001e e e all right good morning how's every everybody doing good I just wanted to quickly go over how the tables are set up and how this work session will run and then I will hand it over to Dr Bryant after that and then I believe he will hand over to Andy so this is being live streamed um but the only time that they're going to hear anything is if your mic is on on your table and you're talking into it and so there are times where we're going to do a presentation for instance Andy is gonna introduce a new tool to you guys and go over that he'll be on the microphone that will be streamed but then as soon as you get into small groups and start working on that you just want
002to leave your mic off because if everybody had their mic on all of those would blend together online it would be nonsensical and so anytime we're doing individual things the mics will be on anytime we're doing group things the mic will be off and with that I will turn it over to Dr Bryant thank you Mike so uh this is our annual Saturday budget uh balancing activity the main difference is that uh today's EX will be electronic versus the paper cards that we've used in the past and that's because we're piloting this really interesting tool called balancing act that I hope you find valuable as we start planning for the budget development process and shout out to member Lon that brought up the idea I think it's great a great tool and I think the
003board is well prepared to use it pretty easily just given how familiar you are with all the various terms um but with that said the point of today is really just to give the board space to look at the budget forecast for next year start thinking through ways you might want to uh approach the budget approval process I will be uh preparing a recommendation over the coming months and you'll see some preliminary guidance on December 17th but I'd like it to be rooted in some of uh the things I'm hearing today or questions that you have today um because I I'd like us to be as coordinated and on the same page as possible um when that uh recommendation comes out um the last thing is that you'll notice that we're joined by our cabinet
004members here that's because as you start uh going through this budget simulation you may have questions about different departments and um risks for cutting certain areas into what degree we're here to provide you with that information and then of course Jim and myself and others are here to answer questions board members might have about the right sizing proposal uh this is our last major meeting together before uh the December 17th date where we'll discuss the preliminary guidance of the budget as well as the rightsizing proposal um so with that said uh I'll hand it off to Andy Ratliff unless uh and president Hollman was there anything you had okay perfect uh then we'll go ahead and hand it off to Andy Ratliff who will walk us through the tool all right thank you so I
005emailed you to the school board email addresses uh a link to this tool it's called Balancing Act um you can click on there and I want to I'll bring it up here on the screen to walk you through some of the nuances of it uh just so you have a pretty quick understanding of it but really our goal is to get the data and not share this link out with others for uh at this time we'll have just the seven board members go through and fill out theirs and we're going to aggregate the data and just see like really what are the trends that the school board is looking at for how they would Bud balance the budget and then we'll bring that back on the meeting on the 17 okay so this is the
006actual Balancing Act tool that we did and we um aligned this to what's in the proor so we put in the revenue that we had on the proor and then the expenditures so it's not going to be a perfect tool where it goes and has changes the the district may be planning on maker Administration proposing it's just really how much does things cost next you're doing business the same way um some of the nuances on this or starting at the 107 million as you recall we had about 60 million whenever you applied fund balance uh there's questions in here where you can apply fund balance um and really kind of high level to these little eye boxes you click on those it'll bring up a little more information about each category there's only one that
007has the more details this will bring up some um or a couple of them have more details and it'll bring up like graphs or charts or something and then on each change if you do want you can put you don't have to but you can put uh comments in there to say here's why I changed it um or you you can put some reasoning in there you don't have to but just kind of get the general sentiment um so we have that for fund balance we have that for that's also one on state revenue on the foundation funding um so we do have it set by to no BSA increase you can put it into different increments that we've calculated over the last few weeks so um I guess this kind of goes back as
008part of the board guidance for yourselves is do you want to have a limit do you only want to put 680 do you want to start it just a zero Revenue scenario or each just want to give kind of board numers free reign of how they how they choose to balance the budget and really kind of looking forward we're also going to you know even after the work session keep using this tool to really kind of model some different things like if we were to get a increase um you do that you can we have it where you can come in and say okay we can or decrease class sizes you know so you have those models to say here's what the new uh reeven would do and here's how we could potentially spend the
009money so we're going to have that modeling for this purpose the purpose of this exercise I don't know that I would want to just go that route because we do need to get to a balanced budget before the state take is going to probably take any sort of action on um legislative funding or state funding so that's the revenue side on the expenditure side we have it broken down it's not really broken down by categories you typically find in our our our budget books that's done by State Statute or state chart of accounts um a lot of times those are hard to understand and for the lay person if you look at instructional support students like really what goes into that so we wanted to make this tool um really understandable for just kind of
010plain language so you can see we have the pupil teacher ratio that's really just class size um there are pair professionals principles Library Services you know things that folks are going to understand um one thing I would say we do have limiters set on some of these so how much could we realistically decrease uh nurses um so we have it where if you click down at some point it's going to hit a limit and say there's a maximum reduction you've reached um that we think we could possibly reduce so just to have some guidance in there so entire uh departments or classification of employees aren't getting kind of wiped out in the in the process um we do have school closures on there uh of the forward proposed just kind of as that is a
011budgetary item we did put it in there so if you want to save money by closing schools or repurposing them then that option's in there and then at the bottom I would say there are some items that are locked that we don't have control over um charter schools that money is directed towards them based on State Statute our fixed costs are typically going to be rents utilities leases uh insurance um indirect cost recovery the amount we recover from Grants for administrative Services that's set by a rate that's in State Statute or that's calculated and then put in the statute attrition vacancies or are estimated amounts of um employee turnover vacant positions and folks waving medical insurance and then we have a small contingency just for emergencies so those are all off where you can't adjust
012them there's a little bit of information on each one uh but those priv we don't have a lot of control over those costs so it's uh we didn't allow for changes but there's a lot of different categories for uh different things you can click down on them see what you want to Red uh have reductions for operations and maintenance those are in there or administrations or you can add to it you know there's if you want to reduce other areas so that's how it's structured um try to make it pretty easy to understand and self-explanatory you guys are the guinea pigs on this so if you do see things that are errors or anything um let us know so we can fix those before it goes to a public version uh first of all thank
013you so much for preparing this um I think I'm excited to well excited is a strong word um I'm grateful for the opportunity to use this I'm really grateful that the community uh in turn will have the opportunity to use this um the one question I had was about the BSA and the question is are you in favor of increasing it by a certain amount so specific to this exercise just to clarify if we click on no that means that the entire exercise today will be based on no BSA increase if we were to click on 1963 the entire exercise would be based on balancing a much uh well a tiny a difference um Perhaps Perhaps a tiny Surplus um so I I guess I just maybe I'm pushing back on the words in favor
014of because yes I am personally in favor of the legislature increasing the BSA but I think that maybe we might want to change that wording yeah that's a great distinction and I think we should probably we'll do that on the public in some way once it once we push it out uh to the public yeah thanks thank you sorry I know the fixed C I saw the fixed cops uh link but what about positions that we cannot cut are there any positions that the law required that we do not cut and do we have a list of those um School Board probably it's uh the special education is one of them yeah and we have that we have that limited and we have notes in there that say um you can't cut like special education
015services and aggregate more than yeah so it's in there and I think like special services are typically limited to about 10% reduction overall but if you're not going to reduce the other categories by 10% we can't reduce uh special education it has to be proportional and that's the maintenance of effort laws I was going to add this as a suggestion on the opening uh dra down that we're in this deficit if we continue to provide the same level of services as we did last year uh and part of that just comes from talking with folks in the community that assume our deficit is coming out of the fact that we're just spending all this money or we have done things that we didn't necessarily have to do um I it's just important for people to
