001e e e meeting back to order it's 5:30 from Clos session I'm go ahead going to go ahead and turn over to trusty Duncan all right so um uh reporting out for close session uh item 3.2 cases 1 and two were heard and the board provided direction to council and we will potentially um report out on case three uh later this evening and just for the record we didn't finish our closed session item so we will be recessing at the close of our Open Session back to closed session all right moving on to item 3.3 just kidding we're going to go ahead and stip to um item four for um and just as a reminder that this meeting is being audio and video recorded and housekeeping restrooms are available across um the parking lot in
002the Gold Country meeting room all righty okay we're going to go ahead and move to item five and do our organization trusty Lake would you please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance sure I'll rise Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for stands one nation God indivisible with liy andice all righty welcome thanks for being with us this evening we appreciate you taking the time to come out and be with us those that are not re ired to be here we we do value your attendance and appreciate your advocacy and involvement with our district um we are going to go ahead and move to item 5.2 approval of the agenda do I have a motion and do I have any changes to the agenda I move to
003approve by second we have a first by trusty Underwood second by trusty Duncan all in favor to approve the agenda all in favor say I I I all oppose hearing none motion passes unanimously item six reports and Communications we're doing this a little bit different um this time around we're going to go ahead and have our reports and Communications all lumped together and um we're going to go ahead and start with the board reports tonight do I have a trustee who' like to go first trusty Underwood would you like to report out first are we doing the board report the last week I my report is on student voice um I'm noticing that more and more students are becoming involved it's it's exciting to see students taking a vested interest in their school um being
004excited wanting to make a contribution basically wanting to be heard and knowing they're being listen to so uh it's one of the best programs I think we have in the district awesome okay um I'd say uh for me as a new board member uh it has been really good to go on the learning walks uh it's been extremely informational uh I am just blown away um on how how well uh these classrooms are being run um the uh the erasable desks is like the coolest thing that I wish I would have had when I was in school um that's just a small piece but the interaction collaboration what's going on with with the school uh with the students um the engagement by the teachers um just the strategy and thoughtfulness that was going on as
005well I was just really impr impressed and just to be specific I was in Forest Hill and I was in um Placer um and so uh so that's been really cool and then um I also had the opportunity to sit in with the uh athletic directors uh and uh and listen and uh that was also a really good experience to hear the the different uh thoughts and and the processes and proced teachers going on there um so that was that was good so a lot of learning and a lot of things I'm trying to take in and these are really important as I continue to uh try to grow in this role so it's been been great Jeff I think since uh our last board meeting there's two events that I attended one was the
006uh spring back to school night at kfax um and that was really nice to see um so many parents and students that came out for that was really was really neat um and then the the learning walk at deloro um that we attended as well um I thought it was really nice to see um you know a whole slew of teachers that are really hardworking that really care about their students um yeah so I mean that was it was just a great evening so both of actually both of these evenings were really nice EXC trusty Lake would you go ahead and click your microphone sure thank you so it's been a it's been a busy month since uh the last board meeting and uh it's been very informative I feel like uh I've learned a
007lot and I can tell you if somebody said there was aou from ATP co-written with anyway this is a this is a a culture of acronyms and there's there's tons of them but uh no I it's been it's been uh it's been very good I'm I'm really grateful so uh I o went to the back to school night at coolax it was really uh I felt like it was really well attended great Energy Great culture there um I appreciate principal uh chassid for um taking the time to show us around uh the facility and to see where there are some uh fairly urgent needs um appreciate that and uh and we also had um a really good conversation so I'm I'm grateful for that I also did the uh uh the walk and learn at
008deloro and uh that's awesome so um I feel like you know you you you you get uh thrust into this role as a as a board truste and um you you you see a different side to to education and I feel like uh Delo is one of those great examples of of um how things can be done and it's and to be honest um I went from that walk and learn we did a walk and learn at Forest Hill a walk and learn at uh classer and a walk and learn back at kfax um and what just stands out is is the the passion not just of um faculty and admin but you you you really feel the sense of um uh uh I just want your students to know that it there are there's
009so much love and support for for you all and um it's it's so apparent and it's and it's really wonderful to be honest um and um I appreciate Zoe taking the time up at Forest Hill I feel like Forest Hill is like a little Hidden Gem because for years I've driven right past it and just didn't even know it was there um to go dirt bike riding or you know Timber sleding or whatever out in the snow but anyway it it's been a it's been a real um and that was just with the schools there's also been a lot of training that's gone on CS uh let's see we did a did a ATP meeting to learn more about I think they had there was a speaker there about the brown act um I attended
010a training from the uh pcoe um uh Gail did a puts on a a great program there and that was really informative learned how to calculate the ad the Ada for the district and um yeah and it seems like um superintendent Steve is there every step of the way everything we we attend so it's it's been good to work with you so I'm just uh grateful for this opportunity and I hope that I can uh be of some service and uh and that's why we're here so thank you awesome thank you guys so much and I just realized that we got to one more item in close so after I give this we're gonna I'm not sure how this works do I'm looking to you because you're probably most on top of um the rules
011but we actually got to 3.3.1 so we just go back after anyway so but um we'll go ahead and finish the board reports at this point and then we'll come back um so like the other trustees attended a lot of different events at the schools I'm always um humbled and honored to get to you know sit in and watch our teachers do their thing and to get to chat with the kids it's awesome so I also attended the learning walk with trusty Lake and Jeff also attended um the pler high school measure gcoc meeting and colfax's uh spring back to school night with trusty Lake and Jeff as well attended Forest HS learning walk um and then I had a couple interesting meetings with um other local elected off officials in our area Auburn Union
012um their board president Greg Holtz he and I spoke and met and discussed a couple different things related to um uh potential internships for our our district students uh they'd really like to have some mentorship and internships um at the elementary schools which I think is awesome we also talked about our Confluence students internships for their work internships and um and he has spoken with his superintendent about it so we'd like to kind of figure out what we can do to collabor at um and they can you know be mentored by by staff at aosd and it kind of clears up some of the other issues that we've been dealing with with trying to hire them at other local businesses with the fingerprinting because everyone in education has been cleared so um I think that
013that'll be a really interesting partnership and we also talked about the math department um obviously that's an area of focus for our all of our districts um and an Our Nation frankly but I'm wanting to kind of coordinate a visit with the superintendent at least to plaster because that's where aosd is feeding and to um have a walkth through and chat with our math department and make sure that our curriculum is speaking to each other and that they're preparing the kids for what they're going to need to know when they're when they're entering our program we also had I also went to a two by two with trusty Duncan and uh current board president uh Darcy Stratton and trusty Chadwick and uh they had some interesting information to share about um Lumis Union School District
014as well and so I'm looking forward to building those um relationships and continuing to um Advocate across not just in our district and with our teachers but with our other elected officials in our our feeder districts um also attended PC's governance Institute and always informative um I appreciate the ongoing training doesn't matter how long you're here there's always something that you can learn and I still am going to work on that math equation I'm I'm grateful the trusty Lake committed I was like you know what I'll come back to the equation okay um but he he just they kept they kept moving and trusty Lake kept working on it and he's all got it and I was like perfect good so um also um on on uh February 4th I went to a plaster school
015for adult visit with with the principal Stephen casb and he had scheduled a meeting with assemblyman Joe Patterson and his chief of staff to discuss some ideas with uh legislation and how plaster school for adults and our how they're helping the adults in our in our community and we had a really great chat and I took them on a tour I also visited the tall program I see an amazing teacher in the crowd today I had the best time making some appetizers with those amazing students um they created some really rad dishes for the Super Bowl appetizers and and she didn't just decide what they were going to what they were going to make she told me that they had brought in some different ideas and they had a democratic process they voted and did
016the whole nine yards I met in the kitchen with these really amazing kids and staff and and made some great dishes and had a little snack with them so um thank you for inviting me I enjoyed it so much um also attended plaster learning walk and uh joined in on the plaster County presidents and delegates call who had an attorney present and discussed um some of the issues related to Title 9 right now in regards to the executive order and what our state's doing and NCAA um specifically around uh Sports and and um and it was informational um I'm sure there's going to be more information coming on that um also attended an HR meeting with trusty Duncan and staff I feel like um I just kudos to our staff for continuing to open your
017doors and being so willing to teach and get us all on the same page and um be able to have some of these conversations that are super important kfax learning walk student voice at pler Ava you do a great job facilitating I'm not sure what your goals are outside of here and I'm sure you're to do amazing things but you would be a great teacher I you know you're you're so observant you're attentive um you have a way of getting the students to speak and be involved you remember what they say and are able to reiterate that it's just really impressive to watch you're absolutely a natural leader and and I've enjoyed sitting in those meetings with you and also last week our special board meeting Workshop um governance training so there's so much going
018on um I feel like we could all agree this is feeling like a full-time gig right now as we're getting all everybody up to speed but it's such a joy and a privilege to be able to serve our community with that I'm going to have us go back to item 3.3.1 clearance of The Expelled student 119 P 2324 and would like to ask do I have a motion on item 3.1 so the motion would be to approve the admin's recommendation for the exposion yeah the clearance of our expelled student 11 uh 9p 2324 a second we have a first by trusty Jeff a second by trusty Duncan all in favor to clear our expelled student 119 p234 all in favor say I I I student board I not on this one just kidding that all
019oppose hearing none motion passes unanimously thank you does R keeping us on track all right we're going to go ahead and pop back into item 6.2 our St student board member reports take it away um good evening this last week we had our second student voice meeting of the year I was able to have 19 students in attendance and a huge personal success of mine was having a ma do student present for the first time to share their feedback so that was really exciting um at the meeting we discussed attendance and the issues that are preventing students from being able to be present at school and how we can seek to approve attendance rates we noted that some issues that prevent students from attending school include family and personal issues lack of Transportation not feeling
020supported and the general feeling of being burnt out students shared many creative ideas on how we can improve attendance one major way was making learning more Hands-On and less reliant on technology in packets many students felt less motivated to come to school and learn in the classroom knowing they could do most of the work independently at home online students also felt that small incentives such as a point system or Raffles with prizes could make coming to school more exciting I also believe that educating students on the importance of the correlation between attendance and school funding is another crucial way we can improve attendance rates many students would love to see improvements in our campuses with funds that are reliant on attendance however most students are completely unaware of this other issues that are more specific
021to plaster were how to improve the tardies and miss periods throughout the day with our passing periods being one m one minute shorter this year students felt they were having more difficulties being on time to their classes additionally students shared that they would be more inclined to be at school if they had more breaks throughout the day or a longer lunch students propose making intervention optional to students who meet certain requirements allowing them to have a longer lunch while the students who are in need of actual help would be required to attend intervention students thought this would be a great incentive for students to do well in their classes if it meant having a longer lunch other updates at Plaster include our learning walk that took place this last month thank you to all the
022trustees and Dr cametti that were able to make it out to our campus and observe all the hard work that our Administration and teachers are doing I also had the opportunity to attend the annual safety meeting today earlier with an amazing team of Staff dedicated to ensuring the safety and well-being of our campus and students during the meeting we discussed the goals for the school year and what items were taking place to meet these goals some key takeaways from the meeting were our new security cameras throughout our campus the usage of catapult in the parents square and pushing to advertise the stop it app for for students concerns plaster staff has also been working incredibly hard to prepare for our was review which is taking place next week um Mr Walters prepared a very informative
023video that was shown during advisory breaking down the process for students and making sure we are prepared for the visit and know what our roles are also taking place next week is the lcap Insight council meeting that I plan on attending and contributing to these important discussions also next week is our Powderpuff week with the big game on Friday and our stady Hawkin STS on Saturday so definitely looking forward to that in regards to the student board member application that is due tonight I've been working with all interest in students in explaining my role and answering any questions and I look forward to seeing the next representative plaster confence in Mau as I am confident that they will be in good hands thank you good evening um so for as far student voice goes uh
024students had a lot a lot of thoughts on all the topics and start with attendance students felt that people are were mainly at school um because our school is kind of our community so our friends our Sports our band rallies games these are all the things that build a feeling of community and it's that community that keeps kids coming to school and they also use it as an escape from boredom a source of routine and the road to diploma and college and for those who are not um or sorry for those who are not at school kids generally pointed for to two things um too much uh sorry my computer is really glitching I don't know what's happening okay too much busy work and uninvolved um like teachers that they felt were unengaged um so
025when the work that students are assigned they feel like they can complete at home they don't feel that they have to be in class to do that if they feel like they can just do it online um and so they're not as motivated to be in school and additionally when their teachers are are absent or unengaged they reciprocally also feel absent or unengaged so some of our solutions to these problems includ uded inclusing the number of like lowcost community building activities like one person suggested movie nights and additionally more uh Hands-On and varied work in the classroom which would encourage kids to actually show up and be like in their seat um and then daily announcements of what's going on on campus each day would help people be aware of like what activities there already
026are happening because there's a lot to do at Delo um and then attendance incentives and rewards and emphasizing the importance of having a diploma in adult life would also be important to keep kids in in school and then as far as Sports Go um our winter sports are coming to a close but our girls wrestling is going on to Masters and our girls succer won the league so that's really cool and our spring sports are just starting their um official practices our um softball girls are still doing their um science experiment with they're all doing uh flip phones to raise money for field lights but they're also going to get brain scans done at the end of the month to see the effect that having no phones has on your brain activity and we also
027are having our Valentine's Day random act of kindness week for leadership and students are writing encouraging notes and participating in various activities at lunch to support that program and we also had eight new clubs start up including the anatomy Club the youth Democratic Socialist club and the cheese club and if the last Club sounds familiar it's because our cheese Club has had a storyed history on Del campus and it ran for years but it had a lull during covid and now it's back on campus so we're all very excited about that and then as far as the cell phone policy kids are gen generally satisfied and policies very class to class but they feel like their teachers have a ton and they're doing what works best for their class so it's going well and all
028in all there's an optimistic feeling on campus as we anticipate the coming of spring thanks um hi everyone things have been going well at Forest Hill uh we also had our learning walk at the end of January so thank you to all of the board members and District staff who were able to attend that um we had a student stent voice meeting last Wednesday where we reviewed the cell phone policy and discussed student attendance in terms of the cell phone policy students mentioned that they wanted more consistency with policy enforcement since they feel as though they never know what to expect from their teachers it was brought up that one teacher on our campus always has students put their phones in the phone pockets and she takes attendance based on which phones are put away
029this way she can make sure that every student know every student places their phones in the pouches and everyone knows what to expect expect from her class this is something that the students feel works very well um we also discuss student attendance and why students do or do not attend school as you would expect students said the main reason they come to school is because they're forced to but they also said that they go to school for the social aspect in order to maintain their grades and to use school as an outlet um in terms of Why students do not attend school transportation was a major issue that was brought up especially since many students who attend FHS are not located within walking or biking distance from the school it was also expressed that we
030have had difficulties with our busing System since now that the new elementary school has opened in Forest Hill the buses have to service three schools rather than two this has caused the bus to be late on multiple occasions um students also stated that the cost of the bus could be a barrier to students who come from lower income families other issues that students felt impacted their attendance are their family situations and obligations such as if they have to care for a family member or need to to work a job in order to support their family um and chronic illnesses and illnesses in general students also said that they feel as though they are able to complete their work at home since it is posted online um in order to comat combat the issue of lower
031attendance rates we discussed ways in which the school Andor District could encourage students to come to school one of the main ideas that was brought up was increasing student engagement both in the classroom and in the general School Community Um this can be done by having more Hands-On projects and activities in the classrooms so that students are excited to participate in work other than packets and worksheets we can also improve student engagement by creating a more positive culture on our campuses and having more events and activities for students to attend um another idea that students expressed interest in is rewarding student attendance like elementary schools do this can be done in the form of an assembly where students with 90% attendance and above can be given a certificate with a gold star and a lollipop
032that was definitely highlighted by the students um many students feel that this can help create a more positive connotation around attendance and that's all for for still thank you all right um so as the fellow board our student board members said um we had our student voice meeting about attendance last week um and as Zoe was saying as well um schools mostly seen as as an obligation so that's why a lot of students come um but also students want to be there to see their friends um to be able B to connect with a lot of teachers because we have such a great community at kfax where our teachers are such instrumental into you know feeling welcome at our school and also um a lot of students at kfax play a lot of sports so
033they have to be at school all day in order to participate in their um sport if they have a game um and then also as everyone was touching on um we have access to all the resources that we need online so it makes um missing a lot easier for students and they feel like they can just check Canvas OR class if they are missing um school and they don't feel like they're that much behind um and with classes that are more Hands-On and have more class activities they feel as if they should be there so I know that I'm in AP Physics right now which is a very Hands-On class so I never want to miss that class which is my fourth block so it really you know makes me want to come to school
034every day um because I know sort of the expectation that we have in that classroom and along with this um there was some talk about scheduling and sort of Seena uneven most of the time um so lot of students were saying that the fall term is usually easier than the spring term and that sort of gets students into a poor habit um in the fall where they feel like they can miss school and then in the spring once they do have those harder classes they feel as if they're sort of behind in terms of um how they approach school um along with this we sort of talked about classroom environments a lot so um there are is a lot of different teachers at kfax all of them are incredible and you know some have a
035lot of different teaching styles and um there are some environments that are incredibly inviting they have decorations all over their classrooms and then others that sort of have blank walls so a lot of students are feeling as if having those more inviting classrooms really helps um encourage students to come to school and also sort of desk arrangements as well um being able to have table groups is more efficient because they feel like they can collaborate with other students and really get to know other people in their class as opposed to just having rows where you're sort of just facing the teacher and you don't really get to know a lot of people around you um so that was a really um strong point as well and then having more group assignments and um that more
036collaborative energy is something that students want to see as well um and some of the solutions that we were coming up with um is very similar to everyone else's as well so getting more word about Transportation um because last year I believe we did not have transportation so a lot of students don't know that this is an option for um them especially those who live farther away um and then having more awards for perfect attendance or near perfect attendance and just celebrating students coming to school more um because like Ava was saying a lot of them don't know that attendance is directly related to funding so understanding that a lot more I know that when we were talking about it during the um voice meetings so so many students were just like very shocked of
037the fact that they were correlated so um at our school we have a principal's challenge as well um that our principal hosts and that's where you get like little gift cards or anything like that for any challenges that she comes up with so um whether it's a certain number of attendant getting into a raffle um something like that where we can really promote um that offer that would be great um and then for our Sports we currently have four teams um that are in playoffs so the girls and boys basketball teams have a their first round of playoff game tonight um girls soccer also has their first or boys basketball has it tomorrow my apologies girls and girls basketball and girls soccer have their first round tonight and then boys soccer is on their second
