CorpusRecord 41140

PUHSD Regular Board Meeting 1.21.25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Placer Union
Date
2025-01-22
Location
Placer County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
33,825 words · about 188 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e can you hear me now all right uh welcome uh back we're going to do a quick report out from Clos session uh just as a reminder this meeting is being audio and video recorded welcome um housekeeping we have restrooms available uh during the Open Session across the hallway and the Gold Country media room so should you need it that's over there across the parking lot uh close session report out items uh during 4.1 reconvene we have item 3.1 readmission of expelled student 0711 CW 2324 um do I have a motion for the readmission of expelled student 3.2 one and just as a reminder um trusty Lake you have to press your microphone it'll go green trusty Underwood trusty Underwood would you also turn on your microphone as well green perfect there we

002go do I have a motion for item 3.21 readmission of expelled student I'll move to readmit have a first agree and a second we have a first and a second on item 3.21 readmission of expelled student 0711 CW 2324 all in favor say I I I I'll opposed hearing none uh motion passes unanimously item 3.3 the board discussed in the first case um and unanimously provideed direction to council and staff in the second case for 3.3 uh conference with legal council regarding anticipated uh litigation uh the board also discussed and unanimously provided direction to council and staff item 3.4 Public Employee discipline dismissal release pursuant to government code section 5 4957 the board approved an unpaid leave request per the collective bargaining agreement CBA and education code 45195 and last but not least of our

003report outs 3.5 conference with real property negotiators government code section 54956.9 the board gave direction to staff to counter the offer all right we are going to carry on here uh with the organization item five welcome and Pledge of Allegiance um trustee Underwood you would you lead us in the pledge I'll be happy to right I pledge aliance to the of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with Li and justice for all all righty welcome to the meeting tonight we've got a Full House it's nice to see you all and our student trustees everyone's here tonight um this again this m uh meeting is being audio and video recorded item 5.2 approval of the agenda the board at this time shall take action

004to provide to approve the agenda do we have any changes to the agenda at this time not including consent I move approval a first second uh we have a first and a second on item 5.2 approval of the agenda all in favor say I starting with our student board I I board hi hi all opposed hearing none motion passes unanimously item six superintendent report and showcase item 6.1 thank you madam President we will go ahead and get started with our first round of showcases tonight with principal jamy Jackson and staff will is going to update us on plaster and confluence good more or evening board I almost said good morning so used to it um I have some things for you first before I get started so present thank you thank you they match the

005slide thank you thanks Jer you're welcome green and gold green and gold one to share thanks so yeah I think we brought half your audience today so um just a quick introduction of of who's here for pler we are um going to present both plaster and Confluence tonight as I get the opportunity to be the principal of both so just to share a little bit of who's here so I have my assistant principal team of Casey Warden Courtney Doland and Jeff Walters in the back we have our Hillman instructional leadership team we have Shauna Stafford Jeff James Trenton Deacon and we are missing one tonight from our hman um instructional leadership team Jason long who's in busy in drama Productions and and all of that and then we also have half of our Confluence staff

006or well two-thirds of our Confluence staff we have Melanie Hall and we have Joey as well and then we have um Diamond Thomas who's here Joey Walker am I missing anyone no okay um so you have the T-shirt you have in front of you is a first for us um in terms of a change this year to pler we wanted to set pler up differently as far as our welcome back so instead of a traditional back to school night this year we had a welcome night for our family so intentionally invited our um our parents and Guardians as well as all their siblings to join in the fun about you know what plaster is all about unique to that night we had um feedback from our staff that our parents weren't necessarily going all the

007way up to autoshop to check out what's happening up there it's a big campus and if you haven't had an opportunity come by we'll give you a tour it's it's a gorgeous campus but it's big and so instead of having everyone go out to their rooms we centered ourselves in the middle of Campus we um Crystal than um to her and her staff provided food for our families and I think the Highlight for me was our teachers who volunteered to give campus tours and straight out of Disneyland with the little flag to follow them through campus and it was a really great opportunity CU not a lot of our parents have actually toured in that way to go see our gym and the Earl crab gym and it was really wonderful the theme of this

008year is about plas our presence being present um at our events on campus at our games in your classes being engaged in your learning and so a lot of what you'll see on our slideshow today is the efforts that we're putting into making sure students are understanding the importance of being present and I have to give it a shout out to chrisly my amazing admin assistant because it's hard to pick a theme and she's good and she helped with this and on the back you'll see um just a nice quote coming and going on the shirt right of um live every moment before it becomes a memory and so hopefully our students are making lots of memories this year so let's go to the next one so some big initiatives this year for us um

009you know with our efforts of full implementation of comp compeny based education we knew we needed a strong instructional leadership team and this team is amazing um every week our Hilt team meets with our admin and we go over what are we seeing from teachers in the classroom how are we supporting them um Jason long he is our instructional integration specialist which really means he's focusing on the tech support needed so the area support the how to pull um data sheets so that um the teachers could organize their proficiency scale data more efficiently and um and really worked on helping organize our professional development opportunities so our plc's our professional development days those um um opportunities where we're bringing our staff together our hman instructional leadership team has also been amazing in helping us support

010our was progress this year because we are in a wasque accreditation year so we have lots of projects s going on with that to get ready for our team they are coming to visit our campus on um February 24th 25th and 26 so lots going on and we're excited to share that with our our visiting team um our admin team has done a huge lift in the instructional minutes um component um a big piece of this is the cell phone policy implementation we rolled it out at the very beginning of the school year it needed some tweaking we had a little bit of I think gray area where it wasn't work wasn't as effective as it could have been and so we tightened things up to start the spring term and we've had really amazing

011feedback and I'll let Miss Warden speak to to some of that um because she's had a big a big lift in that we removed our vending machines which I thought would create a lot more controversy and you know we have a unique campus we have an open lunch so maybe that's why we're not hearing a lot but it has sure avoided a lot of unnecessary trips out of class and it's nice to walk classers campus and see just during instructional time you don't see students out as much anymore and um so that's been a big help and then we have two in um student intervention Specialists we have Barry and Chris who you know kids call by their first names and and are really creating relationships with students but also making sure they're part of

012our admin team and helping support students making good choices we have a big emphasis on being present um during class and and during those passing periods so that um students see us out and about um I'm also going to let um our admin team speak to um the student advisory Council so I won't steal that lead but um that's been huge for us Ava has been excellent as a student board member to really um help us in our transition so this is my second year at pler but it's my first year as principal of Confluence and pler so we're trying to figure out this you know new system and Ava's done an amazing job at connecting with both campuses and trying to bring that student voice piece we have a new staff recognition um opportunity

013that has seems to have um really taken you know a positive effect on our staff they basically they get a gold pan and a gold bar filled with chocolates because who doesn't love chocolate and they recognize each other for great things that they're doing on campus and um so we have four different staff and it's all different staff that recognize each other and um it just becomes a really positive piece in our staff meetings that that we were kind of needing we were needing some some positivity and that has really helped we're continuing to build our campus culture and the um student connectedness because that's part of plas our presence and a big piece that our um activities director Carri Uno and Athletics Mike Sabin are helping us with is um keeping us informed of

014what's happening and some great um activities that you see listed there and then Confluence as a whole you know we're taking what has been kind of two separate campuses and our entire team of both staff are really trying to work with um and support each other and so we're um you'll hear in the the Confluence side of the presentation more about those efforts so um that's that's it for me and I'm going to let the whole rest of the team take take it okay okay next slide sorry my notes are up here all right hi I'm Jeff James I teach uh social studies at Plaster high and I serve as the um intervention advisory coordinator so I kind of oversee the program that allows students to schedule themselves during third block for the classes they

015need to uh retake tests in or get extra help in um so the um one of the tasks that I did in addition was um Shauna Stafford and I worked on the was report this year and wasque Reporting the was report has a lot of components to it and I was tasked with one piece of uh pulling out demographic data like Census Data uh about Auburn and um there were some findings through our our our community and our school that um just really kind of show that we have a a a very changing and diverse um student population at at pler High um some things that stuck out in the data were that are um e population which is it says 8.7 here I think this was from last year's currently at 8.9 and in

0162018 it was at 4.3 so that's a a so we've doubled our English Learners uh population and uh now nearly one in 10 of our students uh speak English as a second language um and we also noticed that our um Hispanic population has gone from um around a fifth 20% in 2018 uh to over a fourth now nearly a third 27 uh% um we've also seen um an increase in our seal population socioeconomically disadvantaged and we probably think that this is a undercount um because that now that California has a free lunch for everyone there's not really an incentive for parents to fill out the income reporting forms um which all of this is to say that we have a um a very diverse student body um we have multigenerational families that grew up in

017Auburn their parents went to school here here um and we have uh newly arrived families and we're all kind of building this uh this very unique and uh fun School culture together um our uh you know I think to to Testament to the teachers at our school and their enthusiasm though is is um our graduation rates our College and Career Readiness rates are still uh doing very well and we're in the blue on the dashboard for both of those and then one more slide over I can speak to that so um just real there's a lot of acronyms on here so s is socioeconomically disadvantaged s swd is students with disabilities which are uh essentially students with individual education plans or IEPs and then our Els are our English Learners um so at pler really

018we have an emphasis on all of the students regardless of their background having uh opportunities for these um classes and programs that set them up for success in their college or or career so we've seen um if you look at the the data here um in advanced placement and I'll start there we've seen a slight dip from 1819 to 2324 in our SED SE swd and El populations however we've seen a near uh doubling of participation in those populations in our dual enrollment classes and in our CTE pathway classes um in this year we've offered a a dual enrollment uh has an advanced credit uh grade bump so they get one GPA Point additional uh on their their transcripts and dual enrollment gives kids an opportunity to get those college credits um so we see

019a shift kind of towards that dual enrollment with all of our um populations and then um the last thing I I wanted to add is that this year we did um we are now a um Title One school because of our changing demographics so Title One means that are um at promise populations say sedel homeless uh populations have um passed a certain threshold that the the federal government now realizes or or notes us as a as a high need School population all right good evening um my name is Courtney doyan I'm an assistant principal at poer high school and I want to share a little bit about our graduation rate uh data for our students so in alignment with our lcap goal of being college and quer ready um plaster definitely has an emphasis on

020watching our students not just hit high levels of CCI but also to their graduation rates um our school has enjoyed a High graduation rate um since as you can see in the de the data tabled there since 2019 we've remained in the 90 percentile um for graduation rates for all students um one thing to note is that there has been an overall increase so we're at 95.8% and that again is for all students specifically though when we're looking at our demographics in our subgroups within Plass or high school um it's important to also see the successes there and also to the growth that we're experiencing so if you look at the data our s students um are actually in the blue and they're at a 94.8% rate which is really high it's almost equal to

021the all student population um we also have a um we've seen an increase in that area of 4.3% um since the um 2019 date as far as our s SW we've had a pretty impressive growth of 15.4% and then for our students experiencing homelessness um we actually have had a 99.1% increase but notable in is that that actually equates to 100% of our students in that category um graduated from high school last year um one thing to note though that we do have some areas of growth that we want to continue to support um for all of our students we did see in 2021 a decrease in our graduation rates for our El and Hispanic populations um however positive on that one is that while it went down to 66. 7% it's actually made an

022increase of 14 14% sense and so again we see that Trend data going in the right direction with some intensive and strategic interventions and that kind of brings me to the final point in terms of graduation rates is that really with the emphasis of class or being having our students be successful after they leave us um we have really strategic plans with our intervention schedule after school tutoring our our counselors do one-on-one counseling with those students we also have a lot of Outreach home to make sure that our parents are understanding things like it's specifically our English learner families of how do you check Aries how do you check where your students are at and and making sure that we're making those supports not just in the classroom not just in the counseling and administration

023offices but also to making sure that our parents are prepared to be able to support their students as well hi I'm Shauna Stafford and I teach nth grade English 11th grade English and um AP English Language and Composition I'm a part of the Helman instructional leadership team I partner with Trenton Deacon as one of the instructional leadership um curricul and instruction representatives for pler and I'm also on the wasque team um and happy to be here tonight presenting to all of you um for the next few slides I'll present the first couple and then we'll continue with Trenton we're going to present our state testing data so for those of you um that are a little bit newer to um learning about that it's the state test that students take through Elementary School all of

024middle school and then they only take it one time in high school their second semester of their junior year each year the results are captured on the dashboard um they're a part of our school report card the data is also shared with potential home buyers and community members who look at this data to see a snapshot of student learning um first I will discuss our ASPC results for the English um Department we're proud of our scores and also are working to continue to improve them you're going to hear over and over again that we have become a title one school so we're serving a larger population of socioeconomically disadvantaged students students with disabilities and English language Learners and as stated earlier um we are happy to be a diverse School with a population that varies

025um and we're really happy to highlight that even with all of these changes we have increased our aspect scores The pler English Department as well as the science and math departments have all used our intervention period strategically to communicate the importance of the test which we found is incredibly important because if a teenager doesn't understand why they're taking a test they will not take the test seriously um and to also meet with groups of students based on their need to help prepare prepare them uniquely with what they need to be prepared to do well on the test and then to share the incentives that the committee has made available to students The English Department has also worked to align our major assessments from 9th through 12th grade and our rubrics that so that students are

026experiencing the same expectation across our campus and then for science really um it's important to know that this team is led by Susanna gado who is phenomenal and Brilliant and um so I talked a lot with her to make sure that I was reporting out accurately um and so a few of the things that she shared while our students have been taking a science test for um state test for years this past year was the first year that the results for the cast test have been reported out over the past few years we have increased our scores as you can see by 14% one thing to keep in mind with all of these tests is that um juniors are only being tested their junior year so you're not comparing a student over time you're just

027comparing the students that are in front of you with the next group of students that are in front of you so fluctuation a little bit of fluctuation is to be expected um but a 14% overall increase since 2021 is definitely commendable um one highlight is the addition of the Global Science systems class this class covers more of the standards and the science team really believes it's making a difference in testing um Susanna shared that we we they're investigating the statistics to ensure that this change is resulting in students taking more science after their Global Science systems class um she said even if the asbc scores are going up overall we still want to ensure that students are experiencing labs and that they are well prepared for universities thank you right hello my name is Trenton

028Deacon and I'm one of the mathematics teachers at pler high school um so echine what Shauna has said about some of the fluctuations that you might see um our math scores um do show that overall we have increased since 2003 and specifically I'll highlight that our social um so social economic disadvantaged students have increased as well as a significant increase in our students with disabilities um within our math scores something important to note especially with the math scores is to notice that fluctuation is normal with these types of Assessments um as sea has said that our juniors are only getting tested in their junior year whereas in lower uh grades elementary school and middle school they're being tested every year so we're only getting a snapshot of this data um of these students now one

029thing to note is that this data for our math scores for our espc is actually comparable to our comparable schools in the area so they're seeing the same kind of fluctuations um with their scores if you look on the um esack dashboard um what uh is a little background about the esack for math specifically um it tests students on their state standards up through the state uh math requirement which is equivalent to Algebra 2 um for us that is our integrated math 2 Series um so we have a three series course integrated math one integrated math 2 and integrated math 3 um but to help with our um students that might require that extra support um we have a requirement here at PSD for three years of math requirement um but not all of our

030not all of our students um will necessarily go through the full integrated math series or go to pre-cal or calculus um so to help that at uh plashy we have actually um developed a few other uh Pathways for students to be able to complete the coursework to get through um what they would see potentially on an esac uh test we have had multiple sections over the last uh two years of um data science um and we also uh have built a career Math course which is kind of a snapshot of students being able to take a third-year math that aren't necessarily taking um a stem pathway so this will get them information that they would see in their future careers being able to use and apply that math um in ways that are relevant for

031them which they would see in an esack test being able to break down data look at charts um being able to pull out that relevant information um to help with that if I can have the next slide um we did develop a couple of um supports for our students to be able to prepare themselves not just for the integrated math series um but for all of their math uh classes um at pler um over the last uh year we did develop two uh supports for students that are incoming into the IM Series so we've got two supports one being an integrated math 1 prep course that would be for students that may have taken integrated math one already or weren't taking it in their first semester um at pler where it gives them foundational supports

032we use one of our uh curriculum tools Alex which is built into our math textbooks um that uh we've created a course where they can go get all the foundational work that they would need to be successful and not uh integrated math one um they're able to take that uh in addition to that we've also created a Readiness course for incoming nth graders that uh have the option of taking um during their uh first semester at pler or over the summer getting them uh ready for when they take that integrated math one first um to help with our uh students in integrated one we have a lot of students that um find math challenges so we have developed supports both within our uh intervention uh supports where teachers can call them in to get extra

033time on assessments get help with assessments review material um we actually had um this last term um starting in week 13 all of our uh im1 teachers at pler identified students that were on the cusp of passing versus having an incomplete and what we did is uh we had four different Math teachers um take some extra time on their prep um to be able to work with those students to make sure we could help Elevate them to that uh score of a c or higher um we actually of those students we had uh 12 students that ended up making it all the way up to a passing score and four continuing to work on incomplete um so in addition to that um uh we also were able to use some Title One funds to hire

034um six peer tutors that uh help students uh with math both in the morning and after school um to provide that additional support for students that might need help uh with their math classes thank you and we typically reserve some questions to the end but because you're there and I've got a couple and you mentioned Alex could you just explain to new board members what exactly that is yes sorry so Alex is a uh learning tool that we have in conjunction with our uh reveal math textbook uh the Alex program is a online learning platform where it adapts to students uh learning needs so they take an assessment at the beginning of the course it judges where they are in their math skills and provides them with targeted supports and instruction on specific tools that

035will help them wherever they're learning in their uh progress to completing whatever uh im1 two or three course they're in thanks welcome thanks my name is Chef Walters and um I'm one of the luckiest people in the world because I get to work with both pler and Confluence students every single day um I'm one of the aps on our campus and this the other diamic partnership um we're going to be splitting this slide and just kind of speaking the good news that is on our campus um lucky for me I'm actually getting to talk about exactly our Weekly Newsletter um which the team at pler is focused on really trying to get the word out and all the wonderful things that are going on so that our stakeholders are aware of what's going on on

036our campus uh this includes A Renewed focus on our Weekly Newsletter highlighting our programs uh at pler as well as the outstanding work being done by our students and our staff um to that point it also provides information and resources available such as before and after school tutoring our CTE showcase uh that is actually coming up um pretty pretty quickly that's being sponsored actually by our uh library and learning comment Tech uh which is going to be very cool our closing our clothing closet uh to also help as you saw uh our socially our our socioeconomically disadvantaged students as well as our safety presentations um in addition to that we also have our weekly counseling Corner um that is put together and sent out through parent Square notification by our counselors uh to let our

037families and students know about academic opportunities such as scholarships uh College and Career presentations and one-on-one counseling opportunities and our counselors do a phenomenal job of really meeting students where they are and trying to work with their needs to help them along in their process so good evening uh my name is Casey wax Warden and I'm another assistant principal here and I get to talk about student parent Guardian Community voice and support which is it's kind of my favorite so um one of the things I want to talk to you about is School site Council so for those of you that may not be familiar with School site Council it's a monthly meeting we have that brings our community members together so parents students staff myself as an assistant principal and then it's led by

038principal Jackson and this is an opportunity to come together and talk about kind of Title One budget what's going on um events happening in school it's a time for for them to ask questions and get information um the other thing that we've done is there's School site Council and then there's something called elac and elac is essentially it's kind of student site Council for school sitec for English language learner families and so what we've done is we voted to combine them and so our elac meetings and our School site Council meetings host together and so that's again a time for questions concerns information really keeping an openline in communication with families in our community which we we really prize at Plasser High School um in addition to the school site Council and elac combination we

039also have deac which is a district elac meeting and that's twice a year and that's where our e families come out twice a year um as a district and get together and talk about whatever issues learn about graduation rates or how to you know a through G things like that that are really important um and sometimes with our our like our Spanish speaking families could get lost in translation um the other thing I get to talk about is student advisory Council so um I get to lead student advisory Council this year and that is a group of students who have come together um I put into teachers asking them for nominations as students and these are kind of our unsung leaders you know they're not necessarily are typical leaders who are in leadership or in

040sports um it's a really diverse range of students that that come to our student advisory Council we meet bi-weekly and we come up with what we think we need to do for plor high school so for example our first meeting was I put out uh sticky notes everywhere papers and the students put what do you really like what's going well for class or high school what are our strengths what do you want to see different and do you have any bright ideas and this really great group of kids just came in with force and had all these great ideas and all these great um proposals our first semester we decided to focus on um a panel we were going to do a CB panel of questions and so we spent the entire first semester preparing

