001e e e we're calling we're calling the regular meeting of the board of education for January 13 2025 to order we're going to be going into closed session do we have any public comments regarding closed session no okay then we will adjourn to close session e e e okay so we're reconvening for the regular board meeting um I do have some couple of items to report out from Clos session in Clos session the board reviewed and discussed the liability claim claimant goshaw versus Martinez Unified School District the board voted to reject the claim by the following motion was made by by Annie hork Martin and it was seconded by Courtney um so Marcel O'Brien how do you vote Yes okay yes so yes you rejected so you said I yeah we're doing a roll call
002because um we have a board member on the phone so we have to roll call everything um Logan Campbell trusty C okay uh trusty horic Martin I and myself I so that motion passes okay um then we have what we heard him yes he answered okay in closed session the board considered the recommendation to approve expulsion of student 24-25 05 is there a motion [Music] do we have a second I'll second okay and then um R call Marcel O'Brien trusty trusty horic Martin hi trusty Campbell I and then myself trusty buger I and we have in Clos session the board considered the recommendation to approve the suspended stipulated expulsion of student 24- 45-06 is there a motion thank you seconded second thank you and then trusty Marcela O'Brien trusty horic Martin I trust trusty Campbell
003I and then trusty buer I so that passes as well okay now it's time for the Pledge of Allegiance Lizzie do you want to start us IED Al flag United States [Music] next item is approval of the agenda do we have any changes yes on item 16.2 um two attachments were um added to that agenda item and both are in the back of the um boardroom on on the credenza towards the left and there is a copy on the um in front of each trustee thank you do we have a motion for that I'll make a motion to approve the agenda thank you with the two additions on 16.2 perfect and then do we have a seconded okay um uh student representative mcau what's your vote I Marcela O'Brien truste um horic Martin I trustee
004Campbell I myself I motion pass or agenda is approved all right and now we have comments from the student representative good evening everybody it's great to be back um Los hunus Elementary staff was treated to a wonderful holiday lunch before the break provided by our fabulous PTA thank you to Los hunus Elementary PTA for all the love and support students had a wonderful time being visited by the Grinch and Max on Friday December TW 20th thank you to our staff for making this possible fifth graders enjoyed making their fifth grade tiles before break Los hunus Elementary PTA meeting will be on Tuesday January 14th at 5:30 p.m. Los hunus Elementary School site council meeting will be on Thursday January 16th at 3 p.m. please also support the lunus elementary dine and donate this Saturday January
00518th at Red Robin thank you Don Mir Elementary is excited for our after school enrichment classes coming students will experience robotics Glee Club singing and dancing and Mathnasium mystery readers have been reading stories to Mrs Harrington's class the identity of their mystery reader remains a mystery to all students Mrs Harrington emails her volunteers and ask them for four clues about themselves to read to the class before they arrive they see if they can figure out who their mystery reader is it can be a parent Aunt Uncle grandparent Etc this is a fun and engaging activity for our Kinders John Mir Elementary celebrates the character trait responsibility for the month of January our assembly comprises reteaching our school experience our school expectations be safe be responsible and be kind John Elementary's PTA movie night will be
006on Friday January 24th the martinus junior high school music tour for fifth graders will be also on January 24th at John SWAT elementary students were excited on campus to be back from the winter break fifth grade students had Hands-On experiences with making bread and cookies from scratch fourth graders have been experimenting with power sources for Motors the librarian MEF sponsored stee event will be on Wednesday the 15th from 3:30 to 4:30 the fifth grade field trip to the Lawrence Hall of Science will be on January 23rd at Mela Park Elementary right before winter break there was the annual second grade Winter concert students performed holiday songs from around the world on Monday January 13th there was a Mad Science assembly to get students excited to participate in the upcoming stem fair the music program has
007been continuing with its after school Gamblin Club students are excited to learn and play traditional indianan instrument the Milla Park Elementary PTA meeting will be on Tuesday January 14th at 6 p.m the coffee with the principal will be on Friday January 24th the Vigilant parent initiative Online safety presentation by Contra costed district attorney will be on Thursday January 30th at 6m at Martinez Junior High bullpups were welcomed back to the second half of the school year with quarterly class meetings they not only focused on reground Ing and daily expectations around safety behavior and academics but took some time to celebrate the achievements of the bullpups in the first half of the year a few of the notable areas of Celebration include honor roll bullpups of the month reduced tardiness and an increase of bullpups upholding
008expectations boys basketball has started with our first home games tomorrow at 4: 5 and 6:00 p.m. the elective course registration opens January 13th and will close on January 15th via AR the School site council meeting will be Tuesday January 14th at 3:15 the PTSA meeting will be on Tuesday January 2st at 7 p.m. the elac meeting will be on Friday January 31st at 8:45 a.m. at alhamra high school it was exciting to welcome everyone back last week on Friday we held meetings with all of our grade levels to discuss the course selection process for students in grades 9 through 11 and completing the federal financial aid application and other post-secondary planning with seniors students started selecting their courses for next year using the academic planner in Aries the Ed Trust West Equity review is underway
009we held our second Community session last Thursday and received great feedback to take back to the committee who will meet for the final time tomorrow students in Grade 9 through 11 will meet oneon-one with their counselors to go over the course selection if students did not have an opportunity to attend their selection this weekend the counselors will help them over the next two weeks there's a club fair this Friday during lunch there are also two parent committee meetings on January 23rd the elac meeting will be from 3:00 to 4: in the library and the School site council meeting will be from 4:00 to 5: virtually please join at the end of the first semester viente had five hardworking students who graduated early and are on their way to the workforce and DVC viente also had
010four students who reached their goal of catching up on credits and returning to alhamra for the second semester of their senior year year and graduating with their class Rion had seven early graduates who will all be attending DBC in the spring one of our current Bion students started a teen book club which is offered to both bionis and bente students the book club will meet on the first Wednesday of each month at 4M at the Martinez Public Library the second semester started great for both schools and we continue to enroll students daily please take a minute to look at our bulletin board in the back of the boardroom where teachers are excited to share students work from martinus adult education welcome back to all students after several weeks off for winter break evening classes resumed
011on Tuesday January 7th and all classes on Wednesday January 8th January 7th teachers and staff participated in CPR training and earned their AMR CPR certification our new electronic outside sign was also installed January 22nd at 3:30 on Zoom is our next Optical assistant training program orientation we will have several employers including warie Parker and Costco Optical providing information on careers as dispensing options finally as students are submitting course requests for the next school year I have a challenge for our staff I would like you to look for a yes first answer there are always opportunities to find Creative Solutions to abnormal problems and situations we want our students to look at the world and see the possibilities I would like the staff to model this for our students people often ask me why I am
012the way that I am one of the reasons is because I was taught to look for the possibility and find the opportunity rather than see the walls so please give a yes and Inspire our students before giving the discouraging no thank you thank you very much anything else you want to add no that's it okay great thank you okay do we have any employee organization reports so do we have any comments from the PTA nope okay um so we have correspondents yes we had um correspondence um in regards to the Martinez adult education school um program so they had their midcycle wasque visits uh in December and I think Tanya you were there and Annie you were there um we went and we listened and learned more about the adult school and the team that
013was visiting they were pretty thorough and they asked a lot of questions and we had a really good lunch and um there was a lot of input and a lot of takeaways but um they did indeed meet the criteria for their accreditation and they were reaffirmed um through the end of their current ACC accreditation cycle through June of 2028 so good job Martinez adult school and and um keep up the good work so and they do do good work I think we have our first um um meeting about uh looking at uh a new facility coming up real soon in the next in February I think beginning of February so exciting exciting time for them perfect thank you um next we have uh staff reports superintendent Rossy shuffle through my papers um as I'm sure
014most of you know we and are aware we have a board vacancy in trust trustee Area 3 and we're looking for candidates to fill this seat by provisional appointment the application deadline is January 17th which is this Friday at 4M completed applications can be emailed to me at H Rossy martinez. k12.ca.us that short little email that we have going around the District but hard copies must be signed and handed in or mailed to the district office here at 921 Susanna for anyone who lives in Area 3 who is interested in becoming involved in determining the policies that Define the operations of this school district this is the way to do it please contact me as soon as possible for more information we will be selecting the new board member on Monday January 27th I also
015want to take moment to let the many many people down south who are suffering in some way whether it be to due to loss of family members loss of Home loss of pets or just living in fear due to the horrific fires that have been devastating the LA communities that the thoughts and prayers of those here in the Martinez District are with them at all times keep them safe thank you very much that was very nice okay now the favorite session of everyone is public comments under government code 5495 4.3 members of the public have the right to address the board on any matter within the board's jurisdiction however the board may not take action on any non-agenda item individual speakers will be allowed three minutes to address the board 20 minutes have been allocated
016for this portion of the agenda additional time is allowed at the end of the meeting if there's not enough time to speak during public comments we have a couple comments first we have uh Paula [Music] McColly at the last Schoolboard meeting something happened that has given me pause to think that I want to bring to your attention part four since June I have noticed an aggressive use of the word transparency in dialogues at board meetings mainly it is the complaint or Applause of some ACT being transparent I've been bothered by this dialogue and after this last board meeting I understand why transparency has become a buzzword in the political world used to give people a pat on the back but transparency without accountability is meaningless even then what we really want is transparency accountability and