038round tonight and they had to drive three hours away for their game so I wish luck um and then finally our school facilities So currently we do not have working school bells clocks or the intercom at our school um so this has been a really really big challenge um especially because when we get out of classes it's on odd numbers so we have like 9:51 or 11:26 a lot of students don't have that memorized because it's not very easy to remember that and with the Mondays that we've had off which have been great um it's like some students are coming back and they're like oh it's Monday I get out at this time but you know we don't so um just not being able to you know hear the morning announcements during Second block or
039hear the Bell when you're leaving class it's just really difficult especially because teachers they're not able to monitor the clock constantly and be able to release students at a certain time that sort of thing um and especially for sports when they're having to monitor time and they the clock doesn't work they don't know what time to get out um so it's it's a lot of different struggle that we're facing at kfax right now and it's been really difficult um so yeah that's the end of my report thank you so much and we are talking about that I just want you to know we have not forgotten you this is an ongoing conversation about the intercoms and and actually all the intercoms across our district so stay tuned more to come well thanks um student board
040members I know I was myself and Dr W at Forest Hill and and so we did a great job controlling um it felt like the entire School body was there um she had a great um diverse student population and they well attended and then I Claire I was thinking this is Dad joke here but I think you and Mr zerwas should be working on an announcement for the cheese club that it has aged out or something along those sorry got it perfict sorry had to had to share that on that note um Dr Ray buuk Bania and your kofax staff to um do our showcase she's um good evening my name is Dr chassid reia and I get to be the proud principal of kfax high school um so the board showcase is usually one
041of my favorite nights because it's a chance for me to brag on a public platform about mycred inedible School up in the mountains before we begin I hope that you're going to see through this presentation why I'm so proud of this school um our staff is absolutely committed and you will be able to see that I know it's taboo to say that um our workplace is our family but um 77% of our teachers do something extra outside of the workday they are our coaches our club advisors our announcers at our games our shop clock they do do everything at that school so um it's easy to see how um we become United and that really close tighten it family 37% of our teachers are kfax grads and 70% of our teachers have kids or will
042have kids that go to kfax high school and if that's not impressive enough 56% of all of our other staff classified in counselors also have children at kfax so it's easy to see why we are so committed to this school we love it we want the best for it um and as a small school you can see that we really do care about our students academically behaviorally and socially um and I hope that you get a glimpse of that tonight so um as Ruby said I have two playoff games at home tonight girls W 10 to zero so they're girls soccer is on their way to their next round and uh girls basketball is just about to start which is always amazing so my staff is limited tonight because like I said I've got staff
043announcing shot clocking coaching all the things at kfax high school tonight so um with me I have my assistant principal Shane Steinbach and one of my curriculum and instruction leaders Sarah schauffer so I'm going to turn it over and Chassy real quick I believe there's a chance that kfax girls basketball could be playing pler that is correct on a semi final that could be a lot of fun that would be on Tuesday so if kfax I mean when kfax wins the next two games and if pler gets through the next two games uh we will see you house on Tuesday so I it looks like there is a friendly principal bet beginning and um let's pack that let's pack the house I think that' be a lot just turn the nhfs network on so we
044can watch the 7 o00 games I think I think Mr zeros would say yes to that yes competition breeds Excellence As We Know right um I think we can go to the second slide here um so you know in preparing for this slide it's really tough to talk about climate and culture by just having a slide up on the board here so I'll start off by telling you what happened over the last two weeks at kfax we've had a rally we've had an entire week last week at every single lunch actually it was two weeks in a row where we were doing compet four weeks in a row where we doing competitions like Uno competition uh pingpong I was actually a big part of the uh dodgeball competition that was fantastic this last week um
045I didn't injure myself which was great um but all the climate and culture things that we do are intentional so one thing that I wanted to tell you guys uh today is that uh kfax is very deliberate and intentional about the type of climate and culture that we create for our school um one of the things that we talk about quite a lot um at uh kfax at at least as a an adult group is a kind of climate is what what you allow and culture is what you allow so I've had a couple kids that come up from e8th grade into ninth grade and um you know maybe they've made an interesting decision and then they're in my office they're like boy you guys are really strict here and I'm like well you know
046maybe that's a good thing right you know we learn like what box we can play and we're maybe not playing outside that box which made me think of that vertical articulation you were talking about um uh Madam um president about U kind of working with our middle schools and our elementaries and that type of thing um our four four pillars of celebrate uh support serve and respect couple of the highlights that I wanted to highlight here you guys was uh bear with me um with celebrating um we celebrate our academic achievements at uh at least half of our rallies not only our Sports um we have epic rallies to support our Sports naturally I I did want to put a plugin for Olympic week which is March 24th through 28th if you guys can make
047it out to that at least one of those days it's awesome kind of culminates on that Friday on the 28th so just throwing that out there um great great opportunity to come out two years ago it was snowing so who knows maybe we'll see that again apparently that was pretty epic that was before I got here um the support right this uh the support piece um I've seen a lot of uh trustees at our games and so you know that we have the nest at the football game the basketball games and like Bear River when we played Bear River last Friday night I attended that game it was just fantastic to see literally I I would say it was at least hundred students watching cheering on our teams and the referees come to me and
048say listen Steinbach make the make sure the kids are up top I'm like we don't even have to worry about it because only the two Nest leaders are going to be there and that's the way it was the whole time we had two students there and the kids are up um maybe some students that come to our school from the other teams can maybe do some questionable things but our kids are well behaved and they're just cheing on the team and which let leads me to sportsmanship um it's one of our pieces or our our um Hallmarks of respect for our school as well we've been focused um in our student voice meetings uh Ruby I I remember you coming to M rbec Mania and myself and talking about you know some of your uh
049LED student uh level discussions and met about respect you know what that means and how we can achieve that but basically from the educational level on our side as adults and you um on the other side as well as students um and you know um I'm I'm out there a lot with the kids uh during passing nutrition and lunch and a lot of the time you know it's as simple as be nice dude like let's be nice to each other let's be kind to each other um so um again it's hard to encapsulate like climate and culture in one slide and one guy talking to you about it but I can tell you that I've worked at several schools and cax high school um has the most fantastic culture and climate that I've ever worked
050for it's awesome um slide two um this is just kind of pointing out some data uh our current enrollment is 628 U we're kind of kfax is right in the middle the comprehensive comprehensive schools of socioeconomic disadvantage or S uh uh populations um we're currently at 25% um there's some data to support potentially that could be higher like these days um there there is incentive for parents and Guardians to fill out the S uh portion of enrolling into a school however since you know lunch is provided for free these days we we anticipate that would probably be a little bit higher but right now we're right in the middle on that we've actually doubled our El um our English Learners since last year so I know it's 0 6 but we doubled that since last
051year so we are fairly fairly diverse and I will say this that as far as academically goes kfax is is very much diverse we have our um IB track uh students International baloria students we have students taking AP okay the higher end students on one side we have a large uh portion of our uh student body that's kind of in the middle um and then we have a a group of students that really do struggle academically at kfax High and um uh and I just wanted to say that aloud because um we we are a very diverse group um social economically and academically um as well okay that is it for me for now all right um one thing I did want to add if you could go back to um the culture side real
052quick backwards um it it really warms my heart that someone brought up the principal's challenges in uh r 's report because that's how we started integrating some of those character education lessons is I was we put out a principal's challenge in The Advisory um during the advisory time so basically I have like the power of gratitude up here they watch a video they have to write a letter of gratitude they share it with me and then I take from the ones that share it with me and that's who gets like a drink of their choice I will deliver it to them in their classroom so I'm really glad someone brought it up and someone noticed um but that's how we're trying to get some of those uh character education lessons in into our advisory classes
053is through those principal challenges um so I'll go back to the data slide um so I'm probably actually Shane I don't know if he says it because he's trying to get on my good side or because if he TR uh believes it true but I love looking at data um so this is our current data right now which I'm really proud of this school for so for the first time this year's seniors are at 83% and 81% um ad G andcc I we've never been at 80% before so and that's a huge jump from 2024 I will say our senior class is exceptional but I will also say that our teachers have been working really really hard as well as our counselors making sure that those students get that third-year level of math really counseling
054them into those higher level courses and challenging our students to take those higher level classes um so I'm really proud of that if you can see there we've had an up uh upwards growth in the last three years um of our class of 2025 our ad students 57% of them have 504s and 14% have IEPs and 57% are socioeconomically disadvantaged so we are starting to see a decrease in those gaps that we've traditionally seen before we're really proud of our seal of biliteracy numbers right now currently we have 48 students pending seal of biliteracy which means if they pass their esack tests um they will be able to and get good grades in English and um Spanish they will get their seal of by literacy on their diploma so we're really proud of that data
055we're really proud of the hard work we've put in to make sure that we're closing those achievement gaps and getting in a trajectory of upward Trends Bear River is the closest like school to kfax in size demographics and they're just 30 minutes down the street from us so I compared ourselves to Bear River um as you can see we're neck and neck with be River and English language um arts for the esack or and then in math we blew them out of the water uh so they are sitting at 36% we're at 50% and then um our cast scores we are more than or we are just under doubled them um they're at 33 and we're at 61% so as you can see on the bottom there's some coolax Trends um we did have huge
056gains in our esack last year we're hoping to see some equal gains this year I'm going to knock on wood there um because obviously we defin want to see that upward Trend there and we've got a lot of things that we're we're doing we got a lot of things we're trying out this year um Terry O'Keefe has put together an esack um practice module an esack course within um Alex and we're going to be pushing that out to all Juniors and we'll probably do some sort of challenge with them as well to get them to finish that ASC module um if you want to go to the next slide um look looking at comparative data so we did compare eighth grade scores to the 11th grade scores these are our current seniors um unfortunately I
057only had eighth grade scores for 46 of our students so that's just a little of a third of the class so I would have liked to see a little bit more of a percentage but I I'll work with what I have right so 54% of the students from 8th grade to junior year stayed exactly the same they were three a three um 21% improved in English and 23% decrease you know High School it gets real tough um math 47% stayed at the exact same 17% decreased in or increased and 34 decreased um you can see our incomplete data for the last three years I only have up to the fall obviously of this year so it'll be interesting to see what this looks like at the end of the year but we have had a
058um you know just kind of like a wave there if you will of incompletes although we only had 69 in completes when I had to turn this presentation in we had 21 outstanding still but only three of those incompletes were given non-credit so the rest of the students had um were able to pass their courses as you can see that is definitely on the downward trend from the last three years 40 um actually from last year sorry we're also in a wave there too I'm really proud of that last year we ended with 13.5% last year we had FS this year it turned to NC so 13.5 um percent NC's and right now we're only sitting at just under 5% so we're hoping that we keep that Trend as well into this spring semester chass
059gave me the slide with words on it because all those numbers make me nauseous I'm like really good at reading no um so the the ways that we're doing this are um I was talking to those of you that attended our learning walk about uh approaches to teaching and learning it's called ATL if you want another acronym um and that is an IB um teaching philosophy that's really just essentially good teaching strategies so um Cara dier who is our IB um coordinator helps run professional development for us and Amanda Bratton and I help try to support her with what our good teaching practices um to constantly remind her um being very clear on what we want students to know facilitated and supported by proficiency scales rubrics and all that kind of stuff I think has
060only gotten better and the data um indicates that as well um on-site Credit Recovery is um super helpful for students especially we were just discussing Transportation issues and things like that it's nice to have someone on campus I think that's um I'm not sure uh if it's happening again this year but um yeah uh it's great to have that teacher that covers that for us part of our communication it's easy to um communicate with that teacher about what each student needs to know based on the scales and scores it's it's great um and then the math Readiness programs Alex um are things that our math department has been working really hard on we um have had retake policies for a long time and actually have just recently um Revisited that at the request of our
061lead team and then we all posted our retake policies so all stakeholders have access to those um and the goal is to move forward to have department-wide retake policies um which is something we were discussing uh today at our lead team meeting um we have been spending a lot of time led by um Shane on developing ways to help our disengage students and be more targeted about it instead of just letting them sit there and do nothing um but how can we help them and where are their needs not being met um and first and for more building relationship with students so they feel like loved up when they get to school every day um and then one of the things that we focused on um in the fall that we will circle around back
062again with is focusing on student self assessment so giving students opportunities to assess their learning um based on the proficiency skills and learning targets and things like that um and that's a pretty powerful tool to have students communicate and advocate for themselves um and then we always always always do our department goals and check-ins with plc's she always reminds us we have goals she always asks us about our goals how we doing on our goals so it's nice to keep goals in the Forefront because sometimes you know you set them and you never revisit them again but that's not true at cax numbers no these these ones are cool so this is our IB program and what you're looking at is the diploma candidates that um top box on the left is and these are
063the students who are doing all the IB requirements in order to be able to graduate with an IB diploma it's so much work it's an incredibly um rigorous program they have to do um a community service project they have to do an extended essay they have to have an essay adviser it's so much work and it's so impressive so you can kind of see since our program started Ed um that it has been growing almost every single year this year is massive and we keep uh we keep I think next year is even bigger by a lot um which is pretty cool to be able to support all these students and then the the line on the bottom is how many students earn their diplomas so not every single student gets to pass every test
064and makes everything happen but what I think is really cool is that students feel empowered to attempt for it um and even if they fall short often pass some course level assessments that still can earn them some college credits um so obviously this year we'll see what our scores are they take their um right now they're all scrambling to get their internal assessments done um and then those are the tests that they do in class that we submit to IB um and then we um will do their external Assessments in May during testing season um and so if you look at those fun facts super fun um we have 31 students that come to our school for our I program which is pretty cool um and then just as a comparative number uh we we
065do work with granite Bas sometimes um and talk to them about their IB program but their class this year class of 2025 has five diploma candidates and I just want to bring your attention up there that we have 21 so um I don't know what's I don't know why the difference but I feel like our students are feeling really empowered to take risks and um have depend on their teachers to get them through when they need support um so that that table down on the bottom right then shows the amount of testers that uh signed up for tests and then the amount of tests that were taken so you can see each year the amount of testers grows and the amount of tests taken grows for the most part every single year and um you
066know those Test passing scores um they you know they go up and down and right now it's um I think as we continue to get more data really interesting but what I see is students who feel safe and empowered to to take tests and attempt things um that may be outside their comfort zones which is always what we want to encourage everyone has access to the IB curriculum which is very rigorous so more data um so this is just a little bit about our CTE pathway completers so we went from 34% to 50% of our graduating class being a pathway completer and then we doubled in our graduating class taking two our mle enrollment classes where do our kids go after college well in the class of 23 85% went to college or trade school
067in the class of 24 80% also went to college or trade school and 3% joined the military so they're doing great things they have a lot of doors open a lot of options for them for when they leave kfax words uh so just to summarize all the data that you guys have seen on the last uh group of slides is um we just want to reiterate again the highest number of a3g completers in cax history that's really really worth celebrating and I know a lot of people have been working really hard to make that happen um and that's a growth of 23.8% in the last three years so pretty incredible um highest number of CCI completers in kfax history as well a growth of 12.5% in the last four years we are doubled in the
068percentage of met and exceeded standards in math and science compared to the like schools um I when CH you shared the be River example um our students are able to remediate their grades to earn passing grades um through our we're getting better at working on Remediation in the classroom but also um through our incomplete policies and making sure our retake policies are nice and tight and clear um and we're on track to decrease our number of NC's um formly known as FS right by almost half which is very very uh exciting I myself had um many less I don't ever have that many but I'm seeing the numbers myself that mirror what we're seeing as a campus and it was really exciting I was excited to run over to the counselors and tell them um
069and more students are challenging themselves with IB classes every year that program grows um I'm really proud of that and we've doubled the percentage of students taking our dual enrollment offerings as well so lots of amazing things happen because of our teachers because of our counselors because of our department chairs and all the other staff that works together to make that happen so it's pretty cool okay what is our environment like um I'll start with the suspension rate so if you look back to 22 to 23 um percentage of students that were uh suspended was 7.1% last year in 2324 that decreased to 5.23% currently currently right now I think this was run about a week ago we're at 2.3% for 2425 um that doesn't mean that we're not suspending students that break Ed code
070right because when that happens that's what happens right however we do use Progressive discipline right so we have leeway as administrators to kind of work that at least to a certain degree one of the ways that we can do that is potentially in lie of a maybe one day of suspension or potentially maybe a two-day suspension we can use the restore program which is at um pastor School uh for adults and um I've heard fantastic things when I meet with the student and meet with the family and parent when they re-enter from a suspension is that Hey listen Mr Steinbach I know that I I was moaning about having to go to this restore program but I did get something out of it or the decision making one in particular is is quite good um
071so our our suspension rates are down as a whole um our attendance rates however are going up which is fantastic 22 23 we're at 90 3.6 23 24 we're 94.3 and then currently right now we're at 95.1 3 um I think that we are currently beating deloro by a 0.13% thank you very much I doubt it too anyways um our attendance rate is quite good right now um just a couple things that like it we are doing um on the attendent side is um just today alone I call cold called I think at least a dozen parents that we have an opportunity for Saturday school at uh at kfax at the learning Commons which um that's a day where students can come and recoup an entire day of school um and actually my I'm trying
072to do one a month and last month we had um I believe it was 16 students that showed up um some earned being there from going off campus and things like that but I would say about half of them were there the parent was like you know I got you Shane I'll send my kid there and make up a day um I feel like we're really good at bringing students in when they receive their 10day letter 15-day letter as well and communicating with parents so we're certainly um you know driven to to help attendance um on our end there um creating our school culture and educational environment um cell phone policy has been a big thing at kfax this year just the history of that um it was a Grassroots effort um when we did
073our our cax Retreat over the summer the idea was to create a um game plan for um a system for disengaged students so that's kind of where the discussion started and um it grew actually from from that so what's an actionable plan to get students to pay attention more in class and um the cell phone policy grew out of that um we're we're very consistent from teacher to teacher from class to classroom to classroom we've probably heard that from Ruby U this this year a little bit and I know that some of the students think that well you know maybe we should augment that a little bit and we are certainly listening but um I've heard from um actually some of the students themselves that um they've been able to concentrate in class and that
074type of thing and actually one of the big things I heard from a handful of students that go are in my office from time to time actually too is they were telling me that I'm actually communicating more with um not only my friends but people that you know I haven't even spoken with at coox and they're they're making they're making new friends and that type of thing which which I think is awesome um and finally um up there on the right hand side we had last year 592 student athletes um which is just absolutely insane we have so many students that are um that are participating in sports currently right now we have 433 and that doesn't even count the spring Sports um the number of scholar athletes 185 or 36% doeses not include the
07588 athletes on snow Sports as they do not comp uh compete in pbll and 101 or 31% 77 athletes are not counted because they do not compete in pbl again so that's the number of scholar athletes that are currently connected to the school be uh uh playing a sport at kfax high school we're super proud of them and the number of clubs have increased from 27 to 31 this year right one more I was joking comment first of all I want to commend you guys all your hard work that you're doing your G is phenomenal and your work on culture it's really exciting what you're doing um and uh in terms of Competency Based education you're really the flagship of the district I think in terms of your successes but the one thing that I
