001e e e good evening everyone will we are reconvening into Open session at 5:37 there was no reportable action taken in closed session do I have a motion for action on stud student discipline cases 11 12 13 14 and 15 I so move second second that motion V okay and that motion carries can we please stand for the of Allegiance um at this time I'd like to request approval of the agenda but adding a 7.02 which is recognition of some of our exceptional student athletes tonight is there a motion to approve I'll move to approve the agenda and a second call for the vote e the motion passes unanimously can we call Coach kit forward to recognize the Merced High girls water polo team okay good good evening board um and and all the people
002that are here to support um what we've accomplished over this year um I just like to thank mered Union High School District it has a very long history of supporting Aquatics um throughout the school district there's several board members that have been very intrical members of what's been happening in our Aquatics Community um and then just a short um recap of our season um you know it was a pretty long season um we had pretty high expectations when we started um I don't know if we really uh thought that we were going to achieve um a section Championship but we never said that we were and we took each game one game at a time and I think it's a testament to the hard work that our athletes put in beginning after we lost in
003the semifinals last fall and so they've worked very hard and our our team has done a great job and played as a team and we pretty much won the championship on our defense and playing Team defense is probably one of the hardest things to do in any sport so um I really am very proud of this group of young ladies and and thank you to the coaches that helped me along the way okay so first athlete Alexandria Martinez Amelia Peterson Audrey oruba Dorothy Drury Elise metf Faith Vargas Jasmine Fagan Kate McIntosh Madison plumen Mariah Osio Olivia Westerberg Sarah slokum Taylor L Zoe Hickman can I can I also thank my coaches Katie slokum uh k Kon Weston and mine Hall [Applause] thank you very much congratulations ladies if I'm not mistaken that's the first ever
004women's section championship team from mered high and there have been some incredible teams there so Bravo all right at this time we will call Mr torren Johnson up all good evening president ham board members superintendent Peterson cabinet Mr Orbach and friends and family of the program uh thank you very much for the invitation um acknowledging our great success with our water po team winning the section Championship we greatly appreciate this opportunity I would like to introduce the coaches uh of this team uh first we have the head coach Mr Wyatt [Applause] Brigham assistant coach Sydney [Applause] and assistant coach Tamara capian Mr Brigham's gonna say a few words about this season hello everyone uh my name is coach W Brigham and I had the great pleasure of being the head coach for the buack Colony
005water po of Varsity Boys uh this year I want to start by thanking all my fellow coaches for all their help support this year and I would also like to thank these boys for here tonight uh for their hard work and dedication okay without that they would not be able to achieve this enormous accomplishment uh thank you for your help in acknowledging these gentlemen tonight in making history and being the first ever Varsity Boys waterfall team to earn a section championship at bu Colony High [Applause] School Alexander CA Andrew Ben roostro Christopher Rellis Donovan Chamberlain Fernando Velasquez gunar pettinger I think Isaiah castan Jackson Simmons Jose Taro Jude Pierce Julian magon Matthew dillaber Tav tippler and Victor kunga e [Applause] thank you to all of our student athletes for your hard work in the pool
006and in the classroom we appreciate you you are very welcome to stay for the remainder of our meeting but if you want to leave drive safe have a good evening at this time we will call Mrs parley forward to present the Atwater High School show case for conratulations all right Mrs parley you have the floor good evening board members superintendent Peterson cabinet and guest I am Alexi parley the principal of Atwater High School on behalf of our students and staff I am honored to welcome you to our campus I'd like to invite all my custodial crew and my students up for my showcase it is my privilege to share with you an inspiring Showcase of the incredible work our students and staff have accomplished through the mered County Workforce Development student internship program this partnership
007exemplifies the missions of both mered Union High School district and Atwater High School to prepare students for college career and Community success first I'd like to Spotlight senior David Dello who was supposed to be here and I do not see him but I'm GNA continue on um David is currently participating in the Workforce Development program as an intern with Merced County's geographic information systems Department David has been using drones to collect data and to create detailed digital maps for the county work that not only sharpens his technical skills and analytical skills but also contributes meaningfully to our community his experiences showcase the program's power to immerse our students in cuttingedge fields and open doors to high demand careers in addition our district partnered with the Workforce Development program to provide internship internships that paired our
008students with our Outwater High School staff this summer this initiative was a true win-win students gained hand on handson experience learning the value of teamwork problem solving and maintaining the infrastructure that supports our school this work gave our students not only practical knowledge but also a great sense of pride in our campus what's equally remarkable is how this program benefited our staff for some of our staff this was their first opportunity to lead and teach others this experience helped them grow as professionals building their leadership skills and deepening their connection to our educational mission one of the most inspiring outcomes of this program is HRA Cortez a former student student who participated in the summer internship program hyro now works side by side with the same staff who mentored him this Summer his story embodies
009the superintendent's goal of grow our own developing Talent from within I would like to thank Deputy superintendent Mandy Ballinger and program administrator Janette mcau for providing us with this opportunity and John sanoa our dedicated staff and the students who embraced these opportunities with enthusiasm thank you for your dedication and hard work and i' now like to hand the mic over to John to say a few words thank you parley good evening board I just want to reach out and just say what a success this was because you know we're growing and we got more and more Portables we got a new gym we got everything we're just getting busier and busier but our staff you know we we're kind of limited to about 11 custodians on days whenever summer comes we got to get these
010rooms all clean get get them deep clean shampoo wax these floors and then you got people taking their vacation time but by having these students and be able to make up teams it was really beneficial to us we were able to accomplish deep clean these rooms we had students we had them we taught them how to run side by side shampoo machines they ran scrubbers pickup machines we had them doing lights wiping walls doing Windows it was just numerous and numerous things that we were able to accomplished by being able to have the ability of these students and also teach them at the same time and it was kind of you know we're a little kind of hectic at first um to work with students but it actually after after a week it was very
011beneficial and we and we we liked it and it really helped us out a lot to accomplish a lot and um but I just want to say thank you to all the students for helping out plus the custodial staff that took the teams on and we had up to about 30 kids throughout the summer so it was it was big for us and it was very very beneficial so I just want to say thank you [Applause] good evening everybody and the board and I wanted to say thank you to the people they have in charge for the program and I wanted to say just my experience and I wanted to show any little idea how a wory kids with me so in the beginning when I got informed we was going to work by myself
012with just kids I got kind of nervous and struggl to think I can imagine to work with all these kids so it it was the day when I have to work by myself with all those kids so it was nothing for me is stressing out before working with the kids so that school keep growing and growing and we don't have enough help it was just the say custodial then added more people so for me it was wonderful work with all those kids and thank you again for the people make this program and for you guys too and the people has all the idea so we clean a lot of stuff and years we don't have time to clean it so example we clean all those windows for the cafeteria inside and outside so we try
013we have a time to clean all those GS for the lights everything so we clean a lot this summer for the help of these kids so the kids there was on it and everything and I learned how manners working with s kids and we do a lot at the school with all this help and thank you everybody for bring this program to us so the school it was more clean than usually because we have more help [Applause] does anyone have any questions for our students are any of our students want to say anything hello board I was to say um I am very thankful for this opportunity as prior to this um as you know like while you're still in high school it is very you struggle a lot to find somewhere to work especially
014because you have to fight with your schedule they say you're too young they want experience and um I'm very grateful that um the staff actually allowed us to come in and were willing to work with us because I know at the beginning we were very chaotic we didn't know what to do where to go but they were very patient they got us on track um they were very kind very opening to us um and I mean they give us a lot of good experience I learned how to use the shampoo machines which was very big to me because at first it was difficult but now like I can say I can do it while a lot of other people cannot and go down on my resume and I did build a pretty nice over the
015summer I also built a very nice bank account so I'm very thankful over thank you honestly when I said that it was a true win-win that was not an understatement we gushed all summer and we had a lunch for all of our students and we brought them back and we also invited the meret county staff Miss Binger joined us and we all gush and almost sometimes to tears because it truly was just a great experience overall I think for our staff and for our students and our school benefited as you heard so we appreciated it again true win-win all the way around thank you thank you guys thank you thank you all very much I commented earlier that the bathroom was incredibly clean this evening and it's not always that way at at board meetings
016so we really appreciate all of the custodial help and your mentorship towards our students plans to continue expand I'm hoping so miss minger and it was such a great success it was supposed to end at the end of the summer and then once we brought the county here and they heard the stories from our students and from of our staff they shared they actually extended it into August and so we've been able to we were able to benefit from it longer so we we sure hope it does continue okay it is an honor to provide an update on the remarkable progress and achievements happening in Atwater High School this year we are proud of the strides that we've made the opportunities we are providing for students and staff and the Partnerships we've made that continue
017to strengthen our school Community tonight you have the opportunity to preview the newly completed Rody spinson Aquatic Center a state-of-the-art facility that will benefit our Aquatics programs students and the community this project exemplifies the district's commitment to providing top-notch resources for our students thank you we can't wait to see our students dive in and create waves of success our CTE turf management pathway a previous Sports showcase completed a significant project recently renovating fields at Osborne Park and our JB baseball field this collaboration with the city of Outwater garden tractor and West Coast turf turf provided valuable hands-on experience and garnered recognition including local and National Industry coverage Community Partnerships Remain the Cornerstone of our success Bloss Memorial recently donated vital industry standard equipment to our patient care pathway in addition Bloss continues to offer free
018physicals for our athletes and required TB test for our pathway students removing barriers to participation and Hands-On learning Outwater High School Remains The Hub of Student Activity and Achi aent as you walked over from from the pool you may have noticed the new gym filling up for tonight's basketball game our stadium for our soccer game our old gym for our Winter band concert and you might have heard the national anthem it sounded like they were warming up um and our assets game room that we relocated this year to a more visible location on campus to support higher attendance and participation you will also find in front of you an athletic photo taken designed edited and printed by our photography pathway students I am proud to share that every one of our fall Athletics programs had