017integrity let me demonstrate I have a puzzle here for you to put together transparency is showing you the picture the details of the task I'm giving you and letting you know the number of pieces so that you can gauge the effort I have disclosed all the information to you accountability is having done my due diligence to check that all the pieces are in the box and the puzzle is as it says it is I've already told you the details being transparent it is the behind the-scenes checking to confirm what is being seen that is accountability Integrity is how I implement the task do I dump it on the floor and walk away do I provide proper time to complete the task or I did I hide that one piece to make me look good we
018are in a bid for a new school board member right now this seat was vacated in an act of transparency we all knew it could happen accountability could be questioned as the process is investigated but Integrity is where our district is feeling the effects someone made a claim to our voters two years ago that they would Faithfully serve in this office for four years and didn't do it this is a problem with integrity happens and we as a district are paying for it in the last school board meeting our finances were reviewed as they have been by Mr Andy Cannon we receive updates all the time about what's happening with our finances this is transparency we had an audit performed to check on the accuracy of our accounting this is accountability the Integrity comes into
019play when Mr Canon accepts direct questions from people which I have posed to him again and again and he is open and responsive and answers them and stands by his work he continues to respond with Integrity the cry for transparency from our district is a misnomer the information people are looking for is readily available everything is posted on our district websites or can be easily asked for I understand that the idea that people want transparency but I want to point out tonight that our District staff are performing beyond the step of transparency they give us accountability and integrity in their work when we as parents are willing to ask and get involved we can easily see there is integrity but it takes us investing to look at the other side of the dice and to
020be willing to not just stand and point to a problem but get involved to see it so tonight I say thank you for your integrity the next speaker we have is Conrad Dandridge evening board and Martinez Unified School District staff I'm here to bring to your attention Black History Month this year's Black History Month is significant for a couple of reasons one it's the 99th Black History Month next year will be 100 but it's also the first black history month after the publication from the California Commission on reparations which I imagine most of you have not read it is an expansive three-year examination into the treatment of BLS in California it covers areas such as education and law but a question I run into over the last 30 years of speaking on black history is
021why February so let me answer that question Carter Woodson who Dr Carter Woodson who created negro history month did so in February simply because of the birthdays of Abraham Lincoln and Frederick Douglas he stated that these two Americans were important to Black Americans and he wanted to create an organization that would study history and provide Research into the contributions of black Americans throughout American history I am not a black nationalist I'm an American I'm not an African American I'm an American and blacks have contributed to American history since that ful day in Boston in 1773 where christas adex was one of the first Patriots to fall and continues to say black history is super important is important for every group of people in this country men women people of color this I'm lucky to participate
022in the workshops and the Dei committee here but I'm scared and worried about what we're not doing to our students your systematic review says black students are at the bottom of the pile and I hear stories about Latinos gay and bisexual students but if we solve the problems for black students we solve the problems for all let me ask you a few questions do you know who invented the stoplight who performed the first open heart surgery or who created blood plasma which saves millions of people's lives every year they were black Americans this year's theme for black history is African-Americans in labor they involve important people as Addie Wyatt and A Philip Randol who were responsible for the creation of the Brotherhood of sleeping car Porters and mids and also involves Martin Luther King we
023all celebrate his I Have a Dream speech but do we realize that I Have a Dream speech was addressing issues of economic inequality today we must focus on History because we have to have some type of foundation to move forward especially in the world that we're living in I implore you to take an active role in ensuring that the students K through 12 get a balanced view of History which includes block history thank you thank you next up we have the consent calendar and since Carlos isn't here I just want to acknowledge the donation from the Martinez Yacht Club um for $2,375 gift cards which is very nice um anyone want to make a motion any public comment on that oh yeah I'm sorry changes there are no changes to the consent count great wonderful
024I'll move to approve the consent calendar I'll second okay um back to roll call let's see um My Little cheat sheet out okay uh trusty Marcel O'Brien for the consent calendar yes yeah okay oh I'm sorry I we should have done student representative Lizzie mccol yes thank you I'm thrown off with this roll call for everything um Annie horic Martin hi trusty Campbell I and myself I I didn't ask for any public comments okay no public comments on that all right so motion approved I don't need to okay okay I did okay great moving right along okay so now we're on to discussion items strategies for a balanced budget and D Canon good evening board I'll let uh Joe get this up we are in that time of year again where we're g to begin
025looking at budget and some of you may we say we always look at budget but that could be true uh we spend an inordinate amount of time looking at finances because not because they're the most interesting or that people want to hear it all the time but they are extremely imp act ful because these dollars and how we organize them our revenues and our expenditures are what makes sure that we can provide for programs and experiences for all of our students throughout the school district and um so many of our staff rely upon it for their wages and for their ability to live in the community and to provide for their own children families um tonight this presentation is not the second interim report um that will occur in March um it's also not a
026budget reduction presentation although we are going to talk about what budget reductions would mean for this school district and the potential need for them but we're not going to get into the details of layoffs or those pieces yet we're going to kind of Hit the surface of it um any reductions that we may need to do for fiscal solvency will be brought to this board on January 27 so that will be the more nuts and bolts about what we would need to be able to reduce in order to maintain fiscal solvency over the next couple of years but we what I want to do tonight is I want to raise awareness of what our current Financial reality is and I also want to amplify our needs to discuss what is the academic programming um and
027how do we prioritize some of our goals and ideas that we have through the elcap through other plans um and also how do we make sure that we maintain strong sapping and compensation for um our members so the focus here is again we're going to look at the current budget status we're going to talk a little bit about balancing the budget specifically around what is our deficit spending what does that mean for the district we're going to look at a process for Budget reductions and also talk uh to a small degree about what the board's role is in all of [Music] this this slide shows a little bit about our reality right now and I'm hoping that there's nothing new here I think that I have spoken on these topics a lot but I am
028going to continue to repeat them because they are what's driving many of our decisions going forward and again that is declining Revenue because of enrollment and Ada as our funded Ada has declined because of enrollment losses here um we do see that we don't get as much revenue funds that can pay for these services that we need U we've also talked at length about the expiration of one-time pandemic funds resources now many of you say like I'm tired of hearing about that the more I get to say that the more frequent I put it in the presentation means we still have money left from those pots so as much as we may want to move on from the pandemic because I think many of us feel that way we want to maximize those dollars as
029much as we can for as long as we can special education is not a villain but sometimes it's looked it this way the reason why it's in this presentation is not because we we disagree with um the program in fact we think it's very positive and it's necessary for our kids but we always want to be that it has a large cost associated with it and I'm going to talk a little bit more about kind of the federal government's role in special education in future slides um health care is all of us have kind of witness it continues to go up this District um through negotiations continues to maintain that um uh a cost amount for our employees and any increase in it is the burden of the district um to pay for and that's
030great for our employees but it does have a dramatic impact on our finances um and then lastly salary increases every year bargaining units want to talk about salary increases and make proposals and some point throughout the year we negotiate on a settlement um but those salary increases do have a again another dramatic impact on what our budget is so when we look at overall with any budget we talk about revenue and we talk about expenditures if we just want to keep it simple those are the things that we look at and the first part today with looking at revenues um we further want to break that down into unrestricted versus restricted so the data that you see in front of you is for un audited actuals from 2223 and 2324 that means what did we
031actually do for those years so in Revenue you're going to see this nice sharp upward trend from 2223 fiscal year to 23 for and that is reflective of cola um being really substantial as you look for the 2425 year right now you're going to see a huge drop in our Revenue we have less revenue for this year and this isn't unrestricted only than we did for 2223 we see a loss there so when folks are going to start looking at our budget and you kind of get this overall sense that you have a 1% Cola you have 1% Cola doesn't that mean that you have more money and the answer is maybe in this situation the 1% Cola is not enough to offset against declining enrollment and in fact if you look out for another
032couple of years it's not until 2026 27 that we are at the same rate that we were for 23 24 with Revenue that means that the next two years are less Revenue than we had before but yet we have lots of staff we have lots of programs we have lots of Cost needs so much of our um issue with balancing the budget with not having um the ample reserves that we once did is because of these two years and the drop that's occurring so let's turn the turn to the other side of this slide restricted Revenue in 2223 was the last real positive year the extra year of getting one-time funds once we receive those we may still have a sizable amount sitting in the bank but you'll see that our Revenue drifts down so
