001e e e value of the dollar um look at that in another way if we were to inflation approve since 2011 the Gap the BSA would need to be included increased by about $1,963 to tie to 2011 spending power you see some other bars in there with the use of fund balance and state onetime funds that's largely how we've been able to balance the budget over the years uh some of those gaps in there would be Cuts so increasing the PTR decreasing other staff Staffing but really as we're looking at this you know the long-term sustainable financial plan just hasn't been there so we get into the situation where we're have this large and ever growing structural deficit um so into our perform budget you know it's really based on our foundation formula that's in
002statute and that multiplies the number of kids through a series of adjustments including um how much each uh the cost of doing business in each district a special needs factor of 20% another CTE factor of 1 and a half% and then intensive need students get 13 times the student count then we add on the back end the correspondence which is 90% of the uh enrollment essentially so it all adds up to that for 41 you know 750 students to start with or 8m gets to about 71,000 and an adjusted ADM uh so when you're talking about BSA increases you can look at that 71,000 uh adjusted ADM number and multiply that by the increase so if the increase was $1,000 multiply that by 71,000 you get 71 million that's how much that's how you can
003rough out additional state revenue based on BSA increases is using that about 71,000 ADM metric um so some of the carats as we're going through this there's a lot of unknowns we have some unsettled contracts that uh have quite a large dollar value to that we haven't Incorporated requests from other departments that might change how they operate or do business in here um and then also is kind of the the local contribution that's where the assembly comes in uh in the mayor's offices we try to support that one of the big drivers that we have from 25 to 26 going into it is that uh required local contribution increase so you see that's about a little over 7 and a half million and that's based on property values and it would be tied to the
004the 2024 uh assessed valuation so as property values go up so does the required local contribution um that additional Lo local contribution is actually going down as that's tied to state revenue and that's gone down based on enrollment so as our enrollments gone down our state uh funding tied to that enrollment is gone down so our additional local contribution that's allowable also goes down but the required local goes up so overall it will the the total funding or total local contribution ask will be increasing um should be noted that required local contribution as that goes up the state goes down dollar for dollar so 7 and half increase to the taxpayers equals $75 million dollar decrease to the state some things we're walking through these Revenue projections uh to note one of the big ones
005is our fund balance we do not include a usage on fund balance on this uh on our on our Revenue projections we will at the end of the towards the end of the presentation we have about 47 million that we'll be adding back to that so you can really we want to show both the structural deficit and then the actual uh reductions would have to be made but the big ones are that 37 million in fund balance and then the $49 million in the onetime funds that we got that received this year and that was equivalent to about $680 per adjusted ADM that was the in a BSA amount so $680 BSA equivalent in onetime funds is what we received this year um but again it's onetime not in statute so we don't include it
006for the purposes of this presentation um kind of a longer term look at the property values and Anchorage and that required local contribution from 17 to uh July 26 um about 23% increase in property values but same increase in that required local contributions so since about over $24 million has been cost shifted from the city to or from the state to the city uh also Transportation incre hasn't increased at all during that time frame um so the city's put in an additional million dollars for this year uh to help support that Transportation program is you see your transportation like your bus program the cost of that continually increase we have to pay our drivers more uh minimum wage is going to affect that now is the minimum wage law has passed and increased the minimum
007wage what that does too is there statute that allows for or requires bus drivers to be paid twice the minimum wage so as that goes up so does our cost for bus drivers um and that will exceed what currently kind of our starting point in our contracts are um and then you can see that addition allowable contribution going down and that's what's really tied to enrollment for the state found Foundation Revenue going down about a little over 40 million 24 of that is the shift to the required to the city and the rest of it is going to be the um just the loss and enrollment any questions on this this is kind of a Salient point for the assembly anyway as far as relating to tax requests I just like to add real quick
008that Miss been the roll call uh we do have mayor France and the superintendent uh Dr Bryant here in the room with us thank you and assembly member Bry has joined us as well yeah sorry I think I think I um missed it when you said it but the addition so I'm looking at the additional local contribution and went from 101 to 79 M or 97 million um can you remind me what that is so that's the amount that it's tied to the additional alal contribution is tied to 23% what the state calls basic need which is that adjusted ADM number times the base D allocation um so as that uh basic need has gone down with static BSA and lower enrollment um then our additional allowable contribution and that's the max based on the
009maximum amounts so that's gone down just it's really just tied to enrollment thanks so it wasn't a policy Choice it was really just a formula correct yeah um so as we go through and we have to look at these reductions about 85% of our costs go to Personnel right now and 15% non-personnel so when we talk about making reductions generally it's going to have to come out of people um the bigger changes uh projected increase in our uh Personnel cost about 11 and a half million that also includes a reduction in 50 teaching positions that are tied to a loss of students that occurred this year so um and that would be lower than what we budgeted so as we lost students below what we projected um where the those teaching positions go away if
010we keep the same people teacher ratio but that's all factored into this presentation and then our attrition estimates they're currently at budgeted levels we're going to continue to review that to see how many vacancies and folks waving medical insurance and turnover we have as far as our FTE distribution you can see up in the 26 that highlighted box that's where the 50 FTE would come out of for instruction and that's just really reled to a lower enrollment for the cost of those employees here's kind of how that shakes out you see you know it's a little you around a 3% mark on little over on our average salary and wages by function as we go uh as we try to figure out that I mean a lot of these are also unbar at this point
011if they are in the AA Bargain unit and then you'll see that metrics based staff to 4.2 2 million that's actually the reduction of those 50 uh positions uh we have that same amount in the benefits uh for metric based track you see the $1.8 million in online 28 there but overall about 2% increase in total salaries wages and benefits that we're projecting based on um just kind of those aggregate things we seeing and then drop in number of staff and as relates to District administration we did toss this in to see where uh our peers are on administration because we do hear that a lot as your Administration costs are too high um our indirect cost rate is about 5.06% it's one of the lowest in the state so we are going to come
012back to this and you know probably perpetually as people want to talk about Administration and how we can reduce those costs as far as our attrition goes our vacancy rates this is kind of a historical look at where we how many percentage of vacancy is um as percent of our total budget how that's increased over time and I know the cities had the same problems the states have some problems even our know private private companies have we're all having trouble filling a lot of these positions and this is just kind of to graphically illustrate how uh the district has um Beed with those so you can see some spikes in 23 and 24 uh typically or generally that's from our Esser money when we were able to push some staff uh cost in the end
013of the year to close out those grants but we are expecting you know about $40 million in um unspent salary and benefits costs that are going to be factored into our budget so we do we do factor that in so we're not going to have a surplus um but it is ever growing at this point um for our non-personnel expenditures most of that um is contracted Services which includes our utilities and those projected increases are you know Electric telephone garbage about 5% and now I believe need to go back and update this I saw a story on a cost going up by about 5% as well so we are going to have some other things to look at but generally um about 1.7 million overall increase or about 2% and so overall the structural gap
014between what's provided in statute for Revenue versus what we're spending to op what education looks like now as far as operations structural Gap about $107 million um I think we'll have about $47 million in fund balance we can put to towards that uh that brings it down to about our fund balance down to about 5% of our total expenditures and about 1% of that would be actual uh unassigned money that we could use in the place of emergencies which would be equivalent about $6 million so it doesn't give us a lot of flexibility when we spend our fund balance down to that level but if the alternative is cutting another 400 positions plus then I think we'd probably want to go ahead and go that route so that leaves us that's general fund budget about
015uh Gap about $60 million in actual reductions that we would need to make um baring any uh Quick Change by the legislature on some of these funding metrics for transportation we're having similar issues about a $3.8 million gap there um for the purpose of this presentation we've included the 9 million do in property taxes that we received for 2425 as part of the 2526 budget um and then we'll be looking at uh how much room we might have within the context of the the city's tax cap to be able to help maybe offset some of those losses as well there any questions so far this kind of quickly remember BR thanks um so yesterday we had a a energy Retreat that was very instructive and and really talking about um you know big picture issues
016uh but one of them that they brought up was um of course if and when uh energy cost significantly increased both for natural gas that also impacts our electric uh generation and um really that that major payers of utilities like the school district would um be harmed by that so I wonder if um if there is uh if it sounds like you guys had modeled in increases of electricity um you'll need to add water and then those other costs that's kind of the Baseline scenario have you modeled out or thought about um you know what might happen in a significant energy Spike um which you know basically it was discussed that by 2027 that is very likely because of the supply but really um in situations of cold Winters Peak usage um that could come