019a team or individuals move on to the post postseason Julian agular and our theater students are currently presenting their 25th Annual production of A Christmas Carol at the Bloss house with our successful Athletics programs are robust Pathways and Career Technical student organizations like skills USA HOSA FCCLA and FFA our students are actively participating competing and thriving Atwater High School had a first quarter attendance rate of 95% clear evidence that our students want to be here and our staff our programs and our opportunities are wide additionally I am proud to report that Outwater high school is in the blue on the California dashboards for graduation rates with an impressive 97.8% of our St students earning diplomas our students also continue to excel in the completion of Industry certifications with a class of 2024 completing an impressive
0201,900 for certifications 40% of all certifications in the district we've continued to expand our multi-tiered system of supports primarily at the tier 2 levels this year our intervention coordinator has expanded opportunities for out promised students by teaching two character strong strands of lessons that equip our students with the skills to regulate and cope with the emotions that would otherwise lead to behaviors that can adversely impact their success our counselors are using Panorama as an early warning system and it's added to drive interventions and placement we've also implemented new interventions like checkin checkout and lunch group sessions that use panorama Panorama curriculum as alternatives to IC and suspensions these efforts have resulted in a 95% reduction in suspensions over the last two years placing Us in the blue on the California dashboards for suspensions we are
021currently designing supports to strengthen tier one practices to better provide highquality Equitable instruction for all students we also reintroduced link crew to our campus this year to help our freshmen feel more and welcome at Outwater High School this program Fosters a sense of belonging and has already made the difference in reducing negative behaviors while promoting positive relationships additionally Freddy's Clothing Closet was transformed to Frederick's wardrobe by reimagining it as a boutique style store we've removed the stigma and encouraged more students to utilize this resource our instructional Focus is to increase opportunities for higher depths of knowledge levels engagement and skill building and classroom tasks this Focus aligns with the district's deeper learning goals to increase higher order thinking tasks in our classroom I am proud to report that last week's do average from our walkthrough
022data is a 2.16 and during our classroom walkthroughs we observe do 2 plus activities at least 83% of the time as well our instructional leadership team has continued to evolve with peer-led cohorts shifting from engage AHS to PLC plunge to better emphasize collaboration and deeper learning instructional PD opportunities have included an ongoing focus on the district's musthaves paired with our and the district's F focus on do and deeper learning Outwater High School Success is a direct result of our Collective commitment to Excellence from student certifications and instructional initiatives to Community Partnerships and expanded expanded reports we are making steady progress towards our site and District goals together we will continue raising expectations building opportunities and ensuring success for every student thank you for the time and your ongoing support of Outwater High School this concludes
023my report thank you for hosting us tonight Mrs Carley are there any questions from trustees okay thank you at this time we will move on to the general public comment period and for everyone the meeting is recorded individuals addressing the board are asked to fill out a speaker card located in the back of the room complete a blue card to speak to an item not on the agenda and a yellow card to speak to an item on the agenda please return the card to the administrative Secretary of the governing board individuals addressing the board shall be limited to three minutes each with no more than 20 minutes per topic during this portion of the agenda the public is invited to come in on items which are not on the agenda but are within the subject
024matter jurisdiction of the Board of Trustees the board will take no action at this time but may refer the issue for further consideration individuals who wish to comment on agenda item shall be provided an opportunity to comment after the staff report and before the board's consideration of that item individuals who cannot wait to address the board when the agenda item is Led they make their comments at this time I'd like to call Bill Warden to the microphone good evening before I begin I would like to state that my presentation represents my pure opinion and we my pure opinion and we all know what an opinion is like no specific names are mentioned to protect the innocent during the board meeting on February 13 2024 I guess I didn't articulate my request for payment of money
025owed to me for substitute assignments in 2017 where maybe both the board and district office Personnel are visual Learners instead of auditory Learners so as a refresher here is the poster the six pillars of character so I just want to make sure everyone has seen these don't many of around any that fortunately I was able to save this one the rest are probably at the bottom of the bird cages where at least they are doing doing some good don't fret the district will probably jump on the next academic bandwagon and the Wagon Train will wander aimlessly throughout the hallway and classrooms of the Merced Union High School District on a positive note now that the November election is over and the results certified it is nice not to see a new name and Fa sitting
026on the board from areas three four and five even though indiv an individual and or individuals sitting here tonight actively actively campaign to unseat an incumbent in closing this is the season of giving I would like to give the district office Personnel some jelly beans place the jelly beans on your tongue and let it dissolve slowly these beans are way more ENT than the liquid concentrate drink known originally as fruit smack and since you're not drinking their current the current version you won't have to wait in line to use a district office restroom also since it doesn't seem the district office sees the Goodwill of giving I had Scrooge and crampus create this prototype Santa look light hat that you can place on the top of your Giving Tree at the district office I will
027gladly donate it to you it will probably talked about a lot around the drink dispensers throughout the district's office ho ho ho and to all a good night here's hoping the district finally does what is right now I'm heading to the gym to listen to the band's Christmas concert it will be so much more enjoyable than coming here tonight thank you thank you Mr Warden enjoy the concert all right at this time we'll move on to the reports and disc of the agenda Mrs Binger good evening board and guests um it's that time of year where we review our superintendent goals and we set some new ones so tonight um I have our goals that we've um been working on and then some suggestions for new ones historically our goals have been two years year
028goals and they start um from their calendar year goals and they'll start in January um I'll kind of review where we currently are and then again make some suggestions for revisions so the first one is our English goal that um we're coming up on the end of our two years with this goal um Miss Burman reviewed that in November with you kind of where we are and that we've accomplished all of these um the recommendation for the English goal would be to go ahead and remove that one and let it fall off we also had a goal for special education that was finishing up its two years and we also reviewed that one in November um we met all the different parts of the goals um Mrs Johnson um presented that to you um and
029that one we also recommend that we remove that one because we completed it um our goal for instruction is just finishing up its first year and this is that do deeper learning goal um we've reviewed where we were at on that one in September um I it is in progress still um I'd like for to recommend that we continue with the implementation um did want to make a change or suggest a change there that we will continue to provide professional development because we did provide professional development this year and we want to continue that next year so that we can provide teachers with um more do and deeper learning strategies that they can use in their classroom so just adding continue to is the recommendation for that goal for our social studies goal we reviewed
030the Freshman seminar Health part in September with you um and we've been working on the world history and US History part this fall what we realize in working with this goal is that the history standards are very chronological um and so um coming up with priority standards was a little bit difficult for those teachers as they were working through it so a suggestion on a revision for this one is to change it to that we're going to review content and literacy standards we found that um the literacy standards aren't um well known in social studies so that was an area that we could grow in there so we wanted to um recommend that change there and then we also wanted to add in the personal finance to the goal because AB 2927 is going to
031soon be a graduation requirement so we might as well work on it as part of this goal also so that's also recommended as a revision for that goal and then our grow your own goal we reviewed that one in November also um it's in progress we want to keep that one the way it is so there are no recommended changes there so with it in mind that that the the English goal and the special ed goal are finishing up two years and we've completed what we requested there um kind of brainstormed some considerations for new goals um they're based on comments that have been made during board meetings I know that um math comes up a lot when we talk about um instruction and also last mon when we talked about speal special education there
032was a discussion about that that goal kind of needed to stay around something with that um also wanted to look at the comprehensiveness of the goals and we've received a lot of feedback about the instruction goal this year and that really it touches all of our classrooms so it requires a lot of people to be involved in it and that that's a good thing so we wanted to kind of look at comprehensiveness with that um we also the the California dashboard we have areas where we're read in um and our special populations normally fall under those we wanted to make sure we kept those in the front of mind um so with with kind of that one of the suggestions is a a goal around data analysis so we have a lot more data available
033to us today um but we don't always know what to do with that or how to use it best so a data analysis goal could be along the lines of creating a collaboration structure um that includes consistent data analysis protocols to analyze math and English so we're keeping that math in the Forefront and the English and spe special populations which rolls special ed back in and also our ELD students on a regular basis with a minimum of quarterly and then also a suggestion could be then at the end of year one then we make some kind of improvement goal for English and math um we're far enough along in the curriculum and the the local Assessments in English and math that they could um come out with a performance goal because they have local assessments
034now we're using NW UEA so if they start digging into that data that could be an area that we can move to making it some kind of performance goal there like I said it keeps the special populations in the Forefront um adds that that ELD also by just making a special population and not special ed um we also can use panorama data um to help with theal part so it also keeps mtss in the Forefront so the a data analysis goal kind of helps us hit multiple areas and all the DAT that is available it helps us figure out how we want to use that to be productive and make data driven decisions so that's a suggestion for a goal for next year um [Music] also I think that we want to start thinking about
035how to align our superintendent goals with our lcap goals um over the last few years as superintendent goals have moved more into the classroom there's more and more discussion about it sites as you heard Miss parley sites are using it for their own own goals and their own initiatives on their campuses and we don't always see that with our lcap goals so I'd like us to to start thinking about moving into tying our lcap goals and our superintendent goals together um this is what it would look like if we went with a data analysis goal um as kind of suggested it falls into three of our lcap goals um our social steady goal Falls that we currently have falls under um the goal number three because we're really working to make our curriculum consistent across
