CorpusRecord 41141

PUHSD Special Board Meeting 1.7.25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Placer Union
Date
2025-01-08
Location
Placer County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
38,636 words · about 215 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e um we are going to go to item five our organization our welcome in Pledge of Allegiance and trusty Duncan clerk Duncan would you please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance Al of the United States of americais all right thank you very much um just as an acknowledgement here this me meeting will be audio and video recorded um item 5.2 approval of the special meeting agenda do we have a motion board we have a motion to approve the meeting agenda I'll move to [Music] approve Competency Based education which is why we're all here so go ahead and take it away I think we're going to have um ATP present first and then uh followed by uh executive director Mr Wilson with um the report he asked him to present [Music] I don't

002see any uh which one is the ATP one okay got you good afternoon there we go okay fantastic okay so just a little bit of background um on this survey so we sent uh this out to the ATP unit members uh right uh about a month before break um a little more than that um just to get from staff about how the implementation of CBE is going um just so kind of we as a a bargaining unit could figure out kind of what our opinions were so that first slide is just to show everyone kind of the breakdown of the responses that we got as you see you know we got the most the majority from doar which makes sense because it's large of site and we had 127 total responses out of about what

003200 maximum so there is a majority of members okay next slide please okay so the first question that we asked was overall your experience with CB in the fourpoint scale has been and as you can tell there the majority of responses said they've had a negative experience with CB so far um the second largest proportion was at 37% which said that they were neutral not overwhelmingly positive or negative we did however on the survey have a spot for people to add a comment and so when I went through the comments 54% of that category had critical or negative responses even though they said that they were neutral which I thought was kind of interesting so I wanted to just make sure that the board was aware of that um because it was you know neutral

004is kind of a hard thing um and then 18.1% said that it was positive okay next slide okay uh we did then break it out each by kfax deloro plaster Etc and all the sides so actually so if you could just scroll down all the way to the bottom of that to the last slide or actually sorry the number nine yeah perfect so this makes it a little bit easier if you you know if the board wants to go through and see each pie chart individually they want they can but I just broke it out just into one slide so it's easy to see um as you can tell um all Sites did not have majority positive okay at the at the highest you had Confluence that was essentially 50% positive and then 50% neutral

005or negative uh going all the way down to delore which was just at 99.1% so overall staff and our unit members are not happy with how things are currently and um as you'll see in the next uh presentation there we do have some suggestions for what what we could do to maybe make our lives as UN members easy and also allow it to be allow our grades to actually reflect what we believe the knowledge of the students to be because right now there's a lot of time investment that people are doing to make sure that grades are accurate um and there's a lot of ambiguity just because there's you know this is a new system and it's hard to change uh from what we were doing before next Jacob just real quick can we stay

006on that slide uh when we think about anytime we have comparisons I want to make sure we're thinking Apples to Apples so not all these sites are the same would that be would that be true no no no no and that's that's also the other thing I want to reiterate is that um as at the last board meeting right before break you know you had a fair number of people from kfax who came up and spoke overwhelmingly positive about CBE we are not asking for CBE to be totally gutted and removed I really there are definitely some things that are great about it and there are some teachers who are doing a fantastic job with it there's just other sites other teachers other disciplines that are having a considerable challenge with implementing CB as it's

007written currently yeah and and kofax being which was pointed out last meeting uh was is an IB School which which is which is different but even then kfax is still not a majority positive they're 47.1% and I think you know part of what I look at here is there's a negative but the neutral piece is an important piece to look at as well because if I'm thinking of change I'm thinking of overwhelming right right is this does this move the needle in a way that substantially makes everyone better so I would actually combine like like I look at combining yeah I would I would look to combine neutral and negative is the way I would look at it in this instance Jacob can I ask a question of course is it fair to say that

008CBE has not been been implemented um exactly the same at each site I can't say it has been I mean I'm only at deloro um and I do talk to other people at the other sites but I know from what I've heard it's definitely not been uniform across every single site every single site has done something slightly differently and that was from at least in my opinion um I think it was right around midterms where we were kind of looking at what midterm grades were looking like and each site made some adjustments to make sure that grades were accurate and I think every site did something a little bit different because we all have slightly different clientele that we're catering to which I think is great in my opinion I think each site should be

009given some control over what they need to do to make sure that they're best serving their students and their parents I'm a supporter of CBE to let you know right out the top of the bat and um I'm not a supporter of the 1234 gr that that bothers me quite a bit um I actually would like to see us continue our work on CBE I have a question for of course and change the 1234 you know just people understand much more and for the high achieving students they're not going to feel frustrated or what do I need to do to get to the next level you know based on my hard work um but my question to you guys is when you kind of separate your one two three four don't look at that right

010now sure let's just take a look at confiden giving students a chance to show excellence where students can have the opportunity to uh retake if they need to to meet the standards that are required my question is what are you hearing in terms of CBE where people are finding it difficult on that end I understand the gradient of course don't know that I think our second survey will help answer that um so if we could hold off to that for just a moment I think that oh sorry sorry sorry yes um I think our second survey will help answer that more clearly and we'll actually have a slide up that goes through and shows what people's actual comments were and those comments refer to um components that deal with the accuracy the equity um how

011the retakes are handled and all that type of stuff if if you don't mind if we wait till that one sure okay thank you but I think you hit upon an important point where the feels like you know since all of this came at the same time you know like CBE granted a lot of practices of CBE as you're talking about came with grading practices that we've been doing for a long time everything's gnarled right now right like the the know CBE when you say CB a lot of people think the fourpoint scale a lot of people think you know retakes and so it would be great right if we could take a step back kind of redefine exactly what we want and what is best for students and what's best for staff um and

012that's what the second survey will kind of help you say what we want are you referring to grading per se are you referring to we want confidence we want to to match your standards that's what we want right I think both go hand in hand I think both to I think I would look at it both go hand inand because I think the ultimate piece here is the craft of the teachers being able to spend more time on your craft in order to provide better competency to the kids I the end of the day we want the students to learn the standards we want them to be able to Y we want them to to learn what we love right I mean the reason why we all win into teaching is because we love teaching

013we love students we love our we love our subjects and so we're all on the same page here we all want the same thing we just want to be able to have a little bit of flexibility when it comes to the accounting we'll say right behind it but I think none of us nobody in this room would argue that we don't want competency and Mastery next slide please okay okay um so after just the the overall what was your experience we did try to get a little bit more granular of kind of what were this kind of get into what you were asking the specific kind of gripes so uh of the respondents 70 over 75% of people said that CB takes a greater amount of work hours than traditional grading and then uh only

0147.1% said it took less and so that's if if I could kind of boil where a lot of the frustration from staff came from was just the sheer amount of time that it took to implement this and really and I mean there were so many people that came to me in tears I'm I've been this District eight years I'm one of the newest members on at the you know the science department at deloro I have not seen so much stress in the eight years I've been there it's been insane and I can say from my own personal experience or from my wife's rather that on the the day I think was the Friday the 20th I think it was your last workday she had to turn in grades that day for that assignment she had

015given finals that day um I think she was in her classroom to almost midnight that night um trying to do this and trying to tabulate the scales and figure all this out and uh know that's really frustrating to be expecting our teachers to do that um so obviously how it's been implemented and rolled out is not good I think everybody can agree to that yeah I I I spoke to several teachers at deloro who had stated that they spent 10 to 12 hours in a work day which is fine but the problem was they were spending it on the grading and not spending it going back to my comment before on their craft right and so there seemed to be a disconnect and again the one that was the kids the people suffering are the

016kids right the students from what I saw next slide please what we're hearing this what I'm hearing at board meeting from students that are speaking is primarily on the grad right what their stigma is I'm not hearing a lot of criticism in terms of compan you know I think most of the students are high te students to be honest with mastering standards not struggling with content but um yeah the grading obviously there an issue probably need to be looked at very carefully uh we can so the next uh question was how well trained do you feel in terms of CB in the fourpoint scale this was kind of almost a third to third to third split um so I know that there were a few cohorts that people uh went through I went through one

017of the trainings and so there was an opportunity for people to get trained but it's still as you can see um you have about a third of the staff who felt like they weren't well trained or at least want more training um in order to fully implement this um and and I know you probably don't have the granular information but again I go back to kofax if if I understood correctly through questions at the last board meeting was they've they implemented CBE as far as go live four years ago and prior to that they had a roll out which seems like it's been about an 8-year Journey from from what we what what I ascertained so curious again that seems to be the gold standard in the district but again I look at it's a

018split pot right now with more a little bit more negative on like 53% versus 47% and so after four years I would assume that whatever grading system they had gone to would have been overwhelmingly we love this this is great so that that just speaks volumes to me as well and uh the last question that we asked for the first survey um was in terms of grading grading CB fourpoint scale compared traditional grading methods is and this was an accuracy statements so 21.3% so there was more accurate um 45.7% was less accurate and then with no difference right in the middle at 33.1% so you have you know almost 80% of Staff essentially saying that either it's not working or it's no better than what we were doing before can I ask were there any

019comments in this section because there was and if you guys are yeah if you guys are interested I could I have all of the data I can you know break it out as grandly as you guys want me to the second survey um gets into a little bit more of what those comments were I'm curious when I look at this uh these statistics less I mean yeah I'm surprised it says it's less what is it yeah thank you 45.7% is less DAV accurate David could you tap your microphone at the it'll green light will turn on I do what your microphone your microphone um you tap the the plastic at the bottom go green I think it's on on than um I'm kind of surprised less accurate I'm not a supporter really because I don't

020know that much about that and I taught all my life 39 years and I don't know if I would have enjoyed the one two three 4 I do believe in equity grading very strongly you know but I'm just wondering why it's less accurate I don't understand that all I mean all I can speak to is my personal experience um I and I think at least I would hope that by the end I was able to fix a lot of the problems but one of the things that I was struggling with was the fact that it I lost some granularity um because you essentially took 100 point scale and just kind of compressed it into four points really eight if you wanted to talk about the halves but really you know if you looked at the

021cut scores you know a four is an a right a 3.5 is also an A but then from a 3.5 to a two well now you've gone from an A to a b and so when I was grading it it was very difficult for me to like well you know is the like you know it's very clear like it either was a 3.5 or was a three is this an A or is is a b my own classes the only way to get a four is if it was perfect and above and beyond right so a lot of my grading really came down to a 3.5 a three a 2.5 or two and the fact I had to kind of put all of the spectrum of information into one of those scores made it a

022little bit difficult and a lot of the information was lost because personally to me an 87 if we go back to traditional grading somebody who gets an 87% of the test and 82% of the test I understand at the end of the day that's both a b but one of those BS is very very close to being a c and one of those B's is very very close to being an A and that's the sort of piece that I personally hated losing um and I know that some of my colleagues especially in the the science department really hated losing that sort of granularity of like where exactly students were I have another example too that um I was just talking to one of the cax teachers last night who uh brought up a really good

023point about um how these scales are set for them and they're weighted automatically but the problem is in some certain subject areas certain skills should be weighed more than other skills right so when they're not when you can't you know change the weight of those scales like why is this thing more important than than these these other things over here like like they teachers need to have that flexibility and right now they don't and I think that's one of the huge problems here does that make sense oh totally yeah really and as you'll see in the I I feel like I'm a broker record as you'll see in the next survey um that is one of the the biggest Cries From the staff is just just give us some flexibility because you know each class

024each discipline is a little bit different and it's great to be able to have that flexibility so that we can accurately display what the student knows exactly so okay sir do you mind switching over to that second tab awesome thanks okay so uh this is the second survey we only had uh one one major question for this we had a little bit more responses just so you can see we had uh various responses from each site um if you want to scroll down to the next slide okay so the question that we had for our members and we sent this out right at the end of the term um was what action would you find most appropriate in terms of how CBE grading looks like for the spring 2025 term okay 43 .1% said give

025teachers the option to use CB or traditional grading so give some sort of hybrid situation okay um the least percent 9.7 say continue as is okay so you have over 90% of Staff saying that we have to make some sort of change okay um the second biggest uh proportion of Staff said continue with CB with some sort of modifications okay and then you had some teachers said no let's get the whole thing and go back to traditional but I think the big thing we need to focus on is that 90% of people want some sort of change okay what that needs to be or what people would want is in the next is on that final slide okay so I went through and people left comments of what suggestions they had and so I went

026through and actually tallied up and tried to group them into somewhat logical groups just so I didn't have you know you know 15 pages of different View use okay so most PE the highest percentage of people 42% of responses said they wanted some autonomy for sites and departments I think this goes back to the cax situation where I mean it feels like especially with the people who came to the port meeting and spoke there's some teachers at kfax who have this dialed in there's some students at kfax who who love this let them do it I have no problem with it okay um and most and most of our members don't have a problem are you talking about autonomy in terms of meeting specific District standards I mean I I I wanted autonomy to do

027to uh help my students try to achieve Excellence no doubt but standards are standards you know and so hopefully the standards will be districtwide based on departments and it's not going to be autonomy well I don't want to work on this standard I'm oh no no no I don't think anybody's asking that okay because we we have we have so what does it mean for you then autonomy can you give an example of what that would mean sure um being able to control the percentages for my categories being able to choose those categories at least by department or by site um that we want to be able to measure one big thing that I had a problem with was at so I'm a science teacher um I have labs and somehow I had to fit

028in Labs into either the 90% category the 10% category or give it its own scale and it didn't really fit into any of those so I would want some autonomy to change those percentages so that I could accurately reflect how much effort those labs really take true um so I think that's what most people are asking for ultimately the teachers are expected to follow the state standards right we all know that so what we're really talking about here is how the teachers individually are assessing those State Standards yeah so this where I need a little bit of help because I when I looked at this I love the idea of providing options okay but if we're providing options at the department level and you have kids that sign up for a class and they know

029that teacher is teaching CB but they know a different teacher teaching traditional I get concerned around consistency from a a a department from a School site level is autonomy is great but what happens from a consistency standpoint I think I think we'll will'll lose something bigger if we go that route and I it'll be a bit of disarray is my concern correct and I think at the very least courses so like for example you know all all i1 classes at deloro need to be in alignment right all chemistry classes at deloro need to be in alignment at the very very least okay and then build up from there because yeah that much autonomy from teacher to teacher not having some sort of consistency I agree with not be great but that go ahead Jeffrey that's

030important from the student parent perspective as well because you're not going to have you know this this history teacher is teaching the traditional grading scale this one's doing cve so I want my I want my son in the traditional grading scale and so they're going to shift his schedule like that those kinds of things shouldn't be happening so it should I think if we're going to be doing something like that it should be by Department definitely so that you know you're they got to take the history class this is how the grading is going to work for this class or you have to take this class and this sou the grading is going to work for this class no matter what teacher you have that was actually reflected in the survey teachers said that they

031didn't want to be um singled out as individuals and felt that that decision should be made at the department level again it's it's not good for kids it's not good for parents because I think it's wildly confusing so I totally agree and most of I almost all of our members are in agreement with that okay the next biggest thing that uh our members were asking for is just kind of going back to what I was talking with you about grading is the autonomy to adjust gradebooks so either change the weight of scale s a lot waiting for specific assignments um that split you know having to put everything into the 90% sum of category their 10% formative category and being able to be a little bit more granular with our grading so instead of going

032just by 05 you know four 3.53 being able to either go by tenths or percentages if that's the case again would that be something that all teachers have to prescribe to or could each teacher be different which gets me to origal concern think the Departments the courses need to be aligned so go I think whatever decision is made all of the teachers in that course at that site at minimum need to be aligned they all have to be doing the same thing um and I I think that is possible I think you know we have we've been doing plc's for years you know people we we work with our colleagues all the time I'm there's enough commonality that I don't think that would be an issue at all yeah that was that was my main

033concern was like who gets to make that decision if if that's the course we go you know who's who's you know making that so I think we're going to go into more of some other you know potential options as well through uh Trent's presentation here in a moment too so um we'll get through these and then you know talk about what our options are so those were the two biggest percentages the rest of them were you know a little you know right around 10% a little bit less than 10% so not uh requiring students to pass all the skills instead just use an average um bringing back the D's um reain in retakes and have clear deadlines which you know that that gets back to just I think you know teachers and departments can deal

034with that um additional training and time to discuss norming what a two three and four looks like and then focusing on teaching practices um was said by a couple of our members so I just threw them there okay um for those of you doing a little bit of quick math you'll realize if you add up all those things it does not have to be 100% um and that's because people are very very passionate about this topic and so a there were a couple that were like you know four or five spaces long on Excel spreadsheet so I tried to break them up so I could accurately represent all of their opinions and not just put them into one so a quick question of course you know I'm thinking back on my tenure in experience in

035education and I don't think I would be comfortable with this 4 three two one point system I don't think I would be um but I loved uh Glasser uh quality schools and Competency Based education because I was doing that 25 35 whatever it was years ago I love that love seeing those low achieving students succeed so my question to you what are your thoughts initially if there were a grading system instead of one two four you know 1 two 3 ABC based on confidency in the standard and so on you want to answer that you got with no D with no D's and Fs you know a b c um I'm just curious because you're an experienced teacher barely I'm the least experienced in the science department delar which is kind of funny um I

036I would so like with every with anything I'm a scientist so I I would need to sit down and kind of play through it a little bit so see exactly what was decided on look at how I would use it in my classroom and then give it a shot so I'd be uncomfortable saying yes or no right now but I would be open to that conversation just to kind of see how that how that would look because and that's the other problem is that you know we're all sitting here trying to figure out what the best thing to do is and at the end of the day we have as teachers we have to bring this back and make it work and sometimes and this happens all the time especially my own life where like

037I think wow this is a great idea and I go back it's like oo no I need to make a couple changes there um and so it's difficult for me to say that would be great or that'd be terrible because I'd really you know I'd want to propose it test it out a little bit and then come back with findings to see how well it worked or if I had any adjustments it sounds to me like what David's asking about is very much like what our neighboring District Rockland UniFi does where they have ABC um and then they have incomplete and no credit um you know because I that's the system I worked under there for two the two years part come to um and it worked really well and I I truly really liked

038the idea of the essential skills that that Rockin have which is like our elos our Central learning objectives that's a very very similar kind of thing U and I think as a teacher it worked out really well um that that particular process but that's you know it's been using that for decades yeah thank you so much for surveying this is one of my asks a while back um you know because as I hear anecdotal information you know as I'm and I apologize I sound horrid right now I swear it's weeks in I'm not going to pass anything um but I you know I getting little bits of anecdotal information and from students it was this has been very helpful to just you know from each site and I visited some sites and had um some

039really wonderful conversations with different staff about it but to kind of see really where some of these numbers are is really um helpful for us as we're trying to navigate you know Uncharted territories as a district and and be responsive to our staff be responsive to our students and families so I just wanted to thank you guys for taking the time to present this and pull this together for us you know kind of on some short notice and be here to present it today so thank you guys thank you um so just to summarize wanted to make sure that we were separating out comy based education and the grading skills that we've been going through and using because if you look at what's up here the frustration is with the grading system that we've been

040using and compy based education doesn't mean that we have to do that so you were talking about the four point scale right it's working for some people um I know for me um personally within math it's been a little tricky because someone could have a three and it could mean different things um I had an experience last ter where I had a kid who made this small mistake but it was on one of the items that were required to hit Target and so he was showing as a be in the class and he was literally a top student in the class it wasn't accurate I was at um I was telling Jacob this story I was at my dentist a few months back and they're like what is going on because that's another thing too

041that came up in this survey there's a lot of little pieces of this and we're happy to give you more information um they're like what's going on at deloro they want to know specifically about deloro because if you look as an outsider deloro has been doing really well you look at us news and World Report like why are these changes being made that are stressing teachers that are stressing out students that parents don't understand the grade for anymore right and so the henus is like we just had somebody come in just before you and they're considering pulling their kid out of deloro and I'm like oh what's the story and this kid had had trouble with anxiety and um was really excited about coming back and starting the school year and right off the bat

042the first test they go through and take percentage wise they passed the test but because they didn't meet all the targets they didn't get a b and other people who had lower percentages than this kid ended up with a higher grade using this scale so when we're saying compy based education I think we're running into a problem where we're equating it with our grading system but that doesn't have to be it at all compy based education like in my eyes which maybe we need to go back and find that and you know how you were talking about let's get together a group of people to talk about it um I think is based on my opinion you're trying to meet the kid where they're at and help them learn and if you have different sites

043you have different departments you have different kids with different needs but we're all being forced to do the same uniform grading system that teachers are perceiving as less accurate and we feel like our hand are tied um it just doesn't make sense and I was shocked when I looked at the data I was thinking with the feedback that quax been given at the meetings that um and with how long they've been doing it that their numbers would be very different than what they were if what we're doing was good for all students across the district and it was a matter of the time they'd spent on it just like what you talked about why in the heck are coaxes numbers what they are why is it that deloro who the teachers have been stressing out

044to try to get this to work the way that they've been told they're supposed to make it work why is that literally none of them are behind it of leaving it as it is and when I look at those numbers and people like okay but we're in the middle of the year right now we're starting a new term this is a perfect time to go through and make a shift and it doesn't have to be a big shift and um I have I I went through I looked at the policy there's very little that has to be changed that would free us up and allow us to make these decisions by department where we can be doing compy based education we're not trying to throw that out but if we're truly doing comy based education

045shouldn't we have accurate and Equitable grading and is that what we're getting um it doesn't look like it to us from what the survey is showing uh thank thank you um I I have a question for you the you're math department yeah yeah yeah yeah what I have heard overwhelmingly from Math teachers is that to your point on the appreciating Competency Based education that you and the ma the math department was providing Essentials which is very similar to the I guess the scales uh and and so a lot of people said they're already they've already been doing compens best education yeah but the problem is that they've been put into this box that they don't fit into with the grading system rubric grading is challenging in math because when you do a math problem there

046are a bunch of previous skills that the kids have to know and really the most effective feedback in my subject area is what do you not know that's going to help you get to the next level it's not a checkbox of you understand this target and this Target and this target or you went above and beyond because you applied that Target to a real life situation or something like that or you connected things right um and it's not that there's not value in that but we've had that all along we maybe need to emphasize that more um but we can't even we don't even have time to think about those kind of things because frankly this this grading stuff has been an overarching time killer um I talked with someone yesterday and they brought up

047the fact that they're a shop teacher and um and this has actually happened in math to where he would like to go through and make um some particular skills to be worth more than others because he doesn't feel right now with everything being split up equally that he's actually representing where the kids are at right there are some things if you're going to go work in a shop that you should have under your belt and there's other things that aren't as important but the way the system is set up right now all of those things have to count for the same amount I've run into that problem in math personally have you run into that in science you have two um and in math and I am one this this one I don't even want

