001Are you ready for me? I reconvene us to open session at 6.01 p.m. and Trustee Cloud will lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the class. All right. We didn't take any action in closed session, so we will move on to special recognitions reports and presentations, starting with a report from McDowell Monarchs. The notes. Can I use yours. Good evening, everyone. We are happy to be here today with our student leadership from McDowell Elementary School and the Dual Language Immersion Academy. So this group of students has been working very hard on their festive presentation to show you this evening of what has been happening at our school. And thank you to Mrs. Nealon and Mr. Siegemond who have taken charge of this leadership team and the students have been meeting each
002week after school in order to prepare this as well as fun events for our school. So I will let them take it from here. Yes, you're good. Was the night before winter break and all through McDowell. Excitement was stirring. We've got so much to tell With pathways of Learning, our students do thrive in English and Spanish success is alive. With buddies for eating young and old pair, they practiced with patience a bond they do share. Leadership and confidence, they grow side by side. Together, they flourish with learning as their guide. At the Ag Fair, we learned about crops on the earth, our environmental field trips enriched with knowledge and mirth. In our garden, we nurture both plants and seeds of the mind. Our garden volunteers share lessons in nature of the hands-on kind, from seeds
003to harvest, the learning is real with teamwork and care, the growth we do feel. With art docens guiding, creativity blooms and VAPA supports the arts in our rooms. Our students explore, imagine, and play, bringing beauty and stories to life every day. On Pathways with Nature, our students explore by learning outdoors, they grow even more. Creating green schools. a bold goal. Oh, yeah, a bold goal for the entire county Environmental literacy we proudly proclaim. our joga our joga-thon spirit brought part and delight. We raised just over 48,000 magnificent sight oh neighboring businesses, the support came in strong together we know how our teamwork belongs. Festive night lit with candles so bright. Dia de los Muertos brought joy and delight. Our students achieve with dedication in mind. Waterly awards brought their hard work to light. With effort
004and pride, they showed us their best, earning recognitions for passing the test. Costings and laughter of spookiest play. Our Halloween parade broadened the day. with witches and superiors marching in line, Islam tradition, fun every time. Preparing for Moana Junior with songs to rehearse, our students are stars in this magical verse. Safe Browsing Ruby showed courage and grace. Together, we've built a community safe space. with building blocks and bridges. grant to purchase books that inspire our readers who are higher fueled by this fire. Happy holidays to all and a bright new year. Awesome. Thank you, McDowell. That was amazing. Yeah. And we're not going to plug anything over here. We're going to do a quick mixture of you guys since you're all so festive All right, you guys. You guys look amazing. That was so fun.
005You ready? All right, Victor. Victor, ready? One, two, three. Say McDowell cheer. One, two, three. McDowell cheer. Great. Nice job, you guys. Okay, thank you. All right. High schools, what cheer and rhymes do you have for us? I'm just kidding. Thank you. Yeah. Do you want me to do anything? Okay, good. Hello, I'm Ella Steiner. I'm representing Petaluma High School. Hi, I'm Lila Partridge and I'm representing Casa Grande. Okay, so this is our report starting in about late September. So we're going to start off with our homecoming dance. At Petaluma, our whole homecoming was themed Olympics. So here we have some of our teachers standing on a little podium. And then we have an overhead shot of what the dance looked like. Unfortunately, I didn't have any photos of the in dance because all of
006our person, like our photographer who like took the photos couldn't get back to me in time with the photos. But on the top right, that is our flyer that we posted on our Instagram with the theme revealing and the ticket prices. And then on the bottom right, those are our two assistant principals taking a photo with one of our background drops at the dance and they were chaperoning as well. Okay, next up we have Petaluma High School's homecoming parade. So each class had a different theme kind of having to do with an Olympic sport. So seniors had surfing Junior said boxing. Sophomores had golf, and freshmen had soccer. So here's some pictures of the floats being built, and then here a picture of us in our senior spirit outfits on the float building day. And
007that was one of my favorite days of the school year because I just got to Spend it with all my friends building our float. And then after that was the game. No. Oh, there we go. Okay. So on the left, this is Petaluma's game. It was… Once again, USA themed for the Olympics It was really fun. We didn't end up winning, but… It's okay. The spirit was high. This is also our football game. Our theme was pink out. And we also had our homecoming royalty during halftime. In the middle-ish, those are our four homecoming winners. who represent our graduate profile categories of personal vision, highly employable. civically engaged and broadly literate. And then, yeah, so we won our homecoming game. Oh, okay. Okay, next up we have Egg Bowl. Lila's going to talk about this.
008We also want egg bowl. You can see the trophy on the top right. But we won the dance competition Actually, there was no winners in that one. No, we had a mascot dance off and Petaluma did win that. That's that picture in the lower right. Yeah, April was tremendous. This was actually the first and only eight ball I will get to go to and it was one of the best experiences for a football game I ever had. So yeah. It was awesome. Okay, now we have a more recent event this was Holiday Market, they had… Fair, just kind of a fundraiser to make money for clubs. Our senior class, we sold Shirley Temples to raise money for prom. That was a hit. Me and Olivia spent some time making those. And then do you want
009to talk about yours? Yeah, so for all her… our holiday fair, it's kind of the same general idea. A bunch of our clubs sold items, as you can see in the bottom right. That's Mr. McSweeney. He bought a Elroy's burrito donated. Bye, Elroy's. Bye. I can't remember. I believe it was the dance club that he bought it from. Our seniors this year did DIY Dutch, so that was awesome. Okay, this is something Petaluma High School does every year. We make snowflakes. And we write each student's name on them. And then we hang them up in the hallways. And the idea is that you can find your name on your snowflake and take it home. And so that's a picture of us coming in during our Thanksgiving break to hang them all up. And then that's
010kind of a picture of what they look like. And they cover all the windows of the hallway and it looks very pretty. Next is our winter spirit weeks. Our Winter Spirit Week is currently going on right now. So today was on the slopes. Monday was Grinch day. So like wear green Tomorrow will be ugly Sweater. Thursday will be candy cane, so like wear stripes. And then Friday will be Holiday Jam. So rip you, Jay. And then ours was last week. So we had grout fit day on the slopes, ugly sweater, pajama day. And then we had a day where you could bring a cup that was anything but a mug and you could get free hot chocolate in whatever your vessel was. And that was a hit? And yeah. So next is just a couple
011little updates and acknowledgments to some of our sports. Ryan Rice, Alex Giacomini, and Hadley Bushey all won all tournament at their respective basketball tournaments last weekend. And girls soccer won their game against Maria Creo. It was a hard-fought game and the girls enjoyed playing in it. There's one more. So another cool thing that Costa Grande is going to be doing this year is we are getting a peace pole. A peace pool is a pole that is being donated by Interact Club with Rotary. and displays the word peace in eight different languages. Peace polls are customized to each location. to ensure the proper demographics are included, Interact Club hopes to place their peaceful In the field next to the language classrooms as the poll represents inclusion despite any barriers. And then there's no pictures of this,
012but currently at Petaluma High School, we have our annual holiday cheer. We were collecting canned food items and snack foods and feminine products and donating them to cots. So that's currently going on too. And that's it. Thank you guys. Great job. Thank you. And now we're going to move on to our students of the month and semester. Trustee Webster, would you like to hand out the Great. So we'll start with Kenilworth. We have two students of the month for December as well as one student of the month for November. Kenilworth readers want to come up. and the students of the month. Okay. Kenilworth Junior High is proud to introduce our November Student of the Month, Harper Gilbert. Harper was chosen Student of the Month because of her academic excellence, hard work, and the kindness she
013exhibits to her classmates and teachers on a daily basis. Not only is Harper a 4.0 student but is also a valuable member of the Kenilworth leadership class. Ms. Romano, Harper's teacher. leadership instructor. Sherrod Harper is an excellent, responsible student who never shies away from hard work, deadlines, or helping others. Herper is so sweet, considerate, and generous with her time. Harper will lend a hand to anyone in need and as always One of the first to give to our school community when asked. Harper is not at… When Harper is not at school, she can be found competing and cheering As a dedicated member of the Petaluma Panthers cheerleading team. Harper expresses she enjoys cheerleading because she likes being loud. Harper has also found… has also found time to volunteer at Adventure Recreation as counselor helping younger
014kids learn to tumble after After high school, Harper would like to attend college, possibly at Sonoma State. and pursue in elementary school teaching credential. Harper would be a great addition to the teaching profession. We look forward to seeing Harper continue to make her school, our community and the planet a better place. Congratulations, Harper. Congratulations, Harper. Do we have Harper's friends and family in the audience? If you can please stand, we want to applaud you too. We know it takes a village. I don't know if junior High School is proud to introduce our December student of the Month, Ella Ware. Ella was chosen Student of the Month by her teachers and she is well deserving of this recognition. Ella is an outstanding student, a tireless worker, a leader. and an exemplary citizen, Ella is always willing
015to lend a helping hand to a classmate or a teacher. Ella is held high in regard by not only her teachers, but also her peers. Ms. Crozier, Ella Science Teacher, enthusiastically shared whether she is helping her classmates Taking the initiative on projects are showing kindness and leadership. Ella consistently exceeds expectations. Ella approaches every challenge with enthusiasm and determination. She is motivated to do her best and always has a positive attitude. Not only is Ella an important member of the Kenilworth leadership class, but she also set the record for push-ups in her PE class. When Ella is not at school, she enjoys being a member of the Petaluma Panthers cheerleading team and is a dedicated gymnast. After high school, Ella would like to attend UCLA and study business and marketing. Like Ms. Romano, Ella's leadership teacher
016eagerly shared, Kenworth is very fortunate to have a student like Ella. Congratulations, Ella. Congratulations, Ella. Do we have Ella's friends and family in the audience? Can you please stand? Ellenmore Junior High School is proud to introduce our December Student of the Month, Nathaniel Ower. Nate was chosen Student of the Month because he has consistently impressed his teachers with academic excellence, hard work. kindness and helpfulness. He is truly Kenilworth's Renaissance man. NAIT is a 4.0 student and editor for the Kenilworth yearbook class An athlete, a student of martial arts, and an enthusiastic reader. Keller's yearbook teacher, Ms. Patrick, shared, Nate has been a huge asset in your book. He is conscientious, takes pride in his work, gets along well with others, and is an excellent role model. Nate is not afraid to express his opinions, is
017not swayed by peer pressure and is mature beyond his age. I know I can trust and rely on Nate. Nate was the only seventh grader to be an editor last year, and of course he's again. This year, Nate is a gem. While Nate is busy taking seven classes at Kenilworth, he still finds the time to be a member of Kenilworth's wrestling team. Outside of school, Nate is a swimmer and has been participating in jujitsu for four years. After high school, Nate would like to attend a junior college and see what doors open to him from there. We at Kenilworth know that sky's the limit for this impressive young man. Congratulations, Nate. Congratulations, Nate. Can Nate's friends and family please stand so we can applaud? Thank you, Kennelorth, and congratulations to our three students of the
018month. And next up, Petaluma Junior, if you all want to come on up. Do I go? Okay. Petaluma Junior High is proud to introduce our December Student of the Month, Bella Fontana. Bella was chosen by her teachers as PJHS Student of the Month Because she is incredibly driven and holds herself to high standards. Bella is trustworthy, responsible, and adaptable. Bella brings a positive attitude to everything she does. Bella is a member of the SAFE, school ambassadors. She is passionate about standing up for others and she leads by example. Her teachers appreciate Bella's adversant personality and congeality. The things Bella loves about PGHS are like community and the supportive teachers. Outside of school, Bella participates in multiple sports including softball, soccer. volleyball and basketball. Bella is looking forward to meeting new friends and teachers in high
019school. She hopes to attend a great college and pursue a career she loves. Bella's family is thrilled to thrilled for and proud of Bella. They say that Bella always strives to do her best. Bella cares deeply for others and can always be counted on for a laugh. Family, friends, and school staff agree that Bella is incredibly well-rounded inside and outside of the classroom. We are lucky to have Bella representing PJHS as our December Student of the Month. Congratulations, Bella. Congratulations, Bella. Do we have Bella's friends and family here? Can you please stand? Petaluma Junior High School is proud to introduce our December Student of the Month, Jack Vula. Jack was chosen as Student of the Month because he is a true bantam. Jack is an absolute rock star as an office TA. He always has
020a smile on his face and has been quoted as saying he cannot leave a job unfinished or incorrect. Jack puts his all into everything he does. He is empathetic, trustworthy, and demonstrates outstanding integrity. Jack is a member of Safe School Ambassadors and dedicates himself to going to doing the right thing. Jack says that what he loves most about PJHS is the opportunities it provides to do what you want to do and be who you want to be. Jack actively participates in Boy Scouts as a leader of his patrol, demonstrating his high moral character. Jack plans to play water polo in high school and afterward he hopes to attend Stanford University and eventually earn a doctoral degree. Jack's family is proud of him too. They say that Jack's discipline, dedication, and generosity set him apart from
021others. Jack has a strong backbone and is not afraid to take a stand for others. In addition, Jack has an incredible sense of humor and loves to make people laugh. He is always willing to lend a hand. to someone in need. We are lucky to have Jack representing PJHS as our December student of the Month. Congratulations, Jack. Jack's friends and family, can you please stand? Thank you and congratulations, Bantums. Let's move over to the gauchos at Casa Grande. All right, so our first student of the month is Shreya She is a hardworking and dedicated senior at Costa Grande High School. Throughout her high school career, she has challenged herself through various honors, AP, and junior college level classes. Sharia is committed to serving her community at Casa Grane High School. She serves as the senior
