001e e e sure all your mics are on okay this uh meeting for the roer board of education on January 23rd 2025 is now in session please stand and join me for the Pledge of Allegiance Al to the flag of un America indivisible liy and Justice so welcome to this first meeting of 2025 uh all board members are present and accounted for with the exception of president truste president Duo um moving on um report of action taken in closed session there was no action taken en closed session moving on uh to adoption of the agenda is there a motion to adopt the agenda moved second and motion and second all those in favor say I I I oppose um motion passes the agenda has passed um that's been approved moving on to Communications um looks
002like there are no open Communications in front of us so we we'll move on to Public Communication this is when members of the public May address the Board of Trustees regarding any special board meeting agenda uh item during board consideration of that time um and then there's a long long go I'm not going to read that please note that if you wish to address the Board of Trustees on an agenda item you should do so when the specific item is called um forward by the board president to comment in person um fill out a request to be heard card and give it to the board clerk uh you will be called during the public during a session like to submit a comment online via assembly gamut meetings enter your name and email address the board
003assistant will approve your comment to the board to submit a comment on YouTube type your comment in live chat the superintendent will share your comment with the board as appropriate is there anyone who would like um to present in person is there any online none online okay then we will move on to reports robal Education Foundation did you turn it on good evening uh tonight it's going to be a little bit uncharacteristic because of the many hats I wear within the district including the found I'm on site counsel here at Ro and as some of you on the board have experience with site counsil from being on it he got a little push uh we deal with the site Council and site council is part of the sipa uh operation that you will be getting
004reports on tonight and being on as the site Council chair for RO I get to work closely with Mr CF and the members of the site Council and one of the things that we address is the both the lcap is the lcap and the spending of Title One funds and we happen to have a member of our site Council who along with her state job she is also on the golden one board donation board and seeing all the the president presentations the state uh the data board dashboard for the school uh she went to Mr CF and said hey there's an opportunity here for you if all you got to do is fill out a grant so he filled out the grant request and it came back in December I don't believe you guys know
005about it yet but we re the site received a $225,000 grant and Mr CF is going to go over what this grant covers a little bit but because like other donations made by the public entities it has to go through a nonprofit organization and that's where I become involved in it so this is something that we were approved in December for 25,000 Mr CF and myself held a meeting an organizational meeting for it during the winter break and came up with how that money is to be spent but this time Mr CF will come up and he's going toh proceed with the presentation because this is his his baby so um thank you thank you all for your for your time thank you this the purpose of this grant is to take our learning platform
006called clever and provide it to families that don't have access so it's really like a grant all about Equity um so John thank you thank you very much for your support cind I might need your help so um extending the classroom um we know um we have mult families that don't have um Wi-Fi and devices at home um and so they can't access our high research related apps like Lexia that are a reading tutor um happy numbers which is number sense and um also epic reading at home and are you guys familiar at all with the the clever op that think okay so um thank you so with Mr Lopez and superintendent's support we have identified 36 families um to support and they're going to have devices new devices for two years that have the
007Wi-Fi embedded so they have um they have the Hotpot actually in the device and then those fans amilies um we will um so we've already collaborated with teachers and staff to identify the students I'm looking at student data we are prioritizing newcomer e students in Kenny vento it's something that Cindy lion and I and our Candace spinn it have talked about a long time how do we give students more opportunities at home um so we we're not going to give this parents devices we're going to have a reading Night Show how to use the device we're going to have our intervention teacher Karen cook have a group greeting we're going to collaborate with Sacramento Public Library the boy books and then we'll have a parent contract of what what's expected and if they are willing
008to do that work then we're going to give them the the Chromebook we are going to have weekly monitoring I was showing Mr Raven how we can go on the platform and monitor if the families are actually doing work and then we are going to have incentives for students that are completing work so it's a two-year program um and um a lot of thanks has to go to Mr Lopez he's purchasing the devices and he's setting them up and then um we will um take over any questions I do John is that sure enough great fantastic thank you Mr CF Mr Evan Lopez Foundation is next month you can expect me to start hammering about fireworks booth and if I get lucky it may be the last year that I have to do the Staffing
009work the work to get at staff but we're going to I'm going to try to get together with the principals within the next month and see if we can't get each School site to take a one day to provide St staing just for that for the all the shifts on that day and then also have them be able to provide a couple of bodies on the sixth and seventh day so that they are also staffs but that's a work in progress but hopefully I won't stress as much we'll before the end of the school year we'll actually have every slot filled so thank you any questions just again thank you thank you to you Mr kef and Mr Lopez and everyone well this is fantastic that's awesome okay roet Teachers Association classified student employee Association
010superintendent good evening um as Mr Barn said it is the first board meeting of the year so happy New Year um just a few things to report and then I'm going to give the rest of my time to Mr up Castillo so um I do want to say congratulations to Taylor Elementary they were the winner of the most recent attendance challenge um we had our first terrific T of the year and Mr Roberts um was our guest speaker again wonderful students and another shout out to our CH nutrition right wonderful meal um we are in our final stages of completing the application for the California Community Schools partnership program that um application I believe is due February 7th we will plan on submitting early but just to be clear we will not know the results
011until May 31st 2025 so we have a couple months to wait um and the next couple weeks I'll be attending the access superintendent Symposium as well as the um keple conference our February par parent empowerment dinner is on Thursday February 13th and our guest speaker will be Dr Luke wood the president of Sacramento um saak State University really excited and now I'll give the rest of my time to Mr Castile to give us a brief update on the budget this this is different now um good evening Board of members superintendent chain anybody who is present um here tonight in online um staff has attended three different um budget workshops so today we will give a very brief summary of the governor's proposal for 25 um 26 I want to start by saying that the budget
012The Proposal was developed prior to the fires in La that's very important so most likely it will change um but this is the latest information that that we know as a as at now and also is a lot of things is there's not a lot of details yet um a lot the trailer bills are developed uh usually in February one thing is that we will hear is that oh K12 has been is is lucky because there's no reduction there's no cut um our Cola for 2526 is 2.4.3 per. um you remember for this year is 1.07 so that is that is good news and we will talk more about more what that means this one okay so um one of the positive things both the governor's budget and the Alo are very online you know
013last year there were billions of dollars and difference there's some difference here by both in those those three Revenue sources the sales tax the corporate tax and the personal income tacts so they are very um their their projections are really close so that's why the buet is considered stable they're not considered a lot of risk about what is expected but again this is prior to the LA fires LA county has to do their taxes until later in the year and in November is the county LA county is the number one count in the nation um from from revenue so that potentially could change um the governor the calculation my is 120 120 uh billion ion dollar that we the laas are entitled but the budget proposes 117 I mean 118 billion dollar so what's the
014question is right there still what's happening with a with a difference so there's still some some um there will be probably a lot of conversations about versus the calculations that we entitled basus on the proposition because that's a calculation versus what the governor proposes um so our our biggest risk for us um we discussing in cabinet is really our um our our Cola is different than what we most potentially receive due to the decrease in enrollment decrease in Ada that we are experiencing so this is um u a reminder or funding is different between it's it's in DK to3 4 to 6 7 and 8 and 912 so the higher The Districts The Great school districts are unified they get higher Revenue than elementary schools uh I want to I highlight the one in the
015very number in the bottom we are required to go um 10 to1 for TK uh so we would probably at least have to additional class and the governor is proposing additional revenue or 3,252 to cover those additional cost for um 25 26 so this is a calculation that I there's a lot of numbers behind to calculate this number what do this mean for um Ro School District so we our average once we did that is um 14, 732 per Ada no no per students so students have to attend school when we calculate that by the projected Ada uh 1,786 we expect about 26.3 for million dollars um I this is really important because for for this year our projection for 2425 is our projected Ada is 1,811 so that is 23 less Ada for the
016following year and this is the number that we have for our P1 Ada so this is our latest so assuming that we continue the same for the following year that will be our Revenue however that could change ver on our Ada and and then enrollment so the 2.43 Ada that I explain earlier that could change right so this is 2.4.3 um right here I don't know I can point it but it he assumes that we maintain our enrollment in in in our Ada when you have declining enrollment that doesn't happen we had we found the best on the prior years or the average of the last three three years so that's some some calculations that that we need to do um so I just did this really Qui this is our continue uh increasing cost
017I just want to bring like Calpers you know for 252 is 27.4% increase for um so it's not the increase but the proi to increase from 27.5 to 27.4 this is a statatory um benefit that that we have to cover the pension cost are are high so what does this mean so we are starting in in in January we will adopt our budget based on the May Revis so then maybe we will um plan is equal change sometimes there's some years where the January is really close to the to the May so that's numbers and sometimes there significant significant significant changes so this is where we are right now and um thank you it's unavailable to answer any questions thank you I have questions um and some of this is I I I want to
018know more about budget in general um so you said us earned a lot of changes between um January and the May Revis but you know we had a really big fire so that's going to be something that might be that will impact the may like I said we every every every Source has tell us that uh they may be and the reason is that because the in California um the top 2% had a majority of the revenue very high earners in that area who are not doing their taxes by April 5 most as they have until November there a lot of corporations that is um I forgot how many numbers I think it's like I think it's 14 or the Fortune 500 um companies are in the count and then get affected so all of
019that will affect the funding for California we have have a lot of natural disasters throughout the history but this they say this is the biggest ever from the economic point point of view what what did destroy so so um it's just we had to see um what it is and uh and so that that's that's why um it's we have to do a lot of B with a lot of caution because a lot of uncertainties okay so we definitely have that that uncertainty and that that that that kind of talks about like how much we collect and when it comes in I have other questions and some of is specific to the fires so uh I know that they that there were a lot of schools lost in the fires what happens to the revenue
020that goes to those schools and I'm not trying to like a vulture but I know because I know that sometimes you know those students will go to maybe nearby schools and sometimes they go other places what what what happens in a situation like that do do you know yeah yeah we know that the the the state the governor and CD a lot of the they did a lot of um revisions to the requirements you know like where they they did a lot of independent study and flexibility class class sizes so that way they will continue so those District who got affected will continue to collect um the Ada Associated so they make it they were some days but um so most of those districts so um they they're trying they it was devastating there was
021some schools who had to relocate completely but they're trying the state is trying to hold those districts um Harless you know as much as as much as possible because the revenue is through through through through the through the Ada that's that's that's what we know there there was like five pages like you don't have to do this you don't have to trying to provide a lot of flexibility to those school districts okay so what if our Ada increases even temporarily because of something like this um you know a lot of um families were displaced some move all over the state if some come here we'd see an increase in Ada even if it's temporary even if it's for the rest of the year well that's very welcome that's very good good news for for the
022for for us because I don't think they will they will not uh if they come to us remember the Ada goes from the first day of school to P2 that is like the middle of March so your student will come now weal so we serving the students we can also collect the Ada but it will be only for um that will be a period of two and a half months so we will get like a quarter of the Ada versus a whole full year Ada that's that's just the way the the Ada the way Ada is calculated so you attend for a certain period for the for for a man you don't you don't you only get for the portion of that year okay um the slide that talked about the the the amounts that
023um that schools were getting per per grade perhaps this for superintendent because I know you have experience with you know um other school systems um can you tell tell me or do you know where the increase in funding goes I mean you know the difference between fourth and sixth grade and 9th 12th grade it's a pretty big difference you want me well well it is just just the way the pro uh local control funding formula was developed um before we used to get um one number per Ada and we when the about 14 years ago when the local control funding formula became that that high school district and mdle school say well that's not fair that you getting more because we have periods we have more cost so therefore the state developed this uh part
024of the governor Davis and those there was a lot so this is kind of like this you see a base right so that every District throughout the state gets the base no matter what so this is this is the minimum that we need that's the base and then the rest in that um then there a cola then after that it just depends on what what we call it duplicated account what our our percentage or what it is or free and people call it free and reduced that's how that's how why we we would get we were getting in our district we get like 14,000 Ada versus um 10,000 or or 10,44 because based on the students I think I went deeper than than than you as but it just depends on the great level that