048to go back and look at my Gradebook because I don't want to have that question in the back of my head did I pass anybody on that probably shouldn't have gone on but like solving equations is absolutely essential to them being able to go up to the upper levels that scale that it's in is the same as inequalities which really frankly like they could survive without it but that gets us all back to the the um all kids all scales thing too or all scales all kids whichever way people are saying it um and it's like is that really necessary too and I do feel like the other thing on this is that we're talking about all these little bitty individual things but really it all comes back to like can we make these decisions

049as departments and you guys have the ability to allow us to do that with a little tweak in the policy um and granted there are things we can do because a lot of these things that the teachers are having a hard time with are things that are not actually part of the board policy it's been interpret and I get how that happens right like how do you go through and get everybody to move on something and at the district level like you have control over grading how we go through and grade but we've had such an I don't think anybody's going to be particularly upset at this point we've had so much of a change in terms of leadership um this this is a right time to do it I think um I would not

050recommend waiting and those kids that are Del that are stressing about college grades and stuff like we can fix that now what's the lift if something were to change now at the beginning of the semester what's what's the lift for the teachers uh we just need the ability to be able to set up with support um to set up our grade books as we see fit so like next Monday we have our department meeting days and this needs to be through departments is is what it looks like from the data um so that would give us an opportunity to go through and and talk about it there I also o feel and I mentioned this that a minimum day that is in March that's right next to our professional development day should get mve to

051next week to Wednesday and then we can set up our grade books and that'll give us a couple of Tas to kind of go through and think things through to so it's not on the same day that we're having these discussions and we're setting up the grade books as well so and maybe some people I mean there there was a group right it was under 10% but there was a group that does like it the way that we have it now like well we have have those grade back uh forms right that people can go through and pull from what do they call those grade Chang templat the templates thank you templates that was the word I was looking for so they have the templates and so if we just had I don't think that

052would be particularly difficult right to have some different templ templates that we could go through in pull front and even that departments could share information across sites or whatever but but our sites are very very different and this is one way to meet the needs of our IND idual sites and then and then we have time this term we've taken care of that we have time this term to go back and talk about what does compy based education actually mean like how can we support accurate and Equitable grading um for all of our students across the district I think one of that one of the things that I'm thinking as I'm sitting here is that we need to get back to a place that we were in this District years ago where we treat our

053teachers like the experts in the field that they are and let them have some autonomy because there's not a person in this room minus the teachers that are sitting over here that know their their students better than we do either we as the board or any of these administrators for that matter um they're the ones that are working with those students every day they're the ones that know the those students needs they're the ones that know oh I can do this to help meet that student's need or this is not working for that student so I need to change that like we need to get back to a place where we're we're trusting our teachers to make those those kinds of decisions because they're the experts they are they're the ones that know the students

054yeah Jeremy you've been in the classroom I've been in the classroom so I agree with you on that uh flexibility is is critical I I'm still at a place and I'm thinking uh Plasser High School had gotten rid of D's and Fs it was ABC and we were doing not it wasn't mandated but i' say half the staff was doing Competency Based education you know giving students different opportunities and more opportunities to learn the standards in different ways if necessary and it was working so my mind says if you if you ditch the grading system per se the point system this point you know kids don't really understand it and that's what I'm hearing or it's hard for me to meet my expectations with the standards the way they are right now I remember we

055not Kim was uh you teaching English 90 she's the only other person in the district that was doing it well that's still around for that we're still around 90% and above an a 80% and above a b 70% and above is C no D's no FS with standards that the district or the department s but it could be that the district says are critical regardless of sight that's what I would love to see see so I think that would be an appropriate discussion for when we get together and have a group because regardless I think we need to have more more time Beyond this not in terms of I I do think we can make the the critical change today is is my thought um if you guys are good with it but um that

056type of stuff frankly we're a little fried um that would come at that time I feel like let's make the change that can fix this and then talk about those kind of things my opinion I hear you I this is so nuanced and complex I I don't think that we can solve The World's problems or our District's you know um difficulties in in one session but I do think we could address what we can hopefully we we have some agreement on that sounds like we we do not exactly sure where that's going to land but I agree that we need some more time to unpack and look at it and um to make you know some more changes down the line potentially that we address it as a district so I just and one thing

057that I know from four decades in the classroom is a teacher has to have flexibility and they have to have some economy to as you're jerem you're saying to meet the needs of the kids there's no doubt about that we're not robots you know that are going to be robotic in how we move we have to be able to be flexible so I I I really think that we need to not only discuss it but make some small changes right now the way I'm looking at it you know to make our system work better for all yes and one other point I would like to make in terms of what Jacob collected here just keep in mind too this is just people putting in their own comments no prompts we didn't have any meetings there's

058probably a lot more here that we don't see so for example yesterday when I was in a meeting um one of the teachers there is like I didn't do the survey can I still do the survey I'm like no it is closed you are not allowed to do it well but I don't like CB I'm like okay can you tell me a little more about that so like I can actually like include that in my thoughts on talking the board well but I don't like anything so like that kind of stuff too you know what I mean like that skew um so I if if you're okay with it I have um some notes if I could approach the board and the superintendent that I'll share with you in terms of what I thought when

059I was going through and doing it um and then the only thing that I missed and I thought about this last night sorry we didn't talk about that um was on the D's probably if you did want to bring back the D's and the reason why you might want to consider doing that is because there's been concerns about College and Career Readiness and not to say longterm it's just things went really fast with all of this and we might just need to reassess how we're doing it like Delaware is getting swamped with incompletes haha um not us as bad but that would be okay because then those kids will have the opportunity to find success without a d which is a low standard well so I'm just saying I'm just putting it out there if

060we want to do that it would be something like just keep in mind even talking to the counselors and that decision wouldn't have to be made today because that isn't going to influence our Gradebook setups necessarily other then we have to tweak the um the possibly a percentage in with the it what I'm saying is that's not a a a a liver dye thing I'm just bringing it up because that language is in the board policy so when I was going through board policy I put little notes about what would have to change to accommodate this and I'm just saying I didn't do that I I put like a you'll see pencil on there is that okay yeah that's great and I just again I'm looking at all this it feels like bring back these

061have clear timelines on retakes some of these things just seem to go back towards the grading system that was in place before um so yeah I think there's a lot to we here okay perfect yep yep perfect thank you pass this down is there any more that you guys would like to share with us at this point or um I'm sure we're going to have some discussion later may have some further questions after Trent's presentation okay I think we said plenty awesome thank you much I thought it was gonna be really short um and people did say thank you there there was there were quite a few responses said Thank you thank you for listening I feel heard now um and thank you um for starting this process in terms of the board and we're

062we all want the same thing we're all on the same team we just we just need to figure out how to best do that amen couldn't have said that better thank you thank you I feel like you deserve walk out music I I will try not to be too long uh I never am too short so um you know I I texted the principles during uh uh the teachers presentation and thank you Beth and Jacob uh just to you know they have a little more boots on the ground so I told them if they want to add some context to jump in uh when when they feel it might be necessary to jump in so um I don't know if they will or not uh I also wanted to start off and saying there is

063a little dis um I think misinformation about kfax um and in their process they they were some early adopters and uh grading practices and there was a lot of teachers that that had taken that role on early and um last year when we started the pilot they were they were doing it full as a as a school but they were eight years ago Tom they weren't like all on board CBE it had been some early adopters with grading practices they had uh went from grading practices to uh looking at grade books like a like a standards based grade book to facilitate uh their work that they had been doing in uh uh equable berring with Joe Feldman and that's what I understood I'm just curious that is it just to confirm was it four years

064ago that they actually rolled it out live uh what's that rolled what out rolled out CB throughout no no I I think last year was the first year that they did as a full pilot of the school if I'm yeah so could you come to the mic thank you there's a lot of misconception that's going on right now um the first thing I'd like to say is that yes I'm an IB School but also yes I serve as special education students I have a very high population of students with with economic disadvantages um so my IB cohort is my AP classes um my IB students who get the diploma have to take six AP classes in order to get their diploma and so and then on top of that they have to do community service

065they have to write a 20page paper and they have to um uh there's one other component that I'm missing right now but it's pretty it's a huge undertaking for those students and those teachers for those 15 IB students but we cannot be disregarded because we're an IB School because we still have to service all of the other students so that's the first thing I'd like to say the second thing is is grading practice started 10 years ago and we started looking at these grading practices and Trent has a beautiful site on it on what those grading practices are we did those 10 years ago I had a lot of teachers on board with that and they were experimenting with that and then we when the board decided to give us these grading practices we did

066them and and we've had success with those the fourpoint scale came about three years ago I came to the school as a new principal I had half of my teachers doing a 100 point scale and half half of them doing a four-point scale we had a lot of conversations we have I have a what I call a quad a team I have a lead team those teams together decided we want to have our full school go to a four-point grading scale because it's too confusing for parents and students to have a teacher have a 100 Point teacher have a four point whatever it was so in January of my first year so three years ago almost three years ago exactly that's when we all decided to do fourpoint grading scale and it had nothing to

067do with CBE it was because it was good grading practice and I can go into the fourpoint scale and what that means and exactly how it ties to the proficiency scales and why it's so important that we don't have these convoluted point this point that or what delineates a 81 from a 82% or an 89 to a 90% so that's why we went to the fourpoint grading scale so when that happened that's when CBE started rolling out and the conversation started happening actually the conversation started happening many years ago about CBE I presented CBE at pler I presented CBE at deloro when I was there too so I've been an administrator in three of the four comprehensives in this uh District so CBE started coming out we started looking we had essential learning outcomes from

068those essential learning outcomes we started building those proficiency scales and so then we started ruling that out so CBE for us still we were with the rest of the district the only difference is that last year when we did the pilot I did have have a good amount of teachers who did the pilot we love CBE we hated Empower we were the first ones to say we need something different so the district went out and found something different and then they brought it to us and then we were the first ones to say this does not work get rid of it so um when did you do that pilot what year was that that was last year that was last year yes last fall um and so then that's when we were I mean the

069whole time we had been playing with Aries all of those things so yeah we may have a little bit more experience with it but that's only because I have a group of teachers who are phenomenal and they wanted to really dig in and figure out what this looked like so we manipulated Aries we didn't like the manipulation of Aries we said we want something different we got Empower we hated EMP power we still want something different than Aries but we don't know what it is I really wish I'm going to look at Nick over here because he's a computer genius that he would like design something for us because he knows exactly what we want um so yes that is the transition so we haven't been doing it for eight years we've been doing the

070fourpoint scale for three years um and that's come it's hard it's difficult we have to Grapple with it and go with it but we're making it work up there but CBE only started last year and the Prof and then um that's only like a good I'm bringing people along right like my teachers are coming along this year it was full implementation just like everybody else so just wanted to clear that up thank you thank you Jesse um I want to begin uh and and apologize if I uh come off to forward but this is a big decision and it has a lot of um you know Downstream effects that will affect a lot of different things that you do and as as administrators do and schools do and I hope you know these decisions aren't

071done uh well my my experience is the best decisions aren't done uh on the fleeting emotions of the moment and I know there's a lot of emotions right now um and I hope that we can see through those um Improvement in any field is never without friction and and I don't you know I would like you guys to think about um what it is that leads to Improvement in any organization personal Improvement all of the things that you think like if somebody or something is going to make an Improvement on something what are all the variables that are needed for somebody to get better do better and make something better because I think that really answers a lot of the work that we've tried to do here at the school uh third thing I want

072to say is leadership in schools is difficult because you are dealing with a lot of competing and conflicting interests right and uh I don't want to tell you your job but your job as a board is to see through those completing competing conflicting interests and make the best decision for the all of the students in our school district um and it's hard I tell uh uh new principles uh new administrators all the time that you are in a position now that every decision you make you're going to upset somebody whether it's a student whether it's a parent whether it's a teacher and that those are the things that we have to do so I just want to make sure that you're aware that that we have to make tough decisions that aren't going to be

073popular sometimes in the moment um the implementation of this the other thing I want to say has been uh something that uh I reflect on often because it was my job and I mentioned about you know taking responsibility for it so I always reflect on uh the implementation of it and one of the things that I will say that I feel like the administrators at the site and myself have always tried to do is begin with a plan but always uh have a process to solicit feedback and make adjustments as we see necessary we've always done that and our door has always been open and we've always had a great relationship with the teachers and the cnis and we are in the process of doing that I mean even right now as we go through

074and we meet every Friday or nearly every Friday we meet every week whether it's in cabinet or in our own personal uh PLC meeting is our discussion about what are the tweaks what are the things that we need to do to make what we're doing better and I think we'll we'll continue doing that because we we believe in in what we're doing but it it's something that I do want to make sure that you guys are aware of is that we didn't set up a plan and say this is what we're doing we're not changing we set up a plan we worked with pilot we had a lot of Engagement a lot of feedback and we made changes like getting rid of Empower uh we had people at like say pler High School who were

075like we hate Empower we like CBE we're going to develop something in Aries and they actually you know sort of developed this the the Aries Gradebook that we use which is the best version that we could find for what we're doing but it wasn't because uh it was because we were engaging in conversation and dialogue and and and working on our craft as we were going through can I ask a question Trent yep let's interrupt you but do you feel like you had enough input from teachers prior to implementing CBE this year across the district do you feel like you had enough input from teachers before you did that before it didn't before you said the district said this is what's going to happen you feel like you had enough input from teachers before implementing

076CBE this year across the district I I didn't Implement CBE that was the board decision to make that I talking about the district do you feel like there was enough input from teachers I think we I think we had been going down this path for a long time and people knew where we were going I think we communicated very effectively if you talk to the principls everybody the people who didn't know that we were going this way I I personally believe chose not to know that so you feel like there was enough input from teachers feedback from teachers about CBE before it was implemented yeah I I I I think we offered the um opportunity for feedback now whether they solicited it or not and gave it or not I don't know do I believe

077that there was some feeling that uh this wasn't going to happen possibly and so we're not going to engage in it I think that might might be the case but I I I feel like we we were I was at sites a lot I know the what the principles were doing what the sites were doing about working with there um with their people how we were and we spent a whole last year and I I think I presented it last time about all of the pullout days and the time of information that we're doing to build these proficiency scales like hey this is where we're going this is what we're doing so um I think there was opportunity for input do you think it's fair to say um just you know in align with that

078that because a small percentage of our staff across the district had had participated in in the pilot that this year going across you know districtwide we got a lot more feedback oh 100% yeah so I think I think there was people that might not have been able to give feedback because they hadn't participated prior potentially and so I think that's why it's pretty overwhelming right now because it's hit critical mass that's no I think you're right I think I think um there's a lot of people who weren't participating and and again I think um you know you don't know what you don't know right um until you implement it I mean you could you we you know you can Implement something and think that it's going to go this way and you realize oh I

079didn't know this I didn't realize this and that's happened yeah and and we realize that and I will say that um you know and I could refer to the teachers too a feeling like um we were very gracious we I I don't think that we were overly um uh prescriptive in like you know hey you guys aren't doing this wrong and I'll give you an example like we would look at gradebooks and I noticed that uh some of the teachers weren't uh entering based off the half-point sca scale system I didn't call them up I didn't call them out we I don't think any of our principles went to their door and said hey you're not doing this right we were giving space for them to understand this system and work through it we knew

080that it was going on but we were like hey well we'll just kind of work with them we know it's it's um it's brand new and we can't uh uh you know have too high of expectations for them uh in in in regarding of being in Fidelity with everything that we had outlined so I think we we tried to provide um some space for them to to make some changes and that's why I think when Jacob said yeah I think there are some differences that are happening at the sites it's because the sites were uh we had this flexible model of here's our North Star and we're going to kind of we're going to go that way and we're going to try to keep everybody moving in that direction even though some people might be

081a little slower um some people might need a little more support and those kinds of things and and the timeline again so we passed this policy David uh Springtime of of 2023 and our resolution dictated the timeline so that was not at a district level that was at the board level so this expedite did kind of roll out yep um there wasn't a lot of flexibility because of what we had prescribed yep so that one's not on them that one's on us the reason I asked that question is because I'm thinking back with grading practices um they had we had literally within the district years to go through that and explore and you know try different things and that kind of stuff uh and it seems from my perspective this CBE was just like pushed

082out very very quickly with not a lot of feedback and the statistics from ATP seem to represent that as well um that there wasn't a lot of feedback from the staff about how this could be implemented okay um and again you know I just say this I think the famous Professor Dumbledore said that uh we all have to make choices between easy and hard and um and I think this is going to be a hard decision and uh I I hope that we make this decision based on again um the whole um breadth and depth of what we're what we're hoping to do for our students you mentioned adjustments and that are in charge of the implementation of this so looking back what would you have done differently and I I don't know about getting

083into the into the granular you know things pop up right sure and you guys are making and I I believe it I mean I've talked to a ton of teachers I've talked to Administration I've sat with with uh with Nick and and and his APS and 100% I know that he cares and is trying right to to get make this work so there's no question in my mind on that and you guys are pivoting as things come up um at least that's my experience with delor but when you think about the implementation of this and I'm in software so I understand like there's there's always things that you look back on and big rocks right you're like maybe we should have done this a little differently what might have you guys have done differently just

084given not only the feedback but also what we're seeing not only the 13 week but also the full semester um grades that we're seeing that soon obviously down it's a tough question I I you know hindsight's always 2020 you know I don't know if I would make these things that come to my mind are like should we have uh slow rolled into a four-point system and and allowed sort of a a similar system with a with a traditional grading uh percentage um you know it would have been nice to have uh another year of uh pulling out teachers and doing some training um for sure I think that that obviously would have uh been um advantageous to have um but uh but I you know I couldn't change that uh so maybe that because that

085feels like the biggest sticking point is is the four-point system because it is the biggest mind shift um and you know i' i' I've talked to I'm blue in the face about this and it's so it's it's hard to keep talking about it when I feel like it it it's not going to resonate um and and Chassis mentioned it too I think it is a better system but you you it takes a while for you to get there um and and some people um take longer especially if they don't want to get there um and and see the value in it so um but the other thing I know about change is um sometimes you have to prod the change sometimes you have to force the the the change to happen because it's not going

086to happen on its own and I think uh you know although it's been stressful uh for a lot of teachers I I you know anecdotally have heard from teachers who say I don't like it but I've learned a lot of different things and I see some value that I wouldn't have seen before um and I've seen a lot of growth in our teachers of understanding their curriculum understanding you know their assessments and ways that they've never really had to think about until now and those are all positive things that takes a lot more work but I think they're thinking about things in ways that they uh were forced to that they they hadn't done before um so I'm not going to read the board policy you guys have uh you guys have it it's I

087think it's in your packets on the thing um I just wanted to to you know let you guys know that there's not a lot Beth talked about it there's not a lot in the board policy that is specific to CBE in the AR which is the next slide um is where all of the details um are found um and all of the elements and components that are found and so you know as as you guys know or may not know some some of you are new the administrative regulation is what supports the the broad um goals of the the board policy so this is what the board approved um and this is what uh is is there now in our administrative regulation so uh just for your for your um ability to review so you

088can go ahead and go to the next slide all right so I just want to talk about so elements of CBE you know realizing that you guys want to review and look at uh and I I told when I talked to Jessica about you know some lines of retreat I use that term um you know sensing that there was going to be some possible change uh with with new board coming in and some of the um issues that were happening on our sites that we had been talking as as administrative group about okay what are the things that that can change how can we again kind of have that North Star of like we think we know this is the right way to go but but what are some of the adjustments we could make

089and still feel like we're we're heading in the right direction and not taking step back taking steps backwards so um there are seven of them there proficiency scales obviously communicate our learning expectations and progress to our uh parents and students the grade books uh provides consistency uh help ensure that the tenants of of the uh um CBE were being followed um the four level scale I I I want to get away from the four point because that point thing just kind of really uh um messes with people's minds um but it provides a road map to learning um the final Mark cut scores were uh you know determines what constitutes a letter grade uh we we changed some of those um grading marks uh What uh what the students that actual letters could get um

090we also changed uh those to align with the tenants of CBE and quality schools um the idea of all scills and all students and again I I get the argument I I've been in uh what is it it used to be called the it's now it's the Aurora Institute which is the big Competency Based National Competency Based uh uh um Think Tank if you will I read some literature that this is an argument that is um within sort of the Competency Based education World anyway ways about you know do they have to know and show competency in everything or or those kinds of things our goal of it was to um really raise our expectations of our student learning we really strongly believe that if this is what is essential to student knowing this thing

091then uh they should know that thing and you should be able to demonstrate it and I will point out that none of us as teacher or as administrators wrote the proficiency skills they were they were written by um the teachers and then the instructions that we gave and and again it could have been poor instruction from us and and how they were going about it but the job was look at the standards identify what's the most essential and needed and that's what you're going to build your proficiency skills from so um that you know if we need to still make some adjustments because we're we're grading something to uh evaluating students on something that's not essential or necessary then we probably shouldn't have it in the grade book anyways and we're willing to make those

092changes as well um and then the accurate and Grading practices that we've been talking about for a long time that uh uh allow for fair uh evaluation of students and also focuses mainly on our student learning so those are the elements and we'll take a look at um I'm sure you guys have perused this a little bit we we'll take a look at each of our um current and then possible revisions and obviously I don't put it on there but you could scrap it all you you can just get rid of it all um so but I didn't put that on there as well and I also want to point out that um it is a little tricky because some of these are sort of interconnected you start pulling them apart and it's like oh

093I pulled this one thing but you don't realize that that that one thing was connected to this thing and it was connected to this thing so um it it can't have that impact So currently um proficiency scales all of our courses are required to have them uh we wanted all of our courses to have the same ones uh we think all grading and evaluation should be done with the proficiency skills based on those and all reporting of grades should be based off those proficiency skills um possible revisions would be as I think people were advocating allow for some variation between sites um but within the department or the subject matter uh they have the same ones so for example like plaster and do have different biology scills but at do all of the biology scales

094will be the same at Plaster all of the U plaster biology scales would be the same I again just my concern is I always feel like I don't want to say oh we've created a system where this these students at this school get this experience and this expectation and these students get a different one and it's lower or higher or something like that I think the thing that you're overlooking there when you're saying that though Trent is we're talking apples and oranges students at one site might be very different than the students at another site I mean we we sometimes we try to fit them all into the same shoe or forgetting that that simple fact no they're different but we believe that all students can meet those standards absolutely 100% Trent would you explain

