CorpusRecord 41053

PCS Board of Education Meeting: February 12, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Petaluma City Schools
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Sonoma County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
15,522 words · about 87 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001All right. You ready for me, Dave? I'm going to reconvene our meeting at 6.02. And Trustee Paun will lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance. And we have no… report on action taken in closed session because we did not take any action in closed session. So we'll move on to special recognitions reports and presentations, starting with our site report from Carpe Diem and Sonoma Mountain. Is that you guys? Awesome. Hello, my name is Bo Keefe and I'm a senior at Sonoma Mountain High School. This is my third year attending SOMO after starting at the beginning of my sophomore year in 2022. After my projected graduation in June, I will be pursuing a career as an electrician. Here are some of the things we've been up to at Carpe Diem and Sonoma Mountain High School since

002we last presented to the board in January. Last June, we held our Alternative Education graduation ceremony on the Casa Grande football field for the fourth consecutive year. Both Carpe, Diem and Sonoma Mountain participated along with graduates from San Antonio and Valley Oaks. Diverse and inspirational stories were shared. The alt-ed ceremony is truly unique graduation and I hope all those who have not attended get a chance to at some point. In August, we once again started with a welcome week for all students at both schools. On the first day, both schools gathered at the Phoenix Theater for a traditional dual school opening day where we practiced in community building activities led by our teachers, including a walk to Oak Hill Park. And a paper airplane building contest. As always, we'd like to thank Tom Gaffey for

003allowing us free use of the theater. If you haven't been to the Phoenix, you should check it out. It certainly stands out as a special Petaluma landmark. Both schools have undergone a number of changes this year. Most notably, we have a new full-time principal, Mr. Morey. And a new science and art teacher, Dr. Rivers. Our first full-time science teacher in two years. They have brought decades of classroom experience to our school. Carpe Diem started the year with 19 students. They've had seven graduates thus far and currently have 19 students enrolled for the spring semester. They have five seniors and one junior expected to graduate in June. Sonoma Mountain started the year with 22 students and we've had three graduates so far. We still have 22 students with three projected graduates, including myself, one of which

004is a junior. It is also worth noting that amongst our small student population, we have students from all four grade levels and all five other high school programs. Phs, CGHS. Valley Oaks, Valley Oaks Online, and San Antonio High School, as well as three freshmen who started at SOMO this year straight from middle school, including my brother Luke This highlights the diversity of our students educational backgrounds and experiences which brought them here. One of the draws of attending our school is that we have the opportunity to participate in activities and events at the bigger high schools, including senior activities, sports. Clubs and electives. Sonoma Mountain has two students currently co-enrolled, one in robotics and one in culinary. As well as five students enrolled in clubs and one student planning on participating in sports in the spring.

005At Carpe Diem, we just graduated a student who was on the baseball team, as well as having another student planning on playing sports and multiple student clubs. In class, we have been very busy. In English, we have studied the beat generation and have now moved on to a unit focused on global sustainability and waste. History has included a deep dive into the social movements of the 1960s, including a three-week-long research essay where we explored one of the events or groups in detail. Such as the Black Panther Party. Occupation of Alcatraz and the Stonewall Uprising. In science, we have completed two separate student-led research projects units testing hypotheses, and math has kept us busy with a blend of math one and two concepts. In our electives, we have enjoyed old favorites like basketball and PE while

006also trying new stuff out in art, including our current stop-motion projects. Which we will be wrapping up with a movie night at our school within the next few weeks. We also go on hikes several times per semester. Hikes this year include our opening hike at Tennessee Valley Beach in Mill Valley, a trip to China Camp in San Rafael, and the trip to the Academy of Science in San Francisco. These trips help us help These trips help show us many riches afforded to us in the area, as well as help build community and expose students to the various recreational and vocational outdoors locations. That we enjoy in this area. Staff is busy planning more trips for the spring semester, including one that was planned for this Friday but had to be canceled due to rain. Seven

007students have also participated in the farms program with Dr. Rivers. The students, along with teachers and students from surrounding areas, visited local farms and agricultural facilities The goal is to gain better understanding of the local agriculture practices being utilized right here in Sonoma County. Our other traditions include the return of our welcome back senior breakfast in August, where seniors cook breakfast for the school as well as our fall break feast. At both schools before the break in November. Students brought plates and turkey was provided by staff. We convened again the day before winter break where we ate together with ham and tri-tip provided by Mr. Anderson. And exchange gifts. We also have maintained community circles on Wednesdays, which provides other ways to build community and work through things that come up throughout the school year.

008These are important traditions, new and old, for establishing the inclusive family atmosphere that we pride ourselves on at our small school sites. Lastly, I'd like to say a few words about my school. First of all, it is a friendly, welcoming environment. Before SOMO, I had issues with personal conflicts and other students that prevented me from learning and often stopped me from coming to school. Here, it is easier to get work done with less distractions. Work is accessible but challenging. Teachers are always nearby and easy to get help from on a one-to-one basis. I feel that I could work at a pace that works for me and is a school that you actually want to show up to. I feel like I know the teachers well and there is a mutual respect. I'm very grateful that

009I had the chance to start here when I was 15. Thank you for your time and for your continued support for our small alternative schools. Very nice. Thank you so much for coming and presenting to us and everything y'all have been up to. Tennessee Valley is like my favorite hike in the North Bay. So I'm glad you all got to Do that. Any questions or comments from anybody? Yeah. I just want to say one of the highlights was watching his parents or supporters, guardians here as he was presenting. That was like a highlight for me just watching how proud they were of him. So cheers to you guys for being here. Thank you. All right, we're moving on to comments from the public on special recognition reports, presentations, and non-agendized items. So if you have

010any public comment on anything not on the agenda or on the wonderful report we just had, now would be your time. I'm going to read. The part about public comment really quickly while we're here. I don't know how quickly. Under government code section 54954, members of the public have the right to address the governing board on any items of interest, providing it relates to the subject matter jurisdiction of the school district. While government code allows speakers to criticize the district's policies, procedures, programs, services, and or employees, the district does have a policy specific to complaints against employees. Should comments from the public pertain to a specific district employee, the board requests that the complaint first be submitted in writing to the employee's immediate supervisor for investigation. If the comment is about something not on the

011agenda, it will be heard only during the public comment on non-agendized items, period. That is right now. Once that part of the meeting is over, comments will only be taken on agenda items during discussion of those items. We value public comment and although we cannot take action or discuss items not on the agenda, we do listen carefully and appreciate input from the public. Public comments are subject to a three minute per person limit or a 20 minute limit per subject matter. Commenters may not cede their time to others. So if you have a public comment on anything not on the agenda, please bring your card up to the wonderful Bree. And she will bring the card over to me and I will make sure we call on you. And if you have public comment on

012something on the agenda, still, please bring your card up to Bree and we will get to your public comment when it is. That time. But seeing none and seeing no one rushing the stage, I'm going to move on. Well, maybe. Nope. Yeah, that's for on the agenda and later. Yeah. All right. So we'll move on to adoption and approval of the agenda. Can I ask, before I hear a motion, will someone move We want to do the staff report about the budget reduction before public comment because I think it might quell a lot of concern. So can someone move comments after it can still be before we discuss as a board but So that would be item 19 before item 18. All right, so motion to approve the agenda with the uh edit that item

01319 goes for item 18. Second. All right. All in favor of approving the agenda as amended, please say aye. Hi. Any opposed? All right. Now we are… on reports on activities and correspondence of school board members. So since our last meeting, trustees attended Casa Grande basketball games, the Sonoma County Office of Education Trustee Recognition Dinner. The NAACP's Community Center's grand opening, a Safe Routes to School Mid-Year Check-In at Petaluma Junior. Meetings with the superintendent and office hours at McNair Elementary, Penn Grove, McKinley Pax. Kennewith Junior High and Valley Vista. Do any of the adult trustees have anything they want to say about any of these? Events. All right. And then next up we have report on activities and correspondence of student board members who are equally busy Actually, their paragraph is longer, so… I think

014they might have been busier. Student board members attended Petaluma High's Club Rush, a Petaluma High girls soccer game, the Petaluma High girls basketball senior night. Petaluma High PTSA meeting, the Petaluma High Sweethearts Dance, and Trojans quarterly practices National Honor Society meetings at Casa Grande, senior nights for Casa girls basketball and Casa girls soccer. And at CASA, the Positivity Project has spoken to about half of the freshman class at CASA about mental health and substance abuse and looks forward to educating the next half next week. As our only student trustee here tonight, do you have anything you want to share about any of that? What's the Positive Project? That's Ava's. That's Ava's um club so I think it's like mental health awareness. The students. All right. Now we'll move on to a public hearing and I

015get to use the gavel again. I'm officially opening the public hearing for the naming of the new public Waldorf School to be located at the campus of Valley Vista, now is the time for any public comments on this matter. I'm going to check and check. None of what I have right now is that. So if you have any public comment on the naming of the charter school at Valley Vista, now's your time to bring a card up. I'll wait, I promise. All right, I'm going to call Becky up and you'll have three minutes. I'll wait for Dave to get the stuff started. So this is kind of spontaneous. I'm not actually here for this. However, my daughter did attend Valley Vista last year and We just had the idea of Valley Oak. Which is kind

016of a blend of both names and also a treasured local native book tree. That the Pomo people used as a LifeSource with their acorns. So just sharing that idea. Thank you so much. We have a school called Valley Oaks already so that Yeah. No, I had that thought too. It was a yeah um Thank you. All right. Any other… public comment about that. If not, I will gavel again very officially. To close the public hearing. We'll have a good gavel. And we'll move on to this action item under ed services, approval of the name. For the Waldorf charter school to be located on the campus of Valley Vista I move to approve. Can I get a second? A second. All right. Can we get a presentation and a little more? Information? Yes, I'm excited to

017invite jamie and Linda, up to present. Some background information on the process and how they got to this name and turn it over to to Jamie to take us away. Good evening. I'm Jamie Bushman. I'm the current principal here at Valley Vista. Thank you. And I want to introduce you to Linda. Go ahead. Hi there, Linda Delgado, current Executive Director at Live Oak Charter School. And we are excited to share with you the process that we've been going through for the Last little bit. Okay, so the timeline, these are wonderful data across the bottom of the slide, but I have to tell you that in every case. It has been expanded. For example, from 14 tours, we're now up to 16. 3 EL tours for English language learners, 28 staff meetings is now 30. 15