025the state um develop does allow and if can add the great span adjustment for TK through three is because we have a required 24 to1 um class size average that doesn't apply to 4 through 7 and then the additional for 9th through 12 is to help with graduation requirements you know programs for graduation requirements yeah there used to be a form like that that's a good point that where they used to do uh K3 class size reduction there used to be a form that we need to complete and um and right now it's now it's part of the lcff calculation and if we don't meet those requirements the superintendent CH mentioned we get penalized by school from those classes redu it's a percentage or what we don't meet those those requirements I have one more
026question and you may not know the answer to this but I'm just curious um when we get a report like this does does it mirror um uh what happens in the community colleges and un ities and things I mean if we get a decent report do they get a decent report or is it kind of um give and take do you know do you ever discuss that we are part of the we are a part of the k14 um so it's a k14 uh um funding so I know that Community College I also they also attend so it's very their name is is not a local control but is that they have a formula very very similar and that's they do it based on based on enrollments in the classes that they they offer um
027in the University I don't know the the university level that's I'm not I'm not familiar enough to this is a different then I what I hear is that universities that you see and they are they are not happy with a cake 14 because they say oh you're getting they're getting reductions but we are not so that's what I when I start a conversation is it's a stable and they say even though it's not enough to cover all our cost they say you should be happy because you are getting Cola we now we're getting reductions that's that's what I that's what I so that's what I hear that sounds about right yeah thank you you're welcome thank you any other questions I think and now our n is our um is is our um PA we
028have board reports okay yeah I was wondering Part B to that okay so board Now we move on to board member reports trusty Divine nothing at this time trusty Cardon nothing to report I see hel starts I'll save my comments to the end okay and the only thing I have is that I did receive my form 700 uh notification you probably all receiv received yours too so again I attended the session at csb on form 700 and it really is scar me so you know encouraging everyone to submit theirs as soon as possible um and also um I would love I I I did see that um I didn't click on it but during the form 700 I saw the little AB something or other number um that talked about the training um so do
029we have any more information about the training U meeing that requirement n not at this time okay well that concludes our reports we'll move on to uh item five uh presentations and information our very first report we only have a few tonight um but our very first report is uh the fiscal audit report yeah um our partner Brian Hal is doing a presentation um they were going to do that there will be here on person at the last board meeting because we we changed yet now we're going to they're going to do it they have a other commitments in other districts or the board meetings because they do a lot of um adds through throughout the state so he will do the presentation through uh on online Brian you can start now good evening I'm
030I appreciate the opportunity that you're giving me to present the audit report to the board this evening um I thought what I would try to do is just give a brief overview of the of the audit report and then if there were specific questions I could try to answer those H after um and and you know what I do when I look at an audit report whether it's one that our firm prepared or another CPA firm prepared I always do these three things um the first thing I do is I look at page one of the audit report that's the opinion letter um that's you know the the audit reportage you can see is about a 100 pages long but that first page the auditor's opinion is the most important page in the audit report
031and there's basically four opinions that you can get in a governmental audit one is an unmodified opinion um and that's what Robla received that's that's the best opinion and what that means is that the financial statements fairly present the financial position of the of the district at June 30224 and as I said an unmodified opinion is the best opinion that you can receive the three other opinions that you can get which are a qualified opinion an adverse opinion and a disclaimer of opinion they only occur if there's problems with the financial statements and uh you know we've never we've never had issues like that with with Roa um then I look at I I look at the the statement of net position and the statement of activities which are on pages 11 and 12 of
032the audit report and they're just the basic financial statements you know the statement of net position is a uh it's a balance sheet but for a governmental entity you call it the statement of net position and it list lists the assets and the liabilities Or List what you own own and what you owe and the statement of activities is an income statement but it's called the statement of of activities for a governmental entity and it lists the revenue and expenses of of the district um I then skip all the way to the back of the audit report and there's a section that's called schedule of Auditors results and there's a section that's called um uh schedule of findings and question costs and I look at those to see if there are findings and a finding
033is something that needs to be brought to the attention of the board uh it would be something that we found in our testing that was not in compliance with the requirements of the uh California Department of Education or the state controller and it would need to be brought to the attention of the board and reported to those two governmental agencies the state controller and the um and the uh California Department of Education and as a result of our testing uh for the year ended June 30 2024 there were no findings that needed to be reported and so that means that uh in we didn't find anything as the results of our testing that needed to be changed or or fixed okay and then the last thing that I do is I turn to the very
034last page of the audit report and it's a schedule of Prior year audit findings and in this section I looked to see if there were findings that were reported on the prior year report so that would be for for the year ended June 30 2023 that were and we have to report to the California Department of Education whether those findings were resolved during the current year and there was one finding in the prior year uh related to independent studies some of the independent study Master agreements didn't contain all of the required information and that find and that finding was completely resolved for the year ended June 30 2024 and so you know that's that that's what I do when I look at these audit reports if you look at the accountants opinion and you look
035to see uh you you look at the assets and liabilities and the the the change in financial position or the excess of revenues over expenses and you see if there were findings and if the prayer your findings were resolved you get a a pretty good idea of the financial uh position and the uh of the district and you get also get a good idea of the the status of the internal control over the over the uh financial information and so um you know that's just what I do um if you had any specific questions regarding the audit report I could answer those questions for you at this time any questions thank you thank you no questions thank you so much for going over like what pages specifically to look at and making it a little
036easier for me to understand it it's greatly appreciated thank you you know there's so much information in that audit report sometimes it's over whelming but those basic things will will you know will lead you will alert you to to problems if there are any okay and thank you Mr Castillo for making sure that we continue to get such great reports at is a teamw work from everybody so yeah the school principls right here they work really hard to make sure we are in compliance with independent studies thank you thank you okay our next report a roblet teacher professional growth system or RT pgs update there's started good evening hi I'm superintendent Chen um my name is Cheryl Coker my colleague Alis um we are the peer peer facilitators that support the rtgs um Roo teacher
037professional growth system and you're going to see that rtgs um acronym a lot tonight a little bit easier um it's a big mouthful um you're also going to hear us refer to anyone participating in r tpgs as practitioners and those completing the evaluations as facilitators um with that in mind here is the update for the 2425 school year there we go all right so new for this year um we added two new evaluation types the preschool special day class and the Performing Arts um the preschool SDC addresses um the unique teaching context and blends elements from both the special day class and the preschool evaluation types um the Performing Arts um was created in response to our new uh music position and it was written using the Visual and Performing Arts standards um that will
038allow for a variety of Performing Arts um such as drama dance or choir as well as music um in response to feedback that we received from practitioners last year we wrote um new goal setting menus to help our teachers um draft and create their goals as well as we create created um a library of walkthrough videos to support practitioners as they were navigating our online platform called Frontline so with the addition of those two new evaluation types we now have a total of 18 different evaluation types each with a multi-dimensional approach um there are kind of four broad categories of evaluation types that we do based on their for um the format of the evaluation um so our teacher group includes classroom teachers resource English learner support teachers and intervention um their evaluation is based
039on the sore frame um that acronym Sor s o a r stands for strategic observation and reflection um and those teachers select from one of three frames um our enrichment teachers art PE technology and now Performing Arts um their evaluation type is also based on sore but adds um the standards from their area of specialty The Specialist Group um encompasses a variety of practitioners um School psychologists social workers speech language Pathologists um there's a whole group there School nurses SDC peer facilitators psts preschool SDC and program Specialists um all of those evaluation types are based on domains that are tied to the um profession and our last category are the early childhood and that's the preschool and transition kindergarten teachers um their evaluation type is based on the class tool um that's the classroom assessment
040scoring system all right so this year um classroom teachers represent um majority of the participants with 58% the next largest group are our specialists at 24% um The Early Childhood Educators and um enrichment teachers each at 9% um as part of RTP GS we also monitor how often practitioners participate in the growth cycle um within the growth system there are four different tracks so track one um include our temporary intern and probationary practitioners um and they participate in the program every year until they reach permanent status track two is our permanent practitioners with three to nine years experience they participate every other year uh track four are permanent practitioners with 10 to 14 years experience in Robla they participate every three years and finally we have our new track four um our permanent practitioners for
04115 or more years in railo and they participate every five years so you can see for the 2425 school year um the majority of participants are those um track one intern and probationary employees 68 % this year track two 23% track three 9% um and this year we do not have any track four practitioners scheduled for review um that large percentage of track one those probationary and interns is a trend that we continue to see over time um you can see that steady increase of those probationary and um interns over the years um in the last few years uh it has almost doubled um so my colleague Marcos is going to share a little bit more about the impact of that trans thank you Cheryl and thank you everybody for your time so here we
042can see uh the number of practitioners that each facilitator is currently working with probationary and intern teachers or or practitioners are required to work with a a principal or director during the review cycle and as the last graph Illustrated about 2third of our this year's uh practitioners are probationary or intern status and as a result uh our our principles and our directors have fairly High case loads this year and this graph shows the number of participants over the past few years as well as projections for the next two uh each year shows the total number of practitioners broken down into a permanent probationary intern status and if you take a look at year this year year 2425 compared to our projections for next year 2526 uh you'll you'll notice that the number of probationary and
043intern teachers looks to go down uh whereas the number of permanent status teachers in review will stay about the same and that's due to the fact that a number of our current probationary status teachers will uh will be reach permanent status this year or next year and they'll be out of cycle uh until year 2627 when they'll be back on cycle and you'll see a pretty large increase in the number of permanent status teachers who will be in review that year okay oh one thing to keep in mind though is that this data will be somewhat fluid as teachers leave and enter the school district WR way there we go uh practitioner feedback is very important to the professional growth system practitioners have access to an anonymous feedback form which allows them to uh share
044thoughts about what's what's helped them throughout the review cycle as well as make suggestions as uh to ways we can we can improve the program um Cheryl shared some examples earlier of ways that practitioner feedback helps us refine the program uh a couple additional resources we created this year um goal setting menus and Frontline walkthrough videos are the result of feedback we received from practitioners and here are some comments that were submitted last review cycle if you wouldn't mind taking just a quick moment to to read over those um as you can see these these comments illustrate some of the benefits practitioners are are seen from participating in the review cycle as well as some suggestions that have us develop supports for them as for next steps we'll continue to use that feedback um from
045practitioners to refine and improve the system uh as well as develop an inclusion specialist evaluation type uh which is going to be tailored to the specific responsibilities of that role which is fairly new to the district and thank you for uh for hearing the current status of the Roa teacher professional growth system if you have any questions we'd be happy to to answer them thank you question I do not have anything this time thank you absolutely one question you know I I see the number of people teachers who retire every year but I never really track that so how does that I mean how many how many do we um lose per year and gain that that that impact these numbers that does impact our is not great in terms of like the coming and
046going um because one um practitioner retires then we would have a new one come in and they start as that track one where they're more frequent um it depends on like who's being replac somebody a lot of experience that only every five years versus somebody who was maybe three and every other year so there about 43 different yeah it's a little bit of a moving Target but you Haven noticed any like Nali right like you know it's kind of going down and up or way down or anything with the year 2021 there was a bit of a drop as a result of the pandemic and and the roll out of the system happening around the same time and so that's leading to a little bit of a EB and flow of the number of people
047who are who are practitioners at at any given point Thank you absolutely thank you very much okay item C 2024 25 School plan for student achievement or S update school there's three presentations um good evening uh Rob School board member superintendent Chen um I think you all know me I'm Lisa Hall I'm the proud principal at um the lab new school and tonight I'm going to give a brief update on our data and our response to data and it's connection to our school site plan the right so in this first slide it's an overview of the ELA cast data for the past three years and when we look at this slide we should not only be looking at the trend and the grade level data but comparing the same group of students as they move