033you have this downward Trend in restricted Revenue which makes perfect sense it's something that we've described in various meetings um over the last year or two um but it does have an impact on what we're going to be seeing throughout the rest of this budget cycle we're going to continue to look at charts it's the reason for all the with the multitude of charts is because I want to continue to present this in so many different ways that the audience and the board can see um maybe something sticks out for them there may be one slide that really makes it you know kind of known to them and it might be another slide for another board member Community but I want to give lots of different visuals here to kind of support um what the
034position is in the budget this slide is going to show the structural deficit so if you go all the way to the right between the blue line and the black line that's there the gap between there is the structural deficit why is it a structural deficit is because you see for more than one year so from 2526 to 2627 you see a continual overspending that we're projecting to have it hasn't happened yet those are future years but based on our current trajectory we will have a structural deficit which means that we are continuing to draw from our reserves to be able to pay for um all our needs here now that wasn't always the case if you look at 2223 and 2324 you see that that black line is above that we were actually growing
035our Reserve at that point in time and it's just this year again going back to what we saw in Revenue that is starting to show that trend of deficit spending you could have um significant changes in the state budget over the next couple of years Super colas can come in and it could change this trend you can also change this trend by reducing expenditures or a combination of both and we'll talk about what that looks like in future slides but for right now know that um we have an ongoing deficit that we need to address this is chart is going to look at the deficit but it's going to look at it from the vantage point of our ending balance our minimum reserve and excess reserves so starting at the bottom you would take your
036ending reserve of $5.3 million you said subtract what we are legally required to do our 3% minimum reserve for unrestricted fund of almost 1.8 and that means at the end of the 2223 school year we had about $3.5 million excess reserves that we can choose as a district how we spend it on most of the time when districts have excess reserves they look down the road and say we anticipate structural deficits or we have other spending money want to do they may assign it to that or they may just leave it in the excess Reserve continuing on what I said in the last slide we said that we increased our Reserve or excess reserve and that can be seen second or third column for 2324 um we begin the year with $7 million we had
037a reserve of 1.9 almost and then the excess was 5.3 but now as we get to this year and we look for future years you're going to see that excess Reserve decline dramatically to the point that in 2627 and this is the same thing that I presented during first interim we will have I mean less than $20,000 above our minimum Reserve based on our current budget over the next three years so I want to say this and because it does become important as we talk about Cola the cola projections of 1% this year of 2.9% next year and 3.09 the following year is not enough to prevent us from going into the negative in 2728 so again Cola projections are inadequate for the level of spending that we are currently doing special education does have
038um an impact on our unrestricted general fund why is that well many years ago when the federal government went back and reauthorized Ida they said that they were going to be spending or contributing about 40% towards everybody's special education so on average if the state of Califoria spent a million dollars on special education they were going to contribute 40% we clearly spend more than that in the billions if you look at just our small little snapshot the federal contribution for us is nowhere near 40% it's just 6% our state and local funding makes up about 30% and part of that is actually increase from what we've done the previous years because the state used some excess dollars to give a reimbursement of 60% of our trans Transportation costs so for every $100 that we spend
039on Transportation the state in the next year will give us back 60 um then we have our contribution 65% of the costs that we have to spend to pay for our special education program come out of the general fund that's not to say that it's negative or that it's not used well it's simply to say that it is an expenditure and it's a large one it's one of the largest we have the only thing that's larger as a whole entity to claim would be our staffing cost but overall for special education we have a $14 million budget so I alluded to this employee salaries are our largest expense and within that um when you look at Health and Welfare again as a district we contribute um I think all but for family about $184 So
040a family um coverage for a teacher or classified staff or management um only have to contribute $184 each month out of their pocket to pay for the healths and Welfare and each year as those costs go up they continue to pay that same out there isn't additional cost to the staff members so when you look across this chart over time you'll see classified Health and Welfare and certificated Health and Welfare and at the bottom you'll notice that they've gone up significantly so 36% increase from 201819 for certificated and almost 6 % increase for classified um those cost over time as you look across the whole which include cash and L so this is when a staff member H maybe has coverage through a spouse or other family member they choose not to take U benefits
041through us they get up to $3,600 a year so you'll see that even with the growth and and cost for certificated cash andl because people take that option we are still looking at a 40.4% increase that's from the year 201819 Total Health and Welfare to what we project for this year and all that's to say is something that you probably have already known and having General conversations at different times is that is the cost of Health Care is really high it's it's expensive it's something that we are proud to do for our staff but it has a cost that goes with it and that yearly cost you can see in the last column where you can see the up and down movement where our largest increase was from 2223 we had a 14% increase in
042the annual change now what this doesn't say is it doesn't say when we've had to do layoffs over the past few years um so this doesn't include any amount that we lost because of you know 10 or 12 or 15 FTE that are lost through here now correspondingly if you look at salary increases you also see that that weighs things down this district has been extremely generous in passing dollars that the state or the federal government give um through our revenue and then valuing people and our staffs to be able to give a 20 what is that a 25% raise in the last three years or since 1819 a total of a 31% cumulative raise so when you look at salary increases Health and Welfare increases of 40% over that same time frame you'll see
043that we have we have pass through a lot of those extra Revenue dollars onto our staff but it has a great cost um and that's Cola of of you know going back to just a couple years ago 133% 8% and then this year 1% we can increase Revenue right we don't always have to reduce expenditures but increasing revenue is a little bit hard in school districts we don't sell a product we provide a service because we don't sell a product we can't change those rates the state sets them for this and so what we can do is we can try um with our best efforts to increase enrollment and we can increase um the kids who are in their seats every day and that's how we ultimately get funded is through that ADA average daily
044attendance so if we were right if if parents were sending kids to school and mind you we don't want kids going to school and they're sick but if kids did not miss um days for arbitrary things if vacations were not done during the school year um if we had uh a real good push to increase 1% in our Ada over the next three years we could increase our Revenue by $760,000 um and that's that's not an insignificant amount of money um to put it in perspective of what a raise is this year a 1% raise districtwide is about $380,000 so this is if it was just passed along to staff it could be almost a 2% raise um other ways for us to increase Revenue Vue and I think we've done a great job about
045opening up our facilities to the public through rentals um using our facilitron app and also taking um different property we have in renting it out to different groups so right now Dutch Bros is paying about $48,000 a year to rent that facility on alhamra Avenue Woodbridge our after school Child Care Program that's not the districts we just rent out to them that's about $25,000 a year um building connections which is a non-public school which is taking place across the street in our old lower campus that's about $75,000 a year we are going to be renting out the old lasus Administration office to our our County Special Education group U for $64,000 and we've increased our short-term facility use so these are the fields the gyms the theaters and we're looking at about $200,000 a year
046in facility rentals all of that going into the general fund to help to be able to to pay for these programs that we have for kids and then also our partial tax right now we have an eight-year term we've got seven years remaining because the tax payers um back in March um voted in favor of that and that gives us about $780,000 a year usually in these conversations um folks start saying well how about we go after grants grants are always a possibility to bring dollars in generally speaking grants are restricted they're for specific purposes and they carry a lot of strings with it there's a lot of administrative oversight that takes place there's a lot of data points that come through these can be really good and valuable sometimes they're so small and I
047don't want to disparage a 100 or $200,000 Grant sometimes you have to put in so much time and energy into those and contribute other dollars to it they sometimes are not worth what they seem to be but that's not to say that we don't go out and look for those those are always a possibility I think when you're doing this you have to be very um cautious about what the requirements are for that Grant when we look out I know recently superintendent Rossy has gone out and really worked hard bringing in some outside grants that are great because they already fit into what we do which is working on Mental Health Services for our students so they're not burdensome and separate they are integral and part of the whole process and those are some of
048the things that we can look at as we go forward when we look at the whole big picture of course we want to raise revenue most of the time the actions that we take to be able to balance a budget is through reductions and when we look at reductions this chart's going to show us where our dollars are spent the majority of it almost 80% is in Staffing 18% is in service and other operating expenses uh many of our special education contracts are in there Insurance um utilities um 3% is materials and supplies 1% is another outgo and that is synonymous with County tuition for special education so that 1% is really same as that the contract to the Blue Area there um what's not represented here in that 78% is we have several special
049education vacancies that are out there between sped teachers uh speech and language psychologist and that fits into that 18% but truly we are we are over 80% when it comes to Staffing to drill down a bit more into what that looks like um this chart shows our overall overall Personnel costs for um the current U budget year 2425 and just out of fundo one so it excludes cafeteria it excludes Bond um and what you notice here is that um you know almost 70% of our costs are for certificated 20% classified and 11% for management and you'll notice there that management says 21 and the next slide it's going to say 23 and that's because as we get to it I use the next slide because I want to give an overall kind of viewpoint of