018community events. Two staff trips plus one. And 45. Is that 45? Yeah, 45 parent square messages and counting. And we're now up to 446 applications. So not too much happening. In talking about the renaming process, we really wanted to take some time and get considering this as a community event, one of the pieces that we shared is that although we're creating the school and thinking about the students that we currently have and love. That this is also a Undertaking as we're thinking about the school that will serve generations to come. So community input was really important to us we had two big nights that were very well attended by Well, it was about 100 people in the Valley Vista multi on night one and night two. And then on the third night, we had a

019committee together to really narrow down and get our suggestion, which we're bringing to you today. So among the groups that made the final decision, we had three from representing Valley Vista. We had three representing live oak We had one district administrator And we'd like to thank our facilitators, BABS, Kavanaugh and Luann for coming out. All right, so the process really we started with back at like night two, we started with some small groups to build consensus and then slowly grew those groups, build a consensus each time. So starting with like a group of eight, building up to 16 and on and on from there. For the final naming selection, we had About four top contenders at the end of night two. And our committee came together and it was really a beautiful night, I have

020to say the conversation, the honesty, the listening from all sides. It was just a moment. I don't know, for me as like someone who's been on this journey for a while, there was a healing piece of it to like get to come together and really finally come to this decision. So we had a whole voting process for them as we narrowed it down. Until we came to two front runners. And finally, building consensus on just one. No, I think we need a drum roll. Yes. Excellent. The winner is? Valley Vista Public Waldor. Yeah, yes, let's do that. Yes. No, just to thank everybody for giving us this opportunity. We're really excited to partner with the district and looking forward to the years ahead. Yeah, Anna, thanks again to all of our committee members who were

021brave enough to take that space to be kind of in the deciding circle. I think, you know, this started out as a really hot topic item And through this process and this conversation and these brave members willing to take on the task There's been ease about it. I think like a little like breathing space now that the decision's done. So we appreciate all the time of Parents who came out, the students who were involved in some of these conversations And our facilitators. Amazing. Thank you all. And thank you to all the committee members and everyone that was a part of that process. Are there any questions or comments from any of the trustees? Yeah, I think it's a beautiful merging of the two. And keeps Valley Vista's legacy. Going on because that's what we heard

022so much from the community is how much they love Valley Vista and how much Valley Vista has meant to them. So that name. Getting to live on in that way will still owning and incorporating the owning wonderful Waldorf aspect that and how it's a public Waldorf and how important that is in our community. It's really great. So the motion is on the table. I'm going to call the question all in favor of approving the name. Bye. Bye. Any opposed? Hearing none, we have our new name. Congratulations. And now we'll move on to comments from the public on consent agenda items. So these are any items under number 15. Please bring up a blue sheet. If you haven't already, if you have anything for the consent agenda. All right, seeing none, we'll move on to approval

023of the consent agenda by consolidated motion. Do I hear a motion? I move to approve. A second. All right. Now that it's on the table, are there any comments or questions from any trustees about anything on are really short consult agenda i like a I like a short little bit. It's the usual suspects. All right, I'll call the question. All in favor of approving the consent agenda, please say aye. Aye. Any posts? Hearing none, the consent agenda passes. So I'll move on to comments from the public on action items. So if you have Public comment on any of the items under action items, which is number 17. Again, please bring up one of these Fun little blue cards to Bree or Luann and they will get it over to me. Right now, none of the

024cards I have are on. Those items. Seeing no one rushing the stage, I will move on to action items, starting with approval of resolution 2425-30. About needed credentials and certificates to be skipped in the layoff process. Do I hear a motion? Sorry, Caitlin, can I have a point of order? Can we have a presentation on the items first and then move to a motion? So I think we just call the item and then staff can present and then we can perfect cool I'll call the first one up and can we get a presentation? Yeah, so this first resolution, we bring these versions of this resolution for it every year and that preparation for our layoffs And it just identifies that there are certain positions and credentials that are more critical and that those positions would

025be skipped in the layoff process With regards to seniority. I move to approve. I'll second. Any comments or questions on this? Resolution. All right, I'll call the question all in favor. Any opposed? Hearing none, Resolution 2425-30 passes Moving on to resolution 2425-31. Anything from staff to add to that that is markedly super different. No, you read this. This is just so that we can state how we will identify if people have the same seniority date, how to break those ties and and Determine order for if there are layoffs for certificated positions. Great. Any questions or comments? A motion to approve. All in favor of passing resolution 2425-31, please say aye. All right, that resolution also passes and we will move on to approval of resolution 2425-32. All right, Jason, give it to tell us what

026this one's about. So earlier this year earlier this year, we approved the calendar for next school year. And that calendar took some federal holidays and moved them. So we're celebrating them on a different date. So this resolution talks specifically about admission day being moved to with Thanksgiving to give our families a bigger Thanksgiving holiday. And this is another one we do every year pretty much. I've never celebrated admission day on the day that it was intended to be celebrated on so Can I hear a motion? I move to approve. Second. All in favor of resolution 2425-32. Bye. Any posts. Hearing none resolution 2425-32 passes. Moving on to resolution 2425-33. Jason, tell us. How about this one? So just like the previous one, this one is like the previous one Where we've moved Lincoln's the celebration

027of Lincoln's holiday. So the President's Day and Lincoln's holiday are together. And it's part of that week-long midwinter break that we pair, which we're going into next week that we pair it with our emergency closure days. Any questions or comments on that one? A motion to approve. All in favor of approving Resolution 2425-33? Please say aye. Aye. Any post? Hearing none, Resolution 2425-33 passes and we will move on to approval of assignments outside of credential area. Can you tell us about this one as well? So this is the final one of one that we do every year. We tried to put a lot of information in the description because it is somewhat complicated, but We do have a number of teaching positions that teachers are Are holding that might be outside of their credential area,

028but we determine as a district and as a board that they have expertise that warrants that. And so this is the process to approve that, which is We're just following the guidelines that we're supposed to follow to approve those. And if you looked in the packet, there were a couple of different categories that they would fall in. This is pretty, we do this every year with a large number of our assignments because we have some different programs that require some some alternative ways to staff them. And to be clear for the folks watching at home, these are all credentialed teachers. They're all credentialed teachers and Yes, they are. Perfect. Any questions or comments? If not, do I hear a motion? One second. All in favor of approving assignments outside of credential area, please say aye.

029Aye. Any opposed? Hearing none, we've approved the assignments outside of the credential area and we'll move on to ed services with our overnight field trip requests. Tony, what do you… What do you want to tell us about these field trip requests? Yeah, these are All the elementary are pretty much the annual field trips that they take every year. And then the other one was um the math the world mass competition where in the event that they do qualify, they want to be ahead of it and prepare for that. That trip. I know that we've had conversations around the forms and we are currently updating them and hopefully we'll be able to finalize them but without trying to hold up some of these field trips that have just, you know, that they submit every year, we

030didn't want to hold these up but We do plan to do plan to to review the new kind of form to address some of the challenges and concerns we've had in previous meetings. Any questions or comments about any of the field trips? All right, do I hear a motion? I move to approve. I'll second. All in favor of approving the overnight field trip request, please say aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Hearing none. We've passed or approved the overnight field trip request and we'll move on to business services review of bond management RFP slash Q. Amanda, I think this is all you. Yes, thank you. Tonight we bring forward a draft of an RFP queue for a request for call of qualifications for a bond program management services for the implementation of measures A, A, and

031Z. There are numerous reasons why staff recommends that we go with a program manager for our new bond. The reasons include hiring bond management firm eliminates long-term salary benefits and pension costs associated with additional full-time staff. A professional firm provides specialized expertise in bond management programs. Ensuring efficient planning, execution, and oversight. The firm brings experience in compliance, reducing legal risks and ensuring adherence to state and federal requirements. External management firms have established processes to prevent cost overruns, delays, mismanagement of funds. A dedicated firm provides scalable resources adjusting staffing levels as needed without overburdening the district's payroll. So we pay for what we need at any given year that we need it. Firms are known to streamline communication and coordination between contractors, architects, and district stakeholders, outsourcing management allows the district to focus on our primary

032mission, which is education. While the experts handle construction complexities. And this helps with voter confidence in the bond program. It is reinforced through structured oversight, regular reporting, and transparent financial tracking. Any questions or comments on the RFQ or the RFQ process? It makes a lot of sense. To me And I assume the dates will be added into the document once this would be approved. Yes. So this will still be approved as a draft so we can make those final changes and we will have legal review it one final time before we put it out. The goal is to Have this out in spring and bring back a qualified firm to the board in early April, which will help us with implementation. Of the new bonds. Great. That's faster than I thought it would be. Any

033questions? What have we previously done for the other bonds that have been passed for the school district? Prior to the 2014 bonds, the district did work with a program manager And then at the implementation at some point with the 2014 bonds a couple years in. That firm, the district decided to no longer work with them and it was managed in-house by the CBO and the Capital Facilities Construction Manager. All right. Do I hear a motion? All in favor, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed? And then the bond management RFP slash Q draft passes and we'll move on to student services. With the approval of comprehensive school safety plan. So Esmeralda, can you tell us a little bit about This is a whole. Sure. So annually we bring our comprehensive school safety plans. And so per

034ed code, we are required to develop a plan on an annual basis at each one of our campuses. So what you have included here are each school's plan with redacted portions that are specific to technical procedures at the school site, the school's emergency plan with those incident command, emergency plans, in addition to all of the education code board policy that's required. So you may have seen it in three parts. That's at the beginning. With the emergency plans second, and then each school also has a culture and climate plan. So we're bringing forth those plans for each one of our school sites tonight for your approval. All right. Does anyone have any comments or questions on the plans as a whole or in any individual plans? I have a question about the CASA plan. So it

035mentions North Bay Security a few times, but only in the realm of emergency preparedness. But as a parent, I got an email that North Bay was going to be on site more. But it went into more detail about ensuring the presence of security representative on our campuses each day. And rotating across campuses, serving as an additional trusted adult presence. For our students. And then it talked about this being a proactive measure as part of safety protocol, but I don't see that. In the safety plan. Yes, so excellent question. So North Bay has been our consultant in terms of developing our safety plans. And training staff. That started in the 23-24 school year. Mid-year, we brought forth a proposal for increasing a contract with That was in December, I believe. And we brought that forth to