016understand that if we if we take this year and we try to do it again next year we are short that much money uh cause of inflation and the lack of adjustment to long-term uh funding which I I think will make it more clear to people that are doing this great and then at the end I think after you've completed and got it in Balance when you submit it it'll ask you for an email address so we can verify that it's a board member in case we get like 10 responses or something somehow Andy um is can you explain the relationship of the different funding sources to this exercise like federal funds come with a lot of mandates so is there a way or have you already broken off the things that are funded by
017federal dollars and that come with main U required Staffing for that it's actually in the federal dollar grants so that we don't um we ought to be looking at General funds is what I'm suggesting right yeah that's correct this is only our general fund so any federal grants that we get for like um title title funding or something like that is not included the federal money that we do is predominantly impact Aid and that is just to offset kind of a local property tax in Li of property taxes so it's not it doesn't have positions specifically tied to it with that I you guys can find the link and if you have questions we have staff around here if you want to know more what's included in each category then happy to help you out
018I also want to say it's really great that you can um get information about where people who are responding to this live uh so we can understand um who's participating in this at a district level and when we push that to the public we're working on getting it translated to that's kind of a longer process with just the way this is set up a lot of the stuff was like keyed directly into the software so I have to pull that out have a translated push it back in but it's not a simple process is great I'm excited to try to get myself through it I'm not that technical but it seems very uh easy to do I guess my question is at what point in the day or the morning will we start to create
019guidance or you g to take it from right so our our goal would be to have you guys each go in and balance create a balanced budget and then we're going to aggregate your data say um just School closure as an example someone says couple of you say zero couple of you say four it's going to average that out say on average to uh the board members are supportive of closing two schools so it does just aggregate your data and kind of give you generalized trends of how each member decided to balance the budget so that's how we'll use it then we'll attach that data to our uh proor memo that's going to be up for the vote on the 17th and use that as the guidance so board members can pull it and adjust
020that and kind of tweak that guidance as you see that and then I'll just reiterate the caveat that this is just a simulation and everything is subject to change on any given day but based off of what we know this is just a good way to capture where we're at yeah and I think it'll be good for the public too is it's a little more interactive um I think we can get better aggregated data of that sentiment when they actually go see the through the exercises and see exactly what's being being reduced rather than trying to pull the information from like surveys or something so just a question on the tool in particular it looks like that there's uh a PTR lever but it doesn't allow something that I think the board's considered in previous
021years to hold certain grades harmless as we rais PTR is that am I seeing that correctly and is there any way to would I then like add edit under to your suggestion is that where it would go yeah you could do that the your suggestion on the bottom um Frank can just time constraint it's harder to build that out and since we have the ptrs at different grade levels aren't necessarily consistent like primary is not all one PTR is more difficult to build that out I'm just thinking specifically K3 reading our primary goals T K3 reading and so I imagine some board member um will be interested in exploring that and I hope we give that option to community as well it's I'm interested to hear yeah we could certainly look at see and what
022it would take and we could do it in Broad more broad Strokes like K3 would be easier than right having separate ones for K1 two three something based on our goals I think would be you do K3 four five and then middle and high right thank you the list starts to get pretty long pretty quick when you start add these um really I guess it's up to you guys once you guys are all submitted I think we can be done we'll have the results aren't we're not able for us to pull the data the analytics until 24 hours after it's all submitted so we wouldn't pull it today but you guys certainly discuss with amongst yourselves kind of how you choose to balance it and then as for rightsizing that could happen simultaneously you may
023have questions as you're working through the budget that relate to rightsizing so Administration will be able to answer both at the same time um but if president holling wants to break up the time into separate blocks they refer to him I'll just say from my perspective I asked the question was I'm hoping that if there's any board member interested in bringing an amendment to 73 forward that it's at least um socialized today um I would as we start to get nearer to the 7 teams that become increasingly nervous about and unlikely to support a significant adjustment to the memorandum that isn't discussed and provided public notice beforehand it seems irresponsible from a governance perspective so I'm I'm sure folks have wonderings and thoughts I'm just hoping we can talk about them today thanks e e
024e if board members will make sure they've submitted the their results um we'll reconvene the session and wrap this up and move on to right sizing e e e real quickly does anyone have feedback or anything they want to say about the exercise and balancing the budget um yeah no appreciate the um opportunity to provide feedback I was checking in with Mr Ratt throughout the um time we had to utilize the tool I think there's some fine-tuning in some additional context the example I think that would be most helpful was when you're clicking and adjusting each of the particular line items say for like a denda or at a particular Department some some of them equal a um percentage cut to the department where some um equate to an actual FTE being lost and so
025drilling down on that um and providing that information and the informational dot I think would be helpful in addition to some of the other contexts we asked to be provided um I'll say for for my part in terms of a solution um I think each of the board members we've we've experienced this exercise in one form or another for multiple years now I think we realistically can't um address our budget challenge without addressing PTR and so my interest remains um to the extent that we can trying to hold um the grades associated with their primary goal of K3 reading harmless to un some level and so I've explored a staggering of um across the board increase of PTR coupled with um a um another PTR increase that holds K3 harmless um just as a concept
026and so I I gathered some figures from Mr R about that those those costings and so um beyond that I think that's the the big feedback I have I did reduce our line item to as much as I could which I understand didn't Impact Staffing but just some other things so our board line item didn't save us a ton but I did reduce that as well thanks and I will say member Jacobs and I had the discussion about uh what we do when to pass as a budget how much do we assume uh will happen from the legislature do we assume that they do uh the statutory minimum do we assume uh a significant increase in the BSA in some form or another in setting the budget um and that uh I don't know that
027we we can discuss it today for certain not sure how the administration feels on that um if I could get a start it's ultimately the decision will be up to the board and there are examples of other districts in the state that have done projections and then as we all remember last year we did uh do a very modest projection of an increase I believe last year was a $100 increase um but I think at that point we had seen the passage of um house bill or Senate Bill 140 um which was the VSA increase and we had the governor and record expressing interest in a $300 increase so those are the conditions that led us to that decision this time around um I would ask Mr ratl to talk about ways in which um
028that could present risk you like to walk through perhaps the Juno example um yes so our our biggest risk on that would be if obviously you over project if you say you know we're going to get $680 BSA equivalent and it comes back at 500 or something uh the timing on that is really the bigger risk know so if you don't know until June um which has been kind of the standard lately of when we get our know how much money we get in June and July um the biggest risk is to be able to we have all these folks on contract because May 15th is the last day that you can lay off any sort of tenard staff and the last day of school for non- tenard um so those are kind of the
029metrics we need to have stuff finalized by uh up in that till that point I mean you could always take the tack that if you don't have anything in statute by you know towards the beginning of may you come back and see here's how we have to balance B the budget and we issue those go back and you might even have to issue pink Subs before you get to that balanced budget say okay we're just laying off a chunk of people um we'll call you back as we know more type thing um or figure out where those remaining dollars go you know so it could be something quick like that um or it could be more detailed I think just one point as I looked that the cost savings associated with closing schools that bees
030by school of course but I think it's also important to note that as we saw a couple years ago uh that amount declines over the years we got a save pay provision where we get largic schools combined we get less for student uh we don't see that reduction effective immediately but we see it over time we saw it last time where some schools actually had a net loss for us uh and other schools we had a saving so it varies depend upon the school and just for clarification to the public that's a that's a one that's a that savings is going to decline or may decline in future years because of class sizes or School sizes and I think that's important to note because it's not that yeah if if I may just add a