050how has our staffing changed as a condition of what our enrollment is so when you look there the 23 I put all administrators in there because you'd have a really weird Trend because what we reported in the past was everybody together so that's the discrepancy if you look at it going to the top of that chart in 1920 we had over 4,000 students we have declined by 9% since that Chim um our enrollment numbers are very positive um at 3780 and we actually may be pushing up over the 3,800 Mark um so that's positive that doesn't include all of our NPS right now um but we do see a decline there we see a similar decline in our certificated FTE so over the same time period we've seen a 99.4% drop in that classified a
051much smaller drop only 2% and management 8% so what does this mean that means that the board over the years with District staff have really tried to work at how do we provide when we look at possible reductions how do we make sure that not one group is carrying a heavier burden necessarily than the other so it's looking at this kind of whole across theboard Spectrum from bargaining units and it is reasonably close when you look at those figures so it's been kind of prepping towards budget reductions and again this isn't the budget reduction presentation but budget reductions are a tool in which you can use to to reduce deficit spending and to balance that budget um there's various different ways um to do this attrition is one as you have um retirements um that's
052a great way to be able to reduce the budget that has a lower impact on Staffing but there are times when the results of enrollment declines and other factors means that you actually have to go through a layoff process um and that's when increasing revenue is either insufficient to cover it like a 1% Cola is not sufficient to cover our our cost or it's unfeasible there's just not other Revenue to get grants are not enough rental income is not enough to do that um but again tonight the board is not being asked to make reductions or approve any reductions but it is to kind of start setting um the table for what would happen if we did and the next slide this belief and assumption slide is something I will bring back next time but
053I want to introduce it more than once and so when we look at these things we need to talk about like why do we do this and when we do what's on our mind what are we thinking and we know that every reduction has an impact because it has some kind of um connection to Student Learning we don't want to do any of these things and there are many programs that people feel really closely aligned to they don't want to see them go away um any item that's not listed here is based is not based on the value of the individuals or the programs um it's not this is not a way to do discipline or to pick out people you don't like or you do like for favoritism and then we know that without
054F reductions we will not meet our reserves in the next few years specifically 27 28 so we have to focus on certain things and this is something that the board has approved in the last couple of years is first is to minimize the impact on the classroom secondly is to maintain safe schools thirdly is to have budget flexibility meaning we need to and in my office specifically has to look at everything to make sure that there's no hidden dollars somewhere there's no money that may be Sav for a program that we weren't going to do we've got to scrub the budget really tightly before we come to the board with um reduction proposals and then um this was the last one counseling was um one of the main priorities of the board over the last
055couple years so to the extent possible maintaining those Services as we look to what a budget reduction timeline might be um we've already started to look at things in December and talked about priorities and starting Gathering list um we continue to do that through January and start making that list of potential reductions um and then today as part of that process is to explain the need for those um changes and then following up as we get to February we would have a public board meeting where we would ask the board um to approve the reductions for the um for this year and then specifically for the next couple of years so what do those reductions need to be if we did not increase any Revenue today what are we looking at so overall for the
0562526 year 256 Year we're looking for about 750 $50,000 in non- Staffing this is taking advantage of um reducing our textbook and supplemental curriculum budget reducing some of our contracted special education services reducing site budgets um other grants that we have in other contracted Services it's looking at potentially $1 million in a decrease in Staffing some of this is from um declining enrollment um it could be looked at at Furlow days we could look at each bargaining unit losing FTE and it would continue into the 2627 fiscal year I'm looking at non- Staffing of about a half million dollars Staffing between 500 and 1 million um we know that we need to be somewhere between one and $1.5 million to reduce that deficit spending um but we have some time to figure out what that's
057going to be so right now what are we not looking to cut um as we move forward with the idea of budget reductions um LVN Medical Services um this has been a conversation in the past and we do need to have a level of service especially for some of our more medically fragile students so that is not um right now being proposed for reduction and you won't see that next week Mental Health Services we are looking at ways to continue that again superintendent Rossy has been working really hard at finding additional funding that can supplement what our current services are and our teachers on special assignment around curriculum and other support um we have enough of one-time funds to continue moving forward with that but we would look at partial reductions or even full reductions
058over the next couple of years so as we conclude um we do need to maintain fiscal solcy um we do have to do some level of reductions or increase Revenue right now that deficit spending is looming large um additional reductions if you want to get to the point where we balance the budget because these projections aren't we would have to cut approximately $2 million next year total um and addition to what we already are looking at looking ahead to that timeline just to be more specific um what we're thinking is that January 27th we would have the Board review a reduction proposal by February 10th the board would potentially adopt that reduction proposal then on February 24th there would be a resolution and that resolution would go specifically into what positions and what spending would
059be reduced so we've got um we've got some heavy lifting to do and um and those are the dates that you have forward and so at the end of this I'm open to any questions that you may have about what we've discussed tonight thank you Andy for the um realistic View and I know you don't like to have to get these reports out it's not fun but um we appreciate um all the honesty in it um I did have a question actually not really a question but a suggestion just for you talk about um on one of your slides employee salaries um plus Health and Welfare and you have salary increase and you have the Health and Welfare cost is there a way to add a column in there that just shows what the cola
060was in those years I'm just kind of curious um to see how closely that was aligned and also um in your projections you said um a 2.9 Cola and I think it's been revised to 2.43 are you gonna update that in the future or you're just sticking with the 2.9 because that was the most well this becomes that really awkward point because the governor has expressed something out Cola still needs multiple um economic indicators to come out before we adjust that so at this point we kind of what we had started with knowing there's a potential for loss so we kind of play that in between range um as we get closer to May we'll what that actual Cola amount is so the the hard answer is yes and yes right the the the best
061answer I can give you is we kind of play that within what our budget reductions are going to be now if we don't propose enough this year that would mean that the following year we would have to reduce a little bit more so we have a little bit of flexibility in how we um how we deal with that at the same time um we are optimistic about what the governor put out that onetime dollars could be coming forward we don't know how much and a small increase to our TK um allotment may be able to help us out as well so the the hope is of that the new money coming in even if it's one time may be able to offset the the drop and poola great thank you um any questions um I
062have one for Staffing reductions you have a 1.05 million I was wondering if you could give us I I know there's different ways in there that you were talking about that being applied but if you can give us a rough estimate of how many positions that would be yeah let me let me pull it up real quick um that's about nine positions but not some of them could be partial positions some could be full and again that's just tentative right now we're looking somewhere in the neighborhood of nine positions and it also some are classified some are certificated some have benefits some don't have benefits so it's really too hard to even say nine positions it's it's so loose out there because and everybody's someplace different on a pay scale so someone with less senority
063let's say a teacher with less seniority could be way up there on a pay scale now because we don't have a a cap on hiring where we used to hire and say you couldn't have more than 12 years experience so someone new would be a lower end of the pay scale now they could be all the way up to 25 years so it's hard to say how many positions that is so there's so many factors that go into it just to kind of picky back on that question I think i' unfortunately been through this we did it last year but um I think for the benefit of the public can you kind of explain that like we're doing this timeline in part because there are deadlines that we have to notify staff which I know
064and that's what March 15th is that the deadline um yes March 15th okay perfect um and then should we have a scenario where I don't know we have more K enrollment than we projected so now we have laid people off what would the process be if we have reduced these but now we have an increased need for Staffing based on our enrollment we would look at our um employees that were laid off first by credential to see if we could bring them back and resend those layoffs and the other thing that you don't say on that is that things can change um you could get 10 teachers retire and we may may not be looking at any layoffs so there a lot of things can happen between then and now um unfortunately it's we're in
065this uncomfortable space and we're not going to feel comfortable for a while there's going to be a lot of hard decisions that take place um and what I've known the last couple of years at least here is that we we start with a larger number and then as soon as we can bring folks back we've done so last year you noticed that through the partial tax it was unknown could we renew a partial tax and there were real people who were being paid out of that when the partial tax was renewed we were able to bring folks back um and I can't even imagine the uncertainty and the anxiety that that creates um for people um but it certainly is an enjoyable process when we as a staff can say we got that we can
