CorpusRecord 41142

PUHSD Board Meeting 12.17.24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Placer Union
Date
2024-12-18
Location
Placer County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
21,859 words · about 122 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e okay we will call the meeting to order as the uh acting clerk I'll call the meeting to order and roll call um Claire Delaney is not here right okay Ruby's here trusty Duncan is here trusty Spade trusty Jeff and trusty Underwood is not with us tonight and Ava is here welcome everybody um before we get on with our regular business uh we will do item number two uh which is the oath of office um for our new trustees and trusty Spade is going to administer the oath for trusty Duncan correctc we do correct we have some we do have some public comment we're going to wait until after the the oath that's too late we're gonna wait till after the oath I'm sorry sir we're gonna we're going to wait till after

002the oath thank you for for and Lieutenant Connors is going to administer the oath for trusty Jeff e [Applause] we will uh need signatures from the person receiving the oath and those that are ministering the oath before you guys leave tonight we'll have those signatures and we have we go ahead and wait we do it now this one is yours sign both of those think that person for okay we do have to uh public comment for item 2.1 in the order Barbara Smith and then Ed Coons I think there three and Annie bowler it's the third one thank you thank you good evening my name is Barbara Smith I reside in the district have grandchildren in its schools and I am a retired teacher having taught for 25 years in California my classroom experience included

003an opportunity to Mentor new inexperienced teachers and as an adviser for teachers whose unsatisfactory teaching practices placed them in the peer review process removing and terminating a teacher requires extensive evidence and documentation and allows the teacher through the peer review process to improve their teaching practice a school district takes the action to terminate only when there is sufficient cause and no other remedy the sustained complaints and the findings upholding the termination of Jeff Jeremy Jeff are disturbing and concerning I hope by now all the board members have read all of the documentation surrounding Mr Jeff's term mination from this District unfortunately the voters did not have the same opportunity and I fult the Sacramento be for waiting until after the election to publish its article outlining the situation I want to direct your attention to

004this summary statement from the findings quote respondent I.E Mr Jeff misconduct constituted immoral conduct unprofessional conduct dishonesty and a persistent violation of or refusal to obey reasonable regulations prescribed by The District's governing board his misconduct also demonstrated an unfitness for service we expect our school board trustees to serve in good faith and prioritize the needs of our students over personal considerations it is appalling to have a trustee Who as a teacher failed in that mission Mr Jeff pledged not to serve in this role if elected I ask that you the board demonstrate the honor and integrity expected of our trustees and insist that Mr jeffri keep his pledge and step down from this board thank you thank you Mr Coons sorry Mr Co would you mind pushing the button on the microphone it's thank you

005and I got two grandkids that'll be going to pler Mr Jeff you were a teacher at deloro and Forest Hill until you were fired by the District For A Cause based on findings of dishonesty unprofessional conduct and mistreatment of your students those findings are contained in a 71-page report which I hold here in my [Music] hand when you campaigned for this office you made it clear that part of your reason for running for this office was to seek retribution against members of the administration and teachers whose testimony and evidence resulted in your discharge during your campaign you were contacted by a reporter from the Sacramento B who had knowledge of this report and based on that conversation you told that reporter that you were going to uh cease your campaign and that if by any

006chance you were elected you would decline to take the oak of of office you also made that statement to the Plastic County elections department and Gail ham your opponent that you would not take the oath of office but the ballots were already prepared and you had a shadow campaign where your supporters and probable violation of California fair political Practices Act did the shadow campaign and the voters really didn't know what your record was I'm here tonight to ask you I was going to ask you not to take the oath but I was prevented from speaking before you took that oath and I think that's a violation of board policy but in any case you can still step down you made a promise a a public promise that would not you would not take the oath

007of office if you have any Integrity you will step down tonight if you take the oath of office you're going to have a serious conflict of interest with respect to any Personnel matters to uh with respect to the many administrators and teachers who gave evidence uh that led to your termination you have no credibility with the teachers in this District they know why you were fired you did not act in the best interest of your students when you're a teacher we have no reason to believe that you can act in the best interest of the students as a board member now if you'd step down it's not the end of the world with the new alignment of the board there will be an appointment for the vacant position that will probably be in line with

008your own political philosophy I ask you once again for the sake of the district please step down thank you Mr KS Annie bowler hi my name is Annie Poler um before I begin I would like to be noted that at your last board meeting I was censored and was not allowed to speak on a topic and on your website it states that individuals may comment on topics not on the current agenda so in the future I'd really appreciate it if you would follow what your own policy State I am deeply concerned about the effect that Jeremy Jeff will have on our board and our district I hope that you board members will read the 2,000 page almost 2,000 pages of evidence against him and the 78 page judge decision that led to his termination the

009details that Jeffrey it details that Jeffrey was so cruel to his students that he chose they chose to go to the office rather than attend his classes it details his unwillingness to listen to administrators that he didn't follow students IEPs which is a state law and that he showed videos through much instructional time rather than actually teach and mentions that he lied with regularity his propensity toward lying was demonstrated this fall when Jeffrey when Jeffrey called his opponent and plaster elections department and announced that he was withdrawing from the race he promised his opponent that if he won he would not take the seat he took down his website and seemed to ceased campaigning but later that fall giant vote Jeffrey signs went up across the district in fact large signs went up in his

010opponent's yard three times and then they took him down and then someone put him up again which and and there were many texts with Jeff's vote jeffy's text went out to many many people Jeffrey complained he comp he said that he had nothing to do with his efforts but he was seen at a campaign fundraiser holding a Jeffrey sign so what's the truth it's your guess as good as mine the question today is Will Jeffrey prove to us that he's an honest man and and follow his word apparently not but I ask you too to step down because how can we he was terminated how how could he possibly be a good board member I spoke to Jeff last summer and after he had filed to run he expressed anger for being terminated as a

011teacher he told me he wanted to get rid of the superintendent and much of the administration of this district and so now that you're sworn in I challenge you to step down and your board to protect the good that goes on in plaster Union High School District um don't allow anyone to tear apart what's been good for our students my family like many of us have been the beneficiaries of the district's steadiness I mentioned this last week it's kindness but firmness towards teenagers it's broad-based curriculum that addresses everyone's needs there's something for everyone here and it's high expectations and support of teachers board members please protect our district is is this on item 2.1 um I just want to State the obvious that there's not a slew of teachers here complaining about Jeremy Jeff and

012that he's a good man I know not just through teaching but also through 4 and that what you read I'm retired teachers what you're reading is not all the facts so you're not seeing both sides so please give him a chance he's a good man he wants to do good he's not about to get back at anybody and congratulations [Applause] item 2.2 annual organization of phsd Board of Trustees this is our annual notification or annual organizational meeting for the purpose of selecting board officers um at this time are there nominations for the office of um new president of trusties tap the the plastic there at the bottom there we go um plastic on the on the microphone it there we go okay I figured it out um I would like to nominate uh Jessica Spade

013thank you uh second hold on one one second uh trustee Spade do you accept the nomination I accept the nomination thank you thank you we'll go ahead and entertain a motion for the appointment of nominee of the board president for the 2025 school year for um the nomination for a trustee Spade second that so trusty Jeffers would you are you making a motion yes okay do I have a second I second all those in favor I I all right passes congratulations um Madame President I'll hand you the gavel happily here you go oh boy do a pass down one thank you sir I've never used one of these so please bear with us as we navigate this thank you perfect thank you thank you Dr cametti um so we're now at this time going to

014um discuss is there any interest for Clerk or nominations for clerk I'd like to nominate Tom Duncan would you accept this nomination I will I will accept there's is there a call for motion I will move to nominate or to uh elect Mr trusty Duncan for the clerk position I second that now this is official our very first vote um all in favor are we including our student board during this process okay all in favor starting with our student board members n i all in favor board I I I those oppose student board no any obstination I don't believe so all right motion carries all right we're going to go ahead and move on here double checking the notes here that were just passed I've seen in other boards where they officially nominate or appoint

015their secretary and but that's not on our script tonight and we know who that is than you are Acting Superintendent um Dr Steve cetti but they made it official I want to say last night that's not in here is that okay I don't think so all right moving along um our organization item three um item number 3.1 welcome and Pledge of Allegiance United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all okay all right all right just a reminder that this meeting um will be audio and video video recorded and um item 3.2 approval of the agenda the board shall take action to approve the agenda any changes to the agenda shall be made at this time I ask you a quick question

016Dr Caron yes typically at consent we also discuss the items in consent before removing so this would be any changes outside of the consent agenda correct uh yeah I think we have one consent item that's been asked to to move on yes and I just heard a second so consent item 5.2 and 5.3 will address it at that time okay do I have a motion for approval of the agenda item 3.2 I'll move to approve the agenda second it's been moved and seconded to approve item 3.2 approval of the agenda all in favor starting with the student board i i i i any opposed I don't believe so motion carries unanimously item 4.1 superintendent report and showcase and at this time I'll turn it over thank you madam president um we'll start with our our

017student board report and their involvement at the csba conference and how they plan to promote our student board position thanks for being here um good morning and welcome to the new Trustees of the board this last month I had the opportunity to attend the csba conference and had the most amazing time at the conference I had the chance to learn from almost 150 student board members across the state one interesting idea that emerged from our discussions was creating an Instagram account dedicated to the student board members of the PSC District this account would serve as a platform form to keep students informed about upcoming District events as well as the initiatives and policies be developed by the board for instance before each board meeting we would post a simplified version of the agenda making it

018easier for students to understand after the meetings we'd share a summary of the key points and takeaways discussed we also plan to incorporate various media formats such as videos of us speaking and digital posters with important information additionally the account would serve as a way to amplify student voices students could engage with us by commenting on posts sending direct messages or responding to interactive story posts where they can provide Anonymous feedback or ask questions this is also something that can continue beyond this year by passing along the login information student board members for years to come could continue this if they choose to I also wanted to take a moment to discuss the promotion of next year's student board member application the Instagram would serve as the perfect platform to bring awareness to what our

019rules look like and encourage students to apply highlighting the variety of respons responsibilities and opportunities that come with being a student board member can help motivate more students to get involved and share their voices on the subject of student voice myself and the other student board student board members feel it is of the utmost importance that we continue our commitment to the three scheduled student voice meetings this year unfortunately our student voice meeting for the month of December was cancelled however I would love to work with the board and Dr cametti to ensure we reschedule it for the upcoming year the proposed student voice topic CBE is incredibly relevant and I feel it is essential for the new board to hear directly from students about their experiences and perspectives on the new curriculum and grading

020system I strongly believe that the student voice meetings are one of the best ways to continue our dialogue directly with students and allow the board to hear from a wide range of students another interesting I took away from the csba conference was learning about the lcap in California dashboard I had the chance to review the school performance overview for pler Confluence and Mau virtual Charter Academy pler was mostly in the blue and green for all categories except for mathematics and English learner progress which continue to be areas of growth ma do and confence on the other hand were both in the yellow for the grad graduation rate which I hope is also an area in which can be improved I look forward to working with administrators on at each site to see what resources we

021can offer to help students Excel I'm very excited for the upcoming year and I look forward to working with the board and super intendent to find innovative ways to address student concerns thank you thank you [Applause] Ava hi um I wanted to welcome you both to the board we are super excited to work with both of you and then as far as site happenings go we have our winter wonder week last week um with spirit days in a rally uh Mr zeros get his haircut at the rally for as a esack award for a student and um we also have impromptu Christmas Raffles throughout leadership where kids can win gift cards and all that sort of stuff as a celebration of Christmas in the um we've had two food drives one on campus through a

022club which had over 400 items donated and a larger Community food drive that was run and organized by do students which gathered 20,000 lbs of food that goes directly into a food pantry that serves the Lumis community so that was really cool to see and then as far as at Confluence it's been a pretty quiet month I did get to talk to a couple Confluence students and they said they were excited about break coming up and that um when asked about CBE they said it was actually helping them so that was interesting to hear and then then as far as the conference went um I also got to explore the lcap dashboard for do and we experienced slight declines in both Ela and math um with 10.4 and 6.9 points respectively but we remain at

0238 82.9 points above standard in ela and 6.9 points above standard uh math and the decline seemed somewhat slight so it might just be caused by natural fluctuation as different students take the test um but it's important that we continue to maintain it progress each year and I got to talk to my site principle about it and and one policy they've introduced as far as um improving in math is a math Workshop over the summer to help struggling incoming freshmen so hopefully that will imp help um that us improve in the math area on the lcap in coming years and we also maintained the graduation rate and college career categories with a blue or an excellent rating in both so that was good to see as far as the Instagram went I also got to

024talk to some student board members at the conference who got to use Instagram to share information with their peers and I'm so excited to start doing the same and I'm really hoping that accessible uh break break downs of board agendas prior to the meetings will help students understand what the board's deciding on and help them encourage participation from students as well at board meetings and then as far as student voice we were supposed to have a student voice meeting this month but it was a cancelled due to a concern about um as far as I understand a controversy during a turbulent time and I just urge the board to consider the importance of student voice meetings they are how we get a real idea of what our peers think and additionally they create a space

025for students to talk candidly about the strength and weaknesses of our campus and work with one another towards Solutions and I think it's a great time to think about what student board members are here to do especially as we consider the elections for the student or the selections for the student board members coming up in for the coming year and to help the board understand and I think the point of having student board members is help the board understand student concerns and priorities and let those concerns and priorities help inform board decisions so I think it's important when things get controversial and complicated at that's when student voice matters the most so I urge the board to continue to place value in the student perspective when things are going well but also and especially when

