001grade, would fifth grade still be required to teach puberty talk as is required in other PCS schools? with the curriculum in seventh grade B Teen Talk, as is required in other PTS schools. And it does mention sexual health education in middle school, but doesn't mention fifth grade puberty talk in another spot as well. There were a lot of places that I was concerned when it talked about funding. I was wondering where the funding would come from for professional development for Waldorf training. Painting classrooms, TK and K ovens and sinks changes to the physical environment of the school, such as wooden furniture, chalkboards, soft furnishings made with natural fibers. There was also a lot of mention of different staff members, there was Spanish teacher. It was my understanding that we don't have Spanish at Valley Vista
002now because of equity issues because other sites don't have Spanish. So would the charter be allowed to have Spanish? There's also mention of a movement teacher, handwork teacher, fourth through eighth grade math teacher, strings teacher, pedagogical director, TOSA. and aides for grades one, two, and three. And another page mentions class assistance in many grades. So I'm wondering if that would be equitable staffing compared to other sites. I wonder where the funding would come from for the materials for fine arts, applied arts, music and drama. There was another position mentioned festival volunteer coordinator that I don't know that that would be that there's any such position at other sites. I also wonder how they would fund the field trips and overnight adventure learning experiences because it's mentioned on page 16 as grades four through eight are
003required to participate in overnight adventure learning opportunities. And then it also mentions tutors, but again, where would the funding come from and will it be equitable? And I don't think that that was mentioned in the budget after the appendices. There are two places where it talks about the weekly minimum day being a Thursday, which is not the same as the other schools in our district and that would be concerning because there should I would think be alignment with the other schools so that there can be meetings between school sites. All right. If you want to give me one. Oh, sorry. I wanted to get it. Yeah. Thank you. I appreciate it. Yeah. All right. Christy. My name is Christy Holquest. And I teach transitional kindergarten at Valley Vista School. I've been on the committee that
004has been looking at the merger between Live Oak and Valley Vista. I appreciate the time I've been given to investigate the Waldorf philosophy. I still have questions. But I've been reading books and listening to podcasts and visiting schools to try to fully inform myself. I read the charter over the weekend. And I appreciate those of you on cabinet and those board members that we're able to hear and reply to the questions I have. For me, change is hard and the future is scary in all aspects of my life. I flip a lid when my husband changes the furniture, moves the mail. I do believe in democracy. And you were the board and were elected. So whatever the vote is tonight. I obviously accept it and understand it's done for reasons that may not be evident
005to me. Once a Viking, always a Viking. Thanks, Christy. All right. If there are any other public comments on the charter, now is the time to submit them. All right. Moving on, I will… close the public hearing. We will still be talking about it later on the agenda. But I want to move on to comments from the public on everything else. So right now we're going to take comments from the public on everything on the agenda. I'll also take a, since the charter is still on the agenda, I'll still take comment on that. And let's see. I don't think anyone is going to need their time. divided up. to be less than three minutes. I'm just grouping things together by by subject and we're good. Otherwise, I'm going to go relatively in the order that
006I received them. So first up is Molly. Thank you. I'm here to respond to the false statements that were made at the last board meeting regarding the parcel tax violations of Measure C. On 1210, it was said that, quote, no carryover for the parcel tax has been restored to the budget, end quote. Actually, it has, and we've all placed our orders. Thank you. It was also said that, quote, the carryover was legally eliminated to pay for positions, end quote. Actually, it was not legal. Comets like this are troubling and require correction. The illegality of this past action was identified and resolved. We've moved forward. But if there's a denial of wrongdoing, we are doomed to repeat the same mistake. Let's be clear. The decision to illegally remove Parcel Tax Measure C carryover to fund administrative
007TOSA positions was made behind closed doors. It was then rushed through the board without acknowledging that nearly $50,000 of restricted parcel tax funding was part of the general sweep of unrestricted funding used to balance the budget. This all happened with no communication to sites just weeks before spending deadlines. Leaving no chance for students to spend their remaining parcel tax funds. This flawed process subverted well-established district protocols that ensure confidence in our systems. This must be acknowledged, not denied, for us to rebuild trust. For the record, parcel tax funding has specific constraints on how it can and cannot be used. Even as carryover. Wherever it is moved, it remains designated to its original voted purpose and can only be used as such. from the voter pamphlet, quote. Proceeds of the tax would be placed in a
008special fund and could only be used for the purposes set out in the measure, and none of this money can go to administrators. Additionally, quote, and that's unquote. Additionally, the Oversight Committee is required by law to account for unspent funding, and yet they were not notified of this action. So yes, the removal and prohibited repurposing of the parcel tax funding was in fact illegal This is precisely why Acting Superintendent Esmeralda Mondragon acted swiftly to rectify the problem by replacing these funds. The parcel tax problem has now been solved. Thank you. Unfortunately, a bigger problem remains. This process has exposed a bureaucracy that is highly uncomfortable with transparency. and seems more committed to covering up mistakes than working as a team This must change. If we are to hold our students to high standards of integrity,
009this needs to be demonstrated at the top There is no room for ego in the days to come. We must cooperate to tackle the challenges facing public education. Humility is paramount. Thank you. Thank you, Molly. Next up, I have Dylan. Hi, my name is Dylan, Damien Barrera. I'm going to be talking about… Funding at… on the CTE student convention. I'm going to be talking from my personal experience. As an alumni. What the field trip did for me. I think it just opened a door. Because I come from… I'm not very athletic. I'm not the smartest. My fields aren't there, so… to see, just to bring us out on a field trip is not a norm for me. I think what Long Beach did was not just the area but It was the experience within the
010experience giving us what we already know. just doing it. It was very nerve-wracking at first. Then, but looking back at it now, I think it was… an experience that molded my experience my career and what I'm doing now, I'm taking classes at the SRJC and I'm I'm just striving to get my digital media certificate and maybe associates You know, I don't know. I don't know, like, uh… what to point out, but I think it was, I think that that trip was really just a foundational point in my life. to see what I want to do but Just an example of what what a class can do for a student of any demographic. Thank you. Thank you very much. And then Jameel? If I have handouts for you guys, do I… Ronnie Dangerfield all of a
011sudden. Only some of you are old enough to actually get that joke. I got it. He was a comedian. Go for it. Okay. So I was asked to actually come and just talk about the CTE field trip that's planned for March. This would be to Tampa, Florida. It would be our second one this last spring, which Dylan went to, and actually Max was in Long Beach. And briefly, the broadcast program at the Petaluma High. In the last two years at Petaluma Junior has really just exploded. I took it over four years ago. There were 13 students. Now, there are 64 at the high school and we could have opened another section, but maybe with seven bells, it'll be easier. And with Petaluma Jr, there were 24 students. We tried it last year and they had
012over 80 apply for this year, so we have two sections there. The student television network is a national program. They actually have a couple of international schools attend. Over 3,000 students, over 200 schools. go there. And the key for this is allowing the opportunities of what the students learn in the classroom to be applied in a completely different environment. I always tell them that our walls are a safe space. We're going to learn. We're going to fail. We're going to fail forward. And then we go to this convention It's four days. The contests there are timed. They drop a prompt and they say you have two to six hours depending, anywhere from two to eight students Working as a team must complete something where hundreds of other teams are competing with. And it's a completely
013different level. It's a high stakes environment. They are tasked, I'm not allowed to help them. They have to do it all themselves. And that's what really sets this experience apart because they're not going to get that at the school. We strive with our CTE funds to make this available so that we cover everything. I have a little bit of I want a little bit of skin in the game, so they have to cover their breakfast and lunch. And they have to do that healthy food, not just Twinkies and ding-dongs. But the whole point of that is to give them all everybody has a chance. And you'll see the criteria that has it. So it's very egalitarian in that respect. If I have more people who want to go than seats, then this is one way
014to winnow it down. If I still have that, then we just do a lottery system. To who can go. It was an amazing experience this last year. I came out from it. We took a charter bus down to Long Beach, drove back. And I mean, I was just three feet off the ground. They were just amazing. We took a second place. in the movie trailer and an honorable mention in the music trailer which Max Stretter can speak to. And I just want that opportunity for all of my students if I could do that. Nailed it. I know. That's better than a book. Can't beat that. All right. Max. You want to come on up? Because I love you, Max. So I'm Max Shatter. I'm part of our children broadcast channel, our digital media class. I
015am currently a third year member, so I've been doing this since my freshman year. When I first joined broadcast, I joined it by accident. I thought it was our journalism class. But because of the opportunities that Doser has brought to us, I found such a love in broadcasting. And by my sophomore year, I knew this is what I want to go into but Broadcasting is such a wide range that you don't know. When I got to the convention, I got to experience so many things from more film than broadcast to going to workshops where I get to work with and learn from actual professionals in the field. I also got to do college tours to learn about more colleges to start looking into for more broadcasts. I went to one workshop where they were talking
016about what it would be like as a student member of this sports broadcasting Instagram thing. And you got to practice what they do every day. I did that workshop and I walked out of it, looked at my friend who was with me and was like, this is what I'm doing. I'm going into sports media and i am going to hopefully crush it. When we're there, like Dosari said, there's nothing like the feeling of competing. I was in two contests One is our crazy eights where all of our students work together to promote something. I was the vinyl editor. I was the person pushing submit. And that was the scariest thing I have ever done. I was in tears, but we did it. I also competed in another contest, which was music video, which was very
017much out of my comfort zone. as at the time we focused more on broadcasting class than film, which we no longer do. We do a mix of both. But it's more of a film contest. So it's very scary. I was able to luckily, me and my friend, it was originally a team of three. Our third person unfortunately couldn't make it the day before we left for convention. So we were already a little stressed. But me and her were able to pull an honorable mention, which when there's over thousands of schools, it's really just awesome to see, especially because we are division two and that was our first year going. And there were people who have been there for four or five years that where we were going a little bit ahead. But there's nothing like
018competing that feeling that gratification of where you put submit and you're like, okay, this is done. This is an experience i want I'm now a link leader. I do link crew There are freshmen who are in my group who are now going to convention or planning to. And I want them to feel that feeling, to experience what it's really like to be there, to be in the world of broadcasting, not just a classroom. Thank you. Great. Thank you, Max. All right, Peter. You got to follow that. I'm sorry. Thank you. I'm Peter Costas, Trustee, Sonoma County Office of Education. And first of all I really appreciate your comments on CT. I've been a real champion of cte and I've really seen how it's become more and more embedded in the last decade with the articulations
019with the junior college. Thank you. And, um. I want to congratulate Ellen for your reelection. You're a strong voice on this board and i And then best wishes to you again. And Sheldon, thank you for all your service. And with that. This month is School Board Appreciation Month. So at our board meeting last week, we passed a resolution honoring all the trustees in the county. And with that, on February 3rd, you'll receive invitation. We have our biannual trustee recognition dinner. It'll be at the Hyatt Wine Country. Up in Santa Rosa and superintendents and trustees from all the 39 or 38 or 40 districts are invited. And we also recognize new trustees that have been elected. So please look out for that. And then our county board, we want to support new trustees and you're going
020to have a new trustee So on January 15th, there's a Brown Act training. That's going to be virtual. And then on March 8th, there's going to be a board member boot camp. So please look out you know for those. And finally. Last week at our board meeting, we passed a a safe haven resolution for our county office education and the programs that our County Office of Education provides. And in that resolution, we put a line in that we encourage district boards to adopt similar resolutions. Now the county board, we have no authority over a district board. So it's just a suggestion, just an encouragement. And finally, thank you for all your work. Thank you, Peter. All right. And then Sarah. You're good. Never been to a school board meeting. Welcome. Intense. Thank you for allowing
021me a moment to speak. My name is Sarah Vela. And I have two daughters in the Petaluma City School District. One is Abigail, who is in 10th grade at Petaluma. high school and the other is Genevieve at Petaluma Junior High School in eighth grade. What I would like to touch on, and I really would like to put a parent stressor out there to the board is my daughter, Abigail, who is in 10th grade. is in SDC classes. Half SDC and half general education. And currently, I'm working with the IEP team to go through something called The alternate assessment decision-making tool for california So that she can get a diploma. And I have been inquiring with everyone and asking lots of questions and trying to find the answers. And I'm still just There. I would like
022to know where Petaluma City Schools is at right now with the alternative pathway to diploma. for special education students. My understanding, and I could be wrong. is that there are no students in SDC classes, and I'm not talking about the consortium area. I have no knowledge of that. But there are no students in the STC program that are on a diploma track. And after doing my own research since May, when I was presented with the question, do you want your child to have a diploma? for a certificate. And I'm like, I need to have the information. So that's where I've been. And I would not want a certificate for my child or any other child at that matter after what I've learned is that employers don't recognize a certificate. that's huge. And then when you're
023talking about special education. and their needs and the type of employment that they're looking for. And there's a lot of what is that AI stuff coming in and Jobs are getting automated more and more every day. So there's less and less availability for this population. So I have high concerns for that. And I know that also that there is an impact with post-secondary education and what's available. I am. Meeting three, we've done three IEP meetings There are seven areas on this alternative assessment decision-making tool. How many more IEP meetings to go through this when this tool is so extremely highly subjective it brings my blood to a place I don't want to be. And I really care about the IEP team. I care about my daughter. But it feels like there's a lot of conflict
024when we're discussing this. And I know that Tony Hua, curriculum director, is working on this. on the vaccine. I just, I feel like I'm left in the dark and my what is Kristen Hoff? is the director anyway. I really want my daughter to get a diploma and we need curriculum modification now. She's got an F. in her favorite class. Anyway, thank you. Thank you, Sarah. All right. Thank you all for all your public comment. Now we're moving on to our action items. And we'll start with the second reading of board policy five one four or five, I don't know why I couldn't read numbers there for a second. 5145.13, response to immigration enforcement. Do I hear a motion? I move to approve Resolution 244 Is this right? Yeah, no. I'm on the wrong one. Sorry.