095um what guaranteed viable curriculum trusty SP and I had a little conversation but just kind of breaking that down a little bit of guaranteed and viable I think applies to what what you're talking about yeah so I think guaranteed and viable curriculum is uh you know a lot of educational researchers Marzano hadti others um realize that the state creates curriculum per subject and they created these standards I one and two and three are great examples all the English courses are the same uh that um are impossible to teach adequately in the depth and breadth needed in the 180 days that a students are in a class or a 90 day 4x4 so um it's just that you can't and so uh with that the idea is um we have to identify exactly what can we

096teach to every single one of our students what is the most important for them to be successful um not only within that subject area but what is going to allow them to be successful across the curriculum at their school so it's that guaranteed like I know you're going to be in this class it's going to guarantee you that you learned this thing and it's you're able to learn that you have the time frame and the ability and the resources to learn that thing to get you on to the next course so is guaranteed and viable great fil is that okay just want to make sure um so we could we could definitely um have some different variation between sites um and and you know Jeremy to your point there might be different students but I

097think also uh on the counter argument is sometimes there's different um like especially science as one of those there's a lot of different Pathways um that exist at pler that don't exist at deloro or don't exist at um at kfax so there might be some you know I think an argument to be made about having a little variation in that because there are different Pathway to to the uh within the same pathway let me give you a perfect example having written some of proficiency skills myself as a video teacher when I was at deloro my focus was more film making however at kfax their video production classes were more like video journalism even though it was still video production so we had kind of two different focuses so so to speak okay so one set

098of proficiency scales at one site might not fit the program at another site do you agree to that uh I I think the standards are the standards I don't know the specific subjects all that you know like every single subject but I think they're um you know they found a way to work together and develop the if they were the same courses then they found a way to for example um in kfax they might be asked the students might be asked to you know write a news article using inverted pyr method right my students at Delora didn't need to know that because we didn't do that kind of work okay perfect example like we need to give autonomy to the different sites to be able to decide like what is JY I'm just giving you

099guys your option for the revisions okay that's all I'm doing so I I get you have a personal aspect that you want to uh discuss here but I'm just giving you what your revisions can be made I think also um trusted Jeff with when you're looking at CTE right the pathway those CT Pathways have specific standards that are lined to that particular pathway and so there was flexibility throughout the proficiency scale process realizing that a CTE course at all especially CT at all of our courses have a different bent based upon what that CT pathway is is doing so they had that flexibility to do that but there were still some guaranteed standards based upon the CT standards that all students regardless of that pathway it still Falls in line with the the CT standards

100but yes to answer your question that that's a good example where there'd be some some variability between CT Pathways same with you know forest forest hill and you know um having um fire science or a science or it's even those a science courses though still follow the state standards for for life science of biology there's still it's just how they deliver it may I'm doing life science standards for the cell I'm going to focus on just the cell versus delor might be vet science and animal cells you know those types of differences but the standard still of understanding all the and I don't we don't have to get all those nuan but yeah you're right there are some differences based on those CT Pathways um and to the point is that you can have a

101certain number of scales be the same and allow for differences so you could say hey here's biology and we you know you call them sort of these here's the five that all the schools agree on that these proficiency scales will be but since we have a little different pathway here a different pathway there these three will be added for deloro these two you know you could we could you know that's also something that we discussed and looked at but again it could be based off of site um you know determination so that's that those are some possible revisions for for the uh profic scales now the downside to that obviously it could be um that uh well well one and I heard this uh from a number of teachers is that um you know the

102district uh plc's have not worked as closely and as tightly and through like working on their curriculum as they have and then once you start doing this it becomes a lot harder to work together when you've now created a system where they might not be teaching exactly the same stuff and it just becomes harder so um that could be a downside of changing that um next scale uh gradebooks uh we re we required the teachers to use are CBE template Gradebook um different types of Assessments were in there so you had a targeted assessment which is 90% of the grade foundational 10% of the grade um all professional all proficiency scales are a category in the Gradebook and all scales were equally weighted and the idea behind the the weighting of the the scales equally

103and again I I don't have um a major emotional connection to this I know some uh of my uh people do might have more of a connection to this but the idea was if you had all scales all students essentially it kind of made it moot because they have to pass every single scale right um so it wasn't like they were not going to pass the most important scale they still had to show that they're proficient and you probably were going to provide more assessments so they had to demonstrate it more often in that one scale that one area to show that they're competent um so that was the that was the rationale behind it again I I get that some teachers are like no no it has to be um there's got to be

104more weight here I think that was something that we could work through so uh with the possible revision I I don't like it going this is I think I would speak for everybody here going below 90% uh for the targeted assessments um because then you start uh creating categories where uh you're really not evaluating and the grade becomes more other things than what they a student can demonstrate in terms of what they know and what they can do that's our um recommendation but obviously you know that's for you guys to to make a determination about can I ask you a quick question on that so are are the targets primarily like tests um I mean there's a there's a lot with assessments because we we sort of had this sort of rigid view of it

105but it it should be should be anything that's aligned to that proficiency scale that a student can demonstrate the skill or the knowledge a lot of times it's been tests a lot of times it's been essays or projects or things like that but in reality anything that is align like if I gave you an assignment said I need you to do this and I was able to watch you to do this thing that could be um my assessment of you uh within that targeted it's just it's just meeting all of those requirements of what's expected of learning what i' I've heard some that that obviously like the practice work outside of it and some of this was the feedback from ATP but also others um that some of that foundational work you know wasn't really

106being reflected in in what they knew or you know depending on how they were they were their target targeted assessments were being like laid out yeah um I know I've got kids with like total test anxiety and dyslexia you know yeah me too so yeah not not you know not always going to perform awesome on a test um but that didn't really show what I knew and it didn't really show what they knew so some of these targets I'm hearing from some um that we're we're not potentially it's not you know um showing really their knowledge um just through the some of the targeted assessments and then that's that's a problem that we would want to definitely dive into and and because uh it and that's been the way to be honest with you uh

107Jessica there's a lot of things that is it's always been the case yeah sure Assessments in in schools have if you looked and then they've done studies on this where they've said uh in fact they call them calibration studies where they go in and say we're going to look at your your test and then calibrate it to the uh standard that's written for that grade in that content area and it's almost always off at a much lower rate yeah so um I think I think that miscalibration between What's um expected and how we're assessing it has been the case and that's something that we've been trying to work through for a while but uh but it's something that those are the those are the revisions that we would and again all categories um if if

108that was going to be unequally weighted um again I think there's some some need to have some uniformity at the sites um because again it could create some situations where teachers are doing things different and then and then there's a a dynamic there that we don't really appreciate yeah and the teachers wouldn't really appreciate either I don't think um next one for uh fourpoint scale four level scale again a tar tulate I can't speak articulates level of learning for each activity for both targeted and foundational and again and I know this is really hard and and I was listening because i' I've listened to Jacob talk about before uh our our goal was that scores should be associated with levels of learning because they're not really points they're identifying where a student is geographically in

109their learning and I know it's really hard for us sometimes to say you know this student got a he met the Target and got a three this student did better on a test not good enough to get a 3.5 but did better than this student on the test and they got a 3-2 and that just fills not right and um and I and I've thought about this you know going yeah that I'm trying to work my uh you know my mind through this and one of the things I I realized too is this happens in a lot of different areas it happens in AP testing um you pass an AP test with a three there's a lot of different versions of Threes some people do a lot better and still get a three and some

110people barely got the three but they still got the three and they're the same so um the idea was that I understand some of those those arguments about not liking it um but again I think uh people I've talked to whove who've made the transition to understanding it um it just takes a while takes a while um so possible revision is obviously you can go back to a traditional 100 points uh system um I think with the these cats that each assignment would still be attached to a proficiency scale um each assignment will be identified as a Target or or foundational um and the level score of two uh would be you know sort of similar to the 70% um so that would be that would be our recommendation of if if the traditional 100

111point system was going to come back that's what we would suggest sounds very much like Rockland High or Rockland unified um possible issues uh as you guys I think already mentioned uh it would be a lot less continuity and some confusion about like okay which teacher me but I always say this this is existed I I know that there have been teachers when we were doing the grading practice practice that had transfer went to a four-point scale they were doing a four-point scale while everybody else was doing a 100 point system um they did a great job of communicating what their grade system was to their to their teachers and or to their parents and students um and I don't recall it being too big of an issue um let's go ahead and next one

112uh cut scores you know we started out at this at at our current with those cut scores and that was not an easy thing to get to because not everybody agreed with it um and we kind of split the baby uh with those cut scores and uh uh so again if there was a change made to that I think we could facilitate that you could allow again for site variation I think the one site that would be real interested in going away from that fourpoint system would be classer and I get their argument um for it as well I think it there's not a right answer there's just a this is what we think and we feel uh better with it um and then obviously if the traditional uh scoring is used then we just

113do what we've always done with the traditional scoring and then if you added a d back then you know obviously that would fit in there somewhere did you go back to the comment just on elaborate a little more on why PL would be the only school to adjust the I think um so there was a philosophical difference about um uh you know reading the literature they they did a really great job of like focusing in on the literature and when Marzano uh presents some scales he'll say to you you know it depends on what you guys want to do as a site locally and you know figuring it out but um the idea if if a student met a three in all of the uh proficiency scales then that should be an a they've met

114the expectations for every single thing that felt like an A and um whereas I think that was their argument if I yeah yeah um the uh the other schools and again it all depends this is where it kind of gets a little convoluted it all depends on what the the wording of the proficiency scale says and what your level two says what your level three says and so those things U make a big difference um but the other idea was the a the 3.25 was we wanted our kids to go above and beyond we want them to shoot Beyond just the expectation and and have them work for that and getting them to try that uh we found value in that um so we went with the a in that category and then the C

115we adjusted because I believe uh kfax and delo both wanted 2.5 to be the floor again to say that they they you know if you get a two you could get a two by just meeting the minimal across the whole breadth of the course but at 2.5 you at least have to really get meet meet the Target on more than half of those uh uh proficiency scales I'm going to interrupt you real fast jent um I think um this discussion alone on the cut scores and we talk about teacher involvement in in input was months semester worth with our principles going to their lead team going to their staff meeting getting feedback anecdotal going to classrooms asking questions and getting to three 3.25 and the cut score of the 2.74 that that took a little

116bit of everybody kind of going oh I can I can live with that but that all came through tremendous work on transpart and our principles and our and our department chairs and our cnis and our classroom teachers having these hard conversations I think that's that's part of it this wasn't this isn't Trent's scale this isn't Jimmy Jackson's scale this was this is a collaborative scale from all of our sites having input in into that and was everybody 100% happy absolutely not that's almost impossible but part of you know negotiating and having hard conversations is saying you know what can what can we live with and what where can we our philosophical differences align um for what's best for kids so that I think it's a kudos to to Trent leadership and to our our site

117administrators and our teachers and our lead teams all coming together and having qu conversations I think we could all say over the last however many years this has been going through the level of dialogue in our plc's in our lead team meetings lead team at at a site meeting that you're Department chairs has never been at a higher level ever um and that's because of these conversations happening throughout out the district so I just need to can I ask an Aries question I I'm not an Aries expert but I'll do my best some else in the room that it would be maybe but you can get you can ask and then we'll see if if the district moved to back to a traditional grade scale system in using Aries but we still wanted to have

118the elos where they had to pass the elos to pass the class like the central skills at Rockland does Aries or yeah does Aries have the ability to have a grade override column so there can be you know they could they could the students and parents could look at like what their grades are so far but then you know if they look at the grade override colum they could tell if they're passing or not passing based on whether they passed or didn't pass the scales I I don't know that does anybody know that I I don't know that Carlos Carlos Carlos I so don't want to have make you come up here but no one in the community who may or may not be watching will never know what you say it'll be a mystery

119thank you did did it make sense what I was asking caros so uh if I understand correctly what you're asking is once you create these standards can the can the parents see the the scores for the standards and the overall the score for the class is that correct um not sure I I think we uh try to restate the question um is there a possibility as the teachers are setting up their grade books if they have you know uh you know a grade column for each of the different proficiency scales is there an an ability or or the assignments or what have you is there an ability to have a grade override column that overrides the grades of the other categories so they can look immediately the student or the parent can look immediately into

120Aries and realize okay yeah I got I did really well on these these scales but it still shows I'm you know I got it incomplete in the class because I didn't pass this other scale over here like but they're proving that they are competent right so that we're we're trying to alleviate the confusion with students and parents not being able to go into Aries and say are they passing or are they not passing or I I I think we have that system right now where where where the where the system that we have they know ex like um I hate to use my daughter as example but I was able to go through and look at her in chemistry and go oh she's not going to pass because she hasn't met all of the I'm

121looking at all of the all the proficiency scale categories going oh she's missed more than the amount that she can so it's all it's all there but I think one thank you I think one thing that you're bringing up a good point is it would be really nice to have that overall grade if there there's 10 scales there it's averaging a c that is confusing to a parent if especially because you get that Friday text as a parent says my kids are good that's exactly what I'm asking yeah I don't know if I don't know if it it I don't know if it's possible but it would be cool yeah that you know that was communicated through a teacher and and that issue and I you know I I look forward to my text on

122Friday for how my kids doing and you know their availability with their friends changes based on what I receive in my house so you know I'm not always going into Aries and yeah you know ensuring that they're passing each of their standards so I think that communication piece um Aries is very very difficult to get them to sort of customize to what we would like and that communication piece with our students and their families is so like critical and I you know I know we're not going to fully unpack the data that you shared from um the fall term grading and the core subjects um there's so many incompletes which I'm not even sure how many incompletes and and I sent that email to you today oh did you oh I so I didn't I

123didn't catch the last one sorry pull it up while I'm here but um yeah that that was a concern of mine was like man I wonder how many parents thought that their kid was passing didn't watch the excellent video you sent out trying to explain how this all works um and so that communication aspect you know unfor I I can't speak for every teacher um that did it and I know that our sites did a really good job of working with their teachers to communicate effectively to their teachers about the incomplete process so um I know that we spent a lot of time in our principal PLC discussing that and making sure everybody had a plan going forward to be able to communicate to the parents exactly how um their incomplete would be able to

124be remediated and make sure that was out there yeah you know I um even with really great planning and an attempt to execute beautifully without a doubt there's always casualties there's always something and so I was hearing from from some staff um that this occurred at the end of their semester like they weren't even fully you know aware that it was going to be all skills and that all of a sudden there were a bunch ofs for them too so yeah so I think that you know there was there was a bit of an issue right there I have a question to the to that so right now um the new semester started and anyone that had an incomplete uh has the opportunity uh to uh to get that grade up by February mid-February sometime

125right yeah sth what what are we going to do in the spring semester with the same situation as we go into summer we we will have a summer program um that will they will communicate to them and say if you have an option here's here's a summer program we've done it for the last years three or four years okay since Co what about seniors same same thing we try to get the seniors dialed in and finished before they walk yeah we there's a a lot of counselors doing a lot of work making sure that they're not having an i or or an NC uh in that spring term okay so that's not anything that it sounds like a process and Paul that you already have yeah we got a process that we're working working through

126it's not it's again it's one of those things that will get better um every time we do it okay but that process Incorporated in the past before this kids that had D's and Fs is that is that right yeah okay these typically I don't know how many FS some we also had incompletes before yeah yeah I mean before the before the grade like went before we did the official like it's starting this year we had been working through this um at our sites for the last three years um so those final marks cut scores next one gr marks again um you know uh ABC NC um is is basically what the student can get we have the I for students who uh the incomplete for students who need a little bit more time and can

127still pass the class IP is available at progress report um so the possible revisions is obviously you guys could restate the D and the f um and you could re revise the in complete Poli policy um you know I don't know how much you want to revise that incomplete policy I would be um again it's one of those things I just don't want to take a step backward for the the good work that we are getting kids through a course instead of having them retake the whole thing um so uh that's that would be our big concern is we're going to lose some of those students who would have passed the course through this incomplete process as opposed to them retaking it um again and we don't know so just for clarification TR like if

128this if a student gets an incomplete um and they don't come back and remediate or they don't you know continue you know and actually pass the scale that reverts to a d no it reverts to an NC take the class yeah yep yeah that's one of the concerns that I've heard from a couple of different teachers now um and granted they were all core teachers that I spoke to with um their course being uh GR graduation requirement that um we should allow the students to have that D because even if they don't meet the a through G requirement um at least they're still getting the credit so they can actually graduate you know that that's a tough one that one hits home for me I have a son who totally struggles um in school and

129um he had a D in his world language class and and I was like well we're going to have to redo that one and you know in meetings we we determined that actually if he's not planning on going to a four your University he doesn't need to be a3g right now he has qualified to graduate with just the D he like barely skimmed through and so I hear you on that obviously we want our kids to be successful I'm not I'm not a fan of lowering a bar but sometimes when you have kids that struggle and a d is a struggle you know I worry with some of the incompletes especially with all scills all students what does that look like if they're only missing one scale or two and I'm hearing with math courses

130that they need 100% to be able to take the retake and then they're not you know anyway there's been some serious nightmares going on um but these kids could pass it with a a d and move it forward because they were very close to the sea but they were they were not enough you know I can only speak to what uh I've heard because obviously now we're going through it and and we're not on the other side of it if we get through the side I don't know but uh you know um when I when I talked to Matt Shay who is our uh trainer for CBE and he mentions this in his training is that that transitional period's hard there's going to be some things where people um you know have you know have

131this situation like you just mentioned but it will become a new system and people will understand it and know how to go get through it it's just if we're going to get there or not so see my take on this is if the student receives an incomplete they've already mastered what is it 70% 75 75% of standards they get six additional weeks four four okay instead of I I I could not right now in my mind ever support changing or allowing a de again because I think those kids can can succeed in that six weeks I really do if they want it they can succeed with help you know and instead of that D which says oh I just really got through I'm I'm not adequate they can they can change that you know to

132a c or B my question for you is what percentage of of students that approximately in the district that have received incomplete are able to ached a b that's good I know we've collected this data before I might have to look and get it back like specific data I don't have an approximate I don't want to approximate it because I don't want to be way off I guess my point but we do we do there's a high IID say it's a good number of students who do um uh remediate that eye to a passing grade more than a passing grade I'm saying that student instead of uh struggling through with the de if they wanted to I I believe this is correct under our current uh grading policy they could actually show proficiency and enough

133of scales to end up with a be as a boy not a c is that accurate can they can they come in with higher than a a c after an an I um yeah are they yeah I mean if you if you had if you had one scale that you missed and you were at you know you showed threes in all of those that that possibility is there where they could they could be in a place that that traditionally they would have gotten an F let's say or they didn't get a d and they want it enough and they get enough help they can actually bring that up to a grade here's the here's the problem though David like when you're talking about these I saw it in my class students getting extra help you're

134talking about you know we have these short intervention periods and you might have 30 students in there and you're trying to do oneon-one with because they all have different proficiency skills that they're missing that's not possible come on I'm telling you what I did kidding you cannot provide one-on-one instruction to 30 kids at the same time you're full of it you're full of it I'm telling you what I did and I'm telling you to work I'm telling you possible he don't tell me what I it's not possible DAV I'm telling idea gentle you have no idea I'm just curious the the uh the sheer number of ic's right now there's not an IC it's an i or an NC yeah NC sorry there sheer number of incompletes right now um that's the concern I have

135there's so many compared to what the data shows in the past that I think Jeremy's bringing up a good point though that how are we going to have the resources to be able to take on all of these incomplete and and David I I I get it like I want kids to be up there too but I'm also there's some kids that are going to be okay and there some families that are going to be okay with getting a d right and and and that's that's that's it that's their choice right we all have different paths but because I also don't want to give a false accept um understanding of of of where kids are right everyone and that's part of the equity thing that I'm I play with back and forth that let's lump

136everyone into this you know a passing grade participation Awards if you will um so I know I've kind of gone the two different areas but I'll go back to I'm concerned about the resources at the school to be able to help with incompletes yeah you know the interesting thing I always like to point up about this and and and really where you know one of the one of the areas subject matters in in places this really originated was at deloro I don't know if You' ever heard this story but in the English the teachers were so they're like I keep getting this kid with it you know in my class and my I have these huge class sizes and we started talking about what if because English n and English 10 scals are exactly the

137same or they're they're the same standards um and so it started with them of going how can we you know not hold a kid back and have four because we all believe in retakes it's just when right is and how long that retake is going to be is it going to be a four week remediation I get you're right there's going to be a little more more time on that teacher or is it a whole other 18 weeks back in that class right so so you're going to remediate that kid either four weeks or 18 weeks um The English Department and and I hopefully delor English teachers who are possibly listening I don't want to uh mistake this but I was there when this happened their goal was to get kids to say hey you

138know what you don't have to retake this whole class you'll have another opportunity to build off of this the the work that you did in this other class and be able to to not have to retake it again but it was off of that idea that I'm either GNA have the kid back in my class for 18 weeks or they're gonna I'm going to try to REM remediate him through four and a half I mean I think that's a I think it's a really good idea too and that's why there's so many good ideas here help make adjustments at the end of the day and I think the other thing I think is uh again I don't know if I mentioned this we've only done this for a full implementation for a half a year

139yeah and there's a lot of things that people uh teachers will go I found this system they'll share it with their other and it'll it'll grow out of it and I know it's a lot of work right now I'm not I'm not discounting that um but I don't think it's going to continue being we're just going to keep doing this thing we're going to find a way to do it better um and you know uh math teacher at deloro um had this great idea with uh um Alex and and uh working on on those kinds of things about how to do this better and less work on the teachers so I just throw that out there as a uh back to the point there's a lot of different ways you can go because I I

140actually love the idea of I think overwhelmingly the teachers I spoke to um you know some of them most all of them did not like with the grading system as it is but they found appreciation in the proficiency scales right and again I'll go back to talking to Math teachers at do where they said we were already doing this right and so now we're Chang we're having to change but I think the point is is if if we if we stay with some type of proficiency scale and a kid still doesn't pass it why would they have to go back and take the whole class again why couldn't they even if they in those four weeks or six weeks they don't get it right and and maybe that next semester instead of taking a whole

141class they just work on those proficiency skills and eventually they're going to get there which is the whole goal of comprehension and and not only that Tom but um you take a kid who's like a freshman or sophomore who just hasn't figured out school yet yeah and now they go oh you know what that isn't hanging on to me and I still I now realize I do want to go to college right after high school and I don't have and I can't because we provided them the opportunity not that every kid should but we do believe that every kid should have an opportunity to make that choice I I 100% agree so but that's why I also big big believer in CTE but so those are your possible revisions and and again I know we

