the village to educate and raise our kids um and we need all hands on deck and I think that's one of the reasons also why I'm standing before you because I know how important it is not to just have one sector but to have multiple sectors to have diverse perspectives to have diverse experiences to have lived realities and experiences that really showcase the many diverse populations that we have here in the district and we want to uplift that and make sure that no one falls behind the cracks that everyone is getting up together and showcasing and getting to their full

279potential and I will continue to bring that as a board member for area three thank you [Applause] thank you Britney you may choose to take a seat here in the audience or wait in the lobby until the second candidate has completed the process Matt will you please go out to the waiting room and ask Amy to bring in Brenda board members May at this time take a minute to finish up your notes board members board members please take this time to finish your notes um on Britney okay ready what happened to Logan oh okay got it it's kind of nice to stand I kind of feel bad for all of [Laughter] y'all I was like no I'm not sitting she a sweetie at the to okay good evening Miss leel thank you for your interest

280in filling the board vacancy you will now have an opportunity to provide a two-minute opening statement which will be followed by five questions okay you may um proceed with your opening statement sorry um it's seemed like you were coming from the ceiling and it's kind of late and I was like disoriented sorry about that um first of all I want to thank everybody that came out tonight I am completely humbled by all of the um comments that you made on my behalf so thank you so very much I know it's time for you to be home with your kids um members of the board thank you for extending this opportunity to me to interview for the open trustee position I appreciate the chance to express my desire to give back to the community of Martinez

281by serving on our school board for those of you that don't know me I have been a student in this District I graduated from alhamra high school and both of my daughters attended and graduated from Al hamper high school as well I am a second generation teacher my mother also worked for martinus Unified School District for 32 years I did my second um student teaching placement at John sweat school I was hired that summer and I didn't leave for 36 years so um I am dedicated to the students and staff of our district I took on um I have always advocated for students and for all students and those of you that know me and know that I've talked at the board many many times for not just John sweat but for all of our

282schools I'm a second generation teacher my mother also worked for musd for 32 years um I did that part I took on leadership roles to help strengthen our schools early in my career and continued to do so until I retired last year I was the president of mea working closely with the district to safely return students to our classrooms during the pandemic and encouraged and supported Dei training both at the district level and within our Union I have a great amount of ownership in our district and I want to continue to give back to our community Through serving on the school board is that it okay well okay we will now start with the first question from board president buer what are you proud of in this district and what would you like to accomplish

283as a board member what am I proud of in this District I am proud of the community that has supported us over and over and over again by passing bonds I am proud of the parents of this community that are part of our PTA I am proud of the the community itself who has supported us through businesses and giving money um and I'm really proud of the students oh my goodness I am proud of the students those speeches they gave today were incredible and some of them were my students I know they've grown and changed but I recognize them yes and I am really really proud of that um and I think that our district does a great job of educating kids which we saw tonight and um I'm proud of the teachers and I'm

284proud of the staff and our par professionals that go every day and help our kids and do them impossible what was the second half of the question uh would you like to accomplish as a board member as a board member I would like to first of all I'm very excited about measure o because I think that that's going to give us lots and lots of opportunity to um put more money into our budget I think it's going to um attract and retain teachers and I think that's something that I would like to accomplish because I consider that one of the areas that is um plaguing us right now in terms of being able to make change and to be able to um become what we can become I I started this District 36 years ago

285during that time all of our schools were um at some point uh recognized and I think that we can make our way back there um but we do have some problems that we need to work on in terms of personnel and being able to attract those people and keep those people here okay board member hak mutton has the second [Music] question as a trustee what do you see as your primary purpose or primary role what would you like to accomplish as a board member which is your highest priority and why that's a lot uh the role of the school board is um to shape the vision Direction and success of the district as a board member I'm excited to be a part of that in looking at programs and looking at what we can do

286to better our programs and to serve the needs of diverse students um and it was a three-point question and I feel like if I had it in front of me uh what would you like to accomplish as a board member which is your highest priority and why highest priority would be working within the budget to figure out ways to hire really um qualified people that will come to our district and stay in our district I think we sometimes get great people here but they don't stay and if we don't have that continuity we're not doing right by our kids and we it's hard to make progress when you have a revolving door of employees board member Campbell has the third question question hello identify a recent board decision that you felt strongly about and describe