026they're not going well so I'm excited to continue to work with you guys and I excited to see what the rest of the year holds thanks Madam president can I ask a question I yeah why was the student voice meeting canceled I think it was just a time of controversy for the board because um it was in supposed to be scheduled for the first week of December and that was directly after there had been um some change of leadership on the board and the topic of discussion for the board was going to be CBE which is a controversial topic okay thank you all we're asking questions I was trying to write it down but I missed it what was the the math policy that was um discussed so they have in the summer there's for

027students who they are going to be struggling as incoming nth graders there's a weeklong workshop where they get to work with I think do Matthew and improving their skills before they even start so that they're hopefully at a more adequate level for high school before they even get in awesome thanks all right um so I have two board report or student board reports to read tonight so I'll start with mine and then Zoe who's our forest H rep um so again I'd like to thank you guys to the board um so first I'd like to start off with finals week this week um there's been a lot of varying feelings um with students a lot are stressed but they're definitely ready for winter break as uh I heard from Claire's report as well which is

028definitely reflected within cax um and we have a current leadership program that's going on right now where we're um offering finals first aid kits so that way students are able to have some useful things so that way they're able to prepare for finals which is a great little resource um and continuing on for next year um concerning the new board member um for this position um I've talked with a lot of different students at my school who are interested and I plan to work closely with them to sort of see um what they're feeling about and what they want to do within this position as well as just any um help I can offer um and I know that a couple of them are wishing to come to these meetings as well I know one

029is here tonight um so I wanted to welcome him but um and then continuing on uh we have our csba conference in Anaheim which was a great success and definitely a lot of fun for each of us as we got to go to Disneyland on top of the incredible conference that we were able to take part in um we learned a lot about establishing better communication with students and making sure that everyone is heard when we are having those discussions um and also fostering a great teacher relationship with students as well so that way it's a consistent sort of flow of information so that way we're able to connect there and then as Ava has said as well being able to um use that Instagram as a sort of reference with that point of you

030know establishing those better Communications with students it really offers um a lot more usefulness in terms of generating more information especially for students who are not too sure about what goes on with District proceedings or are unsure of what happens during these board meetings as well it's a lot of easy information that they're able to access which greatly helps them in terms of new policies that are coming into place and just greater information for them to base their opinions off of um and then this sort of leads into a student advisory Council so um as we were in csba we were able to talk to a lot of different students and I was able to speak to one that um implemented a council within their school so that way there's a lot of different students

031from all grades that um are able to speak to a lot of different issues within the school and um I think this is really important as student voice is definitely the drive in which we conduct a lot of policies so being able to have an advisory Council that that meets a lot more often so that way we're really able to see a lot of the student perspective as opposed to just meeting with students off um like whenever I'm seeing them in the hall and stuff like that it's not really a lot of discourse where I'm able to really get their opinion as opposed to sitting down and really collaborating with students so I've been working with my site principal and hope to present that to the staff within um the next within this upcoming year

032um so that way we can really start that advisory Council running and also increase more interest in this position for next year as well um and this sort of um continues on with the student voice meeting as well I'd wanted to um elaborate on Ava and Claire's Point too and how important student voice meetings are to um our school and every school within this District as it really advocates for what students students are hoping to you know accomplish within their time in high school and also just everything that happens with them it's a very trying time when we are dealing with a lot of stuff when we are in high school so making sure that everything is very much organized and that way our voices are heard so that way everyone knows sort of where

033we are seeing um at our schools so I'm just advocating for that and then as we reach the end of the semester I wanted to talk about the facilities that we currently have at kfax um as our bond did not pass um this past election um we've definitely seen sort of the repercussions of that um as rain is coming and the heaters are broken at our school which are being fixed currently but we have a lot of other issues with that um we have as I said heaters being um broken there's rain leaking into our Portables and we have tarps over all of our Portables currently so that way rain doesn't leak in I've seen a couple trash cans within classes so that way it can catch any draining water um there's a lot of

034disappointment about the bond obviously and that is seen within our facilities as well we'd love some 21st Century Furniture within our classrooms as there has been um a lot of instances specifically in Miss Jenkins English class where um desks have fallen apart while students have been sitting in them and it has been very dangerous especially as they're metal bars and can possibly scratch students and harm them um so yeah just bringing up these topics before the upcoming year is really important especially as we're in the midst of winter um and hopefully it won't be as bad of a winter that we saw about two years ago but we'll see um so that concludes my report so I'd like to move on to AA or sorry Zoe's report for Forest Hill um so hi everyone this

035is from Zoe's perspective by the way hi everyone I'd like to extend a welcome to the new and current board members I'm so excited to continue to work with you all to act as a liaison for student voices and provide input on decisions that directly impact our students we are so thankful that the board has these student board member positions available as a way to listen to student voices that being said the applications for next year's student board members will be opening in the next few months and we will definitely be working to promote this role to the students at our respective schools I plan to talk with students to encourage them to apply for this role and place a flyer within our school's newsletter to alert students of where to find the application as

036well as the deadlines on another on another note the four student board members were recently able to attend the California School Board Association conference in Anaheim where we had a chance to attend a session with about 150 other student board members from across the state of California from this experience I found it really neat to hear all of the different ways in which the student board members operated within their roles and the numerous ways in which each district utilized the student board member to act as a liaison between the student body and the Board of Trustees for example there was one student who spoke about how her school had a council of students with each grade level at the different schools within the district within this Council students were able to bring up key concerns

037to their student board members who would then report back to The District board additionally any presentations that we that were to be brought before the board at a meeting would be first be heard by the Council of students who would provide feedback on the presentation as a way for the district to have more student input in their operations we also spoke to a student board member who had started an Instagram account for her role in which she posts numerous updates board agendas and videos to help the larger student body and Community better understand her role and become more aware of the board agenda and key items that were discussed during the meeting we believe that this would be a great addition to the student board members role as it will help the students within the

038district to have a better understanding of our district board in terms of events that are happening on our campus both our girls and basketball teams have concluded preseason and started League this week we also have our school play going on tonight which is put on by our drama class unfortunately I am not able to go but I was able to sit in on their dress rehearsal yesterday and they all did a great job and I'm very confident that their show tonight will be absolutely amazing lastly our leadership class is putting on a cookies and cram event for finals week where students can come to the library after school and have cookies and hot chocolate together while they study for finals and that's all for Forest Hill thank you yeah thank you student board um um

039some updates that I would need some direction from um president Spade uh February 25th is a scheduled special board meeting that was supposed to be on board governance with Dr Peggy Lynch um staff would need some direction as to whether or not we still proceed with um using the services of Dr Peggy Lynch um having another Topic at the discretion of what the board would like to to see but that's already scheduled for February 25th we just need some direction as to what the board would like to to do on that it's our one of our annual special meetings um you heard from our students about uh student voice um there are some options April 9th April 23rd April 30th to reschedule the Miss December um voice meeting and again I can elaborate on um

040missing the um student voice there was some obvious change in leadership in this seat that where I'm at right now I did not feel appropriate putting our students in a situation to where they were um caught off guard so that was that was my call to make that decision of not have the student voice but we'd like to have that um in April to keep them have them be whole for their student voice meetings um upcoming events if you didn't know next week starts uh winter break and we are all excited about that um school returns back for our second term at January 6 and we pick right up with back to school nights um our important lcap Community forums uh deloro is on the 13th kfax on the 27th of January then Forest H

041till on February 24th and pler on um February 25th our next scheduled board meeting is um January 21st um and we do want to welcome I don Manning our uh new director of Maintenance and operations here for PL Union High School District Welcome and this concludes my [Applause] report thank you very much Dr caminetti um is that something that we should discuss at this time or is that something at the February 25th board governance event for providing um whatever you would like to however you'd like to direct um it's it's scheduled we're contracted I don't think we've we've paid Peggy at this point um remember at the beginning in the fall we had a special meeting on facilities and budget um and then typically that that spring or that February is uh for Budget um

042and board governance but it can be a topic at the discretion that you feel like okay the direction of of where' you like to move the staff okay um I definitely we we certainly need some trainings um uh csba um our our new elected trustees we're we're unable to attend csba this round and so you know maybe it's something to consider and we do we do we have a timeline if we were going to lock in um Peggy well she's already already scheduled and reserved I I believe to be there there on the 25th okay obviously we're going to have to discuss some facilities and some um alternate plans based on our last meeting because of the bond and so obviously that needs to be addressed the facilities need to be addressed and certainly some

043workshops regarding governance and um and building our new team here so I'm I'll let you guys sleep on that and and direct your thoughts to Steve and we'll we'll figure that out is that all right okay all right moving along to item five um consent agenda items there are a couple changes there 5.2 draft minutes from the special meeting conducted on November 18th 2024 at the regular and the regular meeting conducted on November 19th um so there are two little sets in 5.2 we'll move that to our first action item trustey jeffes you wanted to move item 5.3 you had some clarifications or questions corre as well okay so with those changes do we have a motion to approve item number five I'll move to approve the consent agenda items minus 5.2 and 5.3 second

044hearing a first and a second on item five consent agenda items all those in favor starting with student board hi hi board I I I seeing that all members have already voted that is passed unanimously we'll go to 5.2 as our first agenda item so this is a conversation that I had with Dr cetti regarding some um inconsistencies not with uh the special board meeting minutes but actually with the November 19th the the regularly scheduled meeting and a while back we started shifting um when I first joined the board every comment that was made would would say um the trustees name and at that time I remember having a conversation with our former superintendent that we're going to omit the names it's just kind of General comments and it'll just say trusty and then the

045comments made and um and so I think I'm not sure exactly when that shifted it was like maybe summertime or something um I'd have to go back and look anyway but throughout this one um we had some inconsistencies with some of some of the time it was trusty and sometimes it was called out there was um public comment on page 11 community members 2 and five that I just wanted to discuss potentially um reording or or clarification um one of them stated that I sto the speaker um and then begin my commentary but I wanted to make sure that the facts were delineated there that I actually um um called for a point of order to president brandham at that time and then discussed my reasons for my point of order and opened it up

046to the board to consider um obviously the thoughts on that and then um our president board president um said Thank you and released the speakers it also happened again with um named uh named me on five Community member um five of that page and SAR situation point of order and the board president ultimately dismissed the speaker but it also happened on Community member three which wasn't notated but because I didn't um I wasn't the one that that stopped the speaker it was actually stopped by president brandham at that time um and she with that um knowledge that she would be dismissed if she would continue to speak outside of the jurisdiction of the board she then changed her commentary so I'm not sure if we need to list that or not whether or not um

047that President brandham stopped the third speaker and then the speaker went on a different course but I think that it's important to note that they were point of orders number two and five to the board president and dismissed and number three was also stopped by President brandham you have any thoughts on that board so just a point of clarification uh you're you're asking for a revision on those two items yep and then uh so it would be Community member 2 3 and 5 on page 11 so in that order if we're counting them 1 2 three and then uh moving forward is there a direction how the board would like to proceed yeah do you guys have a feeling whether or not um by law I believe that we only have to have really our

048motions the the comments are not required um so summaries and we're keeping our recordings now so people could go back and look at that um do you guys have a feeling one way or another to uname you know the unknown trustees with their comments or would you like the trustees named or to carry on this way and I guess also with 25 and three do we want to just say truste interrupted or do we want to say I interrupted and president grantom interrupted and then moving forward does that make sense my recommendation would be to go without the names okay yeah I'm I'm fine with that okay yeah so um with amendments I'm sure that will be handed handled offline um to remove uh trusty names from the comments and community members two and five

049um and in addition to that they were points of order directed to the board president who dismissed the speakers with those changes do we have a motion I move approval of 5.2 do we have a second second item 5.2 draft minutes from the special meeting conducted on November 18th 2024 and the regular meeting conducted on November 19th draft minutes captured from the special meeting conducted on November 18th 2024 and the regular meeting conducted on November 19th 2024 by PSD Board of Trustees Court um all in favor starting with the student board I board I I and all abstain since I wasn't at the meeting Robert's Rules allows members who were not there to participate if you so choose okay no oppose and we have one abnation now question for that we don't have a quum

050if you don't vote trusty je I'll vote in favor okay all right thank you moving on to item 5.3 it gets tricky when you only have three members here it's majority no matter how many members are here for those who are wondering what we're talking about up here all right item 5.3 District issued warrants trustey Jeff you had questions on this item I did who can answer these questions is it Peter Sue budget and County who was here too as well I just had some uh questions about some of these line items I just kind of wanted a little bit more clarification before uh the board was to vote um there there's two okay sorry there's two attachments so let me know which one you're referring to correct um is the checks from 124 or

051the check from 11:20 124 okay correct 124 so my first question there is the $29,000 go into ctm sound Inc can you clarify what that was um I do believe it's going to be either for Dela or kofax there was money for kofax money that was donated to the school and then we provided some through facilities to I believe it was for their gym or for the athletic field I forget the gym perfect thank you my next question just curious which gym the main gym at kfax Bonner okay yeah not Bonner that's Doo cax oh sorry you're talking pooi poochi Pavilion okay my next question is there I notice on the same pay warrant there are um four um District administrators with relatively significant payments coming to them and I'm curious what those payments are

052for port dland for example is one of them $5,700 Matthew riobo $6,200 Chris strickler for $2,000 and Jeffrey Walters for $4,000 all district administrators so I think M delabo has an idea yes so that is reimbursement for their clearing of their CR credential there um there is a u effective s what was the title of that Grant effective oh educator Effectiveness educator Effectiveness that requires that we pay for their clearing of their credential so um previously our um practice was to pay for half of it well when we discovered that we needed to pay for the entire thing those are the warrants that paid off their um from for certain specific years so 2022 to present they are fully PA paid through this grant okay thank you that's all the questions I had all right