031clarification that the member hang is is correct when you do the projections in terms of the ADM that you get based on your enrollment there is a whole harmless provision that allows us to get funding I think it's 100% the first year and then it goes down afterwards so if you track it in that mechanism then you will see a net loss of Revenue in five years however it's important to note that the C the cost Savings of the principal the administrative assistant and whatever other positions that you lose when you uh consolidate a building that's in perpetuity so there are some savings there and then another important note would be uh any savings from deferred maintenance or whatever happens as a result of repurposing the building so it's a very complicated thing to quantify
032but I want to the full context out there behind that figure because it did cause confusion with the public two years ago yeah and the underlying reason for that is in the in the foundation formula there's a school size adjustment where you get less money per kid for larger schools so but there's that whole harmless provision that steps that down over five years so you save money the first couple years then it starts stepping down and then at the end of five years um on a on average it's supposed to be about cost and R tool where you can reduce your revenue and reduce expend fees um and it's kind of a SL sliding scale for economies or economies of scale it actually works pretty well when you math it out and we have so
033you do get but it's not a long-term uh real long-term savings the long-term savings is in that maintenance side and then the efficiencies you gain or the quality of Education you might have in a little bit larger study yes CH so just a couple of thoughts uh I don't want us to lose sight of the fact that a rightsizing is not it's really it's just not about uh budget it isn't it's more about opportunities for our students having said that though I do this is a I really enjoy doing this activity um I think I'm going to do it again tonight um but I I could not balance this budget without cutting programs and people there's no other way to do it I don't care how optimistic we are I mean we there's a lot
034that's unknown but this is very frustrating for me uh it scares me um with with all that we want for our students the fact that we sit here on a Saturday morning trying to decide decide how to get to the number with so many unknowns it's just very frustrating it's not a good place to be it's not comfortable we have got to do deep cuts and we can't sugarcoat this there's no way to get a balanced budget without cutting features Physicians our counselors whatever whatever all of our staff is on the CH chopping block right now and so I I don't have the answer but I think uh my biggest Reflection from this morning's activity not that I didn't know it before is the extent to which we are absolutely going to have to look
035at cutting people not going to work any other way I doubt if we'll get I I I hope we get at least 600 I doubt it uh will we get 1526 I don't know 1924 I don't know I doubt it um and knowing that we've got to have our budget in before we have all the final pieces so there will be some things that we we we would be able to like I found myself thinking well if we if we get money then we can bring some things that I might cut today we can bring them back in the future um but still it's a tossup so anyway thank you Mr chck no actually I would second that um as someone that spent a lot of my professional career in middle school if you did
036um at different times the districts talked about cutting out middle school and even some Middle School teachers would go well you know really I'm okay with it we'll go back to Junior High that was simpler that was easier and you have to sit down in front of and go you understand that means there won't be as many people here because that's where the cost is it's not it's not based on when we ring the bells is based on how many staff we have in in the building so if we go back to Junior High pick five people that aren't going to be in this building and then see what you think and that usually changed people's minds quite a bit the program doesn't really cost anything the people that staff it or the way you
037save money someone has to leave in order for the cost to go down and uh it is hard because I I do I can't think of a program that we've got that's not stretched thin in terms of Staffing and we're underst staff on counselors we're under staffed on teachers we're underst staffed on administrators um which they're a popular thing to throw a rock at but anybody that's ever walked through the office of a secondary school on a day when every single adult is sitting there with a student usually writing statements out you understand that administrators play a key role in working with kids every day in the buildings as well so I um I have a hard time with it as well and I hope that this legislature is successful in getting us back to
038a level where we can at least stop eliminating things that we have deemed to be of Great Value um but that's what we've been doing for quite some time yeah I I just want to say a couple things I mean I remember in the 90s where the cutbacks were big um and I was uh engaged in that somewhat my wife at on school boy then so I kind of know that uh and and you saw CER technology equipment actually being disposed of I mean they just didn't happen and when you cut a teacher you cut what they teach so it's not that easy to start looking at this from an impact standpoint but it is good to reflect back and say okay what was the stamping like then because we've expanded Staffing in some areas
039and we didn't in others that that's difficult um I I don't want to cut nurses but they used to be part-time and it was switched from part-time to fulltime putting it under a special ed then it came back out and within it are we going to cut teachers are we going to cut that are we going to cut this everything goes Sports uh the sports that could be um Hockey Association everything else it it moved on we didn't you know they didn't have an option because of the amount of cuts that were there but to reflect back on what the Staffing was like at one point as to comparison maybe a good com maybe a good source of information from my perspective to look back and say okay what what's different about what we're doing
040today compared to then not that it's desirable to go back but um I don't know what the impact is on the educational part of each one of these decisions and that's what it really comes down to to me how are we going to impact the outcom if we cut out summer school we're going to have kids that are not going to um uh graduate on time they're going to they're going to have a difficult time uh by the same token how do you keep summer school going when you don't have the money for regular school um and and so laying it all out there and if we cut sports that's probably less than than the dying kids graduation um I don't know that's the kind of choice that I'm facing and from an economic standpoint
041versus academic is a hate mixing those two together um I appreciate the the thoughts that have been shared already and and really um share the bulk of them all of them um one of the I wanted to emphasize a couple of things that has sh that have um helped shape my thinking number one in survey after survey year after year the community says they care about small class sizes and so one of the guiding um principles for me in this exercise was to minimize increases to people teacher ratios to align and align dollars with instruction to the maximum um ability however you can't do that without as others have said finding other Cuts other efficiencies um I think it's also really important that we uh consider our board policy and best practices with respect to
042fund balance we do live in a place where earthquakes can happen we have seen that we've had unexpected Healthcare uh costs um and I think uh for the purposes of this exercise um you know I clicked on the button that said only utilize up to eight uh spend our fund balance down to 8% um if you spend our fund balance down to 5% you can leverage another $20 million or so uh and that's how we balanced our budget last year but that's not abiding by our own board policy or best practices so um I think that you know thinking about PTR and thinking about what the thinking about the importance of our emergency reserves um um are two critical pieces of how we need to function as a district um there are cuts that I'm
043not happy with that I don't support but I think have to be made to programs and to people in order to balance our budget uh under in my case under the assumption that we won't receive uh anything for the purposes of producing a balanced budget I don't think that we can Bank on action um prior to the second meeting in February that said and I haven't really thought through it yet I am I am interested in conceptualizing an approach to our budget process that would pull things back in a in a layered or prioritized way um whether that's you know walking back any increases in class and ptrs and class sizes maybe that's priority number one uh after we pass a budget um maybe you know programs sports activities Personnel in key areas maybe you
044know that's a second layer of priorities yes exactly after yeah that's a good question after we know you know if we get a BSA of x amount or Y amount or Z amount you know what how are we going to um prioritize uh what we would reincorporate into the budget and I I didn't actually see a way to do that with a software but maybe that's a conversation that we can kind of continue to have um at at some point um so I think this is a a good exercise because it underscores the reality of where we're at um it's also an awful exercise and I hope that um the community members can see uh the challenges that we have before us yeah thank you Mr um just to answer the I think the question
045was asked earlier maybe direct to Administration regarding um what to assume as it build this budget my My Hope and expectation is that Administration would start with um no Assumption of a BSA increase I I don't think that if we're going to do any prognostication that should come from the board and I think there's a really strong case that our situation this year is is marketly different than last year and that we had some really positive um signs and messaging from the executive branch and legislative branch that that we don't have this year Beyond um campaign promises and so um my hope is the legislature takes up the issue in February and we can amend our budget um beyond that I I have concerns about balancing a budget based on projected income um when we