287how you would bounce Community concerns students needs state and federal law staff considerations and your personal values and beliefs to determine how to vote on the issue wow I can repeat it yeah you're gonna have to that just give it to me so I can look at it I I'd give it to you but um identify a recent board decision that you felt strongly about and then describe how you would balance Community concerns student needs state and federal law staff considerations and your personal values and beliefs to determine how to vote on that issue well the first one that comes to mind is the one that we had today with the uh pla um because I sat through all of those years ago um and I do feel strongly about it because I am a

288union person and I do believe strongly in the unions I believe that um what they've done for us at our school sites uh being able to rebuild three schools that is incredible so we definitely want plas the problem is that they brought us a situation that is almost unsolvable because on the one hand one group wants us to amend the agreement and on the other hand the other group will not sign it if we do so I I do feel very very strongly about about that um I'm not sure I would have voted on it I'm not sure I wouldn't have told them to go back and figure it out amongst themselves because it's a no-win situation how do you win that I I don't know I really don't know I sat there the whole

289time wondering even no matter how you voted I didn't see that as being resolved so I guess I'm going to have to like study that a bit right thank you okay board member Masala O'Brien has the fourth question describe three priorities you would like to see the district focus on during your term as a board member I think that we need to focus um on continued growth and Improvement we need to focus on delving down into the demographics of the dashboard and figuring out what it is uh that is holding back certain groups and how we can support those kids to learn um I think that for me we need to maintain culturally responsible curriculum I've seen that in my own teaching that um that maybe some of the things that we have in place

290need to be augmented and um I'm gonna go back that Amy and I were talking about PD if if you have this great professional development and you um you give it to your teachers and then they leave how do you ever make progress when you don't have everyone on the same page so we have to retain our employees and we have to get them to stay here I think measure o may be um something that's down the road but I do think that that may be carrot to keep people here to attract them here um Martinez used to be a destination District when I was hired it was a destination district for not just teachers but also for parents and students because we were that great and um we provided um really great employment opportunities

291and I think we can do that again student representative mcau has the fifth question what is your understanding of how the district's lcap guides the budget development process and which of the district's lcap goals would you prioritize well the lcap um looks at our unduplicated population and we look at Services we look at data we look at how to improve the program for our students um um and to tell you the truth I haven't read the lcap this year it is a long lengthy document but as I can see it um I think English language arts and Mathematics for our subgroups should be um should be looked at and we should problem solve in order to continue to strengthen those skills with kids okay thank you Brenda you will now have up to two minutes

292to provide a closing statement all right I would like to say that I have attended board meetings for many years reading the agenda and documents before each one so as to be prepared I am experienced with many of the topics that are discussed in the programs and committees that give input to the important decisions that the trustees are called on to make my knowledge will be an asset because my experience has prepared me to contribute and support Martinez Unified School District at the very start of my appointment and I want to thank you again for giving me time to talk with you this evening if you should select me for this position I want to assure you that I will be a knowledgeable dedicated and reliable member of the board I have no intention of

293running for a higher office just the desire to give back to the educational community that has been my home for most of my life it would be an honor to serve the community as one of the board of trust for our district thank you thank you Brenda you may take a seat in the audience and board members please take a minute to finish up your notes page for our second candidate everybody have their notes down okay um so do you want to start question by question maybe and just talk about Plus and minuses on each candidate okay do do you want to start I I I don't want to any want to volunteer um so we're sort of in a unique like we're lucky because we have I think two really good choices um but

294then that makes this like really difficult too so um I I'll just start by saying I think that um Brenda's well I and and Brenda your the support tonight for you was was amazing I I did hear from um quite a few people for both people outside of the meeting um I think Brenda's knowledge and dedication to the district is commendable and would be an asset to the board um I think Britney would bring a unique voice to the board that um I think we're missing right now and um I am mindful of the voices that are missing in the room in the room for um the reasons that were stated so that's where I'm at it's it this is a really tough decision why don't we go down the line sure so first I've