022class president and representing her peers wants and needs at the school level. She is also the president and regional finance director of Key Club, a nationwide organization dedicated to community service. Outside of school, Sri has taken on the role of the outreach director for California Association of Student Councils in six counties. It is through this position that she is able to present local public officials with potential policy ideas that could one day be implemented, hoping to pursue a career in the law field, Sharia has taken various measures to pursue her interests And this career path inside and outside of the school environment. Next year, she hopes to pursue her interests while attending a four-year university. Yes, neither of our student in the months are here today. Sorry. Well, we will clap for her anyway in
023case she watches this yeah Okay, so our next student of the month is Andy Fong. Annie Fong is a Costa Grande senior who has consistently challenged himself and taken a rigorous course load of summer honors classes, 13 APs, and 12 SRJC classes. He plans to study computer science in college. Inspired by his experience studying machine learning at the UC Cosmos program during his junior summer. During that time, he started a research project in computer vision. Working on advanced novel research and gay gaussian splatting who is… I'm sorry. With supervision from an assistant or an associate CS professor at UC Davis and his grad students. At school, he shares his love of computer science and math with peers, leading the computer science club and teaching various topics in AI and calculus. He also works as an
024intern for CAPS, Climate Action Pathways for Schools. In order to make PCS more sustainable for everybody and volunteers as an instructor for the nonprofit Bit by Bit Coding, teaching the basics of web and game development to middle schoolers. In his free time, he likes to play tennis, produce hip hop music with his friends, practice chess, and plot against his older brother Alan. Currently, he is working on his research paper with other Cosmos alumni and in the future he wants to pursue a career in computer science research. And he is extremely thankful for the friends, family, and teachers that have enabled him to succeed. All right. How about our Trojans over at Petaluma High? Okay, first up we have Trevor Dunn. Trevor is a four-year member of the Petaluma FFA and has maintained a 4.0 GPA
025this semester while also serving as an FFA officer. While at PHS, Trevor has been a valued member of the community both in and outside the classroom. Trevor has played football for PHS all four years and was selected as a member of the TRI County's All-Star Football South team, as well as being honored as an all-league offensive lineman. Trevor has been wrestling since the seventh grade and made it to NCS last year in hopes to make it back this year while also serving as a team captain. Trevor is a leader in the classroom and on the field helping others when he can and serving his community throughout the year. Trevor plans on attending a junior college after high school. His family shared that they are incredibly proud of Trevor and cannot wait to see what he
026accomplishes next. Congratulations, Trevor. Do we have Trevor's friends and family in the audience? Can you please stand? Next up is Nathan Rodriguez. Nathan has been at Petaluma High School for four years and is the oldest sibling to his two sisters. He enjoys spending time with his family and loves family vacations. Nathan has been part of the very loving cross-country team as a very strong runner, excelling in the three mile races at Petaluma High School for all his four years. As a leader, he is the team captain and he will miss everyone that made the sport such an amazing time. Nathan has managed to keep strong grades for his four years and has over a 4.0 GPA. Nathan's teachers all describe him as a role model in class who does excellent work. He's a hard worker
027who his teachers truly admire. Nathan enjoys his daily bike ride to and from school, which also helps his busy family transporting everyone where they need to go. Nathan has a passion for drawing and plans to pursue a career in animation. He will start at Santa Rosa Junior College next year and transfer after two years to Cal Arts. He has taken several art classes in high school. and feels that they introduce new challenges in the forms of art for him. Nathan hopes to work for Pixar or DreamWorks one day. Both his sisters, his dad, and his mom love him very much and are very proud of him. Congratulations. Congratulations, Nathan. Do we have Nathan's friends and family in the audience? Can you please stand or wave your hand? Congratulations. And now we'll move on to students
028of the semester from PAX. Petaluma Accelerated Charter School, we are pleased to honor our seventh grade student of the semester, Luke Leiser. Luke sets the standard for what it means to be a student at PAX. He is hardworking, diligent, respectful, and kind and exempt. and exemplifies the qualities and characteristics we value as a school community. Luke consistently strives for academic excellence. No matter if it is working independently or in a small group. Luke brings his best effort and positive attitude toward learning. His in… inquisitive nature supports His hardworking demeanor. as he is constantly looking for ways to expand his understanding to draw meaningful connections between the concepts of study. Luke is a humble student who celebrates his peer successes while quietly appreciating his own. Something that should be noted about Luke is his genuine… is
029how genuine and kind he is. You could always count on Luke to have his smile on his face And help out whenever is needed. Luke's positivity is contagious and his zest for life is… evident. Luke's parents shared that Luke has a genuine interest for learning. From a young age, they remember him choosing books about space, history. and science. As he got a little older, they that he loved the joy that comes from academic discovery. Luke still loves figuring out how things work. Learning about the past. Or even something simple like reading an anatomy book for fun. A second trait that trait They find it inspiring in Luke is his inspiring intrinsic desire to put his best foot forward. Well, they are proud of his academic achievements. They feel it is even more important that he
030values his best effort in everything he does. We are all very proud of you, Luke. Congratulations and keep up the good work. Congratulations, Luke. Luke's friends and family, are you here in the audience? Can you please stand or raise your hands? Okay, and for our eighth grade student of the semester, we have Josie Brady. She is an outstanding individual, someone who has not only exceeded excelled academically, but also demonstrated the qualities that make our school community a better place. This award is a reflection of her hard work, dedication. and the commitment she brings to her daily studies. But it's not just about the grades or test scores. It's about the character she displays. The way she interacts with others. and the positive impact she has on everyone around her. Josie has shown an unwavering passion
031for learning. She approaches every subject with enthusiasm, always eager to challenge yourself and dig deeper into new material. Regardless of the subject. Josie dives into each topic with focus and determination Never satisfied with just understanding the basics but always striving for mastery. She embodies a growth mindset, always ready to take on new challenges. She doesn't give up when things get tough. She finds… ways to learn, improve and grow. Her persistence and resilience have not only helped her succeed, but have also inspired those around her to push themselves to be better. She is kind, respectful, and always willing to lend a helping hand to her peers. Josie brings… Her best to the classroom, group work, and individual interactions. Josie's parents noted that her academic journey has been marked by dedication and passion for learning. She has
032been an avid reader since kindergarten And is an amazing piano player. Josie, your hard work, perseverance, and kindness have been noticed and appreciated. PAX is lucky to have you as a student. Congratulations. Congratulations, Josie. Do we have Josie's friends and family in the audience? Congratulations Congratulations to all of our students of the month and semester. We're going to take a five minute break, but I want a picture of all the students of the month and semester up here before. So we will reconvene at 640. We're going to come back because it's already 641. I'm reconvening our meeting. Trustee Cloud and Jen? Sorry. And now we will move on to our presentation of the first interim budget. Thank you. All right. Is that better? All right. The only thing better than hearing about first interim once
033would be in surround sound All right. Tonight. we bring forward our first update to the fiscal year 2425 budget, also known as the first interim. As a district, we are dedicated to providing equitable and inclusive education that supports students in reaching their full potential. And our first interim budget reflects this commitment. The resources allocated ensure we can deliver rigorous, culturally relevant instruction foster safe and supportive learning environment and address the diverse needs of our students by prioritizing investments in staff community partnerships. and student support systems, we stay true to our mission of empowering students to succeed academically and grow as responsible community members. Our focus on shared decision making and collaboration ensures that every dollar in the budget supports our core core values and drive student success. Education Code 42130 requires districts submit two interim
034financial reports annually. With the first interim covering transactions from July 1 to October 31st and including updated projections for the the remaining of the fiscal year. Petaluma City Schools has a positive certification affirming its ability to meet financial obligations for the current year and the next two fiscal years. All right, on our financial reporting cycle, we are now at the first interim. After tonight's presentation, we will eagerly await for the governor's January budget. where we will start updating our multi-year projections for fiscal year 26 and we will come back with up an update to this year's budget in March. Which is our second interim. I want to highlight that our first interim is in yellow and this is over our adopted budget, which came to the board for approval in June. On our LCFF funding
035sources, there is a $900,000 variance of a negative. which is due to enrollment in ADA changes, we saw a strong ending with our attendance last year. I think we talked a lot about it and beginning of this year and we are seeing a decline in our students that are attending our schools. Our federal revenue, this reflects small adjustments to revenues that we are receiving. And now that we have our final carryover amounts after closing out last fiscal year. We now add them as deferred revenue so we can spend the funds. And this includes ESSER 3, which is some of the remaining COVID funding for summer school and our ELOP programs. Title. Oh my gosh, can you guys read that title three There's a bit of, sorry, there's a bit of a glare. And… Our CSI
036for Sonoma Mountain and SOCC is Now, in CSI, it started last year, but we did not find out until after second interim. So this reflects the current year budget and the carryover from last year. And our other local revenue always updates with different grants and donations. So we have a net positive of $1.6 million over budget adoption for our revenues. On our general fund expenditures, we have a variance of $6.7 million over adopted budget. Before I touch on the different categories, I'm going to fast forward. This is the slide from our unaudited actuals that show that we expected to spend $12.2 million more than we did at year end. And most of this was with our restricted ending fund balances. So the only way to now spend those balances is to increase our budget. So
037where $6.7 million looks like a very large increase. it is directly reflected from when we did our unaudited actuals at year end. And most of those adjustments, we have some certificated vacancies. And some of our positions that have been open in this year have moved from certificated to classified. We also have a new grant that will have classified positions. That's where those variances are. Our employee benefits will always change as our salaries change. our books and supplies have increased almost $3.9 million. And this has to do with the restricted programs. We had quite a bit budget left over in ELOP, our arts and music block grant. And this is also where we now take our athletic carryover from our grants and donations that we earmark back to the sites. on our services and other operating,
038that also is an increase to our or restricted resources. We have an increase to our capital outlay. We don't usually see a lot of this in the general fund, but these are directly related to the four bands that we have purchased. The last one was delivered today, so they will be to the sites early next week. How many total exactly, I've lost count of the electric vans. And sorry, I said electric. These are the gas vans for these are the four brand new gas vans, but we also have six specifically for field trips and transportation that we approved earlier this year. And we have five electric vans. that are part of our home to school transportation fleet. and 17 electric buses. And also we have a reimbursement grant for new electric charging stations that have
039now been installed at the transportation department. These are specifically for our buses and we will be seeing the rebate likely by second interim. Our other outgoing remain the same and our indirect costs will always vary a little bit. We charged indirect to our special programs based off of our expenditures, not our revenue. That's why there's always fluctuations in our indirect costs. And that's where we get to the $6.7 million in changes. This was that slide. The other thing I wanted to note is these are our restricted ending fund balances that we anticipate at the end of this year. So why we have a positive certification, meaning that we are maintaining at least 3% of unrestricted reserves. A lot of the districts balance is still within our restricted funds. Just give a minute to go over
040those. On our multi-year projections. Now we have updated our beginning balance from our unaudited actuals. We started the year with a higher Beginning fund balance than we anticipated at budget adoption. And with our total revenues for the year and our total expenditures, we are anticipating operating at a $12.7 million deficit. This is a deficit due to all of our restricted balances. Well, it's something we want to maintain. It is not considered a structural deficit at this point. But as we continue our conversations, we want to make sure that we're spending our most restricted dollars and spending those down and really trying to offset and save as many as our unrestricted funds. And this is the balances of our unrestricted and our restricted funds. I would like to note that fiscal year 26 or the 25-26
041school year This does still have a $2 million cut in salaries, which we have been talking about last year and this year. the difference over budget and first interim is we have now included the anticipated cost of the new bell schedule into our multi-year projections. So we talked about using some of our restricted funds and other fundings in the first two years. This shows that we can implement the bell schedule and still maintain our 3% reserves at the end of the 26-27 fiscal year. And these are our ending fund balances in our special funds. One thing to note down that we are spending down our fund 13, which is our cafeteria fund. But that has been, well, we are legally required. You can only have six months of operating costs in your special cafeteria fund,