142have some strong feelings and I'll let you guys uh work through that um the next one is uh I believe all scales all students again I think the the reasoning behind this was we really felt strongly that if if we identified exactly what's essential that we want all of our students to be able to get all of those skills um if it's not essential then it shouldn't be a part of their evaluation um what you could do is a possible revision uh you could apply it to a 100 point system and and so in other words you could you know if you want to keep that but want to allow the 100 point system you could say that they need a minimum of 70% at every scale um you could set a different threshold so

143in other words uh they could have to pass at me at least 80% or 75% um to get a grade um and they could be done something like that um or you could eliminate this entirely and allow students to pass if their average meets the minimal requirements I I I you know I did some cursory looking at some grade books at the final grade book just to kind of see what was out there um and there were some kids who passed and I'm looking at their at their grades and and you know again this the teachers prerogative to to give the grade but I'm looking at the all of the scales that they didn't pass and I'm thinking is that best for the student have we set them up for failure or success in the

144next term um so those are those are things to consider uh that and and I you know I respected the one or I respected the teacher that I the individual teacher I was looking at and and I will say that's what she thinks is best for the student it's hard to argue against that but I have concerns uh about that and this hurts U like I said my my own daughter uh had the average of a c in a class and but she didn't meet all of the requisite proficiency skills and so we're working through that so it it does uh Touch personally but it's a great conversation to have about what our next steps are and what we're going to do so I get it my my other concern and I and I totally

145am with you guys on hey if they're close and incomplete into a little bit more time I get that I and I actually support that um but then that you know there's an opportunity for choice they can engage and they can work on it and remediate or they don't um but my other issue and concern is some of these students are barely hanging on anyway and if it's about meeting these students with potentially some special needs um some other extenuating circumstances that to add you know another six weeks of remediation on top of trying to keep four weeks four weeks excuse me four another four weeks of of remediation for that eye with a new weight of new classes trying to keep up with those classes and remediate it's really rough because some of these

146kids are having to work so hard just to just to get there and that's my that's my concern with well you know maybe a d is appropriate maybe it's an i and then it's a d if they were that close maybe maybe we you know carry that through and have some more conversations on that because because there are some students that that that workload all of a sudden becomes so great and one of my questions to you which now I pulled up thank you so much for yeah pulling all this data for me just so you guys have a rough idea um and I won't give you 2023 even though you gave it to me and I appreciate that but um in the spirit of time yeah um um and if you want to know

147the 2023 um we had this past semester um this last semester 632 students fail um a class and we had um 140 that failed more than one class and in this last semester we also had 354 students who have an an incomplete um and then I asked if how many have how many of these students have more than one incomplete and there's 31 so now we've got 31 students with at least two incompletes where they're going to try to remediate so two more classes on top of their new load I well I and I don't know all of the the uh conversations but in situations like that I think um you know counselors do a great job of sitting down with their students and going what what's possible yeah um what's the thing what's the

148lowest hanging fruit that we could pick off um and so sometimes you go like you got an incomplete in this course and you I just I'm gonna have to retake that I'm gonna focus on this because I know I can remediate this and get this one up there there are decisions like that and strategy that is employed uh to to make sure that you know we're we're meeting that so but but Jessica I think it is important because you just gave stats on 24 that's six the first stat you gave was 600 and change but the 23 number was 42 I think yeah yep yeah yep so 2023 we had 412 students um fail a class and this semester we have 632 so yeah yeah and and all of those categories were in were increased

149that was a fairly nominal number dispar but all of them all of them increased yeah hadn't and like I said uh in my email and I think I sent it to everybody did I yeah um those numbers are not easy to grab in that direction no that's fine um but uh so sometimes you run a query through Aries and you cross your fingers in hope that you got the right query and make sure that you're you're uh you know aggregating the data correctly sometimes it's a it's a tricky system so uh we're going to verify what those numbers are make sure that we're those are right sure can and we have one student just so again for the board to know that we have one student that has three eyes so three eyes a new

150load I just want to be realistic and supportive of these kids because I don't want them frantically well I could I could pass in four weeks but you know maybe the low hanging fruit Works maybe and maybe they pass them all I don't maybe they pass them all maybe they they kill it but I just want to be supportive of the students where they're at meet them at they're at what they're learning and the teachers who are trying to you know do their job to help them remediate can I give you a hypothetical threat um imagine so you you talked about having the ninth grader that's kind of just adjusting to high school um and you know that're they're not you know ready for it yet right so they they fail English n graduation requirement

151um we want all our students to be um a through G so he gets an an incomplete say he has that four-week window to uh remediate the incomplete if we had a policy where that he he maybe he didn't complete it or he didn't remediate high enough to actually you know pass that offici that scale um and his grade reverted to a d uh but then two years later he's like I really want to go to you know go to college you know the four year that's that's my thing now um would he be able to to you know retake uh English n as like a sophomore it be unorthodox I don't know if there' be anything against no I think would there be a policy that we could we've done that before so that

152that could address that concern about like you know maybe they're not ready for it right now but two years from now you know they're going to be there they're going to you know and maybe their mindsets Chang things at home have changed or what have you one of the big challenges because I've had now that I think about I've sat in these conversations with students uh who's a junior who's goes you're going to set me in an English n class I'll I'll not be a to G I mean there's some there's some things like that that that uh uh you know we want to not put up any obstacles for them so um I think there are there we could hypothetical all sorts of scenarios I think the the broad goal and our and I

153I will tell you um our our counselors and our administrators have done a great job at holding a line and saying this is our expectation of of learning and really wanting to get and kids will be better for it in the moment they nobody likes to go through hard things or do hard things but they'll be better for it by saying hey you get through this you can get this class you got four weeks it'll be done and then you don't have to worry about it and move on so um but I get your point uh I don't you know in in that's why uh we said set the the uh metric at 75% because you know if it's if a kid goes I have 50% and it's like that's too much I'm not going

154to be able to remediate it in that short period of time so um I it'll be interesting to see in the next four weeks when we we'll get we'll collect the data of those 320 eyes and go what they do how did how did what what changes did we make so all right thank you Trent yep and then uh grading practice was the last one um and and again I think you know we just think that uh most of these things are are really important about not holding kids um accountable to things that they have no control over and making sure that our grades are reflective of what they know and can do and not punishments um at the end of the day it's a focus on learning I I I know that there's a

155lot of conversation about you know uh preparing them for life and the real world and all of those things um but we feel pretty strongly about these um the permitting retakes and redus I know is probably the the most uh controversial out of those items and I think there are ways to to ensure that um students aren't abusing it um and creating a policy for that yeah I mean the stories I've heard of kids showing up on the first test day with a blank piece of paper to say I'm not ready and I my concern is what does that teach them the dis discipline is they get into postsecondary school and how how that affects them the other piece too on the other side of that is and I've heard stories of kids that uh

156were able to sweep a teachers you know not not here but sweep a teacher floor and get five points and get the a minus that they needed unfair that's that's not good I had a my daughter got mad at me for not going to her teachers back to school night because she was giving extra credit for it and I thought that's not fair for all of the teacher or students whose parents are working um and couldn't be there yeah um and uh and so anyways we just want to focus on learning that's the biggest deal focus on learning and make sure that we're not holding again the students accountable for something that you know they can't be responsible for I want to point out one of your bullet points here um non-grade consequences for student

157Behavior so that conversation I had last night with the kofax autoshop teacher um who uh worked in the industry for 30 years as a mechanic uh before he became a a teacher um one of the things that he mentioned was he doesn't have the ability to uh assess students uh based on one of the some several of the standards that were required to address the students on by CT standards by the state um those soft skills the 21st century workplace skills uh things like uh promptness you know being on time being prepared those kinds of things um and I I absolutely 100% agree with what he was saying that by us not reinforcing those ski those really key skills in fact those skills and some of those skills are more important than any of the

158other skills that they're going to learn in the class um we are not adequately preparing them for a a career in that field um because as soon as they get a job you know working at an autoshop at the Toyota dealership or what have you um you know they they start showing up late they're going to get fired and it's it's going to be because we did not properly prepare them by making sure that they start those habits at a young age um so I think there's there needs to be some flexibility with some with some of these things on certain circumstances like that now I understand like 20 years ago um you know it used to be a commonplace thing for teachers to give extra five extra credit points for you bringing in a

159box of tissue like that used to be a thing you know a common thing with a lot of teachers and I understand that that shouldn't those kinds of things should be H should not be happening because it's not academic it's not benefiting uh the student in any way um so that makes sense but to have a blanket policy saying you know we shouldn't have extra credit like that's you there's different types of extra credit is my point yeah it becomes really hard to differentiate that and to give a autonomy to our staff to be able to make those decisions because they're the subject matter experts they're the ones that know what's right for their classroom and if they are doing the wrong thing that's the that's the job of the administrator to go and say

160wait a second I I see you're giving extra credit for you know tissue you're like you probably shouldn't be doing that you know I mean those have those one-on-one uh conversations rather than you know these blanket policies top down blanket policies that have unintended consequences I just want to point out that our belief is the grade should represent the student's ability knowledge and skill in the course that's what it reflects when it's when a when a when a person gets a grade when we commun that communicate that grade to anybody else they're going to look at whatever that grade is and they're going to say oh this an a this means this this student knows this material they got a C it means they know this much material when you start adding all of those

161other things you lose that and I disagree okay I'm I'm curious and I'm I'm trying to understand this a little bit what I think about leadership there's a behavioral piece to to leadership I would think too right sure and and so um so I don't know if there's a blanket statement that we shouldn't have classroom Behavior as a as a consequence when it applies to the the curriculum right yeah I don't um I think there's a lot of CTE courses that do actually in incorporate uh some proficiency scales that are related to the very thing that you talked about um so I think that's that they have managed to figure that out um for the most part I think when when that happens the the the tricky part is how how many how many points

162do you assign to a tardy how many points do I assign for a kid that calls out without raising their hand then I'm going to deduct how many how right and so now we get in a point chasing game and um holding grades and numbers over over our kids Behavior I think that's I think that's the the fine balance of absolutely soft skills are important uh making sure our students are you know meeting meeting deadlines and and most of our our teachers I think have developed systems to where yeah there's retakes with a couple extra happy hops in order to get those retakes done which I think is in instilling that in there but you know the behavior one's really hard because am I I no tardies in my class Trend comes in late and

163you get minus 20 out of everything or in my assessment category or in my homework category I mean we could we could really ding a kid um with two tar I mean so those are the things that that continue on we talk about how you wait that absolutely absolutely yeah yeah also you're in thinking back like I think it was the last meeting you talked about how we have 63 dual enrollment courses within the district I think that's the number that was thrown outes that sound about right I can't remember whatever number it is through Sierra College so Sierra College has a pol 10% attendance policy so if the student this is more than 10% of the class they automatically fail the class right whatever their policy is yeah that that's the policy when I

164was teaching dual and R it was 10% so how is that I mean we're not we're not in control of SRA College again this is your this is the policy the idea behind the grades we have to make a decision about whether our grades are going to me to our students are there ways that we can hold students accountable for poor behavior and other things like that that don't reflect it in their grade that's the question we believe that you we think you we can um and instead of trying to hold that grade over a student and say you know I'm going to punish you for uh you know being late or whatever those kinds of things I get it um I've he this conversation uh quite often I've I've had multiple conversations and again

165I do we do disagree we do think that um the the punishment for Behavior should be handled in a different way outside of the grade and I think there's ways to incentivize that to to make that there's some teeth behind will we get to there I don't know thank you so much uh for for bringing this forward I think obviously we yeah thank you so much um I'm looking at the time I'm good are you okay okay just making sure um does everybody need a moment do you need do we need a quick recess potty break and come back or are we going to carry forward I'm fine carrying forward I just want to be responsive you guys okay board okay all right everybody else there's a restroom um thanks for hanging out um I

166don't mind sharing a snack if you guys are starving blood sugar is a thing and and nobody was explaining to be here that this long um so I guess I just want to open it up to the board for your thoughts on this um are you in favor of making some changes today if so what are they um and we'll see if we can find some consensus um with the board um and it does sound to me that everyone is is in some kind of alignment based on the ATP results that not everything that we're doing is is completely working right now and um do you guys want to share some feedback on that David David um would you like to share your do you have any suggestions for modifications are you okay with it

167the way that it is or are you um I know that you had mentioned that you're not a fan of the four point okay okay Jeremy do you have any thoughts ideas suggestions yeah so I don't even know where to start now it's a lot um I think that one of the things that we should do is um within that four four-week window for the um the incompletes um we should go to the the system that I which I believe if I'm recalling correctly like Rockin uses where they have that time window to get you know to pass those proficiencies and if they don't it reverts to a D um so that gives them that you know like that situation like if it's a graduation requirement course um that at least now they're going to

168graduate can they go back and retake the class you know hopefully the answer to that question would yes so they can raise the grade if they wanted to um but that gives them that ability so like if I'm terrible at math and I know I have to have that thirdy year math and I'm just struggling struggling struggling I'm a senior and I3 and I'm struggling struggling struggling I should be able to take the D um and actually pass the class and graduate um so I think that's one of the things that we should uh we should be looking at um I'm looking at some of the things that comments that I've got from the numerous students teachers and parents that I've spoken to um limiting the amount of retakes um having a set number of

169retake and I think this is probably something that should be uh addressed by department so each department should be like okay for our department we're going to allow three retakes or we're going to allow unlimited retakes or you know whatever it is but uh they're the subject matter expert so I think that they should have some influence um as to how many retakes are going to be allowed uh for that particular course um I am personally in favor of going back to um the 100o grade scale um with you know the ABC you know incomplete no credit um kind of a kind of a model um but still using the the essential learning objectives um much as like like rockn unified uses their essential skills um where you have to pass these things to pass

170the class um I think that's that's really important um you know for example I had a student my first year at deloro that was in in one of my Advanced video classes who didn't know how to edit like how can you pass a lower level video class and not know how to edit like you that's a foundational kind of thing um so there should be some some skills that we the teachers can ident identify to say you have to learn this to be able to pass this class especially for example I'm thinking of math um you know all the many conversations I have with my wife about it like there's certain skills that they need to learn in im1 to be successful in IM two or learn in im2 to be successful in im3 but

171they don't need to learn they don't need to master everything um but there are those certain skills that like if you don't you know if you haven't got this nailed down you're not going to be successful and we don't want to set our students up for failure so um and I truly think that we should be giving autonomy to each of the departments at each of the sites to determine um what those scales are going to be or those elos are going to be um how they're going to be weighted um and I think that we should you know let the the experts decide how that waiting should look and I I do agree that it should be uniform um for that department for the couple of the reasons that I talked about already mainly

172the main one that I can think about is um a parent saying no I want my student to be with that teacher because that teacher uses a different grading system in that same class or whatever and we don't want to you know put our Administration uh in this in that kind of situation where they're trying to juggle all that that could I could see that could be a huge nightmare um so um so you know just giving more autonomy and flexibility back to back to the staff um and they should be able to add in um their you know you know add or modify or adjust the the scales themselves and I I don't know if it's possible with areas like I mentioned earlier but I would really like to see that great override Callum

173there so that even if you um it looks to your parents like when you get the email and it says to have C like we were talking about you looks like you have a c but really you're not like you're not passing the class so they we don't want I would like to see this get away from that confusion and say you know right now you're you know you have an incomplete or you're you know you're approaching or whatever the case is whatever you want want to call it um so that they're not you know they're not facing that confusion thinking that their son or daughter is passing all the way till the end and realize oh wait now you got an incomplete right okay anything else that you have I think that is it

174okay um we'll if this works out or not I'm going to go through each of the things that you brought up and see if we're in agreement and if we're not we'll just kind of see where we're at and we'll we'll regroup this is a this is a working group right now so all right um your first was about incompletes in the four weeks if they didn't if a student didn't pass within the four weeks um was your comfortability with them at referring to a d for now um um kept an eye do you mind before we get to that I just maybe give some thought can I can I clarify one thing yeah just in this conversation sorry yeah um when you talk about that hopefully the the board whatever you know would be

175amable to teachers who still want to give an i because they that's still a great okay I just want to make sure that yeah that wasn't you know if we if we had teachers who were still like no I want to give eyes I think I can remediate these students and I don't want to slow their progress I just want to make sure thats glad you clarified and I think that Jeremy was in agreement with that that if a student that has an eye and they can try to remediate it if they didn't meet the remediation but still qualified for the deed that it would revert if they didn't remediate is that accurate Jeremy yes yeah so that I would still exist yeah I think so the conversation becomes back to the abcdf conversation right

176right okay go ahead Tom um this is this is great this is collaboration this is listening when I started this journey back in August late August to to run for this board seat um I I just didn't have any the experience that I've I've had over the last four months has been amazing to listen and to learn and it started with of course I have um two children at deloro um and then it started by then the only thing I know how to do is to listen to the folks around me to better understand what they're going through so obvious VI L I heard a ton from the from the kids and the students being active in the community um I had that that that ability to to talk to kids um overwhelmingly it was

177negative uh about the the grading system uh I spoke to parents and they felt there was confusion the same thing uh I I went to the teachers at that point and spoke to gosh over you know almost to 20 20 teachers uh and then heard folks show up to board meetings and and what they had to say um and so you it would be really easy for me to say oh let's let's turn this back right um but I had to go and find more information and really look at the stats and I really appreciate everything Trent's done to to provide information it's been helpful um the survey today um um that we got to take a look at just phenomenal information it's super super helpful and then from there I I would say that

178you know with all this feedback I spent time with with Nick and and and his staff and um you know everywhere I turn it's people that just truly care whether it's the kids caring about their grades the parents caring about their kid the students um it's the students I mean the the teachers really again 10 to 12 hours a day but I'm not working on my craft I'm not doing what I'm supposed to do to help these kids get better or or sitting with with Administration with Nick and his staff I could just tell how much they absolutely care about trying to get this right and making it a better atmosphere and environment for the students and the teachers and so so for me you know there's a ton of great ideas that have been

179passed today around and and I love the collaboration I love the inquisitiveness by everyone I I love the experience that I'm hearing from teachers um on the board and and obviously in the audience of over the last couple meetings so I just have a real question right now is can we solve this at this moment and do it right yeah and and and as much as I'd like to say yes let's solve it by having five things we're going to turn around next week I don't think that's fair to anybody and and so but we can't the the data is overwhelming that we cannot continue down this path of the grading system that we have today we've endured a semester of it and I I would recommend that we we fall back to the traditional

180grading system that we put a committee together comprising of more than what was there before to include students to include parents to include board members teachers Administration as many experienced and and people that can weigh in on this to provide a path forward that will make this truly great because I'm hearing so many wonderful ideas but I don't think we'll do it justice by solving that tonight or even solving it next week um and so that's that would be my recommendation now now if there's some nuances to that falling back to a traditional grading system if there's I I I would hate to say because the overwhelming thing I've heard from everyone is that they appreciate the proficiency scales they absolutely do and and so um how do we how do we incorporate that um

181W but but still go back to a traditional grading system I I I don't I don't know if I truly know the answer to that and so um but it seems like the less we the the less we put on this right now and and go back to traditional grading system I think about the trade-offs there's trade-offs and everything and where's the most risk and so if we went back to a traditional grading system I I would want that to be a short period meaning a semester like we should be able to solve this between now and and and July um and and that would My Hope um so that that's that's my thoughts thank you I just Tom I just think that for clarity sake we would need to Define exactly what that means

182when you say traditional system and what the expectation is um are you saying you know 100 point scale abcdf and uh all of those things I I mean that Devil's always in the details and so when you say we're going to revert back to that I just want to make sure that we know and our administrators ERS know what that is yeah I would say to keep it simple what were the what were the campuses doing before I mean that's that's what I would it's all over the place a wild wild west Yeah a different yeah yeah so yeah we had we had different groups that were that were rolling out CBE so until this this year everybody's been CB prior to that it would be a handful at sites um doing it so it

183was it's been different for a couple of years now it's been different where since we started practices some people had fiveo grading scill some people had four-point grading skills get it so so I guess my thing goes back to the trade-offs right what's is the biggest what's the biggest risk to stay where we are yeah one of the things I do want oh sorry go ahead just try try to solve it next week um I mean I don't think we're going to solve it in the next hour yeah and so that's that that's that's the biggest concern I have the question that I think also needs to be answered and I I don't know this will involve our labor Partners um is the kids whe I don't you know however you want to Def find

184it who are affected adversely affected by this quote is there going to be any relief of saying oh now that you're not in this system you know I took math in the spring semester uh instead of of the fall semester I have this grade here and so I just don't know how much you're going to get pushed back from parents and students wanting to say hey now we're in a traditional grading system um y can I retro my grade and can the teacher grade are we just going to say no it's changed and I just think those are the kinds of questions that are going to be um brought up to our administrators who are going to be trying to figure that out it's a good point yeah and I and I and I think

185there there probably should be something to look at to because we we can't administratively change the grade it would have to be come from the teachers I think we uh uh can't incorporate failure ands I I would be willing to support going back to a traditional ABC no credit incomplete as an interim until we can modify whatever we want to do in terms of 15 scales but I I can't support failure and I can't support these but could and would support ABC as a temporary uh measure before we tweak the system to make it work better so David and Tom so would that be um so ABC and and are traditionally would be using you know 100 points not a four point is that what your both I would I would go again going back

186to 100 points Sy going back to 100 points you as well ABC uh incomplete no credit exactly I can support that as an interim as an interim while we gather some some data because I agree with what you're saying I think we can with more feedback begin to tweak what we have and move forward without losing it all my fear is if you go if you went back to a traditional total grading system abcdf I think it roll back every we done I think you could roll back oh look at this all this work is nothing but I think the ABC and eliminate the keep the elimination of the dnf in complete no credit if people know this is an interim that we're going to be doing so we can begin to find something I

187can support that I'm I'm in agreement that there's not a chance in the world we're going to solve everything right now and that we need some time to gather some data um and that the data overwhelmingly show that we've got some issues and part of and part of that as well is and again I'm it sounds like the the board policy had pushed for a specific time to this yeah which I don't think was fair and so what's missing here especially with the teachers is the lack of the lack of training and so whatever we do we have to discuss how do we find a way to train better and that's that that's what's most important me natur we tweet yeah yeah it's like then how do you roll this out that's that's what was

188missed is the the the level of training um it's it's clear when you have and again I'm I I get it some teachers have probably said I don't care I'm not going to put time and effort into this but I think the majority of teachers I've talked to really tried with this yeah and they're struggling and so if they get the right amount of training uh with the right system again think I think there's flaws in this but nothing's going to be perfect no absolutely not nothing will be perfect but uh training is going to be a big an important piece yeah jemy what are your thoughts on that I agree with David okay so um everyone's in agreement with traditional um are are we going to have nuances in this are is this going