076saw tonight that kind of concerns me a little bit on the data that you presented was 37% decline in mathematics it says if you go back and that decline line and that seems quite High because the year before if I remember it was 177% so could you give me some input on that or expl yeah um I believe that was the uh when we were comparing the eighth grade cohort yeah exactly the current eighth grade uh 11th grade from last year um yes they did sus out that way um that's an interesting data point I want to say there were 70 students that we got roughly on that data for for that cohort which I think the whole quarter s around 155 right in there so it's not the complete data point um one positive
077that we saw is from I know it's different corts for 23 to 24 as compared with from 22 to 23 we did increas as a school you know in in in esack data on the math then which was which we saw as a positive to be sure but that cohort data did stick out to us as well yeah absolutely um really quick on our facilities um if you look up at these pictures here just kind of highlight some of the things that you know we are dealing with on the facility end at kfax high obviously our bond didn't pass that type of thing so we just wanted to bring it to light to the board and the community members who are out here today with us and thank you for being here and anybody watching
078out there on the YouTubes is that we um our facilities really do need some upgrades you can see right there we have water damage in several buildings the water damage that you see on the center one below there on the top of our buildings here um I think that kind of leads to kind of Ruby's Point here too is like the beautification of our classrooms if you to compare some of the newer parts of our school I.E the Jim a forer area you know Mr Wilkinson's room Mr O'Keefe's room and then you were to go to the older Parts the certainly the Portables um it's just a different feel you know over there and I think that that does make it so that students maybe I don't know are affected by that the aesthetic of
079the area you know they may not be engaged as much as well so so we just want to point that out of course you know the PA issue so I won't talk about that but my lungs are doing okay get the class let's go so thank you well you know um those some of those kids right are playing multiple sports right so even though we have 630 kids roughly even though we're in the 400 range right I I don't know off the top of my head but you know it's not like for example the the finished data from last year had about 620 kids roughly last year I want to say and there was 534 I want to say that's kids that are playing multiple Sports so if I if I had a a football
080player a basketball player and a baseball player that would be three that would count as three yeah yeah than I wanted to um just comment you know congratulations and I see two of your counselors back there that would be remiss without mentioning them I mean your your a to d a tog data is not a um something that you can accomplish in one year it takes four years of how many collisions between um meetings with students and it plays into your incompletes because when kids are able to get those incompletes done they have access to classes that opens up their schedule for electives it opens up their schedule to access to higher levels of math to meet those ad but it it is not a it's not a coincidence um this is a strategic um
081move at kfax and and all of our schools that we're seeing kind of the decisions that have been made over the last you know couple years with those outcomes and we should be seeing this across the board especially with CCI as we're seeing it on on all of our schools because the systems that have been designed and and a lot of that work especially with adg falls on the shoulders of our staff and our and our counselor so um even though we have some data tools that they're not perfect right Miss money Penney they're they're far from that and part of the problem is is there's just not a lot of other um schools and districts that are looking at the data that way and everybody goes well we don't have a system to well
082can you do this and they say no um and so we're we're peac mealing some of our data to to get that to support our staff but you guys have done a tremendous job and um your your data shows it but it's not just our our student outcomes it's your Athletics and your clubs and that's the whole well-rounded student that comes into play so great job and thank you for sharing thank you so much I'm still on okay um so um learning walks we have one remaining and that is with Mau on February 28th that will look a whole lot different than than how um we've been participating with principal Davenport it's it's eye openening and you'll get a chance to kind of see what it looks like to be a murder um myu virtual
083Charter student um we celebrated our AXA administrators of the Year celebration a couple weeks ago it was the same night as a cfax back to school night so our lead team split up um so we could attend that and we recogniz were able to recognize our very own Sarah wrath for um our um um classified employee of the year congratulations and um Kristen Miller at my for CTE administrator of the year so we get to celebrate them and it's always fun to to be able to recognize our our staff um I wanted to give a quick update on student board member applications uh at this point uh we have three from deloro uh one from forestel and one from pler at this point we're still waiting to hear from KX um and it closes tonight
084right is that that correct so we'll see how that goes um uh just a you know public thank you to to PE constant for our training that we participated in last week it was very informative um I learned a lot um and I feel like that that conversations that were started by him were were so helpful um for all of us that we be able to make it um coming in March is our quality Schools in service on March 14th and that is just a great day to um participate and see some of the professional development that our teachers will receive all day long um coming out to you as well will be uh graduation signups um so that is something that you know the board we kind of all um divide and conquer so
085all of our schools have a representative at all the um graduation celebrations and those are just a just get get ready new board members um starting March through May you pretty much could be attending a school event every single night it feels like um and they're always the best events of the year it it really is just a celebration um we'll we'll be talking more about the grading committee but I did have some data I wanted to share with you we had we had about 101 participants sign up we had uh seven parents and two staff members from kfax 44 parents 11 staff and seven students from deloro um three from our district campus three staff members um pler had 12 parents eight staff and three students and forestel had four parents and we had
086a couple Confluence and might do sign up as well so those are the raw numbers I know we're going to talk about that later um also shout out to our um our Mike Sabin and I know our wrestling program at pler high school hosted a gigantic meet on Saturday that I popped my head into and there was just a lot going on it was very well attended it was very exciting and fun to watch um and I don't know all the results I'm sure you'll be able to share um trusty Spade but um Lots going on and um that I think that concludes my report tonight thank you so much we're going to do something a little bit different um we have a new item um added to our agenda that hasn't been there and
087just to give you a little bit of background this was something that I had actually approached our old board about um shortly after joining the board because I saw that it was a tradition in some of the other districts um to have our education Partners have an item to be able to update us on things happening in the classroom so with that item 6.5 Associated teachers of plaster CTA Nea ATP president report thank you oh please great than sure we up this way yeah just stud just want to make sure everybody I have it okay everyone's got take it away perfect so I I really don't want to take that much time uh to go through all the ne details so I just kind of want to take a kind of top view down and
088um so we were we saw a need for some fairly immediate feedback just because we saw that the grading po or the grading committee was going to be on tonight's uh board agenda so we just kind of wanted to get some feedback from our members as far as kind of how the grading policy is going so far with the changes that were implemented in January and kind of just moving forward what are maybe some hopes and some expectations for the future um overall uh people are okay it's mostly neutral um if you look at that first question you know lots of Threes lots of fours um huge standard deviation though so it's like most people are okay but there's a wide range of kind of what the okay is um as you flip through the
089next kind of few questions the biggest takeaway I kind of I want to highlight is the fact that um the really needs to be some time for staff um to get together and kind of talk about what what needs to be kind of the expectations for the grading policy and kind of what do we want in terms of the grading policy because at the end of the day the teachers are going to be the ones that will need to enact it um and so and there's some conflicts of kind of what exactly people want there's some negatives there's some positives there's some you know neutrals um and so it'd be great if we could have some time especially with the the inservice coming up in a few weeks for members from all sides to be
090able to kind of get together and be like okay if we want a un for grad policy at the district level what are what are our needs um to make sure that we're you know grading students effectively clearly and that everyone involved from staff to parents to counselors to principes to whoever can look at a grade and understand exactly what it means so so we talked about this for a while this morning we were going back through the data and looking at well what what could we share what would be the meaning behind what we have here and there there are some pieces here and I think Jacob touched on the main one which is that that we have we have some splits and so how do we do this in a way that involves
091everyone um and not go back to where we were before where one party is getting exactly what they want and how big that party is is kind of interesting to look at in terms of when you look at the at the wheel right and again you look back at what neutral is what does neutral mean and so we're going to bring this back to rep Council on Monday um because one of the requests was well what about by Department um and we feel like we could possibly gather some more information there we would like for things to be as straightforward as possible before we say this is what we want this is what we would like how does this fit in with the other pieces of the puzzle with the other people that are involved
092in this so yeah thank you and thank you so much for having us thank you thank you appreciate it all right we're going to go ahead and move to item seven consent agenda items I know we have a couple changes or a few changes to uh our consent agenda I'd like to move out 7.2 and trusty Jeff you had some questions on 7.3 is that correct um I will hold off actually okay so we're going to keep 7.3 inside of the consent and I'd also like to remove 711 out of the consent do we have any other changes to our consent agenda hearing none um do I have a motion for the consent agenda minus those two items yeah motion to approve consent agenda uh minus 7.2 and 7.11 do I have a second we
093have a first by trusty Duncan and a second by trusty jeffes to approve the consent agenda item um consent agenda items minus 7.2 and 711 all in favor starting with the student board I I board I I all oppose hearing n motion passes unanimously okay we're going to go ahead and open up uh we'll start with item 7.2 and I had just a little bit of feedback on 7.2 7.2 specifically our special board meeting on 7 or excuse me on January 16th 2025 on our final page and just very minor so after we swore in on item three so this would be top of page four we swore in trusty Lake he actually joined us at the dis I'm not sure that that's totally necessary but he did make um a short a brief comment
094at that time so I don't know if that needs to be um or how you guys feel about adding that but also he participated in the final vote which is not listed any thoughts or feedback on that so the Amendments would be two parts one for sure which is 4.1 would now include uh trusty lakes's vote on the final meeting adjournment and the other would be just to acknowledge that he joined us at the dis following him swearing in yeah um I think those should be should be put in okay second okay so we'll go ahead and um sounds like we have approval there do would you like to make that a motion yeah a motion to um to add trusty Lake to uh the voting role and uh sorry last week was his comment
095yeah just that he joined us at the D yeah comment that he just joined us at the Das yes okay we have a first second and a second um to approve item 7.2 with the amendments to the agenda on 116 2025 starting with the St student board all in favor say I I I board I I all oppose hearing none motion passes unanimously going to go ahead and jump to um item 71 I got to pull up my notes as well oops okay all righty okay there were um a couple of um errors um so this is on page two if you would move it to page two um it discusses the the district English learner it says learner instead of Learners excuse me leaner thank you and then um so we go ahead and
096change that and then um and then also on just very minor but on page three there was a second parentheses so we'd scratch that remove the second yep at the end see the in the Bold after the Education Code okay all righty and um Mr Wilson this was your item right so um I just wanted if you could share just a little bit about our district English learner um parent advisory committee our DC committee any specific things you want to know just in regards to the changes obviously there was some um legislation and obviously we needed to make several changes to our policy if you just wanted to share a little bit yes so I think uh we the last couple years uh last two years um and we've had a really great um daac
097meeting where we've gotten a lot of people involved um I I'm think I lost her name polar thank you uh Po and and um Alex have done a great job of reaching out to the community um and getting people involved uh and so uh at this meeting uh we uh it's it's required for us to have this meeting prior to our uh District advisory committee um for parent committee that we uh hold every year annually uh they have uh officers and um I forgot the lady's name this year Marie yeah and um and so it's really important we get feedback from the the parents and also from the kids about uh the program the English learner program needs that they feel that we could uh get involved in and better address what they have I
098think it was really cool I think last year um when we were doing it Steve C Steph casite was there and he took the opportunity to come with an idea to help the English learner parents access Aries and have better understanding about how to use that because that's one of the big discrepancies of uh for our English Learners is really connecting to the school and being able to talk uh with people and understand what's happening in their classes and so uh we offered that and uh they've been doing a great job of just kind of providing this feedback about how better to communicate uh what we can do to help them support their students yeah awesome and I don't know if if uh Mr Lemon Robert lemon who who coordinates our um deac meeting and
099our EO if he wants to add anything to that or not sure please so the the legislation goes back to the update on the English Learners and it does specifically say that we're required to have an lcap English learner parent advisory committee and really what it's saying in there is that the DC can serve as that purpose and we have a um a growing and a pretty pretty good participation in that daac so it's positive and I feel that we are getting our parent engagement through that committee perect thank you both so much all right with those um grammatical changes do I have a motion for 7-Eleven yeah a motion to uh approve 7-Eleven and uh make the grammatical changes we have a second we have a first by trusty Duncan second by trusty Jeff
100for item 711 BP 0460 local control and accountability plan update all in favor starting with the board say I I I board I all oppose hearing none motion passes unanimously all right now we're going to go ahead and jump to action items eight starting with item 8.1 certificated Personnel report number 72425 thank you madam president um this is our certificated Personnel report and as you can see there's a lot of additional duties we also have continued to onboard our substitute teachers and curriculum development so all of those activities are happening um so on the behalf of the Acting Superintendent I would approve the I would recommend the approval of the certificated Personnel order do I have a motion second we have a first in a second do we have any further discussion on item 8.1
101hearing none the motion is to approve the certificated Personnel report number 72425 starting with our student board all in favor I I board I I motion carries unanimous item 8.2 classified Personnel report number 72425 yes Madam president as you know we keep um having now the spring sports are coming up and we also have been onboarding our um plaster school for adult teachers um we have numerous volunteers that are constantly supporting our students in our um activities and um out there in the commun in our school communities we do um always want to acknowledge some long-term individuals that have put in their retirement um Tina base who has been a long-term um accounting Tech here and Lisa Smith who has worked both at Plaster high school and here um at the maintenance and operations are
102will be retiring at the end of June we do appreciate their service to our district and as well as Connor for his time with us as well so on the behalf of the um Acting Superintendent I would recommend the approval of the classified Personnel report move to approve we have a first by trustee Duncan and a second by trusty Lake to approve the classified Personnel report number 72425 any further discussion or comments just another kudos to Tina base she's just lovely I don't know the other two as well but um she will be certainly missed so thank you Tina for your service to our district starting with the student board all in favor say I I hi board I I all oppose hearing none motion passes unanimously item 8.3 consider completion of temporary certificated contract
103as required by Education Code selection 44954 B and 4492 n21 B so this is um an annual event that occurs for any individual that is hired under a temporary contract and this is the release of them they have been re they've already received their letter W um you know when they sign they sign as a temporary employee um they've received their notices that this will be going before the board and upon approval they'll be notified that it was approved as well so on behalf of the Acting Superintendent I would recommend approval of the temporary release list do I have a motion have a first and I will second that we have a first by trusty Underwood second by trusty spade for item 8.3 consider completion of temporary cert uh certificated contract as required by Education
104Code section 44954 B and 449 29. 21b any comments questions discussion I just want to acknowledge the people on that list um there are some really great teachers and staff members on that list I just you know I just want you guys to know that we care I know sometimes it's not always it's a rough gig sometimes you just come here on a short-term basis but um I am aware specifically with some that you've just done a phenomenal job in our district and I just wanted to thank them and hope that you know there's a way that you get to find your way back to us in the near future so with that starting with the student board all in favor say I I hi and um Bard hi hi I'll oppose motion passes unanimously
105item 8.4 memorandum of understanding mou between the phsd and the California School Employees Association CA addressing job descriptions and reclassifications 2024 20 through 2025 M yep go ahead okay thank you yes Madam president this has been a uh a an mou that's been in progress for quite a few months and so I'm bringing it back before the board um it has been fully um uh 610 approved which is through the main office of the um CSEA employee group and then approved and ratified by our membership um so um this is where we um had updated some job descriptions um especially for our plaster school for adults their jobs are different they run a different type of um school with different hours and those things and so we wanted to look at those job descriptions the
106individuals that were sitting in those jobs helped to address and look at the duties that were more specific to PSA so we did that as well as we updated our skilled maintenance technician position because of ongoing changes we had to add some low voltage language into that position and so um on the behalf of the Acting Superintendent I would recommend the approval of theou between CA and US regarding these job descriptions all righty do we have a motion for item 8.4 all right we have a first by trust andwood and a second by trusty Jeff to approve the item 8.4 memorandum of understanding mou between the phsd and the California School Employees Association addressing job descriptions and reclassifications for 2024 through 2025 any questions discussion hearing none starting with the student board all all in
107favor say I I Bo I I I'll oppose motion passes unanimously item 8.5 resolution number 1424 through2 authorizing layoff notices due to lack of work and or funds implementing Education Code sections five uh excuse me 45298 and 45308 reduction of one Li vocational nurse 875 FTE yes Madam president this is always a difficult decision to make um but when you look at is there work that is needed um with in this particular case um with the situation of a student aging out that position is no longer required and um appropriate notices have already been sent and received by that individual so on the behalf of the Acting Superintendent I would recommend the approval of the resolution do I have a motion I have a question how many licensed vocational nurses do we have one just
108one so we would have nothing well we have registered nurses right a licensed vocational nurse is really typically for our district specifically hired for based on an IEP an individual education plan that requires a student to have a certain level of um nursing support so really what you're you're saying it's no longer needed right exactly got you all right do I have a motion I move second we have a first by trusty Underwood and a second by trusty Duncan uh to approve the resolution number 14 2425 authorizing layoff notices due to lack of work and or funds implementing education codes which I previously mentioned and we have a resolution so this will be a roll call vote for 8.5 starting with the student board I I board i i i and just as a point
109of clarification um moving forward um and I'm not sure I've seen it done different ways in other districts as far as a clerk calling out names or um our Superintendent at times sometimes um other members of our cabinet are support just for um the impaired if we could when we were calling out resolutions if could we call each member by name how do you guys feel about that sure on resolutions on resolutions on roll call votes okay all right but with that all oppose I didn't hear it because it was roller call motion passes unanimously but let's go ahead and Implement that okay moving forward to item 8.6 pler High School welding shop purchase yes Madam president this is has been in the works for several months uh board approved uh allocating some funds to
110the building 200 at pler High School in in the measure G Bond several months ago um this is a result of some of those funds to be utilized to purchase as you see the attachment some Mills and grinders and band saws along with a plasma system uh we did the walk several times at the high school site along with the teacher and maintenance operations to make sure we have electrical to handle everything and this is us seeking um or requesting approval from the board to go forward with this purchase so on behalf of the superintendent we Rec approval Peter I just had a question number one this is this is great I love to see um these types of purchases made to to help with uh these types of vocational um uh classes but uh
111how did we I see one of the companies was from ban the other one was local in Woodland um is it based on price only on the final bids or is there quality of workmanship I don't know much about welding so I think it's the opportunity of of what they have and what's needed and then also um the quickness of when things can be delivered this is still a couple months out even after approval the the procurement is going to take several months sure one place was longer um I'm actually to be honest with you relying on the expertise of the teacher and then um Jack chelin who's a retired weling teacher in the district and also was on the FFA Advisory board for plaster high school and looking into this and looking at different
112quotes and coming up with this one cool thank you awesome do we have a motion uh I move to to approve a first by trusty Duncan and a second by trusty Lake to approve item 8.6 pler High School welding shop purchase any further comments or questions I'm so excited just as a side note I just think that this is so great and I I appreciate all the hands involved um that have put this together to support our welding shop I think it's just great so there's nothing further we'll go ahead and move to our votes starting with the student board all in favor say I I board I all oppose nay hearing none motion passes unanimously item EV um 8.7 uh plaster High School 600 building HVAC controls upgrade so going along with the previous
113item just spending down that Bond money has been approved by the board uh this is again several months in in the making and then finally getting down to um the actual uh bill that would be charged for the implementation of some new equipment um and controls in the 600 Wing they were not addressed fully and the original um expenditure back when we remodern the 600 and so that's just to finish this off it only includes if you know the 600 there's three buildings to it we call JK and L this is j& L which is basically the Social Studies English wing and then the other part of it if you're familiar with the campus the middle building was renovated completely in terms of the ASB room we put new age back in there these two