295been through this process before uh at the city Council level so I understand how nervous you all might have been I've had just a ton of outpouring support come by phone email here in this meeting about everybody uh both applicants and you know although it's a difficult decision you know we're really lucky that we have two amazing people here that really want to see uh the best for the district and they both bring different um uh you know talents you know one a wealth of knowledge and understanding of the district's ins and outs and uh a commitment that has gone on for decades not only with her but with her uh mother um then we have another person that's supported students uh in an area that we need critical help on with that as we

296talked about earlier with uh potential Cuts with College and Career Readiness and somebody that has a voice in the community that uh doesn't always get to speak so um I just think uh it's going to be very difficult decision but I commend you both for coming out tonight and putting yourselves out [Music] there yeah I think that that was all well said by both Courtney and Logan that first of all thank you for coming and expressing your interest in this job the four of us know how hard it is and that it's not it's not always glamorous you can see that tonight um so I appreciate you putting yourself out there um and yeah I think we are very lucky to have two people that I think are clearly very dedicated to our students um

297I will also say that I do know both of these people um outside of this boardroom and I think they're both people of Integrity I think there are people who would make good decisions for our students primarily which I've repeated over and over tonight in some difficult decisions that that's my primary goal um I know are we not at the opinion sharing piece that's fine I'll let Tanya go and I don't have to first first person to go so um thank you both I thought you both did a great job um it's very gonna be a very hard decision um I think it's interesting that you both went to um same colleges you're both kind of in education um and I thought it was interesting that both of you um had kind of the same

298answer to the first question um you want to be responsive keep parents informed um and I think um that was what Britney said and then uh Brenda had mentioned you know the community uh by passing bonds and you know keep leadership keeping District in Union you know you focused on uh keeping them informed with Dei so I thought your answers really to the first question were were neck and neck so um good job on that and I think as we go along we'll we'll get some different opinion but I think um whoever we get um both will make would make great candidates um would make great great board members um let's see what's um Lizzie what's your thoughts okay I have a quick question first mostly procedural do I get to vote on which one

299is chosen okay just wanted to check with that um okay and then I'm a little confused on the process here are we going question by question and comparing the two applicants or are we simply stating our general overviewing thoughts so I thought it would be nice to go question by question just okay but I was just checking yeah just and then we can go back and we can say you know how we felt I just thought give us a starting point okay um so in the same uh token as you haa I noticed that the answers to the first question were very similar um uh Brenda Le's response was in some ways I think a little more focused on the people in our district um whereas I believe Britney IAS was on the efforts made

300of the district so that's just one thing I saw in that um and they both it was almost like two sides of the same coin where they're acknowledging this amazing thing of our community um but coming at it from two different sides and then after that the different accomplishments of our district the fact that we've put in this effort um and that we need to put in more effort to make sure that our students are being heard on the side of Britney aala and with Branda on the side of making sure that we're getting good qualified teachers and staff and in some ways that's to make sure that our students have that ability so that's my first thoughts as long as I get to share more later that's good let's see shall I keep going

301yeah okay um yeah no I mean I I agree with everything Lizzie said I think um you know it in some ways um they are very similar answers but very just that from spoken from the different perspectives that they each bring which I think both perspectives would be valuable which is what makes this so difficult um so going to the second question um I really liked how Britney mentioned um the vision of the district and um the mission I thought that was really um kind of spoton as far as what what our um our task up here is it it's it's in some ways really hard to make it a a short answer and I think they both did a really good job with that um I also liked how Britney mentioned about uplifting voices

302I think that's really important um and and and Brenda mentioned similar things as well as far as the you know the role and and Sh and shaping the vision of the district so I I I'm confident that they both have a really good understanding of what the role is um and I I know you know I just on a exper experience level I know Brenda's been here for countless meetings so I I know I know she understands how it works and they I think they both know what they're getting into I'll just Echo what she said and let Annie go for okay so um yeah I mean I I I really love that throughout all of the questions both candidates mentioned measure o multiple times obviously this is something that is not only at the