189to be districtwide is this are we going to have some sight with autonomy working this out during this interim um I know the elimination of and continue so if we if we can ABC ABC incomplete no credit um what are we going to do about the proficiency scales though and so that's what we need to talk about so so are you I think the key one key Jus is that the staff realized that this is not what we're doing for a permanent basis we're doing this temporarily yeah you know so we can begin to continue to make progress going for it's anal yeah do you think so let me throw some other logs on the fire obviously we can only talk to One board member at a time so um I've you know my contact

190has been Tom on this one um we discussed some uh possibilities potentially based on conversation here today of um different sites potentially having um a different option um traditional versus um continuing on course and problem solving um or being a resource later down the road Gathering um data and information as we form a committee is that something that you guys are interested in or not interested in we had discussed um cfax remaining in CBE or we had discussed that and what are your thoughts um collectively right now um with a different site carrying forward with a certain grading practice or or all of everyone moving to traditional while we gather data what are your thoughts on that kofax is doing incredible work I mean their site and and teachers not that other teachers aren't at

191other sites we get me wrong but they've been leading the way in terms of this new Direction I don't want to see them hampered at all in terms of what we're doing you know I think actually uh we can utilize that staff once we make whatever tweaking we're going to be doing you know at in services to to help with this retraining that we're going to be doing because they're ahead of our other site there's no doubt about that I I I don't want to see anything that's going to cause a back my fear is if we move too fast too quickly for the let's just say there's 35% I don't know what it is of staff that hates Competency Based education districtwide don't like it never have we're going back traditional It All Rolls

192back I I don't want to see that I don't want to see us lose some of the significant gains that we've gotten with the hard work of Trent and and and our administration because they work their butts off they really have so but when you mention kofax I I think they're like a flagship in terms of where we want to go trusty uh Spade or president Spade can I say something um I I think um and I'm principles can jump in if if um they're directed um I think sometimes a concern when you start isolating sites they get put on an island I think the strength over the last several years has been this group making corporate decisions which has been even if it's not the best decision for their site they've they've made a

193decision because the collective whole of phsd is better as a whole that that's the first thing I think to think about the second thing is we do have anou in place with um with ATP with um a stien in the fall and a and based upon the mou is agreement it's a full implementation um fall stien and a spring styen so that that kind of comes into play with a with theou in place right now that uh we've already talked just elaborate on the stien yeah so it's $500 for every certificated uh teacher and counselor um which we have in place for the school year of 2425 for full implementation of of CBE so they're going to be getting their first fall STP in here shortly and then the then if we're form implementation they'

194then get the second stien in in the spring is that every site or is that just CX no that's every site that's every certificated teacher in the district so that was an mou 23 that was that was signed that um the first part of it was by volunteer and so we had teachers get a $500 stip in who volunteered to to take on CBE and then during the full implementation it was it was the payment of all all teachers interesting okay so there was a performance incentive okay Jeremy do you have any thoughts on um everyone collectively across the district making the same change or essentially kind of what we were back to um the last semester we had certain staff members there or or for instance colfax's site I mean I'm very very torn

195on this topic because even if you're looking at kfax was it 47% of the teachers I think were notv CBE it's 5050 it's 5050 yeah if you well if you if you look I mean that's the lens I look at it through is that there was a negative pi and then there was a neutral but I look at it is that's kind of shifted together and also based on some of the comments from from our folks there that ATP so it's 50/50 so then I go back to the concern that if you give autonomy then going to what's the trade-off there is it going to be worse with and so you can't in my opinion you can't do autonomy and now you you don't it's not overwhelming on the site say stay with CBE absolutely

196will you please come up yeah thanks I've been up here a lot I don't like appreciate it no you're good thanks um when I originally saw this survey I was a little flabbergasted to be frank with you I was uh stung right um so this morning I had a staff meeting with my staff and I'm I don't know how else other to be other than transparent and and my staff knows that um the running joke in the district is that you can read my face um so I told my staff this morning I don't know what's going to happen this afternoon I don't know where we're going what I do know is these results of this survey but but as I reflect there's always going to be a third a third a third with transformational

197change so um I I never like to say this out loud but um my doctorate is actually U my program was organizational leadership and that was one of the biggest flag staffs of like a third a third a thirdd third of your staff is going to be on board we're going to be doing this a third is going to be like I'll do whatever you tell me to do because I want you to stop talking and a third is going to say I don't want have anything to do with this I don't want to have anything to do with you leave me alone right and that's what happened with my staff a third answered the survey or a third did not answer the survey they were like I don't have time for that a third

198loves CBE and they're ready to go and a third said that they were kind of in that middle area right so I said we're going to have some real talk about CB this morning and we discussed it I put up all the things I need to know where you guys are at because I can't advocate for you if I am unclear and I feel like I was unclear so when I got that feedback this morning from my staff this is a running conversation we only had a few minutes we meet our staff meetings are for 1 hour um the department chairs are tasked with finishing the conversations and coming to my lead team meeting because I said no matter what happens we've got to figure out what is our identity what is our curricular and

199instructional identity at kfax and what do we want so they have started the conversation I emailed the department chair and I said I need to know a couple of your comments I need to know what was being said today so I have a clear understanding yes there was 47 in that neutral but neutral to us is not negative neutral to us is we still want to roll our sleeves up and we still want to get to work we still want to work on a few things so I do have some discrepancy I have a PE Department who has a proficiency scale of participation and they don't want students who don't participate every single day to not pass the class because they don't participate every day and they didn't do well on that P specific proficiency

200scale so yes we have a few things to work out we have never said we were perfect we have only said that we're we're doing the work we are rolling our sleeves up together we're having conversations my math department didn't like all scales all students so they wanted to do something that my IB teacher is doing which is all domains all students so they have put their scales into domains and he was ready to roll out that he's ready to go with that but we're kind of waiting in this limbo of like are we going to be doing it are we not doing it what's happening and so he's ready to go with all domains all students and so it's a little bit of a modification but still the same concept and the same idea

201so I just just really want to make sure that there's an understanding of because I I I was stung but like I said I got to the bottom of it this morning to see what was going on and now I know where my departments are I do have one Department that doesn't really like it but like I said it's a third a third a third and I don't think we should stagger our growth because of a third we need to continue to work and roll up our sleeves and work with them so I I have a question just trying to wrap my head around again having a third is much different than the rest of the district right as far as the positivity goes so you guys are doing something good right at the end

202of the day and I again coming into this meeting I had thought that this was rolled out four years ago but you're saying it was rolled out with everybody else why but you guys had started this as far as talking about change and talking about creating system seven eight years ago everybody did yeah everybody did okay so the grading practices is 10 years old that is something that happened and that has been at every single site the no extra credit all that stuff is 10 years old so the fourpoint grading scale was an evolution of that of thinking about grading practices or the levels of four right well for us it started four point scale now we're moving into level learning right and it was an evolution and so because we're we're doing these grading

203practices and we want fair and accurate grades it you know half of my teachers started talking about the the four leveled scale um and that was because for us we we want to know where our student is at all times and you can't know that and then there's the atomic zero when you when you start talking about a 100 point scale if a student doesn't turn in an assessment or doesn't turn in something then they get a zero on that and so for them to jump their grade even 10 you know to the D they have to overcome 60 percentage points whereas a student who wants to go from a c to a b only has to overcome 10 percentage points the the 100 point scale is so inequitable it's not accurate it's not fair

204it penalizes students for struggling it penalizes students when they have a little bit more of a difficult time the fourpoint sales here is the level learning leveled you're at this level you can do all these things in this level you're here that's all you need to know when my kids are in elementary school and they only have a thre level learning scale and I'm sure most of the the parents of Lumis has that because I'm my kids go to Lumis Bas and Charter and they have a three-point my kids don't get credit for homework they only get credit for their test in math um and they in my oldest is in seventh grade and so I really think that we need to think about that as well this is not new to parents it's just

205new now be in the high school um and so that was an evolution the fourpoint scale was an evolution half of my teachers decided to try it so three years ago as a school we said we asked Dr Tucker at the time can we do this can we as a whole school go to four point and he was in support of that and and he allowed us to do that and through that was this evolution of of um you know we have these categories and these competencies and we and and we started talking about that but all of the language the proficiency scales the competencies we all started working on that together so there was there was no conversation at Kola it was just an evolution that occurred because of the grading practices 10 years

206ago and then we were introduced to Competency Based education two years ago with everybody else and started making those changes yeah it it's a it's just a hard question to ask why are you so different than every District I'm sorry every other campus that that's the tough that's the tough piece class sizes I mean obviously your class sizes that much different than my class I 37 right now so it's okay so the same or or or more than the others I think from an outside Observer uh if you don't mind me jumping in there one of the things is that uh you know a smaller staff allows for a little bit more conversation conversation collaboration you're you're I also think that when you have uh you know they've had a couple of high level teacher

207leaders that bought in early and have the respect of the staff and were pushing it at a very high level and I think they did a great job of um doing it that way so but I think the the size of the staff the teacher leaders who were there who were bought in and into it and obviously ch's leadership and and uh pushing them to improve and have challenging conversations with uh people who were sort of the resistors of saying hey we can all do this together and we'll get better at it and I think it's it's made a difference but I think those are the three probably big keys still working but yes I have it's easier for me to go to the two or three or the third than it is for Nick

208right it's easier for for me to have those conversations than it is for Jamie like they have huge staffs and they have wonderful APS to help them with that um but yes I think Trent is absolutely right have a smaller staff and I have some phenomenal just forward thinker teachers that are willing to put themselves out there and in front of everybody and say let's try this new thing and here I'm going to show you how to do it yeah and and just so you know like when when I looked at all the data the first thing that came to my mind was okay how do we how do we bottle what's going on bottle up what's going on in C so when this idea when when Jessica mentioned that the idea of of thinking

209about one site to stay with CBE I said I I I was the one that said maybe it's cofax that's the one that we look at so I because I want to make sure that the you know I've thought I've really thought through this I didn't just say blanket statement I tried to be absolutely judicial in looking at that not all the sides are the same and again I I really appreciate data and the data tells me that there is a 30% you know 35% positive reaction coming from from kofax so um really had to stop and think of why and and better understand that and I think there's a lot of learning lessons that can come from putting a committee together that looks at all there a there a you know not a postmortem

210but a debrief if you will just on what what has gone well what has not gone well at all the campuses um and and to put that into how we we there's so much there's so much and I know that there's there's been so much time and energy and love and Um passion uh you know put into all of this I I don't take that uh for granted for one second um I know some people are a little bit further along in this journey um I've heard a number of times as I've been communicating with staff members that you know we don't want to throw out the baby with the bath water you know there are some things that that are that are helpful that um teachers have learned throughout this process um I think

211one of the biggest statistical issues that I had with the ATP not an issue but that stood out to me was uh the accuracy factor I thought man I was not expecting that that um the majority of the staff didn't feel that it was um accurately reflecting their knowledge because of some of the issues and nuances within the system and um so I think we're all in agreement that we need to form some type of committee that's inclusive of of all parties the question Still Remains um is everyone in agreement with with keeping a site um okay I'm going to throw one more one more log on the barbie and see where you guys are land um some of the teachers that have been doing this for three years um that're a little bit deeper

212at different sites who um are in favor um would you consider um any teachers I know that there would be inconsistencies but just making sure we flushed everything out any teachers that wanted to carry forward CBE through this semester and anyone else rolled it back to a traditional until we can have a working group committee and Report out what are your thoughts on that I would agree with that completely you would agree with um allowing the teachers to decide right where they're at for this next semester what are your thoughts on that David oh I kind of agree primarily with with what we're all doing collaboratively um um one of the things chassid just said that fcks in my mind is a 100 point system is totally unfair you know and my teaching experience for

213all my years is on 100 point system and I know people are confused many people or are dissatisfied with our current system or 3.5 whatever you know students so uh I think we need to have a temporary stop not long uh and really take a look at all the information that we have uh put it together send it out to the sites you know let them know that this is kind of like where we're going get some feedback um and not rush to make a change right away you know yeah I think data is critical yeah yeah and I think we need more data but at the same time I think that what's happening right now as we can see from the data is not working yeah so can I ask about about data I

214think that's important I'm a number Sky what what would the data have to look like for the board in order to know if CBE was working or not working across the across the district what would what would what would be some data points that you'd be looking for well I I can speak for one one element we we don't have any um students or parents in this data at all and so for us to make a really you know proper decision we've had a lot of feedback but we don't have any data there I feel like we're we're missing a key component right now as far as aside from the survey that you did early on which was primarily one site so I feel like as far as data goes we would need some consistency

215across um yeah across the district and um including student and families um with you know some insight there guess what what would be the Met no what would be the metric that you would use in order for for so so we're surveying students how will we know we need some sort of Diagnostic in order to know really how as Tom mentioned he's looking at the ATP results so he's he was looking for him it was the number of positive neutral negative well how are we going to know how is Staff going to know moving forward we we have to use data points that are at are fingertips I mean we can survey students and we can survey parents but that's that's qualitative data dat right we need some quantitative data of whether it's decreased number

216of of DFS or no credits or incompletes or whatever we're going to call increasing rates of of a to G increasing college going rates uh you know for us you know incompletes what wasn't talked about is decreasing number of repeaters which impacts our elective courses I mean those are all that that's kind of the data points that I I think we might want to explore more when I say what what data we know because we are we're a semester in I couldn't I couldn't tell you if CBE has been amazing or awful for for just looking at our our grade reports from for one term so we need some metrics I think would be helpful for staff to be directed in in exploring I think I think that's part of this journey yeah I just

217don't think we can come up with the metrics right now and but to your point when you do look again I take an i an i and an NC and I have to put them together because they're failing right and let's hope that in four weeks they can get to a c or a B right that's what that's the but the moment at the moment that data is overwhelming that it's not working and so and and to go back so fail rate basically I mean that's one but but again I don't think we answer that right now I think we have to go as a group the correct way to do this is put the metrics together based on a collaborative discussion but I go back to to your original question Jessica and your response

218Jeremy I I still feel like we're going to have inconsistency if you allow teachers to choose there is going to be inconsistency and then those metrics we're not going to be able to apply those metrics I think so agree that's a good point because it's it's not going to work and then I think to to kofax I still look at this was a survey in confidence at the end of the day and I appreciate you looking at the numbers and being surprised and then going to your staff but these are that's why surveys are put out people in confidence give their real feelings and we have a negative slice and we have a neutral slice and we can call that neutral slice it's vague we don't know again we we have some antidotal information from

219what you've you've talked talked people about but it's still to me a 50/50 split um and I I have to honor those those that staff and their um and their their what they thought was in well it was still incompetence right um so that's a tough one for me to just say yeah we should allow kofax to have CBE when in my mind it's still a 50-50 squ one of the things that I would like to see data that I haven't seen is is what percentage of students throughout our district that have gotten incompletes have satisfactorily made that up yeah like like if I saw saw a number 65% of these students that would have failed or gotten a d that now have gotten a c probably or who knows a b that would be

220strong on data that competency is working where students are having another opportunity and taking advantage of but that's not necessarily so if we had an i and we were in a traditional model and but they were still able to remediate their elos or whatever whatever we're doing and I'm not entirely certain we all know yet but um if we don't have a site a CBE working through that how would we know if that remediation is working through CBE or if we keep an eye and we're in traditional and someone remediates you know we're going to have inconsistencies with data yeah if we're doing different things yeah or if we don't have anyone doing it so that's that's my other concern but as far as like some of the data goes with with um math was

221so alarming at deloro 48% yeah with the higher and I am was 47 48 im2 was 46 failure yeah that's that's tough and so I I would love to hope that most of those kids are going to come out on the other side of this in February with a C or a B now if we saw that that would be what can you say that's showing us can I can I say something to that two things about the grades one uh our FS would you know I think naturally increase because we've eliminated the D right so you you've kind of created a situation where they're either going to get the NC which is still basically an F or a c and and I think there's a lot of kids who probably might have got a

222D but now it's an F so um that increase of F I would Pro I mean not haven't broken down all the data but that's what I would initially attribute it to thanks Kim Kim Kim mentioned that she's a number of girls uh the second thing though on I do want to speak to that just because that's that's a little part of the the the the layer of the onion of what we're doing with tweaking the policy um you know I went through that data it was alarming to me I'm looking at at grades and talking with Nick and talking with the other principles um I I think that is uh probably some inconsistency about how how teachers were um applying the incomplete policy yeah um and again Pro you know I'll just be trans

223transparent I think some uh teachers said uh I think they got the average and I'm gonna I'm GNA give them the grade and not follow the incomplete policy that's the only way I can make it I could be totally wrong about it that's what it appears to look like just in a cursory look of some grade books that um but that's essentially what is going to happen is created a lot of different Dynamics um that from a administ rative um what I mentioned in the beginning uh from an administrative standpoint it's just hard to be able to implement Improvement and change um at the same time leaving a lot of autonomy and different ambiguity about what can happen and what can't and I know the principles don't like be put put in that situation because

224they're going to be you know whether and teachers don't like it either right like if I'm a teacher in a department and this teacher is you know doing whatever and and it's a lot more lack and those kinds of things same thing with the principles is is they're going to be dealing with a lot more work a lot more Fallout so it's just it's complicated yeah to make a decision like this that doesn't put our our administrators in very precarious situations about incompletes and other things of that nature so yeah I I I I'm concerned about that though because is it any more Fallout than what's happening right now right right we are we're in a pretty tough situation right um and so again going to tradeoffs is I I just don't as a board

225and if we go back to that thinking then then the thinking would be to do nothing and let and keep going and try to fix things on the Fly which is not going to be a great experience and that's that's that's my biggest concern you know in in all the decisions that we make that the kids have to be the center of it and I think you know I want I want to support our staff um because I know that when you guys are supported um and administrators that that our kids are having a better experience in the classroom and we're going to learn and Thrive and have the opportunity to show all the things all the things the awesome things that they're learning and and we're going to be able to see that um

226and I think because of of some of the the vibe and stress this semester I feel like we see it in the results especially at doloro um but other sites as well and um and I and I again I point to that math where we've got 26.6% of the kids who took math failed and we've got 12.4 that have an incomplete and and I'm very concerned about you know where these where these kids are going to be um and I and I want to protect our kids as much as I want to protect the staff right now um I feel it please yeah please come on down yeah so the the 20 let's think you know high in the sky let's imagine what was the number of incompletes there uh 12.4 failure was 26.6 okay

227so 26.6 that's about what our dnf rate was previously right last 10 years for the last 10 years so that is the same amount of kids that 26% historically that would be retaking those classes so now that we have these incompletes at delor we have 115 incompletes in math that feels daunting but we also have a plan to say let's get those kids to learn the things that they need to learn to be ready for the next level and so I feel really hopeful we're calling those kids into the learning commment tomorrow uh most of the the teachers have you know kind of come up with the the same plan and so we're calling them in we've got a boatload of tutors in there supporting kids to get all the way through so that they're

228not part of that 26% but they're on to the next level which I feel really really strongly hopeful about so I just want to point out that that the D and Fs previously would have retaken that class that's our model right we want to keep doors open for them so they're going to keep retaking that class now the NC's will retake the class but the I's we're going to get them there yeah so what you're saying bottom line is once we see what percentage of students have succeeded in getting their incompletes and making that to a passing grade it's going to be higher than what we were doing before that's the Hope right and and we've only had a term so one of the things right now yeah one of the things I'd be interested

229to find out from from the teachers is because what we've asked so far is do you like this um and a couple other questions about it but I don't know if that's the most helpful question I've talked to lots of teachers that are now that they're going into their second term with it they've got some creative changes they're making right and so coming into this next term of like all right I found even feffer mention by the end of the term I kind of figured out some systems and I think there will continue to be that growth in this system throughout the you know like Trent said we've been doing this for one term um and and so there will continue to be growth and teachers figuring out teachers had a had a math teacher

230just yesterday say actually kind of feel like I don't want to say it out loud but I kind of feeling like I like CB so it feels like there's this this sense of growth when chassity has that conversation with the teacher that's all of a sudden one of how many do you have 25 teachers one of 30 teachers right when I have that conversation with the teacher and we get someone over that line that's one of 168 right and so it's it's slower progress at deloro but the progress is there and I think if the the query to teachers were what are some changes you've made between last term and this your plan for this term that will be effective for student learning I think there'd be some pretty cool things that we'd see in

231that in that question do you agree with what Trent said because this St never agree with what Trent said you stop right there noted said is stuck in my head and I I think it's really important he said there's more communication right now going on on the staff in terms of all kinds of issues proficiency scales success and so on than maybe ever before that he's experienced in our district and if that's the case that's awesome that's what a positive statement that is yeah because the change process is usually two steps up one step back think two one yeah yeah so uh yeah I never like to agree with Trent because it goes to his head but but yeah there's all sorts of positive conversations that are happening with staff right now all sorts ofers

232ation that are focused on learning instead of kind of how do I navigate this this point system to you know I need to turn in this sign this syllabus and turn in this you know this assignment here to you know because I need this category up a little higher so the conversation is how do I I I need to learn inequalities how do I get better at inequalities in math because that's the area Focus that you know my my attention should be on I think it is so couple things to point out we had incompletes previously incompletes are not a new thing um so we can look at completes over the last several years and being eliminated now they're mandated now in other words it's ABC or incomplete that means you're going to have more

233incomplete sure and ultimately I think I feel like you know what needs to happen is we need to make a decision tonight for temporary really for this term like well how we're going to address this term and then over the course of you know the next several months or whatever we can put together a committee or however that the board decides to do it um we've got you know tons and tons of you know amazing super in teachers and administrators that and students and and parents that can come together and be like okay what are the issues you know how do we solve them like I I have no doubt that if we get the right Minds together and not those those Minds out there are way smarter than the four of us no I

234agree um and they can they can nail this down and by the time that next year start rolls around we can have a system in place that's amazing that does everything that we wanted to do and obviously there's always going to be some you know push until we reach that point apparently you're saying let's put a stop temporary stop measure traditional like we said earlier ABC no credit incomplete get these committees together parents together get this data together take a look at what the data is in terms of the last semester it completes and so on and and take it from there and make significant changes right absolutely absolutely okay we're on the same mad president um you don't have to make a decision tonight either just so you know but you range of things

235and and as Trent mentioned if a decision is made what's going to be the Fallout from those I mean I don't disagree with a lot of what you're I mean everything very good points Tom's Point hey what can be worse than what we're kind of going through right now other points about change is difficult all those things that go into this but I come from the money side of things right now I'm thinking hey I'm going to save money on stiens I'm pretty sure Feer is going to go that's something they decided I said well I'm hearing they said we're changing this I'm Gonna Save myself 500 bucks 880 teachers that's give me a little I'm just saying so true CFO true CFO is right go ahead I just wanted to share a little bit