036have a daily presence with one North Bay security Security consultant. And so that started mid-year. And so it's a district plan or approach. And so our safety plans, many of our safety plans were approved by site council prior to that being instituted. And so that is a measure that we're putting forth there. They have a presence at all of our secondary campuses, checking in with all of our site administrators. And then also checking in with our elementary sites and they are supporting us in a variety of ways, not only being a consultant for any kind of issue that arises where determining do we need to also call law enforcement? How do we approach this? As well as helping us with Residency verifications, as well as chronic absenteeism. And so we've had situations where actually we've

037had an increase in our students actually coming back to school with having that check-in and supporting and having that follow through Between the school and our North Bay representative. And so it's a pilot. That is, we'll go through the end of this school year and then we'll evaluate it and see if we will continue. So it's in addition to the contract that we had with them and they were just training our staff And this is an additional presence on the campuses every day with one security. What is residency verification? So, for example, if we've had situations where we've had someone maybe put down a residence that may not be where they actually live and they may need an introductory transfer and so going out to do a home visit and making sure, and if not

038making sure that we have the correct Forms and paperwork so that we can support and have accuracy with our attendance. And North Bay is doing this? Because I don't know if I feel comfortable with them. I would feel more comfortable with like one of our staff people doing that Yeah, because they sound like the police. Just like, you know, and we're not supposed to be doing that. That's why that gives me some pause. It's like an officer shows up to verify your residence. Yeah. So thank you for clarifying that. But then they said something about like being a trusted adult. What is that? And in the event so they're trained in restorative practices, de-escalation techniques. So there's Our administrators take the lead with any kind of discipline. They're not in the realm of disciplining any

039students. But if there is mentoring or supports, checking in with a student that may need that kind of support, but not in the realm of any kind of discipline follow-up or any kind of referral process. That is all managed by our administrators. Who determines what residencies need to approved or disproved. That would be my that that would be if it came to my attention And we had any reason that someone was providing a residence that actually they were not residing at and they resided outside of our district. And then what about the chronic absenteeism? How are they helping with that? So if we have a student that isn't attending school and they're a no-show for many, many, many days. Maybe not responding to phone calls, they can make a quick call and say, hey, is

040everything okay? We'd love to see you at school. And we've had cases, for example, where students actually then begin showing up and are like, this is, you know, great. Thanks for making the visit. But it's uh sort of like that wellness check And we'd love to see you at school. Okay. Okay. I don't know how I feel about that. So maybe that's something we can revisit. We can talk about that for like future business because Like when I looked on their website, they look like the police. So like, I mean, I don't know how comfortable I feel with them. Like Ellen was asking a really good question about them going to people's homes and then like making calls for chronic absenteeism. I guess I would want to know what type of training that they've had

041and like what they're saying to families. Certainly. Certainly. Yeah. And just to emphasize it's a pilot. It's just something we're doing till the end of the year. It's something we're looking at and I think as we looked at fall and the needs that were occurring at our school sites and situations that we had on our campuses, having an additional security consultant We thought would be very beneficial. And so, but again, it's something that we're evaluating and we can certainly come back and discuss this more. Okay, thank you. Yeah. Yeah, I would definitely agree talking more about it in the future because if it's like an armed person coming to check. I mean, I'm sure they're not, but it's just the the feeling of a uniformed Person coming to check on your attendance versus more of

042a social worker feeling i mean CPS has its own issues too, but it's a little different than a cop showing up at your door. Yeah, definitely meant to be supportive. But yes, absolutely. Any other questions on any of the safety Yes, school safety plans. All right. Do I hear a motion? I move to approve. I second. All in favor of approving the 2425 comprehensive school safety plans, please say aye. Hi. Any opposed? All right, the safety plans have been approved And now this is the part where we moved the agenda around a little bit. So we'll go to the discussion information items and really quickly, can we go over the board meeting dates for 25-26? Great. Thank you so much. So what we have tonight is up for just discussion. To look at the board

043meeting dates for our coming school year. A couple of things I want to, a couple of thoughts to share with the trustees I would just ask for you to confirm or just offer up, is there a better day for the trustees? We have a new trustee on the board. Do Tuesdays still work for everyone? Is there a different day, which probably would have to be a Wednesday, a Tuesday or Wednesday. You really can't do Monday, Thursday, or Friday. So there may be a recommendation there And the second item that I would just put out there for your consideration is just considering having one board meeting a month and perhaps a second on the calendar for a study session if that is the pleasure of the board. Instead of doing two board meetings a month. And

044that may be something that you're not interested in doing. You want to stay with two board meetings a month and Of course, we're super respectful of that so I just leave it to the board to discuss what your recommendations might be and We can bring back a calendar for your approval at the next board meeting. Anyone have questions or At this point, I'm at this point I like Tuesdays. It's been six years. Tuesdays are But I wouldn't be opposed to changing to Wednesdays. I just wouldn't want to do Mondays because city council meets on Mondays. That's my only thing. I wouldn't be opposed to moving to one meeting a month But I would imagine there will be plenty of times where we will need two meetings a month. With timing of all the different things

045that come out so curious to hear other folks thoughts Yeah, I mean, I would, I'm interested in moving to Wednesdays. And it's because we have several other local jurisdictions that have Tuesday meetings as well. And it just piles on top of one another. We want to make sure that we have access to the public and our constituents and to parents and teachers, making sure that they are able to attend. And so it's something that I would like to discuss and see how that would work and how that would work Also, you know, figuring out if it's the second and fourth first and third or just the third week And then as needed, we have something else, something of that sort. So I do want to see you like. What the different schedules could potentially look

046like. Although we've been meeting on Tuesdays for forever so I don't know, maybe you've heard, but I've never had anybody complain to me that there's too many meetings on Tuesdays and they can't Make this one. I've been on the board for nine years now. So I'd like to keep it on Tuesdays just because That's the way my life is planned. What other meetings are on Tuesdays? For the soups. Oh. Yeah. Well, and I guess it would be good to look at our feeder districts when they meet. Because someone might have a kid at Old Adobe and a kid at Petaluma City Schools or a kid in WA and a kid at Petaluma City Schools. Trying not to be on their nights. Yeah, I don't know if they've already been planning around us being on Tuesdays

047or not. That would be the That would be more of the other bodies I would want to take into consideration. Also, a lot of our committee meetings avoid Tuesdays as well. And that they've been set already. In fact, tomorrow's LCAP. So, which is a Wednesday. So… that would require a pretty big shift to really imagine when we'd have committee meetings and all that other stuff. So thank you for your feedback. With that being said, I think then I'd be interested in seeing if there are a couple of meetings that traditionally we could move around four study sessions and kind of have like more study sessions set onto the schedule. But knowing that like during budget we have these are important like in February and January are probably important to have two meetings but um else

048Sometimes else in the year where we maybe want to remove one or a meeting off the schedule. Is the Board of Supervisors once what is the date on that in general is it's let's not. Okay, I was just curious about that In general, we've had the second Tuesday and the fourth Tuesday of the month So maybe I could connect with our board president and just kind of look at a draft calendar based on this conversation tonight and see if we could bring something back for discussion or approval at the next board meeting. That's okay with the trustees. Yeah. Great. One thing about having Only one a month is only one a month there'd be presentation upon presentation upon presentation upon presentation Not to mention students of the month. It would make for a really Crowded

049calendar. For just once a month. Sure. I do like the idea, though, if we like, let's just say, for example, like October only had one and then reserve the other one for like a special meeting. And then maybe did the same for like March or May, just had one. And then so that way we don't have to schedule like a third meeting potentially in March, but just know that there is a placeholder because I feel like we always have such a hard time trying to find like The date for a special session so I like that idea. Yeah. Great. So I'll work with you and with Trustee Quinn and just come up with a calendar. Okay, great. Thank you for the feedback. Sounds good. All right. Moving on, let's have our presentation on recommendations for

050budget reduction and then I will take trustee questions on the presentation, but then I do want to get to public comment before we like move into too much. Wholehearted discussion. Great. Thank you. I want to start this conversation by just acknowledging the fact that anytime we have to do budget reductions. In the 15 years that I've been a superintendent. It's difficult conversation. It's a hard conversation. And a lot of this is driven by a lot of different factors that come into play. Looking at how we keep our budget balanced so that we don't go into deficit spending. So we could look to see how we want to use our resources to support our labor partners. To look at how we can use outside funding to perhaps help us with our general fund so we're able

051to use those funds more effectively. So there's just a lot of thought that goes around this and it's a lot of emotion and it's a complicated topic. It always is. And so I just want to start with that to acknowledge that our trustees, our community. It's tough. And this is where we are. And I thank the trustees for their patience, their understanding, their communication with our community, it makes a difference. So let me go through this and then let me go through this I am going to, after I present this, I am going to ask the cabinet members to give some specific details as part of my presentation. And then, of course, come back to come back Trustee Quinn for public comment or clarifications. All righty. Our core value, our district employees are dedicated to

052student success and operate as a high performing collaborative team. And even though I haven't been in Petaluma a long time, I've been to almost every campus campus visit is tomorrow. And it's been really powerful and really wonderful. And just getting into classrooms and seeing the teaching and learning happening. It's just as this core value states. So it's been a treat for me to be here. The timeline for the work that has transpired is we have a budget advisory committee recommendations have come forward I'm going to have Amanda talk a little bit about that process. When those recommendations came to cabinet, Superintendent Harris, we've been in touch with him. Then we have a superintendent recommendation based on the budget advisory committee recommendations. The next step where we are right now is for the board to review

053and give us direction on next steps. We will come back with a resolution for a reduction in force, particular kinds of service that happens at the February 25th board meeting And then employee notifications. So that is the general timeline for our budget reduction process. And the Budget Advisory Committee I just want everyone to know and acknowledge that this was a committee that spent, they were supposed to spend just two meetings coming up with a recommendation. It took them four meetings because they did the hard work. They asked for reports, they asked for documents. They really wanted to make a recommendation that they felt confident with. And you'll see the recommendations as we move forward were based on a super majority. That's 75%. I'm looking, is it two-thirds or… two thirds, 66.6, whatever that may be.