042or you have to have a state approved plan. but also we're implementing this year the new our new program where we are no longer contracting with Rev Foods at our elementary and it's It's going very well. We have a lot, you know, right now we've implemented a hot meal and the salad bars and Brian the director of food service is continuing to work on a plan and we're also seeing that as our food service is up by almost 50%. We do need to also look at the staff, what type of staffing we need. So it's great to have this balance in order to increase as we need. In our general fund, we also have a couple, we have a dishwasher grant and a couple other local grants to help our elementary schools. be able to
043offer better service within the school. Other than that, last year we opened our deferred maintenance fund. We still have not yet. We still have not made a contribution to that. I plan at sometime this year coming back to the board with a resolution on what type of plan we want to see for our deferred maintenance. I think this is going to become Even more important as we bring on our as we finish our facilities master plan and then we bring on our bond implementation plan to really spell out how we want to use our different funding sources, including our capital facilities fund. There is an expiration to A, B, um. 1303 in the end of December, which changes the way that You can collect your developer fees and legal requirements on when they need to
044be spent. We are working with dwk And they expect to put out a guidance this week. There was some discussion that we may be looking at a resolution, but they don't feel like we're going to need to do that. So more information to come likely in January on what we need to do to make sure we are following the updated language and the expiration of the assembly bill. Other than that, we have our fund 40, which is our reserve for capital outlay fund. This is something that right now is sitting a little stagnant. that what you see there is interest earned, but really we need to start looking at long term For that, there's been a lot of conversations like with the technology department on how we will be redoing our refresh of our technology
045and I'm going to bring it back to the facilities master plan because technology is included as part of the facilities master plan and it is in our bond language. So I think this will be part of a bigger conversation of how to best use these different Pots of restricted resources. in the future. Other than that, not any major changes to any of the special funds. So that was the overview. I'm happy to back up to any slides you would like to discuss in further detail. Any questions or? Comments? I had a question, and I didn't see this in the larger budget document. If you could go back to where you had it noted, it was one of the first slides about the athletics carryover. I had never seen that. We keep hearing about the fees
046for athletics and transportation, all those things. Can you talk about that? Yes, so we had on this carryover specifically with the changes that we made last year, it really reduced our carryover. So we were able to earmark it for, as I said, under the restricted, most of it was under ELOP. But we did have between the comprehensive junior highs and the two secondary high schools, there was $194,000 of carryover from last year and those the reason why those are carryover funds is that they are donations from parents that were specifically for athletics. And those were donations that were not And so then how can… How can they be used now or how are they being used now? So they have now been added to whatever, whichever school. I don't have the breakdown of which school,
047but what school they belong to. They have now been posted to their site budgets, specifically in their athletic accounts that can now continue to be spent. Yep. I just want to publicly acknowledge that we are in positive certification for the next three years, which is by itself remarkable. accomplishment uh the budget from the state is very lean But we're still able to fund the raises that we've negotiated with our labor partners Over the past year, and it's no small thing to be in positive certification. We just have to look the news around the Bay Area. There are plenty of districts who are not. All right. Thank you. All right, moving on to comments from the public on special recognition reports, presentations, and non-agegendized items. I'm going to read my spiel, but if you have a
048card, please bring it up to Bree for anything not on the agenda or anything we've already discussed tonight. Under Government Code Section 54954, members of the public have the right to address the governing board on any items of interest providing it relates to the subject matter jurisdiction of the school district. While government code allows speakers to criticize districts policies, procedures. programs, services, and our employees. The district does have a policy specific to complaints against employees. Should comments from the public pertain to a specific district employee, the board requests that the complaint first be submitted in writing to the employee's immediate supervisor for investigation. If the comment is about something not on the agenda, it will be heard only during the public comment on non-agendized items, period. That is right now. Once that part of the
049meeting is over, comments will only be taken on agenda items during discussion of those items. The board values public comments and although we cannot take action or discuss items not on the agenda, we listen carefully and appreciate input from the public. Public comments are subject to a three minute per person limit or a 20 minute limit per subject matter. commenters may not cede their time to others. And with that, the only public comment I have for this section is from Molly. Hi, my name is Molly Lunabus. I teach art at CASA. I'm here to report on the great progress in resolving the district mistakes that led to the parcel tax violations of Measure C which has supported library tech and VAPA for the past 20 years. As PCS has worked to understand this measure, we
050appreciate finally being brought to the table to provide essential context Especially since there is currently no district office leadership employee who has been here longer than three years. During times of change and instability, it is critical to listen to those who have been here longer. Our current library tech and VAPA faculty at CASA has a combined service of over 100 years. After much discussion, the district has agreed to the following resolution. Number one, Parcel Tax Measure C material funding has been restored at all secondary sites for VAPA, library, and tech. $38 per high school VAPA student, $36 per junior high school VAPA student, and funding for library tech that is consistent with previous year's allocation Number two, the nearly $50,000 of cost is unspent parcel tax measure C funding that was illegally removed last spring
051and was used for purposes outside of the constraints voted for by the people of Petaluma has been returned. And we are currently placing orders for the materials we need to maintain our programs. Number three, parcel tax funding has been acknowledged to be restricted funding that cannot be swept at the end of the year to be used outside of his designated constraints. Four, PCS will be cutting back on the number of positions covered by parcel tax measure C funding. to maintain a solvent and secure parcel tax budget. Five, a clear guiding document will be presented to the PCS Budget Advisory Committee to steer all future parcel tax funding allocation decisions. This common sense resolution would not have been possible without our interim superintendent Esmeralda Mondragon who listen to our concerns, did the exhaustive research, and corrected
052all the parcel tax violations during her very short time here at PCS. Esmeralda, we truly appreciate your dedication to this matter that has affected so many of our students. Thank you Thank you also to my colleagues, our union president, Sandra Larson, Interim Principal Carla Conroy, and members of the board who are engaged in this process and demanded rectification. We will continue to work closely with the district to ensure that the voices of Petaluma voters are respected in the future And that the needs of our students always come first. Thank you so much for all of your hard work and happy holidays. Thank you. Sorry, my voice. All right. Any other public comment on something not on the agenda? Now's the time to rest the stage. Seeing none, we'll move on to adoption and approval of
053the agenda. Do I hear a motion? I move to adopt and approve the agenda. I second. All right. All in favor, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Any abstain? All right. We have an agenda. So now I will report on our activities and correspondence since the last month. So since our November meeting, trustees attended CASA basketball games, the CASA tennis Awards Night. a meeting with PFT leadership, the Budget Advisory Committee meeting, a meeting with the hr director a gender review, a meeting with a PHS student. the alternative ed committee meeting, board office hours for adult education, and four of us attended the CSBA conference the California School Board Association Conference. And then our student board member started planning and interviewing for TQ, Trojans Quarterly. Right. And attended a PTSA meeting and helped with tours for
054incoming freshmen and families. Because it's already time to start thinking about incoming freshmen, which is wild. Does anyone have anything they want to say about any of their activities? I just want to comment on the CSBA conference this year. It was down in Anaheim. It was really good. There were several workshops that I attended that I really found really helpful. And one of them was on ai It's easy to see that AI is a mystery to me because obvious reasons. And so, but it was really, really informative. It was very… helpful in realizing that, you know, I don't have a choice It's here, it's very much. Who knows where it will go. And the important thing that they talked about was Basically getting ready for it, embracing it. And thinking about how we can use
055it for good. you know it will always be used for bad There are things that we can do. And so it was really instrumental for me in particular. The other thing that I went to was an incredible presentation from San Bernardino City Schools student board representatives. Yes. And I need to talk to you. And all of them and about how they organize it. And it was so cool because they ran the meeting completely the workshop And the way that they… They're huge. They have 45,000 students. They have nine high schools. So, but they have a representative at each high school And they also just the way that they choose their student board members, but what is most appealing to me was the way that they use the student board members during meetings, the trainings, getting
056you, you know, the simple thing like an agenda review Where they invite the students to come to an agenda review and you go over it with them so that if they have questions like. What is an interim, first interim? And then what are you going to be going over? Just so that they can kind of be familiar with the agenda so that when you're here. You can ask questions. And then having dedicated time for you to ask questions. Trainings, all kinds of stuff. And they were absolutely fabulous. So that was a really cool thing. That's all I have to say. Any other? comments on any of our activities? Well, all right. Now we'll move on. Oh, I did. Yeah, I did student board members too. Comments from the public on consent items. All of these
057are not For the consent agenda. So if anyone has any public comment for anything under item 13 about the consent agenda, now's your time to bring that forward. Seeing no one rushing the stage, we'll move on to approval of the consent agenda by consolidated motion. Do I hear a consolidated motion? Somebody's got to do it. To approve the consent agenda by consolidated motion. I'll second. All right. Any questions or comments about anything on the consent agenda? These are the usual suspects. All right. I called a question. All in favor of approving the consent agenda? Aye. Any opposed? All right. Hearing none, the consent agenda passes. So now… We're moving on to comments from the public on action items and i believe that is what my stack here is. So especially if you're here about the
058MOU, now's your time to bring the card forward to Bree. We have eight comments, so that means everyone gets two and a half minutes each, except we're going to start with Cecilia, who is getting her comment translated. So that'll be five minutes to account for the translation time. So Cecilia You're up first. Oh. Yeah, that's a good question. Who's translating? I know there are translators on Zoom. can… Yeah. Ophelia, yeah. Okay, okay. Okay. Hi, my name is Cecilia Vasquez. So I try to speak when my English is not perfect, but I try to speak. So I'm here. I'm the president for ELAC. I'm here because I would like to let you know about for the big change for Ballet Vista. So I would like to let you know too about the information. So the last
059meeting about for the big change We are 25 families. Sometimes it's hard to get more parents came because they work so hard and And King Camin I for the meetings. But we have that information. all the time. I already have Mbala Vista 12 years. My four kids grow up in the Valley Vista. I love Ballet Vista. And I so happy for this big change I know it's hard for other families don't speak English very well and sometimes it's hard for understanding about the change. But we try to send emails and we share with my friends don't speak English, I share in for videos about for the program for about for the big change and the secretary and the… The principal miss angie the secretary, they made a good job because they're saying all the time
060information and departing square in the red folder with the same information in the red folder with the kids. So we have a lot of information. Sometimes some patterns is missing because they're don't check the emails or don't check the padding square. But we have a lot of information about for this change. In my opinion, I'm so happy and I give my support for everything for the change. Because it's a good opportunity for the kids? So when I start to investigate about the program, I remember when I was their age, I start to learn it the same. And I think, well, this change is good because The brain, it's more explored. I love that technology too but Right now, it's hard. You know, it's hard. I just want to let you know about for the the
061Hispanic people, we already have a lot of information the 12 years ago, they made a good job for sending emails And for this big change, we have a lot of information. We have a lot of meetings. In the last meeting with three to five families, and they are so happy for the big change. So I'm so happy. I just want to let you know that all the people from the They've been doing a good job informing everybody about the change. And they never miss to send… all the emails to get together for the meetings we have. 35 families that were present in the last meeting. Estamos de acuerdo con el cambio que va. We agree with the change. y estamos dispuestos apoyar en todos los cambios que se agitas. We wanted to support all the
062changes whatever is going to be necessary. Thank you. And your English is amazing for the record. Yeah, thank you. All right. Next up, Nicole mathers. Mathers? Yeah. Hi, I'm Nicole Mathers and I teach second grade at Live Oak Charter School. And I just want to say thank you for giving me time to speak. I'm very much in support of Live Oak Charter School becoming a Petaluma City School. I have been a part of Waldorf Education since I was a child. I attended the San Francisco Waldorf School. And I have raised three children through Waldorf Education. I now have a college. student and high schooler who's at credo And I have a child at Live Oak Charter School. Live Oak Charter School. is a child-centered, academically rigorous school where students are learning and being creative daily.