041and and getting questions ready and we were going to create a panel and now with the shift we've kind of shifted now this semester into what does it look like now and answering questions and we are working to to create our second spring project and kind of figureing out what that is and we're lucky enough to have Ava on our student advisor Council as well which is a great addition and great leadership so actually our next student advisory council is going to be Ava and principal Jackson and we're going to do a Q&A and that's going to be an opportunity for our these leaders these student leaders to kind of come out and say hey what is your opinion on this or what do you think about this as we start to brainstorm towards our

042spring project um these students were also invited to our lcap Community Forum which I'll get into later and they are just so excited to have the opportunity to come and give input so it's really been wonderful and getting to know these students and seeing them on campus um so on that note for our first student advisory Council we invited Confluence because Confluence is now our sister school right Diamond so we invited them and they came and I loved what they said their feedback was Miss Warden there's three of there's three or four of us and there was 30 plaster kids we didn't feel heard so I kind of chewed on that as a new assistant principal and that from there was born Confluence Council and so we decided to do a separate Council called Confluence

043Council which basically I meet I try and get over there bi-weekly I meet with the Confluence Council which is a group of Confluence student leaders who are amazing articulate passionate they have so much to say um and so for their project they wanted to do uh we were going to do we're doing a they're going to be presenting at a staff meeting and they're going to be talking about what a confence student is who are we what do we represent what some maybe a little piece of their story right these kids have these Amazing Stories and the one thing that they really really wanted that they were really clear about that we've been working on is inclusivity um that was their call and so we've been working on things like let getting them to come

044to rallies um what kind of events can they be involved in spirit days making sure that they have information of whatever is happening on the plaster campus that they're in the know as well and so we're trying to build inclusivity through Confluence Council and it's it's been really fun to to be able to go over there and work with the students that way and then is also getting involved there too so again another Bridge of our of our schools um so the other thing is the Helman foundation so Helman Foundation is a a group who sort of supports our programs who are outside the general fund so things like equipment or field trips when we when we have need the Helman foundation for years has shown up and been an amazing uh source of support

045for plaster high school and so we're really grateful to have a partnership with them as well as friends of Plass or high school who do a lot of our teacher appreciation like for example on January 6 the day we came back we had a minimum day they hosted a beautiful lunch so we're really grateful to have these supports outside in the community because people people love plaster high school plaster High School is not just a school it's a community institution and our community comes out very strongly for our school and we're really lucky for that um the other thing is uh the hman Showcase so kind of like what principal Jackson talked about in Fall about how we had the back to school night we're doing a Hillman Showcase in February and this is going

046to be an opportunity for our incoming Hillman to come and see the school meet teachers see programs get excited they're coming to pler high school this beautiful historic school we want them to feel welcome we want them to feel excited coming coming so that same night what we decided to do is fold our elcap community Forum into the evening so elcap is essentially our school's kind of plan our goals and so what we're going to do is that evening before the f activities start we're going to host the elcap Forum we're going to ask community members my student advisory Council students are super excited to come parents in the community to come and hear what the goals are and then we want feedback and so they're going to break up into different rooms and different

047groups to give feedback on these goals because plaster goals are Community goals um the other thing is uh feeder schools so it's it's January which as a former counselor that means it's time to start thinking about our our our babies coming up so one of the things that we're really trying to do is increase articulation with the middle schools because these are future Hillman they're really important we want them to feel welcomed we want them to feel informed and so we're doing a new thing this year which is we're going to do a hman onboarding where Miss Uno and I are hit in the road and we're going to go take student Leaders with us and we're going to go to different middle schools and visit them and just talk about all the opportunities of

048things that they can get involved with when they come to pler what are opportunities for them build excitement and also share School culture right how we treat each other at class or high school with respect and kindness so that as they come in we're preparing them to be Future Leaders um also we have eighth grade registration so the a little bit different is that the counselors will also go around to the middle schools and they're going to talk with the students about the classes that they can take they're going to help them register they're going to help them plan their future and their four-year plan and help them learn about the different Avenues CTE and dual enrollment and the different paths that kids can take as they come to PL or High School school and

049and lastly on that front is just feeder School data for incoming nth graders and essentially what that means is we want to learn as much about our students as they come in as possible right and so we are trying to increase our communication we're Gathering data from our stakeholders so that we can do early intervention with students that need it help supplement other students that might need that and make sure that we have the accurate picture of a students coming in so we can best serve them thank you thank you okay that's it for pler um had to highlight some fun teacher pictures from the year so far and and staff pictures um in particular my the highlight of fall for me was watching Joey Montoya and you can see him in his white hat

050there on the left yes thank you um I haven't seen that side of Joey Montoya my first year so to watch him lead a staff dance um your our head football coach coach lead a staff dance was just a highlight and you can see from Tracy Ro's face right there in the middle she is definitely enjoying it too so um our staff have fun they love being with students and that's what makes classer amazing so you know all of these data supports are just data they're not the people and these are the people that help them get you know on to the next chapter of their lives so very very proud of very of all of them okay any questions had like I need feel like I need like the tear away pants for like

051take my yeah right yeah is it okay if if the board has questions U related to plaster and then we can move into Confluence is that okay yeah sure any feedback on pler hi hi thank you for the presentation I really enjoyed it you guys I was Cur I was curious how the the schoolside council how that's attended School site Council I can answer that um since I lead that so the um monthly meeting that we have we have um uh we go through a formal process of nominations and then voting depending on their stakeholder group so parents nominate other parents then they vote on the the parents that came with the most amount of nominations and those um are selected to be the representatives anyone can attend a site council meeting those just become

052your voting Representatives so the students also nominated students voted on those students and then they become the representatives so and it's a meeting that's well attended would you say I would say the all of those that are members of site Council yes December maybe not so much because it was the last week in December but yeah I mean we we've moved because we are uh schoolwide title one we have to be very compliant with all of our site Council meetings so what has typically been maybe four site Council meetings in the past for pler is now monthly so it's more of an ask for our parents or Guardians and students and teachers but um but yeah no they they attend and then we have a few other regulars who didn't necessarily get voted in as

053voting members but they are interested and invested so they they show too it's great yeah then one other question about your cell phone policy I was curious about what that entails um so we we've always had a cell phone policy in our student handbook but we haven't had like the implementation plan of how are we going to make sure students are not on their cell phones during instructional time or using technology inappropriately so we have um what we did is we bought cell phone caddies and cell phone lockers for every teacher so whichever they preferred um we started that at the beginning of the school year we also then in the beginning of the school year left some leeway of for the teachers who said well I'm just going to have them keep it in

054their backpack that didn't work for us we saw a lot of students either um on their phones when we were observing classrooms or they would take it out of their backpack and walk to the bathroom and um and so they were on their phones during instructional time so what we did in January here is we shifted to um it's got to be in the phone or a phone Locker or the caddy and that's working it's working yeah awesome yeah yeah I mean teachers are very happy it took it took kind of that new fresh roll out right you get a new set of students let's start the policy right away hit the ground running um you know there's there's a sense of freedom for students as much as they're addicted to the phones that's also

055kind of nice to know I don't have to worry about because I can't see my phone right so um they don't have to worry about that social pressure of responding back or you know maybe they're in trouble because they didn't make their bed and someone's letting them know that morning right I mean we we're all you know guilty of it but so a student walks into the class and they just it goes into the box exactly and it gets locked up a lot of teachers take role by it so it's a quick check to see oh you you know you're here Emerson but I don't see your phone and it's quick to you know to put it away and yeah it's really helping I think the next step for us and you know you guys

056can correct me but um is really identifying for us that that 83 minute block is a lot of time and I think that we teachers have spent spent a lot of time kind of managing phones for a long time and now they're finding wow 83 minutes we could get a lot done you're almost having to over plan now from what you had in the past right so really like how do we effectively teach on a block and what are those instructional practices that we can start to like pick from each other so it's a schoolwide policy and all all uh teachers must yes comply yes and um big efforts huge huge thank you to our admin team because what we did is to really support teachers by going out in the classroom every single classroom

057was visited by our team to make sure that we're supporting our teachers because it's not easy to implement and um and so just having that extra support and and if they need to point at us and go they're making me do it we're happy to to do that you know we we had to really communicate with our families too though of like what are the supports families are used to being able to just quickly text their kid I'm picking you up I forgot you had a dentist appointment so now we're having to kind of retrain families of call the office we'll get them the message to come down to the office to be excused so there's a there's you know it's not smooth but it's working yes oh the instructional time and the you know

058engagement for students is is really worth it awesome thank you Jamie is there any uh news on the character education program going on at pler are you guys doing anything different or unique I would say a lot of it is being built into to the the intervention offerings that were we have I think activities has taken a big part of that in the inclusivity piece you know of um of that part I think that you know our student council is also a driver for us in character education of what are the pieces that our students are needing more support with and needing more Focus yeah we don't have a specific like program that we're continuing to we really as a pler staff heavily invested in the CBE implementation have you guys given any thought to

059picking a particular flag or one of your traits for a couple weeks and and kind of saying to the teachers you know if you can uh say something in your classes for a few minutes regarding uh say loyalty trustworthiness whatever the flag is yeah uh that would be kind of nice because it would be focusing on one particular trait you've already selected as being significant and having different teachers throughout the day saying something about that I think that could be a lifelong lesson they could yeah it's a great idea um One new change right for this year is that our advisory time where we would normally do some of those larger lessons um is now reduced to a shorter time on Mondays and it's been um great because we have four days of Intervention which

060means every class can have a dedicated intervention time my priority um it means our lessons have to we have to tailor them a little bit different because they're with they're with their teacher for a shorter period of time and some of the feedback from our staff has been I'm not as close with my advisory class as I was Prior when we had them for 40 minutes so some of those I think ideas would be good as far as helping staff get to know students and students get to know staff better m in that short period of time yeah I like it okay thanks Jamie um I think I remember when you came in as the new principal you wanted to to grow and build the capacity of your teacher leaders um in your Hilt team

061I think you knocked it out of the park with with uh Trenton and um Jeffrey and and and shaa and Jason um it just it was a good it was a good move it was a good addition I think whenever teacher um capacity is built in leadership it it tends to go really well and I think you start off great with with the team that you have and they're we're seeing the fruit of that with cell phone policies and academics and outcomes happening so yeah good job they're an amazing team they they definitely share all their thoughts right we meet weekly I am not afraid of being kept in the dark like we share all the things and I am so grateful for it because I don't feel like that I'm getting the nod of

062a head and something else happen with without me knowing they also I mean when we did this process last year it was that anyone can submit their interest in those in being part of this team and then we met with each of them and talked about like here's what it's going to look like next year just to make sure it was the right fit for them and for our our team and um and of course they were the right fit but they also understand the importance of this of teacher leadership as well so they're looking forward to like who's the next person that we're going to bring in and how are we going to continue to build capacity at pler with our instructional leadership great so thank you yeah it's exciting they're great I love

063watching you say that and watching your heal team nod their heads like yeah we're tracking it we're definitely they look scared like no no they didn't look scared they're they're in um I just wanted um thank you so much for your presentation I always love to see a little green and gold I mean it's it's the word transplant family to Auburn I know if there's people who've been here for hundreds of years here but it's not you know and I wish we were I wish we were but uh we love plaster so much and I love it and thank you for the T-shirt um I wanted to um just drop back into some of the data and I know that we kind of talked about like the the 11th grade is like this one chance

064and so there's some fluctuation is there anyone who is tracking their final middle school scores in math or English and comparing it to the 11th graders and where do we like are we are we tracking that because I know that this is like a blip in their High School experience but are we tracking if these same students are meeting are exceeding from their eighth grade seventh grade you know you know that's I'm interested in that like are are they are they continuing to improve or are we losing some like where are we at with that so that's part of that that feeder School data piece that was on the very last slide and and I'm totally stealing it from deloro because um the feeder schools in that Community provide a wealth of knowledge for deloro

065and so um part of that's there I tried it last year and had very little success okay so I just had responses like we don't have anyone that can pull that data for you um or you know it were unanswered emails some things like that just needed some more effort I'm hoping with the the visits that's going to create some relationships and um and more of that that Community Police plus Britney being you know new to that district is also I've already met with her several times to to talk about this just the need yeah I'm happy to communicate and articulate with the trustees in that because we need to support the children see when I look at data um in our area and in Rockland I'm competitive rocklin's hurting us a little bit right

066now I don't like that I don't like it um but this is the conversation I had with Steve and some of the other board members recently was just that you know clearly they they've got the unified so they're tracking these kids from you know TK prek through high school it's an advantage yeah aligning the curriculum and having that Di dialogue and so we don't have that luxury so that communication relationship piece like you know it's something we all have to work on as a trusty that's something we can work on too is building those relationships so I can fil them and say hey we really need this data we need to know where our kids are at so we can track it um to support them better and and knowing um just in case you

067didn't know um trusty Emerson also speak Spanish um so he could be another asset come to pler perfect um and um but yeah just focusing on some of our special groups and making sure that we're serving them properly um is a concern and a and a focus of mine I want everyone to succeed but um addressing some of these high need groups is important to me I um I'm just making sure I'm catching my notes here I'm glad to see that our grad rates are are increasing right now and um I appreciate your time thank you thank you okay Confluence um again brought the crew to to speak most of this presentation but just um being able to be given the opportunity to be principal of Confluence was um definitely an important thing I needed

068I think for me this year um our staff at confence is amazing um the real our students are real um they're inspiring and and our need is there and so it's been as challenging as it is to be a principal of two schools it's also very rewarding to see the potential that could be with the partnership and so um we're still working out what this partnership looks like and who supports who it's been a big lift on plaster um classified staff our register I have to give a huge shout out to Willie Bailey um she has if you go to the next slide you'll see some of this um Willie Bailey has as our register now of both campuses um is you know has a learning curve to figure out the the Confluence side and

069has just done it with such an amazing positive attitude we're working through our second admin assistant there so Rebecca cyp has done um just a great job coming in and um and catching up as quickly as possible and I'll let um um Jeff Walter share the rest of the the Staffing pieces because it paints a picture picture of kind of who's there and who's there for support and um and since Jeff spends about half his time at Confluence as well then um he has lots of working time with these people so let you take it so one of the biggest learning curves uh in my career has been the first few months and um as we go through this obviously talking about Confluence um some things stick out in my mind which is consistency and

070one of the things that has been most consistent and they really need a huge shout out is the three individuals that are highlighted in a separate blue um Mel especially has said that multiple times that that is what means the most of these kids is consistency in a life where there is nothing consistent other than change and upheaval um and so in trying to mold the two um or push the two schools into uh a partnership it's been a dynamic thing um all of our admin staff support Confluence um with as Jamie mentioned U me spending about half my day over there and between Kristen as our internship coordinator who's also splitting time between our two uh continuation high schools Nate szy has been amazing as an RSP and another resource um again looking at

071the list it takes a village it really truly does and a big shout out to our Mental Health Specialists who are serving both campuses our cispes who are trying to build relationships but especially on lies with all of our campuses across the districts relationships matter and they really matter in this case um like I said it's really about talking growth on every individual student and as this presentational show it's really really hard to talk about just how much much growth every single individual has because every individual story is so different and it's more than just the numbers on on the screen um but like I said um kind of an homage to the river that uh gained or that our school is named after um the steadying uh presence uh in the Rapids are definitely

072those three individuals uh highlighted in blue so we wanted to share this slide this is just a snapshot of our data in comparison to the other um similar schools in our area so Jessica you trusty Spade you spoke to that um for our Confluence students we are in the blue bar so that's how we're arranging um our averages throughout the last several years um with grad rates for 2023 24 um Confluence um was at 69% and just something kind of remarkable about our students is that again diversity is is ever pre present on that campus um we have 58% of our student body SED 27% swd and 2% eel and then if you look across the board um you have adalante who is um in terms of their graduation rates were pretty similar across the

073board so it's just you know it speaks to the great work of our advisers there and our students there really getting our students across the Finish Line at high rates when um perhaps that traditional educational environment wasn't meeting their needs it's me again so what does this data say right this is the question and these if you guys look at this data it's really a snapshot in time and if we're going with the Confluence theme that I really appreciate how Jeff said that this is sort of an EB and flow right over the years and when we're looking at this one of the the things that is the biggest celebration up here right is our decline in suspensions if you look at the the the decline in suspensions that's a huge celebration and again that

074points to the steadiness of our three advisers right who have are steadfast the kids see them as home the kids see them as family um between them and the mental health specialists they do an amazing job of um conflict mediation teaching kids how to communic Comm unicate life skills helping kids meet their needs when kids needs are met they're not going to get suspended as often and so again attribute to the staff at Confluence um the other celebration is if you guys look at the increase in graduation rates there's a huge increase in graduation rates and again that's a tribute I think to the staff there really meeting students where they're at these are students who that box of school wasn't the right fit for them for whatever reason and Mel and Joey and Jim

075meet the students where they're at and help them get there and that's evidenced in this huge increase in graduation rates um the other celebration is increase in attendance these are students who in another life didn't a lot of them did not come to school um why are they coming to school now well they see Confluence as a home because of what's been created there um they see Confluence as stability in their life it's it's a place they want to be um some students who could graduate early will to stay because they're just not ready yet and Confluence is the one place in their life that is stable that is pro providing for them and so that that relationship that relational aspect has done so much for students and the feeling of hope that hey with

076this curriculum with when I have people who help me meet me where I'm at help me with my work we've got a decrease in suspension and increase in attendance and an increase in graduation rate and it's it's an amazing thing um the other thing is internship so we have a little bit of new Guidance with internships so we've kind of been working through that it it does look like there's a decline in there is a little bit just because there's been some new guidance and how businesses have to um sort of uh be uh vetted and so right now though we are at 22 students have been cleared and three more are in the process and we're continuing to build up as we continue to get more and more businesses who have been through the

077vetting process internships would be a lot easier the other piece I want to go back to for attendance is just to give a shout out to kimberry kimberry comes on the campus often and does Sam meetings and helps with intervention with attendance helps students talks them through getting there helping their goals she was there today so we have this really great team that's wrapping arms around kids to to get them there and I think this data says that we should be celebrating confluence hi good evening everyone everyone staying awake all right I know this the long one um my name is Melanie Hall I'm the lead teacher at confence this my third year as Lead Teacher my eighth year confence has been around for nine years um do you guys know what Confluence is to

078our new folks awesome I know some people don't if you knew Chana before we are Chana rebranded um and I think what we have is pretty amazing this is Joey Walker hi Joey and this is diamonds everybody loves diamonds all right so as you guys can see this is our mission goals and action we kind of came up with this uh a few years ago with Aaron it's funny we have three of our former principal current and two former which is kind of fun to still have them around um just really quickly to capture the fact that we are um under the leadership of Jamie Jackson now has been fantastic you know we love I've loved my former principles that I've had the pleasure to work with but it is nice to be able to

079partner with the the principal who's actually on our campus who we share resources with and she's been been phenomenal at supporting us and backing us and helping us to get what we need which you know doesn't always happen so um we're really grateful for that and Ava's doing an amazing job so thanks Eva um so empowering students to ReDiscover love of learning through personal exploration and Community engagement um I think it's important that we call it the love of learning because our students necessarily in the past they haven't had that Joy learning they think of school as something that's really painful and horrible and awful and we're able to inspire them to realize we call it unschooling so they can start to have that Joy of what it means to actually learn and grow personally

080and through um whatever level of Education that we're working through at the moment and then also a big part of what we do at Confluence is just engaging with a community we take any and every opportunity for our students to um give back and we do a lot of Pay It Forward activities which is really rewarding for them because our community also does a whole lot for our students as well um as you can see our goals academic cultural and systems and structures you guys have any questions on that all right we'll move to the next slide please um these are some of our initiatives we have six we as you can see we're in our ninth year life skills very very important for our students they don't necessarily come from um the best or

081happiest homes um I say that with all due respect uh but these are things that we're trying to teach them some skills that maybe they're not learning at home haven't had the chance to do that so navigating system mental health drug awareness um mock interviews and resumes we work on all of this with our kids we have um a construction math class where kids are actually building sheds just like building like hands on hammers Nails whatever they're doing uh with Jim I'll let you you want to talk about the garden real quick yeah we uh the when you guys remember a plaster there's the old the old houses that used to be on campus that were Tor down a few years ago we worked with in Peter Eid shout out helped us a lot um