054So two thirds is a supermajority. So we have our three PFT members, three CSEA members, a classified administrator, three principals and three parents so It was a group that really represented our constituents and so Their voice mattered to all of us in receiving this recommendation. So the recommendation is, as you have seen in I will go through these and then we'll talk a little bit more about some positions that are being covered with grant funding, but you'll see the PAC secretary, mechanic helpers, student advisors. Classified positions. Then our certificated super substitutes are visual and performing arts teacher on special assignment Our science teacher on special assignment. Certificated positions and then our management positions coordinator, principal coordinator principal for our two alternative high schools. Coordinator communication coordinator, career technical education, CTE. Are licensed marriage family therapists,

055think about that acronym. And then our coordinator, our budget coordinator. So you can also see the percentages that those different Groups are classified certificated and management represent on the budget reductions here. So as we move forward, we'll see the total budget reduction is a little bit over $2 million. We know that our LMFTs can be, there's an alternative funding source, so we are not going to They'll be reduced from the general fund, but they're coming out of restricted dollars. So we take their services to educators and to students will not be impacted. Next, we have two positions, our coordinator, principal, CSI, and coordinator Career Technical Education. Our goal for the career technical education position is to look for alternative sources of funding. In the past, we know that that position has received funding outside of

056the general fund. This year we are using general fund dollars and we're also looking at grant funding for that position. I'm checking, double checking with Amanda on that. And in terms of our coordinator principal for our alternative high schools. Carpe diem and Sonoma Mountain. We are going to host a study session that looks at our alternative education programs, and then we'll make a determination how we want to move forward with that position. But again, we're looking at alternative funding sources so that money can go back to the general fund. Once we receive those recommendations from our budget advisory committee. As a cabinet and in a cabinet in conjunction with conversations with Superintendent Harris It's been recommended that we retain the 0.6 full-time equivalent of our visual and performing arts, TOSA. And that we also keep

057our coordinator of communications. So those were two positions that we recommend that Superintendent Harris recommends. That we do not reduce. In order to make that $2 million budget number that we're looking at. We looked at additional positions to be eliminated. So we looked first at the positions that are currently still COVID funded. The first one was our COVID-funded nurse. And this was voted on by the Budget Advisory Committee. And it was voted on and they reached a majority, but they did not reach a super majority for that position. The other position that we're recommending to be eliminated is a COVID funded floater custodian. And currently that is a vacant position. And then last, we're looking at our gifted and talented identification stipends, subs, and testing fees. And that comes to about $20,000. So when you

058look at the numbers. After we make those adjustments, classified, about 25% of the reductions. Certificated 23. And management 51 so that um Those are the percentages after the superintendent's recommendation. And then again, the Stephen Covey quote, if you don't choose to do it in leadership time upfront. You do it in crisis management time down the road. And that is something we don't want to do. So that is… the overview of what we're recommending, but I'm going to also turn it over i'm going to Start with… Jason Sutter to talk about our PAC secretary and just a little bit of context there. I'm going to then have amanda talk a little bit about the process, thank you very much. And Esmeralda is going to talk about the COVID-funded nurse position. And Tony will have whatever he's

059going to say about this process. I'm going to let you all take it over. And decide how you want to start. All right. There were a couple of positions that were um at sites specifically the secretary, we had secretary position from Max McKinley and we had 1.0 combined student advisor from Pangrove and Mary Collins. And I think that those all reached a super majority and with the budget advisory committee and i think the thinking about this The group was very thoughtful about we've added a lot of positions that we think are very valuable. And so where do we look for places where we can do some reductions and make some hard choices? I know that I know that that when we looked at all the staffing across the schools, we did notice that McKinley Pax

060had 2.5 FTE in the front office where most of the other schools have 1.5 FTE in the front office. Including some schools that are very equivalent in in enrollment numbers. Mckinley Pax does have two separate schools. When we have other schools that are similar, such as McDowell that have a similar format. So I think they were weighing all those things out and looking for ways to keep the administrative support and the TOSA support at those sites. And that was my, I think, how that group got to that decision around those choices was looking at the staffing across the district and the intent to try and keep the extra support that we've added at those schools. Any questions on that particular item? Okay, thanks. Okay, I wanted to start by thanking the Budget Advisory Committee. We

061do have members in the audience and for their hard work, what they put into this. I felt the same way last year when they were tasked with the same thing. The questions that were asked, the dedication of the team and their willingness. We were originally supposed to meet two times in January For an hour to 90 minutes and we ended up with four meetings and one of those was over two hours long because they really The whole committee wanted to take the time to understand the financial picture of the district, the additional positions, not only COVID funded positions, but what positions have been added district-wide and really have the conversation at small group and large group. To deliberate. And one of the things that was apparent from the very beginning was the goal of super

062majority And it felt like at the very first voting meeting, a very large task. And I think Jason and I were like. Wow like that's that's huge. And the fact that we were able to end the last meeting where they had super majority or consensus on every position that was brought forward to superintendent and cabinet was huge. So just wanted to thank them. And know that a lot of thought. And I think there there were no questions left. Unasked, like they looked at it from every position. They asked if there were things outside of staffing that the district could eliminate and really looked at it holistically in a large picture. And as Jason said, wanted to make sure that What was being eliminated from the budget, like there was reasoning behind it and some sort

063of not equity, but because we have additional support can we reduce rather than just saying, let's take it all from this school like that was never the conversation. And we didn't have, we had many different schools involved, but we didn't have a voice for every single school and you you wouldn't even know that as part of the conversation like it was really looked at. As a district of as a whole. Okay, I'll talk about the COVID-funded nurse. The 1.0 FTE that's being recommended to be cut was an increase. Through the COVID funds, obviously. So this would take us back to our staffing model from the 1920 school year before the pandemic We are… continuing to look for funding sources, additional funding sources to potentially support the rehiring. Of the fourth nurse. And we're working with

064our labor partners to work on enhanced staffing for the day-to-day oversight, enhanced support for our medically fragile students. At our school sites. I think, you know, again, I wasn't as involved with the process, but the the process reverberates across our entire district and it impacts all of us In different ways and so i I don't envy the burden that Amanda and Jason and the committee and You know has to has to deal with and address as we look ahead of to how do we remain soluble in uh you know fiscally. And that being said, I do hope that, you know, I know their positions, but they're also people that we do our best to find ways um you know to To mitigate as much as we can and support those that have done tremendous amount

065of work And in some cases, irreplaceable, the work that they've done to move our district ahead and advances ahead. I do like, you know, want to touch base on you know the some of the reasons why we want to remain or maintain our communications coordinator We've had that position since 2016. It was a classified position up until 2022 when the position was shifted to a certificated management position to really be responsive to what was happening at our sites post-pandemic. Addressing some of the challenges with new school leaders and giving them additional mentorship and support. In addition to streamlining communications with our families and our students and our staff in a responsive, timely. Way and having someone with that kind of deep administrative experience being in the schools and leading schools really helps get the nuances

066around how those communications work on top of a lot of things that we're doing to And then retain and increase our enrollment. All seem to be important pieces that would be very challenging for us to let go of. And, you know, with our VAPA coordinator, that was a plan the committee had put together a few years ago. And to unwind that plan and to redo the whole thing again. I think would be a disservice to the arts and music that we spent so much time really trying to maintain and grow as a part of our district goals and initiatives around arts and music. All right, I'm going to get us to public comment before we ask all of the questions. I know we have burning. So I have… Six public comments right now, so everyone

067will get three minutes. Please bring up any cards. That you have if you have any Public comment cards regarding the budget reduction. We may have to do a little bit of math. To fit everybody in 20 minutes if there are more comments. Even if there's just one, I'll give everyone three minutes still. 21 versus 20 is okay. All right. So first up, we'll take Genevieve, please. Hello. I've been asked to read two statements from two nurses that are not able to do their own statements. And I'll go as fast as I can. Statement to the public city schools board of board regarding nurse reduction. Dair Superintendent Harris and Acting Superintendent Carla Mango. Members of the board and cabinet. My name I'm reading for Kristen Bianchi. I am one of the four dedicated school nurses serving

068the students of Petaluma City Schools. I am here tonight to stress how critical it is that we maintain all four of our nursing positions. I've been a school nurse for 20 years and joined PCS in 2020. When there were only three nurses at that time. I was responsible for Casa Grande, Sonoma Mountain, McDowell, McNair, and Valley Vista initially during distant learning, this was manageable. But when students return to campus. The reality became clear. Three nurses were simply not enough to meet the growing health needs of our students. The addition of the fourth nurse initially funded through COVID relief transformed our ability to provide care. It allowed me to be on site at CASA High School. Four days a week instead of just two. Casa Grande serves. 1600 to 1700 students yet before the change It

069had the same nursing coverage. As other schools with less than 800 students. That math. It doesn't add up. Being present on campus saves lives since increasingly my days at Casa Grande, I have personally responded to student overdose administrating Narcan, performing CPR. I've been part of the majority of 10 plus emergency 911 calls. Made each year. I have built relationships with students, ensuring that they get the care they need to stay in school rather than being sent home unnecessarily. The work we do as school nurses is just not about bandages and ice packs. We are frontline responders to medical crises. We are lifelines for students with chronic conditions. We are trusted adults. And if there's a question about that, we can answer that, who help keep kids healthy, safe, and learning. Reducing our team back to

070three nurses would be a dangerous step backward. The health needs of our students have only increased post-COVID, removing the fourth nurse would stretch us too thin. Putting students at risk and diminishing the care they deserve. About 15 seconds. For me? 15 seconds. All right. The decision to eliminate one full-time RN nurse from already small team of our four significantly impact the health That was fun. Anyways. I think you guys know what we're talking about. And I appreciate, Esmeralda, that you will consider rehiring. And not letting go of our nurse. Thank you. All right, Amanda, up next. Hi. All right. I'm Amanda del Benny and um I have two sons at Petaluma City Schools. And my younger son has type 1 diabetes. I also work for Petaluma City Schools. So I am the TDP, the trained

071diabetes person at Mary Collins at Cherry Valley. I love my job. I oversee the care of four students with type 1 diabetes. Three of those students are primary full assistants age students. One is an independent secondary age student. And my day is spent ensuring that they are safe. At school that their blood sugar doesn't drop during PE and they have a seizure or pass out and it becomes an emergency situation. And I am one of five TDPs in our district. There are four primary locations and one at a secondary location. And believe it or not. Not a lot of people want to sub for me. The only people who can sub for me are people who are trained to do so. And those School nurses. We have four right now, and I am here to

072wholeheartedly advocate. That you fund and keep the fourth nurse. I know budgets are hard. I can't your job. But if I'm not on campus, someone has to be there with the four students that I care for legally, ADA, someone has to be there. That means if I'm ill, that means if I go on a field trip with one of my four students. Dana Rodriguez, who oversees my school site, has to ensure those students are safe. And last year, my husband had a major surgery And I was out on leave for a month. And Nurse Dana and Nurse Monica are our fourth nurse. Shifted around their schedules. And did everything to ensure that the students at my site were safe and cared for. Pre-pandemic. We had one student in the primary grades with type 1 diabetes.