053item 5.3 District issued warrants do we have a motion I'll move to approve I second All In favor starting with student board to approve the 5.3 District issued warrants approval of monthly monthly District issued warrants vendor purchase orders and change order listings I hi hi I promise this will get better it will that we can hope we can hope motion passes all right we're cruising to our action items okay item 6.1 certificated Personnel report number five 20 uh 4 to 25 yes madame president uh so this is our certificated Personnel report as you can see we are still onboarding substitute teachers we have a number of our staff that are doing additional duties and the stiens are outlined there and I absolutely want to recognize um and give our appreciation um for his long standing

054in our district Mike Paul is retiring at the end of the school year and we do want to thank him for his service to our students in our district on the behalf of the superintendent I would recommend the approval of the certificated Personnel report do I have a motion I'll move to approve I second all right it's been uh first and seconded item 6.1 certificated Personnel report number 52024 24 through 25 changes in status of certificated Personnel support um do we have any discussion on this item uh no discussion but I did want to point out that Greg kelderman um longtime and beloved uh teacher at deloro is retiring this month this week I should actually so in addition to Mr Paul he will be missed yes he will he's amazing all right all in

055favor starting with student board I I board I I I all oppos no abstention motion carries 6.2 classified Personnel report number 52425 changes in status of classified Personnel yes Madam President we have a number of um onboarding of our athletic coaches and our um volunteers we continue to have a number of individuals that are so willing to support our students and all the different activities that they participate in um with including Don is on this uh classified Personnel report so we want to thank her for joining us um we have a couple of students that have onboarded as well to be student tutors um we do want to thank Mike dine for his um service to our district um on the behalf of the superintendent I would recommend the approval of the classified Personnel order

056do I have a motion motion to approve a second do we have any discussion yes question mhm um Helena I did have a question here on this is the classified Personnel report um Bridget faren is listed here um two two-part question I suppose first of all I thought she was a certificated teacher and also it says the position she's being assigned to as athletic trainer can you explain that for me yes so a number of these positions are classified positions an athletic trainer is one of those so even if she's a certificated individual it doesn't mean that she can't hold um a position that comes up on the classified the athletic trainer is you're asking a great question because it is a new law that is going into play um at the end of our

057um collective bargaining agreement which will be um June 30th um there will be a change that anybody with athletic trainer has to meet very specific guidelines to be called an athletic trainer but prior to that as long as they're still with within that um bargaining agreement they get to maintain that title for this period of time so um after that any individual that's actually given the title of athle trainer will have to meet those guidelines but because she meets it through being grandfathered in being under this collective bargaining agreement she may main maintain that continued position she teaches um the CTE course sports medicine and the students that work under her work with the um athletic teams great question and thank you for that do we suspect any issues with this change in June 30th

058to maintain that position yes we do great okay but there are alternatives and our other school sites do utilize other Alternatives through EMTs um volunteer Physicians uh other medical personnel that volunteer to uh support the team so um at our last athletic director's meeting that was a topic of discussion and there was a lot of discussion that um went around that so moving forward um Mrs Butler will be looking at alternatives to support the the group at um deloro the students will continue to be able to go through the CTE pathway okay okay great thank you all right we have a first and a second on action item 6.2 classified Personnel report number 52425 starting with the student board all in favor I I board I I has voted motion passes item 6.3 teaching outside

059credential pursuant to Education Code section point3 yes Madam president um at this time as we've discussed in the past um we do because of the nature of our district and the size of our district um we do have teachers who have experience knowledge um that will teach outside of their credential area they do have to go through a process it's a um a group typically the department chair of that um like so the math department chair or the math teacher um also signs off with the principal and other members to identify that this individual demonstrates the knowledge and the skill to be able to teach um I believe that they're working specifically at with high risk students to get them um P integrated one and um at this point they're recommending that he be able

060to teach under the local board authorization of integrated for integrated math one and so on behalf of the superintendent I would recommend the approval of this local board authorization thank you do I have a motion for item 6.3 I'll move to approve I second do we have we have a first and a second on item 6.3 do we have any questions or discussion all right seeing none item 6.3 teaching outside credential pursuant to Education Code section 4425 8.3 all in favor starting with the student board hi board I I I uh motion carries 6.4 2024 2025 tenative agreement with Associated teachers of plaster CTA Nea ATP yes um Madam President we met and negotiated on the articles of safety and dual enrollment uh the tenative language um is in the documents that were attached with

061the safety um it's specific to the wearing the name badges on our school campuses this was to ensure that at any time individuals on the campus can identify who are not members of the staff and just asked them to check in at the office um additionally it was for any type of emergency um they know who to identify as members of the staff people students in individual would be able to know that these are staff members that they could seek out and to receive support and uh the dual enrollment language was to clarify for um all members that um that we were not supplanting our staff with any additional courses that are provided through our local community colleges and so that language assures them of that is not a supplant um it is a supplement

062so on the behalf of the superintendent I would recommend the approval of those uh proposed changes in tentatively agreed upon and ratified by um the ATP all right do we have a motion motion to approve I'll second do we have any questions or yes comments so Elena with respect to the first mou on safety my question is simply that if we are asking all the staff members to wear their IDs as a result of on campus security why are we not also asking our students to do the same for the same reason that certainly has that certainly could be something that could be discussed in the future at this point our Focus this was a negotiation item that was specific to staff and to ensure that our students would know how to identify staff and

063our visitors to our um campuses would know how to identify staff okay and my second question um is with respect to the dual enrollment mou um and really I have some concerns with just one area and that is the third bullet pointed item where it looks like you crossed out however if students wave for per rights so as it read that that paragraph reads now um with that um reduction it seems like it would be uh misleading to our staff uh what their responsibilities are under the law and if you do a quick 30 second Google search on furpa rights um you will know that any student that that um enters the post-secondary system which includes Sierra College um dual enrollment teachers cannot by law uh speak to those parents without a waiver from that

064student uh that being the case um this leads me to believe that um with the writing here that the teachers might read through this and think that they were obligated to contact those parents uh and that again being a case they would be violating the law so you're leaving those teachers open for liability as well as the district um whereas you know I don't know why that that line was crossed out in the first place if that line was still there I think it would alleviate those concerns I had um and it's for that reason alone um that I'm I would recommend to the board to not approve this uh this mou at this time uh until that rewarding takes place um since negotiations is a group effort and we address this with our expertise

065from our different members I'm going to ask um Trent to assist me in addressing your concern concerns and questions on this topic yeah so the uh rule the basically the Department of Education has Bas has said and Sarah college has said that uh Sarah college teachers uh share information with the with with the school and then uh we can share information with parents and uh the students off of that uh we've had this conversation multiple times with Sarah College um so the the real issue was making ensuring that our students uh you know if if they were their grades and those kinds of things we could share with our students uh they have an agreement that they get to share grades with the school the school shares it with us so the the the furpa

066is on us there's no violation if you do a quick 30 second search on the uh furpa from uh uh for the Department of Ed it'll say that they that we could share information with our our parents and students H um it's curious because I actually did that research just yesterday I I I'll share the the document with you appreciate that yep the um I recall um and this is a while back because it came up that that uh students that I believe it was the paperwork that the parents signed for them attending the dual enrollment at that at that point you know their that their only communication was to the student into the site and so it was my understanding that the parents um entered that knowing that the communication would stop there um

067it would only be to the school and then you guys report to the families so there was and this is a kind of a separate issue but in the same family sorry no you're good so a while back I remember and I and I'm wondering if this is kind of like circumventing or a similar situation I remember us um approving a document where that the parents are signing you know for them to attend the course and then at that point that the college only communicates with the student but is also communicating and relaying that to you guys to communicate with us but there was a separation is that in the in the same bullet essentially because you guys are the communicating party not the community college and the parents knew that signing up their student

068for that course I I believe I believe you have it have it right that's a long way to get there yeah I know all right um I have another question yep go ahead so Trent do the Sierra College teachers that teach Sierra College classes on our campuses do they communicate with directly with parents no so again why is that exception being made for our dual enrollment staff I the reason I asked is I was a dual enrollment instructor through crer college for a number of years and they were very very clear with us at the trainings that we were not allowed to talk to parents about student anything do with students unless that student is way assigned to so has that changed in the last 10 years about uh teachers talking to parents without the

069waiver process and all that um I don't think so um I think what has changed is our ability to what Sarah's position was that we're we're we could share with parents all of the information that we have does Sierra College have the legal authority to allow us to circumvent furpa does CR College have what does Si College have the authority to allow our staff to circumvent state law with respect to furpa we're not um circumventing furpa um what we've been doing is uh the the teachers have been communicating to us uh their grades we've been communicating with um and and anything in the class we've been communicating that with um the parents so you're saying you communicated with the parents but this the teachers did not is that what you're saying uh correct whatever information

070that that we get we can then share with parents okay because why why does it say unit members will be expected to communicate unit members being teachers I I I think we were Our Hope was that as uh teachers of our students that they would be uh communicating with our students um in the uh in their parents and and partnering with our parents to uh help get those kids uh the education they that they need um and there had been some uh instances that had came up where we had no idea that students were possibly failing a class parents didn't have an idea and um we wanted to prevent that from happening in the best interest of our students so it it really came down to what was in the best interest of our students

071yeah and and I totally understand I have a sophomore in the district I completely understand and I totally support parents understanding what's going on however I don't think we should be putting our teachers in a position where they're potentially breaking the law may I ask a question regarding um so this process did this also go through legal and was approved by legal um this agreement no um but it does Clearly say that you have to continue to follow furpa guidelines okay that is still in the yeah um Lang yeah I feel comfortable moving forward with this knowing that it's still saying that we're we're following fura guidelines um I it's certainly not my my expertise or profession um I didn't work as a teacher um prior to be serving as a board member so I

072I see your concerns and understand that as well trusty uh Duncan do you have any thoughts on that uh the the biggest thing for me was if if the furpa rights were being violated but if if not then typically the the it's the students rights that they're concerned about um feels like we're trying to protect the teachers in this situation and I understand that but it's really most of the time that we've had this experience that the the students are waving their rights to to talk with uh uh so their their parents could engage with the um with the with the parents and or with the teach uh if you guys want to change that and prevent parents from having that access uh you could change the the board policy that's currently in there in

073the Ed code that says that our teachers will that the parents do have a right to communicate with their students regarding their progress in class that is a parent right outlined in the Ed code and in our board policy if you guys want to take that on and and and change that for for dual enrollment and say that if a student uh does wave their right it still precludes the teachers to not engage with the parents uh based off the D do you can do that just for the record that's not what I was suggesting okay I'm just telling you what your options are okay now I definitely support keeping um the lines of communication open so with that in mind do we have a motion for item 6.4 I Mo I uh move to

074approve I second that excuse me 6.5 what did I just say thank you Dez six six is it 6.4 or 6.5 oh oh you're good I'm a rookie oh you know wa I think you're right we we had a first and a second yeah that was a nice long conversation no we got there we got there thank you for that okay so we have a first and second on item 6.4 I'd like to call um for all in favor student board I I um board I I I'll oppose no no all right now with that being said so motion fails is this something um just moving forward so we know what to do here um because essentially obviously this isn't moving forward so this will have have to uh go back I guess and be

075brought back before the board at a regular meeting correct yep it will require negotiation correct um it has been ratified by the union because again the protections of following the furpa guidelines was in that language yes um so uh upon your direction if it is that we just bring it back to another um board meeting um or are you directing us to go back to the table um I would feel comfortable bringing it back to the next board meeting is and we can discuss it at that time I'm confused with the direction is to staff if it's has been voted down the only way to change the wording is to negotiate correct Elena if we're going to change the wording yes but I didn't understand that they were recommending that I I wasn't requesting a

076a change of the wording um we have three members of a five member board here and at the next session we're going to have more than three members I'm just confused did it was two to one vote correct so it failed on a 2 to one vote for has to be a majority of the board so it's always out of five and unfortunately yeah no yeah no thank you for clarifying that so yeah yeah and a five member board you have to have three to pass no matter what so we'll bring it we'll bring it back to the next got it thank you all right moving to item 6.5 memorandum of understanding between PSD and the California School Employees EMP Association CSA addressing the classified School Employees summer assistance program mou between the PSD and

077C sea which addresses the classified school employee summer assistance program yes I think you did it so um we've been uh participating in the summer assistant program I think this is our fourth year um the state uh every year will identify if they will be provid in funds to it's a matching fund system for our um classified staff that work 11 months or less they can sign up to do this they take a percentage of their income out of their check and then the state provides a matching fund amount um they give us that to that amount every year what it will be it's not always a dollar to dollar sometimes it's an 85 cents to on the dollar type of um situation um this has been a helpful tool for our class classified staff

078members we've increased in our enrollment every year so uh this is a very similar mou to the ones that we've had the last um four years the one updated change is that instead of bringing it forth every year we've added language that allows us as long as the state has identified that they will be um providing this uh funds that we will ongoingly provide this program to our um staff there is a cost um in our employees work to do provide that and a little bit of cost for um the additional liability cost for this for our staff but it's been it outweighs the benefits to the staff that work 11 months or less and don't receive checks 12 months of the year so on the behalf of the superintendent I would recommend um the

079approval of this mou which has been ratified by the CSA unit members and that's been quite the process trying to get getting um not the ratification getting the people up in CA we we now have another new um substitute uh representative they they do seem to be going through their representatives at this point great all right um item 6.5 memorandum of understanding mou between PSD and the California school board employees Association do we have a motion I move to approve I'll second all right do we have any questions or discussion all right I'm hearing then we have a a first and a second on item 6.5 memorandum of understanding between the PSD and the California school board ass uh employees Association CA addressing the classified school employee summer assistance program mou between the PSD and