025Board policy 5145 0.13 response to immigration enforcement. I second. All right. Can we be reminded what this Is… this policy basically is in support and in response to the immigration enforcement. Following that, you will see a resolution that provides more detailed information about the district being a safe haven. school district. Does anyone have any questions or comments? We talked about this a little more at the last meeting. I think it's great that we're finally making it board policy. A lot of us thought it was already board policy because from like 2016 So we, yeah. it's good to put it in writing in the books and make it easier for our staff to protect our students. So with that, I'll call the question. All in favor of the new board policy? Aye. Any opposed? Hearing none,
026that policy passes and we'll move on to the resolution on the same subject, do I hear a motion? I move to approve the resolution. 2425-19, recognizing Petaluma City Schools as a safe haven school district. I second. All right. So I… A lot of resolved clauses. I was going to say maybe we should just read the resolved clauses but Does anyone have any questions or comments about the resolution? Can we read it into the if someone wants to read, I'm not going to, I'm going to cry too. Yeah. Resolution of the Board of Education of Petaluma City's elementary and Joint Union High School Districts, recognizing Petaluma City Schools as a safe haven school district. Whereas Petaluma City Schools is committed to the success of all students. Irrespective of their immigration status, ethnicity, race, religion, sexual orientation,
027ability. sex and gender identity, socioeconomic status, or beliefs. Whereas it is the right of every child, regardless of immigration status. to access a free public K-12 education. And the district welcomes and supports all students. And whereas through its policies and practices, the district has made a commitment to a quality education for all students. which includes a safe and stable learning environment. means of transportation to and from school sites. and the preservation of classroom hours for educational instruction. and the requirement of school attendance. Whereas this United States Supreme Court held in Plyer versus Doe 1982, that no public school district has a basis to deny children access to education based on their immigration status. Citing the children have little control over their immigration status. the harm it would inflict on the child and society itself. and
028equal protection rights of the 14th Amendment. Whereas Assembly Bill 699 requires all California public schools. to provide protections for students. Regardless of immigration status. and extend specific support to immigrant students and their families. AB 699 requires that schools support Sorry, adopt supportive practices. In response to the heightened immigration enforcement. Including updated staff training, curriculum development, and the following. Implement measures to prevent students from being discriminated against or bullied based on their immigration status. Ensure schools are teaching students about the harm of bullying students based on immigration status. Refrain from the unnecessary collection of immigration status information from students or families. report police enforcement. of immigration laws to school boards. Ensure schools are following a family's designated emergency plan. Whereas federal immigration law enforcement activities on or around district property and transportation routes, whether by surveillance,
029interview. demand for information, arrest. detention, or any other means harmfully disrupt the learning environment to which all students Regardless of immigration status or entitled. and significantly interfere with the ability of all students, including U.S. citizen students and students who hold other legal grounds for presence in the United States. to access a free public K-12 Education. Whereas parents and students have expressed to the district fear and confusion about the continued physical and emotional safety of all students. And the right to access a free public K-12 education. through district schools and programs. And whereas educational personnel are often the primary sources of support, resources, and information. to assist and support students and student learning. which includes their emotional health. Now, therefore, be it resolved. that the U.S. Immigration Enforcement Office, or ICE, State or local law enforcement
030agencies acting on behalf of ICE or agents or officers of any federal, state, or local agency attempting to enforce federal immigration laws are to follow District Policy 5145.13, which we just passed. attached to and incorporated in this resolution. To ensure that the district meets its duty to provide all students Regardless of immigration status, access to a free public K-12 education. be it further resolved. It continues to be the policy of the district not to allow any individual or organization to enter a school site If the educational setting would be disrupted by that visit. Given the likelihood of substantial disruption posed by the presence of ICE, or state or local law enforcement agencies acting for ICE any request by ICE or other agencies to visit a school site should be presented to the superintendent's office for
031review. As to whether access to the site is permitted by law. A judicial warrant is required. or any other legal considerations apply. This review should be made expeditiously. But before any immigration law enforcement agent or officer appears at the school site. be it further resolved. In its continued commitment to the protection of student privacy, the district shall review its record-keeping policies and practices to ensure that no data is being collected with respect to the student's immigration status or place of birth. and cease any such collection as it is irrelevant to the educational enterprise and potentially discriminatory. be it further resolved. Should ICE or other immigration law enforcement agents request any student information? The request should be referred to the superintendent's office to ensure compliance. with the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act. student constitutional privacy,
032standards for a judicial warrant. and any other limitation or disclosure This review should be conducted expeditiously but before any production of information is made. Be it further resolved. The district shall post this resolution at every school site and distribute it to the district staff. Students and parents using the usual means of communication. And that the resolution will be translated into all languages spoken by the students at home. be it further resolved. the board affirms that certificated district employees have the academic freedom To discuss this resolution during class time. Provided it is age appropriate. And students are to be made aware that district counselors are available to discuss the subjects contained in this resolution. And be it further resolved. After school providers and other vendors and service providers who contract with the district shall be notified
033of this resolution within 30 days and required to abide by it. be it further resolved that Petaluma City Schools approves this resolution to demonstrate its unequivocal commitment to ensuring a safe educational environment for all students. and will serve as a safe location for students and families threatened by immigration enforcement or discrimination. to the fullest extent provided by the law. Thank you, Trustee Cloud, for reading that into the record. Any other questions or comments about this resolution? I just want to thank Bree. for and the staff for really working on this. Yes, it is coming at a very important time and I think I can speak for all of us when I say that we know we want this and need this. Yeah. All right. I call to question all in favor of passing this resolution.
034Aye. Any opposed? Hearing none, the resolution passes. And we move on to acceptance of the independent annual financial audit report for the last fiscal year. Can I hear a motion? I move to accept. the audit report. I second. All right, Amanda, you want to tell us about the audit report? Yes, thank you. Tonight we bring forward the financial audit report for last fiscal year. We ended the year with two findings that are considered non-material. One in our ELOP after-school program. Because we had TK students in with kindergarten, we needed to maintain smaller class size ratio that is just for TKers when they're in a combination class so When this was brought to the district's attention during last year, it was actually fixed midway through the year. So we now are following that. And then we
035had some issues with some of our CNEPs reimbursement claims. due to a changeover in staffing, which we now have written procedures in place to ensure that that won't happen again. Any questions or comments about the audit report. All right, I call the question all in favor of accepting the audit report. Aye. Any opposed? Hearing none, we have accepted the audit report. Now we'll move on to acceptance of the 2324 Measure E and C bond audit. Do I hear a motion? I move to accept the measure. Thank you. All right, Amanda, can you tell us about this one? Yes, tonight we bring forward the official bond audit for last fiscal year that shows that our bonds have been in compliance, I would… like to note that we did not need to request an extension this year.