036the district so it's Equitable for all of our students and then our instruction our current instruction goal and grow your own fall under our current goal number four which is that recruiting and retaining Innovative Staff where we're working on that professional development part so that's something to kind of keep in mind as we're moving forward and discussing superintendent goals is how they can connect to elcap goals so that's kind of what I had for us but I'm sure that you have other things that you've been thinking about um so I wanted to kind of be able to have a discussion about things that you have been considering or that you think are important for us to include in our our goals or maybe any questions you have about these thank you why don't we go
037trustee by trustee and just share some thoughts and ideas Mr Coleman would you care to start sure um so Mrs Ballinger I'm I'm gonna make a a leap here data analysis will pretty much cover dashboard special population comprehensiveness maybe even elcap right so I that would be the goal with with something like data analysis hit a lot of areas yeah we could do like subgroups or sub areas okay and then okay that was my I guess one one thought thank you you can have more um thank you Mandy for this um my comments are um I think regarding the possible next steps with some of the goals um that we're looking at um checking off um one of those um being that the ELA um there I mean what we had that we've accomplished is
038some of the the structure like um you know creating the assessments um we have that in place some of the structures and so forth but then what which I think might go to the you know the instructional goal and the data analysis goal um same thing with special ed you know what is that next step now that we've laid that foundation so that we're we're getting into um the actual achievement um in the proficiency and making gains in those areas um my other comment would be if there's a place to add media literacy maybe somewhere in um uh in that social studies goal with the uh the financial literacy or or someplace so we added media literacy to the Freshman seminar part of that goal so it's a whole unit INF freshments and okay perfect
039thank you um and as far as the the dashboard and kind of what what Mr Coleman was talking about is um I'd be interested in in having some type of a you know performance goal which I think you alluded to in the year to of the the data analysis goal so that we're getting to some type of of quantitative measure that we can actually look at to see are we are we progressing and moving um that could be tied to the dashboard um and then really looking at at um if we're going to take a deeper look at the dashboard looking at the alignment better alignment of graduation rates with academic proficiency because our graduation rates and I can't remember offhand what they are for every site but you know tend to be you know
040green blue they're they're pretty good but that does not correlate with Ela and math proficiency so you know it kind of yeah beg begs the question about the proficiency versus just meeting the the the unit requirement for graduation which we want students to have we want them to have those options for sure when they graduate but also the ability to uh be successful in whatever they do um because they have the the reading and the writing the math skills that they need um um I like the alignment of the elcap and then the only um other piece and this might be maybe with the instructional piece but but something maybe more specific to to language development with our our El students um uh know as feeders I work for one of the feeders and uh
041we need to you know reclassify more students so they have more options when they get to high school and are adequately prepared but even if students opt out of the ELD they're still El for a reason which means they're not proficient somewhere you know either on their lpac or their Casp so um uh maybe you know some attention somewhere in that or a future goal so that we're developing the language but that's it thank you I'd like to say Tiffany um T touched on a lot of great points um one of the things that I was thinking about was you know as we check off um the goal for English and then I think there's a report that's coming up later where when you look at the graduation rates and then you still look at
042see the numbers on the students me or B meeting standards how do we bridge that Gap so that we don't just check this off but how do we go back you know great into depth and make sure that we can improve th those numbers on the students who you know are not just barely meeting but we can work on those so they can Venture towards the exceeding because when you when we look at all our graduation rates they're really good but those numbers you know how how does that correlate so I think we need to still focus on what more we need to do to get you know the the English U you know to where it exceeds and then same thing with the math rates as well yes so um um just go along
043with some of what was said already but uh what mine was uh what are the next steps each time as we're going along and also how are we tracking Improvement or how do we know that there's Improvement movement happening that's it yeah and that kind of that ties into a couple of the comments like I I feel like we kind of have we in a data desert and we really only had that big Casp data and then over the last few years we've put in the nwaa which before that was reading inventory and the the math growth um but so that gave us a little more data and now we've built the local assessments and that's given us a little more data and then now like in our ELD classes they're giving the interim assessments
044so that's giving us more data so as we are growing and Gathering more of that data we need to figure out how to use it so then we can figure out how to improve the data uh because right now I think that some of our teachers they get all these pieces of data and they they don't even know how to look at it and so they just don't or they don't know where to go find that data and so educating and and helping people figure that out and H hearing what they think about how we can improve that I think is an important part of all of that I agree I and I think that um the last few years with gos we've been asking for metrics we've been you know begging for data and
045like you're saying mining it is is just difficult so I don't know if it needs its own goal maybe it does or maybe there just need to be analytics that are part of every goal um I think that could be debated um but I do I think it's something that we need to definitely look continue to look at um most of us were at the Califoria School Board conference this past week and there were a couple things there that um I think were some really great ideas um one was the Civic seal of accomplishment and I would love whether that needs to be a goal or not I would love for that to be something that we um look at offering to our students um another so on that that one miss ham um last
046year we did U make a revision to board policy um so it included the state seal of Civic engagement um and we had a couple sites who were going to try to Pilot something and it just didn't get off the ground so I think we have some structure in place for that um and maybe it's just um letting our teachers and our students know more how you get that um because we do have that board policy in place and the administrative regulation to go with it maybe it's something that's introduced in freshman I me it seems to fit but but just making sure that it's great to have a policy but it's meaningless you know if no if we don't have a site you immediately go directly to the superintendent you're a student you start
047with whom you have the issue with if you're a staff member you start with whom you have the issue with and it's just a very clear um communication piece on how to communicate that I think works for students Guardians and sta um again I'm not I don't think that that necessarily needs to be a goal because I think it's just a process and we need to try and communicate it so that people know did did you happen to get any examples of ones that you liked yes we have examples and I would just add the kind of the the sister piece to that was the customer service for our staff that are interfacing with the public so and I honestly think that does need to be a goal it will be an easy goal but
048I'd like to make sure everyone sees that and that might be a one-year goal to to make sure we have all that and then with something ongoing for new staff and then a couple of things I just want to make sure didn't fall out um we've had I think some struggles or lower than we hope participation and applications for scholarships forance I know we really discussed that we were going to try and have assets like supports for our seniors and potentially Juniors and I don't really know where that's landed I don't know if that's supposed to be part of senior seminar or the US history or I guess I would love for that to be a focal point I think we do a great job of supporting our kids through CTE pathways on to mered
049college um but I think we could be doing more for kids who want to be College Bound and that I mean the faasa application the local scholarships just feels like we could be doing more to support our students and I know assets does a tremendous job with that the last thing because I just love this from csba a year ago was um there are some districts that have a special ed program that's for the general population where they are basically a to students in the classroom um and I it's just a tremendous opportunity for sped kids and gen population kids and Paras and classrooms and everything else so I would really love for us to look further into that we we do offer that we have a pal program it's peer assisted Learners is still
050called that right and um students can take that and they help out in our special ed classes with our special ed students sometimes even with very specific so how does students find out about that it's in our course catalog and then when they register it it's actually a a much better alternative to being a TA at this time because students actually like learn skills while they're helping other students so so do counselors help push kids towards that or I didn't know I have a kid ta perod on accident you know I would have L for him to I can look into more how we advertise that and and what that looks like and I know we've talked a little bit about like um ways to incorporate that into our education CTE pathway along with you
051know some changes to TA to make that part of the that pathway so kids are actually leaving us with a little more skill development there um so we've talked about that but I can find out for you also how we we advertise the pal because it really is fantastic abely and I guess on that note on CTE Pathways we've talked a lot about certific kids not just some of theom skills but something that they can put on their resum certificate I mean are we is that also a focal Pointes it to be a goal so really get certifications are already part of our vision and so um we just updated the scoreboard that's on the district website and on every school's website with the the class of 2024 and how many students earned certifications how
052many earned college credit the graduation rate and then this year we did add involvement on there because we've been focusing on that so much we wanted to publicize the the great numbers there so you can look at every school's website to see that but certifications are a an integral part of every CTE pathway and we're really our our goal with CTE there kind of a side goal is that we want every Pathway to have certification opportunities and college credit opportunities instead of just this the more popular ones we want everybody to have that thank you yeah I mean I know this is just discussion and I know we didn't all feel like we had a lot of time to really think maybe about this we do have a special meeting on Monday and I don't
053know if we want to have more discussion around this or even have a I don't know a working meeting um I don't know what people's thoughts are or what your proposal is to how you want to come back to us with this I think a good idea would be to have item probably another report item um and let us summarize this conversation and bring it back to you and make sure we're on the right track because our timeline's going to be super short for January going to go to break and then boom I think I got it all down believe you have the next topic I do um so we wanted to share with you tonight our science and math textbook adoption um we've been working on that for like the last year and a
054half um we really wanted to have a process that was inclusive of our stakeholders um our our District staff our teachers parents students Librarians any staff member who wanted to be involved have an opportunity to look at the the potential curriculum adoption we're going to do um Stacy cool one of our program administrators has done an excellent job leading that and so I'm going to turn it over to her so she can share some of the specifics on how she's been working with that over the last year and a half thank you Mandy um good evening president ham members of the board superintendent Peterson and cabinet tonight I'm pleased to present the results of our comprehensive textbook adoption process a districtwide initiative that I've LED since spring 2023 during the 2223 school year ed services