073Now in 2025, post-pandemic, we have 10. We have 17 in secondary schools. We had 14 before. Those 10 students have to have everyone or have to have someone, pardon me with them every minute managing their type one. Every minute of their school day. I'm honored that that's my job and I am honored that these people behind me support me when I can't be there. We need them. So I am urging you, I am begging you as a parent of someone with type 1 diabetes, a student with type 1 diabetes. Who trusts our district. To do the right thing and as a coworker of yours a colleague Support me, support us. And taking care of all of our students. Thank you. Thank you. All right, Monica, up next. I promise not to pass out from fear.

074Public speaking speaking is not what I signed up to do as a nurse. My name is Monica Carvalho. I'm a PCS school nurse and a parent here at PCS. I'm here tonight to express my deep concern over the proposed budget cuts to eliminate one full-time RN, a decision that jeopardizes the health and safety of all PCS students, especially those with disabilities. While this reduction aims to revert staffing to pre-COVID levels, our district's health landscape has drastically changed. The most alarming shift is the surge in type 1 diabetes or T1D. In the 2018-2019 school year, PCS had only one elementary student with T1D. Today, the number has skyrocketed to 10, reflecting a global post-COVID trend, these students require constant specialized care, and PCS is legally obligated to provide it under the Americans with Disabilities Act. Currently,

075only school nurses can substitute for RTDPs. And by the way, Amanda is the only one that did not require multiple weeks of training because she is already a parent of a child with type 1 diabetes. So her training was much more simplified. The other TDPs our lay people that we are training, that we are supporting constantly. My TDPs, I am in constant communication with all day long over phone and text. And I'm watching those students remotely, their blood sugar all day long. Even when I'm homesick because there's nobody to cover me. This year alone, I've personally covered diabetes care nearly 50 times in just the first 100 days of school. The nurse for Cherry Valley and Grant covered a similar number of days. There have been occasions when untrained staff has been left to manage

076diabetes care only with the nurse's help by phone, an incredibly unsafe situation. Even with our current four nurses Reducing staff further increases the risk for inadequate care. Legal liability and compromised student safety. We are already stretched thin. We work extra hours. We work through illness. I've had to bring my own child to school sick to administer insulin. To a student without a pump. I have had to have family, not family members, friends watch my own daughter with strep throat so I could go to school and cover diabetes care all day. So those students could attend school because there was nobody to cover my schools and students. What happens when three nurses are left to cover all five TDPs? In the past year, we've had multiple days when three or more TDPs were out at the

077same time. When a school nurse covers elementary school diabetes care, we are on site all day, which results in other sites going without a nurse. Creates care challenges for students at different sites. We have about 15 seconds requiring medical procedures such as G-tube beatings and catheterizations. How will the district manage the care gap that will be created with only three district nurses? Will students be forced to stay home? Thank you. All right. Becky. Hey there, my name is Becky and I'm the mother of a type 1 diabetes student He's in third grade. My son… When he was in first grade. The day after the masks came down and school contacted COVID, And after COVID, about three to a month later. He became a type 1 diabetic. As you've heard from these amazing nurses that are

078my LifeSource. He can't be in school without someone monitoring his blood sugar because his… insulin could actually bring him into a life-threatening situation. So… It's just baffling to me that you can find money in your budget to hire ex-police to be on every campus every day. And you can't think about real safety, which is actually having a nurse for nurses between, you know, thousands of students COVID is not over. In fact. This winter is is insane with all the illnesses going around. My idea of safety for my student, all the diabetic students, all students, asthma, all these different conditions is having trained nurses in schools not having trained ex-police. And why can't we cut communications budgets down? Why can't we actually prioritize what keeps people healthy So that's just one thing that I'm thinking about

079here as a parent. Of a kid that needs… extra support and is actually able to get that support from the American Disabilities Act. You know, it's just… It's just, you know, it puts us all in a really hard situation like honestly How can I safely send my child to school if he doesn't have someone there looking out for him. I mean, that's his legal right But if Amanda's gone. And if Dana has 2,500 students in her jurisdiction. What am I supposed to do you know like I can't send him to school. It just puts us all in a really hard place. And I know I'm not the only person Let's pray that no more children become diabetic because of COVID, but You know, we just have to look at the realities of our present situation

080and our public health situation. So I'm really hoping that we can either fund this position somehow with other funds or we can really think about where we're cutting out the support. Thanks. Thank you. And next up, Sandra. Please don't interrupt my meeting or i'll have to adjourn until there's no disruption. Please continue. Please start with me. What's a Brown Act violation? With who? No, please don't interrupt my meeting or I will adjourn. Don't tell me. You know what? We will adjourn this meeting for five minutes. I'm sorry, Sandra. I'm sorry, public. Thank you all for your patience as we tried to get a little bit of order back. I'm going to reconvene this meeting. At 6.30 and resume public comment with Sandra Larson. I'm old school. I printed mine out. I'm Sandra Larson, longtime resident

081of Petaluma. President of the Petaluma Federation of Teachers. I'm speaking tonight on behalf of the three Petalama Federation of Teachers Budget Committee members Tammy Elliott, Todd Siders, and myself. We were deeply disappointed with the cabinet and the board's apparent lack of faith in the budget committee's recommendation process. The Budget Committee was entrusted with the difficult task of making cuts to our members and staff. The process was painful but collegial. The decisions did not come easy and required many discussions and thought. Yet despite the time and the work that went into the budget committee's recommendations. We find ourselves in the same position we were in last year. One more key recommendations. Once more, key recommendations were discarded, leaving us with a sense of disappointment and frustration. We were always clear that Cabinet would make the final

082recommendation to the board. Still, we hope there would be respect for the committee's recommendations, especially those with a supermajority. We acknowledge that recommendations are not the same as fact. We understand there was no guarantee they'd be accepted. However, when a group representing the public, classified, certificated, and administrative personnel are ignored. Twice, this happened last year as well. We are left wondering what is the purpose of the committee. There was no effort made by cabinet to have a dialogue with the budget committee So that they could understand why our recommendations, so that we could understand why our recommendations were being ignored. The Budget Committee's work and recommendations are being ignored again. As a committee, we unanimously agreed that our first and foremost priority was to preserve student-facing jobs. The failure of the cabinet to uphold these

083this philosophy not only undermines trust, but also questions the accountability of PCS's funding. Pcs has repeatedly sought public funds. How can we justify this if PCS leadership continues to allocate funds for administrative positions against the will of the public and the budget committee members. On a side note, I'm glad that superintendent Harris was involved in this since he has left for his 20%, there has been zero contact with the Pedley Moth Federation of Computers. So we don't feel hurt by that as well. Thank you. Thank you. And next up, Katie Gill. All right, my name is Katie Gill. I'm a teacher at PAX and I have two students at McKinley. I'm here to talk about Nurse Monacab. One of the four PCS nurses and our full-time bilingual secretary, Ms. Carmen, which oddly is listed as

084the PAC secretary on this list of budget cuts. But she's truly our bilingual secretary for our McKinley Impact School, which is often referred to as a TK8 school. But in this sense, we're suddenly two schools and now she's up for budget cuts. Our school is 47% Spanish speaking at McKinley and 29% Spanish speaking at PAX. We are nearing 500 kids taking Carmen from our office will cause us to have 1.5 secretaries, and it'll leave us half of our day without a bilingual secretary. For a lot of our families. When we look at equity and we look at numbers, our site has more students than other sites that are now going to have more secretaries. Than us, which doesn't seem equitable. When we look at Nurse Carmen, I think, or not Nurse Carmen, Nurse monica If

085we look at our ratios of nurses, we have one nurse for every 1,766 students. And it's recommended that we should have one nurse for every 750. So taking Monica away will… be a detriment to the commitment to wellness that is also on the front page of our district website. Thank you. Thank you. And then Kathy, please. Good evening. First of all, let me just thank you for your service and I want to acknowledge the very difficult decision I know that faces you this evening. My name is Kathy Goodacre. I am the CEO for the Career Technical Education Foundation. Our organization has a deep history of supporting and partnering with Petaluma City Schools. As we work to enhance CTE programs and expand career-connected learning for your students. Over the past few years, we have partnered extensively

086with Petaluma City Schools along with two other districts through the new school model initiative. Dan Osterman, in his role as college and career pathway coordinator, has been essential to this work. Helping us redesign the secondary school experience to prioritize integrated, relevant career pathways. Our investment in these pathway models has totaled over $400,000. For PCS since 2021. Thanks to the support from the Peter E. Haas Junior Fund and Congressman Huffman. Petaluma City Schools commitment to this work aligns perfectly with the statewide CTE movement exemplified by hundreds of millions of dollars allocated through programs like your K-12 strong workforce, CTIG, CCAP, and the Golden State Pathway Program. And I know it mirrors your own LCAP priority for college and career readiness. I am deeply concerned by the prospect of this position being cut by this district. Our

087investment alone has yielded a tenfold return with over $4 million being secured for your district through aligned funding sources, all driven by Dan Osterman. It's difficult to believe that this position would not be prioritized and fully funded given these grant resources. I'm also surprised to be just learning of this possibility. As had we known that the district was not making a long-term commitment to this position, we would certainly have been available to meet with your leadership to strategize a way forward. How will this critical work? Continue. Who will manage the deliverables that are promised through these grants? Eliminating this position would be a major setback for Petaluma City Schools, especially as other districts in the county are fully committing to these integrated pathway models. Dan has been a driving force in these countywide efforts and