046know so little about the 30 point1 SL thanks anyone else have have any comments I want to make before we move on seeing no one I'll bring this part to a close and we will move to discussion on right sizing um I don't know if the Administration has a presentation to start with or we can go with questions from board members yes so uh Mr President we don't have a formal presentation today the information is similar to what it was on Tuesday um we are prepared to answer any full group questions and I believe there might have been a a wondering if we could discuss the amendment that was put forward on the record last this Tuesday so maybe we open up the flo to either questions comments or discussion member Jacobs did you want
047to speak to the amendment you presented yeah sure um I'll I'll just open the section of the conversations I hope any other board member who who has wonderings of an amendment um or um of their own or has questions about mine you know certainly open to that conversation now um but I'm hopeful to to provide some clarity to our community before we leave today if there are things in the works as I think that would be more transparent and and hopefully a helpful process so our conversation the 17th um doesn't need to to drag on and um continue into feature meetings so I'll just read the amendment one um it's been attached to multiple agendas both our 123 meeting as well as the joint um assembly school board meeting which happened yesterday um so this
048uh Jacob's Amendment one would add the following language to the end of ASD memorandum number 073 in addition to the recommendations pertinent facts and summary listed above adoption of memorandum number 073 by the uh anchor School District School Board shall constitute direction to the administration to pursue and complete the following actions uh number one expand to elementary school monor program to greates K through six effective for the 2526 school year and Beyond which will align the program scope with as's other closely related program Denali mon uh two provide a revised six-year Capital Improvement plan or CIP to the school board for adoption which reprioritizes necessary capital investment in Wonder Park Elementary School to address major structural improvements to increase educational adequacy uh three relinquish management control for the roughly 24 and 34 acre parcel of
049land located um at 2955 molding road to the municipality uh of Anchorage or Mo MOA as the property is access to the current and projected future needs of ASD the parcel is also right for redevelopment with future decisions on intended use to be made by MOA leadership and then fourth begin collaborating with all Charter programs uh that are being considered for placement in Baxter Elementary fir Lake Elementary lakeh hood and naaka Elementary which are the four programs still on the memorandum number 073 at this point uh to negotiate program specific lease agreements containing a student transportation plan the proposed agreements and plans should be provided to the board for approval as an addendum to the program's Charter application the administration trip leverage funding allocated to ASD via Alaska statutory student transportation funding formula located in
050as1409 do10 equal to the Charter School's average daily membership or ADM coupled with matching funds of a percentage to be determined from the Charter School's annual program budget made available via reduction in program overhead expenses which will be realized post relocation to an ACD facility to address the following Schoolboard guard rail quote the superintendent will not leave under representation in Lottery application based programs on addressed and quote so that's um just for the record what is being proposed and what's been attached to multiple agendas again I'm happy to answer questions if there are any I think it's it's toly self-explanatory and um takes things that I think have have long been considered um and utilizes this opportunity to make potential um positive improvements both um to the plan that's being proposed as well as um
051provides tools onto the district as well as the Municipality of Anchorage to improve lives for students families and citizens um but in addition to to this amendment if there's any others being considered I'd be happy to hear and talk about those two thanks thank you any other board members have discussion questions regarding the proposed Essence I think it's a really thoughtful um Amendment and supportive of U I think all four of the point and princip um the one word that stuck out to me and I thought H maybe we need to work through that in a friendly way is a transportation plan seems like we need something more specific we would need something more specific than um than than just point and so I'd be interested in and thinking through that uh in another in
052another way um and I also think because we don't necessarily know what the board will do with the bulk of memo zero 73 that we might just delete the names of the specific schools and you know substitute the words closed District facilities or something like that for the names of the specific schools Mr chair could I respond briefly okay thank you um so yeah regarding ALS I'll start in reverse order um replacing the specific names of programs um with a more general term um was an idea I had I chose not to pursue it based off of just the language currently in the memo and so the amendment just frankly ref reflects what's in the memo right now um I wouldn't object to a substitution of um a more general term I think that though
053I I hadn't heard any board member wishing to modify the plan and so I felt comfortable listing the flood programs based off of that um and so yeah happy to further discuss and then the the transportation plan um Ling langage certainly can be modified my my hope is in effect what it constitutes is a um a commitment to the between Administration and the and the particular Charter program that realizes utilization of the excess capacity within a district facility to break down the barrier that many families have to our Charter programs which is transportation recognizing that there are others including awareness um and then also meal service a number of Charter programs and so how we want to to frame that um I think is is certainly fine I think in function it would act as
054like an addendum to um a charter application and agreement um yeah but beyond that conceptually speaking I'm not opposed to either of those things I think it's really just relabeling the the underlying intent thanks I would say that so far um when we've talked about possible consolidations of schools we at least at the board level we've not really discussed details of what would happen to buildings after the Administration has mentioned it um and I think it's reasonable that they do but I will say that in responding to emails uh to the public especially from uh charter schools that are looking to relocate in I've made it very clear that that my that's I it was never an action by the board I say my feeling that the board wants to consider relocations or consolidations I'm
055sorry um on their own merits without looking at how that building will be used later I.E uh if we're going to consolidate nunaka into two other buildings I want to make that decision based on what I feel like is right for that school and the students in the district um without going oh and we be able to do this with the building it because it is a neighborhood school and the neighborhood so invested in it I feel like that's the fair way to go forward uh and then once that decision is made of course we will do something with the building and we want to make the best use of it for students and for the district and I would say at this time the the four B at Point would be very relevant um
056but in the process of just ass in consolidations um we're not quite there yet that and other board members may actually feel differently about this if you do I need to know because it means I've been misrepresenting your your feelings on it but but my feeling has been that the board is just looking at the consolidations based on what happens to the students in that school um what their destination is what their travel times are what programs we disrupt as Etc period uh and then once we've made the decisions about that then we will move to what's the best use of those buildings and I I do think it's a good idea that as we bring more uh Charters into ASD buildings that we we try to come up with a plan for transportation or
057something that makes the use of our special programs more Equitable to everybody because there there is a basic inequity to it uh that we've endured for a very long time because the solution is difficult and complicated so I'll say if any board members disagree with that please speak up and I will change my message to the public Mr chair can I just respond Lely yeah so um I think I can add Clarity the um I think it's important to note that the um the administration as a part of the right sizing initiative did propose a a utilization for each of the facilities so um the amendment is not to indicate that the repurposing is driving the memorandum this amendment was to indicate that based off of what's been publicly released um I in my opinion
058there should be qualifiers as to if the proposed plan is to move forward um these items should be in place and so um I agree with your stance that the right sizing issue should be considered on the merits however um in addition to that since we've released a partial Vision at the administrative level as to what happens next I think we should add in more context and details to what that looks like I think that is appropriate um and frankly I think the last bull point is a guardrail more than additional context is to say that if these details and the proposed utilization are to be approved these um things should underpin that vision and so I don't think it's um a change in perspective or asking that the legalization should drive the bus so