082secure one of the half of that lot there and was able to this summer we we were able to have it graded and graveled and we're working with some Community Partners currently to um establish a community garden that the students will work on and um we have some beds going up arburn rotary has been really instrumental in that diamond came and and help spoke at the the arburn rotary so we're excited we're kind of turning it into some learning um and eventually have Big Dreams for that space but right now we're just really grateful to to have it and see what what comes of it so it's cool come by sometime if you want to see it yeah anytime you guys are all welcome anytime um also I want to just call we're been working

083on since last year a tiny home so you see a little house on the trailer that is our tiny home that we're building for a veteran now they're doing like inside wiring and it'll be complete uh when it's done which hopefully will be this year and hopefully start a new one next year which is pretty awesome um we do a lot of environmental exploration so hiking getting kids out there doing things that um you know maybe are a little bit hard for them or didn't think that they could actually do and showing them that their limits that they have in their heads are not actually their limits that they can do so much more than they thought they ever possible so we took a group of kids to um Castle Peak this year and hiked

084to the top of it and that was really an awesome experience I was really excited when Joey came on board because he's kind of like outdoorsy like I am you know coming from an army background as well like put on your wreck and let's go and so with Joey he was willing to take a group of con continuation kids backpacking you know which is not something for the faint of heart um and this is going to be our third year of doing it and going to P Point rays and backpacking for you know three days and two nights and taking the kids out there um to show them things that they haven't been able to see and most of them haven't been backpacking and it's fun you know we have a student who now like

085that's I feel like his passion he's one of our graduates and he's always coming by to talk to us and going out and doing backpacking things on his own and he wouldn't have had that opportunity and this student grew up in Auburn had never been to the ocean and then our senior trip he'd never been to Lake Tahoe so this is kind of um what we face in our reality so you go to the next slide you want to talk about art sure yeah uh our students are um they're especially artistic and and express themselves in a variety of different ways we've had the last few years a group of students who have and some of you have been by Jess you've seen it um developed a little music studio in in one of our

086classrooms which has been active and out of that some of them formed this band that they're actually um yeah they they're like a headliner show in Richmond this weekend they're really moving forward and it all started there and that's that's a really big outlet for our kids we we work hard to try to bring in outside experts or just keep our art supplies stocked um uh because it's it's been a really important um asset and we have um some prop 28 funds we're looking at using this year to um hire some outside sources to do some music lessons um and some art lessons that we were able to do last year and as well use some of it to to restock our art supplies for for our kiddos so it's great so again the navigating

087systems piece is really important um a lot of our kids just don't have they don't have a home that's necessarily knows how to navigate things as it is so we step in often in that role um you know from taking kids down to Sacramento to helping helping them get birth certificates helping kids get social security cards benefits medical like I'm having to learn and we've all had to learn how to do these things for for these kids because otherwise they're not going to have them and you know you can't get a job if you don't have an ID and you don't have a Social Security card so um it's really important to us that we're we go like the extra 10 miles for these kids to get them what they need so that they can

088be successful in the real world um you know and that that diploma is really really important but sometimes those other things out outside of the diploma are can be just as important for these kids including um finding them places to live at times and supporting them and supporting them with with food and clothing and any other element that might be necessary for them at that point in time and it's all very individualistic um knowing what every kid needs at every moment and working through those processes with them and then again Community involvement like I said any volunteer um activity that you can think of and we can take a van there we're going to go and we're going to do something and we're going to give back to our Community because it's just incredibly important

089for us okay so some of the key takeaways and when I get done Diamond's going to take the floor uh it's true we deal with exceptional students with exceptional circumstances and I could stand up here all day and tell you about some things that would probably break your heart but at the end of the day we have to teach these kids what it means to have resilience and to how to persevere and keep going despite the odds that they may face um we work really hard on Breaking the cycle of generational trauma generational poverty the things that that just happen to come with working in continuation high school we we are moms and dads like it or not that's that's what you would you say that who's the mom m mom so but we do

090work hard to mirror that healthy life and healthy relationships and healthy communication uh Within These the these students and what it means to be a healthy high functioning adult so these are the kids that are going to stay in our community are going to work in our community community and they do I see them every day that I'm out there after having worked at Confluence for so long and it's fun to see them thriving when they came to us and they they probably wouldn't have necessarily I know that we've changed lives tremendously and I'm incredibly incredibly proud of that um and the 99% of our students have experienced multiple Aces if you're familiar with aces are um and they just need they need our help to navigate those and and work through it so did

091you have anything to add no I think just on top of that it always feels um out of place to talk about data with our population although it's really important and we don't want to disregard it it feels like um what we do is not formulaic and and it's so individualized and our kids are coming from so many different scenarios and for so many of our kids um they face a lot of adversity just to get to school that day and so that that might be the win so it might not be something that we necessarily can put on a on a graph I just if we we I feel like we could explain it better if we could sit here and tell stor or if you could sit with a kid oneon-one and hear

092um even the evolution of you could look at um attendance rates but it' be really interesting to look at that individual students history of attendance and then see how it's increased when they come to us because a lot of times that was what was going on before and now they're coming to school and they didn't go at all the last couple years so um the the data is great but there's there's so much happening that is is really hard to articulate through data um and and I feel just very um lucky to get to work I I really believe conf fluence is the best kept secret in Auburn so um I'd love if you guys ever want to come by we open door and like visit with a kid or visit with us we we

093we're happy to make that work so um yeah yeah you don't have to call yeah show up easy for sure all right the diamonds okay hi guys um I just want to talk about like Jim Joey and Mel they're honestly such a good help to the school like they're really the rocks of the school and they help us so much Mel she really is Mama Mel she helped she just like she boosts you when you're down and she'll honestly give it to you straight and hard when you really need it because Mel knows and Joey he's Joey he's like the uncle he's the fun Uncle he always has the jokes he's just that guy and he's there to help you all the time honestly and then Jim he's not here but he's the best he

094always has a smile on his face and he's always going to keep you up at all times and um what it's like to learn at conflicts like it's honestly so good because like I'm ready to go sit in a class and I feel comfortable to raise my hand and speak out and ask questions about what's going on and like I don't know what this is like can you help me and they'll come and just help you in an instant whether they're working with another person it'll take them a second come to you but it's really so nice to be in a classroom with them and have them teach you cuz they teach you in such great ways that you feel like you can really learn something and at the end of the day you don't

095leave with just like oh yeah I kind of learned this today you know no you left and you're like oh wow like I know this like I'm so excited to go tell my mom like this is what I learned today um and confence is just such a caring Community like sometimes I haven't always been able to get to school or like had a ride home and Mel's like taking me home multiple times or like I'll show up late sometimes because you know I just have to catch the bus but they're always ready and happy that I even ended up showing up to school in the first place which is great um and it's very Hands-On learning and I'm actually really excited to talk about the garden the garden has been like such an amazing thing

096for me because I got to plan it all out it was so cool I got to learn how to do blueprints they teach you so much here and hands on I got to build my I got to build the beds for the garden dig the holes you know do all that type of stuff it was really cool and especially going to the Rotary Club I was very nervous but it was really cool cuz once I was there and I told them a little bit about it and they like heard about it from others they were just ready and raised their hands and were like we're ready to buy a bed and I was just so happy after that we took a picture we were like cheese thumbs up and everything um and I'm honestly just

097really grateful to be at Confluence it's such an amazing school like it sucks that like you hear that oh it's just like a bad kids school all this all that and I hope we can change that because it's actually such a great school and you learn and you get to go out and do new things and try new things and it's just such a great thing and also inclusivity um I'm really glad that we're more included with plaster because um it's just been so great like being able to go to rallies and being able to like go on their campus more like cuz I actually used to be a plaster student so it's just like being a plaster student and then being a Confluence student you're like oh wait we can't even like go over

098there for some certain times but it's been great because we get to do rallies and we have like nutrition and lunch over there but sometimes you know if you go over there you they'll just be like um you got to go back to your school but it's okay um yeah that's it you be great time thanks Simon so I was singing while she was up there I'm outstanding job best student we've ever brought so good job Diamond who was terrified of public speaking yes he did great great we do a lot lot of public speaking a lot of speaking in front of of people um just thinking we're really fortunate because diamond is a junior so she will be returning to us next year um but this year is really different for us too we

099have a population of 75 kids and generally we're like 68 72 but we are like full to the gills right now like full and they're all coming which is great but it's a lot like on a on a regular basis um but we have so many seniors so that next year the T where we may only have about 8 to 12 Juniors that are going to be seniors so it's going to be a really interesting Dynamic to see how this kind of plays itself out um for next year because we get not only students who are maybe credit deficient or they're needing a different learning environment or just a smaller school so they're a little bit more comfortable and feel like there's just so much I want to share about Confluence and then there's just

100not enough time tonight but if you guys do have more questions and want to come by I know you guys weren't able to make the learning walk we'd be happy to to just kind of take you it's so much better to understand it in person than it is if we were just here yapping at yeah at a board meeting so um any questions for us I can't help um you guys when I think about Confluence I cry I just do I didn't know um I didn't know coming on a board that I was going to fall in love with alt Ed and ALT Ed teachers and the students I didn't know that was was um a surprise to me um you have to go like as the board president I demand that you go to

101con the conferen is um because you can't you can't encapsulate it and it's such a special group and and they give so much um you know we were there just a couple of weeks ago on a learning walk we've got learning walks scheduled at every campus if it's at all possible to squeeze it into your busy life please come um there's just things that you're going to capture and people you're going to talk to and students you run into that otherwise you would not and um we had a very raw learning walk um it was very real you can it always it's always real at the Confluence you guys keep it real I love that I love real people and um you have so much on your plate um something that was brought up was

102like you know looking forward to the future you know what are the goals you know five years and 10 years out and I think that the staff we some things need to be crafted so they have eye on the prize and we support um as much as we can um to get them there so that that we're all working together for the same same thing not just surviving and supporting um but really building things for the future and you guys are doing so many incredible things and I'm happy to hear about the garden and all the Hands-On learning um I'm not surprised that art and music and gardening are focuses for you guys my focus um when I was entering College I thought I was going to go into music therapy I I could see

103why the students are landing in music and art and gardening those are things that bring so much joy and peace and um and I love that for each of you and I just as a trustee it's really important to me is we're supporting you the staff who's who's in there day in and day out that um we're responsive to your needs as well and I know that you've got a good partnership with Jamie and the staff right now but the emotional task told that that takes to support your students day in and day out driving them and picking you guys up and creating this awesome experience for you um you know there's there's always a a balancing act to you know to take care of yourself and to take on this role and you guys

104manage it beautifully but I know it's I know it's not easy and I see it and so I just want you to know I'm a resource for you and and we're going to do everything we can to support you and I'm so thankful that you guys are there and thank you diamond for sharing you you did a great job and you're doing good work and I'm glad we get to keep you another year that you'll continue to lead over there so thank you I think this is the Confluence is the best in 10 years intervention and that we have created in this group is outstanding uh the work that you do the community that you build the healing of of family because it really is that I know um I just have to share one

105picture it was a few years ago we on the board had the opportunity to go in the community and see some of the kids in their internships and here was a young lady um from a troubl town that that she was so happy and she was rebuilding a lawnmower and it was so cool to see that big smile on her face learn the skills so many of the kids find employment afterwards as well you know when internship ends I just want to uh I am thankful to like Jessica for all the hard work that you do it's outstanding program and I'm so excited that we had this in our district thank you a diamond I just wanted to comment on something that you said about the school that is um viewed as where the I

106think you said the bad kids or something like that in the community I can tell you firsthand that is not the perception of our community because they've had internships with students like yourself and it's quite the opposite um if you talk to our community um Partners in the in Auburn and Lumis they love Confluence students they have had such a great experience with every student they've had um and even if it wasn't the best working out for the internship they've still had a great experience because they got to work with amazing students like yourself so that uh opinion his is changing has been changing for several years and it's growing so it's it's very popular in Auburn with our um Business Leaders rotary Optimus clubs um all support Confluence so keep up the good work

107thank you hi it's been a real breath of fresh air to hear about your program I as a new board member I didn't wasn't aware I'm familiar with with continuation school but uh this has been really really impressive also the the plaster Administration hats off I mean I it just feels very good to know that the the community is thriving and I'm I'm happy to hear that you guys are uh are doing such a having such a great time at school that's amazing so thank you you we were it's not a packet School most continuations it's like throw a packet yeah some days we want that just kidding you talked about you talked about integration where you guys are visiting more the plaster campus is it reciprocal are are there is there any sort of

108like um student involvement from the plaster side working with the Confluence um to a point I mean Ava you can talk about it too but it's still new yeah this is still fresh it's still growing and like I said with the attrition rate that we have I think next year and the year after it'll be even easier right because it'll just be an Norm so that is the beauty of only having students for a year or two you just flip it over and we tell them how this is how it is and they're like okay this is how it is so but these kids have worked really hard to you know establish what that means and that they want to be able to participate in what it means to be a student outside of just

109the things that we do because we're not staffed enough or have a student body big enough enough to have rallies or spirit days or some of those things so um and not all students want to do it our kids a lot of them aren't the joiners um but for the kids that in do find you know Joy from being able to participate we love that we can offer them those opportunities now to you know go to prom or go to a rally or whatever it might be Ava did you have anything to add on that um yeah so I would say like the plaster Confluence student relationship is always like evolving but I think we had a really great opportunity at the beginning of the year at our student voice meeting we had confidence and

110plaster students present and one of the main things that we addressed was we kind of got off topic to what we were originally supposed to talk about but I think it was more relevant to us was building that relationship and just having respect between both campuses because we do share resources we share you know the the cafeteria and nutrition and all that stuff restrooms and I think it's really important and I think the big takeaway was that we have so much respect for each other and that's going to be a continuing relationship and I think it's really great but I do think it's still work in progress for sure great thank you guys thank you thank you all set all right thank you guys very much we'll continue on with um superintendent Showcase with our

111student board members on how they plan to promote the student board position and thanks you guys um student voice topics that you'd like to see at our next student voice and whoever wants to go first Ruby oh great um so I'll be reading Zoe's report as well since she had to leave early um she's the Forest Hill representative um so this is her words so picture that I'm her right now um but hi everyone I hope you all enjoyed your 3-day weekend I would like to extend a Welcome to our new board member trusty Lake we're excited to work with you throughout the remainder of the school year things have been going well at Forest Hill our amazing counselor Mr or Mrs sorry cardello has been very busy recently she's in the process of organizing

112fasta workshops for our senior class the first of which will be taking place tomorrow she has also helped to organize a speech contest with our local Lions Club and we have had over 20 students sign up so far our Forest Hill teachers are planning on attending the contest as a part of their professional development in this way they'll be able to support and be there for all the students who are participating and they can also identify places in which students may require extra support in the area of public speaking uh Forest Hill is also um Forest Hill also has our learning walk scheduled for next Wednesday January 29th and we'd absolutely love to have as many board members as possible attend I know that many of you are new to the board so so we'd

113love for you to have an opportunity to come and check out our school and see our beautiful campus uh we also have another opportunity for you to come up to FHS for our community night which is scheduled for February 4th I know Forest Hill feels far away but I promise it's really not that far we hope to see you there while Forest Hill technically does not have a direct board member represent representative right now we would love for all of our district board members to come visit our amazing school I know that there are many students and staff who would love to see an interact with board members on our campus on a different note we have a student voice meeting coming up soon and we're in the process of figuring out a topic one

114idea would be to look at our California healthy kids survey data to see if there are any areas in which our schools and or District could improve their support for our students uh students can can then create and provide input on a plan for moving forward another possible um topic idea would be to have students identify ways in which the district can better provide help and resour to students as they are learning math concepts after looking at our California school dashboard math seemed to be the area that our district struggled in the most academically thus it may be beneficial to hear students thoughts and ideas on what our school can do to help them learn and that's all for Forest till thank you all right so now I'm moving on to my report um sorry

115that you have to listen to me talk so much um so um in the December meeting I spoke about how I wanted to implement a student advisory Council within kofax and we just had our first meeting today uh it went really well and we were able to talk about a lot of different topics a lot of different student concerns um so we t or started off the meeting talking about CBE and a little bit of the annoyance and how it's sort of reflected in Aries so while they're getting a two out of two or three out of three it's not reflected as an A in the grade book which has really confused a lot of parents and that was a lot of the feedback that I got um as a lot of parents just aren't

116really informed with the grading system and you know they're seeing their student get a c or B in a class even though they've gotten 100% on it so you know it's the students trying to explain that to the parents and you know just that um second sort of voice in that um is a little bit difficult to navigate um then we talked about the phone policy and it's been working really well at our school um a lot of the feedback was that at the beginning of last year so first term um it was rolled out pretty harshly so that way a lot of students were used to um you know not having their phones on um on them during school um and this um has been a really great um opportunity for students to get

117used to it um and as we've been coming back to school as well it's pretty consistent to how it was last term um and there are some discrepancies on like listening to music in class too because you know often times um I think it was being mentioned in the plas report as well um you know teachers are often having to compensate for a lot of the um extra time that they now have with their students um so you know being able to do some busy work and listening to some music is always a little bit helpful so um just that sort of continuation there and then um little campus environment stuff as well so um a lot of our facilities as I'm sure you guys know um are not great um so the drinking fountains

118that are by our football field and in um one of our buildings in our Jim B building um don't work and this inhibits a lot of athletes to get water before and during practice and you know often times when you are an athlete you're not allowed to leave your practice to go get water so um it's something that's really difficult for our athletes to navigate um as well as people during school um and then we have our back to school night future Falcon night and spring Sports night next Monday January 27th um clubs and teachers are all getting ready and preparing for that night um there's going to be a lot of booths um with information on each part um of that night and everything it'll entail and then potential student voice topics um everything

119at kfax has been pretty mellow and that was a lot of the feedack that I got during that advisory council meeting today um but I think talking about campus culture and stuff like that might be a little bit helpful um just sort of navigating a lot of the inclusivity and sort of those discussion points as well um and then my last thing is I wanted to speak about the recent appointment of trusty Emerson Lake I wanted to say that I'm very much um looking forward to collaborating with you in these upcoming months but I did want to touch on the process of the appointment a little bit I think this board while having great intentions is not really focused on the students especially since the candidate that had experience as an educator and was supported

120by each student board member did not move on to the second round moving forward I want to make sure we look at the concerns of our students as opposed to political agendas that don't encourage the growth of our district but instead inhibit it let us not forget that everything done in the board um in this board directly affects their students at each School site in ensuring that we have adequate facilities curriculum that encourages learning and a safe environment for students to be in every day should always be the fundamental concern so thank you guys hello and welcome to New trustee Dr Lake I want to take a moment to address the new grading policy that went into place after the meeting on the 7th classer students are adjusting to the change very well however there

121is still some confusion surrounding the decision made by the board and what the future grading practices will look like in the months and years to come currently at fastor the grading practice is chosen on a teacher by teer basis department heads are continuing continuing to work with teachers to set a syllabus that will help guide lesson plans in the overall curriculum teachers teaching a tog classes like global system science are working with one another to agree on a grading practice ensuring there is consisteny and Equity among required classes I also wanted to note that the plaster Administration teachers and staff have worked incredibly hard all year with the implementation of CBE in all the students that I have spoken to we have felt supported and comfortable asking questions regarding CBE I hope that all of

122the time energy and re resources that the district P into CBE will not be disregarded and that we can work to create a grading system that is fair and Equitable for all students I also wanted to touch on the upcoming student voice meeting on February 12th one area that plaster continues to work on is in is attendance with having an open campus there are challenges with students being on time and making it through an entire day I think it could be valuable to listen to what challenges are preventing students from being present at school another important topic is the idea of inclusivity on campus our campus is extremely diverse like you guys heard and I believe it should be of the utmost importance to the board how we can make every single student feel valued

123safe and supported at school no matter there were race race religion gender sexual orientation or beliefs hearing directly from students on how we can strive towards being more inclusive I believe it's very beneficial I also wanted to speak on the student board member application and how I plan to promote it in my last board report I spoke about creating a student board member Instagram account the Instagram account would serve as the perfect platform to bring awareness to what our roles look like and encourage students to apply highlighting the variety of responsibilities and opportunities that come with being a student board member can help motivate more students to get involved and share their voices with my involvement in leadership I will also be hosting an informational Hill time lesson during intervention promoting the application during this