048as they promote throughout the grades I've included some bullet points highlighting some of the school's response to data and I want to point out that um Bell Avenue continues to focus on glad strategies as we feel they benefit all students at our sites um but especially our El students I also want to highlight our practice of examining data as a staff as we receive it as soon as we receive it we're looking at it and teachers are are identifying um areas of growth as well as deficit areas and individual students who are not making appropriate progress and planning interventions and supports that are happening in the classroom so the tier one interventions setting goals for the students and then revisiting um progress monitoring and revisiting at the mid TR and then again at trimester and
049the teachers share out at um so at our next staff meeting which is Tuesday they'll share out their um progress in comparison to the goal that they set for the students that they were um had identified as students needing those tier one interventions um so that's coming up next staff meeting um so those are just a couple of things but we have quite a few um things that we do to respond to the data um as we're as we're receiving it okay so the second slide here is our Ela scores for the past three years by subgroup one of the subgroups I want to highlight tonight is our students with disabilities as you can see um the students in this subgroup the data has been trending downward for three years um so that's something as
050a staff that we are highly focused on trying to find ways to bridge what is happening in general education classrooms with um the students IEP goals and the instruction that they're receiving in special education so um we feel as a staff in our conversations we feel that we're not um we are struggling to make the the grade level materials accessible to the students so that when they're in the gened classroom they're participating um and and um and as engaged as they need to be in order to show that growth so um we have um we're working to create more opportunities for collaboration between our special education Specialists and our gened teachers and we're also using AI quite a bit at this point to um take grade level material and then um simplify it simplify directions
051and things like that so that kids are able to access the grade level curriculum or grade level content standards um but and and work independently in the classroom so that's just one or a couple of strategies that we're using so for this next slide this is our um math data again it's over a three-year period of time and we are looking at not only the grade level spans but we're looking at groups of kids that are promoting through um as they promote through the grade level we um as a staff again we're tracking and analyzing data as quickly as we receive it um and then planning tier one interventions setting individual goals and and then reporting reporting out as a staff and at Mid Tri and trimester we also really encourage the use of exit
052tickets or um as like a quick check frequently as frequently as possible so that we're easily identifying kids that need that support right away because in math um it's hard to tr as they as they may take like a unit one test on multiplication and then unit two test might be on Geometry so they're they're changing the focus of the um the curriculum standards or the grade level standards changes frequently as they're moving through the curriculum and so you're not really com you're not really comparing the same standards often and so we want to make sure that we're quickly identifying kids that maybe didn't get it so that we can um help support them immediately um because the next unit is probably not necessarily going to be based on the same standards um and we
053want to make sure that they get it before we move on okay so this slide here is a threee comparison by subgroup and again I want to highlight that our students with disabilities at Bell Avenue School are not making progress um the expected progress and so again we're really focused on that particular group of kids making sure that they not only um are the General Ed teachers a highly aware of their IEP goals but also how how can we bridge what's happening in the gened classroom to what's happening in in the special education department and um finding ways to again make sure that when our students with disabilities are um in their General Ed classroom that they're accessing the curriculum and they're as engaged as as they um as as engaged Learners in the classroom
054okay so that's something that we're we're really focused on and and working on okay the next slide here is an overview of um our English language prog um the progress for our English language learners and overall our students made small growth or they remained the same the only place that we saw a little bit of a decrease and it was a it was a good decrease was um we were looking at um English language Learners who decreased one L Pack level we we saw a decrease in that score which was good um but overall we are not seeing any major changes um small increases or they're remaining the same one thing that we're um looking at at Bell and I'm I'm sure they're doing this at the other schools as well is is um our
055teachers have the ability to look at the elpac like iabs like practice tests and that's not something that we've done in the past so that's something we're just starting to scratch the surface on and that would be um all of our our teachers in grades one through six are going to be working in advance with the kids so that the kids um when they see the test they have more familiarity with it in the past we've done a lot of work with iabs for cast testing but not the lpac so we're going to try it this year and see if it helps a little bit okay so our next um our next goal is is um for um increasing parent um involvement and this is this slide just shows a few of our strategies that
056we're using to increase parent involvement um probably the biggest difference this year is that we're really using our skoy caregiver um our our family Navigator and she has been presenting parent workshops at our school it's not quite once a month there'll be six by the end of the school year and these are just kind of a list of what what has happened so far um there's we did kind of an over overview of school tools and supports for caregivers um just last week we did cyber bullying and social social media safety and then in the future um they're going to start talking about building a safe School Community they're doing a um workshop on seal navigating separate households we have a lot of kids that are living in Split households and so um there she's
057going to present a workshop on how to navigate that and and continue to support um support the kids um in in school and then the last one um the focus is going to be on substance um use awareness sry split split household meaning um students are going back and forth between two households so we often have students that um have you know even a simple thing as a backpack or um you know School tools or things like that they're have they're struggling to to navigate having to travel back and forth between you know midweek transfers between parents and things like that so she's going to have um she's going to give some strategies and talk about that like not only organizational strategies but communication and and things like that that we have found can be
058really challenging ing um this next week um we have a big family event coming up it's our explor at science night it's usually very well attended um and that's next Thursday from 6:00 to 7:30 if anyone's interested in coming okay the last one this is our last slide this is um about school climate and student engagement the graph that you see up there is our Bell Avenue attendance for the last 2 years this is our actual attendance not our dashboard attendance so the graph you'll see is um it's organized by the past two years and it's organized by subgroup you can see that we um have seen improvement from one year to the next overall we are just slightly below 94% attendance rate at Bell Avenue and we have experienced a positive trend in attendance
059in all subgroups some of the strategies that we're employing to improve our attendance is earlier intervention so we starting at the TK and the Kinder level the other thing that we did a little bit differently this year was We went through all of the report cards with the teachers before parent teacher conferences and students that we identified as being you know as like okay we they're maybe they're not chronically absent yet but they're kind of on that Trend um Mr Foley and I worked with teachers and and just helped them to create some talking points with parents around the attendance data that is on the report card um also you know one of the things at Bell is that we make a point to be very visible as a staff we're out in front every
060day of the school greeting parent greeting kids as they arrive and we're out there in front again as they leave and so the kids know that when they don't come to school we notice and I feel like I mean it seems like a really simple thing but it's super important um that the kids know that if they don't show up somebody's going to miss them so that's something that um we make sure that we are um greeting kids um if they didn't come we're asking them hey we missed you yesterday so glad to see you um welcome back and um and then making sure that kids um feel that they've been seen and um seen every day at school so and that they're part of our school community and that's all I have are there
061any questions or comments you I I have one or a couple um why does the attendance report different demographics than the sub comparisons me I guess I'm not understanding your question oh well in in the sub comparisons you have black white asian Hispanic English Learners students with disabilities because um some of our subgroups don't have enough students in them and so the data doesn't show up because it's too it it it is um they it doesn't show up because it is in um Jeopardy of like almost identifying individual students because the subgroups are so small forgive me for not rec calling remembering how many or the demographics but how many students with disabilities do you have yeah like yeah 50 to 60 kids it's there's a crossover between speech and language and then we've got
062our SDC class as well as our RSP students so probably more than that actually you thank you sure yay um good evening board members superintendent chin Ramone um my name is Michelle Chris I am the principal at Taylor Street Elementary and I am here to present our um sip update for December January 2025 I do this there we go um so first couple slides are our room for improvement slides um this is our current dashboard um and we're focusing just on the four um demographic groups African-American student with disabilities El and homeless um what we're doing currently as you can see there's some orange and Rit there is um peer observations our focus our site Focus for K2 is phonics and our um grades three through six is reading comprehension um our wind Focus which
063is what I need um is implemented and is structured 30 minutes a day um the focus is also phonics and um book clubs So reading comprehension things of that nature our extended day which is our K2 is also on Phonics so that word phonics is coming up quite a bit um because we saw the need as a staff for that found foundational that foundational piece with reading additionally we are partnered with skoy kuang um was here yes yesterday um working with um primarily our new teachers around phonic the phonics lesson and she'll come and observe along with our admin on Monday of those teachers doing the lesson um in a form of our own internal kind of peer observations but really it's going to be cang and um the admin with our new teachers around
064the lesson that um we with her um formulated yesterday um around phonics um again we have plst support um PD for ELA Shannon Canon just um did a wonderful PD around again phonics um and our teachers really really had really great feedback around that similar to Bell every staff meeting we are talking about data um and teachers are bringing data to the staff meetings um and we're using that to help Drive our instruction um in addition we have an addition this year of our African-American umun Outreach and I put her on there because she does provide additional support for the group um the African-Americans in addition there are other students she does see but primarily her Outreach is with African-American students any questions okay our other um slide for improvement um is just increase math
065so this one we have a we're moving in the right direction um math perer observations I put that down because we were really heavy on that last year and so internally we've done a couple with teachers group um great level teachers have done it with each other um around math so um and again staff meetings we are talking um about data so they're bringing data to um the different staff meetings and we're using that to help Drive our instruction as a group um again I'm mentioning our African-American uh commun Outreach he's pulling groups as well um in support um for all um subjects and um I just wanted to acknowledge that that's happening we have our intervention support as well she's helping with um we have uh quite a few combo classes this year um
066we have a 2 three and a 4 five um in addition to our um gate classes which are a 3 four and a 56 so our intervention support has really been helping with the math support in that um with our second graders and then our accounting collections making sure we are kind of honing in on that and continuing that for that basic um math foundational um skills with our kiddos and what's not on here is our African-Americans did double um increased their scores from last year um and along with our homeless students as well so um with our elpi again um there was some consistency um on the bottom part of this graph but up top um we have some work to do and so there is an intentional focus on ELD I mentioned when
067which is our wi time and what I need that's our designated down below ELD portion and this year what's different is we're utilizing our wonders curriculum um using those assessments for um each uh section as you will um around ELD and so we're using that data and we're also bringing that to our staff meetings um as we kind of when time is fluid looking at how our Els are um reading and writing and speaking as well and then our El teacher pulls what we call a second dose of students so she'll see students um earlier in the day and then also in the afternoon as well um and then again we have our designated and integrated ELD throughout the day um and so these are the slides I was really looking forward to I was
068looking forward to all of them but um our increase in parent involvement um those top two pictures are are what we implemented called walking Wednesday so every Wednesday morning before the school bell rings parents are out walking with students and it's a really great sight to see because it's in you know promoting Health but then also a sense of community that parents are um and they're wanting to do it in fact they ask for more days but we're right now um just working with The Walking Wednesdays I'm mentioning our aaca is also there with Outreach um our parent Square communication that has been happening I also want to acknowledge our B coas they've been doing a great job with Outreach as well um for different various events our school event on the bottom left was
069our winter festival that happened um in late December we had a great turnout in fact it was really warm in our cafeteria um and next year we're thinking of maybe splitting um the presentations for primary and intermediate I mean yeah primary intered because it was filled to capacity probably over um and then on our bottom we have um various events um um that was our ready for Rob not ready for Rob but it was our event with um United Way um where families came out which was a really great event um and from there we gained Partnerships with the Sacramento Public Library where our remix dance group performed a k Quanza event um Sac Republic has come out and worked with our students because of this event um we've had great back to school events
070um our H Festival was wonderful um I want to acknowledge it's not on here but our PTO and our elac and school Council has increased in parent participation we just had a mental health workshop on Tuesday um it was great we had quite a few parents show up for that and that was in connection with our skoy clinicians uh we're encouraging reading buddies U starting next month for parents to come and read with their their child or another student um a couple days a week uh we have a lot of parent participation on field trips um and then just we've been parents have been reaching out to help with school beautification as well so we're going to be starting off projects um to help beautify our school um next our student um building School climate