055slides there um Ed servic has recognized that our Science and Mathematics resources needed updating to better serve our students and teachers this launched an 18-month journey to select materials that would not only align with our current standards but truly transformed learning in our classrooms we approached the process with four key points reflecting current academic standards and District goals providing inclusive engaging resources that speak to all our students leveraging modern technology to enhance learning and equipping our teachers with Comprehensive research back tools to ensure success we established a structured framework that engaged all stakeholders throughout the decision making process we created clear selection criteria aligned with educational codes maintain transparency through consistent communication and set realistic timelines for implementation by the 2526 school year this thoughtful approach helps ensure we're not just updating textbooks we're making
056strategic involvement in our students future success this techbook adoption cycle impacts the 22 courses shown on the screen this has been a large-scale process affecting three major departments science mathematics and a as well as the respective AP courses stakeholder engagement was vital to ensure materials meet the diverse needs of our school communities we prioritized involving teachers parents students and others to gather valuable insights into what works in the classroom and support students success this approach also aimed to build trust promote transparency and Foster shared ownership of the educational resources resulting in materials that are inclusive effective and aligned with our district goals the first step in this process was to initiate the adoption effort and compile a broad list of materials for consideration I utilize department chair meetings to task chairs with Gathering input from
057their departments encouraging teachers to suggest any curricula regardless of their familiarity with it in addition I used Ed reports an independent curriculum evaluation organization to add more titles of the list the goal was to create the most comprehensive list possible before applying any selection criteria in Spring 2024 I conducted A needs assessment surveys Gathering input from 104 staff members 156 parents and 116 students here are some of the key findings teachers emphasize the need for resources that support differentation real world relevance skill building and inclusivity many parents Express frustration with purely digital curricula stressing the importance of physical textbooks to better assist their students and address technical challenges students prioritize modern concise content with real world applications while they preferred online options they also voed concerns about bulky underutilized textbooks and then for those interested
058there's a detailed 43-page report summarizing the findings available at the link as part of the adoption process a web page was created and updated throughout to keep stakeholders informed it also invited parents students and community members to explore demonstration materials at this point I'd like to take the opportunity to pause and see if you have any questions so far about what I've described around stakeholder engagement as mentioned earlier it was crucial to have a robust research backed selection criteria that also Incorporated now identified wants and needs of teachers students and parents after Gathering teacher recommendations I assembled a skilled team of librarians in our digital curricul administrator to evaluate publisher samples using our District's established criteria AR 6161 we carefully assessed each option this initial screening revealed some surprising quality issues several Publishers were eliminated
059for concerns that would directly impact our students and teachers there were technical integration problems that would disrupt rather than enhance learning there were some also had basic quality control issues including surprisingly materials with upside down pages and then content that failed to connect with our students lives and experiences we documented and shared all elimination decisions to maintain transparency this careful vetting process helped us narrow our Focus to the most promising options three ma math Publishers and four Science Publishers while Publishers were submitting materials I focused on developing robust evaluation tools to ensure our final selection would truly serve our students and teachers first I Incorporated direct feedback from our spring surveys ensuring our evaluation criteria reflected our community's needs I then strengthened these local insights with proven industry standards the ngss toolkit for Science and
060the imet for mathematics to further validate our approach I collaborated with districts across California learning from their experiences and adapting their successful evaluation methods the resulting rubric was highly detailed and designed to be as comprehensive as possible and the image on the slide provides a snapshot of one of the summ score sheets knowing that our students come to us with different needs and learning styles I assembled review teams that could evaluate materials through multiple lenses I reach Beyond content Area Teachers to include our English language development Specialists special education teachers Librarians and instructional coaches as shown both the math and science teams included a rich mix of expertise this diverse composition ensured that we were not just considering academic rigor but how well the would serve every student in our classrooms the goal of this
061process was not to eliminate materials but to conduct a thorough critical review on this in the previous slide I'm sharing Snippets of the detailed rubric reviewers not only scored each category but also cited supporting evidence these detailed rubrics were eventually shared with teachers and the public these are the findings from the review teams these results were shared several times with teachers and are also available on the district's textbook adoption web page for students parents and other interested parties the links above lead to summary documents comparing all the curricula being considered across each category in science Discovery ranked the lowest with 38% while the others scored in the 60s in math McGraw Hill scored poorly with 45% with Savas and car Carnegie both scoring in the 80s this fall science and math Publishers were invited to
062participate in our textbook Road Show h in September and October 2024 the schedule of events is shown on the screen all math and science teachers currently teaching the subjects under review were invited to attend and substitutes were arranged for the halfday event during the road shows Publishers were assigned time slots to present to the teachers via zoom and answer their questions I ensured that physical materials were available at each School site for teachers to evaluate the warehouse team was crucial in ensuring timely delivery to each campus textbook review summaries detailed rubrics and evaluator documents were provided again to the teachers teachers were also given demo logins to explore the learning platforms and access to a Q&A document to facilitate discussion with the Publishers this is an example of the Q&A document with the Publishers teachers
063could type their questions in yellow areas and Publishers responded in the green column this was extremely successful both during The Road Show event as well as after so that teachers could Ensure all of their questions were answered at the conclusion of the Road show teachers were invited to complete a ranking survey and then again I'd like to take a moment to pause and see if there's any questions while those were the general processes for Math and Science I had to take a slightly different approach with inur to integrated math in the AP courses we're in the midst of making an important change to our math pathway for students who need additional support currently Math A and B splits integrated math one across two years while this slower Pace seem helpful in theory our data shows
064it's not serving students effectively math a has been our entry-level Math course for any student below grade level however starting with half of integrated math one doesn't address students fundamental skill gaps furthermore the slower play Pace actually makes it harder for students to transition to regular speed math 2 here is some compelling data from the class of 202 24 only 40% of students who started in math a as freshman made it to math 2 by junior year in contrast 66% of students who took regular integrated math one as sophomores progressed to math 2 this Gap shows that the slower Pace isn't preparing students for success and higher level math this has significant implications for students academic progress a through G rates postsecondary goals and state test scores therefore we're introducing two targeted approaches for students
065approximately two years behind a new intro to integrated math course this focuses on building foundational skills while preparing students for integrated math one and will utilize hh's Math 180 Books five and six for students more than two years behind we're currently in our second year of the math intensive course which uses hh's Math 180 Program books 1 through four so far this has proven successful last year our students showed average growth of 2.2 grade levels a key success has been boosting students confidence with and achievement in a subject they've long struggled with the Math 180 curriculum has been particularly effective for us so far by adding series five and six to our new intro course will we will better support students in mastering those crucial middle school math concepts that they may have missed this
066restructuring will better prepare our students for success in higher level math courses while supporting their postsecondary goals as for advanced placement many of our materials were outdated with multiple additions used across the district so this curriculum needed to be addressed as well I managed the AP textbook adoption process similarly to how I did for Math and Science one day in September I brought in all the AP science teachers in the morning and AP Math teachers in the afternoon they had the opportunity to review both physical and digital materials and interact with Publishers via Zoom since the group was smaller our goal was to reach consensus on the materials to be purchased they ranked their choices and easily reached agreement that day it was great to see AP teachers collaborate and discuss their options do you
067have any questions at this time about AP or integrated path yes Stacy I really quick so you want to go back to the slide that that talks about integrated our intro to integrated one if I'm not correct me if I'm wrong the requirement for high school graduation is algebra one would integrated or intro to integrated one cover that no it would not um the state is very clear it has to be algebra one or integrated math one okay that's what I was wondering so they'd have to do I guess you would do the intro just to get to that second year correct which is what's happening right now with our math intensive course okay was A and B covering that at one point A and B is in theory covering all of integrated math one
068across two years got okay thank you get a little L here sometimes as mentioned at the very beginning our goals were stakeholder engagement and a comprehensive selection criteria which I've just outlined our other goals were a transparent process and timely implementation one key reason for an open process was to build trust and gain Buy in a curriculum can only be successful if people use it and they're more likely to do so if they understand and are involved in the process and while the process has been lengthy beginning in Fall 2023 we have hit all of our timeline markers and are on track to have new materials for our students and schools in time for fall 2025 if you recall at the conclusion of textbook Road Show participants were invited to complete a survey ranking their
069preferred curriculum choices 46 math and 26 science teachers including eight a science teachers completed the survey other mu uhsd Personnel such as administrators teacher Librarians and instructional coaches were also invited to share their preferences along with students and parents 32 out of 46 Math teachers or about 70% selected Envision by Savas as their first choice textbook if adopted by the board these materials would provide every student with a physical textbook and a consumable workbook as well as access to online textbook and digital practice problems for immediate feedback this Choice aligns with the stakeholder needs identified in earlier surveys beyond the ranking curric Beyond ranking the curricula I asked teachers to share their reasons for choices here you can read what aack colony math teacher thought of the Savas materials a Golden Valley teacher noted that
070the Savas books maintain High rigor while being mindful of students reading levels another teacher appreciated how deso was integrated and highlighted the availability of differentiated practice as well as remediation and extension opportunities for students Savas along with Carnegie was one of the two top ranked Publishers in our deep curricular review in May for Science and a science each discipline evaluated Publishers independently due to the complexities of the three and four course ngss models the majority of biology chemistry and physics teachers including AG bio and ADM teachers selected the experienced science series by Savas since Savas doesn't offer an earth science title teachers recommended hmh for that subject like Math teachers science teachers were asked to explain their selections a Merced High science teacher praised the quality of the Savas science materials while a buack colony
