CorpusRecord 40958

State Board of Education Meeting January 15, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / California Department of Education
Date
2025-01-22
Location
Sonoma County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
47,483 words · about 264 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001two one good morning I see that 10 of our 11 members are present in person here today and I understand that member mcquillin is participating in this meeting from a remote location um and I need to see him he's not yet up on the screen so we'll wait for him to magically appear so I can question him about his whereabouts we need to have member mcquillin before we can begin there he is we see you Jim good morning consistent with changes in the laws governing our meetings I must ask member mcquillin would you confirm that you are present I am here good morning everyone we're glad to see you and would you confirm that there is nobody in the room you are participating from remotely there's nobody in the room nobody in the room except

002me good morning all that's that's great good to have you uh seeing that the board members are now all present I hereby call the January 2025 meeting of the State Board of Education to order at 8:37 a.m. and I'd like to commence by saluting the flag M Cabo will you please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance your ready begin I the United States of America stand indivisible liy and justice for all and I would now like to congratulate two of our board members member oen and member yoshimoto T who were reappointed by the governor on January 7th and I will be ceremonially swearing them in one at a time so first U member oen I think you need to come over here and we'll get the Constitution I did this on Zoom the first

003time yeah all right I think you raise your right hand I guess may you raise your right hand if you want to put your hand on the Constitution it's the left hand all right all right I Sharon oen do solemnly swear I Sharon oen do solemnly swear that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of the State of California that I take this obligation freely and I take this obligation freely without any mental

004reservation or Purp of evasion without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion and that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties and that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I am about to enter upon which I am about to enter congratulations thank you right thank you thank you and now member yoshimo raise your right hand all right I Alison yoshimoto Ari I Alison Yoshi motari do solemnly swear do solemnly swear that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States and

005the constitution of California and the constitution of California that I take this obligation freely I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion or purpose of evasion and that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties and that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I am about to enter upon which I'm about to [Applause] congratulations we're thrilled to have both of these members with us uh to continue the good work that we're in the in the middle of doing and at this time I am going to take up item one uh the annual election of officers uh we hold an election for the position of president for 2025 the bylaws requir that the state superintendent preside over the election of the president and

006such other business as the State Board may direct and I'll turn the gavl over to State superintendent Thurman you are free to bang it if you like thank you in keeping with article four of the state's Sports bylaws I'd like to call for nominations for the office of President no member May nominate or second the nomination for themselves and six votes are necessary to elect an officer and each officer elected Shall Serve for one year or until their successor is elected I will now open the floor for nominations for the office of President are there any nominations I'd like to nominate uh president Darlene Hammond is there a second to this nomination the nomination has been seconded um is there any public comment are there any additional nominations seen none let us move on to

007the vote members of the public wishing to provide comment on this item may do so by calling the number shown on the screen 717 981 926 and dialing the participant access code 116 6083 pound Mr Allen would you please call the role of course sir any public comments there are no colors in the que thank you member Clawson yes president darling Hammond yes member es Cabo yes vice president glev Woods yes yes member Lewis yes member mcquillin yes member Olin absolutely yeah I mean yes member Rosco Gonzalez yes member patillo brownson yes member Rodriguez yes member new doctor yoshimar T yes a motion carries unanimously you I'm glad this is easier than the speaker of the house uh determinations I was wondering how many ballots we might have to have um but I'm I'm really

008uh honored and privileged to serve with this board and with the state superintendent we are getting a lot of good work done on behalf of the children of California and in this uh Administration and I'm glad for us to continue to do it and run through the tape as the governor would say so uh now uh it's my pleasure to um uh uh in keeping with article four of the state bylaws call for nominations for the office of Vice President no member May nominate or second the nomination for him or herself member Lewis Madam president I nominate Uh current vice president uh Cynthia Glover Woods do I have a second oh my second third fourth you can uh and um is there any public comment the public comment slide should be displayed there is no

009public comment okay and anyone wishing to provide comment by calling in can do so by calling the number and using the participant access code on this slide are there I'm going to give a little wait time is there any callers in the queue there are no callers in the queue all right so um at this point Brooks can you call the role member Clawson yes president darling Hammond yes yes member scabo yes vice president glev Woods yes member Lewis yes member mcquillin yes member Olin yes please member Rosco Gonzalez yes member patillo brownson yes member Rodriguez yes Yosh marari yes Mo carries [Applause] Nan all right well let's get down to business we have a lot to do um General announcements I'd like to welcome board members staff and members of the public who are

010attending this board meeting in person uh the consent calendar includes the proposed waiver consent items W1 through W4 and the proposed regular consent items items 6 through 12 there is one public hearing on the agenda it is item 15 the petition for the renewal of a charter school authorized by the California State Board of Education which is the consideration of the High-Tech high state benefit Charter uh in terms of changes in the agenda we will reopen item one SB priorities shortly to hear reports from the state superintendent and myself we will reopen item one again later today to take action on the preliminary report of the actions draft November 2024 meeting minutes and to report on our liaison assignments item four was revised to reflect the addition of item attachment to posted on January 10th

0112025 item 13 was is revised to reflect the addition of attachment one posted on January 10th of 2025 public comment will be accepted either in person or by phone members of the public wishing to call in for public comment should view the live stream of the meeting to know at what time public comment will occur for each item public comment may be provided by dialing the phone number entering a participant access code and then following each of the operators prompts upon dialing in callers will be added to a caller queue the operator will call notify callers when it is their turn to provide public comment we'll also ask callers to please turn down the speaker volume of their computers if they are following the live webcast to avoid an echoing effect members of the public

012wishing to provide public comment in person should sign in using the binder at the table just outside the room the binder is on the table with separate pages for each item number this helps ensure that staff is able to track the in-person speakers for a particular item public comet is limited to one it minute per speaker where speakers require interpretation two minutes will be provided uh and item 16 is the general public comment item during which members of the public May provide comment on matters that are not specifically listed on the board's agenda I will now reopen item one and turn it over to State superintendent chief chief Deputy oh there he is he's already at the like wait a minute stay superintendent Tony Thurman at the podium thank you madam president the gavl is

013back in your hands where it belongs allow me to offer my congratulations to you on your election as president that we enjoy the benefit of your continued leadership in this great state on all things education and to our vice president that we uh have your leadership and thank you for participating in so many of our conversations about how we address educational disparities for our students for African-American students and others we're grateful for you we're grateful for all of you as this is the first meeting of the year I'm grateful to welcome you back uh we look forward to your advice your Council your leadership as we navigate difficult times uh but there are also some positive things ahead for us to look to if you looked at the governor's proposed budget you will see that

014it proposes to fully fund transitional kindergarten and continue a mandate in this state that Early Education will be a priority for California students and we know that that will close gaps and so we know that there are more things to look forward to I wish the vote was here today um but that budget proposal must go through the legislative process but it is uh a great thing to be able to say that California is the only state that provides preschool for every three and four year old and that our governor has proposed that we fully fund it with very low class sizes uh for our students my heart is heavy for our families in Southern California uh we know um that there is just Devastation all around um having had an opportunity this week to

015visit with school leaders and uh family members and students and Community leaders in Pasadena and Altadena um the the devastation is what you've seen on your television and our hearts and prayers go out to those uh who've lost loved ones we recognize that many have lost homes um that schools have been damaged and in some cases destroyed um these are among the most difficult times um I'm very grateful to our firefighters and our First Responders who continue um to do the hard work to put out these fires even under conditions where the wind is rising even as we speak um I'm grateful to our governor and his executive orders um and the State Board staff and others who've worked on them to uh provide schools with the flexibilities that they need um to navigate these

016difficult times we've tried to communicate directly to schools that their main focus should be the safety of children and staff and that this state will hold them harmless as it relates to Ada and revenue and so that message has been communicated directly to schools uh through executive orders uh I want to acknowledge the teams at the Department of Education and the State Board of Education who are working around the clock uh with the office of emergency services and um the emergency units to help schools and family members navigate FEMA and all the resources that are available um but require assistance to get through um to the staff who have uh worked to get meals and basic Aid even housing to put it in context in Pasadena there are 1300 School staff who live in the

017area most impacted by the virus many without homes and I want to thank abil keen and uh the Emergency Services team um who've been working to round up resources like free housing for a month airbnbs uh nonprofit or just finding rentals and housing we know that many of the communities who have been affected are communities that are historic in that they were among the first to desegregate their schools and desegregate their communities and we've heard the call having met with uh some three dozen principles at in Pasadena we've heard their call to make sure that we help everyone in this moment and not let this be a moment for communities low-income communities and communities of color to be displaced during this time so we ask you all to do what you can to support we

018thank you all who've given through our nonprofit charitable partner at Supply bank.org which is a tax deductible contribution that helps for any of the emergency supplies and resources um that our uh families might need as difficult as it is one thing is true every single student deserves to still have a quality education and we're grateful to all the teachers the classified staff the administrators who continue to persevere uh you know I had the chance to serve some meals to families and passadena unified this week and what I saw in spite of the hardship I saw the resilience of Californians I saw families come up to the school and even in their moment of hardship they recognize a friendly face someone who they knew from the school Community it reminded me of the pandemic where our

019schools provided more than 900 million meals and other Main and basic supplies and so uh we will continue to work together to help our school districts find locations for replacement facilities and schools we will help them to continue to provide a quality education uh for all of our students and so thank you all for your will wishes for our California families and again uh to those who are on the ground level uh continuing to help Californians I I want to welcome our Senate uh interns today and congratulate them we look forward to spending time with you and congratulations to you and to the finalists uh on this week we were able to still celebrate our five California teachers of the year and the stories that their students shared about them was so inspiring and rousing

020and so we know that we must continue to provide a great education sadly during even during these times of hardship we have heard reports all across the state of families who are fearful of being deported uh in the Central Valley uh in Southern California in the Bay Area throughout our state it is unimaginable uh that our families many of whom are mixed status families would EXP experience such consequence and threat we must stand against that we know that it hurts our families and we know that the fear of consequences of deportation suppresses attendance at our schools we know because research tells us that when these acts and threats occur we see fewer students at school uh our immigrant students often have an academic consequence and so we want to support them for those Reasons I'm

021honored to have uh sponsored leg ation uh with Senate majority leer uh leader uh Lena Gonzalez S sp48 A bill that clarifies that there's no place for ice immigration on our school campuses that data cannot be released to ice and that it creates a on M radius of protection uh for families who might even be concerned about traveling to schools and so uh this is a bill that's been introduced this year with urgency uh we look forward forward to its passage we want to see all of our students be successful we continue our conversation about how to build competency uh for our students in ela and math through our move the needle um uh initiative where we're working with 250 uh school districts uh we are grateful for many of you who have shared your

022thoughts about uh how we uh can continue to help our students who've made Improvement um but we know that more is needed needed uh I thank many of you uh for your contributions about bright spots Dr darling Hammond Dr esab those so many of you who have shared the bright spots and how we help our students work through the challenges that they face we have 24,000 homeless students in this state we have 10,000 unaccompanied students and many who live in poverty and as we work through these challenges with our programs like Universal meals and Community Schools to help remove barriers so our students can experience academic success we know that we must keep the proficiency of our students front and center preparing them for a great future making sure that they have strong skills in

023literacy and math this budget as I mentioned proposes to provide incredible contributions around coaches in reading and math that builds on all the Investments that this state has made under the leadership of our governor and our board president and our team and our office all working together and so uh in spite of challenges I still see signs for Hope and we have much uh that we can do as we continue to move forward I want to acknowledge uh some new staff who I we will be asking the board to approve in advance I'm respectfully asking for your I vote as we welcome two new staff to the department but I want to begin by acknowledging uh Mary nicely uh who continues to be a leader of all the leaders at the department and is Shifting

024to a new role that will help us Advance the way we use technology to help our students Mary is going to be shifting to the role of Deputy of information and in that capacity she will help us to roll out a new AI work group that was approved in legislation in the last session that says we must find ways to use AI as a tool to help every California Student learn and we'll be leading the superintendent's Initiative for steam advisory uh activities so that our students learn firsthand where the profession is headed and they will learn about computer science and Ai and other Tech cyber security and other types of Technology uh for uh their future and for strengthening our communities um I would like to take a moment of personal privilege as a say

025say thank you very nicely for all that you do here at the California Department of [Applause] Education as you can see she'll still be bossing me around I mean advising me uh and our team on many things and um we're grateful that you're bringing your three decades of experience uh as a leader in the field of Technology um to this new and exciting position thank you Mary uh on that note I'm excited to introduce uh two new members of the California Department of Education team and in many ways this is a reintroduction uh for many of you because they've been working in education and they are partners and you know them um they will both serve as Chief deputies uh at the co-chief deputies at the department um and uh they are here in the

026chamber and I want to uh invite you to join me as we welcome uh co-chief deputies David shapy and Dr ingred Roberson who are to my right um they will many of you know uh David shapy for his many years of service um at the California School Employees Association um he has uh personally written legislation to help us close the gap in chronic absenteeism um and many other initiatives um prior to to that he has served as a teacher uh uh with a specialty around Career Technical education uh he has served as a principal he has served as a city council member School Board member and state legislator and in spite of all of that he's asking to do more and so we're grateful to have him here um and uh Dr Roberson uh who

027many of you know as a partner who uh works with us right now at CCE who has worked as a leader in uh San Francisco Isco Unified School District at Oakland Unified School District for more than 10 years the deputy Superintendent at the Alam County Office of Education we anticipate that uh Dr Roberson will help us uh think through some of our strategies like move the needle uh for proficiency and the work that we do to accelerate uh black student achievement um we anticipate that she will work with many of our programs that focus on teaching and learning and we anticipate that Mr shapy will work on our legislation with our legislative teams with our Communications teams and with many of the superintendent special initiatives and so without further Ado and before they can change

028their mind and try to go someplace else um I would submit to you um uh to the board uh our request for your I vote um to approve uh these two Chief uh uh co-chief deputies at the Department of Education I think what we want to do is open the um phone line right for public comment um so we're going to now open the phone line for public comment members of the public wishing to provide comment on this item may do so in person or by calling the telephone number and using the access code provided on the slide that is shown now there it is uh are there any speakers signed up to provide public comment in person there are no speakers in the room all right and is there anyone uh waiting to provide

029public comment on the phone line there are no callers in the queue all right so do I have a motion member Rodriguez thank you and a second from member rcoo um can you call the role member Clawson yes president darling Hammond yes member of scabo yes vice president glev Woods yes member Le yes member mcquillin yes member Olin yes member Rosco Gonzalez yes member patillo brownson yes member Rodriguez yes member yosha Mari yes the motion carries unanimously all right congratulations thank you board members thank you madam president this concludes my report I'll be uh unless there are any questions from the members of the board I'll be stepping out uh just momentarily to attend Black History Month being uh hit event being provided by the California legislative Black Caucus um I leave you in the

030capable hands of Mary nicely um any questions for me this concludes my report thank you so much and uh I will piggyback on uh those comments and um also I want to start by acknowledging Mary nicely's um amazing work with us over these years and my excitement about your ability to get uh deep into the technology work that I know is your expertise um and welcome our new uh deputies um I want to reinforce Our concern for those impacted by the devastating fires of course and the brave firefighters and Educators and family members and School staff of all kinds who've been stepping up um in addition to the nine schools that have been destroyed or damaged more than a thousand schools were closed uh over the at the worst point last week uh impacting the

031learning of more than 600,000 students so it is a an a huge um undertaking the majority of those schools have since reopened for daily instruction but the trauma for those families uh who have lost their homes who've been displaced by the fires will continue for many months it's going to take many many months to rebuild the schools and the communities and we'll need to support them in many ways um State superintendent Thurman mentioned the governor's executive order which uh uh clears the way for a number of flexibilities suspending a number of the state rules to allow displaced students to attend school outside of their District make it easier for schools damaged or destroyed in the fire to use temporary facilities help schools avoid penalties for not meeting minimum school year requirements direct state agencies to

032work with schools with destroyed or damag buildings to develop a plan for serving displaced students uh and you know we um uh over a year ago put in place some uh affordances for instructional continuity anticipating that climate events would begin to make it more difficult for students to be in school in person but we want them to be uh continue to have access to education and so there are um already um uh in the budget from last year a number of proposals to to allow for that to encourage leas to implement attendance recovery programs that allow us to recapture lost instructional time we have streamline the process to provide hybrid and virtual learning options when students can't be in the classroom making access to the independent study you know container for that work U more

033available and then to build on the infrastructure and processes developed during covid-19 uh to ensure that students you know receive instruction we learned a lot about how to access instruction for students when buildings are not available and we need to you use that knowledge uh in this event and in uh other events that may occur so we hope that we can really support schools uh in doing that um as state superintendent Thurman noted the budget announcement uh came last week which uh allows us to um invest in um Universal prek we uh have uh expanded before after and summer school uh funding uh Universal School meals continues uh increase in um literacy and math coaches now as we begin to implement the math framework uh and increases in local control funding formula so that the

034schools can continue to um expand their opportunities for students uh we know how valid our state finances can be uh from one year to the yet next and so we're focusing on stability in the budget and there'll be more to come in the few next few months we do hope the state's uh fiscal Revenue picture continues to improve as it has been a little bit lately uh as we get closer to the annual May budget revision um this year in addition to Universal TK uh which is an enormous accomplishment in a very short period of time all four-year-olds will be able to attend Universal pre kindergarten and we're already to appoint uh about four years ago about a third of our four-year-olds were a able to attend publicly funded prek uh we're now up over

035half about 54% and that will continue to grow as we as these programs come uh online uh but we also have this is the first year for implementation grants for the partnership Pro School Community Schools partnership program to be fully dispersed so we now have all of those Community Schools uh up and running uh more than a quarter of the state schools are now Community Schools uh all of the local education agencies can access the child and youth Behavioral Health Initiative initiative fee schedule which allows more funding for Behavioral Health Services and could be a through line for continuity for Community Schools as well uh all educators will have access to the literacy road map which is about to be released uh to provide instructional planning guidance and strategies aligned with the uh Ela ELD

036framework all kindergarten through second grade students will be screened for risk of reading disabilities uh or difficulties including dyslexia ensuring early identification and support as you know uh the reading difficulties RIS screener selection panel uh very well led by Dr Young suim and supported by Vice chair Yia Guerrero uh reported its um recommendations last month and so by September uh districts will have a choice of uh four um different screeners um in English and Spanish uh and with the with strong validity evidence there's a very high bar to be selected uh in terms of the quality of the research the validity for multilingual Learners uh and California will be the first state to have accomplished I think such a strong start on multilingual screening with very uh well um designed screeners and more languages are

037coming online we hope that is the plan of some of the um uh the the folks who are doing the work around those screeners so I want to thank that panel they worked so hard in such a short period of time to get that work done and we really really appreciate them um we have other signs of positive progress that were visible on the dashboard this year um all of the student groups showed significant declines in chronic absenteeism uh we have continued State growth and graduation rates uh with the largest cohort of students graduating since 197 uh 2017 not 1917 way more way more than in 1917 uh College and Career Readiness was maintained for all students and increased for black students American Indian students long-term English Learners so we're beginning to narrow some of

038these longstanding achievement gaps which we also saw in the um achievement results earlier this year suspension rates declined for every student group we still need to focus on disparities and suspension and I'm grateful to the state superintendent and the CDE for continuing to you know help the state uh step up around restorative practices and be knowledgeable about the alternatives to suspension so we're getting students back to school and getting more of them prepared for college and careers we're graduating them in greater numbers we're supporting stronger gains for black students Native American students students in foster care socioeconomically disadvantaged students all of those groups gained in various indicators at rates above the state average gains um obviously there's a lot of work still to do and it'll be very important to continue these forward-looking initiatives into

039future years so that they continue to pay dividends for us um so with that I want to uh congratulate again uh Sharon oen and Allison your shimoto t on their recent reappointments and um it's a testament to the dedication that you both bring to this work and move on to the work ahead oh okay uh we want to see if uh David and ingred want to say anything uh now that they've been appointed as well sorry we skipped over that opportunity a little earlier oh thank you thank you for that uh good morning state board uh board president uh vice president um it is really an honor and privilege to be able to step into this role I have been in education since 1995 I started as an instructional assistant um and so it is

040an incredible honor to be standing here today um and I am deeply committed to public education uh in my latest role at the California collaborative for educational Excellence I have been able to see what the need is and the good work across the state whether I have been in sanro which is in San Diego County right on the border and what they're doing for English language Learners and reclassification in a way that is Rich and joyful education or in Taff City uh which is in Kar County and what the teachers are doing there and the hard work around the science of reading so they can do better for students uh whether it has been in Oakland Unified School District and the work that happened there for African-American students and as Chris Chapman of Kings maker

041has said uh those students are doing incredible things and we need to change the story of black students and really Elevate black Student Success that's something near and dear to my heart especially when it comes to my son who's biracial he is afro Latino uh or whether we're talking about humbal County and the work that they're doing around chronic absentismo native communities right what are those strategies that really speak to those communities so people are working really hard I have also really heard from those districts from those communities how they look to the California Department of Education for guidance for leadership so I am very excited to be here to support 1500 plus leaders uh in really supporting what the state needs to accomplish and Achieve and to do that under the leadership of uh

042State superintendent Tony Thurman who really is fighting for the California way and I am deeply supportive of that thank you [Applause] good morning Madam president Madam vice president members of the board staff and guests I I was asked by Brooks appreciate it to to put together just a few remarks uh this morning and I I sat down to write it down and realized I've been writing it my whole life from the student that is desperate for a place to belong and looking for caring adults other than their own family to the School Employees faculty and staff who are looking for the resources to provide what their students need to the school leaders who are desperate for guidance and ideas to the elected leaders and appointed officials who are looking for the answers to the questions

043that their constituents are asking to provide what our students need all of those folks need all of us in this room to be on our aame and I am excited to be a part of this uh in part because I've seen our education system from every single one of those perspectives and so it is incumbent on us as the elected and appointed officials and all of the great team at the California Department of Education under the leadership of superintendent Thurman to provide those answers those resources those policies those budgets uh working in conjunction with our friends in the state capital and the governor uh to ensure that each of those needs at each of those levels are met I've worked my whole career uh to try to have as much positive impact on as many

044students as I possibly could from my classroom to my school district to my work in as an Ed official and to my work as a education Advocate and I can't think of any role in this country that has more impact on more students than the roles of the people in this room and so uh I'm so excited to be a part of this team to work shoulder-to-shoulder with each of you to benefit the students of the State of California excited for this opportunity and thankful for this appointment and for you all and superintendent Thurman trusting and gr and myself to take on these important responsibilities thank you so much thank you very much and congratulations again we're eager to work together um and with that I'm going to move on to item three uh which

045is a mega item uh it is uh the update on the implementation of the integrated local state and federal accountability and continuous Improvement system colon review of the 2024 California school dashboard 2023 24 data release and approval of the 2025 accountability work plan so this is very um uh important uh work for us I'm delighted to um welcome Cindy kazanis uh to begin to present the item with Kimberly M and DT vanet of the CDE morning uh welcome everyone um happy New Year um uh Cindy kazanas with the California Department of Education uh we uh to Echo the superintendent comments um we have been working with the affected districts um around accountability and even data collection and so um just know that um we are um monitoring the situation as well and have been um

046in direct contact with um uh some of the most impacted districts to see how we can help them not only um in the days ahead but um um to your point months and probably years ahead uh today um we are going to talk a little bit about feeling an echo so if if you feel an echo just let me know um we're going to talk about uh the California school dashboard and I know that um president darling Hammond already gave you um a bit of an overview as to um what happened this past year um we also are going to present to you our 2025 accountability work plan and look forward to your feedback and um uh comments related to that work plan it's it's very ambitious we have to get all of this work

047done ahead of um the close of our data set which is in August this year um and then briefly um have an update on our Outreach activities so the recommendation today is that um the State Board of Education provide guidance and approve the proposed 2025 accountability work plan uh we're going to take things out of order and first I'm going to talk about last year and then we're going to move on to current year uh you know we had we had a banner year we had a brand new student group added to the dashboard for reporting purposes which is our long-term English learner student group so now we have 14 student groups being reported on the dashboard um this slide shows you our race ethnicity student groups and then our program student groups on the

048right column in terms of our long-term English learner students uh we have of course a definition that is unique to accountability related to um the number of years that a student has um not obtained English language proficiency and just to give you a glimpse as to what this population looks like it's just over 300,000 students in that population um we uh prior Direction last year we included them in our determinations for the local control funding formula for differentiated assistance and you will see them they showed up um uh absolutely um very present in that data um in most need of support we also were excited to have a a new indicator and um science appeared for informational purposes and uh what a buzz right we spent um the beginning of last year talking about how

049science was unique we continued with that conversation with the adoption of the methodology and then we did a lot of um resource um development and um informational meetings about how science um was coming on board so of course that's based on both of our science test not only our California science test but our alternate Science assessment for um for science which is the ca a for science uh science is still continues to be unique we have different um scales that we use from our English language arts and math uh indicators uh and we have um you know a unique set of grades tested we're only looking at grades five eight and once in high school we don't have performance levels we're going to talk about that today we're going to talk about and um get

050feedback from you on where to head on this in 2025 the other exciting thing and this was in um direct uh uh Direct D direct uh requirement from the legislature is to add a a downloadable copy of every single district and Charter Schools local control uh and accountability plan to the dashboard so in a two to three week period Josh strong um and his team were able to get every single District in the state and um Charter School to add that information um to the dashboard so you now see it not as a link it's actually a file um some of them are big um you know 400 pages long others of them um maybe half the size but that is now a resource again as directed by the legislature that appears on the dashboard

051so just to overall summary um we did see um progress in um decline of suspension rates our chronic absenteeism remains yellow we're going to dig into each of these um very briefly um we have uh improvements um uh still to uh work on between our English learner progress indicators and our um academic indicators as you can see all of those are in the orange at the state level so chronic absenteeism really is um quite a story this year um with a deine a continued decline of 5.7% um for the dashboard when we looking at um TK through grade eight we are down to under 20% um chronic absenteeism which is headed in the right direction and also um to the point where we want to see which is back to prepandemic levels um so just

052in terms of last year we saw every single um uh District um and uh uh rather student group level in in the state at at the yellow um we now see a more um a different distribution right we see improvements that are being made we see districts that have um obtained that blue um status as well as schools so for each of the indicators just briefly um I'll give you the snapshot we'll dig into the school and district and then we'll um continue on um until we get to the uh district and school eligibility piece so for suspension again um we saw this decline of 3% and so we're at the green um at the state level um overall for schools you can see the representation in each of the um categories um with a

053very strong presence in the blue so definitely have schools that have developed perhaps alternative practices um and are not suspending students or finding alternative means um besides uh uh students losing a day in the classroom for English learner progress indicator this is um an indicator That Grew this year because we now added a second student group our long-term English learner students and they appear at the bottom of that um baseball card in the orange um this indicator did see a decline of 3% and then overall um we see um the number of schools that um receive an English learner progress indicator of course we're looking at um 30 for our um English Learners and 15 students for our long-term English learner students you also see the district Distribution on on this slide graduation rate continues

054to maintain which is great news um that um we have um a lot of majority of our students uh graduating within a four to five year period um as a whole we see um again the distributions of our schools and our districts of those that are serving um our grade 12 students and um receive this indicator college career is also something that came back this year with a full color so um we have not had a color since before for covid um and as um an indicator uh can we see about 45% of our students being prepared um which was maintained and the majority of our student population is falling in um the yellow category um similar to graduation rate again you see those that have grade 12 students um appearing um on uh on

055this slide with um the distribution of the colors uh by school and district and then finally just switching into our um two academic indicators English language arts um we we've already gone over this I know with with Mal and um your uh prior meeting but um as a whole we're at the orange with um a maintained and then for U mathematics a maintained as well at 1.5 points um in terms of the Statewide indicator for science um it came came in as a teal um with no performance color um and as a state we were at 13.5 points below standard which was um just slightly up at Point 1 points so just in terms of all of our indicators um there is quite a bit of information not only on the dashboard our additional reports

056but also our downloadable files switching over to local control and um uh our funding determination formulas so we have the three levels of support I would or four levels if you want to include our state um level intervention and what we're uh looking at and what we're required to look at based on um what you've adopted as the criteria is who uh may be eligible for level two support um so that is for um our local educational agencies so schools and districts and then charter schools have a slightly different um criteria that we have to look at so in terms of the criteria um for districts and counties we're looking at student group performance in two or more of the lcf priority areas we're also looking at performance on local indicators or we're looking at

057a combination of the two so this is after all the data has been processed we look to see and apply these criteria to see who may be eligible and of course the story is we continue to see from that High um uh year in 2022 right after Co when we first started looking at um data for accountability purposes again uh that we continue to have a steady um decline in um the number of districts that are eligible um such that we're at uh less than half at 436 districts and Coes um that are eligible for differentiated assistance uh we're often asked like how many of those um were no longer eligible and we had 153 districts and County offices make Improvement such that they're no longer eligible but we had 123 that were newly eligible