071and people engagement this is a really great um I guess you say chart for me or table it shows us in the blue and green uh with suspensions that means we're those aren't happening as much as they used to and a lot of that is um give a shout out to the staff and the just the overall culture at Taylor Street with implementation of our restorative room and practices schoolwide um we didn't have the room per se the beginning of the year just because of spacing but we were still able to continue um that restorative approach with students um our PBIS assemblies we have those once a month various um character traits uh we have culture assemblies as well this is something new we started um student store is active in running students love that
072it's every Friday they can earn PBIS points and go and Shop um at the store uh we had Sammy circuit came the students love him he's a celebrity um and he's really positive and and encouraging students to make great decisions we have our fun fridays and then our parent communication um in fact we've been using parent Square quite a bit um this year so I think that's all help it's helping in contributing to our overall um School culture and my last slide would be um this was a twin day and they all have on their perfect attendance shirts H would be our attendance I think that's huge I give a huge shout out to my sart team which consists of my assistant principal front office um and my social worker who do they do a
073wonderful job holding SAR meetings and sarb um just making sure those are happening and then following through we have a script that our front office uses when students are absent um we have attendance incentives um and then again the parent communication similar to what um Lisa shared about the attendance we're going in the right direction um with our attendance I'm very proud of our community over at Taylor Street and I'm hopeful we continue this this route I did not get to put my picture uh this week we took for our attendance but um it's out there U and thank you if you have any questions thank you I have um on on the suspension page um you've got four demographics three of them went to zero and African-Americans it went down but it's still a
0741.2% are there um what about the other demographics do they all go to zero or they all to zero so African Americans is the only one that's that's still not zero yeah um but I think I want to say I believe this year it is but yeah so the African-Americans were only and I um I'm trying to think back because I know the students so well um but I think what's happening to um in addition to having our aaca building relationships um with students and families and making that connection is is going to be um oh I know it is a great addition to that so that that can eventually go down to zero as well okay so can you talk about the 1.2 1.2 I'm trying to think about when that was I think
075it was probably a beginning of the year student um and I want to say using our Swiss data we were able to kind of work with the student and after that there was no repeat of that 1.2 two students so 1.2 represents one student one student yeah and it was in the beginning of the year you mentioned a public library what are you doing with them so they've been coming out um well they came out last semester and they've been working with the students around soccer um skills and um and the students love it they in fact they bring their own soccer balls and they sign them and things like that but that came about the public library oh I'm sorry said St public I'm soccer ball sack Public Library her name was Ashley she
076was the branch manager she was at the like I said the United Way event and I just asked her I said we want partnership with you so my whole school has done a field trip to the Del Paso Heights library and we made that happen with her and a lot of the students that was the first time going to a public library and I realized most of them said oh I could walk there you know I didn't know that was there and then from that she invited us to perform our remix dance group um to perform at the K Quanza um celebration and then she would also like to come to the Black History Month dinner um and just do partnership she did say the library will be closing and she would like to do
077on Wednesdays a stem class for the community so I will talk with herard um about making that happen as well the library will be closing yeah they're remodeling the um parking lot one I mean the um Heights the Grand Avenue Grand Avenue yeah in fact they were supposed to do it in December but they pushed it back to March so she wants to use she asked if she could use my um the library at Taylor I think 3 to 4 on Wednesday okay so temporary to closing theary yeah yeah sorry was there an increase in library cards and things in fact before they went we had them filled out Library applications and so when they got there they were able to give them an actual library card huge increase yeah which is what I wanted
078I mean we're we're pushing as you can see the phonics and the reading for our kiddos yeah you Miss chispy have a question I I maybe I'm confused with these numbers that um we're talking about the A and the math when you put this number 65 minus 65.8 that is students is percentage of we talking about is it percentage or it's a percentage no oh points from the yeah from the standard so okay from the standard that they didn't score on how how much low of the standard yeah from the standard that they didn't meet yeah right question so no category or no group was hitting standards is that what you're saying they all way below all way below and in particular because we're focusing just on these four but yeah and according to the
079the little um picture up top yeah it says overall Taylor is in the orange for MTH and Ela but these particular groups um this is their points away from standard but when you read homeless in 2023 they were negative n they were 97 points from standard moving to 89.7 so they've made growth it's still distance from standard correct but I'm going to celebrate the little growth absolutely yeah yeah we just MH other questions thank you thank you so um thank you Robo School Board superintendent Chen for the time um as you look at the Roa Mustangs um emblem we are second in academic performance to Bell Avenue Tigers we are coming after them if you're out there on the YouTube go Mustangs but Lisa I just want to say thank you for your glad so
080thank you so um for Wow and I just I I've got to tell you I just had my eyes checked yesterday and I have a cataract so it's kind of blurry do you mind if I work can I work that way mind if I stand up that way and talk to you guys is that okay if I go over there closer to the screen oh they cannot hear you they cannot hear you and the so um disgusting this is kind of embarrassing so don't enjoy this so um we um have just made a bold decision and um you must know that in our district 80% of our third graders can't read that's the whole District we have made a bold decision to increase our resources the intervention teacher and start supporting K through two so
081um it's put pressure on 3 through six to do more small group instruction in the classroom can rep that 0% of our third graders cannot read so we we we can look at the dashboard later but but we have when you look at the Casp testing to read that grade level it's it's what and so we have to do different things differently so um we are supporting K through2 and we'll talk more about that um you can see one of the groups we're kind of keeping an eye on we know um our special or students with disabilities with Mr penman's support we had the Shannon Cannon go in and um work with them and help them identify groups so they know the standards they know their students and they know how to group their students
082per the standard um this year we taught the parents how to use their clever how to use clever so back to school night we had two we had one for primary one for intermediate and um so those families now know how to use the online platform um and and we also did that as one of our sco nights we've increased student recognition and awards with priz PRI for prizes for Lexia the reading platform and um and then also at our PBIS assemblies um we are increasing we haven't been doing a great job teaching students how to take the test so um all teachers receive their student ID cards their state ID so they can take the practice test and they are expected to do that starting this month in January um and our our teacher
083meetings are more explicit to Accurate support so um students have access to the curriculum the other thing in February we have glad training we know that our students don't pref form well um in writing and responding to um non-fiction text and that's a big part of the Casp so our February 4th training is specific to writing in math um there's a book Douglas Reeves it's all about um when you have PLC times in the professional learning communities are specifically about math we don't do all of other school sites do a lot of different things in these RS are specific to math so the teacher looks at how they're teaching math they work with their grade level partner they look at their math tests the other thing we're focusing this year is having more um kinesthetic
084and visual things for students so it's a more Dynamic delivery um we really appreciate Mr penman's support for uh per our plst we just the last couple days we've done instructional rounds where the instructional barriers between teachers goes down and teachers see like there's a buzz on our campus Because Miss malvini she did this amazing first grade math lesson and guess what everybody's talking about it and it's like wow everybody's talking about like that was a wow performance and in teaching you don't get that feedback so I went up to her today and had that like face to face like wow you wowed people um we are increasing the usage of Mobi Max mob Max is a platform where you can just specifically um track kids on math facta you can set it up to
085whatever they need to work on Lexia reading we've underutilized Lexia reading it's a professional really expensive reading tutor set up by speech language pathologist so we are more intentionally using that the one thing I wanted to mention is if you take the third grade math test it is reading dependent so we know that that these scores are kind of connected together so uh like we said before we're going to be uh test taking Pros to overtake the Bell Tigers I did say that okay so on to um English language Learners um our site has a lot of students that aren't making great progress and they're flat so in the past we've had win rotations and win is where every student on campus for 30 minutes gets what they need including the e students but those
086rotations um sometimes depending on absences or a teacher that has a change in a schedule have like broken this year I've covered um Miss coil I've covered so when rotations don't cancel so the students we continue that rotation I talked about the Glad training um they're going to do um something that will help scaffold or support elel students on February 4th and then we are going to sit down and have face-to-face discussions with the El those students to so they understand why they don't want to be a sixth grader and not be um exited out of e so when they go to middle school and they go to Norwood they have a choice on what classes they take and they don't have to take English twice the other things that the students they don't always
087know that they they do well in the elac but they don't do well on the Casp and they don't put forth their best effort that can keep them there and they won't be um they won't be exited okay parent involvment is something that we know we have to improve on our big thing is skoy collaboration we have a charter bus coming to our school site tomorrow because skoy likes what we're doing for family engagement and Par parent engagement um there going to be people from all over Northern California to see what Marcy Bia has done with her intern and they've had four family nights and they've had four C collaborations were they meet with families and talk about financial literacy um they just sit and talk I emailed um superintendent chin because one of them
088through an interpreter change um shared they really felt fear about coming to school in this client in this political climate and it just kind of so it's been a really great access for our biggest student group and family group is um our his Hispanic um families so we've we've done similar to Michelle um with PBIS assemblies we have character traits and we are intentionally uh finding students that maybe have never got an award and um making sure that our awards are inclusive and we find all students being successful we we utilized our intern Mr Abraham um to help make Community Sur survey phone calls he's bilingual and we wanted our biggest uh family group is they speak Spanish we needed to know so I personally asked him to make a lot of phone calls we
089need you to do this survey we want to know what help you need um we've Mr Raven's been really supportive we've had multiple conversations about Community Schools Mr gap's really excited about Community Schools so we've had it many times in there School site Council meetings um we've recruited new members and um we have a a Roba parent teacher club and we've we've had our family movie night that was um well attended and then February 7th we have a dance um for um it's called it's get your cowboy boots ready it's called the a robo Roundup so it's our dance okay um our build our school climate and student engagement um I'm really excited we our team we have um people getting support um and learning building capacity our PBIS team and our mtss teams they
090were today at a check in checkout and if you don't know what that is for students that don't feel connected to school we pair them with an uh a staff member and they check in with them and they check out we've uh the whole staff we've um we've taught our um teachers about the T 10 two plan and I have four students right now that are on that plan and what you do is you go and for 10 days straight you go out of your way you find them and you spend two minutes with them you don't talk about school you don't talk about their school workor you talk about them as a person and you try to see students so we're we're training our teachers and all of our staff to do that um
091I'm really proud of uh for chronic absenteeism Stephanie Coyle our assistant principal and Hillary crook have probably had 40 Fam Family meetings to talk about um how we can support them with attendance and like I spoke previously we've increased student acknowledgement the PBS assemblies um and right now our big thing is we have a student assembly we're not doing the assemblies anymore we have a group of students that are planning the assemblies and we know from Casa and from another um like um administrative training that I went to like like it it works better when the students run things and the students have a voice including cafeteria so we're try to hand over some of our leadership to the [Music] students so um in summation I just want you to know that our number one
092agenda on our on on my staff of agenda every every week is Staff selfcare we've had some really interesting we did restorative practices last year we trained staff so we do like Community circles and wow it really gives you the temperature of what's happening at a school site we did one after break we had all kinds of stuff that just came out about how people's break went some celebration some and it really just helps you know what's happening with your staff and but one of those Community circles is always talking about what are we doing to take care of ourselves and education where you can give endlessly we know we have to improve School climate um number two I'm GNA blame on Chuck because I got erased and I'm kidding Chuck um our math instruction
093rounds we're really excited about that thank you the one thing I didn't mention which um has been really great for our staff so far thanks to Janet is Sam dren if you can imagine every one of our brains in here being neurod Divergent and every one of us thinking about something different than probably what I'm saying that's what the teachers are up against and so our teachers are learning like you can't just force it you have to teach it differently so um we really appreciate that opportunity and some of the teachers aren't liking it because they like to teach how they teach but that doesn't work for all students we really like the opportunity of collaborating with scoy with Miss Marcy viia but you have to know B we have to do a better job