071teacher found the hmh resources of valuable for earth science as we conclude tonight's presentation I want to emphasize the thoughtful Journey we taken over the past 18 months our comprehensive process has led us to select curricula that will serve our students and teachers well into the Future these materials meet all the state and federal requirements but more importantly they deliver what our stakeholders told us they needed engaging content relevant examples and inclusive perspectives that reflect our diverse Community the strong supports from our teachers shown in the survey responses and active participation confirms we're making the right choices for our classrooms I provided access information for digital materials and I encourage you to explore these resources firsthand in January we'll return to present the contracts for your approval marking the final step in bringing these highquality
072materials to Merced Union High School District thank you for your attention this evening and I welcome any questions you may have about our recommendations or the process hi Stacy um are the uh the the math um textbooks are aligned to the new framework um yes they well so technically nobody's really aligned to the new framework they're all going to um the state in January 2025 so this is the these are the latest edition and what we have worked out is a deal with a publisher to get a refresh in about three to four years with the new content material after they've been approved that would give our teachers about three years to get experienced with the materials and then we would roll over into the new framework is it it advantageous to us just to
073wait a little bit and look at the ones that are align that are coming out so that we're not using one that's not align for three years well nobody's aligned because again they're going to the state in 2025 and we really don't want to delay any longer getting our teachers um updated materials so this really does align at the moment you saw um um that comprehensive rubric really dug into the math practices and other facets it wasn't just you know teacher material so it aligns with the current framework um exceptionally well at the moment the updated framework nobody's aligning at the moment with the new new books right but they will be soon and those new ones will be coming out so we're we're just we're a little ahead but then we're going to be
074a little behind well in a in a sense but if they're not going to the state until January 2025 that's pushing back an adoption at least two more years and so like I said we worked out a deal with the publisher to where they're just they're going to give us the new materials once they're published so we're we're accounting for that our current curriculum also expires and so we have to go with something yeah our Carnegie um contract is up and unlike curriculum in the past where we had textbooks that we kept for 14 years even after the adoption was over with digital curriculum that can't happen and so we had to go with something and they addressed that also as they were looking at the Publishers with what they were going to offer with
075the new framework so they'll give us the new materials um at no cost no there is a cost but they're actually giving us a discount to do it now and we negotiated a locked in price as opposed to waiting for them to be published and then getting whatever they decide is anyone attending the um the vendor nights that MCO is hosting with the textbook vendors in their discussions on the alignment with the new so those vendor nights are mainly geared towards Ka because they mostly stay out of high school and so um the vendors that have been attending the mcoe night we've either worked with eliminated or they're not appropriate for us I plan to go to the saice one though because that's who we're we're going to yeah and then this here this is
076the student textbook so it's relatively slender which addressed the student stud concerns and then this is their a workbook that would come with it too so that's inclusive in the contract is the hard cover textbook and a workbook every year for a student is there an online version of that as well absolutely that's something that's pretty standard these days but even if it's not it's something we checked it was a requirement every publisher for both Math and Science had a complete digital curriculum that could be accessed um in some cases even offline so you know taking into account some students don't have internet access it looks like you guys did a very thorough process so that's great thank you um but going back to what Tiffany said is the cost significant going with it now
077and then getting the refresh later actually it's not it's more cost effective to do this this way we also are um looking at a longer contract an 8-year contract with that to cons spread out the ca it actually incorporating the refresh only adds a couple dollars per student as opposed to as Mandy said we'd have to buy something now regardless because our contract is expiring and then we'd have to buy something again in two to three years with the new framework we're just doing it all right ahead so it is actually more cost effective to just lock in somebody for seven to eight years with a refresh as part of the contract thank you that's what I wanted to hear we we were very cognizant of money you know evaluating 22 courses curriculum for 22
078courses for those of us who don't know the going to State process can you explain what that is um so once the Frameworks have been adopted they give I mean it's public information but the Publishers take that information and often times they're sitting in on these public forum and um trying to plan in advance and then they revise their materials in response to that and so usually the state has a deadline all the Publishers have been telling me the submit date is January 2025 you know to kind of get the California says it's okay you meet minimum quality standards and so we would be getting the California Edition with the um the refresh Revis framework for the ma matics the science those are the the California additions but then that I understand you to say
079it Tak two to years to get actually implemented right because Publishers have to whether they're approved or not then have to go to print so you know once this the state just gets them in January and then it would be a whole another months a year once that all gets done and then have to go to print so it's going to be minimum two years before these books hit Market and histo historically let me add on to that real quickly historically that's for the elementary schools yes and then high schools come in later because for elementary schools you have to go through a state adoption the state adopts curriculum and then school districts have to choose from the adopted curriculum lists so they always do those first because that's what the textbook companies want they
080go to the state they try to make sure they get on that list once that's all done then they turn around and start working on high school curriculums because we don't have to have a state adopted textbook we just have to agree that it aligns to the materials and and that's why I was explaining to miss pickle that we're not really participating in those mcoe math dinners because they're geared K8 more towards the elementary Publishers so I mean I guess I'm hearing this maybe a little differently but it sounds like we're actually ahead of the game because we have to be so you've pre I mean we're negotiated to start something immediately or fall but then we renegotiated for once new materials are available we will be able to implement those right and and they
081gave us the um our choice of of when to enact that contract trigger they were willing to give us the digital materials um as part of the contract but they're anticipating about a 20% change and I felt it was important that our teachers had physical materials that reflected the new framework so that's why we yes we negotiated for a change in the coming years so I'm sure like Julio we all really appreciate the th of this review and in particular getting all of that stakeholder feedback it's so important and we know from a few years ago when that didn't happen know what that was like um can you explain because I don't totally follow in your earlier slides it looked like Carnegie scored highest but then ultimately you had a majority a different curriculum so
082I was just trying to understand how those what the difference was between those two measurements um as as far as I'm concerned there is no difference between those two measurements so yes Sava scored 80% and Carnegie 83.5 so this rubric that I had people attend to and you can click on those links when you have a chance and read the detailed rubrics and how they compared side by side um there was about 20 25 points um my review teams had to evaluate on and since it was so comprehensive they could only review one book within the given time frame so this is one person's perspective it wasn't necessarily eight people's perspective on a singular book so the fact that they came in really close to me those were just high quality materials I appreciated about
083this process that you you know I don't feel that the science ones in the 60s are poor materials you know some of it's just be becoming familiar some of the teachers the evaluators were just like okay I'm just trying to understand how this is laid out but it was clear with with Discovery in science and mcgrawhill in math they just really did not meet our needs I was confident with everything else that you know kind of came ranked together so I don't see a difference on that three and a half percent that's just I think just falls into reviewer opinion you know slight difference I see okay so that's a that's a reviewer's opinion and then your later metric was constituents in the districts yes yes so when about 70% teachers selected Savas I gave
084them these rubrics and they and they appreciated that they could see the side by side that somebody really spend hours digging through this textbook because they did not get hours to do that or we incorporated things like equity and literacy and what types of resources were available and so it helped them to already have some of those deeper Dives done and then they were able to see for themselves and look through the materials and that's also why I had them site evidence you know of the look at this page um one of the things with McGraw Hills math was they had um question questions rated by do so actually what they called a do3 question in their textbooks we call A2 and what they called a two we called a one and that was part
085of what ranked them down we didn't feel they were rigorous and that they mislabeled their materials well thank you again for the very very thorough review process and I in particular appreciated teachers comments in your presentation and I think there was one on Ma said um the language in the questions was easy to understand so you didn't have to have a high reading level in order to have a higher math level and I I thought that was pretty significant yeah the the like I said I had them justify you know or I said tell me why it's your first choice and tell me why this is your last choice I didn't have them explain this stuff in the middle but um they had some really insightful comments absolutely and it just like as opposed to
086just giving an opinion and why did they feel this way it just lended a lot of confidence to the process our teachers made a very thoughtful decision and and of course yes I chose quotes that highlighted um you know these align with our board goals and that's also what the teachers were considering and I think I have those all available you know to read because there actually were a lot I had a lot to choose from our teachers had a lot of great things to say and you know they offered real insight about why they chose some things last it was just like okay tell us why you want us to steer clear of this one and that was helpful too and are costs comparable on each of these different um yes so all told
087for the entire adoption it will come to about $5 million for everything I outlined I know so your eyes got big there but you have to remember that's 22 courses that is all math courses science courses and AP courses and so um for seven-year adoptions for Science and eight-year adoption for math so we won't be addressing this question again real soon so the cost per student works out too it it's very um oh I want to say it's in the $ 30s dollars per student which is pretty much our going standard for curriculum it just the price tag seems very large because I'm covering 22 classes there's a lot of curriculum here we're lumping in thank you very much does anyone have any further questions all right thank you very very much all right at
088this time we will call M piser forward to give us a school profile update School profiles are much cheaper than curriculum they are free so I know I am here to give you just a brief overview of school profiles um earlier in the year some questions were opposed to Deputy superintendent um Ballinger about school profiles it's not the first time that community members or board members have asked about school profiles so we thought this was a great time to address it with our sites and um to kind of give you guys a brief overview of what a school profile is so okay historically speaking I worked in um the counseling department for quite a few years years at several schools and school profiles are not typically on anybody's Radars they're not used um very often