058so that gives us the the net um decrease of about 30 um school districts and county offices so um the the one thing I wanted to point out on this slide and we I referred to it um a little earlier when we're talking about student groups is that um for the first time since we released the dashboard in 2017 the um the student group that was the most need of support which has been students with disabilities um all these years has been um replaced by long-term English Learners so that is um absolutely significant and I think one thing to keep in mind is that um at the district level and county office level we uh decrease the end size for long-term English Learners to 15 so this is something that was in statute um that

059we were required to do we do that as well for homeless students and our foster students um for schools we all are operating at the end size of 30 per our SS plan so in terms of charter schools and again slightly different criteria um we see this net decrease of 30 charter schools that are eligible for differentiated assistance in terms of what that looks like of charter schools that are no longer eligible we have 94 um uh improv such that they're no longer eligible for differentiated assistance and then we have um 67 that were newly eligible uh and uh what that um means in the charter school space is that 13.6% of Charter Schools were uh are eligible to receive differentiated assistance um but that we did have that exit of the 94 and the

060student groups look a little different um for uh charter schools because we have this two-year um look that we need to do so there's um is students with disabilities socionomic disadvantaged and English Learners as a student groups in most need of support so just again wanted to give you that overview because the criteria that you adopt directly impact um what we see as well as of course the performance and the improvements that we've seen over the years so I think there's a lot to celebrate um uh as far as improvements at the district um we we have seen some analysis from the county superintendents who have indicated that the long-term English learner um addition has brought in rather almost 50% of our districts are eligible in part because of long-term English Learners so that group

061really did arrive um with a bang and with a lot of notice and um a lot of need of support shifting over to our every student succeeds act um we're thrilled that we actually got it out in the same year in which the data was released we've never been able to do this before but part of that was in part due to um the administration and and our leadership um supporting additional resources and positions um for this work but also this requirement to keep moving up the deadline to release the dashboard so if we can get the same team that is p putting out the dashboard freed up so that they can switch over to these determinations we can get this out out um even earlier in in years um years ahead so they we

062did release this information on Friday the 13th in December um I know very very ironic I won't forget that um right as the California Church Advisory Group was meeting um with a member Woods was here for for that um and uh really um you know for for a lot of other states this is they don't have any other kinds of determinations they don't have a DA criteria but we we have differentiated aist which really um the state feels very strongly that the district is the center of all support we also though on the federal side have to make these determinations at the school level so um just in case you know we've forgotten all these acronyms we have comprehensive support and Improvement um which first we have to look at low graduation rate so anybody

063who has a three-year graduation R average below 68% is automatically identified CSI low performing is limited to our 5% Title One schools and then this um designation of additional targeted support and Improvement atsi and then TSI I'm going to skip over to this slide because this graphic to me really represents very easily where we're at California for the first time is in our three-year cycle other states have gone through this already once they're in their second three-year cycle but what this means for California is that for the first time in 2024 we did not have to re-identify CSI or atsi so those schools have some continuity they can actually Implement their plans they also have the opportunity to exit and I'm going to show you um really the the improvements that a lot of schools

064have made so they've exited um these statuses we had though for the first time to identify schools for this new um uh label which is TSI which is really just using the same criteria as atsi in these um off years so in terms of um that three-year cycle um we don't have to re-identify now until 2026 so we've got we've got another year off before we have to make these designations um but in terms of um who was identified in year one which was La um in 2023 we had um low graduation rate of 289 schools that met that criteria and 540 low performing or Title One schools so as far as exits um 62 of the 289 low graduation rate exit but the big one was under low performing 419 so really significant exits

065um from CSI low performing and keep in mind for California um CSI does come with funding there is a grant that is given um uh per school basis an allocation that's done by a different division so um as they exit um you know I think there's already a talk from the county superintendent I was in a conversation last week is how do you continue to support those programs knowing that the funding is going to be going away the other significant decrease is the exits um in atsi of 1,700 schools um down from the 2300 so really um as a state have done quite a bit of of work in terms of targeted support and Improvement again um we have 306 schools that were identified for this label and just as far as the criteria again

066looking at um um the eligibility uh for uh red indicators um for each of um the areas is how we make these determinations and so just to give you a full breath of all that data together um for atsi we of course didn't have to um make that identification last year um but this year with the 306 that brings us um to um really you know the overall majority of schools so upwards of 87% of schools don't need any of these statuses and that's great a great place to be um for the state um so that no status of 8700 schools is is very significant when I look back especially at that first year of um postco where we had the opposite practically um so that's the great news um we continue to support a

067dashboard toolkit um which is um something that um we're doing office hours on and people come and submit questions and um it's quite quite this uh like a it feels like you're back in college asking your professor questions but um it's been a great opportunity for the um for leas who have to support the rle out of this and explain this to to community members and to um even Educators in their District um these tool kits have been that I items in the toolkit have been U very well used we've also stood up a web page dedicated to English Learners around um the data piece because we recognize that um our assessment colleagues have a different definition that they have to implement and so the numbers um slightly differ and so we've actually um put

068a lot of work and effort and we've gotten a lot of feedback on this web page and um it's been I think well received by the field as a as a great resource as to how do you maneuver when you've got two different definitions you're working on and um talking about what the field so with that I wanted to pause and um turn it back to president darling ham to see if there was questions or or um Insight that you would like to share uh related to the results from this last year clarifying questions have the TSI I know is new I'm just wondering were there any schools that exited at TSI or CSI that are now in TSI was there any redundancy there and if there were why I'm just curious so the criteria

069is if you if you exit CSI or atsi we have to look to see if you are then eligible for for the TSI piece and my my recollection was there was a small a small number I don't have it off the top of my head it was not significant it wasn't you know 50% of the 300 but there was a small number so they may have improved for the student groups they were originally in for but there may have been um you know lack of progress for other student groups or or or um a decline on those other student groups that's how they would have been eligible if that's the case are are we working on trying to create more of a coherent model in the future between these categories of improvement I'd love to

070talk with you outline offline because I'm not quite sure I I I understand the question the the the criteria are that um are exactly the same it's that the school or the the school would not be performing for one student group would would get them in it it's not the same student group that originally got them in right so if it was um I don't know your your homeless students and your um Hispanic students and they've improved but then we have to look to see maybe your students with disabilities have decreased and so you'd be eligible because of you know a different student group um but it gets to the point that um I know that there's um webinars coming up that the individuals who do the support piece of this and the planning piece

071of this are um going to be out in the field over the next couple of weeks definitely um providing resources to districts on this any other clarifying questions at this point all right I think we'll go ahead and um continue with right the next perfect um so just uh Switching gears to um the accountability work plan for 2025 so what is um planned for the the months ahead and looking for direction from you on this next section uh specifically um we have operated since um the uh accountability system was um put in place in 2016 2017 on this continuous Improvement model um you still see um interest from the legislature to make TW weeks as well and so this work plan provides you that opportunity to have a conversation and direct um the work uh

072for the year ahead uh we uh per SB 114 that was of course passed in 2023 have yet a new deadline to produce the dashboard this year it's November 15th which is a Saturday so we'll definitely be um getting it out ahead of then again so before before the Thanksgiving break um for schools rather um and then of course next year is the big one where we move it up to October 15th at the same time as our assessment result requirements um so we have quite a bit to to cover I'm going to cover um just the first section of the every student succeeds act and then I'm going to pause um for I think a brief conversation and then I'm going to turn it over to my colleague Kimberly mhen to cover um the

073majority of these other um items so one of the first things we're going to be talking about is the every student succeeds act state plan um we have a new student group we have a couple other things that um you may want to um include in our federal plan for each of these items we've put in the in the actual um doc doent but we will'll reflect in the beginning of um each of the pieces that you adopted principles around the dashboard several years ago and how do these um you know reflect back on those principles so just a nice reminder that um we are grounded in um uh you know C certain things that we've been doing for a number of years not to say that we can't change them but just um these

074are the principles that we are uh working towards for this particular section so uh the three pieces that we are looking for Direction on um for 2020 that would be effective with next year's dashboard is uh if we were to reopen the state plan adding the science indicator adding long-term English Learners as a student group and adding um our growth data and so um we are looking for um direction from you all if this is something you would like us to pursue um this is a very long process um you have to go uh back and forth with the US Department of Education um when they may have questions um around the state plan and so um we want to start this early for again implementation in 2026 because any um changes you make to

075the state plan we would have to include in our um uh our eligibility requirements for CSI atsi and TSI so that's the connection there between um School eligibility and the esate plan and that's my only slide on this um president darling Hammond so um just to kind of set a frame because as we're listening to the rest of the presentation this point that Cindy is making is a really important one um the previous board at the time that Essa was passed sought to develop a system that was unified federal and state accountability um and that was a good decision at that time uh and it's allowed us to do a multiple measures approach we were one of the first states to really start to Define that and so on um the good work that uh

076that Cindy's division has done and that uh many um interest holders in the state have done have encouraged us to add more and more elements to the um data collection and death for because we see that people benefit from the data and benefit from being able to do that um however one of the principles that that um uh Cindy just showed is the one of coherence um and you know promoting coherence between um the in information in the school Improvement and so the question about whether to um continue to keep everything yolked to the federal um process uh to have all of our state accountability determined essentially by the federal accountability at a time of great uncertainty uh and um the given the time effort that cindia has suggested but also the uncertainty that that

077would pose for our own provision of State accountability should allow us to think U more with a with an open mind about the question of whether we want to continue to develop our state system uh in ways that are productive for us and for our schools uh rather than necessarily having everything that we do yoked to the federal system and to Federal decision makers who are unknown uh at this moment um because there's a lot of transition happening uh to put it um in one way so anyway I just want to I just want to frame up the fact that we have those decisions to make that we have decisions to make what about what will be productive for our schools for our systems of support for our Improvement processes for our and the fact

078that we want to have data uh and we do uh benefit from all of the data um we don't want to be constrained in adding data points that will allow us to drive School Improvement productively here uh or to have to use those in a way that is determined outside of um our understanding of what's working and what is making sense so just to make that point that um you know the accountability division is sort of uh asking us to think about what uh we should be doing with these new indicators which we're all excited about uh and whether we want to use them for uh reopening the Essa state plan which would be a whole process um to get Federal approval for implementing them in the federal system or whether to uh potentially uh

079think about them uh at least in part as um State uh accountability and um Improvement measures for us so with that um any other questions of clarification I just wanted to raise that up because it's an important point and um you can ask Cindy if you have clarification questions about that or we can proceed and we can then bring it into the discussion later sound good all right and just to note that there are these big differences between some aspects of the federal and the state System including the fact that we made a decision to focus more on districts they made a decision to focus more on schools Etc so the coherence question is becoming noticeable very good good morning state board um and president uh darling Hammond Kimberly monank administrator of the accountability development

080and policy analysis unit happy to walk you through our ambitious plan for this year I feel like we say that every year but goodness gracious there's a lot to go through in the next few months um and we're going to start off with the newest indicator on the dashboard and see where it takes us this year so this includes oper options for the incorporation of the science indicator fully into the dashboard um our work plan principles um that go through for this are five 8 and 11 so to bring us back to how science how we've gotten here today in 2018 we administered in the state the very first California science test um the operational version of that um and that was two students in grades five eight and ones during a high school career

081for um those students and at the March 2020 state board meeting um very preent at that time um the state board first discussed the incorporation of science fully into the dashboard um some things happened in 2020 21 and 22 um but two years later right as we were getting and rolling everything back up with accountability in March of 2022 you asked us to look at this again not to forget about essentially where things you know where we stopped um and bring science back into the fold um and in September of 2022 um you approved the insertion of a link to the dashboard additional reports directly to the science test results so it wasn't on the dashboard but we wanted to signal that that was coming in the future um and that was really important for

082you to be able to Showcase that science was important and it was being valued in this sense so we did that in 2022 and we did it again in 2023 however last year in July you fully adopted a metric and all of those lovely decisions that you made around how we would in um measure science performance um and inclusive of a participation rate um and how we would measure student performance in high school I think that's one of my probably the most frequently Asked question that we're getting recently right how are you doing this and I'm so glad that you guys gave us those answers um and then in November on the dashboard a beautiful teal baseball card shows up with science results um and it is in a section for informational purposes only um

083but people are noticing it and recognizing science on the dashboard and we're so proud to be able to have that in addition we've also published the participation rates in our additional reports so that just like our Ela and math participation rates and all of our downloadable files as well folks can see what participation on science looks like and if it looks a little bit different than their participation rate in Eli and math as we presented to the board previously so that takes us to this year in 2025 and the action that we need to take moving forward in order to fully fold in science further than what you've already done with the teal baseball card on the dashboard and so those remaining decision points um include the approval of status cut points change cut points

084and a color scheme for the 5x5 color grid as well as as we just spoke about options to include and fold science into either the state accountability system through differentiated assistance criteria the federal system right of identification for schools um or no inclusion at all so those are the decision points that we're walking through for this year's work plan um in detail what that means is that CDE would provide and evaluate the results from the last three um uh operational tests for the science assessments for both cast and ca for science I want to make sure we do we're including both of those there um so we would share the distribution of those results with the board from 2021 22 22 23 and 23 24 um and then you as the board would um consider

085establishing cut points for both status and change and choosing a color scheme for the 5x5 color grid as far as support determin elgibility determinations you would go through we would be able to provide um uh some ideas for how to fold science in and you'll be able to see based on the decisions that were made for cut points how how those um those decisions impacted or would affect possible support determinations looking backwards right and being able to see what those um choices are um and evaluate those choices for both state and federal identification options we would look to Bringing um those decision points two three and four to your very next board meeting in March we're going to be here a lot um and then we will go through um and you would be able

086to make that decision making the decision in March allows us to come back back with those simulations um for decision points five and six at the May board meeting for a final decision in July that also allows us to be able to bring this to the California practitioners Advisory Group in June so to for us to be able to have a full discussion about science for the next three board meetings as well um so that is what would look like for our science plan for the year next up growth um this is a long long journey but measuring student level growth for grades 4 through eight in English language arts and Mathematics um I think we continue to argue about when the found who thought of it first and how long it's taken us but

087I think we can all agree it's been a very long time um the principles for growth um that we're going to be evaluating are principles 2 4 five 8 and 11 um so as far as the recent history with the board um you adopted the growth calculation and I should say um probably the most valid and reliable growth calculation in our country so thank you very much for that um in May of 2021 um and we are incredibly proud um as I was sitting on my laptop and talking to folks we are planning for that roll out to happen of all of this data um by the end of this month in January um so uh you know as much as uh time I've got today to to make sure that that goes through um

088we're going to be releasing full the full set of data for English language arts and Mathematics growth data based on student performance in 2021 22 22 23 and 23 24 that will include results at all levels so not just so it would be schools districts and student groups at all of those levels and it will be on the dashboard um so the release of this results we are hoping begins a large set of conversations right that we can have with data forward um to not just with the board but with um all of the districts and schools to be able to see their results and really manifest and see what growth score looks like versus what they know about their students performance they know how and see their students growth they actually see those numbers

089but what does this score right look like in comparison and what does it look like to status and change on the dashboard as well so we're so excited to begin to have these conversations moving forward um our work plan looks like we will be obviously releasing this data by the end of this month um and this release will include results um on the dashboard in full graphical displays along with and this is our key Point here and work that ETS did um so great for us uh to be able to fully explain what growth the growth score is and what it is not um so we have full sentence explanations that folks can copy and paste um that they can share with others so um as to understand where their score is on the scale

090um and what it actually means so we're very very excited to be able to share that um so with this release we will begin those conversations with the field um and engage with them for the next few months and then come back in July um both for the June CPAC meeting as well as the July state board meeting um and have the opportunity for the board to approve performance standards for student growth and how are if growth will be account included in accountability determinations um additionally we you know if there's additional conversations we have before then we're welcome to those as well um and then absent anything else in late 2025 or 20 early 2026 we will release the next set of growth data based on 2022 23 23 24 and 20242 school year Casp

091data all right deep breath let's go again all right the CCI it came back in full color this year however um as it is one of the um probably the indicator that has had the most change of any indicator on the dashboard because it's got a lot of components and we would like to spend a little bit of time this year to review some of those currently adopted college career indicator components the work plan principles include principle 2 3 4 8 and 11 so just as a reminder and this is one um again one of those email things that I respond to often is um but for the college career indicator we are not measuring um how well students do however we are measuring how well schools and districts prepare their students so when we're

092looking at the criteria and components for um the college career indicator we're looking at the programs and pieces that schools and districts put into place to prepare students and that's what we're looking to measure so the development of the CCI was trying to emphasize that a high school diploma really represents the broad and rigorous course of study um that prepares a student for Success After High School um and while it was originally adopted back in 2016 um we only first perfor uh created performance levels um in the 2018 dashboard and it's based on all of the students in the four-year cohort um and those who graduate within five years as well um and it's reliant on both assessment criteria as well as a robust amount of course completion data that we collect um from uh

093schools and districts each year to measure whether or not students are prepared approaching prepared or not prepared for college or career upon graduation so what we're looking to do for the next few months is to review currently adopted components of college credit courses assessments as well as the state and federal jobs program for rocp and we are also looking to provide an update to the state board on the data collection for the Seal of Civic engagement for what we're looking to do for college credit courses currently just to let you know the data that we collect we are only collecting the college credit course code whether or not that is an academic course or if it is a CTE college credit course and whether or not a student receives a c minus or better that

094is the information that we utilize presently to gauge whether a student completed a college credit course we do not have any information on whether or not that college credit course has any transferability for ucsu whether it is in an A through G subject area or the minimum number of units that that course has we've received immense questions over the years about these three things does it need to be and our answer is simply we think should be doing things that are in the best interest of students constantly right and offering them the the best opportunities however we don't collect that information so we don't know if students who are completing college credit courses then we are looking and marking as prepared for completing two in our system um are completing robust expectations that we would

095go through so we're going to look and see if that's additional information that you would like to collect um and that we' be able to evaluate to see in the future if that we could add those components moving forward so we don't have this data presently but we would be again looking this year to see if there's any additional components we could collect um moving forward as far as assessments um for those of you who are not familiar with how the CCI came in um to uh the accountability system when ESO was um first adopted we thought that we could be really clever and um use the college career indicator as the vehicle for our student assessments for high school for grade 11 assessments so that is why um the uh high achievement on grade

09611 assessments is in the CCI however the federal government came back to us and said H not too fast you also have to put them in the academic indicator so presently on the dashboard grade 11 student test results on the Casp um and CA are counted twice and so um they're counted into two different indicators um and so we're going to look forward and we have not you know we went in we did this we haven't evaluated really what that looks like for how that's making an impact on um the CCI in general so we're going to be reviewing that um as well as um reviewing the inclusion of AP and IB scores within the um the assessment as well and then finally um state and federal jobs program for for rocp um this was

097adopted in 2020 most recently as a part of a career measures for our dashboard alternative status schools um in 2021 that D status went away um however um as we've moved forward um we've discovered that this data point is redundant within our collection um it was a location essentially collection information but it was not um specific uh did not provide additional data to us because we already collect this information both in the CTE course completion that is that's already data that's coming through to us as well as in our workbase learning um collection so this specific um denotation is not one that we can do um moving forward in our data set however we are already capturing those students in a different way so we just like to remove this denotation within um the categories

098and we'll be making sure with a field that this does not cause any unintended consequences over the next few months and then finally seal of Civic engagement um we created an ad hoc data collection last year to be able to collect the student level information for all of those seals so we've been collecting in bulk the number of seals we've been awarding however we hadn't been attaching those to students so this year we'll be able to evaluate um how those students did across all the other metrics on the CCI right and seeing if um in comparing that and presenting that information um to the board for review to see how Civic engagement and the seal could impact or um improve uh out rates for the CCI and being prepared so we're very excited to be

099able to share that information with you in July as well okay next one review I know this is like it just keeps going review the participation rate for academic indicators in science this is principles 4 8 and 11 so the participation rules this is another one that we implemented a lot of Rules and Things we're thinking about them now and how can we improve things moving forward as we are always constantly subject to continuous Improvement um we incorporate a participation rate penalty um for any um schools districts or student groups that fail to meet the 95% that is because the federal um government requires us to report out on 95% of all students so we need to uh we need to impute a penalty in order to um go forward with that so we measured

100this quite precisely and just want to let everybody know our state really knocks it out of the park on participation rate like we do an amazing job I just want to put that out there um participation is not a problem with our test so um it's very nice to have that um however in um 2018 um the way that when we were rolling out our brand new computerized tests without onetoone devices it's schools I think any of you at school sites back then trying to get everyone right the computers and the rolling carts um of laptops going from classroom to classroom to classroom and testing windows that were like three months long because you only had so many computer carts right to go to the classrooms um we heard a lot of um a lot

101from the field and um what folks were setting up long testing windows and they were like our testing window begins in February but we don't start testing until April but we need to start right because just in case you know something happens and um you know we don't have the laptops that they didn't come from the next school over in time and so what we did in 2018 was we implemented what we call Grace Windows um and Grace periods at the start and end of these windows and it was addressed um it was meant to address these really long windows that were established at the beginning from essentially uh the 67 66% date um so in early February March for schools and then through the end of the school year so we established these Grace

102periods to allow folks to um be held harmless for students who are transferring in and out however things have changed we've updated our processes and now schools and districts are able to select a very precise window of time to test their students they also do so in a very quick manner because students have onetoone devices in many instances so they're able to be you know to test students quicker and these Grace periods we found don't so much apply to the same situations they did in 2018 so we're going to go back and look at the reliability and validity of these Grace periods um and see if there's any tweaks we can make to our business rules and be able to share those updates um in uh July with you um and we would not just

103to make it clear for everyone if we did make any updates to those rules they would not be applied backwards they' be applied forward so we would just want to make that the field was notified of what we were doing moving forward for future years all right the review of Das application and renewal criteria this is principles 4 8 and 11 so our dashboard alternative school status or Das program um uh is another unique feature of California and um Das is not only applicable to accountability but also is found an ed code um to uh you know and it we something we hold um very dear in that um we are allowed to identify schools that treat um that serve a different population and needs of students um and do so with um you know

104the strength of you know a thousand teachers for 10 teachers and um you know and small school populations who you know are really really deserving of these high attention and need um in California Education Code um 52052 G um it requires the state um superintendent of Public Instruction with the approval by the state board to develop this alternative accountability system for schools that serve a large percentage of higher risk students um this automatically includes schools like juvenile court schools and Community Day Schools they're automatically included as Das schools per their school type um and then um and these are automatically AOW of partic ipate in alternative school accountability um there are however alternative schools that are not included in Education Code um and those are schools that need to apply to do so so in3

105the State Board first adopted the definition of alternative schools eligible for inclusion um and that definition included alternative schools of choice and charter schools in which 70% of the school's total enrollment is composed of the following high-risk groups expelled suspended WS of the Court pregnant and or parenting youth recovered dropouts habitually Trent or habitually insubordinate and disorderly as well as retained more than once in kindergarten through grade8 so as you can see for the past 22 years goodness gracious um we've been able to um you know identify these schools as also survey needs um outside of just those identified identication code automatically in 2017 as we were onboarding our new accountability system um and looking to do something a little bit different with our Des schools um you came through and adopted additional criteria for

106das schools and those were um defining recover dropouts specifically as students who are designated as dropouts pursuant to the exit and withdrawal codes and or who left school and weren't enrolled in a school for 180 days so providing some context around that um students who are credit def um students with a gap in enrollment students with high level transiency Foster youth homeless Youth and emotionally disturbed students following this um meeting and later on the State Board removed emotionally disturbed students from that list at a separate action and meeting now the alternative schools application process was also adopted by the state board and required that alternative school applications need to in um include a process to verify over time that schools continue to serve a large percentage I example 70% of high-risk students um as what

107was defined in the eligibility criteria you also adopted a requirement that Das schools be required to recertify every 3 years for alternative school status so what we are going to do for our plan for this year is evaluate that application process and see how in our data Rich environment we can make the process better and easier for das schools moving forward to make sure that D um the those that apply for D status are serving the needs of highest risk students in the state all right differentiated assistance eligibility Based on calpath data submissions I will pass it back over to Cindy kazanis and she will take you through the rest of the presentation that was a lot I know this is the last I think this is the last section so if okay hold your

108thoughts okay almost we're almost there we're almost there uh so this is uh some tweaks that we will be bringing to you in um July around differentiated assistance um uh and specifically uh going back to that same bill that moved up the dashboard this bill also uh included a provision that um any District or county office could be eligible for differentiated assistance if they fail to submit calpads data so this is one that's really um near and dear to my heart and I know um Chief Deputy or um Deputy uh superintendent Mary nic's in that if we don't have quality data it makes it very difficult to do our jobs um for accountability and and data reporting um so just to um briefly go through this um the 2024 dashboard was the first year that

109we applied this criteria and the criteria was is a phased in process um so uh we have to tie back to the calpads um guidelines and then um we needed to work with our partners to create um how we would actually implement this these Provisions um in terms of uh you know why I didn't mention the word Charters is because Charters are are actually not included in this legislation but we want to make sure that um Charters know that they are absolutely um you know in our support system um they receive Services um from our level one uh supporters which is uh Kern County Office of Education through through CIS um so in in terms of though just uh trying to to make um sense of these criteria what you see in in this slide

110in the next couple of slides is um the formal ask for the board to adopt it'll be in July a phased in eligibility criteria so specifically for for this Academic Year we are looking at any Lea which is of course a county office or a district that fails to meet um a CP pad's Final certification deadline and we have three different deadlines one of them is coming up next week but we've already notified um schools and districts that may be affected by the fires that they have the opportunity to um extend that deadline um so just as you know um you know for our purposes um we need to get the data in in a timely manner if we don't get the data in in a timely manner um a district could be eligible for

111differentiated assistance um as we move forward to 2026 um we are again working with our partners from Kar which is the California school information services or CIS um to um give additional parameters again all with the intent of um making sure that once we put out the data we don't receive the Frantic calls that oh my data was wrong I gave you bad data um but also that we get um data in a timely manner so this is the summary of that piece is just this phased in piece um again 2024 has passed there was no districts or counties that were eligible based on the criteria we'll have you formally adopt this uh coming year and 2026 criteria moving forward um finally just for informational um purposes and I know this has been um of

112interest to a lot of members on the board is this review of Priority One and teacher assignment data um this is something that the board um has worked with for several dashboards now in getting our teacher assignment monitoring outcome results onto the dashboard under priority area one um in terms of our work plan for this year um we are actually just trying to get out a backlog of data around Staffing but also just want to keep this for awareness um on on your radar um that uh we want to make sure that this the field is able to use these reports in conjunction with their teacher assignment monitoring outcome data and so with that um president darling Hammond uh we spent a lot of time last year and we always want to uh take credit

113when we present to you that we don't work in isolation we U do a tremendous amount of Outreach and have um developed very strong relationships with the field um around not only accountability but data reporting and so this is a summary of all those that we touched um in the last uh six months so with that I will turn it back to you for the conversation do you want to show the recommendations the recommendation um uh is the same as when I presented it before but let me just reiterate it because I know that's important um that we um received guidance from you and that you approve the proposed 2025 accountability work plan and I can also shift this to the public comment slide for be great thank you um so we're going to open

114the phone line for public comment um and those who wish to comment on the item uh remotely can use the telephone number whoops it disappeared uh and the um access code shown there in the slide uh and we're going to um encourage people to State their name and affiliation for the record um we do want to um also before we take public comment have some comments um some clarifying questions if there are any uh and we'll try to keep clarifying to clarifying and then we'll have discussion after the public comment and then we'll hear from our um uh liaison so are there clarifying questions yes member escabedo I'm just curious for the College and Career indicator I understand you're looking at the Seal of Civic engagement are you also looking at the Seal of biliteracy

115as well or I wasn't sure if that's in cor it's already in okay yeah SE SE bacy was put in several years back so that that's already in and we have that as a model for how to potentially incorporate the sil of Civic engagements absolutely yes we've been collecting we've been fortunate to to collect data on state s of biliteracy for much longer than we have um this SE of Civic engagement and I have a clarifying question um there was a mention of evaluating uh apni IB scores in the um CCI indicator and uh I understand understand the duplication of the Casp scores right which is twice but we don't elsewhere include AP or IB um scores or dual credit I don't know if dual credit was also being re-evaluated but those are kind of

116in a class of characteristics together so I was just wondering what the thinking was about about that and if I understood that okay um sorry um just needed a friend to remind me what we were what we were working on towards the college career indicator um I think part of it is that um where there is um you know the ability to look at courses as opposed to the assessment the assessment um for AP and IB has been a way for a student to demonstrate um that they are college career ready uh and if we're you because we have such a this indicator has such an oversized influence in the assessment Arena shifting over to uh our uh our course taking and those that are enrolled in passing IB and AP courses um as an

117alternative we would provide an analysis of that so we could consider that we would definitely provide an analysis of that um as well as just you know uh I think provide you information about reaffirm the majority of our students are showing that they're college career prepared because of the assessments so if we want it to be um you know less um to to outstrip that that oversized influence and instead focus on courses and focus on things like state syab by literacy and um our C Civic engagement as as metrics um as well as this influence on the courses um looking at course taking IMM conversation later I just wanted to understand what we going to have and I don't I don't anticipate this being a one and this is going to take um yeah this