088recognizes a key contributor to pathway design, implementation, and employer engagement. We cannot afford to lose his vision and dedication. We cannot afford to lose the commitment of this district to career pathways Through its investment in the important people who are driving this work forward. I urge this district to reconsider this decision and ensure that Petaluma students do not fall behind as this vital work progresses across the county and the state. Thank you. Thank you. And next up, Lori. Hi, everyone. I'm going to just state that I am in opposition of two of the cuts and then I'm going to read a letter that I have sent to almost everyone in this room. But I'd like it to be available for public comment as well. So I strongly feel like the secretary position should not be

089cut. It's not a PAC secretary. It's the second secretary at McKinley. And if any one of you have been in that office, you know that they need They fully need that second secretary. Secondly, I am in opposition of cutting Nurse Monica's position. As one of four nurses at Petal Mississa City Schools. The numbers that katie… talked about the ratio will make it even more nerve-wracking for parents like me. So here's my letter that I sent. It has recently come to my attention that the district is considering cutting back on nursing staff within the PCS elementary school system. I sincerely hope. That none of you have a child with life-threatening medical needs. And if you do, I'm hopeful that your school has the nursing staff to support him or her. I would imagine none of you

090have a child with serious medical needs in the Petaluma City School elementary system, otherwise it wouldn't be a consideration to remove one of the four full-time nurses for the entire district. Our school nurse, Monica, serves three elementary schools on different school schedules and is constantly in demand with both on-site needs and with phone calls coming in from the other two schools. I see her in action. She's amazing. She is capable, and she is very, very busy. My son Will was diagnosed with type 1 diabetes on June 14th, 2023. And because of the incredible and consistent nursing staff at McKinley, along with an aide, and he's on his Third aid right now. He is able to stay medically safe and in school each day. As the situation stands, I know Monica has her hands full at

091all times and it makes my stomach drop to think we could have a situation next year where a nurse is split between even more than three schools. Will is thriving at McKinley. In large part due to Monica's consistency knowledge of his condition. Her relationship with his teachers and with all of the staff on site at school. I've been a parent within Petaluma City Schools for 11 years, and I've spent a good deal of time volunteering on campus. Each time I volunteer, I check in at the office. At every school I've been a part of, Cherry Valley, McKinley, Pax, Petaluma High, and Kenworth. I cannot imagine how any school secretary is able to get his Her or his test completed. Last month, I went to Valley Vista to pick up the art box. I had a

092short conversation with the amazing secretary that's also in this room. And within five minutes, a kiddo was in the office crying from an incident during recess. She was pulled away from her job. There was no nurse on site. Having a nurse onsite one to two days per week is paramount and reducing the nursing staff not only hurts our medically unstable kids, but also every single kid and child in Petaluma City Schools, the office staff and our teachers. You have about 15 seconds. Reducing the nursing staff at Petaluma City Schools would be a huge mistake. It will put all of our children at risk and especially children like Will who have life or death decisions to make each and every day. Please reconsider your budget cuts. Thank you. Okay. And then I have a card from

093Andy. It says 17. I'm guessing you mean item 17, which we've already past, but if you have public comment on budget reduction or board meeting dates, I'll take it. Yeah, the budget. I didn't know which item it was. It was hard to find. You're good. Don't worry. It was hard to find the agenda online. So Andy Schrader, I was on your budget advisory committee And we spent the last three months going through this and giving you lots of options. And it was hard. And behind each of these positions is a human being. And we understand that. I'm here tonight because I think that removing the college and career pathways coordinator would be like guiding our students through their entire education system and then yanking the bridge away at the last second. This position is actually

094brought in. A lot of money into the district, a lot of really important attention. And I think it's… important to not remove that one at the last minute. We really need to get our kids into jobs rather than into people's basements where they're sitting there on their phones. So this is super important. The students deserve guidance and this position needs to stay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you all for your public comments. And we'll go back to our discussion about recommendations for budget reduction. Do any of my fellow trustees have questions, go for it. I'm wondering if we can use the same restricted portion of the budget for the nurse as we're doing for LMFTs, if that's a possibility at all. Great. Excuse me. Great question. One of the LFTs is being funded by a

095grant at McDowell. And the second change in the LMFT is we receive Medi-Cal dollars through our partnership with our partnership with We have individuals who bill and receive those funds. So the LMFT does qualify for that. Specifically in the committee, it was discussed, though the nurses bill hours, they do not receive funding so that specific position does not qualify. It's a pretty restricted source of funding. I'm also… That's right. I'm also concerned in what we just voted on as far as saving certain credentials we're saving people with CLAD, be glad. Eld credentials and so i think on the classified side, it would really be doing a disservice to eliminate anyone Anyone. Who is fluent in Spanish. So those are my two comments. Amanda, so you just mentioned the LMFT. How many LMFTs are funded through

096the general funds? Six. And we have one that is one tapping into the Medi-Cal special fund sorry, seven currently. Okay, sorry. Seven. One has moved and then the second one will move into the Medi-Cal funding on July 1. Okay. Is there additional room for another LMFT to move into that funding source freeing up general fund dollars for another position So at our last meeting, the Medi-Cal committee in the budget, there was about one point two million dollars That's a little over $800,000 of carryover and an ongoing revenue source of about $350,000 each year. So we could there is room to support an additional LMFT. Can we look into that? I know that we cannot make a final decision on that because of the subcommittee. But that seems like an additional way to Two birds with

097one stone. And let's make sure that we can, again. Tap into all the resources, ongoing funds um and stuff. So thank you to my colleague for bringing this up and um Leave it at that for right now. Thank you. Kind of along those lines looking at keeping the VAPA Tosa, which I do think is super valuable Is there any way that that funding would fit into the elementary parcel tax? Money and fit in in line with that in a way to free up more general fund money for a nurse or for a Secretary. Currently, the BAPA TOSA is charged to our arts and music discretionary block grant. And as Tony was speaking, it's built into That plan, we have to have that for those dollars. The arts and music discretionary block grant does have quite

098a It's quite unrestricted, restricted funding. So for lack of a better term, but the language in the new parcel tax does allow For VAPA positions. And isn't Prop 28 also part of that funding as well? Yes, Prop 28 is included in the overall plan. And as allowable. Yeah, so what I'm hearing is that even if we freed up used parcel tax funding for VAPA, it wouldn't free up $75,000 that could use towards a nurse necessarily. Yes, I think this brings up a great point. When we started the discussion. Just to back up a little bit, when the budget advisory committee met last year. They were given only the list of COVID or additional temporary funded positions to make the decision from this past year, we have opened it up and we had the opportunity to

099talk about all district positions. So the difference is that every recommendation that was made by the committee Is not actually coming out of the general fund unrestricted. There are restricted pots of money CTE is an example, the VAPA is an example is an example of that. So what the the task really is for the business department once these decisions are made is to look at our budget as a whole. To see where if we reallocate staffing to different restricted dollars to then free up the general fund. So that would be available with the VAPA and with other positions. It's really just looking to reallocate in order to maintain are unrestricted general funds. I'm confused. So the CTE coordinator is coming out of a restricted budget, not the general fund. That's a great question. So last

100year there was grant funding for half of the cte outside of the current grants that we have that went away last year. So we have been right now that position is charged to CTIG, which is restricted, but it also has a lot of Other allowable. Uses for it. So this is one thing that the committee talked a lot about like really going into details, understanding like when there are restricted fundings involved. So it wasn't just about eliminating a position. It was figuring out how to take other things that are happening within our budget that are not being currently charged to restricted funds. What the recommendation of the committee was is if this was eliminated from CTIG. Sections at our comprehensive high schools and secondaries can then be allocated for a cost savings that way. So

101it's really been a lot of these positions that we are discussing do not come out of the unrestricted general fund. I had a question more along the lines of the process. I know last year, like you were saying. We were just looking at the COVID funded jobs. But it looks like this year, some of those COVID funded jobs were not included in the budget cuts. So then What is the plan for continuing to fund those like let's say we're able to find an outside funding source for Cte and then for the nurse Since this was COVID funds originally, then how do we plan on continuing to fund that so we don't run into this every single year. So unfortunately, any time that we use any sort of district carryover. Outside grants, one-time funding that have

102an end date this were prolonging the situation. So we may be able to cover positions numerous positions for an additional year or one or two positions for a couple years, but we ultimately will be back when those funding sources run out. In our first interim in our interim adopted budget and our first interim. It has always been $2 million of cuts in this year and an additional 600,000 in next year. So we are already next year for the following year, excuse me so this is it was we made the decision. We had $7 million of Positions added doing the slow burn and continuing positions for as long as possible. So any decision Outside of the $2 million is if the $2 million is not reduced is prolonging it. But the thought is, is that if

103we have a COVID funded position. That um the will is to keep that position by eliminating a different position. So we will use Say we wanted to keep the floater custodian position and um what we did, what we could have done then is, well, we want to keep this position But we can eliminate the coordinator of budget and accounting. That position has been in our budget for over five years. So by eliminating that position, we've now freed up ongoing dollars because those were built into our multi-year projections. So the only way to continue funding is to eliminate another job that has ongoing funding if that would Yes, for a long term. Okay. And then… can the parcel tax be used for any of these? For any of just any of the positions at all that

104were at all for being cut. I'm just going to briefly look at the list so I don't misspeak. I would have to look. Read the language, but there's a good chance that possibly the secretary or the student advisors would. No administrative salary. So none of our management positions potentially the nurse i would really I cannot clearly say right now of that, but we would be limited Limited to some of the classified or certificated positions that are on the list. Amanda how many jobs which are like you just said. The budget person. It's been for five years. Are there any more jobs like that or know where it's on the books? But nobody's filled that position. So I want to be clear that position was filled until recently. It has not been vacant for five years.