066bring these folks back and what happens between the governor's budget in January and the May revise oftentimes is is a lot different so we we do the best we can but we have to work on the information that's given to us because it would be irresponsible if we did not so do you have any public comment fill out a comment card but yes afterwards you can do it afterwards those two whereas if we hired more internally for special education we would not have to contract out would we save money doing that or are we actually in a positive position because we actually contract some of those position out thank you for all the information all the work and all the openness that you do give to this district and all the funds because I appreciate
067Andy you go ahead and answer that go ahead that's fine you can it's multi-layered answer yeah but yes we always want to hire staff internally um and the only we have contracted staff in place is because we weren't able to hire District employees thank you very much okay the next is uh oh Amy English learner master plan Oh yay all right um good evening board members and superintendent Rossy uh tonight I am going to give an overview of the English learner master plan so the purpose of the English learner master plan it outlines the systems that are in place in every school within our district to ensure compliance with state and federal law background um this uh came into place when the California English learner road map from the California Department of Education uh came
068about which aligns four principles that guide our work to ensure access and achievement for our English learners The Guiding principles are here um one is assets based education schools and Educators Foster asset oriented environments grounded and sociocultural competence two rigorous academics for all students engage in academically rigorous learning that cultivates high achievement prioritizes bilingualism and biliteracy three is systematic support leaders and Educators provide systematic tiered support that includes datadriven assessment for continuous Improvement and ongoing capacity building for all teachers and staff and four is alignment and articulation programs Artic articulated and aligned across the students entire educational experiences and provide a coherent pathway and preparation for College and Career in the 21st century and I'd like you to note these guiding principles are throughout California and therefore are very Broad and are able to be
069implemented in a variety of districts with a variety of programs and so um our El um master plan will outlines how we have them within our system so the first um part of our plan go is an introduction overview this really shows California's vision of success for English Learners this is taken directly out of the California road map we also have a mission statement for English Learners um from the state of California and then I we reiterate the purpose of the English learner master plan and then we share District demographics the district demographics are in generic form and not are are not listed by year because then we would be updating this on a continuous basis because it would be out of date almost every day because we have new students coming in on a
070daily basis chapter one is goes through initial assessment and identification this um chapter outlines how we assess students and how they are determined an English language learner within the system and so we begin with the home language survey this is completed um at your initial enrollment within a California school then the initial English language proficiency assessments for Cali you might um hear these uh referred to as initial lpac that's just in in its full form there and then English learner student groups and then additional support for newcomers and so in this chapter we outline each of these areas and how we do these processes within Martinez UniFi chapter two goes through program options and access this is where we uh have outlined integrated and designated English language development instruction our Structured English immersion parent choice
071and language acquisition program options as well as our secondary English language development programs the reason we have so many um different options it might look like we have a lot of different programs but they are based on the grade level in which the student is enrolled and so it looks a little different at elementary school than it does at Middle School than it does at high school for chapter three uh quality instruction curriculum intellectual equality equality and meaningful access this is where we're talking about access to program within the school day the California English language development standards instructional materials that should be being used within the classrooms and then supporting our duly identified students and what duly identified students are our students who are special education students as well as English Learners in chapter four
072the annual assessment monitoring and support again this is where we share information around summative English language proficiency assessments for California so our summative elpac which we're getting ready to put in motion next month are we go again over initial lpac alternative lpac our alternative lpac is the process in which we um assess students that are duly identified so this would be the process where an individual education plan May outline a different process for identifying language proficiency for a special education student English learner records and cumulative folders and so this is the portion in which we monitor our English Learners how we transfer our records from one District to another and then our parent notification letters we have parent notification letters that go out um after each of our assessment periods in chapter five we talk
073about reclassification this is where we show our reclassification forms and followup alternative reclassification which again if you see the word alternative that's where we're talking about how we're supporting our special education students and then observation protocol for teachers of English Learners this is a new protocol which is um given an acronym it's called the optel and so um this is something that we are going I'm going to have yir bring back and go into in depth so that you guys can see this new process this is a new process throughout the state of California to streamline how we reclassify students throughout the entire state in chapter six we talk about our educational Partnerships so our advisory committees which include our English learn advisory Council and our district English learner advisory Council who were took part
074in supporting and um drafting the E master plan so I'd like to say thank you because one of them's in the audience tonight so thank you and then chapter seven um Staffing professional learning and capacity building Staffing and teacher authorization credentials go together this is how we retain and ensure that our teachers are um qualified to teach English Learners and then professional learning opportunities and then how this has an impact on our lcap which you see written out there our local control and accountability plan as well as our federal agendum immigration services and support is also included here what I'd like to say about our federal addendum and our lcap this is where we talk about how we have our our specific goals for our English Learners as well as how we're using specific money
075toward um the programs chapter eight is our program evaluation which is our data and assessment so looking tonight also be going over the dashboard so you'll hear a little bit about data but also looking at program Effectiveness through A needs assessment our daac and our elac will start A needs assessment this coming month so that as we rewrite and look at our lcap um in the next few months that we will be able to use that information and then our accountability and Federal Federal program monitoring as well and so again I'd like to say thank you to the daac and elac members that did support um the drafting of this document it took a lot of work um over the last few months to get it in place I do want to mention that this
076was an overview and there are a few areas in which I'm going to have yudira come back and do some more in-depth conversation one was the optel so the observation protocol the other is talking about professional development that we offer to our teachers or that will be being offered in the future to our teachers and then the third is our long-term English Learners which you're going to hear about in my next presentation as well any questions thank you very much um when you talk about professional development for this group are you talking about regular professional development or sending them away someplace for specialized training or it could be mixed but we do have the capacity within the district to be able to support professional development here sometimes it can be someone outside so if we're
077looking at like a new program or a change in curriculum then we're going to want to have someone from that publishing company or that has a a more specialized idea around that and that's part of your professional development that we have a couple times a year and you let the actual teachers choose which classes they want to attend yes so in March um we have the choice opportunity again like we did last March so the morning sessions will be Choice opportunities which will include English learner supports during that time frame we um one of our schools is still determining what they're going to do in the afternoon because the school sites will have their own choice in the afternoon from 1 to 3 o'clock and one of our schools uh it has been having conversations
078with our county office to come in and give some supports around English learner development I have heard that um people like the professional development more since you've had that choice in there but do you actually send out surveys and ask them for input on what classes they or what they want to hear I'm just curious I know it's not exactly tied to this but so last year yes that is what I did um we put I put out a Google form to get interest because I do want to ensure that anyone with capacity within our district is able to also facilitate some of these sessions that it's not all about oh I'm going to facilitate it or Andy's going to facilitate it or Janelle but it's about having uh a collective capacity to be able
079to do so um so for example Sarah she's not in here right now but Sarah put in this year to um to facilitate a session that is uh that Google form has gone out and then the second Google form that I send out is if I have people who want to do multiple sessions maybe around literacy I want to ensure that we have people attending the sessions and they're not four people in the room or so then I put out interest surveys showing what our topics are that I've received um facilitators for and that gives people an opportunity to kind of say what they gauge their interests a little bit better so you actually scheduled them so if they wanted to do stuff yes I I am I'm am very strategic around it and so
080for example special education I try to balance like okay if I was a special education teacher I'd want to do this hour this hour and this two hour or I might want to do these two hours and this and I try not I try to ensure that they complement each other and that people are able to make um choices that support maybe their varied needs because we have a variety of needs perfect thank you okay any other questions so for deac there were no students on this committee now yudira had been working on it during the last school year as as well and so she had worked with different groups than myself so only speaking from the group that I worked with I I don't know if she spoke to students but this would be
081a living document that we could modify um we put a date on it because we want to be able to ensure that we look back and say okay no this has changed or this requirements new and be able to modify it so we definitely can ensure that we can move forward and asking for student voice this is re this uh plan itself is really state and federal guidelines there isn't a lot of we don't we can't add a lot of extra or we're really kind of rigid in what is in the Pro in the plan yeah any other questions any public comment thank you very much and you're next again Martinez Unified School District dashboard yes now I have to turn my computer back on sorry I talked so long it's okay thanks okay all