236about plers incomplete plan and I'm kind of spoil alert because I'm your January board showcase right for both pler and Confluence but um just to share so I was super impressed with pler before I had the opportunity to be the Principal I remember the board showcase for pler where they were presenting their summer school model and the teachers at pler had put in really concerted effort to remediate those students on the cusp of getting an incomplete with intentional intervention planning before the end of the term and so we modeled something very similar this year this semester knowing that we were going to have an increase in incompletes so what we did was we took um a teacher we had four teachers for one for each block that we paid on their prep one teacher who

237um krie Uno is our leadership teacher who also teaches math so someone outside of the math department um we were able to capture her one block and what we had our teachers do is identify those students that would potentially be on that cusp of receiving the incomplete so it was about five to six students per block that that teacher was pulling out of potentially like an elective class where they could maybe Miss just half the block and do some remediation with them and our results were really good with that that model um we you know fortunately have some additional funding some Title One funding that we could use for that and so we we have that we had that in place from the um Mark I grading so we identified those students three weeks before

238the end of the term so we had them every day for the end of the term um so that was a that was a big benefit we still have access to those teachers that mod model for the first four weeks if we need them for math but we also have math tutoring before and after school for that and then we have our intervention coordinator Jeff James who's part of our hman instructional leadership team he is doing all of the big heavy lift of like the task management of like how does a teacher take on all of their new students with intervention on top of remediating these incomplete he's doing a lot of communication with teachers with an incomplete contract of let me Proctor the test for you let me you know I'll check in with

239those students to make sure they're making progress um our incompletes we have 69 of them total um the the sticky part has been like what's the contract look like because some of the teachers want to continue to have ownership of those students um some are ready to release them and let Jeff handle it but um we're trying to figure that out what that looks like but it's been really helpful to have a team approach to addressing this I mean that Helman instructional leadership team has been you know just I think a big support for our staff going out and answering questions related to CBE related to the fourpoint scale Aries as much as we can you know um so just want to share that yeah I love what you're talking about because it's best practices

240right and but that's that's part of what I think we're missing and again I wasn't on the board and nothing no disrespect to this board at all but it sounds like there was time time bounds that Force the hand and I I I again that's what we were trying to get away from right time based versus competency and comprehension and uh and so I I think these best practices need to be documented and then how do we make something great and then Peter to your point though like hey you're going to save some stiens right and and and but get I know and it's in just it's it's in just I totally get it but if I may what's the risk I've talked to enough students and teachers and again I know people are emotional

241about this but I would hate to see Granite Bay grab a couple kids or Oakmont grab a couple kids it's the last thing we need yeah I would hate to see some really good teachers retire early and and again that's the other level that's way on the other Edge and is that going to happen maybe we're not going to have a mass you know exit but that's the trade-offs that I worry about in this decision-making process right so yeah every student that leaves is what $32,000 or and we don't sit in a pretty place right now no no you know I I I so appreciate the board's you know collaboration and ideas and thoughts on it I feel like this was a very good example of some good discourse up here and trying to figure

242out with the community's input as well um and and our experts here and I appreciate you taking this time um I it sounds to me and I agree with you we've had these conversations about finances and and just yeah you know we've got to way the pros and cons right now I feel like based on the data some concerns that we're seeing where our teachers are at currently where the majority that we're hearing from students um and families that U preemptively and and for this next semester while we gather this information um Steve how would we go about forming this committee who who heads this committee um how do we how do we go about that I think it just depends on the direction of what we want to where we want to go I

243mean obviously our our teachers our administrators a board representative okay um our ed services department um it just I I think I'm struggling a little bit of what the endgame is for them to be because we've had a lot of collaboration we've had a lot of meetings um it's taken us a long time to get here and so the last thing I'm and I'm probably sure the teachers would say the thing is they want to have another meeting and start all over again and and so I think it would be important for us to go in with some clear lines of saying that by this is what we want to get to um and and of course we can we can organize organize that committee that's that's committe is organizing it's easy it's it's what

244do we want to accomplish come out of it objective and and so that's ready to take notes um where with the direction that this board was liking us to go okay so I think that yeah I think we're in agreement that a committee needs to be formed I think um the exact objectives and the um the metrics I think can be determined um you know with some key administrators um district office I think Trent and Steve um and I don't know who else you'd like to be a part of that um board members I I can't I believe in any committee we can have more than a only two I think so yeah for right now can't right for now um if we wanted to sit in and listen during that process and and then

245we create and figure out what we want to do um moving forward and what information we need to gather but I don't think that we're going to know that tonight um exactly what we're we're looking for Gathering um so is there a direction at as of right now for this term that we're making yeah so that's the next the next phase here I think um from what I'm hearing correct me if I'm wrong it sounds like the board is in agreement U to continue with um ABC I no credit um in in a traditional model or what we were doing like last semester um versus this semester roll out so it's like turned back the clock to Spring of 2024 before we were full implemen CBE if that clarifies is that is that accurate FIB

246AER I'll come the microphone yeah please or or Mr Clen you can so we do have a number of teachers that have been using the fourpoint scale for a long time and I would hate to have to force them to say you need to whether CB tenants are so many of them as you guys have already heard but to tell Andy who's been doing it for three years some other teachers for four years P facta I know every every site has a number of them to say you're forced to go back to what many of us feel is an inequitable traditional scale for this semester I'm not sure what the benefit of that is and and just to speak on the uniqueness of each site right and so and just discussing you know up at

247Forest H I'm a department of one you I don't have anybody else to work with you know if I need to reach out to people I reach out to pler or and other co-workers that I have and stuff like that um and yeah been involved from the very beginning been involved in the Trailblazers every step of the way because I want to be involved and I want to know how to do this job the best that I possibly can through this process uh I have been able to grow and learn and become a much better teacher and have different types of experiences with my students and you know yeah the idea of like okay now we're going to go back completely and and instead of you know especially for me where it's like I don't

248have to you know coordinate with another social science teacher there's just me yeah um and most of our departments are like that their Departments of one so you know and for me who was like I spent all this time invested on this interest and stuff and to then all of a sudden have to revert back it's um you know that's that's I do look back on all that all the meetings I've been at all the time I've spent all the you know all the efforts that we put in as a group to just see it kind of put to the side it's like and that's why just for for still like an an option what would you like to do um because there are staff at our at our site that aren't fully in and

249you know they have their ways of doing things and stuff but there's many of us that are really excited and there's a lot of good improvements that we've seen um especially with social science because you get a lot of opportunities to be creative and stuff like that it's open my eyes and how I can do my job so um yeah that was just something that I'm glad that she clarifies like you know like you know the option whereas on other sites it's like if you have different types and like oh I want to go to that style and it's no longer about the the curriculum it's about it's about the grading policy is how you're going to choose your class I don't think that's you know that's the way best way to get I just

250want to get that no thank you and I appreciated our phone call as well and I appreciate creativity and I feel like I saw so much of that when I was at kfax and the problem solving and the domains which I had never heard of um you know different different areas of the their Journeys and figuring out ways to problem solve so and change is hard change is always going to be hard and it's always going to be painful yeah and there's going to be learning pains and all that kind of stuff and I've been working through all those things and stuff and so just selfishly I'm thinking about all of those things that I put in and time and growing and then just to kind of come back and like you know so but

251thank you yeah um and again these are are things that may come up through the committee is there is there ways to keep um to use the proficiency scale as an ELO does can that translate to 100 I don't know I don't know I'm not I'm not there yep that was an option absolutely I think it'll the the there'll be just some you know trying to understand where where you know learning Falls within that spectrum of what's articulated on the proficiency scale but we I I think we'd hate to see them go [Music] away so to some extent that's already what's happening I mean they do do the final grades as ABCD already anyway right right I mean I think I'm from understanding this correctly you've been advocating for like a rocknes system um I

252think that's part of it here is I think that's the last piece is the proficiency SC scale does that overwhelmingly again it's the the teachers I've talked to appreciate it I mean as as a father of of kids at deloro I see them working their tail off to look at the proficiency scale and know exactly where to hone in so I and and again Math teachers I spoke to at Del all said we were already doing this right but we don't like being put in the fourpoint scale right and and and I know English has been one where it's like oh talk to the English teachers I talked to the English teachers they had a Sixpoint scale they don't like the fourpoint scale right and so um I I'm I'm open like I I'm not

253100% in agreement with you on the the the the D's but I'm willing to say okay ABC's IC and and and I sorry I keep calling IC but I and NC because I want to make sure that you know that's that that's something I can I can work with you on right but the the proficient and let's find out let's see what the the data shows us that comes up and as we are in the committee but the proficiency scale I I think should really be on the table right now given um the feedback that that we have heard so when you able to be off you mean is that what you're saying no to did be key a key got it okay I'm just clarifying yeah I feel sorry I feel like if we're

254GNA keep the proficiency scales we need to give teachers the flexibility to adapt and modify those scales um what's on the scale to some extent and but also the waiting of the scales knowing that every Department I've heard that over and over and over again from students a department basis right yes on a department basis right because I've heard that from over and over again from students and staff that the waiting of it is the one of the biggest issues yeah I agree on that so okay so if we're rolling back the clocks to to our last semester prior to this school year so last spring we have some teachers in an in a CBE model using proficiency scales on the fourpoint scale we have some that that we're not a part of any of

255it are we in agreement to allow them to choose and to to allow RCB if if we're allowing them to choose traditional versus CBE just for this interim while we're Gathering some more information and data are we are the CBE teachers then allowed to change the weight are they allowed to to modify as we're working through these issues if we allow them to stay in the CBE model worry about that's a big question again I worry about the in consisteny I do too I I think that'll that'll have more risk than anything else it be worse than where we're at today I would think I I I think that going to a proficiency scale but allowing teachers or departments let's be clear departments to decide how they want to waight those scales will be important

256and that gives that will give really good data at the end of the day too so with that are we allowing so how does how would that look this semester if we implemented that are we allowing for the consistency portion all teachers can continue to use a proficiency scale as their on 100 point on 100 Point um but they're Department basis on a department basis change the weights but that's still a variation of c and not traditional not throwing baby with the bath water yeah again I I want to be very clear that yeah let's summarize that would beome I appre the I appreciate the comprehension involved with the scales and the focus involv of the scales I don't want to the anecdotical pieces of who I've talked to very clear that people appreciate that

257yeah the grading system of the fourpoint scale is the the one that's most difficult what are what are tight and what are our just want to clarify because I I feel like I've gotten some different answers teachers who like the fourpoint system can use the four point system no I you don't you don't want that I I that's that's again I I would say no to that because we have a that's a consistency issue so keeping keeping um he's reverting to a traditional 100 point system 100 point system so that now is affecting kofax right if that's if that's what the board majority decides yeah Jeff yeah so my my my suggestion would be to move to traditional grade scale ABC incomplete no credit right like we had previously for the last number of years

258um with proficiency scales Allowed by department for them to decide um how to adapt or modify or and and or weigh those scales but but keep it within that that you know that parameter so to speak but but it's by Department it would have to be within the parameter right so that we're we're fixing most of the issues that I think that that have come up um and it gives us time to you you know figure out all the rest of the wrinkles later on down the road and get it you know a system that's running really well um but if we give each department um the opportunity to evaluate the scales modify adapt the scales reway the scales if necessary whatever the case might be um just so they're consistent within the department at

259that at each individual site um I think that seems like a pretty reasonable um compromise to you know for the teachers that like the you know the system and and the teachers that don't um personally I don't I don't see I don't really understand the argument with um you know why you know why it can't be ABC versus 432 um but like let the teachers decide they're the experts but but you're saying decide Tom's saying no fourpoint scale so we have a conflict right now yeah I just worry about one or the other right and and I would go back to the 100 point scale for now and because again if you you have two different streams well no I'm talking about yeah still keeping the 100 point scale but still having the elos and

260still you know requiring requiring the students to pass all those proficiencies all those elos yeah right and this should be a temporary until we get more data and we can quick get better you know really you're right Jeremy I think this would playcate both sides as a compromise it would tell the teachers and the Departments that you have some flexibility and you can adapt in terms of what you're seeing in your individual students uh is saying that we're not giving up on Competency Based education at all we want to continue and even make it more refined and more successful down the road you know and uh that we believe those kids that have received an incomplete which is still going to be a big part can succeed we we haven't seen that data I think

261as a temporary measure that's really hitting the major button really do does that make sense to no it it does I I'm I still am struggling with and and with the with the D portion because I've always believed if we were going to go back we would have a d and I I I understand completely what you're saying and and and the importance but I just have a tougher time with that but I'm willing to move forward um I I would like to make just one suggestions and I think I'm I'm agreeing with um David and and Jeremy that I think the change You' cause more issue by not allowing teachers who are wanting to do the four point scale especially at kfax that's going to be and for still and the handful of teachers

262that are are using it um I think the inconsistency part is going to be there no matter what I'm not sure if I'm advocating for my principles in the right way but I think they would rather have teachers have the option to use the fourpoint system and deal with that inconsistency who are communicating exactly what you know is expected from the students in their course then it would be the uh then to not allow the teacher the teachers to do it at all one of the things I've noticed in this school and it it start this district and it happens over and over again is uh sometimes you get you know movement outwards of a small group of people who are doing things and people see how it's working and being more effective and I

263would hate for it that to go away because I really think eventually we're going to back end up back there but I could be wrong um but I I just think it would be harder to uh and more difficult for our our uh teachers who honor all the hard work that they've done to get to this point the the fourpoint scale and figuring out and then to say no you don't get to use it anymore I mean that is a lot of just hard pill to swallow for those teachers who put that much time into developing this system so my my thought on on that um portion I feel like I I you know hearing everything that we've heard today I think I would feel comfortable allowing a choice to keep the four point and

264for the interim obviously there's going to be some inconsistencies but I do think that because we are at the start of the new semester there are some that are so unhappy they'll be thrilled to shift there are some that are happy that are working right now and until we can make that you know ultimate decision after we gather more data with a committee and I know you guys have had a million meetings at nauseum and I am so sorry um that's what happens when there there are changes and we need to collect more information and and we improve that way too right so um I would be open to that I know that there's some inconsistencies there but given the time frame um right now and we're rolling out to give an option um for

265this semester and then we make final decisions in June but um how would the yeah no I I appreciate that let me just ask a question how how Trent question for you how um what's the back office look like as far as the software with with this type of change if we were to um go to an ABC um 100 point scale with proficiency uh 100 point with proficiency scale still um what's in having a fourpoint scale and a 100 point scale what's that look like I think what we we have to um provide for those uh options within the Gradebook we've hard set them to our Aries Gradebook we'd have to go back and reset them and allow teachers to make make their changes based off whatever Gradebook they're going to do um so

266I don't I don't foresee that being a big issue it'll be kind of in I'd have to talk to Linda a little bit more who's our um Guru technician about you know is it going to cause a problem now that we've already started the um semester I'm imagining I would I would bet that a lot of teachers haven't set up their grade book yet because they were expecting some sort of change and not not knowing what to do yet so um that might not be that big of a deal because uh and it's so early in the semester so so so here's here's here's the concern in it's both ways so let's just say at um a student gets a traditional 100 point scale and they're like I don't want this I love my fourpoint

267scale and there's a few of those in a class and then they all want to go to the other teacher and then the reverse of that happens that's why I think let's look at deloro where you have overwhelming kids that and parents are like I don't want this they're and you have um let's say two-thirds of the teachers go back to 100 point scale and a third of them don't um what's that going to look like in the counselor's office well and you haven't even touched whether or not is it all scales all students still is it you know we haven't even we haven't even talked about that one yet so um when you say go back to 2024 is that going to be off the table and again it refers to all of the

268you know there's just a lot of layers there yeah so yeah what what part of that is you know is there going to be a you know is it just total autonomy 100% uh with the grading practices with without the grading practices I mean there's a lot of elements in there that we have to make sure that we are aware uh of I think our principles would appreciate knowing what they're going back and telling their staffs and I'm sure the staff would realize want to realize like okay what's the expectation of of doing those things and added to that if they if these students whether they're on a fourpoint scale or 100 point scale realize here here we are trying to refine and put together you know uh our Competency Based system this this might

269be not what you do not want at the moment yeah but this is an interim thing and the district's going to be moving forward you know I think people can adapt to that and realize that yeah it's not forever yeah I I I I would rather it I look at it to say what's the what's going to be more fall out if kids are trying to switch classes versus you know decide I think what are the couple things sorry I'm trying to understand what are the if we go with a well I'm just saying that you know some of those conversations have to be had about like are we going to a traditional system are we still using the proficiency skills are we still expecting all scills all students yeah go through what are what

270are the things that are the I think I think it we haven't heard from them specifically but I would like to they talk talked about it uh the teachers uh um Beth and Jacob you talked about what you guys were willing to or what you thought some Alternatives were so why don't you give us what those alternatives are sure I we can sure ask I mean really it just going back to the survey um the main thing that I think teachers wanted was just a little bit of flexibility some choice so I I um trusty Duncan I hear your concern about consistency but I think as long as the messing messaging is that this is temporary yeah I think it would be okay um I know as far really it came down to were there

271was the greatest concern was just the grade book um again proficiency scales weren't really mentioned very much I'm sorry could you clarify when you say the grade book just be specific sure of course s I'm trying to delineate between proficiency scales and Aries so um and also just the tenants of grading practices in CB I don't think there are very many definitely a vast vast minority of teachers who think that grading practices are bad I think there's lots of aspects of compy based education lots of aspects of proficiency scales and lots of aspects of grading practice that are great and a lot of teachers have embraced it and have chosen I think that was one of the great things about grading practices was that teachers were able to to make it their own they were

272able to choose what things worked in their classrooms what they felt like was great with some guard rails I think that was fantastic um but within to make sure I clarify within a 100 point scale right at the time at the time yeah at the time and so I think that's what we're still advocating for Jeremy you I'm not going to steal you you brought it up you said each department will look at their their grading within the 100 point scale how they grade um and set it up to what's going to work best for for that department yeah I guess just but but but my my my issue is com get those streams together with a fourpoint scale and 100 point scale I just don't know how that's going to sure there seems like

273more negative Fallout so I mean seams is a relative term right now it's what we're doing has issues yeah and so it's not there is nothing we can do that's going to be perfect can't go back in time you know like in Harry Potter where they do the right that would be so wonderful right now but we can't so in terms of worrying about the 100 Point versus the four point we've done that before we did that when we were trying everything out so we're just going backwards just one step to where we're allowing people to make the decision about what's most comfortable for them right now and in terms of there are possibly being issues with kids wining a switch that's why we're specifically thinking we're doing it by department and again it's not

274going to be perfect I can't pretend it's going to be perfect but again will it be better than where we are now so what you hear you're saying that we're advocating for potentially ready to put in a motion you see that as a positive not a negative I I see that what I see sorry this is awful okay there we go is that better okay try to save place um no it's just a ma it's it's a matter of where we are now is not good right and what are our choices no perfect choices this is a choice that comes closest to meeting everyone's needs for the time being for the time being while we have to to allow us to actually go back and look at this and again this is not about the

275CBE practices compy based education has a lot of support a lot of support from the staff we don't want to change the practices it's the grading is it reflective of where the kids are do we push through that too quickly where we miss some nuances that are actually going to allow the grading to be reflective of compy based education does that help again I'll go back to the kids because I I and so and when you're advocating for make sure I understand the 40% in the survey that said let us choose and have autonomy by department on what what grading system we go um can you pull that back up again please because I'm actually advocating for more than that I'm advocating for a substantially larger piece of that pie oh yeah well please I'll

276let you uh the second one sorry yeah that second slide perfect yeah so only 18% or 19% of teachers said that they want to rever back to the traditional grading scale um the vast majority of teachers either want to continue with CBE as is continue with modifications or allow some choice that that's the that's the pie piece of the pie of the 43% that I'm talking about which is the concern I have which is CBE or traditional grading and and and what the what what the the backfire that's going to look like now if it's so look I mean I can say right now the entire math department at deloro is probably going to say traditional the entire science department of deloro is probably going to go traditional um and so that that to me

277is there's continuity there at that point uh and the kids know what they're so there's no to my point earlier there's no situation where the kids are going to go okay I'm going to go to a different teacher because the department has decided Ed to adopt a grading I think that's fine yeah well that's where the question is I mean the question I don't totally understand it give teachers the option to use CB or traditional grading that's my problem is it's teachers right instead of the department department is based on Department then there's no issue right and if you go to the next slide that that that goes to the autonomy piece I think allowing teachers autonomy to adjust their their grade books so are we going to again I think we discussed that being

278as a department decision I don't think any teachers would be upset about that yeah okay because they feel like they have autonomy they have a voice if they have some you know you know part in that decision-making process and I understand completely understand your your uh concern with um you know push back and you know from parents and students and you know in particular mostly the students mostly right I just and I understand that that's that's going to happen um but like they were saying that nothing's perfect but that might be a good opportunity too to be like when that does happen to you know to a administrator or teacher they can say Hey you know this is just temporary this is where this we're trying to fix this but we would really want you

279to participate in this committee that we have it coming up because we want your voice we want your your opinion um I think that might be a really simple and easy way to mitigate those concerns so that they feel like they they continue to have a voice and for you know the people who are Department of one who have this nailed down easy autonomy to make his choice but I guess depart my question was back on that and what I heard Beth say I think traditional grading in CBE could you do CBE I I think people are associating four point scale with CB C and those two are not necessarily correlated because Miss Jeff is dying to make public comment over here they're saying proficiency scale which is CBE correct well and someone say ten

280of CBE is not necessarily the fourpoint scale okay I know you would say well you've already been doing the proficiency scale right hi um sorry I didn't mean to barin I know I'm just one teacher but first of all I would never ever want to tell other teachers how to run their classes because I am not their expert so I do not like any decision that tells people that are liking it that are finding it well to tell them to change I just I don't feel good about that I am definitely not for it but it's because of how it's been done um I think what if if I were to say like a simple answer like if you can just do this I would even say don't even say go back to traditional keep

281it CBE proficiency scales allow us number one scale waiting that has been the hugest thing for me in our math department at deloro number two um in terms of four point I can live with four point I actually don't think it's inequitable I like the 100% because I've lived with it I work with it I know what how how I grade puts the kids where I know they're supposed to be and I did come from a system that was honed and tweaked for over 20 years informed mostly from the three years I was at Rockland so my Essential skill system it was amazing it had a lot of the features of CBE but it didn't have everything essential so that's another piece so if I can have flexibility to make not everything the essential I