036So we are back on we are on the schedule that will help the citizens bond oversight committee be able to have time to go over the reports and approve them before the end of the fiscal year. Great. Any questions or comments? on the audit report. All right. Hearing none, I call the question all in favor of accepting this audit report. Aye. Any opposed? All right, we've accepted that audit report. Moving on to ed services. approval of resolution 2425-24, approving the establishment of a new charter school to be operated by Petaluma City Schools. Do I hear a motion? Move to approve Resolution 2425 dash 24. I'll second. All right, now let's have Tony present. I know you all had a chance to take a look at the charter petition I just do want to share a
037little bit about the plannings that have taken place around it the first kind of phase of that planning phase really is focusing around building strong foundation for the new charter school and fostering collaboration with the community. You know, the activities that have happened during this process or during this phase was faculty visits, community events, leadership meetings, communication efforts. A lot of it you've heard at the last board meeting when Jamie had presented around that timeline and what they had done. This is just some visuals of some of those events that have happened during that time. And, you know, pending approval we'd be focusing around the operational pieces, getting the governance and the curriculum and the infrastructures all in place. working on the hiring process and bringing in the resources that are needed to implement a
038school And then moving into launching the new dependent charter school that's overseen by the district. You know, trainings that need to take place and continuous community involvement and collaboration. And then, of course, regular communications with families of the Everything is cool. But if there's any specific questions in regards to the charter petition It is a lengthy document. I'm, you know, contrary to what I tell people, I don't know everything. But I will try my best to try to answer. the things that I know or hopefully make good assumptions around them as well. Tony, I have a question. You have the um operational planning in the spring of 2025. But yet… launch and growth occurs during the 2025-2026 school year. You know what? I just realized I made a mistake. It's okay. I make that all
039the time. All right. I know people have a lot of questions so i think I want to take it one trustee at a time. and go around a couple times. So if everyone can We'll start with Sheldon and go this way. And try and keep it to one question slash broad topic. Yeah. Tony, can you tell us about plans to accommodate our current teachers at Valley Vista if they are not qualified in the new staffing plan for the charter. I might maybe ask Jason to chime into that piece within his realm. Yeah, sure. So our intention is to is to is to bring on teachers that are well-off trained or teachers that are interested in becoming trained. So I think we anticipate that first opening up existing positions to our current staff that might be
040interested in that. And then staff at Live Oak that are interested in that. And based on just preliminary feedback, I mean, I don't believe that with that number, if our enrollment projections are right, I think we're going to need to hire more than than what would be available is what I'm anticipating. But our goal would be to start with our current staff in PCS and at Live Oak. bring them in and not every, you know, on our end, we don't have And very many, if any at all, that are currently trained that I know of. But it's more staff that are interested in pursuing that training and learning more about becoming a Waldorf trained and certified teacher. Does that answer the question? So those who are not interested in that training, what accommodations or efforts
041can we provide? for their future. Well, I mean, we get a little bit into the weeds on that, which we can if you like. I mean, but technically like our, okay, so getting into the weeds, like any of our, for example, our permanent staff at Valley Vista that have reached out to myself and to our labor partners and said. You know, Waldorf isn't for me. I'd like to do something else. We want our teachers to be in places where they're going to be to the best advantage. we would be finding other elementary positions that could mean that that our temporary elementary teachers that are in temporary positions would be let, you know, we release all of our temporaries and then we bring them back that we could be offering some of our temporary teachers that
042are interested. in becoming Waldorf trained, they could have an opportunity to consider that but We have in HR terms, we have the the room with our temporaries to accommodate getting our current permanent and probationary teachers either working at Valley Vista and pursuing training or in another setting at a more traditional site. And then we've discussed with the Live Oak Board about a process for their current teachers that are in good standing and having them go through a letter of intent process and figuring out which of those teachers are interested in this new adventure that we'd be looking at. So we've talked out out the ways really prioritizing our existing permanent and probationary staff. And live oaks established teaching staff. And then we would work work with our temporaries to figure out kind of the places
043where there's gaps. Does that make sense? Yeah. That's great. But I do have a concern of their seniority and whether if they decide not to be at Valley Vista and they don't have high seniority within our district, are they going to lose their job? If you can't find another spot for them. I believe that we will be able to find another spot for them. So I'm just looking at the numbers i'm I don't believe that's it. I don't know that's crossed my mind. It's always crossing my mind I think that we're i think that we'll be okay. I think that we have turnover every year, like people that are moving on. We have a retirement incentive that we've approved for teachers this year. So I think that we'll have an and we have a number
044of temporary teachers like we put a lot of our temporary positions into elementary, knowing that this was going to be like we were looking ahead. So we planned on this. So I think that we are looking at prioritizing. As I mentioned, we look to prioritize protecting our our current permanent and probationary employees. So yeah, we were concerned about that, but I think we're addressing it is what I'm probably more accurate Yeah. Yeah, I know it's not my turn, but I did have a follow-up question related to that as well. In the charter, it noted several times about the Waldorf teacher training certificate. What is the process for someone getting Waldorf trained? Like how much time is a teacher going to have to take? that's not currently Waldorf certified or trained. My understanding is, you know,
045I think there's different programs or different ways teachers can get trained with Word of so it's really looking to see which program might be the best to provide for our staff. I think something there's… We're going to require like five days of water training No, no different than like when our teachers go through the ethnic studies training there's like six six days of training and any other programs that we may decide to implement. will require some numbers of days of training. You know. a part of being a highly effective school, that training will be important to provide. So I think it's really looking to see what is the most appropriate for our staff that are there and provide them the best training that allows them to be at their best. Okay. Maddie, do you want
046to ask a question? I think that was all kind of in the, yeah, I think that's all in the vein of Sheldon's question. The Charter Advisory Council. It says it's collaborative leadership. I don't know what that means and it isn't really spelled out that I could see because I only My power was out all day Saturday, so I only had four days to look at this charter. But it sounds like this council would have authority over budget and hiring and I'm not sure how that… works with our board nor with the leadership at the particular at Valley Vista site. Yeah, the Charter Advisory Council is that. It's an advisory body, and it operates to fulfill a number of responsibilities when the main responsibilities such as the school site council That typically works with the site
047administration as a council to to build their school plan. align with our LCAP. As well as supporting that budget piece that goes along with it and how the money should be spent based on their local needs. So in that sense, they operate essentially as a school city council you know, call it a chart advisory council And I think because there's also other responsibilities that they would like to have. Providing recommendations on maybe things like staffing But there's no recommending to the board But they're not making any of those decisions or approving any of those things without a board authority. So essentially. I think it kind of lays out the three areas that they will operate to fulfill the role, the responsibility of the school site council The purposes of responsibilities designated by law for traditional
048public schools that all of our schools adhere to. collaborate with the principal in the site budgeted processing, much like the school site council would do and share responsibilities for compliance with core principles of the Alliance Public Board of Education, which is Because they're a word of school having some kind of opportunity to kind of opportunity to share in that responsibility of ensuring that the program is running with fidelity. So just to follow up on that. is the Charter Advisory Council what we use at Mary Collins and Penrove? As well. I don't know if they call it a charter advisory council. I don't know of any other cabinet members knows if they operate any differently than calling themselves a school site council but I believe they do have like a charter council okay My kind of
049questions and concerns are really around parent involvement and the the really high thresholds and like it does say legally we can't require parent involvement But I mean, that's been my issue with charters Since day one. So, I mean, I support the most parent and guardian involvement possible of course but I don't want parents to feel obligated to do more than that. I mean, we already hear of parents at other schools that aren't even charter schools saying they feel obligated to put XYZ amount of money up or take PTO just to help at the crosswalk or whatever. So I guess… like seeing 90% parent involvement like scares the scares the blank out of me. Like that's a high number. Yeah, I think it's a broader issue as a district, you know, to what level our parents
050feel obligated to provide donations or fundraising or to contribute I mean, we want parents to be involved in the school. We want them to be a part of decision making. We want them to be involved in And, you know, the overall experience and climate and the culture of the school. And I think we want to encourage that. We definitely want to make sure A number of parents feel obligated or feel pressured or feel They have to commit time that they may not necessarily have. I know that's something that we're trying to address even with athletics. It's just this sense of whether or not Our families are under a lot of pressure. And feeling like they have to give up something for their child to have an equitable experience. I think, as a district is something
051that we We want to make sure across all of our schools. Yeah, relatedly, I saw in some places it was noted as like aspirational, kind of like an LCAP goal, like we want 90% of parents to be involved. than other places, it seemed like it was more like this is what's going to happen. So I think as long as it's explicit once, you know, if everything gets approved and off and running then it's more explicit, like this is an aspirational, not a requirement. So I think that's my follow up to that is that How do you guarantee it is going to be a blending of families and they're there they all have different economic status and everything else and abilities, their jobs and how many people in their families are working and their ability to
052even get PTO. And, you know, it would say that as Waldorf, they always require it, but they can't require it because they're going to be part of our system. So I'm just concerned as how, how is. the school going to and our district going to support these families and make sure that they don't feel this pressure. You can say it. But if it's in the charter. it becomes problematic. I can't remember if we ran across that language in something around not required Peace. This is what we always do, but we can't require it, so we won't. I don't remember where it was. But then on page 45. So yeah, I did see that. Like, this is what we want as Waldorf and then Page 45 does state it as a goal. And so I think
053as long as it stays as a goal and it does say that they'll provide opportunities. I know like my mom, she couldn't do a lot. So even if there's an opportunity, she probably wouldn't have been able to do it. So I think Again, as long as we are not making it some type of a mandate for families. I feel more comfortable. And I think as the overseer of this dependent charter we Those are things that we can monitor and we can monitor and find ways to make sure that our families are not feeling under pressure. Whether that's through surveys or whether that's conversation or having greater opportunity to check and balances, those things will be important. Well, piggybacking on what they talked about, to me, the charter read like This is an independent charter, not
054a dependent charter and a lot of it had to do with requirements for families. But one of my huge concerns is with our EL population. they talk about a BRT. Now, we all know that BRTs are pretty hard to come by. If we find someone and then we tell them, oh, well, you have to go, even though you've been teaching for years and years, you still have to go through Waldorf training. I don't know if that would make them run screaming into the night. If someone said to me. After 30 years of teaching that I had to go through all this different training, I just would have quit. I mean, anyway, so I'm concerned because i'm concerned because from everything you know i looked at the dashboard I read up on the founder. I did
055my homework and Right now, Live Oak does not really have an EL population. And they are… taking, I see it as taking over a Title I school. So I'm really concerned. About our ELs. Where are we going to find the BRT? who's going to be teaching ELs. Do they need to be Waldorf trained as well? So that was one of my huge questions. Yeah, you know. our English learners across our district is a huge concern. For the last couple of years have not been meeting our expectations in regards to what they're doing across the district. So, you know, in one sense, ultimately, as a district, it's our responsibility for our English learners and not necessarily any particular school. We definitely want to work with schools to support ensuring that our English learners are meeting the
056state requirements, the mandates that are required under law. So regardless whether it's a charter school or not, still have to adhere to the requirements and legal responsibilities in servicing our English learners, such as providing them ELD, integrated and designated ELD. And our job is to monitor and provide support and work with their local community to find out what specific needs are needed to help support students who are struggling, whether English learners, students with special needs, low income, foster youth homeless students. Ultimately, it's a district responsibility and all those schools would have to adhere to those state requirements. But would someone like a brt have to be Waldorf trained. we're finding it hard enough to find BRTs right now. So I'm just, you know, I'm kind of curious if that would become a district position and
057They don't have to be Waldorf trained or You know, I'm just really concerned about that whole population the socially economically disadvantaged foster youth, homeless youth. Because Live Oak as it is now does not really have those populations. Yeah, I'll let Jason respond. But in regards to training, to be a certified water school, I think it's 50% that needs to be trained. So 2% certified. the rest of the classroom teachers need to be trained. Yeah. I was whispering it to Tony so he could say it. All of the classroom teachers need to be trained. 50% of them need to be certified. That's for the alliance. membership. And Ellen, to address i mean I think we all understand the concern about making sure we're supporting our English learners and I can just address the staffing part around
058the BRT. not all of our staff are not wanting to do this. There are staff that are interested and I'm I'm pretty confident that we could navigate the staffing part of it, that we still need to make sure we're addressing the needs of our English learners, but I think we can navigate the staffing part of that. So that… That is a concern. I think it's one that we'll be able to work through. I did confirm BRTs do not need to be trained or certified. I keep hearing you say, I think, I think. I don't have a problem with this whole application is there was a lot of buzzwords but no specifics and so that's specifics where my concern comes from. I understand. I'm sorry for not being more specific, but we're talking about individual people
059and I'm trying not to call individual people out. Right. Yeah. Yeah. No, I know. But I mean, when I so I do know which of our staff which of our staff are interested in staying and interested in being part of the Waldorf I know which which of our staff are not. And so when I say I'm confident we can navigate, it's because I have information that that leads me to understand that's without you know what i mean yeah yeah so Yeah, thanks. I do want to clarify it is only the classroom teachers that need to be trained, so not any of the others. certificated. they would be trained because their specialty teachers in their specific areas, but not the BRT or special ed teachers. Okay, Joanna, do you want to Yeah, I had a follow-up.