082right on to the dashboard so um the 2024 dashboard um was published in December this school year and just to just to remind you and mention um this to you it will be P published next year in November and the following year in October so it'll continue to move up so this type of presentation will be able to move up as well and so you'll get this information earlier so just a reminder the dashboard is um here to provide parents and Educators with meaningful information um on school and District progress so that they can participate in decisions to improve student learning since the release so the dashboard in 2017 we've had different mix of indicators available each year and what I mean by that is if you remember last year we had some of the
083gauges that you see a picture there with a little pencil like a spedometer and then we've also had the status bars and so this year um we have moved all to the gauges with the exception of the new um indicator which I'll go over so 2024 has 12 measures of school Success um this is we have an additional measure this year which is science um science this year has no performance color but next year will so there is a grade out status bar it's not even a status bar and I and I took some screenshots so that you guys would be able to see it um and so that is part of a new state measure and then we have five local measures that are collected by the school district and so here they're listed
084for our state um we have academic performance chronic absenteeism College and Career Readiness English learner progress High School graduation rate suspension rate and then new you'll see is science and then our local continue to be the same which is our basic conditions implementation of our academic standards local climate surveys parent involvement and family engagement access to a broad course of study and so tonight I'll share um our U Martinez unified and then this year I've added in also some school level measures as well so they'll be in the coming slides so here is the California school dashboard for the school district you can see that we have gauges all the way across and you'll notice that there is not a science and so so like I said science is there but it would it's like
085gray out so you'll I'll give you an example when we get to that and so you can see that um the gauges are for our state measure and then standard met is listed underneath our um our local for academic performance we have two it is our English language arts and our mathematics these Majors show how well students are meeting grade level standards so we're this year we're yellow in both English language arts and Mathematics so diving a little deeper into the English language arts um you can see where're yellow which is 2.1 points above standard and we maintained 1.2 points there's an equity report section there below and the equity report is what you see and the six gauges to the right hand side of the main of the main gauge we have four um
086group student groups that are in the orange those are English Learners our long-term English Learners our social economically disadvantaged and students with disabilities I'd like to highlight long-term English Learners this is the first year that they are a student group and so this will be the first time that you have will see them on the dashboard and they will continue to be one of the student groups moving forward and then you can see there um no performance color that indicates that we had a low enough number of those students that they didn't count um toward they counted toward the score but they didn't count they did not meet um the requirement of the in number to get a gauge color and so looking at English language arts um at the school level the District um
087in 2023 was yellow and we contined to be yellow in English language arts I'd like to highlight um the two changes that occurred which was um John Mir Elementary they were yellow and declined to the orange color and then um the middle school went from yellow to the green color and so they had an increase for mathematics yellow we are 27.6 points below standard but this increased 9.6 points from the prior year you'll see in our Equity report we had four student groups that were in the yellow which was our africanamerican our English Learners Hispanic and then our social economically disadvantaged and then you'll see that we continue to have the four groups with no performance color and then we had had four groups in our green which just two in our orange being our
088long-term English Learners and our students with disabilities looking districtwide the we had no changes um other than the district moving from Orange performance color in 2023 to the yellow performance color here's science um where it has the grade gauge um they did give us an indicator though of kind of what our Baseline was at this point in time you can see we're 9.1 points below standard and so they put seven points there um but that there is no change indicator so I'm not clear on why we have a change indicator and then you'll see um I just snapshot a few different of the um student groups here so that you could see where they fell within um the points above or below standard so for example we can take our social economically disadvantaged student group
089down in the middle in the bottom and they're 17.6 points below standard at this point and the number of students in that group is 310 and so next year these will be colored just like the other gauges moving on to Chronic absenteeism The Chronic absenteeism measure shows how many students were absent for 10% or more of the instructional days they were enrolled to attend um we are overall through the district yellow we had a decline 6.4% in this situation declined is a positive we want a decline in our chronic absenteeism so always it's hard to switch back and forth but this is a positive and then we have um only one student group that is in the red indicator which is our African-American student group and then um looking at our green we have our
090Asian and our white student groups so here you can see the majority of our student groups are within the yellow but there is work to be done with our African-American homeless and our long-term English Learners looking across the district um the changes that occurred was uh John Mir went from Orange to Yellow which is a a positive change uh John sweat orange to Green a positive change Los hunus orange to Yellow which is a positive change and then Melo Park green to blue which is also a positive change you'll see that our high schools are not listed here and this has to do with um the graduation rate it is done differently so chronic absenteeism is only for the school schools suspension rate the suspension rate measure shows the percentage students who were suspended for
091at least one full day during the school year and this here is also a decline as a positive so we declined by 1% with a 3.8% suspended at least one day um we continue to have one student group that's in red it is a different student Group which is our homeless student group we also have a student group in Orange our African-American and so we have work to be done um around supporting those student groups and then looking at our suspension rate across the district um districtwide we made a posit we made Positive Growth we went orange to Green um alhamra declined they went green to Yellow um and then we had John me going red to Yellow which was positive John sweat declined with a yellow to Orange Los hunus orange to Yellow which
092was a positive the Middle School yellow to Green which was a positive change Melo Park green to Orange which was a negative change and then um Vicente Martinez High School Red to Green which was a a big positive change our English learner progress the English learner progress mejor looks at the progress English learner students are making toward achieving Proficiency in English and here you can see that we have two student groups now before we used to just have English Learners and there wasn't another student group but now we have long-term English Learners as a student group in this area um we have 50.3% making progress which is a decline of 11.7% so this is in this is a decline this year overall our schools that have the English learner progress um indicator as a district
093we're listed there we have alhamra high school which also had a decline which was green to Orange and then Los hunus which was a decline as well which was yellow to Orange our graduation rate measures the number of students who receive a diploma at the end of 12th grade here we maintained um we just went down not even a percent um with a 94.9% graduation rate um you can see we have no student groups in uh red or orange which is uh great news and we have two student groups in yellow Hispanic and socially economically disadvantaged that we may want to look at around equity and then here is our graduation ation rate um and then we have the changes that occurred blue to green um for district wide and then vente um green to
094yellow with our college and crew Readiness um last year this was a status bar if you remember and now it's turned to a gauge since they have two years to compare the data um this measures how many students graduate from high school better prepared for college or career and uses different measures of College and Career prep preparedness such as completion of cour workor and work experience to exam results so this is where they use um the AP exam a to G credit uh CTE completion these are all um parts of this indicator so we had an increase of 2.7% and we are at Green overall although we do have three student groups um that we would want to collect further data on to ensure that they're having Equitable Services which would be our socially economically
095disadvantaged our students with disability and our white students and then here you can see I put the performance status from last year medium medium very low and now we have our performance color um they do green is an increase but the red and the very low is is is a stat is State status quo and then our local indicators which are AC which implementation of academic standards falls under academic performance and then our access to broadc courses study falls under academic engagement and then in our conditions and climate we have our Basics which are teachers instruction materials and Facilities our parent and family engagement and then our local climate survey which standards are met there questions thank you Amy I have a number of questions okay uh first of all what is the number that
096you need to um have a performance color so like for example you said no performance color mathematic under American Indian Foster youth homeless what is that how many kids do you need to have before they get a category it's typically 35 it can range depending on the size of the school but the ins size is for most of them is 35 so I'm going to just pick on well I'm going to pick two categories first I'm going to talk about English language language arts um it looks like we're 2.1 points above the standard and we maintained 1 point2 points I don't know if that means we went up or not um but we're still yellow in there yeah um but I'm curious um so for example um in yellow on the actual chart you have
097African-American and Hispanic can you tell me from this year from the last two years has that number gone up or gone down so has African-Americans has it improved or has it gone down same with Hispanic so looking at the student group is what you what information you would want I would be able to tell you but it would I would have to look it up online okay well and I would like to see a report back with like more detail because we have the Dei committee and I want to make sure that we look at all of the groups not just one or two groups and I think sometimes we get sidetracked and we maybe focus on one group um so it'll be nice to see the stats for you know like especially like englage