017sooner so um again not to rehash that conversation but just wondered how how that's been factored into the budget or if that can be thanks um we certainly can factor in it's really easy for us to go back in and model those percentage increases um but we haven't had a really significant increase like that in included in this presentation but we will go back and look at it and um see what other data that we have that we can p the make sure we kind of have enough money to support our usage yeah and I think also it's just something to to have on the radar because as that conversation continues I think we will need to really illustrate the the impacts of those cost increases and and one of the findings was really it's
018hard to it's hard for large organizations to even know what their utility bills are except for the folks who actually pay those bills um and so I think pulling that out because I know it's you said it's in contracted Services now I think um maybe not changing the budget but just if if we were to ask you know how much does for all the school facilities how much do we spend on natural gas I think that would be a useful number to have um in the near future thanks yeah and we do have that all broken out by school by utility so some of the issues member a I just wanted to respond I appreciate the question I remember that we actually discussed this I brought it up in a finance committee meeting round about
019October a year ago um and I remember looking at uh heat for buildings which is a category that you can look at in our budgets going back for a number of years and it looks like this assembly member brondo thank you um so dub tailing on what Anna said which is I'm going far a field a little bit but um we were talking to uh some Renewables and um renewable IP was looking at Community solar farms and they haven't ever explored it but they thought the roof of a school would be a perfect opportunity to do a community solar farm and um could help benefit your energy cost plus the surrounding community so just a member a I sorry I have another response um I think it was at the Alaska Association of school boards
020meeting Senator marowski was speaking and she had recently come from a really Dynamic uh conversation at South High School where a student there had written to the senator and said why can't we have solar panels on our school and I don't have you know the tea leaves in front of me but Senator Makowski sounded very interested in working to support this students initiative so I would be intrigued to see whether there is any kind of additional um support coming from uh from that direction um in response to uh students assembly member broad yeah thanks um and I and I appreciate I know we went on a a tangent about the energy discussion I think it's it's something that's going to continue so we should make sure that we're tracking it but I guess I just
021want to register my concern now and why I think we need to elevate those numbers um going into next session is um that that if there is a spike in energy costs and our budgets are fin I worry that we will have to make cuts to Services because of that utility cost so I just want to say that very clearly um uh that I think it is a risk and so um it's something that I think we need to keep communicating in addition to all of the things that that we know that that You' have put in here that are are already problems um thanks any other questions at this point um I will add in uh that under mayor Burkwood he pressured us a bit about considering solar or wind or or whatnot I
022I mean one I think anything that complicates repairing roof is an issue um because we repair roofs every year I mean it's just a constant in the bond packages and and whatnot so I think there's some concern on that and then also this to some degree the administrative overhead to make it happen that it is kind of a whole SE area that involves wiring into the building um and ours are Complicated by the fact that a lot of our buildings have auxiliary power uh could be shelters and so it would all have to be um coordinated I think if the municipality ever began exploring uh pushing uh the use of Renewables on city property or in Anchorage you know certainly we've got a lot of real estate I've contemplated before if we had solar over
023parking lots at high schools except there's a huge security question about it and of course clearing the snow and all kinds of other things so I I think most people on the border are very supportive of the idea we'd love to see it happen um but it comes with a complication and um if we ever have the expertise available to work through it would be a marvelous thing there's a lot of space out there but cost a while to use it as well thank you please con all right so just uh this the transportation's been an issue Statewide that hasn't been increased in 20156 so this is a Statewide chart that shows since 2013 um the revenue in expenditures you'll see a few anomalies in fy16 there's a spike in expenditures that was actually the
024result of ASD buying a big chunk of buses for our contractor to buy down the long-term cost of that contract um and then in 17 uh Revenue was short funded by the state so districts had to cover that and then in 21 you'll see a drop there in both cost and um revenue and now it's more tied to covid than anything else where we lost students and um we not running buses quite as much but overall then you start to see those cost trending back up and the revenue trending down it's kind of Statewide enrollments TR it down um so really we're going to have to look at a Comin strategies to produce a balance budget for 26 there's nothing easy to pull out and cover $60 million deficits so and then even if we
025were to get some of that money back from the state that's only a short time a shortterm thing because that's going to spend our money down to uh nearly nothing so really we just need some long-term significant Revenue expenditure adjustments that um are inflation approved from and this is really more of a state issue that we can and if we can get a long-term financial plan in place that really helps those long-term instructional plans as well so being able to project out how much money we have and have it tied to inflation is really critical to be able to produce those instructional plans that was the end of it any other questions or comments assembly member BR um bring I'm sorry thanks um so I know in the past uh well so last meeting that
026you had and the presentation that you gave uh to legislators in October which was great um and that I had a chance to attend you talked about the asks being um uh BSA Transportation school on debt reimbursement I believe um and not saying a specific BSA number just saying please please pick something reasonable um so I wonder B based on this budget is there any change to that is there is there um uh an intent to to start using more specific numbers or is it really just presenting um these facts and then saying the decision is up to you guys but here's here's what we're at as a district right I believe we're g to as a you know school board and as a state uh group start advocating towards that inflationary adjustment since 201
027I think that's really where we want to turn and try to get back some of that buying power to be able to decrease our class sizes now have those supports that our students need board member Watson I think it's probably a yes and um I was uh delighted that over the past couple of months um the Alaska Association of school boards uh passed a resolution that didn't put a number in but it did specifically reference um fy11 um so and I know that alaso and the Alaska Council of school administrators they're also really honing in on this uh fy1 which um I can speak to a little bit later um during regarding the joint memo seeing no other questions we move to the 2025 bom good morning I'm Jim Anderson I'm the chief operating officer
028during the last briefing we went through uh or the last joint assembly meeting we went through the PowerPoint briefing that went in details through the uh the proposed bond package and it passed without any amendments by the school board um during uh the last meeting and the am was transmitted and is on its way to the assembly now um quick overview is uh it's our sixth of eight groups of secure vestibules we're continuing to focus on um providing more secure entry ways to our elementary school buildings um one or two more bonds and we'll be done with all of our elementary schools and then we'll start looking at middle school and high school which are certainly much more complex um the secure vestibule basically it it uh is a good mechanism where someone can't enter
029the initial door uh without being buzzed in and then once they get in they're in a vestibule area where they also can't still access the school until being uh buzzed in into the school office we are implementing Raptor a new um automated program that does a quick background check on people before um they're now allowed access into the school uh in in one of our earlier secure vestibule designs it was in October of 2018 um these actually work exactly as planned um we had two adults in the parking lot getting an argument uh one of the adults shot the other male he made it into the secure vestibule where the um gentleman with a gun was still trying to come after him um if the bulletproof glass works uh the individual was unable to get
030into the school and police were on site uh quick enough to protect both the gentlemen who had been shot um as well as Arrest the the individual with a gun so it definitely is is one of the best practices across our nation although not every state is investing in them yet I think it's just going to keep going as we look at more and more security um incidents around the the US U we're also replacing an intrusion system or a burglar alarm system that outdated at quite a few schools Access Control allowing people to push a panic button and lock down the doors um in the event of an emergency and to use fobs to be able to get into a door it costs about $4 and something to replace a fob if someone loses
031it you can turn it off real quick it costs thousands of dollars to Rey all the exterior doors if someone loses one of those keys so that's a good investment longterm in the district and as well as shortterm um we're also putting on the bond package and we had talked about this uh Bartlett High School infrastructure improvements um the bulk of it will go towards a design of a seven-year master plan but there will also be some improvements uh Spring Hill Elementary also some structural sight circulation um HVAC and electrical and some other improvements that really need to be done in that facility as well as Campbell um West High School will have the utilidor is this underground tunnel kind of thing that has all of the water pipes all the electrical all the everything
032that allows that massive building to operate and uh it had been upgraded many times over 60 years and every time they upgraded they just kept putting the new stuff leaving the old stuff in place so at some point you can no longer walk through there and do repairs and this will finalize those repairs and the most important thing for me Al although they're all important is $3.8 million to upgrade our very old um snow removal equipment so I I know the municipality is approaching um in a slightly different way we can't do a levy for taxes um but we're adding that into the bond and I think after the last couple years I would I would expect to get pretty broad support for that are there any questions okay thank you uh somebody person V