080CSA which addresses the classified school employee summer assistance program all in favor student board I I I board I I I motion carries all right item 6.6 resolution number 10 2425 accounting of annual developer fee report and fiveyear findings for 2023 2024 yes Madam president um what you have present in front of you is again the annual report and the five-year report of developer fees uh these are monies that are collected whenever um residential or commercial construction is happening within our district boundaries um the current rate for residential is 2.07 $2.7 a square foot and I do believe the uh current rate is 34 cents or 33.8 for commercial uh this money is deposited in what's called fund 25 for facilities uh specifically uh growth generated from development and basically the increased Demand on school

081facilities in this report you'll see monies that have been spent um within the district for various uh facility projects um at different School sites and here at the district office and along with the fiveyear report showing where the board has approved allocation of two projects in the future the kofax track and field and the Boon parking lot project at deloro um attached to this is the five-year annual report and the resolution attesting to that and on behalf of the superintendent we recommend approval all right I just had a quick question I was reading through these earlier and um H how are these two do prioritize that the uh the Boyington LW and um board Direction always board Direction board Direction correct okay yeah U we mentioned earlier about that meeting in February that's coming up

082there'll be some more of that conversation but bton has been on genda for well over a year um we first came to the board with a proposal of some idea they then directed me to look into more of the engineering once we got an idea of the engineering I then directed to move forward with an architect come up with plans we have currently met with the architect in the engineer um sometimes not sometimes pardon me when something relevant comes up I'll present some more information through fight facts right now we are in the middle of working with architect coming with a design plan we had a DSA pre-application meeting about a week ago um at that point in time to really figure out what would be the cost of the plan to develop that whole

083parking lot um looking at different things there was an idea of do you need to build a concession stands do you have to do path of travel from the parking lot to the campus is a fire lane required all those things that the board directed us to finally look into because that parking lot has always been for best letter of term you know the bane of the existence out there at deloro and so I was directed to keep looking into it and uh the 1.8 is to cover all of that you want to call pdsa check type of items engineering architect I I don't think we'll use all 1.8 to get there which we then allocate towards the construction currently we are looking at the entire area from the beginning of the stadium all the

084way down to Boyington um it did include the possibility of a future CTE building that's still part of the plan to show what the infrastructure would cost to put it in not necessarily the building we know that would be well beyond our means right now um but I want to be able to propose to the board at least what the findings would be if we considered infrastructure in that that would be part of the proposal when we get there that more to follow because this will be this would be a very big project obviously because when's the window to do the paving considering the business of that school yeah yeah it's going to be tough thank you uh I moved to approve second all right it's been moved in second do we have any further

085questions discussion all right um we have a first and second on item 6.6 resolution number 10 2425 accounting and an of annual developer fee report and fiveyear findings for 2023 2024 um it's a resolution so it's a roll call vote starting with our student board there hi i i i i all right um any opposed no motion carries unanimously all right item 6.7 consider 2024 first interim budget report and accomp accompanying certification hi good evening everyone uh president Spade trustees student board members and Dr cetti I'm here to present the uh District's first interim budget report um it's through October 31st I also want to point out this is a summary review of IT these slides I'm going to be going through all the detail is in the attachment that was also part of the

086the agenda on the next slide I'm going to first go over our general fund revenues as you can see here our local control funding which is the main source of revenues coming in at about 50.4 million um altogether our revenues are 62.9 so of that makeup we have some federal restricted funding um some other state restrict Ed funding some other state unrestricted funding and then we have our other local funding um of the state unrestricted funding that's usually what we can use most of it on it's mostly made up of Lottery as well as the mandated cost block grant that we get from the other state restricted funding um there's a lot of things involved in that there's a lottery that's restricted to instructional materials um there's our proposition 28 Arts and Music and a

087few other grants um that are in there there's also a chunk of 2.5 million which is our stirs on behalf which is offset in the expenditures it's just an in and an out it's one of the new laws on the next slide I'll go over our general fund expenditures it's about 68.3 million as you can see our classified salaries um our cert certificated salaries and our benefits make up about 82% of those expenditures you also have books and supplies some Capital outlay um and services and operating expenditures the other outgo um is what about 1% and that is a net effect of every year uh we have to pay out our Sela cost it's the bill back uh this year we're projecting it to be $1.1 million to pay back for our SOA sorry quick

088question how's that compared to years past it just continues to go up I could get those numbers for you but it's just more analytical yeah um on the next slide is our contributions from our general fund to to other programs as you can see special education the federal and state programs are 4.3 million uh general f contribution um of that the federal makes up about 225,000 the state about 63,000 so what that means basically is the state and the federal cannot keep up at the cost of special ed our routine maintenance we're required 3% we try and keep it at that so that is the 3% 1.7 million and then we have some miscellaneous site and Chromebook protection plan contributions was happen throughout the year of only about 24,000 so in total we're we're contributing

089to other programs $6.1 million then we have some transfers in every year we have an administrator fee we can pull from fund 25 which is the developer fee that's about 41,000 we also have a transfer from our fund 17 which is our Tech endowment we transfer 96,000 that helps by you know the Chromebooks and and those types of things for the incoming students on the next slide here's our components of our ending general fund balance as you can see our beginning balance is 11.5 million you can see our revenues expenditures and our deficit spending of 5.4 million then we also have other financing sources so our net increase is about a decrease rather is 5.1 million off that fund balance of 11.5 so the ending balance we're projecting is 6.4 million right now and then

090you can see the makeup of those we have the restricted Balan is those restrict Ed funds designated for specific purposes about 2.8 million um and then we have our reserve for economic uncertainties which is 3% and we have about 1.5 million left over on the next slide we'll go over Mau the Virtual Academy this is a Qui quick snapshot of their revenues and expenditures this year um they're ending they're projected to with an ending fund balance of about $380,000 this year um so and part of that of that the restricted piece of it is about 153,000 so they still have about 228,000 so they're doing well their their enrollments been increasing on the next side we have all our other funds so we have our Student Activity fund that's our Associated student body fund um

091we're projecting about a million dollar ending fund balance that changes throughout the year um we have our adult education fund which is fund 11 we're projecting uh them to to end with about 148,000 our cafeteria fund again ending in the black it's been doing very well about 1.1 million and then our deferred maintenance fund right now we're showing about 261,000 but I'm projecting that to be spent down probably by the end of the year because we have some things in mind for that on the next slide is fund 17 this is our Special Reserve fund this is kind of like the savings we we designate the board design certain things for these so for like our technology endowment this is part of what we pull the 96,000 from the current balance in there is 3.5

092million uh the state uncertainty Reserve is down to 1.3 million and then we have our per St stabilization trust due to the increase basically in purs right now but the increase in cost for the stirs and purs the retirement of about 689 th000 the district has done real well in the past years to be able to great that fund it's really helped we go into our building funds so fund 21 the building fund has about uh altogether our building funds have about 1.4 million these bonds are almost done deloro measur D they got about 7500 left we're hoping uh to finish that uh plaster High School measure G has about 1.4 million and that's that's being used as well on some other funds we're going to we have quite a few funds as you know

093in the district we have our Education Foundation fund for the scholarships for the students fund 19 we have about a 3.4 million balance in there we also have our Capital facilities fund 25 which we get from develop fees we're showing about ending balance of about 31,000 and that will change throughout the year just because Revenue comes in at all different times we have our fund 40 our Special Reserve for Capital outlay we have about uh ending balance 10.1 but what isn't reflected here because it was received afterwards is another match 1.2 million that'll be reflected in second interim so that's good news and then we have the retiree beneit benefit fund which has about 562 th000 which helps pay for the retiree costs next I'd like to go into the multi-year projections this is the

094fun part um the assumptions used where basically we get from school Services of California um January is when we go to the governor's budget so this could all change depending on what he has to say um as you can see I've outlined what our local control funding formula lcff is expected to receive through through the next three years as you can see this year we had a reduction of 500,000 um that's due to the cola really being less than it was last year too our enrollment projections obviously we're in a declining enrollment um so we go we're going from 3823 down to 3761 hoping that changes but you never know um and then the entitlement per per student per Ada as you can see the amounts are going up a little bit each year um

095it's still you know we feel it's not keeping up with the costs um and then the number of student to teacher ratios as you can see that's been implemented to help save over the next three years we also have federal and state one-time Grant expenditures as you know we got a lot of onetime dollars um in the last four years they're being spent they're going to be gone in the next year or two so this these dollar amounts are going to be have to transfer over to the general fund they're going to have to be moved um and that's going to be a problem in the oute so we're working together to try and really figure out how we can maintain all this um and then our transfer from fund 17 that's the the pars

096the stir purs you know that's just the estimated amount that's going to cost with those increases so on the next slide is our assumptions for the general fund projection for the next this year and the next two years as you can see our our beginning fund balances are there at the top and what we're ending as I pointed out for this year 1.5 million um 25 2025 and 26 um we're still deficit spending not as much but we're still deficit spending it's 2.9 Million so that's reducing the fund balance again unless things change with the state um we're still able to meet the uh 3% economic uh um uncertainty so that it leaves us a balance of $430,000 and then in 2627 as of right now it leaves a balance of about 310,000 um this

097is what we have as of right now I guarantee you this will change when I present second interim so I'm projecting a positive first interim budget report which is what we want um so we'll meet our finan financial obligations for the current and subsequent two years and we recommend the board this as a positive first interim budget report what's up next well there were some articles that came out lately um as far the Lao the legislative analyst office he is projecting well they are projecting rather it was a man talking to me um that the F fiscal Outlook is looking at our Cola was projected to be 2.93 next year they're thinking it's com in a little lower at 2.46 and even though our state revenues are increasing from the taxes in the that it's

098still with proposition um 98 even though we're getting more Revenue there's the law that the uh the state will be uh required to deposit the funds into the reserve because the governor's been pulling monies from the reserves to help the K12 education so in January again like I said we'll be attending the governor's budget to hear their education policies and proposals and to see how that affects us in the out years as well as current year I don't think anything is going to change current year but it will be changing in the out years is there any questions y slide 10 for me correct can you explain again what uh fund 19 is you said it was scholarships and there's $3.4 million sitting there yeah those are um scholarships that were set up and the

099money was uh given to the district as donations there's the Gibb scholarship um what other ones are there I I can't to provide a little bit more detail oh jeez um this money was given well over ades ago a bulk of it to kofax high school um but it's a combination of a few different scholarships where interest is earned and then paid out to students it was in the pler County Treasury earning barely 1% we created this foundation so we could earn more interest off of it and we are seeing the fruits of that um I will be talking more to the board about that in January February because um as Miss bade knows president spay excuse me um we have lost one of the members who was on what's called our investment committee um

100we also have to appoint uh members to that Foundation because this current board is the board members for the foundation so more will come on that but it was made a decision board several years ago to create the foundation so as to promote more interest it's in safe accounts so we're not risking money per se but I can earn one I we could earn one or three to four that's a lot more of scholarships for our students basically what kind of scholarships does a district offer to students uh it's all through the schools mostly um a lot of it is for I mean in general and kofax talk more about it any kids going to trade schools U junior colleges all this thing I think they've gotten really good at I say streamlining the application

101process it was very onerous years ago um and so I think they've got much better at it a lot of them go through applications interviews um at kofax Alone um you know you could have of a senior class of 130 100 kids getting some kind of scholarship somewhere and I can speak to that a little bit as I'm in the scholarship process currently um we have a lot of different ranges we have on our um kfax High School website a list of all the scholarships that are offered so that way you can get um a little bit of a better idea of what we offer because it is such a large range I mean some that I've applied to it's you have to have a 3.5 GPA or higher you have to check these boxes

102I know there's photography scholarships um there's ones for being like involved in different activities within school and like within ASB and stuff like that at kfax so it is a large range of things especially like CTE Pathways as well so yeah also to note that this is not money that we spend every year it's off the interest that we give the scholarships that's why these people give these big endowments um there are scholarships that come through the schools money comes in money goes out um families come in and I want $5,000 to go to three kids and then the money's all expended at one time but this is the big one that earns interest is hence why we wanted to put it in in accounts that would earn more interest thank you my son was

103a recipient of one of those scholarships years ago love that thank you so much Susan you did a great job your first official sorry I had one one question just on the enrollment obviously that's the concern with with budget decline yeah um how are we forecasting out in the in the future years that there is a drop in enrollment is like we receive a lot of information from the feeder schools um so we get that information of what their expected enrollment is and then we we have a a it's called a cooh so we average out the last three years and determine what that increase or decrease could be through the out years and some of the metrics that go into that are just decline in building or what what are some of those things

104that are being that are being seen from uh from the feeder schools the feeder School declining just decline in building and housing oh I don't see any yeah we're not how that well yeah obviously we need housing to have families come into our district and that's I think that's one of the big issues right now is that affordable housing is not available in our district for single you know for family you look at the the feeders um coming in you'll see like a third grade class a fourth grade class at 400 but the first grade class the second grade class are at 350 Yeah by default you're only you're dropping and so there is some projected building What's called the cresley development at the corner of Sierra College and Rockland buard and then bigford but

105you know I don't know who's going to move into there and when that's going to happen and so I could tell you that they're going to build 350 units and we might get 100 kids from there we would be irresponsible for us to project that in there because we don't know if they're going to be all elementary kids you don't know that yet and so we go off of that information there's not a perfect science to it it's really hard yeah I think that that's like that sums up this whole the finances it's not a perfect science I feel like you have to be part psychic to know what's really coming down the pike um and you did a great job yeah obvious concerned about these out years and what we're going to do I