124lesson I will go in depth about what being a student board member is like and answer any questions and comments that arise I plan to promote the lesson via the morning announcements and our news crew during advisory to let students know when it is happening and what teacher they should sign up for in order to attend with all the changes that we have encountered this last semester I look forward to getting back on track and working towards how we can best serve our students I'm excited to work alongside each and every board member to hear student voices and keep them in mind with every decision that is made thank you and then this is my board so I'm going to talk about CBE in first um in general in general the grading practices have been

125fairly appreciated by both students and teachers alike some classes are keeping their CBE sty grading others are reverting to traditional and many are keeping a hybrid and the increase in autonomy has quieted concerns on campus as far as I can tell and at Confluence West the fourpoint scale continues to be used exclusively and with with success and this could be a great voice topic as it is no longer as charged but it is still relevant to student and teacher life and it is quite murky for a lot of us um over on the Confluence West Campus um staff and students are excited about a variety of new classes being offered and they're inviting the board members to stop by and see what's going on whenever they have a chance um as far as student board

126applications go I've been working with my site principal uh to release a video informing students about the student board member position how important it can be and how to apply and this video will be sent via email to the student body um in the Sports World the boys and girls basketball are both through their first round in leagues and girls softball is about to start a fundraiser for field lighting where all the players are going to give up their phones for a month so I'm excited to see how that goes and I'm sure it'll be successful and next I also wish to speak about the newest board appointment first I'm confident that you're going to make a great board member Dr Lake and I'm sure I'm speak for all of us when I say we

127have full confidence in your ability sleep however I do take issue with the way the appointment was made every applicant was qualified and invested in our schools however the one candidate who had by far the greatest involvement in our district and as far as I can tell held the greatest number of official volunteer roles in our district and more importantly the one candidate that was unanimously supported by both the student board members as well as the majority of community members who spoke was the only candidate who was eliminated in the first round Mr Lake himself acknowledged in his acceptance remarks that M tweet the only candidate who failed to make the second round of interviews was the most qualified candidate this seems to point to only one conclusion the board holds not enough regard for

128the views of students and community members and they did not feel the need to lend consideration to our desired candidate it seems to me that the board used the interview to determine which candidate aligned most closely with their political views and again and again we hear the Mantra of serving the students repeated and told that it is the mission of the board yet time and again when students in the community have the opportunity to express their opinions to the board it is dismissed if the board wishes to serve students it must listen to students when they speak and I cannot say for certain why the board is choosing to disregard the needs of students in this respect however I cannot only I can only assume the agenda of outside organizations are being put above the

129voices of our community if that is the case I implore the board to reconsider their motivations and spend a moment thinking about what is more important to them make and to make decisions that align with the needs and values of their constituents I know you all truly want to serve our community and is quite dishe heartening to see such good-hearted people such as yourselves become distracted from our shared goal of service and Improvement outside political organizations and politicians don't know what's best for our district but we the community the students the teachers and the board do so let's regard this regard political differences and divisive rhetoric unless listen to each other and work with one another to improve this special place that we're lucky to call home thank you students um couple items on my

130uh list here uh we've already heard a little bit about uh learning walks tomorrow is at deloro uh we had Confluence at um president spade and I were a part of as well as District administrators those are an amazing opportunity to see uh our students and our teachers in action tomorrow's at Del I'm sure it'll be just a great great morning um and the other those other uh student um or there's other learning walks are all in your calendars so you can they're already shared with you um as mentioned our student board application window is open uh today through February 18th um and so it sounds like our students are are working on finding applicants um later on in the agenda today and we'll talk I'm sure we'll talk about it later is the the

131contract with csba for a new beginnings Workshop um president spade and I worked on um talking with csba in order to get uh our board some training um the upcoming February date is not going to work and so I'm sure there'll be discussion on that but it is a um it is a meeting uh uh five hour training based on board governance goal setting um and New Beginnings as as a new board basically um through csba um grading committee I we did some we did a survey to our parents our staff and our students there's some preliminary numbers uh we had 48 people return uh the survey 32 were from deloro five of those were staff four of those were students uh kfax had five uh one of those was staff pler High School had

132eight three staff and then we had one from Forest Hill one from District campus staff um and then one from uh M over so that was just kind of our initial uh I'm still asking and um needing some some further guidance from the board as to what we want the outcome of of those meetings to be or meetings meeting or um singular or plural um I think our our our sites are collecting lcap data and all their lcap nights that might serve to be helpful in opinions and perceptions of grading we can put all that together but at this point right now we we sent the survey out on Friday it was a long it was a long long weekend um we did get 48 responses and so i' I'd like to honor the request

133of the board to to um have that committee we just need to figure out exactly what that committee is going to be accomplishing um and it probably won't happen in in one meeting um so just staff is requesting further guidance as to you know what the outcome of that um goal would be with grading at at this point um we'd like to get back to all those that have respond resped so we can tell them the potential commitment that um they signed up for so um student voice uh next student voice is on the 12th and our next regular board meeting is on the 18th of February and just a a reminder for our students um that you guys can be excused at 9: should you um should you want to leave then you're not

134required to stay but I'm guessing we're probably going to get to that point so um just so for our students that have studies they need to do so um Trenton is going to look at um our our outcomes with the CCI data which I'm excited to share with the board I I think overall and I'm not going to go through all the details now but just the overall increase in our CCI we saw with with pler um it's a strategic team effort especially by our our staff and our counselors especially making sure our students are taking the right classes at the right time um and and we all know that one test that a student takes their 11th grade years is a really difficult data set to to base uh how well a school is

135doing we appreciate the CCI data because it it does encompass more than just one bucket of data and so to see that those results grow over the last several years is great um in leading the area so I I'll Trent's going to share that data today um with that concludes my report thank you thanks thank you Dr cetti we're going to go ahead and move to item seven consent agenda items it appears we have a couple changes to the consent agenda is that accurate trustee Jeff yes ma'am I would like to pull uh 7.3 and 7.9 for discussion so with moving items 7.3 and 7.9 to the top of our action do I have a motion I'll move to do that do I have a second I second we have a first and a second

136for item seven consent agenda with the removal of 7.3 7.9 to our first action items um all in favor starting with the board say I I I I board I all opposed hearing none motion passes unanimously we'll pick up with item 7.3 District issued warrants all right so I just had a quick question on one of the spreadsheets that was linked there um and actually I'm trying to remember which date it was I think it was the December one but it was interesting it we're talking about expenditures and checks being written from plaster Union High School District but it was to plaster Union High School District so we're writing ourselves a check and it wasn't a very large number but I'm just curious what that was about December 19th or December 11th you remember which

137one no I don't remember off the top of my head and I didn't grab my folder that I had a print out print out in because I do know as an example I can even use myself um huh 19 sometimes what happens is an employee May owe the district money through a writing a check to them oh okay understood the only question I had okay with that do I have a motion for item 7.3 District issued warrants in light of that I'll move to approve I'll second we have a first and a second on District issued warrants all in favor starting with the board or do we have any disc further discussion I don't think so all in favor starting with the board I board I all opposed motion passes unanimously item 7.9 BP 6142

138point9 to mathematics instruction update trusty Jeff questions I do so I'm looking at this particular board policy I'm wondering what staff member I don't know who I would direct this question to but um looking at board policy I don't see any other board policy that that directs this level of guidance to any other academic area is that fair to say um it depends I I think there's a policy in each of the in the 600s about each level of instru instuction for social science instruction for uh World Language PE I think they it contains them these updates just so you're aware uh and and Dr lake is you you're new uh to this uh we get these updates from the csba um the the California School Board Association they say hey here's an update um

139and this one came I believe from the I have to look at it it was a I want to say June 24 update but I I'll double check and so it was probably reflecting if I could guess when I was trying to look through the csb update it was probably reflecting the change in um mathematics framework at the state level uh it takes a while from when the state makes a change of some sort to make its way through csba and then csba takes whatever the state changes and pushes out to all of the districts to say hey here's the policy uh we didn't uh Robert lemon my coordinator of instruction he updated it I looked at it it didn't look anything um other than innocuous and aligned with what we were doing so but

140if there's an issue you guys can discuss and we'll look into any things that you guys would like us to look into when when Mr lmon was making these uh revisions did he seek out the guidance or or feedback or input from any the mathematics instructure teachers no it was it was clear like I said what we do is we get them from the csba uh and we take what they have and we typically update it um based off of their suggestions so is there any purpose behind us making these changes in respect to is the District administration looking at changing some policies some additional policies or how how policies are you know influencing instruction or I'm a little confused on why so again this I'll try to explain it again uh when a law

141or something changes uh usually the csba takes whatever that change was they have lawyers and other people who vet this for a long period of time and they spit it out to us we like to update uh this because if you get behind on three or four updates then it becomes much harder to update because you don't know where they align and what they don't align to um most of the school districts do it this way where they take a look at what the csba has updated um based off of of their recommendation uh unless there was something specific uh sometimes uh within the csba it'll say it's optional uh when we look through it we go does this conflict with what we're doing in some way uh we feel that it didn't uh conflict

142or change anything that we were doing so um that's essentially what we do is we take it from the csba and then update it again I i' I've had um board policies where we update and uh if they if we've missed a couple Cycles it's really hard to update because the wording is so different and especially if those are uh mandatory changes that have to be taking place then it becomes very combersome uh to manage so that's that's essentially how we go about making these policy changes and just for recommendations like right first of all I'm a former csba delegate so I'm familiar with how this process Works um and the recommendations that come from csba are just that they're recommendations for this board to kind of examine and and look at and that kind

143of thing so yep um I was just curious number one if if any Math teachers have gotten eyes on this to see how it may or may not impact what they're doing in the classroom and it sounds like that no that wasn't the case um and again having your word that there's no other underlying motive for the these changes being made you know nothing that we're not aware of at this point like I said all I could ascertain is it was probably from the framework update that exact uh happened in 23 or something like that yeah the state state board of education updated the math Frameworks in 2023 this comes out of out of that update understood is there any other questions or are we prepared to have a motion do we have a motion

144I move approval I'll second we have a first and a second on item 7.9 BP 614 2.92 mathematics instruction update any further discussion board all right with that being said starting with the student board all in favor I I I board I I I'll oppose none U motion passes unanimously for item 7.9 okay now we're jumping into the standard action items 8 8.1 certificated Personnel report report number 6 24 through 25 thank you madam president um again we have a number of different um positions that we've hired for including classer school for adults which is a pretty regular happening because they do short brief um positions for their um programs we also of course have our um other supports Direct direct instruction our home Hospital teachers curriculum development our Specialists so we have a number

145of different um positions that we are um having um putting forth for approval tonight we also um received the end of our early tell for um ATP members um we do have two additional ones um they will be missed they're long-term employees with us and we have appreciated their work and their dedication to our district Terry Barker and Laura Owens and um on the behalf of the Acting Superintendent I would recommend approval of the certificated Personnel report do I have a motion I move approval all second we have a first and a second on item 8.1 certificated Personnel report number 6 2425 do we have any discussion hearing none starting with the student board all in favor I I board I all opposed nay hearing none motion passes 8.2 classified Personnel report number 6 2425

146yes Madam president again we have a number of um classified positions that we have been able to um hire individuals for including our volunteers that once again we always want to say thank you to our volunteers who take the time to work with our students um we so appreciate it I don't know that we could function without all the support that we have um we have some student tutors always appreciate those as well we do have some retirements in our um in our classified Personnel long-term um employee um Lisa FASA she will be missed we want to thank her for her service and time with the district and a few other uh resignations so on the behalf of the Acting Superintendent I would recommend the approval of the classified Personnel report I move approval I'll

147second action item 8.2 classified personel report number 6425 has a first and a second any further discussion all right all in favor starting with the board say I I board I I'll oppose hearing none motion passes unanimously 8.3 242 2024 2025 tenative agreement with the associated teachers of plaster CTA Nea ATP Acting Superintendent Steve cetti when take it away actually I'm gonna let just kidding take it away BR address this one thank you um this uh I am bringing this forth again this has been a negotiated and ratified by the ATP members for dual enrollment and for safety I do understand that there was some language concerns around the furpa language in the dual enrollment I do know that Mr Wilson um did do some additional leg work if there's any further questions but otherwise

148on the behalf of the Acting Superintendent I would recommend the approval of these tenative agreements I move approval I second any discussion yes so um I know I discussed this um a little bit in the December meeting um with my concerns if we can bring the mou on dual enrollment back up my concern really um has to do with that third bullet point in the Striking however if the students wave FP per rights um as it you I'll reiterate what I said in December as it reads now um it gives the teachers the um the idea that they are expected to communicate um which we now know that that's not the case in fact I have a an email here that was forwarded to me um from one of our staff um an email that

149came from Sierra College explaining that particular thing U the board has a copy of that um and Sierra colleges stance is exactly as I explained it in December um and here's the thing from my perspective um as a board member and as a parent that has a sophomore daughter that's in a dual enrollment class right now um I truly believe that parents should have the ability to check on uh you know the grades in the class the progress in the class what's going on in the class that kind of thing um for even dual enrollment classes however that's not how the law is written um and my concern is um if we pass this uh or approve this mou as written we're going to have teachers um inadvertently breaking the law uh and I don't

150like to see that um what I would suggest is if we are going to approve this dual enrou um that we then look at putting it into place uh a district policy uh that every dual enrollment student needs to um sign that waiver um so that the teachers just all know like just like any other class I can talk to the parents uh that seems like it would be a very easy solution um but I think that's a solution that needs to happen otherwise um we're going to have teachers inadvertently violating students furpa rights uh and I do not want to see us as a district put our teachers in that position um and I know that administrators have pressured teachers to have that those conversations with dual enrollment teachers because I've been one of

151them uh in the past it's been pressured in that way um so we need to protect our teachers in that way so either we don't pass theou or we look at putting into a place a policy that suggests that like every dual enrollment student needs to pass that or assign that waiver so that their parents have the right to um to find out what's going on with them in the class thank you for your feedback on that and and Gathering some information from staff I certainly don't want anyone to violate the law and I don't want the teachers in the position to violate the law um with your suggestion of having I know that the parents in order for a student to access the dual enrollment courses they have to sign a waiver basically relinquishing

152their rights for them to participate it's so ironic the irony is wild um they can't take the class without parents' permission but once they're there it's like it's over um but with the language in here if the parents signed that they're in and simultaneously the student says uh my parents have access to it I feel like that's a pretty fair solution and and keeps the line of communication open with that being said we also have some students that are 18 so that um parent Guardian may not apply in that case so with your idea and I like your idea if we and I don't know exactly how this would work if this would be just a direction to staff to you know prepare some kind of AR something to address it so that they're receiving

153as the parents receiving the permission to get into the duel enrollment that simultaneously the student also signs um that fer right you know for their parents to have access could hypothetically kill two birds with one stone what are your thoughts yeah Dr kimy can I have your thoughts on this well um in terms of the legality that uh was mentioned yeah I I think there's um I think there there's a challenge on both on both sides of course we don't want to put our teachers in a situation that causes them to um be perceived or otherwise assume that they're breaking the law but we want our parents to be involved across the board 100% in we're not we're not breaking the law right teachers would not be uh Jeremy was saying we don't want to

154put teachers in a position yeah I haven't I haven't had a legal analysis of all of this we've we've talked with sah colge at length I I I've spoken you know after our last meeting to a lawyer briefly our lawyer um and she said you know and even in even my conversation with s College last week um they admit that there's this gray area and this is the conflict of of dual enrollment and uh one of the one of the many issues um again in that document that I emailed you guys last time uh you know from from the Department of Ed it says parents still retain rights under furpa at the high school and may inspect and review any records sent by The postsecondary Institute tion to the high school so uh it would

155protect the teachers if they were sending any grade information any attendance information to the school to share with the parents they have access to that what uh Sarah College had said is there uh they that we wouldn't have any access to the Sarah College Canvas uh and where they house the grades and all of those things but anything our teachers put into Aries in our system and communicate with us uh we have the right and the ability to communicate to the parents uh institutionally I don't think um that we would be putting the um teachers at risk uh because it would be it would be our policy it would be the school um and you know the breaking the law part is kind of a a weird situation because uh again like I mentioned last

156time purpose to protect the students typically the students are the ones who are bringing their parents involved uh into this into this conversation but certainly the wording of theou says that they're not to violate um the furpa if a dual enrollment instructor was so concerned that that they might happen they have absolutely have the right to say I'd request a waiver uh before having that conversation so I think there's ways to to do that but again like I said last time our goal was to ensure that we weren't losing kids uh and not not having knowledge either parents or counselors of where a kid was at within this dual enrollment class and I think it's really important too because while it is dual enrollment and it is a college level class we are uh pushing

157kids into this uh for for CCI and also their own benefit but it's also a lifetime transcript and so when a student uh is 15 and they're taking the dual enrollment course and and they uh didn't maybe realize the difficulty of that they were in an async course or something like that and then all of a sudden uh they fail or have to withdraw as a late uh we would hate to see that happen and we'd love to intervene and get and be able to say Hey you know here what are some options Let's help you and and so really it's to to um provide communication about where a student is in the progress um to the parents and the counselors to to help ensure the students aren't uh you know suffering a poor decision

158uh you know certainly uh 16-year-old with an F on a college transcript wouldn't be the best thing for us um and it's been close and sometimes we've had kids in English uh 1A as seniors who are counselors had no idea that they were close to not passing the class and um almost didn't graduate because of it uh so we just the the the principle of it the essence behind it was just to help our school sites make sure that our kids um are being supported in that way do we do we know any data from sah College of they having a lot of furpa complaints ultimately I feel like that doesn't matter like if there's even if there hasn't been just curious on the numers I understand that my point here is it says I'm

159reading from that third bullet point unit members will be expected to communicate with parents or counselors regarding students progress in the class now I also have a letter here from the uh director of dual enrollment from Sierra College which most of our dual enrollment classes are through Sierra College himen do you want me to read this or you can yeah it says per fura and our deou de instructors are permitted to share student level information grades and attendance with high school district Partners this allows you to complete progress reports and communicate student grades with any District staff member however you are not permitted to share such information with the guardian of a student this is coming right from Sierra College who were partnering with right um so it seems like the way the way that

160this was uh this mou that this verbiage was struck in struck out it definitely muddies the water and it says unit members will follow furpa but it where in this does it explain what those fple laws are hopefully you understand what my concern is I understand what your concern is um um and I and I can see that for sure with you being a former dual enrollment teacher as well and so I think that if we can strike a balance and at the same time that they're enrolling we we have the kids sign a waiver like it's it's a done deal is that is that a difficult process you know as far as Staffing goes to coordinate as the parents are signing them in that the students also if they're under 18 also sign a

161waiver I would have to ask uh uh the people it's a um very tedious process to uh get them into Sierra College anyways I don't know if adding one extra thing is going to be that that uh big of an ordeal okay and then what happens if they they don't sign it right then we have to have those conversations as right I mean there's always two sides sides of the coin it's never it's never just a a simple when was that written Jeremy that email uh September 18 2024 so just a couple months ago okay thanks I think that in moving in just like that collaboration and transparency aspect I I would feel comfortable moving forward with the meou that has already been agreed to at this point and um if we could direct staff

162to bring back something that we could discuss so that simultaneously as they're they're en rolling that we can have this conversation so that we make sure everyone's protected um through this process and that that line of communication with parents is still open how do you guys feel about that and additionally some kind of a tracking sheet perhaps so that the the teachers know which students parents they can speak to and which ones they can't something to communicate that would be very helpful um because I don't think CR college does a very good job of communicating with us like if they if the student signs the waiver through CR College um so I think that's that's definitely concern my my concern is that we the teachers need to know who what parents they can speak to

163and what parents they can't do you feel comfortable with um if giving direction to staff and and uh adopting it as is currently can I can I ask a clarifying question so so the waiver is going to say that the parent does not give the teacher permission to communicate their grade is that what the waiver is going to say no no so I know the parents sign signed the waiver for for them to attend then the student would sign a waiver for the parent to access or for the so that communication we're going to so the waiver is going to allow a freshman or sophomore or Junior to not communicate with their parent no I well right now well that that's the way that rule is right for dual enrollment I just want to know

164what the the permission slips supposed to say well I would I would maybe suggest uh us verifying with our legal team about what what this says in in terms of the Department of Ed when I had a conversation with uh Nigel regarding this last week he said the big thing is you can't share um you know can't give access to Canvas but once that information's in our hands we can disseminate it to our our parents yeah I get that going back to the mlu the mlu says the teachers will communicate with that's the difference what you're talking about and what I'm talking about are two different things the teachers communicating with us no no it says communicating with parents that's what the M says so it's not talking about data through Aries that your interpretation