033thank you um so the secure vestibule and the buzzing in how much um additional staff no additional staff in fact um well we've got our staff about as low as you could possibly have in a front office there's usually one or two people in a front office um just due to budget cuts over the years um this actually uh frees up some workload for not having to go to a door if you lock it down um it also has uh bulletproof panels all around that that front office um I've got one in my office if you're curious you can come up uh APD shot it with every type of weapon they had and the only thing that can penetrate it is a armor piercing real it's it's a very safe um front office and vule
034and it's you know it certainly has improved security without adding people okay I wasn't I was looking for the next word staff responsibility staff I mean is it pushing those office staff from what they need to do to be monitoring that door in that way do they they're in no way doing background checks prior to buzzing in it's the system that you're putting in place that is correct okay thanks May thank you president hullman um would you refresh my memory on the amount of the bond and then also I understand there's no ongoing discussion about going to a multi-year bond um absolutely May Le France so the bond is $ 63.8 million total um and since our last multi-year the multi-year bond I think was a good idea if as were to do a two-year
035Bond and then the following year the municipality were to be able to do a two-year Bond but what we found was when we're the only ones doing a two-year Bond it's so expensive even though it it looks more expensive because now you've got two years worth of projects um and it failed pretty soundly you know the last seven years our bond packages have pretty much been a neutral as far as debt new debt being incurred we're retiring about the same amount of debt as we were asking for in new bonds what could you explain where we're at with this bond package um I didn't bring the sheet with what we're paying off I can provide that though and get it to the assembly as well but it again is is because we had the $112
036million Bond fail we're actually certainly below that when you look at a three-year period and you know anytime you you don't pass a bond um you're about 60 plus million dollars more that you're paying off that you never added as new debt but the the reality long-term for Anchorage is tied to the state's decision back in 2015 to stop doing State Bond debt reimbursement they did that for many many years and I know when remember Donley was Senator Donley um um you you were supportive of that and in fact the whole state was but in 2015 in April they uh Anchorage had passed a bond in April and they passed a bill in Juno um signed by the governor that retroactively went back to January and stopped doing State Bond at reimbursement it used to
037be depending on the project 60% was picked up by the state for some projects or 70% was picked up by the state for some projects so since January 2015 every bond that passed is 100% on local taxpayers so you do and remember Donley is alluding to this I know he's well aware of it that even though we are putting the total cost of the bond at less than what we're paying off because the state isn't reimbursing any of it anymore um and hasn't since January 2015 that it's becoming much more difficult to use that as a a line that you can't cross um because our infrastructure keeps getting older and older if you look at 2010 we had $170 million in deferred backlog we had $750 million in Total Bond debt we now have around
038$500 million in Total Bond debt um so $250 million less but that 170 million in deferred maintenance is now over a billion dollars and what has caused that is this intentionality of every year trying to make sure the bond Total Bond cost is less than what you're paying off and when you do that over time we we've magnified um our deferred maintenance by a factor of 10 so just to put things in relative perspective it's great to be under what you're paying off but there is certainly a price and at some point it's so difficult to recover from that somebody student represent to B apologize I didn't get the name right okay um I wanted to ask about the road map for the secure vessles coming to middle and high school so it sounded like
039I said two more years until elementary schools are done well they won't be done it will be two more Bond years um they'll probably be done in about five to six years generally when we pass a bond we do projects over four to five years fortunately on the secure vestibules um because we have so many design standards now the design part of that goes pretty quickly but we still as as I think everyone knows there's only so much construction capacity and Anchorage and so even if you could pass more and and have more money it's the workforce and our construction season is really the summer break um when schools are closed and it takes about two and a half to three months what we've seen in the last couple years is uh it's getting harder
040and harder to get some of the supplies and so we've been finishing secure vestibules not at the middle of August but into well into October early November and it's it's just part of the supply pipeline that um is really a nationwide issue and also it's a a shortage of construction workers in an um assembly member Su I believe is online and has a question thank you I don't have a question yet I just want to make sure that I could uh be made a participant which has been fixed thank you I I will have some questions when we get the transportation and a few others thank you thank you uh ass number bra I have uh two questions I guess uh also along the lines of of information requests or numbers I am very interested
041in the school bond debt reimbursement understanding that better um thanks for the overview of of kind of where it is now um the two things I would be interested in is and we probably have these numbers um generally speaking how much the state was contributing but you know in dollar amounts prior to 2015 because I think a theme that I keep hearing is the state kept was giving us a whole bunch of money that they don't do anymore and I think it can be kind of invisible because it well when it happened almost 10 years ago now um and two uh I think people just forget and so I think getting those numbers would be helpful because we already know it's in the millions of dollars it used to be for operating grants for the
042city itself um for Capital money to repave our roads and then of course the school bond uh debt so anyway so that's a request is kind of some historical look back um maybe 10 years to the 2000 something like that oh we have that in fact on some bonds we're still receiving some State Bond debt reimbursement because it went it didn't it wasn't that from January 2015 they stopped they still had a commitment for all the older bonds and since we pay bonds off over you know 20 30 years those older bonds prior to 2015 that were we're still paying off we still do get some State bonded reimbursement um but we I'll find a a way to make it more easily understood in a in a clean way and of course we can provide
043that yeah my my impression is we we think of it as this much money that the state used to give us and it's really this and so we have to be able to explain this um the other question is um you know you mentioned kind of Supply costs and other things going up I would be curious again offline is fine um what the last couple years years of projects have looked like in terms of how they were originally costed out at the design level and then what if any increase there was by the time you got to construction because I'm really interested in understanding that Delta because I I know it's not zero I think it's significant and I think it's really important for us to understand large scale construction projects that take several years
044they have these cost increases and it's not anyone's fault it is the way things are now and I think again I think we really need to clearly understand that not just for this purpose but for other discussions we're having thanks sure I can pull back member Higgins I I appreciate the comment about the inflation because I remember back in the 90s when they used to go out with a bond and didn't have to go on supplemental bonds just to make up the difference with the inflationary factors my concern and I realize that's taken into account that my concern is just always referning to what we paid off to be able to go forward to maintain things when when we're paying things off from 20 years ago and trying to compare the cost to say it's
045going to be the same thing today it isn't the same thing for what it was last year and it sure isn't the same thing what it was 20 years ago so we're constantly sticking with that same approach and I think that's deflating the ability for us to maintain what we've got because that's way underestimating what what the really the cost is to do the same amount of work any other comments or questions seeing none thank you very much brings us to section F which we have no items under uh section g uh first item is table second item is snow removal which was put on the agenda by the assembly thanks um just briefly I think that we had a good discuss in September I'm trying to remember back then um and it was around
046um I think at that time it was preparing for winter um and and the issues of snow removal and how that can impact school um um School service operating um and I think it was also possibly around shared equipment for uh snow removal clearing parking lots and things so I guess I'm I'm looking at Becky not because I'm expecting a report but I'm just trying to jog my memory of what we had talked about and if there's any report on I guess the updates of um uh the coordination between the district and the and the mun if there's anything to share there I that I think that's what this was about thanks assembly member B yeah thank you so we could also take that topic up if we wanted to at our next Transportation committee
047meeting which is on January 15th that's a Wednesday at 1 pm in City Hall so if we want to talk more about those colle abative efforts that would also be a potential Vue thanks uh assembly member bronda thank you I I know that sometimes it's just working out the Kinks and mun Elementary had a lot of problems and it all got ironed out it was like uh Paul Van landingham is amazing and he just realized that the the timing of how they were plowing was not conducive to moldun elementary school students getting to school so it's been all changed and they're very happy there so I am appreciative of that but another um thing that came up is at University Area Community Council um a woman um very passionately you know we had to finally
048put the breakes on her but um she was talking about the number of times that school is closed so every time we have an event where you know there's snow and it doesn't get ploud and but the ice and um recently she said you know she just gets up in the morning and is like oh my God is school going to be off and I have to go to work and I have six kids and what am I going to do with them and I just um it made me wonder the policy has definitely changed over time but is there a way to if you can safely get to school school could roll um I'm not sure why that changed but there there's different areas of town that are are sometimes not as affected as