303Forefront tonight but in our priorities and we have a lot of opportunity there so I love that um I I really I highlighted the comment that Brenda made working within the budget to hire qualified teachers who stay um I'm highlighted the within budget because if we had unlimited funds I think we could attract the very best people we would just pay them the most um but we have budget realities which we talked about tonight and so I think that um it's good to see that that is a consideration which is an unfortunate reality for us um and she also made a comment that I really liked without continuity we can't make progress um and I'm think I'm G to come back to that because I really liked that um I think I I saw from

304Britney a real effort and willingness to work together with the board which I think is also really important to have a functioning Board of five um you know we come at issues as you saw tonight we don't always agree on things and I think it's really important to have a board that can respectfully disagree that we can have ongoing conversations hopefully find resolutions so I really saw that willingness from Britney here and I like that yeah so I also um Britney went first I'm GNA talk about her uh she had the purpose to serve the community um to be successful prioritizing mental Health um for students to be safe and feel seen um and collaborative team so I really I liked those those comments they were they were very good um I also liked um

305Brenda and I kind of again working within the budget um coming to our district in stay and I think that's um that would be great uh as we see we have budget cuts all the time or it seems like the last couple years um but yeah I like that and she wants to shape the vision and direction of the district that's our role um so she's spot on on that so again I think um both have a little bit different perspective but both are really good answers um so yeah so far that can that in my opinion um the I'll just talk because I had many of the same points you guys did I'll just talk about the one main difference I saw um and that is in was in the statement of the role

306and the purpose on um Britney's statement I saw a lot more about the almost like physical actions of what the board was supposed to do with communication with the community Educators and parents um and then serving the community and students and then working with others alongside of each other um and I think that's all very important because that is what we are doing as the board but I really appreciated the way that Brenda defined the overarching goal and purpose and when she said it was to shape the vision Direction and success I was like whoa um so just that idea of that overarching goal I think is in some ways very important to have as that Pillar Point of what's the purpose of being here even Beyond simply the actions that you're taking to get

307to that goal so that was my biggest take away from that I think this is kind of where some of the answers started to diverge a little bit but I still I mean I really liked how Brenda talked about the pl um because I think you're you're you're right um and this is kind of a a unique um a unique issue this that that does not come up a lot um some of the things we do here we are kind of routine that we have to do every year but that this is a kind of a difficult complicated thing that we haven't really dealt with before so I I liked that answer um I really liked how Britney mentioned um data assessment and she mentioned data a few times in some of her answers and

308also in her application which I think is really important because um especially because we have you know one thing I think this District does really well is I think we do a lot of really good things with very little and um and data becomes really really important when when you have to do that and so I really liked that that Britney um is aware of that and is is conscious of that so these are really hard questions by the way guys I mean like even me up here I was like oh man which one I go so uh Brenda I think it was you know it was a true statement right like it's not something that we should have really had to deal with but unfortunately sometimes that comes up um and I'm sure as

309mea president that was something that you know you had to deal with on a constant basis is you know trying to find a solution for everybody um and then as bery talked about and Courtney just mentioned the data right being able to look at things more strategically and try to find what works but versus what doesn't work and seeing how we need to address issues and you know figure out the best way to solve them so uh I know it's difficult if it's not something that you follow uh I'm still learning a lot myself as a new board member uh I won't be the newest one but probably not the smartest one at the end of this for sure so um I appreciate the effort and the answer uh with what information you had so

310thank you yeah I think I um I agree with Courtney this is kind of where we're we're seeing some Divergence in answers I think Brenda here really did the first part of the question which is identifying a recent board decision he felt strongly about um I didn't see a specific issue that Britney felt strongly about but I do I did really appreciate um the ways that she thought she would assess making a decision um but I really appreciated the specificity that Brenda provided and that it was like a true you know in the real moment a conflict that she was sharing that this is really hard and um but I also kind of appreciate her out of the box thinking like well this feels like something you guys can maybe go figure out and then

311come back um so I think that your problem solving showed through in this and um as you can see tonight we often have to think on our feet so appreciate that I really did appreciate the p no a no win situation um and I think ultimately you may come to that you never know but um so I do like that you answered the question very strongly um and again um I will repeat what um Annie said that um I didn't see an actual answer to a recent decision however um I really do love the data assessment um and again just you know discuss issues at hand um to keep informed about issues and DEC you know make good decisions so I don't think that um Britney she maybe hadn't seen a meeting I'm not sure