063Because it embraces UDL universal design learning principles Subjects are brought in a variety of ways that engage all types of learners. By emphasizing creativity, each student can express their understanding in different ways. Waldorf Education is created for the student but also allows for the teacher to tap into their creativity. to meet the students in front of her. The strength of this education can be seen by how upright, strong academically, and motivated my own children are. And the students that come out of Waldorf schools. Waldorf Education strives to integrate the whole person. Giving children tools that will make them happy, successful adults. It does this by weaving art, music, and movement into each day through storytelling. And by delving deeply into the history of each continent on the earth and the peoples that inhabit those places.
064Whenever possible, teachers are encouraged to use hands-on experiences with their students. So that the students grow up feeling that they are capable and creative and can do important things in the world. Students learn to sew, to knit, to cook, to garden. to woodcarve and much more. Science and math are also taught in the same fashion, by inquiry-based lessons and then hands-on exploration. I have been a parent at Live Oak and now a teacher at Live Oak. And it is a wonderful community and I'm very, very happy that it is growing. And I think it would be a very positive thing for all of us to combine. And I look forward to the collaboration. Thank you. And now, Kristen. Hi, thank you. My name is Kristen Walter. I'm the chair of the board of Live Oak.
065I'm a parent of four kids who are attending Live Oak. And I just want to say, I'm speaking. we tried to organize ourselves out of compassion for you. And so… Just stating that. And I don't know whether you're going to pull us up so it might not work But, oh, thank you. How nice of you to follow the numbers. It's been wonderful partnering with the district and the Valley Vista team and to Nicole's point, we're really excited to about the possibility of collaborating further. In preparing to speak with you guys tonight. We reviewed which we've done many times, but the core values of Petaluma City Schools, which Amanda reviewed And as we've been delving into them. we see that there's really a lot of harmony in this match. So we're going to be reviewing the
066values and I'll go over the first two. So value number one, that all students have value, infinite potential, and the right to an excellent education. Through the development of multiple internally sponsored charter schools in Petaluma. The district leadership has demonstrated innovation and a commitment to providing options for families. We believe that the Waldorf approach will be a welcome and effective choice for district families. and an opportunity to expand excellent education in the district. Value number two, all students learn in a safe and caring environment where they are motivated to do their best work. Families enroll their children in our school for a variety of reasons. Ranging from a desire to preserve childhood preferring a low-tech environment. to the desire for a rigorous education. Through annual surveys, parents report that their children find meaning and motivation
067through the Waldorf practice at Live Oak. And the next values will be by our next speaker. All right. Thank you. And next up, we have Dr. Linda. Good evening, Dr. Linda Delgado. I'm the Executive Director at Live Oak. I'll continue with value number three. All students reach high levels of achievement through rigorous and culturally relevant curriculum. Live Oak teachers take great pride in the development of curriculum that is culturally relevant while adhering to the Common Core state standards. In the 2023-24 CAASPP assessment, Live Oak students showed that 60% of our group was at or above grade level in English language arts compared to 47% of the California average. a difference of 13 points. In math, our students measured at 44.23 as opposed to the California average. of 35.54. a difference of 8.69 percentage points. Our
068students scored at 61.36 for science. That is twice the results for California. We are incredibly proud of our students and the rigor that we provide in our education. And from here, I will pass it on to our next speaker, Robert. Next up, I have Valerie. It says three and Robert says four. So I'm happy. Is Valerie okay? Go for it, Robert. I'm just making sure y'all know that I wasn't putting on it. they give me a script, but I'm going off. My name is Robert Bunce. I'm the treasurer of the Live Oak Board. I've been in public education for 30 years. My education started here in Petaluma. I'm a graduate of Valley Vista. And graduate diploma High School. When it came time to choose an elementary school, I chose Live Oak for my three kids.
069knowing all the different things that are out there for our kids in public education. One thing I love about Live Oak is our ability to serve every single child. We have a saying at the school for these kids in this time and in this place. And each of our teachers and our whole community takes that to heart and finds the way to meet the kids where they're at and provide them the education they need to succeed and you heard the results from Linda. Your priority four is diversity is an asset that strengthens and enriches our community. our learning community. I'm confident in our ability to move to Valley Vista and take on a more diverse community. Looking at all of our subgroups and the state tests, we are within one or two points of all
070the different subgroups. for California. Before I leave, I also just wanted to say a thank you to Tony, Amanda, Amy, and Jason who spent so much time working with us. building a foundation of trust that our school and our community can be proud of and move forward with and bring success to all students. Thank you. Next up, Valerie. Good evening. Thank you so much for hearing me. I come here as a resident of Petaluma and as a parent to two kids. One is at Live Oak, one will be there. next year. And as a board member as well. So for values four and five, I just want to kind of show how we're feeding into those nicely. Value for the community supports the educational program and is engaged as a partner and resource in student
071learning. We're really fortunate that we have a very engaged and committed family community. Our school leverages skills and capabilities all across the board in our parent community. It's incredible to watch people step forward as classroom aides, as field trip drivers, as gardening. help and that's just to name a very few things out of many. Family education is really critical in our Waldorf school and to any Waldorf school and our teachers each provide at least one evening each year dedicated to that purpose. Value five, district employees are dedicated to student success and operate as a high-performing collaborative team. Waldorf Education at Live Oak is child-centered, teacher-led, and community held. And for a long time, I didn't quite know what that meant. But it really is just putting the human development of the child at the center
072and letting all of the other partners collaborate to make sure that that is being held first and foremost as they pursue their education. Collaboration is obviously key across all of that, and that includes families, teachers, aides, administrators, and a great deal of trust enables us to rely on each other to make sure that that happens. Thank you. Thank you. And next up, Andy. Hi, Andy Schrader. I'm a parent at Live Oak. We got a second grader. And a fifth grader at Cherry Valley. We moved to Petaluma from the Agora Hills Public Waldorf School and We actually moved here just so our kids could attend Live Oak. Value number six, shared decision making is valued and active participation from all educational partners is critical to student success. All elements of the Live Oak School involve a
073lengthy process of working with all stakeholder groups, including the classroom coordinators. administrative team parents and the parent-led board, consensus is the goal for each of these, which involves intentional conversations with ample opportunity for input. feedback or questioning. Live Oaks ambitious value number seven, parents and caregivers are recognized and engaged as partners. Live Oak's ambitious program would not be possible without our families. Having said that, families participate in ways that stretch from simply bringing their children to school in the morning to service on our parent-led board itself a significant commitment in terms of time and effort. All families are welcome to work with us, but none are required. Thank you. All right. And then Jessica. Shorter. Yep, so I'm going to do that. Hello, my name is Jessica Unfors. I've been in front of you all
074before on behalf of Live Oak. I used to be the chair of the school board and I've had a couple of kids go through the school I have been not on the board this year, which has been really fun. You guys will appreciate that. But I have been participating in the joint planning for the new charter school. Which has been a lot of fun. It's been very collaborative. Both here within Petaluma, but also in the wider public Waldorf world. Well, I'm going to say. Hats off to our district colleagues and our Valley Vista colleagues who are here tonight who have been collaborating with us for months and months. But it's been especially fun to collaborate across the public Waldorf world. Because public welder schools are the public waterf community is really invested in Waldorf Education
075being available to more families. It's sort of built into the mission when you dig under the surface of what Waldorf was all about. So one of our One of our partners in this work has been Alice Bernie Walter School in Sacramento, which is a very diverse Walter School. It serves about 500 students in grades TK through eight. Valley Vista staff and faculty took a field trip there to kind of see What does Waldorf look like when it's in a kind of in-district dependent setting? And I think they had a lot of fun on that trip. The Alice Burney has been around for a very long time. They're one of the oldest public water schools in California. And the Sacramento, sorry, the Stanford School of Education did a special research study on Alice Bernie Walter School,
076which I know I've sent to some of you before, so it may ring a bell. And one of their most interesting findings were the incredible benefits that the public water for education brought to typically underserved communities of students and families. that attend the school. And I think I will spare you the readout. You can read it for yourself. I'm happy to send it on to you. But I think what I'd like to say is that we are really excited to be able to expand what Live Oak is doing in deep collaboration with both Petaluma City Schools and with Valley Vista to offer this to an expanded community of students and families here in Petaluma. It really, it is fulfilling the mission that Waldorf has always had. So thank you. Thank you. And are there any
077other public comments on any of our action items? I'm only asking because some people came in. If you can hand it to Bree. Most speakers took under their two minute 30 seconds. So I think we're fine on time. Great. All right, first up, Patrick. I'll try and be brief and blunt. I have an eighth grader about to graduate from Live Oak. Nevertheless, I'm… sort of deeply rooted in the local community. And I believe that at this time our community, our state, our country, and our world need, desperately need young people who are compassionate. caring, whose educations have been informed by positive sum collaborative decision-making processes and restorative justice. And in my nearly 60 years of watching kids grow up in different forms of pedagogy. I've never seen… a forum quite like the Waldorf inspired one
078to produce a healthy crop of those kind of young people. And so with that in mind, I say, please, please, please support the continuation of this process. Thank you. Thank you. And next up stacy Hi, I'm Stacey DeGoyer and I have two daughters. that have graduated from Live Vogue. One is at Cal and the other one is at Petaluma High. they actually have a wealth of education, so they didn't get so nervous when they're speaking in public. But I just want to say this is a dream come true. The Live Oak community has been working for a very long time to have a home that's campus that's a full-fledged school. And so I really hope to see this board move the MOU forward and that this becomes a beautiful opportunity for all of Petaluma. Thanks.