118there's a lot of policy questions that we can bring to the table great thank you I understand that any other clarifying questions remember oen you look like you were about to say something are you g to hold it for discussion okay very good uh so um just to hear from our uh first Le on uh vice president GL Woods thank you president darling Hammond and thank you uh Cindy and K him for such a robust presentation uh there's a lot definitely to consider um just just a couple of very brief comments before we go into our public comment time and our board discussion I want to Circle back to um the the um statements that were made related to the Essa plan and our consideration there um I I I I again president darling Hammond

119touched base on quite a bit of things that we should consider um when it comes to reopening the Essa plan and um I will say this um I know at the outset the goal was to keep a system the same state and federal and it's been a number of years now and we find as a state there's additional data that's very very important for our schools and our districts to look at as they make determinations about student performance I don't necessarily know that those items need to link into our federal accountability for school eligibility atsi CSI um and TSI so I uh I think we need to really consider what if there is a benefit to reopening the Sate plan to add in some of these additional areas that we will make decisions around for

120this year and I and I would venture to say I don't know that there is a benefit to it um I think our Sate plan is very strong and very robust it touch bases on U many many areas some of which were acquired by the federal government but many of which we've decided on how we want to represent that data and it's it's very strong and it does what it is designed to do at this point I don't know that again it's necessary for us to reopen and add additional things in at this point in time when we know that the Sate plan is going to need to be redone um once this one is concluded so just a a point of thought and consideration and uh the last piece I will say is that

121when we look at um again a very ambitious accountability work plan uh Kim and Cindy you and team will be uh Full Speed Ahead uh for quite quite a while um we have again some very important decision points to be made and it just helps to underg that idea of continuous Improvement as we look at our accountability plan and we look at the data that's necessary to give us a good picture and idea of what how students are doing um again I think we're hitting some very good points that we will receive some very good information around so that we can make decisions going in in into the 2020 25 year thank you I mean as the secondly and I just want to add my thanks to the accountability division which is just working not

122only at um full speed but with you know all kinds of complex U considerations and um one of the things that our uh prior board uh sort of established was the idea that we should uh be thoughtful and deliberate in adopting accountability measures we should see the data before we make decisions about how we're going to use the data that we should understand you know how it may affect the system and as this grows more complex for good reasons many things that we want to know and want to have part of our um data and school Improvement uh we'll need to continue that as well so I appreciate laying out um all of the uh points in time and we will think with our colleagues in CDE about when do we know enough about each

123of the indicators to know how it would perform what what way and what is the most optimal way for it to be used in a school Improvement system and so on so um just great appreciation both for their um the work to date and the opportunity to be able to see more aspects of our school functioning and the opportunity to work closely around how do we want to use those when do we have enough data to make a decision um about how to use it so just appreciate that very very much and we'll have opportunities during discussion to talk about the individual indicators that have been presented um but I I do want to get us to public comment sooner than later are there other any CL other clarifying questions that we want to be

124sure we've asked at this moment then we will go ahead and see what public comment there is we have six people signed up for public comment please line up uh behind the microphone in the following order Eric primac Jessica Sako Lindsay tornator Diana Vu Christina Salazar and Nicole glener we're not hearing you yet can you make sure your mic is on make sure your mouth is closed there we go hold on it's coming up all right uh good morning uh uh president darling and members Eric primac with the charter school Center um we're concerned about the some items that we see missing from the work plan primarily as many of you know Charter School renewal very high stakes process hinges heavily on the dashboard um currently charter schools are allowed to use so-called verified data

125in the absence uh recognizing some of the limitations of the dashboard but that authorization is expiring starting this June we need some significant upgrades for the dashboard if it's going to meet its statutory role in the chartering process and we would urge you to add that to the work plan second there have been some significant changes already to the Dos methodology that caught a number of my members by surprise um we would ask that you see to it that the original 2017 methodology be continued to use uh until such time as we've had a chance to fully vet any major changes and then finally uh we'd be concerned about adding science data to the 5x5 grids given that we can't get growth data off of a test that's only given into two discontin us grades

126we would support continuing using it as a information point on the dashboard thank you good morning uh state board members chair uh Deputy Chief Information officer now I believe very nicely um Jessica Sako on behalf of the California stem Network a project of children now I'm here uh representing the stem Network which is an organization that Works in partnership with 13 Affiliated Regional Network and ecosystems across the state to bring together Partners in tk12 education higher ed business industry Technology community- based organizations to identify scale and sustain effective stem teaching and learning it is uh our work that we strive to outreach and ensure that all students especially those who have been historically underserved and under represented in stem disciplines to have access access to the highest quality stem education therefore I urge the State

127Board to direct CDE to leave open the option to amend the state's Sate plan to incorporate science and to continue taking the plan steps outlined in the proposed 2025 work plan to fully incorporate science into the dashboard both state and federal accountability systems We Believe doing so would be supportive of a number of uh important steps that have already started to take place at the local level in response to science beyond the dashboard for informational purposes as well as supportive of the administration's master plan for Career Education and in support of the priorities that have been pre-identified in your future item on a profile for a graduate which really seeks to incorporate the skills is students gain with a high quality Science Education thank you good morning president darling Hammond vice president Glover Woods members

128of the board Lindsay toritori on behalf of the California county superintendents we support the CD's proposed work plan and deeply value our partnership with Cindy kazanas and her team we look forward to the learning and decisions ahead of us in the next six months and wouldd like to highlight a few key points from our letter first science we are actively engaged in discussion and hope to that the inclusion of science on the dashboard will lead to increased access to high quality science instruction in all classrooms thanks to Liberty van naton and our partners at CIS calpads da had a smooth start with ample communication to the field we look forward to providing input on the next phase how to define data quality issues regarding the Das criteria we strongly support any modifications needed to ensure

129the program only includes the Stu the school serving our highest risk students and finally just to concur with Dr Glover Woods's and Dr darling Hammond's comments about considerations about the state and federal accountability system the county superintendents would concur leaning toward um there are some uh natural splits to happen from lessons learned from our original intent thank you good morning Dr darling Hammond and board members Diana Vu on behalf of the the association of California school administrators axess supports the incorporation science into the dashboard and believes that this will Elevate the importance of robust Science Education science education however is not uniform across the state and assessment alone such as the California science test do not provide a complete picture of a student's acquired knowledge and standards of Science and while assessments are important they

130should not be the sole measure of a Student Success for these reasons axer respectfully recommends that the board consider making science a local indicator as a local indicator Science Education would receive greater public engagement because families Educators and students can provide because local indicators are required to be adopted at a local board meeting where students families and educators can provide input and advocate for high quality Science Education in their communities in addition this approach would preserve our accountability systems emphasis on multiple measures to gauge how leas are meeting the needs of their students rather than over relying on assessments thank you for your consideration good morning president darling hering and board members Christina with Californians together thank you for all the work put into the growth model we are asking for the competation of the

131growth model for English learner subgroup parallel definition of the English learner subgroup used for the um suspension indicator if a student is an English Learner in the current year they should stay an English learner for the growth model computation and the same should be for the uh reclassified English Learners tracking data for 3 years diminishes the instability of the Els and rfib groups and ensures continuity we're also saying that with this approach it helps meeting the federal 4-year monitoring reir me for rips and offering a consistent Statewide um system of support thank you so much are there comments on the phone uh yes we have five people five callers in the queue I will open the phone line now um caller with the last four digits 0493 you are now live please start your public

132comment you have one minute uh president darling Hammond and board members this is Shelley Spiegel Coleman with Californians together we would like to reinforce the recommendations in the lcff Coalition letter for guidance on how the State Board intends to use the growth data in 2025 and Beyond in addition I'd like to reinforce the recommendations presented just presented by Christina Salazar emphasizing the use of the definition of English luners as defined by the suspension indicator this would give more accurate picture of the growth or lack of growth for English Learners and reclassified flu and English proficient students and in turn inform the development of targeted goals actions and services for both student groups in the lcaps this is an opportunity for districts to clarify their successes and areas of Need for English Learners and arip please

133consider using the suspension indicator definition for els for the growth model thank you very much thank you you next caller with the ls for digits 1385 you are now live please start your public comment you have one minute good morning pres darling ham and members this is Sarah Lis executive director for teach plus California I also want to uh reinforce the recommendations in the lcff equity Coalition letter and the alliance for students letters in terms of the prioritization around the policy decisions we have to make around the growth model um we appreciate all the work that staff has done and recognize how ambitious the work plan is for this year but um our teachers and I apologize we were not able to get a letter in in time they uh still had questions around the

134fact that the workland does not include the next steps around including uh consistent measures from the school climate survey uh we we know that there was Direction last year and that staff had held some uh focus groups to better understand what would be involved in identifying a subset of school climate survey questions uh and we were unclear on sort of what the resolution and policy decisions were tied to that our teachers remain committed that elevating and prioritizing positive and affirming School climates as a measure of school performance will really help make sure that we're getting schools and leas the support they need to prioritize the wellbe well well-being School climate and school culture to support our student outcomes so we would love to understand where that shows up in how we're plan or what decisions

135have been made thank you thank you next caller with the last four digits 8256 you are now live please start your public comment you have one minute hello this is Robert maning representing children now uh given the educational impact of a fully qualified teacher we recommend that the state create performance standards for the teacher assignment indicator and report on the dashboard at both the district and school level because data is available at both levels uh in terms of the growth model we recommend adding growth to the 2025 dashboard setting performance standards for it using the growth indicator for differentiated assistance as well as s CSI identification purposes and amending the Sate plan we envision the state releasing the dashboard in November or eventually in October uh but re reporting on the growth data in December

136at the same time that that districts are identified for da and schools for CSI recognizing the additional time to calculate the growth model thank you thank you next caller with the last four digits 8674 you are now live please start your public comment you have 1 minute good morning president darling Hammond and state board members I'm Rachel Murphy public Advocate senior legislative Council for the lcff equity Coalition as stated in our letter we support the inclusion of the science indicator and a student growth model on the dashboard and in determining eligibility in the state and federal accountability systems when considering how to incorporate the student growth model the state should not allow timing issues to be a barrier to accountability for example the board should consider any changes that can be made to when the

137dashboard is released or when dashboard information like tards can be produced by vendors even if that must be done through legislation or by contract adjustments in addition the board should clarify that the college career indicator must measure both College and Career and not one or the other in today's economic and social environment postsecondary education and career preparation are both required to prepare students for success thank you for consideration thank you next caller with the last four digits 9563 you are now live please start your public comment you have one minute good morning president darling Hammond and members of state board John AEL from public advocates in the spirit of continuous Improvement we request that the priority One local teacher indicator be improved upon this year to conform with the legislator legislator's Direction uh we request

138that the board direct Improvement of the teacher indicator uh be added to this year's uh dashboard work plan the Education Code requires inclusion of school level data on local indicators where the state has the data California has Statewide T data on percent of fully prepared clear teachers at every school in the state we've been informed the state board has adopted a policy to not display School level data on local indicators if that's true we request the board reverse that policy as it is in conflict with the Education Code just as with State indicators every school level dashboard uh can report percent of clear teachers at that school compared to the district and state averages thank you caller your time is up we appreciate we appreciate appreciate your uh taking this under consideration thank you thank

139you uh that concludes public comment for item number three lots to discuss um let me just open up the floor for discussion and thank you Cindy for coming back to the uh Podium um maybe I will just ask a question uh to start there one of the questions that was raised was dashboard release dates I know that is an item that is near and to your heart and suggesting changing those but maybe you'd like to speak to where we are with dashboard release dates and why um absolutely so uh the dashboard um release dates are now governed under um statute um specifically as I mentioned Senate Bill 114 last year um required this gradual um incorporation of moving up the dates to October 15th um and the department has um uh interpreted that to mean

140not only the release of the dashboard with every single indicator but also the release of the um School the district eligibility um as required uh for differentiated assistance so um the callers that um suggested that the board had discretion to do this um I would I you have two legal council to here to my right they can provide the legal interpretation but I to my knowledge um it's not something that the board has discretion to do thank you there are a couple other factual items that maybe I'll just raise for you to respond to and then we can open up for a broader discussion um one of those was uh on uh where we are on the school climate survey conversation that started a year ago and um somebody asked like kind of where is

141that in process yes and I um I'm not prepared to respond to that question because it's actually outside of the work of my division um I recognize though with this accountability work plan we did not provide an opportunity for our colleagues in um uh our companion division that handles local priority areas to put information in there we'll strive to do that um in future um meetings and future work plans um but we will definitely touch base with with Josh strong and their team to see um where they're at and if it's you know if there's something that is we could um have somebody come and talk about that in March okay um then the other question was about the um reporting of the school level teacher data which uh um I know there's a way

142to get to it through some links but maybe you could speak to where that is sure and again I would lean on Josh strong for this conversation again because the local indicators are really under their oversight but the board's adoption of those indicators have been to display that at the Lea level and of course for Charter Schools um they are an Lea under under lcff U so the notion that we would start to display School level data um especially when we think about the um the enormity of some of our districts Los Angeles having um hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of schools um we do provide a direct link to data quest which has all this information um posted but we are happy to continue to look into this and have further conversations around um

143what is possible thank you um and there may be other comments about that let me just see if there's any other um okay I think we should just open up for disc discussion and um member patillo brownson you start I actually just wanted to follow up on the school level data um question around uh uh teacher uh qualifications and preparedness is it actually is it a technical issue that is being flagged as the barrier or is it and also I think there was some reference to a prior decision of this board around uh explicitly choosing Lea only but not School site level and if that's correct if you could um just walk us through some of that yeah so I think I would go back to um really the purpose of local indicators and the

144purpose of State indicators State indicators we can measure at um at a student level and local indicators are meant to be um looking at school and and rather um District performance and so um they are responded to at the local level as to how um locally they are implemen men in those priority areas uh so in terms of a policy of this board um it has been um through a narrative function it has uh the local indicators do not um appear at a school level because it's a district-wide implementation so again this is something that is um is very very different um and I think the the hybrid approach that you all adopted two years ago was to um determine performance categories which was to look at just clear so you're looking at Clear compared

145to the state for the district and that would that is a um a truncated version of what we see on the California um on data quest which is our reporting website which has a robust amount of information about all things um around this particular um report the teacher assignment monitoring outcomes report so the challenge if I just want to make sure I'm restating this properly is not a technical one that it would be somehow too onerous to actually provide that directly on one website rather than having a hyperlink to data quest to do the individual searches it's more about whether it makes sense in the sort of tradeoffs between State um and local indicators is that correct I think it's both I mean I I do I do think about Los Angeles and how would

146you display you know 600 plus schools on one web page um that is very honorous and it we we hear you know differences of opinion about how useful the dashboard is and when the dashboard is criticized for not being um user friendly this is one I would point to if you were to add something like this that um just doesn't doesn't um doesn't fit with what the dashboard has in it for yes remember Rosco Gonzalez um this is quite a bit of presentation I just want to acknowledge the thoughtful and detailed work that went into refining our accountability systems as a classroom teacher I'm especially excited about the inclusion of Science of the science indicator and the student level growth model in the 2025 accountability work plan these additions will provide a more well-rounded view

147of student progress allows Educators to better pinpoint areas of strength with additional support where additional support is needed and I know firsthand how critical it is to have growth met tricks that are accurate and reliable and I deeply appreciate the effort to ensure that these tools are meaningful for both the Alas and the classroom practitioners um moving forward I'd like to highlight some areas of focus for Equity I think of students um supporting our most vulnerable students such as the long-term English Learners and students with disabilities must remain a top priority as someone who sees the challenges these students face daily I believe their focused attention can can be a transformative make a transformative difference I think of resources including having the science indicator I think of bringing science into the accountability system means we

148need to invest in our teachers professional learning is going to be a key giving teachers the training and the support they need to feel confident and capable in teaching science effectively it's going to be really important so I think the dashboard's True Value lies in the ability to highlight strengths and weaknesses empowering districts to allocate resources where they are needed most and it's going to need a lot of support and having that science indicator on the dashboard lastly I noticed that I wanted to highlight the efforts of gathering and analyzing data on the Seal of Civic engagement for uh for the 2023 24 year it's important to know who is earning the seal as it helps us understand how Equitable the access to Civic learning opportunities the upcoming analysis from the CDE along with the

149discussions that the May and July's SBE meetings will give us more valuable Insight that will help us guide our decisions moving forward on this and I'm excited to learn more about that since I know several school districts in my area who um are learning how to have our students achieve that seal of Civic engagement so just thank you so much for this extensive it was quite a bit I Mega uh presentation I appreciate it other comments questions member escabedo I'm just really curious our callers on how we are going to be looking at growth model for English Learners is it going to be the same as the way we look at the suspension rats or just just curious yeah so um I I think there's still some confusion from the people that called in about

150how English Learners um appear on the dashboard for the different indicators because we're looking at different um different metrics so for academic indicator the growth model data which will be released later this month uh we will um have our English Learners um use the same metric that we're using for our English language arts and Mathematics indicators so our English Learners we add in the rips um so that we can show the progress of that student group that is what is in our um every student succeeds act state plan uh for the economic indicators great thank you any of the things that I'm just want to plot the number of CSI uh uh schools exiting the Criterion and I know the dashboard has is a great launching point but you know great uh I think uh

151many schools that leave or exit um from being low performing they're looking at local measures right they they they've instituted some assessments locally and you know and I know we have a local measurement in our dashboard and I would love for that local measure to be more robust at at a state level where um we can almost utilize as a launching point to help other of the schools have that have not exited to maybe use some similar approaches you see it's creating a learning environment for schools within the state um you know I I I see our dashboard again as a great place to reflect however to have that incremental Improvement that happens when teachers get together and they're looking at their own local assessments and and and shift instruction to to see student growth

152so um again I know this is a work in uh in progress but I definitely us to not forget that local indicator as a way to dramatically improve um you know our our student achievement you know State one thank you thank you well and I think you're raising the question of how do we learn and how do we then spread the learning and I think um that is not the accountability division helps us have the data from which to learn and then there's a whole set of issues issues around how do we use that in the department and CCE and our system of support Etc so I think those are important questions that we should take up um in addition to the work of the accountability uh work plan itself yeah um I have a

153set of um questions which are really uh in the weeds of some of the complexities and some of them are comments and so I'll um add those at this juncture oh member Olin you go first before I go into the weeds we let we'll let we'll let you have the last set of really wise questions I'm gonna I'm gonna um stick at the not so wise questions um thank you first of all um this was uh in anticipation I was thinking how are we going to possibly be able to take all this in um but I really appreciate the thoughtful presentation and um The Clarity of thinking that helps make it easier to understand um and my questions are at least two of them are clarifying um so one just to make sure I understand

154and maybe somebody else have the same question I don't know um if we the questions around reopening the the Essa work the Essa state plan state plan thank you um the the general idea is there are things that we are are now um looking at in our dashboard and are we is it a are we going to you're asking us are we going to ask you to try and put that into the federal plan also right okay just want to make sure so we'll do it here in the state either way we're gonna yeah so it's really only a question I just want to make sure I'm understanding what is before us okay so it's really it's really either way these are things that we are looking at and measuring and have accountability measures for

155in California it's just are we going to continue to tie what we do here so entirely to what we get approved by the federal government corre that would that would be um impacted by that then would be used to um influence how we look at school eligibility for those metrics right okay PSI yep okay okay just wanted to make sure I understood that piece properly okay that's number one um yeah um okay number two see if I can make my question clear um the data around um the work around the Civic of the Seal of Civic engagement is to the goal is for us to be able to understand the impact of students getting that seal on their overall College and Career Readiness is that because is that is that what you're that you want

156to bring that to us to look at yeah I think there's been um a direction from this board and and our working with our professional development division um they've only been able to collect that at an Aggregate and so for the first time we now have student level data and I think to the point that member Orosco Gonzalez brought us was that like has this um opportunity been given at all school districts and we we know that it's not necessarily been adopted at all school districts I will say that out loud um and the DAT the data may show that the data may also show that these students um are already um you know scoring at the the top of the smarter balance assessment and so this is um yet another um you know like

157are we are we getting at the right students um but and um just just what's the impact of the program right and I think to um president darling Hammond's point about like more data informed decision- making we've not been able to do that with this particular item until this this year and so for the first time um we now have access to that data we will be analyzing that we can give you um all of you know the details around that how many schools are there any D schools that have students that are receiving the Seal of Civic engagement um and also their program subgroups so we want to make sure that um you know when when when you do adopt something that is um hopefully that is available to everyone um maybe even including

158our student board member which I'm sure she is already achieved that long ago I should hope so um thank you that's exciting yeah I'm really excited to um about being able to look at that and think about um you know as we're as we're trying to understand what really makes a difference for our students and um and how equitably um Rich programming is being um accessed by students across the state I think that's gonna be really exciting so thank you okay my third question um is related to the public comment by Eric prac about charter schools and um renewal and verified data um and it's so it's a couple of things one is um I certainly as a as somebody who who has been um in preparing for Charter renewal um in the post 155

159World understand the question and concern that was raised um and so my question is sort of from your vantage point is this work plan where we should be trying to address I mean Bas I I want I guess I'm asking for your um your thoughts on the public comment that was offered if that's a fair question to ask you um I can try and clarify my question if you would prefer maybe I could just take a step back the verified data piece has always been um addressed outside of the accountability item because it is part of the charter school renewal process which is separate and apart from the the role um you would you would see me up here you have seen me up here with the adoption of that verified data piece but I

160understand that there are you know there's been some there are some statutes that will be um uh potentially um sunsetting and so I think the the The Angst I'm hearing is around then what what is going to be used instead of verifi data and uh I don't feel prepared to respond to that right now but I can we can definitely bring that back as we bring items like we will in March around the growth model and what does this mean as far as impact to Charter schooling noals yeah I mean I I think my sense is if if if that's something you can bring back in March as a just um just in the way you just said that would be fantastic um in that I think we all in my first response in hearing

161um the public comment and re and reading it is I'm not like I think we have to do a lot of thinking in lots of places about what this sunsetting of the legislation would mean and maybe it has to do with this and maybe it doesn't um but but I think it's important for all anybody who might be able to help think this through to be um at least investigating what the impact is yoshiman otari and then vice president GL Woods thank you thank you board president uh first again I just wanted to thank you for the presentation it is um very robust um but also to thank uh all the people who are out there working in the field so hard the in the places where we do see growth on the summary of

162the dashboard we only it's reflective of the hard work of people who are working out in our leas and our schools and our County offices and all the people who support us um I just wanted to make a comment um particularly around the inclusion of elts as a student group I know we had previously made that decision uh and I heard you say at some point in the presentation that our ltels emerged as a group uh that needed the most support and just to use that as an opportunity to Mark the importance of um being able to highlight student group level data in our dashboard I think is important as we move forward uh because that does Drive uh allocation of resources and how we support uh the field and and our students in those

163groups um secondly I just I know you're asking for our feedback so in terms of the College and Career indicator um I would would highly encourage uh what you have in the slides in terms of evaluating additional components for course data uh and continuing U many of my colleagues have mentioned the state seal of Civic engagement uh recently at the California school boards Association the youth school board members in Julia's uh seat across the state showed a lot of interest in that particular indicator that call the Seal of Civic engagement so that was exciting to see so thank you for your continued work there um uh the the um other place I just this is probably a clarification question but the there were a couple of letters and a couple of callers that referred to

164the Dos program uh as designed and as I wanted to clarify in the presentation are we talking about a change here in this year's work plan for for dos in terms of the inclus the threeyear cycle and making sure that we have we're talking about refinements yes absolutely can you just re that for me please um we are looking at um I think back to um member olin's questions around um Charter School renewal we are seeing uh increased interest in the D program and we want to make sure that the D program which was set up for accountability purposes is uh includes the schools in which you originally intended it to include back in 2017 and so part of that is looking at the ability to um verify the data data points within the metrics

165that you've adopted um but we will we will definitely as we start to unravel this um make sure that you know every step of the way that we're um providing updates and a decision point in uh July around this so the Integrity of the program um for us is and I think the board especially because it was a different board back then back in 2017 this is um very important that um there's a high standard of who is considered high-risk um and want to make sure that that commit remains thank you I would support I would support that as well and U finally um I just wanted to reiterate that the Outreach activities that you do are so critical I think we've seen this in other items recently but uh those that call in those

166that write letters um who are also helping to reach others who aren't calling in and writing letters uh I think is so important so thank you all right uh and then vice president Glover woods and I'm going to go into some weeds after this well I'll be very brief so we can get into those weeds most definitely I I just wanted to reiterate my support for um again the deeper dive that I know we're going to go into for each of these indicators I we've kind of got the plan laid out and as we go into our future board meetings we know we're going to really start to get very deep into what does this mean how does it look and I appreciate um Cindy and her division for the work that's going to be

167be done in kind of modeling and bringing us the data that we need so that those decision points can be made um definitely interested in the CCI and the course taking data compared to assessment data for AP and IB courses I think there's been a lot of information and research out there of the benefits students get from taking the courses and passing the courses um H related to and sometimes not related to how they may actually take the assessment or if they take the assessment at all and also the impact of the dashboard data and what it means for our those our charter schools and how that plays out so again just reiterating um interest in hearing some of that as we go into our future board meetings I'll conclude by asking a question and

168uh my question is as it relates to an indicator I don't believe at this time we have an indicator that has performance levels that doesn't in a sense trigger eligibility is there anything Cindy that um you know of that would prohibit that I'm not saying we should or should not um because I know we'll have these conversations but is there anything that would prohibit an indicator having performance level levels colors all of that but not serving as a trigger for State accountability yeah I mean we don't have a precedent for this but again I think to president darling Hammond's um comments in the beginning this cohesive system you've reached a point where um perhaps we are at at that at this juncture so um there is nothing to my knowledge that would prohibit you from

169doing this you have a lot of um discretion um although there are areas you don't have discretion that we've already talked about where we are legislative required to put things on the dashboard but this is one um where you could have a baseball card with performance information and not have that used for eligibility determinations um this goes back as well to the Essa piece is how much do you want to um uh have them um replicate each other okay and I just want to reiterate my my statement around I think the Essa plan needs to stay as is and that our conversations around these additional pieces of data need to focus on our state accountability and state data that we provide for uh our schools and districts to make instructional decisions but I don't think

170we need to reopen or amend the Sate plan I feel it should stay as is I want to be clear on that right thank you decisive a decisive statement here we've got a lot of questions but we've got a little bit of a little bit of uh and so just this goes back to M olin's question and I think we're getting some clarification that we have multiple choices one is whether you know we reopen the uh Federal accountability whether we um deal with the indicators in state accountability and then whether they become local indicators uh State dashboard indicators and then whether those are associated with particular consequences and we have a thirst and an appetite for data that is really healthy and then we want to be sure because people are using these data to

171really understand what's going on and then we need to be sure that we're thoughtful about how the data are used um in um various ways so I would just kind of raise a couple of um thoughts about about how we might make those decisions one is um I really appreciated the principle that the prior board put in place that we should always see the data and the implications of the data before we decide on the use of the data so I think we will have you know a lot of these are in motion I'm thrilled that they're in motion you know I'm excited about the growth model and about science and all of the uh changes that we're talking about but I do think we want to be thoughtful about seeing what the uh what

172it looks like when you apply the uh cut scores or when you look at the data that's coming through as we think about okay when would it be ready to be used in a particular way and then how should we use it I say that in part because differentiated assistance in California has really changed in the last few years the idea of uh of d originally was that there would be you know some places where um the county offices would lean in with districts around particular things that they needed to improve over the pandemic we ended up with 600 of our 10,000 districts in differentiated assistance which makes a a level of you you can't ask that intensive support of technical assistance be provided for almost every school district some districts were in that category

173because of Co absences in chronic absenteeism that were not something you could improve upon without getting rid of covid you know it was not a district activity um uh we want to think about what are the ways that we can frame differentiated assistance uh as a um an expectation such that it is able to be effective so it's able to be you know around the right indicators and intensive in the ways that actually help districts improve um one of the things that I'm interested in this time in that regard is elel I'm really glad we have long-term English Learners in this system now um I realized as we were thinking as we saw how many districts fell into the category of differentiate assistance because of the LEL category that there's one indicator that if it

174were uh to be a big uh part of the determination would be counterproductive and so I want to ask Cindy and the division if they do some more analysis policies of of lels and that is yeah elel is another group where uh if you come out of that group if you are a long-term English learner who comes out of that group because you're no longer an English learner and you've been reclassified it lowers the average score on Ela or math for the group so the more successful a district is in moving kids out of the LEL category the worst they could look on that particular indicator that's obviously not our goal that is not the way we want to proceed the better indicator will be the lp the English learner progress indicator uh how many

175kids are making a Year's worth of progress you know or a level of proficiency progress each year so anyway I'm I want to ask um the accountability division to do some analyses of that for us and then so that we could be careful about you there may be multiple indicators that would put an ltel category would would signal that ltels are a category for differentiated assistance which might include suspension rates and failure to progress on the lp and a number of other things we want to be very careful that we're also not um disincentivizing reclassification you know of of you know we we could end up with these uh odd things that have come out of the No Child Left Behind framework from many years ago so I do want us to be thoughtful and