312but I think that her methodology about making decisions would be very spot-on um I just think you didn't have it right here but I I just really I did also really like the data assessment I um we see a lot of data and um sometimes we have to dig in deeper and get even more information but that's you know a great something great that we need to look at and so that would be an asset um kind of echoing what you two have already said as an AP student I've been told many different times that if you don't answer the prompt you don't don't get the point now that doesn't quite get applied here but there is um definitely looking at this some questions that get raised in my mind of how much dedication there's

313been prior to the opening of this job position um as Brenda's answer showed even simply attending this meeting gave a very adequate example of something that you could have talked about if paying attention getting that and so I really appreciated Britney's answer and thinking of coming to the data point but I also acknowledge that in this question she didn't do the data research that she was talking about ahead of time in order to get the answer for this question um and so I think that's just for me that was kind of the first tone of oh here's a point of caution of how much is this investment into the actual role and how much is she demonstrating her current investment into this role before she's even gone into it all right have a question for

314um okay so I this is another one where um I think the the there was some similarity and some differences um I really like how Brenda mentioned mentioned the improving um outcomes for certain demographics because that's absolutely you know one of the things we need to do and one of the elcap things um that's um a top priority um Brenda talked a lot about retaining employees um which I think um is also important I but I also really liked um Britney's focus on the Partnerships with the community because I think that is is really important especially now with a lot of the things that are happening out in the world and the budget cuts and all of that stuff um so fostering a lot of those Partnerships is going to be really important so I

315think it was just kind of a good look at what some of people's different perspectives on some of the difficulties that we're facing are um I'll just Echo what Courtney said and uh yeah I'll just by um so here I saw Brenda really start to focus specifically on student outcomes so her first priority was continued growth and Improvement and um looking for ways to support all groups and specifically our groups that are not succeeding in the way that we want all of our students to succeed then she said culturally responsible curriculum which I think is for this moment in our world really important um and she knows that firsthand in the classroom working with a diverse population and then um again with the continuing continu oh my gosh guys it's late continuity uh to attract

316and retain teachers but in this that she really spoke about um she used this term I've never heard this before destiny District I'm G to start using that I love that um because we definitely want to be that right um and I thought that that was like really showing an understanding of what measure o is trying to do Beyond just the immediate improvements to our classroom but here we have a real opportunity in our properties to have a an income earning potential opportunity so um it's clear that she from these responses it's really clear that she's spent time with our students and spent time here in this boardroom um listening to our meetings multiple meetings all the time um and then um Britney I feel like there was maybe a little bit less specificity but

317I do um the minimizing the impact of budget cuts I thought was really good and I have a feeling that Britney has lots of ideas in terms of you know with her work and how um you know to maximize sometimes scarce resources so I thought that was was a really good comment so yeah um I thought Britney mentioned measure o upgrade everything which um I think she meant you know continued growth I also like um she mentioned that teachers you know have what they need um communication to parents students and teachers Foster relationships um you know try to have creative outcomes and I do really like that she mentioned music and arts um I think that's a way that we can um you know get more money because um some of the programs the more

318students are getting you know they're going to start having a little bit higher budget stepping on sorry um and you know for I and learn so I I like that a lot um and again I also had never heard the phrase destination District um that we should you know shoot for that again so I like that as well um and you know also the um teaching material be socially responsible so um I thought both had um very good answers on that as well I think everybody pretty much said for that one what I was going to say from the difference in specificity to the just basically generally same goals um yes the destination District stood out to me too um but it's a very interesting idea almost because I think it puts in mind a

319vacation in my head and it's not necessarily what I think school is but it's also a nice ideal for school um and then also the emphasis on the special education mental health and the Arts and Music program um which I think are things we have a great potential to expand at our district um and it's going in that direction which would be nice to see continue yeah so okay so the last question is about the lcap and I you know there were defin differences here too and I think this is just kind of we have to think about what we think this Board needs at this point in time for a board member because we have one person who has a lot of knowledge and um experience to impart on the board and then we