114buildings do not have that and so on behalf of the superintendent we recommend appr approval all right do we have a motion to approve second we have a first by trusty Jeff and a second by trusty Duncan to approve item 8.7 pler High School 600 building HVAC controls upgrade any other questions or discussion Peter do we know when uh is there is there a projected timeline I'm glad you asked that question yes it is this summer okay um we just had a conference call with with him today okay um and and looking at that please note that anything even though it's written down is never written in stone um one of the issues they know that come up is once they do some demo depending on what they find um I'm making the professional assumption
115they won't find much because we kind of demo those walls before we rid those rooms right so I would be shocked if they found anything out of the ordinary because a lot of it was ad that we did before in those buildings um they're using the existing um uh where's H ducting thank you Don thank you operations director the existing ducting cleaning it out but then it's like new handlers and things like that and new units to handle all that and so should move a lot smoother than previously other stuff we've been done on the campus because it does not require DSA approval because we're just replacing in kind yeah perfect and so they are looking for summer August 5th being completed perfect that's what that was my next question that was a big topic
116with him today and so when more comes up if they find it with procurement something comes up I I'll let staff know that you know but as of right now we are looking at they they want to start the day after school gets out beautiful and um would the classrooms it's construction we own a construction company we know how it works sometimes if things get pushed back or delayed in any way is there a contingency plan for the classrooms that would be impacted you know in terms of air conditioning um the last time we ran something like this they bring in portable air conditioners okay um what would happen in extreme case if you want extreme is is doing one building at a time you're looking at five teachers being misplaced for a while and
117then Jamie having heartache to figure out how people are doubling up in Sharing rooms which has happened before in the past well let's cross our fingers shall we okay it's good news but yes there could me mean never I I never guarantee your promise anymore okay fair I'm just spending the money or asking you spending money fair enough fair enough all right we um like I said we've got a first and a second on this item starting with the student board all in favor say I hi I board I all oppose hearing none motion passes unanimously yet again all right item 8.8 BP 6158 independent study update yes president Spade I'm going to have Miss Barry our director of child welfare and attendance answer any questions that you have on this I think that's why
118you pulled it you had a few questions regarding this so Center Stage C stage place to be yes so um I did see your notes and so um I concur we could definitely make those adjustments um the reason I did not put them out prior was because they were in the previous one but being that we are a 9 through 12 District we don't have need for TK through three or four through eight so we could definitely pull those okay great yep so we could pull those up we'll just kind of kind of show where we've got some information in there that's not relevant to our school district so um items one and two underneath and right just right there yep they're they're in regards to students that are not our student population so my
119recommendation would be to remove one and two and number three would become number one there and I believe there was one other section yeah they had it in a couple places in there so we can definitely go back through adjust as um yeah so that's not a problem um I do want to also just in going through it after you um did that um I want to make sure in there as we go through that it also says that we're kind of one through 15 16 and Beyond would be a different independent study program 1 through 15 is our shortterm and I think there might be a place or two in there where those numbers are mixed so if it's okay with you I'll correct that as well and then we can resubmit okay great
120yep do or do we need to resubmit or can I just make the adjustments how do you want to proceed I if we agree to make the necessary adjustments and then we could just move forward and it doesn't need to come back if that's yeah and I'm happy to go back and do that feel comfortable with that okay all right with that do we have a motion motion to approve we have a first by trusty Duncan and a second by trusty Jeff for item 8.8 BP 6158 independent study update there are several updates that uh staff will be completing regarding applicability to our our district and with that do we have any further questions or comments all right starting with the student board all in favor say I I board I I I'll oppose motion
121passes unanimously item 8.9 BP 6177 summer learning programs update I didn't get what you wanted from this or why it was pulled so um I'll take notes and try to answer any questions that you you have in particular so if you could just let me pull this back up real fast here is it already up see this is the trouble when I have my own because I want to zoom in yeah now I've got to pull mine up too so just regarding um the summer learning programs obviously the rationale there's some updates to new law but um if you could just explain a little bit about obviously in the kfax report um they talked about some extended Saturdays making up Ada but this obviously doesn't apply to that um what can you just explain just
122kind of on a high level there is a lot of changes to this um policy so uh our summer school program we've uh you know what we're doing the last couple years well since Co has has changed quite a bit and uh due to Financial constraints we've readjusted it again uh basically um you know each site is managing individually sort of how they're rolling out and dealing with a lot of the incompletes that they're having and then um creating a system with the teachers that they hire for this position to get them uh completed and through uh last couple years have been pretty successful and so we're working on that uh to to continue uh we've had some kids come in um and you know they need to to redo one assessment or something and
123we're able to do it on a pretty quick basis so that's been been uh pretty effective um so that's how we have been doing it's been really open to the students who need uh remediation or to complete uh the incompletes that they're getting that's what we've focused on and will continue to focus on this year uh we still uh We've in the past contracted with PSA to do some uh non a tog credit recovery uh we're going to try to do that inhouse as well because we have to pay them a certain amount of money so it's a we're going to hopefully have it more cost effective on our end not that they were charging us too much but their funding model is completely different than our funding model so we have to go along
124with what they do um and we think we could do it uh with not having to to uh pay so much in that regard so we're going to cross our fingers and hope that that works um and and I think that it will uh we also offer a summer bridge program which kind of falls under the umbrella it's usually to incoming n9th graders well in the past it's always been to incoming nth graders each of our schools creates like a week weeklong course in which they uh introduce the students to a lot of different um activities and components about the individual School sites they they get them um uh acquainted with Chromebooks and different aspects of the school um as a means to to get them started correctly usually we get list of names from
125our feeder schools who they make suggestions and say hey this kid could really benefit from from this time uh with you uh Delo I think last summer and all of the schools did some sort of math program uh to hey between 8th grade and nth grade here's uh you know you're going to make this jump in math and so we're going to create this Alex system that will allow students to um access and and start working and practicing on math so they don't have that summer gap of 13 14 weeks of not doing math so that's that's what we've done in the past I don't know if that answers your specific questions but I think that that it's good for me any other questions all right do I have a motion motion to approve all
126right so we have a motion to approve do I have a second we have a first by trusty Duncan a second by trusty Lake to approve item 8.9 BP 61 77 summer learning programs update there's no further questions all in favor starting with the student board signify by saying I hi hi hi all oppose hearing none motion passes all right we're GNA go ahead and move to item 8.10 BB board byot 9320 meetings and notices [Music] and we have a public comment on that I considered just explaining why I brought it but I'm going to go ahead and go a little out of order we're going to have public comment first and then we'll address why I brought it forward so with that Barbara Smith good evening thank you I'm not certain if you're going
127to discuss this among the board members but I'm here to talk about the special meetings uh part of this um document special meetings convened with only 24 hours notice and scheduled during daytime hours raise significant concerns about transparency and inclusivity while such meetings may appear to offer a veneer of openness their frequent use too within the last month can undermine genuine Democratic processes and limit meaningful participation for all stakeholders as an example I site the recent special meeting held to appoint a trustee to an open position holding this meeting during during the day 2: p.m. on a Thursday no doubt prevented many who would have been interested in the process from attending choosing to use a special meeting with limited notice seem designed to prevent or restrict Community input adequate notice is a Cornerstone of
128democratic processes ensuring that all relevant parties have the opportunity to prepare attend and participate in discussions a 24-hour notice period is often insufficient for individuals who need to arrange their schedules gather information or travel to a meeting location this short notice can inadvertently exclude those with rigid work hours caregiving responsibilities or other commitments I urge this board to consider using the special meeting provision very carefully if it's not an emergency most business before this board can be handled within its regularly scheduled meeting times should that not be possible I urge the board to give more than 24 hours notice of a special meeting and to schedule that meeting only during hours when a substantial number of community members are available to attend thank you thank you very much I'm glad that you brought that up
129um so we're going to go ahead and um if you please open that up Sarah so uh the reason why Dr cetti and I were discussing uh bringing this forward was because we clearly we have a very new board and our closed session meetings we're going to be recessing back into closed after this meeting inevitably there are items that are going to take a little bit longer for us to dig through getting the board up to speed on um The Happenings enclosed um and so you know in an effort to try to start on time and be respectful of everyone's time um we had discussed potentially moving the meeting back for our Open Session to begin at 6:00 p.m. rather than 5:30 which would also allow people who are working um potentially if they would
130like to attend um to be able to join us but also that our board closed would still begin at 4:30 so technically the board would have an hour and a half to unpack it if if it's necessary at some point I hope that you know we won't need that but right now um I I feel like it's an important um change that we should make uh to this um so um if you go ahead go down to regular meetings uh paragraph one it says other unless otherwise determined by the board uh the board shall hold one regular meeting each month starting at 5:30 p.m. on the third Tuesday of the month at you know and it goes on but so we'd be essentially just changing the 5:30 to a 600 PM start time to give
131us a little bit of wiggle room any thoughts on that I kind of like it okay so okay you would rather uh recess and then go back if if we have a long okay any thoughts I know as like a student I think having the 5:30 is definitely very helpful um as you were saying I think being able to have some time after school of course while you guys are in a close session and being able to get here but also I have a lot of homework um I'm a senior so you know trying to pile all that in and I know that we're able to leave at 9: but I really do want to stay for these meetings because you know being able to voice a lot of the student concerns at kfax um
132as well as my own just understanding that so I think having those 5:30 um meeting times is really important um but yeah that's just my viewpoint on it no I appreciate that any other thoughts so president Spade is your main rationale I understand was to take the necessary time in close session to potentially avoid having to do the back and forth um and is it common to do closed I mean I know it's for confidential things MH but is that the norm to do closed almost every board meeting typically there are there are inevitably items that just you know have to be discussed and um especially when we're dealing with Council um you know it's not ideal for them to be coming back and joining us in close to 10 p.m. so in order for
133us to receive advisement to be able to have conversations of a confidential nature um so for meeting was expected to go longer and closed the only way we could start this meeting would be to at six would be to make an official change so we discussed that Steve and I said well it does say unless otherwise determined by the board which I believe gives us a little leeway my my thought and our reasoning by bringing it Forward was so that it wasn't just you know everyone's used to a 5:30 start if we were to move it to 6 I'd want some consistency so the commun not like I think it starts at 5:30 but it was actually moved to 6 I would want that to be very clearly delineated moving forward but I do understand
134you know not wanting it to start later because of homework and other obligations just for the record um I think in all of pler County I think we start our meetings the earliest um we used to start them at 5 um and now we based on my schedule and children and obligations I asked for it to be moved back uh by one half hour so that's why we began starting our meetings at 5:30 but I don't off the top of my head I can't think of another District that begins their Open Session prior to 6 PM in pler County so we are a little unique um but I do respect that input and I appreciate that Ruby do you have any thoughts Tom um I'm a little torn I could go both ways um I
135do respect the the homework MH PE um personally I'm fine starting at at six o'clock and I also understand the rationale too because uh it is probably better from a fluidity standpoint to keep the consistency of close session going um so to have to break that up like we did tonight um is difficult uh but I also would like some flexibility but to the to the speaker that just brought up the point on um just transparency I don't think that would flow too well to start at 5:45 uh because we want to get going 15 minutes early because we have the time so I I don't know I don't have a strong opinion either way um because I can hear both sides so yeah no thanks for that trusty Jeff um I agree with what
136Tom just said actually I don't have an opinion on that um start time either way I think it it could work either way um I did want to um reiterate something that Miss Smith said um that I concur that or I agree with her that um you know we need we should be giving the public as much time as possible when we are having a special meeting I understand why why we had to have those other special meetings and I know there's probably going to be more of those in the future um as things pop up um but I think as much as possible we should give more than the you know the required 24 hours notice whenever we can uh just so we can get as many people here as possible oh I completely
137agree on that front as well you know I'm not fully committed one way or another you know this is just something that you know for the past several meetings we've um began a little bit later than um our scheduled time and for that reason I just wanted to be respectful of the community's time of our time and making sure that we're able to be as efficient as possible if if we want to continue at 5:30 I'm I'm okay with that I just I just want us to be aware that there is a chance that we're going to have to uh recess back back and forth to close yeah uh president Spade is is a is an earlier close session an option oh um I mean that does four o'clock work to start a Clos session
138would it be more advantageous to begin close session earlier rather than moving open yeah that' be okay with me that' be my vote as well start at 4 okay and I I had a I had a question regarding the the public speaker yeah did the the meetings last month uh wasn't more notice given than 24 hours yes so um yeah I'd like to unpack that but can we can we put a pin in that and then come back to that I want Dr kimy did you have any thoughts on it just curious on on which one sorry uh on the start time for close session four o'clock no just in general for six o'clock versus 5:30 oh I whatever the board decides yeah I I think um it you know coming back at a close
139session time is tough staff's going to need to remain because because we are committed to live streaming every single meeting we need to keep that live stream going and so it involves staff time waiting around at the end as well so we have to if we have toess back to CL because we need to publicly um um close close the meeting yeah I I'm okay with starting at a 4M start time that used to be more difficult but my that works better in my schedule now if we needed to for the time being and and that could also be something because that is not clarified in this policy it would not be something that would require us changing it it's flexible so um if you guys would prefer that we could yeah start 30 minutes
140earlier and also too just the ru Ruby's comment just um there are students here today too and you know I I value sleep for my kids so uh yeah agreed awesome well I it sounds like we have consensus to to potentially based on you know our meeting prior um to posting our agenda uh Dr cetti what and I will look and see how much we have to unpack and schedule it accordingly if that's okay with you guys yeah okay so but for the time being Clos session for closed for our closed session start time and but just penciling in your brain four o'clock unless otherwise indicated um but if we could also um open that back up because I do want to touch the special meeting um go ahead down yep special meetings so I
141just wanted to acknowledge um that per Education Code 35144 and government code we are only required to post it at least 24 hours prior to the special meeting but I do agree with you that that is not a lot of time but it is following the law and so I want to be clear there that that there's no laws being broken by by giving a 24 hours notice when it's absolutely necessary last month we we had a lot to to handle um including a deadline for an appointment that if we would not have otherwise had that meeting um and at a weird time because that was the only time all of us could be in the room and we it's we're required to have a quorum that we had that a little bit earlier in
142the afternoon so we could accommodate schedules to have a quorum and I know it's while it's not ideal it was the best that we could do and with the time constraints that we had because our vacancy happened to coincide with three weeks off and we have staff and so we did it our first available moment back um from school break and also try to be respectful we're parents with kids in activities and you know we don't want to miss those things either so that was the first date that we could lock down to be together um and I your complaint is not unique I've actually heard um from um other community members regarding that 24 hours notice so I'm not sure if it's something that's being discussed in forums outside of here or through email
143chains but I did want to acknowledge as well um and we're not talking about meeting recordings this is just about our regular meetings or and special meetings um but I did want to acknowledge that prior to last month and we had two special meetings then and a workshop this past week since I became a board member and I will count here one two three four five six seven eight nine special meetings or workshops since I became a trustee um all of which started in the morning midday or afternoon every special meeting um there was one in November on November 18th that began at 3 p.m. there was another on um 117 that ended up being canceled but it was scheduled for 10 a.m. another on October 29th 2024 which began at 10:30 a.m. prior to
144that in May of 2024 we had another 10: a.m. start time and the list goes on and on and on none of these board meetings were recorded streamed and no one said a word about the start time and no one complained about transparency so I want to be clear that while a special meeting and our our um are not required to be streamed we chose to stream or post later and record um to have to provide transparency and an an ability for our community to be a part of our process and CBE is an important topic in our district and knowing that we were starting in a kind of an odd time but what was most available for all of us to be able to meet that we thought it was important to stream even
145though it was a special meeting even though in the history of our board no one has chosen to stream a special meeting to my knowledge ever um so I I would like to just acknowledge that and um but moving forward is there any other comments or feedback have a com I was just going to say I was going to say thank you for acknowledging that the comparison of uh passport meetings to to now thank you um it was brought to my attention I mean consistency is critical as as the last speaker said and it brought to my attention that of our last three special board meetings one was live streamed one was closed caption and one wasn't seen at all I don't I don't understand that why they weren't all live streamed that's a great
146question so the first we elected to live stream in order for the community to be involved because we were going to potentially have action the second um through advisement through Council and through our committee we believed that it might um threaten the Integrity of our process if someone was watching online and knew the questions and could feed the questions to the candidates prior to coming in so that was a conversation between Council and committee and we chose to instead record it and post it so that people could see our process afterwards but in an effort to maintain Integrity for for that we chose to to post it later and then workshops like I said previously workshops we were taking no action and because it was a workshop and that's not been the historical precedence for
147our district and we were taking no action do we think workshops should be live streamed too and let them see how we work together let them see how we interact I think that would be a positive thing if if there's no precedent in the past for that let's start a precedent now because we're talking about transparency and letting the community see us in action I think that that's fair I think another argument would be that it requires more staff on site and and takes them away um from other duties and when we're not taking action that's interesting process for training training purposes any other uh feedback from trustees actually you know and just in respect for the fact that meeting minutes and recordings are not on and we were kind of talking special meetings actually
148I think we probably should divert from that topic well can we make that change we cannot make that change because it's not on the agenda trusty no I'm not saying make it now which I'm saying in the future recording workshops to be uh uh live streamed so people can see that I think they have a right to see that jump in real fast um one of the things about um just on the technical side of of a live stream um trusty Underwood depending upon where those workshops are in the past some of those workshops have been offsite though we're in an age where we can stream pretty easily off of our off of our phones it doesn't usually provide the best best product this room is equipped um for us to be able to stream
149easily we don't have that capability anymore at elmac we would have to move um equipment back where Carlos is at in ordered it so just kind of depends on where you're at in terms of what location we are are for streaming those workshops in the past typically have have not been in a typical boardroom setting because they're sitting around a table so functionally it it it would require some more forethought of where those workshops are so just a point of clarification I think at this point in an effort to not avoid you to avoid uh violating the brown act I think we should probably put a pin in that and we can definitely bring it back at another time to discuss um recordings obviously we've got some information about special meetings but not specifically around
150workshops and recording those workshops because it's not required by law all right with that being said it looks like we're going to go ahead and table um I think we have consensus not to make any changes to board bylaw 9320 meetings and notices be clear on that so we will table that till further notice all right we're going to go ahead and move to item 8.11 csba 2025 delegate assembly ctions ballot pull that up I will pull that up as well so as you can read in the um in the rationale and The quick summary um and we've got a really special color for you guys hopefully you're not blinded uh there are two seats for the csba delegate assembly sub region 4D and three candidates running including two incumbents one of which is me
151um Alisa Fong from Roseville city uh School District who's an incumbent myself and also Jonathan zerson from Roseville city school district and we um the phsd uh board reserves the right to write in a candidate if we so choose otherwise each board may vote for no more than two candidates but no more than one vote per candidate if that makes sense um if you want a little bit of rationale on what csba delegates do I'm happy to speak speak to that as it states in the agenda delegates serve um a two-year term and we essentially have two meetings annually um of the Thousand school boards across the state and 5,000 trustees across the state of California we are technically the largest elected body in the state of California and uh having delegates from every sub