098um English language and math because that's so you know so critical points that we need to really focus on um and I know that it's great that you know mathematics we went up I guess 9.6 points um we're still in yellow but again I'm curious how each category um again because like African-American English Learners Hispanic are still yellow and so are they getting better do we need to put more focus on it I'm just curious what all that detail is okay so definitely so um what you would like in a future board presentation would be um a focus on academics looking at the individual student groups and their movement over the 23 to 24 school year got it right yeah yes just to see if we're on the right track and if we need to
099make some kind of adjustments or not and I can't can share with you that there has been growth overall throughout the district and one um one indicator for us is that we are no longer in differentiated assistance and so when we're in differentiated assistance if you remember my presentation last year we were not in differentiated assistance last year but we were the year prior in the 22 school year and based on that information that is based on student groups being in the red indicator and so if a student is in multiple red indicator or a student group is in multiple red indicators with exception of one if you remember when I did the presentation for um we had three three schools last year one was in um CSI which was a comprehensive support and one
100and then we had two that were also in support which was the atsi none of our schools at this after this dashboard are in any type of um technical support through the state um under Essa perfect great and then also can you somehow put in there because um it's so important that they focus on math and English you know at an early age the elementary schools how their growth is also it just not just that the color changed but um I guess more specific detail if that's possible well I can do color change and then I can do distance from standard that would give you like more detailed like so you could know like for example I'm just going to say a so let's say a school ABC had a distance from St below standard
101at 96.3 points but then School de had a distance from standard um 10.1 below standard we would know that there would there was an opportunity gap between the two schools for example and then we can see if they're doing the same type of correct teaching the same from the same stuff right perfect exactly thank you H yeah other questions yeah thank you for the data I was gonna kind of elaborate on what Tanya said and also I think we had a perfectly timely public comment and I'm sorry s i forgotten your name but uh we do have a Dei committee it's been established for quite some time and um I think not for lack of passion or caring for our students but I think we're still seeing some real areas that now we have some
102data and I would love for this to go directly to the Dei committee I think especially academics are one thing the Dei committee isn't going to change our curriculum and do interventions and things like that but there are a couple of areas one chronic absenteeism which um our black students were in the red in that area and then also suspensions I think those are areas that are really more culture-based and those are things that would be really wonderful targets for the Dei committee to brainstorm what kind of um you know interventions would be good and I think that it would be great to get that Comm kind of to know what else is happening in other committees around the district like elcap for example really specifically addresses these things as our student board rep knows
103she's done elcap for a while um and so I think that there's just a lot of opportunity here and would be really wonderful to sort of Leverage The Passion that we already have within our community using this data to see if we can Implement some real meaningful change for our students so that would be I'm not I'm like looking at you because you did the presentation I'm not saying like your job now go do that but well I have been facilit facilitating Dei this year as Mr Dand knows and um what I can say is one one thing we've added to the format of Dei this year is having an opportunity for school sites to share highlights on what has been going well and an opportunity to ask questions um what that what we can
104do for the upcoming one in February is definitely facilitate that especially around the culture piece because these do have an impact on the culture of the school as well is use our healthy kids survey information that should be backed by that point in time as well and so that will be able to give us a nice some nice data points to be able to have a discussion on how did for example John sweat move from Orange to green and Chron chronic absenteeism right did we have that many parents come off the pmic all of a sudden unlikely there are probably some other variables that took place as well right so yes so definitely that's something hi um Annie said a lot of what I was gonna say um one thing I wanted to add is
105I I think that some of um those student groups that Annie mentioned are a a Rel you know relatively a relatively small population of students and I wonder if there's some opportunity to actually talk to people you know and keeping with privacy but talk to people and find out what some of the challenges are especially with the chronic absenteeism um because you know at the end of the day we want to make sure that every single student has what they need not not just by a group um the other number that really stood out to me curious to know more about is under your College and Career Readiness indicator um white students are listed in Orange and that's our biggest student population so I'm really concerned about that I know a lot goes into that
106but um I'd like to know more about what does go into that and and what's driving that number because that's um our biggest population and that's our that's what our job is College and Career Readiness so what's what's missing from that piece and then there are further um this is this is looking at the dashboard right so this information is from the dashboard but there you can go deeper in what is uh a database called Data Quest as well which can break down it um collagen career specifically much more and by student group and with percent and so I can definitely get that information to so I can add that into the future presentation as well thank you okay can I just add on there too um for the College and Career Readiness um so
107that's also including that you need to take a foreign language for two years to go into a college there are a lot of components I know that superintendent Rossy shared some uh technical like some technical pages with um with the board prior to tonight which were oh okay they're um they're in your packet and so I'm like oh and so the pages there um go deeper into each of the um performance indicators for you to talk about what components go into those indicators and so these are parent facing this is part of a toolkit that um calern Department of Education has designed um specifically to support parents in um reading the dashboard and having support around the dashboard so um I can for sure talk about like the indicators deeper especially around the College and
108Career what what makes a student um well prepared or there's like different categories so one is prepared one is not prepared and then there's like one in the middle there's like kind of a almost prepared but that's not what it's called but I'll definitely get that information to you I'm also not called Almost prepar yeah and and I'm looking at oh yes thanks like it looks like we have um links to well we don't have the link because this is a piece of paper but okay but it it links you to measures of college readiness flyer and measures of career Readiness flyer so um in addition to what the actual um criteria are what's driving that and you to your point T it's I don't think it's necessarily like what classes they're taking because the
109the years of foreign language is only they want to go to an AG school so that's what I'm curious about but AG G is part of one one of them okay and I wonder if the counselors I mean I assume they all the kids but I know that there's it's always like a rush between pick your classes um and they give them like two or three days I think in the high school and then they have time to change it eventually but they give them only a couple days do they actually I mean can we verify and that's probably a Helen question um that they're actually telling the kids that you should take two years of foreign language you know if you are planning to go to a UC or so so I can answer
110because I'm also part of the Ed trust um West Equity Group as well as Mr dandri he is also part of one Our Community member that has been attending and um this is some this is something that we saw an opportunity to do better in and there has been um a redo on the class course selection cards um so they look different uh Lizzie wouldn't have seen one this year so I can't even ask her about it since she's graduating so I see her nodding her head though I can speak a little bit into it though that I know in the past years at least um when I've been choosing classes and when I've been talking to friends of mine in grades below mine and in my grade and they're choosing classes they do not
111always know that fine arts is a and a to g a tog requirement which feeds straight into our College and Career Readiness and B that it is a requirement for going to um a university or at least for most universities and so I have like had sit down with some friends and go no you actually need to take a language because you need to get that to go there um and so there's a little bit difference going in there with what the students are getting that information and how much it goes out it is stated somewhat but I don't think it's emphasized very much I did redo the chart it's in the in the handbook okay okay make sure everybody puts their microphone on when they're talking because Nikki has to go back and watch
112this and it it hasn't been on the whole time so make sure we do it yes so that I so to reiterate that is something that um we put a lens on this year to look at and ensure that we're communicating clearly the expect ations to be able to provide that opportunity once a student graduates because we don't want to get us to um this time of year and a students say oh but I thought I was going to California State University Fresno and they're like well no you're not because you're not prepared you're actually going to need to go to a junior college so we don't want that that moment of well that would be moment but that aha moment that I didn't take the right classes when we in our senior year and
113so that is something that we've been talking about especially in the um Ed trust group so one of the reasons that we're moving to the academic plan scheduler because it has three tabs and the the three Tabs are your general your UC and your state and it should automatically have the the Fine Arts lit up in there um I'm not sure where we are because I haven't you know I started it with Stephanie and then I left her do her job instead of you know I bowed out of that but um it's supposed to have the Fine Art requirements listed right there as to what you need for UC or estate so um I'll I'll check on that too and then just H to piggy back off of what um superintendent Rossy said is we
114also now have um ccgi which is a college um California College guidance initiative oh my my goodness all these ACR um that also supports with four-year planning our counselors and our administrators were all trained in um the fall on how to use it and support students and that is a hub where students can go in and do their four-year planning it also shows them what they would need to go to a UC or a calate school as well as it it helps them do applications and their FASA all in like a single location there's also even little modules to help them decide what their career path may want what they may want it to be and so that is something that we've partnered um across the the whole state of California's partnering with um ccgi