176careful as we move along this path PA that everything we're doing is supporting the right incentives for schools and the right support and technical assistance when that's needed um and that we're not putting people in a category that doesn't actually fit with what the purpose would have been um so just to flag that you know Cindy will be asking you for lots of data and we know that you love data and we love data and we will want to see we'll want to see how that all is playing out so that we're being careful um I mentioned that I was really excited about the growth model obviously there's some really big policy decisions that we'll have to make around that that will also require a lot of data so right now for example we use

177progress from one year to the next for schools for the different cohorts who are being um measured this would be a single cohort do we use a growth metric and a progress metric do we use them both do we use one or the other what are the implications of the of how the growth metric looks when we start to you know look at standards and and start to evaluate that the data are available now um we could probably use some uh tutelage about what the data show uh that are being available now we're excited that they're there uh so anyway just to point out that these are some of the kinds of things that we're going to want to work with our uh colleagues in figuring out out as we make these decisions about what

178goes uh on the dashboard How does it go on the dashboard you know is it there for information is it there for accountability what if it conflicts with another thing that's on the dashboard like progress and growth might do um just to to reinforce the question about verified data the growth model will only uh will have two limitations uh maybe more but at least two uh one is that it will only be for fourth through e8th grade right um because that's where we have kids you know year after year so it won't tell us anything about progress of kids below fourth grade and kids above eighth grade and so that's a a question right not only for Charters but for all schools all schools want to know how kids are doing and what kind of

179growth we're having so that's just a bigger partly philosophical and partly empirical and practical question for us um the other thing is that the growth the the the state tests are constrained by federal requirements that they measure grade level standards but uh that means that kids who are performing below grade level have few of any items to show their growth and kids who are performing above grade level have few of any items to show their growth and so it you actually get very different results and I've seen this in different states that have sometimes had two tests going at once one though that's federally mandated that says grade level standards only the other that measures along the whole continuing of achievement and you see very different uh trajectories and ratings uh particularly for you know

180certain kids certain teachers of certain kids certain schools that Ser different kids so anyway my point is that these are all things that are lurking under the surface we are doing the very best we can to use metrics that tell us more but what the school contributes to Student Learning uh and there are limit ations on what we can do and we'll have to think about those and um I'm a uh an advocate for more data rather than less data and having the ability to see across the Continuum and so so which is not something we can do in our pesp tests uh because of the federal requirements but there are other assessments that are part of verified data uh for um Charter Schools but are also used by other schools and so that's something

181that over time we'll we'll want to conjure with um it's in the work plan I'm not trying to put it in the work plan Cindy I'm not trying to add to the work plan um because it's a huge work plan and we really really appreciate all the work that you're going to do uh there will be questions about the science indicator and we heard some of them because it does not uh go year by year it's you know was it fourth and 8th and 10th 11th or fifth yeah 5ifth 8th and 10 11 um so you can't like kind of measure growth on it it will be a status uh report um and you won't really be able to yeah so anyway that that that is one of the things that was raised the other

182thing that was raised uh was um how it will be it has a different metric so you does that have implications for how we want it to appear or be used I think those are things we'll we'll have to also consider uh just to be aware of those things so all of that is to say uh that we do want to um see data along the way we're going to be asking you lots of questions we're going to be um thrilled to get the information and then we can think about how these things will will play out um be great to have uh in March to have Josh and and team come to talk about the local indicators that we have questions about school climate and I understand the teacher data is also in that

183basket so we need to U continue these conversations so Cindy there was no question there but if you want to answer anything that I said or respond to anything I said I'd be happy to hear it absolutely uh I think one thing is is that we've heard a lot of um conversations around what you're asking us to modify and and we are um we've been talking about maybe doing a memo to the board just to memorialize some of these conversations and adjust the work plan as needed we'll also give you we will be back in March we will be back in May and we'll be back in July so what how can we chunk this out what does it make sense um in addition to Kim I have a whole team under Ryan Lamb who

184do the actual data processing and we want to make sure that we've got the staff to support um all of these decision points um and your March board meeting is literally around the corner um it's the first week of of March and so some of these things may need to be adjusted but one other group that we'll bring back in March um in hopefully in person president darling Hammond is the ETS team that produced this growth model and celebrate what is on the dashboard at the end of this month um so uh very much looking forward to that but yes we've been taking notes and we'll definitely connect with Josh to see if he's ready for March if he's not ready for March we'll definitely bring him um in in May um that's that's what

185happens perfect thank you we just want to applaud you for all the work that you've done and all the work that you will do thank you thank you will you be formally adopting the plan just want to make sure there's maybe an action because I think we want to for we want to formally adopt the recommendation and with the understanding that it is a work plan in action right in process uh do I have a motion member escabedo thank you member Osco Gonzalez take the role member Clawson yes president darling Hamm yes member es Cabo yes vice president clever Woods yes member Lewis yes member mcquillin uh I understand has a power outage in his location so he is not with us at the moment but we'll rejoin shortly uh member oen yes member Rosco

186Gonzalez yes member Patilla brownson yes member Rodriguez yes member yosha m t yes the motion carries running about a half an hour later than we thought we might uh we've got two items before lunch so I'm going to keep the break to about five minutes um when we come back should we ask the Senate we'll we'll we'll reverse the order of items five and four four and five so that item five will be next we have students here that we're excited to see and they're excited to see us and get out after that I'm sure okay so 10-minute break we'll bring the students in and then we'll uh do the personal finance item before lunch if we can get to it all right 10 minutes you okay everyone is back welcome back um we're GNA

187move on to item five then we'll come back for item four item five is the 2025 United States Senate youth program and the recognition of California's selected student delegates and alternates so this is very exciting it's an informational night item and the CDE will be presenting the 2025 delegates and alternates um and I'll let them do that uh set of introductions we're excited for them the item will be presented by Dina song of the CDE Dina please begin a little bit you know you could be a Lou a little louder there oh I think it needed to be turned on all right good morning president darling Hammond Chief Deputy superintendent Mary nicely and honorable board members I'm Dina Fong the United States Senate youth coordinator for California today is one of my favorite days and

188a great way to cook kick off the new year as we honor students from our annual US Senate youth program I'll provide a brief background of the program and then introduce each student who will say a few words the US Senate youth program is sponsored by the US Senate and funded and administered by the William Randol First Foundation now in its 63rd year the program is a unique educational experience especially geared for outstanding students who are interested in pursuing careers in public service High School juniors and seniors are nominated by their principal to apply for this highly competitive merit-based program to qualify students must currently be serving in an elected or appointed leadership position in student government or a Civic or educational organization representing a constituency and serving others for the entire school year our

189students have gone through a rigorous and competitive application process and were selected based upon their leadership qualities academic MC achievement school and Community involvement and commitment to Public Service the last phase of the program is to formally present our 20125 United States Senate youth delegates and alternates to the board these exceptional individuals are among the top students in their school serving their communities with passion and a desire to make a difference our two delegates will represent California during Washington Week in Washington DC from March 1st through 8th where they will get an in-depth view of federal government in action through meetings with Senators cabinet members the Department of State and other federal agencies the delegates will each receive a $10,000 college scholarship for undergraduate studies with encouragement to study coursework in political science or history

190now it's time to meet our students our first delegate is Sarah gal a senior at Canyon Crest Academy in San Diego San Diego County Sarah would you like to step for I'll continue um introducing her but she comes forward Sarah has been described as the type of leader that the world needs one who is driven by a desire to work across disciplines and a passion for service and not only does she create innovative ideas she motivates others to pursue these ideas Sarah was elected as president of the school site council at Canyon Crest Academy where she leads the group on setting school goals she also serves as Vice chair of the city of San Diego Youth commission where she prepares climate and environmental reports for the mayor and city council she is editorinchief of her

191school's award-winning magazine and leads workshops on layout design and writing she is the founder executive director of Costa Canyon which focuses on biodiversity Environmental education and water quality she is founder of the National History Day youth Leadership Council where she directed a segment on voter registration to promote Civic engagement and created a documentary and exhibit for a museum on the Lemon Grove incident the United States first successful School desegregation case as the president of the San Diego Science Fair student board she created the first science fair boot camp to closely Mentor students from under represented backgrounds and created tutorials on how to participate her novel research on drought remediation and water purification has been recognized by the Environmental Protection Agency NASA and the US Department of Education she has numerous Awards including National stem champion

192from the US Department of Education and EPA sustainable sustainability special award uh for her patent pending research and NASA Earth Systems award ranking in the top 1.5% of 20,000 projects Sarah plans to major in environmental engineering and public policy to forge a cleaner future for California and the nation she has a passion and curiosity for Science and how the world Works eventually she would like to run for public office congratulations Sarah I'll turn it over to you for a few words thank you good morning everyone I'm Sarah and I'm so honored to be recognized here today as a senate youth delegate and I'm so excited to represent the beautiful state of California to me public service is about creating meaningful change that benefits communities and uplifts people it's about recognizing the challenges we face whether

193social environmental or economic and stepping up with purpose and dedication to address them it's the commitment to solving problems that matter not just for today but for tomorrow and for our future my goal is to build Sustainable Solutions and infrastructure that address critical issues like climate change resource management and environmental justice in my career I hope to major in environmental engineering or computer science along with public policy or political science I'm still not 100% sure what I want to do yet um but something along the lines of those and I aim to combine technical expt expertise with policy Insight ensuring that Solutions are practical scalable scalable and inclusive in my career I hope to work towards a brighter more sustainable future for all thank [Applause] you thank you Sarah our second delegate is Bod Gower

194a senior at Yukaya High School in Yukaya in medino County his recommendation letter said there are shining lights that make us hopeful for the future bod go is one of these lights he is a fierce advocate for elevating the voices of rural youth which are too often under represented and overlooked bod serves as associate student president at Yukaya High School where he oversees school activities for 1800 students he desires to bridge the gap by striving for a more diverse leadership and ensuring that all student voices are represented he serves as student representative to the Yukaya Unified School District advisory committee and is a member of the superintendent advisory committee representing the student voice on the district strategic plan lcap and other initiatives due the LA to the lack of opportunities to engage in public policy

195in his community bod became the founder and chair of the northern California youth policy Coalition comprising of 30 Northern Cali California counties and 100 students to advocate for Rural Youth and the challenges facing rural communities such as Broadband across uh excuse me Broadband access mental health and school funding through his activities as a member of Senator leanza Butler's youth advisory Council and K12 director of policy gen up he continuously advocates for Rural communities VOD has been recognized as outstanding prosecution attorney during the 2024 California state Mock Trial Competition and received the best attorney award from the UCLA mock trial Institute he has also been recognized by the national first generation recognition program awarded to students who perform extraordinarily well on their AP or sat act tests and are the first in their family to attend

196college he plans to major in public policy and pre-law studies attend law school and pursue a career in public service since he was young bod has had a passion for helping others and empowering people to live their best lives congratulations B please few work thank you very much um I'm super excited to be here and just to have the opportunity to represent the state of California in the ment youth program and coming up here I was a little bit nervous that this was going to be too tall for me but it ended up being just fine you know just the opportunity to be here for me is like it's crazy and you know growing up in in Ru Menino County you know growing up learning all the presence when I was five for fun which

197I think a normal 5-year-old should be doing you know I don't that was just me I guess um being raised by a single mother may I say the best single mother a son could ask for yeah I knew guys would all too it is just the opportunity to be here and actually serve the state of California and be an advocate for Rural communities I could have never have asked for anything better than that and you know 10 years ago I would never say i' have the opportunity to be here I I never thought that I'd be able to achieve my dreams I never thought that I'd be standing here in front of you all and I never thought I'd be part of something that'd be bigger than this and actually have the opportunity to serve

198people I think that's what public service is all about public service is about making sure that we allow people to be better off than we started it's about making sure that people have the abilities to do what they want to do and I think it was St Francis ofce who said that um start by doing what is what's uh what's necessary to do what's possible and before you know it you're doing the impossible and I think that's what public service is all about is making sure that we're allowing people to do and do what they want and making sure that we providing them a little bit better often when they started and you know as Dena mentioned I've been an advocate for RO communities communities that have been overlooked in the public policy process communities

199that have been left behind in every single process that we've seen and we've seen that they've been neglected they've been overlooked and as an advocate for Rural students I will continue to do that and continue to do that in my future and and again thank you so much for for you know selecting me and I'm so excited to represent the state of California in this program so thank you very very [Applause] much thank you bod if Sarah or bod should be unable to participate in Washington week then one of our alternates will take their place our first alternate is James Miller a senior from Westlake Village High School in Westlake Village in Ventura County want to come up he has been described as not just an outstanding student academically but as an exemplary individual in

200terms of character his strong moral compass unwavering honesty trustworthiness and reliability are qualities that set him apart James serves as vice president of West County of the Ventura County young Democrats where he represents the organization at the Ventura County Democratic Central committee meetings and mobilizes voters participates in phone Banking and canvas for endorsed candidates he is the founder and president pres of the Ventura County Education Network which creates free educational programs for Oxnard students through one-on-one tutoring and pairing high school students with students in grades three through eight from underserved communities oops I need to move that he is the founder of the Westlake High School speech and debate club and the model United Nations Club attaining significant membership growth and expanded competitive participation and success as the national director of debate and chapter president

201of the Civic learning Civic leaders of America he facilitates debate workshops and develop curriculum an expert debater James was named 2023 champion of the national speech and debate Association tournament and World schools debate he is the regional director of the Central Coast for California high school Democrats where he organized speakers for a youth Civic engagement fair and texted 10,000 plus young voters to sign a petition against gun violence an AP scholar with distinction James received a $10,000 Grant from the social justice fund for Ventura County to expand the organization uh vcn and Advance educational equity in his community he has a strong desire to meet his community's needs and be a problem solver he would like to study Humanities and pre-law focusing on both the sociological and political forces that impact social mobility and equality

202inequality as an elected official he wants to make a genuine impact on people's lives congratulations Jan so [Applause] much so my name is James Miller and this is really an honor to be here as well um even as an alternate and um sorry about it this isn't a competition or anything but I have the best single mother but my mom is the best in the world but you know talking about public service everyone here is really engaged in that process and I think the Cornerstone of public service is thinking outside the scope with an individual understanding that we as people have autonomy in agency and that we can make a difference in other people's lives I think that if more people thought that they themselves as an individual could make a difference could solve problems

203that affect everyone everyone here today and everyone in the future in posterity I think everyone would be willing to do that and I think what I'm very passionate about is educational Equity as well as inequality now I live in a very poor neighborhood it's majority Latin X and I go to school actually 30 miles away from where I live um in a fluent Westlake Village and so every single day with the help of my mom I drive over two hours to go to a neighboring School District just to get better access to education um quite frankly it is horrible that the place that someone is born determines their education and so seeing this segregation right in front of my eyes I felt compelled um to try to act in some way and so I created

204the Ventura County Education Network where we've been able to have more than 200 high school students tutor these very students and have free services whether it's speech and debate in Oxnard we've worked with the oxg Guard School District to provide these Services I've been able to get a grant with the social justice fund and so we even started typing classes and research where especially students where I live in Oxnard we don't have access to technology in schools and so we're making the foundation um and going to through political means as well talking to the Schoolboard officials in vent County to try to change the system because education I mean as we know here we are at the board of education is one of the biggest foundations for social Mobility it's one of the biggest foundations

205for you know growing growing in the future having a stable life having a house in the future um but education isn't accessible for everyone and so I'm really proud to have been able to create a movement to try to break down those barriers of segregation and County and like I said before I think these are things that we all agree on segregation isn't good lack of access isn't good and because we've been able to link up these high school students with these other underprivileged students they've been able to become leaders in their own community and I think if we truly want to create a change to create communal action that requires a movement of multiple people people can't move people can't create change alone and I'm very excited for the future um I want to

206study in political science as well as soci ology to see the sociological forces that impact how Society is formed why do we see segregation today and by using that information um to better inform the policies I would like to become a policy maker in the future um and again I'm very honored to be here today thank you so much thank you so much James our second alternate is shria shrini vason a junior at Early College High School Angelo Rodriguez high in Fairfield Solano County and sha you can come up her recommendation letter describes her as someone who has a passion that ignites all she encounters action-oriented and projectm minded spearheading enormous efforts for student health public speaking and communication are second nature to her as a successful member of an award-winning debate team shria is

207the youngest student trustee to the Solano Community College representing 10,000 students and providing Insight at bi-weekly college board meetings and has been twice selected in consecutive terms to this position she is the founder president of salano count community college's reproductive Health Club securing a $25,000 Grant and providing free Sexual Health Resources to students she launched the no year period campaign and introduced assembly Bill 2229 to include menstrual education and sex education which was signed into law last fall she is a founder of Bloom for you which focuses on youth health and wellness through education advocacy and Outreach she is currently publishing a cookbook aimed at youth recovering from disordered eating and fostering healthy relationships with food she is a member of the salano County Commission on women and girls Solano County young Democrats and Girl

208Scouts of Northern California as the leite Scout she is currently working on her Gold Award reflecting her dedication to community service and leadership development her involvement in the SEC vars City speech and debate Club led her to Awards including State gold medalist in the individual public debate Association debate category and a bronze medal in impromptu speaking as the youngest competitor in the entire Community College pool she also received a White House youth policy Grant to develop a project aimed at engaging young people with government agencies regarding her future shria aspires to run for public office her goals Center on public policy and advocacy reproductive Health Youth Empowerment and legislative representation congratulations sria it's than you right well good morning everyone first off thank you so much for having me here today even though I just

209live an hour away this is my first time at the C California Department of Education and I'm so excited to meet with all of you my name is Sharia sh Boston I'm a dual enr Junior at the Early College High School program at Salon Community College basically what that means is that I get to take Community College classes in a m at Community College every single day which means I'm exposed to so many different atmospheres and environments and I'm so grateful for that opportunity and so over the course of my advocacy Journey my goals are to continue pursuing a career in public policy particularly with reproductive health and Youth Empowerment and legislative advoc eacy my work as the youngest student trustee at solia college and as a founder of reproductive Health Club has shown me

210how policy can be used to create a real change as the youngest student trustee it can be really daunting and scary to be on a dis like this every single day and going to board meetings but over the past two years I've known that because I have an advisory vote my voice is my only vote so I'm going to continue using it every single day for example through a229 the know your period bill I learned how to create a simple idea on how to turn a law that improves access to mental education to students I lost my period for 3 years and have absolutely no idea why and I wanted young women like me to have access to education because I didn't have access to education and so with this bill not only did it

211mean so much to me but it'll mean so much for the rest of California students and so public service to me means turning Vision into action taking bold steps to address systemic issues advocating for those who are often overlooked ensuring that everyone has access to the resources and opport ities they deserve it's about creating lasting solutions that Empower communities to thrive it's a commitment I carry with me every single day as I continue to work towards a future where youth voices are Central to the discussions that impact us all and so I leave you with this motto that I have as a sticky note on my mirror every single day that I wake up to be bold take action and demand change thank you [Applause] okay aren't they impressive what I've shared is just a

212small sampling of their many accomplishments we would be here all day if I shared everything they're involved in once again I'd like to offer my congratulations to our four students it's amazing to hear about their various passions and all they have to um offer all they've done for their communities and what they will continue to do they are truly shining examples of leadership and give us hope for a brighter future through their dedication dedication to public service so I will turn this back to president darling Hammond and to Chief Deputy Mary nley and the other board members for remarks and we'll have photos and certificates at the end thank you very much you and I'm gonna turn the microphone over to Chief Deputy Mary nicely for some remarks thank you Dena and on behalf of

213the state superintendent who I know you've all had an opportunity to speak to today and the entire department uh California Department of Education I want to congratulate our 2025 delegates Sarah bod shria and James um I think I say this every year you just make me look like a slacker I have no idea what I was doing in high school and I am just so really just honored to have you all here so thank you thank you so much um you've already contributed so much to your schools and your communities and I think think um I I think I speak for this entire department uh that the future is bright when I see you and I hear you and we are confident that you will go on to do everything you actually said you would

214do um because what you've already done in your very short time on this planet is beyond what many of us will ever accomplish so congratulations again and uh thank you for being with us today and for everything you do for your schools and communities and on behalf of students across the nation thank you and um we want to put the public comment slide up uh in case there are folks who want to come uh call in uh for public comment and use the phone number and the access code on that slide uh and um then we will turn to the board if there are any comments or discussion on the board um so let me ask is there any public comment in the room there's no public comment in the room right is there any

215somebody yes there is my apologies here you go let's make sure we get your hello hi I'm Nicole glener I'm the mesino county superintendent of schools I came because I am just so impressed with these students um I want to extend deep gratitude to all the adults that support the USU Senate program all the parents and teachers that have supported these youth who shine bright in their own right but shine even brighter due to the support of so many engaged and dedicated adults like the board of education for the State of California thank you so much and I also want to recognize that it is board appreciation month thank you all the board members for the work that you do [Applause] yeah and congratulations on board appreciation month and thank you very much for those

216comments are there any comments on the phone there are no callers in the queue so that concludes public comment for item number five okay and I would just like to say how much we appreciate all that you are doing we hope that you get old enough soon to run for public office uh it will um it will be helpful to our country and our state uh to have you in the public domain uh this is really exciting and I love all the various issues and disciplines and uh knowledge bases that you're bringing to this work as well as the passion are there any other questions or comments from board members yes I just want to congratulate the delegates and the alternates I believe that the four of you represent the best of California and our

217student body not because of your academics or accomplishment ments but to your commitment to your communities and your commitment to service you all four of you are also Legacy builders in your community and you will have a longlasting and um a lingering ripple effect that we cannot even measure so thank you so much um also we look forward to hearing about your time in DC and following um your career in public service or whatever else comes your way um to today the four of you are delegates and alternates but you are future Senators um so thank you so much for being here as a note if any of my fellow board members have not listened to Gower hour um which is bod's um radio show I think it's on KY YX um also on podcast

218please check that out um and thank you all four of you for the work you do and the Legacy that you will have thank you for being here today all right uh seeing no other um comment at this moment um it is time for lunch so I will adjourn us oh yeah we want to take pictures then we will have lunch and then I want to let people who know who are here for item four that that will come after lunch that will be the personal finance item but if the um students could come forward are we G to do it in front of the flag here okay why don't you come on up to feel fre to get closer you want watch e e e sir board members we are going to reconvene at

21912:30 all right we are reconvened uh and ready to take up item number four uh which is the 2026 personal finance curriculum guide approval of Developmental timeline and curriculum guide foundational principles and we the CDE recommends that we approve the development timeline and foundational principles for the 2026 personal finance curriculum guide and it will be presented by Mike taures hey Mike uh of the CDE nice to see you please begin thank you so much uh good afternoon board members good afternoon president Glover uh Glover Woods that's vice president Glover was President darling Hammond and Chief Deputy nicely um it's my pleasure to present this item on Personal Finance curriculum guide to you um when we prepared the presentation um Deputy superintendent cotton was going to join me up here and present on this item but

220another curriculum related matter um called her attention so you just get me today um the action item uh for you is to recom is that we recommend that the State Board of Education approve the foundational principles and the development timeline for the 2026 personal finance curriculum guide I'm here to take you through some history of the legislation associated with this item as well as our plan for how to meet the deadline that's been established in statute let me start off by um saying that research shows that students have access to high quality personal finance education have better Financial outcomes as adults resulting in less debt and a higher quality of life and that's the goal um that's the goal to personal finance and all of interest around um doing everything that we can to ensure

221that students are knowledgeable about personal finance um AB 2927 chapter 37 of the statutes of 2024 directs the instructional quality commission or iqc to develop and for the State Board of Education to then adopt no later than May 31st 2026 a curriculum guide and resources for school districts to create a separate Standalone one semester course personal finance a personal finance course is required to be offered in schools during the 2728 school year and is required for graduation commencing with pupils graduating in the 20331 year so I'm here today to present to you for consideration suggested foundational principles to guide the development of the curriculum guide as well as a suggested timeline for development of the curriculum guide so as mentioned previously AB 2927 requires that students must complete the Standalone one semester course in Personal

222Finance in order to graduate from high school and that such a course must be offered to students in grades 9 through 12 in the beginning of 2728 today I'll talk about the curriculum guide to be completed by May to support this requirement and to support school districts in the development of this course uh within statute there are 13 topics called out specifically for inclusion in the curriculum guide and those topics do include the fundamentals of banking for personal use the principles of budgeting for Independent Living employment and understanding factors that affect net income uses and effects of credit uses and costs of loans types and costs of insurance impacts of the tax system principles of investing and Building Wealth enhancing consumer protection skills by raising awareness of common scams and frauds and preventing identity theft

223identifying means to finance College understanding how psychology can impact one's Financial well-being charitable giving and my favorite other topics that are directly and specifically relevant to personal finance to complete this work the 2024 state budget allocated 300 $1,000 for the development of a curriculum guide for personal finance this accounts for expenses related to The Writer's contract professional editing and design and accessibility work that's required for online posting of this guidance and it's also inclusive of roll out activities and any kind of state indirect costs on December 12th of 24 superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurman held a public input webinar in which teachers parents and Guardians students and community members were asked to submit written input on content to include in the curriculum guide IE section 13 of Statute the webinar was attended by over

224200 members of the public and based on the proposed timeline the public input submitted would inform the development of the foundational principles to be approved by the instructional quality commission at its January um to be reviewed by the iqc at its January iqc meeting contracted writers would then begin to develop the curriculum guide in alignment with these foundational principles with the formation of a new instructional quality commission subject matter committee being formed in order to support the review of the draft from the writers and that brings us to the main topic of of the agenda item before you and that's um one of them is to review and approve the timeline uh for the development of the curriculum guide to explain the events of our proposed timeline I'd like to review just a few of

225the key points contracted writers would develop the curriculum guide in alignment with the foundational principles developed by the CDE in conjunction with public input and the iqc personal finance subject matter committee would review drafts of the curriculum guide at a meeting during the summer of 2025 the full instructional quality commission would then review the draft curriculum guide at its September 2025 meeting and the draft would be a available for public comment throughout the October 1st through October 31st through the month of October in 2025 in March of 2026 we then anticipate that the iqc will review and then ultimately recommend the draft curriculum Guide to the State Board of Education with the State Board of Education then reviewing and considering the guide for approval at its May of 2026 meeting this proposed timeline will fulfill

226the iqc and the State Board of Education statutory responsibility to have a personal finance curriculum guide in place by 2026 for this type of project we want to we usually give our our writers some guidance about what's needed um statutorily and what we've been told as needed by Educators and other interest holders um in the field the foundational principles were developed and this is the second um document that we're asking for approval these foundational principles were developed based on legislative requ requirements passed curricular projects and input from the public that the CDE collected from the field since our our December 12th webinar that public comment U did close on January 3rd in order for us to prepare uh the foundational principal document for you to review uh at this meeting the statutory requirements section of

227this document outlines what AB 2927 requires the curriculum guide to contain specifically has a list of the personal finance topics that I provided a very brief overview of just a slide ago and um those topics were established by AB 2546 um back in 2016 as content that was to be incorporated into the history social science framework at its next revision just a reminder that that framework was revised in 2016 and that piece of Statute became effective right after the 2016 framework was adopted the statutory requirement section also establishes that the curriculum gu must meet Federal accessibility requirements the foundational principles also lays out the general principles for writers to adhere to including ensuring that information in the guidance is accurate that it's aligned to the literacy standards for history social science included in the California

228Common Core State Standards for English language arts and literacy in history social science science and Technical subjects as well as the model School library standards for media literacy where appropriate other general principles include the promotion of the values of economic empowerment and financial responsibility that the language used in the curriculum guide is inclusive of not only School Personnel but also parents and Guardians and the larger community in general the audience section of the document requires the curriculum guide to be sensitive to teachers of different content area expertise and different grade levels and to include strategies that will allow access to personal finance content for all students that's inclusive of students with disabilities are multilingual learner population and students in a wide range of socioeconomic levels administrative and teacher support the curriculum guide will offer um

229easy to understand for teachers the various educational backgrounds and provide examples of different methods of instruction and pedagogical approaches it should highlight successful personal Finance programs in progress throughout the state because there are personal finance courses already in existence include strategies for engaging with students with parents and communities and provide examples of high quality no cost resources for instruction and professional development resources for teachers and administrators there's a world of things available out there for us to be able to include in this curriculum guide the curriculum guide should also include course outlines of personal finance classes currently being taught in California that can serve as models as schools implement the new course and graduation requirements and finally based on public input that was collected by the department the personal finance curriculum guide will also include

230the following other topics as stipulated in topic 13 of legislation that's that includes purchasing versus leasing a vehicle renting an apartment home buying digital Finance predatory learning learning predatory lending we want them to be learning California specific financial information for example the California Dream Act the Cal grant programs State specific salary information and then any additional topics that are then determined during development because we like that language from 13 we've included it into the uh foundational principles we're confident that this foundational principles document will serve as an effective guidance to assist um in the development of the personal finance curriculum guide so just to recap the department recommends that the state board of education do approve the development timeline and the foundational principles for the 2026 I know we just started 2025 but the 2026