106mean that's that's a huge huge decrease over the past couple of years I'm grateful we can still meet our 3% economic Reserve our former board we had a former board member here they were uh really diligent about um fiscal responsibility and saving and so you know in honor of that and keeping keeping the boat afloat um yeah I'm curious to see I definitely think that we you know as a very green board need some more Finance workshop and really kind of dig into how all of this this works so that we're all on the same page it's complicated and even being in two years you know I have to go back and look at things um and U try to decipher what you're what you're laying down for us and so I I appreciate your

107hard work on this and proud that our district continues to maintain a positive inim budget so I will be attending the workshop in January hopefully you guys inv yep we should all be getting invites count went correct you tell yes good yeah good one yep so say more we should that February meeting as well because that's when we have the governor's Workshop that's presented and then the county one that comes off of that Capital if you're doing a Christmas wish list um onetime money tell them to put it ongoing I I feel really good about that everybody write that down put that in your letter Santa um and just as a sidebar regarding the prop 98 maneuver and that everybody continues to talk about right now um csba um I'm part of the delegate assembly

108and they did Sue the state and so there should be more information on that it'll be interesting in January it will be interesting in January and I will remain helpful all right thank you very much do we have a motion to approve action item 6.7 our interim budget and accompanying certification I move to approve I'll second all right it's been first and seconded uh to approve action item s uh our first interim budget report and accompanying certification do we have any further questions or comments all in favor starting with the board I student board hi board hi I motion carries thank you Susan all righty um item 6.8 resolution number 11242 amending the 20242 budget to reflect changes in revenue and expenditures yeah this report we provide to the board um that shows what our

109changes were from original budget to the first interim um again it details it um I'm not sure um you know it'll same report will be for second interim so if there's any questions now would be good time have any questions on 6.8 I'll call for um approval or a motion move to approve second any uh further questions clarifications discussion all right on resolutions we'll do a roll call this is for item 6.8 resolution number 11425 amending the 2024 2025 budget to reflect changes and revenue and expenditures starting with the student board one by one I I board I I I motion carries thank you thank you that's a lot of work thank you so much thank you Susan all right item 6.9 process to fill a board vacancy well um we have uh Chelsea tips

110here from dwk that's going to give the board a presentation on uh the process of filling the board vacancy and then for your discussion to ask questions of of kind of our next steps thank you for being here thank you so much um good evening everyone my name is Chelsea tibs um correction to the the slide here I'm stepping in for my colleague Marie Nakamura who wasn't able to be here tonight but I am an attorney with the law office of danis wber and Kelly and um as you know there you're um there's been a resignation and a vacant seat on the board and so I was asked to present tonight as to the legal options for filling the board vacancy um you've been presented with my PowerPoint I'm happy to walk through that uh

111and then answer any questions that you might have so essentially um according to Ed code when there is a vacancy the board must within 60 days of the resignation do one of two things um one either order a um special election to fill the vacancy or to make a provisional appointment to the vacancy um if neither of those things happen if the board fails to act within those 60 days and and that date is by um January 19th then the county superintendent would call a special election to fill the vacancy um any in addition to that any provisional appointment would also be um subject to petition um and there would be a process for the the public to for a special election if the board opts for that option to provisional appointment so that's just

112something to sort of be aware of um a couple of pieces about the process for each of those for you to be aware of the um special election may be called by the board um and as I mentioned would be called by the county soup if there was no action within 60 days um a special election um would go out to the public and there's some complicated rules about how that election would be held it would be held on the next election date not less than 130 days following the order um uh for election and because of the timing of that that puts us out to November of 2025 um so essentially um there would be a a vacant seat on the board until that November 2025 election were to take place if the special

113election would be called in addition if the board were to opt to call a special election the district would then bear the cost C of the election um so that's one option uh another option for the board is to um make a resolution for a provisional appointment under this process what the board would do is adopt this resolution and then establish a subcommittee of two board members who would then um be in charge of the nitty-gritty process for um uh directing staff to um publicize the V cancy and go through the appointment process on this slide here you can see that there are certain items that need to be done um during Open session including the adoption of the resolution and the establishment of the subcommittee um the subcommittee would then be able to work

114um with staff on on some of the pieces of this process that aren't mandated by Ed code that are up to the subcommittee's discretion including things like creating an application process managing that application process um and then also verifying the eligibility for any applicants to that position basic eligibility criteria such as you know being over the age of 18 and and being El um you know registered voter being in the um trustee area um Etc after um the subcommittee has screened and verified eligibility then the board would conduct interviews um hear public comment on those um applicants and and make an appointment and all of those last three pieces would happen during Open Session um and the the details of that would could be worked out um and established by the subcommittee um a couple

115of other pieces about how each of those options would work logistically um if the board opts to move forward by calling for a special election um what would happen you would agendize that election order you um would have to approve that election order by January 19th and then you would have four members until the election um the elected member would then serve the remainder of the term from essentially when they're elected to no December of 2026 which would be the remainder of the the vacant term um the other option the logistics um are a little bit more straightforward you would get to authorize the process via resolution um as I described the um appointment of a subcommittee and and that appointment would just have to happen by January 19th and then as of the January

11619th date or at the time earliest time that the new applicant new board member could be appointed and and sworn in then that appointee would fill the remaining two years of of the term um until December 2026 um I'm happy to take any questions I know that um the board's been provided with a a more detailed memo than that but I'm happy to take any questions about the process um if if you'd like um just for the public that's here today I because it's written here somewhere I think but uh can you explain to the public um what if we did if the board did move for a special election what those costs associated with that actually is yeah absolutely so the cost of a special election would be about half a million dollars and

117that would be a cost bored by the district um that cost is based on um what a quote that we understand is uh basically based on per registered voter that's about 7 to 122 per registered voter um and there are um a little over 67,000 registered voters within the district and we are looking we would be looking at a special election districtwide rather than um trustee areawide because the um the rules under the Ed code are that the special election would have to operate under the rules that were established at the time in which the vacant seat was was established and so we would be looking at at um a an atlarge um election rather than a a trusty are election and it's also a speak and just to be clear it was also established

118so we went through a a California voters right act redistricting by trustee area so now we do have brand new trustey area elections and we have a new area for but this is going to also be in our old trustee area 4 at the full at large if we were to move forward with a special election that's correct we'd essentially be rewinding the clock and conducting the special election under the um rules that were operative um in in 2022 when this um last election occurred so that would be the old um District map um and the atlarge voting would that residency requirement be the same it if we're talking about a board appointment um yeah yes it's all operative both of those rules you have to look back to essentially rewind the clock to 2022

119so with respect to a board appointment it could be anybody within the district the district area the the old the old District area yeah yeah right the old district for map which if any if anyone was following that process just so you know now we're properly deviated across the district technically this was the smallest grouping on our last map map so so I think we were 100% out of deviation with our former map so this is actually a smaller pool which means um you know potentially not that it matters but that we could technically um have if we choose to move forward with a provisional that person may or may not be in the new area for which means they may or may not be eligible to run for 2026 so something to consider it's

120not an end all and and the the complexity around which uh rules we're operating under um there's no legal uncertainty around that we're on really solid ground with that understanding there was a recent um California attorney general opinion um about how to conduct uh and and to fill a vacant position um when there's been redistricting and and different rules about trustee areas and elections so now the the verifying the eligibility I know it's just kind of a screening process what does that look like for the people on that committee th those two people would go through essentially a checklist and that that subcommittee can be provided guidance um from staff and legal in terms of what eligibility requirements um you're looking for I mean some of the most basic ones as I said are you

121know age you know over the age of 18 um eligible you know registered voter checking the the residency requirements for that trustee area um and and outside of that um it it's it's a relatively simple process to verify that eligibility okay all righty I does anyone have a feeling one way or another student board feel free to chime in when you feel so inclined just from a from being fiscally responsible uh I I would I would lean towards the uh provisional appointee I agree I agree I think that that number was staggering I had no idea that at the top end it could be over $800,000 for us to go to a special election do are you aware many people challenging a provisional appointment does that happen to our understanding and our experience it it

122is not a a common process challenging a provisional appointment um would be done through petition and would require one and a half% uh of Voters to sign that petition so in our case it would be a very large number it would be a large number in your case and and it is to my understanding a a rare process not unheard of but rare okay all right any other questions no I'm with you I think it we should move to to an appointment especially aside from the the financial a year out but the the election wouldn't even occur for a year which means that seat would be vacant for nearly a year and they'd only be there for a year so I'm with you guys um and are we taking there's no action this was just

123listening on on 6.9 yeah and so um or we need to decide and then and then do the resolution okay so do we have a motion um if we're consensus here regarding I'm if I'm doing this right I moveed to approve uh a provisional appointee I'll second it's been moved and seconded to approve on item 6.9 a provision appointment all in favor starting with the board the student board excuse me I board I I I I'll oppose motion passes unanimously thank you so uh president Spade we anticipated hope in that manner so we do have before you the resolution um with thank you for being here and answering question AB happy to answer questions throughout the process otherwise thank you for your time thank you Chelsea so much I know we all love reading lots

124of where AES um but thought it might be of benefit to read through this line by line um because there are some um blanks at the bottom that we want to make sure we get because we do need to decide the subcommittee in the date and time today yes okay would you like would you like to read it or read and my I would love for you to read version here so before the Board of Trustees of the plaster Union High School District plaster County California resolution number 13425 in the matter of establishing procedure to fill Board of Trustees vacancy by provisional appointment whereas rotes member of Board of Trustees of the plaster Union High School District recently resigned from his seat on the board and whereas this creates a vacancy on the board as

125the term of trustey oat seat will not end until 2026 whereas pursuant to section 5091 of Education Code the vacancy may be filled by provisional appointment or by special election whereas a special election to fill the vacancy may not be held until November 2025 and the district would be responsible for the cost of the election whereas after consideration of the available options the board has determined to fill the vacancy by provisional appointment and whereas uh persuant to board policy 9223 the board May approve by resolution the procedures required to make a provisional appointment to fill the vacancy now therefore be it resolved that pursuant to section 5091 of Education Code the board seeks to fill the current board vacancy by provisional appointment be it further result that the Board instructs District staff to provide notice

126of the vacancy and advertise in the local media to solicit applications for provisional appointment to the board and be further resolve that the board directs District staff to open an application window from December 18th 2024 through January 7th 2025 be it further resolved that the board establishes a subcommittee of board member blank and board member blank and you guys get to decide that and task the subcommittee with determining whether applicants are eligible to fill the vacancy announcing the names of the eligible applicants no later than January 10th 2025 and finalizing the process and questioning for applicant interviews and be it further resolved that board interview applicants in special meeting of the board on January 14th 2025 and I know that was question brought up earlier be it further resolved that the board delegates to the

127Acting Superintendent or their designate all authority necessary and proper to the accomplishment of the purposes of this resolution passed and adopted the 17th day of December 24 during a regular meeting of the Board of Trustees of class Union High School District all right so the two um areas that we need to address are the the date well let's start with the first um the ad hoc subcommittee uh members I'd be happy to be a part of that I would too okay trust you Jeff I'll support both of you okay okay all right well we'll fill in those two and then um and then the other is the date in question for the interviews um there has been um on the on the document it says January 14th um there conflict I understand yeah is a

128conflict um so we were looking at other dates that week and trying to determine what might fit with everyone's schedule I know that there's an event on Monday the 14th at deloro um I know that I have a conflict on the 15th now I don't have my calendar in front of me better look at that yeah I think I think I was looking at either the 13th or unpopular date of the 10th which is a Friday exciting you know what when you're under these timelines 60 days it comes very quickly and there's so many things on the schedule and financially it's worth it we have to do it so what's your schedule availability um I did want to attend the the back to school night on the 13th uh Monday the 13th however I'm free

129both that week before and the week after the week of the week before and the week after I should say okay so you're unavailable on the 13th prefer not to do on that day but I mean if we had to we could but okay and I'm unavailable on the 15th uh Jeff you're you've got obligations on 1416 is that accurate yes I okay we've got a dilemma traveling out of town on the 17th y so it allows for um remote to be a part of it if that's the only conflict I I would kind of defer to um to miss tibs about the Friday the day after we have the subcommittee to have a Friday is that realistic Mee great question I think that stoling around break to sort out the logistics the smoother the

130process would go um so we also have to keep in mind um posting requirements in advance of any so right there are risks in moving the date too up in order to get the work and get stff the time after right the subcommittee meeting sorry is the nth the final correct yeah okay and we're closing the applications on the seventh per the resolution do you think I mean potentially so if we we closed applications on the six instead of the seventh and met the eth again the same same issues exist but at least the application would close a date earlier so staff would have still a two-day window to address it and I think it really just depends on how many applicants you get right we don't know yeah is there a a specific time

131that uh we have we would have to meet uh at the 5:30 time or could we meet earlier in the day the board could decide that I mean it's a special meeting right we could make the 16th work for an earlier meeting on the Thursday but again I want to make sure that yeah appropriate well I mean especially depending on the number of applicants it would be very difficult to do in an evening if we had quite a few and I know that there's time restrictions or boundaries for interviews you know giving equal time could you I'm just thinking we might need more time than just an evening depending on the number of applicants yeah I mean and and those things those sort of logistics can be sorted out once you see once the subcommittee

132is seeing how many applications are coming in we often um will restructure how we conduct those interviews and what the processes are as I said those aren't mandated by Ed code so of often times we'll see if we're seeing a high volume of applicants um a way of streamlining the meeting in order to ask fewer questions um giving everyone an equal amount of time to to present or answer questions in that interview process whereas we might not have to be as um efficient if we had more applicants so that's something that can be those Logistics can be sorted out at a a later date with the subcommittee and and staff and okay is that possible for you trusty jeffre to meet earlier in the day on the 16th absolutely okay well maybe yeah we carry