049the the areas that are causing the call on the the schools I know sometimes I see Girdwood is still open but you know what I'm getting at is there a way to if you can get there we're on so the the challenge we have and and the reason gwood is an exception all but one staff member at gwood elementary lives in gwood um but at all of our other schools like if you look at the hillside you don't see a lot of school teachers living up there um you don't definitely don't see a lot of bpos and custodians and cafeteria managers and and so if we can't get staff to school even if the kids could get there there's no one to open the door and there's no one to teach them or do anything
050but maybe open a gym where it's warm um but that's our challenge we don't hire based off where people live we hire based off who applied and we have people coming from the valley and all over the Anchorage bowl and and it's a very unique situation at Girdwood that allows us to operate that way um and it's because really the entire School staff lives there when we close um but leave Girdwood open their um Community also has organized four-wheel drive transportation system to make sure that kids get to school which would be really really difficult for every school community in the city to also now pick up bus operations um it it's it really is a challenge like yesterday morning when I was talking to my folks um at 3:00 a.m and and it actually
051I thought we were going to be open um only to realize by 3:45 we were probably not opening um we had to send them back out on the road that's why we did a delay we couldn't tell where across the city it was raining and what was the impact um we had early vehicles um that we s on the road that were stuck in ditches for an hour and a half to two hours and we realized school is not opening it was it was everywhere um but that's the challenge if we could you know in a rural community where everyone in the village lives in the village it it's a lot easier to keep that school open no matter what the weather is it's just an Anchorage our staff have to show up to open
052the door I'll also say we looked at this I'm going say 10 or 15 years ago um but we also got kind of a great example of the issue when the bridge was struck out on the Glen Highway it affected schools all across the acridge B and and it wasn't students that had any trouble getting to their their building but it just took a a chunk of Staff out of service um that morning and and that's kind of what we would be facing um birdwood took some time and pushing from the Girdwood Community because they I was liaison to gwood a few years back and they they said you know you may be having really bad weather in Anchorage or something but like we can all walk in and the first response from the administration
053was this just complicates everything but they have made that transition because it is very insulated that way um but even even trying to do Eagle River and and I'll say there was a point where um when I was working with AA I was able to map where I could pick a school and then map where the staff of that school live and it is very scattered um the there is a little bit of exception in that a lot of the staff for Eagle River schools live in Eagle River but it's not the sound and then the communication side of it um it it really complicates that side of it terrifically um the one thing and I say this to someone who started teaching in The District in 96 the thing that really seems to have
054changed was the weather and it's warm weather that really kills us um that's what happened yesterday it's um say a year ago was an unusual year that we closed because of snow usually it's because of heat um and I think previously we had a five day closure um in caroma was superintendent because things warmed up to such a degree we couldn't get the ice gone fast enough so I I will say that at different times the Administration has really taking plus what they've done it where they could um but it it become complicated member can't help but throw this in it it also sounds like our a severe housing problems and inability of most people to afford living close to their jobs in addition to the fact that we're very spread out and everybody has
055to drive everywhere has major operational impacts on our schools that's what I'm hearing as well because I think that's something that maybe has gotten worse over the last uh several years but maybe maybe was Baseline conditions as well I I'm sure it's different with support staff and some of the other folks I was just looking at certificated staff when was able to do it uh and I would actually take exception to what Jim said our our teaching staff lives all over town um in every part of town I really expected to see some clusters uh but I didn't uh and I I think for the most part people in the PO don't move when they change schools and there is a fair amount of movement among School but um yeah we are a car Centric
056town no question about it any other May France thank you and uh not a comment on this topic but just to say I need to leave and wanted to um thank you all for hosting us here today and just thank you all for your work see you at the next meeting thank you very much um I did have one other question that would go to the city and and my apologies if it's been solved I I know there was a glitch with Ali Elementary School that the street it's on was in a limited road service area not attached to the other road service area I'm not even sure I can describe it accurately but thank you yes um I'm so we haven't actually met yeah I'm Becky Pearson I'm the municipal manager thank you yeah
057and I can absolutely speak to that and so this is Rock Ridge Drive that you're talking about and a portion of Rock Ridge Drive is included in the upper om Al limited road service area which as you noted is not adjacent to Rock Ridge Drive it's a um product of historical uh uh cobbling together of services and it's also unique in that the property is immediately adjacent to rockbd drive are not actually included in that lursa it's just the roadway itself which is not an issue that we have anywhere else in the municipality it's the only instance we have of a road without adjoining property owners connected to it being incorporated into a lursa and so last year there was some miscommunication some challenges with the lsa's willingness to continue to plow that roadway we
058have communicated but then this year and made clear their obligation to make sure that that roadway is plowed we're also exploring a variety of different solutions to try and rationalize how that road is plowed in the future because it isn't um it isn't tremendously rational I think this is the broad where there were challenges last year for the lursa is that it requires their plow service their their plow provider to essentially pick up a blade and drive down the hill and then complete this very small section of roadway before completing their work um and so we've been exploring a number of different potential rationalizations of service for this winter the answer is the lursa is going has committed they're aware that's their responsibility they're absolutely committed to making sure they get it done and that
059they provide service on par with the service provided to the remaining of The Limited road service area going forward we have several different options on the table that we're exploring great thank you very much any other question seeing none uh moving to item number three the academies of Anchorage update superintendent thank you Mr President so I'll keep this fairly brief so uh I've spoken several times with the assembly about the goals of the academies of Anchorage um which is an exciting initiative to increase the college career and life Readiness of students the most major update since we last met was initially the district had plan to propose an adjustment to the high school schedule and the reason for that was because with an extra class or two in a student schedule we could um guarantee
060that every student could take at least one uh Career and Technical education course which would lead to a variety of different Career and Technical education Pathways or um Pathways aligned to College Bound students with that said uh what we found is it's not quite the right time to make that shift so I paused that discussion um to be announced so what that means is that we're in the midst of a pivot of the acmy of Anchorage we'd like to move forward but I've heard loud and clear from the community that it's time to go slower so we can go farther because there is a lot of support for this um but what you'll see moving forward is one we want theems to be cost neutral to the general fund but two uh we are in
061receipt of a fairly significant Federal grant so assuming that uh that that Grant remains stable of course there are certain uh uncertainties with the US Department of Education but assuming that Grant is stabilized we'd like to repurpose that to be more targeted towards the same goals which is one to get students more dual credit more uh technical education opportunities internships um so we can increase our graduation rates and get more students into the workforce um and or fantastic colleges uh so the the spirit and the mission ofies is still blazing ahead but right now the team is looking Inward and doing a lot of planning uh so in the next couple of months we'll come back to the school board with a proposal for how we'd like to proceed it'll look different in the sense
062that not every student will be asked to take a current technical education class but we really want to make sure that we can Revitalize these programs because they're key not just for success in college but in high demand high quality uh careers fulfilling careers and I hope that many students will choose careers here in Anchorage because there's a lot of need and this is how we can begin to reinvent ourselves in terms of our own economic Prosperity so that's the major Academy's update question I I I just have one question this member Soul sort of unrelated um but it came out one of the community councils the other day is there a plan I'm not sure where to ask this but is there a plan to go back and evaluate start times and just see
063if if the intended outcomes have been been achieved um just to do like a a POS implementation analysis thank you thank you member salt so in short the district will be analyzing key indicators over the next semester we'll be limited in what uh data points that we'll have after uh the implementation thus far but I have committed to provide a a report on our findings sometime in the spring semester for the board so they can evaluate um the the progress that's been made as a result of the change and also um some of the uh complications that that happened because of the change it's a very complicated Endeavor and there has been positive feedback and then also some challenges so more to come on that excellent thank you I would just invite uh any board
064or assembly members to check out the public data. asdk12.org um sort of portal where you can go and uh it's how to access a number of the data dashboards including the attendance dashboards and you'll see that attendance is up um across the K12 system this this year so I understand there are challenges but it's the best attendance that we've had in years this year any other questions or comments on academies seeing hearing n item number four right sizing superintendent bran thank you I'm back again so in terms of the right sizing ASD plan uh We've shared the proposals with the assembly as as you uh know about a week ago uh we made an adjustment to the plan and that's because the right sizing initiative has always been designed to be responsive to community feedback