115but we signed our mou um this last uh summer to do that great thank you um do we have any public comment you got a f to comment card but yes go ahead you can do that afterwards to Dove Hil off of Amy um being on Dei and Ed trust um one of the focuses um and I brought it up in a meeting with uh superintendent Rossy is education starts at home and I've heard a lot of things over the years about how poor the education is I'm 60 years old I grew up here I went to school at College Park High School my parents were college educated there emphasis on education has passed to me and my kids um this the form looks different my daughter just did hers but she had guidance from
116me from the get-go on what she needed to do um and you brought up S uh suspension rates and absentee rates and that goes directly to home um my background isn't working in the schools here alone but Richmond San Francisco Los Angeles um and dealing with the bad kids you know kids that are in gangs and drugs and it starts at home and that's why I'm involved because one of the things that you deal with black students in particular and all students is you have to give them hope and you can do that through history giving them guidelines and role models that they can emulate when I ask black students today who are your role models LeBron James and Simone biles so those how we can change um is scheduling better yes it is um
117it's more informational to the students but it has to be informational to the parents because the parents are the driving fors that and that's it thank you thank you don't forget to fill out a comment or card sorry I can also confirm that the foreign language and visual Performing Arts are split out in the UC College requirements and the CSU under the academic plan as long as students go and look there got thank you very much Lizzy appreciate that okay any other questions we're good okay Amy sorry that we took a lot of your time you thought it was G to be a quick presentation and so moving right along we have action item um approval of annual developer fee report and resolution 20254 Andy Canon uh thanks for the opportunity again um before you
118tonight is resolution 20254 which is the resolution approving our um developer fee annual report also attached is the report itself uh Joe if you can get that report pulled up for me while I kind of go over the the general specifics here General specifics what a term um the other one sorry the final fantastic um so as we talked about um going way back last year December uh we had a new developer fee Nexus study and so that was a part of a process of saying that we are looking to potentially change our fees those fees went down for the residents of Martinez which is I think is a good thing for them and that's because we have built um new schools and increased our student capacity so I want to make sure that I
119distinguish that developer fee study is done about every two years that is not what we're talking about today what we are talking about tonight our fiscal year report so each year we have to do an annual report that says how much money did we start in our developer if account for us our Capital facilities account fund 25 and what we spent it on how much we have left in any future projects in addition to that we're required every five years to do a larger presentation which shows what are the projects that we may do in future years so the resolution is to approve um that report so as Joe has it up if you scroll down to I believe the next page these were our rates for last year and we separate these by residential
120commercial um so these rates are something that you'd put into play um I believe three years ago now because we just did our our last one go down to the next page right there go up just a little bit perfect um so when we began the year July of 2020 three we had about $185,000 remaining in fund 25 that's after we paid for a significant amount of furniture and other things for the junior high school U so that when we ended our balance we had almost $324,000 next page will show us where that um where the funds came from So within the the attendance boundaries for the Martina sheight School District we collected almost $118,000 for folks who either created built brand new single family detached homes or if they added U square footage onto
121their single family home and then we were collected almost $15,000 from multifam attached very small part for hospitals hospitals don't pay the same rates because they don't have students living there um so there's a smaller rate going forward if you go to the bottom of the table you'll see our total cost that includes interest our fair market value so we collected about $144,000 last year and all of these funds go back into Capital facility projects for the school district so if we keep going down we're going to see the fiveyear uh excuse me expenditures um so each year we have to pay for um certain accounting and other features so that's about $5,000 and that was the total of our cost we spent a bunch in 2223 we didn't spend much in 23 24 we
122anticip using um the funds we we have remaining plus any additional funds we have over the next couple of years that will go towards measure o projects um like the high school and the Junior High um if we identify anything else from the other schools we could potentially use the funds for there and I believe that's on the next area the next chart should be the fiveyear yep keep scrolling fantastic right there now uh what I don't want you to think is that measure o projects are already completely done we know the price amount and we put it in there that is not even close to being true we have just started relooking at our facility uh master plan and what we want to do but in anticipation of that I did break down um
123the amounts by the high school and the junior high simply as a perspective this is something we could do in the future we are not beholden to this we can change it down the road but part of the requirement of doing this fiveyear plan is we can't say that we don't know what we're going to do with the money for we have to assign it in some way so this is where the assignments have been um so at the high school almost $200,000 at the junior high $130,000 this will change as each year we do an annual report if we spend dollars somewhere else I will show that as expenditures and it would change this down the road so ultimately what I'm saying is this Five-Year Plan is kind of hard because we don't know
124how we're going to do things especially since we just got the new Bond in place but we have a placehold ER for how we'd spend these funds if we had to um and that is um our our um fund 3 or excuse me fund 25 report and resolution and I can answer any questions you may have um staff is seeking um approval of this tonight thank you Andy um any questions any public comment do I have a motion I'll move to approve the developer fees report I'll second okay uh roll call um Li student rep first I uh trusty Masala O'Brien hi trusty horic Martin hi trusty Campbell hi and myself I motion passed okay okay last but not least um review and Adoption of resolution 20255 declaring results and certifying proceedings of school bond
125election held November 5th um and this is Andy Cannon and this is more of a house cleaning thing so no new news here uh we did get measure o to pass uh but part of that passage is that the board has to approve and certify those results so resolution 20255 um essentially has three parts for you to look at tonight um part one is that we want to enter the results of the election into the board minutes part two of that is we want you to certify the results and then part three and this is the one that I'm want to really focus on is we want to choose to extend the citizens oversight committee because terminating it and trying to find a second citizens oversight committee that would run parallel with the current Bond
126that's not finished would be immeasurably hard um so those are the three parts that you are adopting tonight if you choose to do so in resolution 2025-the I'll second okay student representative mcau hi trusty Masala O'Brien hi trusty horak Martin hi trusty Campbell hi myself I and motion is approved okay we don't need additional comments from the public so we are down to comments from the superintendent board members and future agenda items why don't we start with Helen I'm good thank you um I just wanted to again um as Helen had said um best wishes for um Southern California that the fires go out um sooner rather than later and that there's not any more high winds um also I wanted to let people know um just FYI you can still get free covid tests
127again from the government I know we're after the um December break but um I had actually tried using one and the old one I had didn't work anymore because it was dried out um but they are available at covid t.gov so um you should always have those on hand they send one to your you know to your household and I think there's five tests in a package so you should try and do that and um so New Year and uh looking forward to the year and with that welcome back to going to school again all right thank you um I was able to attend last Thursday I had to do the math in my head this month already feels like like a whole two months um but uh our special ed director Matthew Jensen put
128on a parent night at alhamra high school and I found it very informative um both as a parent and board member and um I loved what Paula said earlier and so I'll use your analogy with this presentation so there was transparency there are going to be some changes to some special ed programming at Al hamur high school and that was what the president was about so that parents could learn about it and I felt like there was accountability which comes for sped students in the form of an IEP and IEP team and people continuing to monitor that and um in the Integrity piece is I think Matthew I think is very receptive and um really easy to communicate with quick to respond to people and so um I thought it was really it was good
129it was a good night and it's um I think it's good to remember that everyone in the room in those kinds of events is there because we care about children and their own children they're passionate about getting the right services and there's Sometimes some trepidation about changes and whether or not that's going to be the right move for their kid and so I really appreciate sort of the the transparency aspect of like here's all the things ask all the questions it's okay if you're worried about it we're gonna kind of work through all of that so I'm glad that I was able to attend and thank you for putting that on um I can't believe it's 2025 already just and yeah this month has already felt like it's been yeah anyway um I just want
130to say thank you to Mr dandri it sounds like you're doing a lot of good work in our schools and we do really appreciate it it's needed so thank you and um just thank you to everybody that came and sat through the meeting and um we we know that you're here because you care like Annie said and it's appreciated well on the note of the fires in la Martinez Lodge 41 is accepting donations this weekend so if you are willing and if you are able you can go and volunteer or you can go and donate to them um and if you have a high school student they were sent information about that too so you can definitely ask them about it um and then also just as a friendly reminder we have no school next
131Monday um to celebrate Reverend Dr Martin Luther King Jr's birthday otherwise have a great week guys thank you with that we are ad o sorry I'm so sorry Logan uh I'll make it short I just want to thank Helen and staff uh for making it possible for me to attend this meeting remotely I'd had this trip planned uh five or six months ago so I was just glad I was able to participate tonight and uh putting up with the roll calls thank you very much with that we are adjourned thank you