094with our school environment it has to be great and right now it's good our parent environment we have to give parents more opportunities and teach parents how to help us and then I talked about our instructional walls and barriers and lastly US changing with Community Schools like changing our perspective like it the community schools and thanks to Mrs chain is not like what's wrong with the community it's like how do we build out ass ETS it's like there are assets out there like really great families and really great cultures but how do we um recognize that and build on that okay Mr pman did I go over my seven minutes you didn't tiny okay any questions and and I'm honestly embarrassed about being up there so don't think that this was planned my eyes I
095couldn't read them I'll have glasses next the next one I'm still you said 80% of our students can't read I I after that I I kind of yeah so I don't know if anybody else wants to comment on that I'll I'll let somebody yeah thank you on the Casp are they like what grade level are third graders falling at like are they at kindergarten level first grade level so I I don't know my computer's right there I could pull up the Lexia and show you but I think what the Lexia is already differentiating for those students I think like Mr Penman somehow I think it's something that um superintendent chin is thinking about it's something that we have to know that there are that many students like 70% that when they take the Casp it's
096it's really challenging because it's it's hard for them to read at grade level and that grade level third grade some of those I taught third grade are we not identifying students who need IEPs or testing case to see if they have like dyslexia or other reading comprehension skills in this grade level like how is 80% of our students this far behind on a basic need they can't they will never succeed in math or science or anything if they cannot read to professional Fe I agree and and I do but I do know that Janet supports us we um have ssts a student study team meetings I was in two I three IEPs today so it's like we have all those meetings but I'm telling you there is something there and it might be Community Schools
097where we can um have better connection with Sac library we can have more um exposure to print I think when you look at some of the data and it could be the preschool and having more um families and better Outreach and more of our students participate there's I we could go on and talk about this a lot but what we know is there's a couple things that happened our we at Roa had a couple years where we didn't have a lot of students that had went to preschool so when we came in and you Mr pman could show you the data there were students that know no letters and no sounds now if you go to Roseville you go to Elk Gro most of those students um like 4 at 4 are reading so right
098away we're that we're behind um the other factor is summer so students learn a lot and then there's a dip between Kinder and F first and this isn't the average in other districts this isn't the norm is it I I don't I don't I know that um we we can do that and get you those numbers and if you want me to do a little report I will do that for you I would really for I would appreciate that because 80% is unacceptable well I'm GNA say I'm sorry I'm about to C well I I know Mr Raven and I have and I'm telling you it's serious but in ours we're at 28 we're at 28% of third grade what it was last year so it is it is something but um okay well thank
099you for letting us know okay hi thank you we can definitely give an update I think we need to also um just provide some clarity too I'm not excusing data when we say the number of students can read versus being at grade level standards right so I do agree that as Mr Penman said um our students are reading the question that we're looking at is reading comprehension as well as fluency and understanding their grade level standards so um Mr cap stated probably if I look at the data 2% of his grade level um third graders were meeting standards that is correct that 72 are not not um but the comment about that they are unable to read I think we need to look more into that versus they are unable to read or comprehend at
100their grade level and I was as I was looking at backtracking um last years's third graders um were prek TK during um covid right so the following year when their kindergarten was distance learning 2021 and we do know that um you know their instruction was compromised and that um the phonics the phic is focused on K through two right so not making excuses but I will say that we probably will come back and provide some clarity regarding um being able to read versus reading at grade level standards and comprehension at grade level this breaks my heart I I get that you know it's not that I get that they can read and there difference between reading read at Great level but that's you know I mean that's at the point of major intervention you know
101that's you know and not making any excuses but I I would also like to put some things into perspective thinking about what were those deficiencies five years ago six years ago um because I think that would also help to create some clarity um as well and looking at what those numbers look like across the state um we we're looking or what that those numbers look like in districts that are in same in similar communities as ours so I think all of those things I think when you say like oh like you know kids in Roseville and O Grove like we know that those are affluent communities and they can afford more interventions than what our kids can afford so I think um we also have to give ourselves some Grace as well um and trust
102that our teachers are doing the best that they can to um support our students any other questions comments concerns I having hard trying to because um I've been in the board almost 11 years and I I'm not politicians I I'm not here because make money I'm not here for no reason I just here for the kids and when I see all these numbers and these datas and this 12% the kid pass 25% 29% 39% I don't see as a percentage I see as a kid as a life of children's they are behind they're living behind and as a school board member I said you know I'm there just to support them whatever they need whatever a we need to provide them to make their their their life easier they need help economic or social they
103need social workers they need uh uh more teachers more support more books more Chrome blocks whatever it is I'm willing to willing to ask scho board to to to to give it to them and when you see the numbers they never changed I've been here for 11 years and they just it's not just here it's everywhere what are we doing wrong what is what is happening how we feeling as a school as a school boards as a parents as a teachers as a childr what we doing the we are not making any difference years to years to years and years and we are down downhill and as a nation all all over so something has to change I don't know what is it but we need to find that that that link they allow us
104to uh provide this kid or or get the kids out of the hall because they are in the H and we we as adults as as are responsible for it so I know and I proud of our school and I've been here for like I said so many years and I I think we have wonderful teams I think we have wonderful teachs I we have the best intentions uh we want to do the best but we are not seeing we are not seeing it and it's getting worse so I don't know if you guys anybody have ideas or things or perspective something that we can we can do because it's depressing as as depressing as a parents as as a mother as a grandma and as a nation is the Pres that that we are
105going in down hill downhill and we need we need to these kids deserve and and we as a nation we need deserve to get better so um whatever it take so I don't know she want let's speak some and don't take me wrong I see percentage here percentage there and it's great and it's good and and kudos for it but a percent here percentage thing is it is is awesome but also too it's also a percentage they're not reaching a big percentage they're not reaching we not reaching this kid and is uh what's going to happen when day 18 or 2021 they going to go to college they going to fail We are failing it and this is my report this is my report when I see you guys reading and this numbers I my
106report I feeling I feel like we are not we're not doing enough and I know you guys I I know I know you guys has the best heart and the H things and the best intention but the results are not there and it is uh please tell us what you need for us to for us to do to help our students and I said parents I always said it's a tri tripod School parents children is it's a tripod we need all three legs to be be together and something is missing I don't know uh what has to change but something what are we St and and the the group they talk earlier said the cook this and I was wish they were here and they should be here because this numbers are are important and
107it should be simp because they are for helping the teacher to help the community I think that was important and sometime I want to sometime meetings alone when you understand that and it's it's important for them to to be here and listen what what's going on I think like I said our principal have we have beautiful P great professional person we have smart people we have so much in this basket to offer and but we need to put our our our brain togethers and and try to figure out what what's missing here because something is missing and we need to find it yeah and and I I there's not much I can add on um to what's already been said and and um and I know that this is the group that we're finding out
108about how bad it was uh because they're testing now and they came in um at a dis Advantage but yeah this is I mean this is the indicator that there needs to be some kind of something big I mean yeah and again I wanted to give ourselves some grce I think there are systemic issues that we don't have any control over that are also impacting reading um and so as we um think about what's being done here I think there are some things that are out of our control that are really impacting what our how our students are performing on this test that's probably not as culturally relevant and culturally sensitive as as we would like it to be and so I I I don't want to go down this this rabbit hole but I
109just want us to give ourselves some Grace um we do have work to do like everybody needs to be held accountable but we also need to give ourselves some Grace so thank you all for your reports I appreciate um I appreciate that and again like I think that you all are doing a fantastic job so thank you for the work that you do yeah no I want to tell thank you too I know I don't want to put you guys complete down I think you we have smart beautiful big hard people and professional people that we can do we can do better and something has to change we have to just find that Missing Link and see if we can make it an impact in our kids because they got to pay the price they're
110paying the price already yes and thank you to Mr change because I thinking also a big uh spices condiments for the our our group and I thinking that also things things going to change right yeah again I like everything well I mean I agree with everything that's been said here um you I don't we we we knew it was coming we knew that we were going to get the data um um from the kids who were starting school when Co hit we we we knew that was and and this is just hitting us that you know you that we need to do something it's hard okay okay let's keep going we going to be here all night yeah no facilities update next facilities update uh good evening would you would we like to wait for
111The Other Board member to return yeah uh good evening ladies and gentlemen of the board superintendent Chen thank you so much uh my name is Gerald Scher I'm VP implementation Services calwell Flores and winners and with me I also have naren Bruno senior program manager for CFW we're pleased tonight to prevent uh to present excuse me not to prevent uh to present our uh monthly update for the uh facilities implementation program uh we'll start uh I'm sorry I'm not used having to uh be in control one on the bottom there we go um I'm gonna do a brief overview any additional questions are that are required to be in depth I will of course to uh refer to miss Bruno um Bell Avenue um the construction is in the final stages of course substantial completion
112is of February 3D we did of course have an on-site OAC meeting with Miss uh superintendent Chen and Mr and and uh Mr uh Coro Castillo in attendance at that all of the utility points of connections have been made remaining sidewalks and assphalt patching will be completed by uh February uh sorry January 27th a punch list walk will be held on January 29th not the 28th again this was prepared about a week or so ago and so we just finalized that today we have uh finalized that the classroom Furniture is set to arrive uh the week of February 10th sorry um any questions on Belle before I move on next uh this is the uh projected budget um I was informed that this is the same um uh Matrix that was presented last month there
113is no change regarding the budget at this time moving on [Music] to Main Avenue um upon the request of the district uh the architect did generate two options for the building site layout with the purpose of uh with the purpose of uh uh providing a detailed design for districts review until going forward we did receive two proposals for the modular building both under over budget uh CFW and the architect in conjunction with the district were finded the design we were able to bring it down however it is still slightly over budget uh efforts are underway to continue that value Engineering Process uh in concurrent with this what we what we do need to U make the board aware of is that this project is funded by a state pstk Grant uh that funding deadline is
114unfortunately March 27th 2025 which will get down towards the be uh towards the end of this and to that end there are certain conditions that we felt that would be required to hit that request for an extension because we know we will not have the three components required for that particular project to be certified and then by opsc the office of public school construction and be able to have their complete funding those three components are DSA approval approval of the leas leas back contractor and then of course CDE approval to that end we have uh elicited responses for least lease back contractors as well as the modular contractor we did receive seven bids um from lease lease back contractors who were uh interested in providing services for the leas lease back process uh we actually
115do have in-person interviews tomorrow here in the boardroom uh Mrs Bruno um herado superintendent Chen myself and as well as an additional uh District consultant will be conducting those interviews um for those uh leas lease back contractors that will allow us to make a recommendation for at least lease back contract at the first board meeting in December the design from the architect is ongoing with the previously approved design that was approved by the district um as I as noted on the last second to last bullet point the delays in the design process have required us to request an extension from opsc and the Sab State allocation board for the process there are certain components that we feel that will bolster our uh argument for that EX those processes are that we are in design that
116we have submitted to the division of State architect the plans for the project that we do have in fact a contract in place for the lease leas back contractor and the modular buildings in discussing this issue with our state aid um division of state of uh CFW Greg Norman I believe most of you do know him uh he said that if we can comply with those components that will bolster our chances to ensure that our an extension will be granted by opsc through real quick sorry yes sir okay so we we need the extension because um we're at risk of not being fined because of the three components and the three comp tell me the three components again the three components that that we really need are an executed purchase agreement for the contract DSA
117approval of the plans and then the final component of course is then CDE approval and we cannot get that without DSA approval and we are we're we are uh Greg and I share an office three days a week and so it's and we have been you know going back and forth but how can we ensure and give Ro the best uh chance at that extension and and so the furtherance of that is if we have the plans in it DSA and has worked extensively with LDA uh the architectural firm for the project uh and also with the leas with the modular contractor to ensure that we can get those plans into DSA so if we have a contract with the modular contractor if we have a a um an approval for or a submission pardon