065and in response to that feedback we've made some changes and we still have a list of remaining schools and we'll continue to gather information as I shared with the board um this Tuesday I'm committed to listening and analyzing and giving them all the information they need to make an informed decision on December 17th so I don't want to blabber uh some of the information that I've already shared other than the purpose of right sizing ASD is to elevate levels of academic service and I think the other dot that I'd like to connect is uh thinking back to the budget presentation that we had earlier today things are not looking good for ASD moving forward even if there were a significant BSA increase of $600 ASD would still be in a position of a financial deficit
066and what that means is that for years to come we could be looking at uh lowering levels of service if we continue to operate the same number of schools that we've had for decades essentially uh so there is some urgency to this but I do understand this is an emotional and highly complicated topic so we're here to listen uh and we will uh we'll see what happens on December 17th but I'm committed to making sure we have enough information to make an informed decision assembly member bra thanks um yeah I think um most of not all of us have seen a lot of the advocacy happening around specific schools um and I was reading an article this morning um kind of the the schools that were taken off the list have gotten quiet and then
067the schools that are still on the list now now we're seeing that bubble up which is you know pretty predictable and understandable as you said um I guess what happens if uh those Advocates are successful and none no changes are made um I think that's really that's the thing that I struggle with because I hear what you're saying that it that it feel feels necessary it is not a great choice but it feels like a necessary choice in some way um and yet all of the public is going to defend their interest um and so what do we do with that I know I know that's really ultimately on the Schoolboard and the district to make that decision but I I would just like to hear a very clear AR articulation of the case where
068no changes are made and those again those Advocates are successful in their uh protecting their interest uh thank you m branga I think the most distinct way that I could put it isy sorry remember Bry my the most distinct way that I can put it is that uh we're not grappling between status quo and making major changes we're grappling between major changes and Contin uh a continuation of diluting our services in our schools so in some ways uh taking a school off of a list could be viewed as a positive thing and that's because every single one of our buildings offer something incredible through this process we've learned that there are dozens if not hundreds of incredible teachers and Par Educators who are with our students right now in are underutilized schools but with that
069said my responsibility is to look 10 years ahead and things are not looking good and I understand that we have some incredible advocates in Juno and in this room but I can't help but look back the past 10 years where we just haven't gotten to where we need to be on our legislative priorities as I shared last month uh at the legislative lunch and uh our legislative priorities have not Chang because uh there hasn't been a lot of movement towards them so uh it's a very complicated calculus when we talk about those remaining on the list because well yes it would be fantastic for those individual communities to continue on in those buildings I I'm very worried that taking no action means that those schools will get fewer and fewer resources and the bottom line
070is that there's a baseline of resources that you need for a school to operate you need your core teachers you need a fantastic principal a daily counselor and other support Serv but every 5 years that passes by a 1.0 nurse could turn into a 0.5 uh a third grade classroom could turn into a third and fourth grade combination classroom and you see all these complications that will become more acute as time goes on and I think right now everybody feels that their school is doing great right now but there will be a breaking point if we take no action which is why I've expressed at the school board constantly there is a sense of urgency in taking change so while we are collecting feedback and hearing from our constituents and others about all of the
071reasons why a school should remain open I I have to raise the alarm bells that if we take no action in 10 years we're not doing students any favors and this has always been about adding more fantastic Educators and adults in our buildings so that we can advance our mission to S uh set up students for success in life appreciate that somebody member Bond thank you very much um so last night Northeast Community Council passed a resolution of support for nunaka and Baxter and uh Scenic Foothills passed a similar resolution but what was interesting is there was quite a a Cadre of uh backer teachers at the meeting um for Scenic Foothills and they felt very wounded and this is a messaging thing yes you you do have to close some schools but they felt
072this wound in that um they're hearing the message that Bear Valley was able to organize their parents were able to organize and Advocate and that's the way you do it and they are dealing with a different Community um in Northeast Anchorage there are many families who English is a second language they're working a couple of jobs they are not as able to organize and figure out how they're going to save their school so that that came up and then aside from that um there being told that they didn't organize like be Valley but they didn't know that they were on the the Focus right now your original plan had them further out and so that came up as well as um they have the um structured learning program and a teacher from that program was
073there and she said that if these students are moved and um for those of you who don't know that they they um are severely autistic some of them and and Runners and and they've had this would be a third move that they've had recently because they were moved from tarmigan elementary and her experience working with these students is that it takes six months once they have a move for them to feel comfortable enough that they actually start learning again and um so you know she really plead that there's 50 students in that program that are going to be dramatically ected if they're pulled from there so I I want to pass that along I did encourage them to go Saturday um and make their voices be heard but it was pretty um pretty passionate and
074and I'll respond a little bit to that um you I think the the key thing out there Valley was the building was being utilized in some ways we weren't aware of it was a nonprofit that had rooms rented um and and the realization that if we close the school and move the students those Services really would follow and it's really out on be Valley is the edge of town I mean it's almost slitzer compared to the rest of Anchorage um they would have to travel quite a ways this is one of the the frustrating things because I know the East Anchorage doeses feel targeted um another way that someone from outside the area might look at it and say wow you guys have more schools than any other part of town and they do and
075they're fairly close together which means when you're looking at consolidation it it makes a lot of sense we're not talking about long drive times we're not talking about steep hills we're we're looking at a number of blocks and and whatnot it is unfortunately that that reality that density of how the district got built that causes it to be the natural place where we wind up finding places where we can R Us the other thing I want to say is I I completely understand every person in school taking it personally because these folks aren't going in and doing the best work they can do every day and for somebody say oh we're going to close you feels like that's just totally being disregarded um but the reality is it's from looking at 57 locations and and
076that really is the part that gets lost because when folks responding they're responding about their school but it's really about having 57 schools when we might be F the 53 um the numbers are down and and Staffing a school comes with a certain amount of overhead um and I had not thought about what Dr Bryant just mentioned but you look at Fairbanks they did away with school librarians a long time ago staff the library that's not the same a lot of school districts do not have a nurse um there all day long and and I I have to say personally I hate to think of Anchorage having to take that step the nurses th those individual spots do incredible work for a lot of kids that have severe need but it it is getting terribly
077expensive and yeah something will get down the road so unfortunately to the degree we can get people to step back and look at it as a district with 57 schools um you know you think about trying to operate 57 McDonald's in Anchorage that's really Challenge and and if the business drops a little bit at all of them you're still you still have a demand you still have a huge job to do but consolidating into a few a smaller number of buildings you don't have to have a manager you don't have to have as many folks you don't have to have as many fun counter people that's the impact but but I also really understand the school is more than just a collection of classrooms in a building and people are upset and hurt and it
078is it does have a negative effect no one no one thinks we're doing this for the immediate good of everyone um it's it's very position to be in sure for every B member lons um I appreciate the question and the conversation I wanted to connect a few dots earlier uh in this meeting um our CFO kind of explained a general formula which is looking at our ADM or maybe it's the aadm and you can multiply a possible increase to the BSA and you get a magic number and that's basically a rough estimate of how much additional money ASD would receive you should the legislature increase the BSA by 680 or a thousand or $100 so I sketched out um I'll get to the the end of this in a minute when you play around with
079those numbers with potential inputs you can see what the effect on our deficit would be what the Tipping Point is to creating additional revenues I think because of the efficiencies that have been these efficienc and quotations efficiencies prior School consolidations keeping uh salaries and benefits at really as low as possible for a number of years um should the legislature swiftly take action to increase school funding to align it with inflation since fy1 I am confident that it would generate enough Revenue the ASD would be able to invest in more than 200 um uh additional teachers which you could distribute to reinvest in our schools to address the people to teacher ratio increases which have taken place since fy17 K through three have increased by a PTR of plus two that's their ratio grades four and