059to speak I think it's really just putting a guardrail in U before the proposal is approved which includes um you know indicating at this point that the utilization for each of the four buildings I believe from the administration they publicly stated that they would recommend utilization of a charter program and so before um I consider supporting it I would want that guardrail in place and I would hope the rest of us do too because we've agreed frankly um you um unanimously to this guardrail regarding under representation and Charter and optional program so this really is an extension of acting on that so I think your messaging has been appropriate and I don't think this conflicts with it whatsoever and and I would ask the administration that when it is presented to us for a vote
060that it strictly be about the consolidations and then we'll see how that goes and what the outcome is and then at that point uh come to us with recommendations for later utilization of buildings I I would like those two things to St separate as business items anyone else member B thank you Mr chair just a couple of comments um regarding the uh the Jacob's Amendment one uh I I also see that there should be you know once we get to this part in our process it's not just Transportation but it's meals and it's some of the requirements that Charter Schools uh have can be um as member uh Higgins and I were talking earlier can be barriers so we would have to look at the totality of of the Charter School uh of how do
061we have how do we create more access to Charter Schools uh depending on what decision the board makes but I did want to call the board's attention to uh resolutions that we received within the last 24 hours from uh Northeast uh Community Council as as well as Scenic Foothills Community Council uh there were two from uh Northeast and one from uh Scenic Park I did forward those uh I think one the the Northeast uh resolutions just came uh you would have got them late last night or early this morning and that came to the school Bo School District box joint box uh I mailed out yesterday I just forwarded the ones that we got from uh that that I received yesterday so please read through those um there still are some significant questions um that
062that are raised in both in all three because there's there's a total of three resolutions uh one one question I have for the administration that I promised uh I would would forward is you know what happens to title one kids when we move kids from one school into another I know we like to say the money goes with them but what happens what happens to those Title One funds so the total amount of Title One funds the district receives doesn't change um but if you're if you are currently in a title one school um and then you move to a school that's not a title one school that school may or may not get Title One status um with with some caveats so like Nuna Valley this year is a title one school but likely
063won't be next year because they're down to about 26% um tutor is a title one I mean there's title always changes it rotates around um so it's not fixed under their current plan not knowing what parent choice might be um if all of those students that are at newa in supposed to go to college gate College gate would now become a title one school next year so the way that we can help um ease that transition is I I think uh for the school board well all these school board members have been here for a while one of the challenges uh biggest challenges that we can help with is food um you know we have made we can move schools around and group them separately in order to make a gaining School a c school
064not always but in many cases we we certainly have that flexibility um I think there's some confusion about how much money a school actually gets Title One when you're looking at a school of 180 kids or less they may get a little around $100,000 tops which is not even enough for one teacher it ends up being supplies and some other things um C though where they don't have to pay for um food that's that's a big difference the challenge we've had as long as I've been in the district with C schools is when a student leaves a c school and goes to a nonce school um because of federal regulations that family has never turned in paperwork to even be allowed to be um free and reduced at the gaining school so so that's why
065you certainly look at first try to get can the gaining schools be a c because we know that there's this huge population that comes in they've never paid for a meal the whole time their child was in school and now all of a sudden they get a phone call or an email saying hey you owe us money and and many many residents don't understand why they didn't pay before and now they they're owing money because they didn't pay so we know that we would have to do a very active campaign with those family members in the springtime we still can't accept paperwork for free and reduced as long as they're at that school because federal law won't allow it um but we can uh prepare them inform them and be ready as soon as school's
066out to start receiving those applications thank you can I ask one more question yeah because that that that is a a concern um and a significant one and so that I appreciate that information the other uh piece that I have responded to and I just want to make sure my response was correct had to do with preferential um enrollment for students in the neighborhood when it comes to Charters or special programs um do we I and I I know that when I know like with chth optional and maybe denal monu there was this I I'm understanding that there was a certain um pref number or prefer preference for neighborhood kids there was space for neighborhood kids uh is that going to continue or did I get that entirely wrong so currently at tutter there is
067a preference for neighborhood students um if students were to go are you asking if they that would continue as is to yeah depending on the decisions that the board makes right so if a charter went into one the school um is it possible or I mean can we have a preferential slot for families in that neighborhood Who choose that Charter yeah no yes we can um so part of part of the agreement and Jim could speak more to the probably contract process but part of the agreement if we were to look at Charter Schools um in repurposed uh neighborhood schools is that we would put an agreement in there with the charter school that we give neighborhood preference for that neighborhood the the only exceptions might be if it's a charter school that is an
068immersion program and if someone didn't know the language and they're in fourth grade they wouldn't necessarily I think it's Den allei is not a chter school of course it's an optional program so it's not separated out quite the same way with you know in in that sensey dynasty just like the tutor with the monory is part of the regular school system it's not separated as a charter but you're right it's not a charter but virally same thing they've got ABC school and the boundaries there and they obviously get it and other people have to opt in and denalii I've been heavily involved with in the past and it's the same situation um I'm I'm looking at this on the right sizing and I just got a lot of questions still because I'm trying to figure
069out with the some of the recent changes what what the goal is and what we're hoping to accomplish because a couple years ago it started off with the legislative issues about you know what the legislature wanted us to downsize and then it became a finance issue how much we could save and I still remember with the presentation um that was pretty thorough by Mr Anderson and laid out how much savings we might have and the I remember a famous statement if anybody watching this if they understand it they would agree and it was all based on finances this time is based on the issue of the joint classrooms but then we turn around and we say Okay um Bear Valley is not joint but that's going to be okay because the school is fully utilized
070so that's a different criteria to me and then I look at one to park and we're going to transfer things in fully utilize it and so that that's going to make it okay but it's not expanding number of classrooms so I am confused on what the criteria is because it seems to be changing and my bottom line of course is academics I mean we're hearing back we're hearing bachor with the issue of the special ed issues and the other issues of how academics and connection with parents and if we fund it right and we do other things small schools can do better than bigger schools but I appreciate the comments the superintendent has made on that because it's an acknowledgement but the goal seems to be changing because if if if one department is okay
071because we bring in preschool another activities because the school is fully filled it doesn't address the origin the revised goal of combinations of eliminating combinations by having multiple classes in each grade so beay Valley everything that was in Bay Valley I don't know what we heard from the public but I went in there the day after the first school day after that and everything that was said I could see in there anyway I mean I saw the Bear Valley Community Association I saw the the way they were using it with preschool and after school and all everything else they were doing so I'm confused what the bottom line is we moved a lot of kids from sixth grade into middle school and when we did that we've got overc capacity in two schools big time
072and and I don't and the goal there told in the public meeting was well because we have some kids we have middle schools but sixth grade some without we want everything to be the same but I just I the bottom line is academics and I'm not sure right now what the go is anymore because it seems to have changed with Wonder Park and with Bear Valley it's okay now and the others are not so I'm I'm really literally very honestly confused I think I can talk to that I I don't think anything has changed frankly back in April we talked about as part of Education levels of service knowing that we had high need low density staff spread across multiple schools knowing that we had childcare shortfalls and we were going to specifically look at
073that as part of repurposing and that's been now about I don't know over six months that we've been talking it so at Wonder Park when we relooked it um I I don't know how many board members know um the prek at Wonder Park and Tagan and uh new NAA Valley but if you compile and put all of them in one location then even if we have shortages which we do across the district in parapros we have a better chance of providing consistent academic support to all those prek programs if you compile them all in one location and when you look at be Valley and you look at what they're going to be able to do in the next two years as they grow out full day child care I think again I've been we've been