060comments, which leads into my next question or the next question um So there is so there is socioeconomic disadvantaged population at Live Oak. It's not like there's none. It's about 30%, which is still half of Valley Vista but still There's a population there. And I did like how in the charter it did call out that all activities are covered and they're not going to ask families to Where is it no individual student, family, or class is asked to cover the cost for any field trip instrument, art supply, food, or other material. And I know that's been a big source of discussion. I know that that's what Jamil and his student and alumni student came to speak about today, wanting us to help cover the cost of field trips. I know that's super important, but then
061also it leads into some of the questions that have come up tonight at public comment and that I had myself about the funding. do we foresee this being fully funded by fundraising? that's done by the collective fundraising that's also mentioned and by the site budget as well. So, excuse me, like our other charter, dependent charter schools in our district. this charter would have its own fund within our general fund And it will… Like everything else, it will be self-sustaining. A lot of the conversations, the addition to will come specifically from the charter foundation they will be beginning. the foundation with a balance, whatever the reserves that as live oak closes at the end of this year the board and the school will stay open for about a year and there are legal requirements that their
062funding sources were given under because they are a nonprofit. We do not operate as a nonprofit. So any funds that are not having to be given back to the state for specific reasons will stay within the foundation. That's where you see some of the language about the additional specialty teachers and the real unclear that is to be paid for through fund fundraising and the foundation. So to be clear, like. What is Live Oak as a nonprofit entity will turn into the foundation and that is still a 501c3 so parents that donate can actually write it off on their taxes, whereas parents that donate to Well, I guess if you donate to a PTA, that's also a 501c3. But if you were to donate to a school site, that's not tax deductible. correct up to like
063$300 a year for a public right fund yes and um so Just to touch a little bit more on that, this new charter will receive restricted resources just like all of our other charter schools do. Prop 28 funding. And they will receive lottery and different funding sources like that. Cool. Thank you. Ava, do you have any questions. Olivia, do you have any questions? You're welcome to jump in, but I'm going to go back to Sheldon. Okay. I didn't see any… anything in the charter that describes how the charter itself could be amended. you know my hunch is we haven't dotted all the I's. There's always a document this long there's going to be some things overlooked that we'll discover as we implement. Did I miss something or if not, what is the general process? Maybe
064this is for Esmeralda, I'm not sure, but what is the general process of amending a charter after it's been approved. I think that was… Go ahead, Tony. I think you were addressing that too, but I believe that tonight actually the board will be asked to approve it Pending some minor signs changes. Correct, Tony? Correct. I have some revisions that I would present before your board decides to take action. And we can move to amend it here, but I think what Sheldon's asking is if in six months from now, we feel like we need to amend the charter. What are the mechanisms for us to do that? So the charter will go through a renewal process every five years, and I believe that there is language that says that the district administration and the board will
065work with the charter that the name changed from charter council charter advisory. It's been a couple iterations will work in conjunction to make any changes to the charter. So it can only happen every five years. Like all of our charters. Right. Yes. Okay. Yeah. Maddie, do you have a question? I can also. Pick one to start. With your mic. Yeah. I might have missed this in the charter because again, it was 150 pages that we only had a few days to review. specialty teachers, are they credentialed Teachers? So there would be a mix as there is now. Like, for example, now some of our schools have P elementary schools have PE teachers that are classified staff that we bring in. And we have music teachers that are credentialed. So there's a mix of that. I
066think one thing that we discussed as we were looking at this is that the resources for additional teaching support would be identical to all of our other schools. that they're like the number of of specialty teachers provided through the district channels would be the same. decisions would need to be made about which of those positions are certificated and which ones are classified because there's obviously a big budgetary difference between those two. So that part, exactly which ones are going to be which, the language, I think it was in the MOU was saying that that there will be some flexibility and some discussion about figuring out the particulars of that but that it will be a mix of both. And then it only counts as instructional minutes if it's with a certificated. So like we need
067to be super clear which ones are which at some point so teachers know if they, I mean, they'll know, but Yeah, so that and then we have that now in our other elementary schools. So for example, at some of our schools, they hire classified PE teachers. The teacher is required to be supervising that class because they are the credentialed employee. And our music teachers are credentialed. So that's actually our teachers can go and prep and do other things. So you're absolutely right, but it's not any different than our kind of the current it's not a unique problem. No, no. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Thank you. Yeah. Ellen, do you? I'm also concerned about VAPA, the VAPA committee worked really hard and came up with this great plan to a give our elementary teachers a prep And
068B, expose our students to music and art and drama and dance. And we have those people in place now. And I'm very concerned about their jobs. And, you know, again. Do they have to be Waldorf trained or can you know if they're teaching drama Do they need to have a Waldor certificate? Or whatever. Can we keep… that program that we worked hard to establish that seems to be working fairly well at our elementary schools, can we keep that the way it is now or do we have to let all those people go and rehire back? So part of that plan um once this charter is approved, they will be a part of the plan. So anything that we're having at any of our other schools we would then expand to them. They do not need
069to be Waldorf trained for those types of specialty positions and The new charter will have their own source of Prop 28 funding, so we'll receive additional funding to hire more staff. It wouldn't remove from our current allocation. And the remaining part of the arts and music block grant is already allocated to the current PCS schools and the funding from that was three years ago, so they will not receive a portion of that funding. So that that piece of it will stay in play as is. Joanna, do you have any? I feel like we're going to keep looping back around. So it's also. All right. Yeah, I also wanted to address Some emails we got, also public comment about the classrooms Can you talk about that? the 19 versus 17? Yes. So over the years, there
070have been classrooms at Valley Vista that have been modernized and have included adding walls to create smaller spaces. We did do a site walk with Jamie, myself, Ray, and Lisa. to make sure that spaces could be returned to that had been classrooms returned back to classrooms. We also have additional spaces that have not been used as classrooms in the past, like that we've used for our before and after school childcare. We do have shared spaces at many of our other schools. So that's that is becoming the norm is to share the space. And then we do Also, we have… We currently have three SOCC classrooms on the campus. The intention was only to have three for this year. Over the summer, one of those classrooms was going to move to McNair last year and then
071at the last minute it didn't. So under this new model, there will be at least one SOCC classroom. We do rent a building from the county. that they will read that is on that campus that SOCC will likely remain in. I'm unsure if there will be one or two classrooms next year. a lot of this also, I think we're all super aware of the numbers, the classes that we put in there, the enrollment that is hopefully… we have those students and there is a wait list. So final determination of what goes where, who goes where will kind of be based on enrollment. But when we did do the site work. walk, we do have room for the classrooms. So one's going to likely move to McNair. And then what about the other two? So there'll
072be one there was the plan for it just to be one or is it just going to be one to accommodate this? It was… that comes up really about this time, I think at the last SOCC board meeting, it was just starting to be discussed. One of the problems is the size, the current enrollment size of Valley Vista it's harder to um Sorry. Every meeting, a word escapes me. Sorry. I can't. Sounds like there's less classrooms for the students SOC students to go into. So I know that that not mainstream. It is a different word but So that was already part of the conversation. So going down to two. from one to two, space could play into this because and that is a conversation that we have Every year at all of our sites. on
073what does the enrollment and grade levels, how many do we have in that grade level? So right now, I'm unsure if it would be one or two, but this could be a reason to move it from 2 to 1. So the SOC, I mean, we're not the SOCC board, but I just wonder, because I know that there's SOCC classrooms at a bunch of districts, even outside of PCS, old Adobe wall and others some of the rural ones is that decided on how many SOCC students live in that attendance area or is that decided by the board independently on what space is available? a lot of those classrooms are dependent on space on any given year. But not, it's not like if that there are three classrooms sorry two or three classrooms worth of Valley Vistas
074um What is it? See, now I'm forgetting the word. Students who live in the attendance area of Valley Vista three classrooms worth of those students. No, it is the classrooms are program and age-based. So with the decisions that we made in PCS, do not have anything to do with the student's homeschool. Ava or Olivia, do either of you have any questions that have come up since? Okay. Sheldon, okay. I just have to read this quote because it also goes to some of the other things that were in the charter and that were brought up in a couple of emails. about certain classes being taught at certain grade levels that seem to violate our state standards. like no us history is taught according to their curriculum until eighth grade. Instead, in fifth grade, they teach ancient
075Greek. And then there's I'm sorry, but it's just such a sixth graders undergo physical and emotional changes as they approach puberty. Making it an ideal time to study geology. I guess. I think any time is a good time to study geology, but I don't know what it has to do with how And teaching about you know. you know growing up in puberty and everything else. So that would be in sixth grade. So I just needed clarity on how that will need to change and how how much of the curriculum that we require for our district is going to be taught. When it doesn't seem to be in their curriculum. I think… And, you know, starting around page 12 or 13 in the exchange, it'll break down by grade What general things are being taught. The
076program follows what all of our schools are required to follow, common core state standards. In regards to social studies, they follow the history framework as described in Greek. They do not have U.S. history in there at all in fifth grade, and it is in our state standards. Correct. So I know, like, for example, in fourth grade, they focus on California history, local history, indigenous people, geography In fifth grade, I think ancient civilization I can't remember what sixth grade or seventh grade world history and US history in eighth grade. I guess your question is, should they be teaching US history in fifth grade? then that's something that we can. It does say North American history. Is that what that is? That's probably. North American history is in fifth grade. the colonies. I don't know. It just
077says North American history. Yeah. I looked it up under California state standards and it said history of the United States beginnings. In the charter? In any case, what I'd like to know basically is that our other schools in our district teach fifth grade U.S. history. And so I'm assuming that we should implement that. across all of our schools. I mean, if I can't, I'm trying to translate because I think everyone's saying different U.S. The US is a part of North America. fifth grade here says it teaches North American history. U.S. history is part of North American history. So then… Oh, on there. Yeah. Age 23. Yeah, page 23 says North America. Okay. then I want to go back to the family thing and um I get the point of the family handbook but i'm wary
078of asking parents to sign something that like says they're going, like, I agree with all of the recommendations like they seem very much founded in reality and best practices, but maybe it's my like inner libertarian. I'm like, why is the school telling parents exactly how to parent and like exactly what technology to use or not. Again, like I agree with all of the things like that's what I would do with my… stepkids, but It just feels… too intrusive and controlling to make families agree. And I know that it's not like legally enforceable, but it's still I have no problem with it being sent home, but I do have a problem, I guess, with asking families to sign something? I don't know. Do they have to sign it? Because I know like when we do data
079confirmation, we have to like The family handbook is in there. Somewhere. Bring it out when your kids get in trouble but um i don't Yeah, I guess it just is acknowledging that they've read it. So it's not that different than other it just still feels Well, I think it was mentioned quite a few times. And so that was a concern of mine as well. Only because in the work that I do, sometimes I do see not live oak. But other places, I have seen people have seen people say that a student has violated a handbook policy right And only because it's referred to so many times it was also a concern of mine as well. I don't see anywhere where they have to sign something, but even so, it's still implied as a member of
080the school community. Sorry if I'm speaking for you, Caitlin. No, not at all. We're speaking to as well. And on that like I don't really know what the regularly scheduled class family meetings are it like agreeing to individual family teacher conferences totally makes sense. That's what all schools do, but I don't know what the or the class family meetings are for the grade class. And then, yeah, again, with parental involvement, I don't think We should even imply that it's required to go to these class family meetings. Especially since a lot of our parents have more than one job. And I think they said these meetings are every two weeks. What kind of pressures they're going to be on families to meet that. Is there going to be translation? child care. I just… You know, if
081a family is working one or two or three jobs, which many of our families are. How can they be expected to attend these meetings every two weeks? It just seems really intrusive to me. Again, speaking for Ellen, I think the concern is um how strict is this? like how strict is adherence to the family handbook. I'm going to try to answer that question. I think the answer to that the spirit of of the spirit of of the parent involvement piece is is really ensuring that there's community involvement and collaboration and that the parents are clear and understanding of the experiences that their children will be going through and And having parents be a part of that community strengthens the school. I don't assume that parents are mandated or feel like they are forced to participate