152region as we talk about policy and elect um the presidency and talk about legislative action it's important to have uh delegates from our region be able to advocate for our community um I've thoroughly enjoyed it it's been very educational and I've been able to meet and collaborate with a lot of Trustees from across the state and so I would be honored to continue serving in that role um I also nominated uh trusty zachar Alisa has served on this committee for quite some time and I always think it's interesting to have um a new voice so I support trustee zerson and myself do we have any thoughts on item 8.1 now I uh I concur I support uh president spade and uh uh trustee zerson as well is that a nomination uh yes that's a a
153nomination okay so we we'll make that a motion a motion to nominate uh president spade and uh truste zerson from Roseville city uh for the uh for the board position or sorry delegate assembly pallot for csbi awesome I'll second all right we have a first by trusty Duncan and a second by trusty jeffes for item 8.11 csba 2025 delegate assembly elections ballot to vote for trusty zerson and trusty Spade any other comments questions uh trustees zerson Jonathan zerson oh it was trusty Jeff my apologies all right with that um starting with the student board all in favor say I I'd like to abstain you you are welcome to do so may as well please okay and I'm not going to ask why but just in reference typically with an abstention there's a conflict of interest
154or or you don't have enough information to make a vote otherwise I encourage a vote all right uh board all in favor say I I I all oppose hearing none motion passes unanimously with the obstination of our student board members all right item 8.12 superintendent vacancy search firm proposals all right so since our last meeting um we have I contacted several different search firms to of which uh provided proposals for your review hopefully you had the opportunity to review those and uh first being mcferson and Jacobson LLC if we could go ahead and open that there are different levels and uh costs associated with all different types of firms uh but one of the options that we have moving forward um is mcferson and Jacobson um I'm double cheing the page here could we find
155the page um lining out the cost associated with their bid and I apologize I typically write it down but I didn't I think it might be page um keep scrolling sorry and we're going to get there my apologies I should have written it down there it is okay so the total not to exceed amount including expenses 15,500 um obviously that doesn't cover some of the other expenses um and they have what's included in that amount which is BAS essentially posting it um advertising that and some meetings um candidate review information in their package they have uh candidates submit videos they review those videos they are doing background checks on those individuals um and and that's kind of what those cover um if we could pull up pcoe proposal as well thank you so much Sarah
156you're doing a great job okay we'll kind of head on down so similarly they would be doing the post except for the cost is 10,000 less um essentially um kind of the biggest difference I see is um depending on the level of involvement we want um they would you know we can have some add-ons if we wanted them to participate um in other ways and I actually um and we can have kind of some conversation around if if we want some additional information or or um services like a survey for input or Community input facilitation um um and that and I just from a a fiscally responsible perspective I am leaning into this for various reasons but I'd like your take on that trustees any thoughts do we know uh how involved the pccoe has
157been in the past with superintendent ped hunts so I am personally aware of at least three um local districts that have used pccoe and were very happy um some were more happy than others but uh that they were involved um in their process um I was actually attended one meeting because my son attends one of the schools that uh um superintendent Gail garalina moika um came and reported out the number of applicants um obviously not sharing any information at that time but just kind of giving updates on the process um it outlines meeting with the board and discussing um you know kind of the lay of the land you would say um but yeah but at different levels of of participation with her they I have heard positive um feedback from other boards trusty Jeff
158any thoughts on that I'm a little torn um I know the PCA option is is cheaper um however uh the other um firm seems to have a as I read through this yesterday seem to have much more detailed plan on what they plan on doing and how they're planning on doing it and also they seem to be um um more neutral if you understand what I'm saying with respect to political stances and that kind of thing um where I see um Gail for example as not being um necessarily the most neutral person and I no that she's not necessarily going to be running this process but um that may come into play at some point thoughts trusty Underwood trusty Duncan um exactly where I stand on that because I believe when Dr saraki was hired
159as our superintendent it was a nationalwide search where garbolino is more of a local I believe second one is kind of like centered here um I think i' would like to go if I had to choose right now from what I know I would go with the more expensive option which is a national search we might be able to find a candidate that's going to fit our district really well if we have a wider search than a narrow search I was looking through this I didn't I didn't see is it specific that the that the pcoe is just Regional it does not say that I'm not it doesn't say that directly but when I read through it it it kind of inferred that um one of the statements they made was we don't have a
160lot of applicants on file that we're looking through that we're more open and we uh we uh have more flexibility but I got the feeling it was more centered on California and the local area where the other one is a national one I don't know if that's correct but that that's what I picked up yeah so I I had um I I I see your some what you're saying in there um Jeremy that uh there there is more details in there right um as far as their process uh it's hard it's hard for me to look at that proposal without talking to them and interviewing them um to see like the depth of and the efficiency of actually following through with that implementation plan um I I do what what I liked about pcoe was
161um it did seem similar on some of the timeline uh and some of the uh the action items within the implementation plan but what I do like about them uh I do like local I do like that they have a feel for where we've been um and and we'll have a feel of you know where we want to go but also um connecting to like your your talks about you know we've talked about board Vision right and we want to go with that so um and you know fiscally responsible I mean I I I I thought that maybe we should just do this organically but I was told that there's probably some reasons why we shouldn't do it organic to start right from a fiscally conservative standpoint uh and then if we didn't like what
162we we saw um to then higher on but I feel like pcoe is a bit of a mix for me for that or GIC yet um following guidelines and uh an actual organization that's local that uh that we can work with a little closer so I think too just as a thought to add to this conversation is that if we chose to have it facilitated by pccoe and the candidates were not impressive or we didn't receive as many applicants as you know we desired there's nothing to say that we could not at that point you know there's not some hard and fast line where we have to have someone by this day no matter what you know we have some flexibility I'm curious through pccoe if we might receive some really quality candidates and have
163a process that's wonderful um and save our district $10,000 and it could be just as efficient and fabulous as others I've heard stories while I can't verify you know with some other search firms that um superintendent garalina moika spoke to in her third paragraph um and I'm gonna read it just so that I don't paraphrase it incorrectly she said as the pler county superintendent of schools my approach to the search differs from that of a for-profit firm my sole objective is to support the board and finding the best candidate for your District without any external motives unlike for-profit search firms which may prioritize placing candidates from their existing portfolio my only focus is to ident is identifying the right individual who aligns with your District's needs and vision to your point trusty Underwood additionally my
164services are offered at a reduced cost compared to for-profit firms and I have access to a team of experienced professionals within my organization who will assist in facilitating a thorough and comprehensive search my goal is not to generate Revenue but rather to provide a valuable service to our local school districts within pler County and So speaking to potentially some of the other issues that I've heard anec toally is other firms they've have people in the kitty you know and they're trying to push their people in um to the role who might not be the proper fit and we don't have a relationship with these people um to your point not interviewing them and um only going off of what's in black and white is more difficult but we do have a relationship with our County
165and they could be as involved or not as we choose you know we could have her open up the position or pcoe open up the position we could be apprised of all of the applicants and decide at that point if we feel like we need to have a wider net or if we feel like we can work within the parameters that they've provided if we feel like we have a solid candidate pool are we are we obligated to complete the contract with them if we sign with them to go through the whole process or if we decide to go into different direction you know I don't know that it speaks to that in here and I I certainly see that um thought I had one other question I wanted to talk to some of the
166admin that's been here a long time past superintendents how many of them were outside hires versus local hires Dr U srai Back late 90s Randy Olson was an outside hire that's as far back as I can go um Kim Barry might be able to give you a little bit more she was here in the hey Kim but Rand son he was hired from the outside but then B Bren was inside Dave horse he was hired from the outside but he was hired as a principal from the outside and then moved up to assist superintendent Bon bran I mean excuse me George shaki came from the outside so lot you know without going back farther than that I think you know previously that a lot yeah it's not it's not it's a mix you think about
167it between Randy and Bart you know Dave and George I mean 30 years for superintendent that's unheard of you know and sometimes it's like three to five years every time they cycle through so that's why we haven't seen a lot of that historically do outside hires tend to last longer than oh that's hard to say loal um you know at the time when um they heard Dr saraki the board was looking for something specific and he fit that mold that they were looking for and what the board wanted for the district that's the one thing that is remembered you guys are hiring this person you get the input but that that is your one hire is that superintendent based on what you feel your direction for the district is supposed to be yeah my gut
168feels like anybody that is presented as a as a candidate we'd be able to thoroughly vet and and really understand where they're coming from and and what they would uh what they would bring to the district um so it's just basically we're hiring someone to do the leg work to cast the umbrella and and and to be able to you know pull from the largest pool so I'm I'm very open to ecoe helping out I'm too I this is just proposal so as we get into the contract detail we can we can possibly negotiate and dictate some of that on our acceptance of the candidate pool and I'm sure that the $5,000 is negotiable based on the list of candidates that we get and if they're acceptable right I mean there's some ambiguity there um
169but I've I've worked with Recruiters in the past and you can put language in there to to help help us or support us this yeah yeah I I also you know to the survey input designing a survey I was just curious if I could find anything online you know if we if we could save a grand but have a really great survey that we come up with um I was able to find a 28 page survey of you know a starting point I'm just saying um where you know that could be a starting point I I it's really important to me based on our last experience that we have some community and stakeholder input on what's important to them um at the end of the day we represent the community and without some engagement um
170from the community I feel like we haven't done our job thoroughly so I'd like not necessarily running a community input facilitation unless you guys are interested in that or them performing interviews I think that if we have our base cost search and we decide um you know based on the feedback we're getting and the applicants if we need some additional supports um Jessica I don't think we should put the cart before the horse because our first duty is to be very clear of the vision that we want this District to go in and the specific goals that we want a superintendent to be able to fulfill so we don't want to start looking for a superintendent before we really hashed out that out and really have a clear consensus Among Us in terms of where
171we're going I I think it's a long long road too to get to that point so I think that helps Kickstart our our needs to get goals uh more goals put in line but at the same time the the the beginning process if done correctly on any kind of recruitment um that should take a while right to really take in what we need and I think at the same time to your point it will help us as we are trying to build out these goals I think this is actually a a pretty decent process to to ensure we're all in alignment um and actually get some help doing it through the through the surveys and through conversations with pcoe about what we're looking for could we could we pull up page number three please just
172want to review their overview of the super superintendent selection process and straight out of the gate it talks about meeting with the District Board of Trustees to determine the timeline for the procedures and and essentially for us to be ident identifying uh what we need to do and U as far as our contact is um and I think that I think that it's possible I'm not sure if it's a full cart before the horse the the duty that we have right now as trustees is to hire and find our our superintendent and to start that process and that process um from what I've learned um is that essentially candidates potentially for this position are going to be looking from here and and they're going to be selected for the next several months and have a
173you know typical timeline is July 1 start time now we're not married to any timeline but we may have a smaller pool of candidates if we don't consider um taking some actions now and then um working on facilitating opening this position I agree with that sentiment so I agree with that but I also agree with what David's saying that like we all need to be on the same page on what we're looking for um from our next superintendent um before we get too far into this process because I mean so I think if we do go this route I think we probably we'll call for another special special meeting where we can sit down and like and discuss and debate and come up with like a list of you know these are what this is
174what we're looking for what have you yeah so at following our special meeting and um some discussions obviously it's difficult um when we're all well it's a new board right and so making sure that we understand like our last Workshop was about roles and responsibilities and the next one we need to build on that and once we're all speaking the same language and understand our roles um you know I think we'll be able to identify what we feel like we need once our roles are a little bit more clarified um working together as a team I think it would be difficult to set exactly what we want and one more meeting we had a workshop and obviously um two of our trustees um were unable to be there so you know we're going to need
175some time together and and it's probably going to require more than one workshop and meeting to talk about our goals but in the interim and um get the ball rolling we need to get the ball rolling yeah agre but we need those things too so I'm with you on that so we need to you know align some stars and find a some days where we can get together and meet together to to line it out sound good okay so I think that we may have found consensus um with this item do I have a motion on item 8.12 and what specifically are you motioning you look like you want well i' I've already shared how I feel I I would uh motion to proceed with pcoe and uh and start the process second we have
176a first by trusty lake and a second by trusty Duncan to accept the proposal of pcoe um obviously there's going to still be some leg work on determining the depth and breadth and scope um and some uh meetings that will for sure be happening soon so we can figure those things out what additional add-ons we may choose as a board so plan on that any further questions comments yeah I I think uh we need to be careful because if we sign a contract with pccoe and they're not meeting our needs do we still pay the full amount no I think that's a great question yeah you know I want to have an exit we touched we touched on that a little bit where we're not if we're not satisfied with them then we yeah that's
177a good point yeah I think I think contractually we'll get we we'll walk through those on on the teas and C's um in this I think that it would be helpful to have more than one trustee I would um maybe we have the presidency go in and negotiate final terms with pcoe so we make sure we have an exit should they not meet our needs what you mind um okay and so we'll we'll make sure that we have that lined out okay any other questions okay so we have a first and a second on item 8.12 superintendent vacancy search from proposals to accept pcc's proposal for superintendent search with trusty Duncan and trusty Spade um reviewing and and finalizing the contract with them all in favor starting with the board I I board all in
178favor I I all oppose hearing none motion passes un ously all right item nine discussion items 9.1 grading committee board discussion regarding the grading committee procedures expectations and direction for staff I just want to acknowledge as we're moving into this that I sincerely appreciate the number of people who have already volunteered through the data that you you shared the the top of the meeting that would like to have a voice and and participate in in some way through this grading committee and and also the data collected through our educational partners and um all of these things are going to be considered without us without us forming an ad hoc committee and setting some goals and expectations and providing directions of staff were kind of at a stand still and so we felt it was important
179so that we could have another conversation about exactly what we're going to need to be able to make a decision moving forward that this needed to be agendized again so um I just want to share my thoughts regarding the committee um procedures that um my my thought is to create and form an ad hoc committee with two members of the board who will coordinate with um our partners um and those interested in participating in the committee and create a forum to to gather some insight and information potentially there our own surveys for teacher or excuse me not teachers for parents and community and um and students I because I think we need to make sure that when we're taking small uh you know groups that we're also thinking of of an opportunity for an atlarge
180participation if they can't participate um in person and also that as we're gathering this information just an setting an expectation that that the committee will be uh an information gathering tool for the board um and that once all the information is is back and disseminated and we're able to have conversations that setting the expectation that it may not be exactly what came back the recommendation that it could be a variation of that um bringing all of the pieces together that at the end of the day that it won't be the grading committee who sets the standard that it will be brought back as a report we will have a conversation about it and decide the best way moving forward so um at the end of the day the board is you know has to set
181um set some of these decisions um but obviously there's important stakeholders and we've been hearing so much feedback for so long now it's time to get to work so any thoughts on um ad hoc committee or what you feel is important moving forward what you're going to need to hear in order to be able to make a decision or setting some parameters for our committee I think as we're moving forward um I feel like we need to have several meetings so that we can cuz that's a large group of a number of people that are wanting to participate um and I think it should be done outside of normal work hours like on a Saturday perhaps um so that we can get more students and parents and stuff there U because I think that's really
182really important we want to get as much input as we can so I think a couple of Saturdays would would probably be a good um good route and um and I think we need to do it sooner rather than later because the teachers really need to know before too long like what next year is going to look look like so they can start figuring out how this is going to kind of come come together yeah so to the uh I agree um Jeremy on on your points um and I think what's really important is out the gate we have to decide what type of um feedback uh we want to start with because there you're going to have a lot of people in this meeting and we have to be able to drive um uh
183the conversation right otherwise things are just going to get they're going to slow down right because there's a lot of different inputs so we have to have clear agendas for the first couple of meetings in order to to to drive it in a good fluid way and then the committee will find itself at that point you know the fluidity will kind of naturally come up but the agendas are going to be really key in the very beginning so Rusty Underwood yeah I'm just looking at tonight and our staff is divided if take a look at the graphs one3 one3 one3 so you're going to have people that are going to be pretty rigid in their positions regardless I think in terms of our staff you know what they want from us is Direction I think
184I'm not against having input in fact I welcome having input from the community but we're probably the community in a way is going to reflect what the staff is one you know it's going to be split as well um so we're just going to have to uh within us take the information that we have and we're going to have to make a decision based on our vision what we want where we want to go eventually like on the fourpoint scale that we had we were making tremendous progress we really were if you take a look at it historically over two or three years more and more people were coming on board we didn't have all the staff on board but we were coming in that that direction so whatever we do you know we're not
185going to please everybody there's just no way you know um we're just going to have to take the information we have maybe get some more information and make a decision on what we feel is needed to achieve the vision of Excellence that we're looking for I also say like there's there's no need to make a a rush decision too like if we feel there are Milestones coming up that um we need to hit whether it's lcaps or whether it's you know fall like my personal view is that we need to make the best decision for the district we pulled back we augmented so far that feedback from uh from from all all sides has been fairly good um it's been positive uh and we're just you know six weeks in and so we don't really
186have any data to cooperate some of the anotic feelings and thoughts but I feel like the augmentation that was done was for the right purpose we're seeing we're yielding decent early results um and now I just wouldn't want to see us make a quick decision because we feel like we have to hit certain mem dates yeah I have a a little bit different uh feeling based off the teachers that I've talked to um I talked I had a really good conversation with some teachers at AT pler uh at deloro at Forest Hill um yeah and and and a little at kofax but I it it feels like there's a big difference between the stem departments and all the other departments right um there's just been countless hours that have gone in to try and come
187up with grading scales and uh and it what what I've noticed is that a lot of teachers have uh taken the leniency that was given at the beginning of this term and there's modified versions going on right now where there's no it's not uniform you've got some that are doing the fourpoint you've got some that are that are still doing the traditional method and um um so and it's frustrating what's frustrating is there are teachers that are very frustrated and that's transferred to the students and that's transferred to the parents and so why can't we identify where those frustrations are coming from and start there um that's just my my observations from from having meaningful conversations with with uh teachers in different departments um I think that there's a lot of there's there's high value
188in some of the the principles of the fourpoint system I feel like there's some really like meaningful things that standardizing being able to standardize uh grading requirements being able to clearly communicate with students what what what you have to do to meet a level three and what you have to do to meet a level four um so I I I feel like I'm new to this but I've I can't tell you how many hours I've I've studied and listened to not just in this District but abroad this isn't just going on in our district um nobody likes to feel like a guinea pig right especially students especially when you're messing with uh College applicants um and a large push from from this whole approach was to address the students that are potentially you know struggling