079Thank you. And then Blythe. Hi, my name is Blythe Osner. I've had the pleasure of teaching at Live Oak Charter School for six years. When I joined the faculty after teaching in a more traditional setting, I was unsure if Waldorf education was for me. Since then, as a middle school teacher, I've seen the positive impact of this humane and connecting way of teaching. Because I stay with my class from sixth grade through eighth, I get the chance to really understand my students learning needs. and respond over time. In my current eighth grade class, I am seeing the tremendous growth that they've made as thinkers and writers and collaborators in our three years together. And I think that's partly because they've been able to do that together and for us to keep building on the work
080that we do. I also really love the emphasis on the student-teacher relationship in our practice. I have time to listen deeply and to walk with my students through. Both the high points and the low points that they encounter in middle school. In our time together, they've sat together in restorative circles together to listen with empathy. to talk with CARE about difficult and controversial topics. And to repair relationships after significant harm was done. I know that all of this is work that's being done beautifully in classrooms all across Petaluma City Schools. Our Waldorf Way is one way that gives us as teachers the tools to support our students to grow as human beings with the skills to meet the challenges of the 21st century. Thanks. Thank you. All right. Now we are moving on to our
081action items and the first one is under business services approval of the McKinley Modular Classroom Schematic Design. Amanda, can you… Tell us about this. Yes. So McKinley Elementary has experienced significant growth in its TK and kindergarten programs. requiring additional classroom space. After a review process starting in 2020, the project was then prioritized in March of 2024 and approved by the board in October to work with Gelfan Partners Architects on a schematic design. the updated plans include expanded classroom sizes. integrated restrooms and improved play areas that are designed to meet state standards and support the school's growing enrollment. approval of these designs will allow us to move forward with the construction planning phase. So we just wanted to attach. There were meetings with the architects, district administration, site administration, teachers, and classified staff. on the updated
082schematic design, one of the changes over the original building would have been three buildings, but after doing an analysis of the site. the portable where SOCC is is a Beautiful. And I say portable, but it is it is not going anywhere. It would cost $400,000 to move it. It is sunken down and the teachers in the program are very happy with the building and they were actually nervous that we originally we were like, well, we're going to rebuild so we will do some upgrades to that building specifically. So now we have two classrooms that fit in between classrooms where and everything fits perfectly We are at the 13 uh 50 square feet and it has the kinder or the bathroom so when the state does um release the implementation of how to apply for prop
083Proposition 2 funds, we believe that this project will qualify for whatever the matching funds look like. And you will be able to apply for them retroactively for projects that have already been started. All right. Any questions or comments on this one? Well, it's really cute seeing the drawings with the little two foot counters. All right. Do I hear a motion? I move to approve the McKinley modular classrooms. I second. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? All right. The design is approved. Moving on to approval of the proposal. For architect and engineering services for adult transition program portables from DTA. I'm going to do it in the right order this time. Can I hear a motion? I move to approve the proposal for architectural engineering services for adult transition. program. I second. All right. Now that
084it is officially on the table, Amanda, tell us about this one. I always do one out of order just to be spicy. That's okay. It's fine. All right. So one of the reasons why you are seeing this item on action and not up under our consent is that this is not a project that has been discussed with the board at any time. We're bringing it forward as a new project. The district's adult transition program currently located in two portable classrooms at San Antonio high school faces space and restroom limitations due to growing enrollment. We would like to install three new portable classrooms at Casa Grande High School equipped with restrooms, a kitchen, and laundry appliances. This proposed site near Sonoma Mountain Building already has the necessary utilities to move forward with the project. If this
085is approved by the board, DTA will begin work immediately Starting with site assessments, schematic designs, required surveys, and progressing through the design and construction phases. To ensure timely completion and compliance with district standards, we too would have a design committee. One of the things that we need to look at because of the type of buildings that we would need to meet the needs of the program we will likely need to get shells And we do not know right now. We would like to have this in place, all approved by August of next school year. So we do not know if our options are going to be lease or purchase portables at this time. that is one of the things that DTA will do to find what is closest to what we need in order for
086us to add and remove things. And then for a timely matter, we currently do not have any space available district wide to house all three classrooms at an age-appropriate setting. Our only alternative for three classrooms for next year would be Petaluma Junior High. And these are for our adult learners. Any questions or comments? But is this part of the bond? Is that how it's going to be paid for? Is it different? That's a great question. So we would like to use our developer fees or capital impact fees. Those are the fees levied. by individuals when they remodel or they build a new house and they are very restricted funds and Increased enrollment is one of the funding that we can use for this. And the funds are not currently earmarked for any other projects at
087this time. So, Amanda, I remember finally, you know, going to these transitional program graduations which you know it's Great program. Can you… update us on what those projections are on enrollment. And then just correct me if I'm mistaken. As I understand what's being proposed here. we're going to move it from San Antonio to Casa Grande And you needed a third classroom, not just two. Yes, that's correct. So the whole program would move to the Casa Grande campus it would increase to a third classroom. So currently this year there are two and we have a large population at Petaluma High School. that are going to need to move into the adult transition program for next year. And with different, we need different space spaces than we currently have. to have the greatest impact on their learning.
088Yeah, it's a pretty tight fit right now in the two classrooms. We visited for a meeting and I mean, even just with 10 adults in there, you know, I mean, by the time we are seeing these kids, a lot of them are more than fully So I think three makes sense even if enrollment stayed the same. They have currently accessed their They have one restroom that is for the transition program specifically, and then they have access to a second restroom on an emergency basis. needed basis. They do not have access on site for a kitchen or laundry. So they are having to be bused to Petaluma Junior in order to meet that need. Are these dedicated classrooms or is it a different time than school school hours. They are dedicated classrooms during the school day.
089So what of those two classrooms at San Antonio? The two classrooms at San Antonio, like they are two portables that are currently there that could not be moved. So I do know that San Anton could also still use have a need for additional classroom space that has been coming up through the facilities master plan community meetings. they would be utilized. One of the things that they discussed is they do not currently have a place specifically for counseling and for their student advisor. Those individuals are having to use what is also Because I cannot think of the correct term, I apologize. Like the student not rec room the student Like lounge well Anybody? Nope. Yeah. So like when… I apologize. When we toured the space during the day um a gentleman that we contract with 10,000
090degrees was like in the middle of like right next to the pool table. And that's where he was meeting with students because there was no other space for him. So the portables are not in a condition that we would even consider if we moved them, they would likely fall apart. And the space could really be utilized by the campus. Okay. Any other questions or comments? All right. If not, I called a question the approval of the proposal. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Hearing none, we'll move on to our second reading of AR. three five four one point one about transportation for school related trips. Can I hear a motion? I move to approve AR 3541.1. Second. All right. Amanda, can you remind us what This one is. Yes. So this came to the last
091meeting and the only revision that we made to the administrative regulation is we remove the part that it needed to be on a first come first serve basis. That way, if somebody didn't know what they need, we'll continue to work around all of the needs. This just gives the overview of what parents need to do to drive their own students. how to request district transportation and the exceptions to needing to use district. buses outside of the 22 mile requirement. Great. Any questions or comments? Yeah, so I know, you know. been a champion of this one, but I'm also hesitant to approve it because it feels like it's not being followed with fidelity. And so I'm concerned. That even though we have a policy, now we have the administrative regulations the safety and opportunity and the
092opportunity intentions are not being met. or adhered to. So where is the accountability from us in the district level to make sure it's being followed through. That's a great question. So we continue to discuss it with the site administrators. Specifically to the high schools, I plan on going to the Next, coaches meetings to discuss it. I don't know district wide when it is and isn't being always being followed, but we do know that we're mostly hearing about the inconsistencies at our secondary, specifically to the high school level. So it's just reiterating that this is our plan. We've now We have the board policy. We have, if this is approved, it shows the how to request the transportation. We have clarified the funding mechanisms that can be used. just the commitment to continue the conversation. with
093our site administrators and our coaches and our athletic directors and Just with the message of like when people hear about things not being follow just to let us know. Because we can, we will continue to make sure that our policies are adhered to, especially this one specifically. has the board has spent a lot of time discussing and implementing this plan. So we will ensure that whenever we hear of anything or if they're questions are come up, if there's not a clear understanding that anybody can reach out to me. any time for clarification. But we will be meeting with the site principals to go over the new policies. Any other questions or comments? If not, I call the question. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Hearing none, the AR 3541.1 passes. And we move on to
094approval of resolution 2425-16 certifying the election for Measure Z, essentially. Is there anything other than what I just said? Perfect. So we just are certifying the election results. Can I hear a motion? I happily move. to certify the election results. Second. All right. Any questions or comments? Yay, yay. We did it. We did it, Joe. All in favor. Thanks. Aye. Any opposed? Any abstentions? All right. We have certified that Measure Z passed. Thank you to the voters in the elementary school district. Moving on to Resolution 2425-17. Same thing with Measure AA. Do I hear a motion? I move to approve. Any questions or comments? Also, yay. Thank you to the voters of The whole, the huge high school district, including our homies in Marin, all like 230 of them Not all of them voted in
095favor, but that's fine. Sonoma County didn't give the breakdown in the results we're certifying but Thank you very much to all the voters, the majority of whom gladly supported our bonds. So with that, I call the question. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? All right, we have certified those election results. And now moving on to approval of resolution 2425-18 appointing the Measure E and Measure C Citizens Oversight Committee to also oversee measures Z and measure AA. First, can I hear a motion? I move to approve resolution 2425-18. That's perfect. Okay. Second. All right. Is this any more than what it literally says in the title? No. Perfect. Any questions or comments about letting the people that are overseeing the bonds oversee more bonds. or parcel taxes overseen bonds. Yes, we could not do it without
096our citizens overseeing. All right, I call the question. All in favor of the resolution? Aye. Any opposed? All right, the resolution passes. And then approval of the approval of First interim report for 2425. Do I hear a motion? I move to approve Petaluma City School District's first interim report. For 2425. Second. All right. This is the one we had the presentation on at the beginning of the meeting. Have any questions or comments percolated? Since then, yeah. Oh. When I was reporting on the restricted CSI, I said Sonoma Mountain and it is San Antonio. That's what I thought, but I didn't want to. I was like… So thank you for clarifying. I had Sonoma Mountain on my head for right Yes, so I apologize. It's right in the documentation and that's what that's what matters Perfect.