105Yes. That is something that we are constantly looking at and we talk about elimination through attrition. We worked with one of the requests of the budget advisory committee was for us to talk to site administrators and department heads to see if there was anything that was… They could live without. And that list is um is thin from that list came, you know, the rationale for the mechanic helpers. We have a brand new electric fleet. We have a need for bus drivers. The picture may be different in three to five years when those are no longer under warranty. So we've been consistently I would say even in last fiscal year, looking at all of those things, trying to reduce, we were able. Originally, this ask was going to be because we added some positions at the

106end of the year last year. We anticipated this to be $2.2 million originally and through attrition of other positions, we were able to reduce it down to $2 million. So that's something we're constantly looking at. Thank you. I want to bring this back just at a high level. I wanted to Take time to thank advisory committee members for all their time and effort. And seriousness that they put into their recommendations. You know, it is unique to have teachers, classified staff, the principals and parents all working together and to reach super majorities on very difficult questions So I just want to say, again, thank you. And we take your recommendations extremely serious. I also want to point out that, you know. We, the board we learn about the recommendations at the same time as the public

107last last thursday And so we are digesting the recommendations as well. And, you know, I want to thank Ms. Goodacre coming down for Santa Rosa um Thank you for all the work that you do through the CTE Foundation. I was lucky enough to work with Tony Crabb this last fall. And he is uh You're becoming a good friend. I want to… I see that we have a note on the slide that the cte position. Will be eliminated the recommendation, but alternative sources are being investigated. Can you go into that a little bit more and what are the next steps into to investigate funding for those positions. Well, I mean, so we can look at other grants, potential grants that we we could pursue or currently have. In addition, we could request greater funds through the

108CTIG. Currently, I think we get about a half a million dollars from CTIG with a with a mat we have to do a two to one match But I think currently we could potentially absorb more of the CTIC funds, because I think our current match Can exceed or allows us to have more CTA funds but i think the That's hard to know because we've got to go through the application and it's not really up to us. How much will get allocated. I think it's really taking the time to explore what other opportunities Whether it's also potentially through our LCAP, to support our college and career goals and seeing if that could be a possibility as well. So there's multiple Potential funding sources that we would need to explore, but we would just need time for

109that. Thank you, Tony. Go for it. So I had another question about the process. I know, again, last year we looked at just COVID jobs this year. We looked at every job. Is that correct? So, um. What was the process of the jobs? Like, for example, the PAC secretary, the mechanics helpers, I know you said that. Since the cars are under warranty, just one student advisor, even though we originally hired 12. How was the decision made on how not putting more of the COVID jobs funded jobs up there and then including jobs that were not COVID funded. What was the budget advisory committee's process for that? So throughout. The process, one of the things that was clear from the whole committee is that They wanted to keep the eliminations as far away from students as

110possible. When you do that, you automatically look at your operations and places like the district office removed from the students so It wasn't a matter of having a vote on day one. Like I said, there were a lot of requests with a lot of information. I think one of the tools that maybe the committee found I found it helpful. Maybe they didn't was we had a spreadsheet that was broken up by and it was it was like 11 pages, but it was broken up. By department and site. Where we were in the 1920 school year pre-pandemic staffing levels. Versus where we are currently staffed. And then we did have the enrollment. For each of those years because some of our sites have really fluctuated enrollment so that really guided a lot of the conversation of

111over the last five years, you know, we talked about specific COVID funded positions. Those were brought on as temporary for very specific dollars. Different grants, but that really gave them the opportunity of why we'll talk about about the Pax McKinley secretary is when looking at this list. Most of our sites had 1.5 FTE of office support and PACS had 2.5. So that started the conversation there. The other piece that I think the committee heard loud and clear after last year, making the recommendation to eliminate the Tosa positions at the three sites and we brought those back. They asked, like. If they weren't allowed last year, are they on the table this year? And the answer was, yes, they are. But looking at that and keeping those positions, we had three elementary schools, elementary slash K-8s

112that we're going to the recommendation was not going to Cut those three TOSA positions. But where did they have additional staff? So McKinley pecks was one of those sites that has the TOSA AP and additional office support. So that's where that vote came from for the student advisors. Mary Collins and Penrove. Both have TOSAs. Mary Collins has a TOSA EP. Penn Grove has a TOSA. So it was to reduce those. So they will still have student advisors. Mary Collins, because they have their foundation pays for a partial student advisor, they will still actually have one FTE, which is what a lot of our other sites have. And Penn Grove. We were lucky. We had… to Penn Grove representatives. Principal harp and the office secretary and they they talked about this and explained how how the

113TOSA position worked and if they had to eliminate something. So it was very long conversations for every every position discussed. And so that's specifically how the secretaries and the student advisors came about. They realized the committee realized I mean, they would have glad not gladly, it would have been easiest if we had an additional $2 million here at the district office of staffing that we could have just eliminated. And they realized that. So when they had to go to the students, they looked at how to be least impactful. By looking at staffing levels and enrollment. We talked a little bit just now about the secretary, and I think there's been confusion about like packs versus McKinley versus Pax McKinley. Like, can we… and like a concern about a specific employee. Can we talk a little

114bit about How if that 1.0 FTE is eliminated, what that looks like in terms of like. Staffing and individual staff moving around in seniority and whatnot. Yeah, so So first of all, it's important to recognize like every position represents a person, but we are actually talking about positions because there are there's contract and there's bumping and there's seniority and all that. So your question was Can you restate your question one more time? I guess… My understanding is it's not. Even if we were 100% sure we were going to cut 1.0 FTE from McKinley packs we're not 100% sure on who that individual person is because of bumping and seniority and Yeah, that's true. And… the position that's identified is a secretary position. It's not a bilingual secretary position. There are many positions that are not

115required to be bilingual, but we have the benefit of having people that are bilingual and get a stipend for that. As opposed to there are some positions that are strictly bilingual, like it must be this is This position is a secretary position. And you were asking a little bit about, if I understood you right, why it's coded as PACs. I know that the genesis of this position was recognizing that the needs of PACs. Were greater and adding some additional support into the office. Was the rationale when Matthew first brought that forward. So that's why it is labeled that way in the budget. But if you've been to McKinley packs like it's an office and everyone in there is working for all the kids. So on the books, certainly it's labeled that way, but we know

116that in In reality, that's not how any of those positions operate, that they're only dealing with one school or the other school. So I think that the way it's listed is more about how it's budgeted than in reality how they serve how they serve the school. Thank you. Did you have another question about that? So we chose not to eliminate the ptosis where the ptosis, the elementary ptosis Were those COVID funded as well? They were additional Originally COVID funded Last year. The board elected to no longer allow carryover and so it freed up what generally was general fund dollars and those positions lie there now. So originally it could have been if that was that was a temporary measure because you only have that carry over one time once you spend it. And so now

117they will be added to the budget by eliminating if it's 450, I don't know the amount off the top of my head, but say it was $400,000. We've reduced $400,000 somewhere else to keep those positions. But those were originally COVID positions. Yes. That we've kept. Okay. Are the TOSA APs considered certificated or administrative positions. So we have three of those positions. One of those positions is a strictly a TOSA. That's at our TK6 school at Penn Grove. And that's a certificated teacher on special assignment. The other two schools are both TK8 schools, that's McKinley Pax and Mary Collins at Cherry Valley. And those are 50% teacher on special assignment and 50% assistant principal it's one person. So it's one person that they're position is split. So they're certificated administrators that are 50% an administrator and

11850% in a teaching position. Any other questions or comments? Yeah, I got a little more. So we haven't really talked about it too much, but one of the recommended adjustments by the back committee was the communications coordinator. Can you go into when this position was created and when did it become upper management. And maybe Jason has more deeper background, but my understanding it's been around since 2016. It was a classified position. And in 2022, it converted to a management position. But communication coordinator has been around for quite a while. Okay. What was the reasoning behind the backs? It was super majority vote, correct? Yes. What was the reasoning behind the recommendation to have this position be recommended for elimination. I can only I can… I would probably say that it was one of the initial

119the way the process worked was we had a lot of discussion and we actually started with all the COVID positions, like looking at those and then we expanded our discussions. We started with the group's talking about like forming groups that would talk about some ideas of what they wanted to cut and bring those forward and we started a list. There wasn't a ton of discussion about specifically why this one needs to be cut or that one needs to be cut, but my feeling was that the committee's first look was a lot of the first first takes were the positions that were farthest from student. Like as Amanda said earlier, like that was a sentiment of the group was trying to make cuts farthest away from students as possible. And so my inference on the rationale

120was that that was a position farther away from from students directly serving students. And it was one um it was one of the first first kind of cuts because we did a series of cuts like we we got a couple of positions and we voted on it and then we did another cut and we voted on some more and we had some discussion. Both of the coordinator positions were discussed early on and I think My impression was that the main purpose, the main focus was that they are farther away from students and that was the kind of the interest of the group was to make cuts at those locations. Farther away. Okay. And then just It was at the last meeting when we made the final votes. Yes. All right. And I think just circle

121back. And so the cabinets And Superintendent Harris's position, you know, can we go into a little more specific details about why uh why they are, you know, the recommendation is to keep the position. In regards to the communications coordinator? Yes. So as I mentioned in 2022 was kind of shifted to it was shifted to a certificated management position You know, in light of as we were entering, exiting out of the pandemic, there was a lot of challenges around the The crises that were happening at the school sites and the need to be responsive and communicate and And we also had a lot of new administration and being able to have someone who had the administrative background been a principal. It was a veteran to be able to support sites and knowing how to communicate. And

122reaching out to um the site principles to help guide them through talking points and and For example, the Penn Grove situation that happened, communication coordinator was critical in helping us navigate those challenging times when the kids were evacuated. So in addition to the crises, also the mentoring and the coaching that was much needed as we were dealing with a lot of new administration. In addition to all of the you know um working with the media and also working with our own social media working with You know, the district office and how to upgrade a lot of the communication tools that we have and how to streamline the two-way communication with our parents and making sure That the priority with the priority with with our communication with our community through surveys or through other initiatives that

123help us get input and also receive input from our community to help us be more responsive of what we need to do as a district. Yeah, and a big piece of the communications coordinator is working around enrollment As we were also battling declining enrollment and how do we redesign our narrative around what Petaluma City Schools offer around this SSU promise that you might see. And working with our elementary sites and navigating the Valley Vista enrollment piece when we were doing our merger with the Live Oak. So all those pieces with a certificated management background really helped navigate a lot of those nuances that school sites needed and the support that the district needed to help navigate those things. And I'll just add pretty much everything that Tony just said there like did not happen with

124the communications coordinator when it wasn't a management position. It was, yeah, when it was classified it was classified mostly doing social media, helping us run our board events, but not talking to the Argus, not talking with the superintendent for hours on the weekend about all the different crises that have come up. So it really has shifted. Whether it, you know, whether we need to spend $221,000 is what, you know. Definitely a conversation worth having it has shifted into a very, very different role than it was Even though it has the same title as it did in 2016. I'm wondering if, so I'm seeing that the reasoning, I think it's on the next slide or the slide after. One more. Another one. That one. So under the the COVID funded nurse, it says recommended for reduction