282would be ecstatic and four point if you just allow me to give a 2.7 and not be restricted to just 2.5 three 3.5 I don't give me whatever skill you want I know how to grade my kids and I know how to evaluate what they're giving me if it's on a fourpoint scale I don't that's not my big end thing like that's not my big thing I guess I'm not speaking for all teachers but I think any teacher that still wants to do traditional could I mean they come talk to me I can just tell them how they can scale it differently like there's it's it's a lot of math but you can do it it's it's just if you know how you want to evaluate kids you just have to learn how to fit

283it in whatever system that you're given so that's not my big issue I think that's something that we can live with if it's an interim hey we're just trying to figure out something for the end of the term so but I please do not tell people that are liking it not that they can't do it that's just it breaks my heart as a teacher because it's like in a way it's kind of similar I was having a great system and them to be told I had to do this it wasn't great because I love my system and I had been working on it for many years so if I can take this and the components I do like about that and merge it with that that I am just once again growing as a teacher

284which is always what I've wanted to do and I think I can speak for probably every teacher here we all want to do that none of us are just sitting here digging in our heels saying I don't want to change so it's just we need some flexibility to figure out how it's supposed to look and I think each department it's going to look different and we need the ability to let that happen so thank you thank you so much she's very supportive so so the grading system so I I I I kind of want to unpack the the 2.7 real quick and like I'm I'm trying to understand like again I'm I'm a huge proponent of consistency SO waiting is different than the grade right I mean that's that that's my only concern maybe I

285didn't understand your comment 100% but I I would hate for you to have a a b is a 2.7 and another teacher in your math department to have a b is a 2.5 maybe I didn't understand it I teach math so the numbers are my langu just so with what we were given I was told that like okay we have the scale so um for any individual assignment assessment whatever a three is a b and then a 3.5 was an A and then we decided as a department that the high a like if you can like if you were just amazing like you're not making any of the small mistakes that's what we would consider a force it was like a 98% or above we like because we had no other way because our scales

286were not written by us and they were not they're not what we would write so we were doing the best with what we had so I had an assessment that I know how to score and I I know what I'm looking for because I've been doing this for years I would get somebody that maybe had earned an 80% and somebody heard an 87% I think it's been something you've mentioned I had to give both of those kids a three because I was told I cannot put anything other than a three but if I could do a three or a 3.7 which we were doing that at Rockland they were not it wasn't like some scale where you were locked in it's just I do like four because it's it changes the mindset of students instead

287of 90 that's an a 70 that's a c like when you tell kids it's out of four like they don't always think like where is the ABC you just like at Rockin it was yet to get a 2.5 which is actually a 67% but when you mandate every single one of them that's a hard feed and so yeah you can go down to a 67% in each one but you have to have all of them but then there's all these there's other categories I can do that aren't essential so I I want to be able to have some like the math World i c i no one would pass math if I truly had like everything like it's just that's a lot to ask there are Essentials you need to know factoring if you get

288out of integrated two if you come to my integrated three you are going to struggle that would be an essential but if you're integrated to and you you know did the circles unit and secant lines and tangent lines we don't really come back to that much I don't think that needs to be essential and for some I think that was an entire scale because it was a module so we need if we have the flexibility do that and we can just like tweak some of the fourpoint scale as a department because I agree consistency is really important because we don't want kids switching classes I get it but if everybody that's in the math department at Forest Hill everyone in the English Department at pler if they're all agreeing like this is how we're taking

289the CBE model and proficient like keep all that that's fine but can we have some flexibility to make it work with what we know is best for our dep person so good so so so you are in favor of Department making a department wide decision and I'm fine if we are not I don't need to go to 100 point scale necessarily if we end up doing that but I think that is a decision that needs to come from a committee with more time okay so I think we're here I don't want to back pel and I certainly do not want to tell those teachers that have been doing this and working their tales off that they have to now do 100 points so yeah that just doesn't seem fair um we we have a couple

290I mean look we're hearing from everyone we have a couple students here and Justin raised his hand so come on j y I really really so little history last board meeting I came up to you guys with a plea for help because I trusty Underwood I know you weren't there but I pretty much said the students need you now more than ever trustees gave you a bunch of reasons why I just really wanted to say thank you behalf of all the students because um I got so many texts afterwards people were live streaming it from home who had Sports and got replayed in many classrooms uh I was actually in a classroom and they were like Hey we're going to play what Justin said it's really appreciated everything that you guys are doing and only

291few things that uh did not get covered is as a student and as a student representative an advocate we get one shot at high school that means that we get one shot to prove ourselves worthy to colleges or Air Force Academy or a next job wherever we want to be we get one shot at that and the kind of guinea pig area that we were in I just is something that I hope not to move back to until like you said we form committees and we form areas where we could actually know what everyone believes and um uh one more thing is I've personally and I've never met anyone that's been graded on parent night ever either I think that our teachers I have utmost faith in them Mr feffer Miss Jeff Miss Miller Senora

292Matthews Senor Adams like I will name every single teacher I have at deloro minus a few maybe but and say I trust you with my grading the majority of the teachers I trust to grade me and I trust that they that department will make the right decision for them because that's what the students need the students need those teachers who know them who know them not the administration that doesn't the teachers who know them to make those decisions and I just really appreciate you guys listening and um last thing is is I don't think you need CBE to focus on learning that was brought up earlier I think I know in my freshman year I didn't have CB and I learned a lot I could tell you SOA TOA if you want like I go

293off all day but um I definitely think that you don't need CBE to focus on learning and like I said trust our Educators we get one shot at high school and just appreciate you guys listening thank you I try to advocate for the students and I appreciate you guys listening and being there and just ready to take action tonight thank you guys really appreciate it thank you quick question for you you you've you've been kind of a voice there at and just really appreciate all your leadership as for for the students so what you've been hearing up here just really interested to hear like we're talking about again I know I love Steve because Steve's like let's define this right yeah so so AB ABC you know um um incom incomplete and I yeah I'll

294get that down some point and then an NC with the proficiency system right in in place sorry scale system in in place with the Departments I think what we've heard here is the Departments having the choice between a four point versus 100 point scale um when you hear that what what what do what do you think to be really honest with you guys I'm a I I I tutor math I'm a big fan of D's only because I've tutored people that just like trusty president love saying that Spade said we don't have not everyone wants to go to college and not everyone has this these options like I tutored a student that wanted to take a gap year her goal was to get a d so she did not have to keep taking I to

295over and over again be worried be left behind in the last semester that's a slight concern I have I think I totally see where you're coming from chesse Edwood as an educator I see where you're coming from there's just a few worries I have with it not it's not a one- siiz fits-all and I think that having that D is kind of that middle part that's possibly may be missing I don't know I'm not like I said you 30 years of experience but I have as the students perspectives and what I've gathered at deloro is I think that we do miss Some D's but at the same time the majority of it I 100% agree with I think the students would be on board um we obviously care a lot I think that like I

296said we get one shot so all the stuff that is happening I think is safe because before that it was EMP power Aries whoa where are we going right now I think we went from there to gradually coming back to here and I really appreciate that I think that that kind of middle is good I'm a huge fan of I believe most students at Del are fans of the 100 point system because we understand it so even if we were to get a 3.7 it's like I call my I'm gonna be honest I call my grandparents whenever I get good grades and I'm like Grandma I got a 3.5 on a test and they're like is that good I'm like yes but if I say 97% it's clear to parents it's clear to students and

297big fan of 100% or 100 point scale but also big fan of departments I think that each department is different each has unique aspects I think students see that students know their teachers aren out to get them and I think that that's like like they went to college like I trusty Jeff I believe you have your Masters right yeah you went to college for six years like we trust you we trust these Educators to lead us and I think that like having that per Department having those discussions help I know I bring up phsd policy 1,000 titled Concepts and roles I believe it's teachers it's students it's parents it's board members everyone's coming together to collaborate and create decisions not being told what to do but collaboration and I really appreciate I feel like I've

298seen a lot of that tonight I like I my goals in the next few years are to be student board member because I would love to be a part of this like I think that all of that is so so unique and Rich to our district and Rich to this new board and um I appreciate you guys listening and I definitely think that whatever course of action is taken students will be on your side because we need change from what has been happening it's definitely hard to be there so I appreciate you guys thank you again thank you so much yeah so and and I think Justin the D portion again I'm I'm I I I can just tell we've just met tonight so we bonded over basketball so uh but uh I I understand

299the care for hey let's get everyone up right to a c or a B at the very least right I I'm totally with you but I also understand I think your story which is not EV not not every family and kid is on that and I think Trent mentioned which I'm 100% agreement with is everyone should know they have an opportunity to get to college and get good grades but we're not going to the E I love Equity but that portion of equity is what bothers me where we're going to push kids into hey guess what you got to see how' I do that right and I'm I'm okay with failure sometimes too because it's a kick in the pants it's going to make them either decide to go one way or the other so

300I and again I don't want to get too much in the weeds but is there an opportunity for an IC for someone to say oh am I at a where where am I on the grading system and is out a d then I'll take the d and that might sound tough for some folks but again I I I don't want to give out participation Awards um and so that might be something I don't know if we want to make that decision tonight or we want to make it in a committee but that's that's just my thought on I hear what you're saying I couldn't support that I can support everything else we're talking about but I can't support that because I know what my life SP in the classroom and I know what can happen

301so me if a kid has a choice that William Glasser uh quality schools is real clear and he says he's I don't know if you know you read up on that but we started quality schools at uh in this history 40 years ago he actually came he was a famous psychiatrist and educator and he talks about Competency Based education within the parameters of quality schools and his basic statement is a [Music] b incomplete no credit you know he doesn't even do the C yeah you know and um Quality School is still gaining momentum uh throughout the nation and it's like a 40y old program but that was kind of like the beginning of Competency base and knowing what I know wait knowing what I've experienced in the classroom I I can't support it D I

302just can't do it we've worked really hard to get rid of fs and D's and uh I really believe I wish we had the data to see how many students that have received incompletes have moved up to a SE which might make that easier but knowing what I know right now I I couldn't support that but I can support all of our discussions and what we're doing I feel good about that yeah no and I I appreciate that I I I guess for me I I'm interested to see how these next four weeks Go I mean miss Nick I know you're right in the middle of this you're you're ministering tests right I'm sure a lot of these principles are so I know what you guys have done to raise your hand and say well

303let's get it done and so um it's the it's that workload that I'm interested to see how that affects the kids how that affects you guys as administrators or whoever else is helping with this but I'm also interested to see you know how how many kids move off this IC right and I sorry um and uh and get to a c or a B so all right well I think we are narrowing down what this is going to look like potentially are you going to recap so I'm going to do a quick recap unless you have a better recap and then you can I guess can I try and see if I got okay so what I'm hearing that at this point our tight is ABC incomplete no credit and use of proficiency scales by

304all teachers that is our tight our choice at this point of what I heard is proficiency scale Waiting by Department and whether or not the department is going to use a fourpoint scale or a 100 point scale and I really like um Miss jeffes instead of using traditional let's let's yeah not let's not say that 100 point scale versus the four point scale that's all I have right now that's I I feel is concete p the one thing I think that's exactly what I I feel I personally feel comfortable with but it's an interrupt I think that's important it's not going to be the so we can have the time to tweak it sure and I think the other major factor was that the department will um wait their own scales like they will have

305some flexibility within the waiting of the scales not just four versus a 100 Madam president if I may to I I appreciate the fact that the board is looking at maintaining CBE policies because it helps and in all seriousness with theou that we have because that would cause some consternation especially and not just with me I'm saying with but within teachers themselves if if there's talk of well I'm not doing anything anymore I'm just going traditional well that doesn't help that's so I appreciate going in that direction and making it at least consistent that way with and some of the presentations by the teachers about that so yeah just yeah interim I think to to gather some data I think it's going to be um did first of all is everyone in agreement with that

306I'm still I got to be honest I think I would give an incomplete or a D um if they didn't um pass four weeks if they did if here's here's the thing and I'm I'm get your thoughts on this because I really appreciate your experience and your care for this but if they got to the end of the four weeks and so so so I'm trying to be flexible to say hey they still got to go try to get that that c but if they get to the end and they don't pass can we give them a d instead of having him retake the class and that that's that that again yeah as long as they they don't know about that you can't tell the student that or many of know if they knew that

307they're going to not make an effort and move up yeah I don't know how we'd hide that that but but that I hear you I don't know that that's the communication piece would certainly need to be there I don't I don't know any thoughts I mean yeah the D would still repick the class at Del that's our policy that was under the even even two years ago years we want to keep doors open for students we want to make sure that you know a 14-year-old isn't making a decision that's going to limit them when they're 18 or 30 well I would hope that'd be a parent and student decision but but but that's something you were already practice with across District the whole District okay unless unless we can exam sorry unless that wasn't a

308core a core subject or they met like in my case the world you know the the language class they just are required to have one period um unless they're trying to go to college and then they need to pass two and in order to you know to progress they need a c or above and so that's what we're talking about technically they could have a d if they weren't progressing to the next class is that accurate with the old system wouldn't be able to go to the next level course if they don't have a c right correct so technically in a you know foreign language class you know they could technically have a d and pause for the cause if they if they didn't want to you know if they weren't on a college track

309obviously we want all students to have options and I and I I'm not trying to mitigate that in any way shape or form I'm just there's a reality sometimes and I think that you know addressing that um another issue I heard with a with a d is um that it's impacting eligibility for sports um because there's a zero score instead of a one um and I've heard coaches sharing their thoughts with me on that and as a a creative and as a former athlete um I care about that there's some kids that are only coming to school so they can compete and do my my children and my husband says it regularly that he was only in school so that he could wrestle and if it weren't for that he would have dropped out so

310for the last two years this district has not had these they have not hasn't been two it's been two for the last two years right this year just this semester for for the last year so they already students already know that it's only recently we got of the the practice has been with what our principles are talking about it's been a conversation with parents and counselors and administrator and to say hey you have a d we want to put you back in this class again and then the parent gets to decide whether or not that happens but it's it's it's a default to reenroll them right which is something we've done over the years um prior to even CBE for a to G I mean the the the numbers that were being measured on this

311was one of the ways that we were able to help uh mitigate that which is one of the reasons our our C correct Nick can you come up to the microphone I apologize that trending at the next that policy or practice of we're going to reload students and and continue that to have them no you're going to make it through we believe in you enough to say let's go again because we believe in you is the reason that we are a state leader in esack you know CCI uh uh graduation rate all those things that are getting kids to like no we're gonna we're going to keep going we believe hard um and are there just I'm asking a data question I know you don't have SP stuff in front of you but like as

312have we have we seen that that kids that retake the classes is there what's the percentage of them that actually get to a c or better we have we have a at deloro 70 plus per a tog rate um so that's that's kids that are getting all the way through integrade three World Language 2 those are some of the barriers so and some some of those kids are taking math you know multiple times to get there um and taking it their senior year taking it twice their senior year because they don't give up um which is so cool and heartwarming for me so I'd hate to I I wouldn't want to set up a system that kind of you know doesn't continue to to push students to do the hard thing can I point out

313something you said just said Nick you um talked about how our district is a state leader in the CCI indicators as you just mentioned then if that's the case then why did we why did the previous board make all these radical changes with respect to the grading like if we were already doing really well like I I thought i' mentioned it uh Jeremy in a in our report last time is that uh out of that group even we look at our data that we're looking at how we can support all of our students not all of our students are being successful all of the changes that we are making um that have been made over the past 10 years have increased in a large way all of our outcomes and our outcomes for other students

314all students the you know Rising tide lifts all boats kind of concept the CBE was something that we didn't feel uh and and you know looking at the data um was going to prevent students from achieving it was going to provide an opportunity for students to achieve um and give them an opportunity to meet that um those expectations so when we look at our students with disabilities socioeconomic disadvantaged students which we're held responsible specifically for by the state and federal government that we have to find ways to say how can we get them to those same metrics and what came up over and over again when you look at the data of saying why aren't these kids are swd or students with disability are uh socioeconomic disadvantaged kids why aren't they getting the same it's

315usually over course completion they're not doing well in esack scores because they're not in integrated 3 when they take the um esack they're not getting a because they're retaking so many of their courses um those things we start so when we start peeling away and looking like how can we meet the needs of all of our students what are the things that we can do to create a system that is fair to everybody and gives kids opportunities who uh might need a little more time to complete a course that's where it came from so the change was how can we do it better how can we improve yeah the the biggest issue I have with the time piece is we want to move away from time based education but sure we're in class for I

316mean four years so my problem with that is and Jessica brought it up was the kids now go from four classes to five classes right um and and and part of the concerns I had on um cve was the retakes right and and and they're falling behind in their current uh uh classes um and then I think the last thing I'd say is um from a department standpoint um is there going to be pressure for folks to take on CBE um because I get it overwhelmingly Administration wants CBE um and so will there be pressure on the teachers or departments which which I think is a real concern for me yeah as well if we're giving a choice again right I I I'm going back to the choice like I'm yeah I'm not a huge

317fan of it but and if we're GNA if if it's part of making change here I'm willing to you know the D's and the choice are the are the ones that I'm I'll I'll I'll Stand Down on but I think it's really important to think about you know the pressure that could be on these departments and these teachers um based on the administration's goal to see this through and I think I just would say one thing other thing there's a lot of students who have great Advocates at parents who push them who force them into uh tutors who force them into all of the other things our responsibility is all students those students who have those same Advocates that don't have those same resources our job is to say how can we help them because

318they don't have anybody in their corner so um we don't we don't get to say hey we got 80% of our kids meeting CCI the other 20% well our is all of them are going to and CB fixes that in your opinion I think it I think it adds an element to help fix it because it because you give kids opportunity to finish the courses but that that that I I have a fundamental issue with that because again this is you know parents are the ones and the Guardians and the friends and the the network are the ones to do that it's not the it's not the administration's job to do what to to to it's your job to Advocate but not to have a grading system that have has everyone go into the middle

319in order to make sure that um you I but I would disagree Tom that that's that's happening I don't think everybody's going in the middle when you look at the grade distribution not everybody's in the middle uh the the the if you look at it site by site I me I I aggregated the data and you have more C's than ever before you have less Le in some cases less A's and definitely less B's and so and we knew that that the Les a were going to happen as a result of uh uh probably saying hey these are the expectations and it's you have to show it this way and I think um you know the prior board and uh Administration superintendent and assistant superintendent that were here had mentioned that number of times that

320yeah there'll probably be some decreasing of great inflation that happens um for sure this this I mean I Trent you're proving my point right now this is where I get worried about the administration and I worry about the pressure on the teachers to and what decision they're going to make because of the advocacy that this is a I get it you guys want CBE and for the reasons you just mentioned so I I have a lot of concern that we're going to give choice but then at the end of the day there's going to be pressure put on the teachers and so again this that's again why this was pushed through now I've learned a little more on the timing but I know this was push through from an Administration standpoint and from prior superintendence

321as well and if we're back at that place then this will fail I see it a little different where you see pressure I don't see pressure per se I see uh first of all the staff realizing this is an interim process that we're going through and in this interim process you you guys have do have a choice by district and you could discuss this and take a look at what we want to do for this interim process but I hope the interim process is over within a semester yeah okay within a semester okay so in this interim process is what we're going to be doing as a department working together collaborating discussing uh bringing more data to uh the uh District to the to the to us to the board so we can do a

322really good job of refining but I think it's just temporary thing so I don't think it's really pressure per se from a technical definition I don't say I share Tom's concern but our Comprehensive High School principles are all here in this room and they've all been listening to what this board's um concerns are um and you know that would be pretty dumb for them to disregard what we're what we're are asking to to do think so Jeremy I believe I really got to use the rest yeah you do your thing you do your thing let's take a a five minute recess um and then we'll hopefully close this sucker down thanks do I need a make it BR official stretch real fast what are we doing a five minute recess can we e e e

323um um superint or Deputy superintendent Acting Superintendent chetti did you want to read us through our summary one more time sure okay um so what we're saying as um tight continues is um at this point is proficiency scales only because I still feel like we're we're not sold on the on the D yet but if we're moving forward it's the ABC incomplete it's proficiency scale sces and I would add a caveat to that that they're going to need revision we know that going into it they're not perfect they they'd have to be the areas of of of choice among sites is the proficiency scale waiting the 100 point scale use of the 100 point scale or the fourpoint scale and um then we brought we need to bring up the the all scales concept yeah

324all scales all students um I there's just so much feedback right now I don't know that we're having issues with you know what skills are most important and I just feel like at this point while we're in this interim phase that you know we may strike all skills all students for this um working group committee period and let's figure out what we need to do to readdress that um by the time the committee comes back how do we feel about that that mean for last time that's a great question um does anyone have thoughts on that I go ahead it's no different than last year versus this year it's a different system different system right but if a student that's an interesting point yeah um um so right now they they are required to have

32575% of the proficiency skills so and I understand that there are different numbers of scales for different subject matter Department groups so what does that look like is that they're missing one scale I mean I I'm I'm not sure what that looks like I cane so yeah we have integrated math one I think there's 12 scales so someone could be missing three and they have an incomplete there could be someone with an NC that's missing four scale but their grade would have been a c in the grade book and so if they had that class this next term and we go to not all skills all students they would had a c but instead they're retaking it so there there's there's mathematical nuances to work out because there's yeah there there's a lot oh that

326adds a whole other layer I'm trying to wrap my head around all scales all students so whatever if we choose to have those all those scales but I thought the waiting would would yeah would the waiting shift that for this next semester if you guys had the decision to waight the scales differently could you guys make it work differently if you had that flexibility versus all scills all students I mean mathematically the question is so I'm doing so I'll revert to science I'm doing strike geometry and I've got 10% of my it's really important it should be 10% or maybe it's 12% but gas laws is going to be 3% you've automatically now made it more important so the mathematics is going to apply exactly right so if by they still are having to attempt

327it but the weight's going to be on those things that are more important the department chooses that the the department is choosing the weights the weights the weights and Al but but the the all scale thing is important in the sense of if they don't pass a scale that isn't worth very much right so we do I'm assuming what you're saying is that we're establishing that we're taking care of that element simply through the weights and not for all kids okay does that sounds reasonable does that sound reasonable okay it does that make sense jaob no yeah yeah I can tell you're processing so but if if all students have to pass all scales and it doesn't no we're saying they don't if they don't have to then it would get figured out because we're

328we're making sure that they understand the most important things the essential areas by waiting them appropriately correct right because that's one of the the concerns I have with the scales I love the scales for the focus but I I don't love that if you miss one scale you you have an incomplete yeah this is something and again this is something that the working group down the line the committee is GNA have to discuss what kfax did um or one of the teachers now too I the domains all right which this is a whole other thing you know this is a whole other thing so and this came because we were doing all scales all students so my IB teacher my IB Biology teacher has something like I don't remember 46 scales and she couldn't do