074very consistent in repurposing um really from the very first brief in April and then again in June and then in August September October and November the additional eight meetings we we have always had repurposing as uh a component of right sizing it wasn't ever about just closing and combining so I understand maybe I didn't brief it right or maybe I made the wrong charts but I think we've been very very consistent we'll try to clarify a little bit I know the a key thing we've heard is about the number of sections at each grade level and if we move in U say prek or uh kindergarten units and we more fully utilize the building that doesn't really change the sections at grade level and I I think what uh M Higgins may be asking is
075is that really the driving thing or or is it a mix of things that varies a little bit from one location to right it really is a mix I mean we're not doing right by prek either um when we looked at all of the schools we had in East Anchorage um after hearing the community come out and talk about you know what else can be done in the East Anchorage area we did start looking at schools again we did look at be Valley I mean quite honestly the community conversations were a thousand times better than the town halls we did two years ago um you know two years ago we basically had open mic night where maybe 30 people over the course of an hour and a half could express their concerns this time we
076had 30 staff members Plus board members talking to 30 plus people at any one time for Two Plus hours um so we received much more feedback than the classic Town Hall type format and something that was was pretty broadly heard was on the east side and and I probably more than anyone in this room understand just how close all those schools are um and why just because of proximity and low usage rates you would naturally come up with more easts Side schools than you would north or south or West um at the same time I think the community was was pretty loud and consistent about um their concerns and you know one thing that came out not just during the community conversations but when a couple board members and I went to one of the
077uh Community Council meetings on Northeast Side and someone got up and talked about the reality and they saw it too that there was a lot of residents that were zoning out of their Eastside schools and instead of you know continuing to allow that to happen how does the community reimagine um how do you make a school um have the capacity and and a unique Niche that actually draws some of those people not to leave their school area and when you look at it from that perspective you start looking at not just today's numbers and down you know 5 years down the road 2 to 2.3% per year um you know reductions in enrollment but you look at you know frankly how do you um actually help that Community by putting something unique so people don't
078leave that Community to go to a special school so let's take Baxter for example um 46% of all the kids that are zoned in for Baxter leave and they go to 29 different schools um when I look at that list of all the schools they go to many of them are Charter Schools but they're also all these unique special programs um and you know I I think it is worth looking at reimagining how do you create some something such as moving a charter school that has capacity to grow into the East Side um and we won't pick any specific name until January but you know let's let's pick one charter school that we actually saw shrink and grow in the last four years um anccs when we had to move them out of their building
079when we found out they had no ventilation and we moved them to East High they lost 100 kids in one year when we put them in a building where there was the capacity to grow and neighborhood kids could still walk to school and choose that charter school they grew by 120 so it is real the numbers have shown that if you put a program in an area where someone can walk to it still if that's their Preference they may not choose to go outside the neighborhood they live in and you know really I I think we've come up with something that that makes sense and and presents options for families and I think we need some time to figure out what does Wonder Park look like in the future and what is it going to
080hold but at this time we also had two classes of prek at Tagan where they really couldn't support each other we had two classes at Wonder Park where they really couldn't support each other and seven at nunaka Valley but when you put all 11 together they can support each each other and you're going to have a higher quality or at least a better chance of having higher quality with full support by putting them in one location so there is no one thing that should rule or drive every single decision I think just it's all about academics and part of that is crial involvement and that's what we're hearing from the community the connection there being associated with school being the outcomes is part of it the question is what's going to how what's going to
081help the kids most academically small schools pay off we that's not that's not a dispute um we have the issues of pral involvement which is really critical and when we spread this out we take things away we're hearing from the community hot and heavy the impact there um you know we're making changes sometimes that we going to have to reflect back on uh 6 grade to middle school I'm going to ask for five years what the academic growth the sixth grad is and I'm going to compare that to the to the to the mayor's 120% capacity we make the same thing we got impacts after the fact and I'm just concerned about what's going to give us the best academic outcomes not based on just quickly we could combine schools to do something um I
082I'm really concerned about the academic impact and if we look at it afterin the last two weeks we had the issue of tan come up and it's theying by for the first time and it's crops that there's a lot of cost Associated we didn't hear I mean that it it seems like that would have been worked out beforehand or something but uh because moving around with these issues with these kids B is a good example with the special head issues I'm concerned about outcome and I if we can switch the con conversation somewhat academic outcome to how it's going to be positive and negative those pros and cons I don't think we're listening for what the proposal neighborh so Mr President if I may talk a little bit over here sorry I'm behind Andy um
083so if I could talk a little bit about just the academic um benefits that we've seen if you if the board recalls the presentation about um Abbot Loop moving to kassoon and Trailside we shared some academic data that showed um significant academic gains for those students moving to those schools through the move process um and so and and part of that is um because of having additional teachers per grade level the ability for those teachers to collaborate around student needs it also allows support staff to be at schools in a more full-time basis so we're not um only serving students with um special needs such as occupational therapy or speech or other special education services or Support Services through elll in a part-time status so that those teachers are there on a more full-time basis
084so I I just remind um the board to think about that particular move and and the gains that we've seen yeah just to follow up last void meeting in the wood was marginal increases and now was significant I I and I'm talking to the schools and getting different information so I'm going to be looking for get that report I'd like to add see the the the academics and how you arrived at that because I'm getting different information I'm just sharing with that and I don't know that that uh one example applies across is that something to be assumed because we know the the studies show with small schools verus large schools with the the parents involvement all that's impacting uh I just don't see that applying to all the schooles that looking but uh I
085would like to see the report and how it was gathered because I'm getting some information different and when I heard marginal ver is now significant it just comes across different well anyway we've kind of taken a little bit of a detour uh it's always been clear to me that the right sizing while we disagree and we and we may look at our data differently that it's it's about improving opportunities and outcomes for students so that is not a question in my mind um what helps me make the decision relative to what is the best for the kids and the teachers who are teaching the kids it really has to do with you know part of the biggest part is the resources I mean what what is it it's not about a a combination class it
086would be great I've taught combination classes they are difficult to teach they're not impossible but I thought I was a pretty darn good teacher and I had a lot of good resources um but I also look at the opportunities that are missing for our students as I look through through the across the district we we we created an absolute amazing Choice program I mean our parents have choiced where their kids go but they Spen those kids out of the neighborhood school so if we're at some point we've got to have a conversation about just Choice itself I'm not advocating to take away people's choices but we cannot neighborhood schools cannot fight they they don't have the energy and the resources to fight these to fight these um you know the these these op these other
087kinds of programs and it does end up as you'll see in a couple of the re the the the resolution NE neighborhood kids kind of get kicked neighborhood schools rather I mean they they they are where they are they have the kids that they have but they can't stop kids from wanting to and families from wanting to go someplace else so we created this Maze of we we created just a a cycle of which is why I asked for the enrollment I want to know the kids who should be at Nuna why are they not going there but where are they going and I think when we look at what we created and and this is a this is not a criticism it's a observation we've created places for people to go and now we're