231personal finance curriculum guide thanks for your time and I'm ready to answer any questions that you might have thank you very much um at this point uh we want to open the phone line as you have put the slide up so that if anybody wants to call in with comment they can use the phone number and the access codes shown on that slide and while we're waiting for public comment I'm going to ask our leaon member Olen and member Lewis if they have some comments thank you president Linda daring Hammond and thank you Dr Torres for the very clear uh presentation regarding this item issue uh I want to First say that I'm very pleased and excited to be liaison to the personal finance committee um and just a few comments you know with regards

232to this course you know uh we've had districts have had over the last what within the last five years a graduation requirements added to the districts and this is another graduation requirement but I think based on the information uh Dr Tor has given has given and something that James said this morning uh one of the delegates that education is the foundation for creating a better future and how Dr Torres has described that uh the belief in this course is that it will help students when they leave High School have a higher quality of life uh I think we can all agree that despite another graduation requirement this is a good one uh for students to have I mean when you think about our underserved uh populations of students you know uh when they getting the

233knowledge that's coming from this course could potentially change the trajectory of generations of of PE students or individuals in their families for generations to come uh I think back when uh you know I graduated high school and didn't have this information I really wish I had it when they started sending all those free credit cards when you graduate you go to college so this is going to be some really valuable information uh for our students um um it seems as though the the item has an accelerated timeline but considering when the implementation of this course is to take place I I think we can all agree that it it's a reasonable timeline as well as the guiding principles uh I know if I were still at the district office I would be thinking about uh

234some of the concerns that go along with implementing a new course but when you think about the resources that are already available on the CD website for financial literacy some of the grants that are going to be available for districts that jump in early I think this is a um a very good item and a very good course that's going to be beneficial for our for our students and their families that's why I let um Brenda go first because I can just say ditto to to all of that um I would just add that two two quick things one is um I'm really um thrilled to be a liazon for this um particular item on a personal level because this was definitely not part of my um High School experience and um I'm pretty excited

235to learn even late in life so that's number one um and then number two um as somebody who spent you know most of my career in a high school I do truly recognize the um multiple demands on high school um Educators and students um and so I did a little informal polling of high school Educators and students about if they thought this would be a worthwhile thing to be part of their um their education and their work and um without exception everybody said oh well that makes sense because I actually want to use that um and so um I I just am concurring that it feels like a really useful thing for us to be considering um and to remember the the sensitivity around how much how many ways um our high school um our

236high schools and high schoolers are already being pulled as we think about this so at this point I think we want to um see if there's any public comment we do need the comment slide up there members of the public wanting to call in can use the phone number and access code on this slide uh is there anybody in the room for public comment I think I see someone we have uh one person signed up for a public comment uh please come to the microphone Regina chagoya hi I'm Regina chagoya a teacher of Berkeley Unified School District and representing CFT a union of Educators and classified professionals the CFT appreciates the work the staff has prepared thus far regarding the implementation of ab 2927 which makes financial literacy a graduation requirement the CFT wants to

237uplift the attentions found in Ed code 49110 point5 a that provides workplace Readiness education for students and are to be included in the one semester personal finance Course once it's developed and implemented our practitioner members of our climate Justice and labor education policy committee have created a standards align unit based on the components found in the Ed code and CFT CES these topics of study to be non-negotiable one cannot invest and build wealth when one's wages are being stolen by their employer please contact Steve McDougall at C CFT for more information on the work that our members have already completed reg regarding workplace Readiness thank you thank you is there any further comment in the room or on the phone uh there is one call call ER in the queue I will open the phone

238line now um caller with the last four digits 1307 you are now live please start your public comment you have one minute uh president Hammond members of the board uh my name is Sid the president of Junior Achievement of San Diego and Imperial counties and I'm one of four Regional ja presidents together representing nearly every County across our state and we're excited for CD and the board to take up this process for more than 75 years in California we've been partnering with school districts and leas to deliver personal finance and Workforce Development to hundreds of thousands of students annually especially in historically marginalized and underresourced communities we've been doing that through curriculum and mentorship and tangible resources for teachers and students to help apply those classroom lessons and bring them to life given the timeline

239and as Dr Tor has just noted uh cbos like ja already working in this space with districts I'm hopeful ja in California can be a resource and thought partner throughout the process leveraging our years of Statewide impact and breath of experience and we're excited for all of you to take this up so thank you thank you uh that concludes public comment for item number four thank you very much is there any board discussion yes member CL I just wanted to thank the the team for all this work I know personal finance has been a long time coming um just a few months ago I was uh speaking with one of my predecessors Naomi Porter who was incredible L passionate about this as well um and so I know she's following and we're all very excited

240about this um I also love the foundational principles and it's very much um in agreement with what students have been saying for a very long time uh just last year at the student Advisory board on education the student delegates came and they gave a proposal on personal finance and so financial literacy is something that students across the state want and need and this class um will stand out because it supports Equitable outcomes and I think we'll have again just an immeasurable uh ripple effect for Californians for generations to come so thank you so much and love the principles terrific member mcquillin yes thank you can you hear me okay yeah thank you thank you for allowing me to participate this way today um I'm too excited about this potential curriculum here and I I think

241it's way way overdue I also did not receive anything like this when I was back in high school also and paid a price for it no pun intended U but also you know I think about our all those different ways to pay now digital wallets and uh cryptocurrency and all the things coming at us as well as students need to hear what the expected income is from various professions out there I think is so important so great great stuff and I hope it comes really soon if not sooner than what the timeline says so thank you all right member escabedo thank you for all you're doing and and looking forward to um you know your future updates and I just wonder with financial curric uh financial literacy in within your curriculum guide if there's any

242way the Elementary Middle School can support what you're doing and embedded in either social sciences you I know for example our credit union when I was a superintendent Mission you know Credit Unions helped out with this whole financial literacy ja was a partner uh for us when I was superintendent as well but just know that financial literacy really is an evolutionary of awareness that should start at elementary on up so just wanted to put a plug there all right I think we have member pattillo Bron and then member yashim otari uh definitely co-signing with board member esb's um uh raising of the issue of how um the requirement from the legislature is about the um graduation requirement but thinking about how to infuse this early and often I think is is very smart um and

243also I think contributes to the likelihood that it will stick um I also just wanted to uh underscore I I think there was a lot of uh feedback that you um gave an overview of that could fall under that category of um number 13 uh in the list and just wanting to underscore I think the uh payday lenders piece is something that has uh I think not gotten as much Sunshine as um would be helpful for the next generation and just uh wanting to lift that up and then I just have a very practical question which is um we're approving the timeline and uh there's a pretty significant chunk of time between October 31st 2025 with the online posting of the draft curriculum uh to the time that iqc recommends the draft guide can you

244just give a little bit more insight into what is happening there and also whether we would get uh any sort of uh early previews um at the board level to know what's coming rather than one bite at the Apple in May 2026 thank you for those questions uh member Pao Bronson um so the the gap between the public comment period and uh the March iqc meeting um was in question and so that period of time is utilized to um to consolidate that public comment down to analyze it to work with the writing team to see how best to uh to modify the draft uh in order to meet the needs of the public public comment that was received and then um throughout that that period there there there would be an expectation that um the

245the writers in the department and the State Board of Education would work um uh State Board of Education staff would work collectively um on on that draft right um member yoshimoto T yes as a mother of two 18 year olds I'm very excited about this piece a little too late for them but I and uh it's such a necessary skill I think that the uh clarification I was seeking I think uh member Pella Bronson touched on that it feels tight to me with to get public comment ending on October 30th because then we're going straight into the holidays and then to consolidate all of that so I just want to make sure there's enough time to uh Garner to your first point that Garner the feedback from Community Based organizations that have been doing this

246work we also have have um private sector folks that have been supporting this work and and also higher education that's been supporting some of this work the um and that there's time to also help kids understand what like the state programs are like Kell kids the new College uh children Savings Program is and some cities also have college savings programs that are sort of on you know leveled on top of that um so time to incorporate all of that so that locals can make sense sense of it all and figure out how it's going to be implemented um and then um I'll I'll leave it at that for right now so was that more of a maybe it's a question is do you feel like that's enough time between o October 31st and March yeah

247and and and to member of ptio Bronson's point it is a long period of time kind of a gap uh within the timeline between October 31st and and March um and that's intentional because we do anticipate um um a large amount of feedback that we want to very carefully um go through and make sure that we incorporate feels really short to me so you feel like it's enough time to do all the incorporation yes from October to March yes so long to some people and short to others but meanwhile the staff will be working very hard to get that done I I guess to the point then is I think that not only the public comment period but the Outreach is really important because people need to be ready for when that public comment comes

248forward and making sure that we reach all of those different stakeholders that I mentioned plus others vice president GL woods and then member Dr Torres just a quick question um as it relates to when the draft of the curriculum guide comes to the board and this kind of uh piggybacks off of member pattillo brownson's um question if the board has feedback to the draft curriculum guide that comes forward to us in May per this timeline is there sufficient time to incorporate that feedback or respond to the board feedback um is there enough time to do that for the field to have a curriculum guide they can then begin to work off of that's a great question and so that that really does depend on um the how how much feedback there is in in the

249devel in the that would change the curriculum guide um as with any other other curricular guidance that we've uh brought forth before the board um we've always taken in the feedback and incorporated as as quickly as possible um and then updated drafts that are posted for uh for school districts to use um do keep in mind that the course does need to be in place by the 2728 um school year and we're looking at completing the curriculum guide in in the spring of 26 so there's still some wiggle room there for us posting a final version of the curriculum guide um should should it should go beyond me okay U because I'm I'm kind of thinking along the line of the board having an opportunity to see a draft and then coming back for final

250approval again these are just thoughts that have come to mind I don't know um the timeline of the iqc meeting and the March SBE meeting if there's time at Mar in March at the March SBE meeting to look at the draft and provide feedback and if necessary have time to uh provide another vote in may just again kind of that concept of more than one bite at the Apple um there may not be necessary but just wanting to be sure there's enough wiggle room in there in case it is necessary so so the the question is could there be an opportunity to bring a draft at the curriculum guide before the State Board before it goes to the iqc in March I I think that's what I'm saying unless unless if the feedback in May

251provides enough time to incorporate that feedback if you will in enough time for the field to have it uh then perhaps it's not necessary to bring it in March and then again in May if necessary I do foresee an ample time in May to be able to incorporate feedback from the board okay thank you and I I think at the end of the day what I'm trying to get to is I want to be sure the board has opportunity to provide feedback and if there is anything that needs to be incorporated based on that feedback that there's time to do that before the final guide is posted yeah and I just want to recognize that the department is constrained by the statute around this timeline so we appreciate that they are planning it out in

252a way that they can get all of that done in a pretty efficacious way and member oen you are next in the queue if you're ready okay um I'm gonna well I have a couple of questions most of them are just to confirm my understanding um the first one is the timeline for this the development of this curriculum guide is um is really dictated by this this statutory requirements for when we need to act and also when the school the um schools need to implement the new Standalone course is that correct that is correct so so okay so I just want to make sure that's clear to us that this is um the the law itself the statute actually dictates the um 31st yeah May 31st as the yep so so it so that's the

253first thing is that's the timeline that's dictated by the statute okay that's number one number two um um M Lewis and I were just looking at the Timeline that um is in the presentation and it we just want to confirm our understanding it says in um March the iqc rec recommends the curriculum Guide to the State Board um so that is in essence the March meeting of the iqc approving something to recommend us that is correct okay um and then um third question I don't think you raised I don't think you mentioned this in the presentation but I think I read this um is it true that this is going to become a one semester requirement however at the local level for high schools however at the local level there is some flexibility for this

254to um be in lie of Economics that is correct so AB 2927 does allow for a student who takes the takes and passes the one semester Standalone personal finance course to do so in lie of the economics requirement okay but all students must take this course that is correct okay great I think that's all my things I want to make sure I understand oh one more um these are not just for me I'm hoping they're helpful to other people too um the term curriculum guide is a different term than like a framework or um and so can you can you explain for us how we're envisioning a curriculum guide providing sort of the level of support and um like how it differs and because maybe that will help aay some concerns about the speed of

255the process great question so the the curriculum guide as as as we envision it and um as as we talk to our um to experts out in the field with with respect to personal finances is our understanding there are quite a few resources available out there for example um the individuals who called in for public comment um and believe it or not um I and my team have already met with um a very large handful of individuals who have found out about 2927 and want to share about the resources that they offer that are freely available for example um we met with folks with uh FDIC who have a um a freely a ailable um resource and so the general thinking is there's all this um resources available out there but we need something that

256points to all of them and says hey here's what's available and here's what this covers here's what that covers um these are the the requirements in Ed code uh of what the course needs to cover and so um it would be more like a compendium of resources that are available with some uh narrative to interweave um those resources and that would be in addition to what we would offer in say a model curriculum that has like a sample course of studies and then guidance on um the logistics so the master scheduling Etc of how to put together a course and how to fit it um into um into the the school thank you and then I did just think of one more thing I think I also read that um in terms of credentialing for

257high schools because this is going to be um an just thinking master schedule for a second that there's actually quite a bit of there's there's several single subject credentials that um would satisfy the requirement for teaching of this course that is correct that's outlined in statute awesome thank you all right seeing no other comment do I have a motion member Olen so moved member uh BLS were you also ready to second [Laughter] not to put words in your mouth I think uh Brooks can you call the role member Clawson yes president darling Hammond member es Cabello yes vice president GL Woods yes member Lewis yes member mcquillin yes remember Olin yes remember Rosco Gonzalez yes remember pattillo brownson yes M Rodriguez yes Yos motion carries n okay terrific we're gonna move along at a rapid

258clip because we are running about an hour behind of where we had thought we might be at this point so we're going to move to the consent agenda uh regular items 6 through 12 uh I understand that members escabedo and yoshimo otari will be recusing themselves and we will now open the phone line for the queue for public comment on those consent items 6- 12 members of the public wishing to provide comment on consent items 6 through 12 may do so in person or by calling the telephone number and using the access code that is provided on the slide that is shown now are there any uh members of the public uh signed up to comment in person we have one person signed up for item 11 Christina Salazar hey see if she is here

259not seeing anyone at the moment she's not here so shall we go on to the phone commentary uh there are no callers in the queue so this concludes public comment for regular um consent items all right um so given there's no further public comment I'll ask for a motion on consent items 6 through 12 can I have a motion member Rodriguez a second member Rosco Gonzalez thank you and Brooks can you call the role yes and just to clarify just record it's a motion to approve yes thank you just I know we're moving expeditiously I just wanted to for confirm with the record thank you yeah I do um all right member Clawson yes president darling Hammond member escabedo vice president clever Woods yes member Lewis yes member mcquillin yes member oin yes member Rosco

260Gonzalez yes member patillo brownson yes Rodriguez yes motion carries right and let's get um our members back in the room we don't want to forget about them there we go here we go okay uh and so we're going to move on to item 13 item 13 is the followup to the July 2024 State Board of Education study session on the California way proposed development process on the State Board of education's portrait of a graduate uh SL portrait of a learner um no specific action is recommended at this time but we want your input the item will be presented by Jenny Scala from the American Institutes of research and the United States Department of it is the US Department of Education selected uh Center uh West Comprehensive Center selected by the department uh for the period

261of October 24th through September um 2029 the um air representatives are they here okay we're going to take a five minute break and find our speaker do we know where she is and apparently we have found our speaker so there we go that's all right we are ready for you thank you good afternoon everybody my name is Jenny scall I'm a managing director at the American institutes for research and one of the co- project directors for the West Comprehensive Center which is a federally funded technical assistant center and today I want to talk a little bit more about the portrait of a graduate and learner work that was already discussed um previously with you all so just to ground I know you guys have had a b busy day already I'm going to take a

262few minutes just to ground ourselves in um the West Comprehensive Center our purpose our priorities and then talk more and spend most of the time talking about the portrait of a graduate learner here within California and with you all at the State Board of Education I know in November there was a possible approach that was discussed with you all at your meeting I'm going to go into more detail to that today and then provide an overview of a timeline with you all so as a reminder the West Comprehensive Center is a federally funded Center and our priorities are really to create and support capacity building Endeavors with the State education agencies Regional Education agencies local education agencies and tribal education agencies and schools focused on all the things that are in the slides right there

263um we really Endeavor to do that in a partnership with you all and everyone that we're working and supporting and we really understand the value of student voice and local constituent voices in the work that we're doing in terms of collaborating with you all on the portrait of a graduate and learner we have um discussed with State Board of Education staff um some of the work that you've done already and we understand that the goal of this is to gather input for you all in terms of really understanding the multiple perspectives the diverse voices and spaces across the state of what the key elements of a portrait could be this is not moving towards doing anything related to a mandate this is really about understanding how the portrait could guide State Board of education's policies

264and practices and really better understanding what those key elements of the portrait of a learner and graduate are we know that there has been recent work that's been done that summarize about uh 50 or 54 um districts use of a portrait of a learner or graduate within the state we also know that you all have done extensive research and understanding how 18 other states have done this work as well we're not trying to reinvent the wheel we're trying to help you use that information to move forward to really better understand the purpose the key element ments and understand what you all might need answers towards as you're thinking about the policies and guidance around this so our main strategies that we're proposing with your support that we do are to hold at least four listening

265sessions across the state um these would be a combination of inperson and virtual these would be done in a way to make sure that we have um diverse voices from students from tribal Educators indigenous families educators and other community groups we know that there were many that spoke at November session around supporting this that we'd like to encourage and reach out to to help make sure that we have good voices and good representation across the state as we do these listening sessions these listening sessions will be focused on understanding the key elements of the portrait of a learner and graduate and we also know that we might have opportunities to not only learn from other state mod models but also within the state how different local educations agencies are already implementing and learn from those

266successes as you think about those key elements and priorities the proposed timeline is really built off of what we heard in discussion with State Board of Education staff so we're going to aim to um develop different feedback session protocols and Associated materials based on the State Board of Education Direction and announce dates and times for those education partner engagement sessions between now in February we're aiming to conduct those sessions in February to May we're providing and hoping that we do um two in-person and two virtual depending on our Partnerships and where we can get those hosted and the needs in the field particularly in response to what's going on in Southern California we want to make sure that we're able to get those voices in a time when they're able to contribute to it um

267rather than facing with the immediate crisis that they have with the fires May into the beginning of June we're aiming to synthesize the findings share that information back to the State Board of Education for feedback during the July meeting and then support the State Board of Education in terms of other supports um that might be needed with the plan of the adoption of the policies would be happening at the September meeting are there any questions are there um clarifying questions I think we're going to uh put a public comment slide let's put the public comment slide up first and then we'll come to the clarifying questions okay in just a second uh so that people can ceue up if they want to provide comment on this item calling the number or and using the access

268code that will soon be in front of them there it is uh and while we're waiting for that I'm going to ask vice president GL Woods to frame up any comments that she has and then I'll ask for clarifying questions and I'll come to you first member Lewis because you are ready to ask one but first vice president Glover Woods why don't you give your framing thank you thank you very much and board as you know this is uh part of the conversation I believe we started in July around um how to really ensure that we have something that can serve as a North star for the view for Learners in the state of California and again recognizing that leas or I should say districts and schools throughout our state uh many of them have

269engaged this work and engaged with their local Partners to develop portraits um at their local level and these our our state profile is not one that would supersede or even replace or even be mandated for others who don't have a portrait in place to develop one but it really is a a guide for us as we are talking about so many policy decisions um and I think this morning was a great example of all of the decisions we have before us as as it even relates to account ability so um I I appreciate our partners from AR that are going to really help us with a process to one get feedback from throughout this great state of California as large and as vast as it is and as diverse as the voices are to have

270opportunity to get that type of feedback I was excited to hear about the understanding how important it is to get student voice voice from the community from our tribal areas um we want to get as many voices voices from Community Partners in this as well and so these listening sessions as they were termed will help to do that in addition to the listening sessions um and again just conceptualizing some in person uh maybe one or two in person and then uh some virtual opportunities there may be other ways to get feedback as well such as surveys or such as other uh ways that we can get information outside of just a formal meeting but the goal of course as you all know is to get as much feedback as possible from this and um I

271I one other thing I'll just kind of put up before we get to our public comment and then I have another piece I'll say for afterwards is um as it relates to you see us kind of uh toggling between portrait of a graduate portrait of a learner we keep jumping back and forth over that rope there so I I believe during this process we'll be able to really look at what the term that would best represent what we are what uh this document or this portrait would represent would be is it of a graduate or or as a learner and um I think we're really looking long-term not just the graduate but really what is the portrait of a learner as they go through TK all the way through 12 so I'll I'll pause there

272I do have another comment that I'll bring um during our general board discussion thank you so much president darling Hammond of course member Lewis did you have a clarifying question yeah that's a that's a great question and so we're committing to doing at least two if we have time to do more we will try to do that we're looking to figure out um we know in some situations where we're getting Community feedback it's easy to add on to an existing meeting that might be happening where people are already with a trusted organization that they're at an event for and adding into that might be a way that we're able to access different voices that we wouldn't get in other situations particularly excuse me particularly in um tribal and Indigenous communities being invited into an existing

273meeting can really be helpful in terms of that partnership being a way of entering into the conversation rather than an outsider just setting up that conversation we found in other states that that partnership can be really supportive of getting those voices that often um aren't um as frequently there and making sure that they have a space where they feel already invited into that yes are there any other clarifying questions before we take public comment seeing none let's go ahead and see if there's any public comment in the room there are five people signed up um if you are in the room please line up at the microphone in the back as I call your name Lindsay Tator Diana Vu Christina salad Roman Sterns and Tom Adams good afternoon president darling Hammond vice president Glover woods

274and members of the board Lindsay tornator on behalf of the California county superintendent as the State Board prod proceeds with the next steps in this process we respectfully offer the following recommendations please continue to prioritize the collection of diverse educational partner input to ensure the final product honors California's diversity especially as it impacts future policy-making decisions consider developing three interconnected portraits because inclusion of a portrait of the adults and of the system sends a strong message that is the responsib of the adults not solely the students to create the conditions students need to succeed red defining Student Success the county superintendent urged the board to embrace this process as an opportunity to redefine Student Success in a manner that Fosters greater Equity across California currently our our system promotes a dcom that only college or

275career equals Success California serves students who do not fit this mold this shift would ensure all students are recognized supported and empowered to reach their potential post-graduation we look forward to engaging in the upcoming listening sessions thank you good afternoon Dr darling Hammond and board members Diana Vu on behalf of the association California school administrators although AXA believes that an Lea Le community-driven process is the ideal approach for de developing a local portrait of a graduate or learner we appreciate the board's commitment that any state level portrait adopted by the board would not result in any additional requirements for leas in addition it is also crucial that the state board's work does not set a precedent or create pressure for local portraits to line with the state adopted model as such clear and consistent communication

276from the state is vital to avoid any misinterpretation of a Statewide portrait of a graduate of what a Statewide portrait graduate means ensuring that local communities retain flexibility to develop portraits that reflect their distinct educational priorities and goals thank you good afternoon Christina Salas with Californians together excuse me don't count that towards a minute uh we fully support the ongoing effort to develop a state portrait of graduat or learner we appreciate the language saying that the portrait provides a comprehensive vision of what every student should know and be able to do at Key educational Milestones ensuring that they they are well prepared for their next steps this aligns with the four principles of the English learner road map and we recommend it be integrated to ensure inclusivity and Equity we also recommend adding multilingualism as

277a core aspiration under the communication category this would put uh California in a position of leader and reinforcing the importance of the state SE law literacy thank you so much good afternoon I'm Roman Sterns with scaling Student Success um I'd like to tell a personal story as a way to make a point the first time I stood in front of the board this board was in 1980 I was a high school senior one of 50 students selected across the state as part of the student advisor to the board of education for our team I presented a proposal that would have required all students to take like a life skills class which prioritized personal finance as well as nutrition and other topics I'm thrilled that to hear that finally nearly 50 years later all students will

278be required to complete a course in personal finance think about the millions of young people and their families who would have been who would have benefited over the decades if the State Board in 1980 would have listened to the wisdom of student students while much has changed since 1980 one thing has not as Educators and policy makers we must trust that young people know best what they need for their future so as the stateboard pursues its portrait I hope that you'll model best practice and fully engage marginalized youth this time let's heed their wisdom good afternoon members of the State Board Tom Adams of scaling Student Success former trustee for Davis Joint Unified former deputy superintendent here at CDE and I just want to First State my appreciation for you as board members and I

279can say that sincerely from my background um as the State Board considers its process for engaging stakeholders in developing its portrait we hope that you will model best practices by fully engaging all students especially marginalized youth when Port when portrait processes Center adult voices we typically get a long Common list of outcomes students who are academically prepared self-directed effective communicators and other things the these are important things and we should honor them however when we Center the voices of all young people we often get some critical additions like financial and digital lit litery Healthy Mind and Body sense of purpose sense of self and in my experience in Davis kindness and compassion thank you your time is up good place to end with kindness and compassion and you know the wheels of bureaucracy move slowly

28050 years but they do eventually The Arc of justice as uh Martin Luther King would say um so uh do we have any uh speakers in the phone uh we do have one caller in the queue I'll open the phone line now um caller with the last four digits 4691 you are now live please start your public comment you have one minute good afternoon president darling Hammond and members this is Carlos masado with the California Schoolboard Association I want to thank the board for the emphasis placed in Prior discussions and materials noting that a state level portrait will not result in any new requirements for leas and Dr uh Glover Woods comments today as you know many leas have developed their own portraits that reflect local priorities and the interests of their local communities remain

281concerned that a state portrait could have an homogenizing effect on local developed portraits and by extension diminish local priorities that do not align with the state portrait we look forward to working with the State Board to emphasize and protect the important space for local priorities to flourish whether those be in an Lea portrait or elsewhere we are committed to working with you to address these and other unintended consequences thank you thank you uh that concludes public comment right at this point we are open for board discussion um member esab you look like you're ready to go right and in in line with that Student Center approach I just wondered when we get receive the data if we can have it disaggregated by group and if there can be also an inclusion of focus groups as

282well I'm really interested in hearing students who are disenfranchised maybe in the D school if that could be one place where we can hear those voices students that gone through the system but somehow did not do well and needed to go to another so I would love to hear those voices maybe the voices of our long-term yells right so if if some of this data can be shared in a disaggregated form I think would be quite useful for us other comments or questions vice president clever Woods um thank you for everyone who gave public comment and um it it sounds like we're all in a sense singing the same song and um again appreciate the idea of making sure that the voices who are not usually heard are heard heard in this process most definitely

283um I I say to the board I think as we move forward with this work we have many um let me back up by saying we have many lanes of work in 2025 that seem to happen and will be happening simultaneously we just heard quite a bit on work around the accountability work plan the personal finance curriculum and also the development of a state portrait of a learner or graduate and um we're also looking at a timeline of bringing a draft of a portrait back to the full board in July and then perhaps to be able to finalize in in September so I say all that to say what I say all that to say I I think it would be beneficial if we are able to do um engage in this work in the

284process perhaps with a an ad hoc or a subcommittee of the board that would be able to do some work in this area um fully recognizing fully recognizing how um impacted everyone's schedule is so I just throw that out it's not a decision or anything for us to make now but um being able to have a subgroup if you will of the board that can help engage in the listening sessions along with um air I think will be very important and it will be very essential for us to have ears and eyes in the process as we engage with our educational Partners throughout the state so I just lift that up uh for your already full calendars just just consider and um perhaps uh Brooks the State Board staff will be able to assist us

285in how to best develop that subcommittee uh fairly soon so we can get started with this work all right member Clon and then member Rodriguez I'd just like to briefly Echo uh members scabo and Glover WS um and the presenters as well just discussing the importance of student voice but also the excitement of adding student voice to this process I believe this is a very exciting enriching thing for students to be discussing and so I will be you know conducting feedback I will be talking to students and then of course would love to engage in official ways within this role um to discuss students especially our marginalized and underserved communities about what they would like to see and how they would like to be reflected aspirationally but also authentically because we have students who are

286already you know Stellar examples of what we need our graduates and Learners to be um and so I'm just volunteering myself once again um for conducting that uh surveying all right member Rodriguez um yes thank you and and thank you so much for the presentation and the com the public comments I um think back to when we had our first stady session and just how exciting it was to hear from uh people who came in to share about what was happening in their schools and then uh when Lou from Kentucky Lou's her name right yes uh spoke to us about what they were doing in Kentucky and just the excitement that that gives me for uh you know in a non-prescriptive way of course uh but for us to think about um as one of

287the students said earlier today about the future uh and not with our lens but with the lens of um marginalized communities students who don't feel like they have a voice uh that they actually go to listening sessions parents um and just to be able to create a cohesive uh portrait of a graduate that represents uh the goals that we have here in California so I'm excited to see where this where we take this thank you terrific other comments questions so seeing none I think oh member mcquillin has his hand up on zo member mcquillin please yes oh thank you I just want to uh show my appreciation for this topic also I presented to the California oversight committee to American Indians on this topic and they were very pleasantly surprised on on being included and

288in this process and taking the process back to their leas you know California has over 109 federally recognized tribes and well over 700,000 American Indians in California so I know it's brought up it was brought up that uh giving American Indians a voice in this process too I just want to express my appreciation for that so thank you perfect all right so um we've got a process that's going to get rolling I want to ask vice president GL Woods if you want to summarize anything else about where we're where we're heading and and what we should be keeping in mind and then we can because it's an information item we do not need to vote and and what I would say in summary is um first of all we're at a great Next Step um