32946 scales all scales all students so she grouped them into domains and IB sets our curriculum so she doesn't get to decide what that is they set the curriculum so she grouped the scales into domains and it's all Ms all scales now my math teacher wants to do that but I told him to hold off until we figured out if we were going to have autonomy at the sites or if it was going to be he's prepared he was prepared to propose it to all the math teachers in the district of this idea of domains but it would be all domains all all students all domains would be we weighted equally but you would have the opportunity to group up some of those proficiency scales um so then in essence they do become like a

330smaller percentage if you will within that domain so the domain but again the all scales all students is super important to know if we're going to make students pass all those scales or not yeah before tonight so so we would the two options are one all scales all students but then we'd probably need to readdress the last grades which is complex or two go ahead or or the second is that because we're giving flexibility with the weight this next semester that we wouldn't have to go back to the previous grade book because it would still be all scales all students however the weights would be different so they would have you know the flexibility to weight them properly yeah but then also have the flexibility of of not again if you have an IC one

331I sorry if you have one scale that you're missing you don't necessarily have to have a thing complete for that no I think if we if we kept the all scales all students they would still have to show um that they've passed the scales but the the weight would be different so is that accurate yeah come on back sorry just want to make sure we're clear and again I don't know if the board agrees but my my thought was just simplify it and don't have all scales also yes that's exactly I I think that's what Steve was saying too right I'm not speaking for you in terms of simplif in terms of simplifying for this term to get a but then we need to go back to the previous term but yeah to next Point

332yeah you then you have to go back and decide the teachers have to decide then at that point yeah they're gonna give Grace to that and what if one I one teacher says yes and another says no and then that's not an option we're going by department so that's true we're going to tell teachers what you have to still do it by Department how are you going to have one teacher Department do one thing and have somebody do something else well so you could have several departments uh on a on the fourpoint scale and some on the other scale which is okay each department decides what their choice is going to be yeah and this this this is going back to to say look we we're no longer doing all scales all students so in

333order to ensure we have Apples to Apples on semester we're going to go back and give the department decides to give Grace to those kids to say okay and you no longer have an IC or or you have one IC or whatever it is right so yeah can may I ask a question oh please so it it makes sense to me what you're asking are you aware what this ask is going to do for the teachers because after the each department makes their decision then they would have to go back and look at at the current the current grades there's work to do there will be work now the it wasn't actually an incentive it was a compensation for the additional lift of CBE for theou um tomato tomato but in theou it clearly says

334it's compensation for the work let's call and um and so that could be considered part of that but I just want to ensure that our Union partners are aware that what they may be receiving back from their fellow peers when they're requested to go back and look at every single student and consider now that you've made a department decision okay these are our seven important scales and that's and we're going to have to relook at the grades that we provided to all the students but I I I agree with your point but aren't we just looking at the kids in Inc complete status yes well and nnc nnc will that be only that if you some of the scales would that change some of the grades well so so here's I guess so well we

335don't have to go back retroactively and change those grades all we need to really do is have the teachers look at the the incompletes and the no credits and decide very simply I'm going to give this person a c or I'm gonna give this person an F or I'm gonna give this person an incomplete have those grades been on the transcript now though that's what that's the problem they're on the transcript I me here's the same the same argument exists with an ie they have four weeks and we're going to change something potentially anyway I worry about is a lot of teachers will look at it and go I don't want to deal with this for four weeks so see yeah no I want to ask this question again so right now you have 10

336proficiency scales kids got a grade so I got a B but on three of those scales were my lower scores now you're getting rid of those three scales now my grade would be an A so because they're getting rid of some of the skills that's for this term not for last term that we'd be doing that ex we we can't go back and completely eliminate pieces of the grade book from last term we're literally only looking at the eyes and the NC's that is it we are not making this overly complicated yeah we have work to do on the eyes so there's work to be done whether people are going back and reviewing those grades or whether people are doing the work to help the kids get through the eyes and granted in different departments

337in different situations it may be more advantageous for the kid to work through the eye right and other to feel more Comfort comfortable in the sense of now this kid can move on and we feel confident in that this kid can move on in other areas it may be like hey in a different situation in the term before this kid would have already had a c so why are we penalizing that kid and making them go back into a scale that isn't even all that important important so that's where the review part is important and that's why there's the request to please let us have the department time on Monday and then bring that um that minimum day forward to next Wednesday and let us get that done give us that time to make that

338happen sorry if I interject if I'm a teacher I'm going to go and I'm going to now as a department Rees take that reweighted scale compare it to last semester for all my my no my's no you wouldn't do it that way not how what's then then what's the process of deciding if the kid if the student is a incomplete or a SE that would be by Department again because it's going to depend on the department and the case of so I can speak in terms of math right what would they use sort of because this is a department decision so this is my thoughts on it as a math teacher as an individual not as a group yet so the easy thing to do would be to go through and look at those kids

339that got the eyes was that an accurate assessment do they need a little bit more time to learn a little bit more before we say they're totally ready to go on if that's the case they would stay in the ey group and they would go ahead and do remedial work if they don't complete the remedial work it will stay the same as what we've done in the past even before this term which is it's going to revert backwards to the NC I'm good with that I I I I mean I I appreciate app that look but okay I guess what I'm struggling with is they're going to have to reweight all of the scales anyways no but we're not messing with the waiting from this past one but sorry hear me out on this okay

340I'm going to reweight the scales for this spring semester yes I'm then going to take that to say if I would have had the same waiting system in fall semester how would I have graded the student and then because what you're saying feels subjective whereas what I'm saying is hey you got to go build the weight the weighted uh uh proficiency scale anyways why not just grab that and compare it to okay what would the kid what would the student have got have received with this new waiting weighted scale I understand so you're wanting to numerically go through and recalculate and I would say that would be a mistake and what we've been doing with the scales has been more subjective than what we're used to most of us is is that because you felt

341like is it and it's not supposed that's the whole Port that's it was we're trying to get away from subjective right exactly and and and and that's been part of the problem that that we're Blended right with this last semester so I I was just I'm not saying that's what I'm I'm just trying to give an idea that if it were me I would look at the new I would I would take my new weighted weighted scales decided as a department and I would then go back to those kids to easily say yep he would have he would have got a C he would have got a B he would still be an incomplete he would be an um an NC and then that way you can funnel people and give a grade here and

342keep someone on a four-week track so I understand what you're saying I just I would say it's a a it's a heavy lift and B I would say that it is unnecessary because um as part of what we do as teachers we assess where the students are in they're learning and so I don't think you need to number crunch all that stuff backwards to go through and be able to say like for example and I am one if I see a a kid that I look at their scales and they're missing scales that aren't essential I could just easily go in and put an NA on those and see what happens and see if that puts them to a c right if that do you know what I mean like it it's not a total

343reworking it's just you're targeting those places where they missing it's just still you're being subjective oh for sure and I don't want to be but I this is circumstances this is where we are I'm just trying to give a an easy way to but I'm yeah yeah but I'm I'm a proponent of go getting rid of the all scales for all students okay I I feel like just given what this situation I do think Grace is the the word you know we're all figuring this out if there is a chance that they would have had a c prior and they're an NC now or an I um I think that it's fair to look back back and and potentially adjust those and I'm interested to see what that's going to look like um frankly with

344the data so and I appreciate that I just have a concern that there are parents this talk will happen and parents will hear that certain scales were thrown out students will hear that certain scales were thrown out and that would have changed what their grade would have been Justin so so I the just again for the just just would you be looking at that as a student I really appreciate you call me up for that uh yeah so I definitely think as a student we're we're kind of we hear everything right like the more involved you are the more you hear and I definitely think that if we heard one person was getting that treatment not necessarily everyone would expect to get the same treatment but people would raise the questions of why is that

345person getting the treatment however what I think is happening here and the discussions that are happening here if explained to parents and if explained to students in a proper way I think that it's great I think that there's no problems no issues there shouldn't be any misconceptions there's one slight problem I race and that's a four is still above and beyond and I think that those may be the personally I got all a last semester and I believe a lot of the strong a students did but there were a few that tried their best but they were taught to a b so they got a B even though they might have been an a student just because they haven't been given that instruction of an a level that might be upset by it but like

346I said I would I totally understand that I would see that and I would say hey why is this but at the same time with the reasoning that like trusty Duncan just gave with the reason with the reasoning that you guys have all been saying if like that was like able to be addressed in an email that was sent out to all students teachers admin like before the questions were raised I think that that would be really beneficial because then it's not oh I'm hearing this it is actually from the board this is what happen this is what's happening as students go home to parents they are saying they're not complaining and then the parents get mad because they're second in the chain and they don't really always know what's going on they have our

347best interest but and then there's not Mis confusion if it was addressed like upfront I think that's like the biggest thing is that if hey at the last board meeting a lot of concerns were raised about company based education this is how we are proceeding this will be the process if you got an irnc and I think that like I said if it's addressed if it's addressed before and your reasoning 100% agree you guys are incredible I think that if that's what happens I think we should be good do you agree with that uh I think there's parents that will call and complain and so I just want you to be prepared for that and I think uh the other part of that it is it is going to be um you know the the

348way the Ed code says is the teacher has to be the person who changes the grade you can't do it by a board policy they're the one who's going to have to change the grade that's already on the transcript so uh while it might be great to have a department but if there's a department guy who says I'm not going to change it they don't have to change it and the pressure is going to be then on that individual teacher that's what I'm concerned about is some of those some of those situations might come up so if we do all um we don't have all scales all students this next semester and we you know piggyback it with our last that wouldn't be a department decision that would be a unilateral like that would be

349the same across the board not departments choosing all skills all students that would be across the board we would we would uh I guess eliminate that that part of it yeah yeah that's right and then and then the Departments have the decision-making flexibility with the weights and whether incompletes and if they only addressed it on incompletes you know yeah you're I'm sure you're right I have no doubt you're you're probably spot on um I mean it probably would be uh you know something that we work with the ATP about of saying you know this is going to change if you would like to go through and look at your gradebooks from last term and determine whether or not based off of this new system if those kids would have gotten um a better grade would

350you be willing to change it that is a heavy lift to Mrs lll's point Point um but I I just don't know how it will cause some conflict I I'm pretty sure and I think that conflict will ultimately end up on the teachers laps because the administrators can't do anything to force a grade change based on what you said president Spade I think that if what every if what is you're saying what oh my goodness what you are saying is communicated out I think that like like you guys are so like good at like addressing the problem front on like levelheaded like I think that what what you're saying like makes sense and I think that if like maybe president Spade like you help like write all that stuff because like I said 100% like

351if that's what's em out and if that's like a hey it's uniform it's across the district then I just don't think that our admin will be getting as many phone calls because they won't think it's per site the district might get a few but I mean there's always you're like I know that you said like hey uh Mr Wilson you said we have to forget about the 20% like we don't forget about the 20% I definitely think that in this case there'll always be people that are not unpleased but and we're not forgetting about the people that are not but at the same time I think as a number standpoint more students at least I can't really speak about parents but more students I think would be for this and it's giving a little bit

352more grace soate you guys again we're gonna have thank you Justin we're gonna have calls and complaints no matter what again I go to tradeoffs yep which decision here is going to decrease that and but not that that's not why we're making the decision we're making decision on what's best for the students just remember too we're only talking about 300 and some odd incompletes within the entire District yep right and the the no credits already they're you know though there's some that might be really close the failure that change might 632 632 students so there's some of those that might be kind of close but a lot of those probably my guess would be that they're like you know a minor change here and there is not going to bring them from an F to

353a c that that would change my daughter's grade from a NC to a c here we go Trent here we go you're winning am I am I good question you know thank you guys all for your comments again um real quick I think I know that this is not this is not easy this is temporary um as we continue to gather some information but I think we're ready to to uh call a motion and just um we need to clarify that one more time can can he read the sure the points yep one more time that you have heard that we're ready to vote on in terms of putting I'll do my best um ABC incomplete and proficiency scales is the tight Choice by department is proficiency scale waiting 100 point scale or the fourpoint

354scale and tight is also all scale we are I'm have that in the middle of no more all scales all students and can you just clarify you said ABC incomplete so the NC is still there or it is yes it is yes yep that's a tight AB ABC incomplete no credit teachers are using proficiency scales however the choice is the proficiency scale weights and whether or not they're going to be using the 100 point scale or four point scale in their Aries Gradebook and all scales all students is is a no and do we want to are we getting granular say teachers will decide and reevaluate fall semester Inc completes and and NC's I think we should yeah yeah um sorry a question came up is that some departments um have uh emphatically um embraced

355the all scales all students this becomes the challenge right so we have some we have some English departments who are like no this is what we do been doing it for years years so so if they get all of their students across the Finish Line all scales all students more power to you so Department Department based all scale all student if Department says I don't I don't think Department based I think if the if the staff member feels strongly about that you know get them across the finish line that I agree it is a choice no there is no choice no choice it's yeah no scales but if the teacher is like focused on they want all their students to pass all scales to move forward we rolling up some sleeves yeah still confused no

356we're GNA do away with no no so you're saying just we're going with a pure average a pure average than of whatever the score is is it but is it an average if it's if it's if you're saying um you know that some teachers can't use the all scale all students you're forcing them to say I'm just going to average than whatever the average is of the total what my student work is essentially right am my is that is that exactly what happens that's what we're asking that's what you're saying after they weigh this they going to they're going to rely on the average to come up with a score whatever the average of the scales yes yeah sorry the weighted scales doing all scales all students are no longer allowed to do not not

357not allowed but it's no longer required this semester it's either it's either a choice or it's not allowed I mean that's stud or no credit for not passing all the scales right yeah so if if they still don't pass all the all the scales it's an incomplete or a no well we were getting rid of that but the question came up was if we get rid of that and say that's not a that's not a requirement we were asking is it an option Tom said no know um I think it has to be an option because we have a lot of but you guys Mak the decision well now all of a sudden we're going to be back at C this being CBE and so I'm agree with Tom straight I I think it's I

358think it's not all skill all students but again interim decision decision we will go as a committee involving everyone you know not everyone here but a lot of folks to decide what's the best solution so well the other the other thing that that I think ends up is again like in my in my nope I'm glad we talked about unraveling this means you have to unravel a lot of other things right yeah so we unravel this it unravels the incomplete process right so we don't have any demarcation about what constitutes an incomplete we'll just leave that to the teachers to decide if I give them an incomplete that means I think that they can pass it with whatever time frame afterwards because if we're not saying they have to pass a certain amount of scales

359or what scales they have to pass uh it'll be up to the teachers to decide whether they want to give them an eye or not I'm 100% what yeah I'm good with that yeah if the feels they need I mean it's again teacher knows the student the p in my opinion so so you still have a question that's what that's right we need it's not a it's it's either choice or it's it's not I mean there's no like English depart time now cannot that that's the question because if a student doesn't pass one of those scales the average score is still GNA pass them on well that depends on how they weigh the scales right right yep and that's part of that's part of the flexibility of weighting the scales right yeah so they have

360five scales a student says you know what I'm not GNA do this one SC thank you so if the English Department has five scales in a class and a student says I'm only going to do these four they can still pass ju that's just the question on the table and not write a Nar right and so that's what these the English teachers have been doing have been requiring all scales for a long time all they're not called scales but they were called esas all the essential things and they were seeing them as essential so let me just clarify my thought here is that I I they still to take all the scales but what I'm what I'm advocating for is if they get an IC sorry if they if they if they don't pass one

361of the scales it's up to the teacher to say hey you don't you understand and you comprehend this so we're going to move you on with the system we have today they would get an an incomplete and and and fail the class unless they were to take that retake that scale pass the question though is for teachers who have have that all scale currently and they've had it for a long time yeah they just need to know if they if that can continue or not they can I I mean you know I so you know I guess this is coming back to the department conversation because I'm hearing in the rubric model with an English it makes sense but it doesn't make sense in science and math and so I'd like to say it's not

362all scales all students but maybe in English you know it's slightly different based on the number of scales I don't I'm not in the classroom well if you talk to some teachers they'd say in English they'd say they want a Sixpoint scale instead of let me ask this how did they deal with the situation before this year okay what did at other sites that weren't not using incompletes as often what happened there do we have any our English teer okay if they didn't pass all the scales they didn't pass all the scales right and so what I what I'd recommend is that we wait those scales number one and then number two it's up to the teacher at that point to decide are they proficient and instead of having you know one scill that they

363missed um affect them from moving on but you're still leaving it to the teacher to make that decision no I'm I I'm saying that they should take they should have again I think we're getting confused with the language every scale [Music] Nick you mentioned hey if I have 10 scales and if I take the weighted average of six that means I still pass I don't have to take the other four they still have to take the other four I'm trying to stop is the idea of you get one proficiency out of 10 that you miss and and you automatically have an incomplete that doesn't make any sense to me so it should be up to the teacher at that point to say you understand these other nine scales and you've missed this one one I'm

364passing you you get the average of that grade right and you're moving on could that teacher also say you understand these nine but you don't understand this one even though your average grade is a c yep I'm giving you anete because this one matters yeah yeah can they say that good question leave that up with the teacher so maybe there is the teacher at that point to make that determination that's what asking yeah no no I think that that's an important question I know I know you are so so maybe because I'm not hearing this issue outside of English a whole lot so I just maybe we Le leave that up to an English teacher's discretion to make that choice all skill student to determine we not focus on English and just let it up

365to all teachers making that choice all skills all students by department or by Department depart how do we feel about that I don't know I don't know how I feel about that either well I mean how does the department choose that you you have Mr Clem's gonna be he's gonna know figh against himself is it a majority I mean we're getting into a area where we're now we're pitting teachers against in the department of five of them say yes and four say no the yeses get it I mean I mean these are all the things that the nuances of it's not just as you know TR Trent using his Shrek analogy of the onion peel right I mean these are all the things that are are going to develop so yeah it for for me

366I I mean as a recommendation I would I would if if we are wanting to press pause it would be best to to press pause based upon the things that are outlined in the board policy and and the AR that are of of a conflict I would say but going back to what has been happening over the last eight years I don't really want to I wouldn't recommend changing changing that but that can come out in our committee or whatever but I feel like every decision we're making is is coming up with couple more yeah and and I would I would just add that I would I would want a uh small sliver of teachers who are willing to engage in this and keep moving in those directions and finding out you know experimenting being

367curious about the system that they could help us understand a lot of things better and and be have have the choice to do those things yeah um because I just I I I I think there's a lot of teachers who are um seeing some really positives with what's going on and they could continue in that practice and be better they will be better for them in in being involved in that practice so then maybe it cannot be a department it would have to be a personal teacher choice I think the principles will have to kind of figure out how they can get people on the same it's temporary it's temporary I mean what are your thoughts on that Bo I agree with Trent and I think we're ready to vote okay all right you know

368I feel really good about that think so so a teacher the each teacher is gonna make that decision individual decision I really don't like that doesn't sound right I know I don't like it either this is interim I know but but still what they're choosing this the weight then ultimately they get to decide you know and if if the teachers choosing the weight of the scale and they're not all Department choosing the weight of the scale right the Department's choosing the weight and So within so this is our first teacher makes the decision instead of Department that makes the decision which the department shouldn't make the decision where whether that their student passes or fails it should be the the person in the the classroom assessing them anyway the department makes the determination in terms

369of how they want to approach this inter basis right now yeah do they want you know traditional do they want work point but in this case if you only have one scale that you haven't passed and you passed all the others I think the teacher as a professional person can make that choice yeah the department out of it it's a teacher teacher knows the student yeah you have any feelings on that Jeremy I agree I agree with what dve saying yeah absolutely so this it's gonna be sticky either way yeah um it's going to be rough you know but we gota at some point we got to pull off the Band-Aid and yeah no it's go time so are we so are we going um we're we're going to say we're going back to fall

370semester the teachers will have their discretion all skills all students for passing moving forward departments are going to have their you know decisions of flexibility and um they will get to determine all skills all students on a student basis not on a um Department are we are we teacher individual basis not the department making that call are we together teachers making the call Department correct on their student on student that has all scales pass but one yeah he makes that call and and the teacher will also decide reevaluate the fall semester y ex compl yep okay um can I hear from Sarah with communication plan here I think she's got things brewing in her brain I'm positive I'm not gonna lie this sounds like a communication nightmare sorry honey um so once you make your

371decision I'm assuming that it's effective immediately so I would like to be out there letting our families and students and the rest of the staff know about what the next step is but it seems like even that the onion needs to be unraveled so you know Delo has got back to school night on sun on Monday and what are those teachers and how are they explaining to all of their families that are looking them in the eye what we're doing um I just feel like there's so much more than even you know right here and I feel like I'm GNA cry but Communications people don't do that so um you know I just feel like we need to really think about that and because I know your proponent is very much transparency and I feel

372like this is right down there so maybe there's that pause where let's figure it out before something happens so that we can make sure that we're all on the same page because I feel like again this is kind of coming out faster than I'm I don't even know how to speak to it and I'm more concerned about the teachers as they stand there looking at their parents what they're going to say as well so you know like so if there's an action taken I hope to be it that it's very clear on the timelines so that I can communicate that out to our our communities effectively thank you so much I know this is so much um you know as you were sharing about teachers you know standing in front of the families right now

373and it's very real it was very real in the fall of this semester too and and throughout that semester with kids asking them about their grades and them crying to their co-workers not being able to communicate you know the past four months too so um definitely an issue now but it's been an issue with the communication aspect this is going to be a new one for us to to you know figure out as a as a board and as a district so thank you for being aware of what's coming and we'll figure it out we'll figure it out so any other um issue we need to address before we call the motion nope do I have a motion want me to the motion would be um as an interim decision um effective immediately tonight um

374with a working group Committee created right away that will report out by June um so that I could determine can uh determination can be made for the uh fall semester of next year um um that for now we would be ABC I NC all districts would you use proficiency scales but they would have um the Departments would have discretion to choose waiting they'd also have a choice between a 4o and a 100 point scale and at this point teachers would have discretion um to determine all scales all students or not and this would be a retroactive all scales all students for NC's and eyes for last semester do I have a motion I have a first from trusty Underwood I'll second trusty Jeffrey second we have a first and a second on that very long

375motion all in favor say I I I all oppose none we passed unanimously for o all right let me find my not not here I have been taking vigorous notes and my agenda has gone awall oh here it is all right um do we have a call for adjournment item 7.1 we have a motion motion to adjourn second we have a first and a second to adjourn all in favor say I I I all oppose non-existent motion passes unanimously thank you guys very much good night well that was only two and a half hours passed I'm so sorry Tom holy moly

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.