189the ones that tend to get left behind and I think that you know it's a it's a it's a meaning these are meaningful changes to to help uh those students that may not be College Bound right and to get away from I I totally agree with not using Behavior to to come up and finalize grades uh focusing on what the students actually learning but I uh I don't know I just think that it was I tend to agree with the teachers that say Hey this wasn't and I and it's a and it was like this mountain that Trent had to deal with this roll out with expectations and it just wasn't reasonable you can't mess with teachers that have systems in place for Meaningful reasons and I think if you start mandating that teachers now
190have to change their whole approach to Education Without a clear uh explanation or rationale it's just like it's so frustrating I've noticed that there's so many hours wasted in explaining and trying to teach students what does it mean to be a two to be a three to be a four and then you got to go to all this math and convert it back to letter grades because at the end of the day letter grades have been around for hundreds of years so it's like that's frustrating and I don't know maybe I mean I'm on board with deleting D's and Fs because you know if I can be a little vulnerable I got my first f as a fifth grade student and uh in English because I didn't turn in my stupid assignments that I knew
191I should have turned in you know and I still sticks with me Mrs ball fifth grade she says Emerson you you could have done a lot better and you know that and blah blah blah so I'm all for uh you know the no credit or the incomplete but you can't mess with the teachers in the trenches that pour their heart and soul into teaching uh these students and just create this sense of confusion uh you know anyway um so that being said I think I I I really appreciate the survey that was done I would love to see it you know I guess the normal survey is out there for a week this this lasted 3 days uh we only got maybe half there's 182 classroom teachers and uh and I respect the all the
192other admin and all the other teachers that are also participating in feedback for this uh because the counselors also have to deal with this I mean there's a lot that goes into these changes but um I think that you're going to see a big difference in opinions when you start to break down departmentally the feedback that we're getting I think the stems are going to have you know a lot more to say than you know the Ceramics courses so anyway that's where I'm coming from um so with with the survey if we can modify a little bit and and really encourage participation really encourage feedback and let them know that we're ready to take actionable uh moves to to to clarify and to make it more um because it's not streamlined right now you got
193teachers doing all different things in all different sites uh and they're making it work and so you know I I think that uh I think it's possible to to you know make some meaningful changes uh latch on to those those those parts of this of of these original changes that that make the most sense lean into those but then the ones that just don't make any practical sense you have to give teachers the autonomy to be able to you know to run their classrooms I I feel for the teachers that are spending inord amount of time managing students from prior terms and you know it's just like there's so much wasted time honestly um and I get it it's not it's a huge undertaking to try and like fundamentally change how how how grades are
194are administered but uh I think we need the feedback from the teachers in the classrooms and see where the divergences are see where there's agreement and where there's there's disagreement and uh so that we can make choices because we're not informed we don't have that data yet so I think also I think a great St Emerson um I I think also it's not just the teachers right we need to I think we need to talk to our administrators right and get a feel for them on how things are going I I what three weeks ago a month ago I sat down with with Mr zerwas and and um try to get a feel for it was early but like anecdotic right with no data like how are things going right and so I think that's
195part of it too I mean everyone that's why this committee I think will be so important and we can drive surveys out of that committee too right as well just to get a feel for all the parties and how and how they're how they're doing yeah so agreed please a couple um things that I'm that I'm hearing um first of all trusty Jeff is appreciate you recognizing this is going to probably take more than one meeting with a small group um a hundred people is a really a hundred different opinions um and that is um a recipe for not a very successful meeting also heard ad hoc and um um my my recommendation or my suggestion would be um to look at board policy 5121 and do the ad hoc committee with that because at
196this point we we still have policy in place 5 the AR and the BP and the AR comes out of the BP and so if if there was an ad hoc committee with board members to look at 5121 and and really it's the third paragraph of the policy I think that requires probably the most input um that would we pull that up um well wait I don't think we have it here right now but um is it permitted in this session if if we're having a discussion well I don't I don't think we should word Smith it right now is what I'm saying that would be that's not agendized but that's just my re my recommendation do we look at you in addition in addition to it I um that way we now have some
197legs to stand on in terms of where where we're going and and it's kind of kind of more from what I'm what I'm hearing of you know grading committee means lots of different things to lots of different people is that um extending time for learning is that incomp right it's all wrapped up into that is it is it CBE I think that's kind of the elephant in the room right and we do have some timelines that the board has has put on on staff for for June right where I think that was that our special meeting we made made that on so I'm sure staff is fine with with slowing any change changes down I just so the board understands that was the direction I was given that we need to have a decision by
198June um but my recommendation would be the ad hoc committee first with the policy and then that would at least give us a direction to go so when we're inviting people by Community to speak into here's the policy um then could work on the AR and and make them align I think that would be be helpful I just I just don't want to have a meeting where our our parents and our students and our and our staff um are just it's getting argumentative and contentious about a philosophy of education is really what we're kind of talking about and think it's really personal um so th those are kind of my my um as I'm kind of listening here yeah I tend toe and it was mentioned I think last meeting you're going to put 50
199100 people in a room and you're going to have yeah two different opinions right how helpful is that GNA be we we kind of know the arguments on both sides Mr Wilson any any insight or I just what I listen to is um you know Gathering insight and information I I I think you know your way Steve that you mentioned is great I I think getting down to what you want what information you want will be key and I would my suggestion would be maybe come up with two or three questions that are really specific that that people can answer about um you know just grading in general like um you know what should con go into a student's grade what what is a a fair grading practice those kinds of things will then give
200you some insight to what the community is thinking about grading um along with the teachers you know you'll get uh some good details because ultimately you know we're going to kind of go back to where we started was with grading practice that was the uh origination of all of this and just kind of talking about what is appropriate and fair and accurate grading systems that we should do that we treat our student body uh fairly um if it's I wouldn't even really discuss fourpoint system I wouldn't even discuss CBE I would just say what should um a fair accurate system be consist of some of those questions I think we could develop and you guys could sift through and figure out which questions you think are most pertinent um and then that way you guys
201could have a direction of going oh I get to feel like these are the things that our community our teachers would say you know like we use the term non-negotiables all of our students know that they're going to get this expectation in a class all of our students know that they're going to get this expectation in a class and I think there's a lot of value in you guys setting that as a board of saying we want all of our students to have this experience within a class that is fair and treats every kid every student equally in some way um and in developing those I I I think uh so that's my opinion I I don't know if discussing four-point grading system and all of those things to Emerson's point we're going to spend
202a lot of time just trying to help people understand what those are uh and we won't get very far I'd rather us focus on uh you know how we could use grading practices to Spur student learning identify student learning and those kinds of things so that's my recommendation thank you TR go ahead I love that Trent and I feel like that would be the most effective productive way and use of time if if we had those specific questions and then put them out there so that teachers can weigh in let students weigh in if they want to you know let parents weigh in if they want you know what I'm saying the more data the better to to be able to help inform decision making and ultimately you guys are going to have to make
203a decision in which right not everybody's going to be in agreement with but I think it'll at least help you and I and I think uh if if if you guys could think about these questions in general like what should grades be what are the purpose of grades how do they impact our students um um and that way it'll help you guys kind of sift through some some of the responses that you're getting and saying okay this is this is the most important thing this is how grading affects our students and making sure that we have a policy that can um again be fair and accurate to our students yeah and and I completely agree I think foundationally is what you're talking about like big rocks right where where are we where are we going
204to plan our flag and then I think any debate on whether it's a fourpoint or you know 100 point system it's easier to support whatever decision the board goes with based on finding these foundational pieces which those foundational pieces are in 5121 yeah yep absolutely so thank you for that see bottom line to me is from my experience in the classroom because I was in the classroom forever I we want all kids especially the underserved kids to me to succeed okay so Competency Based education is an attempt to do that as long as all the Departments had their standards clearly identified which I think we've already gotten to that point you know the question to us is if we're not going to do the 4 point I never really kind of felt comfortable with the
2054 3 2 one maybe based on my background and experience in the class room but I remember a pler I remember this so clearly we had our standards specifically what we wanted kids to learn and we had a you know based on the 100 point system um based on ABC no D's no FS no credit or incomplete no credit incomplete but the kids could learn that that was 30 years ago and it worked I don't know why pler ever got off that system but most of the teachers were there to help the kids that weren't mastering the standards to learn specifically what they needed to do they got their incomplete to earn that c or B you know whatever we do it needs to be unified it can't be like what you're saying Dr Lake
206this Department's doing this this Department's doing it's going to have to be unified districtwide specifically where we're meeting the needs of the kids making sure those underserved can be successful have our clear standards that we want kids to learn you know and have teachers dedicated to helping those kids learn those and the 100p point system 30 years ago when we did that was pretty successful there's one person in this room that was doing that as an English teacher and that was Kim and she remembers that you know so uh that's that's my statement you know um um obviously there's a lot to unpack here and that this is hence the need for an ad hoc committee to review the policy you know personally I feel like you know I understand the need for some uniformity
207and some consistency I do think that there's been a ton of time there's an argument that some of it's been wasted um trying to explain it um and for the lack of you know better words like beaing a dead horse nobody nobody wants to do that um and I and I and there's been so many struggles trying to make it uniform across the district um with teachers that weren't comfortable with it trying to explain it and spending a crazy amount of time um and some that have you know found a way to make it work where I struggle I think that setting expectations visions and a proper Foundation is critical but I let's face it not all of our kids are the same the same thing doesn't work for everybody the same thing doesn't work
208for every single teacher either I think we need to set those expectations we need to know what was working with the old system and what wasn't where were the barriers where were the potholes what what was holding it back what can we potentially through this this policy and through feedback what elements are non-negotiable for us to keep and and what's not and I I think that overwhelmingly there's been a ton of negative feedback about the endless retake I know that that's a tenant of CBE that it's been a nightmare for some teachers I I don't think it's as far as accountability or kids getting left behind with retake after retake I I'm hearing some departments are shifting some of those practices I think that the retake situation just fundamentally is going to have to be
209addressed I think we need some data on that I need some data on that some information through the Committees um and and then I don't know that there is a a an easy explanation or Direction when we're talking every Department um especially with this system we're finding repeatedly serious issues between departments so I do think we need some of that data and information as well um I so appreciate your feedback U Mr Wilson regarding you know what is some of the questions that we need to ask just to kind of really hone in and drill down on what's most important to us but I do think that we are talking about comp Competency Based education we're talking about that grading system I've met with Mr Lemon about how those words and th that acronym is
210woven through all of our documents right now if we're shifting away from that which could be might not be we there might be some tenants still there obviously all of us want the kids to succeed in the least restrictive environment I'm a SP sped mom we want them to have the the tools that they need to succeed and and and frankly if the my child is in with a teacher and and they're showing the effort and they're showing competency you know and they're doing what they need to do you know I'm you know for the most part I I'm not challenging um teachers and usually when my kids's in trouble I'm not saving my kid I'm like what did you do you know I know that's a little off in this generation where you we're
211usually calling out teachers instead of calling out our kids but I call out my kids so you know if we're hiring the right people they're they're in an environment where they can teach and grow I don't know if uniformity is the goal I think that our expectations need to be clear our goals need to be clear our board policy needs to to be that starting point so um I would agree with the ad hoc committee unpacking that working on some questions for some focus groups and surveys um but there I I need some data regarding the pros and cons of the previous system and where our barriers were to move forward um I am interested to see who is interested in being on this ad hoc committee and helping to facilitate the uh changes to
212the to the policy um and help to organize be interested you're interested I'm interested um can I just add something really quick so um I just wanted to share a couple things that coax is doing and I know that you guys attended the learning walk which was great but I'm just in like a more public platform so like for a retake policy for example like all of the classes that I'm currently taking we taking we have like a onee policy so our teachers like schedule Flex in which like we have an entire week where we're able to do a retake so that way all it may be SE as like endless retakes it's still like in a schedule so that way we're not falling behind because we don't have those basic skills of like a
213um assessment that we did at the beginning of the term which we will maybe continue on later in the term so having that like week of retakes really helps out because then it also gives the teachers the opportunity to sort of assess where different students are at especially like if they got a 2.5 as opposed to like a three and where like they need to be helped with in terms of those retakes and then also with like just real quick on the flex is that do you mean that that entire week you're not focusing on current uh curriculum you are just focusing on retakes no so and you're studying with the teacher so in like flex and stuff like that what I mean is in the 40 minute block that we have during school um
214our like I'll use Miss Bratton as an example because she does it for physics um so she has like we take a test on a Friday for example and then she gives us our scores back um then she has this Flex for the next week so Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday where she schedules a date um where we're able to retake that test so for students that no during the intervention yeah yeah so during that 40 minute period it yeah um yeah and then we like are also in all of our different classes I know in my history class we have to do test corrections before we're able to take that retake so understanding a lot of the things that we we did wrong so that way it's not like a retake where oh I got
215um like a 2.5 on this I'm just going to retake it and not trying understanding it better it's we our teachers are actively making sure that students are like helped throughout um not in a way that's like handholding but in a way that's really collaborative and really understanding the material as opposed to just trying to get um them a good grade those are similar practices at least from my experience at delor anyway so that's good and then also with um communicating like level threes level fours um a lot of my teachers they have designated rubrics which I think um Madame President Miss Bratton and maybe Miss schauffer have shown you yeah so um they give that to all the students at the beginning of the year just hand out papers and um with the syllabus
216that we get at the beginning of the year which is often like a graded assignment um they're were able to communicate with parents and talk about what um each level means what that looks like and then in our back to school nights as well we're able to talk to parents about those practices so I know at kfax we're able to communicate a lot of what those levels mean and as students I think um in all of my classes that I take and even talking with underclassmen who like freshmen who've never experienced this before as well as sophomores and juniors um they all pretty much understand a lot of what those levels are requiring of them and you know we have such a great culture at cax as you know our showcase really um touched on
217which was amazing but you know we're able to talk with our teachers um pretty um like unfiltered wise so understanding a lot of what they need from us and what we need from them so cool thank you do we feel like we have is there any other interest for the ad hoc committee I would I would participate we have two okay we have two we need it work two well we can't have more than two otherwise it would be a meeting and we are required by the brown act which which is only two for the ad hoc but really important now speaking of special meetings and workshops technically um the ad hoc can gather information and they could present some of the findings in a workshop that we're not taking action just so we can
218disseminate and look through the information and have and say hey we might need a little bit more information in this area and you guys provide some I mean like we could I don't want to rush this to your point either there's a lot going on right now I do want direction for our staff before next year but I am not committed like that we have to have I know we we have this we have a projected timeline but if we're not there yet I feel like that the the misstep that we made originally with this plan was was a a torpedo roll out with the best intentions and that's why we're here so I don't want to do the same thing with making another fast decision um that we're going to have to deal with
219agreed so in the meantime just uh I think you have departments all kind of adapting to a system that's working for them they're making it work they're they're tweaking the numbers they're coming up with scenarios uh that make sense but it's there's there's not uniformity and and maybe you won't find that you know with all departments but uh but I think that's important data right for sure so so we have we have fall semester which gave us a certain you know pros and cons now we're going to see the spring semester with its own set of pros and cons right and so like I like I like the ability to make sure that we can and that's why I was really comfortable with the modifications because it's going to give you kind of AB testing
220at this point um so and and with that though I mean and uh Trent's gonna be speaking to this in his staff report I mean it's the lens of feedback has to be student student outcomes that's right so we we have to be able to use use that and as much as the survey survey is survey is great the survey questions are asking more specific questions as how do you feel about about whatever practices the how do you feel about the four point fourpoint scale that doesn't tell me anything about is it working working yeah and so we need we need to look at our outcome data from our our students and then match it to I if we have this many incompletes being resolved or this level of students that are reaching a to
221G I mean that kind of that metric thing we talked about that I I think we need to keep in in a lens um because we can't we don't want to base things only on on feelings and those are really really important but we are in the business of student outcomes and that is where we need to put our our emphasis on whatever that whatever that decision whatever that direction is we need the data to see that it's working or or it's not and if we say it's not working what data are we saying that it's not working if we say it is working what data are we saying that right because it can go both ways we can say CB is the best thing on the planet and but our data is showing we're
222not having persistence we're not having increaseed a tog we're not having students reaching high levels of rigor or CT completers all that amazing data that um as outcome data that's that's what we need to be you know focusing on so I just remind us of that um so absolutely well we've got three interested in participating I I'd be happy to um as well but I've got a lot of other hats I'm wearing right now so it certainly doesn't need to be me is there um do we have I I don't think we need to take a formal anything on this um so it's just kind of Direction um and support consensus from the board on on who's going to be our representatives for the at and trusty Jeffrey were first so okay I feel good
223about that for looking at the policy for uh reviewing the policy and then um working with staff to to um just kind of had the committee we'd be happy to staff to look at questions and submit them to the board yep maybe submit it to the committee yeah and then the committee can kind of disseminate that and then we can they can discuss next steps at this point we still don't have a direction what we're doing with 100 people that said they want to get involved that's a separate that's a separate group okay I just want to make sure just so our our I don't want to frustrate our parents and folks that signed up oh we can we could we could talk isn't that what the committee would be for yeah that's exactly it
224yep yeah so I think I think that if we we hand it over to the committee at this point um you know to gather some feedback knowing what where we're all at and the kind of information that we're going to need to be able to make a decision I think we move it forward sure okay yeah sounds good um can we potentially um discuss like a a a report out or we can add to the reports a committee update on the information gathered some survey information just so that as we're getting as you guys are getting information that we can all hear it yep I'm sorry I'm I'm I just want to clarify I'm still confused um so the ad hoc committee is looking at board policy 5121 that ad hoc committee is going to
225be trusty Duncan trusty Jeff and staff and staff is going to coordinate and come up with questions potentially for a survey for the ad hoc committee to well who's in the ad hoc cany besides you just are two trustees they're going to look at those questions they're going to look at the questions okay I just want to make sure we're clear okay and then and then they'll they will figure out how to roll it out to the people who have signaled that they want to be a part of that um in person or through survey or a number of ways okay but we'll have the ad hoc okay yeah that up yep you guys feel comfortable yeah okay okay thank you for clarifying y nope thanks for asking okay Communications key I think that's part
226of why we got lost um this past uh fall okay let's go ahead and move to 10 our staff report I'm looking at the time here trustees do we need a okay 8:35 8:35 still we need a are we okay if we're okay we're going to keep firing through all right go ahead 10.1 uh proposal adoption of textbook Edge level C for deloro high school welcome Michelle Isam hi nope yes oh but I don't hear you NOP no Carlos I think I hear it hello we do not hi everybody I'm here tonight to introduce for a first read a textbook this should be fairly simple um Edge uh by The Edge textbook level C which is the highest level for our English Learners and is used primarily in advanced AC academic language I do have
227one correction um when I originally filled out the new textbook application form it would looked like it was only going to be Del Oro but luckily Sue found some money because we determined there was a need for this at pler as well so that will be changed before you take action next month um in case some people don't know who I am I'm the district librarian I think the student board members might not know that and part of my job is to um assist teachers and administrators in finding books and then um putting together um committees to take a look at what is needed this particular textbook is again level C we've already adopted in our district the levels a b and fundamentals for our elel students um one thing that's really important about this