080five have increased by one and the rest of the grades of all increas but if we're just talking about these elementary schools the point is should the legislature act swiftly in not a one-time manner but in a statutory manner so that we have predictability moving forward we would be able to at least advertise positions uh I don't know whether those those people are going to exist but then you would need you would be able to reduce the number of combo classes you would be able to hire the Specialists that are needed you would in short be able to elevate the levels of academic service because you have additional bodies in our buildings and you would also need uh additional classrooms in those buildings because you could move from a K1 combo to a kindergarten classroom
081and a first grade classroom that is the effect of an adequate incre not adequate a an inflation adjusted increase for the base student allocation is that we would be able to leverage those resources in direct service to our students to elevate the level of academic um Services which in turn should have positive impacts on their outcomes but the reality and maybe we'll talk about this in a little bit is that we're going to be balancing a significant deficit and so um I also see that consolidating those schools in a way it is a protective mechanism for the school it could be a protective mechanism to increase the number of students at a receiving school which will diminish the likelihood as we stare at our reality that those students are going to have the additional combo
082classes that I think are otherwise going to plague the district uh if no action is taken or if insufficient action is taken so we have multiple things happening at the same time so I have a bit of experience with schools and I know that combination classes are nothing new that for 20 years years there were lots of combination classes and and I don't curriculum may have changed significantly with the the um the different Focus but um those classes are wildly successful usually older kids help Mentor the younger the more um you you teach the better you learn and so that those don't scare me but one thing I I wanted to add is like if you're crunching numbers like this and um there is a school um that has pretty low enrollment having um a
083big Remodel and I wonder what is going to happen with the available space in that school what what the plan is for that so during the second semester we'll be coming back to the school board depending on the decisions on the 17th of December um with some repurpose options uh one of those and we've talked publicly about it since last spring would be to allow some Child Care organizations and to be able to provide them space where they wouldn't have to pay exorbitant leases which maybe would allow them um to present a business model to us um after we released an RFB to demonstrate that due to release uh reduced overhead the expectation would be reduced price for child care um you know it's not something that anyone would believe overnight we're going to have
084multiple um organizations jumping at it um as early as this summer we do have um a couple that have been um talking to me for I don't know six plus months um and depending on decisions on the 17th um you know part of our problem when you look at take an administrative assistant at at one of your elementary schools um after taxes um at $20 an hour they make about $21,000 a school year after taxes and that's if they didn't pay for medical child care for two students or two kids if they had two kids at $1,200 a month is $21,600 per nine months so they would have effectively been in the whole $600 by working in order to have child care so we look at schools that we have had schools for the past
085four years um that we've been challenged hiring cafeteria managers um same thing with all of our hourly employees AAS peros um all of them and a and a big problem is if you go to childcares desert. org Anchorage is a childcare desert I mean with very few exceptions Eagle River is um the vast majority of Anchorage affordable child care just isn't available for the people who otherwise would love to work and so if we can get that um for our staff embedded into schools um you know really looking at those schools that are hard to fill maybe title schools and and schools like that then then maybe it will it will give them an option of now I can afford to work and not only can I afford to work but I'm going to end
086up at the end of the year with working is going to be worth working um so that will be one option we're also looking at moving other District um really to look at repurposing we have to know what our what our Baseline is on the number of facilities but we certainly have looked at multiple facilities and we'll be talking to the board about that starting in January member Bellamy online had a comment I do thank you Mr chair I apologize for my um random uh sounds anyway uh I did want to get back to the res utions that were passed by uh Northeast uh Community Council and Scenic foot hills Community Council um uh assembly uh person um branga is absolutely correct uh the staff uh who we also had a little bit I also
087had a little bit of time to uh touch Bas with before the meeting um I mean it's hard I mean every single EV this is not this is not an INT intent to harm or to diminish or to uh but it's real people have really real emotions and I and I having had my grandson at both Baxter and Nuna uh those schools are very very important to me um but I do want to encourage uh everyone especially the board members to read the the to read the um resolutions that came out of both uh councils um because you know initially it is it's like no keep us hold do not let us do let us continue to provide the level of service and serve the kids that we currently serve uh but there was also
088discussion if that is not possible then here are some other options things that they would like to see and I think in order for us to have a holistic conversation about about this recognizing the emotional um uh um you know pain and that this has you know erupted in our community because it's not just East Anchorage it's not just Bear Valley it's not just Lake Hood uh people who people throughout this city have ties to these schools these are like you know schools are like legacies they're like family leg legacies you just don't interrupt and when something happens that it that that that might happen it is a cause for concern so please read the resolutions and I do want to thank uh those Community councils for really making time scheduling those special meetings to
089make sure that their voices were heard um the other thing I wanted to mention is that in our last work session uh since we're talking about right sizing uh member Jacobs who could not be here today did Issue a an amendment and I don't know if that is Handy for people to see I think I would like to ask uh America if she could maybe make copies so people could have it when they leave not now because unless they have it already if they don't have it already um you know we can uh get copies to you uh but in that uh in in that amend amendment should it uh the board should it pass um we will be talking about it uh on on the 17th I think we'll be talking about it in
090our governance meeting on the 12th and we'll be talking about it again but there are uh a couple of bullets it's only a couple of bullets long uh but he he Pro he in that Amendment he makes some I think significant uh considerations for the board oh thank you America uh one is to expand uh tutor elementary school monor program to grade k6 for the 24 25 26 school year and Beyond uh that puts a montauri school in the big bigger picture the 10,000 foot view it puts a montauri school on this side of town uh he also um makes it uh a a he a recommendation or an am he am makes an amendment to uh rep prioritize our CIP so that we can um uh put some uh capital investment in Wonder Park
091Elementary School and uh build that school up do what we need to do to try to uh create that uh uh re reimagine that particular that school and its programming and everything um relinquishing the management and control of that of the parcel on that's located on U malun Road um back to the assembly I mean that's something that to me makes sense but the board has not discussed any of this yet I'm just making you aware of what the proposed amendment would be and then collaborating with Charter Schools if we are um you know if Charter Schools do occupy our our um buildings if that decision is made and if that happens then he makes some um uh he he makes a request for some special agreements with the charter schools and some of those
092and that a major agreement is around Transportation so I I I I think as painful and as um emotional as this is for all of us especially our students and our families and and I can't leave out the staff because they've given their all to their programming and to their students uh there are there are some I think um legitimate and worthy uh options to have to to also for the board to know about and to discuss as we try to make the best decision possible for all of our students so I'll leave it there and and unless any and if we have questions I can collect them and send them to member Jacobs or I can try to respond to them now thank you thank you I I'm not going to respond right now
093to that particular item uh but there was some questions or issues that I'll the board will be discussing on that in the 17th um I just want to make reference to the right si side thing because a couple years ago last summer I guess a year ago we got into the point of where are we going to cut fund and we put everything out on the board of different areas in the schools we're going to all of that is going to be subject to review and assessment of what we cut right sizing is just one of the options so um within that but all of the Cs whether do you cut Middle School what do you do this what do you do that all of those issues are going to be on the table because
094the amount of funds are so great um what I appreciated about the meeting last night and I attended that as well uh and I appreciate that uh in the resolution is that they focus on educational outcomes and I think that's where we need to get focused on all the different options we have of funding but regardless it's going to be an academic outcomes the involvement with our parents when the schools are closed and they're moved away is going to be ad serously impacted the the special uh programs that they have at backf moving that at this point is going to be impacted we looked at um um um look at lak Hood the idea of moving those programs to turnig again has a tremendous impact when I went there and said how are this going
095to work out are we going to put hundreds of thousands dollars in the changes to even to accommodate that in the construction standpoint plus the impact it's going to have on their programs after that I we got to look down the road absolutely but we got to look down the road on academic outcomes as well and I'm concerned in what I heard last night is that you're dealing with um schools that where the parents involvement is impacted from an economic standpoint you got single families out there trying to be involved and you're distancing them you're you're doing it the question is what other options are there before you move programs from inaca to to um um uh to some place other other than backr for example that was one of the issues how can we
096arrange this differently so that we maintain the school plus the issue about I agree with the comment about uh combined classes you are pros and cons of that obviously I'm familiar with the with classes that are deliberately designed that way one one two three in the same class I know the impact of that and sometimes we work with that we've made it work and some schools have built on that um uh Within that uh so there's a lot of issues there I just somewhere along this line you got to start with the problem statement then you got to analiz all the options before you argue about the solution uh the selection and and I think we've moved quickly from this is the problem here is the solution where we had the discussion of all the