089they are used in a common app which I will explain in just a few minutes um typically the person that updates them briefly is the senior counselor we do not have grade level counselors anymore uh they are alpha so in asking sites who's been updating them people really didn't know who was doing it Department chairs sometimes will do it whatever counselor has the most history would do it but School profiles generally don't take a lot of time to update because you're typically talking about your academic curricula that has been offered at your school um School profiles provide contextual information for college admissions usually around grading how we assign grades how we calculate GPA how we calculate class ranks and the type of coursework that is offered at a school so that's typically what you'll find
090in a school profile it is commonly included in the Common App that is the application that is generally used for private universities and outof state universities at this point in time um I can tell you that only about 4% of our student population is applying using the Common App so it's a very small number of students and usually they will come in and talk to a counselor one-on-one and say you know hey I'm applying this is my common app and it's at that time that the school counselor has to upload student transcripts and usually um the school profile so it's not a super common document that people know about but it should be and it's it's a great representation of the school and there's no reason that we can't bring that more to the the
091Forefront um of our sites so that's kind of what we're going to talk a little bit about today the fundamental elements that should be in a school profile include your school and Community facts School staff contact info it should be very easy for a college admissions counselor to be able to contact a school if they have questions um a description of the grading system is important curriculum offerings including grad requirements um AP course offerings more importantly now dual enrollment that is replacing some of our AP course offerings um educational outcomes extracurricular programs unique programs those can all be highlighted in there that's optional information but it might include post-secondary destinations where are students attending colleges what types of universities are they attending uh National recognitions can be included dual enrollment numbers CTE programs those are
092all newer newer ideas in education that weren't typically on a school profile before but is definitely recommended that they are now so just a quick overview of what makes a competitive applicant um academic riger which would be your a student transcript with GPA and class rank um test scores if they're asked for challenging coursework has always been important so um we typically will list all AP classes that are offered at a school that change just a little bit yearly um depending on student signups but it gives an a college application or a college um admissions Council the opportunity to say hey this school offered you know 16 AP courses but the student who's applying only took advantage of two why is that why didn't they um pursue that the more rigorous courses so that was
093generally what they were looking at they would put that that academic profile or the school profile next to that student's transcript and be able to ask some deeper questions about the the um rigor that the student completed so this is a little bit hard to see but historically including up to last year um mu uhsd School profiles were pretty much just a quick description again of academics and how we grade on school letterhead it's a one-page document in paragraph format a lot of times it requires people to have to actually read through paragraphs which we are finding more and more people people don't like to do that as much as we used to it's difficult to extract information we took it to our counseling teams and found some newer updated profiles what the examples are
094what the recommendations are from the College Board from the National Association of College admission counselors um the UC system what are they looking for in a school profile and it's very different now so with that being said we took it to our counseling teams and we gave them about a week and a half to update their school profiles based on some requirements and guidelines that we gave them and this is a little bit more of what you'll see now on our school websites so they definitely recommend no more than two pages chunking it into sections is easier to read less text more Graphics they really want to see more infographic type School profiles visual Clarity is important and making it easy to search on the Internet is important none of our school profiles were found
095on the internet prior to now so with that being said all of our school profiles can be found on each School website under reports and plans still difficult for me to Google search it you can find it but when you search School profiles for a specific High School it comes up there's a lot of school profiles out there the CDE has one data Quest has one there's a lot of entities that have school profiles for high schools so I'm looking for ways to make that easier to find if you were to just search elcapitan School profile easier to pop in but I'm working on that so all of them are posted on our websites you should should be able to access all of them again under reports and plans School profile um it will be
096they will be maintained by the aps of counseling and their counseling departments every year updated as needed and finally I took all of the newly updated School profiles to our ed services team I just asked them to do a quick little look through and determine which one was the easiest to extract information the quality information that they are looking for in school profiles and overwhelmingly um ed services chose Atwater highs now I I do want to tell you we gave them a week and a half that was it a week and a half we said get this stuff done some of our APS counseling had no idea what a school profile was they're like what never heard of that that some of our new counselors don't really know what it is because they haven't been
097asked to submit one for our common app so um Miguel if you could click on that real quick for me please should pull it up so this is Outwater high schools it is pretty easy to chunk it we have grading system first of all up at the top they do want to give a community profile it is really important to include our demographics especially um when you're coming from a district with low socioeconomic um disadvantages students so very easy to look at their demographics um they have links so full links to the staff directory course offerings um student learner outcomes um they added in Career Technical education which is fairly new school profiles did not have any information about that in the past they did include test scores for their students and then at the
098very bottom as we talked about they added College attended colleges attended by graduates and those are the most um common colleges that Outwater high students have been attending so they did an excellent job I want to thank Lindsay Parker if she's back there because she had this done in a day we said you have a week and a half to get this done I'm putting them on the websites and how do you think this one looks Amy I like wow that was super quick so then we kind of used that with the rest of the sites to give them an example and and everybody buack and um Golden Valley still are in a little bit of the letter head head format but they're working on it and again every year they'll be updating these and
099we'll make sure that they are available able um again it it is typically used for the Common App but it's a great thing to have on our website and there's no reason not to highlight our schools and and the great things are doing and the great things that our graduates are doing so that's what I have for you on school profiles nice and cheap for the district you guys have any questions i' like to bring the free programs to you guys I don't have a question but I do want to say a great big thank you because I was one of the parents um last year we had a bunch of our seniors applying out of state and this is how we found out about the um School profile and when we looked at ours
100and then I think we brought it up to Mrs Bing's attention so night and day just it was it was a great discussion to be had again we've had a you know we have a lot of new people in counseling so a lot of people didn't know what it what it was for so super happy with what everybody's done and it was an easy fix so we're glad that it was brought to the attention of Miss Binger and that we were able to to fix that thank you very much great job okay thank you guys thank you all right at this time we move along to employee Association comment period but I don't think there's anybody here from either employee you can take the floor for DTA if you'd like okay then at this time
101we will move along to the consent agenda um is there a motion to approve so moved and a second second trusty G sing would you like to acknowledge the donations all right on behalf of the um Bo of Trustees I'd like to thank the following donors for their generosity for Atwater high school we have donations for um boy soccer from Los Barbers company Kasa Furniture garia Farms Produce kids pediatric dentistry supply for you Chad Pereira Caroline Baron Donald and Daisy Cole and John Santo sanoa and for Golden Valley High School um donation to be used for ring Sano scholarship from the Livingston United Methodist Church for Golden Valley boys um soccer donation from Campus Automotive and for Livingston high school a donation to be used for the Jackson family scholarship from Rebecca and Trevor Jackson
102thank you so much everyone thank you trustee G Singa are there any questions on the consent agenda I did have a question um and this was with regard to the single plan for student achievement and I I brought it up earlier but but I would like to ask again um just looking at some of the data when I was looking through the Golden Valley High School um report um just the the question is about the High graduation rates and then the um the lower numbers for you know the groups that are meeting the standards how how does that correlate um clearly it doesn't correlate um but our teachers do not have to grade on how students perform on any kind of standardized assessment like the cast which is what our dashboard is based on um
103also we we don't believe that a student is any single test score there's so much more than that so our our teachers provide multiple measures for our students to perform what they're learning in their classrooms so it's really based on a lot of different things besides just their test scores so are be basically saying that they're graduating and they are able to read to maybe the state standards orc despite what the cast School says not just by what the cast Score says no I mean that our cast scores have room for improvement but not all students perform well on tests I mean there's so many variables with that um for sure we want to see our our cast scores improve but I don't know that we'll ever say have 97% met or exceeded where we
104will have 97% graduation I I had a question what is our insurance deductible there was the flood on the turf at the school and I was just curious is that something we would normally put on under insurance or didn't look like we did I will have to look into that one I don't know that one off top of my head um we are self-insured on most things and so um you have to hit certain limits before things kick in but I can look into to that one thank you and then the other question I had was on the ASB reports there was only buack and the adult school and normally we have all of them at once did we have some last month did not okay I didn't remember okay y and the same was
105with the sipsa it's the others were last month and that one and is it the same on the on the site plans we did some last month yes okay thank you I appreciate that does anyone else have any other questions seeing none we'll call for the vote all right that passes unanimously so we will move on to the action agenda section first interim report by Dr wymer so just a fun note before we get started on the stuff that usually drives everybody out of the room but we do have one guest so that's a good thing for us um it was nice to see the it was nice to see the recognitions tonight this will probably feel good for you as well um but three of those students and one of those coaches parents played
106water polo for me at some point so that was always nice to see how many of the trustees played for you I'm not going to answer that so looking at the first interim so we do notice um again we do have our estimated Ada and I've noted in the poll several times where we were looking at and then we thought it might be a little bit better but we did end up about 60 students down this year so so this is the second year in a row that we will be going down in enrollment uh based on the current available data in state database this is the bottom and it will go up starting next year uh not tremendously but it will start going back up a little bit and then we stay within a