228particular textbook is hopefully it addresses long-term English Learners um and gets them over that hump to get them reclassified so just so you understand the process this particular textbook will be available at the district office for the next 30 days until our next meeting when And We Gather feedback from community members students parents Etc they're welcome to come in and we have it at the front desk but I'm also most of the time there so I'm happy to speak with them about it as well and I we have a form that we use for feedback of the textbook and then I present that information to you next month um and the board would take a vote and take action on approval awesome any questions just so the board knows um Michelle has done outstanding job
229with um her role and largely you know throughout the state the nation this is a is a highly charged item um and the systems that Michelle has put in place has allowed um our community feedback and they haven't provided really any on are these first reads but it's there for them right and so they they have been able to do that and Michelle is always available um to our community to ask questions and our staff and and I think is just a testimony to what Michelle's done um in her role to kind of um ease potentially the public perception of how textbooks are adopted or you know content she's always open with all those items so it it's it's just been a really smooth process and we're in this year two with this process of
230the second first second read I think it's all year three okay so I think it happened when I was on so it's got to be less than two or around two oh that might be it's pretty new I think we originally did a two uhep process years ago for some reason the district moved away from it but when I was writing um our our textbook adoption process and our um collection um development process um we went back to that two-step to provide an opportunity for anyone who wants to take a look at what we're adopting um because the biggest tenant was of course transparency that's what we want to have for our community members so will this replace uh what's in that the English class English second language class now so interestingly we actually adopted
231these levels last spring um and when we did that and we had a pilot um of the eel teachers they determined because that's really how we handle textbook adoptions in this District nobody from the district office tells them what to buy we always go to the teachers they indicated they did not feel that they needed this level at that time um but we're getting a lot more El students um the program is growing um and so we needed to address it with this level originally we were using um the ERWC curriculum um which was written by uh the state of California University system so state universities that's cool I I uh I have a English Learner in our home and she attends deloro and uh so I'm looking forward to learning more about this um
232is she in one of the E classrooms she's in a English language class MJ mass is awesome she's an amazing teacher and she has a lot to juggle she's got in what her one class all four levels of el students so it's important for her to have this resource um to use with her students in the classroom thank you question Michelle so you mentioned earlier transparency that the effort to make textbook adoptions transparent if that's the case then why are we making parents go all the way to the school district office you know to to look at the book one each of the sites has has a library that they could be in right they could live in a library potentially um if if the publisher is willing to provide us with that number of
233textbooks for to preview we can certainly do that what I typically do to kind of mitigate that issue is I work with Sarah and she puts in our newsletter and I work with the sites in their newsletters and I reference a link to the digital okay um process at the Textbook Company so that sometimes sometimes um textbook companies will provide numerous books other times not um and this kind of was a timely issue so that's why we wanted to get it on um the agenda as soon as possible so that the textbooks can be in the classrooms as soon as possible and my second question has the elel teacher that's going to be teaching out of that book has she had the he or she had the opportunity to look at that book and kind
234of go through it yes they were chosen by the current yel Staff last spring which didn't include MJ at deloro however she loves the program awesome thank you very much thank you all right we're gonna go ahead and move to item 10.2 yes madame President we are discussing our midyear lcap uh I was just at a California uh High School C ition meeting this past weekend in which there was a lot of consternation and complaints about how the lcap has blown up over its original intent and all of the uh bureaucratic red tape and and work that we have to do with this document that keeps getting larger and larger and larger uh a couple years ago we were able to uh hire a really awesome guy named Robert lmon if you have not uh
235talked to him yet or met him um I'm sure you'll get a chance to he has been a great addition to our staff uh he has tackled the lcap along with Sharice and Ronda and others uh and all of the principles on playing their role in contributing to the information with the elcap so uh I am going to turn it over to him and let him speak about the work that he's done with the the midcap or the midyear uh elcap report thank you well thank you and uh board president and trustees and Dr k um another thing I can mention back to um Shell's presentation is in our lcap um it's been legislated that we need to track our progress on our ltels as well and so one of our Solutions and metrics actions
236for tracking them is to provide leveled curriculum and so that is an answer providing and finding that level C material is in order to meet the needs of all the levels of our ltels and ltels are long-term English learner I was just gonna ask someone to clarify Mr Dr Lake we can add that acronym to your list um so this is year one of three of our lcap cycle and what you'll see out of this process um is that this elcap truly involves all of our educational Partners um it's a great representation and testament the collaboration that happens um across our district because um you will see that um Sue from business is going to be taking a slide and presenting a piece um and then one of our principles Aaron is going to be
237coming up to um talk about myu's information also so this is a truly um collaborative process across all of our departments and all of our schools as well so the reason for the actual update the background is three years ago um Senate Bill 114 out of the requirement to provide an update um this report the idea behind it um is just to give a midyear outcome data whatever we have available of the metrics identified in the lcap to give the board and the public um a preview and an update on the progress of some of those metrics um and so that's really what this purpose is there's no requirement on the format and the style that we do it in um but this is an opportunity to give an update on the progress of our
238metrics um and Dr ketti provided it very well that um a lot of our decisions are based on these metrics and we continuously look at them also so just a preview um review our lcap goals these are our three lcap goals that we have seen um for the last few years and again um this is updating on our one current of our first year of the three-year lcap plan and we will be going through and looking at a handful of metrics from each of these goals to give you an update um you all have access to and it is linked the the full midyear um update which gives progress on all of the metrics that we currently have and I'm going to let Sue and business talk about some of those numbers and what they
239mean um this slide is pretty vanilla I at adopted budget uh we determine what our budget's going to be for you know you have your lcff funds and then you have your supplemental concentration and you have to use those to budget what you're going to do for those lcap goals um so as adopted in budget you see those numbers the midyear update is a is is the same because at this point point we do not still do not know what our actual um lcff we have a pretty good idea but it's really not um certified until after P2 so we usually don't know what the final numbers are going to be until a couple months from now or sometimes not till next fall because CDE has to certify the numbers but we kept the budget
240as is um and then as you'll see in the detail of it you can see what we've spent to date it's a midyear year you know recap so it's more concentrating I think you can agree on how much we're spending to meet these goals and all these actions underneath it so that's why you see usually it's pretty common that the adopted budget in the midyear update Revenue stays the same because we don't have that certification quite yet what you will see uh within this update is that because it's the mid year you are going to see some outcomes that are unknown for example the facility inspection tool not compiled until around the May area so there will be some data um that's not compiled yet some metrics and outcomes are in progress um we continuously
241are looking at attendance rates we are still tracking that we won't get those till the end of the year chronic absenteeism and suspension rates those are on going as you also saw from colfax's um presentation also um there are some outcomes that are known because we base um our years that we are tracking off of the previous years outcomes so we look at appropriate appropriately assigned teachers um access to instructional materials we are tracking our last year's Casp outcomes um because our current LC cap will not be completed and written until we have uh it'll be written and approved before we get this current Year's Casp outcomes so we are referencing last year's Casp outcom comes so you will see that um in this we have some data that is known and some data that
242is not known yet a lot of the data that you're going to see in the metrics that we're tracking are known interesting point um that we can reference also is that right now um we're tracking a total of 151 different metrics completely throughout the entire year um 151 specific metrics um with sub groups and student groups um and really what those are is we're using tracking all those and analyzing them continuously making sure that what are actions and goals making sure that they're effective and that's the whole point of tracking these metrics um right now if you look at and track all the 151 metrics from the previous year um currently 69% of those metrics have all been approved from last year's data 133% of them have had no change or have stayed status quo
243so hopefully that that number of data improving will increase as we get some of our data compiled at the end of the year also so looking back at our goal one uh we don't have the time or the space to look and review every single piece but I wanted to do a good job of giving you a snapshot of some of the important data um but also some data that stood out and areas where we can look at and improve on and Target and see how we can do things differently and improve the outcomes for certain student groups what you'll see the color coding um is the color coding off of the dashboard so in CCI um you'll see the Baseline that we started this year one of three was we had 66% prepared for
244all students our goal at the end of the three years is 80% prepared and currently um from last year from last year's data 73.2% are prepared and we saw some incredible increases from our students with disabilities and our Hispanic students also um and you see those color codings is that the 73.2 puts us in the blue category um students with disabilities in that yellow and Hispanic in that green area um obviously another highlight is our graduation rate and our a through G rates um on and all those if you compare where our midyear update is to our desired outcome we're making adequate progress and we're making gains to actually meet the end of our three-year goal there lofty goals um but in this goal and these metrics that we're looking at we are actually um
245on track to making progress and meeting those three-year goals so lcap 2 um when you look at the full document you will see a lot of the same metrics we're using we're reviewing a lot of the same metrics in goal one as in goal two as well um but I wanted to highlight some of the other ones that we're focusing on on um obviously our Ela and our math scores in Casp um while there may be some dips we see some of those highlights we saw kfax um in general with big increases um we also see some student groups that had some big increases and and what we do um in ed services and with with principles and at sites um and with departments is we look at why did these subgroups improve what did
246we do um what could account for those improvements and how can we replicate that as well and when we see that certain groups have declines we also want to do the same process as well um the elpi is our English learner progress indicator um and that is an indication of our English language Learners making progress towards English language proficiency um what you see is that we had a 6.2% drop in that and um on the surface of things that might be concerning um but when you dive into why that may have occurred um we also had a really high reclassification rate the previous year so what that means is a lot of those students who were making progress got reclassified and weren't taking the lpac summative test to show improve M because they were already
247reclassified so you have a little bit of a double-edged sword of your reclassification rate goes really high um because you're reclassifying students and they're making progress but then they're not tested anymore and um high percentage of our El students are long-term English language Learners um who have been in program for more than seven years um and that's a little bit more of a systematic problem and so but one of our answers and what we're trying to do is right back to what U Michelle presented is we're trying to provide that leveled curriculum to meet the needs of those long-term English language Learners in order to help them making progress so that's that's an area where we're trying to make those take those steps in order to improve the outcomes that we're seeing right now lcap
248goal number three um focused on um a lot of our climate and our safety um around student students um and we have seen and you saw it from colfax's presentation it's it's mirrored in our our results and our outcomes partway through this year in that our suspension rate um is improving it's going down our tendance rate is going up um and maybe a little little mix on the school connect connectedness um but it's fantastic actually to see that um from this year nth graders um in have a 3% increase on their school connectedness meaning that that transition from 8th grade to nth grade we know is very hard into a new system into high school um but they are feeling connected which is fantastic and our our 11th graders stayed flat um they didn't go
249down so we're maintaining that um but we are always trying to look for ways to um increase our connectedness to our students at our schools and I'm going to hand it over to uh principal dport um to talk about my do thank you so um as you can see from the numbers goal 2 is pretty small and part of that uh does come from the fact that our mvca teachers do get to participate in a lot of the professional development um and other resources is tied to CBE which is goal two um so as you can see the majority of our spending does fall in goal one and goal three I'm not going to go into a tremendous amount of detail um I think hopefully many of you can make it to the learning walk
250on the 28th for my do and I'll get a lot more or myself and Dr um Kristen Miller will get more down and dirty on what what we are who we are and where we're going um but I think you'll see here that a couple things I'll just highlight um CTE pathway and course offerings we realized a few years back that we have a charter renewal coming up and um it's pretty big deal and so with that one of the things is we had to take a look at um our CCI data and at that point in time Mau didn't offer any CTE specific courses or Pathways so we have now added uh two current and we have uh two more I think three more on the docket um again I won't go into what
251those are exactly but we do expect that our CTE pathway complet our numbers as well as our CCI will go up as a result next slide uh the other thing just to keep in mind I think when you look at Ma's data is just to remember that we are not a comprehensive we're an alternative education program and so um almost 50% slightly below that about 45% of our entire student body are in what is called our pep program program personalized education PL planner program and they come to us and they go into that program typically because they struggled in a traditional setting um so it's hard to make the comparison but they're often a student who could go to Mau but for whatever purpose and reason an online environment is better for I said might
252Confluence um is better for them and so when you look at some of our data yeah 7% a to G is not great but I think if you look over to the far right we're making progress and improving in that area and then the other thing that we did a deep dive uh when we presented to the board geez feels like it was forever ago November December um which I think only two of you at the time were there um and we looked at our math and 70% of Juniors who were taking the math um Casp test 70% of them had just come to Mau that year so it's really not a reflection of our school our teacher our students um so just a couple data points to keep in mind but I think as
253you see us making our shift into an early college program you're going to see a lot of this data um shift as well next slide I think that's it so just as a reminder this is a this is an update we will be rehashing a lot of this um in May and June um when we are looking at the final numbers and final metric numbers um for our lcap um but if there are any feedback or any questions um I'd be happy to to talk about any of the 151 metrics that we track what are your favorite metcs top five favorite turn on that well let's see actually uh the ones the ones that show all green and all increasing uh two of them stand out um student participation in dual enrollment yeah all subgroups
254increased their involvement in dual enrollment AP or IB course offerings um and another fantastic one that stood out was um our cast scores our science scores every single subgroup that we are tracking um improved awesome so two little extra highlights so as for the new people the lcap is like a it's a compliance thing to show where the the funds that are allocated for goals for reaching goals and it's all the metrics to prove that money's being spent properly yes and some people who may love the lcap would say that it is more of a continuous Improvement uh process and not compliance uh but uh we we understand the reality um of this document and that there's a desire for it to have what they call readability um it is hard to do that um
255in its current form um but we do our best job um within our within our collaboration of all of our departments and sites um to make it as readable and as transparent as possible um for you all and for our public this gets submitted sorry this gets submitted to the county the state federal so this particular document the update does not get transferred approved by anyone um it's just informational and update um our lcap um we do have coordination collaboration with pccoe and after you all approve it um it goes to pcoe to also approve it and it stays at that level sweet yeah thank you so much dat yeah this is so this is so much work and I and I appreciate um all that all that you are doing and and collaborating with
256staff to make this happen it is cumbersome and I hope that the drowning and documents legislation and the other things that are happening in the background will help to make this a little bit easier uh process um and that they hold hold these agencies accountable who are creating these cumbersome duties for you um that you'll have some relief some respit so thank you appreciate it so prior to you Trent had to do all this I tried to stay away from it as as much as I can El is a four-letter word fourl word thank you appreciate it all right we're going to go ahead and move to item 10.3 respect committee board presentation by Miss Elena delabo yes so um the as Robert just reviewed the three lcap goals the third goal is um a
257healthy safe engaged um environment for our students and one of the things that the board um was really we had heard a lot about the student voice since we just recently had one um that uh that was where the board members of that period of time had sat and listened to the students who voiced lots of concern about bullying type of behaviors that were happening on the campuses with that they then developed the goal that they wanted to increase um staff training in regards to um how to um address bullying type of behaviors that were happening on the campuses within the classroom so some of the types of um behaviors that the students had identified was bullying hate speech um they reported that they didn't um they didn't report it to staff um and that
258staff didn't always overhear it it would that individuals that were doing these behaviors would do them in a an environment that would be not where staff were readily available to hear these um statements and that there was a lack of understanding of the different cultures that are a part of our community and our schools so um the committee is made up of an administrator from each of the school sites as well as um Rhonda Kim and Carrie and I to help address US developing staff training type of activities for each of our school sites um what we started with was We did an evaluation um to see a survey very popular thing this tonight comment about surveys so we did do a survey I will say that the lack of results once again when you
259don't get everybody's participation it does change um it limits your ability to interpret the data but what we did discover from the data that there was a disconnect between how students were feeling and staff's perceptions of how students were feeling about being safe on campus how much of these behaviors were being um were happening and teachers identifying that they were more than willing to have more training in these areas so this year um this is a this is last school year what did we do so we really want to try to see how this um Can trickle down to our our students not just our staff and so we spent last year really looking at how can we do this but what can we bite off and do at the same time so um there
260was in so at the end of last year we did do inservice presentations on our quality schools day our March inservice day that surrounded the topic of um just how do we connect with our students how do we hear what they're seeing what is their perceptions that type of um training then we move into this school year and what we've done um is really focus on how do we um provide reasonable trainings in a limited amount of time when there's a lot of other things going on such as training for um CBE uh in practices all those different things and make sure that teachers could walk away with something um so we've been working on that through and we started um at our inservice day in October um chunking out a piece of that day
261that each site looking at their culture of their School site what their needs are and what the feedback they were getting from their staff were focusing their training we were doing a unified training across all the school sites but it was it was um it was taken from the overall umbrella and then focused for that culture and what those individuals and what they felt their needs were so in this March in service day once again um at the very beginning of the school of that day 45 minutes has been set aside for us to focus on um this topic again and every month during staff meetings or every other month during staff meetings they've been providing what we hope are takeaways things that you can use but in a small very short window of time
262um because we're taking it from staff meetings and um so this March um in service day the focus is how do we um develop Norms in the classroom how do we develop upstanders meaning how do our teachers how do our staff it's not just for teachers it's for all staff um we have included other staff in these trainings our classified staff our other certificated staff and how do we have them demonstrate these behaviors while increasing their awareness that these things are happening on the campus um and um so that is going to be the focus of the 45 minutes of um time that has been allotted and it will be site based so each site will be gathering their own staff together they took and they all worked on the same training but then they're
263um focusing it for their School site and so the whole focus is just to provide quick resources something that teachers can take away certificated staff classified staff how can they participate in this um how can it be engaging how can it be self- sustaining how do we make sure that this doesn't isn't a one and done that it's something that becomes a part of the culture of the school sites um allowing the ownership from the employees include all employees and have a whole a long-term systematic change that will support students involvement and learning as well thank you so much we have any is there any data that shows how successful this is for many teachers when they take something with them and impact kids in the classroom so that was just started this school year
264and we haven't gotten to that part of it um we will red be looking at another survey down the road of like what was the most helpful how could we better support them how has it impacted your classrooms um but again our time is limited and so it hasn't been um as focused as maybe what we would like to it for it to um go into and are the teachers given you any feedback verbal feedback in terms of I know you haven't done a survey but wow this really was working so I because it is being provided on the school sites by the administrators I would really have to um ask them for that information and what kind of feedback I know that what they tell me is all positive and that there it has