097Well, then I called a question. Oh, I haven't go for it. Yeah. Did you want to call it? Do you have a question? No, it's just going to call to questions. I have an actual question of Amanda. So we continue to hear about the parcel tax reallocation or whatever it's called. But I do not see that in the budget. Can you clarify about that, please? Because we've had several public comments about that. Yes. So no carryover for the parcel tax has been restored. to the budget. The carryover was legally eliminated to pay for positions that were not removed from this year's budget. And in order to reinstate the carryover, that would take board action. And it has not come to the board and it is not included in the first interim But the sites have
098gotten there. funds their parcel tax. Yes. So the Schites received the full allocation at the beginning of the fiscal year. It was just the funds had for many years been a contribution out of the general fund. So they came, but we didn't. Previously, they had been transferred into a restricted fund and then given out And so what we did is we kept them in the general fund and we gave the same allocation For BAPA that was given last year. Thank you. All right. I call the question. All in favor? Any opposed? And then the first interim report is approved and now we'll move to ed services with new course proposals. Do I hear a motion? I move to approve the new course. proposals. I second. All right. Anything since last meeting that Yeah. It's just
099one kind of one revision with the current events in you. The title has changed to hot topics today's Issues, and Tomorrow's Solutions. So I just want to put that on the record as opposed to the old title current in Benson. Yeah. Hot topics, today's issues and tomorrow's solutions. Do you have to resubmit it or can it just be internal adjustment? You approve it with that revision. then yeah, then we'll adjust it in the… someone needs to probably move to men. I move to amend the course proposal. The title of the course proposal on current events to Hot topics. Today's issues and tomorrow's solutions. Wait a second. Okay, perfect. All in favor of that amendment. Aye. Any opposed? Okay, so now we are reviewing the course proposals as amended. Any questions or comments on any of
100these courses other than a lot of us want to take them. I don't know if any of us want to take accelerated math. But… Yeah. I already took math. Like, I'm good. Yeah. Okay, then you all can enroll in math again. I'm not going to. All right. All in favor of the new course proposals as amended? Aye. Any opposed? All right. The course proposals pass. So now we move on to approval of the memorandum of understanding. First, I need a motion. I move to approve the MOU between Petaluma City Schools and Live Oak Charter. Is there a second? I second. All right. Any questions or comments? Yes. this is not going to be popular. I moved to table this item until at least December 17th board meeting. And not before we as a board have
101the opportunity to read, discuss, and vote on the new dependent charter petition, which was created for the new dependent charter school. We can review and vote on this MOU at the same meeting or at the first meeting in January. My reasons for tabling this. are that there are provisions within this MOU that refer specifically to the charter. I have not seen any aspect of the charter. And so these references don't have I don't know what they are. I don't know what I'm voting on. One of them is around the specialty teacher employment model it refers to element one of the charter petition. The other one was on school leadership. where the principal, I believe the hiring process would be ensure alignment with the criteria outlined in the new charter petition. I've not seen the charter
102petition. So I personally feel very uncomfortable. And actually do not think it is appropriate. for me or the board to consider this MOU before I have seen the charter petition itself. Especially since there is reference to the charter within the MOU. unexplained references. I feel like the cart is before the horse. I don't know why this was rushed. This is brought to our staff. Right before Thanksgiving. They work through Thanksgiving. They work through last week in order to accommodate Live Oaks request on this MOU. And I just feel that I'm not prepared to vote. If this has to go forward before the charter. First, I need a second on the motion to table. I second because I agree. Okay, so now what we are discussing is the motion to table until the meeting next week,
103just to be clear. Is there precedent with our other charters? I think the only other charter that we, and sorry, Tony, I got to look to you. I know this is on the spot. I apologize. I think the only other charter that we approved was the dual immersion. So I don't know if there's past practice of approving an MOU or having some type of MOU before there's a charter presented to us I think this is unique in the sense that we are partnering with with Live Oak to developing a new dependent charter. And essentially, this MOU just outlines responsibilities, expectations, operational processes that we would need to begin implementing a new charter. which then upon approval, if approved, then we would move into a public hearing and review of the charter petition, because this would
104help solidify things that we would need to to put in there before we present it to the board and to the public And then on the 17th, the goal would be on the 17th to review and also to approve the new charter. The goal was also after tonight we would publish the most recent draft of the charter tonight of early tomorrow. So that we can give enough time for the community and the board to review it prior to next week's board meeting. there's a lot of stuff in the MOU that I have a problem with. So that's why I agree with Maddie to table it because I want to see what they're referring to in here in the charter, I don't feel I have enough information to vote yes on this. Tony, help me clarify
105this. So, yeah, it caught me off guard too to have an mou prior to uh prior I'm not sure why there's a need for both is the question. And so I would like you to clarify that but But before you do, I just want to understand This MOU is between live oak and the district. the charter is not Live Oaks charter. It's the district's charter for a new school that's going to be created by the combination of Live Oak and Valley Vista And so I'd like you to chat about Tell us about the need for both the MOU or the purpose for the MOU separate from the charter. and the processes of creating the charter that includes the the the contributions of both the Live Oak families and the Valley Oak or the Valley Vista
106families and staff. Okay, well, you know, this is all a really new territory for all of us, even with our legal counsel, it's a kind of a new territory. There are things in this MOU that don't necessarily need to be in the charter. They're not part of that process. They set the stage for us to begin that process. So that's why this mulu really helps us ensure our expectations and responsibilities on both sides and making sure that there are certain conditions that are are met before we engage any further. And really is just asking for the board to to review that and to ensure that that this is something we've vetted, something that we've gone through our legal to make sure that it that it aligns to what we expect. And protects the district as
107well. So in that sense. It's really to ensure the operational processes and expectations that don't necessarily are reflected in a charter that would be more heavily program focused So, um. So hopefully that answered that first part. And then the second part is if you could repeat that. Just the process of developing the charter give me assurance that we have, you know, we have some representation here tonight from both Valley Vista and Live Oak. My hunches have been heavy on the live oak side, understandably, because we're talking about a Waldorf pedagogy. But tell me about the input and participation of Valley Vista in the creation of the charter. Yeah, so there's there's been a timeline of that Dali Vista has gone through to gather input and provide information I think we heard from parents that they've
108been communicated a lot. I don't know if it's appropriate to ask Jamie to talk about the process that they did with Valley Vista and the community that was involved. And then the piece that the district came on is once that was massaged through, then we began to really look at the charter as it's with the feedback that or the input that had been happening at the sites. I would love to hear from Jamie. Sorry, Jamie, to put you on the spot. like that timer just at the side of me all the time Or maybe I want it. Maybe I want a reason to step down. I don't know. This has been a big journey for us. emotionally and navigating both the community members that are really excited about this. Those that are less than excited
109about this and those that are neutral and just kind of watching the journey unfold. And we definitely have a mixed bag. So there's a lot of conversating and trying to communicate as much as we can and As you guys know, there's no such thing as like over communicating because there's always still questions left out there. So I leave room for that. We've done the big and the small, and I have shared a timeline with Esmeralda Mondragon that I hoped was being shared around occasionally i think with some of you that showed everything from the meetings that we've held with Matthew when he was still here and tony and inviting parents to come in. And just kind of have an open forum. to emails and parent square like frequently asked questions and trying to update as
110updates were available. We have formed a small committee with live oak of parents on both sides and some staff. to kind of help navigate what does the You know, you have to like plan to plan the meetings You know, those fun things. So we've had input just on even how we are involving parents. We had a big night that we invited Live Oak and Valley Vista parents to come to where we had pieces of the charter out. And parents had opportunity to engage and give feedback, ask questions, tell us what they liked, what they had concerns with, what they would want to see more of. within certain parts of the charter that are more Like boots on the ground programmatic pieces And then we took that information and incorporated it into the draft that you
111have available to you soon? Right. I have every faith that you'll see it very soon. And just… having that feedback back and forth. We've done coffees with the principals. We have one tomorrow for all of you out there that would like to stop by and chat about it some more. And again, we had a special evening too, or morning actually for our Spanish speaking population to make sure like we were really targeting the questions from like various various groups and trying to provide as many opportunities as we can. Did that answer all of it? Furthermore, I'm happy to chat about it. Can I just really take a moment here? express that this has been quite a journey for staff. And for parents, we have a mixed bag even here in this room. Sounds like even
112amongst all of us. And one thing I have to say is we have gotten to the point where we are able to get into the trenches together and talk about what would work and talk about what's right for students and we're not always agreeing. We might have different practices for that. But I'm really proud. of our parent community. And I support them whatever the choices for next year. I've told them, like, I'm here for you principal to parent, parent to parent, like let's talk about what's right for your kid. Let me help you find that that right choice. And I would say the same thing to our live oak communities. Like we are all just here trying to help the kids in this town find the right education for themselves. I think it's great that
113PCS is considering giving this as an option? I think it's nice to provide this to families And I think there's enough room for all of us here. And when we're at this place where we can just have an honest conversation and discourse and talk about like. What can we provide kids where we're already kind of winning. So I'm really proud of this community. I think they all deserve a big pat on the back for the hard work that they've done. And that's all. Thank you. Any other questions or comments on the motion to table? I just have a real quick question. So it sounded like you were saying that we will not be seen the charter unless we pass this MOU. Correct. This MOU is so so our PCS responsibility in this is being subsumed
114under an MOU that is from Live Oak? No, this is a mutual MOU that encompasses our non-negotiables along with their non-negotiables that we've come to a mutual agreement with in regards to how things like facilities, things like staffing. Right. But I'm still struggling with why this has to happen before we see the charter when there are specific things in here, including staffing the type of staffing, the amount of staffing And that we are then going to be held to this for four years. when we haven't seen the charter. I don't know what that means. I mean, I'm not against this. I want you all to know that. But the process has been truncated here. And from my perspective. And I don't feel comfortable voting on something that will really change our community. It doesn't just
115change Valley Vista. And it's a really, I'm taking this very seriously. I'm not i'm not taking sides here, I just want to make sure that this process is done so that i can vote on it. feeling like I have enough information to do the right thing. Maddie, I… Completely appreciate your sentiments around this. I know this journey has been challenging for A lot of us, especially with the community We want to acknowledge the strong emotions and feelings people have had on both sides. You know, and I think giving that space for that and sharing that is important because you know there's there's things that we we would look back and say, we wish we could have done things a little differently. But here we are in this moment. And I think sharing that is very
116important. I completely appreciate that. I think, again, this MOU, there are things in this MOU that just wouldn't exist in the charter. And to supersede this MOU with a charter first wouldn't allow certain non-negotiables that we would want to have in place before we approve or the charter. That's why this is really the operational piece of that piece. And some of these things would expire And some of them would exist depending on what needs to exist And so this MOU expires in 2028. And then, but with that approval of this, then we can then initiate the deep review and conversation around the charter petition itself, around the program, around what it looks like and all the details that go along with that new dependent charter. I guess I just don't understand. why we have to
117approve this before we've even seen the charter. It's very valid Live Oak. Not Valley Oaks, Live Oak Heavy. And there's just stuff in here that As I've mentioned to you guys. I don't agree with. And I don't have enough information to vote on. And I would imagine that some of that information would be contained Because you keep the charter you say is a draft at this point. So I don't know why we can't see the draft before we vote on this. I think because this mo you think because You know, based on how it's written, we just wanted to guarantee certain things that we can ensure on our end. Because if this isn't passed and there's no point in moving forward with a charter. And this just at least allows us to set the stage
118for us to have a successful implementation and review of the charter petition once it once It's available, which will have the draft hopefully available by tonight or early tomorrow morning. of which the final should be by which should be before we post for the next board meeting. And again, this is just the operational and responsibilities expectations that we expect to make sure is in place prior to any charter beginning, dependent charter beginning. And Tony, those conditions are in alignment with our labor contracts with our Correct. We have legal, we have human resource, Amanda, we're all, we're sitting and making sure that um The language does not violate any of our collective bargaining agreements and or put our staffing at a disadvantage. One of the things in here is they talk about class size. I don't
119know what they what Live Oak considers what they expect their class size to be compared to what our labor contracts state. They talk about specialty teacher employment model. I don't understand that. I don't know. It just… it just seems more live oak than PCS. Yeah, you know, not to get into specifics unless you would like to, you know, class size, language around this MOU are things that are not solidified in any kind of guarantee. We use language such as reasonable effort to provide additional staffing. We're not saying that So, you know, we've reviewed this with HR to make sure that what the language we put in here is language that isn't tie us into things that we can't fiscally support or things that puts us at a disadvantage. you'll see that the language is aspirational
120and isn't set in stone in any kind of way that puts us at a disadvantage. All right. I think one of the reasons why it feels live oak heavy in the MOU is because As we operate as a district, we already have how we operate, what our class sizes are, what our employment contracts look like. As Live Oak stands today as an independent charter. Their staffing is very different than how we staff here. And when we were meeting to start to discuss the charter. we were running into the big differences. And I think that's what started this conversation of can we agree can we come together of our non-negotiables? Well, for PCS, our non-negotiables are we follow our employment contracts. And I think the language that is very vague on the class size actually is
121on the opposite side of it. So live oak does have classes that are They operate closer to a 1 to 28 And we have a 1 to 24. So it's about we can't make agreements that, and that's for their looping model. to sustain full class sizes. So we are not in a position to say yes. you can have 28 first graders in your class because that is against our employment contract with our certificated union. So it's about having language that we will go to the table. We will discuss this once live the new chart, the new chart I keep calling it that becomes a dependent charter on how to best meet those needs. That's why some of this class size language is very vague because it's to work with our union partners to if if
122it works for everybody, if it works for the families, the teachers, the union, to have more students to maintain the integrity of the program that that's great, but we can't make that promise. Our non-negotiables are we treat within reason of each of our charters have their own charter. every school the same. So we allow this FTE of classified staff for our office, we allow this. We have additional FTE here at some of our one of our charters. It's Spanish at another one it is gardening. So it's to really pare down what we can support within the financials that this charter will encompass and the language reads that There will be, is it a foundation? Is it a PTA that will help support additional staffing. We allow that for all of our other schools. So I
123think we were to the point with this MOU trying to say. Because if it was a non-negotiable for live the current live oak to be at a 20 to 1 certificated staffing ratio we could never agree to that but we didn't truly know what our non-negotiables were until we met to discuss them. And these are all things that don't necessarily need to be in the charter that is already a very long document. It needs to be about really the program, all of the other things that go into a charter that I'm just learning about, but it was to remove that. And if we couldn't come to an agreement the administration of PCS and Live Oak administration on these things. there wouldn't be a charter to bring forward because we would know that we could not
124come to an agreement because though this is a new charter school, we're really in this weird situation that we are merging two schools without doing mergers because essentially both schools will close and cease to exist and there will be this brand new charter. And then some of the pieces about the different elements That is because operationally, one of the things that comes up a lot is the charter council or what our other sites schools would be a site council is All of that isn't… operational in coming to terms if we can or can't. So those type of things can be worked out in the charter. Their Monday, there actually was a lot more language that after working with legal was like, this doesn't belong in an operational MOU. this belongs in a charter, this MOU
125has gotten quite a bit shorter because We wanted a clear what we felt at the time was a very clear and concise of the non-negot in order to move forward with bringing and in a much better world. Then the one we're currently in, we would have one more board meeting this month and um it would be mu This week, next week, it would be first rate of the charter. The following week, it would be approval. We also have this truncated timeline, not only due to our board meetings is that Starting the process of what goes next you in order to do it in order to do correctly and adequately, you really need six months. And that is January 1st, our board meeting is January 10, then… 14th. So that, you know, those, those two first
126two weeks of january make a difference in all of the things that still need to happen in order to apply for a CDS code. You have to have a name. You have to name the charter. That takes time. We need to hire the new principal. which follows all of PCS's hiring guidelines in order to do the next thing. So it's this domino effect and that's how really we ended up where we are now with this MOU that is spelling out really the non-negotiables And taking the charter to the public hearing and the board meeting for approval. It's so we're not in a position that we miss any of our timelines we have to get a new CDS code for a school. We have to go to the county. We have to open a new fund.