165it's talking about teachers communicating with parents like calling a parent saying Hey Little Johnny's doing this in my class or Little Johnny's not struggling in this area like those are the conversations that we can't the teachers dual enrollment teachers cannot have unless that waiver signed right sure the waiver okay so so maybe the direction is to to talk to legal and and present something obviously we want all parents to be communicating with with students and staff it's all about the kids and success and so um if we could get some feedback on that um what a potential waiver could look like but maybe it's maybe it's a click of a button I don't know how the parents are going in it's like parents give permission and student check check it's over you know and some

166kind of I don't know something to discuss I do think with the language on the end according to guidelines I understand what trustee Jeff was referring to is how would our teachers know so that's what you're asking for a followup I think that with this language and the direction you're giving us that would allow us to address those concerns that you guys are talking about perhaps maybe a passive uhuh permission slip we could look into what options are available great and but this having according to the fura guidelines allows that to how is this going to happen how is this communication going to occur and what is the communication with the teachers to ensure that they're aware of who they can be communicating with okay so we have a first and a second on this

167item currently for 8.3 are we prepared do we have any further discussion or are we prepared to move to a vote hearing none we have a first and a second on item 8.3 2024 2025 tenative agreement with Associated teachers of plaster CTA NE EA a TP starting with the student board all in favor say I I board I all opposed hearing none motion passes unanimously so just as far as a feedback loop on that um at the next meeting or just through Friday fax will you communicate that be all right I will work with Mr Wilson so that we're working together on super addressing this awesome thank you if he lets me item 8.4 2023 2024 audit report presented by Crow LLP yes Madam president I'd like to introduce Elizabeth sa from Crow she'll be

168presenting our audit reports for uh plus High School District and measure D and measure G good evening good evening all right so I have five reports to go through with you um um I'm Elizabeth sa I'm an audit partner with Crow LLP we are your external Auditors so we are hired by the board we work closely with management but our responsibility is to report to you so in the world of audit if you don't hear from us until the very end that's good news so no news is good news in the world of audit so all right so let's get started we have a 100 page report that I'm going to go through each page totally kidding um there is a nice summary at the very back of the report and so um if you

169want to open up let's start with the district I think the next one down there we go and if you go to page 86 of the PDF if you just type in like 86 at the top yeah 86 yeah all right so we come in once a year well that's simplistic we work with the district for about six months but we do it once a year um to go through and perform an audit over your financial statements to perform an audit over your federal Awards and then to perform an audit over your state Awards so I'm going to start with the um go up to the top a little bit yep perfect all right so I'm going to go over the results of the financial portion first so we issued an unmodified um opinion and

170that's the highest level of assurance that you can receive at the end of an audit and essentially um we're saying that we have audited your financial statements we've looked at your financials as a whole you'll notice there's multiple financials throughout that report um so we look at your financials as a whole and then we also look at your major funds like your general fund and then we look at all your other fund information and we per we perform various tests um to that and then issue an opinion say saying you know at the end of the day we agree with all the information that is in there we believe your financial statements are fairly stated in all material respects the material number is very important because we don't look at 100% in your transactions we

171perform sampling so um based off of our sampling guidelines and rules it's um fairly stated that's exactly what you want to see at the end of any audit is to have that unmodified opinion because you're a government agency we are also required to report to on internal controls so we don't audit all of your internal controls but if we are required to assess them so your controls around payroll processing your controls around cash dispersements going out the door it was very comforting that you were actually looking as a board member at the warrants and you actually had questions on it so as a as the auditor it makes me feel good um that you're actually looking at at that level um so at the end of the day if we noticed that there was a

172breakdown in controls or something that we would want to recommend we would note that we would note that up here so you can see it says material weaknesses identified there were none and it also says significant deficiencies not considered to be material weaknesses we kind of have grade levels for our deficiencies we have none to report so again exactly what you would want to see at the end of the day there and we also have no non-compliance material to the financial statements noted so if there was some sort of finding that was a big dollar amount that would pop up here um but we had nothing nothing to report all right Federal Awards um so you receive and expend quite a bit of federal dollars and you can see there we're calling out the two

173programs that we were required to test this year were special education and Child Nutrition so the federal government gives us a dictation of how we're supposed to test what we're supposed to test we don't just get to kind of pick willy-nilly we have to follow their guidelines of course and then we go through all of those procedures um again you can see in the middle there that we issued an unmodified opinion over your federal compliance um audit again highest level of assurance that you can receive at the completion of that and what that entails is various um compliance attri what they call as attributes and we do especially for special education we do extensive um expenditure testing making sure the expenditures were spent appropriately looking all the way down into payroll records for teachers Etc

174all right and then State Awards this is the biggest accomplishment in my opinion when a district has unmodified and the state compliance opinion um in all of those tests because the state of California issues out an audit guide each and every year with certain procedures that we have to follow um the whole laundry list is a little bit further up in the report that you could peruse if you ever got bored or needed some light reading at night you could go look up the audit guide on um education appeals panel and read through all of the different requirements this actually comprises up about 50% of our time now the um doing the state compliance audit whereas like probably 15 years ago it was maybe 20% so the state just keeps kind of increasing those compliance

175requirements so there's 38 um different things that we actually have to look at not all of those necessarily apply to the district but um most of them do because you have Charters you've got continuation Ed you've got all these different high school programs so so I say all of that because to get an unmodified opinion the state of California doesn't offer us the option of materiality when it comes to their audit so in your financial audit even in your federal audit there's thresholds that if it's below a certain level we consider it di Minimus and we don't have to necessarily report it State of California that's not a thing so if we go out and do for example we're looking at your um independent study contracts for your Charter and one student didn't sign the

176agreement that's automatically a finding that would show up in your report if one thing wasn't dated that shows up in your report as a finding um if we look at a student we say here here's an absence note we need to tie it back to the system and say was this properly reported in your system and it wasn't and it's just 018a that's a finding in your report so the fact that you scroll down for the next three pages and it's blank no findings no findings is a huge accomplishment not just for Peter's team and the business office but to all of your teachers the Confluence teachers the plaster teachers all of them that we interact with we talk to we interview um at random they never know if they're going to get picked s

177the element of surprise is really important and is actually a professional requirement in our world um so it's a big accomplishment across across the board even your facilities we actually are required to test your safety plans we're required to look at your facility reports um and make sure things are lining up so the fact that you have no findings is is a big accomplishment for for your entire District so any questions on that's the big report no okay all right so we will move to let's start with U measure G performance audit so as you know you have two Bond measures and um because of the consideration that they are considered prop top 39 bonds or they were passed by a simple majority of 55% you're required to have them audited each year throughout the

178expenditures until they're fully expended so the again the audit guide tells us exactly what we need to do and um we basically will pull this first report is the performance report so there's two reports for each measure the first one we're going to talk about is the performance audit this is what people are most interested in because this is talking about where the funds spent on the proper projects that were approved by the voters and the board so if you just scroll down to the next page and just go down to the very bottom yep right there yeah so that very last paragraph um reads the results of our procedures indicated that in all significant respects um pler Union High District expended measure G goo bond funds only for the specific projects developed by the

179governing board and approved by the voters so all of the expenditure testing that we did um we ensured that it was all spent on the proper projects that were approved this leads into the next report which would be the measure G financial statements and so this is similar to what we did with the district but on a much smaller scale is your financial statement specifically for measure G funds so if you scroll down just there we perfect there we go go so this is your point in time as of June 30 this is definitely not the act the actual balances as of now because we're six months out um from June 30 but as of June 30 you had about $3.5 million left in the fund balance to spend on your measure G projects and

180then the next page will show you the if you want to call income statement if you will so the interest income earned on the cash and then the money that was spent um that was subject to test as part of the audit um the rest of this is significant accounting policies just kind of talks about how things are accounted for and if you go to the very last or second to the last page second yeah there we go you can see here that we had no findings to report at the completion there were no items that were considered um out of compliance and there were no items that were considered um incorrectly reported so exactly what you'd like to see at the end all right and then measure D so this is for Del Oro

181that was very handy that you guys had it as measure D Del Oro that's how I remember and keep it straight when I'm going to all the CB's the rest of this week I get to go it's it's my pler week um okay so you can see here again for measure D same same drill the results indicated that everything was spent in accordance with the voter plan um and board plan so no findings were noted um in the performance report and then if you go over to those financial statements again and then go down to that balance sheet that you had there go back up no I think it's like the fifth page or Y yes okay so you can see there's much less left over deloro practically closed out I'm guessing that next year

182will be the final close out yes Final close out audit for that we'll we'll finish this out um but then if you want to go down to um the second to the last page I do want to talk about this um particular finding it's your one finding of the night um so this can cause some alarm to the board if they're seeing that there's a finding in the report so I just wanted to talk through this so first this is a financial accounting finding this is not an indication that the money was spent inappropriately so this the that it's talking about the expenditure that it's talking about was in compliance with the bond so that's why you're not going to see this this matter show up in that performance audit report um what happened was

183essentially there was a construction service that was the the activity and the work was incurred prior to June 30 the close but it wasn't acred for so it was accounted for it was just accounted for in the wrong year so the money was accounted for in 2425 so you will see that expenditure show up next year um we didn't have any concerns about the way the money was spent it just was kind of an isolated incident um with the close so any questions on that how many years have you been doing this for our district or is this your first year with us oh that's a good question I I'm not sure the length it's been a number of years yeah it's been a minute it's been a long time we've been engaged with Crow

184since the time I've been in this position but we have different people coming in because you can have the same firm yeah we're bringing different people so um Elizabeth was I remember in the in the first couple years and then the gap of time and then she's back again in a different in a different role with the fir yeah the law is written where you have to rotate audit Partners every six years so um I I will be signing I'll be signing this is my first year so okay yeah and um just as for any historical preference have we had a discrepancy like this before and obviously there's not a concern but I'm just wondering just for historical no um Elizabeth has been has known the history um and if the previous director of budget

185and accounting were here um she would tell you that it it's a bother for her because we've always prided ourselves on not H I mean yeah it's always that last page has one sentence um David will tell you the here has been on the two years you've been here we've never had a finding of any kind yep and even though this one is technically inconsequential per se in terms of everything was spent the right way just not recorded in the right year it's still something that we would take say personally just something that we want to watch out for our team yeah I appreciate that I appreciate your work and I also appreciate our staff just killing it on there that's a big deal and clearly um eyes have been dotted and tees have been

186crossed and I appreciate all of your work on that and finding even something that wasn't inconsequential yes we often get questions of you know do you are you really looking do you ever find anything especially when we have districts like blasser that are very clean you've always had very um you highly value competent staff in your business office and we definitely have districts and clients that that's not necessarily the case and it's messy um so you guys are always a breath of fresh air so I knew that the prior director would be just mortified because she was a perfectionist she wanted everything to the dollar um but we do find things we do look we do try appreciate that yep any other questions board all righty okay have a great night thank you very much

187appreciate you hanging out here with us till till bedtime it's nice yeah awesome well thank you for your work thank you do we have a motion I move approval a second we have a first and a second on action item 8.4 2023 2024 audit reports presented by Crow LLP any further discussion all in favor starting with the board I I board I I all oppose motion passes unanimously all right we're getting close we've only got a page in a something little left all right um item 8.5 resolution number 12 2425 finding the proposed deloro High School softball stadium lights installation project to be exempt under cqa and adopting categorical exemptions and approving the project and authorizing filing of notice of exemption under project approval yes Madam president so uh several months ago I was approached

188by um the Delo staff admin along with representatives from the softball booster group um with the intent of continuing with the progress of work they've been doing there theyve installed the soft a scoreboard a while ago and now they're looking at lights um to go back in history a little bit the softball field was not always located where it is currently it's where the pool used to be where the pool is now and part of that transition was trying to finish off the stadium eventually and that included putting some lights in um not at District costs that was never a funded item but um through fundraising efforts so I've been working uh with the parent Delo Jen Christensen who is part of the booster group uh is here tonight in the crowd it was mentioned

189earlier about a fundraiser that she is doing to help raise funds for this project this is um a big step for this for this project in regards to if this is cleared um what we're asking for is uh resolution to be approved by the board or recommended approval of the board it'll then be submitted to the county to be basically posted for 35 days for anybody who wants to speak to it once that clears it just clears that hurdle technically uh since you're putting lights in um many sequ exemptions um pass very easily because they don't have this kind of thing but lights may be big speakers for a football team those things would entail um going through a SQL exemption and so we qualify but this is is a process of Step of getting

190the board to approve approve that I'm submitting it um if M Christensen and the group is um successful in fundraising that then some other steps coming forward to the board and then be looking at um engaging we would be going through the process of advertising for um construction because this would be anywhere from a $4 to $500,000 project um so it' be going through the advertising process um and then finding someone but um we've had a good conversation with my my term has always been the money has to be in the bank before this project would start the district is taking on some costs um there were some legal costs involved with this this is part of the share it would not make any sense for the district not to take any share of cost

191with this considering the amount of fundraising that is being hoped by the booster group but right now it's just mostly legal cost in getting this part done Miss Christenson has done a lot of L work on her end with the booster group um I don't know if you want to say a few things real quickly about it Jen the the the project maybe just to give the board up since they're all new and the in the fundraising piece real quick welcome push the button so it's green it's on oh it's onk no it's not I don't think it is there it is now green means on okay um I am a Delo grad but I'm also a parent my daughter is a sophomore and she's a softball player so when she started freshman year um

192I was like oh we're transporting them off site still fine but I'm also like let's get lights installed um um seems like a lot of car washes though what could we do you know to really like really get everyone pumped up and raise a lot of money in a short amount of time so also as a concerned parent and then hearing all of the teachers and administrators discuss the cell phone issue right so that's where I had the idea we' do the 30-day digital detox our girls will be handing in their smartphones and going without social media and uh blue lights smartphones for 30 days they will be provided uh flip phones with call only purposes but there's no blue lights and no social media so anyway we are doing that it starts on jul

193uh January 31st we have the San Francisco Giants a mental health Team coming to Delo high school we have a lot of exciting things surrounding it uh one of which one of our players offered to be the first um teenager in aiman clinic history to be brain scanned both prior to the digital detox as well as after so we'll have medical evidence as to what these cell phones and social media do to sorry I'm shaking I haven't eaten and I'm nervous you can see like I've got like flamingo legs going on right now that's okay um so it'll be really neat to show this study and we can you know districtwide of course what these things actually really do to their little brains and uh I hope our girls hope to spread awareness we will

194be doing community service project throughout those 30 days Etc obviously trying to bring in as much revenue as possible within those 30 days do I know for a fact we can raise half a million dollars in 30 days I don't but I know we will end up with a lot more than we started with so yeah pretty amazing thank you yeah and way to think outside the box and find some Creative Solutions and something that could potentially we all know these kids are on their phone they're living on their phone my kids are living on their phone and it's awful and so I'm excited to hear the data and the fact that uh one of the players has stepped up to do that super cool so please keep us posted on that for sure we'll

195do absolutely and if you want to come see the Logan web and the Giants and you want to support them our tickets are on sale right now we have a website okay so looking up to light up.com will you please email that to us absolutely thank you so much thank you well thank you um just so that the board knows yeah we've been working we did have um some some companies just come out and work with Jen just unofficially kind of give her an idea of what she'd have to raise type of thing cool all with understanding that this is going to have to go out for bid and so very clear understanding of that and on behalf of the superintendent we recommend approval do I have a motion I'll move to approve we have

196a first and a second on item 8.5 resolution number 12425 finding the proposed Del High School uh soft Stadium lights installation project to be exempt under squa and adopting categorical exemptions and approving the project and authorizing filing of notice of exemption under project approval that was a long one all right on resolutions trusty Lake and those um it's a roll call vote so we will go one by one um starting with our student board all in favor say I actually I take it back not all individually one by one say hi Claire I hi trusty Underwood hi trusty Lake hi trusty Jeff hi trusty Spade I motion passes resolution passes unanimously all right item 8.6 Services agreement with Comprehensive Drug Testing Incorporated CDT for 2024 25 through 2026 27 uh yes Madam president and so

197I'm going to rely on my colleague Miss elen Del Alo to help out with us a little bit um this has been I think two years in the making um as referenced in The quick summary uh s sp88 is a law that enhanced um drug testing for um employees who drive students in vehicles District vehicles and so in the past it's always been bus drivers things like that the law was updated to now account for the fact that we transport a lot of our students in Vans 10 passenger vans s passenger vans and we have many employees um we have some teachers uh we have AIDs that will transport Kids U Confluence the ACT program um a lot of our um instructional AIDS and special ed transport students in these vans that we have purchased

198throughout the years um at all the school sites and so we have been developing this process um we we have board policy that was updated several years ago we reached out to our negotiation Partners um in regards to that policy how things would work this is the agreement with this direct testing company it's local here um in in a nutshell we have about it could range anywhere from 20 to 25 drivers depending on how many we have at one time um we have a number of 5% per quarter would be requested it's a random drawing of how these people are picked if you do 5% let say we have 20 that's one person so we're not talking a lot each time um what would happen is they'd get a notice they would have to report

199if they're at Plaster deloro they would say the site these companies would come to the school site and do the testing and then that information would be reported back to the HR department um if you're looking at anywhere from four to six people a year based off the travel and so forth it could range anywhere from $300 to $3500 a year for this service because we are doing it mobile which means the employee would be at the school site we wouldn't take time out of their day to be taken out and that kind of thing there is an exception that forc hill teacher would have to be dried down the hill to get tested and we would have to incur The Substitute costs um for that um but again hopefully since it's a 5% that

200randomly would not occur too often to impact any teaching instruction they were all notified well in advance this has been under process for a couple years they were aware that by driving the the district purchased vehicles to with students would require this and the ones on the list have all voluntarily Chen chosen to continue to drive or it is a part of their job description okay and please not this is just has to do with the drug testing part if unfortunately something were to come out positive that would be a whole different I mean these guys this group does not address that that would become a Personnel issue okay so on behalf of the superintendent Acting Superintendent we recommend approval all right we have a motion I move approval I'll second we have a first

201and a second on item 8.6 Services agreement with comprehensive drug testing Inc CDT for 20242 through 2026 27 any further discussion or questions with that being said all in favor um please say I starting with the student board I I board I I'll oppose motion passes unanimously item 8.7 approval of the Mau V virtual Charter Academy's Federal addendum and who's on this one Aon TR yeah great question Aon yeah thank youin that was in addition to the um original LC cap and so we just completed it about a week or so ago and um I'll give Kristen Miller our assistant principal a lot of credit she does great work with a lot of the writing and so I believe from our business it felt like everything was uh in line and in compliance great do

202I have a motion for item 8.6 I move approv have a first I'll second trusty Lake don't be shy over there Jump On In we're I know there's a snack there's a snack and coffee back there item 8.6 uh Services agreement with comprehensive drug testing ink CDT for 2024 2025 through 2026 27 what am I talking about I'm making up stuff see it is getting late 8.7 thank you for keeping me on track approval of the mighty virtual Charter Academy's Federal addendum any further discussion or questions I just wanted to say um just give you a quick shout out um the Mau virtual Charter Academy staff um and your report which I knew because I've met with you guys but um there's 0% less than two years teaching in that field everyone I believe has

203master's degrees or Beyond and um and there are 0% ineffective teachers and just massive success it's a hugely growing uh program the graduation was huge last year and just thank you guys for all the work that you're doing all right with that being said all in favor starting with the student board I I board I I all oppose motion passes item 8.8 Chromebook purchase request for the 2025 2026 school year take it away Peter yes Madam president so if there are some technical questions I'll ask car seura our director of it to come up but this is just our yearly purchase of the Chromebooks um RTI has been the supplier for the last several years um I know that Carlos and his team have worked diligently every year to work with RTI to make sure

204that every year the Chromebook that we get is better than the one they've gotten the year before and so what you have in front of you is the contract with them and the amount and on behalf of the Acting Superintendent we recommend approval do I have a motion I'll move to approve I second I like it in things up 8.8 Chromebook purchase request for the 2025 2026 school year any further questions or discussion all right all in favor starting with student board I I board I all oppose motion passes item 8.9 BP 95155 sex offenders notification update yes so Madame President um as Mr Wilson had briefed the board earlier whenever we have uh BP or ar updates um two things for me one is new law or has come up that you have to