265um had a lot of conversations that have started and a sharing and questions really positive feedback um would you mind coming up to the microphone my apologies exactly right we had really great feedback Casey Warden our assistant principal LED our first fall um respect committee lesson and she's an excellent facilitator first of all and you kind of need that in this topic because you're you're addressing high stress issues right like classroom behaviors and challenging situations and she just did an amazing job of of connecting with teachers um she also made it light and fun and had a game associated with it and it just um I think the the mini doses are also really good because then you can continue to keep offering them throughout the year um because we have a lot of heavy
266things on our plate anyway so you you know don't want to hit too hard as we're trying to do other big lifts so um we had really positive feedback our staff um it valuable I have a question yeah this I'm looking at the uh survey from uh 2425 it was a link on your presentation that survey was I'm pretty sure is from 23 24 but it's linked in my presentation from that year yeah that's the one where you saw that discrepancy between what yes teachers saw and students I was curious there was like 35 students that took the survey that's that was what I was saying it was and this is not a typical I think of surveys if it's not an interest level if it's not something and our we did ask them to
267send it out multiple times and so we'll continue to work through that and just an email to students it was an email directly to students G given to them for the survey and our teachers we had a low number of of staff and and teachers that completed it and that is what drives some of it some of the information like the disparity between H perspectives also comes from our chick survey um that is another way that we've gained some information is there any uh discussion about I mean I love a good survey because it's data right but I mean 35 kids it's like oh was there any discussion about uh ways to get more student involvement absolutely we actually brought in all our activity directors and had them meet with us we also went back
268to the committee saying hey how do we better do this but this year we focused on the many doses and um these trainings that we set up and we T discussed in the future how we might um get another survey out thinking more towards the end of the school year in the sense that now that we've done some of the training versus before the training ever occur good comparison I mean what if teachers I mean all these students have Chromebooks right and they just are they bringing them to class most days yeah it it be take five minutes this doesn't take long there's like so you know the we did discover along the way too that the ones that we did get a higher not I think that might be one site it wasn't all
269the sites together that you're looking at so it's all the sites together we had more than 35 students the ones that we were able to get the teachers on board and now that we've provided them these um many lessons and we've set aside time they're they too may feel a stronger connection to having the survey completed um so those that did um sit down and say okay we're going to take 15 minutes and do this survey we did have a higher rate of completion yeah for still did great they had 82 students out of like that's like half yeah yeah yeah I don't know just you know given the cell phone policies I'm sitting here I'm like how how could we get more involvement you know or a reward at at the end of the
270um at the end end of the class and have a a QR code and and maybe it's a contest between the school site who has the most participants and their you know intervention block and they scan it and handle business so that we can get some more information that might be um a fun what works fun way what works with students these days as incentives to like take a fem minute survey um I mean like during our intervention blocks which are on Mondays now um I mean we have like detailed presentations where like we have the principal challenge for example so having like a reward is always something that's a good incentive I think so I'm not sure how you could do that on a schoolwide basis but we'll find a way Del de great
271too they had almost yeah it's like legit yeah I would say even just like a piece of candy can motivate high schoolers honestly survive yep nope I'm all for that right on thank you it's a really important topic so thank you very much Elena one more question so these materials that hopefully one teacher will find useful and take away is it primarily on the grading you said grading I was talking about how our time is caught up with all these other different um topics that we are addressing during staff meetings and so grading being one of those topics so 15 minutes it's a no it's a walkway of like strategy of like what Norms to put in a classroom or how to address this um this happened how do you address it in your classroom
272those types of things with strategies and so we're still working on all these mini lessons and they're implementing them in their um staff meetings but they only set aside about 50 you know our staff meetings are 45 minutes to an hour and so they're setting dedicating time to it but it is limited amount of time um so we're trying to do our best I mean our all of our staff have to do a PS uh through our um training online training they do a bowling um training already but this one is much more what our hope is that it's with takeaways something that they can immediately imple Implement in their class right away yes thank you very much okay thank you all right last of the staff reports item 10.4 student outcomes update thank you
273Trent yeah uh so I'll try to get through this pretty quickly we punted this last time due to time so uh yeah we're going to talk about student outomes board uh really important information here stuff that we could really celebrate as well uh this is the 2024 dashboard info just to kind of give you a brief uh background especially since we have some new board members uh the dashboard provides uh information to the communities regarding the effectiveness of schools and how well they're doing uh in these areas right here academic performance academic engagement and conditions and climate so in academic performance you will have the ESC test the E progress uh which is they take the elpac test uh College and Career indicator uh the cast which is the California science test academic engagement is
274based off of your graduation rate and condition in climate is is based off suspension rate since we are a high school district we do not have data on attendance or chronic absenteeism like uh schools with elementaries do I do just want to point out also that there are some interesting understandings about the numbers that you have to really understand in the dashboard before you look at them because uh typically for example when we talk about our esack scores we talk about percentage of met and exceeded the dashboard does not provide that same detail what they look at is uh they calculate the average beyond the lowest score for met so they take all the scores of the students add them all up and they average it out and so they will give you a number
275um distance from the average score distance from the standard met which is a completely different Dynamic than looking at just just how many students were met or exceeded and I say that because you can look at say for example Even in our own School District um El or the U ELA test for esac deloro I believe is the color green which is the you know second to the best uh and and I believe kfax and for still might be blue it's it's in the next slide but Delo actually had uh much higher percentage I don't know about much higher percentage but a higher percentage of those students being um met or exceeded the difference was that uh kfax grew at a much higher rate from the prior year so a lot of the the the
276metrics that the dashboard takes into consideration is not only the current outcome but how much it changed either increased or decreased over the following year and I'll show you a 5x5 here in a second that's uh gives you some detail about how that looks um so there is some information about that other numbers that are just a little bit confusing is for example esac covers Juniors but CCI and some of the others are seniors suspension rate is for everybody so there's always some numbers that you just kind of have to wrap your head around to understand what it's actually uh giving you data about uh the CCI just so you know the college career indicator is the number of graduates meeting a criteria that includes a tog CTE de uh C Career Technical education dual
277enrollment passing an AP and IB test and uh ESC so if you get if a student gets a tog they need something else so they need a CTE pathway they need a dual enrollment course they need an AP test they need a good score on the ESC to be considered um College and Career ready if a student gets a CTE pathway they need a du and class or adg or a good score on the sback to be considered uh College and Career ready you going to get two dual enrollment classes if you pass two dual enrollment classes you'll be considered College and Career ready pass two AP courses or if you pass both ESC courses that's how that those numbers are identified for the College and Career indicator one other note with that and why
278we have such high numbers compared to a lot of other districts and when again I was at the California high school Coalition meeting talking with other High School Districts they wanted to know why our numbers were so high and one of the reasons our numbers were so high is because a couple years ago when the uh dashboard first came out the directive and and accepted by our principles was that all of our students should fall into one of those categories our expectation is to get to 100% of our students being College and Career indicated uh going through that process now it's a lofty goal our counselors who I think we still have one nope she left good for her um our counselors um have done a great job of really identifying and figuring this out
279uh the fact that 85% of students at deloro have met this is is really indic uh indicative of that work and the other schools are not that far behind him as well so some really good work there graduation rate is percentage uh graduated uh suspension rates how many students were suspended at least once it it's not duplicated so it's just a single any student gets suspended they they get lumped in there whether it's in-house or uh at home suspension uh and it also measures demographic data for each of our special groups special groups are usually determined by an in number meaning they have to meet a minimum number so typically it's 30 if we have less than 30 it won't show a color for us it'll just give us some some data um some sometimes
280not any data if it's less than 10 because they don't want that uh information to identify students for example so that is the info that it shows go ahead and click to the next slide uh why is this important uh this is I I mentioned this prior when we were talking about CBE this is how uh we are judged both at the state and at the federal level and um the state makes laws the federal government makes laws both about education and because we get money from the federal government uh the state of California say this is what we're doing and then the Department of Education will say well no you have to do this this and this as well and so the state says okay if we want to continue getting that money we
281have to make some adjustments and so uh we've got a sort of an interesting system here so we have they've tried to mail them but they're actually two different systems so the state really focuses in on the learning or the local educational a agency which is the district um and uh if you are not meeting your numbers in the way that have been identified by the state you get it placed in something called differentiated assistance which is what we're in uh so as Robert was talking about the lcap and what we have to do every time that we're put into something like this we have to spend a lot of time discussing how we're um identifying uh the cause and what we're doing to remediate the cause for these reasons uh this past year last
282two years will be in it for our students with disabilities um for both academic outcomes and suspensions and um most districts fall into that same category as well um if you if it continues multiple groups and multiple years you could be placed in something called intensive intervention but the state hasn't really outlined what that looks like and what that means the county offices get quite a bit of money for being involved in this so they get millions and millions of dollars that are set aside for them to uh oversee differentiated assistant programs and so uh we have to work with them and make sure that we're meeting what they're requiring of us on the federal side this is more for schools we fall into something called comprehensive support and Improvement we known as CSI or
283targeted support and intervention or additional targeted support and intervention uh CSI we in as most School schools uh school districts are in for our alternative Ed program our continuation school um I don't know of a local school that might not be in it I think maybe Rockland um Victory might not be in it but uh it is something that we do get money for in the last couple years we've gotten over $100,000 to help um you know improve our outcomes we have made some changes to get out of it it's based off your three-year graduation rate um and so we're slowly climbing out of that and hopefully uh next year we'll be able to to get out of it of course the money is nice because they give you a lot of money it's it's
284kind of one of those uh sort of bad incentives I think sometimes is like oh you're not doing well but we'll give you money and so um you kind of start to rely on that money uh TSI and atsi are based on student group performance so we've had a number of schools uh that have fallen into a atsi or TSI based off of say for example students with disabilities or um English language Learners sometimes I think kfax was in it last year for students of two different races so whatever those identify markers are um basically it says if you have a student or if a student group is in all red or orange categories they get placed in that um so we take a look at that because it does create a some extra work
285and eventually it will also trigger some other more uh intrusive Elements by the state and the county office so uh go ahead and click it one more time um this is the grid if you wanted to look at the dashboard this is the grid that uh determines the color so if you see that top row going across that is the change from the prior year the uh the vertical uh column is its current status so this is our current grid for ELA uh you can see Delo in the green uh kfax and force tiller in the blue um the big reason is because Forest Hill and uh kfax both increased in those scores and uh that's why they're they're in the blue whereas I think deloro might has slightly took a dip back yep any
286questions on the grid so um just so the board's aware this is not a measurement of where you are maybe in relationship to another school it's how you've improved or decreased so you could potentially be blue which is looks really good um on the dashboard because your dial is all the way over to the right but you could have just increased significantly your scores could still be terrible so just meas your Delta that's right yeah and Delta and current yeah so so it is it is a little deceiving if you start comparing it to other schools uh go ahead and click so I'm just going to go through these real quick if you have any questions this is our academic performance please look at the dashboard it's online if you typed in Google California dashboard
287and then you typed in plaster County you'll have um a full look of the site um but I just threw these on there and I just indicated which groups uh were in student or were in the red or orange so for ELA students with disability our English Learners and our long-term English Learners are in that category for math students with disability long-term English Learners English Learners homeless and socioecon uh socioeconomic disadvantage sorry I can't speak it's past my bedtime CCI we had none in there and then our uh English language Pro uh progress was our ltels as well so you could probably start to hone in on some patterns of the student groups that are falling in those categories go ahead and click the next slide suspension rates um again these are just some highlights
288of our suspension rates our socioeconomic disadvantage students we had 9.6% of them we suspended that's out of the 1100 students uh socioeconomic disadvantage students we have in our district um so that's probably around you know 990 100 or so you ever take um our foster youth uh we only had 16 but it declined by 88.6% so we'll take that as a win um and our students with disability uh we had 11.4% and uh that's out of 500 students uh we before prior to covid we were 4.1% which is pretty good um after Co we had some dramatic increases last year we were at a 5.1 as kofax and I and I think the other schools it feels like I'd have to ask Kim and the principles but it feels like we will have a lower
289number again this year um because we're just not suspending as many students so that's good um any questions on suspension rates okay graduation rates were were obviously really uh high in this 96% of our students are graduating but it is important to note that Hispanics uh in and and our schools um have a pretty big gap so it's about uh 8% less than our white students and other students like that so they declined 1.1% so it's something that we need to take a look at uh homeless students uh 89% of our our homeless students are graduating also a concern because we want to make sure we get those kiddos across uh and uh they declined by 2.8% our homeless students increased by 50% in their graduation rates any questions on graduation rates then then again
290I'm just going through the individual School sites um and and listing any groups that were in um the red or orange and you could see those uh through there again uh a few here and there and if we do have any it's usually s swd s um homeless as well and sometimes uh El students so that's essentially our dashboard again please take a look at the dashboard if you have any specific questions please reach out um again I feel really uh Happy of the work that we've done as a district for our sites when you look at the numbers uh we farare really well to um some of the best school districts in in the state thank you so much thanks all right we're going to go ahead and move to item 11 public comment
291on non- agendized items I do have one blue card but you are not required to fill out a blue card if you want to share something with the board um this is a time for members of the public to address the board regarding items not on the agenda speaking of the blue form it's preferred but not mandatory and this form can be obtained at the meeting I think it's near the front door in the interest of conducting a public meeting in a timely manner uh individual speakers will be allowed three minutes to address the board with no more than 20 minutes per topic this is a comment period only the law California Education Code section 35145 point5 does not allow the Board of Trustees to take action on any item not explicitly posted on the
292agenda in advance the board values public comments and wishes to convey that although board members cannot take action on items that are not on the agenda they listen carefully and appreciate and value input from the public all right with that Barbara Smith round two good evening again um I just like to point out that just like holding special meetings and inconvenient times with limited advanced notice is very similar to having public comments at the end of the meeting when most of the public is gone it's a way to limit participation and manipulate the outcome but I digress in December I came before this board and asked trusty Jeff to step down in addition to his dishonesty about the nature of his campaign I pointed out that voters were not aware of the full facts of
293his termination from this District he was dishonest with his opponent and us when he claimed that if he were elected he would not serve we have since learned that according to the California Commission on teacher credentialing Mr jeffy's teaching credential was revoked on January 19th 2025 for quote immoral conduct or persistent Defiance of or refusal to obey laws regulating duties there is no end date listed for the suspension as a currently credential teacher I can tell you how difficult it is to have a credential revoked at the last regular meeting a retired administrator and esteemed Community member felt it necessary to resign from his position on an advisory committee he spoke eloquently about the failure of this board to insist that Mr Jeff resign and the dangers of implicitly condoning Mr Jeff's actions he could
294not have stated it more plainly we expect Integrity honesty open communication and transparency from those who hold leadership positions in our community board president Spade cited those very traits as necessary for a superintendent how can this board accept less of itself M if Mr Jeff will not act ethically it's up to you as his fellow board members to demand it the legitimacy and intent of this board suspect as long as trusty Jeff remains a part of it thank you do we have any further thank you come on down nice to see you Justin thank you nice to see you as well president's made I was actually not up I just like to come to the meetings I wasn't planning on speaking but uh it's kind of an awkward position but um the public says that
295they're here for the students and I thought it'd be good to have a student come up here and just say my perspective uh Mr Jeff has been nothing but kind to me and the other students of Delo you don't see teachers here you don't see uh students here you don't see people that are uh getting to work with him actually um have a voice here miss Jeff uh is his wife and she's one of the most favorite teachers at deloro I've never had her but i' hear from so many people how amazing she is just a really great family again I wasn't like going up here to speak I wasn't planning on it but um I think it's important to know that uh if you're in it for the students you're in it for the
296new board I uh previously uh prior to the new board uh I brought my ideas up and I was laughed at so I'm very grateful um trusty Duncan is another great great representative um I've been able to work with him since fourth grade uh being on track and um helping out with all that stuff uh I think that he's an amazing man and uh president Spade uh wished me a happy birthday I've never heard of a president of the board do that and have such personable relationships haven't been able to work with uh trusty Underwood as much but I'm sure that you are here for the students and I appreciate that trusty Lake I've also known forever um another great family and uh I just really want to bring up that I'm a student of
297phsd I go to deloro high school I'm super involved I've been able to work with these trustees and if the public is truly in it for the students they will realize the students are with trusty Jeff the students are with President Spade the students are with trusty Duncan trusty Lake and the rest of the phsd board so I uh like I said I wasn't planning on coming up here but I appreciate you guys for your time and uh just hope that that was a little good Insight thank you thanks Justin thank you very much Justin appreciate you all right um we're going to go ahead and move to item 12 Board calendar uh coordinating announcement this is a new topic and I just thought it would be a good way to kind of round out
298although we're not quite adjourning yet I'm sorry guys uh you know to just make sure that we're all on the same page with things calendared between now and the next meeting and so I compiled does not mean that I didn't miss something but I just wanted to let you guys know kind of what's going down the pike uh tomorrow uh morning uh the district has paid for a training it's a zoom training with dwk regarding the brown act um I'm unsure if everyone's able to attend but I do believe that they're going to provide some materials or something or to be able to watch you should have already gotten an email and you can log on from your own everyone should be good beautiful yep so and that runs tomorrow morning from 8:30 to 12
299and uh again I think key topics are important uh they're going to be reviewing um the brown act for new officials 202's modifications to the brown act our favorite rules of the land key provisions of the brown act before a board meeting and during the board meeting also February 25th next week on Tuesday the plaster Helman Showcase in elcap is going down at 5:30 and um uh Dr Davenport also alluded to our learning walk at Mau virtual Charter Academy on the 28th from 9:30 to 11:30 so a slight time shift for that learning walk as well and um on March 5th we have a student engagement all of these should be your your calendar but just so that in case you're not following it um and then we have a student engagement at deloro on
300March 12th and then um Dr cetti also mentioned the quality Schools in service on the 14th and I do think that it's a great opportunity for the board usually this is a time where the entire board goes together um at least if for the beginning you may not stay for the entire thing I normally cannot but um we go and we're there for the opening and uh some of the presentations you can go into some of the trainings I think it's a great time to be able to connect with staff so I would encourage uh participation with that and then our next regular board meeting is Tuesday March 18th now there could be a special meeting you never you never can tell and the law allows it so if if that changes please know that
301we will do our best to get the information out as quickly as possible uh moving forward is there anything else announcements or correspondents that the board has okay with that we're going to go ahead and recess back to close session again thank you for hanging in there tonight you guys are great we'll be back I love it e e e back from our recess at 10 more did you say 46 uh we have a couple items to report out item 3.2 um we took a vote uh to the board approved a final settlement agreement and release of claims for a special education student we had a first by uh trusty Duncan a second by trusty Jeff and the vote was unanimous moving to oh Lord have mercy thank you uh oh all that do I
302need to do that again with my mic on okay all right um and item 3.5 um the board gave direction to staff uh to counter a settlement and that was not a formal vote it was just a direction by majority and I believe that is all for my report out guys keeping me on track guys I think that's it all right we're going to go ahead and move to item 13 adjournment do I have a motion motion to adjourn second we have a first by trusty Duncan a second by trusty Lake all in favor say I I I I'll oppose good night thank you guys