118me of the plans to DSA and we have a lease lease back contractor in progress that will demonstrate to opsc that we have done everything we can in furtherance towards the goal of achieving the required goals required by opsc in order to um advance that request for the uh for the extension so all three of the components were at were not we we're at risk of not meeting we do everything but the DSA approval okay and that's the big thing and the and and uh and as I said Marine might be able to speak a little bit better but we had worked out and had a couple several meetings with LDA to ascertain that the schedule for to get us into DSA will do everything possible and and the reason why is the delay DSA
119approval will take approximately two to four months and given the deadline of March 27th we would actually have to have all of those components in place basically today um but at at the at the very very latest the end of February and it's just not going to be possible to have all the plans and the approvals in place prior to that time because the approval process per my state aid um Guru Greg is that it's going to take between four and six weeks and DSA is just not going to be cooperative in granting us plan approval within that time frame okay um I know that sometimes youve had a call special board meting to to to pass things but usually we we we meet all our our deadlines why why is this one so close
120or or why we have to have an extension listen where did it where did it not work that we have to file an extension uh the reason why it did not work is that there were adjustments to the actual site plan as well as the interior components of the building uh we we're in uh superintendent Chen herard and CFW have actually refined the plans and the site plans in order to achieve the district's goals for that particular site and the the process of getting the plans together is a is a normally a thre Monon process and so we were just be due to the side adjustments we were just not able to achieve that timeline the backgound the original specs that you all approved for Main Avenue in in 2023 didn't um have all the
121requirements for the preschool right one one of it is the bathrooms and so um we needed to look at the designs to ensure that the preschool specs meet all our requirements and um then we just needed to look at to make sure that the specs were clear and meet the requirements and then we needed to to um I'm going to say um reallocate some spaces in the other classroom that had Extra Spaces assigned for something else to meet our needs so when the RFP went out it was um with the understanding that we didn't have all the required spaces but when looking at the design we were able to um adjust without um any extra spaces attached to the buildings thank you so yeah I don't know um sorry I'm I'm still in going to
122be moved from from before but we've been working on since this since 2023 so why um why didn't we get this fixed before I'm sorry sir we've been working on this since 2023 so why why wasn't this fixed before that we have to file an extension uh I I I and I I I'm sorry I cannot speak to exactly when the policy memo for Maine was brought before you I'm not I I don't know that but I can tell you that um what what in conjunction with the district with senior leadership superintendent Chen is that we've taken Lessons Learned um from Bell and have Incorporated this into the main project um which we were not aware of I believe at the time of 2023 I think that's a fair statement superintendent Jen okay I put
123you on the spot I I believe I believe the specs in 20203 um were aligned to TK requirements right and this is a prek tkk and so um the adjustments needed for prek were not um included in the original specs so when we went out to bid um it appeared to meet all tkk requirements and so as um Mr SCH I don't even know schober I know Miss Gerald um stated that Lessons Learned in terms of ensuring that we have uh prek specs right and I want I would also say that the district at in 2023 um that site in its align and its priorities have also changed since that policy memo was approved back then as well I think that's also a different thing because we were looking to incorporate um as facilities that
124we didn't that we were hoping to uh remove from the district general fund um and trying to incorporate that relief on that and just we were not able to work through so we we did a refinement of the site design over the past several months to achieve what is the district's intent and what was the uh requirements for that partic for the for the site just for clarity are you um referring to the Portable Restrooms yes exactly restrooms Library there was some additional there the plan is presented did not align with the district's goals um that are currently in place okay yeah and and I I do get that you know um there are changes and and and sometimes we we have to refine things um and I do hope that this extension goes through
125I I just don't understand why um it took from 2023 to um a deadline in March of 2025 to fix all of it um um it it seems like that we we would be able to catch that and fix that a lot quicker um especially if if we're learning lessons you know we've been doing this uh for a while so it just seems like we will be able to catch something like this a lot quicker and fix it and not be so close to missing a a deadline or having to file for an extension um I I wish I could answer that uh I was not employed by CFW in 2023 um to be perfectly blunt nor was Norine um so um going forward I I going back I I cannot answer that I can
126only um attest to when we were in began to be involved in the process which was in the fall of 2024 and when once we were engaged and we began to evaluate this process that's when we began to present the various site plans to um senior District leadership and that's when that evolving process about what is actually the site plan and how it aligns with District goals okay I get that and you know I guess you know I mean this has just not been a good night um because I mean you know yeah well we've had you know the last I tried I was GNA have some brevity about saying I'm hoping I'm bringing you some better news but I don't think so well well there's that but there's also I mean like you know
127I'm still looking at this I see a lot of rare you know um on on our budget report and I you know I I don't mind um overestimating and coming under under under budget but I do my underestimating and going over budget you know and so I see you know a lot of that and um you know we're not a rich district and and we're not a high performing District so you know I'm seeing red I'm seeing I'm hearing perform underperforming and I'm seeing this and so like I said it's it's not a good night um so you know and you're kind of getting a lot of that but yes sir you know um I I I just don't understand why if we're seeing something if we're seeing think that we're starting in 2023 and
128we're Miss we're almost missing deadlines in 2025 know that's that that's hard to stomach you can say unacceptable that's okay it's unacceptable yes well and we do have a couple of items on on the action item tonight I believe that was discussed with um previously in order to bring the project closer into the budget um on the action items towards the end of the evening's um agenda so um we have we've done um value engineering and we will continue to Value engineer um the process as we go through um both the procurement process for the lease lease back contractor as well as the um modular contractor yes and and I saw that and you know I'll say it then but I'll say it now too thank you for being able to save hundred and something
129thousand dollars I appreciate that you know maybe that'll be you know the silver lining in in tonight but uh yeah this this has been a rough night any other cry any other uh questions or comments or concerns no thank you thank you thank you sir and ladies okay uh District technology infrastructure update um yes please please yes our phones work forever you guys ready to turn the corner yes yes I already looked let's try let's see uh so this got switched on me what am I doing with this okay that didn't that wasn't too hard okay you got this all right um so good evening board members superintendent Chen folks who are still around uh my name is Elliot Lopez as you know it's been a while since I've been up here and I'm your
130uh Chief technology officer in this presentation uh I'm going to be providing an update on the state of our district technology infrastructure and I'm going to talk about the hard work that our team is doing to keep things running smoothly our team approaches our work with the understanding that technology is a means to an end and that we wait wake up in the morning and come to work to support the success of our students to achieve that mission we manage many facets of technology that staff students and the public interact with in many ways this includes the infrastructure that we're going to be talking about today the software and the hardware in use across our schools offices and classrooms the business processes and the standards and protocols that drive the way that we leverage those
131tools and the data that reflect the outcomes that result from their use um as will be the focus of my subsequent pres my next presentation our team focuses on all of these areas every day and this requires that we work with our peers and our colleagues in different functional areas very closely so that we understand their needs goals and priorities and that we provide the best resources and servic as possible what is infrastructure when we discuss infrastructure in the context of the technology environment we're generally talking about the data and Communications Network and the components that make up this network and that includes the wiring the copper and the fiber optic wiring uh wireless devices such as you see hanging on the ceiling here Network switches and firewalls components that help to Route data and
132to secure our data and servers and other tools that tend to reside inside of network cabinets and closets that are generally outside of the view of most folks in the district the core of our infrastructure as you can see here comprises what we call our wide area network or Wan and that connects each of our schools through the district office in a structure that's referred to as a hub and spoke based on its appearance um up until recently a lot of this infrastructure was in dire near need of Maintenance and replacement urgent repair a lot of it was outside of its service life and support life and began to become generally unreliable and to address this we have overhauled and modernized over 80% of our technology infrastructure over the past two to three years um
133that includes replacing 2third of the network switches in the district replacing our entire wireless network infrastructure including extending Wi-Fi to outdoor areas like playgrounds and structures to provide flexible learning environments we rolled out 169 security cameras which is 24 times as many as we had uh before this year uh to improve improve campus safety to provide principles and office staff with better campus situational awareness and also to light up our schools a little bit more effectively to make them safe uh we rolled out battle battery backups to protect our equipment that keep the network up during brief power outages which happens surprisingly frequently in this area and this year we're actually replacing an additional 22 Legacy Network switches under an RFP that just closed so all of that infrastructure and the individuals at our schools
134and in the district are connected to the internet via our primary internet connection uh which is depicted here here uh it's a connection maintained by Comcast and uh but however it's maintained by Comcast but it was built by Roa and it's owned by Roa um they basically maintain it for us and that uh that uh process of building that out ourselves was possible under a very unique collaborative that exists in this region called bestnet where we partnered with other districts in the region to essentially build our own internet uh which we run through skoy um data runs through skoy and they maintain multiple connections to the to the outside world and then they also provide supplemental monitoring to us and support services in real time um and over the past two years we've actually increased
135um our connection to the uh to the outside world by a factor of 10 to accommodate reli uh the increased Reliance that you've heard a lot about today on apps and cloud-based tools for instruction um and other resources across the districts District that are proliferating very quickly we've also uh been very mindful of um the need to continue to improve um uh cyber security and have upgraded our firewall to uh ensure that uh we are protected internally in our district Network all that being said um a short while ago sure enough the district unexpectedly lost access to the internet when a construction project outside of RI Linda High School struck some underground fiber optic cable that carried our connection to to skoy thankfully this didn't happen during uh the middle of our uh State Testing
136window but it definely was disruptive to our school sites um and so we undertook uh the process of mitigating the potential for that um event recurring by rolling out a second connection to scoy to the internet via a second secondary carrier in this case it's AT&T that automatically takes over in the event that our Comcast uh connection to the outside world fails and since that uh that that was deployed we have not experienced any significant disruptions to the internet oopsie wrong button so our our uh infrastructure also includes a third layer of internet connectivity um our transportation services department actually resides in a lease space that's not owned by roblas so we have to extend our Wan out to that facility uh to allow staff to do things like access Bus video in real time
137uh they can watch what's happening on the buses live uh they can track the buses along their routes and then obviously they need to have access to other District resources as well that third high-speed internet connection is actually provided by a third third provider to make sure that we have the maximum amount of uh redundancy there uh in this case Consolidated Communications and we also happen to have multiplied the bandwidth associated with that connection by 10 times uh recently as well um I also wanted to mention that um we are in the process of extending our Network in a pilot program to school buses and today we have um internet connectivity on three of our school buses which which allows Riders uh students or adults to have roet provided internet connectivity while they're on the
138bus whether it be moving or parked um and uh that's a service that we have collaborated with T-Mobile on to um to look at as a possibility to continue to allow access to internet connectivity for students who might be on the bus for considerable periods of time okay the final significant component of our infrastructure is our telepan system um which has uh become a topic of discussion of late um it's certainly a priority for us right now because of issues that we have been experiencing with our venders infrastructure um uh recently we began to experience outages during periods of heavy rain because the rain water was entering the cables it was permeating the cables on the telephone poles and it was also entering the junction boxes that are on the sides of the roads as
139you're driving down the road they were actually being flooded and it was causing our circuit our telephone circuit to fail so the first time we experienced this issue last year we brought um AT&T in we had a fairly prolonged outage uh they did some extensive work it took a considerable amount of time um at the end of that period uh we service was restored and we were um assured that the problem was corrected it did not recur um so uh we took the vendor's word that the problem was corrected and um that was until it started to rain again next the following year so uh so it started rain again and lo and behold um the problem returned um and then we uh we began working with AT&T again and what we learned during our
140interaction with them this go around is that um they they did not fix the root cause of the problem initially but rather applied essentially a Band-Aid solution and the reason for this is that AT&T is divesting themselves of the type of service that we currently have in place the type of um connectivity that we use for telefony uh they basically are no longer actively maintaining these circuits and won't touch them until something goes wrong with them and and uh their Maintenance and Service procedures deprioritize these types of circuits essentially they are only providing what we call in the business World a minimum viable product to uh to comply with their contractual obligations under the state contract um that governs this type of circuit which was acquired a really long time ago um in hopes that