289excited to see how this has moved along from a conversation in July to where we are now and uh what I believe I am hearing and what I um foresee is that we will continue to work with a to finalize what these listening sessions will look like uh when they will be held what formats they will be held in other ways we will get feedback and we will uh begin to begin to engage in this work um one thing I didn't say in some of my earlier comments was again just a reiteration um that the wheel need not be recreated um leas throughout the state o over 100 or so have done this hard work and we can build off of the common traits and common ities in those portraits as well as the portraits

290that have been developed in other states I believe there might be about 18 or so throughout our country so um again we don't have to start from square one we do need it to be reflective of the lens of California if you will in the California way um on the same hand I think we have a great beginning start as well as those organizations that have already been engaged in this work and have uh been doing this work um educational partners that have have been doing this and supporting along the way that we have a great first step so uh in summary that was a long summary Dr darling ham and I'm sure I don't even know that it falls within the definition of summary at this point it has gone into a dissertation but

291in in the summary of my summary next steps will be to finalize um finalize our process to really get in a rich authentic educator feedback and engage in this process over the next few months thank you terrific so I think we're off and running with this um uh initiative and I'm going to move us along to item 14 item 14 is the state annual performance report for Part B of the individuals with disabilities Education Act of 2004 covering program year 22324 uh the California Department of Education recommends that we review and approve the executive summary of the uh ffy 2023 APR for Part B of idea uh this item will be presented by Rachel henan of the CDE and Scott Turner of the California Early Childhood special education Network please begin nice to see you

292is it on Hello good thank you good afternoon president darling Hammond vice president Woods um esteemed board thank you for allowing me and my staff to present here today um as you said I'm Dr Rachel Heenan I have been the director for the special education division for a little bit over a year um have truly had the experience of my life and really am excited about the opportunities and the work that's happening up and down the state to support our students with disabilities um I'm here today with some of my colleagues to review the annual performance report and I'm sure some of you know we call as um affectionately as the APR which truly looks at the outcomes of our students with disabilities in California the progress we are making the areas of need the

293areas um we can celebrate um and the bottom line is we need to do this together so before we um dive into the data I would like to take a moment to recognize our families in the Los Angeles County area um I live in Los Angeles County have been there for 25 years and can't thank enough the families the staff the superintendents the directors of special education to make sure that our families are number one safe that they're supported that they have access to an education if they can access to it they have access to it and for their ongoing commitment and communication with us to make sure that our most vulnerable students needs are being met so I do want to recognize that I also want to recognize this is a time of Celebration

294as this is the 50th year the 50th anniversary of the idea so if you think 50 years ago that's not that long ago that's not that long ago when our students with disabilities were not going to school they were served in institutions not access accessing any Ed education or peers so this is a celebration we have come a long way but we have a long way to go and we know that and the last thing is I do want to um express my gratitude to the state superintendent for always putting with students with disabilities on the front burner when he goes to speak when he's with our legislator when he's with our department of education for always reassuring that idea and the services for our students with disabilities will continue now I'm sure all of

295you have read this data and we're going to do things a little differently today um I didn't want to do what we call a data dump because it gets overwhelming what we did want to highlight is what we're doing well in the state of California where we need to improve and then also bring up our state um system of support Partners to talk about how we're supporting our earliest Learners our early intervention and you can see from the work that they're doing and the data that we're going to review we are seeing great gains so again um this is a journey this isn't something that we see change in two years five years we have 850,000 students with disabilities in California when I was presenting yesterday at AXA in San Diego I I equated that

296people just kind of gloss over 850,000 but if someone to one someone were to hand you a check for $850,000 it kind of is quite eye openening the number of students we have that we need to serve so as you can see from your data we know our students in K12 in general we are declining enrollment probably like most States especially in California our students with disabilities K through 12 over 10 years as you can see we've gone from 600,000 to over 700,000 that does not include our earliest Learners oh thank you um and again if you look at our total number of students 851 th000 students with disabilities again my message that has been this whole year we can't do this alone my staff can't do this alone our state system of support Partners

297we can't do it we need to work together and we're starting to see some great gains the next slide is just a simple um a simple way to see this as you can see we had a steady increase over the past 12 years then we hit our covid years of 20 um 20121 2022 but look at the trajectory how much we have how many more students have been identified since Co mostly we see the gains in our students I identified with autism our students who have specific learning disabilities and our speech and language impaired students and when I presented yesterday I actually put up a map of the United States of America in California the number of students with disabilities is greater than the total population of four states me say that again there are

298four four states in the United States of America that do not have a population a total population that we have for students with disabilities so our needs are great and we'll continue to work towards them I know some people have asked about our students with disabilities represented in our lcff groups and the numbers remain pretty constant we have about 70% of our students with disabilities who are also a foster student who are also a student who received free and reduced lunch a student who is a multilingual language learner so 77 70% of those students are also and should be supported in our lcff funding 30% are not that shouldn't be much of a surprise so next we're going to dive into some of the annual per um performance report or the APR we're going to

299talk about some of our indicators and again we have 18 indicators for special education that we report to the department US Department of Education that looks at how our students with disabilities are performing in California so we will um go through some of those not all and we'll take questions at the end um please know and I'm without further Ado I'd like to introduce um Shiloh Duncan Bessel who many of you know she is a veteran in our office feel honored to work with her and her knowledge um to keep um our system moving forward CH good afternoon board members um I come here this might be the first year ra uh Dr Heenan here this might be my 10th year presenting this data to you um but I always love coming here you always

300are so lovely with us so the annual performance report is a report we must submit to the US Department of Education is one of the factors that is required in order for us to receive the 1.4 billion Dollar in federal funds that support students directly so 99% of those funds go directly to students to support them in districts and so we must complete this report um but I promise we will try to make it as painless as possible for you to watch I'm going to review some of the indicators um this chart as well as the following two charts on the slides um are in your um in the executive summary and the things I want to say here is um the tagline I always say which is you'll look at this and it'll say

301no oh we didn't meet the targets um yes we did not meet all of our targets but we are heading in the right direction so if you will look at these charts and the charts that follow them you will see that we are making gains in lots of spaces within our special education these particular indicators are very challenging for us to meet because they are either zero or 100% which means if we find one non-compliance if we have one student who doesn't meet a timeline then we have not met the target but if you will see we are trending in the right direction for most of them um these are performance indicators if you remember maybe a few years ago I believe in 2021 uh we set the targets for these these were set with

302an educational partner group that identified where we wanted to go as a state for our students with disability um as you can see the same story we are not meeting all of our targets we are meeting some not all but we are trending in the right direction same thing for these as well what I do want to highlight for you all is how we here at the department view our work and we believe that if we have students in the right placement in the right supports exposed to high quality instruction that it will lead to a reduction Behavior an increase in learning that's exhibited through our Statewide assessments and that will lead to um graduation and post School achievement something like 60% of adults with disabilities are unemployed and so part of the work that

303we want to be able to do is set students on the right path to address some of those um deficits one of the things I do want to highlight here is we will be showing a video in a little while that is going to highlight in some ways the portrait of a graduate for us and what we see when we see our children and the exemplars in some of our leas who are working really hard to make inclusive environments for students in the right places now again I'm a data person but I'm not going to bore you with data right after lunch um but I did select a couple of indicators that I wanted to highlight for you all so you all could see some of the work that we are doing and it's going

304to lead into some of our work with our system of support so I wanted to highlight indicator five which is one that folks always have questions about this is part of our theory of action getting students in the right placements and you will see we did not meet our targets um not all of them um but we did see a trend in the right direction and so when I say that we have a increase of 1.21% we are talking about the change of placement to a more inclusive environment for more than 35,000 students so that is a big change and so I think we want to be able to highlight that as well and then um the same thing for having students in more restrictive environments we have fewer and fewer of them so again

305the same tagline we didn't meet the target but we are trending in the right direction and it should be noted that when we make these changes in the state um it is very hard to move the needle because we are a very large state but what we want to be able to see is the change over year over year over year we could be seeing the change in placement for the equivalent of all the students in a single District could change their placement and that would only highlight the state just a little bit so something to keep in mind um indicator six is our preschool least restrictive environment indicator and that one is again we're not meeting the targets but we are trending in the right direction and even here we're seeing a greater Trend

306in the right direction almost a change of 5% from last year to here are preschool students served in more inclusive environments and they're receiving their services in those inclusive environments which I think is really important to highlight um our population changes over the last several years for this population group has changed significantly part of that was due to some changes that the US Department of Education made on this indicator but also changes in how we are uh have reflected some of the work in this space um in 2021 um 2022 the US Department of Education made a change this indicator which um now students who are in TK and five years old are now included in the school age that indicator five so that's why you'll see a significant change here but what's exciting for

307me is that we are finding more students who need supports earlier on and as we know this is an on-ramp to future success if we can identify areas of concern earlier we can address it with the right supports get students in the right placements and put them on a track towards um long-term outcomes the next two indicators I did want to highlight I try to end on a somewhat positive note if I can um in my part which is the two indicators we did meet which is graduation and Dropout I do want to note that this indicator is significantly different from our graduation indicator in the dashboard so it's kind of like uh an apple and an orange but we call them both grapes um it's just not the same thing um but these are

308students who exited um special education with IEPs and graduating with a regular high school diploma um and we the result was almost 80% we did meet this Target and then our dropout rate also um went down and we were meeting this target as well so I think that's really exciting that tells us a little bit about our theory of action if we're getting more kids in the right places getting exposed to that high quality instruction then what we're going to see is we're going to see impact in these indicators um it just doesn't happen as quickly as we would like um but I think what's exciting is that there's so much more opportunity and options for parents and families to begin to meet um their goals in this space and I know um uh Dr

309hean wants to talk a little bit more about some of the pathways that we've um had open to us last year here so now I was asked um to briefly talk about the diploma Pathways I think this is kind of like a hot button issue right now um a hot uh topic as we say uh in the field of special education but an exciting topic um like we talk about this port portrait of a graduate portrait of a student portrait of a successful student um students who have options for diplomas or their next steps will be more successful and we will also see probably a decrease in our dropout rate they're all connected so I just want to take you very quickly um just to clarify um some of the diploma Pathways that we have

310in the past many years we've had a student who was able to meet the graduation requir requirements and receive a diploma then if you look down on the green bar many for many years this was the only option if a student did not receive a diploma they could receive a certificate of completion a certificate of attendance I've heard some dis districts call them and they continue to receive their services until age 22 most often these were our students with the most extensive needs more recently we um are really excited for some options to open the door for our students with with disabilities towards a diploma which will increase their access to not only college but to also career opportunities where we know that many companies require a diploma for employment so if you look at

311the top blue bar um we have some of the work that's already been happening and this um is for our most extensive need students and it is an opportunity for an alternative Pathway to a diploma again this is our most extensive student needs um and most of them will receive a diploma and can continue their journey to hopefully an inclusive college program that we're really trying to push up and down the state um and and many of these students will again continue to receive their services until age 22 we also have another pathway in the orange um that is being worked on right now um it's being led by the work from westad um we have some pilot work going out a lot of um feedback from our leas and this is basically how I

312um in my head keep it straight is we call this as an alternative means for students to express their understanding so when we put it that way it helps clarify so many of our students and then we'll talk a little bit after um have the option to show their understanding not by the standard way that we assess all students they might be using an ey gaze machine they might be expressing themselves um through through pictures or through other ways so we're working right now with leas to make sure teachers are trained um not just our special ed teachers but our general Ed teachers truly understand there's multiple ways for a student to express their understanding of the content and then by 2027 this will be in place so that all students both students that have

313extensive needs and students who um are considered to have a more mild or moderate disability will have options open for them like never before so know that we're doing a lot of training up and down the state um we're providing a lot of technical assistance to leas to make sure that there's understanding and that work will continue at least for another two years till everybody understands their role responsibilities and to move our students towards this portrait of a graduate so I want to bring this all together so as Shiloh talked about we have the right placements supports Services um that rightful presence of a students with disabilities it is their right to be included um and we we're bringing and bringing this up as um I want to show a little video of a clip

314of one of our students Ethan Thomas Ethan's from Walnut Valley High School school district he graduated last year some of you might have seen his videos kind of go viral um on um he recently um presented last year at his graduation ceremony most of the time we see our 4.8 students um give quite an amazing speech and Ethan was given the opportunity to present at commencement and talk about his experience where he was and where he's going and this truly is when we have the right support system in place this should be the opportunity for all our students so I don't know about pressing play Anywhere here should I just press the picture Hello class of 2024 my name isth that's not good see we can get it to project see if the vendor can

315project a video instead of this PowerPoint what's on the screen what's on this for we go perfect hello class of 2024 my name is Ethan Thomas I have spent 4 years here and it's been a great time you might have noticed me talking to myself and making puppet hands during break time or passing period This is called stemming when I feel stressed or overwhelmed my steming increases and I won't be able to focus and hear people when they're speaking to me I wasn't trying to be weird or ignore you I do these things because I have autism and little things can throw me off so steming helps me me calm down the staff here at Diamond Bar High School helped me be successful in more ways than I can count if it wasn't for their

316hard work patience and dedication I wouldn't be here ready and excited for the next chapter in my life next school year I'm going to mount sack [Applause] some of you might see me there remember to say hi I bet just by seeing me around campus some of you thought I couldn't give a commencement speech I'd like to take this opportunity to take my school and those who believed in me advocated for me and finally those who decided to take a chance on me to stand in front of you and give the speech [Applause] did you know I taught myself how to play Mozart on a keyboard just by looking at the lights on the keys as the keyboard plays by itself I don't play it like a person who has taken keyboard or piano lessons

317I play it my way that's called different but able some of you will someday get a job and have a position where you decide who to hire and not hire you should decide who to hire based on the person's abilities if I can give you one piece of advice as you go into the real world and work with people who are different with different abilities that would be to judge people by what they're able to do rather than what you see on the outside being different doesn't mean being unable to do things we're all very different from each other doing things that others might not understand that doesn't mean we're not normal there's no such thing as normal what is normal after all thank you so Ethan received a diploma Ethan is the portrait of

318a graduate Ethan has disabilities Ethan is now on the circuit being asked to come speak all over the place this is we what we want for all our students and last I'm just going to um before I just quickly um introduce and hand over our state system of support I want everybody to know that our US Department of Education Mission and priorities I I put this up last year and that top bar to improve early childhood education and employment outcomes and raise expectations for all people with disabilities families communities in the nation will continue we will continue that work in California when we lead for Equitable outcomes I showed this slide last year and our goals will continue as our data support that we need to continue to working on delivering a comprehensive program for

319all our students we're focusing on their rightful presence not only to be in the classroom but to be on the commencement stage speaking to their other students we're making sure that we have these diploma Pathways in place so that students have greater opportunities for work for college um throughout the state of California or wherever they may land this work will continue for all of us and we're going to lead the work with our partners in the state again my 800,000 students we can't do this alone we can't do this as a board we can't do this in my division and I wanted just to highlight these are some of the partners and I wish when I was a director I knew that these Partnerships existed and I wish I knew where to go when I

320was created my collaborative co- teing program because I was inside my own District going I don't know who to go to if I only knew we have sip we have cxi we have all these support state system of support and our goal this year is to make sure every single District looks at their data and determines who they need to connect with to improve their data for students with u disabilities um so without further do I just would like to introduce Noelia Hernandez she is um a now the new associate director a new associate director and the division of special education overseeing um complaints resolution which we're highlighting as the key word as we opened our constituent office um to really hear our families to hear them out to address their needs right at the

321ground level and to return them back and to assist to work with our school districts because many of these families have a 22-year relationship with the school district so we're working really hard to promote alternative dispute resolution options to cut down on our complaints and noelli is truly going to lead the work of Our Community Partners which she already has and overseeing the Early Childhood division which um she'll introduce um Scott and Melanie who are here today so um Noelia thank you Dr Heenan hello president darling Hammond VP Glover woods and esteem board um I'd like to introduce the California Early Childhood special education or cexi um as one of our key Partners in advancing early special education for the state Dr Scott Turner is here today he's worked in the field of special education

322for approximately 20 years including a position as an early childhood education specialist District special education administrator and adjunct faculty serving higher ed currently Dr Turner is the executive director of the East sang Gabriel Valley Sala and co-executive director of cexi with him today also is Melanie herig who has over 25 years of experience in education she was a preschool school psychologist a special education director in Riverside County and after 10 years as an executive director of of special education uh selpa supporting Irvine Union School District in Orange county is now serving as the co-executive Director of Cal XI Network in the full-time capacity please join me in welcoming them thank you Noelia um just want to thank the State Board of Education and also CDE for having us here today I know our time is

323limited so we're going to try to be brief um but I just want to recognize those other partners that were mentioned um any of them could be here today just sharing the exciting work that's occurring throughout the state and so we're honored to be here but please know that those other projects are working diligently to improve outcomes for our students with disabilities and we wanted to provide you a brief overview of the cexy network California Early Childhood special education Network um a little bit of History um it dates back to Senate Bill 75 so the education trailer bill that was signed by Governor Nome July 1st of 2019 that led to the part C Tob for cow kids workg group um and this workg group had about 50 expert practitioners from throughout the state um

324leas school districts County offices selas family empowerment centers Family Resource Centers Regional centers um and also had a steering committee led by the Department of Developmental services and CDE really looking at the outcomes for our youngest children as they leave part C Services where DDS Department of developmental Services is the lead agency in transition to school districts primarily at age three and so specific recommendations came out of that report to improve outcomes and transition um for California's youngest Learners the work group was held during the pandemic but that really was not the impetus but it definitely was helpful for us to work through those challenges of transitioning those students to school districts during the pandemic um Department of Developmental services and CDE were present throughout the work group and they worked expeditiously to respond to

325those recommendations and um that is the impetus of cexi we were funded by the California Department of Education through Federal idea 619 funds and we're addressing indicators related to preschool so indicator six preschool lre indicator 7 which is um preschool outcomes and we work very closely with desired results Access Project at a Napa County Office of Ed to support that work and indicator 12 which is the part c2b transition having an individualized education program in place for every child by their third birthday um we also are working diligently for child fine that's indicator 11 ensuring that we work with other agencies to ensure any child suspected of a disability um can be found eligible and receive early intervention and just really disseminating best practices for Early Childhood special education throughout the field uh real quick

326on our organization um our work is Led Out of the East San Gabriel Valley Sela and the Irvine Unified School District so Melanie and myself serve as the co-executive directors um we also have a project coordinator and now program specialist in northern and southern California um when we were funded in the spring of 2022 uh we worked diligently to survey the field um and when we say the field we're talking about County offices school districts um selas Family empowerment centers research centers um sorry Family Resource Centers um also working with our Regional Center Partners um and at the same time um we put out out a competitive application process for some of these agencies that had Exemplar practices to help lead some work and so the areas are defined as you see here on this

327slide inter agency collaboration we have a selpa and a regional center who are showcasing the work occurring in San Diego uh County on how school districts and Regional centers work together to make sure that that transition is successful um a lot of work with assessment practices so ensuring that our practitioners have evidence-based practices to thoroughly assess our youngest Learners um a lot of work with assessment team leadership so how do our leaders in our school districts um if their background is not preschool how do they oversee a preschool assessment team and make sure that those cases are assigned appropriately and that timelines are met um working with other agencies including help me grow in first five out of Orange County to increase preschool child fine so ensuring that those students with disabilities or children at

328that age um are identified as expeditiously as possible um we work with family empowerment Cent and we have parents place family Empowerment Center leading the work with parent Outreach and support um and then also data governance um we need to have accurate data and so that work is currently LED out of East County selpa um who also runs the highquality IEPs project shown on a previous slide um and we're very passionate working with our partners including supporting inclusive practices on Innovative and inclusive practices um we strongly believe that if we could set a trajectory in younger years of education um that our students can can be educated alongside they're typically developing peers and stay on that trajectory into high school and Beyond um with those agencies leading that work through memorandums of understanding we also

329have identified Geographic technical assistance facilitators and parts of the state to make sure that this information is disseminated out as Dr Heenan mentioned um we want everyone to know that these resources are available and so we use our um GTS as we call them to help with that and they're all onus as well with our Network um we uh I wouldn't say stole but we uh collaboratively use the California county superintendence model many of you are familiar with this the different regions throughout the state that have been successful in many other models and so those are the regions that we use in our work and I'll turn it over to my colleague Melanie our calx Network team intentionally designed a system of support that we wanted to get down to the practitioner level so when

330I speak of our preschool practitioner level I'm talking about Preschool teachers preschool spe therapists preschool School psychologists and those program administrators that supervise those preschool programs we know sometimes that information is you know provided at maybe the top of the levels and doesn't necessarily always make its way down to the people that are actually doing the work so we wanted to ensure as we were developing this system of support that it was designed to reach those practitioners in the field um therefore our Exemplar leads and our Geographic technical assistant facilitators uh develop content for multiple uh virtual workshops that are offered throughout the year and we do those virtual workshops um midday after school and then we also record those workshops so that people can access those trainings um you know at their own convenience

331and times that they're able to do that the Exemplar leads and our Geographic technical assistance facilitators have also developed resources and um guidance documents that we push out to the field um and they're also housed on our caxy websites website for easy access we also receive questions daily from our info@ Cal x.org site um we do our best to answer those questions we typically can but if there's a question that we can't answer we have so many connections with that Statewide assistant of support and the California Department of Education that are able to provide those answers to people in the field uh we also we Ambi ambitiously felt a need for a conference likee platform for people in this field to um be able to learn and grow professionally we held our second Symposium this

332last October and we were very pleasantly I want say pleasantly surprised but we were very um surprised I guess you could say that we had 700 attendees this is our second our second Symposium we had about 600 at our first and 700 at our second so that just kind of demonstrates that there's a a need and the field is hungry for this information and that's the feedback that we often receive from practitioners in the field we really need something specific for those preschoolers uh we were able to offer 50 different sessions and we were able to do that many sessions uh for the Symposium because we had sessions provided by staff from California Department of Education dep Department of Developmental services our other Statewide system of support partners and other experts from the field so

333it was very rich um in the professional learning that occurred at that Symposium thank you Cal XI also provides intensive and targeted support So as part of that Statewide system of support we are a technical assistance provider and we are assigned districts specifically who require support through that compliance Improvement monitoring process and so we engage with those districts that are identified for specifically for those preschool needs and provide support for them um we also in working with Dr Heenan and her staff recognize that we have a great opportunity to also provide proactive support So in working with her team we've identified specifically for indicators six 7 and 12 so again six is least restrictive environment seven is the Dr access assessment outcomes and 12 that part C Tob transition um we're starting with indicator six

334and we've identified 100 districts that are within 5% of meeting that Target and So Cal XY has engaged in a series of sessions and have invited those 100 districts to participate in those sessions where we specifically help them look at their program practices look at the accuracy of the data that they're reporting and an effort to try to help them just get over that you know get over that little that little gaps and help them achieve those indicator goals in the near future um the interest has been high we actually started our first session this Friday and we have many of those 100 districts that are have teams that are participating so that is great to report um and lastly talk about our communities of practice when I was a brand new uh preschool psych

335or excuse me a school psychologist my boss said can you please work in uh preschool and to be honest I was not comfortable at that point in my early on my career working assessing three and foury olds it is very different than working with a child who's 10 14 16 years old um so I knew a couple colleagues in neighboring districts that were the preschool school psychologist in their districts and I reached out to them we started meeting regularly just to share best practices to share strategies that we use in testing kiddos on the floor you know versus then sitting in a chair working with families who have just been informed that their child has some type of disability um you know sharing our assessment tools the way we write our reports how to work

336um and provide different program options to very young children that have different levels of needs well that little small group that community of three of us in that county at the time which was Riverside now 20 years later has grown into every District in that county participates in that Consortium group so something very small took hold and had grown so our Network took that idea and wanted to apply that concept across the state so thinking about the map that Dr Turner showed you know shared with you all that County the region map we have 11 regions in the state and we have staff and our Geographic technical assistance facilitators assigned to each region and we currently are developing those communities of practice across the state now some of those communities do already exist so we

337did surveys asked questions of colleagues and so we've identified a few places in the state where they do have a specifically preschool um community of practice for those practitioners in the field and so we've invited ourselves to support those existing communities of practice and where those communities of practice do not exist we're developing those communities of practice and the interest has been very high um we're proud to to share that with you all I think there's unfortunately for that that preschool programming World um it is different than working with older children and we have so many practitioners that are new to the field that people are always hungry for this information want to learn from veterans in the field how to support these very Young Learners um we want to thank you for having us

338here today and and able to share more about our our project thank you very much turn it back to Dr he yes we'll turn this back to Dr Heenan thank you Scott Melanie um for coming just to highlight some of the amazing work we're doing especially for our early Learners um and I first thank you um for your time it's always an honor to be here and to I know we kind of go over our time but we just have so much that we're doing um to support our students with disabilities we've come so far in 50 years but we have a lot further to go um and we're ready to do it so with that I at the business side which is um we do request that you approve our 2023 um annual performance

339report for submission to the US Department of Education in order to fulfill requirements under the individuals with disabilities Education Act thank you so much can you put up the public comment slide as well because we are going to ask people who would like to call in for public comment to queue up now uh if you are interested in calling in you would call the phone number on the slide uh that is about to be displayed along with the access code and while we're waiting for members of the public to call in I want to ask AR Lea on um member yoshimoto T if she has any initial comments for us thank you I want to thank Dr Heenan and Shiloh for presenting today and particularly for not only highlighting uh the areas where we need

340to uh our progress but also areas we need to grow uh also K XI uh Scott and Melanie thank you for being here today that when we think about students with disabilities everything's so interconnected anything we talk about at the board usually involves students with disabilities uh think about Community Schools Behavioral Health fin finial literacy so the work really has to be interconnected uh and sometimes the way we're organized isn't always connected right we have certain divisions that are focused on something uh and so they really need to work across divisions and across agencies to support students with disabilities so our County offices our salpas um many of our educational partners are all working together the um one thing I wanted to highlight is uh I think what was different about this year's presentation and

341I want to commend you for that is that you really tried to tell a story with the data um it's there's so many items it's difficult to sometimes just hear the numbers but telling the story and specifically focusing on what we can do uh between you know year to year right between January to January what are the action steps that are happening to improve the outcomes that we're seeing um with our students so thank you for doing that and uh we look forward to making meaningful progress and thank you we look forward to the discussion and approving the AP today are there any clarifying questions before we hear public comment all right uh we'll uh give you a little break in case we have public comment is there any public comment in the room we

342have two people signed up for public comment please come to the microphone Lorraine Richard and Angela steagle hello I'm Lorraine Richards I'm a classroom teacher representing California teacher [Music] Association according to the instructions from the US Department of Education indicator 7 is only a preschool indicator however starting this school year CDE is now mandating that all tkk students under age 6 with IEPs be administered the drdp assessments and have cited indic Ator 7 as the reason for that change CDE special ed staff states that this change was necessary in order to use that data for indicator 7 of the state performance plan this is a significant change from normal practices and has already resulted in significant workload issues for our teachers we do not believe that tkk students should be included in this data unless

343mandated by the US Department of Education thank you hello I'm Angela stagel classroom teacher representing the California Teachers Association with regards to the expanded scope of indicator 7 i l my comments with my colleague and do not believe TK and kindergarten students should be included in this data unless mandated to do so by the US Department of Education when data forther indicators in the state performance plan is meant to include TK or Kinder students the indicator descriptions from the federal government expressly use those terms such as as indicator 5 currently the indicator 7 description does not include TK or Kinder and is specific to only preschool and previously TK and Kinder data were not included for indicator 7 we are confused as to why the CDE is insisting on including TK Kinder students in this

344data set when kindergarten is not considered part of the preschool program thank you and we have two callers in the queue I will open the phone line now um caller with the last 4 digits 8806 you are now live please start your public comment you have 1 minute good afternoon members of the State Board of Education my name is I'm the director of East County the previous chair of the srat association and I'm calling on behalf of the Sela administrators of California first thank you to the State Board of Education and other policy makers ongoing and it comes for our students with disabilities and technical assistance through the support we would like to provide public comment on the California Department of Education division special education divisions monitoring system as we continue to work towards improving

345outcomes for our students with ability reflected in the state performance youve heard today we have worked collaboratively with the California Department of Education special education division to support these efforts with Our member leas the CDE has provided specialized training to our association on the monitoring and Improvement activities focus on and our association and the developers of cross have had an opportunity to work with technical providers led by SAS within the comp Improvement drink Sim system SAS are part of providing direct support their thank youing project thank you colie your time is up uh next caller with the last four digits 6972 you are now live please start your public comment you have one minute good afternoon my name is Tavia Lawson I am a parent member of a community advisory committee and I'm also an

346employee with the family Empowerment Center I really wanted to express my appreciation to the California Department of Education and also to the State Board of Education on your efforts on focusing on improving outcomes for students with disabilities and I was really appreciative of hearing the presentation today um regarding uh amplifying the student voices also about the important collaboration between all agencies including the local educational agencies The Family Resource and empowerment centers Regional centers just to name a few thank you thank you that concludes public comment for item number 14 all right um moving to uh uh state board discussion are there questions or comments from members of the board member Rosco Gonzalez and then member escabedo um going along the lines of what public comment was um I'm I'm just seeking clarification regarding that recent