133forward with the 16th and we'll figure out that timeline with the subcommittee and relay that and that gives us plenty of time for uh noticing we have a Time on the 16th should we do we have to have a time there it might beneficial I it's not listed in the in the resolution but it might I mean that's going to come up real quick I mean it might be helpful to look at times now yeah yeah sure I mean I um on average how long are these meetings again I guess I'm asking a depends on the number of applicants and a lot of it is up to disc of the how you to structure the interiew process each sense a cand there's a lot of flexibility discre the only other thing that I had a

134question about is to your point um President spth we needed more time uh we our Windows shorten because 19th is a Sunday and then we yeah so um do we try to split it in two days or is that we need it yeah is that possible I I'm sure anything's possible I don't know if that's re recommended I mean the situation would now require the applicants to sit through two days potentially because it is an open Open Session and there's a public comment associated with it as well exactly okay let's hope for the best and go for the 16th I think in uh back in 2013 I actually participated in this process with the Ville Unified School District okay um and there were about 10 people that were um looking at that appointment um and

135it took us about two hours to get through those 10 people I think okay okay to give you a rough idea sure and then and then potentially the discussion narrowing applicants down and so the discussion piece outside of the interview process unless there's a standout yeah okay all right well what time do you need to close and then we can work our way yeah backwards um by by 6:30 we need to close by 6:30 so we work backwards about 4 o' yeah I want to be too early because just you know get out of school until certain like 3:00 3:40 my recommendation would be give us a little bit more time than that maybe 2 o'clock and then just in case yeah sure because who who knows how long it actually might take and we

136would hate to have you sure take off in the middle or that's probably a good idea be awful what happens in a situation where it's 2 o'cl and you have a business person that can't make an interview what happens I mean I think we could have set up some procedures where they would note their availability on the um their applications we could collect that information interview schedule time basically yeah schedule interview time um there's no requirement that you have them all there starting at 2 until I mean it's it's ideal that they're you know the best practice is that they're all there and you call a name out of a hat um but for logistic reasons again that's not mandated by Ed Cod so you're you're free to set up a procedure as long as

137it's Equitable and everyone's given the same opportunity to um State their interview time preferences thank you and and the applicants would be aware that we're under a Time scrutiny here and and that this needs to occur and that this is the time frame that all the board come so they they would know in advance that it would be the 16th midday so they'd be aware we can certainly work with the subcommittee and and staff to make sure that that is is publicized in the notices okay we'd be we'd begin that publicity starting tomorrow starting tomorrow right you guys I love that you guys on it starts tomorrow yeah it's go time okay do we have any other questions no about um csba they told us that we can like participate in subcommittees would this be

138a subcommittee that we could participate in I love that question I certainly don't mind I would love that that would be great yeah where timing that's a great question again class no just kidding right we're gonna have the subcommittee at deloro I would do that are we able to do that so you could pop out of class is that possible possible yeah I I mean we could have the location where where where you could access it if it was have a time that works for the student board members okay okay we are we do we have more than one student board member that wanted to participate I would like to as well okay okay well okay everybody in be I'm sure Zoe would as well okay so maybe because we can't be at all four

139schools um maybe we need to coordinate a zoom so you guys could participate virtually and then maybe we just is that possible I haven't been through this process I don't either you know perfect the subcommittee um meetings are not uh you don't have to limit um student board member participation in the subcommittee okay and you um they don't have to be they're not subject to Brown act okay um so remoting in it doesn't present an issue okay thank you so two o' need a Time on the on the 9th correct is that what we decided on the morning's a little bit better for me on the 9th sorry this this is for the actual Sub sub committee yes subcommittee what's your schedule looking like on the night calendar to um we have just as a

140sidebar here we have a learning walk at the Confluence the day before so that date is out I can make anything on the ninth work um I could I can do the ninth um earlier is the only request for me great on the works best for you um students would like 6: a.m. is that is that early enough no no just any like two three o'clock is fine again if we want to keep it consistent two let's do two that work okay all right and staff will communicate with student board so that they can participate okay super thank you yeah awesome all right so I think we've established our resolution inserts we have accurate okay so now it's go ahead it's official all right so item six we're still on six six um .10 resolution

141number 13 2425 establishing procedure to fill Board of Trustees vacancy by provisional appointment it's a roll call vote do I have a motion motion to approve I'll second all in favor starting with the student board I I board I hi hi motion carries all right item 6.11 County committee District voting representative selection for so um annually the board nominates um a member to uh be their voting representative at the county level currently for the pler county committee on school board or School District Organization for 2024 currently I'm on the county committee for the school district organ um organization but I was told that technically um I could serve on both if there's no interest from another party to participate for us is there any interest I'm serving as the representative they meet once you know

142annually I believe um typically prior to a trustee um County trustee dinner and it's pretty lowkey and interest is it just one of us just one up to you Jeff I've already taken one I'm fine if Jessica wants to do that well I will do it if no wants to do it I'm happy to do it that's fine all right so do we have a nomination I will nominate youate okay I will accept that nomination do we have a uh motion for item 6.11 County committee District voting representative I move to approve all right one second all right um we have a first and a second uh for the nomination of Jessica Spade to the county committee District voting representative for 2024 I'm all in favor starting with student board I I board I I

143all oppos none uh motion passes unanimously all right and final for our action item 6.12 call for nominations for the csba delegate assembly um annually the board if they desire it's not required um is able to nominate a member from um our Board of Trustees or technically other trustees throughout the district or throughout the region um to be considered for csba delegate assembly and they have two meetings annually um I'm currently serving as a delegate for the California Schoolboard Association a delegate assembly and um yeah we have two meetings annually uh technically um the work that is done at csba is to guide the legislative committees um and gather feedback from our region and communities um for potential legislation but also just feedback so that the values of our community are represented within the region

144we have two members um up for reelection uh this year myself included and one other member from Rockland uh that was um reelected last year so I would H be happy to continue to serve in that role if our board chooses um and just so you know so this is the nomination process the in February another um a ballot will come back from csba and then we'll vote on the members um that were nominated and so there could be two there could be three there could be more than that and then we'll decide on the two that will represent our region for y uh I nominate trust uh president's fa I I accept that nomination do we have do we have a a motion I've been stealing go ahead yeah I would like to see

145you continue to uh represent us with the csba delegate assembly thank you second all right we have a first and a second for item 6.12 a nomination for delegate assembly um of trusty jus all in favor I I board I I I we can also um discuss I know that there was another nomination in another um District the other night and I asked because he was nominated in another that um there was interest by J Jonathan zerson who was nominated last night as well and if the board would support his nomination I'd like to also put up um trusty Jonathan zerson from Roseville city school district District I support that nomination okay so do a um can we do do we do a separate is just a nomination okay yep I will do that okay

146do we need to take action on his nomination as well okay I move to nominate uh trusty Jonathan zerson from Roseville city school district as our second nominee for uh csba delegate assembly a second all right it's been first and seconded for the nomination of trusty zerson to be a potential uh delegate assembly member all in favor starting with the student board I I think that's fair board all in favor I I I all opposed none and obstination by our student board member Ruby all right super uh moving along to item seven public comment on non- agendized items this is the opportunity for public comments to be received by the board this is a time for members of the public to address the board regarding items not on the agenda um completing a blue participation

147form is preferred but not mandatory this form can be obtained at the meeting um up here at this table um or potentially at the back I'm not sure where it's at tonight in the interest of conducting a public meeting in a timely man manner individual speakers will be allowed three minutes to address the board with no more than 20 minutes per topic this is a comment period only the law does not allow the Board of Trustees to take action on any item not explicitly posted on the agenda in advance the board values public comment and wishes to convey that although board members cannot uh take action on items that are not on the agenda they listen carefully and appreciate and value input from the public and it's true I'm not just reading it we really

148do appreciate it and thank you all for being here tonight okay great thank you so much okay I'm putting them on the bottom if anyone knows no preferred blue cards tonight all right um Stone lionard O'Brien and before you you speak because you put it on here is lionart really in your that's amazing thank you all right awesome take it hi my name is Stone I go to kfax high school I'm a senior um I just wanted to discuss the um Uprising notion that CBE is not beneficial to our uh District CBE is a very easy way to give students benchmarks to hit um in regards to grades the 100o system is arbitrary and biased as well as small-minded whereas CBE allows us to expand on what is correct and seen as valued in terms

149of grading an assignment well in addition to CBE some of the policies that I have heard have been proposed by members of this board are regressive and detrimental to the people and to the students and staff of our district as well as some of the organizations that board members may be affiliated with as a queer person I will not tolerate nor will anyone at my school tolerate any La backlash against trans or queer students whatsoever thank you you all right Sarah and on Deck just so you know is Emily Mitchum there's popular name wasn't sure if you met me sorry I heard we were going to talk about CBE today so I'm in uh I'm Sarah schaer I teach at kfax high school I'm also uh the department chair and curriculum and instruction coordinator where

150I have served with the best minds of this district for the past nine years I opted to speak tonight about CBE because I was at the last meeting and I heard a lot of misinformation I would like to clarify I would first like to acknowledge the frustration of the parents and the students of those um that are here tonight and on our campuses that be here um because there's a lot of confusion that can come with change I see it and I get it hindsights 2020 uh there's always things that could have be done differently now that we're looking through the rearview mirror um from what I've heard from community members uh during public comment at previous board meetings um my understanding and interpretation is that it's not frustration with CBE but frustration with the

151implementation of it and it's really important we understand the difference between those things um CBE practices are you guys trying to censor me I'm just kidding okay I just in the best way possible to my time cametti when implemented correctly uh it's absolutely what's best for students um I don't know how anyone could argue with individualized education based on a students's interests and strengths an opportunity to grow from mistakes try again truly learn content and skill and worry less about points and percentages it's the type of education I want from my fourth grader and my first grader I want to uh address a few misconception specifically in previous meetings I've heard parents say it's harder for students to earn a a and then in the next sentence say that CB CBE lacks rigor and accountability

152both of these things cannot be true in fact the first one's probably the most true it is harder for students to earn a day because it's not about collecting points and shading a map of the Globe Theater it's about authentically demonstrating knowled knowled and skill and that can be really really hard especially if the teacher is not explaining it well which is where we would need to support um and you know what does make it easier Clarity feedback revisions communication um and these things come from using proficiency scales the staff at kfax has worked really really hard for the past five years to build up to the point where we are now and we aren't perfect but I'm really proud of us um accurate grading and the use of proficiency skills has transformed my teaching

153in the past 10 years and has really really evolved I'm really really proud of us none of this change uh comes easy but the battle is worth it because it's what's best for all students my high achieving IB students as well as my students who need the most support in my classroom I can truly say that all of my students are finding success trusty Spade I just wanted to address one thing you brought up last time uh was just you were questioning the use of scales in AP courses and I just wanted to speak to my IB uh English 11 and 12 courses we use scales and I have 100% pass rate in my department which I'm really proud of so happy to answer any questions anytime come visit me up at kfax okay thank

154you thank you Emily and then Amanda Bratton Emily Mitchum uh my name is Emily Mitchum and I teach stage Tech professional theater and business leadership uh at kfax high school these courses are all CTE Pathways I would like to speak to the effectiveness of CBE in meaningful CTE coursework a competency based curriculum that is developed designed and implemented with Fidelity is extremely effective for CTE courses it provides clear expectations and learning goals for skill development while allowing students to both develop general knowledge about career Pathways and focus their learning specifically on their areas of Interest this personalized education motivates students to find their passion within different career Fields while still maintaining a rigorous learning environment it also allows for creativity and flexibility when demonstrating competency um students in my stage tech class for example um

155can demonstrate their skill levels for one of our skills producing theatrical designs through prop making set painting sewing costumes or running lights and sound uh but they all know what skill level they need to demonstrate in order to hit the learning Target CBE that is implemented with Fidelity is a true reflection of students learning in the classroom and it is a more effective Communicator of a student skill level than an arbitrary arbitrary percentage given or a random number of points assigned or even a rubric that might vary from teacher to teacher it is clear meaningful individualized and effective thank you thank [Applause] you on deck is Caitlyn Jenkins hello my name is Amanda Bratton I'm a cfax science teacher I teach chemistry AP Physics IB environmental AP Chemistry and my fourth year 14th year of

156teaching um for from day one I signed up for CBE I always felt the writing assessments and Grading was incredibly arbitrary not transparent and entirely subjective to the grader out assigned random points to questions with some inkling that some questions on assessments should be worth more than others nothing was consistent and furthermore it was incredibly difficult to clearly communicate to my students the level of importance each question or assessment held in their overall grade I was fortunate to have been invited to one of the first groups trained in grading practices in CBE I worked with Joe Felman on Equitable grading practi IES I went to CBE breakdown sessions I fully implemented in power for two terms in my classes while at the same time keeping an AR's Gradebook to at the similarities and differences between

157communicating CBE to parents and students it was not easy and of course it's challenging to redesign your curriculum and assessments but now after all this work it has entirely transformed my teaching and how my students are learning each unit I present my students with our proficiency skills for a unit it looks something like this it's a checklist of all the things they need to know and do for that unit's assessment the checklist is broken down by category foundational Target and sophisticated application the beautiful thing about CBE is that the we work through this scale from bottom up gone are the days of every kid starting at 100% And slowly but surely we lower their score by arbitrarily taking percentages away uh CB is designed to give kids the tools and confidence to perform at the