097options that are out there uh because if it's just saving this money where else we we're going to be cutting anyway and which priority do we want I I think the discussion that we've that the legislature has put us in is that we keep talking about dollars and we're not talking about kids we're not talking about academic outcomes anymore we're not talking about the pros and cons because there are pros and cons to any solution we fit but my concern is that we wen't able to focus on the solution and when we talk about right sizing the school the impact of that like going to turn again is only coming up in the last couple of weeks but we're going to have to deal with that issue and that hasn't been resolved so to me
098this is a serious issue I appreciate uh the discussion last night uh in regards to it saying where is the outcome how are you going to move these pids what are they going to do how are their academics going to be impacted how are the fam is going to be impacted the the bottom line is SEC safety for kids first and academics second and then we we take our ERS from the you know public we represent the public but we we're not focused enough on the kids on academic outcomes will focus on this is a solution that may help us with Staffing ease of administration I don't care um I care about outcomes for kids and if we can somehow get the discussion back on that but the legislature has done a good job of
099making us Focus not on that but what options can we cut how can we but we've got to keep putting kids in it first and I think last night the discussion putting kids first was a really good discussion those resolutions were really good it's going to impact the involvement of parents with these schools and that's going to impact academic outcomes you go in there look at it the size of schools the involvement of parents is a big factor on educational outcomes so this is a big concern I appreciate the administration trying to come out with Alternatives recognizing pros and cons to all this but two years ago it was focused mostly on money and trying to make the legislature happy with C now we're focus on combined classes the the issue is not ease of
100administration it's academic outcomes and this is a tough tough decision that we're facing assembly member B speaking word sure thank you so I in my role I I haven't wanted to weigh in too much on the right sizing because I feel like that is um something the school board uh needs to lead in terms of conversation and I realized I have um very limited insight into the criteria that you all looked at um you know working with the The District administration and in terms of you know what the candidates would be however you know I would just I guess from my perspective I have worked a lot in my role on the assembly at housing affordability and you know taking a city planning lens to these locations schools like bter like nunaka I mean they
101are surrounded by mixed density housing in a way that be Valley is not and when we have had these conversations around zoning or form housing affordability the area of talent that we often hear the loudest from in terms of being opposed to Future growth and density and housing that could be beneficial to the tax base really is South Anchorage that rabbit Creek area and so I guess a question that I ask is you know when you look at housing affordability where can people afford to live where can families afford to live and I think particularly the cost that you that you showed us in your uh budget presentation of Transportation right you have schools that are candidates for closure here that are very walkable neighborhoods you know I certainly appreciate the removal of Wonder Park
102in the list Wonder Park is a is a school that kids can walk to and I also appreciate member brona's line of questioning about you know what if kids can walk to school and they can show up um you know I think about where can teachers afford to live right when we were doing the the home initiative Road show we had a slide on fictional Mr Lewis where we we looked at we created a character and we we actually looked at what is the average um income for a new teacher to ASD and where can they afford to live and if Mr Lewis wanted to walk to I think it was Lake Otis Elementary could he find housing in that area and the answer is no he would be rent overburdened um and so there's
103so many things I think about you know that old concept of of a neighborhood school I think that the um the school that maybe me BR is referencing that's undergo a rebuild right now um it's a neighborhood school it's immersed in the neighborhood the kids can walk there and then when we build these schools that are sort of more of like a they look like a campus in the middle of the woods where you have to drive to right um how does that impact um families and then I I think there's also there should be an expectation that if you want to live on the edge of town you're going to have to drive more um and and you know it may be that you want the two acre lot but that's going to come
104with more of your own travel demand that's the trade-off that you're entering into so I don't I guess I'm I would just opine again with imperfect um insight into the the rubric that you looked at um that I think those schools that are surrounded by multif family housing that people are more likely to be able to afford and that are more walkable I I think that those are things that need to to be carefully considered thank you syo student represented speaking thank you um I I wanted some clarification on what we mean by combination classrooms um especially for schools that previously didn't have them whether there be any impact on curriculum or the pupil teacher Ratio or is it just for the purpose of Consulting classroom use that's a great question I can try to
105take a step at it so really a combination classroom there are kind of two separate types one would be what we know in a monor school where the whole program is designed around students students mentoring other students in a multi-grade format monor is fantastic uh type of educational program but in some schools after you lose enrollment and based off of the district's ways that it's staff schools um if you don't have enough funds to staff as many teachers as you could the year before um one of the mechanisms that districts across the country are faced with is well instead of having a really large um third grade classroom let's say 30 kids um let's have a 20 student classroom at third grade and then we can make a combination between fourth and fifth so it
106happens as a result of uh stagnant funding for example but it could also happened because of bubbles in your enrollment and the district has some U mechanisms to address this um one of which would be um essentially subsidizing the the cost of of an extra teacher and we do that in very rare situations where you know essentially the school is not provided enough teachers based off of the Staffing model and uh essentially we're trying to keep the school whole but the issue is is that every year that there are budget reductions one of the things that we even have to look at is our ability to be able to do that so essentially we hold back a few teaching positions and distribute them very sparingly to help keep class sizes stable um this past year
107those are one of the items that the district had to consider cutting back um because we wanted to actually preserve the teaching positions that were filled by people um rather than holding back a bunch of unassigned teaching positions so it might be a little too complicated for what you're asking but essentially there are different ways to go about combination classrooms I've certainly met fantastic teachers that are experts at teaching multiple grade levels in one building um but with that said uh more and more of anchor school district teachers are in their first or second year and one of the long-term issues that I see is a pension reform I think is required because um really our young people don't have very many incentives to stay teaching in Alaska because most other states offer the opportunity
108to get a pension after they retire so you're going to see more and more first second year and third year teachers in our classrooms and those are the ones that are going to struggle the most with balancing not one but two different curriculums in in a single classroom so that's one of the reasons why we're talking about this is being a an issue but I I do conc that there are some pros to it um but you need to design the the pedagogical structure around combination classrooms in my opinion though some teachers are so excellent they can do well regardless but not every teacher is in that category especially as we have more and more new teachers every year great question and I would add in uh when you look at programs like Bowman open
109optional blis uh and some other schools they design combination classes in but they often are two grade levels with two teachers and they they can combine the class as a whole or the teachers can specialize uh the combos we're trying to avoid is say one teacher with about 25 students that are split between two grade levels because they do have distinct curriculum that they they supposed to be teaching two different lessons at the same time and and some of our lessons at the elementary level were fairly prescribed and the the teacher is occupied delivering um the lesson but you're supposed to be doing that to two different groups it's really tough so U those those we don't think do as well the ones where it spend design as Dr Bryant said where actually is a
110feature of the program those combination classes are great and no one wants to eliminate those we just don't want to be forced into a less desirable model remember less and I wanted to say that thanks to another board member's uh request for information recently the board recently received uh a response from the administration looking at student growth last year in combo classes versus sort of straight grade level classes and it turns out that when you teach just a a straight third grade or straight fourth grade the students are making more grow in their math or in their English language arts than in those unintentional combination classrooms does that make sense and I I don't know if that's something that could be forwarded to the assembly but that might be of interest it was in a
111recent board um there's no other comments I'm going to say we'll move ahead we are in about our last 15 minutes as far as scheduling uh just to make everyone aware uh ASB assembly joint resolution concerning State funding for schools and yes member lessons yeah I'll I'll um kind of walk us through it there are a sort of a series of documents stapled together um just to refresh everyone's mem in at our most recent joint meeting in September we had just received the glimpse of the FY 26 budget deficit and the gravity of the situation uh from my recollection is what spurred uh joint interest or mutual interest in creating a new joint resolution for the upcoming legislative session so uh what you see before you is um memorandum uh 079 with a recommendation which