205update it and or put it in place or you already have the BP in place and there's an update so you should update it to keep up with the language and we do have this BP on the books we don't have an AR it's optional so we don't have one in there um but the notification change that came up is according to a penal code um we are supposed to when we are directed or hold of information U regarding um an sex offender information that's given to us by law enforcement we're supposed to follow their Direction how they're supposed to disseminated so this BP update clar clarifies that um we also took out some language that was in there before because we do not have a district police department or paid security Force yes we

206do have sros that doesn't fall under this jurisdiction so the language in there were stricken um we did not want our principales taking on the responsibility of saying yes you can come on our campus and we'll give weeks notice if if you read the part that been crossed out that's not going to meet that's our recommendation that that not be in there and so that part was taken out and so on behalf of the superintendent we recommend approval of BP 351525 do I have a motion I'm move approval second hey now item 8.9 has been first and seconded I think your first second of your tenure on the board Dr Lake uh board policy um 35155 sex offender notifications update any questions starting with the student board all in favor say I I I board

207I I'll oppose motion carries unanimously item uh 8.11 BB 912 board member electronic communications update uh one before that 91 Mercy 8 save me uh n 10 BB I see I checked it see I need a snack that's what's happening BB 9010 public statements yes uh so this is a an updated board bylaw for public statements reflecting a new court decision um this is really talking about mostly um Court law that has said that a court a district official who limits or prevents critics from speaking on um social media or deletes their posts could violate the First Amendment um and and there's other updated language in there as well for public statements um for your recomend my recommendation and your approval great I know I have some feedback on this we've got a first do

208we have a second a second okay um I did want to can we open that up real quickly I have have some s suggested amendments that full striketh through on paragraph one I understand that they were trying to um what they were trying to do and obviously the bigger issue here is is um this change with the law and this just so so for some historical um perspective csba recently wrote an amus brief that went all the way to the Supreme Court and the Supreme Court um you know ruled on all of this and so it's something to be aware of especially new board members that as you're Eng aging um on social media that you should have a disclaimer that this is you know your opinion only but I but I bring you back

209to the first paragraph because um I'm I'm not a total fan of the their replacement and I'm going to share why um one um I believe that the first paragraph was more clear that there's a responsibility for board members to express themselves because you know we serve the public interest and in order for the public to understand the position of the board or the position of the trustee you've got to disclose where you're at on an issue and the whole intention behind the brown act and transparency is so that the community the public remains in control of the instrument that they created and if the trustees don't disclose where they're at on an item especially when they're not in agreement with the majority it's a disservice to the community so I'm not comfortable with um

210with the new language and I'll give you my um amended version here in a second second um so there's a sentence that I would like to scratch and add um from the original and the new and then the last is it talks about to abide the last few words of the the new paragraph one um to abide by established protocols I actually think with a board member protocols don't hold any real weight with a board member it's it's bylaws it's the laws of the land not the protocol and so I'd like to switch out protocols with bylaws so this is how uh my recommend uh recommended uh Amendment would go it would be the new sentence of one which reads the governing board recognizes the responsibility of board members in their role as Community leaders

211to participate in public discourse on matters of Civic or Community interest including those involving the district then I would insert a period there move uh strike through the rest of that sentence and insert the old sentence two which states the board believes that effective board members have a responsibility to express themselves whether in agreement or disagreement with the board majority in ways that promote the board's ability to govern the district and then the final sentence um would remain the same aside from switching out the last word protocols with bylaws do you guys have any thoughts or feedback on that not sure about that second paragraph um the last sentence how starting with however MH I get the point that's trying to be made um but it almost suggests that like we shouldn't be expressing our

212views at all kind of I don't know it's kind of how I read it yeah you know what I had I had that initial Instinct too and as I kind of unpacked that sentence I felt like um the first part was talking about board members individually and their perspective and the last was talking about delegating Authority and at a certain point we have a majority vote that we're communicating the decision of the majority because we don't hold any Authority or power on our own it's it's the board's decision so um the way I read it which it does obviously however to ensure communication of a consistent unified message regarding District issues which to me District issues once we've taken action there's a authorities call the board members are expected to respect the authority of the

213board to choose its representative which typically um is the board president or our are designated through our communications director um to communicate its positions and to and abide by established bylaws and then the rest of it goes through you know how we do that but essentially I think that that that's how I read it are there I feel like that sentence doesn't even need to be there with the following paragraphs with which outline what the board spokesman's or board spokesman's job is and like it does Jeremy what sentence are you talking about the one that starts with however to ensure communication of a consistent yep could we zoom in on that so start with here however however I can see your point because it addresses it below right but I like your Amendment to the

214your change to the the beginning of the paragraph Okay do either of you trusty lake or trusty Underwood have feedback on on the final sentence and are you comfortable with the revisions I suggested yeah it's interesting an example would be saying the board would choose a representative issues your microphone I'm trying to think of an example where this would be appli apped and is this saying that the board would appoint somebody to be to communicate about issues regarding issues in the district yeah so typically um so if we have a board spokesperson so it speaks to it in the in the next section and that is typically either the board president or design uh we delegate it to our Communications officer and so um typically that's how it goes now you still have the First

215Amendment and you still can speak and and IT addresses that obviously nobody nobody's trying to negate someone's voice but yeah that's just in in certain circumstances reflecting potential action that has occurred or that we've given Direction and I'm communicating as a board president on behalf of the board regarding an item yeah my only thought is that you know will you turn on your mic trusty Underwood please yeah I'm I'm kind of concerned that this is really taken away an individual's right to express thoughts and feelings regarding District policy and I think that's important not to be taken away if it's an official uh board statement then I I concur that the president or the superintendent can get that message but if someone's asking me in a public forum about what what are you guys doing

216in terms of uh Competency Based education I'm going to talk about I I I have a right to talk about that I don't want to feel that I'm being censored or taken away where I have to say well you got to talk to our superintendent about that or you got to talk to our president that kind of concerns me you know freedom of speech and I I don't want to lose that I won't I mean that's who we are so I guess I'm differentiating two things one if it's a public statement that the board has adopted that needs to be go out to the press or someone yeah the president or the superintendent but if it's someone in a public uh Forum asking me about something I have the right to speak on that and

217I I don't want to see that taken away I don't know if that's what this is referring to but I think there's an ambiguity in there that kind of infers that you can't speak then only the president can speak or the superintendent so that bothers me yeah please this is trying to address the changes in our modern culture with social media this was last re revised in 2014 yep and so it's I'm just reading through this for the first time I haven't seen this and so who's got the mouse Sarah Sarah's killing it over there on that Mouse yeah I mean I think it warrants further discussion I wouldn't be prepared to like vote on this right now if is is your hesitation based on that um the sentence that truste Jeff um alluded to

218that felt um like some ambiguity there or is it in general in whole uh more to do with uh Mr Underwood yeah just it sorry it requires some some time to kind of read through and consider yeah yeah sure just um spit ball in here if we strict like we struck out the final sentence of um the new paragraph with the amendments I suggested if that was where the hesitation was um just because it's regarding the unified message regarding District district issues because we might have different opinions on District issues um if that was removed would you feel comfortable moving forward were you were you saying that there was some redundancy because it talks about it further down yeah yeah Y and also it leaves yeah in my mind it leaves that tone like you

219know be careful what you say I agree with what David's talking about like we have an obligation to speak dark and sck about what we believe what going on y That's why I wanted to bring back in SEC sentence two from the struck out original line because that speaks specifically to that if you read Sarah would you zoom in um on it's not one sentence to me it's there's a few it's the whole General uh direction that this is saying you know it's kind of like saying to me there's censorship unless it's one or another person you know and I I think it's my obligation if someone asks me of what's going on you know I'm not going to divulge confidential information but I'm going to say Hey you know this is what we're working

220on you know we got some caveats there you know I I think I have to do be able to do that and my the general feeling it's not one sentence it's the whole tone thing kind of pushes that at me I'm just tell you I always see I don't like it um no I think this is a good good conversation I so if we're we're not going to be able to come to consensus on some changes tonight would the board be interested in creating an ad hoc committee to address this outside of here and then we'll we'll carry on tonight um would we like to table this or create an ad hoc can we table this to the next meeting sure so I move to table this to the next meeting okay well we can

221we can table it to the next meeting but if it's written like this I can't support it there's no way I would support this so I think that potentially we need to come back with some amendments so do we have any interest in an ad hoc two two board members will work with staff I don't know that it'll come back the next meeting it might come back a couple meetings from now but then we can unpack it and then potentially have some of these addressed would you be interested in uh working on ad hoc well I just again it's I I the only thing I can agree with in this is if it's a public significant issue that the public needs to know the media needs to know let the superintendent do that or you

222do that as president that's fine you're our our designated president but I don't want to be feel that I'm being censored or I have to think should I speak to this or not speak to this I mean on the board I was an elected person and if someone asked me a question I and it's not confidential I'm going to respond to it but so this this whole thing just kind of pushes that censorship in my face it really does I don't like it um I think uh trusty Emory and I would be interested in uh great forming a committee and perfect hopefully bring something back that you would be happy with I think you and I have the same view so yeah great so as it stands um trusty Jeff and um trusty Lake if

223you guys would find time to work on that and work with staff to to bring it back okay well we're going to table item 8.10 BB 910 public statements for now to a future date all right moving along item 8 uh .11 board bylaw 912 board member electronic communications update we may find ourselves in a similar simar situation situation here um this one again is is an update this one specifically um is talking about um public statements and complaints um and um electronic communications so I I think president Spade you had some feedback for this one as well so let me see here so yeah so on item first do we have um a motion on item this item I'll move to approve so we can have discussion a motion on what on um on

224member commun me board member what we're just talking about on a new one which uh we're on 8.11 okay okay I'll second for the purpose of discussion um just a couple things on this I um reading through this some of the Amendments um aside from the electronic communications portion um hold on let me see here no I was actually mostly okay with this one it's mine the next bylaw um I think in the the middle line there weren't it we may have to um get more Direction because this one is supposed to conform to the one that we just tabled okay great so we need to take both back probably perfect so ad hoc committee now you have two understood all right so we're also tbling item 8.11 okay moving along item um 8 O

225nope excuse me yeah 8.12 okay yeah okay 8.12 board bylaw uh 9220 governing board elections this is where I had some feedback so two parts to this one um an update and then a new we do not have an exhibit um 9220 is an exhibit with new with a non-exhaustive list of offenses um for making someone ineligible to become a school board member so one's new and um not existing in our board bws at this point right so the exhibit is is non-existing the other correct the board bylaw 9220 is which I had some feedback on so um in paragraph 4 the board encourages all candidates to become knowledgeable about the role of a board member of board members the superintendent or design shall provide all candidates um with information we struck out um shall

226provide all candidates and then inserted language where the board candidate upon the request of the candidate um the essentially that the district would be communicating about their responsibilities and expectations given this the former language um this bylaw was violated ated in in um 2024 election by our former superintendent and it's not um subjective it's effect because I know that not all candidates running for election were contacted um and I felt reading through this and I and I did note this during that time but things happen quickly um you know and I think that the problems associated with with um putting it on the candidates um you know upon their request to have some of these communications is a problem because anybody who's run a campaign knows that it's that it's complicated and I feel that

227um it's important that we set the precedent and the lead um to establish Communication open communication and dialogue with people potentially running for office and I and I don't think it should just be on the candidate upon their request to have some Communications at at the point where we had two new board members this past time around no one had communicated with the winners um to my knowledge um and they've confirmed that with me and they didn't have certain dates blocked on their schedule for csba or other other um opportunities for training and and I feel like it put them at a a slight disadvantage coming onto the board because there was a lack of communication on the district so I actually don't feel comfortable with the changes in in paragraph 4 I think that

228it should remain the way that it was previously I know that in 2022 our former superintendent did contact me and asked me to come in and shared information with me which was very helpful and I months in advance saved dates on my calendar should I win and and I felt like that was really really helpful so um I would support the rest of this uh bylaw um update but remain paragraph four with the original writing I agree with that okay any further discussion questions on that okay yeah I just feel like we we should lead um and if if somebody's going to put their hat in the ring let's open the line of communication and make sure we're starting the relationship on the right foot come what may yeah I'm okay with that okay all

229right so we have a first and a second um and do we do not do we have a motion I'll move to approve with the Amendments that you suggested okay do we have a second it's been uh first and seconded item 8.12 board bylaw and the exhibit 9220 governing board elections update new with the amendments to paragraph 4 remaining in the old version not the new version any further discussion all in favor board I I all I'll oppose motion passes unanimously all right item 8.13 California School Board Association csba agreement agreement for Consulting Services 2024 20 through 2025 with csba consultant Dr Sapa I don't even know how to pronounce that yo something uh we'll provide the good Beginnings Workshop to the phc Board of Trustees um the date is going to change which uh

230Dr cetti already mentioned um just as a sidebar to that um I did send out a doodle poll with a few different dates um I don't believe you've seen that yet or trust oh you did yeah are any of those dates available chall Tuesday are challenging for you or Friday so so our trainer is only available um the 24th 25th 26th of March which is those three days right so and we have something on the 26th we have a student student voice a student engagement at at cax on the 26th and this is a 5 hour training so we have a scheduling conflict are you sure I think just you know a point of reference I do think that um workshops are important I think training is important we have a very green board and

231this obviously um would provide an opportunity for us to um to have some training but we do have a public comment on this um item Pete constant good evening uh thanks for giving me the time to speak my name is Pete conston I'm a professor of political science criminal justice and governance at Jessup University just down the way chair of the Public Policy Department and director of The Institute for Public Policy I have about 40 years of experience in public agencies 14 years working as a public employee in law enforcement eight years as a large city city council member elected to office four years as a school board member I've been a public employee union leader on the board of a a public safety Union and a board member on both profit and nonprofit boards

232I wanted to let you know that Jessup University at The Institute for Public Policy provides this type a training uh we do this training as a community service as part of our give back to the community under our mission of being a nonprofit We have provided training for other agencies in your community we've trained the kfax city council the Lumis Town Council the Grass Valley City Council we provided a variety of trainings that have raged um on a number of different topics forms and structures of governance the policy governance model uh with components of Mutual purposes roles of the board roles of the administration uh governance team leadership team administrative Team Dynamics direct and indirect policy governance ends and means distinctions structure and process balanced and engaged P participation uh balancing personal perspectives views and

233priorities versus Board perspectives views and priorities a topic you just uh spoke about uh components of decision- making such as ethical decision- making personal individual decision making and then how you translate into that Collective as collective decision- making of the board board and then owning the decision making that the board uh takes uh we provide training in setting priorities strategic planning and budget areas both in the shortterm and long-term uh meeting those objectives we provide training in the brown act related to open meeting requirements communicating within the bounds of the brown act which can be difficult given uh the changing landscape we see in our um judicial rulings uh what is a meeting what's not a meeting which is uh I think just as important uh publ public noticing public comment close session the social

234media implications not only the ones that you were speaking about but uh some of the others that come out of some assembly bills uh conflict of interest um not only the political reform act but how it impacts public trust the um ideas of incompatible offices contract conflict of interestes and government 1090 conflicts common law conflicts that a lot of times people don't think about and then of course the policy versus politics um how do you make the transition from a candidate running for office even prior to that being an advocate uh for policies transitioning to a candidate for policies then transitioning from a candidate to actually being a board member and then having to transition again perhaps campaigning while being a board member those are all issues we provide training on we've got a lot

235of uh deep experience this is something that again saves some money because we don't charge for it it's part of our community service um we're here we're local we're literally your neighbors and we can be much more flexible on timing with you as well so I just want to make sure you were aware of that I would have loved to have told you this sooner I just didn't know you guys were going to be talking about it if we can be of service we would love to be thank you if you have any questions I'll be be here thank thank you yeah that's amazing to have it in our back backyard and for free we all like some training for free all right yeah no right so um this item is about the csba contract

236obviously um we still have some scheduling potential issues if if we're unable to when would you know if you're able to make one of the dates in March work trusty Lake it has to be one of those days it's already so right now uh we haven't entered the contract yet and so if if we needed do you know potentially Dr cetti if if we needed to make sure that we could clear some schedules if we could bring this back in February um or do we need to make the decision to hold the date for her at this time um I would have to to reach out to her to see what what her availability is okay um they they they we rushed it because we thought we were doing the 25th and they got the

237contract to us um and the 25th of February is not working out so um I I don't mind reaching out to her we can try to figure that out see in the meantime you know I don't if we're not um if we're not entering anou or a contract and there was another date that worked with Jessup potentially I think we're first of all we need more than one we're going to need some further training so I feel like that's an amazing um gift we have right here in town and we could try to figure out another date potentially with um with Jessup um I guess the question is are should we should we hold until we know we can work the schedule um trusty lake or would you or do we do we want to

238do B in conjunction with the training any thoughts on this my thoughts are save the the kids $3,700 and go with William Jessup for free if they can give this comparable training which it sounds like they can okay I agree okay how do you feel about it I agree okay yes well I think that that may be a wrap a wrap of item um 8.13 we'll have local training flexibility yeah so we'll so um so we can get it on your calendars could either you communicate with me or Dez so we can get it on the calendar so we can make sure everybody has it on their calends yeah would you please thank you yeah we take a quick um five minute recess hey Mrs oh we'll do it afterwards I was GNA I was

239going to suggest pushing out one of my reports to next month since I have two support that where everyone else is at I support that e e e s okay item 9.1 nine staff reports 9.1 student outcomes update I just spoke with Mr Wilson and we are going to postpone that board uh report or excuse me that uh staff report until the next meeting so we're going to table item 9.1 and bring it back so we're going to go ahead and move to item 9.2 yes so we're going to we're going to hold off on the first report we're going to table 9.1 and we're going to go to 9.2 all right so awesome thank you board uh that's a sign Mrs Barry will be tag teaming this with me we'll be doing this together

240uh just update on life skills uh curriculum and culminating activities along with some discussion about new grad requirements Mike Greer's ready for my long presentation in your honor sir stop on the timer uh I might have a slight reputation um but good evening board um so again as as Trent indicated we're going to be talking about this together um part of this is giving a background on life skills and its evolution in our district to now being a part of our graduation requirement um so I can't quite read that anymore so I should have printed it thanks Sarah um the 50s make it even worse than the 40s did um so but the history of life skills basically um emerged from one of our first elcap meetings actually that we held um it was actually

241in the class or High School cafet IA that thankfully is no more in a beautiful learning Commons right now um but it was one of those combined meetings with um um Chana high school at the time was part of it classer high school thank you my do um and out of that um really emerged a call to action by Community by staff by kids um to Institute a life skills course and that began began kind of Dan Wilson's journey to create this course um because it was something he was passionate about something he was interested in and really something he and I had a lot of conversation about one of the things that I I love about the life skills class that's offered right now is the fact that it was pretty much created in

242collaboration with students Dan went to his classes and said what would you like to know and they spewed out a lot of things they would like to know my own children who I feel like I prepared well said gosh we could have really used that class Mom I'm like I told you how to do this but right it's different when you hear it from a teacher it's different when you hear it from someone other than your parent um anyway so they've Incorporated a lot of uh variety into the course to be the life skills class that it is today you'll see up there um it says course description that's the course description that I pulled off of his syllabus and so most of the life skills classes are based off of that some of the

243success and some of the um I don't know missteps maybe with the life skills class is that this was it this is real teacher dependent right Dan Wilson had a a real passion for this class and even though other teachers have done it and have done it well um he kind of just has this innate ability to kind of present this information um when it became a graduation requirement a few years ago this is the first senior class that is going through it as a graduation requirement um part of it was it offset cardio health and so PE teachers were the ones that were basically kind of asked to teach it or given for shot to teach it um except for pler who it did remain with Dan Wilson and then there are a couple

244of PE teachers Karly cyer Smith and Zack Heath right now that currently teach it John Hilton has in the past who's now at deloro I believe he's teaching it there yes um um anyway and then kfax has a variety Aaron at Forest till has had pretty much Bobby I think um doing it and so it it's kind of evolved over time um the life skills teachers did all come together last year they created proficiency scales um you'll see in the parenthesis up there they have five proficiency scales and those are the titles of the proficiency scales that they have um it was based off of both the life skills curriculum and the rise teachers all of them came together um and found kind of those Common Ground common areas where they could U measure student

245achievement in those Arenas um what I also listed up there was what each of the comprehensive sites are doing not to ignore m in um Confluence but as you heard tonight Confluence is all about life skills um they do have the class plus they're doing it on a on The Daily and then Mau works it into their classes as well but cfax currently they um they're kind of in a bridge right now because prior to this year um plaster kept it as a senior class others could have it as a junior or a senior class kfax started off with it being Juniors they're now transitioning it to where it will be seniors but a lot of their Juniors this year had currently taken it so they're offering less sections next year but those sections will