141folks will migrate off um so um can ask you question yeah absolutely okay so you said State contract and hopes and hop so people will migrate so um I'm I'm a little confused okay if it's a state contract then who's migrating off so essentially what happens is that um you know the state goes out to bid and um vendors uh the lowest cost vendor will will receive the estate contracts and then when we go out to obtain these types of services we basically pick GGY back on these State contracts this is a is a very old contract on a technology that they no longer support no new customers acquire this type of a circuit so we're basically on a legacy product um so what they're doing is essentially minimizing the amount of resources that they're
142allocating internally and dedicating to the maintenance and support of these um Legacy circuits um in hopes that eventually folks will move off of them okay so what you're saying is the state provided contracted and got this structure and then we came along and said okay you know we we'll take this service and we'll pay for the service yeah it's a state an umbrella contract that other um other public agencies can piggy back on and so and it basically um ensures that everyone is receiving Equitable pricing as intended to ensure that we're receiving the lowest possible uh pricing for these types of services okay so so piggy bag does mean we're paying for it yeah yeah it is a paid service it is a b service and that means that we can go somewhere else and
143that's what you're talking absolutely absolutely yes yes so that's where I'm going that's that's my next slide um so basically since the recurrence of this issue uh we've been working with multiple vendors um to design a new solution um and that essentially will mirror what we did with our internet connection so the the game plan is to um bring in a failover circuit that is applied by another uh vendor under a different technology and once we Implement that failover circuit that will provide us with the um assurance that should something happen to our phone lines then the uh the service will automatically roll over to that backup circuit so there'll be no loss in service to us and then once that failover is in place will have the ability to migrate the Legacy circuit that
144currently exists to another technology or another vendor at that point we'll have the assurance that there's no possibility of disruption to telephony service like we've been experiencing because we have no backup right now so that's the strategy um and you know I want you to know that the purchase of the failover circus C circuit is um in progress and that we have been you know advised in terms of the timelines for this type of a transition that we're looking at uh probably a spring migration so so by the spring we should have the kind of redundancy that we have for internet connectivity in place for telefony I thought we have to get in the winter to make sure it doesn't rain out right well I mean I I've never hoped for a drought before but
145so who are the vendors the so I I the ver we're currently still talking to the vendors so we're not in contract with anyone yet okay so let me be more specific are any of the vendors you're talking to AT&T they're not no good fail over is is going to be a another party just like we did with the internet we want to make sure that we have like as much redundancy as possible so they're different vendors do you plan to keep it that way that the vendors we are not we were talking to are not AT&T I'm not sure yet so we'll have to see I mean we're the the issue with infrastructure in particular in an area like like where we are is that there are a lot of limitations in terms of
146of what options are available to you because not a lot of vendors service this area okay well let me be a little bit more clear and which camera am I looking at okay is it this camera I am not voting for anything that says AT&T okay so noted yes and my mic was on and I was looking at that camera okay understood um yeah so so there is a plan in place this is a very unusual situation in the three school districts where I've worked in the 20 years that I've worked in public education the dial tone is the last thing that I've had to worry about we're talking about 200 year old technology here generally The Kinks are worked out this is a very very unusual circumstance um so and we have had many
147meetings with AT&T where we have made it very clear to them uh how dissatisfied we are with the level of service that we're receiving uh and how inadequate uh their treatment and their support has been we've been very very transparent about that you know I had one other question because when I was going through our our our Pur work for this um we talked about this being um a temporary solution what is your definition of temporary and solution that they implemented yeah no no just all of this this is this is this is okay so the the strategy about today is not a temporary solution what we're talking about today is implementing the level of robust infrastructure okay that we should expect and that we have deployed in other areas of our infrastructure uh telepan
148for us was deprioritized because typically it is it doesn't it it wasn't first of all as high a priority because it wasn't in need of immediate attention such as the other you know the other uh functional areas of our infrastructure but it Rose to the top as soon as we started to experience these issues with AT&T Okay the reason why I say was because in my PR we doing a lot of discussions and the war temporary came up and I was not interested in the war temporary I wanted to make sure that everything were doing apologies I mean the the the only thing that was temporary was the solution that they implemented last year when they told us that they fixed it and essentially they didn't correct the the so the cable that is problematic
149runs from I guess there's a Moose Lodge somewhere on RI Linda right up there up the street there's a box over here on the corner of RI Linda and Maryville and between there there's a cable that runs it's a bundle of cable has like you know many dozens of cables in it two of those wires in that bundle belong to us connect to our phone system and what they did is they said these are two bad wires we're just going to put you on two other wires and we're going to cross our fingers and hope that those are okay and they were okay for a little while until it started raining again and then those two wires began to become problematic so that's the temporary solution to I was referring I apologize for the confusion
150yeah thank you anything else so that okay that concludes the the update I mean this is only infrastructure focused uh there are lots and lots of moving parts and bits and pieces that comprise infrastructure that we won't go into today but I do want to take the opportunity to give a shout out to Chuck who is who's uh a large part of his job is maintaining this infrastructure so I just wanted to say thank you uh he's quiet in the back of the room there uh and just acknowledge that um that he does spend a lot of time um this is his baby um and he does uh a terrific job of maintaining our infrastructure thank you all too for quick question two things uh you said that we want to deploy background carrier with
151a voice over Internet Protocol VP yeah that's a technology that we're looking at now of again what we're trying to do is we're trying to differentiate the technologies that we're using um our phone system is very flexible and can actually connect to lots of different types of circuits and so what we want to do is look at a couple of different options so that we can you know maximize the fault tolerance as it's called of our system we we used to have a business over here in Norgate and the pass and we used to use the voice over IP and also we used to use Consolidated Freight Consolidated sorry uh communication which has a hyperactive yes and we it was never an issue never an issue never have issue with I I don't have they
152didn't give me no money but yeah no we work we work with them as well like I said we're agnostic um we you know we're looking for the best product at the best cost for the district I know they are in area because we was right there yeah we we'll see yes yes we'll see okay okay any other questions comments thank you thank you thank you Mr CH thank you thank you for you guys okay moving on to our sixth report of the evening um enrollment and attendance update I'll try to talk fast okay supp I'll talk really quickly um I'll try uh so members of the board superintendent Jen good to see you again um this presentation we're going to be focusing on um enrollment figures for the 2425 school year and we'll share
153information about attendance for the prior year and where we are through today so we'll do a year-to DAT brief up date on attendance um every year we examine this information because the size and the profile of our district um drives the resources the programs the services required to help them flourish and this data helps us to understand our system so that we can make good decisions and align resources to needs in support of those goals um you know in the backdrop of this presentation I want us to be to to remember that districts across the country are still trying to recover from the effects of the pandemic you've heard quite a bit about that today um and in particular on enrollment and attendance and on top of that recent changes in the economic and the
154political landscape are making it more critical for us to do everything possible to prepare our students for Success so with that being said we'll start with an overview of our enrollment counts for the 2425 year uh the SL this slide here depicts the 1894 students in enrolled at Robla this year and their distribution across our schools and grade levels uh these counts as you uh probably are aware are based on an enrollment snapshot this is a single day a single point in time uh that is consistently taken every single year on the first Wednesday of October we refer to that as census day uh and then this information is used by the CDE as the basis for determining District funding apportionments and for creating reports and student enrollment counts and calculating account accountability measures like
155the dashboard the top portion of the slide uh reflects enrollment counts and overall percentage of District enrollment by School uh just a reminder that NPS uh uh depict uh um refers to non-public schools where robless students are being provided specialized instructional Services by a third party that's contracted by the district uh the bottom portion of the slide reflects enrollment counts and individual grade level counts by school and you'll note that the preschool is not included in this enrollment account we'll talk about their data in a second okay again remember uh that this is a snapshot in time and that these figures will vary slightly over the course of the year as Ro Roa is processing new enrollments that come in and or dropping students that leave the district at some point in the year okay
156uh on this next slide we're looking at how this year's enrollment Stacks up relative to school years over the past decade or so uh this slide tells us that our current count of 1894 students on census day uh is a decrease of about 1.5% relative to last year uh we are about 18.75 75% below our peak of 2331 way back in 20145 and we're 7.6% below the average enrollment of 2049 students per year over this entire time frame uh the most for the most recent three years our average enrollment count is 1907 this slide also demonstrates the district's difficulty in recovering enrollment past covid uh postco um in the six years prior to the close of school uh Roa averaged 2160 students uh in the four years since uh schools were reopened um after the
157lockdown Robla has averaged 198 students uh which is a drop of about 11.6% pre versus postco um however as you're probably aware we're not alone in this regard um for example in 19 uh 20 before the pandemic the entire State of California recorded a census day enrollment of 6.2 million students and then last year Statewide enrollment was down to 5.8 million so as a state we're down about 5.3% in enrollment so for this reason bringing students back to school is a top priority for the governor for the CDE and definitely for Robla as well one positive trend that we're seeing on this slide here is that uh our enrollment decreases are actually smaller postco than they were preo and that implies that this decrease in enrollment this trend actually started before covid um which um
158implies that perhaps there's something happening in the area that is influencing enrollment um and if you look at the last four years our uh enrollment does appear to be stabilizing somewhat so we're not seeing the DraStic swings year overy year in enrollment here we take a look at enrollment counts across grade levels over the past four years across the board we saw some moderate pluses and minuses across all grade levels um kindergarten first second third and fifth grade saw some small drops uh in enrollment and um TK 4th and six saw some increases I apologize for the size of the font on this um a lot of this is due to just uh um grade size bubbles passing through our system um one thing though that we do want to Spotlight is the start of
159our student pipeline TK we do see a continuation of growth at the entry point which reflects a growth in Focus clearly by the state on TK but I think also a growth in Awareness by our parents and the availability of TK um we do see that that growth is slowing down a little bit uh we don't have a lot of data points to G here so this I wouldn't say this constitutes a trend um and uh uh but we do see a fairly consistent growth um all that being said we do know that uh between the steady growth the specialized classroom and credential requirements and the expectation of the 10 to1 TK ratio that herard referenced earlier we're going to have to keep focusing on meeting TK uh specific Staffing and resource needs as a
160district that will be a challenge for us going forward okay in terms of uh demographic distribution which helps us to understand the community that we're serving our population does continue to be very diverse with well over a dozen ethnicities represented in the student body which is consistent with prior years uh the chart here depicts any variances uh uh uh compared to Prior compared to last year um below the uh indicated percentages here we're looking at the distribution of primary languages among our student population as a reminder uh primary language is defined by the CDE as the language that a student primarily speaks at home it's uh self self-reported by the family um as you can see over 44% of our students speak a primary language other than English uh which um obviously presents challenges in
161terms of our ability to uh interact with Eng and engage our families and our community um in addition of that while Spanish mang and Russian are the most represented languages in our students homes uh I think it was worth noting that over a hundred of our students speak one of 19 other languages not represented on this chart at home uh I think we talked about unduplicated count a little bit earlier today during the fiscal update um as you all know at the start of the school year all of our students needs and demographic information are documented in our student information system so that when data are reported to the state every one of our neediest students is identified and counted uh these students entitled The District to supplemental funding that is intended to support programs
162and resources to meet their specific needs um each qualifying student is counted only once regardless of the number of programs that they fall into um and that's where the term unduplicated comes from this year we're projecting that over 89% of our students are identified as unduplicated um and the uh the slide here uh reflects the uh percent of students who participate each of the most significant qualified programs can I ask you a question yes sir um this is a couple slides back um on the student demographics um if a person has multiple ethnicities how how are they reported in here there is a there is an option for multiple uh for multiple ethnicities so um they're under the 1% yeah okay just didn't get on the list unfortunately so they're under the 1% it still
163has up to 98% yeah I think that we didn't there are probably a couple that are really small okay get on the list here okay and and there's another category oh there's so Sor going back to that so s so if it's other well I can can you explain that a little bit I mean how do you other languages no I mean the other ethnicities um so if a person if a person U reports two ethnicities do both of them go into other no it gets listed as more than one ethnicity so is that so so two or more does go into that one category category called two or more okay yeah that that's okay okay let's see I think we're here uh so this is another um metric that we look at retention when