082if they were external reasons or circumstances beyond their control that they can't but encouraging families to participate and be a part of the school is just a great way to strengthen the school. I know when I was a school leader it was something I struggled with just getting families to participate and to be involved because of, you know, the life circumstances they have But I wouldn't. nothing being mandated for parents, but definitely wanting them to be involved is critical piece of building good climbing culture within the school. And I have no problem with wanting to be involved. It's just it seems Maybe the intent is the intent not that way, but it came across to me as to me mandatory. And I'm wondering for those families that can't, what kind of pressure is going to
083play on them are they going to miss stuff because they can't go to these meetings. Will there be translation at these meetings? Will there be child care at these meetings? And if families just can't make it, how are they going to be kept apprised of what's going on. I totally agree. Having families, having parents involved in the community is is excellent. I guess maybe it was just the way it was worded. I just got the sense that you know, these are the meetings You're expected to attend. If you can't attend. Are you going to get… a newsletter that talks about what went on what what are these meetings every two weeks? I want to… So the meetings that happen every two weeks are for the classroom coordinators or like the room parent volunteer the um
084the parent meetings The class meetings are held two times a year, one in fall and one in winter. So I think maybe we can update the language to just to say twice a year for the family meetings and clarify that the other ones are for the room parent volunteers. into the charter. Yeah, that was definitely not clear. Okay. Yep. We can change that. and i i on the family thing like the family I was confused of what is the family handbook because it says attached separately, but I don't really see it. anywhere and so much of what's in here does feel like a family handbook. So I don't know if they're page numbers that are actually the family handbook or if i'm Missing it. Because page 100. Right. It says Appendix C family handbook attached
085separately, but there aren't separate attachments and it doesn't appear to be at the end of the document, but there's so much about family stuff that I wasn't sure if it is I'm not saying it's not there but if we put I don't also see it explicitly. There. It was a separate document and it looks like we may have left it off the… attachment. I mean, I definitely want to see it before I would vote. to approve this since it references the family handbook so many times or i mean Or not mention the family handbook in whatever we do end up approving Yeah. Ellen, do you have a Was that all part of yours or all part of mine? I don't even remember. If you have a new question that's not in that vein i do
086actually um According to Board Policy 6163.4, It outlines student use of tech, which seems to be at odds with the live oak position of using tech. And I'm not talking cell phones. I don't think they have cell phones have any place on school campuses. But we do have a board policy about text and it is that Because they're a charter, they don't have to follow board policies or I'm confused. And what's an enrollment specialist? Well, you know, in regards to tech, I know that in general, all of our schools have like one-to-one devices is used as a tool for learning You know, like different like like our other charter schools, there's some specific things that are part that makes them a charter makes them kind of separate from from how other traditional schools that we
087have operate. And one of the philosophies around this is how they view technology. I don't know if… If technology is a uh is a you know is something that um is something that's expected that every school has that utilizes, that shows any kind of improvement of what happens in the school. But I think as part of it as a dependent charter, having something that that aligns to the program that they're offering. They have different ways to address the learning and the teaching outside of the technology and And I think that's just what makes them the unique Waldorf School. So I don't, I mean, I can look at, I don't not familiar with our technology policy or how that's supposed to be utilized in our school systems. But I know that, you know, like right now
088we're going through a cell phone change policy. So I don't… believe that it hinder students if they have less use of technology. Because it's just a part of a the approach to teaching and learning that makes them unique and that as a dependent charter school fosters that culture that they're trying to create. Much like, you know, PAX has music as built into their charter and things that we would want to make sure that is a part of their experience because it's specifically built in there. So there's specific things in different charters that that i think help build the program that they're trying to establish as well as the culture that they're trying to establish as well. On the family handbook, it did come to us as a sample with the expectation that it would come
089at a later date for board approval. It still needs to be worked out. So it would need to be board approved. Separate. Separately. Sorry. So… do we need to specify that when we pass because it it's part of it. It says that it's an appendix in the charter, so we would need to then amend our that it will come later. Yes, will be added to the appendix once approved by the board. And it's just a sample, so it's not the one that would be approved by the board that would come later once It's approved once the petition is approved. So there'll be opportunities to give input on the family handbook once it comes later okay it will come for an action. Okay. I think there was like a second part to your question and now
090I'm blanking on what it Yeah, I want to know what an enrollment specialist is, what they do. Specialists. It's on page 68. So a lot of these positions that are written in here and discussed are whereas they as Currently in Live Oak, they're independent positions as they operate just as a single entity. These are positions that are also being like rolled into the what we already have. So enrollment specialist would be Like the, I was going to… I was going to call her out by name, like Amy Fideji, who oversees enrollment. It's not a specific full-time position to the charter. She who shall not be named. be their enrollment specialist, whatever that is or would they use their charter funds to hire somebody or to hire somebody So it's my understanding that the plan is
091that as a PCS school, Amy would also oversee the enrollment. Especially because we really enroll as a district and the district of choice. And one other question. How are the main lesson books different from textbooks? You're saying it's in regards to the instructional materials? Are they still using textbooks? Because I just saw a lot of mention to the main lesson books. And is that what they're teaching off of, it sounds like, or is that what they're creating They're creating the main lesson notes. I would love to answer this one. Jessica, if you're okay, I can ask one of LIBO people to come and answer this one specifically. perhaps Kristen or Jessica or Oh, great. That would be great. Yeah, please. Sure, I can speak to that. So the main lesson books, we talk about those
092as our textbooks, but really they're the they're the They're the work that students are creating to demonstrate their learning. So we teach using multiple modalities, including in middle school, we do use some textbooks. And then the students, as they are learning content, are then creating pages that usually incorporate both student writing and artwork. that demonstrates what they understand and then those are put together so they have a record of their learning that Many students actually hold on to long past their time in elementary and middle school. Does that help? Yeah, thank you. But wait, wait, hold on. I'm happy to answer any questions. They're also using textbooks as well. The teachers are teaching from the textbooks and then the students are creating. So main lesson books from the text. So the student that the student
093In Waldorf curriculum, the teachers really create the lessons, right? And we use all sorts of resources. And then the students Yeah. I mean, we call it a textbook. It's not a textbook because it's not something being given to them. It's something they're creating. that becomes their… a way that they can sort of have a record of their learning. So it's very much like a portfolio. Yeah. Any other questions? We good? Okay. Ava or Olivia, anything coming up for Either of y'all. Okay, no pressure. I just don't want to skip y'all. I just have like a comment that I've been thinking about. It's not really a question. But I just remember like Sixth grade and fifth grade and how much drama there was and stuff. And I'm just a little bit worried about like students from
094both schools getting along and I just see like a really big barrier there. That could be, could be not. But I don't know, I just worry about that. I mean, they'll still have their friends from their other school but I, yeah, I don't know. Yeah, on that. note, I know that when we were talking about this Months ago, we had talked about keeping Fourth, fifth, and sixth at Valley Vista So that those kiddos could finish as Valley Vista students. But I know that enrollment has also changed a lot in the past few months. So what What does that look like? I know we can't totally see the future, but is that still a possibility, a reality or Or not? Yeah, we discussed having a way to phase out students who choose to not be a
095part of it and continue on the current track until they Move on to middle school for the fourth, fifth, and sixth graders. We had language around that depended on enrollment and class size. So it's something that we can look at to see what the current numbers are and how many families. I think we did a survey on how many families would be interested in continuing on a separate track. I don't think there was very many at all from what I recall. Yeah. So as of this moment, I don't believe there's a lot of families that want to continue on a separate track. I think most of them left because they were afraid they weren't going to be able to get into another school. And they don't want Waldorf and they The sense I get from
096emails I've gotten is that they did not trust the district to live up to that. promise of having that separate track for fourth, fifth, and sixth grade. And they were afraid that their students would not be accepted. into another elementary school so they They bailed. And that just tells me something so I think, oh, sorry, Tony. So I just wanted to emphasize or just reiterate that, you know, we do have board policy for families that choose especially schools coming from Title I, that choose to not stay at Valley Vista. They have first rights to to um you know, go to another site. So is that made clear to them? I'll have to check to see what kind of community is, but we can definitely over-communicate that and make sure that they understand that we do
097have a board policy on board on families that um families that that leave, for example, Valley Vesa having first rights to Yeah, the emails I got. did not indicate that they really understood that. So they left quickly. I believe our district enrollment specialist made them aware. Yeah, but I just also wanted to speak to Olivia's comment as well. Because this, I mean, we know everyone who's changed a job, every job has a culture Just like every school has a culture and this is going to be a big change coming to that school. And so this was great. Lots of detail, but I would just love to see like a specific plan for the students and families who are staying. to like introduce them to the terminology that's going to be used moving forward on the
098school site. Like, you know, Waldorf boot camp or something like that. Because I know like when I went to Marin Academy, I was like, what are people saying? Like for six months. Because the acronyms are different in different places and just the terms that they use. So I just think it would be really helpful if we could really you know, really just work with the families and students who are staying So that on day one in August. It's not just a welcome ceremony and you know the um Waldorf students know what to expect, but that you know our pcs students understand as well. So. All right, back to you, Sheldon. I think it's been covered. Thanks. And I know enrollment is something that has been, you know. brought up a lot. And so I think
099it might be important to hear from Amy just to share exactly what communication has been had around this? Thanks, Tony. I just want to make sure the board knows that beginning last spring when conversations were really picking up and we were having our engagement nights. I supported somewhere between 30 and 50 families in making a decision for the current school year that we're in. So I actually went on a tour with a bunch of Valley Vista families at McNair. I sat down with them in my laptop afterwards, took their information and we talked about different pros and cons. We were 100% successful in helping any family who wanted to make a transition move to the school of their choice. And as Shireen has pointed out, is not always their first choice because many Valley Vista
100is their first choice. And we, I hold that space very dearly school choice as a principal was always something that was really important to me. And I would tell families like if it's not our school, like I want you to be where you want to be. I take the responsibility very seriously to help all of our families find another place if they don't want to stay and continue. In the last survey that Jamie did and team, which I know a lot of us in the audience are biting our tongues because we're like, oh, we can talk about this, that, and the other. And I know that's not appropriate, but We did find that many of the students who do want to stay are wanting to stay the fourth, fifth, and sixth graders were wanting to
101go the Waldorf route. So that was just our first time. We're going to keep checking in with people as we're working on on enrollment, but we already have a very good system with our elementary schools of students who are currently at Valley Vista. who do want to make a change for next school year. We have an interest list at several of our schools. I have now, Esmeralda and I have met several times and made sure that we're really clear on the board policy. I share that with families. We have a, they're actually going to be applying in schoolment this year so that they're like in the system. We don't have other spreadsheets. So we have a really good system to make sure that everybody And I'm the point person. So we did discover there were
102some families, particularly in first grade. who were getting the sense from calling different school secretaries like there's not, sorry, we only have three spaces left in first grade. Well, that's because Jason and, you know, PFT we staffed For the kids who we knew were coming. So yeah, we usually have a little wiggle room, but we can't just in the middle of the school year, take 20 kids on. So I definitely heard from parents where like they were getting the vibe of go to now, like last month. Or else there might not be room for you. And as I continue to share with families, like we will staff accordingly to where to where you want to go. So I just wanted to share that. Thank you. That's really helpful information. Okay, I think it's my turn,
103but I don't think I have. I don't think I have a question at this point. Ellen, do you have any other questions? Okay. Does anyone else have any other questions? So I think we, I mean, I was taking notes there's at least two modifications that I heard people say they would like to amend, and I think I know, I think Tony has a couple more So how would you like to handle this, Madam Chair? Let's have someone introduce Tony's edits as one motion to amend vote on that and then tackle the next two that you've identified because I think you're right. Okay. Yeah. Can you make a motion, Maddie? I move to amend the charter petition in these areas charter advisory page 60 the faculty selects the faculty representatives Comma. How do I do this?