347change to the indicator 7 in the state annual performance report specifically the inclusion of the TK Kinder students in the drdp assessments um could you clarify why the CDA is now including uh the TK Kinder students in the data for indicator 7 when it was not the practice in the past so there's a little bit of a history lesson that needs so um in the measurement table so none of these indicators are set by CD we cannot decide how we calculate them and we cannot decide how we determine who goes in where um under the individuals with disabilities Education Act and under the measurement table that supports the annual performance report which is the directions from the US Department of Education to us about these indicators it does not say preschool it says children ages

348three through five in the past prior to the implementation of universal TK and there were very few five-year-old children in kindergarten but once we implemented TK um there were more 5-year-old children in in kindergarten and so the rules that were set forth by us by the US Department of Education is that now we must include those children because there are so many more of them um in previous years I think um 1718 through 2021 there may have been maybe a hundred or less um now there are many thousands of children who are ages five with an IEP in TK and kindergarten and so under the rules set forth by the US part of Education we must include them because of age not because of grade Ida doesn't recognize grade it recognizes ages and they identify

349students who are in preschool as being ages three through five it's that's a good clarification because of the ages now that's now the te K falls under that and so we did provide um the field a warning about a year ago and then we wanted to provide them more time to prepare for this implementation so that's why we it was it was sort of a process that happened uh a little bit slower but it is feeling impacted now so we do understand that and we have been working with the DRX our out of Napa County to provide any additional supports and resources for training um but the the unfortunate side is it's mandated by the requirements under the law remember sco wanted to commend you with your presentation it is a Herculean task working with

350the whole state and and in the era specialed I I love your theory of action I would I would underscore it's not only the right placement but at the earliest time and cexi did a beautiful job in sharing ing that because the more investment at an earlier age the greater tendency to exit as well and I'm in addition uh one of the things that we did in in our south county is disproportionality predictive analysis because we found out that sometimes uh you need to have the right protocols for identification right and you could almost predict certain places that don't use those Pro protols or or or have a different perception all you need to do is provide some additional professional development so just wonder as a state I know that's huge thing to do but

351any thoughts or maybe something Mary might want to do is a AI predictive analysis in the area of dispro professionality I think you know especially when you look at declining enrollment yet increasing enrollment in special ed part of it is that disproportionality as i' I've had lots of conversations over the years with subo director Russell um Coronado out of South County um about the tool that was um developed out of his office and I do think it's an excellent tool for districts to adopt um I don't know if it's something we would necessarily mandate out of the department um I think it's a tool or resource we would make available um to districts um I will say one of the concerns that sometimes is highlighted is that we don't want um leas to um oh

352we can't identify any more students like this because it would make us disproportionate and so part of that has to happen around a lot of education and support to implement something like that Statewide one one of the issues that I found in my district I could almost predict who would be in my Ed classrooms they're typically males and they're typically you know either a Hispanic or or africanamerican black student so I understand where you're coming from but there's an issue in in that area I think you're pointing to the and I'll come right around to member Rodriguez so the interaction between a variety of strategies and services and uh behaviors in the classroom and then what may happen with students at the same time there is the fact that you know for example autism rates

353are increasing at a very rapid rate 500% and I have heard people say you we sometimes feel we can't identify kids who need Services because we've got these statistics so I think a question that I'll come back around to is how do we figure out how to be more nuanced than the federal reporting May sometimes require to capture what's really needed by students and make sure that they get it and I think that goes not only for that question of you know proportionalities but also the 1% cap on alternative assessments and so on those are it come from assumptions that um don't always ensure that students get what they what they need uh member Rodriguez yes uh thank you so much that was a very thorough presentation and I especially wanted to um highlight and

354thank you for uh your comment about just because we're not there doesn't mean we're not progressing uh be as a classroom teacher and uh somebody uh who has uh you know maybe six or seven autistic students in my classes uh that you know I'm constantly working and I see them improving right and maybe we're not there yet but um it just it offered me a lot of comfort and I'll go back and share that with my colleagues who uh sometimes feel like we have to be perfect uh but we're getting there and our heart is there so thank you as much as this is is a very important topic we are more than an hour behind our schedule now but please make a comment I just want to keep the comments efficient be efficient in

355your comment well I just wanted to kind of um piggy back a little bit on what I did said you know I have students also with special needs and what stuck up to me in one of the in the video that um the young man did in his speech was that just because we do things differently doesn't mean that we're not able and I have a high um High performing autistic child who does is very able it's actually probably one of the highest performing in my classroom but just says things differently and so just to honor that that um that all of us have students like that in our classroom and just to give them that space to to do things their way and I think this is a hugely important topic that I wish

356we had a whole another two hours to discuss I'd like to just leave a few questions for you to come back and talk with us about and if any of them are questions you have an immediate answer to we'd love to hear it and if not we we'll definitely plan a time where we can really dig in because uh you know the the federal reporting is one thing and then there's all the rest of what you're doing and all the rest of what we want to see for the students so um you know one of them is you know what other metrics we might want to be using they give us a more nuanced picture beyond what the federal government asks us for as we were saying before and I'd love to hear your thoughts

357about that um and in in more detail when we have the time for that um the another is that you know the uh office of special education in the department of education has sent out a dear colleagues letters trying to remind people that you know by federal law under idea uh students in special education are not to be taught by teachers who are not fully credentialed and that's a that's a huge challenge in 48 states or more uh including California and I would love to hear your thoughts about what we could be doing to be approaching uh approaching that goal more expeditiously um I'm going to give you three more questions and if you feel like you want to have Ready Answers for some feel free to give them and if not we'll come back

358really we will come back around and have a session on special education um the the other of course is we you know that we have you know fewer students in LR environments some part of that you know in the past was caused by the way we're credentialing teachers so that some teachers were only credential to be in special education environments and couldn't uh teach in a blended environment um and um so I'm curious about where we are on that now credentialing is changing and so on maybe I'll pause with those and just see if any of those are ones you want to uh address at the moment and that will not prevent us from getting a deeper dive later I'd love to have another session okay love it yeah um I know you're thinking and

359worrying about these things that we would like to absolutely only you know recruitment but retention you know our teachers are coming in and they're here for two years and they leave the field and we also know the teachers who come in without credentials leave at much higher rates than those who come in fully prepared because the J is hard but you know we I don't know whether we've ever done a survey of California Special Ed teachers to see what is driving them you know Partners at Cedar have done that and so we're um we've connected with them to be part of the board to really take a look at this and what we can do to not only recruit but retain yes special education teachers and and are you suggesting they might be willing to

360do such a study for us possibly possibly okay I'll take that for now yeah the fourth question which you may have some ideas about now is that as we've gotten these graduation Pathways moving what more can we do to make sure that the information about that and how to you know take advantage uh of those uh affordances you know is um is getting out is that one that you have thoughts about that you'd like to share it's educate educate educate a lot of people did not even even know that Senate Bill 181 was there was it two years ago three years ago um and so we're doing a lot of technical assistance a lot of Outreach um sometimes it takes that direct communication with an Lea to make sure they understand what is required by

361law um and the right thing to do so we'll we'd love to hear more about that and what you are doing and finding successful when you come back and I will I will leave you with all of those thoughts and questions because we do have to kind of move along but we really appreciate the opportunity to hear from you we appreciate the opportunity not just to see the data but then to hear what's behind the data and I think we'd love to hear more because it's a very important area for us to lean into thank you did we with that what we still need to do a motion oh I'm sorry don't go away well you could go away but we're gonna still have a motion who would like to give us a motion to

362adopt the um recommendation moved thank you very much and a second member Lewis all right call the rooll member Clawson yes president darling Hamm member of scabo yes vice president clever Woods yes M Lewis yes member mcquillin yes member Olin yes M Rosco Gonzalez yes member pill brownson yes Rodriguez yes Yosh motari motion carries inan um we're supposed to have a little break but I'm afraid to take a break give you five minutes and at three o'clock we're going to start up again okay is that nine minutes oh okay I'm looking at that clock and that's how it looks to me but I'll say 256 all right uh we're missing one person okay okay um we're going to go right on ahead we're going to reconvene the board and take up the waiver consent items

363W1 through W4 we'll now open the phone line for the public comment q and is there any in person uh public comment we have no public commenters in the room and is there anyone on the phone for public comment there are no callers in the queue all right right so uh given there's no further public comment I'll ask for a motion on consent items W1 through W4 do I have a motion thank you vice president clever Woods I move that we approve the consent items W1 through W4 all right thank you and we have a second for member aresco Gonzalez thank you very much and Brooks can you call the role appreciating the well stated motion a member clawen yes president darling Hammond yes member of scabo yes vice president GL Woods Yes Lewis yes

364member mcquillin yesin yes member Rosco Gonzalez yes pill brownson member Rodriguez yesi yes motion carries thank you we're gonna move on to item 15 item 15 is a public hearing regarding the petition for the renewal of the charter school authorized by the California State Board of Education consideration of the High-Tech high Statewide benefits Charter the California Department of Education recommends that we approve the charter school renewal petition for a term of 5 years beginning July 1 2025 and ending June 30th 2030 and the CDE also recommends that we designate the San Diego County Board of Education as the charter schools chartering Authority effective July 1st 2025 the item will be presented by Craig heckner of the CDE Craig welcome thank you uh president darling Hammond and members of the State Board uh I am here

365it's my pleasure to present item 15 uh as just stated so at this hour I hope you will forgive me if I don't um do I need to open the public hearing yes I need to open the public hearing at 3:2 PM okay I I won't read every word I hope you forgive me because it's a little late and I know there may be plain flights and other things impacted but I do want to cover the important points of this very important uh item so as stated we have the uh High-Tech high Statewide benefit Charter this is the last of the Statewide benefit Charters and there are some changes based on law that this will no longer be uh if renewed by the state board no longer be authorized by the state board but it

366has a a delegation choice and we'll get to that and it's comprised of nine schools located on three campuses throughout San Diego County there's an elementary school middle school and high school on each campus and so as you can see in this chart this uniquely involves four different districts uh North County are all in San Marcos unified Mesa in San Diego unified Chula Vista splits between uh Elementary and high school two different dist districts Chula Vista Elementary for the elementary and middle schools and Sweetwater Union high for the high school so these are usually in the past when we've had these type of uh situations of a St state board authorized Charter School up for Renewal if gets approved for Renewal it's been a pretty easy delegation this one is a little different so we've

367gone a little bit more in depth on it um it's the like I mentioned it's the last one we have some Ed code up here I won't go through all of that but as I mentioned this will involve delegation if renewed and if a charter school is assigned to a County Board of Education it can qualify in this case uh it may become a count countywide benefit Charter School countywide charter school excuse me and that's pursuant to EC section 47 65.6 which is what they are requesting our recommendation is that the State Board uh approved the charter schools renewal petition for a term of five years beginning July 1st 2025 ending June 30th 2030 and our recommendation is based on a review of their performance on the dashboard measurable increases in academic achievement equivalent to

368one year's progress for each year in school and strong postsecondary outcomes I'll get into a little bit of that um we also have proposed two very small technical amendments one is a a uh very minor correction of language uh around the home language survey this is commonly being caught just to sort of bring it into line with exact statutory requirements it's very minor the other one of course is to uh designate instead of Statewide benefit Charter that's going away to countywide Charter School if you support that uh delegation and that we also recommend that delegation as well mentioning the uh role of the advisory Commission on Charter Schools briefly they did hear this item on December 10th and they approved uh unanimously C P's recommendation to renew the charter uh just a brief reminder accs

369does not get into the delegation issue that's not in statute so they did not comment on that standard of review just a reminder also that we are no longer in in this path doing what we did mostly for the past few years which are the abuse of discretion uh standards and those are completely different this is back to what we used to call the denovo review it's basically a full review of the petition and we do it uh of all 15 elements uh it's not just our Charter School Division that looks at it it goes around various divisions and it's that's why the re recommendation is not just a charter school division recommendation it is the cde's recommendation at the end of the day and that in in-depth analysis is included as attachment one there

370are based on Ed code 47607 and 67.2 free performance categories as you're well aware of Charter renewal and a Charter School's placement in these categories is determined by its performance on the dashboard Charter Schools meeting this criteria are identified as high uh in the high performing category shall be granted uh renewal they're on a fast track a presumptive basis for Renewal and in the high performing category they could get five to seven years just a reminder on the uh parameters there if they don't meet that criteria and they are in the middle performing category then pursuant to 4760 7.2 B the chartering school or chartering Authority shall consider the schoolwide performance and performance of all subgroups of pupils served by the charter school and on the state indicators included in the evaluation rubrics adopted pursuant

371to statute and the performance of the charter school on the local indicators included in the evaluation rubrics adopted also from 420 64.5 so how did they do with that uh we'll get into that in a moment but I want to mention that greater weight is given to performance on measurements of academic performance and determining whether to Grant a charter renewal and then there are also some more factors to take into account which we've included in our analysis that is that the school has achieved measurable increases in academic achievement as defined by at least one year's progress for each year in school and strong post-secondary outcomes as defined by college enrollment persistence and completion rates equal to similar peers and then also verified data is used so if approved the middle performing Charter uh schools that

372are in that category they get a renewal term of five years not five to seven so High-Tech high has nine schools as we mentioned one school was identified in the high tier and the other eight are in the middle performing category and so accordingly we are recommending a fiveyear renewal term for the charter school as we mentioned previously so on the measurements of academic academic performance engagement conditions and climate uh they outperform Statewide averages on all seven State indicators that includes Ela math English learner progress indicators college career chronic absenteeism graduation rate and suspension rate and then on the verified data the charter school reported administering the measurement measures of academic Pro progress or map assessment that's developed by Northwest valuation Association and they are an SBE approved source of verified data as you know

373and they measured they did this to over five 95% of their students administered it since fall 2021 over the course of the 2023 24 school year the Charter School's average result was within the one- year's progress range recommended by nwaa also their postsecondary outcomes are demonstrated by verified data that includes college going rate data gathered from data Quest and that's an SB approved source of verified data the Charter School's college going rate exceeds countywide and Statewide outcomes both schoolwide and for socioeconomically disadvantage AG students the charter school student groups college going rates are above Statewide levels so it's a solid performance uh to demonstrate a a recommendation basis for Renewal we also do a fiscal analysis and we reviewed their three-year budget we find that their financial plan is reasonable we look at their enrollment

374and their projected enrollment and their stability and they're all within uh reasonable projections by our estimation then as I mentioned we do a very comprehensive review of their 15 Charter elements per statute 47605 C and that is included as I mentioned in attachment one the technical amendments uh in the plan for English Learners the charter schools renewal petition mentions a home language survey be administered Upon A students's enrollment to the Charter School technically the requirement is that it's given upon on a student's first enrollment in any California public school this is like I said very minor very common we recommend that that language is just changed slightly and then more more consequentially is the designation of chartering Authority so if they if you uh Grant the renewal of the charter you have the statutory language

375of 47605 point9 C that state board shall designate in consultation with with the petitioner the governing board of the school district or County Board of Education in which the Charter School is located as a chartering Authority now like I mentioned it's it's most complicated one that's come up for a while so upon review of its renewal petition the charter school or submission excuse me the charter school requested the San Diego County Board of Education and uh as required by that statute state board staff consulted with the charter school and the charter school reaffirmed its preference for the San Diego County as its authorizer if it's if if the county is to be the chartering Authority the charter school will qualify as a countywide charter pursuant to Ed code 47605 6 and as a Statewide benefit

376Charter the charter school situated in four districts as I mentioned and so we had to do a little bit more in-depth analysis in this one than we normally do usually we just have a line that says agree with the recommendation or I don't think we've ever disagreed but we we put a line in now we have more in here because we looked at a couple of different configurations as I mentioned all nine schools are combined into a K12 countywide Charter is one option the other is a four District level split where all three North North Count's uh campus schools are San Marcus unified the Mesa are San Diego high-tech Elementary Chula Vista would become a K5 Charter School under Chula Vista elementaries authorization and high-tech middle Chula Vista and High-Tech high Chula Vista would be

377combined into a grade six through 12 Charter School under with the a district being Sweetwater Union High so it's it's a quite more in depth is we have um taken a look at several areas to see if there is any unforeseen negative consequences to sort of bring that forward in our recommendation and support you in making a a good sound decision on that so we've looked at areas of governments operations and facilities and we found that there may be some benefits in terms of Greater efficiency in program cohesion if we go with the San Diego County recommendation like the school wants and it becomes a countywide charter um it's it's hard to know but there may be some additional administrative burdens on the charter school if it's split CDE also looked at a fiscal analysis

378and uh it's limited to an ongoing formula based program analysis so uh this went through our school fiscal Services Division and they found a negligible difference about 4% of total annual funding with what they could estimate in fiscal impact upon the charter school if renewed between the alternate options of Delegation and a negligible impact from the shift from being a Statewide benefit Charter School to either a countywide benefit charter school or multiple locally authorized charter schools so that was an important consideration is anything going to be coming up that would be harmful and uh something that would be under consideration and the answer is no under past history with the California State Board of Education authorization this the High-Tech high has been with the State Board as you know for a long time uh since

379its establishment it's operated well uh we have done oversight every year and there was one year in 2020 we issued a letter of concern as a result of low projected fund balance for the Charter School's newest School high-tech Elementary Mesa this is as you see the Year this was is a challenging time but as detailed in the fiscal analysis above fiscal concern was resolved there are no concerns outstanding uh regarding the charter school and we have found over in its current term that the CDE uh sees compliance with its Charter and the memorandum of understanding between the state board and the charter school so in conclusion the CDE recommends that the State Board approve the charter schools renewal a term of five years from 20225 to 2030 with the two technical amendments that we mentioned

380and that you designate San Diego County as the charter schools chartering Authority effective July 1st 2025 if you have any questions um I am here and there are also um the school has a presentation to give next thank you hold on questions for now and I'm actually going to uh restate the beginning of the public hearing yes yep for Hightech high are we doing that I I have that scheduled to have to come after all right but isn't High i g have to put their slides up okay so do you want the public comments slide okay I am now going to actually officially open the hearing which starts at the point where we hear from the petitioners and so it is 3:17 pm. and the hearing will officially start uh and we'll hear from the

381petitioner Hightech High we'll have up to 10 minutes to make their presentation uh and then we will open open up the phone line for public comment from individuals who are not part of the presentation so hi takai you may begin when this good afternoon president darling Hammond vice president GL woods and our state board members my name is Dr Diana Coro Sanchez and I'm proudly serving as the interim CEO at High-Tech high on behalf of our schools we would like to extend our sincere appreciation to the CDE and the state board for our collaboration and partnership over the past 20 years as an organization we are committed to changing the educational landscape in this country you have played a major role in supporting us in this Vision we thank you for the commitment dialogue mentorship

382and the trust that you have instilled in US throughout the year we are proudly an organization that is diverse by Design the beauty in our schools are our students coming from all over the county different walks of life with one Miss to be empowered Learners together the demographic of our schools closely match those of San Diego County and our district teacher preparation programs as well as our M's programs from our High-Tech high Graduate School of Education serve teachers across the county and in some cases across the state our strong collaboration with the state has influenced our request to transition our 9 SBE schools to a single countywide Charter our nine sve schools cover the San Diego County region from the south all the way to the north with each School serving students from all over

383the county with such diverse populations in these regions our collaboration with the County Office of Education have proven to be a huge support for our organization we truly believe that being under one authorizer is what is best for us and our students as it will allow us to provide a coherent approach from this map you can see the incredible Regional diversity that our students serve that our schools serve the circle size is determined by the number of students we have in that area our SBC schools are currently made up of a population in which 53% identify as latinx 2 24.2% white and 2.4% black 52.3% are socioeconomically disadvantaged and in addition 16.4% of our students are neurodiverse in 2007 ourc sites at heai North County and heai chil Vista first open fast forward to today

384we have nine schools across San Diego County under our Statewide benefit Charter we have been transforming student and adult learning by integrating students linking hands and minds and connecting school and Community we are are able to accomplish this through our design principles of equity personalization authentic work and collaborative design we what makes our school so unique are that our students have demonstrated that project-based learning can translate to exceptional outcomes as recently highlighted by David Brooks in the Atlantic based on recent updates eight out of nine of our schools were identified by the CDE to be in the middle performing category of the California school dashboard and one of our schools in the high performing category with one recently named a California distinguished school as a first generation college graduate myself I am thrilled to share

385these results with you all our SBC schools in 2024 graduated 100% of their seniors 93% of them applied to a four-year college and 92% of them achieved acceptance to a 4-year College I would love to recognize some of the members that first entered Hightech Elementary Chile Vista as the first group of kindergarten students when they first opened and graduated as the class of 2024 from left to right we have Katya Fernandez who is attending San Diego State University majoring in early childhood development and special education she dreams of becoming a teacher at Hightech High Andre Inda is also attending San Diego State University majoring in Business Administration and accounting Zuri California is attending UC San Cruz studying public and environmental health and Sienna belan is attending Columbia University she is interested in a career in

386advocacy each day we show up for our students and Community constantly evolving to provide the best education we value feedback from our stakeholders and are committed to continuous Improvement our current priorities include math literacy CTE dual enrollment food and nutrition and reducing absenteeism and susp itions in math and the science of reading by build we do so by building teacher confidence through professional development and data driven practices leading to noticeable growth as career Pathways gain importance we're increasing CTE credentials and course offerings we've also expanded college courses with over 250 students enrolled while maintaining internships for all Juniors and seniors additionally we're grateful for the state's free meals programs as we have enhanced meal quality with the opening of our scratch kitchen boosting participation by 55% over the past 2 years chronic absenteeism has dropped

387significantly from 27% to 14% with elementary schools seeing the biggest Improvement we are also seeing a reduction in suspensions down to 2.1% thanks to restorative practices and strong Community Support Hightech High ensures strong financial stability through a Diversified funding model and sound fiscal management study student enrollment supports consistent funding from state and local governments while grants and donations from private foundations corporations and individual donors bolster extracurricular programs and school needs known for operational efficiency high-tech highi effectively manages Staffing facilities and administrative costs without compromizing educational standards the organization also strategically maintains real estate assets to support long-term growth with financial reserves and contingency plans in place Hightech high is prepared for unexpected challenges ensuring continued delivery to of innovative and high quality education we are so grateful for our families who show up consistently to

388student like conferences presentations of learning and exhibitions and all of their support in our field experiences today we have the honor of having Courtney baliski a parent at Hightech Elementary chil Vista with us thank you so much Diana and good afternoon president darling Hammond and esteemed board members my name is Courtney baliski and I'm honored to be here today as a parent and volunteer from Hightech Elementary Chula Vista I'm here to share about wow moments for me wow moments are with an exclamation and an awe from witnessing learning experiences driven by our school's Mission I first encoun owned High-Tech high as a nonprofit leader I agreed to take on a full-time student intern for a month wow was the feeling when I interviewed interested Juniors they blew me away discussing college and career goals and

389projects that got National recognition I went on to support interns for many years all the while considering what if my own kids could have this experience fast forward wow to now what a wonder that my kiddos Maxim and Nora are on their learning Journeys at high-tech Elementary as Fifth and second graders as a parent volunteer I see the intention effort and compassion the team dedicates to students wow to their projects that explore our complex and dynamic world for example learning teamwork by studying colonies of ants or contemplating underrepresented voices in the Revolutionary War and debating if liberty and justice have truly been achieved for all in our country it's a joy to be a part of our High-Tech high community and wow I can't wait to see what comes next I am convinced that we

390have the absolute best students with that said it is with great privilege and honor that I introduce Mila Davidson third grader at high-tech Elementary Jula Vista sorry North County good afternoon president darling Hammond vice president Glover woods and state board members thank you for the opportunity to speak with you this morning my name is Mila Davidson and I'm currently a third grade student at high-tech Elementary North County there are so many things I love about my school but today I want to focus on the projects and how I've learned through them one of my favorites was my second grade spring project where we performed the Three Piggy Opera the essential question of this project was can anyone be a good Storyteller to prepare for the exhibition which is our performance of the Three Piggy Opera

391in front of a live audience we had lots of practice with Reading Writing and other key skills we also got to attend Frozen Junior to more learn more about plays and how they work this project taught me many things but most importantly for me I learned the importance of being able to work well with others to accomplish a goal I was able to answer the essential question of this project for myself over the summer as I began writing my first book called the dragons of peace that I hope to publish at some point in the future another one that comes to mind is my last third grade project we were learning about the biodiversity of our world and the importance preserving out our local natural resources we also learned about animals adaptations and habitats we

392then participated in field work at the safari park where we got to observe animals that we researched when I think about my school I always feel like I belong and can see that my teachers really care about us my school gives me a lot of joy and opportunities to learn in a way that is interesting that means a lot to me again my name is MAA Davidson and thank you for the opportunity to share with you thank you so much stop that if you can um I think we now want to open the phone line for public comment so we'll put the slide up for public comment members of the public wishing to provide public comment can call in and uh use the phone number and participant access code on this slide do we have

393any comment in the room hello we have six individuals in the room they can line up with a microphone thank you Cassie manini Regina chagoya Lorraine Richards Angela stal Erica I'm sorry Eric primac and Dedra Walsh good afternoon my name is Cassie manini and I'm here on behalf of the California School Employees Association CA would strongly urge the SB to designate the local school districts as the authorizers for the High-Tech high schools the legislature and the courts are clear on this question statute requires that Charter Schools must have a reasonable justification as to why they could not be established by petition to a local school district nowhere in the report on this item um is an analysis or even a statement of that justification instead the report notes that the charter school might benefit from

394the efficiency of remaining a single charter school with a single Charter authorizer I can think of dozens of CMOS who would love nothing more to than to have their Charter Schools combined under one authorizer for the sake of efficiency but that's just not a factor the legislature considered when drafting these laws in fact a California court of appeals has ruled that a countywide charter petition should not be granted simply because it's more convenient or cheaper for the CMO to propose a single-wide county countywide Charter instead of multiple District level Charters thank you hi my name is Regina choya a Elementary uh teacher of berklyn Unified School District I'm also a school board member for Emille Unified School District I'm here representing CFT a union of Educators and classified professionals the Axiom of this board and

395the building across the street is local control cft's position is to give control of these charter schools to the respective school districts where it should have been all along when one looks at the grossly oversized reserves for each school that the current authorizer has not addressed perhaps the requisite school districts can ensure that these Charter Schools spend current year um reserves on current current year students moving forward thank you good afternoon members of the State Board of Education I'm D Walsh director of charter schools for San Diego Unified School District here speaking on behalf of the district regarding the renewal of High-Tech high San Diego unified is one of the local districts whose boundaries the SBE authorized high-tech schools operate within we support the renewal of this Charter but request that the local districts rather

396than the county be designated as the chartering authorities as outlined in our letter the charter schools act clearly demonstrates a statutory preference for Local District authorization and strictly limits the criteria under which a new countywide petition should be considered to only when pupes cannot be served as well by District authorized Charter Schools San Diego unified has had a positive relationship with High-Tech high for over 25 years as the authorizer of seven of their schools and this clearly demonstrates that their high that their programs can successfully operate under local authorization local authorization benefits students and families by creating a more cohesive educational Community it's not uncommon for families to have siblings enrolled in both Charter and district schools these families are part of our district communities and we have a vested interest in their success your

397time is up okay thank you uh good afternoon Eric primac with the charter schools development Center in support of both recommendations to renew as well as to delegate the oversight to the county office we've worked with a ton of schools and um and allowing you to work with a single authorizer particularly when you're going through uh kind of an unknown transition like this from state board to local status uh we think is a considerable benefit that will not only reduce administrative costs but uh at a time of transition and enable them to focus better on on serving their students so notwithstanding our respect for San Diego unified and the other uh districts um we think it is best to go forward with the recommendation in front of you thank you good afternoon I'm Angela steagle

398a classroom teacher representing the California Teachers Association while we support the renewal petition for High-Tech high we urge the State Board to assign oversight of the nine High-Tech high Statewide benefit charter schools to the local school districts where they are located assigning the County Office of Education as the authorizer would result in Vital Information tied to each school's individual CDs codes being lost parents families and communities would lose critical information currently available to them at the school site level if the nine HTH Statewide benefit charter schools are combined under one countywide charter this includes information on demographics enrollment facilities conditions credentialing and teacher preparation and placement pupil academic outcomes graduation rates and Dropout rates average class size available support staff and counselor ratios expenditures on teacher salary and other important data for these reasons we

399strongly urge the State Board to designate the local school districts thank you hello I'm Lorraine Richards c um classroom teacher from CTA um we urge a state board to designate the local school districts where the nine High-Tech high Statewide benefit charter schools are located as the authorizers Education Code favors local authorization and local authorization is in the best interest of students parents Educators and the local community all four local districts authorizers have notified San Diego County that they are interested in serving as authorizers of the schools located within their District boundaries it is not unusual for Charter School operators to have multiple District authorizers in fact with seven High-Tech high schools currently authorized by the San Diego Unified School District they have functioned just fine with more than one authorizer authorization of a countywide charter