320have somebody else who may not have as much knowledge and experience but um has a passion and a unique background and um and a different perspective and and voice than than what we have right now so that's kind of how I'm looking at um the two differences in the candidates and it's tough to say which is which is more important um but like I said I am really mindful of um a large population that we do have in our district who um is not feeling safe right now and is not here to provide a voice so I couldn't have said that better um I agree with everything Courtney said and you know on another note you know with Helen only going to be with us for another five or so months in the superintendent role

321because I'm sure she'll still stay much very much involved the wealth and knowledge you've had you've had experience with a lot of different superintendents what you know what things work best what you know what brought everyone together so I think that's very valuable and then for Britney um you know as we talked about again earlier with the career Readiness the experience and passion being able to help students guide them uh whether it be you know the trades for your college um whatever that may be and again that voice um that seems to be missing in this um community at times so uh it's going to be really it's not it's much harder Choice than the vote earlier I'll say that so thank you again both of you I was gonna say what Logan said about

322Helen retiring and um that news which I'm clearly very L I'm not kicking you out I'm clearly very emotional about it um but Helen has more institutional knowledge than probably anyone in this entire district and we when you look at the makeup of of our board right now the two most experienced people four years so for me again I think that both candidates here I think more so fortunate to have two qualified candidates for me what tips the scales is that we really need that expertise and we have a candidate here who can walk in day one and have bring a wealth of knowledge and understanding of our cap our budget our student needs where we're headed where we've been that is something that you don't find often and I don't think that it is

323something that we should take for granted um I know that I could work with either of these women and I know that they would both bring absolute great passion and wonderful things to our district but looking at where we are right now that's where I am [Music] so um I do think Brenda has a ton of knowledge and a wealth of knowledge um but I also I have to say for Britney I really liked her closing statement um she talks about some of the struggles she's overcome she was a teen mom um she felt shunned and she still persevered Um passion and she changed her College um her career goals uh to be in education so um and she you know wants to make sure all students are seen and heard uh have the tools

324and resources necessary to uplift the student voices I think that's all really positive and I think um having someone grown up or lived in that environment is brings a special um unique perspective to the board as well um and you're right I I think Renda has um the knowledge uh that we also can use on the board too so it's uh it's a tough decision um yeah we'll have to see after Lizzy makes her comments what we think um I think one of the main things I've been thinking about comparing these is when I think about the role of a school the role of our school in our school district is to educate our students and provide them a quality education that gets us from a young age into becoming fully functioning adults back in

325our community um and I think there's definitely the important side of that that we need to be providing for all of the different students under our care with different diversity and programs that are specific to them but I also think that we really need the knowledge and the experience and the information and background that helps us to move forward in what we're doing and make sure that we're maintaining that priority um and so even though I didn't get to vote um I believe that Brenda is the candidate that will allow us to move forward and do that um I agree with you guys 100% that I really like the fresh Outlook that Britney would be able to bring to our district but I also think that we need that experience we need somebody who is

326well versed in what has happened in the district um and who has that true dedication to all of our students and to being here not for her own personal gain at all not that I'm saying that Bren Britney is but Brenda very specific she's retired already she is here just for the student use um to be able to help the students um and so I think that's very significant so that's my two cents thank you for your feedback um so do you guys need to have more discussion what do we have any thoughts um I mean do you guys think we can make a decision do more discussion or what do you any let someone else talk to just a second just wait a second any other thoughts I think we could probably talk about

327it all night and we have right um well it's it's is it really 11:30 oh my gosh okay sorry okay you jinxed us but okay so um yeah so if we think there's um we have enough information for a motion do I have a motion from somebody um I make a motion to nominate Britney to the uh open seat for district three or area three sorry I'll second I won't ask for the student vote because I yeah um so all in favor I I I I uh congratulations Brit [Applause] me so we still need to do oath of office so Britney do not leave I would have tyed it you said yes no we could have kept talking and no congratulations to Britney Ayala and again thank you to everyone who applied okay we need