107range for the next five to six years so we don't expect that Trend to continue past this year you can see our lcff components these are just the assumptions that were used for the budget and they have not changed for first interim we can see the revenues of 222 million when you take everything in together the assumptions for expenditures we have our 1.5 steping column uh we have the raises the uh bonuses are already included as well you see the transfers out and then you'll see our expenditures here and it'ss better on when you start looking at this one um you can see the differences between the adopted budget and the first inim here so you do see that our ending balance was 39 it is going to more likely be 28 uh we are
108basically getting rid of those last funds that are about to expire so you're going to see those happening and you'll see it on the multi-year projection better than you'll see it on this one so you do see the multi projection when we go out to 25 and 26 you do see that in the 2425 we had a $39 million projected budget at the end it's going to be most likely down to 28 once we start getting all of the uh funds that are expiring get them those spent that will bring that down you'll see it go down a little bit this year we're going to pretty much get rid of most of the uh big ones the Esser is finished the learning Brock brand is going to be finished then you're going to see in
109the 25 26 we still have some very specific funds that are there we still have some uh Community Schools Grant funds we have some a through G Grant funds some educator effective ones that are not broad-based ones they're very narrow ones you'll see most of those being spent out by the end of 2526 and by 26 27 you do see a normal budget again um you do see that that's going to be about a 16 million 16 million ending balance that's typically between 16 and 18 is what we were running pre-co so we're pretty much back into the normal state of where we're going to be at that particular point you do see that there's negative expenditures in that last one um part of that is going to be identifying the one-time funds that we
110are no longer spending and taking those expenses out so we do expect to have a balanced budget when we come back for the budget um in Jan in June uh for that 26 27 you'll probably see a balanced budget at that particular Point taking those things into account so you will see the other fund balances again the student body Activity one we take the money in then we give it back it's the students money but we have to pull it into the district funds once a year for accounting purposes for the Auditors but then it turns around and goes right back out to the student body funds um Adult School is funded by the Consortium every year we put in and then basically spend what we need to for the Child Development Center over on
111East Campus we are running still a surplus um in the cafeteria food services and then Pupil Transportation will be paying for the last of the buses that are coming in and we will still have $2.1 million in there part of that's probably going to be needed as we try to have a transition in the topic over how do we move to EV what kind of EV infrastructure what kind of EV Vehicles do we need to start getting that gives us a little bit of room there to use for that particular purpose deferred maintenance uh for projects unknown uh building fund you will see that's the bond will be gone so all of that funding will be gone we're probably one year longer than we should have they don't like you to take more than five
112years to spend your bond proceeds once you get it you need to use it um we will be having all of that spent between the pools and the stadiums that money will be gone we do have uh developer fees that's usually right now for our expansion and for uh cbles so that's the majority of use for that um school facility fund 400,000 and then Capital reserves for projects 23 but again that will not include that 23 does not include all of the costs for the stadiums so there will be some of that money next year that will go and finish out the stadiums fund 17 is our reserves so you see the 10 million there there's about 7 million in the regular budget that gives us our 10% reserves and then the opab is the
11311 million which is paying for the current pars uh the bonuses and then any future pars that we would like to offer and then this is one that is inco and we don't or Merced County we don't get to touch this that's interest on the bond stuff that doesn't really apply to us so we do have a positive certification we can pay our bills for out years and this current year so the superintendent does recommend that the board approve the uh first interim certification positive certification I do have some others that I'm going to go on to and we'll come back to that real quickly so go ahead and switch the other is there a motion to approve Scott do you want to finish what you're doing before the motion doesn't matter if it's before
114after okay I'll make the motion to approve second are there any questions I have one it's not so much about approving but I'm curious about the nutrition balance do we always carry a really high balance there that's new for us um if you go back several years uh before we went to the community eligibility provision we actually would run a negative and we would actually be putting in a lot of money into that one um there are some funds that need to be spent that are not regular in there that they will be spending down on that but we are running balances which means they will be able to start doing some other things and some more creative things uh in the cafeteria because we typically don't try to run large balances there you try
115to do a little bit better than breaking even but again that's not normal for us and so we have to get into that mindset that we are covering our costs and doing very well in that particular program so they will be able to change some stuff and do some more stuff so they could potentially Elevate the quality of the food and yep I mean can that go toward is it is that just for ingredients or Could It Go for barbecue equipment at campuses or things of that nature kind of um as long as it's nutrition services facilities if you were to like build a barbecue out here that anybody could use that gets a little bit trickier but if it's things that are used for the cafeterias and the cafeteria Services yes okay wonderful thank
116you I think one of my nephews goes to a public school that has a Michelin starred chef but of course they aren't state funded so anyway uh call for the vote get on okay so I do have one last slide that goes along with that it's not part of the certification it's just a little bit of an update on where we are um in a wide variety of things uh it's been a very interesting couple of months uh economic politically um and things that are going to be facing us here as we start planning our next budget as we move into January and get the governor's budget but a couple of things just to kind of see where we're at uh revenues continue to come in higher than projected for the state so we were
117expected to be below and have some deficits in the state that's actually going much better so there is money coming in there they are going to be required to make a lot of payments back into the reserve funds that they used for this particular year so that we didn't take any Cuts Like Other departments did so we may or may not see any onetime monies coming in from that but it is a much better projection than what it was when we did the budget um so there are still some concerns about 26 27 in the state budget they're still doing a few gimmicks um hopefully there'll be enough onetime money this year and maybe next year to be able to take care of those and not cause problems um so hopefully that's going to take
118care of itself as well we have had an estimate um six of the eight components that determine what the cola is are already in so they have a very good estimate Cola is going to be it is budgeted 2.9 it's looking like it's going to come in around 2.46 um we had one estimate as low as 1.8 but the most recent ones that have come out were 2.4 so that's what the legislative analyst office is thinking it's going to come out we had a CPI come out this morning that was 3.3 so that would be 3.6 so 2.4 is probably in the ballpark when we get it all said and done and we're guessing that 2.4 is what they're going to in the governor's budget that comes out in January uh the district has a
11910% Reserve cap that might be triggered again in 2425 where we have to make sure we stay underneath that so anything above that 10% we would have to make sure we commit those funds to a specific project we can't have them just sitting there or reserves um and the district is projected again to be down 57 adaa for 232 from 2324 but again this is that last year that we're expecting that little bit of dip we're expecting to see go back up and as I drive through the count I do see all of the Machinery along the uh Parkway starting to move again so as you see all the different pieces of Weaver as you get out towards the UC mer said and as you get out towards El Capitan you do see all of
120those um starting to gear back up and starting to move again so that's probably going to increase now whether any of those become high school students or whether they're third or fourth grade students you know what that means and how it gets to us it just means we're not probably going to continue down that that's something you're going to see us start to swing back up the political one is starting to worry a lot of people and you're going to hear a lot I'm sure about that from csba and a wide variety of different things um but there's a couple things between the state and the national level that are going on right now the state is studying enrollment funding rather than Ada funding so giving schools money based on your enrollment your seabed enrollment
121not how many students attend every day which sounds interesting on its face but if you don't put more money into the pot what that means is all of the schools who have really low attendance right now now are going to benefit Oakland La those who run in the 82% 83% attendance rates those who run in the 93 94% attendance rate US would lose money so we are watching that the organizations know what's going on here they're they're looking at those types of things but the legislature passed a bill last year to study this put forward by of course the legislators from La um who want to look at this and the Poss funding of this so this is one of the things we are keeping an eye on because again if they don't adjust the
122funding and give more money into the pot and they just reshuffle things that's a win for some people and a loss for others and we would probably be a loss under that situation um they also studying adding groups to the LC cap C calculation like chronic absenteeism and again that's one of those ones where it depends is that an increased pot where everybody gets more money or are you going to reshuffle the lcap pot and who gets it we would be a loser again on that one as well so those are things we're watching at the state level where you're starting to see a little bit of tensions between large districts and everybody else in the state over funding so that that's probably going to play out within the next couple of years um and
123you do have a large turnover A legislature uh due to term limits so the and the head of the Senate education committee who is a very good friend to education lost his re-election bid so you will see a lot of turnover in the legisl which none of them were there when lcff was written they don't necessarily know what it's about they don't necessarily care it's what can I get done and who do I want to get it done for that makes things a little bit rockier not quite as stable for funding as we go through that picture so those are things we're watching at the state level um of course the national one we're watching we don't know yet until things actually start to happen right now it's talk um but the talk of whether
124or not you get rid of the Department of Education um whether that would mean anything to us we're not sure uh the proposals that you've seen so far would be to get rid of the Department of Education at the federal level but then to take all the programs and put them in other places you know if all the if all the if all the programs stay and you know Perkins stays and we keep getting Perkins and we keep getting special education from a different department and we get Title One funding from a different department I'm not sure how much it impacts us but we're watching those types of things to see whether or not those things change and the other one is whether or not that somehow gets tied into school vouchers or choice or
125any of those types of things as well and what could that could mean so that's a topic that we're watching as well um and then you also have programs we get about1 million 5.4% of our budget from federal programs and so a clash between the state and the federal government could be fiscally something we need to watch um because if you ever get to a point fed say you have to do this to get money and you don't get the money if you don't do it and the state says we don't want to take your money any longer then that's A1 million discussion uh that we get here um I don't see them doing that that's a large amount of money that impacts a variety of of constituencies across the state but they might try