088and now we're in a situation where we can't afford to keep every school as it's been for the last 50 years we just can't and so it's never uh it's never been it's always been about student outcomes for me I don't I don't have that issue I do worry though when it comes to our SLP program and when it comes to way I'm Gonna Keep harping on wayy I want to know what's going to happen with way uh whether we create a specialed resource center wherever that is I don't know if whether we do a resource whatever I don't know what that's going to be like but that's one of the things that I have to have more resource around and then uh the programs are are you know my my grandson was part of
089the SLP program at uh NAA we loved it there he grew he thrived there and while it was during covid I mean that was a gods for for my family so I I I do have a a special um Affinity toward the programs and how that how we if the board based on what the board decides what are the steps we're going to take to make sure those transitions are are uh very sensitive and and and appropriate um it because that's a huge question I understand what it takes for my grandson to adjust to a new place and new people not that it's impossible for him to do it right but there's some things that I know we know we have to do differently uh in in in preparing for that so can anybody speak
090to uh to to to what that might look like and I'm sorry Pam I didn't you oh ke is there too so between the two of you if you can talk yeah if I could start and then I'll have uh tarisha and Pam come join me at a mic up here um so in terms of just overall kids um the academic team as soon as the board makes a decision will start planning some of the transitions that are necessary so that kids and families are are well received um we have a really good template that we've we've used through the Abbott Loop closure um and other special ed programs that we've needed to move in the past um but for overall kids will be able to we will create opportunities for them to see their
091new space um teachers as well uh we will probably plan some parent and family nights as well so that they can um be received in their new uh School environment and we will work on what that looks like in more detail but um those are really sensitive um moves that we want to um create a welcoming um environment for all kids that are coming to that new location so um we even bought School t-shirts for students that were leaving Abbot Loop um that were you know going to other locations so that when they showed up on the first Daye of school they had their school gear um those types of things and then I'll turn it over to Pam and tarisha so they could talk a little bit more about what program moves look like
092um because there there's an extensive process there as well um so I really do appreciate the conversation about this because it is something that's on the Forefront of our minds when we're talking about right sizing and the effects that it has on special education students especially the the ones that are in our special programs um these are not decisions that we take lightly but we do know that in the bigger picture of looking at repurposing schools and moving forward with um any type of potential school closures that does affect our special education population um we do have um 11 schools that house SLC programs right now in the elementary schools so when we talk about elementary schools potentially closing um the likelihood that it's going to affect some type of special program is pretty high
093um we also have five schools that house sbbs um and we have I believe eight or nine schools that house our life skills programs um so that's quite a bit of and they're all in different schools um so I can talk a little bit about the plan for students and parents and staff and then tarisha can talk about the work that she's doing from um making sure that the spaces are adequate to receive um students in special programs um so kind of like what kerson said this isn't the first time that we have moved special programs it is something that we are very sensitive to because we do know that our students with disabilities tend to have um a tougher time with transitions um so we are treating it very um delicately with them as
094well as as the staff um this last year due to the increasing numbers of students who meet the eligibility for our special programs we've actually expanded we went through something we called the special programs expansion plan where we opened up four additional SLC sites we opened up a life skills site at a different school as well as two sbbs sites in the district and so we do have a comprehensive plan on staff trainings um we start that very early as soon as decision are made we actually have gone into the schools and have participated in staff meetings um we've also provided uh trainings in the spring we don't wait until students show up in the fall and these trainings are available not just to special education teachers but also general education teachers because they will
095also be welcoming students into their their schools um when it comes to students um we do offer um the ability to visit their schools early visit their teachers uh we create lots of visuals for them to um get to know the different staff members at their school whether it's the new art teacher or the new principal or their new uh special education teacher um we offer them the opportunity to visit classrooms to uh do walkthroughs of the building to see you know where am I going to have PE where am I going to eat lunch um and then when it comes to family we also um will be offering U different types of family nights like like Kon said uh just to allow the families to come in and familiarize themselves with the school and
096the staff as well okay um as it relates to the logistics and operation side of special education we've been working closely with capital planning and construction and maintenance as a Rel to doing walkthroughs of um uh pre-identified schools to see if the program would be a good fit for specific classrooms um what it looks like for exits what it looks like for safety concerns that may exist around the school whether it's near um a main road or if it's um near a playground uh that that classroom is near a playground um some of the other things that we've been working on is creating a list of um classroom specif specifications very similar to what we do in our Ed specs process but specific for every special program to determine these types of classrooms no matter
097what location they're they're in we have these specific specifications that we'll have for every single classroom to ensure safety to ensure to ensure um increased instructional um capacity for our students whether it be in a life skills program where there's a need for a bathroom and a changing table and there's enough space for that um what one of the other things that we've also been doing is going out going around to our current locations to see what things are working what things aren't working so that we can modify those um modify those classrooms or those areas to make it more appropriate yeah and member bamy the last thing I would just um add to the equation of the transition plan is um Staffing um one of the things that we are doing through the right
098sizing process um and moving programs is ensuring that staff who are currently with students have the preferential placement of following students if they would um like to so it the employees still have a choice in that system um about whether they follow students or not um through the Staffing process but we would um give them preferential treatment and placement um so that we have familiar places in their new um homes so member L member Don and member Jacobs I think is third he's already spoken coup um I think I want to just draw us back to where this conversation started which was the amendment by member Jacobs and uh I don't have a final product fully ready to share but I will likely be interested in bringing uh perhaps an amendment to the amendment via
099an additional bullet point or something to that effect um that would uh recommend uh that the administration brings forward um no later than next fall sometime um the names of one or more additional schools for closure consolidation for the 26 27 school year but whose effect would be to prioritize number one the rec the reduction of combination classes and class sizes among elementary students enrolled on the neighborhood side of schools competing special programs and really number two improved access to robust course offerings and services among secondary students and I think that those two things for me right now are missing in the current plan um I guess I'll begin with the latter concern um it has certainly been said that one of the positive outcomes of the consolidation process is to improve secondary course offerings
100and we've seen no proposals uh to do so um I believe that that is true um I believe that uh should we balance our budget in the really challenging and awful truly awful ways that I think that are it's going to have to be challenged that we have secondary schools that are going to struggle enormously with offering um adequate numbers of courses uh because they're small size and small FTE allocations are um are going to make offering school to those students are challenging um I'm really concerned that the focus on school size and utilization overlooks the reality that um we actually have schools that are not so small but on the neighborhood side of the school things are very small and so you may have a really disproportionate number of combo classes or large class
101sizes on the neighborhood side of things and so I think I would like to see those students academic Services prioritized in perhaps a second look at the school consolidation needs for the district as a whole uh in another you know year's time essentially um I'm also interested and again kind of still working through some of the language and perhaps a second amendment that would potentially um be able to capitalize upon any legislative action that's taken swiftly in January so if prior to the board's second meeting in February which is when we have to pass a balanced budget um that based student allocation statutorily adjusted translation since fy1 and if additional legislation is passed which would adjust that BSA to account for inflation on an annual basis and that's thing which coming out of the joint
102resolution should it be passed um the board would be able to utilize that information that statutory guarantee to really reconsider whatever is approved by memo 73's Passage and because I think I really believe that additional resources should they become available will allow us to improve the services we give to students because we will have additional FTE we will have additional opportunities to hire teachers and if we have additional dollars to allocate towards teachers that means we need additional classrooms and that means that we can have small class sizes and we can have fewer combo classes which would mean in turn that we should re evaluate whatever is passed by memo 73 so I'm working on on some of those thought levels right now um but I'd like to present an amendment which ultimately um focuses