104And then it originally said who must be with who must be with priority given to Waldorf certified teachers who must be is crossed out. So it goes the faculty selects the faculty representatives with priority given. to Waldorf certified teachers, the parents, guardians, and the rest is the same. All right. So let's leave that one as it is right now. And then do I have a second on that move to amend? Or you don't want to do all of them? No, it's going to get too confusing. Okay. I know that's what I said, but I changed. I moved to amend. No, do you second? I second. Okay. So this is just so this is just the amendment changing who must be to with priority given all in favor of that amendment. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? All
105right. That amendment is accepted. Can I hear a motion for… a second amendment. I move to around on or around page 69 under element five. The principal will be hired through a selection and approval process aligned with the district's process for hiring a new principal. The principal hiring committee includes The PCS superintendent or their designee. Three. Originally, it said Waldorf certified or trained teachers who are members of PFT. collective bargaining unit. The Waldorf certified or trained teachers who are has been crossed out So that now we have three members of PFT collective bargaining unit three CSEA staff members to parent guardian members of the CAC and one additional site principal from another elementary school. Do I hear a second? All in favor of that amendment, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Hearing none, that amendment
106is accepted and then Well, there's one more. Yes. Do you want to? Sure. I move to amend the charter petition on Appendix B. Page 97. There is a sample schedule that shows Thursday as a minimum day. it is i want to be we the district. wants to be clear that minimum day is Wednesday to align with all of the other sites. All right. So I know I'm chairing the meeting. I'm going to move to amend to cross out the word Wednesday, put the word Thursday and then cross out the word Thursday and put the word Wednesday on appendix B. Do I have a second? I second. All right. All in favor of that amendment. Aye. All right. the district amendments are handled Trustee Jen, Vice President Jen, would you like to well i'm not sure
107what the specific modification goes that's the issue. The two topics that i heard this discussion revolve around that needs amending is the family handbook, which doesn't exist yet. And so I'm presuming it's modifying the language you know to say a future family handbook But I'm not sure where that is. And the second thing I, actually the second thing I heard wasn't in the charter and it was addressed by Amy, which is plan to integrate Valley Vista stayers So I've been looking because I'm, yeah, the family handbook was my one of my things. Everything I've been looking at over the past few minutes, it doesn't give me a huge red flags still. I don't think we need to say the future, but I'm definitely open to hearing an amendment if anybody has one they would like
108to make. I've been doing control F and looking everywhere it's mentioned. So Sheldon, you're maybe suggesting on the table of content appendix C family handbook future or to be determined. At a later date, something like that. Okay, I'm going to move to amend that instead of saying attached separately in Appendix C that we say to be determined or to be approved by the board of directors at a future meeting. Do I hear a second? Second. Okay. I'll let Bree decide who was faster on that one. No, no, you both are too good. You're too fast. All in favor of that amendment? Any opposed? All right. that amendment carries. So we've made four amendments in Total, nothing particularly material. No, the fifth issue wasn't really a charter issue. It was just a discussion on the valley
109vista families who are staying. So does anyone have any other amendments they would like to make. All right. Hearing none, any last questions about the charter petition that will inform your ability to make a vote on this. resolution and petition. Not a question, but maybe comment. Just acknowledging that this is a charter petition. The reason why we have charter structures in this state is to meet differentiated demand and you know that's a fancy way of saying When there's a group of parents in the community who have an idea for meeting their educational needs in a way that's a little bit different than what the state prescribes. that there's an opportunity for them to do so. That's why we have dual immersion at McDowell, which we're teaching kindergartners in Spanish, which technically violates some ed code,
110except for the fact that it's a charter. And, you know, my kids went through that a dual immersion in town it was and we had to sign a thing as a parent acknowledging that and it worked out great. What we have here. is, and I want to compare it to an earlier experience we had with magnolia, which, you know, was also differentiated demand. But the big difference here is we have an existing community of parents who are experienced in this and are coming to us. with something that's working already. And it was 300, 300 families plus. That's different than what Magnoli was, which was just like an idea that was cooking. So to me, I feel like you know, there may be some some edits that would have to happen at a later date in
111the charter but i feel like It's ready to roll. I mean, it's just encourage us to approve. Sheldon, it's interesting that you brought up dual immersion because at McDowell There's dual immersion and then there's not. families had a choice and you didn't see families bailing like we've seen. So to me, that's the difference is the difference kind of the lack of choice. I have a lot of thoughts swirling around. I very much want to approve this charter. I'm only worried that it's five years and I'm not against it being for five years. I just hate the idea that we can't Edit it over the next five years. Can I have some… reassurance that there's still ways to adapt and like I know when we deal with Cherry Valley or Pengrove, when things come up where
112we are flexible enough to adapt to them. I guess I just want some reassurance from staff that if something ends up not working or something doesn't feel right to families or we do notice huge disparities in ELAC families no longer being super involved and other families being super like are super involved that we can adjust without necessarily amending the charter or Yeah. I want to say that that language was in the MOU where Any changes to the charter, there's a process for changes to the charter and I think it's in collaboration with charter school. it's not just a one-sided change, but there's conversation and collaboration around what that change might be. I believe it was in the MOU and it might be in the charter petition but i I can pull up what that specific
113language was. There wasn't. It wasn't. Yeah. I have the same concern that Caitlin does. If something comes up or we start getting letters from the community about something I would like to be able to address that and not wait five years to fix something. Yeah, I think we'll look for that particular language. I mean, I can… say that as a district, this is our charter school and we want to ensure, like all of our schools success and to do everything we can to work with our communities and our You know, our staff to ensure that whatever programs we offer to our community diverse options that they have that they're successful and that they're valuable and that they're meaningful for our community. So it doesn't… So things aren't working. There's a process for which we can
114address them. Hopefully we can address them at the site level. But at the same time. Just know that, you know. like we wouldn't want to bring something on that we couldn't successfully ensure is successful. Because ultimately it is our responsibility as overseer of all of our schools. to ensure all of our schools can be successful. and have mechanisms in place to support when things aren't going in the right direction. and yeah and all right i wanted to clarify, I misspoke the five years is for the charter school renewal. State law does allow for material revisions approved by the board to go back. So the material and yeah, the renewal, two different things. I apologize. No, that's very, very helpful. I know. I was like, I know there's no. Is that at any time? With, yes.
115Any other questions or comments before we go to a vote? Yeah. I just want to very quickly Thank you to staff. And all staff and Live Oakak for all staff I mean, this has been an incredibly difficult journey for PCS, I think, and particularly for Valley Vista Historically, I have an old friend who's… kids grew up with my kids and went to Valley Vista when it was 450. kids and um It's just been a jolt to the whole community. And I just want to acknowledge that I know everybody's worked really hard And it's emotional for everybody. and um you know, I just want to thank you for continuing to do the work and to really take my Well, I think all of us but my feelings about things and taking them into account, honoring them
116trying to explain things to me. And I think to everybody else. And so I just want to thank you. I know it's been a really hard time. Thank you. Yeah, I know for myself, I'm asking all these questions because I want the school to succeed. And I'm trying to see into the future and prepare for things that may or may not If I were interested in voting no, I would be sitting back with my arms crossed and not entertaining any of this. And I think… I can definitely say for all of us we are very much appreciate from hearing from people on all sides of this. Everyone wants what is best for our students and for our staff and our families. And having a vacant shuttered campus even for a year wouldn't be good. for
117our community or our families And I'm excited. by a lot of things about this new charter school i'm Really excited to see how people will come together to name it and establish a new culture that brings the best parts of both cultures because both schools are amazing in so many ways Yeah. With that, I'll call the question. amended. The resolution of the resolution is not amended, but the charter is amended So I don't… know where that leaves our motion. One moment, please, while I go back to We voted on the amendments, yes. So I have to see Yeah. But it's heck yeah, let's see. I think to be safe, we should do the resolution and the amended charter petition. Yeah, if we only need to… Yeah, we only need two, but I think to be
118safe, we should also prove the charters as amended. Yeah. The charter petition. Okay. And the chart. Okay. I need a motion for the resolution first, please. I move to approve, wait, sorry, which one first? The resolution. Oh, okay. I move to approve. Resolution 2425-24. I second. All right. I'll do a roll call vote. Trustee Cloud. Aye. Trustee Jen. Aye. Trustee Pahn. Aye. Trustee Webster. And I vote aye so the resolution passes. And then can I have a motion to accept the charter petition as amended? I move to approve the charter petition as amended. All right. I will do another roll call vote. Trustee Cloud. Aye. Trustee Jen? Aye. Trustee Pahn? Aye. Trustee Webster. And I vote aye. So the charter petition is approved. And with that, I'd like to give us a five minute break.
119All right. I'm going to reconvene this meeting at 818. All right. So moving on to the CTE television network. student television network. conference. Can I hear a motion? I move to approve the uh student field trip to Florida. I second. Okay. So there's a motion and a second so it's on the table Does anyone have any questions or comments? about the field trip or its funding. Go for it, Sheldon. Thanks. I understand that this field trip is being funded by our grant, our CTE grant, which is our grant I think it's great because I don't think I would feel comfortable approving this amount for a field trip through general funds. But my question is has our CTE grant budgeted for this level of expense on field trips. Talking to our CTE coordinator. who went through
120the process of looking He gave assurances that there's sufficient funds to support this particular trip. And I think as we move forward, how we can expand these opportunities K-12. I mean, essentially, we're offering it down to seven seventh grade as well. And I know, you know, really two issues around this issue around providing these students these opportunities, which seems like a great opportunity. And then the broader issue of you know other schools that have to fundraise or get boosters to support a lot of their field trips. And we did an analysis of all of the field trips Well, the typical field trips that we approve every year, the ones that require donations and boosters. You know, things like sixth grade overnight field trips, outdoor education. Westminster Woods Outdoor Education, all those things that typically the
121board approves. that total that families have had to fundraise is about around $150,000, $160,000. So… across our district, yeah. The ones that are typically generally they do every year. Correct. Yeah. Overnight field. These are overnight field trips Knowing that number, that gives us kind of an idea of what we can do to explore ways to support it so the families don't feel like they're obligated to do that. And Amanda and I will work on how we can find opportunities, whether it's through grants or whether it's through supplemental, whether it's through CTIG, ways that we can potentially alleviate these burdens from our families. Now that we kind of have an idea of how much we are approving every year. I would just like to um talk about the value of this kind of a field trip.