127As I stated earlier, all of our charters are their own funds. We need to submit the information to the state in order to have the funding available this year. when we started the dual language immersion charter for this year stirs information like the teachers do not automatically qualify for STRS. So there's all of these things. And I think that's where we ended up. in the timing, which we realize is not ideal this wasn't what I think any of us really was hoping to do over the last few weeks, but we felt that this is what needed to happen. In order to move this process along and put our best foot forward for for both for the district and for Live Oak. Any questions or comments about that will make you have an informed decision on
128whether or not to vote yes or no on tabling? the MOU until next week. I want to speak in against the motion to table and just encourage my colleagues here to move this forward. Our staff is giving us their assurance that This is in the interest of the district as well as Live Oak and our attorneys have agreed that this is within the realm of what we can do with our labor contracts. And the community is ready to move forward. Let's not be the roadblock. All right. I call the question. Okay, no, go for it. I just want to ask if it's possible to just have the MOU moved So that we pass it next week or look at it next week. At the same time that we're looking at the charter. That's what you
129moved. Okay. All right. So that before we pass the chart or we would pass the mo Yes. Yeah. It would be on the same agenda but we would be we would be moving on the MOU before We would be moving on the charter. Is there anything against doing that and if there's I think the problem is that there's stuff in here that refers to a charter that we haven't seen. That's one of my issues. So we'll let Tony answer. And understood. And ultimately, as a board that those are decisions you guys will have to make. All I can say is that the PCS administration worked hard to put forward something that we believe could carry us forward with the next steps. And now we look to you for leadership. And I really, really, really appreciate
130the amount of time and effort you've got you've you've done for this. I admire you amazingly. So thank you. All right. So I call the question the motion to table. I'm going to do a roll call vote. So this is the motion to table until next week. Trustee Cloud. Trust me. Yes. Trustee Jen. Trustee Pond. No. Trustee Webster. And I vote no. So the motion to table does not carry So we are back to voting to approve the MOU. Or if there's anyone who wants to make a motion to amend or anything like that, now would be the time to do so or ask any clarifying questions about the MOU as it stands. All right. I… call to question the original motion, which was to approve the MOU. I will again do a roll call
131vote. Trustee Cloud. No. Trustee Jen. trustee pawn yes Trustee Webster. And I vote aye. So the MOU passes as written. And we will take a five minute recess. Please come back at 825. Let's come back. I'm reconvening this meeting at 8.32 p.m. And we'll take comments from the public on discussion or information items public if You seem like you're chilling. All right. Since the public is not storming the stage, we'll move on to discussion information items. Including starting with our first reading of board bylaw 9010 about public statements. Who's presenting? Luann, are you presenting on the phone? Cool. Thank you, trustees. As a first read here. you'll see that number one and number two are really board bylaws and they focus on They're updated because of legal requirements. There's new laws in place. And it's
132just interesting because I was looking at the first board policy in 9010 and I think the first version we have here was from 2002. So, right. So there's been some significant changes with social media and everything else. And so this first First read here, let me pull this up. Let's see, spokesperson. Just looking at this confidential information Both of them really focus on what I think about as around the Brown Act and just being careful around not doing serial meetings and looking when you're on social media and if another trustee posts that you don' put a like thumbs up or an emoji to show support. And that's really what these two both go hand in hand. And it's really making clear also that when you speak, you're speaking as an individual trustee. You're not speaking
133for the board. And of course, these things are not applicable when you have personal social media pages and you're talking about going water skiing or something else. It's just related to the business of Petaluma City Schools. And so that really encompasses both the first bylaw 9010 and then bylaw 9012. And this is a first reading for both of you and for all of you and i'm sure you've already look through it, but that is the essence of those two agenda items. We also have as a board norm that the president speaks. So she answers the the emails or he will achieve for right now. So let's just say she. answers the emails. And so this kind of just fits in with what our norms are anyway. Totally. And I just can't even begin to tell
134you how correct that is that you have a spokesperson for the board and everybody isn't doing their own thing. And that's what they talk about in this board policy as well. It's just being united with one voice around the board president so And again, these are first reads, and we'll bring them back to you on the 17th. Cool. Any questions on either of those? All right, moving on to the first reading of 514. 45.13 response to immigration enforcement. Yeah, and I just want to thank, I think Maddie brought this to our attention and Bree did a lot of background research on this and We contacted legal to just make sure that we weren't stepping out of bounds in any ways. And the bottom line is we want to support all of our students. And we're
135not looking at immigration status. We're not making any kinds of judgments. We're here for every child. And I just want to thank both of them for bringing this forward. I remember being a superintendent and bringing this forward My goodness, I don't even remember how many years ago Yeah, 16 was well we i yeah and here we go, folks. So, um. we just ask for, you know, you're reading this this this first read here. But again, in response to immigration enforcement, and we're going to keep our kids safe. That is the bottom line with this policy here. What is this? One of the pieces of the policy in 2016 was that if anybody did come to the school. we would send them to the district. Yeah, and so kind of, no, you can't talk to our
136kids And so that it's not in here, but that was one part of it. Oh, so what we will do so at the next, let me just clarify, check with my superintendent here. When we come back, we'll have a resolution that goes along with this Yes. So when we went to write the resolution, the resolution specifically referenced this policy. And when I checked our board policy, we did not have this policy on file. So we are proposing that we start with a first rate of this policy and then at the next meeting we would bring this back for second read. as well as a resolution that references the policy. So we didn't… We didn't codify it as a policy in 2016. No, it was not. It was a board policy in 2016. Okay, because we
137talked about it. So in many ways for… purposes, board policies are more impactful than a resolution. So that's why we thought that was important to start with. Perfect. I agree. Thank you. I just want to thank you very much for doing that. You really worked hard on it. I think we all felt it was really, really important. It was brought to me by a parent at Avonce when I went for board office hours, you know, and so that's the value of that board office hours and so she wanted to know if we had a policy And I said, well, I'm sure we have a policy. I remember. And, you know, so then we look it up and we didn't. I really appreciate all the hard work on it. And I want to also note that
138it also includes their families are also protected. May I request that this be brought to second reading in action. Next week's action before the organizational meeting. I would like to vote. Thanks. Yeah, we absolutely do that. Thank you. All right. Thank you. And now moving on. business services, we got another board policy, 3550 about food service and child nutrition program. Amanda, what are you going to tell us about this one? Yes, this policy is bringing being brought forward to reflect updated laws and regulations. Perfect. Any questions or comments? Cool. Moving on to free and reduced price meals. This one is updated for universal free meals. language. Makes sense. Perfect. And then moving on to our Terra Verde asset management report. All right, tonight we bring forward the district's report from Terra Verde that shows the
139solar PV systems achieved 98% of the expected production for the first quarter of the 24-25 fiscal year. with most sites performing well. However, Petaluma Junior underperformed due to issues with the implementation of the new battery backup. We had some inverters go down. Those are now being fixed and the battery backups are online and ready for commission. The thing that I did want to note is that we saw an 18% increase in electricity usage. And with McDowell Elementary. 74% over last quarter. So we will now work with our team to do to figure out the why for that. a lot of our solar is 10 to 14 years old and it is aging out. This is a constant topic that has come up with the community meetings. Not only that but the board's potential desire to
140move forward with more battery backups at our other sites. And we have been switching out another thing that we've been trying to get ahead of is lighting on our campuses. the lack of lighting on our campuses. So we did install some Not to the tune of 74% of an increase But there is some new lighting. Lisa is also reaching out to PG&E to make sure that there isn't something wrong with the meter. All right. Any questions or comments other than your hatred of PG&E about the asset management? Report. It's great that, I mean, usage overall went up, but like the usage of non-solar is so low. It's great. Could you briefly explain the negative orange bars? I don't know What happens when you get a negative PG&E? I think the orange bar is PG&E, right?