125The elimination of the nurse position was voted on during the budget advisory meeting and reached the majority, but not a super majority. Were there any other positions that Reach the majority, but not a super majority that don't appear on this list. No, no. Okay. Thank you. I have a follow up on the nurse. There were some statistics read by some of the public comments. Is that true that we have seen jumping students with type 1 diabetes from pre-pandemic to current. That is correct. So, okay. So the numbers that are correct Approximately correct. It's referenced. Thank you. I would be interested at the next meeting or in the meantime if we could know what the nurse to student ratios are in districts near us. Like both our feeder districts and other I forgot the word we

126use is, but districts like us The other big ones, the other big ones. And if… there were ever a way to maybe I mean, I'm just going, making things up on the fly like split FTE like split a nurse with old adobe or something like is that ever a model we could consider doing is sharing a staff member like that that's already floating between sites sharing with one of the smaller districts that Maybe they don't have the budget for a 1.0 FTE nurse. Just getting creative and weird. Yeah, I don't know specific to that position, but it is something that we do we contract with our feeder districts on a lot of services. Especially around transportation and special education. Any other questions or any information you all want before the next meeting or to be

127brought to the next meeting? Any recommendations? For the resolution that will include positions to be eliminated. I can start. I do not want to see the nurse position eliminated. I would like to see if we can find ways to tap into the Medicare fund. And move an additional LMFT position. I believe they are equivalent salaries or rough, you know, approximately. So I believe that is something to where we can utilize that fund as long as, again, we can work that through the subcommittee. I would not be supportive of the budget eliminating the nurse this time due to the comments from the parents and I think the increased need in coverage across the district And I don't want to see our numbers increase with the per pupil per nurse Even if our feeder districts are different

128It still is not good enough. And this is we can do better. And we should stay at this better level. Ryan, I agree. I don't think cutting a nurse is a very good idea. Especially with the spike. And, you know, we Kids get sick and things are really contagious these days. And I just don't think we can afford to lose a nurse at this point. Any other questions or comments? Yeah, I can, you know, again. So second is we have a tremendous ally and resource, Mesquite Acre came down to join us tonight. Ken, before our next meeting, can I Can we schedule a conversation with with them and with CT Sonoma. The foundation. And see if there is additional, let's say like guidance on what the other funding could be and we can provide a

129little bit more clarity or not clarity on, again, where that position is going to go. But I would like to have that conversation. They came down to ask for it and we should have it as soon as possible. Can you clarify? So originally you said for us to you wanted to move another LMFT into the Medi-Cal billing and then free that up for a nurse. Do we have the funds to do that? Do we know? There are carryover funds that would support it for at least one year. Okay, so that would be a one year. So then… Are you just hoping to know that for this year or like for ongoing than how we would keep them or you just want to look at that again next year when we get to that point? Well,

130I am the junior member on the board. I am learning about the different pots of money and how they are allocated and what is ongoing or carryover or one-time money I would like to keep the nurse. I would like to keep four nurses at Petaluma City Schools. I would like to do the best job we can. If we come to that point where there is that nothing else we can tap into. We will have that conversation but Until that point. So for this year. Yeah, for this budget I also, we save credentials for certificated can we do the same thing for classified? For example, bilingual would have had precedence over not bilingual. I'm saying that very clumsily, but you know. I know I understand what you're asking. I can look into that. We haven't done

131that in the past. We haven't We haven't discussed that with our labor partner with CSEA, and we haven't ever brought resolutions to that effect. But I can look into the possibility of that. Trustee Quinn, I just want to make sure I understand the direction of the board. So essentially what you're asking for is for us to look for outside funding so that we don't bring the nurse position to the resolution at the next board meeting. And that we talked to the CTE Foundation and I'm actually meeting with Kathy tomorrow. And we try to strategically look for additional funding sources outside the ones that we currently having the district to support the CTE coordinator position. Is that correct? I think the Medi-Cal funding for the LMFT specifically, less than like outside But yeah, otherwise, yes, I

132would say that. Is that direction is that correct? I think so. Is there any other direction anyone wants to No, I just want to point out that we had a member of the budget committee come up and say, talk about the CTE. So that carried a lot of weight with me. Yeah, I hear that. I mean, I think we can make a justification for every single person's position just because they didn't come and speak or someone didn't speak on their behalf tonight. So I don't want to You know, just set aside everyone's job because even though we know that these are positions, there are people in each of these jobs. Yeah, I just… I hear what you're saying, Ryan. I mean, I think people make a lot of assumptions, but I also have a child

133that has a medical condition, but I also know that we have to fund this somehow. And I'm okay, I guess, for the next year but then What do we have a plan to continue funding? The nurses? After this, like, I don't want to keep doing this every year So then I would want to know what's our long-term plan or we're going to be right back here in a year? So if we move if we move an LMFT into the medical that will support. So there's already been one move there. So the $350,000 that is received annual you cannot support two. So we're limited to carry over. What that will do, just to be perfectly clear, is that makes one of the LMFT Positions that will run out of funding. It will end up with the

134end date. If the nurse isn't then charged to the general fund. The nurse will continue without going through this process again. Just to be mindful of that. So then we're basically… deciding if we want to keep a nurse long-term funding or an LMFT long-term funding. Is that correct? Yes. Okay. We could do it the LMFT like as a in the budget as a temporary for one year And then for… now for multi-year projections, then move that position back into the general unrestricted dollars and eliminate the nurse for multi-year projections so we do have that Type of play. I mean, when I look at the survey feedback the thing that came back as the highest was providing mental health support for students. Along with supporting students with disabilities and ensuring school safety So the LMFTs did

135come back as the highest when we spoke to the community. Of course, I want to say both of the positions, but I don't know how I feel about using the funds that are the Medi-Cal funds that are generated by the LMFTs. To not use for LMFTs. So I'm wondering if there's a different funding source that we can identify for the nurses. I can definitely look at what we anticipate having restricted dollars. One of the other things that we could look at doing is that we receive Title I funds for each of the two districts. And what we do is we have them earmarked by district, but we then do a calculation. To determine which of our schools will be our Title I schools in any given year. Based off of our socioeconomically disadvantaged count. And

136then we allocate specific budgets from Title I to each school site. Schools that are site site-wide Title I schools. We can use something like the nurse to pay for it. So what we could do is we could fund the nurse out of our Title I funds and then that nurse would work at specific school sites that have that were site-wide Title I. So that is an option. It would reduce the allocation that is given to each site. How much would it reduce the allocation by? Because I'm seeing like the the fourth nurse is divided by five schools. I don't know how much the nurse so yeah so right now, I mean, these are current numbers so any salary changes we make this year, these numbers, you know. Changed relatively soon. But we would take them

137out. So let's say… About 20,000 ish. Yeah, well, and it depends like if it was over three sites, we would take the 170 and reduce it by the three. We do historically have carryover in our Title I funds, so they generally are not fully spent each year. So that too. Though it has historically been an ongoing source of funding. Yeah, we don't know. But we could, yes, the nurse does qualify. We could move We could charge the nurse to title one Okay. And then I'm wondering along, because Title I does encapsulate a lot of students. Besides the one with medical needs so then I just wonder then if i just wonder if then you know more of the more services to Title I students could be potentially done by the nurses as well. I mean,

138just for me, I would feel more comfortable if we're going to find a funding source, at least That one that's ongoing. I'm asking you, Ryan junior board member. I think it's a conversation we have to Right now, I mean, if we come up with new funding source, I think with like another position like two two or three months down the road, or you get more clarity on Title I or where the money Well, right now, what we can say is for this next fiscal year, we can use this source of funds to keep the nurse and while we you know, and you have my full support on I do not want to reduce that LMFT as well. And so we can identify the Correct. Funding sources for both positions and get that into alignment with

139Again, with the community priorities and our priorities. Olivia, do you have any questions? Comments? I'm sorry, I missed. Would you prefer that the nurse be moved into title one Or to look at a one year with the Medi-Cal. I would prefer Title I. Because even though we cannot count on the federal government, I know that our state superintendent has identified at least that they believe they can cover. The title funds at least. And we have that for now we have that that revenue currently and we have to carry over from it. And then we wouldn't. Be um basically bumping the LMFT from the funding source that they generate with their billing. So at this point, how many LMFTs Are we keeping? And how many have been cut? So we are keep all of our current

140LMFTs we are keeping on two of the positions, we have moved them into extremely restricted funding sources that they previously we have not used salaries there. Yeah, I'm in supportive of using Title I if we can just because we I mean, as much as we can know anything about the federal government We know that. If I wasn't clear, it is allowable. So we can. Okay. Cool. Do you have any other? Just a point of clarity. I think, are we all in alignment on keeping the 0.6 FTE epidem. That was a position. That's being paid with restricted funds. Yes. Isn't that restricted? One of many positions on this list that is currently being paid with restricted funds. Yeah, I am. You're going to think I'm clear on direction, so we will… be back. We're going to

141work with CTE Foundation. I'll meet with Kathy to look for funding, possibly funding for the coordinator of cte and will remove nurses from the resolution that will come to the board and we will fund that nurse position with Title I. Okay, great. Thank you. All right. Thank you all. Thank you for everyone who participated in the budget advisory and public comment. This is not the official anything. We still have to vote on the resolution next time, but. It sounds like we may have a… have a way forward. Those were our two discussion and information items. So moving on to future business. Does anyone have any future business, any presentation requests any yeah The North Bay Security presentation. Yeah. I just want to know The scope of the work that they do, especially related to chronic

142absenteeism and residency verification, but just overall, not just at CASA, All of our sites. Yeah. And how much money we're spending on them. Thank you. Yeah. Any other feature? Future business, anybody? I asked last time and I'll say it again. I want to hear about math assessments at the secondary level. Great. I brought this up. Launch the land but uh been speaking with our friends of the building trades and they have been an IBEW um They've been going to and doing presentations like a career day or career presentation at several local high schools, they've asked if they can do it at our high school sometime in May. And so I just want to circle back and figure out if we can find Time and resources to provide them on campus. Yeah, we'll connect them to

143Dan and Victor. And definitely. Okay. That would be awesome. Yeah, I don't like hearing that they're going to other schools and not our schools. So we got to Yeah, we can make it as easy as possible for them. Cool. Any other future business? If not, I would join this meeting at 8.33 p.m.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.