112is that the board and the assembly each and our own bodies consider passing the attached joint resolution and then the pertinent facts really review that we went through this process together a year ago that uh our fiscal situation has not improved that our students academic outcomes have not improved and um that we have received new information um and those critical pieces of information are highlighted on page three of um of the memo itself and they are analysis from the end of September from the state of Alaska's legislative finance division which kind of got us to this fy1 moment in time and this legislative analysis calculates that if you were to match the buying power of the fy1 BSA for this current year the base student allocation would need to increase by $ 1,88 and then
113the second piece of information was produced by um our CFO and that simply projects that 1808 figure for expected inflation in order to bridge the gap between fy1 and FY 26 and that's how we came up with the figure of 1,963 so that is all context for the substance of the joint memo itself um which begins with the identical language from last year's joint resolution it really draws heavily on language from the legislative Finance memo in talking about uh how we get funding in the state of Alaska um reviewing uh changes to the BSA um I think it's relevant that over a three-year period between FY 9 10 and 11 as a result of a joint legislative task force uh the legislature increased the BSA by $100 for each of those three years to account
114for inflation and that was the last meaningful adjustment for inflation since that time since the start of the fy1 school year um the state of Alaska has increased the VSA by less than that $300 by 00 80 over over the ensuing years um which is ultimately why we're at where we're at so as you go through the next a few pages the joint resolution um looks at the DSA it looks at the district cost Factor it really reviews people Transportation it reviews school bond debt reimbursement it highlights the cost shift to Anchorage taxpayers which we've just reviewed a little bit today um it notes as it did last year that the Anchorage school board and administration have responded to these challenges by decreasing administrative overhead minimizing growth and labor costs pursuing consolidation promoting efficiencies identifying
115e Revenue opportunities um IT addresses it notes that uh the the board over the years has sought to align available resources with instruction we didn't talk about it during the bond uh conversation but the fact that our our snow removal Fleet is in such sorry State of Affairs is a direct uh manifestation of aligning Resources with instruction and not with snow removal um it review the joint resolution uh reviews briefly how federal funds how the majority of our federal relief funds were used and that was to backfill our um our our growing deficit so more than 102 million of our federal relief funds simply went to maintain our pup to teer ratios and in that budget packet there are a number of years where you can see 400 and something teachers remained on our payroll
116because we used Federal relief funds to keep them in their jobs um and then it reviews uh the structural deficit really growing from fy2 24 25 and where we're at in FY 26 and it I just wanted to flag that um the structural deficit which really encompasses the general fund and transportation fund deficits is overall all $111 million um and then it finally uh concludes by saying uh that the board can uh use fund balance conservatively or aggressively either at a an 8% best practice level or down to a 5% level which would leverage uh some additional dollars uh but at the end of the day um without changes um and going from the the third paragraph from the the end um we may be able to we may be required to eliminate 558 positions
117unless legislative action is taken in advance of Our obligation to pass the Balan budget by the February 18th meeting and that figure 55 58 comes directly from our proor um so that is the total number of positions uh which is calculated from the the overall structural deficit um and so there are essentially two sections to the solution one which says uh adjusts the the figure from last year to raise the BSA by no less than 1963 so as to account for inflation that has occurred since July 1st 2010 and has been projected to increase through June 30th 2026 and two to increase transportation funding by at least $324 per pupil and that is uh reflective of the $9 million in change that the municipality Uh current ly um supports our transportation system so that'd be
118great to be able to cost shift um have the state resume um ownership of those Transportation costs so that we could leverage local dollars towards operations and learning not just transporting students um and then the the last set of resolution items uh include as they did last year passing additional legislation that would adjust the BSA to account for inflation on an annual basis directing and appropriating necessary funds to pay for a state funded iser study of the district cost Factor uh which hasn't happened in a couple decades and passing additional legislation that would update the DCF on a triennial basis and returning to Historic models of crost sharing so uh this was a non-action item we didn't discuss it at our last meeting it will be up subject to action at the December 17th meeting
119um so I would um welcome any comments and then attached you'll see the legislative finance division analysis although I only see one page of it um and uh the ASD calculations bringing that 1808 figure up to 1963 questions or comments Mr chair just a just a quick comment uh thanks member lesons did a great job of uh walking through briefly walking through the resolution and I just want to thank uh the assembly members um and their staff for being patient with us as we juggled lots of uh different uh uh inputs to come out to to end up with this uh particular uh resolution and as always we appreciate the assembly's support sorry Mr salty if I stepped on your on your words any other questions or comments of course we would greatly appreciate the
120assembly taking this up in due time when you do have a qu assembly person bro so your plan is to bring this forward on December 17th um and we would be hoping to put it on in January if that timeline works for you I think that would be time I believe your clerk has it um already drafted as uh for your deliberation on January 7th any other questions or comments seeing none we will move to the Joint Retreat which was brought by the assembly yeah all I can offer is that's been on the agenda since I join this body so I don't know what the intent is and um I don't know who's whose ball or whose Court the ball is in as far as doing that so I think the question is really is
121that a priority for us in 2025 because we should start planning that now if we're going to and and I don't know the answer to that and and we don't um but it is I would assume something our our board would be interested in um yeah we have no idea the timing or or how urgent what um we can put that on for another meeting do we know who which member of the assembly ask that oh um that brings us to member comments again I'm just going to the time it is 11:57 um but does someone have comments they'd like to make on the meeting as a whole number D one first of all I appreciate the presence of the municipal Administration here thank you for being here um I wanted to express I remain
122concerned with the lack of full historical Staffing for our uh student resource officers in our schools um um we have schools times have been increased where there's no officers present and um they're just essential I think to provide an immediate response to any armed threat and even with full traditional uh Staffing levels even our most of only one of our middle schools is has an SRO in it so um the board has passed a resolution uh several years ago asking the assembly continue to do their best to try to get that program EXP expanded into our middle schools also for security um just wanted to also mention that this week the US House of Representatives special committee on the pandemic to report which was quite long highly critical of the degree to which schools in
123the United States were closed down during covid uh did an analysis of the European countries which at the time I pointed out were not shutting down their elementary schools um for covid and they proved to be right and we were wrong in doing so um and with some very serious impacts upon our students that are continuing to this day so we need to learn from that history and do better in keeping our schools open in future circumstances any additional comments member Higgins well I'll echo my appreciation for these meetings um as well uh and you get us a chance to vent our frustrations our issues and our concerns but uh what I'm look forward to is actually um uh a joint workshop with the assembly because there are opportunities here that we don't pursue um
124it's been a history here and I've been moved up to Alaska and Anchorage to T3 of where can the uh municipality and the school district work more jointly together on operations and save uh money for the public and improve our efficiencies um I've made reference to this in the past a good example is just group health insurance we have an unlimited basically liability risk with self-insurance and it's an issue for two years we're working on but not getting anywhere so a billion dollars in life insurance I mean medical insurance that we're exposed to you name it but combining we may be able to save money operationally and some areas and we should at least pursue that some of this won't work out uh when you start putting together other areas that are done by Union
125contracts you find that we have to pay more because you're paying more than us and we have to concede to you it would be kind of interesting but there are opportunities here if we put together a good agenda I think to really look at that because the Public's always asked for it we've had conflicts in the past where the assembly was trying to grab stuff from the from the ASD ASD gets a report says wait we'd benefit if we did more of it they said oh we'll drop it I remember those days but I think right now we've got a a a group that's a perfect group to get together to talk about this without being Territorial and and I think that's a big benefit that we have that we haven't had in the past
126as much uh so I would look forward to um having a workshop that talks about those opportunities where we can do more together and um benefit the public and benefit both operations because when the resource are more we're going to help kids as well so that's I I look forward to some opportunity but having an agenda out there with that type of approach putting that whole list together uh could be real beneficial to both parties I think thank you any other comments seeing none um move to uh this part of our agenda is actually laid out the way we have it for our evening meetings we let students testify first so they can be home in time to get a good night's sleep um hopefully they're all in school right now but I take it
127there's no student comments from the audience anyone from the public that wishes to make a comment seeing none I'm not sure if there're written public comments but respective Administrative Assistant executive assistants will make those available um that brings us to the schedule of our upcoming meetings March 7th and June 6 and that brings us to the final item which will be ajour without cor really allowed to heav thank you all we are in adjournment