400should be a very rare exception to the local authorization High-Tech high schools would not otherwise qualify as a countywide benefit Charter thank you we have callers on the phone there are two callers in the queue I will open the phone line now um caller with the last four digits 7288 you are now live please start your public comment you have one minute thank you good afternoon president darling hamand and the esteemed board my name is Matthew Chapman the North County Campus holds a unique place in my family's heart in 2022 and 23 my two oldest graduated from Hightech North County had norn paths towards Pomona College and Cal Poly Hult my youngest is currently enrolled in fifth grade at the high-tech Elementary North County School while I'm a a proud sixth grade teacher here in

401North County in the middle school as we've emerged from under the scars of a pandemic we have grown stronger and more united as a community I cannot emphasize enough how proud I am of our faculty parents and especially students seeking a charter renewal can be fought with apprehension and yet our North County Campus is the opposite we are so excited to move into the next phase of our Charter while there's been debate upon which organization we should be authorized through North County faculty have steadfast and unanimously expressed their wish like the CDA to be authorized through the San Diego County of Education thanks for your time today thank you uh next caller with the last four digits 2671 you are now live please start your public comment you have one minute hello my name is

402Patricia Davis and I am both a parent and a chemistry teacher here at High-Tech high in Chula Vista my journey with High-Tech high began when my child joined as an inaugural second grader in 2011 and I have seen firsthand how our unique village community Fosters collaboration across our elementary middle and high schools he is now a junior at UC Santa Barbara we have events and projects that bring together students and families from all three schools promoting an interconnected learning environment I am thrilled with the CDE recommendation to move us to the county as our sole authorizer this will allow us to continue thriving as a cohesive Community dividing us among local districts would disrupt the Synergy and I urge the board to keep our schools together under a single authorizer for the benefit of both

403our students and our families thank you very much thank you um that concludes public comment for item number um 15 all right thank you very much um so we've uh there is not a um statement from another party uh so we're going to close the uh public hearing and no more public comments at 3:38 PM I will begin board discussion I'd like to ask our liaison vice president Glover woods and member Oaken if they would like to make a few comments first U thanks to everyone who provided presentation and public comment and uh I would just frame my comments by saying we have a very unique situation in front of us uh with the last existing state uh benefit Charter um that is here um I think we can we've heard from public comment and

404from the presentations there's not a concern around renewal so I know that is one part of the action that we have but uh we have further discussion regarding the chartering Authority and again I just kind of lift up the unique situation we have in front of us we have an existing Charter that has been operating under a single authorizer as far as the state benefit schools are concerned and we I think it's important for us to keep that in mind as we uh engage in our discussion thank you um I I also want to thank everybody who presented and um we've been really lucky to have students throughout the day today um so I want to thank you for your awesome public or being part of the presentation um and um I I wanted to

405just take a second to not jump over the first part of this which is um we do have two decisions to make one is whether um to renew and then the second is um assuming we if if we do choose to renew who to delegate authority to and um I think it's an important thing in the life of these schools to celebrate their um success with students their commitment to public education broadly um the work they do to um um support professional development of teachers both in their schools and Beyond um really serve as a model of what um Project based learning can look like um and as a result they their students are really thriving um and I just I want to take a minute to celebrate that um and put that out there

406as a um an exciting moment for the schools and then the second piece um is the second question before us about the delegating of authority and I do want to just concur with vice president Glover Woods that um this is a very distinct situation um it is it is not a precedent Setter because there 's only one um Statewide benefit Charter um this is it um and the law that was when the law changed um repealing the state board's right to or ability to be an authorizer it specifically said um that we have that we we have the ability to delegate to either the county or the local districts um that's the that's the statute in in question today um not some of what else we heard um but yeah just pointing out this is

407this is truly a one of situation um and so I I hope we think about that as we as we go forward all right thank you very much uh treat this as two motions the first motion around renewing the charter and then the second around the delegation to um the oversight body so do I have a motion on the first part member vice president GL Woods second member Rodriguez okay thank you um go ahead and state I I just wanted to state that um I move that we approve the renewal for the High-Tech high Charter per the CDE recommendation on renewal of the charter all right thank you you want to call the role member Clawson yes president darling Hammond member of scab yes vice president GL Woods Yes Lewis yes M mcquillin I'm stating

408I see member McQuillan's hand up and a thumb up I'm taking that as an affirmative uh member Olen yes member Rosco Gonzalez yes member pillo brownson yes member Rodriguez yes member Yosh moturi yes the motion carries unanimously uh and then uh we would need a second motion about the um designation of the oversight body um do we have a we have a question before we get to that okay okay um do you want to ask the question you can make the motion a second open it for discussion and then vote you you know at that point we say any further discussion I mean we can discuss it now if you want to also okay so we have a point of discussion here and one there perhaps okay member gr Rosco Gonzalez please okay yes I

409motion for discussion I have a question actually um is that can I just go into it is that okay thank you you don't you don't need a motion for that thank you I just um I have actually a question a clarification uh question regarding the given the potential impact of the consolidating the oversight under a country uh countywide Charter I just need um could they provide more further clarification on how the CDE plans to ensure that the key data such as the demographics academic outcomes teacher credentials enrollment statistics currently available at the school level for the High-Tech high schools will remain accessible to parents families and local communities if oversight is delegated to the County Office of Education good afternoon you probably didn't think you'd see me again today uh it will not be a

410two-hour response I promise um Cindy kazanis uh the director of the analysis measurement and accountability reporting Division and we've been asked to support the Charter School Division on on this item uh one of the things that happens when you collapse nine schools is you lose the identity of those nine schools so you would potentially see one sarc for those schools you'd see One dashboard you would not be able to distinguish how one um site in their um uh you know their new school their new County um they don't have the terminology down like you all do but um would you know have a distinct identity so this is something that we had been asked to be prepared to comment on you could um uh ask for that I mean again this is not a precedent

411setting activity this is the one and only um such Charter can we ask that there be a sarc um uh can we vote for there to be such a um division of data by school yeah I think part of that begins with you know what um kind of uh code they are issued when they um reconstitute themselves or we you all reconstitute them um the department would need to continue to receive data with those individual site information so this quasi quasi school in order to be able to put out something like um what we put out for the sarks or putting out a dashboard um right so I think those are considerations that um we've been definitely throwing around there's not an easy answer to it because we don't have situations like this anywhere else

412in the state right all right thank you very much and um vice president Glover woods and then member Oaken thank you and and thank you member Orosco Gonzalez for bringing that up because that was a concern that I had uh that data would be lost um if they were Consolidated under one where the individual data that the schools are now receiving is not available to the families in the the public as it should be um I I had a another question question as it related to um I I just wanted to ask a clarifying question um and Craig you might need to come back up um my understanding from the information we received through the um public comment letters that one of the cons districts being considered as an authorizer indicated that they were not

413able to take on the special education responsibility for the students um am I accurate in that I recall reading that and in a letter from one of the districts I just wanted to ensure that that was an accurate statement yes that's my that's my recollection uh we did get a number of letters and um so this is a consideration I think to include in any um questions that relate to the the details what I would say getting into the weeds of why the school is requesting the county the school is also prepared to come up here and drill down a little bit on some of those type of issues if you need some more information um member oen I was I was actually hoping maybe to ask Cindy to come back up if you don't

414mind I'm sorry just to clarify a little bit um thank you I know you've had a long day we get both of you I got p in case she all right thank you well so so my I just want to make sure again that I understand so um as a Statewide benefit Charter or author being authorized by the state they the nine schools currently have nine different C CDs codes and so well they have they each have their own dashboard we'll just keep it simple and their own School data okay excellent and that is not the way currently that is not the way that countywide um schools they if you're at if you're countywide there's one code okay great so I think I heard but I just want to make sure I it was it

415I understood correctly that um if we were to delegate the the schools if we were to delegate to the county and we did nothing different than what normally happens the both the school communities and the state would we would lose the ability to look at school data individually correct because you've collapsed it into to one school okay so if we did that's if we did nothing unusual um I think I also heard that perhaps depending on how we code it and we look at it it would be possible to maintain that school level information recognizing that this is solely this is not precedent setting because it is the one and only situation we will encounter with a Statewide a state authorized Charter needing to switch its delegation basically so so I I think part part

416of what when I went back to my seat Kim yeah reminded me that there like we started this conversation talking about the school accountability report card yeah I don't know that that you actually that that could be done that's not something we've talked with legal counsel about we were talking more about um dashboard and the collection of data to be able to see um you know insights into these sites um but you know we yeah okay and and and we as a board I think would re I mean I think I mean I'll speak for myself for a second as a as somebody who had um more than one School charter school we really needed to be able to see the data at each School distinctly um because the what was um students progress and

417our school um Effectiveness looked different at the two schools um so um to me it makes entire educational sense to um to proceed with the recommendation from CDE to um delegate to the county if we can also at the same time direct your team to figure out how we can maintain as much school level data as possible [Music] um because I think that's actually really important as well yeah sorted um any other questions or comments because we do have a motion about to be made yes you know in listening to you I think Sharon's actually a thought process was um interesting and helpful because I just think how in our Ed code we emphasize so much the importance of local control and I believe it's in the best interest of our students our parents and

418communities involved um all four local districts have expressed their willingness to serve as the authorizer for these schools in the areas and um they seem to be uh functioning well with multiple District authorizers already so I authorizers no okay so it's just one right now I just I'm I'm I'm just concerned over losing data and information for our community and I think that um I'm not really sure if the CDE can desegregate that data for our community so I I have a lot of concerns around not providing um all stakeholders the information for each individual because you like you're right some schools perform a certain way and other schools don't and as a whole uh we can't uh desegregate that information and see thece President GL Woods you want to make a comment I I

419do thank you thank you very much just a couple of points of clarification and again I'm I'm I'm right there with you and I think I'm right there with you too um so just a just a couple of points of clarification I think and again the uniqueness of this particular um decision that's before us uh one the state authorized Charter that we have um right now Hightech High has San Diego unified with the schools that it authorizes and then the state authorized the other nine schools so in a sense the charter had two authorizers and what's before us now is to have them become countywide uh authorized County authorized Charter or to delegate to the local for four districts that are there and I I'll will point out too for uh High-Tech high Chula Vista

420I believe there were two districts that would actually be authorizers for High-Tech high Chula Vista because they have Chula Vista Elementary School District as one district and Sweetwater as the second so again we have some nuances here and it's not it's not lost on me how essential it is to have local authorizers um and I I definitely understand that again I think we have a very unique situation and in in considering if we were to designate the county as authorizer I would also um like to direct CDE to work directly with High-Tech high Charter to maintain the individuality however that whatever that needs to look look like I I'm not going to try to get into the weeds separate CDs codes if if that's how it has to be done but anything that's necessary to

421maintain the individual data of each of those nine schools uh because again we don't want to lose that uh and the last part again just to bring back to um the Forefront is that with this particular Charter this is very different from a brand new Charter that might try to uh receive an authorization as the county Charter this is a an existing Charter that's been existing for a number of years and I think it's important um to the degree possible that we maintain continuity for the families and the students at those schools and um try to maintain um the structure that they have been familiar with up to this point all right thank you member did you want to say anything you were nodding just just nodding I was just um taking in vice president

422Glover Woods Wisdom okay thank you all right I think we've had a lot of wisdom at the table um the CDE did recommend that this be a countywide that this go to the county for um uh operate for oversight um we have received information that that is U allowable thing to do and so uh we just need to see if we are going to vote that up or down do we have a motion okay all right do I have a second okay we can let me get the second then we can have further discussion okay um Sharon were you about to second I thought I thought you were about to say something I'm sorry I could second it although I would like to make a slight Amendment to the motion so I can SE no

423I'm not wait to the second why don't you raise your comment I shouldn't second have motion with separate um reporting for each school all right I'll I'll I'll amend my motion Amendment Sharon does that capture your question too and I would like to amend the motion uh one to follow C's recommendation and ensure that uh CDE will work with the county to of with the county and the charter right because they'll they'll have that to ensure that the data by each school is um shared as has been done previously do we have a second we have a second and a third all right uh okay fine um yeah all right I think we've had discussion on the motion so all in favor uh let's do the rooll member Clawson yes president darling Hammond yes member

424escabedo yes vice president glev Woods yes M Lewis yes member mcquillin I member Olin yes M Rosco Gonzalez no member till brownson yes member Rodriguez no member yosha motari yes motion carries all right thank you very much uh moving on to um reopening item one uh we are going to reopen item one to take action on the preliminary report of actions draft November 2024 meeting minutes and to report on our liaison assignments uh and so are there any speakers signed up to Prov provide public comment in person on the um preliminary report of actions from November 2024 all right and as I I'm hearing no answer to that so I assume the answer is no and is is there anyone signed up on and there's I need the phone line um slide thank you if

425anyone wants to make public comment on our preliminary report of actions from November 2024 here is the number uh for the phone and participant access code on this slide now we'll ask again just to be sure is there any public comment in the room on this item all right is there any public comment on the phone there are no callers in the queue all right thank you very much um at this point uh I'm going to ask if there's a motion is there a motion on this adoption of the draft actions and minutes yes one motion to approve member patilo Branson seconds call the rooll member Clawson yes president darling Hammond yes member escabel yes vice president CL Woods yes member Lewis yes member mcquillin yes member Olen yes M Rosco Gonzalez yes member Patel

426brownson yes yes M Rodriguez yes Yoshi motion carries unanimously great thank you um we are now going to give our liaz on reports uh and this is to report on items that are not related to any items on our January agenda and we'll start with the reverse alphabetical order U member yoshimoto tari would you prefer the other end of the alphabet Dr yoshimoto T yes remember doctor I just want I I'll be brief today I just wanted to share that the um the California serves program the grant has um the applications are due January 27th for anybody interested in service learning this it's up to $500,000 per year for leas and it could pay for professional development for teachers or paid planning time to increase Service Learning instruction materials Etc so please look on uh

427the California service learning brand uh website for for that um and uh I'm that's it for today thank you um I have a couple of updates uh one the uh regarding CTE and our quap jack work uh the California Workforce Pathways joint advisory committee is a joint advisory uh body that makes recommendations to the State Board of Education and the Board of Governors of the California community colleges regarding Career and Technical education programs and Workforce Pathways the committee held a meeting on November 25th 2024 at which time we've reviewed critical updates in including the final presentation on the California plan for uh Career Technical education by jobs for the future additionally members engaged in discussions on the uh C the uh CTE incentive Grant data metrics focusing on identifying opportunities for regional alignment and Analysis

428the quap Jack staff are working to finalize our next meeting which we anticipate will be scheduled for a date in March 2025 um CAG the request for applications RFA uh round 10B of the uh CTE incentive Grant was released on January 9th applications are due on Friday January 24th CDE plans to post the preliminary allocations on February 3rd and next moving on as the SB Lea on to the CTC I can say that the agency is hard at work advancing and Reporting on a myriad of critical topics including several that were discussed and acted upon in December uh literacy instruction to teacher candidates accreditation performance assessment in the Statewide residency technical assistance center which uh last year supported over 150 existing or prospective teachers and counseling residency programs throughout the state in addition to these

429topics I'd particularly like to highlight new educator Workforce data dashboards commission staff a aimed to publish later this month Budget Trailer bill in 2023 directed The CTC to take a more expansive look at educator assignments and staff have been hard at work to create dashboards on educator preparation and assignments so um I think you will uh be interested at seeing seeing those uh as they come out and lastly um I would like to uh say goodbye to a giant tree that has fallen uh Professor Lee scholman of Stanford University uh a Visionary a friend a mentor uh he was 86 years old and he passed away a little uh before the new years's and um he was the uh when I think of um national board he was the first national board president Board of

430President and a lot of his work the um uh I can't even think now thinking about him pdk uh you know his work with uh what what you know and what you can do as a teacher um and his advocacy for teaching is a profession uh his work uh has influenced many of us and uh may his memory be a blessing Pilla Branson um I am going to um actually not do an update on any of the Lis on assignments and actually just um use this as an opportunity to say thank you to the school leaders throughout LA County uh who have been doing heroic work alongside firefighters and have been in fact fighting all sorts of their own battles um to make sure that there's as much normaly as possible for the students uh

431and staff uh schools across LA County I think uh we've all seen lots of the headlines um community ating fire and I think many of us uh for for just a point of fact have now experienced wildfires with some regularity in various parts um across our state and this is very different um I think at one point um after many thousand uh Acres had been burned across the Pasadena eaten fire and Palisades fire there were also four additional fires that sparked and kept popping up um so I the the easiest way that I can think of is I had a conversation with a colleague who lost her home which is I think intense enough um and then she learned that her child lost her elementary school and then they learned that they lost their local

432library and their local parks and wreck uh so I I think um we have to think about what it means when we are asking at the very minimum minimum what it means to be safe and what it means to be okay and the first order I think is absolutely safety and shelter and I think we we have to uh think about what the rebuilding process looks like for um students in directly affected areas as well as students who will be having um secondary effects of either lost in come from no longer working in the businesses in there even in those neighborhoods even if they did not actually live in either Pasadena or the Palisades um and I I flag this not to uh to depress depress us all so much as to say that we

433have to be cognizant of what it takes to rebuild uh and how thoughtful and how many resources we have um in place in terms of thinking about learning recovery lessons learned from covid online instruction uh but also Community Schools um and what it means to think about all of the social emotional supports that kids families and school leaders are going to need uh in not just the short- term but over the long term too thank you so much um member Rosco Gonzalez well I have some updates um my item was for consent but I just wanted to update you on some of the updates for the Casp and Alpac student score reports I'm excited to share that some updates proposed such as simplifying the information one of the updates removes redundant text from the cast

434reports making them more clear and easier to navigate for younger students in kindergarten through second grade the updated descriptions for the written language skills on the Alpac reports are tailored to better reflect um what's developmentally appropriate for age group and I think that's huge improving usability a small but helpful addition is a resource link explaining ex uh writing extended response results in the cast reports which will help families and Educators better understand these reports another Improvement involves adding a blank page to combine reports to making printing smoother for schools this is very simple but thoughtful as a teacher who has to duplicate these uh listening to feedback these changes are based on input from focus groups which included parents teachers and earlier stateboard discussions that we had about being more inclusive about having stakeholder voice

435it's great to see the level of collaboration ensuring that all the reports truly meet the needs of those who rely on them um another update about the achievement level descriptor labels um I want to highlight that the ongoing work around the achievement level descriptor labels it's uh great to see more focused groups happening this month to hear from parents parents Educators and students and their input is so important I'm looking forward to seeing how it shapes our discussions in March to make sure that these updates work well for everyone involved that concludes my report thank you member oen thank you um actually all my lay on areas were mentioned one way or another today so no report member mcquillin all right thank you uh brief report on the Statewide model curriculum project as we started

436the report last in the last meeting the Orange County uh Department of Education has developed the 3 K12 model curricula on Cambodia American American studies Mong history and cultural studies in the Vietnamese American experiences all three are available on the dedicated platform that was designed and built by the California history science project at UC Davis I would urge you to check them out they're really nice uh lessons that are now available Orange County Department of Ed is now working with their Partners to do rollout activities on the Statewide curriculum this week uh Vietnamese American experiences uh is is going on in San Diego this week Cambodia American studies in Santa Clara uh is rolling out and doing some training this this week um at the end of this month I'm sorry and the Mong history

437and cultural studies is uh is going to have a roll out training in mered next month and uh I would urge you to take a look at these lessons they're very nice on the Native American studies model curriculum um that curriculum is still under development by the two County offices of education at Humbolt and San Diego County the curriculum will be completed uh and posted online by September 2025 um the committee met uh in December and heard updates on the latest drafts and the next steps in the revision process multiple video videos art pieces photos already created by native peoples have have been licensed and integrated throughout the lesson plans between the two County offices of Education the proposed curriculum will feature hundreds of lessons professional development resources and teaching resources these lessons will be

438incorporated into science math art music Health literature and ethnic studies subject areas uh additional information is available on the model curriculum projects web web page on at the California Department of Education website so thank you I think we can be very proud of the work going on in uh developing these units and curriculum thank you that was really good news that those are finally coming coming out it's been a process we appreciate your uh participation in that um member Lewis okay thank you I'll give a report on our the iqc of the instructional quality commission uh at the November meeting the iqc their main focus was on the upcoming 2025 mathematics inst Structural Materials adoption uh they first reviewed an overview of the adoption process and timeline which you can find posted on the cde's

439mathematics adoption significant events web page uh the maatic subject matter committee then reviewed the cde's recommendation for the instructional material reviewers and the content review experts and the application period for these uh two groups was through April from April to September of 2024 and the CDE received nearly 200 applications for these two positions uh the mathematics subject matter committee approved the cde's recommendations and in turn recommended them to the State Board of Education which was on our consent uh one of our consent items today the Commissioners also heard an informal presentation on the Southeast Asian model curriculum that member McCullum just spoke about which was posted online last fall the CDE uh update included an overview of the these projects and the online platform along with an update of the rollout activities the iqc will

440meet again this month on January the 29th and the 30th and this will be of course the first meeting of the year and it'll take place uh over the two days and day one is mainly a orientation uh session which will include uh review of the roles and responsibilities the oath of office for any new Commissioners uh review of the protocols and processes and there will also be a determination of the subject matter committee presid references uh day two is will be more of a business meeting with the election uh of the new chair the vice chair and the executive committee members and appointments and elections will Al also take place for the subject matter committee uh excuse me uh Committee Member assignments there will also be several action items on the January agenda which

441will include an approval of the iqc meeting dates for 25 and 26 the approval of the 2025 iqc goals and also the approval of the newly created personal finance subject matter committee and the purpose of this committee will be to review and make recommendations as we heard today from Dr Torres for the 2026 personal finance curriculum guide which will be based on those principles which we approved today um on our as an act action item finally uh the iqc on day two will hear an overview and updates on the California preschool transitional kindergarten learning foundations presented collaboratively by the cde's curriculum Frameworks and instructional resource Division and the Early Education uh division uh for my my next liaison assignment is the California sub subject matter project which I wasn't able to attend that meeting because

442it's scheduled for today that concludes my report all right thank you um uh before I go into my quick update on the CCE I just wanted to kind of piggyback off of what member patella Bronson said and uh just to again keeping in our minds and our hearts and prayers the families and community that communities that are have been impacted by the wildfires and um just very thankful for our governor our state board of education staff as well as CDE staff that's been really working to provide support and resources and um I just en encourage us to keep in mind that long after this leaves the news and uh no there's no more conversation and maybe even after things are starting to be rebuilt this impact is going to be there forever in the lives

443of families and children and so to as we can Marshall resources to wrap around our children and our families in the long term um I think it'll be greatly beneficial and for those schools that are receiving new students as a result of what has happened um My Hope and prayer is that there'll be some proactive support for those students as they come into those schools um so that they feel welcome in their new environment um and just again support for the families as well so to the leaz on report um CCE continues to be busy and continues to support um throughout our state in some phenomenal ways I just wanted you to know that there's 43 Statewide initiatives that CCE is um supporting and working over and that encompasses both legislative assigned responsibilities as well

444as supports that um leas have asked for and marshalling together resources and supports and networks and all of those different things that help our students in schools um I also wanted to share before for our next board meeting the community engagement initiative will meet at the end of February they'll be convening in Ontario for two days there'll be well over a thousand uh members of from different schools and uh parents School staff and the like that will participate in that Community engagement initiative and uh to in conclusion to kind of link to our accountability plan conversation and support um in the March CCE meeting there'll be conversation around the um direct technical assistant needs of Lea's um CCE is supporting in that area of um differentiated assistance and direct technical assistance many leas throughout our

445state and the governing board will have a chance to get an update on how that work is going how schools are being and districts and rather are being supported and uh what the needs continue to be that concludes my report um member escabedo yes I was a able to attend the the rails meeting in December and it was a great event they highlighted The Muse project in that project they they have a they introduced a California practitioners guide for educating English Learners with disability and they presented three Pathways to classify students with disabilities well done amazing scenarios it was not just step by step but they projected real life scenarios and how to reclassify students so um it's you know it's a lot of professional development that has to be done but I I was

446very very impressed with that project and I think we'll have a significant enhancement in how we um you know we support English Learners that that have disabilities um also my report with nasby uh pleas review uh in January a newsletter that highlights California and their work with the community schools and um also there in pins and needles with the new Administration more definitely more news uh to come within the next few weeks once once that transition happens but um you know it it's uh I I believe there's also I think the next uh session I think is in Austin the next annual conference in Austin I'll let you know more information on when that takes place I'm part of the committee for that annual conference so I'll be asking you for any thoughts on what

447should be highlighted in the conference for 2025 thank you great um member Clawson thank you um before I jump into my liaison reports I would like to highlight um a incredible opportunity I had after our last meeting um I was able to uh participate in a convening about smartphone policies with the governor and the first partner uh to discuss legislation regarding cell phone restrictions and how to best Implement these policies across the state I would like to thank the governor the first partner and also our board's executive director for including me um in this discussion I was h to represent the Statewide student body and share some of the nuances that I believe are important to consider and since the convening I've continue to work with different student groups to learn about successful implementation strategies

448and how students can be included in decision-making processes um I I would also like to emphasize that these policies um for for my fellow students out there that policies are far less about restricting cell phones and far more about prioritizing learning um member mcquillin touched on the model curriculum but I will just briefly say that I had the opportunity for my first time to provide feedback on the latest draft of the Native American studies um the humbled and San Diego County offices of Education um are hard at work to wrap up that development uh by September and I really enjoyed getting to see the art and listen to oral histories from native communities um and I look forward to you know the completion of that curriculum uh and for when it will be made available

449to all students um and then also as a liazon to the California Association of student councils I'm happy to report that yesterday they concluded the student Advisory board on legislation in education I hear it was very successful um as students from across the state work together to present proposals um similar to what to the ones they brought to the board but this time to the legislature I also look forward to continuing to work with nasby their High School Transformation Network um with collaborating from other State student board members from across the nation and then finally I also would like to acknowledge the immense loss in Los Angeles um our my thoughts are with the communities of students and Educators and families um we know that our schools are much more than places of learning they

450are sanctuaries they are places of community um so the loss of these schools and community centers and homes and businesses is devastating after speaking with students who have lost their schools I have seen the resilience and strength of the student body California um and one of their first responses is how can I help how can I help my neighbor um which is a model for us all and then I've have continued to grow the official student board member social media where I've been utilizing it to share resources for affected communities regarding access to meals clothing transportation and wellness and Mental Health Resources um and of course thank you to our state officials Community leaders um and First Responders everywhere and then on a happier note I would like to congratulate new board members um from

451across the state who've been sworn in or starting terms in December and January particularly new student board members from across the state and that concludes my report and president Don I would just say um as Mary and I got to experience member Clawson I think was by all accounts the star of the show at the convening uh as I'm sure will surprise nobody but she fantastic and I'll excuse me I'm just having a dry throat at the moment so I won't make a long report but I will just note that um on the topic that U member scabo was bringing up about reclassifying uh English Learners um our special education students uh we did an analysis at the learning policy Institute of the who are our are long-term English Learners and 30% are also in

452special education and so this question about how to understand both how to identify and support and then reclassify uh those students is a really important one and one that I hope we learn a lot more about and we're able to spread that information um everything else I've been involved in has been talked about I think in one way or another today so I am going to uh move us forward to uh agenda item 16 general public comment which is invited on any matter not included on the printed agenda is this and if you're wanting to call in for general public comment the uh phone number is on the slide that is posted here along with the access code is there anyone in the room who would like to make General Public comment there is not

453um we do have one caller in the queue though all right then we will go to that caller okay um call with the last four digits 4691 you are now live please start your public comment you have one minute thank you good afternoon president darling Hammond and members this is Carlos masado with California school boards Association we appreciate the state board's goal of improving the usefulness of the student score reports for students and their families as the State Board looks ahead at updating the descriptors and labels we urge you to carefully evaluate whether any changes proposed to these items will enhance and promote better understanding of student scores to achieve the greatest level of utility from the report for students and their families it is important that labels and descriptores do not unintentionally OB obfuscate

454or otherwise make it harder to interpret the significance of the scores and ident identify the interventions that the scores May signal are needed we appreciate the State Board taking more time to get feedback from the field and explore options other than those considered earlier csba looks forward to working with you and staff on improving the student score reports thank you thank you and it looks like we have one more um caller with the last four digits 5546 you are now live please start your public comment you have one minute thank you my name is Michelle buer I am a Sacramento native in a California public school teacher for the past 25 years I come to you um via this phone call um to let you know that I have reorganized and reformatted the public information

455presented by your Agency on Ed data and it clearly shows California public schools are hoarding billions of taxpayer dollars in their coffers I believe the dangerous practice occurs only because stakeholders are in the dark they're focused on projections and budgets rather than actual Financial patterns that include all government funds and assets like Surplus property I have posted the information on my website budgets bone.com and I ask you to look for yourself the 2023 state government funds ending total balance by counties for the state total more than 88 billion taxpayer dollars in the 2023 State uh government fund thank you colie your time is up thank you uh that concludes public comment for item number 16 all right thank you very much uh hearing no more comment I hereby adjourn our January 2025 meeting at 4:30

456p.m thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.