246increase next year which is what you see up there on the board um and I'll tell why it's primarily a senior class in a minute um Del Oro they have um all seniors four sections of life skills four of Rise one with Delora teacher and four sections of asynchronous of Rise one with o Sierra College teacher to meet the life skills requirement Forest Hill all seniors one section of life skills two of Rise one one section of personal finance that does count as a life skills graduation requirement for us and pler is all seniors with six sections of life skills three sections of Rise one with Sierra College teacher and a few students have been able to take rise one with Laura sers at my do each term so that's the breakdown of section allocations

247that are attributed to the life skills curriculum part of the reason it went to primarily a senior class it's kind of twofold one if you ask most of the students it fits the topics that you talk about they're getting ready to go postsecondary to whatever their choices are they're looking to maybe move out be on their own apply to colleges trade schools military um Workforce whatever it may be and so it's a lot more pertinent to their immediate needs than just one year removed so we we found a lot of success with that when it was instituted as an elective first at pler and it was a really um highly enrolled elective the second reason and will be kind of slide two is it was one of those um classes where it's a great place

248to house what has now become our senior culminating activity we need to have it housed somewhere and it fits largely with what the curriculum is for life skills and so hence the transition in talking with the teachers and collaboration how do you see this would this work this was the agreement we made really a couple years ago to start transitioning to this model in anticipation of this being the graduation requirement this year so a little culminating activity history um years ago we had what was called senior project um senior project was a really robust program in our district it was a graduation requirement if you walk the halls in the hunter building at deloro um and I think the 100 building still at pler um you're going to see I'm I'm sure they're somewhere in

249kofax for still too um but you you see tiles and the tiles were um made by seniors at the end of their completion of senior project and then each class has them hung up on the wall so much so that when Renovations were made on campuses people said no don't get rid of those and by people I mean probably the students who created them and some of those are our employees today so because we also have a lot of alumni who come back and teach for us or work for us in some capacity but the senior project at the time was a graduation requirement it involved a research paper it involved a project and it involved a presentation to the community um you had to pass it to graduate and it was a pretty long-standing

250tradition eventually though as things evolve and change um there was a a group um and I think haded by our Superintendent at the time Dave horsey who felt that maybe senior project was missing the mark a little bit it wasn't as um robust enough to really look at the skills of kind of that 21st century student and things that they needed and so a decision was made a proposal was made by the superintendent decision by the board was made to not have senior project as a graduation requirement anymore however senior project did one thing really well well it did a lot of things well but one of the things it did really well was it enabled the community to come onto our campuses and see our students in action and that's important and they got

251to see a different side of our student for me someone who was at class for a long time businesses all the time those kids what are they doing right well this gave them a chance to see no no here are really what our kids are doing and to see them getting ready to embark on a New Journey accompl a project talk about it talk about um their successes their um failures there whatever it may be it gave them that opportunity and it gave the the community an opportunity to come in and and hear that and ask questions and and dialogue with our high school students which was really important so the board at the time wanted some type of culminating activity to return and schools have been struggling a little bit with that ever since

252as far as what does that look like I would say most have aired towards the side of a mock interview um and those have been really successful I think um some of you in here have been a part of those in one capacity or another and I do think the students get a lot of value from that and it's nice to bring that community in it kind of started slow because 2020 took us all off the rails and um so businesses had a hard time coming back but I think we're getting some good clientele to bring that back um most schools kfax Del Oro and Forest still do it one time a year um at the end of the spring term pler does it twice at the end of the fall term and the end

253of the spring term pler just did theirs um Jess I know you were there um I think they had 98 seniors go through and they had it's up there somewhere um about 37 yeah different um community members MERS and business people come in so essentially a student would come in their train normally in their life skills class cover letters resumés interview tips and tricks and then they interview with business professionals and they have an opportunity for that business professional to provide feedback for them they're going to have to interview at some point whether it's it's for a job a program in school so it does have um high value in that respect but logistically again it's still something that's difficult in that it has to be housed in some type of a class life skills

254was a vehicle for that for now um I know at Forest H till they're doing it in economics and right now cfax I think is doing it through um English 12 and their history class questions on any of that and then I'm going turn over to you perfect thank you all right so thank you Kim so just wanted to talk about uh the grad requirements and some issues that are coming up with uh new grd requirements from the state and how we uh have to proceed going forward so most of this is just information that I think you guys are going to have to make a decision about regarding a few things uh and just giving you some uh foreshadowing of some of the things that we will be bringing to your attention as well

255so uh our current phsc graduation requirements that we established uh when we redid in 201 as Kim talked about we added the life skills class uh we also added a couple other components to our graduation and that was the addition of two CTE courses two de courses or two apib courses to align with uh the College and Career indicator that the state had uh established for a total of 260 total credits that a student needs to graduate from our Comprehensive High Schools the goal of the graduation requirement committee uh was to increase the number of students who are a tog and CCI uh provide onrack ability for for students to maintain uh that status for as long as they could and as Kim pointed out um also a response to the lcap Committees that were

256happening about uh student uh parents and community members asking for sort of you're doing a great job with teaching our kids academics but they don't know about life and so uh that was added into our uh graduation requirements the issue issue was that uh to accommodate for that extra course we had to do something with cardio health and so we dropped cardio health and because Health isn't necessarily a course requirement for graduation it is a curricular requirement we were going to distribute that curriculum in two places pe9 and our those life skills class uh the challenge with that uh was a couple things is usually pe9 classes are about 45ish students as especially at our bigger schools plaster and deloro not a lot of classroom sizes or you know that can manage uh that component

257and uh the other issue was we were waiting to teach life some of those important Health Concepts till their 12th grade year in life skills and we just feel uh that it might be better to teach them in n9th grade as opposed to 12th grade about drinking drugs vaping sex all of the things uh to give them more information before has a post to the to the end um so those are some of the issues go ahead and click uh next slide so we have two new course requirements I'm sure you guys have possibly heard of this uh I know I've we've mentioned it in some Friday facts and some other issues um and I'll talk through these the two courses that the state has put forward are the ethnic studies course which is uh

258we're supposed to quote unquote offer a course next uh next year and it' be a graduation requirement for that um for the uh class of 2030 uh and then the financial literacy course uh which will be a graduation requirement for the class of 31 or yeah 2031 and the interesting thing about the economics or the the financial literacy class is it financial literacy will count for the economic requirement but the economic requirement will not count for the financial literacy class and in doing that they really are going to eliminate economics being taught and a former economics teacher um that's a bummer because I loved economics but there's no real place to fit both of those in uh the the master schedule um so in regard to e ethnic studies currently there's no money from the

259state to sustain the course and within the ab 101 that put that course as a graduation requirement there was a a statute in there that a clause that said if it's not funded then the school districts don't have to um uh pursue offering the course until it's funded and it's currently not funded under um the budget from that was just released by the governor however um there is talk that uh by the May revise and other things that money will be put into the budget to cover this ethnic studies course uh so I have a plan for that that I'll share with you guys here shortly um but uh if it's not funded we technically don't have to offer it and I know there's been a lot of conversation csba and other places AXA and

260other other institutions that are trying to figure out how to proceed with this uh and figuring out what the state is going to require us and that was the last I heard is that it wasn't funded so we don't need to officially offer it next year but it might be by May so I don't want to be caught holding the bag so I have a plan um we also have to find a way uh for ethnic studies to fit financial literacy to fit if Health which we still got to we we strongly believe it's an important class that we need to make sure that our kids are getting and life skills already into a packed list of courses with a declining enrollment and limited uh sections so that is the big issue go ahead and

261the next so plans moving forward um one of the things I want you guys to think about is um what are we going to do with life skills and financial literacy one thought would be to count financial literacy as the life skills requirement the reason we would do that um is they are really close in alignment a lot if you look at the and they don't have the curriculum built out yet for financial literacy but if you look at a lot of the things that are in that they align really closely with what the uh the goal of our life skills class was uh a lot you know you look at Dan Wilson's curriculum and he covers those topics pretty well so one option would be to to count that to say you know what

262financial literacy will count as the life skills and we move on from it um we also might choose to just re remove the life skills requirement if that's what you guys choose to do because again they're going to get it in that financial literacy class now there's obviously some um collateral uh pieces to this because as Kim pointed out that the life skills classes is where a lot um of the uh culminating event work was happening as well but that might be something that we think we should do I I that would be my recommendation is to to remove it and allow financial literacy to count as it um there is a school I believe kfax is still going to teach life skills um but it's going to be a five credit course instead of

263a 10 credit course is what it is now so we'd still have to make that change within the within the board policy about our graduation requirements I'm going to stop right there and see if you guys have any questions about that portion Bo when will we have some idea if we're going to be required to offer that ethnic studies class next year man well I heard May is awful that's pretty much too late to plan your master schedule yeah I have a plan on there uh on that next don't so so one of the plans that we thought about um and I'll give her credit again uh Mrs money Penny counselor at kfax uh she she had one great idea uh and I always like to give her credit for that but we could offer

264a a dual enrollment course uh they've already said yes to it they have a teacher it wouldn't be our teacher it really it wouldn't affect anything on our um master schedule uh it would be an asynchronous course that we' offer um and then and then if kids take it they take it if we don't get enough kids to take it it doesn't matter but we met the statutory requirement of offering the course to our kids so yeah yeah that sounds like probably the best course of action I you know I this was a complaint we've been talking about this I'm like well okay January for us to be able to start planning out for next year and and this you know Bill it's required to have funding and it didn't and so it's super frustrating

265I was talking on the csba delegate assembly call on Friday and I said take it back to the legislative act activist like action committee and go tell them just either strike it or say it now because you you're you're put putting us in a really compromised position to try to like move forward with our scheduling for next year um especially if it's going to be a graduation requirement from here on out or I guess it would be 2030 would be officially correct okay correct but either way but it was supposed to be rolled out and and offering this next year off offering a course period yeah just off a course um that that uh uh and so a lot of a lot of our schools are trying to figure this out we uh plaster County

266Office of bed had a meeting about it uh Robert uh from our department lemon and uh you know and I've been talking to uh Western Placer Rockland Roseville about how they you know we kind of all want to move together and doing something similar so we're still trying to figure it out but I think right now for us offering the dual enrollment we meet that requirement we wouldn't have to worry about whether it's in the budget or not y we wouldn't have to do all of that sort of stuff so um I think it's what we would like to do um for full implementation if it if it doesn't change we have two options up there one of them is uh and and each of our schools are going to do a little different I

267didn't maybe put uh uh coaxes up there precisely because they they're that IB School that has a little different social science um uh sequence uh but one is ninth grade do health and ethnic studies as a a half a semester course a five credit five credit um and then in the 12th grade doing uh government and financial lit where you typically have government and econ it would be government and financial literacy option two would do something like government and ethnic studies combined and then have a health and financial lit um at the 12th grade um again it all depends on credentialing issues who's able to teach different courses the ethnic studies requires a social studies um credential the financial literacy requires a social science math homech or business credential so you kind of kind of

268play the credential game and figure out how uh who can actually teach it and those kinds of things so those are the two options we're looking at go ahead and click the next slide going forward we're going to bring a graduation requirement policy to ad the life skills whether you know and again I'll I'll I'll solicit more feedback from you guys but um if you guys want to discuss it now and maybe come up with an idea about do we just want to amend that section and say financial literacy will count as life skills and strike it all out of the the actual graduation requirement or not um but we also will be bringing forward some uh series of course adoptions right now I think the only one we'll bring to you is the the

269ethnic studies dual enrollment option through Sierra uh and we'll wait for the others uh to to figure it out get figured out by the state um once the state makes their decision and we got an idea that yes it is going to go forward then we will work on training um our teachers and building that curriculum uh in hopefully with neighboring districts and I also just want to point out is that ethnic studies is controversial curriculum um and I don't want to put our teachers into a position where uh they're not supported by you guys so uh they want to teach the course or they might not want to teach the course because master schedule is going to say this is you know this is the course you have to teach and I don't want

270to be put in a position where those teachers have to teach a very controversial course and they're getting a lot of push back um when it's something that they're required to do so uh when we go forward uh with the curriculum the book and those kinds of things I'll be bringing that forward to make sure that you guys are aware of where we land and uh make sure that you guys can if there's any concerns that you have I appreciate you acknowledging that it's definitely I mean there's there's lawsuits going um going on over this course right now I think it's part partly you know I maybe not the entire um hesitation with the legislature or the funding um because we're we're down but um yeah it's definitely a controversial subject and it's not one

271it's I've received a ton of feedback from from community members not interest Ed in that or not wanting their children to be forced to take that course um but I understand if it's the law and we're required to do something about it um I I mean I yeah I feel more comfortable with the dual enrollment if we're forced to have this at this point and then we we unpack it and figure it out as you've recommended but yeah you know if it's not funded I think that we don't mess with the master schedule um on our end so then then the last thing I'll I just need you guys to think about what what that life skills portion and how we would uh proceed with that if we would keep it as a graduation requirement

272um or we can keep it as a graduation requirement and put next to it life skills or financial lit but financial literacy has got to be on on the graduation requirement no matter what yeah so is it just is it possible to combine the two like you mentioned I mean there's already a lot of overlap with life skills yeah I think in in this the way the course has got to be financial literacy though so it would just it would have to say financial literacy just semantics just change the name that's fine and and meet all of the requirements that are outlined in the law that says these are the 12 units that you will be you know teaching but it's reasonable to say that even though it's called financial literacy there's a lot of

273life skills absolutely yeah yeah that's great I think that makes the most sense as well please have thoughts on that well I I don't want to see us lose life skills I know I don't either popular class kids like it it's giving them life you know it's getting them prepared for what they're going to have to do in life and there's a lot of that David in in the financial literacy there really is um so they're not going to miss out on everything there there might be some subjects that Dan has not taught really well at plers specifically that's where it's going to probably hurt the most but we also know that that unfortunately for us we can't keep Dan in uh uh employed forever he's getting to that point where he's not going to

274have that class anymore and that was his baby and he owned it and did a great job at it but we also have to realize that um unfortunately for us he's going to retire one day and we have to have a class that that's got to be picked up for that and that class I think would be financial literacy so my my I mean after the presentation with the culminating event like that's the other biggest question well where does that go if if we are held to you know a different curriculum is there a challenge with just calling it financial literacy and life skills I don't think so in fact I think that's what almost plaster name of it is right now yeah um the only the only other thing is that it's um I

275don't think it really will be that big of a deal uh but it's a it's a credit issue so right now we have on our books it says life skills as 10 credits it's not going to be a 10 credit course it's going to be a five credit course the financial literacy is a five correct so that that just becomes the issue and that's that's something I think we could solve if if we take a look at the board policy and make some some adjustments and I'll be more than happy to you know work on it n services and we can work on it and Lead team and and then share with you guys what we think okay what that what that board policy update would look like is it possible to have five and

276five and it's the financial literacy five and life skills five and we still I think isn't that what cax or or one of yeah kofax was going to do but again it's still we still to do something have amend the policy with that policy because it says life skills 10 credits okay seems easy yeah yeah that that would be my recommendation yeah I agree that sounds good okay thank you guys thank you any other questions I don't think so thank you so much all right we do have we're going to go ahead and move to item 10 10.1 this is public comment on non- agendized items opport this is our um opportunity for the public comments to be received by the board this is a time for members of the public to address the board

277regarding items not on the agenda completing a blue public participation form is preferred but not mandatory I do have two but you are not required to have that if you'd like to speak to the board this form can be obtained um at the meeting right here at our table by our lovely ladies here running our Tech and taking the minutes in the interest of connecting a public meeting in a timely member uh manner individual speakers will be allowed 3 minutes to address the board with no more than 20 minutes per topic this is a comment period only the law California educ code Che section 35145 point5 does not allow the Board of Trustees to take action on any item not explicitly posted in the agenda in advance the board values public comment and wishes to

278convey that although board members cannot take action on items that are not on the agenda they listen carefully and appreciate and value input from the public and we do we really do all right Eric um I'm going to pronounce your last name wrong veren I think okay followed by Stone yeah Stone lionhardt O'Brien good evening members of the phsd board Deputy superintendent Acting Superintendent uh Steve camon members of the public my name is Eric bin and I have been deeply connected to this district for many years I'm the proud father of two sons who attended cfax high school and was a dedicated employee of PSD for 15 years prior to my retirement in 2022 I've had the privilege of contributing to this District as a volunteer planner and co-presenter for last year's classified managers Academy

279as well as serving as a current member of the PSD scholarship investment advisory committee as part of my role on the committee I'd like to take a moment to recognize the excellent work done by Matt Natoli of Natoli wal management under his stewardship the scholarship funds have seen greater returns than when they were managed by the county this Improvement directly benefits our students and I commend him for his efforts over the years I've given many reports and presentations to the board in my professional capacity however tonight's marks my first as a community member and I wish it was under happier circumstances the reason I'm here tonight is to formally submit my resignation from the PSD scholarship investment advisory committee I've reached this decision because I cannot in good conscience continue to serve under the government

280governance of a trustee whose conduct has raised raised significant ethical concerns specifically and I won't go into detail on Mr Jeff's employment history but I what I find equally um disconcerting is his dishonesty during his uh campaign he was dishonest with the public he was dishonest with um his opponent in the uh in the election to my knowledge not a single trustee has publicly expressed concern about Mr jeffy's actions or his Fitness to serve this silence is troubling as it undermines the integrity and trust that should Define this board's leadership Mr Jeff it's not too late to do the right thing resign your position and allow the board to to appoint a new trustee someone who can earn the trust of the public and enable the board to move forward without distraction I have loved

281serving this district and its students and this decision is not one I take lightly but accountability and integrity are important for the good of this community I urge all of you to consider the precedent being set since I have just one more minute too uh president Spade earlier you talked about the expectations of a superintendent and you noted open communication transparency and starting on the right foot I would need to say to you it's a two-way street and you need to look inward at the members of the board and have the same expectation thank you all right [Music] Stone hello my name is Stone Sparrow lion Hart O'Brien I'm a senior at kfax high school and I play baseball and am non-binary and use they them pronounced despite what any leader might say keeping trains

282people out of sports is there's absolutely no reason that trains people shouldn't be allowed to play in their preferred League however the issue is usually geared toward trans girls and women the biggest issue that shallow-minded people have with trans women in women's sports is that they're basically men or that they're men in Disguise and that genetic advantage that people who are born male have physically is big enough to make it unfair now it's true that people who born male are physically advantaged hormonally in addition to being taller on average and also being able to put on muscle more easily my response who the cares at the end of the day there are tens if not hundreds of thousands of people in the pvl how many of them are trans a dozen maybe being generous in

283addition most trans athletes will not plan their preferred League until they have fully socially transitioned before that being out as transs and playing sports is not something that anyone will choose to endure transs athletes will either come out and or stay closeted but still play in the league that they socially are told to play in neither option is good one keeps student athletes from being their true selves and inevitably leads and one inevitably leads to bullying and harassment from teammates or opposing teams it would be easier to allow trans people to be their true selves and play the sport that they love in the league that makes them comfortable however this doesn't address the issue of how unfair it is that the other person has a other team has a trans person on it again

284who cares at the end of the day all sports are games games are played to have fun everyone deserves to have fun while playing a game that they love it's as simple as that it's not that serious this is high school sports we're talking about what might be important is to talk about is the fact that kfax has leaky roofs and outdated furniture and supplies all across campus maybe just maybe you could leave the Dozen trans athletes that will be affected alone and let them play the sport that they want to given that is such a nightmare right now to be trans and maybe you could pull your heads out of the sand and solve a problem that matters thanks for nothing thank you all right all right we're going to go ahead and move

285to item 11 board report and calendars uh number one is our superintendent vacancy discussion I know it's getting late and I appreciate you guys' patience um I don't know if each of you have had the opportunity to review policy 201120 with superintendent Recruitment and selection um this might be an interesting conversation um moving forward as we work on some governance and talk about vision and goals for the future and what we're looking for but um at this time so I received a phone call from our plaster County Office of Education um superintendent I hate not seeing you I can't move that um and she kind of outlined what it looks like for superintendent search and um essentially um her recommendation to me as far as the timeline goes for a superintendent search is that we