122I used to take students to Washington, D.C. And just being around other students It's invaluable. And for a CTE conference, I imagine it's even more invaluable than it would be going to DC. I just think these kinds of field trips Unfortunately, they're expensive but really necessary in certain areas. All right. If there are no further questions or comments, go for it. So I did want to know Because I searched just relatively quickly just through some past board agendas and things to see when CTAG was mentioned and wasn't mentioned often. So I was just wondering, and this doesn't have to be tonight because I know I am springing this last minute. But how much is left in the CTIG grant? Unless you have that right now? but then also This is the large amount of money
123for a small amount of students. I am glad it's grant funded, but I would like for this to be like the norm. where we are able to fund these big ticket trips for students and chaperones and teachers at no expense to them. We know that we've talked about we've seen Wildlife museum trips that are like 850 per student And they're doing a ton of fundraising to cover the now 60% of students who need scholarships for those. I would love to even see do this even further and provide opportunities for other groups as well. to have theirs fully funded so All right, then I called a question. All in favor of approving these, I don't even know what to call like the students going to the conference Television Network conference. No, I know. I can read
124it. We're not approving the conference existing, though. Yeah. All right. All in favor of approving the attendance of the students at the conference say aye. Aye. Any opposed? All right. The students are going to the conference. And the chaperones. Please send them with chaperones. All right, moving on to second reading update to board policy about employee use of technology. Can I hear a motion? I move to approve, update the board policy 4040. Any questions or comments? We reviewed it last week. Anyone have anything? All right. All in favor of approving this update to board policy, say aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? All right, moving on to the second reading of update board policy regarding student use of technology. Do I hear a motion? All right. Any questions or comments? on this board policy that we
125also reviewed. Last week. Hearing none, I'll call the question. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Hearing none that update to board policy passes We went on to new course proposals. Again, this is a second reading of ones we looked over last week. Is this less than, oh, sorry. I need a motion. Yeah. I move to approve the new course proposals. I second. All right. Is this less than, I feel like we had four last week. Am I going insane? Okay. They were just, okay. Yeah, that was the second reading of those. And they said, okay. There's a lot. Yeah, go for it. I have an informational question. I always thought that that CTEs We're three years. the third year being the capstone. And this one is two years. So is there any kind of rules
126about that or Yeah, so CT pathways can be three years or two years. It can just be a concentrator and a capstone. It doesn't necessarily have to be an intro concentrator or capstone. All right. I'll call the question. All in favor of approving these new course proposals. Aye. Any opposed? All right, the new course proposals are approved. Moving on to discussion and information. We don't need a motion. Jason, can you tell us about the results from the community survey on budget cuts? I can. Do you want to put up? Yeah, let's do it. Can you get that up for us? the attachment in the discussion. It's on the agenda. It's under discussion under human resources. The results from community survey. Okay, so before we go into these, let me give you a quick little background.
127I put some of it in the description, but so we held a community meeting um We have the budget advisory is one track. We have a budget advisory that Amanda runs. on another track, I had worked with Superintendent and cabinet to have like a community engagement track that wasn't specifically about budgets and like what are the numbers and what are we going to cut but focus on what are the things that are important to us as a community? Like what are the as we're considering things to cut, like what are the things that are most important in our priorities? And we anchor that in the board, some of the goals that we had in our LCAP. And so we met on November 14th. And there were themes that came up. So we had probably about,
128I want to say maybe about 25 people. We ended up with four different tables of groups. It was, um, we had We had a good, good cross representation um And as we looked at all those results, some themes came up. And I worked with cabinet and then I worked with Sheldon a little bit on taking those themes and moving a lot of those themes were focused on like people or positions. And I tried to move that into a survey that asked questions if you saw that we're more focused on the impact of those. So instead of saying. like how important are reading specialists like it was a question like it's very important to read by third grade or the things that those positions try and serve. So you can probably see the intention on that
129survey. Moving it over a little bit. So, um. So you could see some of these are self-explanatory like the the um I can't see what that says because I'm too far away. I have it here. Okay, hold on. I'm 53. I need my glasses for that. So obviously, who took it? We had a large number of parents and guardians. We got good representation um from our classified and certificated employees like you know we had a, there was a lot of people that did the survey in just the week times that it was open. We saw that we had a fair amount of, it was almost pretty representative, like we had a third a third and a third of our of our different levels. For terms of what levels do they teach or do they have
130children at? And then you really get into the meat of it with question three, which was the most important four priorities for the district. And that's we wanted to just provide this for you as you prepare. We're going to be going in January, like just to give you some information, here's what were the most important things according to our community. And there are varying levels. Obviously, the things that jumped out to me was the top four the mental health, the school safety and emergency preparedness, having students be able to read by third grade, and then We had supporting students with disabilities. So there were other ones that had equal, you know, had some high marks, but those were the four that jumped out to me. And the intention on this, we did get a lot
131of open response responses, but they also had a lot of information that I wasn't about to put in a board report because they mentioned individuals. So that's going to take a a long time to go through now able to be able to share that with you. My goal is to get you something from that for when we maybe as we come back into the new year. But we really wanted you to have this information to help you as you help make decisions around any budget cuts. And we're having another community meeting on this Thursday night. I'll be sharing some of these results. We'll be having some more dialogue. we'll be able to share anything that comes out of that. Amanda's leading a budget advisory committee with our voting members on January 9th. And she's planning
132on the 14th being able to give you an update because we won't be making a decision on the 9th, we'll be discussing things. We're hopeful that when we come back to you on January 14th, that given this data, given any information, that if there's any any direction, any input, any guidance you want to give the budget advisory committee before they make the recommendation to the superintendent. that we have that from you at the outset. Like we don't want to be discussing maybe putting something on the blocks to be cut that is as a board, you're saying absolutely not. We want to make sure we're being efficient with our time and considering the things that are reasonable to consider, if that makes sense. Just wanting to give you information and give you like the direction that
133we've been working at as a cabinet on how to move forward with engaging all all parts of our school community. As we go through a hard process of making some choices. So you didn't include other comments because they were more person personnel related? There were some that were. And just, yes, I mean, we had… And off the top of my head, I want to say we didn't have 800 comments, but we had well over 100 and almost 200 comments and some of them were lengthy. Some of them mentioned specific people or specific positions. by name or by position, but often even by name. And so that's one that we need to go through and make sure that we're sharing information with you that is like appropriate for a very public setting like that. So yeah,
134I would love to have had it ready for tonight, but it's just too much. So, yeah. Anyone have any questions or comments? I love this survey. It's so different. And it's I found the results really interesting. Did you, I'm sorry, I think I missed. when you gave this, I mean, was it during one of the community meetings that you gave the survey or was it was it sent to them afterwards no so the community meeting that we did I gave them I had handouts and we first we shared why we're doing this like there is this budget process going on and we want to be able to give the district information about what's important to us as a community. And I gave them a list of all the goals and the district goals. They talked
135in small groups to come up with each group had, these are our priorities. And so I took, they gave us three to five priorities in each group from those four groups. I then use that to develop. Here's the themes that people are saying are important. And we use that as the piece to develop the survey that then went out to everyone. And so I think I put in here the dates of the survey It was very short. Like the… it was essentially like a week, like it was a week survey but it was Let's see right here. Yeah, it was from Friday, December 6th to Thursday, December 12th. So we did it just last week. Just last week, got it going and then and then brought it here. But the community meeting was what was
136the first, like the launch pad into figuring out what are the right questions to be asking. based on what resonated with our with our communities. Super helpful. Thank you. Okay, good. All right. Thank you, Jason. Moving on to future business, this is the part where we all cry. Our future business is that Vice President Jen is leaving us. So he's going to… He is going to say a few words. No, he's not literally leaving right now. I've been waiting for this. Yes. I've been waiting for this. You guys… I am in my day job, I'm a professor and my classes are typically three hours long. So buckle up because I've got a message for you. No, seriously, I want to take this opportunity to express my gratitude admiration and best wishes to the people in
137this room. And anyone watching online who have dedicated their careers to public education and speaking directly to the teachers, staff. administrators and leaders of Petaluma City Schools. And I hope the families who are listening to this consider it a call to generously support these workers who have dedicated themselves to educating our children. Our daily work in PCS is a never-ending series of cycles, activities, emergencies, celebrations, crises, negotiations. all coming at a pace that rarely gives us the opportunities to reflect on the long-term direction of our district and how it serves Petaluma across generations. And this setting will become even more challenging in coming years with declining enrollment. budgetary stressors and a political leadership at the national level that looks very skeptically at public education. This can lead to our demoralization and burnout if we are
138not intentional about our motives. So it's important to me to pause lift our chins above the daily demands of our labor. and see how far we've come. where we're going and recognize our own contributions to that trajectory. We tend to look at our work in public education on the scale of periods, like subjects. Days, academic turns, or even years When progress can seem agonizingly slow or even absent. Think of the complex issues we have slowly grappled with over recent years. Returning to in-person instruction, advancing dual immersion instruction. electrifying our transportation fleet. building out our solar energy and microgrid capacities. and even moving toward a seven periods high school schedule. Instead, I encourage us to occasionally consider our work from the scale of your career. or generations when the work you do now is an extension
139of past educators work that brought us to now. and connected to future educators work in a setting that we are only imagining now. From that perspective, it becomes very evident that to work in public education is an act of hope. It is pressing forward with minute changes in the present. Knowing that those minor changes accumulate to alternative futures for the next generation of students. Let me explain what I mean. I lost my mother this summer and my father 11 years ago. So lately I've been thinking a lot about the arc of my family's history from my parents and their parents in China. to me and my siblings in the United States, to our children and their lives ahead of him, them. Hoping that each generation manifests and extends the dreams of the generations before them.
140My parents immigrated from China in 1955 following the communist revolution. and first settled in San Antonio, Texas. which was a segregated city at that time. They witnessed and lived the literal divisions in a city between black and white, often feeling uncomfortable about not being in neither group. They recognize that if their unborn children were to have a better chance at integrating into the US, they should have American names. to make it easier on the dominant culture to accept them as part of their community. So my parents, being completely unfamiliar with American names ask their neighbors to give them a list of names. from which they chose mine and my brother's. My parents always called this bar Chinese names, but our birth certificates record our American names. Even our family name, Jen. was given to us
141by an immigration officer who mispronounced our Chinese name with a Mandarin reading. and proceeded to phonetically spell our family name accordingly. The actual Cantonese pronunciation of our family name is Jan. But later, when my parents finally saved enough money from washing dishes and cleaning homes to consider investing in their own business. No commercial bank would give them a loan. And they were unaware of any government loan programs that they might be eligible for. So they resorted to the Chinese underground market to help fund their startup restaurant. This feeling of separateness from community and isolation is common among all minoritized populations, not just immigrants. So when I learned of these things, these experiences of my parents in the US, When I was in my 20s. I asked them what seemed to be a logical question. Why
142didn't she immigrate to Hong Kong? The city-state was a colony of the United Kingdom at that time, and my father could have pursued his dream of being a lawyer and my mother could have pursued her career as a teacher. Their answer stunned me. you said, despite the flaws in America, they saw a promising trajectory there. for their unborn children. They knew their contribution to it would be slow and difficult with no English language skills. or social capital to navigate the systems of their adopted country. But they saw hope in what this country was becoming. and what their children could become there. And so they acted on that hope, not just for themselves at that time, but for the next generations of their family. that they plan to start in the United States. It was an
143intergenerational hope. That they knew they might not experience themselves, but expect it for their children. real progress moves on that timeline. This is well understood by advocates as well as academics who study social change. Change is slow, but the good news is that on the temporal scale of generations, it almost always moves in a positive direction. Martin Luther King expressed this when he said, the arc of the moral universe is long. But it bends towards justice. In his own lifetime, he wasn't able to see much of that progress in social justice that he fought for. But from our perspective, this generation now, it's obvious how he contributed to that nation's trajectory. Danielle Allen also exemplifies this historical perspective on progress. She's a Harvard political theorist and a MacArthur Genius Fellow. who published a beautiful article
144in 2020 called the flawed genius of our Constitution. And in it, she, a black woman, explained why she loves this country and its constitution. Despite the fact that the document counts her own great-great-grandfather as only three-fifths of a person. Her reason is because the Constitution expected the country to change. to evolve and to improve. and not to remain the same country the founders established. She wrote, the framers don't own the version we live by today. we do, the document is our responsibility now. The document allows every generation of Americans to hope for an even better country and to act on that hope. Danielle Allen shares that hope. a hope for what this country will become. and how it will live up to its ideals for justice and equality. This country's history is filled with these
145historical arcs that bend towards justice. For example, at the founding of this country. voting was restricted to white male adult landowners. But over the centuries, that fundamental democratic right has only been expanded to include more and more segments of our community. to black men in 1870. to women in 1920. Native Americans in 1924, Asian Americans in 1952. English illiterate and language minorities in 1965. and 18-year-olds in 1971. Or take our public schools as another example. The first public schools in California were established in the 1850s, but really, truly weren't open to the public. they explicitly excluded Black, Asian, and Native American children. But even before that century is over. separate but equal schools were established for black students. And about 70 years later, racially integrated schools would come. And even undocumented children's right to public
146education would be reaffirmed and upheld by federal court in 1997. In our little corner of the world and period in history, we see evidence of this ourselves. I still get goosebumps when I think about that board meeting we had about three or five or about four or five years ago. When several of our own high school students came to this room. and demanded that we diversify our narrative. that we expand the readings in our curricula to include stories of people and identities that reflect the diversity of Petaluma and the country. that students and staff read books and stories of varied histories and experiences so we might develop our empathy for others. These were mostly seniors advocating for this, knowing full well that they would not see the outcomes of their advocacy. But they did it
147for the students who would follow them. They hoped for a better education for their younger peers and they acted on that hope. And so did the adults. At last month's board meetings, we read the proposals for three new courses that would explicitly explore The experiences of minoritized populations as students study literature, history, and ethnic studies. Next year's high school students will benefit from the hopes of students and staff who advocated for this years ago. without having experienced the benefits themselves. Progress is slow for sure. But consistently bending towards justice. toward the expansion of rights and the expansion of our circle of community. And this is why I claimed at the start of these remarks that working in public education is fundamentally an act of hope. You all will continue to serve students that we have
148right now in our classrooms, and I know you will continue to do so with all your heart and energy. At the same time, I encourage you to regularly think about what Petaluma City Schools will be for the children of our current students. How much better will it be? In what ways will it be better? that vision that you have in your mind is your hope for public education in general. and Petaluma schools specifically. So now you have to ask yourself. What are the actions to take today that put us on a path of realizing that hope? I deeply thank you for the privilege of working with you in service to our students. It has been my honor to do so. And as a community member, I will continue to support this wonderful team. at Petaluma
149City Schools. Thank you. Thank you, Vice President. Now I'm going to cry. Do I leave now? No. Sheldon will miss you. Very much. You've been incredibly appreciated on this board, your ability to form questions. I think all of us are thinking and can't quite oh now she's crying. I'm going to cry. Just, yeah, thoughtful questions, ability to get us back on track and really get to the meat. of the matter or the tofu of the matter. I'm vegetarian. the way that you always take everything incredibly seriously but still bring levity and humor and humor Hope. Thank you. Let's just frame that like up under. This, Amy? Teaching is fundamentally an act of hope. not be like our make sure you cite Dr. Jen too when it goes up. Yeah, because we do have All right.