164we look at how many of last year's TK to fifth grade students returned to roas school this year we can see that short of 91% of Roa students came back in 2425 so students that finished with us in 2324 how many you're coming back uh this is an improvement over last year uh we want to make sure that our students want to come back to a roess school um we're constantly striving to make this number as close to 100% as we possibly can quick look at robli preschool uh this year we have five students enrolled at the preschool as of census day uh which represents a 32% decrease over last year but there are some caveats here uh first of all uh preschool um enrollment is not reported to calpads and so and we choose
165census day as the day to capture the count but that date may not necessarily coincide with Peak enrollment at the preschool um so we just apply that date in order to have coherence internally in terms of when we run the numbers um in fact we know for a fact that last year it wasn't when the preschool had Peak enrollment because they finished the year with 198 students and as you can see here on census St they had 154 there was a big push in the fall and winter by our director uh Sala at uh the preschool where uh uh a number of additional students were enrolled after this census date um that we chose uh secondly this year we have the additional caveat that there's construction going on at the preschool and a number of
166the classrooms are not available to students and so as a result their uh enrollment is constrained and we are certain knowing that they have a wait list that when those classrooms reopen that we will see the numbers uh pretty rapidly increase at the preschool so like the budget there'll be a may rise I'm sorry I I said like the budget there'll be a may rise maybe earlier than May uh we'll see we'll see when it's done yeah yeah we need um not only do we need the classroom space but we need to make sure that the outdoor space is aligned with the requirements for prek so but this is a little bit bit more of a moving Target than the district's census day count which is an official point in time that the CDE uses
167another area that we look at each year is matriculation of school aged students from our preschool to our ele school so what we're looking at here is what happened to the TK and K eligible students in the cohort of the 198 that I just talked about from last year that ended last year at the preschool based on their birth dates now the 198 preschoolers in this slide we're we're depicting here that 76 were eligible by age for TK this year in 2425 so what happened to those students um 41% of them matriculated to our elementary schools um so they did go to TK uh at Bell Glenwood and Maine however we do have 59% of those TK eligible students that did not matriculate to a TK K grade level in our elementary schools and so
168our next step here is to look more closely at that population of students to find out where they ended up are they at the preschool did they leave the district so that we better understand especially as the landscape surrounding teach TK is changing so quickly how families are making choices about whether to matriculate into TK or to uh to pursue uh preschool in the same vein um of those 198 students from last year's cohort 92 were actually age eligible for Kinder this year and you can see that 54% of those students actually matriculated into K classes at our elementary schools but 46% did not and so again we're going to be looking more closely at those 42 Kinder eligible students uh to find out where they ended up at why okay okay now a quick
169pivot to attendance data as you know Robla is in differentiated assistance receiving assistance from the County Office of Education to help us address attendance and chronic absenteeism um uh I I don't think we have to reiterate that we all know this is a crisis across the state the county the country and because this is such a high priority and area of focus for roblo we wanted to just give you a brief snapshot of where we are right now and the results of our efforts to date and the news is positive on this front um we continuously roll out attendance challenges and maintain a persistent focus on attendance um in multiple areas um and especially during key periods of historically lower attendance throughout the year um and as you heard in many of the sipsa presentations
170today this is a um an area of focus for the individual schools and school leaders uh this is a team effort our principls our assistant principls our teachers are on board and we're seeing High engagement and we're seeing really good results so since we began focusing on attendance Improvement we have now seen consistent growth year toe districtwide and at each of our Schools attendance was up last year from the prior year and so far this year year to date rates do continue to climb uh so far we're up almost 1% uh from the end of the year last year and then when we look at attendance rate growth by individual schools you can see here in this chart that each of our schools has made stride in strides in reducing absences to levels recorded during
171the 2223 school year we're going to continue to disaggregate this information so that we can monitor attendance over the course of the school year and we want to start looking at this more closely um in terms of different School student groups uh grade levels and so forth I know this's a lot of information especially after seven presentations um but it's really important for us and this is information that we need to continue to monitor uh for so many reasons I do appreciate your attention and I'm happy to answer any questions that you might still have questions comments okay thank Youk you very much right can I just say good job all I want to say like congratulations to all the schools every single one of them increased attendance like by quite a bit and I'm
172very proud of that yep awesome okay um California dashboard results uh English learner Services report number seven okay I am going to go through this quickly because you have seen actually a lot of this data already we're all figuring how to use this new one um unfortunately I was able unable to be here when uh Mr Penman gave the presentation on the dashboard to share with you the information on the English language um indicator called the lp or the English language progress indicator so I'm just going to go over some of that data with you very quick so on the California school dashboard these are our measurements the English language progress indicator we are in the orange category the data was surprising um last year we were in green and uh we saw a drop
173we saw a drop by over 7% um excuse me 6.4% which indicated us from moving from green to Orange also we have a new indicator Ator on the dashboard this new indicator is the long-term English Learners indicator so now there's a new student group that shows up in all areas on the dashboard so here we see where they are in terms of um their initial exposure on the dashboard so why did the district go from green to Orange so we looked at all the school sites and when you look at the school sites you can see it's a little bit all over the board and one of the things I want to uh talk a little bit about is one of the things with the dashboard that is actually kind of I say a flaw
174in the dashboard is a small student group can make a big change in your color on the dashboard um so for example Roa has about a 100 English Learners so a 2.5% change means two and a half children um made a change for Roo Elementary School on the dashboard from yellow to Orange but that's not an excuse just wanted to make point that out that when you have a smaller student group it fuat on the colors a little bit more so what do we do so that we can get a better picture we're going to take a look at what makes that indicator so what makes the indicator is we're looking at lpac data for students who have taken the lpac for two years in a row so essentially our first through sixth graders they
175need to have a 23 24 or 22 23 score and and a 23 24 score and we compare those two scores so the colors there the purple blue uh turquoise and pink are how we look at how each the the students did in order to make progress on the lp you need your blue and your purple to go up okay and you don't want your uh turquoise to stay flat you hope that that one also will go down and you definitely want the pink to go down the pink are the students who decrease so they want backwards and our students that are in turquoise are students who are kind of flatlining they're not really making progress are students in blue that number could go down because those students could have been reclassified um they could
176have also moved backwards they might be a student that's in that decreased at least one lpac level I did look we do not have that case so our blue went down for some of the schools because those students actually were reclassified fight out and they're they're going to be out of the system we so we have the smaller group that are sitting in that blue and staying in that blue for two years okay so in working with the school sites um this is what I've really you know asked them to focus on and as you see when they gave their presentations for the sipa they looked at this information a lot of them showed you this information because what we want to know is are we keeping kids from going backwards and um those children
177children that are going backwards why as well as students who are maintaining why are they not moving up so th those are the areas the students that I've asked them to focus on in addition to our long-term English Learners uh those students actually the students that were identified as long-term English Learners were sixth graders last year so they are no longer with the robo School District so we are looking at the students that we call at risk and those are students who are probably in that maintained level um and possibly in the decrease level those are students who are not making annual progress by going at least from a one to a low two a low two to a high two and so forth so they have six levels that they can move the other
178component on the dashboard is our local measures most of these measures are the measures that we use uh rubrics given to us by California Department of Ed um we complete those rubrics uh with the caveat the priority one where we actually do now have basic teacher uh in excuse me teacher information in terms of credentials that goes through the uh s SSS what something system that Nicole Sullivan uh Imports that data so then it gets matriculated into calpads so that was very quick but I feel that um our principles did talk about their El data so if you have any any questions I'm happy to answer them thank you for clarifying the um the slide with the different colors that was help thank you questions thank you thank you okay our last report of the
179evening revised policies regulations and or first reading revised policies regulations and or exhibits just in alignment with um updating our um board policies and administrative regulations especially in alignment with our trainings for Frisk and title 7 thank you questions comments concerns great great moving on I'm sorry I need a breather I need a breather man yeah okay is there a motion to approve the consent agenda so moved second the motion second all those in favor say I I oppose extensions the consent agenda has been approved moving on to action items and we only have a few here uh section 7A approve 5% increase to board member compensation so moved second motion second any discussion all those in favor say I I I that that's not an opposition okay oppose exension I don't think we deserve
180it after saying everything tonight okay abion okay motion carries 3 to one you noted thank you um moving on to 7B uh approve 20242 expanded learning summer contract with Robert's family Development Center so V second there any discussion just there um Sumer contract for Freedom School all those in favor say I I oppose extenstions motion carries unanimously item C approve change order number three to the agreement with enviroplex Inc for the Bell Avenue New preschool and transitional kindergarten classroom construction project so moved second is motion to second is there any discussion this is um in alignment with the presentation one of the pieces that we would need that would make our application stronger for the extension um I want to say c and d c oh no this is different I'm sorry nope this is
181change order yeah this change order has to do with um we have to replace the toilets in the preschool and TK building to ensure that it is allowable for our students Age 2 to 4 um with the um age decrease in TK going down to four a normally um the nor the regular bathrooms in fifth grade I mean excuse me in kindergarten were five so we needed to have a smaller um toilet to accommodate ages 2 to 4 as well as adjustments to the flooring in the preschool building it was originally all carpet and uh for the preschool it is is it all tile or all non- carpet or half and half luy vinyle and carpet combin okay that's what I thought yes but it was originally all carpet but now we have luxury vinyl
182tle tile so it's been all in favor say all of in favor say I I oppose extensions motion carries unanimously sorry I'm half asleep okay uh D I think this is what you were getting okay so um approve agreement for modular construction service within virle for the Main Avenue New preschool and transitional trans transitional kindergarten kindergarten classrooms construction project move second motion then second any discussion I know we've had somebody yes so um from earlier discussion so D and E are associated it's important that we approve the original proposal and then we recognized we were able to do some value engineering um to save some money in item e all those in favor say I I oppose exensions motion carries unanimously item e approve amendment number one to the four modular Construction Services with en
183vioplex for the Main Avenue New preschool and transitional kindergarten kindergarten classrooms construction project move second in motion and second any other discussion I will say thank you thank you for saving us $3,761 much appreciated 61 all those in favor say I I oppose extensions motion carries unanimously finally last item I know it's been a long night um board member requests for future agenda items and reports trusty Divine nothing at this time not trust um trusty Cardona sorry it's been a long evening you have with the Starks I do have something um I want to take a moment to acknowledge the courageous individuals who have come forward to share their concerns about the after school program with me the after school program specifically Helen um I'm truly grateful for the time and care that you took
184to reach out to me and to share those detailed accounts with issues that you've either witnessed or that you've personally experienced um your voices are invaluable and they're really important to me and I want you to know that addressing those concerns is a priority to me and so I'm requesting that uh we add Helen to the Helen after school program be added to the um agenda for our February 20th meeting thank you thank you okay and I want to um thank you for for um saying what you did and just let people know that these are board meetings and um they're very structured unfortunately um so it may seem like we don't hear everyone but we actually do we just there these meetings are very structured to me and there are things that we can
185discuss and things that we canot but we do hear everyone we listen I do not have any well just one um well a couple um not that it's an agenda item but um I would love to um know or see if there is any information about um the people who have been displaced um in Southern California and if or where you know they are going in I know it's kind of hard but I would you know if if they're coming this way how we can prepare know um that's one thing um I'd love to hear more about um the uh training that um that we have to do uh and I because I know that we have 12 months to do it and I I don't want to get to the 12th month and then
186have to hurry and try to find someone and the last thing is um it really broke my heart to hear that um we have um children who are who are afraid come to school and parents who are afraid to send their kids to school and and uh hearing one report of a of a of a parent um well I just say it's heartbreaking um and um I would love to put out some kind of statement or something that says that um that uh your child is safe with us and that that we're not um yeah I'm just going to leave it at that and um with that this meeting is adjourned thank you for attending