328to finish the meeting on yes okay so um thank you and congratulations to Britney and a thank you to everyone who applied president buger would you please administer the oath of office off to our newest board member Joe do you have a mic raise your right hand and repeat after me I Britney aala I Britney AA do solemnly swear do solemnly swear that I will support and defend that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States the Constitution of the United States against all enemies foreign and domestic against all enemies foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith and allegiance that I will bear a true faith in allegiance to the Constitution of the United States to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California

329and the constitution of the State of California that I take this obligation freely that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion or purpose of evasion and that I will well and faithfully and that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties discharge the duties upon which I'm about to enter about which I'm about to enter congratulations Britney come come sit here your seat I know we need sign yep need sign we okay we don't need any more additional comments from the public um so we can start with comments from um we'll start with you Lizzie well I'll make it short because I still have homework to finish but um first of all I just wanted to say to superintendent rossie I'm very thankful that you're

330not gone yet because I get enjoy getting to work with you and I will enjoy that for the rest of my time here in this position as well um and also Welcome to our brand new board member I look forward to getting to work with you and seeing how your perspective works out in our district do you have anything you want to say just really happy to be here and thank you to the community that entrusted me um and seeing my vision and contribution to this board and I just can't wait to to get the ball rolling and and see where it goes from here so thank you so much all right um welcome and I want to say to Helen I I'll have a lot more to say later but um just right now

331I'm I'm sad for us but happy for you um you definitely have earned retirement and I hope you enjoy it oh I will thank you um and yeah it's been a long meeting I won't belabor it um thank you to everybody that hung out I know it was a tough meeting for a lot of reasons um I don't know if I'm going to go home and go to sleep or what but it's going to be hard to wind down from this but um I I do want to say that um we do have a lot of people in our community right now that are really scared and we have a lot of students that are really scared and um I I know we have our this not this board but our board passed a resolution

332in 2017 a safe haven resolution there have been quite a few um changes especially to immigration policy in the last couple of weeks and I would really like us to revisit that resolution and perhaps look at how we can Beef It Up and um reassure as our community that they are safe coming school and that we will stand up for them when we need to uh I agree that we you know that work that was done before need to be Revisited and you know make sure that families feel reassured that we're doing everything that we can uh and again I just want to thank Brenda uh for putting herself out there again been in the position and it's difficult but um I'm excited to see that even though she's retired that she was still willing

333to come back and put herself out there and really fight for the district as a whole and the community um and then Helen you're gon be greatly missed we got you for a long time and I won't feel bad now that I call you and try to schedule meetings to get clarification on stuff welcome to Britney I am really excited to be able to work with you and um I know you're going to bring a lot of passion I've seen that um in the very short time I've known you I've seen a lot of passion so I know that you will bring great things to our district and I think everything else that we could possibly say has been said tonight yeah welcome Brittney and glad to have you here and I did want to

334say um Happy Chinese New Year I think people are probably celebrating that I think it's tomorrow so this is like their Christmas Eve or New Year's Eve um and Helen we will miss you and I know you'll enjoy your retirement because um when your grandson says at 14 that he wants to spend more time with you that's pretty amazing it's little scary that's awesome I just spent three days with him and he didn't have two words to say I don't know but um thank you and welcome Britney and thank you for accepting my my paperwork and um I did just you know um all the sites rest assured all the sites have the appropriate paperwork and and the cheat sheets and so on and so forth about what to do in case um anything happens

335at a site in terms of um immigration and as I told the board I will be attending um workshops over the next not tomorrow I think tomorrow is Tuesday Wednesday and Thursday and um looking at updating um our 2017 resolution but I also um gosh I'm so tired I can't remember what I'm saying my niece's wedding was this weekend unfortunately it was on a on a ship in the middle of the ocean between Mexico and the United States and I flew in this morning and um I'm tired and it is what it is but anyway that's just whining it's um so anyway um I am going to update that and and I've had lengthy conversations with Patty and from Los hunus and we have a plan in place for a um for a a meeting

336and uh more information and to talk with our our parent community in at the in the lentus area so I will check in with her uh tomorrow morning and see where we are in our planning process so um that being said everybody go home and get some sleep please I'll see you in the morning so it is 11:39 and we are adjourned for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.