158highest levels assessments are written to match what is stated on the proficiency scale so that students know exactly what to expect and how to achieve the particular level of proficiency uh for their learning targets most importantly they are all exposed to questions in which they have to use those long-lost critical thinking skills to apply those learning Targets in new ways of sophisticated application CBE has made me really evaluate what I put on my assessments what level of learning am I asking my students to display rather than assigning points to a test question I'm assigning it a level I'm asking myself the question is it foundational Target or sophisticated one of the most most amazing changes CB has brought to my classroom is the way my students are interacting with it my students no longer ask

159the questions of how many points is it worth how will this affect my grade if I don't do it their questions and our conversations are centered around learning they say I know what uh I know that in order to increase my level of proficiency I need to do this and they point to the scale and they ask to come to a flex and we work it out we break down assessments we don't throw away them throw them away um we figure out why a proficiency wasn't met we learn from it we improve and we re SS my grades have never felt more transparent accurate or Equitable I could look at a student's grade on each scale and tell you exactly what they are able to accomplish I and all other stakeholders students parents and counselors

160can pinpoint their exact strengths and weaknesses um I have every confidence that the students grade that they get in my class aligns with the scales and truly indicates their level of learning and knowledge they have about my course I invite any and all of you to come to my class to see what a CB classroom looks like thank you [Applause] on Deck is Justin Petty hello my name is Caitlyn Jenkins I teach English n IB English 12 and IB world religions at kfax high school I wanted to share a quote with you uh Henry Ford broke down the complex tax task of building a complete car into manyi tasks and created the production line after the success of his model became a parent schools were modeled after the assembly line learning was separated isolated and

161comp metalize the teacher became the factory line worker and the students became the tasks the line worker did their small part with each task and then moved them on to the next isolated factory worker and on and on until the product student was deemed finished and left the factory that quote gives you a direct glimpse into my grade book Circa 2011 uh at this point in the term there would have been roughly 70 assignments all ranging in points in difficulty color this map 15 points fill in these vocab definitions 20 points write your own book of vignettes 150 points why these assignments no idea why these Point values I also have no idea I assigned and graded based on what I knew that's how I was taught in my credential program and that's how I

162graded in school side note so were my parents and my grandparents it's not easy for me to admit but my systems were only good for one thing making worker bees who didn't ever need to critically think in order to pass if you're a student in my class today there is a phrase that you get really tired of hearing over and over and it goes like this we don't know what we don't know but when we know better we thank you um this phrase is ingrained in my curriculum whether we're talking about tequila Mockingbird a James Joyce poem or the relevance of sick belief systems within the American medical field but this phrase is also ingrained in the way I view and adapt my own teaching practices it wasn't until I came to PSD six years

163ago that anyone shed light on the fact that the practices I was using might be one confusing two ineffective and three downright harmful to some kids I didn't know that I was complicit in a system that dates back to the Industrial Revolution but now I know better and now I do better CBE has enabled me to have genuine conversations with students about their learning it has enabled students to understand that no they do not just get an A for doing the thing and now they have no place to hide you got a two but you wanted a three use the rubric I wrote to the exact specifications of the proficiency scale and revise it and then do it again and then do it better as many times as as you want the Henry Ford Model

164is one of the direct reasons that so many of my nth graders have made it this far without the skills they need to thrive it's also the reason that so many of them are stuck at the fourth and fifth grade reading levels based on what I've heard if I were a student or a parent in these times of change I would be frustrated too it takes time years to shift the status quo and it's not easy but discomfort is not a good enough reason to stay in a system that is just good enough but kfax is putting in the time and the work because we know better and now we're doing better thank you could I ask a question Justin before you come up do you mind Kaitlin do you mind coming back up just

165had a question could you just explain the IB Program yeah happy to yeah um so our IB students are exposed to um a curriculum that is very globally minded um it it is similar if oh let me rephrase that it is it requires a lot of rigor like the AP programs that we're all used to um when they take their tests their IB tests those tests are graded globally so when my world religion students take their IB world religion test that might be graded at the heg that might be graded in Beijing um and so we make sure that they are ready for those tests and as somebody who's been teaching IB now for the last four years I am finding I had 100% pass rate with English and I had 100% pass rate with

166uh IB world religions and I would attribute that to CBE just because I'm able to give them the time that they need to revise reassess figure out where they they land on those proficiency skills what what percentage of the school is the entire School IB as far as the the student enrollment every single student has access to IB um so for example our Junior and Senior year I can't speak for all the Departments was not ready for this um but uh I can let you know that um for example like in in English and in history our classes are dual so we have IB students sitting side by side elbow to Elbow with non IB students um so they're all exposed to the same curriculum um and whether or not they take the test uh

167is up to them but they all have the same access to to that information awesome thank you for explaining yeah Dr Robia um for your learning walk it might be worth um a session on IB for our new board yeah and then just sorry I'm tall Gooding J I'm Justin Petty sorry if you guys don't know anything about me I am Delo sophomore class officer homecoming Hall chair member of executive Council student voice Council student reference student for student site Council so student boy student Sky oh my gosh uh blood D and Club Rush organizer and just the other day I was stopped in the hallway and someone told me Justin you are actually a lifesaver I feel like I finally have a voice thank you for advocating for the students additionally I Tor math

168I was a I was in a seventh and eighth grade classroom and I had students approach me and they said they were worried for high school I was thinking friends right we're all worried about makinging new friends relationships with teachers these students said CBE that broke my heart they asked me if I could fix it for them and I said I don't have the power but I have the power to talk to them so here I am I am here trying to make a difference and it's easy for these kfax students to speak up because it goes with the board policy there's no one trying to stop them for me and for teachers of Delo high school it's a lot harder to give the other Viewpoint and I appreciate you board members going into classrooms

169and talking with teachers students and staff and if you guys ever need me to go with you I'm happy to do that as well um first an a at Granite Bay is a b at deloro let that sink in I don't want my life to be easy or my grades to be easy I want them to be fair I'm competing against scholarships I'm competing against colleges with these people who don't have the gr that they who do not have the same grading system as us and that hurts my heart I've been really preit about this but um I want to let you know that I have been in contact with the Granite Bay vice principal because I'm worried about my college future I would never want to switch schools I am so involved but at

170the same time I'm worried about college this is the stress CBE has created for both teachers and students touching on teachers I want to say that I unfortunately have witness teachers crying at multiple events thinking that they don't have enough time in the day to get things done these are people I have relationships with and this breaks my heart and everyone says it's the implementation I want to say in the front row we have Senora Adams I'm in her block AO fifth block class and I want to say the implementation is great I understand CBE I'm educated on CBE but I don't like it and it's because it's not fair not only that but I want to bring up phsd policy 1000 titled Concepts and roles this States schools parents Guardians community members and local

171organizations must continually collaborate as partners I ask for a partnership that's all I'm asking for I ask that the students teachers and staff at Del are heard because as I went today most people could not make it but they told me give me a shout out I have 10 seconds left so I can't give anyone a shout out but I do want to let you know I'm listening to you and I want to advocate for you please partner with us and this truste the students need you now more than ever thank you thank you J uh Jennifer Bratton and then on Deck behind her is Livia Lichfield it's on hi I'm a sophomore at delaro I wanted to make you all aware of the concerns with the new grading scale the new CBE grading scale

172has a negative impact on students mental health this new system has students stressed on if their retakes will make them be able to pass classes seeing that every proficiency scale must be passed this makes it difficult for us as students to provide our best work because of the stress anxiety and pressure that's being put onto us the grading scale that has just been pushed onto us the students is unjust we have we had no warning or explanation for why our grading scale would be changed or how it was supposed to work as a student I can say my parents had no idea there was even going to be different grading skill once they knew about it I had to explain why the new grading skill was applied but it was hard to explain something you

173didn't completely have an understanding of yourself it would be like putting a teacher who just started the teaching credentials and try to get them to teach a class full of students not fair I hear at least 10 students per class that have said the grading scale is more than has more of a negative impact then it does a beneficial impact and I think it's not fair that we don't fully get to understand the grading skill that's being put on to us and we don't understand why the grading skill didn't work before as well as when teachers come out with test scores like percentages they put a percentage into their system that spits them out a number that makes us get a grade and our overall grade doesn't mean anything for us it's each individual section

174of the proficiency scale which is not how it used to be and now students that have been getting A's are now getting B's which is not good for college so I just think it's unfair and I wanted to have you all hear me today thank you for your time thank you [Applause] Jennifer on Deck is Lily uh pardon me if I yeah thank you yeah of course good evening everyone my name is lvia Lichfield and I am the senior and the ASB president at kfax high school the teachers at kfax have worked really hard to implement the fourpoint system and has and have made sure that all students understand how it works that is why in our small school we have so much representation here talking about this subject in my experience I have not

175only been graded with this system I have graded my peers this way in my business leadership class it is one of it is one of the many responsibilities in my position as a leader at kofax to use and understand the CBE grading system to evaluate others in my class I will admit at first like everything new it was a learning curve but now I can confidently say that I would prefer to be grade be graded and grade this way it offers Clarity and ability to learn and grow it lets me be personal and connect with the students I have not only um I have not only in the leadership class but also um oh my gosh but also um the school that I have the opportunity of leading the kfax kfax high school way of

176using CBE works really well for students and I personally like it a lot because we are able to understand and learn a lot more indepth than before all the classes I have been in and are graded in this system whether it was IB or not in my opinion it would almost be drawing for the last semester of my high school career to switch to another grading system and speaking for other students that attend kfax who have also always been graded this way thank you so much and I urge you to listen to the voices who have implemented this system for longer and have had more experience working with CBE thank you I have a question for you are you're a senior I am a senior and your freshman year did you start with this yes

177we did we started the transition by freshman year okay great thank you thank [Applause] you hi my name is Lily stoflet I'm a senior at cfax high school and I would like to address the board about CBE I would like to say that change is inevitable in all aspects of life change is how we grow and at cax we have seen our greeting system change and grow over the past couple years um the CB grading system has changed grading for the better and in my experiences thing had has made my learning more clear and has made it easier for the teachers as well reverting back to a grading system that has become that has been widely established since the 1940s would be a setback for students education imagine if our technology and like our cars

178and everything was still the same as the 1940s that would be like insane for us to think about um luckily we have seen a change in those aspects of our lives and than and thankfully we have also seen a change our grading system like I emphasized earlier going back to the 100 point system would be a setback in our schools and therefore creating setbacks in the world because the generations in our schools are the future um the future for our kids in our country to develop and evolve and for the rest of our world to grow and evolve it is critical to change and a good start is to continue to implement cbear like the thank you thank you so Aus and then after Aus one moment Sawyer hey good evening my name is AIS

179I'm a senior at Delo high school I'm one of the senior class officers and um I just want to start off by saying that I completely understand the argument behind CBE especially from hearing you guys speak today and I'm only here to just provide what I've seen on my campus I'm not here to say we should get rid of it I don't have a extremely polarized point of view I just want to uh talk to you guys about what I've seen on my campus so um I think on my campus especially since CBE is a lot newer than kfax I've seen a lot of unanimous confusion among students parents teachers a lot of people don't know um how certain guidelines work and how to get the grade that they want which I know is a

180primary goal of CBE so um I want to focus a lot about the practicality and one aspect that I really want to focus in on is about getting a job so I know a lot of people in here have likely had to do a job interview and punctuality is one of the most important things you need to be at the interview on time this is a good um first impression and that's something that you need to continue to do throughout your job so what I've seen through personal experience through talking to students is that CBE promotes procrastination because of the ability to retake an assignment whenever possible and so I think that education is supposed to prepare students for Life After High School but cve fails in that one regard just because of retakes you

181don't get that in real life when you're working a job sorry when you're work in a job you don't always get the opportunity to retake something as much as possible so um yeah I want to say while some may argue that this helps students learn at their own pace I think not all students possess the discipline to continue to teach themselves that material while the class is still progressing and they're still being bombarded with new material um I've also seen it put a lot of pressure on teachers on campus um one of which I saw break down she couldn't even explain to her daughter how the system worked and so I think main the main issue is with the implementation a lot of teachers don't know how to grade specific students um essays or assignments

182um I've had I've heard of examples in English classes where a student went around the class and looked for an example of a four and not a single student got a four and the teacher couldn't explain what that student could have done to get a for so I feel like there's a lot of conclus sorry uh confusion and misinformation around the correct standards that one has to reach to get a certain grade um uh I think this system which is supposed to be very streamlined at least in the implementation at my school has actually just caused a lot more confusion misinformation and so just to conclude um I want you to understand that CBE from our perspective as a student um as someone who's very involved in campus and who has heard from many different

183voices on campus um as well as teachers I just want to say that um I think that CBE can promote unhealthy habits and that it can cause more stress and misinformation from teachers and that hopefully we can work together to figure out a solution thanks Aus a quick question um see kofax has been this is year four yeah what kind of rollout period or or or trial period did kofax go through how many years was that before you got got to I love talking about this I'm not being sarcastic I do um we started grading practices um about eight years ago and that led to a lot of conversations about the things that we were doing and why they were not necessarily accurate and transparent and that led to uh um changes in our policies

184board policies uh and then we moved on to the four-point scale as a site four years ago and then that easily transitioned us into um CBE practices two years ago a year and a half ago is when we fullon went hardcore CBE but we were doing the practices as Livia said about four or five years ago and and did you trial that so four years ago you started the four-point scale but did you trial that beforehand so the English Department has been using the fourpoint scale for six years and we were kind of triing it and then um I think there was another department that was using it but I can't think of it off the top of my head um and then that helped as cni I had that experience behind me to help