103the attention where it belong which is a you know yeah Alo regarding amendment number one um so it's got four parts um some of these parts aren't very relevant to the question of closing schools or and it seems like it's sort of turning memorandum 73 in some sort of Omnibus legislation here um if tutors no longer going to be considered for closure then you know while I actually agree with this provision about the K through 8 for monor um it seems like it's misplaced in resolution 73 to do so it's be a subject of an entire res separate resolution um also changing the six-year Capital plan which we just passed um I've been told many times over the years well it's six-year plan is merely a guidance be changed every year we review that and
104since Wonder park at this point in time doesn't appear to be although could be subject to an amendment to put it back in um it seems not particularly relevant to change the six-year plan at this point in time in resolution 73 to address it um and the whole question of relinquishing control over of the three sites we have around town for future school um seems to stand alone on its some also um doesn't really have anything to do with closing schools um but it's a legitimate question to come before the board whether to turn over those sites back to the city of anch but it would seem to Merit some pretty substantial debate and Analysis um Beyond just the closing of schools issues that we were faced with in 73 and then this additional guidance
105or conditional regarding Charter Schools kind of begs the question of the whole situation with Charter Schools moving into our existing buildings and we we've been struggling with that as a board um all the way back to an aquarium needed upgrades because they were the only Charter School in a ASD facility and traditionally ASD had not paid for they don't pay rent right um and we had paid for any improvements to the building because we it seemed unfair to other Charter Schools if we were going to do it for one charter school but not for others and now for moving charter schools into these schools we really need a standard policy for addressing this and to just peace meal address the transportation issue only and not address the bigger question in the room is how we're
106going to address these Charter Schools the cost of maintaining those schools if we we move into them seems to be the cart before the horse for me even if it is one of the Bo's um guard rails um to try to address you know Fair access to Charter Schools so the bigger questions to me is are we going to maintain these schools with our own funds or through bond funds but we haven't done that in the past or how are we going to handle them moving in there um so these are all questions that would Merit entire resolutions separately um and I don't know if starting to slam all these on to something as controversial as closing down schools specifically is is a wise idea because what happens with these Christmas tree type things is
107things will collapse eventually under their own weight there's things here that people might not be happy with but they might support closing some of the schools you're going to force them to vote against the whole thing but of course you can do whatever you want with four votes long you don't break the rules yeah thanks um so appreciate the the question regarding the amendment being Germain um the the resolution um amend 73 specifically um is about the right sizing process which had multiple different categories as to how buildings came to be recommended which included utilization um current state of the building related to um their capital investment um the um number of students that existed in an attendance set a program as part of their neighborhood School versus um watering in um as well as
108a proposal to reutilize the facilities for particular purposes um of which point by Administration has been proposed that the four uh buildings are to be considered for utilization by in placement of a charart program in them so um it's pretty clear that this amendment is entirely germine based on the conversations that have happened and the underlying information that um was utilized to consider um the right sizing initiative uh the tutor Elementary piece specifically addresses capacity of of that particular building and utilization so that will change that tutor Elementary tutor Elementary's utilization rate so again Germain um the CIP um and the state of the the buildings um particularly for Wonder Park as it was on a previous CIP and then removed a few years back um again speaks to facility condition again that's Germain um
109the um the best argument that could be made um is for the the land parcel on Malon Road um I would consider this um to be right sizing our portfolio of properties that that we have management rights over and so I think it certainly fits the spirit of right sizing um I also think that it's something the community has long asked for as a part of our right sizing effort not just buildings but also um the property that we have management rights over and so again I think that very clearly meets the spirit of um the underlying desire to to move forward with right sizing as proposed by Administration and then um the last item really is a a guard rail um based on the administrative recommendation to pursue utilizing these spaces for Charter programs
110um I I agree frankly there needs to be a conversation as to how to move forward with capital investment these buildings um specific to bonds um I think the district has set a precedent at this point for at least one program of placing them on a bond um I think that that conversation could cons could continue and I think I could even conceptually um agree to Future Bond propositions that include a program um that exists in a building that is managed by ASD provided that program is providing um the same level of service that our neighborhood schools um provide to include transportation and meal service where those barriers are broken down and I think there might have been some hesitance um I part of that debate years ago in part because there's a huge disparity
111in the level of service provided by Charter programs that don't biomark provide transportation that don't biomark provide meal service um which is one of the major reasons why there's a disparity in t t programs um within the um Municipality of Anchorage and in at least some cases um so with that said I I think it's very clear that this amendments remain but I do appreciate the the concern about um you know adding things to the proposal um folks may not support um for me these items constitute things that I would like to see to support the broader proposal and so that's why I propos the amendment but also gave it plenty of time to socialize and further discuss um and I'm open to amendments to consider um tweaking the amendment if if board members would
112like with that said I'm going to circle back to the original conversation you know board member mentioned that they were confused about um why right sizing um makes sense for the district and I I emphathize with that confusion um it's a complicated topic especially if you only focus at the district level and below and um utilize kind of a view only the tip of the iceberg um right sizing for me has never been just about a district um situation but really the state as the whole when we have now migration at the state level when we have um a unsustainable and and flat education funding do in part to um our state's lack of a long-term fiscal plan um when we have a situation in Anchor specifically where child care and housing is often unaffordable
113for many residents um it it paints a um a picture and provides a foundation of um a scenario that isn't always welcoming to families with young children um you couple that with um the loss of um students that we've experienced to parents utilizing Choice options which is great and then declining birth rates and um you have a situation where we have a number of facilities uh that's based off of a population that we no longer have and so um there are financial implications in that there are student outcome implications um within that um number of factors um it's it's not one or the other and so um it is truly a um a combination of factors and so that's the lens I'm bring to the conversation um and I think we all are bringing a
114lens of of outcomes focused and I think the superintendent I'll I'll flag something that was said yesterday in The Joint School Board assembly meeting that um there isn't a choice between current um operations and Status Quo and changes that are proposed in this memorandum um for example we just heard naaka Valley for instance is going to lose his title status next year um if we do nothing there would be negative impact all by students and in the same way when we talked about school start times um we really went into that conversation with our eyes wide open that um doing nothing had a negative impact for um older adolescence with relation to the amount of sleep that they get and the um outcomes related to student performance as well as physical and mental health at
115a company the changes that were made and so I think it's just important to Circle back to um this not being a status quo versus change conversation this is a um negative impacts to students versus um change which could facilitate positive things as well as impacts for students um based on a whole host of factors outside of our control and so having that 30,000 foot view I think avoids that confusion and provides some clarity for us for the board you're making a decision thanks so we are at our stated determent time um a question to board members if you have a burning question we need to vote to extend uh if not um I think one of the things we can all agree on is this is probably one of the more complex issues we
116take up and uh every time we talk about it even if the discussion is unclear I feel like I learn a lot so does anyone wish to extend anyone have further questions if not I do want to thank everyone that came to watch I appreciate the staff turning out early on the Saturday our apologies to all of you over all that uh and I will declare aurn thank you