286would need if we choose to move forward with requests for proposals from a search firm um that that would need to occur in January so that the staff would have time to bring it back for February's meeting and you are contract to move forward um with with a search firm to help facilitate that process there's a lot of um maze um and then there are some shells in this uh board policy and so um I don't know that we need to go line by line here but just talking about what options we're interested in search firms um you know are not exactly cheap but we could uh get offerings from a number you know of appropriate firms um including um Gail garbolino moika also has does that service at a much lesser cost uh to

287districts and I am aware of several locally that have used her and and have found success um if that's something we'd like to entertain or to bring back multiple options to discuss in February do any of you have preliminary thoughts or feedback on that um like the idea of bringing on board an external head head hunter okay trusty Lake what would the alternative be so um an alternative would be if we didn't use a search firm um we could open potentially we could just open up um what's the what's the site that we typically use I'm sorry it's not coming to M it join Ed join thank you Mike it's there I'm thinking Ed source and it's not translating it's 10 um and and just see who applies uh potentially and then the board could

288filter through that um and then you know go through that process um but that's pretty much you know the options I would say Dr koned am I missing one okay the way we've done it in the past is we've always hired a professional Head Hunter based on our philosophy what we're looking for for our vision our goals and then they give us you know I mean it's a fee obviously I don't know how expensive that is and they finally give us uh we get applicants five six seven applicants based on what they found people that are interested and that understand kind of what we're looking for initially um that's way I'd like to go the only problem is we haven't established our vision and goals right and I think we need to have a special

289board meeting um as soon as possible just to take a look at what do we want and what are the goals that we're looking for so we can be able to send that out yeah uh so people can have an idea of what we're all about because we are on transition and a lot of people are wondering where are you going who are you now sure you know at least they're they're asking me that yeah you know so that's the way I would like to go I'd like to have a special board meeting and and uh I mean this is the only hire we have is our superintendent you know that's it yeah and then he or she you know is going to be doing all of the work to initiate and bring to life

290our goals yeah and our vision as they do the how so I I'd like us to to well that's what I know since I've been on the board for 10 years that we've done in the past and so that's what I would suggest that we consider maybe do but I do think we need to have a special board meeting ASAP to take a look at yeah you know what we're looking for yeah now I totally agree with that um I think that it's important if we're going to give some direction um that we need to we need to Artic be able to articulate that as a board um so would you so at this point in order to have um some request for proposals for them to work for us I think in the meantime

291if we could try to potentially coordinate with a facilitator um in the next month or so by the time we receive some M us back that we could at that point present what we're what we were looking for yeah I would think that we would want to try to schedule a special board meeting within no longer than a couple weeks maybe within a week so we can meet I mean this is the you know this is our number one priority right now I think yeah is finding a person y you know that can be our leader and establish and create and implement the vision and the goals that we want so that's what I suggest yeah I'd move to have that meeting yeah the what I'm sorry to do that that you're mentioning yeah yeah

292I support that too I think we need to have that as quickly as we possible then we're all going to be on the same page we're going to be more connected you know as indiv individual board members we'll will'll have some clarity yeah especially for our administrative staff so they're going to know you know who we are and what we're looking for so they can do the how yeah for us and we can establish the policies and hopefully create the quality that we all want because that's what we want I know I totally agree so I think that um in regards to the superintendent vacancy are you guys on board it sounds like trusty Underwood's pretty solid and that um wanting to hire a search firm I you know my I've only been through one

293um we had a lot of community feedback on that because um it wasn't opened on Ned join people were following and tracking it we didn't hire a search firm um and the appearance of you know impropriety or or some said other things um that it didn't go over well it went over like a lead balloon with the community we had over an hour of community feedback because the community was not involved in any aspect of our hiring process and I don't I want to make sure that this time around that we've had a thorough process that the community at some point we discuss when they're going to be involved you know it talks about that in item seven um on there like how and when to involve whether that's surveys or whatever we might do

294so that we make sure we have um Community input in this process too so I are you guys on board I mean I I feel like my last time around not going through that process definitely had feedback the the community not including the community or hiring a search firm and having interviewing multiple candidates I feel like it set us up for kind of shaky ground and I think it's ultimately why we don't have see I see it a little different yeah Jessica I see that we were elected um we were known Commodities and we were elected to to do our job and our job is to establish our goals our vision based on the community no doubt about that but the community you know it's so split I I can't see how they could really

295be of service in terms of what we need to do we could I mean we we could have a session where anyone that's interested could just say talk about what what they think we should have what what we need you know and listen to them but it ends up us yeah we are the people that have to make that decision we're the people that need that will be end up interviewing yeah um and and talking about who we want eventually to hire not the community no I hear you there I hear you there I think uh the feedback you know that I received at that time was um um and that I shared with the board at the time was that you know we're we're elected as as uh public servants right and so I

296think because they felt disenfranchised in our last process um that that they weren't that parts of the community were not bought into our process and therefore you know there was some back there was some Fallout over that and so I do understand it's absolutely our Authority and our discretion who we hire once we get there um but I think that that hire a professional search firm and going through that process is going to you know create some street cred for the choice that that comes down uh the line what are we talking about I haven't been a part of that process before is there a range are we talking like financially yeah 20,000 50,000 what's a firm going to charge thank you Peter you're looking I don't know this one's not I don't know what

297the superintendent for the the county office would charge but um when we hired the person 10 years ago that was just $220,000 and another 10 grand so was was $30 30,000 for the whole thing so you're probably looking anywhere from 20 to 50 depending on how intensive and how reputable sure and who the firm is does the firm interact with the public and yes the The Firm a really really good firm will come in they'll do what Davis spoke about they'll want to meet with you they want to know your vision and goals if they feel you don't have one CU you're new I don't mean any disrespect they may then do a workshop just to establish that and then build from there they speak with the schools they speak with the communities they they

298will they they hold forums um when we hired Dr saraki it was multitudes of those things yeah hence the cost and that was 12 years ago and so it's a very intensive process and so I don't you know as staff I don't have you know I'd love to save the money if Tom were here we tell you that that's what the CFO is supposed to do is watch The Pennies now type of thing I don't have a solution you know I I can e say leave it is for right now but you guys are a new board you know you want to move on something so the F would hold meetings with the public yeah they would there would be established like stakeholder type groups maybe this is for an area in kofax you know

299and this is area down Delo so they might not do it at every School site but regionally probably go to for still because of where it's at some people coming down here so it's my understanding that with pcoe and I I don't know I think it would depend on the scope of her work but I it's my understanding with a few other districts that um superintendent Gail garalina moiko worked with that she it was somewhere in the you know 5,000 is range versus 20,000 or more so there is a you know more fiscally prudent Choice um but you know depends on the scope of her work too sure sure is fine as long as the appearance isn't staff is running the show because that's part of you mentioned earlier you know we if this is

300you know the outside consultant it's all run by them yeah you know staff we had very little to do with it I believe that one of the other boards that worked with her also um the the board received the applications so it went through her and then but she didn't they didn't have her filter out the board ultimately reviewed it I know that she came to close sessions because when you're going through that process there's some employment confidentiality so this discussion's in the front of the house but the until the hire hiring process um you know no names would be divulged and we'd be able to go through that as a board and then weed them out and and make some choices um working in collabor cation with her I know in another board um

301because she worked with auburn Union recently and I had attended one of their meetings she came and and did report outs about the process and we've received this many applicants and so there was a community communication aspect happening in time so you know that wasn't that was interesting and it sounds like she you know obviously was in trying to be very transparent and open with the process with the board and the community as much as possible so would you feel comfortable moving forward just getting some requests uh for proposals from um a firm or two plus Gail and then we can discuss that at the next meeting in the meantime see if we can't establish a date with a facilitator to talk about goals so that we have that prepared for whoever we're hiring down

302the line so we don't we're not holding holding it up okay when the RFP process Peter correct me if I'm wrong is that's a that's a fairly formal requests for proposals and they present in front of the board is that if you're is that required I I don't think it's required you're not going above a fee that's okay for the lock so you can reach out to a few firms and say what would you charge okay an idea my experience all all brand new all learning at the same time yeah I could provide you with those firms and you can the board can reach out yeah do that that sounds good okay and then um in terms of um timeline this is this is how it was uh relayed to me that at this point

303you know we'll we'll move forward sounds like we're pretty on on board with getting some feedback as far as a search goes um or someone to do that for us um and then ultimately we'll make the call um and Hope Tom will be there at that this time oh and I'm sorry I didn't announce clearly trusty Duncan is not here sorry Dez she reminded me before the meeting started he's out of town for work um so we miss him we will see him back next month um so from this point forward February we would we would choose who's going to run the search um March would probably be the articulating with the community and opening it up by end of March April we would be interviewing and by may we would hire and release the

304name because the the goal would be to have them come on July 1st so that's kind just so you kind of know that's what the timeline looks like and um when she relayed that information to me she just said that you know this is the timeline that they do it we have to take a look at when superintendents are really looking for uh a job so to speak you know yep and this is it so you know timing is going to be really critical on this but I would like us as a board to meet for February to be honest with you about goals I like us all to kind of spend our time take a look at what do we want in this District where do we want to go what's working what's not

305put it together and come to and create our goals yeah and our vision because and it's it's not going to be perfect but at least it'll give us a big a good start because we're going to have to refine that I'm sure yeah yeah I think it's definitely something that we need to do um I'm not sure if we need to do it before the February meeting but um shortly thereafter the least I think that needs to happen I feel it's important to have some type of facil facilitator help us with that process so Jessup we you know and so I think that it's going to be contingent upon all of our availability plus a facilitator so I'll reach out and and try to figure out what dates are available and then you guys give

306your preferred dates or Wednesdays or Fridays days of the week and then we'll try to figure out when we can align the Stars okay okay so I think we're pretty unanimous Dr cetti um if you would um give us some direction um you know some firms to look at um to reach out to sure okay we're going to go ahead and move to item 11.2 board reports announcements and correspondence trusty Lake would you like to kick us off these announcements yep we report or announcements are you asking no pressure yeah yes I am thank you yeah anything to share or anything um well I'm I'm I'm interested in these uh these what do they what you call them walk and learn yeah learning walks there's one tomorrow morning m is that right up in uh

307oh at deloro what time is that 8:20 8:20 well I'll be there I'll be there too excited so awesome I'm also uh very interested in uh visiting the Confluence Confluence that that that was really cool um to hear from them um no regarding the the superintendent search I agree with you that it should be clear what the goals are and uh and that should be very you know should be very public and um but yeah the timeline is important so I'm okay meeting even if it's next week to have that meeting that you're talking about um I know in the past as opposed to waiting a month you know what I'm saying right exactly I know in the past when we've sat down on the board uh usually on a retreat uh in Tahoe City

308we used to go up there uh it would take us hours you know seriously like a couple days three hours here four hours here to try to put it together so it's going to be I think we have to come in prepare you know with some good thoughts and ideas take a look at you know maybe past uh goals that we've had in the district or expectations we've had for the superintendent that we want them to reach in terms of their goals and which ones do we want to look at modify what do we need in our district right now um I really think the staff is looking to us right now for direction to be honest with you we're new uh and uh I don't know if they're sure you know what we're going

309to be doing you know what we're really going to to be supporting so when we come up with our our goals and our vision you know that'll be clear I think that's going to give them some stability so I think that's what we need to do yeah I I agree with you but I I also think that it's not going to feel stable until a hire is made and we start you know what I'm saying so just plan on it feeling that way and I I would also my gut tells me that because it's a new it's a it's a new board newer you're going to get pushed back from the community no matter what you do yeah whether you hire a firm or whether you hold your own interview process I mean just plan

310on it um so that being said I think that's the right next step is just to have that meeting establish the vision moving forward and then and then proceed so that's what I think thank you trusty Lake Jeff all right I just have two things um so first uh last week I attended the uh spring parent back to school night kind of thing that they have every term and uh it was a good evening um I went to all my daughter's classes and uh it was really interesting I also attended one of the uh the workshops that they had before the night kind of kicked off um on parent student engagement uh and that was really interesting to see and so in fact one of our students back there from do was uh was presenting

311that session that night so the other thing that I did want to mention is I wanted to come back to something U superintendent cetti mentioned earlier about requesting us to give him feedback or guidance um regarding the CBE committee U because I think we never really after he said that we never really Circle back around to that yeah thanks for bringing that back um so I think we need to kind of figure out what we want to do with that um and how we're going to move forward with that committee yeah I agree maybe combine that with the other meeting all the meetings all the meetings for my personal opinion I feel like we need to have at least two meetings meetings um preferably on uh a non-work day when students can can be involved

312um and try to get as many students parents community members and that kind of thing all together in the same room um and I I don't really don't think that it's going to be a difficult process to mediate that uh that meeting um you know it could be something as simple as like on that whiteboard we're going to write down what the problems are that we see with how CBE was implemented or what's going on with CBE and this whiteboard we're going to write down Solutions to those problems uh and then just you know work through that and I think that's totally doable with you know a lot of intelligent people in the room really would um you be interested in in helping to guide that committee uh sure if nobody else wants to do

313it I see it a little different the way I see it is uh have on the active agenda a statement or a uh an active item which says we would like the community come in and tell us what they want to see let them talk let people come in then we come in we don't need people in the room at that point we give them their voice let them tell us what what they feels really critical but what I've experienced in the past um is the board sits down looks at that feedback comes up and puts it together without people because if you have a lot of people in here and you're talking you're not really going to make progress and this is what I believe and I think it's it's significant that we do

314the due diligence of what we're hired to do on the board but but the community have let them speak and talk and come in you know you'll probably have 40 or 50 50 or more people that'll want to say something you know here's what we you know and we take our notes and we look at that and and we utilize that when we form our goals and our vision that's what I think is going to work maybe it's my I'm I'm a psychotherapist maybe it's my background in counseling to be honest with you in terms of what I I know and what I've done but you get too many people involved and often you're just going to have chaos sounds like just a varation of what you're saying but basically open it up I like

315the idea that it's at a time when as many students that want to yeah all can yes exactly well are you s are you suggesting a a scheduled special board meeting because that's different from a from a community special board meeting well I'm hearing trusty Underwood say it's special board meeting I'm hearing I'm the direction I thought was a was a committee yeah um at at this this point you know with the numbers we have even if you have I it should probably be Community Based um I would be really nervous about putting um every school community in a room and saying direct this because everybody's feeling um from their school communities is going to be different yeah overall of how it may affect them and so I I'd recommend um School based site based

316Community forums that that have a specific goal and outcome of how many you're going to commit to two meetings this is our topic a good idea I agree with you on that um yeah and and I think and you know my recommendation I and I think you know staff's talked about this and again it's a it's another it's another cost potentially but a third party leading the facilitate a facilitated conversation with our community I think is beneficial sometimes when it's staff leading it or right we want to remove ourselves from it because there's obviously biases that can happen whether you're for it or against it and I would much rather be um removed from that aspect and I know our staff would feel the same way of be putting in a situation where we have

317a trained Prof professional that can um lead it without any skin in the game so I hear you you're saying have them lead a discussion yeah a discussion or is it most important to hear from students and faculty let's get they they help do that they help they help guide the the community Through stating there similar to what trusty Jeffrey said there's there's writing your your comments down you're posting it you're talking about it you're coming up with consensus of what the real root of the issue is if we just have a meeting and say we're going to talk about grading um that I'm not sure what the outcome of that is going to to accomplish other than this group likes it this group doesn't you know we're not going to come with any consensus

318on on I I I think that you're right I don't think that you're going to have success trying to meet a consensus it just won't be successful right but I think the important thing is to hear from the community feedback sure like what you said exactly gather all that information and then make a decision moving forward and you know when we have done evaluations in the past of our superintendent we've always who hired a what was her name Dr kin I don't remember the name that the she's an ex superintendent and she Peggy Peggy Peggy right uh where Peggy she's incredible lady she's in there and she hears what we're saying and she can help us with the formulation of the words and the clarity and so on and she actually puts it together for

319us as we discuss this and I think that would be a a really good uh use of finances to do that so just I'm I feel like you know obviously with the board report announcements and correspondence I feel like we're we have entered a territory we that we is not agendized and I and I want to respect the rules of the brown act here and um you know to cease further discussion on on an item that's not on the agenda tonight and just keep it to our board reports without um discussion at this point um if okay is that something we can bring to I think I think um discussion and yeah I think we that um the proper order would be obviously this needs to be a discussion um moving forward um I'm comfortable

320um let's have yeah I think we need an agenda item in February just to address the procedures for the committee so that we can have a conversation about it because I don't want to you know get us into a situation tonight well that makes sense okay okay all right trusty Underwood I just uh W to say that we have incredible administrative staff work Trent done Peter Elena hard workers focused um and they are the howto they're really amazing once we have established our vision I was talking to Trent earlier tonight once we've EST establish our vision and our goals and they're going to make it uh happen you know they're going to bring that to us and and the how will be what's going to occur um I just hope what what I'm hoping for

321more than anything is we gain the trust of the community we establish stability based on the a consensus of what we all feel is going to bring Excellence into our district you know and let the staff administrative staff show us how to do that and then move forward that that's what I'm really thinking a lot about I'm I'm I'm hopeful that that we can do that I just know that um we have a lot of I guess my passion more than anything and this was my passion on is teaching is the underserved kids you know the 40% of the kids that are underserved in some capacity and and I'm just hoping that we can continue uh to serve them you know and and uh find success they can find success in their education um that's

322that's my fa I think about that a lot I just I'm hopeful thank you trusty Underwood yeah I'm going to run through this real fast obviously I attended the Confluence learning walk and like they said the doors are open to Confluence protocol our protocol established protocol and through Bas we just we're going to just touch base before we drop in with our super and and the um admin and and then the doors will always open right so um but try to be you know we're try we try to be mindful I try to be mindful when I'm dropping in um so that I'm not disrupting but but it's always awesome to be on campus and they want you there they articulated that to me when I was there that we've got a new board we

323really hope that they come because um I was the only board member at that that walk um met with uh superintendent or Acting Superintendent Steve CTI on the 15th to go over the board agenda um for this meeting and attended the pler uh duels last the wrestling duels uh duel meet on a Wednesday of last week with 12 Bridges and I got to talk about it cuz I'm a wrestling mom and my hubby coach is Plaster right now is 4 and0 in the fvl and so I'm just saying um that's pretty cool I don't know that we've had that record in a long time not since um I've been around with the program and so anyway tomorrow is actually a senior night and alumni night and the final home wrestling duel aside from a tournament

324that we're hosting so it's a good time you guys it's really fun so come on out and I just always shout outs to all of um our amazing uh staff um and athletic department and everybody involved in curricular extracurricular um activities because it's so important for our kids I also attended the budget uh perspective workshop at pcoe welcome aboard um it's like trying you you got to be a psychic to know really what's ever happening with the budget with the state and how that's all going to be allotted so there's definitely work that needs to be done uh regarding um finances because it's it's not intuitive on any level and it's always amended and adjusted the preliminary that we we agree on is never one really happens so um you know there again some work

325needs to be done there I had an elcat meeting with um Robert lemon um and as we talk about these goals they impact our lcap and all of the other documents sipsas and was and all of the things because all of the documents are communicating together and we had a great chat about that and just being um I I want to be thoughtful in our process uh because we're over 50% there with a lot of the things that are happening right now so moving forward um as we're discussing options um and and goals to keep that in mind um with our staffing and also attended as csba delegate and board president call last Friday and um discussed some of the similar things that we're talking about right now um and I attended my first JV

326girls basketball game last week and um and we had a great tournament over the weekend and um as far as upcoming events goes and I hope that we're all able to go to some of these I'm so excited that you're going to be able to go to Doo's learning walk I'll be there in the morning as well and I was also asked by the plaster County Clerk and recorder's office to speak at a student voter Outreach tomorrow at Confluence West so in the afternoon I will be at Confluence West so um they they hold a great program there as well there's a measure G committee meeting on Thursday and back to school night at kfax following Monday is anyone else able to go to the back to school night meeting board members on the 27th

327at kfax okay cool I'll be there as well and there's also another learning walk next Wednesday I believe the 29th at Forest Hill so another good opportunity to pop in there um just as far as other governance trainings locally that are happening that are free um there is a school Finance 101 uh governance Institute being held by plaster County Office of Education on February 3rd that morning um I actually take that back I think it's in the evening um I can send something out on that if you don't have it already but um yeah so there's there's a lot going on there's a lot to do we appreciate um I appreciate everyone who continues to give feedback and um and I appreciate your engagement we're here to serve um and we all want what's best

328for these kids and our staff and um with that being said um let's go to item 12 adjournment do I have a motion to second we have a first and a second for adjournment all in favor say I I I passes unanimously thank you all

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.