185support the staff through that next move okay thank you Sawyer and then we have our final is Adam hi my name is Sawyer hacker I'm a senior at kfax high school and I want to talk about CB uh but first back let's take take it back to third grade when I would receive let's say a 90 on a test I would see the questions that I got wrong just marks on it and that was it I got a 90 now I look at a test let's say a three and I see in clear writing the teacher's H handwriting pointing towards whatever I did wrong everything that I know I can improve on in the future I know exactly what I can do better and if I want to develop my knowledge further I can take

186a read date and then that that encourages me to develop my knowledge I'm going to be honest I didn't like it at first but that's because it was completely new K through 8 I was on the 100% system um it's it's a new thing it's always going to take time honestly anyone who says that the CV isn't a good system because we're already seeing benefits they want to take the easy and old way which why would we do that when we're already seeing improvements and we're still in development we we need to take the route that's better rather than the route that's route sorry the route that is easy Stone linhardt O'Brien wanted me to mention that it's very easy to complain about CBE when you aren't trying to implement it properly and to add

187on to that it's hard and it takes effort on both sides from teachers and students the teachers have to adjust and grow for the better the students also have to put in effort it's very easy to blame CBE if you don't put in enough work to get a two in class which is a c a 70% in the old system that's pretty easy to get it's the same thing except you know what you need to get it's not about reaching a certain amount of questions it's about getting your knowledge to that point perseverance is what we need right now which is something I learned in kindergarten you can't complain if you don't get full effort I started this grading system at the same time as I started the IB Program which is notoriously difficult and

188I still have straight A I put in the same effort that I have my entire School career thank you thank you thank you Adam uh hello board and student board members uh good evening so I I'm Adam langard I'm a student facts so I like cve um it's probably due to the immense work that our teachers have put into fully implemented and have completely changed their curriculum um which may not have been as smooth at other other high schools the implementation of CBE so CBE is good but the impl implementation might not have been as perfect as it could have been and for me I'm a junior and class of 2026 we haven't seen anything other than CBE like when I came in as a freshman I thought CB CBE was all we had done

189like I had never done the 100 point scale before so for me going into senior year and hearing that it might get rolled back potentially would probably would be like the worst thing that could happen for me like uh just on top of graduating and all the things that come with being a senior uh just the whole grading system getting changed from what I've been used to last these last three years might be would be really tough uh thank you for your time sorry I had a clarifying question for you you said that prior to entering kfax you hadn't been on a 100 point system uh yeah prior to kfax I have but what you were at what school Newar Hill School okay but like in in high school yep yep and they did not

190have a 100 point system they had a fourpoint scale okay he oh got it okay yeah okay sorry about that confusion thank you [Applause] that was the last of my blue cards unless somebody is brave in the audience wanted to share oh we have a couple oh the race to the microphone hi um I'm not speaking against CBE but I just want to stick up for the other schools um and other subject areas because mostly uh what we're hearing from is either CT or English there is a chemistry teacher too but um I I really firmly believe that all schools are putting a lot of work into this we all are working really really hard I I'm I'm a hard worker I so I I resent a little bit of that those comments um but

191I do think that we need more time and we need more support and we need to be able to work together to come up with the common rubrics that these guys have been doing in English for six years we haven't had that time so I just want to say that we're not against CBE we just need more support more time to do it right and that deloro and pler teachers are working harder than ever too and we believe in CBE but we feel like we've just been like you asked for the timeline um last year we piloted a lot of teachers weren't even trained so they want cold turkey this year so that's that's the issue really and the other issue is that there's a lot of nuances that nobody's mentioning that if you really

192look at the grades you we need to examine that so that we clear things up for everybody it's only fair to the kids and we have different demographics too so that that plays into it as well but I am supportive of CB I just want to say it's more complicated than it's being made seen tonight thanks thank [Applause] you that was almost exactly what I was going to say that was so beautiful I'm from kfax I teach visual uh IB Visual Arts ap2d Art and Design photography dual credit photography and 2D art and um I completely agree kolfax is a much smaller site and we have um we've been doing this longer so it makes sense that our our teachers and our students understand how it works a little bit better and we've had four

193years of going back to the drawing board we we try out little things we've tried it out a little bit at a time and then when something doesn't work we adjust it and then we come back and we try it again the next semester and it's better and so these seniors who have bravely been speaking have benefited from that and they've I think they've seen teachers take risks which we try to model for our students that we don't just do like Sawyer said what's easy and what's always been done but we try something new in the hopes that it can be better and I think that these seniors can probably testify that their freshman year was a hot mess and and even my photo students that I tried my proficiency scales on the first time

194this term there's parts of it that were a hot mess as well but like you mentioned the nuances I can look at the grades and I can say that's not really accurate how can I and I kind of redo it in the moment and then communicate with the student and the parents then um and we can make adjustments and be flexible so thank you for listening I had a question for you sure um and we've heard from a few different um categories of of curriculum here or school um classes visual Visual Arts yeah and then Performing Arts I've heard the same thing it felt like that was a little more difficult to put the older grading system uh into play and you feel like there's more room here with the with the with the CBE

195grading system I certainly feel like it's easier to get a four in production and Studio based classes because when you're when you're shooting for that four you're looking for a creative sophisticated way to apply your learning and an art project or a theater performance lends or a wood shop project lends itself to that like you do you know you demonstrate your understanding then you go above and beyond because you're putting your heart into it and you're adding that creative element um but I've seen all of our teachers at kovax in every Department in math in chemistry and in English do amazingly creative things with students to give them the opportunity to reach that four level it just requires a little bit of um kind of Ingenuity in how you approach your your options for students

196showing their understanding thank you [Applause] thanks all right if there's no further public comment going once going twice all right we're going to go ahead and move on to item eight point1 board reports and calendar anybody like to kick us off here you want to start Tom um yeah sure I'll start uh first of all I I just wanted to say thank you uh the public comment period um I think the right word is to it is uh you you are brave to get up and talk it's not easy um and I just want to say I think I appreciate everyone's point of view um and specifically on this last topic of CBE I've spent a ton of time uh really trying to speak to Administration uh to teachers uh to students and to parents

197uh and um I I appreciate uh the from kofax coming here today um I I do appreciate the work that you have all done um I also as I'm learning there's probably some differences in the way that kofax is an IB School um and compared to the rest of the schools in the district uh I think it's awesome that th those kids have that type of uh environment to learn and it sounds really cool um I'm also trying to compare apples to apples as a board member versus apples to oranges in those types of situations so some of my questions I wanted to get a better idea of how did this roll out and it seems like kofax was a great place to start smaller School IB students uh who um who are um maybe

198at a higher level of Academia uh and so and then I hear the frustrations across the rest of the district um and those schools are all in what I would call an Apples to Apples comparison uh and so it's uh it's it's a tough seat to sit in um I haven't been an administrator nor have I been a teacher uh and uh I'm a parent uh and I have my own experiences uh with with CBE uh but I think the most important thing that I've done over the last two to three months has I've listened and I've really tried to learn uh and so you know with that you know there's there's a lot of different range of emotions um from people um uh but you know overwhelmingly um and and I I get brought

199brushes and I get when you get up here sometimes your words can get a little off but I know for a fact that the teachers that I've spoken to are working harder than ever but they're working harder on the grading system rather than working on their Craft um and that's a concern as a as a board member I know the students are more confused than I've seen students before I know the parents are frustrated um and uh and and I know that there's a lot of act asking for grace in a situation like this but also that's why I I had Curiosity on H how was this implemented in in kofax and what steps went through it um I love the idea of comprehension I really do I think it's great uh I don't know

200if we've mastered that understanding of how to implement comprehension in a time-based world that we all sit in you know the kids aren't here for four years I mean six years they're here for four years so I think there's a lot of questions that go into this and I think the questions um right now um outweigh any of the clarity um so that's that's a concern for me so I just wanted to speak on that and and provide that based on just my experience over the last three months of of digging in and trying to you know see what's the best uh the best go forward for this District thank you so much trusty Duncan trusty Jeff sure so I would first like to thank those students uh parents staff and community members who came

201to this meeting tonight to speak about an issue that they felt passionately about the world would be a much better place if more people like you stood up and spoke out about what they believe in I encourage you including those watching home tonight to reach out to the board anytime you feel something in the district needs to be fixed or if there's something that the board memb should know our contact information is on the district website and we all I think appreciate hearing from you uh the second thing that I wanted to mention I move for the creation of an ad hoc committee to examine and if necessary amend or create 4,000 series board policies this committee would then report back to this board with recommendations for policy adaptations or changes I would support creating

202an ad hoc committee to address the 4,000 Series right I second that all right continuing um it recently came to to my attention that one of our School principles was involved in a potential bullying and intimidation of a student who wanted to come tonight to speak about CBE um and at that point I referenced uh that information with superintendent cametti asking him to look into that matter another thing that um that I wanted to mention as well is I believe that we need to have agendized on our next available opportunity um board policy 93 23.2 um titled actions by the board uh because there's some content within that board policy that seems to be contrary to law and the last thing that I wanted to mention is uh talking about what uh trusty unin was

203talking about over the last several months members of this board have heard comments and concerns regarding CBE or competency best education programs that the district has recently implemented many students parents and staff members have expressed their concerns about CBE it's role at and it's affected on our students it's a vitally important issue and I ask this be agendized for future meetings so that we can have some discussions in a more open form and make try try to make some decisions or even form a committee or something like that so we can kind of address some of the issues that we've heard U from student staff parents and and um community members and that is all I had awesome um I want to thank everyone who stayed through this late meeting I don't even know what

204time it is but this is this is long for us there's some boards that meet for a very long time this is long for us typically um I appreciate uh the feedback from Community as always and from our awesome staff we really do appreciate your Insight um I'm excited to have some new faces at this table some new ideas new parents um with vested interest in this District as well and um excited to see what things are going to look like moving forward I want to um reassure uh that we're going to do our very best to to represent each of you um and I know that I take it seriously and I know that the trustees um here as well um it I don't want to get us in in danger here you know

205with with full discussion CBE but I do agree that um we do need to discuss it further and we need a form that we can do that as a board and um in light of that so that we can have some conversations um And Timely conversations I was going to ask the members about their availability potentially for Thursday evening this week to discuss CBE um are you guys available I will be available um remotely but available remotely MH okay is that possible um Dr cetti with staff to hold an an evening meeting Thursday where we could um have further discussion as a board because we can't technically discuss anything at this point uh what time what time works for you if you're remote that'll be 2our time difference so whatever works for you guys yes

206okay anytime after 3:30 works from fine for me okay um 6:00 5:30 six six that work okay all right and I'm I'm assuming that we'll be working on the agenda together or you'll be okay because if there's there's staff requirements that doesn't give us a lot of time to prepare between now and Thursday if there's a staff report that's being asked of so I just want to conscious of folks especially with um finals and end of the term activities I want our staff to be able to um and then another question is is a side note of um the board's Direction on are these going to be streamed I because that's a that's an additional staff um ask right H correct unless he's area what does that entail yeah we need to know it's basic

207address so that can be published on on the agenda I can provide that 24 hours before yes yes so just to be clear that where would he post it where he's at what does that exactly mean are you in a hotel I am in a hotel yeah posted area in are the okay okay got it y I can do that okay that's exciting sure yeah I just think was that was that a yes on special meeting I mean it's probably a discussion moving forward for for the board of the number of special meetings um yeah streaming and staff to run those meetings if if we have to so if we're streaming and does that ire an extra staff member or is that something we can do just with car car would have to run the

208stream yeah it's it's a requires some monitoring making sure the sound's working and things along those lines I'm assuming if we're if we're doing a remote then we probably should if we're already be here let's just stream it also stream if say that say that again if we are already in a remote situation for a board member then we have a body here already then it just makes sense to stream the meeting that okay um and so that will that just requires additional layer of streaming you in so the public can hear you both on the live stream and in person so that's that's just a person right so if they're come if people come to the special meeting we need to be able to hear you speak and cast your votes if there's an

209action item um we need to be able to hear you on the live stream it's we've done it we've done it before it just adds it just adds a layer yeah yeah uh I I mean that's fine we can I can set up an audio system so you guys can hear me really easily and then I guess Carlos you're our you're the man back there are you available Thursday [Music] evening well that was the easiest yes I feel like of the night thank you Carlos all right yeah I we definitely need to have some conversations and everyone's in a little bit of a different place um throughout the district and so um we'd like to thoughtfully be able to to have that conversation and and support our students um families and staff so there there

210any questions or anything in preparation for that we need to ask now or um so I had um a meeting with um Mr Wilson Mr Trent it's weird to say Mr Wilson um and and I know that staff has had some conversations about um some different options I think you called them lines of retreat um but just to present some options for us and also what that could potentially look like um if action were to occur technology-wise and so obviously we have some different things happening from campus to campus and so we want to have that conversation too what does it look like across what would it look like if it there was a little more autonomy and what does it look like with the technology that we're using yeah I would say a question

211I would have is if this grading system were to roll back to the former grading system uh what's the software implication uh via Aries or any other software so I guess just some information regarding options um I also would want to remind the board that Friday teachers grades are due those are term permanent transcript grades right so um if if there is a a discussion on the board for an action item it would be um really concerning to make that action come into play and affecting Friday teachers grades and putting grades in in their workload and expectations okay yeah thank you for that yeah that makes sense 4M I believe they're due yes yeah you guys have a crazy week thank you guys so much for all that you do I'm going to make this

212brief we've been to a lot of things um and delegate assembly was great I'm I'm excited for some things coming forward that's going to help um benefit all of our schools and look forward to to um sharing more on that down the line and I am honored to be in this new position please uh bear with me and be patient as we all navigate this uh this together but I appreciate you um and I appreciate the nominations and support from the board tonight so last but not least um agenda item nine adjournment do I have a motion motion to adjourn second all in favor say I I I

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.