126to fund part of it themselves they have high taxes receipts coming in so we have to watch those things to see what's going to happen and the two that would happen the title one requirements and the title 9 requirements are the two where you might see a battle between the state and the federal government and again I'm not taking sides on either side of that or having part of that discussion it's just what is that going to mean to us as a funding source um and how does that work out and play out so again those are some interesting things that are very unique to this upcoming year um most of those political ones we have never faced these are brand new issues for us have not seen these in education before any of these
127particular situations so we are watching these so that's just an update real quickly on where we stand economically and politically economically sound but we have to watch some of those things that are going on politics looks like it might start getting to be impacting funding potentially here in different ways so we have to keep watch over those questions on that thank thank you Dr wymer and for anybody watching at home we voted in the middle of his presentation and we did vote 5 to adopt the first interim report next up Mr Nicholson with the super supplemental salary schedule for the 2425 school year good evening uh tonight we bring before you an update on the supplemental salary schedule so on effective January 1st 20 20 25 minimum wage will go to $16.50 an hour and
128so we need to update our salary schedule and that affects our student um employees and college student employees so the superintendent recommends the Board of Trustees approve the new supplementary salary schedule is there a motion to approve I'll make the motion to approve the supplemental salary schedule and the second second any questions for Mr Nicholson see none call for the vote thank you and that also passes 5 Z at this time we would love to hear from Cheryl Garmin about the class of 2029 Chromebook refresh good name 3500 Chromebooks is the projected amount to purchase to cover the class of 2029 and also to maintain sufficient inventory um due to not only possible growth but damage that naturally occurs each year across all grade levels ordering the Gen 4 devices now instead of waiting until
129after the first of the year when Gen five is going to be released is going to provide a little bit of financial savings and more importantly or I guess is equally important um it maintains some consistency among the parts that we are ordering and dealing with with Chromebook repair centers and not introducing another generation model into the fold um across our inventory that's really helps with consistency with that program so the superintendent recommends that the board approves the purchase of $3500 or 3500 Chromebooks for the class of 2029 is there a motion to approve make motion to approve are there any questions I have one how different do you think the Gen five will be from gen four I do not know how different I can tell you that there are differences between the Gen
1303 and Gen 4 that we have in our inventory right now we have Lenovo gen 3 and Lenovo Gen 4 and we have a graduating class of 2025 with Asus 204 so I mean that will leave us potentially with only lenovo's gen 3 and four which will help but there are differences with um the screen size the Wi-Fi antenna the wrist rest the like all the different components a hinge can be differently situated on a new generation mod you just it's hard to say and so I guess I'm asking from the standpoint of we that the advances in technology you know they are pretty great every time some new generation comes out and I just how much money are we saving I mean would it seems like the latest and greatest technology is always better
131and so I'm just wondering if we might not be better off to spend the money to have better units I I would argue it's not necessarily a better unit although not knowing for sure yet an option is of course to wait and see and then you take that risk of how much more per device is going to get charged um for us U that's that's adding a new generation of model and a new set of parts that also come with increased prices that we then have to purchase for our repair centers to fix those devices so I I don't know that you make up hard to say I I think that it would probably be a bigger ation if we were talking about a lab where we talking about desktop power Computing and those types
132of things where you might even be talking about Ai and the ability to run those types of situations or even a lab that we were using with regular um laptops not for Chromebooks I'm not thinking it's going to be that huge and significant of a difference on the Chromebook well I'm watching my colleague trusty G Singa over here use her fingers on her screen and do fancy things that I envy because I can't do because I have a much older model than she does so things like that I guess and I'm I'm just curious this an apple that's why these are Chromebook these are surface has a Chromebook and I have a Mac mine's old this is Garmin quick question you would like to entertain the purchase of Apple products for our students I'm all
133into that conversation that would be more expensive stock pile is it the stock pile of supplies that we still have that Gen 4 that would I guess for a lack of better term end up not using if we went to that gen five because they're outdating I guess are you asking if are they end of life yeah yeah well just the materials like I know we have the repair centers at site so they they repair right now they're what gen 3s and gen 4S because the acus isn't going out yes we have stopped this year um buying new motherboards for example for the Asus because those are graduating and the remaining inventory of that model will become the classroom loaners that we use and that would happen with any gen fors not being used they
134get filtered through classroom use in that manner and basically repair centers are pretty much set on those threes and fours right now so we have materials still for the force this isn't going to radically change their learning curve no it won't these these will be fours coming in what they're used to and they work with the curriculum now um that specifically offers customizable Fixit videos for the models um of Lenovo that we use now and so that's also a reason why to just kind of keep on the same track that we're on the biggest difference is probably just a slight change in the processor right which is much so I I think we gain just we're saving some money but functionally it's probably not much different and the screens might even be the same they
135might for replacement parts thank you for adding well my question is what is the uh Sterling sacramental Warehouse processing fee which is 6,000 that that's who we've been working with for a number of years they um do like the white glove service that gets all their devices ready for us engraves them with our local um gets them all asset tagged it gets them all processed in the same you know the manner so that they're it's like buying a new house and it's like TurnKey ready and you walk in and boom they do that for us so they deliver we to go it's only $116 per unit so I mean if that's the case that's not a lot any other questions seeing none call for the vote there we go what what genen is that okay
136not working well tonight thank you and that passes 5- Z thank you Mrs Garmin at this time we will turn to Mr Peters for the superintendence report thank you uh president ham first of all congratulations to all of our board members for their reelection I really do think that says a lot excellent uh csba conference last week in Anaheim I had not been there in a long time and it's nice to uh have it in that City always enjoyable uh coffee with the soup is this Friday morning tune in got a couple spicy questions which I always enjoy um a Shameless plug for the Christmas Adventure at the Bloss house um Thursday Friday and Saturday check the webites for those times that's Mrs aular and drama department and Mrs ja Singa I think your comment
137tonight about the difference between the Gap in our test scores and the correlation with Brad rates um is a great conversation for next week um is a very uh it's not a light conversation there are a lot of variables to it and um I appreciate that you stated that I think it's a good conversation to have want to thank everyone for a great uh first semester of the school year all of our employees our students and our board members wish you all a merry Christmas thank you Mr Peterson at this time we will to each member for any Communications Mr Valadez sure thanks again to everyone for what you do and I always thank those who stay till the end so thank you and even the ones that don't don't have to be here so
138thank you all and uh thank you for those who supported me to stay on the board again so that's pretty much it for tonight thank you Mrs Jaa um um I attending csba um last weekend or week um attended some really good sessions and then there were a couple of sessions where I attended and as I listened to the presenters talking about all the great things they did I kept thinking to myself we we do that oh we do that and so it was you know it was kind of nice to see that things that they were saying that they just now doing we've been doing for a while so to um staff teachers administrators everyone involved in our um District thank you for everything um each and every one of you um does for
139the success of our students um and that's pretty much it from me um season greetings Merry Christmas um and a Happy New Year to everyone um thank you for a great F first semester and I guess oh no we are going to meet next week we oh yeah so not quite over yet so I'm ready to celebrate thank you everyone Mrs pigle yes I agree with uh Mrs ja Singa that the conference was very good um but when you go to the sessions it does validate you know some of the great things that are happening and the great people that we have behind it you know driving it so thank you to all of you um had a nice visit at Atwater and buack uh recently last week I think it was um it was
140really nice going in talking to the principles but um you know going to the class classrooms and one of the things that that I noticed um um when I was at at buap we went of the classes that there's more student interaction we're not just seeing kids on Chromebooks you know um the relevance of the discussions they were having the topics that they were discussing was was really nice and then here at Outwater they were doing their CTE tours which was um which was awesome to see um student Le which was incredible um things that they do are really amazing very impressive um this is one of them and I know Alexi and I were talking about you know what the what photo's doing and what they have the potential to do and their manufacturing
141and you know just the things you could really um do inside in heading the house and not have to Outsource so um we're really making some uh some good gains there and um and I think that's it so we wish everyone a good weekend I'll see you on Monday thank you Mr Coleman um Stacy it was a great presentation tonight very in depth I really appreciate it thank you so much Amy thank you for going through the the school profiles uh yeah I think that was the same profile when I was graduating in 1978 so just probably so we definitely need it updated had the opportunity to go to a Boosters last night had a really good conversation with the uh teaching staff out there I can't believe they have nine teachers now in 54
142sections that's incredible 1,200 students unduplicated 1200 students that's awesome um great job kit and your program thank you very much I know buack I'll say this so Mr Johnson can relay that great job for those guys as well um again Alexi I loved your showcase on your summer internship I sure hope we can spread that out because that's always I mean a former site principle the summertime was always your stress point and getting that taking care of with those kids was great um I don't get in I didn't get into classrooms a whole lot like I usually like to do but I am a US Mentor for Teacher prep program so I actually get to see them teach uh because they're practicing for their caltpa so and I'll relay what Tiffany just said there's a
143lot more work on outside the Chromebook going on a lot more interaction a lot more when I when I talk to my students uh they're doing a lot better job of of getting the students to engage in their own learning not just listen to Somebody talk all time so again I I have one of your my student teachers in with Mrs Olson so with that I'll say the happy holidays and happy New Year and hopefully we'll see you next week thank you I just want to re iterate once again what a privilege it is to work alongside this group of Trustees this superintendent this cabinet and how high functioning I think that we are I'm elated that three of you were reelected I think the continuity is really helpful for the forward and very positive
144progress that we continue to make and as Molly said um I think this was my sixth csba maybe fth um I don't know did we go during Co I so so Fifth and it really was I mean the first few times Everything's brand new but really a lot this time felt like yeah we do that we do that you know would um I mean we this is just really I think an exceptional District so I'm really proud to be part of it and appreciate all of you our staff our students and and the families of the district and know we can always work on engagement and I think some of those pieces we're discussing and we'll continue to discuss um our goals next week for for the future I think that will be a um
145robust and great conversation and I will look forward to it and with that our meeting is adjourned at 7:52 thank you