150If no one else has comments right now, there is something later on the agenda as well but We wanted to give Sheldon a chance to say his peace. Wonderful piece. Yes, SF State was smart to hire him and make him an assistant dean. Moving on to organizational meeting, we are going to move to our oath of office for office new board members or So I don't know, Tony, are you doing this part? Good. Okay. Then I would ask Ryan Williams to Join me at the podium. Right. Under the government section 1360 in Article 20 of the state constitution. By the power vested in me from the state of California and the full PCS Board of Education. Please raise your right hand and repeat after me. Hi, Ryan Williams, do solemnly swear. That I will support
151and defend the Constitution of the United States. And the Constitution of the State of California. And the Constitution of Against all enemies, foreign and domestic. That I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States. and the Constitution of the state of California. And the Constitution. that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion. And that I will. well and faithfully discharge. The duties upon which I am about to enter. The duties are about to… dues upon which I am about to enter. Congratulations, Board Member William. And congratulations to Ryan's family as well for being here. Thank you. Yeah, we got to do a little, yeah. All right. And… It's Ellen Webster. Okay. Under Government Section 1360, Article 20 of the State of Constitution by the
152power vested in me from the state of California, can the full PCS Board of Education. Please repeat after me with your right hand raised. Hi, Ellen Webster, do solemnly swear. Hi, Alan Webster, do solemnly swear. that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States. And I will support the Constitution of the United States. And the Constitution of the state of California. And the Constitution of the State of California. Against all enemies, foreign and domestic. against all enemies, foreign and domestic. That I will bear true faith and allegiance. that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States. To the Constitution of the United States. And the Constitution of the state of California. And the Constitution of the state of California. that I take this obligation freely. Without
153any mental reservation or purpose of evasion. without any mental revolution. without any mental reservation. Without any mental reservation. Or purpose of evasion. Or purpose of evasion. And that I will. well and faithfully discharged. Well, faithfully discharged. The duties upon which I'm about to enter. duties upon which I am about to enter. Congratulations, board member. That's right. All right. I like having six of us up here. Can we just And even number wouldn't be good, but it feels nice right now. Moving on to nomination and election of board officers. So from here on out, Sheldon, you don't vote but Moving on to nomination and election of board president, do I hear a nomination? I nominate Caitlin Quinn. I reject that nomination. So then what do we do? We have to second the rejection. No, no. Secondly.
154What do we, you reject? I reject the nomination for board president. Yes. Okay. I nominate Madeline Riley Cloud as board president. I second that nomination. All right. I am accepting. And she's really excited about it too. I accept nomination. All right. All in favor of Madeline Leota, Riley Cloud. As board president, please say aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? All right. We have elected Maddie Cloud as our board president, but for continuity, I think I'm going to keep running this meeting unless you're dying to. No. All right, moving on to nomination and election of the board clerk slash vice president. I nominate Caitlin Quinton for vice president. board clerk. I second. I accept that nomination. All in favor. Hi. Aye. Any opposed? All right. I will be board clerk and vice president. Yay. Moving on to
155appointment of the superintendent to secretary. We do this every day we do this every time, except Luann's not here and we're appointing her, so we don't get to ask if she consents or not. I don't think she has a choice. Yeah. Yeah. I moved to a point the superintendent and or acting superintendents to board secretary. I second. All in favor, please say aye. Any opposed? All right. Congratulations. Really, Bree. You get to. Thank you, Bree. Secretary, the secretary. All right, moving on to selection of representatives and alternative representatives to fill vacancies to the Sonoma County Committee on School District Organization. Can someone remind us what this is again. I know we do it every year. selected will receive the absentee ballot once a year. who have left the 11th member board. there's no other function
156to it. Great. I moved to nominate Ryan Williams. That's who I was going to nominate. I second. I accept. All right. All in favor? Aye. And then do we need alternatives early or no? Cool. Congratulations, Ryan, on your first assignment as board member. Moving on to selection of… board meeting dates. Did everyone review I mean, this is for this year, so I don't think any of them really changed. Cool. Okay. I wasn't sure if it was like a test for us. Yeah, perfect. Any questions or comments about the dates? totally fine for a board member to miss a meeting or two. We just ask if you know that you communicate just so that we always make sure we have quorum and don't disappoint the public but i don't I don't think we've ever had a
157meeting where it's only been even three of us. I think there's always been at least four. So you're allowed to get sick. You're allowed to even go on vacation. You're allowed to go to Antarctica. As long as you don't fall and break your freaking arm again. Yeah, you're not supposed to break bones. You're not supposed to break anything. All right. She's risking it all. Our board president is risking it all. Okay, all in favor of the proposed board meeting dates, please say aye. Hi. Oh, did I have a, no, we need a motion. We can't just do that. I need a motion. I move to approve the selection of board meeting dates. Second. All right, now all in favor of the board meeting dates. Aye. All right, so moving on to recognition of board members.
158We have a resolution Commending Sheldon is it yawn Jen, okay. I was like… Okay. Well, trustee slash Vice President Jen for his service as a trustee for Petaluma city schools Does anyone think they can read it into the record without Crying. Okay. Well, you can also cry if you do. Thank you. Whereas Sheldon Jen has served as a trustee I believe we need a motion before. Oh, yeah. See, I'm just, can I have a motion? I move to approve resolution 2425-23. All right. Now that it's on the table, please. Where at Sheldon Jan has served as a trustee of Petaluma City Schools since he was originally appointed to the position in 2019. and has performed his duties in exemplary manner. And whereas Sheldon Jen has been a champion for equity, access, and student achievement both
159in and out of the classroom. And whereas Sheldon Jenn has been instrumental in the development of the Petaluma Promise with Sonoma State University. guaranteeing emissions to Petaluma students as well as ensuring all students are taking an A through G aligned course sequence, whereas Sheldon Jan always takes a unique approach to looking into the institutional barriers that negatively influence student learning and has champion PCS's Ethnic Studies graduation requirements. And whereas Sheldon Jan has frequently used his insight and knowledge to guide Petaluma City schools through complex challenges Such as those posed by the COVID-19 pandemic. Now, therefore, be it resolved. The Petaluma City Elementary and Petaluma Joint Union High School District's Board of Education does hereby commend Sheldon Jen for his dedicated service, expresses its appreciation for his tireless commitment to the students and families and extends
160its best wishes for his future endeavors. Anyone have any comments? Good. That's good. Let's go. Bring on the tears. from the beginning of our work together on the board. Well, actually, even before the beginning. when we were interviewing you for the position. The last question we asked was. of you was what question do you have of us? And you asked us, what book are you reading? And it was so, it was like, whoa. This guy's different. And it was wonderful. We had this whole conversation about books. It was wonderful. So from the beginning, I have said to many people that I wanted your brain. I love the way you think about complex issues. I love the way that you can distill these complex things into understandable chunks and devise the right insightful question. or comment
161that goes to the heart of the matter. And I always really appreciate that. And I admire it tremendously. It has been a privilege. to work with you over these five years. too much to be said right now. I will miss you and your brain, your humor, your congeniality. In your presence. little things and big things. you have changed our district. And… you help me focus my thoughts. And you always have student success. as your buckets. Thank you. Well said. I second that. Thank you. I already said my piece because I got too excited. I probably should have written something down, but I don't even know what to say. I'm going to do so much, Sheldon. Yeah, I just feel like… just your equity lens, your lived experience that you bring to the board, having a
162first gen Not student, but now adult teacher is just so valuable and insightful and just the way that you're always fighting for student achievement and equity and You always help recenter us when we go on our rabbit trails and just like maddie Even pre you serving with us, I remember how many people did we interview? Like 15 or 17? How many? 14. I think it was 14. It was a lot. It was a lot. And I was like, okay, this person's okay. But then when it came to you, I was like star circle, I'm done. Like that's from the beginning. So I've just. I don't even know what to say. I'm going to miss you. I appreciate you. And thank you for everything you've done for our students. Yeah. And Sheldon? Like Maddie, I really
163appreciate your brain. And the way… through your thoughtful questions and comments, you helped me better understand certain complex issues and I needed that help and I really appreciate it. You will be missed a lot. And thank you for being part of our board. All right. I don't know if we need to amend the resolution, but Williams is voting on it, not Jen. Just… Putting that out there. Yeah. Do I need to move to amend that part Okay, I don't think so because it's, yeah, it's just for record keeping, right? Okay. All right. Well, it is on the table. So I'll call the question all in favor of approving resolution 2425-23. Please say aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Any abstention? All right. Hearing none, we… officially commend Sheldon Jen for his service. As a trustee for
164Petaluma City Schools and call on him for future volunteer opportunities as an involved parent and community member. Yeah. And with that We will adjourn the meeting at 9.04 p.m.