141Are we looking on page for example on the site uh on the site reports there's some schools that have negative utility usage. Like Grant, for example. Yeah, Grant is an example yes yeah That is, I'm looking at 14 is an example of alley yokes. Are we selling excess solar back to PG&E? Is that what's going on? Or how do you get a negative utility? Yeah, I am going to check with um I will check with Tara Verde and report back. I think what I want to confirm is if this is over last quarter or overall So some of our usage is down. So I will confirm what exactly this page's reporting. All right, moving on to ed services. First reading of an update to board policy 4040 employee use of technology. Can you tell us
142about this one, Tony? Yeah, the. the board policy 440 and also the 6163.4 is really updates using the language from CSBA around the use of technology. Dave's department actually worked on this. I don't know if he wants to elaborate anymore about it, but it's just updating the the technology policy with the current language. Only if you want to share. Don't feel pressured Yeah. finally at the podium. All right. Someone put the timer on. Now's your time. You're going to need it. And no one can cut your mic. Okay, so we've been doing a lot of work in the district starting last spring around starting to grapple with generative artificial intelligence because it is here. And at first we tried to deny that fact and bury it and block it. That's futile. And so we began
143with meeting with different stakeholder groups and reviewing example guidelines and policies developing our own getting feedback from our staff, from the community, then bringing that to the Learning and Innovation Committee this year, continuing to work with it. And then taking steps to offer professional development opportunities to increase the AI literacy for our educators. And we're now at the point where we're starting to bring some policies that reflect some of this work and laying the groundwork for our next steps. And so these policies are updates to the standard use of technology policies that we currently have in place and they make mention to AI and provide a little bit of guidance and parameters around it. We intend to come back with a standalone AI policy, including the guidelines that the various stakeholders have helped develop. That'll
144put a finer point. around what the… what our values are around the use of it. But especially in this the use of AI by the use of the staff, there's some items that are really importantly outlined there around acceptable use and the importance of having the human and the loop at all times. And that's really an important tenant to us. It's critical that we get to a point soon that we can safely start to expose our students to how to use these tools productively Because we really face an equity issue where the people who have access to devices and a network outside of ours, they can begin to learn to utilize these. And people who don't right now don't have access because it's blocked because we haven't gotten to the point where we felt that
145we could safely start working with students with these technologies but i i We're getting there. I think we've made a lot of progress. And so this is an important milestone in that effort. At the conference, that was one of the big things was that this is to get on top of it now and that students are using it anyway. And they're using it to help themselves in their studies from what I mean. I have a friend whose son used it. figured out math, you know? But, you know, because it was just told in a different way. And there was also a wonderful segment on 60 minutes. Did you see that by any chance? You should try to catch it just on YouTube. It was a segment on AI. And it was around both instruction, but
146it was around schools and instruction and uh student and teacher use but also Just… how it can support students In different ways. It was fascinating. And everything can happen so quickly. Yeah. For some things, but it's all what they said at the conference is it's what you put in it. Just saying, you know, like, you know, write an essay for me, you know, you're going to get really awful stuff. And that's not the, that's not the point of it. You want to get to the being able to help students understand the value and And being aware that, I mean, like in the recent National Geographic articles. that I've been reading about the application of Gen AI in many different industries. archaeology, medicine, and people have these these large language model applications that they've come up
147with that are aiding them in doing the work that they're doing in a more efficient way and it's taking us to a new level. So it's not like they're putting a prompt in and saying. write me a five paragraph essay about this book in my English class, we don't want that happening. We need to work toward educating our students around using it in that way and how that's not what it's really. But at this point, we're not there. We're not quite at the point of releasing it to students, but I feel like by the end of This year we might be with some of our secondary students, because we were able to have over 150 educators. participate in AI professional development recently. We'll be offering another session in January. We have a really engaged group
148with some of them are here tonight that have been reviewing these policies and providing feedback. been doing that accordion process of doing of bringing it to ERC. But I think it's really important that we go slow to go fast. And make sure we do this in a compliant way too, thinking about student data privacy and appropriate use. And so anyhow. That's any other. So this policy alludes to, but isn't really explicit about students using the district computers, but I know at one point we had said, I want to say it was the beginning of last year or this year, we wanted students to be using their district issued computers. Is that correct? Without bringing their own devices to school to use We do still have a bring your own device option so And we offer
149device to any student who wants to and we have like upward of 90% take rate on it. I don't know if people always bring our device to school you know But, uh. I just don't see how we can regulate a lot of these things. And like you were saying um like just an equity issue as well. If there's a student who has like this souped up MacBook who can use all of these extensions and ai things and then there's the student with the Chromebook that does not have that. Yeah, so students who are on our network on their own device would be like violating the use agreement. to get around the internet filters that block AI At this point so i mean at this point It's possible. I'm not going to deny that. There are
150ways to, on your own device, have a VPN or to be tethering to your phone. As opposed to if you're on one of our Chromebooks, it's a little bit harder. I think there's probably savvy students who figure out ways on our Chromebooks too And, you know. patch those holes when we find them. But as far as… the capability of the device to use the AI tools. Once we… come up with a way to bring them to students. I don't have concerns about the functionality and like the you know, and the comparable experience using like because the processing power for the gen AI tools is not happening on the device. It's happening on the platform. So it's, you know. Thank you. All right. Any other questions on either of the tech ones? All right, let's move
151on to more new course proposals. So exciting. Tony, can you tell us about these two new courses? One is both of these courses are CTE or grant funded and they are a part of the CTE pathway. The introduction to public service careers is really exposing students to like nonprofit careers, emergency services, fire, police opportunities. So they'll do a lot of job shadowing and learning about public service careers that hopefully a lot of our students are attracted to. And the other one's internships, where students will have opportunities to intern various pathways that they're interested in. led by our… our staff as well as outside support to help students find internships. The public service is a concentrator course and it will begin at Casa Grande. The internships are at both campuses. And these are grant funded so
152there are… I think it was, I think we received a $200,000 grant for these courses. Any questions or comments? Just real quick, was this brought to you and Dan through students by any chance? Was there a student interest in this? I think through, I think it was through a grant that Dan's department uh apply for. And I believe it was just part of it was just part I don't remember if it was part of the advisory work, but I think it was just part of the pathways that a strong part of the strong workforce and work-based learning things that we wanted to bring to students. All right. Any other comments or questions? Very exciting stuff. And we love grant funded stuff. Speaking of grant funded stuff, Tony, tell us about the student field trip to
153Florida. Yes. So one of our CT teachers really is excited to provide an opportunity for the students in the broadcast journalism pathway to attend a conference in Florida. Typically, we'd go through the process of just doing a first reading, but in this case, because of the cost $56,000. to send a number of students to this conference, I figured it would be a good place to get some input from the board around you know what what if this is something we could bring forward. It is CTE IG funded, so it's a grant funded. So the students, there wouldn't be any cost to the students. They don't have to fundraise. But it is a large amount and it is across the country. I think one piece that I need to sit down with Amanda is to really
154make sure that, because CTEG funds are matching funds. And we continually spend that funding, we also have to match it to two to one. So I need to sit with Amanda to make sure that this does not exceed our match or we're not duplicating purchases with it. But it is a good opportunity for the students. It is a great network conference for the students who are interested in broadcast journalism. And the teacher, Jamal. I was excited about it and it's something that he's passionate about. So I know that the kids will have a great experience, but at the same time. I think just… the cost and everything else. I just want to make sure the board has time to weigh in and make any recommendations that they might have. Any questions or comments? So just
155clarify for me tony that what you just said about the funding. the grant funding is it's not a grant for this trip, it's grant for our cte is our CTE funding. We would pull in that you're that we're pulling from And is that correct? Correct. So our CTIG is something we apply for every year to receive funding. It is matching funds, so it's not like a grant that we you know that it doesn't cost us anything it does it doesn't cost us but But we… But we also, I mean, there's funds that we should be spending. So we just want to make sure. And I think it's generally written into the application for providing our students with these kinds of opportunities. It's really just making sure that we haven't overspent our funds and we're not
156And it was being fiscally responsible around our CTIG. is our match from general funds? Our match has been in the most part salaries. So we pay for all CTE teacher salaries and that can count as a match. Okay. An income. So this wouldn't necessarily impact, we wouldn't be taking away anything from something else. This is so much money. Yeah. I can… Do you think this is something worth bringing to first reading, I can bring more information to bring more assurances to make sure We can address those things. Because it's an exceptional sum of money. So, I mean, it just like went Oh, a lot. And this is taking a kid or the students away for a week from school. as well. And also that if there's something else that money could be used for within
157that pathway other than $56,000 to go to Florida for a week. I mean, for a really good conference, I'm not against it at all. Yeah, I mean, if it was adults, maybe we'd question that, but these are students, so this could be a good opportunity that some students may never actually ever have. It'd be fabulous. I was looking at the… I clicked on the conferencing. It looks amazing. But also, if we're going to pay this, then we cannot be charging for anything, any other field trips. Even the $5 ones. So that needs to be like, so I'm proposing that if we move forward with this, because I do want the kids to have this opportunity, then we just have to just maybe have another resolution like resolution make it very explicit that we are not
158charging for field trips. Because we can't just be like this group of 30 students And four chaperones gets to go all the way to Florida for five days. But then everybody else got to pay. Or how do we like offset some of the costs of like But I know Amanda's like, oh, of like the of the bigger trips, like the whatchamacallit. Yeah, like the, what's it called? The week away. What are they called? Six weed camola. That's like, that's 300 bucks and like, I get it. That would be a lot of money added up over time. But then also… I don't know. If I'm a parent struggling to raise a $300 and then the board just approved. this 56,000. So then how do we Again, make it, I mean, because we know we can't have
159equality, but something like give something For everyone else as well so Yeah, I'd be happy to explore. Work your magic with the budget and yeah. Yeah, you're doing. Yeah, I'd be happy to explore options that we can do. Maybe we can expand CTIG to, I mean, CTIG is essentially K-12. It's not necessarily secondary. So we just have to, you know. find creative ways of utilizing without putting us in any kind of fiscal Yeah, the more field trips we can make CTE. I mean, I think it's Marketing. Just… Right. How is this relevant to your future career? Most of the field trips are because they're educational. It's not just Yeah. All right. Any other questions or comments on that? If not… Olivia, do you have any friends in the Trojan broadcast? Have you spoken about any
160of these trips or anything? My best friend has been in Trojan broadcast since freshman year and she loves it she's Dosari's best friend. They're like twins. She like talks to me all the time about they've gone on other like trips like that. They've gone to competitions and It sounds like it's really helpful to learn from other people and also like They use a lot of teamwork when they go there and I think it's really good for team bonding. So yeah, that sounds really exciting. Thank you. And Esmeralda, you're off the hook again. Oh, my God. It just means something's coming in the future. That's all that means. Moving on to future business. So next week's meeting is supposed to be pretty short, so I would ask Unless something is super, super urgent that we talk
161about future business for next semester. Does anyone have any future business? for next semester or anything that really needs to get added to our second December meeting. the procedures for… I don't know what you call it, for the library, you know, the library for objecting to a to a book. They've had it ready for… They finally got it to us like two days ago. Yeah, just so we can, yeah. Okay, so that's my future business for next year, not next week. Perfect. Yeah, I emailed Tony earlier today and asked for it to be in January too. So, yeah. Mind meld. Any other future business? Yeah, you know. She's making faces over there. This will be for, oh, yes, Shelby. Do you have anything? Yes. You're just going to assign us like to be able to
162accomplish. I think for next year, not next meeting, but again, just hearing more concerns Just around access and opportunity again about like the fees. One of the sessions I attended at the conference was put on by CIF. And we are not supposed to be charging fees for uniforms. And I know we are. We're having people buy uniforms and it's against Ed Code and CIF bylaws. So I guess I'm still concerned about the lack of accountability on following up on Add code and our board policies. So I would, again, I'm pushing for students and parents to be surveyed around their costs and their athletic experiences. Because that also goes to overall school climate so that's that's just a big concern for me right now. And piggybacking on that. costs for field trips. I think that's something
163we really discuss. Any other future business items? All right. So with that, I adjourn us at 9.02.